diff --git "a/data/common-11-626-test.json" "b/data/common-11-626-test.json" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/data/common-11-626-test.json" @@ -0,0 +1,162022 @@ +[ + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/0.wav", + "text": "主席有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/1.wav", + "text": "請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/2.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/3.wav", + "text": "根據勞動部今年展開的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/4.wav", + "text": "2024年3月到6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/5.wav", + "text": "一共有543件職場性騷擾通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/6.wav", + "text": "你知道公務機關有多少件嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/7.wav", + "text": "134件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/8.wav", + "text": "占總比大概是24.7%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/9.wav", + "text": "其中成立的74件占比大概是55%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/10.wav", + "text": "我想請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/11.wav", + "text": "像這種職場性騷擾的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/12.wav", + "text": "未來要如何改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/13.wav", + "text": "性平三法修正通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/14.wav", + "text": "其實是有強化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/15.wav", + "text": "包括幾個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/16.wav", + "text": "尤其是如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/17.wav", + "text": "雇主或機構負責人的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/18.wav", + "text": "當然現在有機制來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/19.wav", + "text": "一些強化作為是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/20.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們還是要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/21.wav", + "text": "你們是性平的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/22.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/23.wav", + "text": "還是要來加強這部分的宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/24.wav", + "text": "尤其是如果真的有發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/25.wav", + "text": "類似的狀況的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/26.wav", + "text": "當然該怎麼處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/27.wav", + "text": "就應該確切處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/28.wav", + "text": "很好要宣導如果是發生違反性平的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/29.wav", + "text": "勞動部就要嚴肅處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/30.wav", + "text": "我想請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/31.wav", + "text": "違反性平或進行言語性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/32.wav", + "text": "有很多種態樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/33.wav", + "text": "我想請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/34.wav", + "text": "如果在職場上指責一個女性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/35.wav", + "text": "穿著暴露噁心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/36.wav", + "text": "請問算不算違反性平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/37.wav", + "text": "甚至嚴重構成所謂性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/38.wav", + "text": "你還要懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/39.wav", + "text": "今天如果有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/40.wav", + "text": "在職場上批評一個女生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/41.wav", + "text": "穿著很暴露很噁心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/42.wav", + "text": "這不是所謂的違反性平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/43.wav", + "text": "甚至性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/44.wav", + "text": "如果造成被指控的人不舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/45.wav", + "text": "非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/46.wav", + "text": "造成被指控的人不舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/47.wav", + "text": "就有構成違反性平跟性騷擾的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/48.wav", + "text": "你穿成這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/49.wav", + "text": "暴露噁心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/50.wav", + "text": "去告男性性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/51.wav", + "text": "你覺得這樣有沒有更嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/52.wav", + "text": "有沒有更嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/53.wav", + "text": "有沒有構成性平跟違反性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/54.wav", + "text": "部長我告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/55.wav", + "text": "你剛剛前面已經講了我要肯定你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/56.wav", + "text": "請問你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/57.wav", + "text": "這種不恰當的性別歧視言論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/58.wav", + "text": "就發生在上週五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/59.wav", + "text": "就是你的前同僚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/60.wav", + "text": "黃捷跟吳沛憶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/61.wav", + "text": "對陳玉珍委員的歧視霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/62.wav", + "text": "就剛剛一個一個要件來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/63.wav", + "text": "他們有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/64.wav", + "text": "說他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/65.wav", + "text": "穿著暴露噁心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/66.wav", + "text": "影帶都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/67.wav", + "text": "性平的主管機關勞動部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/68.wav", + "text": "關心一下去看看影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/69.wav", + "text": "你今天去看看影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/70.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/71.wav", + "text": "部長你不要遇到你前同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/72.wav", + "text": "你前面講過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/73.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/74.wav", + "text": "如果批評女性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/75.wav", + "text": "批評一個人穿著暴露噁心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/76.wav", + "text": "你說要看當事人的感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/77.wav", + "text": "陳玉珍有沒有覺得被冒犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/78.wav", + "text": "你也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/79.wav", + "text": "所以今天我要請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/80.wav", + "text": "對這樣的事情你能認同嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/81.wav", + "text": "你可不可以認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/82.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/83.wav", + "text": "這一位被批評的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/84.wav", + "text": "勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/85.wav", + "text": "他如果遇到這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/86.wav", + "text": "職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/87.wav", + "text": "在職場裡面的工作者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/88.wav", + "text": "當然依法規他是可以提出申訴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/89.wav", + "text": "我問的不是申訴法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/90.wav", + "text": "我問的是你主管機關勞動部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/91.wav", + "text": "推給人家申不申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/92.wav", + "text": "你做一個主管機關遇到前同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/93.wav", + "text": "你的標準就轉彎了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/94.wav", + "text": "但是對於現在你在描述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/95.wav", + "text": "針對這種類似的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/96.wav", + "text": "請你公開表態反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/97.wav", + "text": "關於性平主管機關一個基本的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/98.wav", + "text": "接下來我要跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/99.wav", + "text": "事實上今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/100.wav", + "text": "這件事情我看到民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/101.wav", + "text": "是民進黨的立法委員之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/102.wav", + "text": "這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/103.wav", + "text": "離譜到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/104.wav", + "text": "你一定又說不知道我告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/105.wav", + "text": "他們罵陳玉珍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/106.wav", + "text": "說他裡面穿著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/107.wav", + "text": "內衣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/108.wav", + "text": "暴露噁心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/109.wav", + "text": "事實上陳玉珍影片出來裡面穿的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/110.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/111.wav", + "text": "穿的是襯衫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/112.wav", + "text": "沒關係啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/113.wav", + "text": "穿的是襯衫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/114.wav", + "text": "為什麼襯衫會變成是內衣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/115.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/116.wav", + "text": "就民進黨立委扯破的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/117.wav", + "text": "扯破之後再罵他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/118.wav", + "text": "噁心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/119.wav", + "text": "再罵他暴露還罵他碰瓷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/120.wav", + "text": "今天到這邊我看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/121.wav", + "text": "我們的部長你就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/122.wav", + "text": "一推二五六嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/123.wav", + "text": "因為任何性平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/124.wav", + "text": "按照機制進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/125.wav", + "text": "那不是廢話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/126.wav", + "text": "不是廢話嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/127.wav", + "text": "本來就按照機制進行啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/128.wav", + "text": "我今天問的是身為部長一個性平主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/129.wav", + "text": "機關勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/130.wav", + "text": "的部長對於違反性平甚至性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/131.wav", + "text": "問題的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/132.wav", + "text": "立法委員我先不要講這兩位立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/133.wav", + "text": "過去他經常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/134.wav", + "text": "就是標榜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/135.wav", + "text": "透過自由的穿著來傳達性平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/136.wav", + "text": "的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/137.wav", + "text": "今天遇到陳玉珍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/138.wav", + "text": "性平概念倒退300里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/139.wav", + "text": "他們可以倒退300里因為他們是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/140.wav", + "text": "他們不是勞動部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/141.wav", + "text": "你是勞動部長我跟你講在這個事情上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/142.wav", + "text": "要有很清楚的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/143.wav", + "text": "反對就反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/144.wav", + "text": "不要因為他是你舊同僚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158048/145.wav", + "text": "我會來瞭解一下到底發生了什麼事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/0.wav", + "text": "部長大家都說臺灣好山好水臺灣最美的風景就是人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/1.wav", + "text": "可是據最新統計我們一年的觀光逆差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/2.wav", + "text": "大概就有8,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/3.wav", + "text": "政府現在實施很多大撒幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/4.wav", + "text": "的政策包括外國人來臺灣我們就給他補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/5.wav", + "text": "內部也有大內宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/6.wav", + "text": "為什麼觀光逆差越來越嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/7.wav", + "text": "但恢復的速度確實不夠快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/8.wav", + "text": "甚至沒有快過國人出國的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/9.wav", + "text": "所以確實有產生一些逆差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/10.wav", + "text": "但它那個數據是怎麼算出來的我不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/11.wav", + "text": "我也不曉得那個數據到底精不精準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/12.wav", + "text": "那個逆差是指國人出去花的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/13.wav", + "text": "不過這個部分我們確實要更努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/14.wav", + "text": "其實各國都是這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/15.wav", + "text": "到目前為止如果你到韓國旅遊他們也有補助方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/16.wav", + "text": "例如到日本旅遊像日本恢復這麼快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/17.wav", + "text": "撒幣也要有用啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/18.wav", + "text": "對我們希望有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/19.wav", + "text": "目前疫情已經結束兩年了對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/20.wav", + "text": "我們看了一下這個統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/21.wav", + "text": "數據到目前為止來臺灣的旅客和疫情前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/22.wav", + "text": "另外還有更嚴重的請你看這個圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/23.wav", + "text": "113年今年前十大來臺灣旅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/24.wav", + "text": "這個數據看起來觸目驚心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/25.wav", + "text": "日本和我們最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/26.wav", + "text": "而且大家都想去日本對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/27.wav", + "text": "的日本旅客和113年前9個月相比你看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/28.wav", + "text": "腰斬了一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/29.wav", + "text": "少了52.26" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/30.wav", + "text": "美國少13%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/31.wav", + "text": "當然減少最多的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/32.wav", + "text": "中國大陸少了91.65" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/33.wav", + "text": "表示前十大裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/34.wav", + "text": "除了極少數的泰國和越南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/35.wav", + "text": "菲律賓是正成長之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/36.wav", + "text": "其他都是負的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/37.wav", + "text": "但是這一兩個月的狀況有好一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/38.wav", + "text": "人日本來的觀光客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/39.wav", + "text": "其實這一兩個月成長的速度還滿快的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/40.wav", + "text": "這一兩個來了很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/41.wav", + "text": "最近在日本就推出很多行銷方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/42.wav", + "text": "也確實有看到效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/43.wav", + "text": "這一兩個月的成長速度滿快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/44.wav", + "text": "的委員其實從您提供的這個數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/45.wav", + "text": "我們也看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/46.wav", + "text": "美國的旅客已經排到第四名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/47.wav", + "text": "各國來臺的旅客增加的速度都滿快的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/48.wav", + "text": "當然還是不如預期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/49.wav", + "text": "不過本席也看到一個很特別的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/50.wav", + "text": "的公務預算還算持平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/51.wav", + "text": "但是基金的錢卻非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/52.wav", + "text": "狀況這幾年一直往上跳這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/53.wav", + "text": "樣人民就要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/54.wav", + "text": "了外國旅客越來越少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/55.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/56.wav", + "text": "政府的基金怎麼一下增加那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/57.wav", + "text": "長立法委員要幫人民看緊荷包所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/58.wav", + "text": "只有兩種結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/59.wav", + "text": "嘛第一個你們要更努力趕快把人找進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/60.wav", + "text": "讓旅客多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/61.wav", + "text": "那一定是砍掉預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/62.wav", + "text": "嘛是不是只有這兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/63.wav", + "text": "不是只有對外用來招攬客人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/64.wav", + "text": "都是由這些基金和預算支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/65.wav", + "text": "要管理獅頭山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/66.wav", + "text": "也都是用這方面的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/67.wav", + "text": "其實連續三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/68.wav", + "text": "不過增加的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/69.wav", + "text": "還沒有恢復到疫情之前的水準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/70.wav", + "text": "這是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/71.wav", + "text": "但今年的人數比去年還多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/72.wav", + "text": "去年是649萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/73.wav", + "text": "人我剛有向委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/74.wav", + "text": "人已經比去年高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/75.wav", + "text": "我們必須繼續把它做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/76.wav", + "text": "未來觀光客才會更願意來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/77.wav", + "text": "部長要加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/78.wav", + "text": "啦要再加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/79.wav", + "text": "要不然老實說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/80.wav", + "text": "說現在立法委員要審預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/81.wav", + "text": "明明來旅遊的人就是一直減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/82.wav", + "text": "金額卻一直增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/83.wav", + "text": "這樣也沒辦法向人民交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/84.wav", + "text": "另外一個大問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/85.wav", + "text": "如果你去計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/86.wav", + "text": "就會看到一個很嚴重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/87.wav", + "text": "平均消費也減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/88.wav", + "text": "我們希望大家來臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/89.wav", + "text": "可以做一些消費性強一點的活動和動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/90.wav", + "text": "啦這個部分我們也請觀光署去想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/91.wav", + "text": "看看和旅行社怎麼配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/92.wav", + "text": "讓他們來臺灣時多做一些消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/93.wav", + "text": "這個部分要具體去做好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/94.wav", + "text": "提高人均消費嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/95.wav", + "text": "來了以後消費又降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/96.wav", + "text": "提出報告研議怎麼讓他們的消費提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/97.wav", + "text": "另外一個問題也要注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/98.wav", + "text": "剛才說的是進來的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/99.wav", + "text": "問題就是臺灣現在的服務業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/100.wav", + "text": "尤其是旅館業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/101.wav", + "text": "元喔結果從事藝術和娛樂休閒的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/102.wav", + "text": "特別是服務業住宿和餐飲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/103.wav", + "text": "這個有解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/104.wav", + "text": "這些都是你管的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/105.wav", + "text": "耶老實說現在在餐廳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/106.wav", + "text": "臺灣的薪資水準大概都滿平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/107.wav", + "text": "的啦不會只有旅宿業特別低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/108.wav", + "text": "啦其他的行業應該大家滿平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/109.wav", + "text": "的這個部分必須全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/110.wav", + "text": "我們也有在呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/111.wav", + "text": "因為旅宿業者常向我們反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/112.wav", + "text": "他們徵不到人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/113.wav", + "text": "你們如果提高薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/114.wav", + "text": "或許就不會有缺工的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/115.wav", + "text": "找不到人就是因為薪水太低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/116.wav", + "text": "嘛這大概是連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/117.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/118.wav", + "text": "這個部分需要比較多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/119.wav", + "text": "大概3個月好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/120.wav", + "text": "3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/121.wav", + "text": "提出報告怎麼讓旅館業和服務業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/122.wav", + "text": "等等和交通部有關的行業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/123.wav", + "text": "薪資可以往上走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/124.wav", + "text": "3個月內給本席一份報告好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/125.wav", + "text": "最後本席做3個具體要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/126.wav", + "text": "一個之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/127.wav", + "text": "兩岸官方在觀光旅遊方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/128.wav", + "text": "有很多互動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/129.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/130.wav", + "text": "現在看起來有點停擺了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/131.wav", + "text": "請給本席一份比較明確的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/132.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/133.wav", + "text": "要怎麼解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/134.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/135.wav", + "text": "2個月內針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/136.wav", + "text": "剛才部長也做了一部分解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/137.wav", + "text": "是不是撒幣太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/138.wav", + "text": "對內又是大內宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/139.wav", + "text": "給本席一份報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/140.wav", + "text": "另外在3個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/141.wav", + "text": "對於怎麼提升外國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/142.wav", + "text": "到臺灣旅遊的體驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/143.wav", + "text": "就是我們剛才說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/144.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼讓他們願意花費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/145.wav", + "text": "一方面要讓人家願意來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/146.wav", + "text": "人數也多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/147.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/148.wav", + "text": "不要一直都是逆差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/149.wav", + "text": "啦希望哪一天我們可以看到黃金交叉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/150.wav", + "text": "到國外旅遊當然很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/151.wav", + "text": "可是進來的人要更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/152.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/153.wav", + "text": "我們共同努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158047/154.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/1.wav", + "text": "有請臺鐵董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/2.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/3.wav", + "text": "請杜微董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/4.wav", + "text": "部長不用緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/5.wav", + "text": "請部長稍作休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/6.wav", + "text": "董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/7.wav", + "text": "我每次看到你都想要跟你討論臺鐵的文資保存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/8.wav", + "text": "我們來看投影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/9.wav", + "text": "11月9日臺鐵發了一篇新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/10.wav", + "text": "說臺鐵為了文資編了非常多預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/11.wav", + "text": "還成立了鐵路文化保存及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/12.wav", + "text": "活用小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/13.wav", + "text": "還說已經開了11次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/14.wav", + "text": "跟相關預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/15.wav", + "text": "來看看起來臺鐵對於文資保存是有一些信心跟決心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/16.wav", + "text": "可是我想要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/17.wav", + "text": "臺鐵內部在開這些會議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/18.wav", + "text": "到底對於文資的認定標準是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/19.wav", + "text": "我知道你們後來有找了專家學者討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/20.wav", + "text": "也是因為有新聞出了網友快速積極熱烈地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/21.wav", + "text": "所以臺鐵做出了回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/22.wav", + "text": "可是我當時就提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/23.wav", + "text": "不要因為發生新聞事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/24.wav", + "text": "才來看臺鐵的文資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/25.wav", + "text": "在你們的新聞稿裡面說要保存文資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/26.wav", + "text": "可是我們看到預算的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/27.wav", + "text": "卻被你們自己做了調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/28.wav", + "text": "是因為你們營運的壓力很大嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/29.wav", + "text": "你看一下當你們在臉書發了這個文之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/30.wav", + "text": "底下的留言都在罵你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/31.wav", + "text": "大家擔心那些各式各樣的老火車到哪裡去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/32.wav", + "text": "隨便說一個EU300到哪裡去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/33.wav", + "text": "大家都在問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/34.wav", + "text": "我只是要說看起來是個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/35.wav", + "text": "可是我認為是因為臺鐵公司對於整個文資保存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/36.wav", + "text": "通案的心情跟態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/37.wav", + "text": "才會讓這麼多在意臺鐵文史的網友們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/38.wav", + "text": "董事長你有看過這個追蹤臺鐵文物的臉書專頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/39.wav", + "text": "嗎有二十幾萬人在上面關心你們臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/40.wav", + "text": "如果真的在專家委員會裡面找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/41.wav", + "text": "大家都在意的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/42.wav", + "text": "或者是你們的眼睛看出去的文資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/43.wav", + "text": "跟網友們所在意的文資不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/44.wav", + "text": "是不是可以加入這個粉專來看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/45.wav", + "text": "我們來看一下臺鐵給我們的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/46.wav", + "text": "我們後來跟你們臺鐵索資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/47.wav", + "text": "有一台車叫S201" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/48.wav", + "text": "這是在你們的清單上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/49.wav", + "text": "我們辦了一個自己的考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/50.wav", + "text": "感謝臺鐵當時接待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/51.wav", + "text": "我們來看一下這個機車現在的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/52.wav", + "text": "我們也很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/53.wav", + "text": "它現在維修的狀況跟進度又是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/54.wav", + "text": "確實就是��常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/55.wav", + "text": "不是鐵路發燒友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/56.wav", + "text": "都會認為它是非常重要的火車頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/57.wav", + "text": "而現在這個機車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/58.wav", + "text": "維修的進度跟照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/59.wav", + "text": "還有放在隔壁空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/60.wav", + "text": "的CK101我當天沒有辦法看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/61.wav", + "text": "我也不知道它的維修狀況跟進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/62.wav", + "text": "到底在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/63.wav", + "text": "我會說臺灣有這麼多屬於臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/64.wav", + "text": "的非常珍貴的鐵路文物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/65.wav", + "text": "其實它可以是很好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/66.wav", + "text": "國內觀光旅遊素材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/67.wav", + "text": "甚至也可以召喚起國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/68.wav", + "text": "對於臺鐵的認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/69.wav", + "text": "跟對於臺鐵的喜愛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/70.wav", + "text": "我認為透過這樣子的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/71.wav", + "text": "應該可以更加呼喚大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/72.wav", + "text": "對於臺鐵的喜愛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/73.wav", + "text": "而不是只是靠昂貴的旅遊列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/74.wav", + "text": "那個市場性是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/75.wav", + "text": "我並沒有說昂貴旅遊列車不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/76.wav", + "text": "可是我們這麼多文史的保存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/77.wav", + "text": "董事長你怎麼看這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/78.wav", + "text": "董事長我想問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/79.wav", + "text": "你怎麼看臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/80.wav", + "text": "目前文資保存的問題跟困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/81.wav", + "text": "還有我也想要請你說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/82.wav", + "text": "你們自己認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/83.wav", + "text": "你們目前的困境到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/84.wav", + "text": "其實包括我本人在內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/85.wav", + "text": "我其實是滿注重我們臺鐵的文資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/86.wav", + "text": "但是因為我們臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/87.wav", + "text": "還有我們的rolling stock" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/88.wav", + "text": "退役以後的確有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/89.wav", + "text": "所以我們在界定文資的工作上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/90.wav", + "text": "必須要透過很多的調查還有認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/91.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/92.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員有提到我們有很多的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/93.wav", + "text": "我簡單講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/94.wav", + "text": "或文資保存的相關預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/95.wav", + "text": "當然這些就是在這個範疇之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/96.wav", + "text": "如果是在這個範疇之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/97.wav", + "text": "為珍貴的文化資產的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/98.wav", + "text": "我們未來���有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/99.wav", + "text": "對這個計畫我們的想法跟走法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/100.wav", + "text": "就是我們可能也要提報計畫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/101.wav", + "text": "然後向文化部跟相關單位爭取一些經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/102.wav", + "text": "我聽到你剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/103.wav", + "text": "這個大型計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/104.wav", + "text": "你預計多久內提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/105.wav", + "text": "我的記憶是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/106.wav", + "text": "應該是在後年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/107.wav", + "text": "後年是2026年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/108.wav", + "text": "2026年嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/109.wav", + "text": "對現在已經在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/110.wav", + "text": "好那我們辦公室會再持續追蹤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/111.wav", + "text": "臺鐵這些文資文物的保存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/112.wav", + "text": "我認為現在沒有開放多元透明的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/113.wav", + "text": "還有我也認為臺鐵應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/114.wav", + "text": "積極地定期對外報告這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/115.wav", + "text": "我認為更多的公民參與這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/116.wav", + "text": "絕對有助於臺鐵把相關文資做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/117.wav", + "text": "請不要把這些民間專業的聲音排斥在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/118.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個非常非常可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/119.wav", + "text": "不要等到每次新聞事件爆發出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/120.wav", + "text": "我們才又回頭想要去協助那個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/121.wav", + "text": "好好謝謝董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/122.wav", + "text": "\n最後一題主席不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/123.wav", + "text": "我想要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/124.wav", + "text": "我上次問了關於臺鐵安全的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/125.wav", + "text": "聽說你們就召開了相關會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/126.wav", + "text": "大家沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/127.wav", + "text": "所以這件事情就不要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/128.wav", + "text": "就繼續放著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/129.wav", + "text": "我不知道部長知不知道這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/130.wav", + "text": "但是我想董事長你應該要知道這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/131.wav", + "text": "我想要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/132.wav", + "text": "你們的想法跟規劃到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/133.wav", + "text": "這一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/134.wav", + "text": "是指我們在駕駛台上的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/135.wav", + "text": "這個事情我們現在還在跟我們工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/136.wav", + "text": "民眾乘坐車子的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/137.wav", + "text": "你們怎麼看這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/138.wav", + "text": "如果最後只是因為工會內部沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/139.wav", + "text": "可是我們沒有辦法導入更好的更安全的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/140.wav", + "text": "來保障民眾的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/141.wav", + "text": "我會認為這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/142.wav", + "text": "不能用工會沒有共識來對人民交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/143.wav", + "text": "但我猜想部長可能還來不及知道這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/144.wav", + "text": "但我認為這件事情還有溝通的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/145.wav", + "text": "時間有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/146.wav", + "text": "我想要拜託董事長把這樣的心情帶回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/147.wav", + "text": "真的不要等到出事了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/148.wav", + "text": "我們才來看這件事情好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/149.wav", + "text": "我們都不希望再有相關的交通意外不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/150.wav", + "text": "是還是要向委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/151.wav", + "text": "但是我們既有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/152.wav", + "text": "如果落實去做的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/153.wav", + "text": "其實安全還是可以確保的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/154.wav", + "text": "好本席希望董事長今天說的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/155.wav", + "text": "真的可以做為民眾乘坐臺鐵提供重要的安全保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/156.wav", + "text": "但是如果國外都已經有相關做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/157.wav", + "text": "而臺灣卻遲遲不肯沿用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/158.wav", + "text": "本席認為你們也要給一個說法和交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/159.wav", + "text": "為什麼工會做出這樣的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/160.wav", + "text": "甚至交通部也必須為這樣的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/161.wav", + "text": "買單本席認為這件事情還有待商榷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/162.wav", + "text": "我們也會持續追蹤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158046/163.wav", + "text": "謝謝董事長謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/0.wav", + "text": "好主席謝謝麻煩請陳世凱部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/1.wav", + "text": "委員好陳部長延續剛剛幾個委員大家關心的話題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/2.wav", + "text": "我想交通部身為中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/3.wav", + "text": "臺鐵高鐵現在都公司化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/4.wav", + "text": "對你來講應該沒有大小眼吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/5.wav", + "text": "只要公司能夠服務所有的鄉親民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/6.wav", + "text": "讓2,350萬人的交通更提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/7.wav", + "text": "都應該要給予支持對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/8.wav", + "text": "好那我先請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/9.wav", + "text": "本席有看到一個新聞是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/10.wav", + "text": "高鐵的年終獎金會有好消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/11.wav", + "text": "那請教現在年終獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/12.wav", + "text": "今年確定高鐵會有多少了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/13.wav", + "text": "我聽到的好消息是他們勞資雙方的溝通順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/14.wav", + "text": "這是好消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/15.wav", + "text": "因為勞方也能接受的狀況底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/16.wav", + "text": "就是好消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/17.wav", + "text": "是今年年初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/18.wav", + "text": "因為大家看到高鐵的績��不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/19.wav", + "text": "連同我們看到昨天的新聞是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/20.wav", + "text": "但某種程度上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/21.wav", + "text": "大家現在都講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/22.wav", + "text": "禮拜五晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/23.wav", + "text": "南下一位難求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/24.wav", + "text": "禮拜天晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/25.wav", + "text": "北上一位難求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/26.wav", + "text": "代表大家都坐高鐵非常地多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/27.wav", + "text": "所以高鐵今年的年終獎金有可能會比去年更高嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/28.wav", + "text": "我只能跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/29.wav", + "text": "數字我不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/30.wav", + "text": "但是勞資雙方的溝通過程是順暢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/31.wav", + "text": "目前他們應該有得到共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/32.wav", + "text": "什麼時候可以確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/33.wav", + "text": "這個要由高鐵公司來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/34.wav", + "text": "今天高鐵公司有來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/35.wav", + "text": "今天高鐵公司沒來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/36.wav", + "text": "沒有來是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/37.wav", + "text": "鐵是民營化的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/38.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/39.wav", + "text": "另外一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/40.wav", + "text": "臺鐵員工大家也在思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/41.wav", + "text": "既然現在高鐵公司跟臺鐵公司都公司化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/42.wav", + "text": "那臺鐵今年的年終獎金怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/43.wav", + "text": "所以會有1.5個月年終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/44.wav", + "text": "但是現在公司化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/45.wav", + "text": "尤其是我現在看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/46.wav", + "text": "明年還是虧損的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/47.wav", + "text": "臺鐵公司的員工那麼辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/48.wav", + "text": "也都是同一批人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/49.wav", + "text": "那麼優秀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/50.wav", + "text": "我認識非常多臺鐵的基層同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/51.wav", + "text": "大家也都很優秀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/52.wav", + "text": "交通部這個媽媽管太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/53.wav", + "text": "好像有很多的競爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/54.wav", + "text": "很多的路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/55.wav", + "text": "不願意讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/56.wav", + "text": "跟高鐵公司來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/57.wav", + "text": "良性的競爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/58.wav", + "text": "然後沒有辦法提升臺鐵的績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/59.wav", + "text": "所以我剛剛開始開宗明義請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/60.wav", + "text": "既然都已經公司化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/61.wav", + "text": "對兩個孩子不會大小眼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/62.wav", + "text": "你也同意嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/63.wav", + "text": "嘛同樣地臺鐵公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/64.wav", + "text": "委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/65.wav", + "text": "留任的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/66.wav", + "text": "就是受到條例保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/67.wav", + "text": "所以不會有所差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/68.wav", + "text": "就照以往的方式來發放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/69.wav", + "text": "是新進的從業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/70.wav", + "text": "相關要點已經頒下來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/71.wav", + "text": "所以我們會依據要點的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/72.wav", + "text": "要點規定是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/73.wav", + "text": "有考成獎金跟激勵獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/74.wav", + "text": "兩部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/75.wav", + "text": "比較簡單明確地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/76.wav", + "text": "因為很多員工還是會擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/77.wav", + "text": "所以到底臺鐵今年年終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/78.wav", + "text": "是怎麼發放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/79.wav", + "text": "如果新進同仁的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/80.wav", + "text": "新進同仁的發放就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/81.wav", + "text": "會不會受到虧損的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/82.wav", + "text": "響明年虧損還是會有86億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/83.wav", + "text": "那會不會因為這樣子而沒有發放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/84.wav", + "text": "還有你們的改善狀況怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/85.wav", + "text": "我們當然不要期待臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/86.wav", + "text": "我們那時候希望公司化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/87.wav", + "text": "也是希望能夠提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/88.wav", + "text": "更希望有一天你們轉虧為盈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/89.wav", + "text": "我相信臺鐵和高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/90.wav", + "text": "甚至以班次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/91.wav", + "text": "或是航運的路線來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/92.wav", + "text": "其實臺鐵不比高鐵差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/93.wav", + "text": "那高鐵在去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/94.wav", + "text": "可以拿到五六個月的年終獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/95.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/96.wav", + "text": "一個半月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/97.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/98.wav", + "text": "未來絕對有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/99.wav", + "text": "但是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/100.wav", + "text": "這個未來我們看得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/101.wav", + "text": "可以在你的任內完成嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/102.wav", + "text": "就是我們不敢回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/103.wav", + "text": "不是不敢回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/104.wav", + "text": "公司化的第一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/105.wav", + "text": "我們還是有按照我們的進度在走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/106.wav", + "text": "我也坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/107.wav", + "text": "像今年跟明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/108.wav", + "text": "我們還是會有虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/109.wav", + "text": "那這個虧損會不會影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/110.wav", + "text": "我們從業人員的考成發放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/111.wav", + "text": "我要幫臺鐵的員工講一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/112.wav", + "text": "其實臺鐵有一些虧損是因為政策性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/113.wav", + "text": "是就是臺鐵過去到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/114.wav", + "text": "因為交通部認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/115.wav", + "text": "相對來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/116.wav", + "text": "跟高鐵不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/117.wav", + "text": "競爭良性競爭的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/118.wav", + "text": "他們也認為以臺鐵的票價以臺鐵的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/119.wav", + "text": "以臺鐵的多路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/120.wav", + "text": "不會比高鐵差嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/121.wav", + "text": "是所以員工的權益尤其是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/122.wav", + "text": "基層員工的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/123.wav", + "text": "所以我才要幫臺鐵的同仁講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/124.wav", + "text": "就是現在要確認臺鐵今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/125.wav", + "text": "會不會受到母公司的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/126.wav", + "text": "臺鐵董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/127.wav", + "text": "好部長這樣承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/128.wav", + "text": "\n另外中華電信工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/129.wav", + "text": "現在也有提出相關的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/130.wav", + "text": "跟資方的協商也破局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/131.wav", + "text": "目前的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/132.wav", + "text": "如果現在工會跟公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/133.wav", + "text": "有沒有什麼方法可以來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/134.wav", + "text": "報告委員因為中華電信是上市櫃公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/135.wav", + "text": "我們要尊重他們的公司治理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/136.wav", + "text": "不過我們還是要呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/137.wav", + "text": "資方跟勞方要好好去協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/138.wav", + "text": "去協商不要影響到民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/139.wav", + "text": "它是上市櫃公司但是最大股東是交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/140.wav", + "text": "是所以我們的態度是希望勞方和資方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/141.wav", + "text": "董事長總經理也是交通部派的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/142.wav", + "text": "不是嗎對法人代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/143.wav", + "text": "是啊所以我們現在講的是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/144.wav", + "text": "當這些事情都是過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/145.wav", + "text": "沒有發生或者是過去發生的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/146.wav", + "text": "交通部有比較積極的主導角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/147.wav", + "text": "那我們現在也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/148.wav", + "text": "要求的是合理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/149.wav", + "text": "讓所有工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/150.wav", + "text": "的狀況不至於影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/151.wav", + "text": "一般民眾的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/152.wav", + "text": "其實我們要求的是因為現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/153.wav", + "text": "做無限期的夜宿總公司的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/154.wav", + "text": "抗爭活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/155.wav", + "text": "甚至可能造成民眾的消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/156.wav", + "text": "權益受損這是我們所擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/157.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有提到不要去影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/158.wav", + "text": "一般民眾的權益這個是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/159.wav", + "text": "好再來就是說勞資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/160.wav", + "text": "雙方要好好協議我知道資方已經有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/161.wav", + "text": "一部分的調薪方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/162.wav", + "text": "目前確實勞方還不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/163.wav", + "text": "那這個部分我們也呼籲他們要好好去協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/164.wav", + "text": "好所以有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/165.wav", + "text": "不會上綱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/166.wav", + "text": "延宕造成罷工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/167.wav", + "text": "影響到消費者的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/168.wav", + "text": "我們不會讓它影響到一般消費者的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/169.wav", + "text": "好部長的這個承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/170.wav", + "text": "\n最後部長我只是簡單說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/171.wav", + "text": "我們今天還有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/172.wav", + "text": "航港局的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/173.wav", + "text": "在預算書第11頁航港局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/174.wav", + "text": "的部分有講到針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/175.wav", + "text": "在本席選區的臺北港物流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/176.wav", + "text": "倉儲第三期第四期的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/177.wav", + "text": "圍堤工程並且在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/178.wav", + "text": "115年完工之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/179.wav", + "text": "給予既有油槽的遷建使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/180.wav", + "text": "我記得之前我看到的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/181.wav", + "text": "是在114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/182.wav", + "text": "所以你們是114年就要開始做計畫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/183.wav", + "text": "我也要求在既有油槽遷移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/184.wav", + "text": "開始計畫評估之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/185.wav", + "text": "臺北港港內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/186.wav", + "text": "的這一塊用地要做後續的規劃使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/187.wav", + "text": "這一個部分也要一併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/188.wav", + "text": "有計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/189.wav", + "text": "你簡單回應一下就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/190.wav", + "text": "我們都按照期程在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/191.wav", + "text": "大概在民國115年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/192.wav", + "text": "把嫌惡設施往外移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/193.wav", + "text": "繼續規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/194.wav", + "text": "那一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/195.wav", + "text": "是我也特別讓部長了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/196.wav", + "text": "部長您的轄區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/197.wav", + "text": "商港臺北港是重中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/198.wav", + "text": "之重其中油槽遷移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/199.wav", + "text": "從過去規劃本席也從上一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/200.wav", + "text": "到現在都一直關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/201.wav", + "text": "也要開始著手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/202.wav", + "text": "作業去規劃後續的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/203.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158045/204.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/0.wav", + "text": "請杜董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/2.wav", + "text": "董事長好現在臺鐵公司化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/3.wav", + "text": "跟你們原來的預期你覺得效果如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/4.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告我們有按照我們原來的步調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/5.wav", + "text": "跟我們的規劃在走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/6.wav", + "text": "有沒有遇到阻礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/7.wav", + "text": "阻礙有但是要克服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/8.wav", + "text": "要克服跟你們預計的期程都滿符合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/9.wav", + "text": "目前是還尚稱符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/10.wav", + "text": "農曆過年前臺鐵不會漲價對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/11.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/12.wav", + "text": "那農曆過年後就會漲價對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/13.wav", + "text": "這個要等到我們把票價合理化的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/14.wav", + "text": "報到部裡去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/15.wav", + "text": "你們已經規劃好了只是還沒送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/16.wav", + "text": "我們還沒有送我們公司的董事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/17.wav", + "text": "那會降價嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/18.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/19.wav", + "text": "不會嘛所以農曆過年後就有可能漲價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/20.wav", + "text": "嘛好\n第二個漲價以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/21.wav", + "text": "到底什麼樣的人會被影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/22.wav", + "text": "優惠就是幾乎每天搭車的這些客人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/23.wav", + "text": "可以打折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/24.wav", + "text": "可不可以告訴大家哪一些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/25.wav", + "text": "很少在坐臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/26.wav", + "text": "大家不要緊張臺鐵雖然漲價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/27.wav", + "text": "可是每天都坐臺鐵通勤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/28.wav", + "text": "人買TPASS的也不用緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/29.wav", + "text": "其實大部分的人都不會影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/30.wav", + "text": "只有那種像我有時候會去花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/31.wav", + "text": "買一張臺北到花蓮的車票440元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/32.wav", + "text": "元我可能會被影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/33.wav", + "text": "因為我不是常客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/34.wav", + "text": "第一個如果是使用TPASS的客人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/35.wav", + "text": "因為這部分的票價不在我們合理化的調動裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/36.wav", + "text": "基本上我們現在已經調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/37.wav", + "text": "而且我們也有推出定期票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/38.wav", + "text": "常客為什麼不買TPASS" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/39.wav", + "text": "的只有搭乘臺鐵的機會多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/40.wav", + "text": "乘客有可能只買臺鐵的定期票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/41.wav", + "text": "或者是使用電子票證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/42.wav", + "text": "這樣比較划得來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/43.wav", + "text": "對就是說因為它的總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/44.wav", + "text": "是因為你們最短的是15塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/45.wav", + "text": "是這個原因嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/46.wav", + "text": "你坐臺鐵時有沒有發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/47.wav", + "text": "在臺鐵的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/48.wav", + "text": "跟高鐵的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/49.wav", + "text": "比如說我在高鐵站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/50.wav", + "text": "走走走走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/51.wav", + "text": "走就知道我到臺鐵了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/52.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/53.wav", + "text": "你有沒有這種感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/54.wav", + "text": "有我有這種感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/55.wav", + "text": "但是怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/56.wav", + "text": "臺鐵比較陳舊一點的車站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/57.wav", + "text": "如果現在委員有到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/58.wav", + "text": "這些新營運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/59.wav", + "text": "臺中沒有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/60.wav", + "text": "對這個我們有重置計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/61.wav", + "text": "其實高雄站也很明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/62.wav", + "text": "是這個部分我們臺鐵公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/63.wav", + "text": "都有編重置計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/64.wav", + "text": "我們會再來改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/65.wav", + "text": "建議重置快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/66.wav", + "text": "走走走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/67.wav", + "text": "下一題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/68.wav", + "text": "你有沒有在臺鐵列車上過廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/69.wav", + "text": "你有沒有在高鐵列車上廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/70.wav", + "text": "比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/71.wav", + "text": "為什麼臺鐵列車廁所的地板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/72.wav", + "text": "然後高鐵的都不會濕漉漉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/73.wav", + "text": "有沒有發現這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/74.wav", + "text": "是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/75.wav", + "text": "你知道為什麼嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/76.wav", + "text": "大概原因不只一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/77.wav", + "text": "你們新買的車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/78.wav", + "text": "這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/79.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/80.wav", + "text": "第一個可能是使用量的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/81.wav", + "text": "因為乘客在臺鐵列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/82.wav", + "text": "也比較久一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/83.wav", + "text": "不像高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/84.wav", + "text": "在高鐵車上的時間比較短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/85.wav", + "text": "好我給你一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/86.wav", + "text": "我有認真想過這個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/87.wav", + "text": "我也認真測試過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/88.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/89.wav", + "text": "臺鐵的廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/90.wav", + "text": "所以水很容易濺出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/91.wav", + "text": "第二個是臺鐵的列車裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/92.wav", + "text": "並沒有擦手紙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/93.wav", + "text": "臺鐵沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/94.wav", + "text": "所以乘客手洗一洗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/95.wav", + "text": "甩下一個進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/96.wav", + "text": "的人覺得地上濕答答的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/97.wav", + "text": "他就覺得髒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/98.wav", + "text": "因為他不知道地上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/99.wav", + "text": "是什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/100.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/101.wav", + "text": "臺鐵的票價要調漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/102.wav", + "text": "服務品質要跟上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/103.wav", + "text": "不要讓人家從空間上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/104.wav", + "text": "就知道到了臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/105.wav", + "text": "坐列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/106.wav", + "text": "其實是坐你們新買的列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/107.wav", + "text": "啊這就是臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/108.wav", + "text": "這絕對不是高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/109.wav", + "text": "這樣實在是算是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/110.wav", + "text": "這個我們再來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/111.wav", + "text": "好希望臺鐵公司加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/112.wav", + "text": "讓我們有一天坐臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/113.wav", + "text": "時走到臺鐵的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/114.wav", + "text": "覺得這個地方好像到高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/115.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158044/116.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/0.wav", + "text": "請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/1.wav", + "text": "我們叫會計處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/2.wav", + "text": "不用說恭喜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/3.wav", + "text": "我們今天看就業安定基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/4.wav", + "text": "業安定基金的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/5.wav", + "text": "就業安定基金收支保管及應用辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/6.wav", + "text": "所以在整個基金管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/7.wav", + "text": "中有主計總處的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/8.wav", + "text": "管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/9.wav", + "text": "之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/10.wav", + "text": "是不是會計處要先審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/11.wav", + "text": "業務單位會先簽核給你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/12.wav", + "text": "還是直接就送到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/13.wav", + "text": "管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/14.wav", + "text": "決定要舉辦這個音樂會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/15.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/16.wav", + "text": "都有照相關的行政程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/17.wav", + "text": "簽核到首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/18.wav", + "text": "怎麼會講不清楚呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/19.wav", + "text": "就業安定基金管理委員會審議之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/20.wav", + "text": "內部要先簽核對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/21.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/22.wav", + "text": "要不要先會你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/23.wav", + "text": "如果是涉及到採購的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/24.wav", + "text": "要動支經費都要會會當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/25.wav", + "text": "然會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/26.wav", + "text": "我是說這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/27.wav", + "text": "要讓部長瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/28.wav", + "text": "上在送到就業安定基金管理委員會審議之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/29.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/30.wav", + "text": "先經過會計處嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/31.wav", + "text": "部長你要去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/32.wav", + "text": "瞭解什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/33.wav", + "text": "就是在程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/34.wav", + "text": "有沒有盡到責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/35.wav", + "text": "會計處要去審查這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/36.wav", + "text": "到底符不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/37.wav", + "text": "就業安定基金的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/38.wav", + "text": "這是最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/39.wav", + "text": "這恐怕也不只是會計處的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/40.wav", + "text": "責任的很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/41.wav", + "text": "之前委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/42.wav", + "text": "大家都在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/43.wav", + "text": "第一個當然是部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/44.wav", + "text": "第二個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/45.wav", + "text": "這個委員會有沒有好好的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/46.wav", + "text": "基本上如果會計處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/47.wav", + "text": "都隨便蓋章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/48.wav", + "text": "那就是錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/49.wav", + "text": "會計處處長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/50.wav", + "text": "這個辦公室的採購案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/51.wav", + "text": ",250萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/52.wav", + "text": "元就業安定基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/53.wav", + "text": "當年度的預算書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/54.wav", + "text": "裡有沒有編這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/55.wav", + "text": "預算數有沒有編那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/56.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/57.wav", + "text": "所以不是就業安定基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/58.wav", + "text": "是啊有這麼多嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/59.wav", + "text": "有編這麼多嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/60.wav", + "text": "一定是在我們的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/61.wav", + "text": "我問的是有沒有編那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/62.wav", + "text": "預算數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/63.wav", + "text": "處長你也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/64.wav", + "text": "好這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/65.wav", + "text": "委員這些確實都是用就安基金來支付的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/66.wav", + "text": "這個我已經確認過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/67.wav", + "text": "處長我要問會計處處長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/68.wav", + "text": "你很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/69.wav", + "text": "我是老公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/70.wav", + "text": "基本上第一關就是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/71.wav", + "text": "可不可以動支這個經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/72.wav", + "text": "第一關就是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/73.wav", + "text": "這個是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/74.wav", + "text": "因為你們是一條鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/75.wav", + "text": "什麼叫一條鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/76.wav", + "text": "勞動部部長是管不了你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/77.wav", + "text": "是行政院主計總處指派的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/78.wav", + "text": "對不對處長是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/79.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/80.wav", + "text": "所以你很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/81.wav", + "text": "這機制有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/82.wav", + "text": "如果他們都蓋章沒有表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/83.wav", + "text": "那就是會計處的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/84.wav", + "text": "如果他們有表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/85.wav", + "text": "那就是部長的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/86.wav", + "text": "好你回去也查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/87.wav", + "text": "有沒有比預算數還高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/88.wav", + "text": "你現在知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/89.wav", + "text": "可以現在回答嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/90.wav", + "text": "有沒有比預算數還高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/91.wav", + "text": "當年度的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/92.wav", + "text": "這個我們回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/93.wav", + "text": "好回去查是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/94.wav", + "text": "我們回去確認然後再提供給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/95.wav", + "text": "好為什麼我要問這個呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/96.wav", + "text": "提供資料給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/97.wav", + "text": "超支併決算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/98.wav", + "text": "有一個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/99.wav", + "text": "這個機制是最糟糕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/100.wav", + "text": "最容易出問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/101.wav", + "text": "關於這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/102.wav", + "text": "因為時間的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/103.wav", + "text": "本來還有很多議題要談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/104.wav", + "text": "下次再跟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/105.wav", + "text": "來提供相關的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158043/106.wav", + "text": "謝謝鄭委員提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/1.wav", + "text": "有請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/2.wav", + "text": "有請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/3.wav", + "text": "先請洪部長看兩張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/4.wav", + "text": "表勞保基金收不抵支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/5.wav", + "text": "從2017年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/6.wav", + "text": "它的保費收入3005百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/7.wav", + "text": "元支出3008百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/8.wav", + "text": "元negative是276億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/9.wav", + "text": "元一路到2023年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/10.wav", + "text": "元然後今年預估要虧605億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/11.wav", + "text": "元2025年預估虧849億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/12.wav", + "text": "元這是你們給的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/13.wav", + "text": "而勞保的潛藏負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/14.wav", + "text": "有人講是十幾兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/15.wav", + "text": "元所以一個人平均要背56萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/16.wav", + "text": "2017年到2025年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/17.wav", + "text": "累計的收不抵支計3,818億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/18.wav", + "text": "元再看下一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/19.wav", + "text": "從2020年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/20.wav", + "text": "政府撥補200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/21.wav", + "text": "元2021年撥220億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/22.wav", + "text": "元一直到2024年的1,200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/23.wav", + "text": "元疫後特別條例是分三年300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/24.wav", + "text": "元合計已經撥補了2,670億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/25.wav", + "text": "元加上你們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/26.wav", + "text": "已經算出的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/27.wav", + "text": "明年要撥補1,300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/28.wav", + "text": "收不抵支3,818" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/29.wav", + "text": "政府給了3,870" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/30.wav", + "text": "億元這兩張圖講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/31.wav", + "text": "就是如果沒有政府撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/32.wav", + "text": "勞保是不是要破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/33.wav", + "text": "請問部長是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/34.wav", + "text": "撥補當然非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/35.wav", + "text": "我就請你回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/36.wav", + "text": "如果沒有這3,870億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/37.wav", + "text": "元勞保是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/38.wav", + "text": "目前數字算起來可能還沒啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/39.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/40.wav", + "text": "什麼叫離危險的線愈來愈近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/41.wav", + "text": "聽不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/42.wav", + "text": "這是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/43.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/44.wav", + "text": "現在我們的餘額有一兆九百零多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/45.wav", + "text": "但是很多人沒有來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/46.wav", + "text": "啊那些人全部來就爆了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/47.wav", + "text": "就是有些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/48.wav", + "text": "有條件來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/49.wav", + "text": "但是他沒有申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/50.wav", + "text": "所以你還有一兆多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/51.wav", + "text": "那些有資格的通通來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/52.wav", + "text": "這位長官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/53.wav", + "text": "不好意思我是保險司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/54.wav", + "text": "如果可以申請的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/55.wav", + "text": "今天都來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/56.wav", + "text": "今天就破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/57.wav", + "text": "當然是有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/58.wav", + "text": "是這樣子嘛沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/59.wav", + "text": "啊大家都清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/60.wav", + "text": "是但是他還是要符合資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/61.wav", + "text": "要離職退保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/62.wav", + "text": "如果還在工作的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/63.wav", + "text": "是不能來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/64.wav", + "text": "對啦我講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/65.wav", + "text": "如果符合條件的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/66.wav", + "text": "都來跟你申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/67.wav", + "text": "就破產了就不夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/68.wav", + "text": "可是我們的負債有十幾兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/69.wav", + "text": "這個潛藏負債的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/70.wav", + "text": "大家一次都來提領的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/71.wav", + "text": "會有這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/72.wav", + "text": "極端情境的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/73.wav", + "text": "明年的1,300億元不用給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/74.wav", + "text": "啊還有一兆多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/75.wav", + "text": "但是現在保費的收入跟支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/76.wav", + "text": "確實就像賴委員剛才呈現的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/77.wav", + "text": "還是有短差的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/78.wav", + "text": "這部分在數字上面是很清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/79.wav", + "text": "這也是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/80.wav", + "text": "還是需要撥補的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/81.wav", + "text": "但是也因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/82.wav", + "text": "包括撥補包括我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/83.wav", + "text": "基金的投資收益這幾年都還不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/84.wav", + "text": "所以現在整體基金的水位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/85.wav", + "text": "目前是超過1兆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/86.wav", + "text": "原本大家對於勞保基金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/87.wav", + "text": "警報時限再往後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/88.wav", + "text": "不過我們不會說這樣子勞保基金就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/89.wav", + "text": "全然是不用擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/90.wav", + "text": "也不是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/91.wav", + "text": "那你現在潛藏負債有十幾兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/92.wav", + "text": "有人講15兆打個七折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/93.wav", + "text": "也有10兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/94.wav", + "text": "你這個部長總是要想一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/95.wav", + "text": "比較長期的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/96.wav", + "text": "辦法據我瞭解的以前勞保局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/97.wav", + "text": "上任第一件事依據他信的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/98.wav", + "text": "宗教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/99.wav", + "text": "幾乎都先要禱告或者要唸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/100.wav", + "text": "什麼的希望他任內不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/101.wav", + "text": "破產幾乎都是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/102.wav", + "text": "這個數字講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/103.wav", + "text": "2020年到2025" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/104.wav", + "text": "年如果不是政府撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/105.wav", + "text": "賴委員我們非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/106.wav", + "text": "非常審慎的在看待這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/107.wav", + "text": "絕對沒有隨隨便便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/108.wav", + "text": "也因為很審慎所以才覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/109.wav", + "text": "這時候政府的撥補在這個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/110.wav", + "text": "是有很高的必要性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/111.wav", + "text": "照你們剛才那位司長講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/112.wav", + "text": "根本就不需要撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/113.wav", + "text": "因為你們有一兆多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/114.wav", + "text": "這麼多錢在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/115.wav", + "text": "我們並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/116.wav", + "text": "這是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/117.wav", + "text": "這個是現在的事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/118.wav", + "text": "但即便有1兆元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/119.wav", + "text": "現在來講一個很重要的原因就是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/120.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能保費提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/121.wav", + "text": "即便現在有1兆元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/122.wav", + "text": "包括保費提高或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/123.wav", + "text": "砍給付這兩件事情確實很大程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/124.wav", + "text": "會影響勞工的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/125.wav", + "text": "所以這件事情我們認為要非常非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/126.wav", + "text": "謹慎而為或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/127.wav", + "text": "謹慎的來思量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/128.wav", + "text": "陳建仁前副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/129.wav", + "text": "在推動年改的時候他是連勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/130.wav", + "text": "都要砍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/131.wav", + "text": "後來勞工都沒有砍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/132.wav", + "text": "也沒有人反對了保障勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/133.wav", + "text": "因為勞工相對比較弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/134.wav", + "text": "砍得凶巴巴的然後勞工都不砍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/135.wav", + "text": "這是unfair的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/136.wav", + "text": "但是就是這樣子啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/137.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛跟賴委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/138.wav", + "text": "不管是增加保費或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/139.wav", + "text": "所以我們在很謹慎的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/140.wav", + "text": "後才會覺得現在政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/141.wav", + "text": "的撥補很重要也很關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/142.wav", + "text": "這樣講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/143.wav", + "text": "就可以了對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/144.wav", + "text": "不對部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/145.wav", + "text": "你在這裡是不是可重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/146.wav", + "text": "一句話剛剛你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/147.wav", + "text": "你當部長任內不會提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/148.wav", + "text": "不會砍勞保給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/149.wav", + "text": "一毛錢可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/150.wav", + "text": "目前政策上面就是沒有要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/151.wav", + "text": "提高保費也沒有要砍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/152.wav", + "text": "至少就目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/153.wav", + "text": "最後一個小問題也是很重要的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/154.wav", + "text": "我們來看薪資占GDP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/155.wav", + "text": "結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/156.wav", + "text": "臺灣給勞工的只有43%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/157.wav", + "text": "美國給勞工的是53%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/158.wav", + "text": "日本是53.6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/159.wav", + "text": "韓國是超過50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/160.wav", + "text": "這個嚴重讓臺灣的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/161.wav", + "text": "薪資都長期偏低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/162.wav", + "text": "我們有7成的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/163.wav", + "text": "領不到平均薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/164.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/165.wav", + "text": "你有什麼作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/166.wav", + "text": "可以讓企業主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/167.wav", + "text": "願意將賺的錢多付一點給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/168.wav", + "text": "勞工這是你該做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/169.wav", + "text": "讓勞工的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/170.wav", + "text": "生活不要那麼辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/171.wav", + "text": "我很同意你現在說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/172.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣拉高薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/173.wav", + "text": "在招聘過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/174.wav", + "text": "都要揭露這部分過去來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/175.wav", + "text": "是有一定的效果的這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/176.wav", + "text": "我們對基本工資的部分也持續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/177.wav", + "text": "的在做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/178.wav", + "text": "接下來我自己在思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/179.wav", + "text": "也跟同仁在討論有沒有可能透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/180.wav", + "text": "部分它可能怎麼樣提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/181.wav", + "text": "能夠提高薪資或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/182.wav", + "text": "讓勞工有更多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/183.wav", + "text": "分潤甚至包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/184.wav", + "text": "減低工時的具體策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/185.wav", + "text": "或者是行動方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/186.wav", + "text": "在這裡面能不能放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/187.wav", + "text": "你可以跟金管會談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/188.wav", + "text": "現在不是很流行ETF嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/189.wav", + "text": "最前面的100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/190.wav", + "text": "加薪100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/191.wav", + "text": "現在沒有這個指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/192.wav", + "text": "沒有這個指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/193.wav", + "text": "加薪100或者加薪50都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/194.wav", + "text": "賴委員對於金融相關的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/195.wav", + "text": "比我專業很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/196.wav", + "text": "我覺得這些相關的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/197.wav", + "text": "我們可以來持續討論我願意跟金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/198.wav", + "text": "我們立委人微言輕你是部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/199.wav", + "text": "比較有分量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/200.wav", + "text": "我們當然願意跟金管會來做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158042/201.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/0.wav", + "text": "再請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/1.wav", + "text": "林委部長臨危受命我覺得你其實是很有勇氣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/2.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得你應該也可以作為一個很願意改革的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/3.wav", + "text": "我今天要就教於你是因為你早上講了一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/4.wav", + "text": "你自己給自己的期待是這樣子你是要解決問題導向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/5.wav", + "text": "我要就教於你的這件事情就是關於勞動事件法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/6.wav", + "text": "因為勞動事件法從立法通過施行到現在將近5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/7.wav", + "text": "幾乎就快要滿5年了當時在立法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/8.wav", + "text": "雖然是司法及法制委員會跟我們一起聯席的這個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/9.wav", + "text": "當然我們就在想勞資關係在勞資爭議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/10.wav", + "text": "勞工是處於弱勢的這個狀況因為勞工的談判籌碼少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/11.wav", + "text": "證據的掌握都在資方手上尤其勞資爭議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/12.wav", + "text": "不利勞工去舉證可是勞工被欺負的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/13.wav", + "text": "沒有證據沒有辦法舉證在這種狀況裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/14.wav", + "text": "產生了一種結構上的不對等權利義務關係的不對等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/15.wav", + "text": "爭議協商的地位也不對等也沒有錢請律師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/16.wav", + "text": "比起資方聘僱的專業律師大家都覺得效果沒那麼好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/17.wav", + "text": "對等協商便淪為口號訴訟的經濟條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/18.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛講到其實也不一樣所以我們看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/19.wav", + "text": "整個法律的制定過程或是法律訴訟的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/20.wav", + "text": "其實有階級上的差異是非常大的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/21.wav", + "text": "\n所以當時我們衛環委員會跟司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/22.wav", + "text": "大家覺得應該要為弱勢的勞工做點什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/23.wav", + "text": "在這種狀況裡面我們就在民事訴訟的特別架構裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/24.wav", + "text": "架構了一個特別法也就是勞動事件法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/25.wav", + "text": "主要是調整了爭訟程序的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/26.wav", + "text": "這裡面當時在立法的時候強調了幾項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/27.wav", + "text": "第一個就是專業審理第二個強化當事人自主及迅速解決爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/28.wav", + "text": "但是對勞工而言更是金錢因為他比雇主更弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/29.wav", + "text": "當時是要減少勞工訴訟障礙便利勞工尋求法院的救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/30.wav", + "text": "然後要促進審判程序和時效要強化紛爭統一解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/31.wav", + "text": "最後第五個是叫做即時有效的權利保全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/32.wav", + "text": "其實這裡面一直在講時效時效時效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/33.wav", + "text": "現在講起來經過了5年實務界發現了一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/34.wav", + "text": "所以需要你去跟司法單位或者是相關的法制單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/35.wav", + "text": "2018年通過到現在已經7年施行到現在5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/36.wav", + "text": "到底是不是也應該要有一個新的檢討法案也要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/37.wav", + "text": "在這種狀況裡面我要跟你分享的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/38.wav", + "text": "我們在講強化當事人自主還有迅速解決爭議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/39.wav", + "text": "結果強制要調解先行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/40.wav", + "text": "起訴以前先調解調解不成的時候再進行訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/41.wav", + "text": "這樣效率比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/42.wav", + "text": "可是我們知道問題是執行起來就不是那樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/43.wav", + "text": "勞動事件法第8條第1項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/44.wav", + "text": "法院處理勞動事件應迅速進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/45.wav", + "text": "依事件性質擬定調解或審理計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/46.wav", + "text": "當事人應以誠信方式協力於前項程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/47.wav", + "text": "全部都要先強制調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/48.wav", + "text": "要求強制調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/49.wav", + "text": "那你的調解必須要是有效的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/50.wav", + "text": "率如果高你要求人家強制調解還有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/51.wav", + "text": "可是現在發現法律規定的強制調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/52.wav", + "text": "司法院進行的強制調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/53.wav", + "text": "跟你們過去勞工局勞動部門的行政調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/54.wav", + "text": "都一樣的無效也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/55.wav", + "text": "因為勞動事件法第三十一條第1項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/56.wav", + "text": "要先組成調解委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/57.wav", + "text": "調解委員會認為進行勞動調解不利於紛爭的迅速或妥適解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/58.wav", + "text": "或不能依職權提出適當方案者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/59.wav", + "text": "視為調解不成立並告知或通知當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/60.wav", + "text": "這個調解委員會的問題在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/61.wav", + "text": "它宣布調解不成立之後才可以進行訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/62.wav", + "text": "所以調解不成立是調解委員會才能夠宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/63.wav", + "text": "當事人不能宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/64.wav", + "text": "這個配套我們不知道為什麼當初的法律是這樣立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/65.wav", + "text": "勞動調解委員會可以宣布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/66.wav", + "text": "布人民沒有主張調解無效的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/67.wav", + "text": "那沒有宣告調解不成立的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/68.wav", + "text": "啦因為勞動事件法第十六條第十七條第十八" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/69.wav", + "text": "第8條第二十三條第二十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/70.wav", + "text": "要求當事人及法院要協力促進調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/71.wav", + "text": "然後講得很好聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/72.wav", + "text": "說調解程序以三個月內進行3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/73.wav", + "text": "終結為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/74.wav", + "text": "為原則而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/75.wav", + "text": "調解不成立以後的訴訟採集中審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/76.wav", + "text": "然後還以一次期日辯論終結為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/77.wav", + "text": "第一審並應於六個月內審結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/78.wav", + "text": "這兩個條款看起來很讚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/79.wav", + "text": "耶一定要調解啦三個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/80.wav", + "text": "一定要調解出一個結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/81.wav", + "text": "六個月內一定要審結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/82.wav", + "text": "啦聽起來很好聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/83.wav", + "text": "但是現實就不是那樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/84.wav", + "text": "因為都有例外條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/85.wav", + "text": "當時我們在立法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/86.wav", + "text": "都允許例外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/87.wav", + "text": "所以現在運作起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/88.wav", + "text": "都沒有三個月三次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/89.wav", + "text": "也沒有六個月內審結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/90.wav", + "text": "然後就存在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/91.wav", + "text": "調解委員會成員本來規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/92.wav", + "text": "要有一位法官加調解委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/93.wav", + "text": "現在法官都沒有參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/94.wav", + "text": "調解委員坐在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/95.wav", + "text": "然後叫人家來調解人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/96.wav", + "text": "所以以前我們在立法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/97.wav", + "text": "大家就這樣拍拍手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/98.wav", + "text": "因為大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/99.wav", + "text": "過去的行政調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/100.wav", + "text": "時才有處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/101.wav", + "text": "而這一些處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/102.wav", + "text": "事實上也沒有用過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/103.wav", + "text": "啦所以大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/104.wav", + "text": "你這個行政調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/105.wav", + "text": "觀念勸導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/106.wav", + "text": "單純溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/107.wav", + "text": "對於爭議解決方面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/108.wav", + "text": "實質影響幾乎是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/109.wav", + "text": "啦所以大家想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/110.wav", + "text": "換成這個勞動事件法來調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/111.wav", + "text": "應該很有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/112.wav", + "text": "喔到時候調解不成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/113.wav", + "text": "法官在調解過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/114.wav", + "text": "就形成心證了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/115.wav", + "text": "到時候審理會很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/116.wav", + "text": "爭點在調解的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/117.wav", + "text": "已經整理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/118.wav", + "text": "直接轉化成訴訟資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/119.wav", + "text": "無縫對接這樣的法律設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/120.wav", + "text": "讓大家都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/121.wav", + "text": "司法調解會更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/122.wav", + "text": "更有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/123.wav", + "text": "結果有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/124.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/125.wav", + "text": "法官都沒有參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/126.wav", + "text": "法官也不願意參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/127.wav", + "text": "也沒有時間參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/128.wav", + "text": "啦大家都知道法官的案量如海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/129.wav", + "text": "我們還幫法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/130.wav", + "text": "聘請很多的助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/131.wav", + "text": "5年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/132.wav", + "text": "勞動部沒有發現這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/133.wav", + "text": "結果勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/134.wav", + "text": "反而因為被強制調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/135.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法即時進行審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/136.wav", + "text": "連行政調解都行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/137.wav", + "text": "換了一個調解可是法官也沒有參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/138.wav", + "text": "也沒有能力調解成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/139.wav", + "text": "拖上六個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/140.wav", + "text": "啊部長你怎麼看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/141.wav", + "text": "先謝謝林委員的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/142.wav", + "text": "其實就我所知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/143.wav", + "text": "確實現在要調解先行這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/144.wav", + "text": "其實是司法院他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/145.wav", + "text": "那也的確如剛剛委員所說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/146.wav", + "text": "其實在很多調解場合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/147.wav", + "text": "反而都沒看到法官到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/148.wav", + "text": "原本看起來立意良善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/149.wav", + "text": "跟執行上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/150.wav", + "text": "跟大家的期待會有些落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/151.wav", + "text": "對此我自己非常非常願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/152.wav", + "text": "或者是有經歷過調解過程的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/153.wav", + "text": "在執行面可以改善的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/154.wav", + "text": "我們非常非常願意來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/155.wav", + "text": "現在不是執行面的改善而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/156.wav", + "text": "是司法院他們往往提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/157.wav", + "text": "立意良善的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/158.wav", + "text": "包括我們的醫療糾紛訴訟裡醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/159.wav", + "text": "醫糾的鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/160.wav", + "text": "要求自然人醫生要去具名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/161.wav", + "text": "醫生跟他們說不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/162.wav", + "text": "他們仍然一意孤行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/163.wav", + "text": "已經通過了八個多月九個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/164.wav", + "text": "沒有任何一個醫療糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/165.wav", + "text": "有醫生願意去鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/166.wav", + "text": "擺爛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/167.wav", + "text": "所以沒有辦法進行審理程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/168.wav", + "text": "這就是一個很鮮明的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/169.wav", + "text": "為了醫療鑑定的公正性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/170.wav", + "text": "負責性可信度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/171.wav", + "text": "會比較公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/172.wav", + "text": "但實際運作起來卻不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/173.wav", + "text": "其實也是立意良善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/174.wav", + "text": "其他也很不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/175.wav", + "text": "可是因為你強迫人家強制調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/176.wav", + "text": "結果這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/177.wav", + "text": "沒有配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/178.wav", + "text": "法第28條第1項還規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/179.wav", + "text": "當事人不能合意成立調解時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/180.wav", + "text": "勞動調解委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/181.wav", + "text": "應依職權斟酌一切情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/182.wav", + "text": "並求兩造利益之平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/183.wav", + "text": "於不違反兩造之主要意思範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/184.wav", + "text": "提出解決事件之適當方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/185.wav", + "text": "這個法條寫的都是騙人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/186.wav", + "text": "委員所以我剛剛說有兩個層面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/187.wav", + "text": "第一個部分就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/188.wav", + "text": "在執行面怎麼樣改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/189.wav", + "text": "我們可以跟司法院來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/190.wav", + "text": "但如果執行面真的一直沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/191.wav", + "text": "立法時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/192.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法達成當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/193.wav", + "text": "其實我想這些規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/194.wav", + "text": "該檢討的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/195.wav", + "text": "我們當然非常願意來檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/196.wav", + "text": "不是規範是法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/197.wav", + "text": "司法院不可能自己去改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/198.wav", + "text": "啦當初他們就說這是正確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/199.wav", + "text": "改革方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/200.wav", + "text": "所以現在勞動部行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/201.wav", + "text": "在這個過程裡面的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/202.wav", + "text": "我是說執行面能改善的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/203.wav", + "text": "如果執行面改善還不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/204.wav", + "text": "能達到當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/205.wav", + "text": "修法的目的的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/206.wav", + "text": "當然我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/207.wav", + "text": "我現在就是告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/208.wav", + "text": "執行面就是沒辦法進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/209.wav", + "text": "勞動事件法第23條第1項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/210.wav", + "text": "勞動調解委員會進行調解時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/211.wav", + "text": "該委員會的法官要指揮其程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/212.wav", + "text": "要怎麼指揮程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/213.wav", + "text": "法官沒有全程在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/214.wav", + "text": "勞工提起確認僱傭關係存在之訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/215.wav", + "text": "法院認勞工有勝訴之望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/216.wav", + "text": "且雇主繼續僱用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/217.wav", + "text": "非顯有重大困難者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/218.wav", + "text": "得依勞工之聲請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/219.wav", + "text": "為繼續僱用及給付工資之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/220.wav", + "text": "定暫時狀態處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/221.wav", + "text": "這條法律看起來對勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/222.wav", + "text": "就要繼續請這個勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/223.wav", + "text": "要繼續給付他工資喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/224.wav", + "text": "勞工被雇主違法解僱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/225.wav", + "text": "勞工聲請定暫時狀態處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/226.wav", + "text": "還是要先去找工作另謀他就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/227.wav", + "text": "事情就大條了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/228.wav", + "text": "因為法院在認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/229.wav", + "text": "有沒有定暫時狀態處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/230.wav", + "text": "必要的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/231.wav", + "text": "高等法院113年勞抗字第19號裁定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/232.wav", + "text": "你要訴訟但你在這當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/233.wav", + "text": "已經找到新的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/234.wav", + "text": "所以勞工已經有工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/235.wav", + "text": "支付其生活所需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/236.wav", + "text": "維持其工作技能及競爭力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/237.wav", + "text": "故駁回勞工的聲請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/238.wav", + "text": "你要定暫時處分狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/239.wav", + "text": "要繼續發薪水給勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/240.wav", + "text": "如果你有工作了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/241.wav", + "text": "人家就說你有工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/242.wav", + "text": "我不會叫雇主付錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/243.wav", + "text": "到底是要去找工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/244.wav", + "text": "然後人家就幫你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/245.wav", + "text": "定不要求雇主繼續給付工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/246.wav", + "text": "或者是你在那裡喝西北風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/247.wav", + "text": "不找工作沒有收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/248.wav", + "text": "然後去請求法院可能會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/249.wav", + "text": "叫雇主繼續給付工資給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/250.wav", + "text": "這不是讓勞工陷入困境嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/251.wav", + "text": "還要等法院裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/252.wav", + "text": "到底是要另謀他就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/253.wav", + "text": "還是坐以待斃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/254.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/255.wav", + "text": "當初設計這個條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/256.wav", + "text": "最主要目的是儘快來做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/257.wav", + "text": "所以現在的法院依照勞動事件法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/258.wav", + "text": "法官會很快的確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/259.wav", + "text": "有沒有顯無勝訴之望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/260.wav", + "text": "然後來做這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/261.wav", + "text": "你說很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/262.wav", + "text": "本來是說六個月要審結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/263.wav", + "text": "事實上有例外條款以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/264.wav", + "text": "都沒有六個月審結的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/265.wav", + "text": "受得住你三個月的儘快嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/266.wav", + "text": "受得住你一個月的儘快嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/267.wav", + "text": "每個月的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/268.wav", + "text": "都是為了支撐他那一個月的開銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/269.wav", + "text": "你如果有房貸可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/270.wav", + "text": "一個月沒薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/271.wav", + "text": "然後去借錢來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/272.wav", + "text": "繳房租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/273.wav", + "text": "繳孩子的生活費用等等嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/274.wav", + "text": "高等法院的這個裁定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/275.wav", + "text": "會不會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/276.wav", + "text": "跟司法院討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/277.wav", + "text": "然後剛剛委員在講的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/278.wav", + "text": "當然可能就這部分還有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/279.wav", + "text": "像假處分這樣的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/280.wav", + "text": "然也會需要一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/281.wav", + "text": "可能不一定會這麼定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/282.wav", + "text": "定暫時狀態的處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/283.wav", + "text": "如果找到工作有薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/284.wav", + "text": "是非常不利於勞工的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/285.wav", + "text": "原本的設計都是基於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/286.wav", + "text": "之間可能的權利不平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/287.wav", + "text": "我們想要把勞工的權利往上撐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/288.wav", + "text": "對啊可是你們執行起來的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/289.wav", + "text": "所以我們要把這個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/290.wav", + "text": "感受到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/291.wav", + "text": "來跟他們討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/292.wav", + "text": "我們是不是有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/293.wav", + "text": "說得很好聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/294.wav", + "text": "可是口惠實不至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/295.wav", + "text": "啊六個月審結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/296.wav", + "text": "大家都有例外條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/297.wav", + "text": "如果你要讓他有例外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/298.wav", + "text": "就不要規定六個月審結這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/299.wav", + "text": "整個都是騙人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/300.wav", + "text": "你如果沒辦法六個月審結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/301.wav", + "text": "規定這個條文是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/302.wav", + "text": "所以我說這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/303.wav", + "text": "來跟司法院反映和討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/304.wav", + "text": "對我剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/305.wav", + "text": "司法院很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/306.wav", + "text": "高等法院那個判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/307.wav", + "text": "會不會變成是法院一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/308.wav", + "text": "是我理解你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/309.wav", + "text": "可是他們就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/310.wav", + "text": "但是勞動部不能夠眼睜睜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/311.wav", + "text": "看著原本一個立意良善的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/312.wav", + "text": "執行起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/313.wav", + "text": "反而變成對勞工落井下石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/314.wav", + "text": "調解就無效沒路用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/315.wav", + "text": "嘛五年來沒有一件調解成功的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/316.wav", + "text": "本來是馬上可以審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/317.wav", + "text": "這個也都很荒謬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/318.wav", + "text": "啦然後到底要找工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/319.wav", + "text": "還是不找工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/320.wav", + "text": "也是很荒謬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/321.wav", + "text": "都陷勞工於更不利的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/322.wav", + "text": "法律立意良善但執行起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/323.wav", + "text": "勞工頗受其苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/324.wav", + "text": "這時候勞動部不能夠眼睜睜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/325.wav", + "text": "所以我說我們會主動的把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/326.wav", + "text": "勞工現在所遇到的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/327.wav", + "text": "什麼時候會主動找司法院討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/328.wav", + "text": "我們這個月就來找他們討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/329.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/330.wav", + "text": "這很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/331.wav", + "text": "根據我們的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/332.wav", + "text": "司法院死也不認錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/333.wav", + "text": "死也不改過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/334.wav", + "text": "因為我們醫療糾紛鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/335.wav", + "text": "九個月來好幾百件的審理案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/336.wav", + "text": "他們就是擺爛在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/337.wav", + "text": "沒有想要找解決的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/338.wav", + "text": "所以我語重心長地告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/339.wav", + "text": "事情會很大條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/340.wav", + "text": "我知道這是跨院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/341.wav", + "text": "可是真的是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/342.wav", + "text": "我們會主動來反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/343.wav", + "text": "好沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/344.wav", + "text": "親自協調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/345.wav", + "text": "沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/346.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/347.wav", + "text": "謝謝林淑芬委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158041/348.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/1.wav", + "text": "請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/2.wav", + "text": "部長好委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/3.wav", + "text": "部長最近有一則新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/4.wav", + "text": "我先跟你說聲恭喜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/5.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/6.wav", + "text": "有感第一那全民都需要你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/7.wav", + "text": "請問一下您會交通部長做好做滿嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/8.wav", + "text": "做好做滿是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/9.wav", + "text": "交通部長沒有任期政務官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/10.wav", + "text": "沒有任期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/11.wav", + "text": "你能不能期許自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/12.wav", + "text": "還是你會有個人的生涯規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/13.wav", + "text": "做到一半就會離開呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/14.wav", + "text": "我儘量努力做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/15.wav", + "text": "儘量努力做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/16.wav", + "text": "可以跟大家承諾你一定全力以赴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/17.wav", + "text": "做完這一任期嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/18.wav", + "text": "做完這一任期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/19.wav", + "text": "政務官的任期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/20.wav", + "text": "不是由政務官自己決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/21.wav", + "text": "百日挑戰好感第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/22.wav", + "text": "就是因為我們找不到人來接任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/23.wav", + "text": "找到了你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/24.wav", + "text": "那你也百日挑戰好感第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/25.wav", + "text": "那我相信你一定有被重用的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/26.wav", + "text": "我們也希望你在交通部能夠繼續發揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/27.wav", + "text": "你也不要離開交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/28.wav", + "text": "我努力做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/29.wav", + "text": "那另外我想跟你請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/30.wav", + "text": "因為你擔任過議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/31.wav", + "text": "臺中市的一些民意基礎心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/32.wav", + "text": "我希望你能夠帶到交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/33.wav", + "text": "我想請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/34.wav", + "text": "對於機車待轉這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/35.wav", + "text": "您的態度是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/36.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/37.wav", + "text": "機車待轉有相當多民眾在反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/38.wav", + "text": "有些民眾覺得不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/39.wav", + "text": "有些民眾覺得感覺比較安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/40.wav", + "text": "對那你個人呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/41.wav", + "text": "其實比較牽涉到的是路權的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/42.wav", + "text": "你個人覺得你是支持機車要待轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/43.wav", + "text": "還是取消機車待轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/44.wav", + "text": "還是彈性機車待轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/45.wav", + "text": "所謂的彈性就是不強制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/46.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/47.wav", + "text": "首要是交通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/48.wav", + "text": "當然我們都知道交通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/49.wav", + "text": "\n好部長那我問你一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/50.wav", + "text": "機車兩段式左轉推動多久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/51.wav", + "text": "這個政策你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/52.wav", + "text": "我是不是請司長來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/53.wav", + "text": "這個政策他比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/54.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/55.wav", + "text": "我印象中應該是民國八十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/56.wav", + "text": "從臺北市開始推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/57.wav", + "text": "1985年臺北市楊市長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/58.wav", + "text": "開始推動共計19處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/59.wav", + "text": "機慢車的專用道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/60.wav", + "text": "也提出機車交通管理的政策白皮書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/61.wav", + "text": "彰化縣政府最近取消了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/62.wav", + "text": "對沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/63.wav", + "text": "本席想問第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/64.wav", + "text": "你知道目前有哪幾個縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/65.wav", + "text": "有取消或者是至少試行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/66.wav", + "text": "取消兩段式左��嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/67.wav", + "text": "彰化是最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/68.wav", + "text": "針對兩車道的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/69.wav", + "text": "將兩段式左轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/70.wav", + "text": "那其他縣市我所知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/71.wav", + "text": "應該滿多縣市有做過試辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/72.wav", + "text": "包含臺中市也應該有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/73.wav", + "text": "來我提一個具體的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/74.wav", + "text": "臺北市78處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/75.wav", + "text": "新北63處取消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/76.wav", + "text": "高雄臺中針對特定區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/77.wav", + "text": "區域放寬兩段式左轉的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/78.wav", + "text": "臺南市8月全面取消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/79.wav", + "text": "市區的單向兩車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/80.wav", + "text": "機車兩段式左轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/81.wav", + "text": "桃園去年底試辦24處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/82.wav", + "text": "六都其實已經有部分一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/83.wav", + "text": "六都之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/84.wav", + "text": "新竹市針對63處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/85.wav", + "text": "取消兩段式的左轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/86.wav", + "text": "新竹縣是9個路口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/87.wav", + "text": "苗栗縣一年內也有3個路口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/88.wav", + "text": "取消兩段式的左轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/89.wav", + "text": "請教部長第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/90.wav", + "text": "你是否有盤點本席上述的這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/91.wav", + "text": "改變兩段式左轉的政策以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/92.wav", + "text": "交通事故是上升還是下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/93.wav", + "text": "我這陣子其實有請我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/94.wav", + "text": "部內同仁來蒐集這方面的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/95.wav", + "text": "因為這個要科學的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/96.wav", + "text": "再做後面的討論才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/97.wav", + "text": "對但是他們都已經執行一段時間了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/98.wav", + "text": "先不講彰化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/99.wav", + "text": "化之前的試辦目前狀況如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/100.wav", + "text": "我有請同仁們在蒐集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/101.wav", + "text": "司長可以回應嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/102.wav", + "text": "他們都已經試辦一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/103.wav", + "text": "我記得我擔任議員的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/104.wav", + "text": "臺中市就已經有試辦幾處了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/105.wav", + "text": "所以這些數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/106.wav", + "text": "司長你到底有沒有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/107.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/108.wav", + "text": "目前是在跟地方政府瞭解當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/109.wav", + "text": "也藉這個機會跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/110.wav", + "text": "因為每一個路段或是每一個路口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/111.wav", + "text": "車道相關配置給機車行駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/112.wav", + "text": "要不要搭配兩段式左轉的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/113.wav", + "text": "牽涉到這個路段交通車流的變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/114.wav", + "text": "如果這些試辦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/115.wav", + "text": "都有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/116.wav", + "text": "越來越高的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/117.wav", + "text": "不會有其他的縣市又跟進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/118.wav", + "text": "所以我們可以發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/119.wav", + "text": "廢除兩段式左轉是一個趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/120.wav", + "text": "有網友做了一張圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/121.wav", + "text": "很清楚地說明了一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/122.wav", + "text": "重點是不在內車道左轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/123.wav", + "text": "而不是沒有兩段式左轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/124.wav", + "text": "就連列在你們執政黨不分區立委名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/125.wav", + "text": "的石明謹他曾經是交通警察他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/126.wav", + "text": "也說沒有交錯就沒有車禍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/127.wav", + "text": "這是交通安全不變的定律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/128.wav", + "text": "越多路線的交叉重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/129.wav", + "text": "就會產生越多的車禍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/130.wav", + "text": "轉一個彎要分兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/131.wav", + "text": "就會容易與其他車輛的路線重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/132.wav", + "text": "左轉就靠左" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/133.wav", + "text": "右轉就靠右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/134.wav", + "text": "是正常的一個邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/135.wav", + "text": "所以常常有機車族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/136.wav", + "text": "與其他的汽車族群產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/137.wav", + "text": "這樣子的一個緊張關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/138.wav", + "text": "很多人覺得內車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/139.wav", + "text": "應該是汽車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/140.wav", + "text": "外車道才是機車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/141.wav", + "text": "所以發生衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/142.wav", + "text": "我們要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/143.wav", + "text": "當然就像部長你說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/144.wav", + "text": "有很多人有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/145.wav", + "text": "可是就彰化來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/146.wav", + "text": "他們叫做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/147.wav", + "text": "彈性對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/148.wav", + "text": "那這個彈性有多彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/149.wav", + "text": "這個彈性能不能擴大辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/150.wav", + "text": "這個彈性能不能由交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/151.wav", + "text": "這個部分我希望部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/152.wav", + "text": "您有一個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/153.wav", + "text": "今天可以讓我知道一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/154.wav", + "text": "都有自己可以開放的裁量權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/155.wav", + "text": "這個部分都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/156.wav", + "text": "都可以自己做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/157.wav", + "text": "包含現在您所看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/158.wav", + "text": "您所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/159.wav", + "text": "當然我知道地方政府可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/160.wav", + "text": "但是您是交通部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/161.wav", + "text": "我現在就是要跟您討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/162.wav", + "text": "嘛我希望交通部要來做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/163.wav", + "text": "實際的探討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/164.wav", + "text": "公布一個數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/165.wav", + "text": "或者是一個指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/166.wav", + "text": "或者是您的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/167.wav", + "text": "能夠讓各縣市知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/168.wav", + "text": "嘛您支不支持他們傾向於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/169.wav", + "text": "跟彰化學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/170.wav", + "text": "可不可以跟我回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/171.wav", + "text": "我想我們會給他們足夠的裁量權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/172.wav", + "text": "讓各個地方自己去決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/173.wav", + "text": "我們也會收攏大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/174.wav", + "text": "包含學者專家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/175.wav", + "text": "包含地方政府的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/176.wav", + "text": "我們最近積極來做這方面的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/177.wav", + "text": "如果我們在指引方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/178.wav", + "text": "有需要去做修正的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/179.wav", + "text": "我們後續再來做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/180.wav", + "text": "部長你認為機車走內車道左轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/181.wav", + "text": "到底是不是安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/182.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/183.wav", + "text": "像臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/184.wav", + "text": "你也在臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/185.wav", + "text": "我在臺中時常騎摩托" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/186.wav", + "text": "在騎的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/187.wav", + "text": "我發現內車道很多是禁行機車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/188.wav", + "text": "我根本沒有辦法直接轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/189.wav", + "text": "對所以這個部分要先解決禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/190.wav", + "text": "禁行機車也要檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/191.wav", + "text": "所謂的取消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/192.wav", + "text": "兩段式左轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/193.wav", + "text": "我們是一併納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/194.wav", + "text": "一起來做一個探討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/195.wav", + "text": "所以我問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/196.wav", + "text": "你個人的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/197.wav", + "text": "你還是不願意說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/198.wav", + "text": "這個部分其實現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/199.wav", + "text": "地方就可以自己去決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/200.wav", + "text": "不一定要中央有決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/201.wav", + "text": "他們才能決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/202.wav", + "text": "您剛剛也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/203.wav", + "text": "很多縣市都已經在做試辦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/204.wav", + "text": "如果他們試辦的成效好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/205.wav", + "text": "他們可以全市來開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/206.wav", + "text": "這個是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/207.wav", + "text": "了時間有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/208.wav", + "text": "部長司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/209.wav", + "text": "機車取消兩段式左轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/210.wav", + "text": "多久可以完成評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/211.wav", + "text": "剛剛所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/212.wav", + "text": "公布並且由你們內部拿來評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/213.wav", + "text": "是不是有一個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/214.wav", + "text": "一個指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/215.wav", + "text": "然後一個公文下去給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/216.wav", + "text": "六都及各縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/217.wav", + "text": "這個部分多久可以完成報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/218.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/219.wav", + "text": "基本上在交通法規裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/220.wav", + "text": "它不是一個通案強制性的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/221.wav", + "text": "機車最起碼是外面兩個車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/222.wav", + "text": "那剛剛委員有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/223.wav", + "text": "包括臺南市或彰化縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/224.wav", + "text": "可以行駛兩車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/225.wav", + "text": "但是不是所有都是三車道以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/226.wav", + "text": "你就直接回應我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/227.wav", + "text": "召委站起來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/228.wav", + "text": "你數據多久能夠彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/229.wav", + "text": "有一個評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/230.wav", + "text": "委員部裡面下禮拜會找路權團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/231.wav", + "text": "及專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/232.wav", + "text": "大家共同來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/233.wav", + "text": "現行交通法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/234.wav", + "text": "中有關於機車行駛的路權的部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/235.wav", + "text": "分其他現行已經開放的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/236.wav", + "text": "我們請各地方政府提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/237.wav", + "text": "的相關數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/238.wav", + "text": "一個月內提供資料給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/239.wav", + "text": "那你多久可以完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/240.wav", + "text": "你自己的內部評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/241.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告評估的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/242.wav", + "text": "兩個月好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/243.wav", + "text": "我們在兩個月內跟相關團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/244.wav", + "text": "看看討論大家可以聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/245.wav", + "text": "可以進一步檢討的方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/246.wav", + "text": "兩個月啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/247.wav", + "text": "我會再追喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/248.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158040/249.wav", + "text": "好謝謝羅廷瑋委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/0.wav", + "text": "請臺鐵杜董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/1.wav", + "text": "我們預計12月20日會結標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/2.wav", + "text": "在這段期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/3.wav", + "text": "我們有很積極地去拜訪潛在的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/4.wav", + "text": "包括我本人在內也都有去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/5.wav", + "text": "讓廠商了解空中鳳城它的發展性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/6.wav", + "text": "所以它設計的一些困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/7.wav", + "text": "跟有可能來OT的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/8.wav", + "text": "所使用的不見得完全match對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/9.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/10.wav", + "text": "內部調整的部分是誰來調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/11.wav", + "text": "內部調整的部分最後還是要由得標廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/12.wav", + "text": "在我們的招標規範跟我們的規定裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/13.wav", + "text": "電影院目前是在幾樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/14.wav", + "text": "本來是在高樓層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/15.wav", + "text": "現在允許它變更可以拿到這個低樓層來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/16.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/17.wav", + "text": "我本來想說我沒有管那麼細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/18.wav", + "text": "只要標得出去就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/19.wav", + "text": "但是現在標不出去的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/20.wav", + "text": "我就要管更細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/21.wav", + "text": "了所以電影院那個20人座根本就不符使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/22.wav", + "text": "還有7樓和8樓的百貨商場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/23.wav", + "text": "樓層規劃承重有問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/24.wav", + "text": "因為它是用辦公場域的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/25.wav", + "text": "所以要怎麼調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/26.wav", + "text": "承重不足的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/27.wav", + "text": "允許它用別的方式招租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/28.wav", + "text": "那百貨商場的部分就是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/29.wav", + "text": "是擺在比較低樓層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/30.wav", + "text": "比較低樓層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/31.wav", + "text": "對允許它做一些改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/32.wav", + "text": "那當然還有手扶梯等問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/33.wav", + "text": "細節我就不講那麼細了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/34.wav", + "text": "原則上就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/35.wav", + "text": "也要讓部長跟董事長知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/36.wav", + "text": "這是我鳳山重要的事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/37.wav", + "text": "這個沒有完成交代不過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/38.wav", + "text": "所以我是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/39.wav", + "text": "董事長跟部長也特別重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/40.wav", + "text": "總是要找到適合的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/41.wav", + "text": "符合鳳山的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/42.wav", + "text": "真的有人開始動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/43.wav", + "text": "目前我看你們的契約年限是30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/44.wav", + "text": "採購法我比較沒有那麼懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/45.wav", + "text": "這沒問題嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/46.wav", + "text": "是這個沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/47.wav", + "text": "那不管權利金是固定的或變動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/48.wav", + "text": "反正你們自己依照採購法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/49.wav", + "text": "好這個就交給你們的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/50.wav", + "text": "我的目標就是要順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/51.wav", + "text": "董事長把這個當作非常重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/52.wav", + "text": "會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/53.wav", + "text": "你們預計的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/54.wav", + "text": "9月的時候董事長是說這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/55.wav", + "text": "應該沒有問題吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/56.wav", + "text": "要努力啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/57.wav", + "text": "要努力我們去洽商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/58.wav", + "text": "在南部對於開發有興趣的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/59.wav", + "text": "現在也不只是只有在空中鳳城而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/60.wav", + "text": "他們焦點也有擺在高雄周邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/61.wav", + "text": "對當然因為高雄現在有很多商場會出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/62.wav", + "text": "那當然商人很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/63.wav", + "text": "對不對就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/64.wav", + "text": "租金就不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/65.wav", + "text": "但是也有租得出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/66.wav", + "text": "所以這個東西其實就是兩方面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/67.wav", + "text": "權利義務關係的商榷是是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/68.wav", + "text": "這個我了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/69.wav", + "text": "所以拜託董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/70.wav", + "text": "因為這個是對我們鳳山非常重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/71.wav", + "text": "我們鳳山人跟我都非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/72.wav", + "text": "我們希望不要再這樣拖下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/73.wav", + "text": "所以希望董事長多用一點心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/74.wav", + "text": "台積電站應該沒問題吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/75.wav", + "text": "你不知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/76.wav", + "text": "這是鐵道局在設計的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/77.wav", + "text": "鐵道局也沒有那麼清楚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/78.wav", + "text": "注意一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/79.wav", + "text": "也拜託部長瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/80.wav", + "text": "慕達在2022年6月15" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/81.wav", + "text": "日劉世芳部長還當立委的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/82.wav", + "text": "跟我跟李柏毅都有去考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/83.wav", + "text": "鐵路立體化的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/84.wav", + "text": "局長跟董事長應該都清楚吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/85.wav", + "text": "目前只有一條路線就是捷運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/86.wav", + "text": "所以這條捷運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/87.wav", + "text": "在吞吐上一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/88.wav", + "text": "所以我們要分流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/89.wav", + "text": "台積電楠梓廠前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/90.wav", + "text": "台積電站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/91.wav", + "text": "這個應該是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/92.wav", + "text": "有助於分流的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/93.wav", + "text": "從鳳山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/94.wav", + "text": "要去台積電上班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/95.wav", + "text": "多設一個站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/96.wav", + "text": "所以這個需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/97.wav", + "text": "應該是非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/98.wav", + "text": "對於這一點局長跟董事長的看法如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/99.wav", + "text": "這個應該是由市政府先辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/100.wav", + "text": "地下立體化的可行性研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/101.wav", + "text": "如果它在這個案子裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/102.wav", + "text": "提出來這樣的規劃的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/103.wav", + "text": "我想我們會來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/104.wav", + "text": "所以目前市府都沒有把這個訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/105.wav", + "text": "跟你們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/106.wav", + "text": "那我最後請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/107.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/108.wav", + "text": "部長就這兩件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/109.wav", + "text": "第一個是拜託幫我關注一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/110.wav", + "text": "讓鳳山車站這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/111.wav", + "text": "第二楠梓百慕達這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/112.wav", + "text": "包括臺鐵在台積電這邊設個站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/113.wav", + "text": "這件事情部長知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/114.wav", + "text": "有提到過我大概知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/115.wav", + "text": "是他們提出來我們來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/116.wav", + "text": "那當然就是說也希望部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/117.wav", + "text": "幫忙蓋這個應該是鐵道局的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/118.wav", + "text": "對到時候應該是鐵道局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/119.wav", + "text": "蓋好再交給臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/120.wav", + "text": "所以鐵道局會是第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/121.wav", + "text": "所以拜託部長跟局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/122.wav", + "text": "至少臺鐵董事長要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/123.wav", + "text": "以後這裡設個站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/124.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/125.wav", + "text": "好那我們往這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/126.wav", + "text": "前進市府那邊我會再去拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/127.wav", + "text": "我們一起來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/128.wav", + "text": "也希望交通部可以重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/129.wav", + "text": "好最後再給我一段簡短的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/130.wav", + "text": "現在國民黨把中央預算刪減6,000億以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/131.wav", + "text": "我們鐵道跟捷運本來是七比三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/132.wav", + "text": "三那刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/133.wav", + "text": "這個可能要由主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/134.wav", + "text": "做整體考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/135.wav", + "text": "跟行政院做整體考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/136.wav", + "text": "不過中央對於地方的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/137.wav", + "text": "必然會減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/138.wav", + "text": "我這邊再鄭重呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/139.wav", + "text": "一下我們高雄現在軌道很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/140.wav", + "text": "將來路竹延伸線我們希望可以延伸到臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/141.wav", + "text": "這個也讓部長跟局長都瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/142.wav", + "text": "我們也希望林園線有機會延伸到屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/143.wav", + "text": "包括我們的捷運黃線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/144.wav", + "text": "包括未來有機會開發的捷運紫線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/145.wav", + "text": "包括臺鐵在台積電設個站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/146.wav", + "text": "這些都是交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/147.wav", + "text": "這些部分分擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/148.wav", + "text": "坦白講我們要呼籲一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/149.wav", + "text": "國民黨跟民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/150.wav", + "text": "到時候中央要補我們七成一定是不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/151.wav", + "text": "不夠就沒錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/152.wav", + "text": "沒錢又要讓我們做這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/153.wav", + "text": "重大的建設有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/154.wav", + "text": "所以我們高雄人很沉痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/155.wav", + "text": "因為很多高雄人民跟我反映說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/156.wav", + "text": "必須要公開地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/157.wav", + "text": "再呼籲一下國民黨跟民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/158.wav", + "text": "你們如果這樣搞搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/159.wav", + "text": "到我們的交通建設都沒辦法做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/160.wav", + "text": "不只是交通建設包括長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/161.wav", + "text": "包括幼托" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/162.wav", + "text": "包括所有國家整體的福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/163.wav", + "text": "你看產生多大的變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/164.wav", + "text": "所以也希望呼籲一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/165.wav", + "text": "表達我們高雄人民的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/166.wav", + "text": "也請藍白兩黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/167.wav", + "text": "三思而後行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/168.wav", + "text": "不要隨便想要動就動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/169.wav", + "text": "會貽害到整個國家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/170.wav", + "text": "整體建設跟發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/171.wav", + "text": "我也在這邊再一次地呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/172.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158039/173.wav", + "text": "謝謝局長董事長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/1.wav", + "text": "請陳部長航港局葉局長港務公司李董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/2.wav", + "text": "三位早委員早我相信早上有一些委員應該也都關注到這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/3.wav", + "text": "媒體揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/4.wav", + "text": "彭博駐台記者何貴森在社群平台上面爆料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/5.wav", + "text": "提到香港這一艘貨船長和輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/6.wav", + "text": "的這件事情部長早上應該也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/7.wav", + "text": "我看媒體上也有揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/8.wav", + "text": "這個昨天就有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/9.wav", + "text": "我想請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/10.wav", + "text": "國安單位有沒有跟你們聯絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/11.wav", + "text": "這一艘船必須被特別地處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/12.wav", + "text": "報告委員當時沒有特別通知這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/13.wav", + "text": "航港局跟港務公司都沒有得到任何訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/14.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們沒有得到任何訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/15.wav", + "text": "所以這艘船當時是用商船的方式來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/16.wav", + "text": "就一般處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/17.wav", + "text": "回到我們正常的SOP去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/18.wav", + "text": "對於正常SOP的抽檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/19.wav", + "text": "我們的百分比大概占多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/20.wav", + "text": "報告委員這就是我們商港法所謂的港口國管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/21.wav", + "text": "全球的港口都有這樣的管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/22.wav", + "text": "制我國的百分比是15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/23.wav", + "text": "對抽檢到的這15%我們會做什麼樣的檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/24.wav", + "text": "我們會依照這個國際公約來檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/25.wav", + "text": "不管是它的適航性安全設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/26.wav", + "text": "是不是都能夠正常地運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/27.wav", + "text": "所以我們實際檢查人員會進到船艙裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/28.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/29.wav", + "text": "如果按照正常SOP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/30.wav", + "text": "這一艘船並沒有我們檢查的實質內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/31.wav", + "text": "港口國檢查所謂的高風險的一個標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/32.wav", + "text": "還有原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/33.wav", + "text": "這艘船就不在我們抽檢的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/34.wav", + "text": "所以我們並沒有對它做港口國管制的檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/35.wav", + "text": "就是進到正常程序的檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/36.wav", + "text": "因為不在那15%的比例抽驗裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/37.wav", + "text": "所以我們也不知道怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/38.wav", + "text": "對於它在這一次的裝卸貨裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/39.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有重新再去看一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/40.wav", + "text": "有沒有任何的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/41.wav", + "text": "事後有沒有再看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/42.wav", + "text": "就是這件事情我們掌握了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/43.wav", + "text": "這個其實也不能怪你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/44.wav", + "text": "因為它的爭議點在於它曾經參加對岸的演習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/45.wav", + "text": "它的功能是把那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/46.wav", + "text": "放在它的船艙裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/47.wav", + "text": "可以吊起來現場作戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/48.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/49.wav", + "text": "因為媒體揭露這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/50.wav", + "text": "我們有監視設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/51.wav", + "text": "這個監視設備是不是一切正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/52.wav", + "text": "它主要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/53.wav", + "text": "就是一般的裝卸起重機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/54.wav", + "text": "我們去檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/55.wav", + "text": "它沒有什麼異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/56.wav", + "text": "就是一般的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/57.wav", + "text": "看過這個影像了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/58.wav", + "text": "都看過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/59.wav", + "text": "我想這個是國人關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/60.wav", + "text": "甚至在軍事演習上面不斷地在挑釁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/61.wav", + "text": "所以我們對於安全意識的建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/62.wav", + "text": "其實是重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/63.wav", + "text": "我們當然不會隨便看到黑影就開槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/64.wav", + "text": "也不需要大家做到杯弓蛇影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/65.wav", + "text": "但我要強調的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/66.wav", + "text": "透過這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/67.wav", + "text": "對這艘船的狀況去掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/68.wav", + "text": "啦這個要請國安單位來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/69.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/70.wav", + "text": "空港跟海港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/71.wav", + "text": "建立起同仁的安全意識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/72.wav", + "text": "從這個事件裡面去凸顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/73.wav", + "text": "跟國安單位來協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/74.wav", + "text": "就類似這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/75.wav", + "text": "所謂參與軍演背景的船舶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/76.wav", + "text": "要來申請靠港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/77.wav", + "text": "應該有一個特殊的審查機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/78.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有去研議這樣的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/79.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們一週之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/80.wav", + "text": "會找國安單位一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/81.wav", + "text": "開會來協商這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/82.wav", + "text": "我們會主動詢問國安單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/83.wav", + "text": "有沒有這方面相關的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/84.wav", + "text": "或是未來有什麼資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/85.wav", + "text": "我們一週之內會找他們開會來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/86.wav", + "text": "都要不要made in China" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/87.wav", + "text": "這個幾乎是全球的一個趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/88.wav", + "text": "特別是臺灣在第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/89.wav", + "text": "讓同仁大家都有這個想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/90.wav", + "text": "就讓它正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/91.wav", + "text": "但是特殊的情況也必須要掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/92.wav", + "text": "我再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/93.wav", + "text": "這艘船離是幾號離開臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/94.wav", + "text": "12月7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/95.wav", + "text": "它是七號離港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/96.wav", + "text": "但是離港之後因為海象不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/97.wav", + "text": "所以它在停錨區再停錨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/98.wav", + "text": "兩天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/99.wav", + "text": "所以此刻應該還在停錨區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/100.wav", + "text": "已經離開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/101.wav", + "text": "今天海象已經轉好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/102.wav", + "text": "所以它離開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/103.wav", + "text": "是今天早上離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/104.wav", + "text": "因為我看它申請7號出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/105.wav", + "text": "可是今天早上的位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/106.wav", + "text": "還離我們很近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/107.wav", + "text": "表示它在停錨區停錨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/108.wav", + "text": "今天早上才開始移動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/109.wav", + "text": "它的下一個位置在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/110.wav", + "text": "它要跟我們申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/111.wav", + "text": "它下一個要去哪裡嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/112.wav", + "text": "出港會寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/113.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/114.wav", + "text": "它不需要告訴我們它想去哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/115.wav", + "text": "還是它必須要告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/116.wav", + "text": "啦只是我今天早上發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/117.wav", + "text": "它好像還在我們附近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/118.wav", + "text": "7號就申請離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/119.wav", + "text": "為什麼今天早上還在我們的旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/120.wav", + "text": "因為海象的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/121.wav", + "text": "對海象的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/122.wav", + "text": "所以在停錨區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/123.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個就應該要特別注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/124.wav", + "text": "就如同我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/125.wav", + "text": "這個安全意識跟觀念的建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158038/126.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/0.wav", + "text": "請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/1.wav", + "text": "我們從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/2.wav", + "text": "遞補就任到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/3.wav", + "text": "一直在關心運動員的相關權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/4.wav", + "text": "那也許是部長比較不熟悉的我們花一些時間跟部長討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/5.wav", + "text": "我在2023年10月就問了當時的陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/6.wav", + "text": "說國營事業的運動團隊如果不幫球員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/7.wav", + "text": "投保勞保會不會產生法規範的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/8.wav", + "text": "當時的陳建仁院長認為這個不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/9.wav", + "text": "他認為要進一步了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/10.wav", + "text": "後來我們問了許銘春部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/11.wav", + "text": "他認為國營事業應該善盡雇主的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/12.wav", + "text": "到了經濟部郭智輝部長因為在他自己的企業底下其實也有企業球隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/13.wav", + "text": "我們問他有沒有幫他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/14.wav", + "text": "球隊的運動員加保當然是有的而且他認為這是天經地義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/15.wav", + "text": "他承諾會進一步進行勞動檢查現在部長您新上任過去在運動員這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/16.wav", + "text": "我想問一下部長你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/17.wav", + "text": "國營事業運動團隊幫自己的球員加保勞保這件事情是不是天經地義的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/18.wav", + "text": "因為過去在我們積極質詢之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/19.wav", + "text": "過往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/20.wav", + "text": "台啤跟台電的態度是非常的消極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/21.wav", + "text": "他們說這是委任關係所以不需要幫他們投保勞保甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/22.wav", + "text": "請他們自己去外面加保我們認為這非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/23.wav", + "text": "有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/24.wav", + "text": "到目前為止我跟部長報告台電到今年已經全數幫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/25.wav", + "text": "非正職球員換約加保勞保也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/26.wav", + "text": "在勞動部的協助之下我猜勞動部應該有積極協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/27.wav", + "text": "台電已經做了合乎法律規範的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/28.wav", + "text": "可是台啤到目前為止依然說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/29.wav", + "text": "這是委任關係我們認為這是規避雇主責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/30.wav", + "text": "部長我想請問一下你在這件事情上的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/31.wav", + "text": "其實就從屬關係來說我們當然不希望出現所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/32.wav", + "text": "假委任真僱傭的狀況再來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/33.wav", + "text": "其實有更積極去照顧旗下付出勞動工作者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/34.wav", + "text": "的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/35.wav", + "text": "勞動部現在當然有這個勞動契約從屬性判斷檢核表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/36.wav", + "text": "可以供大家來做相關的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/37.wav", + "text": "目前我們針對體育團體的部分其實也已經有勞動檢查9月到11月有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/38.wav", + "text": "蠻多次我從數據看到的是大概25家的勞動檢查目前正在執行之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/39.wav", + "text": "所以關於台啤要不要幫球員投保勞保的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/40.wav", + "text": "其實我想我們的態度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/41.wav", + "text": "當然希望國營事業要承擔起更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/42.wav", + "text": "多社會期待的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/43.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長非常正向的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/44.wav", + "text": "我想後續的部分而且我非常開心聽到部長您說在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/45.wav", + "text": "過去這段時間其實有非常多勞動檢查我認為這件事情對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/46.wav", + "text": "球員來說非常重要因為一旦我們要成立運動部我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/47.wav", + "text": "整個臺灣不管是行政機關或是民間企業對運動或是運動員相關權益的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/48.wav", + "text": "也想要跟部長提出相關的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/49.wav", + "text": "對於價值外交這件事情我們認為勞動部可以做以下的事情我時間有限我們就直接來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/50.wav", + "text": "強化國際及兩岸勞動交流的部分勞動部現行的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/51.wav", + "text": "是如果是產業特殊的企業工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/52.wav", + "text": "或是職業工會其實是沒有國際交流的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/53.wav", + "text": "我們覺得這比較可惜當然我們相信當時的法規範一定有其時空背景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/54.wav", + "text": "如果我們現在要修法可能有新的想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/55.wav", + "text": "必須要去承擔這個可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/56.wav", + "text": "可是我們看到地方政府以臺北市政府勞動局補助工會辦理國際交流活動的部分來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/57.wav", + "text": "它又只限於工會的聯合組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/58.wav", + "text": "所以看起來在國際交流這件事情上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/59.wav", + "text": "我們必須要說企業工會職業工會的國際交流可能被中央跟地方政府同時遺忘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/60.wav", + "text": "\n我想要跟部長舉一些例子到底什麼叫做企業工會跟職業工會部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/61.wav", + "text": "像動漫企劃人員職業工會女子足球員職業工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/62.wav", + "text": "臺大醫學院附設醫院企業工會桃園市空服員職業工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/63.wav", + "text": "我相信部長一定都非常熟悉他們各自是企業工會也是非常特殊屬性的職業工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/64.wav", + "text": "而這些工會他們都有非常多的機會跟國際做交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/65.wav", + "text": "可是卻不在相關法規範的補助辦法我們有沒有可能現在開啟一個新的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/66.wav", + "text": "來協助這些所謂企業工會職業工會做所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/67.wav", + "text": "專業性的交流然後呈現一種價值外交可能的全新樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/68.wav", + "text": "因為確實我們在很多外交場合被打壓這件事情是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/69.wav", + "text": "但是如果可以透過他們的特殊性我認為我們可以進一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/70.wav", + "text": "產生更多的國際影響力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/71.wav", + "text": "跟陳委員報告因為我自己也待過外交及國防委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/72.wav", + "text": "所以我很清楚知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/73.wav", + "text": "在政府部會以外的其他二軌外交的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/74.wav", + "text": "所以就像剛剛委員的提醒我會請我們關係司把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/75.wav", + "text": "補助工會強化國際交流的這個範疇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/76.wav", + "text": "研究一下能不能更大程度來放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/77.wav", + "text": "大家現在比較關注的一些新興產業的產職業工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/78.wav", + "text": "外界相當關注是很受關注的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/79.wav", + "text": "如果可以放入而且能夠讓大家有實質的國際交流的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/80.wav", + "text": "我覺得這確實是一個好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/81.wav", + "text": "當然我們是勞動部我們不是外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/82.wav", + "text": "可是能夠做的部分能夠對外交提供貢獻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/83.wav", + "text": "或者是能夠讓這些工會未來的進展可以更順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/84.wav", + "text": "或者是得到更多支持的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/85.wav", + "text": "我請關係司來研究這件事情看能不能把它更擴大的放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/86.wav", + "text": "好我們辦公室也非常樂意跟你們討論我們看到的樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/87.wav", + "text": "\n最後一個問題其實每次勞動部長來我都會問這一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/88.wav", + "text": "因為對於新時代的爸媽來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/89.wav", + "text": "其實大家最在意的是家庭跟工作的平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/90.wav", + "text": "部長你可以看到右邊的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/91.wav", + "text": "有一個雜誌去問一般的爸爸媽媽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/92.wav", + "text": "你認為何種職場措施最能夠讓父母安心生跟養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/93.wav", + "text": "也就是在所有育兒津貼相關的費用補助以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/94.wav", + "text": "其實所有年輕爸媽最在意的就是彈性工時這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/95.wav", + "text": "我們也跟新部長討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/96.wav", + "text": "確實彈性工時需要企業整體的轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/97.wav", + "text": "甚至企業需要重新去設計一個所謂的生產流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/98.wav", + "text": "我們來看下一頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/99.wav", + "text": "是民間雜誌辦的調查跟相關的獎項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/100.wav", + "text": "可是他們後續造成的效應我想要跟部長分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/101.wav", + "text": "部長你知道嗎被他們點選出來的獲獎企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/102.wav", + "text": "他們的新生兒總數竟然達到臺北市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/103.wav", + "text": "一整年新生兒數的三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/104.wav", + "text": "這個是前兩年的數字其實非常驚人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/105.wav", + "text": "也就是如果企業端他們真的可以做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/106.wav", + "text": "友善育兒職場這件事情的所有政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/107.wav", + "text": "其實對於出生率真的是有幫忙的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/108.wav", + "text": "我們來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/109.wav", + "text": "他說原本我跟先生沒有打算生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/110.wav", + "text": "我們的工作真的都很忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/111.wav", + "text": "擔心沒有時間陪伴小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/112.wav", + "text": "可是公司推動遠距上班跟彈性工時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/113.wav", + "text": "我們就決定生了小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/114.wav", + "text": "我想部長對於彈性工時絕對是熟悉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/115.wav", + "text": "對於遠距上班也是熟悉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/116.wav", + "text": "後續造成的效應跟部長分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/117.wav", + "text": "看起來雖然是一個民間雜誌社" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/118.wav", + "text": "他們自辦了10年的獎項10年的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/119.wav", + "text": "他們花自己的經費做了這麼多這麼多的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/120.wav", + "text": "結果後來造成了包含歐洲商會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/121.wav", + "text": "還有很多的中小企業聯合會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/122.wav", + "text": "到底展現出什麼樣的成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/123.wav", + "text": "讓企業在用人這件事情上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/124.wav", + "text": "真的是大大的加分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/125.wav", + "text": "\n就勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/126.wav", + "text": "來說我們當然知道要談彈性工時很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/127.wav", + "text": "因為臺灣有百分之九十幾都是中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/128.wav", + "text": "但是我們想問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/129.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/130.wav", + "text": "透過產官學跟民間的合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/131.wav", + "text": "不斷來擴大這個獎項的效應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/132.wav", + "text": "讓相關獎項的可能性被更多企業看見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/133.wav", + "text": "也被更多負責人力政策的行政官員看見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/134.wav", + "text": "原來彈性工時遠距上班還有更多的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/135.wav", + "text": "可以被理解可以被轉換成政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/136.wav", + "text": "所以這邊我想要快速的倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/137.wav", + "text": "我希望後續可以跟勞動部持續討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/138.wav", + "text": "我們如何站在產官學合作的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/139.wav", + "text": "跟這個雜誌社合作也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/140.wav", + "text": "或是跟很多民間企業合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/141.wav", + "text": "去規劃跟去討論更多的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/142.wav", + "text": "讓這些東西可以被看見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/143.wav", + "text": "跟陳委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/144.wav", + "text": "關於照顧不離職的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/145.wav", + "text": "其實是我上任以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/146.wav", + "text": "非常非常重視的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/147.wav", + "text": "幾個司署的同仁做研討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/148.wav", + "text": "的部分怎麼樣能夠更彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/149.wav", + "text": "也包括如果需要有些經費支出的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/150.wav", + "text": "剛才講到彈性工時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/151.wav", + "text": "我覺得重點應該是這個彈性工時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/152.wav", + "text": "是能夠有助於勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/153.wav", + "text": "工作跟生活平衡的彈性工時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/154.wav", + "text": "這是我們優先考慮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/155.wav", + "text": "不管是透過獎勵的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/156.wav", + "text": "或者是這些表揚的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/157.wav", + "text": "我們都非常非常樂意參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/158.wav", + "text": "因為這確實還需要持續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/159.wav", + "text": "可是我想我們的態度會是很清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/160.wav", + "text": "就是這部分我也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/161.wav", + "text": "有必要再去做更多的突破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/162.wav", + "text": "不然會有更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/163.wav", + "text": "尤其是我們的婦女勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/164.wav", + "text": "其實在職場工作上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/165.wav", + "text": "常常面對二選一的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/166.wav", + "text": "不管是從缺工的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/167.wav", + "text": "或是從性別平等的角度來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/168.wav", + "text": "這都不是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/169.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長非常正向的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/170.wav", + "text": "後續我們辦公室會再跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/171.wav", + "text": "勞動部積極的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/172.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158037/173.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳培瑜委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/1.wav", + "text": "還有勞動基金運用局蘇局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/2.wav", + "text": "請部長跟局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/3.wav", + "text": "蘇委員好部長好我今天問你兩個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/4.wav", + "text": "第一個問題是問比較大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/5.wav", + "text": "了我現在問的就是勞動部下面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/6.wav", + "text": "新制勞工退休基金四兆500多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/7.wav", + "text": "嚇死人了舊制勞工退休基金一兆四百零多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/8.wav", + "text": "這兩個加起來就5.5兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/9.wav", + "text": "還有勞工保險基金1兆956億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/10.wav", + "text": "這個剛剛你的報告書裡面我有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/11.wav", + "text": "就業保險基金1,723億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/12.wav", + "text": "勞職災的保險基金365億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/13.wav", + "text": "所以夯不啷噹加起來是七兆500多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/14.wav", + "text": "你今年編450億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/15.wav", + "text": "請問局長這個操作是你在handle嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/16.wav", + "text": "你是用什麼委員會或者用什麼來操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/17.wav", + "text": "委員提到的是我們最近一次公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/18.wav", + "text": "要委託國內的投信來投資國內的股票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/19.wav", + "text": "這個是我們每年度都會有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/20.wav", + "text": "撥出來的嘛是每一年拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/21.wav", + "text": "每年都會有一個委託投資操作的招標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/22.wav", + "text": "然後有一定的相關程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/23.wav", + "text": "所以是有一個委員會在操作還不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/24.wav", + "text": "我們評選的時候有評選委員9位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/25.wav", + "text": "然後是評選這些代操作的金控公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/26.wav", + "text": "投信來投標的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/27.wav", + "text": "部長你有在管這個嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/28.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/29.wav", + "text": "這個錢這麼多你讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/30.wav", + "text": "報告委員不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/31.wav", + "text": "這個有沒有弊端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/32.wav", + "text": "如果有虧損誰要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/33.wav", + "text": "然後你們是所有七兆多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/34.wav", + "text": "全部都是國內跟國外投資嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/35.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/36.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們所經管的基金規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/37.wav", + "text": "7.5兆我們的投資是全球多元布局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/38.wav", + "text": "包括國內的市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/39.wav", + "text": "國外的市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/40.wav", + "text": "國內的股票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/41.wav", + "text": "國際全球的股票市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/42.wav", + "text": "然後還有債券" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/43.wav", + "text": "這個是你們委託的這些代操作公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/44.wav", + "text": "你們有自己在操作嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/45.wav", + "text": "有報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/46.wav", + "text": "我們有國內的自營團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/47.wav", + "text": "來投資操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/48.wav", + "text": "好我看到的是國內跟國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/49.wav", + "text": "差不多各占一半一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/50.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/51.wav", + "text": "最近俄烏戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/52.wav", + "text": "投資俄羅斯那邊的都卡死了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/53.wav", + "text": "那邊的回得來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/54.wav", + "text": "很多錢都被美國凍結了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/55.wav", + "text": "給歐盟拿去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/56.wav", + "text": "要把那些錢拿來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/57.wav", + "text": "做烏克蘭的重建費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/58.wav", + "text": "我們自營的團隊對俄羅斯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/59.wav", + "text": "並沒有自營的部位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/60.wav", + "text": "主要是因為我們是全球布局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/61.wav", + "text": "我們有很多國外委託的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/62.wav", + "text": "國外的資產管理公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/63.wav", + "text": "他們有一些設計是相對報酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/64.wav", + "text": "所謂相對報酬就是有一些指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/65.wav", + "text": "他可能有一些是被動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/66.wav", + "text": "會去追蹤到各個國家的成份股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/67.wav", + "text": "所以我們其實是被動持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/68.wav", + "text": "俄羅斯的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/69.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/70.wav", + "text": "我們金額也已經逐漸下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/71.wav", + "text": "因為我們也要求受託機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/72.wav", + "text": "國際資產管理公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/73.wav", + "text": "我看俄羅斯那個是五六十億臺幣吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/74.wav", + "text": "二點多億美金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/75.wav", + "text": "這是有人給我消息給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/76.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/77.wav", + "text": "第二你現在去外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/78.wav", + "text": "亂搞嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/79.wav", + "text": "內線交易嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/80.wav", + "text": "拿你們的錢去玩嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/81.wav", + "text": "有沒有這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/82.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/83.wav", + "text": "或者違反法令規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/84.wav", + "text": "我們都一定嚴懲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/85.wav", + "text": "最近媒體報導的那幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/86.wav", + "text": "事實上都沒有涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/87.wav", + "text": "那個是包括他們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/88.wav", + "text": "共同基金等等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/89.wav", + "text": "我們也會跟金管會很密切的合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/90.wav", + "text": "如果有類似的情形發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/91.wav", + "text": "你的七兆多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/92.wav", + "text": "加上郵政儲金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/93.wav", + "text": "5兆左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/94.wav", + "text": "加起來就是我們的國安基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/95.wav", + "text": "還有一個公務人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/96.wav", + "text": "十幾兆耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/97.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/98.wav", + "text": "十幾兆耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/99.wav", + "text": "你說的三五百萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/100.wav", + "text": "當然我們拿這個基金來做投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/101.wav", + "text": "當然我們不能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/102.wav", + "text": "它絕對不會賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/103.wav", + "text": "我自己也要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/104.wav", + "text": "第一個是希望能夠專業操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/105.wav", + "text": "第二件事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/106.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛委員關注的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/107.wav", + "text": "怎麼防弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/108.wav", + "text": "在防弊的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/109.wav", + "text": "這也是我請我們基金應用局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/110.wav", + "text": "在操作這麼龐大資產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/111.wav", + "text": "最重要的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/112.wav", + "text": "所以郵政儲金那一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/113.wav", + "text": "你們沒有管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/114.wav", + "text": "公保軍保那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/115.wav", + "text": "你們沒有管���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/116.wav", + "text": "在維護我們股市安定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/117.wav", + "text": "國內護盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/118.wav", + "text": "這個你們是自己操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/119.wav", + "text": "我們也沒有護盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/120.wav", + "text": "行政院下命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/121.wav", + "text": "你們就開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/122.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/123.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛部長所提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/124.wav", + "text": "我們都是秉持專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/125.wav", + "text": "來進行投資操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/126.wav", + "text": "對於委外的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/127.wav", + "text": "是同樣的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/128.wav", + "text": "來進行相關的操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/129.wav", + "text": "上次那個復華投顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/130.wav", + "text": "有好幾個人被判4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/131.wav", + "text": "判10個月等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/132.wav", + "text": "那是操作你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/133.wav", + "text": "2020年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/134.wav", + "text": "2020年是遠東百貨的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/135.wav", + "text": "遠東百貨的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/136.wav", + "text": "這個部分部長使得上力使不上力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/137.wav", + "text": "部長能督促你們嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/138.wav", + "text": "蘇委員其實現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/139.wav", + "text": "我們的基金應用局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/140.wav", + "text": "在相關的防弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/141.wav", + "text": "尤其之前發生了幾次的弊端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/142.wav", + "text": "所以後來蘇局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/143.wav", + "text": "我其實已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/144.wav", + "text": "我們最重要的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/145.wav", + "text": "就是專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/146.wav", + "text": "然後要防止弊端的發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/147.wav", + "text": "這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/148.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠做得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/149.wav", + "text": "蘇局長你把這幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/150.wav", + "text": "一些書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/151.wav", + "text": "好不好我要比對比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/152.wav", + "text": "就是投資的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/153.wav", + "text": "概括就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/154.wav", + "text": "然後有什麼弊端要講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/155.wav", + "text": "我們就把這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/156.wav", + "text": "這個基金投資的一些概況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/157.wav", + "text": "提供給蘇委員好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/158.wav", + "text": "對然後有賺錢的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/159.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/160.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/161.wav", + "text": "部長有沒有分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/162.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/163.wav", + "text": "怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/164.wav", + "text": "我們全部都是要依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/165.wav", + "text": "中央銀行操作外匯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/166.wav", + "text": "我們的外匯存底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/167.wav", + "text": "現在差不多500多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/168.wav", + "text": "美金喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/169.wav", + "text": "美金上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/170.wav", + "text": "他們就賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/171.wav", + "text": "中央銀行是可以分的喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/172.wav", + "text": "有拿獎金的喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/173.wav", + "text": "我們中央銀行以前是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/174.wav", + "text": "雙月領雙薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/175.wav", + "text": "你知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/176.wav", + "text": "部長你不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/177.wav", + "text": "我們不會去分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/178.wav", + "text": "2月4月就領2個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/179.wav", + "text": "1月3月就領1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/180.wav", + "text": "中央銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/181.wav", + "text": "我們是行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/182.wav", + "text": "所以沒有分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/183.wav", + "text": "所以要怎麼給你們鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/184.wav", + "text": "啊如果賺錢的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/185.wav", + "text": "要想一想啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/186.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/187.wav", + "text": "我覺得這幾年確實賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/188.wav", + "text": "所以我們也希望給同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/189.wav", + "text": "更多的肯定跟鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/190.wav", + "text": "但是賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/191.wav", + "text": "我覺得這對整體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/192.wav", + "text": "比如勞保基金等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/193.wav", + "text": "其實對大家來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/194.wav", + "text": "這是一件好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/195.wav", + "text": "這裡面都是公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/196.wav", + "text": "依法行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/197.wav", + "text": "依法執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/198.wav", + "text": "如果有好的效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/199.wav", + "text": "我們會在部內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/200.wav", + "text": "看可以怎麼樣給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/201.wav", + "text": "但不是分潤啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/202.wav", + "text": "不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/203.wav", + "text": "我們是公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/204.wav", + "text": "說的那樣分潤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/205.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/206.wav", + "text": "再來一個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/207.wav", + "text": "勞保基金說現在負債13兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/208.wav", + "text": "一下子說11兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/209.wav", + "text": "一下子說13兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/210.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/211.wav", + "text": "這是在情緒勒索" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/212.wav", + "text": "還是在恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/213.wav", + "text": "這是怎麼算出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/214.wav", + "text": "也算給我聽聽看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/215.wav", + "text": "什麼1年補10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/216.wav", + "text": "億是勞保操作的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/217.wav", + "text": "也是勞動部業績的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/218.wav", + "text": "大家都亂講一通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/219.wav", + "text": "你是怎麼算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/220.wav", + "text": "13兆是怎麼算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/221.wav", + "text": "每天都在情緒勒索" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/222.wav", + "text": "奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/223.wav", + "text": "那個是在講潛藏負債的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/224.wav", + "text": "潛藏負債的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/225.wav", + "text": "100年後才會發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/226.wav", + "text": "叫潛藏負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/227.wav", + "text": "曾經加保的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/228.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/229.wav", + "text": "健保不會倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/230.wav", + "text": "嘛勞保也不會倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/231.wav", + "text": "啊這個潛藏負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/232.wav", + "text": "你跟我說key point" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/233.wav", + "text": "──你跟我說13兆是怎麼算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/234.wav", + "text": "就是把被保險的年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/235.wav", + "text": "跟投保薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/236.wav", + "text": "是世代互助的社會保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/237.wav", + "text": "採的是部分提存準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/238.wav", + "text": "所以產生潛藏負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/239.wav", + "text": "是公共年金普遍的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/240.wav", + "text": "跟投保薪資增長而增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/241.wav", + "text": "它的潛藏負債會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/242.wav", + "text": "所以潛藏負債是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/243.wav", + "text": "未來可能會給付的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/244.wav", + "text": "但是它不會一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/245.wav", + "text": "它會在未來逐步支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/246.wav", + "text": "而且如果沒有符合請領的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/247.wav", + "text": "他也不會來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/248.wav", + "text": "我們整個政府的負債比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/249.wav", + "text": "我看也都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/250.wav", + "text": "在很良性的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/251.wav", + "text": "不像美國已經超過全國GDP的幾倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/252.wav", + "text": "日本是幾倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/253.wav", + "text": "我們都還好嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/254.wav", + "text": "我們的負債比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/255.wav", + "text": "percent占整個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/256.wav", + "text": "23兆的GDP也不多啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/257.wav", + "text": "蘇委員這個潛藏負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/258.wav", + "text": "比較是去預設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/259.wav", + "text": "給付的狀況發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/260.wav", + "text": "所以我們很重要的事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/261.wav", + "text": "要避免這種恐慌性的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/262.wav", + "text": "有財務精算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/263.wav", + "text": "也有怎麼樣在心理上給大家更多的安心的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/264.wav", + "text": "所以整體來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/265.wav", + "text": "政府的態度就是政府當然會負最終的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/266.wav", + "text": "我們把這個態度給講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/267.wav", + "text": "而且有具體的行動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/268.wav", + "text": "來讓大家知道政府就是會負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/269.wav", + "text": "全部來請領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/270.wav", + "text": "但這個狀況是一個蠻極端的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/271.wav", + "text": "我們要用各種方式來防止這種極端的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/272.wav", + "text": "\n最後一個問題我問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/273.wav", + "text": "一套勞基法可以適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/274.wav", + "text": "勞工的大太陽下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/275.wav", + "text": "綁鐵的還有我們醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/276.wav", + "text": "主治醫師要值班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/277.wav", + "text": "像我們主席這樣一天到晚三更半夜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/278.wav", + "text": "跑去看病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/279.wav", + "text": "這個有可能嗎用一套勞基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/280.wav", + "text": "不可能嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/281.wav", + "text": "當然勞基法立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/282.wav", + "text": "跟立定的目的其實是對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/283.wav", + "text": "保障的一個最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/284.wav", + "text": "各行各業確實可能會有一些樣態的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/285.wav", + "text": "但是勞基法設定目的是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/286.wav", + "text": "最基本最底線的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/287.wav", + "text": "沒有喔勞基法是霸王條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/288.wav", + "text": "什麼人只要拿出勞基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/289.wav", + "text": "大家都亂搞一通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/290.wav", + "text": "醫生的部分搞到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/291.wav", + "text": "也只敢把住院醫師納入勞基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/292.wav", + "text": "主治醫師要怎麼納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/293.wav", + "text": "全世界也沒人敢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/294.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼算時間像我們主席那麼認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/295.wav", + "text": "還是要檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/296.wav", + "text": "\n現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/297.wav", + "text": "因為我們東港那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/298.wav", + "text": "遠洋漁船那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/299.wav", + "text": "我跟部長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/300.wav", + "text": "我排個考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/301.wav", + "text": "我們到屏東去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/302.wav", + "text": "那個遠洋漁工譬如一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/303.wav", + "text": "CT4CT5的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/304.wav", + "text": "船一百零多噸那個裡面的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/305.wav", + "text": "我們的船是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/306.wav", + "text": "從東港開出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/307.wav", + "text": "然後上面只有3個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/308.wav", + "text": "大副輪機長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/309.wav", + "text": "其他漁工是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/310.wav", + "text": "然後船就開到印尼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/311.wav", + "text": "然後那些印尼的漁工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/312.wav", + "text": "就一個一個跳上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/313.wav", + "text": "就出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/314.wav", + "text": "他們一定住在船上嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/315.wav", + "text": "吃喝拉撒睡都在那條船上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/316.wav", + "text": "他住的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/317.wav", + "text": "跟船長住的地方差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/318.wav", + "text": "船長室裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/319.wav", + "text": "你下去我帶你去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/320.wav", + "text": "他是關在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/321.wav", + "text": "裡面還有槍耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/322.wav", + "text": "所以船長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/323.wav", + "text": "住的地方跟船員住的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/324.wav", + "text": "都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/325.wav", + "text": "可能有比較大間一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/326.wav", + "text": "物質條件就不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/327.wav", + "text": "船長也吃一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/328.wav", + "text": "的所以這樣你還那麼苛刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/329.wav", + "text": "而美國在那邊胡說八道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/330.wav", + "text": "一些綠色組織也是這樣胡說八道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/331.wav", + "text": "不同的業別確實會有一些情境的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/332.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/333.wav", + "text": "從勞動部的立場來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/334.wav", + "text": "我們還是希望對勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/335.wav", + "text": "我們還是要盡力去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/336.wav", + "text": "那當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/337.wav", + "text": "啦不要對那些船東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/338.wav", + "text": "對那些船長喊打喊殺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/339.wav", + "text": "每天都是喊打喊殺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/340.wav", + "text": "我要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/341.wav", + "text": "勞基法的適用跟勞基法的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/342.wav", + "text": "還是對於勞工最基本的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/343.wav", + "text": "去做一個規範性的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/344.wav", + "text": "業別上面有不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/345.wav", + "text": "可是其實勞基法很多部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/346.wav", + "text": "工作權益的底線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/347.wav", + "text": "這一塊要注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/348.wav", + "text": "對勞基法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/349.wav", + "text": "可能的對象施展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/350.wav", + "text": "你要弄的話都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/351.wav", + "text": "case by case" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/352.wav", + "text": "不要這樣一以概之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158036/353.wav", + "text": "好不好好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/0.wav", + "text": "主席有請交通部陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/1.wav", + "text": "還有臺鐵公司杜董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/2.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/3.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/4.wav", + "text": "部長我們最近看到不只勞動部有傳出霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/5.wav", + "text": "在交通部也有幾起霸凌的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/6.wav", + "text": "部長有強調程序不會延遲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/7.wav", + "text": "然後也有承諾會接住每一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/8.wav", + "text": "今天我們就臺鐵公司人力資源處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/9.wav", + "text": "吳姓處長霸凌案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/10.wav", + "text": "本席要向杜董事長來一一了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/11.wav", + "text": "也請董事長一一來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/12.wav", + "text": "這次臺鐵人力資源處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/13.wav", + "text": "吳姓處長疑似霸凌案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/14.wav", + "text": "臺鐵的處理經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/15.wav", + "text": "有幾個問題要就教董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/16.wav", + "text": "申訴人在去年112年6月29日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/17.wav", + "text": "就提出了不法侵害通知單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/18.wav", + "text": "同年9月14號召開調查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/19.wav", + "text": "認定了有霸凌的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/20.wav", + "text": "臺鐵為何要等到申訴人在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/21.wav", + "text": "提出臺鐵不回復通報表的申訴之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/22.wav", + "text": "才向申訴人回函" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/23.wav", + "text": "這邊表上講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/24.wav", + "text": "9月14號我們調查委員會認定以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/25.wav", + "text": "我們有通知雙方的當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/26.wav", + "text": "因為通知雙方當事人以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/27.wav", + "text": "我們要處理這個情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/28.wav", + "text": "所以才會有11月的這個結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/29.wav", + "text": "董事長簽辦歷程需要花這麼長的時間嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/30.wav", + "text": "為什麼這個霸凌案成立花了兩個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/31.wav", + "text": "可是推翻卻不到半個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/32.wav", + "text": "沒有講要推翻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/33.wav", + "text": "可是它確實被推翻了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/34.wav", + "text": "因為他有提出申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/35.wav", + "text": "所以我們就依據這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/36.wav", + "text": "確實前面的霸凌案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/37.wav", + "text": "調查了這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/38.wav", + "text": "推翻成立結論卻這麼快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/39.wav", + "text": "是前面的調查小組效率太差嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/40.wav", + "text": "還是後面的調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/41.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/42.wav", + "text": "不是剛剛講了因為雙方都有提申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/43.wav", + "text": "所以我們在處理的過程中要很慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/44.wav", + "text": "很仔細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/45.wav", + "text": "這確實要很慎重很仔細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/46.wav", + "text": "我們看到今年5月7號的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/47.wav", + "text": "保訓會也要求臺鐵兩個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/48.wav", + "text": "要做出適法的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/49.wav", + "text": "然後臺鐵在7月16號的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/50.wav", + "text": "要求延長回覆期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/51.wav", + "text": "保訓會又分別在9月23號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/52.wav", + "text": "還有10月18號發文兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/53.wav", + "text": "要求臺鐵來做回覆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/54.wav", + "text": "可是臺鐵到了11月15號才回文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/55.wav", + "text": "回文的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/56.wav", + "text": "僅敘述收到保訓會行文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/57.wav", + "text": "後的處理經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/58.wav", + "text": "以及另訂11月18號重啟調查會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/59.wav", + "text": "請問董事長本案處理起來很困難嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/60.wav", + "text": "是有什麼樣的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/61.wav", + "text": "這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/62.wav", + "text": "因為雙方都有各自的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/63.wav", + "text": "所以我們很慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/64.wav", + "text": "很慎重所以足足拖了半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/65.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/66.wav", + "text": "我們重啟調查的調查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/67.wav", + "text": "還有包括雙方當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/68.wav", + "text": "都提供了資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/69.wav", + "text": "這都花了很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/70.wav", + "text": "花了很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/71.wav", + "text": "所以讓這位吳姓處長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/72.wav", + "text": "有時間申請調職到國發會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/73.wav", + "text": "還是臺鐵想要隱藏什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/74.wav", + "text": "這個我不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/75.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告沒有隱藏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/76.wav", + "text": "是不認這名吳姓的員工入職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/77.wav", + "text": "所以目前的程序是暫緩了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/78.wav", + "text": "了請問董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/79.wav", + "text": "這名吳姓員工調職暫緩之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/80.wav", + "text": "人會待在哪一個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/81.wav", + "text": "目前還是在他原來的職務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/82.wav", + "text": "如果他之後沒有辦法到國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/83.wav", + "text": "他繼續在臺鐵待著的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/84.wav", + "text": "還會讓他繼續在臺鐵職場霸凌嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/85.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/86.wav", + "text": "有沒有霸凌這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/87.wav", + "text": "我們是透過程序慎重地處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/88.wav", + "text": "確實有透過程序慎重地處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/89.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/90.wav", + "text": "OK如果他繼續在臺鐵霸凌的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/91.wav", + "text": "那就是臺鐵應作為而不作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/92.wav", + "text": "因為臺鐵的霸凌案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/93.wav", + "text": "港務公司霸凌成立案之霸凌行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/94.wav", + "text": "我們相較港務公司和臺鐵公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/95.wav", + "text": "董事長可以從簡報中看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/96.wav", + "text": "這兩個表格分別為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/97.wav", + "text": "臺鐵在112年9月14號的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/98.wav", + "text": "調查委員會的紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/99.wav", + "text": "還有港務公司霸凌成立案之霸凌行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/100.wav", + "text": "請問部長您看到的簡報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/101.wav", + "text": "臺鐵的霸凌行為相較於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/102.wav", + "text": "港務公司來說真的是有過之而無不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/103.wav", + "text": "可是臺鐵公司卻不成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/104.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/105.wav", + "text": "您認為臺鐵公司做出的決議合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/106.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/107.wav", + "text": "其實他們霸凌案的成立跟不成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/108.wav", + "text": "雙方當事人一定都有自己的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/109.wav", + "text": "在審議的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/110.wav", + "text": "也有一定的機制在走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/111.wav", + "text": "所以我確實要顧及雙方的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/112.wav", + "text": "霸凌成立的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/113.wav", + "text": "就遭臺鐵自己推翻了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/114.wav", + "text": "推翻的理由是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/115.wav", + "text": "請您說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/116.wav", + "text": "就是因為雙方有提出申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/117.wav", + "text": "我們妥善處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/118.wav", + "text": "我們還成立了委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/119.wav", + "text": "不是我們自己單純的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/120.wav", + "text": "這邊也讓董事長了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/121.wav", + "text": "被霸凌者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/122.wav", + "text": "然後還有其他基層員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/123.wav", + "text": "也有指出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/124.wav", + "text": "吳姓處長不滿員工的��候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/125.wav", + "text": "會貶低侮辱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/126.wav", + "text": "還有頻退公文以及咆哮方式來霸凌員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/127.wav", + "text": "並要求下屬下班還有假日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/128.wav", + "text": "下週天氣預報下屬都要回答收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/129.wav", + "text": "這麼神奇的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/130.wav", + "text": "3年來已經有63個人離職了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/131.wav", + "text": "請問董事長這麼多人離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/132.wav", + "text": "您有沒有去了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/133.wav", + "text": "臺鐵有沒有去了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/134.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/135.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/136.wav", + "text": "對於我們的調查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/137.wav", + "text": "他們都有提供相對的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/138.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/139.wav", + "text": "第二個3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/140.wav", + "text": "3年來63人離職這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/141.wav", + "text": "並不單純是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/142.wav", + "text": "工作環境壓力或者是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/143.wav", + "text": "有各種的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/144.wav", + "text": "讓那麼多人沉默離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/145.wav", + "text": "這不是本末倒置嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/146.wav", + "text": "你們不改善工作環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/147.wav", + "text": "讓這麼多人離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/148.wav", + "text": "你們有去檢討嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/149.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/150.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/151.wav", + "text": "我們的調查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/152.wav", + "text": "調查結果出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/153.wav", + "text": "調查委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/154.wav", + "text": "還有做了好幾項的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/155.wav", + "text": "這些建議就是剛剛委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/156.wav", + "text": "包括環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/157.wav", + "text": "在這邊先請教董事長一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/158.wav", + "text": "上週五六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/159.wav", + "text": "臺鐵在花蓮舉辦共識營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/160.wav", + "text": "有46名的一級主管在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/161.wav", + "text": "請問董事長您有參加嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/162.wav", + "text": "有我有參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/163.wav", + "text": "這名吳姓處長有沒有去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/164.wav", + "text": "處長好像沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/165.wav", + "text": "他是有參加晚上的有爆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/166.wav", + "text": "被產工糾纏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/167.wav", + "text": "還在臺上感謝馮經理相挺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/168.wav", + "text": "逆轉霸凌案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/169.wav", + "text": "延宕回文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/170.wav", + "text": "保訓會讓兩次審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/171.wav", + "text": "霸凌案不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/172.wav", + "text": "依照吳處長的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/173.wav", + "text": "都應該是經理相挺的結果吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/174.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/175.wav", + "text": "您這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/176.wav", + "text": "在我們共識營裡面沒有發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/177.wav", + "text": "另外再請教董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/178.wav", + "text": "對於吳姓處長的霸凌案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/179.wav", + "text": "有不具名的員工指出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/180.wav", + "text": "吳姓處長有一個同姓的親戚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/181.wav", + "text": "擔任立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/182.wav", + "text": "您知道是哪一位立法委員嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/183.wav", + "text": "這個我不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/184.wav", + "text": "你不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/185.wav", + "text": "也有民眾陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/186.wav", + "text": "說吳姓處長的父親" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/187.wav", + "text": "是高階公務人員退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/188.wav", + "text": "稱自己的後臺很硬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/189.wav", + "text": "人脈很廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/190.wav", + "text": "不但如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/191.wav", + "text": "還揚言自己是吳秉叡委員的親戚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/192.wav", + "text": "這則爆料的真偽本席在此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/193.wav", + "text": "向董事長求證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/194.wav", + "text": "他們有親戚關係嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/195.wav", + "text": "這個過程我並不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/196.wav", + "text": "所以董事長對這個霸凌案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/197.wav", + "text": "沒有去了解嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/198.wav", + "text": "有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/199.wav", + "text": "我有了解這個霸凌案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/200.wav", + "text": "我也很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/201.wav", + "text": "他的親戚是吳姓立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/202.wav", + "text": "這個我真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/203.wav", + "text": "所以你不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/204.wav", + "text": "處理這個案件的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/205.wav", + "text": "是不是有受到壓力嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/206.wav", + "text": "我這邊是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/207.wav", + "text": "因為這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/208.wav", + "text": "如果最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/209.wav", + "text": "查出來與您說的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/210.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/211.wav", + "text": "我都是據實以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/212.wav", + "text": "你都是據實以報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/213.wav", + "text": "部長也擔任過民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/214.wav", + "text": "相信你從政的初衷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/215.wav", + "text": "就是為了減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/216.wav", + "text": "社會上不公不義的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/217.wav", + "text": "你也承諾會接住每一位員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/218.wav", + "text": "希望部長可以還給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/219.wav", + "text": "我們基層同仁一個安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/220.wav", + "text": "乾淨的工作環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/221.wav", + "text": "這個部分我一定會詳查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158035/222.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席有請交通部陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/1.wav", + "text": "請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/2.wav", + "text": "請楊局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/3.wav", + "text": "部長局長早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/4.wav", + "text": "部長跟局長最近辛苦了都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/5.wav", + "text": "陸續到高雄辦了幾場高鐵南延屏東的說明會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/6.wav", + "text": "我想請教部長跟局長目前辦完說明會的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/7.wav", + "text": "我記得部長上任之後本席在這邊也質詢了好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/8.wav", + "text": "部長有承諾今年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/9.wav", + "text": "高鐵南延屏東的路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/10.wav", + "text": "一定會定案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/11.wav", + "text": "但是現在本席很遺憾地看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/12.wav", + "text": "我們每隔一段時間就會看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/13.wav", + "text": "對於左營線跟高雄線的路線之爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/14.wav", + "text": "技術面的錯綜複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/15.wav", + "text": "動工的時間一再往後延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/16.wav", + "text": "報告委員應該不太可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/17.wav", + "text": "2039年這個數字我不知道這個數字怎麼來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/18.wav", + "text": "這都是媒體報導的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/19.wav", + "text": "是我不知道媒體報導的依據是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/20.wav", + "text": "但大概不是這個數字也不會有這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/21.wav", + "text": "好部長可不可以在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/22.wav", + "text": "再承諾一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/23.wav", + "text": "今年底到底高鐵南延屏東的路線會不會定案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/24.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們在高雄總共辦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/25.wav", + "text": "其中專家學者會議1場在高雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/26.wav", + "text": "1場在臺北" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/27.wav", + "text": "另外針對民眾直接面對面的座談會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/28.wav", + "text": "我們總共辦了5場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/29.wav", + "text": "其實我們聽到了許多的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/30.wav", + "text": "目前我們正在選擇路線沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/31.wav", + "text": "高雄的民眾也提供了很多寶貴的意見給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/32.wav", + "text": "我們的目標還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/33.wav", + "text": "我們要在年底的時候確定路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/34.wav", + "text": "我要跟委員報告的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/35.wav", + "text": "高鐵南延的國家政策不會改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/36.wav", + "text": "現在在討論的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/37.wav", + "text": "要走左營線沿著高屏二快的這條線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/38.wav", + "text": "或者是進入高雄市區走高雄火車站的這條線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/39.wav", + "text": "這兩條線路在選擇而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/40.wav", + "text": "但是延伸屏東這個部分是完全確定的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/41.wav", + "text": "部長本席還是要再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/42.wav", + "text": "南延屏東不是為了屏東人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/43.wav", + "text": "而是要落實我們交通平權很重要的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/44.wav", + "text": "是而且總統也不斷在提均衡臺灣的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/45.wav", + "text": "我們對區域均衡發展一定要落實交通平權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/46.wav", + "text": "所以特別拜託一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/47.wav", + "text": "我們一定要趕快不管A案B案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/48.wav", + "text": "趕快定案趕快動工才是好案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/49.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/50.wav", + "text": "葉局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/51.wav", + "text": "貨船擱淺的案子隨著陸續幾個颱風都有發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/52.wav", + "text": "是不是請葉局長跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/53.wav", + "text": "凱米颱風的部分目前還有6艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/54.wav", + "text": "目前總共有8艘在處理中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/55.wav", + "text": "當然你們有一個處置的SOP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/56.wav", + "text": "但是目前看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/57.wav", + "text": "我記得上次質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/58.wav", + "text": "但到目前為止還是在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/59.wav", + "text": "都沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/60.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/61.wav", + "text": "第二個是抽油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/62.wav", + "text": "再來才是船貨的移除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/63.wav", + "text": "經過積極跟他們協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/64.wav", + "text": "我們就依照商港法介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/65.wav", + "text": "後續我們會求償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/66.wav", + "text": "預計13日就會決標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/67.wav", + "text": "就會以福洋的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/68.wav", + "text": "因為只要停泊多1天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/69.wav", + "text": "就會有很多鄉親靠近變成網紅景點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/70.wav", + "text": "真的看起來很危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/71.wav", + "text": "我們看了都膽顫心驚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/72.wav", + "text": "瞭解我們會要求把圍籬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/73.wav", + "text": "做得完善避免發生安全的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/74.wav", + "text": "現在一年大概有一百零多萬人次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/75.wav", + "text": "室白沙尾港的候船碼頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/76.wav", + "text": "壅塞的情形非常地嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/77.wav", + "text": "我們看了很不捨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/78.wav", + "text": "就這兩個碼頭的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/79.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請部長跟局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/80.wav", + "text": "報告委員目前縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/81.wav", + "text": "也有辦一個規劃跟評估的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/82.wav", + "text": "總共450萬的計畫正在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/83.wav", + "text": "所提報的內容大概總經費11億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/84.wav", + "text": "這個部分我也請航港局儘量來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/85.wav", + "text": "趕快把整個設施做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/86.wav", + "text": "因為目前小琉球的旅客確實非常非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/87.wav", + "text": "另外還要再麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/88.wav", + "text": "除了候船室本身之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/89.wav", + "text": "應該要結合縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/90.wav", + "text": "把周邊的停車空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/91.wav", + "text": "看起來更符合國際級的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/92.wav", + "text": "新的計畫裡面有包含整個立體停車場的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/93.wav", + "text": "也會加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/94.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分會做整體的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/95.wav", + "text": "我們覺得比較重要的觀光元素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/96.wav", + "text": "旭海跟海口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/97.wav", + "text": "屏東縣政府已經準備提這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/98.wav", + "text": "子了是不是可以請交通部跟航港局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/99.wav", + "text": "報告委員就這個部分他們的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/100.wav", + "text": "已經提出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/101.wav", + "text": "115年可以完工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/102.wav", + "text": "因為航港局有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/103.wav", + "text": "遊艇貨區的整體發展計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/104.wav", + "text": "預算執行率不到七成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/105.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/106.wav", + "text": "最主要是地方政府請款的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/107.wav", + "text": "比較慢一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/108.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們已經積極地催辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/109.wav", + "text": "預計到11月底的執行率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/110.wav", + "text": "可以到九成三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/111.wav", + "text": "可以改善到年底的執行率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/112.wav", + "text": "可以到百分之百" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/113.wav", + "text": "到年底剩下的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/114.wav", + "text": "我們會持續督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/115.wav", + "text": "轉正的作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/116.wav", + "text": "這邊也要特別謝謝部長跟局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/117.wav", + "text": "我們鹽埔漁港候船室做好以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/118.wav", + "text": "每個漁港都希望打造成這樣的規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/119.wav", + "text": "\n有請臺鐵杜董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/120.wav", + "text": "董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/121.wav", + "text": "的連續假期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/122.wav", + "text": "第一個票價會不會調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/123.wav", + "text": "是不是有做好準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/124.wav", + "text": "第一個我們明年春節的疏運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/125.wav", + "text": "我們會投入所有的運能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/126.wav", + "text": "提供旅客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/127.wav", + "text": "在明年春節前是不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/128.wav", + "text": "可以應付嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/129.wav", + "text": "不會因為在先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/130.wav", + "text": "我們已經有考量到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/131.wav", + "text": "我們春節之前的人力運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/132.wav", + "text": "春節之後的人力運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/133.wav", + "text": "我們在今年年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/134.wav", + "text": "還會有第二波" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/135.wav", + "text": "從業人員的考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/136.wav", + "text": "還是要再提醒上次質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/137.wav", + "text": "時都有提過我們現有的薪資結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/138.wav", + "text": "都輸其他的單位輸很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/139.wav", + "text": "這個誘因不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/140.wav", + "text": "年輕人想要加入這個領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/141.wav", + "text": "但是相對性來說他們會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/142.wav", + "text": "臺鐵公司不是最好的選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/143.wav", + "text": "影響到報考的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/144.wav", + "text": "修正跟調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/145.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個部分目前臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/146.wav", + "text": "但是剛剛聽到董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/147.wav", + "text": "提到未來在於鐵道觀光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/148.wav", + "text": "跟地方創生之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/149.wav", + "text": "我相信未來一定要跟我們中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/150.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠好好地活化資產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/151.wav", + "text": "關於這部分尤其我們屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/152.wav", + "text": "有好幾個車站都非常非常地漂亮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/153.wav", + "text": "今年我們在合作之下辦了鐵道文化節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/154.wav", + "text": "就辦得非常非常成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/155.wav", + "text": "也希望部長跟董事長繼續支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/156.wav", + "text": "並帶動這樣一個產業的文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158034/157.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/0.wav", + "text": "請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/1.wav", + "text": "臺鐵公司杜董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/2.wav", + "text": "杜董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/3.wav", + "text": "港務公司李董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/4.wav", + "text": "李董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/5.wav", + "text": "針對臺鐵現在電子票證的收費基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/6.wav", + "text": "我們最近有收到一個陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/7.wav", + "text": "這一個個案拿出來跟大家討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/8.wav", + "text": "當然也有其他滿多的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/9.wav", + "text": "剛好這個案子比較明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/10.wav", + "text": "就是說他搭乘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/11.wav", + "text": "搭乘長途區間車從臺南到臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/12.wav", + "text": "它是用自強號的標準來扣款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/13.wav", + "text": "他是因為自己有發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/14.wav", + "text": "有把它改成用一般的區間車的方式來扣款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/15.wav", + "text": "我們要討論的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/16.wav", + "text": "他是因為比較細心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/17.wav", + "text": "所以自己有發現被高額扣款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/18.wav", + "text": "多卡通電子票證的乘車營運規定來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/19.wav", + "text": "70公里以內是按照區間車的車票來計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/20.wav", + "text": "超過70公里之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/21.wav", + "text": "就變成有兩種方式計價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/22.wav", + "text": "所以整個票價的計價方式非常複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/23.wav", + "text": "應該這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/24.wav", + "text": "我們當初推動多卡通電子票證的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/25.wav", + "text": "有一種可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/26.wav", + "text": "就是當初在討論政策規定的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/27.wav", + "text": "是希望大家把電子票證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/28.wav", + "text": "或是城市內部把臺鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/29.wav", + "text": "當成捷運的一部分來使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/30.wav", + "text": "我們那時候有這樣思考過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/31.wav", + "text": "所以才去推動所謂的多卡通電子票證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/32.wav", + "text": "是在計價方式上面你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/33.wav", + "text": "你們70公里以內用這樣的方式算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/34.wav", + "text": "又有別的計價方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/35.wav", + "text": "所以導致一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/36.wav", + "text": "或是大家對於計票的基準方式也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/37.wav", + "text": "假設他真的都坐自強號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/38.wav", + "text": "問題是如果我是買對號座的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/39.wav", + "text": "我就會有位置坐現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/40.wav", + "text": "對公司來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/41.wav", + "text": "沒有人坐的位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/42.wav", + "text": "就是沒有人坐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/43.wav", + "text": "就像高鐵一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/44.wav", + "text": "今天我買自由座上車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/45.wav", + "text": "我當然就是可以去坐自由座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/46.wav", + "text": "沒有賣掉的就是沒有賣掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/47.wav", + "text": "我覺得臺鐵在增加營運的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/48.wav", + "text": "是不是可以思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/49.wav", + "text": "要不要整合一下所謂70公里的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/50.wav", + "text": "是不是以後用電子票證來搭乘的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/51.wav", + "text": "要去調整一下你們計價的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/52.wav", + "text": "也就是說反正如果都是電子搭乘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/53.wav", + "text": "不管他是坐什麼方式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/54.wav", + "text": "車在這區間幾公里該收多少錢就收多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/55.wav", + "text": "他如果要買對號座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/56.wav", + "text": "就用對號座方式計價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/57.wav", + "text": "用電子票證就用電子票證的方式來計價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/58.wav", + "text": "藉此提升電子票證的搭乘意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/59.wav", + "text": "我不知道董事長跟部長怎麼看待這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/60.wav", + "text": "報告委員我覺得計價的部分要合理化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/61.wav", + "text": "民眾有發現這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/62.wav", + "text": "或許真的有些民眾在比較長距離的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/63.wav", + "text": "也會搭區間車或許有這樣的選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/64.wav", + "text": "臺鐵也必須給民眾有這樣的選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/65.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/66.wav", + "text": "其實這個部分我們一直都有在做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/67.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員講的我們也有檢討過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/68.wav", + "text": "基本上會發生這個情事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/69.wav", + "text": "應該是我們在車站端的閘門設定不符實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/70.wav", + "text": "其實這個可以用管理的方式來改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/71.wav", + "text": "如果是用電子票證來搭乘自強號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/72.wav", + "text": "之類的其實現在在70公里以內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/73.wav", + "text": "像我們一般的PP自強號或DMU還是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/74.wav", + "text": "我知道我現在是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/75.wav", + "text": "要不要來檢討70公里的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/76.wav", + "text": "這樣講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/77.wav", + "text": "今天如果有人逃票被抓到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/78.wav", + "text": "你們會加重50%的票價嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/79.wav", + "text": "但是你們多收錢也沒有多退人家50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/80.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/81.wav", + "text": "70公里的部分可以來研議來檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/82.wav", + "text": "你們多收也不會多退啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/83.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說從整體營運的方式來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/84.wav", + "text": "他既然搭乘這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/85.wav", + "text": "不管他是搭乘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/86.wav", + "text": "從臺中到臺南它就是固定的距離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/87.wav", + "text": "也就是說你們在計票的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/88.wav", + "text": "如果他是用電子票證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/89.wav", + "text": "就不要有這種到車站設定的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/90.wav", + "text": "你乾脆全部都是按照距離來計價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/91.wav", + "text": "不就解決這個問題了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/92.wav", + "text": "因為70公里之外還有很多的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/93.wav", + "text": "除了單一���強號費率之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/94.wav", + "text": "轉乘的費率也會算在所謂70公里的計算基準裡面嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/95.wav", + "text": "那你的計算基準就變得很複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/96.wav", + "text": "站長都要去調整一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/97.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/98.wav", + "text": "管理上是不是很麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/99.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/100.wav", + "text": "有沒有機會檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/101.wav", + "text": "好這個我們來檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/102.wav", + "text": "好謝謝董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/103.wav", + "text": "事後請再提供一個報告給我看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/104.wav", + "text": "你們要怎麼處理因為新的電子票證是今年8月20號才實施的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/105.wav", + "text": "所以你們要怎麼檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/106.wav", + "text": "怎麼調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/107.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣提升臺鐵的運輸比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/108.wav", + "text": "及讓大家願意使用電子票證的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/109.wav", + "text": "我覺得要好好地思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/110.wav", + "text": "尤其在城市之間轉乘的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/111.wav", + "text": "當大家都使用電子票證的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/112.wav", + "text": "我們當然希望他能夠搭乘大眾運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/113.wav", + "text": "如果你的電子票證計價方式這麼複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/114.wav", + "text": "我想對使用者來講非常不方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/115.wav", + "text": "好好我們來研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/116.wav", + "text": "董事長謝謝董事長請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/117.wav", + "text": "的部分在進入今天的主題之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/118.wav", + "text": "我們先談一下時事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/119.wav", + "text": "媒體人甚至有駐臺的外媒爆料也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/120.wav", + "text": "參與過中共軍演的商船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/121.wav", + "text": "停靠臺中港是不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/122.wav", + "text": "沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/123.wav", + "text": "陳部長你又再揹國安局的鍋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/124.wav", + "text": "上次我講到機場的時候是算他們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/125.wav", + "text": "這次我覺得也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/126.wav", + "text": "到底國安局或是國安相關單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/127.wav", + "text": "過去有沒有提供給港務局或港務公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/128.wav", + "text": "哪些商船參與過中共軍演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/129.wav", + "text": "有這個數據嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/130.wav", + "text": "過去沒有提供過這樣的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/131.wav", + "text": "這次這艘商船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/132.wav", + "text": "也是用商船的方式來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/133.wav", + "text": "申請的時候它的船代公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/134.wav", + "text": "也有跟我們說它裡面裝載的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/135.wav", + "text": "一些零件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/136.wav", + "text": "對港務公司來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/137.wav", + "text": "他們收到這樣子的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/138.wav", + "text": "他們就依法讓它停靠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/139.wav", + "text": "大概過程就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/140.wav", + "text": "國安單位確實在整個過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/141.wav", + "text": "沒有提供給我們軍演方面的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/142.wav", + "text": "過去沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/143.wav", + "text": "但我們希望未來可以提供這方面的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/144.wav", + "text": "要做應處的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/145.wav", + "text": "要先給我們訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/146.wav", + "text": "我們才有辦法來應對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/147.wav", + "text": "今天如果是中共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/148.wav", + "text": "換位思考因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/149.wav", + "text": "今天兩邊相對比較緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/150.wav", + "text": "中共會不會知道我們的商船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/151.wav", + "text": "或我們的任何非軍用船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/152.wav", + "text": "他們可能會知道吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/153.wav", + "text": "他們的情報掌握能力會不會是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/154.wav", + "text": "港務公司跟港務局你們是第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/155.wav", + "text": "如果你們手上都沒有資料的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/156.wav", + "text": "你們當然不會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/157.wav", + "text": "還有一個問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/158.wav", + "text": "假設今天這事件發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/159.wav", + "text": "當然這可能不是個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/160.wav", + "text": "是因為剛好有外媒看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/161.wav", + "text": "然後把它報導出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/162.wav", + "text": "所以我們才知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/163.wav", + "text": "可能其他港口也有類似的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/164.wav", + "text": "我們沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/165.wav", + "text": "假設知道以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/166.wav", + "text": "這些曾經參與過中共軍演的商船也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/167.wav", + "text": "漁船也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/168.wav", + "text": "能不能靠港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/169.wav", + "text": "我們要跟國安單位商討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/170.wav", + "text": "如果國安單位覺得這有國安疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/171.wav", + "text": "未來不應該讓它停靠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/172.wav", + "text": "那就要做另外的處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/173.wav", + "text": "甚至是要進行修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/174.wav", + "text": "如果國安單位認為這樣是可行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/175.wav", + "text": "我們就會遵照國安單位的安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/176.wav", + "text": "所謂的海巡單位有上船來檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/177.wav", + "text": "部長你有回應說海巡單位有上船檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/178.wav", + "text": "但沒有看到任何異狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/179.wav", + "text": "它當然不會有異狀���你看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/180.wav", + "text": "它不可能放武器在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/181.wav", + "text": "因為放武器兩岸就開始了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/182.wav", + "text": "啦不可能直接放武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/183.wav", + "text": "但是我們擔心什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/184.wav", + "text": "它停了幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/185.wav", + "text": "它是2號停靠的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/186.wav", + "text": "還是3號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/187.wav", + "text": "2號停靠7號離港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/188.wav", + "text": "我們擔心什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/189.wav", + "text": "就像我們常常講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/190.wav", + "text": "臺灣有時候會限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/191.wav", + "text": "今天一艘商船為什麼停那邊停五天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/192.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/193.wav", + "text": "它本來就停五天嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/194.wav", + "text": "因為媒體人是6號爆料的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/195.wav", + "text": "它7號離港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/196.wav", + "text": "到底它本來預計停幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/197.wav", + "text": "港務公司有掌握嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/198.wav", + "text": "的裝卸是按照它的期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/199.wav", + "text": "到該出去的時候本來就是要離開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/200.wav", + "text": "但是海象不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/201.wav", + "text": "所以它就停在外圍的停泊區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/202.wav", + "text": "所以本來是預計幾號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/203.wav", + "text": "它是2號到港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/204.wav", + "text": "本來預計幾號離港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/205.wav", + "text": "7號就要離開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/206.wav", + "text": "本來就是7號離港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/207.wav", + "text": "所以它在港外停了兩天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/208.wav", + "text": "今天已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/209.wav", + "text": "所以今天才離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/210.wav", + "text": "啦但是在海外多停了兩天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/211.wav", + "text": "在錨區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/212.wav", + "text": "我們當然知道它裡面沒有裝武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/213.wav", + "text": "也沒有裝軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/214.wav", + "text": "但是我們擔心什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/215.wav", + "text": "今天它停了五加二天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/216.wav", + "text": "就像我剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/217.wav", + "text": "不能有中國製的零組件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/218.wav", + "text": "原因是什麼就是怕資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/219.wav", + "text": "外洩嘛今天商船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/220.wav", + "text": "當然我不知道檢查的結果是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/221.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/222.wav", + "text": "港務公司或港務局能夠掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/223.wav", + "text": "商船上面一定有所謂的紀錄器或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/224.wav", + "text": "攝影機吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/225.wav", + "text": "日這五天運作的模式跟狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/226.wav", + "text": "當然從衛星也可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/227.wav", + "text": "但衛星看到的是大概的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/228.wav", + "text": "商船停靠在港口邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/229.wav", + "text": "它就能夠很明確地掌握整個臺中港的布局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/230.wav", + "text": "你的閘門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/231.wav", + "text": "你的船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/232.wav", + "text": "你的人員怎麼走動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/233.wav", + "text": "我想這才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/234.wav", + "text": "我們最有可能面臨的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/235.wav", + "text": "雖然我們沒有國防的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/236.wav", + "text": "但是真的要拜託你們去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/237.wav", + "text": "檢討比如這一週內要開協調的檢討報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/238.wav", + "text": "是不是要請國安單位或國安局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/239.wav", + "text": "針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/240.wav", + "text": "提供相關的資料給你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/241.wav", + "text": "不然你們永遠不會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/242.wav", + "text": "1週之內要開的協調會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/243.wav", + "text": "就是跟國安單位要來開協調會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/244.wav", + "text": "國安單位如果對於這方面的船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/245.wav", + "text": "未來有什麼樣的因應措施的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/246.wav", + "text": "可以先讓我們知道我們這邊都會配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/247.wav", + "text": "如果今天開完這個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/248.wav", + "text": "這些真正因為其實真的滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/249.wav", + "text": "有很多商船參加過軍演的行動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/250.wav", + "text": "這些商船未來靠港是你們做審核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/251.wav", + "text": "還是會由其他單位來做審核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/252.wav", + "text": "這可能要我們跟國安單位開完會之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/253.wav", + "text": "交通部自己的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/254.wav", + "text": "是報告委員我們可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/255.wav", + "text": "也會跟國安單位討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/256.wav", + "text": "是不是就會商國安單位共同來檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/257.wav", + "text": "或是採取必要的相關配套措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/258.wav", + "text": "以確保國安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158033/259.wav", + "text": "好謝謝謝謝部長謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/0.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席麻煩請勞動部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/1.wav", + "text": "有請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/2.wav", + "text": "部長好民眾積欠就安基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/3.wav", + "text": "生財的器具要被查封" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/4.wav", + "text": "政府收到的就安基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/5.wav", + "text": "就淪為勞動部的小金庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/6.wav", + "text": "更成為各機關的提款機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/7.wav", + "text": "勞動部想要怎���花就怎麼花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/8.wav", + "text": "相對對照起來看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/9.wav", + "text": "是真的還滿諷刺的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/10.wav", + "text": "媒體最近不斷報導就安基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/11.wav", + "text": "經費使用的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/12.wav", + "text": "也覺得說有部分是非常不恰當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/13.wav", + "text": "除了媒體報導出來以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/14.wav", + "text": "請問您還會再繼續清查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/15.wav", + "text": "其他就安計畫的使用情形嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/16.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/17.wav", + "text": "我們現在正在檢討中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/18.wav", + "text": "好就是會繼續持續不斷地往前進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/19.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/20.wav", + "text": "如果有發現其他不當用途的使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/21.wav", + "text": "身為勞動部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/22.wav", + "text": "部長會主動對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/23.wav", + "text": "還是以家醜不可外揚的心態選擇隱蔽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/24.wav", + "text": "如果有看到不法的具體事證的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/25.wav", + "text": "當然該送政風該送檢調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/26.wav", + "text": "我們都不會遮蔽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/27.wav", + "text": "已經開始在熟悉了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/28.wav", + "text": "甚至是機關首長要負很大的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/29.wav", + "text": "例如說就安基金的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/30.wav", + "text": "如果名目不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/31.wav", + "text": "不適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/32.wav", + "text": "同時又執行得很沒有績效的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/33.wav", + "text": "而且每年都在實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/34.wav", + "text": "甚至是同一個組織或者團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/35.wav", + "text": "拿到這些計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/36.wav", + "text": "我希望部長看到這些情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/37.wav", + "text": "就麻煩你要特別注意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/38.wav", + "text": "目前社會各界都是從名目上來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/39.wav", + "text": "從計畫名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/40.wav", + "text": "就覺得很不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/41.wav", + "text": "可是還有一些是計畫名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/42.wav", + "text": "看起來很偉大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/43.wav", + "text": "但是實際上是掛羊頭賣狗肉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/44.wav", + "text": "成果績效又不是很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/45.wav", + "text": "所以我今天的質詢要特別提醒部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/46.wav", + "text": "就是對於這個部分也要了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/47.wav", + "text": "也就是我剛剛提到的這些計畫的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/48.wav", + "text": "不應該執行的就要停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/49.wav", + "text": "也要拜託部長花一點時間去了解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/50.wav", + "text": "我舉例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/51.wav", + "text": "譬如說職安署花了一億多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/52.wav", + "text": "這預算其實匡得還滿高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/53.wav", + "text": "其實也是看不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/54.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分也麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/55.wav", + "text": "可以協助去好好了解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/56.wav", + "text": "我相信以部長的聰明才智" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/57.wav", + "text": "可以考上建中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/58.wav", + "text": "又可以考上臺大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/59.wav", + "text": "絕對可以看懂這些不恰當的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/60.wav", + "text": "想想說為什麼要這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/61.wav", + "text": "應該不是件難事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/62.wav", + "text": "跟陳委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/63.wav", + "text": "其實就像你說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/64.wav", + "text": "除了名目上面到底適不適宜正在做檢討以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/65.wav", + "text": "當然績效是不是有做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/66.wav", + "text": "其實都應該是綜合考慮的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/67.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/68.wav", + "text": "要談一下制度面的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/69.wav", + "text": "就安基金管理會召開的頻率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/70.wav", + "text": "部長知道是多久開一次嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/71.wav", + "text": "每季" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/72.wav", + "text": "每季3個月一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/73.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/74.wav", + "text": "這些管理的規定是法律層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/75.wav", + "text": "還是行政命令還是行政規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/76.wav", + "text": "它有母法是在就服法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/77.wav", + "text": "現在應該它也有所謂收支管理辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/78.wav", + "text": "所以基本上它也是用行政命令的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/79.wav", + "text": "它一些項目的細則是定在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/80.wav", + "text": "收支管理辦法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/81.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/82.wav", + "text": "就安基金管理會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/83.wav", + "text": "是管理基金的用途還有審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/84.wav", + "text": "而負責勞動力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/85.wav", + "text": "跨國勞動力政策協商諮詢小組的成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/86.wav", + "text": "我剛剛提了這兩個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/87.wav", + "text": "我就想要請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/88.wav", + "text": "既然是重要的裁判角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/89.wav", + "text": "裡面的委員有沒有重疊的名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/90.wav", + "text": "這個可能要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/91.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/92.wav", + "text": "後面的有點頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/93.wav", + "text": "有沒有重疊的名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/94.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告確實是有一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/95.wav", + "text": "因為他是從勞資政學各個領域來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/96.wav", + "text": "好沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/97.wav", + "text": "不要緊張重疊沒關係不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/98.wav", + "text": "下面的問題比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/99.wav", + "text": "這些委員可以申請就安基金下的計畫嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/100.wav", + "text": "完全都不用迴避嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/101.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告我們的就安基金除了我們行政機關自己用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/102.wav", + "text": "也會補助地方政府還有透過採購或者是補助的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/103.wav", + "text": "結合民間的力量來推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/104.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們並沒有因為他是就安基金委員的所屬機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/105.wav", + "text": "或者是補助的單位資格裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/106.wav", + "text": "因為我剛舉的例子是有球員兼裁判的嫌疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/107.wav", + "text": "我沒有一定說是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/108.wav", + "text": "但是球員兼裁判的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/109.wav", + "text": "大家就會有疑慮嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/110.wav", + "text": "但是你如何在這個過程當中迴避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/111.wav", + "text": "我想這個是重要的事情大家會關心嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/112.wav", + "text": "我提出這樣的質疑應該沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/113.wav", + "text": "委員的提醒我會很嚴肅地來參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/114.wav", + "text": "好再來這個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/115.wav", + "text": "可以去砍掉別人的計畫來成就自己的計畫嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/116.wav", + "text": "這樣是什麼樣的委員呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/117.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/118.wav", + "text": "我們的委員是依照我們所提報的相關工作計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/119.wav", + "text": "或者是有臨時提案的話針對那些提案來做審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/120.wav", + "text": "好沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/121.wav", + "text": "不會聽到很滿意的解釋啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/122.wav", + "text": "我就丟出我的質疑也是提醒好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/123.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼課的兼任教授是不是可以來接你們的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/124.wav", + "text": "這個我也丟出來給你們參考參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/125.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們會一併留意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/126.wav", + "text": "不過基本上我們不會讓一位委員在某一個計畫裡面同時球員又兼裁判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/127.wav", + "text": "這部分我們會特別留意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/128.wav", + "text": "你們就已經做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/129.wav", + "text": "我建議你們調閱過去三個年度的歷次審查會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/130.wav", + "text": "我想你會發現一次平均審多少計畫一次會議的時間多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/131.wav", + "text": "部長我做這個非常重要的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/132.wav", + "text": "我再講一次一次平均審多少計畫一次的會議時間多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/133.wav", + "text": "這些計畫都是文官及主官或者是首長蓋章同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/134.wav", + "text": "然後資料內容都非常少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/135.wav", + "text": "甚至連續幾年內容都差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/136.wav", + "text": "然後就包裏式一次審一個年度的計畫一次幾十個計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/137.wav", + "text": "不論是計畫審查還是成果的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/138.wav", + "text": "其實都已經被內部初審過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/139.wav", + "text": "提供初審意見其實也都提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/140.wav", + "text": "啦所以請問這些委員如何能夠看得懂聽得懂審得好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/141.wav", + "text": "委員其實都是針對這些初審意見去做評論而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/142.wav", + "text": "嘛那他們審的是初審意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/143.wav", + "text": "而不是計畫的實質內容跟實際的成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/144.wav", + "text": "部長你同意我的說法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/145.wav", + "text": "其實現在我們在做基金管理相關機制的檢討裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/146.wav", + "text": "我自己很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/147.wav", + "text": "我們檢討的方向就是要讓這個基金管理的過程更具監理的性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/148.wav", + "text": "包括外部委員的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/149.wav", + "text": "包括監理的性質更明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/150.wav", + "text": "包括計畫事前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/151.wav", + "text": "當然一些細節我們還在討論之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/152.wav", + "text": "但是現在委員做的一些提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/153.wav", + "text": "我們都會納入接下來的參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/154.wav", + "text": "部長我們對你是有很高的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/155.wav", + "text": "建議部長應該要大刀闊斧去改變審查機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/156.wav", + "text": "有些問題其實也不能怪審查委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/157.wav", + "text": "因為有時候他們也是心有餘而力不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/158.wav", + "text": "但是有些委員他真的就可以成為御用的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/159.wav", + "text": "因為他們平常都有拿你們勞動部跟發展署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/160.wav", + "text": "還有安研所的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/161.wav", + "text": "嘛審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/162.wav", + "text": "就會以專家學者的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/163.wav", + "text": "這個不打緊重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/164.wav", + "text": "連計畫內容都不看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/165.wav", + "text": "我講這個不是唬爛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/166.wav", + "text": "真的就有人是計畫連看都不看的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/167.wav", + "text": "並且要汰換這些不適任的委員嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/168.wav", + "text": "整體就安基金的審查跟管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/169.wav", + "text": "其實這整個都在我們現在的檢討範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/170.wav", + "text": "都在檢討的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/171.wav", + "text": "這樣子很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/172.wav", + "text": "我們很期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/173.wav", + "text": "你們的就業保險基金跟職災保護基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/174.wav", + "text": "事實上這些我剛剛提到的都應該要被檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/175.wav", + "text": "相關的主管跟首長也應該要對您負責才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/176.wav", + "text": "所以也建議部長用檢視就安基金的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/177.wav", + "text": "也看看你們的就保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/178.wav", + "text": "還有職災保護基金可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/179.wav", + "text": "如果有哪些部分真的明確有不妥的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/180.wav", + "text": "用同樣的角度去檢視這些基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/181.wav", + "text": "因為這樣會比我們後面有其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/182.wav", + "text": "把這個案例直接丟出來要來得好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/183.wav", + "text": "上次我有質詢就是為什麼不要恭喜部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/184.wav", + "text": "因為部長擔任的是一個救火隊的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/185.wav", + "text": "現在看起來感覺好像是火源很多到處都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/186.wav", + "text": "一個不小心可能就會把星星之火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/187.wav", + "text": "引發成宇宙大爆炸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/188.wav", + "text": "我想這些會引起火災或爆炸的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/189.wav", + "text": "最重要的就是它可以被燒成材料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/190.wav", + "text": "關鍵其實都在於人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/191.wav", + "text": "人的問題很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/192.wav", + "text": "所以希望部長不僅可以有好的機要人員來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/193.wav", + "text": "一起合作承擔勞動部的重責大任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/194.wav", + "text": "部長剛剛同意了解各種基金是否有發現問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/195.wav", + "text": "可以提供書面報告給本辦還有我們衛環委員會的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/196.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/197.wav", + "text": "好跟委員再補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/198.wav", + "text": "我覺得除了人以外很重要的是機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/199.wav", + "text": "就是我們還是必須從機制面著手去面對問題跟解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158032/200.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/0.wav", + "text": "主席有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/1.wav", + "text": "有請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/2.wav", + "text": "先恭喜你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/3.wav", + "text": "我就剛才就業安定基金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/4.wav", + "text": "先請問部長112年就業安定基金的規模是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/5.wav", + "text": "你是說水位是流量還是存量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/6.wav", + "text": "流量的話應該是二百零多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/7.wav", + "text": "大概是247億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/8.wav", + "text": "主管機關對下列自願就業人員應訂定計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/9.wav", + "text": "致力促進其就業必要時得發給相關津貼或補助金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/10.wav", + "text": "一共有10個類別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/11.wav", + "text": "你們如果有做相關補貼的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/12.wav", + "text": "金額大概是多少或者它的規模是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/13.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告原住民朋友目前有59萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/14.wav", + "text": "整個勞動參與的狀況跟失業的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/15.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們在相關的經費上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/16.wav", + "text": "因為我並不知道實際補助的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/17.wav", + "text": "所以我想知道這10個類別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/18.wav", + "text": "能不能在一個月之內給我相關的書面說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/19.wav", + "text": "相關經費的編列如果有類別的部分我會再補充給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/20.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/21.wav", + "text": "不用1個月2個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/22.wav", + "text": "好2個禮拜謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/23.wav", + "text": "我就針對爭議就是在疫情補助的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/24.wav", + "text": "109年暴增到70.6億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/25.wav", + "text": "110年是8.4億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/26.wav", + "text": "我的意思是這個部分怎麼會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/27.wav", + "text": "由勞動部這邊來支應而不是衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/28.wav", + "text": "爭議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/29.wav", + "text": "變成疫情補助的小金庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/30.wav", + "text": "109年高達70.6億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/31.wav", + "text": "如果它是針對因為疫情其實也影響到一些勞工就業的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/32.wav", + "text": "會影響到他在職場就業的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/33.wav", + "text": "也影響到整體經濟情勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/34.wav", + "text": "雖然它是因為疫情而影響到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/35.wav", + "text": "這我知道但是我在醫院服務的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/36.wav", + "text": "甚至是在衛生所服務的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/37.wav", + "text": "是毫不留情地在刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/38.wav", + "text": "明明就付出了這些勞力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/39.wav", + "text": "可是這裡如果有70.6億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/40.wav", + "text": "這麼多的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/41.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法去補足它之前被扣的這些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/42.wav", + "text": "因為會覺得有點不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/43.wav", + "text": "我明明也是在照顧這些需要的病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/44.wav", + "text": "可是我們被扣了這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/45.wav", + "text": "而這邊又補助了這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/46.wav", + "text": "到底是補助給誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/47.wav", + "text": "如果它是針對促進國民就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/48.wav", + "text": "或者是勞工福祉相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/49.wav", + "text": "當然在這個名目上面比較可以透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/50.wav", + "text": "就業安定基金來支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/51.wav", + "text": "但如果跟這個名目比較不相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/52.wav", + "text": "那就比較困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/53.wav", + "text": "OK我第二個疑問是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/54.wav", + "text": "我們看到111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/55.wav", + "text": "有所謂的女性勞動活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/56.wav", + "text": "跟國民黨執政縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/57.wav", + "text": "有著10倍到40倍的差距之多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/58.wav", + "text": "像高雄市有到3,173萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/59.wav", + "text": "新竹縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/60.wav", + "text": "我就不講直轄市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/61.wav", + "text": "我們講屏東縣好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/62.wav", + "text": "屏東縣是605萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/63.wav", + "text": "彰化縣是22萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/64.wav", + "text": "這個就將近差了40倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/65.wav", + "text": "跟盧委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/66.wav", + "text": "其實我自己覺得是可以整體來檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/67.wav", + "text": "就安基金補助給地方政府的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/68.wav", + "text": "是因為你們沒有去推女性勞動價值活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/69.wav", + "text": "還是只有在綠色執政的縣市才有推這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/70.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/71.wav", + "text": "那一次我們訂定了一個計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/72.wav", + "text": "給各縣市政府自己提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/73.wav", + "text": "大概是一個月多一點的時間可提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/74.wav", + "text": "各縣市政府收回來的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/75.wav", + "text": "因為有的縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/76.wav", + "text": "當年上半年已經做過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/77.wav", + "text": "所以就沒有再繼續提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/78.wav", + "text": "跟你說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/79.wav", + "text": "後來高雄市政府就把它的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/80.wav", + "text": "OK好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/81.wav", + "text": "還有就綠能產業的安全促進計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/82.wav", + "text": "編了1,140萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/83.wav", + "text": "我想知道針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/84.wav", + "text": "針對原住民高風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/85.wav", + "text": "比如像掉落的這些產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/86.wav", + "text": "跟盧委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/87.wav", + "text": "這邊之所以針對綠能產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/88.wav", + "text": "是因為綠能產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/89.wav", + "text": "裡面其實有一些比較新興的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/90.wav", + "text": "比方說像離岸風電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/91.wav", + "text": "或比方說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/92.wav", + "text": "所以補助的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/93.wav", + "text": "並不是只獨厚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/94.wav", + "text": "而是對既有的產業樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/95.wav", + "text": "相對比較成熟的作法在協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/96.wav", + "text": "但因綠能產業會有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/97.wav", + "text": "比較新的工作樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/98.wav", + "text": "跟新的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/99.wav", + "text": "所以針對這些新的工作樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/100.wav", + "text": "跟風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/101.wav", + "text": "去做到底要怎麼管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/102.wav", + "text": "這些風險的研擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/103.wav", + "text": "勞工死亡最高的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/104.wav", + "text": "這個部分應該要再多給一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/105.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/106.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/107.wav", + "text": "我們在職災專款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/108.wav", + "text": "會特別針對人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/109.wav", + "text": "人數比較多的營造業跟製造業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/110.wav", + "text": "其實我們對3個產業有補助跟協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/111.wav", + "text": "這部分我們再加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/112.wav", + "text": "這10年來其實跟國人一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/113.wav", + "text": "都有在穩定成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/114.wav", + "text": "不過它的差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/115.wav", + "text": "永遠都是穩定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/116.wav", + "text": "也就是有1萬元的差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/117.wav", + "text": "我看最新的數據98年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/118.wav", + "text": "就差了將近1萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/119.wav", + "text": "一直到現在還是差了1萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/120.wav", + "text": "所以在這個就業安定基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/121.wav", + "text": "能不能做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/122.wav", + "text": "讓它的差距變少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/123.wav", + "text": "能不能最先研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/124.wav", + "text": "盧委員我非常能夠理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/125.wav", + "text": "其實原住民遇到的就業情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/126.wav", + "text": "甚至是職場的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/127.wav", + "text": "這可能確實是相對比較高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/128.wav", + "text": "我可以請業務單位檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/129.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣特別考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/130.wav", + "text": "可能要把比其他身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/131.wav", + "text": "有更多風險的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/132.wav", + "text": "K還有一些歧視的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/133.wav", + "text": "我們的中華隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/134.wav", + "text": "還是有人習慣叫他們小黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/135.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/136.wav", + "text": "其實在職場上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/137.wav", + "text": "我們都會受到很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/138.wav", + "text": "你在這方面有沒有想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/139.wav", + "text": "如果這些是在職場發生的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/140.wav", + "text": "是法規該怎麼規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/141.wav", + "text": "甚至是裁罰的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/142.wav", + "text": "我們的立場一直都是很清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/143.wav", + "text": "我們常常在拍影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/144.wav", + "text": "有原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/145.wav", + "text": "要有我們主流的族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/146.wav", + "text": "而不是如果今天是拍原住��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/147.wav", + "text": "就全部原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/148.wav", + "text": "如果今天是拍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/149.wav", + "text": "那個就會沒有一個實際的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/150.wav", + "text": "參考價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/151.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/152.wav", + "text": "我們願意納入這個建議跟參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/153.wav", + "text": "就業服務法裡面有規定所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/154.wav", + "text": "不得對這些種類的歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/155.wav", + "text": "你看一下這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/156.wav", + "text": "有沒有缺的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/157.wav", + "text": "缺了哪一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/158.wav", + "text": "其實裡面的項目是不少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/159.wav", + "text": "重點是落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/160.wav", + "text": "對我努力看了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/161.wav", + "text": "大概缺身高體重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/162.wav", + "text": "因為確實它已經很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/163.wav", + "text": "要包含所有的類別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/164.wav", + "text": "可是我們對身高體重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/165.wav", + "text": "還是有一些歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/166.wav", + "text": "所以還是希望能夠標明上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/167.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/168.wav", + "text": "最後一個要提的就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/169.wav", + "text": "屏東榮總發生了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/170.wav", + "text": "不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/171.wav", + "text": "醫院自己調查的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/172.wav", + "text": "不是霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/173.wav", + "text": "它確實是一個霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/174.wav", + "text": "所以希望我們勞動部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/175.wav", + "text": "能夠深刻地去了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/176.wav", + "text": "去檢討這件事情的發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/177.wav", + "text": "到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/178.wav", + "text": "因為這位護理人員還在加護病房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/179.wav", + "text": "職安署這邊也有做一些調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/180.wav", + "text": "也有給我們一些回報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/181.wav", + "text": "就是說這些違反哪些規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/182.wav", + "text": "上面有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/183.wav", + "text": "滿奇怪的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/184.wav", + "text": "就是3年內未重複違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/185.wav", + "text": "3年內太久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/186.wav", + "text": "而且最主要是這個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/187.wav", + "text": "還在加護病房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/188.wav", + "text": "這個受害者還在加護病房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/189.wav", + "text": "所以我是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/190.wav", + "text": "3年內違反的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/191.wav", + "text": "其實這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/192.wav", + "text": "或者是請它做���善的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/193.wav", + "text": "員這個部分我們正在做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/194.wav", + "text": "我們其實是通知它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/195.wav", + "text": "1個月內要改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/196.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/197.wav", + "text": "才剛剛開幕沒有多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/198.wav", + "text": "並不是3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/199.wav", + "text": "它沒有所謂的以前的做比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/200.wav", + "text": "現在就是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/201.wav", + "text": "所以希望它能夠立即改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/202.wav", + "text": "是我們要求1個月內改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/203.wav", + "text": "我們現在有16族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/204.wav", + "text": "族常常因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/205.wav", + "text": "要請假的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/206.wav", + "text": "原住民勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/207.wav", + "text": "不好意思跟老闆說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/208.wav", + "text": "我是原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/209.wav", + "text": "我要請那天法定的假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/210.wav", + "text": "有些預算是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/211.wav", + "text": "其實這個費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/212.wav", + "text": "發一個簡訊通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/213.wav", + "text": "或者是說LINE的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/214.wav", + "text": "跟他們講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/215.wav", + "text": "如果你職場上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/216.wav", + "text": "有原住民朋友的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/217.wav", + "text": "請主動告知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/218.wav", + "text": "他可以休一天的假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/219.wav", + "text": "而不是讓原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/220.wav", + "text": "告訴老闆說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/221.wav", + "text": "我是原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/222.wav", + "text": "我要請一天假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/223.wav", + "text": "這部分我們願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/224.wav", + "text": "再特別宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/225.wav", + "text": "甚至主動宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/226.wav", + "text": "還有一個是沒有人提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/227.wav", + "text": "的就是如果今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/228.wav", + "text": "是嫁給原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/229.wav", + "text": "或是娶了原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/230.wav", + "text": "今天我的內人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/231.wav", + "text": "另外一半要請原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/232.wav", + "text": "歲時祭儀假的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/233.wav", + "text": "我不是這個族群的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/234.wav", + "text": "我沒有這個假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/235.wav", + "text": "我能不能因為我的配偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/236.wav", + "text": "是原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/237.wav", + "text": "我們就可以一起返鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/238.wav", + "text": "儀這個部分也請部長這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/239.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/240.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/241.wav", + "text": "好謝謝盧委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158031/242.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/0.wav", + "text": "但這7支單支影片的點擊率都很差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/1.wav", + "text": "王育敏委員講過針對其他的7支影片點擊率都是幾百次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/2.wav", + "text": "最高的不過就是兩千出頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/3.wav", + "text": "報告委員那是所有的連結起來總共是七萬多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/4.wav", + "text": "這是總計的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/5.wav", + "text": "因為其他的單支影片點擊率都很低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/6.wav", + "text": "後來我們也要求跟你們要後臺的點閱資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/7.wav", + "text": "可是要了很久發現你們也都不願意提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/8.wav", + "text": "我們想了解這一部分算是機密嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/9.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告當天的現場是有兩千位左右民眾參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/10.wav", + "text": "當天我們也有發不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/11.wav", + "text": "不是這個資料提供會有困難嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/12.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們要這個資料要不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/13.wav", + "text": "目前從我們網頁上面找到的是這樣的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/14.wav", + "text": "我們可以調每個月的觸擊率嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/15.wav", + "text": "因為我們發現有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/16.wav", + "text": "大家才很有興趣上去看這個影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/17.wav", + "text": "並不是之前大家就很有興趣看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/18.wav", + "text": "耶而是這個事件爆發點閱率才高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/19.wav", + "text": "所以我們才要求調每個月的觸擊率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/20.wav", + "text": "我想了解一下這是檢察官講的偵查不公開的部分嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/21.wav", + "text": "因為我們真的很懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/22.wav", + "text": "之前你說有一些核銷的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/23.wav", + "text": "因為帳務的問題檢察官在調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/24.wav", + "text": "偵查不公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/25.wav", + "text": "可是我相信這個應該不在檢察官的偵查範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/26.wav", + "text": "我相信這應該不是機密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/27.wav", + "text": "涂委員我覺得這部分可以公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/28.wav", + "text": "好那請你們儘快提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/29.wav", + "text": "因為我們很有興趣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/30.wav", + "text": "因為我們看這個單支的影片點閱率一直都很低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/31.wav", + "text": "我相信大家是因為這個事件爆發之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/32.wav", + "text": "才對這個音樂會很有興趣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/33.wav", + "text": "應該是最近才爆量的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/34.wav", + "text": "請把這個數據提供給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/35.wav", + "text": "這個可以提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/36.wav", + "text": "那時候我們說這個音樂會的籌辦跟簽核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/37.wav", + "text": "式的簽核流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/38.wav", + "text": "所以我們說這個演唱會是不是許銘春自己簽核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/39.wav", + "text": "然後高歌由納稅人買單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/40.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/41.wav", + "text": "那個案子是條平司這邊簽核的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/42.wav", + "text": "整個案件來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/43.wav", + "text": "並沒有所謂為了要開個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/44.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說你那時候有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/45.wav", + "text": "所以基本上部長一定也有簽核啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/46.wav", + "text": "條平司送上去部長一定有簽核嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/47.wav", + "text": "所以我們才說這是許銘春演唱會自己核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/48.wav", + "text": "然後高歌由納稅人買單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/49.wav", + "text": "啦而且你看一下他現場有唱3首歌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/50.wav", + "text": "喔孤女的願望純情青春夢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/51.wav", + "text": "我的心裡只有你沒有他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/52.wav", + "text": "然後我們也看一下歌詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/53.wav", + "text": "我想我的心裡只有你沒有他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/54.wav", + "text": "這跟我們的性別工作平等不知道到底有沒有什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/55.wav", + "text": "這些歌單這些規劃是條平司規劃部長上去唱的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/56.wav", + "text": "這個部分的話我們有跟製作單位共同討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/57.wav", + "text": "那製作單位在安排上面我們有討論到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/58.wav", + "text": "然後再來做宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/59.wav", + "text": "能夠把整個宣導的部分做得稍微活一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/60.wav", + "text": "好所以你們那時候就有規劃嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/61.wav", + "text": "可是我們去了解以後節目企劃的整個流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/62.wav", + "text": "從熊熊音樂的四季紅安平追想曲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/63.wav", + "text": "到擊樂二重奏然後中場休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/64.wav", + "text": "我們看整個企劃整個流程並沒有許部長唱歌這個流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/65.wav", + "text": "啊企劃書也沒有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/66.wav", + "text": "這個是我們在設計上面包括像後來的節目單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/67.wav", + "text": "實際上我們也有提供給委員在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/68.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有把這部分擺上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/69.wav", + "text": "後面要擺一個這個也是設計橋段的問題啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/70.wav", + "text": "就是設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/71.wav", + "text": "要給大家一個驚喜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/72.wav", + "text": "一個彩蛋進來的那個情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/73.wav", + "text": "然後大家有一個譁然的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/74.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說你當初所有的企劃並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/75.wav", + "text": "所以聽司長這樣講其實你們事前就有規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/76.wav", + "text": "只是企劃書裡面沒有對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/77.wav", + "text": "企劃書沒有嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/78.wav", + "text": "企劃書是後面在提報的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/79.wav", + "text": "當初在思考這個部分我們再去做一些修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/80.wav", + "text": "可能不敢把這個橋段放上去啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/81.wav", + "text": "因為這個企劃流程放上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/82.wav", + "text": "我不知道大家的觀感是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/83.wav", + "text": "而且你想想看這整個音樂會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/84.wav", + "text": "他要唱歌也不是像公園阿公阿嬤把錢投下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/85.wav", + "text": "點歌就會出來耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/86.wav", + "text": "他要唱哪些歌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/87.wav", + "text": "歌曲曲目絕對都要事先排演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/88.wav", + "text": "我不知道為什麼你們在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/89.wav", + "text": "的整個企劃跟節目表完全都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/90.wav", + "text": "然後後面不知道為什麼會安插進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/91.wav", + "text": "可能你們自己也在規避吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/92.wav", + "text": "好沒關係這個我相信大家心裡有數啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/93.wav", + "text": "這個音樂演唱會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/94.wav", + "text": "那你知不知道我們疫情指揮中心全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/95.wav", + "text": "鬆綁室內室外空間全程戴口罩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/96.wav", + "text": "有跟場地的衛武營那邊接洽過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/97.wav", + "text": "現場上去表演部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/98.wav", + "text": "對但是我不知道當初為什麼勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/99.wav", + "text": "堅持要去辦這個演唱會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/100.wav", + "text": "因為那個時候疫情這麼的嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/101.wav", + "text": "我們到111年12月1號才鬆綁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/102.wav", + "text": "那你們在9月3號辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/103.wav", + "text": "你知道9月3號那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/104.wav", + "text": "全國新冠確診人數有多少嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/105.wav", + "text": "沒關係這也不用考你啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/106.wav", + "text": "我們查了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/107.wav", + "text": "那一天新冠確診還有3萬4,339" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/108.wav", + "text": "人結果你們花了400萬去辦這場演唱會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/109.wav", + "text": "我不知道當初你們的想法到底是怎麼樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/110.wav", + "text": "是不是可以給我們一個調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/111.wav", + "text": "中間也這樣子安插" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/112.wav", + "text": "是不是故意規避這個企劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/113.wav", + "text": "跟涂委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/114.wav", + "text": "在臺灣的勞動法制是一個非常非常重要的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/115.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個事情我認為是OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/116.wav", + "text": "但確實在部分的呈現橋段上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/117.wav", + "text": "適不適合對社會來說觀感好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/118.wav", + "text": "這部分我覺得是可以有檢討的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/119.wav", + "text": "好針對我們剛剛所提的幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/120.wav", + "text": "包括每個月的觸及率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/121.wav", + "text": "還有針對這個企劃流程你們也說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/122.wav", + "text": "當初為什麼刻意沒有去把它呈現出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/123.wav", + "text": "還有為什麼會挑那一天來辦這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/124.wav", + "text": "活動沒關係你就在調查報告跟我們說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/125.wav", + "text": "然後為什麼在那個時候舉辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/126.wav", + "text": "那個時間點的選擇原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/127.wav", + "text": "相關的說明我會提供給對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/128.wav", + "text": "調查報告請部長再處理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/129.wav", + "text": "提供給好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/130.wav", + "text": "現在全國移工的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/131.wav", + "text": "應該是突破80萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/132.wav", + "text": "對部長知道突破80萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/133.wav", + "text": "其實在去年1月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/134.wav", + "text": "只有72萬多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/135.wav", + "text": "那到今年10月就突破了80萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/136.wav", + "text": "尤其我們桃園市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/137.wav", + "text": "的增幅是全國最高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/138.wav", + "text": "那我們去了解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/139.wav", + "text": "在移工持續暴增的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/140.wav", + "text": "針對移工業務的訪查員跟諮詢人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/141.wav", + "text": "卻遠遠不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/142.wav", + "text": "數百億的就安基金補助地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/143.wav", + "text": "政府做這個業務是不是補助得太少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/144.wav", + "text": "而讓人數嚴重不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/145.wav", + "text": "謝謝涂委員的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/146.wav", + "text": "這個部分如果有經費的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/147.wav", + "text": "更多一點支持好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/148.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/149.wav", + "text": "辦理移工的相關業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/150.wav", + "text": "不管是訪查或者是通譯人員相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/151.wav", + "text": "服務的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/152.wav", + "text": "我們是參考各個縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/153.wav", + "text": "還有雇主家數以及仲介的家數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/154.wav", + "text": "它的規模如果變大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/155.wav", + "text": "輔導員的人數就跟著調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/156.wav", + "text": "好你看一下三個移工最多的直轄市分別是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/157.wav", + "text": "新北桃園臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/158.wav", + "text": "在106年三都訪查員人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/159.wav", + "text": "只有37位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/160.wav", + "text": "34位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/161.wav", + "text": "34位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/162.wav", + "text": "新��37" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/163.wav", + "text": "位桃園34" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/164.wav", + "text": "位臺中34" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/165.wav", + "text": "位人均服務量是兩千四百零多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/166.wav", + "text": "跟諮詢服務人員的人數增加速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/167.wav", + "text": "比不上移工增加的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/168.wav", + "text": "以桃園市為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/169.wav", + "text": "它雖然從34個增加到43個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/170.wav", + "text": "人力的速度遠遠落後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/171.wav", + "text": "各縣市移工增加的數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/172.wav", + "text": "跟涂委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/173.wav", + "text": "目前是訂在16號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/174.wav", + "text": "會邀集各地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/175.wav", + "text": "來檢討關於訪查員員額的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/176.wav", + "text": "剛才涂委員提醒的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/177.wav", + "text": "我會請部內的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/178.wav", + "text": "在檢討的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/179.wav", + "text": "我這邊也提醒部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/180.wav", + "text": "尤其大家現在對就安基金的使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/181.wav", + "text": "像這個應該補助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/182.wav", + "text": "我也提醒部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/183.wav", + "text": "應該針對這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/184.wav", + "text": "因為中央大開移工之門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/185.wav", + "text": "收了很多雇主的就業安定費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/186.wav", + "text": "大家對這個錢的使用都非常的關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/187.wav", + "text": "所以針對第一線的訪查人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/188.wav", + "text": "跟移工諮詢服務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/189.wav", + "text": "我們真的要多增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/190.wav", + "text": "你看移工諮詢服務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/191.wav", + "text": "桃園市的人均服務量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/192.wav", + "text": "他一個人要服務8007百多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/193.wav", + "text": "所以我們覺得逃逸移工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/194.wav", + "text": "對於這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/195.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們要好好去關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/196.wav", + "text": "因為我們覺得訪查員跟諮詢服務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/197.wav", + "text": "是逃逸移工的第一道防線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/198.wav", + "text": "這部分部長真的要幫忙重視一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/199.wav", + "text": "好沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/200.wav", + "text": "之前爆發霸凌的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/201.wav", + "text": "工作的績效壓力真的很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/202.wav", + "text": "而且我看洪部長也有公開承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/203.wav", + "text": "會向行政院爭取員額是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/204.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/205.wav", + "text": "我其實也有發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/206.wav", + "text": "目前勞發署整���的員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/207.wav", + "text": "甚至在正式人員跟約用人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/208.wav", + "text": "包括承攬之間的人數比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/209.wav", + "text": "我認為是不夠健康的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/210.wav", + "text": "執行的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/211.wav", + "text": "是比較容易出現風險的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/212.wav", + "text": "我有理解到這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/213.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/214.wav", + "text": "這部分我們當然希望跟行政院的人總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/215.wav", + "text": "總做更多的爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/216.wav", + "text": "所以我們真的要為勞發署的這些同仁發聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/217.wav", + "text": "他們真的應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/218.wav", + "text": "尤其最近我看他們的業務真的暴漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/219.wav", + "text": "來看針對我們國會的服務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/220.wav", + "text": "只有1位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/221.wav", + "text": "勞發署對我們國會的服務人員只有1位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/222.wav", + "text": "我們去查了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/223.wav", + "text": "它在108年前的編制是3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/224.wav", + "text": "現在勞發署對我們國會的業務人員只有1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/225.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得部長要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/226.wav", + "text": "幫我們關心瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/227.wav", + "text": "自己周邊的同仁要多關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/228.wav", + "text": "我也希望霸凌事件能夠減低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/229.wav", + "text": "因為同仁的工作壓力真的太大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/230.wav", + "text": "謝謝涂委員的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/231.wav", + "text": "請部長再多幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158030/232.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/0.wav", + "text": "跟部長分享一下臺南一個重要的交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/1.wav", + "text": "需要交通部來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/2.wav", + "text": "現在六都裡面唯一沒有捷運的就只有臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/3.wav", + "text": "就臺南市政府而言除了進度最快的藍線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/4.wav", + "text": "藍線是預計115年動工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/5.wav", + "text": "另外臺南市政府又規劃了綠線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/6.wav", + "text": "這條綠線為什麼非常重要呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/7.wav", + "text": "因為它是從高鐵站出發也就是沙崙區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/8.wav", + "text": "然後往北到南科" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/9.wav", + "text": "兩個都是高科技的重鎮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/10.wav", + "text": "沙崙因為它土地面積非常廣闊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/11.wav", + "text": "可以形成兩個最重要的高科技聚落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/12.wav", + "text": "中間我們用捷運綠線把它串聯起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/13.wav", + "text": "這條路線總工程經費大概871億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/14.wav", + "text": "現在它的期末報告已經完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/15.wav", + "text": "需要的就是綜合規劃的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/16.wav", + "text": "這個部分是不是請部長支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/17.wav", + "text": "臺南市捷運綠線的綜合規劃經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/18.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/19.wav", + "text": "這條路線其實我們也很支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/20.wav", + "text": "也覺得相當的重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/21.wav", + "text": "因為從科學園區一直要到高鐵站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/22.wav", + "text": "其實最快的路線會是這條線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/23.wav", + "text": "而不是目前看到的藍線延伸線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/24.wav", + "text": "那個等於繞了一圈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/25.wav", + "text": "目前可研的計畫還沒有送出來給我們審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/26.wav", + "text": "不是藍延線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/27.wav", + "text": "深綠線沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/28.wav", + "text": "它的可行性研究如果經過我們審查通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/29.wav", + "text": "綜合規劃的部分也沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/30.wav", + "text": "一定會來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/31.wav", + "text": "針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/32.wav", + "text": "綜合規劃經費也要請部長來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/33.wav", + "text": "因為它幾乎就是南科到高鐵最重要的路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/34.wav", + "text": "而且它經過南科附近的新市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/35.wav", + "text": "以及永康科技工業區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/36.wav", + "text": "然後再連接到高鐵附近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/37.wav", + "text": "的三井outlet等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/38.wav", + "text": "之後再到沙崙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/39.wav", + "text": "就是高鐵特區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/40.wav", + "text": "這個部分請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/41.wav", + "text": "另外剛剛有很多委員都在關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/42.wav", + "text": "郵輪旅遊的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/43.wav", + "text": "何欣純委員在講臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/44.wav", + "text": "其實全臺灣最慘的恐怕是安平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/45.wav", + "text": "安平去年沒有任何郵輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/46.wav", + "text": "去年就是臺中跟安平掛零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/47.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員沒有給你看這個表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/48.wav", + "text": "2023年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/49.wav", + "text": "臺灣只有三個國際港口沒有郵輪來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/50.wav", + "text": "就是臺中蘇澳安平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/51.wav", + "text": "臺中跟蘇澳有至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/52.wav", + "text": "安平一如預期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/53.wav", + "text": "你們去年就預測今年安平是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/54.wav", + "text": "我看交通部的預測很少這麼準確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/55.wav", + "text": "安平說零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/56.wav", + "text": "還真的就是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/57.wav", + "text": "一艘都沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/58.wav", + "text": "你預測明年一樣還是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/59.wav", + "text": "這樣我們怎麼受得了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/60.wav", + "text": "你要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/61.wav", + "text": "政府推郵輪旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/62.wav", + "text": "確實有成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/63.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/64.wav", + "text": "我們的郵輪旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/65.wav", + "text": "去年有327艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/66.wav", + "text": "今年預測有422艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/67.wav", + "text": "應該可以達成吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/68.wav", + "text": "可以達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/69.wav", + "text": "是高成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/70.wav", + "text": "明年預報到620艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/71.wav", + "text": "由今年的422艘到明年的620" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/72.wav", + "text": "艘成長了47%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/73.wav", + "text": "臺南都是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/74.wav", + "text": "針對臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/75.wav", + "text": "航港局也去做了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/76.wav", + "text": "碼頭的設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/77.wav", + "text": "我記得好像花了一億多吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/78.wav", + "text": "那不是多花的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/79.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/80.wav", + "text": "客人還沒來之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/81.wav", + "text": "四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/82.wav", + "text": "耶疫後四年預測都是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/83.wav", + "text": "硬體設備有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/84.wav", + "text": "我們就要努力對外去爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/85.wav", + "text": "所以我也拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/86.wav", + "text": "宣傳的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/87.wav", + "text": "尤其是比較少人來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/88.wav", + "text": "例如說安平港跟臺中港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/89.wav", + "text": "我們要特別去做宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/90.wav", + "text": "臺南好吃又好玩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/91.wav", + "text": "臺南現在大概是國內旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/92.wav", + "text": "啦我相信以臺南的特色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/93.wav", + "text": "來吸引國際觀光客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/94.wav", + "text": "是讓大家認識更真實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/95.wav", + "text": "更不一樣的臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/96.wav", + "text": "時都把安平跳過去嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/97.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/98.wav", + "text": "啦因為在去年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/99.wav", + "text": "名勝世界有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/100.wav", + "text": "沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/101.wav", + "text": "你寫的是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/102.wav", + "text": "就是有來高雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/103.wav", + "text": "我們也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/104.wav", + "text": "你把高雄當做安平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/105.wav", + "text": "你現在是在跟我說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/106.wav", + "text": "好吃好玩的安平也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/107.wav", + "text": "所以我那天特別去找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/108.wav", + "text": "船停在高雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/109.wav", + "text": "高雄有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/110.wav", + "text": "所以希望能夠拉到臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/111.wav", + "text": "我們的王總經理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/112.wav", + "text": "也有跟名勝世界談過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/113.wav", + "text": "耶我沒有否定你們推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/114.wav", + "text": "郵輪的成長績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/115.wav", + "text": "我有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/116.wav", + "text": "我剛剛也跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/117.wav", + "text": "確實有成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/118.wav", + "text": "但是你要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/119.wav", + "text": "更多國際旅客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/120.wav", + "text": "在臺灣更多不同的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/121.wav", + "text": "然後一起來推動觀光旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/122.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/123.wav", + "text": "部長你再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/124.wav", + "text": "這幾年都出國去考察郵輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/125.wav", + "text": "包括馬來西亞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/126.wav", + "text": "新加坡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/127.wav", + "text": "日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/128.wav", + "text": "美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/129.wav", + "text": "郵輪做得非常好的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/130.wav", + "text": "確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/131.wav", + "text": "帶回來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/132.wav", + "text": "我們也看到一些成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/133.wav", + "text": "再回去看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/134.wav", + "text": "臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/135.wav", + "text": "但1到10月還是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/136.wav", + "text": "可能是11月跟12月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/137.wav", + "text": "我不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/138.wav", + "text": "12月有一艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/139.wav", + "text": "如果臺中明年兩艘的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/140.wav", + "text": "明年大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/141.wav", + "text": "只有臺南還是持續掛零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/142.wav", + "text": "我們有特別到新加坡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/143.wav", + "text": "還有日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/144.wav", + "text": "一些名勝還有好玩的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/145.wav", + "text": "好吃的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/146.wav", + "text": "我們繼續努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/147.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/148.wav", + "text": "剛是不是有委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/149.wav", + "text": "隻停靠我們港口的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/150.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/151.wav", + "text": "既然這艘船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/152.wav", + "text": "有參與中國的演習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/153.wav", + "text": "而且他演習的想定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/154.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/155.wav", + "text": "演習都有一個想像的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/156.wav", + "text": "他演習的想定科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/157.wav", + "text": "就是類似木馬屠城" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/158.wav", + "text": "也就是特種部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/159.wav", + "text": "躲在民用船隻裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/160.wav", + "text": "就是這艘船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/161.wav", + "text": "演練的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/162.wav", + "text": "特種部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/163.wav", + "text": "躲在這樣的民用商船裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/164.wav", + "text": "然後突襲進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/165.wav", + "text": "對手的港口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/166.wav", + "text": "中國做這樣的演習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/167.wav", + "text": "對象一定是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/168.wav", + "text": "臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/169.wav", + "text": "它裡面一定經過改造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/170.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/171.wav", + "text": "像這艘船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/172.wav", + "text": "一定優先徵召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/173.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/174.wav", + "text": "因為他已經在這艘船上演練過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/175.wav", + "text": "可能有更動過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/176.wav", + "text": "而且也實際參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/177.wav", + "text": "像這種船到臺灣你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/178.wav", + "text": "你們事先有沒有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/179.wav", + "text": "你事先知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/180.wav", + "text": "商船要靠港必然要申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/181.wav", + "text": "它當時是有申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/182.wav", + "text": "所以我們當然知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/183.wav", + "text": "有這艘船要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/184.wav", + "text": "資訊上的落差就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/185.wav", + "text": "它曾經參加過軍演這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/186.wav", + "text": "跟航港局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/187.wav", + "text": "現在我們知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/188.wav", + "text": "因為這艘船2號就停到臺中港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/189.wav", + "text": "停到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/190.wav", + "text": "我們是不是應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/191.wav", + "text": "已經離港了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/192.wav", + "text": "那段期間你們知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/193.wav", + "text": "這艘船參與過這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/194.wav", + "text": "等它離開了才知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/195.wav", + "text": "整個過程其實我們不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/196.wav", + "text": "為什麼會造成這樣的落差呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/197.wav", + "text": "國防部知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/198.wav", + "text": "有沒有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/199.wav", + "text": "或許國防單位或國安單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/200.wav", + "text": "有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/201.wav", + "text": "假如有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/202.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/203.wav", + "text": "交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/204.wav", + "text": "這樣國安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/205.wav", + "text": "你應該去了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/206.wav", + "text": "不然這樣部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/207.wav", + "text": "間哪有聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/208.wav", + "text": "我們會在一週之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/209.wav", + "text": "跟國安單位開會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/210.wav", + "text": "討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/211.wav", + "text": "未來如果有類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/212.wav", + "text": "這樣的商船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/213.wav", + "text": "應該要怎麼處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/214.wav", + "text": "不要處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/215.wav", + "text": "商港法第58條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/216.wav", + "text": "規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/217.wav", + "text": "我們國家本來就有這樣的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/218.wav", + "text": "任何國家都會訂這樣的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/219.wav", + "text": "對於可疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/220.wav", + "text": "所謂的可疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/221.wav", + "text": "當然有很多種樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/222.wav", + "text": "本來我們就應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/223.wav", + "text": "有權力檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/224.wav", + "text": "而且登船檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/225.wav", + "text": "我們的法律寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/226.wav", + "text": "商港法第58條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/227.wav", + "text": "您在說的可疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/228.wav", + "text": "必須要國安單位提供給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/229.wav", + "text": "我們才會知道可疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/230.wav", + "text": "不然對我們來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/231.wav", + "text": "交通部所收到的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/232.wav", + "text": "是以商船的方式來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/233.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/234.wav", + "text": "我不管你這樣是不是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/235.wav", + "text": "在推卸責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/236.wav", + "text": "但至少就是你們相關部會之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/237.wav", + "text": "當然我們一個禮拜之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/238.wav", + "text": "會跟他們開會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/239.wav", + "text": "看未來這樣的訊息怎麼提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/240.wav", + "text": "也讓本席知道好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/241.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158029/242.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/0.wav", + "text": "我們請陳部長葉局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/1.wav", + "text": "還有港務公司李董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/2.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/3.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/4.wav", + "text": "大家都非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/5.wav", + "text": "曾經配合中共軍演的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/6.wav", + "text": "進入臺灣的港口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/7.wav", + "text": "我想今天大家都很關心臺中港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/8.wav", + "text": "等一下我再跟你討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/9.wav", + "text": "但國安的問題非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/10.wav", + "text": "臺中港是港務公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/11.wav", + "text": "也是交通部的港口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/12.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/13.wav", + "text": "這一艘貨船進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/14.wav", + "text": "臺灣港口的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/15.wav", + "text": "交通部事先知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/16.wav", + "text": "它當時一定都有申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/17.wav", + "text": "依法申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/18.wav", + "text": "但是是用民用船舶的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/19.wav", + "text": "是沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/20.wav", + "text": "在申請的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/21.wav", + "text": "你知道它曾經配合過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/22.wav", + "text": "中共軍演嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/23.wav", + "text": "你不知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/24.wav", + "text": "應該是不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/25.wav", + "text": "這一艘貨船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/26.wav", + "text": "曾經配合中共軍演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/27.wav", + "text": "演習當下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/28.wav", + "text": "曾經載了六艘突擊艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/29.wav", + "text": "而且重要的國安資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/30.wav", + "text": "是沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/31.wav", + "text": "但我們沒有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/32.wav", + "text": "這表示什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/33.wav", + "text": "我們事前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/34.wav", + "text": "並沒有相關機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/35.wav", + "text": "部長對不對對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/36.wav", + "text": "沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/37.wav", + "text": "是不是應該主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/38.wav", + "text": "跟軍方及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/39.wav", + "text": "我們事先有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/40.wav", + "text": "或者任何相關資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/41.wav", + "text": "做一個資訊交換的平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/42.wav", + "text": "我們是不是應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/43.wav", + "text": "這些可能帶來危險的船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/44.wav", + "text": "是委員你這樣的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/45.wav", + "text": "非常合理也是應該要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/46.wav", + "text": "過去確實我們的港務公司也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/47.wav", + "text": "不會有國安這一類的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/48.wav", + "text": "但是這件事情發生之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/49.wav", + "text": "讓我們覺得這方面的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/50.wav", + "text": "事先獲得會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/51.wav", + "text": "或者航港局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/52.wav", + "text": "要趕快跟國安單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/53.wav", + "text": "趕快開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/54.wav", + "text": "未來如果遇到類似狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/55.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣讓我們的航港局或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/56.wav", + "text": "事先可以獲知這樣的國安訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/57.wav", + "text": "要事先獲得國安訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/58.wav", + "text": "要事先掌握該船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/59.wav", + "text": "是不是曾經配合過中共軍演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/60.wav", + "text": "曾經載運過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/61.wav", + "text": "或者是相關的零組件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/62.wav", + "text": "它是依法用民用貨運船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/63.wav", + "text": "申請靠港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/64.wav", + "text": "對是這樣沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/65.wav", + "text": "那發生這件事情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/66.wav", + "text": "在網路平臺爆料了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/67.wav", + "text": "我們港務公司第一手知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/68.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/69.wav", + "text": "我們必須會同有公權力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/70.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有登船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/71.wav", + "text": "你剛剛回答其他委員的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/72.wav", + "text": "表示沒有登船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/73.wav", + "text": "是船東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/74.wav", + "text": "公司跟你們報備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/75.wav", + "text": "船裝運的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/76.wav", + "text": "最主要就是零組件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/77.wav", + "text": "都是一般的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/78.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/79.wav", + "text": "這是他們報備他們申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/80.wav", + "text": "那請問一下到底有沒有登船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/81.wav", + "text": "你說港務公司沒有權力登船檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/82.wav", + "text": "那到底是誰登船檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/83.wav", + "text": "哪一個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/84.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/85.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/86.wav", + "text": "那為什麼陸委會還可以說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/87.wav", + "text": "我們曾經登船檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/88.wav", + "text": "請問誰提供這個資訊給陸委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/89.wav", + "text": "誰提供資訊給陸委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/90.wav", + "text": "讓陸委會可以公開說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/91.wav", + "text": "政府相關單位已經於日前登檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/92.wav", + "text": "並沒有發現異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/93.wav", + "text": "我們可能需要了解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/94.wav", + "text": "我們的單位是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/95.wav", + "text": "但是海巡單位有沒有登船檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/96.wav", + "text": "這個我們可能要再了解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/97.wav", + "text": "所以事情發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/98.wav", + "text": "你們事前不知道沒有任何機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/99.wav", + "text": "見了媒體了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/100.wav", + "text": "也沒有任何機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/101.wav", + "text": "連港務公司都不知道是誰登船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/102.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/103.wav", + "text": "的港口管理太離譜了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/104.wav", + "text": "海巡單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/105.wav", + "text": "來請回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/106.wav", + "text": "按照我們現在的CIQS作業規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/107.wav", + "text": "船舶進出港海巡要登船做檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/108.wav", + "text": "目前的機制是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/109.wav", + "text": "好目前的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/110.wav", + "text": "你們什麼時候收到這個情資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/111.wav", + "text": "什麼時候登船檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/112.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/113.wav", + "text": "它進出港的第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/114.wav", + "text": "海巡就要登船檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/115.wav", + "text": "所以你現在的登船檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/116.wav", + "text": "是在它依法依程序的情況之下去做檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/117.wav", + "text": "而不是事後發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/118.wav", + "text": "有異常狀況的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/119.wav", + "text": "再一次去登船檢查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/120.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/121.wav", + "text": "不是是進港的時候就要檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/122.wav", + "text": "要登船檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/123.wav", + "text": "海巡署嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/124.wav", + "text": "海巡單位嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/125.wav", + "text": "如果有提供的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/126.wav", + "text": "應該是海巡單位提供給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/127.wav", + "text": "那我就要請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/128.wav", + "text": "了這裡出現一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/129.wav", + "text": "這個問題在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/130.wav", + "text": "陸委會對外公開發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/131.wav", + "text": "表示因為發現這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/132.wav", + "text": "這一次配合中共軍演的貨船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/133.wav", + "text": "進入臺中港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/134.wav", + "text": "所以我們有登檢該船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/135.wav", + "text": "沒有發現異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/136.wav", + "text": "他收到的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/137.wav", + "text": "是你們例行性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/138.wav", + "text": "而不是為了國安問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/139.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/140.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是前後邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/141.wav", + "text": "跟不同層次的國安問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/142.wav", + "text": "對沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/143.wav", + "text": "部長要趕快主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/144.wav", + "text": "跟國安單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/145.wav", + "text": "好好的把機制建立起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/146.wav", + "text": "我們當然不希望以後再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/147.wav", + "text": "類似事件可是我相信以中國對臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/148.wav", + "text": "一定會一而再再而三的試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/149.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/150.wav", + "text": "我們自己要先把港口安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/151.wav", + "text": "一定要先建立機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/152.wav", + "text": "能防堵就儘量防堵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/153.wav", + "text": "能夠不發生就不能發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/154.wav", + "text": "是我們會儘快跟國安單位協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/155.wav", + "text": "看看未來相關機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/156.wav", + "text": "我們會把它建置起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/157.wav", + "text": "是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/158.wav", + "text": "不然你看這艘船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/159.wav", + "text": "你們提供的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/160.wav", + "text": "12月2號晚上停靠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/161.wav", + "text": "12月3號卸貨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/162.wav", + "text": "12月6號又卸貨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/163.wav", + "text": "12月7號離港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/164.wav", + "text": "事實上它在臺中港停靠了幾個晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/165.wav", + "text": "從12月2號到12月7號離港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/166.wav", + "text": "喔這5天如果他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/167.wav", + "text": "船艙裡裝的是武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/168.wav", + "text": "裝的是什麼東西的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/169.wav", + "text": "這安全性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/170.wav", + "text": "問題如何對國人交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/171.wav", + "text": "我覺得要趕快好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/172.wav", + "text": "是我們會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/173.wav", + "text": "你可以跟國安單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/174.wav", + "text": "做一個橫向的溝通跟聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/175.wav", + "text": "我們一週之內會來跟他們開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/176.wav", + "text": "好一週之內趕快開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/177.wav", + "text": "趕快把SOP建立起來好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/178.wav", + "text": "\n臺中港另外一個問題是我非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/179.wav", + "text": "的也是剛剛很多委員非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/180.wav", + "text": "的就是臺中現在有空港跟海港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/181.wav", + "text": "空港我們非常感謝交通部的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/182.wav", + "text": "還有很多國籍航空公司的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/183.wav", + "text": "大增21條航線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/184.wav", + "text": "這在今年跟明年是可以期待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/185.wav", + "text": "在此我要先感謝交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/186.wav", + "text": "因為不管是航班航線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/187.wav", + "text": "還有航權等等相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/188.wav", + "text": "問���都是中央跟國籍公司努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/189.wav", + "text": "去跟對方國家談判而來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/190.wav", + "text": "我們希望好還要更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/191.wav", + "text": "但一樣都是港口卻兩樣情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/192.wav", + "text": "空港大增21條國際航線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/193.wav", + "text": "大家都說郵輪市場疫後大復甦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/194.wav", + "text": "可是問題是臺中看不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/195.wav", + "text": "啊包括港務公司去參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/196.wav", + "text": "或者是論壇也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/197.wav", + "text": "在你們提出的簡報裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/198.wav", + "text": "在港口的部分都沒有看到臺中港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/199.wav", + "text": "這表示什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/200.wav", + "text": "港務公司到底有沒有把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/201.wav", + "text": "臺中港放在心上努力來推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/202.wav", + "text": "郵輪市場不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/203.wav", + "text": "讓我們的國人出去玩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/204.wav", + "text": "我們也可以讓國際的觀光客進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/205.wav", + "text": "看見臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/206.wav", + "text": "臺中是一個很棒的城市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/207.wav", + "text": "臺中是全國第二大城市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/208.wav", + "text": "臺中有很多的觀光路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/209.wav", + "text": "跟好山好水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/210.wav", + "text": "但我覺得郵輪要進臺中港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/211.wav", + "text": "真的比搶周杰倫的門票還要難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/212.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/213.wav", + "text": "李董事長說未來會有三艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/214.wav", + "text": "董事長我要跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/215.wav", + "text": "你的資料可能要更新一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/216.wav", + "text": "12月18號確實會來一艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/217.wav", + "text": "接著明年也一艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/218.wav", + "text": "後年也一艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/219.wav", + "text": "你說的三艘是把今年的也算進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/220.wav", + "text": "是連續三年一年一艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/221.wav", + "text": "臺中可能只占了2個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/222.wav", + "text": "看起來臺中港真的還要再努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/223.wav", + "text": "對不對部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/224.wav", + "text": "報告委員這個要很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/225.wav", + "text": "要很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/226.wav", + "text": "硬體設備有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/227.wav", + "text": "然後臺中也真的很好玩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/228.wav", + "text": "整個中部地區的觀光景點相當的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/229.wav", + "text": "我們希望透過郵輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/230.wav", + "text": "可以吸引更多的國外旅客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/231.wav", + "text": "但目前確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/232.wav", + "text": "港務公司在國外招商的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/233.wav", + "text": "我們把臺灣幾個重要的港口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/234.wav", + "text": "國際航商來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/235.wav", + "text": "結果大家最後選擇臺中相對是少一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/236.wav", + "text": "我希望針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/237.wav", + "text": "我們再更加把勁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/238.wav", + "text": "部長那可不可以討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/239.wav", + "text": "為什麼國際航商沒有選擇臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/240.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/241.wav", + "text": "地方政府的某一個局長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/242.wav", + "text": "因為高雄港跟基隆港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/243.wav", + "text": "他們躺著就會有郵輪進港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/244.wav", + "text": "相對的好像臺中港是沒人愛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/245.wav", + "text": "究竟沒人愛的問題在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/246.wav", + "text": "條件真的那麼差嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/247.wav", + "text": "在幫忙招攬客人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/248.wav", + "text": "下了船之後的旅遊動線等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/249.wav", + "text": "他們都有做很棒的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/250.wav", + "text": "臺中這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/251.wav", + "text": "其實也可以再更努力一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/252.wav", + "text": "啦這個還是要中央地方一起加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/253.wav", + "text": "但也不是只有中央的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/254.wav", + "text": "而是大家要一起努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/255.wav", + "text": "港區的建設我想你一定會支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/256.wav", + "text": "尤其臺中的消費力強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/257.wav", + "text": "產業也非常完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/258.wav", + "text": "而且非常的強壯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/259.wav", + "text": "所以我們要建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/260.wav", + "text": "我們有去臺中港區考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/261.wav", + "text": "B1站或是跟港務公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/262.wav", + "text": "共同開發的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/263.wav", + "text": "跟蔡其昌委員要共同推進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/264.wav", + "text": "臺中港區其他的大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/265.wav", + "text": "一定要大力的支持好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158028/266.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席有請交通部陳部長航港局葉局長跟港務公司李董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/1.wav", + "text": "首先第一個問題剛剛很多委員都問過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/2.wav", + "text": "榮耀號最多可以載500多個客戶可以講說是我們疫情復甦之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/3.wav", + "text": "以臺灣作為母港的一個非常重要的遊艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/4.wav", + "text": "現在的情況就是4號出發的這一團郵輪在6號就故障了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/5.wav", + "text": "我先問一下部長你是幾號知道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/6.wav", + "text": "昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/7.wav", + "text": "昨天嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/8.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/9.wav", + "text": "昨天是7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/10.wav", + "text": "昨天是8號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/11.wav", + "text": "部長兩天之後知道你什麼時候知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/12.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們是7號晚上知道那我們跟港務公司就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/13.wav", + "text": "7號晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/14.wav", + "text": "7號晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/15.wav", + "text": "對我們跟港務公司就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/16.wav", + "text": "好這個是在昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/17.wav", + "text": "榮耀號船上的廣播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/18.wav", + "text": "播\n好這是昨天說的至少待到週一之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/19.wav", + "text": "可是剛剛部長說的顯然沒有這麼簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/20.wav", + "text": "大概可以多載七百零多人回國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/21.wav", + "text": "現在那邊有一千八百多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/22.wav", + "text": "除了零星走的我們大概知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/23.wav", + "text": "大概還有1,100位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/24.wav", + "text": "現在遇到一個情況是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/25.wav", + "text": "他們是不是跟航港局這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/26.wav", + "text": "局長他們說不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/27.wav", + "text": "就算船預計10號修好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/28.wav", + "text": "但他要空船回來是還是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/29.wav", + "text": "你們聽到的消息是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/30.wav", + "text": "報告委員這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/31.wav", + "text": "我們有強烈的跟船方表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/32.wav", + "text": "一定要做好妥適的安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/33.wav", + "text": "我們不允許他以空船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/34.wav", + "text": "回到基隆港的這種作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/35.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分已經強烈的跟船代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/36.wav", + "text": "代船方來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/37.wav", + "text": "我知道你們今天要開緊急會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/38.wav", + "text": "但是今天已經是6號之後的第3天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/39.wav", + "text": "我們在處理這個問題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/40.wav", + "text": "我們真的希望能夠快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/41.wav", + "text": "我也看到榮耀號他們整體公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/42.wav", + "text": "我們覺得他們基本上還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/43.wav", + "text": "以一種負責任的態度在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/44.wav", + "text": "要怪誰或罵人我覺得也不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/45.wav", + "text": "但知道這個訊息之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/46.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/47.wav", + "text": "如果10號他的船要開回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/48.wav", + "text": "我就有兩個疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/49.wav", + "text": "第一個疑問是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/50.wav", + "text": "我們現在飛機不夠載的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/51.wav", + "text": "到明天如果只能載七百零多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/52.wav", + "text": "還有一千多人怎麼辦住哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/53.wav", + "text": "或者他坐什麼飛機回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/54.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/55.wav", + "text": "\n第二個如果船修好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/56.wav", + "text": "為什麼他不載日本的旅客回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/57.wav", + "text": "這是雙母港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/58.wav", + "text": "他就是載日本的客人來臺灣旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/59.wav", + "text": "到底發生了什麼事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/60.wav", + "text": "簡單來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/61.wav", + "text": "我覺得航港局跟港務公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/62.wav", + "text": "司要非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/63.wav", + "text": "而且不要再編故事講真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/64.wav", + "text": "既然負責任就講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/65.wav", + "text": "訂到過年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/66.wav", + "text": "過年一班一班五天一班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/67.wav", + "text": "8號的2,100人上不去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/68.wav", + "text": "再來12號呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/69.wav", + "text": "到底可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/70.wav", + "text": "你們會不會想這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/71.wav", + "text": "當然部長說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/72.wav", + "text": "他要負責通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/73.wav", + "text": "啊可是你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/74.wav", + "text": "但我是沒看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/75.wav", + "text": "報告委員今年跟明年的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/76.wav", + "text": "看起來明年會成長不少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/77.wav", + "text": "對我們現在看到是這樣在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/78.wav", + "text": "疫情之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/79.wav", + "text": "搭乘郵輪來的國外旅客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/80.wav", + "text": "大概105萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/81.wav", + "text": "人次當然最低是111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/82.wav", + "text": "差不多到100多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/83.wav", + "text": "大概預估可以到9293萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/84.wav", + "text": "這是你們給我的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/85.wav", + "text": "明年會更高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/86.wav", + "text": "所以看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/87.wav", + "text": "我們今年原本預估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/88.wav", + "text": "國外旅客來臺1,200萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/89.wav", + "text": "雖然沒有辦法達標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/90.wav", + "text": "可能是七八百萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/91.wav", + "text": "可是我們在郵輪這個領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/92.wav", + "text": "部長你怎麼看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/93.wav", + "text": "未來這是我們爭取國外旅客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/94.wav", + "text": "一個非常重要的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/95.wav", + "text": "就是透過郵輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/96.wav", + "text": "所以我們在各個港口的建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/97.wav", + "text": "要把硬體先建好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/98.wav", + "text": "在客人還沒來之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/99.wav", + "text": "硬體要先做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/100.wav", + "text": "那我們歡迎客人來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/101.wav", + "text": "關於這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/102.wav", + "text": "我們的港務公司也積極在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/103.wav", + "text": "郵輪展的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/104.wav", + "text": "都會儘量去遊說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/105.wav", + "text": "其他國家的郵輪可以來到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/106.wav", + "text": "好所以我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/107.wav", + "text": "不管是港務公司航港局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/108.wav", + "text": "你們要更精確的更專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/109.wav", + "text": "我們不懂船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/110.wav", + "text": "可是旅客就是旅遊嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/111.wav", + "text": "我們很多的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/112.wav", + "text": "好不容易招攬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/113.wav", + "text": "遇到一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/114.wav", + "text": "第一個我們要儘量提早知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/115.wav", + "text": "要擬定一些方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/116.wav", + "text": "不管是國人在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/117.wav", + "text": "是不是要有接駁的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/118.wav", + "text": "再下一批的旅客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/119.wav", + "text": "到底什麼時候可以恢復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/120.wav", + "text": "我覺得政府要精準掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/121.wav", + "text": "不然像業者也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/122.wav", + "text": "或者旅客會打電話到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/123.wav", + "text": "我們的公務機關來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/124.wav", + "text": "我們如果是3個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/125.wav", + "text": "不清楚不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/126.wav", + "text": "我覺得是不行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/127.wav", + "text": "因為這個事情我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/128.wav", + "text": "能夠最有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/129.wav", + "text": "未來到底什麼時候可以載客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/130.wav", + "text": "也希望提前可以了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/131.wav", + "text": "\n這個數據出來我擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/132.wav", + "text": "大家恢復用郵輪出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/133.wav", + "text": "這樣的旅遊模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/134.wav", + "text": "看到一批一批幾千人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/135.wav", + "text": "其實國人參與度滿高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/136.wav", + "text": "跟信心的建立是不太容易的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/137.wav", + "text": "可是如果產生了很多隱憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/138.wav", + "text": "坐上去之後哇搞不好多送3天5天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/139.wav", + "text": "大家不要覺得很快樂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/140.wav", + "text": "當然上面有吃的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/141.wav", + "text": "我們直接電話聯絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/142.wav", + "text": "他們基本上要留在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/143.wav", + "text": "那個船艙裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/144.wav", + "text": "為什麼呢就是行李包好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/145.wav", + "text": "全部包好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/146.wav", + "text": "一喊嗶嗶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/147.wav", + "text": "就要全部衝出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/148.wav", + "text": "做下一個動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/149.wav", + "text": "所以他們精神壓力很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/150.wav", + "text": "滿多人有事要回來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/151.wav", + "text": "因此我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/152.wav", + "text": "最後100多人包機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/153.wav", + "text": "沖繩的機場做申請了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/154.wav", + "text": "他們也同意我們要坐加班機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/155.wav", + "text": "我們看今天可不可以上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/156.wav", + "text": "或者是明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/157.wav", + "text": "加班機可以趕快上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/158.wav", + "text": "明天跟後天都一定要趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/159.wav", + "text": "把我們的旅客全部輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/160.wav", + "text": "都要出任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/161.wav", + "text": "啊現在有沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/162.wav", + "text": "他們有幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/163.wav", + "text": "華航的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/164.wav", + "text": "我知道他們都有幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/165.wav", + "text": "對到時候包機的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/166.wav", + "text": "我們現在已經有申請到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/167.wav", + "text": "加班機的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/168.wav", + "text": "我們會跟我們國籍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/169.wav", + "text": "航空公司來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/170.wav", + "text": "看誰可以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/171.wav", + "text": "就儘量上這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/172.wav", + "text": "這個最好是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/173.wav", + "text": "啦因為你如果沒有密集的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/174.wav", + "text": "載回來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/175.wav", + "text": "會產生先後次序的剝奪感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/176.wav", + "text": "我真的不騙你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/177.wav", + "text": "最大尾就全部都走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/178.wav", + "text": "剩下一些人在後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/179.wav", + "text": "我是覺得只要密集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/180.wav", + "text": "的我們就同一天的早晚班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/181.wav", + "text": "或者明天早班機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/182.wav", + "text": "大家都可以忍耐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/183.wav", + "text": "不然這個部分屬於很多家旅行社" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/184.wav", + "text": "我知道有些旅行社" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/185.wav", + "text": "比較有議價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/186.wav", + "text": "他們全部跑完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/187.wav", + "text": "最晚明天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/188.wav", + "text": "一定要把我們的國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/189.wav", + "text": "除非航港局協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/190.wav", + "text": "他的船10號回來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/191.wav", + "text": "在船上的國人都可以載回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/192.wav", + "text": "所以你們要非常密切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/193.wav", + "text": "而且非常迅速找出答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/194.wav", + "text": "有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/195.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/196.wav", + "text": "委員這個我們來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/197.wav", + "text": "好稍等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/198.wav", + "text": "接著這個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/199.wav", + "text": "既然郵輪是在復甦的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/200.wav", + "text": "我就提一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/201.wav", + "text": "當然我們現在有很多港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/202.wav", + "text": "但主要目前我們看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/203.wav", + "text": "郵輪去年今年的旅客來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/204.wav", + "text": "它停泊的港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/205.wav", + "text": "在基隆港跟高雄港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/206.wav", + "text": "人數分別是第一名第二名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/207.wav", + "text": "但是我們看人數上的差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/208.wav", + "text": "基隆港大概平均是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/209.wav", + "text": "1年80萬人次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/210.wav", + "text": "高雄港現在大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/211.wav", + "text": "8萬到9萬人次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/212.wav", + "text": "大概是9到10倍的差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/213.wav", + "text": "其實很好理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/214.wav", + "text": "啦因為船不是載出去海上釣魚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/215.wav", + "text": "是停到下一個接近的城市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/216.wav", + "text": "可能日本韓國比較多城市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/217.wav", + "text": "兩岸如果交流的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/218.wav", + "text": "搞不好臺中港人最多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/219.wav", + "text": "坦白講現在不講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/220.wav", + "text": "不過現在有個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/221.wav", + "text": "現在的趨勢你們都看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/222.wav", + "text": "了船越造越大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/223.wav", + "text": "本來一艘船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/224.wav", + "text": "現在變成一個城市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/225.wav", + "text": "它進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/226.wav", + "text": "500多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/227.wav", + "text": "等於我們的幾棟大樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/228.wav", + "text": "一個小城市它進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/229.wav", + "text": "所有人下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/230.wav", + "text": "其實在歐洲我們常看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/231.wav", + "text": "我們也了解一些資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/232.wav", + "text": "榮耀號在歐洲這樣一個量體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/233.wav", + "text": "大概平均2個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/234.wav", + "text": "不可能一次進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/235.wav", + "text": "嘛大概2個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/236.wav", + "text": "可以讓他們分次進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/237.wav", + "text": "可是目前在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/238.wav", + "text": "我們目前基隆東岸西岸都已經完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/239.wav", + "text": "可以同時容納4艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/240.wav", + "text": "所以目前我們都在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/241.wav", + "text": "目前也在整修當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/242.wav", + "text": "我做個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/243.wav", + "text": "結論就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/244.wav", + "text": "我們講說疫情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/245.wav", + "text": "希望你們建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/246.wav", + "text": "我也看到你們有努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/247.wav", + "text": "把沒有自動通關閘道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/248.wav", + "text": "在基隆港總共東西岸各4個閘道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/249.wav", + "text": "可是問題現在你要注意一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/250.wav", + "text": "尤其是西岸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/251.wav", + "text": "西岸的部分因為它的水深" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/252.wav", + "text": "所以像剛剛講的這種城市級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/253.wav", + "text": "那種大的遊艇都從這邊來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/254.wav", + "text": "大家到了臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/255.wav", + "text": "都想要第一時間下來去旅遊嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/256.wav", + "text": "大家一下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/257.wav", + "text": "現在是東岸4個自動閘道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/258.wav", + "text": "西岸4個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/259.wav", + "text": "顯然對這種密集性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/260.wav", + "text": "目前我個人是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/261.wav", + "text": "以基隆現在這個吞吐量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/262.wav", + "text": "做了4個雙向的閘道很有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/263.wav", + "text": "進來出去也可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/264.wav", + "text": "這種我覺得真的很棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/265.wav", + "text": "而且對於大家來到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/266.wav", + "text": "覺得這個郵輪城市很棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/267.wav", + "text": "很棒就可以通關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/268.wav", + "text": "不要讓大家評估說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/269.wav", + "text": "來到臺灣的郵輪最慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/270.wav", + "text": "這個部分是不是建議部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/271.wav", + "text": "你們怎麼喬得預算我不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/272.wav", + "text": "最後是港務公司航港局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/273.wav", + "text": "當然你也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/274.wav", + "text": "這是移民署的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/275.wav", + "text": "內政部的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/276.wav", + "text": "其他人的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/277.wav", + "text": "觀光人數是交通部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/278.wav", + "text": "港務公司也是交通部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/279.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分是不是可以從西岸開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/280.wav", + "text": "空間都出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/281.wav", + "text": "至少可以再設六到八個閘道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/282.wav", + "text": "錢也沒有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/283.wav", + "text": "能不能儘快幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/284.wav", + "text": "旅客人數確實在基隆港非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/285.wav", + "text": "閘口也是必然要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/286.wav", + "text": "所以我們會請港務公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/287.wav", + "text": "大概一個小時可以通關3,100人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/288.wav", + "text": "所以像地中海榮耀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/289.wav", + "text": "號就停靠在西岸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/290.wav", + "text": "現在移民署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/291.wav", + "text": "還有很多旅行社" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/292.wav", + "text": "都已經提出這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/293.wav", + "text": "你知道靠岸後在外面會有一堆人要去接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/294.wav", + "text": "但它的遊覽車第一臺到最後一臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/295.wav", + "text": "搭不在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/296.wav", + "text": "很多的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/297.wav", + "text": "所以我要拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/298.wav", + "text": "部長旅遊市場有這樣的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/299.wav", + "text": "我們就努力來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/300.wav", + "text": "更多雙向通關閘道的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/301.wav", + "text": "跟經費來源好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/302.wav", + "text": "一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158027/303.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席請主席邀請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/1.wav", + "text": "還有董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/2.wav", + "text": "部長早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/3.wav", + "text": "本席在這邊首先也要關心一下榮耀號郵輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/4.wav", + "text": "今年首度以基隆港為母港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/5.wav", + "text": "採取基隆─那霸雙母港的模式營運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/6.wav", + "text": "搭載了4,000名的旅客從基隆出發之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/7.wav", + "text": "本來是去日本幾個景點遊玩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/8.wav", + "text": "所以導致目前這些旅客都還滯留在那霸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/9.wav", + "text": "霸剛剛也有很多委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/10.wav", + "text": "我個人也是覺得稍微慢了一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/11.wav", + "text": "因為很多旅客如果遇到這種狀況真的是非常掃興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/12.wav", + "text": "所以在這個部分你們應該要盡力給予完善的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/13.wav", + "text": "可是8號又有一個航次要出發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/14.wav", + "text": "很多旅客是到了基隆港要報到的時候才知道航次取消了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/15.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分好像也是又慢了半拍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/16.wav", + "text": "報告委員這個部分我們跟船公司也都協商過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/17.wav", + "text": "船公司其實事先的宣導有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/18.wav", + "text": "他們也有跟旅客聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/19.wav", + "text": "儘量確保大部分的旅客都有聯繫到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/20.wav", + "text": "但必然有一些沒有聯繫到的他們也都有派人在基隆港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/21.wav", + "text": "也就是說有旅客沒有接到訊息所以來到基隆港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/22.wav", + "text": "那他們就要跟他解釋解說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/23.wav", + "text": "這個部分其實我們在第一時間都有要求船公司必須要做這些動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/24.wav", + "text": "我想不是短期決定的一定也是經過長期的籌劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/25.wav", + "text": "有可能三個月或半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/26.wav", + "text": "然後整個行程都泡湯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/27.wav", + "text": "所以我想之後在旅客權益的部分還有善後的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/28.wav", + "text": "我們也希望交通部這邊要給予旅客最大的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/29.wav", + "text": "當然在一開始我們就跟船公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/30.wav", + "text": "還有旅行社講過旅客的權益是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/31.wav", + "text": "對旅客也做了說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/32.wav", + "text": "後續回來臺灣之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/33.wav", + "text": "如果還有需要求償或者是需要船公司補償的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/34.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們會協助來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/35.wav", + "text": "不曉得還有其他郵輪以臺灣的港口為母港嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/36.wav", + "text": "應該蠻多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/37.wav", + "text": "是不是請港務公司說明好不好蠻多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/38.wav", + "text": "還有明年的4月5號116年的1月8號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/39.wav", + "text": "在臺中有三艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/40.wav", + "text": "都是哪一個國籍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/41.wav", + "text": "哪一個國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/42.wav", + "text": "我們知道榮耀號是瑞士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/43.wav", + "text": "還要再查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/44.wav", + "text": "還要再查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/45.wav", + "text": "是那就是陸續都有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/46.wav", + "text": "現在就是臺中本來都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/47.wav", + "text": "我們努力後已經有三艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/48.wav", + "text": "花蓮明年也有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/49.wav", + "text": "是好我想這也是一個好消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/50.wav", + "text": "可以讓我們的國人在旅遊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/51.wav", + "text": "希望強化臺灣成為亞洲航運的中心嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/52.wav", + "text": "是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/53.wav", + "text": "是在貨運的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/54.wav", + "text": "我們希望臺灣能夠成為航運中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/55.wav", + "text": "貨運的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/56.wav", + "text": "臺灣就是整個亞太地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/57.wav", + "text": "地理位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/58.wav", + "text": "也是一個戰略位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/59.wav", + "text": "前幾天也發生一個事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/60.wav", + "text": "中共軍演的香港貨船停靠臺中港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/61.wav", + "text": "對於這樣子的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/62.wav", + "text": "我不曉得部長這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/63.wav", + "text": "有掌握這個訊息嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/64.wav", + "text": "掌握這個訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/65.wav", + "text": "這艘船也已經離開臺中港了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/66.wav", + "text": "第7條的規定讓它合法停靠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/67.wav", + "text": "當時是給它合法停靠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/68.wav", + "text": "但現在大家在討論這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/69.wav", + "text": "我認為這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/70.wav", + "text": "我們應該要去洽國安單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/71.wav", + "text": "跟國安單位來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/72.wav", + "text": "如果未來有參加過解放軍演習的船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/73.wav", + "text": "如果不適合停靠在臺灣的港口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/74.wav", + "text": "那這個部分或許要進行修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/75.wav", + "text": "因為中共對我們臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/76.wav", + "text": "一直在文攻武嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/77.wav", + "text": "所以我們也要有防範的心理準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/78.wav", + "text": "所以我再請問一下我們讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/79.wav", + "text": "登船去做檢查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/80.wav", + "text": "有登船檢查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/81.wav", + "text": "這個可以說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/82.wav", + "text": "它在進港的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/83.wav", + "text": "有跟我們報備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/84.wav", + "text": "目前查出來就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/85.wav", + "text": "它主要是以零件為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/86.wav", + "text": "零件為主的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/87.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/88.wav", + "text": "所以我們沒有登船檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/89.wav", + "text": "我們只是書面檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/90.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/91.wav", + "text": "是船代他提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/92.wav", + "text": "所以這樣子真的是非常危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/93.wav", + "text": "萬一他真的裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/94.wav", + "text": "有藏了什麼武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/95.wav", + "text": "那這個真的是一個很大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/96.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/97.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/98.wav", + "text": "我們真的還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/99.wav", + "text": "是要有一個防範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/100.wav", + "text": "心理準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/101.wav", + "text": "報告委員這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/102.wav", + "text": "確實如果大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/103.wav", + "text": "未來應該要更嚴格檢視的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/104.wav", + "text": "我們會跟國安單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/105.wav", + "text": "討論這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/106.wav", + "text": "如果國安單位那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/107.wav", + "text": "也認為未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/108.wav", + "text": "針對這一類的船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/109.wav", + "text": "必須要做不一樣的檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/110.wav", + "text": "那我們就會做不一樣的檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/111.wav", + "text": "對我覺得這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/112.wav", + "text": "一定是要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/113.wav", + "text": "再來最後一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/114.wav", + "text": "智慧航安這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/115.wav", + "text": "很重要的一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/116.wav", + "text": "中有一個我國智慧航安服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/117.wav", + "text": "總經費是19億3,457萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/118.wav", + "text": "智慧航安的服務升級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/119.wav", + "text": "升級明年114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/120.wav", + "text": "智慧航安2.0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/121.wav", + "text": "有什麼更精進的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/122.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/123.wav", + "text": "特別跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/124.wav", + "text": "2.0的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/125.wav", + "text": "第一個重點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/126.wav", + "text": "我們要擴大我們的VTS" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/127.wav", + "text": "把現在的673平方公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/128.wav", + "text": "大幅增加到4,000平方公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/129.wav", + "text": "依照能源局的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/130.wav", + "text": "會大幅增加風場的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/131.wav", + "text": "為了確保航安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/132.wav", + "text": "我們要把整個監控的範圍擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/133.wav", + "text": "\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/134.wav", + "text": "全球海上遇險系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/135.wav", + "text": "（GMDSS" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/136.wav", + "text": "）這個涉及到我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/137.wav", + "text": "整個臺灣周邊海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/138.wav", + "text": "衛星搜救系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/139.wav", + "text": "我們必須要跟國際一起升級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/140.wav", + "text": "\n另外我們要加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/141.wav", + "text": "我們VTS的備援系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/142.wav", + "text": "這個VTS我們就把它當作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/143.wav", + "text": "一個關鍵基礎設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/144.wav", + "text": "如果有狀況的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/145.wav", + "text": "備援系統一定要能夠馬上接得起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/146.wav", + "text": "所以要強化我們航安的韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/147.wav", + "text": "航標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/148.wav", + "text": "航路標識管理系統的建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/149.wav", + "text": "我們要掌握全國的航路標識管理系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/150.wav", + "text": "能夠有效的進行監督跟管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/151.wav", + "text": "智慧航安推動辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/152.wav", + "text": "這部分目前的進度如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/153.wav", + "text": "透過公開招標的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/154.wav", + "text": "由海大的專業團隊進駐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/155.wav", + "text": "來協助我們共同來推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/156.wav", + "text": "已經成立了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/157.wav", + "text": "我們也都要與時俱進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/158.wav", + "text": "郵輪的航行安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/159.wav", + "text": "或者是貨運的航行安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/160.wav", + "text": "都能夠得到一個更大的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/161.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/162.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158026/163.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席是不是有請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/1.wav", + "text": "有請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/2.wav", + "text": "洪部長你知不知道此時此刻勞動部前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/3.wav", + "text": "有勞團有勞工朋友在那邊絕食抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/4.wav", + "text": "知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/5.wav", + "text": "那你知道他們的訴求是什麼嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/6.wav", + "text": "有針對就安基金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/7.wav", + "text": "講得模糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/8.wav", + "text": "其中一個就是跟過勞的問題有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/9.wav", + "text": "勞工的訴求很清楚就是要恢復國定的七天假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/10.wav", + "text": "而且也希望提高加班費費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/11.wav", + "text": "我就問洪部長請問你對這兩個議題是支持還是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/12.wav", + "text": "跟王委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/13.wav", + "text": "第一我當然支持要降低勞工在工時上面的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/14.wav", + "text": "你直接回答因為本席也發現你的回答都是有點避重就輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/15.wav", + "text": "然後沒有直接針對問題具體明白的回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/16.wav", + "text": "復勞團也發現你這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/17.wav", + "text": "對於國定假日的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/18.wav", + "text": "你贊不贊成恢復國定的七天假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/19.wav", + "text": "贊成或反對就這樣就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/20.wav", + "text": "跟王委員說明對於國定假日的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/21.wav", + "text": "我們希望能把勞工的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/22.wav", + "text": "不是勞工的聲音你勞動部要先有立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/23.wav", + "text": "你到底支不支持恢復國定的七天假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/24.wav", + "text": "你回答不出來不敢回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/25.wav", + "text": "那你就回答支持還是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/26.wav", + "text": "王委員我不是不敢回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/27.wav", + "text": "我現在說的事情是我們當然希望降低工時的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/28.wav", + "text": "在各種作法上我們都可以看哪些部分能夠做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/29.wav", + "text": "部長你就是繞來繞去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/30.wav", + "text": "不敢直接回答問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/31.wav", + "text": "這個也是勞團已經發現的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/32.wav", + "text": "就是你都沒有正面回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/33.wav", + "text": "桃總就批評你們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/34.wav", + "text": "在砍國定假日的時候勞動部當時是站上第一線支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/35.wav", + "text": "現在要增加國定假日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/36.wav", + "text": "結果勞動部說跟我沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/37.wav", + "text": "你從剛剛的回答到現在你都是推給內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/38.wav", + "text": "我沒有說跟我沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/39.wav", + "text": "那你贊成還是反對總要有個立場吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/40.wav", + "text": "洪部長勇敢一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/41.wav", + "text": "王委員我要向你說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/42.wav", + "text": "這件事情涉及到跨部會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/43.wav", + "text": "到底是贊成恢復國定七天假還是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/44.wav", + "text": "我們會把現在勞工朋友的聲音跟期待反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/45.wav", + "text": "部長你就是不敢回答問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/46.wav", + "text": "這個就是我看到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/47.wav", + "text": "如果我們換了一個洪部長上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/48.wav", + "text": "標榜說他是跟基層勞工比較接近的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/49.wav", + "text": "會為弱勢發聲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/50.wav", + "text": "結果在關鍵議題上面不敢表態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/51.wav", + "text": "第二個問題提高加班費的費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/52.wav", + "text": "你贊成還是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/53.wav", + "text": "我們當然希望能夠盡力的爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/54.wav", + "text": "所以是贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/55.wav", + "text": "為什麼贊成反對都回答不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/56.wav", + "text": "當你支持的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/57.wav", + "text": "就是帶領全國的勞工再往前進往前推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/58.wav", + "text": "回答模稜兩可不敢表達你的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/59.wav", + "text": "你真的是跟勞工站在一起嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/60.wav", + "text": "還是你現在必須聽命行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/61.wav", + "text": "必須聽命經濟部跟內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/62.wav", + "text": "只要各部會部長反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/63.wav", + "text": "作為勞動部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/64.wav", + "text": "你只好跟著他們的王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/65.wav", + "text": "這並不是聽命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/66.wav", + "text": "第一個這並不是聽命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/67.wav", + "text": "那你要有主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/68.wav", + "text": "我們當然有一個方向上的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/69.wav", + "text": "那到底是贊成還是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/70.wav", + "text": "確實這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/71.wav", + "text": "如果涉及到跨部會的權責的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/72.wav", + "text": "我們當然是盡力來反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/73.wav", + "text": "洪部長所有的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/74.wav", + "text": "都是你要先有立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/75.wav", + "text": "你要有主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/76.wav", + "text": "才可以去跟人家談判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/77.wav", + "text": "所以我們要把這樣的聲音給表達出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/78.wav", + "text": "所以你贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/79.wav", + "text": "我可以說你贊成恢復國定七天假嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/80.wav", + "text": "我們會把相關勞工的聲音給反映出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/81.wav", + "text": "再這樣模稜兩可下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/82.wav", + "text": "我覺得你當不了勞動部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/83.wav", + "text": "太軟弱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/84.wav", + "text": "我必須這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/85.wav", + "text": "沒有立場不夠堅定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/86.wav", + "text": "你要如何捍衛勞工的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/87.wav", + "text": "這是我請洪部長要好好去思考的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/88.wav", + "text": "不是推給其他部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/89.wav", + "text": "我們沒有推給其他部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/90.wav", + "text": "我們就是把勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/91.wav", + "text": "從勞工角度的聲音要反映出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/92.wav", + "text": "當你站穩了你的立場和主張之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/93.wav", + "text": "你才可以去跟其他的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/94.wav", + "text": "人家一問勞動部部長的主張是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/95.wav", + "text": "沒有主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/96.wav", + "text": "沒有主張當然就順著內政部部長的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/97.wav", + "text": "哪這個是我要講的第一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/98.wav", + "text": "因為現在我們的勞工工時過長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/99.wav", + "text": "如果你上任一樣提不出解方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/100.wav", + "text": "你不敢站在勞工的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/101.wav", + "text": "勞工已經提出他們的解方就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/102.wav", + "text": "結果你不敢去支持的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/103.wav", + "text": "沒有最高還會更高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/104.wav", + "text": "你看到從112年到114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/105.wav", + "text": "都還是在繼續成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/106.wav", + "text": "\n第二件事情我要問你的關鍵態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/107.wav", + "text": "勞保終究是會破產的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/108.wav", + "text": "不改革終究是會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/109.wav", + "text": "結果上個禮拜你呼應了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/110.wav", + "text": "上一任何佩珊的論點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/111.wav", + "text": "說撥補就是改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/112.wav", + "text": "你說你贊成撥補就是改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/113.wav", + "text": "那我就問洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/114.wav", + "text": "既然撥補就是改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/115.wav", + "text": "請問你要撥補多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/116.wav", + "text": "才不會讓勞保破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/117.wav", + "text": "跟王委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/118.wav", + "text": "撥補只是手段之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/119.wav", + "text": "這幾年基金的投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/120.wav", + "text": "投資有賺有賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/121.wav", + "text": "對也很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/122.wav", + "text": "但我要提的事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/123.wav", + "text": "政府終究會負最終的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/124.wav", + "text": "好那你是不是支持讓最終責任入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/125.wav", + "text": "不管入法或不入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/126.wav", + "text": "政府都會負最終的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/127.wav", + "text": "既然是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/128.wav", + "text": "修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/129.wav", + "text": "現在的政策就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/130.wav", + "text": "政府會負最終支付的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/131.wav", + "text": "因為現在的政府會換人會下臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/132.wav", + "text": "不可能是空口白話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/133.wav", + "text": "就必須入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/134.wav", + "text": "全國勞工才有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/135.wav", + "text": "那你支不支持最終責任入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/136.wav", + "text": "我覺得我自己是正向的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/137.wav", + "text": "在看待這一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/138.wav", + "text": "那就是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/139.wav", + "text": "我以正向的態度看待這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/140.wav", + "text": "修法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/141.wav", + "text": "你就不能再迴避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/142.wav", + "text": "我以正向的態度看待這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/143.wav", + "text": "好我就說洪部長是支持最終責任入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/144.wav", + "text": "\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/145.wav", + "text": "今天是審查預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/146.wav", + "text": "我們持續來看你們的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/147.wav", + "text": "到底出了多大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/148.wav", + "text": "包括我之前揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/149.wav", + "text": "你們濫用就安基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/150.wav", + "text": "7支影片花200萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/151.wav", + "text": "結果觀看次數慘不忍睹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/152.wav", + "text": "部長你有看過這7支影片嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/153.wav", + "text": "每一支要花將近30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/154.wav", + "text": "結果它的觀看次數只有幾百人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/155.wav", + "text": "每一支都只有幾百人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/156.wav", + "text": "你們做事情是這樣子做的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/157.wav", + "text": "這樣子有效益嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/158.wav", + "text": "就安基金好好花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/159.wav", + "text": "隨便亂花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/160.wav", + "text": "這就是你們做事情的態度嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/161.wav", + "text": "你們有檢討嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/162.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/163.wav", + "text": "這幾支片子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/164.wav", + "text": "包括一個正片的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/165.wav", + "text": "連同7支影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/166.wav", + "text": "目前的瀏覽率大概有七萬多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/167.wav", + "text": "是喔是從哪邊看的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/168.wav", + "text": "所謂音樂會的那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/169.wav", + "text": "那7支影片的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/170.wav", + "text": "你要把所有的資訊都給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/171.wav", + "text": "我要好好地檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/172.wav", + "text": "你們到底是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/173.wav", + "text": "我們再把相關的資訊給王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/174.wav", + "text": "在這一個標案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/175.wav", + "text": "我就讓部長看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/176.wav", + "text": "你這整個標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/177.wav", + "text": "是每一年都漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/178.wav", + "text": "從106年開始到113年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/179.wav", + "text": "大家來看一下得標廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/180.wav", + "text": "得標廠商從108年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/181.wav", + "text": "就只有3家媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/182.wav", + "text": "通通都不會變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/183.wav", + "text": "從108年109年110年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/184.wav", + "text": "111年112年113年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/185.wav", + "text": "全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/186.wav", + "text": "都是不論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/187.wav", + "text": "有哪些別家的媒體投標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/188.wav", + "text": "一定是三立民視年代得標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/189.wav", + "text": "哇好巧喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/190.wav", + "text": "還要有特定的政治立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/191.wav", + "text": "是中性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/192.wav", + "text": "或其他你所標榜的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/193.wav", + "text": "通通都沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/194.wav", + "text": "就只有這3家會得標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/195.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/196.wav", + "text": "我們都是透過公開的採購程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/197.wav", + "text": "你公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/198.wav", + "text": "我現在就要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/199.wav", + "text": "這幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/200.wav", + "text": "這一個標案的評審是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/201.wav", + "text": "招標的過程請如實揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/202.wav", + "text": "我要所有的社會大眾評評理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/203.wav", + "text": "我們要讓那一些沒有得標的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/204.wav", + "text": "大家心服口服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/205.wav", + "text": "你是不是用同樣的評審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/206.wav", + "text": "及所有的通通都應該揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/207.wav", + "text": "部長贊成嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/208.wav", + "text": "我們通通都把它全面檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/209.wav", + "text": "如實揭露出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/210.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/211.wav", + "text": "我們的評選委員是外聘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/212.wav", + "text": "我要部長回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/213.wav", + "text": "我覺得該揭露的就揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/214.wav", + "text": "好全部通通都揭露出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/215.wav", + "text": "攤在陽光下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/216.wav", + "text": "一方面我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/217.wav", + "text": "固定就是那幾家媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/218.wav", + "text": "這當中到底有什麼樣的貓膩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/219.wav", + "text": "而且召集人主持人是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/220.wav", + "text": "所有的通通攤在陽光下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/221.wav", + "text": "你們多久可以整理出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/222.wav", + "text": "1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/223.wav", + "text": "好1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/224.wav", + "text": "我要求這些資料通通都要提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/225.wav", + "text": "部長我就問你一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/226.wav", + "text": "今天這些勞團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/227.wav", + "text": "其中一項就是就安基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/228.wav", + "text": "要求你全面檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/229.wav", + "text": "要求你如實揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/230.wav", + "text": "請問你做得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/231.wav", + "text": "這是現在我們正在做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/232.wav", + "text": "好那就從這個標案開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/233.wav", + "text": "從這個媒體採購案開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/234.wav", + "text": "我們要讓外界看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/235.wav", + "text": "為什麼可以這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/236.wav", + "text": "通通都不會得標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/237.wav", + "text": "這到底是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/238.wav", + "text": "我們要好好地揭露出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/239.wav", + "text": "而立法院也應該強化監督就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/240.wav", + "text": "就安基金的濫用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/241.wav", + "text": "已經讓國人沒有辦法忍受了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/242.wav", + "text": "所以接下來的預算審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/243.wav", + "text": "大家都應該要全力把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/244.wav", + "text": "被濫用到這般的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158025/245.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席有請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/1.wav", + "text": "有請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/2.wav", + "text": "部長你好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/3.wav", + "text": "勞動部最新公布了我國2023年的年總工時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/4.wav", + "text": "達2,020個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/5.wav", + "text": "為世界第2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/6.wav", + "text": "2全國更有25萬人的週工時大於60個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/7.wav", + "text": "整個臺灣已經陷入極度的過勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/8.wav", + "text": "可以說透過過勞讓世界看到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/9.wav", + "text": "想請問一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/10.wav", + "text": "你覺得造成這個事情的原因如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/11.wav", + "text": "有沒有什麼應對的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/12.wav", + "text": "從勞動部的角度來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/13.wav", + "text": "當然希望能夠協助勞工降低工時的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/14.wav", + "text": "這當然是我們整體的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/15.wav", + "text": "那在做法上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/16.wav", + "text": "原因是什麼你們有檢討原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/17.wav", + "text": "嗎為什麼又比上一年多加了15個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/18.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/19.wav", + "text": "那是每一人的每年平均工時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/20.wav", + "text": "含括了所謂的部分工時和全時勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/21.wav", + "text": "那在跟國際比較的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/22.wav", + "text": "我國的部分工時勞工占比只有3%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/23.wav", + "text": "像日本和韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/24.wav", + "text": "這個應該是說我們每一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/25.wav", + "text": "跟國際比是一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/26.wav", + "text": "跟國際比我們的數據已經很糟糕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/27.wav", + "text": "但是你跟自己比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/28.wav", + "text": "你今年也比去年再增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/29.wav", + "text": "所以還有什麼理由呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/30.wav", + "text": "今年的部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/31.wav", + "text": "其實是回到疫情前的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/32.wav", + "text": "我們慢慢地復甦回來到疫情前的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/33.wav", + "text": "你有沒有什麼應對方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/34.wav", + "text": "現在有沒有什麼應對方式要讓它降下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/35.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/36.wav", + "text": "幾個部分其實我們現在都規劃在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/37.wav", + "text": "要怎麼讓低薪的問題能夠比較大的克服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/38.wav", + "text": "這部分很重要的原因是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/39.wav", + "text": "我們知道其實有一部分的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/40.wav", + "text": "是因為他的薪水過低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/41.wav", + "text": "所以他必須透過加班的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/42.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在在推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/43.wav", + "text": "包括像是薪資的透明化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/44.wav", + "text": "也包括這幾年一直不斷調高的基本工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/45.wav", + "text": "這部分都是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/46.wav", + "text": "讓低薪的問題能夠多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/47.wav", + "text": "所以你今年還會再調高基本工資嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/48.wav", + "text": "這當然不是我現在這邊能夠說的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/49.wav", + "text": "可是我的意思是這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/50.wav", + "text": "我們陸續在做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/51.wav", + "text": "這是第一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/52.wav", + "text": "第二個部分我們也希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/53.wav", + "text": "建立勞資之間的協商機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/54.wav", + "text": "讓協商機制可以做得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/55.wav", + "text": "希望可以讓更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/56.wav", + "text": "比方說跟工會簽團體協約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/57.wav", + "text": "因為團體協約其實就可以做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/58.wav", + "text": "優於法規的合理工時的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/59.wav", + "text": "部長全國產業總工會理事長有指出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/60.wav", + "text": "可以有相對應的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/61.wav", + "text": "比如說有關積極減少工時的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/62.wav", + "text": "包含鼓勵試辦企業週休三日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/63.wav", + "text": "國定假日法制化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/64.wav", + "text": "還有適用勞基法第八十四之一條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/65.wav", + "text": "責任制行業別重新檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/66.wav", + "text": "全國產業總工會理事長提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/67.wav", + "text": "這裡面有幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/68.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們自己願意來參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/69.wav", + "text": "去做更大程度的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/70.wav", + "text": "然後有關於七天假的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/71.wav", + "text": "你過去在立委任內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/72.wav", + "text": "說要反映給行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/73.wav", + "text": "嘛那現在你也當家了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/74.wav", + "text": "你現在說要繼續彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/75.wav", + "text": "請問你現在還願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/76.wav", + "text": "給勞工減低過勞嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/77.wav", + "text": "然後要去跟內政部溝通的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/78.wav", + "text": "我跟廖委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/79.wav", + "text": "確實現在在國定假日相關的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/80.wav", + "text": "目前相關的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/81.wav", + "text": "是主責在內政部下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/82.wav", + "text": "我想你也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/83.wav", + "text": "映勞工朋友與各界的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/84.wav", + "text": "讓內政部知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/85.wav", + "text": "你反映了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/86.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/87.wav", + "text": "我們自己很願意跟內政部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/88.wav", + "text": "除了反映之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/89.wav", + "text": "還有什麼積極作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/90.wav", + "text": "如果內政���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/91.wav", + "text": "或大家要做跨部會討論的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/92.wav", + "text": "我們也很願意跟內政部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/93.wav", + "text": "你會強硬要求嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/94.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/95.wav", + "text": "站在勞動部的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/96.wav", + "text": "這涉及跨部會的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/97.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/98.wav", + "text": "所以我們能做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/99.wav", + "text": "當然是確切反映勞工相關的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/100.wav", + "text": "現在能做的就是反映而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/101.wav", + "text": "因為這個議題本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/102.wav", + "text": "部長請你好好反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/103.wav", + "text": "映根據就業服務法第55條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/104.wav", + "text": "申請家庭看護或家事移工時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/105.wav", + "text": "若雇主為身心障礙者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/106.wav", + "text": "仍須繳納就業安定費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/107.wav", + "text": "一般家庭是繳納2,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/108.wav", + "text": "中低收入戶或低收入戶可以減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/109.wav", + "text": "這項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/110.wav", + "text": "其實被身心障礙族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/111.wav", + "text": "稱之為障礙稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/112.wav", + "text": "與障礙平權觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/113.wav", + "text": "障礙者與健全者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/114.wav", + "text": "在生活及各方面的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/115.wav", + "text": "障礙者必須自力救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/116.wav", + "text": "請問部長認為這樣的規定合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/117.wav", + "text": "部長我剛剛已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/118.wav", + "text": "這是CRPD公約的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/119.wav", + "text": "已經自己花錢聘請移工這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/120.wav", + "text": "本來應該是政府的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/121.wav", + "text": "與健全者的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/122.wav", + "text": "現在他們自己聘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/123.wav", + "text": "請問這不是國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/124.wav", + "text": "在製造並增加他們的障礙嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/125.wav", + "text": "外籍看護工的家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/126.wav", + "text": "我認為有開放討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/127.wav", + "text": "只有開放討論與檢討嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/128.wav", + "text": "部長回去可以好好研議嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/129.wav", + "text": "我們會做各種情境的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/130.wav", + "text": "程我簡單講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/131.wav", + "text": "之前我也請教過何佩珊部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/132.wav", + "text": "說要研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/133.wav", + "text": "雖然規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/134.wav", + "text": "雇主應向中央主管機關設置的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/135.wav", + "text": "就業安定基金專戶繳納就業安定費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/136.wav", + "text": "但法條中其實沒有具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/137.wav", + "text": "修正子法或行政函釋方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/138.wav", + "text": "或免除身心障礙者的繳納義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/139.wav", + "text": "當然是在子法中修訂即可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/140.wav", + "text": "所涉及的幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/141.wav", + "text": "看什麼時候可以給具體回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/142.wav", + "text": "多久時間可以有具體回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/143.wav", + "text": "三個月好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/144.wav", + "text": "三個月嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/145.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/146.wav", + "text": "好我們期待三個月後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/147.wav", + "text": "給這些身心障礙者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/148.wav", + "text": "我們確實在思考怎麼來降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/149.wav", + "text": "可能的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/150.wav", + "text": "請儘速在三個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/151.wav", + "text": "而這些費用最終進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/152.wav", + "text": "就業安定基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/153.wav", + "text": "成為基金的資金來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/154.wav", + "text": "這一次引起很大風波" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/155.wav", + "text": "的就業安定基金被不當挪用的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/156.wav", + "text": "其實我們接到非常多雇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/157.wav", + "text": "雇主陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/158.wav", + "text": "他們覺得自己已經多花錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/159.wav", + "text": "結果政府還亂用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/160.wav", + "text": "所以他們感到非常不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/161.wav", + "text": "也就是就業安定基金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/162.wav", + "text": "媒體政策及業務宣導費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/163.wav", + "text": "該項支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/164.wav", + "text": "從111年的1.09億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/165.wav", + "text": "到114年的預算編列達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/166.wav", + "text": "2.17億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/167.wav", + "text": "這樣的成長比例是不是過高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/168.wav", + "text": "如果金額成長兩倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/169.wav", + "text": "那麼我是不是可以期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/170.wav", + "text": "宣傳效應也應該要提升兩倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/171.wav", + "text": "會大幅擴充的主要原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/172.wav", + "text": "在過去兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/173.wav", + "text": "所以把它的規模做大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/174.wav", + "text": "亞洲技能競賽也要在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/175.wav", + "text": "除了辦理全國賽擴大之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/176.wav", + "text": "這兩個占了多少比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/177.wav", + "text": "然後你們預算成長的比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/178.wav", + "text": "率差別在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/179.wav", + "text": "這兩個部分所占的比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/180.wav", + "text": "這個成長比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/181.wav", + "text": "率跟臺灣GDP成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/182.wav", + "text": "物價漲幅有關嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/183.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明亞太技能競賽宣傳費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/184.wav", + "text": "競賽宣傳項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/185.wav", + "text": "增加了5,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/186.wav", + "text": "跟之前比起來呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/187.wav", + "text": "是3,800萬左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/188.wav", + "text": "可是整體卻增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/189.wav", + "text": "快5,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/190.wav", + "text": "你們爭議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/191.wav", + "text": "修辦公空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/192.wav", + "text": "網路行銷等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/193.wav", + "text": "應該是促進就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/194.wav", + "text": "提升勞工福祉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/195.wav", + "text": "跟外國人聘僱等目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/196.wav", + "text": "請問你覺得這些運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/197.wav", + "text": "支應妥當嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/198.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/199.wav", + "text": "跟廖委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/200.wav", + "text": "但可能是為了因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/201.wav", + "text": "其實有這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/202.wav", + "text": "就像上次講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/203.wav", + "text": "可以增加勞工福祉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/204.wav", + "text": "其他還有非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/205.wav", + "text": "相關的細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/206.wav", + "text": "都是其實上次我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/207.wav", + "text": "確實我並不認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/208.wav", + "text": "這裡面每一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/209.wav", + "text": "都適合用就安基金來支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/210.wav", + "text": "是我不會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/211.wav", + "text": "這裡面每一個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/212.wav", + "text": "並不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/213.wav", + "text": "它確實有它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/214.wav", + "text": "使用上的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/215.wav", + "text": "但就項目的適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/216.wav", + "text": "我的確認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/217.wav", + "text": "用就安基金來使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/218.wav", + "text": "安基金被濫用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/219.wav", + "text": "我覺得有檢討空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/220.wav", + "text": "是不是被濫用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/221.wav", + "text": "我覺得有檢討空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/222.wav", + "text": "有檢討空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/223.wav", + "text": "可是你也不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/224.wav", + "text": "正面回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/225.wav", + "text": "是不是被濫用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/226.wav", + "text": "這是前朝的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/227.wav", + "text": "卻也不願意概���承受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/228.wav", + "text": "有檢討的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/229.wav", + "text": "上次你也不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/230.wav", + "text": "就安基金被濫用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/231.wav", + "text": "我覺得很遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/232.wav", + "text": "前任部長潘世偉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/233.wav", + "text": "就安基金就是勞動部的小金庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/234.wav", + "text": "美其名為公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/235.wav", + "text": "卻以私利為目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/236.wav", + "text": "若不是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/237.wav", + "text": "那麼這沒有人監督的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/238.wav", + "text": "要改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/239.wav", + "text": "是不是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/240.wav", + "text": "沾不上邊的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/241.wav", + "text": "讓就安基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/242.wav", + "text": "我們確實也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/243.wav", + "text": "就不一定要使用就安基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/244.wav", + "text": "這是我們也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/245.wav", + "text": "該去努力的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/246.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/247.wav", + "text": "其實就安基金的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/248.wav", + "text": "我上禮拜就說到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/249.wav", + "text": "的事根據會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/250.wav", + "text": "這筆補助是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/251.wav", + "text": "前一年的11月23日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/252.wav", + "text": "臨時會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/253.wav", + "text": "以臨時動議的提案方式通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/254.wav", + "text": "隔年3月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/255.wav", + "text": "第105次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/256.wav", + "text": "才由就業平等司提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/257.wav", + "text": "所需經費4,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/258.wav", + "text": "編列於提升勞工福祉項目當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/259.wav", + "text": "家對就安基金的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/260.wav", + "text": "已經很深了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/261.wav", + "text": "而目前能夠查閱的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/262.wav", + "text": "僅有這個會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/263.wav", + "text": "就跨年度的會議紀錄去做對比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/264.wav", + "text": "的話根本無法追蹤相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/265.wav", + "text": "而且審議委員會並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/266.wav", + "text": "沒有公開審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/267.wav", + "text": "有長期被亂用的不良紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/268.wav", + "text": "要更公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/269.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要把審議會議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/270.wav", + "text": "放在網站上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/271.wav", + "text": "供全國人民查閱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/272.wav", + "text": "共同監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/273.wav", + "text": "請問部長是否支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/274.wav", + "text": "廖委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/275.wav", + "text": "就你剛才講的這個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/276.wav", + "text": "就我知道後來高雄市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/277.wav", + "text": "其實已經把這個計畫撤回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/278.wav", + "text": "沒錯我知道撤回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/279.wav", + "text": "上禮拜我也有講撤回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/280.wav", + "text": "但是整個過程其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/281.wav", + "text": "因為當時有被拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/282.wav", + "text": "在立法院檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/283.wav", + "text": "包含楊曜委員等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/284.wav", + "text": "變成軒然大波" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/285.wav", + "text": "所以他才趕快撤回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/286.wav", + "text": "不然這也是一個嚴重的政治事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/287.wav", + "text": "事但是這件事情的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/288.wav", + "text": "就像你說的制度上有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/289.wav", + "text": "所以我所以我們認為在機制上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/290.wav", + "text": "包括事前的審查怎麼強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/291.wav", + "text": "甚至事後計畫後的稽核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/292.wav", + "text": "我們當然現在也在檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/293.wav", + "text": "包括在收支管理辦法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/294.wav", + "text": "可不可以公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/295.wav", + "text": "可不可以公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/296.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們是可以做到更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/297.wav", + "text": "我認為我們可以做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/298.wav", + "text": "更多資訊的公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/299.wav", + "text": "剛具體的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/300.wav", + "text": "錄影的公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/301.wav", + "text": "像是健保審議一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/302.wav", + "text": "廖委員我們現在還在整體的檢討中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/303.wav", + "text": "但我自己認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/304.wav", + "text": "我們是可以再做到更多的公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/305.wav", + "text": "部長你講的話都是很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/306.wav", + "text": "不具體的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/307.wav", + "text": "所以我只是說這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/308.wav", + "text": "跟國人同胞公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/309.wav", + "text": "這個其實應該是對一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/310.wav", + "text": "我希望部長可以正面回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/311.wav", + "text": "我覺得可以做到更多的公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/312.wav", + "text": "所以你可以比這更多對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/313.wav", + "text": "當然可以比現在更多的公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/314.wav", + "text": "還是你只是比現在你不敢承" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/315.wav", + "text": "但是我現在的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/316.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/317.wav", + "text": "錄音錄影委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/318.wav", + "text": "我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/319.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在真的正在檢討中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/320.wav", + "text": "所以關於這些細節的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/321.wav", + "text": "其實現在也在討論中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/322.wav", + "text": "我就進一步追" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/323.wav", + "text": "為什麼一定要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/324.wav", + "text": "我跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/325.wav", + "text": "同樣的會議紀錄中有寫到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/326.wav", + "text": "如果辦理高雄市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/327.wav", + "text": "或辦理這類的活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/328.wav", + "text": "經費不足的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/329.wav", + "text": "再以併決算的方式來辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/330.wav", + "text": "那我們發現這就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/331.wav", + "text": "就安基金動用上的常態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/332.wav", + "text": "雖然作法上你覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/333.wav", + "text": "好像預算法有法源依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/334.wav", + "text": "但其實這等同於削弱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/335.wav", + "text": "和閹割立法院的監督權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/336.wav", + "text": "就算我們再怎麼努力監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/337.wav", + "text": "不管公務預算或是就安基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/338.wav", + "text": "其實都是徒勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/339.wav", + "text": "因為你們編列是一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/340.wav", + "text": "立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/341.wav", + "text": "又是一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/342.wav", + "text": "但最終你們都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/343.wav", + "text": "自行超支併決算處理那一套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/344.wav", + "text": "基本上就是想怎麼用就怎麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/345.wav", + "text": "這個作法美其名是彈性因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/346.wav", + "text": "可是事實上就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/347.wav", + "text": "讓它不公開不透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/348.wav", + "text": "而且讓我們沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/349.wav", + "text": "好好審查的一個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/350.wav", + "text": "跟廖委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/351.wav", + "text": "我們現在確實也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/352.wav", + "text": "在就安基金收支管理辦法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/353.wav", + "text": "其實有部分的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/354.wav", + "text": "我們要怎麼樣更嚴格的把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/355.wav", + "text": "這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/356.wav", + "text": "部長我跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/357.wav", + "text": "就安基金濫用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/358.wav", + "text": "所謂的併決算的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/359.wav", + "text": "等於是編列不實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/360.wav", + "text": "等於是可能導致機關故意低估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/361.wav", + "text": "以便日後併決算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/362.wav", + "text": "併決算的過程幾乎缺乏透明度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/363.wav", + "text": "不利於公眾監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/364.wav", + "text": "所以為什麼我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/365.wav", + "text": "你們這個審查會議應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/366.wav", + "text": "讓錄音錄影的影像全部公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/367.wav", + "text": "而且每一條明細應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/368.wav", + "text": "很詳細的交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/369.wav", + "text": "尤其是這些繳納就業安定基金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/370.wav", + "text": "對於政府完全沒有信心沒有信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/371.wav", + "text": "是真的有照顧到老百姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/372.wav", + "text": "還是只是部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/373.wav", + "text": "以上我講到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/374.wav", + "text": "是未來在這部分的審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/375.wav", + "text": "可以把錄音錄影都公開上網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/376.wav", + "text": "我並不覺得有併決算的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/377.wav", + "text": "就一定叫做編列不實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/378.wav", + "text": "這之間並不是等價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/379.wav", + "text": "這是弊端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/380.wav", + "text": "而且還不夠公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/381.wav", + "text": "但是如果有併決算狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/382.wav", + "text": "我確實覺得應該儘量的減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/383.wav", + "text": "但我並不覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/384.wav", + "text": "只要有超支併決算的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/385.wav", + "text": "就一定叫做編列不實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/386.wav", + "text": "我也沒有說全部都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/387.wav", + "text": "但是這個就是叫濫用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/388.wav", + "text": "對所以我說併決算應該減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/389.wav", + "text": "尤其是接下來應該在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/390.wav", + "text": "我自己認為應該在部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/391.wav", + "text": "已經分析給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/392.wav", + "text": "聽你不用針對每一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/393.wav", + "text": "回應那些比較空泛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/394.wav", + "text": "我覺得就是在透明公開上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/395.wav", + "text": "是不是可以像現在立法院一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/396.wav", + "text": "可以錄影出來直播紀錄放上網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/397.wav", + "text": "我認為我們應該可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/398.wav", + "text": "資訊的揭露跟公開上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/399.wav", + "text": "好那我希望一個月後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158024/400.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/0.wav", + "text": "我看了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/1.wav", + "text": "宣布對於輕生公務員追封勞動獎章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/2.wav", + "text": "會爭取因公傷亡的撫卹補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/3.wav", + "text": "但是上個星期銓敘部卻說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/4.wav", + "text": "卻說還沒收到勞動部的文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/5.wav", + "text": "是什麼原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/6.wav", + "text": "當然因為我們現在在重啟調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/7.wav", + "text": "在重啟調查的結果發布以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/8.wav", + "text": "該怎麼樣幫這個公務員爭取的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/9.wav", + "text": "我們都會盡力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/10.wav", + "text": "資遣撫卹法第52條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/11.wav", + "text": "病故或意外死亡予以認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/12.wav", + "text": "所以你們準備要用什麼樣的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/13.wav", + "text": "我們會先等這週的調查報告內容出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/14.wav", + "text": "後續該幫這位吳姓公務員爭取的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/15.wav", + "text": "我們都會盡力爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/16.wav", + "text": "對現在在重啟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/17.wav", + "text": "那你現在找到適合的法條了沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/18.wav", + "text": "法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/19.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/20.wav", + "text": "我們會先看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/21.wav", + "text": "我們會把重啟調查的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/22.wav", + "text": "都還是要基於這一位吳姓公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/23.wav", + "text": "在生前他經歷了什麼他遇到了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/24.wav", + "text": "所以這個調查報告的公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/25.wav", + "text": "所以你們是要把這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/26.wav", + "text": "就給銓敘部去認定還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/27.wav", + "text": "銓敘部當然是撫卹的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/28.wav", + "text": "但我們會等調查報告出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/29.wav", + "text": "向社會報告以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/30.wav", + "text": "我們拿著這些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/31.wav", + "text": "來盡力幫吳姓公務員爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/32.wav", + "text": "撫卹金額差非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/33.wav", + "text": "差非常多勞動部既然已經在第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/34.wav", + "text": "說要替這位公務員爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/35.wav", + "text": "我希望你們說到要做到好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/36.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/37.wav", + "text": "就勞保年金你說不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/38.wav", + "text": "你也說不會砍年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/39.wav", + "text": "但是在你的業務報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/40.wav", + "text": "看不到你到底要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/41.wav", + "text": "還有你的期程規劃是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/42.wav", + "text": "其實現在勞保年金的水位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/43.wav", + "text": "今年應該有機會可以破1兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/44.wav", + "text": "撥補是維持水位的作法之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/45.wav", + "text": "也不會只有撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/46.wav", + "text": "我們在多元的投資裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/47.wav", + "text": "其實收益的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/48.wav", + "text": "作法更精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/49.wav", + "text": "也都有助於整個水位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/50.wav", + "text": "的狀況所以我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/51.wav", + "text": "我們要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/52.wav", + "text": "第一個確實現在政策上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/53.wav", + "text": "並沒有砍給付的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/54.wav", + "text": "這是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/55.wav", + "text": "對於維持基金水位的作法上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/56.wav", + "text": "我們其實會有各種不同的多元作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/57.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/58.wav", + "text": "也是有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/59.wav", + "text": "可是做了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/60.wav", + "text": "其實現在今年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/61.wav", + "text": "蔡英文總統執政了8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/62.wav", + "text": "他一直說要彙集意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/63.wav", + "text": "而到現在也還是只有撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/64.wav", + "text": "現在你上任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/65.wav", + "text": "了你又說要彙集意見凝聚共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/66.wav", + "text": "他一定會解決退休金的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/67.wav", + "text": "這個部分你有什麼想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/68.wav", + "text": "還是延續傳統這樣子複製貼上就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/69.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/70.wav", + "text": "當然不會是複製貼上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/71.wav", + "text": "我說撥補這部分我們會持續辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/72.wav", + "text": "可是我們維持基金水位的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/73.wav", + "text": "不會只有撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/74.wav", + "text": "包括檢討基金投資的收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/75.wav", + "text": "我希望勞動部不是一個冰冷的行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/76.wav", + "text": "要貼近我們勞工的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/77.wav", + "text": "希望你們能夠提供有效的解決方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/78.wav", + "text": "你看到300多名民眾上街頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/79.wav", + "text": "還有工人要絕食100個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/80.wav", + "text": "等你給答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/81.wav", + "text": "這個部分你有什麼感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/82.wav", + "text": "我們當然尊重公民社會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/83.wav", + "text": "各種聲音的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/84.wav", + "text": "然後我們也很重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/85.wav", + "text": "明我們當然非常重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/86.wav", + "text": "現在大家提出來的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/87.wav", + "text": "尤其是關於霸凌的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/88.wav", + "text": "尤其是大家現在也提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/89.wav", + "text": "很多關於就安基金運用的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/90.wav", + "text": "都是我上任這兩個禮拜以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/91.wav", + "text": "非常非常大力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/92.wav", + "text": "也花很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/93.wav", + "text": "我們在全力檢討跟推動的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/94.wav", + "text": "他們會走上街頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/95.wav", + "text": "我這樣看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/96.wav", + "text": "他們就是不接受你們的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/97.wav", + "text": "你們一再的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/98.wav", + "text": "還是跟之前一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/99.wav", + "text": "我想大家都不願意看到這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/100.wav", + "text": "也不願意去做這樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/101.wav", + "text": "還有包含絕食抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/102.wav", + "text": "愛因斯坦也說過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/103.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做瘋子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/104.wav", + "text": "就是重複同樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/105.wav", + "text": "一直在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/106.wav", + "text": "還期待會有不同的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/107.wav", + "text": "這個就是愛因斯坦口中的瘋子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/108.wav", + "text": "我希望勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/109.wav", + "text": "不是他口中的瘋子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/110.wav", + "text": "尤其是關於就安基金的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/111.wav", + "text": "我們一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/112.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法只是重複過去的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/113.wav", + "text": "啦期待洪部長上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/114.wav", + "text": "趕快提出一個新的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/115.wav", + "text": "\n另外我看到你們的預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/116.wav", + "text": "安排明年9月要到大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/117.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/118.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/119.wav", + "text": "因為我們可能要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/120.wav", + "text": "沒有說一定要去大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/121.wav", + "text": "那你編這預算要幹出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/122.wav", + "text": "出國預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/123.wav", + "text": "有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/124.wav", + "text": "但你們民進黨政府不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/125.wav", + "text": "去大陸很危險嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/126.wav", + "text": "你覺得你去安全嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/127.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/128.wav", + "text": "因為有些國際性的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/129.wav", + "text": "會在大陸召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/130.wav", + "text": "所以我們是預留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/131.wav", + "text": "對嘛所以部長你覺得呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/132.wav", + "text": "你們不怕過去被統戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/133.wav", + "text": "我會跟業務單位來檢討相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/134.wav", + "text": "所以部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/135.wav", + "text": "你覺得過去是對的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/136.wav", + "text": "我這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/137.wav", + "text": "跟經費的編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/138.wav", + "text": "有沒有符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/139.wav", + "text": "我們達到政策目的的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/140.wav", + "text": "其實檢視的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/141.wav", + "text": "是在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/142.wav", + "text": "去什麼地方就一定怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/143.wav", + "text": "我不會用這個角度看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/144.wav", + "text": "重點是對於我們推展業務有沒有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/145.wav", + "text": "兩岸的交流互動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/146.wav", + "text": "其實我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/147.wav", + "text": "本來它就存在必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/148.wav", + "text": "不要因為政治立場而停擺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/149.wav", + "text": "不要為了反對而反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/150.wav", + "text": "我們有一個正常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/151.wav", + "text": "我覺得是非常好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/152.wav", + "text": "我們就是希望各種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/153.wav", + "text": "只針對中國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/154.wav", + "text": "而是各種出國的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/155.wav", + "text": "它能夠對於我們業務推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/156.wav", + "text": "有什麼幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/157.wav", + "text": "我會非常非常看重這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/158.wav", + "text": "好最後就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/159.wav", + "text": "就安基金裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/160.wav", + "text": "你們很多東西寫得非常籠統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/161.wav", + "text": "像固定資產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/162.wav", + "text": "無形資產這幾個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/163.wav", + "text": "你們分了4個地方編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/164.wav", + "text": "總共編了八億300多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/165.wav", + "text": "這是要買什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/166.wav", + "text": "這是要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/167.wav", + "text": "就安基金裡面的媒體事務費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/168.wav", + "text": "就編了兩億100多萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/169.wav", + "text": "等於1個月要花1,800萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/170.wav", + "text": "這裡面你們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/171.wav", + "text": "複製貼上這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/172.wav", + "text": "相關媒體通路宣傳製作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/173.wav", + "text": "託播及刊登經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/174.wav", + "text": "這樣不清不楚的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/175.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/176.wav", + "text": "這個2億1,700萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/177.wav", + "text": "是屬於我們對於各種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/178.wav", + "text": "促進國民就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/179.wav", + "text": "聘僱許可管理相關措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/180.wav", + "text": "你們去買東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/181.wav", + "text": "都不用問價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/182.wav", + "text": "或是製作影片圖檔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/183.wav", + "text": "還是數量多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/184.wav", + "text": "託播哪些平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/185.wav", + "text": "刊登在哪���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/186.wav", + "text": "這個部分都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/187.wav", + "text": "反正編下去花完就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/188.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/189.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/190.wav", + "text": "還是要給我們的綠媒賺一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/191.wav", + "text": "邱委員並不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/192.wav", + "text": "政策跟法令需要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/193.wav", + "text": "外界接收到訊息的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/194.wav", + "text": "相關的計畫編列裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/195.wav", + "text": "有沒有哪些適不適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/196.wav", + "text": "每個項目適不適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/197.wav", + "text": "這部分當然我們也會檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/198.wav", + "text": "你要找外部人員來把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/199.wav", + "text": "勞動部發展署就發新聞稿說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/200.wav", + "text": "就安基金有外部監督機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/201.wav", + "text": "就安基金符合用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/202.wav", + "text": "沒有浮編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/203.wav", + "text": "以促進國民就業為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/204.wav", + "text": "沒有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/205.wav", + "text": "這之前就在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/206.wav", + "text": "啦所以我不曉得你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/207.wav", + "text": "會不會找到同樣的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/208.wav", + "text": "關於外部的成員是一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/209.wav", + "text": "但還有一個部分是在機制面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/210.wav", + "text": "我自己認為也要從機制面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/211.wav", + "text": "去面對問題跟檢討問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/212.wav", + "text": "所以除了人以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/213.wav", + "text": "還有機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/214.wav", + "text": "你上次說過1個月要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/215.wav", + "text": "好我希望不要流於形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/216.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/217.wav", + "text": "謝謝邱委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158023/218.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/0.wav", + "text": "主席請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/1.wav", + "text": "臺鐵杜董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/2.wav", + "text": "陳部長杜董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/3.wav", + "text": "好陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/4.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/5.wav", + "text": "剛才我們兩位同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/6.wav", + "text": "都已經提到榮耀號的事情你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/7.wav", + "text": "答當然本席也不需要贅述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/8.wav", + "text": "在這裡有一個觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/9.wav", + "text": "我們確實對於臺灣人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/10.wav", + "text": "不管是參加任何一個旅遊也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/11.wav", + "text": "發生事情時的危機處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/12.wav", + "text": "非常不當非常不積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/13.wav", + "text": "針對榮耀號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/14.wav", + "text": "的事情還好是比較鄰近的Okinawa" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/15.wav", + "text": "如果是在別的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/16.wav", + "text": "所以我在這裡要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/17.wav", + "text": "你們現在在處理的當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/18.wav", + "text": "有沒有成立應變小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/19.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/20.wav", + "text": "我們航港局的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/21.wav", + "text": "他們有成立應變小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/22.wav", + "text": "不是只有航港局啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/23.wav", + "text": "這個我們交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/24.wav", + "text": "航港局跟港務公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/25.wav", + "text": "然後民航局還有觀光署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/26.wav", + "text": "一起在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/27.wav", + "text": "應該是港務公司吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/28.wav", + "text": "還是航港局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/29.wav", + "text": "是航港局在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/30.wav", + "text": "其實部長我給你建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/31.wav", + "text": "啦有時候航港局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/32.wav", + "text": "來主導這些大家都是平行單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/33.wav", + "text": "要由我們部裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/34.wav", + "text": "我們的政次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/35.wav", + "text": "報告委員這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/36.wav", + "text": "由我們林國顯次長在督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/37.wav", + "text": "是是所以要成立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/38.wav", + "text": "當然我們交通部是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/39.wav", + "text": "但是有時候還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/40.wav", + "text": "協調到別的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/41.wav", + "text": "所以我還是要建議啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/42.wav", + "text": "為了慎重起見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/43.wav", + "text": "要積極儘快把協調小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/44.wav", + "text": "就只有部長去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/45.wav", + "text": "才會有效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/46.wav", + "text": "不可以這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/47.wav", + "text": "因為我們是一個團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/48.wav", + "text": "不是一個部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/49.wav", + "text": "所以我還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/50.wav", + "text": "不管如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/51.wav", + "text": "一定要去成立這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/52.wav", + "text": "這樣效能可能會更加好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/53.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/54.wav", + "text": "第一時間其實就已經組織起來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/55.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/56.wav", + "text": "是只有單一的小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/57.wav", + "text": "不能去面對各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/58.wav", + "text": "對���跨單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/59.wav", + "text": "對對一定要有應變小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/60.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/61.wav", + "text": "不管發生什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/62.wav", + "text": "一定要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/63.wav", + "text": "就是杜董事長可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/64.wav", + "text": "我不是在找臺鐵的毛病啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/65.wav", + "text": "但是我們一定要去針對問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/66.wav", + "text": "事業民營化公司化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/67.wav", + "text": "這樣給你們的空間會比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/68.wav", + "text": "杜董我們憑良心講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/69.wav", + "text": "小問題解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/70.wav", + "text": "未來就沒有大問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/71.wav", + "text": "所以我舉例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/72.wav", + "text": "現在像我們臺鐵車站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/73.wav", + "text": "你知道事情發生幾次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/74.wav", + "text": "杜董" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/75.wav", + "text": "已經發生好幾次了喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/76.wav", + "text": "過去我們是公務機關的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/77.wav", + "text": "那沒話可講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/78.wav", + "text": "一定要按部就班來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/79.wav", + "text": "但是現在公司化之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/80.wav", + "text": "公司經營助理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/81.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/82.wav", + "text": "是比較有彈性空間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/83.wav", + "text": "我就感覺到很納悶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/84.wav", + "text": "事情發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/85.wav", + "text": "不管是任何一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/86.wav", + "text": "我舉例高雄車站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/87.wav", + "text": "很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/88.wav", + "text": "電梯為什麼常常會壞掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/89.wav", + "text": "到底是採購的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/90.wav", + "text": "或者你們經營管理有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/91.wav", + "text": "的我舉例高雄車站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/92.wav", + "text": "12月4號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/93.wav", + "text": "2023年都不要講啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/94.wav", + "text": "那個電梯有問題的已經非常之多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/95.wav", + "text": "但是2024年12月4號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/96.wav", + "text": "最近而已耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/97.wav", + "text": "還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/98.wav", + "text": "我不曉得有沒有跟你回報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/99.wav", + "text": "我也贊同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/100.wav", + "text": "管經營策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/101.wav", + "text": "你底下要有掌控啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/102.wav", + "text": "為什麼會發生這些事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/103.wav", + "text": "更何況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/104.wav", + "text": "你們現在還成立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/105.wav", + "text": "機房的電梯小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/106.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/107.wav", + "text": "還有存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/108.wav", + "text": "在我們電務單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/109.wav", + "text": "就是公司本部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/110.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/111.wav", + "text": "有電梯組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/112.wav", + "text": "編制這麼完善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/113.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/114.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/115.wav", + "text": "電梯的使用那麼爛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/116.wav", + "text": "高雄這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/117.wav", + "text": "人家是要出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/118.wav", + "text": "結果一家四口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/119.wav", + "text": "關在電梯裡面45分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/120.wav", + "text": "關在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/121.wav", + "text": "如果窒息怎麼辦呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/122.wav", + "text": "所以這代表什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/123.wav", + "text": "你們還有電梯組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/124.wav", + "text": "董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/125.wav", + "text": "還有電梯組耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/126.wav", + "text": "他們都在睡覺嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/127.wav", + "text": "跟你們編列預算有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/128.wav", + "text": "不然這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/129.wav", + "text": "幹嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/130.wav", + "text": "要編人事費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/131.wav", + "text": "要編維修費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/132.wav", + "text": "結果效果不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/133.wav", + "text": "請問一下董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/134.wav", + "text": "你有什麼看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/135.wav", + "text": "這不是找你毛病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/136.wav", + "text": "但是會牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/137.wav", + "text": "經營問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/138.wav", + "text": "管理問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/139.wav", + "text": "所以董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/140.wav", + "text": "針對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/141.wav", + "text": "你有什麼看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/142.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/143.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/144.wav", + "text": "其實每一件我都有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/145.wav", + "text": "它在發生的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/146.wav", + "text": "馬上就會傳訊給我本人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/147.wav", + "text": "剛剛講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/148.wav", + "text": "員林在三四月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/149.wav", + "text": "還有高雄在這個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/150.wav", + "text": "發生的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/151.wav", + "text": "我們第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/152.wav", + "text": "有責成他去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/153.wav", + "text": "多少年沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/154.wav", + "text": "啦正常維護保養做好的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/155.wav", + "text": "它就不應該故障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/156.wav", + "text": "高雄這個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/157.wav", + "text": "先前這台電梯沒有故障過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/158.wav", + "text": "它是有一個扣腳斷損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/159.wav", + "text": "為什麼它會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/160.wav", + "text": "該換的我們會全部換掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/161.wav", + "text": "人家一家四口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/162.wav", + "text": "關在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/163.wav", + "text": "你們危機處理也很不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/164.wav", + "text": "電梯要壞掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/165.wav", + "text": "我怎麼會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/166.wav", + "text": "這個對白基本上就不對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/167.wav", + "text": "第一個一定說抱歉抱歉抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/168.wav", + "text": "一定是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/169.wav", + "text": "嘛所以董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/170.wav", + "text": "我會在立法院殿堂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/171.wav", + "text": "這些乘客都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/172.wav", + "text": "對這些事情非常不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/173.wav", + "text": "所以我特別提供給董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/174.wav", + "text": "未來不管是總經理副總經理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/175.wav", + "text": "你們副總經理一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/176.wav", + "text": "主管這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/177.wav", + "text": "你還是要特別注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/178.wav", + "text": "這麼小的事情還要部長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/179.wav", + "text": "部長下令嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/180.wav", + "text": "所以我是希望董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/181.wav", + "text": "因為你是對全公司負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/182.wav", + "text": "你是要對部長負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/183.wav", + "text": "不要這種東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/184.wav", + "text": "我也可以K部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/185.wav", + "text": "啊可是這個就是找麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/186.wav", + "text": "這個是我們公司要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/187.wav", + "text": "對所以這個部分我還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/188.wav", + "text": "你們的態度要特別注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/189.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/190.wav", + "text": "你們車廂的衛生打掃是不佳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/191.wav", + "text": "你可以看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/192.wav", + "text": "我特別去拍照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/193.wav", + "text": "這是我親身體驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/194.wav", + "text": "但是因為有一次我要去屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/195.wav", + "text": "坐了你們的火車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/196.wav", + "text": "已經改進的就只有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/197.wav", + "text": "什麼的現在我看到的是準時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/198.wav", + "text": "但是衛生卻非常髒亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/199.wav", + "text": "因為有一個人剛剛好坐在我旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/200.wav", + "text": "從桃園上車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/201.wav", + "text": "他是身障老人家自己用輪椅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/202.wav", + "text": "結果是在那邊尿尿跟拉屎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/203.wav", + "text": "我看所有的人都離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/204.wav", + "text": "那是禮拜六禮拜天人算蠻多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/205.wav", + "text": "但是來整理這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/206.wav", + "text": "的時間是半個小時以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/207.wav", + "text": "董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/208.wav", + "text": "這代表什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/209.wav", + "text": "這代表你們任何小問題的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/210.wav", + "text": "不夠積極沒有機動性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/211.wav", + "text": "所以我要特別給董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/212.wav", + "text": "做一個參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/213.wav", + "text": "小問題解決就沒有大問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/214.wav", + "text": "如果以客為尊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/215.wav", + "text": "小問題都讓他們感覺到很舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/216.wav", + "text": "就變成沒有服務不周之理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/217.wav", + "text": "衛生很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/218.wav", + "text": "我們一定會檢討改進來加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/219.wav", + "text": "不是你們一年清潔委辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/220.wav", + "text": "編了那麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/221.wav", + "text": "難道要把這個東西全部刪掉嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/222.wav", + "text": "你們都是委辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/223.wav", + "text": "我們會再加強來督管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/224.wav", + "text": "我們一定會來改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/225.wav", + "text": "最後主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/226.wav", + "text": "我記得我上次在觀光署也來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/227.wav", + "text": "港務公司跟港務局這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/228.wav", + "text": "也就是每一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/229.wav", + "text": "基隆港也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/230.wav", + "text": "所以我希望部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/231.wav", + "text": "你們要特別督促觀光署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/232.wav", + "text": "還有局裡面跟港務公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/233.wav", + "text": "這裡一定要積極的想辦法趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/234.wav", + "text": "觀光景點不足或者其他的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/235.wav", + "text": "拜託部長這個非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/236.wav", + "text": "不要每一年往下墜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/237.wav", + "text": "這對我們臺灣觀光郵輪不來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/238.wav", + "text": "就沒有人來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/239.wav", + "text": "郵輪要停靠自然就要有觀光景點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/240.wav", + "text": "人家就要來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/241.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/242.wav", + "text": "所以為什麼大家都很喜歡去香港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/243.wav", + "text": "因為它有景點它有賣點嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/244.wav", + "text": "所以要拜託部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/245.wav", + "text": "好這個這是是一個非常重要的好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/246.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/247.wav", + "text": "謝謝林國成委員關心郵輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/248.wav", + "text": "我也很歡迎郵輪來停靠臺中港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158022/249.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委請一下陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/1.wav", + "text": "請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/2.wav", + "text": "杜董事長還有李董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/3.wav", + "text": "部長好現在地中海榮耀號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/4.wav", + "text": "本來預計昨天就要返回基隆港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/5.wav", + "text": "那因為引擎故障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/6.wav", + "text": "現在有大概1,880名的旅客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/7.wav", + "text": "仍然滯留在當地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/8.wav", + "text": "部長剛才提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/9.wav", + "text": "會請民航局盡力的協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/10.wav", + "text": "希望在大後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/11.wav", + "text": "讓所有旅客都能夠回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/12.wav", + "text": "部長要提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/13.wav", + "text": "啦昨天就應該要回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/14.wav", + "text": "然後你現在說要到大後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/15.wav", + "text": "才能夠將所有的旅客送回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/16.wav", + "text": "這個效率我認為是有待提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/17.wav", + "text": "今明兩天長榮已經有放大機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/18.wav", + "text": "加大機型的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/19.wav", + "text": "星宇也請你盡力協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/20.wav", + "text": "這個部分有在協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/21.wav", + "text": "希望能夠在後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/22.wav", + "text": "當然有很多行政或相關班次的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/23.wav", + "text": "但是我還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/24.wav", + "text": "你要展現你的效率跟能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/25.wav", + "text": "督促民航局儘量在後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/26.wav", + "text": "就能夠讓全部的旅客回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/27.wav", + "text": "我們會在今天明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/28.wav", + "text": "儘量讓速度加快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/29.wav", + "text": "另外還有旅客權益的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/30.wav", + "text": "它又分成兩種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/31.wav", + "text": "一種是旅行社的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/32.wav", + "text": "一種是散客的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/33.wav", + "text": "旅行社的要請觀光署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/34.wav", + "text": "趕快保障相關的旅客旅客的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/35.wav", + "text": "要請航港局來確保相關旅客權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/36.wav", + "text": "但是岸上行程的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/37.wav", + "text": "又是觀光署要來跟品保協會全力協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/38.wav", + "text": "散客的部分又不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/39.wav", + "text": "部長你簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/40.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/41.wav", + "text": "目前我們有跟船公司協調過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/42.wav", + "text": "對於這趟旅程的整個費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/43.wav", + "text": "他們會做全面的減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/44.wav", + "text": "也就是這一趟的旅程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/45.wav", + "text": "所有的費用都由船公司來吸收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/46.wav", + "text": "另外在當地的交通費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/47.wav", + "text": "他們也有200塊美金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/48.wav", + "text": "然後要回來臺灣的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/49.wav", + "text": "如果沒有坐他們的包機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/50.wav", + "text": "或者擴大機型的部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/51.wav", + "text": "可以有400塊美金的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/52.wav", + "text": "所以民眾的權益我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/53.wav", + "text": "這次的事件對部長是一個能力的基本考驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/54.wav", + "text": "你也可以透過這次的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/55.wav", + "text": "來了解民航局的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/56.wav", + "text": "航港局的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/57.wav", + "text": "觀光署的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/58.wav", + "text": "全力的督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/59.wav", + "text": "趕快做好相關的應變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/60.wav", + "text": "當然應變現在是由航港局在主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/61.wav", + "text": "這幾個單位部長要全力的督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/62.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/63.wav", + "text": "我們都開過會議都協調過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/64.wav", + "text": "好會要開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/65.wav", + "text": "我要看到效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/66.wav", + "text": "民眾都要看到效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/67.wav", + "text": "好我現在針對臺鐵的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/68.wav", + "text": "來請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/69.wav", + "text": "讓旅客能夠安全回家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/70.wav", + "text": "是交通部及臺鐵最重要的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/71.wav", + "text": "如果產生員工過勞的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/72.wav", + "text": "如何去確保旅客的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/73.wav", + "text": "這讓社會大眾會有很大的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/74.wav", + "text": "每天工作將近15小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/75.wav", + "text": "董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/76.wav", + "text": "人力不足是個嚴重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/77.wav", + "text": "東區的營運處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/78.wav", + "text": "以各單位來比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/79.wav", + "text": "前三名都是東區營運處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/80.wav", + "text": "工時是每個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/81.wav", + "text": "322小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/82.wav", + "text": "這還不是單一個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/83.wav", + "text": "簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/84.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/85.wav", + "text": "的確我們同仁工作都很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/86.wav", + "text": "基本上我們很注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/87.wav", + "text": "還是要符合勞基法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/88.wav", + "text": "但是在這個規定之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/89.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣能夠讓同仁的負擔不要那麼重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/90.wav", + "text": "同仁負擔很重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/91.wav", + "text": "董事長跟部長我提醒你們一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/92.wav", + "text": "及人數的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/93.wav", + "text": "我們看到30至35小時有469人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/94.wav", + "text": "35至40小時有511人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/95.wav", + "text": "40小時以上的有891人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/96.wav", + "text": "加班總人數達到5,725人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/97.wav", + "text": "加班30小時以上的就有1,871人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/98.wav", + "text": "這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/99.wav", + "text": "我看我們負責臺鐵營運安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/100.wav", + "text": "最重要的兩個單位是營運安全處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/101.wav", + "text": "跟職業安全衛生室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/102.wav", + "text": "他們的工時是平均的前兩名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/103.wav", + "text": "他們是要負責營運安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/104.wav", + "text": "耶他們工時那麼長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/105.wav", + "text": "我認為對營運安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/106.wav", + "text": "是很大的一個考驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/107.wav", + "text": "社會也會質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/108.wav", + "text": "董事長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/109.wav", + "text": "是跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/110.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員講的這個是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/111.wav", + "text": "這些加班超過35或甚至40小時的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/112.wav", + "text": "我們知道大部分都是在現場工作的運務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/113.wav", + "text": "還有機務的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/114.wav", + "text": "尤其是乘務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/115.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的運安處跟職安室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/116.wav", + "text": "因為他們主要也是輪班性的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/117.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們會從兩個方式來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/118.wav", + "text": "我們會再去調整他們的員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/119.wav", + "text": "讓每一個人平均分擔的工作能夠降下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/120.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/121.wav", + "text": "部長跟董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/122.wav", + "text": "我們現在最嚴重的是人力不足的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/123.wav", + "text": "我看我們的法定員額是1萬6,330人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/124.wav", + "text": "預算員額有1萬7,351人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/125.wav", + "text": "實際的員額現在只有1萬5,743人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/126.wav", + "text": "缺額是1,608人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/127.wav", + "text": "我看我們臺鐵的薪資待遇就是個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/128.wav", + "text": "因為薪資待遇以及工時的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/129.wav", + "text": "把臺鐵作為一個跳板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/130.wav", + "text": "或是有這個經歷之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/131.wav", + "text": "再轉到其他的軌道運輸事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/132.wav", + "text": "或其他國營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/133.wav", + "text": "工務跟電務是最嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/134.wav", + "text": "新進人員離職率將近五成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/135.wav", + "text": "運工機電的工務跟電務這個情況最嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/136.wav", + "text": "董事長不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/137.wav", + "text": "那如何改善嘛你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/138.wav", + "text": "因為是比較有技術性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/139.wav", + "text": "的確有這個情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/140.wav", + "text": "我們現在改善的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/141.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到就兩個主要的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/142.wav", + "text": "我們會去注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/143.wav", + "text": "還會再公告招考第二批" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/144.wav", + "text": "這是今年的第二批人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/145.wav", + "text": "你公告招考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/146.wav", + "text": "進來的離職率就將近五成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/147.wav", + "text": "部長工時待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/148.wav", + "text": "待遇跟工作環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/149.wav", + "text": "這個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/150.wav", + "text": "因為關係到旅客的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/151.wav", + "text": "發生了一件讓人很遺憾的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/152.wav", + "text": "11月20號上午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/153.wav", + "text": "最後不幸死亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/154.wav", + "text": "其實鐵道運輸安全第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/155.wav", + "text": "尤其是相關的駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/156.wav", + "text": "我們看到鐵路法第56條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/157.wav", + "text": "之4以及相關子法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/158.wav", + "text": "臺鐵高鐵都應該要編預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/159.wav", + "text": "讓員工定期來做相關的健康檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/160.wav", + "text": "包括駕駛行控乘務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/161.wav", + "text": "人員檢查頻率也都有一定的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/162.wav", + "text": "其中有個規範我要提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/163.wav", + "text": "部長跟董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/164.wav", + "text": "高鐵的行車人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/165.wav", + "text": "新進人員是6,400" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/166.wav", + "text": "塊定期檢查是5,800" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/167.wav", + "text": "塊檢查的項目比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/168.wav", + "text": "有運動心電圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/169.wav", + "text": "視野理學檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/170.wav", + "text": "藥毒物法定傳��病等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/171.wav", + "text": "臺鐵的定期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/172.wav", + "text": "體格檢查是1,100塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/173.wav", + "text": "健康檢查大概是3,000塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/174.wav", + "text": "加起來大概是4,100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/175.wav", + "text": "塊高鐵是5,800至6,400" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/176.wav", + "text": "塊我們是4,100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/177.wav", + "text": "對員工照顧不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/178.wav", + "text": "你們有什麼改善的措施嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/179.wav", + "text": "是跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/180.wav", + "text": "就是預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/181.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠在明年或者是後年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/182.wav", + "text": "至少向高鐵看齊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/183.wav", + "text": "好這個一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/184.wav", + "text": "這是最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/185.wav", + "text": "必須要全力地去督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/186.wav", + "text": "我再說一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/187.wav", + "text": "這是對你就任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/188.wav", + "text": "一個基本的考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/189.wav", + "text": "也驗證你的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/190.wav", + "text": "當然也讓你去了解民航局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/191.wav", + "text": "相關的效率跟能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/192.wav", + "text": "請你全力照顧旅客的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/193.wav", + "text": "益臺鐵員工的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/194.wav", + "text": "也請你全力督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158021/195.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/0.wav", + "text": "有請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/1.wav", + "text": "請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/2.wav", + "text": "部長有關地中海榮耀號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/3.wav", + "text": "現在據我所知還有1,800個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/4.wav", + "text": "在日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/5.wav", + "text": "因為全國民眾都很關心這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/6.wav", + "text": "能不能麻煩您跟我們先說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/7.wav", + "text": "現在目前最新的狀況是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/8.wav", + "text": "昨天發生這件事情之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/9.wav", + "text": "我們的航港局就積極在協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/10.wav", + "text": "包含民航局還有觀光署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/11.wav", + "text": "也積極在協調這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/12.wav", + "text": "我們希望在第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/13.wav", + "text": "可以讓我們的民眾趕快回到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/14.wav", + "text": "所以我們經過協調之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/15.wav", + "text": "今天跟明天總共會有5班飛機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/16.wav", + "text": "長榮跟華航會有5班飛機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/17.wav", + "text": "用擴大機型的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/18.wav", + "text": "今天跟明天總共可以多載運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/19.wav", + "text": "748位民眾回到臺灣來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/20.wav", + "text": "就是今天跟明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/21.wav", + "text": "也已經跟日方溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/22.wav", + "text": "也已經發文給日方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/23.wav", + "text": "希望能夠增加班機的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/24.wav", + "text": "也就是用包機的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/25.wav", + "text": "可以更快速的載運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/26.wav", + "text": "我們的民眾回到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/27.wav", + "text": "目前日方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/28.wav", + "text": "也就是沖繩那霸機場的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/29.wav", + "text": "已經有同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/30.wav", + "text": "我們也在跟船公司積極協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/31.wav", + "text": "臺灣這部分的運費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/32.wav", + "text": "就是票價的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/33.wav", + "text": "應該由船公司來吸收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/34.wav", + "text": "他們也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/35.wav", + "text": "所以有可能我剛剛在講的748位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/36.wav", + "text": "是擴大機型的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/37.wav", + "text": "在明天跟後天可以加入的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/38.wav", + "text": "我想運輸的速度會更快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/39.wav", + "text": "聽部長這樣報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/40.wav", + "text": "理論上應該是後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/41.wav", + "text": "甚至大後天才能全部運送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/42.wav", + "text": "送完畢對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/43.wav", + "text": "如果要全部回來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/44.wav", + "text": "可能要到大後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/45.wav", + "text": "大後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/46.wav", + "text": "可能要到大後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/47.wav", + "text": "當地的旅館也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/48.wav", + "text": "都是由船公司來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/49.wav", + "text": "由船公司來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/50.wav", + "text": "那艘船雖然不能夠移動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/51.wav", + "text": "但是它上面的設備設施都還可以使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/52.wav", + "text": "住宿的部分也沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/53.wav", + "text": "也就是說我們的旅客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/54.wav", + "text": "如果滯留在沖繩應該就是在船上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/55.wav", + "text": "直接住在他原本的房間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/56.wav", + "text": "一樣餐食的部分也都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/57.wav", + "text": "所以就不能開回來就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/58.wav", + "text": "對就是船不能開回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/59.wav", + "text": "它可能之後要進廠維修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/60.wav", + "text": "好至少我們本國旅客的權益沒有受損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/61.wav", + "text": "請問一下有關航運安全的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/62.wav", + "text": "跟航運安全的鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/63.wav", + "text": "是哪個單位去處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/64.wav", + "text": "是港務公��呢還是航港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/65.wav", + "text": "應該是航港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/66.wav", + "text": "好那我想請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/67.wav", + "text": "因為現在基隆有另外一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/68.wav", + "text": "除了郵輪之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/69.wav", + "text": "就是所謂的四接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/70.wav", + "text": "接四接的議題來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/71.wav", + "text": "因為我以前在港務公司工作過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/72.wav", + "text": "所以2015年的時候我有看過那份報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/73.wav", + "text": "人口密集的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/74.wav", + "text": "其實是非常不適合LNG" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/75.wav", + "text": "也就是所謂的液態天然氣上船或卸載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/76.wav", + "text": "可是我現在這邊看到台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/77.wav", + "text": "也就是說台電似乎要在四接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/78.wav", + "text": "也就是在基隆港的港嘴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/79.wav", + "text": "要去做出一個所謂LNG的發電廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/80.wav", + "text": "而不是當年2015" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/81.wav", + "text": "其實是2012年的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/82.wav", + "text": "本來在高雄外海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/83.wav", + "text": "要做出一個LNG的轉運站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/84.wav", + "text": "在旗津外海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/85.wav", + "text": "當然不是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/86.wav", + "text": "不過那時候交通部部長回我四個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/87.wav", + "text": "我後來私底下遇到他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/88.wav", + "text": "他又講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/89.wav", + "text": "他就把這個在旗津外海的LNG轉運站取消掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/90.wav", + "text": "但是依照同樣的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/91.wav", + "text": "居然要在基隆港的港嘴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/92.wav", + "text": "而且同時會遇到國際商港的航道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/93.wav", + "text": "那我就想請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/94.wav", + "text": "在這個報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/95.wav", + "text": "我的記憶如果沒有錯的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/96.wav", + "text": "每年基隆港所帶給國家的稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/97.wav", + "text": "是1,100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/98.wav", + "text": "也就是說一天就有3億的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/99.wav", + "text": "如果有擱淺的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/100.wav", + "text": "一艘船擱淺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/101.wav", + "text": "跟一台車在路邊報廢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/102.wav", + "text": "處理的時間完全不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/103.wav", + "text": "鈺洲號現在還是留在金山萬里的外海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/104.wav", + "text": "極端狀況就是LNG出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/105.wav", + "text": "基本上沒有個四五天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/106.wav", + "text": "應該是救不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/107.wav", + "text": "是航安政策的執行者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/108.wav", + "text": "也是鑑定者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/109.wav", + "text": "您會認同現在四接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/110.wav", + "text": "四接基隆港港口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/111.wav", + "text": "面對基隆港商港航道港嘴這樣的設計嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/112.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/113.wav", + "text": "我想針對四接的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/114.wav", + "text": "經濟部已經責成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/115.wav", + "text": "台電公司委託專業的第三公正單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/116.wav", + "text": "針對驗證的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/117.wav", + "text": "也提出了相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/118.wav", + "text": "的水工模型試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/119.wav", + "text": "也提出了相關的應該要執行的配套措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/120.wav", + "text": "其中包括應該要建立嚴謹的LNG" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/121.wav", + "text": "進出港的條件跟指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/122.wav", + "text": "我想委員很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/123.wav", + "text": "像臺中港西碼頭區的LNG船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/124.wav", + "text": "前後相距的距離就要幾百公尺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/125.wav", + "text": "而且前後左右的間距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/126.wav", + "text": "也需要有具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/127.wav", + "text": "你講的臺中港西碼頭區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/128.wav", + "text": "附近住多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/129.wav", + "text": "請問您知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/130.wav", + "text": "目前的預定地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/131.wav", + "text": "在陳部長上任之前就出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/132.wav", + "text": "基隆市中山區人口密度多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/133.wav", + "text": "請問你知道旁邊住多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/134.wav", + "text": "所以旁邊至少有超過500人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/135.wav", + "text": "我記得沒有錯的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/136.wav", + "text": "應該有三到四個里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/137.wav", + "text": "里靠近這個港區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/138.wav", + "text": "就是未來準備要做四接碼頭的地方附近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/139.wav", + "text": "應該有5,000個居民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/140.wav", + "text": "也有5,000個居民嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/141.wav", + "text": "是的所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/142.wav", + "text": "也有5,000個居民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/143.wav", + "text": "那邊沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/144.wav", + "text": "所以對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/145.wav", + "text": "我為什麼要這樣講的原因就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/146.wav", + "text": "很實際的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/147.wav", + "text": "如果在高雄的港區內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/148.wav", + "text": "應該是同一批有關安全這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/149.wav", + "text": "不應該有雙標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/150.wav", + "text": "也不應該會有雙標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/151.wav", + "text": "這是完全的科學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/152.wav", + "text": "完全沒有任何質疑的餘地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/153.wav", + "text": "如果2015年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/154.wav", + "text": "港務公司跟我講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/155.wav", + "text": "高雄港港區絕對不能做LNG的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/156.wav", + "text": "那你現在跟我講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/157.wav", + "text": "基隆港港區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/158.wav", + "text": "就要做個LNG的發電廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/159.wav", + "text": "請問一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/160.wav", + "text": "您覺得這個情何以堪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/161.wav", + "text": "我想安全性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/162.wav", + "text": "一定要用科學的方式去評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/163.wav", + "text": "如果真的是不安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/164.wav", + "text": "那當然不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/165.wav", + "text": "評估出來如果是安全的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/166.wav", + "text": "那也要有辦法說服我們大家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/167.wav", + "text": "它怎麼樣帶來大家的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/168.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/169.wav", + "text": "目前設定的點是在那個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/170.wav", + "text": "我相信基隆市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/171.wav", + "text": "應該也有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/172.wav", + "text": "他們在這方面的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/173.wav", + "text": "這個部分大家其實可以在環評的會議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/174.wav", + "text": "也可以用科學的方式去驗證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/175.wav", + "text": "本席的態度很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/176.wav", + "text": "因為一方面來講是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/177.wav", + "text": "整個地方產業很重要的一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/178.wav", + "text": "1,100億一年一年的收入有3億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/179.wav", + "text": "目前基隆港港區所製造的工作機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/180.wav", + "text": "超過1萬3,000人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/181.wav", + "text": "也就是1萬3,000個家庭是靠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/182.wav", + "text": "導致這個商港的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/183.wav", + "text": "不要講被廢被阻礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/184.wav", + "text": "甚至北部航運都是非常傷的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/185.wav", + "text": "我再重申我的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/186.wav", + "text": "如果沒有航道安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/187.wav", + "text": "我再次在這邊重申我的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158020/188.wav", + "text": "這是必然要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/0.wav", + "text": "主席委員還有各位官員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/1.wav", + "text": "我想請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/2.wav", + "text": "有請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/3.wav", + "text": "你有聽聞今天包含桃園市產業總工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/4.wav", + "text": "還有很多勞團要聯合起來絕食100個小時嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/5.wav", + "text": "有我有看到相關的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/6.wav", + "text": "那你也知道他們有針對三大議題要請您回應嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/7.wav", + "text": "是我在他們的資訊裡面有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/8.wav", + "text": "好全國的勞工已經氣炸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/9.wav", + "text": "因為你們本該是捍衛全國勞工的勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/10.wav", + "text": "結果最近是揮霍公帑被看破手腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/11.wav", + "text": "所以他們有三個要回應的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/12.wav", + "text": "第一個是全面檢討基金的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/13.wav", + "text": "包括相關部會如實的揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/14.wav", + "text": "第二個是強化基金審查委員會成員的專業度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/15.wav", + "text": "並且由第三方建立真正外部監督的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/16.wav", + "text": "第三個對於勞動部長久以來遲遲沒有回應的重大勞動議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/17.wav", + "text": "比如增加國定假日等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/18.wav", + "text": "希望藉由絕食讓你聽到他們的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/19.wav", + "text": "你現在初步有想要利用這樣的場合回應嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/20.wav", + "text": "其實這裡面幾個訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/21.wav", + "text": "尤其我們看到針對就安基金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/22.wav", + "text": "我們上週其實就已經開始非常非常密切的在檢討了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/23.wav", + "text": "甚至也開始邀請一些外部有相關專業的專家來給我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/24.wav", + "text": "我自己也認為就安基金整體的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/25.wav", + "text": "要朝向更監理化的方向來做檢討跟調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/26.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛也提到包括像現在就安基金的收支管理辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/27.wav", + "text": "也在整體檢討的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/28.wav", + "text": "所以您會到現場回應還是你在這邊回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/29.wav", + "text": "或是等一下跟媒體朋友做回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/30.wav", + "text": "沒有其實對我們來說這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/31.wav", + "text": "我們就是要努力大力的往前做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/32.wav", + "text": "把事情做出來才是最好回應的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/33.wav", + "text": "好再來我們就看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/34.wav", + "text": "你的就安基金現在為什麼大家會非常的生氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/35.wav", + "text": "我們先看左邊這個圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/36.wav", + "text": "我已經幫你整理出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/37.wav", + "text": "我們看到勞動部粉專經營管理網路行銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/38.wav", + "text": "還有文宣媒體通路採購案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/39.wav", + "text": "簡單來說就是大內宣大外宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/40.wav", + "text": "111年從就安基金出了20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/41.wav", + "text": "然後186萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/42.wav", + "text": "林林總總的我先幫你加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/43.wav", + "text": "因為這些項目連續3年都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/44.wav", + "text": "全部加起來是1億2,544萬6,480元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/45.wav", + "text": "可能演唱會也包含在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/46.wav", + "text": "因為是媒體通路採購案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/47.wav", + "text": "比起你右邊這個真的是令人很心寒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/48.wav", + "text": "右邊是你們的公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/49.wav", + "text": "針對勞動條件及就業平等業務工作計畫的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/50.wav", + "text": "也只編了9,714萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/51.wav", + "text": "那做這些媒體宣傳粉專大外宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/52.wav", + "text": "就花了1億2,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/53.wav", + "text": "你覺得這樣的作法正確嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/54.wav", + "text": "你這個就安基金顧名思義就是要幫助國人就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/55.wav", + "text": "創造國人的就業機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/56.wav", + "text": "結果被部長挪用去做媒體宣傳的採購費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/57.wav", + "text": "我們知道現在大家都在檢討這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/58.wav", + "text": "但我自己覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/59.wav", + "text": "其實我們有很多政策或相關的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/60.wav", + "text": "要怎麼讓更多可能失業的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/61.wav", + "text": "或者是有需要的勞工可以知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/62.wav", + "text": "這裡面確實也是需要有一些宣傳推廣的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/63.wav", + "text": "所以我並不認為所有編列在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/64.wav", + "text": "的經費都能夠叫做大外宣或大內宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/65.wav", + "text": "讓大家能夠知道現在的政策跟資源編列到哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/66.wav", + "text": "這部分我要先說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/67.wav", + "text": "但是你們是從111年到113年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/68.wav", + "text": "逐年不斷的上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/69.wav", + "text": "你看從3,812萬到最後是4,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/70.wav", + "text": "是所以我要說明是就像這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/71.wav", + "text": "我OK你覺得這些東西宣傳很有必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/72.wav", + "text": "但是你也該拿出實際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/73.wav", + "text": "對於就業安定有什麼指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/74.wav", + "text": "是所以我再補充一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/75.wav", + "text": "但是對於這裡面有一些宣傳的形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/76.wav", + "text": "是不是有讓外界覺得觀感不佳的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/77.wav", + "text": "這當然我們現在正在檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/78.wav", + "text": "它就是大外宣大內宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/79.wav", + "text": "可是就裡面項目的形式該檢討的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/80.wav", + "text": "我們現在也正在檢討中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/81.wav", + "text": "好這件事情最荒謬的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/82.wav", + "text": "我去查閱了您擔任第10屆立法委員的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/83.wav", + "text": "整整8個會期都在衛環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/84.wav", + "text": "衛環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/85.wav", + "text": "也就是編列這些預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/86.wav", + "text": "許銘春部長在編列這些預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/87.wav", + "text": "你就在這邊擔任監督者的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/88.wav", + "text": "你那個時候就沒有監督好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/89.wav", + "text": "或者是你那個時候覺得OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/90.wav", + "text": "這些都很合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/91.wav", + "text": "結果現在呢你還要回來抓漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/92.wav", + "text": "耶你不覺得這整件事很荒謬嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/93.wav", + "text": "跟陳委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/94.wav", + "text": "當然我現在是以勞動部長的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/95.wav", + "text": "去處理我該面對該解決的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/96.wav", + "text": "所以我現在很清楚知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/97.wav", + "text": "在這個時間點上面我的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/98.wav", + "text": "所以你的意思是你以前沒有抓出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/99.wav", + "text": "你以前8個會期都沒有看出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/100.wav", + "text": "但是你現在看出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/101.wav", + "text": "你是這個意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/102.wav", + "text": "我覺得也不是這樣去引申的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/103.wav", + "text": "但我能說我現在是一個勞動部長的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/104.wav", + "text": "我就必須在這個角色上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/105.wav", + "text": "做好我現在必須面對問題的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/106.wav", + "text": "所以你現在覺得你當時可能不夠嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/107.wav", + "text": "沒有看出這些預算的貓膩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/108.wav", + "text": "我覺得也不是這樣延伸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/109.wav", + "text": "我自己也很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/110.wav", + "text": "包括跟國會我們一起合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/111.wav", + "text": "接下來可能陸陸續續會有更多資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/112.wav", + "text": "就像我剛才說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/113.wav", + "text": "讓管理的機制更監理化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/114.wav", + "text": "甚至某些部分的資訊應該必要地揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/115.wav", + "text": "本席只是想告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/116.wav", + "text": "看到這樣子的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/117.wav", + "text": "一邊是做媒體宣傳粉專花費1億2,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/118.wav", + "text": "一邊是認真的公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/119.wav", + "text": "做勞動條件就業平等花費9,714" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/120.wav", + "text": "萬如果你把這1.2億的血汗錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/121.wav", + "text": "拿去提升不管是勞檢員的福利培訓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/122.wav", + "text": "我們現在也在看怎麼樣重新檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/123.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣該補充的把它補上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/124.wav", + "text": "但我覺得這兩件事情不見得是直接相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/125.wav", + "text": "只要在這一筆預算上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/126.wav", + "text": "有哪些項目真的有不妥的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/127.wav", + "text": "沒關係全國人民都在等你對就安基金的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/128.wav", + "text": "你當立委的時候通過的這些就安基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/129.wav", + "text": "現在你要來檢討它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/130.wav", + "text": "大家都在看你要怎麼檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/131.wav", + "text": "今年3月5月7月8月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/132.wav", + "text": "分別從第5次會議進展到第8次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/133.wav", + "text": "以及勞動部三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/134.wav", + "text": "對於還沒有訂定外送員專法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/135.wav", + "text": "以前各項爭議問題的解決機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/136.wav", + "text": "之前是每兩個月就會開一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/137.wav", + "text": "但第8次至今" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/138.wav", + "text": "過了4個月遲遲都沒有再召開第9次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/139.wav", + "text": "你知道為什麼嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/140.wav", + "text": "就我所知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/141.wav", + "text": "12月中應該就會召開下一次的第9次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/142.wav", + "text": "包括外送員的報酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/143.wav", + "text": "都是現在大家最關注的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/144.wav", + "text": "我也要求12月就應該儘速召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/145.wav", + "text": "對我知道你也蠻重視這樣子的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/146.wav", + "text": "因為第8次之前都是部內的司長出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/147.wav", + "text": "那您會有意願出席第9次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/148.wav", + "text": "相挺外送員嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/149.wav", + "text": "如果有需要的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/150.wav", + "text": "其實我都不排斥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/151.wav", + "text": "可是在這個平臺重點在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/152.wav", + "text": "我覺得這裡面可能不只是挺或不挺的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/153.wav", + "text": "我們當然要站在外送員勞動權益的角度出發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/154.wav", + "text": "但因為這涉及到不同利害關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/155.wav", + "text": "係人重點還是在溝通協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/156.wav", + "text": "有一個很大的爭議就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/157.wav", + "text": "經濟補償方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/158.wav", + "text": "這個你也都很熟知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/159.wav", + "text": "您現在有什麼有效的解方可以提出來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/160.wav", + "text": "其實在第9次的平臺會議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/161.wav", + "text": "就會處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/162.wav", + "text": "您會有意願想要自己出席嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/163.wav", + "text": "我跟業務單位討論一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/164.wav", + "text": "但我是說勞動部整體而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/165.wav", + "text": "對於外送員勞動權利的支持立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/166.wav", + "text": "這是我們很清楚的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/167.wav", + "text": "好那我們就期待你的第9次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/168.wav", + "text": "再來中華電信近年來當然是非常賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/169.wav", + "text": "它是交通部轉民營化的事業單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/170.wav", + "text": "中央政府也是最大股東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/171.wav", + "text": "剛剛我聽您的業務報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/172.wav", + "text": "您在第七點第八點都講得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/173.wav", + "text": "你要做勞資雙方協商的推手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/174.wav", + "text": "建立勞資雙方的平臺等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/175.wav", + "text": "但您知道現在中華電信的工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/176.wav", + "text": "正夜宿於他們的總部嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/177.wav", + "text": "知道當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/178.wav", + "text": "所以我想請教部長的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/179.wav", + "text": "是如果中華電信員工的訴求沒有太過分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/180.wav", + "text": "您有沒有什麼積極的舉動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/181.wav", + "text": "想要應援他們支持他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/182.wav", + "text": "我其實就已經跟業務單位說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/183.wav", + "text": "當然現在他們可能會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/184.wav", + "text": "開始進行一些勞資方面的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/185.wav", + "text": "而哪些部分是勞動部可以協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/186.wav", + "text": "我們當然要採協助勞工的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/187.wav", + "text": "有啊因為剛剛的報告你寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/188.wav", + "text": "你說強化勞資協商能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/189.wav", + "text": "這是勞動部的關鍵功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/190.wav", + "text": "輔導及獎勵勞資雙方協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/191.wav", + "text": "輔導及獎勵勞資雙方簽訂團體協約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/192.wav", + "text": "落實勞資會議制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/193.wav", + "text": "及迅速有效勞資爭議處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/194.wav", + "text": "這都是你剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/195.wav", + "text": "所以我就說這個事情我們願意跟交通部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/196.wav", + "text": "當然是會站在怎麼樣更大程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/197.wav", + "text": "上能夠協助工會及勞工的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/198.wav", + "text": "作為我們表達想法的出發點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/199.wav", + "text": "可能有一些工會的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/200.wav", + "text": "現在正在看電視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/201.wav", + "text": "其實我都跟我部會的同仁說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/202.wav", + "text": "了我們不會說現在就是勞資協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/203.wav", + "text": "而讓他們自己去協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/204.wav", + "text": "在這個協商的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/205.wav", + "text": "哪些事情是勞動部可以協助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/206.wav", + "text": "我們就應該協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/207.wav", + "text": "有我剛剛已經唸給你聽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/208.wav", + "text": "您會做好吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/209.wav", + "text": "您剛剛講的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/210.wav", + "text": "你的關鍵功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/211.wav", + "text": "今天報告列了四五項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/212.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/213.wav", + "text": "我們希望盡力做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/214.wav", + "text": "但因為這確實涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/215.wav", + "text": "不同利害關係人各方之間的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/216.wav", + "text": "所以會在我們能夠扮演的角色上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/217.wav", + "text": "盡力協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/218.wav", + "text": "您會願意過去中華電信工會那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158019/219.wav", + "text": "為他們打氣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/0.wav", + "text": "有請洪部長代理署長及司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/1.wav", + "text": "部長早想問部長過年過節送禮是習俗你過年會送禮嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/2.wav", + "text": "我必要的會但是我知道委員想問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/3.wav", + "text": "我認為應該要盡力地避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/4.wav", + "text": "是部長11月26號上任就已經對勞發署宣布取消送禮文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/5.wav", + "text": "跟挑戰勞動部內部相互送禮向上管理的文官文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/6.wav", + "text": "當然近日外界也在不斷質疑就業基金的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/7.wav", + "text": "可是本席了解勞動部過往送禮也會使用就安基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/8.wav", + "text": "其中很大的數量事實上是用來採購身心障礙者庇護工場的產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/9.wav", + "text": "因為我一直很關心我們的身障朋友們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/10.wav", + "text": "他們要在這個庇護工場工作才能得到自己所需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/11.wav", + "text": "也才能夠建構他的未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/12.wav", + "text": "所以對於身心障礙者庇護性就業有很大的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/13.wav", + "text": "庇護工場有賺錢就更有能力去聘僱更多的身心障礙者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/14.wav", + "text": "所以想問部長的是要對抗不當的送禮文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/15.wav", + "text": "可是我們還是期待同時要支持這些庇護性的就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/16.wav", + "text": "更要落實監督就安基金的支出你怎麼權衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/17.wav", + "text": "這兩件事情是我們都要兼顧的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/18.wav", + "text": "所以不必要的送禮我們認為要避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/19.wav", + "text": "第二個事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/20.wav", + "text": "部內接下來如果有採購禮盒的需求的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/21.wav", + "text": "我已經有指示下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/22.wav", + "text": "一定是要以庇護工場的商品為優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/23.wav", + "text": "然是大力的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/24.wav", + "text": "甚至不只是對於他們產品的採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/25.wav", + "text": "我們也希望看怎麼樣來協助他們更大力地做行銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/26.wav", + "text": "包括有很多可能在行銷計畫的介面上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/27.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼更大力地支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/28.wav", + "text": "讓這些庇護工場本身有能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/29.wav", + "text": "有更多的餘裕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/30.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個事情不是權衡的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/31.wav", + "text": "這件事情是我們必須兼顧的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/32.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/33.wav", + "text": "我真的要幫這些身心障礙者朋友講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/34.wav", + "text": "因為我來自社福" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/35.wav", + "text": "接下來當然推動庇護性就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/36.wav", + "text": "支持庇護工場一直是發展署的施政重點之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/37.wav", + "text": "可是勞動力發展署身心障礙者就業資源網裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/38.wav", + "text": "對庇護工場的推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/39.wav", + "text": "我們覺得實在是不及格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/40.wav", + "text": "為什麼這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/41.wav", + "text": "只有用一個頁面去推廣庇護工場的產品資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/42.wav", + "text": "而且視覺非常單調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/43.wav", + "text": "連產品的圖片都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/44.wav", + "text": "也看不到價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/45.wav", + "text": "那看不到價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/46.wav", + "text": "當然你就沒有辦法讓人家知道到底我要買的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/47.wav", + "text": "政府對於推動庇護工場產品的行銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/48.wav", + "text": "只靠傳統的DM" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/49.wav", + "text": "這樣的想法會不會太落後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/50.wav", + "text": "跟農業部的網頁相比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/51.wav", + "text": "有沒有水準差人家很多的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/52.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/53.wav", + "text": "對不起我沒有看過農業部的相關網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/54.wav", + "text": "但是從剛剛委員所出示的這個頁面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/55.wav", + "text": "我們會持續來改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/56.wav", + "text": "希望你們要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/57.wav", + "text": "甚至更多政府部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/58.wav", + "text": "可以來採買我們的身心障礙者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/59.wav", + "text": "庇護工場所做出來的產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/60.wav", + "text": "這部分我們會用更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/61.wav", + "text": "更多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/62.wav", + "text": "甚至更有效的方式來協助庇護工場的行銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/63.wav", + "text": "甚至我自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/64.wav", + "text": "親身來做這些相關的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/65.wav", + "text": "這部分我們會非常非常重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/66.wav", + "text": "如果林委員這邊有更多的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/67.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/68.wav", + "text": "因為我們覺得讓弱勢者得到就業機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/69.wav", + "text": "他才能夠去照顧他家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/70.wav", + "text": "者這個孩子能夠自立的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/71.wav", + "text": "也能夠得到一頓溫飽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/72.wav", + "text": "所以優化網頁才能有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/73.wav", + "text": "地讓更多的網友們或民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/74.wav", + "text": "看到庇護工場的產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/75.wav", + "text": "到底有哪些好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/76.wav", + "text": "所以不是只有就安基金來買這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/77.wav", + "text": "我覺得要花在支持庇護性就業跟工場裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/78.wav", + "text": "所以本席要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/79.wav", + "text": "研議出優化庇護工場產品販售的網站期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/80.wav", + "text": "我其實是覺得時間可以更短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/81.wav", + "text": "那太好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/82.wav", + "text": "因為這對他們來講真的是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/83.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/84.wav", + "text": "再來想問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/85.wav", + "text": "今年7月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/86.wav", + "text": "本院就通過了勞動基準法第54條的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/87.wav", + "text": "規定勞工年屆65歲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/88.wav", + "text": "可以跟雇主協商延緩退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/89.wav", + "text": "法律公布之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/90.wav", + "text": "勞工普遍有比較高的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/91.wav", + "text": "但同時又憂心修法後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/92.wav", + "text": "看得到吃不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/93.wav", + "text": "所以想問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/94.wav", + "text": "如何有效地透過這樣的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/95.wav", + "text": "達到延緩退休的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/96.wav", + "text": "這更是極為關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/97.wav", + "text": "修法是為了改變現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/98.wav", + "text": "不要讓勞工空歡喜一場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/99.wav", + "text": "所以想問謝司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/100.wav", + "text": "還有署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/101.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/102.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣有效促進協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/103.wav", + "text": "我來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/104.wav", + "text": "感謝委員關心這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/105.wav", + "text": "我們希望讓有意願留在職場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/106.wav", + "text": "的勞工能夠續留職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/107.wav", + "text": "也讓雇主能夠讓高齡勞工續留職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/108.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員關心的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/109.wav", + "text": "就是因為這是要勞資雙方去協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/110.wav", + "text": "勞工工時不變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/111.wav", + "text": "工作不變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/112.wav", + "text": "可是工資下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/113.wav", + "text": "怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/114.wav", + "text": "我們會在協商指引上面明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/115.wav", + "text": "而他的工作條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/116.wav", + "text": "工作內容都不改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/117.wav", + "text": "其實他的勞動條件是不能夠變更的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/118.wav", + "text": "司長你也一直強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/119.wav", + "text": "中高齡者跟高齡者就業促進法第十二條的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/120.wav", + "text": "禁止就業歧視不可違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/121.wav", + "text": "可是法不入家門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/122.wav", + "text": "你怎麼去叫雇主遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/123.wav", + "text": "雇主若不遵守的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/124.wav", + "text": "摸摸鼻子是不是就只能接受不利的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/125.wav", + "text": "當然依照中高齡就業專法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/126.wav", + "text": "所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/127.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/128.wav", + "text": "有委員剛剛擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/129.wav", + "text": "的或勞工朋友擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/130.wav", + "text": "他其實是可以向縣市政府去申訴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/131.wav", + "text": "對申訴最後就罰錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/132.wav", + "text": "可是他的工作可能也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/133.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/134.wav", + "text": "我們相關的業務單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/135.wav", + "text": "接下來會把這個協商的參考指引訂出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/136.wav", + "text": "目前可能會在兩個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/137.wav", + "text": "把它訂出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/138.wav", + "text": "但我其實也要求同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/139.wav", + "text": "我們不只是把指引訂出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/140.wav", + "text": "我們要站在協助勞工的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/141.wav", + "text": "所以不是說今天這個指引訂出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/142.wav", + "text": "就只是請勞工自己去協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/143.wav", + "text": "我們勞動部要站在協助勞工的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/144.wav", + "text": "站在怎麼樣替勞工爭取更大更好的條件的這個立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/145.wav", + "text": "去推動這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/146.wav", + "text": "我其實已經有跟負責業務的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/147.wav", + "text": "好也謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/148.wav", + "text": "你現在有法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/149.wav", + "text": "可是申訴的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/150.wav", + "text": "結果勞工反而失去工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/151.wav", + "text": "可是這協商的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/152.wav", + "text": "對他們來講真的是很不利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/153.wav", + "text": "因為就業市場有時候難免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/154.wav", + "text": "有不可避免的流動性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/155.wav", + "text": "除了要追求穩定就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/156.wav", + "text": "政府真的有義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/157.wav", + "text": "有責任去找到就業機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/158.wav", + "text": "開創再就業市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/159.wav", + "text": "特別是要主動地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/160.wav", + "text": "北分署的銀髮人才服務據點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/161.wav", + "text": "它是主動找廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/162.wav", + "text": "這個我上次質詢的時候就有講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/163.wav", + "text": "這個方式非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/164.wav", + "text": "找求職者並做媒合的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/165.wav", + "text": "應該要擴大到全國的368個鄉鎮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/166.wav", + "text": "因為111跟104" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/167.wav", + "text": "大概都是網站的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/168.wav", + "text": "可是到底就業的機會在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/169.wav", + "text": "有沒有主動去找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/170.wav", + "text": "中高齡及高齡者的就業促進計畫當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/171.wav", + "text": "113年訂定的工作機會發展計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/172.wav", + "text": "全國要開發3萬6,850個職缺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/173.wav", + "text": "請問到目前為止開發了多少職缺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/174.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/175.wav", + "text": "因為開發職缺的工作是持續不斷進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/176.wav", + "text": "我們也認為中高齡朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/177.wav", + "text": "這個職缺目前媒合了多少人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/178.wav", + "text": "不過這些職缺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/179.wav", + "text": "如果不是符合他們的狀態的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/180.wav", + "text": "開發了這個可能也是沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/181.wav", + "text": "對所以我們對於中高齡朋友的工作機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/182.wav", + "text": "一直強調的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/183.wav", + "text": "能夠儘量兼顧他們在家庭的生活需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/184.wav", + "text": "跟自己未來的職涯發展需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/185.wav", + "text": "所以朝向彈性化跟部分工時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/186.wav", + "text": "一直是我們努力的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/187.wav", + "text": "所以一直以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/188.wav", + "text": "我覺得政府就業服務的留任率都很有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/189.wav", + "text": "就是你要靠獎助金去支撐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/190.wav", + "text": "在僱用獎助金到期後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/191.wav", + "text": "超過一年的人數有多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/192.wav", + "text": "我們目前的僱用獎助是鼓勵雇主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/193.wav", + "text": "僱用這些中高齡或特定對象朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/194.wav", + "text": "那僱用的期程是12個月為補助的期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/195.wav", + "text": "希望還是要提供一些統計數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/196.wav", + "text": "讓我們更精準的去了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/197.wav", + "text": "是我們會再提供給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/198.wav", + "text": "因為我們辦公室一直都收到這樣的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/199.wav", + "text": "你們鼓勵持續就業還有再就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/200.wav", + "text": "可是有沒有好好的面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/201.wav", + "text": "中高齡被逼退假優退的社會問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/202.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟到一個主管職缺的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/203.wav", + "text": "通常薪水比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/204.wav", + "text": "雇主付的薪水比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/205.wav", + "text": "或55歲被逼退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/206.wav", + "text": "所以我想問的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/207.wav", + "text": "所謂的優退搞不好都是假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/208.wav", + "text": "勞工只能吞下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/209.wav", + "text": "被逼退之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/210.wav", + "text": "後來又用比較低的薪水來邀請你工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/211.wav", + "text": "對於這些人數性別年齡區間的掌握程度是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/212.wav", + "text": "還有這些人退休前的薪資待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/213.wav", + "text": "你們有掌握嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/214.wav", + "text": "勞動部就相關的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/215.wav", + "text": "他不是資遣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/216.wav", + "text": "有時候是用優退的方式逼著你退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/217.wav", + "text": "整體協商的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/218.wav", + "text": "這也是為什麼我們要用這些相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/219.wav", + "text": "中得到更多的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/220.wav", + "text": "在細節的部分我請跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/221.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/222.wav", + "text": "雇主不能用任何理由去強迫一個員工接受優退的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/223.wav", + "text": "都這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/224.wav", + "text": "可是實際上我們辦公室真的收到這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/225.wav", + "text": "的陳情雖然用優退比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/226.wav", + "text": "可是也在職場當中用某種型態逼著他要退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/227.wav", + "text": "他退出之後大概很難再找到工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/228.wav", + "text": "所以我們自己在看數據也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/229.wav", + "text": "啊就是我們60歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/230.wav", + "text": "的勞參率跟其他國家比也是比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/231.wav", + "text": "的很多時候有沒有真的去了解真實的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/232.wav", + "text": "講優退的到底是不是真實的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/233.wav", + "text": "哪些部分我們可以再多做協助好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/234.wav", + "text": "我現在接到單一的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/235.wav", + "text": "一些個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/236.wav", + "text": "單一個案可以擴及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/237.wav", + "text": "霸凌不敢去申訴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/238.wav", + "text": "最後你還是不會得到訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/239.wav", + "text": "這次事實上是#MeToo事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/240.wav", + "text": "才會讓更多人跳出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/241.wav", + "text": "這件事情勞動部也要去思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/242.wav", + "text": "怎麼去了解到真實的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/243.wav", + "text": "或者是有沒有一些申訴的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/244.wav", + "text": "不要認為優退就是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/245.wav", + "text": "可是實際上他才50歲或55歲就被逼退了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/246.wav", + "text": "這部分我們會來檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158018/247.wav", + "text": "好再麻煩部長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席有請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/1.wav", + "text": "請洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/2.wav", + "text": "部長早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/3.wav", + "text": "我今天要跟你談大林電廠的鬼故事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/4.wav", + "text": "部長大林電廠用了不少不合格的防爆電氣管配件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/5.wav", + "text": "也曾質詢過何部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/6.wav", + "text": "我也跟民眾黨其他委員一起召開過記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/7.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜我收到經濟部下面的財團法人金屬中心的正式檢測報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/8.wav", + "text": "他們按照CNS國家的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/9.wav", + "text": "還有國際ASTM的作業規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/10.wav", + "text": "幫助勞動部職安署對大林電廠抽測的防爆電氣管配件進行完整的檢測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/11.wav", + "text": "我先請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/12.wav", + "text": "金屬中心是政府掌控的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/13.wav", + "text": "他們的報告應該具有公正性跟準確性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/14.wav", + "text": "當然金屬中心的報告當然都有它的參考性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/15.wav", + "text": "好部長請你看簡報上右邊這張表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/16.wav", + "text": "它是檢測結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/17.wav", + "text": "我問過金屬中心上面的製造廠商產品名稱型號抽測地點都是台電提供的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/18.wav", + "text": "他們只是照打上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/19.wav", + "text": "然後最後一欄石墨球化率的百分比是金屬中心把檢測結果填上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/20.wav", + "text": "按照台電採購的規範及所提供的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/21.wav", + "text": "台電採購防爆氣管配件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/22.wav", + "text": "材質必須是鋼或是球墨鑄鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/23.wav", + "text": "而球墨鑄鐵依照國家的CNS標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/24.wav", + "text": "石墨球化率必須是80%以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/25.wav", + "text": "才可稱為球墨鑄鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/26.wav", + "text": "但是我們從檢測結果來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/27.wav", + "text": "部長你看到這個紅框框起來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/28.wav", + "text": "所以是屬於不合格的產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/29.wav", + "text": "請問勞動部收到這份報告後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/30.wav", + "text": "有做任何調查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/31.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告那個報告我們有收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/32.wav", + "text": "我們有找另外一家公司再做double check" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/33.wav", + "text": "你在調查中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/34.wav", + "text": "我等你的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/35.wav", + "text": "那我想請部長仔細看這個項目8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/36.wav", + "text": "依照台電提供給金屬中心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/37.wav", + "text": "資料製造廠商是正鶴公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/38.wav", + "text": "產品叫圓型接線盒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/39.wav", + "text": "球化率是0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/40.wav", + "text": "0就是相當於最低階的灰口鑄鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/41.wav", + "text": "部長外面大馬路上的水溝蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/42.wav", + "text": "就是這種材質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/43.wav", + "text": "不可能防爆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/44.wav", + "text": "但是我也請你看項目10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/45.wav", + "text": "的產品名稱也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/46.wav", + "text": "都是圓型接線盒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/47.wav", + "text": "但球化率有88%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/48.wav", + "text": "那就是合格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/49.wav", + "text": "請你先牢牢記住這兩個項目好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/50.wav", + "text": "我認為就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/51.wav", + "text": "任何人任何立委都不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/52.wav", + "text": "涉入去喬事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/53.wav", + "text": "因為我們的職責是監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/54.wav", + "text": "部長你同意或支持我這個觀點嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/55.wav", + "text": "委員這個立場是沒有錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/56.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/57.wav", + "text": "我的個性絕對不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/58.wav", + "text": "有弊端就該追究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/59.wav", + "text": "但是我無法接受台電內部人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/60.wav", + "text": "竟然有人想藉著這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/61.wav", + "text": "當立委的手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/62.wav", + "text": "去修理特定廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/63.wav", + "text": "利用你嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/64.wav", + "text": "對為什麼我這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/65.wav", + "text": "還有包括職安署的檢測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/66.wav", + "text": "剛剛我提到那10個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/67.wav", + "text": "他抽了很多項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/68.wav", + "text": "但是其中有7項是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/69.wav", + "text": "台電指定給職安署抽的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/70.wav", + "text": "防爆管配件中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/71.wav", + "text": "明顯是有斑駁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/72.wav", + "text": "圓型接線盒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/73.wav", + "text": "檢測結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/74.wav", + "text": "就是剛剛我報告的球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/75.wav", + "text": "球化率是0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/76.wav", + "text": "%我的辦公室主任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/77.wav", + "text": "有參與這次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/78.wav", + "text": "抽測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/79.wav", + "text": "他在現場覺得怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/80.wav", + "text": "為什麼都是台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/81.wav", + "text": "台電指定給職安署呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/82.wav", + "text": "所以他當場也抽了很多件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/83.wav", + "text": "抽了3件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/84.wav", + "text": "其中有1件就是第1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/85.wav", + "text": "0就是第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/86.wav", + "text": "按照前面那張表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/87.wav", + "text": "的8跟10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/88.wav", + "text": "部長請你注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/89.wav", + "text": "同一家廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/90.wav", + "text": "同樣是美國著名大廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/91.wav", + "text": "所生產的圓型接線盒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/92.wav", + "text": "但是檢測出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/93.wav", + "text": "一個球化率是0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/94.wav", + "text": "%一個是88%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/95.wav", + "text": "部長你覺得合乎常理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/96.wav", + "text": "如果從這個數據上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/97.wav", + "text": "看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/98.wav", + "text": "確實我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/99.wav", + "text": "這裡面會有些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/100.wav", + "text": "需要細究的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/101.wav", + "text": "同一家嘛我進一步查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/102.wav", + "text": "要求台電提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/103.wav", + "text": "當時的採購抽驗單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/104.wav", + "text": "尤其是這10個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/105.wav", + "text": "的第8項是不清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/106.wav", + "text": "不完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/107.wav", + "text": "的所以過幾天我只好請他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/108.wav", + "text": "到辦公室來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/109.wav", + "text": "查驗單到我辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/110.wav", + "text": "台電知道東窗事發了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/111.wav", + "text": "台電南部施工處鄭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/112.wav", + "text": "鄭姓經理改口了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/113.wav", + "text": "也就是剛剛你看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/114.wav", + "text": "並沒有材料查驗申請單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/115.wav", + "text": "鄭姓經理並且承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/116.wav", + "text": "這個項目的圓型接線盒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/117.wav", + "text": "是當初大林電廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/118.wav", + "text": "更新改建工程的統包商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/119.wav", + "text": "下面的一個承包商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/120.wav", + "text": "叫做承岡公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/121.wav", + "text": "它沒有經過台電查驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/122.wav", + "text": "興達漁港工程的餘料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/123.wav", + "text": "拿來裝在大林電廠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/124.wav", + "text": "煤倉工程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/125.wav", + "text": "我上面這些說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/126.wav", + "text": "都有台電政風在場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/127.wav", + "text": "而且這個會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/128.wav", + "text": "我也把副本給了職安署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/129.wav", + "text": "職安署你知道嘛\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/130.wav", + "text": "去調查這個仿冒品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/131.wav", + "text": "到底是誰生產的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/132.wav", + "text": "到底不合格的產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/133.wav", + "text": "是由APPLETON生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/134.wav", + "text": "的還是由其他公司仿冒的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/135.wav", + "text": "要調查清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/136.wav", + "text": "但是職安署是不是也要調查呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/137.wav", + "text": "這個仿冒品的生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/138.wav", + "text": "我很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/139.wav", + "text": "職安署跟我都同時被利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/140.wav", + "text": "要借我們的手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/141.wav", + "text": "去打特定的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/142.wav", + "text": "勞動部是不是應該搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/143.wav", + "text": "台電在搞什麼鬼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/144.wav", + "text": "還是部長認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/145.wav", + "text": "我是拒絕喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/146.wav", + "text": "我是拒絕當打手的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/147.wav", + "text": "被當作是任何廠商競爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/148.wav", + "text": "我們絕對不允許這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/149.wav", + "text": "所以一定是從管制的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/150.wav", + "text": "這是我們一定強烈要求的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/151.wav", + "text": "我等你的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/152.wav", + "text": "鬼故事講完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/153.wav", + "text": "部長上次我質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/154.wav", + "text": "有請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/155.wav", + "text": "因為環境部彭部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/156.wav", + "text": "而且還用公文指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/157.wav", + "text": "如果發LINE給員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/158.wav", + "text": "發LINE就是加班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/159.wav", + "text": "部長您上次說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/160.wav", + "text": "可能類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/161.wav", + "text": "但是沒有直接回答我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/162.wav", + "text": "在我質詢結束後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/163.wav", + "text": "很多勞動部的基層員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/164.wav", + "text": "跑來問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/165.wav", + "text": "委員你應該繼續追問下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/166.wav", + "text": "啊所以部長我今天再問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/167.wav", + "text": "勞動部主管於下班傳LINE" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/168.wav", + "text": "給員工就是加班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/169.wav", + "text": "應該要有加班費或是補休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/170.wav", + "text": "你做得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/171.wav", + "text": "委員我想我們會優先來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/172.wav", + "text": "或是把這些真的不必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/173.wav", + "text": "工作排程而導致的加班狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/174.wav", + "text": "我們會優先來改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/175.wav", + "text": "但是你做得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/176.wav", + "text": "如果環境部做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/177.wav", + "text": "勞動部做得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/178.wav", + "text": "我們會優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/179.wav", + "text": "部長勞動部的員工士氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/180.wav", + "text": "現在是最壞的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/181.wav", + "text": "你如果沒有一個實際作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/182.wav", + "text": "他們會很心寒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/183.wav", + "text": "啦部長你今天沒辦法承諾我嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/184.wav", + "text": "這樣子的工作情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/185.wav", + "text": "當然我們在一些國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/186.wav", + "text": "其實有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/187.wav", + "text": "往減少加班的方向來部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/188.wav", + "text": "部長就業安定基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/189.wav", + "text": "還有勞動部預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/190.wav", + "text": "有很多委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/191.wav", + "text": "我現在要告訴你一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/192.wav", + "text": "勞動部還花錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/193.wav", + "text": "在養一些慣老闆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/194.wav", + "text": "去年勞動部本部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/195.wav", + "text": "決標的標案有99件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/196.wav", + "text": "我把這99件標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/197.wav", + "text": "查詢系統去交叉比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/198.wav", + "text": "不得了了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/199.wav", + "text": "發現有25件的得標廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/200.wav", + "text": "近年都違反過勞動法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/201.wav", + "text": "而且很多是慣犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/202.wav", + "text": "這些廠商累計的違規次數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/203.wav", + "text": "只算到去年就有194次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/204.wav", + "text": "有四分之一的標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/205.wav", + "text": "近期違反勞工法令的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/206.wav", + "text": "部長你覺得這樣合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/207.wav", + "text": "委員這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/208.wav", + "text": "我們會依照目前採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/209.wav", + "text": "跟工程會一些相關的規範來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/210.wav", + "text": "這99件標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/211.wav", + "text": "總金額大概是8,800萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/212.wav", + "text": "累計139次的罰款金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/213.wav", + "text": "部長你不覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/214.wav", + "text": "嗎難怪每個企業都不怕違反勞動法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/215.wav", + "text": "啊因為本來你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/216.wav", + "text": "們是可以罰到20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/217.wav", + "text": "但這些都罰1萬2萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/218.wav", + "text": "他們就會想繳錢了事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/219.wav", + "text": "花錢消災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/220.wav", + "text": "啊勞動部到底這個罰款是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/221.wav", + "text": "你們繼續給他標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/222.wav", + "text": "啊等於他犯規了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/223.wav", + "text": "他還繼續有糖吃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/224.wav", + "text": "啊部長這件事我要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/225.wav", + "text": "一個月內給我書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/226.wav", + "text": "合理吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/227.wav", + "text": "現在討論的這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/228.wav", + "text": "尤其是我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/229.wav", + "text": "嘛你們發標給這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/230.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/231.wav", + "text": "他賺8,800萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/232.wav", + "text": "結果你們罰一百零多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/233.wav", + "text": "他當然不怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/234.wav", + "text": "我會請業務單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/235.wav", + "text": "做相關的說明跟檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/236.wav", + "text": "這個數字您大概很清楚吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/237.wav", + "text": "因為當時我也質詢過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/238.wav", + "text": "從許部長到何部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/239.wav", + "text": "你覺得要有競爭力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/240.wav", + "text": "你講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/241.wav", + "text": "那我請問你你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/242.wav", + "text": "你覺得5%符合競爭力嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/243.wav", + "text": "競爭力的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/244.wav", + "text": "仲介的這一個軌道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/245.wav", + "text": "我們要讓國家的直聘做到好用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/246.wav", + "text": "這個才會讓它有競爭力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/247.wav", + "text": "這個5%目標是底線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/248.wav", + "text": "我當然希望可以做到更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/249.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/250.wav", + "text": "最後一件事是外籍漁工的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/251.wav", + "text": "你知道臺灣遠洋漁業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/252.wav", + "text": "近年又被美國列為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/253.wav", + "text": "強迫勞動清單吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/254.wav", + "text": "連續三年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/255.wav", + "text": "這是個惡名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/256.wav", + "text": "耶我知道遠洋漁工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/257.wav", + "text": "主要是由農業部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/258.wav", + "text": "但是勞動部還是有角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/259.wav", + "text": "尤其漁業人權行動改善方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/260.wav", + "text": "勞動部是有一些參與的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/261.wav", + "text": "我說這些遠洋漁工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/262.wav", + "text": "常常面臨薪資被扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/263.wav", + "text": "超時加班及肢體虐待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/264.wav", + "text": "何部長說這些情況都消失了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/265.wav", + "text": "已經沒有這件事情了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/266.wav", + "text": "他還說他要跟美國反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/267.wav", + "text": "但是漁工團體給我的反映都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/268.wav", + "text": "第二個如果這個情況都消失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/269.wav", + "text": "為什麼美國還把我們列在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/270.wav", + "text": "強迫勞動清單裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/271.wav", + "text": "第一個勞動部真的有去澄清嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/272.wav", + "text": "臺灣從這個惡名單拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/273.wav", + "text": "你有做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/274.wav", + "text": "有去澄清嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/275.wav", + "text": "陳委員我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/276.wav", + "text": "說明我對這件事情的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/277.wav", + "text": "對於強迫勞動議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/278.wav", + "text": "各部會都需要更加重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/279.wav", + "text": "我先說明因為確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/280.wav", + "text": "就漁工的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/281.wav", + "text": "目前是由農業部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/282.wav", + "text": "我自己認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/283.wav", + "text": "可以有做得更好的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/284.wav", + "text": "而且勞動部也願意跟農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/285.wav", + "text": "強迫勞動的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/286.wav", + "text": "如果有能做而未做的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/287.wav", + "text": "我也願意能夠做更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/288.wav", + "text": "這部分勞動部非常非常願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/289.wav", + "text": "來配合來克服這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/290.wav", + "text": "如果美國沒有誤會我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/291.wav", + "text": "我們這些現象都還是存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/292.wav", + "text": "嘛請部長多努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158017/293.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/0.wav", + "text": "各位民進黨的朋友們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/1.wav", + "text": "你們知道什麼叫做噁心的蟾蜍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/2.wav", + "text": "這是憤怒的南韓民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/3.wav", + "text": "送給民進黨的新名字──噁心的蟾蜍\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/4.wav", + "text": "南韓發生了荒腔走板離譜反民主的尹錫悅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/5.wav", + "text": "他踐踏民主宣布戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/6.wav", + "text": "還派軍隊攻占國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/7.wav", + "text": "當全世界都不恥不屑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/8.wav", + "text": "譴責這樣一個破壞民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/9.wav", + "text": "反民主的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/10.wav", + "text": "只有一個偉大的政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/11.wav", + "text": "──民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/12.wav", + "text": "民進黨立法院黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/13.wav", + "text": "竟然貼文肯定尹錫悅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/14.wav", + "text": "我直接念給大家聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/15.wav", + "text": "民進黨的立法院黨團告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/16.wav", + "text": "南韓總統為守護自由憲政體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/17.wav", + "text": "緊急宣布全國戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/18.wav", + "text": "民進黨事後在拗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/19.wav", + "text": "這篇貼文沒有挺戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/20.wav", + "text": "民進黨去中化去到中文不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/21.wav", + "text": "��直接肯定他們守護自由憲政體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/22.wav", + "text": "我也告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/23.wav", + "text": "民進黨在貼文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/24.wav", + "text": "竟然挺尹錫悅戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/25.wav", + "text": "這還不是最恐怖的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/26.wav", + "text": "最恐怖的是民進黨事後的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/27.wav", + "text": "我就要跟各位說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/28.wav", + "text": "民進黨事後的態度第一個不交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/29.wav", + "text": "第二個不道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/30.wav", + "text": "第三個猛牽拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/31.wav", + "text": "如果真的這個貼文寫得不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/32.wav", + "text": "民進黨你就道歉啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/33.wav", + "text": "到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/34.wav", + "text": "我想請問民進黨的黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/35.wav", + "text": "有站出來跟社會大眾表達歉意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/36.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/37.wav", + "text": "還很兇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/38.wav", + "text": "牽拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/39.wav", + "text": "三十多年前的國民黨戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/40.wav", + "text": "國民黨戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/41.wav", + "text": "民進黨的前輩們爭取解嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/42.wav", + "text": "結果淪落到今天的徒子徒孫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/43.wav", + "text": "來挺戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/44.wav", + "text": "難怪連呂秀蓮副總統都看不下去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/45.wav", + "text": "民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/46.wav", + "text": "你們對得起以前創黨的前輩嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/47.wav", + "text": "還有民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/48.wav", + "text": "你們對得起臺灣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/49.wav", + "text": "讓臺灣今天執政黨的醜名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/50.wav", + "text": "名揚海外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/51.wav", + "text": "連南韓民眾都憤怒到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/52.wav", + "text": "直接稱民進黨是噁心的蟾蜍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/53.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統在臉書貼文上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/54.wav", + "text": "也沒有對這事有任何的交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/55.wav", + "text": "真的拜託民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/56.wav", + "text": "道歉沒這麼難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158004/57.wav", + "text": "趕快道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/0.wav", + "text": "主席及在座各位委員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/1.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團發言挺戒嚴丟臉丟到全世界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/2.wav", + "text": "\n南韓總統尹錫悅日前突襲發布戒嚴令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/3.wav", + "text": "雖然6小時之後戒嚴解除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/4.wav", + "text": "但是當解嚴消息一曝光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/5.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團竟然在第一時間就在社群媒體發文附和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/6.wav", + "text": "支持尹錫悅的戒嚴令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/7.wav", + "text": "並且以臺灣立法院的狀況比擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/8.wav", + "text": "批評藍白刪除審查的國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/9.wav", + "text": "預算提出改革法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/10.wav", + "text": "同樣是被親共勢力所操控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/11.wav", + "text": "儼然是對尹錫悅總統面對執政困境感同身受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/12.wav", + "text": "南韓遭受北韓的威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/13.wav", + "text": "臺灣則遭受中共的威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/14.wav", + "text": "尹錫悅與賴清德同屬少數政府結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/15.wav", + "text": "又不願意與國會多數進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/16.wav", + "text": "因此將所有執政上的不如意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/17.wav", + "text": "都怪罪於不願意配合總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/18.wav", + "text": "不願意聽命行事的國會在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/19.wav", + "text": "民進黨見此奇招" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/20.wav", + "text": "心有戚戚焉立即發文挺錫悅挺戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/21.wav", + "text": "民進黨此番言論無疑是愚蠢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/22.wav", + "text": "但更讓人驚悚的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/23.wav", + "text": "顯露出獨裁專制者的心態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/24.wav", + "text": "一旦執政權受到威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/25.wav", + "text": "隨時都可以發動軍事戒嚴來整肅異己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/26.wav", + "text": "控制全國上下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/27.wav", + "text": "\n我們要知道在民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/28.wav", + "text": "將執政困境過度簡化成在野黨與境外勢力的陰謀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/29.wav", + "text": "藉此來正當化戒嚴以及其他手段的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/30.wav", + "text": "這只會凸顯出統治當局的愚昧與無知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/31.wav", + "text": "是絕對不可能贏得社會大眾與人民的同情與支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/32.wav", + "text": "\n民進黨自己丟臉就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/33.wav", + "text": "讓才剛贏得世界棒球冠軍的Team Taiwan" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/34.wav", + "text": "竟然變成挺戒嚴的Team Taiwan" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/35.wav", + "text": "真是丟臉丟到全世界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/36.wav", + "text": "\n在此本席強烈譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/37.wav", + "text": "民進黨必須召開國際記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/38.wav", + "text": "來向世界道歉向國人道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/39.wav", + "text": "洗刷Team Taiwan就是挺戒嚴的污名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/40.wav", + "text": "\n這一次民進黨的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/41.wav", + "text": "我在這裡要鄭重的警告賴清德政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/42.wav", + "text": "不要妄想步南韓的後塵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/43.wav", + "text": "假借民主之名行專制之實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/44.wav", + "text": "濫用國家的權力去打擊政敵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/45.wav", + "text": "這次的南韓經驗提醒我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/46.wav", + "text": "比起外部威脅的北韓勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/47.wav", + "text": "內部侵犯人權的戒嚴令更近在眼前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/48.wav", + "text": "民主最大的威脅不是共產黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/49.wav", + "text": "而永遠是執政者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/50.wav", + "text": "在當前的臺灣對民主最大的威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/51.wav", + "text": "就是民進黨政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158003/52.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/0.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員媒體朋友大家早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/1.wav", + "text": "今天要聊的是臺灣棒球贏了冠軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/2.wav", + "text": "民進黨卻把民主丟了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/3.wav", + "text": "上個月中華隊在日本東京巨蛋奪下2024年世界十二強棒球賽冠軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/4.wav", + "text": "當時賴清德總統接見所有臺灣英雄時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/5.wav", + "text": "說出了一句冠冕堂皇的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/6.wav", + "text": "讓國際社會看見臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/7.wav", + "text": "只要臺灣團結一定可以走得更遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/8.wav", + "text": "結果短短兩個禮拜後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/9.wav", + "text": "民進黨又再次讓世界看到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/10.wav", + "text": "但這次是用支持戒嚴的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/11.wav", + "text": "也是最丟臉的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/12.wav", + "text": "南韓宣布戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/13.wav", + "text": "朝野與全國人民全部反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/14.wav", + "text": "就民進黨團發出脆文來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/15.wav", + "text": "本來是他國的內政議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/16.wav", + "text": "卻變成我國的外交危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/17.wav", + "text": "現在韓國人都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/18.wav", + "text": "臺灣的民進黨政府是支持戒嚴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/19.wav", + "text": "已經被韓國三大報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/20.wav", + "text": "朝鮮日報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/21.wav", + "text": "東亞日報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/22.wav", + "text": "中央日報報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/23.wav", + "text": "也有日本媒體報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/24.wav", + "text": "讓大批的南韓網友來留言怒嗆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/25.wav", + "text": "大家為了表達憤怒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/26.wav", + "text": "還使用翻譯軟體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/27.wav", + "text": "也讓國際媒體有了新的話題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/28.wav", + "text": "\n臺灣棒球贏冠軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/29.wav", + "text": "執政黨卻把民主丟了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/30.wav", + "text": "發文之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/31.wav", + "text": "綠營的側翼們趕快出來滅火洗地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/32.wav", + "text": "口徑一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/33.wav", + "text": "哪隻眼睛看到那篇文在支持戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/34.wav", + "text": "啊然而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/35.wav", + "text": "被網友比對發文用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/36.wav", + "text": "跟文字排版習慣以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/37.wav", + "text": "懷疑可能是某執政黨委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/38.wav", + "text": "這位委員就心急的跳出來澄清說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/39.wav", + "text": "我最關注人權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/40.wav", + "text": "怎��可能發文支持戒嚴呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/41.wav", + "text": "我也很相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/42.wav", + "text": "這絕對不是那位委員本人發文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/43.wav", + "text": "但這不就證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/44.wav", + "text": "黨團官方帳號那篇被刪掉的文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/45.wav", + "text": "都被委員本人認證是支持戒嚴的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/46.wav", + "text": "發生這種低級的錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/47.wav", + "text": "嚴重影響國際形象的重大危機事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/48.wav", + "text": "民進黨毫不意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/49.wav", + "text": "馬上祭出小編背鍋術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/50.wav", + "text": "但誰會相信一個普通的小編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/51.wav", + "text": "就有權力代表立法院黨團官方帳號發文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/52.wav", + "text": "到底是誰授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/53.wav", + "text": "誰撰文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/54.wav", + "text": "誰同意發出的呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/55.wav", + "text": "這個SOP是不是要跟大家交代清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/56.wav", + "text": "做為執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/57.wav", + "text": "有種發出嚴重反民主的文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/58.wav", + "text": "就要有guts說清楚講明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/59.wav", + "text": "我們強烈要求民進黨把發文的流程講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/60.wav", + "text": "誰應該負責任就要出來道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/61.wav", + "text": "而且是向我們全國臺灣人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/62.wav", + "text": "以及南韓人民道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158002/63.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/0.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/1.wav", + "text": "各位同仁大家早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/2.wav", + "text": "南韓總統尹錫悅12月3號晚間突然宣布戒嚴令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/3.wav", + "text": "舉世譁然全球為之震驚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/4.wav", + "text": "當全世界都在問南韓怎麼了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/5.wav", + "text": "豈料民進黨立院黨團竟然第一時間在社群平臺發文力挺韓國戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/6.wav", + "text": "認同尹錫悅宣布戒嚴是為了維護民主憲政體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/7.wav", + "text": "並指控國內在野黨是暗黑勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/8.wav", + "text": "追查弊案嚴審預算就是惡勢力嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/9.wav", + "text": "民進黨執政後有許多重要的公共政策預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/10.wav", + "text": "都是在黑箱中被少數人決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/11.wav", + "text": "其中涉及各種龐大的利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/12.wav", + "text": "民進黨怕追查已經沒收國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/13.wav", + "text": "現在還想挺戒嚴沒收國會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/14.wav", + "text": "\n德國前總理梅克爾說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/15.wav", + "text": "自由需要民主支撐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/16.wav", + "text": "沒有民主就沒有自由沒有法治也沒有人權的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/17.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統在國慶演說的主軸是團結臺灣共圓夢想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/18.wav", + "text": "臺灣的民主指數排名世界第10亞洲第1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/19.wav", + "text": "而民主進步黨挺戒嚴的文案不僅讓臺灣民主蒙羞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/20.wav", + "text": "更讓臺灣民主倒退到最後1名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/21.wav", + "text": "民進黨已經執政超過8年疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/22.wav", + "text": "快篩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/23.wav", + "text": "雞蛋光電霸凌等濫權貪腐的弊案更是罄竹難書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/24.wav", + "text": "國人都想知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/25.wav", + "text": "各式各樣的重大公共議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/26.wav", + "text": "到底是誰說了算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/27.wav", + "text": "國人沒欠民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/28.wav", + "text": "是民進黨對不起國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/29.wav", + "text": "民進黨再怎麼不滿新國會新民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/30.wav", + "text": "都不該有挺戒嚴的心思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/31.wav", + "text": "\n季辛吉說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/32.wav", + "text": "權力是終極的春藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/33.wav", + "text": "民進黨可以為了權力變得如此的瘋狂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/34.wav", + "text": "挺戒嚴的荒誕言行令國人毛骨悚然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/35.wav", + "text": "難道民進黨也想學尹錫悅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/36.wav", + "text": "宣布戒嚴進行政變嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/37.wav", + "text": "若真如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/38.wav", + "text": "民進黨可以改名為民主退步黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/39.wav", + "text": "民進黨利用南韓的戒嚴帶風向賺取政治紅利的荒誕行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/40.wav", + "text": "已經被韓國和日本多家媒體報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/41.wav", + "text": "新聞的標題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/42.wav", + "text": "臺灣執政黨支持戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/43.wav", + "text": "民進黨發文支持戒嚴的丟臉行為搞到全世界都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/44.wav", + "text": "有夠丟人現眼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/45.wav", + "text": "身為民主進步黨的主席──賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/46.wav", + "text": "應該負起責任向國人道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/47.wav", + "text": "我們守護臺灣民主憲政秩序的立場堅定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/48.wav", + "text": "我要呼籲賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/49.wav", + "text": "利用返航的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/50.wav", + "text": "好好的想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/51.wav", + "text": "抵達國門後第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/52.wav", + "text": "可以為民進黨挺戒嚴的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/53.wav", + "text": "向國人道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/54.wav", + "text": "並公開保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/55.wav", + "text": "民進黨不會在臺灣建立新黨國體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/56.wav", + "text": "也不會利用軍隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/57.wav", + "text": "接管國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158001/58.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/0.wav", + "text": "厲害了民進黨丟臉丟到國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/1.wav", + "text": "我們看到內政處理不好還丟臺灣國家的臉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/2.wav", + "text": "我們更看到最近卓榮泰還有賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/3.wav", + "text": "一條公務人員的生命你一個道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/4.wav", + "text": "就以為能夠了事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/5.wav", + "text": "卓榮泰說檢討報告調查報告一個禮拜生出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/6.wav", + "text": "到現在教育部到現在勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/7.wav", + "text": "我們看不到完整的報告我們看不到一個交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/8.wav", + "text": "我們要的是真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/9.wav", + "text": "在野黨會全力以赴的監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/10.wav", + "text": "並且不會放過任何一個謝宜容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/11.wav", + "text": "以及背後支撐著謝宜容系統的執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/12.wav", + "text": "\n我也要跟大家特別報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/13.wav", + "text": "南韓總統短短幾小時的戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/14.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到國際討論紛紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/15.wav", + "text": "民進黨立法院的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/16.wav", + "text": "在以為自己撿到槍認同戒嚴的一個發文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/17.wav", + "text": "事後不敢承認還敢刪掉文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/18.wav", + "text": "刪文以後更是一直不斷的想要找藉口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/19.wav", + "text": "我要說如果執政黨只會講被抹黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/20.wav", + "text": "請問傳遍全世界現在的國際媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/21.wav", + "text": "南韓日本美國這些國家的報導也是抹黑嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/22.wav", + "text": "他們都不如民進黨更懂民主嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/23.wav", + "text": "過去民進黨自詡為反威權爭取民主的捍衛者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/24.wav", + "text": "他們一再聲稱反對戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/25.wav", + "text": "到現在我們看到民進黨從反對戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/26.wav", + "text": "到理解戒嚴到支持戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/27.wav", + "text": "臺灣已經被國際貼上了支持戒嚴的一個標籤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/28.wav", + "text": "也讓臺灣在國際外交嚴重的損害到形象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/29.wav", + "text": "澈底蒙羞\n我要呼籲賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/30.wav", + "text": "所謂的賴清德皇上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/31.wav", + "text": "麻煩你說清楚講明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/32.wav", + "text": "第一為這一次的風波向全國國人道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/33.wav", + "text": "第二請你慎重的跟國人承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/34.wav", + "text": "任內絕對不會宣布戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/35.wav", + "text": "也不會發生戒嚴更不會挺戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/36.wav", + "text": "我們希望讓國人安心讓產業安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/37.wav", + "text": "執政黨的責任不是挑起爭端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/38.wav", + "text": "更不是讓國家丟臉到國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/39.wav", + "text": "守護人民的勞權守護民主的政治守護國家的尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/158000/40.wav", + "text": "執政黨不做在野黨來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/0.wav", + "text": "主席各位立院同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/1.wav", + "text": "最近我常常在想執政的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/2.wav", + "text": "什麼是執政的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/3.wav", + "text": "在民主法治國家裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/4.wav", + "text": "能夠通過人民的票選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/5.wav", + "text": "一票一票選出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/6.wav", + "text": "並且獲得執政的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/7.wav", + "text": "這是何等的光榮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/8.wav", + "text": "跟何等的榮幸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/9.wav", + "text": "在執政者掌握權力的那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/10.wav", + "text": "其實更多的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/11.wav", + "text": "他對於全國人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/12.wav", + "text": "有相對的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/13.wav", + "text": "要把臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/14.wav", + "text": "要把中華民國帶到一個更好的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/15.wav", + "text": "要讓我們全體國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/16.wav", + "text": "都可以感受到更好的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/17.wav", + "text": "要讓大家更能夠充滿希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/18.wav", + "text": "如同今天的陽光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/19.wav", + "text": "但很可惜也很遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/20.wav", + "text": "從520賴清德總統就職到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/21.wav", + "text": "執政的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/22.wav", + "text": "有沒有在民主進步黨裡面深化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/23.wav", + "text": "說實在話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/24.wav", + "text": "在這個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/25.wav", + "text": "南韓總統尹錫悅發動了一場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/26.wav", + "text": "6小時落幕的反民主戒嚴鬧劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/27.wav", + "text": "雖然這已經落幕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/28.wav", + "text": "但更突顯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/29.wav", + "text": "在這個過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/30.wav", + "text": "我們的執政黨在做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/31.wav", + "text": "第一時間居然就上車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/32.wav", + "text": "在不了解全體事情的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/33.wav", + "text": "公開地發出了一篇貼文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/34.wav", + "text": "講說南韓國會已經被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/35.wav", + "text": "親北韓勢力給掌控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/36.wav", + "text": "執政黨你憑什麼講這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/37.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/38.wav", + "text": "貼文雖然已經刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/39.wav", + "text": "但是又再補了一個新的貼文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/40.wav", + "text": "怪東怪西怪南怪北" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/41.wav", + "text": "怪在野黨怪媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/42.wav", + "text": "就是沒有檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/43.wav", + "text": "為什麼你們會發出這樣的文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/44.wav", + "text": "你們的內控內稽制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/45.wav", + "text": "呢你們的審查制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/46.wav", + "text": "呢還是你們打從心裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/47.wav", + "text": "根本就認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/48.wav", + "text": "這樣的狀況是你們想要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/49.wav", + "text": "你們想表達的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/50.wav", + "text": "當所有的側翼網軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/51.wav", + "text": "都在帶一樣的風向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/52.wav", + "text": "只要能夠把不中聽不好聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/53.wav", + "text": "不喜歡聽的聲音給消滅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/54.wav", + "text": "你們就可以達成你們的目的了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/55.wav", + "text": "當南韓總統把任何反對勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/56.wav", + "text": "都打成親北韓同路人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/57.wav", + "text": "我們中華民國的執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/58.wav", + "text": "也一樣把任何的反對聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/59.wav", + "text": "都打成中共同路人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/60.wav", + "text": "這樣子你們以為就可以了事了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/61.wav", + "text": "到底執政的責任在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/62.wav", + "text": "\n賴清德總統在這個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/63.wav", + "text": "以中華民國元首的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/64.wav", + "text": "出訪友邦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/65.wav", + "text": "身為中華民國的國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/66.wav", + "text": "身為中華民國的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/67.wav", + "text": "我們當然由衷的祝福" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/68.wav", + "text": "他這次出訪順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/69.wav", + "text": "但是賴總統在國外出訪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/70.wav", + "text": "執政黨的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/71.wav", + "text": "卻在國內搞挺戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/72.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/73.wav", + "text": "這是你授意的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/74.wav", + "text": "這是你在玩兩手手法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/75.wav", + "text": "如果不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/76.wav", + "text": "請賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/77.wav", + "text": "以民進黨黨主席的身分跟高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/78.wav", + "text": "在今天回國的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/79.wav", + "text": "正式向國人公開道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/80.wav", + "text": "並且負起相關的政治責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157999/81.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席各位觀眾朋友各位媒體先進大家早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/1.wav", + "text": "12月3號韓國總統尹錫悅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/2.wav", + "text": "在沒有任何戰爭具體威脅的前提之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/3.wav", + "text": "僅僅因為在野黨刪除預算彈劾人事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/4.wav", + "text": "就將之指控為親北勢力反國勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/5.wav", + "text": "以及亡國的罪魁禍首" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/6.wav", + "text": "宣布韓國緊急戒嚴停止一切政治集會活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/7.wav", + "text": "並且派遣軍隊進駐首爾街頭以及控制國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/8.wav", + "text": "以鬥爭在野黨作為發動戒嚴的理由聞所未聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/9.wav", + "text": "不僅令韓國人民感到困惑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/10.wav", + "text": "也令全世界同感憤怒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/11.wav", + "text": "這是一場毫無正當性的戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/12.wav", + "text": "在肅殺的氛圍中在野勢力展現出果斷與勇氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/13.wav", + "text": "人民走上街頭用行動對暴行說不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/14.wav", + "text": "其中更令人感到可貴而且敬佩的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/15.wav", + "text": "是韓國國會的輔佐官也就是他們的助理跟幕僚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/16.wav", + "text": "用生命突破軍方的封鎖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/17.wav", + "text": "護送韓國的國會議員在深夜進入議場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/18.wav", + "text": "緊急投票來解除戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/19.wav", + "text": "才結束這一場發生於2024年的反民主風暴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/20.wav", + "text": "我們在此肯定如此冒險犯難的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/21.wav", + "text": "正因為有這樣子的民主精神以及真正的行動力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/22.wav", + "text": "民主的價值才得以捍衛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/23.wav", + "text": "\n回首臺灣我們的國家也面對類似的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/24.wav", + "text": "韓國發生如此反民主的暴行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/25.wav", + "text": "很遺憾的是我們的同事民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/26.wav", + "text": "居然發文影射" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/27.wav", + "text": "而其支持者竟有出言贊和甚有期待戒嚴者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/28.wav", + "text": "悲劇發生至今賴清德總統沉默" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/29.wav", + "text": "迴避民主進步黨上上下下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/30.wav", + "text": "也無一人為此道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/31.wav", + "text": "隨著外媒的報導本事件上升至中華民國的國際形象危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/32.wav", + "text": "我要在此強調世界不應看到這樣的臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/33.wav", + "text": "中華民國身為民主和平體制的捍衛者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/34.wav", + "text": "賴總統也曾經發願要打造民主和平的新臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/35.wav", + "text": "我們在此呼籲賴清德總統應該立刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/36.wav", + "text": "而且正式的譴責韓國總統尹錫悅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/37.wav", + "text": "因為利用戒嚴當作政治鬥爭的工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/38.wav", + "text": "就是全世界民主國家的敵人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/39.wav", + "text": "任何一個民主國家都不應該允許這樣子的事情發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/40.wav", + "text": "我們也在此誠懇呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/41.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統應該立刻徹查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/42.wav", + "text": "並且公布民進黨內部反民主的倡議者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/43.wav", + "text": "到底是誰發了那篇文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/44.wav", + "text": "臺灣身為和平民主的淨土人民絕對不會姑息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157998/45.wav", + "text": "轉型正義不該偽善雙標更不該淪為鬥爭工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/0.wav", + "text": "大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/1.wav", + "text": "近日韓國總統尹錫悅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/2.wav", + "text": "因執政無方弊案重重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/3.wav", + "text": "於困獸之鬥中竟以宣布戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/4.wav", + "text": "出動軍隊的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/5.wav", + "text": "試圖逃避國會監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/6.wav", + "text": "結果數小時之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/7.wav", + "text": "草草收場鬧得聲敗名裂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/8.wav", + "text": "眾叛親離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/9.wav", + "text": "如此破壞民主憲政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/10.wav", + "text": "遭全民唾罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/11.wav", + "text": "貪腐獨裁者的下場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/12.wav", + "text": "所有民主國家的執政者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/13.wav", + "text": "都應知所警惕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/14.wav", + "text": "唯有我們的執政黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/15.wav", + "text": "居然呼應贊聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/16.wav", + "text": "一副欣羨不已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/17.wav", + "text": "有為者亦若似的嘴臉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/18.wav", + "text": "事後心虛刪文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/19.wav", + "text": "卻又嘴硬不道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/20.wav", + "text": "還讓韓國媒體誤以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/21.wav", + "text": "我們中華民國居然相挺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/22.wav", + "text": "民心背離的尹錫悅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/23.wav", + "text": "丟臉丟到國際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/24.wav", + "text": "權吉要在此嚴肅譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/25.wav", + "text": "\n此外民國105年時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/26.wav", + "text": "民進黨以國家財政困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/27.wav", + "text": "基金難以永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/28.wav", + "text": "大刀砍向公教人員年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/29.wav", + "text": "而今政府連年誇讚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/30.wav", + "text": "經濟最佳財務健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/31.wav", + "text": "稅收超徵國債下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/32.wav", + "text": "民間卻是通貨膨脹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/33.wav", + "text": "萬物齊漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/34.wav", + "text": "正是應該重新檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/35.wav", + "text": "制度的時機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/36.wav", + "text": "公務人員退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/37.wav", + "text": "原本就有因應物價指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/38.wav", + "text": "以及每4年應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/39.wav", + "text": "依國家經濟環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/40.wav", + "text": "政府財政等現況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/41.wav", + "text": "檢討之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/42.wav", + "text": "政府自109年至今" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/43.wav", + "text": "年年撥補勞保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/44.wav", + "text": "總金額已達2,670億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/45.wav", + "text": "軍公教人員作為國家的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/46.wav", + "text": "政府更不該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/47.wav", + "text": "對他們應有的退休權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/48.wav", + "text": "言而無信推諉卸責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/49.wav", + "text": "而今立法院再度推動修法改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/50.wav", + "text": "照顧我們的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/51.wav", + "text": "在職時戮力從公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/52.wav", + "text": "免受霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/53.wav", + "text": "退休後讓他們生活無虞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/54.wav", + "text": "無後顧之憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157997/55.wav", + "text": "才是正確的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝敬愛的院會主席韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/1.wav", + "text": "以及各位同仁新聞界的朋友楊瓊瓔發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/2.wav", + "text": "南韓總統尹錫悅戒嚴又遭到國會打臉解嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/3.wav", + "text": "但民進黨立院黨團卻在Threads上面發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/4.wav", + "text": "尹錫悅為守護自由憲政體制宣布戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/5.wav", + "text": "不僅在未求證明朗前就幫尹背書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/6.wav", + "text": "說南韓國會被親北韓者操縱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/7.wav", + "text": "還意圖比喻臺灣用此事來連結整個國內政治議題的攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/8.wav", + "text": "用來批評在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/9.wav", + "text": "貼文刪除之後民進黨卻毫無悔意也毫無道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/10.wav", + "text": "僅發了不痛不癢的聲明說只是轉發國際資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/11.wav", + "text": "更反過來檢討外界不要渲染" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/12.wav", + "text": "對於大家的批評更表示遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/13.wav", + "text": "\n尹錫悅置個人的政治利益高於國家人民利益之上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/14.wav", + "text": "而民進黨發言跟尹錫悅的態度類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/15.wav", + "text": "只想如何能夠打擊反對者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/16.wav", + "text": "連戒嚴這種事情都可以拿來做文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/17.wav", + "text": "忽略了查證分析忽略了執權力者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/18.wav", + "text": "應該要對民眾要負責而非只對黨負責的這個義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/19.wav", + "text": "更糟糕的是根本不是外界渲染" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/20.wav", + "text": "而是民進黨表現得毫無悔意死不認錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/21.wav", + "text": "現在被國際認證是挺戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/22.wav", + "text": "南韓媒體包括了朝鮮中央東亞日報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/23.wav", + "text": "都報導了民進黨發言支持尹錫悅戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/24.wav", + "text": "日媒等國際媒體也連番報導貼文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/25.wav", + "text": "新聞中質疑者眾獨獨不見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/26.wav", + "text": "肇事者的道歉說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/27.wav", + "text": "\n本席譴責民進黨操作此議題的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/28.wav", + "text": "民進黨跟目前身兼民進黨主席的賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/29.wav", + "text": "你必須為此事嚴正的道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/30.wav", + "text": "否則死不認錯的民進黨被國際懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/31.wav", + "text": "被世界誤解的後果卻是臺灣人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/32.wav", + "text": "口口聲聲說以民主同盟作為外交突破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/33.wav", + "text": "自己卻在國內用最獨裁的方式來打擊異己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/34.wav", + "text": "這是不願意認錯全民必須要背負這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/35.wav", + "text": "執政者代表全國連道歉都做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/36.wav", + "text": "只躲在小編之名下假裝沒事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/37.wav", + "text": "所以本席要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/38.wav", + "text": "如果繼續以黨意至上傲慢以對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/39.wav", + "text": "那不只是消費過去的悲痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/40.wav", + "text": "也是用民主倒退的方式來傷害全民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157996/41.wav", + "text": "傷害過去民主前輩的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/0.wav", + "text": "院長各位立院同仁跟全國的同胞大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/1.wav", + "text": "首先本席在這邊對民進黨黨團發文挺戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/2.wav", + "text": "表達強烈的譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/3.wav", + "text": "並呼籲民進黨不要再繼續抹黑在野黨是境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/4.wav", + "text": "在瞬息萬變的國際環境當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/5.wav", + "text": "執政黨需要具備國際視野和專業能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/6.wav", + "text": "韓國宣布戒嚴已經很荒唐了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/7.wav", + "text": "而民進黨竟然挺戒嚴更是荒唐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/8.wav", + "text": "民進黨發文挺戒嚴的鬧劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/9.wav", + "text": "在國外出訪中的賴總統都要出面解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/10.wav", + "text": "你說誇不誇張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/11.wav", + "text": "今天本席站在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/12.wav", + "text": "不僅是要討論一則社群媒體的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/13.wav", + "text": "而是要讓大家共同反思這件事情的背後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/14.wav", + "text": "對民主價值的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/15.wav", + "text": "一篇被廣泛解讀成肯定戒嚴價值的文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/16.wav", + "text": "不僅引發了社會的強烈批評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/17.wav", + "text": "更讓我們懷疑民進黨對民主理念的忠誠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/18.wav", + "text": "這篇文章引發的爭議不是只有言詞表達的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/19.wav", + "text": "而是牽涉到民進黨作為執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/20.wav", + "text": "是否依然維持過去民主的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/21.wav", + "text": "我們不禁要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/22.wav", + "text": "竟然會有民進黨基層工作者發出這樣子的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/23.wav", + "text": "民進黨你們內部真是發生了很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/24.wav", + "text": "\n民主是我國最珍貴的資產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/25.wav", + "text": "任何對威權的美化對戒嚴的認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/26.wav", + "text": "都是出於錯誤的歷史觀或策略性的政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/27.wav", + "text": "都應該被視為民主臺灣的挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/28.wav", + "text": "民進黨在這個問題上的立場及草率的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/29.wav", + "text": "帶給社會信任危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/30.wav", + "text": "只因為在野黨意見不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/31.wav", + "text": "你們就支持戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/32.wav", + "text": "這是否意味著民主價值正在被放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/33.wav", + "text": "\n身為在野黨的一員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/34.wav", + "text": "我們堅定維護中華民國的民主自由法治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/35.wav", + "text": "以及在當前複雜的國際環境與兩岸關係當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/36.wav", + "text": "維護穩定與安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/37.wav", + "text": "民主與國家安全是可以依靠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/38.wav", + "text": "當民主框架還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/39.wav", + "text": "社會內部穩定和人民信任感會增強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/40.wav", + "text": "將會為國家安全提供更強大的內部保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/41.wav", + "text": "捍衛我國民主制度是所有政黨應該有的共同基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/42.wav", + "text": "民主和國家安全是相輔相成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/43.wav", + "text": "而不是對立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/44.wav", + "text": "\n執政黨民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/45.wav", + "text": "有責任對世界進行全面的思考和行動的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/46.wav", + "text": "並應該為這件事情向社會公開道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/47.wav", + "text": "因為在民主化的今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157995/48.wav", + "text": "戒嚴這個行為應該被強力譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/0.wav", + "text": "所有臺灣的同胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/1.wav", + "text": "今天是國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/2.wav", + "text": "進入立法院以來第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/3.wav", + "text": "在國是論壇發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/4.wav", + "text": "今天我和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/5.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨的夥伴們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/6.wav", + "text": "我們八位立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/7.wav", + "text": "全體到齊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/8.wav", + "text": "在國是論壇登記輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/9.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/10.wav", + "text": "我們要讓大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/11.wav", + "text": "一起站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/12.wav", + "text": "反霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/13.wav", + "text": "護勞權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/14.wav", + "text": "挺警消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/15.wav", + "text": "吹哨者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/16.wav", + "text": "要保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/17.wav", + "text": "2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/18.wav", + "text": "蔡英文前總統在競選的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/19.wav", + "text": "他提出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/20.wav", + "text": "勞工六大保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/21.wav", + "text": "沒想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/22.wav", + "text": "我們看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/23.wav", + "text": "卻是修惡勞基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/24.wav", + "text": "砍掉七天假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/25.wav", + "text": "甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/26.wav", + "text": "當時的行政院院長賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/27.wav", + "text": "還要勞工朋友們做功德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/28.wav", + "text": "八年過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/29.wav", + "text": "勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/30.wav", + "text": "所引頸期盼的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/31.wav", + "text": "沒有等到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/32.wav", + "text": "迎接所有基層勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/33.wav", + "text": "所有基層公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/34.wav", + "text": "的卻是日益惡化的職場環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/35.wav", + "text": "一位年輕的工程師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/36.wav", + "text": "結束了他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/37.wav", + "text": "年輕的生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/38.wav", + "text": "引發了臺灣社會的震動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/39.wav", + "text": "我們想要問的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/40.wav", + "text": "要負責保障公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/41.wav", + "text": "工作健康安全的行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/42.wav", + "text": "你們在做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/43.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/44.wav", + "text": "要負責修安衛辦法的考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/45.wav", + "text": "可以睡了八年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/46.wav", + "text": "什麼事情都沒有幹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/47.wav", + "text": "更讓大家痛心的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/48.wav", + "text": "不僅僅是職場的霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/49.wav", + "text": "而是整個貪腐的結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/50.wav", + "text": "多少辛苦的家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/51.wav", + "text": "每個月省吃儉用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/52.wav", + "text": "繳的就業安定基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/53.wav", + "text": "被民進黨的高官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/54.wav", + "text": "被民進黨的權貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/55.wav", + "text": "拿去吃喝玩樂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/56.wav", + "text": "開個人演唱會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/57.wav", + "text": "裝潢辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/58.wav", + "text": "這樣的體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/59.wav", + "text": "我們呼籲大家一起站出來反抗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/60.wav", + "text": "這樣的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/61.wav", + "text": "我們號召大家一起出來改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/62.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157994/63.wav", + "text": "在保障人權的道路上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/0.wav", + "text": "各位好朋友大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/1.wav", + "text": "近日霸凌的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/2.wav", + "text": "此起彼落請問我們的政府有深刻的反省過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/3.wav", + "text": "看起來是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/4.wav", + "text": "事件發生到現在仍然官官相護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/5.wav", + "text": "到現在還是只有討論霸凌者的處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/6.wav", + "text": "完全沒有想過為什麼受害者不願意提出申訴的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/7.wav", + "text": "本席嚴重懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/8.wav", + "text": "執政黨根本就是演了一場戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/9.wav", + "text": "表面上看起來好像給了大家非常滿意的處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/10.wav", + "text": "其實純粹是為了消除全民的怒火而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/11.wav", + "text": "根本就是騙局一場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/12.wav", + "text": "\n從這次勞動部發生的霸凌事件就可以知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/13.wav", + "text": "現有的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/14.wav", + "text": "即使有再多申訴的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/15.wav", + "text": "也不管用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/16.wav", + "text": "如果缺乏保障吹哨者法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/17.wav", + "text": "就會讓那些有意揪出內部不法的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/18.wav", + "text": "不敢站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/19.wav", + "text": "因為他們擔心會被秋後算帳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/20.wav", + "text": "因此要解決霸凌的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/21.wav", + "text": "就要從源頭做起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/22.wav", + "text": "要有人敢當揭弊者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/23.wav", + "text": "才能杜絕問題的發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/24.wav", + "text": "\n2017年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/25.wav", + "text": "總統府開了司改國是會議後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/26.wav", + "text": "已經過了兩千多天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/27.wav", + "text": "到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/28.wav", + "text": "為什麼揭弊者保護法卻連一個影子都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/29.wav", + "text": "執政黨總是說還在研議中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/30.wav", + "text": "難道其他單位裡面還藏有更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/31.wav", + "text": "連執政黨都不敢動的土皇帝嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/32.wav", + "text": "執政黨口口聲聲說自己是最重視勞權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/33.wav", + "text": "和人權的政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/34.wav", + "text": "如今執政卻荒腔走板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/35.wav", + "text": "勞動部主管勞權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/36.wav", + "text": "竟然還爆發了霸凌事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/37.wav", + "text": "帶頭違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/38.wav", + "text": "違反勞權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/39.wav", + "text": "這是多麼諷刺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/40.wav", + "text": "\n行得直坐得正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/41.wav", + "text": "就該站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/42.wav", + "text": "我們不想再看到任何憾事發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/43.wav", + "text": "我們民眾黨選擇與勇敢站出來的人站在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/44.wav", + "text": "而不是縱容那些作威作福的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/45.wav", + "text": "因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/46.wav", + "text": "我們希望在源頭就立法保障吹哨者出面檢舉的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/47.wav", + "text": "解決霸凌行為的出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/48.wav", + "text": "我們更不希望官僚殺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/49.wav", + "text": "我們也將制定反霸凌專法來保護每一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/50.wav", + "text": "12月7號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/51.wav", + "text": "跟我們台灣民眾黨一起站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/52.wav", + "text": "反霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/53.wav", + "text": "護勞權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/54.wav", + "text": "因為我們不需要一個默不吭聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/55.wav", + "text": "官官相護一直向下沉淪的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/56.wav", + "text": "我們需要的是一個能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/57.wav", + "text": "保護吹哨者的法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/58.wav", + "text": "讓更多人願意站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/59.wav", + "text": "揪出那些害群之馬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157993/60.wav", + "text": "讓臺灣可以越來越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/0.wav", + "text": "當沉默變成常態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/1.wav", + "text": "霸凌就變成一種文化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/2.wav", + "text": "當吹哨者還要擔心害怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/3.wav", + "text": "官僚殺人官官相護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/4.wav", + "text": "就會繼續橫行無阻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/5.wav", + "text": "一個月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/6.wav", + "text": "大家還記得勞動部的老吳嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/7.wav", + "text": "很多送花悼念老吳的朋友說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/8.wav", + "text": "他是一個勤奮努力工作善良的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/9.wav", + "text": "可是一條年輕努力工作善良的人的生命消失了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/10.wav", + "text": "吳媽媽痛哭吶喊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/11.wav", + "text": "她說我兒子不能再回來吃晚餐了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/12.wav", + "text": "她說你們不要再官官相護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/13.wav", + "text": "你們不要再官官相護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/14.wav", + "text": "我們要的是一個真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/15.wav", + "text": "還我兒子一個清白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/16.wav", + "text": "一個月了勞動部跟政府還給老吳真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/17.wav", + "text": "還給老吳清白了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/18.wav", + "text": "送花悼念老吳的公務員朋友們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/19.wav", + "text": "我是公務員我要好好活著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/20.wav", + "text": "我們不要就這樣算了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/21.wav", + "text": "我們不要就這樣算了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/22.wav", + "text": "政府有保護我們的公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/23.wav", + "text": "保護我們的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/24.wav", + "text": "讓他們好好活著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/25.wav", + "text": "有尊嚴的工作嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/26.wav", + "text": "這段時間有多少機關多少部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/27.wav", + "text": "霸凌的事件像雨後春筍這樣冒出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/28.wav", + "text": "政府到現在還是像狗屁的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/29.wav", + "text": "一直在拖延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/30.wav", + "text": "卓榮泰不是說一個禮拜調查清楚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/31.wav", + "text": "真相在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/32.wav", + "text": "清白在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/33.wav", + "text": "我們公務員勞工的安全保障在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/34.wav", + "text": "尊嚴生活在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/35.wav", + "text": "我們要行動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/36.wav", + "text": "我們不要再等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/37.wav", + "text": "推卸責任的行政部門了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/38.wav", + "text": "我們一起上街我們一起吶喊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/39.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨非常負責任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/40.wav", + "text": "從法律面跟體制面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/41.wav", + "text": "來捍衛我們公務員的尊嚴跟生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/42.wav", + "text": "我們會提出公務人員保障法的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/43.wav", + "text": "\n我們要問的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/44.wav", + "text": "人民的忍耐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/45.wav", + "text": "還要持續多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/46.wav", + "text": "官僚繼續殺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/47.wav", + "text": "官官相護的體制要持續多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/48.wav", + "text": "我們要站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157992/49.wav", + "text": "臺灣要改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/0.wav", + "text": "各位媒體朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/1.wav", + "text": "各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/2.wav", + "text": "臺灣人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/3.wav", + "text": "在勞動部發表了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/4.wav", + "text": "調查報告案記者會的第2天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/5.wav", + "text": "我第一個上臺質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/6.wav", + "text": "勞動部部長何佩珊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/7.wav", + "text": "我定位那篇調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/8.wav", + "text": "是一個前後不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/9.wav", + "text": "邏輯不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/10.wav", + "text": "官官相護的調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/11.wav", + "text": "我連續問他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/12.wav", + "text": "你敢辦嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/13.wav", + "text": "你敢辦嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/14.wav", + "text": "我回到辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/15.wav", + "text": "不到一小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/16.wav", + "text": "我的LINE訊息一直湧進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/17.wav", + "text": "不是稱讚我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/18.wav", + "text": "是向我申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/19.wav", + "text": "告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/20.wav", + "text": "他們如何在職場被霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/21.wav", + "text": "都是有名有姓的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/22.wav", + "text": "其中很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/23.wav", + "text": "來自衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/24.wav", + "text": "這也是我最熟悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/25.wav", + "text": "長期專業互動的部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/26.wav", + "text": "第二天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/27.wav", + "text": "剛好質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/28.wav", + "text": "衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/29.wav", + "text": "我質詢邱部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/30.wav", + "text": "我看到在場的一個被申訴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/31.wav", + "text": "他的主秘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/32.wav", + "text": "我思考了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/33.wav", + "text": "我把他直接請上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/34.wav", + "text": "��問他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/35.wav", + "text": "你有沒有讓同事有被霸凌的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/36.wav", + "text": "他一概的否認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/37.wav", + "text": "邱部長一直說他很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/38.wav", + "text": "認真跟霸凌有什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/39.wav", + "text": "我回到辦公室之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/40.wav", + "text": "又一大堆更多的衛福部同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/41.wav", + "text": "把他的事蹟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/42.wav", + "text": "具體的都傳給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/43.wav", + "text": "後來我一直在等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/44.wav", + "text": "等到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/45.wav", + "text": "我告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/46.wav", + "text": "衛福部做了一件欺騙人民的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/47.wav", + "text": "這位主秘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/48.wav", + "text": "剛剛升官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/49.wav", + "text": "從社保司升到主秘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/50.wav", + "text": "他竟然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/51.wav", + "text": "直接升官成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/52.wav", + "text": "我不得不繼續把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/53.wav", + "text": "申訴者給我的錄音檔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/54.wav", + "text": "放出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/55.wav", + "text": "我看他怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/56.wav", + "text": "我等著他怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/57.wav", + "text": "只有在野黨的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/58.wav", + "text": "才是人民可靠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/59.wav", + "text": "信任的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/60.wav", + "text": "只有在野黨的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/61.wav", + "text": "能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/62.wav", + "text": "不庇護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/63.wav", + "text": "包庇不護短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/64.wav", + "text": "民眾黨願意做你們的靠山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/65.wav", + "text": "做你們的後盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/66.wav", + "text": "反霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/67.wav", + "text": "請加入我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/68.wav", + "text": "明天下午的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/69.wav", + "text": "反霸凌護勞權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157991/70.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/0.wav", + "text": "全國同胞們我們今天非常沉痛的站在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/1.wav", + "text": "要反霸凌反黑箱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/2.wav", + "text": "從一位公務員之死看到的是整個系統失靈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/3.wav", + "text": "中華民國有公務人員保障法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/4.wav", + "text": "中華民國有公務員考績法還有相關的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/5.wav", + "text": "但是在所有法規裡面在這一次沒有發揮任何作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/6.wav", + "text": "我們最近在審查考試院的人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/7.wav", + "text": "但是沒有一位考試委員對於相關這些法規及執行的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/8.wav", + "text": "拿出他們具體未來的政見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/9.wav", + "text": "或他們要如何改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/10.wav", + "text": "整個政府到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/11.wav", + "text": "高到行政院低到基層的公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/12.wav", + "text": "大家對反霸凌這件事情都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/13.wav", + "text": "可是霸凌不只一天霸凌已經成為常態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/14.wav", + "text": "任何形式的霸凌都不應該存在在臺灣社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/15.wav", + "text": "從爸爸媽媽不應該擔心孩子在學校被霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/16.wav", + "text": "到同事之間不應該相互之間有任何欺凌的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/17.wav", + "text": "更嚴重的是現在連我們認為最應該公平公開的公務系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/18.wav", + "text": "都產生同樣的黑箱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/19.wav", + "text": "更嚴重的是無所不在的言語霸凌網路霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/20.wav", + "text": "每一天政論節目的霸凌甚至在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/21.wav", + "text": "立法委員對於立法院同仁的霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/22.wav", + "text": "這些都存在你我的身邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/23.wav", + "text": "今天的問題在於反霸凌是普世價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/24.wav", + "text": "包括現在講的警消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/25.wav", + "text": "警消今天公祭明天忘記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/26.wav", + "text": "希望成立工會這樣卑微的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/27.wav", + "text": "到今天為止行政院也沒有做任何的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/28.wav", + "text": "我們的公務員進到職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/29.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法適應或碰到問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/30.wav", + "text": "只能默不作聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/31.wav", + "text": "接下來他可能就求助無門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/32.wav", + "text": "最後官官相護的結果成為官僚殺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/33.wav", + "text": "這不是在臺灣民主法治的現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/34.wav", + "text": "應該會發生的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/35.wav", + "text": "多年前我們大家一起反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/36.wav", + "text": "洪仲丘在軍隊裡面被霸凌致死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/37.wav", + "text": "同樣的多年後的現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/38.wav", + "text": "我們竟然還要在這裡討論公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/39.wav", + "text": "為什麼因為被霸凌而輕生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/40.wav", + "text": "任何形式的霸凌都不應該存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/41.wav", + "text": "不管在職場在學校在公務系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/42.wav", + "text": "更不應該存在在我們的輿論界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/43.wav", + "text": "還有相關任何民意機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/44.wav", + "text": "都不應該有霸凌行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/45.wav", + "text": "所以今天我們站在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/46.wav", + "text": "希望反霸凌是全民的運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/47.wav", + "text": "反黑箱讓所有的霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/48.wav", + "text": "呈現在光天化日之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/49.wav", + "text": "不會再被公務系統逼得暗無天日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/50.wav", + "text": "不要讓���何公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/51.wav", + "text": "必須要用他的生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157990/52.wav", + "text": "來捍衛他的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/0.wav", + "text": "各位全國的國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/1.wav", + "text": "線上所有的勞工跟基層公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/2.wav", + "text": "所有的好朋友大家早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/3.wav", + "text": "民進黨以勞工起家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/4.wav", + "text": "2016年提出六大勞動改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/5.wav", + "text": "工時減少薪水增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/6.wav", + "text": "支持青年跟中高齡就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/7.wav", + "text": "保護非典型的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/8.wav", + "text": "照顧職災勞工鼓勵組工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/9.wav", + "text": "還有7天假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/10.wav", + "text": "請問民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/11.wav", + "text": "你們執政快9年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/12.wav", + "text": "有高達多數的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/13.wav", + "text": "都認為民進黨對於勞工的承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/14.wav", + "text": "是跳票的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/15.wav", + "text": "這可以說選前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/16.wav", + "text": "這不是政治界的陳世美嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/17.wav", + "text": "很多人說不爽啦不爽啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/18.wav", + "text": "所以我呼籲現在的執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/19.wav", + "text": "不要只有逃避事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/20.wav", + "text": "最少六成以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/21.wav", + "text": "認為民進黨在處理職場霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/22.wav", + "text": "是沒有任何作為的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/23.wav", + "text": "只有立意良善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/24.wav", + "text": "頭痛醫頭腳痛醫腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/25.wav", + "text": "沒關係就是有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/26.wav", + "text": "有關係就是沒有關係的處理態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/27.wav", + "text": "所以我們在職場裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/28.wav", + "text": "需要的是一個保護一個保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/29.wav", + "text": "所有基層的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/30.wav", + "text": "如何去對抗職場的威權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/31.wav", + "text": "所以所有勞工的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/32.wav", + "text": "所有基層的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/33.wav", + "text": "我們要站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/34.wav", + "text": "要敢向威權的職場霸凌去挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/35.wav", + "text": "只有找出自己的生路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/36.wav", + "text": "所以我們要求不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/37.wav", + "text": "勞工要求不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/38.wav", + "text": "基層公務人員也要求不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/39.wav", + "text": "心安理得為臺灣人民來打拚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/40.wav", + "text": "所以我要呼籲執政的民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/41.wav", + "text": "趕快改進如果不改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/42.wav", + "text": "我們所有勞工團���起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157989/43.wav", + "text": "對抗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/0.wav", + "text": "民進黨執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/1.wav", + "text": "進入了第9年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/2.wav", + "text": "公務單位霸凌事件卻層出不窮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/3.wav", + "text": "連標榜維護勞工權益的勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/4.wav", + "text": "都爆發勞發署北區分署前分署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/5.wav", + "text": "長期霸凌下屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/6.wav", + "text": "導致下屬在辦公室尋短的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/7.wav", + "text": "而勞動部第一次的調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/8.wav", + "text": "竟表示謝宜容前分署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/9.wav", + "text": "霸凌下屬的行為是立意良善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/10.wav", + "text": "引發人民更大的怒火之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/11.wav", + "text": "才緊急將謝宜容記兩大過免職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/12.wav", + "text": "連帶讓前勞動部長何佩珊辭職下台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/13.wav", + "text": "但民進黨這種見矛頭不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/14.wav", + "text": "才急急轉向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/15.wav", + "text": "試圖滅火的行為真的有用嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/16.wav", + "text": "根據民調顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/17.wav", + "text": "高達58.1%的受訪者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/18.wav", + "text": "不滿意賴政府這一次的處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/19.wav", + "text": "表示滿意的只有25.5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/20.wav", + "text": "比民進黨鐵桿支持者還要低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/21.wav", + "text": "原因何在呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/22.wav", + "text": "因為人民眼睛所看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/23.wav", + "text": "以及心裡都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/24.wav", + "text": "民進黨並沒有真正要解決問題的根源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/25.wav", + "text": "也就是民進黨拿到權力之後的扭曲心態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/26.wav", + "text": "在民進黨掌權之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/27.wav", + "text": "無論是公部門甚至是半官方單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/28.wav", + "text": "似乎只有政治正確才足以生存下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/29.wav", + "text": "用人哲學滿滿都是政治文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/30.wav", + "text": "不是政治正確就是有裙帶關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/31.wav", + "text": "形成小圈圈的自己人文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/32.wav", + "text": "不在小圈圈裡的就是外人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/33.wav", + "text": "即使是內閣政務官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/34.wav", + "text": "如果是專業任命而非政治任命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/35.wav", + "text": "你就不在小圈圈之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/36.wav", + "text": "小圈圈逐漸地形成權貴文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/37.wav", + "text": "自認自己是主子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/38.wav", + "text": "其他的公務人員都是家僕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/39.wav", + "text": "外行領導內行官員不敢有主見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/40.wav", + "text": "必須仰賴黨意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/41.wav", + "text": "\n民進黨對公務人員頤指氣使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/42.wav", + "text": "大家深刻體會到在民進黨執政下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/43.wav", + "text": "公務人員是非常痛苦的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/44.wav", + "text": "導致現在高普考的報考率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/45.wav", + "text": "竟然只剩下以前的一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/46.wav", + "text": "民進黨官官相護的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/47.wav", + "text": "以及敗壞官場風氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/48.wav", + "text": "已經不是這一兩天的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/49.wav", + "text": "而是長期綠營權貴仰仗自己有靠山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/50.wav", + "text": "在職場胡作非為為所欲為所導致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/51.wav", + "text": "民進黨再不痛定思痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/52.wav", + "text": "真心地面對及處理問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/53.wav", + "text": "將會繼續動搖國家的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/54.wav", + "text": "包括了36萬的公務大軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157988/55.wav", + "text": "以及全國1,200萬的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/0.wav", + "text": "各位親愛的家人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/1.wav", + "text": "大家早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/2.wav", + "text": "已經一個月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/3.wav", + "text": "記得嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/4.wav", + "text": "洪申翰部長曾說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/5.wav", + "text": "他早就知道勞動部高官常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/6.wav", + "text": "霸凌基層公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/7.wav", + "text": "當時他說他只是一個立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/8.wav", + "text": "無法協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/9.wav", + "text": "如今身為部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/10.wav", + "text": "卻依然束手無策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/11.wav", + "text": "被質詢時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/12.wav", + "text": "他說不出解決方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/13.wav", + "text": "不敢承擔責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/14.wav", + "text": "也毫無具體作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/15.wav", + "text": "更離譜的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/16.wav", + "text": "到現在還說在調查中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/17.wav", + "text": "這位很可愛的洪部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/18.wav", + "text": "但是做不到半撇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/19.wav", + "text": "所以別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/20.wav", + "text": "別人說他的學歷是歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/21.wav", + "text": "他到處去講我的學歷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/22.wav", + "text": "取笑我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/23.wav", + "text": "就是高尚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/24.wav", + "text": "有嘴說別人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/25.wav", + "text": "沒嘴說自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/26.wav", + "text": "在你刮別人的鬍子之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/27.wav", + "text": "請先把自己的鬍子刮乾淨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/28.wav", + "text": "\n勞動部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/29.wav", + "text": "霸凌案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/30.wav", + "text": "釀成一位年輕的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/31.wav", + "text": "這樣的職場霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/32.wav", + "text": "不只是在勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/33.wav", + "text": "其他部會也一直發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/34.wav", + "text": "洪申翰部長踩著基層的生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/35.wav", + "text": "爬上高位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/36.wav", + "text": "卻不知道大家的苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/37.wav", + "text": "大家知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/38.wav", + "text": "現在有一位媽媽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/39.wav", + "text": "每天在等孩子回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/40.wav", + "text": "我們還在等什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/41.wav", + "text": "一起上班的同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/42.wav", + "text": "現在有人不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/43.wav", + "text": "難道我們還要繼續沉默嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/44.wav", + "text": "我們要一起牽著手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/45.wav", + "text": "一起站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/46.wav", + "text": "走出霸凌的陰影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/47.wav", + "text": "需要極大的勇氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/48.wav", + "text": "絕對不是容易的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/49.wav", + "text": "但是我深深地體驗到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/50.wav", + "text": "7月16號我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/51.wav", + "text": "審查新住民基本法時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/52.wav", + "text": "民進黨立委輪流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/53.wav", + "text": "用各種歧視語言去霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/54.wav", + "text": "嘲笑我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/55.wav", + "text": "有7位立委陪伴支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/56.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨是我的後盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/57.wav", + "text": "更高興的是我們高金委員及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/58.wav", + "text": "國民黨各位委員們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/59.wav", + "text": "伸出援手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/60.wav", + "text": "牽著我走出霸凌的陰影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/61.wav", + "text": "\n校園霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/62.wav", + "text": "職場霸凌不是一天兩天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/63.wav", + "text": "但是我們希望大家站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/64.wav", + "text": "為了我們的下一代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/65.wav", + "text": "難道我們都不心疼嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/66.wav", + "text": "小孩子都有媽媽的疼愛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/67.wav", + "text": "每一個人都是媽媽心目中的寶貝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/68.wav", + "text": "所以邀請大家一起和我們站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/69.wav", + "text": "反霸凌護勞權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/70.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157987/71.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/0.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/1.wav", + "text": "今天在場的各位好朋友大家早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/2.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/3.wav", + "text": "對委員所提出的有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/4.wav", + "text": "政府對於現職及退休人員的待遇都應該衡平兼顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/5.wav", + "text": "則是橫跨歷代政府希望完成的相關改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/6.wav", + "text": "過去我們的退撫基金曾經因為根本性問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/7.wav", + "text": "在馬政府時期曾經提出要推動年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/8.wav", + "text": "不過最後未能完成相關修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/9.wav", + "text": "直到2016年蔡政府上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/10.wav", + "text": "才開始著手推動年金改革的重大政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/11.wav", + "text": "月退休金起支年齡偏低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/12.wav", + "text": "所得替代率偏高等問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/13.wav", + "text": "當時部長您也在人事總處服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/14.wav", + "text": "對充分的參與到推動年金改革方案的整個過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/15.wav", + "text": "現在提案委員所提出的修法主張和理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/16.wav", + "text": "相信部長您應該感到非常熟悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/17.wav", + "text": "首先想就教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/18.wav", + "text": "您認為2018年以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/19.wav", + "text": "對整個基金財務健全來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/20.wav", + "text": "真的有很大的幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/21.wav", + "text": "因為它達成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/22.wav", + "text": "至少努力達成當初的一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/23.wav", + "text": "即希望能夠延後一個世代才破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/24.wav", + "text": "因為這樣的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/25.wav", + "text": "因為有更多的錢進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/26.wav", + "text": "讓我們的年度收支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/27.wav", + "text": "因此我們就有更多基金的錢可以進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/28.wav", + "text": "進行投資累積基金淨額其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/29.wav", + "text": "我們現在還有2.9兆負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/30.wav", + "text": "但是因為這些努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/31.wav", + "text": "大概可以維持到1.8兆左右的負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/32.wav", + "text": "等於是這中間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/33.wav", + "text": "我們未來還會繼續再有新的錢進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/34.wav", + "text": "我想這是蠻重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/35.wav", + "text": "財務上的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/36.wav", + "text": "好部長您認為以目前來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/37.wav", + "text": "還有沒有再實施改革的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/38.wav", + "text": "我還是講這個基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/39.wav", + "text": "不是只有已退的人員會使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/40.wav", + "text": "還包括現職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/41.wav", + "text": "未來要一起使用這個基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/42.wav", + "text": "其實對財務貢獻是非常非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/43.wav", + "text": "我個人是主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/44.wav", + "text": "因為到118年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/45.wav", + "text": "大概就停止調降所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/46.wav", + "text": "未來我們的財務以估算來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/47.wav", + "text": "是真的可以比較穩健的達到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/48.wav", + "text": "有一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/49.wav", + "text": "是要提前停止退休所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/50.wav", + "text": "再繼續逐年遞減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/51.wav", + "text": "就剛剛部長您說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/52.wav", + "text": "到118年才會停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/53.wav", + "text": "的當年年金改革所提出1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/54.wav", + "text": "應當是為了要減輕衝擊的力道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/55.wav", + "text": "透過衡平考量來作為制度的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/56.wav", + "text": "舒緩退休所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/57.wav", + "text": "偏高所造成的相關問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/58.wav", + "text": "如果即刻停止退休所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/59.wav", + "text": "基金是不是又會面臨再次破產的一個危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/60.wav", + "text": "如果真的就停止的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/61.wav", + "text": "未來我們大概會減少2,800億的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/62.wav", + "text": "這個其實對基金來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/63.wav", + "text": "是很大一個衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/64.wav", + "text": "停止的話降低所造成財務的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/65.wav", + "text": "就會跑出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/66.wav", + "text": "而退撫基金的收支失衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/67.wav", + "text": "持續累積下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/68.wav", + "text": "受影響的不單是退撫基金本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/69.wav", + "text": "也有可能會衝擊到國家整體財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/70.wav", + "text": "和相關的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/71.wav", + "text": "所以政府應當讓年金制度能夠朝向合理化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/72.wav", + "text": "健全化還有永續化的方向來發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/73.wav", + "text": "未來我們應該如何來達成基金財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/74.wav", + "text": "我想除了繼續讓基金改革措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/75.wav", + "text": "按照法律走以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/76.wav", + "text": "當然我們也會來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/77.wav", + "text": "能夠讓它增加投資效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/78.wav", + "text": "這方面都是我們一起共同來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/79.wav", + "text": "有很大的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/80.wav", + "text": "還是聚焦在退休所得替代率的一個上限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/81.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要著重於實際領到的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/82.wav", + "text": "尤其我們看到這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/83.wav", + "text": "銓敘部所提出的相關附表顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/84.wav", + "text": "我們目前這種平均月退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/85.wav", + "text": "大部分都在5萬塊以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/86.wav", + "text": "我想是否能夠維持基本的生活需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/87.wav", + "text": "而且現職的人員待遇之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/88.wav", + "text": "他們衡平性也能夠再進行相關的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/89.wav", + "text": "\n我想請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/90.wav", + "text": "若我們依照現行的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/91.wav", + "text": "持續來調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/92.wav", + "text": "退休所得替代率會不會降到比其他的國家還低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/93.wav", + "text": "還是說我們因為計算的方式不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/94.wav", + "text": "已經沒有反映實質的替代率了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/95.wav", + "text": "我想即使名目上維持在60" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/96.wav", + "text": "%跟OECD國家的平均值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/97.wav", + "text": "比事實上都還是高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/98.wav", + "text": "更何況名目上60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/99.wav", + "text": "實質上並不是60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/100.wav", + "text": "比其他國家還高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/101.wav", + "text": "對都比其他國家還高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/102.wav", + "text": "大概是在70%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/103.wav", + "text": "70%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/104.wav", + "text": "確實也是存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/105.wav", + "text": "啦這也是一些退休人員所擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/106.wav", + "text": "應該要有穩健合理的調整機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/107.wav", + "text": "加以保障並維持退休所得的實質購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/108.wav", + "text": "銓敘部目前是透過什麼樣的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/109.wav", + "text": "我們就應該要檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/110.wav", + "text": "所以過去這一段年改以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/111.wav", + "text": "對退休人員的退休所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/112.wav", + "text": "已經累計調整6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/113.wav", + "text": "當然如果沒有達到5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/114.wav", + "text": "我們還有另外一個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/115.wav", + "text": "每4年也應該定期來檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/116.wav", + "text": "其實我們兩次調整6%第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/117.wav", + "text": "的物價指數還沒有達到5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/118.wav", + "text": "事實上那時候是用每4年去調整它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/119.wav", + "text": "公部門的人力正面臨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/120.wav", + "text": "一個非常大的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/121.wav", + "text": "不但高普考的報考率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/122.wav", + "text": "10年來對砍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/123.wav", + "text": "公部門離職率和流動率也都相對的在提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/124.wav", + "text": "改制會對現職的人員和新進人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/125.wav", + "text": "造成什麼樣的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/126.wav", + "text": "我們新進人員都已經實施專戶制了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/127.wav", + "text": "所以專戶制跟我們現在討論這個基金是獨立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/128.wav", + "text": "新進的人員來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/129.wav", + "text": "他們不會受我們今天討論的東西的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/130.wav", + "text": "就是純粹就退休金來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/131.wav", + "text": "新進的就不會受對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/132.wav", + "text": "因為已經實施專戶制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/133.wav", + "text": "好我們大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/134.wav", + "text": "下一個世代正面臨少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/135.wav", + "text": "尤其明年臺灣即將進入超高齡的社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/136.wav", + "text": "年輕人肩負的壓力不斷上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/137.wav", + "text": "會造成退撫基金不幸的提前破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/138.wav", + "text": "該如何來補償權益受損的這些青年世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/139.wav", + "text": "所以還是跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/140.wav", + "text": "我們銓敘部的職責就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/141.wav", + "text": "無論如何要讓這個基金財務能夠永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/142.wav", + "text": "讓現在適用這個基金的現職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/143.wav", + "text": "他以後退休的時候能夠領得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/144.wav", + "text": "我想這是我們的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/145.wav", + "text": "因此我們對於任何檢討的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/146.wav", + "text": "我都認為應該要重視對財務基金的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/147.wav", + "text": "當然還有社會不同聲音的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/148.wav", + "text": "我們也非常的清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/149.wav", + "text": "維持現行的制度會是相對穩健衡平的一個作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/150.wav", + "text": "我們要保障公務人員權益的同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/151.wav", + "text": "讓年金制度能夠永續不破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/152.wav", + "text": "是我們共同的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/153.wav", + "text": "但是也需要和社會來持續的溝通尋求共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/154.wav", + "text": "我們後續可能對於這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/155.wav", + "text": "以慎重的態度來討論年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/156.wav", + "text": "持續朝向世代財務穩健的一個目標來發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/157.wav", + "text": "讓年金破產的危機不再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/158.wav", + "text": "我相信領得到持續領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/159.wav", + "text": "而且領到老有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/160.wav", + "text": "這個一定是我們軍公教各階層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/161.wav", + "text": "所有民眾所期待的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157986/162.wav", + "text": "我希望我們相關部會能夠審慎地來處理這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/1.wav", + "text": "有請銓敘部施部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/2.wav", + "text": "麻煩施部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/3.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/4.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/5.wav", + "text": "過去我們為了顧及世代正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/6.wav", + "text": "也兼顧年金制度的合理化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/7.wav", + "text": "健全化永續化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/8.wav", + "text": "總統府成立國家年金改革委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/9.wav", + "text": "在縝密的討論跟考量下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/10.wav", + "text": "在2018年修正實施至今" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/11.wav", + "text": "如果當初沒有推行這個改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/12.wav", + "text": "根據精算結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/13.wav", + "text": "退撫基金將提前在2030年破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/14.wav", + "text": "這下不只國家照顧不到公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/15.wav", + "text": "我想連現任公務人員也連帶會被拖累" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/16.wav", + "text": "甚至對於年度總預算的編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/17.wav", + "text": "\n在年金改革下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/18.wav", + "text": "財政效益當然是顯而易見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/19.wav", + "text": "2016年到2023年軍公教人員節省的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/20.wav", + "text": "全部挹注在退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/21.wav", + "text": "高達2,774億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/22.wav", + "text": "另外我們也撥補294億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/23.wav", + "text": "挹注專戶新制所造成的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/24.wav", + "text": "如果修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/25.wav", + "text": "提前停止替代率再逐年調降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/26.wav", + "text": "將減少挹注約2,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/27.wav", + "text": "隨著退撫基金可運用的投資金額減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/28.wav", + "text": "版本很明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/29.wav", + "text": "就是想進一步拖垮國家財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/30.wav", + "text": "我覺得是一個相當不負責任的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/31.wav", + "text": "那這個修法的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/32.wav", + "text": "顯然一定不是銓敘部所贊同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/33.wav", + "text": "所以要請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/34.wav", + "text": "銓敘部站在照顧公務人員立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/35.wav", + "text": "停止退休所得替代率再逐年降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/36.wav", + "text": "是不是會影響全體公務人員權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/37.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告確實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/38.wav", + "text": "因為委員剛剛所提出的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/39.wav", + "text": "所以確實會讓基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/40.wav", + "text": "大概提早4到5年破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/41.wav", + "text": "而這個基金支付的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/42.wav", + "text": "包括現職還沒有退休的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/43.wav", + "text": "員所以這是大家要一起共同維護的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/44.wav", + "text": "就財務永續經營來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/45.wav", + "text": "會有很大的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/46.wav", + "text": "當年的年金改革修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/47.wav", + "text": "司法院也曾作出憲法解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/48.wav", + "text": "肯認修法的合憲性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/49.wav", + "text": "當年備受國民黨質疑的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/50.wav", + "text": "所謂法律不溯及既往原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/51.wav", + "text": "信賴保護原則以及比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/52.wav", + "text": "年金改革的修法是完全合憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/53.wav", + "text": "合憲從這個釋字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/54.wav", + "text": "也可以看出大法官的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/55.wav", + "text": "就是肯定年金改革的合憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/56.wav", + "text": "我們在改革上所做的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/57.wav", + "text": "特別是影響到國家財政的穩健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/58.wav", + "text": "前副總統陳建仁之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/59.wav", + "text": "前作為國家年金改革委員會召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/60.wav", + "text": "曾經指出這項憲法解釋的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/61.wav", + "text": "代表全國所有現職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/62.wav", + "text": "跟已退休軍公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/63.wav", + "text": "退撫基金會有破產危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/64.wav", + "text": "可以有穩定的退休生活保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/65.wav", + "text": "讓世世代代領得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/66.wav", + "text": "長長久久領到老" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/67.wav", + "text": "可是我們看到這次的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/68.wav", + "text": "不但有可能打破這項保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/69.wav", + "text": "也有可能再拖累我們下個世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/70.wav", + "text": "在釋字第782號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/71.wav", + "text": "解釋肯認當年修法合憲的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/72.wav", + "text": "這一次違反世代正義修法的合憲性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/73.wav", + "text": "已經經過大法官會議解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/74.wav", + "text": "所有的改革措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/75.wav", + "text": "基本上都具有合憲性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/76.wav", + "text": "包括信賴保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/77.wav", + "text": "大家最大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/78.wav", + "text": "也因為要創造更大的公共利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/79.wav", + "text": "社會利益所以都認為合憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/80.wav", + "text": "是想要再重新討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/81.wav", + "text": "我想這是立法委員的職掌我們表示尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/82.wav", + "text": "但也建議應該再尋求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/83.wav", + "text": "社會更多的共識大家一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/84.wav", + "text": "這樣會是比較穩當的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/85.wav", + "text": "是好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/86.wav", + "text": "最後我想呼籲在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/87.wav", + "text": "為了讓退撫基金的財務可以永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/88.wav", + "text": "而且也回應社會世代正義的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/89.wav", + "text": "影響國家財務健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/90.wav", + "text": "也期待站在永續照顧公務人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/91.wav", + "text": "角度來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/92.wav", + "text": "停止這次的修法審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157985/93.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/0.wav", + "text": "還有媒體先進今天在場的各位好朋友大家早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/1.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/2.wav", + "text": "針對委員所提出的有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/3.wav", + "text": "政府對於現職及退休人員的待遇都應該衡平兼顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/4.wav", + "text": "則是橫跨歷代政府希望完成的相關改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/5.wav", + "text": "過去我們的退撫基金曾經因為根本性問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/6.wav", + "text": "在馬政府時期曾經提出要推動年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/7.wav", + "text": "不過最後未能完成相關修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/8.wav", + "text": "直到2016年蔡政府上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/9.wav", + "text": "才開始著手推動年金改革的重大政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/10.wav", + "text": "起支年齡偏低所得替代率偏高等問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/11.wav", + "text": "當時部長您也在人事總處服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/12.wav", + "text": "充分的參與到推動年金改革方案的整個過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/13.wav", + "text": "現在提案委員所提出的修法主張和理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/14.wav", + "text": "相信部長您應該感到非常熟悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/15.wav", + "text": "首先想就教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/16.wav", + "text": "您認為2018年以來現行的這套制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/17.wav", + "text": "對整個基金財務健全來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/18.wav", + "text": "真的有很大的幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/19.wav", + "text": "因為它達成了至少努力達成當初的一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/20.wav", + "text": "即希望能夠延後一個世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/21.wav", + "text": "因此我們就有更多基金的錢可以進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/22.wav", + "text": "進行投資累積基金淨額其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/23.wav", + "text": "我們現在還有2.9兆負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/24.wav", + "text": "但是因為這些努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/25.wav", + "text": "大概可以維持到1.8兆左右的負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/26.wav", + "text": "等於是這中間我們未來還會繼續再有新的錢進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/27.wav", + "text": "好部長您認為以目前來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/28.wav", + "text": "還有沒有再實施改革的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/29.wav", + "text": "這個基金不是只有已退的人員會使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/30.wav", + "text": "未來要一起使用這個基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/31.wav", + "text": "其實對財務貢獻是非常非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/32.wav", + "text": "我個人是主張繼續讓它走完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/33.wav", + "text": "因為到118年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/34.wav", + "text": "大概就停止調降所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/35.wav", + "text": "未來我們的財務以估算來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/36.wav", + "text": "是真的可以比較穩健的達到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/37.wav", + "text": "是要提前停止退休所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/38.wav", + "text": "再繼續逐年遞減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/39.wav", + "text": "就剛剛部長您說到118年才會停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/40.wav", + "text": "的當年年金改革所提出1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/41.wav", + "text": "應當是為了要減輕衝擊的力道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/42.wav", + "text": "透過衡平考量來作為制度的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/43.wav", + "text": "舒緩退休所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/44.wav", + "text": "偏高所造成的相關問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/45.wav", + "text": "如果即刻停止退休所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/46.wav", + "text": "又會面臨再次破產的一個危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/47.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告我們估算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/48.wav", + "text": "未來我們大概會減少2,800億的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/49.wav", + "text": "注這個其實對基金來講是很大一個衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/50.wav", + "text": "降低所造成財務的缺口就會跑出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/51.wav", + "text": "而退撫基金的收支失衡持續累積下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/52.wav", + "text": "受影響的不單是退撫基金本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/53.wav", + "text": "也有可能會衝擊到國家整體財政和相關的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/54.wav", + "text": "所以政府應當讓年金制度能夠朝向合理化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/55.wav", + "text": "健全化還有永續化的方向來發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/56.wav", + "text": "未來我們應該如何來達成基金財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/57.wav", + "text": "我想除了繼續讓基金改革措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/58.wav", + "text": "按照法律走以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/59.wav", + "text": "當然我們也會來努力做基金的財務投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/60.wav", + "text": "能夠讓它增加投資效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/61.wav", + "text": "這方面都是我們一起共同來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/62.wav", + "text": "有很大的程度還是聚焦在退休所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/63.wav", + "text": "替代率的一個上限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/64.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要著重於實際領到的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/65.wav", + "text": "尤其我們看到這次銓敘部所提出的相關附表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/66.wav", + "text": "顯示我們目前這種平均月退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/67.wav", + "text": "大部分都在5萬塊以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/68.wav", + "text": "我想是否能夠維持基本的生活需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/69.wav", + "text": "而且現職的人員待遇之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/70.wav", + "text": "他們衡平性也能夠再進行相關的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/71.wav", + "text": "\n我想請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/72.wav", + "text": "若我們依照現行的制度持續來調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/73.wav", + "text": "退休所得替代率會不會降到比其他的國家還低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/74.wav", + "text": "還是說我們因為計算的方式不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/75.wav", + "text": "已經沒有反映實質的替代率了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/76.wav", + "text": "我想即使名目上維持在60" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/77.wav", + "text": "%跟OECD國家的平均值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/78.wav", + "text": "比事實上都還是高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/79.wav", + "text": "更何況名目上60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/80.wav", + "text": "實質上並不是60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/81.wav", + "text": "比其他國家還高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/82.wav", + "text": "對都比其他國家還高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/83.wav", + "text": "大概是在70%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/84.wav", + "text": "70%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/85.wav", + "text": "加以保障並維持退休所得的實質購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/86.wav", + "text": "銓敘部目前是透過什麼樣的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/87.wav", + "text": "來減少物價通膨對退休人員生活的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/88.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/89.wav", + "text": "其實我們現在都是根據法律明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/90.wav", + "text": "如果說CPI累計達到5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/91.wav", + "text": "我們就應該要檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/92.wav", + "text": "所以過去這一段年改以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/93.wav", + "text": "已經累計調整6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/94.wav", + "text": "當然如果沒有達到5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/95.wav", + "text": "我們還有另外一個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/96.wav", + "text": "每4年也應該定期來檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/97.wav", + "text": "其實我們兩次調整6%第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/98.wav", + "text": "的物價指數還沒有達到5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/99.wav", + "text": "事實上那時候是用每4年去調整它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/100.wav", + "text": "公部門的人力正面臨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/101.wav", + "text": "一個非常大的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/102.wav", + "text": "不但高普考的報考率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/103.wav", + "text": "10年來對砍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/104.wav", + "text": "公部門離職率和流動率也都相對的在提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/105.wav", + "text": "改制會對現職的人員和新進人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/106.wav", + "text": "造成什麼樣的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/107.wav", + "text": "我們新進人員都已經實施專戶制了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/108.wav", + "text": "所以專戶制跟我們現在討論這個基金是獨立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/109.wav", + "text": "來講他們不會受我們今天討論的東西的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/110.wav", + "text": "就是純粹就退休金來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/111.wav", + "text": "好我們大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/112.wav", + "text": "下一個世代正面臨少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/113.wav", + "text": "尤其明年臺灣即將進入超高齡的社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/114.wav", + "text": "年輕人肩負的壓力不斷上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/115.wav", + "text": "會造成退撫基金不幸的提前破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/116.wav", + "text": "該如何來補償權益受損的這些青年世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/117.wav", + "text": "所以還是跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/118.wav", + "text": "我們銓敘部的職責就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/119.wav", + "text": "無論如何要讓這個基金財務能夠永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/120.wav", + "text": "讓現在適用這個基金的現職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/121.wav", + "text": "他以後退休的時候能夠領得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/122.wav", + "text": "我想這是我們的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/123.wav", + "text": "因此我們對於任何檢討的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/124.wav", + "text": "我都認為應該要重視對財務基金的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/125.wav", + "text": "當然還有社會不同聲音的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/126.wav", + "text": "今天一個早上到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/127.wav", + "text": "我們也非常的清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/128.wav", + "text": "維持現行的���度會是相對穩健衡平的一個作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/129.wav", + "text": "我們要保障公務人員權益的同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/130.wav", + "text": "讓年金制度能夠永續不破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/131.wav", + "text": "是我們共同的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/132.wav", + "text": "但是也需要和社會來持續的溝通尋求共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/133.wav", + "text": "我們後續可能對於這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/134.wav", + "text": "以慎重的態度來討論年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/135.wav", + "text": "持續朝向世代財務穩健的一個目標來發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/136.wav", + "text": "讓年金破產的危機不再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/137.wav", + "text": "我相信領得到持續領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/138.wav", + "text": "而且領到老有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/139.wav", + "text": "這個一定是我們軍公教各階層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/140.wav", + "text": "所有民眾所期待的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157979/141.wav", + "text": "我希望我們相關部會能夠審慎地來處理這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/1.wav", + "text": "等一下我質詢時會就教於這二位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/2.wav", + "text": "請劉部長李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/3.wav", + "text": "問的都是關於這個鳥籠罷免的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/4.wav", + "text": "罷免的票數必須比當選的票數還要高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/5.wav", + "text": "這個就是鳥籠罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/6.wav", + "text": "但我還是要請問內政部劉部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/7.wav", + "text": "其實她已經卸任了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/8.wav", + "text": "為什麼還要解除她的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/9.wav", + "text": "應該要放棄他國國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/10.wav", + "text": "並給予一年的時間放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/11.wav", + "text": "當選在南投縣議會公告她當選之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/12.wav", + "text": "因此我們就引用國籍法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/13.wav", + "text": "的規定發公文給史雪燕本人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/14.wav", + "text": "及南投縣議會解除她的議員職務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/15.wav", + "text": "也就是她沒有放棄中國的國籍就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/16.wav", + "text": "目前是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/17.wav", + "text": "有沒有放棄中國國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/18.wav", + "text": "戶役政系統裡查不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/19.wav", + "text": "我們也問過南投縣議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/20.wav", + "text": "南投縣議會應該在一年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/21.wav", + "text": "就知道這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/22.wav", + "text": "但南投縣議會也沒辦法回答這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/23.wav", + "text": "所以我們的判斷是她並沒有放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/24.wav", + "text": "證明自己已經放棄中國國籍就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/25.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/26.wav", + "text": "第10條的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/27.wav", + "text": "外國人不得擔任總統副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/28.wav", + "text": "包含立法委員���不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/29.wav", + "text": "嘛國籍法第2條也規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/30.wav", + "text": "中華民國國民取得外國國籍者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/31.wav", + "text": "不得擔任中華民國的公職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/32.wav", + "text": "總統副總統的選舉罷免法也規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/33.wav", + "text": "具有外國國籍者不得申請登記為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/34.wav", + "text": "總統副總統候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/35.wav", + "text": "針對縣市首長立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/36.wav", + "text": "是否有規定具雙重國籍者不得參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/37.wav", + "text": "只要是符合選罷法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/38.wav", + "text": "4個月以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/39.wav", + "text": "而且具有中華民國國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/40.wav", + "text": "並符合設籍的要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/41.wav", + "text": "即便是具有外國的國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/42.wav", + "text": "並無礙於其候選人的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/43.wav", + "text": "他是可以參選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/44.wav", + "text": "他是可以參選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/45.wav", + "text": "如果選上之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/46.wav", + "text": "在就職前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/47.wav", + "text": "這是國籍法第2條的規定嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/48.wav", + "text": "在一年之內必須要完成放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/49.wav", + "text": "總統副總統的規定很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/50.wav", + "text": "雙重國籍外國籍就不能登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/51.wav", + "text": "參選但是對於縣市首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/52.wav", + "text": "或其他民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/53.wav", + "text": "都沒有這樣的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/54.wav", + "text": "也就是說具有雙重國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/55.wav", + "text": "者可以參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/56.wav", + "text": "就是當選無效是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/57.wav", + "text": "要解職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/58.wav", + "text": "有74%的人認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/59.wav", + "text": "中配擔任立法委員等公職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/60.wav", + "text": "需要放棄中華人民共和國的國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/61.wav", + "text": "陸委會最新的民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/62.wav", + "text": "74%的人認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/63.wav", + "text": "必須放棄中華人民共和國的國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/64.wav", + "text": "現在我想問一個實際的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/65.wav", + "text": "有機會遞補的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/66.wav", + "text": "他是中配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/67.wav", + "text": "是否要提出申請拋棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/68.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/69.wav", + "text": "在立法委員就職那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/70.wav", + "text": "是對著大法官宣誓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/71.wav", + "text": "就是要恪遵中華民國的憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/72.wav", + "text": "立法委員也必須簽署一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/73.wav", + "text": "因此在當選的那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/74.wav", + "text": "中華民國的人民自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/75.wav", + "text": "因為我們要給他一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/76.wav", + "text": "點作業的時間緩衝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/77.wav", + "text": "任中華民國的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/78.wav", + "text": "一直到他解職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/79.wav", + "text": "助理費要繳回嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/80.wav", + "text": "這個要由立法院決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/81.wav", + "text": "在當選的狀態中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/82.wav", + "text": "不符合國籍法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/83.wav", + "text": "必須解職的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/84.wav", + "text": "必須由立法院告知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/85.wav", + "text": "他被解職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/86.wav", + "text": "因為這是一層一層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/87.wav", + "text": "擔任立法委員時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/88.wav", + "text": "所取得的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/89.wav", + "text": "及其他相關的薪資補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/90.wav", + "text": "公職人員選舉罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/91.wav", + "text": "應該要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/92.wav", + "text": "者可以參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/93.wav", + "text": "一年內放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/94.wav", + "text": "總統副總統選舉罷免法一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/95.wav", + "text": "具有雙重國籍者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/96.wav", + "text": "者就不能登記參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/97.wav", + "text": "登記為不分區立委的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/98.wav", + "text": "立法委員的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/99.wav", + "text": "但是因為過去被註銷掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/100.wav", + "text": "都是引用國籍法為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/101.wav", + "text": "我是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/102.wav", + "text": "不要有這個漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/103.wav", + "text": "或空窗期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/104.wav", + "text": "具有雙重國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/105.wav", + "text": "才要放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/106.wav", + "text": "於是就衍生出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/107.wav", + "text": "雙重國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/108.wav", + "text": "立委或一樣可以參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/109.wav", + "text": "縣市議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/110.wav", + "text": "甚至搞不好參選立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/111.wav", + "text": "都有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/112.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/113.wav", + "text": "就我所了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/114.wav", + "text": "包括縣市議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/115.wav", + "text": "臺北市議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/116.wav", + "text": "及高雄市議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/117.wav", + "text": "不允許雙重國籍的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/118.wav", + "text": "議員並請他們簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/119.wav", + "text": "署因此事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/120.wav", + "text": "確實有議員本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/121.wav", + "text": "因為具有雙重國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/122.wav", + "text": "而被取消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/123.wav", + "text": "要說第一個議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/124.wav", + "text": "還是要根據國籍法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/125.wav", + "text": "進行嚴格的把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/126.wav", + "text": "我也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/127.wav", + "text": "立法院當然就是要立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/128.wav", + "text": "要立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/129.wav", + "text": "要立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/130.wav", + "text": "譬如可能要立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/131.wav", + "text": "院會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/132.wav", + "text": "有些立委提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/133.wav", + "text": "了比較嚴格的修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/134.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/135.wav", + "text": "謝謝主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157975/136.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/0.wav", + "text": "想要跟部長分享一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/1.wav", + "text": "因為這些問題每一題我都問過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/2.wav", + "text": "我也有很多的提案版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/3.wav", + "text": "但是好像一直被漠視也一直沒有獲得解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/4.wav", + "text": "所以這一次看到選罷法修正案能夠受到這麼大的關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/5.wav", + "text": "我個人滿羨慕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/6.wav", + "text": "我也希望大家一起來重視原住民的選舉需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/7.wav", + "text": "\n第一個部分要提到的就是關於憲法保障原住民有6席立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/8.wav", + "text": "但是我們的選罷法卻允許缺額的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/9.wav", + "text": "怎麼說呢因為選罷法第7條第2項後段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/10.wav", + "text": "跟直轄市議員縣（市）議員鄉（鎮市）民代表原住民區民代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/11.wav", + "text": "視同一樣就是同一個選舉區內缺額達二分之一的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/12.wav", + "text": "才能夠進行補選投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/13.wav", + "text": "也就是說按照我們現在的情況山原假設有3位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/14.wav", + "text": "二分之一就是要2位要缺額2位才能補選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/15.wav", + "text": "3個立委2個出事才能補選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/16.wav", + "text": "如果單一來看假設山原缺1個平原缺1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/17.wav", + "text": "等同6個立法委員缺2個其實也都不能補選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/18.wav", + "text": "\n這樣的狀況以前有沒有發生有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/19.wav", + "text": "例如第8屆的平地原住民立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/20.wav", + "text": "在2013年被判刑定讞解除職務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/21.wav", + "text": "嚴重的傷害我們的參政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/22.wav", + "text": "所以本席有提出過選罷法第7條第71條及第73條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/23.wav", + "text": "一旦有缺額就有補選或遞補的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/24.wav", + "text": "但是很遺憾沒有引起共鳴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/25.wav", + "text": "\n另外我也要提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/26.wav", + "text": "大家都知道我們原住民立委很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/27.wav", + "text": "因為選區很大為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/28.wav", + "text": "憲法增修條文在2005年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/29.wav", + "text": "國民大會複決通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/30.wav", + "text": "所以第7屆立委的席次減半變為113席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/31.wav", + "text": "從那個時候開始區域立委是單一選區多數決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/32.wav", + "text": "我們原住民立委又來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/33.wav", + "text": "跟地方民代相同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/34.wav", + "text": "是複數選區單記非讓渡投票制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/35.wav", + "text": "這讓我們疲於奔命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/36.wav", + "text": "最沒有經濟能力的原住民立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/37.wav", + "text": "不論是在選舉或者是在服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/38.wav", + "text": "都是那麼大的等同總統的選區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/39.wav", + "text": "所以我想要問一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/40.wav", + "text": "哪一條法律告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/41.wav", + "text": "原住民的選區一定要全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/42.wav", + "text": "這個選區劃分是誰的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/43.wav", + "text": "選區的劃分好像是由中選會來訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/44.wav", + "text": "我們的選務機關嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/45.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/46.wav", + "text": "因為時間的關係我就直接講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/47.wav", + "text": "我希望修正選罷法第35條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/48.wav", + "text": "讓我們的選舉區能夠有所改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/49.wav", + "text": "因為我們要面對的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/50.wav", + "text": "不但有山原平原這個憲法給我們匡住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/51.wav", + "text": "的毫無意義或者是殖民分類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/52.wav", + "text": "現在全國的原住民根本沒有在分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/53.wav", + "text": "啊根本沒有在分全國哪裡都可以住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/54.wav", + "text": "啊然後這造成了什麼萬年立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/55.wav", + "text": "我們的年輕人很難挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/56.wav", + "text": "我們原住民立委很難以世代交替" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/57.wav", + "text": "\n然後很快速的我再跟部長講一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/58.wav", + "text": "這個問題我質詢過11次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/59.wav", + "text": "就是我們原住民在都會區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/60.wav", + "text": "沒有憲法保障的秘密投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/61.wav", + "text": "投票所也就是原住民開票所的五分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/62.wav", + "text": "投票即亮票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/63.wav", + "text": "降低我們的投票意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/64.wav", + "text": "所以我也說過要修第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/65.wav", + "text": "能不能夠請中選會在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/66.wav", + "text": "同意我們不在籍移轉投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/67.wav", + "text": "還有幽靈人口更可怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/68.wav", + "text": "因為我們原住民自從有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/69.wav", + "text": "刑法第104十六條的增修慘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/70.wav", + "text": "一選舉完很多人就去抓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/71.wav", + "text": "看誰是投票前回來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/72.wav", + "text": "即便是他的子女他的表妹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/73.wav", + "text": "統統都觸犯刑法第104十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/74.wav", + "text": "所以我也希望能夠修正選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/75.wav", + "text": "第五十七條第三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/76.wav", + "text": "應在戶籍地投票的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/77.wav", + "text": "\n以上我只是要表達感慨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/78.wav", + "text": "我們原住民的這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/79.wav", + "text": "每一個議題我都不知道已經質詢過多少次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/80.wav", + "text": "也有提案版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/81.wav", + "text": "但從來沒有獲得大家的共鳴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/82.wav", + "text": "內心很難過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/83.wav", + "text": "希望我們的選政單位選務單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/84.wav", + "text": "還有各位立委同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/85.wav", + "text": "我們大家一起努力好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/86.wav", + "text": "還有很多的事情是值得我們努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157974/87.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/1.wav", + "text": "立法院已經來到第11屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/2.wav", + "text": "這一屆真的實在令人嘆為觀止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/3.wav", + "text": "我從代表議員一直到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/4.wav", + "text": "代表其實也有制定法律的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/5.wav", + "text": "不過那個叫做地方自治事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/6.wav", + "text": "啦只要經過民意機關通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/7.wav", + "text": "的統統叫做法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/8.wav", + "text": "啦那我只是要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/9.wav", + "text": "有時候在法律訂定的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/10.wav", + "text": "不一定極盡的公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/11.wav", + "text": "也必須要透過多次修正之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/12.wav", + "text": "才有辦法達到符合現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/13.wav", + "text": "但是要達到公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/14.wav", + "text": "或許啦或許就某種程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/15.wav", + "text": "必須要廣泛的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/16.wav", + "text": "甚至也要做出相關的這些研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/17.wav", + "text": "但最少最少也要有所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/18.wav", + "text": "符合比例的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/19.wav", + "text": "這是我們一直在為人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/20.wav", + "text": "爭取福利過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/21.wav", + "text": "要求行政機關要有所作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/22.wav", + "text": "如果今天我們民意機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/23.wav", + "text": "訂定出來的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/24.wav", + "text": "基本上連一個比例原則的門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/25.wav", + "text": "都沒有辦法達標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/26.wav", + "text": "這樣的法律坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/27.wav", + "text": "覺得是不能被信任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/28.wav", + "text": "當一個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/29.wav", + "text": "訂定出來的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/30.wav", + "text": "不被人民所信任的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/31.wav", + "text": "這個國家顯然會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/32.wav", + "text": "啦我必須要很誠懇地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/33.wav", + "text": "在這邊做這樣的呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/34.wav", + "text": "我看我們中選委員主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/35.wav", + "text": "聲音也已經快沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/36.wav", + "text": "輪一下請劉部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/37.wav", + "text": "不然劉部長在那邊也滿孤單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/38.wav", + "text": "現在剩下3分鐘而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/39.wav", + "text": "我有十萬火急的重要議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/40.wav", + "text": "要請教劉部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/41.wav", + "text": "條例在上個會期已經通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/42.wav", + "text": "持續被在野黨這樣杯葛退回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/43.wav", + "text": "雖然最終開始審了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/44.wav", + "text": "不過目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/45.wav", + "text": "內政委員會相關的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/46.wav", + "text": "還沒有審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/47.wav", + "text": "所以也沒有到大會去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/48.wav", + "text": "又要延會到1月21號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/49.wav", + "text": "有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/50.wav", + "text": "會到1月21號才決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/51.wav", + "text": "如果1月21號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/52.wav", + "text": "順利完成三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/53.wav", + "text": "有機會領到第一次在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/54.wav", + "text": "期間加發的1.5個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/55.wav", + "text": "事務補助費嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/56.wav", + "text": "是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/57.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/58.wav", + "text": "我們確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/59.wav", + "text": "因為這個是我們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/60.wav", + "text": "在上個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/61.wav", + "text": "林右昌部長任內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/62.wav", + "text": "就已經答應的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/63.wav", + "text": "一共5." + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/64.wav", + "text": "1月21號通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/65.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/66.wav", + "text": "我們會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/67.wav", + "text": "希望在10天前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/68.wav", + "text": "啦我們希望在春節前10天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/69.wav", + "text": "撥進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/70.wav", + "text": "春節前10天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/71.wav", + "text": "春節前10天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/72.wav", + "text": "但如果三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/73.wav", + "text": "是在1月21號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/74.wav", + "text": "我跟你說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/75.wav", + "text": "就是我們會去處理這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/76.wav", + "text": "我們已經完成了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/77.wav", + "text": "所以沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/78.wav", + "text": "我們已經先編好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/79.wav", + "text": "我知道你們編好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/80.wav", + "text": "但編好也是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/81.wav", + "text": "經過審查通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/82.wav", + "text": "是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/83.wav", + "text": "是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/84.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/85.wav", + "text": "是嘛三讀有可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/86.wav", + "text": "在1月21號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/87.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/88.wav", + "text": "但是我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/89.wav", + "text": "大院的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/90.wav", + "text": "不會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/91.wav", + "text": "大院委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/92.wav", + "text": "沒有哪一黨會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/93.wav", + "text": "你們可以這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/94.wav", + "text": "也是不簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/95.wav", + "text": "也很好處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/96.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/97.wav", + "text": "今天這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/98.wav", + "text": "因為沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/99.wav", + "text": "啦三個黨都沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/100.wav", + "text": "是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/101.wav", + "text": "的就可以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/102.wav", + "text": "但是我會替他們擔心啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/103.wav", + "text": "你如果說這個已經有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/104.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/105.wav", + "text": "如果沒過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/106.wav", + "text": "我再來拜託劉委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/107.wav", + "text": "不過我相信會過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/108.wav", + "text": "你只有拜託我一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/109.wav", + "text": "雖然我們同宗同姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/110.wav", + "text": "但是也不必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/111.wav", + "text": "然你拜託我我就有能力處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/112.wav", + "text": "啊這是要大家有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/113.wav", + "text": "的沒有我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/114.wav", + "text": "黨團或什麼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/115.wav", + "text": "都有請教過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/116.wav", + "text": "沒有人會反對這一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/117.wav", + "text": "我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/118.wav", + "text": "當然沒人敢反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/119.wav", + "text": "這案不是沒人會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/120.wav", + "text": "但是因為我擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/121.wav", + "text": "拖延的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/122.wav", + "text": "而過年是1月2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/123.wav", + "text": "你的作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/124.wav", + "text": "有辦法在過年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/125.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/126.wav", + "text": "先去借來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/127.wav", + "text": "你去借是一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/128.wav", + "text": "你有錢是一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/129.wav", + "text": "但你要執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/130.wav", + "text": "但是它是一個法定支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/131.wav", + "text": "法定支出有點像是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/132.wav", + "text": "譬如我們公務人員的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/133.wav", + "text": "1月的薪水還是要照發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/134.wav", + "text": "也是一樣的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/135.wav", + "text": "這1.5個月的補助費是新增項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/136.wav", + "text": "是但是它是法定支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/137.wav", + "text": "是法定支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/138.wav", + "text": "我知道沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/139.wav", + "text": "我們有跟主計單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/140.wav", + "text": "了他們覺得這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/141.wav", + "text": "你來得及就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/142.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/143.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/144.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157973/145.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/0.wav", + "text": "我的朋友在線上問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/1.wav", + "text": "你們到底在談什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/2.wav", + "text": "大家已經有點看不懂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/3.wav", + "text": "我說了國民黨的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/4.wav", + "text": "我的朋友就聽懂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/5.wav", + "text": "然後我的朋友問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/6.wav", + "text": "這樣到底會對民主政治造成什麼傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/7.wav", + "text": "我就做了一些結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/8.wav", + "text": "主委可不可以從您過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/9.wav", + "text": "從事政治工作的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/10.wav", + "text": "參與臺灣民主自由的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/11.wav", + "text": "來告訴我我的總結對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/12.wav", + "text": "我認為如果按照藍白的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/13.wav", + "text": "會有一個很大部分的疑慮就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/14.wav", + "text": "當要我們的國民交出身分證的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/15.wav", + "text": "其實可能會降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/16.wav", + "text": "人民對於政治的信任度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/17.wav", + "text": "這個部分你認同嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/18.wav", + "text": "也就是說如果我的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/19.wav", + "text": "是可以被國家這樣掌控的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/20.wav", + "text": "如果國家用這樣的權力來強迫人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/21.wav", + "text": "其實會讓人民對於民主政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/22.wav", + "text": "是越來越沒有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/23.wav", + "text": "國民是會有戒心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/24.wav", + "text": "這個戒心也許是來自於對政府的不信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/25.wav", + "text": "也許是來自於對詐騙集團的憂慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/26.wav", + "text": "都有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/27.wav", + "text": "對我相信尤其是內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/28.wav", + "text": "這麼積極地在做很多詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/29.wav", + "text": "一個非常重要的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/30.wav", + "text": "不管是對長輩或是對青少年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/31.wav", + "text": "我們都告訴大家不要隨便交出證件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/32.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得光是這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/33.wav", + "text": "我們就應該要更努力地讓全國人民知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/34.wav", + "text": "如果真的照藍白的法案通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/35.wav", + "text": "光是身分證這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/36.wav", + "text": "我覺得一般人民會有同感的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/37.wav", + "text": "\n接下來像這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/38.wav", + "text": "鞏固自己權力的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/39.wav", + "text": "我必須要這麼定義它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/40.wav", + "text": "鞏固自己權力的法案如果通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/41.wav", + "text": "了參與政治的不平等的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/42.wav", + "text": "偏袒既得權力者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/43.wav", + "text": "我這樣的結論你覺得你可以接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/44.wav", + "text": "也就是說如果罷免的門檻變得這麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/45.wav", + "text": "不適任的民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/46.wav", + "text": "這麼難以被罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/47.wav", + "text": "其實人民就會對政治越來越冷感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/48.wav", + "text": "越來越沒有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/49.wav", + "text": "認為都是你們這些在搞政治的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/50.wav", + "text": "自己玩就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/51.wav", + "text": "於是民意代表被監督的強度跟機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/52.wav", + "text": "也就降低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/53.wav", + "text": "這個直接的限制了人民的罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/54.wav", + "text": "是不是有些公職人員會因此而避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/55.wav", + "text": "這個反射的利益會存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/56.wav", + "text": "對沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/57.wav", + "text": "我認為這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/58.wav", + "text": "應該要讓更多人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/59.wav", + "text": "\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/60.wav", + "text": "我認為回到我們自己身為民意代表身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/61.wav", + "text": "我們會不會就因此降低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/62.wav", + "text": "對政治工作負責任的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/63.wav", + "text": "尤其是現在我們看到很多立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/64.wav", + "text": "一天到晚在上通告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/65.wav", + "text": "我們久久才能夠看到他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/66.wav", + "text": "跟我同樣在教育及文化委員會的葉元之委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/67.wav", + "text": "他連第一次要質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/68.wav", + "text": "都搞不清楚狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/69.wav", + "text": "他錯過了第一次的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/70.wav", + "text": "我認為這樣是一個非常不及格的民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/71.wav", + "text": "一旦藍白的法案通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/72.wav", + "text": "把這個罷免的門檻變得這麼難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/73.wav", + "text": "是不是我們就更難以去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/74.wav", + "text": "像這樣子不認真的民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/75.wav", + "text": "不負責的民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/76.wav", + "text": "公職人員如何去行使他的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/77.wav", + "text": "如何去經營他的選民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/78.wav", + "text": "每個人可能都有不同的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/79.wav", + "text": "所以這一點我們就無從評論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/80.wav", + "text": "好沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/81.wav", + "text": "我告訴我朋友最後一個非常重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/82.wav", + "text": "我認為它會削弱自由民主的正當性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/83.wav", + "text": "怎麼說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/84.wav", + "text": "因為民主的正當性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/85.wav", + "text": "來自於程序的公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/86.wav", + "text": "及公民的廣泛參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/87.wav", + "text": "如果這個制度設計是在偏袒當權者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/88.wav", + "text": "偏袒這些既得利益者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/89.wav", + "text": "我認為長此以往將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/90.wav", + "text": "導致大家對於政治越來越冷感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/91.wav", + "text": "公民參與社會討論議題的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/92.wav", + "text": "跟範圍也會越縮越小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/93.wav", + "text": "所以我認為我們今天之所以花這麼長的時間討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/94.wav", + "text": "就是希望避免剛剛的那個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/95.wav", + "text": "當然後續我們還有很多事情要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/96.wav", + "text": "跟積極的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/97.wav", + "text": "到時候再請主委跟我們一起努力好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/98.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/99.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主委謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157972/100.wav", + "text": "我非常準時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席麻煩請中選會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/1.wav", + "text": "主委好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/2.wav", + "text": "我首先在這裡要跟主委討論一個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/3.wav", + "text": "每一個人的每一張票都非常的重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/4.wav", + "text": "即便是總統選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/5.wav", + "text": "那麼多人投票的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/6.wav", + "text": "也一樣每一票都是非常重要的這樣的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/7.wav", + "text": "我想主委是認同的吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/8.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/9.wav", + "text": "曾經發生了一件還滿刺激的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/10.wav", + "text": "選務人員竟然給了山地原住民的選票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/11.wav", + "text": "勝負之差只有差一票而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/12.wav", + "text": "所以每一票都很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/13.wav", + "text": "尤其是在我們原住民的選舉當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/14.wav", + "text": "這個影響更是很明顯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/15.wav", + "text": "依照規定選舉公報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/16.wav", + "text": "應該是在二日前就要送到選舉人的手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/17.wav", + "text": "今年的選舉是1月13" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/18.wav", + "text": "號舉行我1月10號收到彰化的選民跟我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/19.wav", + "text": "但是並沒有收到原住民立委候選人的選舉公報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/20.wav", + "text": "就有跟中選會反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/21.wav", + "text": "但是你們唯一的回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/22.wav", + "text": "是要我們自己去問彰化選委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/23.wav", + "text": "但是面對這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/24.wav", + "text": "你們都沒有一定的SOP處理模式嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/25.wav", + "text": "對於委員接受民眾的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/26.wav", + "text": "我們都應該會直接跟縣選委會做聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/27.wav", + "text": "希望他們能夠查明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/28.wav", + "text": "因為這件事情就發生在選前三天嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/29.wav", + "text": "可是你知道他們怎麼回的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/30.wav", + "text": "他們也是很誇張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/31.wav", + "text": "原住民立委的選舉公報有沒有發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/32.wav", + "text": "他們都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/33.wav", + "text": "然後他們要我們的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/34.wav", + "text": "自己去統計有多少戶沒有收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/35.wav", + "text": "還要我們寫好姓名地址傳真給他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/36.wav", + "text": "他們再重新寄發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/37.wav", + "text": "我想要請教主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/38.wav", + "text": "選務工作是這樣做的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/39.wav", + "text": "我們不是選務人員對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/40.wav", + "text": "於這個個案我可能回去要再進行了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/41.wav", + "text": "如果像委員所說的是這樣的處理過程的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/42.wav", + "text": "我們一定要嚴加糾正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/43.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/44.wav", + "text": "因為原住民每次在相關選舉投票之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/45.wav", + "text": "類似這樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/46.wav", + "text": "層出不窮啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/47.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/48.wav", + "text": "因為過去曾經發生過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/49.wav", + "text": "所以我們也都是一再叮嚀一再交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/50.wav", + "text": "當時我的選民是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/51.wav", + "text": "不只他們那個里沒有收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/52.wav", + "text": "連隔壁里也沒有收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/53.wav", + "text": "要民眾自己去統計有多少人沒有收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/54.wav", + "text": "然後還要傳真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/55.wav", + "text": "回傳姓名地址給他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/56.wav", + "text": "這個真的是一個非常扯的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/57.wav", + "text": "我們會進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/58.wav", + "text": "把這個調查結果跟委員做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/59.wav", + "text": "等於是說這件事情從選舉結束到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/60.wav", + "text": "現在已經12月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/61.wav", + "text": "你們完全都沒有去了解這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/62.wav", + "text": "是出在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/63.wav", + "text": "然後未來要怎麼改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/64.wav", + "text": "這樣聽起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/65.wav", + "text": "我看主委還是沒有掌握到這樣的一個情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/66.wav", + "text": "初步他們跟我講是沒有接獲通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/67.wav", + "text": "所以我我一定要再進行了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/68.wav", + "text": "所以你們吃案了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/69.wav", + "text": "嘛彰化那邊吃案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/70.wav", + "text": "我來了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/71.wav", + "text": "跟我們回報這個結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/72.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157971/73.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/0.wav", + "text": "麻煩請中選會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/1.wav", + "text": "用我來舉例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/2.wav", + "text": "他說如果要罷免我的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/3.wav", + "text": "可以擺攤的話就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/4.wav", + "text": "如果改成要身分證可以騙個資對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/5.wav", + "text": "是吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/6.wav", + "text": "他剛剛這樣講嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/7.wav", + "text": "我想問一下現在如果要連署的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/8.wav", + "text": "需不需要提供個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/9.wav", + "text": "在不修法的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/10.wav", + "text": "格式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/11.wav", + "text": "以及這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/12.wav", + "text": "要提供什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/13.wav", + "text": "身分證字號要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/14.wav", + "text": "身分證字號要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/15.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/16.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/17.wav", + "text": "姓名要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/18.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/19.wav", + "text": "這是不是個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/20.wav", + "text": "是吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/21.wav", + "text": "所以在現行版本的規定之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/22.wav", + "text": "詐騙集團如果要蒐集個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/23.wav", + "text": "也是可以嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/24.wav", + "text": "這是第一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/25.wav", + "text": "第二件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/26.wav", + "text": "王義川剛剛講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/27.wav", + "text": "如果我們要讓這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/28.wav", + "text": "提議或連署失效的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/29.wav", + "text": "就自己去擺另外一個攤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/30.wav", + "text": "然後讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/31.wav", + "text": "來連署的人重複連署這樣就可以失效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/32.wav", + "text": "請問一下這個狀況在現在的規定之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/33.wav", + "text": "會不會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/34.wav", + "text": "可不可以發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/35.wav", + "text": "我不保證它不會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/36.wav", + "text": "會發生嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/37.wav", + "text": "所以實際上詐騙集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/38.wav", + "text": "如果要詐騙的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/39.wav", + "text": "跟要不要提供身分證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/40.wav", + "text": "沒什麼關係嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/41.wav", + "text": "我是不知道為什麼王義川" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/42.wav", + "text": "這麼了解詐騙集團的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/43.wav", + "text": "可能平常有交流還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/44.wav", + "text": "其實他講的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/45.wav", + "text": "在現在就會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/46.wav", + "text": "我們現在是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/47.wav", + "text": "要把連署的階段取消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/48.wav", + "text": "因為怕詐騙集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/49.wav", + "text": "蒐集個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/50.wav", + "text": "時有獨立參選人要進行連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/51.wav", + "text": "乾脆把連署取消好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/52.wav", + "text": "因為都有可能被騙個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/53.wav", + "text": "嘛所以這應該不會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/54.wav", + "text": "考慮的主要論點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/55.wav", + "text": "啦論點應該是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/56.wav", + "text": "把身分證加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/57.wav", + "text": "會不會減少死人連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/58.wav", + "text": "濫用連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/59.wav", + "text": "抄名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/60.wav", + "text": "嘛這個才是關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/61.wav", + "text": "就職未滿一年者不得罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/62.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/63.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/64.wav", + "text": "就職未滿一年不得罷免的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/65.wav", + "text": "定義是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/66.wav", + "text": "是不能向中選會提交罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/67.wav", + "text": "還是不能啟動罷免的活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/68.wav", + "text": "不得向中選會提出罷免提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/69.wav", + "text": "所以換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/70.wav", + "text": "在我們現行選罷法的規定裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/71.wav", + "text": "就立刻找自己的競選團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/72.wav", + "text": "開始罷免對手可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/73.wav", + "text": "選罷法沒有規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/74.wav", + "text": "沒有規定所以就很荒謬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/75.wav", + "text": "嘛這個就是最荒謬的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/76.wav", + "text": "罷免當初的設計是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/77.wav", + "text": "你做得不好所以要把你罷免掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/78.wav", + "text": "投你的人覺得你有違我們的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/79.wav", + "text": "我們現在的選罷法是規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/80.wav", + "text": "你的得票比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/81.wav", + "text": "下次要選贏你也不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/82.wav", + "text": "所以乾脆我第二天就開始啟動罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/83.wav", + "text": "把你罷免掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/84.wav", + "text": "利用罷免門檻比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/85.wav", + "text": "的規定希望能夠爭取第二次罷免的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/86.wav", + "text": "這個就是我們現在選罷法最荒謬的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/87.wav", + "text": "人家可能一天都還沒開始做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/88.wav", + "text": "就準備要被罷免了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/89.wav", + "text": "主委你認同這種惡罷嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/90.wav", + "text": "這個社會自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/91.wav", + "text": "你認不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/92.wav", + "text": "社會有公斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/93.wav", + "text": "那你個人認不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/94.wav", + "text": "我站在中選會我不是個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/95.wav", + "text": "你不是個人喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/96.wav", + "text": "所以你不是公民是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/97.wav", + "text": "現在為什麼大家會在這邊討論選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/98.wav", + "text": "就是我們現在的社會充滿惡罷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/99.wav", + "text": "現在就是對手在罷免你啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/100.wav", + "text": "因為選贏你不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/101.wav", + "text": "願賭不服輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/102.wav", + "text": "嘛所以不需要把罷免講得好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/103.wav", + "text": "什麼沒收民權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/104.wav", + "text": "這個不是沒收民權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/105.wav", + "text": "這個是沒收別人政治鬥爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/106.wav", + "text": "願賭不服輸的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/107.wav", + "text": "讓他們一罷再罷一罷再罷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/108.wav", + "text": "搞得每年都要選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/109.wav", + "text": "可以這樣子喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/110.wav", + "text": "\n再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/111.wav", + "text": "我唸一段話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/112.wav", + "text": "他說單一席次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/113.wav", + "text": "選舉區往往造成高票當選低票罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/114.wav", + "text": "少數民意否決多數民意的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/115.wav", + "text": "這是民主機制上之謬誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/116.wav", + "text": "應該罷免同意票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/117.wav", + "text": "要多於當初的得票一票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/118.wav", + "text": "請問你認同這樣的說法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/119.wav", + "text": "你認同嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/120.wav", + "text": "這個就是今天我們討論的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/121.wav", + "text": "你認不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/122.wav", + "text": "我個人不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/123.wav", + "text": "那你就打臉郭國文了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/124.wav", + "text": "因為這個是郭國文的主張啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/125.wav", + "text": "當時郭國文提出這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/126.wav", + "text": "還有好幾位民進黨的立委連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/127.wav", + "text": "所以昨是今非啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/128.wav", + "text": "類似的版本民進黨提很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/129.wav", + "text": "不是只有郭國文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/130.wav", + "text": "賴瑞隆也提一模一樣的案子啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/131.wav", + "text": "罷免實施之後出現惡罷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/132.wav", + "text": "亂象叢生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/133.wav", + "text": "違反票票等值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/134.wav", + "text": "為了要改善惡質罷免的文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/135.wav", + "text": "所以同意罷免票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/136.wav", + "text": "要多於當初得票一票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/137.wav", + "text": "賴瑞隆講的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/138.wav", + "text": "所以我真的不知道民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/139.wav", + "text": "每一個人在這邊講得一副" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/140.wav", + "text": "好像捍衛民主價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/141.wav", + "text": "講那麼一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/142.wav", + "text": "實際上只是想要鬥爭嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157970/143.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/0.wav", + "text": "的在選舉理論裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/1.wav", + "text": "漏斗理論就是選舉活動剛開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/2.wav", + "text": "大家考慮的因素很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/3.wav", + "text": "或者相關性別的議題等各種因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/4.wav", + "text": "到選舉越來越接近的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/5.wav", + "text": "這些因素會逐漸去除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/6.wav", + "text": "這個選擇就是所謂的冷靜期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/7.wav", + "text": "\n好各位同學先休息一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/8.wav", + "text": "剛才提到漏斗理論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/9.wav", + "text": "最重要的就是到最後會做一個純粹的選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/10.wav", + "text": "現在要將前10日調整為前3日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/11.wav", + "text": "但民調對選舉的衝擊是非常大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/12.wav", + "text": "不管是以前的臺北市長選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/13.wav", + "text": "或者是宋楚瑜參選總統的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/14.wav", + "text": "或是這一次總統大選的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/15.wav", + "text": "都可以看到假民調的充斥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/16.wav", + "text": "修正我認為是萬萬不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/17.wav", + "text": "這會讓假民調更為充斥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/18.wav", + "text": "或者是要去做澄清的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/19.wav", + "text": "根本沒有辦法去做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/20.wav", + "text": "這對選舉公平性的影響非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/21.wav", + "text": "請主委簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/22.wav", + "text": "的包裝可能會做得非常非常精細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/23.wav", + "text": "就是讓你不會覺得有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/24.wav", + "text": "就會相信了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/25.wav", + "text": "所以要讓我們的選民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/26.wav", + "text": "能夠有足夠的時間去做分辨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/27.wav", + "text": "當然最直接的是這個候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/28.wav", + "text": "他要去澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/29.wav", + "text": "而這個澄清也需要相當的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/30.wav", + "text": "才能夠把它說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/31.wav", + "text": "好這是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/32.wav", + "text": "今天在這邊質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/33.wav", + "text": "滿像在南機場夜市質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/34.wav", + "text": "非常的熱鬧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/35.wav", + "text": "我們提到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/36.wav", + "text": "這次的修法要求罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/37.wav", + "text": "的同意票數必須要高於當選票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/38.wav", + "text": "數這個是非常奇特的一個政治設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/39.wav", + "text": "我們限縮了人民罷免的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/40.wav", + "text": "這是反公民的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/41.wav", + "text": "耶這是非常離譜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/42.wav", + "text": "然後我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/43.wav", + "text": "所謂的選舉罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/44.wav", + "text": "他們說票太少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/45.wav", + "text": "是民意的代表性不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/46.wav", + "text": "我要跟各位說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/47.wav", + "text": "不是民意代表性不足的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/48.wav", + "text": "而是投票率的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/49.wav", + "text": "啦如果我們修正讓罷免能夠成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/50.wav", + "text": "的要件是同意票必須要高於當選票數的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/51.wav", + "text": "這無疑是限制人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/52.wav", + "text": "這在我們的憲政體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/53.wav", + "text": "跟政治制度的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/54.wav", + "text": "是相違反的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/55.wav", + "text": "這個問題是非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/56.wav", + "text": "其實在多數的民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/57.wav", + "text": "他們都是鼓勵民眾能夠實質的參與政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/58.wav", + "text": "但我們卻是開民主的倒車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/59.wav", + "text": "這是非常莫名其妙的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/60.wav", + "text": "如果修法通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/61.wav", + "text": "人民幾乎是沒有罷免的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/62.wav", + "text": "了請主委最後簡單的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/63.wav", + "text": "其實相關的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/64.wav", + "text": "我已經在今天說明了很多次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/65.wav", + "text": "每次講的也都差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/66.wav", + "text": "容許我用另外一種方式來表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/67.wav", + "text": "也就是剛剛提到的當初選舉時的得票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/68.wav", + "text": "這個罷免就不成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/69.wav", + "text": "這有一點類似怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/70.wav", + "text": "為用明朝的劍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/71.wav", + "text": "來殺清朝的官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/72.wav", + "text": "啦這個罷免投票的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/73.wav", + "text": "就是清朝了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/74.wav", + "text": "你用投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/75.wav", + "text": "主委你要不要用書面回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/76.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/77.wav", + "text": "好謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/78.wav", + "text": "不過我還是要跟各位同仁簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/79.wav", + "text": "身為立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/80.wav", + "text": "保障人民的權利是我們最基本的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/81.wav", + "text": "不是去限縮人民的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157969/82.wav", + "text": "這是我一再要提醒各位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/0.wav", + "text": "主委辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/1.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/2.wav", + "text": "針對翁曉玲委員等人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/3.wav", + "text": "選罷法第53條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/4.wav", + "text": "要將禁止發布民調時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/5.wav", + "text": "從選前10天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/6.wav", + "text": "縮短為前3天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/7.wav", + "text": "關於這點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/8.wav", + "text": "本席覺得大家可以好好地想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/9.wav", + "text": "為什麼過去許多區域立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/10.wav", + "text": "民意代表常常指控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/11.wav", + "text": "受到假民調的攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/12.wav", + "text": "假訊息的干擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/13.wav", + "text": "導致影響最後選舉的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/14.wav", + "text": "當初設計10天前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/15.wav", + "text": "禁止發布民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/16.wav", + "text": "用意也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/17.wav", + "text": "如此如果真的有假民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/18.wav", + "text": "假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/19.wav", + "text": "要給候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/20.wav", + "text": "一個澄清的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/21.wav", + "text": "\n關於翁委員提案縮短為3天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/22.wav", + "text": "本席不曉得用意為何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/23.wav", + "text": "難道是磨刀霍霍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/24.wav", + "text": "要幹什麼大事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/25.wav", + "text": "這個制度設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/26.wav", + "text": "就是要保護臺灣的民主制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/27.wav", + "text": "避免惡意操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/28.wav", + "text": "這樣胡亂修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/29.wav", + "text": "本席擔心會有無法想像的後果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/30.wav", + "text": "所以想問主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/31.wav", + "text": "從10天前調整成3天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/32.wav", + "text": "前不能發布民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/33.wav", + "text": "你認為會有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/34.wav", + "text": "我們看不到把10天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/35.wav", + "text": "縮短為3天的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/36.wav", + "text": "過去設定為10天也是有共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/37.wav", + "text": "嘛而且運作已經有一段時間了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/38.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/39.wav", + "text": "修法的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/40.wav", + "text": "要將選罷法第9條修正為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/41.wav", + "text": "同意票數超過被罷免人的得票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/42.wav", + "text": "本席更是深感不解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/43.wav", + "text": "攤開我國選舉的歷程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/44.wav", + "text": "罷免的投票率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/45.wav", + "text": "普遍低於一般投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/46.wav", + "text": "這樣變相加嚴罷免的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/47.wav", + "text": "也導致被民眾戲稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/48.wav", + "text": "為鳥籠罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/49.wav", + "text": "目前現行的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/50.wav", + "text": "本席必須坦白說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/51.wav", + "text": "無論哪個政黨的民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/52.wav", + "text": "都有面臨過選民的挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/53.wav", + "text": "有罷免成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/54.wav", + "text": "的也有罷免失敗的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/55.wav", + "text": "這也代表目前的制度不分顏色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/56.wav", + "text": "不分黨派促使民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/57.wav", + "text": "縣市首長要戰戰兢兢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/58.wav", + "text": "好好地把自己的工作做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/59.wav", + "text": "所以主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/60.wav", + "text": "對於國民黨的罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/61.wav", + "text": "提案罷免票數需要高於當選票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/62.wav", + "text": "您的見解是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/63.wav", + "text": "我們已經做過很多次說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/64.wav", + "text": "最重要的就是它的立論基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/65.wav", + "text": "是不存在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/66.wav", + "text": "因為兩個數字所產生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/67.wav", + "text": "候選人的人數都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/68.wav", + "text": "這些都是一些變項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/69.wav", + "text": "既然基礎不一樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/70.wav", + "text": "你就沒有辦法拿它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/71.wav", + "text": "所產出的數字來做比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/72.wav", + "text": "你覺得這是不是一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/73.wav", + "text": "很簡單地說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/74.wav", + "text": "選舉投票時的民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/75.wav", + "text": "因為罷免投票時的民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/76.wav", + "text": "才是最新的民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/77.wav", + "text": "經過至少一年半以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/78.wav", + "text": "會發生變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/79.wav", + "text": "所以它已經不具參考價值了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/80.wav", + "text": "所以這是不是一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/81.wav", + "text": "鳥籠罷免假罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/82.wav", + "text": "是不是假罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/83.wav", + "text": "是真的要罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/84.wav", + "text": "是真的要罷免啊可是門檻調的這麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/85.wav", + "text": "根本就做不到不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/86.wav", + "text": "所以本席覺得現行的罷免機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/87.wav", + "text": "的也有失敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/88.wav", + "text": "的有投票通過罷免的也有否決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/89.wav", + "text": "的不管藍綠職位高低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/90.wav", + "text": "民意代表真的必須戰戰兢兢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/91.wav", + "text": "接受民意的監督和檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/92.wav", + "text": "這也是選舉罷免的精神所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/93.wav", + "text": "所以如今藍白要沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/94.wav", + "text": "不知道是害怕還是霸道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157968/95.wav", + "text": "霸道以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/1.wav", + "text": "有請主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/2.wav", + "text": "還是要再次抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/3.wav", + "text": "只有4分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/4.wav", + "text": "很難針對這麼重要的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/5.wav", + "text": "方面的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/6.wav", + "text": "的立場非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/7.wav", + "text": "我們反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/8.wav", + "text": "用任何方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/9.wav", + "text": "哪怕是連署加難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/10.wav", + "text": "或者投票門檻提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/11.wav", + "text": "來閹割憲法賦予人民的珍貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/12.wav", + "text": "罷免權這些我們都反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/13.wav", + "text": "今天本席還要針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/14.wav", + "text": "選罷法第53條的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/15.wav", + "text": "非常重要的新議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/16.wav", + "text": "世界119個國家進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/17.wav", + "text": "有79個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/18.wav", + "text": "都有所謂的選前冷靜期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/19.wav", + "text": "選前冷靜期除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/20.wav", + "text": "禁止在特定時間進行競選活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/21.wav", + "text": "或者禁止媒體的相關報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/22.wav", + "text": "還包括禁止公布民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/23.wav", + "text": "翁曉玲委員提的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/24.wav", + "text": "是針對選罷法第52條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/25.wav", + "text": "要把民調的冷靜期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/26.wav", + "text": "也就是禁止公布民調的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/27.wav", + "text": "從10天縮短為3天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/28.wav", + "text": "本席個人認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/29.wav", + "text": "民調是一個選舉時有效的策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/30.wav", + "text": "它更被援用成為一種武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/31.wav", + "text": "因為成本非常低廉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/32.wav", + "text": "所以利用假民調影響選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/33.wav", + "text": "案例\n現在有幾件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/34.wav", + "text": "大家都還記憶深刻的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/35.wav", + "text": "總統選舉時在三組候選人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/36.wav", + "text": "選舉辯論會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/37.wav", + "text": "柯文哲民眾黨的總統候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/38.wav", + "text": "就在公開辯論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/39.wav", + "text": "質疑國民黨的侯友宜候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/40.wav", + "text": "為什麼接受中共的假民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/41.wav", + "text": "來影響選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/42.wav", + "text": "這是柯文哲對侯友宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/43.wav", + "text": "中這件事情不是空穴來風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/44.wav", + "text": "因為今年8月30日正式被判刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/45.wav", + "text": "和蘇姓退休教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/46.wav", + "text": "確實收受中共福建省委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/47.wav", + "text": "150萬元的報酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/48.wav", + "text": "灌水製造假民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/49.wav", + "text": "替侯康配衝高支持率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/50.wav", + "text": "臺中地院今年8月底判決確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/51.wav", + "text": "劉世芳部長也在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/52.wav", + "text": "為什麼內政部要循政黨法的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/53.wav", + "text": "提請憲法法庭解散統促黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/54.wav", + "text": "因為有非常清楚的證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/55.wav", + "text": "顯示統促黨收受4,700萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/56.wav", + "text": "元介入臺灣的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/57.wav", + "text": "中共的介選不只對臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/58.wav", + "text": "對世界各國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/59.wav", + "text": "所以本席認為中國用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/60.wav", + "text": "假民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/61.wav", + "text": "灌水民調介選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/62.wav", + "text": "或者進行各種認知作戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/63.wav", + "text": "以錯假訊息介選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/64.wav", + "text": "我們認為現行的辦法10天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/65.wav", + "text": "既然是當初朝野的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/66.wav", + "text": "一般的選民也都認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/67.wav", + "text": "適應了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/68.wav", + "text": "所以這個10天我們認為不宜再更改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/69.wav", + "text": "所以本席要利用短短的4分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/70.wav", + "text": "今天審查的還包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/71.wav", + "text": "這個非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/72.wav", + "text": "可能會幫助中國透過灌水假民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/73.wav", + "text": "影響臺灣選舉的可怕修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/74.wav", + "text": "讓民調的冷靜期縮短為3天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/75.wav", + "text": "中共公然介選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/76.wav", + "text": "就可以用更廉價的成本影響臺灣的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/77.wav", + "text": "這個是新的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/78.wav", + "text": "新生事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/79.wav", + "text": "切莫快速進入審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/80.wav", + "text": "今天一併列入議案討論的新生議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/81.wav", + "text": "我們還需要和非常多選舉專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/82.wav", + "text": "政治專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/83.wav", + "text": "民調專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/84.wav", + "text": "媒體專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/85.wav", + "text": "乃至於公民團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/86.wav", + "text": "嚴肅的討論這項修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/87.wav", + "text": "這是本席對主席的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/88.wav", + "text": "我們需要先召開公聽會之後再審查相關議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157967/89.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/0.wav", + "text": "委員好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/1.wav", + "text": "本席先說一個小小的故事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/2.wav", + "text": "席要協尋一位2013年的大預言家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/3.wav", + "text": "他那時候說了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/4.wav", + "text": "他說有一批立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/5.wav", + "text": "或許預知他接下來會做很可怕的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/6.wav", + "text": "所以他在立法院提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/7.wav", + "text": "進一步讓罷免程序變的複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/8.wav", + "text": "中間還說了很多很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/9.wav", + "text": "話最後他說我理念上支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/10.wav", + "text": "啦但是要我把影本交出來門都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/11.wav", + "text": "他說這會讓你行使直接民權的路變的很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/12.wav", + "text": "他要大家記住他們的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/13.wav", + "text": "育昇江啟臣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/14.wav", + "text": "這六個人覺得之前的限制還不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/15.wav", + "text": "還要讓罷免權行使變得更困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/16.wav", + "text": "2013年的大預言家是什麼人呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/17.wav", + "text": "不黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/18.wav", + "text": "黃國昌先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/19.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/20.wav", + "text": "人民有選舉罷免創制複決之權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/21.wav", + "text": "罷免權其實是憲法賦予人民的參政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/22.wav", + "text": "不可以在沒有經過充分的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/23.wav", + "text": "就要強行用修法剝奪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/24.wav", + "text": "而被罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/25.wav", + "text": "也因為這樣就想要修改遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/26.wav", + "text": "這在很多人聽起來真的是荒謬至極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/27.wav", + "text": "是非常荒謬的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/28.wav", + "text": "有這麼難嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/29.wav", + "text": "不要利用臺灣的民主反民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/30.wav", + "text": "這是本席的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/31.wav", + "text": "也是很多人的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/32.wav", + "text": "只保護自己的權位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/33.wav", + "text": "從上一個會期想要擴權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/34.wav", + "text": "一直到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/35.wav", + "text": "本來應該優先處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/36.wav", + "text": "果國眾兩黨偏偏臨時變更議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/37.wav", + "text": "把應該通過的學輔法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/38.wav", + "text": "中間這一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/39.wav", + "text": "有14歲學生跳樓自殺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/40.wav", + "text": "本來學輔法應該要擺在最前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/41.wav", + "text": "處理的本席認為應該要把民生法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/42.wav", + "text": "重要法案擺在這種政治性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/43.wav", + "text": "所以要提高罷免門檻的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/44.wav", + "text": "關於議程的安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/45.wav", + "text": "我們不便置喙啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/46.wav", + "text": "但是排上這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/47.wav", + "text": "我們選務機關認為有待商榷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/48.wav", + "text": "所以我們必須很負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/49.wav", + "text": "公職人員應該遵守的一個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/50.wav", + "text": "當立委面臨可能被罷免的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/51.wav", + "text": "而修法提升罷免的難度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/52.wav", + "text": "這���部分請教一下主委的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/53.wav", + "text": "這個也牽涉到所謂的利益迴避問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/54.wav", + "text": "我們覺得這個修法是不好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/55.wav", + "text": "不應該現在通過即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/56.wav", + "text": "即便現任的立委不適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/57.wav", + "text": "但是卻把這個不應該通過的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/58.wav", + "text": "留到下一屆適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/59.wav", + "text": "因為它還是不應該適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/60.wav", + "text": "人民的罷免權被剝奪之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/61.wav", + "text": "本席相信很多人是不認同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/62.wav", + "text": "好好思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/63.wav", + "text": "也謝謝主委今天辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/64.wav", + "text": "我們繼續協尋2013年那位大預言家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/65.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157966/66.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/0.wav", + "text": "請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/1.wav", + "text": "主委好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/2.wav", + "text": "因為我們發言時間只有4分鐘240秒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/3.wav", + "text": "所以一個案子大概只能問40秒左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/4.wav", + "text": "顯然不是很合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/5.wav", + "text": "啦所以只能集中問幾個本席比較關心的點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/6.wav", + "text": "現在我們除了單純" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/7.wav", + "text": "或者還有一定的行政裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/8.wav", + "text": "除此之外還有什麼預防措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/9.wav", + "text": "這種現象大概分成兩種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/10.wav", + "text": "有一種狀況這是我們也不能否認的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/11.wav", + "text": "就是政黨和政黨之間的合縱連橫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/12.wav", + "text": "也許會發生在不同政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/13.wav", + "text": "之間但是允許有相當程度的連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/14.wav", + "text": "當然也有惡意的連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/15.wav", + "text": "藉此做為他投票的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/16.wav", + "text": "也會有這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/17.wav", + "text": "對為什麼本席問這個問題很大的原因是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/18.wav", + "text": "如果已經出現這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/19.wav", + "text": "況後來才去裁罰或者阻止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/20.wav", + "text": "但是傷害已經造成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/21.wav", + "text": "所以有什麼預防措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/22.wav", + "text": "因為我們不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/23.wav", + "text": "規定他在刊登相關廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/24.wav", + "text": "或者做任何宣傳的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/25.wav", + "text": "要經過中選委的審核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/26.wav", + "text": "這是不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/27.wav", + "text": "也就是說針對這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/28.wav", + "text": "我們即使在法律上做了這樣的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/29.wav", + "text": "可能還是很難預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/30.wav", + "text": "如果認定上有困難的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/31.wav", + "text": "我們是想要達到一個目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/32.wav", + "text": "可是手段可能不一定足夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/33.wav", + "text": "但是反過來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/34.wav", + "text": "有時候手段可能會過多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/35.wav", + "text": "本席覺得他可能搞錯一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/36.wav", + "text": "因為身分證影本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/37.wav", + "text": "席剛剛聽主委回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/38.wav", + "text": "其實在本來的機制裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/39.wav", + "text": "我們就可以得知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/40.wav", + "text": "這是有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/41.wav", + "text": "然後予以剔除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/42.wav", + "text": "有可能沒有辦法達到這個目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/43.wav", + "text": "我們今天要討論的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/44.wav", + "text": "必須大於當時的得票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/45.wav", + "text": "其實這中間並沒有關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/46.wav", + "text": "就是讓人民能夠行使他的政治權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/47.wav", + "text": "第一個它的門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/48.wav", + "text": "絕對不能過高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/49.wav", + "text": "嘛但是另外一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/50.wav", + "text": "也不能夠有權利的濫用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/51.wav", + "text": "今天即使規定同意票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/52.wav", + "text": "要大於當時當選的票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/53.wav", + "text": "但是根本就沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/54.wav", + "text": "阻止權利濫用這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/55.wav", + "text": "所以最後只剩一個副作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/56.wav", + "text": "就是實質提高罷免的門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/57.wav", + "text": "本席覺得這當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/58.wav", + "text": "不能接受的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/59.wav", + "text": "\n本席最後還有一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/60.wav", + "text": "但時間不太夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/61.wav", + "text": "問題一個問題只能問40秒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/62.wav", + "text": "這真的不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/63.wav", + "text": "啦本席不知道議程到底是怎麼安排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/64.wav", + "text": "但本席還是要問一下關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/65.wav", + "text": "才能民調這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/66.wav", + "text": "本席覺得這反而是值得討論的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/67.wav", + "text": "目前本席看到的溫委員提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/68.wav", + "text": "看來時間是有縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/69.wav", + "text": "到底幾天前不能發布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/70.wav", + "text": "才是比較妥當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/71.wav", + "text": "也很歧異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/72.wav", + "text": "臺灣的規定是10天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/73.wav", + "text": "朝野協商��的最大共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/74.wav", + "text": "本席覺得主委這個答案很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/75.wav", + "text": "因為它有時候並不是一個科學問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/76.wav", + "text": "而是一個政治問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/77.wav", + "text": "政治問題在立法院藉由朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/78.wav", + "text": "得到一定結論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/79.wav", + "text": "如果今天要用暴力的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/80.wav", + "text": "把它直接縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/81.wav", + "text": "或者延長其實都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/82.wav", + "text": "和我們今天要達到的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/83.wav", + "text": "本席最後還是要再說一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157965/84.wav", + "text": "一個問題40秒真的太少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/0.wav", + "text": "請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/1.wav", + "text": "席提出來的修正案有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/2.wav", + "text": "政黨任何人印發文字圖畫從事競選之宣傳品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/3.wav", + "text": "應親自簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/4.wav", + "text": "非政黨推薦候選人未經政黨授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/5.wav", + "text": "不得在宣傳品上使用政黨負責人頭像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/6.wav", + "text": "政黨負責人姓名和政黨負責人標章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/7.wav", + "text": "總統大選的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/8.wav", + "text": "有許多地區的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/9.wav", + "text": "候選人不管是立委或者總統選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/10.wav", + "text": "會有特定人士刻意混淆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/11.wav", + "text": "什麼意思呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/12.wav", + "text": "為了減少某一個政黨的政治人物票源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/13.wav", + "text": "就讓其他的第三或第四政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/14.wav", + "text": "或者是沒有政黨無所屬的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/15.wav", + "text": "或者分散票源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/16.wav", + "text": "這些人有一個特徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/17.wav", + "text": "所以這是很嚴肅的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/18.wav", + "text": "\n本席剛剛提供給你的資料請你仔細看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/19.wav", + "text": "候選人不管是嘉義或高雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/20.wav", + "text": "他們用當時的副總統頭像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/21.wav", + "text": "做他們的宣傳品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/22.wav", + "text": "但是沒有經過民主進步黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/23.wav", + "text": "或者當時的執政黨授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/24.wav", + "text": "或者分散這些人的票源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/25.wav", + "text": "這是非常嚴肅的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/26.wav", + "text": "本席發覺許多國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/27.wav", + "text": "他們會利用這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/28.wav", + "text": "合照的照片去宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/29.wav", + "text": "所以這和您之前的書面回應不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/30.wav", + "text": "席剛剛看到這個書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/31.wav", + "text": "按政黨是否推薦某一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/32.wav", + "text": "人或是否授權該政黨推薦之候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/33.wav", + "text": "使用政黨之頭像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/34.wav", + "text": "政黨負責人姓名和政黨標章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/35.wav", + "text": "是涉及其結盟考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/36.wav", + "text": "不是的這是特意在違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/37.wav", + "text": "所以本席希望中選會要正視它而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/38.wav", + "text": "他們就是要利用我們的漏洞反民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/39.wav", + "text": "我們現在的民主制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/40.wav", + "text": "維護當然要以相應的方式修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/41.wav", + "text": "不然到時候你就會發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/42.wav", + "text": "有各種魚目混珠的現象出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/43.wav", + "text": "\n比方如果我們面對的是中國國民黨的對手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/44.wav", + "text": "我們就請四五個或六七個或七八個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/45.wav", + "text": "人和當時的中國國民黨黨魁合照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/46.wav", + "text": "做宣傳品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/47.wav", + "text": "請問這樣中國國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/48.wav", + "text": "就是在野黨的人士會答應嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/49.wav", + "text": "今天我們談論選罷法的修正案本席提出這些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/50.wav", + "text": "有辦理公聽會的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/51.wav", + "text": "而不是強硬通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/52.wav", + "text": "\n當然今天的選罷法大家都專注在罷免相關的法律上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/53.wav", + "text": "可是我們的國家不是只有罷免相關的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/54.wav", + "text": "這一次的選戰有各種侵擾我們民主進程的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/55.wav", + "text": "都需要時間才有辦法把它討論完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/56.wav", + "text": "所以本席也要向在野黨的國會同事們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/57.wav", + "text": "再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/58.wav", + "text": "看看我們這麼多修正法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/59.wav", + "text": "我們這幾次選舉遇到的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/60.wav", + "text": "其實是很可怕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/61.wav", + "text": "兩個本土政黨在決鬥而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/62.wav", + "text": "還有來自中國的各種影響力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/63.wav", + "text": "\n所以本席希望召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/64.wav", + "text": "可以召開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/65.wav", + "text": "我們針對這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/66.wav", + "text": "好好討論因為它除了影響我們之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157964/67.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/0.wav", + "text": "質詢時間只有240秒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/1.wav", + "text": "啊請中選會李主委內政部劉部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/2.wav", + "text": "請李主委劉部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/3.wav", + "text": "部長好像坐的比較久一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/4.wav", + "text": "\n不管主委或者部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/5.wav", + "text": "你們都擔任過立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/6.wav", + "text": "地方的行政首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/7.wav", + "text": "你要思考國家的利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/8.wav", + "text": "全民的利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/9.wav", + "text": "制定的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/10.wav", + "text": "要福國利民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/11.wav", + "text": "而不是禍國殃民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/12.wav", + "text": "制定的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/13.wav", + "text": "要得到大家的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/14.wav", + "text": "全民的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/15.wav", + "text": "才能可長可久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/16.wav", + "text": "制定的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/17.wav", + "text": "要符合民主的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/18.wav", + "text": "不能制定出反民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/19.wav", + "text": "屠殺民主的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/20.wav", + "text": "的立場李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/21.wav", + "text": "你看了這個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/22.wav", + "text": "案會不會覺得憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/23.wav", + "text": "啊罷免權是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/24.wav", + "text": "民主國家的基本規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/25.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/26.wav", + "text": "這個案子一旦修法完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/27.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/28.wav", + "text": "罷免權是名存實亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/29.wav", + "text": "永遠不可能有任何罷免案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/30.wav", + "text": "成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/31.wav", + "text": "中選會做為一個選務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/32.wav", + "text": "的執行機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/33.wav", + "text": "一般人民的選舉權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/34.wav", + "text": "尤其是憲法保證的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/35.wav", + "text": "參政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/36.wav", + "text": "我們要予以維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/37.wav", + "text": "你們有辦法維護嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/38.wav", + "text": "所以我們一定要把話說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/39.wav", + "text": "這樣的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/40.wav", + "text": "這樣的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/41.wav", + "text": "反民主也違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/42.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/43.wav", + "text": "晚上都睡不著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/44.wav", + "text": "請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/45.wav", + "text": "劉部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/46.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/47.wav", + "text": "因為人民的參政權本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/48.wav", + "text": "選舉罷免創制複決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/49.wav", + "text": "其實就是變相剝奪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/50.wav", + "text": "人民的罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/51.wav", + "text": "我們自詡為民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/52.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/53.wav", + "text": "甚至是民主國家的模範生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/54.wav", + "text": "臺灣的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/55.wav", + "text": "竟然要制定一個反民主的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/56.wav", + "text": "我們以後在國際社會還敢說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/57.wav", + "text": "自己是民主國家的模範生嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/58.wav", + "text": "臺灣的立法院竟然制定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/59.wav", + "text": "這麼反民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/60.wav", + "text": "抗爭反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/61.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/62.wav", + "text": "好的解方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/63.wav", + "text": "讓本席憂心忡忡的指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/64.wav", + "text": "能夠下降一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/65.wav", + "text": "是不是可以維持現在的選舉罷免制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/66.wav", + "text": "因為我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/67.wav", + "text": "在立法院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/68.wav", + "text": "政黨的競爭非常激烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/69.wav", + "text": "不要隨便修改選舉罷免的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/70.wav", + "text": "條款或是門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/71.wav", + "text": "國家利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/72.wav", + "text": "政黨利益凌駕於國家利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/73.wav", + "text": "從動機行為理論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/74.wav", + "text": "背後一定有一個動機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/75.wav", + "text": "那就是一個懦夫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/76.wav", + "text": "只有懦夫會提出這種法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/77.wav", + "text": "不敢接受民意的洗禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/78.wav", + "text": "主委同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157963/79.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席有請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/1.wav", + "text": "主委好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/2.wav", + "text": "這個案子今天討論了一整天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/3.wav", + "text": "雖然休息的時間非常長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/4.wav", + "text": "但是發言時間只有4分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/5.wav", + "text": "所以本席要說快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/6.wav", + "text": "本席要回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/7.wav", + "text": "現在國民黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/8.wav", + "text": "其實就是司馬昭之心路人皆知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/9.wav", + "text": "他們怕進入所謂的大罷免時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/10.wav", + "text": "本席也是媒體出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/11.wav", + "text": "主委你應該知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/12.wav", + "text": "是投票前一天晚上10點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/13.wav", + "text": "就禁止在媒體上宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/14.wav", + "text": "也就是跨過隔天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/15.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/16.wav", + "text": "這是依照哪一條法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/17.wav", + "text": "是一年前就不可以說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/18.wav", + "text": "說而我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/19.wav", + "text": "如果有人違反選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/20.wav", + "text": "在投票前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/21.wav", + "text": "10點以後還幫特定候選人宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/22.wav", + "text": "是由誰負責開罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/23.wav", + "text": "是中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/24.wav", + "text": "吧還是NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/25.wav", + "text": "是中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/26.wav", + "text": "中選會嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/27.wav", + "text": "活動期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/28.wav", + "text": "因為那是非活動期間嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/29.wav", + "text": "過去也有一些案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/30.wav", + "text": "就是投票當天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/31.wav", + "text": "還有人在社群媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/32.wav", + "text": "幫特定候選人宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/33.wav", + "text": "是不是也由中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/34.wav", + "text": "負責開罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/35.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/36.wav", + "text": "好那本席就要請問了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/37.wav", + "text": "在社群媒體當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/38.wav", + "text": "只要提到罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/39.wav", + "text": "或者只要在電視台提到罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/40.wav", + "text": "就一律要開罰是這個意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/41.wav", + "text": "在未滿一年的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/42.wav", + "text": "是不是變成不能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/43.wav", + "text": "臺灣是不是變成一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/44.wav", + "text": "言論自由受到箝制的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/45.wav", + "text": "這幾天國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/46.wav", + "text": "一直在諷刺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/47.wav", + "text": "民進黨說要戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/48.wav", + "text": "本席不知道現在國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/49.wav", + "text": "是不是要透過選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/50.wav", + "text": "實施另外一種戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/51.wav", + "text": "就是讓罷免這兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/52.wav", + "text": "連說都不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/53.wav", + "text": "所以這是另外一個層次的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/54.wav", + "text": "在一年以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/55.wav", + "text": "對於任何人做罷免的倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/56.wav", + "text": "對倡議這兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/57.wav", + "text": "就是我現在講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/58.wav", + "text": "本席的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/59.wav", + "text": "今天如果有人在臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/60.wav", + "text": "貼文或者像現在一樣後面有4台攝影機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/61.wav", + "text": "剛剛甚至超過10台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/62.wav", + "text": "只要哪一台說到罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/63.wav", + "text": "是不是通通會被NCC罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/64.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/65.wav", + "text": "這樣臺灣是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/66.wav", + "text": "回到戒嚴時的白色恐怖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/67.wav", + "text": "現在是不是透過修正選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/68.wav", + "text": "讓罷免這兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/69.wav", + "text": "連說都不能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/70.wav", + "text": "你認為是不是這樣主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/71.wav", + "text": "如果不是的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/72.wav", + "text": "請問現在要怎麼罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/73.wav", + "text": "怎麼抓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/74.wav", + "text": "提議或倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/75.wav", + "text": "這要怎麼界定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/76.wav", + "text": "無從規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/77.wav", + "text": "中選會也無從查處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/78.wav", + "text": "而且這牽涉到個人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/79.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為這樣的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/80.wav", + "text": "並不適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/81.wav", + "text": "所以本席要特別凸顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/82.wav", + "text": "身為一個立法委員立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/83.wav", + "text": "必須是可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/84.wav", + "text": "的如果不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/85.wav", + "text": "或者變成對臺灣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/86.wav", + "text": "言論自由戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/87.wav", + "text": "甚至是罷免的戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/88.wav", + "text": "或者沒收罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/89.wav", + "text": "那麼臺灣就是走回頭路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/90.wav", + "text": "本席也要奉勸國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/91.wav", + "text": "不要在那邊一直諷刺民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/92.wav", + "text": "卻默默的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/93.wav", + "text": "偷偷摸摸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/94.wav", + "text": "偷雞摸狗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/95.wav", + "text": "要利用修選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/96.wav", + "text": "實施戒嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157962/97.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/1.wav", + "text": "有請李進勇主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/2.wav", + "text": "請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/3.wav", + "text": "您的任期到現在幾年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/4.wav", + "text": "2019年6月就到職了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/5.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/6.wav", + "text": "在你的印象當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/7.wav", + "text": "類似今天這樣的選罷法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/8.wav", + "text": "類似這樣的草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/9.wav", + "text": "對就是有關門檻的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/10.wav", + "text": "在上一屆的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/11.wav", + "text": "我印象中沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/12.wav", + "text": "你曉不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/13.wav", + "text": "本席有提案將門檻調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/14.wav", + "text": "完全沒有討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/15.wav", + "text": "本席提出這個版本的��候被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/16.wav", + "text": "國民黨拿來做宣傳說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/17.wav", + "text": "郭國文有提案賴瑞隆也有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/18.wav", + "text": "案但是如果他們關心選罷法的門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/19.wav", + "text": "你不覺得非常奇怪嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/20.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/21.wav", + "text": "和現階段國民黨的版本不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/22.wav", + "text": "是從下一屆開始適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/23.wav", + "text": "沒有執行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/24.wav", + "text": "你是說法律上的適合性與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/25.wav", + "text": "是任期的延長對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/26.wav", + "text": "防止罷免阻礙罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/27.wav", + "text": "相對而言也是防止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/28.wav", + "text": "任期縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/29.wav", + "text": "所以綜歸來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/30.wav", + "text": "或者避免任期縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/31.wav", + "text": "也好都是在保護任期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/32.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/33.wav", + "text": "是的是嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/34.wav", + "text": "所以釋字第499號和國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/35.wav", + "text": "有異曲同工之妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/36.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/37.wav", + "text": "你都說是啊為什麼不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/38.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/39.wav", + "text": "既然是同本質都是一種任期保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/40.wav", + "text": "當然有異曲同工之妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/41.wav", + "text": "這就牽扯到自肥的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/42.wav", + "text": "它不是從下一屆開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/43.wav", + "text": "這樣不是很清楚就是違憲嗎主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/44.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/45.wav", + "text": "都是一種任期的保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/46.wav", + "text": "這不是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/47.wav", + "text": "再加上什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/48.wav", + "text": "這一次更糟糕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/49.wav", + "text": "是把門檻加高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/50.wav", + "text": "第一個不能宣傳是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/51.wav", + "text": "身分證有可能會引發詐騙集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/52.wav", + "text": "個資的嫌疑嘛是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/53.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/54.wav", + "text": "這樣的結果就會讓整個罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/55.wav", + "text": "完全被閹割嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/56.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能得到這樣的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/57.wav", + "text": "會受到更多的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/58.wav", + "text": "對有很多的限制嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/59.wav", + "text": "不論是程序上的限制或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/60.wav", + "text": "這個罷免權還有辦法行使嗎主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/61.wav", + "text": "本席就教於您啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/62.wav", + "text": "是比較困難啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/63.wav", + "text": "這和你們的預算有關聯本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/64.wav", + "text": "席請問一下以前你們編列預算時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/65.wav", + "text": "罷免的經費用在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/66.wav", + "text": "如果罷免立委的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/67.wav", + "text": "當然是你們編列預算啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/68.wav", + "text": "一般而言你們是用第二預備金嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/69.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/70.wav", + "text": "林昶佐的部分大概花了1,500萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/71.wav", + "text": "陳柏惟的部分花了2,000萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/72.wav", + "text": "席可以告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/73.wav", + "text": "以後這筆錢你們不用編列那麼多了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/74.wav", + "text": "如果國民黨版本通過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/75.wav", + "text": "這筆錢根本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/76.wav", + "text": "大家看到門檻那麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/77.wav", + "text": "就不想進行罷免啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/78.wav", + "text": "你們這筆錢就不用花了嘛不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/79.wav", + "text": "我們大概不會編列罷免的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/80.wav", + "text": "是不會你們是動用第二預備金啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/81.wav", + "text": "所以你們的第二預備金就不用編列那麼多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/82.wav", + "text": "這等於是國民黨自打嘴巴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/83.wav", + "text": "把孫文當年留下來的罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/84.wav", + "text": "不用編列那麼多了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/85.wav", + "text": "如果國民黨這個法案真的通過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/86.wav", + "text": "其實國民黨最需要做的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/87.wav", + "text": "不是修改法案啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/88.wav", + "text": "是修改自己的言行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/89.wav", + "text": "因為自己的言行倒行逆施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/90.wav", + "text": "本席覺得主席今天真的操之過急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/91.wav", + "text": "給我們的發言時間這麼短而且還等這麼久謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/92.wav", + "text": "謝謝郭國文委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157961/93.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請林楚茵委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我請中選會李進勇主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/1.wav", + "text": "主委請你看一下這個簡報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/2.wav", + "text": "發生了一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/3.wav", + "text": "中正萬華區的臺北市議員鍾小平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/4.wav", + "text": "請投下不同意票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/5.wav", + "text": "這樣有沒有違反選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/6.wav", + "text": "投票日當天在投票所門口宣傳拉票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/7.wav", + "text": "依照選罷法第56條第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/8.wav", + "text": "報告委員這個案子已經有民眾檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/9.wav", + "text": "按照我們的處理程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/10.wav", + "text": "就事實的部分進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/11.wav", + "text": "與基隆選委會一起關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/12.wav", + "text": "這件事情任何人一律平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/13.wav", + "text": "無論你有沒有政黨有沒有公職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/14.wav", + "text": "只要有違法就一定要裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/15.wav", + "text": "公開點名我並說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/16.wav", + "text": "國民黨要指定動員令罷免吳沛憶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/17.wav", + "text": "並從今年7月開始在我的選區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/18.wav", + "text": "宣傳要罷免吳沛憶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/19.wav", + "text": "憶今天我看到國民黨委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/20.wav", + "text": "提出選罷法的修法版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/21.wav", + "text": "其中許宇甄委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/22.wav", + "text": "除了許宇甄委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/23.wav", + "text": "提案人也有主席徐欣瑩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/24.wav", + "text": "不只是我不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/25.wav", + "text": "國民黨臺北市黨部的主委黃呂錦茹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/26.wav", + "text": "也不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/27.wav", + "text": "從我就職到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/28.wav", + "text": "了因此國民黨是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/29.wav", + "text": "對於國民黨立委現在這個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/30.wav", + "text": "國民黨臺北市黨部的主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/31.wav", + "text": "現在就已經在宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/32.wav", + "text": "要連署罷免吳沛憶罷免吳思瑤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/33.wav", + "text": "所以這個可能要回去討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/34.wav", + "text": "\n但我還是要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/35.wav", + "text": "國民黨臺北市黨部主委下了動員令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/36.wav", + "text": "全區國民黨籍的里長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/37.wav", + "text": "要開始動員準備明年要罷免吳沛憶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/38.wav", + "text": "即使如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/39.wav", + "text": "我也不贊成國民黨這個修法版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/40.wav", + "text": "因為我們還是要捍衛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/41.wav", + "text": "人民的罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/42.wav", + "text": "這是憲法賦予人民的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/43.wav", + "text": "因為我們擔任了立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/44.wav", + "text": "很重要的一點修法時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/45.wav", + "text": "要利益迴避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/46.wav", + "text": "嘛我們修法是為了福國利民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/47.wav", + "text": "因為今天吳沛憶要被罷免了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/48.wav", + "text": "說一年之內不能宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/49.wav", + "text": "不可以這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/50.wav", + "text": "人家要罷免我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/51.wav", + "text": "這是民眾的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/52.wav", + "text": "我們能做的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/53.wav", + "text": "我們要更加努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/54.wav", + "text": "國民黨的黃呂錦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/55.wav", + "text": "茹對中正萬華" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/56.wav", + "text": "華付出什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/57.wav", + "text": "我的付出努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/58.wav", + "text": "是他們的1,000倍1萬倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/59.wav", + "text": "所以我對自己非常有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/60.wav", + "text": "我們要更加努力為民服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/61.wav", + "text": "爭取民眾的認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/62.wav", + "text": "不是在立法院搞修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/63.wav", + "text": "修惡法亂修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/64.wav", + "text": "法沒收民眾的人民罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/65.wav", + "text": "\n還有蘇清泉委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/66.wav", + "text": "自私自利的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/67.wav", + "text": "因為蘇清泉委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/68.wav", + "text": "了當時想要驗票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/69.wav", + "text": "但是按照現行的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/70.wav", + "text": "於是現在就提出修法認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/71.wav", + "text": "這些通通都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/72.wav", + "text": "自私利己的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/73.wav", + "text": "立委不可以這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/74.wav", + "text": "所有不分黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/75.wav", + "text": "的各位立法院同仁們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/76.wav", + "text": "即便我們要面臨民眾的罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/77.wav", + "text": "這是民眾的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/78.wav", + "text": "我們要尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/79.wav", + "text": "憲法保障的參政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/80.wav", + "text": "而我們自己則是要更加努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/81.wav", + "text": "爭取民眾的認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157960/82.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席有請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/1.wav", + "text": "請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/2.wav", + "text": "主委辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/3.wav", + "text": "我們不應該用任何方式沒收人民的意志" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/4.wav", + "text": "這一點主委認同嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/5.wav", + "text": "認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/6.wav", + "text": "不過現在國民黨與民眾黨提出幾個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/7.wav", + "text": "要超過被罷免人的當選票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/8.wav", + "text": "一次是總統及立委的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/9.wav", + "text": "另外一次就是地方縣市長及議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/10.wav", + "text": "投票率一定會比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/11.wav", + "text": "投票率一定會比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/12.wav", + "text": "計算票數的基礎不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/13.wav", + "text": "包括投票率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/14.wav", + "text": "包括當選人的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/15.wav", + "text": "但是以歷屆的選舉模式來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/16.wav", + "text": "一���是總統及立委選舉時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/17.wav", + "text": "投票率比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/18.wav", + "text": "選舉的投票率會比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/19.wav", + "text": "罷免時的投票率就會比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/20.wav", + "text": "要附身分證影本的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/21.wav", + "text": "我個人認為萬萬不可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/22.wav", + "text": "而且關於冒名連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/23.wav", + "text": "的問題剛剛好幾位民進黨立委都講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/24.wav", + "text": "過沒有人敢擔這個風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/25.wav", + "text": "而言我們是可以再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/26.wav", + "text": "精進可以把冒名或死亡連署等等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/27.wav", + "text": "是不是會把罷免連署期拉長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/28.wav", + "text": "是不是又會造成許多工作上的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/29.wav", + "text": "罷免的時程拉長與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/30.wav", + "text": "與身分證影本可能並沒有很直接的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/31.wav", + "text": "不過我認為中選會還是得花很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/32.wav", + "text": "處理這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/33.wav", + "text": "增加了你們的工作量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/34.wav", + "text": "再者大法官釋字第499號解釋也有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/35.wav", + "text": "利益迴避的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/36.wav", + "text": "主委針對這個部分是否能表明你的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/37.wav", + "text": "關於利益迴避原則的適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/38.wav", + "text": "我們尊重司法院大法官會議的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/39.wav", + "text": "如果是就我們這次選罷法修正案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/40.wav", + "text": "我們認為是不宜修正不宜更動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/41.wav", + "text": "也不應該把這個不宜留到下一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/42.wav", + "text": "所以只有一個標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/43.wav", + "text": "我認為是恣意提高罷免門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/44.wav", + "text": "逃避人民的監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/45.wav", + "text": "國民黨召委急著排審付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/46.wav", + "text": "主委本身是法律人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/47.wav", + "text": "現在是中選會的主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/48.wav", + "text": "你個人有什麼看法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/49.wav", + "text": "站在你身為法律人的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/50.wav", + "text": "於這樣一個惡意修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/51.wav", + "text": "你個人有什麼看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/52.wav", + "text": "我不敢說是惡意修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/53.wav", + "text": "但是我認為這次修法的發動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/54.wav", + "text": "並沒有很直接的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/55.wav", + "text": "而是因為有一股政治上的風潮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/56.wav", + "text": "也許是不是會引起相互之間的罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/57.wav", + "text": "正因為有這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/58.wav", + "text": "最後中選會一定會支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/59.wav", + "text": "人民有罷免的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/60.wav", + "text": "憲法保障的國民參政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157959/61.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/1.wav", + "text": "請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/2.wav", + "text": "請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/3.wav", + "text": "主委你好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/4.wav", + "text": "今天我要向你請教的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/5.wav", + "text": "就是為了守護民眾的罷免權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/6.wav", + "text": "憲法第十七條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/7.wav", + "text": "人民有選舉罷免創制複決之權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/8.wav", + "text": "我知道你與我的大學同學郭醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/9.wav", + "text": "那是在40年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/10.wav", + "text": "的科目有三民主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/11.wav", + "text": "五權憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/12.wav", + "text": "這些都是我們曾經背過也非常熟悉的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/13.wav", + "text": "現在要做改變當然意見會有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/14.wav", + "text": "到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/15.wav", + "text": "一共只有7件罷免案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/16.wav", + "text": "包括立法委員有3件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/17.wav", + "text": "直轄市長有1件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/18.wav", + "text": "縣市長有1件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/19.wav", + "text": "直轄市議員有2件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/20.wav", + "text": "那麼多年來只有7件代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/21.wav", + "text": "即使門檻降低了罷免仍然是非常困難的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/22.wav", + "text": "的罷免權利造成很大的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/23.wav", + "text": "這個部分大家應該都會很容易理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/24.wav", + "text": "我們也知道根據選罷法第十三條的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/25.wav", + "text": "目前在這個過程中往往中央與地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/26.wav", + "text": "連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/27.wav", + "text": "都會有不同的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/28.wav", + "text": "不知道主委有什麼樣的看法該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/29.wav", + "text": "該如何精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/30.wav", + "text": "以避免這樣的問題產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/31.wav", + "text": "謝謝王委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/32.wav", + "text": "的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/33.wav", + "text": "在最近某一個罷免案的個案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/34.wav", + "text": "有發生類似的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/35.wav", + "text": "針對連署人名冊的查對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/36.wav", + "text": "大家的看法有一點出入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/37.wav", + "text": "其實有出入也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/38.wav", + "text": "縣市長的選舉罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/39.wav", + "text": "都是屬於中央選委會主管的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/40.wav", + "text": "但是它指揮監督地方選委會執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/41.wav", + "text": "因此���果有見解不一樣的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/42.wav", + "text": "大家可以透過溝通協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/43.wav", + "text": "或是上級行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/44.wav", + "text": "本於行政指導的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/45.wav", + "text": "可以達到一致的見解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/46.wav", + "text": "我們也為了讓所有的各地選委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/47.wav", + "text": "法律相關的規定也提示了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/48.wav", + "text": "所以這個東西是有存在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/49.wav", + "text": "我們再將它做一個綜合的整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/50.wav", + "text": "好謝謝謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/51.wav", + "text": "\n我也要麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/52.wav", + "text": "部長針對這個部分如果未來要改善的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/53.wav", + "text": "有什麼方案可以執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/54.wav", + "text": "的事情部長也表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/55.wav", + "text": "造成政黨間的惡性競爭造成不當的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/56.wav", + "text": "因此提出三點意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/57.wav", + "text": "作為參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/58.wav", + "text": "也針對這個罷免改善方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/59.wav", + "text": "提供了兩個可行性的探討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/60.wav", + "text": "包括依職務性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/61.wav", + "text": "做不同的設計及規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/62.wav", + "text": "部長是否有什麼方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/63.wav", + "text": "謝謝王委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/64.wav", + "text": "我相信最大的原因是來自於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/65.wav", + "text": "大家都知道選舉與罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/66.wav", + "text": "雖然是人民的參政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/67.wav", + "text": "但是在落實也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/68.wav", + "text": "在執行的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/69.wav", + "text": "難免也會加入政黨的競爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/70.wav", + "text": "我們最近一次的選罷法修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/71.wav", + "text": "在立法院的各個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/72.wav", + "text": "取得共識後的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/73.wav", + "text": "比較不會讓人覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/74.wav", + "text": "其實站在行政機關的立場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/75.wav", + "text": "我們都願意來參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/76.wav", + "text": "但是如果是為了某一個政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/77.wav", + "text": "為了某一些特別的其他因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/78.wav", + "text": "反而會造成外界的誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/79.wav", + "text": "是為了某一個特別的政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/80.wav", + "text": "是不是請部長書面回覆好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157958/81.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/0.wav", + "text": "主席麻煩請內政部劉部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/1.wav", + "text": "請劉部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/2.wav", + "text": "吳委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/3.wav", + "text": "後來我也自動撤案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/4.wav", + "text": "國民黨說我增加連署的難度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/5.wav", + "text": "說我增加罷免的難度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/6.wav", + "text": "因為我認為他們是汙衊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/7.wav", + "text": "所以我就撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/8.wav", + "text": "了為什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/9.wav", + "text": "因為我的提案是要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/10.wav", + "text": "加上身分證的發證日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/11.wav", + "text": "並不是身分證的影印本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/12.wav", + "text": "我們每個人的身分證上都有一個發證日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/13.wav", + "text": "過去無論是選罷的連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/14.wav", + "text": "或公投的連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/15.wav", + "text": "說難聽一點死人也在連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/16.wav", + "text": "沒辦法核對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/17.wav", + "text": "也沒辦法將這些作假的人移送法辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/18.wav", + "text": "因此如何讓連署是一個事實的連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/19.wav", + "text": "我認為這是一個重要的課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/20.wav", + "text": "就算我們要罷免我們要公投" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/21.wav", + "text": "也必須是真的有這麼多人要罷免要公投" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/22.wav", + "text": "嘛當時我要提案時就在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/23.wav", + "text": "最方便的方法就是像國民黨講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/24.wav", + "text": "證明是本人自己拿出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/25.wav", + "text": "但是我也考慮到拿出身分證影印本會增加許多的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/26.wav", + "text": "誠如剛剛前面許多委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/27.wav", + "text": "現在的詐欺犯罪這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/28.wav", + "text": "身分證上都會有一個發證日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/29.wav", + "text": "所以我提案加上一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/30.wav", + "text": "避免出現死亡連署的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/31.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣做很合理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/32.wav", + "text": "報告委員你說得非常合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/33.wav", + "text": "但是在檢核的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/34.wav", + "text": "第一個發證日期有可能會更改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/35.wav", + "text": "譬如我的身分證丟了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/36.wav", + "text": "或是身分證做什麼其他的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/37.wav", + "text": "當發證日期與原始日期不相同的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/38.wav", + "text": "你可能要回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/39.wav", + "text": "你可能沒在戶政機關辦過身分證的補發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/40.wav", + "text": "補發身分證的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/41.wav", + "text": "戶政機關在新身分證上寫的發證日期就是補發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/42.wav", + "text": "這個在查核上有什麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/43.wav", + "text": "請聽我講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/44.wav", + "text": "譬如連署需要3個月6個月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/45.wav", + "text": "在3個月6個月之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/46.wav", + "text": "假設日期不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/47.wav", + "text": "這樣你就要再回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/48.wav", + "text": "即使是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/49.wav", + "text": "的狀況數量也是非常的少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/50.wav", + "text": "但是你有沒有算過多少比例的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/51.wav", + "text": "在3個月內丟失身分證而去補發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/52.wav", + "text": "我完全了解你的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/53.wav", + "text": "但是變成要刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/54.wav", + "text": "你可以問他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/55.wav", + "text": "那就要問他本人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/56.wav", + "text": "可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/57.wav", + "text": "這樣會增加選務機關的麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/58.wav", + "text": "但是那樣的比例會非常少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/59.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/60.wav", + "text": "從未處理有關身分證發證日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/61.wav", + "text": "要不要變成檢核的一個要項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/62.wav", + "text": "對於你們的回答說我的提議是增加連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/63.wav", + "text": "連署的困難我非常的生氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/64.wav", + "text": "這個明明就是為了檢核的需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/65.wav", + "text": "並不是增加連署的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/66.wav", + "text": "你與國民黨一樣都說我是增加連署的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/67.wav", + "text": "還向記者發表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157957/68.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席請主席邀請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/1.wav", + "text": "請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/2.wav", + "text": "大家辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/3.wav", + "text": "人民有選舉罷免創制及複決之權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/4.wav", + "text": "罷免權是憲法明定的參政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/5.wav", + "text": "是基於直接民權所制定的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/6.wav", + "text": "有依憲法行使罷免權的權利對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/7.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/8.wav", + "text": "但是我們都知道過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/9.wav", + "text": "也因此被民眾稱為鳥籠罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/10.wav", + "text": "包括第一階段提案人數門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/11.wav", + "text": "第二階段的連署人數門檻從13%降為10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/12.wav", + "text": "最終階段有關於投票人數的門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/13.wav", + "text": "以及同意罷免票數超過有效票數的二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/14.wav", + "text": "修正為同意票數超過選舉人數的25%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/15.wav", + "text": "以及同意票超過不同意票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/16.wav", + "text": "這個罷免案就可以成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/17.wav", + "text": "確保罷免權確實是可以被行使的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/18.wav", + "text": "請教主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/19.wav", + "text": "人民會提起罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/20.wav", + "text": "是只要符合條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/21.wav", + "text": "就有權利行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/22.wav", + "text": "當然是用民主的選舉制度選出民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/23.wav", + "text": "從中央一直到地方的各級民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/24.wav", + "text": "他們是所謂的代議士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/25.wav", + "text": "士代替民眾代替百姓表達民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/26.wav", + "text": "當然他們也有權利監督民意代表的表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/27.wav", + "text": "針對民意代表的言行操守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/28.wav", + "text": "議事態度及表決立場等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/29.wav", + "text": "這些都是可以監督檢驗的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/30.wav", + "text": "沒有違背民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/31.wav", + "text": "言行操守不要太離譜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/32.wav", + "text": "你認為民眾會無緣無故提出罷免案嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/33.wav", + "text": "我想百姓也不會吃飽閒閒沒事做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/34.wav", + "text": "事做隨便就去搞一個罷免案吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/35.wav", + "text": "畢竟要經過第一階段及第二階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/36.wav", + "text": "也不是那麼的容易對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/37.wav", + "text": "實際上就是為這個選罷法設下更高的門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/38.wav", + "text": "的同意票數是高於不同意票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/39.wav", + "text": "但是這個同意票數是低於他的當選票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/40.wav", + "text": "因為他是十一萬多票當選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/41.wav", + "text": "當時朱立倫的態度是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/42.wav", + "text": "國民黨的主席喊說這是民主的勝利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/43.wav", + "text": "今天國民黨再來提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/44.wav", + "text": "罷免案成立一定要同意票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/45.wav", + "text": "這樣不是打他們主席的臉嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/46.wav", + "text": "能夠好好思考站在民意的這一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/47.wav", + "text": "不要老是想著自己的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/48.wav", + "text": "況且4年的選舉很快就會到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/49.wav", + "text": "的權利等到再次選舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157956/50.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/0.wav", + "text": "請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/1.wav", + "text": "罷免葉元之就在路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/2.wav", + "text": "證影本收一收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/3.wav", + "text": "連署1萬份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/4.wav", + "text": "交給你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/5.wav", + "text": "後面我就不連署了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/6.wav", + "text": "為1萬份我就賺到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/7.wav", + "text": "你們要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/8.wav", + "text": "分證中選會管不如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/9.wav", + "text": "不是無法那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/10.wav", + "text": "可以我們也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/11.wav", + "text": "擔心這種情形是不是會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/12.wav", + "text": "成為詐騙集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/13.wav", + "text": "作為蒐集個人資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/14.wav", + "text": "的一種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/15.wav", + "text": "這點是必須要考慮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/16.wav", + "text": "先擺一攤來罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/17.wav", + "text": "他自己第一階段成案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/18.wav", + "text": "之後就放著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/19.wav", + "text": "第二階段就不夠了對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/20.wav", + "text": "這樣他就不能被罷免了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/21.wav", + "text": "理論上是可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/22.wav", + "text": "所以收身分證這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/23.wav", + "text": "這也是我們擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/24.wav", + "text": "啦因為現在政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/25.wav", + "text": "對於詐騙集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/26.wav", + "text": "廣泛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/27.wav", + "text": "一般老百姓都深入腦海裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/28.wav", + "text": "所以大家對於個人資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/29.wav", + "text": "能會被詐騙集團收走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/30.wav", + "text": "走如果有誰想要罷免葉元之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/31.wav", + "text": "因為他的身分證會被收走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/32.wav", + "text": "能會被詐騙集團拿去使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/33.wav", + "text": "所以不能交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/34.wav", + "text": "我現在回答的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/35.wav", + "text": "就一般的法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/36.wav", + "text": "至於是不是特定的人選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/37.wav", + "text": "我是沒有辦法評論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/38.wav", + "text": "這樣我再問你一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/39.wav", + "text": "關於2026" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/40.wav", + "text": "年的縣市長選舉中國人可以參選縣長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/41.wav", + "text": "選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/42.wav", + "text": "的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/43.wav", + "text": "候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/44.wav", + "text": "資格的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/45.wav", + "text": "只要符合我們選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/46.wav", + "text": "民但是他沒有放棄中國國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/47.wav", + "text": "序沒有放棄中國國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/48.wav", + "text": "什麼沒有戶籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/49.wav", + "text": "而已也沒有放棄中國國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/50.wav", + "text": "這種狀況可以參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/51.wav", + "text": "我是針對選罷法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/52.wav", + "text": "涉到兩岸人民關係條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/53.wav", + "text": "的部分並不在我們的管轄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/54.wav", + "text": "範圍之內我剛才講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/55.wav", + "text": "及陸委會到時候要嚴格把關喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/56.wav", + "text": "上下游都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157955/57.wav", + "text": "一起配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/1.wav", + "text": "��主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/2.wav", + "text": "主委好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/3.wav", + "text": "委員等39人在5月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/4.wav", + "text": "而且在這個草案中並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/5.wav", + "text": "分相信許多委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/6.wav", + "text": "也都與你共同探討過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/7.wav", + "text": "是否會違反大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/8.wav", + "text": "在解釋中禁止立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/9.wav", + "text": "認為這樣的修法是有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/10.wav", + "text": "法之後把問題留到下一屆因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/11.wav", + "text": "我們認為所謂的利益迴避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/12.wav", + "text": "是另外一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/13.wav", + "text": "但是就修法的本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/14.wav", + "text": "在這一屆不適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/15.wav", + "text": "在下一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/16.wav", + "text": "再下一屆一樣不適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/17.wav", + "text": "我們將我們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/18.wav", + "text": "希望貴委員會能夠審慎的斟酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/19.wav", + "text": "主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/20.wav", + "text": "呢修法後就是從這一屆開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/21.wav", + "text": "報告委員我對這一點就沒有評論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/22.wav", + "text": "因為我著重的重點在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/23.wav", + "text": "他修法是不適當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/24.wav", + "text": "從1994年到2016年期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/25.wav", + "text": "其實就是因為1994年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/26.wav", + "text": "修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/27.wav", + "text": "後的條件太過嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/28.wav", + "text": "然而今天國民黨就是要讓這樣的歷史重演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/29.wav", + "text": "從1994年到2024年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/30.wav", + "text": "你看1994年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/31.wav", + "text": "對韓國瑜及洪秀柱等6位立法委員的5個罷免提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/32.wav", + "text": "並於9月完成第二階段連署並且成案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/33.wav", + "text": "到了1994年10月份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/34.wav", + "text": "就修法限制罷免不得綁選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/35.wav", + "text": "到了1994年11月27日5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/36.wav", + "text": "均因為投票人數未過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/37.wav", + "text": "而失敗如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/38.wav", + "text": "今2024年國民黨又玩一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/39.wav", + "text": "又重來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/40.wav", + "text": "你認為是不是沒收了人民的罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/41.wav", + "text": "對於人民的罷免權是一種限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/42.wav", + "text": "在既有的條件規定之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/43.wav", + "text": "另外加上了這個限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/44.wav", + "text": "主委如果這樣的選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/45.wav", + "text": "請問有沒有違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/46.wav", + "text": "我不方��評論是否有違憲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/47.wav", + "text": "至於修法到底適不適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/48.wav", + "text": "站在法律適用機關的立場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/49.wav", + "text": "我們必須有責任向委員會說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/50.wav", + "text": "啦好謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157954/51.wav", + "text": "也謝謝主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/0.wav", + "text": "國民黨委員所提的有效同意票數需要超過被罷免人當選得票數才算通過的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/1.wav", + "text": "我就藉由經民連副秘書長的說法他是這樣子說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/2.wav", + "text": "就是說這個提案中國國民黨就是正式向臺灣人民宣告從此以後臺灣人就沒有罷免的可能了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/3.wav", + "text": "我們把近年3起有關立法委員被罷免的數據調出來向大家報告說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/4.wav", + "text": "從數據上我們明顯的可以看到罷免時的投票率跟選舉時的投票率大相逕庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/5.wav", + "text": "兩者是不一樣的母數這個邏輯很好理解因為投票選舉是全國一起來的競選活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/6.wav", + "text": "多方的候選人一起來表達訴求然後多方的動員多方的資源都投入所以投票率自然會很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/7.wav", + "text": "但是罷免選舉這個罷免投票往往只有發起方在動員一方動員的結果當然是投票率相對的比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/8.wav", + "text": "所以經民連的副秘書長繼續說我們可以看到2016年新北市第2選區黃國昌當選的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/9.wav", + "text": "投票率63%但是罷免的時候投票率只有27%過去投票率大概都可以在六成以上甚至達到八成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/10.wav", + "text": "比如說2020或2024年的選舉臺中市第二選區臺北市第五選區這個都是2020年的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/11.wav", + "text": "兩個選區在選舉時都有將近八成的投票率但是後來提出罷免時的投票率最多最多就是五成最緊繃就是五成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/12.wav", + "text": "所以這是兩個完全不同計算基礎的母數你要同意票數必須大於原本被當選的票數這是完全不可能的天方夜譚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/13.wav", + "text": "如果你將兩者放在一起也就是公然宣布臺灣人民此後將沒有罷免的權利所以大家都在反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/14.wav", + "text": "卻把政治性的法案排在第一位強行通過了違憲的擴權法案現在又為了保護立法委員自己的權位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/15.wav", + "text": "避免被罷免於是就急著要修選罷法提高罷免的難度誠如我們剛剛講的讓罷免變成不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/16.wav", + "text": "的事但我們認為在野黨提出這個法案時應該要先回頭想一想為什麼自己需要這麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/17.wav", + "text": "還需要怕被罷免嗎你們這樣不顧民生只講擴權及政治鬥爭才會害怕被罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/18.wav", + "text": "也代表你們是站在民意的對立面才會害怕被罷免嘛因此增加罷免的難度剝奪民權這是你們使用的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/19.wav", + "text": "為了保護這些亂來的立委不被罷免再提高門檻保護自己的權位剝奪了人民的權利這是不應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/20.wav", + "text": "當時也曾經提議要修正公投法連署時要附身分證影本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/21.wav", + "text": "在張宏陸召委排審時國民黨的立委總召江啟臣帶領凌晨5點一樣破窗進入會議室霸占主席台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/22.wav", + "text": "將會議室門鎖灌注三秒膠等方式強力杯葛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/23.wav", + "text": "當時國民黨的主席江啟臣現在的立法院副院長批評民進黨所提的修法案是侵害隱私提高連署難度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/24.wav", + "text": "江啟臣國民黨的訴求是鐵籠公投限縮公民權開民主倒車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/25.wav", + "text": "雖然當時民進黨握有國會多數席次但是面對外界的反彈並沒有通過公投連署要附身分證影本的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/26.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁說修法的理由是為了避免造假連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/27.wav", + "text": "但是從過去到現在民間推動罷免韓國瑜時的不合格率是7%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/28.wav", + "text": "國民黨立委推動罷免高閔琳時的不合格率是49%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/29.wav", + "text": "請尊重會議程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/30.wav", + "text": "避免造假的連署要附身分證影本為什麼只修選罷法卻沒有修到公投法呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/31.wav", + "text": "光是利益迴避的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/32.wav", + "text": "也應該是從下一屆再實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/33.wav", + "text": "沒有人因為怕自己被罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/34.wav", + "text": "就現在馬上修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/35.wav", + "text": "而且這一屆就馬上適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/36.wav", + "text": "這是明顯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/37.wav", + "text": "沒有利益迴避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/38.wav", + "text": "這是自肥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/39.wav", + "text": "這是自肥法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/40.wav", + "text": "啊這是不應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/41.wav", + "text": "好謝謝林淑芬委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157953/42.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/0.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/1.wav", + "text": "請林宜瑾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/2.wav", + "text": "林宜瑾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/3.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/4.wav", + "text": "請照常計時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/5.wav", + "text": "有請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/6.wav", + "text": "請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/7.wav", + "text": "我想這一屆國民黨跟民眾黨藍白聯手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/8.wav", + "text": "造成最大的民主危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/9.wav", + "text": "不只把自己立委的權力擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/10.wav", + "text": "還向人民盜竊原有的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/11.wav", + "text": "全臺灣人民都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/12.wav", + "text": "罷免權是憲法賦予人民的基本參政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/13.wav", + "text": "如果沒有經過充分的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/14.wav", + "text": "就要來修法剝奪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/15.wav", + "text": "限制這個民權的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/16.wav", + "text": "這是萬萬不可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/17.wav", + "text": "當然今天有這樣的詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/18.wav", + "text": "我們也期待還有充分的公聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/19.wav", + "text": "對於選罷法要修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/20.wav", + "text": "有更充分的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/21.wav", + "text": "國眾兩黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/22.wav", + "text": "從整肅異己的國會擴權惡法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/23.wav", + "text": "到今天取消人民的罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/24.wav", + "text": "這個脈絡是一脈相承" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/25.wav", + "text": "其實簡單可是又暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/26.wav", + "text": "藍白兩黨因為民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/27.wav", + "text": "而成為國會的多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/28.wav", + "text": "可是卻反過頭要威脅臺灣人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/29.wav", + "text": "用引以為傲的民主體制來威脅他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/30.wav", + "text": "取消罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/31.wav", + "text": "所以大家不要看表面上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/32.wav", + "text": "國民黨好像就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/33.wav", + "text": "推動提高罷免門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/34.wav", + "text": "實際上我看今天早上的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/35.wav", + "text": "袖手旁觀的民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/36.wav", + "text": "也是閹割憲法賦權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/37.wav", + "text": "剝奪人民參政權的幫助犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/38.wav", + "text": "\n我當然很好奇的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/39.wav", + "text": "到底是怎麼樣的一群人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/40.wav", + "text": "一天到晚在害怕罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/41.wav", + "text": "連謝國樑這樣的縣市長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/42.wav", + "text": "施政滿意度調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/43.wav", + "text": "全國排名倒數第2名的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/44.wav", + "text": "在現行制度下都可以沒被罷免掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/45.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/46.wav", + "text": "其實現行的罷免已經非常的周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/47.wav", + "text": "那實在很遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/48.wav", + "text": "我們一次又一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/49.wav", + "text": "把國家的資源耗費在這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/50.wav", + "text": "所謂學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/51.wav", + "text": "或者整體社會都還沒有共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/52.wav", + "text": "所以今天即便有這樣的詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/53.wav", + "text": "我還是對這樣子的修法感到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/54.wav", + "text": "非常的遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/55.wav", + "text": "\n我想藍白聯手搞出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/56.wav", + "text": "這個國會擴權惡法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/57.wav", + "text": "這種拼裝車才在憲法法庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/58.wav", + "text": "被判為違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/59.wav", + "text": "現在又要用另一個角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/60.wav", + "text": "來擴大自己的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/61.wav", + "text": "如果要想罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/62.wav", + "text": "就要提供身分證影本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/63.wav", + "text": "要求人民若想罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/64.wav", + "text": "同意罷免票數就必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/65.wav", + "text": "要高於當選票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/66.wav", + "text": "這種提高罷免門檻的雙管齊下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/67.wav", + "text": "其實真的就是沒收了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/68.wav", + "text": "人民的罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/69.wav", + "text": "同意罷免票數要高於當選票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/70.wav", + "text": "當初選舉進行投票那群人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/71.wav", + "text": "和罷免投票的那群人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/72.wav", + "text": "誰能保證是同一群人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/73.wav", + "text": "從選舉投票到罷免投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/74.wav", + "text": "至少要經過一年半的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/75.wav", + "text": "那這一年半的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/76.wav", + "text": "人事物難道不會有變化嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/77.wav", + "text": "至少選舉跟罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/78.wav", + "text": "投票的目的本質性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/79.wav", + "text": "其實完全不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/80.wav", + "text": "而且通常全國性選舉的投票率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/81.wav", + "text": "也高於罷免案的投票率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/82.wav", + "text": "所以如果再一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/83.wav", + "text": "用基隆市長謝國樑來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/84.wav", + "text": "當時2022基隆市長選舉的投票率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/85.wav", + "text": "是60.16%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/86.wav", + "text": "罷免謝國樑的投票率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/87.wav", + "text": "也只有50.44%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/88.wav", + "text": "差了10%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/89.wav", + "text": "這兩種基礎完全不同的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/90.wav", + "text": "硬要擺在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/91.wav", + "text": "混為一談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/92.wav", + "text": "作為罷免是否通過的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/93.wav", + "text": "你認為這樣的依據是合理的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/94.wav", + "text": "這也是中選會一直做的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/95.wav", + "text": "也就是說在投票的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/96.wav", + "text": "選舉投票的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/97.wav", + "text": "跟在罷免投票的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/98.wav", + "text": "時空環境已經有所改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/99.wav", + "text": "民意是流動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/100.wav", + "text": "罷免就是要再一次地來審視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/101.wav", + "text": "再一次地來做確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/102.wav", + "text": "所以不應該用舊的民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/103.wav", + "text": "要來框住新的民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/104.wav", + "text": "這樣子是說不過去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/105.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/106.wav", + "text": "期待再凝聚社會共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/107.wav", + "text": "我們再來審議這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157952/108.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/0.wav", + "text": "我不得不說銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/1.wav", + "text": "主掌全國公務員的銓敘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/2.wav", + "text": "敘對數字對統計計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/3.wav", + "text": "要非常精確地了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/4.wav", + "text": "啦但是我不客氣地送你4個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/5.wav", + "text": "你這個部長叫烏龍部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/6.wav", + "text": "啊怎麼說呢光說你今天這個報告就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/7.wav", + "text": "在今天這份報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/8.wav", + "text": "裡你提出一些數字來解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/9.wav", + "text": "但是這些數字錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/10.wav", + "text": "你等於是幫倒忙欸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/11.wav", + "text": "年金改革要從公務人員先改起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/12.wav", + "text": "是因為軍公教的所得替代率非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/13.wav", + "text": "跟民間勞保的差距那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/14.wav", + "text": "導致民間勞工這種相對剝奪感很重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/15.wav", + "text": "但是就你提出的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/16.wav", + "text": "我唸一段給你聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/17.wav", + "text": "啦你說所得替代率有七成高於5萬1啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/18.wav", + "text": "然後現職人員大概有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/19.wav", + "text": "民間6萬5的八成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/20.wav", + "text": "你說民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/21.wav", + "text": "這就是一個烏龍錯誤的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/22.wav", + "text": "啊民間有哪個退休勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/23.wav", + "text": "有辦法領到3萬7,500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/24.wav", + "text": "你講給我聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/25.wav", + "text": "我現在講實際數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/26.wav", + "text": "你錯在哪裡你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/27.wav", + "text": "對於今年勞保局提供公告的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/28.wav", + "text": "你自己搞錯啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/29.wav", + "text": "的退休金請領人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/30.wav", + "text": "總金額是請領353億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/31.wav", + "text": "好這個數字是沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/32.wav", + "text": "問題是在後續勞退部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/33.wav", + "text": "你完全搞錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/34.wav", + "text": "690件總金額1,251" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/35.wav", + "text": "萬元平均每人領取1萬8,141元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/36.wav", + "text": "部長你要搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/37.wav", + "text": "是3個月份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/38.wav", + "text": "欸勞退是3個月份請領一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/39.wav", + "text": "欸你有沒有搞錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/40.wav", + "text": "這麼明顯的錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/41.wav", + "text": "你回去把這個數字搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/42.wav", + "text": "就算有勞退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/43.wav", + "text": "就算有得領勞退的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/44.wav", + "text": "等於才6000元一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/45.wav", + "text": "但沒有那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/46.wav", + "text": "然後對於75歲以上的老人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/47.wav", + "text": "來說因為勞退是從民國92年才開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/48.wav", + "text": "你非常清楚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/49.wav", + "text": "他們根本沒有勞退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/50.wav", + "text": "你回去問你的長輩就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/51.wav", + "text": "那你為什麼要把勞保年金形容成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/52.wav", + "text": "有3萬7,500那麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/53.wav", + "text": "胡說八道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/54.wav", + "text": "這個數字別人搞錯沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/55.wav", + "text": "你不能搞錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/56.wav", + "text": "你職司全國公務員的銓敘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/57.wav", + "text": "拜託你對於數字應該很精通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/58.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/59.wav", + "text": "勞退有得領的已經很少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/60.wav", + "text": "都在唯一一家公司唯一一個老闆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/61.wav", + "text": "所以絕大多數勞工們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/62.wav", + "text": "沒有勞退金可以領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/63.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/64.wav", + "text": "更何況領取是3個月一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/65.wav", + "text": "你回去問清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/66.wav", + "text": "問清楚你的手下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/67.wav", + "text": "再來寫這一份報告可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/68.wav", + "text": "欸全國勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/69.wav", + "text": "實質領的金額相對於退休公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/70.wav", + "text": "你卻美化了這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/71.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/72.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這份報告不及格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/73.wav", + "text": "啦烏龍部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/74.wav", + "text": "委員您的指教我虛心接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/75.wav", + "text": "我在報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/76.wav", + "text": "引用的確實沒有查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/77.wav", + "text": "證而是引用媒體引述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/78.wav", + "text": "喔原來銓敘部是引用媒體的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/79.wav", + "text": "天啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/80.wav", + "text": "因為媒體是用勞保局的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/81.wav", + "text": "說法我沒有再查證一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/82.wav", + "text": "天啊你引用媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/83.wav", + "text": "我還以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/84.wav", + "text": "因為媒體是引用勞保局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/85.wav", + "text": "原來你是抄媒體的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/86.wav", + "text": "天啊你愈答復愈糟糕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/87.wav", + "text": "你真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/88.wav", + "text": "對你自己也是愈幫愈忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/89.wav", + "text": "好烏龍部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/90.wav", + "text": "謝謝王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/91.wav", + "text": "\n委員均已發言完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157951/92.wav", + "text": "詢答結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/0.wav", + "text": "我看你們都辛苦了一整天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/1.wav", + "text": "辛苦了一整天都在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/2.wav", + "text": "所以今天有非常多人針對相關議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/3.wav", + "text": "不管是關於現職公務人員或退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/4.wav", + "text": "當時在進行年金改革的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/5.wav", + "text": "你們有考慮到有預判到後來的通貨膨脹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/6.wav", + "text": "這麼嚴重這件事情嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/7.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告那已經是幾年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/8.wav", + "text": "當時的物價相對來講是平穩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/9.wav", + "text": "這個問題應該要問主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/10.wav", + "text": "比較知道他們能不能預測那麼遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/11.wav", + "text": "是我了解\n我們當時看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/12.wav", + "text": "我是說我們回頭去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/13.wav", + "text": "有一個每5年檢討一次的制度對吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/14.wav", + "text": "每喔是每4年檢討一次的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/15.wav", + "text": "那為什麼要每4年檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/16.wav", + "text": "就是可能因為通貨膨脹CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/17.wav", + "text": "所以才會有每4年討論一次這樣的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/18.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/19.wav", + "text": "應該這樣講其實源頭是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/20.wav", + "text": "CPI只要達到5%就要調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/21.wav", + "text": "如果沒有達到5%就是每4年應該檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/22.wav", + "text": "對沒有達到5%的話有兩個標準嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/23.wav", + "text": "就是CPI超過5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/24.wav", + "text": "跟每4年檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/25.wav", + "text": "但是我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/26.wav", + "text": "還有物價調漲速度其實非常地快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/27.wav", + "text": "再加上我們做了年金改革之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/28.wav", + "text": "就不能說被剝了兩次皮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/29.wav", + "text": "能夠使用出去的退休金又變得更少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/30.wav", + "text": "既然現在也過了4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/31.wav", + "text": "那我們希望做個檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/32.wav", + "text": "這是第一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/33.wav", + "text": "\n第二件事情剛剛您也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/34.wav", + "text": "超過5%的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/35.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能在修法版本當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/36.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/37.wav", + "text": "分之幾要調整屬於立法政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/38.wav", + "text": "但另外一個議題涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/39.wav", + "text": "包括國民年金公保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/40.wav", + "text": "全國不要有不同的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/41.wav", + "text": "所以這是一個要一起來討論的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/42.wav", + "text": "當然要一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/43.wav", + "text": "但是比方說勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/44.wav", + "text": "如果真的都要一起討論的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/45.wav", + "text": "那勞保年金也沒改革啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/46.wav", + "text": "但是我們每4年也一定會做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/47.wav", + "text": "是現在是到了一個檢討的時段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/48.wav", + "text": "大家才會在這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/49.wav", + "text": "提出法律的修正案嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/50.wav", + "text": "所以我才會想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/51.wav", + "text": "未來在可見的未來就會有通貨膨脹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/52.wav", + "text": "而是全球都可能發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/53.wav", + "text": "那我們是不是該在這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/54.wav", + "text": "將公務人員年金隨CPI調漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/55.wav", + "text": "不要因為物價上漲的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/56.wav", + "text": "委員我們現在的機制是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/57.wav", + "text": "跟著CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/58.wav", + "text": "而這是正確的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/59.wav", + "text": "全世界都這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/60.wav", + "text": "要用5%還是往下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/61.wav", + "text": "可以在社會上再多作一些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/62.wav", + "text": "OK所以您不是特別反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/63.wav", + "text": "只是希望能夠統一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/64.wav", + "text": "還有前提就是要跟別的制度一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/65.wav", + "text": "最重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/66.wav", + "text": "中第一次調整就是每4年檢討一次的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/67.wav", + "text": "第二次調整就是剛好CPI真的達到5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/68.wav", + "text": "這我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/69.wav", + "text": "\n最後大家會問的問題就是會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/70.wav", + "text": "在大家關注勞保基金的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/71.wav", + "text": "不是只有砍年金才是改革的迷思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/72.wav", + "text": "撥補健全勞保財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/73.wav", + "text": "就是政府的決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/74.wav", + "text": "她認為撥補經費也是一種改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/75.wav", + "text": "那麼我想請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/76.wav", + "text": "為什麼勞保可以用撥補作為改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/77.wav", + "text": "有撥補進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/78.wav", + "text": "本上我們節省的經費兩千多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/79.wav", + "text": "元都全數挹注回基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/80.wav", + "text": "並沒有拿去別的地方用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/81.wav", + "text": "同時為了退撫新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/82.wav", + "text": "目前大概還另外再撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/83.wav", + "text": "要怎麼讓基金永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/84.wav", + "text": "其實都是多軌道進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157950/85.wav", + "text": "這就是當初設定要讓年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/0.wav", + "text": "麻煩人事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/1.wav", + "text": "人事���好我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/2.wav", + "text": "不知道您有沒有注意到您知道這件事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/3.wav", + "text": "應該是提到原民會執行的預算金額增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/4.wav", + "text": "所以你們也期待員額也可以有一定比例的增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/5.wav", + "text": "應該不是這個部分啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/6.wav", + "text": "把這些經費節省起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/7.wav", + "text": "未來要挪到原民會聘請一般公務人員使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/8.wav", + "text": "我要請教人事長經費可以這樣挪來挪去嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/9.wav", + "text": "這個涉及組織的安定性我覺得非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/10.wav", + "text": "是有一點點不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/11.wav", + "text": "除了不公平以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/12.wav", + "text": "也不是把這筆經費刪掉省起來就可以挪到別的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/13.wav", + "text": "不是這樣說挪就挪的吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/14.wav", + "text": "基本上我們在編人事費時都會考量要執行哪些業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/15.wav", + "text": "這些業務是屬於新增的或者做哪些再給額外的人事費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/16.wav", + "text": "因為人事費這個科目本來就有很明確的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/17.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得他們真的是搞不清楚狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/18.wav", + "text": "把整個政府預算當成小學生的數學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/19.wav", + "text": "想要怎麼挪就怎麼挪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/20.wav", + "text": "其實他們最近一直在用這種話術欺騙民眾欺騙我們原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/21.wav", + "text": "讓大家覺得政府為什麼要讓原民會的人力一直都不足處於不足的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/22.wav", + "text": "但事實上針對原民會員額的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/23.wav", + "text": "我有跟原民會再三確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/24.wav", + "text": "其實他們的編制員額是206人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/25.wav", + "text": "你們這邊是給到198人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/26.wav", + "text": "實際員額則是166人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/27.wav", + "text": "會再補進這些人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/28.wav", + "text": "但是原民會人力不足的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/29.wav", + "text": "並不是預算員額的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/30.wav", + "text": "而是實際員額太低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/31.wav", + "text": "也就是說原民會根本就找不到人或者是留不住人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/32.wav", + "text": "這才是真正的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/33.wav", + "text": "針對這些問題我要請教人事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/34.wav", + "text": "事實上我也跟很多原住民朋友討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/35.wav", + "text": "啦尤其原民會的上班地點在新莊那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/36.wav", + "text": "我知道原住民有一個非常好的習慣就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/37.wav", + "text": "因為那裡是他生活的場域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/38.wav", + "text": "所以到都會區來工作對於原住民來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/39.wav", + "text": "吸引力會相對比較不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/40.wav", + "text": "因為到都會區開銷很大啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/41.wav", + "text": "吃的也貴住的也貴啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/42.wav", + "text": "整個消費都滿高的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/43.wav", + "text": "但我想這是其中一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/44.wav", + "text": "然是要調整原民會所有職員的專業加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/45.wav", + "text": "否則沒有誘因怎麼留得住人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/46.wav", + "text": "我知道你一定會講到土管處啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/47.wav", + "text": "但我認為土管處是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/48.wav", + "text": "──像是國產署地政司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/49.wav", + "text": "一樣都在辦理土地業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/50.wav", + "text": "那就應該給一樣的加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/51.wav", + "text": "加給邏輯上是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/52.wav", + "text": "所以不要拿土管處來做比喻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/53.wav", + "text": "你們刪掉土管處這個比喻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/54.wav", + "text": "好我們再來跟原民會好好溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/55.wav", + "text": "針對怎麼補齊人力這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/56.wav", + "text": "好好想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/57.wav", + "text": "在1個月內提出報告謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157949/58.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/0.wav", + "text": "請部長人事長委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/1.wav", + "text": "國家的利益永遠是高於政黨的利益對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/2.wav", + "text": "而且一定要兼顧世代公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/3.wav", + "text": "立法者每天在思考的是怎麼樣讓國家更進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/4.wav", + "text": "讓人民更幸福" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/5.wav", + "text": "建立的法律制度及相關的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/6.wav", + "text": "都是要福國利民而不是禍國殃民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/7.wav", + "text": "兩位同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/8.wav", + "text": "非常同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/9.wav", + "text": "剛剛邱議瑩委員說馬前總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/10.wav", + "text": "吳前副總統也說如果這個不改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/11.wav", + "text": "一旦引爆會引起很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/12.wav", + "text": "社會的問題國家的危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/13.wav", + "text": "公務人員相關的權益對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/14.wav", + "text": "我相信他們在當國家元首的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/15.wav", + "text": "他們應該是思考到國家的利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/16.wav", + "text": "他們兩位同時也擔任過國民黨的黨主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/17.wav", + "text": "所以他們當時說這句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/18.wav", + "text": "應當是為了國家的利益或者制度的永續存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/19.wav", + "text": "我不曉得的是為什麼年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/20.wav", + "text": "在他們任內沒辦法執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/21.wav", + "text": "而蔡英文總統執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/22.wav", + "text": "了這是一個福國利民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/23.wav", + "text": "沒有錯嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/24.wav", + "text": "既是對的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/25.wav", + "text": "為什麼有人或是有特定的政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/26.wav", + "text": "而且是曾經說年改不做是未爆彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/27.wav", + "text": "且當過黨主席的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/28.wav", + "text": "他們政黨竟然要走回頭路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/29.wav", + "text": "這情何以堪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/30.wav", + "text": "我想是不是他們把政黨的利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/31.wav", + "text": "高於國家的利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/32.wav", + "text": "把一個制度變成沒有辦法可長可久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/33.wav", + "text": "也破壞了世代的公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/34.wav", + "text": "兩位同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/35.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/36.wav", + "text": "那怎麼辦呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/37.wav", + "text": "如果假設按照國民黨的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/38.wav", + "text": "會出現哪些恐怖的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/39.wav", + "text": "我光是用想的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/40.wav", + "text": "就覺得真的不寒而慄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/41.wav", + "text": "會有哪些狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/42.wav", + "text": "我想最重要的就是年金提早用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/43.wav", + "text": "年金用罄就破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/44.wav", + "text": "就破產吧就沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/45.wav", + "text": "對現職的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/46.wav", + "text": "來講很多人都還在這個基金裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/47.wav", + "text": "所以會產生很大的一個衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/48.wav", + "text": "未來會有很多或是現在的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/49.wav", + "text": "都無法領到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/50.wav", + "text": "年金不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/51.wav", + "text": "事實上破產不只是影響到現職公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/52.wav", + "text": "還有退休的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/53.wav", + "text": "甚至還影響到未來很多公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/54.wav", + "text": "會有疑慮不敢來考公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/55.wav", + "text": "所以影響的層面還是非常廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/56.wav", + "text": "就是會找不到公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/57.wav", + "text": "沒退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/58.wav", + "text": "金那做公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/59.wav", + "text": "這是很嚴重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/60.wav", + "text": "你看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/61.wav", + "text": "從今年的1,186億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/62.wav", + "text": "會增加到明年的1,316億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/63.wav", + "text": "增幅到11%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/64.wav", + "text": "的是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/65.wav", + "text": "那改回去怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/66.wav", + "text": "部長你會煩惱嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/67.wav", + "text": "我會煩惱到睡不著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/68.wav", + "text": "因為本席一向都很尊重時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/69.wav", + "text": "不要影響到後面委員的質詢權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/70.wav", + "text": "相關的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/71.wav", + "text": "我再用書面跟兩位請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157948/72.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/1.wav", + "text": "到底要問施部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/2.wav", + "text": "還是要問蘇人事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/3.wav", + "text": "兩個都互指對方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/4.wav", + "text": "以示公平請兩位都上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/5.wav", + "text": "坐太久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/6.wav", + "text": "對身體也不太好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/7.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/8.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有聽過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/9.wav", + "text": "曾經有一位總統說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/10.wav", + "text": "年金改革一定要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/11.wav", + "text": "今天不做明天就會後悔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/12.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/13.wav", + "text": "可以指出這位是誰嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/14.wav", + "text": "馬前總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/15.wav", + "text": "馬英九先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/16.wav", + "text": "在2012年的時候說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/17.wav", + "text": "年金改革一定要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/18.wav", + "text": "今天不做明天就會後悔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/19.wav", + "text": "那請問兩位有沒有聽過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/20.wav", + "text": "年金改革一定要快做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/21.wav", + "text": "否則將成國家的未爆彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/22.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/23.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/24.wav", + "text": "那這位是誰說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/25.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/26.wav", + "text": "啦你不要一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/27.wav", + "text": "馬前總統這個答案不一定正確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/28.wav", + "text": "這個是吳敦義先生說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/29.wav", + "text": "這兩位都是國民黨的大老" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/30.wav", + "text": "年金改革一定要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/31.wav", + "text": "不做會後悔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/32.wav", + "text": "年金改革不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/33.wav", + "text": "會成為國家的未爆彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/34.wav", + "text": "但是這兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/35.wav", + "text": "都做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/36.wav", + "text": "也沒辦法做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/37.wav", + "text": "也不能做也不會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/38.wav", + "text": "所以年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/39.wav", + "text": "就由蔡英文來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/40.wav", + "text": "這個年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/41.wav", + "text": "改了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/42.wav", + "text": "我想請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/43.wav", + "text": "人事長對國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/44.wav", + "text": "帶來什麼樣的正面影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/45.wav", + "text": "我想它主要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/46.wav", + "text": "兩個非常重大的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/47.wav", + "text": "就是一個永續的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/48.wav", + "text": "另外一個是世代公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/49.wav", + "text": "正義的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/50.wav", + "text": "如何永續的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/51.wav", + "text": "人事長可不可以再簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/52.wav", + "text": "如果年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/53.wav", + "text": "不做的話如果2018年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/54.wav", + "text": "我們的年金改革沒做的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/55.wav", + "text": "那現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/56.wav", + "text": "會面臨到什麼樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/57.wav", + "text": "你的永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/58.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣的永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/59.wav", + "text": "如果不做會不會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/60.wav", + "text": "一定會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/61.wav", + "text": "啊一定會提早破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/62.wav", + "text": "提早到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/63.wav", + "text": "119年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/64.wav", + "text": "119年就會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/65.wav", + "text": "轉眼就很快了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/66.wav", + "text": "有可能現在坐在台上這幾位議事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/67.wav", + "text": "等到您退休的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/68.wav", + "text": "已經沒有年金可以領了會不會出現這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/69.wav", + "text": "機會還蠻高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/70.wav", + "text": "我看現在這幾位都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/71.wav", + "text": "大概還有一二十年才會退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/72.wav", + "text": "如果119年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/73.wav", + "text": "破產的話你們會領不到退休金喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/74.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/75.wav", + "text": "過去這五六年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/76.wav", + "text": "年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/77.wav", + "text": "改革方案在實施之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/78.wav", + "text": "延緩了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/79.wav", + "text": "破產的危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/80.wav", + "text": "但是我們其實還有潛在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/81.wav", + "text": "2.9兆債務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/82.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/83.wav", + "text": "好如果現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/84.wav", + "text": "按照國民黨委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/85.wav", + "text": "的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/86.wav", + "text": "要再把它調整回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/87.wav", + "text": "會產生什麼樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/88.wav", + "text": "就是會提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/89.wav", + "text": "會提早到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/90.wav", + "text": "還是119年嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/91.wav", + "text": "還是因為��去有6年的緩衝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/92.wav", + "text": "所以會再晚一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/93.wav", + "text": "所以本來是119年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/94.wav", + "text": "我們做了年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/95.wav", + "text": "本來會到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/96.wav", + "text": "那現在如果要再把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/97.wav", + "text": "改回來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/98.wav", + "text": "會再往前提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/99.wav", + "text": "所以有可能就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/100.wav", + "text": "現在改回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/101.wav", + "text": "台上這些議事人員有可能領得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/102.wav", + "text": "但是未來新進的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/103.wav", + "text": "大概一毛都領不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/104.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/105.wav", + "text": "就是最近這幾年進來的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/106.wav", + "text": "請問一下這對國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/107.wav", + "text": "是好事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/108.wav", + "text": "新進公務人員是好事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/109.wav", + "text": "你要現在就告訴他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/110.wav", + "text": "你進來當公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/111.wav", + "text": "但公家單位等到你退休的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/112.wav", + "text": "年金是破產的你一毛錢都沒得領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/113.wav", + "text": "因為前面領完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/114.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/115.wav", + "text": "那如果是這樣我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/116.wav", + "text": "老實的告訴大家不要再去考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/117.wav", + "text": "公務人員了因為你沒有退休年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/118.wav", + "text": "可以領啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/119.wav", + "text": "年金破產了年限會提早啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/120.wav", + "text": "人事長銓敘部長我們不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/121.wav", + "text": "說謊的知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/122.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣你們應該要老實的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/123.wav", + "text": "告訴那些公務人員不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/124.wav", + "text": "再去考公務人員了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/125.wav", + "text": "因為你們未來會沒有年金可以領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/126.wav", + "text": "等到你退休的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/127.wav", + "text": "你只能望著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/128.wav", + "text": "壁紙在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/129.wav", + "text": "吹風你沒有年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/130.wav", + "text": "對國家是好事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/131.wav", + "text": "對公務人員是好事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/132.wav", + "text": "現在改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/133.wav", + "text": "你還是回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/134.wav", + "text": "照顧給原來的那一個區塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/135.wav", + "text": "那個所得替代率又回到上升的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/136.wav", + "text": "年金又提早破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/137.wav", + "text": "你對後面的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/138.wav", + "text": "對後面願意報效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/139.wav", + "text": "國家的人要怎麼交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/140.wav", + "text": "看不出來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/141.wav", + "text": "雖然我平常不是很同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/142.wav", + "text": "馬英九先生的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/143.wav", + "text": "不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/144.wav", + "text": "馬英九先生講的這一段話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/145.wav", + "text": "我倒是認同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/146.wav", + "text": "年金改革一定要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/147.wav", + "text": "一定要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/148.wav", + "text": "臺灣不能再走回頭路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/149.wav", + "text": "啊這件事情我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/150.wav", + "text": "人事長跟銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/151.wav", + "text": "我們一定要站穩我們的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/152.wav", + "text": "年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/153.wav", + "text": "如果再走回頭路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/154.wav", + "text": "臺灣就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/155.wav", + "text": "那這是滿足了誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/156.wav", + "text": "好到了誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/157.wav", + "text": "把臺灣整個弄到滅亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/158.wav", + "text": "會好到了什麼人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157947/159.wav", + "text": "大家應該心裡有數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委請一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/1.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/2.wav", + "text": "部長有關於軍公教的年金改革是一個非常嚴肅的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/3.wav", + "text": "在馬英九時代他們也希望能夠推出相關的改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/4.wav", + "text": "承擔起這樣改革的沉重責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/5.wav", + "text": "能夠有基本的保障這是不分藍綠共同的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/6.wav", + "text": "而且這樣的保障必須是能夠永續的同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/7.wav", + "text": "也要給他們信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/8.wav", + "text": "\n剛才我聽了幾位國民黨委員所提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/9.wav", + "text": "有關於軍公教改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/10.wav", + "text": "他們認為軍公教改革在賴清德擔任總統之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/11.wav", + "text": "我們對於勞保有相關的持續撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/12.wav", + "text": "他們認為勞保有撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/13.wav", + "text": "他們認為這是有差異性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/14.wav", + "text": "其實這是非常扭曲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/15.wav", + "text": "而且是非常謬誤的一個說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/16.wav", + "text": "請部長簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/17.wav", + "text": "我們改革所省下來的所有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/18.wav", + "text": "統統一樣回歸給這個基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/19.wav", + "text": "這兩千多億是砍掉了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/20.wav", + "text": "沒有砍掉就是回到原基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/21.wav", + "text": "或是教育的改革校園的設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/22.wav", + "text": "或是國王的支出也都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/23.wav", + "text": "都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/24.wav", + "text": "這個必須要說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/25.wav", + "text": "\n另外對於勞保相關的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/26.wav", + "text": "勞保在2012年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/27.wav", + "text": "因為勞保的財務精算報告提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/28.wav", + "text": "當時的行政院長是陳冲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/29.wav", + "text": "勞委會主委是王如玄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/30.wav", + "text": "玄當時我就提出兩大訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/31.wav", + "text": "第一個是政府撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/32.wav", + "text": "第二個是國家最終支付責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/33.wav", + "text": "努力了多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/34.wav", + "text": "終於在蘇貞昌院長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/35.wav", + "text": "在2020年政府編了200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/36.wav", + "text": "2021年編了220億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/37.wav", + "text": "2022年編了300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/38.wav", + "text": "2023年編到750億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/39.wav", + "text": "今年2024年編到1,200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/40.wav", + "text": "明年是希望有1,300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/41.wav", + "text": "我要跟國民黨的委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/42.wav", + "text": "這個政府的撥補還沒有明文入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/43.wav", + "text": "這是實質的撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/44.wav", + "text": "還沒有進行到下一個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/45.wav", + "text": "勞保條例第69條的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/46.wav", + "text": "勞保要有明文入法這才是安心條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/47.wav", + "text": "勞保還是必須要面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/48.wav", + "text": "未來的勞保年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/49.wav", + "text": "就是為了要讓它永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/50.wav", + "text": "還是面臨同樣的一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/51.wav", + "text": "我們在這邊都必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/52.wav", + "text": "向所有的國人報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/53.wav", + "text": "我們都要照顧每一個國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/54.wav", + "text": "這是我們共同的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/55.wav", + "text": "不管是軍公教還是勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/56.wav", + "text": "還是各階層都要運用國家的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/57.wav", + "text": "來保障他們的基本權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/58.wav", + "text": "\n相關的有關於勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/59.wav", + "text": "他們認為對軍公教沒有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/60.wav", + "text": "退休撫卹基金管理條例第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/61.wav", + "text": "就有明文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/62.wav", + "text": "他們的年金如果有經費的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/63.wav", + "text": "政府要撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/64.wav", + "text": "而且是由國家負最終支付責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/65.wav", + "text": "任它有明文入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/66.wav", + "text": "喔國民年金法第49條也有明文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/67.wav", + "text": "國民年金如果有經費的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/68.wav", + "text": "政府也要撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/69.wav", + "text": "也要負最終支付責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/70.wav", + "text": "不管哪一個階層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/71.wav", + "text": "我們國家都要負起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/72.wav", + "text": "請部長做最後的補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/73.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157946/74.wav", + "text": "另外有一個會議宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/0.wav", + "text": "麻煩請銓敘部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/1.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/2.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/3.wav", + "text": "部長我之前跟一個公立醫院的院長聊天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/4.wav", + "text": "他說現在越來越少醫生願意到公立醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/5.wav", + "text": "他跟醫生講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/6.wav", + "text": "沒關係你來我們這邊啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/7.wav", + "text": "我們公務人員保障比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/8.wav", + "text": "那個年輕醫生回答什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/9.wav", + "text": "他說現在政府講的話都不算數啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/10.wav", + "text": "誰知道你現在講的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/11.wav", + "text": "到時候會不會兌現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/12.wav", + "text": "這就是年金改革帶來的後遺症" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/13.wav", + "text": "它其實殘害了我們整個公務體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/14.wav", + "text": "對於我們招募優秀人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/15.wav", + "text": "產生極大的負面影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/16.wav", + "text": "我就想問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/17.wav", + "text": "因為年金財產要破產了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/18.wav", + "text": "因此政府可以不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/19.wav", + "text": "維持信賴保護原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/20.wav", + "text": "也可以突破法不溯及既往原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/21.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/22.wav", + "text": "我想這個做法在大法官會議解釋裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/23.wav", + "text": "我是問說你們的主張是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/24.wav", + "text": "我現在沒有在跟你討論有沒有違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/25.wav", + "text": "我是說當時你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/26.wav", + "text": "以未違反信賴保護原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/27.wav", + "text": "及法不溯及既往原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/28.wav", + "text": "就是你認為有更高的法益嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/29.wav", + "text": "對嘛就是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/30.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/31.wav", + "text": "退撫基金要破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/32.wav", + "text": "真的是因為公務人員領太多嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/33.wav", + "text": "報酬率計算有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/34.wav", + "text": "當時基金報酬率是算多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/35.wav", + "text": "當初的基金報酬率大概是4%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/36.wav", + "text": "你是算4%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/37.wav", + "text": "然後覺得會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/38.wav", + "text": "那如果你的計算方式是5%會破產嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/39.wav", + "text": "我還是跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/40.wav", + "text": "你回答我的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/41.wav", + "text": "如果你的報酬率是5%的話會破產嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/42.wav", + "text": "委員我跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/43.wav", + "text": "現在整個負債還是有2.9兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/44.wav", + "text": "所以即使我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/45.wav", + "text": "提升到百分之七點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/46.wav", + "text": "如果現在負債有2.9兆的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/47.wav", + "text": "之後你還是會砍人家的年金嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/48.wav", + "text": "會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/49.wav", + "text": "我們會努力維持這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/50.wav", + "text": "我想我們就繼續讓年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/51.wav", + "text": "所以不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/52.wav", + "text": "政府是不是不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/53.wav", + "text": "喔你現在如果破產的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/54.wav", + "text": "你是不是考慮要再繼續砍人家年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/55.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/56.wav", + "text": "委員我們現在不會討論這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/57.wav", + "text": "代表什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/58.wav", + "text": "代表基金破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/59.wav", + "text": "跟要不要砍年金是兩回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/60.wav", + "text": "你們現在的考慮方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/61.wav", + "text": "就是也許我們要提高基金報酬率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/62.wav", + "text": "讓退撫基金的水位能夠維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/63.wav", + "text": "嘛當時就是因為你們基金的經營成效太差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/64.wav", + "text": "了所以才會造成破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/65.wav", + "text": "所以真正會造成這個年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/66.wav", + "text": "可能破產的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/67.wav", + "text": "跟退休人員領多少無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/68.wav", + "text": "嘛真正的關鍵是你報酬率太低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/69.wav", + "text": "嘛因為你報酬率太低的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/70.wav", + "text": "你說因為你們領太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/71.wav", + "text": "當時的民進黨幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/72.wav", + "text": "還說你們公務人員不要吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/73.wav", + "text": "喔你們吵越兇砍更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/74.wav", + "text": "是這麼粗暴這麼情緒化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/75.wav", + "text": "這樣不把公務人員的尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/76.wav", + "text": "當一回事的砍價方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/77.wav", + "text": "結果你們有沒有檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/78.wav", + "text": "實際上是你們基金的報酬率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/79.wav", + "text": "太差的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/80.wav", + "text": "造成公教人員這幾年來一直背黑鍋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/81.wav", + "text": "好像是因為他們領太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/82.wav", + "text": "才拖垮了臺灣的財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/83.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是非常可惡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/84.wav", + "text": "啦我覺得非常可惡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/85.wav", + "text": "絕對不是單純的投資報酬率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/86.wav", + "text": "因為從基金開始成立以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/87.wav", + "text": "就沒有按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/88.wav", + "text": "如果你的報酬率高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/89.wav", + "text": "你能夠維持5%的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/90.wav", + "text": "也許就不會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/91.wav", + "text": "部長你這樣講我就很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/92.wav", + "text": "因為你的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/93.wav", + "text": "到時候也許不是報酬率的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/94.wav", + "text": "我們如果報酬率沒辦法解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/95.wav", + "text": "我要繼續砍人家年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/96.wav", + "text": "你怎麼對公務人員交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/97.wav", + "text": "啊你已經完全破壞了信賴保護原則了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/98.wav", + "text": "我沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/99.wav", + "text": "要招募優秀人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/100.wav", + "text": "就是因為你們粗暴的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/101.wav", + "text": "讓人家都不敢來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/102.wav", + "text": "啦我還沒有問問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/103.wav", + "text": "我沒有問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/104.wav", + "text": "現在這個問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/105.wav", + "text": "我們現在為了要建立優秀的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/106.wav", + "text": "願意進到公部門服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/107.wav", + "text": "過去的公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/108.wav", + "text": "犧牲了企業的高薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/109.wav", + "text": "他們到公家機關服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/110.wav", + "text": "他們奠定了臺灣經濟的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/111.wav", + "text": "包括現在民進黨常常講的台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/112.wav", + "text": "護國神山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/113.wav", + "text": "也都是那個時候的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/114.wav", + "text": "辛辛苦苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/115.wav", + "text": "由他們擬定計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/116.wav", + "text": "所建立起來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/117.wav", + "text": "現在你說因為他們領太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/118.wav", + "text": "所以就把他們的退休金砍了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/119.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣子對他們公平嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/120.wav", + "text": "你現在還堂而皇之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/121.wav", + "text": "沾沾自喜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/122.wav", + "text": "覺得自己的年金改革做得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/123.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有去思考說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/124.wav", + "text": "應該要提高自己基金的績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/125.wav", + "text": "反而去破壞了這樣的一個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/126.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得非常的可惡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/127.wav", + "text": "啦我現在就是問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/128.wav", + "text": "接下來你還是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/129.wav", + "text": "基金的水位不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/130.wav", + "text": "所以你要繼續砍嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/131.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/132.wav", + "text": "目前沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/133.wav", + "text": "那為什麼之前就用這種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/134.wav", + "text": "代表你有別的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/135.wav", + "text": "可以讓基金水位增加嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/136.wav", + "text": "你為什麼不思考這個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/137.wav", + "text": "所以我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/138.wav", + "text": "因為召委已經站起來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/139.wav", + "text": "所以其實我覺得國民黨版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/140.wav", + "text": "第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/141.wav", + "text": "沒有要恢復18%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/142.wav", + "text": "第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/143.wav", + "text": "也沒有要恢復年改前的所得報酬率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/144.wav", + "text": "現在只是因為已經砍了那麼多年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/145.wav", + "text": "從75%降到67.5%所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/146.wav", + "text": "希望你們先停損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/147.wav", + "text": "先檢討一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/148.wav", + "text": "了解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/149.wav", + "text": "如果現在所得替代率到67.5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/150.wav", + "text": "狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/151.wav", + "text": "未來的基金有沒有可能因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/152.wav", + "text": "假設提高投資報酬率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/153.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/154.wav", + "text": "就以這樣子停損的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/155.wav", + "text": "就這樣下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/156.wav", + "text": "現在只是要做這樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/157.wav", + "text": "版本就這樣而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/158.wav", + "text": "啊部長你覺得到底為什麼不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/159.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/160.wav", + "text": "所有基金的財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/161.wav", + "text": "投資報酬率只是其中一個因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/162.wav", + "text": "但是我們這個基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/163.wav", + "text": "為什麼到目前為止有這麼大的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/164.wav", + "text": "從一開始就沒有根據基金所精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/165.wav", + "text": "最適費率做提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/166.wav", + "text": "加上我們所得制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/167.wav", + "text": "退休制���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/168.wav", + "text": "所以你接下來要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/169.wav", + "text": "嘛接下來你覺得如果有可能破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/170.wav", + "text": "就要繼續砍人家年金嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/171.wav", + "text": "還是你會找別的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/172.wav", + "text": "還是你會找別的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/173.wav", + "text": "如果你接下來沒有要砍年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/174.wav", + "text": "可以找其他的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/175.wav", + "text": "那為什麼之前要砍人家年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/176.wav", + "text": "就是要砍人家年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/177.wav", + "text": "也破壞好不容易建立起來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/178.wav", + "text": "政府跟人民的信任基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/179.wav", + "text": "我覺得實在是得不償失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/180.wav", + "text": "啦希望部長可以好好思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/181.wav", + "text": "謝謝葉委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/182.wav", + "text": "\n我們現在先處理會議時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157945/183.wav", + "text": "依照上午的宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/0.wav", + "text": "因為這個國家正在退回無法想像的樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/1.wav", + "text": "因為國民黨今天排案審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/2.wav", + "text": "公務人員退休資遣撫卹法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/3.wav", + "text": "名義上是說審查實質上就是要推翻掉過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/4.wav", + "text": "蔡英文總統執政努力推動的年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/5.wav", + "text": "所以想問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/6.wav", + "text": "目前蔡英文總統執政時期推動的年改版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/7.wav", + "text": "預計退撫基金可以維持多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/8.wav", + "text": "針對於年輕的公務人員是否有同樣保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/9.wav", + "text": "應該當初在推動的時候就設定至少延後一個世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/10.wav", + "text": "所以如果一直走下去的話我們預估會到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/11.wav", + "text": "這中間如果我們再多做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/12.wav", + "text": "比方說財務上的投資效益會更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/13.wav", + "text": "以各式各樣的方式進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/14.wav", + "text": "當然可能還會再往後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/15.wav", + "text": "這是我們當初所希望走的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/16.wav", + "text": "所以看起來年改可能就是被誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/17.wav", + "text": "絕對不是歧視公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/18.wav", + "text": "犧牲公務員實際上反而是為了國家永續發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/19.wav", + "text": "或者換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/20.wav", + "text": "讓每位退休軍公教人員都能夠真正的放心平安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/21.wav", + "text": "渡過退休後的日子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/22.wav", + "text": "無需擔心是否國家垮台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/23.wav", + "text": "基金破產退休金領不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/24.wav", + "text": "我想這是年改的初衷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/25.wav", + "text": "\n第二個要請教部長有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/26.wav", + "text": "有其他黨團提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/27.wav", + "text": "目前國際局勢動盪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/28.wav", + "text": "原物料上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/29.wav", + "text": "帶動國內物價的上漲趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/30.wav", + "text": "可能造成目前退休公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/31.wav", + "text": "領取退休金不足以支付生活狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/32.wav", + "text": "請問現況為何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/33.wav", + "text": "我想所有的物價指數變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/34.wav", + "text": "的退休所得本來就會跟著物價做5%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/35.wav", + "text": "所以過去年改以後也調了6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/36.wav", + "text": "目前所有退休人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/37.wav", + "text": "不管他是哪一個年度退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/38.wav", + "text": "大概七成左右都會有5萬塊以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/39.wav", + "text": "勞工體系的月薪資所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/40.wav", + "text": "目前國民黨的版本修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/41.wav", + "text": "如果退回過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/42.wav", + "text": "請問我國每一年的財政負擔要增加多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/43.wav", + "text": "是否目前有財源可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/44.wav", + "text": "應該講我們所有改革是對基金會衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/45.wav", + "text": "基金我們是根據精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/46.wav", + "text": "50年來做精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/47.wav", + "text": "因為基金要永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/48.wav", + "text": "所以如果這個停止的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/49.wav", + "text": "我們估算會提早4到5年用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/50.wav", + "text": "然後會減少2,800億左右的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/51.wav", + "text": "我們有辦法支撐下去嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/52.wav", + "text": "對基金是一個很大的挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/53.wav", + "text": "所以如果目前現行版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/54.wav", + "text": "運作上銓敘部是否有看到什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/55.wav", + "text": "窒礙難行之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/56.wav", + "text": "我覺得已經推動5年6年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/57.wav", + "text": "我想順順利利讓它到118年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/58.wav", + "text": "會做公務人員調薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/59.wav", + "text": "或者是定期就退休人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/60.wav", + "text": "大家要看到的是可以拿的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/61.wav", + "text": "其實可能跟大家想像中說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/62.wav", + "text": "的那個60%其實是不用那麼驚慌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/63.wav", + "text": "因此本席希望國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/64.wav", + "text": "停止你們掏空國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/65.wav", + "text": "掏空臺灣的種種行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/66.wav", + "text": "好好的重視下一代的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157944/67.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/0.wav", + "text": "公務人員退休生活的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/1.wav", + "text": "絕對不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/2.wav", + "text": "政策買票或是保護自己的政治工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/3.wav", + "text": "我想在第9屆的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/4.wav", + "text": "及背景資料大家也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/5.wav", + "text": "花了將近快四個委員會的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/6.wav", + "text": "從4月19日一直審到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/7.wav", + "text": "106年6月20日才完成三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/8.wav", + "text": "現在我們迫不及待要來修這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/9.wav", + "text": "我在這邊也要特別提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/10.wav", + "text": "過去有幾個在野的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/11.wav", + "text": "有特別提出希望有個精算報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/12.wav", + "text": "希望看到最新的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/13.wav", + "text": "然後來提出一個永續的基金改革制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/14.wav", + "text": "再來討論修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/15.wav", + "text": "現在都還沒有出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/16.wav", + "text": "我不曉得為什麼這麼急就章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/17.wav", + "text": "而且到目前為止也只有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/18.wav", + "text": "國民黨委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/19.wav", + "text": "連民進黨的版本都沒有出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/20.wav", + "text": "我為什麼要特別提到民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/21.wav", + "text": "因為民眾黨的委員吳春城" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/22.wav", + "text": "城也特別提一個叫壯世代的草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/23.wav", + "text": "那壯世代這個相關的草案是跨部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/24.wav", + "text": "臺灣又要進入到超高齡的社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/25.wav", + "text": "在目前臺灣整體的社會醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/26.wav", + "text": "這麼發達的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/27.wav", + "text": "有很多65歲以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/28.wav", + "text": "其實都有具備相對的工作能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/29.wav", + "text": "就像我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/30.wav", + "text": "我記得好像是64歲了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/31.wav", + "text": "還1年而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/32.wav", + "text": "還1年而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/33.wav", + "text": "很多65歲的公務人員能夠繼續工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/34.wav", + "text": "他並不是為了一定要這麼工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/35.wav", + "text": "反而是國家需要他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/36.wav", + "text": "基本上這些都可以在65歲之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/37.wav", + "text": "繼續發揮自己的長才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/38.wav", + "text": "為國家所用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/39.wav", + "text": "民間也是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/40.wav", + "text": "來延後退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/41.wav", + "text": "全世界皆然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/42.wav", + "text": "全世界現在也都在討論這樣的內容跟方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/43.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/44.wav", + "text": "如果未來公務人員要比照勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/45.wav", + "text": "可以用這個協商的方式來延後退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/46.wav", + "text": "針對這些有意願繼續留在職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/47.wav", + "text": "的人國家也需要這些願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/48.wav", + "text": "貢獻自己經驗能力的中高齡公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/49.wav", + "text": "他們的退撫要如何計算才公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/50.wav", + "text": "部長這邊有相關的計算嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/51.wav", + "text": "委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/52.wav", + "text": "當然是整個人力運用的一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/53.wav", + "text": "我們目前沒有這方面的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/54.wav", + "text": "還沒有這樣一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/55.wav", + "text": "然後去精算的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/56.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/57.wav", + "text": "在臺灣進入超高齡社會情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/58.wav", + "text": "公務人員是否能像勞工一樣與政府協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/59.wav", + "text": "來延後退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/60.wav", + "text": "向委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/61.wav", + "text": "到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/62.wav", + "text": "做到65歲這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/63.wav", + "text": "我們還維持著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/64.wav", + "text": "但是勞工的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/65.wav", + "text": "因為政府機關有一些是勞工身分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/66.wav", + "text": "這部分我們有開放讓他們去做協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/67.wav", + "text": "具有勞工身分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/68.wav", + "text": "我們已經有開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/69.wav", + "text": "讓他可以做協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/70.wav", + "text": "延後退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/71.wav", + "text": "就像我講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/72.wav", + "text": "但是不具有勞工身分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/73.wav", + "text": "或是公兼勞的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/74.wav", + "text": "目前我們是維持著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/75.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分如果要延後的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/76.wav", + "text": "牽涉的議題會很複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/77.wav", + "text": "我希望要有更多的對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/78.wav", + "text": "大家有形成共識再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/79.wav", + "text": "因為那不是只影響到公務機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/80.wav", + "text": "還有勞工的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/81.wav", + "text": "你覺得正式的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/82.wav", + "text": "國家有必要調整這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/83.wav", + "text": "讓大家來好好做檢討嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/84.wav", + "text": "民進黨委員說55歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/85.wav", + "text": "以上就是壯世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/86.wav", + "text": "代55歲到65歲才10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/87.wav", + "text": "這個方向有必要大家來檢討嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/88.wav", + "text": "你給我回答這樣就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/89.wav", + "text": "其實我們內部有檢討啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/90.wav", + "text": "所以你覺得這是有必要的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/91.wav", + "text": "大家要做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/92.wav", + "text": "一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/93.wav", + "text": "一定要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/94.wav", + "text": "所以這也牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/95.wav", + "text": "我們今天要審的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/96.wav", + "text": "基本上是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/97.wav", + "text": "是的都有相交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/98.wav", + "text": "是啦是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/99.wav", + "text": "你這個相交插講得太好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/100.wav", + "text": "他剛才講這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/101.wav", + "text": "這個有相交插的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/102.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/103.wav", + "text": "對國家來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/104.wav", + "text": "不是一件好事所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/105.wav", + "text": "是很密切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/106.wav", + "text": "很直接的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/107.wav", + "text": "實在要用比較多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/108.wav", + "text": "大家來好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/109.wav", + "text": "讓比較好優質的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/110.wav", + "text": "繼續在65歲以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/111.wav", + "text": "可以留在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/112.wav", + "text": "和政府裡面一起來打拚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/113.wav", + "text": "接下來有關計算的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/114.wav", + "text": "就必須重新再做一個調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/115.wav", + "text": "有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157943/116.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/0.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/2.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/3.wav", + "text": "部長今天我們委員會是討論公務人員退休資遣撫卹法第37條的修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/4.wav", + "text": "我必須用很嚴正的態度來表達我們的基本立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/5.wav", + "text": "那是經過各界的努力總算在2017年完成了年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/6.wav", + "text": "我想這已經不只是制度的改革更是世代正義的實踐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/7.wav", + "text": "現在如果要貿然停止這個退休所得替代率的調降機制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/8.wav", + "text": "我認為這並不是一個負責任的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/9.wav", + "text": "\n我們來看一下數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/10.wav", + "text": "部長你的報告已經很清楚地說明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/11.wav", + "text": "現在退休公務人員七成以上的平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/12.wav", + "text": "實支月退休所得超過5萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/13.wav", + "text": "高俸點的退休者是高達6到8萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/14.wav", + "text": "也就是說大概可以到達現職公務人員平均月薪的八成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/15.wav", + "text": "這樣子的退休所得水準是否有如部分主張者所說的不足以維持基本生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/16.wav", + "text": "我想以這個數字當然每個人對什麼叫基本生活的定義不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/17.wav", + "text": "不過我相信以國人一般的基本生活來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/18.wav", + "text": "一個退休人員來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/19.wav", + "text": "如果你問我的話我應該自己不會用到那麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/20.wav", + "text": "我認為這是對公務人員過去對國家付出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/21.wav", + "text": "那我想都有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/22.wav", + "text": "所以接下來我們必須要正視的是退撫基金有沒有辦法讓財務永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/23.wav", + "text": "如果現在我們就貿然終止替代率的調降機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/24.wav", + "text": "根據你們的評估未來50年是不是會減少2,800億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/25.wav", + "text": "沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/26.wav", + "text": "基金用完的時間是提前幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/27.wav", + "text": "提前4到5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/28.wav", + "text": "對嘛那這樣子也有沒有辦法永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/29.wav", + "text": "當然會對永續有很大的一個衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/30.wav", + "text": "就會有問題在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/31.wav", + "text": "嘛其實任何的政策就是希望有它的延續性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/32.wav", + "text": "包含公務人員也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/33.wav", + "text": "政府必須要有完整的評估以及充分的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/34.wav", + "text": "如果我們只是單純的想要去討好某一個族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/35.wav", + "text": "讓某一個族群在某些狀況之下支持我們的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/36.wav", + "text": "那就是沒有全局觀嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/37.wav", + "text": "所以我在這邊還是希望任何制度的變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/38.wav", + "text": "都要有完整的評估跟充分的社會對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/39.wav", + "text": "把這樣的事情全部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/40.wav", + "text": "我也認為要繼續這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/41.wav", + "text": "\n第一個確保退撫基金財務的永續性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/42.wav", + "text": "是不可以短期的訴求來犧牲基金的長期健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/43.wav", + "text": "第二個我也要特別在這個地方再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/44.wav", + "text": "我們必須要兼顧每一個世代的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/45.wav", + "text": "不可以讓年輕的公務人員來承擔過重的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/46.wav", + "text": "\n最後就是我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/47.wav", + "text": "有一個完整的財務影響評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/48.wav", + "text": "才可以讓我們有機會來跨黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/49.wav", + "text": "跨世代的充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/50.wav", + "text": "因為我們不是只要針對一個世代讓一個世代好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/51.wav", + "text": "我們希望每一個世代都共榮共好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/52.wav", + "text": "所以面對年金制度這個這麼嚴重的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/53.wav", + "text": "我們不能夠在缺乏完整評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/54.wav", + "text": "及專業意見諮詢的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/55.wav", + "text": "甚至沒有在社會充分的對話之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/56.wav", + "text": "我們就貿然的通過修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/57.wav", + "text": "這樣的倉促決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/58.wav", + "text": "我認為會直接動搖整個年改的根基" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/59.wav", + "text": "所以我是希望如果可以的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/60.wav", + "text": "可以組成專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/61.wav", + "text": "我們邀請相關的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/62.wav", + "text": "學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/63.wav", + "text": "還有各年齡層的公務人員代表來做研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/64.wav", + "text": "改革的路應該是非常不容易的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/65.wav", + "text": "但是我們希望每一個人都要為我們自己的下一代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/66.wav", + "text": "留下一個更永續的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157942/67.wav", + "text": "這才是一個負責的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/1.wav", + "text": "有請銓敘部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/2.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/3.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/4.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/5.wav", + "text": "辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/6.wav", + "text": "應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/7.wav", + "text": "我來立法院5年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/8.wav", + "text": "我在進來的第一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/9.wav", + "text": "有參與一個修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/10.wav", + "text": "叫做退休年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/11.wav", + "text": "納入年改前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/12.wav", + "text": "已具有育嬰留職停薪年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/13.wav", + "text": "但是沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/14.wav", + "text": "\n我隔年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/15.wav", + "text": "又參與了一個修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/16.wav", + "text": "叫做公立學校教職員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/17.wav", + "text": "退休資遣撫卹條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/18.wav", + "text": "現職公教人員與勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/19.wav", + "text": "私校教職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/20.wav", + "text": "在退撫給與扣稅的規定一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/21.wav", + "text": "軍公教人員退休退役後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/22.wav", + "text": "轉任私校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/23.wav", + "text": "仍然可以領到退休俸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/24.wav", + "text": "俸另外一個部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/25.wav", + "text": "公務人員退休資遣撫卹法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/26.wav", + "text": "它的效果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/27.wav", + "text": "軍公教及政務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/28.wav", + "text": "每個月繳付的退撫基金費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/29.wav", + "text": "比照勞工和私校教職員不課稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/30.wav", + "text": "並回溯至110年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/31.wav", + "text": "1月1日起算\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/32.wav", + "text": "\n我再隔年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/33.wav", + "text": "又參與了一個修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/34.wav", + "text": "它的效果就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/35.wav", + "text": "退撫基金法制化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/36.wav", + "text": "讓我們的基金永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/37.wav", + "text": "我又有參與一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/38.wav", + "text": "公教人員比照一般勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/39.wav", + "text": "每個月提撥退撫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/40.wav", + "text": "而且免稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/41.wav", + "text": "那是公教退撫基金財務缺口撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/42.wav", + "text": "我講這些就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/43.wav", + "text": "推動完成這個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/44.wav", + "text": "讓現職公教人員得以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/45.wav", + "text": "與勞工私校教職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/46.wav", + "text": "在退撫給與扣稅的規定一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/47.wav", + "text": "\n好我以上講的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/48.wav", + "text": "部長您都熟悉吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/49.wav", + "text": "我是5月才任職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/50.wav", + "text": "不過這些改變我印象中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/51.wav", + "text": "大部分都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/52.wav", + "text": "好為什麼我要講這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/53.wav", + "text": "我是要讓您知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/54.wav", + "text": "我覺得它如果是一個好的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/55.wav", + "text": "我們能夠做的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/56.wav", + "text": "可以看國家經濟的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/57.wav", + "text": "政府的財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/58.wav", + "text": "跟退撫基金準備率的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/59.wav", + "text": "其實我一直以來主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/60.wav", + "text": "是可以微調的對吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/61.wav", + "text": "我想這個是不是要微調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/62.wav", + "text": "我們就是根據財務的一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/63.wav", + "text": "我剛才唸的那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/64.wav", + "text": "都是三讀通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/65.wav", + "text": "我知道就是一個立法政策的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/66.wav", + "text": "對所以我們一直以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/67.wav", + "text": "這樣一個微調的狀況前進對吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/68.wav", + "text": "不過這邊的調整基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/69.wav", + "text": "並不涉及基金根本的財務狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/70.wav", + "text": "是所以是微調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/71.wav", + "text": "我們把一些可以調得過來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/72.wav", + "text": "還是儘量地把它優化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/73.wav", + "text": "讓法條更好對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/74.wav", + "text": "好那我就要請教您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/75.wav", + "text": "其實我經常面對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/76.wav", + "text": "就是人家問我一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/77.wav", + "text": "唉呀政府說年金會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/78.wav", + "text": "所以軍公教人員感受很不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/79.wav", + "text": "請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/80.wav", + "text": "是政府在騙人嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/81.wav", + "text": "我想不是在騙人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/82.wav", + "text": "這是根據精算算出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/83.wav", + "text": "那他們自己也會精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/84.wav", + "text": "他們算的結果跟我們不一樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/85.wav", + "text": "遊說團體經常來哦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/86.wav", + "text": "他們也很會精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/87.wav", + "text": "精算本身需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/88.wav", + "text": "有非常精確的事實資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/89.wav", + "text": "然後透過一些統計模型去計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/90.wav", + "text": "好部長我要說的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/91.wav", + "text": "年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/92.wav", + "text": "如果是一條對的路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/93.wav", + "text": "我們就不需要回頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/94.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得態度是要有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/95.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講微調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/96.wav", + "text": "讓它優化就是一種態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/97.wav", + "text": "我精算就是會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/98.wav", + "text": "人家算就不會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/99.wav", + "text": "我跟你講一個簡單的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/100.wav", + "text": "前天發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/101.wav", + "text": "我碰到一個退役的軍公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/102.wav", + "text": "他說他兩次都沒有選我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/103.wav", + "text": "因為他恨死民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/104.wav", + "text": "做年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/105.wav", + "text": "但是他看到我為他做事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/106.wav", + "text": "為他服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/107.wav", + "text": "他說他釋懷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/108.wav", + "text": "他沒有那麼恨民進黨了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/109.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這個社會溝通的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/110.wav", + "text": "我自己也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/111.wav", + "text": "年金改革持續進行的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/112.wav", + "text": "未來讓公立學校的教職員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/113.wav", + "text": "跟私校教職員一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/114.wav", + "text": "可以選擇何時提領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/115.wav", + "text": "這是我們的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/116.wav", + "text": "國家其實沒有犧牲軍警公教的利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/117.wav", + "text": "仍然透過許多的修法來保障跟優化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/118.wav", + "text": "可以微調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/119.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們要做好社會溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/120.wav", + "text": "蒐集民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/121.wav", + "text": "部長您的看法如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/122.wav", + "text": "是我希望我們就這個公聽會來辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/123.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/124.wav", + "text": "好好謝謝部長謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157941/125.wav", + "text": "\n現在請謝龍介委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/0.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/2.wav", + "text": "我們的主張是要持續進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/3.wav", + "text": "因為我們希望年金可以永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/4.wav", + "text": "但是非常的遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/5.wav", + "text": "在野黨提出來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/6.wav", + "text": "是要讓年金改革中止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/7.wav", + "text": "那現在我們最擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/8.wav", + "text": "今天銓敘部你們給出來的意見是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/9.wav", + "text": "你們也認為年金改革應該要繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/10.wav", + "text": "最主要的原因是什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/11.wav", + "text": "我想不繼續的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/12.wav", + "text": "傷害的是現職的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/13.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/14.wav", + "text": "因為基金會提早用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/15.wav", + "text": "所以你就領不到錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/16.wav", + "text": "會提早4到5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/17.wav", + "text": "還沒有退休的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/18.wav", + "text": "或者最近這幾年進來的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/19.wav", + "text": "他們可能到時候都會碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/20.wav", + "text": "這個很嚴肅的課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/21.wav", + "text": "就是說我們的年金會提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/22.wav", + "text": "未來這些公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/23.wav", + "text": "等到他退休的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/24.wav", + "text": "他就領不到退休金了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/25.wav", + "text": "而這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/26.wav", + "text": "現在就中止的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/27.wav", + "text": "會提早4到5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/28.wav", + "text": "我們年金就會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/29.wav", + "text": "有沒有預估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/30.wav", + "text": "受影響的人數是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/31.wav", + "text": "這個倒沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/32.wav", + "text": "112年才是新進的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/33.wav", + "text": "所以現在在職的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/34.wav", + "text": "應該都是在這個基金裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/35.wav", + "text": "有36萬的公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/36.wav", + "text": "我在猜大概有33人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/37.wav", + "text": "專戶可能是兩萬多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/38.wav", + "text": "新進的專戶大概兩萬多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/39.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/40.wav", + "text": "所以影響的人數是非常大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/41.wav", + "text": "而公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/42.wav", + "text": "是我們國家運作的根本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/43.wav", + "text": "啊不只是臺灣面臨到這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/44.wav", + "text": "還有世界各國我們立法機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/45.wav", + "text": "應該要來支持政府的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/46.wav", + "text": "因為政府不是為我們運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/47.wav", + "text": "也不是為你們運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/48.wav", + "text": "是為人民去服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/49.wav", + "text": "\n我另外請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/50.wav", + "text": "我們從開始進行年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/51.wav", + "text": "從75%開始降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/52.wav", + "text": "嘛我們是逐年調降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/53.wav", + "text": "調到現在我們替代率是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/54.wav", + "text": "現在是67.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/55.wav", + "text": "%我們的目標值是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/56.wav", + "text": "如果35年年資就是60" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/57.wav", + "text": "我們目標值最終是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/58.wav", + "text": "調降到60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/59.wav", + "text": "但是即便到我們的目標60" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/60.wav", + "text": "%其實我們還是比OECD國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/61.wav", + "text": "平均所得替代率還來得高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/62.wav", + "text": "因為OECD國家平均所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/63.wav", + "text": "在57%到58%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/64.wav", + "text": "替代率要調降到多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/65.wav", + "text": "不是任意決定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/66.wav", + "text": "這是符合國際的一個趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/67.wav", + "text": "還沒有達到國際的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/68.wav", + "text": "所以我想我們是要去持續進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/69.wav", + "text": "60%是名目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/70.wav", + "text": "實質上是比60%高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/71.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/72.wav", + "text": "當然都有權提出法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/73.wav", + "text": "但是這個數字的計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/74.wav", + "text": "還是要有一個科學的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/75.wav", + "text": "然後也要符合國際的趨勢跟潮流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/76.wav", + "text": "而我們正在進行中的年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/77.wav", + "text": "其實就是符合這樣的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/78.wav", + "text": "\n另外我也希望釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/79.wav", + "text": "過去這幾年我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/80.wav", + "text": "4年來總共節省了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/81.wav", + "text": "2,774億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/82.wav", + "text": "這些錢用到哪裡去了統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/83.wav", + "text": "統統回給基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/84.wav", + "text": "所以這些省下來的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/85.wav", + "text": "並不是說政府部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/86.wav", + "text": "拿去作為他途來用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/87.wav", + "text": "他們未來的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/88.wav", + "text": "除了這個以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/89.wav", + "text": "我們的公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/90.wav", + "text": "每年是不是還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/91.wav", + "text": "因為我們實施新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/92.wav", + "text": "所以目前大概累計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/93.wav", + "text": "撥補了294億左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/94.wav", + "text": "是明年我們預計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/95.wav", + "text": "明年的預算是194億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/96.wav", + "text": "明年我們預計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/97.wav", + "text": "要撥補給退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/98.wav", + "text": "也就是公務人員未來的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/99.wav", + "text": "是194億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/100.wav", + "text": "我也是要再次的呼籲在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/101.wav", + "text": "因為撥補的公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/102.wav", + "text": "194億就是中央的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/103.wav", + "text": "現在在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/104.wav", + "text": "第一個還在擋總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/105.wav", + "text": "第二個在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/106.wav", + "text": "版本的財劃法修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/107.wav", + "text": "會讓中央的預算少了幾千億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/108.wav", + "text": "所以我相當地擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/109.wav", + "text": "撥補給退撫基金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/110.wav", + "text": "因為這是一個大水庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/111.wav", + "text": "一樣是在職公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/112.wav", + "text": "他往後退休的福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/113.wav", + "text": "所以我希望不分黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/114.wav", + "text": "大家要一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/115.wav", + "text": "做全體公務人員的後盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/116.wav", + "text": "因為他們跟我們一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/117.wav", + "text": "都是為人民來服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157940/118.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/0.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/1.wav", + "text": "我們想到了在蔡英文執政的第2年開始啟動年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/2.wav", + "text": "在當時召開公聽會包括由總統府陳建仁當時是副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/3.wav", + "text": "十幾場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/4.wav", + "text": "可能到20場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/5.wav", + "text": "有將近20場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/6.wav", + "text": "在立法院也開了不少的場次甚至立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/7.wav", + "text": "當時還決定說到各縣市可能都需要再多加溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/8.wav", + "text": "所以在當時整個年改的過程中第一個充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/9.wav", + "text": "第二個整合各方的意見然後達到一個衡平的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/10.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟在年金改革的過程中當然被改革的人心裡會痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/11.wav", + "text": "他會覺得自己的年金被減少了心裡會痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/12.wav", + "text": "這個我們都可以感受得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/13.wav", + "text": "但是總是經過了年改這一段這麼痛苦的過程\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/14.wav", + "text": "從馬英九的時代就已經確定年改是臺灣必定要走的一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/15.wav", + "text": "但是馬英九政府沒有辦法把年改順利推動下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/16.wav", + "text": "終於在蔡英文總統的時候完成了年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/17.wav", + "text": "確保我們臺灣的年金有30年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/18.wav", + "text": "當然如果財政狀況更好有可能再持續更久對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/19.wav", + "text": "我覺得這件事情事實上提案的這些委員他們話都講一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/20.wav", + "text": "當然物價指數有調所以是不是對現任的公務員也有給他調薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/21.wav", + "text": "當然我們調了累計快14%如果明年的加薪有通過累計會有14%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/22.wav", + "text": "所以加上明年這3%因為現在總預算還沒過嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/23.wav", + "text": "所以如果這個也加進來的話會有14%就是現職的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/24.wav", + "text": "就是說年改以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/25.wav", + "text": "對年改後調了14%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/26.wav", + "text": "對已經退休的呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/27.wav", + "text": "調了6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/28.wav", + "text": "也調了6%嘛所以這就是一個重點嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/29.wav", + "text": "至少對退休的人國家應該要予以照顧的在現職的有調薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/30.wav", + "text": "也調整了6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/31.wav", + "text": "也調整了6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/32.wav", + "text": "所以這是一個重點欸重點就是說事實上公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/33.wav", + "text": "除了是比較特殊的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/34.wav", + "text": "不然的話他經過調薪縱使有年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/35.wav", + "text": "事實上已經把他的傷害降到最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/36.wav", + "text": "結果現在這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/37.wav", + "text": "就是讓這些過去可能被年改的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/38.wav", + "text": "部長我覺得這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/39.wav", + "text": "的立場因為你去對公務員嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/40.wav", + "text": "你領導這些公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/41.wav", + "text": "部長你的看法是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/42.wav", + "text": "我覺得年改實施以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/43.wav", + "text": "就像委員剛剛講我們已經往好的方向在走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/44.wav", + "text": "對現職或者是新進的幾年前進來的公務同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/45.wav", + "text": "都有一個安定性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/46.wav", + "text": "知道他未來的退休金是怎麼一個運作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/47.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該繼續讓這一條路往下走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/48.wav", + "text": "這才是對所有公務同仁好的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/49.wav", + "text": "部長我覺得站在政府照顧公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/50.wav", + "text": "這個都是毋庸置疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/51.wav", + "text": "比方說現在工程類科的公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/52.wav", + "text": "他會覺得他的薪資比民間少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/53.wav", + "text": "所以行政院在今年7月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/54.wav", + "text": "在軍中的士官長也是有這樣的續服獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/55.wav", + "text": "對然後這幾年也提高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/56.wav", + "text": "警勤加給也提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/57.wav", + "text": "所以這是政府可以去做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/58.wav", + "text": "但是這一些用國家預算做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/59.wav", + "text": "跟基金要去支付的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/60.wav", + "text": "我們基金就是要讓它永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/61.wav", + "text": "嘛政府可以怎麼照顧公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/62.wav", + "text": "我們就繼續來照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/63.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我是覺得年改這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/64.wav", + "text": "我知道主席有答應要召開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/65.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是正確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/66.wav", + "text": "我們再多聽一點廣納多一點聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/67.wav", + "text": "然後在此時此刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/68.wav", + "text": "不要再把會高度造成社會分裂的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/69.wav", + "text": "我覺得在此時此刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/70.wav", + "text": "大家應該對這件事情再三思一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/71.wav", + "text": "\n最後我要稱讚一下主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/72.wav", + "text": "因為我剛剛在內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/73.wav", + "text": "召委座位旁邊有一個按鈕可以消音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/74.wav", + "text": "欸過去我當召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/75.wav", + "text": "我完全不知道有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/76.wav", + "text": "講超過了主席也站起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/77.wav", + "text": "我也準備不說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/78.wav", + "text": "不過你不會把我按消音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/79.wav", + "text": "我在內政委員會被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/80.wav", + "text": "嘛就沒有紀錄了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/81.wav", + "text": "以後看到會議紀錄的人會想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/82.wav", + "text": "所以召委這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/83.wav", + "text": "有尊重大家的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157939/84.wav", + "text": "謝謝蔡委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/0.wav", + "text": "施部長你先喝水沒關係我等你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/1.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/2.wav", + "text": "部長這個議題其實你觀察很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/3.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/4.wav", + "text": "我們當過總統的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/5.wav", + "text": "說出年金改革如果不改現在不改以後就會後悔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/6.wav", + "text": "是從哪一任總統開始的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/7.wav", + "text": "今天很多人提到這應該是馬英九總統的時候就開始做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/8.wav", + "text": "馬總統當時英明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/9.wav", + "text": "他就希望要做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/10.wav", + "text": "因為當時我記得國際氛圍是希臘的危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/11.wav", + "text": "希臘的退休公務人員去翻垃圾桶找漢堡的那一張相片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/12.wav", + "text": "刊在全球媒體上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/13.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/14.wav", + "text": "因為他們的年金制度破產了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/15.wav", + "text": "我答應你要給多少破產了你就領不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/16.wav", + "text": "還有他們曾經對解放軍的一些承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/17.wav", + "text": "也因為財務出問題承諾的東西做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/18.wav", + "text": "所以年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/19.wav", + "text": "我相信不同政黨執政的時候能夠不動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/20.wav", + "text": "大家都希望不要動它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/21.wav", + "text": "但是從馬英九當總統開始就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/22.wav", + "text": "不管是軍保公教人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/23.wav", + "text": "如果當時不進行改革的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/24.wav", + "text": "可能會面臨破產的危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/25.wav", + "text": "\n現在當然有人說要把它都改回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/26.wav", + "text": "如果現在把它改回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/27.wav", + "text": "因為制度已經變革了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/28.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有概算過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/29.wav", + "text": "都照原來的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/30.wav", + "text": "年金這個財庫多久會開始變紅字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/31.wav", + "text": "如果改回去大概在135年會歸零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/32.wav", + "text": "135年嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/33.wav", + "text": "差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/34.wav", + "text": "就歸零了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/35.wav", + "text": "那受傷害的是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/36.wav", + "text": "當然是包括現職人員還有已經退休的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/37.wav", + "text": "同樣都會受傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/38.wav", + "text": "我坦白講已退休人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/39.wav", + "text": "我們應該照顧他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/40.wav", + "text": "可是現職人員我正在繳保費欸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/41.wav", + "text": "甚至於我即將要退了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/42.wav", + "text": "尤其現在如果你的年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/43.wav", + "text": "你大概計畫10年後要退的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/44.wav", + "text": "你聽到要改回去應該要擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/45.wav", + "text": "啊因為當你退的時候歸零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/46.wav", + "text": "甚至於領不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/47.wav", + "text": "而且我們年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/48.wav", + "text": "不管是軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/49.wav", + "text": "事實上民國84年85年改過一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/50.wav", + "text": "現在的公務人員也沒有18%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/51.wav", + "text": "軍公教本來就沒有18%優存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/52.wav", + "text": "退休制度那一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/53.wav", + "text": "已退的恩給制的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/54.wav", + "text": "可以領到超過100%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/55.wav", + "text": "所以讓當時剛就職的軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/56.wav", + "text": "領得比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/57.wav", + "text": "軍人把樓地板面積定在40%嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/58.wav", + "text": "民國85年那個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/59.wav", + "text": "啊那時候說沒有人反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/60.wav", + "text": "廢話都還沒任官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/61.wav", + "text": "因為85年以後的還沒任官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/62.wav", + "text": "當然沒有人反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/63.wav", + "text": "所以拿以後的軍公教的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/64.wav", + "text": "去補貼以前這個恩給制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/65.wav", + "text": "是84年85年發生的事嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/66.wav", + "text": "然後當時這樣子一黨獨大的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/67.wav", + "text": "後來發現這個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/68.wav", + "text": "新的人民國85年以後的軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/69.wav", + "text": "他的福利本來就沒有18%優存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/70.wav", + "text": "他的退休制度也比較正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/71.wav", + "text": "他繳的錢反而要去支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/72.wav", + "text": "過去恩給制的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/73.wav", + "text": "所以形成了不改不行的危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/74.wav", + "text": "而且是從馬政府第一任期的末端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/75.wav", + "text": "就發現這個問題很大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/76.wav", + "text": "可是他推不動啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/77.wav", + "text": "到蔡英文政府的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/78.wav", + "text": "好不容易推動了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/79.wav", + "text": "然後現在慢慢穩定下來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/80.wav", + "text": "還要去攪動它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/81.wav", + "text": "其實傷害的反而是軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/82.wav", + "text": "\n本席當時是負責軍人年金改革的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/83.wav", + "text": "軍改當時的滿意度達到98%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/84.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/85.wav", + "text": "我們不僅要財務平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/86.wav", + "text": "我們還要改變說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/87.wav", + "text": "還在工作的領得比退休的人還少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/88.wav", + "text": "其實軍改當時還有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/89.wav", + "text": "跟公教不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/90.wav", + "text": "我們把樓地板面積從40%調高到55%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/91.wav", + "text": "當時我們算過現職中校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/92.wav", + "text": "因為制度改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/93.wav", + "text": "因為我們改變了制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/94.wav", + "text": "他退休的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/95.wav", + "text": "月退反而增加1萬2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/96.wav", + "text": "就是那15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/97.wav", + "text": "而軍人跟公教人員不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/98.wav", + "text": "可以做到65歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/99.wav", + "text": "軍人如果升了少校20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/100.wav", + "text": "我升不上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/101.wav", + "text": "停留年限滿就強制離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/102.wav", + "text": "他不是想做幾年就做幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/103.wav", + "text": "工作時間長度不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/104.wav", + "text": "他的工作內容也不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/105.wav", + "text": "所以當時把它調到55%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/106.wav", + "text": "然後每多1年加2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/107.wav", + "text": "對已退的老學長們影響很小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/108.wav", + "text": "因為我們那時候的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/109.wav", + "text": "連80歲以上都不變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/110.wav", + "text": "去當工友技工的不變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/111.wav", + "text": "去私立學校兼職的雙餉不變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/112.wav", + "text": "都已經做到最小影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/113.wav", + "text": "最大照顧及財務衡平\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/114.wav", + "text": "現在因為政治的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/115.wav", + "text": "都不去看內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/116.wav", + "text": "去翻動攪動它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/117.wav", + "text": "到最後受害的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/118.wav", + "text": "現在可能已經年近中壯年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/119.wav", + "text": "軍公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/120.wav", + "text": "甚至於新進的軍公教人員繳的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/121.wav", + "text": "可能未來要支付這被恢復的錢坑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/122.wav", + "text": "這件事情不是政治問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/123.wav", + "text": "這件事情也不應該有黨派之分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/124.wav", + "text": "這件事情是國家永續發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/125.wav", + "text": "照顧所有公職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/126.wav", + "text": "很重要的一個使命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/127.wav", + "text": "所以我真的希望包含召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/128.wav", + "text": "包含不同黨派的同伴們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/129.wav", + "text": "這件事情不應該拿出來政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/130.wav", + "text": "它既不道德而且很危險謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/131.wav", + "text": "謝謝王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/132.wav", + "text": "因為今天登記發言到67位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/133.wav", + "text": "所以我們比較重視時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157938/134.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/1.wav", + "text": "麻煩人事總處蘇人事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/2.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/3.wav", + "text": "我的父親93歲他是公務員退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/4.wav", + "text": "讓他覺得生活很舒適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/5.wav", + "text": "當然有的人會覺得需要改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/6.wav", + "text": "不過我相信以我父親" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/7.wav", + "text": "來說他是真的很感謝國家給他的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/8.wav", + "text": "\n我要跟兩位請教的是有關於整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/9.wav", + "text": "國人健檢資料強化落實預防醫學的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/10.wav", + "text": "各位會覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/11.wav", + "text": "我為什麼會請教兩位這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/12.wav", + "text": "我本身是一個臨床醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/13.wav", + "text": "所以對這個健康檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/14.wav", + "text": "其實國民健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/15.wav", + "text": "包括公務員的健康也是很重要的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/16.wav", + "text": "所以今天特別利用這個時間來請教兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/17.wav", + "text": "包括蘇人事長和施部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/18.wav", + "text": "\n因為健康元年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/19.wav", + "text": "我們今年要開始針對健康的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/20.wav", + "text": "打造健康台灣非常非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/21.wav", + "text": "我們過去也發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/22.wav", + "text": "只有六成多四成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/23.wav", + "text": "多大家都覺得自己身體很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/24.wav", + "text": "不用去做什麼檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/25.wav", + "text": "銓敘部在107年的時候就注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/26.wav", + "text": "公務人員有四大死因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/27.wav", + "text": "第一個是癌症" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/28.wav", + "text": "第二個是心臟病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/29.wav", + "text": "第三個是自殺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/30.wav", + "text": "第四個是肺部疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/31.wav", + "text": "這四個病都是可避免造成死亡的疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/32.wav", + "text": "就是說如果我們平常有在注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/33.wav", + "text": "有在做健康檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/34.wav", + "text": "知道有這個過程的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/35.wav", + "text": "就有機會去減少這樣的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/36.wav", + "text": "導致他的死亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/37.wav", + "text": "這是107年的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/38.wav", + "text": "\n考試院針對這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/39.wav", + "text": "也希望銓敘部能夠有更多的瞭解跟注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/40.wav", + "text": "針對公務人員進行健檢的分析掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/41.wav", + "text": "我這裡跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/42.wav", + "text": "我們現在整個健檢的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/43.wav", + "text": "變得比以前更有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/44.wav", + "text": "一般是一年健檢一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/45.wav", + "text": "我們現在允許他有兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/46.wav", + "text": "因為一年的檢查項目一般比較有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/47.wav", + "text": "可以改成兩年檢查一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/48.wav", + "text": "他可以做的檢查項目會比較周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/49.wav", + "text": "而且也有往年齡比較年輕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/50.wav", + "text": "大概四十幾歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/51.wav", + "text": "讓他們也可以提早去做健檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/52.wav", + "text": "大概這幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/53.wav", + "text": "我們也做了很多的調整與改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/54.wav", + "text": "所以事實上都有在幫我們公務同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/55.wav", + "text": "做這些把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/56.wav", + "text": "好謝謝因為我們也知道目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/57.wav", + "text": "很多的健檢資料分布在不同的族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/58.wav", + "text": "包括勞工學生國人及公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/59.wav", + "text": "依照這個防護辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/60.wav", + "text": "或者是實施要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/61.wav", + "text": "他會去做健康檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/62.wav", + "text": "的部分對象需要提報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/63.wav", + "text": "檢查結果這個提報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/64.wav", + "text": "公立醫院及學校中的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/65.wav", + "text": "必須要提報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/66.wav", + "text": "就是說你如果有不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/67.wav", + "text": "你就要去提報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/68.wav", + "text": "給相關機關作處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/69.wav", + "text": "\n最後想要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/70.wav", + "text": "的就是政府機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/71.wav", + "text": "針對這些健康檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/72.wav", + "text": "除了補助以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/73.wav", + "text": "因為現在都是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/74.wav", + "text": "各個機關的年度預算支應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/75.wav", + "text": "嘛支應的過程提報的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/76.wav", + "text": "就會有一些資料運用的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/77.wav", + "text": "允不允許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/78.wav", + "text": "未來把這一些公務人員相關的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/79.wav", + "text": "也能夠納為全民在做保健的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/80.wav", + "text": "一個重要的運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/81.wav", + "text": "這部分就要麻煩考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/82.wav", + "text": "及人事總處提供資料和研商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/83.wav", + "text": "包括有沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/84.wav", + "text": "讓它跟衛福部的資料可以銜接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/85.wav", + "text": "他要是有不正常或是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/86.wav", + "text": "在健康的保護上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/87.wav", + "text": "可以有更大的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/88.wav", + "text": "這部分可不可以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/89.wav", + "text": "部長跟人事長也多用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/90.wav", + "text": "啦跟這邊來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/91.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157937/92.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席有請施部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/1.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/2.wav", + "text": "施部長如果根據原來年改的��容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/3.wav", + "text": "遞延的所得替代率最後是60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/4.wav", + "text": "對對法律上是講60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/5.wav", + "text": "法律上到60%的情況底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/6.wav", + "text": "但是我們以實際的本俸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/7.wav", + "text": "我們是用本俸的2倍嘛乘以2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/8.wav", + "text": "它其實大概是實支薪資的1.8倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/9.wav", + "text": "如果這樣計算起來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/10.wav", + "text": "我們現在想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/11.wav", + "text": "但是以我們這種基數的換算方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/12.wav", + "text": "差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/13.wav", + "text": "要看每一個人退休的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/14.wav", + "text": "到底是年功俸還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/15.wav", + "text": "對當然有些微的差異啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/16.wav", + "text": "但是我必須說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/17.wav", + "text": "因為你這個基數的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/18.wav", + "text": "基本上有比較優惠的計算方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/19.wav", + "text": "當初是這樣設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/20.wav", + "text": "對有技術上的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/21.wav", + "text": "所以它的所得替代率看起來是60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/22.wav", + "text": "其實是70%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/23.wav", + "text": "我請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/24.wav", + "text": "OECD國家一般退休的所得替代率大概是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/25.wav", + "text": "在年改進行的時候有一個統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/26.wav", + "text": "我印象中大概在53%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/27.wav", + "text": "對大概是50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/28.wav", + "text": "好那就我們勞工的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/29.wav", + "text": "你知道現在所得替代率大概多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/30.wav", + "text": "我知道勞保大概是一萬多塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/31.wav", + "text": "平均大概一萬多塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/32.wav", + "text": "那勞退可能因為它實施還沒有很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/33.wav", + "text": "實施比較短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/34.wav", + "text": "勞退是2005年實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/35.wav", + "text": "它比較短所以可能不會那麼多以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/36.wav", + "text": "勞保最高投保金額來換算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/37.wav", + "text": "我跟你講事實上它約莫連四成都不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/38.wav", + "text": "現在1萬8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/39.wav", + "text": "所以說相對其他職業別而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/40.wav", + "text": "我們現在即便年改之後的70%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/41.wav", + "text": "它是一個社會安全網的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/42.wav", + "text": "你覺得70%夠不夠你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/43.wav", + "text": "我比較傾向回過頭來看他實際上拿多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/44.wav", + "text": "因為談錢才知道說我夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/45.wav", + "text": "你要談絕對額當然也是一種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/46.wav", + "text": "但是每一個人的絕對額不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/47.wav", + "text": "對因為那個是就每個人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/48.wav", + "text": "因為每個人絕對額不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/49.wav", + "text": "但是我們都拿平均值來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/50.wav", + "text": "OECD國家來做比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/51.wav", + "text": "我們明明已經多人家兩成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/52.wav", + "text": "你認為夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/53.wav", + "text": "我們真的是比人家高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/54.wav", + "text": "另外一個我要就教於您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/55.wav", + "text": "所得替代率是70%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/56.wav", + "text": "而不是降到60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/57.wav", + "text": "這樣子你說50年會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/58.wav", + "text": "變成是少撥了2,800億對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/59.wav", + "text": "然後另外一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/60.wav", + "text": "你還有一個現實的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/61.wav", + "text": "事實上你112年7月開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/62.wav", + "text": "新進人員就用個人帳戶制了不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/63.wav", + "text": "你這部分也少挹注了對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/64.wav", + "text": "就是由另外一部分─政府在挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/65.wav", + "text": "對那現在可以預估的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/66.wav", + "text": "是提前到131年破產對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/67.wav", + "text": "這兩個合計的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/68.wav", + "text": "這兩個合起來就提早到131年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/69.wav", + "text": "但是政府會不會負最終責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/70.wav", + "text": "應該這樣講現在法律規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/71.wav", + "text": "那個新制的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/72.wav", + "text": "政府一定要先分年撥補完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/73.wav", + "text": "沒有我就問這個舊制的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/74.wav", + "text": "有有提到說要負最終責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/75.wav", + "text": "如果回到最終責任的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/76.wav", + "text": "那你應該預估出來錢多少啊不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/77.wav", + "text": "剛講現在基金潛藏負債2.9兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/78.wav", + "text": "2.9兆我請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/79.wav", + "text": "以50年來換算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/80.wav", + "text": "每年政府要多支出多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/81.wav", + "text": "相當多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/82.wav", + "text": "大概五百零多億對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/83.wav", + "text": "剛剛兩千八百零多億我給你算過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/84.wav", + "text": "就是56億了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/85.wav", + "text": "啦如果每年因為這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/86.wav", + "text": "政府要多五百多億的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/87.wav", + "text": "那我跟你講依照國民黨的財劃法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/88.wav", + "text": "本來可以自有的資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/89.wav", + "text": "一千多億你再拿掉五百五十多億的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/90.wav", + "text": "所以潛藏的事實我覺得其實你也把這個數字展露出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/91.wav", + "text": "變成整個國家的財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/92.wav", + "text": "根本無法負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/93.wav", + "text": "最終你要承擔最終責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/94.wav", + "text": "額結果最終責任額是政府最終責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/95.wav", + "text": "額是來自於它的財務能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/96.wav", + "text": "政府沒有財務能力的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/97.wav", + "text": "如何保障這些軍公教人員的退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/98.wav", + "text": "如何確保他的社會安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/99.wav", + "text": "如何確保他老年之後的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/100.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157936/101.wav", + "text": "部長麻煩這部分再強調一下謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/0.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/2.wav", + "text": "部長辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/3.wav", + "text": "站了一整天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/4.wav", + "text": "應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/5.wav", + "text": "我們來說一些一般人可能比較聽得懂的話好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/6.wav", + "text": "知道在看這個題目的時候可以怎麼理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/7.wav", + "text": "如果真的照藍白的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/8.wav", + "text": "到底會發生什麼事情\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/9.wav", + "text": "在第一個提案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/10.wav", + "text": "他們建議從113年1月開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/11.wav", + "text": "或者是114年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/12.wav", + "text": "停止退休所得替代率降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/13.wav", + "text": "那你們的建議是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/14.wav", + "text": "你可不可以用我們一般人聽得懂的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/15.wav", + "text": "回答如果真的如他們的條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/16.wav", + "text": "會對國家的財政造成什麼樣的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/17.wav", + "text": "會對世代之間的爭議產生什麼樣的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/18.wav", + "text": "如果停止適用的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/19.wav", + "text": "必須憂慮這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/20.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/21.wav", + "text": "對於現職公務人員來說看起來也會造成影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/22.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/23.wav", + "text": "所以我們不能拿我們以為現在有很多很多錢的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/24.wav", + "text": "去照顧那些已經退休的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/25.wav", + "text": "\n如果對現職公務人員的福利也都會造成影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/26.wav", + "text": "那我們再假設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/27.wav", + "text": "再4年再8年再12年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/28.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/29.wav", + "text": "會造成什麼樣的連動效應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/30.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/31.wav", + "text": "這筆基金如果一直就這樣停在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/32.wav", + "text": "不光是破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/33.wav", + "text": "我也不曉得財源要從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/34.wav", + "text": "我覺得這也是一般國人想聽到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/35.wav", + "text": "就是現在根本不知道財源在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/36.wav", + "text": "可是看起來就要做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/37.wav", + "text": "了也如同剛才許智傑委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/38.wav", + "text": "的如果之後財劃法也修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/39.wav", + "text": "所有中央的錢都到地方去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/40.wav", + "text": "那目前討論的這個基金應該也會受到影響嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/41.wav", + "text": "行政院的餅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/42.wav", + "text": "沒有變大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/43.wav", + "text": "卻有很多事情要做的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/44.wav", + "text": "每一個人可以分到的餅理論上當然會更小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/45.wav", + "text": "啦一定會排擠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/46.wav", + "text": "好所以看起來其實是非常簡單的數學公式問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/47.wav", + "text": "本來餅有這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/48.wav", + "text": "可是有人說這裡要多挖一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/49.wav", + "text": "這裡再多拿一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/50.wav", + "text": "這裡也要多爭取一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/51.wav", + "text": "最後中央可以用的資源就剩下這麼多的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/52.wav", + "text": "確實會造成影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/53.wav", + "text": "\n那我剛剛說的世代爭議部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/54.wav", + "text": "呢你們有聽取過相關不同年齡層的意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/55.wav", + "text": "就一定要由全民負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/56.wav", + "text": "嘛全民負擔就等於是下一代的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/57.wav", + "text": "要跟著負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/58.wav", + "text": "所以這一定有世代的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/59.wav", + "text": "這樣好了銓敘部長我再問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/60.wav", + "text": "喔我自己有2個小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/61.wav", + "text": "現在一個大一一個高一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/62.wav", + "text": "你就用這兩個孩子來舉例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/63.wav", + "text": "上如果真的如同藍白的法案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/64.wav", + "text": "我這兩個小孩以後要背負多少事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/65.wav", + "text": "當然我們沒有具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/66.wav", + "text": "不過很肯定的一件事情就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/67.wav", + "text": "政府要撥更多錢進入這個基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/68.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/69.wav", + "text": "那政府的錢從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/70.wav", + "text": "就是我的小孩即將出去工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/71.wav", + "text": "就是大家要負擔啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/72.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/73.wav", + "text": "所以這個邏輯看起來其實沒有很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/74.wav", + "text": "\n那我們再用白話文來講另外一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/75.wav", + "text": "也許一般人也會很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/76.wav", + "text": "就是為什麼他們會有這個提案呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/77.wav", + "text": "在一項提案裡他們主張針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/78.wav", + "text": "警消海巡入出國境管理跟移民事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/79.wav", + "text": "防止人口販運人員及執行空中任務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/80.wav", + "text": "將退休所得替代率增加到90%為上限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/81.wav", + "text": "他們特別把某些業種給拉出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/82.wav", + "text": "以您的評估是為了什麼原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/83.wav", + "text": "以我理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/84.wav", + "text": "但是現在的制度設計就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/85.wav", + "text": "針對在現職的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/86.wav", + "text": "如果只是因為這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/87.wav", + "text": "這對其他人員完全不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/88.wav", + "text": "因為基金本身強調一個最基本的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/89.wav", + "text": "所有人繳同樣的費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/90.wav", + "text": "用同樣的公式來計算那個給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/91.wav", + "text": "這才是公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/92.wav", + "text": "所以您最後的這一句話其實也是簡單的數學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/93.wav", + "text": "嘛大家繳一樣的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/94.wav", + "text": "用一樣的費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/95.wav", + "text": "所以應該分配到一樣的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/96.wav", + "text": "好謝謝銓敘部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/97.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157935/98.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/0.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/1.wav", + "text": "部長好我剛才以為人事長怎麼又回來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/2.wav", + "text": "但人事長坐在底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/3.wav", + "text": "我是說現在要請他上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/4.wav", + "text": "\n接續剛才吳秉叡委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/5.wav", + "text": "但我要問的可能部長也很難回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/6.wav", + "text": "我也滿希望公務員年金改革可以回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/7.wav", + "text": "啊但是財政OK嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/8.wav", + "text": "我很希望勞保基金可以撥補進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/9.wav", + "text": "如果是正常勞工正常退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/10.wav", + "text": "我真的希望可以領2萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/11.wav", + "text": "元國家可以幫忙嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/12.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償現在是6萬元對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/13.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們對原住民應該更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/14.wav", + "text": "給他們10萬元啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/15.wav", + "text": "這樣國家可以負擔嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/16.wav", + "text": "原住民津貼每個月4,00" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/17.wav", + "text": "0元我也覺得我們應對原住民更好那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/18.wav", + "text": "可不可以給2萬元呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/19.wav", + "text": "好像都很好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/20.wav", + "text": "大家都在臺灣土生土長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/21.wav", + "text": "如果原住民領2萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/22.wav", + "text": "元老人也希望領2萬元啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/23.wav", + "text": "可不可以做到呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/24.wav", + "text": "老農年金現在一個月八千多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/25.wav", + "text": "國家可不可以給我呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/26.wav", + "text": "部長你是不是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/27.wav", + "text": "當然這個問題太大了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/28.wav", + "text": "你畢竟不是總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/29.wav", + "text": "如果今天問的是總統的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/30.wav", + "text": "不管是國民黨或民進黨的當總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/31.wav", + "text": "大家都想要把所有人民不分族群地照顧好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/32.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/33.wav", + "text": "才能夠把孩子都照顧好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/34.wav", + "text": "把不同族群都照顧好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/35.wav", + "text": "我們沒有辦法針對某一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/36.wav", + "text": "而是要做整體的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/37.wav", + "text": "比如說我是年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/38.wav", + "text": "差不多三四千塊而已嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/39.wav", + "text": "還是內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/40.wav", + "text": "內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/41.wav", + "text": "三四千塊怎麼夠在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/42.wav", + "text": "最少也要1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/43.wav", + "text": "元那可以給我1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/44.wav", + "text": "元嗎\n現在私立大專院校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/45.wav", + "text": "但其實還不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/46.wav", + "text": "我也想再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/47.wav", + "text": "中低收入戶呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/48.wav", + "text": "每個月也只發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/49.wav", + "text": "一萬多元吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/50.wav", + "text": "要生活可能也不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/51.wav", + "text": "還有很多邊緣戶喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/52.wav", + "text": "又沒有半毛錢可以補助我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/53.wav", + "text": "我我只有房子老了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/54.wav", + "text": "孩子又不孝順" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/55.wav", + "text": "那政府也應該給我兩萬元吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/56.wav", + "text": "我是要讓國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/57.wav", + "text": "藍白的朋友們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/58.wav", + "text": "尤其是藍白的立委諸公想想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/59.wav", + "text": "今天如果你是大家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/60.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣讓所有資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/61.wav", + "text": "照顧到所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/62.wav", + "text": "族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/63.wav", + "text": "針對年金改革我就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/64.wav", + "text": "如果今天國家只有一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/65.wav", + "text": "財務要分配就是針對年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/66.wav", + "text": "其實我也滿贊成的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/67.wav", + "text": "但是我要再一次呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/68.wav", + "text": "在馬英九總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/69.wav", + "text": "說要推動年金改革的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/70.wav", + "text": "他也說不能把問題留給下一任總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/71.wav", + "text": "蔡英文總統說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/72.wav", + "text": "愈是困難的改革就愈要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/73.wav", + "text": "有承擔的勇氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/74.wav", + "text": "2016年黃國昌說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/75.wav", + "text": "全力支持當時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/76.wav", + "text": "年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/77.wav", + "text": "2019年柯文哲也說這是20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/78.wav", + "text": "前就應該處理的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/79.wav", + "text": "結果現在更嚴重的是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/80.wav", + "text": "藍白還要用財劃法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/81.wav", + "text": "刪掉中央6,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/82.wav", + "text": "增加卻要把政府的錢剝掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/83.wav", + "text": "是要叫國家怎麼運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/84.wav", + "text": "我覺得真的很沉痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/85.wav", + "text": "啦藍白立委同事們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/86.wav", + "text": "各大族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157934/87.wav", + "text": "對於這件事情我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/0.wav", + "text": "主席麻煩請施部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/1.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/2.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/3.wav", + "text": "部長關於退撫制度的沿革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/4.wav", + "text": "從開始到現在也經過了很多次轉變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/5.wav", + "text": "跟屢次改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/6.wav", + "text": "中有哪一次是沒有經過行政機關提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/7.wav", + "text": "沒有對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/8.wav", + "text": "由立法院立法委員單獨提案來做這項變革的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/9.wav", + "text": "以我的理解印象中沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/10.wav", + "text": "沒有啦我爸爸也跟我講沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/11.wav", + "text": "中不光只有錢的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/12.wav", + "text": "而是涉及憲政結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/13.wav", + "text": "關於立法院在我們中華民國孫文先生所訂的五權憲法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/14.wav", + "text": "有行政權跟立法權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/15.wav", + "text": "在今年年初舉行的其實是2項選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/16.wav", + "text": "總統的選舉屬於行政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/17.wav", + "text": "立法院是國會的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/18.wav", + "text": "行政權的核心其實說穿了只有2個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/19.wav", + "text": "一個��是人事一個就是經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/20.wav", + "text": "立法權則是做審議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/21.wav", + "text": "如果行政權不能決定人事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/22.wav", + "text": "也不能決定經費要怎麼支用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/23.wav", + "text": "那這個行政權就是名存實亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/24.wav", + "text": "嘛所以過去為什麼要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/25.wav", + "text": "就是因為過去無論退撫制度如何沿革如何訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/26.wav", + "text": "都是由行政機關提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/27.wav", + "text": "經立法院審議通過之後實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/28.wav", + "text": "剛剛前面的委員也有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/29.wav", + "text": "啊無論國民黨執政或民進黨執政都有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/30.wav", + "text": "認為年金制度應該怎麼改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/31.wav", + "text": "都是由行政機關提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/32.wav", + "text": "行政權每年要花多少費用放在退撫上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/33.wav", + "text": "如果立法院沒有經過行政機關的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/34.wav", + "text": "就自己立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/35.wav", + "text": "行政權得乖乖聽我的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/36.wav", + "text": "繼續做下去呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/37.wav", + "text": "你對這點有什麼樣的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/38.wav", + "text": "了解委員的所有講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/39.wav", + "text": "不得為增加預算支出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/40.wav", + "text": "都要先徵詢行政院的意思之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/41.wav", + "text": "以我的理解是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/42.wav", + "text": "對\n另外現在還有一項什麼財政紀律法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/43.wav", + "text": "賴士葆委員還很得意說是他通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/44.wav", + "text": "他認為是他非常得意的成績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/45.wav", + "text": "這跟預算法其實很相近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/46.wav", + "text": "裡面就講到若" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/47.wav", + "text": "若要為增加預算的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/48.wav", + "text": "必須講財源要從那裡來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/49.wav", + "text": "但現在的講法是我就是要你多出啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/50.wav", + "text": "財源行政機關要給我擠出來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/51.wav", + "text": "我管你什麼原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/52.wav", + "text": "不然國家就多印錢嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/53.wav", + "text": "全民來承擔啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/54.wav", + "text": "超級的通貨膨脹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/55.wav", + "text": "就讓全民來負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/56.wav", + "text": "這個後果啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/57.wav", + "text": "我覺得今天若要討論這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/58.wav", + "text": "微調的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/59.wav", + "text": "不涉及金額的部分可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/60.wav", + "text": "沒有經過行政機關的研究研討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/61.wav", + "text": "我覺得太可怕了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/62.wav", + "text": "��樣要是可以的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/63.wav", + "text": "以後在每一個地方都可以亂來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/64.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/65.wav", + "text": "我如果很同情勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/66.wav", + "text": "又糾集了一半以上立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/67.wav", + "text": "為什麼就只有他們可以加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/68.wav", + "text": "我們不能加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/69.wav", + "text": "這樣國家要如何進行下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/70.wav", + "text": "我們的憲政要如何維繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/71.wav", + "text": "這個議題可能比光講要花多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/72.wav", + "text": "幾年會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/73.wav", + "text": "以我讀法律的人而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/74.wav", + "text": "這是國家憲政結構的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/75.wav", + "text": "所以我請你們要慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/76.wav", + "text": "不能亂答應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/77.wav", + "text": "亂答應是違憲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157933/78.wav", + "text": "加油謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/2.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/3.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/4.wav", + "text": "部長下午好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/5.wav", + "text": "你好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/6.wav", + "text": "我想針對今天的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/7.wav", + "text": "就是基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/8.wav", + "text": "債會不會留給現任公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/9.wav", + "text": "我們從這一張表裡頭來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/10.wav", + "text": "其實是橫跨了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/11.wav", + "text": "不管是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/12.wav", + "text": "會不會造成提前5年破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/13.wav", + "text": "退撫基金預估可以用到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/14.wav", + "text": "甚至有更多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/15.wav", + "text": "可是請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/16.wav", + "text": "預計會提前多久破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/17.wav", + "text": "我相信從早上到現在已經非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/18.wav", + "text": "就是再4年或5年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/19.wav", + "text": "可能就會破產了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/20.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/21.wav", + "text": "對於這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/22.wav", + "text": "大家都知道非常地嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/23.wav", + "text": "現在的公務人員是不是要提撥更多基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/24.wav", + "text": "嘛如果最後沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/25.wav", + "text": "但我們不希望走這樣的選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/26.wav", + "text": "站在保護所有現職公務人員的角度來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/27.wav", + "text": "了啦而法律上限現在是18%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/28.wav", + "text": "嘛站在我們部裡面的立場是完全不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/29.wav", + "text": "走提高提撥費率這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/30.wav", + "text": "部長如果超過18%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/31.wav", + "text": "啊可不可以這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/32.wav", + "text": "破產就提早5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/33.wav", + "text": "如果我們不想讓這件事發生的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/34.wav", + "text": "就要窮盡各種可能的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/35.wav", + "text": "那你們現在想到的各種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/36.wav", + "text": "提高繳交的費率要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/37.wav", + "text": "不然就是政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/38.wav", + "text": "要用納稅人的錢挹注進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/39.wav", + "text": "萬一轉投資失敗的話怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/40.wav", + "text": "長期投資的平均報酬率還是維持在5%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/41.wav", + "text": "我們的責任我們一定要努力做好投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/42.wav", + "text": "累積的財務缺口太大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/43.wav", + "text": "投資效益可以解決這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/44.wav", + "text": "部長有沒有做最壞的打算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/45.wav", + "text": "站在銓敘部的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/46.wav", + "text": "不能現在先想最壞的打算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/47.wav", + "text": "我們要努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/48.wav", + "text": "所以希望按照這樣的年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/49.wav", + "text": "持續走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/50.wav", + "text": "這是最好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/51.wav", + "text": "可是最壞的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/52.wav", + "text": "呢如果最壞的情況發生的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/53.wav", + "text": "你會採取什麼樣的樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/54.wav", + "text": "最壞的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/55.wav", + "text": "我相信你們在部裡頭絕對有討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/56.wav", + "text": "嘛包含地板天花板不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/57.wav", + "text": "完全朝著西線無戰事的方式討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/58.wav", + "text": "應該這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/59.wav", + "text": "現在的法律當然明文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/60.wav", + "text": "政府一定會對基金負最後的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/61.wav", + "text": "啦但是以負責任的經營基金者來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/62.wav", + "text": "應該窮盡各種可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/63.wav", + "text": "對於所有基金的運作包括現在參與的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/64.wav", + "text": "還有政府本來也有角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/65.wav", + "text": "都要努力做好這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/66.wav", + "text": "真的迫不得已才走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/67.wav", + "text": "其實這件事大家都很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/68.wav", + "text": "可是國民黨為了自己的選票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/69.wav", + "text": "這是我們大家非常擔心的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/70.wav", + "text": "我在這裡非常謝謝部長的答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/71.wav", + "text": "詢也謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157932/72.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席有請施部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/1.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/2.wav", + "text": "部長我想年金改革是我們必須進行而且無可迴避的國家政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/3.wav", + "text": "所以民進黨政府很負責任我們提出了年金改革的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/4.wav", + "text": "造成退休以後領得比上班還多這個畸形現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/5.wav", + "text": "所以他們這一次聽到國民黨立委提出這樣的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/6.wav", + "text": "也覺得不可思議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/7.wav", + "text": "不只是能保障他們所得替代率很好的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/8.wav", + "text": "而且是為了確保年金改革這個制度實行之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/9.wav", + "text": "所以他們都希望民進黨所有立委一定要站在這個立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/10.wav", + "text": "因為我們好不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/11.wav", + "text": "做到當初基金的財務面臨很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/12.wav", + "text": "所以推動年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/13.wav", + "text": "至少讓它可以延後一個世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/14.wav", + "text": "罄在這個過程裡大家一起努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/15.wav", + "text": "我覺得既然已經有了成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/16.wav", + "text": "我想我們過去很負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/17.wav", + "text": "跟充分的政策討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/18.wav", + "text": "但很遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/19.wav", + "text": "我想任何試圖逆轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/20.wav", + "text": "都是不負責任的政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/21.wav", + "text": "他們如何逼迫下一代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/22.wav", + "text": "一旦又走回頭路的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/23.wav", + "text": "未來我們的下一代就必須面臨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/24.wav", + "text": "而且也會讓社會每一個世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/25.wav", + "text": "年金改革不是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/26.wav", + "text": "是將軍公教跟非軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/27.wav", + "text": "我想這樣不甚公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/28.wav", + "text": "啦部長有什麼看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/29.wav", + "text": "我們根據部裡面的專業分析報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/30.wav", + "text": "還是認為年金改革的步調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/31.wav", + "text": "應該按照現在的法律制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/32.wav", + "text": "是所以我們期待年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/33.wav", + "text": "不是只解決現在的財政問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/34.wav", + "text": "更應該建立一個長期穩定的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/35.wav", + "text": "定期評估這樣改革的效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/36.wav", + "text": "進行政策微調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/37.wav", + "text": "部長是否贊成這樣的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/38.wav", + "text": "第一次把相關數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/39.wav", + "text": "非常負責任地給國人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/40.wav", + "text": "我想這是提供公共討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/41.wav", + "text": "對���以本席還是要強烈呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/42.wav", + "text": "國家財政穩健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/43.wav", + "text": "跟世代公平的基石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/44.wav", + "text": "我們必須堅持推進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/45.wav", + "text": "拒絕倒退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/46.wav", + "text": "年改修法跟政策調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/47.wav", + "text": "確保改革的公平跟永續性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/48.wav", + "text": "我想這也是關係到全國國民福祉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/49.wav", + "text": "對於這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/50.wav", + "text": "不管是行政院或立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157931/51.wav", + "text": "啦好部長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/0.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/2.wav", + "text": "今天司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/3.wav", + "text": "是針對幾位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/4.wav", + "text": "提出的公務人員退休資遣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/5.wav", + "text": "撫卹法相關條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/6.wav", + "text": "修正草案進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/7.wav", + "text": "就是針對之前的年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/8.wav", + "text": "他們希望再把它恢復就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/9.wav", + "text": "是不是這就是這幾個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/10.wav", + "text": "當初推動年金改革中的主要措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/11.wav", + "text": "大概這次都變成修正的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/12.wav", + "text": "對啊就是要再把它翻案就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/13.wav", + "text": "也就是改回去走回頭路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/14.wav", + "text": "關於當年進行年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/15.wav", + "text": "為什麼會推動這樣的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/16.wav", + "text": "是不是可以簡單講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/17.wav", + "text": "關於推動這個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/18.wav", + "text": "就已經先做精算提出預警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/19.wav", + "text": "指出如果不做改革的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/20.wav", + "text": "那為什麼會造成這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/21.wav", + "text": "因為繳得少領得多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/22.wav", + "text": "然後也很早就可以領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/23.wav", + "text": "啦所以所有措施都是針對這3項來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/24.wav", + "text": "那時候退休的人中有些人領得比現職人員還多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/25.wav", + "text": "繳的錢不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/26.wav", + "text": "如果繳的錢不足以支付領的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/27.wav", + "text": "撫基金就是一座大水庫的理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/28.wav", + "text": "基於剛剛部長講的這三個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/29.wav", + "text": "讓退撫基金可以永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/30.wav", + "text": "──之後的年輕世代公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/31.wav", + "text": "也可以獲得保障嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/32.wav", + "text": "嘛\n我們來回想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/33.wav", + "text": "自己也���過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/34.wav", + "text": "如果我們今天不推動改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/35.wav", + "text": "軍人退撫基金會在2019年破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/36.wav", + "text": "教職退撫基金會和勞保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/37.wav", + "text": "會在2027年破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/38.wav", + "text": "而公職退撫基金也會在2031年破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/39.wav", + "text": "這是馬英九說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/40.wav", + "text": "然後他也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/41.wav", + "text": "下任總統或下下任總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/42.wav", + "text": "遲早都會碰到這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/43.wav", + "text": "社會在這段期間也會長期惶恐不安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/44.wav", + "text": "所以他也是主張進行年金改革的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/45.wav", + "text": "他也講得很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/46.wav", + "text": "可是他沒有能力做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/47.wav", + "text": "他只會嘴巴講講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/48.wav", + "text": "沒有能力做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/49.wav", + "text": "我們民進黨執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/50.wav", + "text": "我們也知道這是很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/51.wav", + "text": "所以我們回應基層的民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/52.wav", + "text": "背負著得罪公務人員選票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/53.wav", + "text": "我們仍推動這項改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/54.wav", + "text": "那時候我已經在立法院了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/55.wav", + "text": "在北中南東辦了很多公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/56.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/57.wav", + "text": "我記得至少有10場以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/58.wav", + "text": "很多場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/59.wav", + "text": "我也參加過包括主持臺東的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/60.wav", + "text": "對我們也是經過非常充分的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/61.wav", + "text": "希望尋求一個比較合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/62.wav", + "text": "可以保障退休公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/63.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我們按照這樣的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/64.wav", + "text": "程在討論之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/65.wav", + "text": "我們也設有樓地板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/66.wav", + "text": "生活能夠得到保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/67.wav", + "text": "嘛我們要追求的就是世代正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/68.wav", + "text": "益\n我們也看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/69.wav", + "text": "休公務人員認為所領的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/70.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/71.wav", + "text": "其實還是高於目前一般勞工所得的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/72.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/73.wav", + "text": "不要昨是今非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/74.wav", + "text": "等於在打他們的臉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157930/75.wav", + "text": "打馬英九總統的臉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/0.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/1.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/2.wav", + "text": "從早上到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/3.wav", + "text": "那我們先來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/4.wav", + "text": "能夠讓大家清楚了解的圖示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/5.wav", + "text": "像一座大水庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/6.wav", + "text": "這個大水庫其實有3個來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/7.wav", + "text": "要提撥嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/8.wav", + "text": "樣現在我們已經用這個大水庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/9.wav", + "text": "軍公教人員的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/10.wav", + "text": "退休所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/11.wav", + "text": "要是停止退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/12.wav", + "text": "挹注退撫基金的資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/13.wav", + "text": "國民黨在財劃法當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/14.wav", + "text": "搶中央的財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/15.wav", + "text": "還有錢可以挹注嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/16.wav", + "text": "對不對\n那我們再來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/17.wav", + "text": "第二個選項好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/18.wav", + "text": "繳納的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/19.wav", + "text": "工作崗位上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/20.wav", + "text": "的以高考三級第六職等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/21.wav", + "text": "本俸一級的薪水來講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/22.wav", + "text": "要繳到將近3,700元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/23.wav", + "text": "大概是7%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/24.wav", + "text": "%以這個7%來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/25.wav", + "text": "照我們剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/26.wav", + "text": "的如果要停止降低就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/27.wav", + "text": "挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/28.wav", + "text": "對現職人員確實會有衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/29.wav", + "text": "不可行第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/30.wav", + "text": "如果要現職人員繳納更多金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/31.wav", + "text": "看起來也不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/32.wav", + "text": "那我們來找第三個解方好了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/33.wav", + "text": "第三個解方有可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/34.wav", + "text": "延後退休年齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/35.wav", + "text": "那我們要不要延後退休的年齡呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/36.wav", + "text": "我們知道從111年起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/37.wav", + "text": "年資至少要15年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/38.wav", + "text": "已經一律增加到65歲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/39.wav", + "text": "法律已經這樣規定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/40.wav", + "text": "嘛就是這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/41.wav", + "text": "嘛請問有人要延後退休嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/42.wav", + "text": "現職公務人員可能會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/43.wav", + "text": "很不一樣的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/44.wav", + "text": "好\n接下來我要提到另外一個問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/45.wav", + "text": "現行退休所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/46.wav", + "text": "對於公務人員的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/47.wav", + "text": "有沒有一些影響呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/48.wav", + "text": "或者對於勞工來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/49.wav", + "text": "說有沒有相對被剝奪感呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/50.wav", + "text": "──只要他已經退休了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/51.wav", + "text": "有七成月領退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/52.wav", + "text": "將近5萬1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/53.wav", + "text": "勞工月領退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/54.wav", + "text": "都已經退休之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/55.wav", + "text": "軍公教所領的錢將近5萬1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/56.wav", + "text": "1另外在勞工部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/57.wav", + "text": "他們每個月領的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/58.wav", + "text": "退休金是3萬8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/59.wav", + "text": "這裡有沒有產生相對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/60.wav", + "text": "被剝奪感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/61.wav", + "text": "如果勞工對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/62.wav", + "text": "還自己覺得沒有被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/63.wav", + "text": "剝奪感那真的叫做佛心來的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/64.wav", + "text": "更不用講跟現職軍公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/65.wav", + "text": "平均薪資是四萬六千多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/66.wav", + "text": "塊還不到剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/67.wav", + "text": "軍公教退休後的5萬1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/68.wav", + "text": "勞工會不會跳腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/69.wav", + "text": "有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/70.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/71.wav", + "text": "我的詢問就到這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157929/72.wav", + "text": "讓大家去想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/0.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/1.wav", + "text": "辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/2.wav", + "text": "有這樣的時間討論這些案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/3.wav", + "text": "畢竟我們最近討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/4.wav", + "text": "的違憲跟國家安全相關案子實在是太多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/5.wav", + "text": "難得可以針對一些比較重要的議題來做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/6.wav", + "text": "現在都回來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/7.wav", + "text": "我覺得也算有一種親切感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/8.wav", + "text": "啦\n我第一件事想先問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/9.wav", + "text": "目前來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/10.wav", + "text": "假設破產時間是抓到140年左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/11.wav", + "text": "那麼會受影響的公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/12.wav", + "text": "還是只有現在即將退休的公務員會受到比較大的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/13.wav", + "text": "基金當然會影響到現在已經退休者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/14.wav", + "text": "但是未來也持續有人在退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/15.wav", + "text": "所以現職人員未來當然也會受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/16.wav", + "text": "那麼在這一段時間退休的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/17.wav", + "text": "會是哪一些人受到的影響比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/18.wav", + "text": "這段時間退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/19.wav", + "text": "說真的針��年改完以後退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/20.wav", + "text": "者包括從年改完到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/21.wav", + "text": "以明年再加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/22.wav", + "text": "預計大概14%的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/23.wav", + "text": "本俸就調了14%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/24.wav", + "text": "喔因為物價等而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/25.wav", + "text": "而我們是以本俸乘以2來計算退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/26.wav", + "text": "所以最近這幾年若以剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/27.wav", + "text": "因為隨著調薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/28.wav", + "text": "真的不會是當初核定的那個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/29.wav", + "text": "是非常非常高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/30.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/31.wav", + "text": "因為很多人拿得比之前還要更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/32.wav", + "text": "因為我們對軍人有特別的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/33.wav", + "text": "是因為軍人的基金是獨立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/34.wav", + "text": "跟公教人員不一樣且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/35.wav", + "text": "且軍人役期短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/36.wav", + "text": "意思是我們確實讓他們所得替代率高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/37.wav", + "text": "但是這裡的所得替代率高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/38.wav", + "text": "其實應該這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/39.wav", + "text": "官階大概在中校上校以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/40.wav", + "text": "是因為就軍方來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/41.wav", + "text": "中校上校跟少校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/42.wav", + "text": "啦\n剛好今天也有一個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/43.wav", + "text": "也要提高到甚至90" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/44.wav", + "text": "%也就是這樣的政策要跟軍人比照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/45.wav", + "text": "現在已包含危勞給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/46.wav", + "text": "與退休金裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/47.wav", + "text": "本來就考量這樣的情事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/48.wav", + "text": "但是的確也有這樣的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/49.wav", + "text": "如果跟軍人比較起來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/50.wav", + "text": "警察的計算基礎是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/51.wav", + "text": "警察的計算基礎跟公務人員一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/52.wav", + "text": "裡所以一樣是本俸乘以2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/53.wav", + "text": "但因為警察的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/54.wav", + "text": "我講的警察是指人數最多的警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/55.wav", + "text": "大部分警員退休時是在警正四階" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/56.wav", + "text": "以職等區分可能是在六職等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/57.wav", + "text": "可是我們把它設計成以相當於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/58.wav", + "text": "所以退休金本來就比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/59.wav", + "text": "啦以這個基礎上跟軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/60.wav", + "text": "相較若純粹就實質月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/61.wav", + "text": "月退休金來講不會比軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/62.wav", + "text": "因為有些軍人其實拿得還更低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/63.wav", + "text": "但這裡當然還是牽涉到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/64.wav", + "text": "依照目前國民黨委員提的這些提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/65.wav", + "text": "有可能會造成更不平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/66.wav", + "text": "集中在一些特定的人手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/67.wav", + "text": "譬如說我們在外交及國防委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/68.wav", + "text": "會所做的事情就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/69.wav", + "text": "作一些專業加給等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/70.wav", + "text": "也就是針對一些特定的人去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/71.wav", + "text": "我們都是往那個方向去進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/72.wav", + "text": "現在因應共機擾臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/73.wav", + "text": "一直要飛的那些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/74.wav", + "text": "可能要給一些專業加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/75.wav", + "text": "那我們做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/76.wav", + "text": "會不會也影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/77.wav", + "text": "本俸會不會跟專業加給一起算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/78.wav", + "text": "就是以本俸來調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/79.wav", + "text": "加給是另外一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/80.wav", + "text": "一般不會算到退休金裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/81.wav", + "text": "所以用這樣的方法或許可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/82.wav", + "text": "更能達到一些實質的公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/83.wav", + "text": "在我過去擔任人事長快6年任內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/84.wav", + "text": "其實對軍方這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/85.wav", + "text": "都是用這種方法在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/86.wav", + "text": "這樣也比較合適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/87.wav", + "text": "我看他們也是滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157928/88.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/1.wav", + "text": "請銓敘部施部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/2.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/3.wav", + "text": "陳委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/4.wav", + "text": "部長好辛苦了部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/5.wav", + "text": "根據你們今天提出的報告所載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/6.wav", + "text": "2013年的時候考試院是不是就有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/7.wav", + "text": "退休所得替代率偏高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/8.wav", + "text": "及退休金安全準備不足等等問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/9.wav", + "text": "來提出公務人員退休資遣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/10.wav", + "text": "撫卹法的草案是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/11.wav", + "text": "沒有錯那時候已經有一些精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/12.wav", + "text": "然後發現可能有一些危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/13.wav", + "text": "所以就跟考試院提了草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/14.wav", + "text": "那是不是你們同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/15.wav", + "text": "如果沒有修正的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/16.wav", + "text": "在2030年的時候用對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/17.wav", + "text": "差不多在民國119年民國120年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/18.wav", + "text": "請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/19.wav", + "text": "退撫基金用罄的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/20.wav", + "text": "是不是表示說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/21.wav", + "text": "現任的公務員及退休公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/22.wav", + "text": "都會領不到退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/23.wav", + "text": "是2013年當時執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/24.wav", + "text": "那時候立法院的多數應該是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/25.wav", + "text": "那個時候他們是完全執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/26.wav", + "text": "國民黨完全執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/27.wav", + "text": "但是他們並沒有去正視銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/28.wav", + "text": "罄可能破產的這個嚴重問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/29.wav", + "text": "他們也堅持不願意改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/30.wav", + "text": "也沒有顧到公務員的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/31.wav", + "text": "是一直到2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/32.wav", + "text": "蔡英文政府上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/33.wav", + "text": "發現退撫基金的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/34.wav", + "text": "才提出一系列的年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/35.wav", + "text": "讓退撫基金得以延續到下一個世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/36.wav", + "text": "來保障現任公務員的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/37.wav", + "text": "站在基金管理的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/38.wav", + "text": "很早就提出這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/39.wav", + "text": "那時候的銓敘部也跟考試院提出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/40.wav", + "text": "但是那時候的立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/41.wav", + "text": "並沒有去審理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/42.wav", + "text": "好部長我想請教您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/43.wav", + "text": "在停止調降替代率之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/44.wav", + "text": "退撫基金大概在什麼時候會用完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/45.wav", + "text": "因為提早4到5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/46.wav", + "text": "大概在民國135年前後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/47.wav", + "text": "到時候就等於說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/48.wav", + "text": "現任公務員退休後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/49.wav", + "text": "完全領不到退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/50.wav", + "text": "地喊說要政府撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/51.wav", + "text": "退撫基金依民國112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/52.wav", + "text": "未提存的退休金精算負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/53.wav", + "text": "高達2.9兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/54.wav", + "text": "已經將近我國行政院一年的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/55.wav", + "text": "國民黨他們主張要修財劃法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/56.wav", + "text": "大幅下放給各縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/57.wav", + "text": "也會影響到行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/58.wav", + "text": "所推行的各項政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/59.wav", + "text": "的預算都會受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/60.wav", + "text": "現在又提出停止調降替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/61.wav", + "text": "那等到退撫基金的缺口大了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/62.wav", + "text": "一定會要求行政院來撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/63.wav", + "text": "到時候行政院所推行的各項政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/64.wav", + "text": "是不是全數要停擺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/65.wav", + "text": "我們真的是非常擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/66.wav", + "text": "委員會剛通過學生輔導法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/67.wav", + "text": "跟專輔人力的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/68.wav", + "text": "縮減公私立大學學費差距的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/69.wav", + "text": "青壯世代心理健康支持方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/70.wav", + "text": "以及諸如太空科技AI科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/71.wav", + "text": "啦但這會大幅影響全民的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/72.wav", + "text": "\n部長在你們銓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/73.wav", + "text": "替代率上限僅是名目效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/74.wav", + "text": "其實更應該重視的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/75.wav", + "text": "退休公務員實際領到的月退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/76.wav", + "text": "那我想請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/77.wav", + "text": "現在退休公務員實際領到的月退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/78.wav", + "text": "有沒有減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/79.wav", + "text": "應該這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/80.wav", + "text": "今年來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/81.wav", + "text": "在全部退休人員中已經有七成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/82.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/83.wav", + "text": "愈晚退休的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/84.wav", + "text": "實際上領到的月退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/85.wav", + "text": "112年新退休者的平均月退休金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/86.wav", + "text": "有5.85萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/87.wav", + "text": "元在113年實支退休金所得有多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/88.wav", + "text": "還是高於5.1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/89.wav", + "text": "元\n在少子化時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/90.wav", + "text": "現任公務員未來退休的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/91.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/92.wav", + "text": "因為我們的人口是急遽地下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/93.wav", + "text": "人口愈來愈少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/94.wav", + "text": "要支撐的基金壓力就愈來愈大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/95.wav", + "text": "甚至在退休後恐怕就會面臨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/96.wav", + "text": "其實年金改革的初衷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/97.wav", + "text": "是為了維護基金的永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/98.wav", + "text": "反而是為了整體公務員的退休保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/99.wav", + "text": "也是為了維護現任公務員的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/100.wav", + "text": "國民黨當初不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/101.wav", + "text": "為公務員權益提出改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/102.wav", + "text": "現在我們不能走回頭路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/103.wav", + "text": "我們必須共同維護基金的永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/104.wav", + "text": "重視世代正義才能保障全民的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/105.wav", + "text": "部長你認為呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157927/106.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/0.wav", + "text": "主席各位大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/1.wav", + "text": "麻煩人事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/2.wav", + "text": "部長你很開心喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/3.wav", + "text": "終於可以喝一口水了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/4.wav", + "text": "叫人事長幫你代打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/5.wav", + "text": "北分署發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/6.wav", + "text": "不幸的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/7.wav", + "text": "我們都很不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/8.wav", + "text": "當然這個跟你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/9.wav", + "text": "也有一點相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/10.wav", + "text": "現在已經成為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/11.wav", + "text": "謝分署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/12.wav", + "text": "他在法律上倒打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/13.wav", + "text": "不是只有霸凌的申訴制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/14.wav", + "text": "我特別看到其中有一項是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/15.wav", + "text": "吳姓員工承辦資訊業務的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/16.wav", + "text": "他的直屬長官叫他限期繳出成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/17.wav", + "text": "果事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/18.wav", + "text": "他是一個很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/19.wav", + "text": "而且求好心切的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/20.wav", + "text": "人不是擺爛的那種公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/21.wav", + "text": "因為他很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/22.wav", + "text": "所以他覺得他沒有辦法完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/23.wav", + "text": "辜負了這樣的一個期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/24.wav", + "text": "檢視一下他們那個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/25.wav", + "text": "大家在檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/26.wav", + "text": "他們那個單位的人力配置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/27.wav", + "text": "那個單位業務很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/28.wav", + "text": "也很繁雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/29.wav", + "text": "辦公室裡面有5個人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/30.wav", + "text": "還有其他5個人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/31.wav", + "text": "可是那5個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/32.wav", + "text": "是業務承攬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/33.wav", + "text": "就是勞務承攬的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/34.wav", + "text": "政府用的派遣人員一度很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/35.wav", + "text": "因為派遣人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/36.wav", + "text": "當時的勞動條件非常差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/37.wav", + "text": "所以我們的政府就對外宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/38.wav", + "text": "政府機關零派遣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/39.wav", + "text": "人力人力還是不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/40.wav", + "text": "總額管控了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/41.wav", + "text": "我們都知道勞發署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/42.wav", + "text": "以前大概有八成的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/43.wav", + "text": "是來自於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/44.wav", + "text": "所以其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/45.wav", + "text": "是沒有證照的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/46.wav", + "text": "不專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/47.wav", + "text": "未來的失業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/48.wav", + "text": "幫現在的失業者找工作的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/49.wav", + "text": "以前派遣的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/50.wav", + "text": "要派公司我用你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/51.wav", + "text": "你要接受我的指揮監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/52.wav", + "text": "要聽從我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/53.wav", + "text": "我需要你做什麼你都要配合我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/54.wav", + "text": "我現在命令你叫你要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/55.wav", + "text": "做什麼事情你都要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/56.wav", + "text": "\n以前可以命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/57.wav", + "text": "現在變成勞務承攬就不一樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/58.wav", + "text": "所謂的勞務承攬就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/59.wav", + "text": "的工作都不用做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/60.wav", + "text": "所以對公務人員來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/61.wav", + "text": "從派遣變成勞務承攬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/62.wav", + "text": "不能夠指揮監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/63.wav", + "text": "所以能夠幫忙公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/64.wav", + "text": "解決問題的人手變少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/65.wav", + "text": "而且少很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/66.wav", + "text": "很多單位是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/67.wav", + "text": "一個公務人員指揮6個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/68.wav", + "text": "10個勞務承攬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/69.wav", + "text": "人以前可以指揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/70.wav", + "text": "以前可以指揮派遣公司的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/71.wav", + "text": "現在完全都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/72.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/73.wav", + "text": "大概就分兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/74.wav", + "text": "這些派遣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/75.wav", + "text": "事實上我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/76.wav", + "text": "已經有在內部檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/77.wav", + "text": "因為他們那裡用這種人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/78.wav", + "text": "本身正職公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/79.wav", + "text": "的比例相對低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/80.wav", + "text": "八成都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/81.wav", + "text": "對這個問題我們內部已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/82.wav", + "text": "在討論準備要跟勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/83.wav", + "text": "來討論看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/84.wav", + "text": "他們未來的人力需求是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/85.wav", + "text": "這部分我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/86.wav", + "text": "規劃對他們的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/87.wav", + "text": "的整個組織結構人力需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/88.wav", + "text": "派一個分署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/89.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/90.wav", + "text": "人事長我看你的資歷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/91.wav", + "text": "你���資訊專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/92.wav", + "text": "然後你在國稅局的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/93.wav", + "text": "資歷相當豐富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/94.wav", + "text": "資訊的業務也很熟悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/95.wav", + "text": "在人事總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/96.wav", + "text": "應該也有資訊上管理上的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/97.wav", + "text": "就這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/98.wav", + "text": "你有沒有辦法有更精進的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/99.wav", + "text": "應該是在勞發署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/100.wav", + "text": "署本部或者是在勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/101.wav", + "text": "的資訊處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/102.wav", + "text": "不可以丟給一個四級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/103.wav", + "text": "讓分署來測試某些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/104.wav", + "text": "功能是不是符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/105.wav", + "text": "需求請一個四級機關的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/106.wav", + "text": "直接去做政策規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/107.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/108.wav", + "text": "那個工作指派有一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/109.wav", + "text": "檢討的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/110.wav", + "text": "叫一個四級機關的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/111.wav", + "text": "去做資訊業務把整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/112.wav", + "text": "AI資訊管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/113.wav", + "text": "核心業務丟給四級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/114.wav", + "text": "的一個公務人員去辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/115.wav", + "text": "辦不出來然後才發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/116.wav", + "text": "不幸的事件這是導火線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/117.wav", + "text": "嘛結果三級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/118.wav", + "text": "沒有統整這個需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/119.wav", + "text": "更上面的勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/120.wav", + "text": "也沒有不過這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/121.wav", + "text": "就不歸你管了我比較想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/122.wav", + "text": "這個人事業務我覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/123.wav", + "text": "因為你們就把員額控制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/124.wav", + "text": "增加人事費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/125.wav", + "text": "可是明明都有人事的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/126.wav", + "text": "在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/127.wav", + "text": "你們就覺得還要增加1.5個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/128.wav", + "text": "的年終獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/129.wav", + "text": "還要有很多額外的成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/130.wav", + "text": "所以就用派遣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/131.wav", + "text": "可以省多少到底可以省多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/132.wav", + "text": "我想不通到底可以省" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/133.wav", + "text": "幾成你們有算過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/134.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/135.wav", + "text": "我們政府的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/136.wav", + "text": "是由各種類型的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/137.wav", + "text": "各式各樣的人組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/138.wav", + "text": "不過針對這一次的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/139.wav", + "text": "我們內部已經重新再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/140.wav", + "text": "檢視整個勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/141.wav", + "text": "甚至勞發署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/142.wav", + "text": "我們也會協助他們去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/143.wav", + "text": "我為什麼會問這個問題是因為核心業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/144.wav", + "text": "有些單位的核心業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/145.wav", + "text": "以前是派遣的人在蓋章的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/146.wav", + "text": "有的現在可能是勞務承攬的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/147.wav", + "text": "在蓋章的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/148.wav", + "text": "交給這種人來蓋章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/149.wav", + "text": "他要怎麼去負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/150.wav", + "text": "扛責我就搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/151.wav", + "text": "我們會一併納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/152.wav", + "text": "檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/153.wav", + "text": "又說不可以再增加人事支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/154.wav", + "text": "明明就需要這些人事支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/155.wav", + "text": "卻說不可以增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/156.wav", + "text": "約聘僱也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/157.wav", + "text": "是派遣和勞務承攬的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/158.wav", + "text": "在蓋那個章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/159.wav", + "text": "這樣合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/160.wav", + "text": "約聘僱人員都沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/161.wav", + "text": "我是覺得也是有一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/162.wav", + "text": "主席都已經站起來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/163.wav", + "text": "主席我剛剛把我的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/164.wav", + "text": "講完就已經4分鐘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/165.wav", + "text": "所以要控制一下時間謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/166.wav", + "text": "這樣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/167.wav", + "text": "洗刷我的污名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/168.wav", + "text": "不用10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157926/169.wav", + "text": "我自己自動下台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我們請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/1.wav", + "text": "麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/2.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/3.wav", + "text": "部長辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/4.wav", + "text": "部長我想請教我相信從今天早上到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/5.wav", + "text": "如果照這樣子的版本修改的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/6.wav", + "text": "退撫基金可能會提早破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/7.wav", + "text": "那我想請教如果會提早破產會提早到幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/8.wav", + "text": "以現在來估算大概在民國135年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/9.wav", + "text": "那就提早4到5年左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/10.wav", + "text": "所以其實我要講的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/11.wav", + "text": "應該是在2016年到2017年中間的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/12.wav", + "text": "也透過當時的副總統陳建仁副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/13.wav", + "text": "召開年金改革會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/14.wav", + "text": "一個一個提出討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/15.wav", + "text": "再交由立院來審理修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/16.wav", + "text": "最主要是希望年金能夠永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/17.wav", + "text": "尤其是我們現在是老年化少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/18.wav", + "text": "照剛剛部長講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/19.wav", + "text": "我們的退撫基金可能會提早破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/20.wav", + "text": "那其實對於在職的年輕公務人員是不公平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/21.wav", + "text": "之前也有幾位國民黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/22.wav", + "text": "議是不是用撥補的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/23.wav", + "text": "那我想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/24.wav", + "text": "我認為撥補不是一個永續的好的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/25.wav", + "text": "所以我是不是可以請部長先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/26.wav", + "text": "只要年改每一年度節省下來的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/27.wav", + "text": "全數挹注給年改基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/28.wav", + "text": "所以你可以理解為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/29.wav", + "text": "為只是不用撥補這個字眼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/30.wav", + "text": "每年都有穩定的財源回到基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/31.wav", + "text": "所以才能夠讓基金有更多的錢可以去投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/32.wav", + "text": "然後如果我們投資效益好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/33.wav", + "text": "效益就會更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/34.wav", + "text": "所以就可以穩定那個基金用罄的年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/35.wav", + "text": "如果完全依賴這個撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/36.wav", + "text": "所以用撥補的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/37.wav", + "text": "其實也是用人民的納稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/38.wav", + "text": "所以我認為這不是一個好的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/39.wav", + "text": "如果照目前的現況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/40.wav", + "text": "可以用到民國140年左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/41.wav", + "text": "那當然我們也會去滾動地檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/42.wav", + "text": "受到一些影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/43.wav", + "text": "針對這些退休的公務人員所提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/44.wav", + "text": "問題你們每年有在針對物價指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/45.wav", + "text": "做一個調整嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/46.wav", + "text": "一個就是說當物價指數累積到5%的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/47.wav", + "text": "我們就要調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/48.wav", + "text": "另外即使沒有到5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/49.wav", + "text": "每4年都應該去檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/50.wav", + "text": "所以我們過去67年調整兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/51.wav", + "text": "第一次調整的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/52.wav", + "text": "其實物價指數沒有到5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/53.wav", + "text": "是到4年我們去調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/54.wav", + "text": "第二次是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/55.wav", + "text": "最近幾年物價波動多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/56.wav", + "text": "所以到5%的時候我們就調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/57.wav", + "text": "我想是這樣的一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/58.wav", + "text": "67年前進行年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/59.wav", + "text": "當時執政黨民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/60.wav", + "text": "非常負責任地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/61.wav", + "text": "希望這個年金能夠永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/62.wav", + "text": "很可惜的是國民黨跟民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/63.wav", + "text": "如果在這個時候走回頭路的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/64.wav", + "text": "其實對現任公務人員是不公平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157925/65.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/0.wav", + "text": "有請部長和人事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/2.wav", + "text": "我想請問有關於霸凌申訴機制的建立狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/3.wav", + "text": "就是說昨天卓院長回答媒體提問的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/4.wav", + "text": "有提到人總已經成立了一個通報平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/5.wav", + "text": "近日也會開通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/6.wav", + "text": "但我想要跟部長和人事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/7.wav", + "text": "和人事長來討論一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/8.wav", + "text": "就是說在我們的性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/9.wav", + "text": "在知悉兩年之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/10.wav", + "text": "都還可以去申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/11.wav", + "text": "然後如果是權勢性騷擾的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/12.wav", + "text": "是3年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/13.wav", + "text": "可以申訴可是現在這個只有1年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/14.wav", + "text": "把它調整到和權勢性騷擾的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/15.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/16.wav", + "text": "案件兩年的和三年的我們都同步在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/17.wav", + "text": "我們沒有直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/18.wav", + "text": "了這一個也只是你們修改一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/19.wav", + "text": "就可以去調整的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/20.wav", + "text": "是不是也可以一併跟進呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/21.wav", + "text": "既然實務上已經這樣運作了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/22.wav", + "text": "每一個機關定的不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/23.wav", + "text": "那為什麼會是不一樣呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/24.wav", + "text": "是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/25.wav", + "text": "沒有本來霸凌事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/26.wav", + "text": "就是由服務機關本身第一線去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/27.wav", + "text": "我們人事總處會另外成立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/28.wav", + "text": "也是你們一直慣行的一個模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/29.wav", + "text": "那為什麼現在變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/30.wav", + "text": "又要回到各機關來規範呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/31.wav", + "text": "是不是有可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/32.wav", + "text": "性騷擾案件本來就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/33.wav", + "text": "性騷擾案件本來就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/34.wav", + "text": "對但我們現在講的是霸凌嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/35.wav", + "text": "我們現在講的是霸凌案件是不是可以比照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/36.wav", + "text": "目前還是由服務機關直接處理第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/37.wav", + "text": "如果當事人去申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/38.wav", + "text": "受理機關沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/39.wav", + "text": "就可以循新的管道到人事總處來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/40.wav", + "text": "我們也會收案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/41.wav", + "text": "因為你的申訴機制是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/42.wav", + "text": "沒關係這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/43.wav", + "text": "跟您請教好了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/44.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/45.wav", + "text": "我想要先問一個我們現在比較關注的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/46.wav", + "text": "議題今天來了非常多機關的人事首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/47.wav", + "text": "我想請問一下現場各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/48.wav", + "text": "可不可以舉個手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/49.wav", + "text": "\n今天有滿多單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/50.wav", + "text": "警政署消防署移民署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/51.wav", + "text": "可以舉手嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/52.wav", + "text": "\n都沒有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/53.wav", + "text": "因為我想說我這邊收到滿多通報的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/54.wav", + "text": "如果都沒有是有點離譜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/55.wav", + "text": "好謝謝請放下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/56.wav", + "text": "\n那我想問一下現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/57.wav", + "text": "關於這個機制的建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/58.wav", + "text": "我想問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/59.wav", + "text": "現在你們在調查期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/60.wav", + "text": "可以暫時調離現職嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/61.wav", + "text": "可以要求先請假接受調查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/62.wav", + "text": "如果你們現在有做這些事情的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/63.wav", + "text": "我想請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/64.wav", + "text": "你們的法令依據又是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/65.wav", + "text": "可以用的工具又是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/66.wav", + "text": "你們都沒有告訴各機關人事單位這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/67.wav", + "text": "我想要請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/68.wav", + "text": "如果現在各個機關都有用這些手段的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/69.wav", + "text": "法令依據到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/70.wav", + "text": "他們現在可以使用這些依據嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/71.wav", + "text": "可以使用這些工具嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/72.wav", + "text": "行為人被調查期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/73.wav", + "text": "除非是有重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/74.wav", + "text": "沒有的話就是繼續任用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/75.wav", + "text": "我覺得現在大家都有點頭痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/76.wav", + "text": "他們並不是那麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/77.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能在一個月以內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/78.wav", + "text": "建立因應調查霸凌機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/79.wav", + "text": "建立所需要的一些相關法令依據跟工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/80.wav", + "text": "我們有訂一些遵循的規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/81.wav", + "text": "因為目前在法律上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/82.wav", + "text": "沒有一條法律有針對霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/83.wav", + "text": "沒錯那我們是不是可以來研擬呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/84.wav", + "text": "因為這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/85.wav", + "text": "我覺得各個部會各個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/86.wav", + "text": "現在處理的霸凌案非常之多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/87.wav", + "text": "我想不只是勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/88.wav", + "text": "行政院內部會先討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/89.wav", + "text": "行政院內部討論完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/90.wav", + "text": "會跟考試院再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/91.wav", + "text": "要在哪一個法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/92.wav", + "text": "因為有法的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/93.wav", + "text": "大家在執行上會比較有所遵循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/94.wav", + "text": "瞭解一下那現在的進度呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/95.wav", + "text": "因為聽起來你們有在討論你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/96.wav", + "text": "預計什麼時候會完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/97.wav", + "text": "因為我想現在大家都非常需要這一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/98.wav", + "text": "套法就是你剛剛講的這個法這個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/99.wav", + "text": "有一個時間表嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/100.wav", + "text": "通知所有行政院相關機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/101.wav", + "text": "按照指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/102.wav", + "text": "權責是在所有服務機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/103.wav", + "text": "機關本身第一線都要去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/104.wav", + "text": "不可能所有的案件都集中在我們當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/105.wav", + "text": "當然我們現在講的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/106.wav", + "text": "因為現在這些法令依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/107.wav", + "text": "基本上是沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/108.wav", + "text": "的剛剛你說你們有在討論嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/109.wav", + "text": "我想是分三個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/110.wav", + "text": "第一個是指引的告知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/111.wav", + "text": "第二個是建立一個申訴平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/112.wav", + "text": "第三個是法律依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/113.wav", + "text": "我們大概會按照這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/114.wav", + "text": "我現在問的就是法令依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/115.wav", + "text": "你們有一個預計期程嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/116.wav", + "text": "我就簡單回復公務人員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/117.wav", + "text": "我知道考試院的保訓會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/118.wav", + "text": "應該近期也在討論這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/119.wav", + "text": "主要是要去修那邊的相關法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/120.wav", + "text": "或者是那個辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/121.wav", + "text": "好那沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/122.wav", + "text": "是不是可以在一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/123.wav", + "text": "給我們相關的進度報告呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/124.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/125.wav", + "text": "委員因為這個不是我主管的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/126.wav", + "text": "所以我把你的意見帶回去給考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/127.wav", + "text": "好那我了解了謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157924/128.wav", + "text": "謝謝接下來我們請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席主席有請施部長麻煩施部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/1.wav", + "text": "有關於軍公教的年改到現在經過多少年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/2.wav", + "text": "不知道我們銓敘部有沒有委外來做民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/3.wav", + "text": "或者是有沒有掌握到一些民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/4.wav", + "text": "就是真的如同現在國民黨提案委員認為的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/5.wav", + "text": "真的導致了這些退休的軍公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/6.wav", + "text": "造成了他們活不下去嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/7.wav", + "text": "又或者是讓他們的生活上面出現了什麼困難嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/8.wav", + "text": "銓敘部針對這個部分有沒有什麼樣的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/9.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告我們的法律明文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/10.wav", + "text": "調整或者每四年會檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/11.wav", + "text": "並不是沒有調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/12.wav", + "text": "至於每個人退休所得有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/13.wav", + "text": "因為會跟他任職的時候擔任哪一個職等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/14.wav", + "text": "有關算起來的金額會不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/15.wav", + "text": "用社會的角度來講有人可能到現在還是滿高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/16.wav", + "text": "的有人可能比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/17.wav", + "text": "根據我們的報告算出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/18.wav", + "text": "的結果以今年來講所有退休人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/19.wav", + "text": "公務人員這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/20.wav", + "text": "七成左右大概都在5萬元以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/21.wav", + "text": "好言下之意就是其實在當年年改的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/22.wav", + "text": "我們還是有適時反映對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/23.wav", + "text": "沒有錯而且這是全世界幾乎主要國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/24.wav", + "text": "對退休人員所得調整的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/25.wav", + "text": "是所以說本席要讓你看一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/26.wav", + "text": "數據這是我找到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/27.wav", + "text": "在2018年的時候針對軍公教的年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/28.wav", + "text": "當時是55%的民眾滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/29.wav", + "text": "其實還是有六成的民眾覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/30.wav", + "text": "對年改這樣一條改革的道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/31.wav", + "text": "所謂的藍粉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/32.wav", + "text": "當然我覺得藍粉這樣的形容可能很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/33.wav", + "text": "不能真的完全精準地表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/34.wav", + "text": "但是我相信他們就是支持國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/35.wav", + "text": "或者是在政治立場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/36.wav", + "text": "不是支持民進黨的這部分也有38%是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/37.wav", + "text": "最重要的應該就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/38.wav", + "text": "整體來說是不是一個職業的對立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/39.wav", + "text": "它其實是在解決世代差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/40.wav", + "text": "或解決世代上面的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/41.wav", + "text": "其實在臺灣的社會當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/42.wav", + "text": "都可以找到一位軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/43.wav", + "text": "人員像本席家裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/44.wav", + "text": "有人是軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/45.wav", + "text": "也有人是教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/46.wav", + "text": "其實是跟我們全國每一個人都有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/47.wav", + "text": "所以為什麼今天值得在這裡詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/48.wav", + "text": "也希望部長能夠做一些回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/49.wav", + "text": "提供我們更多的資料跟資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/50.wav", + "text": "因為這不只是國家整體的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/51.wav", + "text": "更是接下來年輕世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/52.wav", + "text": "如果要報考公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/53.wav", + "text": "如果要成為教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/54.wav", + "text": "或者是如果要從軍報國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/55.wav", + "text": "他們所擔憂的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/56.wav", + "text": "接下來當他們年資滿了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/57.wav", + "text": "可以退休了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/58.wav", + "text": "要退役的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/59.wav", + "text": "未來他們的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/60.wav", + "text": "有沒有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/61.wav", + "text": "我想部長你也能夠同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/62.wav", + "text": "當時我們從2017年2018" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/63.wav", + "text": "年在推年改的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/64.wav", + "text": "其實想法都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/65.wav", + "text": "我們要解決的是讓年金制度能夠永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/66.wav", + "text": "所以這也是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/67.wav", + "text": "部長應該已經看到不要看了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/68.wav", + "text": "我是第幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/69.wav", + "text": "我是第20個發言的你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/70.wav", + "text": "可能看到第20次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/71.wav", + "text": "馬英九也講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/72.wav", + "text": "雖然說馬英九現在講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/73.wav", + "text": "跟過去講的話不一定是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/74.wav", + "text": "但是這個東西就實實在在地讓人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/75.wav", + "text": "可以感受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/76.wav", + "text": "它不是藍綠的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/77.wav", + "text": "也不是職業別的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/78.wav", + "text": "它是整體世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/79.wav", + "text": "跟整體臺灣人的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/80.wav", + "text": "\n主席站起來了我會儘量遵守時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/81.wav", + "text": "\n當年關中也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/82.wav", + "text": "可不是讓你養尊處優" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/83.wav", + "text": "所以這也是我一開始講的一個命題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/84.wav", + "text": "我也請部長來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/85.wav", + "text": "我找了七職等九職等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/86.wav", + "text": "跟十二職等退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/87.wav", + "text": "跟現役公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/88.wav", + "text": "我們來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/89.wav", + "text": "七職等退休金是5萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/90.wav", + "text": "九職等是6萬3,5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/91.wav", + "text": "我沒有要挑起任何世代上面的差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/92.wav", + "text": "我只是想問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/93.wav", + "text": "以現在這樣的數據跟數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/94.wav", + "text": "這是本就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/95.wav", + "text": "退休公務人員來講這部分是正確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/96.wav", + "text": "沒有算專業加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/97.wav", + "text": "我在猜是這樣一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/98.wav", + "text": "好那麼言下之意就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/99.wav", + "text": "用關中的話來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/100.wav", + "text": "以現在這樣一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/101.wav", + "text": "讓退休的公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/102.wav", + "text": "能夠獲得一定的溫飽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/103.wav", + "text": "獲得一定的生活必需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/104.wav", + "text": "而且要給他尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/105.wav", + "text": "如果依照現行的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/106.wav", + "text": "修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/107.wav", + "text": "然後又改成所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/108.wav", + "text": "不要再往下降的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/109.wav", + "text": "比在工作的領得還要多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/110.wav", + "text": "這也是我們在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/111.wav", + "text": "退休制度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/112.wav", + "text": "退休者所得方案合理化時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/113.wav", + "text": "時特別要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/114.wav", + "text": "這是不好的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/115.wav", + "text": "希望今天我們透過主席安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/116.wav", + "text": "的詢答讓很多事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/117.wav", + "text": "能夠清楚地被社會大眾了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/118.wav", + "text": "因為就像我說的那一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/119.wav", + "text": "每一個人的家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/120.wav", + "text": "都一定找得到一位���公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/121.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望的是整體社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/122.wav", + "text": "過去的爭端爭議不要再起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/123.wav", + "text": "而且在工酬的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/124.wav", + "text": "都是處於合理的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/125.wav", + "text": "也讓退休的軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157923/126.wav", + "text": "人員能夠獲得一定的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/1.wav", + "text": "先請內政部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/2.wav", + "text": "好請劉部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/3.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/4.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/5.wav", + "text": "部長內政部近日有預告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/6.wav", + "text": "村里長慰勞金支給及表揚辦法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/7.wav", + "text": "而且年滿65歲的村里長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/8.wav", + "text": "30萬的慰問金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/9.wav", + "text": "但是本席稍微瞭解過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/10.wav", + "text": "似乎內政部之前針對預算編列的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/11.wav", + "text": "是跟縣市政府地方政府做溝通取得共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/12.wav", + "text": "但是地方的里長都反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/13.wav", + "text": "也建議本席一定要向內政部反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/14.wav", + "text": "你們要跟全國的村里長來溝通座談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/15.wav", + "text": "的合理性來做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/16.wav", + "text": "並且要聽取全國村里長的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/17.wav", + "text": "所以本席希望內政部這邊可以考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/18.wav", + "text": "是不是跟全國的村里長來進行溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/19.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/20.wav", + "text": "有全國村里長的聯誼會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/21.wav", + "text": "另外一個就是我們所謂的預告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/22.wav", + "text": "是預告完成但是還沒公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/23.wav", + "text": "表示說還要再收集意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/24.wav", + "text": "那今天有所以還是有溝通的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/25.wav", + "text": "對很多委員有提到不同的看法跟說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/26.wav", + "text": "我們根據委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/27.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長因為這個事關村里長權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/28.wav", + "text": "然後之後才做定案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/29.wav", + "text": "沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/30.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/31.wav", + "text": "\n請主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/32.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/33.wav", + "text": "主委好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/34.wav", + "text": "主委請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/35.wav", + "text": "您認為高罷免門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/36.wav", + "text": "已經有凝聚社會共識了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/37.wav", + "text": "高罷免門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/38.wav", + "text": "我現在不知道所謂的高是高到什麼樣的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/39.wav", + "text": "但是至少現在的這個標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/40.wav", + "text": "是已經有相當的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/41.wav", + "text": "主委您認為同意票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/42.wav", + "text": "需要超過被罷免人當選票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/43.wav", + "text": "這樣子會不會影響人民的罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/44.wav", + "text": "這樣子的修法真的很抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/45.wav", + "text": "容我說一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/46.wav", + "text": "我是期期以為不可啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/47.wav", + "text": "為什麼期期以為不可呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/48.wav", + "text": "因為它沒有根據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/49.wav", + "text": "這樣子的比較是沒有根據的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/50.wav", + "text": "那主委您認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/51.wav", + "text": "本屆修法本屆就適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/52.wav", + "text": "有沒有自肥的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/53.wav", + "text": "我們還是按照司法院大法官會議解釋的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/54.wav", + "text": "來處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/55.wav", + "text": "但是就這個案子來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/56.wav", + "text": "基本上我認為不要通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/57.wav", + "text": "憲法賦予人民有罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/58.wav", + "text": "但是國眾兩黨用這樣子的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/59.wav", + "text": "要來限縮人民的罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/60.wav", + "text": "藍白兩黨在立法院無止境擴權的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/61.wav", + "text": "人民卻沒有辦法來限縮這些自肥立委的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/62.wav", + "text": "力本席自己也是立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/63.wav", + "text": "我要說明的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/64.wav", + "text": "提高罷免門檻就是缺乏全民共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/65.wav", + "text": "用強渡關山的方式來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/66.wav", + "text": "就是傷害民主自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/67.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我想請教主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/68.wav", + "text": "跟罷免的投票率會相同嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/69.wav", + "text": "通常選舉的投票率會高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/70.wav", + "text": "在罷免的投票中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/71.wav", + "text": "人民所面對的心理壓力跟成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/72.wav", + "text": "是不是與大選不相同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/73.wav", + "text": "心理壓力跟成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/74.wav", + "text": "其實主委剛剛有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/75.wav", + "text": "但是罷免的投票率平均是4成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/76.wav", + "text": "再來在我們臺灣傳統的選舉氛圍之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/77.wav", + "text": "其實要人民站出來罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/78.wav", + "text": "他面對這個心理壓力會比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/79.wav", + "text": "比平常的選舉還要大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/80.wav", + "text": "因此如果我們要以投票率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/81.wav", + "text": "以及投票率的基數來推導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/82.wav", + "text": "罷免案應該要以同樣的數據來代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/83.wav", + "text": "今天這個罷免案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/84.wav", + "text": "是不是有一定的民意基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/85.wav", + "text": "本席覺得是不合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/86.wav", + "text": "當然國民黨你們也不要說少數否決多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/87.wav", + "text": "其實討論的基礎根本就不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/88.wav", + "text": "我們不能用這樣子的言論來欺騙人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/89.wav", + "text": "民眾的眼睛很雪亮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/90.wav", + "text": "民眾的理智也會判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/91.wav", + "text": "選舉其實可以視為一種締結契約的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/92.wav", + "text": "當人民對於選舉出來的民選公職表現不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/93.wav", + "text": "有受到衝突的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/94.wav", + "text": "就會利用罷免來做一個折衷挽回的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/95.wav", + "text": "這是憲法賦予人民的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/96.wav", + "text": "所以提高罷免門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/97.wav", + "text": "這件事情本來就不可以作為政治喊價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/98.wav", + "text": "應該要經過詳細的規劃和充分的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/99.wav", + "text": "主委您認為呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/100.wav", + "text": "是的謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157922/101.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主委謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/0.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/1.wav", + "text": "主委好我想罷免是人民的權利主委對此應該相當能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/2.wav", + "text": "現在在鳳山我們有一個團體已經成立許智傑被罷免總部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/3.wav", + "text": "我們也勇於面對我相信我們可以接受人民的檢驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/4.wav", + "text": "罷免是人民的基本權利所以我們一定要盡力去維護住人民的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/5.wav", + "text": "的話這樣適合嗎是不是應該要延到下一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/6.wav", + "text": "也就是這一屆的法這次如果修法成功的話我們立委本身都是利害關係人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/7.wav", + "text": "所以是不是應該要延到下一屆才適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/8.wav", + "text": "有關於利益迴避的問題司法院大法官已經有過解釋我們表示尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/9.wav", + "text": "但是就這個選罷法修改的議題部分基本上中選會是認為不宜在這個時候去更動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/10.wav", + "text": "對所以這一次如果國民黨強行過關通過以後是不是應該下一屆才適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/11.wav", + "text": "這個我們尊重大法官會議的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/12.wav", + "text": "如果真的已經通過以後我希望立法院大家都可以一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/13.wav", + "text": "下一屆才適用我想身為利害關係人本來就應該迴避不應該自己這一屆修改然後在這一屆就適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/14.wav", + "text": "我認為這個不恰當所以我希望大家可以認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/15.wav", + "text": "\n再來就是國民黨提了一個版本一個就是提出身分證影印本這個我們很多同事都問過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/16.wav", + "text": "或者是在連署的時候把它交出來真的是有洩漏個資的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/17.wav", + "text": "所以希望國民黨可以好好思考因為很多人民不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/18.wav", + "text": "人民不願意你卻提出這個法基本上它就會提高罷免的門檻然後就會變成鳥籠罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/19.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我希望大家可以三思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/20.wav", + "text": "\n再來國民黨還提出了另外一個版本就是罷免門檻要高於當選票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/21.wav", + "text": "數其實這個坦白講這真的是不合理因為每一次的選舉狀況都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/22.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨想要提高門檻坦白講我並不是很反對但是提高門檻要有一個限度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/23.wav", + "text": "其實在當時黃捷陳柏惟還有王浩宇都被黃捷沒有被罷免成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/24.wav", + "text": "而是陳柏惟跟王浩宇被罷免成功的時候當時我也曾經提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/25.wav", + "text": "是不是可以考慮三分之一提高罷免門檻我們並不是100%反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/26.wav", + "text": "但是你要恰當要適當而不是高到又變成一個鳥籠罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/27.wav", + "text": "所以我想這個部分國民黨要修改的時候也可以思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/28.wav", + "text": "\n我要嚴正聲明請國民黨不要踐踏民主還權於民不要設鳥籠公投" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/29.wav", + "text": "前面這幾個罷免參考名單乃是經過不正式投票產生好像是葉元之第1名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/30.wav", + "text": "參考啊很多民調不正式但是都可以供參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157921/31.wav", + "text": "這是我的訴求希望主委可以幫忙一起維護我們選民罷免的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我們請主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/1.wav", + "text": "請李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/2.wav", + "text": "主委好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/3.wav", + "text": "主委我剛剛聽了幾位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/4.wav", + "text": "有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/5.wav", + "text": "其實我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/6.wav", + "text": "對所有的選民所有的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/7.wav", + "text": "來說這個選區選出來的民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/8.wav", + "text": "只要好好地服務地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/9.wav", + "text": "或者你是一個立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/10.wav", + "text": "或者是提出對地方有利的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/11.wav", + "text": "我相信這個地方的民眾不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/12.wav", + "text": "吃飽撐著沒事做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/13.wav", + "text": "因為這個民意代表也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/14.wav", + "text": "在地方可能也做得太超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/15.wav", + "text": "或者是在國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/16.wav", + "text": "做得讓地方的選民民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/17.wav", + "text": "覺得非常地不適任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/18.wav", + "text": "才會提出這個罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/19.wav", + "text": "所以在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/20.wav", + "text": "有提到一個利益迴避的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/21.wav", + "text": "增加自己的報酬或待遇的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/22.wav", + "text": "如果今天我們修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/23.wav", + "text": "並從這一屆就要開始實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/24.wav", + "text": "把這個罷免門檻提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/25.wav", + "text": "其實就有自肥的嫌疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/26.wav", + "text": "我是不是可以請教主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/27.wav", + "text": "像這樣子你贊不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/28.wav", + "text": "關於大法官會議的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/29.wav", + "text": "我們表示尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/30.wav", + "text": "但是就這兩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/31.wav", + "text": "個選罷法的修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/32.wav", + "text": "最重要的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/33.wav", + "text": "是我們基本上認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/34.wav", + "text": "是不宜修正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/35.wav", + "text": "不論是在國會還是在議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/36.wav", + "text": "替人民發聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/37.wav", + "text": "當這個代議士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/38.wav", + "text": "已經沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/39.wav", + "text": "以致於民眾發起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/40.wav", + "text": "這樣一個罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/41.wav", + "text": "或是行使這樣一個權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/42.wav", + "text": "我覺得這應該是要去保障的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/43.wav", + "text": "其實這個問題今天之所以會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/44.wav", + "text": "並不是因為對制度本身的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/45.wav", + "text": "而是因應所謂的罷免潮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/46.wav", + "text": "所以因為這種一時的政治現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/47.wav", + "text": "而動搖我們的法制基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/48.wav", + "text": "我認為不宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/49.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/50.wav", + "text": "其實從今年2月1號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/51.wav", + "text": "新任第11屆的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/52.wav", + "text": "就職到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/53.wav", + "text": "了其實我相信很多地方的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/54.wav", + "text": "會覺得這一屆的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/55.wav", + "text": "到現在是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/56.wav", + "text": "大家會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/57.wav", + "text": "好像每一天都是這樣吵吵鬧鬧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/58.wav", + "text": "對於原本所立的法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/59.wav", + "text": "現在變成國民黨跟民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/60.wav", + "text": "加起來是多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/61.wav", + "text": "它原本立的法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/62.wav", + "text": "已經可以好好地去執行了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/63.wav", + "text": "卻又要再去立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/64.wav", + "text": "所以在這邊我們也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/65.wav", + "text": "所有民眾選你們出來當民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/66.wav", + "text": "你在國會應該是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/67.wav", + "text": "好好地替人民發聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/68.wav", + "text": "而不是國會擴權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/69.wav", + "text": "也不是搶錢又搶權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/70.wav", + "text": "所以我們在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/71.wav", + "text": "是不是可以再請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/72.wav", + "text": "其實很多民眾會很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/73.wav", + "text": "因為現在的詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/74.wav", + "text": "確實是非常猖獗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/75.wav", + "text": "如果一旦還要要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/76.wav", + "text": "提供身分證件的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/77.wav", + "text": "其實會讓民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/78.wav", + "text": "即使有這個罷免的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/79.wav", + "text": "他也會擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/80.wav", + "text": "要把這個身分證件交出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/81.wav", + "text": "怎麼認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/82.wav", + "text": "是的會影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/83.wav", + "text": "參與的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157920/84.wav", + "text": "是謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/0.wav", + "text": "主委好主委我想現在這個狀況是我們很樂見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/1.wav", + "text": "就是大家來理性討論選罷法的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/2.wav", + "text": "到底它的合理性在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/3.wav", + "text": "現行的罷免制度是否公平合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/4.wav", + "text": "我想今天就藉由這個機會來跟主委好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/5.wav", + "text": "\n我想我們在2016年修法以後公職人員的罷免門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/6.wav", + "text": "降為同意票數達原選舉區選舉人總數四分之一以上即為通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/7.wav", + "text": "這樣一個低門檻的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/8.wav", + "text": "讓敗選的一方非常容易地操作罷免成為選舉的延長賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/9.wav", + "text": "不利我們民主的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/10.wav", + "text": "且會耗費國家社會的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/11.wav", + "text": "修法後的罷免制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/12.wav", + "text": "是不是會造成罷免比當選容易的畸形制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/13.wav", + "text": "主委請回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/14.wav", + "text": "今天我們的案子所討論的是要罷免的得票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/15.wav", + "text": "必須高於當選的得票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/16.wav", + "text": "並不是對罷免的門檻的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/17.wav", + "text": "罷免的門檻定在四分之一到底是不是太高或者太低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/18.wav", + "text": "其實參考世界各國的立法例會有不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/19.wav", + "text": "這是另外一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/20.wav", + "text": "但是針對罷免票要多於當選票1票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/21.wav", + "text": "這點我們認為不宜做這樣的修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/22.wav", + "text": "其實我是想聽聽您對於我剛剛那個問題的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/23.wav", + "text": "當然世界各國也有很多先進國家根本沒有罷免制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/24.wav", + "text": "��們尊重人民選出來的代議士民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/25.wav", + "text": "如果他真的非常不適任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/26.wav", + "text": "也要讓他把4年的時間做完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/27.wav", + "text": "我們下一任再把他淘汰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/28.wav", + "text": "\n我想我們來看看總統的罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/29.wav", + "text": "總統的罷免要經過立法院同意後提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/30.wav", + "text": "然後經過中華民國自由地區的選舉人總額過半數的投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/31.wav", + "text": "有效票數要過半數罷免才算通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/32.wav", + "text": "但是我們看立委的罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/33.wav", + "text": "則是罷免同意票達原選區總額的四分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/34.wav", + "text": "就可以通過也就是我們剛才講的門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/35.wav", + "text": "他當選的票數只有40%的支持度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/36.wav", + "text": "就當選了總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/37.wav", + "text": "但是要罷免總統卻要高達50%的支持才能夠通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/38.wav", + "text": "所以我們假設以60%的支持度當選的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/39.wav", + "text": "他卻只要有25%的支持就能被罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/40.wav", + "text": "兩者被罷免的設計上是否失衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/41.wav", + "text": "主委你的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/42.wav", + "text": "有關總統被罷免的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/43.wav", + "text": "除了剛剛委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/44.wav", + "text": "就是必須達到二分之一再二分之一之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/45.wav", + "text": "還必須要是立法院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/46.wav", + "text": "所以它不只是門檻高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/47.wav", + "text": "它的過程程序也更加嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/48.wav", + "text": "因為茲事體大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/49.wav", + "text": "他是一個國家的元首" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/50.wav", + "text": "因此罷免必須要以非常非常嚴格的標準以及程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/51.wav", + "text": "主委我同意你這個看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/52.wav", + "text": "但是我也要提醒你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/53.wav", + "text": "難道立法委員就不重要嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/54.wav", + "text": "經過這麼多民意的肯定而選出來的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/55.wav", + "text": "他的罷免門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/56.wav", + "text": "當然我們今天不是在講這個門檻的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/57.wav", + "text": "但他的當選票數支持度那麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/58.wav", + "text": "但卻只要25%就可以罷免他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/59.wav", + "text": "您認為合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/60.wav", + "text": "立法院通過的法律在中選會的立場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/61.wav", + "text": "我們就是按照這個規定來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/62.wav", + "text": "這就凸顯出這個制度的不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/63.wav", + "text": "所以我們這一次認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/64.wav", + "text": "為這樣的罷免同意票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/65.wav", + "text": "我這樣的回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/66.wav", + "text": "並不等同我認為它不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/67.wav", + "text": "我想你已經凸顯制度的不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/68.wav", + "text": "這就可以證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/69.wav", + "text": "門檻的部分各國有不同的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/70.wav", + "text": "票數一定要大於他的當選票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/71.wav", + "text": "這才叫公平正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157919/72.wav", + "text": "這個基礎實在是不存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我們有請主委謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/2.wav", + "text": "主委好我想延續剛剛林俊憲委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/3.wav", + "text": "就是其實照這樣子的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/4.wav", + "text": "罷免票數要超過被罷免者的當選票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/5.wav", + "text": "您認為是不是非常難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/6.wav", + "text": "因為依據投票率來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/7.wav", + "text": "這樣子是不是非常難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/8.wav", + "text": "有任何人民可以實施真正所謂的罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/9.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/10.wav", + "text": "您的看法也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/11.wav", + "text": "它的難度是相當高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/12.wav", + "text": "相當的高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/13.wav", + "text": "其實因為我們的憲法裡面就有規範了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/14.wav", + "text": "罷免權是人民的基本權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/15.wav", + "text": "也是民主政治的重要機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/16.wav", + "text": "所以我認為任何企圖限制或剝奪罷免權的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/17.wav", + "text": "都必須要有充分的民意支持基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/18.wav", + "text": "不然其實就是破壞了我們這個民主的體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/19.wav", + "text": "釋字第499號的意旨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/20.wav", + "text": "立法委員應該遵守利益迴避原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/21.wav", + "text": "當涉及自身利益的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/22.wav", + "text": "應該要延至下一屆才能夠適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/23.wav", + "text": "而且在理由書裡面也明確地記載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/24.wav", + "text": "利益迴避乃是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/25.wav", + "text": "任何公職人員行使職權均應遵守之原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/26.wav", + "text": "所以我想請教主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/27.wav", + "text": "您認為現在國民黨的修法加了這個同意票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/28.wav", + "text": "被罷免人當選票數的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/29.wav", + "text": "是否已經違反了這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/30.wav", + "text": "行使職權時應遵守的利益迴避原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/31.wav", + "text": "我想這不只是所謂迴避的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/32.wav", + "text": "其實它很重要的一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/33.wav", + "text": "就是一個法制的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/34.wav", + "text": "這個選舉罷免的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/35.wav", + "text": "它的法制規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/36.wav", + "text": "應該要穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/37.wav", + "text": "不要因為一時政黨之間的對立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/38.wav", + "text": "或者政治環境的波動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/39.wav", + "text": "那麼用改變我們的法律制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/40.wav", + "text": "其實這個是不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/41.wav", + "text": "我非常認同主委說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/42.wav", + "text": "保護人民的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/43.wav", + "text": "應該都是我們所有立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/44.wav", + "text": "應該要堅守的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/45.wav", + "text": "制度要穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/46.wav", + "text": "保護這個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/47.wav", + "text": "讓我們的民主體制可以持續運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/48.wav", + "text": "我想回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/49.wav", + "text": "剛剛鄭天財委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/50.wav", + "text": "一上任就開始進行惡意罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/51.wav", + "text": "我覺得國民黨應該要好好地深自檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/52.wav", + "text": "為什麼人民會產生罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/53.wav", + "text": "因為一開始上個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/54.wav", + "text": "就提出了一個國會擴權惡法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/55.wav", + "text": "是因為你們的所作所為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/56.wav", + "text": "召喚了我們的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/57.wav", + "text": "要主動出來捍衛這個體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/58.wav", + "text": "所以才行使了罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/59.wav", + "text": "權同時現在的國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/60.wav", + "text": "在預算會期裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/61.wav", + "text": "也不審我們國家的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/62.wav", + "text": "還在做這些所謂的政治鬥爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/63.wav", + "text": "來操弄這些法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/64.wav", + "text": "根本就是把政治擺第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/65.wav", + "text": "民生法案擺最後把百姓丟一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/66.wav", + "text": "才會造成今天民眾必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/67.wav", + "text": "我也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/68.wav", + "text": "國民黨如果真的想要好好地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/69.wav", + "text": "最好的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/70.wav", + "text": "就是好好地工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/71.wav", + "text": "好好地做事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/72.wav", + "text": "這樣就不必擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/73.wav", + "text": "也不用再來修這個選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/74.wav", + "text": "破壞這個體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/75.wav", + "text": "\n最後我想要請教主委一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/76.wav", + "text": "2004年以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/77.wav", + "text": "其實我們有一條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/78.wav", + "text": "次高得票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/79.wav", + "text": "得於投票日後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/80.wav", + "text": "7天內提出驗票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/81.wav", + "text": "我想請教主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/82.wav", + "text": "從2004年以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/83.wav", + "text": "重新驗票有6次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/84.wav", + "text": "有哪一次結果有翻盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/85.wav", + "text": "沒有翻盤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/86.wav", + "text": "對從來沒有翻盤過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/87.wav", + "text": "所以如果今天我們將得票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/88.wav", + "text": "差距從千分之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/89.wav", + "text": "修正至千分之十的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/90.wav", + "text": "我覺得這就要問國民黨一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/91.wav", + "text": "如果你有去現場監票的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/92.wav", + "text": "你就會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/93.wav", + "text": "各黨各派都會派人去現場監票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/94.wav", + "text": "今天只要有任何異議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/95.wav", + "text": "現場都可以提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/96.wav", + "text": "我只要再30秒就可以結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/97.wav", + "text": "今天如果我們要把得票差距拉高到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/98.wav", + "text": "千分之十的話有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/99.wav", + "text": "有多少公務人員要在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/100.wav", + "text": "陪你們玩這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/101.wav", + "text": "千分之三都沒有成案過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/102.wav", + "text": "你今天拉到千分之十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/103.wav", + "text": "的科學根據到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/104.wav", + "text": "今天一天到晚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/105.wav", + "text": "叫公務人員不要加班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/106.wav", + "text": "但你們現在要做的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/107.wav", + "text": "就是讓公務人員加班啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/108.wav", + "text": "不要這麼荒謬好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/109.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157918/110.wav", + "text": "謝謝張委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席本席邀請我們中選會李主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/1.wav", + "text": "主委2021年臺中的陳柏惟委員被罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/2.wav", + "text": "那時候國民黨的主席朱立倫說這是民主的勝利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/3.wav", + "text": "你要知道陳柏惟被罷免成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/4.wav", + "text": "但是贊成罷免的票也沒有大於他當選的票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/5.wav", + "text": "現在國民黨要把這個改掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/6.wav", + "text": "國民黨說罷免同意票如果沒有大於當選票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/7.wav", + "text": "這叫做少數民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/8.wav", + "text": "國民黨又在轉變了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/9.wav", + "text": "不一樣的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/10.wav", + "text": "了\n我們立委同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/11.wav", + "text": "現在可以在這裡開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/12.wav", + "text": "是因為我們當選立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/13.wav", + "text": "我們依法當選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/14.wav", + "text": "公職人員選舉罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/15.wav", + "text": "這個法律不是只有選舉法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/16.wav", + "text": "它還包含罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/17.wav", + "text": "這是我們跟選民的約定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/18.wav", + "text": "約定任期4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/19.wav", + "text": "我們按照這樣的法律當選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/20.wav", + "text": "我們選民也有權利按照現在這個法律來把我罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/21.wav", + "text": "現在我們任期剛開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/22.wav", + "text": "我們就把罷免的部分改掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/23.wav", + "text": "是我們違背跟選民的約定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/24.wav", + "text": "現在改成這樣等於不可能有罷免了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/25.wav", + "text": "身分證是很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/26.wav", + "text": "的當時黃國昌是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/27.wav", + "text": "國民黨就有提案要用身分證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/28.wav", + "text": "黃國昌就在那邊哭夭他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/29.wav", + "text": "說這樣不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/30.wav", + "text": "啦所以張啓楷要搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/31.wav", + "text": "啦\n現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/32.wav", + "text": "國民黨再提這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/33.wav", + "text": "一定要贊成罷免的票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/34.wav", + "text": "現在的罷免制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/35.wav", + "text": "而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/36.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/37.wav", + "text": "數就沒有大於他的當選票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/38.wav", + "text": "為什麼會怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/39.wav", + "text": "嗎我認為就接受選民考驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/40.wav", + "text": "20個立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/41.wav", + "text": "政黨或政治人物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/42.wav", + "text": "對自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/43.wav", + "text": "對選民負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/44.wav", + "text": "不能一開始我們就先自肥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/45.wav", + "text": "把罷免的法律給改掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/46.wav", + "text": "這是圖利我們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/47.wav", + "text": "這是我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/48.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/49.wav", + "text": "\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/50.wav", + "text": "聽說是因為國民黨臺中的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/51.wav", + "text": "怕被罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/52.wav", + "text": "我不曉得是不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/53.wav", + "text": "根本就是完全要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/54.wav", + "text": "杜絕以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/55.wav", + "text": "啦過去幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/56.wav", + "text": "次罷免的投票率是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/57.wav", + "text": "主委你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/58.wav", + "text": "差不多40%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/59.wav", + "text": "28%到50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/60.wav", + "text": "但是選舉投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/61.wav", + "text": "至少投票率都五成多六成五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/62.wav", + "text": "所以這兩個選舉的基本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/63.wav", + "text": "結構是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/64.wav", + "text": "你怎麼可以拿這個的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/65.wav", + "text": "這是不一樣的選舉投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/66.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/67.wav", + "text": "你看它投票率差那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/68.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/69.wav", + "text": "現在只要動到這個選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/70.wav", + "text": "第一個我們立委在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/71.wav", + "text": "任期中我們依照這個選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/72.wav", + "text": "罷免法宣誓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/73.wav", + "text": "就職立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/74.wav", + "text": "我們不能把這個法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/75.wav", + "text": "你這樣一改很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/76.wav", + "text": "如果按照過去的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/77.wav", + "text": "過去的投票率過去的得票數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/78.wav", + "text": "不可能有任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/79.wav", + "text": "罷免案會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/80.wav", + "text": "\n國民黨再提一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/81.wav", + "text": "什麼一年裡面不能有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/82.wav", + "text": "提案跟連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/83.wav", + "text": "連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/84.wav", + "text": "你怎麼去認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/85.wav", + "text": "一年內什麼樣的連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/86.wav", + "text": "以後認為有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/87.wav", + "text": "也沒有明細的一個施行細則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/88.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/89.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得我們立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/90.wav", + "text": "對自己要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/91.wav", + "text": "對選民要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/92.wav", + "text": "我們不能在這個時候把人民的罷免權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/93.wav", + "text": "給沒收掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/157917/94.wav", + "text": "胡亂偷改這個法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家今天一起出席我們朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1.wav", + "text": "今天應國民黨黨團所提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2.wav", + "text": "關於行政院對本院三讀通過的立法院職權行使法部分條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/3.wav", + "text": "及增訂中華民國刑法第五章之一章名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/4.wav", + "text": "及第104條之1條文等移請本院覆議案等事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/5.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團提出要求協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/6.wav", + "text": "我們先請國民黨黨團發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/7.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長跟我們各黨黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/8.wav", + "text": "我想行政院已經正式對立法院所三讀通過的職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/9.wav", + "text": "還有刑法修正案提出了這次的覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/10.wav", + "text": "我們本於職權希望儘快來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/11.wav", + "text": "因為15天內必須要處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/12.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡希望今天的協商能夠把明確的時程定出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/13.wav", + "text": "也能夠在明天院會的報告事項順利來付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/14.wav", + "text": "所以在這裡希望我們大家都能夠本諸理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/15.wav", + "text": "本諸對民意託付的監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/16.wav", + "text": "我們能夠朝野大家一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/17.wav", + "text": "能夠儘快把覆議案做一個明確的議決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/18.wav", + "text": "才剛剛就職就對立法院提出覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/19.wav", + "text": "這個是過去所沒有見過的一個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/20.wav", + "text": "對本院也相當的不尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/21.wav", + "text": "所以我們也建請希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/22.wav", + "text": "卓榮泰院長必須來跟全國國人說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/23.wav", + "text": "為什麼要提出覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/24.wav", + "text": "這是一個國會自主的問題為什麼行政院窒礙難行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/25.wav", + "text": "我們希望他們能夠來這裡表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/26.wav", + "text": "還有一個雙向的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/27.wav", + "text": "那溝通完之後我們就進行議決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/28.wav", + "text": "也希望大家都能夠理性來看待這個事情我們很務實地來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/29.wav", + "text": "好不好也不要有任何議場衝突發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/30.wav", + "text": "全國國人全世界都在看謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/31.wav", + "text": "簡言之傅崐萁總召有三個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/32.wav", + "text": "第一就是希望卓榮泰院長到院說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/33.wav", + "text": "大家能夠理性地探討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/34.wav", + "text": "\n第二位我們請民眾黨黃總召第三位請柯總召請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/35.wav", + "text": "那個覆議案的提出在憲法增修條文裡面有明定處理的時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/36.wav", + "text": "在憲法下我們本來就應該在憲法增修條文所定的期限當中予以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/37.wav", + "text": "就舉行的方式以及舉行的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/38.wav", + "text": "其實過去也都有前例可以援引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/39.wav", + "text": "引我大概看了一下全院委員會跟投票以前地政士法是差一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/40.wav", + "text": "那個時候的地政士法是1月27號全院委員會1月28號投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/41.wav", + "text": "而會計法的話那個時候也沒有邀行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/42.wav", + "text": "然後就直接全院委員會當天就投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/43.wav", + "text": "那個時候是6月13號處理就是當天全院委員會然後同時那天投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/44.wav", + "text": "那要分一天或者是分兩天來加以進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/45.wav", + "text": "我覺得以立法院整個運作有效率為最高考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/46.wav", + "text": "其他的事情我們並沒有什麼特別的堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/47.wav", + "text": "就尊重其他各個黨團大家所表示的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/48.wav", + "text": "這個我們OK啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/49.wav", + "text": "對就是基本上面把時間劃出來然後都談好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/50.wav", + "text": "這樣子就OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/51.wav", + "text": "對我們不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/52.wav", + "text": "好的接下來我們請民進黨黨團柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/53.wav", + "text": "韓院長各位協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/54.wav", + "text": "首先針對韓院長剛才在問的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/55.wav", + "text": "請院長到院說明覆議案這是憲法增修條文所規定的很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/56.wav", + "text": "也不必再強調了也不是說有什麼問題所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/57.wav", + "text": "我是覺得我們把這個事情講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/58.wav", + "text": "\n針對剛才傅崐萁總召所談的有三點我有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/59.wav", + "text": "第二個不尊重立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/60.wav", + "text": "第三個這是國會自主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/61.wav", + "text": "這到底有沒有憲法常識啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/62.wav", + "text": "剛才黃國昌已經馬上打臉你了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/63.wav", + "text": "憲法增修條文本來就有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/64.wav", + "text": "程序立法院常常在處理覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/65.wav", + "text": "也不是今天才有所謂的未見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/66.wav", + "text": "覆議請傅總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/67.wav", + "text": "你去查一下過去的公報紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/68.wav", + "text": "528表決完畢以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/69.wav", + "text": "我們黨團立場說這絕對會釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/70.wav", + "text": "我們一定會提釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/71.wav", + "text": "當天晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/72.wav", + "text": "所以這是照憲法而來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/73.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/74.wav", + "text": "卓院長講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/75.wav", + "text": "行政院是憲政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/76.wav", + "text": "我們也是憲政機關嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/77.wav", + "text": "當然是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/78.wav", + "text": "所以要依憲政體制來踐行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/79.wav", + "text": "覆議案怎麼是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/80.wav", + "text": "傅總召所談的不曾看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/81.wav", + "text": "到底是在說什麼美國話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/82.wav", + "text": "這很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/83.wav", + "text": "講重點嘛不要再人身攻擊了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/84.wav", + "text": "一天到晚在人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/85.wav", + "text": "講重點我是說大家要遵照憲法行事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/86.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/87.wav", + "text": "是不尊重立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/88.wav", + "text": "違憲的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/89.wav", + "text": "難道行政院這個憲政機關不表示意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/90.wav", + "text": "他沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/91.wav", + "text": "啊對於他施政作為上有問題這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/92.wav", + "text": "根本就還沒有違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/93.wav", + "text": "有沒有違憲留到憲法法庭去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/94.wav", + "text": "一下你不控制他只控制我要幹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/95.wav", + "text": "你的情緒不要受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/96.wav", + "text": "你要制止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/97.wav", + "text": "\n他所謂的不尊重立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/98.wav", + "text": "根本就是沒有憲政常識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/99.wav", + "text": "七大點理由已經列在那裡很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/100.wav", + "text": "你去看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/101.wav", + "text": "嘛你可以在全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/102.wav", + "text": "在全院委員會把他叫來問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/103.wav", + "text": "多問幾天也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/104.wav", + "text": "找一堆人去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/105.wav", + "text": "電他也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/106.wav", + "text": "這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/107.wav", + "text": "哪有國會立什麼法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/108.wav", + "text": "違憲有擴權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/109.wav", + "text": "也有剝奪行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/110.wav", + "text": "實質的施政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/111.wav", + "text": "以及違反憲法第7條增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/112.wav", + "text": "增加預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/113.wav", + "text": "他都不能有意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/114.wav", + "text": "到底還是不是憲政體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/115.wav", + "text": "所以這三點大家要看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/116.wav", + "text": "原則同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/117.wav", + "text": "他說原則嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/118.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/119.wav", + "text": "民進黨會占領主席台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/120.wav", + "text": "不要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/121.wav", + "text": "啦不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/122.wav", + "text": "院長來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/123.wav", + "text": "他能夠好好說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/124.wav", + "text": "能說服大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/125.wav", + "text": "希望能夠贏啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/126.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼會搞這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/127.wav", + "text": "歷史上沒有人會在這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/128.wav", + "text": "不讓他施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/129.wav", + "text": "超過兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/130.wav", + "text": "所以這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/131.wav", + "text": "都不用多說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/132.wav", + "text": "而且這種話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/133.wav", + "text": "對我們來講是一種侮辱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/134.wav", + "text": "我一定要提出抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/135.wav", + "text": "也不必在那裡杯弓蛇影覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/136.wav", + "text": "心中有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/137.wav", + "text": "不正常的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/138.wav", + "text": "自己把它講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/139.wav", + "text": "絕對沒有那個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/140.wav", + "text": "這是我們期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/141.wav", + "text": "不行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/142.wav", + "text": "還有釋憲的途徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/143.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/144.wav", + "text": "照憲法增修條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/145.wav", + "text": "這是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/146.wav", + "text": "第二個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/147.wav", + "text": "要談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/148.wav", + "text": "時間要談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/149.wav", + "text": "有在同一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/150.wav", + "text": "也有在不同一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/151.wav", + "text": "他所舉例的一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/152.wav", + "text": "會計法的覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/153.wav", + "text": "全院委員會來問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/154.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/155.wav", + "text": "因為那時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/156.wav", + "text": "文字錯誤很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/157.wav", + "text": "這沒有什麼好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/158.wav", + "text": "爭辯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/159.wav", + "text": "大家都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/160.wav", + "text": "嘛共識錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/161.wav", + "text": "時候沒有全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/162.wav", + "text": "那時候朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/163.wav", + "text": "都認為這個應該更正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/164.wav", + "text": "嘛蘇貞昌為了這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/165.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/166.wav", + "text": "幾個例子我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/167.wav", + "text": "把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/168.wav", + "text": "還原歷史真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/169.wav", + "text": "\n今天我們要談的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/170.wav", + "text": "兩個星期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/171.wav", + "text": "這段時間一定要完成嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/172.wav", + "text": "2月6號進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/173.wav", + "text": "2月19號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/174.wav", + "text": "完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/175.wav", + "text": "不管隨時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/176.wav", + "text": "憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/177.wav", + "text": "的憲政行為來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/178.wav", + "text": "民黨民進黨都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/179.wav", + "text": "這個沒有人可以抵抗憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/180.wav", + "text": "的所以對於傅崐萁剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/181.wav", + "text": "那合不合憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/182.wav", + "text": "等到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/183.wav", + "text": "覆議案結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/184.wav", + "text": "表決結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/185.wav", + "text": "要釋憲的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/186.wav", + "text": "表決結果總統一定要公告嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/187.wav", + "text": "公告以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/188.wav", + "text": "只要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/189.wav", + "text": "黨團釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/190.wav", + "text": "乃至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/191.wav", + "text": "監察院要釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/192.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/193.wav", + "text": "憲政機關都會釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/194.wav", + "text": "因為也影響到監察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/195.wav", + "text": "所以我們的原則是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/196.wav", + "text": "時間裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/197.wav", + "text": "我的看法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/198.wav", + "text": "效率不效率的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/199.wav", + "text": "面最多是在這個時間嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/200.wav", + "text": "所以這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/201.wav", + "text": "大家兩邊都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/202.wav", + "text": "我看昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/203.wav", + "text": "要百場以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/204.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/205.wav", + "text": "那是一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/206.wav", + "text": "那明知是誇大其詞嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/207.wav", + "text": "週末開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/208.wav", + "text": "各黨都開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/209.wav", + "text": "下鄉說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/210.wav", + "text": "去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/211.wav", + "text": "自己去說明自己的理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/212.wav", + "text": "這是好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/213.wav", + "text": "社會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/214.wav", + "text": "有這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/215.wav", + "text": "這是好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/216.wav", + "text": "所以這不是所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/217.wav", + "text": "效率的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/218.wav", + "text": "這是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/219.wav", + "text": "時間的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/220.wav", + "text": "一定要完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/221.wav", + "text": "但是方式怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/222.wav", + "text": "等一下再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/223.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/224.wav", + "text": "我濃縮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/225.wav", + "text": "三位總召的講法就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/226.wav", + "text": "行政院院長到院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/227.wav", + "text": "來做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/228.wav", + "text": "這一點是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/229.wav", + "text": "三個黨團都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/230.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/231.wav", + "text": "這第一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/232.wav", + "text": "好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/233.wav", + "text": "這第一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/234.wav", + "text": "非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/235.wav", + "text": "大家都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/236.wav", + "text": "我們先確定這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/237.wav", + "text": "第二點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/238.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/239.wav", + "text": "三位總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/240.wav", + "text": "等一下你會發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/241.wav", + "text": "沒問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/242.wav", + "text": "我們先把兩個重點確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/243.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就選一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/244.wav", + "text": "來開全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/245.wav", + "text": "柯總召你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/246.wav", + "text": "下星期一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/247.wav", + "text": "不是我先問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/248.wav", + "text": "對我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/249.wav", + "text": "我們先確定這兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/250.wav", + "text": "我不知道是不是講你啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/251.wav", + "text": "但是一般大家講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/252.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/253.wav", + "text": "你也不必嘗試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/254.wav", + "text": "如果大家都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/255.wav", + "text": "我們就先確定請卓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/256.wav", + "text": "到院來說明報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/257.wav", + "text": "這一點我們來擇一天時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/258.wav", + "text": "第二個就是時間了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/259.wav", + "text": "那能不能拜託大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/260.wav", + "text": "聚焦在這個重點上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/261.wav", + "text": "請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/262.wav", + "text": "好謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/263.wav", + "text": "我想剛剛討論行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/264.wav", + "text": "因為覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/265.wav", + "text": "要來立法院得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/266.wav", + "text": "邀請行政院長來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/267.wav", + "text": "這是立院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/268.wav", + "text": "覆議案的這個章節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/269.wav", + "text": "清楚明白規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/270.wav", + "text": "也因此我們剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/271.wav", + "text": "三個黨團都一致共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/272.wav", + "text": "邀請行政院長來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/273.wav", + "text": "並且備質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/274.wav", + "text": "我想這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/275.wav", + "text": "大家沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/276.wav", + "text": "那我也先還原一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/277.wav", + "text": "柯總召也不用杯弓蛇影啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/278.wav", + "text": "我的原話講的是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/279.wav", + "text": "任何人用暴力衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/280.wav", + "text": "議事杯葛的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/281.wav", + "text": "發起者負起完全責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/282.wav", + "text": "並沒有講哪一個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/283.wav", + "text": "也不用杯弓蛇影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/284.wav", + "text": "也不用對號入座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/285.wav", + "text": "不過我接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/286.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召的抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/287.wav", + "text": "畢竟柯總召在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/288.wav", + "text": "從第2屆到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/289.wav", + "text": "所以我想我們這邊就還原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/290.wav", + "text": "也不用再情緒性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/291.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/292.wav", + "text": "大家時間都寶貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/293.wav", + "text": "委員會都在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/294.wav", + "text": "我們也預擬了兩個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/295.wav", + "text": "既然大家都認為說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/296.wav", + "text": "覆議案來非常重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/297.wav", + "text": "也是社會大家關注的一個焦點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/298.wav", + "text": "我想我們是不是提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/299.wav", + "text": "也聽聽看兩個黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/300.wav", + "text": "聚焦討論比較具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/301.wav", + "text": "第一現在是行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/302.wav", + "text": "總質詢的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/303.wav", + "text": "覆議案已經在進行中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/304.wav", + "text": "但是總質詢也同步進行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/305.wav", + "text": "在詢問的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/306.wav", + "text": "明天（6月14號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/307.wav", + "text": "也是院會的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/308.wav", + "text": "如果可以接受的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/309.wav", + "text": "我們何不直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/310.wav", + "text": "要變更議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/311.wav", + "text": "上午變成全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/312.wav", + "text": "已經預留時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/313.wav", + "text": "邀請行政院長早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/314.wav", + "text": "可以很清楚明白知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/315.wav", + "text": "跟掌握方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/316.wav", + "text": "明天早上是禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/317.wav", + "text": "會有國是論壇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/318.wav", + "text": "所以從10點鐘開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/319.wav", + "text": "因此上午的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/320.wav", + "text": "各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/321.wav", + "text": "譬如說院長通常報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/322.wav", + "text": "差不多20分鐘左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/323.wav", + "text": "報告完畢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/324.wav", + "text": "各黨團推派代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/325.wav", + "text": "大家討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/326.wav", + "text": "各黨團推派差不多1點以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/327.wav", + "text": "中午議事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/328.wav", + "text": "布置一下會場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/329.wav", + "text": "下午2點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/330.wav", + "text": "我先試圖提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/331.wav", + "text": "明天確實時間上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/332.wav", + "text": "因為行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/333.wav", + "text": "本來明天就已經安排好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/334.wav", + "text": "要過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/335.wav", + "text": "也是院會的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/336.wav", + "text": "這麼短暫的時間內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/337.wav", + "text": "早就已經把這個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/338.wav", + "text": "給備妥了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/339.wav", + "text": "\n如果沒有辦法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/340.wav", + "text": "因為下個禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/341.wav", + "text": "當天就整天開全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/342.wav", + "text": "早上9點就可以請行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/343.wav", + "text": "整個質詢時間很充分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/344.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/345.wav", + "text": "要理性溝通開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/346.wav", + "text": "我們就好好地用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/347.wav", + "text": "可能政黨的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/348.wav", + "text": "就可以派比較多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/349.wav", + "text": "全院委員會整個結束之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/350.wav", + "text": "投票表決的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/351.wav", + "text": "所以早上9點到11點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/352.wav", + "text": "也許2個小時的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/353.wav", + "text": "也許可以提早開票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/354.wav", + "text": "就如同正副院長選舉一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/355.wav", + "text": "下午2點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/356.wav", + "text": "我們繼續進行行政院長的總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/357.wav", + "text": "已經講出7月16號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/358.wav", + "text": "6月18號（禮拜二）的院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/359.wav", + "text": "我認為上午可以投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/360.wav", + "text": "投票完之後下午做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/361.wav", + "text": "行政院長的總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/362.wav", + "text": "都已經準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/363.wav", + "text": "還有很多議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/364.wav", + "text": "\n最後我只簡單講一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/365.wav", + "text": "不知道是不是說溜嘴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/366.wav", + "text": "一結束之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/367.wav", + "text": "就在臉書上說他會提出覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/368.wav", + "text": "卓榮泰院長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/369.wav", + "text": "卓榮泰院長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/370.wav", + "text": "他連條文都還沒看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/371.wav", + "text": "不過既然各政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/372.wav", + "text": "都有各政黨的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/373.wav", + "text": "既然這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/374.wav", + "text": "很清楚明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/375.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛已經把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/376.wav", + "text": "我們的兩個方案提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/377.wav", + "text": "針對這兩個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/378.wav", + "text": "你們提出一個比較具體的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/379.wav", + "text": "我們可以聚焦在這個時間上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/380.wav", + "text": "謝謝孟楷書記長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/381.wav", + "text": "A案就是明天（星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/382.wav", + "text": "）全部把它處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/383.wav", + "text": "B案的話就是下星期一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/384.wav", + "text": "開全院委員會下星期二表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/385.wav", + "text": "這是AB兩個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/386.wav", + "text": "\n吳思瑤幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/387.wav", + "text": "我要問一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/388.wav", + "text": "民眾黨有沒有再派第二輪發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/389.wav", + "text": "還是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/390.wav", + "text": "有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/391.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召請繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/392.wav", + "text": "請發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/393.wav", + "text": "到底是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/394.wav", + "text": "是不是今天先請院長確定一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/395.wav", + "text": "有的時候用舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/396.wav", + "text": "有的時候用照輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/397.wav", + "text": "規矩到底是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/398.wav", + "text": "我覺得院長立下規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/399.wav", + "text": "我們大家都願意遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/400.wav", + "text": "這個規則是不是先訂好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/401.wav", + "text": "容許我已經講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/402.wav", + "text": "嘛就是我希望能夠平均發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/403.wav", + "text": "例如民進黨發言完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/404.wav", + "text": "國民黨發言完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/405.wav", + "text": "民眾黨發言完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/406.wav", + "text": "但是有的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/407.wav", + "text": "會有人提早舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/408.wav", + "text": "所以在這個時候我就要問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/409.wav", + "text": "第二輪或第三輪沒有發言的政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/410.wav", + "text": "請問一下你們要不要補充發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/411.wav", + "text": "形式上一定是平均大家都有發言的次序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/412.wav", + "text": "這一點很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/413.wav", + "text": "所以我就問你有沒有二次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/414.wav", + "text": "如果你有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/415.wav", + "text": "現在都已經第二次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/416.wav", + "text": "您發言完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/417.wav", + "text": "就是請民進黨第二輪發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/418.wav", + "text": "請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/419.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/420.wav", + "text": "我基本上是建議這個規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/421.wav", + "text": "就把它立下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/422.wav", + "text": "要不然每次黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/423.wav", + "text": "到底規則是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/424.wav", + "text": "大家都不是很清楚的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/425.wav", + "text": "我覺得對於黨團協商的效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/426.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼太大的幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/427.wav", + "text": "未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/428.wav", + "text": "如果就三個黨團大家輪流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/429.wav", + "text": "就平均發言的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/430.wav", + "text": "當然輪到你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/431.wav", + "text": "你不想講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/432.wav", + "text": "你可以放棄嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/433.wav", + "text": "也讓院長不用那麼辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/434.wav", + "text": "然後在那邊看誰有舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/435.wav", + "text": "誰沒有舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/436.wav", + "text": "誰先舉誰後舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/437.wav", + "text": "誰舉得長誰舉得短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/438.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個規則如果把它立下來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/439.wav", + "text": "我們都樂於遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/440.wav", + "text": "這個沒有什麼問題\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/441.wav", + "text": "我還是會認為我們在黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/442.wav", + "text": "基本上就針對院長所要召開的議事事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/443.wav", + "text": "實質地進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/444.wav", + "text": "不要再扯一堆有的沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/445.wav", + "text": "因為浪費大家的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/446.wav", + "text": "在那邊進行人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/447.wav", + "text": "到底有什麼樣子的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/448.wav", + "text": "完全都在講自己主觀的一些想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/449.wav", + "text": "甚至對別人進行謾罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/450.wav", + "text": "然後說人家沒有憲政常識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/451.wav", + "text": "說一些有的沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/452.wav", + "text": "說當初會計法的覆議是因為文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/453.wav", + "text": "要還原歷史真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/454.wav", + "text": "這太可笑了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/455.wav", + "text": "2013年會計法第99條之1為什麼會覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/456.wav", + "text": "議就是因為幫貪污除罪化嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/457.wav", + "text": "整個社會譁然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/458.wav", + "text": "公民團體出來抗議嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/459.wav", + "text": "四個黨團的總召躲在議場背後的等一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/460.wav", + "text": "你現在有沒有針對主席的在回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/461.wav", + "text": "現在是可以插嘴嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/462.wav", + "text": "現在是可以插嘴嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/463.wav", + "text": "現在是可以插嘴嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/464.wav", + "text": "現在是可以插嘴嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/465.wav", + "text": "沒有我只想請院長裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/466.wav", + "text": "��後大家按麥克風別人在講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/467.wav", + "text": "其他人都可以按麥克風講話嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/468.wav", + "text": "就把規矩講好嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/469.wav", + "text": "不要永遠好像就有人可以按著麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/470.wav", + "text": "在那邊插人家的嘴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/471.wav", + "text": "在那邊罵人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/472.wav", + "text": "因為你在做人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/473.wav", + "text": "什麼叫人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/474.wav", + "text": "你說這沒有違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/475.wav", + "text": "這個是人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/476.wav", + "text": "你你可以決定有沒有違憲嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/477.wav", + "text": "這個剛才黃國昌打臉你了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/478.wav", + "text": "人家才打臉你啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/479.wav", + "text": "你們兩個合起來狼狽為奸沒有用啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/480.wav", + "text": "要講道理動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/481.wav", + "text": "你是大法官嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/482.wav", + "text": "再大聲一點沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/483.wav", + "text": "說什麼不要人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/484.wav", + "text": "政常識是人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/485.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/486.wav", + "text": "連內容是什麼都不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/487.wav", + "text": "好啦好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/488.wav", + "text": "相互尊重嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/489.wav", + "text": "我怎麼罵你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/490.wav", + "text": "就是院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/491.wav", + "text": "你是大法官嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/492.wav", + "text": "好啦好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/493.wav", + "text": "能不能拜託大家尊重一下黃國昌總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/494.wav", + "text": "我要制止他們兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/495.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/496.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/497.wav", + "text": "黃國昌情緒不要受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/498.wav", + "text": "不會啦院長我情緒不會受什麼影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/499.wav", + "text": "因為其實我記得在前幾次的協商當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/500.wav", + "text": "我也很清楚地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/501.wav", + "text": "跟院長報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/502.wav", + "text": "我每次來這邊協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/503.wav", + "text": "我都是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/504.wav", + "text": "針對院長所召集協商的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/505.wav", + "text": "就事論事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/506.wav", + "text": "針對問題表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/507.wav", + "text": "這樣就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/508.wav", + "text": "那每一黨有它各自的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/509.wav", + "text": "說清楚就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/510.wav", + "text": "但幾次下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/511.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法去接受的一點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/512.wav", + "text": "當在黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/513.wav", + "text": "有人刻意用這個黨團協商的現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/514.wav", + "text": "對別人進行人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/515.wav", + "text": "發表他自己的長篇大論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/516.wav", + "text": "那講完了一輪以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/517.wav", + "text": "根本沒有重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/518.wav", + "text": "啊針對這個議事要討論的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/519.wav", + "text": "根本沒有重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/520.wav", + "text": "啊純粹都只是在罵人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/521.wav", + "text": "如果遊戲規則是這個樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/522.wav", + "text": "那我們就要把話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/523.wav", + "text": "給講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/524.wav", + "text": "嘛特別是又在講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/525.wav", + "text": "還原歷史真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/526.wav", + "text": "2013年會計法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/527.wav", + "text": "第99條之1的歷史真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/528.wav", + "text": "就是四個黨團的總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/529.wav", + "text": "躲在議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/530.wav", + "text": "議場後面的會議室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/531.wav", + "text": "簽下了可恥的會計法的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/532.wav", + "text": "嘛要幫貪污犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/533.wav", + "text": "除罪化免除一切法律責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/534.wav", + "text": "群起反彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/535.wav", + "text": "那個時候才受不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/536.wav", + "text": "蘇貞昌才出來道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/537.wav", + "text": "馬英九才出來道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/538.wav", + "text": "如果只是文字修正的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/539.wav", + "text": "用得著藍綠兩大黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/540.wav", + "text": "出來跟社會道歉嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/541.wav", + "text": "也正是因為那件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/542.wav", + "text": "從頭到尾太丟臉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/543.wav", + "text": "嘛丟臉到不想要請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/544.wav", + "text": "行政院院長來院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/545.wav", + "text": "大家就直接趕快把票投一投" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/546.wav", + "text": "讓覆議案成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/547.wav", + "text": "\n你要還原歷史真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/548.wav", + "text": "那就把事情談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/549.wav", + "text": "再去扯以前的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/550.wav", + "text": "因為這就不是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/551.wav", + "text": "要談的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/552.wav", + "text": "我們大家今天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/553.wav", + "text": "都有委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/554.wav", + "text": "要去質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/555.wav", + "text": "我們昨天接到院長的通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/556.wav", + "text": "因為這是重大事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/557.wav", + "text": "我們也是趕快趕來這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/558.wav", + "text": "希望協商可以早一點結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/559.wav", + "text": "我們就可以去各個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/560.wav", + "text": "\n回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/561.wav", + "text": "剛剛院長所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/562.wav", + "text": "問的問題本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/563.wav", + "text": "對於A案（明天就要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/564.wav", + "text": "）還是B案（禮拜一開全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/565.wav", + "text": "禮拜二來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/566.wav", + "text": "）台灣民眾黨黨團都可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/567.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/568.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃國昌總召\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/569.wav", + "text": "接下來請吳思瑤幹事長發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/570.wav", + "text": "事實有關會計法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/571.wav", + "text": "覆議案很清楚就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/572.wav", + "text": "覆議案不要扯到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/573.wav", + "text": "會計法之前修法的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/574.wav", + "text": "提出會計法的覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/575.wav", + "text": "案就是針對會計法第99條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/576.wav", + "text": "增列第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/577.wav", + "text": "支用研究計畫費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/578.wav", + "text": "不罰人員之範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/579.wav", + "text": "依立法委員提案各版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/580.wav", + "text": "之條文及說明均含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/581.wav", + "text": "所以確實是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/582.wav", + "text": "欠明確及恐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/583.wav", + "text": "執行產生爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/584.wav", + "text": "這是2013年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/585.wav", + "text": "提出會計法第99條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/586.wav", + "text": "的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/587.wav", + "text": "覆議案的緣由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/588.wav", + "text": "\n黃國昌委員扯遠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/589.wav", + "text": "你扯到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/590.wav", + "text": "會計法在修正討論的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/591.wav", + "text": "但是我們今天在講覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/592.wav", + "text": "不是嗎覆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/593.wav", + "text": "覆議案的事實真相就是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/594.wav", + "text": "當初議事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/595.wav", + "text": "誤植三讀文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/596.wav", + "text": "就是漏了一個教職員的教字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/597.wav", + "text": "所以行政院在那個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/598.wav", + "text": "提出覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/599.wav", + "text": "也正因為它只是補正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/600.wav", + "text": "文字的疏漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/601.wav", + "text": "所以非常快那一次的覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/602.wav", + "text": "同一天處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/603.wav", + "text": "詢答時各黨只派一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/604.wav", + "text": "���民黨一個民進黨一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/605.wav", + "text": "親民黨一個台聯一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/606.wav", + "text": "而且每個人只發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/607.wav", + "text": "言3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/608.wav", + "text": "這些都可以佐證會計法當時覆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/609.wav", + "text": "覆議的緣由就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/610.wav", + "text": "文字疏漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/611.wav", + "text": "這個一定要補正說明好嗎\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/612.wav", + "text": "我還是覺得有一點小小的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/613.wav", + "text": "不解和遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/614.wav", + "text": "我覺得這一屆的立法委員為什麼對於每次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/615.wav", + "text": "要討論的事情大家都不太願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/616.wav", + "text": "花時間討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/617.wav", + "text": "我必須說朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/618.wav", + "text": "何其重要各黨鞭在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/619.wav", + "text": "處理今天的主題叫做覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/620.wav", + "text": "我們好好交換意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/621.wav", + "text": "這個討論何其珍貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/622.wav", + "text": "這是一個補正的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/623.wav", + "text": "所以同樣我們都登記了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/624.wav", + "text": "各個委員會的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/625.wav", + "text": "但是黨鞭的職責就是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/626.wav", + "text": "把這個覆議案的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/627.wav", + "text": "好好處理我不希望大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/628.wav", + "text": "坐在這裡都是趕鴨子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/629.wav", + "text": "時間快委員會要質詢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/630.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/631.wav", + "text": "不要有時間壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/632.wav", + "text": "因為這樣發言我覺得壓力好大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/633.wav", + "text": "不要讓這一屆的立法院成為最不愛討論的立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/634.wav", + "text": "這樣是不好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/635.wav", + "text": "\n回到今天的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/636.wav", + "text": "中華民國行政院跟立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/637.wav", + "text": "行政院提出覆議案是第14次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/638.wav", + "text": "所以有非常清楚的運作規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/639.wav", + "text": "民進黨也絕對遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/640.wav", + "text": "議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/641.wav", + "text": "不會因為杯葛讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/642.wav", + "text": "來不及在15天之後就失效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/643.wav", + "text": "這個前提非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/644.wav", + "text": "我相信各黨都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/645.wav", + "text": "不會有任何一黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/646.wav", + "text": "要刻意蓄意的杯葛讓覆議案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/647.wav", + "text": "運作行使投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/648.wav", + "text": "是不順利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/649.wav", + "text": "我想各黨都展現了這種民主精神跟風度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/650.wav", + "text": "不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/651.wav", + "text": "因為不會有人惡意杯葛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/652.wav", + "text": "所以就沒有擔心15天處理不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/653.wav", + "text": "的那個時間壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/654.wav", + "text": "或者是儘早處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/655.wav", + "text": "的那種時間壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/656.wav", + "text": "因此從時間點來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/657.wav", + "text": "我們應當讓這個覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/658.wav", + "text": "成為這一次的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/659.wav", + "text": "跟行政院認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/660.wav", + "text": "窒礙難行的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/661.wav", + "text": "再一次補課的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/662.wav", + "text": "我用補課來形容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/663.wav", + "text": "也是再一次對話的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/664.wav", + "text": "也是再一次審視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/665.wav", + "text": "的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/666.wav", + "text": "擴權法案裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/667.wav", + "text": "已經失掉了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/668.wav", + "text": "討論的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/669.wav", + "text": "這一次覆議案的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/670.wav", + "text": "review補課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/671.wav", + "text": "補正的機會不要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/672.wav", + "text": "重蹈覆轍不要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/673.wav", + "text": "快轉不要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/674.wav", + "text": "就表決就處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/675.wav", + "text": "我覺得社會在看我們各黨的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/676.wav", + "text": "覆議的本質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/677.wav", + "text": "就是review" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/678.wav", + "text": "re-discussion" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/679.wav", + "text": "大家去重新審視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/680.wav", + "text": "這個議案本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/681.wav", + "text": "所以也沒有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/682.wav", + "text": "快快快投票投票投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/683.wav", + "text": "快轉快轉快轉真的不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/684.wav", + "text": "再重蹈覆轍一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/685.wav", + "text": "不需要把時間壓縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/686.wav", + "text": "得那麼緊這是第二個我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/687.wav", + "text": "有充裕的時間在15天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/688.wav", + "text": "之內各黨有共識這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/689.wav", + "text": "沒有時間的壓力\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/690.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/691.wav", + "text": "因為要重新審視所以院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/692.wav", + "text": "要來報告他當然要來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/693.wav", + "text": "他當然要來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/694.wav", + "text": "他當然要提出行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/695.wav", + "text": "認為窒礙難���的層面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/696.wav", + "text": "所以院長來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/697.wav", + "text": "各黨都應當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/698.wav", + "text": "有充分完整的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/699.wav", + "text": "好好對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/700.wav", + "text": "所以非常樂意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/701.wav", + "text": "我個人都認為歡迎各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/702.wav", + "text": "都安排人來問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/703.wav", + "text": "因為它就是一個review的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/704.wav", + "text": "我相信在野黨對於行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/705.wav", + "text": "詢問的時間來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/706.wav", + "text": "好好再討論一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/707.wav", + "text": "\n我以過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/708.wav", + "text": "13次覆議案我就挑時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/709.wav", + "text": "比較近的幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/710.wav", + "text": "我們來看看那個討論的密度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/711.wav", + "text": "我從比較近的講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/712.wav", + "text": "地政士的發言人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/713.wav", + "text": "是國民黨7個民進黨7個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/714.wav", + "text": "台聯2個無黨1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/715.wav", + "text": "所以加起來是17位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/716.wav", + "text": "每位各10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/717.wav", + "text": "因為要好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/718.wav", + "text": "嘛會計法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/719.wav", + "text": "因為會計法剛剛說是文字疏漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/720.wav", + "text": "所以4個黨都只派1個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/721.wav", + "text": "1個人只有3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/722.wav", + "text": "它是一個例外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/723.wav", + "text": "再來在2008年的農會法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/724.wav", + "text": "那是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/725.wav", + "text": "國民黨民進黨親民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/726.wav", + "text": "台聯無盟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/727.wav", + "text": "那時候有無黨聯盟每一位10分鐘各派1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/728.wav", + "text": "所以是5位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/729.wav", + "text": "發言319" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/730.wav", + "text": "真相調查委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/731.wav", + "text": "覆議案那個條例的覆議案是2004" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/732.wav", + "text": "年當時民進黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/733.wav", + "text": "8個國民黨6個親民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/734.wav", + "text": "4個台聯2個無盟2個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/735.wav", + "text": "無黨1個加起來是23個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/736.wav", + "text": "委員每位10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/737.wav", + "text": "在2003的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/738.wav", + "text": "公投法覆議案裡頭一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/739.wav", + "text": "民進黨8個國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/740.wav", + "text": "6個親民黨4個台聯2個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/741.wav", + "text": "無盟2個無黨1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/742.wav", + "text": "加起來是23位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/743.wav", + "text": "每位10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/744.wav", + "text": "台聯2個無黨1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/745.wav", + "text": "加起來15個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/746.wav", + "text": "然後每個是5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/747.wav", + "text": "\n我花一點時間把我所整理的這些人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/748.wav", + "text": "講出來就是朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/749.wav", + "text": "行政跟立法之間都非常重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/750.wav", + "text": "覆議案的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/751.wav", + "text": "因為它就是一個再討論的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/752.wav", + "text": "然後委員充分的welcome" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/753.wav", + "text": "而且多則一位10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/754.wav", + "text": "以上或是大家認為有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/755.wav", + "text": "這次一個要15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/756.wav", + "text": "這都可以談一個充分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/757.wav", + "text": "討論的前提是覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/758.wav", + "text": "行使的一個很重要的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/759.wav", + "text": "所以我認為好好的讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/760.wav", + "text": "委員們跟行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/761.wav", + "text": "時間也不能快轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/762.wav", + "text": "跳號人數少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/763.wav", + "text": "然後每個問短短我想這不是大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/764.wav", + "text": "想要的覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/765.wav", + "text": "距離提出到行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/766.wav", + "text": "表決投票的那一刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/767.wav", + "text": "我同樣以過去的幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/768.wav", + "text": "經驗來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/769.wav", + "text": "地政士法是7天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/770.wav", + "text": "送達跟結束是7天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/771.wav", + "text": "會計法因為是文字疏漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/772.wav", + "text": "所以它很快2天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/773.wav", + "text": "農會法是花了13天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/774.wav", + "text": "319真調的條例是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/775.wav", + "text": "花了12天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/776.wav", + "text": "公投法是花了7到8天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/777.wav", + "text": "然後財劃法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/778.wav", + "text": "花了13天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/779.wav", + "text": "換言之都在這個合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/780.wav", + "text": "15天裡面但因為是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/781.wav", + "text": "重大議案我以我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/782.wav", + "text": "講的像財劃法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/783.wav", + "text": "319真調的特別條例或是農會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/784.wav", + "text": "法那個是很大的重大議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/785.wav", + "text": "都是讓大家有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/786.wav", + "text": "審視的充分時間所以都花到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/787.wav", + "text": "13天12天去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/788.wav", + "text": "行使它所以我以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/789.wav", + "text": "過去執行的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/790.wav", + "text": "跟套用在這一次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/791.wav", + "text": "覆議案裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/792.wav", + "text": "大家都認同它是一個重大議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/793.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/794.wav", + "text": "要在審視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/795.wav", + "text": "的過程review的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/796.wav", + "text": "充分的給空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/797.wav", + "text": "給時間而這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/798.wav", + "text": "review過程不只給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/799.wav", + "text": "立委跟行政部門冷靜思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/800.wav", + "text": "好好再對話同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/801.wav", + "text": "我們也很樂見各黨都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/802.wav", + "text": "各地有公民的宣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/803.wav", + "text": "這都是好事就是讓社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/804.wav", + "text": "也去討論關注這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/805.wav", + "text": "這都好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/806.wav", + "text": "所以綜結來講我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/807.wav", + "text": "歸納了過去表決的行使時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/808.wav", + "text": "到詢答所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/809.wav", + "text": "花費的各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/810.wav", + "text": "派出來的精銳好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/811.wav", + "text": "來跟行政院再battle" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/812.wav", + "text": "一次對於法案到底有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/813.wav", + "text": "違憲到底有沒有窒礙難行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/814.wav", + "text": "好好的來發言過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/815.wav", + "text": "發言人數的安排跟時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/816.wav", + "text": "的安排乃至於回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/817.wav", + "text": "覆議案的本質這次國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/818.wav", + "text": "擴權法案的本質它的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/819.wav", + "text": "非常大不管對於行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/820.wav", + "text": "立法的權力行使甚至對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/821.wav", + "text": "人民的權利義務的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/822.wav", + "text": "也都受到影響的前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/823.wav", + "text": "下重大議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/824.wav", + "text": "不要再有時間壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/825.wav", + "text": "然後為快而快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/826.wav", + "text": "我個人都認為review" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/827.wav", + "text": "的機會就好好地重新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/828.wav", + "text": "再來審視條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/829.wav", + "text": "所以在這樣的前提下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/830.wav", + "text": "不會有人去杯葛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/831.wav", + "text": "讓它拖過15天自動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/832.wav", + "text": "失效不會所以don'tworry" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/833.wav", + "text": "因此我個人會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/834.wav", + "text": "現在的時間點如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/835.wav", + "text": "從今天是6月13日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/836.wav", + "text": "13日我們在協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/837.wav", + "text": "那到我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/838.wav", + "text": "的時間要是25號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/839.wav", + "text": "嘛所以其實下週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/840.wav", + "text": "或下下週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/841.wav", + "text": "就是一個關鍵的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/842.wav", + "text": "我個人認為以我剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/843.wav", + "text": "充分再討論再對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/844.wav", + "text": "再審視的這個精神以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/845.wav", + "text": "援引過去的執行慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/846.wav", + "text": "我認為下週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/847.wav", + "text": "都會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/848.wav", + "text": "在那個時間裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/849.wav", + "text": "可以踐行我剛剛期待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/850.wav", + "text": "各黨再發言再討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/851.wav", + "text": "那個創造最大對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/852.wav", + "text": "空間的前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/853.wav", + "text": "院長我現在沒有就時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/854.wav", + "text": "上來做因為我認為那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/855.wav", + "text": "是時間點等一下大家來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/856.wav", + "text": "我現在在處理一個大的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/857.wav", + "text": "跟態度的分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/858.wav", + "text": "提到就是17號18號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/859.wav", + "text": "我反而認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/860.wav", + "text": "後面的院會有18號的院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/861.wav", + "text": "21號的院會25號的院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/862.wav", + "text": "21號跟25號都是一個可行的選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/863.wav", + "text": "我是在說明就沒有一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/864.wav", + "text": "18號的那個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/865.wav", + "text": "那覆議的目的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/866.wav", + "text": "re-discussion" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/867.wav", + "text": "我們不能再一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/868.wav", + "text": "沒有討論就要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/869.wav", + "text": "這是我的態度也很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/870.wav", + "text": "懇切地跟大家分享我的觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/871.wav", + "text": "第一個希望能夠充分地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/872.wav", + "text": "應該在發言人數這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/873.wav", + "text": "延長一點能夠大家更冷靜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/874.wav", + "text": "來面對所以他的時間是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/875.wav", + "text": "6月21號星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/876.wav", + "text": "或者是6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/877.wav", + "text": "25號星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/878.wav", + "text": "這就是踩線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/879.wav", + "text": "報告我還是在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/880.wav", + "text": "我沒有在我這一輪的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/881.wav", + "text": "去做出時間的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/882.wav", + "text": "我只是在說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/883.wav", + "text": "有三次院會都是可以選擇的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/884.wav", + "text": "那針對洪孟楷書記長剛才所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/885.wav", + "text": "完全不可能謝謝院長讓我再說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/886.wav", + "text": "明天的議程昨天的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/887.wav", + "text": "委員會都已經排好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/888.wav", + "text": "所以明天不可能早上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/889.wav", + "text": "我們透過朝野協商來變更這樣對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/890.wav", + "text": "已經安排質詢的委員也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/891.wav", + "text": "不好所以明天是不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/892.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/893.wav", + "text": "要急得這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/894.wav", + "text": "B案18號我認為也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/895.wav", + "text": "辦法達到我說的再審視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/896.wav", + "text": "再討論的這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/897.wav", + "text": "請準備發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/898.wav", + "text": "現在請莊瑞雄書記長請發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/899.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛不是講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/900.wav", + "text": "三個黨團大家輪嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/901.wav", + "text": "如果這個是規則我們就按照這個規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/902.wav", + "text": "等一下跳來跳去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/903.wav", + "text": "院長你到底主持會議是在聽黃國昌指揮嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/904.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/905.wav", + "text": "等一下我把它講完好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/906.wav", + "text": "一開始的時候因為他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/907.wav", + "text": "要談覆議案我們提出來他們有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/908.wav", + "text": "所以他們有意見先講嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/909.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁黃國昌嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/910.wav", + "text": "然後是我嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/911.wav", + "text": "然後現在又可以跳來跳去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/912.wav", + "text": "但他一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/913.wav", + "text": "等一下你聽我講完好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/914.wav", + "text": "現在既然可以跳來跳去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/915.wav", + "text": "後來大家回應就是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/916.wav", + "text": "然後現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/917.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷舉手要我等沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/918.wav", + "text": "但你剛才先跳過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/919.wav", + "text": "他講完換他講換我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/920.wav", + "text": "我就等洪孟楷講完再來講嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/921.wav", + "text": "這個對你有利就要跳來跳去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/922.wav", + "text": "你就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/923.wav", + "text": "程序性的問題上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/924.wav", + "text": "亂打轉嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/925.wav", + "text": "院長你主持會議要有定見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/926.wav", + "text": "我絕對公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/927.wav", + "text": "現在先以黨團為最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/928.wav", + "text": "現在如果是洪孟楷二次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/929.wav", + "text": "黃國昌二次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/930.wav", + "text": "我們一定要徵詢他嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/931.wav", + "text": "他們如果放棄發言我們就另外沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/932.wav", + "text": "剛才你已經裁示過了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/933.wav", + "text": "思瑤講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/934.wav", + "text": "這裡面有一個小小的不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/935.wav", + "text": "你說第一輪按照程序第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/936.wav", + "text": "開始又隨便插了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/937.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/938.wav", + "text": "你到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/939.wav", + "text": "我沒有在急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/940.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/941.wav", + "text": "等一下我要講清楚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/942.wav", + "text": "現在是第三輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/943.wav", + "text": "你說第一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/944.wav", + "text": "照順序以後就可以隨便插了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/945.wav", + "text": "不是我們尊重不同的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/946.wav", + "text": "我馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/947.wav", + "text": "你也不要來插啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/948.wav", + "text": "黃國昌罵到我的時候我要馬上回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/949.wav", + "text": "你不能回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/950.wav", + "text": "這個遊戲規則我OK啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/951.wav", + "text": "如果黨團放棄的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/952.wav", + "text": "今天到目前沒有人在放棄啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/953.wav", + "text": "但以前有放棄的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/954.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/955.wav", + "text": "以前是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/956.wav", + "text": "好你先講我接著後面講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/957.wav", + "text": "什麼叫人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/958.wav", + "text": "什麼叫言論自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/959.wav", + "text": "你在黃總召後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/960.wav", + "text": "那他呢他怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/961.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/962.wav", + "text": "我希望你公正不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/963.wav", + "text": "跟柯總召無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/964.wav", + "text": "院長看起來是很公沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/965.wav", + "text": "院長這個跟他無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/966.wav", + "text": "這是你跟我的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/967.wav", + "text": "不是你剛剛本來就說輪到我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/968.wav", + "text": "你話也都亂講啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/969.wav", + "text": "剛剛是黃國昌在講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/970.wav", + "text": "他們兩個在吵架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/971.wav", + "text": "我還試圖制止他們兩個讓他繼續講下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/972.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做干脆你就整個怎樣我就關掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/973.wav", + "text": "你說下一個輪到我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/974.wav", + "text": "不是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/975.wav", + "text": "你剛剛是不是講說吳思瑤講完換我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/976.wav", + "text": "本來是該輪到我講的院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/977.wav", + "text": "該要有原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/978.wav", + "text": "這裡所謂的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/979.wav", + "text": "什麼叫看到我的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/980.wav", + "text": "我在主持會議當然要公平不是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/981.wav", + "text": "那你不是說輪到我嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/982.wav", + "text": "我是啊但其他黨團要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/983.wav", + "text": "我當然要讓他發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/984.wav", + "text": "那你就不要講待會輪到我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/985.wav", + "text": "不然你就不要指定我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/986.wav", + "text": "你也很愛演啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/987.wav", + "text": "我在演什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/988.wav", + "text": "我也是不是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/989.wav", + "text": "不是因為他是黨團其他黨團提出發言我必須尊重他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/990.wav", + "text": "等到他們發言完還是會回到你不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/991.wav", + "text": "你就要跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/992.wav", + "text": "莊委員不好意思現在換黨團來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/993.wav", + "text": "你稍微這樣講我會舒服一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/994.wav", + "text": "莊委員不好意思現在換黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/995.wav", + "text": "不是嘛院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/996.wav", + "text": "他不是黨團嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/997.wav", + "text": "我不是黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/998.wav", + "text": "他們講幾次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/999.wav", + "text": "我都還沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1000.wav", + "text": "好他們講幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1001.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1002.wav", + "text": "你什麼時候讓我講過話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1003.wav", + "text": "我沒有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1004.wav", + "text": "是你點名等一下接下來是我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1005.wav", + "text": "你那個才叫吼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1006.wav", + "text": "你這個才叫吼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1007.wav", + "text": "啦我也可以挑戰你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1008.wav", + "text": "啊你是立委我也是立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1009.wav", + "text": "啊你只是人家選出來你叫做院長而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1010.wav", + "text": "那你繼續喊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1011.wav", + "text": "啊喔我是院長我朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1012.wav", + "text": "啊我挑戰你剛好而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1013.wav", + "text": "喊再大聲一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1014.wav", + "text": "誰制止你講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1015.wav", + "text": "你剛剛裁示輪到我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1016.wav", + "text": "為什麼你又跳過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1017.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做你已經說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1018.wav", + "text": "是你指揮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1019.wav", + "text": "我終於知道你為什麼血壓會高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1020.wav", + "text": "因為你太不講道理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1021.wav", + "text": "等一下會回到民進黨黨團身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1022.wav", + "text": "你就可以發言了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1023.wav", + "text": "院長你還是要有固定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1024.wav", + "text": "遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1025.wav", + "text": "剛剛不要裁示輪到我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1026.wav", + "text": "我不會有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1027.wav", + "text": "不要戴帽子我耍什麼權威了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1028.wav", + "text": "那為什麼剛才你點名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1029.wav", + "text": "你刻意跳過去給別人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1030.wav", + "text": "這是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1031.wav", + "text": "那更糟糕了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1032.wav", + "text": "院長那更糟糕了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1033.wav", + "text": "\n院長是你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1034.wav", + "text": "對著我你認為你是院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1035.wav", + "text": "我必須要跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1036.wav", + "text": "剛剛黃國昌在講的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1037.wav", + "text": "是你們講你尊重他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1038.wav", + "text": "但你就變成不尊重我了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1039.wav", + "text": "耶你還沒搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1040.wav", + "text": "你不要裁示我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1041.wav", + "text": "講你跳別人我沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1042.wav", + "text": "嘛這裡本來就是你院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1043.wav", + "text": "在主持朝野協商嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1044.wav", + "text": "你也安撫我一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1045.wav", + "text": "你贏要尊重你就尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1046.wav", + "text": "你一定會尊重你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1047.wav", + "text": "嘛可是你幹嘛給我耍這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1048.wav", + "text": "我在耍什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1049.wav", + "text": "你不是裁示過接下來輪到我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1050.wav", + "text": "我已經等很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1051.wav", + "text": "你還在雞蛋裡挑鋼筋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1052.wav", + "text": "不是挑骨頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1053.wav", + "text": "什麼叫我挑鋼筋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1054.wav", + "text": "你如果不裁示是我的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1055.wav", + "text": "我跟各位黨團幹部再一次報告因為我們只有三個黨的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1056.wav", + "text": "這個發言次序上很容易就運作就ABC三大塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1057.wav", + "text": "以後還是以黨團為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1058.wav", + "text": "如果黨團個別成員放棄發言沒有關係那就視同放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1059.wav", + "text": "但是黨團輪流我再���申一遍以黨團為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1060.wav", + "text": "以黨團為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1061.wav", + "text": "如果以黨團為主就不會出大亂子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1062.wav", + "text": "也不會有個人的情緒等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1063.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我們請國民黨黨團洪孟楷書記長二次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1064.wav", + "text": "這個遊戲規則怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1065.wav", + "text": "我們坐下來對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1066.wav", + "text": "因為在野黨有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1067.wav", + "text": "我先講我們回答對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1068.wav", + "text": "接下去也應該是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1069.wav", + "text": "可是我們有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1070.wav", + "text": "你聽我講我們大家平心靜氣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1071.wav", + "text": "這個遊戲規則就是柯總召恕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1072.wav", + "text": "你再算一算我們就數羊數羊12345算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1073.wav", + "text": "第一次是傅總召發言一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1074.wav", + "text": "第二次是洪孟楷書記長兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1075.wav", + "text": "第三次是黃國昌發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1076.wav", + "text": "他再發言二二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1077.wav", + "text": "黃國昌為什麼可以發言二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1078.wav", + "text": "因為他們另外的吳春城不講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1079.wav", + "text": "沒有不講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1080.wav", + "text": "以黨團為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1081.wav", + "text": "那他們還有一個沒有來他也可以發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1082.wav", + "text": "不講話就放棄嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1083.wav", + "text": "他還可以講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1084.wav", + "text": "那他們還有一個沒有來他也可以講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1085.wav", + "text": "不要拗啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1086.wav", + "text": "我是講良心話啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1087.wav", + "text": "吳春城不講話他可以講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1088.wav", + "text": "我上次不是說那我出去換一個人進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1089.wav", + "text": "你說這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1090.wav", + "text": "他們另外還有一個沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1091.wav", + "text": "沒有來就放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1092.wav", + "text": "沒有講話就放棄嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1093.wav", + "text": "你們三個都講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1094.wav", + "text": "在場五個都講話我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1095.wav", + "text": "講完話我們三個再講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1096.wav", + "text": "這個就是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1097.wav", + "text": "我們不是不講話我們請書記長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1098.wav", + "text": "對啊沒有關係你就放棄了你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1099.wav", + "text": "你不講話就放棄嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1100.wav", + "text": "那你現在洪孟楷就不能講話了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1101.wav", + "text": "照你這個邏輯洪孟楷就不能二次發言了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1102.wav", + "text": "因為林思���還沒可以講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1103.wav", + "text": "可以講話可以講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1104.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1105.wav", + "text": "請說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1106.wav", + "text": "我們剛才講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1107.wav", + "text": "在野黨五個都講話我都沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1108.wav", + "text": "換我們三個講話你們不會有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1109.wav", + "text": "好林思銘不講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1110.wav", + "text": "就代表他不講有人代表講就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1111.wav", + "text": "吳春城不講也是他講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1112.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1113.wav", + "text": "他不講他就放棄了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1114.wav", + "text": "那我們這邊三個都要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1115.wav", + "text": "三個都可以講你們三個都可以講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1116.wav", + "text": "我沒有意見啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1117.wav", + "text": "你們一次五個人講完換我們三個人講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1118.wav", + "text": "這個是遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1119.wav", + "text": "為什麼突然出現你可以改來改去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1120.wav", + "text": "黃國昌可以講兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1121.wav", + "text": "因為他講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1122.wav", + "text": "柯總召我只問你洪孟楷可不可以二次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1123.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1124.wav", + "text": "那黃國昌為什麼不能二次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1125.wav", + "text": "可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1126.wav", + "text": "那等我們第一次發言先講完再來二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1127.wav", + "text": "黨團輪流過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1128.wav", + "text": "第一次講完再二輪嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1129.wav", + "text": "當然是這樣對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1130.wav", + "text": "現在第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1131.wav", + "text": "沒有現在第一輪還沒講完他還沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1132.wav", + "text": "所以你們等一下可以是莊瑞雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1133.wav", + "text": "柯總召你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1134.wav", + "text": "你們三個都要講我們沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1135.wav", + "text": "你們兩個講多久我都沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1136.wav", + "text": "我們三個都講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1137.wav", + "text": "怎麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1138.wav", + "text": "現在是國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1139.wav", + "text": "讓國民黨團第三次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1140.wav", + "text": "柯總召我算給你聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1141.wav", + "text": "一開始進來國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1142.wav", + "text": "你也宣告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1143.wav", + "text": "過突然把他剝奪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1144.wav", + "text": "沒有剝奪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1145.wav", + "text": "他的意見就是這樣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1146.wav", + "text": "柯總召三十秒鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1147.wav", + "text": "您先把麥克風關起來好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1148.wav", + "text": "麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1149.wav", + "text": "因為現在已經唱名洪孟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1150.wav", + "text": "你就按麥克風講我們協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1151.wav", + "text": "都是直播的沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1152.wav", + "text": "是講道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1153.wav", + "text": "我們讓洪孟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1154.wav", + "text": "我有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1155.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄剛才在吵就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1156.wav", + "text": "說第一輪他還沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1157.wav", + "text": "你現在是講到關鍵的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1158.wav", + "text": "要趕快叫洪孟楷出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1159.wav", + "text": "來爭辯嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1160.wav", + "text": "這一起回答沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1161.wav", + "text": "都有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1162.wav", + "text": "情你不能說你們兩個講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1163.wav", + "text": "是你不要說的問題嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1164.wav", + "text": "沒關係等一下再說沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1165.wav", + "text": "你們一開始不是兩個人講嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1166.wav", + "text": "你們一開始不是兩個人講嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1167.wav", + "text": "對啊所以你三個都可以講啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1168.wav", + "text": "他不講是他的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1169.wav", + "text": "那現在是國民黨團發言啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1170.wav", + "text": "黨團要派誰是我們的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1171.wav", + "text": "你們民進黨團管到國民黨團誰發言啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1172.wav", + "text": "所以要用黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1173.wav", + "text": "我們誰講話還要經過你同意喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1174.wav", + "text": "我們黨團要派誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1175.wav", + "text": "要經過你同意喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1176.wav", + "text": "你們三個都講我也沒有意見啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1177.wav", + "text": "什麼閉嘴我們三個都要講啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1178.wav", + "text": "我沒有說你們三個不能講啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1179.wav", + "text": "等到你們民進黨團發言的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1180.wav", + "text": "你們就可以講啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1181.wav", + "text": "你為什麼說他不能講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1182.wav", + "text": "因為你們民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1183.wav", + "text": "第三輪發言還沒有到啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1184.wav", + "text": "我們現在是第三輪第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1185.wav", + "text": "現在已經第三輪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1186.wav", + "text": "第一輪第一次傅崐萁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1187.wav", + "text": "第一輪第二次黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1188.wav", + "text": "第一輪第三次你柯建銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1189.wav", + "text": "第二輪第三次吳思瑤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1190.wav", + "text": "所以現在進入第三輪第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1191.wav", + "text": "你可以理解嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1192.wav", + "text": "思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1193.wav", + "text": "一輪就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1194.wav", + "text": "裁示進入到第三輪的第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1195.wav", + "text": "國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1196.wav", + "text": "不可能嘛我已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1197.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷發言了嘛你為什麼要這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1198.wav", + "text": "呢等一下就馬上回到你們民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1199.wav", + "text": "是黃國昌給你設下的陷阱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1200.wav", + "text": "不是陷阱以黨團是公平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1201.wav", + "text": "你到底是聽黃國昌還是聽傅崐萁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1202.wav", + "text": "還是你真正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1203.wav", + "text": "依黨團發言是公平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1204.wav", + "text": "把莊瑞雄剝奪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1205.wav", + "text": "他連講都還沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1206.wav", + "text": "你還講第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1207.wav", + "text": "但是他們黨團到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1208.wav", + "text": "他不講的是他的事情啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1209.wav", + "text": "你要第二輪第三輪講也沒有問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1210.wav", + "text": "現在洪孟楷請發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1211.wav", + "text": "接下來請民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1212.wav", + "text": "主席非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1213.wav", + "text": "我們都看得出來第一輪是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1214.wav", + "text": "三個黨團輪流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1215.wav", + "text": "第二輪也是讓國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1216.wav", + "text": "再民眾黨團再民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1217.wav", + "text": "民進黨團第一輪的第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1218.wav", + "text": "是柯建銘總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1219.wav", + "text": "第二輪的第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1220.wav", + "text": "是吳思瑤委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1221.wav", + "text": "所以等一下民進黨團有第三次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1222.wav", + "text": "發言的但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1223.wav", + "text": "麼不你可以不要再插話了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1224.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1225.wav", + "text": "我們現在是第三輪第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1226.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1227.wav", + "text": "那是不是可以不要再插話了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1228.wav", + "text": "您就是在我說話的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1229.wav", + "text": "您在插我的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1230.wav", + "text": "現在是大家在討論程序的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1231.wav", + "text": "我們沒有在討論程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1232.wav", + "text": "我在進入實質發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1233.wav", + "text": "我沒有在討論程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1234.wav", + "text": "我在進入實質發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1235.wav", + "text": "剛剛主席也已經裁示我來發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1236.wav", + "text": "我們一開始就已經尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1237.wav", + "text": "柯總召你這樣子就是在插話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1238.wav", + "text": "的人都看到您在插話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1239.wav", + "text": "我現在在講說沒關係你儘管說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1240.wav", + "text": "但不要把莊瑞雄丟包好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1241.wav", + "text": "就第三輪的時候不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1242.wav", + "text": "傅總召麻煩把麥克風壓掉謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1243.wav", + "text": "請洪孟楷書記長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1244.wav", + "text": "好我想黨團發言不是個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1245.wav", + "text": "我們今天在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1246.wav", + "text": "並不是因為我是洪孟楷所以我有發言權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1247.wav", + "text": "這個會期第一次開會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1248.wav", + "text": "主席就講得非常明確我們今天來這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1249.wav", + "text": "幹部有可能會換人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1250.wav", + "text": "所以當下一個會期我不是書記長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1251.wav", + "text": "都非常的明確感謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1252.wav", + "text": "\n再來我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1253.wav", + "text": "很負責任的也提出了方案一跟方案二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1254.wav", + "text": "其實不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1255.wav", + "text": "是方案一或是方案二都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1256.wav", + "text": "不是快轉我們當然也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1257.wav", + "text": "覆議案是行政院的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1258.wav", + "text": "行政院提出來覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1259.wav", + "text": "議立法院就要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1260.wav", + "text": "要有充分討論的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1261.wav", + "text": "那覆議案為什麼會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1262.wav", + "text": "訂時間15天裡面要處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1263.wav", + "text": "重大政策我們當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1264.wav", + "text": "要在一定時間內去做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1265.wav", + "text": "而且這個是全國國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1266.wav", + "text": "關注的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1267.wav", + "text": "媒體朋友也關心國人也關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1268.wav", + "text": "覆議案處理完畢之後我們還有很多民生議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1269.wav", + "text": "法案也要處理不要因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1270.wav", + "text": "耽擱了很多民生議題法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1271.wav", + "text": "也因此我們提出方案一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1272.wav", + "text": "跟方案二並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1273.wav", + "text": "要所謂的快轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1274.wav", + "text": "我們當然也希望充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1275.wav", + "text": "所以這就是為什麼我們自始至終都很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1276.wav", + "text": "的要求行政院長要來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1277.wav", + "text": "並且備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1278.wav", + "text": "\n如果是用方案一即上午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1279.wav", + "text": "全院委員會下午來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1280.wav", + "text": "院會表決可能有黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1281.wav", + "text": "有意見但是我必須再重新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1282.wav", + "text": "聲明在過去13次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1283.wav", + "text": "的覆議案裡面也曾經有過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1284.wav", + "text": "上午是全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1285.wav", + "text": "下午就直接院會表決的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1286.wav", + "text": "所以這並不是我們首開先例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1287.wav", + "text": "以前就有過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1288.wav", + "text": "但我們也提出方案二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1289.wav", + "text": "（6月17日）一整天來做全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1290.wav", + "text": "請行政院長從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1291.wav", + "text": "早上9點來說明之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1292.wav", + "text": "我們備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1293.wav", + "text": "就可以依比例來推派之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1294.wav", + "text": "之假設一個人是10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1295.wav", + "text": "或是像之前專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1296.wav", + "text": "院長有15分鐘的備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1297.wav", + "text": "時間的話我們推算過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1298.wav", + "text": "也許我們總數可以抓到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1299.wav", + "text": "的政黨代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1300.wav", + "text": "平均大家分配也許就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1301.wav", + "text": "或是772" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1302.wav", + "text": "\n再來6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1303.wav", + "text": "日上午院會來做表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1304.wav", + "text": "我想以我們現在的投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1305.wav", + "text": "效率還有院長副院長的投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1306.wav", + "text": "半個小時內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1307.wav", + "text": "其實大家如果都到的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1308.wav", + "text": "就可以投完票但我們預計比較寬鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1309.wav", + "text": "所以我們抓兩個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1310.wav", + "text": "但是我們希望今天協商能夠有個但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1311.wav", + "text": "就是如果大家都已經領票了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1312.wav", + "text": "除了院長不參與投票以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1313.wav", + "text": "其餘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1314.wav", + "text": "院長也參與投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1315.wav", + "text": "如果113位委員都投票完畢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1316.wav", + "text": "開票那就不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1317.wav", + "text": "拉那麼久的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1318.wav", + "text": "因為很多委員的總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1319.wav", + "text": "我是要說非常多的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1320.wav", + "text": "真的還是希望能針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1321.wav", + "text": "新任閣揆還不到一個月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1322.wav", + "text": "質詢所以我們提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1323.wav", + "text": "符合��家剛剛所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1324.wav", + "text": "\n吳思瑤幹事長剛剛有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1325.wav", + "text": "那時候從提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1326.wav", + "text": "到覆議完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1327.wav", + "text": "是7天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1328.wav", + "text": "我們也說如果採取方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1329.wav", + "text": "二的話6月11日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1330.wav", + "text": "提出來的覆議到6月18日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1331.wav", + "text": "處理完畢是8天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1332.wav", + "text": "所以其實並沒有比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1333.wav", + "text": "跟地政士法相比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1334.wav", + "text": "或是跟其他過去的覆議案相比的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1335.wav", + "text": "其實方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1336.wav", + "text": "二的6月17日禮拜一全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1337.wav", + "text": "6月18日院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1338.wav", + "text": "表決並沒有比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1339.wav", + "text": "反而它會是落在一個非常平均的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1340.wav", + "text": "8天左右的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1341.wav", + "text": "我想也符合社會大眾的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1342.wav", + "text": "也符合我們的議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1343.wav", + "text": "更重要的是也希望能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1344.wav", + "text": "讓國人看到各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1345.wav", + "text": "對於覆議案的態度以及我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1346.wav", + "text": "後續能夠進行總質詢以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1347.wav", + "text": "各重大民生法案的後續推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1348.wav", + "text": "孟楷書記長大概兩個重點第一就是6月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1349.wav", + "text": "行政院長來然後我們詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1350.wav", + "text": "6月18號早上投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1351.wav", + "text": "下午繼續總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1352.wav", + "text": "是第二個發言人數是772" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1353.wav", + "text": "772或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1354.wav", + "text": "看其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1355.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1356.wav", + "text": "其實今天一開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1357.wav", + "text": "針對發言規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1358.wav", + "text": "我有請示過院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1359.wav", + "text": "我的記憶應該是不會錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1360.wav", + "text": "就很清楚的講是三個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1361.wav", + "text": "這樣子院長也不用在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1362.wav", + "text": "搞得很累" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1363.wav", + "text": "誰有舉手誰沒舉手誰先誰後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1364.wav", + "text": "既然這是黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1365.wav", + "text": "就是以黨團為代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1366.wav", + "text": "每一個黨團派一個代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1367.wav", + "text": "在他輪到的輪次時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1368.wav", + "text": "進行發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1369.wav", + "text": "這樣整個程序進行就會很順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1370.wav", + "text": "而不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1371.wav", + "text": "莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1372.wav", + "text": "自己按著麥克風不斷地在發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1373.wav", + "text": "\n其實剛剛發生這樣的狀況時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1374.wav", + "text": "院長也可以看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1375.wav", + "text": "我們很克制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1376.wav", + "text": "沒有搶著按麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1377.wav", + "text": "這裡是黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1378.wav", + "text": "就各個黨團把各個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1379.wav", + "text": "按照今天議事所要處理的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1380.wav", + "text": "大家把自己的立場跟意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1381.wav", + "text": "表達完整就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1382.wav", + "text": "沒有必要在別人要發言的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1383.wav", + "text": "在那邊干擾人家發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1384.wav", + "text": "這個恐怕也不是黨團協商的本質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1385.wav", + "text": "跟應該遵守的紀律及規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1386.wav", + "text": "的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1387.wav", + "text": "剛剛院長完全按照黨團來輪流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1388.wav", + "text": "發言至於各個黨團要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1389.wav", + "text": "派誰當代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1390.wav", + "text": "其他黨團當然都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1391.wav", + "text": "也不會說三道四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1392.wav", + "text": "為什麼誰講話誰不講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1393.wav", + "text": "每一個黨團要派誰講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1394.wav", + "text": "這本來就是每一個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1395.wav", + "text": "自己要決定的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1396.wav", + "text": "對於處理的時間問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1397.wav", + "text": "下禮拜一整天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1398.wav", + "text": "開全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1399.wav", + "text": "你看時間上有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1400.wav", + "text": "而各個政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1401.wav", + "text": "彼此之間的代表人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1402.wav", + "text": "基本上我們沒有太強烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1403.wav", + "text": "的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1404.wav", + "text": "公平就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1405.wav", + "text": "公平就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1406.wav", + "text": "所以17號進行全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1407.wav", + "text": "18號進行投票的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1408.wav", + "text": "我們表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1409.wav", + "text": "支持\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1410.wav", + "text": "\n第三個重點既然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1411.wav", + "text": "今天各個黨團大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1412.wav", + "text": "都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1413.wav", + "text": "不會再有占領主席臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1414.wav", + "text": "或干擾議事行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1415.wav", + "text": "避免擔心議事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1416.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法順利進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1417.wav", + "text": "今天就日期跟時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1418.wav", + "text": "大家能夠達成共識那麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1419.wav", + "text": "對不干擾議事進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1420.wav", + "text": "不去占領主席臺這樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1421.wav", + "text": "我們也能夠白紙黑字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1422.wav", + "text": "裡這樣也可以確保接下來的議事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1423.wav", + "text": "進行順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1424.wav", + "text": "以上兩點意見謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1425.wav", + "text": "國昌總召的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1426.wav", + "text": "6月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1427.wav", + "text": "院長到院說明完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1428.wav", + "text": "6月18號上午表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1429.wav", + "text": "各黨團派的代表是772" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1430.wav", + "text": "原則上也沒有太大意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1431.wav", + "text": "\n好接下來請民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1432.wav", + "text": "請莊委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1433.wav", + "text": "員會是上個禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1434.wav", + "text": "停止收案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1435.wav", + "text": "但剛好碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1436.wav", + "text": "端午節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1437.wav", + "text": "事項程序上是怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1438.wav", + "text": "停止收案後又要再增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1439.wav", + "text": "連這個都要朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1440.wav", + "text": "啦院長我提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1441.wav", + "text": "的這個是很重要的一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1442.wav", + "text": "啦\n第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1443.wav", + "text": "院長你也不要期待大家都很紳士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1444.wav", + "text": "吵來吵去很正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1445.wav", + "text": "本來就很正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1446.wav", + "text": "讓大家多一點講話的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1447.wav", + "text": "大家講了很多到最後都會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1448.wav", + "text": "所以我剛才在等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1449.wav", + "text": "為什麼會產生這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1450.wav", + "text": "因為我尊重你是主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1451.wav", + "text": "你的裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1452.wav", + "text": "裁示我都當真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1453.wav", + "text": "重點是因為這個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1454.wav", + "text": "否則他們在講話的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1455.wav", + "text": "所有對面的人在講話的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1456.wav", + "text": "動不動就批評柯總召說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1457.wav", + "text": "什麼人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1458.wav", + "text": "朝野協商大家講的話都差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1459.wav", + "text": "大家本來情緒就是一大堆啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1460.wav", + "text": "但我倒是這樣建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1461.wav", + "text": "你說在整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1462.wav", + "text": "法案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1463.wav", + "text": "藍白有他們自己的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1464.wav", + "text": "共同提出一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1465.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1466.wav", + "text": "可是在整個覆議案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1467.wav", + "text": "也不用你們大家都喬好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1468.wav", + "text": "啦既然大家覺得很重要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1469.wav", + "text": "我倒認為不用這麼急比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1470.wav", + "text": "從過去大家提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1471.wav", + "text": "不管是地政士法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1472.wav", + "text": "三一九到公民投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1473.wav", + "text": "覆議到財政收支劃分法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1474.wav", + "text": "有7天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1475.wav", + "text": "有2天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1476.wav", + "text": "但是你去看農會法又是13天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1477.wav", + "text": "財政收支劃分法在2022年那一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1478.wav", + "text": "我想各個黨團都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1479.wav", + "text": "也有13天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1480.wav", + "text": "報告完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1481.wav", + "text": "你說人數的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1482.wav", + "text": "與其大家在批評說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1483.wav", + "text": "審議的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1484.wav", + "text": "大家討論的時間比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1485.wav", + "text": "那是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1486.wav", + "text": "在這一次再做充分的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1487.wav", + "text": "我是做這樣的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1488.wav", + "text": "對整個立法院來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1489.wav", + "text": "也是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1490.wav", + "text": "藍跟白多數嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1491.wav", + "text": "到最後就遵照整個民主的程序來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1492.wav", + "text": "這也不要有過多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1493.wav", + "text": "政治攻防我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1494.wav", + "text": "可以有不同的解讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1495.wav", + "text": "我必須苦口婆心地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1496.wav", + "text": "這次我們立法院其實是重傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1497.wav", + "text": "你說國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1498.wav", + "text": "藍白認為是國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1499.wav", + "text": "可是就民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1500.wav", + "text": "來講我們就認為這個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1501.wav", + "text": "是不是我們操之過急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1502.wav", + "text": "那外界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1503.wav", + "text": "的看法又是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1504.wav", + "text": "譬如說國民黨他們也認為在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1505.wav", + "text": "臺南賴清德總統的本命區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1506.wav", + "text": "他們甚至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1507.wav", + "text": "要在那個地方辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1508.wav", + "text": "一場大型的演講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1509.wav", + "text": "而民進黨也認為應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1510.wav", + "text": "應該要讓民眾知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1511.wav", + "text": "所以各黨之間各有它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1512.wav", + "text": "那是不是我們立法院在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1513.wav", + "text": "地方既然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1514.wav", + "text": "對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1515.wav", + "text": "那有沒有可能大家今天再討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1516.wav", + "text": "這個過程比較會讓外界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1517.wav", + "text": "批評說我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1518.wav", + "text": "討論的這個程序的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1519.wav", + "text": "進行不論是黑箱也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1520.wav", + "text": "或者說逐條的部分都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1521.wav", + "text": "已經省略掉了那在這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1522.wav", + "text": "覆議案裡面大家來做更充分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1523.wav", + "text": "像國民黨剛剛所提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1524.wav", + "text": "我們大家就那一天報告完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1525.wav", + "text": "以後一天就把它解決掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1526.wav", + "text": "我在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1527.wav", + "text": "謝謝莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1528.wav", + "text": "的發言您的重點大概是兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1529.wav", + "text": "第一個就是時間可以往後退一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1530.wav", + "text": "第二個是發言人數稍微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1531.wav", + "text": "更札實更多元一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1532.wav", + "text": "所以說772你希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1533.wav", + "text": "再放大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1534.wav", + "text": "改為11112類似像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1535.wav", + "text": "這樣的意思經過充分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1536.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團提的不是當天就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1537.wav", + "text": "表決而是第二天早上表決這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1538.wav", + "text": "有一點不太一樣\n接下來國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1539.wav", + "text": "有沒有寶貴意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1540.wav", + "text": "這樣不會亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1541.wav", + "text": "我要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1542.wav", + "text": "到目前為止我才講一次而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1543.wav", + "text": "黃國昌講三次你講兩次你現在要講第三次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1544.wav", + "text": "什麼叫黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1545.wav", + "text": "你們就講好你們誰要發言代表黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1546.wav", + "text": "每一個都可以發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1547.wav", + "text": "你們每一個都有發言少跟我搞這一套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1548.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1549.wav", + "text": "我等一下看你怎麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1550.wav", + "text": "我第二輪都還沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1551.wav", + "text": "你現在要講第三輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1552.wav", + "text": "院長你不能護航他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1553.wav", + "text": "啦他們所有辯論的都不構成理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1554.wav", + "text": "亂講一通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1555.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在已經推進到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1556.wav", + "text": "什麼日期來排定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1557.wav", + "text": "這些不需要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1558.wav", + "text": "討論的事情我們就把它按下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1559.wav", + "text": "基本上在朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1560.wav", + "text": "現在就要下結論啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1561.wav", + "text": "等一下吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1562.wav", + "text": "尊重他的發言嘛你等一下可以發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1563.wav", + "text": "這樣不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1564.wav", + "text": "我怎麼會不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1565.wav", + "text": "他講三次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1566.wav", + "text": "你又在插話了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1567.wav", + "text": "我講一次而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1568.wav", + "text": "你又在插話了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1569.wav", + "text": "我不是插話我是嚴正抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1570.wav", + "text": "我不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1571.wav", + "text": "沒關係大聲一點沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1572.wav", + "text": "我我們現在已經推進到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1573.wav", + "text": "在討論什麼時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1574.wav", + "text": "程當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1575.wav", + "text": "剛剛國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1576.wav", + "text": "已經提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1577.wav", + "text": "因為這個是全國國人矚目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1578.wav", + "text": "甚至國際也在矚目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1579.wav", + "text": "是不是明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1580.wav", + "text": "院會我們改開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1581.wav", + "text": "改開全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1582.wav", + "text": "直接來質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1583.wav", + "text": "331也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1584.wav", + "text": "講完之後下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1585.wav", + "text": "當然還有方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1586.wav", + "text": "二是17號跟18號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1587.wav", + "text": "現在執政黨有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1588.wav", + "text": "方案一就先保留沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1589.wav", + "text": "方案二的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1590.wav", + "text": "應該是比較恰當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1591.wav", + "text": "\n方案二的話就是6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1592.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1593.wav", + "text": "從早上到下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1594.wav", + "text": "一整天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1595.wav", + "text": "也不影響到二五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1596.wav", + "text": "院會的施政總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1597.wav", + "text": "時間也都沒有影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1598.wav", + "text": "如果我們禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1599.wav", + "text": "來開全院委員會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1600.wav", + "text": "從早上到下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1601.wav", + "text": "以過去慣例15分鐘來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1602.wav", + "text": "10分鐘也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1603.wav", + "text": "都沒有關係如果10分鐘的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1604.wav", + "text": "早上9點鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1605.wav", + "text": "到12點有3個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1606.wav", + "text": "下午2點半到5點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1607.wav", + "text": "也有3個小時總共有6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1608.wav", + "text": "6個小時如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1609.wav", + "text": "10分鐘的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1610.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1611.wav", + "text": "對我先把我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1612.wav", + "text": "表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1613.wav", + "text": "這樣6個小時1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1614.wav", + "text": "1個小時5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1615.wav", + "text": "所以大概可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1616.wav", + "text": "的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1617.wav", + "text": "含休息的話大概30位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1618.wav", + "text": "應該可以成行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1619.wav", + "text": "行如果11112的話至少在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1620.wav", + "text": "這個時間範圍內都還可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1621.wav", + "text": "現在應該確定兩個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1622.wav", + "text": "第一個是時間上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1623.wav", + "text": "什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1624.wav", + "text": "可以確定包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1625.wav", + "text": "到底哪一天開全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1626.wav", + "text": "哪一天來做議決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1627.wav", + "text": "現在既然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1628.wav", + "text": "執政黨對明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1629.wav", + "text": "來處理有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1630.wav", + "text": "我們就折衷一下\n下禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1631.wav", + "text": "6月17號）用一整天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1632.wav", + "text": "的全院委員會來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1633.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1634.wav", + "text": "當然還有中間院長可能要先報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1635.wav", + "text": "20分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1636.wav", + "text": "順利來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1637.wav", + "text": "\n我想有什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1638.wav", + "text": "歧見也不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1639.wav", + "text": "溝通良好因為各有各的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1640.wav", + "text": "想法及立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1641.wav", + "text": "第一個把時間定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1642.wav", + "text": "第二個我們質詢的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1643.wav", + "text": "好那是你的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1644.wav", + "text": "謝謝傅總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1645.wav", + "text": "接下來請問民眾黨黨團有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1646.wav", + "text": "有意見請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1647.wav", + "text": "他是以黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1648.wav", + "text": "什麼黨團黨團我講1次而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1649.wav", + "text": "他是什麼黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1650.wav", + "text": "超級黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1651.wav", + "text": "啊他可以講4次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1652.wav", + "text": "最小的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1653.wav", + "text": "有超級的以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1654.wav", + "text": "黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1655.wav", + "text": "為什麼他講第4次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1656.wav", + "text": "他是民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1657.wav", + "text": "跟特權一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1658.wav", + "text": "黨團一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1659.wav", + "text": "我想又繞回一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1660.wav", + "text": "我們在講那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1661.wav", + "text": "基本上面會議規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1662.wav", + "text": "的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1663.wav", + "text": "以黨團為代表跟以人為代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1664.wav", + "text": "這個概念的區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1665.wav", + "text": "其實沒有很複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1666.wav", + "text": "我想大家應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1667.wav", + "text": "都可以很容易地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1668.wav", + "text": "理解沒有必要在這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1669.wav", + "text": "地方上面爭執" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1670.wav", + "text": "甚至為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1671.wav", + "text": "發洩個人的情緒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1672.wav", + "text": "隨便按麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1673.wav", + "text": "在那邊恣意地指責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1674.wav", + "text": "用黨團當作代表是什麼概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1675.wav", + "text": "我想真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1676.wav", + "text": "一點都不難理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1677.wav", + "text": "\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1678.wav", + "text": "針對剛剛院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1679.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1680.wav", + "text": "772也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1681.wav", + "text": "11112也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1682.wav", + "text": "我們基本上都可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1683.wav", + "text": "雖然11112" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1684.wav", + "text": "當然在某個程度上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1685.wav", + "text": "我們可以發言的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1686.wav", + "text": "有受到一些壓縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1687.wav", + "text": "但我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1688.wav", + "text": "我也不會刻意去爭執" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1689.wav", + "text": "這樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1690.wav", + "text": "77211112都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1691.wav", + "text": "把它放大到111" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1692.wav", + "text": "我們既然有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1693.wav", + "text": "準備要花一天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1694.wav", + "text": "來進行全院委員會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1695.wav", + "text": "每一位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1696.wav", + "text": "發言的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1697.wav", + "text": "可能再拜託院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1698.wav", + "text": "請議事人員精算一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1699.wav", + "text": "是不是有可能到15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1700.wav", + "text": "還是必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1701.wav", + "text": "維持10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1702.wav", + "text": "因為我必須幫台灣民眾黨黨團講個話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1703.wav", + "text": "我們如果只有兩個人的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1704.wav", + "text": "大概只有一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1705.wav", + "text": "10分鐘的時間來予以發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1706.wav", + "text": "但我必須要再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1707.wav", + "text": "我們不強求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1708.wav", + "text": "時間上面允許的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1709.wav", + "text": "我覺得一個人15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1710.wav", + "text": "如果真的會太趕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1711.wav", + "text": "一個人10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1712.wav", + "text": "我們也會接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1713.wav", + "text": "也可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1714.wav", + "text": "\n第三個事情是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1715.wav", + "text": "因為覆議案基本上的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1716.wav", + "text": "是針對行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1717.wav", + "text": "所提出的覆議理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1718.wav", + "text": "來進行全院委員會的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1719.wav", + "text": "跟詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1720.wav", + "text": "行政院的覆議理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1721.wav", + "text": "其實已經提出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1722.wav", + "text": "它的內容也不複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1723.wav", + "text": "因為行政院所提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1724.wav", + "text": "覆議理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1725.wav", + "text": "我想大概正常的人閱讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1726.wav", + "text": "大概半個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1727.wav", + "text": "就看完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1728.wav", + "text": "既然這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1729.wav", + "text": "行政院也準備好了覆議理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1730.wav", + "text": "因為我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1731.wav", + "text": "行政院一定是經過他們的深思熟慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1732.wav", + "text": "整個行政團隊的專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1733.wav", + "text": "精煉出這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1734.wav", + "text": "覆議的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1735.wav", + "text": "這個覆議理由也都提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1736.wav", + "text": "了我相信各��黨團各個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1737.wav", + "text": "大家也都看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1738.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得在準備的時間上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1739.wav", + "text": "下個禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1740.wav", + "text": "來加以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1741.wav", + "text": "想法謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1742.wav", + "text": "謝謝民眾黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1743.wav", + "text": "接下來我們請民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1744.wav", + "text": "我現在先表示一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1745.wav", + "text": "他是超級黨團是吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1746.wav", + "text": "我現在才講第二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1747.wav", + "text": "剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1748.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄委員在抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1749.wav", + "text": "明明就講好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1750.wav", + "text": "我講完換思瑤講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1751.wav", + "text": "換莊瑞雄講你就把他跳過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1752.wav", + "text": "跳給洪孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1753.wav", + "text": "你在操作這個就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1754.wav", + "text": "現在吳思瑤講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1755.wav", + "text": "的理由裡面刺到國民黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1756.wav", + "text": "你就趕快叫黃國昌回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1757.wav", + "text": "你也趕快叫洪孟楷回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1758.wav", + "text": "這個明眼人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1759.wav", + "text": "一看就很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1760.wav", + "text": "院長我還是要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1761.wav", + "text": "這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1762.wav", + "text": "\n第二個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1763.wav", + "text": "黃國昌剛才講說以黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1764.wav", + "text": "那就全部用黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1765.wav", + "text": "一下黨團一下個人跳來跳去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1766.wav", + "text": "中間我會插話是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1767.wav", + "text": "我和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1768.wav", + "text": "這難免大家一定是彼此攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1769.wav", + "text": "嘛黃國昌講得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1770.wav", + "text": "所謂的會計法是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1771.wav", + "text": "請他不要走請黃國昌不要走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1772.wav", + "text": "我現在來講這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1773.wav", + "text": "我一個一個講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1774.wav", + "text": "我請問周萬來秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1775.wav", + "text": "委員會收案的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1776.wav", + "text": "過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1777.wav", + "text": "因為我們從6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1778.wav", + "text": "拜二才來到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1779.wav", + "text": "程序委員會就沒有開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1780.wav", + "text": "嘛禮拜二沒有開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1781.wav", + "text": "昨天禮拜三開了程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1782.wav", + "text": "超過時間收案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1783.wav", + "text": "這個是不是要朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1784.wav", + "text": "我請你認真回答這一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1785.wav", + "text": "吳宗憲委員可以逕自裁示嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1786.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄已經點出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1787.wav", + "text": "這一點我們先釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1788.wav", + "text": "我們有收件的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1789.wav", + "text": "所以我們議事處不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1790.wav", + "text": "跟人家排這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1791.wav", + "text": "所以我當時也跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1792.wav", + "text": "議事處說明不能提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1793.wav", + "text": "當天在開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1794.wav", + "text": "到底要不要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1795.wav", + "text": "這不是我們議事處裡面所能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1796.wav", + "text": "這個我講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1797.wav", + "text": "議事處不能介入到裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1798.wav", + "text": "我有跟處長特別說明過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1799.wav", + "text": "就是變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1800.wav", + "text": "你們當天的程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1801.wav", + "text": "要怎麼去決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1802.wav", + "text": "不是我們幕僚所能夠介入的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1803.wav", + "text": "這是我要特別說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1804.wav", + "text": "歷來都是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1805.wav", + "text": "超過時間要列案的一定要朝野協商同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1806.wav", + "text": "才可以列進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1807.wav", + "text": "昨天在吳宗憲主持的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1808.wav", + "text": "我們有抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1809.wav", + "text": "抗議這個不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1810.wav", + "text": "要朝野協商他就不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1811.wav", + "text": "的問題現在很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1812.wav", + "text": "沒有抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1813.wav", + "text": "是三個黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1814.wav", + "text": "有沈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1815.wav", + "text": "沈發惠有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1816.wav", + "text": "好啦你不要再講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1817.wav", + "text": "報紙都有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1818.wav", + "text": "沈發惠有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1819.wav", + "text": "我都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1820.wav", + "text": "你稍微插話一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1821.wav", + "text": "我也覺得正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1822.wav", + "text": "是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1823.wav", + "text": "既然這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1824.wav", + "text": "第一案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1825.wav", + "text": "禮拜五早上就來質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1826.wav", + "text": "下午就來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1827.wav", + "text": "你都還沒列入報告事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1828.wav", + "text": "這個遊戲規則難道不懂嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1829.wav", + "text": "現在連列入報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1830.wav", + "text": "事項都還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1831.wav", + "text": "禮拜五就要開始質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1832.wav", + "text": "一定要列入報告事項以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1833.wav", + "text": "這有程序性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1834.wav", + "text": "列入報告事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1835.wav", + "text": "況且那個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1836.wav", + "text": "違法處理的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1837.wav", + "text": "都有問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1838.wav", + "text": "這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1839.wav", + "text": "這是有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1840.wav", + "text": "立法院周萬來也不會答應你這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1841.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1842.wav", + "text": "你們現在就是要開快車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1843.wav", + "text": "開快車就是禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1844.wav", + "text": "禮拜二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1845.wav", + "text": "來投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1846.wav", + "text": "這個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1847.wav", + "text": "畏懼民意嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1848.wav", + "text": "你們自己說要開幾百場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1849.wav", + "text": "瑤剛剛講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1850.wav", + "text": "讓社會去冷靜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1851.wav", + "text": "讓立法院冷靜讓社會來看這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1852.wav", + "text": "做一個討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1853.wav", + "text": "這才是民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1854.wav", + "text": "啦財劃法覆議當年是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1855.wav", + "text": "第13天才投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1856.wav", + "text": "例子都是如此這個時間是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1857.wav", + "text": "一個很長的時間院長請你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1858.wav", + "text": "實際聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1859.wav", + "text": "非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1860.wav", + "text": "我有在看你的眼睛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1861.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1862.wav", + "text": "覆議案不是像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1863.wav", + "text": "這個是國會自主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1864.wav", + "text": "另外我要講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1865.wav", + "text": "是黃國昌也跑掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1866.wav", + "text": "所謂的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1867.wav", + "text": "我不會做人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1868.wav", + "text": "但是朝野協商有不同的意見不是人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1869.wav", + "text": "這個是不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1870.wav", + "text": "是大家可以講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1871.wav", + "text": "不能論述嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1872.wav", + "text": "昌現在跑掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1873.wav", + "text": "了他不敢面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1874.wav", + "text": "一定百分之百會不見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1875.wav", + "text": "黃國昌請回來��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1876.wav", + "text": "黃國昌回來啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1877.wav", + "text": "我講的都是大道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1878.wav", + "text": "你一定會拍手啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1879.wav", + "text": "這是言論自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1880.wav", + "text": "這是朝野在論證的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1881.wav", + "text": "我可以講這個你也可以講那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1882.wav", + "text": "都沒有關係都是在爭辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1883.wav", + "text": "民主最可貴的就是在爭辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1884.wav", + "text": "黃國昌常常講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1885.wav", + "text": "我們來辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1886.wav", + "text": "昨天還講我們到電視辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1887.wav", + "text": "我說你們委員會都不審查了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1888.wav", + "text": "什麼都破壞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1889.wav", + "text": "每天講大話不要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1890.wav", + "text": "稍微忍受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1891.wav", + "text": "一下因為我要綜合回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1892.wav", + "text": "大家要對焦的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1893.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1894.wav", + "text": "朝野協商不同意見的展示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1895.wav", + "text": "以及攻防這是民主政治ABC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1896.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂的人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1897.wav", + "text": "直接人身攻擊就不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1898.wav", + "text": "像傅崐萁說我是糟老頭要去養老院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1899.wav", + "text": "那個才是人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1900.wav", + "text": "你罵錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1901.wav", + "text": "反而會反彈到你身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1902.wav", + "text": "反而對他不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1903.wav", + "text": "社會自有公平論斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1904.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1905.wav", + "text": "第二洪孟楷講這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1906.wav", + "text": "這個時間大家都訂出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1907.wav", + "text": "了我怎麼不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1908.wav", + "text": "當初也有想到覆議案的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1909.wav", + "text": "所以總共有14次的院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1910.wav", + "text": "滿大家都講滿只有10次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1911.wav", + "text": "換言之還保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1912.wav", + "text": "4次空的時間我們已經用掉1次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1913.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償用掉1次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1914.wav", + "text": "還有3次其實不只3次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1915.wav", + "text": "可能4到5次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1916.wav", + "text": "因為民進黨會把總質詢的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1917.wav", + "text": "減半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1918.wav", + "text": "就會增加時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1919.wav", + "text": "即便我們不減半時間都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1920.wav", + "text": "因為只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1921.wav", + "text": "覆議投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1922.wav", + "text": "影響到民生法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1923.wav", + "text": "完全不影響民生法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1924.wav", + "text": "完全沒有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1925.wav", + "text": "因為只是兩次的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1926.wav", + "text": "民進黨質詢再減半的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1927.wav", + "text": "會有5次的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1928.wav", + "text": "民生法案一點都不影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1929.wav", + "text": "而且大家都知道遲早有覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1930.wav", + "text": "所以當初院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1931.wav", + "text": "做這樣巧妙地安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1932.wav", + "text": "我那時候就覺得這些都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1933.wav", + "text": "這一點我必須在這裡說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1934.wav", + "text": "會計法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1935.wav", + "text": "會計法不是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1936.wav", + "text": "請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1937.wav", + "text": "喔那時候最嚴重的問題是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1938.wav", + "text": "有的大學教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1939.wav", + "text": "造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1940.wav", + "text": "所有的人包括大學校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1941.wav", + "text": "副校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1942.wav", + "text": "所以吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1943.wav", + "text": "那個教授的教文字缺漏所以重新來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1944.wav", + "text": "我在2015" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1945.wav", + "text": "年回去新竹選舉的時候出一本書大局．承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1946.wav", + "text": "那時候柯文哲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1947.wav", + "text": "幫我寫序貴黨黨主席幫我寫序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1948.wav", + "text": "他怎麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1949.wav", + "text": "歷史終於還我清白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1950.wav", + "text": "當初是為了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1951.wav", + "text": "為了這些大學教授的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1952.wav", + "text": "做統一解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1953.wav", + "text": "來除罪化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1954.wav", + "text": "抓這些大學教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1955.wav", + "text": "憂鬱症有的要跳樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1956.wav", + "text": "全國所有的學術界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1957.wav", + "text": "就是為了解套這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1958.wav", + "text": "人家不會處理這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1959.wav", + "text": "事情經過是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1960.wav", + "text": "所以那時候我才第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1961.wav", + "text": "聽到有一個叫黃國昌的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1962.wav", + "text": "出來打我說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1963.wav", + "text": "密室協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1964.wav", + "text": "以後要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1965.wav", + "text": "就是不要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1966.wav", + "text": "直接辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1967.wav", + "text": "他發展出這個理論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1968.wav", + "text": "今天我們不是在這裡協商嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1969.wav", + "text": "而且是直播的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1970.wav", + "text": "這是2016年的時候民進黨黨團改直播的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1971.wav", + "text": "在這裡我要告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1972.wav", + "text": "你去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1973.wav", + "text": "全國大學教授有一堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1974.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1975.wav", + "text": "當時覆議的時候各黨一個人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1976.wav", + "text": "馬英九就是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1977.wav", + "text": "我們的目的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1978.wav", + "text": "那個那時候王金平院長主持協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1979.wav", + "text": "我們黨團是最後一個簽名的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1980.wav", + "text": "台聯的林世嘉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1981.wav", + "text": "因為楊泮池" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1982.wav", + "text": "身上掛了四億多的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1983.wav", + "text": "怎麼解套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1984.wav", + "text": "所以柯文哲那時候被調查局找去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1985.wav", + "text": "只有10萬塊而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1986.wav", + "text": "他說那些東西找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1987.wav", + "text": "就是貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1988.wav", + "text": "找得到就是偽造文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1989.wav", + "text": "用在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1990.wav", + "text": "研究上面的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1991.wav", + "text": "拿10萬塊去買電腦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1992.wav", + "text": "但是這已經落伍了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1993.wav", + "text": "還有幾張桌子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1994.wav", + "text": "還來辦公室跟我們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1995.wav", + "text": "就變成貪污找得到就是偽造文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1996.wav", + "text": "後來全部除罪化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1997.wav", + "text": "各位要清楚在2013年5月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1998.wav", + "text": "那天將近十二點的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/1999.wav", + "text": "會計法是這樣子通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2000.wav", + "text": "不要再來抹黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2001.wav", + "text": "那我們來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2002.wav", + "text": "時間的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2003.wav", + "text": "大家明眼人都看得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2004.wav", + "text": "社會討論嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2005.wav", + "text": "的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2006.wav", + "text": "就是要讓社會去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2007.wav", + "text": "我看得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2008.wav", + "text": "政府沒有這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2009.wav", + "text": "一天裡面把它結束掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2010.wav", + "text": "這個都是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2011.wav", + "text": "我認為都不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2012.wav", + "text": "要讓它多多讓人討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2013.wav", + "text": "你剛才說那是不是可以十幾個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2014.wav", + "text": "我在這裡做具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2015.wav", + "text": "25號以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2016.wav", + "text": "處理就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2017.wav", + "text": "全院委員會多開幾次都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2018.wav", + "text": "這個沒有違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2019.wav", + "text": "啦這是朝野協商同意就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2020.wav", + "text": "大家要問都可以問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2021.wav", + "text": "25號以前一定要投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2022.wav", + "text": "民進黨會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2023.wav", + "text": "會不會破壞大家不要排隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2024.wav", + "text": "嘛已經講得很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2025.wav", + "text": "民進黨不可能去破壞這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2026.wav", + "text": "你剛才不是講說大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2027.wav", + "text": "朝野協商結論要簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2028.wav", + "text": "就不要排隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2029.wav", + "text": "免得大家排隊等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2030.wav", + "text": "這是在誣衊自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2031.wav", + "text": "覆議案有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2032.wav", + "text": "我們會成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2033.wav", + "text": "當然我們盡量說服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2034.wav", + "text": "沒有成功我們釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2035.wav", + "text": "民進黨不要占領主席台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2036.wav", + "text": "甚至剛才講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2037.wav", + "text": "朝野協商要先簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2038.wav", + "text": "這個你們自己去簽就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2039.wav", + "text": "占主席台這次到現在都是你們占領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2040.wav", + "text": "你們占了4天你都忘記了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2041.wav", + "text": "連排隊都是你們排隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2042.wav", + "text": "的這個很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2043.wav", + "text": "\n所以我繼續談話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2044.wav", + "text": "司馬昭之心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2045.wav", + "text": "不是路人皆知是全國皆知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2046.wav", + "text": "你們在這裡的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2047.wav", + "text": "全部是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2048.wav", + "text": "全部串通好來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2049.wav", + "text": "院長你也不要被他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2050.wav", + "text": "牽著鼻子走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2051.wav", + "text": "你要活在歷史的高度一個中立角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2052.wav", + "text": "我是覺得你們這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2053.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2054.wav", + "text": "你們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2055.wav", + "text": "趕快把它處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2056.wav", + "text": "下午再來總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2057.wav", + "text": "總質詢沒有影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2058.wav", + "text": "你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2059.wav", + "text": "讓外面不要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2060.wav", + "text": "未戰先敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2061.wav", + "text": "要到電視去辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2062.wav", + "text": "你們連在這裡發言都不敢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2063.wav", + "text": "這種說法就是棄兵甲而逃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2064.wav", + "text": "未戰先敗的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2065.wav", + "text": "然後自己在杯弓蛇影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2066.wav", + "text": "我講的話就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2067.wav", + "text": "具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2068.wav", + "text": "在25號以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2069.wav", + "text": "你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2070.wav", + "text": "要排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2071.wav", + "text": "平而論還是要朝野協商同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2072.wav", + "text": "啦因為你前面那個就沒有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2073.wav", + "text": "這個我們到時候可以來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2074.wav", + "text": "但是沒有所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2075.wav", + "text": "快速打包起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2076.wav", + "text": "我就覺得大家都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2077.wav", + "text": "好要好好談你剛才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2078.wav", + "text": "16個20個都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2079.wav", + "text": "全院委員會多排幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2080.wav", + "text": "最晚到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2081.wav", + "text": "24號以前要投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2082.wav", + "text": "24號投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2083.wav", + "text": "即便不要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2084.wav", + "text": "也要這時間再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2085.wav", + "text": "不可能是25號當天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2086.wav", + "text": "啦不能超過25" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2087.wav", + "text": "24號也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2088.wav", + "text": "第13天完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2089.wav", + "text": "其實25號也可以我們不必弄這麼緊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2090.wav", + "text": "大家好好談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2091.wav", + "text": "去說服你的選民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2092.wav", + "text": "你講你的理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2093.wav", + "text": "你講說為什麼這個沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2094.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2095.wav", + "text": "會講他說這絕對沒有違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2096.wav", + "text": "我也不是大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2097.wav", + "text": "就請大法官去釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2098.wav", + "text": "所以黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2099.wav", + "text": "你是一個學法的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2100.wav", + "text": "你不要把憲法丟到旁邊去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2101.wav", + "text": "要談大家就好好來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2102.wav", + "text": "在這裡好好談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2103.wav", + "text": "你講兩次也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2104.wav", + "text": "25號不要壓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2105.wav", + "text": "最後一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2106.wav", + "text": "好好的讓老百姓知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2107.wav", + "text": "各黨的理念是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2108.wav", + "text": "你們很有把握去說服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2109.wav", + "text": "你們說是藍鳥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2110.wav", + "text": "我們自己來說服就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2111.wav", + "text": "讓所有全國老百姓都看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2112.wav", + "text": "非常重要的一課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2113.wav", + "text": "讓大家去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2114.wav", + "text": "民意在什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2115.wav", + "text": "大家正式面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2116.wav", + "text": "你很有把握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2117.wav", + "text": "沒有違憲沒有關係你們去講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2118.wav", + "text": "我說違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2119.wav", + "text": "院長說違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2120.wav", + "text": "我們也可以上去講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2121.wav", + "text": "啊大家以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2122.wav", + "text": "就讓大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2123.wav", + "text": "但是請勇敢講出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2124.wav", + "text": "你們沒有違憲的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2125.wav", + "text": "好好去多講幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2126.wav", + "text": "讓你們所有的支持者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2127.wav", + "text": "能夠信服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2128.wav", + "text": "甚至影響到我們的支持者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2129.wav", + "text": "去支持你也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2130.wav", + "text": "民意決定一切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2131.wav", + "text": "最後投票大家對歷史負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2132.wav", + "text": "柯建銘總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2133.wav", + "text": "我們再加一天20號（星期四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2134.wav", + "text": "）召開全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2135.wav", + "text": "審查行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2136.wav", + "text": "所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2137.wav", + "text": "行使法部分條文及中華民國刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2138.wav", + "text": "增訂第五章之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2139.wav", + "text": "章名及第104條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2140.wav", + "text": "之1條文之覆議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2141.wav", + "text": "審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2142.wav", + "text": "邀請行政院院長列席說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2143.wav", + "text": "各日分別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2144.wav", + "text": "由國民黨黨團推派11位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2145.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2146.wav", + "text": "推派11位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2147.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團推派2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2148.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2149.wav", + "text": "加開一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2150.wav", + "text": "每位委員詢答時間為10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2151.wav", + "text": "詢答順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2152.wav", + "text": "依例授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2153.wav", + "text": "議事處辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2154.wav", + "text": "名單我們就於6月18號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2155.wav", + "text": "（星期二）中午12點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2156.wav", + "text": "以前交議事處彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2157.wav", + "text": "逾期視同放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2158.wav", + "text": "這是第一個重點結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2159.wav", + "text": "大家看一看要不要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2160.wav", + "text": "第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2161.wav", + "text": "6月21號（星期五）上午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2162.wav", + "text": "報告事項處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2163.wav", + "text": "進行記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2164.wav", + "text": "投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2165.wav", + "text": "2案分別為2張票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2166.wav", + "text": "同時投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2167.wav", + "text": "並由各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2168.wav", + "text": "推派1人擔任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2169.wav", + "text": "投開票監察員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2170.wav", + "text": "其餘相關投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2171.wav", + "text": "依例授權議事處辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2172.wav", + "text": "當日會議不進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2173.wav", + "text": "施政方針報告質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2174.wav", + "text": "這兩點我們把時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2175.wav", + "text": "融合大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2176.wav", + "text": "融會貫通的就這兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2177.wav", + "text": "6月19號6月20號我們召開全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2178.wav", + "text": "請問各位黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2179.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2180.wav", + "text": "看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2181.wav", + "text": "野協商都是院長先簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2182.wav", + "text": "我現在把這個意見唸出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2183.wav", + "text": "從來就是院長先簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2184.wav", + "text": "如果有意見的話沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2185.wav", + "text": "各黨團的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2186.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團跟民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2187.wav", + "text": "請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2188.wav", + "text": "仔細看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2189.wav", + "text": "所以加開2天嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2190.wav", + "text": "全院委員會2天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2191.wav", + "text": "你們也可以釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2192.wav", + "text": "這個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2193.wav", + "text": "沒有問題我們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2194.wav", + "text": "那我只有一個技術性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2195.wav", + "text": "我們在開全院委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2196.wav", + "text": "其他的委員會是繼續進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2197.wav", + "text": "還是會停開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2198.wav", + "text": "這個先講清楚比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2199.wav", + "text": "因為這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2200.wav", + "text": "在以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2201.wav", + "text": "一般全院委員會審查時委員會是不開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2202.wav", + "text": "但是我知道現在這兩屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2203.wav", + "text": "裡面是有委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2204.wav", + "text": "也在開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2205.wav", + "text": "啦有這個例在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2206.wav", + "text": "以前是沒以前是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2207.wav", + "text": "比較嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2208.wav", + "text": "照議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2209.wav", + "text": "照周" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2210.wav", + "text": "但是我們民進黨從來不會破壞規矩在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2211.wav", + "text": "我們不會去排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2212.wav", + "text": "那秘書長也說明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2213.wav", + "text": "了院長裁示尊重召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2214.wav", + "text": "那就尊重召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2215.wav", + "text": "好的那再一次謝謝各位黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2216.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2217.wav", + "text": "好很感謝大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2218.wav", + "text": "有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2219.wav", + "text": "非常好的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/16011/2220.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/0.wav", + "text": "審查完竣的36案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1.wav", + "text": "然後第二個逕付二讀有19案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2.wav", + "text": "\n我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/3.wav", + "text": "就針對保留條文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/4.wav", + "text": "開始審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/5.wav", + "text": "總共保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/6.wav", + "text": "有18條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/7.wav", + "text": "\n另外修正動議有12案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/8.wav", + "text": "我們現在開始協商\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/9.wav", + "text": "現在針對第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/10.wav", + "text": "衛福部是不是表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/11.wav", + "text": "第2條我們在第1項第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/12.wav", + "text": "增訂重製持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/13.wav", + "text": "以及支付對價觀覽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/14.wav", + "text": "的樣態以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/15.wav", + "text": "好請問委員針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/16.wav", + "text": "衛福部的修正條文有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/17.wav", + "text": "第2條嗎對第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/18.wav", + "text": "好來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/19.wav", + "text": "一直在訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/20.wav", + "text": "定義在第2條我提案修的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/21.wav", + "text": "第2條內容是拍攝製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/22.wav", + "text": "散布播送交付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/23.wav", + "text": "公然陳列或販賣兒童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/24.wav", + "text": "或少年之性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/25.wav", + "text": "而客觀上足以引起性慾或羞恥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/26.wav", + "text": "以真人所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/27.wav", + "text": "繪製之色情圖畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/28.wav", + "text": "及電磁紀錄生成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/29.wav", + "text": "之擬真色情圖畫語音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/30.wav", + "text": "\n我有和民團討論過大家有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/31.wav", + "text": "還是覺得聚焦在真實兒童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/32.wav", + "text": "或少年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/33.wav", + "text": "所以建議是不是就改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/34.wav", + "text": "以真實兒童或少年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/35.wav", + "text": "所繪製之色情圖畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/36.wav", + "text": "及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/37.wav", + "text": "電磁紀錄生成之擬真色情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/38.wav", + "text": "我還是要重申一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/39.wav", + "text": "我們同意衛福部的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/40.wav", + "text": "法條要保有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/41.wav", + "text": "但是現在我們的版本入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/42.wav", + "text": "並沒有失去這樣的彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/43.wav", + "text": "並不是把整個法條都拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/44.wav", + "text": "而且是因為之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/45.wav", + "text": "衛福部想要擴大解釋而有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/46.wav", + "text": "所以現在的限縮並不是全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/47.wav", + "text": "都否決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/48.wav", + "text": "也不是全部的都限縮全然限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/49.wav", + "text": "所以為了保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/50.wav", + "text": "創作者的權益是不是在合理的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/51.wav", + "text": "能夠做一個限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/52.wav", + "text": "\n二次元的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/53.wav", + "text": "兒少色情不涉及任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/54.wav", + "text": "真實兒童的受害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/55.wav", + "text": "如果把這些創作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/56.wav", + "text": "與有真實兒童受害的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/57.wav", + "text": "深偽AI創作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/58.wav", + "text": "或AI繪圖混為一談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/59.wav", + "text": "範圍就會擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/60.wav", + "text": "現實抓到的是沒有加害兒童的繪師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/61.wav", + "text": "而不是真正有傷害兒童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/62.wav", + "text": "並早就打算跑遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/63.wav", + "text": "逃避刑責的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/64.wav", + "text": "所以堅持第2條如果要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/65.wav", + "text": "會是給ACG創作者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/66.wav", + "text": "權益最大的一個保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/67.wav", + "text": "如果只有說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/68.wav", + "text": "就算是有函釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/69.wav", + "text": "衛福部是同意函釋的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/70.wav", + "text": "未來也會容易被擴大解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/71.wav", + "text": "我們都知道ACG創作者的權益問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/72.wav", + "text": "不是今天才發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/73.wav", + "text": "所以我希望這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/74.wav", + "text": "是不是衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/75.wav", + "text": "能夠給我們回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/76.wav", + "text": "好來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/77.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/78.wav", + "text": "針對擬真這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/79.wav", + "text": "兩個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/80.wav", + "text": "第一個我們的確在說明欄裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/81.wav", + "text": "已經很明確地去範定它的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/82.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/83.wav", + "text": "第二個部分我們不建議修的原因是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/84.wav", + "text": "因為這一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/85.wav", + "text": "是配合刑法第10條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/86.wav", + "text": "相關文字所以如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/87.wav", + "text": "刑法這邊沒有修我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/88.wav", + "text": "特別法修恐怕會有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/89.wav", + "text": "法條上解釋的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/90.wav", + "text": "以上請委員支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/91.wav", + "text": "好主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/92.wav", + "text": "主席因為衛福部有這樣的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/93.wav", + "text": "那我是建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/94.wav", + "text": "你要先保留嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/95.wav", + "text": "好那我們第2條先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/96.wav", + "text": "待會再回過來看\n來第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/97.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/98.wav", + "text": "我們接受委員會討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/99.wav", + "text": "委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/100.wav", + "text": "在第2項增訂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/101.wav", + "text": "主管機關以及目的事業主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/102.wav", + "text": "機關的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/103.wav", + "text": "閱\n另外在第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/104.wav", + "text": "部分我們配合性別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/105.wav", + "text": "平等政策把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/106.wav", + "text": "諮詢會的學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/107.wav", + "text": "以及性別比例酌做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/108.wav", + "text": "修正\n第5項到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/109.wav", + "text": "基於事權統一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/110.wav", + "text": "以及為了即時回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/111.wav", + "text": "兒少性影像的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/112.wav", + "text": "因此採中央集中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/113.wav", + "text": "來處理所以成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/114.wav", + "text": "性影像中心以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/115.wav", + "text": "做主動的巡查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/116.wav", + "text": "以及相關網路業者要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/117.wav", + "text": "配合的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/118.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/119.wav", + "text": "好針對第3條委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/120.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/121.wav", + "text": "好來林月琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/122.wav", + "text": "在第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/123.wav", + "text": "第5款的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/124.wav", + "text": "可能跟我要討論的第5條有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/125.wav", + "text": "是不是還是把被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/126.wav", + "text": "身分識別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/127.wav", + "text": "第3項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/128.wav", + "text": "主管機關應會同前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/129.wav", + "text": "相關機關定期公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/130.wav", + "text": "並檢討教育宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/131.wav", + "text": "之前就已經有提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/132.wav", + "text": "就是說不要把教育宣導混雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/133.wav", + "text": "在一談那就會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/134.wav", + "text": "教育沒做教育然後很多都視為宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/135.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/136.wav", + "text": "警政署要不要表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/137.wav", + "text": "警政署報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/138.wav", + "text": "有關於月琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/139.wav", + "text": "有提到第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/140.wav", + "text": "第2項第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/141.wav", + "text": "警政主管機關的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/142.wav", + "text": "第一個就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/143.wav", + "text": "應該是警政機關我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/144.wav", + "text": "這個部分沒有問題但是被害人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/145.wav", + "text": "識別這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/146.wav", + "text": "上一次會議的時候其實我們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/147.wav", + "text": "警政機關最重要的就是犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/148.wav", + "text": "相關的文字其實最好不要列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/149.wav", + "text": "\n另外有關於後段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/150.wav", + "text": "行為人登記報到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/151.wav", + "text": "查訪查閱的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/152.wav", + "text": "因為這個跟第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/153.wav", + "text": "51條其實是有連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/154.wav", + "text": "的所以也是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/155.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/156.wav", + "text": "好來林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/157.wav", + "text": "因為後邊還是有資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/158.wav", + "text": "資料庫現在還是歸納在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/159.wav", + "text": "警政署的工作本來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/160.wav", + "text": "有對被害人身分做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/161.wav", + "text": "分做所謂的識別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/162.wav", + "text": "所以我認為還是要加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/163.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/164.wav", + "text": "可能是要衛福部來回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/165.wav", + "text": "宣導以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/166.wav", + "text": "好來陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/167.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/168.wav", + "text": "我想要支持月琴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/169.wav", + "text": "琴委員的版本主要是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/170.wav", + "text": "真的在現場實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/171.wav", + "text": "看見關於識別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/172.wav", + "text": "這件事情的困難性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/173.wav", + "text": "以目前幾個案例來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/174.wav", + "text": "例如說有些人他是主動知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/175.wav", + "text": "他自己被偷拍可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/176.wav", + "text": "在網路上有人告訴他他就看見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/177.wav", + "text": "可是有大量的資料庫看見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/178.wav", + "text": "的困境是被害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/179.wav", + "text": "人的素材其實沒有辦法被識別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/180.wav", + "text": "如果在這個識別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/181.wav", + "text": "的部分我們行政主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/182.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法給予支持跟協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/183.wav", + "text": "那我其實也還滿想問我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/184.wav", + "text": "後續還有沒有什麼其他的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/185.wav", + "text": "來完成這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/186.wav", + "text": "就是說如果你們覺得在識別這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/187.wav", + "text": "不是屬於警政機關的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/188.wav", + "text": "那後續還有沒有其他的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/189.wav", + "text": "可以討論還是可以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/190.wav", + "text": "衛福部給予一些建議呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/191.wav", + "text": "因為這個是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/192.wav", + "text": "兒少性剝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/193.wav", + "text": "有幾個跡象看起來他是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/194.wav", + "text": "兒少基本上它都是犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/195.wav", + "text": "不一定在第一時間要去識別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/196.wav", + "text": "所以應該是先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/197.wav", + "text": "做移除下架的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/198.wav", + "text": "比例我們先前跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/199.wav", + "text": "部長在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/200.wav", + "text": "我們會做一個滾動修正就類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/201.wav", + "text": "我們現在iWI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/202.wav", + "text": "IN的方式我們一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/203.wav", + "text": "會找相關網路業者跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/204.wav", + "text": "甚至法院的相關人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/205.wav", + "text": "大家來做一些討論在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/206.wav", + "text": "有沒有一些特別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/207.wav", + "text": "另外我們也可以參考國外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/208.wav", + "text": "一些做法它有一些特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/209.wav", + "text": "例如說我常看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/210.wav", + "text": "的就是它會特別標示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/211.wav", + "text": "他是未成年第一個在文字上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/212.wav", + "text": "第二個他在衣著上面特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/213.wav", + "text": "所謂的學生制服來標示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/214.wav", + "text": "他是未成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/215.wav", + "text": "做一些滾動修正再來做一些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/216.wav", + "text": "好還有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/217.wav", + "text": "謝謝司長警政署在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/218.wav", + "text": "再做補充比如說創意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/219.wav", + "text": "私房裡面有20萬片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/220.wav", + "text": "其實我們在整個偵查作為當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/221.wav", + "text": "兒少性剝削絕對是用最高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/222.wav", + "text": "規格跟最高標準也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/223.wav", + "text": "第一優先要去辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/224.wav", + "text": "這樣子的被害人但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/225.wav", + "text": "確實有些辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/226.wav", + "text": "時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/227.wav", + "text": "\n就像剛剛司長所說的當我們了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/228.wav", + "text": "確實是兒少性影像的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/229.wav", + "text": "第一時間要先做下架的動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/230.wav", + "text": "但是有一些我們可能在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/231.wav", + "text": "即時還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/232.wav", + "text": "辦法去辨識被害人的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/233.wav", + "text": "它絕對是後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/234.wav", + "text": "要做犯罪偵查也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/235.wav", + "text": "優先的事項這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/236.wav", + "text": "尤其是兒少性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/237.wav", + "text": "的部分絕對是我們優先跟第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/238.wav", + "text": "會去處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/239.wav", + "text": "好來林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/240.wav", + "text": "的第5條是有關聯性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/241.wav", + "text": "資料庫因為這條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/242.wav", + "text": "申訴人去申訴我已經知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/243.wav", + "text": "我自己被害所以我去申訴了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/244.wav", + "text": "即便你用展示的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/245.wav", + "text": "它事實上是跟合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/246.wav", + "text": "固定的網站去看H" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/247.wav", + "text": "ash值然後去交叉比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/248.wav", + "text": "那也是我知道我自己是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/249.wav", + "text": "被害人了然後去做這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/250.wav", + "text": "\n當初要建資料庫就是我覺得第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/251.wav", + "text": "破獲了創意私房可是那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/252.wav", + "text": "的確要時間既然他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/253.wav", + "text": "要去做所謂的身分比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/254.wav", + "text": "那表示警政署有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/255.wav", + "text": "工作所以我本來就期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/256.wav", + "text": "資料庫建在警政署的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/257.wav", + "text": "你既然就已經要做這個工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/258.wav", + "text": "我覺得前面在工作定義當中把它定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/259.wav", + "text": "清楚有何不可呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/260.wav", + "text": "因為被動跟主動不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/261.wav", + "text": "很多人都不知道自己受害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/262.wav", + "text": "\n我想各位應該去看6月3號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/263.wav", + "text": "報導者一系列的報導寫出他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/264.wav", + "text": "是我自己的片子每天都要跑去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/265.wav", + "text": "Telegram有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/266.wav", + "text": "去跟如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/267.wav", + "text": "今天破獲犯罪比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/268.wav", + "text": "後一一地去建置這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/269.wav", + "text": "才可以用Hash" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/270.wav", + "text": "sh值比對才能讓很多網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/271.wav", + "text": "這才是真正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/272.wav", + "text": "正本清源去解決問題\n所以我才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/273.wav", + "text": "會認為第5條既然跟第3條有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/274.wav", + "text": "性的話應該在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/275.wav", + "text": "第3條就先把警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/276.wav", + "text": "的工作確定下來我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/277.wav", + "text": "也只有增加幾個字而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/278.wav", + "text": "不知道到底警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/279.wav", + "text": "為什麼因為連第5條那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/280.wav", + "text": "時候我也是希望比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/281.wav", + "text": "對我們被害人的身分這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/282.wav", + "text": "也是沒有列入所以希望在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/283.wav", + "text": "第3條就已經列入確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/284.wav", + "text": "的工作範圍第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/285.wav", + "text": "建的資料庫才有辦法名正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/286.wav", + "text": "順地的說你要做的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/287.wav", + "text": "是什麼以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/288.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/289.wav", + "text": "來警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/290.wav", + "text": "因為確實它跟第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/291.wav", + "text": "有相關那請示一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/292.wav", + "text": "就是我們現在是要在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/293.wav", + "text": "先做討論還是等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/294.wav", + "text": "進到第5條的時候我想我們刑事局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/295.wav", + "text": "副局長也在現場他會做很完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/296.wav", + "text": "的說明然後再回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/297.wav", + "text": "第2項第5款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/298.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/299.wav", + "text": "那第2項第2款有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/300.wav", + "text": "於警政主管機關的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/301.wav", + "text": "第3條就這個部分保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/302.wav", + "text": "主管機關那個就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/303.wav", + "text": "\n好那我們來第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/304.wav", + "text": "我們把內政主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/305.wav", + "text": "修正為中央警政主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/306.wav", + "text": "機關第2項第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/307.wav", + "text": "第4項就是剛才討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/308.wav", + "text": "警察機關要建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/309.wav", + "text": "被害人性影像的數位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/310.wav", + "text": "鑑識資料庫以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/311.wav", + "text": "辦法以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/312.wav", + "text": "兒少性剝削案件的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/313.wav", + "text": "司法人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/314.wav", + "text": "要加強訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/315.wav", + "text": "來充實辦案的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/316.wav", + "text": "素養以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/317.wav", + "text": "好我們請警政署跟司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/318.wav", + "text": "分別表示意見來警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/319.wav", + "text": "報告首先感謝各位委員對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/320.wav", + "text": "兒少性剝削條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/321.wav", + "text": "有關於在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/322.wav", + "text": "性影像建置數位資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/323.wav", + "text": "現在我們已經針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/324.wav", + "text": "所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/325.wav", + "text": "以數位採證的程序來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/326.wav", + "text": "進行因為為便利在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/327.wav", + "text": "各司法警察機關包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/328.wav", + "text": "到地檢署法院的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/329.wav", + "text": "由法務部主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/330.wav", + "text": "結合司法院高檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/331.wav", + "text": "調查局跟警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/332.wav", + "text": "已經有建置一個數位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/333.wav", + "text": "查扣平臺從今年4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/334.wav", + "text": "有一個司法聯盟鏈的共同驗證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/335.wav", + "text": "平臺各執法機關查扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/336.wav", + "text": "的數位證物都必須上傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/337.wav", + "text": "這個平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/338.wav", + "text": "另外它可以確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/339.wav", + "text": "整個證據不受偽造及變造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/340.wav", + "text": "也可以跟原先查扣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/341.wav", + "text": "原始檔案是相符的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/342.wav", + "text": "\n它在上傳影像的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/343.wav", + "text": "除了相關的影像紀錄以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/344.wav", + "text": "同時會產生它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/345.wav", + "text": "雜湊值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/346.wav", + "text": "這個雜湊值其實就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/347.wav", + "text": "讓我們未來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/348.wav", + "text": "偵查人員如果有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/349.wav", + "text": "兒少性剝削的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/350.wav", + "text": "性影像他可以利用雜湊值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/351.wav", + "text": "跟原本的資料庫來做比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/352.wav", + "text": "所以這邊也要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/353.wav", + "text": "主席及委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/354.wav", + "text": "今年4月1號才新上線的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/355.wav", + "text": "它是已經包含所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/356.wav", + "text": "數位影像也包含兒少性剝削的影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/357.wav", + "text": "所以基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/358.wav", + "text": "應該不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/359.wav", + "text": "再另外建立一個專責的性影像專區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/360.wav", + "text": "因為現在已經合用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/361.wav", + "text": "\n我們當然非常感謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/362.wav", + "text": "能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/363.wav", + "text": "體察我們警察後續偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/364.wav", + "text": "要去確認到底這個影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/365.wav", + "text": "之前有沒有辦過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/366.wav", + "text": "也可以減少被害人簡述的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/367.wav", + "text": "已經有司法聯盟鏈的數位影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/368.wav", + "text": "它就已經有這個功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/369.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議在第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/370.wav", + "text": "第2項第3項部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/371.wav", + "text": "是否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/372.wav", + "text": "可以不予增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/373.wav", + "text": "因為目前就已經可以達到這個功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/374.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/375.wav", + "text": "所以警政署意思是說資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/376.wav", + "text": "不用在這個條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/377.wav", + "text": "再去增設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/378.wav", + "text": "你們現在已經有現有的涵蓋成人跟兒少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/379.wav", + "text": "而且是各司法機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/380.wav", + "text": "包含警察機關都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/381.wav", + "text": "共同運用這個司法聯盟鏈的平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/382.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/383.wav", + "text": "接下來我們請司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/384.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/385.wav", + "text": "關於第5條的部分我們對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/386.wav", + "text": "於衛福部的版本沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/387.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/388.wav", + "text": "司法院沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/389.wav", + "text": "針對剛剛警政署的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/390.wav", + "text": "好來林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/391.wav", + "text": "警政署這樣回答了可是在我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/392.wav", + "text": "知道的第一線有去瞭解的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/393.wav", + "text": "你跟我談的跟我跟你談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/394.wav", + "text": "有沒有一樣可是當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/395.wav", + "text": "事實上是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/396.wav", + "text": "我有建議要設這個資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/397.wav", + "text": "所以後來你們也列入了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/398.wav", + "text": "今天又突然說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/399.wav", + "text": "不要那個真的要有一些理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/400.wav", + "text": "因為當初我提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/401.wav", + "text": "這個資料庫要做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/402.wav", + "text": "兩大項的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/403.wav", + "text": "你們如果濃縮成這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/404.wav", + "text": "兩項說明我當然也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/405.wav", + "text": "可是某些字眼還要加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/406.wav", + "text": "前面我剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/407.wav", + "text": "第3條第2項第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/408.wav", + "text": "的部分要針對於被害人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/409.wav", + "text": "要加進去所以本來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/410.wav", + "text": "第2項為辦理本法第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/411.wav", + "text": "第1項第3款的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/412.wav", + "text": "性剝削" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/413.wav", + "text": "這邊本來我有寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/414.wav", + "text": "就是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/415.wav", + "text": "有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/416.wav", + "text": "性剝削行為之被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/417.wav", + "text": "犯罪偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/418.wav", + "text": "還有寫到並利用該項資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/419.wav", + "text": "庫來協助犯罪偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/420.wav", + "text": "我想這次我只是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/421.wav", + "text": "再加上及比對潛在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/422.wav", + "text": "被害人才能夠回應我當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/423.wav", + "text": "討論出來的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/424.wav", + "text": "結果現在反而連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/425.wav", + "text": "因為原本期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/426.wav", + "text": "是要達到這兩個功能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/427.wav", + "text": "所以若要濃縮成這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/428.wav", + "text": "那就再把這幾個字眼加上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/429.wav", + "text": "而不是全部刪除這也是部裡面提出來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/430.wav", + "text": "因為這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/431.wav", + "text": "很重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/432.wav", + "text": "這次如果真的破獲了20" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/433.wav", + "text": "可是沒有辦法第一時間比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/434.wav", + "text": "可能比對有一些是未成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/435.wav", + "text": "形體上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/436.wav", + "text": "還有有沒有學號或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/437.wav", + "text": "真的是可以比對得出來可是有些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/438.wav", + "text": "可能在下一次破獲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/439.wav", + "text": "可以為什麼要這個資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/440.wav", + "text": "否則北中南東各地警察局裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/441.wav", + "text": "我破獲我的你破獲你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/442.wav", + "text": "集中放在一起去做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/443.wav", + "text": "瞭解或者是未來再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/444.wav", + "text": "有的時候又再拿進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/445.wav", + "text": "去做比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/446.wav", + "text": "所以比較希望有這樣的資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/447.wav", + "text": "還是非常堅持這一點一定要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/448.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/449.wav", + "text": "好警政署請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/450.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝委員對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/451.wav", + "text": "地方偵查同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/452.wav", + "text": "在偵辦上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/453.wav", + "text": "因為司法聯盟鏈是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/454.wav", + "text": "今年4月1號才上線使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/455.wav", + "text": "在之前跟委員報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/456.wav", + "text": "他們還沒獲得最新的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/457.wav", + "text": "建置平臺是怎麼運用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/458.wav", + "text": "有一點點資訊上的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/459.wav", + "text": "委員認為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/460.wav", + "text": "還是一定要去做影像比對的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/461.wav", + "text": "警政署這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/462.wav", + "text": "也建議提出一個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/463.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/464.wav", + "text": "我這邊報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/465.wav", + "text": "我們建議在第2項跟第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/466.wav", + "text": "可以整併為為辦理本法第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/467.wav", + "text": "第1項第3款性剝削行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/468.wav", + "text": "之犯罪偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/469.wav", + "text": "警察機關得運用數位影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/470.wav", + "text": "證物轉碼比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/471.wav", + "text": "或其他技術確認查獲之被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/472.wav", + "text": "性影像是否屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/473.wav", + "text": "前案被害人以減少被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/474.wav", + "text": "重複陳述就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/475.wav", + "text": "我們還是會去做這部分的比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/476.wav", + "text": "目前就已經建置建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/477.wav", + "text": "不用再重複建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/478.wav", + "text": "但是我們也是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/479.wav", + "text": "授予警察機關運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/480.wav", + "text": "這些數位影像的轉碼比對或其他技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/481.wav", + "text": "因為未來可能還有更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/482.wav", + "text": "技術我們預留一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/483.wav", + "text": "保留空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/484.wav", + "text": "或其他技術來確認是否影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/485.wav", + "text": "屬於前案被害人的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/486.wav", + "text": "我這邊還是要再三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/487.wav", + "text": "專責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/488.wav", + "text": "也就是這樣的經驗才會累積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/489.wav", + "text": "否則的話資料庫誰拿去比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/490.wav", + "text": "類似韓國N號房事件的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/491.wav", + "text": "那些警員他們過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/492.wav", + "text": "做的這些經驗值累積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/493.wav", + "text": "去比對的時候速度是比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/494.wav", + "text": "像當初黃子佼的事情為什麼很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/495.wav", + "text": "快可以知道有7個是未成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/496.wav", + "text": "就是因為他們前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/497.wav", + "text": "有查臺北市N號房的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/498.wav", + "text": "才有辦法在第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/499.wav", + "text": "去看黃子佼他們下載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/500.wav", + "text": "的這些影片哪一些是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/501.wav", + "text": "他曾經過去看過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/502.wav", + "text": "這個為什麼要專責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/503.wav", + "text": "專責單位才可以累積經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/504.wav", + "text": "所以不要忽略掉我這邊講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/505.wav", + "text": "我這邊要的是由專責單位來做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/506.wav", + "text": "所以可能沒有辦法說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/507.wav", + "text": "可是還是要專人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/508.wav", + "text": "過去在辦這個案子的警員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/509.wav", + "text": "他們如果收到影片的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/510.wav", + "text": "就以他們過去看的經驗去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/511.wav", + "text": "因為看過會有印象大概時間上會比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/512.wav", + "text": "專責單位然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/513.wav", + "text": "性影像資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/514.wav", + "text": "這個傷害真的很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/515.wav", + "text": "只是看重罰則根本就抓不到人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/516.wav", + "text": "因為第一個我就不知道我是受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/517.wav", + "text": "等你抓到我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/518.wav", + "text": "否則創意私房不會在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/519.wav", + "text": "十幾年觸感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/520.wav", + "text": "空間也不會在臺灣七八年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/521.wav", + "text": "如果之前有建的話為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/522.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/523.wav", + "text": "有關剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/524.wav", + "text": "委員所提到的專責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/525.wav", + "text": "事實上我們在針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/526.wav", + "text": "檔案或是他們的網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/527.wav", + "text": "刑事局已經有偵九大隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/528.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/529.wav", + "text": "電腦犯罪偵查的專責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/530.wav", + "text": "當然它不僅限於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/531.wav", + "text": "只要屬於電腦偵查犯罪的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/532.wav", + "text": "都是我們偵九大隊在負責偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/533.wav", + "text": "委員剛剛所提到的創意私房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/534.wav", + "text": "房還有後來衍生的部分其實我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/535.wav", + "text": "都在持續偵辦當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/536.wav", + "text": "了有專責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/537.wav", + "text": "在處理電腦犯罪這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/538.wav", + "text": "但它不僅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/539.wav", + "text": "性影像這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/540.wav", + "text": "所以我們確實有專責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/541.wav", + "text": "一直在處理電腦犯罪相關事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/542.wav", + "text": "在這邊做個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/543.wav", + "text": "好我們請范雲委員再來是陳培瑜委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/544.wav", + "text": "在委員會的時候我當時就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/545.wav", + "text": "有發言支持過林月琴委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/546.wav", + "text": "婦女團體都希望有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/547.wav", + "text": "性影像資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/548.wav", + "text": "我記得當時我們委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/549.wav", + "text": "其實滿多跨黨派委員都認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/550.wav", + "text": "要做這樣的資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/551.wav", + "text": "來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/552.wav", + "text": "檢警這邊如果能夠建立兒少性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/553.wav", + "text": "的大資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/554.wav", + "text": "從扣案畫面透過分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/555.wav", + "text": "一方面溯源抓製造散播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/556.wav", + "text": "也可以多重比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/557.wav", + "text": "發現被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/558.wav", + "text": "所以就是不用被動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/559.wav", + "text": "重複一再出現的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/560.wav", + "text": "也能夠判斷背後的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/561.wav", + "text": "所以這個專責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/562.wav", + "text": "做被害人影像資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/563.wav", + "text": "的系統針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/564.wav", + "text": "身分未知的被害人性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/565.wav", + "text": "進行辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/566.wav", + "text": "我覺得是在犯罪偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/567.wav", + "text": "跟預防上有很大的幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/568.wav", + "text": "我記得在委員會當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/569.wav", + "text": "跨黨派委員都認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/570.wav", + "text": "為什麼這邊不能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/571.wav", + "text": "以我們委員多數意見為主請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/572.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我們還滿好奇的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/573.wav", + "text": "在工作順序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/574.wav", + "text": "因為衛福部這個版本已經列上來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/575.wav", + "text": "但是說實話剛剛幾個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/576.wav", + "text": "私下討論我們聽到警政署突然這樣發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/577.wav", + "text": "我們也是想這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/578.wav", + "text": "是要翻衛福部的版本嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/579.wav", + "text": "是不是等一下也請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/580.wav", + "text": "表達一下意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/581.wav", + "text": "除了剛剛兩位委員所說的之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/582.wav", + "text": "我們真的要再一次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/583.wav", + "text": "我們多年從事兒少工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/584.wav", + "text": "發現近年來有一個很大的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/585.wav", + "text": "如果你自己是爸爸媽媽或是你家裡親戚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/586.wav", + "text": "這幾年小孩在數位媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/587.wav", + "text": "的使用上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/588.wav", + "text": "有非常多情況是自己不知不覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/589.wav", + "text": "就掉入讓自己成為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/590.wav", + "text": "剝削影像的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/591.wav", + "text": "而在這個不知不覺的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/592.wav", + "text": "不管是透過教育宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/593.wav", + "text": "讓孩子們知道你現在就處在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/594.wav", + "text": "這個危險當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/595.wav", + "text": "所以我認為專責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/596.wav", + "text": "並且加上相關資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/597.wav", + "text": "這件事情的意義非常重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/598.wav", + "text": "資料當中我們硬要把它跟原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/599.wav", + "text": "你們所說的資料庫扣在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/600.wav", + "text": "那我們專門保護兒少的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/601.wav", + "text": "又在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/602.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分還是要拜託衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/603.wav", + "text": "是不是也可以表達一下立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/604.wav", + "text": "就你們自己在現場跟兒少互動的觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/605.wav", + "text": "或是相關專家學者的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/606.wav", + "text": "我要再一次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/607.wav", + "text": "不僅是報導者那個報導出來才讓我們看見問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/608.wav", + "text": "過往我們辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/609.wav", + "text": "在幫助很多個案陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/610.wav", + "text": "關於兒少數位性剝削的案例上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/611.wav", + "text": "有很多時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/612.wav", + "text": "孩子是不知道自己已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/613.wav", + "text": "掉入那個困境當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/614.wav", + "text": "他們甚且不敢告訴家長不敢告訴老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/615.wav", + "text": "加害者威脅的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/616.wav", + "text": "如果我們在這件事情上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/617.wav", + "text": "沒有更積極的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/618.wav", + "text": "我要談的是更積極的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/619.wav", + "text": "去應對這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/620.wav", + "text": "我會覺得今天大家坐在這裡談論這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/621.wav", + "text": "所以是不是也可以請衛福部回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/622.wav", + "text": "警政署之前有告訴你們他們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/623.wav", + "text": "要做這樣的調整嗎謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/624.wav", + "text": "好陳菁徽委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/625.wav", + "text": "首先我先稱讚一下衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/626.wav", + "text": "因為它今天有把每一個部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/627.wav", + "text": "應該要做什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/628.wav", + "text": "而且拉進數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/629.wav", + "text": "這一點我覺得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/630.wav", + "text": "但是它上面寫定期要有一個公布並檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/631.wav", + "text": "假使你可以把定期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/632.wav", + "text": "訂出比如一年或是半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/633.wav", + "text": "可以出版一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/634.wav", + "text": "這樣子我們委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/635.wav", + "text": "就不用茫茫上網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/636.wav", + "text": "找你們公布的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/637.wav", + "text": "資料因為現在衛福部保護司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/638.wav", + "text": "上面這些宣導教材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/639.wav", + "text": "向陽雛菊專書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/640.wav", + "text": "幾乎都是107" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/641.wav", + "text": "108109年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/642.wav", + "text": "已經很過時了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/643.wav", + "text": "\n再來當然針對資料庫的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/644.wav", + "text": "要呼應林月琴委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/645.wav", + "text": "可以回到上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/646.wav", + "text": "希望可以修改的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/647.wav", + "text": "因為這個在美國已經行之有年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/648.wav", + "text": "不管是利用雜湊值或是去識別化等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/649.wav", + "text": "可以讓這樣子的檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/650.wav", + "text": "變成一個犯罪的指紋嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/651.wav", + "text": "嘛現在我們又是依賴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/652.wav", + "text": "AI這樣子的科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/653.wav", + "text": "所以不管在民團或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/654.wav", + "text": "檢察官等等的他們都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/655.wav", + "text": "利用這樣子的資料庫未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/656.wav", + "text": "我們又可以應用AI的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/657.wav", + "text": "其實可以很快地找出犯罪者的慣性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/658.wav", + "text": "可以更快去定位鎖定出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/659.wav", + "text": "犯罪並且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/660.wav", + "text": "可以來比對時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/661.wav", + "text": "交叉分析對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/662.wav", + "text": "性犯罪影像處理都會很有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/663.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/664.wav", + "text": "好謝謝還有其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/665.wav", + "text": "要發言嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/666.wav", + "text": "如果沒有我們先請衛福部回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/667.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/668.wav", + "text": "針對陳培瑜委員剛才所詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/669.wav", + "text": "第2項第3項的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/670.wav", + "text": "是先前跟警政署討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/671.wav", + "text": "這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/672.wav", + "text": "剛剛在會上刑事局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/673.wav", + "text": "副局長報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/674.wav", + "text": "鑑識運用平台也是第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/675.wav", + "text": "聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/676.wav", + "text": "擬的文字跟他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/677.wav", + "text": "目前實際運作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/678.wav", + "text": "狀況有一些落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/679.wav", + "text": "這個落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/680.wav", + "text": "我們也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/681.wav", + "text": "因此就說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/682.wav", + "text": "我們過去的討論一直沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/683.wav", + "text": "鑑識運用平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/684.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/685.wav", + "text": "警政署要不要補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/686.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/687.wav", + "text": "有關於專責人員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/688.wav", + "text": "在婦幼保護這一塊警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/689.wav", + "text": "一直有專責人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/690.wav", + "text": "在承辦這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/691.wav", + "text": "警察局都有婦幼警察隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/692.wav", + "text": "我們署也有防治組跟刑事局的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/693.wav", + "text": "預防科這邊也是承辦相關的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/694.wav", + "text": "在屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/695.wav", + "text": "這些可能涉及到數位影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/696.wav", + "text": "的部分我們也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/697.wav", + "text": "科技偵查隊在負責這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/698.wav", + "text": "所以都有專責人員在處理這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/699.wav", + "text": "先跟委員做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/700.wav", + "text": "報告跟說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/701.wav", + "text": "\n再來就是有關於性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/702.wav", + "text": "數位鑑識資料庫的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/703.wav", + "text": "這邊最主要報告說現在已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/704.wav", + "text": "司法聯盟鏈的一個資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/705.wav", + "text": "在那個地方我們是否需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/706.wav", + "text": "獨特的一個資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/707.wav", + "text": "因為那個資料庫其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/708.wav", + "text": "也可以達到這個功能所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/709.wav", + "text": "警政署這邊最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/710.wav", + "text": "要表達說這個東西目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/711.wav", + "text": "已經有這套的系統可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/712.wav", + "text": "運用而且它也不僅是警察機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/713.wav", + "text": "運用包含在地檢高檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/714.wav", + "text": "司法院都可以同樣運用這套系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/715.wav", + "text": "當然這相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/716.wav", + "text": "訊息沒有及時提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/717.wav", + "text": "算是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/718.wav", + "text": "沒有主動再跟衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/719.wav", + "text": "來做說明報告所以他們可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/720.wav", + "text": "不瞭解有最新的這套系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/721.wav", + "text": "目前已經在運用以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/722.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/723.wav", + "text": "我的建議就是按照部版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/724.wav", + "text": "因為按照剛剛保護司的講法已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/725.wav", + "text": "跟警政署討論過嘛這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/726.wav", + "text": "第二個就是按照文字它是指定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/727.wav", + "text": "或設立它可以指定所以如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/728.wav", + "text": "本來就已經有單位在做你也可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/729.wav", + "text": "指定本來的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/730.wav", + "text": "在做這件事情啊如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/731.wav", + "text": "也包含性影像數位資料庫的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/732.wav", + "text": "這是可以涵蓋在裡面的資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/733.wav", + "text": "如果說要切割出來這個應該並不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/734.wav", + "text": "那麼大的困難所以我還是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/735.wav", + "text": "畢竟這個文字來講它有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/736.wav", + "text": "指定啦如果沒有指定是要設立的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/737.wav", + "text": "可能會造成很多的困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/738.wav", + "text": "但是如果有指定的話其實對警政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/739.wav", + "text": "機關來講應該不會太麻煩才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/740.wav", + "text": "這是我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/741.wav", + "text": "好林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/742.wav", + "text": "上次事實上在委員會就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/743.wav", + "text": "我當初提出來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/744.wav", + "text": "而且警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/745.wav", + "text": "自己也拿一個這樣子的版本就跟今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/746.wav", + "text": "部版的事實上是一��的我就不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/747.wav", + "text": "為什麼不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/748.wav", + "text": "也拿出來給我的版本這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/749.wav", + "text": "子這是第一個\n第二個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/750.wav", + "text": "你剛剛提的平台沒有一個人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/751.wav", + "text": "已經有你自己提出來的版本今天部版的也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/752.wav", + "text": "突然講說我有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/753.wav", + "text": "版本為什麼大家都不知道等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/754.wav", + "text": "是不是可以解釋告訴我們那個到底存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/755.wav", + "text": "的是什麼我們大家從來都沒看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/756.wav", + "text": "這樣的東西當然我們就會擔憂還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/757.wav", + "text": "那個東西如果真的好用也針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/758.wav", + "text": "兒少性剝削有做我還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/759.wav", + "text": "要講為什麼創意私房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/760.wav", + "text": "跟觸感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/761.wav", + "text": "空間然後現在Telegram也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/762.wav", + "text": "很多喔我們都還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/763.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/764.wav", + "text": "更有效能的處理畢竟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/765.wav", + "text": "它一定沒有特別針對我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/766.wav", + "text": "想要達到的目標我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/767.wav", + "text": "我要再重申\n第三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/768.wav", + "text": "我還是要建議除了要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/769.wav", + "text": "同意部版以外我還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/770.wav", + "text": "期待要加入所謂被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/771.wav", + "text": "身分識別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/772.wav", + "text": "你原來提出來在委員會的版本本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/773.wav", + "text": "就寫說要並利用該資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/774.wav", + "text": "協助犯罪偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/775.wav", + "text": "只是我期待再加一個及比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/776.wav", + "text": "潛在被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/777.wav", + "text": "好請警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/778.wav", + "text": "偵查機關比較常在用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/779.wav", + "text": "因為4月1號才上線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/780.wav", + "text": "所以可能其他機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/781.wav", + "text": "運用的存在啦這邊做個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/782.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/783.wav", + "text": "委員有提到說可以以指定的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/784.wav", + "text": "讓現在既有單位存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/785.wav", + "text": "的部分去做一個處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/786.wav", + "text": "這個我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/787.wav", + "text": "相關影像裡面被害人的辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/788.wav", + "text": "其實並不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/789.wav", + "text": "因為我們目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/790.wav", + "text": "要從影像中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/791.wav", + "text": "就可以辨識出到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/792.wav", + "text": "這個人是什麼人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/793.wav", + "text": "我們現在並沒有運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/794.wav", + "text": "所謂的人臉辨識系統去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/795.wav", + "text": "我們都要透過種種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/796.wav", + "text": "偵查方法才能夠去確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/797.wav", + "text": "找到被害人所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/798.wav", + "text": "其實它並不是那麼容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/799.wav", + "text": "這是一個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/800.wav", + "text": "就如同我們很多偵查犯罪我們在路口拍攝到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/801.wav", + "text": "或是住宅它本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/802.wav", + "text": "拍攝到犯罪嫌疑人我們是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/803.wav", + "text": "經過非常多的努力才可能去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/804.wav", + "text": "辨識到這個犯罪嫌疑人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/805.wav", + "text": "也有一些是無法辨識出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/806.wav", + "text": "所以說我們如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/807.wav", + "text": "現在光從這些性剝削的影像裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/808.wav", + "text": "辨識被害人當然我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/809.wav", + "text": "警察機關一定會盡一切努力去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/810.wav", + "text": "做辨識但是我在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/811.wav", + "text": "這邊也要說明報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/812.wav", + "text": "它並不容易以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/813.wav", + "text": "我想我們上次委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/814.wav", + "text": "的審查其實都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/815.wav", + "text": "委員包含我自己也有講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/816.wav", + "text": "如果以現在的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/817.wav", + "text": "或是知識來講的話會覺得很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/818.wav", + "text": "相關的專家都告訴我們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/819.wav", + "text": "警方查扣的性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/820.wav", + "text": "可以用軟體生成雜湊值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/821.wav", + "text": "這個軟體要錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/822.wav", + "text": "到時候可能數發部也許就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/823.wav", + "text": "來協助將來如果在網路上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/824.wav", + "text": "發現性影像可以直接使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/825.wav", + "text": "那個軟體生成的雜湊值比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/826.wav", + "text": "所以最短的時間就能夠知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/827.wav", + "text": "被害人是誰而且協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/828.wav", + "text": "移除影像那麼這個雜湊值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/829.wav", + "text": "其實不是原始的性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/830.wav", + "text": "而是一連串的數值它也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/831.wav", + "text": "避免實際影像外流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/832.wav", + "text": "也方便網路平台不再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/833.wav", + "text": "把那個影像刊登上網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/834.wav", + "text": "\n第三個就是剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/835.wav", + "text": "其實有這個能力下架雜湊值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/836.wav", + "text": "它可以減少被害人陳述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/837.wav", + "text": "有時被害人到不同縣市的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/838.wav", + "text": "其實這中間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/839.wav", + "text": "他還要再去找相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/840.wav", + "text": "檢警單位再次詢問的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/841.wav", + "text": "會造成再次傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/842.wav", + "text": "現在網路時代如果你有這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/843.wav", + "text": "一個資料庫的話有時候被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/844.wav", + "text": "的外流影像是被其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/845.wav", + "text": "縣市嫌疑人刊登的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/846.wav", + "text": "那麼被害人也不用親自跑到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/847.wav", + "text": "\n最後一個就是嫌犯的比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/848.wav", + "text": "自助模式及犯嫌的影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/849.wav", + "text": "讓偵辦人員都能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/850.wav", + "text": "提供給被害人比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/851.wav", + "text": "而不只是身分證影像的比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/852.wav", + "text": "都有提供的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/853.wav", + "text": "所以說部版的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/854.wav", + "text": "還有增加部版沒有的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/855.wav", + "text": "我們是希望都能夠放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/856.wav", + "text": "我想這部分其實沒有什麼黨派立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/857.wav", + "text": "大家就是從受害者的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/858.wav", + "text": "角度來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/859.wav", + "text": "這個性影像的問題解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/860.wav", + "text": "跟現在的高科技能夠結合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/861.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/862.wav", + "text": "好陳培瑜委員謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/863.wav", + "text": "我可以提一個程序的可能性嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/864.wav", + "text": "就是因為剛剛連衛福部都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/865.wav", + "text": "你們也是第一次聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/866.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以中場休息一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/867.wav", + "text": "請警政署把相關資料給我們看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/868.wav", + "text": "或是跟我們說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/869.wav", + "text": "不然這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/870.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以休息一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/871.wav", + "text": "你們跟我們說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/872.wav", + "text": "是我先簡要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/873.wav", + "text": "委員再看需要暫停說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/874.wav", + "text": "司法聯盟鏈裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/875.wav", + "text": "它上傳影像也會產生雜湊值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/876.wav", + "text": "所以雜湊值的部分就可以足供比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/877.wav", + "text": "啦當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/878.wav", + "text": "對於這個也算是一個新上線��東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/879.wav", + "text": "可能我們在座的很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/880.wav", + "text": "委員包含我們各單位可能不是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/881.wav", + "text": "再來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/882.wav", + "text": "委員如果覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/883.wav", + "text": "第5條第2項第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/884.wav", + "text": "必要新增訂的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/885.wav", + "text": "所以是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/886.wav", + "text": "我們就同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/887.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/888.wav", + "text": "再加幾個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/889.wav", + "text": "為辦理本法第2條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/890.wav", + "text": "第3款性剝削" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/891.wav", + "text": "並利用該資料及比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/892.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/893.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/894.wav", + "text": "警政署表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/895.wav", + "text": "警政署表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/896.wav", + "text": "如果針對原條文通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/897.wav", + "text": "話我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/898.wav", + "text": "現有制度雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/899.wav", + "text": "有不同的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/900.wav", + "text": "在運作也可以列入到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/901.wav", + "text": "指定的機關剛剛委員已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/902.wav", + "text": "有陳述過所以我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/903.wav", + "text": "這可以納入\n另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/904.wav", + "text": "新增的辨識是所有機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/905.wav", + "text": "都可以辨識不是只有警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/906.wav", + "text": "警察的專責我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/907.wav", + "text": "不必要這個本來就應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/908.wav", + "text": "是大家都可以做不是只有警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/909.wav", + "text": "另外增添的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/910.wav", + "text": "文字是不必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/911.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/912.wav", + "text": "好謝謝警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/913.wav", + "text": "就教各位委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/914.wav", + "text": "為辦理本法應該修正為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/915.wav", + "text": "辦理本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/916.wav", + "text": "因為這是條例所以這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/917.wav", + "text": "現在就是兩個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/918.wav", + "text": "一個是完全按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/919.wav", + "text": "衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/920.wav", + "text": "通過另外一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/921.wav", + "text": "林月琴委員有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/922.wav", + "text": "文字修正是不是就這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/923.wav", + "text": "兩個來表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/924.wav", + "text": "建議不用再增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/925.wav", + "text": "你��是同意衛福部的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/926.wav", + "text": "按衛福部的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/927.wav", + "text": "是不是請委員們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/928.wav", + "text": "再表示意見如果大家有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/929.wav", + "text": "沈委員好像也是尊重衛福部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/930.wav", + "text": "因為月琴委員最早提到辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/931.wav", + "text": "剛剛有講到辨識不容易做或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/932.wav", + "text": "窒礙難行如果要協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/933.wav", + "text": "的話是不是改成可供辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/934.wav", + "text": "的數位鑑識資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/935.wav", + "text": "這樣的話你們在技術發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/936.wav", + "text": "上做得越好這條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/937.wav", + "text": "越能做但是可供辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/938.wav", + "text": "這件事情並不會一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/939.wav", + "text": "就造成窒礙難行所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/940.wav", + "text": "如果要折衷的話看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/941.wav", + "text": "看要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/942.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得他的工作不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/943.wav", + "text": "只有犯罪偵查有時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/944.wav", + "text": "第一時間還沒有辦法偵查犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/945.wav", + "text": "可是這個資料庫要存下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/946.wav", + "text": "一個很重要的點就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/947.wav", + "text": "是比對潛在的被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/948.wav", + "text": "像過去在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/949.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的臺北市N號房的那種狀況時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/950.wav", + "text": "後來還核對到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/951.wav", + "text": "黃子佼案的那7個未成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/952.wav", + "text": "受害人所以我才會認為把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/953.wav", + "text": "我都蠻佩服各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/954.wav", + "text": "我們不一定要卡分卡那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/955.wav", + "text": "大家討論的方向因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/956.wav", + "text": "我知道林月琴委員很堅持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/957.wav", + "text": "就是所謂的比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/958.wav", + "text": "及預防未來看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/959.wav", + "text": "衛福部提出來的這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/960.wav", + "text": "我發覺跟林月琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/961.wav", + "text": "第2項性影像資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/962.wav", + "text": "的管理儲存及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/963.wav", + "text": "使用辦法林月琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/964.wav", + "text": "的版本是希望主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/965.wav", + "text": "跟內政部來定之但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/966.wav", + "text": "由中央警政主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/967.wav", + "text": "等於是直接丟給中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/968.wav", + "text": "對未來這種犯罪有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/969.wav", + "text": "修正衛福部提出���的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/970.wav", + "text": "即前項資料庫之內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/971.wav", + "text": "儲存管理及使用之辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/972.wav", + "text": "由衛福部及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/973.wav", + "text": "警政主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/974.wav", + "text": "讓衛福部在這上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/975.wav", + "text": "也有加入的角色也才不會像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/976.wav", + "text": "警政署相關單位說4月1號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/977.wav", + "text": "已經有這個資料庫但其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/978.wav", + "text": "部會大家都不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/979.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣子是不是會比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/980.wav", + "text": "現在各委員都期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/981.wav", + "text": "當然部的版本也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/982.wav", + "text": "條文及用字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/983.wav", + "text": "的儲存管理及使用上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/984.wav", + "text": "上未來要怎麼使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/985.wav", + "text": "而且這個使用一定是去標籤化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/986.wav", + "text": "不是一個真實影像的使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/987.wav", + "text": "這樣的話一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/988.wav", + "text": "所以我才說這不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/989.wav", + "text": "只有警政主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/990.wav", + "text": "衛福部因為衛福部是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/991.wav", + "text": "這部法律的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/992.wav", + "text": "是不是可以用這樣的方向處理那我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/993.wav", + "text": "第5條就可以繼續往下走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/994.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/995.wav", + "text": "就是要採取什麼樣的版本什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/996.wav", + "text": "文字法務部可以提供一下意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/997.wav", + "text": "是委員好原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/998.wav", + "text": "我們是尊重衛福部所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/999.wav", + "text": "建議的版本我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1000.wav", + "text": "也同意衛福部的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1001.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1002.wav", + "text": "還有不同意嗎請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1003.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷委員跟沈伯洋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1004.wav", + "text": "委員有一個稍微能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1005.wav", + "text": "綜合月琴委員的版本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1006.wav", + "text": "如果衛福部不反對警政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1007.wav", + "text": "體系也不反對的話其實納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1008.wav", + "text": "讓它空間稍微大一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1009.wav", + "text": "不知道是不是有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1010.wav", + "text": "請林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1011.wav", + "text": "如果不要寫的話我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1012.wav", + "text": "大概就是提附帶決議否則就是請你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1013.wav", + "text": "思考文字上要怎麼表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1014.wav", + "text": "可以把我要的東西放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1015.wav", + "text": "林委員不堅持一定要放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1016.wav", + "text": "就用衛福部的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1017.wav", + "text": "然後加附帶決議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1018.wav", + "text": "好不好因為法務部也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1019.wav", + "text": "贊成衛福部的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1020.wav", + "text": "這是修法體例的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1021.wav", + "text": "主管機關他們也同意而委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1022.wav", + "text": "對這個版本其實意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1023.wav", + "text": "不大一開始大家很反彈說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1024.wav", + "text": "要刪現在如果維持這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1025.wav", + "text": "版本大家可以接受林委員也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1026.wav", + "text": "接受用附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1027.wav", + "text": "就請林委員再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1028.wav", + "text": "見我們就修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1029.wav", + "text": "兩個字即本法\n改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1030.wav", + "text": "然後按衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1031.wav", + "text": "修正過後的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1032.wav", + "text": "另外請林月琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1033.wav", + "text": "提附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1034.wav", + "text": "好謝謝大家\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1035.wav", + "text": "接下來第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1036.wav", + "text": "第8條第1項加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1037.wav", + "text": "十四小時限制瀏覽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1038.wav", + "text": "載明第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1039.wav", + "text": "性影像處理中心得知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1040.wav", + "text": "網路業者警察機關跟中央主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1041.wav", + "text": "機關第5項第6項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1042.wav", + "text": "第7項都是中央主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1043.wav", + "text": "機關收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1044.wav", + "text": "性影像處理中心的通知之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1045.wav", + "text": "要做的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1046.wav", + "text": "相關事項以及做行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1047.wav", + "text": "處分行政處分要記載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1048.wav", + "text": "的事項都規定在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1049.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1050.wav", + "text": "好就教各位委員針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1051.wav", + "text": "衛福部提出來的版本有沒有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1052.wav", + "text": "請范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1053.wav", + "text": "保存犯罪網頁到一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1054.wav", + "text": "另外就是網路業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1055.wav", + "text": "應該要設置被害人申訴管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1056.wav", + "text": "還有一個是國際刑事的司法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1057.wav", + "text": "互助上次我們卡住的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1058.wav", + "text": "因為我跟婦女團體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1059.wav", + "text": "大家都非常希望網路業者設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1060.wav", + "text": "被害人申訴管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1061.wav", + "text": "這個部分我也覺得非常合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1062.wav", + "text": "因為這樣就能夠更快速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1063.wav", + "text": "可是當時衛福部覺得這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1064.wav", + "text": "會窒礙難行有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1065.wav", + "text": "讓受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1066.wav", + "text": "去了沒有辦法最快來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1067.wav", + "text": "上次卡在這裡所以保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1068.wav", + "text": "後來也謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1069.wav", + "text": "這個部分的確是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1070.wav", + "text": "要更有效率所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1071.wav", + "text": "的版本為主這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1072.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1073.wav", + "text": "還有委員有意見嗎請陳菁徽委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1074.wav", + "text": "上次還有討論到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1075.wav", + "text": "是保留180天或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1076.wav", + "text": "是一年我是主張保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1077.wav", + "text": "一年而且只是保留犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1078.wav", + "text": "的網頁資料嫌疑人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1079.wav", + "text": "的資料還有嫌疑人使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1080.wav", + "text": "網路的紀錄當天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1081.wav", + "text": "警政委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1082.wav", + "text": "賈樂吉是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1083.wav", + "text": "呼應他覺得延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1084.wav", + "text": "的話對於後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1085.wav", + "text": "很多案件一定都是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1086.wav", + "text": "當時衛福部認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1087.wav", + "text": "認為站在業者角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1088.wav", + "text": "他們可能沒有辦法保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1089.wav", + "text": "一年可是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1090.wav", + "text": "的資料他們的資料庫會不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1091.wav", + "text": "可是我們只留犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1092.wav", + "text": "的網頁資料嫌疑人資料嫌疑人使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1093.wav", + "text": "網路紀錄我覺得這樣子應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1094.wav", + "text": "是夠的我們應該要站在被害人的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1095.wav", + "text": "因為其他國家都做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1096.wav", + "text": "好這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1097.wav", + "text": "這個180" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1098.wav", + "text": "天早在112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1099.wav", + "text": "以前是90天在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1100.wav", + "text": "112年修的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1101.wav", + "text": "也是跟相關的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1102.wav", + "text": "及網路業者做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1103.wav", + "text": "很多的共識才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1104.wav", + "text": "達成180天這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1105.wav", + "text": "調成365天的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1106.wav", + "text": "現行是我們沒有跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1107.wav", + "text": "各網路業者討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1108.wav", + "text": "我剛剛漏講一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1109.wav", + "text": "我之前的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1110.wav", + "text": "還有一個如果知道有犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1111.wav", + "text": "嫌疑情事的話應於24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1112.wav", + "text": "小時內先行限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1113.wav", + "text": "瀏覽或移除因為本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1114.wav", + "text": "衛福部是放在子法當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1115.wav", + "text": "而我希望放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1116.wav", + "text": "母法裡面上次衛福部好像沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1117.wav", + "text": "同意但是這一次衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1118.wav", + "text": "的版本已經有24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1119.wav", + "text": "小時了我想要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1120.wav", + "text": "肯定我想這樣非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1121.wav", + "text": "因為這個時效寫在母法裡面的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1122.wav", + "text": "能夠更有效率也讓被害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1123.wav", + "text": "知道他相關的權益所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1124.wav", + "text": "針對這點我要表達肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1125.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1126.wav", + "text": "針對保存的天數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1127.wav", + "text": "警政署要表示意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1128.wav", + "text": "我們是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1129.wav", + "text": "衛福部版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1130.wav", + "text": "你們是尊重衛福部版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1131.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1132.wav", + "text": "請問各位委員針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1133.wav", + "text": "第8條還有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1134.wav", + "text": "如果沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1135.wav", + "text": "剛剛衛福部有說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1136.wav", + "text": "去跟相關的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1137.wav", + "text": "180天是有共識的是可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1138.wav", + "text": "執行的是不是我們先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1139.wav", + "text": "開始好希望衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1140.wav", + "text": "之後看可不可以跟業者溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1141.wav", + "text": "我們就只保留犯罪相關的就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1142.wav", + "text": "因為之前業者說做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1143.wav", + "text": "是因為他們必須保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1144.wav", + "text": "全部的網路紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1145.wav", + "text": "對吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1146.wav", + "text": "就是現行文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1147.wav", + "text": "上面的這些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1148.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1149.wav", + "text": "我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1150.wav", + "text": "就先通過第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1151.wav", + "text": "先180天但是剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1152.wav", + "text": "陳菁徽委員提醒的如果其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1153.wav", + "text": "一年都不是問題的話那就是衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1154.wav", + "text": "的功課請持續再去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1155.wav", + "text": "第8條可以好可以好謝謝各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1156.wav", + "text": "按衛福部建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1157.wav", + "text": "修正的條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1158.wav", + "text": "\n接下來從第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1159.wav", + "text": "32條開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1160.wav", + "text": "一直到第41" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1161.wav", + "text": "1條之1這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1162.wav", + "text": "其實都是跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1163.wav", + "text": "司法機關有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1164.wav", + "text": "都是加重刑責的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1165.wav", + "text": "但是在委員會討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1166.wav", + "text": "司法機關其實都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1167.wav", + "text": "今天書面資料有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1168.wav", + "text": "是刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1169.wav", + "text": "刑罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1170.wav", + "text": "級距配置表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1171.wav", + "text": "法務部提供的謝謝法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1172.wav", + "text": "這個部分是不是請法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1173.wav", + "text": "\n因為在委員會好像所有委員要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1174.wav", + "text": "加重的大家其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1175.wav", + "text": "都是不贊成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1176.wav", + "text": "所以都是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1177.wav", + "text": "今天有提供這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1178.wav", + "text": "級距配置表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1179.wav", + "text": "是謝謝召委跟各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1180.wav", + "text": "應該是在上個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1181.wav", + "text": "就把現行刑法刑罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1182.wav", + "text": "級距配置表也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1183.wav", + "text": "也送交到委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1184.wav", + "text": "每個委員的手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1185.wav", + "text": "我們該怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1186.wav", + "text": "訂法定刑度我就我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1187.wav", + "text": "法務部的考量跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1188.wav", + "text": "來做一個報告說明\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1189.wav", + "text": "\n我們可以分實體面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1190.wav", + "text": "的法益衡平跟罪責相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1191.wav", + "text": "這兩大塊先跟大家說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1192.wav", + "text": "刑事處罰的法制根本大法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1193.wav", + "text": "刑法透過各個罪的處罰規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1194.wav", + "text": "揭示的保護法益有國家法益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1195.wav", + "text": "社會法益跟個人法益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1196.wav", + "text": "法益包含生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1197.wav", + "text": "身體自由財產這四大類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1198.wav", + "text": "刑法所規定的極刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1199.wav", + "text": "就是死刑跟無期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1200.wav", + "text": "請各位參考我們給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1201.wav", + "text": "刑罰級距配置表大家可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1202.wav", + "text": "死刑無期徒刑跟個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1203.wav", + "text": "法益相關的罪名只有4個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1204.wav", + "text": "就是強制性交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1205.wav", + "text": "強盜而故意殺人罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1206.wav", + "text": "海盜而故意殺人罪以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1207.wav", + "text": "擄人勒贖而故意殺人罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1208.wav", + "text": "我們都有用紅筆標給大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1209.wav", + "text": "所以刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1210.wav", + "text": "為上限再依序就各個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1211.wav", + "text": "法益還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1212.wav", + "text": "行為的手段來排序各罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1213.wav", + "text": "的法定刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1214.wav", + "text": "其他的刑事處罰規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1215.wav", + "text": "也是以刑法為比較基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1216.wav", + "text": "保護的法益及行為手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1217.wav", + "text": "來排序各個罪的法定刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1218.wav", + "text": "所以我們所有的法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1219.wav", + "text": "律基本上是以刑法來做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1220.wav", + "text": "基礎比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1221.wav", + "text": "\n我們看兒少性剝削防制條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1222.wav", + "text": "第1條的原則我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1223.wav", + "text": "這個法的保護法益是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1224.wav", + "text": "兒少身心健全發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1225.wav", + "text": "兒少性剝削樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1226.wav", + "text": "主要是四大類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1227.wav", + "text": "第一個是兒少性交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1228.wav", + "text": "兒少性交或猥褻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1229.wav", + "text": "物品的製造跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1230.wav", + "text": "流傳散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1231.wav", + "text": "第四個就是兒少色情的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1232.wav", + "text": "陪侍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1233.wav", + "text": "然後大家可以看到跟刑法相關的罪章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1234.wav", + "text": "就是跟妨害性自主罪章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1235.wav", + "text": "妨害性隱私及不實性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1236.wav", + "text": "罪章以及妨害秘密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1237.wav", + "text": "罪章與這四個罪章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1238.wav", + "text": "是相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1239.wav", + "text": "另外如果是行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1240.wav", + "text": "故意對兒少犯刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1241.wav", + "text": "各章的罪的時候我們另外是依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1242.wav", + "text": "兒少福利與權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1243.wav", + "text": "保障法第一百十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1244.wav", + "text": "第一項規定是加重其刑到二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1245.wav", + "text": "所以我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1246.wav", + "text": "平及罪責相當的每一個法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1247.wav", + "text": "來比較來看的時候其實去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1248.wav", + "text": "的時候我們為了配合刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1249.wav", + "text": "增訂性影像的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1250.wav", + "text": "及妨害性隱私跟不實性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1251.wav", + "text": "罪章再參照我們剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1252.wav", + "text": "每個刑法相關罪章保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1253.wav", + "text": "法益行為手段刑度的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1254.wav", + "text": "跟兒權法第一百十二條第一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1255.wav", + "text": "的規定我們是有全面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1256.wav", + "text": "剝削防制條例相關罪責的刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1257.wav", + "text": "\n而且為了落實這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1258.wav", + "text": "其實無正當理由持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1259.wav", + "text": "兒少性影像還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1260.wav", + "text": "無正當理由觀覽兒少性影像及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1261.wav", + "text": "猥褻行為本來是行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1262.wav", + "text": "罰而已後來去年是改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1263.wav", + "text": "為刑罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1264.wav", + "text": "這個部分的修法去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1265.wav", + "text": "那時候行政院也多次召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1266.wav", + "text": "跨部會的研商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1267.wav", + "text": "各部會也有共識才通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1268.wav", + "text": "院會提到立法院並經過委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1269.wav", + "text": "審議\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1270.wav", + "text": "是屬於行政裁罰的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1271.wav", + "text": "無正當理由持有兒少性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1272.wav", + "text": "跟無正當理由觀覽兒少性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1273.wav", + "text": "有比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1274.wav", + "text": "可是當時是考量整體的社會風氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1275.wav", + "text": "種型態的法制意識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1276.wav", + "text": "也有參酌各國的立法例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1277.wav", + "text": "例我們那時候是參採法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1278.wav", + "text": "刑度比較低的日本立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1279.wav", + "text": "例現在再來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1280.wav", + "text": "還可以再商議當然這點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1281.wav", + "text": "認為應該是可以有再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1282.wav", + "text": "研求的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1283.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們認為去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1284.wav", + "text": "在修的時候其實每個刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1285.wav", + "text": "刑度已經比刑法高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1286.wav", + "text": "最輕本刑再提高但是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1287.wav", + "text": "部分剛剛我們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1288.wav", + "text": "跟各位報告這個刑度設計有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1289.wav", + "text": "符合法益衡平跟罪責相當性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1290.wav", + "text": "跟各位報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1291.wav", + "text": "除了是要對犯罪人追究刑責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1292.wav", + "text": "施以刑罰之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1293.wav", + "text": "還有其他的部分一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1294.wav", + "text": "要讓司法資源有效的運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1295.wav", + "text": "還有填補被害人的損害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1296.wav", + "text": "另外就是有利被告跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1297.wav", + "text": "犯罪嫌疑人的再社會化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1298.wav", + "text": "還有犯罪的特別預防等目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1299.wav", + "text": "所以緩起訴處分這個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1300.wav", + "text": "是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1301.wav", + "text": "需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1302.wav", + "text": "\n現行刑事訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1303.wav", + "text": "有關緩起訴處分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1304.wav", + "text": "規定檢察官在個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1305.wav", + "text": "諭知的時候他必須也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1306.wav", + "text": "要符合法定要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1307.wav", + "text": "如果不符合法定要件是不可能做出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1308.wav", + "text": "緩起訴處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1309.wav", + "text": "另外的救濟程序也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1310.wav", + "text": "就是如果有告訴人告訴人不服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1311.wav", + "text": "他是可以聲請再議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1312.wav", + "text": "議如果沒有告訴人檢察官也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1313.wav", + "text": "依職權聲請送再議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1314.wav", + "text": "所以像黃子佼這個案件雖然他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1315.wav", + "text": "緩起訴有引起輿論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1316.wav", + "text": "一些反彈但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1317.wav", + "text": "再發回重新再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1318.wav", + "text": "所以對於檢察官所為的緩起訴處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1319.wav", + "text": "刑事訴訟法其實是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1320.wav", + "text": "相當的審核救濟機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1321.wav", + "text": "來確保緩起訴處分的妥適性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1322.wav", + "text": "所以如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1323.wav", + "text": "委員們的提案提高是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1324.wav", + "text": "要排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1325.wav", + "text": "檢察官緩起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1326.wav", + "text": "處分的權力其實這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1327.wav", + "text": "相關的機制是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1328.wav", + "text": "刑度一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1329.wav", + "text": "處理就比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1330.wav", + "text": "其實不見得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1331.wav", + "text": "至於相關的案例我們上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1332.wav", + "text": "也有跟委員們報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1333.wav", + "text": "檢察官沒有緩起訴處分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1334.wav", + "text": "權限會有什麼樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1335.wav", + "text": "上次也有提過一些案例司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1336.wav", + "text": "廳長也有跟大家提到一些案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1337.wav", + "text": "現在臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1338.wav", + "text": "有一個高職學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1339.wav", + "text": "覺得好玩並不一定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1340.wav", + "text": "但是他就直接傳給同學這樣彼此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1341.wav", + "text": "看依照法律構成要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1342.wav", + "text": "來看他們是有可能構成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1343.wav", + "text": "及散布這都是非常重的罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1344.wav", + "text": "要是沒有緩起訴處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1345.wav", + "text": "的機制刑度一律都拉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1346.wav", + "text": "三年以上很高的話沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1347.wav", + "text": "對於年輕人來講這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1348.wav", + "text": "可能可以再多思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1349.wav", + "text": "\n另外實務上也有青少年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1350.wav", + "text": "因為觸犯兒少性剝削條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1351.wav", + "text": "的罪名遭移送法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1352.wav", + "text": "地檢署的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1353.wav", + "text": "在逃家期間結交男朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1354.wav", + "text": "男女交往期間分別透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1355.wav", + "text": "男生去打零工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1356.wav", + "text": "女生從事性交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1357.wav", + "text": "尋獲後這個男友就有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1358.wav", + "text": "因為涉嫌兒少性剝削條例遭到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1359.wav", + "text": "移送像這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1360.wav", + "text": "的很重刑的兒少性剝削" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1361.wav", + "text": "那種很可惡的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1362.wav", + "text": "犯行是不是要等同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1363.wav", + "text": "一概的這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1364.wav", + "text": "去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1365.wav", + "text": "如果用重刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1366.wav", + "text": "來排除檢察官對這種案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1367.wav", + "text": "的緩起訴處分權限到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1368.wav", + "text": "對於那種非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1369.wav", + "text": "可惡的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1370.wav", + "text": "我跟各位報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1371.wav", + "text": "比如臺版N號房這種情節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1372.wav", + "text": "我們檢警都是積極查緝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1373.wav", + "text": "也會清查所有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1374.wav", + "text": "的被害人並查明他們的相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1375.wav", + "text": "犯罪所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1376.wav", + "text": "他們犯罪所查獲的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1377.wav", + "text": "罪數是可以加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1378.wav", + "text": "如果每犯一次其實那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1379.wav", + "text": "應該是每一個行為都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1380.wav", + "text": "數罪併罰是可以加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1381.wav", + "text": "所以不見得是一種行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1382.wav", + "text": "的刑度就拉得很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1383.wav", + "text": "可以累計加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1384.wav", + "text": "這樣他們就會被輕判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1385.wav", + "text": "而且犯罪所得提高法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1386.wav", + "text": "宣判的刑度跟沒收的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1387.wav", + "text": "來累加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1388.wav", + "text": "\n另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1389.wav", + "text": "我們在去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1390.wav", + "text": "修法的時候其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1391.wav", + "text": "已經把無正當理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1392.wav", + "text": "持有兒少性影像和觀覽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1393.wav", + "text": "兒少性影像刑罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1394.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們贊同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1395.wav", + "text": "這次衛福部提出的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1396.wav", + "text": "法務部尊重衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1397.wav", + "text": "提出的版本至於其他部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1398.wav", + "text": "之前已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1399.wav", + "text": "通盤考量到的我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1400.wav", + "text": "維持原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1401.wav", + "text": "無正當理由持有和無正當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1402.wav", + "text": "建議按照衛福部這次提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1403.wav", + "text": "刑度的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1404.wav", + "text": "做修正以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1405.wav", + "text": "謝謝法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1406.wav", + "text": "的說明請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1407.wav", + "text": "司法院有沒有補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1408.wav", + "text": "各位委員大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1409.wav", + "text": "剛剛法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1410.wav", + "text": "援引也都贊成對衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1411.wav", + "text": "後來有稍微調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1412.wav", + "text": "我們稍後也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1413.wav", + "text": "為了避免兒少遭到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1414.wav", + "text": "本來的刑法體系也就是法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1415.wav", + "text": "主管的刑法體系裡面本來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1416.wav", + "text": "有一些關於兒少保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1417.wav", + "text": "刑法體系不論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1418.wav", + "text": "是普通刑法或是特別刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1419.wav", + "text": "都不會因為這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1420.wav", + "text": "去減少對兒少的保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1421.wav", + "text": "加重其刑至二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1422.wav", + "text": "這都是分則的加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1423.wav", + "text": "\n這部分代表整個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1424.wav", + "text": "社會對兒少保護是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1425.wav", + "text": "的任務像我們已經把兒權公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1426.wav", + "text": "性剝削防制條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1427.wav", + "text": "體系來看似乎並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1428.wav", + "text": "法定刑過輕的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1429.wav", + "text": "參事說的去年才修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1430.wav", + "text": "把一些過去沒有入罪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1431.wav", + "text": "希望能夠像前次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1432.wav", + "text": "強調人人保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1433.wav", + "text": "社會人人讓兒少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1434.wav", + "text": "經濟剝削或是犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1435.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠得到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1436.wav", + "text": "資料請大家去細看我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1437.wav", + "text": "第31條以下一直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1438.wav", + "text": "影像的這些罪名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1439.wav", + "text": "大概都可以看到我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1440.wav", + "text": "和各自的刑法體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1441.wav", + "text": "第1項到第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1442.wav", + "text": "交或猥褻行為而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1443.wav", + "text": "引誘容留或媒介以營利者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1444.wav", + "text": "營利者是五年以下對比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1445.wav", + "text": "現行條文其實並沒有過輕的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1446.wav", + "text": "其他的各條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1447.wav", + "text": "保護兒少不受性剝削" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1448.wav", + "text": "的特別刑法當中其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1449.wav", + "text": "要強調即使是特別刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1450.wav", + "text": "目前普通刑法裡面的刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1451.wav", + "text": "體系來看可能還是要回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1452.wav", + "text": "補充謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1453.wav", + "text": "謝謝法務部和司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1454.wav", + "text": "討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1455.wav", + "text": "第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1456.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1457.wav", + "text": "司法院法務部的意見是不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1458.wav", + "text": "訂維持原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1459.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1460.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1461.wav", + "text": "我們就維持原條文\n第33" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1462.wav", + "text": "條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1463.wav", + "text": "也是維持原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1464.wav", + "text": "各位有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1465.wav", + "text": "維持原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1466.wav", + "text": "36條衛福部有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1467.wav", + "text": "第36條第1項第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1468.wav", + "text": "第3項及第7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1469.wav", + "text": "項增加重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1470.wav", + "text": "另外在第1項的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1471.wav", + "text": "罰金部分訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1472.wav", + "text": "樓地板十萬元以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1473.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1474.wav", + "text": "在第36條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1475.wav", + "text": "尊重但是我看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1476.wav", + "text": "幾個委員提案的版本我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1477.wav", + "text": "有兩項是大家可以去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1478.wav", + "text": "在第25頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1479.wav", + "text": "林思銘委員和本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1480.wav", + "text": "的圖畫影像去恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1481.wav", + "text": "別人的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1482.wav", + "text": "我覺得實務上的樣態可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1483.wav", + "text": "不想要被外流外洩的話你要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1484.wav", + "text": "答應我什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1485.wav", + "text": "或者是對他有進一步的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1486.wav", + "text": "恐嚇威脅往往很多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1487.wav", + "text": "可能是不小心或是他可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1488.wav", + "text": "在性影像被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1489.wav", + "text": "掌握之後反而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1490.wav", + "text": "一步一步就被人家做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1491.wav", + "text": "有這樣的一個樣態是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1492.wav", + "text": "把這個再加入當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1493.wav", + "text": "或規範這樣的犯罪行為等下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1494.wav", + "text": "再請相關司法單位來做意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1495.wav", + "text": "如果它有不同的樣態然後去恐嚇別人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1496.wav", + "text": "加重刑責我認為是可以考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1497.wav", + "text": "的版本提到是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1498.wav", + "text": "否應該要輔助相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1499.wav", + "text": "的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1500.wav", + "text": "跟衛福部比較相關以上這兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1501.wav", + "text": "謝謝好謝謝請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1502.wav", + "text": "范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1503.wav", + "text": "第36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1504.wav", + "text": "在刑罰方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1505.wav", + "text": "我並沒有意見所以對衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1506.wav", + "text": "十萬以上的部分我覺得滿好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1507.wav", + "text": "這一條我們主要就是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1508.wav", + "text": "大家記得當時我們在委員會討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1509.wav", + "text": "衛福部好像有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1510.wav", + "text": "很高興衛福部接受大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1511.wav", + "text": "因為重製性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1512.wav", + "text": "是性剝削裡面非常重要的一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1513.wav", + "text": "重製依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1514.wav", + "text": "智慧財產局的規定下載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1515.wav", + "text": "網路影片存下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1516.wav", + "text": "都是重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1517.wav", + "text": "製這邊我想提醒大家的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1518.wav", + "text": "去年性私密影像修法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1519.wav", + "text": "我們是增訂刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1520.wav", + "text": "之3未經他人同意無故重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1521.wav", + "text": "當時我們斟酌的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1522.wav", + "text": "用無故把無故加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1523.wav", + "text": "不小心下載了就不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1524.wav", + "text": "這裡面或者是他因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1525.wav", + "text": "研究目的譬如說我們性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1526.wav", + "text": "因為它是有故有正當理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1527.wav", + "text": "但是我想對兒少可能會更嚴謹一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1528.wav", + "text": "所以這邊是用重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1529.wav", + "text": "我也OK我只是提醒大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1530.wav", + "text": "要不要放無故還是就直接放重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1531.wav", + "text": "製因為我有條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1532.wav", + "text": "放在第三十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1533.wav", + "text": "但是跟衛福部第36條的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1534.wav", + "text": "是一致的以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1535.wav", + "text": "我主要也是想要確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1536.wav", + "text": "重製的意思是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1537.wav", + "text": "因為上次衛福部是認為下載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1538.wav", + "text": "就是一個重製但上次有一個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1539.wav", + "text": "只是不小心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1540.wav", + "text": "他就把影片傳到整個群組裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1541.wav", + "text": "可是班上在這個群組裡的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1542.wav", + "text": "收到的那個時候在上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1543.wav", + "text": "的討論似乎也算是重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1544.wav", + "text": "就會有一些青少年在這種狀況之下他可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1545.wav", + "text": "根本沒有意思要去做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1546.wav", + "text": "所以我想再確認一下重製的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1547.wav", + "text": "到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1548.wav", + "text": "法務部跟司法院有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1549.wav", + "text": "重製的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1550.wav", + "text": "請司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1551.wav", + "text": "衛福部新增的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1552.wav", + "text": "沒有意見沒有意見好法務部呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1553.wav", + "text": "各位委員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1554.wav", + "text": "不好意思對這個部分其實我在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1555.wav", + "text": "衛福部的會議上也有表達同樣的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1556.wav", + "text": "因為已經有委員問了我就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1557.wav", + "text": "他們要訂重製這兩個字的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1558.wav", + "text": "我們是說這個可能會隱憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1559.wav", + "text": "張雅琳委員所提的這個部分確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1560.wav", + "text": "稍微給我一點點的時間說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1561.wav", + "text": "一下當時刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1562.wav", + "text": "那個時候的規定是討論到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1563.wav", + "text": "我們要規範持有還是要規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1564.wav", + "text": "當時的司法院代表是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1565.wav", + "text": "反對就是持有跟重製都不適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1566.wav", + "text": "因為這個牽連過廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1567.wav", + "text": "廣很直白地講大家手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1568.wav", + "text": "不管男的女的可能不小心手機裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1569.wav", + "text": "都有所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1570.wav", + "text": "當時立法大家討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1571.wav", + "text": "持有也好重製也好如果規範下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1572.wav", + "text": "真的是太廣泛了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1573.wav", + "text": "但是行政院當時在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1574.wav", + "text": "一些團體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1575.wav", + "text": "後來在幾經考量之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1576.wav", + "text": "這兩個動作其實在法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1577.wav", + "text": "上還是有一點點差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1578.wav", + "text": "底下持有跟重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1579.wav", + "text": "幾乎等同但是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1580.wav", + "text": "實體的世界所謂的持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1581.wav", + "text": "就像我現在手拿杯子是持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1582.wav", + "text": "但是我製造很多個才叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1583.wav", + "text": "狀況當時我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1584.wav", + "text": "在協調過程當中後來行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1585.wav", + "text": "院是認為重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1586.wav", + "text": "的可責任性還是比持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1587.wav", + "text": "高一點所以才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1588.wav", + "text": "整個刑法並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1589.wav", + "text": "去處罰持有這個動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1590.wav", + "text": "只有處罰重製\n現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1591.wav", + "text": "請衛福部要訂重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1592.wav", + "text": "的原因是因為它有持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1593.wav", + "text": "它去處罰持有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1594.wav", + "text": "我們是參考外國立法例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1595.wav", + "text": "當時衛福部參考日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1596.wav", + "text": "德國南韓他們先採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1597.wav", + "text": "採日本的立法例處罰一年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1598.wav", + "text": "\n這一次整個是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1599.wav", + "text": "黃子佼事件引發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1600.wav", + "text": "的很多人去重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1601.wav", + "text": "這個問題所以就一直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1602.wav", + "text": "會比較刑法為什麼刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1603.wav", + "text": "所以這邊要規定重製但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1604.wav", + "text": "確實如剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1605.wav", + "text": "張雅琳委員所提的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1606.wav", + "text": "底下我今天在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1607.wav", + "text": "持有的那一剎那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1608.wav", + "text": "其實就是重製就是下載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1609.wav", + "text": "的那個當下它就是重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1610.wav", + "text": "製剛剛其實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1611.wav", + "text": "會前的時候也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1612.wav", + "text": "委員辦公室的助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1613.wav", + "text": "這個在未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1614.wav", + "text": "因為這還是要看法院法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1615.wav", + "text": "的見解他們怎麼說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1616.wav", + "text": "他們要怎麼去切割" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1617.wav", + "text": "但我只能說就現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1618.wav", + "text": "尤其是在數位科技的這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1619.wav", + "text": "所以我只能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1620.wav", + "text": "就我們過去一直以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1621.wav", + "text": "的討論表示一點意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1622.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1623.wav", + "text": "所以我問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1624.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1625.wav", + "text": "一個訊息傳出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1626.wav", + "text": "我可能不想接收但已經到了我的手機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1627.wav", + "text": "這算重製嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1628.wav", + "text": "LINE的影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1629.wav", + "text": "我們看影片在點開的那一剎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1630.wav", + "text": "其實它就是下載到我的手機裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1631.wav", + "text": "這樣就叫重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1632.wav", + "text": "這好嚴格喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1633.wav", + "text": "以前很常有一種案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1634.wav", + "text": "就是所謂使用BT" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1635.wav", + "text": "大家很喜歡在網路上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1636.wav", + "text": "使用一個軟體叫作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1637.wav", + "text": "BT或騾子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1638.wav", + "text": "所以它同時上傳跟下載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1639.wav", + "text": "正在下載這個檔案的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1640.wav", + "text": "全部集結在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1641.wav", + "text": "同時把A段傳出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1642.wav", + "text": "但他可能不知道那個裡面是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1643.wav", + "text": "很多被告後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1644.wav", + "text": "跟我們抗辯可是因為沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1645.wav", + "text": "因為被告也知道這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1646.wav", + "text": "像這一類的案件在過去有一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1647.wav", + "text": "時間其實都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1648.wav", + "text": "因為那個是著作權法的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1649.wav", + "text": "好我具體地問就法務部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1650.wav", + "text": "見解你認為第36條要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1651.wav", + "text": "怎麼修訂文字比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1652.wav", + "text": "不會有你剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1653.wav", + "text": "如果僅止於被動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1654.wav", + "text": "接收他可能就要入罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1655.wav", + "text": "這的確是有點太" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1656.wav", + "text": "在實務上我們也不是要追究這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1657.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有比較具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1658.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1659.wav", + "text": "兒少性剝削其實就已經有規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1660.wav", + "text": "就不要規定因為其實它就有製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1661.wav", + "text": "然後有持有就把這個整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1662.wav", + "text": "分開那如果持有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1663.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講的那一種情況就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1664.wav", + "text": "他是被動接收了就不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1665.wav", + "text": "嗎他還是持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1666.wav", + "text": "啊但是他的罪刑度就會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1667.wav", + "text": "例如我剛剛所說明的例如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1668.wav", + "text": "今天有一個人傳了一個檔案給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1669.wav", + "text": "我我點開的那一剎那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1670.wav", + "text": "它就是下載到我的手機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1671.wav", + "text": "然後我就持有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1672.wav", + "text": "我們的法條上第36條有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1673.wav", + "text": "重製第39條有持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1674.wav", + "text": "那就會同時構成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1675.wav", + "text": "條然後會依刑法第55條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1676.wav", + "text": "的規定想像競合從一重處斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1677.wav", + "text": "就會處到重製罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1678.wav", + "text": "在我們的司法實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1679.wav", + "text": "可能這一類的案件我們就會認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1680.wav", + "text": "他持有就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1681.wav", + "text": "依第39條第1項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1682.wav", + "text": "來處罰這個人這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1683.wav", + "text": "所以像兒少這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1684.wav", + "text": "參事有向各位委員說明解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1685.wav", + "text": "像我前陣子也有接到電話就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1686.wav", + "text": "有一些小孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1687.wav", + "text": "學校的學生因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1688.wav", + "text": "然後已經被移送少院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1689.wav", + "text": "那我前陣子也聽到檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1690.wav", + "text": "檢察官也有在講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1691.wav", + "text": "少年法院竟然還有把這一類案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1692.wav", + "text": "因為移到地檢署幾乎可能就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1693.wav", + "text": "需要我們起訴所以現在這一類的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1694.wav", + "text": "可能占全國的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1695.wav", + "text": "是學生所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1696.wav", + "text": "檢察官都會比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1697.wav", + "text": "就是會覺得自己也是都有小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1698.wav", + "text": "啦所以他們都會將心比心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1699.wav", + "text": "所以說才會在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1700.wav", + "text": "我只能說現在目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1701.wav", + "text": "的實務狀況是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1702.wav", + "text": "也感謝剛剛委員都有支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1703.wav", + "text": "維持這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1704.wav", + "text": "發生再更多了以後法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1705.wav", + "text": "對於重製跟持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1706.wav", + "text": "這塊的解釋說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1707.wav", + "text": "會不會再限縮這個可能就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1708.wav", + "text": "等到未來的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1709.wav", + "text": "因為我們在過去像著作權法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1710.wav", + "text": "一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1711.wav", + "text": "就是說法剛開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1712.wav", + "text": "都是一直適用這個法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1713.wav", + "text": "就發現處罰的範圍非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1714.wav", + "text": "他後來開始慢慢限縮解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1715.wav", + "text": "好幾年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1716.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1717.wav", + "text": "好洪孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1718.wav", + "text": "我想主席我具體建議因為現在是數位時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1719.wav", + "text": "啦所以剛剛其實我認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1720.wav", + "text": "我們官方代表這邊講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1721.wav", + "text": "就是說如果說把這個定下去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1722.wav", + "text": "而且可能很多人不小心就會犯了罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1723.wav", + "text": "甚至現在有很多的通訊軟體是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1724.wav", + "text": "有設定自動下載功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1725.wav", + "text": "所以我被人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1726.wav", + "text": "發了訊息來之後我根本還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1727.wav", + "text": "如果已經下載到我的手機相簿裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1728.wav", + "text": "那是不是這也已經構成犯法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1729.wav", + "text": "另外我就回歸到立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1730.wav", + "text": "精神其實我相信委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1731.wav", + "text": "大家提出來重製這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1732.wav", + "text": "要把它放入概念是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1733.wav", + "text": "\n概念是我們不希望有買方市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1734.wav", + "text": "啦就是大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1735.wav", + "text": "會講是說我們第36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1736.wav", + "text": "是要限制不要有去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1737.wav", + "text": "拍攝兒童的性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1738.wav", + "text": "那為什麼會有人拍攝因為有人要買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1739.wav", + "text": "有人要買所以才會有獲利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1740.wav", + "text": "有獲利之後造成賣方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1741.wav", + "text": "有市場所以賣方會持續去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1742.wav", + "text": "拍攝想要獲利但是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1743.wav", + "text": "說在第39條現在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1744.wav", + "text": "已經把它加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1745.wav", + "text": "無正當理由支持對價持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1746.wav", + "text": "等於是說我們對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1747.wav", + "text": "買方市場是強制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1748.wav", + "text": "的處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1749.wav", + "text": "他的問題在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1750.wav", + "text": "他去付費購買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1751.wav", + "text": "兒童性影像下載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1752.wav", + "text": "到他電腦裡面所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1753.wav", + "text": "立法精神應該是要嚇阻這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1754.wav", + "text": "不可能同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1755.wav", + "text": "付費的狀態所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1756.wav", + "text": "我們的立法精神大家委員可以同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1757.wav", + "text": "應該回歸到第39條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1758.wav", + "text": "我們支持第39條現在部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1759.wav", + "text": "版本也是有無正當理由支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1760.wav", + "text": "對價持有其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1761.wav", + "text": "就是禁止購買的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1762.wav", + "text": "疑慮的地方可能就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1763.wav", + "text": "不加入但是我再拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1764.wav", + "text": "主席等一下可以考慮一下如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1765.wav", + "text": "是持有但是拿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1766.wav", + "text": "人家的性影像去威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1767.wav", + "text": "的這樣的樣態的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1768.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠把它給放進去加重處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1769.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1770.wav", + "text": "我認同洪孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1771.wav", + "text": "委員的意見因為最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1772.wav", + "text": "有許許多多新的犯罪型態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1773.wav", + "text": "是用這樣子的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1774.wav", + "text": "去威脅未成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1775.wav", + "text": "可以繼續再不斷地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1776.wav", + "text": "拍攝影片給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1777.wav", + "text": "如果我們可以放進去可以趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1778.wav", + "text": "阻止很多快發生的犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1779.wav", + "text": "好范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1780.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1781.wav", + "text": "因為性私密影像當時用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1782.wav", + "text": "無故重製就可以避免那種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1783.wav", + "text": "不小心下載的誤觸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1784.wav", + "text": "大家覺得重製會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1785.wav", + "text": "這個問題然後並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1786.wav", + "text": "要接受無故重製的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1787.wav", + "text": "可是我剛剛在想刪掉會有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1788.wav", + "text": "問題因為重製性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1789.wav", + "text": "其實跟擁有又不大一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1790.wav", + "text": "因為我有可能就是下載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1791.wav", + "text": "可是我們的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1792.wav", + "text": "其實是有可能知道他去色情網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1793.wav", + "text": "下載兒少的性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1794.wav", + "text": "只是有刪除嘛因為他已經刪除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1795.wav", + "text": "他就沒有持有了你就沒有辦法用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1796.wav", + "text": "持有這個罪來處理他所以我在想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1797.wav", + "text": "如果刪掉這個東西的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1798.wav", + "text": "又有這個問題所以提出來問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1799.wav", + "text": "回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1800.wav", + "text": "剛剛大家這些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1801.wav", + "text": "以性影像作為威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1802.wav", + "text": "這個部分在現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1803.wav", + "text": "刑法的第305條以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1804.wav", + "text": "兒權法的第一百十二條都有相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1805.wav", + "text": "是不是還要另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1806.wav", + "text": "在本條例裡頭去增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1807.wav", + "text": "那我們基本上是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1808.wav", + "text": "司法院跟法務部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1809.wav", + "text": "這是第一個第二個部分就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1810.wav", + "text": "拿掉就回到第三十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1811.wav", + "text": "是無故持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1812.wav", + "text": "那就回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1813.wav", + "text": "現行的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1814.wav", + "text": "是不是沒有辦法回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1815.wav", + "text": "黃姓藝人這個事件之後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1816.wav", + "text": "各界的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1817.wav", + "text": "斟酌以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1818.wav", + "text": "好大家還有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1819.wav", + "text": "我是覺得其實大家修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1820.wav", + "text": "是想要針���比較惡意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1821.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛洪孟楷委員特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1822.wav", + "text": "脅迫的部分還有陳菁徽委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1823.wav", + "text": "就是說你這麼惡意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1824.wav", + "text": "還用這個去威脅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1825.wav", + "text": "我們是不是要在第36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1826.wav", + "text": "裡面反而應該要特別去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1827.wav", + "text": "強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1828.wav", + "text": "跟司法院有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1829.wav", + "text": "就是把它加進來體例上有沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1830.wav", + "text": "不好意思我表示一下意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1831.wav", + "text": "在去年（112）年2月修法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1832.wav", + "text": "就討論過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1833.wav", + "text": "有一些婦女團體他們也一直在提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1834.wav", + "text": "見解是這樣子就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1835.wav", + "text": "在刑法第305條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1836.wav", + "text": "已經有規定了他恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1837.wav", + "text": "的惡害通知包含我威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1838.wav", + "text": "生命法益身體法益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1839.wav", + "text": "財產自由這一些我們都包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1840.wav", + "text": "在裡面當時我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1841.wav", + "text": "刑法的整個體例來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1842.wav", + "text": "今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1843.wav", + "text": "有人拿刀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1844.wav", + "text": "對著被害人說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1845.wav", + "text": "我要殺你喔你如果不怎樣我就要殺你喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1846.wav", + "text": "其實在整個現行的法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1847.wav", + "text": "底下並沒有加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1848.wav", + "text": "所以站在我們的立場就像剛剛我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1849.wav", + "text": "體例其實4個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1850.wav", + "text": "個人法益裡面生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1851.wav", + "text": "身體財產跟自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1852.wav", + "text": "要殺你這樣子的一個動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1853.wav", + "text": "已經把生命法益拿到最" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1854.wav", + "text": "危險的情況之下我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1855.wav", + "text": "都沒有加重其刑的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1856.wav", + "text": "其他的狀況以刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1857.wav", + "text": "的體例來講是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1858.wav", + "text": "比較沒有什麼特別的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1859.wav", + "text": "二來就是說其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1860.wav", + "text": "其實在今天如果他的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1861.wav", + "text": "這個狀況之下的話第305" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1862.wav", + "text": "條雖然刑度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1863.wav", + "text": "兩年以下有期徒刑但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1864.wav", + "text": "依照兒權法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1865.wav", + "text": "它就是加重其刑它是從3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1866.wav", + "text": "起跳而且它是法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1867.wav", + "text": "刑直接提高因為是故意對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1868.wav", + "text": "兒少犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1869.wav", + "text": "刑度會提高就變3年以下有期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1870.wav", + "text": "徒刑所以就是說如果依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1871.wav", + "text": "我們過去這樣子一貫的見解跟立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1872.wav", + "text": "來講的話這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1873.wav", + "text": "可能我們的意見還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1874.wav", + "text": "維持這樣子那過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1875.wav", + "text": "有用過嗎有用到你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1876.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的有引用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1877.wav", + "text": "兒權法加重其刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1878.wav", + "text": "二分之一嗎有類似這樣的案例嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1879.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1880.wav", + "text": "因為我沒有去查過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1881.wav", + "text": "恐嚇的案件其實很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1882.wav", + "text": "少年法院這一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1883.wav", + "text": "啦因為很少大人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1884.wav", + "text": "去威脅小孩這種案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1885.wav", + "text": "我不敢說沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1886.wav", + "text": "但是應該不會很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1887.wav", + "text": "但如果是小孩子跟小孩子例如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1888.wav", + "text": "像國中生那種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1889.wav", + "text": "再羅廷瑋委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1890.wav", + "text": "法務那邊一直說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1891.wav", + "text": "加無故會有認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1892.wav", + "text": "的問題可是我們修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1893.wav", + "text": "性私密影像的時候刑法第三百十九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1894.wav", + "text": "之三條就有無故重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1895.wav", + "text": "我們當時不是用重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1896.wav", + "text": "我們是用無故重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1897.wav", + "text": "所以我在想這邊如果用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1898.wav", + "text": "無故重製就可以避免剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1899.wav", + "text": "張雅琳委員跟一些委員的擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1900.wav", + "text": "也就是兒少LINE群組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1901.wav", + "text": "是什麼就點下去下載了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1902.wav", + "text": "因為他其實完全並不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1903.wav", + "text": "就會排除這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1904.wav", + "text": "不知道這部分這樣會有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1905.wav", + "text": "嗎因為我還是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1906.wav", + "text": "如果我們拿掉了他只要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1907.wav", + "text": "去兒少色情網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1908.wav", + "text": "假如不是付費的他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1909.wav", + "text": "下載看完之後就殺掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1910.wav", + "text": "那他就不算持有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1911.wav", + "text": "這種人我們就變成沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1912.wav", + "text": "辦法處理了\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1913.wav", + "text": "重製也有包含另外一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1914.wav", + "text": "他把一個影像變成很多份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1915.wav", + "text": "那個也是重製還是跟持有不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1916.wav", + "text": "一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1917.wav", + "text": "算不算製造變成很多份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1918.wav", + "text": "算不算製造製造是要從零到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1919.wav", + "text": "有那個是製造可是重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1920.wav", + "text": "就是弄很多copy" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1921.wav", + "text": "要依照經濟部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1922.wav", + "text": "著作權部分你只要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1923.wav", + "text": "印刷複印錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1924.wav", + "text": "等等讓它直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1925.wav", + "text": "間接永久或暫時之重複製作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1926.wav", + "text": "羅廷瑋委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1927.wav", + "text": "我也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1928.wav", + "text": "支持洪孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1929.wav", + "text": "所說的但我還是要再次提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1930.wav", + "text": "我覺得不只是恐嚇他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1931.wav", + "text": "這樣的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1932.wav", + "text": "也有誘騙他人這個誘騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1933.wav", + "text": "的過程有沒有恐嚇其實我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1934.wav", + "text": "可以依照上次提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1935.wav", + "text": "的這個案例警察也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1936.wav", + "text": "創意私房的會員一手法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1937.wav", + "text": "誘騙3少女拍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1938.wav", + "text": "性影像然後再一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1939.wav", + "text": "販售遭判一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1940.wav", + "text": "十個月我想這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1941.wav", + "text": "因為自己的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1942.wav", + "text": "特別拿到了影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1943.wav", + "text": "可是再一次拍攝的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1944.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1945.wav", + "text": "還是純誘騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1946.wav", + "text": "我覺得都應該把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1947.wav", + "text": "寫在這裡面\n我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1948.wav", + "text": "加重刑期三分之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1949.wav", + "text": "二這件事情不符合比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1950.wav", + "text": "原則但是我們現在遇到的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1951.wav", + "text": "就是這個劉姓員警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1952.wav", + "text": "最後被判一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1953.wav", + "text": "十個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1954.wav", + "text": "讓我們覺得他有加重的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1955.wav", + "text": "但是我們也擔心就算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1956.wav", + "text": "就算加重加重再加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1957.wav", + "text": "現在的法官如果用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1958.wav", + "text": "判例不是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1959.wav", + "text": "兒少性剝削來做判罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1960.wav", + "text": "隱私權來判罰所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1961.wav", + "text": "也擔心除了一昧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1962.wav", + "text": "的加重之外如果法官不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1963.wav", + "text": "新法令這也會造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1964.wav", + "text": "一個過程所以我還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1965.wav", + "text": "該加重的要加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1966.wav", + "text": "相關的一些法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1967.wav", + "text": "還有其他法令來做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1968.wav", + "text": "解釋的時候這部分我們是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1969.wav", + "text": "應該想辦法破解所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1970.wav", + "text": "我也希望法務部不是只告訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1971.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1972.wav", + "text": "現在不符合比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1973.wav", + "text": "原則而是告訴我們該怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1974.wav", + "text": "防範這個問題我們才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1975.wav", + "text": "安心來訂定這個法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1976.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1977.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1978.wav", + "text": "案件後來我們有去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1979.wav", + "text": "其實檢察官起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1980.wav", + "text": "的部分並沒有及於後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1981.wav", + "text": "而且那時候是舊法在舊法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1982.wav", + "text": "起訴的對象就不及於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1983.wav", + "text": "行為部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1984.wav", + "text": "但是去年修法之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1985.wav", + "text": "了也就是說現在的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1986.wav", + "text": "情形可能我們要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1987.wav", + "text": "一點這樣的說明因為上次委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1988.wav", + "text": "有提到這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1989.wav", + "text": "整個審判起訴對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1990.wav", + "text": "其實是他的犯罪事實的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1991.wav", + "text": "以上做一點說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1992.wav", + "text": "跟我們的法官同仁在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1993.wav", + "text": "我傳一個照片給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1994.wav", + "text": "有時候這個照片不見得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1995.wav", + "text": "是他要我傳給他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1996.wav", + "text": "但是我就傳給他了所以這時候你怎麼認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1997.wav", + "text": "他有沒有持有的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1998.wav", + "text": "調查跟認定的評價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/1999.wav", + "text": "持有必須要有持有的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2000.wav", + "text": "重製也要有重製的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2001.wav", + "text": "剛剛朱主檢有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2002.wav", + "text": "的確在實務上很可能因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2003.wav", + "text": "數位的發達我們常常就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2004.wav", + "text": "有那種自動下載的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2005.wav", + "text": "可能就自動重製了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2006.wav", + "text": "所以這裡其實會有一個認定事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2007.wav", + "text": "跟適用法律的時候尤其是刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2008.wav", + "text": "人民輕易的入罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2009.wav", + "text": "不過我覺得這時候可能也必須仰賴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2010.wav", + "text": "這部分的問題\n所以我們第三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2011.wav", + "text": "拜託各位委員儘可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2012.wav", + "text": "往前面的教育端走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2013.wav", + "text": "創意私房的這些大人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2014.wav", + "text": "大概都是在成長當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2015.wav", + "text": "在社會化過程的這些兒少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2016.wav", + "text": "大院可以特別去注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2017.wav", + "text": "應該回到個案如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2018.wav", + "text": "嚴格的處罰但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2019.wav", + "text": "再是這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2020.wav", + "text": "重刑去年才修正的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2021.wav", + "text": "本來是行政罰的部分都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2022.wav", + "text": "入罪了我覺得這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2023.wav", + "text": "中部地區的法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2024.wav", + "text": "如果去跟校園家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2025.wav", + "text": "非常憂心不過法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2026.wav", + "text": "其實是一視同仁的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2027.wav", + "text": "一旦都重刑的話我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2028.wav", + "text": "這個影響所及可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2029.wav", + "text": "也會造成其他的社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2030.wav", + "text": "問題以上補充謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2031.wav", + "text": "包括寫重製還是剛剛范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2032.wav", + "text": "說無故重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2033.wav", + "text": "或者是拿掉你們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2034.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2035.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有提到我們對於衛福部的這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2036.wav", + "text": "重製會不會吸收持有要從個案上面去認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2037.wav", + "text": "使用數位可能每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2038.wav", + "text": "都是一樣的所以應該還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2039.wav", + "text": "我剛剛舉例譬如我傳給林月琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2040.wav", + "text": "一張照片好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2041.wav", + "text": "但是他有沒有持有的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2042.wav", + "text": "在舉證的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2043.wav", + "text": "我會說你有要我傳給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2044.wav", + "text": "啊但是林月琴委員說沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2045.wav", + "text": "啊我哪有要你傳給我那誰知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2046.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有持有是很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2047.wav", + "text": "法律的設計其實不應該是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2048.wav", + "text": "無論法條是持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2049.wav", + "text": "製其實還是要看個案的事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2050.wav", + "text": "去做一個認定只是我們怎麼透" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2051.wav", + "text": "讓整個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2052.wav", + "text": "不被性剝削我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2053.wav", + "text": "我們現在第39條已經有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2054.wav", + "text": "重製在法律的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2055.wav", + "text": "樣態上本來就是兩個行為樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2056.wav", + "text": "可是有時候會二合一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2057.wav", + "text": "要看整個的具體行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2058.wav", + "text": "基本上我們司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2059.wav", + "text": "這邊沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2060.wav", + "text": "但就是回到個案casebycase去認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2061.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2062.wav", + "text": "那是不是在第36條因為剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2063.wav", + "text": "張雅琳委員也擔心重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2064.wav", + "text": "所以如果按照范雲委員剛剛提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2065.wav", + "text": "加一個無故重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2066.wav", + "text": "版再加一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2067.wav", + "text": "我們就可以結束討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2068.wav", + "text": "因為這樣就避免掉剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2069.wav", + "text": "雅琳委員提的然後范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2070.wav", + "text": "又提到刑法本來就有這樣定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2071.wav", + "text": "那是不是就比較清楚一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2072.wav", + "text": "畢竟剛才廳長這邊講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2073.wav", + "text": "所謂的持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2074.wav", + "text": "是不太一樣的型態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2075.wav", + "text": "這樣我們兩邊就都解決啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2076.wav", + "text": "因為那邊等一下持有也是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2077.wav", + "text": "是不是兩邊都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2078.wav", + "text": "擔心的有時候孩子真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2079.wav", + "text": "不小心下載下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2080.wav", + "text": "請問還有沒有委員要表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2081.wav", + "text": "我們就尊重委員大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2082.wav", + "text": "討論的意見加無故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2083.wav", + "text": "就是比照成人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2084.wav", + "text": "脅迫的部分還是沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2085.wav", + "text": "加上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2086.wav", + "text": "原本的強暴脅迫就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2087.wav", + "text": "有加重恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2088.wav", + "text": "原本就有加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2089.wav", + "text": "不符合社會期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2090.wav", + "text": "沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2091.wav", + "text": "大人恐嚇小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2092.wav", + "text": "恐嚇未成年這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2093.wav", + "text": "不常見但其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2094.wav", + "text": "最近的新聞都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2095.wav", + "text": "越來越常見了還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2096.wav", + "text": "所以我想這是未來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2097.wav", + "text": "新興犯罪的型態之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2098.wav", + "text": "只會越來越多而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2099.wav", + "text": "是不是還有空間可以研議一下怎麼把委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2100.wav", + "text": "意見放進去因為委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2101.wav", + "text": "法官也好或檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2102.wav", + "text": "所以我們在第5條有增加最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2103.wav", + "text": "就是這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2104.wav", + "text": "包括警察包括檢察官跟法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2105.wav", + "text": "就是上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2106.wav", + "text": "如何防制兒少性剝削" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2107.wav", + "text": "及性剝削法律適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2108.wav", + "text": "包括恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2109.wav", + "text": "除了刑法的第305" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2110.wav", + "text": "條之外還有一個兒少福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2111.wav", + "text": "法第一百十二條是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2112.wav", + "text": "加重其刑的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2113.wav", + "text": "加強我想應該可以回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2114.wav", + "text": "委員擔心這一類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2115.wav", + "text": "我覺得也可以回應民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2116.wav", + "text": "前面剛剛通過第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2117.wav", + "text": "訓練的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2118.wav", + "text": "委員沒有其他意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2119.wav", + "text": "按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2120.wav", + "text": "衛福部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2121.wav", + "text": "修正條文然後重製前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2122.wav", + "text": "加上無故兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2123.wav", + "text": "大家可以同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2124.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見的話那我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2125.wav", + "text": "修正通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2126.wav", + "text": "好修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2127.wav", + "text": "接下來是第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2128.wav", + "text": "38" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2129.wav", + "text": "38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2130.wav", + "text": "維持原條文大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2131.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2132.wav", + "text": "第38條維持原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2133.wav", + "text": "\n第39條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2134.wav", + "text": "第39條增加第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2135.wav", + "text": "無正當理由支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2136.wav", + "text": "對價而持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2137.wav", + "text": "一年以上七年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2138.wav", + "text": "有期徒刑同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2139.wav", + "text": "第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2140.wav", + "text": "無正當理由單純持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2141.wav", + "text": "性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2142.wav", + "text": "前次條文是一年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2143.wav", + "text": "現在是修正為三年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2144.wav", + "text": "不好意思主席剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2145.wav", + "text": "第38條太快了我漏講一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2146.wav", + "text": "洩漏個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2147.wav", + "text": "譬如洩漏被害人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2148.wav", + "text": "姓名出生年月日居住所等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2149.wav", + "text": "要加重其刑二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2150.wav", + "text": "這個部分因為原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2151.wav", + "text": "並沒有那衛福部不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2152.wav", + "text": "願不願意考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2153.wav", + "text": "因為的確是有一些洩漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2154.wav", + "text": "兒少性影像就很糟糕了他還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2155.wav", + "text": "告訴大家說他是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2156.wav", + "text": "然後在哪裡讀書這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2157.wav", + "text": "好像應該要更加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2158.wav", + "text": "衛福部還沒有回應我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2159.wav", + "text": "抱歉我剛剛跳太快還沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2160.wav", + "text": "看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2161.wav", + "text": "38條剛剛是說維持現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2162.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2163.wav", + "text": "范委員是說他提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2164.wav", + "text": "洩漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2165.wav", + "text": "因為這個涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2166.wav", + "text": "違反個資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2167.wav", + "text": "我們當初在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2168.wav", + "text": "討論的時候並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2169.wav", + "text": "採納委員的意見是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2170.wav", + "text": "因為在現行的個資法裡頭有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2171.wav", + "text": "規定是不是就回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2172.wav", + "text": "個資法以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2173.wav", + "text": "性私密影像這個是蠻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2174.wav", + "text": "特殊的個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2175.wav", + "text": "耶就是說一般個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2176.wav", + "text": "放在網路上跟有兒少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2177.wav", + "text": "性私密影像又被知道幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2178.wav", + "text": "幾月幾日不要說誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2179.wav", + "text": "他搞不好都會去跳樓��所以這蠻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2180.wav", + "text": "不一樣的狀況好不好是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2181.wav", + "text": "可以再考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2182.wav", + "text": "那我們第38條先保留一下\n第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2183.wav", + "text": "抱歉我想再確認一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2184.wav", + "text": "就是第39條我們在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2185.wav", + "text": "無正當理由支付對價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2186.wav", + "text": "而持有兒少性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2187.wav", + "text": "那現在臉書有一些霸社或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2188.wav", + "text": "Risu這種社團這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2189.wav", + "text": "人在那邊放一些私密照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2190.wav", + "text": "現在如果要處理這個問題的話是用第36條去罰嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2191.wav", + "text": "不是可以請衛福部回答我嗎謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2192.wav", + "text": "這個可能要請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2193.wav", + "text": "檢察官跟法官就個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2194.wav", + "text": "來做整體的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2195.wav", + "text": "這個是要請法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2196.wav", + "text": "以請委員再講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2197.wav", + "text": "你說的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2198.wav", + "text": "好就是說因為第39條處理是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2199.wav", + "text": "無正當理由支付對價而持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2200.wav", + "text": "等於付錢持有的這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2201.wav", + "text": "嘛但是因為臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2202.wav", + "text": "有些這種霸社或是Risu" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2203.wav", + "text": "這種社團它基本上就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2204.wav", + "text": "然後裡面有很多私密照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2205.wav", + "text": "如果我今天進去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2206.wav", + "text": "這個人如果要被處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2207.wav", + "text": "是用第36條還是用第39條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2208.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2209.wav", + "text": "抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2210.wav", + "text": "我看一下第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2211.wav", + "text": "第44條也還是支付對價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2212.wav", + "text": "這種狀況呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2213.wav", + "text": "因為這種社團也非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2214.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2215.wav", + "text": "我可能就我的想像說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2216.wav", + "text": "假設說今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2217.wav", + "text": "我進入了這個網頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2218.wav", + "text": "我必須要點才會看嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2219.wav", + "text": "那點下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2220.wav", + "text": "如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2221.wav", + "text": "我在偵查的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2222.wav", + "text": "我可以證明說他其實在點的當下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2223.wav", + "text": "就已經下載了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2224.wav", + "text": "��因為他就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2225.wav", + "text": "比觀覽要再更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2226.wav", + "text": "因為如果說今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2227.wav", + "text": "我可能點開這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2228.wav", + "text": "例如說我點到A網友的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2229.wav", + "text": "這個頁面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2230.wav", + "text": "我就看到這張照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2231.wav", + "text": "我不用去點照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2232.wav", + "text": "我就看到這張照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2233.wav", + "text": "那依照目前應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2234.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2235.wav", + "text": "因為他沒有支付對價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2236.wav", + "text": "但是如果說這是一個影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2237.wav", + "text": "然後我要點下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2238.wav", + "text": "才會開始跑影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2239.wav", + "text": "這樣子這個動作就有可能已經下載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2240.wav", + "text": "然後我已經持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2241.wav", + "text": "那我們就會看整個過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2242.wav", + "text": "司法院廳長有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2243.wav", + "text": "照我剛剛在之前的說明解釋的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2244.wav", + "text": "這個也有可能已經到重製了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2245.wav", + "text": "但是還要看法官的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2246.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2247.wav", + "text": "觀覽這塊是有被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2248.wav", + "text": "要看個案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2249.wav", + "text": "證據蒐集的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2250.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2251.wav", + "text": "39條各位還有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2252.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2253.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2254.wav", + "text": "衛福部修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2255.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2256.wav", + "text": "第39條通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2257.wav", + "text": "\n第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2258.wav", + "text": "第4條也請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2259.wav", + "text": "司法院法務部表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2260.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2261.wav", + "text": "法務部司法院是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2262.wav", + "text": "維持現行條文嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2263.wav", + "text": "維持現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2264.wav", + "text": "各位委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2265.wav", + "text": "在第1款至第3款後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2266.wav", + "text": "增加一個非對價性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2267.wav", + "text": "交或猥褻行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2268.wav", + "text": "有這個部分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2269.wav", + "text": "而這個部分是不是漏掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2270.wav", + "text": "可以問一下衛福部的意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2271.wav", + "text": "因為我們在第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2272.wav", + "text": "就已經定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2273.wav", + "text": "這個行為就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2274.wav", + "text": "有對價的性交猥褻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2275.wav", + "text": "所以在條例上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2276.wav", + "text": "已經把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2277.wav", + "text": "性交猥褻就在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2278.wav", + "text": "另外又針對非對價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2279.wav", + "text": "性交猥褻物品就回到刑法的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2280.wav", + "text": "來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2281.wav", + "text": "我看第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2282.wav", + "text": "那個是下列行為之一者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2283.wav", + "text": "一才是有對價的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2284.wav", + "text": "二就是利用兒少為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2285.wav", + "text": "性交或猥褻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2286.wav", + "text": "\n對啊供人觀賞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2287.wav", + "text": "你這邊的影視裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2288.wav", + "text": "不就是供人觀賞嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2289.wav", + "text": "你這是宣傳品出版品廣電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2290.wav", + "text": "所以所以它就不需要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2291.wav", + "text": "可是現在不是在講罰則嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2292.wav", + "text": "併科新臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2293.wav", + "text": "一百萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2294.wav", + "text": "所以你的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2295.wav", + "text": "他已經犯別的法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2296.wav", + "text": "這邊不用再寫是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2297.wav", + "text": "就是如果它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2298.wav", + "text": "供人觀賞的兒少性交猥褻行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2299.wav", + "text": "就在這個條例裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2300.wav", + "text": "已經規定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2301.wav", + "text": "就是宣傳品出版品那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2302.wav", + "text": "用別條就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2303.wav", + "text": "謝謝說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2304.wav", + "text": "現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2305.wav", + "text": "\n接下來是第41條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2306.wav", + "text": "這個是如果用組織形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2307.wav", + "text": "犯罪的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2308.wav", + "text": "加重其刑二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2309.wav", + "text": "請法務部跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2310.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2311.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2312.wav", + "text": "這個以組織形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2313.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2314.wav", + "text": "上一次我們已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2315.wav", + "text": "提供委員參考就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2316.wav", + "text": "我們依照組織犯罪條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2317.wav", + "text": "它有它特定的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2318.wav", + "text": "跟它的結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2319.wav", + "text": "還有它的構成要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2320.wav", + "text": "我不知道委員的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2321.wav", + "text": "要跟組織犯罪條例所定義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2322.wav", + "text": "組織不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2323.wav", + "text": "然後要訂在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2324.wav", + "text": "我們也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2325.wav", + "text": "但是如果用以組織形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2326.wav", + "text": "定義的話可能就會跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2327.wav", + "text": "組織犯罪條例有重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2328.wav", + "text": "有沒有必要在這裡訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2329.wav", + "text": "這是我們想請委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2330.wav", + "text": "理解的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2331.wav", + "text": "如果不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2332.wav", + "text": "決定不要跟組織犯罪條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2333.wav", + "text": "一樣而要訂在這裡的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2334.wav", + "text": "可能用組織這兩個字在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2335.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2336.wav", + "text": "羅廷瑋委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2337.wav", + "text": "有要補充嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2338.wav", + "text": "就是維持現行條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2339.wav", + "text": "不用應該是不需要增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2340.wav", + "text": "因為其實如果有組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2341.wav", + "text": "這樣一個結構形式的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2342.wav", + "text": "其實我們就用組織犯罪條例來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2343.wav", + "text": "其他更重的罪其實我們也都是這樣來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2344.wav", + "text": "可能用這樣子維持原來的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2345.wav", + "text": "就應該適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2346.wav", + "text": "好第41條之1就維持現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2347.wav", + "text": "第43條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2348.wav", + "text": "配合第39條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2349.wav", + "text": "修正增加了它的項次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2350.wav", + "text": "酌作項次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2351.wav", + "text": "增加以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2352.wav", + "text": "好這個應該沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2353.wav", + "text": "好如果委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2354.wav", + "text": "樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2355.wav", + "text": "刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2356.wav", + "text": "做一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2357.wav", + "text": "還有罰金也做了一個調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2358.wav", + "text": "第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2359.wav", + "text": "有意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2360.wav", + "text": "來林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2361.wav", + "text": "當初我有提所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2362.wav", + "text": "無正當理由故買取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2363.wav", + "text": "違反第四章規定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2364.wav", + "text": "網際網路內容提供者之會員資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2365.wav", + "text": "認支付對價取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2366.wav", + "text": "兒少影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2367.wav", + "text": "所以不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2368.wav", + "text": "如果有這個會員資格像創意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2369.wav", + "text": "私房就是有這個會員資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2370.wav", + "text": "嘛所以想問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2371.wav", + "text": "一下當時你們沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2372.wav", + "text": "放在這邊的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2373.wav", + "text": "是什麼如果有會員資格怎麼做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2374.wav", + "text": "當時我們沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2375.wav", + "text": "第一個有些網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2376.wav", + "text": "並不是全部內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2377.wav", + "text": "但它不見得全部都是違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2378.wav", + "text": "而查到他有加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2379.wav", + "text": "這個不是全部都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2380.wav", + "text": "就涉及第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2381.wav", + "text": "似乎有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2382.wav", + "text": "擴大就不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2383.wav", + "text": "那麼地妥適所以應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2384.wav", + "text": "回到具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2385.wav", + "text": "個案去認定他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2386.wav", + "text": "是不是有那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2387.wav", + "text": "犯罪行為對可是我這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2388.wav", + "text": "很清楚地講因為不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2389.wav", + "text": "只有我一個委員提出來我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2390.wav", + "text": "像創意私房跟觸感空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2391.wav", + "text": "韓國N號房也都是會員制所以當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2392.wav", + "text": "才會去提出來這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2393.wav", + "text": "相同的今天大概只有我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2394.wav", + "text": "在場而已所以我還是要請你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2395.wav", + "text": "們具體做說明因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2396.wav", + "text": "無目的說全部都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2397.wav", + "text": "就是你說去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2398.wav", + "text": "某某什麼網站不是現在是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2399.wav", + "text": "違反第四章規定之網際網路內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2400.wav", + "text": "提供者之會員資格並有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2401.wav", + "text": "事實足以認定他支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2402.wav", + "text": "對價取得兒童跟少年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2403.wav", + "text": "之性影像者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2404.wav", + "text": "科或併科" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2405.wav", + "text": "新臺幣三萬元以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2406.wav", + "text": "三十萬元以下罰金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2407.wav", + "text": "因為他已經有這個動作他取得了會員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2408.wav", + "text": "沒有看到他有去下載可是他已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2409.wav", + "text": "加入會員的話我覺得這應該也要認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2410.wav", + "text": "因為他已經有這樣的動作了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2411.wav", + "text": "因為這也是一個犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2412.wav", + "text": "樣態的認定是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2413.wav", + "text": "請法務部朱主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2414.wav", + "text": "朱主檢來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2415.wav", + "text": "其實我們在看待這一項的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2416.wav", + "text": "我們現在仔細唸一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2417.wav", + "text": "也就是取得會員資格並有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2418.wav", + "text": "事實足認支付對價取得兒少性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2419.wav", + "text": "其實已經有到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2420.wav", + "text": "支付對價取得兒少性影像的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2421.wav", + "text": "就已經是符合現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2422.wav", + "text": "衛福部所提出建議版本第39條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2423.wav", + "text": "支付對價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2424.wav", + "text": "持有兒少性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2425.wav", + "text": "的刑責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2426.wav", + "text": "了而有沒有取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2427.wav", + "text": "會員資格也不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2428.wav", + "text": "只要支付對價取得兒少性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2429.wav", + "text": "像他就是有持有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2430.wav", + "text": "就是屬於第39條第1項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2431.wav", + "text": "如果我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2432.wav", + "text": "又變成會跟前面的第39條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2433.wav", + "text": "互相扞格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2434.wav", + "text": "因為都是支付對價取得持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2435.wav", + "text": "剛剛有委員提到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2436.wav", + "text": "如果他刪除了刪除只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2437.wav", + "text": "消滅證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2438.wav", + "text": "他不曾持有過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2439.wav", + "text": "那只是我們未來偵查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2440.wav", + "text": "問題但是他只要取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2441.wav", + "text": "曾經持有過這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2442.wav", + "text": "就是第39條第1項就可以處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2443.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2444.wav", + "text": "已經囊括在第39條可是如果你今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2445.wav", + "text": "去掃蕩創意私房的時候的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2446.wav", + "text": "你沒有看到後面這個人的動作可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2447.wav", + "text": "他事實上是其中的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2448.wav", + "text": "會員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2449.wav", + "text": "似乎就沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2450.wav", + "text": "以加入會員來看的話是不是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2451.wav", + "text": "可以用這個部分去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2452.wav", + "text": "而不是一定說他要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2453.wav", + "text": "規定的事實上是無故持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2454.wav", + "text": "可是如果你只是查到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2455.wav", + "text": "進一步去證明他持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2456.wav", + "text": "才能進一步針對他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2457.wav", + "text": "犯罪事實來認定不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2458.wav", + "text": "不好意思我再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2459.wav", + "text": "我們先分成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2460.wav", + "text": "兩個層次來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2461.wav", + "text": "我們就設計刑罰要處罰他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2462.wav", + "text": "就這個部分我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2463.wav", + "text": "的意見認為可能不是那麼地適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2464.wav", + "text": "因為他有點類似所謂的預備犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2465.wav", + "text": "就好像說我今天想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2466.wav", + "text": "殺一個人我先去做了一個預備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2467.wav", + "text": "的計畫然後去買了刀我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2468.wav", + "text": "刑法上這就叫做預備犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2469.wav", + "text": "而預備犯在我們整個現行的法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2470.wav", + "text": "底下他是屬於重罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2471.wav", + "text": "才會有預備犯的處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2472.wav", + "text": "參與這個會員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2473.wav", + "text": "加入這個會員他的目的其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2474.wav", + "text": "就是想要看想要持有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2475.wav", + "text": "部分變成是持有的前階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2476.wav", + "text": "的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2477.wav", + "text": "題\n第二個問題是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2478.wav", + "text": "其實整個我們現在所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2479.wav", + "text": "網站它可能有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2480.wav", + "text": "也有可能是成人的性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2481.wav", + "text": "甚至就是盜版的A片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2482.wav", + "text": "講很直白就是盜版A片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2483.wav", + "text": "有的人他可以主張他就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2484.wav", + "text": "只看盜版A片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2485.wav", + "text": "可能就有一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2486.wav", + "text": "事實足認支付對價取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2487.wav", + "text": "有事實足認支付對價取得的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2488.wav", + "text": "其實就已經是持有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2489.wav", + "text": "所以他其實就是符合第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2490.wav", + "text": "39條第1項以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2491.wav", + "text": "好我這邊沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2492.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2493.wav", + "text": "如果委員這邊沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2494.wav", + "text": "44條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2495.wav", + "text": "按照衛福部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2496.wav", + "text": "建議修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2497.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛第41���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2498.wav", + "text": "之1因為是原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2499.wav", + "text": "沒有的條文所以是不予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2500.wav", + "text": "訂\n接下來是第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2501.wav", + "text": "45條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2502.wav", + "text": "第45條建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2503.wav", + "text": "維持原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2504.wav", + "text": "好各位有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2505.wav", + "text": "因為這一條也是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2506.wav", + "text": "要提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2507.wav", + "text": "去年2月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2508.wav", + "text": "有做了一些調整而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2509.wav", + "text": "司法院法務部也可以表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2510.wav", + "text": "法務部有要表示意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2511.wav", + "text": "因為這是盤整過的刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2512.wav", + "text": "原來的比較基礎來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2513.wav", + "text": "像第45條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2514.wav", + "text": "兒少坐檯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2515.wav", + "text": "陪酒陪侍的這種行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2516.wav", + "text": "去年在盤整的時候其實那個刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2517.wav", + "text": "也已經是有考量過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2518.wav", + "text": "提高因為我們是整體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2519.wav", + "text": "已經是OK的所以這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2520.wav", + "text": "比較之下是不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2521.wav", + "text": "不是就維持原條文應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2522.wav", + "text": "就可以了因為這不是我們去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2523.wav", + "text": "沒有考慮到的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2524.wav", + "text": "只是委員還有一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2525.wav", + "text": "要怎麼依法勒令停業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2526.wav", + "text": "這個部分可能就是屬於行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2527.wav", + "text": "是不是就請衛福部主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2528.wav", + "text": "來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2529.wav", + "text": "我們當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2530.wav", + "text": "參照兒權法的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2531.wav", + "text": "是讓它停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2532.wav", + "text": "一個月以上一年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2533.wav", + "text": "去做這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2534.wav", + "text": "就是讓它去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2535.wav", + "text": "一個改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2536.wav", + "text": "現行有嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2537.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2538.wav", + "text": "如果委員沒有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2539.wav", + "text": "意見的話是不是第45條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2540.wav", + "text": "維現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2541.wav", + "text": "45條之2我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2542.wav", + "text": "有討論到所謂的公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2543.wav", + "text": "姓名因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2544.wav", + "text": "防制條例大修的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2545.wav", + "text": "現在是一個人權國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2546.wav", + "text": "如果要對特定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2547.wav", + "text": "去做公布姓名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2548.wav", + "text": "就回到兒權法所以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2549.wav", + "text": "公布姓名其他部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2550.wav", + "text": "因為已經有一些判決書在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2551.wav", + "text": "司法的系統裡頭都有公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2552.wav", + "text": "所以這個地方我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2553.wav", + "text": "建議不予第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2554.wav", + "text": "第45條之2不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2555.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2556.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見我們就不予等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2557.wav", + "text": "你說判決書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2558.wav", + "text": "有公布所以就不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2559.wav", + "text": "兩個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2560.wav", + "text": "一個如果是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2561.wav", + "text": "行為人的特定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2562.wav", + "text": "職業是跟兒少有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2563.wav", + "text": "例如說他可能是當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2564.wav", + "text": "老師或者是當幼保的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2565.wav", + "text": "教保人員我們會在兒權法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2566.wav", + "text": "裡頭去公布他的姓名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2567.wav", + "text": "因為他會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2568.wav", + "text": "跟孩子有接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2569.wav", + "text": "此外的部分這些都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2570.wav", + "text": "所謂的刑法然後他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2571.wav", + "text": "網站或者是他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2572.wav", + "text": "公布所以我們建議不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2573.wav", + "text": "因為他會接觸到兒童所以公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2574.wav", + "text": "所以酒駕的人會接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2575.wav", + "text": "兒童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2576.wav", + "text": "那個行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2577.wav", + "text": "會對兒少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2578.wav", + "text": "例如說性侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2579.wav", + "text": "兒少虐待還有兒少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2580.wav", + "text": "性剝等這些都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2581.wav", + "text": "我們在保護兒少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2582.wav", + "text": "部分就不在我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2583.wav", + "text": "規範範圍裡當然所以我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2584.wav", + "text": "是說他有公布嘛所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2585.wav", + "text": "現在你建議不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2586.wav", + "text": "再公布因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2587.wav", + "text": "已經有原本的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2588.wav", + "text": "對在兒權法可是我們提的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2589.wav", + "text": "就是希望規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2590.wav", + "text": "就兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2591.wav", + "text": "104年以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2592.wav", + "text": "這一類的案件都有公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2593.wav", + "text": "姓名在104年修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2594.wav", + "text": "已經有一個提案就是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2595.wav", + "text": "不再公布姓名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2596.wav", + "text": "如果這個犯罪行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2597.wav", + "text": "職業會跟兒少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2598.wav", + "text": "接觸就是他會跟孩子的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2599.wav", + "text": "或教育有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2600.wav", + "text": "我們會依兒少福利法第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2601.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2602.wav", + "text": "不重複抱歉我想延伸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2603.wav", + "text": "現在在兒權法裡面有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2604.wav", + "text": "但是它主要是規範在各縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2605.wav", + "text": "我們有一個CRC的網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2606.wav", + "text": "所以在CRC網站裡面可以找到這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2607.wav", + "text": "這些人員的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2608.wav", + "text": "那是因為從事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2609.wav", + "text": "跟兒童相關的行業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2610.wav", + "text": "啊對啊我要的是全面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2611.wav", + "text": "啊所以主席我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2612.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2613.wav", + "text": "第45條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2614.wav", + "text": "我們2點50" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2615.wav", + "text": "分要結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2616.wav", + "text": "如果處理不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2617.wav", + "text": "就再開一次協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2618.wav", + "text": "就是保留條文如果沒辦法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2619.wav", + "text": "\n來第51條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2620.wav", + "text": "五十一條回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2621.wav", + "text": "要身心治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2622.wav", + "text": "我們把它在第1項裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2623.wav", + "text": "第3項之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2624.wav", + "text": "經判決有罪確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2625.wav", + "text": "準用性侵害犯罪防治法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2626.wav", + "text": "身心治療輔導教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2627.wav", + "text": "包括要有所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2628.wav", + "text": "登記報到查訪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2629.wav", + "text": "這件事情寫在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2630.wav", + "text": "第51條的第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2631.wav", + "text": "請問各位有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2632.wav", + "text": "\n來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2633.wav", + "text": "范委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2634.wav", + "text": "關於第51條我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2635.wav", + "text": "覺得目前這個四小時以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2636.wav", + "text": "五十小時以下的輔導教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2637.wav", + "text": "好像真的滿不夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2638.wav", + "text": "所以我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2639.wav", + "text": "第一個部分把四改成八" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2640.wav", + "text": "八小時以上五十小時以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2641.wav", + "text": "罰款他如果不來上你就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2642.wav", + "text": "一次罰新臺幣600" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2643.wav", + "text": "以上三萬元以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2644.wav", + "text": "雖然可以按次處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2645.wav", + "text": "可是他如果都不來呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2646.wav", + "text": "所以我的部分是加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2647.wav", + "text": "處罰至其參加為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2648.wav", + "text": "這個部分我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2649.wav", + "text": "各界還是覺得目前這個四小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2650.wav", + "text": "以上好像太少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2651.wav", + "text": "是不是真的能夠考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2652.wav", + "text": "增加那我這個按次處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2653.wav", + "text": "到參加為止是不是可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2654.wav", + "text": "大家可以考慮一下謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2655.wav", + "text": "謝謝\n林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2656.wav", + "text": "我的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2657.wav", + "text": "針對輔導教育沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2658.wav", + "text": "特別意見可是是不是可以加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2659.wav", + "text": "身心治療因為有時候不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2660.wav", + "text": "只有輔導教育就會有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2661.wav", + "text": "還有再增列一項是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2662.wav", + "text": "前項輔導教育或身心治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2663.wav", + "text": "屆滿前還是要評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2664.wav", + "text": "像這種性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2665.wav", + "text": "如果觀覽影片大概也有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2666.wav", + "text": "有沒有上癮頭不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2667.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得如果沒效的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2668.wav", + "text": "應該經評估認有繼續執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2669.wav", + "text": "之必要的時候直轄市縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2670.wav", + "text": "主管機關得延長之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2671.wav", + "text": "而輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2672.wav", + "text": "教育延長不得逾二十小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2673.wav", + "text": "身心治療不得逾二十四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2674.wav", + "text": "小時所以我希望再加一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2675.wav", + "text": "如果無效的時候還可以再繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2676.wav", + "text": "延長以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2677.wav", + "text": "第51條因為兩位委員都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2678.wav", + "text": "還有意見\n來羅廷瑋委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2679.wav", + "text": "好我也是提高八小時到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2680.wav", + "text": "五十小時以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2681.wav", + "text": "新臺幣處三萬到十萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2682.wav", + "text": "元以下支持輔導教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2683.wav", + "text": "還要再加上心理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2684.wav", + "text": "治療但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2685.wav", + "text": "之前王正旭委員有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2686.wav", + "text": "跟我們稍微提到如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2687.wav", + "text": "這一類的人都要心理治療的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2688.wav", + "text": "整個量能會造成崩壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2689.wav", + "text": "所以我是建議在心理治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2690.wav", + "text": "前應該要接受評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2691.wav", + "text": "有必要者才接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2692.wav", + "text": "心理治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2693.wav", + "text": "無必要者或者是沒救的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2694.wav", + "text": "我覺得也不能讓我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2695.wav", + "text": "整個崩毀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2696.wav", + "text": "在所有的加害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2697.wav", + "text": "那會造成真正需要的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2698.wav", + "text": "用不到所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2699.wav", + "text": "我希望能夠增加評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2700.wav", + "text": "後需心理治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2701.wav", + "text": "第51條我們就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2702.wav", + "text": "基本上就在第51條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2703.wav", + "text": "裡面的內容我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2704.wav", + "text": "建議不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2705.wav", + "text": "因為第51條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2706.wav", + "text": "這個就併到第51條對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2707.wav", + "text": "第51條之二不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2708.wav", + "text": "第51條之3也是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2709.wav", + "text": "第51條的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2710.wav", + "text": "好那就不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2711.wav", + "text": "\n第四章之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2712.wav", + "text": "第四章之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2713.wav", + "text": "有民眾黨團提的這些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2714.wav", + "text": "性侵害犯罪防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2715.wav", + "text": "要建立所謂去氧核醣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2716.wav", + "text": "的因為性侵害的特殊性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2717.wav", + "text": "第一個再犯率高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2718.wav", + "text": "第二個有密室犯罪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2719.wav", + "text": "這種效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2720.wav", + "text": "預防他再犯或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2721.wav", + "text": "要去確定他是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2722.wav", + "text": "就是該行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2723.wav", + "text": "去氧核醣核酸來建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2724.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2725.wav", + "text": "然而犯兒少性剝削" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2726.wav", + "text": "基本上跟性侵害不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2727.wav", + "text": "第四章之一的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2728.wav", + "text": "所有內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2729.wav", + "text": "不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2730.wav", + "text": "它的第52條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2731.wav", + "text": "也是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2732.wav", + "text": "以下都是嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2733.wav", + "text": "它都是配合這一個的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2734.wav", + "text": "好所以是從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2735.wav", + "text": "條之6有關加害人的登記報到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2736.wav", + "text": "也就是第51條的內容裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2737.wav", + "text": "有涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2738.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議併入第51條去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2739.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2740.wav", + "text": "第52條之2之三之四之五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2741.wav", + "text": "都不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2742.wav", + "text": "再來討論處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2743.wav", + "text": "\n第53條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2744.wav", + "text": "第53條配合第39條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2745.wav", + "text": "增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2746.wav", + "text": "這個應該也沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2747.wav", + "text": "\n第55條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2748.wav", + "text": "第55條就是施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2749.wav", + "text": "這一次修正的第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2750.wav", + "text": "第8條第8條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2751.wav", + "text": "以及第47條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2752.wav", + "text": "因此我們希望這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2753.wav", + "text": "日期由行政院定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2754.wav", + "text": "其他的自公布日施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2755.wav", + "text": "這個沒有涉及到剛剛的保留條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2756.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2757.wav", + "text": "那就先保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2758.wav", + "text": "沒關係我們下一次再一併處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2759.wav", + "text": "\n如果這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2760.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2761.wav", + "text": "第2條保留第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2762.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2763.wav", + "text": "第45條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2764.wav", + "text": "保留第51條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2765.wav", + "text": "我們下一次再繼續協商處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2766.wav", + "text": "剩1分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2767.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2768.wav", + "text": "下一次我們協商就處理這幾個保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15986/2769.wav", + "text": "時間到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/0.wav", + "text": "歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1.wav", + "text": "歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2.wav", + "text": "\n行政院主計總處陳副主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/3.wav", + "text": "歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/4.wav", + "text": "\n內政部國家公園署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/5.wav", + "text": "綜合計劃組孫組長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/6.wav", + "text": "歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/7.wav", + "text": "蘇組長歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/8.wav", + "text": "林副署長歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/9.wav", + "text": "\n法務部廖參事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/10.wav", + "text": "歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/11.wav", + "text": "\n各位黨團幹部以及今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/12.wav", + "text": "特別列席的幾位原住民委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/13.wav", + "text": "伍委員陳委員高金委員鄭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/14.wav", + "text": "今天我們就原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/15.wav", + "text": "保留地禁伐補償條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/16.wav", + "text": "召開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/17.wav", + "text": "柯總召所提出來的請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/18.wav", + "text": "柯總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/19.wav", + "text": "能促成今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/20.wav", + "text": "主要就是5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/21.wav", + "text": "528已經結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/22.wav", + "text": "激情過後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/23.wav", + "text": "大家應該坐下來好好談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/24.wav", + "text": "我們希望朝野以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/25.wav", + "text": "4年的時間都是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/26.wav", + "text": "不是對立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/27.wav", + "text": "立法院應該建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/28.wav", + "text": "一個遊戲規則出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/29.wav", + "text": "我在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/30.wav", + "text": "所有法案預算協商的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/31.wav", + "text": "一定是委員會審查完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/32.wav", + "text": "然後委員會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/33.wav", + "text": "委員會協商各黨黨鞭都簽名的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/34.wav", + "text": "那就直接送院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/35.wav", + "text": "各黨鞭沒有簽名的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/36.wav", + "text": "就交給院長主持協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/37.wav", + "text": "所以院長的最主要功能就在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/38.wav", + "text": "能夠調和鼎鼐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/39.wav", + "text": "能夠把朝野議事爭議全部地來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/40.wav", + "text": "我們在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/41.wav", + "text": "從來就是這樣的一個遊戲規則和流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/42.wav", + "text": "有兩個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/43.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/44.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/45.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有違憲違憲與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/46.wav", + "text": "那是實體性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/47.wav", + "text": "該提釋憲的就去提釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/48.wav", + "text": "第二點我比較在意的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/49.wav", + "text": "假如立法院的遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/50.wav", + "text": "從來沒有這樣突然之間改變了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/51.wav", + "text": "所以我一直很抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/52.wav", + "text": "一直罵韓院長說你必須議事中立你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/53.wav", + "text": "寫得很清楚就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/54.wav", + "text": "是立法院院長的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/55.wav", + "text": "假如完全改變的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/56.wav", + "text": "那立法院非常危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/57.wav", + "text": "也就是掌控半數的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/58.wav", + "text": "要為所欲為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/59.wav", + "text": "這樣真的是毀憲亂政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/60.wav", + "text": "而且造成了國會香港化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/61.wav", + "text": "\n而今天我們就走過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/62.wav", + "text": "528我們看民意也在反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/63.wav", + "text": "映每一個都是民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/64.wav", + "text": "\n所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/65.wav", + "text": "我們昨天也已經發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/66.wav", + "text": "韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/67.wav", + "text": "還沒表決以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/68.wav", + "text": "違法表決以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/69.wav", + "text": "我們一直也發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/70.wav", + "text": "的遊戲規則是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/71.wav", + "text": "大家談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/72.wav", + "text": "是不是只有3個黨鞭參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/73.wav", + "text": "顯然過去不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/74.wav", + "text": "嘛有些預算和法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/75.wav", + "text": "有些預算牽涉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/76.wav", + "text": "個別選區的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/77.wav", + "text": "法案有提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/78.wav", + "text": "也有召集委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/79.wav", + "text": "有相關選區的代表委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/80.wav", + "text": "比如環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/81.wav", + "text": "各地方都有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/82.wav", + "text": "就是大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/83.wav", + "text": "讓民主在這裡實現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/84.wav", + "text": "像柯文哲講的一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/85.wav", + "text": "你們都沒有來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/86.wav", + "text": "都是大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/87.wav", + "text": "透過直播再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/88.wav", + "text": "嘛這是一種溝通一種協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/89.wav", + "text": "並不存在所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/90.wav", + "text": "要民進黨端著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/91.wav", + "text": "法案去請柯文哲來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/92.wav", + "text": "打勾與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/93.wav", + "text": "這是立法院在主導的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/94.wav", + "text": "嘛所以不要把責任推給說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/95.wav", + "text": "民進黨都沒有來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/96.wav", + "text": "\n比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/97.wav", + "text": "國會擴權的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/98.wav", + "text": "從1月15日我們就很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/99.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員就提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/100.wav", + "text": "說院長答應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/101.wav", + "text": "國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/102.wav", + "text": "那很清楚院長的責任就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/103.wav", + "text": "行政中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/104.wav", + "text": "就是國會外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/105.wav", + "text": "嘛所以不存在由院長來主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/106.wav", + "text": "提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/107.wav", + "text": "也不會存在院長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/108.wav", + "text": "指揮各黨要提什麼版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/109.wav", + "text": "這是不會存在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/110.wav", + "text": "院長是有一定的高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/111.wav", + "text": "所以以這樣的原則來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/112.wav", + "text": "我們把很多事情釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/113.wav", + "text": "我不希望像柯文哲這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/114.wav", + "text": "可以一直轉移焦點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/115.wav", + "text": "然後好像變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/116.wav", + "text": "我們沒有去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/117.wav", + "text": "就比如說好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/118.wav", + "text": "兩黨做壞事被警察抓到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/119.wav", + "text": "然後說警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/120.wav", + "text": "你沒有來溝通沒有來協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/121.wav", + "text": "變成警察的責任警察殺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/122.wav", + "text": "這個邏輯我們要把它澄清掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/123.wav", + "text": "角度立場來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/124.wav", + "text": "我早上也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/125.wav", + "text": "跟韓院長講韓院長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/126.wav", + "text": "他會來主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/127.wav", + "text": "要各黨來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/128.wav", + "text": "嘛來談的時候後來大家談得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/129.wav", + "text": "說大家免驚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/130.wav", + "text": "這個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/131.wav", + "text": "只是走一個流程而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/132.wav", + "text": "今天就處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/133.wav", + "text": "嘛並不會故意拖延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/134.wav", + "text": "\n本來我是建議說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/135.wav", + "text": "第四案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/136.wav", + "text": "村里長那個先調開來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/137.wav", + "text": "我們往第四案走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/138.wav", + "text": "然後專心來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/139.wav", + "text": "不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/140.wav", + "text": "所以今天在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/141.wav", + "text": "有這個程序我很感謝終於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/142.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我要談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/143.wav", + "text": "我對本案的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/144.wav", + "text": "我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/145.wav", + "text": "權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/146.wav", + "text": "這是憲法所規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/147.wav", + "text": "憲法第53條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/148.wav", + "text": "國家最高行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/149.wav", + "text": "憲法第63條規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/150.wav", + "text": "行政院院會通過後送到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/151.wav", + "text": "什麼時候送到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/152.wav", + "text": "年度結束前三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/153.wav", + "text": "要送進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/154.wav", + "text": "這是一個國家的權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/155.wav", + "text": "預算權是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/156.wav", + "text": "行政責任無法歸屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/157.wav", + "text": "也破壞了憲政體制裡面的權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/158.wav", + "text": "\n我講這個就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/159.wav", + "text": "憲法第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/160.wav", + "text": "64號解釋也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/161.wav", + "text": "都是預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/162.wav", + "text": "總數不變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/163.wav", + "text": "連移動都不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/164.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/165.wav", + "text": "會涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/166.wav", + "text": "施政計畫內容之變動與調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/167.wav", + "text": "導致政策成敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/168.wav", + "text": "無所歸屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/169.wav", + "text": "責任政治難以建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/170.wav", + "text": "有違行政權與立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/171.wav", + "text": "所以像這樣對於預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/172.wav", + "text": "預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/173.wav", + "text": "增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/174.wav", + "text": "只能當做一種建議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/175.wav", + "text": "所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/176.wav", + "text": "要行政院必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/177.wav", + "text": "吞下去3萬變6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/178.wav", + "text": "當然這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/179.wav", + "text": "等一下當然會請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/180.wav", + "text": "行政部門包括主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/181.wav", + "text": "經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/182.wav", + "text": "造林獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/183.wav", + "text": "造林獎勵它有一定的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/184.wav", + "text": "它用辦法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/185.wav", + "text": "這等於有三條預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/186.wav", + "text": "一個是原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/187.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/188.wav", + "text": "農業部也有獎勵辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/189.wav", + "text": "所以我們要平行來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/190.wav", + "text": "其他兩個部門是用辦法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/191.wav", + "text": "現行辦法到底是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/192.wav", + "text": "現在我們要用法去強制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/193.wav", + "text": "的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/194.wav", + "text": "等一下行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/195.wav", + "text": "自己會講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/196.wav", + "text": "它必須承擔很多法定的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/197.wav", + "text": "除了人事費以外的法定預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/198.wav", + "text": "通過以後假如變成六萬的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/199.wav", + "text": "剩下的只有10%而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/200.wav", + "text": "那10%要做很多事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/201.wav", + "text": "原住民權利回復條例要買土地回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/202.wav", + "text": "整修等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/203.wav", + "text": "原民會及各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/204.wav", + "text": "來談一談大家冷靜來聽一聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/205.wav", + "text": "我們應該如何處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/206.wav", + "text": "有待朝野協商大家共同來決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/207.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/208.wav", + "text": "洪書記長發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/209.wav", + "text": "感謝院長今天召開這個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/210.wav", + "text": "我們每個人在我們的桌上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/211.wav", + "text": "都有看到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/212.wav", + "text": "黨團協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/213.wav", + "text": "就已經有召開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/214.wav", + "text": "針對這個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/215.wav", + "text": "下面所有簽名的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/216.wav", + "text": "是各黨團都有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/217.wav", + "text": "共同贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/218.wav", + "text": "結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/219.wav", + "text": "均照委員會審查結果同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/220.wav", + "text": "不管是鄭天財委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/221.wav", + "text": "伍麗華委員陳瑩委員張啓楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/222.wav", + "text": "所有各黨團的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/223.wav", + "text": "都在這上面有簽字了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/224.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/225.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/226.wav", + "text": "剛剛一席話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/227.wav", + "text": "又花了十三分鐘的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/228.wav", + "text": "講這些話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/229.wav", + "text": "其實也都沒有針對今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/230.wav", + "text": "院長召開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/231.wav", + "text": "這一點必須要先釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/232.wav", + "text": "您剛剛還是把過去的歷史" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/233.wav", + "text": "都講了一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/234.wav", + "text": "可是我們不知道你的態度到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/235.wav", + "text": "是民進黨團現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/236.wav", + "text": "要推翻這個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/237.wav", + "text": "不��持這個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/238.wav", + "text": "還是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/239.wav", + "text": "相關委員的意見不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/240.wav", + "text": "我想這部分民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/241.wav", + "text": "應該也要很務實的跟國人說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/242.wav", + "text": "其實在委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/243.wav", + "text": "時這一次是內政委員會及經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/244.wav", + "text": "部會也都有出具相關的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/245.wav", + "text": "也都有表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/246.wav", + "text": "這非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/247.wav", + "text": "其中關於法務部門的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/248.wav", + "text": "我特別看了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/249.wav", + "text": "法務部的書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/250.wav", + "text": "草案規範原住民保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/251.wav", + "text": "地禁伐補償申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/252.wav", + "text": "禁伐申請範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/253.wav", + "text": "以及補償金額調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/254.wav", + "text": "攸關原住民族權益保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/255.wav", + "text": "事關主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/256.wav", + "text": "當然有權能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/257.wav", + "text": "處理以及決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/258.wav", + "text": "所以我不清楚剛剛民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/259.wav", + "text": "好像又要講立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/260.wav", + "text": "無權處理這個事實但不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/261.wav", + "text": "啊行政部門的書面報告資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/262.wav", + "text": "已經清楚明白表示了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/263.wav", + "text": "非常感謝韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/264.wav", + "text": "我們再一次釐清上禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/265.wav", + "text": "五我們就已經確定這禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/266.wav", + "text": "二的五個討論事項包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/267.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團很負責任的把再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/268.wav", + "text": "法及再生醫療製劑條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/269.wav", + "text": "排在第一案第二案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/270.wav", + "text": "而第三案也是所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/271.wav", + "text": "原住民委員共同關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/272.wav", + "text": "關注從2015年開始爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/273.wav", + "text": "一直到現在當初2015年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/274.wav", + "text": "通過之後一直到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/275.wav", + "text": "十年內我們希望能夠追求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/276.wav", + "text": "所謂的原民正義所以排在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/277.wav", + "text": "地方民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/278.wav", + "text": "的一個譴責案我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/279.wav", + "text": "議程說真的如果各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/280.wav", + "text": "有任何意見的話當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/281.wav", + "text": "應該在上禮拜五10點半之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/282.wav", + "text": "就可以拜託院長再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/283.wav", + "text": "召集協商但是剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/284.wav", + "text": "柯總召自己也講了是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/285.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團才送出拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/286.wav", + "text": "院長協商是在禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/287.wav", + "text": "一昨天才送出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/288.wav", + "text": "禮拜五的10點半禮拜六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/289.wav", + "text": "禮拜天一直到禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/290.wav", + "text": "才送出協商然後跟我們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/291.wav", + "text": "很追求程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/292.wav", + "text": "我想明眼人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/293.wav", + "text": "大家都看得出來\n所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/294.wav", + "text": "最終我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/295.wav", + "text": "還是強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/296.wav", + "text": "我們尊重過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/297.wav", + "text": "委員會的審查我們尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/298.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會跟內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/299.wav", + "text": "聯席委員會的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/300.wav", + "text": "2日（禮拜四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/301.wav", + "text": "）朝野協商所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/302.wav", + "text": "簽名的出席代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/303.wav", + "text": "包括伍麗華委員陳瑩委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/304.wav", + "text": "鄭天財委員高金素梅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/305.wav", + "text": "以及下面所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/306.wav", + "text": "各黨團的委員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/307.wav", + "text": "共同簽字的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/308.wav", + "text": "我們希望大家共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/309.wav", + "text": "來支持讓今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/310.wav", + "text": "協商能夠順利通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/311.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/312.wav", + "text": "黃總召請發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/313.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/314.wav", + "text": "針對我們今天協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/315.wav", + "text": "討論的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/316.wav", + "text": "──原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/317.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/318.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/319.wav", + "text": "但我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/320.wav", + "text": "本院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/321.wav", + "text": "不分黨派的原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/322.wav", + "text": "提案當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/323.wav", + "text": "高金素梅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/324.wav", + "text": "提的是每" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/325.wav", + "text": "每公頃到5萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/326.wav", + "text": "民主進步黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/327.wav", + "text": "伍麗華委員跟陳瑩委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/328.wav", + "text": "在他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/329.wav", + "text": "民進��委員的支持下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/330.wav", + "text": "提出來的條文是到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/331.wav", + "text": "6萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/332.wav", + "text": "內政跟經濟聯席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/333.wav", + "text": "審理完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/334.wav", + "text": "在5月2日我們看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/335.wav", + "text": "黨團協商的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/336.wav", + "text": "那個結論是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/337.wav", + "text": "大家都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/338.wav", + "text": "當作補償的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/339.wav", + "text": "\n當然在這個過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/340.wav", + "text": "也很感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/341.wav", + "text": "高金素梅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/342.wav", + "text": "來解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/343.wav", + "text": "他們這樣子調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/344.wav", + "text": "基本上面的正當性基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/345.wav", + "text": "跟計算的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/346.wav", + "text": "所以我們本來以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/347.wav", + "text": "這個是一個跨黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/348.wav", + "text": "各個不同的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/349.wav", + "text": "種植的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/350.wav", + "text": "屬於一種特別的犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/351.wav", + "text": "對於這種特別的犧牲國家予以補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/352.wav", + "text": "本來就是在憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/353.wav", + "text": "上面的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/354.wav", + "text": "補償的金額到底要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/355.wav", + "text": "哪裡這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/356.wav", + "text": "我們有一些其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/357.wav", + "text": "reference可以當作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/358.wav", + "text": "參照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/359.wav", + "text": "我們在理解了這整個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/360.wav", + "text": "的時候我們黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/361.wav", + "text": "也對於最後這個黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/362.wav", + "text": "所以在上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/363.wav", + "text": "我們統統都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/364.wav", + "text": "簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/365.wav", + "text": "\n我大概溯源了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/366.wav", + "text": "因為在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/367.wav", + "text": "法案的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/368.wav", + "text": "當初去訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/369.wav", + "text": "這個補償條例的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/370.wav", + "text": "一開始會有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/371.wav", + "text": "立法委員在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/372.wav", + "text": "年那屆國會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/373.wav", + "text": "我現在看到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/374.wav", + "text": "簡東明等48位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/375.wav", + "text": "擬具的原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/376.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償及造林回饋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/377.wav", + "text": "條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/378.wav", + "text": "當初要怎麼補償這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/379.wav", + "text": "也是由立法部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/380.wav", + "text": "上面的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/381.wav", + "text": "在我們這屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/382.wav", + "text": "國會的時候在整個討論審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/383.wav", + "text": "的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/384.wav", + "text": "有提出什麼強烈反對的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/385.wav", + "text": "包括那天黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/386.wav", + "text": "就我們所看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/387.wav", + "text": "會議紀錄大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/388.wav", + "text": "這個樣子\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/389.wav", + "text": "所以我想前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/390.wav", + "text": "委員會討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/391.wav", + "text": "在委員會的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/392.wav", + "text": "大家也都簽字了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/393.wav", + "text": "高金素梅委員也很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/394.wav", + "text": "負責地有來跟我們解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/395.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/396.wav", + "text": "有需要予以調整以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/397.wav", + "text": "調整基準的考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/398.wav", + "text": "現在目前的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/399.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/400.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/401.wav", + "text": "\n我們再請民進黨柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/402.wav", + "text": "第一個我一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/403.wav", + "text": "再次講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/404.wav", + "text": "政府的預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/405.wav", + "text": "預算能夠照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/406.wav", + "text": "原住民乃至於弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/407.wav", + "text": "包括造林補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/408.wav", + "text": "我們都100%贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/409.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/410.wav", + "text": "我也瞭解原住民委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/411.wav", + "text": "包括你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/412.wav", + "text": "讚你可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/413.wav", + "text": "高金委員是原住民委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/414.wav", + "text": "特別瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/415.wav", + "text": "剛才不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/416.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/417.wav", + "text": "我非常訝異他們為什麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/418.wav", + "text": "這些話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/419.wav", + "text": "各位都在立法院裡面這麼久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/420.wav", + "text": "第一個委員會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/421.wav", + "text": "所有朝野黨團都簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/422.wav", + "text": "委員會協商是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/423.wav", + "text": "一般委員會討論以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/424.wav", + "text": "大���都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/425.wav", + "text": "最後黨鞭都會簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/426.wav", + "text": "直接就送三讀了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/427.wav", + "text": "當然沒有完成這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/428.wav", + "text": "嘛民進黨都沒有簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/429.wav", + "text": "在立法院這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/430.wav", + "text": "黃國昌你還不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/431.wav", + "text": "每次都是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/432.wav", + "text": "跑掉的時候人家拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/433.wav", + "text": "再回來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/434.wav", + "text": "甚至到院長這邊也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/435.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做你以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/436.wav", + "text": "這次已經朝野黨團都簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/437.wav", + "text": "我們三長都沒有簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/438.wav", + "text": "這是立法院遊戲規則很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/439.wav", + "text": "不要這樣子講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/440.wav", + "text": "到這裡已經是直播的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/441.wav", + "text": "還在講這種話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/442.wav", + "text": "\n第二個所謂法務部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/443.wav", + "text": "他說尊重主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/444.wav", + "text": "以及大院主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/445.wav", + "text": "主管機關是原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/446.wav", + "text": "是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/447.wav", + "text": "行政是一體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/448.wav", + "text": "行政院有院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/449.wav", + "text": "所以是一體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/450.wav", + "text": "所以委員排這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/451.wav", + "text": "慣當然表示尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/452.wav", + "text": "但是真正的主管機關是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/453.wav", + "text": "以及大院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/454.wav", + "text": "所以兩院必須要好好談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/455.wav", + "text": "當然沒有所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/456.wav", + "text": "非常清楚且明白的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/457.wav", + "text": "不要再曲解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/458.wav", + "text": "\n至於坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/459.wav", + "text": "我是上禮拜五就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/460.wav", + "text": "衝突以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/461.wav", + "text": "就發協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/462.wav", + "text": "給韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/463.wav", + "text": "昨天再補發一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/464.wav", + "text": "回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/465.wav", + "text": "當然韓院長說他昨天另外有行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/466.wav", + "text": "這我能夠體會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/467.wav", + "text": "但是因為他早上才跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/468.wav", + "text": "嘛所以請黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/469.wav", + "text": "以及傅崐萁你們注意聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/470.wav", + "text": "有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/471.wav", + "text": "一開始我們一直講這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/472.wav", + "text": "講了多少次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/473.wav", + "text": "遊戲規則現在先訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/474.wav", + "text": "包括什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/475.wav", + "text": "包括所謂的三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/476.wav", + "text": "我上次講過今天是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/477.wav", + "text": "和原住民有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/478.wav", + "text": "原住民委員是不是應該來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/479.wav", + "text": "怎麼會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/480.wav", + "text": "包括和選區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/481.wav", + "text": "有關係包括提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/482.wav", + "text": "包括召委都應該來過去都是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/483.wav", + "text": "前瞻基礎建設預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/484.wav", + "text": "因為國民黨整個一路阻擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/485.wav", + "text": "造成委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/486.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/487.wav", + "text": "所以送到院會來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/488.wav", + "text": "院會協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/489.wav", + "text": "當初的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/490.wav", + "text": "好安排一個鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/491.wav", + "text": "到這個朝野協商場我們都退了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/492.wav", + "text": "把朝野協商變成委員會質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/493.wav", + "text": "我們也忍受啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/494.wav", + "text": "民眾黨一個鐘頭國民黨兩個鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/495.wav", + "text": "在那邊罵我們也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/496.wav", + "text": "接著講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/497.wav", + "text": "因為就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/498.wav", + "text": "是特別把朝野協商變成委員會化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/499.wav", + "text": "當初我們我們是非常有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/500.wav", + "text": "但是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/501.wav", + "text": "能夠議事和諧讓大家能夠好好談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/502.wav", + "text": "我們也是忍受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/503.wav", + "text": "所以並不存在所謂說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/504.wav", + "text": "什麼委員會協商大家都簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/505.wav", + "text": "委員會沒有黨鞭簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/506.wav", + "text": "這個大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/507.wav", + "text": "什麼時候黨鞭沒有簽名就算數的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/508.wav", + "text": "所以黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/509.wav", + "text": "這不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/510.wav", + "text": "在協商大家很坦然地來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/511.wav", + "text": "然後取片段激將法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/512.wav", + "text": "用這樣抹黑這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/513.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員有一段話請她講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/514.wav", + "text": "接下來吳思瑤委員請發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/515.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長我很快速地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/516.wav", + "text": "來報告一下對於這���案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/517.wav", + "text": "我想幾個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/518.wav", + "text": "其實我手上拿的也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/519.wav", + "text": "我們當天委員會審查的這個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/520.wav", + "text": "剛剛洪孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/521.wav", + "text": "所為大家念誦的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/522.wav", + "text": "法務部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/523.wav", + "text": "但這個案子的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/524.wav", + "text": "是原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/525.wav", + "text": "原民會在當天會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/526.wav", + "text": "有關各委員所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/527.wav", + "text": "增加預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/528.wav", + "text": "涉及國家整體預算政策規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/529.wav", + "text": "建議待新內閣審慎評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/530.wav", + "text": "再通盤考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/531.wav", + "text": "這是剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/532.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷委員念的這一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/533.wav", + "text": "但是我是截取主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/534.wav", + "text": "部會原民會的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/535.wav", + "text": "他們都希望能夠做得到的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/536.wav", + "text": "預算能夠協調的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/537.wav", + "text": "努力來照顧原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/538.wav", + "text": "是我們共同的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/539.wav", + "text": "但是整體預算的規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/540.wav", + "text": "而且增加的預算甚高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/541.wav", + "text": "所以建議待新內閣來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/542.wav", + "text": "然後審慎地評估通盤考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/543.wav", + "text": "這就是為什麼民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/544.wav", + "text": "我們認為也期待韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/545.wav", + "text": "我們上週五就2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/546.wav", + "text": "2次發函來爭取今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/547.wav", + "text": "這是我們5月31日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/548.wav", + "text": "我就講兩點就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/549.wav", + "text": "第一點當然就是預算會不會因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/550.wav", + "text": "為增加之後造成了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/551.wav", + "text": "業務的排擠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/552.wav", + "text": "這是大家比較擔憂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/553.wav", + "text": "照顧原住民不但要更全方位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/554.wav", + "text": "而且不要有任何人的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/555.wav", + "text": "因此而受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/556.wav", + "text": "衝擊受到排擠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/557.wav", + "text": "但是很具體地等一下原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/558.wav", + "text": "也可以說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/559.wav", + "text": "如果從3萬到6萬的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/560.wav", + "text": "一個年度總預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/561.wav", + "text": "40%以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/562.wav", + "text": "的法定支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/563.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/564.wav", + "text": "占整個原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/565.wav", + "text": "換言之如果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/566.wav", + "text": "3萬到6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/567.wav", + "text": "明年原民會只剩下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/568.wav", + "text": "11%的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/569.wav", + "text": "可以去做其他照顧原住民族的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/570.wav", + "text": "工作不管是道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/571.wav", + "text": "尤其教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/572.wav", + "text": "所以這些東西都要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/573.wav", + "text": "其他預算的排擠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/574.wav", + "text": "所以這個需要很衡平地去面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/575.wav", + "text": "另外在部會之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/576.wav", + "text": "譬如農業部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/577.wav", + "text": "造林獎勵計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/578.wav", + "text": "3萬經濟部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/579.wav", + "text": "植樹保林獎勵金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/580.wav", + "text": "1公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/581.wav", + "text": "是一個比較合理的range" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/582.wav", + "text": "對於原住民族的禁伐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/583.wav", + "text": "補償如果要提高到6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/584.wav", + "text": "可能就會牽一髮而動全身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/585.wav", + "text": "\n最後一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/586.wav", + "text": "一定要補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/587.wav", + "text": "我們都是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/588.wav", + "text": "我們推動的任何一個修法立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/589.wav", + "text": "縱使立意良善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/590.wav", + "text": "我們要擴大照顧我們的人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/591.wav", + "text": "我們自己所修過所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/592.wav", + "text": "訂的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/593.wav", + "text": "是新的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/594.wav", + "text": "財政紀律法第5條第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/595.wav", + "text": "都規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/596.wav", + "text": "政府機關要增加新的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/597.wav", + "text": "新的可行財源在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/598.wav", + "text": "我自己非常感同身受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/599.wav", + "text": "我在爭取文化部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/600.wav", + "text": "文化基本法授權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/601.wav", + "text": "它已經有一個基本法位階" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/602.wav", + "text": "文化基本法告訴我們國家要設文化發展基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/603.wav", + "text": "可是就因為財政紀律法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/604.wav", + "text": "新頒布了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/605.wav", + "text": "所以文化發展基金籌不到新的財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/606.wav", + "text": "我們多拖了好幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/607.wav", + "text": "文化部想方設法真的找到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/608.wav", + "text": "新的財源才慢慢讓文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/609.wav", + "text": "幾億幾億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/610.wav", + "text": "財政紀律法也是一個我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/611.wav", + "text": "財主單位一定會去捍衛這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/612.wav", + "text": "法律精神更不要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/613.wav", + "text": "憲法第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/614.wav", + "text": "大法官釋字等相關的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/615.wav", + "text": "說等一下讓部會說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/616.wav", + "text": "如果預算有空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/617.wav", + "text": "增加來酌予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/618.wav", + "text": "提高禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/619.wav", + "text": "做得到哪裡可以做得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/620.wav", + "text": "儘量到位我想大家可以思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/621.wav", + "text": "但如果是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/622.wav", + "text": "倍增了而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/623.wav", + "text": "排擠明年只剩下11%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/624.wav", + "text": "可以做原住民族業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/625.wav", + "text": "這個法案受惠的是5.1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/626.wav", + "text": "的原住民族朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/627.wav", + "text": "高達60萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/628.wav", + "text": "換言之60萬的原住民族朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/629.wav", + "text": "發展性工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/630.wav", + "text": "職業創業教育文化的支持工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/631.wav", + "text": "只能夠剩下11%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/632.wav", + "text": "預算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/633.wav", + "text": "我覺得原民會應該也很頭痛啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/634.wav", + "text": "所以衡平地說怎麼樣喬出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/635.wav", + "text": "一個合理做得到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/636.wav", + "text": "我想是我們共同面對的課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/637.wav", + "text": "講完你再發言好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/638.wav", + "text": "我們可以交錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/639.wav", + "text": "麻煩請原住民曾主委你是最重要的大掌櫃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/640.wav", + "text": "你一定要表達意見好不好具體一點謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/641.wav", + "text": "院長及各位委員我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/642.wav", + "text": "維護國土保安還有氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/643.wav", + "text": "受限制的原住民本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/644.wav", + "text": "就是原民會的天職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/645.wav", + "text": "因為原民會明年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/646.wav", + "text": "預算大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/647.wav", + "text": "125億左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/648.wav", + "text": "補償從原來的3萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/649.wav", + "text": "變到6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/650.wav", + "text": "20%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/651.wav", + "text": "義務支出幾乎是占70%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/652.wav", + "text": "再加上這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/653.wav", + "text": "只有剩下10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/654.wav", + "text": "可以再為我們的族人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/655.wav", + "text": "服務來照顧我們的族人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/656.wav", + "text": "所以很多的業務就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/657.wav", + "text": "辦法再推動比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/658.wav", + "text": "老人健康站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/659.wav", + "text": "還有一些人事教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/660.wav", + "text": "很難再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/661.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/662.wav", + "text": "謝謝曾主委請主計處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/663.wav", + "text": "表達意見好不好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/664.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/665.wav", + "text": "主計總處在這邊說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/666.wav", + "text": "財政上推估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/667.wav", + "text": "原民會在114年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/668.wav", + "text": "額度是125億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/669.wav", + "text": "相較於113年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/670.wav", + "text": "大概是增加15億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/671.wav", + "text": "但是如果這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/672.wav", + "text": "從3萬調到6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/673.wav", + "text": "就會增加二十幾億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/674.wav", + "text": "還可能會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/675.wav", + "text": "需要把原來113施政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/676.wav", + "text": "項目部分的額度也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/677.wav", + "text": "空出來所以我們擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/678.wav", + "text": "一些業務的推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/679.wav", + "text": "變6萬需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/680.wav", + "text": "增加的支出會比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/681.wav", + "text": "的部分怎麼籌措也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/682.wav", + "text": "有比較大的壓力以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/683.wav", + "text": "其他列席的行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/684.wav", + "text": "有沒有寶貴的意見要補充呢不用客氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/685.wav", + "text": "林次長發言主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/686.wav", + "text": "各位委員我想經濟部這邊來補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/687.wav", + "text": "一下因為剛剛有提到經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/688.wav", + "text": "涉及到原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/689.wav", + "text": "的部分主要是自來水法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/690.wav", + "text": "規範底下的自來水水質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/691.wav", + "text": "的銷售是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/692.wav", + "text": "收取每一度0.5元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/693.wav", + "text": "那是按不同的區去設算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/694.wav", + "text": "專戶的委員去審定的所以那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/695.wav", + "text": "部分的審定價格每一公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/696.wav", + "text": "的補助是不一定的這個部分我再做一個補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/697.wav", + "text": "說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/698.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他行政單位要補充的沒有請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/699.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/700.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/701.wav", + "text": "各黨團列席的行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/702.wav", + "text": "官員大家好我想這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/703.wav", + "text": "案子是這樣我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/704.wav", + "text": "特別有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/705.wav", + "text": "啦這個案子是從3萬開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/706.wav", + "text": "始調整不是無中生有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/707.wav", + "text": "行政部門已經在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/708.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償如果調高到6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/709.wav", + "text": "的話我剛也聽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/710.wav", + "text": "這個部分所增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/711.wav", + "text": "114年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/712.wav", + "text": "就不能開玩笑了而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/713.wav", + "text": "這個一增加以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/714.wav", + "text": "就是每一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/715.wav", + "text": "喔這跟經濟部跟農委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/716.wav", + "text": "了那不一樣我為什麼說我特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/717.wav", + "text": "有感我那邊有6個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/718.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/719.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員所提到的部分我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/720.wav", + "text": "特別有一點感觸啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/721.wav", + "text": "比如說他強調特別犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/722.wav", + "text": "我們一般在講特別犧牲的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/723.wav", + "text": "比如說土地好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/724.wav", + "text": "或者一般我們都會也好各地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/725.wav", + "text": "一直走走到形成一定的要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/726.wav", + "text": "以後很抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/727.wav", + "text": "你這個是特別犧牲怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/728.wav", + "text": "政府怎麼去做補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/729.wav", + "text": "很負責任擔負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/730.wav", + "text": "起這樣的責任現在是3萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/731.wav", + "text": "嘛不然很多既成巷道如果按照大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/732.wav", + "text": "沒錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/733.wav", + "text": "市長你也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/734.wav", + "text": "不是以前的高雄市每一條既成巷弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/735.wav", + "text": "你都有辦法去把它做一個徵收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/736.wav", + "text": "你說列為保護區的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/737.wav", + "text": "你的容積你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/738.wav", + "text": "建蔽一定都是比別人還要少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/739.wav", + "text": "對不對這大家都知道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/740.wav", + "text": "所以說為什麼特別犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/741.wav", + "text": "特別犧牲如果照你這樣講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/742.wav", + "text": "我這整個墾丁國家公園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/743.wav", + "text": "或者整個保護林的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/744.wav", + "text": "全部都是特別犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/745.wav", + "text": "啊所以大家都去發明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/746.wav", + "text": "有念過書的人開始去發明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/747.wav", + "text": "了就看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/748.wav", + "text": "你的高不高你這個地方是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/749.wav", + "text": "保護林這個地質比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/750.wav", + "text": "敏感你要負擔的社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/751.wav", + "text": "義務就比較高沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/752.wav", + "text": "超過容忍的限度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/753.wav", + "text": "有感就是說國家公園的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/754.wav", + "text": "那在我們這整個原民區的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/755.wav", + "text": "你說這些你去禁伐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/756.wav", + "text": "那該不該補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/757.wav", + "text": "我就認為這就屬於特別犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/758.wav", + "text": "已經超越社會的忍耐程度了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/759.wav", + "text": "所以政府來補償他是應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/760.wav", + "text": "\n所以本案要討論的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/761.wav", + "text": "曾主委他剛提到一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/762.wav", + "text": "他不好意思講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/763.wav", + "text": "我就幫你講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/764.wav", + "text": "他應該講的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/765.wav", + "text": "我行政跟立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/766.wav", + "text": "他不好意思來跟立法院對抗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/767.wav", + "text": "一年編的預算就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/768.wav", + "text": "然後我的施政計畫是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/769.wav", + "text": "你立法院你們誰把我做調整了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/770.wav", + "text": "那政治責任誰來擔負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/771.wav", + "text": "這個其實就是在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/772.wav", + "text": "大法官會議解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/773.wav", + "text": "所講的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/774.wav", + "text": "哪怕你只是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/775.wav", + "text": "項目之間去把它做移動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/776.wav", + "text": "他都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/777.wav", + "text": "這個就跟憲法上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/778.wav", + "text": "所指的增加的提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/779.wav", + "text": "施政成敗沒有辦法有人來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/780.wav", + "text": "所以本案是3萬本來就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/781.wav", + "text": "你現在是要調高到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/782.wav", + "text": "6萬還是多少才合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/783.wav", + "text": "那現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/784.wav", + "text": "曾主委來跟你講說我就真的沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/785.wav", + "text": "我就變41%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/786.wav", + "text": "這樣我要怎麼施政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/787.wav", + "text": "你像原民會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/788.wav", + "text": "那麼多原民鄉裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/789.wav", + "text": "其實原民會對整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/790.wav", + "text": "經濟弱勢原住民的建構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/791.wav", + "text": "跟修繕住宅的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/792.wav", + "text": "它也必須要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/793.wav", + "text": "我們也都在爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/794.wav", + "text": "排擠的問題啦所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/795.wav", + "text": "是不是會到6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/796.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/797.wav", + "text": "大家再想一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/798.wav", + "text": "好謝謝莊瑞雄委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/799.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱委員難得來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/800.wav", + "text": "請鍾佳濱委員拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/801.wav", + "text": "是感謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/802.wav", + "text": "google一下禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/803.wav", + "text": "大概可以看到2014年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/804.wav", + "text": "有一位屏東的原住民縣議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/805.wav", + "text": "陸月嬌可能在場幾位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/806.wav", + "text": "他在競選政見上就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/807.wav", + "text": "提到什麼他要擴大屏東縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/808.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/809.wav", + "text": "2014年的時候我們禁伐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/810.wav", + "text": "補償是2016年立法通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/811.wav", + "text": "當年7月要實施有4萬位原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/812.wav", + "text": "受惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/813.wav", + "text": "惠怎麼在2014年就提禁伐補償呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/814.wav", + "text": "曹啟鴻就任屏東縣縣長後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/815.wav", + "text": "有鑑於原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/816.wav", + "text": "原住民的經濟生活受到限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/817.wav", + "text": "他率先用縣款提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/818.wav", + "text": "那個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/819.wav", + "text": "是從1萬元開始做用縣款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/820.wav", + "text": "那個時候的原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/821.wav", + "text": "處處長是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/822.wav", + "text": "就是現在的主委曾智勇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/823.wav", + "text": "所以我們對後來中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/824.wav", + "text": "能夠立法來推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/825.wav", + "text": "我們也是非常欣慰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/826.wav", + "text": "\n但是我還是要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/827.wav", + "text": "我們認為在本次的修法當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/828.wav", + "text": "有一個地方要提醒各位來注意一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/829.wav", + "text": "就是我們在這個法條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/830.wav", + "text": "最後一項它裡面提到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/831.wav", + "text": "每兩年調整一次由中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/832.wav", + "text": "參照中央主計機關發布的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/833.wav", + "text": "最近一次消費者物價指數來調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/834.wav", + "text": "這個是屬於我們立法的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/835.wav", + "text": "因為立法權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/836.wav", + "text": "它是一個重複性普遍性的適用原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/837.wav", + "text": "所以它跟預算權的不同在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/838.wav", + "text": "當年訂定的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/839.wav", + "text": "訂定金額也是在2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/840.wav", + "text": "當時立法權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/841.wav", + "text": "跟行政都在由國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/842.wav", + "text": "執政的情況下所通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/843.wav", + "text": "但是我們必須提醒的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/844.wav", + "text": "現在我們去調整這個法律的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/845.wav", + "text": "從3萬到6萬不管調為幾萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/846.wav", + "text": "是屬於預算權的一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/847.wav", + "text": "依照大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/848.wav", + "text": "釋字419號解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/849.wav", + "text": "這麼辛苦得來不易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/850.wav", + "text": "得到朝野共識的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/851.wav", + "text": "到頭來被認為只是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/852.wav", + "text": "建議性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/853.wav", + "text": "而希望它具有約束力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/854.wav", + "text": "所以在這裡具體建議朝野思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/855.wav", + "text": "一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/856.wav", + "text": "就本條文的後項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/857.wav", + "text": "就是屬於兩年一次的物調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/858.wav", + "text": "這是屬於立法權的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/859.wav", + "text": "我們予以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/860.wav", + "text": "你從3萬調到4萬還是5萬還是6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/861.wav", + "text": "這事實上是行政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/862.wav", + "text": "在預算編列的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/863.wav", + "text": "要去衡量衡酌考量的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/864.wav", + "text": "立法院在審議預算之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/865.wav", + "text": "所作的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/866.wav", + "text": "譬如在民國94年調整公教人員年終獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/867.wav", + "text": "增發半個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/868.wav", + "text": "編入追加預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/869.wav", + "text": "大法官也跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/870.wav", + "text": "院長主持責成行政院原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/871.wav", + "text": "就禁伐補償在全國的範圍內實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/872.wav", + "text": "金額可以提到多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/873.wav", + "text": "由行政院提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/874.wav", + "text": "由立法院來寫入這樣的條文當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/875.wav", + "text": "因為我非常支持這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/876.wav", + "text": "尤其是後半段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/877.wav", + "text": "關於每兩年一次的物調規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/878.wav", + "text": "相關的主計總處都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/879.wav", + "text": "我們立法院所訂各��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/880.wav", + "text": "攸關民眾的受益權部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/881.wav", + "text": "都有訂定一個物調的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/882.wav", + "text": "這個我是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/883.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/884.wav", + "text": "每個人簡短扼要說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/885.wav", + "text": "的請高金委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/886.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/887.wav", + "text": "此時此刻的心情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/888.wav", + "text": "還有場景我要回顧到八年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/889.wav", + "text": "也是一樣的場景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/890.wav", + "text": "我心裡面非常心痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/891.wav", + "text": "所以今天我有幾點要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/892.wav", + "text": "第一點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/893.wav", + "text": "三讀通過的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/894.wav", + "text": "也沒有所謂的行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/895.wav", + "text": "都是原住民立法委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/896.wav", + "text": "所以這八年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/897.wav", + "text": "所發放的禁伐補償金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/898.wav", + "text": "難道是違法發放嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/899.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/900.wav", + "text": "\n第二個民進黨在這八年當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/901.wav", + "text": "不管是在他們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/902.wav", + "text": "業務報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/903.wav", + "text": "或者到原住民的地方都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/904.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/905.wav", + "text": "政府的德政讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/906.wav", + "text": "原住民的禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/907.wav", + "text": "在這八年當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/908.wav", + "text": "政府都有編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/909.wav", + "text": "今天非常多的族人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/910.wav", + "text": "在電視機前面看我們的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/911.wav", + "text": "\n接著我要來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/912.wav", + "text": "我是排案的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/913.wav", + "text": "我把程序再簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/914.wav", + "text": "4月7號我開始排禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/915.wav", + "text": "沒有行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/916.wav", + "text": "在場委員的版本都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/917.wav", + "text": "4月7號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/918.wav", + "text": "包括內政委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/919.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/920.wav", + "text": "在我們的委員會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/921.wav", + "text": "大家都同意支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/922.wav", + "text": "原住民族的土地正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/923.wav", + "text": "尤其原住民的禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/924.wav", + "text": "是憲法保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/925.wav", + "text": "原住民的私有地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/926.wav", + "text": "因為政府的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/927.wav", + "text": "而被限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/928.wav", + "text": "不能夠有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/929.wav", + "text": "其他的利用的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/930.wav", + "text": "政府應該要給補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/931.wav", + "text": "以前都沒有補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/932.wav", + "text": "一直到104年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/933.wav", + "text": "這個法案通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/934.wav", + "text": "才開始補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/935.wav", + "text": "\n今天為什麼會希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/936.wav", + "text": "提高它的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/937.wav", + "text": "第一點是因為物價指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/938.wav", + "text": "升高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/939.wav", + "text": "第二點我們是依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/940.wav", + "text": "林務局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/941.wav", + "text": "即將通過的獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/942.wav", + "text": "輔導造林辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/943.wav", + "text": "的修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/944.wav", + "text": "林務局的這個草案是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/945.wav", + "text": "第二年到第六年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/946.wav", + "text": "每年每公頃6萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/947.wav", + "text": "所以我們不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/948.wav", + "text": "無的放矢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/949.wav", + "text": "我們是按照這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/950.wav", + "text": "造林辦法的修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/951.wav", + "text": "他們即將要提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/952.wav", + "text": "1公頃6萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/953.wav", + "text": "我相信林務局的造林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/954.wav", + "text": "造林辦法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/955.wav", + "text": "5月2號朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/956.wav", + "text": "大家手上都有資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/957.wav", + "text": "所有的原住民委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/958.wav", + "text": "全部通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/959.wav", + "text": "照理說朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/960.wav", + "text": "民進黨的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/961.wav", + "text": "雖然陳瑩委員沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/962.wav", + "text": "只有伍麗華委員到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/963.wav", + "text": "但是後來陳瑩委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/964.wav", + "text": "在大院的時候也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/965.wav", + "text": "能夠補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/966.wav", + "text": "陳瑩委員簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/967.wav", + "text": "這是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/968.wav", + "text": "5月2號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/969.wav", + "text": "我也非常感謝國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/970.wav", + "text": "三長都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/971.wav", + "text": "支持原住民的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/972.wav", + "text": "土地轉型正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/973.wav", + "text": "\n然��在5月3號的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/974.wav", + "text": "這個朝野協商的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/975.wav", + "text": "去給柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/976.wav", + "text": "簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/977.wav", + "text": "柯總召當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/978.wav", + "text": "馬上就回我一句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/979.wav", + "text": "你的這個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/980.wav", + "text": "我很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/981.wav", + "text": "花政府太多錢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/982.wav", + "text": "我都不會簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/983.wav", + "text": "那時候柯總召跟我回了這麼一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/984.wav", + "text": "我心裡很冷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/985.wav", + "text": "我先講完嘛好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/986.wav", + "text": "然後我心裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/987.wav", + "text": "很難過我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/988.wav", + "text": "包括民進黨的立委都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/989.wav", + "text": "為什麼柯總召不簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/990.wav", + "text": "一直到今天6月4號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/991.wav", + "text": "這麼長的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/992.wav", + "text": "我也不斷地透過媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/993.wav", + "text": "透過我的臉書也讓柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/994.wav", + "text": "能夠理解原住民的土地法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/995.wav", + "text": "然後民進黨的兩位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/996.wav", + "text": "也都跟部落承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/997.wav", + "text": "個條例要表決的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/998.wav", + "text": "他們會站在民族的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/999.wav", + "text": "我非常的高興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1000.wav", + "text": "所以因此我們就請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1001.wav", + "text": "已經過了一個月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1002.wav", + "text": "依立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1003.wav", + "text": "只要過了一個月的冷凍期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1004.wav", + "text": "就可以在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1005.wav", + "text": "表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1006.wav", + "text": "這是我在立法院這22年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1007.wav", + "text": "的經驗也看到民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1008.wav", + "text": "也好國民黨團也好執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1009.wav", + "text": "大家都是這麼做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1010.wav", + "text": "國民黨團的孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1011.wav", + "text": "是不是已經過了一個月的冷凍期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1012.wav", + "text": "我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1013.wav", + "text": "如果一直在等柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1014.wav", + "text": "簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1015.wav", + "text": "我們不知道等到何年何月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1016.wav", + "text": "既然柯總召不簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1017.wav", + "text": "它已經過了一個月的冷凍期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1018.wav", + "text": "當然就可以表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1019.wav", + "text": "啊��以我們才會在上個禮拜五的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1020.wav", + "text": "請國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1021.wav", + "text": "把原住民的禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1022.wav", + "text": "能夠排在今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1023.wav", + "text": "第3案來表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1024.wav", + "text": "但是我非常遺憾的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1025.wav", + "text": "今天要表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1026.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團還會有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1027.wav", + "text": "而且還虧黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1028.wav", + "text": "他不懂得立法行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1029.wav", + "text": "事實上一個月就可以表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1030.wav", + "text": "有多少的案子是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1031.wav", + "text": "一定要有行政院版本才有預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1032.wav", + "text": "我在立法院這22年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1033.wav", + "text": "從來都沒有看過這麼荒謬的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1034.wav", + "text": "法案本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1035.wav", + "text": "立法委員就可以自提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1036.wav", + "text": "不管立法院自提法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1037.wav", + "text": "或者是行政院提的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1038.wav", + "text": "只要立法院三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1039.wav", + "text": "行政院就必須要依法行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1040.wav", + "text": "依法編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1041.wav", + "text": "然後我們來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1042.wav", + "text": "沒有行政院版本的黨產條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1043.wav", + "text": "是不是在立法院三讀通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1044.wav", + "text": "現在在執行了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1045.wav", + "text": "再看一下今天的第4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1046.wav", + "text": "地方民意補助費修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1047.wav", + "text": "也沒有行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1048.wav", + "text": "啊這也是要非常多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1049.wav", + "text": "預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1050.wav", + "text": "為什麼今天就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1051.wav", + "text": "呢再來促轉條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1052.wav", + "text": "有沒有行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1053.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1054.wav", + "text": "所以我真的非常期望今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1055.wav", + "text": "院長您在這邊主持公道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1056.wav", + "text": "能夠還給原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1057.wav", + "text": "土地正義的公道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1058.wav", + "text": "然後剛剛聽到幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1059.wav", + "text": "民進黨團委員說沒有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1060.wav", + "text": "好像我們編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1061.wav", + "text": "這個多了25億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1062.wav", + "text": "會阻擋掉原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1063.wav", + "text": "或者是原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1064.wav", + "text": "行政依法編列的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1065.wav", + "text": "我記得伍麗華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1066.wav", + "text": "陳建仁的時候還有主計總長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1067.wav", + "text": "行政院院長就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1068.wav", + "text": "他們一定會去找財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1069.wav", + "text": "總長也講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1070.wav", + "text": "只要是立法院通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1071.wav", + "text": "他一定會會去找預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1072.wav", + "text": "為什麼今天會說我們今天通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1073.wav", + "text": "這個條例增加了25億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1074.wav", + "text": "吃掉排擠掉原民會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1075.wav", + "text": "我在這邊要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1076.wav", + "text": "所謂的文健站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1077.wav", + "text": "站不是原民會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1078.wav", + "text": "它是長照基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1079.wav", + "text": "我們所有的教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1080.wav", + "text": "所有的道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1081.wav", + "text": "所以既然立法院通過了這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1082.wav", + "text": "就不應該排擠既有原民會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1083.wav", + "text": "行政院跟主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1084.wav", + "text": "必須要找財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1085.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1086.wav", + "text": "而且才多了25億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1087.wav", + "text": "它是會怎麼樣影響到中華民國的財源呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1088.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1089.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1090.wav", + "text": "麻煩請伍麗華委員請發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1091.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1092.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1093.wav", + "text": "各位行政夥伴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1094.wav", + "text": "我其實一路爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1095.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償金提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1096.wav", + "text": "都很順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1097.wav", + "text": "是到最近幾十天才不順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1098.wav", + "text": "但是我很高興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1099.wav", + "text": "我們終於有機會坐在這邊協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1100.wav", + "text": "我相信這才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1101.wav", + "text": "符合立法院民主的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1102.wav", + "text": "那我就溯源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1103.wav", + "text": "其實因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1104.wav", + "text": "這個案子我三年前就開始質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1105.wav", + "text": "我溯源的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1106.wav", + "text": "就是1996年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1107.wav", + "text": "賀伯颱風之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1108.wav", + "text": "土石流這個名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1109.wav", + "text": "所以開始做國土保安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1110.wav", + "text": "於是實施全民造林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1111.wav", + "text": "但是執行不當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1112.wav", + "text": "我們發現很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1113.wav", + "text": "砍大樹種小樹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1114.wav", + "text": "所以曾經一度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1115.wav", + "text": "全民造林停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1116.wav", + "text": "可是在這個當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1117.wav", + "text": "當時叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1118.wav", + "text": "還不是基金會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1119.wav", + "text": "還有一些立委像田秋堇等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1120.wav", + "text": "他們就開始倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1121.wav", + "text": "護林禁伐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1122.wav", + "text": "伐在此同時終於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1123.wav", + "text": "2001年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1124.wav", + "text": "第一個禁伐補償條例版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1125.wav", + "text": "是曾華德立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1126.wav", + "text": "時他是副縣長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1127.wav", + "text": "曹啟鴻縣長一上任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1128.wav", + "text": "就用縣款自己在屏東縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1129.wav", + "text": "做禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1130.wav", + "text": "一直到2015年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1131.wav", + "text": "簡東明委員所領銜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1132.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償條例版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1133.wav", + "text": "終於在立法院三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1134.wav", + "text": "當時蔡英文總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1135.wav", + "text": "已經當選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1136.wav", + "text": "\n所以我要說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1137.wav", + "text": "因應剛才高金委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1138.wav", + "text": "講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1139.wav", + "text": "我們面臨碳匯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1140.wav", + "text": "碳權的交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1141.wav", + "text": "我們面臨造林補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1142.wav", + "text": "獎勵金的提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1143.wav", + "text": "所以我們都覺得禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1144.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償金要調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1145.wav", + "text": "我曾經在2021年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1146.wav", + "text": "夷將主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1147.wav", + "text": "他說只要修法就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1148.wav", + "text": "後來我兩度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1149.wav", + "text": "質詢陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1150.wav", + "text": "他也都肯定地說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1151.wav", + "text": "修法就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1152.wav", + "text": "也請原民會研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1153.wav", + "text": "要提高到多少是最恰當的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1154.wav", + "text": "確實主計總長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1155.wav", + "text": "也說只要修法通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1156.wav", + "text": "就可以來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1157.wav", + "text": "一路過程中沒有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1158.wav", + "text": "去擋這個東西我覺得很順" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1159.wav", + "text": "我也不太曉得說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1160.wav", + "text": "為什麼現在變得不順" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1161.wav", + "text": "但是我知道的是我們本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1162.wav", + "text": "就應該要坐下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1163.wav", + "text": "討論協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1164.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1165.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這一路當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1166.wav", + "text": "可能就是沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1167.wav", + "text": "行政機關單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1168.wav", + "text": "出來講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1169.wav", + "text": "今天很好大家都坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1170.wav", + "text": "我們終於坐下來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1171.wav", + "text": "我絕對雙手贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1172.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償金提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1173.wav", + "text": "順啊越來越順" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1174.wav", + "text": "麻煩請鄭天財委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1175.wav", + "text": "立法權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1176.wav", + "text": "沒有限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1177.wav", + "text": "包括預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1178.wav", + "text": "立了這個法絕對會包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1179.wav", + "text": "經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1180.wav", + "text": "我就講最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1181.wav", + "text": "101年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1182.wav", + "text": "國民黨執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1183.wav", + "text": "馬英九執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1184.wav", + "text": "花東地區發展條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1185.wav", + "text": "沒有行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1186.wav", + "text": "立法院三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1187.wav", + "text": "400億的花東基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1188.wav", + "text": "第二個103年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1189.wav", + "text": "原住民族教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1190.wav", + "text": "原住民族的教育經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1191.wav", + "text": "本來是1.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1192.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1193.wav", + "text": "103年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1194.wav", + "text": "修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1195.wav", + "text": "只有原住民立委的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1196.wav", + "text": "103年我們修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1197.wav", + "text": "提高為1.9%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1198.wav", + "text": "從1.2%提高為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1199.wav", + "text": "1.9%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1200.wav", + "text": "沒有人說不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1201.wav", + "text": "這是立法權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1202.wav", + "text": "\n另外就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1203.wav", + "text": "現在我們談的原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1204.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1205.wav", + "text": "104年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1206.wav", + "text": "馬英九執政的最後一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1207.wav", + "text": "最後四個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1208.wav", + "text": "我們104年12月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1209.wav", + "text": "在這裡三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1210.wav", + "text": "沒有行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1211.wav", + "text": "沒有行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1212.wav", + "text": "啊沒有人說不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1213.wav", + "text": "啊好我們就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1214.wav", + "text": "最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1215.wav", + "text": "111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1216.wav", + "text": "我當內政委員會的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1217.wav", + "text": "我主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1218.wav", + "text": "地方民代及村里長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1219.wav", + "text": "的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1220.wav", + "text": "村里長的事務費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1221.wav", + "text": "調高為5萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1222.wav", + "text": "沒有行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1223.wav", + "text": "喔當時內政部的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1224.wav", + "text": "在做報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1225.wav", + "text": "反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1226.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1227.wav", + "text": "朝野認為是需要調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1228.wav", + "text": "三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1229.wav", + "text": "所以為什麼今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1230.wav", + "text": "各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1231.wav", + "text": "只剩下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1232.wav", + "text": "民進黨團不簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1233.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1234.wav", + "text": "本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1235.wav", + "text": "召委協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1236.wav", + "text": "就可以表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1237.wav", + "text": "也歡迎補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1238.wav", + "text": "啊今天補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1239.wav", + "text": "了既然協商完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1240.wav", + "text": "今天協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1241.wav", + "text": "我們共同拜託柯總召簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1242.wav", + "text": "等一下就不用表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1243.wav", + "text": "拜託柯總召簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1244.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1245.wav", + "text": "按照立法院職權行使法是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1246.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1247.wav", + "text": "接下來三位委員要不要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1248.wav", + "text": "陳瑩委員盧縣一委員跟黃仁委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1249.wav", + "text": "院長好其實本席是推了6萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1250.wav", + "text": "從一開始是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1251.wav", + "text": "為什麼會推6萬元的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1252.wav", + "text": "法源依據是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1253.wav", + "text": "我看了110年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1254.wav", + "text": "原民會的新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1255.wav", + "text": "當時是夷將的新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1256.wav", + "text": "上面寫說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1257.wav", + "text": "跟生態保育的經濟價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1258.wav", + "text": "第2項是我查了資料文獻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1259.wav", + "text": "2001年英國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1260.wav", + "text": "生態經濟學博士皮爾斯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1261.wav", + "text": "一個原始林的碳匯價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1262.wav", + "text": "這是2001年的價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1263.wav", + "text": "喔現在是2024年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1264.wav", + "text": "現在已經過了20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1265.wav", + "text": "不是更超過了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1266.wav", + "text": "所以本席強烈要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1267.wav", + "text": "必須要先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1268.wav", + "text": "也沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1269.wav", + "text": "無異議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1270.wav", + "text": "所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1271.wav", + "text": "這個禁伐補償的案子才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1272.wav", + "text": "列進來我們今天才有機會坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1273.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的時候韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1274.wav", + "text": "也都一直點頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1275.wav", + "text": "敬表同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1276.wav", + "text": "\n所以我要在這邊特別說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1277.wav", + "text": "我反對高金委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1278.wav", + "text": "在臉書上特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1279.wav", + "text": "點名我和伍麗華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1280.wav", + "text": "說我們兩個反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1281.wav", + "text": "這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1282.wav", + "text": "也反對把這個議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1283.wav", + "text": "列入今天的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1284.wav", + "text": "我想這樣子的操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1285.wav", + "text": "這樣也無助於我們大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1286.wav", + "text": "來推動這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1287.wav", + "text": "爭取權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1288.wav", + "text": "所有的原住民委員其實應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1289.wav", + "text": "我們來替原住民爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1290.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1291.wav", + "text": "是沒有錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1292.wav", + "text": "當然我們的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1293.wav", + "text": "也是非常堅定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1294.wav", + "text": "要和原住民族站在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1295.wav", + "text": "任何一個黨執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1296.wav", + "text": "也是沒有錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1297.wav", + "text": "簡東明委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1298.wav", + "text": "當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1299.wav", + "text": "也沒有行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1300.wav", + "text": "但是我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1301.wav", + "text": "有充分的溝通協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1302.wav", + "text": "當時或許那樣的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1303.wav", + "text": "行政院沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1304.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1305.wav", + "text": "就一起無異議通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1306.wav", + "text": "講了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1307.wav", + "text": "都有提示過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1308.wav", + "text": "我比較想要瞭解的是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1309.wav", + "text": "這樣子盤點之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1310.wav", + "text": "到底行政院這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1311.wav", + "text": "有多少的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1312.wav", + "text": "我想要瞭解這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1313.wav", + "text": "因為我們剛剛討論了這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1314.wav", + "text": "都沒有在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1315.wav", + "text": "提出一個比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1316.wav", + "text": "當然也是有精算過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1317.wav", + "text": "但是我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1318.wav", + "text": "聽聽行政院的意見到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1319.wav", + "text": "你們面臨什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1320.wav", + "text": "盤點之後你們的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1321.wav", + "text": "到底在哪裡請說出來讓我們瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1322.wav", + "text": "陳委員6萬塊錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1323.wav", + "text": "這個你先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1324.wav", + "text": "6萬塊錢這個你保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1325.wav", + "text": "不是因為我想聽他們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1326.wav", + "text": "我都沒有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1327.wav", + "text": "陳瑩委員沒關係你的意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1328.wav", + "text": "你很支持原住民但也重視行政部門的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1329.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1330.wav", + "text": "我想聽看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1331.wav", + "text": "現在請黃仁委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1332.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1333.wav", + "text": "大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1334.wav", + "text": "今天既然伍麗華跟陳瑩委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1335.wav", + "text": "都已經認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1336.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償6萬塊這樣的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1337.wav", + "text": "而且也非常支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1338.wav", + "text": "當然我們也感謝高金素梅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1339.wav", + "text": "過去一直提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1340.wav", + "text": "這樣的歷程到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1341.wav", + "text": "已經進入到三讀通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1342.wav", + "text": "但是朝野希望民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1343.wav", + "text": "不要再擋這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1344.wav", + "text": "讓族人明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1345.wav", + "text": "（114）年1月1號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1346.wav", + "text": "趕快實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1347.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1348.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃仁委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1349.wav", + "text": "了所有委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1350.wav", + "text": "發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1351.wav", + "text": "當然我非常理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1352.wav", + "text": "你們基於選區的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1353.wav", + "text": "應該爭取預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1354.wav", + "text": "這是理所當然我也非常尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1355.wav", + "text": "但是要把事實釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1356.wav", + "text": "我不希望做政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1357.wav", + "text": "高金委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1358.wav", + "text": "你們朝野協商以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1359.wav", + "text": "你跑到院會來找我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1360.wav", + "text": "就叫我簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1361.wav", + "text": "我說這個要院長主持朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1362.wav", + "text": "我並沒說要花很多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1363.wav", + "text": "我我有沒有跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1364.wav", + "text": "要院長主持朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1365.wav", + "text": "所以你這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1366.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1367.wav", + "text": "我不會否認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1368.wav", + "text": "但是我一直跟你講說這個一定要院長主持朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1369.wav", + "text": "嘛所以你馬上做政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1370.wav", + "text": "在臉書批評我我都忍受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1371.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1372.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1373.wav", + "text": "你等一下再回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1374.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1375.wav", + "text": "都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1376.wav", + "text": "我希望大家不要做政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1377.wav", + "text": "因為你在臉書批評我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1378.wav", + "text": "我說沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1379.wav", + "text": "我不計較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1380.wav", + "text": "高金素梅第一句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1381.wav", + "text": "八年前的場景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1382.wav", + "text": "我都在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1383.wav", + "text": "剛才伍麗華委員把這個立法過程也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1384.wav", + "text": "剛才鍾佳濱委員也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1385.wav", + "text": "2006年朝野協商的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1386.wav", + "text": "也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1387.wav", + "text": "那我把這個講清楚好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1388.wav", + "text": "事實上這個題目在臺灣不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1389.wav", + "text": "只有2006年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1390.wav", + "text": "曹啟鴻縣長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1391.wav", + "text": "省府時期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1392.wav", + "text": "省主席的時候就有想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1393.wav", + "text": "去做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1394.wav", + "text": "補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1395.wav", + "text": "都有一些辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1396.wav", + "text": "這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1397.wav", + "text": "是不是要來思考一些對原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1398.wav", + "text": "一個補償乃至於照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1399.wav", + "text": "就是從這裡開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1400.wav", + "text": "高金委員你不要忘記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1401.wav", + "text": "當你進來立法院的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1402.wav", + "text": "你們成立了原住民問政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1403.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1404.wav", + "text": "我和王拓（他已經過往了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1405.wav", + "text": "）我是總召他是幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1406.wav", + "text": "我們兩個還去參加原住民問政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1407.wav", + "text": "這個事情你沒有忘記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1408.wav", + "text": "有一個照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1409.wav", + "text": "當原住民老人津貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1410.wav", + "text": "還有很多原住民委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1411.wav", + "text": "把我抬起來在議場裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1412.wav", + "text": "通過的時候把我抬起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1413.wav", + "text": "這是我們一起去爭取的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1414.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1415.wav", + "text": "這段歷史你不要忘記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1416.wav", + "text": "八年前是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1417.wav", + "text": "是馬英九執政通過是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1418.wav", + "text": "這最早是沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1419.wav", + "text": "2002年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1420.wav", + "text": "曾華德開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1421.wav", + "text": "弄到2015年12月18號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1422.wav", + "text": "是簡東明委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1423.wav", + "text": "那不是民進黨執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1424.wav", + "text": "是馬英九執政時期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1425.wav", + "text": "不是只有一個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1426.wav", + "text": "通過一個叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1427.wav", + "text": "原住民禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1428.wav", + "text": "當然我們認為這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1429.wav", + "text": "違反權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1430.wav", + "text": "但是假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1431.wav", + "text": "假如行政部門能夠做得下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1432.wav", + "text": "它當然會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1433.wav", + "text": "它認為沒有辦法執行的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1434.wav", + "text": "只是當作參考它要多少是它的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1435.wav", + "text": "權力分立原則一定要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1436.wav", + "text": "這個權力分立原則是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1437.wav", + "text": "預算編列權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1438.wav", + "text": "是在行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1439.wav", + "text": "我們沒有辦法去編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1440.wav", + "text": "做預算增加的支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1441.wav", + "text": "所以2015年12月18號通過的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1442.wav", + "text": "那時候也沒有財政紀律法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1443.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1444.wav", + "text": "現在有沒有有財政紀律法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1445.wav", + "text": "包括這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1446.wav", + "text": "它什麼時候公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1447.wav", + "text": "是2016年7月1號公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1448.wav", + "text": "2016年到我們執政了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1449.wav", + "text": "我準備要講另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1450.wav", + "text": "林全院長開始編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1451.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1452.wav", + "text": "當時是行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1453.wav", + "text": "他更照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1454.wav", + "text": "他把這些水源水質水量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1455.wav", + "text": "\n然後我講另外一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1456.wav", + "text": "也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1457.wav", + "text": "那時候馬英九坦白講他太過聰明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1458.wav", + "text": "他知道他已經不可能再執政了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1459.wav", + "text": "所以他下了很多毒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1460.wav", + "text": "就必須接這一招" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1461.wav", + "text": "還有一個是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1462.wav", + "text": "國土計畫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1463.wav", + "text": "國土計畫法是2015年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1464.wav", + "text": "因為國土計畫法是很有進步性理想性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1465.wav", + "text": "是沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1466.wav", + "text": "但執行起來非常困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1467.wav", + "text": "所以那時候我也在在野黨的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1468.wav", + "text": "我都提出很多挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1469.wav", + "text": "包括國民黨立委都提出很多挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1470.wav", + "text": "那時候有兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1471.wav", + "text": "一個叫做邱文彥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1472.wav", + "text": "一個叫田秋堇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1473.wav", + "text": "他很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1474.wav", + "text": "後來終於通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1475.wav", + "text": "那時候馬英九的政策是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1476.wav", + "text": "2015年通過的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1477.wav", + "text": "他設定2016年5月1號開始實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1478.wav", + "text": "換我們接到了520" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1479.wav", + "text": "蔡英文總統執政了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1480.wav", + "text": "我們接到這兩個球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1481.wav", + "text": "這兩個球要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1482.wav", + "text": "呢當然就是國土計畫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1483.wav", + "text": "他發現說糟糕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1484.wav", + "text": "這國土計畫法一通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1485.wav", + "text": "區域計畫法也要廢掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1486.wav", + "text": "那各縣市全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1487.wav", + "text": "的國土計畫都不送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1488.wav", + "text": "把優良農田改為工業區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1489.wav", + "text": "當然不行啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1490.wav", + "text": "所以再去延了三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1491.wav", + "text": "現在我們又面對到國土計畫法的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1492.wav", + "text": "國土計畫法現在各縣市又不送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1493.wav", + "text": "所以當年馬英九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1494.wav", + "text": "在最後的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1495.wav", + "text": "通過這兩個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1496.wav", + "text": "他知道要讓民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1497.wav", + "text": "去背這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1498.wav", + "text": "\n我們今天回頭過來談這個事情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1499.wav", + "text": "所以有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1500.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員所謂的特別犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1501.wav", + "text": "特別犧牲發生在什麼地方呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1502.wav", + "text": "就是經濟部嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1503.wav", + "text": "你要去造林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1504.wav", + "text": "我才會給你補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1505.wav", + "text": "我知道我把這個東西談完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1506.wav", + "text": "我們等一下要講一個終極答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1507.wav", + "text": "我把這個該講的話先講完再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1508.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1509.wav", + "text": "幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1510.wav", + "text": "包括伍麗華講得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1511.wav", + "text": "當然要有某種程序的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1512.wav", + "text": "包括陳瑩委員也講一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1513.wav", + "text": "但是他還是要尊重行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1514.wav", + "text": "所以大家都在一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1515.wav", + "text": "憲法法規範裡面做這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1516.wav", + "text": "譬如行政立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1517.wav", + "text": "職權的分立上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1518.wav", + "text": "包括黃仁委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1519.wav", + "text": "什麼6萬塊也是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1520.wav", + "text": "我們今天不要講政治語言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1521.wav", + "text": "我們講說面對這個問題我都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1522.wav", + "text": "但是不要做政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1523.wav", + "text": "以及抹黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1524.wav", + "text": "\n今天我要談到最後就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1525.wav", + "text": "我們面對這個題目的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1526.wav", + "text": "大家要如何面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1527.wav", + "text": "剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1528.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱委員談得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1529.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1530.wav", + "text": "他們都是學法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1531.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱以前是國大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1532.wav", + "text": "在行政院所能做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1533.wav", + "text": "會影響到施政的完整性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1534.wav", + "text": "以及責任的歸屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1535.wav", + "text": "都屬於建議性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1536.wav", + "text": "但是行政權在他身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1537.wav", + "text": "他如何編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1538.wav", + "text": "當然是他的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1539.wav", + "text": "所以並無法強制為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1540.wav", + "text": "啦我只能講這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1541.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯建銘總召我建議曾主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1542.wav", + "text": "等一下我會敲一個休息時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1543.wav", + "text": "你在休息時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1544.wav", + "text": "跟我們的召委黨團的幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1545.wav", + "text": "高金委員你簡短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1546.wav", + "text": "扼要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1547.wav", + "text": "好我知道謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1548.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1549.wav", + "text": "柯總召也好陳瑩委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1550.wav", + "text": "也好都說我在政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1551.wav", + "text": "我還是要再強調一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1552.wav", + "text": "不是照顧原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1553.wav", + "text": "我們只想要公平對待這是我的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1554.wav", + "text": "也是我的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1555.wav", + "text": "第二沒有所謂的政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1556.wav", + "text": "因為在上禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1557.wav", + "text": "民進黨沒有把禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1558.wav", + "text": "列入他們今天要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1559.wav", + "text": "的議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1560.wav", + "text": "是事實我只是把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1561.wav", + "text": "事實貼在臉書也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1562.wav", + "text": "陳瑩委員跟伍麗華委員趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1563.wav", + "text": "去說服柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1564.wav", + "text": "八年前柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1565.wav", + "text": "我謝謝你你告訴我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1566.wav", + "text": "只要田秋堇委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1567.wav", + "text": "簽字你就不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1568.wav", + "text": "有意見因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1569.wav", + "text": "我跟簡東明委員兩個人就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1570.wav", + "text": "每天纏著田秋堇委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1571.wav", + "text": "最後田秋堇委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1572.wav", + "text": "簽字了因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1573.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償在八年前的立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1574.wav", + "text": "就三讀通過照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1575.wav", + "text": "還在我的臉書上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1576.wav", + "text": "然後當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1577.wav", + "text": "一通過之後民進黨黨團馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1578.wav", + "text": "就發了一個新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1579.wav", + "text": "也就是由我們的夷將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1580.wav", + "text": "當時是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1581.wav", + "text": "原住民事務部的主任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1582.wav", + "text": "他在新聞上就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1583.wav", + "text": "這是一個錢坑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1584.wav", + "text": "法案這是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1585.wav", + "text": "我也沒有政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1586.wav", + "text": "大家都可以去翻新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1587.wav", + "text": "而八年後的今天柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1588.wav", + "text": "告訴我因為這個會花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1589.wav", + "text": "政府太多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1590.wav", + "text": "但事實上你沒有簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1591.wav", + "text": "那天鄭天財也在我旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1592.wav", + "text": "\n最後我要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1593.wav", + "text": "院長今天如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1594.wav", + "text": "柯總召沒有辦法簽字的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1595.wav", + "text": "我剛剛就說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1596.wav", + "text": "依我們立法院的職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1597.wav", + "text": "超過一個月的冷凍期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1598.wav", + "text": "就可以表決今天民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1599.wav", + "text": "也好國民黨黨團也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1600.wav", + "text": "我們在這邊都在期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1601.wav", + "text": "等待院長最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1602.wav", + "text": "說服柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1603.wav", + "text": "我們就進去表決吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1604.wav", + "text": "這個很關鍵性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1605.wav", + "text": "因為曾主委是行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1606.wav", + "text": "我現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1607.wav", + "text": "對簡單的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1608.wav", + "text": "我等一下就會簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1609.wav", + "text": "因為有朝野協商就要簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1610.wav", + "text": "嘛簽的時候我們有不同立場再來表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1611.wav", + "text": "這一定會啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1612.wav", + "text": "不然我今天來這裡幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1613.wav", + "text": "朝野協商有簽字才能表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1614.wav", + "text": "我是堅持這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1615.wav", + "text": "做那種低級的操作根本沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1616.wav", + "text": "已經都在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1617.wav", + "text": "就算沒有結論也要簽字要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1618.wav", + "text": "嘛這等一下要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1619.wav", + "text": "哪還有什麼你在爭取的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1620.wav", + "text": "是再生二法以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1621.wav", + "text": "村里長補助這是我們的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1622.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1623.wav", + "text": "等一下我們提出來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1624.wav", + "text": "當然是我們主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1625.wav", + "text": "下一個案子是你們的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1626.wav", + "text": "有禁伐補償以及什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1627.wav", + "text": "以及郭國文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1628.wav", + "text": "懲戒案好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1629.wav", + "text": "國民黨提的我馬上同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1630.wav", + "text": "有沒有反對沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1631.wav", + "text": "吧我現在講的就是沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1632.wav", + "text": "走程序但是要朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1633.wav", + "text": "就是如此你現在來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1634.wav", + "text": "拗這個東西拗得很難看根本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1635.wav", + "text": "毫無道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1636.wav", + "text": "嘛等一下當然要簽字不然要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1637.wav", + "text": "簽字以後輸贏是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1638.wav", + "text": "進黨1979年成立以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1639.wav", + "text": "到2016年我們30年間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1640.wav", + "text": "表決了幾萬次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1641.wav", + "text": "經過朝野協商表決了幾萬次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1642.wav", + "text": "我們都輸但是我們還是服膺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1643.wav", + "text": "就是這樣啊今天我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1644.wav", + "text": "人數少每一個表決都輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1645.wav", + "text": "但是有經過像這樣的民主程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1646.wav", + "text": "這是我們最在意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1647.wav", + "text": "就是如此嘛你到底懂不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1648.wav", + "text": "院長我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1649.wav", + "text": "院長對不起我建議您是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1650.wav", + "text": "大家為了5月31號我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1651.wav", + "text": "跟伍麗華被操作所以我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1652.wav", + "text": "5月31號就無異議通過啊我們都無異議通過啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1653.wav", + "text": "只是要朝野協商而已啊操作這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1654.wav", + "text": "非常低級而且愚笨啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1655.wav", + "text": "現在到底還有沒有主席都請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1656.wav", + "text": "贊成啊無異議啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1657.wav", + "text": "你你到底在講什麼話嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1658.wav", + "text": "朝野都是一致的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1659.wav", + "text": "現在有點凌亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1660.wav", + "text": "現在我正在主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1661.wav", + "text": "我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1662.wav", + "text": "我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1663.wav", + "text": "曾主委掌握最後的黃金時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1664.wav", + "text": "我會喊休息10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1665.wav", + "text": "你跟幾個不同黨團的委員協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1666.wav", + "text": "我感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1667.wav", + "text": "你在執行的時候你剛剛的表情告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1668.wav", + "text": "部分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1669.wav", + "text": "都要再講這個再講會講不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1670.wav", + "text": "我要請曾主委掌握黃金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1671.wav", + "text": "我不是不讓你發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1672.wav", + "text": "我讓曾主委掌握時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1673.wav", + "text": "我也必須要把剛剛朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1674.wav", + "text": "很多意見胡說八道的部分來講清楚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1675.wav", + "text": "我在指涉你們胡說八道呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1676.wav", + "text": "你溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1677.wav", + "text": "各位委員各位黨團幹部請坐我們準備繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1678.wav", + "text": "憲法不可表決的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1679.wav", + "text": "暫時達成立法院黨團協商的給莊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1680.wav", + "text": "我一定控制時間啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1681.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1682.wav", + "text": "剛剛鄭天財委員講話我又有所感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1683.wav", + "text": "你說過去怎麼樣怎麼樣怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1684.wav", + "text": "0年前如何8年前如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1685.wav", + "text": "我說實在話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1686.wav", + "text": "立法院通過任何的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1687.wav", + "text": "如果到最後行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1688.wav", + "text": "把預算給編列進去了這個叫追認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1689.wav", + "text": "也沒有人提出釋憲它又編了預算這沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1690.wav", + "text": "但是我必須要提出來在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1691.wav", + "text": "在2019年4月10日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1692.wav", + "text": "中央政府各級機關或立法委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1693.wav", + "text": "法律案大幅增加政府歲出或減少歲入者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1694.wav", + "text": "甚至於各地方政府或立法機關所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1695.wav", + "text": "自治法規增加的政府歲出或減少歲入者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1696.wav", + "text": "同樣都是準用啦\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1697.wav", + "text": "剛剛大家一直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1698.wav", + "text": "在提的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1699.wav", + "text": "本來3萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1700.wav", + "text": "今天的案子是6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1701.wav", + "text": "高金委員特別提到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1702.wav", + "text": "這個不是對原住民族的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1703.wav", + "text": "這個是一個特別犧牲我接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1704.wav", + "text": "那是容忍的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1705.wav", + "text": "社會容忍度到什麼地方的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1706.wav", + "text": "3萬塊的時候大家一直慶祝說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1707.wav", + "text": "我們為原住民族爭取了多少權利了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1708.wav", + "text": "好那我請問今天變成6萬塊了呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1709.wav", + "text": "如果明年變成10萬塊了呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1710.wav", + "text": "後年變成20萬塊了呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1711.wav", + "text": "所以我剛剛特別開宗明義講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1712.wav", + "text": "這個社會容忍的義務到什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1713.wav", + "text": "我特別也指名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1714.wav", + "text": "名整個國家公園保護區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1715.wav", + "text": "或者保護林的地方容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1716.wav", + "text": "容積跟建蔽全部都是限制啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1717.wav", + "text": "這到底是不是特別犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1718.wav", + "text": "政府說不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1719.wav", + "text": "現在我們的社會共識也說還不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1720.wav", + "text": "因為你那個地方土質比較敏感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1721.wav", + "text": "你還要去做承擔去承受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1722.wav", + "text": "那我要特別再去指名的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1723.wav", + "text": "今天剛好是涉及到原住民委員會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1724.wav", + "text": "你現在把它提撥到41%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1725.wav", + "text": "光這一個部分而且是逐年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1726.wav", + "text": "我們各位偉大的政治家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1727.wav", + "text": "你認為這樣子真的是合理的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1728.wav", + "text": "真的是合理的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1729.wav", + "text": "今天大家談的都是在談情啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1730.wav", + "text": "\n都在談理啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1731.wav", + "text": "說要達到一個公平的對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1732.wav", + "text": "笨到說我來阻擋你變成社會的一個箭靶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1733.wav", + "text": "法律也講在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1734.wav", + "text": "我贊同柯總召所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1735.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有牴觸憲法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1736.wav", + "text": "憲法的規定在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1737.wav", + "text": "立法跟行政的分際倒不是用表決啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1738.wav", + "text": "\n但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1739.wav", + "text": "如果說原民會對這個金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1740.wav", + "text": "額有所折衝它都同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1741.wav", + "text": "我認為那是事後的追認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1742.wav", + "text": "這倒也沒有破壞到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1743.wav", + "text": "就是行政權跟立法權之間的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1744.wav", + "text": "啊\n所以我是認為這個就是要想好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1745.wav", + "text": "主委你在原住民裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1746.wav", + "text": "但是你是沒有錢的國王" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1747.wav", + "text": "你知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1748.wav", + "text": "沒有錢的國王" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1749.wav", + "text": "你有困境你也必須要去講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1750.wav", + "text": "我也知道你會站在原住民朋友的立場講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1751.wav", + "text": "合理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1752.wav", + "text": "本來就是對原住民族這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1753.wav", + "text": "有特別的補助你都會去答應啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1754.wav", + "text": "我們也不想當壞人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1755.wav", + "text": "我屏東那個地方也有6個原民鄉鎮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1756.wav", + "text": "我現在跟你講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1757.wav", + "text": "會不會有排擠的問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1758.wav", + "text": "立法院制定把它弄成6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1759.wav", + "text": "明年弄個10萬20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1760.wav", + "text": "大家說不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1761.wav", + "text": "排擠我們大家講爽了就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1762.wav", + "text": "反正有選票就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1763.wav", + "text": "全部都是政治操作啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1764.wav", + "text": "我也不想當壞人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1765.wav", + "text": "但是我必須要指明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1766.wav", + "text": "明2019年的財政紀律法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1767.wav", + "text": "是要對全國國民負責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1768.wav", + "text": "大家現在認為大法官都沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1769.wav", + "text": "但是釋字第391號就跟你講得很清楚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1770.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1771.wav", + "text": "你請掌握最後重要的黃金時間好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1772.wav", + "text": "你請發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1773.wav", + "text": "我們大家都想聽聽您的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1774.wav", + "text": "你發言之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1775.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1776.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1777.wav", + "text": "因為還有一個更重要的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1778.wav", + "text": "物我們副主計長都沒講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1779.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1780.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1781.wav", + "text": "我想這樣的一個預算進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1782.wav", + "text": "真的會排擠到原民會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1783.wav", + "text": "很多的預算就不能做了是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1784.wav", + "text": "不管這6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1785.wav", + "text": "原民會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1786.wav", + "text": "很多對族人的照顧就沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1787.wav", + "text": "可是莊瑞雄委員講了一個話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1788.wav", + "text": "有玄機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1789.wav", + "text": "我來解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1790.wav", + "text": "不會這麼困難的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1791.wav", + "text": "還有沒有一點彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1792.wav", + "text": "而這個彈性點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1793.wav", + "text": "將來我們立法院他已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1794.wav", + "text": "仙人指路你有沒有瞭解他的苦心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1795.wav", + "text": "跟主席報告我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1796.wav", + "text": "我們也還要再細算一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1797.wav", + "text": "麻煩請副主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1798.wav", + "text": "跟主席各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1799.wav", + "text": "基本上有一些是法律義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1800.wav", + "text": "有一些已經是專項像國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1801.wav", + "text": "防公共建設跟科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1802.wav", + "text": "所以它基本上是已經有一個框架在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1803.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有跟主席和各位委員報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1804.wav", + "text": "就是目前我們匡列給它的額度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1805.wav", + "text": "125億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1806.wav", + "text": "相對對它就會有所衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1807.wav", + "text": "以我們現在114年推估的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1808.wav", + "text": "空間是非常的小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1809.wav", + "text": "主要就是調整的幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1810.wav", + "text": "會有這樣的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1811.wav", + "text": "一些標準的提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1812.wav", + "text": "我們比較擔心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1813.wav", + "text": "會有援引比照的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1814.wav", + "text": "農業部的部分是每公頃3萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1815.wav", + "text": "都是有造林的前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1816.wav", + "text": "那是2萬到4萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1817.wav", + "text": "所以相對現在3萬調成6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1818.wav", + "text": "幅度是有比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1819.wav", + "text": "另外所謂的限制使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1820.wav", + "text": "而所做的特別犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1821.wav", + "text": "其他也蠻多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1822.wav", + "text": "所以會有一些連動的效應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1823.wav", + "text": "我們希望調整的幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1824.wav", + "text": "考慮整個政府財政的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1825.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1826.wav", + "text": "現在就在聽你的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1827.wav", + "text": "有多少的幅度你們都不講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1828.wav", + "text": "你不講今天就是6萬塊下去表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1829.wav", + "text": "決現在在給你機會講這個空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1830.wav", + "text": "他沒有辦法決定你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1831.wav", + "text": "你聽我講一下嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1832.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1833.wav", + "text": "我來講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1834.wav", + "text": "我跟你報告就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1835.wav", + "text": "你那個空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1836.wav", + "text": "我不曉得你有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1837.wav", + "text": "我知道接下來是傅總召講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1838.wav", + "text": "麻煩請傅崐萁總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1839.wav", + "text": "因為今天這個協商也是應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1840.wav", + "text": "柯總召要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1841.wav", + "text": "嘛事實上今天這是第二次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1842.wav", + "text": "了第一次的協商會我們就講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1843.wav", + "text": "因為遊戲規則要清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1844.wav", + "text": "我們協商是協商多少時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1845.wav", + "text": "在擔任立法院的會議主持時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1846.wav", + "text": "不管是委員會的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1847.wav", + "text": "或者院會的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1848.wav", + "text": "其中有一次在冷凍期一個月後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1849.wav", + "text": "就可以正式進行表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1850.wav", + "text": "這都已經是記錄在公報的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1851.wav", + "text": "如果今天要變更為其他的遊戲方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1852.wav", + "text": "一定要院長召集的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1853.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1854.wav", + "text": "第二個同意的前提必須是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1855.wav", + "text": "遊戲規則要很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1856.wav", + "text": "不然的話我們永遠的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1857.wav", + "text": "明明就是立場完全不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1858.wav", + "text": "當然異中求同是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1859.wav", + "text": "但如果完全只是各自表述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1860.wav", + "text": "永遠沒有辦法交集的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1861.wav", + "text": "那是損耗全民的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1862.wav", + "text": "而且有這麼多幾百個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1863.wav", + "text": "立法院可能有很多的時間都在空轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1864.wav", + "text": "\n對於禁伐補償的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1865.wav", + "text": "我們要再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1866.wav", + "text": "調整時也是一樣也是立法院發動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1867.wav", + "text": "執行到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1868.wav", + "text": "有沒有違憲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1869.wav", + "text": "有違憲的話那時候就應該講嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1870.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1871.wav", + "text": "你們說憲法第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1872.wav", + "text": "這又不是預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1873.wav", + "text": "大法官釋憲第391號講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1874.wav", + "text": "我們可以刪減行政院的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1875.wav", + "text": "這就是要求他們來做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1876.wav", + "text": "\n更重要的一件事情我們還是要強調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1877.wav", + "text": "有沒有財政紀律是全民來公斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1878.wav", + "text": "立法委員都可以表述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1879.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有財政紀律的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1880.wav", + "text": "民間一度電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1881.wav", + "text": "民眾繳兩塊八" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1882.wav", + "text": "他們搞了一個風電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1883.wav", + "text": "一度電五塊八" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1884.wav", + "text": "你們去買五塊八的電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1885.wav", + "text": "來收兩塊八的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1886.wav", + "text": "台電怎麼可能會不倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1887.wav", + "text": "核四二千九百多億蓋好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1888.wav", + "text": "隨時可以啟用卻不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1889.wav", + "text": "然後搞了一個風電兩兆多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1890.wav", + "text": "我們的代代子孫要怎麼面對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1891.wav", + "text": "更重要的一個事情我要在這裡特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1892.wav", + "text": "因為我今天實在不想發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1893.wav", + "text": "我想大家講好就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1894.wav", + "text": "但我們要真的來看一下去年和前年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1895.wav", + "text": "副主計長今天演得不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1896.wav", + "text": "說沒有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1897.wav", + "text": "去年我們政府超收3,671億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1898.wav", + "text": "前年超收5,237億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1899.wav", + "text": "怎麼會沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1900.wav", + "text": "錢一天到晚在超收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1901.wav", + "text": "主計什麼時候預估準過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1902.wav", + "text": "原住民是臺灣土地最早的主人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1903.wav", + "text": "我們給一份尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1904.wav", + "text": "嘛如果院長真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1905.wav", + "text": "因為我們在這裡講一次兩次三次五次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1906.wav", + "text": "講六輪都沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1907.wav", + "text": "因為各自表述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1908.wav", + "text": "我想民眾看這個直播也看得很厭煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1909.wav", + "text": "我想我們就訴諸民主程序來解決好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1910.wav", + "text": "主席做個宣告不要再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1911.wav", + "text": "了本案因為最後沒有達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1912.wav", + "text": "等一下院會進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1913.wav", + "text": "廣泛討論221" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1914.wav", + "text": "院長我反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1915.wav", + "text": "你反對我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1916.wav", + "text": "等一下等一下我把它講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1917.wav", + "text": "為什麼不能講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1918.wav", + "text": "呢到最後一好你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1919.wav", + "text": "我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1920.wav", + "text": "今天只有這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1921.wav", + "text": "有這麼急嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1922.wav", + "text": "現在講了半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1923.wav", + "text": "他說叫我要簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1924.wav", + "text": "我當然簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1925.wav", + "text": "���們不要把這些都跳掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1926.wav", + "text": "我等了半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1927.wav", + "text": "他講第一句話是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1928.wav", + "text": "應我的要求沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1929.wav", + "text": "我感謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1930.wav", + "text": "大家就這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1931.wav", + "text": "但你現在的談話就很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1932.wav", + "text": "了每一個人發言要多少時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1933.wav", + "text": "要多少次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1934.wav", + "text": "奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1935.wav", + "text": "剛才我甚至講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1936.wav", + "text": "要撥出時間給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1937.wav", + "text": "國民黨民眾黨再去質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1938.wav", + "text": "質詢應該要講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1939.wav", + "text": "要回到各黨同意啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1940.wav", + "text": "所以這個問題很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1941.wav", + "text": "很重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1942.wav", + "text": "上次因為行政部門同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1943.wav", + "text": "英九執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1944.wav", + "text": "但硬壓下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1945.wav", + "text": "所以後來我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1946.wav", + "text": "就吞下去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1947.wav", + "text": "而且還放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1948.wav", + "text": "不管主計長或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1949.wav", + "text": "原民會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1950.wav", + "text": "在這裡都很難決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1951.wav", + "text": "嘛行政院來決定說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1952.wav", + "text": "這6萬太少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1953.wav", + "text": "不然8萬也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1954.wav", + "text": "這是行政權的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1955.wav", + "text": "則啊憲法可以拿來這裡表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1956.wav", + "text": "院長請你把朝野協商結論拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1957.wav", + "text": "誰不簽再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1958.wav", + "text": "那各黨幾個發言先寫一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1959.wav", + "text": "過去也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1960.wav", + "text": "先寫出來打出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1961.wav", + "text": "嘛然後再補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1962.wav", + "text": "總是要這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1963.wav", + "text": "朝野協商拿出來大家簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1964.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位委員同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1965.wav", + "text": "我想我們等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1966.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1967.wav", + "text": "雖然沒有達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1968.wav", + "text": "但我們等一下進院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1969.wav", + "text": "每個黨2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1970.wav", + "text": "民眾黨1位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1971.wav", + "text": "我唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1972.wav", + "text": "先拿出來簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1973.wav", + "text": "太多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1974.wav", + "text": "接下來就處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1975.wav", + "text": "這有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1976.wav", + "text": "一第3條第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1977.wav", + "text": "維持現行條文不予修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1978.wav", + "text": "第6條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1979.wav", + "text": "提報院會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1980.wav", + "text": "三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1981.wav", + "text": "院會進行處理時廣泛討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1982.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨派1位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1983.wav", + "text": "民進黨團派2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1984.wav", + "text": "國民黨團派2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1985.wav", + "text": "輪流交叉發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1986.wav", + "text": "順序授權議事處處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1987.wav", + "text": "每人發言3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1988.wav", + "text": "逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1989.wav", + "text": "各黨團均不發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1990.wav", + "text": "逐條討論要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1991.wav", + "text": "一位吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1992.wav", + "text": "啊院長你不要忘記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1993.wav", + "text": "你第一次主持朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1994.wav", + "text": "有關於凍漲電價協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1995.wav", + "text": "協商以後沒有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1996.wav", + "text": "後來是拿來給我補簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1997.wav", + "text": "逐條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1998.wav", + "text": "大體討論至少3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/1999.wav", + "text": "逐條1沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2000.wav", + "text": "反正大家整個原則都講清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2001.wav", + "text": "我正在修正我馬上會再唸一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2002.wav", + "text": "上次還叫我補簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2003.wav", + "text": "第3條院會進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2004.wav", + "text": "時廣泛討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2005.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團推派1位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2006.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團推派2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2007.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團推派2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2008.wav", + "text": "輪流交叉發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2009.wav", + "text": "順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2010.wav", + "text": "逐條討論時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2011.wav", + "text": "時每個黨團派1位代表發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2012.wav", + "text": "大體是只有2位是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2013.wav", + "text": "院長你先簽名嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2014.wav", + "text": "什麼大體221" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2015.wav", + "text": "上次我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2016.wav", + "text": "廣泛討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2017.wav", + "text": "我們都是3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2018.wav", + "text": "廣泛討論都是3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2019.wav", + "text": "個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2020.wav", + "text": "大體3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2021.wav", + "text": "上次我們也是一樣5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2022.wav", + "text": "528也是如此處理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2023.wav", + "text": "大體講完逐條就差不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2024.wav", + "text": "好啦好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2025.wav", + "text": "上次就是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2026.wav", + "text": "院長你先簽嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2027.wav", + "text": "行政部門各個列席的官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2028.wav", + "text": "謝謝你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2029.wav", + "text": "後面就交給我們來處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2030.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2031.wav", + "text": "祝福大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2032.wav", + "text": "各黨團幹部簽了字以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2033.wav", + "text": "我們預計在3點10分左右開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15978/2034.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/0.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/2.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/3.wav", + "text": "\n柯總召請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/4.wav", + "text": "院長各位協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/5.wav", + "text": "我在這裡還是要很誠懇的拜託大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/6.wav", + "text": "國會是大家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/7.wav", + "text": "國家也是大家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/8.wav", + "text": "需要大家一起來維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/9.wav", + "text": "這是最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/10.wav", + "text": "的假如國會變成亂無章法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/11.wav", + "text": "也不依法行事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/12.wav", + "text": "也沒有程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/13.wav", + "text": "那這個國家的民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/14.wav", + "text": "將是一個輓歌一個結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/15.wav", + "text": "所以在這裡我還是很誠懇的呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/16.wav", + "text": "韓院長今天你的角色是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/17.wav", + "text": "我認為你有能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/18.wav", + "text": "來解決這個紛爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/19.wav", + "text": "議長就是調和鼎鼐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/20.wav", + "text": "權行使法規定的很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/21.wav", + "text": "議事爭端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/22.wav", + "text": "最大的功能及權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/23.wav", + "text": "當這個權柄在你手上的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/24.wav", + "text": "全部化解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/25.wav", + "text": "\n我今天在這裡重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/26.wav", + "text": "要有程序正義要依法行事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/27.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/28.wav", + "text": "不會存在所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/29.wav", + "text": "一個月到了就馬上表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/30.wav", + "text": "過去沒有這個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/31.wav", + "text": "當我們今天破壞了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/32.wav", + "text": "你看現在的國會是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/33.wav", + "text": "是藍白過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/34.wav", + "text": "嘛我們就舉幾個國會改革的方案好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/35.wav", + "text": "我們的版本惡意不併入審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/36.wav", + "text": "也不併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/37.wav", + "text": "換言之只有你們一個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/38.wav", + "text": "你們的版本在立法院是怎麼樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/39.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/40.wav", + "text": "這是我們沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/41.wav", + "text": "仗著人數多數要走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/42.wav", + "text": "內容只有大體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/43.wav", + "text": "你們不能說我們已經給你們大體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/44.wav", + "text": "了立法委員的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/45.wav", + "text": "是憲法所賦予的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/46.wav", + "text": "不是只有大體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/47.wav", + "text": "逐條討論的結果不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/48.wav", + "text": "的話還有委員會的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/49.wav", + "text": "委員會的朝野協商如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/50.wav", + "text": "有問題當然是交付給院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/51.wav", + "text": "這時候在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/52.wav", + "text": "我們坐了多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/53.wav", + "text": "每一個人都在這個地方坐過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/54.wav", + "text": "然後大家簽協商協論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/55.wav", + "text": "總共幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/56.wav", + "text": "然後幾條要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/57.wav", + "text": "幾條不必發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/58.wav", + "text": "有時後大部頭的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/59.wav", + "text": "都是一直精簡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/60.wav", + "text": "院會表決以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/61.wav", + "text": "大家能夠談到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/62.wav", + "text": "有共通的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/63.wav", + "text": "這是國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/64.wav", + "text": "這是國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/65.wav", + "text": "這個程序也沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/66.wav", + "text": "國昌今天在這裡我還是要談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/67.wav", + "text": "幹事長書記長都過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/68.wav", + "text": "因為我擔任這麼久的總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/69.wav", + "text": "我不會去參加委員會的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/70.wav", + "text": "因為都押到最後不行的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/71.wav", + "text": "假如他們協商好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/72.wav", + "text": "我看可以就會簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/73.wav", + "text": "儘量尊重委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/74.wav", + "text": "到最後不行的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/75.wav", + "text": "我一定會參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/76.wav", + "text": "而且隨傳隨到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/77.wav", + "text": "隨傳隨到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/78.wav", + "text": "這是我們國會踐行這麼久以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/79.wav", + "text": "大家所維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/80.wav", + "text": "互相指責誰對或不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/81.wav", + "text": "是非的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/82.wav", + "text": "最好不要再講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/83.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷你說我們耍流氓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/84.wav", + "text": "我知道你們很辛苦排了三天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/85.wav", + "text": "過去我們也這樣排過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/86.wav", + "text": "但排的目的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/87.wav", + "text": "最早的遞案權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/88.wav", + "text": "處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/89.wav", + "text": "能夠有我們的優先順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/90.wav", + "text": "這是要讓院會開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/91.wav", + "text": "你們這個排一排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/92.wav", + "text": "是不讓院會開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/93.wav", + "text": "\n我看不出什麼耍流氓的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/94.wav", + "text": "今天早上7點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/95.wav", + "text": "要進去的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/96.wav", + "text": "居然有警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/97.wav", + "text": "在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/98.wav", + "text": "這過去沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/99.wav", + "text": "警察可以站在議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/100.wav", + "text": "議場門口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/101.wav", + "text": "進去以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/102.wav", + "text": "的議場門口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/103.wav", + "text": "也在那裡擋立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/104.wav", + "text": "讓民進黨的立委不能進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/105.wav", + "text": "這個像樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/106.wav", + "text": "今天整個議場多了多少警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/107.wav", + "text": "院長你的議場後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/108.wav", + "text": "我看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/109.wav", + "text": "有10個警察站在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/110.wav", + "text": "院長沒有人會對你動手的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/111.wav", + "text": "大家都非常尊重你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/112.wav", + "text": "種過當的防衛是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/113.wav", + "text": "我們曾經看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/114.wav", + "text": "1990年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/115.wav", + "text": "張俊雄打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/116.wav", + "text": "梁肅戎也打他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/117.wav", + "text": "叫警察進來把張俊雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/118.wav", + "text": "拖到茶水間打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/119.wav", + "text": "然後再拖出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/120.wav", + "text": "盧修一就是這樣被處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/121.wav", + "text": "民主的這一頁也翻過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/122.wav", + "text": "王院長當院長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/123.wav", + "text": "他絕對不會動用警察權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/124.wav", + "text": "所以這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/125.wav", + "text": "請院長要三思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/126.wav", + "text": "大禹治水也是疏導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/127.wav", + "text": "防堵都是沒有用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/128.wav", + "text": "我很誠懇地告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/129.wav", + "text": "你第3條以後就走掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/130.wav", + "text": "這樣是過水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/131.wav", + "text": "照你2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/132.wav", + "text": "絕對是吵翻天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/133.wav", + "text": "可是你今天怎麼變成完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/134.wav", + "text": "基本的這種道義與責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/135.wav", + "text": "你自己都會翻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/136.wav", + "text": "早上7點4分的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/137.wav", + "text": "我來送案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/138.wav", + "text": "所有人都進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/139.wav", + "text": "黃國昌我在你後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/140.wav", + "text": "我要送案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/141.wav", + "text": "我在你後面你怎麼回頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/142.wav", + "text": "就大罵我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/143.wav", + "text": "站在後面的人怎麼插" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/144.wav", + "text": "前面的隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/145.wav", + "text": "和你一點關係都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/146.wav", + "text": "你那種激情的演出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/147.wav", + "text": "實在是讓我很詫異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/148.wav", + "text": "現在變報紙可以寫說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/149.wav", + "text": "我打黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/150.wav", + "text": "所以我今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/151.wav", + "text": "要把這個事情講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/152.wav", + "text": "\n傅崐萁委員一直講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/153.wav", + "text": "你叫韓院長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/154.wav", + "text": "院長只有兩個職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/155.wav", + "text": "一個就是調和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/156.wav", + "text": "主持院會的糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/157.wav", + "text": "會的糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/158.wav", + "text": "院長不會介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/159.wav", + "text": "要到出委員會的那種層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/160.wav", + "text": "就是院長的層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/161.wav", + "text": "這是國會能夠運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/162.wav", + "text": "這麼久以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/163.wav", + "text": "所最根本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/164.wav", + "text": "\n今天假如這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/165.wav", + "text": "我要回答一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/166.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/167.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁與黃國昌一直講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/168.wav", + "text": "國會改革民進黨8年不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/169.wav", + "text": "試問這8年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/170.wav", + "text": "國民黨沒有在立法院嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/171.wav", + "text": "8年前黃國昌你也在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/172.wav", + "text": "20年來沒有做過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/173.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/174.wav", + "text": "一直沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/175.wav", + "text": "在王院長時代的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/176.wav", + "text": "國會調查權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/177.wav", + "text": "那是2004年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/178.wav", + "text": "我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/179.wav", + "text": "到憲法法庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/180.wav", + "text": "當初參加憲法法庭的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/181.wav", + "text": "有尤清委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/182.wav", + "text": "還有現在兩位已經變成大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/183.wav", + "text": "釋憲出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/184.wav", + "text": "有調查權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/185.wav", + "text": "那時候在想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/186.wav", + "text": "這個調查權應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/187.wav", + "text": "監察院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/188.wav", + "text": "我們要如何分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/189.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/190.wav", + "text": "沒有把事情釐得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/191.wav", + "text": "我們也不敢修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/192.wav", + "text": "我們不敢修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/193.wav", + "text": "有提版本但不敢修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/194.wav", + "text": "那時候我們國會多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/195.wav", + "text": "什麼都可以過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/196.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/197.wav", + "text": "這種對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/198.wav", + "text": "以及公平性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/199.wav", + "text": "我們要想清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/200.wav", + "text": "於是乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/201.wav", + "text": "只有這個其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/202.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/203.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/204.wav", + "text": "立法院組織法第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/205.wav", + "text": "院長必須行政中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/206.wav", + "text": "以及退出政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/207.wav", + "text": "都是我們修的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/208.wav", + "text": "直播也是我們修的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/209.wav", + "text": "差不多可以想得到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/210.wav", + "text": "合理的都修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/211.wav", + "text": "但是衝突性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/212.wav", + "text": "我們不太敢處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/213.wav", + "text": "包括聽證等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/214.wav", + "text": "\n所以今天不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/215.wav", + "text": "我們做不到的你們來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/216.wav", + "text": "8年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/217.wav", + "text": "這晚近8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/218.wav", + "text": "國民黨沒有在立法院嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/219.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有提國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/220.wav", + "text": "呢黃國昌8年前你也在嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/221.wav", + "text": "我們應該做的都會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/222.wav", + "text": "到1999年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/223.wav", + "text": "劉松藩院長有最大的功勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/224.wav", + "text": "他把國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/225.wav", + "text": "五法全部做出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/226.wav", + "text": "要確定議事錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/227.wav", + "text": "就來一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/228.wav", + "text": "程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/229.wav", + "text": "一大堆人就排在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/230.wav", + "text": "等著講程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/231.wav", + "text": "各位偉大政治家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/232.wav", + "text": "程序沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/233.wav", + "text": "不要一直講程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/234.wav", + "text": "要尋求發言的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/235.wav", + "text": "所以才有後來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/236.wav", + "text": "國是論壇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/237.wav", + "text": "因為大家愛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/238.wav", + "text": "就比照美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/239.wav", + "text": "讓大家講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/240.wav", + "text": "大家講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/241.wav", + "text": "這是一些國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/242.wav", + "text": "由今天整個國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/243.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/244.wav", + "text": "已經改過才是之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/245.wav", + "text": "第71條本身是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/246.wav", + "text": "沒有結論以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/247.wav", + "text": "定期處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/248.wav", + "text": "不是馬上處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/249.wav", + "text": "所以才有第68條規定由院長來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/250.wav", + "text": "四個月改一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/251.wav", + "text": "\n所以大家要懂得法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/252.wav", + "text": "今天我不是在這裡講故事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/253.wav", + "text": "這是一個很重要的憲政時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/254.wav", + "text": "\n至於各位所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/255.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/256.wav", + "text": "在協商完畢以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/257.wav", + "text": "表決輸了就是輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/258.wav", + "text": "你們要提釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/259.wav", + "text": "連我們提釋憲的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/260.wav", + "text": "立法委員三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/261.wav", + "text": "就可以提釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/262.wav", + "text": "他說你們要提什麼釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/263.wav", + "text": "這個很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/264.wav", + "text": "他一時忘記了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/265.wav", + "text": "加起來聯手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/266.wav", + "text": "掌控臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/267.wav", + "text": "轉動世界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/268.wav", + "text": "所以我們感到非常憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/269.wav", + "text": "啊你們聯手起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/270.wav", + "text": "把整個秩序都破壞掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/271.wav", + "text": "我們不會擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/272.wav", + "text": "將來所有抗中保臺的法案都被修掉嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/273.wav", + "text": "年金改革好不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/274.wav", + "text": "而且國民黨說違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/275.wav", + "text": "你們現在突然要叫停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/276.wav", + "text": "反年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/277.wav", + "text": "你們一直來把它顛覆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/278.wav", + "text": "這是一個國家最危險的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/279.wav", + "text": "當一個人有權力的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/280.wav", + "text": "他手中掌握的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/281.wav", + "text": "不是他可以為所欲為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/282.wav", + "text": "而且交給一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/283.wav", + "text": "EQ" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/284.wav", + "text": "我站在後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/285.wav", + "text": "你們兩個在主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/286.wav", + "text": "這是非常可怕的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/287.wav", + "text": "完全就是為所欲為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/288.wav", + "text": "然後可以顛覆自己過去的價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/289.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁我跟你講我們是老朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/290.wav", + "text": "今天要來處理這三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/291.wav", + "text": "上去發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/292.wav", + "text": "那個人數再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/293.wav", + "text": "很快就結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/294.wav", + "text": "剩下完全沒有協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/295.wav", + "text": "藐視國會這一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/296.wav", + "text": "也有所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/297.wav", + "text": "要對官員來聽證來任免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/298.wav", + "text": "也有所謂列為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/299.wav", + "text": "不審理的預算法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/300.wav", + "text": "自己發明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/301.wav", + "text": "全世界獨有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/302.wav", + "text": "這難道不會讓人擔心嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/303.wav", + "text": "\n所以我今天還是要講一樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/304.wav", + "text": "我們等一下要衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/305.wav", + "text": "要尋求解決方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/306.wav", + "text": "我相信院長你心中應該有一把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/307.wav", + "text": "假如真的不能解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/308.wav", + "text": "冷靜下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/309.wav", + "text": "禮拜二還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/310.wav", + "text": "你們希望的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/311.wav", + "text": "我們可以跟你好好協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/312.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/313.wav", + "text": "包括環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/314.wav", + "text": "都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/315.wav", + "text": "做一個協商結論出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/316.wav", + "text": "可以表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/317.wav", + "text": "突然之間說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/318.wav", + "text": "下個政府再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/319.wav", + "text": "你們實在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/320.wav", + "text": "而且發朝野協商通知是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/321.wav", + "text": "大家手上都有一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/322.wav", + "text": "國昌竟然在最後的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/323.wav", + "text": "說新政府再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/324.wav", + "text": "我們認為這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/325.wav", + "text": "剝奪行政院的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/326.wav", + "text": "難道新政府會同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/327.wav", + "text": "不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/328.wav", + "text": "啊你這樣轉來轉去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/329.wav", + "text": "當然剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/330.wav", + "text": "也發生一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/331.wav", + "text": "在這裡互" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/332.wav", + "text": "互責不適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/333.wav", + "text": "都是枝節末端的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/334.wav", + "text": "臺灣的民主還要不要維繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/335.wav", + "text": "臺灣的國會還要不要維繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/336.wav", + "text": "假如這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/337.wav", + "text": "毀憲亂政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/338.wav", + "text": "國會報銷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/339.wav", + "text": "跟大陸人大差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/340.wav", + "text": "香港化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/341.wav", + "text": "啦這不是只有臺灣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/342.wav", + "text": "全世界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/343.wav", + "text": "在臺灣投資的外商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/344.wav", + "text": "全部在看待這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/345.wav", + "text": "有外媒就是要來訪問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/346.wav", + "text": "叫我出來開國際記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/347.wav", + "text": "我說我們會解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/348.wav", + "text": "我相信我們會解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/349.wav", + "text": "是全球緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/350.wav", + "text": "但是這個緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/351.wav", + "text": "就是院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/352.wav", + "text": "要翻轉你的思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/353.wav", + "text": "跟黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/354.wav", + "text": "\n黃國昌我希望你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/355.wav", + "text": "談出一個道理出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/356.wav", + "text": "不是還在說你插話我插話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/357.wav", + "text": "老是轉到這個地方去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/358.wav", + "text": "然後跟你講法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/359.wav", + "text": "你說這個你也不理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/360.wav", + "text": "那我們要怎麼走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/361.wav", + "text": "最後還是懇求大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/362.wav", + "text": "冷靜來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/363.wav", + "text": "昨天下午的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/364.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召並沒有說停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/365.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召希望透過我的嘴巴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/366.wav", + "text": "再一次確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/367.wav", + "text": "在前一次的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/368.wav", + "text": "我是不是曾經說過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/369.wav", + "text": "等新的交通部長報到之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/370.wav", + "text": "我們再來協商環島高鐵的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/371.wav", + "text": "我說是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/372.wav", + "text": "不是說他希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/373.wav", + "text": "而是他希望跟我來確認一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/374.wav", + "text": "事實上在前一次朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/375.wav", + "text": "現在交通部部長即將下臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/376.wav", + "text": "離開職務了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/377.wav", + "text": "新的交通部長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/378.wav", + "text": "我們聽他的專業分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/379.wav", + "text": "也經過藍白國民黨民眾黨他們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/380.wav", + "text": "所以黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/381.wav", + "text": "昨天下午要再從我的嘴巴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/382.wav", + "text": "再一次確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/383.wav", + "text": "我曾經是不是說過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/384.wav", + "text": "我說是的我說過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/385.wav", + "text": "院長這是過去一些對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/386.wav", + "text": "但是是你有這樣想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/387.wav", + "text": "但是你還是召開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/388.wav", + "text": "我們還是協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/389.wav", + "text": "來否定大家已經坐在這裡的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/390.wav", + "text": "我要先講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/391.wav", + "text": "然後他就走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/392.wav", + "text": "我當然很磊落啊因為我的確是有講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/393.wav", + "text": "不能用他曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/394.wav", + "text": "當天都在協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/395.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯總召接下來國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/396.wav", + "text": "有沒有寶貴意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/397.wav", + "text": "\n請洪孟楷書記長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/398.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯建銘總召15分零3秒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/399.wav", + "text": "的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/400.wav", + "text": "還是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/401.wav", + "text": "開創性的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/402.wav", + "text": "還是沒有打算要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/403.wav", + "text": "來解決這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/404.wav", + "text": "我們只講一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/405.wav", + "text": "誰沒有依法行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/406.wav", + "text": "今天我們都是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/407.wav", + "text": "我們坐在這邊誰沒有依法行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/408.wav", + "text": "再者誰先衝突動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/409.wav", + "text": "所有國人都看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/410.wav", + "text": "今天都有直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/411.wav", + "text": "從早上六點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/412.wav", + "text": "一直到現在下午三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/413.wav", + "text": "快四點誰先動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/414.wav", + "text": "六波的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/415.wav", + "text": "每一次都是民進黨團的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/416.wav", + "text": "先動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/417.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/418.wav", + "text": "動手就是民主嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/419.wav", + "text": "動手就是比較大聲講話嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/420.wav", + "text": "動手就有權力嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/421.wav", + "text": "而且更重要的是剛剛柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/422.wav", + "text": "特別有提到警察的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/423.wav", + "text": "到目前為止我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/424.wav", + "text": "院長非常的中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/425.wav", + "text": "都還嚴守我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/426.wav", + "text": "最後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/427.wav", + "text": "國會議場的秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/428.wav", + "text": "沒有警察進入到議場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/429.wav", + "text": "而剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/430.wav", + "text": "發生了一件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/431.wav", + "text": "即便過去到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/432.wav", + "text": "幾十年來國會有所謂的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/433.wav", + "text": "都是委員對委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/434.wav", + "text": "從來沒有一個委員對議事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/435.wav", + "text": "但我們居然看到剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/436.wav", + "text": "民進黨籍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/437.wav", + "text": "郭國文委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/438.wav", + "text": "直接對著秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/439.wav", + "text": "人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/440.wav", + "text": "衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/441.wav", + "text": "秘書長高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/442.wav", + "text": "七十多歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/443.wav", + "text": "專業的文官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/444.wav", + "text": "郭國文委員直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/445.wav", + "text": "把秘書長壓在座位上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/446.wav", + "text": "從秘書長的懷中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/447.wav", + "text": "把秘書長的資料搶去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/448.wav", + "text": "這是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/449.wav", + "text": "什麼時候民進黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/450.wav", + "text": "可以在國會裡面連議事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/451.wav", + "text": "都不放過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/452.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/453.wav", + "text": "我想請教為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/454.wav", + "text": "民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/455.wav", + "text": "黨主席賴清德授意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/456.wav", + "text": "要你們這樣做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/457.wav", + "text": "柯總召講那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/458.wav", + "text": "我不會發言那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/459.wav", + "text": "因為我來這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/460.wav", + "text": "我認為有理行遍天下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/461.wav", + "text": "我只想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/462.wav", + "text": "今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/463.wav", + "text": "國會是比人頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/464.wav", + "text": "還是比拳頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/465.wav", + "text": "請民進黨的代表告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/466.wav", + "text": "國會是比人頭還是比拳頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/467.wav", + "text": "國會是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/468.wav", + "text": "沒有照你們的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/469.wav", + "text": "就是要衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/470.wav", + "text": "就是不肯讓議事繼續進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/471.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/472.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/473.wav", + "text": "兩點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/474.wav", + "text": "我們協商結束之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/475.wav", + "text": "在議場後面的院長休息室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/476.wav", + "text": "有高達7位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/477.wav", + "text": "的民進黨委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/478.wav", + "text": "把議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/479.wav", + "text": "休息室的門給鎖住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/480.wav", + "text": "不讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/481.wav", + "text": "幾位代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/482.wav", + "text": "從議場休息室出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/483.wav", + "text": "包括院長跟副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/484.wav", + "text": "這是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/485.wav", + "text": "這是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/486.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/487.wav", + "text": "我們現在再問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/488.wav", + "text": "院長今天非常的中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/489.wav", + "text": "今天的討論事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/490.wav", + "text": "第一案第二案第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/491.wav", + "text": "就是國會改革的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/492.wav", + "text": "也已經經過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/493.wav", + "text": "4月16號出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/494.wav", + "text": "召委召開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/495.wav", + "text": "都已經完備相關的法律程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/496.wav", + "text": "我再強調一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/497.wav", + "text": "2024年4月16號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/498.wav", + "text": "出司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/499.wav", + "text": "5月8號吳宗憲召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/500.wav", + "text": "召開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/501.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/502.wav", + "text": "如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/503.wav", + "text": "等一下不能處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/504.wav", + "text": "議事人員不會讓我們處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/505.wav", + "text": "如果等一下可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/506.wav", + "text": "議事人員就會依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/507.wav", + "text": "來進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/508.wav", + "text": "這個不用爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/509.wav", + "text": "不用爭你對還是我對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/510.wav", + "text": "這是我一開始在上一段協商的時候就講過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/511.wav", + "text": "如果說今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/512.wav", + "text": "有任何議事的規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/513.wav", + "text": "法令的規則我們沒有確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/514.wav", + "text": "請議事人員請秘書長直接講明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/515.wav", + "text": "我們看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/516.wav", + "text": "是沒有一個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/517.wav", + "text": "因為柯總召剛剛講了15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/518.wav", + "text": "聽起來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/519.wav", + "text": "只要不照他的意思做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/520.wav", + "text": "那就是反民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/521.wav", + "text": "就是沒有辦法繼續進行下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/522.wav", + "text": "但是我們認為今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/523.wav", + "text": "既然很負責任地提出案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/524.wav", + "text": "而且也已經完備所有的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/525.wav", + "text": "包括4月16號出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/526.wav", + "text": "5月8號已經協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/527.wav", + "text": "在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/528.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法達成朝野協商的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/529.wav", + "text": "之下只能按照議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/530.wav", + "text": "做後續的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/531.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/532.wav", + "text": "站在議事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/533.wav", + "text": "合法合憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/534.wav", + "text": "合規定的情況下面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/535.wav", + "text": "我們就來這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/536.wav", + "text": "但是我們完全尊重剛剛院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/537.wav", + "text": "提出來的進行方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/538.wav", + "text": "院長提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/539.wav", + "text": "大體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/540.wav", + "text": "每個黨團各派三位代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/541.wav", + "text": "逐條發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/542.wav", + "text": "每個黨團推派一位代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/543.wav", + "text": "我們敬表同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/544.wav", + "text": "我們也認為能夠讓所有國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/545.wav", + "text": "透過我們的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/546.wav", + "text": "看到我們對於每一條法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/547.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/548.wav", + "text": "所以我希望各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/549.wav", + "text": "等一下就針對院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/550.wav", + "text": "所提出來的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/551.wav", + "text": "進行同意或不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/552.wav", + "text": "讓國人都清楚明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/553.wav", + "text": "我們各黨團的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/554.wav", + "text": "如果真的沒有辦法有協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/555.wav", + "text": "那真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/556.wav", + "text": "我們已經浪費太多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/557.wav", + "text": "而且六波的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/558.wav", + "text": "我最後強調沒有一次衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/559.wav", + "text": "是我們發起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/560.wav", + "text": "但是如果還要再衝突的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/561.wav", + "text": "國人都在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/562.wav", + "text": "民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/563.wav", + "text": "黨主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/564.wav", + "text": "你願意讓國會持續的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/565.wav", + "text": "有史上最大規模的衝突嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/566.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/567.wav", + "text": "之前在黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/568.wav", + "text": "我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/569.wav", + "text": "院長可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/570.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/571.wav", + "text": "基本上都是針對院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/572.wav", + "text": "所垂詢的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/573.wav", + "text": "表達我們的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/574.wav", + "text": "即使柯建銘先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/575.wav", + "text": "常常莫名其妙的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/576.wav", + "text": "在扯一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/577.wav", + "text": "其他的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/578.wav", + "text": "甚至扭曲事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/579.wav", + "text": "指鹿為馬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/580.wav", + "text": "我也很少利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/581.wav", + "text": "這個協商的場合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/582.wav", + "text": "再去回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/583.wav", + "text": "因為我知道這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/584.wav", + "text": "是屬於大家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/585.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/586.wav", + "text": "院長在上一次協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/587.wav", + "text": "您所提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/588.wav", + "text": "大體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/589.wav", + "text": "每一個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/590.wav", + "text": "推派一到三名的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/591.wav", + "text": "逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/592.wav", + "text": "每一個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/593.wav", + "text": "推派一名的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/594.wav", + "text": "這樣的處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/595.wav", + "text": "在上一次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/596.wav", + "text": "最後的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/597.wav", + "text": "我說院長我有幾句話想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/598.wav", + "text": "你說已經結束那我尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/599.wav", + "text": "我事很清楚地跟院長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/600.wav", + "text": "我們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/601.wav", + "text": "的裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/602.wav", + "text": "非常遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/603.wav", + "text": "的協商結束以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/604.wav", + "text": "沒有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/605.wav", + "text": "我們覺得應該下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/606.wav", + "text": "依照程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/607.wav", + "text": "加以進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/608.wav", + "text": "所以我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/609.wav", + "text": "說3點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/610.wav", + "text": "要協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/611.wav", + "text": "其實我們有一些不解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/612.wav", + "text": "也有一些困惑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/613.wav", + "text": "但是基於對院長的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/614.wav", + "text": "我們現在坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/615.wav", + "text": "\n我具體回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/616.wav", + "text": "剛剛院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/617.wav", + "text": "提出來的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/618.wav", + "text": "處理的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/619.wav", + "text": "其他的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/620.wav", + "text": "我們不多談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/621.wav", + "text": "但有一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/622.wav", + "text": "我跟所有在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/623.wav", + "text": "的台灣民眾黨立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/624.wav", + "text": "因為當時在場的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/625.wav", + "text": "共同目睹了一幕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/626.wav", + "text": "讓人無法相信的景象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/627.wav", + "text": "竟然有立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/628.wav", + "text": "以粗暴的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/629.wav", + "text": "秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/630.wav", + "text": "從他手中強行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/631.wav", + "text": "搶奪東西以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/632.wav", + "text": "拔腿就跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/633.wav", + "text": "周秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/634.wav", + "text": "協助院長主持議事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/635.wav", + "text": "何錯之有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/636.wav", + "text": "何其無辜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/637.wav", + "text": "到底是什麼樣的心態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/638.wav", + "text": "大家都敬重的長者動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/639.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/640.wav", + "text": "的所有成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/641.wav", + "text": "無法忍受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/642.wav", + "text": "這樣的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/643.wav", + "text": "這絕對不是依法行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/644.wav", + "text": "這也絕對不��什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/645.wav", + "text": "程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/646.wav", + "text": "我們非常尊重院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/647.wav", + "text": "我們也知道院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/648.wav", + "text": "的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/649.wav", + "text": "但是有的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/650.wav", + "text": "院長可能面臨的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/651.wav", + "text": "人軟土深掘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/652.wav", + "text": "我知道院長的苦處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/653.wav", + "text": "這樣的手段可以得逞的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/654.wav", + "text": "請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/655.wav", + "text": "哪裡是盡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/656.wav", + "text": "因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/657.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/658.wav", + "text": "院長依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/659.wav", + "text": "主持議事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/660.wav", + "text": "針對院長所提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/661.wav", + "text": "那一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/662.wav", + "text": "各政黨的代表人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/663.wav", + "text": "逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/664.wav", + "text": "各政黨的代表人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/665.wav", + "text": "我們都同意院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/666.wav", + "text": "所提出來的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/667.wav", + "text": "好我會把握時間快速回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/668.wav", + "text": "首先回應黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/669.wav", + "text": "我們是在自由民主的臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/670.wav", + "text": "不是在中國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/671.wav", + "text": "你不用稱他柯建銘先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/672.wav", + "text": "我們不是在北京" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/673.wav", + "text": "第二個每一次在協商現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/674.wav", + "text": "我發現每一個黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/675.wav", + "text": "黨鞭都真的很克盡職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/676.wav", + "text": "包括我自己及總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/677.wav", + "text": "都是全程參與每一次都出席傅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/678.wav", + "text": "傅總召孟楷思銘也都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/679.wav", + "text": "但是唯獨黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/680.wav", + "text": "屢屢都是協商中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/681.wav", + "text": "帥氣的甩頭走人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/682.wav", + "text": "來來去去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/683.wav", + "text": "往往最不尊重協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/684.wav", + "text": "就是黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/685.wav", + "text": "為什麼你一直說協商很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/686.wav", + "text": "不尊重協商跟不尊重院長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/687.wav", + "text": "往往就是黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/688.wav", + "text": "而這就發生在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/689.wav", + "text": "剛剛洪孟楷委員一直說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/690.wav", + "text": "院職權行使法吳宗憲召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/691.wav", + "text": "確實在5月8號召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/692.wav", + "text": "黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/693.wav", + "text": "是全程在場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/694.wav", + "text": "就停了為什麼停呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/695.wav", + "text": "因為黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/696.wav", + "text": "又再次甩頭走人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/697.wav", + "text": "先離席了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/698.wav", + "text": "所以吳宗憲召委就順勢說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/699.wav", + "text": "有在野黨的代表已經離席了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/700.wav", + "text": "那我們沒有協商的必要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/701.wav", + "text": "所以那天68條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/702.wav", + "text": "我跟瑞雄都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/703.wav", + "text": "排了整個下午空下來的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/704.wav", + "text": "就因為黃國昌總召的提早離席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/705.wav", + "text": "68個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/706.wav", + "text": "應當逐條協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/707.wav", + "text": "只進行了4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/708.wav", + "text": "所以我比喻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/709.wav", + "text": "就像是一個老師上課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/710.wav", + "text": "這一個學期要上68堂課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/711.wav", + "text": "68個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/712.wav", + "text": "老師上到第4堂課的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/713.wav", + "text": "一個同學說他蹺課走人了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/714.wav", + "text": "老師說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/715.wav", + "text": "因為同學不在了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/716.wav", + "text": "我們這堂課就不用上了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/717.wav", + "text": "有這種課嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/718.wav", + "text": "因為一個蹺課的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/719.wav", + "text": "而讓整個課就沒有辦法上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/720.wav", + "text": "這是什麼道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/721.wav", + "text": "剛剛黃國昌總召說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/722.wav", + "text": "支持院長依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/723.wav", + "text": "主持議事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/724.wav", + "text": "我要說其實正是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/725.wav", + "text": "在逼迫院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/726.wav", + "text": "不依法主持議事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/727.wav", + "text": "這個我就不再贅述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/728.wav", + "text": "院長回過頭來我想跟您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/729.wav", + "text": "分享一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/730.wav", + "text": "今天還有可以處理下去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/731.wav", + "text": "氣氛嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/732.wav", + "text": "今天已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/733.wav", + "text": "僵成這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/734.wav", + "text": "還有可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/735.wav", + "text": "順利進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/736.wav", + "text": "氣氛嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/737.wav", + "text": "我們有這麼急切的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/738.wav", + "text": "一定要在今天處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/739.wav", + "text": "跳過程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/740.wav", + "text": "急切的要在今天處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/741.wav", + "text": "就在昨天的協商會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/742.wav", + "text": "大家各黨都同意也簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/743.wav", + "text": "這個會期要延會到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/744.wav", + "text": "7月16號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/745.wav", + "text": "我們有充分的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/746.wav", + "text": "這個會期沒有要在5月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/747.wav", + "text": "在大家充分同意之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/748.wav", + "text": "可以延會到7月16號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/749.wav", + "text": "一個半月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/750.wav", + "text": "可以讓更多的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/751.wav", + "text": "透過好的審查跟對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/752.wav", + "text": "有這麼急嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/753.wav", + "text": "如果這麼急的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/754.wav", + "text": "為什麼再生醫療二法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/755.wav", + "text": "今天你們要把它甩到一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/756.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/757.wav", + "text": "韓院長尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/758.wav", + "text": "那天黃國昌總召的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/759.wav", + "text": "建議因為兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/760.wav", + "text": "花東建設的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/761.wav", + "text": "要等新任的交通部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/762.wav", + "text": "來再進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/763.wav", + "text": "那新任的行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/764.wav", + "text": "院長都還沒有上任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/765.wav", + "text": "我們要進行的立法委員職權法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/766.wav", + "text": "當中非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/767.wav", + "text": "包括藐視國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/768.wav", + "text": "這些權限都跟行政院大有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/769.wav", + "text": "可以因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/770.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召一個建議說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/771.wav", + "text": "要等新的交通部長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/772.wav", + "text": "再來討論交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/773.wav", + "text": "同樣的那就是院長您的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/774.wav", + "text": "邏輯那我也在這裡提醒您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/775.wav", + "text": "新任的行政院長都還沒有上任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/776.wav", + "text": "就急切的要通過一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/777.wav", + "text": "跟行政立法監督關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/778.wav", + "text": "國會擴權法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/779.wav", + "text": "有這麼急嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/780.wav", + "text": "這個會期要延會到7月16號了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/781.wav", + "text": "我們多出一個半月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/782.wav", + "text": "可以處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/783.wav", + "text": "可以好好的來討論條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/784.wav", + "text": "\n我最後想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/785.wav", + "text": "院長我為什麼今天上午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/786.wav", + "text": "提到我看到這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/787.wav", + "text": "警察而且每一個都帶著密錄器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/788.wav", + "text": "當然您剛剛在協商當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/789.wav", + "text": "也解釋說是為了保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/790.wav", + "text": "委員的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/791.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常的奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/792.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得非常的奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/793.wav", + "text": "王金平院長過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/794.wav", + "text": "堅持即使在318學運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/795.wav", + "text": "他都堅持絕對不能動用警察權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/796.wav", + "text": "如果動用警察權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/797.wav", + "text": "就是對於民主的迫害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/798.wav", + "text": "這是王金平院長說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/799.wav", + "text": "我相信您也會尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/800.wav", + "text": "因為2月1號您上任的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/801.wav", + "text": "也說過同樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/802.wav", + "text": "絕對不會動用警察權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/803.wav", + "text": "不是比拳頭的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/804.wav", + "text": "國會要論理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/805.wav", + "text": "那是您上任的時候說的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/806.wav", + "text": "但我有一點我真的不解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/807.wav", + "text": "我不曉得我有沒有聽錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/808.wav", + "text": "因為距離很近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/809.wav", + "text": "小會議室裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/810.wav", + "text": "真的很不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/811.wav", + "text": "說給我調多一點警察來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/812.wav", + "text": "我不曉得我有沒有聽錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/813.wav", + "text": "我要問院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/814.wav", + "text": "為什麼可以說給我調多一點警察來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/815.wav", + "text": "我覺得我沒有辦法理解跟想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/816.wav", + "text": "我有沒有聽錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/817.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/818.wav", + "text": "我們尊重院長的裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/819.wav", + "text": "絕對不能讓警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/820.wav", + "text": "介入委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/821.wav", + "text": "任何議事之進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/822.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重也相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/823.wav", + "text": "但是我要再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/824.wav", + "text": "部署這麼多的警力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/825.wav", + "text": "每一個佩戴密錄器這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/826.wav", + "text": "讓人感受真的不是很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/827.wav", + "text": "我也認為這是有點過當的部署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/828.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們還是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/829.wav", + "text": "不要逼迫院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/830.wav", + "text": "進行非法的議事主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/831.wav", + "text": "沒有完備逐條協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/832.wav", + "text": "就是沒有完備這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/833.wav", + "text": "到7月16日我們要延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/834.wav", + "text": "有這麼急嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/835.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召有這麼急嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/836.wav", + "text": "我們有充分的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/837.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召的面部表情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/838.wav", + "text": "管理要訓練一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/839.wav", + "text": "謝謝你發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/840.wav", + "text": "接下來請國民黨傅崐萁總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/841.wav", + "text": "今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/842.wav", + "text": "真的辛苦你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/843.wav", + "text": "也委屈你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/844.wav", + "text": "了在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/845.wav", + "text": "說長也不長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/846.wav", + "text": "看了二十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/847.wav", + "text": "從來沒有像今天這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/848.wav", + "text": "民進黨男性的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/849.wav", + "text": "去攻擊在野黨女性的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/850.wav", + "text": "還大言不慚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/851.wav", + "text": "指鹿為馬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/852.wav", + "text": "我們七十多歲的秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/853.wav", + "text": "還被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/854.wav", + "text": "民進黨的立委攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/855.wav", + "text": "如果立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/856.wav", + "text": "變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/857.wav", + "text": "民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/858.wav", + "text": "院長很抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/859.wav", + "text": "你也有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/860.wav", + "text": "為什麼可以這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/861.wav", + "text": "要講警察權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/862.wav", + "text": "民進黨的太后來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/863.wav", + "text": "不得了陳菊要來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/864.wav", + "text": "這麼多的警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/865.wav", + "text": "他們的太后來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/866.wav", + "text": "我們需要用這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/867.wav", + "text": "那本院自己的院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/868.wav", + "text": "到現在為止還在吞忍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/869.wav", + "text": "為什麼連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/870.wav", + "text": "院長一個國會議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/871.wav", + "text": "該擁有的人身安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/872.wav", + "text": "都要放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/873.wav", + "text": "剛剛竟然民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/874.wav", + "text": "以流氓的行徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/875.wav", + "text": "把院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/876.wav", + "text": "禁錮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/877.wav", + "text": "在院長室裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/878.wav", + "text": "還不得開門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/879.wav", + "text": "柯建銘還當眾威脅你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/880.wav", + "text": "你出去只能宣布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/881.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/882.wav", + "text": "還要確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/883.wav", + "text": "約定好才能讓你出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/884.wav", + "text": "我們實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/885.wav", + "text": "無法想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/886.wav", + "text": "我們實在無法想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/887.wav", + "text": "院長可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/888.wav", + "text": "立法院被禁錮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/889.wav", + "text": "本席剛剛打電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/890.wav", + "text": "是請他們去通知警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/891.wav", + "text": "說院長被禁錮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/892.wav", + "text": "了在國會裡面被禁錮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/893.wav", + "text": "可以這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/894.wav", + "text": "這是報警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/895.wav", + "text": "院長可以被禁錮嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/896.wav", + "text": "那所有的立委以後怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/897.wav", + "text": "誰來保護立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/898.wav", + "text": "我們外面都是民進黨的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/899.wav", + "text": "要出來不能出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/900.wav", + "text": "我也是被害人之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/901.wav", + "text": "我覺得院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/902.wav", + "text": "如果再這麼放軟的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/903.wav", + "text": "國會永無寧日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/904.wav", + "text": "可以這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/905.wav", + "text": "可以這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/906.wav", + "text": "\n可以這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/907.wav", + "text": "民進黨可以禁錮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/908.wav", + "text": "國會的議長嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/909.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/910.wav", + "text": "暴力犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/911.wav", + "text": "今天是國會最黑暗的一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/912.wav", + "text": "立法院從來沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/913.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/914.wav", + "text": "被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/915.wav", + "text": "幫派式的流氓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/916.wav", + "text": "禁錮在國會裡面的房間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/917.wav", + "text": "不讓他出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/918.wav", + "text": "還要講好條件才能出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/919.wav", + "text": "同時在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/920.wav", + "text": "總召書記長也被禁錮在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/921.wav", + "text": "我是打電話要他去報警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/922.wav", + "text": "姑息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/923.wav", + "text": "不會讓國會成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/924.wav", + "text": "民進黨第三度執政還用這種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/925.wav", + "text": "這是民主的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/926.wav", + "text": "耶可以用這個方式嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/927.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/928.wav", + "text": "你真的要堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/929.wav", + "text": "你今天要對全體國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/930.wav", + "text": "不能開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/931.wav", + "text": "我們為什麼不能開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/932.wav", + "text": "為什麼你主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/933.wav", + "text": "議事他們就要暴力相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/934.wav", + "text": "為什麼是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/935.wav", + "text": "拜託院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/936.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/937.wav", + "text": "有沒有要發言的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/938.wav", + "text": "其實在整個協商的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/939.wav", + "text": "我一直試圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/940.wav", + "text": "守著一個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/941.wav", + "text": "就是不太針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/942.wav", + "text": "我們現在在程序上面討論的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/943.wav", + "text": "說太多的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/944.wav", + "text": "但是我剛才也一直在思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/945.wav", + "text": "當有人指名道姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/946.wav", + "text": "在對你進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/947.wav", + "text": "潑糞的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/948.wav", + "text": "坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/949.wav", + "text": "要忍受到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/950.wav", + "text": "譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/951.wav", + "text": "柯建銘說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/952.wav", + "text": "2016年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/953.wav", + "text": "我人不在立法院嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/954.wav", + "text": "我所有的版本都寫出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/955.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/956.wav", + "text": "那個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/957.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/958.wav", + "text": "可以請你制止他發言嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/959.wav", + "text": "\n好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/960.wav", + "text": "但是過半的是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/961.wav", + "text": "召委也是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/962.wav", + "text": "啊不排案就是不排案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/963.wav", + "text": "\n只處理完最" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/964.wav", + "text": "只處理完最" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/965.wav", + "text": "就是IVOD啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/966.wav", + "text": "調查權的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/967.wav", + "text": "人事同意權的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/968.wav", + "text": "有處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/969.wav", + "text": "他們那個時候沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/970.wav", + "text": "是要想清楚不敢修調查權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/971.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/972.wav", + "text": "我聽不懂啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/973.wav", + "text": "那請教一下蔡英文總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/974.wav", + "text": "他也是沒有想清楚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/975.wav", + "text": "所以提出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/976.wav", + "text": "這樣國會改革的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/977.wav", + "text": "這樣國會改革的政見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/978.wav", + "text": "這樣國會改革的承諾嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/979.wav", + "text": "當初蔡英文總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/980.wav", + "text": "提出這個國會改革的政見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/981.wav", + "text": "柯建銘不是複製貼上到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/982.wav", + "text": "自己的臉書上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/983.wav", + "text": "他又把他提成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/984.wav", + "text": "他當年選舉時的政見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/985.wav", + "text": "\n可是奇怪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/986.wav", + "text": "怎麼拿到權力了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/987.wav", + "text": "國會過半了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/988.wav", + "text": "真的可以修了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/989.wav", + "text": "發現什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/990.wav", + "text": "發現要強化國會的調查權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/991.wav", + "text": "國會的監督權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/992.wav", + "text": "自己執政會不方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/993.wav", + "text": "就不處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/994.wav", + "text": "就是這麼回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/995.wav", + "text": "一個掌握過半席次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/996.wav", + "text": "掌握權力的政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/997.wav", + "text": "背棄了選舉的承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/998.wav", + "text": "結果現在責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/999.wav", + "text": "要推給其他的在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1000.wav", + "text": "真的令人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1001.wav", + "text": "大開眼界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1002.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1003.wav", + "text": "說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1004.wav", + "text": "委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1005.wav", + "text": "協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1006.wav", + "text": "蹺課的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1007.wav", + "text": "請大家回去看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1008.wav", + "text": "那一天在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1009.wav", + "text": "協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1010.wav", + "text": "具體發生的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1011.wav", + "text": "我舉一個最簡單的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1012.wav", + "text": "我們處理到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1013.wav", + "text": "翁曉玲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1014.wav", + "text": "所提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1015.wav", + "text": "針對總統的緊急命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1016.wav", + "text": "從現行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1017.wav", + "text": "不記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1018.wav", + "text": "改成記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1019.wav", + "text": "結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1020.wav", + "text": "號稱所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1021.wav", + "text": "最好的準備的民進黨立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1022.wav", + "text": "看著那個對照的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1023.wav", + "text": "說欸這到底改在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1024.wav", + "text": "我為什麼看不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1025.wav", + "text": "\n令我瞠目結舌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1026.wav", + "text": "啊你連對照條文都沒看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1027.wav", + "text": "就來參與協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1028.wav", + "text": "然後在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1029.wav", + "text": "誇誇而談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1030.wav", + "text": "說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1031.wav", + "text": "這個條文差別在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1032.wav", + "text": "不是寫得一樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1033.wav", + "text": "我當場是瞠目結舌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1034.wav", + "text": "啊不敢置信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1035.wav", + "text": "啊來參與協商的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1036.wav", + "text": "連人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1037.wav", + "text": "提了什麼修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1038.wav", + "text": "都看不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1039.wav", + "text": "然後坐在那邊協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1040.wav", + "text": "說自己準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1041.wav", + "text": "\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1042.wav", + "text": "又把責任推給說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1043.wav", + "text": "提案的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1044.wav", + "text": "為什麼不來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1045.wav", + "text": "每一份法律提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1046.wav", + "text": "在你提出法律條文的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1047.wav", + "text": "後面有個欄位叫修正理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1048.wav", + "text": "任何有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1049.wav", + "text": "基本法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1050.wav", + "text": "素養的人都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1051.wav", + "text": "你看條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1052.wav", + "text": "要看修正理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1053.wav", + "text": "如果你條文看不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1054.wav", + "text": "不懂的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1055.wav", + "text": "就好好的去看修正理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1056.wav", + "text": "結果呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1057.wav", + "text": "在條文哪裡不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1058.wav", + "text": "看不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1059.wav", + "text": "在那邊東問西問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1060.wav", + "text": "立法意旨到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1061.wav", + "text": "其實明眼人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1062.wav", + "text": "一起回去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1063.wav", + "text": "那一天整個IVOD的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1064.wav", + "text": "看民主進步黨的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1065.wav", + "text": "在司法及法制委員會協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1066.wav", + "text": "到底是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1067.wav", + "text": "故意拖延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1068.wav", + "text": "討論條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1069.wav", + "text": "大家只要看了那個協商的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1070.wav", + "text": "我相信每一個人心裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1071.wav", + "text": "都有一把尺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1072.wav", + "text": "\n至於說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1073.wav", + "text": "我協商蹺課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1074.wav", + "text": "對不起喔我無法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1075.wav", + "text": "那天實際上面的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1076.wav", + "text": "大家可以去問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1077.wav", + "text": "吳宗憲召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1078.wav", + "text": "我忠實的還原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1079.wav", + "text": "因為當他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1080.wav", + "text": "正用漫無止境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1081.wav", + "text": "毫無意義的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1082.wav", + "text": "在拖延的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1083.wav", + "text": "當那兩個條文到底哪裡不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1084.wav", + "text": "看不出來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1085.wav", + "text": "然後一個簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1086.wav", + "text": "由無記名投票改成記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1087.wav", + "text": "可以東拉西扯扯一堆的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1088.wav", + "text": "我知道他們是來拖延時間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1089.wav", + "text": "但我在隔壁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1090.wav", + "text": "內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1091.wav", + "text": "輪到我質詢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1092.wav", + "text": "所以我往前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1093.wav", + "text": "告訴吳宗憲召委說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1094.wav", + "text": "我等一下旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1095.wav", + "text": "內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1096.wav", + "text": "我要質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1097.wav", + "text": "我就過去質詢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1098.wav", + "text": "等到我質詢完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1099.wav", + "text": "召委宣布協商結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1100.wav", + "text": "我也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1101.wav", + "text": "我沒有其他的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1102.wav", + "text": "因為實際參與過那個協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1103.wav", + "text": "我很清楚地知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1104.wav", + "text": "我很清楚地知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1105.wav", + "text": "那個協商是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1106.wav", + "text": "不會有任何結論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1107.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1108.wav", + "text": "如果當你從無記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1109.wav", + "text": "改成記名投票的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1110.wav", + "text": "都可以東扯西扯扯一堆的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1111.wav", + "text": "我們可以形成一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1112.wav", + "text": "非常清楚的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1113.wav", + "text": "不會有任何結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1114.wav", + "text": "\n不好意思院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1115.wav", + "text": "這是我非常少數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1116.wav", + "text": "針對你所垂詢的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1117.wav", + "text": "講了這麼久的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1118.wav", + "text": "但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1119.wav", + "text": "我要呼籲的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1120.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1121.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1122.wav", + "text": "院長您所提出來的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1123.wav", + "text": "大家要大體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1124.wav", + "text": "要逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1125.wav", + "text": "各政黨推派代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1126.wav", + "text": "我們都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1127.wav", + "text": "就變成了是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1128.wav", + "text": "就變成了是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1129.wav", + "text": "那到底民主進步黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1130.wav", + "text": "要不要面對國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1131.wav", + "text": "要不要處理立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1132.wav", + "text": "我相信他們有任何的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1133.wav", + "text": "說要喊什麼毀憲亂政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1134.wav", + "text": "甚至柯建銘總召說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1135.wav", + "text": "他要開國際記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1136.wav", + "text": "要不要開國際記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1137.wav", + "text": "是柯建銘總召的自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1138.wav", + "text": "我沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1139.wav", + "text": "我只是要提醒的是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1140.wav", + "text": "從美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1141.wav", + "text": "到英國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1142.wav", + "text": "到法國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1143.wav", + "text": "到德國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1144.wav", + "text": "有哪一個國家的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1145.wav", + "text": "行政官員在國會裡面說謊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1146.wav", + "text": "是不用承擔法律責任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1147.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1148.wav", + "text": "對於國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1149.wav", + "text": "聽證調查制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1150.wav", + "text": "有基本涉獵的人都知道答案是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1151.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1152.wav", + "text": "請莊瑞雄幹事長發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1153.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1154.wav", + "text": "院長還有各位協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1155.wav", + "text": "我對黃國昌委員剛剛的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1156.wav", + "text": "這個我就不同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1157.wav", + "text": "在我們整個國會職權行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1158.wav", + "text": "大家這樣在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1159.wav", + "text": "也未必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1160.wav", + "text": "就像你講的說這個叫做拖延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1161.wav", + "text": "冗長的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1162.wav", + "text": "各個政黨都會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1163.wav", + "text": "每一個人都有議事程序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1164.wav", + "text": "看你要做什麼樣的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1165.wav", + "text": "這個只要按照整個議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1166.wav", + "text": "大家尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1167.wav", + "text": "愛講多久以我的話常常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1168.wav", + "text": "不是講最多的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1169.wav", + "text": "可是我必須要指出來就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1170.wav", + "text": "如何來面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1171.wav", + "text": "我大膽的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1172.wav", + "text": "很真實的講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1173.wav", + "text": "當年在第9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1174.wav", + "text": "我就跟顧立雄兩個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1175.wav", + "text": "共同提出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1176.wav", + "text": "我們提出版本以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1177.wav", + "text": "連我們黨內都有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1178.wav", + "text": "所以從這次條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1179.wav", + "text": "送進來以後我一直在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1180.wav", + "text": "強調的就是這個射程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1181.wav", + "text": "到底有多廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1182.wav", + "text": "難道這個不應該討論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1183.wav", + "text": "我一直講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1184.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1185.wav", + "text": "國會調查權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1186.wav", + "text": "聽證跟調查是輔助立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1187.wav", + "text": "讓人民知道真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1188.wav", + "text": "這是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1189.wav", + "text": "但問題是你那個射程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1190.wav", + "text": "朝野協商的時候我就講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1191.wav", + "text": "也就是我們不斷地這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1192.wav", + "text": "國民黨你現在提出來修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1193.wav", + "text": "啊你的版本已經修正了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1194.wav", + "text": "所以第一個我要回應黃國昌委員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1195.wav", + "text": "\n第二個在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1196.wav", + "text": "在這個朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1197.wav", + "text": "大家都會有脾氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1198.wav", + "text": "我看連傅崐萁對院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1199.wav", + "text": "我聽起來也不舒服啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1200.wav", + "text": "但他會認為不是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1201.wav", + "text": "他認為他只是很嚴肅而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1202.wav", + "text": "那個過程要講也不要胡說八道嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1203.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召他是來去自如啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1204.wav", + "text": "我也在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1205.wav", + "text": "如果是禁錮的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1206.wav", + "text": "民進黨禁錮韓國瑜院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1207.wav", + "text": "那不是把柯建銘把吳思瑤把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1208.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄我們一起都禁錮在裡面了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1209.wav", + "text": "你不要來這套啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1210.wav", + "text": "為什麼國民黨一直在講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1211.wav", + "text": "這個引起暴力衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1212.wav", + "text": "秘書長好像有所不敬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1213.wav", + "text": "媒體甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1214.wav", + "text": "誇張到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1215.wav", + "text": "郭國文把他給打趴了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1216.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1217.wav", + "text": "源頭在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1218.wav", + "text": "源頭就是你今天霸占了主席臺啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1219.wav", + "text": "最好笑的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1220.wav", + "text": "國民黨你霸占了主席臺以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1221.wav", + "text": "喊著說不要暴力要開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1222.wav", + "text": "少來這一套啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1223.wav", + "text": "我要問你的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1224.wav", + "text": "現在是我發言的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1225.wav", + "text": "我發言的時間不用幫我上字幕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1226.wav", + "text": "那一張請收下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1227.wav", + "text": "我要說的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1228.wav", + "text": "這麼多年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1229.wav", + "text": "議事攻防大家都會啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1230.wav", + "text": "朝野協商本來就是吵吵鬧鬧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1231.wav", + "text": "朝野協商從來就不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1232.wav", + "text": "來這邊拍手的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1233.wav", + "text": "不會啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1234.wav", + "text": "當立法委員我聽你們在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1235.wav", + "text": "我也覺得你們都亂講啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1236.wav", + "text": "立法委員哪有什麼行政可以行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1237.wav", + "text": "我們就依法來行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1238.wav", + "text": "我們的職權我倒聽得下去啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1239.wav", + "text": "我要講的是程序如果都對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1240.wav", + "text": "表決輸了民進黨認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1241.wav", + "text": "了你們剛剛一直提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1242.wav", + "text": "國會改革協商的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1243.wav", + "text": "好像民進黨都吵吵鬧鬧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1244.wav", + "text": "是啊是吵吵鬧鬧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1245.wav", + "text": "但你們要去追根究底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1246.wav", + "text": "為什麼會吵吵鬧鬧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1247.wav", + "text": "就會有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1248.wav", + "text": "提出來這幾部法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1249.wav", + "text": "你去看嘛你們講的就是5月8號召集的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1250.wav", + "text": "朝野協商真的就只有四條而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1251.wav", + "text": "你如果走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1252.wav", + "text": "讓民進黨提出不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1253.wav", + "text": "提出了以後你說保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1254.wav", + "text": "我沒意見喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1255.wav", + "text": "有討論了你保留意見沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1256.wav", + "text": "那到最後來議場裡面表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1257.wav", + "text": "輸了我吞喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1258.wav", + "text": "但現在不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1259.wav", + "text": "你們一直在講說為什麼提了那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1260.wav", + "text": "的散會動議很簡單啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1261.wav", + "text": "為什麼會提出散會動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1262.wav", + "text": "你們就不讓人家討論啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1263.wav", + "text": "你們每一條都要保留我們只好提出散會動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1264.wav", + "text": "講話要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1265.wav", + "text": "我們真的是有提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1266.wav", + "text": "散會動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1267.wav", + "text": "但是你要講原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1268.wav", + "text": "因為你們根本就不想討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1269.wav", + "text": "人數是多數人多當然到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1270.wav", + "text": "是數人頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1271.wav", + "text": "我的結論也是數人頭啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1272.wav", + "text": "表決輸你我就輸你嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1273.wav", + "text": "但程序你本來就是要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1274.wav", + "text": "踐行啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1275.wav", + "text": "\n我來請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1276.wav", + "text": "林思銘委員你剛剛一直講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1277.wav", + "text": "你們民進黨不是都講過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1278.wav", + "text": "那個叫大體討論啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1279.wav", + "text": "啦大家一條一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1280.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒意見這叫有共識如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1281.wav", + "text": "大家有意見難道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1282.wav", + "text": "民進黨不能有反對意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1283.wav", + "text": "我不能反對你的國會調查權的射程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1284.wav", + "text": "或者是那個範圍處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1285.wav", + "text": "到底是到行政部門就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1286.wav", + "text": "官員就好還是人民我不能有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1287.wav", + "text": "就是因為我有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1288.wav", + "text": "到最後國民黨你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1289.wav", + "text": "的版本也去做修訂了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1290.wav", + "text": "你讓大家都說那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1291.wav", + "text": "我很少說這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1292.wav", + "text": "我也知道你們要藉著周萬來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1293.wav", + "text": "秘書長這件事情又要把民進黨給醜化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1294.wav", + "text": "源頭在什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1295.wav", + "text": "源頭就在今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1296.wav", + "text": "大家的議事���爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1297.wav", + "text": "占領了全部都是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1298.wav", + "text": "跟民眾黨在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1299.wav", + "text": "民進黨就跟你在這邊一直表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1300.wav", + "text": "然後我們輸是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1301.wav", + "text": "你們會服氣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1302.wav", + "text": "民進黨多數的時候這樣做你們也不會服氣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1303.wav", + "text": "民進黨多數的時候在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1304.wav", + "text": "你們不是也一直在爆發衝突嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1305.wav", + "text": "朝野協商到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1306.wav", + "text": "大家都會變成是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1307.wav", + "text": "對於事情不同的看法而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1308.wav", + "text": "我不敢跟你說院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1309.wav", + "text": "我一點都不覺得悲傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1310.wav", + "text": "這幾年來都是這樣要悲傷什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1311.wav", + "text": "不要裝了啦等一下出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1312.wav", + "text": "大家還不是笑嘻嘻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1313.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1314.wav", + "text": "我知道現在都已經二輪發言完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1315.wav", + "text": "沒關係沒關係等一下會讓大家發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1316.wav", + "text": "綜合上面今天兩場的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1317.wav", + "text": "再擴大一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1318.wav", + "text": "有關討論事項法案的程序部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1319.wav", + "text": "剛才建議發言的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1320.wav", + "text": "我想國民黨民眾黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1321.wav", + "text": "他們是支持但是民進黨團對此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1322.wav", + "text": "沒有任何表態甚至反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1323.wav", + "text": "派多一點的委員來發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1324.wav", + "text": "如一至三位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1325.wav", + "text": "國民黨跟民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1326.wav", + "text": "正式表達支持這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1327.wav", + "text": "民進黨沒有表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1328.wav", + "text": "沒關係還有第二點你等一下會發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1329.wav", + "text": "我們各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1330.wav", + "text": "派請一位委員來發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1331.wav", + "text": "發言後我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1332.wav", + "text": "依送案先後依序進行各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1333.wav", + "text": "版本條文的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1334.wav", + "text": "逐條的時候我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1335.wav", + "text": "宣讀條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1336.wav", + "text": "我的初步建議就是宣讀黨團版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1337.wav", + "text": "其餘的我們就列入公報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1338.wav", + "text": "\n第三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1339.wav", + "text": "也很重要今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1340.wav", + "text": "院會的時間是到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1341.wav", + "text": "下午6點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1342.wav", + "text": "如果我們溝通沒有一致的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1343.wav", + "text": "我們沒有辦法處理時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1344.wav", + "text": "必須下星期二早上9點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1345.wav", + "text": "繼續開會所以我特別要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1346.wav", + "text": "因為現在已經是4點33分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1347.wav", + "text": "要負責跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1348.wav", + "text": "不要急啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1349.wav", + "text": "柯建銘總召請發言黃國昌總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1350.wav", + "text": "召你剛才有舉手對不對請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1351.wav", + "text": "今天我看黃國昌活起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1352.wav", + "text": "了可以針對條文內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1353.wav", + "text": "來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1354.wav", + "text": "他剛才一直說指鹿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1355.wav", + "text": "根本是違法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1356.wav", + "text": "嘛今天我看黃國昌開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1357.wav", + "text": "有一些回應了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1358.wav", + "text": "神也亮起來不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1359.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1360.wav", + "text": "院長針對你剛才的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1361.wav", + "text": "我覺得你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1362.wav", + "text": "說的結論到最後一個結論是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1363.wav", + "text": "可以的很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1364.wav", + "text": "這個氣氛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1365.wav", + "text": "嗎你要略過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1366.wav", + "text": "朝野協商這個程序一條一條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1367.wav", + "text": "現在幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1368.wav", + "text": "下禮拜二再來也無所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1369.wav", + "text": "但是我還是堅持一個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1370.wav", + "text": "朝野協商把事情講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1371.wav", + "text": "然後簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1372.wav", + "text": "\n引據最近的一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1373.wav", + "text": "4月30號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1374.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷也坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1375.wav", + "text": "我們那天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1376.wav", + "text": "對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1377.wav", + "text": "決議案的朝野協商那是很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1378.wav", + "text": "一個決議案的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1379.wav", + "text": "與否黃國昌提一個什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1380.wav", + "text": "提一個晶鼎─彰化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1381.wav", + "text": "一個焚化爐的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1382.wav", + "text": "全部還沒講到核心問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1383.wav", + "text": "院長突然站起來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1384.wav", + "text": "在那一刻的時候院長沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1385.wav", + "text": "這一定要先講協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1386.wav", + "text": "通常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1387.wav", + "text": "一個協商結論幾黨發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1388.wav", + "text": "所以那天也沒有講幾個人要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1389.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1390.wav", + "text": "\n我記得第一次朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1391.wav", + "text": "黃國昌問你說議事人員怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1392.wav", + "text": "馬上做好幾個人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1393.wav", + "text": "所以這個程序後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1394.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷也跑到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1395.wav", + "text": "院長室來找我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1396.wav", + "text": "院長也在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1397.wav", + "text": "這怎麼辦沒有簽朝野協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1398.wav", + "text": "我說沒有關係啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1399.wav", + "text": "那我來圓這個局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1400.wav", + "text": "解決這個危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1401.wav", + "text": "那麼一黨1個人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1402.wav", + "text": "3個人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1403.wav", + "text": "那時候是2個人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1404.wav", + "text": "2個人發言怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1405.wav", + "text": "簽了協商結論才去表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1406.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員請你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1407.wav", + "text": "的我不希望在你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1408.wav", + "text": "讓你沒有聽到我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1409.wav", + "text": "對你的問題的談話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1410.wav", + "text": "晶鼎案那個案子就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1411.wav", + "text": "在這裡講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1412.wav", + "text": "所有政府採購或是任何公共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1413.wav", + "text": "都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1414.wav", + "text": "一定照合約來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1415.wav", + "text": "不行的話就要停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1416.wav", + "text": "但是從來沒有說立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1417.wav", + "text": "來表決說這個把它停掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1418.wav", + "text": "那公共工程委員會不必了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1419.wav", + "text": "那採購法也不必了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1420.wav", + "text": "所以我們主張應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1421.wav", + "text": "依合約嚴謹來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1422.wav", + "text": "是誰要賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1423.wav", + "text": "所以假如這樣可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1424.wav", + "text": "立法院立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1425.wav", + "text": "可以介入任何公共工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1426.wav", + "text": "的話這個的反面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1427.wav", + "text": "我想你自己很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1428.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1429.wav", + "text": "我絕對會針對你每一個事情去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1430.wav", + "text": "我不會跟你講那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1431.wav", + "text": "坦白講那個版本我們黨團討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1432.wav", + "text": "因為是我領銜提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1433.wav", + "text": "的我坦白跟你講是在2015的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1434.wav", + "text": "提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1435.wav", + "text": "的開放的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1436.wav", + "text": "人民的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1437.wav", + "text": "那時候我在選舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1438.wav", + "text": "我只要開放國會沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1439.wav", + "text": "法很容易改嘛改成直播嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1440.wav", + "text": "轉直播就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1441.wav", + "text": "但是唯一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1442.wav", + "text": "釋字585號國會調查權的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1443.wav", + "text": "我剛才已經說明得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1444.wav", + "text": "當年是我領銜提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1445.wav", + "text": "為319真調會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1446.wav", + "text": "國民黨委託外面的人可以去做調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1447.wav", + "text": "法案通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1448.wav", + "text": "阿扁下令行使抵抗權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1449.wav", + "text": "就是20年前的往事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1450.wav", + "text": "所以那時候是想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1451.wav", + "text": "我們要很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1452.wav", + "text": "國會的調查權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1453.wav", + "text": "是國會調閱權的往前延伸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1454.wav", + "text": "就是大法官325" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1455.wav", + "text": "釋字解釋的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1456.wav", + "text": "所以585的時候不是可以任意調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1457.wav", + "text": "這是我要先說明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1458.wav", + "text": "所以很疑惑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1459.wav", + "text": "後來都沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1460.wav", + "text": "這不是誰的責任問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1461.wav", + "text": "大家共同的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1462.wav", + "text": "\n我要問國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1463.wav", + "text": "國民黨這8年沒有在國會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1464.wav", + "text": "怎麼說民進黨不敢做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1465.wav", + "text": "你們做到的是一些違憲的東西出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1466.wav", + "text": "不能這樣搞法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1467.wav", + "text": "嘛藐視國會罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1468.wav", + "text": "昌剛才講官員說謊不必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1469.wav", + "text": "罰嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1470.wav", + "text": "是刑責還是罰款沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1471.wav", + "text": "這是責任政治的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1472.wav", + "text": "官員說謊當然是這個行政團隊的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1473.wav", + "text": "造成你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1474.wav", + "text": "說謊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1475.wav", + "text": "要不要讓他下台不下台你自己負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1476.wav", + "text": "我說人民就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1477.wav", + "text": "下次選舉把你淘汰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1478.wav", + "text": "全世界沒有這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1479.wav", + "text": "至於什麼叫說謊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1480.wav", + "text": "謊有沒有客觀標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1481.wav", + "text": "所以今天我們要談的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1482.wav", + "text": "國會民主之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1483.wav", + "text": "所以能夠遂行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1484.wav", + "text": "剛才對吳思瑤委員的指責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1485.wav", + "text": "非常不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1486.wav", + "text": "黃國昌請您注意聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1487.wav", + "text": "之所以吳思瑤委員會問說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1488.wav", + "text": "這個緊急命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1489.wav", + "text": "那個關係很重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1490.wav", + "text": "因為委員會沒有討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1491.wav", + "text": "所以他問得很合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1492.wav", + "text": "嘛所以當然假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1493.wav", + "text": "如是委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1494.wav", + "text": "這個問題很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1495.wav", + "text": "看起來好像是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1496.wav", + "text": "記名不記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1497.wav", + "text": "為什麼當初設計要不記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1498.wav", + "text": "那我現在改成記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1499.wav", + "text": "情境的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1500.wav", + "text": "這樣一個記名不記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1501.wav", + "text": "當然要經過討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1502.wav", + "text": "提案委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1503.wav", + "text": "就是委員會從來沒有討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1504.wav", + "text": "所以才有這種情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1505.wav", + "text": "68條總共55個欄位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1506.wav", + "text": "總共68條審3條就下課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1507.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1508.wav", + "text": "就是這樣過水這叫做有充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1509.wav", + "text": "黃珊珊委員你早上有一個發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1510.wav", + "text": "我是覺得可能要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1511.wav", + "text": "你說這些都在媒體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1512.wav", + "text": "媒體討論可以取代國會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1513.wav", + "text": "取代國會嗎不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1514.wav", + "text": "這是政黨政治的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1515.wav", + "text": "所以黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1516.wav", + "text": "當然就是用冗長的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1517.wav", + "text": "小政黨常用這個武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1518.wav", + "text": "用冗長的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1519.wav", + "text": "也許發言一整天但是不能斷電喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1520.wav", + "text": "你一直講一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1521.wav", + "text": "比誰的功力強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1522.wav", + "text": "國會就是要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1523.wav", + "text": "你不能斷喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1524.wav", + "text": "你有能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1525.wav", + "text": "他就一直講一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1526.wav", + "text": "這是民主的可貴啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1527.wav", + "text": "然後有時候都不討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1528.wav", + "text": "沒收起來直接去表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1529.wav", + "text": "今天我還是在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1530.wav", + "text": "非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1531.wav", + "text": "非常嚴正地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1532.wav", + "text": "抗議這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1533.wav", + "text": "美國國會也有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1534.wav", + "text": "叫他上來發言他拖時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1535.wav", + "text": "太空漫步三進三退走來走去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1536.wav", + "text": "搞一整天還在那邊推來推去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1537.wav", + "text": "這個是民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1538.wav", + "text": "但是臺灣沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1539.wav", + "text": "人用到filibuster" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1540.wav", + "text": "在我們當野黨的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1541.wav", + "text": "但是現在立法院不是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1542.wav", + "text": "全部沒收以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1543.wav", + "text": "這國會不會完蛋嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1544.wav", + "text": "\n洪孟楷委員你上次就知道說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1545.wav", + "text": "這要簽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1546.wav", + "text": "不要針對什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1547.wav", + "text": "禁錮什麼禁錮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1548.wav", + "text": "周萬來這個我也不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1549.wav", + "text": "周萬來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1550.wav", + "text": "我們兩個是同年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1551.wav", + "text": "過去我們常常不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1552.wav", + "text": "到目前為止還是不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1553.wav", + "text": "但是我還是維持可以跟你講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1554.wav", + "text": "我會反對你的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1555.wav", + "text": "你既然可以告訴韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1556.wav", + "text": "這個去表決沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1557.wav", + "text": "請你舉出一個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1558.wav", + "text": "這樣我也不會完蛋嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1559.wav", + "text": "哪一個院長敢這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1560.wav", + "text": "沒有一個人嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1561.wav", + "text": "所以我只是在這個地方請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1562.wav", + "text": "的行為我代表黨團跟你抱歉都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1563.wav", + "text": "但大家一起思考這個背後的原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1564.wav", + "text": "所有衝突的原因在什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1565.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們大家會在房間裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1566.wav", + "text": "我一直跟你拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1567.wav", + "text": "再想一想這樣衝突不是辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1568.wav", + "text": "乾脆去宣布散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1569.wav", + "text": "我說好沒有關係我陪你去宣布散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1570.wav", + "text": "休息協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1571.wav", + "text": "我相信你因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1572.wav", + "text": "大家老同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1573.wav", + "text": "你們不至於在這裡騙我一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1574.wav", + "text": "以後給我笑你就頭都抬不起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1575.wav", + "text": "所以大家有互相的信任感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1576.wav", + "text": "今天當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1577.wav", + "text": "最大的問題是朝野沒有信任感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1578.wav", + "text": "也許我們重新要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1579.wav", + "text": "建立一個新夥伴關係的時代開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1580.wav", + "text": "大家恢復理性談判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1581.wav", + "text": "這個是一個國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1582.wav", + "text": "我一直期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1583.wav", + "text": "是一個理性的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1584.wav", + "text": "能夠朝野和諧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1585.wav", + "text": "重新建立一個新的國會文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1586.wav", + "text": "大家互相對立抗爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1587.wav", + "text": "都是真的一個字理字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1588.wav", + "text": "一個理\n而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1589.wav", + "text": "一個憲政理論而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1590.wav", + "text": "沒有任何私心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1591.wav", + "text": "我今天跟傅崐萁總召講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1592.wav", + "text": "但是你罵我我忍受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1593.wav", + "text": "我罵你你忍受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1594.wav", + "text": "因為我們都是為了公的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1595.wav", + "text": "沒有為私人的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1596.wav", + "text": "情但是不要太超過就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1597.wav", + "text": "我都忍受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1598.wav", + "text": "你罵我什麼瘋人院糟老頭晚上不睡覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1599.wav", + "text": "算了算了你愛罵就自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1600.wav", + "text": "罵個痛快也好沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1601.wav", + "text": "但是我要跟你爭的是一個道理而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1602.wav", + "text": "這是我們之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1603.wav", + "text": "一個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1604.wav", + "text": "明天520馬上就到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1605.wav", + "text": "520難道我們這個國會在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1606.wav", + "text": "這樣演給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1607.wav", + "text": "外賓這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1608.wav", + "text": "大家冷靜下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1609.wav", + "text": "時間還很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1610.wav", + "text": "你如果要表決沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1611.wav", + "text": "大家來協商協商說輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1612.wav", + "text": "講到沒辦法講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1613.wav", + "text": "表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1614.wav", + "text": "絕對輸4年都會輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1615.wav", + "text": "但是大家照步來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1616.wav", + "text": "接下來我們洪孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1617.wav", + "text": "感謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1618.wav", + "text": "現在各黨團都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1619.wav", + "text": "有4位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1620.wav", + "text": "等一下還有民眾黨團要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1621.wav", + "text": "我想大家已經很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1622.wav", + "text": "協商的結論也已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1623.wav", + "text": "漸縮了我們再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1624.wav", + "text": "國民黨團同意剛剛院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1625.wav", + "text": "講的就是黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1626.wav", + "text": "代表大體討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1627.wav", + "text": "1至3位發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1628.wav", + "text": "逐條討論的時候1位發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1629.wav", + "text": "但是國民黨團沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1630.wav", + "text": "同意的是今天院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1631.wav", + "text": "只開到6點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1632.wav", + "text": "因為既然等一下院會要持續進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1633.wav", + "text": "今天已經被民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1634.wav", + "text": "用衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1635.wav", + "text": "杯葛阻撓議事的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1636.wav", + "text": "本來早上10點鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1637.wav", + "text": "就可以開始的議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1638.wav", + "text": "到現在下午4點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1639.wav", + "text": "46分了還沒有辦法開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1640.wav", + "text": "而讓院長召開了3次朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1641.wav", + "text": "我想民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1642.wav", + "text": "用這樣拖延的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1643.wav", + "text": "我們沒有辦法認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1644.wav", + "text": "如果說現在國人都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1645.wav", + "text": "只要民進黨他們不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1646.wav", + "text": "不想要面對的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1647.wav", + "text": "過去承諾的不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1648.wav", + "text": "溝通的不願意協調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1649.wav", + "text": "不願意討論的或是說覺得不滿意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1650.wav", + "text": "他們就可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1651.wav", + "text": "議事杯葛的方式用拖延時間的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1652.wav", + "text": "就讓院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1653.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法開會下去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1654.wav", + "text": "這不是新民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1655.wav", + "text": "我相信這也不是在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1656.wav", + "text": "擔任過4屆賴清德前立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1657.wav", + "text": "想要看到的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1658.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1659.wav", + "text": "國民黨團沒有辦法同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1660.wav", + "text": "院長剛剛講的到6點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1661.wav", + "text": "我們希望今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1662.wav", + "text": "院會能夠處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1663.wav", + "text": "挑燈夜戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1664.wav", + "text": "討論事項第一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1665.wav", + "text": "就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1666.wav", + "text": "我們真的聽不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1667.wav", + "text": "到底民進黨團還是沒有正面回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1668.wav", + "text": "立法院到底是比人頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1669.wav", + "text": "還是比拳頭的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1670.wav", + "text": "立法院是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1671.wav", + "text": "只要你不同意我的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1672.wav", + "text": "你就可以恣意攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1673.wav", + "text": "任意妄為嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1674.wav", + "text": "如果真是這樣的話所以今天才會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1675.wav", + "text": "男委員打女委員男委員抱女委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1676.wav", + "text": "年輕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1677.wav", + "text": "郭國文委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1678.wav", + "text": "來對72歲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1679.wav", + "text": "秘書長用搶奪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1680.wav", + "text": "用壓制的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1681.wav", + "text": "把院長的行動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1682.wav", + "text": "這就是民進黨團認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1683.wav", + "text": "只要不滿你的意什麼都可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1684.wav", + "text": "我們等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1685.wav", + "text": "還是再一次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1686.wav", + "text": "520即將到來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1687.wav", + "text": "即便我們之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1688.wav", + "text": "有說不出席總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1689.wav", + "text": "的就職典禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1690.wav", + "text": "但我們由衷地祝福" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1691.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統就職典禮順利圓滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1692.wav", + "text": "我們也希望中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1693.wav", + "text": "國泰民安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1694.wav", + "text": "這是我不管是當立委之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1695.wav", + "text": "或是到現在或是有一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1696.wav", + "text": "我也會卸下立委的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1697.wav", + "text": "我都是這樣的中心思想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1698.wav", + "text": "但是520的前夕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1699.wav", + "text": "如果說在今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1700.wav", + "text": "2024年的5月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1701.wav", + "text": "民進黨團要留下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1702.wav", + "text": "國會史上最嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1703.wav", + "text": "暴力肢體衝突的畫面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1704.wav", + "text": "之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1705.wav", + "text": "在野黨都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1706.wav", + "text": "占過主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1707.wav", + "text": "但是我們都有讓議事進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1708.wav", + "text": "並且我們從來沒有先動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1709.wav", + "text": "我們等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1710.wav", + "text": "要開會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1711.wav", + "text": "我們也絕對不會先動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1712.wav", + "text": "誰先動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1713.wav", + "text": "誰理虧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1714.wav", + "text": "誰先動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1715.wav", + "text": "誰負最大責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1716.wav", + "text": "誰先動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1717.wav", + "text": "我們合理懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1718.wav", + "text": "這就是執政的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1719.wav", + "text": "民進黨要做的議事杯葛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1720.wav", + "text": "請執政的民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1721.wav", + "text": "負起完全的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1722.wav", + "text": "我會限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1723.wav", + "text": "剛剛院長最後裁示的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1724.wav", + "text": "剛剛院長有表示說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1725.wav", + "text": "是不是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1726.wav", + "text": "我忘了院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1727.wav", + "text": "剛剛好像是說到五點半還是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1728.wav", + "text": "如果我時間有記錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1729.wav", + "text": "請院長見諒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1730.wav", + "text": "但我們對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1731.wav", + "text": "今天只處理到6點的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1732.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1733.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1734.wav", + "text": "我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1735.wav", + "text": "已經正式書面提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1736.wav", + "text": "希望我們今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1737.wav", + "text": "議事能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1738.wav", + "text": "到討論事項前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1739.wav", + "text": "3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1740.wav", + "text": "也就是國會改革的核心條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1741.wav", + "text": "到處理完畢為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1742.wav", + "text": "這個程序的動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1743.wav", + "text": "我們已經正式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1744.wav", + "text": "提交給議事處了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1745.wav", + "text": "院長能夠尊重台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1746.wav", + "text": "這邊的提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1747.wav", + "text": "我們就依照議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1748.wav", + "text": "來加以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1749.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1750.wav", + "text": "現在每一個黨團都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1751.wav", + "text": "我有議事程序的問題要詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1752.wav", + "text": "就是對於剛剛幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1753.wav", + "text": "試圖的宣告但它還不是結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1754.wav", + "text": "我想要再表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1755.wav", + "text": "第一個相較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1756.wav", + "text": "於您早上上一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1757.wav", + "text": "協商時試圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1758.wav", + "text": "說服大家同意的那個宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1759.wav", + "text": "其實有微調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1760.wav", + "text": "但是我要說一下在發言人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1761.wav", + "text": "的部分您是更限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1762.wav", + "text": "這個我們不能同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1763.wav", + "text": "本來大體討論是說各黨3個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1764.wav", + "text": "您現在說1至3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1765.wav", + "text": "人這是更限縮我們更不能同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1766.wav", + "text": "但是上一次是講3人\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1767.wav", + "text": "更重要的事情是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1768.wav", + "text": "我們整個協商已經被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1769.wav", + "text": "快轉跳過根本沒有進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1770.wav", + "text": "剛剛您宣告說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1771.wav", + "text": "不宣讀提案條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1772.wav", + "text": "萬萬不可院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1773.wav", + "text": "依據立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1774.wav", + "text": "第9條第二讀會的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1775.wav", + "text": "應將議案朗讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1776.wav", + "text": "依次或逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1777.wav", + "text": "提付討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1778.wav", + "text": "我們不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1779.wav", + "text": "在委員會沒有討論條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1780.wav", + "text": "在二三讀會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1781.wav", + "text": "連條文都不宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1782.wav", + "text": "誰知道在通過什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1783.wav", + "text": "條文啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1784.wav", + "text": "所以議案一定要宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1785.wav", + "text": "這是程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1786.wav", + "text": "不能再跳過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1787.wav", + "text": "而且議案不只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1788.wav", + "text": "要宣讀也不能選擇性的宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1789.wav", + "text": "剛剛院長您說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1790.wav", + "text": "只宣讀黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1791.wav", + "text": "不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1792.wav", + "text": "每一個立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1793.wav", + "text": "都有提案權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1794.wav", + "text": "每一個委員的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1795.wav", + "text": "都應當依立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1796.wav", + "text": "職權行使法第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1797.wav", + "text": "該宣讀就宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1798.wav", + "text": "這就是現在這一屆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1799.wav", + "text": "立法院讓我們覺得很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1800.wav", + "text": "難以接受的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1801.wav", + "text": "什麼程序都要跳過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1802.wav", + "text": "什麼程序都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1803.wav", + "text": "便宜行事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1804.wav", + "text": "連宣讀議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1805.wav", + "text": "最基本的ABC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1806.wav", + "text": "都脅迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1807.wav", + "text": "議事人員或是院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1808.wav", + "text": "作成這種違法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1809.wav", + "text": "不可容忍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1810.wav", + "text": "從來沒有看過立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1811.wav", + "text": "強行表決一個沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1812.wav", + "text": "逐條討論的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1813.wav", + "text": "沒有逐條討論的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1814.wav", + "text": "現在要強行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1815.wav", + "text": "碾壓表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1816.wav", + "text": "連議案的宣讀都可以不要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1817.wav", + "text": "我們哪知道你宣讀過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1818.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1819.wav", + "text": "啊這讓我覺得非常地氣憤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1820.wav", + "text": "任何的鄉鎮市民代表會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1821.wav", + "text": "縣市議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1822.wav", + "text": "乃至於國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1823.wav", + "text": "地方到中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1824.wav", + "text": "絕對不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1825.wav", + "text": "進行不宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1826.wav", + "text": "條文就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1827.wav", + "text": "就討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1828.wav", + "text": "\n最後一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1829.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1830.wav", + "text": "講到我當事人我一定要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1831.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員不要再胡說八道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1832.wav", + "text": "5月8號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1833.wav", + "text": "吳宗憲召委所主持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1834.wav", + "text": "黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1835.wav", + "text": "進行職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1836.wav", + "text": "有關於翁曉玲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1837.wav", + "text": "對於總統發布緊急命令時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1838.wav", + "text": "要記名或無記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1839.wav", + "text": "這件事情我們是認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1840.wav", + "text": "嚴肅地在討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1841.wav", + "text": "因為提案委員必須說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1842.wav", + "text": "為什麼記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1843.wav", + "text": "有記名的理由不記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1844.wav", + "text": "有不記名的理由我還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1845.wav", + "text": "場非常專業地提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1846.wav", + "text": "中華民國行憲以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1847.wav", + "text": "上一次緊急命令在李登輝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1848.wav", + "text": "總統的任內針對921" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1849.wav", + "text": "震災發布的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1850.wav", + "text": "我還針對緊急命令過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1851.wav", + "text": "到現在的歷史經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1852.wav", + "text": "進行分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1853.wav", + "text": "不要只會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1854.wav", + "text": "帶風向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1855.wav", + "text": "騙小草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1856.wav", + "text": "我們專業問政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1857.wav", + "text": "昨天在院長主持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1858.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1859.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤莊瑞雄柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1860.wav", + "text": "我們扛了五十多公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1861.wav", + "text": "的交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1862.wav", + "text": "專業評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1863.wav", + "text": "包括蘇花改蘇花安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1864.wav", + "text": "包括西部高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1865.wav", + "text": "五十多公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1866.wav", + "text": "的資料因為我們都專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1867.wav", + "text": "嚴肅地在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1868.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1869.wav", + "text": "在立法院不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1870.wav", + "text": "比拳頭當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1871.wav", + "text": "也不是只比人頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1872.wav", + "text": "在立法院要比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1873.wav", + "text": "專業比良知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1874.wav", + "text": "如此而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1875.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1876.wav", + "text": "剛剛那個初步建議是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1877.wav", + "text": "我徵詢各位的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1878.wav", + "text": "宣讀黨團版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1879.wav", + "text": "我希望吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1880.wav", + "text": "不要過度地把我講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1881.wav", + "text": "這個宣告過度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1882.wav", + "text": "偏差跟扭曲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1883.wav", + "text": "\n我們現在就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15928/1884.wav", + "text": "再回到議事廳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/0.wav", + "text": "因為目前報告事項處理完畢後續是處理變更議程討論事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1.wav", + "text": "今天早上九點鐘以後我到院長室跟院長談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/2.wav", + "text": "我想昨天也是跟你談一樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/3.wav", + "text": "我一直在呼籲在臉書上一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/4.wav", + "text": "就是說臺灣的民主能夠發展到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/5.wav", + "text": "三十年來我們都走過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/6.wav", + "text": "你有幸當院長我有幸見證整個民主的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/7.wav", + "text": "民主是非常可貴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/8.wav", + "text": "在這以前三代臺灣人犧牲奉獻幾萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/9.wav", + "text": "才走到今天來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/10.wav", + "text": "的但是這個民主要被摧毀也是在旦夕之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/11.wav", + "text": "尤其今天是最重要的一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/12.wav", + "text": "所以我要求要朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/13.wav", + "text": "商前幾次朝野協商大家都很清楚是這樣走過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/14.wav", + "text": "這樣走過來的中間我一直很捍衛一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/15.wav", + "text": "而且是沒有辦法妥協的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/16.wav", + "text": "就是說我們第一個要依法來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/17.wav", + "text": "第二個要有程序正義才有實質正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/18.wav", + "text": "整個國會職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/19.wav", + "text": "不管內容怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/20.wav", + "text": "假如透過大家協商然後最後簽字表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/21.wav", + "text": "我們本來就會輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/22.wav", + "text": "啊1985年到2016年三十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/23.wav", + "text": "來民進黨在立法院表決幾萬次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/24.wav", + "text": "不管在院會委員會程序委員會都輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/25.wav", + "text": "從1993年到2016年二十二年間從來沒有贏過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/26.wav", + "text": "這段歷史大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/27.wav", + "text": "即便賴總統在立法院十二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/28.wav", + "text": "他那時候當幹事長我們一樣沒有贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/29.wav", + "text": "讓臺灣民主能夠往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/30.wav", + "text": "第一個在這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/31.wav", + "text": "韓院長你議事中立的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/32.wav", + "text": "凡事在你一念之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/33.wav", + "text": "就是說國民黨排這麼久今天不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/34.wav", + "text": "你怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/35.wav", + "text": "\n這不是這樣一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/36.wav", + "text": "也許過去你比較不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/37.wav", + "text": "三十一年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/38.wav", + "text": "七百零場朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/39.wav", + "text": "就是差不多整整兩年每天都在協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/40.wav", + "text": "我當然瞭解這中間的過程應該是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/41.wav", + "text": "從劉松藩院長王金平院長蘇嘉全院長乃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/42.wav", + "text": "至於到最後游錫堃院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/43.wav", + "text": "坐在這個位置上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/44.wav", + "text": "大家不厭其煩的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/45.wav", + "text": "協商到最後講完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/46.wav", + "text": "大家要簽名然後表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/47.wav", + "text": "院會表決的時候要幾個人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/48.wav", + "text": "這個都是願賭服輸的這是民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/49.wav", + "text": "未來四年中間我可以認真告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/50.wav", + "text": "也告訴傅總召黃總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/51.wav", + "text": "未來四年你們聯手起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/52.wav", + "text": "我們沒有一件會贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/53.wav", + "text": "這是事實不會存在說表決幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/54.wav", + "text": "就好像非常受不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/55.wav", + "text": "我們對這件事情非常淡定瞭解清楚得很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/56.wav", + "text": "所以我要講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/57.wav", + "text": "假如今天大家不依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/58.wav", + "text": "所以我昨天臉書有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/59.wav", + "text": "會發生史上最大的嚴重衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/60.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們要捍衛立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/61.wav", + "text": "要捍衛立法院的存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/62.wav", + "text": "讓國會的功能能夠存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/63.wav", + "text": "民主能夠繼續發展遂行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/64.wav", + "text": "否則臺灣的國會會變成中國人大化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/65.wav", + "text": "變成香港化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/66.wav", + "text": "假如變香港化難保臺灣不會香港化嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/67.wav", + "text": "影響所及不是只有國會已死民主已死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/68.wav", + "text": "是臺灣我再把話講清楚請不要急好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/69.wav", + "text": "這是一個非常關鍵的很抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/70.wav", + "text": "臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/71.wav", + "text": "這樣的情形在整個民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/72.wav", + "text": "大家會怎麼樣看待臺灣是一個可以合作的夥伴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/73.wav", + "text": "呢外媒不會關心嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/74.wav", + "text": "主管單位不會關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/75.wav", + "text": "因為臺灣到底未來發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/76.wav", + "text": "會變成怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/77.wav", + "text": "\n所以我在這裡要很懇切地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/78.wav", + "text": "回到一個原點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/79.wav", + "text": "院長還是你一念之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/80.wav", + "text": "這個中間的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/81.wav", + "text": "我都不要講太清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/82.wav", + "text": "我只要講兩點就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/83.wav", + "text": "我為什麼說一定要依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/84.wav", + "text": "職權行使法規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/85.wav", + "text": "不存在所謂黃國昌講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/86.wav", + "text": "一個月到就要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/87.wav", + "text": "我每次要跟他辯論他就走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/88.wav", + "text": "然後每次講話都講一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/89.wav", + "text": "誰插話誰怎麼樣講話太久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/90.wav", + "text": "就是這種枝節問題不敢面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/91.wav", + "text": "真正的問題來面對問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/92.wav", + "text": "這���國會五法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/93.wav", + "text": "當年1993年到1999年1月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/94.wav", + "text": "我全程參與了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/95.wav", + "text": "才有國會五法才有職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/96.wav", + "text": "才有立法院議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/97.wav", + "text": "才有立法委員行為法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/98.wav", + "text": "才有立法院組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/99.wav", + "text": "各委員會組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/100.wav", + "text": "留給國會最重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/101.wav", + "text": "所以很清楚職權行使法過去是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/102.wav", + "text": "四個月以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/103.wav", + "text": "朝野協商講不下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/104.wav", + "text": "四個月以後就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/105.wav", + "text": "那是依法經過整個程序走過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/106.wav", + "text": "有正常的程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/107.wav", + "text": "後來馬英九上臺以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/108.wav", + "text": "那時候是我們27席的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/109.wav", + "text": "他在國會絕對多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/110.wav", + "text": "後來他把它改為一個月以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/111.wav", + "text": "但這個法是怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/112.wav", + "text": "委員會協商以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/113.wav", + "text": "沒有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/114.wav", + "text": "一個月後要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/115.wav", + "text": "這是定期表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/116.wav", + "text": "這時候就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/117.wav", + "text": "回到立法院職權行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/118.wav", + "text": "第68條很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/119.wav", + "text": "長的功能就在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/120.wav", + "text": "你所有權力只有在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/121.wav", + "text": "你對國會負責在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/122.wav", + "text": "你的角色就出現了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/123.wav", + "text": "為什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/124.wav", + "text": "要黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/125.wav", + "text": "或者有爭議事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/126.wav", + "text": "我要求你協商你一定要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/127.wav", + "text": "你要求大家來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/128.wav", + "text": "我們一定來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/129.wav", + "text": "過去這麼多年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/130.wav", + "text": "王院長或者任何後任院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/131.wav", + "text": "邀集朝野協商我從來不會缺席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/132.wav", + "text": "大家在裡面能夠辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/133.wav", + "text": "\n但是2015年我回去選舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/134.wav", + "text": "黃國昌一直主張說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/135.wav", + "text": "我們在密室協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/136.wav", + "text": "那個是法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/137.wav", + "text": "他要直播就直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/138.wav", + "text": "我更樂意見到直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/139.wav", + "text": "他說要來辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/140.wav", + "text": "請問黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/141.wav", + "text": "你所謂委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/142.wav", + "text": "會中心主義要辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/143.wav", + "text": "你把這個程序都沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/144.wav", + "text": "整個國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/145.wav", + "text": "整個職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/146.wav", + "text": "在委員會是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/147.wav", + "text": "呢在委員會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/148.wav", + "text": "我們的被丟包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/149.wav", + "text": "甚至洪孟楷委員你的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/150.wav", + "text": "也都被丟包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/151.wav", + "text": "只審理你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/152.wav", + "text": "一路壓過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/153.wav", + "text": "當然我們要主張散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/154.wav", + "text": "一直讓它的程序不能往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/155.wav", + "text": "很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/156.wav", + "text": "還是照常壓出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/157.wav", + "text": "我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/158.wav", + "text": "總統上臺以前的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/159.wav", + "text": "也是一個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/160.wav", + "text": "這是表象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/161.wav", + "text": "我們鍾佳濱委員開了5次以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/162.wav", + "text": "每一次都散會動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/163.wav", + "text": "換言之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/164.wav", + "text": "立法院現在可以沒收委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/165.wav", + "text": "這夠厲害吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/166.wav", + "text": "不讓它開你就來散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/167.wav", + "text": "甚至有一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/168.wav", + "text": "傅總召還拍桌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/169.wav", + "text": "然後也是散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/170.wav", + "text": "國會天搖地動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/171.wav", + "text": "這個是最近的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/172.wav", + "text": "很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/173.wav", + "text": "\n然後經過委員會朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/174.wav", + "text": "委員會朝野協商是怎麼樣呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/175.wav", + "text": "吳宗憲委員主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/176.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/177.wav", + "text": "討論三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/178.wav", + "text": "這一大包五六十條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/179.wav", + "text": "談了三條以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/180.wav", + "text": "是國民黨強行出委員會黃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/181.wav", + "text": "就走人了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/182.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/183.wav", + "text": "就到院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/184.wav", + "text": "請問這樣就是可以表決嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/185.wav", + "text": "我要請問黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/186.wav", + "text": "你這樣就可以表決嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/187.wav", + "text": "你的法學常識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/188.wav", + "text": "你是法律博士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/189.wav", + "text": "這是很嚴肅的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/190.wav", + "text": "你每次都要挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/191.wav", + "text": "到昨天為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/192.wav", + "text": "你還是說要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/193.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼好協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/194.wav", + "text": "就直接表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/195.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/196.wav", + "text": "\n第二個我要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/197.wav", + "text": "沒有程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/198.wav", + "text": "假如這樣可以遂行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/199.wav", + "text": "聯合起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/200.wav", + "text": "在程序委員會擋案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/201.wav", + "text": "就不會看到委員會討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/202.wav", + "text": "立法院在幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/203.wav", + "text": "沒有透過直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/204.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法知道你在幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/205.wav", + "text": "蓋到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/206.wav", + "text": "也不朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/207.wav", + "text": "就直接表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/208.wav", + "text": "表決我當然知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/209.wav", + "text": "講一兩次以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/210.wav", + "text": "就停止討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/211.wav", + "text": "表決一路這樣下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/212.wav", + "text": "這樣的國會有存在價值嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/213.wav", + "text": "這樣的國會和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/214.wav", + "text": "中國人大不是差不多嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/215.wav", + "text": "和香港人大不是差不多嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/216.wav", + "text": "這是一個非常嚴肅的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/217.wav", + "text": "你的幕僚應該給你高度實情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/218.wav", + "text": "你的幕僚不應該跟你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/219.wav", + "text": "我要請問周萬來秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/220.wav", + "text": "我們今天早上還在院長室辯論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/221.wav", + "text": "你舉一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/222.wav", + "text": "歷任院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/223.wav", + "text": "誰搞過這樣的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/224.wav", + "text": "誰敢這樣搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/225.wav", + "text": "誰敢這樣搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/226.wav", + "text": "沒有人敢這樣搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/227.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/228.wav", + "text": "我很懇切地講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/229.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/230.wav", + "text": "大家來朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/231.wav", + "text": "整段講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/232.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/233.wav", + "text": "當傅崐萁講話的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/234.wav", + "text": "你從來不會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/235.wav", + "text": "子我也忍受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/236.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/237.wav", + "text": "我把整段講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/238.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/239.wav", + "text": "我今天都講實情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/240.wav", + "text": "每次都做直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/241.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁講話的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/242.wav", + "text": "不會看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/243.wav", + "text": "黃國昌講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/244.wav", + "text": "不敢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/245.wav", + "text": "我們這三個人講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/246.wav", + "text": "一定是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/247.wav", + "text": "但是你對我比較客氣一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/248.wav", + "text": "appreciate" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/249.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/250.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/251.wav", + "text": "這個是很重要的一刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/252.wav", + "text": "我必須把話講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/253.wav", + "text": "你可以第二次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/254.wav", + "text": "才能夠進入程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/255.wav", + "text": "所以我還是試圖說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/256.wav", + "text": "我們如何解決這個僵局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/257.wav", + "text": "我們今天可以大家好好談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/258.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/259.wav", + "text": "總統來國會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/260.wav", + "text": "那個我們講過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/261.wav", + "text": "而且幾乎是憲法法庭的辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/262.wav", + "text": "但是當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/263.wav", + "text": "我一直講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/264.wav", + "text": "這個是憲政體制的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/265.wav", + "text": "你們說不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/266.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/267.wav", + "text": "憲法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/268.wav", + "text": "對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/269.wav", + "text": "所以我試圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/270.wav", + "text": "讓大家可以解這個局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/271.wav", + "text": "也讓立法院立下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/272.wav", + "text": "我們以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/273.wav", + "text": "國會也不會讓人家擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/274.wav", + "text": "是很危險的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/275.wav", + "text": "我們選立委來幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/276.wav", + "text": "來數人頭就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/277.wav", + "text": "法案也不必審了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/278.wav", + "text": "這是民主輓歌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/279.wav", + "text": "也是國會的輓歌\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/280.wav", + "text": "所以我具體主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/281.wav", + "text": "假如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/282.wav", + "text": "針對國情報告的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/283.wav", + "text": "雖然那個要交由朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/284.wav", + "text": "一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/285.wav", + "text": "針對國情報告的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/286.wav", + "text": "我們講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/287.wav", + "text": "只有三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/288.wav", + "text": "第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/289.wav", + "text": "十五條之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/290.wav", + "text": "第十五條之四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/291.wav", + "text": "待會我們大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/292.wav", + "text": "好好談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/293.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/294.wav", + "text": "大體討論要多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/295.wav", + "text": "第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/296.wav", + "text": "一條討論要多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/297.wav", + "text": "讓這個事情有個ending" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/298.wav", + "text": "讓國會至少在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/299.wav", + "text": "搶救國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/300.wav", + "text": "最後的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/301.wav", + "text": "把國會的遮羞布也拿回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/302.wav", + "text": "這是一個民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/303.wav", + "text": "在懸崖的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/304.wav", + "text": "最關鍵時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/305.wav", + "text": "假如說一定要把所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/306.wav", + "text": "今天你們排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/307.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召所排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/308.wav", + "text": "變更議程的三案都要通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/309.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/310.wav", + "text": "今天開會到12點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/311.wav", + "text": "硬幹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/312.wav", + "text": "我在這裡講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/313.wav", + "text": "對不起那個衝突會很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/314.wav", + "text": "啦那個衝突絕對很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/315.wav", + "text": "我不是在恐嚇這個很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/316.wav", + "text": "嘛我們要挽救國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/317.wav", + "text": "要挽救民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/318.wav", + "text": "挽救臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/319.wav", + "text": "就要一路下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/320.wav", + "text": "其他都還沒協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/321.wav", + "text": "乃至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/322.wav", + "text": "藐視國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/323.wav", + "text": "全部還沒協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/324.wav", + "text": "這些還沒協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/325.wav", + "text": "來就一路幹下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/326.wav", + "text": "表決下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/327.wav", + "text": "這不會有衝突嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/328.wav", + "text": "這衝突是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/329.wav", + "text": "挽救國會的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/330.wav", + "text": "不是為了個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/331.wav", + "text": "也不是為了黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/332.wav", + "text": "所以我很誠懇地建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/333.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/334.wav", + "text": "你們要開會到晚上12點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/335.wav", + "text": "可能要斟酌一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/336.wav", + "text": "我剛才跟傅崐萁講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/337.wav", + "text": "其他沒有協商的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/338.wav", + "text": "再另期安排協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/339.wav", + "text": "協商以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/340.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/341.wav", + "text": "講不下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/342.wav", + "text": "那就是表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/343.wav", + "text": "反正未來四年中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/344.wav", + "text": "任何時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/345.wav", + "text": "差一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/346.wav", + "text": "差一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/347.wav", + "text": "差一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/348.wav", + "text": "我們永遠是表決輸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/349.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/350.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁委員所在意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/351.wav", + "text": "快及環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/352.wav", + "text": "發了兩次都在談這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/353.wav", + "text": "昨天談到最後的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/354.wav", + "text": "我們還想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/355.wav", + "text": "找傅委員還有您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/356.wav", + "text": "吳幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/357.wav", + "text": "我們在旁邊講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/358.wav", + "text": "我說乾脆這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/359.wav", + "text": "啦花東快也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/360.wav", + "text": "啦在憲政原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/361.wav", + "text": "行政院編的預算權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/362.wav", + "text": "是它獨享的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/363.wav", + "text": "議決預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/364.wav", + "text": "又可以編列預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/365.wav", + "text": "大家講好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/366.wav", + "text": "把那個走完也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/367.wav", + "text": "就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/368.wav", + "text": "黃國昌開始反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/369.wav", + "text": "這個等到520再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/370.wav", + "text": "但協商了這麼多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/371.wav", + "text": "520以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/372.wav", + "text": "憲法會改變嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/373.wav", + "text": "不可能嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/374.wav", + "text": "\n所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/375.wav", + "text": "傅總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/376.wav", + "text": "我很懇切地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/377.wav", + "text": "要講道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/378.wav", + "text": "就要來這裡講道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/379.wav", + "text": "不要等一下講一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/380.wav", + "text": "目前為止沒有做任何人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/381.wav", + "text": "這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/382.wav", + "text": "非常重要的幾點觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/383.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/384.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/385.wav", + "text": "接下來請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/386.wav", + "text": "有沒有寶貴的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/387.wav", + "text": "稍微等一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/388.wav", + "text": "我們交叉嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/389.wav", + "text": "你們一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/390.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/391.wav", + "text": "我們請洪孟楷書記長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/392.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/393.wav", + "text": "院長剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/394.wav", + "text": "我們非常有風度地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/395.wav", + "text": "聽柯建銘總召講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/396.wav", + "text": "19分鐘的歷史回顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/397.wav", + "text": "說實在話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/398.wav", + "text": "還是沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/399.wav", + "text": "坐下來好好協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/400.wav", + "text": "我們要先請教民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/401.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/402.wav", + "text": "今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/403.wav", + "text": "一定要耍流氓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/404.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/405.wav", + "text": "賴清德主席下的命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/406.wav", + "text": "要你們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/407.wav", + "text": "一定要來暴力衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/408.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/409.wav", + "text": "只要想怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/410.wav", + "text": "連插隊都可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/411.wav", + "text": "我先說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/412.wav", + "text": "我不會像你一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/413.wav", + "text": "歷史回顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/414.wav", + "text": "我只講這三天的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/415.wav", + "text": "\n禮拜三上午8點鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/416.wav", + "text": "我們就已經在議場前面排隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/417.wav", + "text": "大家也都清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/418.wav", + "text": "我們也講得非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/419.wav", + "text": "國民黨團要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/420.wav", + "text": "我們能夠在禮拜五的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/421.wav", + "text": "順利進行議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/422.wav", + "text": "也因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/423.wav", + "text": "我們在禮拜三上午8點鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/424.wav", + "text": "黨團大會之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/425.wav", + "text": "我們就排隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/426.wav", + "text": "在禮拜三的中午左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/427.wav", + "text": "民眾黨也加入排隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/428.wav", + "text": "一直都在做排隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/429.wav", + "text": "但直到今天早上6點40分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/430.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團才多位委員過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/431.wav", + "text": "沒有一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/432.wav", + "text": "直接用肢體衝突暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/433.wav", + "text": "想要硬來插隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/434.wav", + "text": "我們要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/435.wav", + "text": "這種耍流氓的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/436.wav", + "text": "是誰指使的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/437.wav", + "text": "誰下令的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/438.wav", + "text": "民主包含耍流氓嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/439.wav", + "text": "捍衛國會包含耍流氓嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/440.wav", + "text": "我們在進行任何議事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/441.wav", + "text": "程序正義包含耍流氓嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/442.wav", + "text": "插隊是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/443.wav", + "text": "\n再者今天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/444.wav", + "text": "所有的衝突點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/445.wav", + "text": "我再強調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/446.wav", + "text": "我們講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/447.wav", + "text": "行霹靂手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/448.wav", + "text": "方能使菩薩心腸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/449.wav", + "text": "我們沒有主動動過一次手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/450.wav", + "text": "我們在今天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/451.wav", + "text": "每一次的暴力衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/452.wav", + "text": "全都是民進黨的委員先動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/453.wav", + "text": "我在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/454.wav", + "text": "也要非常強力地譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/455.wav", + "text": "剛剛在國會的殿堂裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/456.wav", + "text": "就距離院長不到1公尺的位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/457.wav", + "text": "民進黨籍的鍾佳濱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/458.wav", + "text": "還可以直接跳上院長台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/459.wav", + "text": "台把我們女性的委員整個熊抱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/460.wav", + "text": "然後撲倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/461.wav", + "text": "壓倒在地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/462.wav", + "text": "這就是你們民進黨委員的水準嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/463.wav", + "text": "就是你們男性委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/464.wav", + "text": "對一個女性委員肢體接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/465.wav", + "text": "肢體暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/466.wav", + "text": "有辦法接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/467.wav", + "text": "有任何一個人可以接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/468.wav", + "text": "我請教在場的每一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/469.wav", + "text": "有任何一個人可以接受這樣的行為嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/470.wav", + "text": "如果說今天這位女性委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/471.wav", + "text": "是你的媽媽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/472.wav", + "text": "你的太太" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/473.wav", + "text": "你的女兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/474.wav", + "text": "你有辦法能夠接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/475.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛柯總召一直強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/476.wav", + "text": "我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/477.wav", + "text": "職權行使法寫得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/478.wav", + "text": "就是一個月提出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/479.wav", + "text": "可以來做議事處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/480.wav", + "text": "昨天我們也提出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/481.wav", + "text": "民進黨在過去第9屆第10屆的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/482.wav", + "text": "也都有相關的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/483.wav", + "text": "包括我講到公投法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/484.wav", + "text": "2018年因為公投綁大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/485.wav", + "text": "讓民進黨縣市長選舉選輸之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/486.wav", + "text": "民進黨怕影響2020年的總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/487.wav", + "text": "也因此民進黨在第9屆的會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/488.wav", + "text": "2019年的5月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/489.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀公投法脫鈎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/490.wav", + "text": "從原本的公投綁大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/491.wav", + "text": "變成是兩年投一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/492.wav", + "text": "5月17號逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/493.wav", + "text": "6月17號直接院會三讀表決通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/494.wav", + "text": "一個月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/495.wav", + "text": "而且6月17號當時的會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/496.wav", + "text": "還是以加開臨時會的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/497.wav", + "text": "為的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/498.wav", + "text": "為的就是民進黨怕影響到2020" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/499.wav", + "text": "你們的總統大選嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/500.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/501.wav", + "text": "一個月能不能進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/502.wav", + "text": "當然可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/503.wav", + "text": "再者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/504.wav", + "text": "於法有沒有據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/505.wav", + "text": "有沒有不法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/506.wav", + "text": "於規有沒有合乎規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/507.wav", + "text": "不是你說了算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/508.wav", + "text": "不是我說了算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/509.wav", + "text": "我們請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/510.wav", + "text": "指示我們一定有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/511.wav", + "text": "秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/512.wav", + "text": "法案助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/513.wav", + "text": "法案主任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/514.wav", + "text": "由議事人員清楚明白說明解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/515.wav", + "text": "我不知道他們要怎麼解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/516.wav", + "text": "但我只知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/517.wav", + "text": "不是你說了算不是我說了算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/518.wav", + "text": "議事人員講清楚之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/519.wav", + "text": "我們就按照議事規則走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/520.wav", + "text": "所以你不要再吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/521.wav", + "text": "我也不用再吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/522.wav", + "text": "不用再吵是說你覺得這個不合規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/523.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個合規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/524.wav", + "text": "議事人員講了大家照做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/525.wav", + "text": "您剛剛一直提到過去30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/526.wav", + "text": "你有輸有贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/527.wav", + "text": "過去4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/528.wav", + "text": "我們全輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/529.wav", + "text": "過去4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/530.wav", + "text": "我們國民黨團在立法院全輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/531.wav", + "text": "但我很驕傲很自豪是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/532.wav", + "text": "我沒有一次主動動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/533.wav", + "text": "我很明白地跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/534.wav", + "text": "你看著我的眼睛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/535.wav", + "text": "我也看你的眼睛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/536.wav", + "text": "很真誠地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/537.wav", + "text": "我過去4年全輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/538.wav", + "text": "但我們沒有主動動手過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/539.wav", + "text": "有動手也是被動動手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/540.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/541.wav", + "text": "國會要尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/542.wav", + "text": "國會要秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/543.wav", + "text": "就請從各黨團的三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/544.wav", + "text": "約束自己的委員開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/545.wav", + "text": "國會不會因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/546.wav", + "text": "中華民國不會因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/547.wav", + "text": "什麼人大化香港化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/548.wav", + "text": "如果在蔡英文總統要下台的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/549.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統下禮拜要上台的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/550.wav", + "text": "國會就如同柯總召所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/551.wav", + "text": "要香港化人大化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/552.wav", + "text": "你是在唱衰賴清德總統嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/553.wav", + "text": "蔡英文主政之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/554.wav", + "text": "國會變成香港化人大化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/555.wav", + "text": "賴清德要上台前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/556.wav", + "text": "國會變成香港化人大化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/557.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/558.wav", + "text": "中華民國永遠存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/559.wav", + "text": "中華民國永遠存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/560.wav", + "text": "沒有人附和任何人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/561.wav", + "text": "我們是民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/562.wav", + "text": "我是113席之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/563.wav", + "text": "你也是113席之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/564.wav", + "text": "我們都要為歷史負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/565.wav", + "text": "但請不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/566.wav", + "text": "隨便地惡意給人家潑紅水潑髒水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/567.wav", + "text": "扣我們紅帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/568.wav", + "text": "過去我們人少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/569.wav", + "text": "被你們多講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/570.wav", + "text": "現在我們不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/571.wav", + "text": "因為我們人多所以說話大聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/572.wav", + "text": "我們是因為我們理直所以氣順" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/573.wav", + "text": "所以我們絕對拒絕再被扣任何的紅帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/574.wav", + "text": "我是臺灣人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/575.wav", + "text": "我是中華民國國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/576.wav", + "text": "不要再扣我們任何紅帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/577.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/578.wav", + "text": "好謝謝洪書記長的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/579.wav", + "text": "接下來民眾黨團請表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/580.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/581.wav", + "text": "基於對院長的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/582.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是參與這次的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/583.wav", + "text": "因為院長協商的主題是針對接下去的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/584.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼處理的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/585.wav", + "text": "我想還是扣合著這個主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/586.wav", + "text": "避免在討論的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/587.wav", + "text": "出現太多污衊抹黑指鹿為馬的言論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/588.wav", + "text": "我們就把他當成都沒有聽見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/589.wav", + "text": "否則在這邊吵這些其他的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/590.wav", + "text": "只是不斷地在拖延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/591.wav", + "text": "整個院會應該進行所有的效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/592.wav", + "text": "\n在我發言完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/593.wav", + "text": "我也想請院長大概跟大家宣布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/594.wav", + "text": "因為上次在黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/595.wav", + "text": "我就善意地提出了一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/596.wav", + "text": "就是3個黨團大家有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/597.wav", + "text": "就3個黨團輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/598.wav", + "text": "這樣院長也不會看舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/599.wav", + "text": "看得眼花繚亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/600.wav", + "text": "有的時候誰舉得快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/601.wav", + "text": "有的時候誰舉得慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/602.wav", + "text": "有的時候誰舉得久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/603.wav", + "text": "有的時候誰舉得短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/604.wav", + "text": "要院長用視力去做這些判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/605.wav", + "text": "我覺得就建立一個非常基本文明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/606.wav", + "text": "又簡單的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/607.wav", + "text": "就3個黨團輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/608.wav", + "text": "至於說要由哪一位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/609.wav", + "text": "針對這個程序性的事項發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/610.wav", + "text": "當然尊重各個黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/611.wav", + "text": "\n第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/612.wav", + "text": "針對有關於民主進步黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/613.wav", + "text": "要求院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/614.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/615.wav", + "text": "前面那一些莫名其妙的言論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/616.wav", + "text": "我說過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/617.wav", + "text": "為了院會整個接下來議事進行的效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/618.wav", + "text": "我都不想在這邊回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/619.wav", + "text": "不過針對他所提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/620.wav", + "text": "他只打算要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/621.wav", + "text": "第十五條之1以下的幾個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/622.wav", + "text": "今天只處理這些條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/623.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團敬表不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/624.wav", + "text": "敬表不同意的理由非常簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/625.wav", + "text": "也非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/626.wav", + "text": "國會改革的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/627.wav", + "text": "臺灣社會等得夠久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/628.wav", + "text": "建立國會聽證調查制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/629.wav", + "text": "也是當初蔡英文總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/630.wav", + "text": "在2016年所做出來的莊嚴承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/631.wav", + "text": "8年過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/632.wav", + "text": "我們的國會建立了國會聽證調查制度嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/633.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/634.wav", + "text": "沒有所以我們無法同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/635.wav", + "text": "\n最後一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/636.wav", + "text": "有關於立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/637.wav", + "text": "第71條之1的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/638.wav", + "text": "其實之前在這個協商的會場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/639.wav", + "text": "我已經把這個問題提出來過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/640.wav", + "text": "在那一次協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/641.wav", + "text": "我相信不管是秘書長的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/642.wav", + "text": "或者是院長的裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/643.wav", + "text": "對立法院職權行使法第71條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/644.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼樣解釋適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/645.wav", + "text": "這件事情我相信應該有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/646.wav", + "text": "蠻清楚的解釋跟規則出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/647.wav", + "text": "更何況在我們之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/648.wav", + "text": "非常多的前例當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/649.wav", + "text": "經過委員會的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/650.wav", + "text": "一個月內沒有辦法達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/651.wav", + "text": "本來就可以交給院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/652.wav", + "text": "依照議事規則來加以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/653.wav", + "text": "這不僅僅是立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/654.wav", + "text": "第71條之1的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/655.wav", + "text": "也出現在我們非常多歷次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/656.wav", + "text": "議事前例當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/657.wav", + "text": "我想這一點相對而言是清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/658.wav", + "text": "如果認為還有不清楚之處的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/659.wav", + "text": "是不是等一下就請院長裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/660.wav", + "text": "請秘書長跟大家做一個解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/661.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/662.wav", + "text": "剛剛3位黨團都已經發言過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/663.wav", + "text": "我想針對剛剛發言的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/664.wav", + "text": "我們先告一個段落之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/665.wav", + "text": "我來總結一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/666.wav", + "text": "下面我們開會要進行的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/667.wav", + "text": "等我唸完之後你們起碼消化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/668.wav", + "text": "你們再來發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/669.wav", + "text": "我覺得發言的急切性還超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/670.wav", + "text": "我所要做的小結論的急切性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/671.wav", + "text": "暫時不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/672.wav", + "text": "嘛等一下你還是有發言機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/673.wav", + "text": "\n我想三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/674.wav", + "text": "第一點廣泛討論部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/675.wav", + "text": "我建議由各黨團派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/676.wav", + "text": "幾位立法委員進行發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/677.wav", + "text": "大概1位到3位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/678.wav", + "text": "等一下可以請大家共同議決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/679.wav", + "text": "第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/680.wav", + "text": "點逐條討論的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/681.wav", + "text": "各黨團請推派1位委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/682.wav", + "text": "發言後我們就依送案的先後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/683.wav", + "text": "依序進行各黨團版本條文的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/684.wav", + "text": "我想這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/685.wav", + "text": "我現在綜合3位委員發言之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/686.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/687.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/688.wav", + "text": "麻煩一下時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/689.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長剛剛試圖做出來的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/690.wav", + "text": "但是不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/691.wav", + "text": "民主進步黨團敬表不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/692.wav", + "text": "我看到我們韓院長跟江啟臣副院長身上別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/693.wav", + "text": "中華民國國旗的別針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/694.wav", + "text": "坐在我們中華民國的國會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/695.wav", + "text": "真的是百感交集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/696.wav", + "text": "我非常同意院長早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/697.wav", + "text": "在協商我們私下談的時候院長說的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/698.wav", + "text": "再過23天520新任的總統就要交接了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/699.wav", + "text": "國會要拿出什麼樣的大禮給國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/700.wav", + "text": "現在有73個外國的訪團來到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/701.wav", + "text": "有高達687位國外的訪賓正在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/702.wav", + "text": "國會在最關鍵的520之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/703.wav", + "text": "我們拿出什麼樣的內容形象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/704.wav", + "text": "不只給社會國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/705.wav", + "text": "也是給世界看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/706.wav", + "text": "我們坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/707.wav", + "text": "我們都要非常嚴肅地思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/708.wav", + "text": "所以我非常同意院長你一早就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/709.wav", + "text": "不要有任何暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/710.wav", + "text": "我再同意也不過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/711.wav", + "text": "民主進步黨再同意也不過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/712.wav", + "text": "唯一能夠化解干戈跟暴力的作法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/713.wav", + "text": "就是沒有協商的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/714.wav", + "text": "就不能送院會強行表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/715.wav", + "text": "這是過去數十年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/716.wav", + "text": "立法院從來沒有發生過的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/717.wav", + "text": "我再說一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/718.wav", + "text": "要停止暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/719.wav", + "text": "我們都不希望發生任何人受傷的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/720.wav", + "text": "我們都不希望在520之前端給國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/721.wav", + "text": "的是一個非常負面的國會形象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/722.wav", + "text": "唯一的方式就是請求院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/723.wav", + "text": "行使院長應當行使的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/724.wav", + "text": "就是要把未經協商的議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/725.wav", + "text": "透過協商之後才能表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/726.wav", + "text": "這是程序的正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/727.wav", + "text": "\n我當立委9年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/728.wav", + "text": "但是我年輕的時候就在立法院當助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/729.wav", + "text": "加起來20年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/730.wav", + "text": "我很不明瞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/731.wav", + "text": "我也要跟院長表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/732.wav", + "text": "我從來沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/733.wav", + "text": "立法院的議場內有這麼多的警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/734.wav", + "text": "我今天看到好多的員警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/735.wav", + "text": "也許是要保護委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/736.wav", + "text": "可是我從來沒有看過這麼多的警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/737.wav", + "text": "在立法院的議場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/738.wav", + "text": "在我有限的職業時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/739.wav", + "text": "裡我也沒有看過立法院的警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/740.wav", + "text": "每一個人身上都有一個密錄器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/741.wav", + "text": "我從來沒有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/742.wav", + "text": "柯總召可能經驗更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/743.wav", + "text": "我第一次看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/744.wav", + "text": "每一個警察佩戴一個密錄器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/745.wav", + "text": "是把每個委員當作罪犯嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/746.wav", + "text": "我也沒有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/747.wav", + "text": "早上7點鐘開門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/748.wav", + "text": "是有警察擋在門口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/749.wav", + "text": "不讓委員進場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/750.wav", + "text": "我從來沒有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/751.wav", + "text": "但是今天發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/752.wav", + "text": "院長說要主持我們的議事秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/753.wav", + "text": "我再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/754.wav", + "text": "我們都不想要有暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/755.wav", + "text": "您早上的制止很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/756.wav", + "text": "有委員拿著喇叭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/757.wav", + "text": "您宣讀了我們的議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/758.wav", + "text": "他就應該沒收沒入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/759.wav", + "text": "但是同樣地也許院長沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/760.wav", + "text": "今天有在野黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/761.wav", + "text": "是帶著拳擊手套進場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/762.wav", + "text": "那是要傷人的武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/763.wav", + "text": "就是在野黨的委員還是粉紅色的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/764.wav", + "text": "有委員帶著布條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/765.wav", + "text": "還有旗幟類的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/766.wav", + "text": "剛剛在拉扯當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/767.wav", + "text": "是要纏住委員勒住委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/768.wav", + "text": "所以請求院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/769.wav", + "text": "我們要避免暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/770.wav", + "text": "這些不應當拿入議場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/771.wav", + "text": "boxing的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/772.wav", + "text": "我不知道這個叫什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/773.wav", + "text": "然後這個布條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/774.wav", + "text": "要纏住人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/775.wav", + "text": "這種都是違禁品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/776.wav", + "text": "我們要把傷害降到最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/777.wav", + "text": "如何能夠制止暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/778.wav", + "text": "今天民主進步黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/779.wav", + "text": "如同國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/780.wav", + "text": "我先講國民黨的變更議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/781.wav", + "text": "就是優先處理國會擴權的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/782.wav", + "text": "就是國情咨文之類往後推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/783.wav", + "text": "這是國民黨團端出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/784.wav", + "text": "的而且等一下要進行的變更議程裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/785.wav", + "text": "還是���限列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/786.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/787.wav", + "text": "只能夠處理國民黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/788.wav", + "text": "變更議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/789.wav", + "text": "我也要呼籲民眾黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/790.wav", + "text": "珊珊姐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/791.wav", + "text": "民進黨今天的變更議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/792.wav", + "text": "提案是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/793.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠讓衛環委員會充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/794.wav", + "text": "不經協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/795.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/796.wav", + "text": "以及再生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/797.wav", + "text": "也就是所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/798.wav", + "text": "再生醫療雙法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/799.wav", + "text": "是我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/800.wav", + "text": "第一案希望讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/801.wav", + "text": "國人這麼多的癌症病患" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/802.wav", + "text": "重症病患慢性病患" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/803.wav", + "text": "再生醫療療法能夠趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/804.wav", + "text": "上路這樣的一個議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/805.wav", + "text": "雙法是在衛環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/806.wav", + "text": "通過充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/807.wav", + "text": "不經協商可以直接表決的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/808.wav", + "text": "但是被國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/809.wav", + "text": "擋在國會擴權法案之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/810.wav", + "text": "也就是政治性的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/811.wav", + "text": "優先民生救命的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/812.wav", + "text": "擱一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/813.wav", + "text": "\n民主進步黨議程的第二案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/814.wav", + "text": "是什麼也是通過內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/815.wav", + "text": "充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/816.wav", + "text": "就是村里長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/817.wav", + "text": "年終慰問金待遇提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/818.wav", + "text": "以及地方議會助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/819.wav", + "text": "的待遇提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/820.wav", + "text": "這都是民生法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/821.wav", + "text": "\n所以第一案是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/822.wav", + "text": "希望今天能夠在520前國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/823.wav", + "text": "端給國人最好的禮物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/824.wav", + "text": "第一案是救命的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/825.wav", + "text": "再生醫療雙法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/826.wav", + "text": "可以在今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/827.wav", + "text": "儘速來三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/828.wav", + "text": "第二案就是村里長的福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/829.wav", + "text": "以及地方助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/830.wav", + "text": "待遇提升的福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/831.wav", + "text": "我想珊珊姐我們過去都是臺北市議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/832.wav", + "text": "我們多麼努力奮力地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/833.wav", + "text": "替議員助理爭取了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/834.wav", + "text": "二十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/835.wav", + "text": "這兩個都是民生議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/836.wav", + "text": "福國利民沒有政治性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/837.wav", + "text": "沒有針對性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/838.wav", + "text": "更重要的前提是這兩個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/839.wav", + "text": "都是通過衛環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/840.wav", + "text": "跟內政委員會充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/841.wav", + "text": "履行了委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/842.wav", + "text": "而且都簽字不需要協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/843.wav", + "text": "\n所以這樣的議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/844.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法在timetable上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/845.wav", + "text": "被優先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/846.wav", + "text": "而是國民黨的變更議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/847.wav", + "text": "強行要讓國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/848.wav", + "text": "擴權法案優先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/849.wav", + "text": "而國會擴權法案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/850.wav", + "text": "委員會沒有審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/851.wav", + "text": "黨團協商沒有進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/852.wav", + "text": "沒有經過合理程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/853.wav", + "text": "連韓院長主持協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/854.wav", + "text": "都沒有進行就要強行表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/855.wav", + "text": "這是過去立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/856.wav", + "text": "從來沒有發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/857.wav", + "text": "我不曉得在野黨委員是不信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/858.wav", + "text": "韓院長的協商能力嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/859.wav", + "text": "我對韓院長充滿著信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/860.wav", + "text": "給韓院長機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/861.wav", + "text": "給大家彼此一個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/862.wav", + "text": "我們讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/863.wav", + "text": "職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/864.wav", + "text": "刑法等大家有提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/865.wav", + "text": "都可以在協商場域好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/866.wav", + "text": "這是踐行程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/867.wav", + "text": "最重要的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/868.wav", + "text": "不可以遺漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/869.wav", + "text": "翻轉跳過的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/870.wav", + "text": "\n黃國昌總召說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/871.wav", + "text": "一定要優先處理國會擴權法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/872.wav", + "text": "因為民進黨8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/873.wav", + "text": "沒有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/874.wav", + "text": "再生醫療的雙法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/875.wav", + "text": "民間等了二三十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/876.wav", + "text": "多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/877.wav", + "text": "及病患的家屬在暗夜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/878.wav", + "text": "啜泣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/879.wav", + "text": "等待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/880.wav", + "text": "今天沒有辦法在立法院處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/881.wav", + "text": "就為了優先處理在野黨在意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/882.wav", + "text": "國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/883.wav", + "text": "擴權法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/884.wav", + "text": "\n我要收束我的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/885.wav", + "text": "回應一下洪孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/886.wav", + "text": "昨天在協商會場我已經跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/887.wav", + "text": "說明過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/888.wav", + "text": "不要再拿錯誤的議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/889.wav", + "text": "來做非常讓人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/890.wav", + "text": "公民投票法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/891.wav", + "text": "7個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/892.wav", + "text": "經過內政委員會的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/893.wav", + "text": "在2019年5月30號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/894.wav", + "text": "張宏陸召委主持過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/895.wav", + "text": "2019年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/896.wav", + "text": "6月17號蘇嘉全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/897.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/898.wav", + "text": "主持過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/899.wav", + "text": "所以洪孟楷委員說的公投法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/900.wav", + "text": "沒有協商1個月就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/901.wav", + "text": "這是錯的洪孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/902.wav", + "text": "說錯了洪孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/903.wav", + "text": "說錯了洪孟楷說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/904.wav", + "text": "錯了歷經張宏陸──內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/905.wav", + "text": "召委召開的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/906.wav", + "text": "以及蘇嘉全院長在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/907.wav", + "text": "場域舉行的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/908.wav", + "text": "因為協商沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/909.wav", + "text": "才表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/910.wav", + "text": "\n所以院長任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/911.wav", + "text": "一個爭議性的議案必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/912.wav", + "text": "在院長的高度調和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/913.wav", + "text": "鼎鼐之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/914.wav", + "text": "透過協商才能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/915.wav", + "text": "表決這是程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/916.wav", + "text": "的正義這是國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/917.wav", + "text": "要捍衛的底線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/918.wav", + "text": "這是院長職權神聖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/919.wav", + "text": "不可侵犯的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/920.wav", + "text": "這也是化解今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/921.wav", + "text": "不要發生暴力衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/922.wav", + "text": "的唯一解方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/923.wav", + "text": "就是依照議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/924.wav", + "text": "依照國會的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/925.wav", + "text": "我們��好來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/926.wav", + "text": "福國利民的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/927.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/928.wav", + "text": "剛剛講警察今天在議場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/929.wav", + "text": "空前的多而且有密錄器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/930.wav", + "text": "我要跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/931.wav", + "text": "為了維護議場的安全還有委員的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/932.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/933.wav", + "text": "今天早上我把所有的警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/934.wav", + "text": "我們駐衛警的幹部都找來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/935.wav", + "text": "我下的指令非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/936.wav", + "text": "其實在幾個月前我就下達了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/937.wav", + "text": "因為立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/938.wav", + "text": "有一些餐廳跟出入口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/939.wav", + "text": "我們有嘗試性去管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/940.wav", + "text": "但非常的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/941.wav", + "text": "所以我加派了便衣哨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/942.wav", + "text": "可能大家沒有注意事實上我們有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/943.wav", + "text": "駐衛警變成便衣哨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/944.wav", + "text": "來維護整個立法院的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/945.wav", + "text": "\n針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/946.wav", + "text": "今天5月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/947.wav", + "text": "的院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/948.wav", + "text": "昨天晚上我們也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/949.wav", + "text": "巡邏跟正式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/950.wav", + "text": "員警不停的巡邏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/951.wav", + "text": "因為有一些女性的立委晚上如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/952.wav", + "text": "在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/953.wav", + "text": "駐守的話要考慮到安全問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/954.wav", + "text": "第三今天早上我把所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/955.wav", + "text": "的駐衛警隊長都找來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/956.wav", + "text": "再三強調每個委員的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/957.wav", + "text": "跟尊嚴一定要維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/958.wav", + "text": "但是如果有宵小不法分子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/959.wav", + "text": "要破壞我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/960.wav", + "text": "議事廳的話這時候警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/961.wav", + "text": "同仁一定不能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/962.wav", + "text": "疏失掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/963.wav", + "text": "自己的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/964.wav", + "text": "好像我把這邊變成一個警察國家一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/965.wav", + "text": "絕對不是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/966.wav", + "text": "因為你看到警察那麼多其實過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/967.wav", + "text": "很多啦你剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/968.wav", + "text": "太強調了強調太多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/969.wav", + "text": "其實過去也有可是今天所有警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/970.wav", + "text": "的第一個要項就是保護每個委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/971.wav", + "text": "安全跟尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/972.wav", + "text": "第二個是議場的次序第三是怕宵小分子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/973.wav", + "text": "趁火打劫我有特別交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/974.wav", + "text": "所以絕對沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/975.wav", + "text": "要讓委員像你講的心生恐懼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/976.wav", + "text": "你已經把他延伸到心生恐懼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/977.wav", + "text": "了不你這個意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/978.wav", + "text": "從來沒看過這麼多警察戴著密錄器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/979.wav", + "text": "不保護大家的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/980.wav", + "text": "是我當院長的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/981.wav", + "text": "好不好我特別要澄清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/982.wav", + "text": "至於其他議案的內容討論我們都尊重你的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/983.wav", + "text": "我們要在在行政管理上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/984.wav", + "text": "因為思瑤委員點名我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/985.wav", + "text": "我還是要回一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/986.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/987.wav", + "text": "大家都在這裡都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/988.wav", + "text": "各黨團的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/989.wav", + "text": "剛剛思瑤委員所說的兩個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/990.wav", + "text": "一個是再生醫療一個是地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/991.wav", + "text": "我想這兩個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/992.wav", + "text": "都在上一屆的立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/993.wav", + "text": "躺了很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/994.wav", + "text": "我也不明白今天為什麼突然變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/995.wav", + "text": "特別優先的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/996.wav", + "text": "應該是民進黨完全執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/997.wav", + "text": "在完全執政的情況下不做今天突然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/998.wav", + "text": "間變成非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/999.wav", + "text": "優先的方案我覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1000.wav", + "text": "該做的事情早就該做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1001.wav", + "text": "而且上一屆好像都已經要表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1002.wav", + "text": "但是後來民進黨沒有排入議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1003.wav", + "text": "\n我還是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1004.wav", + "text": "這麼多的醫療團體這麼多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1005.wav", + "text": "病人家屬他們其實很期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1006.wav", + "text": "大家就應該一起趕快把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1007.wav", + "text": "這東西過去而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1008.wav", + "text": "用這個來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1009.wav", + "text": "當成今天案子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1010.wav", + "text": "藉口我覺得這是另外一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1011.wav", + "text": "包括國會改革是我們從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1012.wav", + "text": "大選前就提出的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1013.wav", + "text": "我們一開議就提出了版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1014.wav", + "text": "民進黨團也提��了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1015.wav", + "text": "很多他們的想法跟立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1016.wav", + "text": "今天大家都已經把所有東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1017.wav", + "text": "不要說經不經過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1018.wav", + "text": "我想在媒體上也辯論很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1019.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1020.wav", + "text": "如果按照議事規則該怎麼做就怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1021.wav", + "text": "各自有各自的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1022.wav", + "text": "這一屆的國會當然因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1023.wav", + "text": "屬性的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1024.wav", + "text": "但我還是認為如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1025.wav", + "text": "個別有表達立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1026.wav", + "text": "就讓社會來做公評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1027.wav", + "text": "但是不是優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1028.wav", + "text": "我覺得不應該個別來去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1029.wav", + "text": "對對方做指責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1030.wav", + "text": "每個人都希望福國利民的法案趕快過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1031.wav", + "text": "但今天各黨團的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1032.wav", + "text": "我們已經表達得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1033.wav", + "text": "國會改革是民眾黨的重中之重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1034.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們不會退讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1035.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃珊珊委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1036.wav", + "text": "接下來請傅崐萁總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1037.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1038.wav", + "text": "我要特別表達民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1039.wav", + "text": "兩位代表發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1040.wav", + "text": "人第一位發言18分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1041.wav", + "text": "第二位發言9分35秒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1042.wav", + "text": "我現在就重新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1043.wav", + "text": "我們現在就開始發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1044.wav", + "text": "會場就是要有次序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1045.wav", + "text": "我想院長多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1046.wav", + "text": "在協商過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1047.wav", + "text": "一直表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1048.wav", + "text": "我們國會的形象起碼要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1049.wav", + "text": "有一個次序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1050.wav", + "text": "而不是漫無" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1051.wav", + "text": "邊際不斷的騷擾性的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1052.wav", + "text": "人身攻擊的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1053.wav", + "text": "抹黑似的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1054.wav", + "text": "完全跟本題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1055.wav", + "text": "無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1056.wav", + "text": "\n院長召集了多次的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1057.wav", + "text": "本題的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1058.wav", + "text": "甚至都沒有進入任何的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1059.wav", + "text": "其實這個也算是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1060.wav", + "text": "院長已經有召集協商過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1061.wav", + "text": "不管時間怎麼使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1062.wav", + "text": "我想這以後要建成一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1063.wav", + "text": "立法院的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1064.wav", + "text": "就是這些議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1065.wav", + "text": "你們要討論也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1066.wav", + "text": "你們要浪費在其他的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1067.wav", + "text": "其他侮辱人的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1068.wav", + "text": "抹黑攻擊的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1069.wav", + "text": "但是你把時間用掉了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1070.wav", + "text": "就回歸院長已經召集協商過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1071.wav", + "text": "了這個才是一個有制度的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1072.wav", + "text": "而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1073.wav", + "text": "藉由冗長耽誤所有政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1074.wav", + "text": "全國國人的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1075.wav", + "text": "來看這個不必要的猴戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1076.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1077.wav", + "text": "從這個會期到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1078.wav", + "text": "協商這麼多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1079.wav", + "text": "我們幾乎沒有一次有任何的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1080.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡每一次都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1081.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1082.wav", + "text": "又或是民眾黨再三的退讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1083.wav", + "text": "才會有小部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1084.wav", + "text": "\n我還是要再強調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1085.wav", + "text": "我們現在面對的國會改革法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1086.wav", + "text": "明明就是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1087.wav", + "text": "對人民的承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1088.wav", + "text": "我們實在無法瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1089.wav", + "text": "對人民的承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1090.wav", + "text": "要落實為什麼這麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1091.wav", + "text": "而且這是一個超級陽光的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1092.wav", + "text": "而這八年來民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1093.wav", + "text": "完全不會去面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1094.wav", + "text": "給全國國人的保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1095.wav", + "text": "現在在野黨把它提出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1096.wav", + "text": "也按照大法官第585號解釋令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1097.wav", + "text": "都沒有涉及刑責的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1098.wav", + "text": "都是民事的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1099.wav", + "text": "包括聽證調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1100.wav", + "text": "不得藐視國會權等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1101.wav", + "text": "民間更不會有刑事的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1102.wav", + "text": "政府官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1103.wav", + "text": "有沒有涉及刑事的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1104.wav", + "text": "具體的偽造文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1105.wav", + "text": "跟偽證罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1106.wav", + "text": "那個本來就由刑法去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1107.wav", + "text": "而不在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1108.wav", + "text": "職權行使法的修法範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1109.wav", + "text": "\n所以這個都是很明確的一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1110.wav", + "text": "也符合大法官的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1111.wav", + "text": "我想我們也都把條文公告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1112.wav", + "text": "我不曉得民進黨到底在恐懼什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1113.wav", + "text": "一定要韓院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1114.wav", + "text": "我不瞭解為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1115.wav", + "text": "一定要韓院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1116.wav", + "text": "一個院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1117.wav", + "text": "要面對立法院千百條的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1118.wav", + "text": "千百件的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1119.wav", + "text": "國會議長哪有這麼多的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1120.wav", + "text": "來做協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1121.wav", + "text": "另外委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1122.wav", + "text": "本來在委員會就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1123.wav", + "text": "有經過緊密的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1124.wav", + "text": "而且委員會的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1125.wav", + "text": "是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1126.wav", + "text": "剛好民進黨三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1127.wav", + "text": "都在的司法委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1128.wav", + "text": "都共同參與全體的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1129.wav", + "text": "而且從早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1130.wav", + "text": "冗長的發言也提過44次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1131.wav", + "text": "散會動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1132.wav", + "text": "我不曉得為什麼討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1133.wav", + "text": "國會改革法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1134.wav", + "text": "我們實在不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1135.wav", + "text": "民進黨為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1136.wav", + "text": "要提44次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1137.wav", + "text": "散會動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1138.wav", + "text": "有什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1139.wav", + "text": "是見不了人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1140.wav", + "text": "為什麼不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1141.wav", + "text": "在委員會做實質的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1142.wav", + "text": "而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1143.wav", + "text": "在民進黨提了44次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1144.wav", + "text": "長中間都有到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1145.wav", + "text": "所以在這個過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1146.wav", + "text": "我們很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1147.wav", + "text": "他不斷在強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1148.wav", + "text": "要院長來幫民進黨背書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1149.wav", + "text": "我們實在不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1150.wav", + "text": "法案是國民黨提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1151.wav", + "text": "在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1152.wav", + "text": "完全細密的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1153.wav", + "text": "民進黨不是沒有討論的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1154.wav", + "text": "他們三長都在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1155.wav", + "text": "而且迴避討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1156.wav", + "text": "不敢討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1157.wav", + "text": "通通都提散會動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1158.wav", + "text": "提了44次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1159.wav", + "text": "歷史上都會見證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1160.wav", + "text": "\n所以到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1161.wav", + "text": "我們還是要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1162.wav", + "text": "為什麼民進黨這麼懼怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1163.wav", + "text": "有一個陽光的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1164.wav", + "text": "我還是要再一次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1165.wav", + "text": "在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1166.wav", + "text": "2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1167.wav", + "text": "民進黨大勝以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1168.wav", + "text": "執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1169.wav", + "text": "國會過半數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1170.wav", + "text": "立刻在3月25號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1171.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1172.wav", + "text": "所有普通高中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1173.wav", + "text": "的國文及社會領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1174.wav", + "text": "課綱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1175.wav", + "text": "要微調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1176.wav", + "text": "105年3月25號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1177.wav", + "text": "民進黨把它逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1178.wav", + "text": "105年4月29號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1179.wav", + "text": "直接透過變更議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1180.wav", + "text": "未曾召集過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1181.wav", + "text": "逕行在院會做表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1182.wav", + "text": "三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1183.wav", + "text": "如果民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1184.wav", + "text": "有需要拿資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1185.wav", + "text": "我可以提供給你們沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1186.wav", + "text": "剛剛公投法的事情也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1187.wav", + "text": "我就不再贅述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1188.wav", + "text": "再過來2019年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1189.wav", + "text": "內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1190.wav", + "text": "所提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1191.wav", + "text": "在4月22號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1192.wav", + "text": "委員會審竣以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1193.wav", + "text": "也是在5月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1194.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1195.wav", + "text": "要逕付三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1196.wav", + "text": "表決三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1197.wav", + "text": "完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1198.wav", + "text": "再過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1199.wav", + "text": "2016年4月29號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1200.wav", + "text": "民進黨執政以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1201.wav", + "text": "擔任立法院的院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1202.wav", + "text": "講得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1203.wav", + "text": "他在105年4月29號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1204.wav", + "text": "講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1205.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1206.wav", + "text": "議案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1207.wav", + "text": "逾一個月的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1208.wav", + "text": "爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1209.wav", + "text": "一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1210.wav", + "text": "要經過一次的協商召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1211.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1212.wav", + "text": "在一次的召集之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1213.wav", + "text": "就由院會來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1214.wav", + "text": "這是蘇嘉全院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1215.wav", + "text": "所表達的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1216.wav", + "text": "\n我們一直很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1217.wav", + "text": "國會形象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1218.wav", + "text": "貴賓都在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1219.wav", + "text": "但是我們很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1220.wav", + "text": "執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1221.wav", + "text": "今天用這種完全的暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1222.wav", + "text": "用干戈的手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1223.wav", + "text": "來對付手無寸鐵的在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1224.wav", + "text": "今天不只在立法院攻擊警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1225.wav", + "text": "而且民進黨的男性立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1226.wav", + "text": "竟然對女性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1227.wav", + "text": "用抱摔的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1228.wav", + "text": "來對付在野黨的女性立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1229.wav", + "text": "我們完全無法想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1230.wav", + "text": "這就是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1231.wav", + "text": "所要求的國會正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1232.wav", + "text": "一定要照你們的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1233.wav", + "text": "不需要照國會的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1234.wav", + "text": "要照你們的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1235.wav", + "text": "不然的話就要暴力相向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1236.wav", + "text": "這就是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1237.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得院長這時候要硬起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1238.wav", + "text": "如果一再地被軟土深挖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1239.wav", + "text": "我們的國會尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1240.wav", + "text": "會蕩然無存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1241.wav", + "text": "今天民進黨用這種暴力的手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1242.wav", + "text": "在新一屆的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1243.wav", + "text": "在520之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1244.wav", + "text": "在全世界的貴賓面前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1245.wav", + "text": "對在野黨用這種暴力的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1246.wav", + "text": "我們不只要予以譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1247.wav", + "text": "我們真的不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1248.wav", + "text": "國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1249.wav", + "text": "陽光法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1250.wav", + "text": "民進黨到底有什麼見不得人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1251.wav", + "text": "的我在這裡再一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1252.wav", + "text": "地提醒院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1253.wav", + "text": "也謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1254.wav", + "text": "也再次跟院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1255.wav", + "text": "針對國會改革法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1256.wav", + "text": "您今天已經正式來召集了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1257.wav", + "text": "有正式召集了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1258.wav", + "text": "至於他們要講30年前50年前的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1259.wav", + "text": "我們都予以尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1260.wav", + "text": "到現在發言完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1261.wav", + "text": "是9分8秒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1262.wav", + "text": "都低於他們的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1263.wav", + "text": "謝謝傅崐萁總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1264.wav", + "text": "容許我發言一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1265.wav", + "text": "大家的意見到目前為止還沒有溝通一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1266.wav", + "text": "針對推派委員發言乙節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1267.wav", + "text": "我想請大家繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1268.wav", + "text": "現在請大家先休息用餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1269.wav", + "text": "休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1270.wav", + "text": "都不好聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1271.wav", + "text": "國民黨今天早上一直在指控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1272.wav", + "text": "人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1273.wav", + "text": "其實這樣講話都不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1274.wav", + "text": "今天國民黨的穿著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1275.wav", + "text": "大家愛怎麼穿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1276.wav", + "text": "大家也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1277.wav", + "text": "軍容壯盛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1278.wav", + "text": "本來氣氛就搞得很緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1279.wav", + "text": "不過院長我倒是要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1280.wav", + "text": "我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1281.wav", + "text": "這很合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1282.wav", + "text": "真的也不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1283.wav", + "text": "平常沒有密錄器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1284.wav", + "text": "今天特別弄個密錄器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1285.wav", + "text": "這沒有對與不對的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1286.wav", + "text": "是氣氛真的就搞得緊張了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1287.wav", + "text": "不同政黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1288.wav", + "text": "在排隊時從來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1289.wav", + "text": "也不會擺兩個警察在那個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1290.wav", + "text": "這真的都不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1291.wav", + "text": "氣氛真的弄得太過於緊張了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1292.wav", + "text": "\n今天為什麼我們一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1293.wav", + "text": "擴權法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1294.wav", + "text": "每一個政黨都會有不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1295.wav", + "text": "這非常非常的合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1296.wav", + "text": "啊國民黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1297.wav", + "text": "這段時間以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1298.wav", + "text": "大家不斷地批評你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1299.wav", + "text": "聽證的部分課予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1300.wav", + "text": "本來就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1301.wav", + "text": "啊因為民進黨就跟你們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1302.wav", + "text": "你們這個不符合比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1303.wav", + "text": "是一年以下的有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1304.wav", + "text": "對老百姓為什麼是三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1305.wav", + "text": "不斷地在議場裡面跟你們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1306.wav", + "text": "這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1307.wav", + "text": "是這個原因改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1308.wav", + "text": "這個大家要弄清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1309.wav", + "text": "啊那我也一直認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1310.wav", + "text": "到底今天的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1311.wav", + "text": "會怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1312.wav", + "text": "要不要繼續進行下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1313.wav", + "text": "\n我再來還原昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1314.wav", + "text": "昨天我記得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1315.wav", + "text": "院長也拿出你的高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1316.wav", + "text": "了這些環島高速鐵路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1317.wav", + "text": "再請他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1318.wav", + "text": "也很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1319.wav", + "text": "這個是院長的高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1320.wav", + "text": "所以你昨天也裁示了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1321.wav", + "text": "這部分是不是等新的院長來了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1322.wav", + "text": "嘛既然如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1323.wav", + "text": "這個就讓院長難看了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1324.wav", + "text": "\n另外第二個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1325.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1326.wav", + "text": "我一直不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1327.wav", + "text": "國民黨委員雖然改了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1328.wav", + "text": "你們自己的版本自己也都沒看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1329.wav", + "text": "啊一直在強調我們刑法拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1330.wav", + "text": "了只剩下民事的處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1331.wav", + "text": "民事哪來的處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1332.wav", + "text": "這我連聽都聽不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1333.wav", + "text": "至少你們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1334.wav", + "text": "要講的讓人家懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1335.wav", + "text": "不是我跟你找碴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1336.wav", + "text": "是我根本就不知道什麼叫做民事的處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1337.wav", + "text": "我今天看傅總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1338.wav", + "text": "一直在談民事處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1339.wav", + "text": "有這個東西嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1340.wav", + "text": "我話也不想講太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1341.wav", + "text": "攻防的非常激烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1342.wav", + "text": "國民黨今天對我們指控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1343.wav", + "text": "譬如說像孟楷兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1344.wav", + "text": "你剛剛就站在主席臺上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1345.wav", + "text": "你一直點著我的名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1346.wav", + "text": "不要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1347.wav", + "text": "我很不喜歡舉人家的名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1348.wav", + "text": "每一個人有每一個人的忌諱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1349.wav", + "text": "有的人被摸個頭覺得很開心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1350.wav", + "text": "有的人被你指一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1351.wav", + "text": "他都不舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1352.wav", + "text": "院長每一個人的奇蒙子不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1353.wav", + "text": "站在那裡指著我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1354.wav", + "text": "我第8屆進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1355.wav", + "text": "我這4屆當中沒有哪一屆碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1356.wav", + "text": "立法院沒有衝突的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1357.wav", + "text": "都會有肢體衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1358.wav", + "text": "嘛議事攻防難免大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1359.wav", + "text": "會有情緒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1360.wav", + "text": "嘛但是剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1361.wav", + "text": "朝野協商就朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1362.wav", + "text": "你就秀出什麼鍾佳濱去攻擊暴力還有怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1363.wav", + "text": "這對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1364.wav", + "text": "真的是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1365.wav", + "text": "你們為什麼要截那個圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1366.wav", + "text": "呢\n是鍾佳濱要爬上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1367.wav", + "text": "你們陳委員要把他推上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1368.wav", + "text": "不然哪有什麼鍾佳濱倒在地下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1369.wav", + "text": "然後你們陳委員在上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1370.wav", + "text": "你不覺得這畫面很怪嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1371.wav", + "text": "都當到立法委員了大家都拿片段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1372.wav", + "text": "出來這樣攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1373.wav", + "text": "這個我就不喜歡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1374.wav", + "text": "你說我今天有沒有跟我們其他國民黨委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1375.wav", + "text": "衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1376.wav", + "text": "有啊\n我都承認啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1377.wav", + "text": "那你要去說為什麼會有衝突嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1378.wav", + "text": "看到吳思瑤就講你那麼老了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1379.wav", + "text": "看到柯建銘也講你那麼老了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1380.wav", + "text": "看到邱議瑩你也這樣攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1381.wav", + "text": "你排前面你走進去就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1382.wav", + "text": "了怎麼你排在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1383.wav", + "text": "你不走進去你擋著我進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1384.wav", + "text": "這個在搞什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1385.wav", + "text": "院長在這種情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1386.wav", + "text": "以你當年幹國會議員難道不會衝突嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1387.wav", + "text": "什麼7點到了你排在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1388.wav", + "text": "你排在前面你就走進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1389.wav", + "text": "你排在前面是為了擋我進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1390.wav", + "text": "這就莫名其妙了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1391.wav", + "text": "我們昨天有協商過的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1392.wav", + "text": "表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1393.wav", + "text": "民進黨沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1394.wav", + "text": "輸了我們就輸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1395.wav", + "text": "但是沒有協商完成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1396.wav", + "text": "喔這個茲事體大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1397.wav", + "text": "這個我看連韓院長你都擔待不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1398.wav", + "text": "沒有這樣的\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1399.wav", + "text": "占了主席台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1400.wav", + "text": "我們也占過啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1401.wav", + "text": "但是總是占了主席台以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1402.wav", + "text": "還一直罵說哎呦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1403.wav", + "text": "要協商了你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1404.wav", + "text": "幹嘛要這樣暴力啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1405.wav", + "text": "這很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1406.wav", + "text": "你怎麼不說為了協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1407.wav", + "text": "氣氛好一點你們自己下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1408.wav", + "text": "啊話都你們自己在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1409.wav", + "text": "所以我倒是這樣建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1410.wav", + "text": "大家參考看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1411.wav", + "text": "有協商過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1412.wav", + "text": "要互相控訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1413.wav", + "text": "我沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1414.wav", + "text": "但是不要用那種截取片段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1415.wav", + "text": "的方式這個在我看來就不夠光明磊落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1416.wav", + "text": "這個都不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1417.wav", + "text": "啦有出手就出手啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1418.wav", + "text": "的穿得漂漂亮亮的來議事抗爭沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1419.wav", + "text": "你們今天軍容壯盛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1420.wav", + "text": "我也都尊重啊那是你們的自由啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1421.wav", + "text": "講得一副你們是紳士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1422.wav", + "text": "然後控訴別人是暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1423.wav", + "text": "不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1424.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1425.wav", + "text": "思銘委員有沒有要補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1426.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1427.wav", + "text": "我們對��長剛才裁示的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1428.wav", + "text": "我們在大體討論的時候是1到3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1429.wav", + "text": "逐條的時候是1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1430.wav", + "text": "我們敬表同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1431.wav", + "text": "我想整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1432.wav", + "text": "議事程序的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1433.wav", + "text": "如果是依照相關的議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1434.wav", + "text": "在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1435.wav", + "text": "諸多的議事干擾來阻礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1436.wav", + "text": "或者冗長的發言阻礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1437.wav", + "text": "我們法案審查的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1438.wav", + "text": "所以對於院長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1439.wav", + "text": "這個提議我們非常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1440.wav", + "text": "贊同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1441.wav", + "text": "\n另外我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1442.wav", + "text": "長篇大論講了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1443.wav", + "text": "國會改革五法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1444.wav", + "text": "這部法案在整個委員會的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1445.wav", + "text": "或者是在我們黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1446.wav", + "text": "協商或者是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1447.wav", + "text": "院長的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1448.wav", + "text": "不管它進行的最後一個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1449.wav", + "text": "是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1450.wav", + "text": "總是我們都依照相關的議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1451.wav", + "text": "在審查這部法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1452.wav", + "text": "但是我們都有依照相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1453.wav", + "text": "程序在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1454.wav", + "text": "所以我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1455.wav", + "text": "大家不要再去一直說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1456.wav", + "text": "什麼程序沒有正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1457.wav", + "text": "這怎麼沒有程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1458.wav", + "text": "\n不過講到程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1459.wav", + "text": "我們過去在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1460.wav", + "text": "地方制度法第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1461.wav", + "text": "有關大新竹合併這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1462.wav", + "text": "總召提了一個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1463.wav", + "text": "把我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1464.wav", + "text": "條件就是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1465.wav", + "text": "人口數要125萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1466.wav", + "text": "而且它要是政治教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1467.wav", + "text": "才來做一個合併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1468.wav", + "text": "但是那時候柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1469.wav", + "text": "您一個人的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1470.wav", + "text": "有到委員會去討論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1471.wav", + "text": "有嗎沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1472.wav", + "text": "然後您是不是抽出來逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1473.wav", + "text": "\n也��出來逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1474.wav", + "text": "啊所以你現在跟我們講什麼程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1475.wav", + "text": "這是真的很打臉你自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1476.wav", + "text": "每一個黨都有自己的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1477.wav", + "text": "在這個法案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1478.wav", + "text": "我們做了那麼多的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1479.wav", + "text": "\n只是你們在委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1480.wav", + "text": "逐條討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1481.wav", + "text": "提了40次的散會動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1482.wav", + "text": "到底是誰不想討論這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1483.wav", + "text": "充分給你討論的機會你不要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1484.wav", + "text": "一直講那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1485.wav", + "text": "本案核心沒有相干的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1486.wav", + "text": "我甚至可以大膽地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1487.wav", + "text": "當時在大體討論時你們對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1488.wav", + "text": "每一條條文其實都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1489.wav", + "text": "瞭若指掌都已經討論過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1490.wav", + "text": "再去自欺欺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1491.wav", + "text": "了大家對整個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1492.wav", + "text": "條文的內容其實都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1493.wav", + "text": "瞭若指掌了我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1494.wav", + "text": "長什麼樣子你們都非常瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1495.wav", + "text": "了怎麼到現在還一直講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1496.wav", + "text": "沒有經過實質討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1497.wav", + "text": "真的經過充分討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1498.wav", + "text": "春城兄要不要補充第三位發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1499.wav", + "text": "沒有好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1500.wav", + "text": "我特別報告一下我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1501.wav", + "text": "均已發言完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1502.wav", + "text": "我知道你有什麼事情你等一下再說好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1503.wav", + "text": "都已經發言完畢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1504.wav", + "text": "但是我們並沒有達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1505.wav", + "text": "這個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1506.wav", + "text": "大家都把自己的想法表達出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1507.wav", + "text": "我們還是等一下到院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1508.wav", + "text": "來共同決議好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1509.wav", + "text": "怎麼衝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1510.wav", + "text": "這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1511.wav", + "text": "有這樣想但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1512.wav", + "text": "你還不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1513.wav", + "text": "嗎要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1514.wav", + "text": "其實我們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1515.wav", + "text": "度說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1516.wav", + "text": "沒有像今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1517.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1518.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15927/1519.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1.wav", + "text": "列席的幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2.wav", + "text": "今天我們繼續進行朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3.wav", + "text": "\n特別跟各位黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4.wav", + "text": "幹部報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5.wav", + "text": "列5項討論的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/6.wav", + "text": "第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/7.wav", + "text": "要請各位黨團幹部來研商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/8.wav", + "text": "新任行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/9.wav", + "text": "施政方針報告及本院配合延會相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/10.wav", + "text": "民國89年新任行政院院長唐飛院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/11.wav", + "text": "是6月2日執行行政院院長施政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/12.wav", + "text": "報告97年新任行政院院長劉兆玄院長是於5月30日做施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/13.wav", + "text": "105年行政院院長林全院長是在5月31日做施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/14.wav", + "text": "就這一點請教各位黨團幹部我們有幾個時間點請大家討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/15.wav", + "text": "一個是5月31日另外有一個是6月4日但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/16.wav", + "text": "6月4日這個時間點是有一點超過兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/17.wav", + "text": "希望各黨團所有的幹部們共同表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/18.wav", + "text": "\n請柯建銘總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/19.wav", + "text": "院長各位協商代表有關於行政院院長什麼時候來做施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/20.wav", + "text": "職權行使法規定得很清楚也就是說520以後兩個禮拜內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/21.wav", + "text": "另外就是3天前要提出書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/22.wav", + "text": "所以這樣看起來一個是524一個是531" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/23.wav", + "text": "還有剛才講的6月4日看起來只有5月31日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/24.wav", + "text": "是剛好最好的時間不會超過兩個禮拜也不會太快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/25.wav", + "text": "快慢之間都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/26.wav", + "text": "是不是大家參考一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/27.wav", + "text": "謝謝民進黨柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/28.wav", + "text": "\n接下來還有哪位黨團要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/29.wav", + "text": "各位有沒有其他寶貴意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/30.wav", + "text": "\n請國民黨傅崐萁總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/31.wav", + "text": "依照過去的慣例是520就職以後兩週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/32.wav", + "text": "事實上以這個兩週6月4日也是一個滿好的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/33.wav", + "text": "因為過去兩週大概是一個慣例但是也有超過兩週的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/34.wav", + "text": "過去還有不能上臺的紀錄都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/35.wav", + "text": "過去曾經由王院長召集開談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/36.wav", + "text": "因為民進黨當時不同意院長上臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/37.wav", + "text": "所以當時有開過談話會然後再決定院長上臺的日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/38.wav", + "text": "案國民黨認為6月4日是滿適合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/39.wav", + "text": "好謝謝傅崐萁總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/40.wav", + "text": "\n請問一下民眾黨黃珊珊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/41.wav", + "text": "我們還是尊重院長的裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/42.wav", + "text": "尊重院長的裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/43.wav", + "text": "是如果謝謝黃珊珊副總召的信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/44.wav", + "text": "因為我怕6月4日有一點點溢出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/45.wav", + "text": "我們定為5月31日好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/46.wav", + "text": "\n第二個就是非常重要的延會時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/47.wav", + "text": "預計延會到什麼時間點請大家表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/48.wav", + "text": "\n請民進黨柯建銘柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/49.wav", + "text": "剛才有關於院長來做施政報告很感謝大家今天都在理性範圍裡面討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/50.wav", + "text": "延會也是如此這是可以算得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/51.wav", + "text": "為什麼要延會大家很清楚5月31日會期就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/52.wav", + "text": "了除了延會或臨時會才可以處理後續的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/53.wav", + "text": "既然我們5月31日是請院長來做施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/54.wav", + "text": "我算一算差不多要延會幾天才能夠講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/55.wav", + "text": "第一個這不可能是按政黨比例一定是各黨都發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/56.wav", + "text": "一個正常的總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/57.wav", + "text": "我們還看到民眾黨曾經提出要做食安的專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/58.wav", + "text": "這個已經排在院會朝野協商中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/59.wav", + "text": "其實這個都一併可以談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/60.wav", + "text": "國民黨明天會在院會提出來有關於能源政策的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/61.wav", + "text": "電的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/62.wav", + "text": "這個也要專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/63.wav", + "text": "這個在今天可以一併談所以都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/64.wav", + "text": "有可能的目前有可能至少2個專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/65.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/66.wav", + "text": "院長能不能順利上臺這是一個變數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/67.wav", + "text": "歷年來在野黨都會有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/68.wav", + "text": "至少當天不一定能夠準時上臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/69.wav", + "text": "但我很期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/70.wav", + "text": "大家都講好的話當天就順利上臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/71.wav", + "text": "這個時間才可以控制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/72.wav", + "text": "曾經為了要道歉與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/73.wav", + "text": "以及開放美豬的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/74.wav", + "text": "他12次沒有辦法上臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/75.wav", + "text": "那次大家還記得嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/76.wav", + "text": "結果造成最後一次的時候是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/77.wav", + "text": "豬心什麼都丟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/78.wav", + "text": "造成嚴重衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/79.wav", + "text": "然後我們勉強排除障礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/80.wav", + "text": "做施��報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/81.wav", + "text": "12次是多少時間呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/82.wav", + "text": "6個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/83.wav", + "text": "禮拜五沒有禮拜二再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/84.wav", + "text": "所以這些變數是存在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/85.wav", + "text": "但是要講這些的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/86.wav", + "text": "我們今天打開天窗說亮話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/87.wav", + "text": "一個是食安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/88.wav", + "text": "一個是能源政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/89.wav", + "text": "這樣要12次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/90.wav", + "text": "12次往回推的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/91.wav", + "text": "大概在7月中旬左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/92.wav", + "text": "等一下看日曆就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/93.wav", + "text": "假如不能順利上臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/94.wav", + "text": "耽擱兩個月一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/95.wav", + "text": "我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/96.wav", + "text": "延會多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/97.wav", + "text": "是一個變數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/98.wav", + "text": "既然今天要講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/99.wav", + "text": "都要打開天窗說亮話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/100.wav", + "text": "否則的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/101.wav", + "text": "誰也沒有辦法抓準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/102.wav", + "text": "或是不行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/103.wav", + "text": "再來開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/104.wav", + "text": "大家先斟酌一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/105.wav", + "text": "第二個我們可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/106.wav", + "text": "要對我們自己的職權上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/107.wav", + "text": "有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/108.wav", + "text": "憲法規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/109.wav", + "text": "NCC在程序委員會被擋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/110.wav", + "text": "什麼時候可以審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/111.wav", + "text": "未定之天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/112.wav", + "text": "可以永遠不審嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/113.wav", + "text": "永遠不審的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/114.wav", + "text": "他們就繼續坐在那個位子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/115.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/116.wav", + "text": "名單已經送進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/117.wav", + "text": "今天是5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/118.wav", + "text": "把考試院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/119.wav", + "text": "副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/120.wav", + "text": "以及考試委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/121.wav", + "text": "在5月底以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/122.wav", + "text": "送進來什麼時候必須完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/123.wav", + "text": "是8月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/124.wav", + "text": "三個月前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/125.wav", + "text": "都不行使的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/126.wav", + "text": "大考會不會受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/127.wav", + "text": "很多職業證照考試會受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/128.wav", + "text": "這一點請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/129.wav", + "text": "站在國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/130.wav", + "text": "整個憲政體制底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/131.wav", + "text": "來思考這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/132.wav", + "text": "考試院院長副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/133.wav", + "text": "以及考委的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/134.wav", + "text": "在8月底前完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/135.wav", + "text": "我們可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/136.wav", + "text": "在什麼時候來行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/137.wav", + "text": "這個都是對於我們延會多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/138.wav", + "text": "有一些變數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/139.wav", + "text": "另外再召開單獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/140.wav", + "text": "獨的臨時會來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/141.wav", + "text": "也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/142.wav", + "text": "當然大家要很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/143.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/144.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/145.wav", + "text": "是憲政體制的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/146.wav", + "text": "不可能迴避人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/147.wav", + "text": "事同意權是我們的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/148.wav", + "text": "我們可以自動放棄嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/149.wav", + "text": "這可能必須斟酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/150.wav", + "text": "7月底會送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/151.wav", + "text": "司法院院長副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/152.wav", + "text": "以及五個大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/153.wav", + "text": "這個要做宣判的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/154.wav", + "text": "當然那個比較有時間性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/155.wav", + "text": "在7月底以前一定要送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/156.wav", + "text": "那是三個月以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/157.wav", + "text": "10月底以前要審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/158.wav", + "text": "竣可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/159.wav", + "text": "開議以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/160.wav", + "text": "積極來安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/161.wav", + "text": "或是要在這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/162.wav", + "text": "畢其功於一役一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/163.wav", + "text": "請各位黨鞭與院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/164.wav", + "text": "大家來討論及斟酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/165.wav", + "text": "這幾個變數都是要考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/166.wav", + "text": "否則的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/167.wav", + "text": "我們今天只講一個頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/168.wav", + "text": "尾在什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/169.wav", + "text": "不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/170.wav", + "text": "就是所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/171.wav", + "text": "延會要延到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/172.wav", + "text": "那就不具任何意義了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/173.wav", + "text": "謝謝民進黨柯總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/174.wav", + "text": "請問一下還有其他哪個黨團要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/175.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/176.wav", + "text": "我想剛剛聽完柯總召的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/177.wav", + "text": "其實我們就很具體地建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/178.wav", + "text": "先訂一個延會的定點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/179.wav", + "text": "後面用臨時會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/180.wav", + "text": "因為這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/181.wav", + "text": "是2月1號就開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/182.wav", + "text": "其實相當長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/183.wav", + "text": "如果一直又到8月的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/184.wav", + "text": "我覺得可能時間太長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/185.wav", + "text": "新的院長來總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/186.wav", + "text": "加上剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/187.wav", + "text": "又有兩次專報共6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/188.wav", + "text": "6個禮拜到7月中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/189.wav", + "text": "我覺得是一個適合的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/190.wav", + "text": "來處理人事同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/191.wav", + "text": "或有特殊需要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/192.wav", + "text": "可能這樣對委員的時間安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/193.wav", + "text": "會比較妥當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/194.wav", + "text": "但是如果一下子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/195.wav", + "text": "就延到8月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/196.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個對很多委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/197.wav", + "text": "包括國會外交的一些安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/198.wav", + "text": "可能都沒有辦法進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/199.wav", + "text": "所以是不是就具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/200.wav", + "text": "直接訂一個延會的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/201.wav", + "text": "在7月中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/202.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃珊珊副總召的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/203.wav", + "text": "接下來我們請國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/204.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/205.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/206.wav", + "text": "我想今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/207.wav", + "text": "大家來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/208.wav", + "text": "我們本來就是儘可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/209.wav", + "text": "平和理性地處理完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/210.wav", + "text": "難得看到柯總召今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/211.wav", + "text": "能夠字正腔圓地把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/212.wav", + "text": "院長所提及的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/213.wav", + "text": "我們一樣一樣來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/214.wav", + "text": "仔細討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/215.wav", + "text": "剛剛院長已經裁示了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/216.wav", + "text": "5月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/217.wav", + "text": "由新任卓榮泰卓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/218.wav", + "text": "上臺做施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/219.wav", + "text": "至少兩個以上的專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/220.wav", + "text": "是全國國人都在擔心的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/221.wav", + "text": "如果再不調整的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/222.wav", + "text": "這個是很麻煩的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/223.wav", + "text": "全民都要面對破產危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/224.wav", + "text": "而食安的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/225.wav", + "text": "更是刻不容緩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/226.wav", + "text": "所以這兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/227.wav", + "text": "是不是兩個還不能確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/228.wav", + "text": "也可能是三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/229.wav", + "text": "甚至於可能在這段時間還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/230.wav", + "text": "民眾矚目的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/231.wav", + "text": "我們都要立刻提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/232.wav", + "text": "所以至少兩個可能三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/233.wav", + "text": "大概有6週的施政總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/234.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在也回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/235.wav", + "text": "剛剛民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/236.wav", + "text": "黃珊珊副總召所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/237.wav", + "text": "7月中能夠明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/238.wav", + "text": "把時間定出來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/239.wav", + "text": "延會到7月16號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/240.wav", + "text": "剛好7月中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/241.wav", + "text": "因為7月有31天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/242.wav", + "text": "五二一次會嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/243.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/244.wav", + "text": "7月16號也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/245.wav", + "text": "最後一次會的結束點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/246.wav", + "text": "是不是我們能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/247.wav", + "text": "這樣子明確定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/248.wav", + "text": "以7月16號做一個會期的終結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/249.wav", + "text": "把所有相關的食安專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/250.wav", + "text": "人民關切的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/251.wav", + "text": "包括電價等等的專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/252.wav", + "text": "因為現在520以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/253.wav", + "text": "新任的各部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/254.wav", + "text": "畢竟上一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/255.wav", + "text": "在520之前的陳建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/256.wav", + "text": "陳建仁內閣已經正式卸任了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/257.wav", + "text": "新任的院長副院長還有部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/258.wav", + "text": "尤其是部會首長在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/259.wav", + "text": "新國會所有立委的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/260.wav", + "text": "在7月16號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/261.wav", + "text": "至於剛剛柯總召所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/262.wav", + "text": "不管是其他人事權的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/263.wav", + "text": "我想也回應一下民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/264.wav", + "text": "剛剛有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/265.wav", + "text": "我們可以開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/266.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/267.wav", + "text": "是不是可以這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/268.wav", + "text": "再請柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/269.wav", + "text": "我剛才出去接個電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/270.wav", + "text": "我希望我沒有會錯意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/271.wav", + "text": "同意權到臨時會再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/272.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/273.wav", + "text": "傅總召也是同意權到臨時會來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/274.wav", + "text": "暫定7月16號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/275.wav", + "text": "當然大家定7月16號就7月16號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/276.wav", + "text": "因為只要總質詢沒有結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/277.wav", + "text": "你就等下會期臨時會再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/278.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/279.wav", + "text": "就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/280.wav", + "text": "頭尾定好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/281.wav", + "text": "我們就努力把它完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/282.wav", + "text": "同意權沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/283.wav", + "text": "放到臨時會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/284.wav", + "text": "已經回到這裡聚焦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/285.wav", + "text": "剛才算過差不多要1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/286.wav", + "text": "0次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/287.wav", + "text": "總質詢一輪10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/288.wav", + "text": "0次差不多到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/289.wav", + "text": "7月5號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/290.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/291.wav", + "text": "你等一下再跟他討論好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/292.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/293.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/294.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/295.wav", + "text": "傅總召你剛才說幾號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/296.wav", + "text": "大家不要再說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/297.wav", + "text": "我們現在就針對這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/298.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/299.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/300.wav", + "text": "現在要1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/301.wav", + "text": "0次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/302.wav", + "text": "我們預留三次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/303.wav", + "text": "預留三次沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/304.wav", + "text": "就是食安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/305.wav", + "text": "以及能源政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/306.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/307.wav", + "text": "就預留一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/308.wav", + "text": "預留三次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/309.wav", + "text": "我們都OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/310.wav", + "text": "大家都依約行事就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/311.wav", + "text": "我們希望新的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/312.wav", + "text": "是一個很正式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/313.wav", + "text": "隆重的開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/314.wav", + "text": "而且大家對新內閣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/315.wav", + "text": "任何挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/316.wav", + "text": "都是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/317.wav", + "text": "那就預留一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/318.wav", + "text": "不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/319.wav", + "text": "到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/320.wav", + "text": "不要占領主席台或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/321.wav", + "text": "不讓他上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/322.wav", + "text": "又兩三次就整個報銷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/323.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/324.wav", + "text": "要補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/325.wav", + "text": "書記長要補充嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/326.wav", + "text": "這個可以談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/327.wav", + "text": "現在都可以表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/328.wav", + "text": "沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/329.wav", + "text": "馬上定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/330.wav", + "text": "我們就定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/331.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/332.wav", + "text": "我們順著大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/333.wav", + "text": "講就OK不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/334.wav", + "text": "我都無所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/335.wav", + "text": "講好就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/336.wav", + "text": "那就時間算一算就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/337.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/338.wav", + "text": "有些委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/339.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/340.wav", + "text": "黨鞭在這裡決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/341.wav", + "text": "16日以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/342.wav", + "text": "再出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/343.wav", + "text": "國會外交等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/344.wav", + "text": "都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/345.wav", + "text": "先定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/346.wav", + "text": "一下要簽名的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/347.wav", + "text": "他講16" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/348.wav", + "text": "他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/349.wav", + "text": "那就國會外交再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/350.wav", + "text": "去安排時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/351.wav", + "text": "嘛你們有一些行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/352.wav", + "text": "你們商量一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/353.wav", + "text": "不是大家商量一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/354.wav", + "text": "你要國會外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/355.wav", + "text": "要到大陸去什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/356.wav", + "text": "都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/357.wav", + "text": "們先商量一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/358.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/359.wav", + "text": "當日質詢人數由國民黨黨團推派3位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/360.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團推派3位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/361.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團推派1位進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/362.wav", + "text": "質詢順序依民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/363.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/364.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團之順序輪流交叉方式進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/365.wav", + "text": "施政方針個人質��之登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/366.wav", + "text": "請於5月24日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/367.wav", + "text": "至6月7日（星期五）止辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/368.wav", + "text": "有關質詢期間之順序及人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/369.wav", + "text": "均依例授權議事處辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/370.wav", + "text": "當次會議不處理臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/371.wav", + "text": "二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/372.wav", + "text": "本（第1）會期延至113年7月16號（" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/373.wav", + "text": "星期二）止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/374.wav", + "text": "請問各位黨團幹部有沒有寶貴意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/375.wav", + "text": "請柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/376.wav", + "text": "這個是兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/377.wav", + "text": "辦理個人質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/378.wav", + "text": "7天內登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/379.wav", + "text": "所以你從5月31日算到6月7號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/380.wav", + "text": "是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/381.wav", + "text": "因為剛開始的時候我們會先進行政黨質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/382.wav", + "text": "政黨質詢的第一天是5月31日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/383.wav", + "text": "331" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/384.wav", + "text": "然後之後就循例進行政黨質詢的第二天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/385.wav", + "text": "就第2個工作天的禮拜二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/386.wav", + "text": "以前的經驗政黨質詢可能需要4到5個工作日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/387.wav", + "text": "然後接下來就會個人質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/388.wav", + "text": "那我們登記的截止日是之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/389.wav", + "text": "從5月24日開始登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/390.wav", + "text": "就是按照內政這樣來質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/391.wav", + "text": "總質詢開始以前就可以去安排個人質詢嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/392.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/393.wav", + "text": "大家來登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/394.wav", + "text": "到6月7號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/395.wav", + "text": "我請問一下總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/396.wav", + "text": "政黨質詢差不多要幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/397.wav", + "text": "過去經驗是4到5個工作日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/398.wav", + "text": "所以你531開始的話算出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/399.wav", + "text": "就是大概在6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/400.wav", + "text": "對在那個地方結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/401.wav", + "text": "因為我們前面登記內政組就會先了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/402.wav", + "text": "所以會到差不多6月14號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/403.wav", + "text": "或是6月11號政黨質詢才會結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/404.wav", + "text": "才會進入個人質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/405.wav", + "text": "所以你個人質詢在6月7號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/406.wav", + "text": "那時候還在政黨質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/407.wav", + "text": "所以你來得及啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/408.wav", + "text": "6月7號截止來得及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/409.wav", + "text": "正常的話差不多4次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/410.wav", + "text": "一般是7天之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/411.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/412.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/413.wav", + "text": "謝謝我們請各位黨團幹部依序來簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/414.wav", + "text": "確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/415.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/416.wav", + "text": "在這邊跟黨團幹部報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/417.wav", + "text": "我要更正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/418.wav", + "text": "上一次開朝野協商我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/419.wav", + "text": "楊瓊瓔當過國大代表經查沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/420.wav", + "text": "是陳雪生跟羅明才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/421.wav", + "text": "特別在這裡更正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/422.wav", + "text": "還有賴士葆對我講過賴士葆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/423.wav", + "text": "李昆澤對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/424.wav", + "text": "所以特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/425.wav", + "text": "我沒有當過國大代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/426.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/427.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們進入討論事項第二案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/428.wav", + "text": "繼續研商中國國民黨黨團建請院會作成決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/429.wav", + "text": "於新任行政院院長施政方針報告前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/430.wav", + "text": "邀請賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/431.wav", + "text": "至立法院進行國情報告請公決案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/432.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/433.wav", + "text": "）三繼續研商台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/434.wav", + "text": "建請院會作成決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/435.wav", + "text": "於新任行政院院長施政方針報告前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/436.wav", + "text": "邀請賴清德總統至立法院進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/437.wav", + "text": "並依法回應立法委員提出之問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/438.wav", + "text": "請公決案\n相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/439.wav", + "text": "請各位黨團幹部就詢答方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/440.wav", + "text": "表述具體意見謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/441.wav", + "text": "請提案委員再次說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/442.wav", + "text": "好好我們請提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/443.wav", + "text": "國民黨團請傅總召再次說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/444.wav", + "text": "過去國民大會的憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/445.wav", + "text": "總統每一年都會到國民大會來做相關的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/446.wav", + "text": "並對不瞭解的地方所提出的問題來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/447.wav", + "text": "將整個國家運作的各個層面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/448.wav", + "text": "讓國人能夠更加地瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/449.wav", + "text": "也讓這些代表民意的國大代表的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/450.wav", + "text": "一些建言能夠讓總統聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/451.wav", + "text": "自從國民大會正式結束以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/452.wav", + "text": "現在我們單一國會就是在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/453.wav", + "text": "而總統到國會來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/454.wav", + "text": "也相對地延宕了一段時間都沒有正式來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/455.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨是很誠懇地希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/456.wav", + "text": "面對2024新民意所成立的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/457.wav", + "text": "希望賴清德總統當選人在520就職以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/458.wav", + "text": "能夠優先來到立法院做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/459.wav", + "text": "並就相關問題也能為大家釋疑解惑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/460.wav", + "text": "我們要再三表達我們國民黨是有高度的善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/461.wav", + "text": "也希望有國會的尊嚴有一定的格局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/462.wav", + "text": "本黨一再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/463.wav", + "text": "賴總統在大選前就一再表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/464.wav", + "text": "如果他有機會當選中華民國總統的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/465.wav", + "text": "他很希望到立法院來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/466.wav", + "text": "我想今天既然賴總統有高度的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/467.wav", + "text": "那我們也很願意成就這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/468.wav", + "text": "上能夠有一個非常清楚的高度跟定位來到國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/469.wav", + "text": "國民黨很願意來搭橋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/470.wav", + "text": "也希望這件事能夠圓滿完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/471.wav", + "text": "\n至於什麼樣的安排跟形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/472.wav", + "text": "我們沒有強烈地去要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/473.wav", + "text": "最基本我們想賴總統回到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/474.wav", + "text": "真的是回娘家這是第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/475.wav", + "text": "第二我們過去也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/476.wav", + "text": "李登輝總統在國民大會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/477.wav", + "text": "在大家提案的過程當中說明的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/478.wav", + "text": "表示意見的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/479.wav", + "text": "李登輝前故總統就常常會主動要求跟主席要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/480.wav", + "text": "他現在就想要回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/481.wav", + "text": "所以有的時候是不是我們不要在這裡太過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/482.wav", + "text": "畢竟賴總統來自於立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/483.wav", + "text": "也當過臺南市的市長也當過行政院的院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/484.wav", + "text": "我相信對於民意代表所提出來的相關問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/485.wav", + "text": "我想他來侃侃而談都不是什麼太大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/486.wav", + "text": "而且來到立法院國民黨絕對以禮相待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/487.wav", + "text": "我們非常清楚表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/488.wav", + "text": "我們也希望共同來寫歷史" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/489.wav", + "text": "是101十三分之一共同來見證而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/490.wav", + "text": "所以我們要再三強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/491.wav", + "text": "國民黨一再釋出高度的善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/492.wav", + "text": "我想台灣民眾黨的案子非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/493.wav", + "text": "也��是說希望能夠邀請賴清德總統到立法院進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/494.wav", + "text": "依法回應立法委員提出的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/495.wav", + "text": "在現行法還沒有修正之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/496.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法其實也規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/497.wav", + "text": "我們希望立法委員在國情報告完畢後得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/498.wav", + "text": "就報告不明確處提出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/499.wav", + "text": "那發言的時間順序都已經按照上一次的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/500.wav", + "text": "現在只是就委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/501.wav", + "text": "有一條叫做經總統同意時得綜合再作補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/502.wav", + "text": "我相信其實重點是總統同不同意用什麼樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/503.wav", + "text": "方式的部分我認為目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/504.wav", + "text": "不管是上一次也好或這次也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/505.wav", + "text": "其實大家都希望說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/506.wav", + "text": "因為目前協商出20位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/507.wav", + "text": "要這20位委員一次統問統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/508.wav", + "text": "這樣子對總統來說也是很大的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/509.wav", + "text": "而且對於相關的問題能不能一一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/510.wav", + "text": "一臚列清楚地回應我覺得也會是個困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/511.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們希望就像上次提出的是各黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/512.wav", + "text": "詢問完畢之後有一個統答的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/513.wav", + "text": "這樣子的話第一也可以聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/514.wav", + "text": "第二個如果總統同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/515.wav", + "text": "我相信對賴總統來說他應該不至於不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/516.wav", + "text": "只要在這個的問題上面能夠有一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/517.wav", + "text": "我覺得這次是中華民國民主史上很重要的一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/518.wav", + "text": "總統有史以來第一次到立法院做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/519.wav", + "text": "各黨團能夠有高度的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/520.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是一件好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/521.wav", + "text": "所以民眾黨的立場是希望統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/522.wav", + "text": "統問統答只是一個形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/523.wav", + "text": "對總統來說我相信他同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/524.wav", + "text": "來國情報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/525.wav", + "text": "我也相信他願意回應每一個委員的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/526.wav", + "text": "我們不用自己先預設總統會不會同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/527.wav", + "text": "以上我們希望能夠儘快把這個事情做成決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/528.wav", + "text": "這也是中華民國民主史上很重要的一頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/529.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/530.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃珊珊幹事長的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/531.wav", + "text": "我把上一次朝野協商關於總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/532.wav", + "text": "達成共識的三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/533.wav", + "text": "快速念一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/534.wav", + "text": "第一個發言時間每位委員限時6分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/535.wav", + "text": "第二個發言次數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/536.wav", + "text": "國民黨9位民進黨9位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/537.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/538.wav", + "text": "第三發言的次序是民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/539.wav", + "text": "第一第二次序是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/540.wav", + "text": "第三是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/541.wav", + "text": "詢答的方式剛才國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/542.wav", + "text": "以及台灣民眾黨團的代表都講得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/543.wav", + "text": "接下來請民進黨黨團吳思瑤幹事長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/544.wav", + "text": "回去讓大家好好重新再思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/545.wav", + "text": "檢視條文所賦予的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/546.wav", + "text": "還有參酌各黨代表所發言背後的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/547.wav", + "text": "我自己也花了時間就在這幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/548.wav", + "text": "我特別又回去把美國最近一次總統的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/549.wav", + "text": "是2024年3月8號拜登總統的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/550.wav", + "text": "他的國情咨文我從頭又看了一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/551.wav", + "text": "美國總統制的狀況是他報告完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/552.wav", + "text": "全場起立鼓掌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/553.wav", + "text": "然後總統就離席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/554.wav", + "text": "我也回頭去看臺灣1997修憲之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/555.wav", + "text": "採取的半總統制雙首長制的法國憲政的原理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/556.wav", + "text": "我也去看了法國國情咨文報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/557.wav", + "text": "我看的是2017年7月3號馬克宏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/558.wav", + "text": "的國情咨文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/559.wav", + "text": "他也是報告完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/560.wav", + "text": "然後他離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/561.wav", + "text": "但在法國憲法第十八條第二項說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/562.wav", + "text": "國會議員可以在總統國情咨文結束之後進行辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/563.wav", + "text": "但是為了要去貫行憲法所賦予的雙首長之下的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/564.wav", + "text": "他並不對國會負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/565.wav", + "text": "所以即使國會議員要進行辯論或是表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/566.wav", + "text": "都必須在總統離場不在場為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/567.wav", + "text": "所以我特別再把法國跟美國的制度重新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/568.wav", + "text": "也再次強化我自己對於條文的理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/569.wav", + "text": "\n首先我想要回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/570.wav", + "text": "剛剛不管是傅總召也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/571.wav", + "text": "或是黃珊珊副總召所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/572.wav", + "text": "大家願意做這件事情再好好地溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/573.wav", + "text": "這是搭建起一個很好的憲政慣例的契機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/574.wav", + "text": "但我有一點思維想先跟大家分享一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/575.wav", + "text": "有時候我們在討論的是憲政層次的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/576.wav", + "text": "所以大家應當要試著去跳脫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/577.wav", + "text": "因人設置的這種思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/578.wav", + "text": "我所謂的因人設置是因為大家都感受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/579.wav", + "text": "不管是感受到賴清德個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/580.wav", + "text": "他表達他願意來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/581.wav", + "text": "這是他的friendly" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/582.wav", + "text": "以及剛剛傅副總召所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/583.wav", + "text": "賴清德過去曾是立法院的同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/584.wav", + "text": "所以他回娘家他也很熟悉立法院的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/585.wav", + "text": "所以是以這個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/586.wav", + "text": "因為賴清德可能對立法院夠熟悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/587.wav", + "text": "他個人也釋出了善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/588.wav", + "text": "所以似乎詢答是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/589.wav", + "text": "或者是去推敲說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/590.wav", + "text": "他可以接受這樣子的詢問跟挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/591.wav", + "text": "行憲憲法的規定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/592.wav", + "text": "不要去假設他是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/593.wav", + "text": "它是一個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/594.wav", + "text": "所以制度是一個重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/595.wav", + "text": "不能因為人擁有什麼樣的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/596.wav", + "text": "所以去試想這個制度可以怎麼設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/597.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們再回到憲法本文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/598.wav", + "text": "本文第4條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/599.wav", + "text": "很清楚的是立法院於每年集會時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/600.wav", + "text": "得聽取總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/601.wav", + "text": "第一個報告出現了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/602.wav", + "text": "相關的就是職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/603.wav", + "text": "第二章之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/604.wav", + "text": "所以第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/605.wav", + "text": "有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/606.wav", + "text": "依中華民國憲法增修條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/607.wav", + "text": "等立法院得於每年集會時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/608.wav", + "text": "聽取總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/609.wav", + "text": "報告第一次出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/610.wav", + "text": "這是職權行使法第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/611.wav", + "text": "報告兩個字第一次出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/612.wav", + "text": "第十五條之二第一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/613.wav", + "text": "立法院得經全體立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/614.wav", + "text": "四分之一以上提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/615.wav", + "text": "院會決議後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/616.wav", + "text": "由程序委員會排定議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/617.wav", + "text": "就國家安全大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/618.wav", + "text": "聽取總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/619.wav", + "text": "報告這兩字第二次出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/620.wav", + "text": "這是第十五條之二的第一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/621.wav", + "text": "第十五條之二的第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/622.wav", + "text": "總統就其職權相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/623.wav", + "text": "之國家大政方針得咨請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/624.wav", + "text": "立法院同意後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/625.wav", + "text": "赴立法院進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/626.wav", + "text": "這是第二次出現的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/627.wav", + "text": "就在同一條第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/628.wav", + "text": "然後再來第十五條之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/629.wav", + "text": "立法院聽取國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/630.wav", + "text": "前三日要送書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/631.wav", + "text": "所以報告報告又出現了兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/632.wav", + "text": "第十五條之四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/633.wav", + "text": "立法委員於總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/634.wav", + "text": "完畢後得就報告不明瞭處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/635.wav", + "text": "提出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/636.wav", + "text": "由黨團協商決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/637.wav", + "text": "而最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/638.wav", + "text": "就前項委員之發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/639.wav", + "text": "經總統同意時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/640.wav", + "text": "得綜合再進行補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/641.wav", + "text": "所以這當中我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/642.wav", + "text": "從憲法本文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/643.wav", + "text": "再到職權行使法的4個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/644.wav", + "text": "出現了好幾次的都是報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/645.wav", + "text": "所以為什麼在修法跟憲政的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/646.wav", + "text": "援引它的文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/647.wav", + "text": "非常清楚而且謹慎地是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/648.wav", + "text": "用報告兩個字為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/649.wav", + "text": "而從頭到尾沒有出現詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/650.wav", + "text": "答復這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/651.wav", + "text": "即便是職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/652.wav", + "text": "第十五條之四的最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/653.wav", + "text": "第二項就是經總統同意時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/654.wav", + "text": "得針對委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/655.wav", + "text": "進行綜合報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/656.wav", + "text": "它也是報告的形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/657.wav", + "text": "當然我也要替鍾佳濱委員爭取一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/658.wav", + "text": "等一下他是不是能夠有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/659.wav", + "text": "補充說明的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/660.wav", + "text": "如果他沒有獲得補充說明的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/661.wav", + "text": "再簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/662.wav", + "text": "其實在場除了佳濱委員過去擔任國代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/663.wav", + "text": "邱議瑩委員曾經擔任國代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/664.wav", + "text": "我自己在1997年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/665.wav", + "text": "民進黨團的助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/666.wav", + "text": "所以我也曾經在國民大會裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/667.wav", + "text": "去見證過李登輝前總統的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/668.wav", + "text": "國情報告的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/669.wav", + "text": "因此幾次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/670.wav", + "text": "國民大會修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/671.wav", + "text": "1991年是第一次修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/672.wav", + "text": "1992年是第二次修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/673.wav", + "text": "然後都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/674.wav", + "text": "的這個原則之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/675.wav", + "text": "一直到2005年的第4屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/676.wav", + "text": "任務型國大修憲之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/677.wav", + "text": "廢除了國大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/678.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱委員的論述很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/679.wav", + "text": "我是真的很想替他爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/680.wav", + "text": "他自己講會比我替他講來得更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/681.wav", + "text": "因為佳濱委員去回溯幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/682.wav", + "text": "修憲之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/683.wav", + "text": "回應到我剛剛說的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/684.wav", + "text": "落在條文他還是以報告兩字為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/685.wav", + "text": "也就是李前總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/686.wav", + "text": "僅曾於最後結束前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/687.wav", + "text": "再進行一次總結發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/688.wav", + "text": "這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/689.wav", + "text": "行憲的實例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/690.wav", + "text": "實踐憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/691.wav", + "text": "精神之下所發生的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/692.wav", + "text": "所以未來如果有總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/693.wav", + "text": "再應邀赴立院國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/694.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統所負有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/695.wav", + "text": "義務應當不能超出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/696.wav", + "text": "李前總統當年在國民大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/697.wav", + "text": "之範圍也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/698.wav", + "text": "在委員提問之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/699.wav", + "text": "總統是在最終他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/700.wav", + "text": "得以決定選擇他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/701.wav", + "text": "要不要來進行一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/702.wav", + "text": "總結發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/703.wav", + "text": "\n我希望我的說法沒有溢出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/704.wav", + "text": "我對於憲政的理解還有當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/705.wav", + "text": "李登輝前總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/706.wav", + "text": "的這整個實例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/707.wav", + "text": "所以我從第一個我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/708.wav", + "text": "履行創造一個憲���慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/709.wav", + "text": "我們要跳脫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/710.wav", + "text": "因人設置的那個想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/711.wav", + "text": "因為賴清德當過立委他辯才無礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/712.wav", + "text": "慣例\n第二個就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/713.wav", + "text": "憲法本文到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/714.wav", + "text": "職權行使法的4個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/715.wav", + "text": "所出現的文字都是報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/716.wav", + "text": "兩個字從來沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/717.wav", + "text": "答詢回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/718.wav", + "text": "我們作為立法委員對於每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/719.wav", + "text": "修法的立法原意我們都會去推敲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/720.wav", + "text": "而且會去研究它過去為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/721.wav", + "text": "這樣落款文字的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/722.wav", + "text": "非常清楚所以它是報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/723.wav", + "text": "第三個再搭配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/724.wav", + "text": "過去行憲的經驗李登輝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/725.wav", + "text": "前總統所運行的國民大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/726.wav", + "text": "報告他是最終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/727.wav", + "text": "進行一個綜合發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/728.wav", + "text": "所以我再清楚地表明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/729.wav", + "text": "創造憲政慣例總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/730.wav", + "text": "不是對國會負責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/731.wav", + "text": "他不是接受詢問之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/732.wav", + "text": "Q&A" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/733.wav", + "text": "不是這樣的因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/734.wav", + "text": "綜合即便是最終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/735.wav", + "text": "總統可以決定他要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/736.wav", + "text": "或不要進行綜合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/737.wav", + "text": "總結的發言這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/738.wav", + "text": "我們一定要抓得非常精準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/739.wav", + "text": "我們在創造憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/740.wav", + "text": "不要溢出憲法的規範還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/741.wav", + "text": "實際運行的一個實際經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/742.wav", + "text": "我再一次爭取讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/743.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱法制委員會的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/744.wav", + "text": "今天能夠在場發言他是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/745.wav", + "text": "過去有經驗的當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/746.wav", + "text": "邱議瑩委員也是謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/747.wav", + "text": "柯建銘總召先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/748.wav", + "text": "舉手洪孟楷委員請稍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/749.wav", + "text": "院長各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/750.wav", + "text": "立法院同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/751.wav", + "text": "我們上次花了三個半鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/752.wav", + "text": "在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/753.wav", + "text": "總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/754.wav", + "text": "其實有點像在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/755.wav", + "text": "開憲法法庭兩造有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/756.wav", + "text": "不同的意見的憲法法庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/757.wav", + "text": "剛才吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/758.wav", + "text": "以及邱議瑩委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/759.wav", + "text": "曾經做過國大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/760.wav", + "text": "那我們來看整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/761.wav", + "text": "李登輝總統的時候曾經有修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/762.wav", + "text": "第一次修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/763.wav", + "text": "1991年修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/764.wav", + "text": "總統由國大選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/765.wav", + "text": "國大選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/766.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/767.wav", + "text": "國大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/768.wav", + "text": "可以有修憲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/769.wav", + "text": "到1992年第二次修憲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/770.wav", + "text": "總統要直選的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/771.wav", + "text": "但是總統要直選的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/772.wav", + "text": "國大剩下什麼權力呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/773.wav", + "text": "司法考試監察的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/774.wav", + "text": "現在單一國會的權力回到我們這裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/775.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個演變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/776.wav", + "text": "李登輝還是在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/777.wav", + "text": "並檢討國是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/778.wav", + "text": "提供建言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/779.wav", + "text": "換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/780.wav", + "text": "他還是保留給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/781.wav", + "text": "們同意權的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/782.wav", + "text": "檢討國是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/783.wav", + "text": "提供建言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/784.wav", + "text": "總共去了7次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/785.wav", + "text": "是綜合回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/786.wav", + "text": "沒有存在所謂的即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/787.wav", + "text": "\n2005年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/788.wav", + "text": "第7次修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/789.wav", + "text": "就在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/790.wav", + "text": "大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/791.wav", + "text": "整個全部都改變了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/792.wav", + "text": "完畢以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/793.wav", + "text": "也廢了國大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/794.wav", + "text": "所以那一次修憲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/795.wav", + "text": "第4條就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/796.wav", + "text": "立法院作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/797.wav", + "text": "國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/798.wav", + "text": "但沒有辦法那一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/799.wav", + "text": "並檢討國是提供建言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/800.wav", + "text": "不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/801.wav", + "text": "因為總統是民選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/802.wav", + "text": "國大選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/803.wav", + "text": "總統當然要對國大負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/804.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在回到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/805.wav", + "text": "很重要的憲政體制上面來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/806.wav", + "text": "我是覺得這樣比較有意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/807.wav", + "text": "也就是說我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/808.wav", + "text": "同時要看待整個修憲過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/809.wav", + "text": "的演變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/810.wav", + "text": "整個臺灣憲政體制是這樣發展而來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/811.wav", + "text": "也很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/812.wav", + "text": "也曾經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/813.wav", + "text": "立法院已經變成單一國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/814.wav", + "text": "了單一國會當然我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/815.wav", + "text": "也可以修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/816.wav", + "text": "\n整個憲法上的設計是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/817.wav", + "text": "呢憲法寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/818.wav", + "text": "是第53條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/819.wav", + "text": "行政院是國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/820.wav", + "text": "最高行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/821.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/822.wav", + "text": "從第53條到第61條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/823.wav", + "text": "都在講行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/824.wav", + "text": "有編列預算的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/825.wav", + "text": "會通過以後送來給立法院審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/826.wav", + "text": "很清楚第62" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/827.wav", + "text": "是有關立法委員的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/828.wav", + "text": "尤其第63條寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/829.wav", + "text": "立法院是在議決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/830.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/831.wav", + "text": "這個是憲法給我們的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/832.wav", + "text": "所以立法委員的權力是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/833.wav", + "text": "\n我們再回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/834.wav", + "text": "憲法增修條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/835.wav", + "text": "第2條總統的職權到底寫在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/836.wav", + "text": "大家找總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/837.wav", + "text": "到底在做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/838.wav", + "text": "憲法本文提到總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/839.wav", + "text": "是元首三軍統帥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/840.wav", + "text": "那總統的職權到底怎麼行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/841.wav", + "text": "過去還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/842.wav", + "text": "行政院長對法律案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/843.wav", + "text": "副署權都修掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/844.wav", + "text": "大家看一看在憲法增修條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/845.wav", + "text": "第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/846.wav", + "text": "主要是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/847.wav", + "text": "主要是針對國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/848.wav", + "text": "有關總統的條文就只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/849.wav", + "text": "對國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/850.wav", + "text": "方針總統的權力就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/851.wav", + "text": "對國家安全的大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/852.wav", + "text": "所以我們要解釋說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/853.wav", + "text": "國防兩岸外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/854.wav", + "text": "這個屬於總統的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/855.wav", + "text": "憲法增修條文寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/856.wav", + "text": "國家安全大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/857.wav", + "text": "下要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/858.wav", + "text": "同時設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/859.wav", + "text": "局過去國安三法的時代就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/860.wav", + "text": "所以很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/861.wav", + "text": "總統的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/862.wav", + "text": "就是國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/863.wav", + "text": "這寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/864.wav", + "text": "總統是民選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/865.wav", + "text": "嘛他是對選民負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/866.wav", + "text": "總統不是對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/867.wav", + "text": "行政院對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/868.wav", + "text": "這很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/869.wav", + "text": "這個邏輯應該是順著下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/870.wav", + "text": "嘛行政院對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/871.wav", + "text": "所以憲法增修條文第3條寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/872.wav", + "text": "總統指定行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/873.wav", + "text": "來立法院做施政方針並備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/874.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/875.wav", + "text": "有剛才我們講的總質詢嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/876.wav", + "text": "部會首長當然到委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/877.wav", + "text": "第3條就寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/878.wav", + "text": "所以權力分立非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/879.wav", + "text": "誰對誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/880.wav", + "text": "一個人對一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/881.wav", + "text": "假如行政院提出的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/882.wav", + "text": "政策在立法院不通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/883.wav", + "text": "它可以提出覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/884.wav", + "text": "沒有過的話你就要吞下去否則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/885.wav", + "text": "你就是倒閣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/886.wav", + "text": "修訂以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/887.wav", + "text": "就沒有倒閣的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/888.wav", + "text": "行政院長也不理它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/889.wav", + "text": "當然接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/890.wav", + "text": "可以提不信任案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/891.wav", + "text": "就你根本藐視國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/892.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/893.wav", + "text": "我再把這個東西講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/894.wav", + "text": "我不講清楚大家天天在鬧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/895.wav", + "text": "很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/896.wav", + "text": "今天我們再回到這整個邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/897.wav", + "text": "來談這個事情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/898.wav", + "text": "剛才黃珊珊委員談的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/899.wav", + "text": "有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/900.wav", + "text": "統問統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/901.wav", + "text": "嘛就一個黨團問完另一個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/902.wav", + "text": "在設計上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/903.wav", + "text": "總統不是對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/904.wav", + "text": "做國情報告而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/905.wav", + "text": "不是來給你質詢給你問的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/906.wav", + "text": "當然你有不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/907.wav", + "text": "事項的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/908.wav", + "text": "提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/909.wav", + "text": "問題的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/910.wav", + "text": "他有絕對主動權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/911.wav", + "text": "我要不要回答你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/912.wav", + "text": "有他的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/913.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛黃珊珊委員所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/914.wav", + "text": "我相信你也是律師出身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/915.wav", + "text": "的統問統答就是變相的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/916.wav", + "text": "因為總統並不是給你質詢用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/917.wav", + "text": "這一點我們先釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/918.wav", + "text": "否則我們再一直談下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/919.wav", + "text": "接下來我們談一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/920.wav", + "text": "宣示一個東西但是我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/921.wav", + "text": "他重點在宣示什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/922.wav", + "text": "我們都知道總統來就是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/923.wav", + "text": "憲政慣例從立法院先開始等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/924.wav", + "text": "但是他只講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/925.wav", + "text": "我假如講錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/926.wav", + "text": "請傅委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/927.wav", + "text": "安排及形式上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/928.wav", + "text": "沒有強烈要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/929.wav", + "text": "這代表什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/930.wav", + "text": "安排及形式上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/931.wav", + "text": "你要在合憲底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/932.wav", + "text": "讓總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/933.wav", + "text": "踐行他憲法上的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/934.wav", + "text": "我們來釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/935.wav", + "text": "上次洪孟楷及傅崐萁委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/936.wav", + "text": "都談過相同問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/937.wav", + "text": "再回答1次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/938.wav", + "text": "有3次總統的回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/939.wav", + "text": "這是一個變相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/940.wav", + "text": "詢洪孟楷的意見講這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/941.wav", + "text": "請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/942.wav", + "text": "我們憲法設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/943.wav", + "text": "總統是來給立法院質詢的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/944.wav", + "text": "當然是行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/945.wav", + "text": "嘛所以在這個地方大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/946.wav", + "text": "把觀念講清楚才有可能往下走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/947.wav", + "text": "不然一直鬧下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/948.wav", + "text": "以上就是我所談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/949.wav", + "text": "可是你贊成哪一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/950.wav", + "text": "一定要合憲性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/951.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/952.wav", + "text": "合憲性就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/953.wav", + "text": "總統來做國情報告以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/954.wav", + "text": "你有問題問他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/955.wav", + "text": "他得嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/956.wav", + "text": "是他的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/957.wav", + "text": "這是他的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/958.wav", + "text": "要3個問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/959.wav", + "text": "落實在具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/960.wav", + "text": "總統得來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/961.wav", + "text": "他可以主動要求來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/962.wav", + "text": "或我們請他來都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/963.wav", + "text": "國情報告以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/964.wav", + "text": "就是對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/965.wav", + "text": "有疑問的地方可以提出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/966.wav", + "text": "接下來往下走是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/967.wav", + "text": "總統要不要回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/968.wav", + "text": "是總統權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/969.wav", + "text": "兩種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/970.wav", + "text": "第一個當然就是綜合回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/971.wav", + "text": "第二個他想依政黨來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/972.wav", + "text": "我把它完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/973.wav", + "text": "他說一個政黨完畢總統要回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/974.wav", + "text": "就是一個政黨完畢就回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/975.wav", + "text": "一個政黨完畢就回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/976.wav", + "text": "只有3次回答機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/977.wav", + "text": "這就是變相的即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/978.wav", + "text": "不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/979.wav", + "text": "副總召所提這兩個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/980.wav", + "text": "您都不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/981.wav", + "text": "一個是綜合答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/982.wav", + "text": "第二個是根據政黨依序答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/983.wav", + "text": "這個要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/984.wav", + "text": "他提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/985.wav", + "text": "就是拋磚引玉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/986.wav", + "text": "嘛他說看看這兩個方案傅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/987.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召的意思是完全高度尊重賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/988.wav", + "text": "只要在形式上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/989.wav", + "text": "完全合乎憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/990.wav", + "text": "規定總召有最大的善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/991.wav", + "text": "很大的彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/992.wav", + "text": "但是我現在聽不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/993.wav", + "text": "賴清德到底要不要回答的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/994.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/995.wav", + "text": "他要有合憲性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/996.wav", + "text": "果不合憲性統問統答他怎麼回答呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/997.wav", + "text": "破壞憲政體制他不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/998.wav", + "text": "謝謝你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/999.wav", + "text": "書記長發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1000.wav", + "text": "感謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1001.wav", + "text": "從頭到尾到今天我們討論第一個案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1002.wav", + "text": "我們釋出最大的善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1003.wav", + "text": "不管是在行政院長施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1004.wav", + "text": "跟延會的事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1005.wav", + "text": "我們都採取最寬容的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1006.wav", + "text": "來配合大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1007.wav", + "text": "有5個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1008.wav", + "text": "可不可以在別人發言的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1009.wav", + "text": "不要插嘴好不好尊重大家的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1010.wav", + "text": "我們也希望今天大家坐下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1011.wav", + "text": "是真的尊重你尊重我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1012.wav", + "text": "尊重大家不要浪費大家時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1013.wav", + "text": "請針對問題來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1014.wav", + "text": "而不是又在話山話水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1015.wav", + "text": "剛剛院長主持的非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1016.wav", + "text": "就是直指核心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1017.wav", + "text": "問說你講了5分鐘8分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1018.wav", + "text": "到底你想表達什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1019.wav", + "text": "我想這一點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1020.wav", + "text": "最重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1021.wav", + "text": "\n總結來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1022.wav", + "text": "請先看一下國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1023.wav", + "text": "跟民眾黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1024.wav", + "text": "第二案跟第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1025.wav", + "text": "我們都有特別寫到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1026.wav", + "text": "要新任行政院長施政方針報告前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1027.wav", + "text": "邀請總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1028.wav", + "text": "來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1029.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛也已經在遞案的時候釋出最大善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1030.wav", + "text": "我們認為行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1031.wav", + "text": "可以在5月31號來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1032.wav", + "text": "施政總報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1033.wav", + "text": "我們也算過在5月31��之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1034.wav", + "text": "有3次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1035.wav", + "text": "院會時間分別是5月21" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1036.wav", + "text": "日5月24日跟5月28" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1037.wav", + "text": "日也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1038.wav", + "text": "等一下各黨團不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1039.wav", + "text": "說一定要行政院長先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1040.wav", + "text": "因為我們兩個的提案其實都寫得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1041.wav", + "text": "就是總統先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1042.wav", + "text": "再行政院長\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1043.wav", + "text": "再者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1044.wav", + "text": "講到的我們如果都要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1045.wav", + "text": "憲法的語言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1046.wav", + "text": "文字之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1047.wav", + "text": "媒體有報導即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1048.wav", + "text": "統問統答一問一答等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1049.wav", + "text": "這個是方便民眾大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1050.wav", + "text": "如果今天我們就事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1051.wav", + "text": "論事如同剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1052.wav", + "text": "民進黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1053.wav", + "text": "講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1054.wav", + "text": "規定的話那我們就用憲法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1055.wav", + "text": "憲法規定我們得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1056.wav", + "text": "邀請總統來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1057.wav", + "text": "而在立法院職權行使法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1058.wav", + "text": "我們立法委員可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1059.wav", + "text": "提出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1060.wav", + "text": "總統就立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1061.wav", + "text": "提出問題的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1062.wav", + "text": "總統同意之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1063.wav", + "text": "得做補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1064.wav", + "text": "換言之一個權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1065.wav", + "text": "是提出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1066.wav", + "text": "另外一個權利是報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1067.wav", + "text": "但是他的報告要不要針對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1068.wav", + "text": "或是立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1069.wav", + "text": "對於總統講報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1070.wav", + "text": "沒有一定規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1071.wav", + "text": "要針對問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1072.wav", + "text": "可是這是對人民報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1073.wav", + "text": "如果今天立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1074.wav", + "text": "在提出問題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1075.wav", + "text": "沒有針對總統負責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1076.wav", + "text": "外交國防兩岸等相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1077.wav", + "text": "那是我們立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1078.wav", + "text": "失職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1079.wav", + "text": "所以我們有6分鐘的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1080.wav", + "text": "我們對我們自己負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1081.wav", + "text": "一樣我們得邀請總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1082.wav", + "text": "詢問他同不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1083.wav", + "text": "針對提出的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1084.wav", + "text": "總統有兩個權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1085.wav", + "text": "可以同意或是他可以不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1086.wav", + "text": "我們現在不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1087.wav", + "text": "決定因為在場沒有一位是總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1088.wav", + "text": "我們不需要幫賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1089.wav", + "text": "決定他要不要同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1090.wav", + "text": "或他要不要不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1091.wav", + "text": "我們只提出如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1092.wav", + "text": "因為這次有20位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1093.wav", + "text": "都可以有發言的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1094.wav", + "text": "所以是不是以20位來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1095.wav", + "text": "4位提出問題一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1096.wav", + "text": "你要不要補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1097.wav", + "text": "總統可以不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1098.wav", + "text": "總統也可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1099.wav", + "text": "這個是總統的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1100.wav", + "text": "所以我們不用去設限總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1101.wav", + "text": "前四位委員講的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1102.wav", + "text": "不屑一顧不想回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1103.wav", + "text": "他也有他的權利說不回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1104.wav", + "text": "但我相信賴清德準總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1105.wav", + "text": "他應該不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1106.wav", + "text": "再者就回歸到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1107.wav", + "text": "他報告的時候是不是所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1108.wav", + "text": "民進黨團代表講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1109.wav", + "text": "其實不是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1110.wav", + "text": "提問的人有提問的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1111.wav", + "text": "但是我們沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1112.wav", + "text": "限制總統回答的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1113.wav", + "text": "以及限制回答的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1114.wav", + "text": "這就是最大的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1115.wav", + "text": "總統是報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1116.wav", + "text": "他是補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1117.wav", + "text": "所以說他不是詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1118.wav", + "text": "他不是在我們提問題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1119.wav", + "text": "他來做詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1120.wav", + "text": "而他補充報告的時候他的內容是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1121.wav", + "text": "沒有人給他限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1122.wav", + "text": "他可以針對委員提出來的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1123.wav", + "text": "做補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1124.wav", + "text": "他也可以不針對委員提出來的問��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1125.wav", + "text": "做補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1126.wav", + "text": "因為沒有一個人有辦法左右他的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1127.wav", + "text": "依照相關的法令給予他權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1128.wav", + "text": "讓他去做補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1129.wav", + "text": "所以這就很明顯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1130.wav", + "text": "絕對不存在剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1131.wav", + "text": "所謂統問統答就是變相的即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1132.wav", + "text": "這完全不是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1133.wav", + "text": "這一個描述完全是錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1134.wav", + "text": "\n再來我們現在提出來的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1135.wav", + "text": "也都是合乎憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1136.wav", + "text": "以及合乎立院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1137.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1138.wav", + "text": "綜整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1139.wav", + "text": "我們現在有幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1140.wav", + "text": "國民黨團上一次林思銘委員有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1141.wav", + "text": "不管是4位問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1142.wav", + "text": "詢問總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1143.wav", + "text": "要不要補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1144.wav", + "text": "或是5位問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1145.wav", + "text": "詢問總統要不要補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1146.wav", + "text": "總統原則上他有4次或5次的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1147.wav", + "text": "是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1148.wav", + "text": "針對或是不針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1149.wav", + "text": "提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1150.wav", + "text": "但是他有機會做補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1151.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1152.wav", + "text": "今天我們要討論的是一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1153.wav", + "text": "我們不要設限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1154.wav", + "text": "賴清德準總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1155.wav", + "text": "他願意或不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1156.wav", + "text": "或是賴清德準總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1157.wav", + "text": "他回答的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1158.wav", + "text": "我覺得如果任何一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1159.wav", + "text": "除非民進黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1160.wav", + "text": "跟我們說這是賴清德總統的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1161.wav", + "text": "我們都依照憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1162.wav", + "text": "依照立院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1163.wav", + "text": "給予我們的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1164.wav", + "text": "然後我們還自我設限的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1165.wav", + "text": "那我覺得我們沒有對人民有交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1166.wav", + "text": "國民黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1167.wav", + "text": "協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1168.wav", + "text": "在談到憲法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1169.wav", + "text": "這邏輯就錯誤了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1170.wav", + "text": "為什麼說邏輯錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1171.wav", + "text": "總統想到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1172.wav", + "text": "不是想來就可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1173.wav", + "text": "第一個他想來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1174.wav", + "text": "他要先咨請立法院同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1175.wav", + "text": "立法院想要總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1176.wav", + "text": "我們四分之一提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1177.wav", + "text": "院會做決議以後到程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1178.wav", + "text": "去排時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1179.wav", + "text": "排了他就一定來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1180.wav", + "text": "也未必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1181.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1182.wav", + "text": "立法委員得聽取總統的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1183.wav", + "text": "然後又沒有去課予他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1184.wav", + "text": "義務為什麼會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1185.wav", + "text": "就是總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1186.wav", + "text": "他不是立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1187.wav", + "text": "監督機關也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1188.wav", + "text": "一般講的行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1189.wav", + "text": "當然要對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1190.wav", + "text": "天經地義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1191.wav", + "text": "偏偏不是這樣設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1192.wav", + "text": "不是說總統想來對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1193.wav", + "text": "所謂國民黨所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1194.wav", + "text": "民意來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1195.wav", + "text": "所以他要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1196.wav", + "text": "No立法院同意才可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1197.wav", + "text": "不是他想來就可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1198.wav", + "text": "立法院做成決議以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1199.wav", + "text": "總統是不是一定有義務要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1200.wav", + "text": "那也未必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1201.wav", + "text": "如果我的憲法解釋沒錯的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1202.wav", + "text": "這個就是民進黨的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1203.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1204.wav", + "text": "\n第二個我們討論完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1205.wav", + "text": "時間6分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1206.wav", + "text": "人數順序都討論完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1207.wav", + "text": "討論這個有沒有意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1208.wav", + "text": "有意義啊我們上個禮拜還說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1209.wav", + "text": "我們是往前跨出一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1210.wav", + "text": "了我本來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1211.wav", + "text": "不想講話的可是你們又談到了憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1212.wav", + "text": "的規定如果真的要談憲法規定的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1213.wav", + "text": "總統報告完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1214.wav", + "text": "有不清楚的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1215.wav", + "text": "詢問完總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1216.wav", + "text": "得去做補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1217.wav", + "text": "好了我們去做決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1218.wav", + "text": "總統也不知道你們要問什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1219.wav", + "text": "就各政黨輪流來答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1220.wav", + "text": "或者是統問統答來答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1221.wav", + "text": "我們也太早幫他做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1222.wav", + "text": "有善意的時候其實都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1223.wav", + "text": "做成決定的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1224.wav", + "text": "很抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1225.wav", + "text": "嗎我不認為這合乎憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1226.wav", + "text": "只是如果真的願意且大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1227.wav", + "text": "有默契就談得下去但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1228.wav", + "text": "你們不是我看你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1229.wav", + "text": "的看今天國民黨這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1230.wav", + "text": "從整個法律的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1231.wav", + "text": "到這兩三次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1232.wav", + "text": "其實我真的還沒有看到善意啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1233.wav", + "text": "所以莊瑞雄幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1234.wav", + "text": "提了一個比較大膽一點的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1235.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有聽出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1236.wav", + "text": "意思是說我們時間定好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1237.wav", + "text": "一個人6分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1238.wav", + "text": "人數也定好了992" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1239.wav", + "text": "政黨次序也定好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1240.wav", + "text": "民眾黨民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1241.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1242.wav", + "text": "的他意思說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1243.wav", + "text": "全部都問完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1244.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統做最後的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1245.wav", + "text": "他可以通通不答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1246.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家就走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1247.wav", + "text": "也就是莊瑞雄幹事長點出這個要點出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1248.wav", + "text": "而不是我們過去三次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1249.wav", + "text": "朝野協商我們一直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1250.wav", + "text": "孜孜不倦在追求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1251.wav", + "text": "希望怎麼樣問他怎麼答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1252.wav", + "text": "我們三四個人問他三四個答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1253.wav", + "text": "或我們以政黨為代表他來答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1254.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄委員的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1255.wav", + "text": "我們就不要再去過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1256.wav", + "text": "問這一塊了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1257.wav", + "text": "完全尊重賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1258.wav", + "text": "這是民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1259.wav", + "text": "我嘗試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1260.wav", + "text": "因為莊瑞雄董事長委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1261.wav", + "text": "了莊瑞雄委員的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1262.wav", + "text": "我想請林思銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1263.wav", + "text": "副書記長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1264.wav", + "text": "委員其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1265.wav", + "text": "我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1266.wav", + "text": "得聽取總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1267.wav", + "text": "國情報告這在憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1268.wav", + "text": "增修條文寫得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1269.wav", + "text": "這是立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1270.wav", + "text": "權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1271.wav", + "text": "你同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1272.wav", + "text": "但是要怎麼進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1273.wav", + "text": "是不是就在我們立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1274.wav", + "text": "第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1275.wav", + "text": "來做出相關很明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1276.wav", + "text": "要件都寫得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1277.wav", + "text": "立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1278.wav", + "text": "同意就請他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1279.wav", + "text": "或者總統咨請我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1280.wav", + "text": "讓他來所以這寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1281.wav", + "text": "有沒有義務來如果今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1282.wav", + "text": "我們依照立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1283.wav", + "text": "邀請他來總統可以不來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1284.wav", + "text": "他不能拒絕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1285.wav", + "text": "因為在第十五條之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1286.wav", + "text": "寫得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1287.wav", + "text": "總統應在我們邀請之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1288.wav", + "text": "經過決議邀請總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1289.wav", + "text": "他就一定要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1290.wav", + "text": "\n他就一定要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1291.wav", + "text": "這是我先跟大家做的第一個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1292.wav", + "text": "\n第二個到底總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1293.wav", + "text": "來之後我們要怎麼樣進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1294.wav", + "text": "這在第十五條之4寫得非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1295.wav", + "text": "還要去做解讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1296.wav", + "text": "做報告我們可以有提問的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1297.wav", + "text": "權利這也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1298.wav", + "text": "提問的次序人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1299.wav", + "text": "什麼都講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1300.wav", + "text": "我們問了之後他是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1301.wav", + "text": "做補充報告還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1302.wav", + "text": "他要怎麼回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1303.wav", + "text": "這沒有很明確規定總統要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1304.wav", + "text": "報告權或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1305.wav", + "text": "補充報告的方式這沒有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1306.wav", + "text": "��黃珊珊副總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1307.wav", + "text": "講得很清楚尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1308.wav", + "text": "方式我們很open啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1309.wav", + "text": "說我們就是一定要要求他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1310.wav", + "text": "回答沒有這樣的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1311.wav", + "text": "我要特別澄清謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1312.wav", + "text": "照莊瑞雄幹事長的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1313.wav", + "text": "可聽可說大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1314.wav", + "text": "有這個彈性當然前面幾位是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1315.wav", + "text": "希望總統秉持一個善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1316.wav", + "text": "的氛圍能夠針對委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1317.wav", + "text": "做出一些補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1318.wav", + "text": "的說明與報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1319.wav", + "text": "接下來我們請傅崐萁總召請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1320.wav", + "text": "我發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1321.wav", + "text": "不用這麼冗長的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1322.wav", + "text": "相信我講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1323.wav", + "text": "大家都聽得懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1324.wav", + "text": "我們一再表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1325.wav", + "text": "我們有高度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1326.wav", + "text": "善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1327.wav", + "text": "在選舉前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1328.wav", + "text": "再三跟國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1329.wav", + "text": "表達希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1330.wav", + "text": "當選總統以後能夠到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1331.wav", + "text": "立法院來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1332.wav", + "text": "這是賴清德總統所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1333.wav", + "text": "表示的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1334.wav", + "text": "民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1335.wav", + "text": "三位幹部所提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1336.wav", + "text": "他可來可不來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1337.wav", + "text": "我要比較好奇的詢問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1338.wav", + "text": "這是柯總召個人的意思呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1339.wav", + "text": "還是賴總統的意思呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1340.wav", + "text": "因為賴總統是對全國國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1341.wav", + "text": "表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1342.wav", + "text": "他希望當選以後有機會到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1343.wav", + "text": "來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1344.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1345.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1346.wav", + "text": "柯總召要取代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1347.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1348.wav", + "text": "來幫他做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1349.wav", + "text": "甚至剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1350.wav", + "text": "也表示說他不一定要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1351.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1352.wav", + "text": "當然如果是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1353.wav", + "text": "柯總召權力有這麼大我們也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1354.wav", + "text": "第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1355.wav", + "text": "對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1356.wav", + "text": "明確的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1357.wav", + "text": "來做國情報告以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1358.wav", + "text": "總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1359.wav", + "text": "到國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1360.wav", + "text": "做國情報告以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1361.wav", + "text": "我們這些立法委員對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1362.wav", + "text": "其中不瞭解之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1363.wav", + "text": "提出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1364.wav", + "text": "今天聽起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1365.wav", + "text": "也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1366.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1367.wav", + "text": "表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1368.wav", + "text": "賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1369.wav", + "text": "可答可不答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1370.wav", + "text": "\n所以賴總統到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1371.wav", + "text": "立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1372.wav", + "text": "國情報告完我們把所有的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1373.wav", + "text": "都講完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1374.wav", + "text": "掉頭就走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1375.wav", + "text": "聽起來像是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1376.wav", + "text": "民進黨提出這樣一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1377.wav", + "text": "我想民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1378.wav", + "text": "剛剛有提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1379.wav", + "text": "他講完了就走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1380.wav", + "text": "並沒有我們憲法上說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1381.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1382.wav", + "text": "提問之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1383.wav", + "text": "提問之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1384.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1385.wav", + "text": "就相關的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1386.wav", + "text": "總統是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1387.wav", + "text": "解惑釋疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1388.wav", + "text": "畢竟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1389.wav", + "text": "那就是回應民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1390.wav", + "text": "所以我在這裡要特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1391.wav", + "text": "強調一件事情我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1392.wav", + "text": "賴總統是希望來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1393.wav", + "text": "立法院做國情報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1394.wav", + "text": "我也相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1395.wav", + "text": "賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1396.wav", + "text": "應該是尊重立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1397.wav", + "text": "相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1398.wav", + "text": "看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1399.wav", + "text": "來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1400.wav", + "text": "國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1401.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1402.wav", + "text": "我還是要再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1403.wav", + "text": "討論到現在民進黨不斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1404.wav", + "text": "提出的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1405.wav", + "text": "是不是就如同柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1406.wav", + "text": "講的這就是賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1407.wav", + "text": "總統的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1408.wav", + "text": "如果確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1409.wav", + "text": "是賴清德總統他的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1410.wav", + "text": "我想這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1411.wav", + "text": "就會比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1412.wav", + "text": "謝謝國民黨團的柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1413.wav", + "text": "因為我看到你舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1414.wav", + "text": "不是不行我要問一下黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1415.wav", + "text": "因為我們講好的佳濱兄對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1416.wav", + "text": "我絕對不是那個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1417.wav", + "text": "非常歡迎你來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1418.wav", + "text": "稍微等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1419.wav", + "text": "一直沒有談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1420.wav", + "text": "朝野協商的代表到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1421.wav", + "text": "在法案預算的時候是三個人嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1422.wav", + "text": "這一點請尊重過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1423.wav", + "text": "這一題一直沒有談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1424.wav", + "text": "上次差一點被你請出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1425.wav", + "text": "現在在那裡枯坐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1426.wav", + "text": "啦坦白講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1427.wav", + "text": "大家保持善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1428.wav", + "text": "的基本禮貌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1429.wav", + "text": "當過國大代表我剛才也跟你講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1430.wav", + "text": "應該請他發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1431.wav", + "text": "你可以再徵詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1432.wav", + "text": "黃總召是敬表不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1433.wav", + "text": "嘛我們再問看看好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1434.wav", + "text": "我們休息3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1435.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1436.wav", + "text": "現在我們繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1437.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請民進黨黨團柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1438.wav", + "text": "簡短發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1439.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1440.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1441.wav", + "text": "到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1442.wav", + "text": "我們都是在一個非常理性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1443.wav", + "text": "軌道上在談事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1444.wav", + "text": "尊重大家我也瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1445.wav", + "text": "對於國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1446.wav", + "text": "再做綜合回答補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1447.wav", + "text": "然後大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1448.wav", + "text": "談不下去我們就放旁���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1449.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1450.wav", + "text": "因為這個朝野協商期的1個月還沒到嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1451.wav", + "text": "接下去就剩下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1452.wav", + "text": "剩下二個議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1453.wav", + "text": "上次也談很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1454.wav", + "text": "我們應該就是說假如明天要處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1455.wav", + "text": "我們整個議事程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1456.wav", + "text": "要完整化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1457.wav", + "text": "朝野協商大家簽名決定幾個人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1458.wav", + "text": "明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1459.wav", + "text": "到議場的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1460.wav", + "text": "反正這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1461.wav", + "text": "早表決晚表決未來4年的結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1462.wav", + "text": "都是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1463.wav", + "text": "我們不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1464.wav", + "text": "沒有討論就直接表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1465.wav", + "text": "剛才也跟院長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1466.wav", + "text": "也跟傅總召談了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1467.wav", + "text": "有共同結論的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1468.wav", + "text": "明天就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1469.wav", + "text": "不必大動干戈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1470.wav", + "text": "了剩下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1471.wav", + "text": "職權行使法很多還沒談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1472.wav", + "text": "很多條文嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1473.wav", + "text": "反正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1474.wav", + "text": "以立法院的結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1475.wav", + "text": "我們承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1476.wav", + "text": "我們過去三十年來沒有贏過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1477.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1478.wav", + "text": "但是至少民主能夠在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1479.wav", + "text": "呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1480.wav", + "text": "所以院長假如這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1481.wav", + "text": "等一下徵得大家的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1482.wav", + "text": "我們就很理性的明天也不必衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1483.wav", + "text": "該表決就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1484.wav", + "text": "協商結論要簽完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1485.wav", + "text": "大家在院會上發言結束以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1486.wav", + "text": "我們照程序來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1487.wav", + "text": "至少這是一個很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1488.wav", + "text": "民主的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1489.wav", + "text": "最後防線好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1490.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1491.wav", + "text": "補充報告和綜合答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1492.wav", + "text": "聽不聽都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1493.wav", + "text": "各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1494.wav", + "text": "現在我就跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1495.wav", + "text": "報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1496.wav", + "text": "我們已經經過三次朝野協商討論總統的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1497.wav", + "text": "顯然大家已經把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1498.wav", + "text": "所有自己心中的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1499.wav", + "text": "看法意見都和盤托出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1500.wav", + "text": "我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1501.wav", + "text": "及各位官員已經列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1502.wav", + "text": "列席第三次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1503.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天就把總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1504.wav", + "text": "的這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1505.wav", + "text": "我們今天開始進入第四案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1506.wav", + "text": "院長等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1507.wav", + "text": "我補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1508.wav", + "text": "結束以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1509.wav", + "text": "我還是要釐清一個觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1510.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1511.wav", + "text": "並不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1512.wav", + "text": "憲法增修條文第4條寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1513.wav", + "text": "立法院於每年集會時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1514.wav", + "text": "這在憲法增修條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1515.wav", + "text": "第4條寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1516.wav", + "text": "於每年集會時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1517.wav", + "text": "你叫他來他就一定要來這是我們的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1518.wav", + "text": "那我們的職權行使法怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1519.wav", + "text": "聽取總統國情報告就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1520.wav", + "text": "就是得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1521.wav", + "text": "接下來的第十五條之二則是規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1522.wav", + "text": "總統可以咨請立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1523.wav", + "text": "然後來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1524.wav", + "text": "這是一個管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1525.wav", + "text": "他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1526.wav", + "text": "是得你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1527.wav", + "text": "你聽我講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1528.wav", + "text": "我們得邀請他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1529.wav", + "text": "他也可以咨請說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1530.wav", + "text": "阿扁都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1531.wav", + "text": "我把它講完不要插話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1532.wav", + "text": "院長等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1533.wav", + "text": "讓我講完嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1534.wav", + "text": "我把它做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1535.wav", + "text": "我們上次是講說總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1536.wav", + "text": "不必先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1537.wav", + "text": "行政院長先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1538.wav", + "text": "他今天又回到說總統要先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1539.wav", + "text": "而且又講出指定的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1540.wav", + "text": "521524528" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1541.wav", + "text": "���的講法和上次是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1542.wav", + "text": "總統要先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1543.wav", + "text": "我時間給你喬好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1544.wav", + "text": "了是521524528" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1545.wav", + "text": "然後我們來談的531" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1546.wav", + "text": "就是請行政院長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1547.wav", + "text": "所以大家不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1548.wav", + "text": "耍詭計啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1549.wav", + "text": "每次講的話不要都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1550.wav", + "text": "上次講的很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1551.wav", + "text": "20個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1552.wav", + "text": "請問他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1553.wav", + "text": "沒有這回事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1554.wav", + "text": "這個就有點變相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1555.wav", + "text": "造成政治衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1556.wav", + "text": "就要回答一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1557.wav", + "text": "總共回答5次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1558.wav", + "text": "等一下我把它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1559.wav", + "text": "爭點先講出來留待下一次協商我們才能夠談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1560.wav", + "text": "好但是洪孟楷講過一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1561.wav", + "text": "他說總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1562.wav", + "text": "是來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1563.wav", + "text": "補充報告而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1564.wav", + "text": "不是質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1565.wav", + "text": "報告就是報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1566.wav", + "text": "總統來做國情報告就是報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1567.wav", + "text": "那也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1568.wav", + "text": "不要設限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1569.wav", + "text": "\n還有傅崐萁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1570.wav", + "text": "一直質問我的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1571.wav", + "text": "你柯總召的意思還是賴清德的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1572.wav", + "text": "了賴總統在選舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1573.wav", + "text": "就講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1574.wav", + "text": "了是合法合憲他一定來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1575.wav", + "text": "這個當然是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1576.wav", + "text": "所以我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1577.wav", + "text": "對於今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1578.wav", + "text": "所談的這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1579.wav", + "text": "包括民眾黨的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1580.wav", + "text": "說一黨問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1581.wav", + "text": "總統不對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1582.wav", + "text": "的總統指派行政院長來到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1583.wav", + "text": "做施政報告對大家負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1584.wav", + "text": "所以報告就是報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1585.wav", + "text": "質詢就是質詢是兩碼子事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1586.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1587.wav", + "text": "邀請賴清德總統至立法院進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1588.wav", + "text": "我們留待下次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1589.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我們繼續討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1590.wav", + "text": "第四案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1591.wav", + "text": "環島高速鐵路建設特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1592.wav", + "text": "花東快速公路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1593.wav", + "text": "建設特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1594.wav", + "text": "請國民黨黨團說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1595.wav", + "text": "說明提案旨趣請說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1596.wav", + "text": "是哪一個先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1597.wav", + "text": "請國民黨先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1598.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1599.wav", + "text": "從民國88年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1600.wav", + "text": "臺灣高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1601.wav", + "text": "動工到95年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1602.wav", + "text": "完工通車以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1603.wav", + "text": "整個南北的距離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1604.wav", + "text": "不但縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1605.wav", + "text": "也讓整個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1606.wav", + "text": "各方面的動力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1607.wav", + "text": "還有經濟實力大幅提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1608.wav", + "text": "就如同當年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1609.wav", + "text": "經國先生十大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1610.wav", + "text": "中山高速公路以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1611.wav", + "text": "讓臺灣能夠整體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1612.wav", + "text": "蛻變成為亞洲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1613.wav", + "text": "四小龍之首（龍頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1614.wav", + "text": "）國家的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1615.wav", + "text": "重大的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1616.wav", + "text": "本來就應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1617.wav", + "text": "積極的來推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1618.wav", + "text": "而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1619.wav", + "text": "臺灣高鐵通車以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1620.wav", + "text": "我們全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1621.wav", + "text": "臺灣島就這麼小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1622.wav", + "text": "三萬六千平方公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1623.wav", + "text": "國土裡面到底有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1624.wav", + "text": "均衡發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1625.wav", + "text": "人道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1626.wav", + "text": "人本的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1627.wav", + "text": "有沒有基本的平權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1628.wav", + "text": "現在不光是整體經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1629.wav", + "text": "是不是在一個共同生活圈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1630.wav", + "text": "更重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1631.wav", + "text": "經由這次的大地震" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1632.wav", + "text": "大家也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1633.wav", + "text": "只要是新開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1634.wav", + "text": "這些新的路廊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1635.wav", + "text": "蘇花改��車以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1636.wav", + "text": "不但在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1637.wav", + "text": "在這次大地震裡面文風不動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1638.wav", + "text": "緊急時刻共同避難的處所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1639.wav", + "text": "我們也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1640.wav", + "text": "之後整個臺灣高鐵安好如初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1641.wav", + "text": "所以對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1642.wav", + "text": "整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1643.wav", + "text": "宜花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1644.wav", + "text": "這些最基礎的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1645.wav", + "text": "我們是不是要用交通平權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1646.wav", + "text": "生命無價的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1647.wav", + "text": "來讓整個臺灣成為一個共同生活圈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1648.wav", + "text": "而且是兩個小時的共同生活圈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1649.wav", + "text": "提到環島高鐵不是夢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1650.wav", + "text": "以後我們也多次在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1651.wav", + "text": "在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1652.wav", + "text": "跟歷任的蘇貞昌院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1653.wav", + "text": "都有提到這些相關的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1654.wav", + "text": "也特別表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1655.wav", + "text": "得到蘇貞昌院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1656.wav", + "text": "跟陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1657.wav", + "text": "我們也要特別感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1658.wav", + "text": "在今年2月初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1659.wav", + "text": "陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1660.wav", + "text": "來拜訪您的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1661.wav", + "text": "你也告訴他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1662.wav", + "text": "對臺灣有一個重大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1663.wav", + "text": "國道6號要打通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1664.wav", + "text": "臺灣高鐵環島要做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1665.wav", + "text": "可能完工的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1666.wav", + "text": "大家都不在世上了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1667.wav", + "text": "不過沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1668.wav", + "text": "活到100歲應該不會有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1669.wav", + "text": "我們一起來坐環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1670.wav", + "text": "\n我想今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1671.wav", + "text": "大家都是善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1672.wav", + "text": "對國土的規劃跟建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1673.wav", + "text": "我們要積極來推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1674.wav", + "text": "當然朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1675.wav", + "text": "有不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1676.wav", + "text": "但是這絕對不是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1677.wav", + "text": "我們一再的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1678.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1679.wav", + "text": "大家各自所表達的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1680.wav", + "text": "我們對民進黨所提出的相關看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1681.wav", + "text": "也非常的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1682.wav", + "text": "民眾黨討論了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1683.wav", + "text": "我們也做了相關的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1684.wav", + "text": "所以現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1685.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1686.wav", + "text": "是不用特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1687.wav", + "text": "第二個是不設置基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1688.wav", + "text": "原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1689.wav", + "text": "比照臺灣高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1690.wav", + "text": "做國內的BOT" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1691.wav", + "text": "招商或國際的BOT招商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1692.wav", + "text": "整個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1693.wav", + "text": "在跟民眾黨討論了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1694.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1695.wav", + "text": "暫定是12年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1696.wav", + "text": "因為我們對整個去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1697.wav", + "text": "在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1698.wav", + "text": "臺灣高鐵興建的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1699.wav", + "text": "在BOT的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1700.wav", + "text": "立法上也花了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1701.wav", + "text": "一段4年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1702.wav", + "text": "基本上現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1703.wav", + "text": "工法都比過去還要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1704.wav", + "text": "更加的進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1705.wav", + "text": "我想從民國88年動工距今" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1706.wav", + "text": "今已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1707.wav", + "text": "25年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1708.wav", + "text": "了現在的工法也更加的進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1709.wav", + "text": "當然我們也瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1710.wav", + "text": "王國材部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1711.wav", + "text": "因為今天內閣總辭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1712.wav", + "text": "王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1713.wav", + "text": "我們在幫你圓夢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1714.wav", + "text": "所以我們馬上回應你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1715.wav", + "text": "也立即來圓夢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1716.wav", + "text": "我想宜蘭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1717.wav", + "text": "花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1718.wav", + "text": "臺東屏東的鄉親" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1719.wav", + "text": "被整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1720.wav", + "text": "中央過去的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1721.wav", + "text": "把他們劃在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1722.wav", + "text": "臺灣居民以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1723.wav", + "text": "我們非常遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1724.wav", + "text": "但是還好在王部長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1725.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵不是夢以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1726.wav", + "text": "我們馬上積極的跟進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1727.wav", + "text": "透過國內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1728.wav", + "text": "BOT或國際的BOT" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1729.wav", + "text": "執政黨能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1730.wav", + "text": "欣然接受我們大家一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1731.wav", + "text": "來為臺灣加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1732.wav", + "text": "能夠讓環島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1733.wav", + "text": "來推動來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1734.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1735.wav", + "text": "來報告一下今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1736.wav", + "text": "列席的幾位官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1737.wav", + "text": "第一位是交通部王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1738.wav", + "text": "然後是國家發展委員會的高副主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1739.wav", + "text": "還有其他所有列席的官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1740.wav", + "text": "包括財政部環境部文化部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1741.wav", + "text": "原住民族委員會法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1742.wav", + "text": "好熱情歡迎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1743.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1744.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1745.wav", + "text": "我還是要談一個程序性問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1746.wav", + "text": "當然我們非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1747.wav", + "text": "今天已經是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1748.wav", + "text": "內閣總辭了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1749.wav", + "text": "所以相關人員在後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1750.wav", + "text": "一些主管都換人了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1751.wav", + "text": "他們還是能夠來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1752.wav", + "text": "代表他們非常負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1753.wav", + "text": "只要有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1754.wav", + "text": "機會能夠對國家做一些貢獻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1755.wav", + "text": "我想他們還是秉持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1756.wav", + "text": "一個很好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1757.wav", + "text": "公務體系上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1758.wav", + "text": "的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1759.wav", + "text": "我們這一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1760.wav", + "text": "院長當了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1761.wav", + "text": "我們對於朝野協商上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1762.wav", + "text": "有曾經談過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1763.wav", + "text": "只要是程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1764.wav", + "text": "可以三個黨鞭來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1765.wav", + "text": "但是有關法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1766.wav", + "text": "以及預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1767.wav", + "text": "那個人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1768.wav", + "text": "不應該予以限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1769.wav", + "text": "剛才我提出鍾佳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1770.wav", + "text": "很謙虛的今天不跟你吵架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1771.wav", + "text": "不跟大家吵過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1772.wav", + "text": "也從來沒有這種慣例說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1773.wav", + "text": "委員來這裡不能講話的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1774.wav", + "text": "這個大概是破天荒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1775.wav", + "text": "堅持的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1776.wav", + "text": "有關於鍾佳濱委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1777.wav", + "text": "總召說OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1778.wav", + "text": "黃總召還是不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1779.wav", + "text": "我們歷史會記上這一刻\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1780.wav", + "text": "\n其實現在我還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1781.wav", + "text": "要談同樣問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1782.wav", + "text": "宜蘭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1783.wav", + "text": "當地的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1784.wav", + "text": "要不要出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1785.wav", + "text": "不可以出席嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1786.wav", + "text": "屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1787.wav", + "text": "經過原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1788.wav", + "text": "柯總召我是高雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1789.wav", + "text": "你是屏東人啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1790.wav", + "text": "屏東人啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1791.wav", + "text": "他是美濃選區沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1792.wav", + "text": "高雄啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1793.wav", + "text": "他是屏東人啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1794.wav", + "text": "他爸爸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1795.wav", + "text": "他爸爸是美麗島事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1796.wav", + "text": "難者民族英雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1797.wav", + "text": "我講簡單一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1798.wav", + "text": "法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1799.wav", + "text": "有關原住民保留區的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1800.wav", + "text": "都不能來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1801.wav", + "text": "我不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1802.wav", + "text": "以後包括總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1803.wav", + "text": "三個黨團的黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1804.wav", + "text": "是萬能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1805.wav", + "text": "專業委員非常大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1806.wav", + "text": "傷害委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1807.wav", + "text": "我們在立法院現在可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1808.wav", + "text": "什麼都委員會不讓你審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1809.wav", + "text": "這樣的立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1810.wav", + "text": "是我們要的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1811.wav", + "text": "這是我們要的國會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1812.wav", + "text": "你為什麼敬表不同意我就很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1813.wav", + "text": "這個東西是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1814.wav", + "text": "我們是不想在這裡吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1815.wav", + "text": "30年來不曾這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1816.wav", + "text": "能夠在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1817.wav", + "text": "踐行才有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1818.wav", + "text": "並不是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1819.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣就怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1820.wav", + "text": "所以我今天還是一樣回到一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1821.wav", + "text": "像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1822.wav", + "text": "我們召委來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1823.wav", + "text": "召委來了不能講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1824.wav", + "text": "有召委要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1825.wav", + "text": "院會做報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1826.wav", + "text": "所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1827.wav", + "text": "韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1828.wav", + "text": "我很誠懇再點出這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1829.wav", + "text": "這個問題不解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1830.wav", + "text": "立法院很難再走得下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1831.wav", + "text": "再回頭過來我要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1832.wav", + "text": "今天的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1833.wav", + "text": "剛才傅崐萁委員所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1834.wav", + "text": "談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1835.wav", + "text": "或是花東快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1836.wav", + "text": "以及國道六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1837.wav", + "text": "我想這些都是韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1838.wav", + "text": "領銜提案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1839.wav", + "text": "我們不在這裡談你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1840.wav", + "text": "領銜提案造成你角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1841.wav", + "text": "尷尬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1842.wav", + "text": "立法院組織法已經寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1843.wav", + "text": "要議事中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1844.wav", + "text": "這個不管沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1845.wav", + "text": "我相信你會中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1846.wav", + "text": "你也講過以後你大概也下不為例了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1847.wav", + "text": "好我們現在在談這個問題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1848.wav", + "text": "回到核心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1849.wav", + "text": "剛才傅崐萁委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1850.wav", + "text": "講了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1851.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員你們也合併提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1852.wav", + "text": "不用基金了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1853.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1854.wav", + "text": "錢從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1855.wav", + "text": "也不談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1856.wav", + "text": "主權基金怕被誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1857.wav", + "text": "中共一帶一路的主權基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1858.wav", + "text": "BOT本來就有條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1859.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1860.wav", + "text": "為了高鐵獎參條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1861.wav", + "text": "也立過BOT條例都立過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1862.wav", + "text": "以現行法律本來就可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1863.wav", + "text": "那是另外一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1864.wav", + "text": "模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1865.wav", + "text": "但是你這裡面有錢錢從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1866.wav", + "text": "也有談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1867.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1868.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁委員都講不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1869.wav", + "text": "到底要多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1870.wav", + "text": "過去花東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1871.wav", + "text": "曾經在王廷升的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1872.wav", + "text": "就提過了馬英九執政就提過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1873.wav", + "text": "後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1874.wav", + "text": "傅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1875.wav", + "text": "2016也提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1876.wav", + "text": "為什麼馬英九執政的時候不敢讓它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1877.wav", + "text": "這當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1878.wav", + "text": "的權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1879.wav", + "text": "我永遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1880.wav", + "text": "要講一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1881.wav", + "text": "所有立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1882.wav", + "text": "乃至於行政官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1883.wav", + "text": "都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1884.wav", + "text": "有基本上憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1885.wav", + "text": "及公法上的一個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1886.wav", + "text": "假如沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1887.wav", + "text": "你就非常不高興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1888.wav", + "text": "但是我可以不講嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1889.wav", + "text": "我可以不講嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1890.wav", + "text": "權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1891.wav", + "text": "行政院院會通過以後送到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1892.wav", + "text": "年度結束前三個月前送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1893.wav", + "text": "這再清楚不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1894.wav", + "text": "就是預算的編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1895.wav", + "text": "是屬於行政院的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1896.wav", + "text": "立法院是監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1897.wav", + "text": "這有主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1898.wav", + "text": "被動的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1899.wav", + "text": "憲法也分得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1900.wav", + "text": "立法院是審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1901.wav", + "text": "是議決預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1902.wav", + "text": "並沒有編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1903.wav", + "text": "所以這是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1904.wav", + "text": "的權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1905.wav", + "text": "\n在這裡我要談的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1906.wav", + "text": "我們的原始點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1907.wav", + "text": "我們也可以面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1908.wav", + "text": "但是要把話講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1909.wav", + "text": "所以我要在這裡講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1910.wav", + "text": "包括大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1911.wav", + "text": "號等等都寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1912.wav", + "text": "憲法第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1913.wav", + "text": "既然你這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1914.wav", + "text": "特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1915.wav", + "text": "立法院可以弄個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1916.wav", + "text": "變成法律案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1917.wav", + "text": "要叫行政院去分年編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1918.wav", + "text": "這是行政權的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1919.wav", + "text": "我們可以提建議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1920.wav", + "text": "我在這裡重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1921.wav", + "text": "國家有經費有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1922.wav", + "text": "對於各地建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1923.wav", + "text": "去投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1924.wav", + "text": "我們百分百贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1925.wav", + "text": "不會反對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1926.wav", + "text": "反正民進黨執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1927.wav", + "text": "已經對花東編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1928.wav", + "text": "列將近300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1929.wav", + "text": "也是在民進黨執政下動工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1930.wav", + "text": "我們現在還有蘇花安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1931.wav", + "text": "鐵路交通系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1932.wav", + "text": "等一下交通部長也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1933.wav", + "text": "一一闡明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1934.wav", + "text": "\n所以今天回到一個核心問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1935.wav", + "text": "和剛才上一個題目一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1936.wav", + "text": "那就是憲政原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1937.wav", + "text": "假如任何一個立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1938.wav", + "text": "我是桃竹苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1939.wav", + "text": "我是屏東的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1940.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱和屏東的莊瑞雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1941.wav", + "text": "或是邱議瑩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1942.wav", + "text": "發展特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1943.wav", + "text": "請問責任政治在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1944.wav", + "text": "國家其他政事都不要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1945.wav", + "text": "了我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1946.wav", + "text": "審預算都有政事別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1947.wav", + "text": "有國防外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1948.wav", + "text": "衛環什麼都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1949.wav", + "text": "經濟發展都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1950.wav", + "text": "你越過公共建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1951.wav", + "text": "可以一個人提出將近2兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1952.wav", + "text": "請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1953.wav", + "text": "這個國家怎麼經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1954.wav", + "text": "了去選總統幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1955.wav", + "text": "行政院長來幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1956.wav", + "text": "行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1957.wav", + "text": "變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1958.wav", + "text": "遂行傅崐萁委員所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1959.wav", + "text": "違憲的條文和預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1960.wav", + "text": "幫你護航不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1961.wav", + "text": "嘛是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1962.wav", + "text": "所以今天這個邏輯大家講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1963.wav", + "text": "假如一直講不清楚的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1964.wav", + "text": "這是原點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1965.wav", + "text": "請各位注意這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1966.wav", + "text": "謝謝接下來請黃國昌總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1967.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1968.wav", + "text": "我如果沒有記錯的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1969.wav", + "text": "上一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1970.wav", + "text": "要進行這個協商以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1971.wav", + "text": "院長有做一個很好的提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1972.wav", + "text": "說新的部長來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1973.wav", + "text": "我們再來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1974.wav", + "text": "我那時候聽了覺得有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1975.wav", + "text": "我只是先在程序上面問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1976.wav", + "text": "其實王國材部長很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1977.wav", + "text": "他也要離開交通部長的位子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1978.wav", + "text": "子今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1979.wav", + "text": "適合針對這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1980.wav", + "text": "進行實質的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1981.wav", + "text": "嗎我是提出程序上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1982.wav", + "text": "一個問題請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1983.wav", + "text": "至於說到實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1984.wav", + "text": "上的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1985.wav", + "text": "這個特別條例有沒有必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1986.wav", + "text": "編列的內容到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1987.wav", + "text": "合不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1988.wav", + "text": "當然是接下來實質討論的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1989.wav", + "text": "但問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1990.wav", + "text": "民主進步黨的總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1991.wav", + "text": "柯建銘先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1992.wav", + "text": "剛剛提出了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1993.wav", + "text": "他自認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1994.wav", + "text": "所謂憲政上的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1995.wav", + "text": "立法委員可以提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1996.wav", + "text": "然後用特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1997.wav", + "text": "來匡預算嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1998.wav", + "text": "讓我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/1999.wav", + "text": "困惑的事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2000.wav", + "text": "在2005年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2001.wav", + "text": "10月5號的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2002.wav", + "text": "陳水扁執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2003.wav", + "text": "有40位立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2004.wav", + "text": "共同提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2005.wav", + "text": "石門水庫及其集水區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2006.wav", + "text": "整治特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2007.wav", + "text": "然後就是用這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2008.wav", + "text": "匡列了預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2009.wav", + "text": "當初是40名立法委員提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2010.wav", + "text": "在這個特別條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2011.wav", + "text": "處理的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2012.wav", + "text": "還是用特別預算的方式做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2013.wav", + "text": "這不是行政部門提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2014.wav", + "text": "而是立法委員提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2015.wav", + "text": "其中的40名立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2016.wav", + "text": "我看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2017.wav", + "text": "不僅僅是國民黨的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2018.wav", + "text": "還有民主進步黨的立委也參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2019.wav", + "text": "大家全部都參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2020.wav", + "text": "那讓我開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2021.wav", + "text": "有一點困惑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2022.wav", + "text": "如果柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2023.wav", + "text": "今天講的是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2024.wav", + "text": "是真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2025.wav", + "text": "那就讓人無法理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2026.wav", + "text": "當初民主進步黨陳水扁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2027.wav", + "text": "政府執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2028.wav", + "text": "怎麼會允許40個立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2029.wav", + "text": "透過特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2030.wav", + "text": "去匡特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2031.wav", + "text": "呢套用柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2032.wav", + "text": "現在最喜歡掛在嘴上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2033.wav", + "text": "這不是毀憲亂政嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2034.wav", + "text": "而這種毀憲亂政的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2035.wav", + "text": "可以做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2036.wav", + "text": "那也不是只有2005年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2037.wav", + "text": "才這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2038.wav", + "text": "2016年2月24號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2039.wav", + "text": "所編發的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2040.wav", + "text": "重建及紓困特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2041.wav", + "text": "一樣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2042.wav", + "text": "也都是立法委員提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2043.wav", + "text": "啊有這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2044.wav", + "text": "這個特別條例也匡了特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2045.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2046.wav", + "text": "個特別條例最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2047.wav", + "text": "沒有進入實質的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2048.wav", + "text": "但當初這些委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2049.wav", + "text": "提出這樣的特別條例的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2050.wav", + "text": "我也不記得有任何人說他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2051.wav", + "text": "毀憲亂政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2052.wav", + "text": "這裡是在進行黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2053.wav", + "text": "的場合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2054.wav", + "text": "在黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2055.wav", + "text": "就是各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2056.wav", + "text": "針對他們的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2057.wav", + "text": "表示他們的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2058.wav", + "text": "當然沒有一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2059.wav", + "text": "講的是絕對正確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2060.wav", + "text": "這就是一個民主的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2061.wav", + "text": "大家進行民主的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2062.wav", + "text": "跟審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2063.wav", + "text": "如果能夠得到共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2064.wav", + "text": "我們就得到最大的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2065.wav", + "text": "能夠順利的解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2066.wav", + "text": "如果沒有辦法得到共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2067.wav", + "text": "那也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2068.wav", + "text": "因為在黨團協商的這個會場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2069.wav", + "text": "從來也就不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2070.wav", + "text": "去逼迫達成什麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2071.wav", + "text": "的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2072.wav", + "text": "因為這會牽涉到我們接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2073.wav", + "text": "所剩不多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2074.wav", + "text": "黨團協商時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2075.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2076.wav", + "text": "怎麼使用的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2077.wav", + "text": "所以我才請教一下院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2078.wav", + "text": "我前面所提出來的程序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2079.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2080.wav", + "text": "特別跟各位黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2081.wav", + "text": "同仁報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2082.wav", + "text": "因為上一次王部長高副主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2083.wav", + "text": "已經說明了他們單位的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2084.wav", + "text": "非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2085.wav", + "text": "這一次朝野協商請他們來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2086.wav", + "text": "針對這兩法律案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2087.wav", + "text": "國民黨跟民眾黨所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2088.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2089.wav", + "text": "我們是針對法的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2090.wav", + "text": "來進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2091.wav", + "text": "這點特別跟黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2092.wav", + "text": "報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2093.wav", + "text": "大家都同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2094.wav", + "text": "我們也可以請交通部各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2095.wav", + "text": "沒關係我們今天要討論內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2096.wav", + "text": "看看各位的意見因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2097.wav", + "text": "如果他們已經把他們的立場都表達得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2098.wav", + "text": "院長等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2099.wav", + "text": "我先問一下如果不同意沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2100.wav", + "text": "你不要急好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2101.wav", + "text": "現在這些部會首長在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2102.wav", + "text": "我現在徵詢大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2103.wav", + "text": "如果大家同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2104.wav", + "text": "他們可以離開如果不同意他們就繼續待在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2105.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2106.wav", + "text": "對不起請吳思瑤委員好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2107.wav", + "text": "因為我們這是黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2108.wav", + "text": "院長這是協商為什麼我們不可以發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2109.wav", + "text": "這個案子當時是交付到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2110.wav", + "text": "經濟跟交通聯席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2111.wav", + "text": "我是經濟委員會召委我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2112.wav", + "text": "為什麼不能發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2113.wav", + "text": "馬上跟你回報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2114.wav", + "text": "可以任其下去嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2115.wav", + "text": "照理講如果是這樣子的規矩的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2116.wav", + "text": "法案的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2117.wav", + "text": "應該是主審委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2118.wav", + "text": "的召委才能發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2119.wav", + "text": "沒來參加過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2120.wav", + "text": "法案逐條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2121.wav", + "text": "應該是不可以發言的喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2122.wav", + "text": "對不對院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2123.wav", + "text": "我已經當了6屆的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2124.wav", + "text": "的時候針對法條召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2125.wav", + "text": "是不可以發言的邱委員我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2126.wav", + "text": "馬上跟你回報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2127.wav", + "text": "交通部跟國家發展委員會的官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2128.wav", + "text": "要繼續留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2129.wav", + "text": "院長回答我的問題嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2130.wav", + "text": "我們都能夠讓他留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2131.wav", + "text": "表示一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2132.wav", + "text": "他們也很樂意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2133.wav", + "text": "現任的召委立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2134.wav", + "text": "這是什麼邏輯啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2135.wav", + "text": "你每次都敬表不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2136.wav", + "text": "剛才那個案子也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2137.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱要留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2138.wav", + "text": "說不行敬表不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2139.wav", + "text": "大家要直球對決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2140.wav", + "text": "啦要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2141.wav", + "text": "你剛才對我的挑戰我現在就回答你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2142.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2143.wav", + "text": "你所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2144.wav", + "text": "2005年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2145.wav", + "text": "石門水庫特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2146.wav", + "text": "那時候是阿扁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2147.wav", + "text": "為了擴大公共建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2148.wav", + "text": "英九後來上來也是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2149.wav", + "text": "後來發現石門水庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2150.wav", + "text": "淤泥很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2151.wav", + "text": "不處理不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2152.wav", + "text": "所以當地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2153.wav", + "text": "立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2154.wav", + "text": "和朝野都講說這個應該要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2155.wav", + "text": "所以在行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2156.wav", + "text": "同意底下才去制定這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2157.wav", + "text": "特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2158.wav", + "text": "你後來講的例子當初是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2159.wav", + "text": "的所以我們要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2160.wav", + "text": "你弄一個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2161.wav", + "text": "弄幾個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2162.wav", + "text": "要2兆這個東西還得了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2163.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2164.wav", + "text": "你們現在在變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2165.wav", + "text": "喔沒有特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2166.wav", + "text": "其實就是有特別條例存在怎麼沒有特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2167.wav", + "text": "當然是特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2168.wav", + "text": "你說我們沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2169.wav", + "text": "當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2170.wav", + "text": "違反權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2171.wav", + "text": "還在那邊詭辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2172.wav", + "text": "你是法學博士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2173.wav", + "text": "耶所以今天我要把很多問題談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2174.wav", + "text": "\n明天要怎麼表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2175.wav", + "text": "我們沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2176.wav", + "text": "但是立場要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2177.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2178.wav", + "text": "召委在這裡不能講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2179.wav", + "text": "卸任官員可以留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2180.wav", + "text": "這是什麼立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2181.wav", + "text": "接下來我要針對邱議瑩委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2182.wav", + "text": "兩個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2183.wav", + "text": "因為我們本來上次已經協商過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2184.wav", + "text": "由楊瓊瓔委員召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2185.wav", + "text": "黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2186.wav", + "text": "所有條文均保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2187.wav", + "text": "送請院長召集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2188.wav", + "text": "這是我們今天進入這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2189.wav", + "text": "第二您所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2190.wav", + "text": "為什麼召委不能發言的確是一個好問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2191.wav", + "text": "的確是一個好問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2192.wav", + "text": "但是我們前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2193.wav", + "text": "當然代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2194.wav", + "text": "可是這一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2195.wav", + "text": "這不是用表決的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2196.wav", + "text": "權是憲法規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2197.wav", + "text": "柯總召你讓我先講完我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2198.wav", + "text": "來龍去脈嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2199.wav", + "text": "那個子彈隨便亂射一通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2200.wav", + "text": "\n我說現在我們徵詢三黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2201.wav", + "text": "結果三黨都同意由召委來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2202.wav", + "text": "或者跟地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2203.wav", + "text": "建設有關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2204.wav", + "text": "這些委員可以列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2205.wav", + "text": "三黨都同意的話可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2206.wav", + "text": "另外我主席覺得邀請委員來列席的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2207.wav", + "text": "要經過三個黨團都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2208.wav", + "text": "那這些委員非常歡迎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2209.wav", + "text": "這是我們暫時妥協的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2210.wav", + "text": "這是暫時的權宜措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2211.wav", + "text": "從頭到尾這個問題都沒有講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2212.wav", + "text": "院長你要瞭解你的職務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2213.wav", + "text": "柯總召我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2214.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員你可以這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2215.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2216.wav", + "text": "\n國民黨黨團跟民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2217.wav", + "text": "是不是要表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2218.wav", + "text": "如果說新的法案審查的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2219.wav", + "text": "召集委員以後就列為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2220.wav", + "text": "主席我還是要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2221.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個不合理啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2222.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會的召委有兩席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2223.wav", + "text": "楊瓊瓔委員沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2224.wav", + "text": "那我關心這個案子我來參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2225.wav", + "text": "然後你不讓我發言你不讓我參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2226.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個也很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2227.wav", + "text": "每一個召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2228.wav", + "text": "對於自己的排案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2229.wav", + "text": "委員會裡頭案子的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2230.wav", + "text": "我們都必須要很慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2231.wav", + "text": "過去立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2232.wav", + "text": "是委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2233.wav", + "text": "但是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2234.wav", + "text": "的立法院不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2235.wav", + "text": "耶現在是只要3個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2236.wav", + "text": "或者是你們兩個黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2237.wav", + "text": "隨意要抽出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2238.wav", + "text": "隨意要表決就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2239.wav", + "text": "隨意要阻擋法案就阻擋法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2240.wav", + "text": "救人的法案都可以擋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2241.wav", + "text": "民進黨排的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2242.wav", + "text": "就說是你們國民黨排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2243.wav", + "text": "現在都是如你們的意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2244.wav", + "text": "耶但是你們有沒有想過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2245.wav", + "text": "立法院113席委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2246.wav", + "text": "不是只有你們6個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2247.wav", + "text": "才是立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2248.wav", + "text": "大家都是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2249.wav", + "text": "大家對於法案的關心程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2250.wav", + "text": "過去我從來沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2251.wav", + "text": "看過一個院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2252.wav", + "text": "是可以阻止委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2253.wav", + "text": "或者召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2254.wav", + "text": "參與法案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2255.wav", + "text": "不准他講話的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2256.wav", + "text": "你告訴我是依照哪一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2257.wav", + "text": "立法委員職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2258.wav", + "text": "哪一條有這樣規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2259.wav", + "text": "謝謝你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2260.wav", + "text": "這個不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2261.wav", + "text": "傅氏王朝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2262.wav", + "text": "所訂下的規範喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2263.wav", + "text": "傅氏王朝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2264.wav", + "text": "所訂下的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2265.wav", + "text": "絕對不是喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2266.wav", + "text": "我當這麼久的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2267.wav", + "text": "沒有看過像你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2268.wav", + "text": "這麼鴨霸的處理模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2269.wav", + "text": "協商不是這樣進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2270.wav", + "text": "好邱委員謝謝你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2271.wav", + "text": "我覺得韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2272.wav", + "text": "真的很委屈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2273.wav", + "text": "在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2274.wav", + "text": "不管是委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2275.wav", + "text": "也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2276.wav", + "text": "主席在主持議事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2277.wav", + "text": "大家都要在主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2278.wav", + "text": "的主持之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2279.wav", + "text": "照立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2280.wav", + "text": "議事規則來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2281.wav", + "text": "要發言都有一定的順序和程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2282.wav", + "text": "在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2283.wav", + "text": "也都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2284.wav", + "text": "但是唯獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2285.wav", + "text": "在朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2286.wav", + "text": "這也是當時民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2287.wav", + "text": "強烈要求不是三長就不可以進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2288.wav", + "text": "當場警告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2289.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2290.wav", + "text": "說你們不要落人來喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2291.wav", + "text": "要落人來大家來落喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2292.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2293.wav", + "text": "柯總召強烈要求之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2294.wav", + "text": "協商只有黨團三長才能進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2295.wav", + "text": "不能有其他人進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2296.wav", + "text": "有全程錄影的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2297.wav", + "text": "經由柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2298.wav", + "text": "強烈表達之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2299.wav", + "text": "民眾黨兩位立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2300.wav", + "text": "離開會場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2301.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2302.wav", + "text": "大家進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2303.wav", + "text": "確定以後的遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2304.wav", + "text": "就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2305.wav", + "text": "\n我想我們今天要再強調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2306.wav", + "text": "一致作成的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2307.wav", + "text": "我們應該就要照決議走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2308.wav", + "text": "一個國會是要有制度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2309.wav", + "text": "我們一直在強調的就是制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2310.wav", + "text": "我剛剛也很高興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2311.wav", + "text": "聽到有所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2312.wav", + "text": "的委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2313.wav", + "text": "就委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2314.wav", + "text": "我們真的很感動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2315.wav", + "text": "句話出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2316.wav", + "text": "我算是聽到比較正常的人講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2317.wav", + "text": "既然是委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2318.wav", + "text": "那為什麼委員會已經討論完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2319.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵在委員會沒有討論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2320.wav", + "text": "大家都清楚地表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2321.wav", + "text": "所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2322.wav", + "text": "詢答都詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2323.wav", + "text": "完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2324.wav", + "text": "詢答完畢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2325.wav", + "text": "召委也有召集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2326.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2327.wav", + "text": "就是楊瓊瓔委員召集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2328.wav", + "text": "一席都沒有到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2329.wav", + "text": "委員會已經討論完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2330.wav", + "text": "再經由召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2331.wav", + "text": "召集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2332.wav", + "text": "然後才建請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2333.wav", + "text": "韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2334.wav", + "text": "這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2335.wav", + "text": "都非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2336.wav", + "text": "也非常完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2337.wav", + "text": "我們不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2338.wav", + "text": "在立法院所有的議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2339.wav", + "text": "都有錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2340.wav", + "text": "我還要喚醒大家的記憶嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2341.wav", + "text": "會場要有制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2342.wav", + "text": "哪有在這裡又在人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2343.wav", + "text": "又不是三長但又跑到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2344.wav", + "text": "做人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2345.wav", + "text": "我們實在覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2346.wav", + "text": "為什麼國會制度的建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2347.wav", + "text": "有這麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2348.wav", + "text": "大家都照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2349.wav", + "text": "現行的規則走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2350.wav", + "text": "嘛沒有規則大家協議好是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2351.wav", + "text": "就照協議走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2352.wav", + "text": "嘛有條例照條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2353.wav", + "text": "沒有條例照慣例沒有慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2354.wav", + "text": "我們照協商協商出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2355.wav", + "text": "就是這樣我們要照走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2356.wav", + "text": "嘛我覺得院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2357.wav", + "text": "你的制度面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2358.wav", + "text": "不要因為人家刻意的挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2359.wav", + "text": "而不斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2360.wav", + "text": "犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2361.wav", + "text": "遵守規則的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2362.wav", + "text": "遵守規則的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2363.wav", + "text": "是應該要被尊重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2364.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2365.wav", + "text": "列席的委員法案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2366.wav", + "text": "召集委員本來是第五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2367.wav", + "text": "下一案才要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2368.wav", + "text": "現在被迫往前提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2369.wav", + "text": "大概在一個月前的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2370.wav", + "text": "我們曾經講過黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2371.wav", + "text": "列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2372.wav", + "text": "如果要有召集委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2373.wav", + "text": "列席的話經過三個黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2374.wav", + "text": "那是不是以後所有類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2375.wav", + "text": "這種法案也好預算也好只要是召集委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2376.wav", + "text": "就變成當然列席代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2377.wav", + "text": "我們先確定這一點這一點是非常關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2378.wav", + "text": "的請黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2379.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2380.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2381.wav", + "text": "我先講程序上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2382.wav", + "text": "的事情其實在這個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2383.wav", + "text": "現場我好幾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2384.wav", + "text": "次在程序上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2385.wav", + "text": "有跟院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2386.wav", + "text": "基於對院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2387.wav", + "text": "的尊重您在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2388.wav", + "text": "主持會議的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2389.wav", + "text": "即使在這個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2390.wav", + "text": "有時讓人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2391.wav", + "text": "覺得為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2392.wav", + "text": "有人可以任意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2393.wav", + "text": "按麥克風發言你都不制止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2394.wav", + "text": "讓人沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2395.wav", + "text": "接受為什麼有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2396.wav", + "text": "要守規矩有人可以不用守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2397.wav", + "text": "規矩甚至連你在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2398.wav", + "text": "話的時候他喜歡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2399.wav", + "text": "按麥克風講話就講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2400.wav", + "text": "所以我希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2401.wav", + "text": "再釐清一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2402.wav", + "text": "我們現在在進行黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2403.wav", + "text": "協商的基本規矩是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2404.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2405.wav", + "text": "當別人講話的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2406.wav", + "text": "要按麥克風講話都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2407.wav", + "text": "甚至你在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2408.wav", + "text": "主持會議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2409.wav", + "text": "要按麥克風講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2410.wav", + "text": "也可以是每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2411.wav", + "text": "人都可以還是每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2412.wav", + "text": "人都不可以還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2413.wav", + "text": "只有特定的人可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2414.wav", + "text": "其他的人不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2415.wav", + "text": "我要講很嚴肅的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2416.wav", + "text": "這一個規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2417.wav", + "text": "可能要請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2418.wav", + "text": "院長告訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2419.wav", + "text": "所有黨團協商的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2420.wav", + "text": "我們應該要遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2421.wav", + "text": "的規矩到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2422.wav", + "text": "黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2423.wav", + "text": "只有黨團的三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2424.wav", + "text": "可以到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2425.wav", + "text": "這個是當初柯建銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2426.wav", + "text": "站出���抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2427.wav", + "text": "他要求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2428.wav", + "text": "您做了這樣的裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2429.wav", + "text": "我們大家都遵守了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2430.wav", + "text": "今天要變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2431.wav", + "text": "這樣子的規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2432.wav", + "text": "不是不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2433.wav", + "text": "就把規則講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2434.wav", + "text": "而且要注意程序上的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2435.wav", + "text": "為什麼我說要注意程序上的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2436.wav", + "text": "如果我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2437.wav", + "text": "要建立一個新的規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2438.wav", + "text": "譬如說法律案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2439.wav", + "text": "哪一些委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2440.wav", + "text": "適合來參加黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2441.wav", + "text": "例如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2442.wav", + "text": "當初這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2443.wav", + "text": "負責主審的召集委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2444.wav", + "text": "那我們就應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2445.wav", + "text": "要把這個規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2446.wav", + "text": "讓那個召集委員知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2447.wav", + "text": "否則的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2448.wav", + "text": "會形成一個很奇怪的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2449.wav", + "text": "我們今天突然又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2450.wav", + "text": "變更了規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2451.wav", + "text": "那其他可能受這個規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2452.wav", + "text": "所影響的利害關係人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2453.wav", + "text": "都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2454.wav", + "text": "這樣子的話我覺得對他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2455.wav", + "text": "並不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2456.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2457.wav", + "text": "要變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2458.wav", + "text": "在這個會期我們一開始所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2459.wav", + "text": "只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2460.wav", + "text": "黨團三長可以參加黨團會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2461.wav", + "text": "要變更這個規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2462.wav", + "text": "在特定議案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2463.wav", + "text": "我記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2464.wav", + "text": "院長上一次在召集黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2465.wav", + "text": "你也很努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2466.wav", + "text": "試圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2467.wav", + "text": "要把這個規則給訂出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2468.wav", + "text": "譬如說法律案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2469.wav", + "text": "還可以邀請誰來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2470.wav", + "text": "預算案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2471.wav", + "text": "還可以邀請誰來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2472.wav", + "text": "我記得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2473.wav", + "text": "有一次黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2474.wav", + "text": "你真的很努力地試圖要建立這個規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2475.wav", + "text": "但是那一次的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2476.wav", + "text": "就無疾而終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2477.wav", + "text": "嘛因為你在試圖要建立這個規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2478.wav", + "text": "尋求大家意見的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2479.wav", + "text": "中間不斷地被打斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2480.wav", + "text": "導致這個規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2481.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法建立起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2482.wav", + "text": "\n所以拉回來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2483.wav", + "text": "回復您剛剛所垂詢的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2484.wav", + "text": "要針對法律案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2485.wav", + "text": "要針對預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2486.wav", + "text": "除了黨團三長以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2487.wav", + "text": "還可以邀哪一些委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2488.wav", + "text": "或哪一些委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2489.wav", + "text": "有意見可以來參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2490.wav", + "text": "我們都抱持開放的心胸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2491.wav", + "text": "可以來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2492.wav", + "text": "這個規則訂了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2493.wav", + "text": "就應該要讓各個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2494.wav", + "text": "都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2495.wav", + "text": "這個遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2496.wav", + "text": "而在這個新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2497.wav", + "text": "遊戲規則下面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2498.wav", + "text": "我們以後的會議才能夠進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2499.wav", + "text": "嘛要不然我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2500.wav", + "text": "突然在這裡變更了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2501.wav", + "text": "新的規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2502.wav", + "text": "其他的人都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2503.wav", + "text": "只有到場的人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2504.wav", + "text": "沒有到場而沒有收到這個規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2505.wav", + "text": "變更通知的委員而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2506.wav", + "text": "恐怕不是很公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2507.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2508.wav", + "text": "我想把前次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2509.wav", + "text": "幹部的意見就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2510.wav", + "text": "我所草擬的一個有關協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2511.wav", + "text": "的案子我想再唸一次給大家聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2512.wav", + "text": "我知道大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2513.wav", + "text": "很急著發言稍微等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2514.wav", + "text": "就是預算案協商時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2515.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團5人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2516.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團5人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2517.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團4人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2518.wav", + "text": "以上人數是包含黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2519.wav", + "text": "三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2520.wav", + "text": "除法案審查報告所列的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2521.wav", + "text": "院會說明人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2522.wav", + "text": "可參加院長朝野協商外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2523.wav", + "text": "如果各黨團有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2524.wav", + "text": "其他委員參加的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2525.wav", + "text": "經過各黨團都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2526.wav", + "text": "我們就允許增加委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2527.wav", + "text": "列席參與協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2528.wav", + "text": "這是我們在上上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2529.wav", + "text": "朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2530.wav", + "text": "我嘗試著把它唸出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2531.wav", + "text": "希望獲得各黨團的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2532.wav", + "text": "結果那一天因為開會太零散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2533.wav", + "text": "也就是黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2534.wav", + "text": "剛剛所提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2535.wav", + "text": "院長我非常非常非常尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2536.wav", + "text": "在場的每一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2537.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤我雖然年紀比較輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2538.wav", + "text": "但我的立委資歷沒有比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2539.wav", + "text": "我是三屆的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2540.wav", + "text": "我要沉重的跟院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2541.wav", + "text": "我往往是在您主持的協商會議上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2542.wav", + "text": "舉手舉最久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2543.wav", + "text": "手舉得最挺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2544.wav", + "text": "然後您最常略過我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2545.wav", + "text": "今天就好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2546.wav", + "text": "我希望以後不要再這樣好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2547.wav", + "text": "我也是一個立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2548.wav", + "text": "我是民進團黨團的幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2549.wav", + "text": "不要再刻意的略過我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2550.wav", + "text": "我首先要在此說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2551.wav", + "text": "\n第二個我個人是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2552.wav", + "text": "傾向不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2553.wav", + "text": "剛剛院長所說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2554.wav", + "text": "您試圖做的那樣子的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2555.wav", + "text": "協商決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2556.wav", + "text": "我要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2557.wav", + "text": "院長您真是辛苦跟難為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2558.wav", + "text": "把很簡單的事情被迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2559.wav", + "text": "要讓它複雜化的去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2560.wav", + "text": "把一個主持協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2561.wav", + "text": "可以很靈活很彈性的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2562.wav", + "text": "被迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2563.wav", + "text": "綁得死死的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2564.wav", + "text": "在場的黨鞭們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2565.wav", + "text": "我不要說是哪幾位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2566.wav", + "text": "黨鞭們主持協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2567.wav", + "text": "就是院長的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2568.wav", + "text": "依照過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2569.wav", + "text": "立法院運作數十年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2570.wav", + "text": "從來沒有任何一個院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2571.wav", + "text": "會在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2572.wav", + "text": "因為有其他的委員列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2573.wav", + "text": "而要去請問其他的黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2574.wav", + "text": "他可以留或可以走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2575.wav", + "text": "他可以發言或不可以發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2576.wav", + "text": "從來沒有發生過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2577.wav", + "text": "我替韓院長您抱屈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2578.wav", + "text": "啊所以從剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2579.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2580.wav", + "text": "如果要新上路一個新的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2581.wav", + "text": "要大家同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2582.wav", + "text": "您的言下之意是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2583.wav", + "text": "為什麼有李昆澤召委跟邱議瑩召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2584.wav", + "text": "坐在這好像這個制度還沒有講好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2585.wav", + "text": "其他委員不知道所以不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2586.wav", + "text": "我要在這裡還原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2587.wav", + "text": "其實在上一次的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2588.wav", + "text": "甚至上上次的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2589.wav", + "text": "不管是吳思瑤莊瑞雄或是柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2590.wav", + "text": "我們都很試圖地要建立起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2591.wav", + "text": "一個爭取法案或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2592.wav", + "text": "預算協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2593.wav", + "text": "其他相關的委員都能夠列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2594.wav", + "text": "我們講了N次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2595.wav", + "text": "只是不被理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2596.wav", + "text": "不被重視不被處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2597.wav", + "text": "所以才會限縮在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2598.wav", + "text": "現在的狀況韓院長很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2599.wav", + "text": "院長的主持權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2600.wav", + "text": "真的大大的被弱化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2601.wav", + "text": "今天誰在場可以講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2602.wav", + "text": "或是誰必須離席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2603.wav", + "text": "還要讓貴為立法院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2604.wav", + "text": "的您請問傅總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2605.wav", + "text": "可以嗎黃總召可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2606.wav", + "text": "我真的要替韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2607.wav", + "text": "啊您有至高無上的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2608.wav", + "text": "議長的主持權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2609.wav", + "text": "剛剛您說的為什���我並不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2610.wav", + "text": "要限縮人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2611.wav", + "text": "您是用人員的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2612.wav", + "text": "在看待未來協商出席的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2613.wav", + "text": "我們要很彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2614.wav", + "text": "跟很負責任地去面對每一個議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2615.wav", + "text": "議案是活的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2616.wav", + "text": "政策是活的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2617.wav", + "text": "您剛剛的說法就是5個5個4個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2618.wav", + "text": "預算的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2619.wav", + "text": "部分那是用人數在看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2620.wav", + "text": "是一個僵化的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2621.wav", + "text": "我要再次說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2622.wav", + "text": "每一個議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2623.wav", + "text": "關切的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2624.wav", + "text": "不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2625.wav", + "text": "來的委員也不太有人關切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2626.wav", + "text": "坦白說啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2627.wav", + "text": "有的議案是百家爭鳴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2628.wav", + "text": "基於重要的公共建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2629.wav", + "text": "如果您開放了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2630.wav", + "text": "像環島高鐵也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2631.wav", + "text": "今天的花東快速道路也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2632.wav", + "text": "我相信有非常多的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2633.wav", + "text": "不分黨派都想來關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2634.wav", + "text": "要看議案的本質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2635.wav", + "text": "本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2636.wav", + "text": "所以過去從王金平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2637.wav", + "text": "從蘇嘉全到游錫堃院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2638.wav", + "text": "主持的協商會場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2639.wav", + "text": "是大家都能夠充分地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2640.wav", + "text": "welcomeopen" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2641.wav", + "text": "接受大家來到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2642.wav", + "text": "參與的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2643.wav", + "text": "由院長主持的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2644.wav", + "text": "就是任何一個議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2645.wav", + "text": "想方設法匯聚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2646.wav", + "text": "最終的朝野共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2647.wav", + "text": "是最重要的場域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2648.wav", + "text": "而不是過水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2649.wav", + "text": "表決前最終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2650.wav", + "text": "政策的辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2651.wav", + "text": "需要多元的參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2652.wav", + "text": "需要朝野的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2653.wav", + "text": "共同來成就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2654.wav", + "text": "所以我不認同框死的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2655.wav", + "text": "以後每一個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2656.wav", + "text": "為了5個人誰可以來誰不可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2657.wav", + "text": "更麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2658.wav", + "text": "的所以講回來簡單的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2659.wav", + "text": "不要複雜化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2660.wav", + "text": "可以靈活彈性主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2661.wav", + "text": "議事的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2662.wav", + "text": "也不需要自己受制於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2663.wav", + "text": "部分黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2664.wav", + "text": "作出來的那個決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2665.wav", + "text": "是完全不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2666.wav", + "text": "的我必須要這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2667.wav", + "text": "以我九年多的國會資歷來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2668.wav", + "text": "\n再一次回顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2669.wav", + "text": "不要凡事都嫁禍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2670.wav", + "text": "給柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2671.wav", + "text": "什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2672.wav", + "text": "朝野的委員們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2673.wav", + "text": "都聽柯總召的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2674.wav", + "text": "柯建銘總召上一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2675.wav", + "text": "針對民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2676.wav", + "text": "第一次朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2677.wav", + "text": "時陳昭姿立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2678.wav", + "text": "有來到現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2679.wav", + "text": "如果來到現場是好好地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2680.wav", + "text": "就事論事沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2681.wav", + "text": "mostwelcome" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2682.wav", + "text": "可是那一天院長也記憶猶新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2683.wav", + "text": "陳昭姿委員來到現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2684.wav", + "text": "是直接針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2685.wav", + "text": "嗆聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2686.wav", + "text": "針對他投錯票的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2687.wav", + "text": "來這裡找柯建銘總召算帳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2688.wav", + "text": "那是一個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2689.wav", + "text": "失禮失態不合宜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2690.wav", + "text": "來到朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2691.wav", + "text": "是要來找人算帳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2692.wav", + "text": "所以在那一天的場域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2693.wav", + "text": "中柯建銘總召才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2694.wav", + "text": "這種程序性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2695.wav", + "text": "針對那天的議題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2696.wav", + "text": "要不要排食安專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2697.wav", + "text": "開議日是哪一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2698.wav", + "text": "它完全是落在議事運作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2699.wav", + "text": "程序性範疇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2700.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛您主持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2701.wav", + "text": "這個會期要延會到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2702.wav", + "text": "這種程序性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2703.wav", + "text": "我想大家是沒有意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2704.wav", + "text": "就是議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2705.wav", + "text": "（包括法律案預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2706.wav", + "text": "）都不應當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2707.wav", + "text": "強制去受限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2708.wav", + "text": "院長真的要懇求您聽進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2709.wav", + "text": "因為這是您的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2710.wav", + "text": "如果限縮了人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2711.wav", + "text": "限縮了人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2712.wav", + "text": "我想那個真的不利於民主多元的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2713.wav", + "text": "協商的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2714.wav", + "text": "\n好所以現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2715.wav", + "text": "再請教程序上的問題現在是直接進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2716.wav", + "text": "人數的那個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2717.wav", + "text": "還沒有進入花東快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2718.wav", + "text": "跟高鐵對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2719.wav", + "text": "是不是先進入那個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2720.wav", + "text": "如果花東快稍後再進入實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2721.wav", + "text": "我還有很多的內容要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2722.wav", + "text": "我的認知是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2723.wav", + "text": "現在好像已經進入協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2724.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣我們先就這個議題匯聚共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2725.wav", + "text": "了現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2726.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣我可以繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2727.wav", + "text": "那沒關係這可以彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2728.wav", + "text": "環島高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2729.wav", + "text": "請莊瑞雄委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2730.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2731.wav", + "text": "還有各位在場的協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2732.wav", + "text": "院長我是這樣看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2733.wav", + "text": "的朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2734.wav", + "text": "氣氛不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2735.wav", + "text": "大家都會想盡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2736.wav", + "text": "一些理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2737.wav", + "text": "嘛柯總召講的一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2738.wav", + "text": "也不會以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2739.wav", + "text": "就變成立法院的常態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2740.wav", + "text": "動不動就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2741.wav", + "text": "回復到說柯總召你講過3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2742.wav", + "text": "也跟院長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2743.wav", + "text": "其實大家在講的是程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2744.wav", + "text": "但是各黨有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2745.wav", + "text": "那就各自去做解讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2746.wav", + "text": "我以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2747.wav", + "text": "過去在當臺北市議員的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2748.wav", + "text": "朝野協商的��候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2749.wav", + "text": "那個不是只有三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2750.wav", + "text": "每一個人對地方建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2751.wav", + "text": "有關心的就是可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2752.wav", + "text": "站在議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2753.wav", + "text": "行政部門沒有困難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2754.wav", + "text": "甚至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2755.wav", + "text": "對行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2756.wav", + "text": "有人要凍結有人要刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2757.wav", + "text": "看有沒有辦法就儘量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2758.wav", + "text": "調和鼎鼐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2759.wav", + "text": "整個重大預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2760.wav", + "text": "碰到有要凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2761.wav", + "text": "的接下來有預算協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2762.wav", + "text": "一定很多人在關心地方建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2763.wav", + "text": "不管它是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2764.wav", + "text": "不同政黨的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2765.wav", + "text": "如果讓那些人就不能到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2766.wav", + "text": "也都很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2767.wav", + "text": "\n我甚至要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2768.wav", + "text": "當主席的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2769.wav", + "text": "本來就是權力很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2770.wav", + "text": "你那個叫做刻意尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2771.wav", + "text": "拿這個在做攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2772.wav", + "text": "沒完沒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2773.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思就是院長你那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2774.wav", + "text": "我可以講實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2775.wav", + "text": "我對於傅崐萁總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2776.wav", + "text": "關心東西的平衡及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2777.wav", + "text": "當然是敬佩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2778.wav", + "text": "可不可以擁有高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2779.wav", + "text": "我們不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2780.wav", + "text": "只是針對你用這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2781.wav", + "text": "我們是不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2782.wav", + "text": "而且我也要幫楊曜講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2783.wav", + "text": "你也替楊曜講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2784.wav", + "text": "這樣全國都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2785.wav", + "text": "的那裡是比較遠一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2786.wav", + "text": "這樣等一下民眾黨會說那是財政紀律的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2787.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2788.wav", + "text": "都可以開心地來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2789.wav", + "text": "但是對於提出的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2790.wav", + "text": "我真的就有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2791.wav", + "text": "也不會去決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2792.wav", + "text": "地方政府敬老津貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2793.wav", + "text": "臺北市議會做這樣的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2794.wav", + "text": "臺北市政府不管���一個政黨的人當市長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2795.wav", + "text": "他都不會就範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2796.wav", + "text": "你這個條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2797.wav", + "text": "我要提出你最荒謬我最不能認同的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2798.wav", + "text": "就是可行性評估到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2799.wav", + "text": "我們立法委員哪有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2800.wav", + "text": "然後你本來是10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2801.wav", + "text": "要去完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2802.wav", + "text": "都已經進入綜合規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2803.wav", + "text": "我們也不敢去奢望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2804.wav", + "text": "你這個叫做環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2805.wav", + "text": "島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2806.wav", + "text": "耶不然我聽到你那個從花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2807.wav", + "text": "到臺東又到屏東整個都圈起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2808.wav", + "text": "所以你應該改一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2809.wav", + "text": "這個環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2810.wav", + "text": "是從屏東開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2811.wav", + "text": "但是我還是堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2812.wav", + "text": "這是國家建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2813.wav", + "text": "哪一天我們立法院去決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2814.wav", + "text": "再來花個20兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2815.wav", + "text": "弄一個環海的高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2816.wav", + "text": "那會更快坐起來更爽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2817.wav", + "text": "叫做磁浮列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2818.wav", + "text": "全國人爽死了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2819.wav", + "text": "如果有這種異想天開的案的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2820.wav", + "text": "我們也希望國民黨來支持一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2821.wav", + "text": "敗選的人就是去監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2822.wav", + "text": "當選的人落實他的政見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2823.wav", + "text": "而不是敗選的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2824.wav", + "text": "透過政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2825.wav", + "text": "謝謝莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2826.wav", + "text": "兩位登記發言委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2827.wav", + "text": "等一下會依序發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2828.wav", + "text": "現在我們請秘書小姐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2829.wav", + "text": "來唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2830.wav", + "text": "我知道等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2831.wav", + "text": "我們正式請秘書小姐來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2832.wav", + "text": "唸環島高速鐵路建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2833.wav", + "text": "特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2834.wav", + "text": "修正動議對照表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2835.wav", + "text": "請宣讀法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2836.wav", + "text": "請宣讀第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2837.wav", + "text": "\n第1條為推動環島高速鐵路建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2838.wav", + "text": "發展大眾公共運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2839.wav", + "text": "平衡區域發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2840.wav", + "text": "促進觀光產業增進民眾福祉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2841.wav", + "text": "特制定本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2842.wav", + "text": "本條例未規定者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2843.wav", + "text": "適用其他法律之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2844.wav", + "text": "好請柯建銘總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2845.wav", + "text": "院長我以下講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2846.wav", + "text": "有一句話叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2847.wav", + "text": "騙人騙己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2848.wav", + "text": "就是坐在我對面的傅總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2849.wav", + "text": "他說這個在委員會有充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2850.wav", + "text": "委員會只是大體討論而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2851.wav", + "text": "已詢答以後就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2852.wav", + "text": "進入逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2853.wav", + "text": "逐條是3分鐘出去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2854.wav", + "text": "朝野協商亦復如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2855.wav", + "text": "這個委員會的朝野協商不會有結論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2856.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我們沒有去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2857.wav", + "text": "連黃國昌也沒有去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2858.wav", + "text": "然後呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2859.wav", + "text": "到最後過水來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2860.wav", + "text": "這裡要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2861.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁這不是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2862.wav", + "text": "你要講實情不要騙人騙己\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2863.wav", + "text": "至於洪孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2864.wav", + "text": "我講話洪孟楷插話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2865.wav", + "text": "我也算了沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2866.wav", + "text": "這我都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2867.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2868.wav", + "text": "你不要見樹不見林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2869.wav", + "text": "你一直迴避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2870.wav", + "text": "核心事項都不回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2871.wav", + "text": "有人插話怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2872.wav", + "text": "剛才是我在講話院長把我插話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2873.wav", + "text": "呢什麼院長講話我把他插話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2874.wav", + "text": "都有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2875.wav", + "text": "\n你一直在這上面去講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2876.wav", + "text": "你張開眼睛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2877.wav", + "text": "不是立法委員的有多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2878.wav", + "text": "八九十個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2879.wav", + "text": "啊何以容納不下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2880.wav", + "text": "兩個立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2881.wav", + "text": "來這裡參加會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2882.wav", + "text": "這什麼邏輯過去有這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2883.wav", + "text": "你不要見樹不見林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2884.wav", + "text": "在這裡講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2885.wav", + "text": "所有人都相信你講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2886.wav", + "text": "大家要憑良心講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2887.wav", + "text": "黨鞭的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2888.wav", + "text": "你曾經在2016年到2020年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2889.wav", + "text": "是蘇嘉全院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2890.wav", + "text": "撥一個鐘頭給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2891.wav", + "text": "罵官員把它變成質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2892.wav", + "text": "撥兩個鐘頭給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2893.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2894.wav", + "text": "然後你今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2895.wav", + "text": "要趕快把這個弄完走過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2896.wav", + "text": "既然你講出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2897.wav", + "text": "昧於良心的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2898.wav", + "text": "你過去常常在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2899.wav", + "text": "委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2900.wav", + "text": "要好好辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2901.wav", + "text": "5年我回去選舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2902.wav", + "text": "你攻擊我密室協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2903.wav", + "text": "那個制度是誰設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2904.wav", + "text": "好像我在做什麼壞事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2905.wav", + "text": "然後說立法院要廢除朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2906.wav", + "text": "都是你們講的大家來辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2907.wav", + "text": "\n今天有談話的空間嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2908.wav", + "text": "今天連理性談話的空間都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2909.wav", + "text": "你既然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2910.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2911.wav", + "text": "房間裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2912.wav", + "text": "立法委員不能坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2913.wav", + "text": "不能講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2914.wav", + "text": "過去是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2915.wav", + "text": "三十年來是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2916.wav", + "text": "從來不是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2917.wav", + "text": "我們在講程序性協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2918.wav", + "text": "另外一位委員跑進來大罵說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2919.wav", + "text": "我要負責我根本莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2920.wav", + "text": "所以說這程序性協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2921.wav", + "text": "長其他委員根本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2922.wav", + "text": "不關心這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2923.wav", + "text": "和預算的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2924.wav", + "text": "請你找出一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2925.wav", + "text": "你所看到查到的資料裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2926.wav", + "text": "都限定三個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2927.wav", + "text": "再來跟我講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2928.wav", + "text": "所以不要這樣詭辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2929.wav", + "text": "點再無限放大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2930.wav", + "text": "好像你是正義使者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2931.wav", + "text": "何來正義使者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2932.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2933.wav", + "text": "面對你的選民我都沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2934.wav", + "text": "請你面對你的良心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2935.wav", + "text": "請面對你是一個立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2936.wav", + "text": "這比較重要吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2937.wav", + "text": "對不起主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2938.wav", + "text": "我剛比洪孟楷委員早舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2939.wav", + "text": "李昆澤委員舉很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2940.wav", + "text": "一樣的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2941.wav", + "text": "幹部沒有比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2942.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2943.wav", + "text": "大家一樣都是立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2944.wav", + "text": "互相尊重一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2945.wav", + "text": "為什麼院長不讓我們發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2946.wav", + "text": "大家互相尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2947.wav", + "text": "我們也是黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2948.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2949.wav", + "text": "我們也是黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2950.wav", + "text": "這沒有什麼修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2951.wav", + "text": "我敬告韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2952.wav", + "text": "不要把自己做小了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2953.wav", + "text": "過去的院長沒有像您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2954.wav", + "text": "做這麼小的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2955.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2956.wav", + "text": "我先講話好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2957.wav", + "text": "尊重一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2958.wav", + "text": "院長已經指示了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2959.wav", + "text": "我們要尊重院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2960.wav", + "text": "你們有尊重院長嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2961.wav", + "text": "我覺得你們是在挾持院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2962.wav", + "text": "你們讓韓國瑜院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2963.wav", + "text": "做得這麼小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2964.wav", + "text": "以前你們敢這樣子對王金平嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2965.wav", + "text": "你們不敢這樣對王金平院長吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2966.wav", + "text": "王金平院長從來不會限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2967.wav", + "text": "幾個人能講話幾個人不能講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2968.wav", + "text": "不管是哪一個院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2969.wav", + "text": "之前我第十屆進來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2970.wav", + "text": "游錫堃院長我們也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2971.wav", + "text": "三個人可以參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2972.wav", + "text": "游院長也沒有限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2973.wav", + "text": "只有三個人可以參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2974.wav", + "text": "然後你們現在要求韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2975.wav", + "text": "以及訂出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2976.wav", + "text": "我可以稱讚一下韓院長嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2977.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長的英明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2978.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2979.wav", + "text": "這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2980.wav", + "text": "大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2981.wav", + "text": "要解決問題的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2982.wav", + "text": "都是有原因的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2983.wav", + "text": "你來我往這是朝野攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2984.wav", + "text": "一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2985.wav", + "text": "第一哪一個人講對講錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2986.wav", + "text": "這是直播的選民自有公斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2987.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2988.wav", + "text": "立法院30年來的遊戲規則很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2989.wav", + "text": "但是我們破壞那個遊戲規則的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2990.wav", + "text": "這個衝擊很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2991.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2992.wav", + "text": "有關法案預算幾個人可以參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2993.wav", + "text": "這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2994.wav", + "text": "否則的話立法院後面已經開始進入深水區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2995.wav", + "text": "沒有一個走得動啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2996.wav", + "text": "我們把它在一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2997.wav", + "text": "一個憲政慣例底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2998.wav", + "text": "行之三十年的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/2999.wav", + "text": "拿出來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3000.wav", + "text": "以前就可以現在為什麼不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3001.wav", + "text": "這要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3002.wav", + "text": "然後遊戲規則也講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3003.wav", + "text": "我要講的是這是立法院最後一道防線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3004.wav", + "text": "你也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3005.wav", + "text": "院長你存在就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3006.wav", + "text": "維持中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3007.wav", + "text": "\n至於兩個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3008.wav", + "text": "已經講了兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3009.wav", + "text": "再怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3010.wav", + "text": "我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3011.wav", + "text": "邏輯和理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3012.wav", + "text": "就是在憲政底下權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3013.wav", + "text": "底下來看待這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3014.wav", + "text": "所以有關條文的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3015.wav", + "text": "包括立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3016.wav", + "text": "叫行政院去編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3017.wav", + "text": "在我們眼光裡都是違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3018.wav", + "text": "但是我講違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3019.wav", + "text": "都聽不下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3020.wav", + "text": "條文甚少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3021.wav", + "text": "我們今天就講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3022.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3023.wav", + "text": "明天院會要怎麼進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3024.wav", + "text": "大��要心裡有個底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3025.wav", + "text": "沒有朝野協商簽名的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3026.wav", + "text": "院會實難進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3027.wav", + "text": "一定會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3028.wav", + "text": "史上最嚴重的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3029.wav", + "text": "這也不樂見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3030.wav", + "text": "\n新的國會大家磨合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3031.wav", + "text": "在這段時間重新磨合的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3032.wav", + "text": "也到了一個臨界點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3033.wav", + "text": "了必須冷靜下來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3034.wav", + "text": "所以我以下具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3035.wav", + "text": "反正這兩個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3036.wav", + "text": "我們已經討論兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3037.wav", + "text": "花了相當多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3038.wav", + "text": "我們至少程序把它走完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3039.wav", + "text": "第1條怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3040.wav", + "text": "稍微講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3041.wav", + "text": "我們還是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3042.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3043.wav", + "text": "二個法案也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3044.wav", + "text": "已經在兩輪裡面都講得很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3045.wav", + "text": "至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3046.wav", + "text": "大家再簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3047.wav", + "text": "明天院會我們只處理這兩個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3048.wav", + "text": "換言之就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3049.wav", + "text": "30年來就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3050.wav", + "text": "大體討論幾個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3051.wav", + "text": "發言每一條幾個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3052.wav", + "text": "明天就依序發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3053.wav", + "text": "反正4年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3054.wav", + "text": "我們沒有一個表決會贏的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3055.wav", + "text": "我們會認定這個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3056.wav", + "text": "要把話講清楚就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3057.wav", + "text": "這是我比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3058.wav", + "text": "斗膽地建議大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3059.wav", + "text": "\n今天我要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3060.wav", + "text": "凡是沒有經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3061.wav", + "text": "協商的程序好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3062.wav", + "text": "沒有經過院長主持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3063.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3064.wav", + "text": "乃至於院會發言的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3065.wav", + "text": "絕對不能破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3066.wav", + "text": "否則國會就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3067.wav", + "text": "死亡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3068.wav", + "text": "這是我今天要講的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3069.wav", + "text": "我會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3070.wav", + "text": "講這些話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3071.wav", + "text": "是今天大家要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3072.wav", + "text": "假如大家沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3073.wav", + "text": "最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3074.wav", + "text": "簽一個朝野協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3075.wav", + "text": "大體討論幾個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3076.wav", + "text": "這才是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3077.wav", + "text": "\n我引幾個案例給大家聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3078.wav", + "text": "2016年我們全面執政以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3079.wav", + "text": "2016年我們通過什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3080.wav", + "text": "不當黨產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3081.wav", + "text": "那時候在院會怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3082.wav", + "text": "在院會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3083.wav", + "text": "每一條發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3084.wav", + "text": "讓國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3085.wav", + "text": "表決就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3086.wav", + "text": "但我們走完這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3087.wav", + "text": "不會因為我們是國會過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3088.wav", + "text": "全部給你一下子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3089.wav", + "text": "封殺不能來講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3090.wav", + "text": "2017年促進轉型正義條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3091.wav", + "text": "也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3092.wav", + "text": "但是到最後一條一條表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3093.wav", + "text": "2018" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3094.wav", + "text": "農田水利會收歸國有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3095.wav", + "text": "亦復如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3096.wav", + "text": "2019年政治檔案條例也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3097.wav", + "text": "這是我們國會多數的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3098.wav", + "text": "但是我們瞭解這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3099.wav", + "text": "要讓每一個人講話講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3100.wav", + "text": "以後才表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3101.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂不協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3102.wav", + "text": "不發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3103.wav", + "text": "那時國會就要結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3104.wav", + "text": "我們剛才講的你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3105.wav", + "text": "假如這樣的話大家沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3106.wav", + "text": "我們就進入程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3107.wav", + "text": "程序性的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3108.wav", + "text": "朝野協商要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3109.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3110.wav", + "text": "你針對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3111.wav", + "text": "重新來檢視好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3112.wav", + "text": "謝謝請吳思瑤委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3113.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3114.wav", + "text": "如果大家等一下要進入程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3115.wav", + "text": "的條文我尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3116.wav", + "text": "但是因為我現在講述的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3117.wav", + "text": "跟我等一下條文的主張絕對相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3118.wav", + "text": "讓我花一點時間來闡述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3119.wav", + "text": "\n第一個本質上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3120.wav", + "text": "我們認為用立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3121.wav", + "text": "確實在權力運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3122.wav", + "text": "在憲法的運作層次上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3123.wav", + "text": "我們是立法委員一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3124.wav", + "text": "依法行政所以我們都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3125.wav", + "text": "很清楚預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3126.wav", + "text": "整個制度是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3127.wav", + "text": "預算籌編的權限是行政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3128.wav", + "text": "預算審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3129.wav", + "text": "是立法權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3130.wav", + "text": "預算執行是行政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3131.wav", + "text": "最後還有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3132.wav", + "text": "監督預算的執行是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3133.wav", + "text": "審計權所以相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3134.wav", + "text": "在預算法會計法決算法審計法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3135.wav", + "text": "公庫法財政紀律法跟公共債務法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3136.wav", + "text": "這些相關的預算法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3137.wav", + "text": "裡面都很清楚地告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3138.wav", + "text": "預算的籌編權是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3139.wav", + "text": "行政權而立法院能夠行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3140.wav", + "text": "的是監督權\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3141.wav", + "text": "講到實質層面因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3142.wav", + "text": "是立法委員法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3143.wav", + "text": "依法行政在依預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3144.wav", + "text": "法規來編列預算的過程我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3145.wav", + "text": "不能夠跳過交通的專業跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3146.wav", + "text": "財務試算其依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3147.wav", + "text": "的法規是政府公共建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3148.wav", + "text": "計畫先期作業實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3149.wav", + "text": "要點這個是所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3150.wav", + "text": "重大的建設都需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3151.wav", + "text": "適用的程序第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3152.wav", + "text": "法規就是中央政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3153.wav", + "text": "中程計畫預算編製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3154.wav", + "text": "辦法這樣一個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3155.wav", + "text": "的編製辦法也就是財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3156.wav", + "text": "的部分一定要能夠遵循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3157.wav", + "text": "我現在手上拿的這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3158.wav", + "text": "兩個第一個是攸關交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3159.wav", + "text": "建設相關的程序是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3160.wav", + "text": "不能夠略過的第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3161.wav", + "text": "預算編纂也有一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3162.wav", + "text": "法定期程但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3163.wav", + "text": "回到今天由傅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3164.wav", + "text": "所提的這兩個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3165.wav", + "text": "都沒有這些程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3166.wav", + "text": "如果大家願意看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3167.wav", + "text": "我今天特別把我能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3168.wav", + "text": "可行性評估到綜合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3169.wav", + "text": "規劃到環評計劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3170.wav", + "text": "到預算編纂我試圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3171.wav", + "text": "拿幾本來給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3172.wav", + "text": "看看現在在審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3173.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵請大家可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3174.wav", + "text": "看過來看過來我手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3175.wav", + "text": "這一本就是民國76年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3176.wav", + "text": "開始針對現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3177.wav", + "text": "高鐵所進行的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3178.wav", + "text": "評估這一本是歷史文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3179.wav", + "text": "我去國會圖書館借的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3180.wav", + "text": "76年開始有這本可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3181.wav", + "text": "評估之後才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3182.wav", + "text": "進入綜合規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3183.wav", + "text": "就是可行性評估確認yes" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3184.wav", + "text": "可以做才開始進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3185.wav", + "text": "綜合規劃基本設計細部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3186.wav", + "text": "設計而我手上的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3187.wav", + "text": "就是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3188.wav", + "text": "現行的高鐵後續的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3189.wav", + "text": "期末報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3190.wav", + "text": "工程建設計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3191.wav", + "text": "還有英文版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3192.wav", + "text": "因為我們要跟國外的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3193.wav", + "text": "合作這是英文版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3194.wav", + "text": "這是高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3195.wav", + "text": "我手上這邊還有傅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3196.wav", + "text": "最關心的花東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3197.wav", + "text": "安全回家的路手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3198.wav", + "text": "這個是蘇花改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3199.wav", + "text": "的可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3200.wav", + "text": "通過了可行性評估之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3201.wav", + "text": "才會有工程規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3202.wav", + "text": "報告書在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3203.wav", + "text": "然後它還要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3204.wav", + "text": "環評說明書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3205.wav", + "text": "每一本我都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3206.wav", + "text": "把它帶來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3207.wav", + "text": "最近剛通過的蘇花安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3208.wav", + "text": "我們要給花東���責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3209.wav", + "text": "安全的交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3210.wav", + "text": "就是蘇花安的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3211.wav", + "text": "評估通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3212.wav", + "text": "才會有各項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3213.wav", + "text": "計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3214.wav", + "text": "這個是現在剛被通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3215.wav", + "text": "蘇花安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3216.wav", + "text": "當然它不能略過的是環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3217.wav", + "text": "在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3218.wav", + "text": "大家可以看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3219.wav", + "text": "後面桌上的那幾個箱子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3220.wav", + "text": "都是我搬過來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3221.wav", + "text": "針對現行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3222.wav", + "text": "高鐵及蘇花改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3223.wav", + "text": "蘇花安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3224.wav", + "text": "所有的從可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3225.wav", + "text": "到綜合規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3226.wav", + "text": "細部計畫到最後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3227.wav", + "text": "預算編纂到期末報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3228.wav", + "text": "我全部都帶過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3229.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3230.wav", + "text": "這是行政權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3231.wav", + "text": "因為行政團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3232.wav", + "text": "才有這樣的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3233.wav", + "text": "才有這樣的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3234.wav", + "text": "負責任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3235.wav", + "text": "真的給我們一個安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3236.wav", + "text": "交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3237.wav", + "text": "\n所以為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3238.wav", + "text": "雖然我看到藍白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3239.wav", + "text": "國民黨跟民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3240.wav", + "text": "透過修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3241.wav", + "text": "共同提出了一個10個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3242.wav", + "text": "一個9個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3243.wav", + "text": "把特別預算拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3244.wav", + "text": "用公務預算來編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3245.wav", + "text": "但是公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3246.wav", + "text": "要編多少預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3247.wav", + "text": "還是需要我剛剛說的這些評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3248.wav", + "text": "它的路線怎麼經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3249.wav", + "text": "唯有行政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3250.wav", + "text": "才能夠去規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3251.wav", + "text": "更何況我們經過了一場大地震" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3252.wav", + "text": "所有地質環境的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3253.wav", + "text": "都在變化當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3254.wav", + "text": "這些交通專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3255.wav", + "text": "評估及財務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3256.wav", + "text": "在10個條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3257.wav", + "text": "高鐵案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3258.wav", + "text": "在9個條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3259.wav", + "text": "改一改填一填數字改一改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3260.wav", + "text": "從10年改成12年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3261.wav", + "text": "把特別預算改成公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3262.wav", + "text": "這樣子就可以遂行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3263.wav", + "text": "這是非常慎重的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3264.wav", + "text": "我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3265.wav", + "text": "經得起交通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3266.wav", + "text": "專業評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3267.wav", + "text": "的考驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3268.wav", + "text": "這才是負責任的給國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3269.wav", + "text": "最好的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3270.wav", + "text": "所以我對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3271.wav", + "text": "等一下的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3272.wav", + "text": "我真的都覺得這不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3273.wav", + "text": "立法權能夠進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3274.wav", + "text": "但是我敬佩我們立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3275.wav", + "text": "願意為地方建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3276.wav", + "text": "爭取最好最大的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3277.wav", + "text": "這是我們的建議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3278.wav", + "text": "我予以尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3279.wav", + "text": "\n我最後要回應一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3280.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3281.wav", + "text": "您剛提的兩個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3282.wav", + "text": "我一定要清楚回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3283.wav", + "text": "看待議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3284.wav", + "text": "政策不能夠去脈絡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3285.wav", + "text": "不能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3286.wav", + "text": "見樹不見林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3287.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召剛剛說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3288.wav", + "text": "過去也有在2005年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3289.wav", + "text": "有跨黨派的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3290.wav", + "text": "桃園的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3291.wav", + "text": "提出石門水庫及其集水區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3292.wav", + "text": "整治特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3293.wav", + "text": "為什麼2005年可以呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3294.wav", + "text": "今年2024年傅崐萁就不可以呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3295.wav", + "text": "我來回答您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3296.wav", + "text": "2005年的時空背景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3297.wav", + "text": "是由行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3298.wav", + "text": "先行提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3299.wav", + "text": "陳水扁執政任內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3300.wav", + "text": "行政院先行提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3301.wav", + "text": "水患治理特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3302.wav", + "text": "由行政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3303.wav", + "text": "先發動了一個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3304.wav", + "text": "及特別預算的編纂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3305.wav", + "text": "然後為了讓桃園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3306.wav", + "text": "地區的委員們能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3307.wav", + "text": "針對他們關心的石門水庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3308.wav", + "text": "特別有一個他們關切的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3309.wav", + "text": "條例所以是在朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3310.wav", + "text": "共議同意之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3311.wav", + "text": "讓委員提這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3312.wav", + "text": "但是它是循著行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3313.wav", + "text": "水患治理特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3314.wav", + "text": "而來這是第一個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3315.wav", + "text": "所以黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3316.wav", + "text": "您說錯了不要這樣去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3317.wav", + "text": "脈絡化帶錯的風向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3318.wav", + "text": "第二個您提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3319.wav", + "text": "0206震災條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3320.wav", + "text": "也有立委提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3321.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3322.wav", + "text": "臺南的立委關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3323.wav", + "text": "0206的震災重建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3324.wav", + "text": "但是委員提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3325.wav", + "text": "是為了彰顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3326.wav", + "text": "對於選區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3327.wav", + "text": "建設重建的重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3328.wav", + "text": "這個議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3329.wav", + "text": "也因為扞格了行政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3330.wav", + "text": "而且行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3331.wav", + "text": "地方政府都可以依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3332.wav", + "text": "已經上路的災害防救法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3333.wav", + "text": "來進行所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3334.wav", + "text": "震災相關重建工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3335.wav", + "text": "因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3336.wav", + "text": "0206震災條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3337.wav", + "text": "提案的立委並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3338.wav", + "text": "委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3339.wav", + "text": "它是一個象徵性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3340.wav", + "text": "所以這也會回應到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3341.wav", + "text": "為什麼現在行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3342.wav", + "text": "對於0403的花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3343.wav", + "text": "是以行政院的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3344.wav", + "text": "已經編列高達3,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3345.wav", + "text": "來進行而不需要特別立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3346.wav", + "text": "因為921之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3347.wav", + "text": "沒有災害防救法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3348.wav", + "text": "921震災條例的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3349.wav", + "text": "當我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3350.wav", + "text": "921之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3351.wav", + "text": "有了災害防救法的建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3352.wav", + "text": "所有的震災重建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3353.wav", + "text": "就依災害防救法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3354.wav", + "text": "我必須花時間回應這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3355.wav", + "text": "傅總召不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3356.wav", + "text": "讓您覺得時間可能比較急促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3357.wav", + "text": "請不要催促我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3358.wav", + "text": "我也是一個立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3359.wav", + "text": "我今天這麼認真地拿了這麼多的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3360.wav", + "text": "請不要發出怪異的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3361.wav", + "text": "我拿出這麼多負責任的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3362.wav", + "text": "就是要告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3363.wav", + "text": "我們支持交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3364.wav", + "text": "但是行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3365.wav", + "text": "有行政該做的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3366.wav", + "text": "也有行政才能做好的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3367.wav", + "text": "立委有立委的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3368.wav", + "text": "我們是監督建議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3369.wav", + "text": "然後讓整個工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3370.wav", + "text": "有地方民意的匯入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3371.wav", + "text": "但不代表立法權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3372.wav", + "text": "可以取代行政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3373.wav", + "text": "所以請大家看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3374.wav", + "text": "立法院有可能進行這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3375.wav", + "text": "交通專業的可行性評估嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3376.wav", + "text": "我們能夠由立委來做環境影響評估嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3377.wav", + "text": "我們可能由立委來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3378.wav", + "text": "專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3379.wav", + "text": "交通的各項規劃嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3380.wav", + "text": "\n這是行政的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3381.wav", + "text": "我們支持交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3382.wav", + "text": "但是嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3383.wav", + "text": "及憲法的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3384.wav", + "text": "我們不能扞格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3385.wav", + "text": "不能逾越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3386.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷委員請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3387.wav", + "text": "院長我想要請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3388.wav", + "text": "就是說因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3389.wav", + "text": "按照禮拜二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3390.wav", + "text": "程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3391.wav", + "text": "我們所排定的議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3392.wav", + "text": "跟議事的順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3393.wav", + "text": "我剛剛再確認了一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3394.wav", + "text": "應該沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3395.wav", + "text": "我們前三個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3396.wav", + "text": "都是跟國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3397.wav", + "text": "相關的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3398.wav", + "text": "都是跟國會改革相關的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3399.wav", + "text": "這個是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3400.wav", + "text": "我還是要再次表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3401.wav", + "text": "就是上一次您說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3402.wav", + "text": "就這兩個條例的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3403.wav", + "text": "等新的部長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3404.wav", + "text": "我也非常尊重院長的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3405.wav", + "text": "我覺得也有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3406.wav", + "text": "因為老實說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3407.wav", + "text": "現在大家非常多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3408.wav", + "text": "真的關切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3409.wav", + "text": "的是明天在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3410.wav", + "text": "針對國會改革法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3411.wav", + "text": "的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3412.wav", + "text": "這兩個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3413.wav", + "text": "的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3414.wav", + "text": "是不是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3415.wav", + "text": "在這個時候進行還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3416.wav", + "text": "依照您的指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3417.wav", + "text": "之前的考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3418.wav", + "text": "那個考慮我覺得是有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3419.wav", + "text": "等新的交通部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3420.wav", + "text": "因為明天要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3421.wav", + "text": "有關於國會改革的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3422.wav", + "text": "法案所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3423.wav", + "text": "我們今天要先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3424.wav", + "text": "確認清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3425.wav", + "text": "之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3426.wav", + "text": "我在黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3427.wav", + "text": "我確認過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3428.wav", + "text": "經過委員會的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3429.wav", + "text": "而且過了30日的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3430.wav", + "text": "冷凍期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3431.wav", + "text": "就已經踐行了立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3432.wav", + "text": "職權行使法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3433.wav", + "text": "所定的要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3434.wav", + "text": "那天協商的時候我講得滿清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3435.wav", + "text": "那第二天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3436.wav", + "text": "還有秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3437.wav", + "text": "再度地確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3438.wav", + "text": "這樣子的議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3439.wav", + "text": "我想我應該沒有誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3440.wav", + "text": "兩位當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3441.wav", + "text": "的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3442.wav", + "text": "因為我不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3443.wav", + "text": "用程序上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3444.wav", + "text": "這樣的事由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3445.wav", + "text": "來進行杯葛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3446.wav", + "text": "導致明天沒有辦法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3447.wav", + "text": "國會改革的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3448.wav", + "text": "我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3449.wav", + "text": "這個是大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3450.wav", + "text": "所不樂見的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3451.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3452.wav", + "text": "還是依照您剛剛的指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3453.wav", + "text": "我們按照這個順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3454.wav", + "text": "只不過我比較懇切地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3455.wav", + "text": "提供一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3456.wav", + "text": "因為以現在這個時間點來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3457.wav", + "text": "我們可能必須要先去確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3458.wav", + "text": "我剛剛所講的議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3459.wav", + "text": "\n明天星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3460.wav", + "text": "已經過了協商冷凍期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3461.wav", + "text": "而且那三個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3462.wav", + "text": "也踐行了之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3463.wav", + "text": "的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3464.wav", + "text": "因此明天在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3465.wav", + "text": "處理是沒有法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3466.wav", + "text": "上面的障礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3467.wav", + "text": "至於贊成或不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3468.wav", + "text": "當然大家有不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3469.wav", + "text": "的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3470.wav", + "text": "但我要確認的事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3471.wav", + "text": "明天在院會處理我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3472.wav", + "text": "禮拜二程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3473.wav", + "text": "所表定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3474.wav", + "text": "前面那三個議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3475.wav", + "text": "是不存在法規上面的障礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3476.wav", + "text": "以上就這個程序性的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3477.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3478.wav", + "text": "非常地重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3479.wav", + "text": "所以我在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3480.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3481.wav", + "text": "先確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3482.wav", + "text": "這個根本不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3483.wav", + "text": "柯總召等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3484.wav", + "text": "職權行使法第71條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3485.wav", + "text": "定期處理未達共識之協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3486.wav", + "text": "逾一個月無法達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3487.wav", + "text": "由院會定期處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3488.wav", + "text": "什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3489.wav", + "text": "馬上處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3490.wav", + "text": "委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3491.wav", + "text": "定期處理就是排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3492.wav", + "text": "程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3493.wav", + "text": "院會來做議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3494.wav", + "text": "黨團以及民進黨黨團這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3495.wav", + "text": "的發言聽下來明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3496.wav", + "text": "我們排定的這個院會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3497.wav", + "text": "事項能夠處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3498.wav", + "text": "改革五法這是合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3499.wav", + "text": "這是第一個我們先確認的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3500.wav", + "text": "\n第二從兩點協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3501.wav", + "text": "到現在三個多小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3502.wav", + "text": "終於民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3503.wav", + "text": "柯總召先排了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3504.wav", + "text": "剛剛一個多小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3505.wav", + "text": "又在假意說尊重院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3506.wav", + "text": "但其實最不尊重院長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3507.wav", + "text": "說實在院長已經指示誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3508.wav", + "text": "發言了都還可以在那邊搶麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3509.wav", + "text": "我想全國人民都看在眼裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3510.wav", + "text": "討論了一個多小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3511.wav", + "text": "要來扯程序其實根本不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3512.wav", + "text": "想要扯程序就是想要拖延時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3513.wav", + "text": "想要限制明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3514.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵跟花東快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3515.wav", + "text": "這兩案但是不想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3516.wav", + "text": "面對國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3517.wav", + "text": "──我們已經在程序委員會排的前三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3518.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3519.wav", + "text": "國人會感到非常失望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3520.wav", + "text": "這是知法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3521.wav", + "text": "玩法是玩弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3522.wav", + "text": "議事規則我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3523.wav", + "text": "禮拜三的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3524.wav", + "text": "為了要確保我們能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3525.wav", + "text": "在明天順利地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3526.wav", + "text": "地合法合規合憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3527.wav", + "text": "討論事項我們提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3528.wav", + "text": "來排隊在議場前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3529.wav", + "text": "現在還有我們的兄弟姐妹在排隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3530.wav", + "text": "也因此我們講的是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3531.wav", + "text": "如果今天民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3532.wav", + "text": "先排他的陽謀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3533.wav", + "text": "就是不想要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3534.wav", + "text": "到明天這三個法案的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3535.wav", + "text": "我覺得沒有��法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3536.wav", + "text": "\n再者今天協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3537.wav", + "text": "剛好民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3538.wav", + "text": "在最後一刻如果我沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3539.wav", + "text": "在今天的最後一刻又要求院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3540.wav", + "text": "研商立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3541.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案等三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3542.wav", + "text": "什麼最後一刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3543.wav", + "text": "開會通知的時候是在今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3544.wav", + "text": "就請院長做一個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3545.wav", + "text": "這個協商我們一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3546.wav", + "text": "我們今天協商沒有時間表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3547.wav", + "text": "所以柯總召不要跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3548.wav", + "text": "等一下我們一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3549.wav", + "text": "你要多久的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3550.wav", + "text": "只要主席能夠我們一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3551.wav", + "text": "明天早上7點我都OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3552.wav", + "text": "我都一定奉陪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3553.wav", + "text": "我們要的就是明天依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3554.wav", + "text": "討論事項的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3555.wav", + "text": "所有案子尤其是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3556.wav", + "text": "尤其是前三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3557.wav", + "text": "這是我們的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3558.wav", + "text": "真的啦院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3559.wav", + "text": "我還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3560.wav", + "text": "我們黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3561.wav", + "text": "資歷可能有輕有淺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3562.wav", + "text": "年紀有輕有淺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3563.wav", + "text": "但是既然坐在這個位置上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3564.wav", + "text": "代表國民黨團民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3565.wav", + "text": "民眾黨團大家平起平坐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3566.wav", + "text": "我覺得發言時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3567.wav", + "text": "真的要控制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3568.wav", + "text": "在演講比賽今天並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3569.wav", + "text": "誰大聲誰贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3570.wav", + "text": "所以我每一次發言都很注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3571.wav", + "text": "意我自己的時間該3分鐘我3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3572.wav", + "text": "結束該5分鐘我5分鐘結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3573.wav", + "text": "但不是每一次都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3574.wav", + "text": "予取予求讓這樣子的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3575.wav", + "text": "東扯西扯東加西加然後到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3576.wav", + "text": "最後拖延時間大家不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3577.wav", + "text": "覺得剛剛我們從兩點多到四點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3578.wav", + "text": "多的這段時間真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3579.wav", + "text": "被嚴重地耽誤時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3580.wav", + "text": "\n所以我拜託院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3581.wav", + "text": "如果可以的話我們真的還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3582.wav", + "text": "考慮之前有講過一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3583.wav", + "text": "代表3分鐘時間5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3584.wav", + "text": "分鐘時間該訂規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3585.wav", + "text": "的我們把它訂下來謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3586.wav", + "text": "保證不走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3587.wav", + "text": "你留多久我陪多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3588.wav", + "text": "接下來請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3589.wav", + "text": "柯建銘總召發言然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3590.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3591.wav", + "text": "黃國昌都走了很可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3592.wav", + "text": "我希望大家一起聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3593.wav", + "text": "今天不是講程序性問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3594.wav", + "text": "今天是講法律的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3595.wav", + "text": "而且是立法院的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3596.wav", + "text": "你知道什麼叫職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3597.wav", + "text": "爭議事項是院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3598.wav", + "text": "院長覺得有需要他可以召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3599.wav", + "text": "我們覺得有需要可以請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3600.wav", + "text": "召集這是院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3601.wav", + "text": "在整個立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3602.wav", + "text": "裡面一個很重要的武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3603.wav", + "text": "\n你講了第71條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3604.wav", + "text": "委員會協商一個月以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3605.wav", + "text": "使法是寫什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3606.wav", + "text": "是定期表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3607.wav", + "text": "本來是四個月以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3608.wav", + "text": "2008年馬英九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3609.wav", + "text": "執政把它改為一個月以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3610.wav", + "text": "你要瞭解整個立法的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3611.wav", + "text": "大家如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3612.wav", + "text": "讓立法院好好討論事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3613.wav", + "text": "協商沒有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3614.wav", + "text": "也不是明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3615.wav", + "text": "就表決是定期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3616.wav", + "text": "所以你要把法看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3617.wav", + "text": "你看黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3618.wav", + "text": "根本不在這裡不講法律了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3619.wav", + "text": "你在這邊好像你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3620.wav", + "text": "占到了極大的優勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3621.wav", + "text": "極大的理論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3622.wav", + "text": "然後不要跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3623.wav", + "text": "坐到12點你坐到明天也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3624.wav", + "text": "沒有結論就是定期處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3625.wav", + "text": "不是你排在那裡就要馬上處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3626.wav", + "text": "你以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3627.wav", + "text": "了因為你沒有當過黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3628.wav", + "text": "我告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3629.wav", + "text": "包括黃國昌委員剛剛講了一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3630.wav", + "text": "你們昨天在程序委員會強制表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3631.wav", + "text": "一二三案國會改革案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3632.wav", + "text": "然後明天就排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3633.wav", + "text": "然後你們就開始排隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3634.wav", + "text": "我一直很納悶你們在排什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3635.wav", + "text": "我只是不好意思講而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3636.wav", + "text": "\n我今天特別發言臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3637.wav", + "text": "韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3638.wav", + "text": "所有的事是韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3639.wav", + "text": "一念之間整個國家民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3640.wav", + "text": "整個國家民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3641.wav", + "text": "假如不照法來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3642.wav", + "text": "不照憲政體制來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3643.wav", + "text": "那我們就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3644.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷委員你聽聽看傅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3645.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁委員也做當黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3646.wav", + "text": "黃國昌也當過黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3647.wav", + "text": "啊我們過去讓他在這裡單獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3648.wav", + "text": "協商讓他單獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3649.wav", + "text": "找我們部會討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3650.wav", + "text": "討論一個鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3651.wav", + "text": "我們尊重給他說完沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3652.wav", + "text": "所以你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3653.wav", + "text": "不要曲解法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3654.wav", + "text": "\n然後你要限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3655.wav", + "text": "發言時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3656.wav", + "text": "沒有一次的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3657.wav", + "text": "所以朝野協商要簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3658.wav", + "text": "每個人發言幾分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3659.wav", + "text": "你要曲解法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3660.wav", + "text": "然後以為你占到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3661.wav", + "text": "無敵的武力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3662.wav", + "text": "你這樣根本破壞國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3663.wav", + "text": "整個民主都毀掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3664.wav", + "text": "這是一個很嚴肅的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3665.wav", + "text": "我們一直在這裡不厭其煩的講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3666.wav", + "text": "包括剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3667.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員講得這麼詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3668.wav", + "text": "權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3669.wav", + "text": "就跟你講得這麼清楚你還看不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3670.wav", + "text": "不是你今天你們兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3671.wav", + "text": "什麼都可以發明可以創造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3672.wav", + "text": "沒有這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3673.wav", + "text": "你們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3674.wav", + "text": "跟傅總召你也在旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3675.wav", + "text": "我們都講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3676.wav", + "text": "反正這兩個法案已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3677.wav", + "text": "講到透了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3678.wav", + "text": "我們認為違反權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3679.wav", + "text": "你們認為沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3680.wav", + "text": "講這麼詳細你也聽不下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3681.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3682.wav", + "text": "那我們就表決輸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3683.wav", + "text": "但是輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3684.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3685.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好可以進入程序了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3686.wav", + "text": "而且院長我告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3687.wav", + "text": "講那小事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3688.wav", + "text": "然後跑掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3689.wav", + "text": "今天程序委員會你們強行表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3690.wav", + "text": "一二三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3691.wav", + "text": "只要談的好的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3692.wav", + "text": "明天議程就變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3693.wav", + "text": "討論事項順序可以變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3694.wav", + "text": "這個天天在演的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3695.wav", + "text": "你是有要解決事情嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3696.wav", + "text": "你有要解決事情再來說要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3697.wav", + "text": "不然你用你的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3698.wav", + "text": "你再砸一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3699.wav", + "text": "我們樂見謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3700.wav", + "text": "總召發言林思銘委員請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3701.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員請再準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3702.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3703.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3704.wav", + "text": "因為現在在直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3705.wav", + "text": "全國國人都看見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3706.wav", + "text": "我們要向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3707.wav", + "text": "韓院長致敬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3708.wav", + "text": "韓院長真的不只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3709.wav", + "text": "不斷在蛻變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3710.wav", + "text": "在升級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3711.wav", + "text": "為了這樣一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3712.wav", + "text": "還有今天我正式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3713.wav", + "text": "看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3714.wav", + "text": "過去民進黨在演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3715.wav", + "text": "還是對院長有一些尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3716.wav", + "text": "今天的演法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3717.wav", + "text": "又改變了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3718.wav", + "text": "就表示要把這層假面拿下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3719.wav", + "text": "剛剛不斷地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3720.wav", + "text": "不是黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3721.wav", + "text": "也在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3722.wav", + "text": "對韓院長直接做人身的攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3723.wav", + "text": "原來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3724.wav", + "text": "直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3725.wav", + "text": "來挑戰你的權威" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3726.wav", + "text": "甚至在直播的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3727.wav", + "text": "現在把你刻意醜化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3728.wav", + "text": "醜化了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3729.wav", + "text": "才可以把你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3730.wav", + "text": "國會議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3731.wav", + "text": "來做一個正面的挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3732.wav", + "text": "我想我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3733.wav", + "text": "聽了這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3734.wav", + "text": "我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3735.wav", + "text": "很單純的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3736.wav", + "text": "也都相信大家是要善意的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3737.wav", + "text": "前幾次的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3738.wav", + "text": "謾罵的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3739.wav", + "text": "在謾罵人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3740.wav", + "text": "不斷地在損耗大家的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3741.wav", + "text": "\n今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3742.wav", + "text": "協商的內容來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3743.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3744.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3745.wav", + "text": "除了這個協商的內容以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3746.wav", + "text": "還有其他的但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3747.wav", + "text": "明天只能處理哪個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3748.wav", + "text": "明天不能處理哪些案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3749.wav", + "text": "其實今天院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3750.wav", + "text": "發的協商已經很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3751.wav", + "text": "我想民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3752.wav", + "text": "也提出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3753.wav", + "text": "國會改革相關的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3754.wav", + "text": "也提出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3755.wav", + "text": "在第五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3756.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天準備好要挑燈夜戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3757.wav", + "text": "反正也沒有要睡覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3758.wav", + "text": "嘛如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3759.wav", + "text": "民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3760.wav", + "text": "再三強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3761.wav", + "text": "委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3762.wav", + "text": "不斷地在這裡呼天搶地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3763.wav", + "text": "的討論有多麼多麼的重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3764.wav", + "text": "國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3765.wav", + "text": "相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3766.wav", + "text": "這些修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3767.wav", + "text": "在司法委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3768.wav", + "text": "經過整整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3769.wav", + "text": "8個小時的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3770.wav", + "text": "民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3771.wav", + "text": "也經過44次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3772.wav", + "text": "44次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3773.wav", + "text": "44次的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3774.wav", + "text": "的柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3775.wav", + "text": "書記長我搞不清楚他是怎麼排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3776.wav", + "text": "反正每一個人都表演的相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3777.wav", + "text": "傑出大家上網都可以再查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3778.wav", + "text": "那一天都看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3779.wav", + "text": "從早上演到下午四點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3780.wav", + "text": "我們也非常敬佩演技十足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3781.wav", + "text": "還不是委員會演完就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3782.wav", + "text": "之後再到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3783.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3784.wav", + "text": "由吳宗憲召委召集的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3785.wav", + "text": "好像吳思瑤也到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3786.wav", + "text": "也搞了很多個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3787.wav", + "text": "也經過了這個程序完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3788.wav", + "text": "然後我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3789.wav", + "text": "哇看到很高興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3790.wav", + "text": "民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3791.wav", + "text": "提議今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3792.wav", + "text": "黨團協商通知第五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3793.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3794.wav", + "text": "我想民進黨提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3795.wav", + "text": "了我們就準備要挑燈夜戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3796.wav", + "text": "\n第一個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3797.wav", + "text": "中心主義委員會已經踐行了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3798.wav", + "text": "所有該必須進行的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3799.wav", + "text": "包括委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3800.wav", + "text": "朝野協商也都經過完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3801.wav", + "text": "這個版本又是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3802.wav", + "text": "過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3803.wav", + "text": "不斷地要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3804.wav", + "text": "國會必須陽光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3805.wav", + "text": "必須要清廉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3806.wav", + "text": "除弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3807.wav", + "text": "我們是依照民進黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3808.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3809.wav", + "text": "大法官第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3810.wav", + "text": "585號解釋令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3811.wav", + "text": "我們全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3812.wav", + "text": "都是依照第585號解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3813.wav", + "text": "所提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3814.wav", + "text": "這些修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3815.wav", + "text": "我實在不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3816.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統即將就職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3817.wav", + "text": "你尊重我的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3818.wav", + "text": "你尊重我的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3819.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統即將就職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3820.wav", + "text": "難道不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3821.wav", + "text": "有一個健全的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3822.wav", + "text": "把不是他當總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3823.wav", + "text": "都能夠讓人民瞭解清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3824.wav", + "text": "我們要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3825.wav", + "text": "今天國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3826.wav", + "text": "所有的這些條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3827.wav", + "text": "通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3828.wav", + "text": "對國家是正面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3829.wav", + "text": "對國會是正面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3830.wav", + "text": "對民進黨更是正面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3831.wav", + "text": "對賴總統絕對是正面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3832.wav", + "text": "這能夠讓國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3833.wav", + "text": "更加地廉能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3834.wav", + "text": "更加地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3835.wav", + "text": "有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3836.wav", + "text": "更加地清白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3837.wav", + "text": "這個我想賴總統半夜都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3838.wav", + "text": "鼓掌到天亮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3839.wav", + "text": "我想這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3840.wav", + "text": "經過委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3841.wav", + "text": "你不必替賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3842.wav", + "text": "他不能說他沒有參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3843.wav", + "text": "三長都在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3844.wav", + "text": "從頭參與到尾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3845.wav", + "text": "協商他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3846.wav", + "text": "幹事長有出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3847.wav", + "text": "一路協商到結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3848.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3849.wav", + "text": "接著下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3850.wav", + "text": "我等你沒有問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3851.wav", + "text": "我等你沒有問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3852.wav", + "text": "我們一條一條來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3853.wav", + "text": "沒有關係嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3854.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3855.wav", + "text": "再一次地強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3856.wav", + "text": "全部是按照立法院的議事程序走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3857.wav", + "text": "禮拜二的程序委員會已經送了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3858.wav", + "text": "禮拜五該排的議程都已經排好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3859.wav", + "text": "我們完全按照議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3860.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3861.wav", + "text": "對於可能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3862.wav", + "text": "突發狀況會去破壞禮拜五的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3863.wav", + "text": "議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3864.wav", + "text": "我們態度也都非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3865.wav", + "text": "我們可以餐風露宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3866.wav", + "text": "在議場門口排隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3867.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們就是守規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3868.wav", + "text": "照規則走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3869.wav", + "text": "既然議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3870.wav", + "text": "5月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3871.wav", + "text": "也經過了這些程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3872.wav", + "text": "也到了可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3873.wav", + "text": "院會處理的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3874.wav", + "text": "我們當然照議程走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3875.wav", + "text": "我們不會有任何的交換條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3876.wav", + "text": "更不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3877.wav", + "text": "徇私舞弊的情況發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3878.wav", + "text": "我要跟全國國人在這裡報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3879.wav", + "text": "我們沒有按照議事規則走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3880.wav", + "text": "我們每一條都按照議事規則走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3881.wav", + "text": "委員會的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3882.wav", + "text": "全國人民都看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3883.wav", + "text": "了委員會的討論全國人民都看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3884.wav", + "text": "今天的國會沒有柯建銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3885.wav", + "text": "點頭統統不能處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3886.wav", + "text": "都不能討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3887.wav", + "text": "我在這裡要特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3888.wav", + "text": "程序都完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3889.wav", + "text": "程序都完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3890.wav", + "text": "我們要再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3891.wav", + "text": "我個人是吃素的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3892.wav", + "text": "但是在野黨不是全部都吃素的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3893.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3894.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3895.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3896.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3897.wav", + "text": "沒有照他的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3898.wav", + "text": "會有史上最嚴重的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3899.wav", + "text": "預先恐嚇在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3900.wav", + "text": "他當家還要鬧事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3901.wav", + "text": "我們不怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3902.wav", + "text": "今天就不會來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3903.wav", + "text": "我先針對第四案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3904.wav", + "text": "環島高速鐵路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3905.wav", + "text": "剛剛聽不管是吳思瑤幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3906.wav", + "text": "或者柯總召的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3907.wav", + "text": "一直說這個部分違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3908.wav", + "text": "權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3909.wav", + "text": "我們立法院沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3910.wav", + "text": "訂立特別條例的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3911.wav", + "text": "我想我們立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3912.wav", + "text": "的職權就是有立法權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3913.wav", + "text": "有議決法律的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3914.wav", + "text": "嘛這是很明顯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3915.wav", + "text": "你同意吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3916.wav", + "text": "去訂立特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3917.wav", + "text": "訂立這個法律案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3918.wav", + "text": "這你應該同意吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3919.wav", + "text": "訂立這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3920.wav", + "text": "然後我們現在來議決這個法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3921.wav", + "text": "你沒有意見吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3922.wav", + "text": "所以怎麼會認為說我們沒有訂立特別條例的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3923.wav", + "text": "至於這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3924.wav", + "text": "裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3925.wav", + "text": "不管是行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3926.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣子來配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3927.wav", + "text": "有沒有違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3928.wav", + "text": "這部分我想我們也可以來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3929.wav", + "text": "有侵犯到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3930.wav", + "text": "它編列預算的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3931.wav", + "text": "但是我們要提醒你請你看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3932.wav", + "text": "修正動議修改後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3933.wav", + "text": "第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3934.wav", + "text": "第6條很明確規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3935.wav", + "text": "這預算從哪裡而來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3936.wav", + "text": "有三個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3937.wav", + "text": "第一個依照促進民間參與公共建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3938.wav", + "text": "法辦理採用民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3939.wav", + "text": "興建營運後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3940.wav", + "text": "移轉模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3941.wav", + "text": "第二個依照國際招標方式以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3942.wav", + "text": "興建營運後轉移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3943.wav", + "text": "模式第三個由中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3944.wav", + "text": "執行機關分年編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3945.wav", + "text": "預算辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3946.wav", + "text": "所以也不是特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3947.wav", + "text": "不是依照第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3948.wav", + "text": "跟第二個方式第三個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3949.wav", + "text": "也是由我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3950.wav", + "text": "中央政府行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3951.wav", + "text": "它逐年編列預算來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3952.wav", + "text": "都是交由行政機關去評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3953.wav", + "text": "只是利用這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3954.wav", + "text": "督促你不要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3955.wav", + "text": "這麼久的花東快速公路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3956.wav", + "text": "環島高速鐵路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3957.wav", + "text": "嘛所以這個條例的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3958.wav", + "text": "立法用意非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3959.wav", + "text": "\n另外針對我們第五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3960.wav", + "text": "使法我要再特別補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3961.wav", + "text": "委員會的黨團協商我有參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3962.wav", + "text": "他剛剛講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3963.wav", + "text": "沒有逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3964.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄你也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3965.wav", + "text": "啦有通過一條耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3966.wav", + "text": "你說沒有逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3967.wav", + "text": "其他的都有在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3968.wav", + "text": "都有一直在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3969.wav", + "text": "但是為什麼你自己知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3970.wav", + "text": "開記者會說什麼原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3971.wav", + "text": "我們有進入逐條討論的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3972.wav", + "text": "請尊重發言委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3973.wav", + "text": "不要被情緒干擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3974.wav", + "text": "的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3975.wav", + "text": "當然雙方就無法達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3976.wav", + "text": "討論了很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3977.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3978.wav", + "text": "所以我們就依照相關的議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3979.wav", + "text": "既然沒有共識就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3980.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3981.wav", + "text": "嘛\n這樣子出委員會怎麼沒有逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3982.wav", + "text": "呢這個不要亂講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3983.wav", + "text": "明明有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3984.wav", + "text": "謝謝林思銘委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3985.wav", + "text": "接下來在吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3986.wav", + "text": "發言之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3987.wav", + "text": "各位黨團幹部如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3988.wav", + "text": "是不是請列席的各位官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3989.wav", + "text": "就可以先離席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3990.wav", + "text": "因為他們是公務員他們可能回去還有很多事情處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3991.wav", + "text": "不是我說列席的交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3992.wav", + "text": "發會還有各其他部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3993.wav", + "text": "如果各位黨團幹部沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3994.wav", + "text": "我們就請官員先離席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3995.wav", + "text": "也謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3996.wav", + "text": "再次感謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3997.wav", + "text": "\n我們接下來請吳思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3998.wav", + "text": "院長能不能把今天協商這些案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/3999.wav", + "text": "的內容文件全部都發下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4000.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4001.wav", + "text": "因為我們就要進入了嘛因為這是民進黨團排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4002.wav", + "text": "那我們現在就是進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4003.wav", + "text": "怎麼是我們排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4004.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4005.wav", + "text": "今天的議程是院長排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4006.wav", + "text": "連你們自己請求都不敢認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4007.wav", + "text": "現在在處理花東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4008.wav", + "text": "拿公文出來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4009.wav", + "text": "民進黨團有沒有請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4010.wav", + "text": "那是最後一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4011.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4012.wav", + "text": "現在最後一案所以說把所有資料都發下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4013.wav", + "text": "嘛因為剛剛院長已經講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4014.wav", + "text": "第四案第五案要綜合討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4015.wav", + "text": "嘛所以不要再講說沒有院長召開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4016.wav", + "text": "了喔現在就是針對民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4017.wav", + "text": "來要求院長召開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4018.wav", + "text": "有程序正義還有實質正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4019.wav", + "text": "我們現在就是遵守程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4020.wav", + "text": "請各位官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4021.wav", + "text": "稍微快速一點好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4022.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4023.wav", + "text": "稍微等一下請官員離席之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4024.wav", + "text": "院長我可以發言了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4025.wav", + "text": "各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4026.wav", + "text": "現在關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4027.wav", + "text": "司法院法務部總統府列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4028.wav", + "text": "列席的官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4029.wav", + "text": "我想因為我們時間拖太晚就請他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4030.wav", + "text": "一併就回去了好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4031.wav", + "text": "我們自己委員來討論好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4032.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4033.wav", + "text": "再一次謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4034.wav", + "text": "法務部總統府還有行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4035.wav", + "text": "考試院監察院各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4036.wav", + "text": "官員你們就請回了我們來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4037.wav", + "text": "了因為已經到了你們要下班的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4038.wav", + "text": "不打擾大家了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4039.wav", + "text": "請快速移動保持微笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4040.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4041.wav", + "text": "我等大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4042.wav", + "text": "議事人員引導一���好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4043.wav", + "text": "請官員先離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4044.wav", + "text": "那邊有3部電梯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4045.wav", + "text": "因為我們下面還有委員要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4046.wav", + "text": "離開會有一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4047.wav", + "text": "雜音\n好接下來我們請吳思瑤委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4048.wav", + "text": "如果照今天的協商議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4049.wav", + "text": "現在進入的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4050.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4051.wav", + "text": "以及花東快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4052.wav", + "text": "我的認知沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4053.wav", + "text": "那國會改革的議案等一下要不要繼續協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4054.wav", + "text": "我們先等這兩個案子處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4055.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4056.wav", + "text": "職權行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4057.wav", + "text": "第71條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4058.wav", + "text": "我在講實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4059.wav", + "text": "你剛才講的是實質嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4060.wav", + "text": "你剛才演講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4061.wav", + "text": "請有耐性好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4062.wav", + "text": "不是說大家好好來談嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4063.wav", + "text": "柯總召尊重一下吳思瑤委員發言好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4064.wav", + "text": "對不起是傅總召沒有尊重我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4065.wav", + "text": "我在講話他在干擾我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4066.wav", + "text": "職權行使法第71條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4067.wav", + "text": "議案自交黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4068.wav", + "text": "逾一個月無法達成共識者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4069.wav", + "text": "由院會定期處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4070.wav", + "text": "這意思是其實我在當國會助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4071.wav", + "text": "參議的時候那個時候是4個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4072.wav", + "text": "後來改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4073.wav", + "text": "1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4074.wav", + "text": "但是這一個議案改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4075.wav", + "text": "1個月的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4076.wav", + "text": "任何一個議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4077.wav", + "text": "出了委員會進入協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4078.wav", + "text": "至少要有1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4079.wav", + "text": "再對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4080.wav", + "text": "再匯聚共識這是至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4081.wav", + "text": "所以1個月之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4082.wav", + "text": "擇期再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4083.wav", + "text": "不是說1個月D-Day" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4084.wav", + "text": "就馬上處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4085.wav", + "text": "這個法條的精神很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4086.wav", + "text": "所以不要錯誤理解法條了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4087.wav", + "text": "這一個條文是告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4088.wav", + "text": "至少要有1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4089.wav", + "text": "而不是1個月就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4090.wav", + "text": "放在那裡乾等過水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4091.wav", + "text": "然後等過1個月之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4092.wav", + "text": "馬上表決這完全是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4093.wav", + "text": "誤解法律也是誤用法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4094.wav", + "text": "韓院長跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4095.wav", + "text": "我也去請教了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4096.wav", + "text": "好多委員都很沒有風度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4097.wav", + "text": "喔人家講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4098.wav", + "text": "你們不願意面對的真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4099.wav", + "text": "就一個一個離席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4100.wav", + "text": "好沒關係我們講給社會大眾聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4101.wav", + "text": "從以前到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4102.wav", + "text": "從來沒有任何一個立法院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4103.wav", + "text": "過水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4104.wav", + "text": "協商期過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4105.wav", + "text": "never" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4106.wav", + "text": "蘇嘉全也好到游錫堃也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4107.wav", + "text": "窮極一切的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4108.wav", + "text": "在重要的議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4109.wav", + "text": "協商一次兩次三次四次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4110.wav", + "text": "九次七次都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4111.wav", + "text": "就是在表決前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4112.wav", + "text": "努力的讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4113.wav", + "text": "每一個條文能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4114.wav", + "text": "儘量少表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4115.wav", + "text": "就儘量少表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4116.wav", + "text": "而不是熬過1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4117.wav", + "text": "過水之後就直接表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4118.wav", + "text": "韓院長謝謝您對我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4119.wav", + "text": "這個眼神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4120.wav", + "text": "我就跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4121.wav", + "text": "我手上隨便去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4122.wav", + "text": "找幾個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4123.wav", + "text": "王金平院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4124.wav", + "text": "針對食品衛生管理法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4125.wav", + "text": "協商了9次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4126.wav", + "text": "王金平院長針對廣播電視法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4127.wav", + "text": "協商了6次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4128.wav", + "text": "蘇嘉全院長針對反滲透法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4129.wav", + "text": "協商了兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4130.wav", + "text": "但是一次都是78個小時以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4131.wav", + "text": "蘇嘉全院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4132.wav", + "text": "針對前瞻基礎建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4133.wav", + "text": "協商了兩天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4134.wav", + "text": "一次都是10小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4135.wav", + "text": "15小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4136.wav", + "text": "蘇嘉全院長針對政黨不當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4137.wav", + "text": "協商了10個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4138.wav", + "text": "都是一條一條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4139.wav", + "text": "蘇嘉全院長針對促轉條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4140.wav", + "text": "協商了7次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4141.wav", + "text": "好講到游錫堃院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4142.wav", + "text": "我這裡列出來是因為我自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4143.wav", + "text": "作為列席委員我是教育及文化委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4144.wav", + "text": "召委我都有來參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4145.wav", + "text": "學校衛生法游錫堃院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4146.wav", + "text": "協商了4次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4147.wav", + "text": "文化藝術講助條例游錫堃院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4148.wav", + "text": "協商了3次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4149.wav", + "text": "\n我要跟韓院長報告我認為您是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4150.wav", + "text": "理性可以溝通的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4151.wav", + "text": "至高無上協商的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4152.wav", + "text": "一個立法院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4153.wav", + "text": "匯聚共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4154.wav", + "text": "不是凡事都表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4155.wav", + "text": "反而相反在表決前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4156.wav", + "text": "能夠減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4157.wav", + "text": "彼此的歧異讓表決的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4158.wav", + "text": "越少越好因為這就是院長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4159.wav", + "text": "協調能耐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4160.wav", + "text": "所以過去幾任院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4161.wav", + "text": "協調了7次8次9次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4162.wav", + "text": "這都是協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4163.wav", + "text": "1個月2個月還繼續協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4164.wav", + "text": "從來沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4165.wav", + "text": "1個月時間到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4166.wav", + "text": "不逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4167.wav", + "text": "就像現在我們也看得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4168.wav", + "text": "傅總召也好洪孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4169.wav", + "text": "書記長也好打的如意算盤就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4170.wav", + "text": "熬過時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4171.wav", + "text": "等一下一個一個條文就過水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4172.wav", + "text": "然後明天直接表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4173.wav", + "text": "\n回到現在講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4174.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4175.wav", + "text": "跟蘇花快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4176.wav", + "text": "我這裡提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4177.wav", + "text": "都是負責任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4178.wav", + "text": "交通專業評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4179.wav", + "text": "立法部門沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4180.wav", + "text": "辦法做到這些你憑什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4181.wav", + "text": "去規定編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4182.wav", + "text": "多少預算你憑什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4183.wav", + "text": "去規定框定它10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4184.wav", + "text": "或是改成12年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4185.wav", + "text": "這是不負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4186.wav", + "text": "的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4187.wav", + "text": "\n我們講講被國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4188.wav", + "text": "罵到臭頭杯葛最力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4189.wav", + "text": "的前瞻建設條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4190.wav", + "text": "我這裡拿了4本厚厚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4191.wav", + "text": "預算書都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4192.wav", + "text": "通過特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4193.wav", + "text": "再編特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4194.wav", + "text": "才會有8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4195.wav", + "text": "是1,089億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4196.wav", + "text": "我跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4197.wav", + "text": "重要工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4198.wav", + "text": "被國民黨杯葛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4199.wav", + "text": "這麼強力的前瞻建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4200.wav", + "text": "才有特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4201.wav", + "text": "特別條例從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4202.wav", + "text": "2017年3月23號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4203.wav", + "text": "行政院送到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4204.wav", + "text": "到它表決通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4205.wav", + "text": "是2017年7月5號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4206.wav", + "text": "審查了104天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4207.wav", + "text": "當中委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4208.wav", + "text": "辦了6場公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4209.wav", + "text": "6個委員會聯席審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4210.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4211.wav", + "text": "由蘇嘉全院長主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4212.wav", + "text": "協商了兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4213.wav", + "text": "一次9小時一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4214.wav", + "text": "15小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4215.wav", + "text": "在院會表決的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4216.wav", + "text": "前瞻特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4217.wav", + "text": "各黨共提案80案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4218.wav", + "text": "表決59次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4219.wav", + "text": "先有條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4220.wav", + "text": "再有預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4221.wav", + "text": "我就以前瞻建設的第一期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4222.wav", + "text": "編列的預算是1,089億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4223.wav", + "text": "行政院2017年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4224.wav", + "text": "7月11號送到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4225.wav", + "text": "完成審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4226.wav", + "text": "歷經了51天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4227.wav", + "text": "當中也是7個委員會聯席審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4228.wav", + "text": "花了足足3天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4229.wav", + "text": "逐條逐項審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4230.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4231.wav", + "text": "由蘇嘉全院長主持了3次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4232.wav", + "text": "院會的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4233.wav", + "text": "在野黨提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4234.wav", + "text": "前瞻特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4235.wav", + "text": "在立法院的院會表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4236.wav", + "text": "\n我要跟院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4237.wav", + "text": "前瞻的第一期計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4238.wav", + "text": "1,089億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4239.wav", + "text": "要歷經這樣層層的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4240.wav", + "text": "層層的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4241.wav", + "text": "層層的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4242.wav", + "text": "才表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4243.wav", + "text": "這是1,089億的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4244.wav", + "text": "前瞻預算第一期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4245.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4246.wav", + "text": "1兆以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4247.wav", + "text": "第二案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4248.wav", + "text": "花東快要2,500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4249.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4250.wav", + "text": "請問我們不值得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4251.wav", + "text": "好好來討論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4252.wav", + "text": "我們不值得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4253.wav", + "text": "嚴肅地來行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4254.wav", + "text": "我們的監督權嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4255.wav", + "text": "我們當立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4256.wav", + "text": "就做好我們的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4257.wav", + "text": "不要只想過水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4258.wav", + "text": "不要只想硬幹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4259.wav", + "text": "不要只想表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4260.wav", + "text": "非常遺憾我今天在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4261.wav", + "text": "搬了這麼多的預算書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4262.wav", + "text": "在野黨哪一個立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4263.wav", + "text": "這麼認真地去看交通評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4264.wav", + "text": "在野黨哪一個立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4265.wav", + "text": "這麼認真地去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4266.wav", + "text": "所有建設的財務試算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4267.wav", + "text": "應當如何進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4268.wav", + "text": "坐在這裡只想等過水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4269.wav", + "text": "熬過今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4270.wav", + "text": "等一下韓院長離開這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4271.wav", + "text": "宣布協商結束明天就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4272.wav", + "text": "我們是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4273.wav", + "text": "我們可以這樣胡亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4274.wav", + "text": "地行使我們的職權嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4275.wav", + "text": "我們也看得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4276.wav", + "text": "在野黨的委員除了要在明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4277.wav", + "text": "強行表決通過錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4278.wav", + "text": "錢坑條例之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4279.wav", + "text": "還要加碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4280.wav", + "text": "讓到目前為止還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4281.wav", + "text": "協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4282.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4283.wav", + "text": "也就是國會擴權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4284.wav", + "text": "一起表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4285.wav", + "text": "我要挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4286.wav", + "text": "在委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4287.wav", + "text": "在司法及法制委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4288.wav", + "text": "時哪一個條文被逐條了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4289.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4290.wav", + "text": "\n你們一直在講那天吳宗憲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4291.wav", + "text": "主持的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4292.wav", + "text": "我有在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4293.wav", + "text": "他花了不到1個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4294.wav", + "text": "討論的條文只有3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4295.wav", + "text": "通過1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4296.wav", + "text": "我們總共有68條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4297.wav", + "text": "只通過1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4298.wav", + "text": "你跟我說那個有經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4299.wav", + "text": "這就是過水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4300.wav", + "text": "嘛這就是過水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4301.wav", + "text": "如果明天要強行表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4302.wav", + "text": "職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4303.wav", + "text": "只有國民黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4304.wav", + "text": "只有民眾黨的版本民進黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4305.wav", + "text": "職權行使法被拋在後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4306.wav", + "text": "被丟包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4307.wav", + "text": "重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4308.wav", + "text": "所以我最後要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4309.wav", + "text": "國民黨跟民眾黨打的是什麼如意算盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4310.wav", + "text": "再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4311.wav", + "text": "雙法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4312.wav", + "text": "就因為你們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4313.wav", + "text": "強行表決錢坑法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4314.wav", + "text": "強行表決國會擴權法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4315.wav", + "text": "讓所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4316.wav", + "text": "癌症病患重症病患慢性病患" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4317.wav", + "text": "苦苦等待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4318.wav", + "text": "再生醫療雙法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4319.wav", + "text": "在明天的議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4320.wav", + "text": "中被排到後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4321.wav", + "text": "明天要強行通過政治法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4322.wav", + "text": "把民生法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4323.wav", + "text": "救命法案丟在一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4324.wav", + "text": "這是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4325.wav", + "text": "民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4326.wav", + "text": "你們的良知嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4327.wav", + "text": "\n你們最關心的村里長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4328.wav", + "text": "年終慰問金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4329.wav", + "text": "我們一起爭取的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4330.wav", + "text": "議員助理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4331.wav", + "text": "薪資提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4332.wav", + "text": "都被排在後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4333.wav", + "text": "你已經講了很多我都很尊重你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4334.wav", + "text": "好好院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4335.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4336.wav", + "text": "就事論事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4337.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4338.wav", + "text": "我們是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4339.wav", + "text": "1兆元以上的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4340.wav", + "text": "我不能講10分鐘嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4341.wav", + "text": "你現在已經講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4342.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4343.wav", + "text": "就是因為你們急切地要處理錢坑法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4344.wav", + "text": "也急切地要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4345.wav", + "text": "職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4346.wav", + "text": "這麼嚴肅的事情我們不能講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4347.wav", + "text": "10分鐘15分鐘嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4348.wav", + "text": "我們是民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4349.wav", + "text": "高鐵的逐條協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4350.wav", + "text": "如果心態上大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4351.wav", + "text": "只是想要過水我講50" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4352.wav", + "text": "次時間都不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4353.wav", + "text": "我們這麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4354.wav", + "text": "認真的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4355.wav", + "text": "但我們的問政都要被踐踏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4356.wav", + "text": "你們不尊重我們實質討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4357.wav", + "text": "大家都互相發言你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4358.wav", + "text": "我不是演講比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4359.wav", + "text": "你已經超出太多範圍了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4360.wav", + "text": "麻煩你進入環島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4361.wav", + "text": "高鐵逐條協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4362.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法我們等下會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4363.wav", + "text": "你為什麼要把兩個都混在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4364.wav", + "text": "院長我非常的失望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4365.wav", + "text": "我們認真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4366.wav", + "text": "在監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4367.wav", + "text": "你說我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4368.wav", + "text": "演講比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4369.wav", + "text": "我還特別說請你發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4370.wav", + "text": "那你自己要自重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4371.wav", + "text": "院長我非常的自愛自重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4372.wav", + "text": "我們就自己控制時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4373.wav", + "text": "院長不要選擇性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4374.wav", + "text": "對待不同黨派的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4375.wav", + "text": "言盡於此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4376.wav", + "text": "不要吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4377.wav", + "text": "主席宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4378.wav", + "text": "我們現在進行環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4379.wav", + "text": "逐條協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4380.wav", + "text": "拜託各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4381.wav", + "text": "能夠對焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4382.wav", + "text": "資料就在大家桌上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4383.wav", + "text": "逐條進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4384.wav", + "text": "沒有共識我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4385.wav", + "text": "沒有共識我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4386.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4387.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄委員有沒有寶貴意見請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4388.wav", + "text": "我這個意見一定寶貴院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4389.wav", + "text": "他們最關心的高鐵他們卻一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4390.wav", + "text": "我們全部都有討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4391.wav", + "text": "是這樣子才引起的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4392.wav", + "text": "所以我們當然必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4393.wav", + "text": "誤會\n剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4394.wav", + "text": "林思銘也開始講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4395.wav", + "text": "都已經討論過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4396.wav", + "text": "想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4397.wav", + "text": "我講給你聽4月15" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4398.wav", + "text": "都沒有做實質討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4399.wav", + "text": "是逐案保留送院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4400.wav", + "text": "你還怎麼講你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4401.wav", + "text": "你還講朝野協商沒有在逐條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4402.wav", + "text": "你忘記了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4403.wav", + "text": "我可以拿給你看我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4404.wav", + "text": "院長我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4405.wav", + "text": "我在回應他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4406.wav", + "text": "你既然要對焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4407.wav", + "text": "但他們就不想對焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4408.wav", + "text": "啊我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4409.wav", + "text": "要講出一個道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4410.wav", + "text": "你說現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4411.wav", + "text": "有傅崐萁委員等53人所擬具的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4412.wav", + "text": "環島高速鐵路建設特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4413.wav", + "text": "我們現在要開始講第1條對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4414.wav", + "text": "我們當然要提出我們的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4415.wav", + "text": "\n推動環島高速鐵路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4416.wav", + "text": "我為什麼會從第1條開始要講雖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4417.wav", + "text": "立意良善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4418.wav", + "text": "但大家剛剛就在談這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4419.wav", + "text": "真的是我們立法院要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4420.wav", + "text": "我們真的要來制定這一部法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4421.wav", + "text": "然後就花東部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4422.wav", + "text": "對屏東來說我是苦主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4423.wav", + "text": "院長我是苦主記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4424.wav", + "text": "我們就希望做可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4425.wav", + "text": "結果你們就來告訴我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4426.wav", + "text": "經濟效益不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4427.wav", + "text": "現在國民黨要推動了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4428.wav", + "text": "經濟效益評估是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4429.wav", + "text": "然後要你行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4430.wav", + "text": "是這樣一個態度嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4431.wav", + "text": "我一直認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4432.wav", + "text": "軌道建設不是不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4433.wav", + "text": "其實在前瞻基礎建設的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4434.wav", + "text": "最痛恨的就是軌道建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4435.wav", + "text": "這段當初你也都有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4436.wav", + "text": "我願意讓這樣一個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4437.wav", + "text": "進入實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4438.wav", + "text": "討論我願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4439.wav", + "text": "我們國家一年的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4440.wav", + "text": "兩兆多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4441.wav", + "text": "去做環島高速鐵路建設特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4442.wav", + "text": "我們制定一部法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4443.wav", + "text": "命令行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4444.wav", + "text": "促成這樣的交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4445.wav", + "text": "行政院施政本來就必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4446.wav", + "text": "顧及到城鄉差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4447.wav", + "text": "然後逐案推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4448.wav", + "text": "整個條例通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4449.wav", + "text": "請問其他的地方呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4450.wav", + "text": "這樣是不是會更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4451.wav", + "text": "失衡為了達到平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4452.wav", + "text": "結果最後更失衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4453.wav", + "text": "這點我覺得大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4454.wav", + "text": "\n我現在談的是第1條這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4455.wav", + "text": "全部都是實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4456.wav", + "text": "我講的全部都是實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4457.wav", + "text": "你新竹多弄一點是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4458.wav", + "text": "為什麼我會對第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4459.wav", + "text": "院長我意思是如果要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4460.wav", + "text": "做邏輯要搞清楚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4461.wav", + "text": "為什麼進入綜規的你不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4462.wav", + "text": "然後到花蓮再到臺東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4463.wav", + "text": "而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4464.wav", + "text": "從已經進綜規的屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4465.wav", + "text": "到臺東然後再到花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4466.wav", + "text": "這個大家要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4467.wav", + "text": "了大家沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4468.wav", + "text": "院長我沒有意見但是我要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4469.wav", + "text": "稍微等一下請宣讀第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4470.wav", + "text": "請柯建銘委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4471.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4472.wav", + "text": "我一直試圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4473.wav", + "text": "讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4474.wav", + "text": "講很多話會有一個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4475.wav", + "text": "整個法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4476.wav", + "text": "我一直在講一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4477.wav", + "text": "非常關鍵的一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4478.wav", + "text": "都是在大家一念之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4479.wav", + "text": "你要把它破壞掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4480.wav", + "text": "民主就毀了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4481.wav", + "text": "所以我今天很誠懇地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4482.wav", + "text": "大家把話講透了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4483.wav", + "text": "剛才也在外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4484.wav", + "text": "跟韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4485.wav", + "text": "還有傅崐萁總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4486.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4487.wav", + "text": "我們在外面有先講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4488.wav", + "text": "要解決事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4489.wav", + "text": "比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4490.wav", + "text": "但是要在立法院軌道上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4491.wav", + "text": "來完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4492.wav", + "text": "我必須承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4493.wav", + "text": "我也瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4494.wav", + "text": "我們堅守的是什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4495.wav", + "text": "請大家瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4496.wav", + "text": "他會很中立處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4497.wav", + "text": "不會把立法院搞亂掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4498.wav", + "text": "你還講一句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4499.wav", + "text": "我們都這把年紀了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4500.wav", + "text": "還在吵什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4501.wav", + "text": "這都是很誠懇的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4502.wav", + "text": "有這種體認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4503.wav", + "text": "於是乎我們三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4504.wav", + "text": "黃國昌以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4505.wav", + "text": "我們在外面都講好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4506.wav", + "text": "了而且我進來代表大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4507.wav", + "text": "的談話內容做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4508.wav", + "text": "試圖性的解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4509.wav", + "text": "等這兩個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4510.wav", + "text": "我們理念講得非常透澈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4511.wav", + "text": "我也不會為難大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4512.wav", + "text": "我們做這樣嘗試性結論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4513.wav", + "text": "大家覺得很滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4514.wav", + "text": "黃國昌不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4515.wav", + "text": "轉到別的地方去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4516.wav", + "text": "前天程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4517.wav", + "text": "強行表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4518.wav", + "text": "通過國會三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4519.wav", + "text": "放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4520.wav", + "text": "這個怎麼解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4521.wav", + "text": "把環島高弄到前面來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4522.wav", + "text": "這個很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4523.wav", + "text": "嘛所以黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4524.wav", + "text": "常常講完就走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4525.wav", + "text": "我一直說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4526.wav", + "text": "他所堅持的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4527.wav", + "text": "一些程序性問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4528.wav", + "text": "我講話你有沒有來插話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4529.wav", + "text": "我承認他講話我有插過話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4530.wav", + "text": "都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4531.wav", + "text": "\n今天禮拜四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4532.wav", + "text": "昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4533.wav", + "text": "我特別到司法及法制委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4534.wav", + "text": "黃國昌第一個發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4535.wav", + "text": "有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4536.wav", + "text": "阿扁的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4537.wav", + "text": "我在那邊看他講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4538.wav", + "text": "而且一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4539.wav", + "text": "的時間都講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4540.wav", + "text": "他照常超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4541.wav", + "text": "發言時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4542.wav", + "text": "吳宗憲不得不站起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4543.wav", + "text": "我們還是很忍耐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4544.wav", + "text": "我在看他到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4545.wav", + "text": "有沒有守規矩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4546.wav", + "text": "我們要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4547.wav", + "text": "只要黃國昌委員走了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4548.wav", + "text": "我們今天試圖把這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4549.wav", + "text": "圓滿起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4550.wav", + "text": "簽一個朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4551.wav", + "text": "大家講好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4552.wav", + "text": "表決輸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4553.wav", + "text": "我們也不可能表決贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4554.wav", + "text": "嘛我們一定會釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4555.wav", + "text": "就是這樣而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4556.wav", + "text": "這個東西就是在程序軌道上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4557.wav", + "text": "我們還要謹守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4558.wav", + "text": "我們所能努力的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4559.wav", + "text": "要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4560.wav", + "text": "那邊發表演講都講錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4561.wav", + "text": "弟話整個程序都是一路沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4562.wav", + "text": "他覺得這個沒收是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4563.wav", + "text": "很有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4564.wav", + "text": "現在要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4565.wav", + "text": "不要發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4566.wav", + "text": "發生衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4567.wav", + "text": "但是我一直講一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4568.wav", + "text": "沒有經過朝野協商的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4569.wav", + "text": "也沒有經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4570.wav", + "text": "院會討論的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4571.wav", + "text": "直接表決那絕對會衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4572.wav", + "text": "這是民主的最後一道防線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4573.wav", + "text": "也不是在恐嚇誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4574.wav", + "text": "所以這個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4575.wav", + "text": "現場講的大家都很明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4576.wav", + "text": "沒有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4577.wav", + "text": "不是馬上處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4578.wav", + "text": "而且院長你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4579.wav", + "text": "有爭議的事情是你來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4580.wav", + "text": "我們都30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4581.wav", + "text": "你要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4582.wav", + "text": "確實幹起院長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4583.wav", + "text": "角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4584.wav", + "text": "我們可以樂意跟你配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4585.wav", + "text": "但只要維持民主程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4586.wav", + "text": "我們現在說的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4587.wav", + "text": "是有算數嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4588.wav", + "text": "我們就白搞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4589.wav", + "text": "接下來請洪孟楷書記長發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4590.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4591.wav", + "text": "好謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4592.wav", + "text": "我們現在進入到第2條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4593.wav", + "text": "但我先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4594.wav", + "text": "針對柯總召剛剛所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4595.wav", + "text": "如果說要扣這大帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4596.wav", + "text": "說什麼現在破壞之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4597.wav", + "text": "民主體制就破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4598.wav", + "text": "我們只想問過去第9屆第10屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4599.wav", + "text": "你們民進黨破壞得還少嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4600.wav", + "text": "剛剛民進黨團代表一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4601.wav", + "text": "過去有協商9次協商8次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4602.wav", + "text": "協商幾次的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4603.wav", + "text": "是各黨有提出相關的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4604.wav", + "text": "能夠讓院長調和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4605.wav", + "text": "限縮再限縮提出有一些共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4606.wav", + "text": "所以當然可以協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4607.wav", + "text": "啊可是從環島高鐵也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4608.wav", + "text": "花東快也好或者是相關的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4609.wav", + "text": "一開始開宗明義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4610.wav", + "text": "我就有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4611.wav", + "text": "如果民進黨的代表真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4612.wav", + "text": "有意見真的有想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4613.wav", + "text": "拿出版本來行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4614.wav", + "text": "拿出版本來我們針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4615.wav", + "text": "逐條逐條大家去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4616.wav", + "text": "小兄弟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4617.wav", + "text": "你如果沒有辦法有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4618.wav", + "text": "那你協商50次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4619.wav", + "text": "協商100次不都一樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4620.wav", + "text": "那不就是了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4621.wav", + "text": "你現在講是說你一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4622.wav", + "text": "又講是說以前的院長你先把麥克風關掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4623.wav", + "text": "我剛剛你在講話的時候我沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4624.wav", + "text": "按過麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4625.wav", + "text": "你先把麥克風關掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4626.wav", + "text": "說實在我們大家互相尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4627.wav", + "text": "對沒錯我現在講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4628.wav", + "text": "你提出來8次9次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4629.wav", + "text": "的協商那是大家各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4630.wav", + "text": "有版本有版本之後院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4631.wav", + "text": "能夠來協調來收納來歸納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4632.wav", + "text": "但是現在重點在於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4633.wav", + "text": "你一開始就講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4634.wav", + "text": "你們沒有拿出版本你們只想反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4635.wav", + "text": "到底那我協商1次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4636.wav", + "text": "3次協商5次有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4637.wav", + "text": "道理嗎再者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4638.wav", + "text": "裡面哪一條沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4639.wav", + "text": "我說實在話裡面每一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4640.wav", + "text": "如果你真的有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4641.wav", + "text": "有要討論的話你就可以針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4642.wav", + "text": "逐條我們現在來討論再者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4643.wav", + "text": "剛剛吳思瑤講我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4644.wav", + "text": "只想要過水想表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4645.wav", + "text": "想表決的是誰想表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4646.wav", + "text": "的是坐在你旁邊的柯建銘啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4647.wav", + "text": "他剛剛就已經講了就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4648.wav", + "text": "唉唷來喔我們來確定明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4649.wav", + "text": "要發言幾個人反正明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4650.wav", + "text": "表決我們會輸誰想表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4651.wav", + "text": "三長先把意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4652.wav", + "text": "統一一致再說啦\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4653.wav", + "text": "最後我真的必須講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4654.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4655.wav", + "text": "很不喜歡口出惡言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4656.wav", + "text": "所以我不會指名道姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4657.wav", + "text": "講到底是誰怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4658.wav", + "text": "可是從一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4659.wav", + "text": "坐下來從兩點坐到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4660.wav", + "text": "要麼是講人家的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4661.wav", + "text": "就是錢坑要麼就是講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4662.wav", + "text": "別人然後講說我們擋什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4663.wav", + "text": "法案等等的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4664.wav", + "text": "說真的從禮拜二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4665.wav", + "text": "的程序委員會我們就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4666.wav", + "text": "確定一二三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4667.wav", + "text": "是國會改革四五是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4668.wav", + "text": "總統國情報告七八" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4669.wav", + "text": "是環島高鐵跟花東快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4670.wav", + "text": "這些都已經確定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4671.wav", + "text": "民進黨團的朋友難道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4672.wav", + "text": "沒有看到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4673.wav", + "text": "沒有想要來溝通討論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4674.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4675.wav", + "text": "就只是想要今天再來做翻盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4676.wav", + "text": "剛剛休息時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4677.wav", + "text": "在外面刻意講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4678.wav", + "text": "我們就拉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4679.wav", + "text": "花東快跟環島高鐵明天來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4680.wav", + "text": "表決就好就是刻意要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4681.wav", + "text": "忽視一二三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4682.wav", + "text": "討論事項的國會改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4683.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4684.wav", + "text": "這不是刻意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4685.wav", + "text": "想要魚目混珠什麼才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4686.wav", + "text": "魚目混珠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4687.wav", + "text": "最後請容許我再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4688.wav", + "text": "一過協商期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4689.wav", + "text": "一個月馬上就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4690.wav", + "text": "表決了之前民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4691.wav", + "text": "還少過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4692.wav", + "text": "2019年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4693.wav", + "text": "5月17號處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4694.wav", + "text": "公告期的公投" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4695.wav", + "text": "把公投" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4696.wav", + "text": "跟大選在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4697.wav", + "text": "變成公投明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4698.wav", + "text": "兩年舉行一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4699.wav", + "text": "5月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4700.wav", + "text": "院會民進黨團提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4701.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4702.wav", + "text": "6月17號直接院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4703.wav", + "text": "三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4704.wav", + "text": "這算什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4705.wav", + "text": "這不就是你們當時一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4706.wav", + "text": "的協商期完之後馬上處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4707.wav", + "text": "公投法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4708.wav", + "text": "公投法怎麼從跟大選在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4709.wav", + "text": "變成每兩年一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4710.wav", + "text": "就是你們在2019年5月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4711.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀6月17號你們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4712.wav", + "text": "表決通過了不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4713.wav", + "text": "有人只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4714.wav", + "text": "會指別人但是不講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4715.wav", + "text": "自己我們就找出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4716.wav", + "text": "你們過去就有這樣的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4717.wav", + "text": "所以拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4718.wav", + "text": "我們今天就事論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4719.wav", + "text": "我沒有演講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4720.wav", + "text": "而你又在犯規了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4721.wav", + "text": "你又按麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4722.wav", + "text": "請你先把麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4723.wav", + "text": "關掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4724.wav", + "text": "你先不要違規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4725.wav", + "text": "如果沒有共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4726.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4727.wav", + "text": "謝謝接下來我們請吳思瑤委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4728.wav", + "text": "再提醒一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4729.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4730.wav", + "text": "平等原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4731.wav", + "text": "第2條的條文其實很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4732.wav", + "text": "是屏東的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4733.wav", + "text": "針對環島高鐵的路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4734.wav", + "text": "怎麼走他其實曾多次表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4735.wav", + "text": "為什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4736.wav", + "text": "這個路線在這個條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4737.wav", + "text": "版本是從臺東銜接到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4738.wav", + "text": "屏東六塊厝站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4739.wav", + "text": "而不是順著從高雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4740.wav", + "text": "而這個路線的選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4741.wav", + "text": "就是交通專業的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4742.wav", + "text": "而且是選區的立委最瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4743.wav", + "text": "屏東的委員他本身就認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4744.wav", + "text": "這個條文不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4745.wav", + "text": "粗糙條文的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4746.wav", + "text": "沒有徵詢在地的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4747.wav", + "text": "那為什麼我要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4748.wav", + "text": "這個路線的劃定跟第2條很有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4749.wav", + "text": "各縣市送到中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4750.wav", + "text": "條例來講行經的路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4751.wav", + "text": "都攸關國土計畫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4752.wav", + "text": "的授權縣市政府要提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4753.wav", + "text": "國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4754.wav", + "text": "怎麼劃定送交給內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4755.wav", + "text": "可是這個條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4756.wav", + "text": "所行經的道路經過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4757.wav", + "text": "生態保育系統或是原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4758.wav", + "text": "需要諮商的區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4759.wav", + "text": "完全都跟縣市政府提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4760.wav", + "text": "所以用這個來辯證以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4761.wav", + "text": "這樣的條例條文以第2條來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4762.wav", + "text": "這個路線是隨便想想隨便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4763.wav", + "text": "畫畫就把它入法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4764.wav", + "text": "這完全不可行除了中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4765.wav", + "text": "政府交通部要配合第二個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4766.wav", + "text": "政府的意願是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4767.wav", + "text": "地方政府的規劃是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4768.wav", + "text": "這完全是非常粗略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4769.wav", + "text": "欠缺跟在地民意的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4770.wav", + "text": "我認為是沒辦法來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4771.wav", + "text": "也要回應一下洪孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4772.wav", + "text": "你又講錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4773.wav", + "text": "公投法有經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4774.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4775.wav", + "text": "有經過充分在協商當中的對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4776.wav", + "text": "才去表決的好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4777.wav", + "text": "我們講的是任何議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4778.wav", + "text": "都要通過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4779.wav", + "text": "逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4780.wav", + "text": "而不是為表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4781.wav", + "text": "而表決然後您剛說民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4782.wav", + "text": "為什麼不提對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4783.wav", + "text": "交通部為什麼不提環島高鐵的對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4784.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4785.wav", + "text": "違反憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4786.wav", + "text": "違反行政權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4787.wav", + "text": "跟立法權限的劃分就不可能提對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4788.wav", + "text": "案我已經講了N次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4789.wav", + "text": "做了不對的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4790.wav", + "text": "還要別人在你不對的事情上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4791.wav", + "text": "提一個對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4792.wav", + "text": "這不是笑掉大牙嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4793.wav", + "text": "說什麼因為民進黨沒有提對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4794.wav", + "text": "所以就合理化你們不應該逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4795.wav", + "text": "就因為民進黨沒有對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4796.wav", + "text": "不可能提對案好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4797.wav", + "text": "因為已經讓交通部門走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4798.wav", + "text": "所以提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4799.wav", + "text": "應當跟我們說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4800.wav", + "text": "他也許可以說服我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4801.wav", + "text": "為什麼他對於這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4802.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵條例是從宜蘭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4803.wav", + "text": "到花蓮然後臺東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4804.wav", + "text": "銜接到屏東六塊厝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4805.wav", + "text": "厝提案委員要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4806.wav", + "text": "啊為什麼屏東這一塊不是從高雄延伸到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4807.wav", + "text": "屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4808.wav", + "text": "提案委員應該說明吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4809.wav", + "text": "可以說服我們啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4810.wav", + "text": "提案委員完全沒有盡到這個條例任何說明的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4811.wav", + "text": "請問有想好好溝通嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4812.wav", + "text": "提案委員沒有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4813.wav", + "text": "你提案的任何一條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4814.wav", + "text": "清楚地說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4815.wav", + "text": "怎麼溝通怎麼說服我們呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4816.wav", + "text": "所以是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4817.wav", + "text": "你們提出來的條文啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4818.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4819.wav", + "text": "這是最起碼要負責任的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4820.wav", + "text": "我們不會提違憲的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4821.wav", + "text": "但是既然你們提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4822.wav", + "text": "你們敢提就要敢說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4823.wav", + "text": "就要敢論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4824.wav", + "text": "所以是不是請提案委員針對第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4825.wav", + "text": "這樣才能夠匯聚共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4826.wav", + "text": "才能夠討論的下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4827.wav", + "text": "提案委員是有這個責任要說明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4828.wav", + "text": "請林思銘委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4829.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4830.wav", + "text": "思瑤我回答你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4831.wav", + "text": "第2條很明確規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4832.wav", + "text": "就是從宜蘭開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4833.wav", + "text": "做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4834.wav", + "text": "宜蘭開始下來而不是由屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4835.wav", + "text": "一直往上走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4836.wav", + "text": "現在是這種邏輯嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4837.wav", + "text": "所以你不能說一定要從屏東往上做嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4838.wav", + "text": "但是我們現在就告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4839.wav", + "text": "第2條我要的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4840.wav", + "text": "就是從宜蘭延伸至花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4841.wav", + "text": "臺東並銜接至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4842.wav", + "text": "屏東縣六塊厝站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4843.wav", + "text": "很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4844.wav", + "text": "我再講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4845.wav", + "text": "你看一下第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4846.wav", + "text": "不要斷章取義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4847.wav", + "text": "第5條講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4848.wav", + "text": "交通部於本條例通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4849.wav", + "text": "每半年檢討一次並於一年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4850.wav", + "text": "會同相關部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4851.wav", + "text": "及縣市政府制定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4852.wav", + "text": "環島高速鐵路建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4853.wav", + "text": "推動發展計畫綱要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4854.wav", + "text": "這講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4855.wav", + "text": "嘛怎麼斷章取義說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4856.wav", + "text": "沒有經過跟縣市政府討論呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4857.wav", + "text": "就是由交通部未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4858.wav", + "text": "依照這個條例通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4859.wav", + "text": "來跟各縣市政府討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4860.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4861.wav", + "text": "各位委員各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4862.wav", + "text": "等一下等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4863.wav", + "text": "可行性評估你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4864.wav", + "text": "在第5條寫是要送立法院審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4865.wav", + "text": "立法院有能力審議這個嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4866.wav", + "text": "交通部要先做可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4867.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4868.wav", + "text": "我在講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4869.wav", + "text": "可是我會容忍你啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4870.wav", + "text": "你按麥克風也無所謂啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4871.wav", + "text": "我不是黃國昌啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4872.wav", + "text": "我們是能夠理性討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4873.wav", + "text": "這是屬於理性討論範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4874.wav", + "text": "名稱是不是叫環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4875.wav", + "text": "對吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4876.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵不是要繞一圈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4877.wav", + "text": "這名字是錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4878.wav", + "text": "錯了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4879.wav", + "text": "聽起來好像很好聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4880.wav", + "text": "什麼叫環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4881.wav", + "text": "你要做的這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4882.wav", + "text": "所以我這邊講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4883.wav", + "text": "剛才吳思瑤也講得很透澈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4884.wav", + "text": "楷我們說違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4885.wav", + "text": "你說不是大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4886.wav", + "text": "我們沒有在跟你講誰是大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4887.wav", + "text": "我們在裝睡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4888.wav", + "text": "是誰在裝睡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4889.wav", + "text": "你根本就不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4890.wav", + "text": "去瞭解憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4891.wav", + "text": "不瞭解什麼大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4892.wav", + "text": "的釋憲條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4893.wav", + "text": "然後說我們在裝睡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4894.wav", + "text": "你是自己裝睡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4895.wav", + "text": "你在這裡講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4896.wav", + "text": "你也許就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4897.wav", + "text": "反正你怎麼講沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4898.wav", + "text": "講給你的支持者聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4899.wav", + "text": "然後去剪一些影音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4900.wav", + "text": "我曾經跟你媽媽同事過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4901.wav", + "text": "我希望的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4902.wav", + "text": "你是一個很負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4903.wav", + "text": "有良心的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4904.wav", + "text": "講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4905.wav", + "text": "要面對自己的良心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4906.wav", + "text": "來這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4907.wav", + "text": "要正派經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4908.wav", + "text": "這個我還講得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4909.wav", + "text": "根本每一條都有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4910.wav", + "text": "我們不會跟你拿對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4911.wav", + "text": "你應該知道吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4912.wav", + "text": "我是挑戰你們每一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4913.wav", + "text": "要不要接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4914.wav", + "text": "反正到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4915.wav", + "text": "我們到院會去處理沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4916.wav", + "text": "但是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4917.wav", + "text": "問題又回來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4918.wav", + "text": "我們剛才在外面講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4919.wav", + "text": "我試圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4920.wav", + "text": "讓今天所有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4921.wav", + "text": "能夠解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4922.wav", + "text": "但是我一直堅持一個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4923.wav", + "text": "韓院長也非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4924.wav", + "text": "沒有經過朝野協商討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4925.wav", + "text": "沒有經過澈底討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4926.wav", + "text": "所以我們要解這個套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4927.wav", + "text": "已經談了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4928.wav", + "text": "了但是我講的話你不會接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4929.wav", + "text": "你講的話我不會接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4930.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4931.wav", + "text": "最後的狀況是院會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4932.wav", + "text": "嘛我們有沒有辦法今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4933.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4934.wav", + "text": "嘗試性地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4935.wav", + "text": "地走完朝野協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4936.wav", + "text": "簽得出來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4937.wav", + "text": "黃國昌不在了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4938.wav", + "text": "那很困難了院長你要思考這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4939.wav", + "text": "否則的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4940.wav", + "text": "以前也常常這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4941.wav", + "text": "他不簽結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4942.wav", + "text": "或是講一半就走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4943.wav", + "text": "但是後來再來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4944.wav", + "text": "後來是拜託他簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4945.wav", + "text": "才有辦法解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4946.wav", + "text": "嘛否則沒有辦法解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4947.wav", + "text": "的院長我一直非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4948.wav", + "text": "珍惜過去30年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4949.wav", + "text": "我們曾經同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4950.wav", + "text": "今天有幸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4951.wav", + "text": "我在這裡見證30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4952.wav", + "text": "我們有義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4953.wav", + "text": "有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4954.wav", + "text": "去維護國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4955.wav", + "text": "的民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4956.wav", + "text": "這是我很懇切講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4957.wav", + "text": "所以希望大家冷靜沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4958.wav", + "text": "就用民主程序處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4959.wav", + "text": "但是至少我們有踐行這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4960.wav", + "text": "我是絕對沒有辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4961.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁你也不用講兄弟話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4962.wav", + "text": "這不是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4963.wav", + "text": "我們不會接受恐嚇的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4964.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4965.wav", + "text": "\n莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4966.wav", + "text": "我還是要談實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4967.wav", + "text": "但是這個實質請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4968.wav", + "text": "認真思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4969.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4970.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召提出這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4971.wav", + "text": "他對花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4972.wav", + "text": "情有獨鍾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4973.wav", + "text": "要發展花蓮的重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4974.wav", + "text": "我深感敬佩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4975.wav", + "text": "真的是敬佩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4976.wav", + "text": "但交通重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4977.wav", + "text": "不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4978.wav", + "text": "每一個條文我都會講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4979.wav", + "text": "等一下每一個條文我全部都會去論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4980.wav", + "text": "但問題就是我們還是卡關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4981.wav", + "text": "憑各位這麼偉大的政治家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4982.wav", + "text": "的聰明才智都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4983.wav", + "text": "可行性評估出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4984.wav", + "text": "做可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4985.wav", + "text": "你怎麼知道評估出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4986.wav", + "text": "就一定要做呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4987.wav", + "text": "全部都已經矛盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4988.wav", + "text": "你們還要求10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4989.wav", + "text": "你們這是要半夜吃西瓜拉肚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4990.wav", + "text": "你們本來是講國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4991.wav", + "text": "迷途知返是很好的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4992.wav", + "text": "知道錯了把它改過來是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4993.wav", + "text": "啊但重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4994.wav", + "text": "可行性評估以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4995.wav", + "text": "是評估什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4996.wav", + "text": "以我們屏東來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4997.wav", + "text": "我們幾次被人家講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4998.wav", + "text": "我們都做完可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/4999.wav", + "text": "這個經濟效益不足啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5000.wav", + "text": "花太多錢啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5001.wav", + "text": "\n你現在說要把它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5002.wav", + "text": "本來你們講10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5003.wav", + "text": "如果可行性評估出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5004.wav", + "text": "大家認為沒有經濟效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5005.wav", + "text": "呢思考一下啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5006.wav", + "text": "而且各個政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5007.wav", + "text": "院長不要協調完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5008.wav", + "text": "到最後變成少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5009.wav", + "text": "當然有代表在啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5010.wav", + "text": "吳委員當然是重量級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5011.wav", + "text": "我們很敬佩的一個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5012.wav", + "text": "所以我必須要去講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5013.wav", + "text": "你們這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5014.wav", + "text": "都是把它當成這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5015.wav", + "text": "一定要做的一定要過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5016.wav", + "text": "的可是你這個條文的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5017.wav", + "text": "不是說要求去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5018.wav", + "text": "我已經有寫進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5019.wav", + "text": "我就是硬要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5020.wav", + "text": "那就變成你這個條文都是寫假的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5021.wav", + "text": "你那就是寫假的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5022.wav", + "text": "難道不是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5023.wav", + "text": "民眾黨你們最注重財政紀律的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5024.wav", + "text": "如果可行性評估出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5025.wav", + "text": "不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5026.wav", + "text": "謝謝瑞雄委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5027.wav", + "text": "好啦好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5028.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5029.wav", + "text": "\n現在請宣讀第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5030.wav", + "text": "\n第3條本條例所稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5031.wav", + "text": "環島高速鐵路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5032.wav", + "text": "範圍包括宜蘭縣花蓮縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5033.wav", + "text": "臺東縣及屏東縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5034.wav", + "text": "沿線規劃之用地取得開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5035.wav", + "text": "及環境保護等公共運輸建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5036.wav", + "text": "及生態保育系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5037.wav", + "text": "黨團幹部我現在請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5038.wav", + "text": "因為我要處理大家晚餐的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5039.wav", + "text": "我們現在去訂晚餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5040.wav", + "text": "我就宣布請總務人員要訂晚餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5041.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有寶貴意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5042.wav", + "text": "我有吃沒有吃都無所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5043.wav", + "text": "啦讓我能夠講話就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5044.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5045.wav", + "text": "麻煩總務部門統計一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5046.wav", + "text": "現場的加班還有後面幕後工作夥伴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5047.wav", + "text": "有多少請幫大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5048.wav", + "text": "簡單訂一點餐飲好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5049.wav", + "text": "現在第一位請吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5050.wav", + "text": "發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5051.wav", + "text": "我看到第3條條文的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5052.wav", + "text": "是跟第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5053.wav", + "text": "所寫的範圍哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5054.wav", + "text": "縣市是重複的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5055.wav", + "text": "第3條的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5056.wav", + "text": "我也覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5057.wav", + "text": "條文的我不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5058.wav", + "text": "它的動詞在講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5059.wav", + "text": "我��得這個條文就是怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5060.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5061.wav", + "text": "說明一下為什麼第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5062.wav", + "text": "已經清楚定義其實是4縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5063.wav", + "text": "第3條又重複講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5064.wav", + "text": "範圍包括哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5065.wav", + "text": "第2條跟第3條完全是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5066.wav", + "text": "重複的而且整個條文就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5067.wav", + "text": "沒有那個動詞我不知道它要ending" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5068.wav", + "text": "在那裡是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5069.wav", + "text": "\n主席是不是要請提案委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5070.wav", + "text": "啊提案委員從頭到尾都沒有說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5071.wav", + "text": "條文我覺得這是很奇怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5072.wav", + "text": "事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5073.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他哪一位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5074.wav", + "text": "要發言沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5075.wav", + "text": "現在意見不統一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5076.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5077.wav", + "text": "前提都沒有說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5078.wav", + "text": "\n第4條本條例之主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5079.wav", + "text": "原來這一條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5080.wav", + "text": "條文就是我們之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5081.wav", + "text": "認為更是期期以為不可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5082.wav", + "text": "原始的條文又有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5083.wav", + "text": "交通部又有國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5084.wav", + "text": "還有地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5085.wav", + "text": "所以現在在修正條文裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5086.wav", + "text": "單一部會叫做交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5087.wav", + "text": "那這樣改有沒有比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5088.wav", + "text": "我不知道因為這要尊重提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5089.wav", + "text": "所以我的建議還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5090.wav", + "text": "我也要求提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5091.wav", + "text": "來說明一下好嗎提案委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5092.wav", + "text": "一下為什麼你們從交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5093.wav", + "text": "國發會縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5094.wav", + "text": "現在只濃縮成為交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5095.wav", + "text": "提案委員請說明好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5096.wav", + "text": "同意就好了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5097.wav", + "text": "第4條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5098.wav", + "text": "提案委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5099.wav", + "text": "等一下等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5100.wav", + "text": "提案委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5101.wav", + "text": "應該給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5102.wav", + "text": "說明的權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5103.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5104.wav", + "text": "人家有問題��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5105.wav", + "text": "我們再來徵詢好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5106.wav", + "text": "主管機關交通部你們有反對是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5107.wav", + "text": "宣讀第5條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5108.wav", + "text": "沒有連原因都要跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5109.wav", + "text": "你沒那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5110.wav", + "text": "交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5111.wav", + "text": "你講什麼話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5112.wav", + "text": "請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5113.wav", + "text": "尊重宣讀人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5114.wav", + "text": "議事人員的權利好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5115.wav", + "text": "交通部有能力統合這些嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5116.wav", + "text": "你一定要想清楚喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5117.wav", + "text": "\n第5條交通部應於本條例通過後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5118.wav", + "text": "立即啟動可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5119.wav", + "text": "每半年內檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5120.wav", + "text": "並於一年內會同相關部會及縣（市）政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5121.wav", + "text": "制定環島高速鐵路建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5122.wav", + "text": "推動發展計畫綱要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5123.wav", + "text": "配合施工工程進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5124.wav", + "text": "需要全部計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5125.wav", + "text": "之建設完成以不逾十二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5126.wav", + "text": "為限擬定綜合建設方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5127.wav", + "text": "其內容如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5128.wav", + "text": "一方案目標及實施範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5129.wav", + "text": "\n二高速鐵路沿線建設規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5130.wav", + "text": "\n三土地徵收取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5131.wav", + "text": "\n四環境綠化保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5132.wav", + "text": "\n五配合天然觀光資源開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5133.wav", + "text": "\n六天然災害防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5134.wav", + "text": "\n七分期實施計畫及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5135.wav", + "text": "執行分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5136.wav", + "text": "\n八分期財務需求及經費來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5137.wav", + "text": "\n九其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5138.wav", + "text": "\n前項所列可行性評估內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5139.wav", + "text": "應送交立法院進行審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5140.wav", + "text": "這一條是整個條例的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5141.wav", + "text": "重中之重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5142.wav", + "text": "國民黨跟民眾黨也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5143.wav", + "text": "共提酌修了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5144.wav", + "text": "原本的原始條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5145.wav", + "text": "我想就是要清楚地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5146.wav", + "text": "地說明跟探究一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5147.wav", + "text": "任何一個交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5148.wav", + "text": "的可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5149.wav", + "text": "尤其像這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5150.wav", + "text": "兆元以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5151.wav", + "text": "它的可行性評估一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5152.wav", + "text": "有評估才會有期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5153.wav", + "text": "我手上就剛好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5154.wav", + "text": "臺灣西部走廊高速鐵路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5155.wav", + "text": "綜合規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5156.wav", + "text": "這個是綜合規劃可行性評估是這一本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5157.wav", + "text": "先有這一本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5158.wav", + "text": "才有這一本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5159.wav", + "text": "先有這一本民國76年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5160.wav", + "text": "然後才有綜合規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5161.wav", + "text": "\n就這個裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5162.wav", + "text": "一個可行性評估進入綜合規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5163.wav", + "text": "它必須要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5164.wav", + "text": "第一個定線與車站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5165.wav", + "text": "包括地質水文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5166.wav", + "text": "怎麼通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5167.wav", + "text": "第二個要有市場的預測及運轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5168.wav", + "text": "包括城際之間的客運需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5169.wav", + "text": "包括各種試算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5170.wav", + "text": "結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5171.wav", + "text": "可行性評估裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5172.wav", + "text": "也需要有具體的站體車站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5173.wav", + "text": "規劃選址" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5174.wav", + "text": "然後建築理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5175.wav", + "text": "風格尺寸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5176.wav", + "text": "每個車站是單一開發還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5177.wav", + "text": "聯合開發之可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5178.wav", + "text": "車站站務設備其他配備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5179.wav", + "text": "相關的規劃這個在車站規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5180.wav", + "text": "再來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5181.wav", + "text": "系統及設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5182.wav", + "text": "我們要採取哪一國的系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5183.wav", + "text": "什麼樣子的車廂採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5184.wav", + "text": "系統及設備非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5185.wav", + "text": "號誌系統電車線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5186.wav", + "text": "系統電信與供電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5187.wav", + "text": "系統電信系統電力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5188.wav", + "text": "供應軌道與倒閘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5189.wav", + "text": "軌道結構軌道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5190.wav", + "text": "鋪設高速運轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5191.wav", + "text": "安全車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5192.wav", + "text": "等等這些都是系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5193.wav", + "text": "及設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5194.wav", + "text": "這個條文都沒有寫到\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5195.wav", + "text": "第六章要進入土木工程與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5196.wav", + "text": "安全設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5197.wav", + "text": "土木工程與安全設施包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5198.wav", + "text": "橫斷面是不是有隧道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5199.wav", + "text": "隧道要經過幾個土方的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5200.wav", + "text": "工程土壤的結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5201.wav", + "text": "整個地震的防護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5202.wav", + "text": "等等安全設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5203.wav", + "text": "外物干擾的偵測因為如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5204.wav", + "text": "進去一些山區可能會有我們的黑熊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5205.wav", + "text": "還是什麼的這些都是必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5206.wav", + "text": "要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5207.wav", + "text": "不是畫了路線就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5208.wav", + "text": "蓋任何的車站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5209.wav", + "text": "都要有維修的基地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5210.wav", + "text": "要設幾個維修基地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5211.wav", + "text": "維修的組織配備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5212.wav", + "text": "路線的作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5213.wav", + "text": "還需要購地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5214.wav", + "text": "及拆遷補償計畫這就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5215.wav", + "text": "重點了你路線行經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5216.wav", + "text": "哪裡要跟地方政府溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5217.wav", + "text": "你會不會經過原住民族你需要行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5218.wav", + "text": "的原住民族諮商權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5219.wav", + "text": "你有多少土地要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5220.wav", + "text": "購地有多少土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5221.wav", + "text": "要去拆遷補償用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5222.wav", + "text": "不同的財務試算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5223.wav", + "text": "去做這些土地的徵得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5224.wav", + "text": "還有原住民族地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5225.wav", + "text": "這些都不能夠跳躍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5226.wav", + "text": "我就不贅述了有自然環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5227.wav", + "text": "生態環境社會環境經濟環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5228.wav", + "text": "等等這些都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5229.wav", + "text": "必要的後面當然還有營運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5230.wav", + "text": "所以沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5231.wav", + "text": "這些清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5232.wav", + "text": "評估你怎麼訂出12" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5233.wav", + "text": "年原始是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5234.wav", + "text": "10年也許聽到我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5235.wav", + "text": "呼籲認為說要更嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5236.wav", + "text": "所以12年可是你們的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5237.wav", + "text": "很粗糙當初我們的高鐵是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5238.wav", + "text": "花了20年從可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5239.wav", + "text": "評估到最後的興建完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5240.wav", + "text": "營運那你們的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5241.wav", + "text": "就只有一個現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5242.wav", + "text": "時代進步了技術進步了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5243.wav", + "text": "所以就可以快速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5244.wav", + "text": "高鐵可以20年現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5245.wav", + "text": "就從10年變到12年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5246.wav", + "text": "我也不知道這個怎麼算來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5247.wav", + "text": "\n這個條文最可議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5248.wav", + "text": "最不可行的就最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5249.wav", + "text": "這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5250.wav", + "text": "可行性評估要送立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5251.wav", + "text": "審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5252.wav", + "text": "所以送審查是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5253.wav", + "text": "意思審查完才可以通過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5254.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5255.wav", + "text": "如果這些審查真的要送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5256.wav", + "text": "立法院審查的話我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5257.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷委員都在交通委會你相對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5258.wav", + "text": "都知道一本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5259.wav", + "text": "要審查多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5260.wav", + "text": "在立法院審議的期程不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5261.wav", + "text": "算嗎這會不會影響你們1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5262.wav", + "text": "12年完工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5263.wav", + "text": "的預判呢時程的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5264.wav", + "text": "認為交通專業送到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5265.wav", + "text": "審查這是很奇怪的事情就如同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5266.wav", + "text": "送立法院審查一樣是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5267.wav", + "text": "政治凌駕專業的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5268.wav", + "text": "所以就以這個重中之重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5269.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵的第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5270.wav", + "text": "樣樣項項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5271.wav", + "text": "都不合理不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5272.wav", + "text": "\n然後我再一次請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5273.wav", + "text": "提案委員請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5274.wav", + "text": "說明您的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5275.wav", + "text": "為什麼是這樣寫主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5276.wav", + "text": "我也要抗議提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5277.wav", + "text": "又戴上他的耳機我不曉得是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5278.wav", + "text": "聽英文歌臺語歌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5279.wav", + "text": "還是在聽什麼廣播電臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5280.wav", + "text": "提案委員帶戴上了他的耳機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5281.wav", + "text": "現在我呼喚他他也不看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5282.wav", + "text": "在聽音樂吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5283.wav", + "text": "這是尊重我們的協商嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5284.wav", + "text": "提案委員提出一個要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5285.wav", + "text": "1兆以上的環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5286.wav", + "text": "拒絕說明條文我們在認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5287.wav", + "text": "的討論他戴上他的耳機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5288.wav", + "text": "聽音樂請問主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5289.wav", + "text": "您要不要制止一下呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5290.wav", + "text": "這是立委之間對於自己職權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5291.wav", + "text": "尊重吧主席您是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5292.wav", + "text": "要制止一下呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5293.wav", + "text": "請問提案委員要不要說明這麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5294.wav", + "text": "的條文是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5295.wav", + "text": "應該說明院長是不是應該說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5296.wav", + "text": "我會徵詢提案委員好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5297.wav", + "text": "請稍待但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5298.wav", + "text": "左邊看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5299.wav", + "text": "我不好意思講太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5300.wav", + "text": "大家都傷感情嘛好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5301.wav", + "text": "他在找資料我知道我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5302.wav", + "text": "因為他也有可能在找資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5303.wav", + "text": "所以我為什麼都尊重每個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5304.wav", + "text": "因為我不好講嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5305.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤你這樣講弄得我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5306.wav", + "text": "提醒提案委員要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5307.wav", + "text": "簡短扼要的說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5308.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5309.wav", + "text": "本席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5310.wav", + "text": "他們今天真的有誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5311.wav", + "text": "要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5312.wav", + "text": "不會說禮拜一鬧了一整天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5313.wav", + "text": "都沒有談這兩條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5314.wav", + "text": "今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5315.wav", + "text": "2點鐘開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5316.wav", + "text": "到6點鐘才開始逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5317.wav", + "text": "而且逐條之前他們已經宣布了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5318.wav", + "text": "他們要聲請大法官釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5319.wav", + "text": "他們完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5320.wav", + "text": "我要跟他們說明什麼我不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5321.wav", + "text": "你完全反對你都講明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5322.wav", + "text": "你要釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5323.wav", + "text": "所以他們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5324.wav", + "text": "就是要過場過場就過場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5325.wav", + "text": "啦就這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5326.wav", + "text": "這條我還沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5327.wav", + "text": "說明你就講一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5328.wav", + "text": "你不要在這邊講那種顛倒是非的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5329.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5330.wav", + "text": "立法院還沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5331.wav", + "text": "開始就說你們要送大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5332.wav", + "text": "釋憲這就是執政者的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5333.wav", + "text": "傲慢都已經講成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5334.wav", + "text": "我認為違憲當然最後要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5335.wav", + "text": "送釋憲不行嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5336.wav", + "text": "等一下等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5337.wav", + "text": "可以這樣講話嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5338.wav", + "text": "我們認為有意見不能送釋憲嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5339.wav", + "text": "各位黨團幹部現在繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5340.wav", + "text": "我們現在討論到第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5341.wav", + "text": "請莊瑞雄委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5342.wav", + "text": "第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5343.wav", + "text": "我來跟各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5344.wav", + "text": "協商代表分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5345.wav", + "text": "當然提到了一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5346.wav", + "text": "限期以12年為限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5347.wav", + "text": "然後去擬定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5348.wav", + "text": "綜合建設的一個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5349.wav", + "text": "然後說前項所列的可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5350.wav", + "text": "內容應該送立法院來進行審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5351.wav", + "text": "也不清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5352.wav", + "text": "似乎就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5353.wav", + "text": "一定要通過立法院的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5354.wav", + "text": "不然要審查的意義在什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5355.wav", + "text": "既然提到了可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5356.wav", + "text": "就更凸顯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5357.wav", + "text": "這個計畫的一個荒謬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5358.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5359.wav", + "text": "520以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5360.wav", + "text": "叫做賴政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5361.wav", + "text": "不是花蓮縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5362.wav", + "text": "新的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5363.wav", + "text": "當然有新的民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5364.wav", + "text": "未來的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5365.wav", + "text": "就職以後叫做賴政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5366.wav", + "text": "我相信發動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5367.wav", + "text": "的是賴政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5368.wav", + "text": "不是花蓮縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5369.wav", + "text": "\n尤其談到這個可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5370.wav", + "text": "這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5371.wav", + "text": "不要開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5372.wav", + "text": "都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5373.wav", + "text": "可行性評估裡面一定要講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5374.wav", + "text": "我們要來蓋這一條花東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5375.wav", + "text": "到底它的技術可不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5376.wav", + "text": "甚至於財務的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5377.wav", + "text": "法律的可行性跟土地取得的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5378.wav", + "text": "可行��以及環境影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5379.wav", + "text": "最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5380.wav", + "text": "當然還會有公聽的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5381.wav", + "text": "那裡面涉及到最嚴重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5382.wav", + "text": "你在整個可行性評估裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5383.wav", + "text": "在經濟可行性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5384.wav", + "text": "評估裡面你總要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5385.wav", + "text": "估看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5386.wav", + "text": "它的成本到底是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5387.wav", + "text": "到底是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5388.wav", + "text": "把財務做一個評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5389.wav", + "text": "一個健全政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5390.wav", + "text": "馬政府如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5391.wav", + "text": "蔡政府如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5392.wav", + "text": "我相信未來的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5393.wav", + "text": "也一樣是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5394.wav", + "text": "\n整部憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5395.wav", + "text": "五權憲法也是你們從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5396.wav", + "text": "的現在增修條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5397.wav", + "text": "也沒有改幾條針對這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5398.wav", + "text": "的也沒有去改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5399.wav", + "text": "整個行政權的發動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5400.wav", + "text": "對整個重大建設的發動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5401.wav", + "text": "你們現在就變成在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5402.wav", + "text": "因為你們是多數你們就認為立法院可以做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5403.wav", + "text": "既然要談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5404.wav", + "text": "可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5405.wav", + "text": "可行性評估完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5406.wav", + "text": "整個工程概算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5407.wav", + "text": "第一個專業真的是不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5408.wav", + "text": "啦再次地強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5409.wav", + "text": "審任何法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5410.wav", + "text": "尤其是政府重大預算加發錢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5411.wav", + "text": "國民黨的委員們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5412.wav", + "text": "也一直在講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5413.wav", + "text": "你們都是反對到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5414.wav", + "text": "上一屆就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5415.wav", + "text": "沒有可行性評估不得編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5416.wav", + "text": "這是當初你們就一直在反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5417.wav", + "text": "一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5418.wav", + "text": "想到哪裡就做到哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5419.wav", + "text": "愛怎麼做就怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5420.wav", + "text": "一二十年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5421.wav", + "text": "我們現在看環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5422.wav", + "text": "這個叫花東高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5423.wav", + "text": "啦花東高鐵好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5424.wav", + "text": "花東高鐵當然會很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5425.wav", + "text": "但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5426.wav", + "text": "推動的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5427.wav", + "text": "還是真的要逐案去做一個推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5428.wav", + "text": "按照一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5429.wav", + "text": "重大工程的程序來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5430.wav", + "text": "不要去想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5431.wav", + "text": "謹記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5432.wav", + "text": "啊我們立法院在審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5433.wav", + "text": "重大預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5434.wav", + "text": "任何的一個重大工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5435.wav", + "text": "超過10億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5436.wav", + "text": "都不是單一部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5437.wav", + "text": "你交通部要花個10億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5438.wav", + "text": "很抱歉沒有那麼容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5439.wav", + "text": "也不是你交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5440.wav", + "text": "你要送到公共工程委員會去做同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5441.wav", + "text": "啊所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5442.wav", + "text": "在講可行性評估的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5443.wav", + "text": "荒謬性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5444.wav", + "text": "啊財務評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5445.wav", + "text": "到底是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5446.wav", + "text": "我管你我哪有需要什麼財務評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5447.wav", + "text": "經濟效益的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5448.wav", + "text": "是多少收益是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5449.wav", + "text": "我管你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5450.wav", + "text": "我愛怎麼寫就怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5451.wav", + "text": "所以這一條我反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5452.wav", + "text": "謝謝莊瑞雄委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5453.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請吳思瑤委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5454.wav", + "text": "針對第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5455.wav", + "text": "我要補充一下一個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5456.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5457.wav", + "text": "很久的李昆澤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5458.wav", + "text": "他是交通委員會的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5459.wav", + "text": "他也是現在立法院交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5460.wav", + "text": "最資深的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5461.wav", + "text": "他請我要代為傳達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5462.wav", + "text": "針對這個重要的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5463.wav", + "text": "昆澤委員是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5464.wav", + "text": "依現在的交通各項評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5465.wav", + "text": "都要納入一個永續經營的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5466.wav", + "text": "如何去落實永續經營的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5467.wav", + "text": "都要藉由事前的專業審查評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5468.wav", + "text": "來納入導入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5469.wav", + "text": "要導入可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5470.wav", + "text": "環境影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5471.wav", + "text": "環差評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5472.wav", + "text": "財務評估等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5473.wav", + "text": "有了這個永續經營灌入的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5474.wav", + "text": "完整評估之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5475.wav", + "text": "才能夠循預算的期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5476.wav", + "text": "來編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5477.wav", + "text": "然後事後來落實配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5478.wav", + "text": "這是最新的觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5479.wav", + "text": "讓交通建設能夠永續經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5480.wav", + "text": "提供民眾穩定便捷安全的運輸系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5481.wav", + "text": "這是李昆澤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5482.wav", + "text": "表達他高度的遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5483.wav", + "text": "他作為立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5484.wav", + "text": "現今在交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5485.wav", + "text": "最最專業的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5486.wav", + "text": "又是此屆的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5487.wav", + "text": "又是負責審查環島高鐵條例的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5488.wav", + "text": "交通委員會的召委之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5489.wav", + "text": "他認為他的意見沒有辦法在這裡納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5490.wav", + "text": "他覺得非常遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5491.wav", + "text": "請我無論如何一定要轉達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5492.wav", + "text": "\n另外因為這個條文是進入期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5493.wav", + "text": "跟可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5494.wav", + "text": "剛剛休息的時間我再把這一本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5495.wav", + "text": "已經是納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5496.wav", + "text": "國會圖書館珍藏的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5497.wav", + "text": "現行的臺灣西部走廊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5498.wav", + "text": "高速鐵路可行性研究評估裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5499.wav", + "text": "一頁來論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5500.wav", + "text": "這是提案委員應當說明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5501.wav", + "text": "提案委員又離場了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5502.wav", + "text": "也就是這有一個很清楚的年限表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5503.wav", + "text": "第一階段要建立計畫管理制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5504.wav", + "text": "第二階段運輸規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5505.wav", + "text": "第三階段是工程概念分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5506.wav", + "text": "第四階段是經濟與財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5507.wav", + "text": "第五階段當然進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5508.wav", + "text": "整個結論建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5509.wav", + "text": "這樣是一個完整的交通的可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5510.wav", + "text": "所以它會落在所有的期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5511.wav", + "text": "總共的年限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5512.wav", + "text": "第一階段要走幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5513.wav", + "text": "第二階段走幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5514.wav", + "text": "然後彼此��會有重疊的時限如果以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5515.wav", + "text": "現在臺灣的高鐵的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5516.wav", + "text": "是花了13年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5517.wav", + "text": "可行性評估的期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5518.wav", + "text": "所以這樣一個評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5519.wav", + "text": "就跟我們現在討論的這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5520.wav", + "text": "完全需要來貼合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5521.wav", + "text": "來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5522.wav", + "text": "如果沒有這樣的專業評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5523.wav", + "text": "我們如何在這個條文裡頭提出要12年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5524.wav", + "text": "所以再一次請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5525.wav", + "text": "\n我們的提案委員傅崐萁委員又離場了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5526.wav", + "text": "這個條文他真的無論如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5527.wav", + "text": "應當說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5528.wav", + "text": "為什麼原本是10年現在變12年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5529.wav", + "text": "那他的提案有沒有經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5530.wav", + "text": "這樣子的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5531.wav", + "text": "嚴謹的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5532.wav", + "text": "然後剛剛李昆澤召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5533.wav", + "text": "所詢問的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5534.wav", + "text": "在傅崐萁委員提案的環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5535.wav", + "text": "其實它應該正名叫做四縣市高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5536.wav", + "text": "啦不是環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5537.wav", + "text": "那這個四縣市高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5538.wav", + "text": "有沒有能夠導入永續經營的理念呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5539.wav", + "text": "所以提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5540.wav", + "text": "應當釋疑好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5541.wav", + "text": "這個條文我沒有辦法支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5542.wav", + "text": "再一次表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5543.wav", + "text": "我補一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5544.wav", + "text": "李昆澤召委剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5545.wav", + "text": "也善意地提醒我們黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5546.wav", + "text": "我想如果各位黨團都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5547.wav", + "text": "尤其春城兄也在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5548.wav", + "text": "下一次我們到法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5549.wav", + "text": "我在發朝野協商開會通知的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5550.wav", + "text": "我一定會列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5551.wav", + "text": "該法案相關的召集委員來這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5552.wav", + "text": "參與朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5553.wav", + "text": "他一旦來這裡開會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5554.wav", + "text": "他自然可以獲得發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5555.wav", + "text": "這樣又不用很尷尬的每一次還要徵詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5556.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5557.wav", + "text": "如果各位黨團都同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5558.wav", + "text": "的確是有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5559.wav", + "text": "因為不見得每個黨團幹部統統都瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5560.wav", + "text": "\n我們接下來請柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5561.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5562.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5563.wav", + "text": "我沒有挑戰的意味" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5564.wav", + "text": "說下次法案朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5565.wav", + "text": "請召委來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5566.wav", + "text": "但是我一開始講的原意是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5567.wav", + "text": "我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5568.wav", + "text": "來處理一個朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5569.wav", + "text": "專門法案預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5570.wav", + "text": "應該怎麼樣那個才是一個完整化的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5571.wav", + "text": "很多法案已經進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5572.wav", + "text": "表決期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5573.wav", + "text": "預算也馬上要協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5574.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5575.wav", + "text": "特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5576.wav", + "text": "追加預算也馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5577.wav", + "text": "要協商所以我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5578.wav", + "text": "把這個機制完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5579.wav", + "text": "建立這個是比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5580.wav", + "text": "把這個建立以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5581.wav", + "text": "後面就照這個途徑去走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5582.wav", + "text": "這些都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5583.wav", + "text": "行之有年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5584.wav", + "text": "第5條我的看法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5585.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5586.wav", + "text": "原來提案版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5587.wav", + "text": "改為15年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5588.wav", + "text": "現在改為交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5589.wav", + "text": "當然不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5590.wav", + "text": "這麼大的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5591.wav", + "text": "這麼大的一個規劃是國發會所能完成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5592.wav", + "text": "我們看過去高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5593.wav", + "text": "從民國76年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5594.wav", + "text": "開始做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5595.wav", + "text": "可行性評估做了3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5596.wav", + "text": "到79年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5597.wav", + "text": "79年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5598.wav", + "text": "到81年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5599.wav", + "text": "兩年的時間可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5600.wav", + "text": "通過以後才被核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5601.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5602.wav", + "text": "經過7年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5603.wav", + "text": "到96年才完工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5604.wav", + "text": "走了20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5605.wav", + "text": "這個條文改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5606.wav", + "text": "前項所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5607.wav", + "text": "內容應送交立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5608.wav", + "text": "剛才吳思瑤講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5609.wav", + "text": "包括方案目標實施及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5610.wav", + "text": "沿線規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5611.wav", + "text": "9款還有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5612.wav", + "text": "突然加上這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5613.wav", + "text": "這個完全是政治介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5614.wav", + "text": "毫無專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5615.wav", + "text": "立法委員不可能有能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5616.wav", + "text": "去審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5617.wav", + "text": "這代表怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5618.wav", + "text": "就是淪為政治作秀舞臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5619.wav", + "text": "發想的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5620.wav", + "text": "就是前項可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5621.wav", + "text": "送立法院審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5622.wav", + "text": "審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5623.wav", + "text": "過與不過與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5624.wav", + "text": "當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5625.wav", + "text": "國會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5626.wav", + "text": "嘛大概國民黨就想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5627.wav", + "text": "現在藍白合起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5628.wav", + "text": "國會過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5629.wav", + "text": "這個東西就用政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5630.wav", + "text": "來處理表決就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5631.wav", + "text": "司馬昭之心路人皆知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5632.wav", + "text": "\n和這個題目有關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5633.wav", + "text": "就是我們第一次朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5634.wav", + "text": "有關的立法院決議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5635.wav", + "text": "但是民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5636.wav", + "text": "多提一個叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5637.wav", + "text": "彰化晶鼎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5638.wav", + "text": "晶鼎焚化爐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5639.wav", + "text": "有9座焚化爐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5640.wav", + "text": "要再蓋一個焚化爐當然當地反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5641.wav", + "text": "嘛當地反對的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5642.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5643.wav", + "text": "不應該再蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5644.wav", + "text": "但是黃國昌用一個政治力介" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5645.wav", + "text": "一個決議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5646.wav", + "text": "在立法院表決要立即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5647.wav", + "text": "停工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5648.wav", + "text": "這個所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5649.wav", + "text": "依照合約走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5650.wav", + "text": "有嚴格的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5651.wav", + "text": "做不下去就把它停掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5652.wav", + "text": "用現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5653.wav", + "text": "藍白國會過半介入���有的一切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5654.wav", + "text": "這是一個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5655.wav", + "text": "荒謬而且惡質的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5656.wav", + "text": "一個寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5657.wav", + "text": "這麼專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5658.wav", + "text": "沒有一個立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5659.wav", + "text": "搞得懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5660.wav", + "text": "都要經過繁雜的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5661.wav", + "text": "各位想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5662.wav", + "text": "高鐵蓋到一半的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5663.wav", + "text": "曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5664.wav", + "text": "本來政府出資不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5665.wav", + "text": "只有25" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5666.wav", + "text": "然後還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5667.wav", + "text": "才能夠把它財務稍微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5668.wav", + "text": "改善走得下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5669.wav", + "text": "而這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5670.wav", + "text": "修這個東西時還在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5671.wav", + "text": "通過表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5672.wav", + "text": "還是蓋不下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5673.wav", + "text": "馬英九下臺以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5674.wav", + "text": "行政院長毛治國他本身是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5675.wav", + "text": "交通部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5676.wav", + "text": "為了高鐵該怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5677.wav", + "text": "那時候有財改計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5678.wav", + "text": "但那財改計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5679.wav", + "text": "必須在立法院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5680.wav", + "text": "這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5681.wav", + "text": "是造成整個交通黑暗期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5682.wav", + "text": "非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5683.wav", + "text": "所以後來范" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5684.wav", + "text": "范志強董事長之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5685.wav", + "text": "的折舊時間拉長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5686.wav", + "text": "折舊時間拉長了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5687.wav", + "text": "就馬上沒有虧損了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5688.wav", + "text": "因為折舊拉長了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5689.wav", + "text": "這樣高鐵才活起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5690.wav", + "text": "到現在高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5691.wav", + "text": "能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5692.wav", + "text": "有盈餘賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5693.wav", + "text": "到一半的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5694.wav", + "text": "馬英九曾說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5695.wav", + "text": "這個以後會變成廢鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5696.wav", + "text": "這麼冗長的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5697.wav", + "text": "前一陣子我碰到殷琪董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5698.wav", + "text": "但是後來他寫好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5699.wav", + "text": "好了不敢出版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5700.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5701.wav", + "text": "高鐵是這麼複雜的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5702.wav", + "text": "5大公司介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5703.wav", + "text": "有包機電的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5704.wav", + "text": "的包土木的等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5705.wav", + "text": "這樣的情形之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5706.wav", + "text": "他覺得別人也不一定相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5707.wav", + "text": "\n從這裡看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5708.wav", + "text": "第5條這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5709.wav", + "text": "把它全部交給立法院來審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5710.wav", + "text": "藍白合起來過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5711.wav", + "text": "出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5712.wav", + "text": "前一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5713.wav", + "text": "又把10年改為12年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5714.wav", + "text": "這是非常不負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5715.wav", + "text": "是萬萬不可能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5716.wav", + "text": "所以對於這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5717.wav", + "text": "我們表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5718.wav", + "text": "無法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5719.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯建銘總召的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5720.wav", + "text": "\n莊委員瑞雄您還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5721.wav", + "text": "再發言嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5722.wav", + "text": "我想再發言一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5723.wav", + "text": "重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5724.wav", + "text": "但是我還是要再次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5725.wav", + "text": "一個重大工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5726.wav", + "text": "真的要審慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5727.wav", + "text": "而且不是用這樣的一個立法方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5728.wav", + "text": "光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5729.wav", + "text": "藍白合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5730.wav", + "text": "提出這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5731.wav", + "text": "你看從主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5732.wav", + "text": "我贊成去做可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5733.wav", + "text": "但是可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5734.wav", + "text": "到最後不是立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5735.wav", + "text": "來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5736.wav", + "text": "可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5737.wav", + "text": "做了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5738.wav", + "text": "你就必須要概估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5739.wav", + "text": "到底有多少院長你當過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5740.wav", + "text": "市長你會很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5741.wav", + "text": "做了可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5742.wav", + "text": "我認為技術上可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5743.wav", + "text": "我認為土地取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5744.wav", + "text": "也都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5745.wav", + "text": "我認為環評也會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5746.wav", + "text": "但是可行性評估可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5747.wav", + "text": "會比環評更快完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5748.wav", + "text": "可是重點來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5749.wav", + "text": "重點就是可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5750.wav", + "text": "出來的過程中必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5751.wav", + "text": "假設估出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5752.wav", + "text": "是1兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5753.wav", + "text": "不要說2兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5754.wav", + "text": "估出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5755.wav", + "text": "綜合規劃我不能去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5756.wav", + "text": "發包完以後綜合規劃出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5757.wav", + "text": "要有人核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5758.wav", + "text": "耶我請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5759.wav", + "text": "是賴政府來核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5760.wav", + "text": "還是立法院來核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5761.wav", + "text": "重大公共工程建設全部把它給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5762.wav", + "text": "顛覆掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5763.wav", + "text": "我們都知道各縣市都想要有重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5764.wav", + "text": "這個是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5765.wav", + "text": "你們現在不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5766.wav", + "text": "因為你們在立法院人數比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5767.wav", + "text": "好像就用通過一個條例把它給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5768.wav", + "text": "框住了讓你們非做不可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5769.wav", + "text": "真的是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5770.wav", + "text": "我很想說不然這個過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5771.wav", + "text": "我在幫你做高鐵的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5772.wav", + "text": "情況乾脆跟台積電說好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5773.wav", + "text": "再送一個台積電好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5774.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思是不能異想天開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5775.wav", + "text": "整個建設計畫以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5776.wav", + "text": "綜規完了以後這個計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5777.wav", + "text": "總要有人核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5778.wav", + "text": "不要弄一個法律到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5779.wav", + "text": "會產生一個僵局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5780.wav", + "text": "如果賴政府不跟你核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5781.wav", + "text": "那你怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5782.wav", + "text": "真的讓我們很佩服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5783.wav", + "text": "同樣的留聲機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5784.wav", + "text": "從禮拜一的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5785.wav", + "text": "已經轉了大概一百零多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5786.wav", + "text": "今天又持續轉他們三位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5787.wav", + "text": "發言完全沒有改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5788.wav", + "text": "你亂講我就有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5789.wav", + "text": "我先講待會你要講再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5790.wav", + "text": "你要點名我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5791.wav", + "text": "你剛剛點名我你剛剛有沒有點名我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5792.wav", + "text": "我說花蓮我沒有講你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5793.wav", + "text": "我點名你要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5794.wav", + "text": "請尊重院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5795.wav", + "text": "請尊重院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5796.wav", + "text": "是你點名我你不尊重人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5797.wav", + "text": "民進黨就是這麼鴨霸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5798.wav", + "text": "請尊重一下發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5799.wav", + "text": "因為院長在主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5800.wav", + "text": "他們已經表明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5801.wav", + "text": "他們就是抵制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5802.wav", + "text": "但是要透過這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5803.wav", + "text": "過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5804.wav", + "text": "他們從頭到尾就是在羞辱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5805.wav", + "text": "羞辱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5806.wav", + "text": "羞辱好像不應該去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5807.wav", + "text": "這樣的環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5808.wav", + "text": "也羞辱了韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5809.wav", + "text": "今年在2月份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5810.wav", + "text": "告訴陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5811.wav", + "text": "這麼先進的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5812.wav", + "text": "早就該做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5813.wav", + "text": "但是政府就是不願意做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5814.wav", + "text": "所以國會議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5815.wav", + "text": "本來就應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5816.wav", + "text": "必須要來做這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5817.wav", + "text": "本來就有這些條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5818.wav", + "text": "我們一再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5819.wav", + "text": "我不願意把錄音機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5820.wav", + "text": "再轉一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5821.wav", + "text": "但是他們轉了一百零多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5822.wav", + "text": "而且不斷的醜化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5823.wav", + "text": "不斷的誤導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5824.wav", + "text": "在講這個細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5825.wav", + "text": "什麼叫材料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5826.wav", + "text": "路線在哪裡然後怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5827.wav", + "text": "怎麼會故意在這裡講這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5828.wav", + "text": "當然是這個條例通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5829.wav", + "text": "行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5830.wav", + "text": "交通部就開始進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5831.wav", + "text": "怎麼會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5832.wav", + "text": "我們要來訂什麼材料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5833.wav", + "text": "什麼系統什麼車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5834.wav", + "text": "在這裡詐騙所有不懂的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5835.wav", + "text": "我們要再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5836.wav", + "text": "條例過了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5837.wav", + "text": "交通部該怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5838.wav", + "text": "它會循序漸進去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5839.wav", + "text": "這些東西都是一個基本的常識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5840.wav", + "text": "你不用在那邊專程錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5841.wav", + "text": "你民進黨的助理不用在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5842.wav", + "text": "這個上網通通都有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5843.wav", + "text": "不用故意在那邊錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5844.wav", + "text": "我要特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5845.wav", + "text": "我才講幾分鐘他們講多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5846.wav", + "text": "你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5847.wav", + "text": "我才講一下話他們幾個人在插" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5848.wav", + "text": "話他們在講話的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5849.wav", + "text": "我們有插話他們嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5850.wav", + "text": "今天實在是很不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5851.wav", + "text": "用這種素質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5852.wav", + "text": "執政黨就這種素質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5853.wav", + "text": "我們要再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5854.wav", + "text": "國會議員所提出來的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5855.wav", + "text": "在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5856.wav", + "text": "不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5857.wav", + "text": "民國90年10月11號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5858.wav", + "text": "三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5859.wav", + "text": "廖學廣委員所提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5860.wav", + "text": "基隆河流域整治特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5861.wav", + "text": "通過了以後行政院也執行了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5862.wav", + "text": "剛剛也講到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5863.wav", + "text": "林正峰委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5864.wav", + "text": "包括40個委員連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5865.wav", + "text": "民進黨也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5866.wav", + "text": "就是石門水庫及其集水區整治特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5867.wav", + "text": "在95年1月13號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5868.wav", + "text": "三讀通過行政院也執行了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5869.wav", + "text": "當然可能當時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5870.wav", + "text": "政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5871.wav", + "text": "是可以順應國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5872.wav", + "text": "國會提醒它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5873.wav", + "text": "有些沒做到的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5874.wav", + "text": "要儘快積極的來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5875.wav", + "text": "所以當時的政府有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5876.wav", + "text": "可能沒有像現在是如此的傲慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5877.wav", + "text": "如此的跋扈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5878.wav", + "text": "能夠在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5879.wav", + "text": "每一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5880.wav", + "text": "用同樣的方式都罵一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5881.wav", + "text": "就是很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5882.wav", + "text": "我認為他們到今天為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5883.wav", + "text": "把所有不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5884.wav", + "text": "討論的細項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5885.wav", + "text": "這都應該要交通部專業去處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5886.wav", + "text": "故意在這裡不斷repeat" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5887.wav", + "text": "把在野黨污名化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5888.wav", + "text": "把在野黨醜化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5889.wav", + "text": "他們三個人就講了多少次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5890.wav", + "text": "我跟黃國昌怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5891.wav", + "text": "還說沒有點名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5892.wav", + "text": "動不動就說沒有點名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5893.wav", + "text": "這個都有錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5894.wav", + "text": "可以隨時轉過來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5895.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5896.wav", + "text": "明天就要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5897.wav", + "text": "所以柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5898.wav", + "text": "在這裡公然恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5899.wav", + "text": "國會議員明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5900.wav", + "text": "會有史上最嚴重的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5901.wav", + "text": "公然恐嚇我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5902.wav", + "text": "但為了回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5903.wav", + "text": "廣大民意這是我們必須要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5904.wav", + "text": "我們不會接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5905.wav", + "text": "任何賄賂及任何的交換條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5906.wav", + "text": "或用什麼地方的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5907.wav", + "text": "來交換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5908.wav", + "text": "明天不要審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5909.wav", + "text": "國家至上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5910.wav", + "text": "國會改革絕對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5911.wav", + "text": "是重中之重我們一定要進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5912.wav", + "text": "已經一語道破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5913.wav", + "text": "即便立法院三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5914.wav", + "text": "他們要提釋憲他們也不會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5915.wav", + "text": "上次你也裁示過等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5916.wav", + "text": "新的部長來以後我們再來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5917.wav", + "text": "言猶在耳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5918.wav", + "text": "我們也都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5919.wav", + "text": "從頭到尾在這裡開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5920.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重院長的裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5921.wav", + "text": "要動員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5922.wav", + "text": "的可能明天我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5923.wav", + "text": "讓國會的尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5924.wav", + "text": "與議事能夠順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5925.wav", + "text": "\n我要再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5926.wav", + "text": "國民黨絕對有決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5927.wav", + "text": "讓陽光照進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5928.wav", + "text": "是對建設的攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5929.wav", + "text": "所謂逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5930.wav", + "text": "了你可以表達你的意見不願意不同意就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5931.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5932.wav", + "text": "但不是每一條都要做人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5933.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5934.wav", + "text": "你根本毫無柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5935.wav", + "text": "你可不可以讓我同意你發言再發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5936.wav", + "text": "先等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5937.wav", + "text": "我跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5938.wav", + "text": "我已經很老了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5939.wav", + "text": "所以第一個環島高鐵要趕快做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5940.wav", + "text": "第二個東部臺灣跟西部臺灣要連成一條線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5941.wav", + "text": "國道六號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5942.wav", + "text": "結果陳建仁院長也很感動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5943.wav", + "text": "那是個對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5944.wav", + "text": "過兩天卓榮泰院長也要來拜訪我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5945.wav", + "text": "這個也回應了莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5946.wav", + "text": "一直問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5947.wav", + "text": "一直問我說我把高鐵當成盲腸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5948.wav", + "text": "因為過兩天卓榮泰院長要來拜訪我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5949.wav", + "text": "一樣環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5950.wav", + "text": "東部臺灣跟西部臺灣要連成一條線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5951.wav", + "text": "讓整個臺灣生命力放出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5952.wav", + "text": "第三個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5953.wav", + "text": "下一代一定中英雙語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5954.wav", + "text": "全面實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5955.wav", + "text": "這個我一定會跟卓榮泰院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5956.wav", + "text": "高屏這一段高鐵看作盲腸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5957.wav", + "text": "我都糊塗了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5958.wav", + "text": "因為我總是想把臺灣連成一條線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5959.wav", + "text": "在此我一併做一個澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5960.wav", + "text": "你大概講了我五六次我都沒有回話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5961.wav", + "text": "但過幾天卓院長來我會重申一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5962.wav", + "text": "我的理想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5963.wav", + "text": "整個臺灣連成一條線生命力放出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5964.wav", + "text": "這是我個人的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5965.wav", + "text": "等到高鐵做完我早就去西方極樂世界報到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5966.wav", + "text": "開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5967.wav", + "text": "的但是我們要為子孫留一些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5968.wav", + "text": "所以我跟陳建仁院長鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5969.wav", + "text": "也希望卓院長能夠接納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5970.wav", + "text": "這些法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5971.wav", + "text": "這是我們立法院的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5972.wav", + "text": "我沒有別的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5973.wav", + "text": "我盡可能維持公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5974.wav", + "text": "不過我把我心裡的話跟各位黨團幹部來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5975.wav", + "text": "今天也辛苦了大家真的很累了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15924/5976.wav", + "text": "我們就留待下次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15917/0.wav", + "text": "先跟大家說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15917/1.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15917/2.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15917/3.wav", + "text": "政府的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15917/4.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15917/5.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15917/6.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15914/0.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15914/1.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15914/2.wav", + "text": "的我們現在在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15914/3.wav", + "text": "得這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15914/4.wav", + "text": "報告這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15914/5.wav", + "text": "措施這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15914/6.wav", + "text": "八年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15914/7.wav", + "text": "價差這個部分也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15914/8.wav", + "text": "我們也願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/0.wav", + "text": "今天主要是有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1.wav", + "text": "全民健康保險法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/2.wav", + "text": "黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/3.wav", + "text": "現在要併案協商的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/4.wav", + "text": "全民健康保險法第62條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/5.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/6.wav", + "text": "總共有5個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/7.wav", + "text": "已經併案審查完竣3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/8.wav", + "text": "委員王育敏等19人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/9.wav", + "text": "委員蘇清泉等28人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/10.wav", + "text": "及國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/11.wav", + "text": "分別擬具全民健康保險法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/12.wav", + "text": "第62條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/13.wav", + "text": "二逕付二讀案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/14.wav", + "text": "委員謝衣鳯等21人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/15.wav", + "text": "委員楊瓊瓔等26人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/16.wav", + "text": "分別擬具全民健康保險法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/17.wav", + "text": "第62條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/18.wav", + "text": "\n現在開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/19.wav", + "text": "審查完竣的有3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/20.wav", + "text": "今天有逕付二讀的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/21.wav", + "text": "2個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/22.wav", + "text": "針對這總共5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/23.wav", + "text": "經過這段期間主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/24.wav", + "text": "有沒有深思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/25.wav", + "text": "到底醫界的這些訴求當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/26.wav", + "text": "可以呼應醫界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/27.wav", + "text": "真的非常辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/28.wav", + "text": "醫院的經營也不是很容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/29.wav", + "text": "包括國民黨黨團提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/30.wav", + "text": "希望調高健保點值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/31.wav", + "text": "就是希望可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/32.wav", + "text": "不要讓醫事人員付出的心力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/33.wav", + "text": "不曉得衛福部這邊是不是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/34.wav", + "text": "調整了一些作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/35.wav", + "text": "主席及各位委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/36.wav", + "text": "我們也在思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/37.wav", + "text": "無論上次的審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/38.wav", + "text": "或委員所辦的公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/39.wav", + "text": "各界的一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/40.wav", + "text": "還是在處理的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/41.wav", + "text": "如果照這幾個版本所提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/42.wav", + "text": "因為這裡面的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/43.wav", + "text": "顯然不是衛福部單獨一個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/44.wav", + "text": "所能夠解決的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/45.wav", + "text": "我們現在在盤點這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/46.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/47.wav", + "text": "這個非常重要的政見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/48.wav", + "text": "健康臺灣其實也舉辦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/49.wav", + "text": "多次的論壇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/50.wav", + "text": "當中當然也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/51.wav", + "text": "包括你們上次說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/52.wav", + "text": "是不是要有一些增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/53.wav", + "text": "這些到底有沒有在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/54.wav", + "text": "賴總統就上任了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/55.wav", + "text": "所以健康論壇是健康論壇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/56.wav", + "text": "一個上位的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/57.wav", + "text": "引領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/58.wav", + "text": "賴總統要上任了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/59.wav", + "text": "他自己的政見會不會變成政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/60.wav", + "text": "這是大家關注的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/61.wav", + "text": "大家其實也很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/62.wav", + "text": "由相關單位相關司署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/63.wav", + "text": "署針對這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/64.wav", + "text": "我們在政策上面是不是都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/65.wav", + "text": "可以執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/66.wav", + "text": "是哪些現在都還在盤點當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/67.wav", + "text": "這個工作沒有暫緩下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/68.wav", + "text": "所以有持續在研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/69.wav", + "text": "國發會和行政院主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/70.wav", + "text": "是不是也講一下這段期間你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/71.wav", + "text": "有沒有做什麼討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/72.wav", + "text": "有沒有什麼進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/73.wav", + "text": "請國發會謝處長講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/74.wav", + "text": "沒有進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/75.wav", + "text": "沒有在動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/76.wav", + "text": "行政院主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/77.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/78.wav", + "text": "基金預算處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/79.wav", + "text": "請黃專門委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/80.wav", + "text": "你們有接到指令嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/81.wav", + "text": "沒有政策上還沒有指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/82.wav", + "text": "沒有下達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/83.wav", + "text": "只有衛福部有接收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/84.wav", + "text": "你們要pass出去啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/85.wav", + "text": "這件事情大家有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/86.wav", + "text": "所以現在還停留在衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/87.wav", + "text": "還沒有到其他部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/88.wav", + "text": "所以國發會跟行政院主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/89.wav", + "text": "基金預算處都沒有嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/90.wav", + "text": "我的意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/91.wav", + "text": "只有你們在研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/92.wav", + "text": "其他部會其實都還在看你們研議出什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/93.wav", + "text": "裡面需要的經費有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/94.wav", + "text": "如果真的需要他們幫忙的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/95.wav", + "text": "才會找他們一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/96.wav", + "text": "黃秀芳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/97.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/98.wav", + "text": "等到新部長上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/99.wav", + "text": "我們再來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/100.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟新的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/101.wav", + "text": "下禮拜就要上任了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/102.wav", + "text": "可以先緩一緩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/103.wav", + "text": "可以找到財源也不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/104.wav", + "text": "內閣上任之後新部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/105.wav", + "text": "到任我們再來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/106.wav", + "text": "蘇清泉委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/107.wav", + "text": "昨天幾位大醫院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/108.wav", + "text": "這兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/109.wav", + "text": "我們的平均餘命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/110.wav", + "text": "已經下降了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/111.wav", + "text": "我跟秀芳召委說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/112.wav", + "text": "我們這兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/113.wav", + "text": "減2歲的原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/114.wav", + "text": "是全世界最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/115.wav", + "text": "為什麼全世界最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/116.wav", + "text": "就是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/117.wav", + "text": "健保署有像石崇良署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/118.wav", + "text": "那麼優秀的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/119.wav", + "text": "他對健保和對每一家醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/120.wav", + "text": "但是他不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/121.wav", + "text": "所以每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/122.wav", + "text": "醫療院所看到石崇良" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/123.wav", + "text": "就聞風喪膽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/124.wav", + "text": "我們醫療的優點就是可近性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/125.wav", + "text": "公平性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/126.wav", + "text": "這還會往下掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/127.wav", + "text": "我今天要去跟內政部要2023年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/128.wav", + "text": "我跟大家保證會再往下掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/129.wav", + "text": "不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/130.wav", + "text": "很方便很便宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/131.wav", + "text": "那是累積在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/132.wav", + "text": "醫護人員的假象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/133.wav", + "text": "王正旭委員每天也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/134.wav", + "text": "這是事實他都不敢罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/135.wav", + "text": "罵他又講不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/136.wav", + "text": "政黨不配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/137.wav", + "text": "我很嚴肅的跟大家報告這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/138.wav", + "text": "癌症品質也下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/139.wav", + "text": "糖尿病等等的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/140.wav", + "text": "死亡率也增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/141.wav", + "text": "顯示掉了2歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/142.wav", + "text": "澳門新加坡都還差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/143.wav", + "text": "我們現在平均餘命剩下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/144.wav", + "text": "79.84" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/145.wav", + "text": "歲等於10年前的平均壽命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/146.wav", + "text": "這個很糟糕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/147.wav", + "text": "我們要廢總額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/148.wav", + "text": "我要再次澄清我們沒有要廢總額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/149.wav", + "text": "我們是要把總額改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/150.wav", + "text": "目標制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/151.wav", + "text": "制就是有一個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/152.wav", + "text": "的部分看你要打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/153.wav", + "text": "苟延殘喘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/154.wav", + "text": "的錢就這麼簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/155.wav", + "text": "來用總額預算丟給醫界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/156.wav", + "text": "把財務風險全部丟給醫界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/157.wav", + "text": "衛福部只要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/158.wav", + "text": "就把全部財務管理丟給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/159.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/160.wav", + "text": "億元這樣累積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/161.wav", + "text": "現在醫界已經吞下好幾千億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/162.wav", + "text": "元了王委員也不否認這點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/163.wav", + "text": "再這樣下去一定受不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/164.wav", + "text": "所以現在為什麼會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/165.wav", + "text": "有這麼大的反彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/166.wav", + "text": "因為疫情之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/167.wav", + "text": "所有的年輕人不管醫事相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/168.wav", + "text": "連醫師自己都感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/169.wav", + "text": "到他們不像我們以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/170.wav", + "text": "刻苦耐勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/171.wav", + "text": "勞石崇良當住院醫師的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/172.wav", + "text": "我們被霸凌的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/173.wav", + "text": "也都靜靜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/174.wav", + "text": "為了抱負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/175.wav", + "text": "我跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/176.wav", + "text": "50幾年次以後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/177.wav", + "text": "不用想了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/178.wav", + "text": "60幾年次70幾年次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/179.wav", + "text": "講待遇講休假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/180.wav", + "text": "你跟他講什麼偏遠地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/181.wav", + "text": "去屏東山地離島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/182.wav", + "text": "拚你講理想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/183.wav", + "text": "聽的人一個都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/184.wav", + "text": "所以這是現在年輕世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/185.wav", + "text": "不只是醫界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/186.wav", + "text": "包括科技業也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/187.wav", + "text": "\n所以現在人跑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/188.wav", + "text": "新加坡的醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/189.wav", + "text": "放射師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/190.wav", + "text": "新加坡的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/191.wav", + "text": "放射技師大概1415萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/192.wav", + "text": "他們也怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/193.wav", + "text": "人跑了結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/194.wav", + "text": "真的跑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/195.wav", + "text": "他們的護士找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/196.wav", + "text": "馬來西亞和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/197.wav", + "text": "菲律賓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/198.wav", + "text": "結果現在居然找不到人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/199.wav", + "text": "跑去哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/200.wav", + "text": "跑去加拿大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/201.wav", + "text": "高到那邊上班試用期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/202.wav", + "text": "權我們在搶人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/203.wav", + "text": "耶我們現在人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/204.wav", + "text": "臺灣有專業技術的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/205.wav", + "text": "跟臺灣人在外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/206.wav", + "text": "不要講臺勞不好聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/207.wav", + "text": "有80幾萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/208.wav", + "text": "我們出去的是技術人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/209.wav", + "text": "我們邀進來的是勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/210.wav", + "text": "補充人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/211.wav", + "text": "這是不是對國家造成隱憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/212.wav", + "text": "我想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/213.wav", + "text": "次長石崇良署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/214.wav", + "text": "那麼優秀石崇良頭腦很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/215.wav", + "text": "他一定會想出好辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/216.wav", + "text": "政府一年要出36%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/217.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/218.wav", + "text": "朱澤民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/219.wav", + "text": "反正他會湊出一些數據給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/220.wav", + "text": "所以問他等於白問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/221.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/222.wav", + "text": "政府應該出36%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/223.wav", + "text": "去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/224.wav", + "text": "如果36%的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/225.wav", + "text": "政府短少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/226.wav", + "text": "937億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/227.wav", + "text": "112年937億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/228.wav", + "text": "元111年883億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/229.wav", + "text": "元110年700多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/230.wav", + "text": "嚇死人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/231.wav", + "text": "或者靠停車場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/232.wav", + "text": "美食街的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/233.wav", + "text": "造成自費的市場非常雜亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/234.wav", + "text": "我們常常聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/235.wav", + "text": "鄉親選民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/236.wav", + "text": "自費一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/237.wav", + "text": "這都是扭曲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/238.wav", + "text": "不忍心看到這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/239.wav", + "text": "沒有私人保險的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/240.wav", + "text": "一般底層的人怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/241.wav", + "text": "們修法的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/242.wav", + "text": "總額目標制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/243.wav", + "text": "總額目標線下1點1元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/244.wav", + "text": "超額部分打折給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/245.wav", + "text": "折數協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/246.wav", + "text": "超額打折後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/247.wav", + "text": "公務預算來補或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/248.wav", + "text": "政府投資要夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/249.wav", + "text": "醫療院所不會刻意衝量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/250.wav", + "text": "你的修法報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/251.wav", + "text": "元1點1元要補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/252.wav", + "text": "1,100億元等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/253.wav", + "text": "所以政府吃老百姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/254.wav", + "text": "所以不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/255.wav", + "text": "政府依照健保法應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/256.wav", + "text": "應該承擔的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/257.wav", + "text": "健康臺灣提到政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/258.wav", + "text": "要投資38%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/259.wav", + "text": "我心裡想說36%能補足就很厲害了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/260.wav", + "text": "所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/261.wav", + "text": "要有個結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/262.wav", + "text": "不要一直討論討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/263.wav", + "text": "討論就是擺爛嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/264.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/265.wav", + "text": "你自己都說1點1元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/266.wav", + "text": "我看到民視的截圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/267.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統說1點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/268.wav", + "text": "我心想他是不是講錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/269.wav", + "text": "還是我聽錯他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/270.wav", + "text": "對不對我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/271.wav", + "text": "來提出好的對策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/272.wav", + "text": "已經到非改革不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/273.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/274.wav", + "text": "今天沒有看到部長看到次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/275.wav", + "text": "跟署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/276.wav", + "text": "我陳昭姿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/277.wav", + "text": "在健保署誕生那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/278.wav", + "text": "受聘到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/279.wav", + "text": "我的聘書都還在經歷4位總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/280.wav", + "text": "大概超過10位署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/281.wav", + "text": "所以我參與到一個相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/282.wav", + "text": "我就用我很專業理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/283.wav", + "text": "的角度來談這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/284.wav", + "text": "健保開辦將近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/285.wav", + "text": "第一個10年其實大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/286.wav", + "text": "很滿意都很happy" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/287.wav", + "text": "大家比較沒有相對的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/288.wav", + "text": "而且早期的設計也沒有想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/289.wav", + "text": "後來醫學這麼進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/290.wav", + "text": "造成很多高規格高標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/291.wav", + "text": "得這麼快所以第一個10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/292.wav", + "text": "大家都很開心度過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/293.wav", + "text": "民眾滿意度也很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/294.wav", + "text": "第二個10年老實說已經遇到一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/295.wav", + "text": "財務上的挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/296.wav", + "text": "有驚無險的度過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/297.wav", + "text": "第三個10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/298.wav", + "text": "10年就是現在而且是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/299.wav", + "text": "在最後的12年我想不可否認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/300.wav", + "text": "大家為什麼會有這個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/301.wav", + "text": "因為我們覺得已經在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/302.wav", + "text": "我們今天該質詢的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/303.wav", + "text": "是總統和院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/304.wav", + "text": "因為我一直說這個層級其實是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/305.wav", + "text": "健康投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/306.wav", + "text": "在之前大概只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/307.wav", + "text": "所謂的醫療支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/308.wav", + "text": "但是因為去年薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/309.wav", + "text": "悄悄的把它調到7.5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/310.wav", + "text": "那沒關係他說是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/311.wav", + "text": "把長照放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/312.wav", + "text": "但是我在質詢的時候也有告訴他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/313.wav", + "text": "當你算6.1%的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/314.wav", + "text": "其實韓國是8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/315.wav", + "text": "贏我們你要算7.5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/316.wav", + "text": "韓國是9.7%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/317.wav", + "text": "再怎麼樣在OECD國家中都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/318.wav", + "text": "就是投資不足投資不足我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/319.wav", + "text": "的投資裡只有50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/320.wav", + "text": "出頭是放在健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/321.wav", + "text": "3.5%左右是放在健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/322.wav", + "text": "而健保是百分之百的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/323.wav", + "text": "民眾都被涵蓋到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/324.wav", + "text": "只要不連手續費大家都被涵蓋到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/325.wav", + "text": "了所以老實說3.5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/326.wav", + "text": "涵蓋100%的國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/327.wav", + "text": "這本身是奇蹟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/328.wav", + "text": "是臺灣創造的奇蹟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/329.wav", + "text": "包山包海的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/330.wav", + "text": "咳嗽流鼻水到重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/331.wav", + "text": "疾病罕見疾病致死性疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/332.wav", + "text": "當這件事加進來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/333.wav", + "text": "就變成奇蹟就變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/334.wav", + "text": "提供者他們很努力去撐住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/335.wav", + "text": "當時我們還覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/336.wav", + "text": "我們的醫療是全世界最好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/337.wav", + "text": "但是誠如蘇清泉委員剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/338.wav", + "text": "我們現在是每況愈下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/339.wav", + "text": "什麼都輸還在末段班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/340.wav", + "text": "包括癌症死亡率韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/341.wav", + "text": "5年存活率是70%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/342.wav", + "text": "我們只剩60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/343.wav", + "text": "所以臺灣人不要再罵韓國了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/344.wav", + "text": "健康指標都輸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/345.wav", + "text": "還有什麼好說的新生兒死亡率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/346.wav", + "text": "也是最高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/347.wav", + "text": "現在不是只有這個錢是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/348.wav", + "text": "我們什麼很高很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/349.wav", + "text": "在什麼地方很高很高因為民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/350.wav", + "text": "在知識不對等的情況下還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/351.wav", + "text": "看病很方便的滿意度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/352.wav", + "text": "你如果問醫療人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/353.wav", + "text": "的滿意度就是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/354.wav", + "text": "所以早期我說血汗跟奇蹟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/355.wav", + "text": "現在我還是要用兩句話告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/356.wav", + "text": "現在小病保得滿好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/357.wav", + "text": "大病有缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/358.wav", + "text": "大病保得不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/359.wav", + "text": "這是健保的精神嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/360.wav", + "text": "這是社會健保的精神嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/361.wav", + "text": "這是我們要的健保嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/362.wav", + "text": "有問題了嘛為什麼會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/363.wav", + "text": "就是當初什麼病都涵括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/364.wav", + "text": "括什麼小病症的藥也都涵括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/365.wav", + "text": "現在進來的藥都是很昂貴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/366.wav", + "text": "因為醫學進步太快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/367.wav", + "text": "又要精準又要再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/368.wav", + "text": "當然現在還沒有納入給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/369.wav", + "text": "都很昂貴動不動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/370.wav", + "text": "一年就是上百萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/371.wav", + "text": "元你當然撐不住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/372.wav", + "text": "也沒有退場機制\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/373.wav", + "text": "我可能是目前唯一有提出附帶決議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/374.wav", + "text": "我知道光要求本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/375.wav", + "text": "是會有擔憂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/376.wav", + "text": "因為這會回到老路叫做論量計酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/377.wav", + "text": "0.70.80.9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/378.wav", + "text": "大家都在拚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/379.wav", + "text": "那到1點1元會不會衝點數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/380.wav", + "text": "絕對會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/381.wav", + "text": "絕對會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/382.wav", + "text": "給大家合理配套措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/383.wav", + "text": "這個措施也許要請健保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/384.wav", + "text": "衛福部來研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/385.wav", + "text": "但是最後一定要更高級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/386.wav", + "text": "行政院院長或是總統來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/387.wav", + "text": "嘛因為事實上整個投資是不夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/388.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛蘇委員也講到36%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/389.wav", + "text": "那天我講的時候薛部長不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/390.wav", + "text": "但是署長你一定懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/391.wav", + "text": "那個36%的計算方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/392.wav", + "text": "有人認為根本還不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/393.wav", + "text": "36%這個當然可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/394.wav", + "text": "也說照支出變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/395.wav", + "text": "還有我一直強調因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/396.wav", + "text": "雇主60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/397.wav", + "text": "當然我們可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/398.wav", + "text": "政府的部分36%還是不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/399.wav", + "text": "那不足是不是要補到足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/400.wav", + "text": "我們不反對這一次如果點值提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/401.wav", + "text": "民眾的保費也要調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/402.wav", + "text": "看用什麼方式調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/403.wav", + "text": "但是政府是不是已經付足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/404.wav", + "text": "法定的36%我們還是有疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/405.wav", + "text": "所以我後來提出了幾項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/406.wav", + "text": "\n我們看到的醫療品質問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/407.wav", + "text": "當然第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/408.wav", + "text": "專業服務費太低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/409.wav", + "text": "連洗頭還不如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/410.wav", + "text": "都輸給洗頭的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/411.wav", + "text": "的基本上專業服務費一直不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/412.wav", + "text": "正正當當好好看病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/413.wav", + "text": "好好正正當當賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/414.wav", + "text": "所以他必須想盡辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/415.wav", + "text": "你說自費也罷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/416.wav", + "text": "自費是近幾年才出現的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/417.wav", + "text": "以藥養醫也是事實啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/418.wav", + "text": "這不能否認的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/419.wav", + "text": "各醫院如果有盈餘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/420.wav", + "text": "要有一定的比例拿來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/421.wav", + "text": "職場環境的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/422.wav", + "text": "就是工作負荷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/423.wav", + "text": "這是第一個專業服務費要做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/424.wav", + "text": "然後是不是有一定的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/425.wav", + "text": "我們也跟企業界的要求一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/426.wav", + "text": "民眾黨也有提出相關的這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/427.wav", + "text": "我知道可能會讓很多基層的醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/428.wav", + "text": "會有一些擔憂但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/429.wav", + "text": "指示藥違法給付30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/430.wav", + "text": "其實大家都很自私" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/431.wav", + "text": "所以沒有人去按鈴申告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/432.wav", + "text": "按鈴申告的就是健保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/433.wav", + "text": "健保就是違法給付其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/434.wav", + "text": "實有人說指示藥才15到21億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/435.wav", + "text": "元陳委員你不要那麼計較不是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/436.wav", + "text": "就有可能民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/437.wav", + "text": "民眾看完病又要自己去買藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/438.wav", + "text": "處理了不要忘記還有一群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/439.wav", + "text": "分數也很高的專業人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/440.wav", + "text": "員守在社區藥局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/441.wav", + "text": "只要少1次少多少點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/442.wav", + "text": "375億點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/443.wav", + "text": "只要民眾少看一兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/444.wav", + "text": "所以指示藥真的早晚要退出市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/445.wav", + "text": "我還是必須為他們講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/446.wav", + "text": "很多人以為藥廠賺了很多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/447.wav", + "text": "我跟大家講在我的價值觀裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/448.wav", + "text": "每個行業都是對等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/449.wav", + "text": "今天要有醫師看病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/450.wav", + "text": "今天要有健保署來管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/451.wav", + "text": "可是也要有人做研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/452.wav", + "text": "每一個人的貢獻都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/453.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣努力來議價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/454.wav", + "text": "這是不爭的事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/455.wav", + "text": "來說我一個月前問薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/456.wav", + "text": "他說400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/457.wav", + "text": "元第二個月再問他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/458.wav", + "text": "才隔一個月他又說變500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/459.wav", + "text": "元署長你偷偷跟他咬耳朵說可能是500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/460.wav", + "text": "元可是我問到比500億元更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/461.wav", + "text": "曾經也衝過600億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/462.wav", + "text": "你還是要處理這件事嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/463.wav", + "text": "人家日本到最後就是處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/464.wav", + "text": "來一個猛降然後小降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/465.wav", + "text": "你要有一個合理的藥價差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/466.wav", + "text": "因為議價能力沒有大醫院高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/467.wav", + "text": "又都不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/468.wav", + "text": "這次就勇敢的處理吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/469.wav", + "text": "已經打破八年魔咒可以繼續執政了對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/470.wav", + "text": "做得好還是有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/471.wav", + "text": "想請署長研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/472.wav", + "text": "我也必須承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/473.wav", + "text": "你這樣走一定是衝破了頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/474.wav", + "text": "就會衝破嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/475.wav", + "text": "不過我先告訴大家現在全世界幾乎沒有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/476.wav", + "text": "只剩臺灣做總額制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/477.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得你們要引進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/478.wav", + "text": "把論質用品質的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/479.wav", + "text": "中我們不是只有拼這個能夠熬得過啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/480.wav", + "text": "我們的醫療指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/481.wav", + "text": "不用翻回來嗎不用逆轉嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/482.wav", + "text": "我們真的要繼續輸很多國家嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/483.wav", + "text": "要繼續躲在末段班嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/484.wav", + "text": "曾經是臺灣最引以為豪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/485.wav", + "text": "世界前幾名名列前茅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/486.wav", + "text": "醫療品質現在已經都不是了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/487.wav", + "text": "不要再講了因為數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/488.wav", + "text": "攤出來大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/489.wav", + "text": "所以我希望論質計酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/490.wav", + "text": "的部分包括早期推動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/491.wav", + "text": "bundledpayment署長你也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/492.wav", + "text": "我們過去也溝通過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/493.wav", + "text": "你是不是說如果沒有辦法大動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/494.wav", + "text": "作你其實要有一些東西進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/495.wav", + "text": "證明臺灣的醫療品質是OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/496.wav", + "text": "現在不是只有量就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/497.wav", + "text": "所以是不是也要鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/498.wav", + "text": "各醫院還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/499.wav", + "text": "來做各醫院提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/500.wav", + "text": "我有辦法提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/501.wav", + "text": "供的品質是這樣的以論質計酬的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/502.wav", + "text": "來給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/503.wav", + "text": "\n前次我們討論再生醫療的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/504.wav", + "text": "部長說有困難公布結果有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/505.wav", + "text": "可是我覺得如果我們永遠不把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/506.wav", + "text": "治療結果照顧病人品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/507.wav", + "text": "公布上網讓民眾選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/508.wav", + "text": "他們永遠就覺得越大的醫院就越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/509.wav", + "text": "但這不是我們要的這種分級醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/510.wav", + "text": "不是我們要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/511.wav", + "text": "我要作結語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/512.wav", + "text": "了分級醫療真的大崩壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/513.wav", + "text": "據我知道的數字所及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/514.wav", + "text": "健保開辦的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/515.wav", + "text": "醫學中心12家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/516.wav", + "text": "區域醫院大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/517.wav", + "text": "地區醫院六百零多家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/518.wav", + "text": "但是25年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/519.wav", + "text": "醫學中心就有二十幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/520.wav", + "text": "還有違規多跑了幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/521.wav", + "text": "區域醫院七八十家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/522.wav", + "text": "地區醫院剩三十幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/523.wav", + "text": "大家也都覺得大醫院放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/524.wav", + "text": "逛百貨公司也是逛大的百貨公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/525.wav", + "text": "去醫院也是逛大醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/526.wav", + "text": "分級醫療根本就是全面放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/527.wav", + "text": "嘛\n還有請把醫療分級的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/528.wav", + "text": "納入社區藥局好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/529.wav", + "text": "他們在醫療機構是屬於醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/530.wav", + "text": "重新分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/531.wav", + "text": "時也要把社區藥局納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/532.wav", + "text": "嘛他們也有能力照顧病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/533.wav", + "text": "擔任20年以上的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/534.wav", + "text": "我當主席超過5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/535.wav", + "text": "所有食藥署的配套都已經做得很完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/536.wav", + "text": "所以要勇敢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/537.wav", + "text": "把這一條指示藥不給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/538.wav", + "text": "全部回歸法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/539.wav", + "text": "\n以上這幾點附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/540.wav", + "text": "藥價差的部分指示藥的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/541.wav", + "text": "專業服務費的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/542.wav", + "text": "盈餘拿來改善薪酬的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/543.wav", + "text": "加上鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/544.wav", + "text": "論質計酬的支付方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/545.wav", + "text": "署長可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/546.wav", + "text": "雖然部長不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/547.wav", + "text": "但是我知道署長跟次長都留任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/548.wav", + "text": "也恭喜你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/549.wav", + "text": "大家也繼續期許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/550.wav", + "text": "\n主席今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/551.wav", + "text": "我們應該把總統找來才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/552.wav", + "text": "因為這個問題真的很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/553.wav", + "text": "現在朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/554.wav", + "text": "希望總統可以到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/555.wav", + "text": "院會做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/556.wav", + "text": "而且統問統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/557.wav", + "text": "如果可以的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/558.wav", + "text": "總統真的應該要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/559.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席給我這麼多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/560.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/561.wav", + "text": "充分表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/562.wav", + "text": "接下來請王正旭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/563.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/564.wav", + "text": "現場還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/565.wav", + "text": "二位委員包括秀芳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/566.wav", + "text": "昭姿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/567.wav", + "text": "蘇清泉委員一直要我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/568.wav", + "text": "表達我的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/569.wav", + "text": "還有衛福部的官員們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/570.wav", + "text": "\n我想這真的是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/571.wav", + "text": "非常重大的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/572.wav", + "text": "大家都可以確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/573.wav", + "text": "我很高興有機會到國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/574.wav", + "text": "身為醫界的一份子我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/575.wav", + "text": "在上任前就去請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/576.wav", + "text": "署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/577.wav", + "text": "看待健保這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/578.wav", + "text": "每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/579.wav", + "text": "前任的部長跟署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/580.wav", + "text": "一定要改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/581.wav", + "text": "��於如何改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/582.wav", + "text": "大家一定要有好的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/583.wav", + "text": "來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/584.wav", + "text": "他們給我共同的鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/585.wav", + "text": "可能的方式作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/586.wav", + "text": "當然醫界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/587.wav", + "text": "非常非常期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/588.wav", + "text": "因為醫界真的非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/589.wav", + "text": "委屈我們也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/590.wav", + "text": "自從召委提出這個議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/591.wav", + "text": "以後最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/592.wav", + "text": "我們也召開了公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/593.wav", + "text": "有一個很大型的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/594.wav", + "text": "都一直在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/595.wav", + "text": "我們要怎麼改才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/596.wav", + "text": "適當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/597.wav", + "text": "新內閣很快就會在520" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/598.wav", + "text": "成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/599.wav", + "text": "就會面臨這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/600.wav", + "text": "籌設越多越好我都非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/601.wav", + "text": "同意也非常贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/602.wav", + "text": "將來也希望不同的黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/603.wav", + "text": "資源的挹注大家共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/604.wav", + "text": "來努力來促成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/605.wav", + "text": "\n對於健保資源怎麼樣能夠投入到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/606.wav", + "text": "打造健康臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/607.wav", + "text": "照顧民眾的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/608.wav", + "text": "這是非常非常重大的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/609.wav", + "text": "如果可以的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/610.wav", + "text": "衛福部長在面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/611.wav", + "text": "這些問題的時候有一個更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/612.wav", + "text": "全盤的處理也能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/613.wav", + "text": "來敦促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/614.wav", + "text": "甚至要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/615.wav", + "text": "他們做什麼樣的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/616.wav", + "text": "如何回應民眾需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/617.wav", + "text": "的同時針對醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/618.wav", + "text": "藥師們護理師們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/619.wav", + "text": "各個職類們所面臨的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/620.wav", + "text": "一起努力來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/621.wav", + "text": "才能夠讓民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/622.wav", + "text": "健康得到更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/623.wav", + "text": "保護的同時對醫界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/624.wav", + "text": "才是公平的所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/625.wav", + "text": "醫界是包括各個職類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/626.wav", + "text": "所有從業人員\n我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/627.wav", + "text": "也知道包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/628.wav", + "text": "臺大醫院院長他每一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/629.wav", + "text": "談到醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/630.wav", + "text": "困境的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/631.wav", + "text": "醫療機構面臨這麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/632.wav", + "text": "大的困難怎麼樣去改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/633.wav", + "text": "服務的同時可以讓民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/634.wav", + "text": "看得好這就是品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/635.wav", + "text": "的問題剛剛昭姿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/636.wav", + "text": "委員也非常強烈的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/637.wav", + "text": "品質如何能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/638.wav", + "text": "變成我們在做健康照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/639.wav", + "text": "裡很重要的一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/640.wav", + "text": "我們需要有社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/641.wav", + "text": "不管是專家不管是學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/642.wav", + "text": "不管是業者包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/643.wav", + "text": "醫師團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/644.wav", + "text": "能夠聽到民眾的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/645.wav", + "text": "訴求其實真的非常非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/646.wav", + "text": "簡單就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/647.wav", + "text": "你把我的健康照顧好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/648.wav", + "text": "就可以了我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/649.wav", + "text": "也知道要照顧他的健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/650.wav", + "text": "需要各方面的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/651.wav", + "text": "這個資源如何能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/652.wav", + "text": "透過大家的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/653.wav", + "text": "一起來籌措" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/654.wav", + "text": "這個困難度非常非常的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/655.wav", + "text": "可是有困難並不代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/656.wav", + "text": "就沒有辦法解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/657.wav", + "text": "我們要找到好的路徑來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/658.wav", + "text": "解決才能夠真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/659.wav", + "text": "達到這樣的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/660.wav", + "text": "如果我們用的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/661.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/662.wav", + "text": "真的可以很順利達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/663.wav", + "text": "會不會是另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/664.wav", + "text": "一些困難的開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/665.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛蘇清泉委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/666.wav", + "text": "真的非常不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/667.wav", + "text": "這是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/668.wav", + "text": "醫療進步的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/669.wav", + "text": "我們把它統稱為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/670.wav", + "text": "財務毒性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/671.wav", + "text": "財務毒性的意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/672.wav", + "text": "當一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/673.wav", + "text": "癌症病人需要接受醫療的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/674.wav", + "text": "他會面臨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/675.wav", + "text": "各方面的挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/676.wav", + "text": "跟困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/677.wav", + "text": "的開發非常快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/678.wav", + "text": "以前不敢想像的用藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/679.wav", + "text": "可是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/680.wav", + "text": "癌症毒性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/681.wav", + "text": "非常昂貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/682.wav", + "text": "導致在使用上有一些困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/683.wav", + "text": "這在美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/684.wav", + "text": "在世界各國都有同樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/685.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/686.wav", + "text": "我當初在擔任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/687.wav", + "text": "社會團體負責人的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/688.wav", + "text": "這樣的一些訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/689.wav", + "text": "來了解健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/690.wav", + "text": "如何能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/691.wav", + "text": "如何引進社會其他資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/692.wav", + "text": "照顧癌症的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/693.wav", + "text": "當他有醫療需求的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/694.wav", + "text": "應該都可以透過國家的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/695.wav", + "text": "共同來保護他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/696.wav", + "text": "這樣的保護力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/697.wav", + "text": "怎樣才能夠得到最好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/698.wav", + "text": "這就是我們今天希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/699.wav", + "text": "透過更好的方式來解決\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/700.wav", + "text": "這個議題是那麼樣的重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/701.wav", + "text": "牽扯到那麼多單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/702.wav", + "text": "意思就是我們必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/703.wav", + "text": "要有更周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/704.wav", + "text": "更完整的處理以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/705.wav", + "text": "才知道未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/706.wav", + "text": "如果要面對更多的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/707.wav", + "text": "如何來面對這樣的挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/708.wav", + "text": "所以我們很期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/709.wav", + "text": "能夠讓新任的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/710.wav", + "text": "新任的院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/711.wav", + "text": "更好的面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/712.wav", + "text": "這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/713.wav", + "text": "包括讓各界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/714.wav", + "text": "都能夠提供更多意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/715.wav", + "text": "沒有經過大家共同的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/716.wav", + "text": "帶來的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/717.wav", + "text": "不過我非常的贊同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/718.wav", + "text": "趕快讓醫界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/719.wav", + "text": "能安下心來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/720.wav", + "text": "讓他們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/721.wav", + "text": "未來的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/722.wav", + "text": "未來的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/723.wav", + "text": "如何能夠讓他們在第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/724.wav", + "text": "針對他們所需要的醫療資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/725.wav", + "text": "讓他們安心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/726.wav", + "text": "繼續提供醫療服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/727.wav", + "text": "這些擔任院長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/728.wav", + "text": "能夠繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/729.wav", + "text": "面對困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/730.wav", + "text": "繼續面對挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/731.wav", + "text": "讓他們安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/732.wav", + "text": "讓他們了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/733.wav", + "text": "真的是很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/734.wav", + "text": "很有誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/735.wav", + "text": "以上是我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/736.wav", + "text": "謝謝謝謝王正旭委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/737.wav", + "text": "接下來請陳菁徽委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/738.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/739.wav", + "text": "大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/740.wav", + "text": "我也認同剛剛陳昭姿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/741.wav", + "text": "王正旭委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/742.wav", + "text": "這件事情已經過了多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/743.wav", + "text": "我現在跟王正旭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/744.wav", + "text": "補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/745.wav", + "text": "20152016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/746.wav", + "text": "蔡英文總統在競選的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/747.wav", + "text": "直接跳票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/748.wav", + "text": "我們要讓醫療服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/749.wav", + "text": "的價格合理化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/750.wav", + "text": "我知道長年以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/751.wav", + "text": "為了不讓健保倒下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/752.wav", + "text": "健保給付給各位的點值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/753.wav", + "text": "一直在打折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/754.wav", + "text": "我們感謝醫師護理師們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/755.wav", + "text": "為守護國人健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/756.wav", + "text": "所付出的犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/757.wav", + "text": "未來我們也願意來檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/758.wav", + "text": "健保支付標準表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/759.wav", + "text": "同時不會只顧及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/760.wav", + "text": "支出面的控制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/761.wav", + "text": "也會重視醫療需求面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/762.wav", + "text": "的問題我把原文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/763.wav", + "text": "再唸一次讓大家回憶一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/764.wav", + "text": "89年前他的競選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/765.wav", + "text": "政見結果現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/766.wav", + "text": "大家不滿的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/767.wav", + "text": "是8年來不但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/768.wav", + "text": "沒有改革而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/769.wav", + "text": "點值是越來越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/770.wav", + "text": "低這已經是攸關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/771.wav", + "text": "他們生存的問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/772.wav", + "text": "當你們在這邊討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/773.wav", + "text": "我們要提出什麼相關的配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/774.wav", + "text": "這是一個茲事體大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/775.wav", + "text": "問題我們的護理人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/776.wav", + "text": "正在不斷地流失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/777.wav", + "text": "我們國人的健康正在不斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/778.wav", + "text": "地受損\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/779.wav", + "text": "醫護人員醫界的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/780.wav", + "text": "不是拿來讓你們開支票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/781.wav", + "text": "的因為前後任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/782.wav", + "text": "的總統一再地開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/783.wav", + "text": "健保點值的支票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/784.wav", + "text": "而且我們提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/785.wav", + "text": "的就是賴準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/786.wav", + "text": "總統講的1." + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/787.wav", + "text": "1元還比我們國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/788.wav", + "text": "講的多了0.1元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/789.wav", + "text": "請問困難點到底在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/790.wav", + "text": "這就是賴準總統的政見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/791.wav", + "text": "這是他跟他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/792.wav", + "text": "健保改革全國專家會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/793.wav", + "text": "召開之後提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/794.wav", + "text": "的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/795.wav", + "text": "三位總統候選人提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/796.wav", + "text": "之後薛部長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/797.wav", + "text": "OK我們可以提出這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/798.wav", + "text": "但是要經過修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/799.wav", + "text": "好我們現在也要修法了不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/800.wav", + "text": "就是這樣做我們也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/801.wav", + "text": "遵照薛部長所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/802.wav", + "text": "出來的他認為解方要透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/803.wav", + "text": "修法我們現在不就是在修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/804.wav", + "text": "法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/805.wav", + "text": "所以我想要知道其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/806.wav", + "text": "現在非常多醫護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/807.wav", + "text": "人員正在看我們的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/808.wav", + "text": "頻道想要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/809.wav", + "text": "這8年來到底我們可以改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/810.wav", + "text": "什麼而不是現在又繼續8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/811.wav", + "text": "上次薛部長有講到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/812.wav", + "text": "他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/813.wav", + "text": "覺得他這樣子揣摩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/814.wav", + "text": "他認為賴準總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/815.wav", + "text": "的意思是4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/816.wav", + "text": "內可以達到1點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/817.wav", + "text": "1元我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/818.wav", + "text": "全國所有的醫事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/819.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法等這個4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/820.wav", + "text": "我看了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/821.wav", + "text": "你知道2月我透過全國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/822.wav", + "text": "健保資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/823.wav", + "text": "點值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/824.wav", + "text": "低於50" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/825.wav", + "text": "低於不知道多少錢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/826.wav", + "text": "低於幾十萬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/827.wav", + "text": "20萬50萬的就占了七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/828.wav", + "text": "八成以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/829.wav", + "text": "裡面有藥師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/830.wav", + "text": "有護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/831.wav", + "text": "有行政人員有醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/832.wav", + "text": "你覺得到底誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/833.wav", + "text": "還可以在這樣的狀態之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/834.wav", + "text": "經營下去呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/835.wav", + "text": "然後護理師部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/836.wav", + "text": "的護理師都已經快要撐不下去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/837.wav", + "text": "因為你又要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/838.wav", + "text": "護病比然後又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/839.wav", + "text": "要幾個人然後他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/840.wav", + "text": "的離職率這麼高所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/841.wav", + "text": "班都排不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/842.wav", + "text": "科別傾斜這麼嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/843.wav", + "text": "\n這個禮拜有一個大新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/844.wav", + "text": "大家都沒有看到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/845.wav", + "text": "一個懷孕的女醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/846.wav", + "text": "因為班排不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/847.wav", + "text": "他在有游離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/848.wav", + "text": "輻射的狀態之下值了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/849.wav", + "text": "32小時的班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/850.wav", + "text": "過去20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/851.wav", + "text": "我坦白說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/852.wav", + "text": "我也是不忍心我的同事值太多班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/853.wav", + "text": "所以我破水的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/854.wav", + "text": "人就在開刀房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/855.wav", + "text": "我懷孕的時候也都在值班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/856.wav", + "text": "沒有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/857.wav", + "text": "我同一屆只有兩個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/858.wav", + "text": "你覺得我不值班難道要他值30天的班嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/859.wav", + "text": "要我同屆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/860.wav", + "text": "這個同事值30天的班嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/861.wav", + "text": "\n所以現在我們科別的傾斜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/862.wav", + "text": "已經非常的嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/863.wav", + "text": "許多科別根本沒人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/864.wav", + "text": "嘛兒科你也知道沒人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/865.wav", + "text": "這一切一切的源頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/866.wav", + "text": "還不就是健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/867.wav", + "text": "已經大崩壞了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/868.wav", + "text": "所以不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/869.wav", + "text": "都告訴我現在連放射師都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/870.wav", + "text": "沒有人幫忙照片子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/871.wav", + "text": "請問放射科醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/872.wav", + "text": "要怎麼執行他的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/873.wav", + "text": "\n藥師也沒有檢驗科也離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/874.wav", + "text": "護理師也離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/875.wav", + "text": "你覺得光有醫師能幹嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/876.wav", + "text": "結果現在就是醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/877.wav", + "text": "還在幫忙你們講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/878.wav", + "text": "王正旭委員還在幫你們講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/879.wav", + "text": "喔你也知道吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/880.wav", + "text": "放射師沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/881.wav", + "text": "檢驗科也離職了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/882.wav", + "text": "這個你都清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/883.wav", + "text": "所以如果你覺得你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/884.wav", + "text": "4年本來就可以達成的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/885.wav", + "text": "為什麼不馬上就做到呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/886.wav", + "text": "我們不是應該要趕快做到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/887.wav", + "text": "所以我還是非常的希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/888.wav", + "text": "大家可以馬上為我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/889.wav", + "text": "醫療環境注入一針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/890.wav", + "text": "強心針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/891.wav", + "text": "給予實質的幫助才是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/892.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/893.wav", + "text": "員很用力的為醫事人員發聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/894.wav", + "text": "接下來王正旭委員要補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/895.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席讓我有第二次發言的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/896.wav", + "text": "謝謝菁徽醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/897.wav", + "text": "菁徽委員的指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/898.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/899.wav", + "text": "我們都不會去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/900.wav", + "text": "說我們的醫師有多辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/901.wav", + "text": "我們的護理人員有多辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/902.wav", + "text": "我們都不會我們都瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/903.wav", + "text": "因為我們都來自醫療體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/904.wav", + "text": "這是一定的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/905.wav", + "text": "所以請你不要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/906.wav", + "text": "我好像沒有辦法認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/907.wav", + "text": "同仁的這種付出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/908.wav", + "text": "本身有哪一些的保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/909.wav", + "text": "一點保留都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/910.wav", + "text": "因為我也是曾經這樣付出的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/911.wav", + "text": "我現在還是一樣這樣的付出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/912.wav", + "text": "我相信大家都是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/913.wav", + "text": "只是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/914.wav", + "text": "我們在這個付出的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/915.wav", + "text": "如何能夠讓我們的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/916.wav", + "text": "可以得到更好的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/917.wav", + "text": "\n所以我剛剛也麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/918.wav", + "text": "當新的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/919.wav", + "text": "新的院長就任以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/920.wav", + "text": "他們能不能趕快在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/921.wav", + "text": "第一時間就能夠去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/922.wav", + "text": "讓這樣的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/923.wav", + "text": "這樣的幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/924.wav", + "text": "能夠來促成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/925.wav", + "text": "當然我們也知道修法非常非常的重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/926.wav", + "text": "很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/927.wav", + "text": "可是就時效上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/928.wav", + "text": "也許反而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/929.wav", + "text": "並沒有辦法達到我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/930.wav", + "text": "在第一時間就得到的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/931.wav", + "text": "這是我需要再跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/932.wav", + "text": "報告的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/933.wav", + "text": "我相信大家都在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/934.wav", + "text": "政府怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/935.wav", + "text": "大家也都希望趕快把問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/936.wav", + "text": "那解決的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/937.wav", + "text": "如何能夠讓大家都非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/938.wav", + "text": "滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/939.wav", + "text": "同時都能夠讓社會也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/940.wav", + "text": "我們為什麼要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/941.wav", + "text": "這是需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/942.wav", + "text": "大家一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/943.wav", + "text": "一起來讓社會也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/944.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/945.wav", + "text": "所以請大家也要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/946.wav", + "text": "我身為醫界的一員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/947.wav", + "text": "支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/948.wav", + "text": "我們整個醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/949.wav", + "text": "同仁的付出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/950.wav", + "text": "是需要透過政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/951.wav", + "text": "透過大家一起來努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/952.wav", + "text": "而且時間上越快越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/953.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/954.wav", + "text": "謝謝王正旭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/955.wav", + "text": "那我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/956.wav", + "text": "剛剛大家都有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/957.wav", + "text": "新政府上任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/958.wav", + "text": "讓新的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/959.wav", + "text": "新的院長在這件事情上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/960.wav", + "text": "他必須要有一個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/961.wav", + "text": "而且也要拿出方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/962.wav", + "text": "這一點上我是認同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/963.wav", + "text": "所以如果是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/964.wav", + "text": "這樣的情況底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/965.wav", + "text": "必須要一個期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/966.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/967.wav", + "text": "總是要有一個期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/968.wav", + "text": "坦白講這個案子已經送出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/969.wav", + "text": "當時其實不分朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/970.wav", + "text": "大家沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/971.wav", + "text": "就是送出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/972.wav", + "text": "喔送出委員會現在是在朝野協商階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/973.wav", + "text": "大家要看的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/974.wav", + "text": "到底這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/975.wav", + "text": "由國民黨立院黨團提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/976.wav", + "text": "蘇委員提出我提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/977.wav", + "text": "我們這麼多委員的支持底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/978.wav", + "text": "送出了委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/979.wav", + "text": "那我們要的是衛福部的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/980.wav", + "text": "讓醫界第一線人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/981.wav", + "text": "可以得到一個合理的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/982.wav", + "text": "方案不能是原地踏步\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/983.wav", + "text": "大家都同意現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/984.wav", + "text": "是不行的大家都不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/985.wav", + "text": "我想連民進黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/986.wav", + "text": "也都不認同現行的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/987.wav", + "text": "所以非改革不可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/988.wav", + "text": "而且一定要有具體的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/989.wav", + "text": "出來我想這是最重要的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/990.wav", + "text": "包括黃秀芳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/991.wav", + "text": "召委也排了公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/992.wav", + "text": "公聽會裡面大家最有共識的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/993.wav", + "text": "政府投資不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/994.wav", + "text": "你政府的方案總得要拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/995.wav", + "text": "一下子就恐嚇大家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/996.wav", + "text": "如果這一動那健保一定調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/997.wav", + "text": "這不能立刻劃上等號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/998.wav", + "text": "就是你在既有的財政狀況下你要怎麼去調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/999.wav", + "text": "包括賴總統自己也講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1000.wav", + "text": "他最有能力解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1001.wav", + "text": "既然他已經承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1002.wav", + "text": "而且他當時提到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1003.wav", + "text": "不曉得是1.1還是1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1004.wav", + "text": "現在不太知道他真正的語意是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1005.wav", + "text": "但是顯然他所提的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1006.wav", + "text": "也顯示他對現狀的不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1007.wav", + "text": "因為現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1008.wav", + "text": "點值絕對沒有到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1009.wav", + "text": "所以在這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1010.wav", + "text": "底下我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1011.wav", + "text": "剛剛民進黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1012.wav", + "text": "提出來說要等新的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1013.wav", + "text": "新的院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1014.wav", + "text": "當然可以等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1015.wav", + "text": "但是不能等太久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1016.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1017.wav", + "text": "那是不是在一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1018.wav", + "text": "之內你們就應該要把這個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1019.wav", + "text": "丟出來因為這個議題坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1020.wav", + "text": "也討論了很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1021.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1022.wav", + "text": "一個月之後就應該要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1023.wav", + "text": "可以再開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1024.wav", + "text": "也可以等你們的新部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1025.wav", + "text": "但重點是要有方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1026.wav", + "text": "若是沒有方案我們就直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1027.wav", + "text": "院會表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1028.wav", + "text": "一個月過後就直接院會表決通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1029.wav", + "text": "所以衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1030.wav", + "text": "你們的具體方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1031.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1032.wav", + "text": "我覺得一定要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1033.wav", + "text": "要不然剛剛大家講了那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1034.wav", + "text": "我想我們委員會要有所作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1035.wav", + "text": "也不能就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1036.wav", + "text": "什麼都不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1037.wav", + "text": "黃委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1038.wav", + "text": "新任的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1039.wav", + "text": "他527要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1040.wav", + "text": "他要帶隊去是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1041.wav", + "text": "24號就出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1042.wav", + "text": "新任部長24號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1043.wav", + "text": "出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1044.wav", + "text": "回來就6月1號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1045.wav", + "text": "6月底怎麼是一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1046.wav", + "text": "你的數學不太好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1047.wav", + "text": "不是啦他現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1048.wav", + "text": "我跟你說部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1049.wav", + "text": "他現在會不知道有這個議題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1050.wav", + "text": "對啊他擔任過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1051.wav", + "text": "本委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1052.wav", + "text": "老早就都知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1053.wav", + "text": "這跟他出國沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1054.wav", + "text": "6月中啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1055.wav", + "text": "主席因為我個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1056.wav", + "text": "有提出一些附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1057.wav", + "text": "就算部長還沒有辦法到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1058.wav", + "text": "這些你們還是可以先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1059.wav", + "text": "可以先提出建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1060.wav", + "text": "0.951一定過關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1061.wav", + "text": "嘛就一定過關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1062.wav", + "text": "尤其剛剛我談的附帶決議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1063.wav", + "text": "所以你們先幫部長研擬好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1064.wav", + "text": "政策跟對策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1065.wav", + "text": "到時候就要用最快的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1066.wav", + "text": "去達成這個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1067.wav", + "text": "我想你們應該知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1068.wav", + "text": "已經沒有辦法擋了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1069.wav", + "text": "已經沒有辦法擋了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1070.wav", + "text": "但是我也體會說這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1071.wav", + "text": "一些平衡的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1072.wav", + "text": "那些平衡的作法我已經很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1073.wav", + "text": "就我參與29年的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1074.wav", + "text": "提出這些建議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1075.wav", + "text": "那你們一併來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1076.wav", + "text": "是一個平衡的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1077.wav", + "text": "配套先寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1078.wav", + "text": "先提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1079.wav", + "text": "我們來做你們的後盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1080.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1081.wav", + "text": "部長就得收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1082.wav", + "text": "賴總統也得收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1083.wav", + "text": "卓院長也得收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1084.wav", + "text": "反正你們也已經擋不住了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1085.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1086.wav", + "text": "我們國民黨還有民眾黨這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1087.wav", + "text": "是打算要排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1088.wav", + "text": "延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1089.wav", + "text": "延會就是要讓新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1090.wav", + "text": "行政院長來備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1091.wav", + "text": "我們要總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1092.wav", + "text": "我們每一個委員都再問一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1093.wav", + "text": "30分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1094.wav", + "text": "各個委員會一三四照開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1095.wav", + "text": "然後這樣搞可以搞到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1096.wav", + "text": "20號左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1097.wav", + "text": "我們不是加開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1098.wav", + "text": "院會開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1099.wav", + "text": "委員會有到7月中嗎沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1100.wav", + "text": "那是亂講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1101.wav", + "text": "最多也到6月下旬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1102.wav", + "text": "都已經結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1103.wav", + "text": "所以我建議還是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1104.wav", + "text": "6月中旬頂多到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1105.wav", + "text": "提的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1106.wav", + "text": "他不會放過你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1107.wav", + "text": "來次長是不是要回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1108.wav", + "text": "原先是希望有多一點的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1109.wav", + "text": "除了我們自己內部的這些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1110.wav", + "text": "我們原先是希望能夠有多一點的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1111.wav", + "text": "來跟行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1112.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣挹注更多的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1113.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會希望在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1114.wav", + "text": "時間上稍微有一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1115.wav", + "text": "空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1116.wav", + "text": "如果真的是沒辦法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1117.wav", + "text": "儘量在6月20日左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1118.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1119.wav", + "text": "剛剛陳昭姿委員講得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1120.wav", + "text": "是總統跟院長的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1121.wav", + "text": "也還不是你們的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1122.wav", + "text": "你懂我的意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1123.wav", + "text": "這件事情你們一定要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1124.wav", + "text": "新任的院長跟總統知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1125.wav", + "text": "委員會現在的狀態就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1126.wav", + "text": "這個案子已經是在協商期了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1127.wav", + "text": "沒有方案就是表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1128.wav", + "text": "看是過0.95" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1129.wav", + "text": "或是1而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1130.wav", + "text": "但是你們要趕快提一個對策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1131.wav", + "text": "就是行政院要有態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1132.wav", + "text": "卓榮泰跟賴清德關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1133.wav", + "text": "那麼好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1134.wav", + "text": "其實這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1135.wav", + "text": "我在兩個禮拜前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1136.wav", + "text": "我當面就跟他講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1137.wav", + "text": "已經通過要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1138.wav", + "text": "所以他其實應該知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1139.wav", + "text": "他現在應該知道這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1140.wav", + "text": "那院長的態度很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1141.wav", + "text": "不是靠你們去協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1142.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼和主計總處協商我都不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1143.wav", + "text": "院長一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1144.wav", + "text": "主計總處就買單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1145.wav", + "text": "這個就是可以非常快速處理的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1146.wav", + "text": "只要賴總統他的意志" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1147.wav", + "text": "他今天是賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1148.wav", + "text": "他想要幫醫界解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1149.wav", + "text": "他說他最有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1150.wav", + "text": "最有辦法就要展現一種效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1151.wav", + "text": "跟能力給國人看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1152.wav", + "text": "知道的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1153.wav", + "text": "現在只是錢要怎麼調的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1154.wav", + "text": "調到怎樣就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1155.wav", + "text": "讓醫界也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1156.wav", + "text": "這樣子的確有改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1157.wav", + "text": "我們讓這一些重症醫療的醫護人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1158.wav", + "text": "大家都願意在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1159.wav", + "text": "崗位上面繼續捍衛國人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1160.wav", + "text": "健康坦白講是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1161.wav", + "text": "不再是由下而上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1162.wav", + "text": "再繼續由下而上你拖一年也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1163.wav", + "text": "你也處理不來坦白講就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1164.wav", + "text": "我認為那就是考驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1165.wav", + "text": "我們的卓內閣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1166.wav", + "text": "健康臺灣健康論壇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1167.wav", + "text": "都開假的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1168.wav", + "text": "其實裡面已經有腹案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1169.wav", + "text": "已經有某種程度的腹案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1170.wav", + "text": "現在是要做到哪裡的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1171.wav", + "text": "所以這件事情我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1172.wav", + "text": "不用再拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1173.wav", + "text": "懸著到底要改不要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1174.wav", + "text": "還是可以怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1175.wav", + "text": "那就展現新內閣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1176.wav", + "text": "的決斷力跟魄力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1177.wav", + "text": "這種事情就是這麼簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1178.wav", + "text": "這也不用拖那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1179.wav", + "text": "那就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1180.wav", + "text": "我們6月17日那一週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1181.wav", + "text": "會再開一次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1182.wav", + "text": "那次協商就要見真章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1183.wav", + "text": "了如果讓大家不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1184.wav", + "text": "那就是院會直接表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1185.wav", + "text": "因為1個月過了也可以處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1186.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1187.wav", + "text": "自己要把工作完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1188.wav", + "text": "反正我那一週就會排協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1189.wav", + "text": "在6月17日那一週排協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1190.wav", + "text": "趕快告訴新的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1191.wav", + "text": "WHA" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1192.wav", + "text": "在那邊也可以處理臺灣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1193.wav", + "text": "沒有忙碌到這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1194.wav", + "text": "因為我們大會根本進不去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1195.wav", + "text": "都是周邊的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1196.wav", + "text": "啦\n所以這件重中之重的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1197.wav", + "text": "他自己應該列為最優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1198.wav", + "text": "\n好所以如果是這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1199.wav", + "text": "那就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1200.wav", + "text": "請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1201.wav", + "text": "回去必須針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1202.wav", + "text": "具體改革的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1203.wav", + "text": "就要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1204.wav", + "text": "因為現在已經是朝野協商階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1205.wav", + "text": "那我們預定就是6月17日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1206.wav", + "text": "當週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1207.wav", + "text": "就會再召開一次朝野協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1208.wav", + "text": "也是最後一次6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1209.wav", + "text": "6月17日再召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1210.wav", + "text": "該溝通的該處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1211.wav", + "text": "我們希望衛福部把這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1212.wav", + "text": "列為重要事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1213.wav", + "text": "該跟醫界溝通的也在這段期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1214.wav", + "text": "把握時間跟大家去做溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1215.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1216.wav", + "text": "目的是要讓我們的醫護人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1217.wav", + "text": "有更好的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1218.wav", + "text": "不用那麼血汗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1219.wav", + "text": "然後讓我們的健保真正可長可久好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1220.wav", + "text": "是健康的狀況可長可久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1221.wav", + "text": "\n請問各位委員跟官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1222.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他意見要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1223.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1224.wav", + "text": "協商會議到此結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15913/1225.wav", + "text": "我們散會謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/0.wav", + "text": "各位列席的官員還有各位黨團幹部各位工作夥伴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1.wav", + "text": "\n今天最主要有3個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2.wav", + "text": "第一案第二案我們可以考慮���案討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3.wav", + "text": "第一案就是國民黨黨團建請院會作成決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/4.wav", + "text": "對於新任行政院長施政方針報告前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/5.wav", + "text": "邀請賴清德總統至立法院進行國情報告請公決案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/6.wav", + "text": "這是第一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/7.wav", + "text": "第二案台灣民眾黨黨團提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/8.wav", + "text": "建請院會作成決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/9.wav", + "text": "對於新任行政院長施政方針報告前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/10.wav", + "text": "邀請賴清德總統至立法院進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/11.wav", + "text": "並依法回應立法委員提出之問題請公決案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/12.wav", + "text": "這2個案建議黨團幹部可以併案討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/13.wav", + "text": "第三案就是繼續研商環島高速鐵路建設特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/14.wav", + "text": "以及花東快速公路建設特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/15.wav", + "text": "2案由國民黨黨團提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/16.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們針對第一案第二案總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/17.wav", + "text": "各黨團共同的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/18.wav", + "text": "請國民黨團傅崐萁總召說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/19.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長各黨黨鞭柯總召還有黃總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/20.wav", + "text": "從過去臺灣中華民國民主憲政發展以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/21.wav", + "text": "總統都有到國民大會做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/22.wav", + "text": "讓國家發展的方向能夠更加地清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/23.wav", + "text": "而這些具有民意的各黨籍國大代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/24.wav", + "text": "都能夠確實地反映基層的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/25.wav", + "text": "能夠讓總統聽到來自各個不同面向的希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/26.wav", + "text": "以及對於基層的聲音能有基礎了解之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/27.wav", + "text": "能夠更加地多元能夠更加地順利執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/28.wav", + "text": "也讓朝野能夠一起把國家往前全面地推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/29.wav", + "text": "\n自從國民大會以及臺灣省議會正式併入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/30.wav", + "text": "單一國會立法院之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/31.wav", + "text": "過去原有這樣的一個憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/32.wav", + "text": "反而在民國87年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/33.wav", + "text": "把國民大會跟省議會併進來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/34.wav", + "text": "成為單一的民選的全國性的基層的代議士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/35.wav", + "text": "從立法院推動到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/36.wav", + "text": "還沒有總統正式來到立法院做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/37.wav", + "text": "並備詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/38.wav", + "text": "中國國民黨提出一個這樣的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/39.wav", + "text": "就是希望回復到過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/40.wav", + "text": "不只能夠把所有施政的面向讓全國國人瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/41.wav", + "text": "也能夠讓所有立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/42.wav", + "text": "針對總統所提出的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/43.wav", + "text": "有不懂的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/44.wav", + "text": "或者是有其他面向可以一起討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/45.wav", + "text": "並請總統能夠讓這些立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/46.wav", + "text": "有不清楚的地方更加地釐清說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/47.wav", + "text": "讓國家發展的方向能夠更加地明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/48.wav", + "text": "\n而在2024年新民意產生之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/49.wav", + "text": "即將在5月20號就職的賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/50.wav", + "text": "以及在今年2月1號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/51.wav", + "text": "已經全面改選的113席國會議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/52.wav", + "text": "在這一個新的時代裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/53.wav", + "text": "我們希望總統能夠到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/54.wav", + "text": "做好相關的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/55.wav", + "text": "並傾聽各個政黨及來自基層的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/56.wav", + "text": "讓國家未來的整體施政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/57.wav", + "text": "能夠更加地完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/58.wav", + "text": "也讓朝野能夠更加地圓融" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/59.wav", + "text": "我想這對我們的國家都是好的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/60.wav", + "text": "所以今天提起這樣的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/61.wav", + "text": "是否允當大家一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/62.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/63.wav", + "text": "謝謝國民黨團的傅崐萁總召的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/64.wav", + "text": "接下來請台灣民眾黨黨團黃國昌總召請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/65.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長以及各黨團的幹部代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/66.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團這一次所提出來的議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/67.wav", + "text": "是基於我們憲法增修條文第4條的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/68.wav", + "text": "邀請新當選的總統賴清德先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/69.wav", + "text": "能夠來立法院進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/70.wav", + "text": "到目前為止從我們修憲完到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/71.wav", + "text": "從來沒有總統到立法院來進行國情報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/72.wav", + "text": "\n因此誠如我們在上個禮拜五院會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/73.wav", + "text": "針對我們提案所提出的提案說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/74.wav", + "text": "認為這是一個建立良好的憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/75.wav", + "text": "以及典範的關鍵時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/76.wav", + "text": "因此我們依法提出了這樣的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/77.wav", + "text": "希望能夠邀請賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/78.wav", + "text": "在他就任以後到立法院來進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/79.wav", + "text": "至於賴總統在立法院進行國情報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/80.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼進行的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/81.wav", + "text": "我們基本的主張就是依照法律來予以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/82.wav", + "text": "那依照法律來處理就會牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/83.wav", + "text": "來的時間點��底是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/84.wav", + "text": "到底是依照新的立法院職權行使法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/85.wav", + "text": "還是按照目前既有的立法院職權行使法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/86.wav", + "text": "因為來的時間還不確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/87.wav", + "text": "所以現在也沒有辦法真的確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/88.wav", + "text": "當時所適用的法律到底會是什麼樣子的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/89.wav", + "text": "不過在上個禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/90.wav", + "text": "由院長所召集各個黨團的幹部交換意見的那一場會談當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/91.wav", + "text": "我們也拋磚引玉提出了幾種可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/92.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統是希望每一個委員講完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/93.wav", + "text": "他能夠有機會回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/94.wav", + "text": "還是一個黨團全部的委員都講完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/95.wav", + "text": "這個某個程度上我們都抱持開放的心態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/96.wav", + "text": "願意也聆聽賴清德總統當選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/97.wav", + "text": "到國會來進行國情報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/98.wav", + "text": "他所希望進行的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/99.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/100.wav", + "text": "接下來請柯建銘總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/101.wav", + "text": "院長各位列席出席的所有委員與官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/102.wav", + "text": "今天總統來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/103.wav", + "text": "我們要講的一件事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/104.wav", + "text": "這個在國會改選以後都變成一個假議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/105.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/106.wav", + "text": "他如果有軍購案要來立法院做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/107.wav", + "text": "國民黨就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/108.wav", + "text": "即問即答再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/109.wav", + "text": "即便馬英九2015去新加坡參加馬習會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/110.wav", + "text": "回來要到立法院做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/111.wav", + "text": "我說不可能你們馬習會立法院有人來幫你背書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/112.wav", + "text": "所以即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/113.wav", + "text": "所以這個永遠是一個政治攻防的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/114.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/115.wav", + "text": "因為這是憲法的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/116.wav", + "text": "憲法增修條文寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/117.wav", + "text": "得來做國情報告並不是應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/118.wav", + "text": "應所以剛才黃國昌委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/119.wav", + "text": "依當時的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/120.wav", + "text": "是說假如我們接下來馬上處理立法院職權行使法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/121.wav", + "text": "依當時的法律錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/122.wav", + "text": "這叫依憲法不是依法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/123.wav", + "text": "職權行使法假如修了但是違反憲法的話也是違憲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/124.wav", + "text": "所以是依憲不是依當時的法���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/125.wav", + "text": "\n至於上禮拜五的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/126.wav", + "text": "院長在院長室找大家來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/127.wav", + "text": "談有關於國情報告今天要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/128.wav", + "text": "還有兩個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/129.wav", + "text": "那時候是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/130.wav", + "text": "討論事項要處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/131.wav", + "text": "所以三黨黨鞭在中間都有一些對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/132.wav", + "text": "院長你也是在場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/133.wav", + "text": "很平實就是講說國情報告怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/134.wav", + "text": "他沒有提到很關鍵性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/135.wav", + "text": "不過他剛才也有談到就是過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/136.wav", + "text": "這種國情報告就是要質詢沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/137.wav", + "text": "不是質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/138.wav", + "text": "登輝總統國情報告以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/139.wav", + "text": "都是統一回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/140.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂質詢的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/141.wav", + "text": "\n我們現在要回到我們今天要談的核心問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/142.wav", + "text": "當然大家都要打開天窗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/143.wav", + "text": "我記得那時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/144.wav", + "text": "由國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/145.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷委員開始講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/146.wav", + "text": "聽起來好像沒有條件他們都OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/147.wav", + "text": "我說洪孟楷你能不能代表傅總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/148.wav", + "text": "傅總召就在旁邊嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/149.wav", + "text": "你們倆坐在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/150.wav", + "text": "請傅總召表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/151.wav", + "text": "在院會發言的時候也講得冠冕堂皇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/152.wav", + "text": "就是大概要展開憲政的新頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/153.wav", + "text": "有一個但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/154.wav", + "text": "要賴總統先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/155.wav", + "text": "行政院長是520以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/156.wav", + "text": "的兩個禮拜內要來立法院做施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/157.wav", + "text": "3天前要把書面報告拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/158.wav", + "text": "不過國民黨堅持是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/159.wav", + "text": "賴總統先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/160.wav", + "text": "這個爭點嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/161.wav", + "text": "至於黃國昌委員還講得剛才那樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/162.wav", + "text": "依當時的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/163.wav", + "text": "律你有把握5月17號或哪一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/164.wav", + "text": "因為520以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/165.wav", + "text": "行政院長就要來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/166.wav", + "text": "按照憲法他要來備詢啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/167.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜要來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/168.wav", + "text": "你總不能製造憲政衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/169.wav", + "text": "你能保證5月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/170.wav", + "text": "是可用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/171.wav", + "text": "但我還是堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/172.wav", + "text": "依憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/173.wav", + "text": "你也有講過嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/174.wav", + "text": "嘛依當時通過的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/175.wav", + "text": "假設你們517就要處理這些職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/176.wav", + "text": "那517能不能處理職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/177.wav", + "text": "處理到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/178.wav", + "text": "那是另外一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/179.wav", + "text": "職權行使法5月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/180.wav", + "text": "當然它有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/181.wav", + "text": "不是只有國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/182.wav", + "text": "罪調查權的問題等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/183.wav", + "text": "這是臺灣憲政史上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/184.wav", + "text": "一個最衝突的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/185.wav", + "text": "當然我們在這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/186.wav", + "text": "有一些評判以及說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/187.wav", + "text": "我們認為不應該毀憲亂政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/188.wav", + "text": "所以在這樣的情況底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/189.wav", + "text": "就是統問統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/190.wav", + "text": "什麼叫統問統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/191.wav", + "text": "聽不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/192.wav", + "text": "民進黨問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/193.wav", + "text": "國民黨問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/194.wav", + "text": "我假如有講錯你的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/195.wav", + "text": "修正沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/196.wav", + "text": "等民眾黨問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/197.wav", + "text": "你一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/198.wav", + "text": "賴總統回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/199.wav", + "text": "但職權行使法在這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/200.wav", + "text": "規定得很詳盡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/201.wav", + "text": "至於這個要多少人問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/202.wav", + "text": "程序委員會怎麼排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/203.wav", + "text": "問的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/204.wav", + "text": "每一黨占的比例是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/205.wav", + "text": "最後主動權是在賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/206.wav", + "text": "他得與否都是他決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/207.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/208.wav", + "text": "當然總統能夠來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/209.wav", + "text": "國會做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/210.wav", + "text": "這是歷史性的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/211.wav", + "text": "美國總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/212.wav", + "text": "做國情報告以後就走人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/213.wav", + "text": "法國總統甚至要留下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/214.wav", + "text": "國會議員的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/215.wav", + "text": "都被國會議員趕出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/216.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在是在一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/217.wav", + "text": "同時我們希望打開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/218.wav", + "text": "國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/219.wav", + "text": "對立法院的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/220.wav", + "text": "很嶄新的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/221.wav", + "text": "也是光榮的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/222.wav", + "text": "他自己自願來也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/223.wav", + "text": "或我們邀請他都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/224.wav", + "text": "這是雙向的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/225.wav", + "text": "我相信賴總統也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/226.wav", + "text": "立法委員出身的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/227.wav", + "text": "他對立法院也是很瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/228.wav", + "text": "他也當過行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/229.wav", + "text": "常常來備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/230.wav", + "text": "現在提一個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/231.wav", + "text": "下禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/232.wav", + "text": "那當然韓院長你要主持交接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/233.wav", + "text": "嘛然後賴總統會在凱道前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/234.wav", + "text": "發表520的演說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/235.wav", + "text": "也就是說520他講完的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/236.wav", + "text": "馬上叫他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/237.wav", + "text": "這些話會有所不同嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/238.wav", + "text": "我們先講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/239.wav", + "text": "因為這是很簡單的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/240.wav", + "text": "但是這個問題還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/241.wav", + "text": "回到憲法層次去講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/242.wav", + "text": "我們立法院是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/243.wav", + "text": "可以理性討論的場域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/244.wav", + "text": "\n韓院長我們在30年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/245.wav", + "text": "有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/246.wav", + "text": "在國會全面改選以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/247.wav", + "text": "進到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/248.wav", + "text": "共事9年你今天貴為院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/249.wav", + "text": "這個民主來得非常珍貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/250.wav", + "text": "我們大家一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/251.wav", + "text": "定要共同來守護民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/252.wav", + "text": "讓民主在臺灣能夠踐行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/253.wav", + "text": "況且你在4月也講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/254.wav", + "text": "民主非常可愛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/255.wav", + "text": "可以理性討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/256.wav", + "text": "講這些話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/257.wav", + "text": "也許大家覺得有點刺耳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/258.wav", + "text": "但是我是肺腑之言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/259.wav", + "text": "我今天對任何人都沒有貶抑的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/260.wav", + "text": "我只是講出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/261.wav", + "text": "我們共同要思考的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/262.wav", + "text": "立法院是一個讓民主能夠踐行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/263.wav", + "text": "讓民主能夠繼續發展走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/264.wav", + "text": "製造憲政衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/265.wav", + "text": "倘若也在這裡製造憲政衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/266.wav", + "text": "\n行政院長要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/267.wav", + "text": "總統也要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/268.wav", + "text": "到底我們憲法的設計是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/269.wav", + "text": "我們憲法的設計當然是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/270.wav", + "text": "就是總統任命行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/271.wav", + "text": "行政院長來立法院作施政報告以及備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/272.wav", + "text": "這是他的義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/273.wav", + "text": "相對地質詢是我們的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/274.wav", + "text": "這個是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/275.wav", + "text": "嘛假如行政院長對法案提覆議以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/276.wav", + "text": "然後都失敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/277.wav", + "text": "了也可以倒閣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/278.wav", + "text": "啊不信任案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/279.wav", + "text": "然後解散國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/280.wav", + "text": "這是整個憲法的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/281.wav", + "text": "憲法本文也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/282.wav", + "text": "從第53條到第61條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/283.wav", + "text": "是行政院要做什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/284.wav", + "text": "是立法院要做什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/285.wav", + "text": "及國家重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/286.wav", + "text": "施政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/287.wav", + "text": "所以我在這裡非常懇切地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/288.wav", + "text": "拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/289.wav", + "text": "大家要從憲政的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/290.wav", + "text": "憲法的角度去看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/291.wav", + "text": "全世界沒有一個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/292.wav", + "text": "乃至共產國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/293.wav", + "text": "任何人對於憲法有抵抗權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/294.wav", + "text": "我們都必須向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/295.wav", + "text": "憲法低頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/296.wav", + "text": "立法院對憲法也沒有抵抗權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/297.wav", + "text": "德國憲法的設計比較特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/298.wav", + "text": "它是人民對於行政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/299.wav", + "text": "有不服從的抵抗權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/300.wav", + "text": "但是全世界找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/301.wav", + "text": "一個國家是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/302.wav", + "text": "對憲法去做抵抗的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/303.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/304.wav", + "text": "每一個人都要向憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/305.wav", + "text": "應該修憲的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/306.wav", + "text": "不是你用修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/307.wav", + "text": "這一點我不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/308.wav", + "text": "以黃總召你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/309.wav", + "text": "素質應該很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/310.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/311.wav", + "text": "我是覺得大家懇切冷靜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/312.wav", + "text": "我們接下來應該怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/313.wav", + "text": "做對於兩個爭點當然大家都可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/314.wav", + "text": "論以上我先發表我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/315.wav", + "text": "不行不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/316.wav", + "text": "因為我是以見證人的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/317.wav", + "text": "我要跟院長請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/318.wav", + "text": "我是在場唯一一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/319.wav", + "text": "現在在場唯一一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/320.wav", + "text": "聽取過總統國情報告的前國大代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/321.wav", + "text": "兼現任的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/322.wav", + "text": "請容我就歷史上的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/323.wav", + "text": "描述一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/324.wav", + "text": "您稍待一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/325.wav", + "text": "國民黨團跟民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/326.wav", + "text": "請問一下對於鍾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/327.wav", + "text": "想要用見證者的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/328.wav", + "text": "來作一個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/329.wav", + "text": "同不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/330.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/331.wav", + "text": "國情報告是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/332.wav", + "text": "這個主席沒有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/333.wav", + "text": "請你把麥克風按掉好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/334.wav", + "text": "這個是你在指揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/335.wav", + "text": "是你在指揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/336.wav", + "text": "鍾委員對不起非常抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/337.wav", + "text": "等一下我們要好好來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/338.wav", + "text": "因為第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/339.wav", + "text": "朝野協商柯總召就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/340.wav", + "text": "如果民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/341.wav", + "text": "請鍾委員來作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/342.wav", + "text": "說明我必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/343.wav", + "text": "要尊重一下國民黨黨團跟民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/344.wav", + "text": "的意見抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/345.wav", + "text": "喔程序上我一定要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/346.wav", + "text": "等一下再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/347.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團跟民眾黨黨團必須要表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/348.wav", + "text": "因為我不能夠擅自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/349.wav", + "text": "院長裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/350.wav", + "text": "因為院長沒點頭以前我不敢隨便發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/351.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/352.wav", + "text": "這個東西委員大家相處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/353.wav", + "text": "會很尷尬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/354.wav", + "text": "我建議是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/355.wav", + "text": "跟時間無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/356.wav", + "text": "3分鐘5分鐘不是這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/357.wav", + "text": "是跟我們這個體制有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/358.wav", + "text": "真的很抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/359.wav", + "text": "我可能要請你離席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/360.wav", + "text": "如果我們討論結束之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/361.wav", + "text": "如果您方便的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/362.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/363.wav", + "text": "你把一個委員從議場趕出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/364.wav", + "text": "這個是何等大事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/365.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/366.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/367.wav", + "text": "你有表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/368.wav", + "text": "嘛國民黨團表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/369.wav", + "text": "我是覺得我們這個會場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/370.wav", + "text": "還是要有制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/371.wav", + "text": "制度怎麼訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/372.wav", + "text": "的上次院長有說得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/373.wav", + "text": "提出要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/374.wav", + "text": "院長也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/375.wav", + "text": "其他政黨也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/376.wav", + "text": "那我們就可以來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/377.wav", + "text": "我想第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/378.wav", + "text": "因為院長有提出上次這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/379.wav", + "text": "一個議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/380.wav", + "text": "我們也表示敬表尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/381.wav", + "text": "今天既然民進黨有提出希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/382.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/383.wav", + "text": "能夠來做見證的方式講3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/384.wav", + "text": "國民黨的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/385.wav", + "text": "請問台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/386.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/387.wav", + "text": "對於鍾佳濱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/388.wav", + "text": "以過來人的身分做3分鐘的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/389.wav", + "text": "同意不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/390.wav", + "text": "第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/391.wav", + "text": "也是基於對院長的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/392.wav", + "text": "在整個發言的順序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/393.wav", + "text": "基本的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/394.wav", + "text": "那個原則是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/395.wav", + "text": "上次院長其實試圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/396.wav", + "text": "發言的順序跟次數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/397.wav", + "text": "奠定一些規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/398.wav", + "text": "不過很遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/399.wav", + "text": "上次的這個規則其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/400.wav", + "text": "無疾而終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/401.wav", + "text": "沒有任何的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/402.wav", + "text": "好那也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/403.wav", + "text": "如果是這個樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/404.wav", + "text": "我們針對一個議題的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/405.wav", + "text": "是不是可以徵求院長的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/406.wav", + "text": "三個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/407.wav", + "text": "彼此之間就用輪流的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/408.wav", + "text": "譬如說國民黨團發言一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/409.wav", + "text": "民進黨團發言一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/410.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團發言一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/411.wav", + "text": "我們透過這樣子rotation的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/412.wav", + "text": "我想說看是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/413.wav", + "text": "可以更有效率一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/414.wav", + "text": "的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/415.wav", + "text": "建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/416.wav", + "text": "讓院長可以考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/417.wav", + "text": "可以參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/418.wav", + "text": "採第二個部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/419.wav", + "text": "在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/420.wav", + "text": "發言次序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/421.wav", + "text": "跟發言順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/422.wav", + "text": "以及可不可以發言的整個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/423.wav", + "text": "我們都還是會尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/424.wav", + "text": "院長對於會議的主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/425.wav", + "text": "謝謝台灣民眾黨黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/426.wav", + "text": "總召的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/427.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請吳思瑤幹事長請說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/428.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/429.wav", + "text": "我想先進入一下程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/430.wav", + "text": "然後再實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/431.wav", + "text": "程序的部分我想今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/432.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱委員他坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/433.wav", + "text": "爭取發言跟參與他是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/434.wav", + "text": "兩個身分第一個當然他是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/435.wav", + "text": "在場唯一一個國民大會過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/436.wav", + "text": "曾任代表的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/437.wav", + "text": "他過去參與過李登輝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/438.wav", + "text": "前總統在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/439.wav", + "text": "的時候來進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/440.wav", + "text": "所以有必要讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/441.wav", + "text": "表達一下過去的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/442.wav", + "text": "作為我們今天協商議定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/443.wav", + "text": "在國會立法院總統國情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/444.wav", + "text": "咨文報告的經驗參採\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/445.wav", + "text": "第二個鍾佳濱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/446.wav", + "text": "坐在這他同時身兼立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/447.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/448.wav", + "text": "今天在討論總統的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/449.wav", + "text": "國情報告的同時其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/450.wav", + "text": "不可切割的也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/451.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召在發言時提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/452.wav", + "text": "我們同時在司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/453.wav", + "text": "進行的立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/454.wav", + "text": "職權行使法也就是國會改革法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/455.wav", + "text": "當中的修法進程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/456.wav", + "text": "而當中就攸關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/457.wav", + "text": "總統赴立院的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/458.wav", + "text": "修法的內容應當如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/459.wav", + "text": "所以我們在前幾次的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/460.wav", + "text": "過程當中也多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/461.wav", + "text": "跟院長表達過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/462.wav", + "text": "在立法院協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/463.wav", + "text": "的現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/464.wav", + "text": "相關重要的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/465.wav", + "text": "議案的召委主持的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/466.wav", + "text": "他勢必應當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/467.wav", + "text": "是受邀的列席人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/468.wav", + "text": "這個我們要多次來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/469.wav", + "text": "所以今天再請兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/470.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝剛剛傅總召他認為是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/471.wav", + "text": "尊重院長裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/472.wav", + "text": "示黃國昌總召是不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/473.wav", + "text": "我還是再發言一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/474.wav", + "text": "爭取不同的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/475.wav", + "text": "能夠來同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/476.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱委員的發言列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/477.wav", + "text": "\n第二個回到這個案子的實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/478.wav", + "text": "如果以國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/479.wav", + "text": "的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/480.wav", + "text": "它的第一句話就是依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/481.wav", + "text": "美國跟法國的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/482.wav", + "text": "美國法國的經驗不管是總統制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/483.wav", + "text": "或者是半總統制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/484.wav", + "text": "我們都知道他們的經驗是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/485.wav", + "text": "總統國情報告完之後隨即離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/486.wav", + "text": "即便在法國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/487.wav", + "text": "制度上能夠讓國會議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/488.wav", + "text": "進行相關總統報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/489.wav", + "text": "的辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/490.wav", + "text": "但是那也必須在總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/491.wav", + "text": "報告結束離場之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/492.wav", + "text": "才得進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/493.wav", + "text": "所以我們也在1997年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/494.wav", + "text": "修憲之後臺灣才行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/495.wav", + "text": "半總統制所以相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/496.wav", + "text": "法國跟美國的經驗都值得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/497.wav", + "text": "臺灣來參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/498.wav", + "text": "總統是報告完之後隨即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/499.wav", + "text": "離開我是先依據國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/500.wav", + "text": "願意釋出善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/501.wav", + "text": "答復的部分我們可以比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/502.wav", + "text": "不設前提的討論我非常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/503.wav", + "text": "認同我們稍後可以來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/504.wav", + "text": "\n民眾黨團提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/505.wav", + "text": "的部分我就提案論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/506.wav", + "text": "提案它的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/507.wav", + "text": "是說依法回應立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/508.wav", + "text": "民眾黨團的依法回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/509.wav", + "text": "就涉及我們在安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/510.wav", + "text": "的制度上如何來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/511.wav", + "text": "所以我們在協商中應當來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/512.wav", + "text": "的是總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/513.wav", + "text": "國情報告時間落在何時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/514.wav", + "text": "民進黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/515.wav", + "text": "跟主張就是依據憲政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/516.wav", + "text": "的權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/517.wav", + "text": "應當先由卓榮泰新閣揆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/518.wav", + "text": "來進行施政報告之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/519.wav", + "text": "然後總統再來安排所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/520.wav", + "text": "是如此因為這是憲政精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/521.wav", + "text": "\n再來總統來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/522.wav", + "text": "依據立法院職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/523.wav", + "text": "行使法第十五條之4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/524.wav", + "text": "4講得很清楚對於發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/525.wav", + "text": "委員的發言時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/526.wav", + "text": "委員的發言順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/527.wav", + "text": "政黨的比例各是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/528.wav", + "text": "這個就是我們今天要討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/529.wav", + "text": "所以說如果以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/530.wav", + "text": "我也聽到黃總召有說到是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/531.wav", + "text": "逐位回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/532.wav", + "text": "那是每一位每一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/533.wav", + "text": "A委員問完總統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/534.wav", + "text": "B委員問完總統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/535.wav", + "text": "或者是統合全部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/536.wav", + "text": "委員假設20位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/537.wav", + "text": "詢問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/538.wav", + "text": "之後總統統一回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/539.wav", + "text": "這個是不同形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/540.wav", + "text": "第三種形式也有可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/541.wav", + "text": "假設國民黨5位委員問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/542.wav", + "text": "總統先答一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/543.wav", + "text": "民眾黨委員可能是2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/544.wav", + "text": "問完總統回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/545.wav", + "text": "然後民進黨可能5位然後總統回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/546.wav", + "text": "所以在逐位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/547.wav", + "text": "回應上其實有三種模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/548.wav", + "text": "輪流問答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/549.wav", + "text": "問答但是問答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/550.wav", + "text": "問答我個人是認為可能不太合宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/551.wav", + "text": "因為變相的是一種即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/552.wav", + "text": "我個人認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/553.wav", + "text": "如果說total" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/554.wav", + "text": "假設所有政黨代表跨黨問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/555.wav", + "text": "可能是20位總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/556.wav", + "text": "統一回答我認為這也許是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/557.wav", + "text": "接受的方式第三種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/558.wav", + "text": "就是依黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/559.wav", + "text": "ABC三個黨團問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/560.wav", + "text": "總統分別回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/561.wav", + "text": "所以大概是這三種形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/562.wav", + "text": "\n這個部分就大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/563.wav", + "text": "共同來共商但如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/564.wav", + "text": "A問完就回答B問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/565.wav", + "text": "就回答這樣子的逐次回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/566.wav", + "text": "就可能比較不宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/567.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我想是稍後我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/568.wav", + "text": "在協調的過程裡頭我們必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/569.wav", + "text": "來做出回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/570.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤幹事長對不起你剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/571.wav", + "text": "這三種模式第一種跟第三種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/572.wav", + "text": "似乎非常接近你能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/573.wav", + "text": "再解釋清楚一點好我現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/574.wav", + "text": "預判可能的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/575.wav", + "text": "我們剛好要決定政黨代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/576.wav", + "text": "總共多少位因為那天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/577.wav", + "text": "賴士葆委員他在做提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/578.wav", + "text": "113位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/579.wav", + "text": "都問這顯然是不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/580.wav", + "text": "民進黨認為比較可行比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/581.wav", + "text": "單純的就是全部一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/582.wav", + "text": "啦全部一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/583.wav", + "text": "全部問完打破政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/584.wav", + "text": "全部一起問完然後看順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/585.wav", + "text": "這是我們的認為因為你講ABC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/586.wav", + "text": "我說的ABC是在回應剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/587.wav", + "text": "依序回答是什麼我只在設想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/588.wav", + "text": "不是我們的主張因為很重要好不是主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/589.wav", + "text": "我只是在設想他們的想法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/590.wav", + "text": "好的好的謝謝接下來我們請洪孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/591.wav", + "text": "記長請發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/592.wav", + "text": "感謝主席我們經過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/593.wav", + "text": "40分鐘的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/594.wav", + "text": "ABC的三種方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/595.wav", + "text": "這樣才有實質討論的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/596.wav", + "text": "我開宗明義先說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/597.wav", + "text": "過去要求總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/598.wav", + "text": "來立法院做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/599.wav", + "text": "不管別人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/600.wav", + "text": "怎麼想但至少我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/601.wav", + "text": "那時要求總統來做國情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/602.wav", + "text": "報告這都是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/603.wav", + "text": "能夠創造一個憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/604.wav", + "text": "達成可是這絕對不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/605.wav", + "text": "所謂的政治攻防手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/606.wav", + "text": "有承認是政治攻防手段的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/607.wav", + "text": "只有柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/608.wav", + "text": "柯建銘總召自己承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/609.wav", + "text": "當時必須要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/610.wav", + "text": "即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/611.wav", + "text": "2012年講必須即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/612.wav", + "text": "否則沒有意義2024年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/613.wav", + "text": "講說即問即答只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/614.wav", + "text": "政治攻防手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/615.wav", + "text": "不是每個人都跟你想的一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/616.wav", + "text": "套在每一個人身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/617.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/618.wav", + "text": "\n上個禮拜韓國瑜院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/619.wav", + "text": "有講到一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/620.wav", + "text": "有講到一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/621.wav", + "text": "民進黨的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/622.wav", + "text": "回去請示一下賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/623.wav", + "text": "也都講得非常有高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/624.wav", + "text": "而且看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/625.wav", + "text": "國民黨團民眾黨團以及民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/626.wav", + "text": "其實也都很希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/627.wav", + "text": "有一個憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/628.wav", + "text": "讓大家能夠看到我們1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/629.wav", + "text": "月13號2024年的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/630.wav", + "text": "有個新民意新改變新的格局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/631.wav", + "text": "所以既然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/632.wav", + "text": "有這樣的一個高度的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/633.wav", + "text": "那我不知道今天民進黨的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/634.wav", + "text": "的想法是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/635.wav", + "text": "尤其剛才吳思瑤幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/636.wav", + "text": "先舉了其他國家的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/637.wav", + "text": "總統來報告完就要離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/638.wav", + "text": "我不知道這是不是賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/639.wav", + "text": "準總統的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/640.wav", + "text": "我希望不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/641.wav", + "text": "如果這是賴清德準總統的意思的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/642.wav", + "text": "那顯然他沒有打算要來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/643.wav", + "text": "溝通交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/644.wav", + "text": "所以民進黨的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/645.wav", + "text": "因為你們是唯一一個可能跟賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/646.wav", + "text": "準總統最接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/647.wav", + "text": "而且最瞭解他意思的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/648.wav", + "text": "也應該要說明一下賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/649.wav", + "text": "準總統的意思是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/650.wav", + "text": "以及他有沒有期待的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/651.wav", + "text": "今天應該要確認的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/652.wav", + "text": "時間跟形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/653.wav", + "text": "5月20號賴清德總統就職之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/654.wav", + "text": "我們其實最快5月24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/655.wav", + "text": "日禮拜五的院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/656.wav", + "text": "邀請賴清德準總統了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/657.wav", + "text": "所以今天協商完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/658.wav", + "text": "只要大家有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/659.wav", + "text": "5月24號我們就可以來邀請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/660.wav", + "text": "5月24號邀請之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/661.wav", + "text": "再由行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/662.wav", + "text": "來做施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/663.wav", + "text": "我想這符合合憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/664.wav", + "text": "合法合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/665.wav", + "text": "合乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/666.wav", + "text": "憲法以及我們相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/667.wav", + "text": "立院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/668.wav", + "text": "包括第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/669.wav", + "text": "新任行政院院長應於就職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/670.wav", + "text": "兩週內向立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/671.wav", + "text": "提出施政方針之報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/672.wav", + "text": "換言之在第十六條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/673.wav", + "text": "就講很清楚兩週內提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/674.wav", + "text": "施政方針之報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/675.wav", + "text": "但是這沒有寫明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/676.wav", + "text": "他應該是提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/677.wav", + "text": "嘛可是備受質詢的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/678.wav", + "text": "其實是我們立院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/679.wav", + "text": "要再召開協商討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/680.wav", + "text": "因為新任的行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/681.wav", + "text": "如同2016年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/682.wav", + "text": "要重新再做一次施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/683.wav", + "text": "新任的卓榮泰院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/684.wav", + "text": "在就職兩週之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/685.wav", + "text": "送書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/686.wav", + "text": "再接受我們113位委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/687.wav", + "text": "這是第一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/688.wav", + "text": "\n第二個是合法我剛剛已經說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/689.wav", + "text": "以及第三個合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/690.wav", + "text": "為什麼總統的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/691.wav", + "text": "要先於行政院長的施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/692.wav", + "text": "我想因為總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/693.wav", + "text": "就是第一我們創下一個慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/694.wav", + "text": "第二總統就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/695.wav", + "text": "主理國家大政方向的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/696.wav", + "text": "外交國防兩岸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/697.wav", + "text": "民生議題能源政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/698.wav", + "text": "當然要由新任總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/699.wav", + "text": "來國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/700.wav", + "text": "把他的施政理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/701.wav", + "text": "講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/702.wav", + "text": "有點像是現在民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/703.wav", + "text": "政府的CEO執行長的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/704.wav", + "text": "我們才去盯行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/705.wav", + "text": "及他的各部會主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/706.wav", + "text": "要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/707.wav", + "text": "怎麼達成賴清德總統的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/708.wav", + "text": "如果說今天是行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/709.wav", + "text": "先來施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/710.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統後來國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/711.wav", + "text": "那賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/712.wav", + "text": "要附和行政院院長講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/713.wav", + "text": "這樣就有點奇怪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/714.wav", + "text": "行政院院長先說了什麼東西之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/715.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/716.wav", + "text": "是幫他背書還是否定他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/717.wav", + "text": "還是賴清德總統有什麼不同的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/718.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/719.wav", + "text": "既然要做真真正正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/720.wav", + "text": "很持平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/721.wav", + "text": "有一天執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/722.wav", + "text": "當國民黨有一天執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/723.wav", + "text": "我們也會要求國民黨籍的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/724.wav", + "text": "先於行政院院長來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/725.wav", + "text": "之後再由行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/726.wav", + "text": "來做總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/727.wav", + "text": "我想這樣子合乎全民的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/728.wav", + "text": "所以我的結論是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/729.wav", + "text": "我希望接下來大家的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/730.wav", + "text": "就是針對我們到底有幾個代表來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/731.wav", + "text": "然後在什麼時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/732.wav", + "text": "如果沒有異議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/733.wav", + "text": "是不是確定一個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/734.wav", + "text": "更重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/735.wav", + "text": "這樣一個進行的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/736.wav", + "text": "我們一定要依照立法院政黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/737.wav", + "text": "席次比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/738.wav", + "text": "如果沒有辦法113席委員的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/739.wav", + "text": "那也儘量多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/740.wav", + "text": "以政黨席次比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/741.wav", + "text": "來分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/742.wav", + "text": "來做我們之前有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/743.wav", + "text": "過我們沒有堅持即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/744.wav", + "text": "所以現在假設沒有即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/745.wav", + "text": "這樣一個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/746.wav", + "text": "一問一答是一個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/747.wav", + "text": "三問一答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/748.wav", + "text": "是一個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/749.wav", + "text": "統問統答是一個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/750.wav", + "text": "我也希望能夠聽聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/751.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/752.wav", + "text": "詢問過賴清德準總統之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/753.wav", + "text": "他心裡有沒有什麼想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/754.wav", + "text": "來討論以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/755.wav", + "text": "謝謝洪孟楷委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/756.wav", + "text": "接下來請莊瑞雄委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/757.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/758.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/759.wav", + "text": "新的總統到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/760.wav", + "text": "來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/761.wav", + "text": "這個其實也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/762.wav", + "text": "符合社會的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/763.wav", + "text": "這個也沒有分黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/764.wav", + "text": "參選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/765.wav", + "text": "在這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/766.wav", + "text": "競選之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/767.wav", + "text": "他們也認為若他們能當選然後到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/768.wav", + "text": "來做國情報告這沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/769.wav", + "text": "啊過去是沒有民意基礎的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/770.wav", + "text": "接受沒有民意基礎的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/771.wav", + "text": "國大代表在那邊問來問去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/772.wav", + "text": "過去都沒有民意基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/773.wav", + "text": "那些老國代哪有什麼民意基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/774.wav", + "text": "以前的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/775.wav", + "text": "國代要求總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/776.wav", + "text": "來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/777.wav", + "text": "他有民意基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/778.wav", + "text": "立法委員當然也有民意基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/779.wav", + "text": "可是偏偏現在的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/780.wav", + "text": "都互不相隸屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/781.wav", + "text": "院長好意召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/782.wav", + "text": "各黨團大家私底下瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/783.wav", + "text": "其實大家也都有一個默契" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/784.wav", + "text": "新任的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/785.wav", + "text": "賴清德準總統到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/786.wav", + "text": "立法院來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/787.wav", + "text": "這個對各政黨來講都不是問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/788.wav", + "text": "國民黨也很開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/789.wav", + "text": "民眾黨也很開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/790.wav", + "text": "大家都很開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/791.wav", + "text": "我們也很願意促成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/792.wav", + "text": "像洪孟楷剛所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/793.wav", + "text": "國政方針要在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/794.wav", + "text": "否則行政院長又跟他不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/795.wav", + "text": "總統到國會來做一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/796.wav", + "text": "這個是沒有條件的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/797.wav", + "text": "他報告完行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/798.wav", + "text": "後面再來做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/799.wav", + "text": "做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/800.wav", + "text": "其實他也不是來做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/801.wav", + "text": "是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/802.wav", + "text": "立法院聽取總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/803.wav", + "text": "國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/804.wav", + "text": "這是憲法裡面的一個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/805.wav", + "text": "所以賴清德來到國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/806.wav", + "text": "我們來聽取他的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/807.wav", + "text": "他也表達樂意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/808.wav", + "text": "我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/809.wav", + "text": "三個黨團大家也都樂意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/810.wav", + "text": "所以我反而會覺得既然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/811.wav", + "text": "大家就一起來成就它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/812.wav", + "text": "再來是行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/813.wav", + "text": "後總統才會到國會來讓立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/814.wav", + "text": "聽取他的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/815.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子的話就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/816.wav", + "text": "大家都願意來促成所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/817.wav", + "text": "這麼樂意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/818.wav", + "text": "讓新的總統到國會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/819.wav", + "text": "就照程序來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/820.wav", + "text": "卓榮泰是新的院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/821.wav", + "text": "本來就要對我們本院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/822.wav", + "text": "來做一個負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/823.wav", + "text": "他要到國會裡面來做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/824.wav", + "text": "以這個大家再來做一個討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/825.wav", + "text": "讓這件事情來做一個成就的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/826.wav", + "text": "我想可能會更好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/827.wav", + "text": "接下來請黃國昌總召請發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/828.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/829.wav", + "text": "賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/830.wav", + "text": "到立法院進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/831.wav", + "text": "這一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/832.wav", + "text": "看起來是沒有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/833.wav", + "text": "如果時間上要比較有意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/834.wav", + "text": "來進行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/835.wav", + "text": "可能我們就要聚焦的談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/836.wav", + "text": "針對於各個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/837.wav", + "text": "發言的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/838.wav", + "text": "各個黨團分配的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/839.wav", + "text": "以及進行的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/840.wav", + "text": "我覺得透過這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/841.wav", + "text": "聚焦一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/842.wav", + "text": "在講以前的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/843.wav", + "text": "進行一些政治上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/844.wav", + "text": "的口水跟攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/845.wav", + "text": "來說意義不是非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/846.wav", + "text": "發生什麼事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/847.wav", + "text": "暢通的時代大家大概稍微查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/848.wav", + "text": "\n所以我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/849.wav", + "text": "是不是針對時間上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/850.wav", + "text": "以及各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/851.wav", + "text": "發言人數代表分配的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/852.wav", + "text": "立法院本於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/853.wav", + "text": "自己的主體性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/854.wav", + "text": "立法院希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/855.wav", + "text": "邀請總統來了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/856.wav", + "text": "本於什麼樣子的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/857.wav", + "text": "讓總統在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/858.wav", + "text": "聽取完各個立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/859.wav", + "text": "或是各個黨團的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/860.wav", + "text": "所發表完意見以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/861.wav", + "text": "來透過什麼樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/862.wav", + "text": "比較聚焦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/863.wav", + "text": "是我針對接下來所要進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/864.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃國昌總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/865.wav", + "text": "\n接下來的有柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/866.wav", + "text": "跟林思銘委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/867.wav", + "text": "還有吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/868.wav", + "text": "發言的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/869.wav", + "text": "大致上就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/870.wav", + "text": "總統賴清德如果來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/871.wav", + "text": "報告的時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/872.wav", + "text": "這似乎有一點不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/873.wav", + "text": "有一方說法是希望在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/874.wav", + "text": "行政院長之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/875.wav", + "text": "另外一方說法是不用限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/876.wav", + "text": "可以在行政院長施政報告之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/877.wav", + "text": "這是一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/878.wav", + "text": "第二個就是發言人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/879.wav", + "text": "各政黨的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/880.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/881.wav", + "text": "就是發言的模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/882.wav", + "text": "是用委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/883.wav", + "text": "政黨全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/884.wav", + "text": "一個大水庫問完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/885.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統統一回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/886.wav", + "text": "分三個政黨為主體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/887.wav", + "text": "統一問完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/888.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/889.wav", + "text": "這是這個模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/890.wav", + "text": "最後就是政黨發言的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/891.wav", + "text": "大致上就是這幾個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/892.wav", + "text": "我期盼所有委員能針對這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/893.wav", + "text": "聚焦一下來探討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/894.wav", + "text": "謝謝\n接下來我們請柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/895.wav", + "text": "我仔細聆聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/896.wav", + "text": "幾位的高見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/897.wav", + "text": "針對剛剛黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/898.wav", + "text": "所回答的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/899.wav", + "text": "一次發言時就問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/900.wav", + "text": "你說依當時的法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/901.wav", + "text": "我說是依憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/902.wav", + "text": "這一點我們應該直球對決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/903.wav", + "text": "談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/904.wav", + "text": "你講的那個發言其他都不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/905.wav", + "text": "什麼政黨比例時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/906.wav", + "text": "那個都不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/907.wav", + "text": "希望的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/908.wav", + "text": "焦點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/909.wav", + "text": "的重點在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/910.wav", + "text": "於總統來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/911.wav", + "text": "任何一個人在此時此刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/912.wav", + "text": "當總統都認為能走進立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/913.wav", + "text": "做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/914.wav", + "text": "是國家開啟了新頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/915.wav", + "text": "也是他個人光榮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/916.wav", + "text": "這問題在臺灣已經講了幾十年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/917.wav", + "text": "為什麼都沒有辦法談好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/918.wav", + "text": "憲法規定的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/919.wav", + "text": "違憲性的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/920.wav", + "text": "法律違背憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/921.wav", + "text": "何來合法性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/922.wav", + "text": "呢這很簡單嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/923.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/924.wav", + "text": "並不是在講口水或是政治鬥爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/925.wav", + "text": "這是一個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/926.wav", + "text": "重要的憲政辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/927.wav", + "text": "我希望大家先定位在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/928.wav", + "text": "不是什麼口水攻擊\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/929.wav", + "text": "剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/930.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷委員對我的指正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/931.wav", + "text": "我當然應該回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/932.wav", + "text": "這點很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/933.wav", + "text": "我講的沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/934.wav", + "text": "這題目在立法院從來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/935.wav", + "text": "朝野攻防的假議題而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/936.wav", + "text": "否則不要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/937.wav", + "text": "雖然也有不同樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/938.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/939.wav", + "text": "所以這時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/940.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法踐行這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/941.wav", + "text": "本來就是朝野攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/942.wav", + "text": "這不是我發明的也不是國民黨發明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/943.wav", + "text": "的兩黨都搞過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/944.wav", + "text": "這個要先談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/945.wav", + "text": "並不是我去創造出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/946.wav", + "text": "的大家在歷史現場都看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/947.wav", + "text": "這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/948.wav", + "text": "很容易Google" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/949.wav", + "text": "嘛洪孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/950.wav", + "text": "講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/951.wav", + "text": "最快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/952.wav", + "text": "5月24號就可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/953.wav", + "text": "有共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/954.wav", + "text": "就是說假如有共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/955.wav", + "text": "合憲性才有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/956.wav", + "text": "否則的話沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/957.wav", + "text": "傅總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/958.wav", + "text": "但是在迴避問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/959.wav", + "text": "傅總召在院會講的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/960.wav", + "text": "賴總統回娘家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/961.wav", + "text": "但是接下去的國民黨代表是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/962.wav", + "text": "是賴士葆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/963.wav", + "text": "賴士葆講的言論就回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/964.wav", + "text": "跟洪孟楷剛才的言論一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/965.wav", + "text": "院長室裡面講得很漂亮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/966.wav", + "text": "什麼都沒有條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/967.wav", + "text": "但是賴清德總統先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/968.wav", + "text": "但是那天在講話的時候我有注意聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/969.wav", + "text": "賴士葆代表國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/970.wav", + "text": "上臺發言的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/971.wav", + "text": "他就是講剛才洪孟楷講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/972.wav", + "text": "幾個人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/973.wav", + "text": "三個人發言完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/974.wav", + "text": "就回答一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/975.wav", + "text": "賴士葆還說過去是這樣從來沒有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/976.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/977.wav", + "text": "問題講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/978.wav", + "text": "過去在國大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/979.wav", + "text": "所以這一點請大家談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/980.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/981.wav", + "text": "這是從來在哪裡進行過我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/982.wav", + "text": "但是賴士葆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/983.wav", + "text": "既然在議事殿堂上講這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/984.wav", + "text": "那你今天也在講這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/985.wav", + "text": "\n第二個就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/986.wav", + "text": "總統他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/987.wav", + "text": "國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/988.wav", + "text": "所以很容易理解所謂國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/989.wav", + "text": "當然就是國防外交兩岸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/990.wav", + "text": "講清楚的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/991.wav", + "text": "行政院長先來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/992.wav", + "text": "那賴總統是不是要依附他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/993.wav", + "text": "行政是一個團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/994.wav", + "text": "啦賴總統任命他當行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/995.wav", + "text": "行政院長當然瞭解整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/996.wav", + "text": "賴總統的施政理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/997.wav", + "text": "先來講給他聽他才聽得懂嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/998.wav", + "text": "不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/999.wav", + "text": "邏輯的轉移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1000.wav", + "text": "你要瞭解什麼叫施政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1001.wav", + "text": "一個國家的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1002.wav", + "text": "要去施政的時候是一個非常龐大的機器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1003.wav", + "text": "賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1004.wav", + "text": "參選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1005.wav", + "text": "你心中要有盤算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1006.wav", + "text": "國防應該是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1007.wav", + "text": "這不是在選里長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1008.wav", + "text": "耶大家都是心中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1009.wav", + "text": "有一盤棋的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1010.wav", + "text": "未來不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1011.wav", + "text": "我在講就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1012.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1013.wav", + "text": "要回到核心事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1014.wav", + "text": "大家繞來繞去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1015.wav", + "text": "就講說我們要趕快來踐行立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1016.wav", + "text": "怎麼問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1017.wav", + "text": "怎麼問幾個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1018.wav", + "text": "極其簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1019.wav", + "text": "不過所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1020.wav", + "text": "就是一個憲政時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1021.wav", + "text": "所有問題焦點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1022.wav", + "text": "是我們要在這裡踐行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1023.wav", + "text": "在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1024.wav", + "text": "又馬上破壞掉嗎不可能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1025.wav", + "text": "乃至於說總統應該先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1026.wav", + "text": "我當然也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1027.wav", + "text": "不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1028.wav", + "text": "這在憲政體制規定的很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1029.wav", + "text": "總統先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1030.wav", + "text": "啊是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1031.wav", + "text": "多少年來行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1032.wav", + "text": "來立法院備詢有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1033.wav", + "text": "看到哪一位總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1034.wav", + "text": "走過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1035.wav", + "text": "怎麼今天突然說要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1036.wav", + "text": "賴總統先來下指導棋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1037.wav", + "text": "然後行政院長才能夠來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1038.wav", + "text": "這是反民主違憲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1039.wav", + "text": "我在這裡還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1040.wav", + "text": "充分表達這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1041.wav", + "text": "假如我講的不對沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1042.wav", + "text": "你們也可以跟我爭辯都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1043.wav", + "text": "但是��今天要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1044.wav", + "text": "大家要面對問題來說事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1045.wav", + "text": "這才是一個核心的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1046.wav", + "text": "\n我以為剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1047.wav", + "text": "黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1048.wav", + "text": "是有什麼高見要針對合憲性合法性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1049.wav", + "text": "這很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1050.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1051.wav", + "text": "是本黨委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1052.wav", + "text": "我請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1053.wav", + "text": "本黨委員坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1054.wav", + "text": "坐在這裡好像院長你把他趕出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1055.wav", + "text": "你還主張他要出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1056.wav", + "text": "你說你主張他出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1057.wav", + "text": "助理都可以坐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1058.wav", + "text": "難道立委比助理還不如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1059.wav", + "text": "嗎助理誰進來我們都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1060.wav", + "text": "後面那一排人我們都不知道是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1061.wav", + "text": "立委可以被趕出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1062.wav", + "text": "那到底是助理還是記者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1063.wav", + "text": "立法院可以如此嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1064.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員你竟然贊成把鍾佳濱委員趕出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1065.wav", + "text": "處理的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1066.wav", + "text": "這個跟黃國昌委員無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1067.wav", + "text": "這是我而且我還特別跟鍾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1068.wav", + "text": "對不起我說抱歉抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1069.wav", + "text": "我一直說抱歉上次跟洪委員我也說抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1070.wav", + "text": "諒解一下等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1071.wav", + "text": "一下上次請洪委員出去是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1072.wav", + "text": "因為我們一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1073.wav", + "text": "第一次朝野協商時就定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1074.wav", + "text": "由黨團負責人來這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1075.wav", + "text": "開會我不是對你不禮貌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1076.wav", + "text": "請你不要誤會我再澄清一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1077.wav", + "text": "抱歉\n抱歉我不能讓你發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1078.wav", + "text": "我要徵詢其他黨團同意好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1079.wav", + "text": "這一點要請你能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1080.wav", + "text": "理解也能諒解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1081.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我們請林思銘書記長發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1082.wav", + "text": "我又聽到柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1083.wav", + "text": "剛才又在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1084.wav", + "text": "他的意思好像又說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1085.wav", + "text": "這個不合憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1086.wav", + "text": "其實我想剛才幾位委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1087.wav", + "text": "發言講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1088.wav", + "text": "報告三黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1089.wav", + "text": "都不認為這是違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1090.wav", + "text": "這怎麼會違憲呢依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1091.wav", + "text": "我們憲法的規定可以邀請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1092.wav", + "text": "做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1093.wav", + "text": "依相關職權行使法立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1094.wav", + "text": "所以完全合憲也合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1095.wav", + "text": "我想他剛才講的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1096.wav", + "text": "一直講的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1097.wav", + "text": "對所以你要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1098.wav", + "text": "你尊重林思銘的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1099.wav", + "text": "我想柯總召的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1100.wav", + "text": "是即問即答的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1101.wav", + "text": "總召我再勾起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1102.wav", + "text": "剛才已講過幾次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1103.wav", + "text": "你2012年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1104.wav", + "text": "總統來國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1105.wav", + "text": "有鑑於國會監督的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1106.wav", + "text": "呼籲馬英九總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1107.wav", + "text": "以即問即答的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1108.wav", + "text": "回答所有的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1109.wav", + "text": "又在講說即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1110.wav", + "text": "是違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1111.wav", + "text": "我就搞不清楚他的邏輯在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1112.wav", + "text": "民意選出來的立法委員也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1113.wav", + "text": "直接民意選出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1114.wav", + "text": "為什麼總統要來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1115.wav", + "text": "我想我們大家都心知肚明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1116.wav", + "text": "現在中華民國是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1117.wav", + "text": "什麼制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1118.wav", + "text": "我們的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1119.wav", + "text": "無責行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1120.wav", + "text": "過去要經過立法院同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1121.wav", + "text": "他的任命但是現在行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1122.wav", + "text": "不用經過立法院同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1123.wav", + "text": "所以行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1124.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1125.wav", + "text": "大家才會希望總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1126.wav", + "text": "依憲法的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1127.wav", + "text": "來立法院做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1128.wav", + "text": "對我們的民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1129.wav", + "text": "負責並接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1130.wav", + "text": "我想賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1131.wav", + "text": "自己也表示得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1132.wav", + "text": "講了所以我不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1133.wav", + "text": "為什麼今天還會有人��什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1134.wav", + "text": "這樣是違憲一直掛在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1135.wav", + "text": "院長我希望今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1136.wav", + "text": "針對剛才院長提的幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1137.wav", + "text": "人數還有日期等趕快做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1138.wav", + "text": "\n我最後再說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1139.wav", + "text": "跟民進黨的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1140.wav", + "text": "講一下我們剛才也一直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1141.wav", + "text": "行政院長先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1142.wav", + "text": "沒有先來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1143.wav", + "text": "你覺得這教總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1144.wav", + "text": "情何以堪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1145.wav", + "text": "到底是總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1146.wav", + "text": "的位階比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1147.wav", + "text": "還是行政院長的位階比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1148.wav", + "text": "你覺得這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1149.wav", + "text": "符合體制嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1150.wav", + "text": "當然是總統先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1151.wav", + "text": "啊總統先到立法院做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1152.wav", + "text": "之後我們接下來才請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1153.wav", + "text": "行政院長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1154.wav", + "text": "嘛這完全符合我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1155.wav", + "text": "對我們國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1156.wav", + "text": "重大方針要做最後負責的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1157.wav", + "text": "行政院長只是他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1158.wav", + "text": "幕僚長當然是總統先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1159.wav", + "text": "我不曉得你們還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1160.wav", + "text": "為什麼一定要總統先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1161.wav", + "text": "我們的直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1162.wav", + "text": "覺就是感覺總統要先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1163.wav", + "text": "依憲法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1164.wav", + "text": "人民的民意是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1165.wav", + "text": "是一定要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1166.wav", + "text": "位階" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1167.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1168.wav", + "text": "不要按麥克風稍微等一下會讓你發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1169.wav", + "text": "我再重申一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1170.wav", + "text": "我們現在再講一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1171.wav", + "text": "大概有四到五個子題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1172.wav", + "text": "是真正的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1173.wav", + "text": "此時此刻要探討有意義的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1174.wav", + "text": "第一個就是總統跟行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1175.wav", + "text": "孰先孰後還是完全尊重總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1176.wav", + "text": "這是一個可以討論的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1177.wav", + "text": "第二我們請總統來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1178.wav", + "text": "每一位委員發言的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1179.wav", + "text": "例如是5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1180.wav", + "text": "但113個委員派出來代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1181.wav", + "text": "如果10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1182.wav", + "text": "甚至20分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1183.wav", + "text": "適合不適合還是說應該5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1184.wav", + "text": "這一點請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1185.wav", + "text": "就這個子題發表你的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1186.wav", + "text": "第三是發言人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1187.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1188.wav", + "text": "總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1189.wav", + "text": "議場跟大家表述的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1190.wav", + "text": "幾位委員能夠把問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1191.wav", + "text": "問得比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1192.wav", + "text": "通透一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1193.wav", + "text": "全面性一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1194.wav", + "text": "結構性一點等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1195.wav", + "text": "以大家的智慧來判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1196.wav", + "text": "發言人數要多少人比較適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1197.wav", + "text": "再來是發言的次序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1198.wav", + "text": "發言的次序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1199.wav", + "text": "如果以黨團的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1200.wav", + "text": "哪個黨團先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1201.wav", + "text": "哪個黨團後等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1202.wav", + "text": "我們能不能聚焦在這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1203.wav", + "text": "問題其他問題我們就不用再探討了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1204.wav", + "text": "因為第一個問題就很重要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1205.wav", + "text": "我們尊重賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1206.wav", + "text": "總統認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1207.wav", + "text": "他要在行政院長之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1208.wav", + "text": "也許總統認為行政院長先施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1209.wav", + "text": "各位黨團委員同意不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1210.wav", + "text": "如果大家也同意能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1211.wav", + "text": "只要能促成這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1212.wav", + "text": "美事一樁的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1213.wav", + "text": "那我想這個我們也可以探討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1214.wav", + "text": "其他的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1215.wav", + "text": "情緒性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1216.wav", + "text": "過去的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1217.wav", + "text": "我想我們就暫時請大家忍耐一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1218.wav", + "text": "先不要發表好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1219.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1220.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1221.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1222.wav", + "text": "我想就條文論條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1223.wav", + "text": "總統要來立法院進行史上第一次的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1224.wav", + "text": "憲法第4條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1225.wav", + "text": "得聽取總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1226.wav", + "text": "在立法院職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1227.wav", + "text": "行使法第二章之一裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1228.wav", + "text": "寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1229.wav", + "text": "第一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1230.wav", + "text": "然後是進行什麼主題呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1231.wav", + "text": "是國家安全大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1232.wav", + "text": "這符合憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1233.wav", + "text": "所規範的總統的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1234.wav", + "text": "是國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1235.wav", + "text": "兩岸國防外交等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1236.wav", + "text": "所以立委的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1237.wav", + "text": "發問或是提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1238.wav", + "text": "也不應當涉及過多的內政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1239.wav", + "text": "包山包海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1240.wav", + "text": "應當回到法制面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1241.wav", + "text": "就是憲法對於總統職權的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1242.wav", + "text": "以及職權行使法第十五之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1243.wav", + "text": "國家安全大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1244.wav", + "text": "的這個focus" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1245.wav", + "text": "不是包山包海什麼都問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1246.wav", + "text": "然後再看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1247.wav", + "text": "職權行使法第十五之四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1248.wav", + "text": "也寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1249.wav", + "text": "就是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1250.wav", + "text": "於總統國情報告完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1251.wav", + "text": "得就報告不明瞭處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1252.wav", + "text": "提出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1253.wav", + "text": "一個補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1254.wav", + "text": "也就是扣著剛剛的第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1255.wav", + "text": "總統報告的是國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1256.wav", + "text": "大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1257.wav", + "text": "如果立委們在總統報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1258.wav", + "text": "完畢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1259.wav", + "text": "所以邏輯是這樣順下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1260.wav", + "text": "所以它就告訴了我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1261.wav", + "text": "從憲法的規定到職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1262.wav", + "text": "的再聲明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1263.wav", + "text": "都是在說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1264.wav", + "text": "也要扣合著國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1265.wav", + "text": "大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1266.wav", + "text": "而不是包山包海所以也不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1267.wav", + "text": "僭越到行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1268.wav", + "text": "院長的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1269.wav", + "text": "這個是非常清楚的法制面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1270.wav", + "text": "\n現在講到為什麼民主進步黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1271.wav", + "text": "認為應當先由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1272.wav", + "text": "行政院院長來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1273.wav", + "text": "之後再進行總統的國情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1274.wav", + "text": "報告呢我想這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1275.wav", + "text": "也要跟幾位委員的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1276.wav", + "text": "有個回應我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1277.wav", + "text": "大家可能在主跟副有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1278.wav", + "text": "一點顛倒了我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1279.wav", + "text": "為什麼一直在說國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1280.wav", + "text": "大政方針這個是憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1281.wav", + "text": "跟職權行使法所規範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1282.wav", + "text": "因為對立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1283.wav", + "text": "負責的是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1284.wav", + "text": "院長所以那個主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1285.wav", + "text": "就是立法院監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1286.wav", + "text": "的對象就是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1287.wav", + "text": "依我們的議程新任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1288.wav", + "text": "行政院院長閣揆他組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1289.wav", + "text": "之後要在兩週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1290.wav", + "text": "到立法院來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1291.wav", + "text": "施政總報告所以它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1292.wav", + "text": "框定了這個時間這是法所明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1293.wav", + "text": "定的這就很清楚地告訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1294.wav", + "text": "大政方針他跟行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1295.wav", + "text": "院長要來報告的內政事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1296.wav", + "text": "是脫鉤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1297.wav", + "text": "所以如果說是讓總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1298.wav", + "text": "先來然後行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1299.wav", + "text": "再來某種程度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1300.wav", + "text": "削弱了行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1301.wav", + "text": "院長的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1302.wav", + "text": "某種程度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1303.wav", + "text": "在野黨的委員恐怕認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1304.wav", + "text": "凡事是總統說了算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1305.wav", + "text": "然後行政院院長再來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1306.wav", + "text": "後續的執行面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1307.wav", + "text": "的說明跟報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1308.wav", + "text": "我想這完全錯置了憲政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1309.wav", + "text": "的權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1310.wav", + "text": "所以立法院的主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1311.wav", + "text": "主要的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1312.wav", + "text": "先後的主是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1313.wav", + "text": "針對行政院院長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1314.wav", + "text": "監督跟質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1315.wav", + "text": "總統來國情報告是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1316.wav", + "text": "副所以前後的順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1317.wav", + "text": "跟邏輯我這樣子在說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1318.wav", + "text": "就是有憲法的層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1319.wav", + "text": "跟法條的層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1320.wav", + "text": "\n所以我不得不也講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1321.wav", + "text": "2015年剛剛大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1322.wav", + "text": "有提到那個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1323.wav", + "text": "馬英九前總統是不是要來國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1324.wav", + "text": "我們再回憶一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1325.wav", + "text": "歷史" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1326.wav", + "text": "王金平前院長還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1327.wav", + "text": "馬英九前總統他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1328.wav", + "text": "都說得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1329.wav", + "text": "總統不是立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1330.wav", + "text": "監督的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1331.wav", + "text": "所以並不存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1332.wav", + "text": "也不應當存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1333.wav", + "text": "即問即答這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1334.wav", + "text": "馬英九王金平的口徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1335.wav", + "text": "一致總統非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1336.wav", + "text": "國會監督的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1337.wav", + "text": "國會監督的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1338.wav", + "text": "是行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1339.wav", + "text": "\n所以我綜整我的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1340.wav", + "text": "時間上先由卓榮泰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1341.wav", + "text": "率內閣進行施政總報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1342.wav", + "text": "這是優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1343.wav", + "text": "因為這是立法院優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1344.wav", + "text": "主要監督的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1345.wav", + "text": "再進行總統的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1346.wav", + "text": "然後應當是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1347.wav", + "text": "全部的報告完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1348.wav", + "text": "我們律定了各黨派的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1349.wav", + "text": "代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1350.wav", + "text": "政黨比例代表之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1351.wav", + "text": "全部發問完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1352.wav", + "text": "總統一次地來做回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1353.wav", + "text": "我的主張完全依附於憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1354.wav", + "text": "以及職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1355.wav", + "text": "這樣才是合理可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1356.wav", + "text": "在這裡補充跟幾位委員做說明報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1357.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1358.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳思瑤委員這麼清楚的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1359.wav", + "text": "至於很細瑣的發言時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1360.wav", + "text": "每位委員發言的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1361.wav", + "text": "我們現在暫時還沒有討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1362.wav", + "text": "但是最起碼已經說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1363.wav", + "text": "您心中所認為的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1364.wav", + "text": "行政院院長要優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1365.wav", + "text": "來立法院做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1366.wav", + "text": "總統的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1367.wav", + "text": "可以在之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1368.wav", + "text": "第二個發言的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1369.wav", + "text": "方式的話是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1370.wav", + "text": "統問統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1371.wav", + "text": "就全部一起問完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1372.wav", + "text": "再請賴清德總統統一回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1373.wav", + "text": "這是您選擇的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1374.wav", + "text": "政黨比例代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1375.wav", + "text": "跟發言時間因為這比較細瑣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1376.wav", + "text": "我們稍後再定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1377.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請黃國昌委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1378.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1379.wav", + "text": "針對院長剛剛所點出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1380.wav", + "text": "那些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1381.wav", + "text": "我們黨團基本上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1382.wav", + "text": "的立場是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1383.wav", + "text": "行政院院長要先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1384.wav", + "text": "還是賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1385.wav", + "text": "要先這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1386.wav", + "text": "在次序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1387.wav", + "text": "我們沒有什麼強制的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1388.wav", + "text": "基於對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1389.wav", + "text": "總統的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1390.wav", + "text": "他希望行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1391.wav", + "text": "先來接受總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1392.wav", + "text": "完了以後他要再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1393.wav", + "text": "這件事情我們事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1394.wav", + "text": "覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1395.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1396.wav", + "text": "不可的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1397.wav", + "text": "針對關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1398.wav", + "text": "在立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1399.wav", + "text": "提出來他們的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1400.wav", + "text": "跟回應以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1401.wav", + "text": "總統再回應的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1402.wav", + "text": "還不知道代表的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1403.wav", + "text": "到底有幾個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1404.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1405.wav", + "text": "公平的計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1406.wav", + "text": "我們不會有多的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1407.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1408.wav", + "text": "在整個回應問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1409.wav", + "text": "方式上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1410.wav", + "text": "不管是幾個代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1411.wav", + "text": "今天有可能是10個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1412.wav", + "text": "有可能是20個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1413.wav", + "text": "因為我不知道最後決定的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1414.wav", + "text": "到底會多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1415.wav", + "text": "會提議說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1416.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1417.wav", + "text": "底線最好是一個黨團問完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1418.wav", + "text": "執政黨的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1419.wav", + "text": "一些建言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1420.wav", + "text": "在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1421.wav", + "text": "有不明瞭的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1422.wav", + "text": "所提出來的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1423.wav", + "text": "讓總統來加以回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1424.wav", + "text": "我們覺得會比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1425.wav", + "text": "聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1426.wav", + "text": "這大概是我們基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1427.wav", + "text": "的一些想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1428.wav", + "text": "跟一些態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1429.wav", + "text": "\n到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1430.wav", + "text": "我們大概所有的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1431.wav", + "text": "都還是按照院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1432.wav", + "text": "剛剛的指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1433.wav", + "text": "在進行發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1434.wav", + "text": "所以有一些政治上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1435.wav", + "text": "攻防的口水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1436.wav", + "text": "我在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1437.wav", + "text": "就不回應了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1438.wav", + "text": "我們基本上展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1439.wav", + "text": "現出來的善意跟誠意我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1440.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1441.wav", + "text": "院長在召集意見交換的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1442.wav", + "text": "我們也都赴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1443.wav", + "text": "院長您也在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1444.wav", + "text": "我們所展現出來的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1445.wav", + "text": "你大概也都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1446.wav", + "text": "聽得非常地清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1447.wav", + "text": "柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1448.wav", + "text": "所提出來的一些指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1449.wav", + "text": "或是跟客觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1450.wav", + "text": "事實不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1451.wav", + "text": "的陳述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1452.wav", + "text": "我先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1453.wav", + "text": "基於對於院長的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1454.wav", + "text": "我在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1455.wav", + "text": "就先不做進一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1456.wav", + "text": "的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1457.wav", + "text": "要不然會讓整件事情開花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1458.wav", + "text": "然後討論到不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1459.wav", + "text": "到什麼樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1460.wav", + "text": "的一個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1461.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯建銘說我趕鍾佳濱出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1462.wav", + "text": "請你回去調錄影帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1463.wav", + "text": "我什麼時候講過這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1464.wav", + "text": "院長問各個黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1465.wav", + "text": "我說我敬表不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1466.wav", + "text": "我是在回應院長的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1467.wav", + "text": "我什麼時候趕鍾佳濱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1468.wav", + "text": "委員出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1469.wav", + "text": "這種跟客觀事實不符合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1470.wav", + "text": "這種抹黑的言語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1471.wav", + "text": "我上次已經跟院長報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1472.wav", + "text": "我們願意坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1473.wav", + "text": "就事論事討論問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1474.wav", + "text": "但並不代表說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1475.wav", + "text": "我們遵守規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1476.wav", + "text": "就要坐在這邊莫名地接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1477.wav", + "text": "其他的人不遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1478.wav", + "text": "規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1479.wav", + "text": "在那邊恣意地亂按麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1480.wav", + "text": "進行人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1481.wav", + "text": "要建立好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1482.wav", + "text": "\n我再強調一次基於對院長的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1483.wav", + "text": "我以上的發言就針對院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1484.wav", + "text": "剛剛希望各個黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1485.wav", + "text": "所表達的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1486.wav", + "text": "我很具體地跟院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1487.wav", + "text": "做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1488.wav", + "text": "不要再出現我剛剛所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1489.wav", + "text": "的那樣的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1490.wav", + "text": "否則等一下接下來的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1491.wav", + "text": "恐怕會開花到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1492.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法處理的境界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1493.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1494.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃國昌總召的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1495.wav", + "text": "\n跟各位黨團幹部報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1496.wav", + "text": "現在我們的協商進行了一個半小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1497.wav", + "text": "了跟大家說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1498.wav", + "text": "下週一是520" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1499.wav", + "text": "新總統和新任行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1500.wav", + "text": "院長就要就任了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1501.wav", + "text": "行使法的規定新任行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1502.wav", + "text": "兩週之內要來本院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1503.wav", + "text": "進行施政方針報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1504.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就訂本週四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1505.wav", + "text": "下午來進行新任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1506.wav", + "text": "行政院院長施政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1507.wav", + "text": "報告及本院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1508.wav", + "text": "配合延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1509.wav", + "text": "相關事宜的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1510.wav", + "text": "也要一併跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1511.wav", + "text": "如果大家能同意的話我們就確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1512.wav", + "text": "於星期四下午來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1513.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1514.wav", + "text": "延會的事情也要一併來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1515.wav", + "text": "\n我知道大家都很辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1516.wav", + "text": "我特別對王部長及高副主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1517.wav", + "text": "非常不好意思因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1518.wav", + "text": "事實上跟各位職掌都沒有什麼直接的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1519.wav", + "text": "大家這樣枯坐在這裡我很不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1520.wav", + "text": "主席真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1521.wav", + "text": "等一下大家可以休息一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1522.wav", + "text": "等我們把第一個議題討論完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1523.wav", + "text": "各位再進來沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1524.wav", + "text": "請各位在外面休息一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1525.wav", + "text": "我們也先休息一下謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1526.wav", + "text": "國情說明還是行政院長先施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1527.wav", + "text": "我們先放在旁邊回頭再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1528.wav", + "text": "我們先就立法院職權行使法第十五條之4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1529.wav", + "text": "規定的四個要素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1530.wav", + "text": "發言的時間發言的人數發言的順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1531.wav", + "text": "以及發言的政黨比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1532.wav", + "text": "確定完畢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1533.wav", + "text": "我們再來討論總統跟院長次序的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1534.wav", + "text": "\n現在請柯建銘總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1535.wav", + "text": "講了這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1536.wav", + "text": "我們沒有直指核心問題來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1537.wav", + "text": "核心問題不處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1538.wav", + "text": "所謂的技術性問題是最簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1539.wav", + "text": "今天這個朝野協商要討論政黨比例發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1540.wav", + "text": "一天結束怎麼樣那個都是很簡單的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1541.wav", + "text": "但是沒有把核心問題講清楚的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1542.wav", + "text": "這個絕對不可能很難進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1543.wav", + "text": "\n針對黃國昌委員講說我做人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1544.wav", + "text": "我一直問你合憲合法你要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1545.wav", + "text": "我何來去做人��攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1546.wav", + "text": "呢因為剛才一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1547.wav", + "text": "的時候鍾佳濱委員在這裡韓院長一度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1548.wav", + "text": "想請他出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1549.wav", + "text": "你也贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1550.wav", + "text": "那傅崐萁委員說可以留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1551.wav", + "text": "你認為他留下來是不適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1552.wav", + "text": "嘛所以說這哪來的人身攻擊呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1553.wav", + "text": "你說應該出去我說這樣事情就大條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1554.wav", + "text": "了把委員趕出議場這個事情大條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1555.wav", + "text": "委員助理坐在這裡我們都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1556.wav", + "text": "理有多少人可以留在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1557.wav", + "text": "所以你講完以後黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1558.wav", + "text": "請你再倒帶你自己講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1559.wav", + "text": "你說他在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1560.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱委員在這裡不合適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1561.wav", + "text": "所以我是針對你所提的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1562.wav", + "text": "今天沒有人有做任何人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1563.wav", + "text": "只是我們不希望迴避問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1564.wav", + "text": "我會問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1565.wav", + "text": "合憲性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1566.wav", + "text": "到底是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1567.wav", + "text": "你不答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1568.wav", + "text": "然後你拋出一個統問統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1569.wav", + "text": "黨這個就是變相的即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1570.wav", + "text": "所以今天在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1571.wav", + "text": "大家都要把問題攤開來講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1572.wav", + "text": "否則開了半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1573.wav", + "text": "所有問題都沒有獲得解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1574.wav", + "text": "然後就趕快來決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1575.wav", + "text": "多少人問政黨比例是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1576.wav", + "text": "了院長這個都不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1577.wav", + "text": "所以我還是要很認真地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1578.wav", + "text": "很誠懇地對大家所有的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1579.wav", + "text": "來回答清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1580.wav", + "text": "\n我再次講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1581.wav", + "text": "總統來立法院做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1582.wav", + "text": "各黨包括我自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1583.wav", + "text": "你要來就即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1584.wav", + "text": "了這不是只有我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1585.wav", + "text": "我反對是因為馬英九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1586.wav", + "text": "在馬習會以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1587.wav", + "text": "要來立法院讓我們幫他背書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1588.wav", + "text": "你要來就即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1589.wav", + "text": "嘛這個都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1590.wav", + "text": "大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1591.wav", + "text": "那林思銘委員還在提這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1592.wav", + "text": "這個我已經解釋得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1593.wav", + "text": "所以不要再提這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1594.wav", + "text": "了他說總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1595.wav", + "text": "感覺上直覺上是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1596.wav", + "text": "這不是感覺直覺的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1597.wav", + "text": "這是憲法層次的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1598.wav", + "text": "憲法是要去實踐的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1599.wav", + "text": "法官解釋得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1600.wav", + "text": "你是學法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1601.wav", + "text": "所以我們在這裡還是要弄清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1602.wav", + "text": "我們把問題講清楚你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1603.wav", + "text": "你一直要用政黨比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1604.wav", + "text": "是最末端的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1605.wav", + "text": "是最簡單的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1606.wav", + "text": "這裡面只有我和韓院長兩個有行使過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1607.wav", + "text": "閣揆同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1608.wav", + "text": "但是在1997年修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1609.wav", + "text": "把它修掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1610.wav", + "text": "1997年修憲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1611.wav", + "text": "也就是說過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1612.wav", + "text": "總統到國大去做國情報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1613.wav", + "text": "可以檢討國是提供建言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1614.wav", + "text": "國大代表可以檢討國是提供建言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1615.wav", + "text": "在1997年把這一段刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1616.wav", + "text": "了只有總統得來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1617.wav", + "text": "那是97年修憲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1618.wav", + "text": "97年修憲把閣揆同意權修掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1619.wav", + "text": "也修了倒閣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1620.wav", + "text": "不信任案以及解散國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1621.wav", + "text": "修到225" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1622.wav", + "text": "人就是為了省議員的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1623.wav", + "text": "所以大家從憲法來看待這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1624.wav", + "text": "97年這句話就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1625.wav", + "text": "了所以沒有所謂的檢討國是提供建言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1626.wav", + "text": "在2005年立法院修憲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1627.wav", + "text": "這句話也沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1628.wav", + "text": "所以大家很清楚憲法的規定是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1629.wav", + "text": "我們現在的核心問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1630.wav", + "text": "合憲性比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1631.wav", + "text": "所以所謂一黨問完並回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1632.wav", + "text": "之後再另一黨提問然後回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1633.wav", + "text": "這個就是變相的即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1634.wav", + "text": "當然這個我們恕難同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1635.wav", + "text": "\n在剛才休息的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1636.wav", + "text": "你們國民黨的意思到底是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1637.wav", + "text": "因為黃國昌已經拋出一個善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1638.wav", + "text": "也就是說他們不堅持總統要先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1639.wav", + "text": "好這個好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1640.wav", + "text": "我們禮拜四要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1641.wav", + "text": "行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1642.wav", + "text": "什麼時候要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1643.wav", + "text": "以及延會的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1644.wav", + "text": "或是臨時會的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1645.wav", + "text": "代表這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1646.wav", + "text": "應該有共識就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1647.wav", + "text": "總統沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1648.wav", + "text": "所謂要先來的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1649.wav", + "text": "這個應該是有這樣的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1650.wav", + "text": "否則的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1651.wav", + "text": "在禮拜四要協商什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1652.wav", + "text": "行政院長什麼時候來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1653.wav", + "text": "最快什麼時候來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1654.wav", + "text": "假如照我們現在的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1655.wav", + "text": "行使法就是說總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1656.wav", + "text": "要多少時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1657.wav", + "text": "政黨比例怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1658.wav", + "text": "就是說要朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1659.wav", + "text": "那我們已經交付朝野協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1660.wav", + "text": "所以再怎麼樣最快也是6月13" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1661.wav", + "text": "13號以後的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1662.wav", + "text": "這個事情大家很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1663.wav", + "text": "\n我要回到一個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1664.wav", + "text": "到底總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1665.wav", + "text": "一直要講這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1666.wav", + "text": "行政院長可以先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1667.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1668.wav", + "text": "國民黨的意思是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1669.wav", + "text": "這個要回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1670.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜五我們在院長室的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1671.wav", + "text": "你們只有堅持說總統要先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1672.wav", + "text": "嘛所以大家要對焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1673.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1674.wav", + "text": "國民黨現在傅總召跑掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1675.wav", + "text": "了誰要來回答這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1676.wav", + "text": "這個先處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1677.wav", + "text": "嘛\n接下來所謂的統問統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1678.wav", + "text": "一黨問完再回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1679.wav", + "text": "傅總召回來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1680.wav", + "text": "剛才休息的時候我也跟傅總召談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1681.wav", + "text": "你的意思是什麼要說好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1682.wav", + "text": "他說這樣啦三個問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1683.wav", + "text": "回答一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1684.wav", + "text": "五個問完回答一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1685.wav", + "text": "嘛賴士葆是講說每一個人都要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1686.wav", + "text": "好像總統來這裡接受總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1687.wav", + "text": "這不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1688.wav", + "text": "啦這當然違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1689.wav", + "text": "啦三個問完三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1690.wav", + "text": "回答一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1691.wav", + "text": "五個問完五個回答一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1692.wav", + "text": "總統是來這裡總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1693.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天要把問題講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1694.wav", + "text": "\n韓院長我不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1695.wav", + "text": "我們在枝節上一直很注重枝節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1696.wav", + "text": "趕快來協商什麼人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1697.wav", + "text": "那個都不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1698.wav", + "text": "核心事情憲法層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1699.wav", + "text": "次的問題先解決先回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1700.wav", + "text": "否則再怎麼講也講不下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1701.wav", + "text": "嘛然後黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1702.wav", + "text": "故意說這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1703.wav", + "text": "他不想回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1704.wav", + "text": "他只要講核心問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1705.wav", + "text": "他不想回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1706.wav", + "text": "你就迴避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1707.wav", + "text": "我問你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1708.wav", + "text": "所謂的核心思想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1709.wav", + "text": "嘛是合憲性還是合法性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1710.wav", + "text": "有做人身攻擊嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1711.wav", + "text": "大家都很冷靜啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1712.wav", + "text": "我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1713.wav", + "text": "在你來當院長以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1714.wav", + "text": "現在已經進入一個所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1715.wav", + "text": "必須面對的深水期了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1716.wav", + "text": "因為很多法案都到了要表決期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1717.wav", + "text": "表決前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1718.wav", + "text": "比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1719.wav", + "text": "我們三長在這裡講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1720.wav", + "text": "出席人數是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1721.wav", + "text": "你不能永遠三個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1722.wav", + "text": "啊三個黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1723.wav", + "text": "不是萬能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1724.wav", + "text": "有法案的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1725.wav", + "text": "你要尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1726.wav", + "text": "比如說鍾佳濱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1727.wav", + "text": "就是一個很好的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1728.wav", + "text": "他是在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1729.wav", + "text": "他當過國大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1730.wav", + "text": "還有黃國昌聯合起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1731.wav", + "text": "把它散會掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1732.wav", + "text": "5次散會掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1733.wav", + "text": "也就是沒收了委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1734.wav", + "text": "這些核心問題沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1735.wav", + "text": "所以他今天非常有感而發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1736.wav", + "text": "的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1737.wav", + "text": "就是講那一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1738.wav", + "text": "我們在修憲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1739.wav", + "text": "也把那段文字刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1740.wav", + "text": "所以大家要面對核心問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1741.wav", + "text": "\n現在最重要的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1742.wav", + "text": "除了這個問題以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1743.wav", + "text": "我今天寫了臉書很懇切地跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1744.wav", + "text": "我相信你看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1745.wav", + "text": "臉書我今天早上起來寫臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1746.wav", + "text": "我把我的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1747.wav", + "text": "用將近兩千字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1748.wav", + "text": "把它寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1749.wav", + "text": "立法院現在是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1750.wav", + "text": "一個懸崖的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1751.wav", + "text": "韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1752.wav", + "text": "第一次朝野協商第二次朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1753.wav", + "text": "你都面對一個挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1754.wav", + "text": "也就是傅崐萁委員跟黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1755.wav", + "text": "認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1756.wav", + "text": "商1月以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1757.wav", + "text": "就要直接進入表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1758.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂的院長的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1759.wav", + "text": "而且院長你要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1760.wav", + "text": "你最大的功能就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1761.wav", + "text": "裡面講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1762.wav", + "text": "以及朝野黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1763.wav", + "text": "這是立法院長最有力的p" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1764.wav", + "text": "歷年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1765.wav", + "text": "所有的立法院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1766.wav", + "text": "在這個地方從來是非常堅持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1767.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1768.wav", + "text": "你的角色完全沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1769.wav", + "text": "到院會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1770.wav", + "text": "國民黨也可能講停止討論直接表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1771.wav", + "text": "這些臺灣的民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1772.wav", + "text": "經過整個三代臺灣人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1773.wav", + "text": "犧牲奉獻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1774.wav", + "text": "迎來了國會全面改選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1775.wav", + "text": "我們是歷史的幸運兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1776.wav", + "text": "不是我們多偉大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1777.wav", + "text": "\n你今天貴為立法院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1778.wav", + "text": "我能夠在這裡31年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1779.wav", + "text": "見證整個國會發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1780.wav", + "text": "這是我們又要感恩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1781.wav", + "text": "又要惜福的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1782.wav", + "text": "所以你要很堅定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1783.wav", + "text": "我們談論問題要直指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1784.wav", + "text": "問題的中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1785.wav", + "text": "不是在旁邊繞然後講半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1786.wav", + "text": "到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1787.wav", + "text": "所有的待證事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1788.wav", + "text": "所有憲法解釋的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1789.wav", + "text": "沒有人要直接面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1790.wav", + "text": "我甚至都期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1791.wav", + "text": "我剛才跟黃國昌講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1792.wav", + "text": "我們都期待我們在憲法層次來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1793.wav", + "text": "但是這是憲法時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1794.wav", + "text": "所以我對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1795.wav", + "text": "我們不把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1796.wav", + "text": "把程序正義定好的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1797.wav", + "text": "已經喪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1798.wav", + "text": "各位論證的場域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1799.wav", + "text": "了而且這是國家級危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1800.wav", + "text": "\n所以院長請三思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1801.wav", + "text": "核心事項核心性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1802.wav", + "text": "先談完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1803.wav", + "text": "整個憲政設計先談完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1804.wav", + "text": "我們才有能力往下走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1805.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯總召的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1806.wav", + "text": "還有楊瓊瓔跟賴士葆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1807.wav", + "text": "葆今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1808.wav", + "text": "國民黨團並沒有請賴士葆和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1809.wav", + "text": "楊瓊瓔過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1810.wav", + "text": "因為我相信他們一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1811.wav", + "text": "先徵詢其他黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1812.wav", + "text": "所以我對鍾佳濱委員一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1813.wav", + "text": "惡意都沒有我只是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1814.wav", + "text": "我們這樣黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1815.wav", + "text": "大家有這個默契" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1816.wav", + "text": "有這個規範要不要持續下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1817.wav", + "text": "柯總召你今天請鍾佳濱鍾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1818.wav", + "text": "來你沒有先跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1819.wav", + "text": "我不曉得他是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1820.wav", + "text": "弄得我很尷尬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1821.wav", + "text": "弄得我很尷尬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1822.wav", + "text": "上一次另外兩位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1823.wav", + "text": "我也很尷尬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1824.wav", + "text": "因為我如果讓他們發言的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1825.wav", + "text": "此例一開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1826.wav", + "text": "假設像今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1827.wav", + "text": "國民黨團直接找楊瓊瓔跟賴士葆說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1828.wav", + "text": "他們曾經看過總統在國民大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1829.wav", + "text": "會做過國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1830.wav", + "text": "請他們發言請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1831.wav", + "text": "你們做何感想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1832.wav", + "text": "做過國代還有兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1833.wav", + "text": "所以真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1834.wav", + "text": "如果有必要三個黨團都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1835.wav", + "text": "我們一定可以請委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1836.wav", + "text": "來這裡列席不管就預算就法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1837.wav", + "text": "案絕對沒有問題的\n我再重申一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1838.wav", + "text": "如果今天這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1839.wav", + "text": "後續的話再發生什麼狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1840.wav", + "text": "我當主席也很難控制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1841.wav", + "text": "這個場面請你一定要理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1842.wav", + "text": "我絕對不是對你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1843.wav", + "text": "或對鍾佳濱委員有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1844.wav", + "text": "我回答你一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1845.wav", + "text": "這典範是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1846.wav", + "text": "已經被打破了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1847.wav", + "text": "過去朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1848.wav", + "text": "的樣子大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1849.wav", + "text": "所有的提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1850.wav", + "text": "我們講一個問題就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1851.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員上次一直講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1852.wav", + "text": "我們審查法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1853.wav", + "text": "比如說我們今天審查花東快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1854.wav", + "text": "是不是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1855.wav", + "text": "經過4個縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1856.wav", + "text": "那4個縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1857.wav", + "text": "──宜蘭花蓮臺東乃至於屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1858.wav", + "text": "的立法委員都應該來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1859.wav", + "text": "有經過原住民保留區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1860.wav", + "text": "原住民委員也要來發表意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1861.wav", + "text": "這是立法院一個長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1862.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1863.wav", + "text": "的遊戲規則是被打破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1864.wav", + "text": "這是確定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1865.wav", + "text": "被打破的是什麼現在只有3個可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1866.wav", + "text": "法案多複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1867.wav", + "text": "一個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1868.wav", + "text": "比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1869.wav", + "text": "很熱門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1870.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1871.wav", + "text": "有多少人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1872.wav", + "text": "比如說很熱門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1873.wav", + "text": "酒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1874.wav", + "text": "有可能有五六十個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1875.wav", + "text": "所以我只是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1876.wav", + "text": "立法院從來審查法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1877.wav", + "text": "召委一定會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1878.wav", + "text": "因為召委要到委員會做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1879.wav", + "text": "你把他晾在旁邊去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1880.wav", + "text": "審完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1881.wav", + "text": "他不知道我們這裡處理到怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1882.wav", + "text": "各黨都有召委要不要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1883.wav", + "text": "要不要派代表來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1884.wav", + "text": "多少人數是可以談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1885.wav", + "text": "國防委員會否則的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1886.wav", + "text": "大家都沒有去過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1887.wav", + "text": "所以這個問題一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1888.wav", + "text": "法條協商那是不是尊重一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1889.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1890.wav", + "text": "現在就不是法條協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1891.wav", + "text": "而是針對第一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1892.wav", + "text": "不是你已經講完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1893.wav", + "text": "現在是您違規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1894.wav", + "text": "按麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1895.wav", + "text": "我從來沒按掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1896.wav", + "text": "現在請洪孟楷委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1897.wav", + "text": "你剛剛已經多用了十幾分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1898.wav", + "text": "的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1899.wav", + "text": "你多用了十幾分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1900.wav", + "text": "你讓我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1901.wav", + "text": "我現在講的是非核心事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1902.wav", + "text": "大家要面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1903.wav", + "text": "我接下來請洪孟楷委員吳思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1904.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員也請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1905.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1906.wav", + "text": "主席我說實在話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1907.wav", + "text": "今天到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1908.wav", + "text": "一個小時又五十分���過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1909.wav", + "text": "我看不懂今天各黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1910.wav", + "text": "三長出來到底是想要促成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1911.wav", + "text": "的首例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1912.wav", + "text": "還是想要打破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1913.wav", + "text": "還是想要惡意杯葛讓賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1914.wav", + "text": "準總統不要來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1915.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1916.wav", + "text": "代表發言的時候用二分之一的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1917.wav", + "text": "在前集回顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1918.wav", + "text": "在講過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1919.wav", + "text": "明明主席已經裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1920.wav", + "text": "的事情他就是要重複講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1921.wav", + "text": "拜託不要那麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1922.wav", + "text": "玻璃心好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1923.wav", + "text": "如果什麼事情都要那麼玻璃心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1924.wav", + "text": "花一半的時間講自己的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1925.wav", + "text": "然後玻璃心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1926.wav", + "text": "我到目前為止沒有指名道姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1927.wav", + "text": "不要對號入座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1928.wav", + "text": "\n還有更重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1929.wav", + "text": "如果真的有什麼事情要表達的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1930.wav", + "text": "我們講不客氣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1931.wav", + "text": "記者會開不夠嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1932.wav", + "text": "每天早上禮拜六禮拜天都各自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1933.wav", + "text": "受媒體聯訪了這樣還不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1934.wav", + "text": "還要在協商的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1935.wav", + "text": "發言今天主席定了四個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1936.wav", + "text": "兩點到六點我們要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1937.wav", + "text": "的是三個重大案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1938.wav", + "text": "但是我們現在連第一個案件都還沒有突破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1939.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常可惜如果各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1940.wav", + "text": "想要惡意杯葛不讓賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1941.wav", + "text": "創下這個憲政首例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1942.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是全民的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1943.wav", + "text": "遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1944.wav", + "text": "真的是全民的遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1945.wav", + "text": "\n我現在直接講重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1946.wav", + "text": "上禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1947.wav", + "text": "已經請民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1948.wav", + "text": "三長先回去請示賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1949.wav", + "text": "內心的想法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1950.wav", + "text": "說一定要行政院長先來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1951.wav", + "text": "這是民進黨團的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1952.wav", + "text": "還是賴清德總統的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1953.wav", + "text": "是賴清德總統覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1954.wav", + "text": "先讓卓榮泰行政院長上臺報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1955.wav", + "text": "他才願意來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1956.wav", + "text": "還是其實賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1957.wav", + "text": "因為創下憲政首例比什麼都重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1958.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1959.wav", + "text": "我們也希望因為這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1960.wav", + "text": "中華民國建國113年以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1961.wav", + "text": "第一次有總統踏上立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1962.wav", + "text": "所以他有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1963.wav", + "text": "很高的制高點大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1964.wav", + "text": "也都講得慷慨激昂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1965.wav", + "text": "就職之後524" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1966.wav", + "text": "或者是再下一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1967.wav", + "text": "馬上就能夠安排的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1968.wav", + "text": "都會覺得某種程度上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1969.wav", + "text": "朝野和解某種程度上總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1970.wav", + "text": "對立法院負責某種程度上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1971.wav", + "text": "總統直接面對2,350萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1972.wav", + "text": "的民意這不是很好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1973.wav", + "text": "惡意拖延說一定要行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1974.wav", + "text": "報告完之後才讓賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1975.wav", + "text": "來你是想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1976.wav", + "text": "成局還是想要破局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1977.wav", + "text": "我就直接問你們是想要成局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1978.wav", + "text": "還是想要破局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1979.wav", + "text": "\n再來如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1980.wav", + "text": "真的非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1981.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統看什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1982.wav", + "text": "你來定一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1983.wav", + "text": "假設賴清德總統認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1984.wav", + "text": "524不行530不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1985.wav", + "text": "6月5號不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1986.wav", + "text": "6月10號行不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1987.wav", + "text": "看哪一個時間點賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1988.wav", + "text": "覺得可以我們先確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1989.wav", + "text": "來總質詢報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1990.wav", + "text": "會提出來如果要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1991.wav", + "text": "總質詢的話我們就會這樣堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1992.wav", + "text": "總不會說一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1993.wav", + "text": "做國情報告吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1994.wav", + "text": "針對怎麼樣的進行方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1995.wav", + "text": "我們國民黨團真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1996.wav", + "text": "已經釋出很大的善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1997.wav", + "text": "之前有媒體說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1998.wav", + "text": "我們堅持即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/1999.wav", + "text": "我們沒有堅持即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2000.wav", + "text": "以及立院職權行事法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2001.wav", + "text": "我們沒有堅持即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2002.wav", + "text": "即問即答是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2003.wav", + "text": "就像現在的質詢一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2004.wav", + "text": "立法委員把麥克風開著行政院長把麥克風開著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2005.wav", + "text": "互相問答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2006.wav", + "text": "這叫即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2007.wav", + "text": "我們沒有堅持這樣的模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2008.wav", + "text": "我們也認為只要總統願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2009.wav", + "text": "來到立法院做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2010.wav", + "text": "我們尊重總統的高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2011.wav", + "text": "用所謂統問統答的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2012.wav", + "text": "人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2013.wav", + "text": "請依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2014.wav", + "text": "我們立院的政黨比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2015.wav", + "text": "去做一個分派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2016.wav", + "text": "看是十分之一的立委人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2017.wav", + "text": "還是五分之一的立委人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2018.wav", + "text": "來推派代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2019.wav", + "text": "時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2020.wav", + "text": "一個人假設5分鐘7分鐘或10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2021.wav", + "text": "形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2022.wav", + "text": "我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2023.wav", + "text": "既然可以統問統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2024.wav", + "text": "我們希望聽到的是真切的答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2025.wav", + "text": "也就是總統的高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2026.wav", + "text": "能夠回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2027.wav", + "text": "的立法委員在這邊絕對不會無的放矢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2028.wav", + "text": "我想大家都在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2029.wav", + "text": "\n所以吳思瑤幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2030.wav", + "text": "剛剛有提到所謂的國家方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2031.wav", + "text": "報告那是總統要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2032.wav", + "text": "國家安全方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2033.wav", + "text": "國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2034.wav", + "text": "同樣地立法委員提出的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2035.wav", + "text": "也一定會針對中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2036.wav", + "text": "外交國防兩岸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2037.wav", + "text": "民生能源經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2038.wav", + "text": "等重大方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2039.wav", + "text": "來就教賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2040.wav", + "text": "只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2041.wav", + "text": "既然賴清德總統要回答的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2042.wav", + "text": "我們還是期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2043.wav", + "text": "問完他才一次綜合回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2044.wav", + "text": "再者很多時候可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2045.wav", + "text": "就如同外界所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2046.wav", + "text": "他會選擇性的回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2047.wav", + "text": "也因此我們當然希望賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2048.wav", + "text": "但是在給予一定高度尊重的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2049.wav", + "text": "能夠分階段回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2050.wav", + "text": "三位問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2051.wav", + "text": "總統能夠回答一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2052.wav", + "text": "還是五位問完總統能夠回答一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2053.wav", + "text": "針對問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2054.wav", + "text": "來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2055.wav", + "text": "我們甚至都還沒有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2056.wav", + "text": "總統回答要不要限制時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2057.wav", + "text": "這是尊重總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2058.wav", + "text": "如果總統願意講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2059.wav", + "text": "不限制時間這可能是一個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2060.wav", + "text": "或是跟立法委員一樣詢問問題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2061.wav", + "text": "一個人有5分鐘或7分鐘的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2062.wav", + "text": "總統回答也有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2063.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2064.wav", + "text": "\n要成局我拜託大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2065.wav", + "text": "拿出誠意討論這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2066.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2067.wav", + "text": "要去做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2068.wav", + "text": "而不是像現在還在打高空" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2069.wav", + "text": "還在解釋還在說明我沒有那個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2070.wav", + "text": "我有那個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2071.wav", + "text": "那個回去黨團記者會你們要怎麼開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2072.wav", + "text": "但是協商時候我真的拜託大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2073.wav", + "text": "我們聚焦在這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2074.wav", + "text": "題目上我已經很有誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2075.wav", + "text": "把我們的一些方法想法都提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2076.wav", + "text": "我也拜託其他兩個黨團的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2077.wav", + "text": "好謝謝洪孟楷委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2078.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請吳思瑤委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2079.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2080.wav", + "text": "為什麼民進黨團認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2081.wav", + "text": "我們要在整個憲政脈絡精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2082.wav", + "text": "合憲性先去釐清清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2083.wav", + "text": "我接著剛剛洪孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2084.wav", + "text": "書記長所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2085.wav", + "text": "我真真切切聽到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2086.wav", + "text": "可能在洪委員的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2087.wav", + "text": "或國民黨團的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2088.wav", + "text": "就已經把總統到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2089.wav", + "text": "進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2090.wav", + "text": "定調為立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2091.wav", + "text": "可以來質詢總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2092.wav", + "text": "剛剛整個的發言脈絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2093.wav", + "text": "不要讓總統選擇性回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2094.wav", + "text": "要分階段來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2095.wav", + "text": "就是問一階段後答一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2096.wav", + "text": "如果以洪委員剛剛所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2097.wav", + "text": "就坐實了國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2098.wav", + "text": "可能設想的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2099.wav", + "text": "總統來到國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2100.wav", + "text": "是接受立法委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2101.wav", + "text": "就是照著這個邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2102.wav", + "text": "但我們要說的是憲法的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2103.wav", + "text": "憲法的精神是總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2104.wav", + "text": "基於尊重國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2105.wav", + "text": "願意來這裡做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2106.wav", + "text": "而國情報告是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2107.wav", + "text": "就國家安全大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2108.wav", + "text": "絕對不是如剛剛洪委員所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2109.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2110.wav", + "text": "這樣交換意見很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2111.wav", + "text": "從剛剛洪委員的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2112.wav", + "text": "證明您的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2113.wav", + "text": "跟我的想法是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2114.wav", + "text": "那你的想法跟我的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2115.wav", + "text": "一不一樣其實也沒那麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2116.wav", + "text": "重點是憲法所賦予的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2117.wav", + "text": "權限是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2118.wav", + "text": "憲法所賦予的權限是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2119.wav", + "text": "總統來做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2120.wav", + "text": "\n這個是從職權行使法再衍生出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2121.wav", + "text": "如果有立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2122.wav", + "text": "就總統所報告的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2123.wav", + "text": "那個主題叫做國家安全大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2124.wav", + "text": "有不明瞭之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2125.wav", + "text": "委員可以提出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2126.wav", + "text": "然後總統是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2127.wav", + "text": "作最後的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2128.wav", + "text": "所以總統當然可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2129.wav", + "text": "依他認為的委員所問的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2130.wav", + "text": "是不是他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2131.wav", + "text": "報告的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2132.wav", + "text": "也就是憲法所賦予總統的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2133.wav", + "text": "國家安全相涉的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2134.wav", + "text": "來進行回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2135.wav", + "text": "如果依據合憲性來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2136.wav", + "text": "兩個黨團所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2137.wav", + "text": "這個院會的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2138.wav", + "text": "裡面所要求總統來進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2139.wav", + "text": "內容說明其實都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2140.wav", + "text": "溢出了憲法所授權的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2141.wav", + "text": "兩個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2142.wav", + "text": "所提出來的這些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2143.wav", + "text": "請總統針對ABCDEFG" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2144.wav", + "text": "之類的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2145.wav", + "text": "真的都是溢出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2146.wav", + "text": "國家安全大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2147.wav", + "text": "這裡頭你們所列出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2148.wav", + "text": "各種從財劃法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2149.wav", + "text": "從物價起漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2150.wav", + "text": "淨零排放產業轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2151.wav", + "text": "健保財務穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2152.wav", + "text": "保障民眾就醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2153.wav", + "text": "這些都是行政院長的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2154.wav", + "text": "不是總統要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2155.wav", + "text": "回答立法委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2156.wav", + "text": "內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2157.wav", + "text": "\n我也認為在這裡對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2158.wav", + "text": "很有意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2159.wav", + "text": "這是史上第一次總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2160.wav", + "text": "來到國會進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2161.wav", + "text": "合憲性的認知跟理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2162.wav", + "text": "我們一定要先確立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2163.wav", + "text": "絕對不是說立委這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2164.wav", + "text": "我們立委說好朝野協商說好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2165.wav", + "text": "就怎樣怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2166.wav", + "text": "那是憲法可以給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2167.wav", + "text": "怎樣的一個架構我們才能夠依循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2168.wav", + "text": "而不是今天這麼便宜行事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2169.wav", + "text": "我們幾個黨團講好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2170.wav", + "text": "時間幾分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2171.wav", + "text": "然後是如何回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2172.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2173.wav", + "text": "那真的是太便宜行事了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2174.wav", + "text": "\n我們面對的是憲政時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2175.wav", + "text": "史上第一次總統來國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2176.wav", + "text": "所以回到合憲性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2177.wav", + "text": "我再一次說我覺得非常遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2178.wav", + "text": "\n當然今天鍾佳濱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2179.wav", + "text": "不是我們邀請的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2180.wav", + "text": "我有跟他說是不是能夠發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2181.wav", + "text": "賴士葆委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2182.wav", + "text": "他們願意來這裡我相信我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2183.wav", + "text": "會有這樣子的雅量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2184.wav", + "text": "願意聽聽他們分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2185.wav", + "text": "過去國民大會幾次修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2186.wav", + "text": "從國民大會行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2187.wav", + "text": "投票總統到民選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2188.wav", + "text": "整個制度的延伸是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2189.wav", + "text": "演繹是什麼落成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2190.wav", + "text": "今天的憲法文字增修條文第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2191.wav", + "text": "第3項如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2192.wav", + "text": "賴士葆委員楊瓊瓔委員今天來到現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2193.wav", + "text": "我想我們民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2194.wav", + "text": "是非常同意可以讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2195.wav", + "text": "們坐在這裡分享過去的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2196.wav", + "text": "這對於我們就國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2197.wav", + "text": "認知大有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2198.wav", + "text": "所以我很謝謝剛剛傅崐萁委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2199.wav", + "text": "員一開始說他並不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2200.wav", + "text": "鍾佳濱委員可以發表意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2201.wav", + "text": "只是民眾黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2202.wav", + "text": "朋友認為不宜好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2203.wav", + "text": "但我還是覺得這是有點可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2204.wav", + "text": "的事因為這有助於釐清合憲性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2205.wav", + "text": "\n所以合憲性是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2206.wav", + "text": "我們絕對需要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2207.wav", + "text": "釐清楚至於安排哪一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2208.wav", + "text": "我非常同意院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2209.wav", + "text": "就是我們釐訂了下週四的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2210.wav", + "text": "我們把行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2211.wav", + "text": "依職權行使法二週內要來的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2212.wav", + "text": "先訂好那總統的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2213.wav", + "text": "就在訂好的時間之後去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2214.wav", + "text": "彈性安排這是OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2215.wav", + "text": "因為我們監督的對象叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2216.wav", + "text": "行政院長依照我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2217.wav", + "text": "議事日程就應當先訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2218.wav", + "text": "屆期交換的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2219.wav", + "text": "新任閣揆要來施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2220.wav", + "text": "它的時間要落在法定時間內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2221.wav", + "text": "這個絕對是我們要訂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2222.wav", + "text": "這個是優先的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2223.wav", + "text": "所以主跟副" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2224.wav", + "text": "不能前後倒置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2225.wav", + "text": "我再一次回到就是主跟副" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2226.wav", + "text": "立法院監督的叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2227.wav", + "text": "行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2228.wav", + "text": "的這個部分再多花一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2229.wav", + "text": "論述我的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2230.wav", + "text": "選舉的時候大學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2231.wav", + "text": "找座談都願意去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2232.wav", + "text": "結果現在選上當選總統之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2233.wav", + "text": "結果就講要合憲性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2234.wav", + "text": "你不是違規了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2235.wav", + "text": "接下來請黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2236.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄委員請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2237.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2238.wav", + "text": "剛剛依照院長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2239.wav", + "text": "針對有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2240.wav", + "text": "目前立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2241.wav", + "text": "職權行使法第十五條之4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2242.wav", + "text": "就發言的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2243.wav", + "text": "人數順序政黨比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2244.wav", + "text": "等事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2245.wav", + "text": "請我們台灣民眾黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2246.wav", + "text": "發表意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2247.wav", + "text": "其實我剛剛在發言的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2248.wav", + "text": "院長垂詢的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2249.wav", + "text": "我們都已經具體表明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2250.wav", + "text": "我再清楚地說明一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2251.wav", + "text": "整個發言的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2252.wav", + "text": "時間人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2253.wav", + "text": "順序等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2254.wav", + "text": "我們都願意遵照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2255.wav", + "text": "只要政黨比例之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2256.wav", + "text": "彼此公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2257.wav", + "text": "我們不會有太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2258.wav", + "text": "其他的強烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2259.wav", + "text": "只不過在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2260.wav", + "text": "上一次發言的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2261.wav", + "text": "我曾經跟院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2262.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2263.wav", + "text": "就是如果我們這個黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2264.wav", + "text": "要能夠聚焦的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2265.wav", + "text": "需要大家協商的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2266.wav", + "text": "來進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2267.wav", + "text": "嘛因為這是剛剛院長所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2268.wav", + "text": "依照現行法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2269.wav", + "text": "剛剛所說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2270.wav", + "text": "發言的時間人數順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2271.wav", + "text": "還有政黨比例的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2272.wav", + "text": "嘛只不過說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2273.wav", + "text": "剛剛很遺憾的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2274.wav", + "text": "就聽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2275.wav", + "text": "民主進步黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2276.wav", + "text": "柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2277.wav", + "text": "其實顯然溢出了您剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2278.wav", + "text": "指示要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2279.wav", + "text": "的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2280.wav", + "text": "他大概從1997年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2281.wav", + "text": "修憲講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2282.wav", + "text": "目前的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2283.wav", + "text": "才能夠參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2284.wav", + "text": "各式各樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2285.wav", + "text": "不是我們現在在協商的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2286.wav", + "text": "全部搬到檯面上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2287.wav", + "text": "來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2288.wav", + "text": "甚至指名道姓地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2289.wav", + "text": "說我迴避問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2290.wav", + "text": "讓我覺得非常困惑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2291.wav", + "text": "我們現在是在黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2292.wav", + "text": "各黨團表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2293.wav", + "text": "還是正在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2294.wav", + "text": "政黨的憲政辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2295.wav", + "text": "\n我不客氣地說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2296.wav", + "text": "有合憲或沒有合憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2297.wav", + "text": "恐怕也不是在座幾位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2298.wav", + "text": "說了就算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2299.wav", + "text": "你主張違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2300.wav", + "text": "你有你的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2301.wav", + "text": "我不同意我尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2302.wav", + "text": "事情就這麼簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2303.wav", + "text": "真的要講到柯建銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2304.wav", + "text": "當初在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2305.wav", + "text": "即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2306.wav", + "text": "他剛剛一直在解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2307.wav", + "text": "說那是馬習會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2308.wav", + "text": "他就是不要讓馬英九來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2309.wav", + "text": "很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2310.wav", + "text": "耶當初柯建銘跟潘孟安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2311.wav", + "text": "總統府秘書長的潘孟安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2312.wav", + "text": "說要即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2313.wav", + "text": "因為我看潘孟安臉書上的貼文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2314.wav", + "text": "是2012年4月10號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2315.wav", + "text": "問題是馬習會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2316.wav", + "text": "是2015年11月7號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2317.wav", + "text": "發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2318.wav", + "text": "2012年4月9號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2319.wav", + "text": "或10號的潘孟安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2320.wav", + "text": "先坐著時光機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2321.wav", + "text": "預知到3年多以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2322.wav", + "text": "會發生這樣子的馬習會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2323.wav", + "text": "要提前3年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2324.wav", + "text": "用所謂的即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2325.wav", + "text": "是政治攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2326.wav", + "text": "就是沒有要讓馬英九來當做藉口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2327.wav", + "text": "這已經不是邏輯錯亂的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2328.wav", + "text": "而是根本就悖離了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2329.wav", + "text": "歷史客觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2330.wav", + "text": "事實的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2331.wav", + "text": "\n我必須要再跟院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2332.wav", + "text": "報告一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2333.wav", + "text": "就如同我一開始前一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2334.wav", + "text": "時跟您說明的一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2335.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2336.wav", + "text": "能夠遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2337.wav", + "text": "您立下來的一些規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2338.wav", + "text": "以及發言的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2339.wav", + "text": "這個規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2340.wav", + "text": "不要好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2341.wav", + "text": "只有少數的人要遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2342.wav", + "text": "用在柯建銘身上就不適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2343.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2344.wav", + "text": "接下來的討論就會開花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2345.wav", + "text": "就會開花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2346.wav", + "text": "為什麼我要強調這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2347.wav", + "text": "是開花的責任不在我們身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2348.wav", + "text": "\n最後一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2349.wav", + "text": "我們依照目前的憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2350.wav", + "text": "增修條文以及立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2351.wav", + "text": "職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2352.wav", + "text": "這是所謂的違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2353.wav", + "text": "或者是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2354.wav", + "text": "我們做為一個憲政民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2355.wav", + "text": "是不是違憲恐怕也不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2356.wav", + "text": "誰說了就算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2357.wav", + "text": "那你就依照我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2358.wav", + "text": "憲政民主的機制該怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2359.wav", + "text": "就怎麼處理嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2360.wav", + "text": "立法院做了決議以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2361.wav", + "text": "如果總統他認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2362.wav", + "text": "違反憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2363.wav", + "text": "窒礙難行總統有總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2364.wav", + "text": "自己的憲政手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2365.wav", + "text": "可以去做處理嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2366.wav", + "text": "我們所提出來的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2367.wav", + "text": "是希望邀請賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2368.wav", + "text": "總統到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2369.wav", + "text": "就國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2370.wav", + "text": "進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2371.wav", + "text": "那我們就依照現行立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2372.wav", + "text": "職權行使法第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2373.wav", + "text": "需要協商的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2374.wav", + "text": "好好地來進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2375.wav", + "text": "有共識的就有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2376.wav", + "text": "沒有共識也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2377.wav", + "text": "因為坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2378.wav", + "text": "有共識嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2379.wav", + "text": "但我們最起碼是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2380.wav", + "text": "盡心盡力坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2381.wav", + "text": "把該協商該討論的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2382.wav", + "text": "好好討論出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2383.wav", + "text": "不要再做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2384.wav", + "text": "超越範圍太久以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2385.wav", + "text": "民主發展史" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2386.wav", + "text": "每一個人在這個民主發展史裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2387.wav", + "text": "所曾經做過的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2388.wav", + "text": "談到自己的臉書發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2389.wav", + "text": "談到朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2390.wav", + "text": "到底誰可以來以及誰不可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2391.wav", + "text": "我們現在在進行的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2392.wav", + "text": "每一個人的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2393.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2394.wav", + "text": "關心的公民大家都會看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2395.wav", + "text": "所以我也是很懇切的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2396.wav", + "text": "跟院長表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2397.wav", + "text": "我們的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2398.wav", + "text": "發言的時間人數順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2399.wav", + "text": "政黨比例等事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2400.wav", + "text": "我們就按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2401.wav", + "text": "公平的原則予以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2402.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨不會強求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2403.wav", + "text": "我們現在針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2404.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法第十五條之4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2405.wav", + "text": "所進行的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2406.wav", + "text": "有人說是枝微末節的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2407.wav", + "text": "根本不需要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2408.wav", + "text": "也不需要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2409.wav", + "text": "那麼我們就在這邊一直坐著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2410.wav", + "text": "全部都在繞圈子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2411.wav", + "text": "嘛柯建銘繼續坐在對面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2412.wav", + "text": "主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2413.wav", + "text": "指責中國國民黨跟台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2414.wav", + "text": "所提出來的東西是違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2415.wav", + "text": "那我就坐在這邊負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2416.wav", + "text": "任的跟你講我認為沒有違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2417.wav", + "text": "嘛接下來的關鍵點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2418.wav", + "text": "是什麼接下來的關鍵點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2419.wav", + "text": "就變成是不是違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2420.wav", + "text": "恐怕不是你柯建銘說了算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2421.wav", + "text": "也不是我黃國昌說了算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2422.wav", + "text": "我們的憲政民主體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2423.wav", + "text": "要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2424.wav", + "text": "就怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2425.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2426.wav", + "text": "是我們的看法謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2427.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃國昌總召的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2428.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2429.wav", + "text": "按照我們立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2430.wav", + "text": "職權行使法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2431.wav", + "text": "本來就得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2432.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2433.wav", + "text": "我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2434.wav", + "text": "報告代表這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2435.wav", + "text": "發動權還是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2436.wav", + "text": "我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2437.wav", + "text": "也不是總統想來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2438.wav", + "text": "他就可以自己說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2439.wav", + "text": "我要到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2440.wav", + "text": "總統就他職權相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2441.wav", + "text": "國家大政方針得咨請立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2442.wav", + "text": "同意以後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2443.wav", + "text": "他想來也要經過立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2444.wav", + "text": "的也就不要去扯什麼新民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2445.wav", + "text": "舊民意兩個都有民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2446.wav", + "text": "只是兩個人的民意基礎不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2447.wav", + "text": "總統的民意也不會輸給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2448.wav", + "text": "立法委員總統是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2449.wav", + "text": "幾個政黨推派人選所選出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2450.wav", + "text": "立法委員當然民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2451.wav", + "text": "也很深厚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2452.wav", + "text": "問題就是確實按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2453.wav", + "text": "總統確實不是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2454.wav", + "text": "立法委員對總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2455.wav", + "text": "對憲政機關愛怎麼罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2456.wav", + "text": "當然怎麼罵都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2457.wav", + "text": "但是重點來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2458.wav", + "text": "對於總統到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2459.wav", + "text": "立法院來做報告這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2460.wav", + "text": "民眾黨的態度就變開放了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2461.wav", + "text": "\n院長那是不是就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2462.wav", + "text": "第一個憲法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2463.wav", + "text": "還有我們禮拜五那天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2464.wav", + "text": "大家的講法就是總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2465.wav", + "text": "要到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2466.wav", + "text": "三黨都表達歡迎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2467.wav", + "text": "這是第一個就是要來的這件事情就沒話講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2468.wav", + "text": "只是來了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2469.wav", + "text": "這個人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2470.wav", + "text": "到底一個政黨是幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2471.wav", + "text": "順序民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2472.wav", + "text": "他也都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2473.wav", + "text": "時間人家他也沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2474.wav", + "text": "那就看看國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2475.wav", + "text": "我就不曉得國民黨再提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2476.wav", + "text": "我就聽不懂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2477.wav", + "text": "所以大家可以聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2478.wav", + "text": "嘛行政院長是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2479.wav", + "text": "不管你立法院同不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2480.wav", + "text": "行政院都必須要來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2481.wav", + "text": "這本來就必須要來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2482.wav", + "text": "嘛這個絕對不會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2483.wav", + "text": "什麼總統到立法院來報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2484.wav", + "text": "任何一個條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2485.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我們把它分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2486.wav", + "text": "啦行政院長不管如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2487.wav", + "text": "一定要來只是時間我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2488.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣來做大家朝野協商來做一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2489.wav", + "text": "這樣子而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2490.wav", + "text": "嘛所以把這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2491.wav", + "text": "的邏輯確立下來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2492.wav", + "text": "新總統也想來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2493.wav", + "text": "大家認為只要合憲的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2494.wav", + "text": "那就不用在那邊繞來繞去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2495.wav", + "text": "上來就先攻擊對方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2496.wav", + "text": "謝謝莊瑞雄委員精闢的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2497.wav", + "text": "謝謝喔講得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2498.wav", + "text": "\n請傅崐萁總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2499.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2500.wav", + "text": "本席第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2501.wav", + "text": "從提案說明以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2502.wav", + "text": "院長開放給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2503.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2504.wav", + "text": "在大選前表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2505.wav", + "text": "希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2506.wav", + "text": "如果他有機會當選後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2507.wav", + "text": "能夠到國會來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2508.wav", + "text": "依照我們的職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2509.wav", + "text": "也依照憲法增修條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2510.wav", + "text": "第4條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2511.wav", + "text": "我想我們的職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2512.wav", + "text": "已經寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2513.wav", + "text": "剛剛也不斷在聚焦就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2514.wav", + "text": "到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2515.wav", + "text": "我們發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2516.wav", + "text": "有多少時間多少人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2517.wav", + "text": "我們的順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2518.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣政黨比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2519.wav", + "text": "是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2520.wav", + "text": "我想剛剛韓院長針對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2521.wav", + "text": "已經請教各政黨現在算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2522.wav", + "text": "算起來我們從兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2523.wav", + "text": "講到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2524.wav", + "text": "\n我想我們再回到重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2525.wav", + "text": "全國國人對肥皂劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2526.wav", + "text": "已經都沒有興趣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2527.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2528.wav", + "text": "我們接受人民的託付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2529.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2530.wav", + "text": "賴總統當選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2531.wav", + "text": "在賴候選人的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2532.wav", + "text": "就表示他有機會當選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2533.wav", + "text": "來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2534.wav", + "text": "我想國民黨黨團立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2535.wav", + "text": "非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2536.wav", + "text": "我們會友善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2537.wav", + "text": "大格局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2538.wav", + "text": "賴總統到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2539.wav", + "text": "來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2540.wav", + "text": "人數的方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2541.wav", + "text": "我要特別向民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2542.wav", + "text": "的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2543.wav", + "text": "黨團三長來表示敬意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2544.wav", + "text": "他們也表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2545.wav", + "text": "對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2546.wav", + "text": "依照政黨比例他們也沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2547.wav", + "text": "所以我想今天不管是國民黨也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2548.wav", + "text": "民眾黨也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2549.wav", + "text": "都已經再三再三表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2550.wav", + "text": "高度的善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2551.wav", + "text": "我不曉得為什麼這兩個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2552.wav", + "text": "還在原地打轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2553.wav", + "text": "所以也要拜託院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2554.wav", + "text": "我們可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2555.wav", + "text": "在朝野協商上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2556.wav", + "text": "要特別能夠儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2557.wav", + "text": "因為全國國人都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2558.wav", + "text": "我們光一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2559.wav", + "text": "人數以及什麼時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2560.wav", + "text": "討論兩個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2561.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2562.wav", + "text": "很有耐心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2563.wav", + "text": "我們深表敬佩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2564.wav", + "text": "不過我們的格局可能沒有這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2565.wav", + "text": "在這裡坐到實在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2566.wav", + "text": "從提案說明完到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2567.wav", + "text": "第一個階段還沒有進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2568.wav", + "text": "\n到底我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2569.wav", + "text": "人數時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2570.wav", + "text": "院會質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2571.wav", + "text": "我們不要說對院長的質詢是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2572.wav", + "text": "30分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2573.wav", + "text": "專案報告的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2574.wav", + "text": "大概1個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2575.wav", + "text": "是15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2576.wav", + "text": "771還是要992" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2577.wav", + "text": "就講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2578.wav", + "text": "大家希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2579.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2580.wav", + "text": "主要幹部能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2581.wav", + "text": "先請教一下賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2582.wav", + "text": "到底他希望什麼樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2583.wav", + "text": "來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2584.wav", + "text": "瞭解什麼樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2585.wav", + "text": "我們可能在溝通上會快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2586.wav", + "text": "本席現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2587.wav", + "text": "再次地強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2588.wav", + "text": "人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2589.wav", + "text": "發言時間我們現在在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2590.wav", + "text": "院會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2591.wav", + "text": "專案報告是1個委員大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2592.wav", + "text": "15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2593.wav", + "text": "順序的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2594.wav", + "text": "是大黨到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2595.wav", + "text": "小黨還是小黨到大黨都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2596.wav", + "text": "我們不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2597.wav", + "text": "就人數的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2598.wav", + "text": "政黨比例的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2599.wav", + "text": "發言時間的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2600.wav", + "text": "順序的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2601.wav", + "text": "我們大概都有做了意思表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2602.wav", + "text": "不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2603.wav", + "text": "我還是要在這裡講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2604.wav", + "text": "我們不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2605.wav", + "text": "把過去的事情再持續地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2606.wav", + "text": "打轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2607.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2608.wav", + "text": "在2012年的4月9日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2609.wav", + "text": "已經講得很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2610.wav", + "text": "強烈要求即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2611.wav", + "text": "如果今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2612.wav", + "text": "民進黨執政以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2613.wav", + "text": "認為即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2614.wav", + "text": "執政以後就不同意這樣的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2615.wav", + "text": "同樣的民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2616.wav", + "text": "位置的時候就不同樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2617.wav", + "text": "看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2618.wav", + "text": "當然我們也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2619.wav", + "text": "但是總要表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2620.wav", + "text": "到底民進黨現在的立場是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2621.wav", + "text": "看法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2622.wav", + "text": "賴總統當選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2623.wav", + "text": "本身的意願又是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2624.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2625.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜五我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2626.wav", + "text": "做善意溝通的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2627.wav", + "text": "就再三請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2628.wav", + "text": "問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2629.wav", + "text": "賴總統的看法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2630.wav", + "text": "我們才能夠就他的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2631.wav", + "text": "來做實質的討論跟協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2632.wav", + "text": "但是到今天為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2633.wav", + "text": "完全沒有聽到這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2634.wav", + "text": "抑或是也可以先不要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2635.wav", + "text": "賴總統想什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2636.wav", + "text": "把賴總統想什麼變成你們黨團的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2637.wav", + "text": "現在直接講出來也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2638.wav", + "text": "\n但是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2639.wav", + "text": "我們實在是都沒有進度的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2640.wav", + "text": "這樣的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2641.wav", + "text": "到底有什麼樣的實質意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2642.wav", + "text": "全國的國人都在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2643.wav", + "text": "大家要不要寫歷史" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2644.wav", + "text": "今天寫完歷史以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2645.wav", + "text": "像今天我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2646.wav", + "text": "黨團有在講這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2647.wav", + "text": "到底寫了歷史以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2648.wav", + "text": "賴總統是以總統的高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2649.wav", + "text": "這裡每一位都是101十三分之一的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2650.wav", + "text": "我們是見證的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2651.wav", + "text": "我們只是見證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2652.wav", + "text": "而已當然院長高度是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2653.wav", + "text": "但是其他的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2654.wav", + "text": "都是101十三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2655.wav", + "text": "今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2656.wav", + "text": "已經這麼大一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2657.wav", + "text": "要讓賴總統能夠寫下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2658.wav", + "text": "歷史" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2659.wav", + "text": "見證歷史" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2660.wav", + "text": "我現在蠻懷疑的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2661.wav", + "text": "到底民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2662.wav", + "text": "今天是要讓賴總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2663.wav", + "text": "還是不希望賴總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2664.wav", + "text": "是聽不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2665.wav", + "text": "到底是來搭台子還是來砸場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2666.wav", + "text": "我到現在沒有聽懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2667.wav", + "text": "我們花了這麼多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2668.wav", + "text": "所以我真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2669.wav", + "text": "要請院長明示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2670.wav", + "text": "好不好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2671.wav", + "text": "柯總召稍微等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2672.wav", + "text": "麻煩你稍微等一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2673.wav", + "text": "具體地提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2674.wav", + "text": "綜合三個黨團的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2675.wav", + "text": "大家聽聽看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2676.wav", + "text": "這個能不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2677.wav", + "text": "總統如果到院國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2678.wav", + "text": "我們暫定每一個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2679.wav", + "text": "5分鐘時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2680.wav", + "text": "大家有意見回頭可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2681.wav", + "text": "我們政黨比例代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2682.wav", + "text": "992" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2683.wav", + "text": "第三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2684.wav", + "text": "我們依序為台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2685.wav", + "text": "民主進步黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2686.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2687.wav", + "text": "這個都可以調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2688.wav", + "text": "完全沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2689.wav", + "text": "只是我們總是把這幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2690.wav", + "text": "清清楚楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2691.wav", + "text": "拋磚引玉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2692.wav", + "text": "各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2693.wav", + "text": "對我所提出來的有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2694.wav", + "text": "請針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2695.wav", + "text": "我剛所提的這事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2696.wav", + "text": "直接做出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2697.wav", + "text": "其他拜託大家就不要再提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2698.wav", + "text": "謝謝\n請柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2699.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2700.wav", + "text": "我不知道我今天講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2701.wav", + "text": "你有沒有在思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2702.wav", + "text": "剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2703.wav", + "text": "傅總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2704.wav", + "text": "假裝笑得很可愛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2705.wav", + "text": "講了半天我不知道他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2706.wav", + "text": "到底知不知道自己在講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2707.wav", + "text": "包括黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2708.wav", + "text": "也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2709.wav", + "text": "\n我們今天講總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2710.wav", + "text": "你講9925分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2711.wav", + "text": "那是小事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2712.wav", + "text": "重點是他來是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2713.wav", + "text": "即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2714.wav", + "text": "還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2715.wav", + "text": "依照憲法到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2716.wav", + "text": "他得統一回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2717.wav", + "text": "重點在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2718.wav", + "text": "這是一個憲政問題的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2719.wav", + "text": "我不希望是缺一席審判他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2720.wav", + "text": "啦但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2721.wav", + "text": "我只留下一個紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2722.wav", + "text": "我要對各位所言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2723.wav", + "text": "做一些看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2724.wav", + "text": "這個很簡單的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2725.wav", + "text": "都是憲法層次的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2726.wav", + "text": "我們現在是在講憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2727.wav", + "text": "不是說總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2728.wav", + "text": "來的時候他是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2729.wav", + "text": "告這個才重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2730.wav", + "text": "我們可以做違憲性的解釋嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2731.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員既然講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2732.wav", + "text": "憲法合憲違憲是我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2733.wav", + "text": "他認為沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2734.wav", + "text": "我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2735.wav", + "text": "憲法寫得這麼簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2736.wav", + "text": "幾個做很簡單的陳述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2737.wav", + "text": "竟然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2738.wav", + "text": "故意略過故意不聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2739.wav", + "text": "尤其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2740.wav", + "text": "剛才傅崐萁委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2741.wav", + "text": "以及黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2742.wav", + "text": "所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2743.wav", + "text": "過去我主張總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2744.wav", + "text": "做國情報告2012年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2745.wav", + "text": "4月大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2746.wav", + "text": "我一開始就講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2747.wav", + "text": "我們曾經要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2748.wav", + "text": "這個沒有辦法踐行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2749.wav", + "text": "我不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2750.wav", + "text": "2015那一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2751.wav", + "text": "黃國昌故意把它嫁接起來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2752.wav", + "text": "我2012就知道2015的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2753.wav", + "text": "那時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2754.wav", + "text": "不是只有我民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2755.wav", + "text": "親民黨黨團李桐豪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2756.wav", + "text": "共同開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2757.wav", + "text": "針對什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2758.wav", + "text": "針對油電雙漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2759.wav", + "text": "針對禽流感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2760.wav", + "text": "以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2761.wav", + "text": "油價上漲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2762.wav", + "text": "繳費不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2763.wav", + "text": "另外有一個比較爭議性的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2764.wav", + "text": "一國兩區之憲政解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2765.wav", + "text": "這個是當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2766.wav", + "text": "的在野黨聯合開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2767.wav", + "text": "3個黨聯合開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2768.wav", + "text": "當然這是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2769.wav", + "text": "那時候的情況大家做政治攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2770.wav", + "text": "我承認這本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2771.wav", + "text": "這樣一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2772.wav", + "text": "在野黨挑戰執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2773.wav", + "text": "這是天經地義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2774.wav", + "text": "我們今天執政被挑戰也是天經地義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2775.wav", + "text": "的所以不要引喻失義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2776.wav", + "text": "我剛才講的2015" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2777.wav", + "text": "那時候卡在什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2778.wav", + "text": "卡在合憲性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2779.wav", + "text": "這個大家心裡很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2780.wav", + "text": "我並不是要繞圈子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2781.wav", + "text": "我搞不清��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2782.wav", + "text": "你們講的大格局是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2783.wav", + "text": "嘛洪孟楷也這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2784.wav", + "text": "主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2785.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁也這樣主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2786.wav", + "text": "賴士葆也這樣主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2787.wav", + "text": "這個澈底違憲的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2788.wav", + "text": "這是什麼大格局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2789.wav", + "text": "所以我今天要大家面對問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2790.wav", + "text": "來回答問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2791.wav", + "text": "已經修過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2792.wav", + "text": "1997年把後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2793.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2794.wav", + "text": "檢討國是提供建言那一段刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2795.wav", + "text": "2005年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2796.wav", + "text": "我們也把它刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2797.wav", + "text": "了所以就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2798.wav", + "text": "所謂回答的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2799.wav", + "text": "所以希望大家看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2800.wav", + "text": "憲法很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2801.wav", + "text": "院長我一直你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2802.wav", + "text": "跟我謝謝我也不好意思啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2803.wav", + "text": "我是講問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2804.wav", + "text": "你所提的問題你剛才講的那個都是小事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2805.wav", + "text": "那沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2806.wav", + "text": "那個都是小事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2807.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣來踐行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2808.wav", + "text": "是要怎麼回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2809.wav", + "text": "不是統問統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2810.wav", + "text": "那個當然違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2811.wav", + "text": "違憲的部分你講了半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2812.wav", + "text": "請問賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2813.wav", + "text": "大家是禮貌性這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2814.wav", + "text": "我心裡知道這個答案就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2815.wav", + "text": "要在合憲性底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2816.wav", + "text": "所以我想你旁邊那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2817.wav", + "text": "周萬來秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2818.wav", + "text": "應該很強可以稍微回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2819.wav", + "text": "我想聽你的高見好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2820.wav", + "text": "謝謝你喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2821.wav", + "text": "這不是小事喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2822.wav", + "text": "這一定要3個黨團都同意喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2823.wav", + "text": "我們已經花了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2824.wav", + "text": "150分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2825.wav", + "text": "幾個結論這怎麼會是小事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2826.wav", + "text": "院長我講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2827.wav", + "text": "合憲性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2828.wav", + "text": "這個1分鐘就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2829.wav", + "text": "我們先把大家能達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2830.wav", + "text": "民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2831.wav", + "text": "民進黨國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2832.wav", + "text": "的政黨次序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2833.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2834.wav", + "text": "請就這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2835.wav", + "text": "\n吳思瑤幹事長你再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2836.wav", + "text": "麻煩就直接針對這個好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2837.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2838.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得前提性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2839.wav", + "text": "沒有釐清的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2840.wav", + "text": "直接就跳入誰幾分鐘幾分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2841.wav", + "text": "容我要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2842.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛有委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2843.wav", + "text": "2012跟2015的時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2844.wav", + "text": "這個是直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2845.wav", + "text": "不是開玩笑的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2846.wav", + "text": "這是直播不是開玩笑的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2847.wav", + "text": "我就針對2012年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2848.wav", + "text": "總統府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2849.wav", + "text": "馬英九總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2850.wav", + "text": "接受國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2851.wav", + "text": "跟綜合問答的這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2852.wav", + "text": "府方的正式說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2853.wav", + "text": "容我必須把2012年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2854.wav", + "text": "4月26號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2855.wav", + "text": "總統府發言人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2856.wav", + "text": "范姜泰基的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2857.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛有委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2858.wav", + "text": "不容抹謠歷史" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2859.wav", + "text": "總統府范姜泰基發言人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2860.wav", + "text": "代表馬英九前總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2861.wav", + "text": "說國情報告的相關程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2862.wav", + "text": "應由立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2863.wav", + "text": "在符合憲法規定的意旨上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2864.wav", + "text": "依法來協商解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2865.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2866.wav", + "text": "根據憲法的規定與精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2867.wav", + "text": "總統至立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2868.wav", + "text": "發表國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2869.wav", + "text": "不論是一問一答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2870.wav", + "text": "或是綜合問答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2871.wav", + "text": "等等的備詢形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2872.wav", + "text": "都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2873.wav", + "text": "嚴重混淆總統與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2874.wav", + "text": "行政院長之間的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2875.wav", + "text": "分際與權責分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2876.wav", + "text": "一旦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2877.wav", + "text": "馬英九總統接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2878.wav", + "text": "立法委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2879.wav", + "text": "就形同總統對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2880.wav", + "text": "立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2881.wav", + "text": "將違背憲政上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2882.wav", + "text": "明定由行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2883.wav", + "text": "對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2884.wav", + "text": "並備詢之精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2885.wav", + "text": "所以范姜泰基" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2886.wav", + "text": "代表馬英九前總統說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2887.wav", + "text": "若在野黨堅持要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2888.wav", + "text": "一問一答或綜合問答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2889.wav", + "text": "都是創下憲政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2890.wav", + "text": "惡例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2891.wav", + "text": "破壞憲法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2892.wav", + "text": "這是2012年的4月26號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2893.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2894.wav", + "text": "第二個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2895.wav", + "text": "2015年11月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2896.wav", + "text": "又再次討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2897.wav", + "text": "馬前總統要不要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2898.wav", + "text": "立法院國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2899.wav", + "text": "這個時候我們來看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2900.wav", + "text": "當時的立法院院長王金平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2901.wav", + "text": "怎麼說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2902.wav", + "text": "王金平前院長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2903.wav", + "text": "如果立委要上臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2904.wav", + "text": "一問一答將破壞憲政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2905.wav", + "text": "破壞中華民國憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2906.wav", + "text": "增修條文的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2907.wav", + "text": "因為立法院監督的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2908.wav", + "text": "是行政院不是總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2909.wav", + "text": "王金平院長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2910.wav", + "text": "總統不是受國會監督的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2911.wav", + "text": "如果質詢就違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2912.wav", + "text": "我為什麼要講這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2913.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛有委員講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2914.wav", + "text": "2012的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2915.wav", + "text": "然後又跳到2015的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2916.wav", + "text": "完全去脈絡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2917.wav", + "text": "把他對於事實錯誤的理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2918.wav", + "text": "要戴在柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2919.wav", + "text": "民進黨的頭上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2920.wav", + "text": "當然我要還原清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2921.wav", + "text": "我手上這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2922.wav", + "text": "都在司法及法制委員會質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2923.wav", + "text": "清楚提出來過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2924.wav", + "text": "我確實同意幾分鐘幾分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2925.wav", + "text": "那是技術層次的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2926.wav", + "text": "但是到底可不可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2927.wav", + "text": "一問一答或是綜合回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2928.wav", + "text": "用馬英九當年2012的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2929.wav", + "text": "他是認為綜合回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2930.wav", + "text": "也都逾越了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2931.wav", + "text": "總統不對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2932.wav", + "text": "而是行政院對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2933.wav", + "text": "的憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2934.wav", + "text": "這是當時的國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2935.wav", + "text": "馬英九前總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2936.wav", + "text": "\n回過頭來我認為這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2937.wav", + "text": "必須釐清因為大家要如何看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2938.wav", + "text": "大家不要這麼便宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2939.wav", + "text": "行事覺得我們現在敲好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2940.wav", + "text": "一個人5分鐘或15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2941.wav", + "text": "其實落入這個邏輯就等於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2942.wav", + "text": "在場的立法委員認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2943.wav", + "text": "總統必須接受立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2944.wav", + "text": "的詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2945.wav", + "text": "這就違反了憲政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2946.wav", + "text": "所以先要把這個前提講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2947.wav", + "text": "好那總統的回答是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2948.wav", + "text": "時間是什麼不要忘了喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2949.wav", + "text": "過去馬英九前總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2950.wav", + "text": "的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2951.wav", + "text": "那個說法即使是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2952.wav", + "text": "綜合問答他都認為是逾越了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2953.wav", + "text": "憲政的分際所以重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2954.wav", + "text": "在回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2955.wav", + "text": "的部分要怎麼安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2956.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2957.wav", + "text": "你們民進黨三長坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2958.wav", + "text": "就今天總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2959.wav", + "text": "的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2960.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄幹事長講得最大怎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2961.wav", + "text": "麼大為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2962.wav", + "text": "他幾乎完全認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2963.wav", + "text": "請總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2964.wav", + "text": "讓總統創造歷史" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2965.wav", + "text": "另外吳思瑤幹事長我也必須講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2966.wav", + "text": "你說一問一答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2967.wav", + "text": "4個字剛才國民黨民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2968.wav", + "text": "根本沒有提一問一答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2969.wav", + "text": "也不認同為詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2970.wav", + "text": "你現在再把這個問題勾起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2971.wav", + "text": "我們就很難進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2972.wav", + "text": "了因為他們已經講了民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2973.wav", + "text": "還有國民黨剛才都已經講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2974.wav", + "text": "他們尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2975.wav", + "text": "總統最終採取什麼形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2976.wav", + "text": "但是我們先把這三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2977.wav", + "text": "問題釐清時間政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2978.wav", + "text": "分配政黨次序接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2979.wav", + "text": "我們再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2980.wav", + "text": "一問一答還是政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2981.wav", + "text": "問完以後由賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2982.wav", + "text": "總統來答復政黨即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2983.wav", + "text": "一個part一個part的答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2984.wav", + "text": "我們還沒有討論到那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2985.wav", + "text": "你現在不要再把它勾起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2986.wav", + "text": "你勾起來把問題搞複雜了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2987.wav", + "text": "很大氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2988.wav", + "text": "民眾黨跟你們民進黨完全高度共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2989.wav", + "text": "好不好不要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2990.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2991.wav", + "text": "大家看得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2992.wav", + "text": "各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2993.wav", + "text": "我們現在繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2994.wav", + "text": "還有哪一位要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2995.wav", + "text": "請柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2996.wav", + "text": "針對我們剛才講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2997.wav", + "text": "兩個半鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2998.wav", + "text": "所謂執行9個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/2999.wav", + "text": "9個2個一個人5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3000.wav", + "text": "我一直講支端末" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3001.wav", + "text": "現在也答應你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3002.wav", + "text": "從頭到尾都答應你這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3003.wav", + "text": "但前提是要合憲性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3004.wav", + "text": "誤解我們的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3005.wav", + "text": "我講得太清楚我一直跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3006.wav", + "text": "那是最支端末節1分鐘就結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3007.wav", + "text": "我現在就可以答應你我們在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3008.wav", + "text": "都是一樣這個小事啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3009.wav", + "text": "崐萁委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3010.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷剛才也有講三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3011.wav", + "text": "問完三個回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3012.wav", + "text": "這���才不會掛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3013.wav", + "text": "問東答西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3014.wav", + "text": "嘛這個才是問題之所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3015.wav", + "text": "憲法是可以這樣搞嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3016.wav", + "text": "一黨完畢回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3017.wav", + "text": "這個東西很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3018.wav", + "text": "為什麼大家可以鬧了半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3019.wav", + "text": "我一直說我們要針對合憲性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3020.wav", + "text": "不是合憲性的問題來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3021.wav", + "text": "行政院長是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3022.wav", + "text": "對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3023.wav", + "text": "的院長你也知道這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3024.wav", + "text": "個過去當然大家有不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3025.wav", + "text": "看法在野黨去挑戰執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3026.wav", + "text": "但是馬英九也有回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3027.wav", + "text": "這個問題我們都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3028.wav", + "text": "你把過去的事情加在不一樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3029.wav", + "text": "上面我講的是2012那時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3030.wav", + "text": "三個在野黨聯合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3031.wav", + "text": "還有台聯及親民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3032.wav", + "text": "然後針對瘦肉精美牛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3033.wav", + "text": "禽流感油電雙漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3034.wav", + "text": "一國兩區等等很多問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3035.wav", + "text": "馬英九馬英九確實回答說這個是違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3036.wav", + "text": "再一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3037.wav", + "text": "馬習會回來要來立法院報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3038.wav", + "text": "要立法院背書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3039.wav", + "text": "當然是不可能同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3040.wav", + "text": "所以當然出個題目給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3041.wav", + "text": "啊所以黃國昌委員你不要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3042.wav", + "text": "兩個不一樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3043.wav", + "text": "全部攪在一起然後說我會預測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3044.wav", + "text": "2015的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3045.wav", + "text": "這就是大家說話都不老實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3046.wav", + "text": "把事實真相講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3047.wav", + "text": "我從頭到尾都這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3048.wav", + "text": "我過去也主張過但是這個都不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3049.wav", + "text": "嘛大家都知道那是朝野攻防的工具而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3050.wav", + "text": "今天我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3051.wav", + "text": "要面對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3052.wav", + "text": "我再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3053.wav", + "text": "那毫無問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3054.wav", + "text": "前提是什麼來以後要怎麼回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3055.wav", + "text": "那才是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3056.wav", + "text": "嘛講了半天都是在講憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3057.wav", + "text": "難道這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3058.wav", + "text": "東西不重要嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3059.wav", + "text": "我們在憲法底下做事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3060.wav", + "text": "我們要向憲法低頭啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3061.wav", + "text": "哪裡有說那些不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3062.wav", + "text": "那些歷史不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3063.wav", + "text": "啊所以大家不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3064.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3065.wav", + "text": "接下來請洪孟楷書記長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3066.wav", + "text": "想要過來國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3067.wav", + "text": "有一百零個方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3068.wav", + "text": "不想來國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3069.wav", + "text": "有一百零個藉口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3070.wav", + "text": "我想大家都在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3071.wav", + "text": "但到現在還是在講這種空話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3072.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常地遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3073.wav", + "text": "院長剛剛其實講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3074.wav", + "text": "2的政黨比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3075.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常符合現實的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3076.wav", + "text": "也是有所進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3077.wav", + "text": "我們予以敬佩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3078.wav", + "text": "今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3079.wav", + "text": "即便連現在的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3080.wav", + "text": "都是合乎憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3081.wav", + "text": "憲法有規定可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3082.wav", + "text": "邀請總統來國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3083.wav", + "text": "而針對立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3084.wav", + "text": "得就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3085.wav", + "text": "報告不明瞭之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3086.wav", + "text": "提出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3087.wav", + "text": "發言時間人數順序政黨比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3088.wav", + "text": "等事項由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3089.wav", + "text": "決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3090.wav", + "text": "換言之現在此時此刻我們在做的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3091.wav", + "text": "就是合法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3092.wav", + "text": "所以不要再拿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3093.wav", + "text": "不合憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3094.wav", + "text": "違憲來當藉口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3095.wav", + "text": "\n我說實在話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3096.wav", + "text": "剛剛其實黃國昌總召也有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3097.wav", + "text": "我也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3098.wav", + "text": "不順你的意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3099.wav", + "text": "就說別人違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3100.wav", + "text": "扣這種大帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3101.wav", + "text": "過去已經屢屢上演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3102.wav", + "text": "如果我們未來在這個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3103.wav", + "text": "會場裡��有黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3104.wav", + "text": "就沒有什麼好談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3105.wav", + "text": "講出違憲就是要終止這一回合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3106.wav", + "text": "我們大家就表決吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3107.wav", + "text": "我必須要說實在話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3108.wav", + "text": "我們現在在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3109.wav", + "text": "的其實就是創下一個憲政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3110.wav", + "text": "慣例憲政首例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3111.wav", + "text": "如果賴清德總統當選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3112.wav", + "text": "2024年會是中華民國史上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3113.wav", + "text": "很有意義的一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3114.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在就是創下一個例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3115.wav", + "text": "這個例創下之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3116.wav", + "text": "未來歷屆總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3117.wav", + "text": "都會依這個例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3118.wav", + "text": "來做相關的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3119.wav", + "text": "有一天國民黨會執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3120.wav", + "text": "國民黨的總統也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3121.wav", + "text": "要依照今年中華民國113年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3122.wav", + "text": "我們確定的一個例來去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3123.wav", + "text": "所以現在只是看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3124.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統當選人願不願意當第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3125.wav", + "text": "歷史留名的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3126.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3127.wav", + "text": "到底這是賴清德總統不願意面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3128.wav", + "text": "還是今天民進黨的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3129.wav", + "text": "不願意讓賴清德總統面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3130.wav", + "text": "\n所以我最後做一個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3131.wav", + "text": "想搭臺的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3132.wav", + "text": "找方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3133.wav", + "text": "想拆臺的人找藉口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3134.wav", + "text": "我們確實很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3135.wav", + "text": "創下一個憲政首例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3136.wav", + "text": "國民黨身為在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3137.wav", + "text": "但我們負起責任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3138.wav", + "text": "希望能夠讓這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3139.wav", + "text": "歷史留名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3140.wav", + "text": "我們也希望總統在還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3141.wav", + "text": "修憲我們國家到底是雙首長制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3142.wav", + "text": "總統制還是內閣制的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3143.wav", + "text": "現在還是雙首長制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3144.wav", + "text": "但是總統相對權力比較大的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3145.wav", + "text": "總統能夠真正謙卑地來到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3146.wav", + "text": "聽取立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3147.wav", + "text": "給他的一些建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3148.wav", + "text": "並且好好的在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3149.wav", + "text": "回答全國國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3150.wav", + "text": "我想這才是真真正正有意義的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3151.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3152.wav", + "text": "接下來請黃國昌總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3153.wav", + "text": "針對剛剛院長所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3154.wav", + "text": "就是中國國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3155.wav", + "text": "代表9位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3156.wav", + "text": "民主進步黨代表9位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3157.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨代表2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3158.wav", + "text": "我們沒有意見敬表尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3159.wav", + "text": "只不過在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3160.wav", + "text": "發言的時間上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3161.wav", + "text": "提一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3162.wav", + "text": "看能不能夠斟酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3163.wav", + "text": "再予以稍微延長一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3164.wav", + "text": "因為我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3165.wav", + "text": "大概算了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3166.wav", + "text": "如果是20位立法委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3167.wav", + "text": "時間大概是100分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3168.wav", + "text": "100分鐘大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3169.wav", + "text": "是1個小時40分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3170.wav", + "text": "現在的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3171.wav", + "text": "大概是僅用半天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3172.wav", + "text": "或者是一天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3173.wav", + "text": "來處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3174.wav", + "text": "但基於對總統的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3175.wav", + "text": "多給總統一些發言的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3176.wav", + "text": "我覺得是必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3177.wav", + "text": "而且是合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3178.wav", + "text": "接下來綜合答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3179.wav", + "text": "的一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3180.wav", + "text": "或者是你要把它稱為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3181.wav", + "text": "補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3182.wav", + "text": "也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3183.wav", + "text": "不管是綜合答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3184.wav", + "text": "還是綜合補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3185.wav", + "text": "都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3186.wav", + "text": "來規劃整個國情報告的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3187.wav", + "text": "如果是歷史上面的第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3188.wav", + "text": "我覺得立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3189.wav", + "text": "花一天的時間來做這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3190.wav", + "text": "絕對是全體國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3191.wav", + "text": "大家可以期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3192.wav", + "text": "也樂於看到的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3193.wav", + "text": "因此在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3194.wav", + "text": "我會認為是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3195.wav", + "text": "委員發言的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3196.wav", + "text": "可以酌度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3197.wav", + "text": "予以延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3198.wav", + "text": "譬如說每位委員發言的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3199.wav", + "text": "我們算20位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3200.wav", + "text": "大概就2個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3201.wav", + "text": "又多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3202.wav", + "text": "進行報告的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3203.wav", + "text": "以及接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3204.wav", + "text": "答復的形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3205.wav", + "text": "這件事情我們到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3206.wav", + "text": "還沒有協商到那個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3207.wav", + "text": "不管是剛剛中國國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3208.wav", + "text": "所提出來的不管是3位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3209.wav", + "text": "還是5位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3210.wav", + "text": "或者是我們曾經建議過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3211.wav", + "text": "一個黨團講完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3212.wav", + "text": "再來換另外一個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3213.wav", + "text": "算一算我覺得一整天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3214.wav", + "text": "這樣下來應該都是足夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3215.wav", + "text": "這樣子的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3216.wav", + "text": "以上提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3217.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3218.wav", + "text": "我嘗試性宣告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3219.wav", + "text": "你們能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3220.wav", + "text": "我想後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3221.wav", + "text": "發言可能跟我想法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3222.wav", + "text": "一致的話就不用再繼續發言了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3223.wav", + "text": "我先很具體地唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3224.wav", + "text": "各黨團針對國情報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3225.wav", + "text": "協商意見初步意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3226.wav", + "text": "未來總統至本院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3227.wav", + "text": "進行國情報告時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3228.wav", + "text": "於總統國情報告後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3229.wav", + "text": "由本院各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3230.wav", + "text": "推派代表發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3231.wav", + "text": "每位委員發言時間為5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3232.wav", + "text": "這個點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3233.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召希望延長一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3234.wav", + "text": "點到7分鐘請問民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3235.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3236.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3237.wav", + "text": "5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3238.wav", + "text": "請問國民黨團有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3239.wav", + "text": "5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3240.wav", + "text": "如果7分鐘的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3241.wav", + "text": "是比較符合我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3242.wav", + "text": "所有委員在過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3243.wav", + "text": "所提出問題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3244.wav", + "text": "在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3245.wav", + "text": "不管是在委員會也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3246.wav", + "text": "在院會也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3247.wav", + "text": "一般來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3248.wav", + "text": "起碼都78分鐘以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3249.wav", + "text": "因為這些發言都沒有影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3250.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3251.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這個應該跟賴總統之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3252.wav", + "text": "他不會有任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3253.wav", + "text": "其他額外的包袱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3254.wav", + "text": "都不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3255.wav", + "text": "因為這是委員之間的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3256.wav", + "text": "所以我想我們就修正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3257.wav", + "text": "7分好沒關係我再繼續唸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3258.wav", + "text": "發言人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3259.wav", + "text": "國民黨9人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3260.wav", + "text": "民進黨9人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3261.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨2人進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3262.wav", + "text": "發言的順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3263.wav", + "text": "一台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3264.wav", + "text": "民進黨國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3265.wav", + "text": "依順序進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3266.wav", + "text": "二至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3267.wav", + "text": "詢答的方式我們繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3268.wav", + "text": "國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3269.wav", + "text": "仍然列入本週四的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3270.wav", + "text": "協商主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3271.wav", + "text": "柯總召這一點完全沒有違憲問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3272.wav", + "text": "請放心第三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3273.wav", + "text": "新任的行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3274.wav", + "text": "施政方針報告以及本院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3275.wav", + "text": "配合延會相關事情的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3276.wav", + "text": "第四點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3277.wav", + "text": "法案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3278.wav", + "text": "一樣列入本週四下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3279.wav", + "text": "再協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3280.wav", + "text": "請問各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3281.wav", + "text": "黨團幹部有意見嗎請簡短扼要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3282.wav", + "text": "5分鐘跟7分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3283.wav", + "text": "就只有這一個點有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3284.wav", + "text": "那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3285.wav", + "text": "5分鐘7分鐘我們禮拜四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3286.wav", + "text": "再來共同討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3287.wav", + "text": "好不好還是我就直接現在折衷6分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3288.wav", + "text": "政治是妥協的藝術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3289.wav", + "text": "好不好直接折衷6分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3290.wav", + "text": "這個事情時間就不要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3291.wav", + "text": "發言請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3292.wav", + "text": "我每次都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3293.wav", + "text": "短話短說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3294.wav", + "text": "只有柯總召是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3295.wav", + "text": "短話長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3296.wav", + "text": "我是講道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3297.wav", + "text": "我想要特別再強調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3298.wav", + "text": "我想我們今天協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3299.wav", + "text": "不是論斤計兩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3300.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是一個很神聖的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3301.wav", + "text": "事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3302.wav", + "text": "但是我想今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3303.wav", + "text": "柯總召把整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3304.wav", + "text": "場已經攪成這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3305.wav", + "text": "了我覺得我們把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3306.wav", + "text": "給賴總統一個歷史的定位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3307.wav", + "text": "已經被攪成這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3308.wav", + "text": "我覺得滿可惜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3309.wav", + "text": "這一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3310.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3311.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統當選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3312.wav", + "text": "在歷史上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3313.wav", + "text": "一個非常清楚的定位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3314.wav", + "text": "但是不是像菜市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3315.wav", + "text": "裡面論斤論量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3316.wav", + "text": "還有一個更重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3317.wav", + "text": "如果民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3318.wav", + "text": "要設這麼多但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3319.wav", + "text": "我比較好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3320.wav", + "text": "我只問一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3321.wav", + "text": "到底是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3322.wav", + "text": "賴總統本人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3323.wav", + "text": "想法和決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3324.wav", + "text": "還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3325.wav", + "text": "柯總召自己的想法和決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3326.wav", + "text": "這個必須要跟大家講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3327.wav", + "text": "因為是他個人的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3328.wav", + "text": "還是賴總統的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3329.wav", + "text": "賴總統的想法我們儘量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3330.wav", + "text": "敬予尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3331.wav", + "text": "所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3332.wav", + "text": "在這裡花了3個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3333.wav", + "text": "講到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3334.wav", + "text": "我們還是不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3335.wav", + "text": "因為上個禮拜五已經講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3336.wav", + "text": "請柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3337.wav", + "text": "回去詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3338.wav", + "text": "賴總統的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3339.wav", + "text": "是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3340.wav", + "text": "我們都表達高度善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3341.wav", + "text": "請告訴我們到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3342.wav", + "text": "我們儘可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3343.wav", + "text": "來配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3344.wav", + "text": "講得非常善意也非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3345.wav", + "text": "大氣我們講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3346.wav", + "text": "\n但今天3個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3347.wav", + "text": "一直在繞憲政問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3348.wav", + "text": "第4條第3項講得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3349.wav", + "text": "很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3350.wav", + "text": "再過來立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3351.wav", + "text": "97年就修了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3352.wav", + "text": "也不是今年國民黨來修的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3353.wav", + "text": "第十五條就寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3354.wav", + "text": "那為什麼今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3355.wav", + "text": "在這個問題不斷地用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3356.wav", + "text": "所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3357.wav", + "text": "違憲違憲違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3358.wav", + "text": "我要再強調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3359.wav", + "text": "這個東西在立法院是很糟糕的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3360.wav", + "text": "不能變成一個口頭禪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3361.wav", + "text": "立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3362.wav", + "text": "依法執行職務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3363.wav", + "text": "不是哪一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3364.wav", + "text": "可以在這裡糾正所有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3365.wav", + "text": "說有沒有違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3366.wav", + "text": "有沒有違憲是大法官做的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3367.wav", + "text": "而且還不是一個大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3368.wav", + "text": "做的還要憲法法庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3369.wav", + "text": "來做決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3370.wav", + "text": "但是現在已經變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3371.wav", + "text": "立法院濫用為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3372.wav", + "text": "第一名的代名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3373.wav", + "text": "連這麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3374.wav", + "text": "莊嚴的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3375.wav", + "text": "都空轉了3個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3376.wav", + "text": "這個是我們不能接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3377.wav", + "text": "為什麼一個這麼嚴肅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3378.wav", + "text": "問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3379.wav", + "text": "誰能夠代表憲法在這裡講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3380.wav", + "text": "\n這裡沒有一個人有資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3381.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3382.wav", + "text": "要再一次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3383.wav", + "text": "到底是誰的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3384.wav", + "text": "因為上個禮拜五講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3385.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3386.wav", + "text": "還是賴總統的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3387.wav", + "text": "讓我們瞭解清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3388.wav", + "text": "至少我們對內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3389.wav", + "text": "我們黨團成員也會問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3390.wav", + "text": "為什麼是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3391.wav", + "text": "我要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3392.wav", + "text": "賴總統的意思是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3393.wav", + "text": "大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3394.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3395.wav", + "text": "是自命為大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3396.wav", + "text": "常駐在這裡天天發號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3397.wav", + "text": "施令的人講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3398.wav", + "text": "我要搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3399.wav", + "text": "嘛但到今天為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3400.wav", + "text": "轉了3個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3401.wav", + "text": "這個事情都沒有明確化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3402.wav", + "text": "所以抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3403.wav", + "text": "因為當時也在院長室大家談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3404.wav", + "text": "都還沒有清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3405.wav", + "text": "真的有必要讓大家搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3406.wav", + "text": "如果堅持是賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3407.wav", + "text": "他的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3408.wav", + "text": "我們會用最大的格局和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3409.wav", + "text": "看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3410.wav", + "text": "來做整體的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3411.wav", + "text": "但這要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3412.wav", + "text": "好不好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3413.wav", + "text": "來我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3414.wav", + "text": "請莊委員發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3415.wav", + "text": "我再講一次啦民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3416.wav", + "text": "我們三長的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3417.wav", + "text": "其實是一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3418.wav", + "text": "的傅總召也沒有必要那麼多情緒上的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3419.wav", + "text": "總統要到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3420.wav", + "text": "有二個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3421.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3422.wav", + "text": "我們四分之一的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3423.wav", + "text": "然後院會做決議以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3424.wav", + "text": "可以邀請總統到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3425.wav", + "text": "是立法院想要他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3426.wav", + "text": "第二個總統想來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3427.wav", + "text": "他也可以咨請立法院同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3428.wav", + "text": "就���兩個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3429.wav", + "text": "總統也想來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3430.wav", + "text": "立法院也想要他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3431.wav", + "text": "那這就好事了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3432.wav", + "text": "嘛不管是哪一種都很好安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3433.wav", + "text": "本來進行到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3434.wav", + "text": "就是當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3435.wav", + "text": "賴總統假設到了立法院以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3436.wav", + "text": "他先講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3437.wav", + "text": "嘛他做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3438.wav", + "text": "嘛他報告完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3439.wav", + "text": "各黨團就像剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3440.wav", + "text": "剛院長講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3441.wav", + "text": "民進黨幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3442.wav", + "text": "民眾黨幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3443.wav", + "text": "大家派比例來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3444.wav", + "text": "有不明瞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3445.wav", + "text": "我也可以講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3446.wav", + "text": "你這個國政大方針很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3447.wav", + "text": "啊該往哪個方向去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3448.wav", + "text": "立法委員愛怎麼講這個其實也沒辦法去限制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3449.wav", + "text": "管你明不明瞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3450.wav", + "text": "就算很明瞭我也想繼續問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3451.wav", + "text": "你說太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3452.wav", + "text": "像我講的那一天看到你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3453.wav", + "text": "啊那個東西好不好吃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3454.wav", + "text": "總統會覺得你很無聊你問我這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3455.wav", + "text": "但他想不想回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3456.wav", + "text": "就在於他了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3457.wav", + "text": "明不明瞭就在於他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3458.wav", + "text": "了所以我倒覺得剛剛院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3459.wav", + "text": "你那個裁示如果大家沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3460.wav", + "text": "這個部分大家就先有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3461.wav", + "text": "了其他的方式如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3462.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3463.wav", + "text": "我會回答很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3464.wav", + "text": "傅總召難得開金口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3465.wav", + "text": "每次開金口他都在我前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3466.wav", + "text": "我都仔細聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3467.wav", + "text": "我都不知道他在講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3468.wav", + "text": "他說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3469.wav", + "text": "毫無但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3470.wav", + "text": "只是在合憲性底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3471.wav", + "text": "你也會講到憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3472.wav", + "text": "權行使法是寫是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3473.wav", + "text": "權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3474.wav", + "text": "是誰在論斤論兩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3475.wav", + "text": "院長裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3476.wav", + "text": "嗎所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3477.wav", + "text": "要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3478.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3479.wav", + "text": "其實我很坦白告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3480.wav", + "text": "他早就在媒體講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3481.wav", + "text": "只要合憲合法他一定來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3482.wav", + "text": "這再清楚不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3483.wav", + "text": "嘛所以那天你們說問賴總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3484.wav", + "text": "我知道答案是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3485.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員提出你也提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3486.wav", + "text": "表示很尊重大家的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3487.wav", + "text": "一定是好啊我去瞭解看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3488.wav", + "text": "因為我知道這個要朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3489.wav", + "text": "還有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3490.wav", + "text": "大家都有講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3491.wav", + "text": "他有說要來即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3492.wav", + "text": "嗎沒有這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3493.wav", + "text": "情是合憲合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3494.wav", + "text": "嘛所以這一點請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3495.wav", + "text": "既然傅總召講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3496.wav", + "text": "只要賴總統講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3497.wav", + "text": "我們就敬表同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3498.wav", + "text": "是合憲合法就沒有即問即答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3499.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼統問統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3500.wav", + "text": "你們要不要同意答案就出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3501.wav", + "text": "我一直講說那是最簡單的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3502.wav", + "text": "1分鐘就解決了沒什麼好爭辯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3503.wav", + "text": "我們講了半天3個鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3504.wav", + "text": "了都在講憲法層次的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3505.wav", + "text": "大家迴避問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3506.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3507.wav", + "text": "你現在認為合憲沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3508.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3509.wav", + "text": "我要特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3510.wav", + "text": "因為剛才莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3511.wav", + "text": "他講得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3512.wav", + "text": "我非常贊同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3513.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄委員剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3514.wav", + "text": "我現在再提醒一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3515.wav", + "text": "但是99220個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3516.wav", + "text": "9個人9個人發言完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3517.wav", + "text": "這樣子可能時間很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3518.wav", + "text": "冗長所以我建議請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3519.wav", + "text": "每5個人或4個人發言完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3520.wav", + "text": "提問之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3521.wav", + "text": "我們的總統就來做一次回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3522.wav", + "text": "不用全部20個人講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3523.wav", + "text": "他來做回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3524.wav", + "text": "我先提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3525.wav", + "text": "啦我們星期四可以再做協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3526.wav", + "text": "另外就是總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3527.wav", + "text": "要怎麼回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3528.wav", + "text": "我想剛才莊瑞雄委員也講得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3529.wav", + "text": "這個就是立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3530.wav", + "text": "就是我們對不明瞭之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3531.wav", + "text": "總統他自己會去做一個選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3532.wav", + "text": "所以這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3533.wav", + "text": "職權行使法都規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3534.wav", + "text": "了我不曉得你們還在擔心什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3535.wav", + "text": "所以我想就依照職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3536.wav", + "text": "來做啦OK好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3537.wav", + "text": "主席來決定好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3538.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3539.wav", + "text": "發言吳思瑤委員請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3540.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3541.wav", + "text": "我們上個星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3542.wav", + "text": "在院長的召集之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3543.wav", + "text": "黨團彼此之間交換的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3544.wav", + "text": "我想在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3545.wav", + "text": "院長也聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3546.wav", + "text": "我那時候其實有提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3547.wav", + "text": "AB兩個可能的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3548.wav", + "text": "一個是一個立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3549.wav", + "text": "發表完他的看法以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3550.wav", + "text": "總統就可以回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3551.wav", + "text": "B案是一個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3552.wav", + "text": "發表他的看法以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3553.wav", + "text": "總統就可以回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3554.wav", + "text": "那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3555.wav", + "text": "民進黨的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3556.wav", + "text": "是怎麼說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3557.wav", + "text": "我相信坐在這邊的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3558.wav", + "text": "大家的記憶都歷歷在目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3559.wav", + "text": "結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3560.wav", + "text": "剛剛聽柯建銘那樣的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3561.wav", + "text": "似乎是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3562.wav", + "text": "他上個禮拜五告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3563.wav", + "text": "說他要帶回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3564.wav", + "text": "請問一下賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3565.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3566.wav", + "text": "顯然從頭到尾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3567.wav", + "text": "就是在講空話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3568.wav", + "text": "從頭到尾就是在講空話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3569.wav", + "text": "我們那天坐在那邊談得很具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3570.wav", + "text": "A案跟B案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3571.wav", + "text": "他說他也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3572.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統怎麼想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3573.wav", + "text": "他要帶回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3574.wav", + "text": "再問一下結果今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3575.wav", + "text": "坐在這邊又說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3576.wav", + "text": "只要合憲就願意來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3577.wav", + "text": "我們把問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3578.wav", + "text": "從試圖要具體化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3579.wav", + "text": "又拉回去抽象化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3580.wav", + "text": "我必須要再一次的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3581.wav", + "text": "基於對韓院長的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3582.wav", + "text": "那一天您召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3583.wav", + "text": "在您的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3584.wav", + "text": "辦公室裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3585.wav", + "text": "不是進行正式的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3586.wav", + "text": "是在進行意見交換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3587.wav", + "text": "我們其實也去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3588.wav", + "text": "那樣子的意見交換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3589.wav", + "text": "並不是不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3590.wav", + "text": "但你沒有留下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3591.wav", + "text": "到時候出來大家就各說各話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3592.wav", + "text": "本來應該是很清楚的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3593.wav", + "text": "都可以搞成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3594.wav", + "text": "像羅生門一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3595.wav", + "text": "我覺得真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3596.wav", + "text": "會讓人覺得非常地遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3597.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3598.wav", + "text": "目前我們在進行的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3599.wav", + "text": "顯然就不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3600.wav", + "text": "依照憲法增修條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3601.wav", + "text": "在進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3602.wav", + "text": "因為憲法增修條文第4條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3603.wav", + "text": "已經把它具體化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3604.wav", + "text": "所以我們一直在進行的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3605.wav", + "text": "其實都是按照目前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3606.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3607.wav", + "text": "第十五條之4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3608.wav", + "text": "我們依法論法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3609.wav", + "text": "以目前現行的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3610.wav", + "text": "就委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3611.wav", + "text": "總統同意可以綜合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3612.wav", + "text": "再做補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3613.wav", + "text": "委員可以發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3614.wav", + "text": "要不要同意綜合補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3615.wav", + "text": "總統不做綜合補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3616.wav", + "text": "我們也不能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3617.wav", + "text": "總統違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3618.wav", + "text": "\n我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3619.wav", + "text": "立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3620.wav", + "text": "有立法院自己的主體性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3621.wav", + "text": "譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3622.wav", + "text": "我們今天做了一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3623.wav", + "text": "還是1個黨團的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3624.wav", + "text": "發言完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3625.wav", + "text": "提出了問題以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3626.wav", + "text": "我們把規矩設下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3627.wav", + "text": "我們邀請總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3628.wav", + "text": "請他來回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3629.wav", + "text": "那總統說我不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3630.wav", + "text": "我不想回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3631.wav", + "text": "我想不管是本院任何一位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3632.wav", + "text": "乃至於院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3633.wav", + "text": "恐怕都沒有辦法強迫總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3634.wav", + "text": "但問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3635.wav", + "text": "總統同意或不同意這一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3636.wav", + "text": "我們何必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3637.wav", + "text": "預先做決定呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3638.wav", + "text": "最後立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3639.wav", + "text": "按照民主程序所設定的規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3640.wav", + "text": "三位立委講完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3641.wav", + "text": "我們希望總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3642.wav", + "text": "能夠綜合地來做補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3643.wav", + "text": "不願意我們最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3644.wav", + "text": "也只能尊重總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3645.wav", + "text": "因為假設我們適用的是現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3646.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3647.wav", + "text": "那總統表示我不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3648.wav", + "text": "我相信以院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3649.wav", + "text": "的高度在主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3650.wav", + "text": "議事您也一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3651.wav", + "text": "尊重總統你不會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3652.wav", + "text": "我不同意你不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3653.wav", + "text": "嘛因為他只要不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3654.wav", + "text": "他就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3655.wav", + "text": "需要針對回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3656.wav", + "text": "\n但是我覺得我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3657.wav", + "text": "邀請總統來立法院有自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3658.wav", + "text": "的主體性我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3659.wav", + "text": "能夠落實整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3660.wav", + "text": "人民對於立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3661.wav", + "text": "這一次進行國情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3662.wav", + "text": "報告的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3663.wav", + "text": "在現行的法律架構下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3664.wav", + "text": "我們本來就可以邀請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3665.wav", + "text": "總統來也可以邀請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3666.wav", + "text": "他針對立法委員所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3667.wav", + "text": "出來的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3668.wav", + "text": "補充報告不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3669.wav", + "text": "今天是3位5位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3670.wav", + "text": "1個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3671.wav", + "text": "還是到最後的統問統答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3672.wav", + "text": "這個是我們立法院自己可以決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3673.wav", + "text": "我們決定了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3674.wav", + "text": "總統同意或不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3675.wav", + "text": "我們依照現行法就是要尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3676.wav", + "text": "個人對於目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3677.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3678.wav", + "text": "在維持國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3679.wav", + "text": "的尊嚴跟主體性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3680.wav", + "text": "方面我自己所做出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3681.wav", + "text": "看法也提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3682.wav", + "text": "給院長做參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3683.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3684.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3685.wav", + "text": "事實上點出了很重要的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3686.wav", + "text": "稍微等一下請吳思瑤委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3687.wav", + "text": "今天花了三個多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3688.wav", + "text": "小時的時間在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3689.wav", + "text": "討論也許有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3690.wav", + "text": "野黨委員覺得思瑤的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3691.wav", + "text": "或總召的發言讓大家覺得聽得很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3692.wav", + "text": "煩很膩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3693.wav", + "text": "但我覺得這個討論都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3694.wav", + "text": "有意義的因為我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3695.wav", + "text": "創造第一次臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3696.wav", + "text": "憲政的好的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3697.wav", + "text": "所以我們都想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3698.wav", + "text": "成就這個美事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3699.wav", + "text": "我們都想要把這個台搭的好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3700.wav", + "text": "搭的穩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3701.wav", + "text": "所以沒有人要拆台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3702.wav", + "text": "沒有人要毀掉這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3703.wav", + "text": "反而是欲速則不達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3704.wav", + "text": "我一直是非常正向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3705.wav", + "text": "在看待在這樣的討論裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3706.wav", + "text": "讓我們對於憲政的精神也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3707.wav", + "text": "職權行使法的實踐也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3708.wav", + "text": "都有更進一步的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3709.wav", + "text": "\n我認為到今天到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3710.wav", + "text": "此時此刻9比9比2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3711.wav", + "text": "每位6分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3712.wav", + "text": "這是我們往前推進了一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3713.wav", + "text": "這個共識的凝聚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3714.wav", + "text": "也是一步一步這樣爭論而來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3715.wav", + "text": "我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3716.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長讓我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3717.wav", + "text": "定在這裡我們週四可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3718.wav", + "text": "繼續針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3719.wav", + "text": "問的問題已經沒有問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3720.wav", + "text": "就是答的方式跟時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3721.wav", + "text": "大家可以冷靜都再回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3722.wav", + "text": "好好地思考看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3723.wav", + "text": "\n我花了這麼多時間論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3724.wav", + "text": "就是回到憲法的本文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3725.wav", + "text": "跟職權行使法的文義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3726.wav", + "text": "基本上總統來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3727.wav", + "text": "他接受的是大家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3728.wav", + "text": "詢問而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3729.wav", + "text": "質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3730.wav", + "text": "提問而不是質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3731.wav", + "text": "或者是詢問因為職權行使法的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3732.wav", + "text": "是詢問而不是質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3733.wav", + "text": "我要一直論述的是這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3734.wav", + "text": "所以這會回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3735.wav", + "text": "我們如果下週四要去決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3736.wav", + "text": "是幾個完之後回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3737.wav", + "text": "或者是全部一起回答請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3738.wav", + "text": "扣合著這個精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3739.wav", + "text": "總統來他不是備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3740.wav", + "text": "他不是質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3741.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3742.wav", + "text": "\n請尊重我的發言好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3743.wav", + "text": "大家都耐著性子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3744.wav", + "text": "我也不是沒有個性好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3745.wav", + "text": "但是我願意在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3746.wav", + "text": "耐著性子一再講一再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3747.wav", + "text": "讓大家能夠把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3748.wav", + "text": "這個東西融會貫通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3749.wav", + "text": "形而上者謂之道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3750.wav", + "text": "我們在處理的��道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3751.wav", + "text": "跟器並用的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3752.wav", + "text": "它需要花時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3753.wav", + "text": "所以我還是認為這個討論非常正向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3754.wav", + "text": "我非常appreciate" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3755.wav", + "text": "今天大家坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3756.wav", + "text": "但是不要在這邊繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3757.wav", + "text": "沒有人拆台好嗎洪委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3758.wav", + "text": "我們都在成就這個好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3759.wav", + "text": "把台搭好把台搭穩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3760.wav", + "text": "我們已經往前推進一步了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3761.wav", + "text": "我們也都接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3762.wav", + "text": "9比9比2的6分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3763.wav", + "text": "至於答的部分我們大家好好思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3764.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3765.wav", + "text": "順著剛才吳思瑤委員講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3766.wav", + "text": "我們絕沒有拖延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3767.wav", + "text": "讓賴總統能夠來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3768.wav", + "text": "這是一個新的里程碑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3769.wav", + "text": "但是剛剛黃國昌講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3770.wav", + "text": "包括各位講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3771.wav", + "text": "我一直在繞來繞去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3772.wav", + "text": "說我好像沒有在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3773.wav", + "text": "你說要一問一答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3774.wav", + "text": "或是黨問黨答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3775.wav", + "text": "這不是質詢嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3776.wav", + "text": "這不是質詢嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3777.wav", + "text": "然後你說那天沒有語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3778.wav", + "text": "語言記錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3779.wav", + "text": "那天沒有錄音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3780.wav", + "text": "我知道你最反對密室協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3781.wav", + "text": "但是你常常進行密室協商就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3782.wav", + "text": "這個不計較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3783.wav", + "text": "提了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3784.wav", + "text": "他有提到問題我才回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3785.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3786.wav", + "text": "當他問我我當然是禮貌上說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3787.wav", + "text": "也講說我一定問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3788.wav", + "text": "我當然禮貌上都會回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3789.wav", + "text": "難道我當天就在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3790.wav", + "text": "沒有直播的地方跟你們吵架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3791.wav", + "text": "不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3792.wav", + "text": "天氣氛還不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3793.wav", + "text": "我知道賴總統在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3794.wav", + "text": "媒體上講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3795.wav", + "text": "當然我跟你們吵架也不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3796.wav", + "text": "黃國昌委員剛才又是迴避問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3797.wav", + "text": "又是講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3798.wav", + "text": "他要來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3799.wav", + "text": "決定就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3800.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3801.wav", + "text": "後面的形式我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3802.wav", + "text": "那會造成憲政衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3803.wav", + "text": "吧你把一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3804.wav", + "text": "憲法問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3805.wav", + "text": "這是迴避問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3806.wav", + "text": "他來難道立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3807.wav", + "text": "來決定就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3808.wav", + "text": "假如你們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3809.wav", + "text": "他不要的話是不是憲政衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3810.wav", + "text": "這個大家要講好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3811.wav", + "text": "我們不是讓他來製造憲政衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3812.wav", + "text": "這是歷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3813.wav", + "text": "歷史的里程碑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3814.wav", + "text": "是用這種心情去看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3815.wav", + "text": "講了半天還是在憲法的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3816.wav", + "text": "大家迴避憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3817.wav", + "text": "然後又繞了半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3818.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3819.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位黨團幹部大家真的非常地辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3820.wav", + "text": "再一次感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3821.wav", + "text": "事實上那一天我們講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3822.wav", + "text": "禮拜四我們要再協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3823.wav", + "text": "應該是有3個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3824.wav", + "text": "第二個政黨問完總統回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3825.wav", + "text": "第三個全部問完以後總統做一個統一的回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3826.wav", + "text": "大致上禮拜四下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15906/3827.wav", + "text": "我們可以討論這個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/0.wav", + "text": "連續幾次朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1.wav", + "text": "大家都曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2.wav", + "text": "氣氛不是很融洽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/4.wav", + "text": "第一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/5.wav", + "text": "朝野協商發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/6.wav", + "text": "我們會計時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/7.wav", + "text": "一次發言5分鐘為限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/8.wav", + "text": "發言完畢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/9.wav", + "text": "其他黨團幹部要發言的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/10.wav", + "text": "主席會裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/11.wav", + "text": "請5分鐘一到時間就自動停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/12.wav", + "text": "如果要再發言的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/13.wav", + "text": "可以徵求二次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/14.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/15.wav", + "text": "發言時間請問各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/16.wav", + "text": "同意不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/17.wav", + "text": "我一個一個來因為好多喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/18.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/19.wav", + "text": "5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/20.wav", + "text": "我們試試看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/21.wav", + "text": "發言的時間限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/22.wav", + "text": "以及次數限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/23.wav", + "text": "議事規則也都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/24.wav", + "text": "假如沒有辦法說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/25.wav", + "text": "院會只有發言一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/26.wav", + "text": "以及在討論法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/27.wav", + "text": "都沒有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/28.wav", + "text": "和次數限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/29.wav", + "text": "所以主席要斟酌一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/30.wav", + "text": "不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/31.wav", + "text": "這麼久以來的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/32.wav", + "text": "我認為主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/33.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/34.wav", + "text": "柯總召的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/35.wav", + "text": "但是我想對於發言的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/36.wav", + "text": "發言的內容我們依序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/37.wav", + "text": "一點一滴我的觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/38.wav", + "text": "我的憂心還有大家輿情的反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/39.wav", + "text": "我們就試試看我們第一次發言5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/40.wav", + "text": "時間到了暫停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/41.wav", + "text": "等其他人發言二次發言再舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/42.wav", + "text": "我覺得用這種方式的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/43.wav", + "text": "可能可以讓會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/44.wav", + "text": "進行的效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/45.wav", + "text": "提高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/46.wav", + "text": "而且劍拔弩張的氛圍可以降低一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/47.wav", + "text": "你要裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/48.wav", + "text": "坦白講這不是院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/49.wav", + "text": "裁示的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/50.wav", + "text": "對我我的看法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/51.wav", + "text": "你裁示了5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/52.wav", + "text": "目前暫時還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/53.wav", + "text": "嘛將來修正再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/54.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/55.wav", + "text": "我們先試試看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/56.wav", + "text": "很多事情要重新建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/57.wav", + "text": "因為要試試看所以大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/58.wav", + "text": "現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/59.wav", + "text": "議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/60.wav", + "text": "給你弄很多遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/61.wav", + "text": "包括上禮拜我們朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/62.wav", + "text": "幾個決議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/63.wav", + "text": "協商完畢以後要簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/64.wav", + "text": "拿出來簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/65.wav", + "text": "我不知道議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/66.wav", + "text": "怎麼搞的沒有拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/67.wav", + "text": "後來孟楷來跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/68.wav", + "text": "我說沒有關係這個我們要予以解套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/69.wav", + "text": "補簽好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/70.wav", + "text": "過去協商完畢一定是院長唸完協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/71.wav", + "text": "有的不簽跑掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/72.wav", + "text": "所以這個是一個民主程序的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/73.wav", + "text": "議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/74.wav", + "text": "非常瞭解遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/75.wav", + "text": "周秘書長也非常瞭解遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/76.wav", + "text": "怎麼會沒有講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/77.wav", + "text": "然後協商完畢以後跑掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/78.wav", + "text": "過去這種協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/79.wav", + "text": "商是無效的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/80.wav", + "text": "一定要簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/81.wav", + "text": "大部分都能夠解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/82.wav", + "text": "尤其本會期開始大家對立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/83.wav", + "text": "法院憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/84.wav", + "text": "不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/85.wav", + "text": "我在這裡一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/86.wav", + "text": "我認為是違法違憲的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/87.wav", + "text": "大家都會攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/88.wav", + "text": "這個房間裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/89.wav", + "text": "攻防的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/90.wav", + "text": "我先把話講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/91.wav", + "text": "不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/92.wav", + "text": "立法院要踐行民主程序這很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/93.wav", + "text": "沒有程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/94.wav", + "text": "就沒有實質正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/95.wav", + "text": "一些遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/96.wav", + "text": "臺式國會多數暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/97.wav", + "text": "好謝謝柯總召善意提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/98.wav", + "text": "我們第一個如果各黨團沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/99.wav", + "text": "我們就試試看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/100.wav", + "text": "新的民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/101.wav", + "text": "在這個會期正式展開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/102.wav", + "text": "我想國瑜院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/103.wav", + "text": "所帶領的立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/104.wav", + "text": "是要讓國人耳目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/105.wav", + "text": "過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/106.wav", + "text": "漫無目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/107.wav", + "text": "如同菜市場一般的雜亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/108.wav", + "text": "我想不再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/109.wav", + "text": "是現在人民的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/110.wav", + "text": "所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/111.wav", + "text": "真的非常高興聽到韓院長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/112.wav", + "text": "是我們不斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/113.wav", + "text": "聽到有一種聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/114.wav", + "text": "當在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/115.wav", + "text": "會議室提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/116.wav", + "text": "散會動議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/117.wav", + "text": "有太多的人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/118.wav", + "text": "要散會動議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/119.wav", + "text": "委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/120.wav", + "text": "既然是委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/121.wav", + "text": "一個民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/122.wav", + "text": "既然在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/123.wav", + "text": "已經討論過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/124.wav", + "text": "已經到了院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/125.wav", + "text": "召集協商的區塊裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/126.wav", + "text": "我們的制度真的要建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/127.wav", + "text": "我們的制度真的要建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/128.wav", + "text": "我們不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/129.wav", + "text": "十四小時四十八小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/130.wav", + "text": "中華民國不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/131.wav", + "text": "一個案子兩個案子三個案子要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/132.wav", + "text": "一個制度的建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/133.wav", + "text": "真的不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/134.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得院長要大破大立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/135.wav", + "text": "發言本來就由主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/136.wav", + "text": "一次發言幾分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/137.wav", + "text": "詢答等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/138.wav", + "text": "接著下來到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/139.wav", + "text": "部會首長院長的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/140.wav", + "text": "都有15分鐘或30分鐘的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/141.wav", + "text": "但一個會期就那麼一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/142.wav", + "text": "所思考的已經有一點差距了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/143.wav", + "text": "我想是因為院長比較宏觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/144.wav", + "text": "五分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/145.wav", + "text": "得再發言一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/146.wav", + "text": "除非表達能力有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/147.wav", + "text": "不然五分鐘之內已經可以講得很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/148.wav", + "text": "人民都聽得懂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/149.wav", + "text": "不會說你講了五分鐘跟五十分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/150.wav", + "text": "人民就有不一樣的感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/151.wav", + "text": "就是要有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/152.wav", + "text": "所以今天欣見韓院長願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/153.wav", + "text": "制度我們深表敬佩也願意來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/154.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/155.wav", + "text": "舉手請發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/156.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/157.wav", + "text": "能透過比較好的議事管控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/158.wav", + "text": "也就是大家彼此能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/159.wav", + "text": "我當然樂見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/160.wav", + "text": "但是新的民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/161.wav", + "text": "民主運作的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/162.wav", + "text": "委員會有委員會的規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/163.wav", + "text": "協商有協商大家對話的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/164.wav", + "text": "新的民意更不能凌駕憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/165.wav", + "text": "不是言必稱新民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/166.wav", + "text": "就可以把過去立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/167.wav", + "text": "數十年來運作的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/168.wav", + "text": "如果要約束大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/169.wav", + "text": "一次發言幾分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/170.wav", + "text": "這個我可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/171.wav", + "text": "大家就儘量來約束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/172.wav", + "text": "我認為是不宜限制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/173.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛傅崐萁總召說到委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/174.wav", + "text": "太好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/175.wav", + "text": "我終於從傅總召的嘴巴裡聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/176.wav", + "text": "委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/177.wav", + "text": "不是拿來嘴巴空講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/178.wav", + "text": "是要實踐的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/179.wav", + "text": "剛剛傅總召說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/180.wav", + "text": "因為有了委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/181.wav", + "text": "所以在委員會充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/182.wav", + "text": "再多花時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/183.wav", + "text": "所以要限制協商發言的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/184.wav", + "text": "次數跟時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/185.wav", + "text": "這我萬萬不能同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/186.wav", + "text": "啊如果委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/187.wav", + "text": "有被履行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/188.wav", + "text": "那我大可接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/189.wav", + "text": "這也是過去的好經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/190.wav", + "text": "委員會充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/191.wav", + "text": "只留下部分爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/192.wav", + "text": "未解的部分送到協商來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/193.wav", + "text": "這個是如常運作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/194.wav", + "text": "立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/195.wav", + "text": "但是現在的立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/196.wav", + "text": "委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/197.wav", + "text": "7個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/198.wav", + "text": "蕩然無存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/199.wav", + "text": "我如果有說錯傅總召可以指正我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/200.wav", + "text": "今天要協商的三個議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/201.wav", + "text": "委員會中心主義在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/202.wav", + "text": "花東快速公路建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/203.wav", + "text": "特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/204.wav", + "text": "交通委員會只審了3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/205.wav", + "text": "第二個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/206.wav", + "text": "國道六號東延花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/207.wav", + "text": "建設特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/208.wav", + "text": "交通委員會只花了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/209.wav", + "text": "1分50秒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/210.wav", + "text": "第三個案子環島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/211.wav", + "text": "高鐵N兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/212.wav", + "text": "現在還算不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/213.wav", + "text": "到底要花多少民脂民膏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/214.wav", + "text": "交通委員會只花6分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/215.wav", + "text": "換言之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/216.wav", + "text": "今天要審的三大法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/217.wav", + "text": "委員會分3天開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/218.wav", + "text": "total的討論時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/219.wav", + "text": "只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/220.wav", + "text": "這是什麼委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/221.wav", + "text": "所以今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/222.wav", + "text": "我們是在補進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/223.wav", + "text": "我必須很遺憾的說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/224.wav", + "text": "我們是在彌補委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/225.wav", + "text": "中心主義被踐踏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/226.wav", + "text": "的那幾次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/227.wav", + "text": "我們只好不得已到協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/228.wav", + "text": "再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/229.wav", + "text": "那是因為委員會中心主義被國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/230.wav", + "text": "壓陣之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/231.wav", + "text": "予以踐踏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/232.wav", + "text": "\n所以回到主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/233.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/234.wav", + "text": "昨天內政委員會審議通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/235.wav", + "text": "地方民代支給條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/236.wav", + "text": "我們提升了村里長的年終慰問金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/237.wav", + "text": "我們提升了地方民代助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/238.wav", + "text": "24年未調的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/239.wav", + "text": "朝野就努力在內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/240.wav", + "text": "針對8個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/241.wav", + "text": "討論了10個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/242.wav", + "text": "那是委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/243.wav", + "text": "8個條文討論了10個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/244.wav", + "text": "三個法案有幾個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/245.wav", + "text": "我們是不是真的能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/246.wav", + "text": "堅守國會議員監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/247.wav", + "text": "的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/248.wav", + "text": "來看一個委員協商三長的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/249.wav", + "text": "一次5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/250.wav", + "text": "一個人發言50次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/251.wav", + "text": "都不嫌多啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/252.wav", + "text": "因為委員會中心主義被踐踏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/253.wav", + "text": "三大議案在交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/254.wav", + "text": "只花了10分50秒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/255.wav", + "text": "積極的爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/256.wav", + "text": "難道不值得好好討論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/257.wav", + "text": "過去的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/258.wav", + "text": "昨天內政委員會8個條文討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/259.wav", + "text": "10個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/260.wav", + "text": "那今天每一個委員可以發言50次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/261.wav", + "text": "都不嫌多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/262.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/263.wav", + "text": "如果我們沒有做一個正式決議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/264.wav", + "text": "再講下去也講不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/265.wav", + "text": "今天民進黨的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/266.wav", + "text": "發言到目前為止我聽不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/267.wav", + "text": "是不是真的想要針對這三個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/268.wav", + "text": "請容許我特別來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/269.wav", + "text": "這三個條例不管是在經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/270.wav", + "text": "或是在交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/271.wav", + "text": "都是有正式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/272.wav", + "text": "詢答所有的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/273.wav", + "text": "相關部會的官員做過詢答之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/274.wav", + "text": "才進入實質的逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/275.wav", + "text": "但因為沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/276.wav", + "text": "在委員會裡面確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/277.wav", + "text": "出一個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/278.wav", + "text": "所以才會送來朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/279.wav", + "text": "但是在這個過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/280.wav", + "text": "絕對不是民進黨代表剛剛所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/281.wav", + "text": "幾分鐘5分鐘3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/282.wav", + "text": "不要自我閹割了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/283.wav", + "text": "委員會的審查功能之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/284.wav", + "text": "來這邊的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/285.wav", + "text": "我想這是第一個最大的謬論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/286.wav", + "text": "今天朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/287.wav", + "text": "的重點在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/288.wav", + "text": "朝野協商的重點是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/289.wav", + "text": "我們會議室裡面的人互相講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/290.wav", + "text": "可是我發覺現在民進黨的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/291.wav", + "text": "把這裡當成是直播舞臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/292.wav", + "text": "演講舞臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/293.wav", + "text": "從頭到尾眼神也沒有交集過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/294.wav", + "text": "感覺就是一直在找攝影機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/295.wav", + "text": "如果說真的要這樣子做的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/296.wav", + "text": "我倒建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/297.wav", + "text": "也不用5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/298.wav", + "text": "一個人發言3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/299.wav", + "text": "甚至2分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/300.wav", + "text": "大家把我們自己想要講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/301.wav", + "text": "概念講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/302.wav", + "text": "擔任到立法委員了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/303.wav", + "text": "你想表達的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/304.wav", + "text": "都沒有辦法在3分鐘2分鐘裡面完成的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/305.wav", + "text": "你的語言表達要重練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/306.wav", + "text": "時間給占滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/307.wav", + "text": "啦既然如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/308.wav", + "text": "真的我建議誠摯的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/309.wav", + "text": "為了我們的議事效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/310.wav", + "text": "不是要表演給外界看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/311.wav", + "text": "我們真的希望是坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/312.wav", + "text": "大家可以互相尊重彼此的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/313.wav", + "text": "我們把這個具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/314.wav", + "text": "精神給講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/315.wav", + "text": "委員會審查完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/316.wav", + "text": "都有各自的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/317.wav", + "text": "既然今天要討論條例的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/318.wav", + "text": "我也想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/319.wav", + "text": "行政部門有沒有相對應的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/320.wav", + "text": "民進黨團有沒有相對應的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/321.wav", + "text": "如果都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/322.wav", + "text": "你們來只是一昧的否定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/323.wav", + "text": "這樣根本不叫實質的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/324.wav", + "text": "啦如果你們沒有版本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/325.wav", + "text": "比如說我們今天討論第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/326.wav", + "text": "你們沒有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/327.wav", + "text": "那我們要討論什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/328.wav", + "text": "你只有yesorno" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/329.wav", + "text": "嘛這樣就根本不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/330.wav", + "text": "想要實質的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/331.wav", + "text": "進入這個協商會場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/332.wav", + "text": "都沒有任何版本的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/333.wav", + "text": "我合理的懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/334.wav", + "text": "今天根本不是帶著誠意來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/335.wav", + "text": "根本不是有心為地方建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/336.wav", + "text": "為臺灣建設的發展來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/337.wav", + "text": "這樣的協商還有意義嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/338.wav", + "text": "我們是不是在經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/339.wav", + "text": "三個黨團都有發言過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/340.wav", + "text": "之後就直接進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/341.wav", + "text": "就按照您剛剛的遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/342.wav", + "text": "我們就裁定時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/343.wav", + "text": "之後就直接進行今天的第一案討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/344.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/345.wav", + "text": "謝謝\n接下來我們請第一次舉手的莊瑞雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/346.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/347.wav", + "text": "還有在場的先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/348.wav", + "text": "以及各位列席官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/349.wav", + "text": "剛剛聽了洪孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/350.wav", + "text": "的一席話我是非常的驚嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/351.wav", + "text": "這個不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/352.wav", + "text": "你國民黨提什麼版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/353.wav", + "text": "我們就要提對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/354.wav", + "text": "可以用個案來推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/355.wav", + "text": "但你也必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/356.wav", + "text": "確實的去做實質的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/357.wav", + "text": "第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/358.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/359.wav", + "text": "高鐵南延到屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/360.wav", + "text": "我第8屆進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/361.wav", + "text": "後問毛治國的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/362.wav", + "text": "他跟我說要花那麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/363.wav", + "text": "了院長在幹高雄市長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/364.wav", + "text": "你說高鐵到屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/365.wav", + "text": "什麼方案都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/366.wav", + "text": "但院長在選總統的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/367.wav", + "text": "想法就不一樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/368.wav", + "text": "你還記得吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/369.wav", + "text": "這是你當初的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/370.wav", + "text": "侯友宜在選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/371.wav", + "text": "時我也沒有看到有這樣一個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/372.wav", + "text": "啊花蓮縣政府的國土" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/373.wav", + "text": "規劃裡面我也沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/374.wav", + "text": "依我高鐵南延到屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/375.wav", + "text": "不是說到臺東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/376.wav", + "text": "不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/377.wav", + "text": "也不是說到花蓮不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/378.wav", + "text": "但你們這是漫天要價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/379.wav", + "text": "嘛要多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/380.wav", + "text": "你家的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/381.wav", + "text": "我人多數提了就算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/382.wav", + "text": "是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/383.wav", + "text": "可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/384.wav", + "text": "呢洪孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/385.wav", + "text": "我看你連搞都搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/386.wav", + "text": "高鐵要南延到屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/387.wav", + "text": "的可行性評估跟綜規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/388.wav", + "text": "綜合規劃最快要8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/389.wav", + "text": "你知道蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/390.wav", + "text": "我為什麼說要用個案推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/391.wav", + "text": "我們主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/392.wav", + "text": "高鐵南延到屏東以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/393.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/394.wav", + "text": "還要再多久你知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/395.wav", + "text": "你現在說要拉到臺東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/396.wav", + "text": "我問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/397.wav", + "text": "政府跟我們承諾到潮州的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/398.wav", + "text": "部分連這個的另外一個計畫都還沒推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/399.wav", + "text": "喔你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/400.wav", + "text": "到了潮州" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/401.wav", + "text": "好就算一個案子對我們的favor很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/402.wav", + "text": "說財政資源都很充足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/403.wav", + "text": "我給你到潮州" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/404.wav", + "text": "到潮州以後你又要推動一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/405.wav", + "text": "說要到臺東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/406.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/407.wav", + "text": "屏南的人認為可能要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/408.wav", + "text": "可是你請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/409.wav", + "text": "專家來看的話他會跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/410.wav", + "text": "這是浪費錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/411.wav", + "text": "一個縣市哪有3個站的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/412.wav", + "text": "搞不好不同意見都出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/413.wav", + "text": "了光高鐵南延到屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/414.wav", + "text": "我們這些主張屏東要有高鐵的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/415.wav", + "text": "的例子不是在說你亂講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/416.wav", + "text": "是在講當你在不同位子的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/417.wav", + "text": "會有不同的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/418.wav", + "text": "\n所以我的意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/419.wav", + "text": "建設地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/420.wav", + "text": "這是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/421.wav", + "text": "也是大家都樂見的沒有人會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/422.wav", + "text": "但問題是說我反對的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/423.wav", + "text": "用特別條例的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/424.wav", + "text": "騙鬼來到我屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/425.wav", + "text": "不用經過山的我就要蓋17年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/426.wav", + "text": "民進黨在執政欸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/427.wav", + "text": "然後你們提出的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/428.wav", + "text": "都在變魔術嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/429.wav", + "text": "嗎那為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/430.wav", + "text": "不是用個案去推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/431.wav", + "text": "因為人多所以我要用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/432.wav", + "text": "把它匡住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/433.wav", + "text": "國家建設是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/434.wav", + "text": "國家建設是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/435.wav", + "text": "你評評理是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/436.wav", + "text": "縮短城鄉差距我也樂於見到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/437.wav", + "text": "我們屏東跟整個北部均衡發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/438.wav", + "text": "我也樂於看到東部跟西部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/439.wav", + "text": "可是建設是用這樣子的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/440.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子的話為什麼過去國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/441.wav", + "text": "你們選總統的人包括韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/442.wav", + "text": "我也沒看過啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/443.wav", + "text": "這個叫做個人即興之作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/444.wav", + "text": "啊管你建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/445.wav", + "text": "要50年你就給我通過就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/446.wav", + "text": "幾十年有沒有活那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/447.wav", + "text": "跟我無關啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/448.wav", + "text": "可以這樣子搞嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/449.wav", + "text": "莊委員你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/450.wav", + "text": "講到現在對於5分鐘的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/451.wav", + "text": "第一次發言同意還是不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/452.wav", + "text": "用條例的方式我反對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/453.wav", + "text": "個案去推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/454.wav", + "text": "尊重科學專業的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/455.wav", + "text": "我就贊成啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/456.wav", + "text": "我跟莊委員還有各位黨團的幹部再解釋一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/457.wav", + "text": "我們現在要針對幾次朝野協商下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/458.wav", + "text": "我們累積了一些寶貴的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/459.wav", + "text": "在這裡我想跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/460.wav", + "text": "就是這樣簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/461.wav", + "text": "典範出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/462.wav", + "text": "第一個就是發言的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/463.wav", + "text": "接下來發言的參加對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/464.wav", + "text": "第三個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/465.wav", + "text": "發言的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/466.wav", + "text": "還有第四個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/467.wav", + "text": "發言的情緒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/468.wav", + "text": "我嘗試著一點一滴把它建立起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/469.wav", + "text": "我知道我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/470.wav", + "text": "我懂等一下你可以就實質部分發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/471.wav", + "text": "\n柯總召您還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/472.wav", + "text": "發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/473.wav", + "text": "我當然要發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/474.wav", + "text": "言你是在做發言限5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/475.wav", + "text": "5分鐘的���試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/476.wav", + "text": "你要想清楚院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/477.wav", + "text": "國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/478.wav", + "text": "被國民黨這樣在委員會裡面就是沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/479.wav", + "text": "然後國會改革法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/480.wav", + "text": "沒有經過逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/481.wav", + "text": "然後他在朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/482.wav", + "text": "協商的時候過水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/483.wav", + "text": "馬上去表決也不讓你講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/484.wav", + "text": "這個國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/485.wav", + "text": "是死亡的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/486.wav", + "text": "現在變成你一個人在很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/487.wav", + "text": "的關鍵位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/488.wav", + "text": "和黃國昌要沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/489.wav", + "text": "你的協調權他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/490.wav", + "text": "一個月到就要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/491.wav", + "text": "這個你想想看連你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/492.wav", + "text": "職權都要被沒收還是我們幫你捍衛的喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/493.wav", + "text": "\n你現在處於一個地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/494.wav", + "text": "你在笑什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/495.wav", + "text": "寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/496.wav", + "text": "本來過去協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/497.wav", + "text": "要定期表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/498.wav", + "text": "不是馬上表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/499.wav", + "text": "所以過去這個民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/500.wav", + "text": "不管黃國昌或傅崐萁都在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/501.wav", + "text": "你是少年人講話要照道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/502.wav", + "text": "誰在找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/503.wav", + "text": "什麼攝影機在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/504.wav", + "text": "我個人不知道攝影機在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/505.wav", + "text": "什麼在直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/506.wav", + "text": "啊什麼我們沒有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/507.wav", + "text": "還跟你拿什麼版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/508.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/509.wav", + "text": "你要從憲法的層次去看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/510.wav", + "text": "這個有沒有違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/511.wav", + "text": "這是行政的權力嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/512.wav", + "text": "憲法規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/513.wav", + "text": "送到立法院給我們審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/514.wav", + "text": "然後我們是有監督權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/515.wav", + "text": "主被動要看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/516.wav", + "text": "我現在跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/517.wav", + "text": "時間的問題我要跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/518.wav", + "text": "實踐給你看看嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/519.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/520.wav", + "text": "你是一個很重要的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/521.wav", + "text": "因為這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/522.wav", + "text": "這三個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/523.wav", + "text": "你是提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/524.wav", + "text": "織法規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/525.wav", + "text": "議長必須議事中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/526.wav", + "text": "你是提案人又要主持朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/527.wav", + "text": "商像這個時候你在角色上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/528.wav", + "text": "面要更中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/529.wav", + "text": "不是一來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/530.wav", + "text": "就限制5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/531.wav", + "text": "我曾經在委員會發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/532.wav", + "text": "一條講一天也在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/533.wav", + "text": "這是民主的實現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/534.wav", + "text": "嘛我們希望好不容易建立的民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/535.wav", + "text": "能夠實現不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/536.wav", + "text": "鐘2分鐘就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/537.wav", + "text": "了這是什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/538.wav", + "text": "沒有嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/539.wav", + "text": "就沒有委員會了嘛哪有委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/540.wav", + "text": "根本沒有討論的空間最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/541.wav", + "text": "在一個月以後隨便協商一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/542.wav", + "text": "但是不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/543.wav", + "text": "你現在回去想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/544.wav", + "text": "你可以取一個折衷的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/545.wav", + "text": "法案討論何其複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/546.wav", + "text": "你現在光這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/547.wav", + "text": "包括很多法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/548.wav", + "text": "一條一條要再前後對對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/549.wav", + "text": "相信你們每一個法案都懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/550.wav", + "text": "所以今天要談的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/551.wav", + "text": "曾經一個法案協商20次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/552.wav", + "text": "後來才把它弄好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/553.wav", + "text": "司法院和法務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/554.wav", + "text": "部至少在我們辦公室協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/555.wav", + "text": "10次以上然後再朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/556.wav", + "text": "任何一個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/557.wav", + "text": "都是和人民相當有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/558.wav", + "text": "黃國昌在這個地方也曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/559.wav", + "text": "實踐過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/560.wav", + "text": "因為前瞻他們在委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/561.wav", + "text": "國民黨抵制他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/562.wav", + "text": "讓他沒有辦法發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/563.wav", + "text": "蘇嘉全前院長還撥1個鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/564.wav", + "text": "給他再把各部會找來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/565.wav", + "text": "國民黨也撥2個鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/566.wav", + "text": "罵到飽為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/567.wav", + "text": "在我們執政的時候我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/568.wav", + "text": "至少要讓民主程序維持著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/569.wav", + "text": "否則的話你以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/570.wav", + "text": "你國會多數你沒有永遠都國會多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/571.wav", + "text": "你這樣搞法就是你永遠不想執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/572.wav", + "text": "嘛這種搞法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/573.wav", + "text": "這個邏輯很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/574.wav", + "text": "要1分鐘就好2分鐘就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/575.wav", + "text": "你現在講的都是極度的錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/576.wav", + "text": "對於這個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/577.wav", + "text": "我有非常多的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/578.wav", + "text": "提案者請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/579.wav", + "text": "我應該請教韓院長因為你是提案者啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/580.wav", + "text": "我可以跟你請教你這個在憲政體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/581.wav", + "text": "法對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/582.wav", + "text": "這個是政府的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/583.wav", + "text": "審議的權力立法院沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/584.wav", + "text": "直接編列國家預算的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/585.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁一個人可以提2兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/586.wav", + "text": "0年內完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/587.wav", + "text": "行性評估要多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/588.wav", + "text": "還要環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/589.wav", + "text": "還要限10年完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/590.wav", + "text": "這個有沒有可能啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/591.wav", + "text": "\n院長現在你是一個非常關鍵的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/592.wav", + "text": "因為你同時是提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/593.wav", + "text": "我希望你能夠中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/594.wav", + "text": "這個法就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/595.wav", + "text": "侵犯了不管大法官解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/596.wav", + "text": "我們國家的憲政體制是很清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/597.wav", + "text": "行政院做什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/598.wav", + "text": "是行政院做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/599.wav", + "text": "在憲法上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/600.wav", + "text": "第53條到第61條規定行政院的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/601.wav", + "text": "他們編列了要送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/602.wav", + "text": "我們是一章而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/603.wav", + "text": "所以主動權被動權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/604.wav", + "text": "要很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/605.wav", + "text": "你跨越這個權力的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/606.wav", + "text": "我們桃竹苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/607.wav", + "text": "那屏東也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/608.wav", + "text": "那就是執政權啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/609.wav", + "text": "責任政治在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/610.wav", + "text": "你這個版本根本就不行嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/611.wav", + "text": "這個就先行討論再來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/612.wav", + "text": "還有立法院在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/613.wav", + "text": "在審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/614.wav", + "text": "提案的版本嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/615.wav", + "text": "也有只有民進黨提案國民黨不提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/616.wav", + "text": "民眾黨人少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/617.wav", + "text": "還不一定每個法案都提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/618.wav", + "text": "提出他們的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/619.wav", + "text": "這是民主政治啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/620.wav", + "text": "所以今天我要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/621.wav", + "text": "拜託韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/622.wav", + "text": "這是一個歷史的關鍵時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/623.wav", + "text": "發言好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/624.wav", + "text": "過去的朝野協商坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/625.wav", + "text": "像這個就是法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/626.wav", + "text": "這個法案觸及了憲政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/627.wav", + "text": "論多廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/628.wav", + "text": "這個法案涉及整個憲政運作多廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/629.wav", + "text": "我們要從這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/630.wav", + "text": "不是談內容而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/631.wav", + "text": "是整個法的立法邏輯對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/632.wav", + "text": "所以一種是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/633.wav", + "text": "法案另一種就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/634.wav", + "text": "預算包括中央政府總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/635.wav", + "text": "還有國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/636.wav", + "text": "然後會在這裡協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/637.wav", + "text": "這個就是最主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/638.wav", + "text": "這三十幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/639.wav", + "text": "臺灣的民主化會一直往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/640.wav", + "text": "這是很重要的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/641.wav", + "text": "1986年到2016" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/642.wav", + "text": "年我們30年在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/643.wav", + "text": "程序委員會院會委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/644.wav", + "text": "但是我們還是會往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/645.wav", + "text": "到2016" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/646.wav", + "text": "從來沒有表決成功過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/647.wav", + "text": "但是我們還是讓民主往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/648.wav", + "text": "今天要講一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/649.wav", + "text": "很重要的道理就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/650.wav", + "text": "而不是說我是新民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/651.wav", + "text": "你今天只是多民進黨1票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/652.wav", + "text": "你和黃國昌加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/653.wav", + "text": "2個人可能過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/654.wav", + "text": "黃國昌到最後不一定每一條都聽你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/655.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/656.wav", + "text": "你以為你們加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/657.wav", + "text": "轉動臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/658.wav", + "text": "你們做什麼就要什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/659.wav", + "text": "不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/660.wav", + "text": "你這個樣子就永遠不想執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/661.wav", + "text": "嘛我們每次在這裡講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/662.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/663.wav", + "text": "你們就愛聽不聽的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/664.wav", + "text": "什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/665.wav", + "text": "我在找什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/666.wav", + "text": "攝影機攝影機在哪裡我根本搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/667.wav", + "text": "我們到這個年紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/668.wav", + "text": "因為好不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/669.wav", + "text": "你們自己未來要面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/670.wav", + "text": "你們選區的選民怎麼看待你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/671.wav", + "text": "你要面對你的選民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/672.wav", + "text": "院長有一個程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/673.wav", + "text": "我我講一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/674.wav", + "text": "因為我們有很多法案要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/675.wav", + "text": "營業基金非營業基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/676.wav", + "text": "多繁雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/677.wav", + "text": "然後還有表決議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/678.wav", + "text": "電業法要抽出逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/679.wav", + "text": "那個可以這樣搞嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/680.wav", + "text": "電業法多繁雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/681.wav", + "text": "只有一種最簡單的叫做程序性的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/682.wav", + "text": "那個可以3個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/683.wav", + "text": "其他在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/684.wav", + "text": "我在這裡30年從來沒有限制人數過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/685.wav", + "text": "你試想看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/686.wav", + "text": "有一個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/687.wav", + "text": "40個人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/688.wav", + "text": "就你們3個人來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/689.wav", + "text": "至少委員會召委要來提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/690.wav", + "text": "很嚴肅的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/691.wav", + "text": "我希望你能夠聽得下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/692.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/693.wav", + "text": "各位黨團幹部因為我們有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/694.wav", + "text": "列席官員大家可能還不太清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/695.wav", + "text": "我念一下名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/696.wav", + "text": "也是對官員稍微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/697.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛有人問官員列席的有誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/698.wav", + "text": "第一位是國家發展委員會高副主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/699.wav", + "text": "歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/700.wav", + "text": "第二位是我們交通部王部長歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/701.wav", + "text": "推動促參司的張副司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/702.wav", + "text": "歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/703.wav", + "text": "內政部地政司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/704.wav", + "text": "張視察歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/705.wav", + "text": "環境部環境保護司蔡司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/706.wav", + "text": "歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/707.wav", + "text": "原住民族委員會的洪副處長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/708.wav", + "text": "歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/709.wav", + "text": "行政院公共工程委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/710.wav", + "text": "胡副處長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/711.wav", + "text": "歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/712.wav", + "text": "行政院主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/713.wav", + "text": "的王專門委員歡迎您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/714.wav", + "text": "是列席的官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/715.wav", + "text": "\n現在我想再重申一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/716.wav", + "text": "剛才我一開始就開宗明義講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/717.wav", + "text": "我們每一次發言5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/718.wav", + "text": "如果認為有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/719.wav", + "text": "可以再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/720.wav", + "text": "出第二輪發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/721.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛看到很多委員講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/722.wav", + "text": "我所提的這個內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/723.wav", + "text": "我只想請問一下各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/724.wav", + "text": "同意不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/725.wav", + "text": "我這樣一個宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/726.wav", + "text": "就講同意還是不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/727.wav", + "text": "不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/728.wav", + "text": "國民黨團同意請問一下民眾黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/729.wav", + "text": "國民黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/730.wav", + "text": "好沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/731.wav", + "text": "我不處理嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/732.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/733.wav", + "text": "你第三次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/734.wav", + "text": "有幾個黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/735.wav", + "text": "請了其他委員來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/736.wav", + "text": "因為他也離開現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/737.wav", + "text": "我建議我們以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/738.wav", + "text": "召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/739.wav", + "text": "或者其他委員列席的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/740.wav", + "text": "如果一個黨團提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/741.wav", + "text": "其他兩個黨團沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/742.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/743.wav", + "text": "這一點要先確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/744.wav", + "text": "同意不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/745.wav", + "text": "等一下不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/746.wav", + "text": "如果這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/747.wav", + "text": "我念完嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/748.wav", + "text": "不要急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/749.wav", + "text": "我請他離場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/750.wav", + "text": "因為我們希望黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/751.wav", + "text": "在開朝野協商的時候就是當然代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/752.wav", + "text": "如果黨團三長有事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/753.wav", + "text": "請不要派代表來代替" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/754.wav", + "text": "我們先確定黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/755.wav", + "text": "出席的審慎性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/756.wav", + "text": "第二針對個別重要的預算跟法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/757.wav", + "text": "大家覺得有需要委員來列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/758.wav", + "text": "大家都同意也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/759.wav", + "text": "第三如果主席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/760.wav", + "text": "要邀請某些委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/761.wav", + "text": "來列席的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/762.wav", + "text": "三位黨團都同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/763.wav", + "text": "我們也可以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/764.wav", + "text": "請問這樣可不可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/765.wav", + "text": "創造出一個主席的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/766.wav", + "text": "要來立法院開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/767.wav", + "text": "是要主席同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/768.wav", + "text": "根據什麼法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/769.wav", + "text": "我要來這裡發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/770.wav", + "text": "講很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/771.wav", + "text": "後面就在講這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/772.wav", + "text": "昨天立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/773.wav", + "text": "職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/774.wav", + "text": "委員會自己協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/775.wav", + "text": "從來沒有限制人數過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/776.wav", + "text": "現在也沒有限制人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/777.wav", + "text": "這麼多年三十年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/778.wav", + "text": "就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/779.wav", + "text": "提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/780.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/781.wav", + "text": "這麼多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/782.wav", + "text": "來已經形成了憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/783.wav", + "text": "我們好不容易形成憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/784.wav", + "text": "能夠讓我們的民主在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/785.wav", + "text": "實踐是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/786.wav", + "text": "不是你來當院長以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/787.wav", + "text": "然後聽從傅崐萁指揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/788.wav", + "text": "是不是第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/789.wav", + "text": "院長室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/790.wav", + "text": "啊這問題是法源在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/791.wav", + "text": "委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/792.wav", + "text": "曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/793.wav", + "text": "一個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/794.wav", + "text": "搞一年多還在委員會那邊審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/795.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/796.wav", + "text": "早就應該出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/797.wav", + "text": "最有名就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/798.wav", + "text": "林為洲搞了一兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/799.wav", + "text": "能夠討論都是儘量討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/800.wav", + "text": "這是一個民主的殿堂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/801.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/802.wav", + "text": "也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/803.wav", + "text": "我們回到院長主持的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/804.wav", + "text": "職權行使法第68條開始寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/805.wav", + "text": "\n我今天要講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/806.wav", + "text": "剛才其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/807.wav", + "text": "韓院長也發現這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/808.wav", + "text": "問題法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/809.wav", + "text": "三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/810.wav", + "text": "不管民進黨三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/811.wav", + "text": "國民黨三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/812.wav", + "text": "民眾黨三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/813.wav", + "text": "沒有一個是萬能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/814.wav", + "text": "一個會期通過的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/815.wav", + "text": "一年通過的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/816.wav", + "text": "有一百零多條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/817.wav", + "text": "總共通過將近五百多個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/818.wav", + "text": "連其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/819.wav", + "text": "七百多個包括預算案廢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/820.wav", + "text": "廢止案等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/821.wav", + "text": "都是靠黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/822.wav", + "text": "行政部門的意見是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/823.wav", + "text": "的因為他們最瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/824.wav", + "text": "所有內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/825.wav", + "text": "立法院所通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/826.wav", + "text": "各個法案影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/827.wav", + "text": "每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/828.wav", + "text": "點值一定要加1.0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/829.wav", + "text": "這個東西衛環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/830.wav", + "text": "他們經過討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/831.wav", + "text": "每一個人都有他的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/832.wav", + "text": "要去先行研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/833.wav", + "text": "黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/834.wav", + "text": "每一個都是萬能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/835.wav", + "text": "所以法案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/836.wav", + "text": "過去黃國昌也在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/837.wav", + "text": "也是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/838.wav", + "text": "大家都實踐過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/839.wav", + "text": "嘛\n所以我剛才第一個程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/840.wav", + "text": "就是在談這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/841.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜吳思瑤幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/842.wav", + "text": "為了這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/843.wav", + "text": "說我懇求你拜託你好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/844.wav", + "text": "你要讓提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/845.wav", + "text": "有人來參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/846.wav", + "text": "委員會的人都不能來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/847.wav", + "text": "他們都不是委員嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/848.wav", + "text": "所以這個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/849.wav", + "text": "第一個就是多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/850.wav", + "text": "多增加一些\n等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/851.wav", + "text": "就是增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/852.wav", + "text": "增加人你有注意到這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/853.wav", + "text": "我們往下走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/854.wav", + "text": "可是還沒走到這裡的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/855.wav", + "text": "你又說要增加多少人要大家同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/856.wav", + "text": "這都絕對不成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/857.wav", + "text": "第二個你又有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/858.wav", + "text": "霸王條款說你同意也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/859.wav", + "text": "這個不是這樣搞的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/860.wav", + "text": "所以這個邏輯上是錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/861.wav", + "text": "你應該好好的不要去設計這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/862.wav", + "text": "立法委員不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/863.wav", + "text": "這樣恢復到一個霸王條款而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/864.wav", + "text": "要院長同意要是院長不同意怎麼辦呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/865.wav", + "text": "現在應該怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/866.wav", + "text": "而且很多都非常複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/867.wav", + "text": "什麼講1分鐘就聽得懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/868.wav", + "text": "那是你們根本不想瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/869.wav", + "text": "法案內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/870.wav", + "text": "很多法案包括司法院很多法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/871.wav", + "text": "刑法刑訴還有未來打詐什麼法都會進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/872.wav", + "text": "非常多各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/873.wav", + "text": "在各委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/874.wav", + "text": "了所以大家要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/875.wav", + "text": "電業法有電業法的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/876.wav", + "text": "主要是我們尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/877.wav", + "text": "委員會的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/878.wav", + "text": "委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/879.wav", + "text": "你把委員會都沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/880.wav", + "text": "會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/881.wav", + "text": "所有法案都逕付二讀立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/882.wav", + "text": "嘛所以今天我是很理性在跟你談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/883.wav", + "text": "我最憂心的是這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/884.wav", + "text": "\n我講坦白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/885.wav", + "text": "的啦民進黨曾經30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/886.wav", + "text": "在立法院表決幾萬次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/887.wav", + "text": "我1993年進來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/888.wav", + "text": "十多年來表決沒有贏過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/889.wav", + "text": "但我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/890.wav", + "text": "民主實踐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/891.wav", + "text": "立法院不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/892.wav", + "text": "你把臺灣的民主政治摧毀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/893.wav", + "text": "這個可能嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/894.wav", + "text": "不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/895.wav", + "text": "今天我們覺得這個才是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/896.wav", + "text": "我要跟柯總召澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/897.wav", + "text": "我跟你澄清一些事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/898.wav", + "text": "周萬來我還不清楚周萬來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/899.wav", + "text": "坦白講周萬來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/900.wav", + "text": "但是我們可以講理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/901.wav", + "text": "耶各位首長都坐在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/902.wav", + "text": "他們在立法院都有經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/903.wav", + "text": "啊每次來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/904.wav", + "text": "\n這什麼東西啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/905.wav", + "text": "桌子一拍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/906.wav", + "text": "你要重視這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/907.wav", + "text": "很抱歉我今天一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/908.wav", + "text": "我是為了整個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/909.wav", + "text": "柯總召我要澄清三件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/910.wav", + "text": "第一請黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/911.wav", + "text": "來這裡列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/912.wav", + "text": "是第一次朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/913.wav", + "text": "你直接指責民眾黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/914.wav", + "text": "什麼我要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/915.wav", + "text": "先徵詢一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/916.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/917.wav", + "text": "尊重一下主席好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/918.wav", + "text": "你剛剛已經講了七分多鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/919.wav", + "text": "尊重一下主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/920.wav", + "text": "請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/921.wav", + "text": "聽我講我們為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/922.wav", + "text": "朝野協商想建立這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/923.wav", + "text": "就是總結了過去幾次經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/924.wav", + "text": "柯總召剛剛對我的批判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/925.wav", + "text": "有一點偏差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/926.wav", + "text": "好像我這個主席把自己的權無限放大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/927.wav", + "text": "必須徵詢我主席的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/928.wav", + "text": "誰才能列席或者不列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/929.wav", + "text": "錯我們這樣建立黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/930.wav", + "text": "我們覺得有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/931.wav", + "text": "當天民眾黨來了兩位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/932.wav", + "text": "你還講了一句很重的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/933.wav", + "text": "──你今天是撂人來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/934.wav", + "text": "所以我們才確定黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/935.wav", + "text": "代表各政黨坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/936.wav", + "text": "其他的委員請不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/937.wav", + "text": "來這裡坐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/938.wav", + "text": "第二我剛剛所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/939.wav", + "text": "如果各位黨團認為某些委員要列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/940.wav", + "text": "說明法案預算請提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/941.wav", + "text": "其他黨團沒有意見歡迎來列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/942.wav", + "text": "如果主席有認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/943.wav", + "text": "哪些委員要列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/944.wav", + "text": "來補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/945.wav", + "text": "三個黨團都同意也歡迎來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/946.wav", + "text": "你嚴重誤會我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/947.wav", + "text": "我只想點點滴滴來建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/948.wav", + "text": "所以後面我還要唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/949.wav", + "text": "在預算審查期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/950.wav", + "text": "你們再聽聽看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/951.wav", + "text": "預算協商時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/952.wav", + "text": "國民黨團推派5人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/953.wav", + "text": "民進黨團推派5人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/954.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨推派4人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/955.wav", + "text": "參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/956.wav", + "text": "以上人數是包括黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/957.wav", + "text": "要徵詢大家同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/958.wav", + "text": "如果各黨團認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/959.wav", + "text": "有增加其他委員參加的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/960.wav", + "text": "經過各黨的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/961.wav", + "text": "我現在在講協商的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/962.wav", + "text": "我等一下印一份給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/963.wav", + "text": "我們就允許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/964.wav", + "text": "增加委員來參與協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/965.wav", + "text": "這是一個比較完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/966.wav", + "text": "所以你一聽到前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/967.wav", + "text": "就開始扭曲主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/968.wav", + "text": "你完全誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/969.wav", + "text": "以後列席代表是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/970.wav", + "text": "以黨團幹部為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/971.wav", + "text": "當黨團幹部請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/972.wav", + "text": "有事不能來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/973.wav", + "text": "請不要叫其他委員來頂替" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/974.wav", + "text": "代替參加可以不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/975.wav", + "text": "你看我一點一滴來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/976.wav", + "text": "院長我先回答你的問題好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/977.wav", + "text": "我剛才講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/978.wav", + "text": "協商有很多種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/979.wav", + "text": "那是很簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/980.wav", + "text": "往後就有很複雜的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/981.wav", + "text": "光是預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/982.wav", + "text": "一個人來了二十幾個國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/983.wav", + "text": "繁雜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/984.wav", + "text": "案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/985.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/986.wav", + "text": "我現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/987.wav", + "text": "回答你的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/988.wav", + "text": "各黨要增加人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/989.wav", + "text": "要互相同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/990.wav", + "text": "嘛包括你說你提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/991.wav", + "text": "要大家同意這是不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/992.wav", + "text": "我們要面對現實到底哪些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/993.wav", + "text": "應該讓他進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/994.wav", + "text": "委員會召委提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/995.wav", + "text": "各黨要幾個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/996.wav", + "text": "尤其是法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/997.wav", + "text": "你沒有叫他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/998.wav", + "text": "像搞財政的他怎麼懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/999.wav", + "text": "當然三長要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1000.wav", + "text": "能夠進來這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1001.wav", + "text": "讓民主能夠在這裡實現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1002.wav", + "text": "謝謝\n第三點我一併唸出來請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1003.wav", + "text": "我是嘗試性地來建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1004.wav", + "text": "第三點院會進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1005.wav", + "text": "表決的時候開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1006.wav", + "text": "時大家難免會走動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1007.wav", + "text": "議場會有喧嘩的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1008.wav", + "text": "我要請各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1009.wav", + "text": "也要拜託一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1010.wav", + "text": "共同維護一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1011.wav", + "text": "議場的秩序一同維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1012.wav", + "text": "立法院井然有序理性問政的形象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1013.wav", + "text": "這是我一開始想要建立的三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1014.wav", + "text": "如果各位連這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1015.wav", + "text": "都有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1016.wav", + "text": "那我們未來院會一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1017.wav", + "text": "發生很多不必要的波折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1018.wav", + "text": "所以我們一點一滴來建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1019.wav", + "text": "請問各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1020.wav", + "text": "有意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1021.wav", + "text": "我們一點一點來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1022.wav", + "text": "你講井然有序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1023.wav", + "text": "要點裡面寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1024.wav", + "text": "不可攜帶麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1025.wav", + "text": "一一列舉出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1026.wav", + "text": "包括動物內臟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1027.wav", + "text": "所以你用井然有序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1028.wav", + "text": "這四個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1029.wav", + "text": "那個又寫在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1030.wav", + "text": "議場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1031.wav", + "text": "場安全維護及管理要點寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1032.wav", + "text": "不可攜帶兇器等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1033.wav", + "text": "所以過去是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1034.wav", + "text": "丟的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1035.wav", + "text": "不夠清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1036.wav", + "text": "不要麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1037.wav", + "text": "國民黨會稿這一套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1038.wav", + "text": "在演講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1039.wav", + "text": "所以這一點我們先把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1040.wav", + "text": "什麼叫井然有序定義清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1041.wav", + "text": "說好的我們都贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1042.wav", + "text": "都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1043.wav", + "text": "我再澄清一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1044.wav", + "text": "這是我的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1045.wav", + "text": "跟周萬來秘書長一點關係都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1046.wav", + "text": "不是他唆使我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1047.wav", + "text": "或者建議我這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1048.wav", + "text": "我只是感覺院會朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1049.wav", + "text": "我們一點一滴來建立一些規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1050.wav", + "text": "向大家宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1051.wav", + "text": "我知道院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1052.wav", + "text": "有想把事情做好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1053.wav", + "text": "我是認同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1054.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1055.wav", + "text": "各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1056.wav", + "text": "現在我們繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1057.wav", + "text": "我想再一次建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1058.wav", + "text": "針對第一個時間問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1059.wav", + "text": "第二協商代表還有預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1060.wav", + "text": "我們派554" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1061.wav", + "text": "然後經過各黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1062.wav", + "text": "我們就允許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1063.wav", + "text": "增加委員會參與協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1064.wav", + "text": "第三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1065.wav", + "text": "院會進行會議表決的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1066.wav", + "text": "請黨團幹部大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1067.wav", + "text": "一起來約束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1068.wav", + "text": "我們每一位委員其實不複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1069.wav", + "text": "只有記住4個字就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1070.wav", + "text": "請所有的委員在院會表決的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1071.wav", + "text": "開會審法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1072.wav", + "text": "記住4個字輕聲細語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1073.wav", + "text": "我想這樣就夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1074.wav", + "text": "這是我新一點的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1075.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1076.wav", + "text": "我想因為等一下要進入協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1077.wav", + "text": "我要回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1078.wav", + "text": "剛剛洪孟楷書記長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1079.wav", + "text": "民進黨有沒有對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1080.wav", + "text": "行政部門有沒有對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1081.wav", + "text": "案我可能要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1082.wav", + "text": "這樣一個違憲的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1083.wav", + "text": "違法的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1084.wav", + "text": "我們不可能有對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1085.wav", + "text": "案我想先說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1086.wav", + "text": "因為5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1087.wav", + "text": "先講到5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1088.wav", + "text": "不是5分鐘不夠講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1089.wav", + "text": "我的口才沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1090.wav", + "text": "我的表達能力沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1091.wav", + "text": "我想在場的每一位表達能力都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1092.wav", + "text": "恐怕是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1093.wav", + "text": "對方的理解能力有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1094.wav", + "text": "所以我們需要多花時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1095.wav", + "text": "好好來對話跟論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1096.wav", + "text": "也擔心大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1097.wav", + "text": "聆聽能力有問題的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1098.wav", + "text": "我有準備比較清楚的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1099.wav", + "text": "大家也可以看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1100.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們沒有提對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1101.wav", + "text": "因為這3個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1102.wav", + "text": "是違反憲法第7條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1103.wav", + "text": "行政院對於行政院所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1104.wav", + "text": "預算案不得為增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1105.wav", + "text": "支出之決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1106.wav", + "text": "所以就是違反憲法第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1107.wav", + "text": "它也違反大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1108.wav", + "text": "釋字第391號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1109.wav", + "text": "行政立法權力分立的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1110.wav", + "text": "對面的朋友如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1111.wav", + "text": "理解能力沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1112.wav", + "text": "也可以用看的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1113.wav", + "text": "這3個法案也違反大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1114.wav", + "text": "釋字第613號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1115.wav", + "text": "我再一次準備出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1116.wav", + "text": "也就是立法權跟行政權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1117.wav", + "text": "權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1118.wav", + "text": "這3個法案也違反了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1119.wav", + "text": "我們立法院自己修的法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1120.wav", + "text": "財政紀律的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1121.wav", + "text": "財政紀律法第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1122.wav", + "text": "財政紀律法第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1123.wav", + "text": "以及預算法第91條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1124.wav", + "text": "我就不再贅述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1125.wav", + "text": "所以一個違憲又違法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1126.wav", + "text": "法案我們當然不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1127.wav", + "text": "所以不要說沒有對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1128.wav", + "text": "好像就不關心交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1129.wav", + "text": "好像就無助於今天的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1130.wav", + "text": "我想先釐清這是非常錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1131.wav", + "text": "顛倒是非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1132.wav", + "text": "\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1133.wav", + "text": "我也要回應剛剛主席說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1134.wav", + "text": "未來如果在限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1135.wav", + "text": "我們的出席人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1136.wav", + "text": "我還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1137.wav", + "text": "因為在審法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1138.wav", + "text": "該委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1139.wav", + "text": "尤其是召委是一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1140.wav", + "text": "才能夠額外plus的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1141.wav", + "text": "他就是必須到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1142.wav", + "text": "因為唯有召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1143.wav", + "text": "因為一個委員會有兩個召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1144.wav", + "text": "都可以來他可以清楚地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1145.wav", + "text": "針對在協商的時間來提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1146.wav", + "text": "這些法案在委員會審查當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1147.wav", + "text": "的爭點在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1148.wav", + "text": "所以召委的出席絕對有利於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1149.wav", + "text": "協商的品質跟效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1150.wav", + "text": "\n然後我也建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1151.wav", + "text": "對該法案非常關切的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1152.wav", + "text": "提案委員我認為他也有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1153.wav", + "text": "列席協商的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1154.wav", + "text": "譬如說原住民族的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1155.wav", + "text": "你可能要讓原住民族的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1156.wav", + "text": "或是提案委員來參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1157.wav", + "text": "或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1158.wav", + "text": "譬如因為剛好傅崐萁委員身兼總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1159.wav", + "text": "所以今天這三個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1160.wav", + "text": "他是提案委員他又是總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1161.wav", + "text": "他可以用總召的身分取代提案委員的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1162.wav", + "text": "分如果個別的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1163.wav", + "text": "重要的重大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1164.wav", + "text": "個別的法案是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1165.wav", + "text": "有代表性所以我也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1166.wav", + "text": "不應當限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1167.wav", + "text": "法案的協商只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1168.wav", + "text": "3位黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1169.wav", + "text": "鞭另外的人員出席人員要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1170.wav", + "text": "黨團同意我覺得這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1171.wav", + "text": "非常怪我講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1172.wav", + "text": "非常公平的事情\n同樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1173.wav", + "text": "的原則跟原理也運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1174.wav", + "text": "在預算的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1175.wav", + "text": "一樣預算協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1176.wav", + "text": "的時候當然該委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1177.wav", + "text": "一定要能夠是受邀的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1178.wav", + "text": "必然列席人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1179.wav", + "text": "以及某些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1180.wav", + "text": "議案的某一個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1181.wav", + "text": "一直堅持這個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1182.wav", + "text": "就是要砍他就是要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1183.wav", + "text": "他有堅強強大的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1184.wav", + "text": "他必須要來到協商的現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1185.wav", + "text": "論述給大家聽那他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1186.wav", + "text": "當然也是要在列席之列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1187.wav", + "text": "所以我對剛剛主席的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1188.wav", + "text": "裁示我要提出這個實務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1189.wav", + "text": "以我過去9年非常資淺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1190.wav", + "text": "淺的國會運作的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1191.wav", + "text": "我想提出我的分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1192.wav", + "text": "\n第三件事情就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1193.wav", + "text": "如果說要限制今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1194.wav", + "text": "每一次的發言是5分鐘我尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1195.wav", + "text": "但是次數我認為不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1196.wav", + "text": "限制我再次說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1197.wav", + "text": "今天的3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1198.wav", + "text": "法案是N兆元的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1199.wav", + "text": "給我50次的發言時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1200.wav", + "text": "我都非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1201.wav", + "text": "想要把握這個時間所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1202.wav", + "text": "次數是不宜限制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1203.wav", + "text": "也不應該限制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1204.wav", + "text": "同樣地我們在場有非常多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1205.wav", + "text": "出席官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1206.wav", + "text": "今天主責的主涉的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1207.wav", + "text": "有我們的交通部國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1208.wav", + "text": "也必須讓官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1209.wav", + "text": "有充分合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1210.wav", + "text": "回答時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1211.wav", + "text": "他們才能夠基於他們的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1212.wav", + "text": "來說明每一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1213.wav", + "text": "是可行不可行合理不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1214.wav", + "text": "不是只有立委有發言權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1215.wav", + "text": "而是代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1216.wav", + "text": "也有一點點不太理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1217.wav", + "text": "因為有3個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1218.wav", + "text": "如果依交通委員會送審排完的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1219.wav", + "text": "順序第一個案應該是花東快速道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1220.wav", + "text": "發給我們的資料第一個好像是高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1221.wav", + "text": "高鐵是第二個交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1222.wav", + "text": "審查的所以我不知道這個程序的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1223.wav", + "text": "安排是不是有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1224.wav", + "text": "特別的考量\n好我現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1225.wav", + "text": "剩最後10秒鐘謝謝孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1226.wav", + "text": "給我你的計時器我會遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1227.wav", + "text": "我的時間我的幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1228.wav", + "text": "就反映給大家剛剛好非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1229.wav", + "text": "精準5分鐘謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1230.wav", + "text": "傅總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1231.wav", + "text": "我在這裡要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1232.wav", + "text": "讓本院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1233.wav", + "text": "院長及本院委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1234.wav", + "text": "還有全國國人來瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1235.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵路網國道6號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1236.wav", + "text": "這個都是經過長年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1237.wav", + "text": "的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1238.wav", + "text": "年在立法院表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1239.wav", + "text": "而且希望納入前瞻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1240.wav", + "text": "基礎計畫結果民進黨反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1241.wav", + "text": "把這個案子封殺了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1242.wav", + "text": "已經經過8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1243.wav", + "text": "年不斷地一再地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1244.wav", + "text": "重複地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1245.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵2021" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1246.wav", + "text": "王部長說出環島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1247.wav", + "text": "高鐵不是夢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1248.wav", + "text": "經過本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1249.wav", + "text": "跟蘇貞昌蘇院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1250.wav", + "text": "在院會多次的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1251.wav", + "text": "包括陳建仁陳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1252.wav", + "text": "院長我們都有多次的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1253.wav", + "text": "對這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1254.wav", + "text": "他們都持正面的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1255.wav", + "text": "我們今天提出的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1256.wav", + "text": "正是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1257.wav", + "text": "有經過委員會跟院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1258.wav", + "text": "的討論過才把它正式地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1259.wav", + "text": "地提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1260.wav", + "text": "\n再過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1261.wav", + "text": "國道6號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1262.wav", + "text": "2020年3月4日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1263.wav", + "text": "在交通委員會就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1264.wav", + "text": "做成決議要開始探勘等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1265.wav", + "text": "然後民進黨延遲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1266.wav", + "text": "這在去年年底來發包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1267.wav", + "text": "2020年3月4日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1268.wav", + "text": "在交通委員會就已經通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1269.wav", + "text": "但到2023年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1270.wav", + "text": "12月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1271.wav", + "text": "才正式發包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1272.wav", + "text": "立法院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1273.wav", + "text": "甚至在立法院都有表決過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1274.wav", + "text": "尤其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1275.wav", + "text": "花東快速道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1276.wav", + "text": "是在2017年前瞻基礎計畫的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1277.wav", + "text": "徐榛蔚立委提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1278.wav", + "text": "但是被民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1279.wav", + "text": "立委在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1280.wav", + "text": "以挾多數暴力的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1281.wav", + "text": "來否決了這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1282.wav", + "text": "在這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1283.wav", + "text": "2024總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1284.wav", + "text": "民進黨所提名的花蓮區的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1285.wav", + "text": "立法委員候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1286.wav", + "text": "及臺東區的立法委員候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1287.wav", + "text": "都把它列為主要政見的第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1288.wav", + "text": "上網查就可以查得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1289.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統當選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1290.wav", + "text": "在競選的時候也到花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1291.wav", + "text": "表示花東快他們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1292.wav", + "text": "支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1293.wav", + "text": "所以本席只是把所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1294.wav", + "text": "這些政治人物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1295.wav", + "text": "對人民的承諾付諸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1296.wav", + "text": "條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1297.wav", + "text": "來進行推動及實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1298.wav", + "text": "而這一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1299.wav", + "text": "這幾個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1300.wav", + "text": "都在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1301.wav", + "text": "交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1302.wav", + "text": "以及經濟委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1303.wav", + "text": "經過了完整的詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1304.wav", + "text": "但是蠻遺憾的是詢答完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1305.wav", + "text": "在委員會召委擇期召集處理的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1306.wav", + "text": "民進黨都選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1307.wav", + "text": "缺席不出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1308.wav", + "text": "然後再用各種扭曲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1309.wav", + "text": "睜著眼睛說謊話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1310.wav", + "text": "大概說謊說久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1311.wav", + "text": "認為說謊就是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1312.wav", + "text": "這些都經過長年的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1313.wav", + "text": "而且委員會也正式詢答過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1314.wav", + "text": "但是唯獨在朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1315.wav", + "text": "民進黨惡意地缺席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1316.wav", + "text": "然後再來韓院長這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1317.wav", + "text": "把這裡韓院長主持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1318.wav", + "text": "朝野協商當秀場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1319.wav", + "text": "不斷在呼天搶地說沒有討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1320.wav", + "text": "\n我們要再一次地表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1321.wav", + "text": "在當時王金平院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1322.wav", + "text": "所提出來的生技條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1323.wav", + "text": "柯建銘總召也是連署人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1324.wav", + "text": "他們也是共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1325.wav", + "text": "在協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1326.wav", + "text": "一起來推這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1327.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂院長不能執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1328.wav", + "text": "立法委員的職務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1329.wav", + "text": "再看到蘇嘉全院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1330.wav", + "text": "連黨產條例他都是連署人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1331.wav", + "text": "他一樣召集朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1332.wav", + "text": "我們要特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1333.wav", + "text": "蘇嘉全院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1334.wav", + "text": "有多少案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1335.wav", + "text": "是他個人連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1336.wav", + "text": "也參與朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1337.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得韓院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1338.wav", + "text": "不要讓這些不實的謠言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1339.wav", + "text": "行使職權上有任何恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1340.wav", + "text": "威脅或者謠言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1341.wav", + "text": "重傷都不要怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1342.wav", + "text": "我們是依照我們自己的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1343.wav", + "text": "在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1344.wav", + "text": "我要特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1345.wav", + "text": "依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1346.wav", + "text": "大法官解釋463號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1347.wav", + "text": "解釋令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1348.wav", + "text": "如果多數立法委員審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1349.wav", + "text": "就是在審議整個預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1350.wav", + "text": "我們本來就可以刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1351.wav", + "text": "也可以請行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1352.wav", + "text": "自行來做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1353.wav", + "text": "剛剛有沒有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1354.wav", + "text": "是否增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1355.wav", + "text": "預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1356.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1357.wav", + "text": "我們這個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1358.wav", + "text": "是增加預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1359.wav", + "text": "那是預算案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1360.wav", + "text": "並不是法律案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1361.wav", + "text": "預算案的時候我們不能增加預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1362.wav", + "text": "但是法律案我們本來就可以提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1363.wav", + "text": "我要特別在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1364.wav", + "text": "跟全國國人還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1365.wav", + "text": "我們立法院同仁來做個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1366.wav", + "text": "從過去到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1367.wav", + "text": "這個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1368.wav", + "text": "非常的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1369.wav", + "text": "在民國90年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1370.wav", + "text": "10月11日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1371.wav", + "text": "基隆河流域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1372.wav", + "text": "整治特別條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1373.wav", + "text": "由廖學廣委員所提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1374.wav", + "text": "在立法院三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1375.wav", + "text": "在95年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1376.wav", + "text": "1月13日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1377.wav", + "text": "石門水庫及其集水區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1378.wav", + "text": "整治特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1379.wav", + "text": "也是三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1380.wav", + "text": "所提出來都三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1381.wav", + "text": "立法院通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1382.wav", + "text": "行政院並沒有提出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1383.wav", + "text": "但是行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1384.wav", + "text": "也分別地編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1385.wav", + "text": "也都執行完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1386.wav", + "text": "我們所有都是依法在辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1387.wav", + "text": "多年的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1388.wav", + "text": "甚至環島高鐵是交通部主動提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1389.wav", + "text": "我們再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1390.wav", + "text": "這個10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1391.wav", + "text": "今天提出的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1392.wav", + "text": "大家都可以來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1393.wav", + "text": "但是這完全是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1394.wav", + "text": "合法而且沒有違憲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1395.wav", + "text": "因為過去有這麼多的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1396.wav", + "text": "再過來要特別強調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1397.wav", + "text": "為什麼有所謂10年這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1398.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1399.wav", + "text": "所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1400.wav", + "text": "這些建設等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1401.wav", + "text": "跟民間的力量差太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1402.wav", + "text": "我就舉個最簡單的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1403.wav", + "text": "臺北到宜蘭現在規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1404.wav", + "text": "是11年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1405.wav", + "text": "用政府預算支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1406.wav", + "text": "但是到底要做多少年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1407.wav", + "text": "但是我們反觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1408.wav", + "text": "民間來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1409.wav", + "text": "七年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1410.wav", + "text": "多全部完工通車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1411.wav", + "text": "所以今天是一個很簡單的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1412.wav", + "text": "我們行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1413.wav", + "text": "效率的腐敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1414.wav", + "text": "行政效率的延宕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1415.wav", + "text": "這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1416.wav", + "text": "是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1417.wav", + "text": "交由民間來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1418.wav", + "text": "會比政府的效率更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1419.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1420.wav", + "text": "執政黨不要在這裡抹黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1421.wav", + "text": "這裡完全沒有所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1422.wav", + "text": "錢坑法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1423.wav", + "text": "如果對行政院編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1424.wav", + "text": "有意見沒有關係我們可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1425.wav", + "text": "行政院編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1426.wav", + "text": "可以拿掉委託民間BOT來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1427.wav", + "text": "政府零出資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1428.wav", + "text": "我們也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1429.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵國道6號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1430.wav", + "text": "都由民間來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1431.wav", + "text": "國內國際BOT標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1432.wav", + "text": "沒有問題政府零出資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1433.wav", + "text": "我們也接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1434.wav", + "text": "不要再污名化這是錢坑法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1435.wav", + "text": "這是國家要做的基礎建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1436.wav", + "text": "早就應該要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1437.wav", + "text": "臺灣已經跟全世界脫節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1438.wav", + "text": "就是腐敗的行政體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1439.wav", + "text": "花東快是賴清德總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1440.wav", + "text": "到花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1441.wav", + "text": "所承諾的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1442.wav", + "text": "更是從2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1443.wav", + "text": "討論到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1444.wav", + "text": "當時民進黨以多數暴力在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1445.wav", + "text": "在前瞻基礎計畫的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1446.wav", + "text": "把它否決掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1447.wav", + "text": "這是最基本的基礎建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1448.wav", + "text": "卑微的應該要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1449.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟這次的大地震" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1450.wav", + "text": "我們大家都看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1451.wav", + "text": "這次的大地震" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1452.wav", + "text": "清朝時代走的路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1453.wav", + "text": "我們現在還在給花東人走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1454.wav", + "text": "蘇花公路埋掉了多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1455.wav", + "text": "這次台8線埋掉了多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1456.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1457.wav", + "text": "蘇花改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1458.wav", + "text": "卻是最安全的一條路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1459.wav", + "text": "沒有任何人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1460.wav", + "text": "在蘇花改有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1461.wav", + "text": "這次大地震的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1462.wav", + "text": "蘇花改也成為避難所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1463.wav", + "text": "所以我們要特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1464.wav", + "text": "新的路廊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1465.wav", + "text": "本來就應該要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1466.wav", + "text": "這是政府虧欠東部人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1467.wav", + "text": "早就應該要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1468.wav", + "text": "稍微等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1469.wav", + "text": "麻煩請交通部王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1470.wav", + "text": "國家發展委員會高副主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1471.wav", + "text": "要不要簡短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1472.wav", + "text": "等一下院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1473.wav", + "text": "或者說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1474.wav", + "text": "請準備一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1475.wav", + "text": "馬上會請兩位發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1476.wav", + "text": "我來裁決一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1477.wav", + "text": "馬上會請兩位發言請準備一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1478.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1479.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1480.wav", + "text": "你到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1481.wav", + "text": "在講什麼我搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1482.wav", + "text": "賴清德是講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1483.wav", + "text": "花東快在交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1484.wav", + "text": "也在做可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1485.wav", + "text": "嘛8月份才會出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1486.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1487.wav", + "text": "不講這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1488.wav", + "text": "講一個憲政框架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1489.wav", + "text": "這比較重要吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1490.wav", + "text": "就是說整個憲政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1491.wav", + "text": "體制上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1492.wav", + "text": "應該是怎樣的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1493.wav", + "text": "行政權是行政權的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1494.wav", + "text": "立法權是立法權的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1495.wav", + "text": "剛才吳思瑤也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1496.wav", + "text": "我剛才也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1497.wav", + "text": "這裡面還有391264" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1498.wav", + "text": "還有大法官釋字520585" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1499.wav", + "text": "憲法第7條憲法從第58條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1500.wav", + "text": "開始看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1501.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1502.wav", + "text": "你要講BOT" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1503.wav", + "text": "是另外的現在本來就有BOT條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1504.wav", + "text": "例兩個法案的性質是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1505.wav", + "text": "\n院長我現在講一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1506.wav", + "text": "請你不要再介意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1507.wav", + "text": "今年34月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1508.wav", + "text": "羅委員的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1509.wav", + "text": "民主改革營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1510.wav", + "text": "副院長也去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1511.wav", + "text": "你講一句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1512.wav", + "text": "民主實在太可愛了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1513.wav", + "text": "可以理性對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1514.wav", + "text": "但是我們沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1515.wav", + "text": "我講錯你來指正我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1516.wav", + "text": "你講錯我來指正你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1517.wav", + "text": "今天我要講的就是傅崐萁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1518.wav", + "text": "你不要把很多不同的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1519.wav", + "text": "而且根本沒有邏輯基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1520.wav", + "text": "那是2012年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1521.wav", + "text": "到了2016年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1522.wav", + "text": "我們修改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1523.wav", + "text": "使法立法院組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1524.wav", + "text": "院長必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1525.wav", + "text": "退出黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1526.wav", + "text": "同時也要議事中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1527.wav", + "text": "所以我說院長不宜再去提法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1528.wav", + "text": "是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1529.wav", + "text": "他坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1530.wav", + "text": "況且這個法案裡面充滿違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1531.wav", + "text": "現在你倒過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1532.wav", + "text": "是編預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1533.wav", + "text": "馬英九執政時期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1534.wav", + "text": "101年的時候王廷升就提這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1535.wav", + "text": "但馬英九不敢讓他過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1536.wav", + "text": "2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1537.wav", + "text": "今天你捲土重來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1538.wav", + "text": "你說在立法院討論多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1539.wav", + "text": "但立法院這一屆才開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1540.wav", + "text": "現在才開始討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1541.wav", + "text": "所以已經是不同的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1542.wav", + "text": "屆期也不連續了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1543.wav", + "text": "所以今天要談的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1544.wav", + "text": "可以這樣搞嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1545.wav", + "text": "我們先談清楚這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1546.wav", + "text": "環島高當然現在你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1547.wav", + "text": "根本不是環島高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1548.wav", + "text": "那個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1549.wav", + "text": "本來就有BOT條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1550.wav", + "text": "坦白講就有BOT條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1551.wav", + "text": "BOT是沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1552.wav", + "text": "BOT有自辦也有政府辦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1553.wav", + "text": "所以我要講說兩個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1554.wav", + "text": "層次是不一樣的尤其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1555.wav", + "text": "花東快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1556.wav", + "text": "它很清楚是違反憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1557.wav", + "text": "你可以這樣編以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1558.wav", + "text": "接下去你還有新中橫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1559.wav", + "text": "那個才厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1560.wav", + "text": "因為東部地質非常糟糕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1561.wav", + "text": "一定要環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1562.wav", + "text": "這些都沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1563.wav", + "text": "你要限制什麼都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1564.wav", + "text": "尤其你要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1565.wav", + "text": "你就隨便寫一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1566.wav", + "text": "我看不大懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1567.wav", + "text": "國際主權基金是哪一國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1568.wav", + "text": "是中國的一帶一路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1569.wav", + "text": "還是什麼的國際主權基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1570.wav", + "text": "所以今天我們要提的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1571.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1572.wav", + "text": "你是一個非常關鍵的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1573.wav", + "text": "我們今天還沒進入逐條現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1574.wav", + "text": "先把很多遊戲規則講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1575.wav", + "text": "因為這一屆大家都新來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1576.wav", + "text": "很多都新來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1577.wav", + "text": "所以過去立法院應該怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1578.wav", + "text": "大家能夠把民主好好的再完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1579.wav", + "text": "實踐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1580.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂限制5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1581.wav", + "text": "限制次數的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1582.wav", + "text": "你對行政部門要不要給它限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1583.wav", + "text": "行政部門有時候要解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1584.wav", + "text": "有時候司法院要解釋這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1585.wav", + "text": "怎麼判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1586.wav", + "text": "和法務部有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1587.wav", + "text": "也會在這裡爭辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1588.wav", + "text": "啊交通部要解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1589.wav", + "text": "所以在民主的發展上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1590.wav", + "text": "說限制5分鐘3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1591.wav", + "text": "說5分鐘太多3分鐘就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1592.wav", + "text": "這是絕對不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1593.wav", + "text": "反正我們今天少數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1594.wav", + "text": "我們就認定了到最後表決一定會輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1595.wav", + "text": "我們一定會認定這個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1596.wav", + "text": "我曾經也是表決過30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1597.wav", + "text": "我們都走過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1598.wav", + "text": "了我們也曾經8年表決都贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1599.wav", + "text": "所以今天情勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1600.wav", + "text": "朝小野大我們也認定這個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1601.wav", + "text": "我們表決都會輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1602.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1603.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1604.wav", + "text": "針對這個協商的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1605.wav", + "text": "員發言完畢後請吳思瑤委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1606.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員發言完畢後就請王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1607.wav", + "text": "以及高副主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1608.wav", + "text": "準備發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1609.wav", + "text": "我就沒有按照順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1610.wav", + "text": "另外不是三長的委員出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1611.wav", + "text": "我是不想讓氣氛太過於緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1612.wav", + "text": "所以我走出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1613.wav", + "text": "了本來我們在朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1614.wav", + "text": "程序性的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1615.wav", + "text": "但實質性的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1616.wav", + "text": "其實朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1617.wav", + "text": "大家都走來走去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1618.wav", + "text": "各個政黨也都不會去反對比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1619.wav", + "text": "我們很快就會討論到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1620.wav", + "text": "這一些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1621.wav", + "text": "你說農業縣的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1622.wav", + "text": "甚至於召委沒讓他進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1623.wav", + "text": "讓我們這些比較都市的委員來討論這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1624.wav", + "text": "通嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1625.wav", + "text": "也不太對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1626.wav", + "text": "譬如涉及到整個醫療的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1627.wav", + "text": "或者涉及到整個點數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1628.wav", + "text": "怎麼計價的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1629.wav", + "text": "這也好奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1630.wav", + "text": "真的好奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1631.wav", + "text": "所以那天在講我本來要跟你補一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1632.wav", + "text": "我們本來三長講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1633.wav", + "text": "在慣例上其實都是程序性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1634.wav", + "text": "實質性的東西本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1635.wav", + "text": "由各委員會的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1636.wav", + "text": "這才是合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1637.wav", + "text": "院長的職務本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1638.wav", + "text": "讓整個議案或立法的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1639.wav", + "text": "即整個立法院議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1640.wav", + "text": "議事程序的進行更順遂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1641.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛傅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1642.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1643.wav", + "text": "雪隧才12.9公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1644.wav", + "text": "蓋了二十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1645.wav", + "text": "行政效率那麼差那麼貪腐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1646.wav", + "text": "我不會這樣去想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1647.wav", + "text": "被列入大英百科全書裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1648.wav", + "text": "大家覺得這是臺灣很不簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1649.wav", + "text": "\n工程上會有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1650.wav", + "text": "有些工期長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1651.wav", + "text": "有時候你不要以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1652.wav", + "text": "人定勝天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1653.wav", + "text": "我剛剛私底下也跟傅總召講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1654.wav", + "text": "我不是反對花蓮的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1655.wav", + "text": "不是反對臺東的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1656.wav", + "text": "高鐵到臺東到花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1657.wav", + "text": "高鐵沒有到屏東永遠沒辦法到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1658.wav", + "text": "來推動嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1659.wav", + "text": "高鐵現在到屏東六塊厝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1660.wav", + "text": "十幾年再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1661.wav", + "text": "來行政院核定的是要到潮州" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1662.wav", + "text": "你要來個案幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1663.wav", + "text": "推動到了潮州以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1664.wav", + "text": "你再去想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1665.wav", + "text": "路廊要怎麼走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1666.wav", + "text": "合理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1667.wav", + "text": "你去看看1987年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1668.wav", + "text": "台灣高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1669.wav", + "text": "研究了快4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1670.wav", + "text": "當初是怎麼樣叫行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1671.wav", + "text": "指示交通部去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1672.wav", + "text": "可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1673.wav", + "text": "立法院沒那麼���害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1674.wav", + "text": "立法院沒有辦法去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1675.wav", + "text": "我們不要外行領導內行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1676.wav", + "text": "想到什麼就想去做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1677.wav", + "text": "沒那麼簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1678.wav", + "text": "好像變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1679.wav", + "text": "行政院來做立法院的行政局就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1680.wav", + "text": "這個也不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1681.wav", + "text": "回到原來剛剛院長講那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1682.wav", + "text": "我認為程序性確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1683.wav", + "text": "真的是三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1684.wav", + "text": "但是實質性的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1685.wav", + "text": "議案不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1686.wav", + "text": "要讓不同專業的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1687.wav", + "text": "可以進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1688.wav", + "text": "難免啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1689.wav", + "text": "至於立法院裡面你剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1690.wav", + "text": "剛剛講四個字叫做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1691.wav", + "text": "怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1692.wav", + "text": "回兩個人見了面就要對幹了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1693.wav", + "text": "要怎麼輕聲細語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1694.wav", + "text": "有時候我講話大聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1695.wav", + "text": "院長看到我的眼神也知道很溫柔對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1696.wav", + "text": "大聲不一定叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1697.wav", + "text": "只要讓它可以更順遂地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1698.wav", + "text": "去進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1699.wav", + "text": "我覺得院長怎麼裁示都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1700.wav", + "text": "合理但不要說用同意的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1701.wav", + "text": "程序跟實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1702.wav", + "text": "本來就有所不同好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1703.wav", + "text": "謝謝莊瑞雄委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1704.wav", + "text": "我補充兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1705.wav", + "text": "第一我是說我們在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1706.wav", + "text": "彼此聊天的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1707.wav", + "text": "請黨團幹部約束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1708.wav", + "text": "讓大家儘量輕聲細語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1709.wav", + "text": "不是說質詢的委員輕聲細語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1710.wav", + "text": "那這個質詢起來還有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1711.wav", + "text": "震撼性或者威力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1712.wav", + "text": "在聊天的時候不要喧嘩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1713.wav", + "text": "大家輕聲細語是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1714.wav", + "text": "第二不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1715.wav", + "text": "如果大家都在講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1716.wav", + "text": "的的確確很像菜市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1717.wav", + "text": "你自己去看一看那個錄影帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1718.wav", + "text": "至於您剛剛所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1719.wav", + "text": "請相關委員會說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1720.wav", + "text": "如果各位黨團同意的話授權給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1721.wav", + "text": "我下次提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1722.wav", + "text": "我把文字嘗試性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1723.wav", + "text": "修正為至於其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1724.wav", + "text": "議案除各委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1725.wav", + "text": "院會說明人之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1726.wav", + "text": "為外圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1727.wav", + "text": "有增加其他委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1728.wav", + "text": "參加的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1729.wav", + "text": "經過各黨團都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1730.wav", + "text": "我們就允許相關的委員來參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1731.wav", + "text": "類似像這樣的一個文字精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1732.wav", + "text": "我們修正完我下次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1733.wav", + "text": "提出來但是不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1734.wav", + "text": "剛剛幾位委員講得很有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1735.wav", + "text": "等等這的的確確是說不過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1736.wav", + "text": "所以我嘗試性的下一週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1737.wav", + "text": "週把文字修正再跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1738.wav", + "text": "這樣好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1739.wav", + "text": "\n好接下來請吳思瑤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1740.wav", + "text": "發言完以後請交通部王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1741.wav", + "text": "還有國家發展委員會高副主委準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1742.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1743.wav", + "text": "我會努力輕聲細語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1744.wav", + "text": "我一直認為講話若是有道理就不必大聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1745.wav", + "text": "對講話若是有道理就不必大聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1746.wav", + "text": "而且問政質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1747.wav", + "text": "也不是為了要求什麼威力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1748.wav", + "text": "震撼性我都不這樣認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1749.wav", + "text": "據理力爭我們說話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1750.wav", + "text": "有道理不用大聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1751.wav", + "text": "回應一下傅崐萁總召剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1752.wav", + "text": "其實事實很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1753.wav", + "text": "交通建設在花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1754.wav", + "text": "我們都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1755.wav", + "text": "而事實上關心花東建設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1756.wav", + "text": "發展民進黨執政的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1757.wav", + "text": "八年是最用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1758.wav", + "text": "到目前為止對於花東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1759.wav", + "text": "的交通建設整個民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1760.wav", + "text": "政府八年投入了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1761.wav", + "text": "5,200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1762.wav", + "text": "已經投入了2,200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1763.wav", + "text": "所以照顧花東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1764.wav", + "text": "民進黨政府最用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1765.wav", + "text": "已經來主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1766.wav", + "text": "有人沒有輕聲細語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1767.wav", + "text": "就傅崐萁總召又在用這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1768.wav", + "text": "很奇怪的笑聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1769.wav", + "text": "干擾本席的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1770.wav", + "text": "第二個就講剛剛傅總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1771.wav", + "text": "說的花東快速公路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1772.wav", + "text": "其實早在過去國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1773.wav", + "text": "執政的時候馬英九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1774.wav", + "text": "政府執政的時候交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1775.wav", + "text": "就已經提出一個可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1776.wav", + "text": "評估對不對等一下王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1777.wav", + "text": "可以回應王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1778.wav", + "text": "花東快速公路建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1779.wav", + "text": "在104年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1780.wav", + "text": "交通部的可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1781.wav", + "text": "是被馬英九總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1782.wav", + "text": "任內打回票的你等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1783.wav", + "text": "可以再說明是不是我說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1784.wav", + "text": "正確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1785.wav", + "text": "是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1786.wav", + "text": "想方設法針對花東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1787.wav", + "text": "快速公路的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1788.wav", + "text": "在蔡英文總統上任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1789.wav", + "text": "以後109年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1790.wav", + "text": "重啟了這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1791.wav", + "text": "建設案的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1792.wav", + "text": "評估再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1793.wav", + "text": "有關傅崐萁總召今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1794.wav", + "text": "的花東快速公路建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1795.wav", + "text": "馬英九執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1796.wav", + "text": "104年打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1797.wav", + "text": "回票了交通部的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1798.wav", + "text": "評估也就是馬英九否認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1799.wav", + "text": "否定了這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1800.wav", + "text": "但是民進黨政府上臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1801.wav", + "text": "蔡英文總統讓這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1802.wav", + "text": "重啟評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1803.wav", + "text": "死灰復燃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1804.wav", + "text": "重新能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1805.wav", + "text": "被討論花東能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1806.wav", + "text": "被發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1807.wav", + "text": "所以道理講清楚說明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1808.wav", + "text": "照顧花東建設立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1809.wav", + "text": "當然大家都關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1810.wav", + "text": "但是行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1811.wav", + "text": "做最多重啟評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1812.wav", + "text": "的是蔡英文執政的交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1813.wav", + "text": "而且今年8月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1814.wav", + "text": "就要有可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1815.wav", + "text": "評估的完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1816.wav", + "text": "既然行政部門經過他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1817.wav", + "text": "交通評估的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1818.wav", + "text": "提出一個完整的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1819.wav", + "text": "評估那為什麼立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1820.wav", + "text": "需要在現在用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1821.wav", + "text": "個別立委特別條例的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1822.wav", + "text": "呢這是要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1823.wav", + "text": "是在割稻尾嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1824.wav", + "text": "是在搶功勞嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1825.wav", + "text": "為了花東的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1826.wav", + "text": "功勞是大家一起努力推動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1827.wav", + "text": "成行成案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1828.wav", + "text": "是我們共同的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1829.wav", + "text": "\n然後我再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1830.wav", + "text": "在高鐵的這個提案裡傅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1831.wav", + "text": "員說要限期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1832.wav", + "text": "十年完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1833.wav", + "text": "而高鐵的這個特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1834.wav", + "text": "條例你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1835.wav", + "text": "你所提的條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1836.wav", + "text": "只有10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1837.wav", + "text": "對於環島高鐵傅崐萁委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1838.wav", + "text": "就押了要限期十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1839.wav", + "text": "完成大家可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1840.wav", + "text": "回溯一下我如果講錯等一下王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1841.wav", + "text": "可以指正我就是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1842.wav", + "text": "已經完成的臺灣高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1843.wav", + "text": "是從民國76年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1844.wav", + "text": "開始可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1845.wav", + "text": "通過可行性評估然後開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1846.wav", + "text": "進行所有的招標程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1847.wav", + "text": "開始進行所有的施工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1848.wav", + "text": "興建到完工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1849.wav", + "text": "是民國96年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1850.wav", + "text": "現行的高鐵是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1851.wav", + "text": "經過了76年到96年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1852.wav", + "text": "從第一個可行性評估到最後完工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1853.wav", + "text": "它就要二十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1854.wav", + "text": "現在傅崐萁委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1855.wav", + "text": "提案要求十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1856.wav", + "text": "就要完成誰做得到呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1857.wav", + "text": "這就是這個條文不合理的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1858.wav", + "text": "更何況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1859.wav", + "text": "很多臺灣的地質受損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1860.wav", + "text": "還需要更嚴謹的環境影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1861.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1862.wav", + "text": "\n最後一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1863.wav", + "text": "剛剛因為傅總召提了過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1864.wav", + "text": "賴清德主席如何如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1865.wav", + "text": "如何如何那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1866.wav", + "text": "我也只好拿出過去傅崐萁委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1867.wav", + "text": "在2017年5月8號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1868.wav", + "text": "接受專訪的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1869.wav", + "text": "這是傅崐萁總召說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1870.wav", + "text": "今天民進黨提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1871.wav", + "text": "前瞻建設4,200億預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1872.wav", + "text": "興建輕軌跟捷運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1873.wav", + "text": "未來的營運會虧損多少呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1874.wav", + "text": "國家要把這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1875.wav", + "text": "講給國民聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1876.wav", + "text": "才可以來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1877.wav", + "text": "這是2017年5月8號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1878.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁委員的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1879.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1880.wav", + "text": "審查任何的交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1881.wav", + "text": "都要好好的說給國民聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1882.wav", + "text": "興建的計畫是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1883.wav", + "text": "我支持2017年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1884.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁委員的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1885.wav", + "text": "同樣在我對面的有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1886.wav", + "text": "在2021年10月27號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1887.wav", + "text": "在立法院交通委員會質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1888.wav", + "text": "有關於高鐵環臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1889.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1890.wav", + "text": "可行性評估呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1891.wav", + "text": "要花多少民脂民膏呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1892.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷委員更質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1893.wav", + "text": "高鐵從南港拉到宜蘭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1894.wav", + "text": "就要花1007百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1895.wav", + "text": "那麼環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1896.wav", + "text": "又要花多少錢呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1897.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷委員在2021年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1898.wav", + "text": "10月27號立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1899.wav", + "text": "議事錄交通委會可以找得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1900.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷委員認為這種花大錢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1901.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1902.wav", + "text": "要好好的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1903.wav", + "text": "可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1904.wav", + "text": "所以我就以今天坐在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1905.wav", + "text": "現場的兩位我都非常同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1906.wav", + "text": "你們過去的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1907.wav", + "text": "同樣的現在我們在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1908.wav", + "text": "這個重要的交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1909.wav", + "text": "就應當循交通的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1910.wav", + "text": "進行可行性評估所有的營運計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1911.wav", + "text": "都應當好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1912.wav", + "text": "\n今天一次發言限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1913.wav", + "text": "5分鐘我再講一次給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1914.wav", + "text": "50次發言我都非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1915.wav", + "text": "樂意來跟公共對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1916.wav", + "text": "部長可以回應一下我剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1917.wav", + "text": "幾個問題完整的交通評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1918.wav", + "text": "是什麼現在的花東快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1919.wav", + "text": "是不是就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1920.wav", + "text": "109年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1921.wav", + "text": "蔡英文上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1922.wav", + "text": "讓它重啟評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1923.wav", + "text": "而今年8月就會有可行性評估出爐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1924.wav", + "text": "以及現在的高鐵是花了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1925.wav", + "text": "幾十年的時間去興建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1926.wav", + "text": "這些部分就專業論專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1927.wav", + "text": "需要行政部門來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1928.wav", + "text": "你們兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1929.wav", + "text": "有沒有任何寶貴的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1930.wav", + "text": "第一個是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1931.wav", + "text": "今天院長所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1932.wav", + "text": "建議在程序上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1933.wav", + "text": "進行的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1934.wav", + "text": "我們原則上是贊同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1935.wav", + "text": "這會直接牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1936.wav", + "text": "黨團協商的本質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1937.wav", + "text": "有這個非常特殊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1938.wav", + "text": "黨團協商制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1939.wav", + "text": "在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1940.wav", + "text": "職權行使法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1941.wav", + "text": "相關條文規範得比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1942.wav", + "text": "但是它的本質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1943.wav", + "text": "是針對大家有不一樣意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1944.wav", + "text": "看看可不可以尋求共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1945.wav", + "text": "黨團協商的本質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1946.wav", + "text": "是共識決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1947.wav", + "text": "而共識決就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1948.wav", + "text": "如果有人不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1949.wav", + "text": "協商就不成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1950.wav", + "text": "也正是因為這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1951.wav", + "text": "所以黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1952.wav", + "text": "其實也沒有強制出席的效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1953.wav", + "text": "就好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1954.wav", + "text": "我們所召集的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1955.wav", + "text": "我們也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1956.wav", + "text": "所有的人在那邊枯坐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1957.wav", + "text": "等了一個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1958.wav", + "text": "民進黨就是不來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1959.wav", + "text": "浪費其他兩個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1960.wav", + "text": "的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1961.wav", + "text": "我們也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1962.wav", + "text": "就只能很遺憾的說協商不成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1963.wav", + "text": "我相信這個黨團協商的本質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1964.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1965.wav", + "text": "其實掌握得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1966.wav", + "text": "蠻清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1967.wav", + "text": "當然從我們的立場來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1968.wav", + "text": "有的時候院長所召集的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1969.wav", + "text": "我們基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1970.wav", + "text": "都是基於尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1971.wav", + "text": "基於善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1972.wav", + "text": "所以院長召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1973.wav", + "text": "我們其實都把其他的事情排開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1974.wav", + "text": "就坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1975.wav", + "text": "有時候在討論一些問題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1976.wav", + "text": "不是就事論事地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1977.wav", + "text": "而是進行人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1978.wav", + "text": "從人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1979.wav", + "text": "笑的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1980.wav", + "text": "臉部的表情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1981.wav", + "text": "全部都可以成為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1982.wav", + "text": "黨團協商評論的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1983.wav", + "text": "真的就會讓人家不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1984.wav", + "text": "時間的分配跟使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1985.wav", + "text": "到底有什麼意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1986.wav", + "text": "上一次在黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1987.wav", + "text": "針對程序性的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1988.wav", + "text": "我也再次地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1989.wav", + "text": "請教了院長及秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1990.wav", + "text": "事後也有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1991.wav", + "text": "到院會跟兩位確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1992.wav", + "text": "我那天的理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1993.wav", + "text": "沒有錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1994.wav", + "text": "目前立法院的���戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1995.wav", + "text": "是當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1996.wav", + "text": "有黨團拉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1997.wav", + "text": "必須要黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1998.wav", + "text": "那就是強制冷凍一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/1999.wav", + "text": "必須要召集一次的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2000.wav", + "text": "但是那次的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2001.wav", + "text": "並沒有限定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2002.wav", + "text": "一定要是院長召集的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2003.wav", + "text": "換言之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2004.wav", + "text": "也就是在委員會召集過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2005.wav", + "text": "協商不成立了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2006.wav", + "text": "我們接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2007.wav", + "text": "就可以依照規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2008.wav", + "text": "交給院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2009.wav", + "text": "當然黨團如果要選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2010.wav", + "text": "交給院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2011.wav", + "text": "再進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2012.wav", + "text": "也有程序上的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2013.wav", + "text": "拜託院長您再出面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2014.wav", + "text": "看可不可以尋求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2015.wav", + "text": "一定的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2016.wav", + "text": "運作上面的規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2017.wav", + "text": "我相信院長及秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2018.wav", + "text": "都非常非常地清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2019.wav", + "text": "今天針對程序性上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2020.wav", + "text": "的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2021.wav", + "text": "我們先表達我們的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2022.wav", + "text": "就實質上面的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2023.wav", + "text": "我們的黨團有討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2024.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2025.wav", + "text": "有關於重要的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2026.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2027.wav", + "text": "我們會注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2028.wav", + "text": "有關於財政紀律上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2029.wav", + "text": "的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2030.wav", + "text": "特別預算的方式加以編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2031.wav", + "text": "我們其實並不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2032.wav", + "text": "那就排除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2033.wav", + "text": "有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2034.wav", + "text": "預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2035.wav", + "text": "相關的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2036.wav", + "text": "這個我們也不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2037.wav", + "text": "有可行性的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2038.wav", + "text": "行政部門負責任地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2039.wav", + "text": "交由立法院來把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2040.wav", + "text": "確定真的有可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2041.wav", + "text": "的時候我們再往下走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2042.wav", + "text": "因為今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2043.wav", + "text": "也只是協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2044.wav", + "text": "大家表達基本的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2045.wav", + "text": "並沒有要就法條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2046.wav", + "text": "文字去做細部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2047.wav", + "text": "調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2048.wav", + "text": "今天院長所提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2049.wav", + "text": "程序性的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2050.wav", + "text": "以及在交通建設上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2051.wav", + "text": "我們原則上支持建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2052.wav", + "text": "用特別預算的方式加以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2053.wav", + "text": "遵守財政的紀律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2054.wav", + "text": "可行性的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2055.wav", + "text": "大概是我們黨團基本的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2056.wav", + "text": "以上說明謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2057.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃國昌委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2058.wav", + "text": "\n各位黨團幹部我們請行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2059.wav", + "text": "列席的王部長及高副主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2060.wav", + "text": "簡短扼要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2061.wav", + "text": "對我們的特別條例有什麼看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2062.wav", + "text": "請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2063.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2064.wav", + "text": "說明現在整個交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2065.wav", + "text": "都是用行政的中長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2066.wav", + "text": "個案計畫這也是剛才黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2067.wav", + "text": "委員所提的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2068.wav", + "text": "研究綜合規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2069.wav", + "text": "環評設計施工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2070.wav", + "text": "過去很多案子都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2071.wav", + "text": "包括楊梅─頭份的延伸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2072.wav", + "text": "準備要動工了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2073.wav", + "text": "高鐵延伸屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2074.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁委員的蘇花安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2075.wav", + "text": "院長過去在高雄的捷運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2076.wav", + "text": "黃線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2077.wav", + "text": "當時爭取汐止交流道的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2078.wav", + "text": "的國4豐原段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2079.wav", + "text": "新竹輕軌都是按照這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2080.wav", + "text": "好像故意刁難的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2081.wav", + "text": "而是讓這個案子更可行的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2082.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2083.wav", + "text": "不適合用一個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2084.wav", + "text": "進行某一個個案計畫來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2085.wav", + "text": "還是回到剛才談到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2086.wav", + "text": "可行性評估的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2087.wav", + "text": "\n今天這3個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2088.wav", + "text": "國道6號東延花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2089.wav", + "text": "事實上我們現在正在進行中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2090.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2091.wav", + "text": "國6到花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2092.wav", + "text": "銅鑼最大的問題是穿越中央山脈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2093.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在在做路廊的選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2094.wav", + "text": "及地質的探勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2095.wav", + "text": "這個在115年就會完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2096.wav", + "text": "高鐵現在有兩段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2097.wav", + "text": "南邊是到屏東的六塊厝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2098.wav", + "text": "北邊是到宜蘭的縣政中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2099.wav", + "text": "我們都留下了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2100.wav", + "text": "讓它可以延伸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2101.wav", + "text": "高鐵延伸宜蘭屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2102.wav", + "text": "現在在進行綜合規劃及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2103.wav", + "text": "我們會啟動下一階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2104.wav", + "text": "就是屏東潮州" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2105.wav", + "text": "臺東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2106.wav", + "text": "另外宜蘭就是到花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2107.wav", + "text": "最後就是花蓮跟臺東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2108.wav", + "text": "這就是一段一段按照這個程序來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2109.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2110.wav", + "text": "在過去的這兩段也是按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2111.wav", + "text": "這樣的方式來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2112.wav", + "text": "花東快速道路剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2113.wav", + "text": "在104年103年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2114.wav", + "text": "是不可行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2115.wav", + "text": "所以它是中斷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2116.wav", + "text": "在108年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2117.wav", + "text": "提出能夠重啟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2118.wav", + "text": "我們也接受這個主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2119.wav", + "text": "所以我們就重啟了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2120.wav", + "text": "在今年的8月就完成可行性報告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2121.wav", + "text": "如果完成可行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2122.wav", + "text": "接下來就開始走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2123.wav", + "text": "所以這個程序也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2124.wav", + "text": "非常的快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2125.wav", + "text": "全國的陸海空建設非常的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2126.wav", + "text": "每個過去都是遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2127.wav", + "text": "這樣的程序來走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2128.wav", + "text": "這些案子我們加速來辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2129.wav", + "text": "但是不適合用一個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2130.wav", + "text": "這樣每個個案就要多提一個這樣的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2131.wav", + "text": "這是我們的意見謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2132.wav", + "text": "謝謝交通部王部���說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2133.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請國家發展委員會高副主委請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2134.wav", + "text": "好院長還有各黨團的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2135.wav", + "text": "這次的環島高速鐵路的特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2136.wav", + "text": "把國發會列為主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2137.wav", + "text": "我想國發會有兩點意見的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2138.wav", + "text": "政府推動重大交通建設的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2139.wav", + "text": "已經相當明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2140.wav", + "text": "部長也有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2141.wav", + "text": "應該不宜以特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2142.wav", + "text": "的方式來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2143.wav", + "text": "我可能再詳細說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2144.wav", + "text": "一下目前在重大公共建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2145.wav", + "text": "裡面有關中央部會的分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2146.wav", + "text": "基本上就是交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2147.wav", + "text": "整體的交通需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2148.wav", + "text": "然後它會有一個整體的規劃藍圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2149.wav", + "text": "它會辦理可行性研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2150.wav", + "text": "綜合規劃還有一些建設計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2151.wav", + "text": "之後會循所謂的行政院所屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2152.wav", + "text": "中長程個案計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2153.wav", + "text": "提報行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2154.wav", + "text": "然後報行政院以後其實會交國發會審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2155.wav", + "text": "在審議的過程中間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2156.wav", + "text": "要符合所有的相關法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2157.wav", + "text": "比如是環境影響評估水土保持法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2158.wav", + "text": "為什麼要經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2159.wav", + "text": "呢基本上是要確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2160.wav", + "text": "政府的支出具有效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2161.wav", + "text": "而且有助於我們國土的永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2162.wav", + "text": "發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2163.wav", + "text": "我們的交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2164.wav", + "text": "其實依現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2165.wav", + "text": "鐵路法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2166.wav", + "text": "交通建設的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2167.wav", + "text": "剛才其實部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2168.wav", + "text": "有講到西部的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2169.wav", + "text": "高速鐵路目前是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2170.wav", + "text": "如果東部的是由國發會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2171.wav", + "text": "主管的話第一個也不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2172.wav", + "text": "而且同時東西兩部是有不同的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2173.wav", + "text": "第三個有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2174.wav", + "text": "剛才的建設時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2175.wav", + "text": "10年剛才委員也有講過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2176.wav", + "text": "其實我們從可行性研究到真正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2177.wav", + "text": "事實上是耗時了21年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2178.wav", + "text": "所以以上報告謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2179.wav", + "text": "謝謝高副主委的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2180.wav", + "text": "接下來發言次序是柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2181.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2182.wav", + "text": "再接下來林思銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2183.wav", + "text": "銘拜託大家掌握一下時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2184.wav", + "text": "我們不要超過5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2185.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2186.wav", + "text": "我想經大家的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2187.wav", + "text": "應該都是很理性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2188.wav", + "text": "很多現象都浮現地很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2189.wav", + "text": "剛才民眾黨也表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2190.wav", + "text": "他的意見和看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2191.wav", + "text": "大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2192.wav", + "text": "你不要每次講話都說民進黨呼天搶地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2193.wav", + "text": "我們何來呼天搶地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2194.wav", + "text": "威脅恐嚇院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2195.wav", + "text": "這些都是沒有這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2196.wav", + "text": "情我們要把道理講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2197.wav", + "text": "他剛才講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2198.wav", + "text": "高鐵BOT以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2199.wav", + "text": "7年完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2200.wav", + "text": "如果給民進黨做的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2201.wav", + "text": "根本不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2202.wav", + "text": "啊高鐵從民國76年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2203.wav", + "text": "就是解嚴那一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2204.wav", + "text": "蔣經國開始十大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2205.wav", + "text": "然後才開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2206.wav", + "text": "經過幾年才核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2207.wav", + "text": "核定下來以後到1999年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2208.wav", + "text": "開始動工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2209.wav", + "text": "然後完成是在2006" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2210.wav", + "text": "年2006是阿扁時期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2211.wav", + "text": "那時候馬英九還講了一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2212.wav", + "text": "高鐵是廢鐵他在反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2213.wav", + "text": "即便在民進黨執政時期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2214.wav", + "text": "為了增資案還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2215.wav", + "text": "國民黨反對要讓高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2216.wav", + "text": "蓋不起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2217.wav", + "text": "坦白講高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2218.wav", + "text": "沒有高鐵的話會變成怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2219.wav", + "text": "後來又財改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2220.wav", + "text": "後來又增資案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2221.wav", + "text": "然後在2015" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2222.wav", + "text": "民黨還在執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2223.wav", + "text": "時任院長毛治國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2224.wav", + "text": "是交通部長出身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2225.wav", + "text": "的為了高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2226.wav", + "text": "院所有人都在反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2227.wav", + "text": "毛治國還到我辦公室說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2228.wav", + "text": "他想放棄了我說這怎麼可能放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2229.wav", + "text": "後來換我們執政以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2230.wav", + "text": "才把高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2231.wav", + "text": "的財改完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2232.wav", + "text": "我很感謝那時候的兩任董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2233.wav", + "text": "鄭總經理他們都很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2234.wav", + "text": "劉維琪董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2235.wav", + "text": "前面有范志強董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2236.wav", + "text": "能夠讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2237.wav", + "text": "所以才完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2238.wav", + "text": "也就是高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2239.wav", + "text": "能夠完成這是經過非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2240.wav", + "text": "所以沒有所謂的什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2241.wav", + "text": "民進黨在貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2242.wav", + "text": "民進黨是把它完成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2243.wav", + "text": "包括雪隧也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2244.wav", + "text": "雪隧是最困難的游錫堃時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2245.wav", + "text": "今天的主題來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2246.wav", + "text": "剛才兩位部長都談得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2247.wav", + "text": "黃國昌剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2248.wav", + "text": "前面那一段我是有不同意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2249.wav", + "text": "他說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2250.wav", + "text": "朝野協商交給黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2251.wav", + "text": "就可以表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2252.wav", + "text": "那是第7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2253.wav", + "text": "之1定期表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2254.wav", + "text": "有爭執的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2255.wav", + "text": "或是議案要協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2256.wav", + "text": "是回到院長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2257.wav", + "text": "已經這麼多年都是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2258.wav", + "text": "黃委員的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2259.wav", + "text": "今天我們的院長主持朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2260.wav", + "text": "都不應該舉行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2261.wav", + "text": "直接到院會去表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2262.wav", + "text": "這個是民主嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2263.wav", + "text": "你看大家在這裡很多年大家都在做一樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2264.wav", + "text": "怎麼今天突然講不一樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2265.wav", + "text": "回到剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2266.wav", + "text": "黃委員講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2267.wav", + "text": "看起來他也反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2268.wav", + "text": "然後由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2269.wav", + "text": "委員個人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2270.wav", + "text": "這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2271.wav", + "text": "今天假如是這樣的方式當然很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2272.wav", + "text": "我們現在回到權力分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2273.wav", + "text": "力分立原則大家要守住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2274.wav", + "text": "我希望我沒有誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2275.wav", + "text": "我不知道他接下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2276.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2277.wav", + "text": "是要BOT還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2278.wav", + "text": "那是可以討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2279.wav", + "text": "請傅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2280.wav", + "text": "理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2281.wav", + "text": "很多事情不是你想怎麼做就怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2282.wav", + "text": "你對花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2283.wav", + "text": "的交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2284.wav", + "text": "很關心我們都能夠體會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2285.wav", + "text": "但是國家也會照顧的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2286.wav", + "text": "這幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2287.wav", + "text": "交通部在花蓮的交通上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2288.wav", + "text": "花了將近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2289.wav", + "text": "3,000億蘇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2290.wav", + "text": "蘇花改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2291.wav", + "text": "蘇花快都在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2292.wav", + "text": "當然你要再做這三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2293.wav", + "text": "沒有那麼簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2294.wav", + "text": "地質問題環評可行性都要評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2295.wav", + "text": "國家財政都要評估的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2296.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯總召的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2297.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請國民黨黨團傅崐萁總召發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2298.wav", + "text": "今天我從頭到尾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2299.wav", + "text": "都沒提到任何人名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2300.wav", + "text": "但是我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2301.wav", + "text": "已經被N次提到人名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2302.wav", + "text": "在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2303.wav", + "text": "一直到朝野協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2304.wav", + "text": "院長召集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2305.wav", + "text": "所以本席一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2306.wav", + "text": "我們是對事情在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2307.wav", + "text": "民進黨是對人在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2308.wav", + "text": "這就是很奇怪的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2309.wav", + "text": "當然這是個人修養問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2310.wav", + "text": "但是我們還是回到對事的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2311.wav", + "text": "但我要特別提一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2312.wav", + "text": "民眾黨剛剛所提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2313.wav", + "text": "如果要編列特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2314.wav", + "text": "舉債的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2315.wav", + "text": "他們不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2316.wav", + "text": "但是他們願意支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2317.wav", + "text": "交通建設必須要推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2318.wav", + "text": "就是真正的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2319.wav", + "text": "要像這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2320.wav", + "text": "提出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2321.wav", + "text": "而不是完全把人家否定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2322.wav", + "text": "而且不斷的人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2323.wav", + "text": "謾罵等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2324.wav", + "text": "我要再次強調今天到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2325.wav", + "text": "我沒有提任何人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2326.wav", + "text": "姓名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2327.wav", + "text": "這就是為什麼未來我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2328.wav", + "text": "要設立一個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2329.wav", + "text": "從委員會開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2330.wav", + "text": "就一路對人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2331.wav", + "text": "一路攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2332.wav", + "text": "所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2333.wav", + "text": "要求發言是不斷地repeat發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2334.wav", + "text": "但是今天我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2335.wav", + "text": "謝謝民眾黨做一個很好的示範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2336.wav", + "text": "他們表達如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2337.wav", + "text": "要用特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2338.wav", + "text": "或是增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2339.wav", + "text": "他們表示應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2340.wav", + "text": "由政府編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2341.wav", + "text": "不要用特別舉債的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2342.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分我敬表同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2343.wav", + "text": "如果能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2344.wav", + "text": "是地方主要民生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2345.wav", + "text": "交通建設他們都表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2346.wav", + "text": "支持我也謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2347.wav", + "text": "本席剛剛已經講了這麼多的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2348.wav", + "text": "我不曉得是聽不懂還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2349.wav", + "text": "永遠叫不醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2350.wav", + "text": "在過去立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2351.wav", + "text": "已經通過這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2352.wav", + "text": "委員當然是秉持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2353.wav", + "text": "民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2354.wav", + "text": "在政府疏漏的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2355.wav", + "text": "該有的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2356.wav", + "text": "經過立法院國會通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2357.wav", + "text": "當然要來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2358.wav", + "text": "啊過去不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2359.wav", + "text": "本席剛剛都已經講得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2360.wav", + "text": "院會通過以後也都來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2361.wav", + "text": "有沒有貪污腐化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2362.wav", + "text": "這個等國會聽證跟調查權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2363.wav", + "text": "正式國會五法通過了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2364.wav", + "text": "這個會做全面地清查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2365.wav", + "text": "到時候再來看有沒有這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2366.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2367.wav", + "text": "社會大眾大家很多的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2368.wav", + "text": "到時候可以一目了然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2369.wav", + "text": "能夠大放光明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2370.wav", + "text": "\n還是要在這裡再提一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2371.wav", + "text": "今天我要謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2372.wav", + "text": "不過我們還是要強調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2373.wav", + "text": "今天我們是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2374.wav", + "text": "民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2375.wav", + "text": "其實謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2376.wav", + "text": "院長為了要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2377.wav", + "text": "我也找你很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2378.wav", + "text": "也在晚上騷擾你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2379.wav", + "text": "很抱歉希望這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2380.wav", + "text": "儘快來召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2381.wav", + "text": "因為依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2382.wav", + "text": "2016年蘇嘉全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2383.wav", + "text": "院長主持的院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2384.wav", + "text": "協商一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2385.wav", + "text": "期滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2386.wav", + "text": "如果無法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2387.wav", + "text": "達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2388.wav", + "text": "就依立法院職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2389.wav", + "text": "行使法第71條之1的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2390.wav", + "text": "當時在委員會的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2391.wav", + "text": "民進黨拒不出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2392.wav", + "text": "所以朝野協商是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2393.wav", + "text": "已經經過一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2394.wav", + "text": "應該可以送院會來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2395.wav", + "text": "民進黨的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2396.wav", + "text": "還是再請院長來召集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2397.wav", + "text": "絕對沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2398.wav", + "text": "1分鐘還是11分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2399.wav", + "text": "我實在完全聽不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2400.wav", + "text": "這在委員會就討論了多少個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2401.wav", + "text": "為什麼用這麼扭曲的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2402.wav", + "text": "來對一個神聖的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2403.wav", + "text": "建設用這種戲謔的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2404.wav", + "text": "來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2405.wav", + "text": "在立法院都有錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2406.wav", + "text": "委員會有沒有開過有沒有詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2407.wav", + "text": "這個答案都非常清楚的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2408.wav", + "text": "為什麼可以在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2409.wav", + "text": "用這種扭曲的方式來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2410.wav", + "text": "朝野協商時的逐條委員會的逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2411.wav", + "text": "有人參加嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2412.wav", + "text": "民進黨拒不出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2413.wav", + "text": "那你逐條為什麼不來呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2414.wav", + "text": "院長召集的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2415.wav", + "text": "這時候再來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2416.wav", + "text": "什麼1分鐘幾分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2417.wav", + "text": "我覺得大家不要扭曲一個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2418.wav", + "text": "當時委員會的紀錄都可以調出來看的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2419.wav", + "text": "大家不要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2420.wav", + "text": "過度扭曲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2421.wav", + "text": "\n我還是要特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2422.wav", + "text": "為什麼要有年限的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2423.wav", + "text": "大家不斷在強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2424.wav", + "text": "40年前臺灣的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2425.wav", + "text": "現在是民國幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2426.wav", + "text": "了40年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2427.wav", + "text": "要搞19年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2428.wav", + "text": "40年後還要搞19年嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2429.wav", + "text": "是不是我們國家的效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2430.wav", + "text": "就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2431.wav", + "text": "所以本席覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2432.wav", + "text": "我們的政府應該與時俱進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2433.wav", + "text": "2008年5月20號國民黨執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2434.wav", + "text": "經過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2435.wav", + "text": "2年8個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2436.wav", + "text": "2011年1月29號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2437.wav", + "text": "蘇花改動工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2438.wav", + "text": "我再強調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2439.wav", + "text": "2年8個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2440.wav", + "text": "把所有程序全部走完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2441.wav", + "text": "其實蘇花改的動工就很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2442.wav", + "text": "有三段沒有做就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2443.wav", + "text": "當然民進黨取名叫蘇花安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2444.wav", + "text": "我們都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2445.wav", + "text": "但是第一期動工是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2446.wav", + "text": "2011年（民國100年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2447.wav", + "text": "）1月29號動工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2448.wav", + "text": "但是到了2016年（民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2449.wav", + "text": "105年）民進黨執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2450.wav", + "text": "到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2451.wav", + "text": "八年多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2452.wav", + "text": "蘇花安在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2453.wav", + "text": "蘇花安在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2454.wav", + "text": "國民黨2年8個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2455.wav", + "text": "蘇花改動工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2456.wav", + "text": "所有程序完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2457.wav", + "text": "民進黨2016年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2458.wav", + "text": "蘇花安在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2459.wav", + "text": "花東快已經討論了這麼多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2460.wav", + "text": "還要扯到輕軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2461.wav", + "text": "輕軌在臺灣就不適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2462.wav", + "text": "輕軌跟高鐵是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2463.wav", + "text": "何等大的差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2464.wav", + "text": "這個commonsense" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2465.wav", + "text": "臺灣適不適合輕軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2466.wav", + "text": "高鐵已經做在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2467.wav", + "text": "已經很成功的案例在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2468.wav", + "text": "我們今天就是要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2469.wav", + "text": "嘛政府的效率永遠比不上民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2470.wav", + "text": "嘛所以民間來做BOT" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2471.wav", + "text": "我們都很歡迎國內國際的BOT" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2472.wav", + "text": "我們都很歡迎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2473.wav", + "text": "今天不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2474.wav", + "text": "哪一個委員代表誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2475.wav", + "text": "今天國土的平均發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2476.wav", + "text": "本來就該做的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2477.wav", + "text": "到現在都還沒有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2478.wav", + "text": "這不是一個國會議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2479.wav", + "text": "該提出來的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2480.wav", + "text": "不是應該院會來做處理的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2481.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2482.wav", + "text": "我聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2483.wav", + "text": "今天最大的一個笑話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2484.wav", + "text": "到現在在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2485.wav", + "text": "請民進黨政府明天公布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2486.wav", + "text": "剛剛都有錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2487.wav", + "text": "天方夜譚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2488.wav", + "text": "執政8年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2489.wav", + "text": "5,200億在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2490.wav", + "text": "在這裡不要信口雌黃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2491.wav", + "text": "嘛不要把這裡當秀場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2492.wav", + "text": "嚴肅一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2493.wav", + "text": "嘛我到現在為止都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2494.wav", + "text": "指名任何一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2495.wav", + "text": "我希望我們以後在這裡討論是對事對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2496.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2497.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠大家理性討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2498.wav", + "text": "謝謝傅崐萁總召的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2499.wav", + "text": "接下來我們請吳思瑤委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2500.wav", + "text": "然後洪孟楷委員準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2501.wav", + "text": "然後林思銘委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2502.wav", + "text": "我已經唸過發言次序了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2503.wav", + "text": "稍微等一下柯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2504.wav", + "text": "請吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2505.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2506.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2507.wav", + "text": "跟傅總召澄清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2508.wav", + "text": "今天之所以會多次提到您的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2509.wav", + "text": "因為您是這三大法案的提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2510.wav", + "text": "所以一定都會提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2511.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2512.wav", + "text": "也因為今天討論的是您所提的三大法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2513.wav", + "text": "當然就會提到您過去的一些觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2514.wav", + "text": "所以民主就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2515.wav", + "text": "對事不對人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2516.wav", + "text": "我們對事不對人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2517.wav", + "text": "提到名字就是人身攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2518.wav", + "text": "我想這是兩碼子事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2519.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡都非常理性地對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2520.wav", + "text": "對事不對人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2521.wav", + "text": "這是民主應當有的基本的氣度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2522.wav", + "text": "\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2523.wav", + "text": "剛剛我所提的這個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2524.wav", + "text": "就是在交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2525.wav", + "text": "審查的時間都歡迎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2526.wav", + "text": "去看委員會的所有紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2527.wav", + "text": "您剛剛一開始講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2528.wav", + "text": "的我非常同意那7個字委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2529.wav", + "text": "在這三大法案上很可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2530.wav", + "text": "它並沒有被實踐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2531.wav", + "text": "在交通委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2532.wav", + "text": "不管是3月25號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2533.wav", + "text": "4月1號或4月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2534.wav", + "text": "委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2535.wav", + "text": "就是只花加總起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2536.wav", + "text": "來打包協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2537.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分沒有扭曲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2538.wav", + "text": "沒有戲謔完全就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2539.wav", + "text": "就事論事歡迎去調委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2540.wav", + "text": "議事紀錄跟相關的錄影帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2541.wav", + "text": "\n第三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2542.wav", + "text": "我要回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2543.wav", + "text": "也非常支持肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2544.wav", + "text": "剛剛黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2545.wav", + "text": "民眾黨團的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2546.wav", + "text": "所以我綜整黃國昌總召的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2547.wav", + "text": "跟剛剛行政部門的共同回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2548.wav", + "text": "其實也就是民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2549.wav", + "text": "對於這3個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2550.wav", + "text": "長久以來的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2551.wav", + "text": "第一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2552.wav", + "text": "我們需要有完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2553.wav", + "text": "交通專業的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2554.wav", + "text": "重大的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2555.wav", + "text": "一定要有完整的交通專業評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2556.wav", + "text": "我想這是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2557.wav", + "text": "跟民眾黨以及行政部門的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2558.wav", + "text": "第二件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2559.wav", + "text": "這麼大的鉅額的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2560.wav", + "text": "資源的投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2561.wav", + "text": "必須要有非常縝密的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2562.wav", + "text": "財政紀律的財務評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2563.wav", + "text": "所以這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2564.wav", + "text": "民進黨跟民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2565.wav", + "text": "以及行政部門共同的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2566.wav", + "text": "第三個主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2567.wav", + "text": "就是本人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2568.wav", + "text": "一直認為民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2569.wav", + "text": "在憲法的精神下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2570.wav", + "text": "行政權跟立法權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2571.wav", + "text": "各司其職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2572.wav", + "text": "的這個爭點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2573.wav", + "text": "是我一直在這裡試圖論述的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2574.wav", + "text": "這一點是我到目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2575.wav", + "text": "也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2576.wav", + "text": "應當說是民進黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2577.wav", + "text": "強烈主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2578.wav", + "text": "要論述給社會聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2579.wav", + "text": "不能違反憲法第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2580.wav", + "text": "不能違反大法官釋字第613號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2581.wav", + "text": "以及391號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2582.wav", + "text": "但這個部分我不曉得民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2583.wav", + "text": "剛剛是黃總召沒有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2584.wav", + "text": "也許黃總召也認同這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2585.wav", + "text": "但至少我們兩個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2586.wav", + "text": "跟行政部門共同對於財政紀律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2587.wav", + "text": "以及交通專業評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2588.wav", + "text": "都認為在這3個法案上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2589.wav", + "text": "顯然都沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2590.wav", + "text": "俱足所以我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2591.wav", + "text": "非常大膽的冒昧的也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2592.wav", + "text": "既然這個前提本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2593.wav", + "text": "各黨的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2594.wav", + "text": "沒辦法進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2595.wav", + "text": "任何的協商跟進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2596.wav", + "text": "因為在本質上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2597.wav", + "text": "它要用特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2598.wav", + "text": "跳過交通影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2599.wav", + "text": "框十年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2600.wav", + "text": "我認為這三個案子沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2601.wav", + "text": "再討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2602.wav", + "text": "所以我希望這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2603.wav", + "text": "良性對話是非常好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2604.wav", + "text": "我們就法案論法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2605.wav", + "text": "就制度論制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2606.wav", + "text": "大家輕聲細語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2607.wav", + "text": "大家不用咆哮不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2608.wav", + "text": "很激動我都非常同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2609.wav", + "text": "今天是一個很好的示範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2610.wav", + "text": "所以如果這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2611.wav", + "text": "不可行就是不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2612.wav", + "text": "您議事主持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2613.wav", + "text": "智慧看後續怎麼來進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2614.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我們請洪孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2615.wav", + "text": "發言林思銘委員請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2616.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2617.wav", + "text": "兩個小時過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2618.wav", + "text": "我對今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2619.wav", + "text": "失望的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2620.wav", + "text": "根本不是來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2621.wav", + "text": "我們立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2622.wav", + "text": "第十二章黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2623.wav", + "text": "第68條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2624.wav", + "text": "開宗明義強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2625.wav", + "text": "為了協商議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2626.wav", + "text": "或解決爭議事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2627.wav", + "text": "但是兩個小時過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2628.wav", + "text": "看直播的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2629.wav", + "text": "坐在這邊的代表有想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2630.wav", + "text": "解決爭議事項嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2631.wav", + "text": "就是各持己見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2632.wav", + "text": "所以你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2633.wav", + "text": "5分鐘有人已經嗆明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2634.wav", + "text": "要講30次50次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2635.wav", + "text": "那還是一樣沒有想要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2636.wav", + "text": "自己的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2637.wav", + "text": "一開始開宗明義就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2638.wav", + "text": "後來又說不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2639.wav", + "text": "到底你的論點是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2640.wav", + "text": "如果是違憲的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2641.wav", + "text": "抱歉我們在場沒有一個人是大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2642.wav", + "text": "沒有人有資格講出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2643.wav", + "text": "這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2644.wav", + "text": "請提出來讓它變合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2645.wav", + "text": "這也是為什麼我一直強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2646.wav", + "text": "如果今天大家沒有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2647.wav", + "text": "只是各說各的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2648.wav", + "text": "那你根本沒有心來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2649.wav", + "text": "剛剛有委員提到我的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2650.wav", + "text": "我要特別講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2651.wav", + "text": "2021年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2652.wav", + "text": "質詢王國材部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2653.wav", + "text": "先在媒體上說環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2654.wav", + "text": "不是夢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2655.wav", + "text": "我特別質詢他請教你的夢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2656.wav", + "text": "要花多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2657.wav", + "text": "王國材部長答不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2658.wav", + "text": "財政紀律以及相關的配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2659.wav", + "text": "措施當然很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2660.wav", + "text": "你在媒體上面回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2661.wav", + "text": "只講了一個夢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2662.wav", + "text": "但是講不出你的夢要多少錢的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2663.wav", + "text": "那我怎麼有辦法相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2664.wav", + "text": "你有辦法有責任有能力有期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2665.wav", + "text": "所以到現在我還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2666.wav", + "text": "所有的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2667.wav", + "text": "都在我的腦子裡面我不用看資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2668.wav", + "text": "今天大家不是來這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2669.wav", + "text": "比演講比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2670.wav", + "text": "我要的是能不能夠實質討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2671.wav", + "text": "我今天為什麼開宗明義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2672.wav", + "text": "就講其實到目前為止我們都還沒進入條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2673.wav", + "text": "到底是在確定我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2674.wav", + "text": "的協商程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2675.wav", + "text": "還是我們已經進入到實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2676.wav", + "text": "我也沒有辦法確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2677.wav", + "text": "但為什麼規定時間非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2678.wav", + "text": "剛剛我算過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2679.wav", + "text": "發言裡面有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2680.wav", + "text": "違憲預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2681.wav", + "text": "立法邏輯黨團人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2682.wav", + "text": "歷史民主進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2683.wav", + "text": "攝影機限制人數公糧收購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2684.wav", + "text": "所有的主題包山包海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2685.wav", + "text": "全都在他的3分鐘5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2686.wav", + "text": "裡面講出來了那我們怎麼有辦法聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2687.wav", + "text": "所以本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2688.wav", + "text": "很誠摯地建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2689.wav", + "text": "如果今天我們有心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2690.wav", + "text": "大家針對這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2691.wav", + "text": "來做真真正正的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2692.wav", + "text": "一定要安全無虞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2693.wav", + "text": "一定要專業評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2694.wav", + "text": "一定要國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2695.wav", + "text": "能夠永續經營才去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2696.wav", + "text": "不要自己沒看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2697.wav", + "text": "就以為上面沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2698.wav", + "text": "\n最後我只講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2699.wav", + "text": "真的沒辦法進入的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2700.wav", + "text": "各自已經有定見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2701.wav", + "text": "那就只能表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2702.wav", + "text": "因為看起來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2703.wav", + "text": "我們沒辦法透過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2704.wav", + "text": "來解決爭議事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2705.wav", + "text": "也講到昨天的村里長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2706.wav", + "text": "跟民意代表條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2707.wav", + "text": "8個小時馬拉松" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2708.wav", + "text": "到最後可以結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2709.wav", + "text": "我覺得我最有資格講這個話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2710.wav", + "text": "因為我是從頭坐到尾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2711.wav", + "text": "我是堅持到最後一刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2712.wav", + "text": "在場所有委員沒有一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2713.wav", + "text": "除了我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2714.wav", + "text": "沒有一位是坐到最後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2715.wav", + "text": "所以我們昨天能夠逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2716.wav", + "text": "逐條的你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2717.wav", + "text": "1.5個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2718.wav", + "text": "我認為2個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2719.wav", + "text": "你認為地方財政有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2720.wav", + "text": "我認為中央應該編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2721.wav", + "text": "到最後我們共同找出辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2722.wav", + "text": "順利送出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2723.wav", + "text": "那就是逐條的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2724.wav", + "text": "如果今天沒有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2725.wav", + "text": "只要各說各話的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2726.wav", + "text": "主席我認為真的這樣的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2727.wav", + "text": "可以宣告一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2728.wav", + "text": "我們就做後續議事規則的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2729.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2730.wav", + "text": "未來黨團協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2731.wav", + "text": "幾個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2732.wav", + "text": "就只有三長能夠參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2733.wav", + "text": "今天院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2734.wav", + "text": "又更開放的對於相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2735.wav", + "text": "預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2736.wav", + "text": "或者相關重要的議事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2737.wav", + "text": "幾個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2738.wav", + "text": "經過我們黨團的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2739.wav", + "text": "就可以來參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2740.wav", + "text": "我們絕對非常支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2741.wav", + "text": "院長做這個非常用心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2742.wav", + "text": "第二個我對於今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2743.wav", + "text": "整個協商程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2744.wav", + "text": "其實這三個重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2745.wav", + "text": "法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2746.wav", + "text": "我們現在從頭到尾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2747.wav", + "text": "坐了二個多小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2748.wav", + "text": "我們聽到民進黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2749.wav", + "text": "就是心中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2750.wav", + "text": "違憲的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2751.wav", + "text": "所以你們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2752.wav", + "text": "要進入逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2753.wav", + "text": "你們也不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2754.wav", + "text": "啊我想協商的目的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2755.wav", + "text": "最後要達成什麼樣的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2756.wav", + "text": "就是要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2757.wav", + "text": "我們雙方的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2758.wav", + "text": "嘛到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2759.wav", + "text": "我們都沒有任何的交集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2760.wav", + "text": "如何能夠達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2761.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2762.wav", + "text": "為什麼不想講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2763.wav", + "text": "就是想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2764.wav", + "text": "你們到底心中在想什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2765.wav", + "text": "這種已經有定見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2766.wav", + "text": "對這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2767.wav", + "text": "一直在主張是違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2768.wav", + "text": "而不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2769.wav", + "text": "很認真的來看真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2770.wav", + "text": "這幾個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2771.wav", + "text": "我們講的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2772.wav", + "text": "就否定說這違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2773.wav", + "text": "啦這不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2774.wav", + "text": "啦那這樣永遠���有交集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2775.wav", + "text": "所以我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2776.wav", + "text": "既然沒有辦法達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2777.wav", + "text": "是不是請院長就做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2778.wav", + "text": "最後的裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2779.wav", + "text": "讓這種沒有交集的協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2780.wav", + "text": "有個ending" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2781.wav", + "text": "最後的結論上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2782.wav", + "text": "我是贊成剛剛林思銘委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2783.wav", + "text": "因為各個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2784.wav", + "text": "針對這個議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2785.wav", + "text": "其實都表達了基本的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2786.wav", + "text": "之所以再次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2787.wav", + "text": "舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2788.wav", + "text": "簡單有三個要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2789.wav", + "text": "加以說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2790.wav", + "text": "\n第一個要點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2791.wav", + "text": "針對立法院職權行使法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2792.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2793.wav", + "text": "我所提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2794.wav", + "text": "觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2795.wav", + "text": "以及我說過我上次黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2796.wav", + "text": "有提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2797.wav", + "text": "針對一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2798.wav", + "text": "協商冷凍期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2799.wav", + "text": "以及在一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2800.wav", + "text": "有召集過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2801.wav", + "text": "就可以依照立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2802.wav", + "text": "交院會來加以處理這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2803.wav", + "text": "我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2804.wav", + "text": "在議事規則上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2805.wav", + "text": "正常的理解是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2806.wav", + "text": "有立委提出不一樣的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2807.wav", + "text": "每個人都可以有自己的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2808.wav", + "text": "但我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2809.wav", + "text": "最後就有關於議事規則的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2810.wav", + "text": "跟操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2811.wav", + "text": "我們尊重院長跟秘書長這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2812.wav", + "text": "的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2813.wav", + "text": "\n第二個事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2814.wav", + "text": "本黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2815.wav", + "text": "剛剛所表達的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2816.wav", + "text": "說得非常清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2817.wav", + "text": "我就不要再複述我只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2818.wav", + "text": "不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2819.wav", + "text": "有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2820.wav", + "text": "把你自己想講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2821.wav", + "text": "塞到別人的嘴巴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2822.wav", + "text": "這樣就不好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2823.wav", + "text": "我講話條理應該還算滿清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2824.wav", + "text": "全程都錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2825.wav", + "text": "簡單地說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2826.wav", + "text": "我們支持交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2827.wav", + "text": "但是我們不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2828.wav", + "text": "用特別預算的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2829.wav", + "text": "來加以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2830.wav", + "text": "要遵守財政紀律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2831.wav", + "text": "要進行可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2832.wav", + "text": "這大概是我們黨團會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2833.wav", + "text": "基本上的四個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2834.wav", + "text": "也因此針對這個議案的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2835.wav", + "text": "我們會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2836.wav", + "text": "我們的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2837.wav", + "text": "在這邊先跟院長做一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2838.wav", + "text": "以及說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2839.wav", + "text": "特別條例的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2840.wav", + "text": "相關的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2841.wav", + "text": "跟處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2842.wav", + "text": "以前我們曾經通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2843.wav", + "text": "特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2844.wav", + "text": "行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2845.wav", + "text": "在特別條例裡面所提出的預算額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2846.wav", + "text": "在立法院審議之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2847.wav", + "text": "因為立法院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2848.wav", + "text": "而使得最後的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2849.wav", + "text": "增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2850.wav", + "text": "這樣的例子其實所在多有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2851.wav", + "text": "我也不需要去複述了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2852.wav", + "text": "行政跟立法兩者之間的界線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2853.wav", + "text": "在什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2854.wav", + "text": "我相信過去有非常非常多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2855.wav", + "text": "例子都可以來參酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2856.wav", + "text": "什麼相關的操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2857.wav", + "text": "都沒有提出違憲之說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2858.wav", + "text": "等到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2859.wav", + "text": "遇到了才突然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2860.wav", + "text": "連違憲都跑出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2861.wav", + "text": "每個人都有每個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2862.wav", + "text": "自己的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2863.wav", + "text": "就按照規則來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2864.wav", + "text": "在你任內的辛勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2865.wav", + "text": "還參加這個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2866.wav", + "text": "我先表示對你過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2867.wav", + "text": "辛勞的感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2868.wav", + "text": "只不過我覺得王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2869.wav", + "text": "您今天在面對環島高鐵這個議題上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2870.wav", + "text": "在歷史上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2871.wav", + "text": "可能要比較負責任一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2872.wav", + "text": "因為我大概看了環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2873.wav", + "text": "相關的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2874.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵不是夢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2875.wav", + "text": "真的是您說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2876.wav", + "text": "在立法院的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2877.wav", + "text": "我們的前行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2878.wav", + "text": "蘇貞昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2879.wav", + "text": "他也是大力地贊同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2880.wav", + "text": "大力地支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2881.wav", + "text": "認為您這個主意非常地好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2882.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2883.wav", + "text": "或者是你另外用時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2884.wav", + "text": "就環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2885.wav", + "text": "你自己當初的整個想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2886.wav", + "text": "你的理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2887.wav", + "text": "我們的前行政院院長蘇貞昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2888.wav", + "text": "都這麼大力地挺你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2889.wav", + "text": "你心裡面所規劃的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2890.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣來加以進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2891.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2892.wav", + "text": "要跟臺灣社會做一個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2893.wav", + "text": "對您個人的歷史定位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2894.wav", + "text": "會有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2895.wav", + "text": "最後我也非常感謝你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2896.wav", + "text": "在剛剛提例子的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2897.wav", + "text": "終於說出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2898.wav", + "text": "當初汐止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2899.wav", + "text": "那個南下的匝道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2900.wav", + "text": "是我爭取的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2901.wav", + "text": "因為當初你們執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2902.wav", + "text": "因為等到你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2903.wav", + "text": "真的通車要剪綵的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2904.wav", + "text": "我人已經不在立法院了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2905.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2906.wav", + "text": "算了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2907.wav", + "text": "我覺得講割稻尾3個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2908.wav", + "text": "就太沉重了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2909.wav", + "text": "不過沒有關係謝謝你今天的肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2910.wav", + "text": "\n要跟院長報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2911.wav", + "text": "是因為等一下還有事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2912.wav", + "text": "我黨團的立場已經很清楚地表明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2913.wav", + "text": "了不過為了表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2914.wav", + "text": "對院長的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2915.wav", + "text": "我剛剛也特別委請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2916.wav", + "text": "我們黨團的幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2917.wav", + "text": "他會繼續留下來參與協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2918.wav", + "text": "不過以最後的結論來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2919.wav", + "text": "我們是支持剛剛林思銘委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2920.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2921.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃國昌委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2922.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我們請柯建銘柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2923.wav", + "text": "繼續發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2924.wav", + "text": "我很遺憾黃國昌委員要走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2925.wav", + "text": "柯總召我打個岔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2926.wav", + "text": "王部長你要不要等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2927.wav", + "text": "補充說明一下還是不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2928.wav", + "text": "等我講完吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2929.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2930.wav", + "text": "等我講完吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2931.wav", + "text": "我知道當然等你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2932.wav", + "text": "院長我知道你在耍什麼遊戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2933.wav", + "text": "我要講話你就趕快要岔開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2934.wav", + "text": "什麼時候黃國昌在我前面我就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2935.wav", + "text": "我就舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2936.wav", + "text": "對王部長等一下講沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2937.wav", + "text": "請尊重我的發言權好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2938.wav", + "text": "我沒有什麼心思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2939.wav", + "text": "我非常尊重你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2940.wav", + "text": "剛才也特別講一段說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2941.wav", + "text": "民主可貴你自己講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2942.wav", + "text": "可以理性對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2943.wav", + "text": "我說今天大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2944.wav", + "text": "非常理性在對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2945.wav", + "text": "即便傅崐萁委員的名字被提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2946.wav", + "text": "我想都是很平和地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2947.wav", + "text": "倒是我持平而論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2948.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁委員比較有動氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2949.wav", + "text": "但是還好我們都可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2950.wav", + "text": "那黃國昌委員今天也沒有咆哮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2951.wav", + "text": "這個都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2952.wav", + "text": "今天大家認真在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2953.wav", + "text": "不聽你講的話沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2954.wav", + "text": "民主就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2955.wav", + "text": "我現在願意來回答雖然黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2956.wav", + "text": "\n當然到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2957.wav", + "text": "一定會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2958.wav", + "text": "表決起來我們一定輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2959.wav", + "text": "這個我們都能認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2960.wav", + "text": "但是我要把很多話講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2961.wav", + "text": "這才是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2962.wav", + "text": "委員會以後黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2963.wav", + "text": "那像有的人常常是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2964.wav", + "text": "各黨團都有不來的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2965.wav", + "text": "因為大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2966.wav", + "text": "後面還有一個院長的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2967.wav", + "text": "才是一個final才是結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2968.wav", + "text": "所以立法院並不存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2969.wav", + "text": "一個月以後就要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2970.wav", + "text": "過去是一個月以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2971.wav", + "text": "定期表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2972.wav", + "text": "後來馬英九改成一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2973.wav", + "text": "職權行使法請大家看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2974.wav", + "text": "假如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2975.wav", + "text": "委員會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2976.wav", + "text": "那吳宗憲委員就說送給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2977.wav", + "text": "韓院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2978.wav", + "text": "這個也不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2979.wav", + "text": "不是說他走了我們就不能協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2980.wav", + "text": "這樣子搞法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2981.wav", + "text": "沒收院長的權力了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2982.wav", + "text": "委員會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2983.wav", + "text": "一個月以後就要到院會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2984.wav", + "text": "韓院長你這個位子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2985.wav", + "text": "做得下去嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2986.wav", + "text": "從劉松藩院長到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2987.wav", + "text": "游錫堃院長每一個人都遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2988.wav", + "text": "那這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2989.wav", + "text": "黨團協商從哪裡來的呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2990.wav", + "text": "從1993年到1999年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2991.wav", + "text": "因為立法院沒有遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2992.wav", + "text": "所以劉松藩院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2993.wav", + "text": "最大功能是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2994.wav", + "text": "他最值得敬佩的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2995.wav", + "text": "在他任內到1999年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2996.wav", + "text": "1月12號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2997.wav", + "text": "把國會五法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2998.wav", + "text": "奉行的遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/2999.wav", + "text": "\n但整個民主實踐大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3000.wav", + "text": "表決輸就輸沒有什麼話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3001.wav", + "text": "講但是要把話講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3002.wav", + "text": "所以黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3003.wav", + "text": "他理解那以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3004.wav", + "text": "院長你沒有什麼功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3005.wav", + "text": "啊你也不必在這裡裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3006.wav", + "text": "人家就到院會直接表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3007.wav", + "text": "立法院不是這樣大家在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3008.wav", + "text": "這麼久以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3009.wav", + "text": "包括傅崐萁委員包括黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3010.wav", + "text": "都曾經在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3011.wav", + "text": "林思銘也來過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3012.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷也都來過為什麼今天大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3013.wav", + "text": "突然要把遊戲規則改掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3014.wav", + "text": "把你的權力架空" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3015.wav", + "text": "立法院還能走得下去嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3016.wav", + "text": "因為民主結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3017.wav", + "text": "從上次朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3018.wav", + "text": "一直在捍衛你院長的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3019.wav", + "text": "這是一個非常嚴肅的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3020.wav", + "text": "這是第一點我針對黃國昌委員所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3021.wav", + "text": "\n但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3022.wav", + "text": "他要提對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3023.wav", + "text": "他口中不講出違憲兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3024.wav", + "text": "我不知道他要講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3025.wav", + "text": "他贊成由行政部門編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3026.wav", + "text": "他要提對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3027.wav", + "text": "寫在法條裡面嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3028.wav", + "text": "寫在法條裡面就是你從特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3029.wav", + "text": "要求行政人員要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3030.wav", + "text": "那當然是違憲啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3031.wav", + "text": "各位憲法第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3032.wav", + "text": "585" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3033.wav", + "text": "613" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3034.wav", + "text": "並不是這個法條裡面沒有這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3035.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷你要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3036.wav", + "text": "什麼故意沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3037.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3038.wav", + "text": "任何一個當立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3039.wav", + "text": "都要很正確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3040.wav", + "text": "有基本的憲法及公法知識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3041.wav", + "text": "否則的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3042.wav", + "text": "拿那本都沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3043.wav", + "text": "違憲的部分就是違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3044.wav", + "text": "\n請看違憲的條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3045.wav", + "text": "文剛才我們講的幾個大法官釋字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3046.wav", + "text": "包括憲法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3047.wav", + "text": "立法院職權的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3048.wav", + "text": "行政院職權的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3049.wav", + "text": "看完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3050.wav", + "text": "我們可能比較能夠順利走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3051.wav", + "text": "至少你看憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3052.wav", + "text": "總統任命行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3053.wav", + "text": "來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3054.wav", + "text": "備詢做施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3055.wav", + "text": "行政院長有這個職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3056.wav", + "text": "立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3057.wav", + "text": "憲法上對於立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3058.wav", + "text": "在第63條看得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3059.wav", + "text": "議決法律案預算案等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3060.wav", + "text": "這些在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3061.wav", + "text": "\n然後你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3062.wav", + "text": "我們有定見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3063.wav", + "text": "我們不是有定見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3064.wav", + "text": "是你有定見我希望說你回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3065.wav", + "text": "今天我們協商到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3066.wav", + "text": "要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3067.wav", + "text": "當然我希望把話講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3068.wav", + "text": "你也不要急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3069.wav", + "text": "反正怎麼表決我們一定輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3070.wav", + "text": "當然有釋憲程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3071.wav", + "text": "但是否違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3072.wav", + "text": "道理自明沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3073.wav", + "text": "你也是同樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3074.wav", + "text": "反對違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3075.wav", + "text": "的你說這個合憲性沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3076.wav", + "text": "他認為沒有違憲性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3077.wav", + "text": "講了半天我不知道黃國昌的主張是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3078.wav", + "text": "所以這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3079.wav", + "text": "我要很清楚告訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3080.wav", + "text": "各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3081.wav", + "text": "另外就是傅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3082.wav", + "text": "崐萁委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3083.wav", + "text": "\n林思銘委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3084.wav", + "text": "我們都是新竹縣市的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3085.wav", + "text": "五楊高架橋你應該贊成吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3086.wav", + "text": "2015年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3087.wav", + "text": "我對行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3088.wav", + "text": "那時候行政院長是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3089.wav", + "text": "是毛治國那年我要回去選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3090.wav", + "text": "毛治國在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3091.wav", + "text": "會也跟我們講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3092.wav", + "text": "橋很重要他們能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3093.wav", + "text": "支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3094.wav", + "text": "然後對於新竹縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3095.wav", + "text": "新竹縣市所有的現在都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3096.wav", + "text": "我有沒有弄一個特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3097.wav", + "text": "我知道那是違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3098.wav", + "text": "我回去選舉到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3099.wav", + "text": "走了8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3100.wav", + "text": "經過可行性評估環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3101.wav", + "text": "都還沒開始施工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3102.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們今天講環島高鐵乃至於你的蘇花快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3103.wav", + "text": "你要從整個公法上的理論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3104.wav", + "text": "包括整個行政作為上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3105.wav", + "text": "包括立法委員能夠做什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3106.wav", + "text": "大家去看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3107.wav", + "text": "十年要完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3108.wav", + "text": "十年要完成環島高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3109.wav", + "text": "環島高鐵也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3110.wav", + "text": "弄一個特別條例叫政府要多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3111.wav", + "text": "多久完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3112.wav", + "text": "那你就澈底剝奪了行政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3113.wav", + "text": "這很清楚吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3114.wav", + "text": "林思銘委員你是法律人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3115.wav", + "text": "耶傅崐萁不是法律人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3116.wav", + "text": "他可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3117.wav", + "text": "怎麼講我都接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3118.wav", + "text": "至少你是法律人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3119.wav", + "text": "黃國昌也是法律人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3120.wav", + "text": "所以剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3121.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁講了一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3122.wav", + "text": "我們兩個人不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3123.wav", + "text": "坐在這裡不講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3124.wav", + "text": "他說臺灣用什麼輕軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3125.wav", + "text": "這是高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3126.wav", + "text": "你也贊成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3127.wav", + "text": "所有人都贊成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3128.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3129.wav", + "text": "有建議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3130.wav", + "text": "但主被動的關係大家要搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3131.wav", + "text": "主動性是在行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3132.wav", + "text": "這是權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3133.wav", + "text": "道理自明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3134.wav", + "text": "我們講了半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3135.wav", + "text": "當然也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3136.wav", + "text": "各位覺得我們講的很刺耳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3137.wav", + "text": "或是覺得不夠明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3138.wav", + "text": "大家回去把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3139.wav", + "text": "520585613" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3140.wav", + "text": "264" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3141.wav", + "text": "391" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3142.wav", + "text": "有一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3143.wav", + "text": "但你看結論就知道你好好看一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3144.wav", + "text": "尤其585號是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3145.wav", + "text": "前在立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3146.wav", + "text": "出來真調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3147.wav", + "text": "在立法院的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3148.wav", + "text": "大家總是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3149.wav", + "text": "為國家做事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3150.wav", + "text": "三十年我在這個場域裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3151.wav", + "text": "從一個完全陌生的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3152.wav", + "text": "到我會花很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3153.wav", + "text": "去研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3154.wav", + "text": "法案以及憲政體制的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3155.wav", + "text": "以及國家應該如何進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3156.wav", + "text": "這是我們的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3157.wav", + "text": "我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3158.wav", + "text": "然後大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3159.wav", + "text": "也不管憲政體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3160.wav", + "text": "尤其未來要談的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3161.wav", + "text": "所謂的立法院職權行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3162.wav", + "text": "使法有沒有擴權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3163.wav", + "text": "有沒有違憲都是應該好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3164.wav", + "text": "在一個非常危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3165.wav", + "text": "我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3166.wav", + "text": "院長再讓他們回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3167.wav", + "text": "跟釋憲文後再論也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3168.wav", + "text": "到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3169.wav", + "text": "表決我們一定輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3170.wav", + "text": "我們也認了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3171.wav", + "text": "但是我們要把話講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3172.wav", + "text": "因為我們講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3173.wav", + "text": "連法律人都在否定我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3174.wav", + "text": "我就覺得都很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3175.wav", + "text": "我很遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3176.wav", + "text": "他是法學博士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3177.wav", + "text": "我倒是很希望跟他直球對決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3178.wav", + "text": "跟他好好辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3179.wav", + "text": "不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3180.wav", + "text": "不是我們就在這裡直球對決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3181.wav", + "text": "我知道你一直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3182.wav", + "text": "有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3183.wav", + "text": "我沒有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3184.wav", + "text": "你今天所提的有些觀念我是能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3185.wav", + "text": "但是我們稍微謹慎一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3186.wav", + "text": "我們今天協商勢必不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3187.wav", + "text": "任何結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3188.wav", + "text": "但是請各位回去看完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3189.wav", + "text": "主要是看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3190.wav", + "text": "看完之後我們再好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3191.wav", + "text": "可能也比較適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3192.wav", + "text": "你們會贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3193.wav", + "text": "贏了表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3194.wav", + "text": "國會暴力的時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3195.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁你應該很珍惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3196.wav", + "text": "你們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3197.wav", + "text": "在國會多我們一席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3198.wav", + "text": "我希望大家都有歷史上的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3199.wav", + "text": "也不要說你和黃國昌加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3200.wav", + "text": "什麼事情都可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3201.wav", + "text": "在這裡提到你名字不是有所不敬而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3202.wav", + "text": "是因為你是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3203.wav", + "text": "這個法案的提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3204.wav", + "text": "我們這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3205.wav", + "text": "都要有經濟委員會財政委員會都沒有來列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3206.wav", + "text": "都沒有來參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3207.wav", + "text": "所以剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3208.wav", + "text": "院長所提的一些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3209.wav", + "text": "我們應該好好再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3210.wav", + "text": "以上我是很誠懇表示這個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3211.wav", + "text": "韓院長今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3212.wav", + "text": "我特別跟柯總召補充報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3213.wav", + "text": "剛才我的意思是您發言完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3214.wav", + "text": "因為多次提到交通部王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3215.wav", + "text": "我擔心他有心裡的話要講一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3216.wav", + "text": "所以我才特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3217.wav", + "text": "說我在玩什麼遊戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3218.wav", + "text": "不是的我是覺得行政官員坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3219.wav", + "text": "多次被委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3220.wav", + "text": "他一定也有一些話想要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3221.wav", + "text": "所以我說你發言完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3222.wav", + "text": "我們請王國材部長補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3223.wav", + "text": "我想我應該沒有處理錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3224.wav", + "text": "假如我講錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3225.wav", + "text": "但是我常常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3226.wav", + "text": "被安排到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3227.wav", + "text": "王部長包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3228.wav", + "text": "再1個禮拜以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3229.wav", + "text": "王部長請你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3230.wav", + "text": "1個鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3231.wav", + "text": "柯總召因為我覺得這樣比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3232.wav", + "text": "所有要離職的官員都可以來發表感言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3233.wav", + "text": "對於國家建設你的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3234.wav", + "text": "王部長你的夢想是我們大家的夢想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3235.wav", + "text": "美夢會成真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3236.wav", + "text": "你發言完我請交通部王部長補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3237.wav", + "text": "結果你一直說我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3238.wav", + "text": "在玩什麼把戲我是跟你講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3239.wav", + "text": "\n我們請王部長補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3240.wav", + "text": "從我的專業來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3241.wav", + "text": "必須要有前瞻性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3242.wav", + "text": "跟臺鐵會來互補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3243.wav", + "text": "還有互為備援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3244.wav", + "text": "所以對於東部也很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3245.wav", + "text": "我當時是提要逐段完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3246.wav", + "text": "不是一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3247.wav", + "text": "屏東另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3248.wav", + "text": "到宜蘭有三個可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3249.wav", + "text": "報告要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3250.wav", + "text": "第一個就是屏東潮州臺東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3251.wav", + "text": "第二個是宜蘭到花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3252.wav", + "text": "第三個就是花蓮跟臺東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3253.wav", + "text": "因為它的經費很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3254.wav", + "text": "比如剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3255.wav", + "text": "要繞過大武山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3256.wav", + "text": "所以也有路廊的課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3257.wav", + "text": "覺得這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3258.wav", + "text": "至少我當部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3259.wav", + "text": "時還有包括蘇院長的共識是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3260.wav", + "text": "逐段來完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3261.wav", + "text": "但是我不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3262.wav", + "text": "用特別條例把它匡住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3263.wav", + "text": "因為每一段統統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3264.wav", + "text": "要克服工程技術環評的課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3265.wav", + "text": "這是我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3266.wav", + "text": "謝謝王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3267.wav", + "text": "非常負責任的說明非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3268.wav", + "text": "\n接下來高副主委有沒有什麼要補充的我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3269.wav", + "text": "想高速鐵路的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3270.wav", + "text": "是交通部我們尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3271.wav", + "text": "交通部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3272.wav", + "text": "謝謝接下來我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3273.wav", + "text": "吳委員能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3274.wav", + "text": "簡短扼要因為已經講了非常多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3275.wav", + "text": "謝謝沒關係等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3276.wav", + "text": "莊委員請準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3277.wav", + "text": "我想要表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3278.wav", + "text": "對於協商秩序的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3279.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁總召在協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3280.wav", + "text": "是在戴耳機的我不知道他是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3281.wav", + "text": "大家的對話他這樣充耳不聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3282.wav", + "text": "這樣是不好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3283.wav", + "text": "也不尊重在場委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3284.wav", + "text": "跟官員的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3285.wav", + "text": "他現在也離場但他剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3286.wav", + "text": "就是戴著耳機我覺得這樣不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3287.wav", + "text": "因為我們都想要互相論述互相對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3288.wav", + "text": "第二個現在黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3289.wav", + "text": "是坐在這裡審查完當然有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3290.wav", + "text": "吳春城委員來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3291.wav", + "text": "回到我的三個點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3292.wav", + "text": "第一個回應一下剛剛洪孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3293.wav", + "text": "委員說的今天如果在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3294.wav", + "text": "有既定的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3295.wav", + "text": "這沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3296.wav", + "text": "啊因為對就是對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3297.wav", + "text": "不對就是不對對於任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3298.wav", + "text": "政策的立場沒有模糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3299.wav", + "text": "的地帶那您剛剛在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3300.wav", + "text": "問哪裡不合憲哪裡不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3301.wav", + "text": "我都已經把法條說給您聽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3302.wav", + "text": "不合憲有憲法第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3303.wav", + "text": "大法官釋字613號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3304.wav", + "text": "釋字391號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3305.wav", + "text": "我再一次說明不合理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3306.wav", + "text": "呢剛剛行政部門也多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3307.wav", + "text": "的說明了交通的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3308.wav", + "text": "專業評估以及財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3309.wav", + "text": "試算的評估還有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3310.wav", + "text": "特別預算的方式也不合宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3311.wav", + "text": "這就是不合理的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3312.wav", + "text": "所以我再一次說明今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3313.wav", + "text": "坐在這裡各黨團當然會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3314.wav", + "text": "他們的政策觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3315.wav", + "text": "黃國昌總召離場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3316.wav", + "text": "了我可能要說給吳春城委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3317.wav", + "text": "的立場是剛剛黃國昌總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3318.wav", + "text": "說得很清楚不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3319.wav", + "text": "特別預算認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3320.wav", + "text": "建設不能夠違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3321.wav", + "text": "財政紀律也一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3322.wav", + "text": "進行可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3323.wav", + "text": "如果這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3324.wav", + "text": "在表決的過程中剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3325.wav", + "text": "講的很好聽這個不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3326.wav", + "text": "這個不支持我要說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3327.wav", + "text": "我們原則方向是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3328.wav", + "text": "如果不支持那就不要在明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3329.wav", + "text": "的表決裡頭又放水了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3330.wav", + "text": "或者是說要提對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3331.wav", + "text": "但對案可能又是一種放水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3332.wav", + "text": "的話我覺得跟黃總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3333.wav", + "text": "剛剛所說的幾大原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3334.wav", + "text": "可能會有很大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3335.wav", + "text": "的策略說的好聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3336.wav", + "text": "做的是另一套我是認為期期以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3337.wav", + "text": "不可春城大哥您是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3338.wav", + "text": "可以對話的人我要把這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3339.wav", + "text": "的訊息轉達給您聽因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3340.wav", + "text": "社會都在觀察剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3341.wav", + "text": "黃總召說的不可支持的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3342.wav", + "text": "ABCD四個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3343.wav", + "text": "可是明天如果表決又支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3344.wav", + "text": "了我覺得這樣可能比較難以交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3345.wav", + "text": "\n第三件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3346.wav", + "text": "基於立法委員的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3347.wav", + "text": "我們行政立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3348.wav", + "text": "互有分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3349.wav", + "text": "如果就這個議案上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3350.wav", + "text": "一個立委可以行使的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3351.wav", + "text": "是什麼很可惜我現在要講可是傅總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3352.wav", + "text": "又離開了我真的很想說給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3353.wav", + "text": "聽希望他有看直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3354.wav", + "text": "不是聽耳機而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3355.wav", + "text": "立委可以行使的叫做預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3356.wav", + "text": "的建議權對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3357.wav", + "text": "我們可以在委員會提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3358.wav", + "text": "可以在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3359.wav", + "text": "提案也可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3360.wav", + "text": "審查預算的時候做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3361.wav", + "text": "出預算提案的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3362.wav", + "text": "我們立法委員問政的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3363.wav", + "text": "工具跟手段我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3364.wav", + "text": "思銘委員都認同這就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3365.wav", + "text": "立委對於一個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3366.wav", + "text": "的建議案這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3367.wav", + "text": "我們合憲可以行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3368.wav", + "text": "的所以不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3369.wav", + "text": "逾越行政權自己用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3370.wav", + "text": "一個特別條例的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3371.wav", + "text": "來要求行政部門編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3372.wav", + "text": "什麼預算這完全就是不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3373.wav", + "text": "可以善用預算建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3374.wav", + "text": "權\n我作為立委雖然只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3375.wav", + "text": "9年的時間但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3376.wav", + "text": "我推動教育部的新宿舍運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3377.wav", + "text": "也是透過我的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3378.wav", + "text": "透過預算的建議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3379.wav", + "text": "要求行政部門去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3380.wav", + "text": "我爭取文化部的文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3381.wav", + "text": "禮金也是透過我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3382.wav", + "text": "建議權透過質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3383.wav", + "text": "提案然後行政部門就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3384.wav", + "text": "做這是走正道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3385.wav", + "text": "的一個方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3386.wav", + "text": "立法行政互有分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3387.wav", + "text": "我也要回應剛剛有委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3388.wav", + "text": "提到的過去基隆河整治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3389.wav", + "text": "條例也是特別條例沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3390.wav", + "text": "因為它是特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3391.wav", + "text": "它是一個area的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3392.wav", + "text": "的特別條例是馬英九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3393.wav", + "text": "都有提過它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3394.wav", + "text": "一個擴大區域而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3395.wav", + "text": "單一建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3396.wav", + "text": "所以把過去的法制面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3397.wav", + "text": "經驗面都講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3398.wav", + "text": "可以就是可以不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3399.wav", + "text": "就是不可以在憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3400.wav", + "text": "的原則下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3401.wav", + "text": "我們都要行憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3402.wav", + "text": "如果委員要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3403.wav", + "text": "我們都支持交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3404.wav", + "text": "那就用預算的建議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3405.wav", + "text": "這個東西才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3406.wav", + "text": "合乎正道的好嗎謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3407.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳思瑤委員發言接下來我們請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3408.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄委員簡短扼要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3409.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3410.wav", + "text": "好不好我的發言很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3411.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3412.wav", + "text": "這個條文不像國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3413.wav", + "text": "第二個我的重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3414.wav", + "text": "不要想到什麼做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3415.wav", + "text": "尤其是重大的一個交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3416.wav", + "text": "建設也不要外行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3417.wav", + "text": "再去領導內行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3418.wav", + "text": "把國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3419.wav", + "text": "變成一個主責的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3420.wav", + "text": "這個我更反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3421.wav", + "text": "這個笑死人了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3422.wav", + "text": "各位把它想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3423.wav", + "text": "過去的交通建設裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3424.wav", + "text": "你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3425.wav", + "text": "像我們這種比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3426.wav", + "text": "農業縣的尤其最南端的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3427.wav", + "text": "過去政府重北輕南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3428.wav", + "text": "我個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3429.wav", + "text": "就絕對不會去反對建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3430.wav", + "text": "我在民進黨團也不會去反對建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3431.wav", + "text": "但是用這樣的一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3432.wav", + "text": "我就反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3433.wav", + "text": "我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3434.wav", + "text": "應該是剛才王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3435.wav", + "text": "所講的用個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3436.wav", + "text": "可行性評估就要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3437.wav", + "text": "可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3438.wav", + "text": "譬如我剛剛所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3439.wav", + "text": "高鐵就不會從高雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3440.wav", + "text": "直接跳到臺東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3441.wav", + "text": "沒有到我屏東來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3442.wav", + "text": "不會到臺東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3443.wav", + "text": "啦那就應該以個案去把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3444.wav", + "text": "公路建設的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3445.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分更應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3446.wav", + "text": "借助於行政部門的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3447.wav", + "text": "要經過幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3448.wav", + "text": "縱谷要經過幾個原民部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3449.wav", + "text": "可行性評估裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3450.wav", + "text": "還要再去做環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3451.wav", + "text": "這些都不能省略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3452.wav", + "text": "我們本來一直在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3453.wav", + "text": "我上次在質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3454.wav", + "text": "高鐵南延到屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3455.wav", + "text": "我質詢毛治國的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3456.wav", + "text": "我還記得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3457.wav", + "text": "我說日本都已經在用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3458.wav", + "text": "磁浮列車了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3459.wav", + "text": "我們還在用高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3460.wav", + "text": "結果現在日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3461.wav", + "text": "從品川到名古屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3462.wav", + "text": "這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3463.wav", + "text": "的環境影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3464.wav", + "text": "也就是說本來2027年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3465.wav", + "text": "預計就要開通了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3466.wav", + "text": "結果它現在整個建設停下來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3467.wav", + "text": "那我的想法就很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3468.wav", + "text": "這個環評的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3469.wav", + "text": "你前面的部分都不先去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3470.wav", + "text": "然後就先匡定要幾年把它完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3471.wav", + "text": "民眾黨提到了財政紀律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3472.wav", + "text": "我就覺得這很像樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3473.wav", + "text": "啦這個我相信各個政黨裡面都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3474.wav", + "text": "必須要去堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3475.wav", + "text": "就是因為明天要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3476.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天才要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3477.wav", + "text": "大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3478.wav", + "text": "三個政黨大家都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3479.wav", + "text": "找到的一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3480.wav", + "text": "最重要的一點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3481.wav", + "text": "這三件事情環島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3482.wav", + "text": "高鐵花東交通快速道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3483.wav", + "text": "國道六號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3484.wav", + "text": "東延花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3485.wav", + "text": "這是東部發展的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3486.wav", + "text": "該不該做以民眾黨的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3487.wav", + "text": "覺得該做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3488.wav", + "text": "那怎麼做再說嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3489.wav", + "text": "就是該做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3490.wav", + "text": "對於我們東部的發展是該做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3491.wav", + "text": "當然民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3492.wav", + "text": "的立場是該做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3493.wav", + "text": "但是可行性評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3494.wav", + "text": "這個不是我們立法院能夠評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3495.wav", + "text": "這當然是行政部門要評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3496.wav", + "text": "當然有國家財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3497.wav", + "text": "的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3498.wav", + "text": "這些都是民眾黨主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3499.wav", + "text": "的務實理性科學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3500.wav", + "text": "這一定是要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3501.wav", + "text": "但我還是要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3502.wav", + "text": "國民黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3503.wav", + "text": "但是可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3504.wav", + "text": "用心是好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3505.wav", + "text": "為東部發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3506.wav", + "text": "對但是方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3507.wav", + "text": "但是我看到民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3508.wav", + "text": "就是從頭到尾在阻擋批判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3509.wav", + "text": "所以我們一事無成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3510.wav", + "text": "我們花了好長的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3511.wav", + "text": "對於柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3512.wav", + "text": "我真的非常的佩服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3513.wav", + "text": "你這種講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3514.wav", + "text": "古的功力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3515.wav", + "text": "\n其實聽起來也是滿有趣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3516.wav", + "text": "老實講我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3517.wav", + "text": "但是不一定有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3518.wav", + "text": "但是你還是說不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3519.wav", + "text": "你發言大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3520.wav", + "text": "快占到我們一半的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3521.wav", + "text": "但是我還是沒有得到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3522.wav", + "text": "到底這三件事情該不該做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3523.wav", + "text": "我們還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3524.wav", + "text": "對於整個東部發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3525.wav", + "text": "這是何等重大的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3526.wav", + "text": "當然也不能太匆忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3527.wav", + "text": "應該要開國是會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3528.wav", + "text": "大家好好來討論我們的東部發展好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3529.wav", + "text": "我們不是一事無成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3530.wav", + "text": "各位黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3531.wav", + "text": "很多人都針對我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3532.wav", + "text": "我必須回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3533.wav", + "text": "我也很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3534.wav", + "text": "我們能夠有一個很好的對焦的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3535.wav", + "text": "該不該做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3536.wav", + "text": "沒有人敢說不該做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3537.wav", + "text": "這很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3538.wav", + "text": "花蓮要發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3539.wav", + "text": "但是要如何做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3540.wav", + "text": "這是一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3541.wav", + "text": "所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3542.wav", + "text": "不厭其煩地講就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3543.wav", + "text": "民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3544.wav", + "text": "黃國昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3545.wav", + "text": "他繞了半天在包牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3546.wav", + "text": "講到財政紀律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3547.wav", + "text": "然後他說要提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3548.wav", + "text": "我不知道他怎麼去提這案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3549.wav", + "text": "他沒有辦法正視核心問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3550.wav", + "text": "也就是憲法上的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3551.wav", + "text": "\n今天我在這裡講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3552.wav", + "text": "我們每一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3553.wav", + "text": "都要向憲法低頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3554.wav", + "text": "這是一個憲政時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3555.wav", + "text": "這是非常嚴肅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3556.wav", + "text": "任何一個立法委員乃至於官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3557.wav", + "text": "你做出的任何違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3558.wav", + "text": "都不通嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3559.wav", + "text": "我們一直苦口婆心乃至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3560.wav", + "text": "至於我們衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3561.wav", + "text": "這個沒有個人恩怨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3562.wav", + "text": "這是為公的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3563.wav", + "text": "未來我們面對的不是只有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3564.wav", + "text": "職權行使法的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3565.wav", + "text": "所謂的藐視國會罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3566.wav", + "text": "等很多事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3567.wav", + "text": "他要離開王" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3568.wav", + "text": "王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3569.wav", + "text": "所以有很多很嚴肅的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3570.wav", + "text": "我最後要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3571.wav", + "text": "我剛才一直跑去跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3572.wav", + "text": "也跟大家講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3573.wav", + "text": "不應該明天表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3574.wav", + "text": "就沒有所謂明天表決的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3575.wav", + "text": "針對憲法上的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3576.wav", + "text": "我們來好好針對憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3577.wav", + "text": "9條是怎麼規定第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3578.wav", + "text": "怎麼規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3579.wav", + "text": "很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3580.wav", + "text": "585520613" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3581.wav", + "text": "264319" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3582.wav", + "text": "大家回去看完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3583.wav", + "text": "我們對於憲法上的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3584.wav", + "text": "先有一個基本的對焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3585.wav", + "text": "否則的話表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3586.wav", + "text": "呢以後大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3587.wav", + "text": "群起效尤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3588.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁可以提2兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3589.wav", + "text": "我也可以提1兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3590.wav", + "text": "個3兆也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3591.wav", + "text": "這樣行政權就要交出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3592.wav", + "text": "了責任政治在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3593.wav", + "text": "所以這是很嚴肅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3594.wav", + "text": "的大家要面對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3595.wav", + "text": "不是我今天反對什麼建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3596.wav", + "text": "所有建設我都贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3597.wav", + "text": "國家有錢好好去蓋很多建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3598.wav", + "text": "天經地義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3599.wav", + "text": "院長今天是歷史的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3600.wav", + "text": "你要有所堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3601.wav", + "text": "有所理想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3602.wav", + "text": "並不是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3603.wav", + "text": "哪一個人的指揮下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3604.wav", + "text": "\n我相信你是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3605.wav", + "text": "我們都是走過同一個時代的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3606.wav", + "text": "我跟你講過一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3607.wav", + "text": "我們都到頂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3608.wav", + "text": "這一屆做完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3609.wav", + "text": "我也要告老還鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3610.wav", + "text": "最成熟的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3611.wav", + "text": "了這是我們共同的期待好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3612.wav", + "text": "好謝謝總召很感性的一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3613.wav", + "text": "話讓我想到林覺民與妻訣別書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3614.wav", + "text": "謝謝列席官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3615.wav", + "text": "也謝謝黨團幹部開了兩個半小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3616.wav", + "text": "的會\n我們作以下結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3617.wav", + "text": "各黨團對本次研商之相關法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3618.wav", + "text": "均已充分發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15900/3619.wav", + "text": "本次會議到此為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/0.wav", + "text": "\n首先協商第一案併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會報告併案審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/2.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法部分條文修正草案等15案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/3.wav", + "text": "院會逕付二讀委員羅智強等31人提案等2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/4.wav", + "text": "及自委員會抽出逕付二讀委員呂玉玲等17人提案等5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/5.wav", + "text": "\n審查會於4月15日審查完竣審查情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/6.wav", + "text": "各提案均保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/7.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/8.wav", + "text": "另院會第11次會議將委員羅智強等31人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/9.wav", + "text": "及委員羅智強等16人提案逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/10.wav", + "text": "院會第12次會議再將委員呂玉玲等17人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/11.wav", + "text": "委員呂玉玲等16人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/12.wav", + "text": "委員翁曉玲等17人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/13.wav", + "text": "及委員羅智強等20人提案等5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/14.wav", + "text": "自委員會抽出逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/15.wav", + "text": "與相關提案併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/16.wav", + "text": "以上共計22案於今日併案進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/17.wav", + "text": "協商時請參閱協商條文對照表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/18.wav", + "text": "審查報告及逕付二讀提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/19.wav", + "text": "會委員如果有修正動議或機關有建議內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/20.wav", + "text": "請提出書面印發現場進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/21.wav", + "text": "開始協商審查會保留3個章名55條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/22.wav", + "text": "次新增逕付二讀提案後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/23.wav", + "text": "計須協商3個章名67條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/24.wav", + "text": "次現在請各黨團代表表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/25.wav", + "text": "請問有委員要發言嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/26.wav", + "text": "好鍾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/27.wav", + "text": "主席吳召委我們各黨團的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/28.wav", + "text": "今天這樣的一個協商意義很重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/29.wav", + "text": "因為終於我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/30.wav", + "text": "可以完完全全的就法條來論法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/31.wav", + "text": "第一個審查會保留的黨團提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/32.wav", + "text": "是台灣民眾黨黨團的第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/33.wav", + "text": "其實我是先舉例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/34.wav", + "text": "像這樣的一個條文它的第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/35.wav", + "text": "就是將現行規定明文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/36.wav", + "text": "符合目前的運作實況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/37.wav", + "text": "我們當然是敬表支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/38.wav", + "text": "我現在要表達的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/39.wav", + "text": "想請教一下主席我們的處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/40.wav", + "text": "譬如以民眾黨的第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/41.wav", + "text": "增列第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/42.wav", + "text": "將現行實施的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/43.wav", + "text": "以明文表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/44.wav", + "text": "如果各黨團都覺得沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/45.wav", + "text": "就可以達成協商同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/46.wav", + "text": "如果其他條文也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/47.wav", + "text": "或者不是這樣要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/48.wav", + "text": "各黨團代表說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/49.wav", + "text": "我們就是進行逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/50.wav", + "text": "是不是還是你們有別的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/51.wav", + "text": "我詢問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/52.wav", + "text": "因為民進黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/53.wav", + "text": "針對職權行使法有24個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/54.wav", + "text": "但沒有在今天的協商裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/55.wav", + "text": "這也是立法院很少發生的怪異狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/56.wav", + "text": "就是先行針對某一個黨的委員的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/57.wav", + "text": "打包先協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/58.wav", + "text": "那民進黨的版本沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/59.wav", + "text": "在今天這個場域一起被討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/60.wav", + "text": "等一下如果進入到相關條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/61.wav", + "text": "而民進黨也有提出條文的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/62.wav", + "text": "可不可以一起來討論發言呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/63.wav", + "text": "否則這樣子可能會掛一漏萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/64.wav", + "text": "因為很多法條的論證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/65.wav", + "text": "必須進入彼���條文的比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/66.wav", + "text": "這樣會更有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/67.wav", + "text": "而且就是進入直接的對照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/68.wav", + "text": "就可以看到誰優誰劣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/69.wav", + "text": "所以今天蠻遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/70.wav", + "text": "的我在立法院9年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/71.wav", + "text": "我是比較疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/72.wav", + "text": "民眾黨版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/73.wav", + "text": "還有部分國民黨籍委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/74.wav", + "text": "真的在未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/75.wav", + "text": "後續的處理上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/76.wav", + "text": "也會有些錯置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/77.wav", + "text": "包括在院會的處置上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/78.wav", + "text": "都會呈現有的被丟包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/79.wav", + "text": "事實上規範的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/80.wav", + "text": "同樣的條文內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/81.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/82.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的權宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/83.wav", + "text": "今天協商的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/84.wav", + "text": "就是我剛剛宣告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/85.wav", + "text": "所提到的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/86.wav", + "text": "其他範圍以外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/87.wav", + "text": "不是今天會議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/88.wav", + "text": "那我也無權多說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/89.wav", + "text": "主席我是覺得很可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/90.wav", + "text": "我講幾句話就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/91.wav", + "text": "啦你是委員會召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/92.wav", + "text": "結果朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/93.wav", + "text": "你說要逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/94.wav", + "text": "這也很好我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/95.wav", + "text": "卻不讓人家逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/96.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請主席說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/97.wav", + "text": "這部分我沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/98.wav", + "text": "好說明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/99.wav", + "text": "為什麼我要對我的決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/100.wav", + "text": "告訴你們我的想法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/101.wav", + "text": "你是委員會的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/102.wav", + "text": "我已經說明我要怎麼做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/103.wav", + "text": "我的義務是告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/104.wav", + "text": "我要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/105.wav", + "text": "至於說我心裡想什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/106.wav", + "text": "我覺得那應該不是有義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/107.wav", + "text": "跟各位報告吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/108.wav", + "text": "沒有啊你們要協調你們就協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/109.wav", + "text": "如果你們不想協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/110.wav", + "text": "不是啦我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/111.wav", + "text": "委員會裡面本來就該逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/112.wav", + "text": "你卻不讓人家討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/113.wav", + "text": "我們今天是協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/114.wav", + "text": "那你要往回走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/115.wav", + "text": "要翻頁到前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/116.wav", + "text": "這個不叫翻頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/117.wav", + "text": "基本提出的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/118.wav", + "text": "我就在請教嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/119.wav", + "text": "可以逐條討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/120.wav", + "text": "啊我只是要問說很怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/121.wav", + "text": "欸\n那你當委員會的召委要幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/122.wav", + "text": "我們今天是進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/123.wav", + "text": "如果對議事的主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/124.wav", + "text": "有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/125.wav", + "text": "沒關係啊那之後再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/126.wav", + "text": "因為我們今天是協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/127.wav", + "text": "我針對第2條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/128.wav", + "text": "民眾黨條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/129.wav", + "text": "確實是把現在進行的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/130.wav", + "text": "但是我想請教周萬來秘書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/131.wav", + "text": "長你認為有沒有需要把這樣子的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/132.wav", + "text": "因為這是我們一般的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/133.wav", + "text": "加進來這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/134.wav", + "text": "我同意你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/135.wav", + "text": "因為也有立過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/136.wav", + "text": "所以這個文字的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/137.wav", + "text": "有沒有要再精煉的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/138.wav", + "text": "第1項開議日黨團協商無法達成共識時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/139.wav", + "text": "應即由院長召開全院委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/140.wav", + "text": "即由的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/141.wav", + "text": "幾日內還是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/142.wav", + "text": "然後依各黨團所提之議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/143.wav", + "text": "草案表決定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/144.wav", + "text": "有沒有一個比較清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/145.wav", + "text": "文字或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/146.wav", + "text": "沒辦法達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/147.wav", + "text": "到共識當然主席就一定要請各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/148.wav", + "text": "他一定會發文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/149.wav", + "text": "開全院委員談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/150.wav", + "text": "目前的處理方式也都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/151.wav", + "text": "有沒有那個即由是需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/152.wav", + "text": "再訂時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/153.wav", + "text": "因為職權行使法裡面有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/154.wav", + "text": "好就是在討論的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/155.wav", + "text": "我覺得可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/156.wav", + "text": "我個人沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/157.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/158.wav", + "text": "我想今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/159.wav", + "text": "的審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/160.wav", + "text": "針對台灣民眾黨第2條的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/161.wav", + "text": "大家應該是有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/162.wav", + "text": "如果這一條大家沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/163.wav", + "text": "我們就照民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/164.wav", + "text": "如果有意見就送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/165.wav", + "text": "國民黨的意見是沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/166.wav", + "text": "整個程序要怎麼進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/167.wav", + "text": "我的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/168.wav", + "text": "國民黨傅崐萁委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/169.wav", + "text": "全部都有連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/170.wav", + "text": "就以這兩個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/171.wav", + "text": "那我們就是送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/172.wav", + "text": "我想這樣也比較有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/173.wav", + "text": "我建議這樣子好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/174.wav", + "text": "和國民黨的版本差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/175.wav", + "text": "只是用字遣詞有點不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/176.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁委員的版本就是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/177.wav", + "text": "52位委員連署的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/178.wav", + "text": "我剛才講第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/179.wav", + "text": "比較沒有意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/180.wav", + "text": "我們同意這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/181.wav", + "text": "處理其他的就是以傅崐萁委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/182.wav", + "text": "所提國民黨52個人連署的那個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/183.wav", + "text": "以及民眾黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/184.wav", + "text": "請問還有委員要表示意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/185.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/186.wav", + "text": "我們現在就開始逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/187.wav", + "text": "依照民眾黨黨團的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/188.wav", + "text": "請問就第2條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/189.wav", + "text": "各位有無異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/190.wav", + "text": "議沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/191.wav", + "text": "就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/192.wav", + "text": "第十五條是翁曉玲委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/193.wav", + "text": "請問就翁曉玲委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/194.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/195.wav", + "text": "有意見的話我想本條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/196.wav", + "text": "針對這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/197.wav", + "text": "如果在委員會審查的時候可以討論的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/198.wav", + "text": "我們就可以充分地說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/199.wav", + "text": "但今天只能在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/200.wav", + "text": "這樣一個有限的時間空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/201.wav", + "text": "及有限的委員面前來做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/202.wav", + "text": "我想���裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/203.wav", + "text": "我們看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/204.wav", + "text": "修正的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/205.wav", + "text": "它和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/206.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/207.wav", + "text": "這一條很怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/208.wav", + "text": "是第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/209.wav", + "text": "我們看成第十五條之1我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/210.wav", + "text": "是對第十五條之1有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/211.wav", + "text": "但我不明白第十五條的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/212.wav", + "text": "是標點符號嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/213.wav", + "text": "是不是說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/214.wav", + "text": "一一個是記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/215.wav", + "text": "鍾委員你剛剛是不是要表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/216.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/217.wav", + "text": "因為現行是這樣處置的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/218.wav", + "text": "總統所頒布的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/219.wav", + "text": "追認的時候要由全院委員會來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/220.wav", + "text": "審查之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/221.wav", + "text": "要用無記名的方式來表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/222.wav", + "text": "覺得這有點困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/223.wav", + "text": "現在提案委員就變成一個關鍵的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/224.wav", + "text": "他是認為現行有什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/225.wav", + "text": "扞格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/226.wav", + "text": "所以他要改成以記名投票為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/227.wav", + "text": "不來說明這要怎麼討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/228.wav", + "text": "可以替他說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/229.wav", + "text": "這個如果在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/230.wav", + "text": "討論的話提案人就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/231.wav", + "text": "對提案要說明啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/232.wav", + "text": "在今天協商這個程序上他又不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/233.wav", + "text": "但這是一個關鍵從無記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/234.wav", + "text": "要改成記名他的立論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/235.wav", + "text": "是什麼現行在處置上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/236.wav", + "text": "有什麼樣子的扞格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/237.wav", + "text": "有什麼樣的不妥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/238.wav", + "text": "目前提案委員不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/239.wav", + "text": "那就只能保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/240.wav", + "text": "好接下來請黃委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/241.wav", + "text": "如果有黨團表示不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/242.wav", + "text": "而要保留我沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/243.wav", + "text": "我們接下來就按照這個原則處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/244.wav", + "text": "\n不過我先代表台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/245.wav", + "text": "針對這個條文發表我們的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/246.wav", + "text": "針對第十五條這樣的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/247.wav", + "text": "我們是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/248.wav", + "text": "支持的理由非常的容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/249.wav", + "text": "針對總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/250.wav", + "text": "所提出來的緊急命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/251.wav", + "text": "要讓立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/252.wav", + "text": "投票決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/253.wav", + "text": "我們到底是同意還是不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/254.wav", + "text": "這一種對於國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/255.wav", + "text": "重大事項的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/256.wav", + "text": "決定當然是以記名投票的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/257.wav", + "text": "才能夠展現負責任的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/258.wav", + "text": "對於把現行條文第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/259.wav", + "text": "從無記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/260.wav", + "text": "改成記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/261.wav", + "text": "不僅符合責任政治的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/262.wav", + "text": "目前立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/263.wav", + "text": "在院會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/264.wav", + "text": "也是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/265.wav", + "text": "因此本黨團針對第十五條的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/266.wav", + "text": "敬表同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/267.wav", + "text": "十五條如果大家沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/268.wav", + "text": "不是沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/269.wav", + "text": "提案委員說明的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/270.wav", + "text": "我們的確連一個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/271.wav", + "text": "的差別都會忽略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/272.wav", + "text": "\n事實上因為目前立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/273.wav", + "text": "表決都是用表決器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/274.wav", + "text": "形同記名表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/275.wav", + "text": "條文上沒有特別註明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/276.wav", + "text": "就是形同記名表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/277.wav", + "text": "啦當然我們現在還保留有記名表決的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/278.wav", + "text": "但那只是我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/279.wav", + "text": "立法院議事規則當中的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/280.wav", + "text": "作法以前沒有用電子表決既成一個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/281.wav", + "text": "現在是不是可以請秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/282.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/283.wav", + "text": "因為這涉及到後面還有一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/284.wav", + "text": "像這麼重大的國家大事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/285.wav", + "text": "的表決在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/286.wav", + "text": "比這個小很多的都是記名表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/287.wav", + "text": "沒有理由說這個不記名表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/288.wav", + "text": "只是在條文上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/289.wav", + "text": "特別規定記名或不記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/290.wav", + "text": "做這樣的更動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/291.wav", + "text": "對實況上的影響是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/292.wav", + "text": "可不可以請秘書長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/293.wav", + "text": "麻煩秘書長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/294.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/295.wav", + "text": "什麼我個人沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/296.wav", + "text": "過要跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/297.wav", + "text": "全院委員會審查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/298.wav", + "text": "六個案都是用投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/299.wav", + "text": "不是用表決器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/300.wav", + "text": "這部分各位可以去看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/301.wav", + "text": "相關條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/302.wav", + "text": "目前是三個用記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/303.wav", + "text": "三個沒有記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/304.wav", + "text": "不過這一次職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/305.wav", + "text": "的修正幾乎全部改為記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/306.wav", + "text": "說明的時候講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/307.wav", + "text": "那就由大家合議吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/308.wav", + "text": "主席在場各位代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/309.wav", + "text": "我對記名和無記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/310.wav", + "text": "我們正副院長的投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/311.wav", + "text": "那也都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/312.wav", + "text": "我們在立法院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/313.wav", + "text": "你說不記名投票其實大家也都亮票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/314.wav", + "text": "你看美國的投票他們就記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/315.wav", + "text": "啊你去看日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/316.wav", + "text": "你去看德國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/317.wav", + "text": "像法國英國他們又是不記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/318.wav", + "text": "要記名或不記名那不是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/319.wav", + "text": "如果真的要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/320.wav", + "text": "甚至於讓民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/321.wav", + "text": "在投票的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/322.wav", + "text": "你的行為你的取向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/323.wav", + "text": "這個很透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/324.wav", + "text": "啊我覺得這也沒有什麼不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/325.wav", + "text": "提案的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/326.wav", + "text": "一個案子在朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/327.wav", + "text": "也沒有人來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/328.wav", + "text": "這就可以凸顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/329.wav", + "text": "為什麼先要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/330.wav", + "text": "提案委員做提案說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/331.wav", + "text": "以後再進行大體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/332.wav", + "text": "如果我們把前面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/333.wav", + "text": "都忽略掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/334.wav", + "text": "像我們剛剛在看這個條文的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/335.wav", + "text": "到最後還是黃國昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/336.wav", + "text": "看到少了一個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/337.wav", + "text": "關於少了這一個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/338.wav", + "text": "如果提案委員說這是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/339.wav", + "text": "或者是整個憲政的思潮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/340.wav", + "text": "這個也可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/341.wav", + "text": "啊但是連提案委員都不到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/342.wav", + "text": "這在委員會裡面是怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/343.wav", + "text": "我們連審都沒有審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/344.wav", + "text": "啊立法院的慣例就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/345.wav", + "text": "但是我們是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/346.wav", + "text": "啊不過我要跟主席講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/347.wav", + "text": "委員會不審查法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/348.wav", + "text": "不逐條討論就會造成這樣的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/349.wav", + "text": "不管民眾黨或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/350.wav", + "text": "民進黨的委員都表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/351.wav", + "text": "就是把這一條改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/352.wav", + "text": "記名投票大家也沒什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/353.wav", + "text": "很大的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/354.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/355.wav", + "text": "那就停止討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/356.wav", + "text": "我們就同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/357.wav", + "text": "不要再發言了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/358.wav", + "text": "這個無當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/359.wav", + "text": "這是編印的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/360.wav", + "text": "啦不是提案委員沒來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/361.wav", + "text": "所以我們不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/362.wav", + "text": "我想既然這個立法的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/363.wav", + "text": "大家都贊同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/364.wav", + "text": "剛剛秘書長也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/365.wav", + "text": "尊重大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/366.wav", + "text": "剛才聽你們講就同意啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/367.wav", + "text": "就這樣給它過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/368.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/369.wav", + "text": "我想在場的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/370.wav", + "text": "我們大概都沒有周秘書長來的資深" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/371.wav", + "text": "莊委員第八屆進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/372.wav", + "text": "我個人跟吳委員第九屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/373.wav", + "text": "還有黃委員也是第九屆進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/374.wav", + "text": "林委員第十屆進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/375.wav", + "text": "現在是第十一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/376.wav", + "text": "從第八屆到第十一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/377.wav", + "text": "本院有進行過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/378.wav", + "text": "記名投票表決嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/379.wav", + "text": "有沒有進行過記名投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/380.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/381.wav", + "text": "沒有進行過記名投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/382.wav", + "text": "但是我們有進行過無記名投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/383.wav", + "text": "無記名投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/384.wav", + "text": "誠如剛剛秘書長說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/385.wav", + "text": "目前在立法院職權行使法當中有6項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/386.wav", + "text": "無記名投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/387.wav", + "text": "是對於人事同意權進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/388.wav", + "text": "所以我們是去領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/389.wav", + "text": "類似像選票啦是領票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/390.wav", + "text": "但是票上沒有註明你的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/391.wav", + "text": "所以我們都很習慣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/392.wav", + "text": "領了票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/393.wav", + "text": "然後就對於票上的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/394.wav", + "text": "表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/395.wav", + "text": "圈選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/396.wav", + "text": "為什麼我剛剛還特別去請教秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/397.wav", + "text": "因為我來這九年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/398.wav", + "text": "沒有遇到過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/399.wav", + "text": "但是過去的記名投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/400.wav", + "text": "每張選票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/401.wav", + "text": "都有該委員的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/402.wav", + "text": "它的嚴謹度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/403.wav", + "text": "比點名表決還要嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/404.wav", + "text": "點名表決是唱名唱到委員的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/405.wav", + "text": "委員起來表示贊成或反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/406.wav", + "text": "但是記名表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/407.wav", + "text": "是記名表決的票上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/408.wav", + "text": "有註明委員的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/409.wav", + "text": "委員領到票之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/410.wav", + "text": "在上面做出你的意思表示贊成或反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/411.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/412.wav", + "text": "再投到票匭裡去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/413.wav", + "text": "唱名表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/414.wav", + "text": "還要嚴謹的原因是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/415.wav", + "text": "它會留下了一個很清楚的紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/416.wav", + "text": "\n所以過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/417.wav", + "text": "我們立法院職權行使法當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/418.wav", + "text": "無記名表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/419.wav", + "text": "就是包括原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/420.wav", + "text": "以及人事同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/421.wav", + "text": "包括倒閣包括解散國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/422.wav", + "text": "以及包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/423.wav", + "text": "剛剛秘書長還提到的有3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/424.wav", + "text": "也還未處理過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/425.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法中的記名投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/426.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/427.wav", + "text": "就是不信任案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/428.wav", + "text": "啦因為目前還沒有發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/429.wav", + "text": "所以我這裡還是要很慎重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/430.wav", + "text": "因為我們秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/431.wav", + "text": "是議事專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/432.wav", + "text": "3項無記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/433.wav", + "text": "3項記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/434.wav", + "text": "秘書長說過去都曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/435.wav", + "text": "我第九屆才進來我不曉得之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/436.wav", + "text": "有對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/437.wav", + "text": "這樣的記名表決行使的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/438.wav", + "text": "立法院的生態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/439.wav", + "text": "我想召委也沒有遇到過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/440.wav", + "text": "我們其實都沒有遇到過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/441.wav", + "text": "記名投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/442.wav", + "text": "這個情況是不是請秘書長完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/443.wav", + "text": "說明一下我們才能瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/444.wav", + "text": "為什麼原來第十五條的規定是無記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/445.wav", + "text": "名我們現在改成記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/446.wav", + "text": "誠如剛剛黃總召所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/447.wav", + "text": "大家認為這麼重大的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/448.wav", + "text": "我們用表決器表決都是具名的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/449.wav", + "text": "嘛按下去就會出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/450.wav", + "text": "在按表決器的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/451.wav", + "text": "脫序或疏漏的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/452.wav", + "text": "但是如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/453.wav", + "text": "記名投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/454.wav", + "text": "就會完完全全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/455.wav", + "text": "杜絕這樣的亂象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/456.wav", + "text": "所以它是個非常慎重的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/457.wav", + "text": "幾位現場的委員過去不曾有經歷過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/458.wav", + "text": "可不可以請秘書長幫我們介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/459.wav", + "text": "這6種記名表決跟無記名表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/460.wav", + "text": "因為我們今天是協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/461.wav", + "text": "這一條我本來以為大家都有高度的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/462.wav", + "text": "當然沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/463.wav", + "text": "如果鍾召委有這個需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/464.wav", + "text": "我們就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/465.wav", + "text": "有效率一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/466.wav", + "text": "有高度共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/467.wav", + "text": "有必要再回過頭去做這些事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/468.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/469.wav", + "text": "佳濱講得好像也有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/470.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/471.wav", + "text": "這種問題我們不要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/472.wav", + "text": "議事處去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/473.wav", + "text": "記名投票會有什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/474.wav", + "text": "這根本就不用說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/475.wav", + "text": "大家可想而知它都做過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/476.wav", + "text": "我們就信任它吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/477.wav", + "text": "我們沒有做過但他們以前做過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/478.wav", + "text": "整個議事效率就變慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/479.wav", + "text": "大家都同意說要改記名投票方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/480.wav", + "text": "我們就用記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/481.wav", + "text": "剛才你們都說這個就可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/482.wav", + "text": "所以我們要慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/483.wav", + "text": "嘛他們已經處理過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/484.wav", + "text": "秘書長你儘快說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/485.wav", + "text": "記名跟不記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/486.wav", + "text": "我舉個例來講憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/487.wav", + "text": "所以不信任案已經做過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/488.wav", + "text": "覆議案也做過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/489.wav", + "text": "陳總統的時候也做過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/490.wav", + "text": "我剛才講過有6個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/491.wav", + "text": "3個有做過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/492.wav", + "text": "現在這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/493.wav", + "text": "權行使法裡面委員提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/494.wav", + "text": "把另外3個也改成記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/495.wav", + "text": "我剛才已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/496.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/497.wav", + "text": "實務上我們已經都處理過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/498.wav", + "text": "你如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/499.wav", + "text": "認為這個不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/500.wav", + "text": "宜用記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/501.wav", + "text": "各位委員去合議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/502.wav", + "text": "謝謝秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/503.wav", + "text": "再度的讓我們修正很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/504.wav", + "text": "它這裡講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/505.wav", + "text": "罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/506.wav", + "text": "不信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/507.wav", + "text": "跟覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/508.wav", + "text": "前兩項是對人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/509.wav", + "text": "罷免是對總統進行罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/510.wav", + "text": "不信任是對行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/511.wav", + "text": "對閣揆等於形同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/512.wav", + "text": "它就是對人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/513.wav", + "text": "是用記名投票的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/514.wav", + "text": "來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/515.wav", + "text": "那覆議就不同囉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/516.wav", + "text": "覆議是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/517.wav", + "text": "對於立法院所為之重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/518.wav", + "text": "政策之決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/519.wav", + "text": "它無法執行它就移請立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/520.wav", + "text": "進行覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/521.wav", + "text": "這個覆議是就事就政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/522.wav", + "text": "這種情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/523.wav", + "text": "要記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/524.wav", + "text": "它的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/525.wav", + "text": "是相當程度的嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/526.wav", + "text": "我們可以理解原來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/527.wav", + "text": "職權行使法當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/528.wav", + "text": "立法院所要行使的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/529.wav", + "text": "人事罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/530.wav", + "text": "跟不信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/531.wav", + "text": "就是倒閣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/532.wav", + "text": "是就人的部分它是要記名的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/533.wav", + "text": "覆議的部分是就事的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/534.wav", + "text": "進行覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/535.wav", + "text": "但是另外3項的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/536.wav", + "text": "一個就是這裡所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/537.wav", + "text": "我們的人事同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/538.wav", + "text": "是無記名的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/539.wav", + "text": "請問秘書長還有哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/540.wav", + "text": "彈劾罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/541.wav", + "text": "加彈劾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/542.wav", + "text": "彈劾跟罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/543.wav", + "text": "對現在目前罷免是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/544.wav", + "text": "彈劾是不記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/545.wav", + "text": "彈劾不記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/546.wav", + "text": "對總統進行彈劾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/547.wav", + "text": "我再一分鐘說明可不可以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/548.wav", + "text": "的不信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/549.wav", + "text": "案如果從議學上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/550.wav", + "text": "對人是不記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/551.wav", + "text": "對事記名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/552.wav", + "text": "那不信任案就對人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/553.wav", + "text": "條文就明定記名投票了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/554.wav", + "text": "所以要用議學裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/555.wav", + "text": "對人對事這個我就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/556.wav", + "text": "很難在這邊做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/557.wav", + "text": "所以我才說請各位委員去合議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/558.wav", + "text": "我沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/559.wav", + "text": "啦送院會處理了啦好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/560.wav", + "text": "如果大家都沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/561.wav", + "text": "那就乾脆保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/562.wav", + "text": "等一下我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/563.wav", + "text": "我也同意送保留處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/564.wav", + "text": "為什麼呢理由要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/565.wav", + "text": "跳過了委員會討論的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/566.wav", + "text": "所以我們剛剛對於現行的6項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/567.wav", + "text": "記名或無記名它過去行使的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/568.wav", + "text": "歷史脈���是什麼我們都沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/569.wav", + "text": "在委員會討論只好在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/570.wav", + "text": "協商討論以目前來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/571.wav", + "text": "其實緊急命令是非常非常嚴肅跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/572.wav", + "text": "重要的事情我當然當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/573.wav", + "text": "立委只有九年我沒有碰過但我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/574.wav", + "text": "印象中可以記得的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/575.wav", + "text": "李登輝針對921的時候提起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/576.wav", + "text": "的緊急命令因為當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/577.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有震災條例也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/578.wav", + "text": "災害防救法所以當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/579.wav", + "text": "總統為了要超越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/580.wav", + "text": "法律就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/581.wav", + "text": "目前沒有法律來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/582.wav", + "text": "的事情所以他的緊急命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/583.wav", + "text": "等於是賦予在國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/584.wav", + "text": "或人民遭受緊急危難的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/585.wav", + "text": "有一個準法律的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/586.wav", + "text": "543號裡面對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/587.wav", + "text": "緊急命令的追認權行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/588.wav", + "text": "是提出來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/589.wav", + "text": "只有追認yesorno" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/590.wav", + "text": "但是追認也有部分追認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/591.wav", + "text": "或是全部追認這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/592.wav", + "text": "因為我們都沒有經歷過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/593.wav", + "text": "現在立法委員針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/594.wav", + "text": "其他的立法相對都更為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/595.wav", + "text": "嚴謹完備譬如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/596.wav", + "text": "的時候也曾經討論要不要總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/597.wav", + "text": "來頒緊急命令但是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/598.wav", + "text": "是越來越進步所以這幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/599.wav", + "text": "是沒有過上一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/600.wav", + "text": "應該就是921的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/601.wav", + "text": "所以我認為更嚴謹的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/602.wav", + "text": "是這個條文保留但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/603.wav", + "text": "在院會處理的時候更為嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/604.wav", + "text": "的是我們應當針對現在的6個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/605.wav", + "text": "在院會所行使的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/606.wav", + "text": "投票行為彈劾罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/607.wav", + "text": "不信任覆議緊急命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/608.wav", + "text": "跟人事同意權的各個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/609.wav", + "text": "哪一項應當是在哪一個level" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/610.wav", + "text": "用記名或無記名更為嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/611.wav", + "text": "它一定都有法律的立論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/612.wav", + "text": "我認為這樣討論才是��責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/613.wav", + "text": "好嗎所以這個在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/614.wav", + "text": "必須做這樣的處理當然也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/615.wav", + "text": "期待提案的委員要負責任說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/616.wav", + "text": "他提案的緣由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/617.wav", + "text": "這樣才是嚴謹才是嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/618.wav", + "text": "因為這是涉及憲法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/619.wav", + "text": "力所以這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/620.wav", + "text": "第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/621.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/622.wav", + "text": "請問一下第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/623.wav", + "text": "好因為有異議的話我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/624.wav", + "text": "有意見也是要講一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/625.wav", + "text": "這一條是重中之重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/626.wav", + "text": "耶第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/627.wav", + "text": "職權行使法從第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/628.wav", + "text": "開始有好幾個條文都在處理總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/629.wav", + "text": "到立法院國情報告的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/630.wav", + "text": "程序委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/631.wav", + "text": "國民黨也好民眾黨也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/632.wav", + "text": "也都有援引職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/633.wav", + "text": "第十五條相關的條例要提請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/634.wav", + "text": "未來總統賴清德來立法院國情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/635.wav", + "text": "條文是只有一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/636.wav", + "text": "就是回應憲法增修條文第四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/637.wav", + "text": "第三項的規定立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/638.wav", + "text": "得於每年集會時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/639.wav", + "text": "聽取總統國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/640.wav", + "text": "所以它的keyword第一個是得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/641.wav", + "text": "第二個是報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/642.wav", + "text": "就是onlyfor報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/643.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁委員是增加了兩項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/644.wav", + "text": "好像是我在替傅崐萁委員做提案說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/645.wav", + "text": "好怪喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/646.wav", + "text": "第二項也是把時間明定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/647.wav", + "text": "是2月1號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/648.wav", + "text": "然後3月1號要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/649.wav", + "text": "進行時間就把它block住了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/650.wav", + "text": "就職兩週內就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/651.wav", + "text": "先送國情報告書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/652.wav", + "text": "然後在一個月來進行國情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/653.wav", + "text": "報告所以他把時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/654.wav", + "text": "定死了而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/655.wav", + "text": "定死的包括實體的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/656.wav", + "text": "人來報告也包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/657.wav", + "text": "送報告書文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/658.wav", + "text": "\n我認為這樣都已經溢出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/659.wav", + "text": "憲法的授權而且更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/660.wav", + "text": "綁手綁腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/661.wav", + "text": "我個人是沒有辦法同意國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/662.wav", + "text": "幾位委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/663.wav", + "text": "我再一次說怎麼會是我在替" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/664.wav", + "text": "傅崐萁委員做提案說明呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/665.wav", + "text": "提案委員沒有能力來這裡針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/666.wav", + "text": "自己的提案做說明嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/667.wav", + "text": "憲法的原文我覺得有所扞格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/668.wav", + "text": "而且有所逾越我沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/669.wav", + "text": "主席我是建議既然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/670.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員他們有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/671.wav", + "text": "那我們就送保留嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/672.wav", + "text": "主席讓我們在協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/673.wav", + "text": "表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/674.wav", + "text": "其實原來的第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/675.wav", + "text": "它原條文是依中華民國憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/676.wav", + "text": "增修條文第四條第三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/677.wav", + "text": "規定立法院得於每年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/678.wav", + "text": "集會時聽取總統國情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/679.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/680.wav", + "text": "有參與到當年增修條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/681.wav", + "text": "修改的時候我們很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/682.wav", + "text": "立法院有許多的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/683.wav", + "text": "在有存在國民大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/684.wav", + "text": "跟不存在國民大會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/685.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/686.wav", + "text": "長提到的罷免跟彈劾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/687.wav", + "text": "在存有國民大會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/688.wav", + "text": "罷免權是立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/689.wav", + "text": "所有的但是要提交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/690.wav", + "text": "全國公民去進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/691.wav", + "text": "因為總統是人民直選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/692.wav", + "text": "立法院只能提出罷免案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/693.wav", + "text": "交全國公民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/694.wav", + "text": "來複決之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/695.wav", + "text": "就像原來的修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/696.wav", + "text": "立法院可以提出修憲案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/697.wav", + "text": "後來的增修條文要提到全國公民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/698.wav", + "text": "複決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/699.wav", + "text": "但是原來對總統的彈劾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/700.wav", + "text": "監察院接著跑到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/701.wav", + "text": "後來又再跑到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/702.wav", + "text": "\n就目前的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/703.wav", + "text": "它在原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/704.wav", + "text": "增修條文當中在還存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/705.wav", + "text": "國民大會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/706.wav", + "text": "是在憲法增修條文第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/707.wav", + "text": "國民大會集會時得聽取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/708.wav", + "text": "總統國情報告並檢討國是提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/709.wav", + "text": "建言如一年內未集會由總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/710.wav", + "text": "召集會議為之不受憲法第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/711.wav", + "text": "之限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/712.wav", + "text": "如果這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/713.wav", + "text": "不是我就不懂今天我們不是審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/714.wav", + "text": "要審慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/715.wav", + "text": "因為原來它把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/716.wav", + "text": "增修條文臚列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/717.wav", + "text": "其實就是表示增修條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/718.wav", + "text": "移到立法院來繼受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/719.wav", + "text": "但是它放在第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/720.wav", + "text": "就表示原來立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/721.wav", + "text": "並不存在這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/722.wav", + "text": "聽取總統的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/723.wav", + "text": "純粹是在2005年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/724.wav", + "text": "將國民大會廢除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/725.wav", + "text": "才會將國民大會原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/726.wav", + "text": "總統國情報告這樣一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/727.wav", + "text": "移給立法院來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/728.wav", + "text": "要1個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/729.wav", + "text": "其實這些提案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/730.wav", + "text": "體例都是參照目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/731.wav", + "text": "行政院向立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/732.wav", + "text": "而行政院必須向立法院提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/733.wav", + "text": "這樣的施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/734.wav", + "text": "它的體例是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/735.wav", + "text": "所以我們從國民大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/736.wav", + "text": "接受了國民大會廢止後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/737.wav", + "text": "儀式性的一個職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/738.wav", + "text": "現在卻把它擴張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/739.wav", + "text": "立法院直接可以監督行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/740.wav", + "text": "要求行政院來做施政報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/741.wav", + "text": "職權的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/742.wav", + "text": "格式程序類同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/743.wav", + "text": "這就是為什麼我們一再的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/744.wav", + "text": "認為這個條文期期以為不可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/745.wav", + "text": "為因為這讓我們目前立法院在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/746.wav", + "text": "憲法規範的職權對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/747.wav", + "text": "行政院進行監督的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/748.wav", + "text": "再跑出了一個跟總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/749.wav", + "text": "類似的監督權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/750.wav", + "text": "而這兩個行使的格式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/751.wav", + "text": "模式幾乎一模一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/752.wav", + "text": "\n為什麼提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/753.wav", + "text": "不在現場我們很難去詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/754.wav", + "text": "但其實主席在您現在就在臺上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/755.wav", + "text": "立法院去監督行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/756.wav", + "text": "把它拷貝過來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/757.wav", + "text": "這才會引發為什麼說是憲政上的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/758.wav", + "text": "因為立法院不對總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/759.wav", + "text": "進行監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/760.wav", + "text": "總統不是對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/761.wav", + "text": "是行政院對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/762.wav", + "text": "當時有這樣一個國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/763.wav", + "text": "是基於總統原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/764.wav", + "text": "在1996年之前是由國民大會選舉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/765.wav", + "text": "所以國民大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/766.wav", + "text": "才取得了對總統聽取國民大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/767.wav", + "text": "國情報告這樣的權力但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/768.wav", + "text": "現在總統不是由立法院選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/769.wav", + "text": "國民大會也廢止了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/770.wav", + "text": "我們把一個廢止機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/771.wav", + "text": "在增修條文裡面的一個權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/772.wav", + "text": "把它繼受過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/773.wav", + "text": "我們就要把它當作是監督行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/774.wav", + "text": "一樣的方式來行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/775.wav", + "text": "這裡面的確有憲政上的扞格啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/776.wav", + "text": "\n過去我們在委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/777.wav", + "text": "時沒有機會做這樣的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/778.wav", + "text": "今天剛好主席您本身就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/779.wav", + "text": "提案委員所以我藉這個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/780.wav", + "text": "來做一個交換意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/781.wav", + "text": "因為剛好不巧本席是1996年選出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/782.wav", + "text": "我們不能選總統之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/783.wav", + "text": "還拿了一個總統來國情報告的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/784.wav", + "text": "1996年總統就直選了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/785.wav", + "text": "聽取國情報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/786.wav", + "text": "是完全沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/787.wav", + "text": "對於總統行實質上監督的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/788.wav", + "text": "我們只有對總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/789.wav", + "text": "執行彈劾的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/790.wav", + "text": "那是在幾次修憲當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/791.wav", + "text": "一度有過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/792.wav", + "text": "難免會讓人覺得我們是錯亂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/793.wav", + "text": "我們到底是監督行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/794.wav", + "text": "還是監督總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/795.wav", + "text": "這一點還是要懇請讓我們未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/796.wav", + "text": "有進一步可以討論的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/797.wav", + "text": "我們再來好好討論這第十五條之1的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/798.wav", + "text": "及說明的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/799.wav", + "text": "因為我們今天是協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/800.wav", + "text": "不是審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/801.wav", + "text": "所以如果對於我們的提案內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/802.wav", + "text": "有異議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/803.wav", + "text": "那就是送院會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/804.wav", + "text": "既然有異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/805.wav", + "text": "沒有問題我們都尊重大家的異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/806.wav", + "text": "或是有要提修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/807.wav", + "text": "我也沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/808.wav", + "text": "本來我還覺得你很開明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/809.wav", + "text": "不是你剛不是也講我們今天就是要來逐條討論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/810.wav", + "text": "不是我們今天可不可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/811.wav", + "text": "逐條討論是剛才你講的不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/812.wav", + "text": "我們就送院會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/813.wav", + "text": "有直播了誰敢在這個地方胡說八道呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/814.wav", + "text": "如果大家有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/815.wav", + "text": "對那個異不是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/816.wav", + "text": "沒有討論怎麼會知道大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/817.wav", + "text": "怎樣可以整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/818.wav", + "text": "立法通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/819.wav", + "text": "總統的國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/820.wav", + "text": "條文裡面做規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/821.wav", + "text": "你們認為這個好像不太妥當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/822.wav", + "text": "保留送院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/823.wav", + "text": "立法委員總要有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/824.wav", + "text": "把自己的見解在審查條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/825.wav", + "text": "裡面講出來看誰講得有沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/826.wav", + "text": "或胡說八道嘛主席我可以講話吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/827.wav", + "text": "\n我想第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/828.wav", + "text": "各位其實也可以去想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/829.wav", + "text": "條文第四條之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/830.wav", + "text": "行法的規定是立法院每一年集會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/831.wav", + "text": "國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/832.wav", + "text": "我相信這個也是要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/833.wav", + "text": "總統被人民選出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/834.wav", + "text": "本來都是把行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/835.wav", + "text": "放在第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/836.wav", + "text": "希望也有機會讓立法院來聽聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/837.wav", + "text": "總統的一個看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/838.wav", + "text": "我不曉得傅崐萁委員吳宗憲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/839.wav", + "text": "還有翁曉玲委員跟呂玉玲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/840.wav", + "text": "4個版本你們要用哪一個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/841.wav", + "text": "4個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/842.wav", + "text": "你們要自己先去整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/843.wav", + "text": "啊以吳宗憲委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/844.wav", + "text": "跟傅崐萁委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/845.wav", + "text": "跟其他委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/846.wav", + "text": "我就看出你們文字裡面大有不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/847.wav", + "text": "啊你們的中心思想是完全不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/848.wav", + "text": "啊從過去立法院的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/849.wav", + "text": "總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/850.wav", + "text": "都想到國會來做國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/851.wav", + "text": "可是立法院就會加碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/852.wav", + "text": "沒有一問一答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/853.wav", + "text": "就不要來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/854.wav", + "text": "過去是總統想來立法院不給他們來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/855.wav", + "text": "為什麼總統想來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/856.wav", + "text": "立法院不給他們來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/857.wav", + "text": "總統又不能來了呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/858.wav", + "text": "因為立法院就是不歡迎你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/859.wav", + "text": "啊總統是不是想來就可以來呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/860.wav", + "text": "倒也不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/861.wav", + "text": "你自己本身的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/862.wav", + "text": "你是說總統在每一年的2月1號以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/863.wav", + "text": "將國情報告書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/864.wav", + "text": "送交立法院並咨請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/865.wav", + "text": "立法院同意後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/866.wav", + "text": "你的第三項新修訂的是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/867.wav", + "text": "新就任總統應於就職兩週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/868.wav", + "text": "向立法院提出國情報告書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/869.wav", + "text": "並咨請立法院同意後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/870.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/871.wav", + "text": "你的提案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/872.wav", + "text": "就算總統想來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/873.wav", + "text": "第一個國情報告書要先送到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/874.wav", + "text": "而且還要經過立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/875.wav", + "text": "同意以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/876.wav", + "text": "1個月內才可以到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/877.wav", + "text": "進行國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/878.wav", + "text": "現在傅崐萁委員的提案就跟你完全不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/879.wav", + "text": "啦傅崐萁是說你就是要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/880.wav", + "text": "我立法院不用同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/881.wav", + "text": "你就是法定義務變成一個應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/882.wav", + "text": "那我要就教的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/883.wav", + "text": "這樣跟我們現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/884.wav", + "text": "憲法增修條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/885.wav", + "text": "第四條第三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/886.wav", + "text": "立法院得於每年集會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/887.wav", + "text": "聽取總統報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/888.wav", + "text": "是得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/889.wav", + "text": "你現在把它變成應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/890.wav", + "text": "應和得在法律上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/891.wav", + "text": "整個用意含義完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/892.wav", + "text": "今天我們是在協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/893.wav", + "text": "不是在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/894.wav", + "text": "先聽我說協商的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/895.wav", + "text": "應該是大家有沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/896.wav", + "text": "就送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/897.wav", + "text": "嘛應該是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/898.wav", + "text": "這是今天會議的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/899.wav", + "text": "但又回過頭去講誰的提案怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/900.wav", + "text": "內容又怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/901.wav", + "text": "不是就沒有共識了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/902.wav", + "text": "林委員提說到院會再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/903.wav", + "text": "因為今天是協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/904.wav", + "text": "協商就是你對於提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/905.wav", + "text": "我跟你講啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/906.wav", + "text": "今天如果是台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/907.wav", + "text": "他們就跟你們翻臉啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/908.wav", + "text": "今天提案的人沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/909.wav", + "text": "你這是閹割自己啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/910.wav", + "text": "提案的人既然已經提這樣子了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/911.wav", + "text": "那就是沒有共識嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/912.wav", + "text": "就是沒有共識啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/913.wav", + "text": "你現在又要回過頭去變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/914.wav", + "text": "逐條審查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/915.wav", + "text": "不是你今天協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/916.wav", + "text": "逐條審查要就每一個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/917.wav", + "text": "然後去批評每個提案人的意見怎麼樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/918.wav", + "text": "不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/919.wav", + "text": "你講的是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/920.wav", + "text": "提案人講的都是錯的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/921.wav", + "text": "我們該尊重他們吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/922.wav", + "text": "不認同他們的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/923.wav", + "text": "那有異議我們就送院會處理嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/924.wav", + "text": "是不是今天協商應該是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/925.wav", + "text": "好第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/926.wav", + "text": "既然大家��有共識那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/927.wav", + "text": "\n第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/928.wav", + "text": "我不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/929.wav", + "text": "我舉手舉了2分鐘不讓我講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/930.wav", + "text": "沒有講過的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/931.wav", + "text": "今天是協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/932.wav", + "text": "不是你的演講比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/933.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/934.wav", + "text": "你讓委員講一下話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/935.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員舉手舉這麼久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/936.wav", + "text": "協商不就是大家講話嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/937.wav", + "text": "對於第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/938.wav", + "text": "跟補充好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/939.wav", + "text": "主席要不然協商是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/940.wav", + "text": "我們來這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/941.wav", + "text": "主席就因為你們在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/942.wav", + "text": "在委員會沒有辦法逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/943.wav", + "text": "協商就是審查的延伸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/944.wav", + "text": "主席我還沒有講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/945.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/946.wav", + "text": "我還沒有講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/947.wav", + "text": "我還沒有講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/948.wav", + "text": "我還沒有講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/949.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/950.wav", + "text": "我要補充我為什麼反對的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/951.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/952.wav", + "text": "我們現在審查第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/953.wav", + "text": "第十五條之一保留送院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/954.wav", + "text": "現在是第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/955.wav", + "text": "請問各位對第十五條之2的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/956.wav", + "text": "這種協商是什麼意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/957.wav", + "text": "我就一直在舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/958.wav", + "text": "奇怪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/959.wav", + "text": "我現在已經在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/960.wav", + "text": "第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/961.wav", + "text": "那你要看他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/962.wav", + "text": "想不想講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/963.wav", + "text": "第十五條之2的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/964.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/965.wav", + "text": "過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/966.wav", + "text": "2第一項跟第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/967.wav", + "text": "第一項本來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/968.wav", + "text": "規定就國家安全大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/969.wav", + "text": "第二項是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/970.wav", + "text": "總統就其職權相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/971.wav", + "text": "的國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/972.wav", + "text": "第一項跟第二項在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/973.wav", + "text": "客體面過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/974.wav", + "text": "在法條的文字上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/975.wav", + "text": "有出現彼此的銜接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/976.wav", + "text": "不是非常密合的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/977.wav", + "text": "所以我們針對文字上面調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/978.wav", + "text": "寫了第十五條之2第一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/979.wav", + "text": "跟第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/980.wav", + "text": "就總統職權相關的大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/981.wav", + "text": "不管是主動還是被動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/982.wav", + "text": "的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/983.wav", + "text": "予以統一規定說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/984.wav", + "text": "提案的台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/985.wav", + "text": "已經說明完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/986.wav", + "text": "鍾召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/987.wav", + "text": "感謝民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/988.wav", + "text": "黃總召的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/989.wav", + "text": "終於我這樣才知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/990.wav", + "text": "因為只是把原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/991.wav", + "text": "第十五條之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/992.wav", + "text": "第二項就其職權相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/993.wav", + "text": "之國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/994.wav", + "text": "他把它從底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/995.wav", + "text": "拉到上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/996.wav", + "text": "來重複一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/997.wav", + "text": "就是排定議程之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/998.wav", + "text": "本來是就國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/999.wav", + "text": "安全大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1000.wav", + "text": "還要再加上就總統職權相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1001.wav", + "text": "之國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1002.wav", + "text": "所以總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1003.wav", + "text": "只能就總統職權相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1004.wav", + "text": "國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1005.wav", + "text": "顯然是台灣民眾黨所肯定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1006.wav", + "text": "所以在第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1007.wav", + "text": "要再重複一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1008.wav", + "text": "本來就有的是就其職權相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1009.wav", + "text": "之國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1010.wav", + "text": "第一項也要就總統職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1011.wav", + "text": "相關之國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1012.wav", + "text": "我這樣的理解應該沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1013.wav", + "text": "就是當時我們在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1014.wav", + "text": "職權行使法第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1015.wav", + "text": "要特別在第十五條之2裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1016.wav", + "text": "強調必須就總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1017.wav", + "text": "職權相關的國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1018.wav", + "text": "才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1019.wav", + "text": "來進行報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1020.wav", + "text": "就是因為要區隔於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1021.wav", + "text": "行政院向立法院負責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1022.wav", + "text": "憲法第五十條明文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1023.wav", + "text": "避免立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1024.wav", + "text": "對總統問一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1025.wav", + "text": "對行政院問一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1026.wav", + "text": "顯然對總統跟對行政院長問的要不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1027.wav", + "text": "所以第十五條之2在當年就把它區隔出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1028.wav", + "text": "把這樣一個重要的憲政分立精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1029.wav", + "text": "區隔出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1030.wav", + "text": "在第2項要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1031.wav", + "text": "在第1項也要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1032.wav", + "text": "我是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1033.wav", + "text": "但是就文字上表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1034.wav", + "text": "需不需要在第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1035.wav", + "text": "跟第2項都重複表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1036.wav", + "text": "我覺得這可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1037.wav", + "text": "但是至少我覺得這個方向上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1038.wav", + "text": "就是尊重原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1039.wav", + "text": "憲法體制的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1040.wav", + "text": "第十五條之2當年放了這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1041.wav", + "text": "就是要跟行政院長以示區隔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1042.wav", + "text": "\n我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1043.wav", + "text": "還是要提醒一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1044.wav", + "text": "因為接下來還有第十五條之4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1045.wav", + "text": "怎麼看不到第十五條之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1046.wav", + "text": "我再去找找看第十五條之三放在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1047.wav", + "text": "第十五條之三可能沒有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1048.wav", + "text": "我在猜應該是沒有人提修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1049.wav", + "text": "\n我這裡還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1050.wav", + "text": "做一個意見交換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1051.wav", + "text": "就是說其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1052.wav", + "text": "立法院從國民大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1053.wav", + "text": "接受的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1054.wav", + "text": "歷經多次修憲變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1055.wav", + "text": "憲法本文當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1056.wav", + "text": "司法院考試院的人事同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1057.wav", + "text": "不是由國民大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1058.wav", + "text": "而是由監察院行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1059.wav", + "text": "當時立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1060.wav", + "text": "有的人事同意權是對行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1061.wav", + "text": "的人事同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1062.wav", + "text": "是因為後來監察院去國會機關化之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1063.wav", + "text": "試院和司法院的人事同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1064.wav", + "text": "跑到國民��會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1065.wav", + "text": "又因為國民大會廢止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1066.wav", + "text": "才跑到我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1067.wav", + "text": "我還是一樣要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1068.wav", + "text": "原來憲法本文的架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1069.wav", + "text": "其實五院制的區隔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1070.wav", + "text": "是清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1071.wav", + "text": "雖然我們不盡然同意這五院制的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1072.wav", + "text": "但是經過幾次憲法增修條文遞嬗之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1073.wav", + "text": "我們發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1074.wav", + "text": "立法院從廢止的國民大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1075.wav", + "text": "接收了一些儀式性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1076.wav", + "text": "作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1077.wav", + "text": "可能會衝擊到原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1078.wav", + "text": "行政院向立法院負責的架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1079.wav", + "text": "特別慎重地區隔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1080.wav", + "text": "總統職權所在範圍內的國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1081.wav", + "text": "不會跟行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1082.wav", + "text": "必須向立法院報告的內容有所重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1083.wav", + "text": "但是反過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1084.wav", + "text": "這種儀式性的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1085.wav", + "text": "顯然會造成憲政體制的紊亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1086.wav", + "text": "所以當年在立法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1087.wav", + "text": "才增加第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1088.wav", + "text": "限制於跟總統職權有關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1089.wav", + "text": "國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1090.wav", + "text": "這樣的情況而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1091.wav", + "text": "開了一個門可能造成麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1092.wav", + "text": "又趕快再關上門這個門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1093.wav", + "text": "開開關關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1094.wav", + "text": "又打開又關上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1095.wav", + "text": "就是因為憲法本文的憲政體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1096.wav", + "text": "\n第十五條之1已經保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1097.wav", + "text": "第十五條之二我本來是認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1098.wav", + "text": "民眾黨強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1099.wav", + "text": "總統職權相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1100.wav", + "text": "是否要兩邊都表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1101.wav", + "text": "我的理由是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1102.wav", + "text": "第十五條之2分兩項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1103.wav", + "text": "第一項的發動者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1104.wav", + "text": "是立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1105.wav", + "text": "立法院可以經四分之一委員的提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1106.wav", + "text": "然後院會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1107.wav", + "text": "程序委員會排案就邀總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1108.wav", + "text": "這是立法院的發動權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1109.wav", + "text": "第二項是總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1110.wav", + "text": "自己主動要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1111.wav", + "text": "總統是主體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1112.wav", + "text": "總統就其職權相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1113.wav", + "text": "之國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1114.wav", + "text": "然後到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1115.wav", + "text": "所以第二項比較沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1116.wav", + "text": "因為是總統主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1117.wav", + "text": "想要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1118.wav", + "text": "當然就是依原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1119.wav", + "text": "報告的內容跟他職權行使相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1120.wav", + "text": "第二項是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1121.wav", + "text": "但第一項是立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1122.wav", + "text": "邀請總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1123.wav", + "text": "要邀請總統講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1124.wav", + "text": "我們討論第一項是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1125.wav", + "text": "維持原條文還是民眾黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1126.wav", + "text": "我認為就憲法的授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1127.wav", + "text": "負責國防外交跟兩岸的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1128.wav", + "text": "這是非常清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1129.wav", + "text": "邀請總統來就是依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1130.wav", + "text": "國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1131.wav", + "text": "相關的國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1132.wav", + "text": "不會讓立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1133.wav", + "text": "邀請總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1134.wav", + "text": "的議題溢出總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1135.wav", + "text": "直接的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1136.wav", + "text": "它是包山包海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1137.wav", + "text": "不管是國民黨的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1138.wav", + "text": "或是民眾黨的提案當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1139.wav", + "text": "寫到邀請未來的賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1140.wav", + "text": "總統到立法院國情報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1141.wav", + "text": "的內容事項每一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1142.wav", + "text": "總統的職權也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1143.wav", + "text": "每一項要問的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1144.wav", + "text": "都是行政院院長對立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1145.wav", + "text": "負責的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1146.wav", + "text": "為什麼我反對第1項的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1147.wav", + "text": "修正我認為還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1148.wav", + "text": "維持因為立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1149.wav", + "text": "要就國家相關的所有事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1150.wav", + "text": "對行政院長提出質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1151.wav", + "text": "如果立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1152.wav", + "text": "發起邀請總統來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1153.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法獲得更清楚的與國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1154.wav", + "text": "相關的國家大政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1155.wav", + "text": "才邀請總統來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1156.wav", + "text": "所以不能將第1項改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1157.wav", + "text": "現在的文字那就過當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1158.wav", + "text": "包山包海重蹈覆轍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1159.wav", + "text": "又重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1160.wav", + "text": "憲法第53條跟五十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1161.wav", + "text": "──行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1162.wav", + "text": "對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1163.wav", + "text": "行政院作為國家最高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1164.wav", + "text": "行政機關\n我再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1165.wav", + "text": "回來剛剛主席一直不讓我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1166.wav", + "text": "在第十五條之1繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1167.wav", + "text": "發言我在這裡一併重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1168.wav", + "text": "第十五條之1我反對的理由是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1169.wav", + "text": "它違反憲法第五十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1170.wav", + "text": "以及憲法第五十七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1171.wav", + "text": "條的原則對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1172.wav", + "text": "立法院負責的是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1173.wav", + "text": "院長第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1174.wav", + "text": "讓國情報告常態化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1175.wav", + "text": "每年必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1176.wav", + "text": "要求總統一定要來這就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1177.wav", + "text": "權力分立的扞格跟衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1178.wav", + "text": "好第十五條之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1179.wav", + "text": "我也沒有辦法支持民眾黨團這是我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1180.wav", + "text": "剛剛所說的意見立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1181.wav", + "text": "邀請的話要focus在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1182.wav", + "text": "總統直接的職權──國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1183.wav", + "text": "安全相關的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1184.wav", + "text": "總統依第二項他自己願意來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1185.wav", + "text": "他可以比較open他想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1186.wav", + "text": "跟國會對話什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1187.wav", + "text": "只要總統認為跟他的職權相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1188.wav", + "text": "他可以來發表好我報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1189.wav", + "text": "我的意見我沒有辦法同意民眾黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1190.wav", + "text": "我現在整個聽起來可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1191.wav", + "text": "很難達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1192.wav", + "text": "所以我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1193.wav", + "text": "要講到院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1194.wav", + "text": "再把它講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1195.wav", + "text": "否則這樣的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1196.wav", + "text": "我很溫柔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1197.wav", + "text": "不會啦才剛開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1198.wav", + "text": "我們現在是在補進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1199.wav", + "text": "因為委員會逐條沒有討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1200.wav", + "text": "現在只好補進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1201.wav", + "text": "的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1202.wav", + "text": "其實針對這些條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1203.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1204.wav", + "text": "從前面這幾條的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1205.wav", + "text": "看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1206.wav", + "text": "最沒有太大爭議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1207.wav", + "text": "譬如剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1208.wav", + "text": "第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1209.wav", + "text": "都可以扯到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1210.wav", + "text": "跟條文本身沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1211.wav", + "text": "的彈劾罷免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1212.wav", + "text": "不信任投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1213.wav", + "text": "記名投票表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1214.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1215.wav", + "text": "這些事情都要牽扯到條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1216.wav", + "text": "都沒有辦法達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1217.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1218.wav", + "text": "當然在整個發言的時間上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1219.wav", + "text": "我也都很節制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1220.wav", + "text": "主席需要我說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1221.wav", + "text": "但是其他的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1222.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1223.wav", + "text": "可能在整個處理的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1224.wav", + "text": "上我會尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1225.wav", + "text": "首席副書記長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1226.wav", + "text": "表達的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1227.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1228.wav", + "text": "國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1229.wav", + "text": "以及民眾黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1230.wav", + "text": "的想法應該是一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1231.wav", + "text": "你要這樣裁決以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1232.wav", + "text": "我先講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1233.wav", + "text": "我會尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1234.wav", + "text": "主席這個就很弔詭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1235.wav", + "text": "說有異議就協商再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1236.wav", + "text": "然後朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1237.wav", + "text": "有異議沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1238.wav", + "text": "就送院會再說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1239.wav", + "text": "這個實在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1240.wav", + "text": "我們必須向民眾負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1241.wav", + "text": "委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1242.wav", + "text": "以後就很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1243.wav", + "text": "會議裡面都可以不用討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1244.wav", + "text": "朝野協商就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1245.wav", + "text": "好大家的意見都不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1246.wav", + "text": "全部保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1247.wav", + "text": "想要擴權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1248.wav", + "text": "行使全部都閹割掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1249.wav", + "text": "最後主席要怎麼裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1250.wav", + "text": "我們大概猜到也知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1251.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1252.wav", + "text": "會產生一些結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1253.wav", + "text": "的制度產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1254.wav", + "text": "沒有共識就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1255.wav", + "text": "逐條討論都好像變得沒有意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1256.wav", + "text": "認為所有的討論都不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1257.wav", + "text": "會有結果也許真的是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1258.wav", + "text": "但是過去朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1259.wav", + "text": "包括預算包括法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1260.wav", + "text": "那就是需要很大的耐心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1261.wav", + "text": "這就是我們在每一黨的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1262.wav", + "text": "協商到半夜在預算審查之後逐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1263.wav", + "text": "就這樣在協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1264.wav", + "text": "我相信林思銘委員有參加過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1265.wav", + "text": "所以為什麼會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1266.wav", + "text": "這些議案不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1267.wav", + "text": "在討論協商之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1268.wav", + "text": "也許結果是沒有共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1269.wav", + "text": "但是一開始還沒有討論就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1270.wav", + "text": "看起來顯然沒有共識我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1271.wav", + "text": "這個就會讓整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1272.wav", + "text": "多此一舉因為來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1273.wav", + "text": "只是不能表決而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1274.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1275.wav", + "text": "所以我再說一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1276.wav", + "text": "我個人反對主席的裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1277.wav", + "text": "但是最後主席要怎麼裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1278.wav", + "text": "因為我認為應該要逐條地來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1279.wav", + "text": "即使最後結果是沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1280.wav", + "text": "也是經過討論之後的沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1281.wav", + "text": "而不是主席主觀認為沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1282.wav", + "text": "因為今天是黨團的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1283.wav", + "text": "嘛因為國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1284.wav", + "text": "黨團以及民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1285.wav", + "text": "後面都還沒走你怎麼知道沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1286.wav", + "text": "不是我現在在轉述另外兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1287.wav", + "text": "黨團的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1288.wav", + "text": "不叫做問我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1289.wav", + "text": "莊委員我剛剛在轉述兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1290.wav", + "text": "黨團的說法不是我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1291.wav", + "text": "您再仔細聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1292.wav", + "text": "我跟您報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1293.wav", + "text": "他馬上會說好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1294.wav", + "text": "我跟您報告一下莊委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1295.wav", + "text": "我剛剛說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1296.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團以及民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1297.wav", + "text": "他們表示沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1298.wav", + "text": "希望全案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1299.wav", + "text": "保留送院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1300.wav", + "text": "我現在轉述的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1301.wav", + "text": "他們兩位的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1302.wav", + "text": "你不要又扯到我身上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1303.wav", + "text": "依協商是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1304.wav", + "text": "啦因為您顯然都滿偏聽的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1305.wav", + "text": "有鍾佳濱召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1306.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1307.wav", + "text": "沈發惠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1308.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員我們四位都主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1309.wav", + "text": "因為委員會的逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1310.wav", + "text": "被剝奪了我們在協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1311.wav", + "text": "可以好好來補進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1312.wav", + "text": "趕進度把它補回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1313.wav", + "text": "我們有四位委員是這個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1314.wav", + "text": "但是在場國民黨只有林思銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1315.wav", + "text": "委員一位民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1316.wav", + "text": "只有黃國昌總召一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1317.wav", + "text": "所以我們有四位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1318.wav", + "text": "的聲音要逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1319.wav", + "text": "你為什麼偏聽只要聽兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1320.wav", + "text": "委員的主張呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1321.wav", + "text": "大家不要輕信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1322.wav", + "text": "今天是黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1323.wav", + "text": "不是個別委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1324.wav", + "text": "我是主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1325.wav", + "text": "主席請尊重我的發言時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1326.wav", + "text": "我們今天叫做黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1327.wav", + "text": "協商不是個別委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1328.wav", + "text": "是如果今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1329.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1330.wav", + "text": "今天的進度就是到第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1331.wav", + "text": "今天的逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1332.wav", + "text": "協商到第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1333.wav", + "text": "您要再排下一次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1334.wav", + "text": "再針對十五條之三繼續協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1335.wav", + "text": "這樣我可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1336.wav", + "text": "因為今天你們不想討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1337.wav", + "text": "協商就是這樣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1338.wav", + "text": "協商沒有講到一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1339.wav", + "text": "在場多數的委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1340.wav", + "text": "我們都還要逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1341.wav", + "text": "然後另外的少數委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1342.wav", + "text": "我要打包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1343.wav", + "text": "這樣什麼都被沒收掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1344.wav", + "text": "而且我可以預言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1345.wav", + "text": "在聽線上直播的所有公民朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1346.wav", + "text": "朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1347.wav", + "text": "一樣同樣的理由國民黨跟民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1348.wav", + "text": "又說討論很久了這裡只處理程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1349.wav", + "text": "不用討論了直接院會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1350.wav", + "text": "就是這個結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1351.wav", + "text": "一關一關拖過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1352.wav", + "text": "我們在委員會的時候你們國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1353.wav", + "text": "不就是這個理由嗎說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1354.wav", + "text": "有爭議送協商協商再討論就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1355.wav", + "text": "結果今天在協商了又不給討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1356.wav", + "text": "然後你說黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1357.wav", + "text": "不給討論就推給韓國瑜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1358.wav", + "text": "說韓國瑜的朝野協商再討論就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1359.wav", + "text": "我跟你預判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1360.wav", + "text": "以你們傅崐萁總召的壓霸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1361.wav", + "text": "院長所主持的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1362.wav", + "text": "一樣是不准討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1363.wav", + "text": "直接處理程序不討論實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1364.wav", + "text": "所以我堅持如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1365.wav", + "text": "主席說今天到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1366.wav", + "text": "第十五條之2討論到這裡好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1367.wav", + "text": "只協商了三個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1368.wav", + "text": "後面沒有你要繼續再排協商啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1369.wav", + "text": "我們等你啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1370.wav", + "text": "我們願意啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1371.wav", + "text": "只討論兩條就說整個打包的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1372.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1373.wav", + "text": "不要重蹈覆轍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1374.wav", + "text": "不要繼續壓霸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1375.wav", + "text": "所以如果主席裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1376.wav", + "text": "要打包協商就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1377.wav", + "text": "到剛剛的第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1378.wav", + "text": "第十五條之1跟第十五條之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1379.wav", + "text": "就協商到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1380.wav", + "text": "還要再另排協商的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1381.wav", + "text": "都要再排協商的時間啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1382.wav", + "text": "照起工來就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1383.wav", + "text": "啊領人民的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1384.wav", + "text": "就是要好好開會逐條審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1385.wav", + "text": "委員會已經被沒收了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1386.wav", + "text": "協商不能再被沒收討論啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1387.wav", + "text": "我們現在在趕進度召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1388.wav", + "text": "我建議啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1389.wav", + "text": "就今天處理三條可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1390.wav", + "text": "今天處理三條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1391.wav", + "text": "贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1392.wav", + "text": "再開協商啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1393.wav", + "text": "我們早上你認為沒有共識的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1394.wav", + "text": "要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1395.wav", + "text": "對啊沒有審的要再協商啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1396.wav", + "text": "再開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1397.wav", + "text": "是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1398.wav", + "text": "這才是程序我們在各個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1399.wav", + "text": "都是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1400.wav", + "text": "在各個委員會都是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1401.wav", + "text": "今天就是處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1402.wav", + "text": "討論了三條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1403.wav", + "text": "另外沒有討論的再擇期協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1404.wav", + "text": "但是無法達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1405.wav", + "text": "也只有前面三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1406.wav", + "text": "後面可能有共識啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1407.wav", + "text": "不要放棄自我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1408.wav", + "text": "不要放棄自我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1409.wav", + "text": "不要放棄自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1410.wav", + "text": "不要放棄我們的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1411.wav", + "text": "不要放棄大家的智慧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1412.wav", + "text": "透過討論可以匯聚共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1413.wav", + "text": "不要放棄好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1414.wav", + "text": "不要輕言放棄好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1415.wav", + "text": "這麼沒有擋頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1416.wav", + "text": "不用擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1417.wav", + "text": "對繼續討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1418.wav", + "text": "雖然我也覺得很痛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1419.wav", + "text": "今天提案委員居然都沒有在場說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1420.wav", + "text": "害我們要隔空抓藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1421.wav", + "text": "要試想他提案的緣由是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1422.wav", + "text": "正因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1423.wav", + "text": "今天提案的委員都沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1424.wav", + "text": "所以主席我們應該擇期再協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1425.wav", + "text": "擇期再協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1426.wav", + "text": "朝野協商協商兩個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1427.wav", + "text": "再來不想協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1428.wav", + "text": "那有打包的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1429.wav", + "text": "不能打包啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1430.wav", + "text": "原住民的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1431.wav", + "text": "在協商的時候民進黨不來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1432.wav", + "text": "很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1433.wav", + "text": "但是會讓你討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1434.wav", + "text": "喔人家沈發惠都有到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1435.wav", + "text": "人家有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1436.wav", + "text": "所以要來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1437.wav", + "text": "沒有繼續協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1438.wav", + "text": "但是我們有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1439.wav", + "text": "啊我們有來的人要討論啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1440.wav", + "text": "我們有來的委員要逐條繼續討論啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1441.wav", + "text": "如果主席要停在第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1442.wav", + "text": "那就再擇期協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1443.wav", + "text": "我們接著第十五條之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1444.wav", + "text": "你不要到這邊來亂出草好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1445.wav", + "text": "是你要我發言的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1446.wav", + "text": "話都不會講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1447.wav", + "text": "你這個叫白目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1448.wav", + "text": "你當頭目你當白目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1449.wav", + "text": "我沒有資格當頭目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1450.wav", + "text": "那個有標準的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1451.wav", + "text": "不是隨便可以當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1452.wav", + "text": "我跟各位報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1453.wav", + "text": "我現在報告因為有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1454.wav", + "text": "民眾黨已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1455.wav", + "text": "都不出席了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1456.wav", + "text": "不是所謂的沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1457.wav", + "text": "那就是協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1458.wav", + "text": "所以不叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1459.wav", + "text": "老師不可以這樣沒有蹺課的同學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1460.wav", + "text": "因為蹺課的同學沒有來上課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1461.wav", + "text": "今天這堂課就下課嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1462.wav", + "text": "我們是乖乖在這裡上課的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1463.wav", + "text": "因為民眾黨團沒有出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1464.wav", + "text": "所以本日的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1465.wav", + "text": "因為有黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1466.wav", + "text": "沒有出席討論所以無法達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1467.wav", + "text": "本日五案就是五個主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1468.wav", + "text": "因為仍待繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1469.wav", + "text": "溝通取得共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1470.wav", + "text": "後續會依立法院職權行使法第十二章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1471.wav", + "text": "相關規定辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1472.wav", + "text": "再擇期協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1473.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15893/1474.wav", + "text": "再擇期協商" + } +] \ No newline at end of file