diff --git "a/data/negotiation-10-125-train.json" "b/data/negotiation-10-125-train.json" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/data/negotiation-10-125-train.json" @@ -0,0 +1,301914 @@ +[ + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/0.wav", + "text": "各位黨團領袖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1.wav", + "text": "各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/2.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/3.wav", + "text": "是研商委員曾銘宗等37人所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/4.wav", + "text": "召開第10屆第8會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/5.wav", + "text": "第一次臨時會的相關事宜案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/6.wav", + "text": "先請提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/7.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/8.wav", + "text": "各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/9.wav", + "text": "本席會同37位國民黨團委員提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/10.wav", + "text": "要召開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/11.wav", + "text": "為什麼要召開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/12.wav", + "text": "以下是我們的具體理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/13.wav", + "text": "第一點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/14.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/15.wav", + "text": "在12月30號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/16.wav", + "text": "說有關高端的契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/17.wav", + "text": "要公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/18.wav", + "text": "來釐清外界的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/19.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/20.wav", + "text": "第二點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/21.wav", + "text": "這個契約有沒有圖利特定廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/22.wav", + "text": "第三點是過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/23.wav", + "text": "這疫苗也打了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/24.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/25.wav", + "text": "外國都不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/26.wav", + "text": "當時購買的高端疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/27.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有符合國際的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/28.wav", + "text": "能不能確保國人的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/29.wav", + "text": "這三件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/30.wav", + "text": "國民黨團建議召開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/31.wav", + "text": "邀請陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/32.wav", + "text": "來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/33.wav", + "text": "講清楚說明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/34.wav", + "text": "給國人一個具體的交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/35.wav", + "text": "\n其實我可以講得更細一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/36.wav", + "text": "假設政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/37.wav", + "text": "要培植國內的疫苗產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/38.wav", + "text": "國民黨團強力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/39.wav", + "text": "但是可以比照過去國民黨時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/40.wav", + "text": "培植台積電的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/41.wav", + "text": "你要補助它5億10億20億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/42.wav", + "text": "國民黨團都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/43.wav", + "text": "但是你不能為了要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/44.wav", + "text": "培植高端阻礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/45.wav", + "text": "我們國人要捐贈疫苗也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/46.wav", + "text": "或者購買疫苗也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/47.wav", + "text": "過去你看連工商協進會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/48.wav", + "text": "連慈濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/49.wav", + "text": "連佛光山要捐都擋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/50.wav", + "text": "真的是拿人民的健康開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/51.wav", + "text": "我手上這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/52.wav", + "text": "高端公司的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/53.wav", + "text": "整個交易情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/54.wav", + "text": "從2020年的27塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/55.wav", + "text": "炒到2021年5月31號的417塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/56.wav", + "text": "到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/57.wav", + "text": "只是雙位數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/58.wav", + "text": "在這個過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/59.wav", + "text": "有多少的散戶受傷慘重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/60.wav", + "text": "但是都不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/61.wav", + "text": "啊這個檢調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/62.wav", + "text": "現在檢調在你們手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/63.wav", + "text": "金管會移送了9次資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/64.wav", + "text": "把9次裡面比較嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/65.wav", + "text": "來跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/66.wav", + "text": "第一個是109年12月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/67.wav", + "text": "高端疫苗公告終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/68.wav", + "text": "跟馬來西亞MGB公司備忘錄的協議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/69.wav", + "text": "你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/70.wav", + "text": "當時是12月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/71.wav", + "text": "12月29號交易量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/72.wav", + "text": "就放大到6,690張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/73.wav", + "text": "12月30號放大到8,316張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/74.wav", + "text": "12月31號放大到5,731張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/75.wav", + "text": "28號只有200多張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/76.wav", + "text": "12月25號只有九百零多張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/77.wav", + "text": "\n另外更誇張的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/78.wav", + "text": "110年5月13號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/79.wav", + "text": "6點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/80.wav", + "text": "那一天蔡英文總統宣布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/81.wav", + "text": "預計7月底可以開始供應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/82.wav", + "text": "第一波國產疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/83.wav", + "text": "那一天是6點半才開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/84.wav", + "text": "接著我們來看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/85.wav", + "text": "5月10號交易量是2,118張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/86.wav", + "text": "5月11號交易量跳到7,278張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/87.wav", + "text": "5月12號跳到1萬3,558張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/88.wav", + "text": "5月13號跳到1萬6,108張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/89.wav", + "text": "這個說沒有內線交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/90.wav", + "text": "我真的不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/91.wav", + "text": "本人當過金管會檢查局局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/92.wav", + "text": "金管會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/93.wav", + "text": "這��說沒有內線交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/94.wav", + "text": "我真的不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/95.wav", + "text": "\n另外110年6月10號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/96.wav", + "text": "高端疫苗宣布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/97.wav", + "text": "新冠肺炎疫苗二期臨床" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/98.wav", + "text": "試驗期間分析數據的解盲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/99.wav", + "text": "你看6月7號交易量是2,301張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/100.wav", + "text": "6月8號交易量又跳升到8,740張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/101.wav", + "text": "6月9號跳到7,439張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/102.wav", + "text": "6月11號交易量只有355張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/103.wav", + "text": "你說這個沒有內線交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/104.wav", + "text": "檢調查一查說沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/105.wav", + "text": "檢調在你們手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/106.wav", + "text": "要查就查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/107.wav", + "text": "不查就不查啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/108.wav", + "text": "很多的散戶罵死了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/109.wav", + "text": "罵死了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/110.wav", + "text": "從27塊漲到417塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/111.wav", + "text": "現在又跌下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/112.wav", + "text": "多少散戶損失慘重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/113.wav", + "text": "這哪有公平正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/114.wav", + "text": "這哪有公平正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/115.wav", + "text": "好謝謝來邱總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/116.wav", + "text": "好謝謝院長還有各黨團黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/117.wav", + "text": "我想今天協商的重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/118.wav", + "text": "針對高端採購合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/119.wav", + "text": "還有國人相關的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/120.wav", + "text": "要進行臨時會的召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/121.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/122.wav", + "text": "儘速召開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/123.wav", + "text": "並且邀請行政院陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/124.wav", + "text": "到國會來做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/125.wav", + "text": "高端疫苗採購合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/126.wav", + "text": "相關細節的公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/127.wav", + "text": "過程中EUA的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/128.wav", + "text": "甚至是剛剛提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/129.wav", + "text": "有股價異常的波動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/130.wav", + "text": "是不是有圖利特定的廠商等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/131.wav", + "text": "是針對藥害損害的賠償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/132.wav", + "text": "其實這幾個主張都應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/133.wav", + "text": "在這一次的臨時會專案報告中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/134.wav", + "text": "來向國人說清楚講明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/135.wav", + "text": "我們重申台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/136.wav", + "text": "絕對贊成國家發展戰略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/137.wav", + "text": "物資疫苗國產疫苗的開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/138.wav", + "text": "但是不能接受的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/139.wav", + "text": "在這個過程中不夠公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/140.wav", + "text": "甚至是不是有圖利特定廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/141.wav", + "text": "其實它有對國人說明的義務跟權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/142.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/143.wav", + "text": "它本來就應該要公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/144.wav", + "text": "但是2年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/145.wav", + "text": "高端卻說是衛福部要求不公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/146.wav", + "text": "衛福部到底為什麼這麼害怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/147.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/148.wav", + "text": "在總統辯論會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/149.wav", + "text": "賴清德總統候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/150.wav", + "text": "也公開贊成說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/151.wav", + "text": "鄭文燦副院長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/152.wav", + "text": "衛福部會跟高端協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/153.wav", + "text": "公布時間由兩者決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/154.wav", + "text": "可以說是兩邊互相甩鍋來甩鍋去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/155.wav", + "text": "行政院院長也先放訊息說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/156.wav", + "text": "合約公開必須高端開股東會同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/157.wav", + "text": "衛福部的薛瑞元也打臉說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/158.wav", + "text": "解密需要董事會開會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/159.wav", + "text": "衛福部將持續跟對方聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/160.wav", + "text": "但是時間無法預測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/161.wav", + "text": "那是怎麼樣是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/162.wav", + "text": "你們如果沒有這個協議的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/163.wav", + "text": "你們就不公開了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/164.wav", + "text": "包含之前的衛福部長陳時中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/165.wav", + "text": "也說簽過的合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/166.wav", + "text": "就可以任意公開嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/167.wav", + "text": "而且這個批評是對合約的不尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/168.wav", + "text": "這種人當總統必然是災難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/169.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/170.wav", + "text": "是沒有人可以接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/171.wav", + "text": "\n我們這邊提供一個資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/172.wav", + "text": "這個是高端公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/173.wav", + "text": "對外發布的重訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/174.wav", + "text": "當時的第6點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/175.wav", + "text": "就有明確地提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/176.wav", + "text": "這個相關限制條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/177.wav", + "text": "(解除者不適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/178.wav", + "text": "依採購機關的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/179.wav", + "text": "合約其他細節不予公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/180.wav", + "text": "重點在這一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/181.wav", + "text": "依採購機關的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/182.wav", + "text": "也就是說高端公司在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/183.wav", + "text": "110年5月28號對外的重訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/184.wav", + "text": "就已經明確說出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/185.wav", + "text": "採購合約沒有辦法對外公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/186.wav", + "text": "是因為針對採購機關的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/187.wav", + "text": "那採購機關是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/188.wav", + "text": "就是我們的衛福部嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/189.wav", + "text": "就是我們的行政院嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/190.wav", + "text": "到底是誰在打假球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/191.wav", + "text": "到底是誰在甩鍋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/192.wav", + "text": "\n我們希望這次可以把它釐清清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/193.wav", + "text": "\n另一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/194.wav", + "text": "到底是封存還是保存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/195.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/196.wav", + "text": "這個部分是審計部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/197.wav", + "text": "第4次會議的關係文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/198.wav", + "text": "當時就已經有提出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/199.wav", + "text": "疾管署歷次採購的簽辦文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/200.wav", + "text": "均未見價格分析資料或者依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/201.wav", + "text": "且部分採購的文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/202.wav", + "text": "保密期限長達30年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/203.wav", + "text": "到140年始得解密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/204.wav", + "text": "這個不是封存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/205.wav", + "text": "什麼是封存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/206.wav", + "text": "\n審計部的報告中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/207.wav", + "text": "也明確地指出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/208.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/209.wav", + "text": "上至賴清德副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/210.wav", + "text": "下至疾管署發言人羅一鈞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/211.wav", + "text": "包含前部長陳時中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/212.wav", + "text": "行政院長陳建仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/213.wav", + "text": "還有現在的薛瑞元部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/214.wav", + "text": "大家對於高端解封的表態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/215.wav", + "text": "其實說法上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/216.wav", + "text": "但是高端公司在之前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/217.wav", + "text": "110年5月28號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/218.wav", + "text": "重訊就明確表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/219.wav", + "text": "只要採購方它同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/220.wav", + "text": "基本上是採採購方的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/221.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們呼籲行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/222.wav", + "text": "儘快到國會來說清楚講明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/223.wav", + "text": "第一個針對採購合約的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/224.wav", + "text": "第二個針對股價有沒有異常波動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/225.wav", + "text": "有沒有圖利特定廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/226.wav", + "text": "還有相關EUA的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/227.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到高端的大事紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/228.wav", + "text": "在2020年到2021年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/229.wav", + "text": "從二期臨床的試驗獲准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/230.wav", + "text": "到2021年5月30號簽約採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/231.wav", + "text": "還有到6月10號公布EUA的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/232.wav", + "text": "下午就二期解盲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/233.wav", + "text": "這中間其實有太多國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/234.wav", + "text": "包含我們剛剛講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/235.wav", + "text": "其實我們有到監察院提出檢舉案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/236.wav", + "text": "包含這中間有沒有委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/237.wav", + "text": "疑似中資公司丘以思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/238.wav", + "text": "來進行二期臨床實驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/239.wav", + "text": "在疫情這麼緊急的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/240.wav", + "text": "國人對疫苗需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/241.wav", + "text": "這麼急迫的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/242.wav", + "text": "是不是有一路護航高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/243.wav", + "text": "國際已經認證的疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/244.wav", + "text": "這個其實很多國人都需要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/245.wav", + "text": "所以我們主張臨時會一定要召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/246.wav", + "text": "也不僅止於合約採購的細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/247.wav", + "text": "應該還要把相關的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/248.wav", + "text": "都一次講清楚說明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/249.wav", + "text": "所以這個是民眾黨的基本態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/250.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/251.wav", + "text": "好謝謝邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/252.wav", + "text": "\n接下來陳椒華總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/253.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/254.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/255.wav", + "text": "我想高端這個事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/256.wav", + "text": "從疫情開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/257.wav", + "text": "扶植國產疫苗到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/258.wav", + "text": "燒這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/259.wav", + "text": "到2024大選前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/260.wav", + "text": "還有很多沒有釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/261.wav", + "text": "我在這個過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/262.wav", + "text": "執政黨最多之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/263.wav", + "text": "就是疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/264.wav", + "text": "包括高端這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/265.wav", + "text": "所以我們看到全面執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/266.wav", + "text": "即使有做錯事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/267.wav", + "text": "我覺得這也是國人對於執政黨的不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/268.wav", + "text": "非常不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/269.wav", + "text": "所以現在大家會喊出不要過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/270.wav", + "text": "三黨不過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/271.wav", + "text": "四黨不過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/272.wav", + "text": "當然我們也希望大家支持時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/273.wav", + "text": "當然要過5%我們還在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/274.wav", + "text": "\n今天我要表達的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/275.wav", + "text": "不管幾黨不過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/276.wav", + "text": "不要傲慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/277.wav", + "text": "啦你即使8年執政過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/278.wav", + "text": "像這麼簡單的事情拖這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/279.wav", + "text": "我覺得柯總召真的要負最大的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/280.wav", + "text": "就不公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/281.wav", + "text": "啊2021年衛環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/282.wav", + "text": "成立調閱專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/283.wav", + "text": "很多重要的資訊衛福部都遮蔽全黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/284.wav", + "text": "塗黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/285.wav", + "text": "為什麼衛福部敢把它塗黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/286.wav", + "text": "一定是柯總召同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/287.wav", + "text": "啊縱容這些行政部門這麼地多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/288.wav", + "text": "都是被柯總召你寵壞啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/289.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛我們聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/290.wav", + "text": "邱總召說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/291.wav", + "text": "高端可以公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/292.wav", + "text": "啊就是採購單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/293.wav", + "text": "我們衛福部不敢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/294.wav", + "text": "陳時中在怕什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/295.wav", + "text": "所以今天我們希望儘快公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/296.wav", + "text": "儘快公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/297.wav", + "text": "搞不好可以救我們執政黨的選情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/298.wav", + "text": "不要再隱瞞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/299.wav", + "text": "我覺得高端這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/300.wav", + "text": "讓很多國人都受不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/301.wav", + "text": "講都講不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/302.wav", + "text": "每次都用過半的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/303.wav", + "text": "來否定該公開透明的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/304.wav", + "text": "這也是我們非常不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/305.wav", + "text": "的司法改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/306.wav", + "text": "揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/307.wav", + "text": "到這一屆都不願意送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/308.wav", + "text": "都是柯總召把行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/309.wav", + "text": "把行政院都寵壞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/310.wav", + "text": "甚至監察院也不查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/311.wav", + "text": "司法也不查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/312.wav", + "text": "我們非常不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/313.wav", + "text": "\n身為在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/314.wav", + "text": "我們還是要把這個事情講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/315.wav", + "text": "所以今天我們時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/316.wav", + "text": "支持要召開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/317.wav", + "text": "儘快來公布高端所有的合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/318.wav", + "text": "甚至包括司法改革的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/319.wav", + "text": "還有這一次選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/320.wav", + "text": "所有的查賄反介選的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/321.wav", + "text": "都要一併來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/322.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/323.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/324.wav", + "text": "接下來柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/325.wav", + "text": "柯總召講完了就換賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/326.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/327.wav", + "text": "各位政黨代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/328.wav", + "text": "我剛才仔細聆聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/329.wav", + "text": "當然陳椒華委員對我多所恭維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/330.wav", + "text": "你可能已經都搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/331.wav", + "text": "自己在講什麼話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/332.wav", + "text": "你不要批評人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/333.wav", + "text": "你在講話時我都沒講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/334.wav", + "text": "但是我要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/335.wav", + "text": "你總是給我聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/336.wav", + "text": "但是事實上不是這樣一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/337.wav", + "text": "嘛黨團有黨團立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/338.wav", + "text": "行政院有行政院立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/339.wav", + "text": "各部會有各部會立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/340.wav", + "text": "但是我剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/341.wav", + "text": "第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/342.wav", + "text": "在上禮拜三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/343.wav", + "text": "既然要召開臨時會當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/344.wav", + "text": "我們必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/345.wav", + "text": "回答很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/346.wav", + "text": "就請院長來召集朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/347.wav", + "text": "然後還有談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/348.wav", + "text": "嘛至於本黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/349.wav", + "text": "面對臨時會態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/350.wav", + "text": "等一下我再講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/351.wav", + "text": "有關於高端的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/352.wav", + "text": "包含疫苗的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/353.wav", + "text": "至少我們經過百年大疫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/354.wav", + "text": "大疫國人一起努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/355.wav", + "text": "好不容易走出這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/356.wav", + "text": "但這中間我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/357.wav", + "text": "一直拿國人健康來做消費做為攻擊的武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/358.wav", + "text": "那是非常不道德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/359.wav", + "text": "到今天為止還在這樣搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/360.wav", + "text": "所謂什麼包庇等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/361.wav", + "text": "什麼EUA還要從頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/362.wav", + "text": "到尾再講一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/363.wav", + "text": "這代表什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/364.wav", + "text": "照我個人看法就是國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/365.wav", + "text": "民黨是不是選情告急侯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/366.wav", + "text": "凱旋苑或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/367.wav", + "text": "新莊土地的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/368.wav", + "text": "因為選舉到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/369.wav", + "text": "以為這個是可以翻盤嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/370.wav", + "text": "\n這個題目已經吵兩年多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/371.wav", + "text": "各位在野黨現在還在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/372.wav", + "text": "以至於62個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/373.wav", + "text": "都不起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/374.wav", + "text": "我們從頭到尾大家冷靜來想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/375.wav", + "text": "今天國家面對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/376.wav", + "text": "我們能夠走出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/377.wav", + "text": "我們沒有阻擋購買疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/378.wav", + "text": "當初BNT疫苗是我和郭台銘去處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/379.wav", + "text": "啊大家都努力在採購疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/380.wav", + "text": "當然工商協進會是要買大陸疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/381.wav", + "text": "嘛這些都已經說爛了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/382.wav", + "text": "這題目也不是新的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/383.wav", + "text": "也不是新的戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/384.wav", + "text": "倒是我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/385.wav", + "text": "國民黨心虛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/386.wav", + "text": "啦選情告急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/387.wav", + "text": "啦這是我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/388.wav", + "text": "\n至於王鴻薇在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/389.wav", + "text": "我召集行政部門以及潘孟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/390.wav", + "text": "孟安來開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/391.wav", + "text": "本來就是這麼一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/392.wav", + "text": "情啊這是一體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/393.wav", + "text": "行政立法是一體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/394.wav", + "text": "的我們面對臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/395.wav", + "text": "國民黨要開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/396.wav", + "text": "當然我們必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/397.wav", + "text": "彼此要交換意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/398.wav", + "text": "國民黨這次要召開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/399.wav", + "text": "侯友宜也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/400.wav", + "text": "這選戰攻防本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/401.wav", + "text": "大家各陣營會有所因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/402.wav", + "text": "嘛這沒有什麼不可告人之事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/403.wav", + "text": "搞得好像他們來看我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/404.wav", + "text": "這就是一個弊案的樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/405.wav", + "text": "國民黨已經是方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/406.wav", + "text": "這是我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/407.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/408.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/409.wav", + "text": "有關於高端的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/410.wav", + "text": "疫苗的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/411.wav", + "text": "我在這裡做個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/412.wav", + "text": "簡單的描述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/413.wav", + "text": "過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/414.wav", + "text": "行政院院長來做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/415.wav", + "text": "已經3次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/416.wav", + "text": "剛才談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/417.wav", + "text": "調閱小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/418.wav", + "text": "已經2次調閱小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/419.wav", + "text": "大家都看過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/420.wav", + "text": "一劑多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/421.wav", + "text": "大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/422.wav", + "text": "八百零多塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/423.wav", + "text": "都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/424.wav", + "text": "這沒有什麼弊案不弊案啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/425.wav", + "text": "況且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/426.wav", + "text": "在立法院的專案報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/427.wav", + "text": "總共有16次專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/428.wav", + "text": "專案報告16次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/429.wav", + "text": "調閱小組2次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/430.wav", + "text": "然後院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/431.wav", + "text": "專案報告3次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/432.wav", + "text": "在這兩年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/433.wav", + "text": "全部轉過一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/434.wav", + "text": "天天報紙在寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/435.wav", + "text": "轉來轉去都是到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/436.wav", + "text": "現在投票前再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/437.wav", + "text": "搞一次專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/438.wav", + "text": "來我們當然尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/439.wav", + "text": "審計部的查核報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/440.wav", + "text": "也做出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/441.wav", + "text": "現在所有的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/442.wav", + "text": "合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/443.wav", + "text": "全部在審計部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/444.wav", + "text": "在監察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/445.wav", + "text": "衛福部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/446.wav", + "text": "也把整個合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/447.wav", + "text": "全部送給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/448.wav", + "text": "所以有時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/449.wav", + "text": "弊案你們去檢舉都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/450.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/451.wav", + "text": "就是照這個程序採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/452.wav", + "text": "合約之間的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/453.wav", + "text": "我們也希望能夠公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/454.wav", + "text": "就公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/455.wav", + "text": "但總是要有程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/456.wav", + "text": "接下來我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/457.wav", + "text": "要談的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/458.wav", + "text": "差不多大家講一輪都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/459.wav", + "text": "大家的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/460.wav", + "text": "我們也發甲動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/461.wav", + "text": "當然等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/462.wav", + "text": "我們會去開個黨團會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/463.wav", + "text": "馬上會有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/464.wav", + "text": "有結論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/465.wav", + "text": "我們就來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/466.wav", + "text": "不管開不開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/467.wav", + "text": "都要舉辦談話會要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/468.wav", + "text": "要開就開不開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/469.wav", + "text": "就是大家表決負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/470.wav", + "text": "嘛但是我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/471.wav", + "text": "馬上有很清楚的答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/472.wav", + "text": "因為這個不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/473.wav", + "text": "不面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/474.wav", + "text": "我的看法就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/475.wav", + "text": "差不多這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/476.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡互" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/477.wav", + "text": "沒什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/478.wav", + "text": "我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/479.wav", + "text": "待會我們開完黨團會議以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/480.wav", + "text": "我們就可以延續了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/481.wav", + "text": "要做補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/482.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/483.wav", + "text": "接下來賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/484.wav", + "text": "謝謝幾位總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/485.wav", + "text": "在第8會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/486.wav", + "text": "最後又有臨時會召開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/487.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是要珍惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/488.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/489.wav", + "text": "國會還是國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/490.wav", + "text": "知的權利裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/491.wav", + "text": "最直接的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/492.wav", + "text": "剛剛我聽柯總召的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/493.wav", + "text": "應該是不排斥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/494.wav", + "text": "這是一個正向的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/495.wav", + "text": "不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/496.wav", + "text": "等一下你們黨團會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/497.wav", + "text": "如果等一下你們黨團會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/498.wav", + "text": "能夠從善如流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/499.wav", + "text": "我覺得也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/500.wav", + "text": "還大家一個所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/501.wav", + "text": "在知的權利上的公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/502.wav", + "text": "因為我看到我們前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/503.wav", + "text": "衛福部長陳時中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/504.wav", + "text": "之前在1月3號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/505.wav", + "text": "他也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/506.wav", + "text": "趕快公布合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/507.wav", + "text": "畢竟這是在他任內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/508.wav", + "text": "大家對他質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/509.wav", + "text": "最多的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/510.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/511.wav", + "text": "柯總召太寵行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/512.wav", + "text": "那我希望我們真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/513.wav", + "text": "不要寵高端公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/514.wav", + "text": "畢竟這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/515.wav", + "text": "民間的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/516.wav", + "text": "但是它拿了國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/517.wav", + "text": "研究經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/518.wav", + "text": "跟採購的疫苗費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/519.wav", + "text": "這個公司必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/520.wav", + "text": "公開透明讓國人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/521.wav", + "text": "到底它的合約裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/522.wav", + "text": "在行政部門也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/523.wav", + "text": "在它自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/524.wav", + "text": "涉及內線的疑雲也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/525.wav", + "text": "它也必須要對國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/526.wav", + "text": "公布畢竟它是一個上市公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/527.wav", + "text": "\n第二個我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/528.wav", + "text": "我們還是記憶猶新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/529.wav", + "text": "剛剛雖然柯總召講了幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/530.wav", + "text": "可是我還是要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/531.wav", + "text": "第一次在衛環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/532.wav", + "text": "110年5月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/533.wav", + "text": "COVID-19的防治及紓困" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/534.wav", + "text": "特別條例的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/535.wav", + "text": "我們黨團就已經主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/536.wav", + "text": "能夠透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/537.wav", + "text": "以前像疫苗採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/538.wav", + "text": "調閱委員會的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/539.wav", + "text": "來實踐我們的監督權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/540.wav", + "text": "當時也是被柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/541.wav", + "text": "最後變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/542.wav", + "text": "疫苗採購的調閱小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/543.wav", + "text": "本人是小組成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/544.wav", + "text": "我是關鍵一票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/545.wav", + "text": "所以我們在衛環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/546.wav", + "text": "有調閱小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/547.wav", + "text": "但很可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/548.wav", + "text": "我去看了幾次的合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/549.wav", + "text": "都是塗黑比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/550.wav", + "text": "三分之二左右是塗黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/551.wav", + "text": "我當時就跟國人說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/552.wav", + "text": "我想去看的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/553.wav", + "text": "如果它的採購數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/554.wav", + "text": "沒有如期交貨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/555.wav", + "text": "到底違約部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/556.wav", + "text": "怎麼履約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/557.wav", + "text": "第二個我想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/558.wav", + "text": "每一劑多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/559.wav", + "text": "是用什麼資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/560.wav", + "text": "通通都看不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/561.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/562.wav", + "text": "如果在臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/563.wav", + "text": "也能夠通過整個合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/564.wav", + "text": "公布出土" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/565.wav", + "text": "就不用塗黑讓大家用猜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/566.wav", + "text": "這是一個對的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/567.wav", + "text": "也希望等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/568.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/569.wav", + "text": "以不塗黑的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/570.wav", + "text": "讓高端公司對社會各界公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/571.wav", + "text": "以及陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/572.wav", + "text": "到立院來接受質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/573.wav", + "text": "我相信這才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/574.wav", + "text": "反黑箱要公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/575.wav", + "text": "反黑箱有真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/576.wav", + "text": "的一個最好的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/577.wav", + "text": "\n其次我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/578.wav", + "text": "縱使我們用了這麼多的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/579.wav", + "text": "去把國產疫苗催生出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/580.wav", + "text": "可是這個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/581.wav", + "text": "有沒有像解盲未成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/582.wav", + "text": "就公布可以簽約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/583.wav", + "text": "解盲後的當天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/584.wav", + "text": "才出現EUA審查的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/585.wav", + "text": "有沒有量身訂做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/586.wav", + "text": "有沒有先射箭再畫靶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/587.wav", + "text": "這個也要還疾管署一個公道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/588.wav", + "text": "不然剛剛大家都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/589.wav", + "text": "走出了百年大疫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/590.wav", + "text": "可是疑雲重重之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/591.wav", + "text": "不是也讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/592.wav", + "text": "有了污名化的一個印記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/593.wav", + "text": "這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/594.wav", + "text": "臨時會的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/595.wav", + "text": "可以讓大家更來面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/596.wav", + "text": "如果一個上市公司的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/597.wav", + "text": "重訊已經讓國人產生疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/598.wav", + "text": "那在總統大選的辯論裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/599.wav", + "text": "總統候選人等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/600.wav", + "text": "都認為可以公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/601.wav", + "text": "特別是賴副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/602.wav", + "text": "也覺得要趕快公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/603.wav", + "text": "能夠在1月12日以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/604.wav", + "text": "在國會大家可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/605.wav", + "text": "也能夠讓合約部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/606.wav", + "text": "所有的合約都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/607.wav", + "text": "有一個公正性來對外透露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/608.wav", + "text": "合約保密的方式來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/609.wav", + "text": "但是所謂的公文封存30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/610.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/611.wav", + "text": "是到140年2月25日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/612.wav", + "text": "我想國人不會接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/613.wav", + "text": "所以希望今天主席能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/614.wav", + "text": "裁示我們儘速完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/615.wav", + "text": "臨時會的召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/616.wav", + "text": "接下來請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/617.wav", + "text": "國民黨提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/618.wav", + "text": "因為外界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/619.wav", + "text": "黑幕重重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/620.wav", + "text": "尤其是最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/621.wav", + "text": "高端內部的錄音檔出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/622.wav", + "text": "做為最大在野黨有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/623.wav", + "text": "邀請行政院或相關部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/624.wav", + "text": "來講清楚說明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/625.wav", + "text": "不是基於國民黨的選情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/626.wav", + "text": "國民黨的選情非常樂觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/627.wav", + "text": "我們會繼續執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/628.wav", + "text": "超過六成五的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/629.wav", + "text": "希望下架民進黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/630.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/631.wav", + "text": "既然這個資料已經送地檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/632.wav", + "text": "送監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/633.wav", + "text": "那為什麼不送給立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/634.wav", + "text": "這奇怪囉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/635.wav", + "text": "所以是藐視立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/636.wav", + "text": "你送給地檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/637.wav", + "text": "也送給監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/638.wav", + "text": "當時該公開的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/639.wav", + "text": "卻遮遮掩掩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/640.wav", + "text": "那就直接公布吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/641.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/642.wav", + "text": "謝謝接下來請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/643.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/644.wav", + "text": "剛剛三位在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/645.wav", + "text": "黨團在報告時說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/646.wav", + "text": "希望能夠召開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/647.wav", + "text": "其實從頭到尾都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/648.wav", + "text": "我們要正面接受這個挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/649.wav", + "text": "但是我們黨團內部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/650.wav", + "text": "也有民主程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/651.wav", + "text": "所以我們召開黨團會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/652.wav", + "text": "然後馬上會有結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/653.wav", + "text": "但是有關於這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/654.wav", + "text": "特別把高端拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/655.wav", + "text": "在選前三四天的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/656.wav", + "text": "臨時會裡面的攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/657.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們都會強烈懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/658.wav", + "text": "其實就是跟總統大選有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/659.wav", + "text": "是不是在野黨告急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/660.wav", + "text": "很多在野黨委員自己心知肚明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/661.wav", + "text": "我們就不在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/662.wav", + "text": "多做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/663.wav", + "text": "可是我們會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/664.wav", + "text": "那是不是我們也在變相炒作高端呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/665.wav", + "text": "\n曾總召特別提到股價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/666.wav", + "text": "政黨全面執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/667.wav", + "text": "然後也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/668.wav", + "text": "高端疫苗在技術性上面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/669.wav", + "text": "有沒有什麼議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/670.wav", + "text": "我跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/671.wav", + "text": "大家都心知肚明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/672.wav", + "text": "這一次兩三年以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/673.wav", + "text": "有關高端的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/674.wav", + "text": "已經舉行過24次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/675.wav", + "text": "會議包括行政院長的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/676.wav", + "text": "疫苗調閱小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/677.wav", + "text": "專報及公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/678.wav", + "text": "裡面有19次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/679.wav", + "text": "都是國民黨的人當召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/680.wav", + "text": "或是當主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/681.wav", + "text": "包括蔣萬安陳玉珍張育美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/682.wav", + "text": "不管是在財政方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/683.wav", + "text": "或是在衛環方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/684.wav", + "text": "都是報告得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/685.wav", + "text": "而且還有開秘密會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/686.wav", + "text": "當然秘密會議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/687.wav", + "text": "是限定衛環委員會的委員去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/688.wav", + "text": "這個我們都是按照立法院的標準操作程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/689.wav", + "text": "否則如果大家都公開的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/690.wav", + "text": "會不會就像我們在外交及國防委員會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/691.wav", + "text": "說要保密結果卻洩密到韓國去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/692.wav", + "text": "這樣的在野黨立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/693.wav", + "text": "讓大家非常不齒\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/694.wav", + "text": "所���我們會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/695.wav", + "text": "民進黨的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/696.wav", + "text": "就是有關任何爭議或弊案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/697.wav", + "text": "當然要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/698.wav", + "text": "我們站在立法院監督行政院的立場上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/699.wav", + "text": "不管是在財政方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/700.wav", + "text": "或者是在整個處理程序方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/701.wav", + "text": "請提出來新的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/702.wav", + "text": "在總統大選辯論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/703.wav", + "text": "賴清德說要公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/704.wav", + "text": "但是公開也不是倉促地公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/705.wav", + "text": "公開的時候在程序要解開之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/706.wav", + "text": "也要有一定的SOP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/707.wav", + "text": "否則我們就變成獨裁國家了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/708.wav", + "text": "皇帝詔曰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/709.wav", + "text": "然後下令馬上封存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/710.wav", + "text": "其實不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/711.wav", + "text": "這就是我們在民主社會裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/712.wav", + "text": "國會運作上應該有的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/713.wav", + "text": "\n另外剛剛也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/714.wav", + "text": "檢調是否就是聽民進黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/715.wav", + "text": "完全相反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/716.wav", + "text": "從這次中國介選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/717.wav", + "text": "或社區委員會等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/718.wav", + "text": "每一黨都有對於很多人質疑檢調的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/719.wav", + "text": "三權分立的權力分立原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/720.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛還有人提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/721.wav", + "text": "高端內部有錄音檔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/722.wav", + "text": "是否涉及弊案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/723.wav", + "text": "我覺得這種影射的殺傷力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/724.wav", + "text": "有民進黨的官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/725.wav", + "text": "或民進黨的若干人涉及弊案的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/726.wav", + "text": "請直接移送檢調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/727.wav", + "text": "你可以說這企圖影響總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/728.wav", + "text": "可以用選罷法來偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/729.wav", + "text": "不必要遮遮掩掩用影射的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/730.wav", + "text": "用這種片段的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/731.wav", + "text": "來影射民進黨在執政當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/732.wav", + "text": "所產生的這些議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/733.wav", + "text": "我們並不會迴避這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/734.wav", + "text": "但如果你們一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/735.wav", + "text": "高端公司高端公司高端公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/736.wav", + "text": "我認為有點變相炒作高端公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/737.wav", + "text": "好與壞大家心知肚明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/738.wav", + "text": "\n再來就是回應剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/739.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/740.wav", + "text": "其實現在民進黨並沒有全面執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/741.wav", + "text": "在地方政府上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/742.wav", + "text": "全面執政的叫國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/743.wav", + "text": "有十七八個是國民黨執政的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/744.wav", + "text": "你看了很多環保廢棄物的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/745.wav", + "text": "難道不就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/746.wav", + "text": "國民黨執政的地方首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/747.wav", + "text": "等等這些議題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/748.wav", + "text": "其實你也心知肚明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/749.wav", + "text": "所以不要把所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/750.wav", + "text": "全部一股腦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/751.wav", + "text": "我們覺得不可取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/752.wav", + "text": "謝謝劉委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/753.wav", + "text": "接下來請邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/754.wav", + "text": "邱總召之後是張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/755.wav", + "text": "你要讓他先說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/756.wav", + "text": "講完以後我們馬上協商一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/757.wav", + "text": "這樣比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/758.wav", + "text": "院長各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/759.wav", + "text": "今天我們還是回到正題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/760.wav", + "text": "在2022年11月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/761.wav", + "text": "就已經去監察院檢舉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/762.wav", + "text": "也就是今天談的所有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/763.wav", + "text": "我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/764.wav", + "text": "檢調已經送了六十幾案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/765.wav", + "text": "我們要直說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/766.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/767.wav", + "text": "監察院也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/768.wav", + "text": "就是部份合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/769.wav", + "text": "嘛就是因為沒有資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/770.wav", + "text": "所以不管誰來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/771.wav", + "text": "當然都沒有結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/772.wav", + "text": "我們要奉勸執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/773.wav", + "text": "如果覺得問心無愧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/774.wav", + "text": "都沒有任何問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/775.wav", + "text": "讓大家來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/776.wav", + "text": "我覺得這就是關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/777.wav", + "text": "資訊到底能不能是透明的公開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/778.wav", + "text": "大家能夠來審閱的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/779.wav", + "text": "的調閱小組有看了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/780.wav", + "text": "三分之二塗黑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/781.wav", + "text": "三分之二塗黑的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/782.wav", + "text": "誰能查得出什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/783.wav", + "text": "我們給監察院的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/784.wav", + "text": "也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/785.wav", + "text": "變成一千三百四百零億的市值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/786.wav", + "text": "中間又來來回回這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/787.wav", + "text": "但這就是一個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/788.wav", + "text": "所以到底能不能解除國人的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/789.wav", + "text": "\n坦白說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/790.wav", + "text": "剛才各位黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/791.wav", + "text": "也講了一些政治性的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/792.wav", + "text": "我只補充一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/793.wav", + "text": "政治當然有攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/794.wav", + "text": "如果大家都覺得沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/795.wav", + "text": "問心無愧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/796.wav", + "text": "那就把它公開起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/797.wav", + "text": "公開起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/798.wav", + "text": "其實身為在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/799.wav", + "text": "還蠻高興的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/800.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/801.wav", + "text": "就繼續這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/802.wav", + "text": "啊因為繼續這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/803.wav", + "text": "倒楣的可能會是執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/804.wav", + "text": "讓大家能夠看清楚資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/805.wav", + "text": "看看是怎麼回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/806.wav", + "text": "大家再來公斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/807.wav", + "text": "就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/808.wav", + "text": "做個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/809.wav", + "text": "剛剛聽過一輪之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/810.wav", + "text": "這次我們臨時會的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/811.wav", + "text": "我們還是呼籲執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/812.wav", + "text": "可以直球對決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/813.wav", + "text": "我們同意召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/814.wav", + "text": "我們當然尊重你們黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/815.wav", + "text": "我想今天談了那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/816.wav", + "text": "大家政治互有攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/817.wav", + "text": "但是我們必須強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/818.wav", + "text": "這次連賴清德副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/819.wav", + "text": "也就是民進黨的總統候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/820.wav", + "text": "他都已經公開表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/821.wav", + "text": "要公開相關高端的這些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/822.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/823.wav", + "text": "應該要讓國人有知的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/824.wav", + "text": "因為這不只涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/825.wav", + "text": "股價問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/826.wav", + "text": "後續藥害賠償的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/827.wav", + "text": "其實很多國人對這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/828.wav", + "text": "是非常關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/829.wav", + "text": "我們今天的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/830.wav", + "text": "應該回歸到主題的主軸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/831.wav", + "text": "希望民進黨可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/832.wav", + "text": "來召開這個臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/833.wav", + "text": "好不好同樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/834.wav", + "text": "商要有結論了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/835.wav", + "text": "不知道在演什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/836.wav", + "text": "我搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/837.wav", + "text": "接下來請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/838.wav", + "text": "好時力第二輪發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/839.wav", + "text": "我來回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/840.wav", + "text": "我想民進黨執政8年以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/841.wav", + "text": "對於揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/842.wav", + "text": "不法饋贈不法關說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/843.wav", + "text": "等一直不願意立法或修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/844.wav", + "text": "這個部分我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/845.wav", + "text": "國人對於司法改革非常失望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/846.wav", + "text": "揭弊的鏡電視案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/847.wav", + "text": "包括國民黨也一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/848.wav", + "text": "要求鏡電視案的這個弊端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/849.wav", + "text": "在司法或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/850.wav", + "text": "非常多的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/851.wav", + "text": "都被否決封殺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/852.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/853.wav", + "text": "包括在野黨的失望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/854.wav", + "text": "包括國人的失望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/855.wav", + "text": "我在這裡還是要請執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/856.wav", + "text": "能夠聽進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/857.wav", + "text": "你們的傲慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/858.wav", + "text": "或者你們用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/859.wav", + "text": "這種霸凌式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/860.wav", + "text": "過半的否決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/861.wav", + "text": "真的是讓非常多人不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/862.wav", + "text": "包括國人非常不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/863.wav", + "text": "\n今天提到廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/864.wav", + "text": "提到很多中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/865.wav", + "text": "可以處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/866.wav", + "text": "包括廢清法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/867.wav", + "text": "我進第10屆立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/868.wav", + "text": "後講了非常非常多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/869.wav", + "text": "廢清法要修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/870.wav", + "text": "才能夠解決現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/871.wav", + "text": "非常嚴重的廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/872.wav", + "text": "不法傾倒掩埋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/873.wav", + "text": "但是都被否決掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/874.wav", + "text": "都被我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/875.wav", + "text": "包括柯總召等寵壞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/876.wav", + "text": "都不願意送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/877.wav", + "text": "所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/878.wav", + "text": "今天���最後要表達的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/879.wav", + "text": "就是我要拜託民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/880.wav", + "text": "不要再這麼傲慢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/881.wav", + "text": "該公開還是要公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/882.wav", + "text": "這才是國人之福" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/883.wav", + "text": "謝謝椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/884.wav", + "text": "\n現在發言告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/885.wav", + "text": "剛才柯總召有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/886.wav", + "text": "要再表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/887.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/888.wav", + "text": "發言告一段落了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/889.wav", + "text": "大家心證也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/890.wav", + "text": "既然要開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/891.wav", + "text": "那我們就來面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/892.wav", + "text": "至於接下來的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/893.wav", + "text": "因為現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/894.wav", + "text": "談話會還沒開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/895.wav", + "text": "連議場的大門都沒有開門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/896.wav", + "text": "這很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/897.wav", + "text": "怎麼會議場大門不開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/898.wav", + "text": "所有委員都在辦公室裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/899.wav", + "text": "本來就要開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/900.wav", + "text": "的不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/901.wav", + "text": "談話會一定會開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/902.wav", + "text": "老是在搞這套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/903.wav", + "text": "沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/904.wav", + "text": "嘛議事人員怎麼在控制這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/905.wav", + "text": "好那我來宣告一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/906.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/907.wav", + "text": "要打開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/908.wav", + "text": "我們現在就可以來處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/909.wav", + "text": "如果各黨沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/910.wav", + "text": "那就以國民黨的這個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/911.wav", + "text": "至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/912.wav", + "text": "時間當然最快就是明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/913.wav", + "text": "嘛明天幾點到幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/914.wav", + "text": "政黨比例排一排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/915.wav", + "text": "一般是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/916.wav", + "text": "專案報告的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/917.wav", + "text": "9點到幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/918.wav", + "text": "一般來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/919.wav", + "text": "行政院長要報告差不多30分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/920.wav", + "text": "如果是1天的會議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/921.wav", + "text": "我們整天會議就是6個半小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/922.wav", + "text": "所以會有6個小時的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/923.wav", + "text": "一個人是15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/924.wav", + "text": "點到幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/925.wav", + "text": "如果你們是要開1天的專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/926.wav", + "text": "早上就是30分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/927.wav", + "text": "到下午6點的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/928.wav", + "text": "是有6個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/929.wav", + "text": "6個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/930.wav", + "text": "1個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/931.wav", + "text": "4個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/932.wav", + "text": "那就是24個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/933.wav", + "text": "按照政黨比例來區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/934.wav", + "text": "中午時間有休息就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/935.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/936.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/937.wav", + "text": "大家比較不會亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/938.wav", + "text": "就9點開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/939.wav", + "text": "中間有休息嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/940.wav", + "text": "政黨比例也要排一排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/941.wav", + "text": "這個是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/942.wav", + "text": "談話會大家決定要開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/943.wav", + "text": "等一下我們就照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/944.wav", + "text": "在談話會通過就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/945.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/946.wav", + "text": "院長這樣子可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/947.wav", + "text": "就照這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/948.wav", + "text": "如果通過要開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/949.wav", + "text": "如果大家協商有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/950.wav", + "text": "開這個院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/951.wav", + "text": "我們現在可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/952.wav", + "text": "打個草稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/953.wav", + "text": "然後我們在談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/954.wav", + "text": "宣讀這個協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/955.wav", + "text": "這樣就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/956.wav", + "text": "然後就訂一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/957.wav", + "text": "邀請行政院長來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/958.wav", + "text": "就是明天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/959.wav", + "text": "看是明天或什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/960.wav", + "text": "一定是明天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/961.wav", + "text": "難道是選後再來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/962.wav", + "text": "那就明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/963.wav", + "text": "就是星期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/964.wav", + "text": "星期二嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/965.wav", + "text": "好那我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/966.wav", + "text": "現在來寫一下協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/967.wav", + "text": "談話會就宣讀就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/968.wav", + "text": "院長先跟大家談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/969.wav", + "text": "談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/970.wav", + "text": "談話會還是要召開喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/971.wav", + "text": "因為在談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/972.wav", + "text": "大家要同意嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/973.wav", + "text": "但是��話會沒有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/974.wav", + "text": "沒有嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/975.wav", + "text": "但是還是要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/976.wav", + "text": "幾個人進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/977.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/978.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/979.wav", + "text": "談話會的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/980.wav", + "text": "時間如果這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/981.wav", + "text": "可能要10點半喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/982.wav", + "text": "不用啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/983.wav", + "text": "論的文字如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/984.wav", + "text": "等一下就馬上進去喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/985.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/986.wav", + "text": "你們要把門打開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/987.wav", + "text": "讓人進去嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/988.wav", + "text": "站著不好意思吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/989.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/990.wav", + "text": "以後這個要改進嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/991.wav", + "text": "定是要開談話會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/992.wav", + "text": "怎麼門不開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/993.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/994.wav", + "text": "那就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/995.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/996.wav", + "text": "題目就是原來曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/997.wav", + "text": "你們黨團提的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/998.wav", + "text": "我們尊重啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/999.wav", + "text": "我們就尊重就開嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1000.wav", + "text": "好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1001.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1002.wav", + "text": "我們知道這是國民黨選情告急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1003.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1004.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1005.wav", + "text": "如果明天開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1006.wav", + "text": "那個合約資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1007.wav", + "text": "何時可以讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1008.wav", + "text": "你明天去問他嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1009.wav", + "text": "啊他怎麼公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1010.wav", + "text": "你看他題目嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1011.wav", + "text": "他明天會回答你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1012.wav", + "text": "他的內容會怎麼樣對外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1013.wav", + "text": "這是關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1014.wav", + "text": "啊不然我們質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1015.wav", + "text": "他一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1016.wav", + "text": "就先告訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1017.wav", + "text": "你這個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1018.wav", + "text": "這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1019.wav", + "text": "是用什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1020.wav", + "text": "他會去面對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1021.wav", + "text": "他怎麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1022.wav", + "text": "你再聽他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1023.wav", + "text": "他怎麼回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1024.wav", + "text": "所以他已經看到內容了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1025.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1026.wav", + "text": "他可以對外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1027.wav", + "text": "給我們公談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1028.wav", + "text": "話會的題目就在這裡嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1029.wav", + "text": "報告的題目在這裡嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1030.wav", + "text": "是否公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1031.wav", + "text": "是否圖利廠商及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1032.wav", + "text": "全民健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1033.wav", + "text": "他一定會回答的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1034.wav", + "text": "公開形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1035.wav", + "text": "還是要明確啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1036.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1037.wav", + "text": "我們明天會處理這個事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1038.wav", + "text": "合約資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1039.wav", + "text": "可不可以今天5點前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1040.wav", + "text": "各個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1041.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1042.wav", + "text": "你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1043.wav", + "text": "不然明天我們質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1044.wav", + "text": "就跟之前的訊息一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1045.wav", + "text": "怎麼對呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1046.wav", + "text": "我們現在是要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1047.wav", + "text": "他來專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1048.wav", + "text": "因為就是很多資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1049.wav", + "text": "我們還不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1050.wav", + "text": "才要專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1051.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1052.wav", + "text": "一下子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1053.wav", + "text": "當然黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1054.wav", + "text": "是沒有辦法提供出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1055.wav", + "text": "所以他報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1056.wav", + "text": "可能順便同時可以對外公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1057.wav", + "text": "我們具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1058.wav", + "text": "是不是在協商結論裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1059.wav", + "text": "要求行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1060.wav", + "text": "3點以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1061.wav", + "text": "或5點以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1062.wav", + "text": "提供給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1063.wav", + "text": "不然我們質詢內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1064.wav", + "text": "跟院長是不對等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1065.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1066.wav", + "text": "我們具體建議啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1067.wav", + "text": "請行政院下午5點以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1068.wav", + "text": "先提供書面資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1069.wav", + "text": "他明天要來做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1070.wav", + "text": "以前他一定要把書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1071.wav", + "text": "送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1072.wav", + "text": "你不能明天早上才送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1073.wav", + "text": "今天要先給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1074.wav", + "text": "傍晚以前啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1075.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1076.wav", + "text": "要有資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1077.wav", + "text": "不能不對等協商不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1078.wav", + "text": "這個本來就是這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1079.wav", + "text": "行政院長做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1080.wav", + "text": "一定要書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1081.wav", + "text": "你們講好就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1082.wav", + "text": "我們只有8頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1083.wav", + "text": "都比我們多5倍以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1084.wav", + "text": "而且你還先去跟他們開會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1085.wav", + "text": "他已經把所有的內容告知你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1086.wav", + "text": "們我們的內容都是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1087.wav", + "text": "我和行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1088.wav", + "text": "行政立法是一體的有開會那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1089.wav", + "text": "很正常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1090.wav", + "text": "資訊不對等是不行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1091.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼資訊不對等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1092.wav", + "text": "我們也沒有什麼資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1093.wav", + "text": "我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1094.wav", + "text": "大家不要再吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1095.wav", + "text": "這個都是平行處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1096.wav", + "text": "可能更能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1097.wav", + "text": "謝謝你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1098.wav", + "text": "我跟柯總召感情很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1099.wav", + "text": "這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1100.wav", + "text": "我們我們儘量請行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1101.wav", + "text": "儘早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1102.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1103.wav", + "text": "最好能夠在今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1104.wav", + "text": "因為我們今天才決定要不要開嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1105.wav", + "text": "所以他們一定要寫啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1106.wav", + "text": "一定要開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1107.wav", + "text": "因為副總統已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1108.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1109.wav", + "text": "所有的程序就要照程序來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1110.wav", + "text": "好現在在影印" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1111.wav", + "text": "等一下印" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1112.wav", + "text": "就會發給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1113.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1114.wav", + "text": "決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1115.wav", + "text": "1月9日(星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1116.wav", + "text": ")邀請行政院院長率同相關部會首長列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1117.wav", + "text": "提出就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1118.wav", + "text": "是否公布高端合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1119.wav", + "text": "是否圖利廠商及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1120.wav", + "text": "危害全民健康權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1121.wav", + "text": "等相關事宜進行專案報告並備質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1122.wav", + "text": "由民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1123.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1124.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團及時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1125.wav", + "text": "各推派1人進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1126.wav", + "text": "未參加黨團委員得優先發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1127.wav", + "text": "質詢順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1128.wav", + "text": "依例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1129.wav", + "text": "授權議事處辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1130.wav", + "text": "上述名單請於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1131.wav", + "text": "1月8日(星期一)下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1132.wav", + "text": "4時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1133.wav", + "text": "送交議事處彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1134.wav", + "text": "逾時視同放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1135.wav", + "text": "有沒有要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1136.wav", + "text": "時力可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1137.wav", + "text": "可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1138.wav", + "text": "簽好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1139.wav", + "text": "國民黨這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1140.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1141.wav", + "text": "這個大家簽一簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1142.wav", + "text": "談話會直接宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1143.wav", + "text": "就不再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1144.wav", + "text": "宣讀就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1145.wav", + "text": "宣讀完大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1146.wav", + "text": "趕快回去選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1147.wav", + "text": "準備資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1148.wav", + "text": "談話會可以提早一點嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1149.wav", + "text": "在這裡已經提案說明很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1150.wav", + "text": "談話會可以提早10分鐘嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1151.wav", + "text": "在這裡說明得這麼清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1152.wav", + "text": "邱總召明天是9點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1153.wav", + "text": "喔9點開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1154.wav", + "text": "好大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1155.wav", + "text": "6點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1156.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1157.wav", + "text": "椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1158.wav", + "text": "你說要提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1159.wav", + "text": "我們現在馬上過去就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1160.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1161.wav", + "text": "等一下馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1162.wav", + "text": "馬上過去馬上開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1163.wav", + "text": "只有宣讀而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1164.wav", + "text": "這個可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1165.wav", + "text": "我們就簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1166.wav", + "text": "簽好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1167.wav", + "text": "現在已經快10點了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1168.wav", + "text": "10點20" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1169.wav", + "text": "10點20" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1170.wav", + "text": "還是要15" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1171.wav", + "text": "10點15分啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1172.wav", + "text": "為了配合大家的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1173.wav", + "text": "大家都很忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1174.wav", + "text": "10點15分開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1175.wav", + "text": "談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1176.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1177.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1178.wav", + "text": "10點15分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1179.wav", + "text": "談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1180.wav", + "text": "大家朝野協商的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1181.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1182.wav", + "text": "協商結論已經簽好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1183.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1184.wav", + "text": "我們10點15分召開談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1185.wav", + "text": "\n現在散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15361/1186.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/0.wav", + "text": "房屋稅條例部分條文修正草案等案(如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1.wav", + "text": ")這是民進黨黨團提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2.wav", + "text": "我就宣布到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/3.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請林為洲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/4.wav", + "text": "因為上禮拜衛環委員會在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/5.wav", + "text": "社家署113年的托育工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/6.wav", + "text": "其中編列2億6,000萬的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/7.wav", + "text": "以備萬一如果有一些虐兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/8.wav", + "text": "又增加了2億6,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/9.wav", + "text": "要做什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/10.wav", + "text": "都要上傳到全國的監管雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/11.wav", + "text": "要弄一個雲端的儲存空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/12.wav", + "text": "然後全國集中管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/13.wav", + "text": "這不管是家長或是托育中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/14.wav", + "text": "或是各托育中心的硬碟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/15.wav", + "text": "上傳到雲端全國集合起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/16.wav", + "text": "這樣有比較安全嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/17.wav", + "text": "造成全國性的洩漏個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/18.wav", + "text": "洩漏可能還只是局部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/19.wav", + "text": "把它全部集中在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/20.wav", + "text": "又要花那麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/21.wav", + "text": "這樣大家會有一點疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/22.wav", + "text": "\n那時候院長你記得嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/23.wav", + "text": "你說在表決之前我們要再協商一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/24.wav", + "text": "50%凍結等到社會各界溝通完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/25.wav", + "text": "那時候我有提出有有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/26.wav", + "text": "甚至有人提議4個黨團共同提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/27.wav", + "text": "整合成1個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/28.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/29.wav", + "text": "因為明天院長有講啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/30.wav", + "text": "柯總召我有聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/31.wav", + "text": "不好因為明天就是最後1天了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/32.wav", + "text": "原來我是提案凍結80%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/33.wav", + "text": "我是覺得這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/34.wav", + "text": "讓它經過社會溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/35.wav", + "text": "公聽會各界發表意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/36.wav", + "text": "但是也不要讓他們沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/37.wav", + "text": "啟動這個計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/38.wav", + "text": "所以凍結一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/39.wav", + "text": "然後到委員會報告後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/40.wav", + "text": "我的建議是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/41.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/42.wav", + "text": "我們講程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/43.wav", + "text": "啦今天朝野協商發通知是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/44.wav", + "text": "這個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/45.wav", + "text": "明天一定要通過大家要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/46.wav", + "text": "有關朝野協商留下的這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/47.wav", + "text": "衛福部也在這邊說明得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/48.wav", + "text": "\n我知道有些在陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/49.wav", + "text": "啦那些我認識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/50.wav", + "text": "啊你現在講他們都在看直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/51.wav", + "text": "108年通過兒少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/52.wav", + "text": "兒少權益保障法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/53.wav", + "text": "以後也就是說那時候立法院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/54.wav", + "text": "那時時常發生虐兒事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/55.wav", + "text": "學校必須錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/56.wav", + "text": "沒有錄影還要罰錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/57.wav", + "text": "通過以後辦法都訂定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/58.wav", + "text": "現在是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/59.wav", + "text": "大家就說錄影帶找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/60.wav", + "text": "照不清楚等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/61.wav", + "text": "很多的糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/62.wav", + "text": "這是一體兩面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/63.wav", + "text": "全國家長在看這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/64.wav", + "text": "有些是反對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/65.wav", + "text": "嘛可是法律已經規定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/66.wav", + "text": "\n現行的辦法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/67.wav", + "text": "後來縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/68.wav", + "text": "臺北市縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/69.wav", + "text": "縣市政府自己弄一個雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/70.wav", + "text": "全部來這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/71.wav", + "text": "是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/72.wav", + "text": "子有108十幾個學校都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/73.wav", + "text": "至少六都差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/74.wav", + "text": "我這裡有問題來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/75.wav", + "text": "是一個全國的雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/76.wav", + "text": "現在只是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/77.wav", + "text": "各個學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/78.wav", + "text": "的把它放入全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/79.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說會發生資安的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/80.wav", + "text": "啊縣市政府也會發生資安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/81.wav", + "text": "題國家來做資安會做得更完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/82.wav", + "text": "而且這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/83.wav", + "text": "大家在幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/84.wav", + "text": "只有在發生糾紛的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/85.wav", + "text": "小孩不會講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/86.wav", + "text": "很多糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/87.wav", + "text": "常常就發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/88.wav", + "text": "了過去社會常常爆出這種現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/89.wav", + "text": "所以衛福部的意思是整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/90.wav", + "text": "放在一個雲上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/91.wav", + "text": "要政府來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/92.wav", + "text": "資安會做得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/93.wav", + "text": "你談的資安是表面他們談的是資安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/94.wav", + "text": "實質上是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/95.wav", + "text": "上全國雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/96.wav", + "text": "就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/97.wav", + "text": "你知道說全部照他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/98.wav", + "text": "的這個題目他們討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/99.wav", + "text": "了好久這個不是今天才出現的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/100.wav", + "text": "已經從108年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/101.wav", + "text": "我等一下要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/102.wav", + "text": "這些業者當然很反彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/103.wav", + "text": "放在上面平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/104.wav", + "text": "平常誰都不能偷看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/105.wav", + "text": "也不能去監督學校怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/106.wav", + "text": "學校可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/107.wav", + "text": "偷看老師有沒有認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/108.wav", + "text": "這個好像更有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/109.wav", + "text": "啊當然這是一個很大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/110.wav", + "text": "公共化議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/111.wav", + "text": "我們這樣很為難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/112.wav", + "text": "假如站在他們那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/113.wav", + "text": "國家要花錢把它整合起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/114.wav", + "text": "他們有在溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/115.wav", + "text": "最近也一直要找我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/116.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天在談這個議題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/117.wav", + "text": "那天談的就是不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/118.wav", + "text": "不然這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/119.wav", + "text": "全部凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/120.wav", + "text": "我到立法院到現在為止三十年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/121.wav", + "text": "還沒有發生一個單位的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/122.wav", + "text": "是被全部凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/123.wav", + "text": "50%也不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/124.wav", + "text": "上禮拜在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/125.wav", + "text": "有講他講的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/126.wav", + "text": "我跟邱臣遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/127.wav", + "text": "有稍微溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/128.wav", + "text": "他們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/129.wav", + "text": "他們也接受陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/130.wav", + "text": "他也知道這個東西很為難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/131.wav", + "text": "所以大概講話都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/132.wav", + "text": "不敢講得太清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/133.wav", + "text": "我算很清楚地講這些話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/134.wav", + "text": "啦邱臣遠是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/135.wav", + "text": "我們現在哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/136.wav", + "text": "預算有50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/137.wav", + "text": "到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/138.wav", + "text": "這麼多年來所有的預算凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/139.wav", + "text": "這個數字可以談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/140.wav", + "text": "他們好好去溝通開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/141.wav", + "text": "都無所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/142.wav", + "text": "大家去釐清這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/143.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/144.wav", + "text": "他們有什麼疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/145.wav", + "text": "不是我們的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/146.wav", + "text": "要給他們有機會講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/147.wav", + "text": "還有什麼好講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/148.wav", + "text": "溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/149.wav", + "text": "不是凍結百分比的問題而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/150.wav", + "text": "依法而來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/151.wav", + "text": "很多委員都有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/152.wav", + "text": "我自己有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/153.wav", + "text": "對啊你現在再翻轉回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/154.wav", + "text": "你聽我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/155.wav", + "text": "好叫他們好好去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/156.wav", + "text": "那凍結數大家來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/157.wav", + "text": "對於所有預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/158.wav", + "text": "凍結頂多10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/159.wav", + "text": "像這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/160.wav", + "text": "凍結10%的也不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/161.wav", + "text": "有的5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/162.wav", + "text": "這個凍結數我們來談沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/163.wav", + "text": "叫他們來做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/164.wav", + "text": "OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/165.wav", + "text": "啊我們能夠做的大概這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/166.wav", + "text": "你說叫他不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/167.wav", + "text": "要刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/168.wav", + "text": "我先補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/169.wav", + "text": "等一下再請吳怡玎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/170.wav", + "text": "第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/171.wav", + "text": "就是現有法令的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/172.wav", + "text": "我在衛環委員會很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/173.wav", + "text": "現有法令的規定就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/174.wav", + "text": "都要錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/175.wav", + "text": "有硬碟儲存一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/176.wav", + "text": "是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/177.wav", + "text": "沒有規定要做雲端集中起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/178.wav", + "text": "這是第一點我要說明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/179.wav", + "text": "所以教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/180.wav", + "text": "他們是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/181.wav", + "text": "幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/182.wav", + "text": "做全國監管雲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/183.wav", + "text": "本來幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/184.wav", + "text": "也有各幼兒園的硬碟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/185.wav", + "text": "你回去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/186.wav", + "text": "所以現在幼兒園是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/187.wav", + "text": "做全國監管雲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/188.wav", + "text": "就是各幼兒園都要儲存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/189.wav", + "text": "一個月的硬碟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/190.wav", + "text": "有罰責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/191.wav", + "text": "加重罰責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/192.wav", + "text": "定儲存起來就要儲存起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/193.wav", + "text": "一個月內縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/194.wav", + "text": "隨時去檢查都要提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/195.wav", + "text": "現在幼兒園是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/196.wav", + "text": "態度就是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/197.wav", + "text": "監視器硬碟的全國監管雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/198.wav", + "text": "它認為風險更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/199.wav", + "text": "所以這個我要跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/200.wav", + "text": "說明現有法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/201.wav", + "text": "是規定要做硬碟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/202.wav", + "text": "要儲存沒有規定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/203.wav", + "text": "做全國監管雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/204.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得啦當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/205.wav", + "text": "柯總召說有時候去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/206.wav", + "text": "說什麼沒有錄影到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/207.wav", + "text": "好這個都是違規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/208.wav", + "text": "啊本身就是違規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/209.wav", + "text": "規定要儲存一個月就是要儲存一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/210.wav", + "text": "不管任何理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/211.wav", + "text": "所以應該要加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/212.wav", + "text": "另外就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/213.wav", + "text": "如果各縣市都已經在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/214.wav", + "text": "縣市的監管雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/215.wav", + "text": "那就給縣市做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/216.wav", + "text": "嘛把全國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/217.wav", + "text": "全國監管雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/218.wav", + "text": "而且真正在執行檢查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/219.wav", + "text": "也都是縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/220.wav", + "text": "而不是衛福部下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/221.wav", + "text": "執行檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/222.wav", + "text": "那麼回到縣市政府來管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/223.wav", + "text": "不是更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/224.wav", + "text": "落實更直接嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/225.wav", + "text": "給縣市政府讓縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/226.wav", + "text": "自己做縣市監管雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/227.wav", + "text": "這也是一個方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/228.wav", + "text": "一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/229.wav", + "text": "啦因為有的縣市政府已經在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/230.wav", + "text": "然後也不會風險這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/231.wav", + "text": "把全國的全部集中在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/232.wav", + "text": "那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/233.wav", + "text": "\n資安的問題是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/234.wav", + "text": "越分散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/235.wav", + "text": "資安受到駭客攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/236.wav", + "text": "的傷害越小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/237.wav", + "text": "因為資料分散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/238.wav", + "text": "嘛為什麼資料要分散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/239.wav", + "text": "去中心化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/240.wav", + "text": "因為被攻擊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/241.wav", + "text": "的話全部資料都在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/242.wav", + "text": "非常重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/243.wav", + "text": "嘛\n我們全國的資訊譬如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/244.wav", + "text": "健保資訊被盜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/245.wav", + "text": "如果是限制在縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/246.wav", + "text": "萬一被駭了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/247.wav", + "text": "受傷害的情形比較小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/248.wav", + "text": "\n這個當然各有利弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/249.wav", + "text": "我知道家長裡面也有不同的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/250.wav", + "text": "所以我才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/251.wav", + "text": "說應該要凍結一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/252.wav", + "text": "然後我們來開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/253.wav", + "text": "社會溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/254.wav", + "text": "還有執行面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/255.wav", + "text": "要如何即使將來做了全國監管雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/256.wav", + "text": "這個管理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/257.wav", + "text": "機制在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/258.wav", + "text": "如何防止資料外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/259.wav", + "text": "這些都要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/260.wav", + "text": "或是老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/261.wav", + "text": "社會溝通以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/262.wav", + "text": "好吳怡玎委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/263.wav", + "text": "我簡單講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/264.wav", + "text": "其實這不是只有業者反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/265.wav", + "text": "我做為家長其實會很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/266.wav", + "text": "這樣子的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/267.wav", + "text": "被中央統一放在一個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/268.wav", + "text": "尤其是我們現在中央部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/269.wav", + "text": "資料外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/270.wav", + "text": "這些事情真的是常常聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/271.wav", + "text": "如果它是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/272.wav", + "text": "幼兒園所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/273.wav", + "text": "或是托嬰園所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/274.wav", + "text": "而且是一個不聯外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/275.wav", + "text": "網路的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/276.wav", + "text": "這是最安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/277.wav", + "text": "出事的時候調不到資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/278.wav", + "text": "或者是調的資料看不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/279.wav", + "text": "老實說調的資料如果看不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/280.wav", + "text": "你集中到中央還是看不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/281.wav", + "text": "因為那是要你去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/282.wav", + "text": "抽查才知道照的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/283.wav", + "text": "你看不看得清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/284.wav", + "text": "我覺得這不是調到中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/285.wav", + "text": "就是你還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/286.wav", + "text": "要去抽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/287.wav", + "text": "看不到的話出事調不到資料的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/288.wav", + "text": "這也是去抽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/289.wav", + "text": "就可以解決不需要集中到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/290.wav", + "text": "中央雲這應該是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/291.wav", + "text": "我們是不是更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/292.wav", + "text": "頻繁地去抽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/293.wav", + "text": "就是去看這個帶子即使是沒有問題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/294.wav", + "text": "由我們的縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/295.wav", + "text": "派人去看這個帶子是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/296.wav", + "text": "有保存完好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/297.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛為洲委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/298.wav", + "text": "你分散的時候駭客他多忙啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/299.wav", + "text": "他要去攻擊多少地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/300.wav", + "text": "才可以拿到一點點資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/301.wav", + "text": "但是你集中的時候真的是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/302.wav", + "text": "危險其實不是只有衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/303.wav", + "text": "有這個問題我們中央各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/304.wav", + "text": "現在都開始出現很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/305.wav", + "text": "他們開始到處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/306.wav", + "text": "蒐集許多人民的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/307.wav", + "text": "這攸關到你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/308.wav", + "text": "怎麼蒐集的你有沒有告知人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/309.wav", + "text": "你怎麼儲存你怎麼應用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/310.wav", + "text": "你怎麼銷毀我們對於這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/311.wav", + "text": "東西都沒有一個很明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/312.wav", + "text": "規定一般民眾會很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/313.wav", + "text": "擔心的謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/314.wav", + "text": "好柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/315.wav", + "text": "要彼此說服彼此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/316.wav", + "text": "不是只有我們兩造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/317.wav", + "text": "者我知道大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/318.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/319.wav", + "text": "遊說的壓力我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/320.wav", + "text": "不諱言他們要找我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/321.wav", + "text": "我也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/322.wav", + "text": "但是我還是要講一些話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/323.wav", + "text": "儲存系統而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/324.wav", + "text": "這個沒有用來監管的任何意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/325.wav", + "text": "督學校有沒有好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/326.wav", + "text": "教書等等的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/327.wav", + "text": "incase發生事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/328.wav", + "text": "只有30天而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/329.wav", + "text": "調出來看的第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/330.wav", + "text": "或是清不清楚乃至於被重置等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/331.wav", + "text": "這種社會問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/332.wav", + "text": "各位難道忘記了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/333.wav", + "text": "尤其我們要站在保護嬰幼兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/334.wav", + "text": "的角度上面來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/335.wav", + "text": "0到2歲因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/336.wav", + "text": "不會講話是屬於衛福部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/337.wav", + "text": "3歲到6歲屬於教育部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/338.wav", + "text": "所以教育部的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/339.wav", + "text": "是說大家要協調好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/340.wav", + "text": "並不是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/341.wav", + "text": "兒少權益保護法上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/342.wav", + "text": "這個法制面以後都有都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/343.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/344.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/345.wav", + "text": "集中你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/346.wav", + "text": "它已經用非常安全的等級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/347.wav", + "text": "在處理這個事情要駭的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/348.wav", + "text": "現在每個學校的最簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/349.wav", + "text": "你不要用這樣的話來講那之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/350.wav", + "text": "我們就什麼都不要做雲端了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/351.wav", + "text": "包括加密什麼等等的他們會去做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/352.wav", + "text": "我的看法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/353.wav", + "text": "我們在這邊彼此爭辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/354.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/355.wav", + "text": "這是一體多面的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/356.wav", + "text": "要凍多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/357.wav", + "text": "這個我們都OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/358.wav", + "text": "來我相信這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/359.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡說要往後退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/360.wav", + "text": "誰打死都不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/361.wav", + "text": "等有一天發生事情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/362.wav", + "text": "你不再做立委我們還在做立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/363.wav", + "text": "每個黨團都會碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/364.wav", + "text": "家長當然是希望保護兒童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/365.wav", + "text": "嘛把那些家長弄出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/366.wav", + "text": "又變成社會問題大家對峙不好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/367.wav", + "text": "這是可以理性討論的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/368.wav", + "text": "大概用這樣的方式來處理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/369.wav", + "text": "你先寫好文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/370.wav", + "text": "大家繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/371.wav", + "text": "繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/372.wav", + "text": "我寫還是你寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/373.wav", + "text": "我們寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/374.wav", + "text": "你寫一張我寫一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/375.wav", + "text": "各黨都可以寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/376.wav", + "text": "本來立法院表決都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/377.wav", + "text": "寫好以後再整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/378.wav", + "text": "那何時要整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/379.wav", + "text": "這3個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/380.wav", + "text": "我相信應該沒有問題比較好談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/381.wav", + "text": "明天很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/382.wav", + "text": "但是表決前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/383.wav", + "text": "我們現在談的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/384.wav", + "text": "我要跟黨團說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/385.wav", + "text": "我們六十幾項要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/386.wav", + "text": "我都要一一說明大家才會一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/387.wav", + "text": "所以是不是9點半以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/388.wav", + "text": "我們再來進行院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/389.wav", + "text": "9點可以先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/390.wav", + "text": "9點半到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/391.wav", + "text": "沒有啦議場後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/392.wav", + "text": "議場後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/393.wav", + "text": "我想國民黨也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/394.wav", + "text": "六十幾項要表決你總要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/395.wav", + "text": "對啦我們會開黨團大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/396.wav", + "text": "大家都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/397.wav", + "text": "再來調整就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/398.wav", + "text": "到議場後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/399.wav", + "text": "表決之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/400.wav", + "text": "大家有個默契" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/401.wav", + "text": "就是明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/402.wav", + "text": "原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/403.wav", + "text": "到也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/404.wav", + "text": "再來表決表決前要發言等一下要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/405.wav", + "text": "最好是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/406.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/407.wav", + "text": "要回選區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/408.wav", + "text": "所以原則上就是中午不休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/409.wav", + "text": "當然不休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/410.wav", + "text": "中午不休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/411.wav", + "text": "表決完再回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/412.wav", + "text": "請院長再召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/413.wav", + "text": "不必表決的先緊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/414.wav", + "text": "接著要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/415.wav", + "text": "你們甲動如果是9點半就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/416.wav", + "text": "也要讓我去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/417.wav", + "text": "差不多這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/418.wav", + "text": "原則上就是中午不休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/419.wav", + "text": "大家如果同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/420.wav", + "text": "這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/421.wav", + "text": "拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/422.wav", + "text": "有三個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/423.wav", + "text": "第一個案是房屋稅條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/424.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/425.wav", + "text": "另外第二案第三案都跟所得稅法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/426.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/427.wav", + "text": "列席的首長有財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/428.wav", + "text": "部長莊翠雲女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/429.wav", + "text": "賦稅署署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/430.wav", + "text": "宋秀玲女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/431.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/432.wav", + "text": "開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/433.wav", + "text": "了針對第一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/434.wav", + "text": "第一案的第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/435.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/436.wav", + "text": "於房屋稅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/437.wav", + "text": "大概在委員會審查以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/438.wav", + "text": "文事實上關鍵只有一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/439.wav", + "text": "和國民黨的部分都差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/440.wav", + "text": "關鍵只有這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/441.wav", + "text": "是因為第5條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/442.wav", + "text": "那要補貼等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/443.wav", + "text": "都配合保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/444.wav", + "text": "有關第9條就是刪除民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/445.wav", + "text": "那個是小���題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/446.wav", + "text": "這個大家有高度共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/447.wav", + "text": "還有第十一條的部分就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/448.wav", + "text": "評定的時程是多久一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/449.wav", + "text": "關鍵就是第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/450.wav", + "text": "們和國民黨的意見趨於一致啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/451.wav", + "text": "大概這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/452.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/453.wav", + "text": "看大家有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/454.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/455.wav", + "text": "房屋稅條例第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/456.wav", + "text": "也就是所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/457.wav", + "text": "囤房稅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/458.wav", + "text": "國民黨的立場第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/459.wav", + "text": "假設稅率4.8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/460.wav", + "text": "基本上支持這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/461.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/462.wav", + "text": "有關課稅現值的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/463.wav", + "text": "要請財政部再講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/464.wav", + "text": "課稅現值非常的重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/465.wav", + "text": "假設稅率再高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/466.wav", + "text": "而課稅現值嚴重偏低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/467.wav", + "text": "也沒有辦法達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/468.wav", + "text": "不說是打房啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/469.wav", + "text": "但至少你要產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/470.wav", + "text": "讓房市更健全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/471.wav", + "text": "效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/472.wav", + "text": "基本上支持這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/473.wav", + "text": "第二點請莊部長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/474.wav", + "text": "課稅現值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/475.wav", + "text": "現在跟市價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/476.wav", + "text": "有沒有相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/477.wav", + "text": "假設沒有相當要多久之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/478.wav", + "text": "才可以讓它相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/479.wav", + "text": "請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/480.wav", + "text": "先講一下再請部長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/481.wav", + "text": "民眾黨原始的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/482.wav", + "text": "是比較重一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/483.wav", + "text": "的但我們也是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/484.wav", + "text": "而且也是最後的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/485.wav", + "text": "當然其實我們可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/486.wav", + "text": ".8%因為我們是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/487.wav", + "text": "至少一定要讓今天能夠完全通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/488.wav", + "text": "我們不希望因為一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/489.wav", + "text": "雖然也許有更高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/490.wav", + "text": "目標但是結果因為技術性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/491.wav", + "text": "問題反而導致今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/492.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法實踐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/493.wav", + "text": "\n同時我還是要先指出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/494.wav", + "text": "不能完全達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/495.wav", + "text": "我們真正想要的政策目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/496.wav", + "text": "其原因很簡單就有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/497.wav", + "text": "認真講稅基其實才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/498.wav", + "text": "坦白講也只能是邊際性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/499.wav", + "text": "都能囤房4戶以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/500.wav", + "text": "加幾千塊錢說實話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/501.wav", + "text": "對他們來說也是不痛不癢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/502.wav", + "text": "但是不往這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/503.wav", + "text": "做絕對是不可以的我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/504.wav", + "text": "堅持主張一定要往這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/505.wav", + "text": "院版的共識是可以的話當然我們是一定要讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/506.wav", + "text": "\n另外有關稅基調整的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/507.wav", + "text": "可能財政部真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/508.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是非常急迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/509.wav", + "text": "更能夠接近真正的實價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/510.wav", + "text": "大方向我想民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/511.wav", + "text": "事實上實價課稅可能是更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/512.wav", + "text": "稅制改革的部分所以這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/513.wav", + "text": "也是我們的希望然後我們也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/514.wav", + "text": "能看怎麼調整雖然這個部分也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/515.wav", + "text": "地方政府有時候甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/516.wav", + "text": "不是往上調連往下調的都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/517.wav", + "text": "發生所以這個部分要怎麼樣讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/518.wav", + "text": "配套更好還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/519.wav", + "text": "未來財政部在配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/520.wav", + "text": "上能做得更好以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/521.wav", + "text": "謝謝謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/522.wav", + "text": "召先講一下他剛才有舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/523.wav", + "text": "你再綜合回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/524.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/525.wav", + "text": "房屋稅條例第5條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/526.wav", + "text": "最高是3.6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/527.wav", + "text": "%結果現在只增加到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/528.wav", + "text": "%事實上只增加了1.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/529.wav", + "text": "這樣實施的結果到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/530.wav", + "text": "持有的成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/531.wav", + "text": "能夠逼出空餘屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/532.wav", + "text": "這是自欺欺人嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/533.wav", + "text": "我現在囤房十幾間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/534.wav", + "text": "然後你給我增加這些稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/535.wav", + "text": "空餘屋我覺得這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/536.wav", + "text": "掩耳盜鈴也是自欺欺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/537.wav", + "text": "全國非自住住家用房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/538.wav", + "text": "房屋稅籍個人歸戶統計表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/539.wav", + "text": "持有的空屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/540.wav", + "text": "如果你持有空屋的話是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/541.wav", + "text": "1到3戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/542.wav", + "text": "這個是比較多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/543.wav", + "text": "但是依照財政部的參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/544.wav", + "text": "3.6%的最高稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/545.wav", + "text": "才增加了0.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/546.wav", + "text": "所以這樣的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/547.wav", + "text": "增加0.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/548.wav", + "text": "空餘屋釋出給住家用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/549.wav", + "text": "到底有什麼樣的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/550.wav", + "text": "財政部的版本是非常非常離譜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/551.wav", + "text": "你還要等到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/552.wav", + "text": "所持有的空屋數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/553.wav", + "text": "包括7戶以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/554.wav", + "text": "等於是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/555.wav", + "text": "你要課到最高4.8%的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/556.wav", + "text": "你要持有最高的7戶以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/557.wav", + "text": "對於有意囤房的投資客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/558.wav", + "text": "嚇阻的作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/559.wav", + "text": "所以這是自欺欺人嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/560.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個更嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/561.wav", + "text": "就是關於房屋起造人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/562.wav", + "text": "囤房的部分這個才是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/563.wav", + "text": "現在最重要想去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/564.wav", + "text": "對付的嘛結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/565.wav", + "text": "是從使用執照下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/566.wav", + "text": "開始起算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/567.wav", + "text": "在拿到這個建照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/568.wav", + "text": "之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/569.wav", + "text": "就有至少2年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/570.wav", + "text": "可以用預售屋的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/571.wav", + "text": "才開始起算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/572.wav", + "text": "你的算法等於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/573.wav", + "text": "也要超過5年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/574.wav", + "text": "才能對這個起造人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/575.wav", + "text": "課以最高4.8%的稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/576.wav", + "text": "他在預售屋的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/577.wav", + "text": "就可以賣個12年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/578.wav", + "text": "之後還要再賣5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/579.wav", + "text": "5年後總共加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/580.wav", + "text": "將近7年才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/581.wav", + "text": "課以最高的稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/582.wav", + "text": "安心地囤房7年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/583.wav", + "text": "提高價格來緩賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/584.wav", + "text": "所以就這個部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/585.wav", + "text": "說實在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/586.wav", + "text": "到底是要提高成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/587.wav", + "text": "還是不想要讓大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/588.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛柯總召講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/589.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/590.wav", + "text": "和國民黨黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/591.wav", + "text": "差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/592.wav", + "text": "我會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/593.wav", + "text": "這個有點奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/594.wav", + "text": "民進黨是農工起家的一個政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/595.wav", + "text": "搞到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/596.wav", + "text": "在面對囤房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/597.wav", + "text": "稅(房屋稅條例第5條)的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/598.wav", + "text": "現在臺灣房價已經高不可攀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/599.wav", + "text": "年輕人根本買不起房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/600.wav", + "text": "臺灣的出生嬰兒人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/601.wav", + "text": "已經是歷史的新低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/602.wav", + "text": "去年才13萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/603.wav", + "text": "今年1到6月是6萬多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/604.wav", + "text": "要破紀錄了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/605.wav", + "text": "搞到年輕人都已經活不下去的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/606.wav", + "text": "結果你就輕巧一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/607.wav", + "text": "千呼萬喚始出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/608.wav", + "text": "在這將近78年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/609.wav", + "text": "現在總算要推出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/610.wav", + "text": "增加個1.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/611.wav", + "text": "甚至最多的囤房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/612.wav", + "text": ")這個級距最高是3.8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/613.wav", + "text": "%等於只增加0.2%而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/614.wav", + "text": "又可以讓建商安心地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/615.wav", + "text": "囤房7年再來賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/616.wav", + "text": "結果輕巧一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/617.wav", + "text": "和國民黨的一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/618.wav", + "text": "你不會覺得奇怪嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/619.wav", + "text": "實時代力量的版本是非常清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/620.wav", + "text": "這些故意囤房的建商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/621.wav", + "text": "非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/622.wav", + "text": "如果超過1年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/623.wav", + "text": "你就是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/624.wav", + "text": "課以他最高的稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/625.wav", + "text": "有效地去兼顧各方的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/626.wav", + "text": "利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/627.wav", + "text": "去嚇阻故意囤房的建商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/628.wav", + "text": "空餘屋被逼出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/629.wav", + "text": "能夠真正地刺激" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/630.wav", + "text": "財政部才喜洋洋地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/631.wav", + "text": "公布今年前11個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/632.wav", + "text": "個人房地合一稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/633.wav", + "text": "收累積已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/634.wav", + "text": "6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/635.wav", + "text": "有望超過去年全年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/636.wav", + "text": "382億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/637.wav", + "text": "挑戰400億的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/638.wav", + "text": "新高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/639.wav", + "text": "這到底有什麼好高興的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/640.wav", + "text": "這到底有什麼好高興的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/641.wav", + "text": "你房地合一稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/642.wav", + "text": "的目的是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/643.wav", + "text": "嚇阻這個短期交易的投機買賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/644.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/645.wav", + "text": "你的稅收應該要越少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/646.wav", + "text": "才表示你這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/647.wav", + "text": "結果不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/648.wav", + "text": "那不是表示這個短期交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/649.wav", + "text": "結果財政部竟然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/650.wav", + "text": "把它當作政績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/651.wav", + "text": "財政部的這個房市政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/652.wav", + "text": "根本就沒有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/653.wav", + "text": "根本就沒有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/654.wav", + "text": "結果你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/655.wav", + "text": "非常的高興喜洋洋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/656.wav", + "text": "你有沒有想到那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/657.wav", + "text": "在臺灣水深火熱完全沒辦法買到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/658.wav", + "text": "房子的年輕世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/659.wav", + "text": "整個世代被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/660.wav", + "text": "房價壓得喘不過氣來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/661.wav", + "text": "房子與孩子之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/662.wav", + "text": "二擇一的這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/663.wav", + "text": "所以投資客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/664.wav", + "text": "完全都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/665.wav", + "text": "沒有感受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/666.wav", + "text": "任何壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/667.wav", + "text": "也沒有感受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/668.wav", + "text": "有什麼好害怕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/669.wav", + "text": "這樣的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/670.wav", + "text": "你還敢提出這樣的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/671.wav", + "text": "還是不願意提高房屋稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/672.wav", + "text": "跟將稅率明定入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/673.wav", + "text": "另外一個更自欺欺人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/674.wav", + "text": "方式就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/675.wav", + "text": "全臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/676.wav", + "text": "到底有哪一個地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/677.wav", + "text": "有根據所謂的地方稅法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/678.wav", + "text": "自行調高到三成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/679.wav", + "text": "這是非常離譜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/680.wav", + "text": "地方政府這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/681.wav", + "text": "甚至還有調更低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/682.wav", + "text": "所以這個基本上就是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/683.wav", + "text": "自欺欺人的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/684.wav", + "text": "我基本上會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/685.wav", + "text": "認為負責任的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/686.wav", + "text": "不只是替這一代的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/687.wav", + "text": "年輕世代也要替未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/688.wav", + "text": "的年輕世代來著想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/689.wav", + "text": "負責任的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/690.wav", + "text": "坦白講你今天提出這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/691.wav", + "text": "版本之後未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/692.wav", + "text": "臺灣的房價未來臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/693.wav", + "text": "炒房的問題囤房的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/694.wav", + "text": "減少反而可能又更加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/695.wav", + "text": "重好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/696.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/697.wav", + "text": "好在這裡還是要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/698.wav", + "text": "稅率還是太低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/699.wav", + "text": "提出來的版本──差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/700.wav", + "text": "級距必須要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/701.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡還是要呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/702.wav", + "text": "在野黨我們不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/703.wav", + "text": "用這樣草率的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/704.wav", + "text": "為執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/705.wav", + "text": "房屋稅條例的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/706.wav", + "text": "應該只是一個騙票的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/707.wav", + "text": "作法以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/708.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/709.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/710.wav", + "text": "柯總召你有要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/711.wav", + "text": "接下來再曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/712.wav", + "text": "所謂預售屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/713.wav", + "text": "我想大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/714.wav", + "text": "在平均地權條例修正以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/715.wav", + "text": "預售屋就不能轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/716.wav", + "text": "我們現在有兩稅合一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/717.wav", + "text": "已經併到所得稅上面去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/718.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/719.wav", + "text": "似乎就是等著我們講什麼話就要攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/720.wav", + "text": "行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/721.wav", + "text": "和國民黨版本兩個差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/722.wav", + "text": "我想這個不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/723.wav", + "text": "你們都假的或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/724.wav", + "text": "因為你的概念和別人的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/725.wav", + "text": "不大一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/726.wav", + "text": "可以這樣做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/727.wav", + "text": "這值得討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/728.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天要很冷靜來談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/729.wav", + "text": "至於建商部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/730.wav", + "text": "當然建商部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/731.wav", + "text": "是買來就要賣掉的它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/732.wav", + "text": "賣不掉就必須忍受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/733.wav", + "text": "稅率的增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/734.wav", + "text": "把房子逼出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/735.wav", + "text": "的稅基已經到4.8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/736.wav", + "text": "這個房屋稅條例的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/737.wav", + "text": "你們都假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/738.wav", + "text": "財政部針對時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/739.wav", + "text": "好好說明好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/740.wav", + "text": "曾總召講完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/741.wav", + "text": "你先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/742.wav", + "text": "都要面對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/743.wav", + "text": "我想有關房屋稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/744.wav", + "text": "修正條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/745.wav", + "text": "相關的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/746.wav", + "text": "事實上已經好幾年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/747.wav", + "text": "基本上是地方政府的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/748.wav", + "text": "在憲法裡面房屋稅也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/749.wav", + "text": "屬於地方政府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/750.wav", + "text": "稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/751.wav", + "text": "但是因為現在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/752.wav", + "text": "房價的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/753.wav", + "text": "目前房屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/754.wav", + "text": "房屋稅相關的稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/755.wav", + "text": "大家認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/756.wav", + "text": "更清楚的差別稅率的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/757.wav", + "text": "必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/758.wav", + "text": "大家俗稱的囤房稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/759.wav", + "text": "其實就是所謂差別稅率的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/760.wav", + "text": "級距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/761.wav", + "text": "多年的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/762.wav", + "text": "包括我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/763.wav", + "text": "歸戶的技術以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/764.wav", + "text": "但是我們要用全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/765.wav", + "text": "技術問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/766.wav", + "text": "在這12年間財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/767.wav", + "text": "跟地方政府其實進行了相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/768.wav", + "text": "的溝通今天才有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/769.wav", + "text": "克服這些困難訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/770.wav", + "text": "大家也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/771.wav", + "text": "這個禮拜就是我們這一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/772.wav", + "text": "會期最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/773.wav", + "text": "我們院會處理沒有通過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/774.wav", + "text": "房屋稅即大家所謂的囤房稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/775.wav", + "text": "要延到下一屆又要重新來一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/776.wav", + "text": "因為它屆期不連續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/777.wav", + "text": "又必須重新來一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/778.wav", + "text": "但事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/779.wav", + "text": "囤房稅的期待都是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/780.wav", + "text": "的會期能夠通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/781.wav", + "text": "在通過的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/782.wav", + "text": "當然各黨有各黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/783.wav", + "text": "各黨也有各自的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/784.wav", + "text": "但是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/785.wav", + "text": "都堅持自己的版本指責其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/786.wav", + "text": "版本是自欺欺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/787.wav", + "text": "是離譜等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/788.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣子的作法第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/789.wav", + "text": "期待都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/790.wav", + "text": "希望房屋稅條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/791.wav", + "text": "至少我們今天這一次通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/792.wav", + "text": "後大家有取得一個共識踏出第一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/793.wav", + "text": "地方政府的實施上面如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/794.wav", + "text": "還有問題我們才有繼續往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/795.wav", + "text": "前進修改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/796.wav", + "text": "一個基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/797.wav", + "text": "所以我是希望今天各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/798.wav", + "text": "彼此瞭解大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/799.wav", + "text": "沒有一個政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/800.wav", + "text": "是自欺欺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/801.wav", + "text": "也沒有一個政黨是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/802.wav", + "text": "提出離譜的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/803.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個是大家要互相尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/804.wav", + "text": "會期最後的時間裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/805.wav", + "text": "通過一個大家有共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/806.wav", + "text": "地方政府對於房屋稅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/807.wav", + "text": "院長各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/808.wav", + "text": "各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/809.wav", + "text": "有關房屋稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/810.wav", + "text": "條例部分條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/811.wav", + "text": "修正草案我再提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/812.wav", + "text": "三點說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/813.wav", + "text": "第一點房屋稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/814.wav", + "text": "囤房稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/815.wav", + "text": "政策目的是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/816.wav", + "text": "健全房市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/817.wav", + "text": "讓年輕朋友可以買得到房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/818.wav", + "text": "這是它的政策目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/819.wav", + "text": "第二點其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/820.wav", + "text": "提出這個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/821.wav", + "text": "草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/822.wav", + "text": "後已經討論了兩三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/823.wav", + "text": "從早期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/824.wav", + "text": "財政部不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/825.wav", + "text": "不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/826.wav", + "text": "到現在已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/827.wav", + "text": "把行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/828.wav", + "text": "版本送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/829.wav", + "text": "所以已經有進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/830.wav", + "text": "還是那句話稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/831.wav", + "text": "支持行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/832.wav", + "text": "稅率4.8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/833.wav", + "text": "但最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/834.wav", + "text": "是它的課稅現值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/835.wav", + "text": "它比稅率還重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/836.wav", + "text": "有沒有跟市價相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/837.wav", + "text": "我都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/838.wav", + "text": "比稅率更重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/839.wav", + "text": "也要請財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/840.wav", + "text": "注意因為這是整個囤房稅中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/841.wav", + "text": "最重要的配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/842.wav", + "text": "所以等一下請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/843.wav", + "text": "要說明課稅現值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/844.wav", + "text": "到底現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/845.wav", + "text": "跟市價差距多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/846.wav", + "text": "假如有差距的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/847.wav", + "text": "多少年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/848.wav", + "text": "可以讓它貼近市價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/849.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/850.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/851.wav", + "text": "我想在房屋稅裡面當然有兩個因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/852.wav", + "text": "也就是課稅現值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/853.wav", + "text": "值在稅率的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/854.wav", + "text": "雖然只提高1.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/855.wav", + "text": "%但是它有一個很大的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/856.wav", + "text": "目前的房屋稅是縣市歸戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/857.wav", + "text": "坐落在各縣市的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/858.wav", + "text": "所有房屋都必須要統計進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/859.wav", + "text": "這個部分就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/860.wav", + "text": "較往年進步了一大步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/861.wav", + "text": "第二個它是全數累進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/862.wav", + "text": "也就是說你的房屋戶數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/863.wav", + "text": "達到某一個數字的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/864.wav", + "text": "多少戶數以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/865.wav", + "text": "你的每一間房屋除了你自住以外��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/866.wav", + "text": "只要沒有做合理使用的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/867.wav", + "text": "都必須按照高稅率來課徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/868.wav", + "text": "其實是不低的這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/869.wav", + "text": "第二個部分就講到稅基" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/870.wav", + "text": "因為它是課徵房屋稅的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/871.wav", + "text": "長年沒有調整稅基" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/872.wav", + "text": "基因此這幾年我們都一直要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/873.wav", + "text": "地方政府要合宜的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/874.wav", + "text": "因為這幾年都在調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/875.wav", + "text": "尤其是新蓋的房屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/876.wav", + "text": "再加上地段率的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/877.wav", + "text": "商業化的情形都有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/878.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/879.wav", + "text": "地方政府這幾年已經調高非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/880.wav", + "text": "以臺北市來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/881.wav", + "text": "已經調高到1.84倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/882.wav", + "text": "所以不能說它沒有在調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/883.wav", + "text": "地方政府要合宜的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/884.wav", + "text": "\n各位可以看到第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/885.wav", + "text": "所謂的買賣價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/886.wav", + "text": "也就是附近的買賣價格都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/887.wav", + "text": "關稅率的部分其實這一次的稅率調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/888.wav", + "text": "當然在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/889.wav", + "text": "除了高的之外我們還對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/890.wav", + "text": "有一些必須要釋出的或自用的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/891.wav", + "text": "做一些相對應的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/892.wav", + "text": "至於起造人的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/893.wav", + "text": "為什麼會兩年內才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/894.wav", + "text": "超過兩年以後再最高到4.8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/895.wav", + "text": "%因為我們知道起造人蓋房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/896.wav", + "text": "使用執照拿到以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/897.wav", + "text": "後續要辦理所有權移轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/898.wav", + "text": "縱使他已經銷售掉要辦所有權移轉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/899.wav", + "text": "也得先辦完所有權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/900.wav", + "text": "保存登記即所謂的第一次登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/901.wav", + "text": "第一次登記需要一定的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/902.wav", + "text": "需要測量再辦登記以及公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/903.wav", + "text": "最後再辦所有權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/904.wav", + "text": "移轉登記甚至要辦貸款的抵押權登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/905.wav", + "text": "登記這些都需要時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/906.wav", + "text": "因此在這兩年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/907.wav", + "text": "我們必須給予一個合理的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/908.wav", + "text": "適用不同的稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/909.wav", + "text": "我認為現在是在談稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/910.wav", + "text": "都在講稅基基本上這是兩件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/911.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法逼出空餘屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/912.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/913.wav", + "text": "轉售規定那是平均地權條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/914.wav", + "text": "跟這件事情是風馬牛不相及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/915.wav", + "text": "你要讓建商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/916.wav", + "text": "拿到使用執照之後才開始起算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/917.wav", + "text": "依照現在的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/918.wav", + "text": "那要你回答的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/919.wav", + "text": "最高的級距4.8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/920.wav", + "text": "是不是變相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/921.wav", + "text": "又給他七年的時間可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/922.wav", + "text": "囤房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/923.wav", + "text": "才4.8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/924.wav", + "text": "空餘屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/925.wav", + "text": "有七戶以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/926.wav", + "text": "加上你自己自住的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/927.wav", + "text": "三戶等於是總共有十戶以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/928.wav", + "text": "才會算到4.8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/929.wav", + "text": "多少人會有十戶以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/930.wav", + "text": "這個是可以就事論事的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/931.wav", + "text": "以現在臺灣來看最多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/932.wav", + "text": "本來3.6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/933.wav", + "text": "%現在3.8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/934.wav", + "text": "%所以這完全是可以理性來討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/935.wav", + "text": "不是說你現在提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/936.wav", + "text": "然後說院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/937.wav", + "text": "跟國民黨團提案都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/938.wav", + "text": "差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/939.wav", + "text": "問題是要看這個法案到底是不是合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/940.wav", + "text": "如果不合理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/941.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣才能夠有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/942.wav", + "text": "目的然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/943.wav", + "text": "然後逼人家在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/944.wav", + "text": "這樣的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/945.wav", + "text": "也要接受接受一個完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/946.wav", + "text": "沒有作用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/947.wav", + "text": "現在這些年輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/948.wav", + "text": "繼續存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/949.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/950.wav", + "text": "在民進黨完全執政一黨獨大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/951.wav", + "text": "的情況之下哪有法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/952.wav", + "text": "能夠阻擋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/953.wav", + "text": "啦坦白講今天保留之後明天還不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/954.wav", + "text": "照樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/955.wav", + "text": "合理嗎我們要問的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/956.wav", + "text": "這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/957.wav", + "text": "這個法案已經遲到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/958.wav", + "text": "太久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/959.wav", + "text": "過去的理由是說這個會轉嫁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/960.wav", + "text": "什麼有的沒的理由一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/961.wav", + "text": "總算7年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/962.wav", + "text": "願意提出房屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/963.wav", + "text": "稅條例的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/964.wav", + "text": "拿出一個對策全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/965.wav", + "text": "臺灣沒有人會接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/966.wav", + "text": "即便已經在全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/967.wav", + "text": "歸戶的情況之下我當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/968.wav", + "text": "要全國歸戶這個也不知道已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/969.wav", + "text": "駁說這多困難多困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/970.wav", + "text": "好現在總算要全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/971.wav", + "text": "歸戶了結果在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/972.wav", + "text": "全國歸戶的情況下要算到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/973.wav", + "text": "10戶一個臺灣人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/974.wav", + "text": "整個臺灣有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/975.wav", + "text": "0戶以上房屋才會算到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/976.wav", + "text": "稅率這樣的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/977.wav", + "text": "有多少明明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/978.wav", + "text": "最多持有的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/979.wav", + "text": "1到3戶的空屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/980.wav", + "text": "對不對數字都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/981.wav", + "text": "看得出來最多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/982.wav", + "text": "是1到3戶結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/983.wav", + "text": "2%而已然後告訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/984.wav", + "text": "大家說增加這0." + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/985.wav", + "text": "%的稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/986.wav", + "text": "空餘屋的是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/987.wav", + "text": "嗎我今天都持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/988.wav", + "text": "這麼多房屋了我會在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/989.wav", + "text": "再多繳個幾千塊嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/990.wav", + "text": "狀況對他有效果嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/991.wav", + "text": "所以為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/992.wav", + "text": "說是自欺欺人掩耳盜鈴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/993.wav", + "text": "是稅務專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/994.wav", + "text": "推出這個政策之後能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/995.wav", + "text": "增加多少稅我想連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/996.wav", + "text": "想連個位數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/997.wav", + "text": "的時候你告訴大家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/998.wav", + "text": "這樣可以逼出空餘屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/999.wav", + "text": "在他增加幾千塊稅負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1000.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1001.wav", + "text": "完全是可以講道理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1002.wav", + "text": "天如果要就這個版���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1003.wav", + "text": "果大家有一點誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1004.wav", + "text": "基本上應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1005.wav", + "text": "大家所認為的爭點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1006.wav", + "text": "這個版本通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1007.wav", + "text": "也毫無意義可言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1008.wav", + "text": "好沈委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1009.wav", + "text": "通過是毫無意義可言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1010.wav", + "text": "我個人不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1011.wav", + "text": "社會上也不太能夠接受說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1012.wav", + "text": "這個版本通過是毫無意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1013.wav", + "text": "邱委員是律師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1014.wav", + "text": "就法論法今天我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1015.wav", + "text": "房屋稅條例第5條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1016.wav", + "text": "的內容你剛剛所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1017.wav", + "text": "長篇大論其實大部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1018.wav", + "text": "你談的都是級距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1019.wav", + "text": "級距稅率基準的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1020.wav", + "text": "這個東西並不是定在法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1021.wav", + "text": "而是等這個條文通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1022.wav", + "text": "才會有你剛剛討論的那些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1023.wav", + "text": "房屋差別稅率的級距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1024.wav", + "text": "是要等我們這個法通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1025.wav", + "text": "超過一年未出售的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1026.wav", + "text": "房屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1027.wav", + "text": "通過後才有你剛剛講的幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1028.wav", + "text": "的問題第一類在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1029.wav", + "text": "一年之內二年超過一年到二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1030.wav", + "text": "到四年等這個都是法通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1031.wav", + "text": "以後這不是在法條上面的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1032.wav", + "text": "所以如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1033.wav", + "text": "你們真的在意這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1034.wav", + "text": "那麼就應該在今天大家協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1035.wav", + "text": "支持院版的法條通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1036.wav", + "text": "通過之後就可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1037.wav", + "text": "稅率的級距不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1038.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1039.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1040.wav", + "text": "頭了大家剛才都有充分發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1041.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1042.wav", + "text": "這邊再補充一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1043.wav", + "text": "因為剛才部長有特別講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1044.wav", + "text": "想法是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1045.wav", + "text": "這個政策的目標到底能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1046.wav", + "text": "藉著這次修法完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1047.wav", + "text": "坦白說當然我��也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1048.wav", + "text": "這次為什麼外面的民團也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1049.wav", + "text": "如果真的要逼出空屋的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1050.wav", + "text": "甚至應該要有一個所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1051.wav", + "text": "中央的囤房特別稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1052.wav", + "text": "事實上我們也有提版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1053.wav", + "text": "當然我知道不可能在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1054.wav", + "text": "會期能夠達成這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1055.wav", + "text": "先通過這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1056.wav", + "text": "稅基的部分能夠儘量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1057.wav", + "text": "貼合市價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1058.wav", + "text": "這個部分財政部到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1059.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1060.wav", + "text": "但是我們怎麼樣讓稅基" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1061.wav", + "text": "能夠慢慢的跟上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1062.wav", + "text": "這部分部長能不能有比較具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1063.wav", + "text": "坦白說你們也只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1064.wav", + "text": "胡蘿蔔和棍子在手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1065.wav", + "text": "就是要求地方政府去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1066.wav", + "text": "嘛那這個部分是不是有辦法能夠更具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1067.wav", + "text": "口頭承諾一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1068.wav", + "text": "結果最後還是達不成這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1069.wav", + "text": "院長我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1070.wav", + "text": "剛才沈發惠委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1071.wav", + "text": "這個法基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1072.wav", + "text": "我不知道這個理解對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1073.wav", + "text": "供自住或公益出租人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1074.wav", + "text": "出租使用者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1075.wav", + "text": "為其房屋現值1.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1076.wav", + "text": "最低不得少於房屋現值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1077.wav", + "text": "1.5%最高不得超過3.6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1078.wav", + "text": "所以我們討論的脈絡就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1079.wav", + "text": "現在最高為3.6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1080.wav", + "text": "所以怎麼會說這個沒有在討論稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1081.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1082.wav", + "text": "你這個就是裝睡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1083.wav", + "text": "睡的人搖不醒嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1084.wav", + "text": "他在委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1085.wav", + "text": "但是它的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1086.wav", + "text": "它的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1087.wav", + "text": "基本上在財委會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1088.wav", + "text": "每個委員也會講說如果要修這個法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1089.wav", + "text": "相關的配套是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1090.wav", + "text": "它的配套就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1091.wav", + "text": "我們不要睜眼說瞎話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1092.wav", + "text": "現在它整個規範的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1093.wav", + "text": "我們的版本是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1094.wav", + "text": "它能夠入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1095.wav", + "text": "希望它至少有一個法規範的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1096.wav", + "text": "而財政部的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1097.wav", + "text": "是不是像我講的這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1098.wav", + "text": "它要到五年之後才算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1099.wav", + "text": "建商囤房五年之後才算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1100.wav", + "text": "4.8%是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1101.wav", + "text": "部長在這裡應該很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1102.wav", + "text": "法還沒有沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1103.wav", + "text": "所以你要做實質的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1104.wav", + "text": "你不要這樣子亂扣帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1105.wav", + "text": "因為這是大家非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1106.wav", + "text": "那我要說的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1107.wav", + "text": "睜眼說瞎話離譜自欺欺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1108.wav", + "text": "掩耳盜鈴這些帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1109.wav", + "text": "們就保留因為囤房的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1110.wav", + "text": "才增加0.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1111.wav", + "text": "%怎麼會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1112.wav", + "text": "院長等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1113.wav", + "text": "我要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1114.wav", + "text": "這個是可以講道理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1115.wav", + "text": "我不知道為什麼今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1116.wav", + "text": "其他三黨都支持財政部的見解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1117.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1118.wav", + "text": "最多囤房的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1119.wav", + "text": "就是一到三房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1120.wav", + "text": "這大家都同意嘛空屋就是一到三房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1121.wav", + "text": "那增加多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1122.wav", + "text": "在這個版本之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1123.wav", + "text": "最多數的人是囤房一到三房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1124.wav", + "text": "他會增加0.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1125.wav", + "text": "增加0.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1126.wav", + "text": "告訴大家說這樣不是掩耳盜鈴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1127.wav", + "text": "只增加0.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1128.wav", + "text": "%可以增加多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1129.wav", + "text": "一間房子有1,00邱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1130.wav", + "text": "題嘛我要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1131.wav", + "text": "我今天也是完全覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1132.wav", + "text": "莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1133.wav", + "text": "是非常體恤建商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1134.wav", + "text": "建商囤房是大家認為說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1135.wav", + "text": "現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1136.wav", + "text": "不是扣帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1137.wav", + "text": "讓它可以賣7年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1138.wav", + "text": "不是體恤建商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1139.wav", + "text": "所以我們這個就保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1140.wav", + "text": "保留\n請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1141.wav", + "text": "第5條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1142.wav", + "text": "時代力量提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1143.wav", + "text": "5條之1我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1144.wav", + "text": "只有一個就是鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1145.wav", + "text": "空屋的釋出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1146.wav", + "text": "你現在最高級距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1147.wav", + "text": "都已經4.8了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1148.wav", + "text": "才4.8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1149.wav", + "text": "所以就這部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1150.wav", + "text": "我們是希望你至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1151.wav", + "text": "應該要多鼓勵它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1152.wav", + "text": "讓它去出租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1153.wav", + "text": "因此所定的稅率比財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1154.wav", + "text": "的稅率為低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1155.wav", + "text": "的規定的話一定要達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1156.wav", + "text": "租金的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1157.wav", + "text": "此方式不僅可以影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1158.wav", + "text": "房東與租客之間的交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1159.wav", + "text": "協議自由還限定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1160.wav", + "text": "要達最低房租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1161.wav", + "text": "這也是讓民眾感到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1162.wav", + "text": "因此既然是要鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1163.wav", + "text": "出租的話那應該就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1164.wav", + "text": "只需要審查租賃契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1165.wav", + "text": "房客較大方便性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1166.wav", + "text": "讓民眾有適宜的房屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1167.wav", + "text": "其實我們的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1168.wav", + "text": "並不是就像剛剛房地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1169.wav", + "text": "合一稅提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1170.wav", + "text": "基本上你不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1171.wav", + "text": "為了要徵稅而徵稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1172.wav", + "text": "我們的目的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1173.wav", + "text": "我們的目的是要平抑房價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1174.wav", + "text": "嘛是讓許多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1175.wav", + "text": "需要房屋去成家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1176.wav", + "text": "年輕人有一個家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1177.wav", + "text": "或者是租得起也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1178.wav", + "text": "買得起房子嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1179.wav", + "text": "所以徵到稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1180.wav", + "text": "再強調一次徵到稅不是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1181.wav", + "text": "重點是我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1182.wav", + "text": "所以不要把徵稅當作最主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1183.wav", + "text": "的目的而忘了最根本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1184.wav", + "text": "房屋稅條例第五之一���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1185.wav", + "text": "跟第5條是有互動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1186.wav", + "text": "第5條保留我們這一條也保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1187.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1188.wav", + "text": "\n好請大家看第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1189.wav", + "text": "第6條一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1190.wav", + "text": "好再來第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1191.wav", + "text": "有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1192.wav", + "text": "是不是照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1193.wav", + "text": "\n請看第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1194.wav", + "text": "第十一條也有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1195.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有意見我們也照協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1196.wav", + "text": "的內容通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1197.wav", + "text": "有一個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1198.wav", + "text": "就是同意後來改的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1199.wav", + "text": "有一個修正動議是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1200.wav", + "text": "修正動議是不是要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1201.wav", + "text": "還是要照修正動議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1202.wav", + "text": "好那不然就照修正動議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1203.wav", + "text": "應該要放進來參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1204.wav", + "text": "好其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1205.wav", + "text": "就照審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1206.wav", + "text": "結論通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1207.wav", + "text": "\n第25條的立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1208.wav", + "text": "第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1209.wav", + "text": "是吧大家看一下最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1210.wav", + "text": "那個立法說明要調整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1211.wav", + "text": "要調整一下就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1212.wav", + "text": "那好接下來就請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1213.wav", + "text": "第二案第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1214.wav", + "text": "第二案第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1215.wav", + "text": "合併來處理併案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1216.wav", + "text": "所得稅法第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1217.wav", + "text": "的條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1218.wav", + "text": "看大家的意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1219.wav", + "text": "這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1220.wav", + "text": "其實沒有太多的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1221.wav", + "text": "只是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1222.wav", + "text": "金額的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1223.wav", + "text": "我們很多委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1224.wav", + "text": "提出的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1225.wav", + "text": "主要的目的我先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1226.wav", + "text": "跟院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1227.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1228.wav", + "text": "官員們來報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1229.wav", + "text": "就是臺灣的出生率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1230.wav", + "text": "現在越來越低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1231.wav", + "text": "去年的出生率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1232.wav", + "text": "好像只有13萬3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1233.wav", + "text": "今年可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1234.wav", + "text": "會比13萬3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1235.wav", + "text": "還要少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1236.wav", + "text": "臺灣小孩子的出生率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1237.wav", + "text": "在世界上很有名我們是排名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1238.wav", + "text": "倒數第一名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1239.wav", + "text": "全世界排名倒數第一名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1240.wav", + "text": "提這個案子的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1241.wav", + "text": "第一個當然很多人說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1242.wav", + "text": "這是個國安問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1243.wav", + "text": "提了總共有十幾個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1244.wav", + "text": "主要目的是日後可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1245.wav", + "text": "增加勞動力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1246.wav", + "text": "可以有多繳稅的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1247.wav", + "text": "否則我們臺灣人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1248.wav", + "text": "減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1249.wav", + "text": "或者是外來人口的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1250.wav", + "text": "加入我想我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1251.wav", + "text": "要多生一點臺灣的小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1252.wav", + "text": "這是主要的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1253.wav", + "text": "我們現在總共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1254.wav", + "text": "有幾個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1255.wav", + "text": "我們學前的年齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1256.wav", + "text": "從5歲到6歲這個沒有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1257.wav", + "text": "因為很多是晚生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1258.wav", + "text": "9月1號以後生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1259.wav", + "text": "這個連財政部也都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1260.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1261.wav", + "text": "個的特別扣除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1262.wav", + "text": "額目前是12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1263.wav", + "text": "部長是不是12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1264.wav", + "text": "很多委員提出來要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1265.wav", + "text": "後來我跟財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1266.wav", + "text": "我們微幅調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1267.wav", + "text": "就從12萬到15萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1268.wav", + "text": "當然財政部願意到18萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1269.wav", + "text": "我們也接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1270.wav", + "text": "啦我們在審這個案子的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1271.wav", + "text": "有些委員大概都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1272.wav", + "text": "除非我們老柯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1273.wav", + "text": "你生第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1274.wav", + "text": "你比我還有能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1275.wav", + "text": "我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1276.wav", + "text": "我回去要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1277.wav", + "text": "徵求我太太同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1278.wav", + "text": "同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1279.wav", + "text": "不排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1280.wav", + "text": "因為排富加上一百零多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1281.wav", + "text": "說實在的以臺北市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1282.wav", + "text": "年薪100萬也不算高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1283.wav", + "text": "你要考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1284.wav", + "text": "現在養孩子很貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1285.wav", + "text": "而且買房子也很貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1286.wav", + "text": "所以我們把排富拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1287.wav", + "text": "第一個孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1288.wav", + "text": "的特別扣除額是12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1289.wav", + "text": "增加到多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1290.wav", + "text": "5到6歲沒有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1291.wav", + "text": "第二個小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1292.wav", + "text": "特別扣除額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1293.wav", + "text": "是調整後增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1294.wav", + "text": "50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1295.wav", + "text": "便於財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1296.wav", + "text": "計算方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1297.wav", + "text": "再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1298.wav", + "text": "50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1299.wav", + "text": "\n事實上財政部也有拿幾年前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1300.wav", + "text": "資料試算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1301.wav", + "text": "大概在8到10億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1302.wav", + "text": "跟院長報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1303.wav", + "text": "稅損沒有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1304.wav", + "text": "當時是3年前5年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1305.wav", + "text": "那時候的小孩子出生率是比較高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1306.wav", + "text": "現在小孩子出生率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1307.wav", + "text": "是越來越少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1308.wav", + "text": "所以坊間很多人在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1309.wav", + "text": "生第二個小孩我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1310.wav", + "text": "送給你100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1311.wav", + "text": "所有委員的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1312.wav", + "text": "都是良善的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1313.wav", + "text": "希望臺灣的小孩多生一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1314.wav", + "text": "日後增加勞動力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1315.wav", + "text": "日後在他成年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1316.wav", + "text": "工作可以多繳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1317.wav", + "text": "其實長遠地看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1318.wav", + "text": "對國家絕對是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1319.wav", + "text": "好的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1320.wav", + "text": "第一個小孩的特別扣除額要從12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1321.wav", + "text": "增加到幾萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1322.wav", + "text": "第二個我們就固定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1323.wav", + "text": "第二個小孩以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1324.wav", + "text": "比第一胎小孩增加50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1325.wav", + "text": "大概是這兩個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1326.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1327.wav", + "text": "其祿比較早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1328.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1329.wav", + "text": "我這邊很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1330.wav", + "text": "因為過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1331.wav", + "text": "我們是用列舉的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1332.wav", + "text": "甚至講直白一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1333.wav", + "text": "所以這個東西一直都是看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1334.wav", + "text": "吃不到它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1335.wav", + "text": "它沒有真的所謂incentive" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1336.wav", + "text": "當然我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1337.wav", + "text": "的目標是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1338.wav", + "text": "這個誘因能真正發揮作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1339.wav", + "text": "額因為我們已經試算過非常多次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1340.wav", + "text": "那真正最好的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1341.wav", + "text": "額這樣反而是比較一步到位一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1342.wav", + "text": "也許我們在細節上有很多的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1343.wav", + "text": "但是目的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1344.wav", + "text": "我們先問這個政策最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1345.wav", + "text": "真正想要幹嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1346.wav", + "text": "如果說你真的都弄了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1347.wav", + "text": "都是很邊際的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1348.wav", + "text": "然後都看得到吃不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1349.wav", + "text": "只有一點點杯水車薪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1350.wav", + "text": "就是直接一個特別扣除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1351.wav", + "text": "額當然我們是提24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1352.wav", + "text": "他們甚至還希望是30" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1353.wav", + "text": "所以這個大家真的可以認真考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1354.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1355.wav", + "text": "其實在第十七條所得稅法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1356.wav", + "text": "跟黨團提了也是有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1357.wav", + "text": "租金扣除額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1358.wav", + "text": "那財政部這邊已經OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1359.wav", + "text": "把它放到特別扣除額了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1360.wav", + "text": "是在不同的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1361.wav", + "text": "我所知道財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1362.wav", + "text": "本來是覺得12到18" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1363.wav", + "text": "就夠了但是我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1364.wav", + "text": "版本認為是到30萬才夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1365.wav", + "text": "其實這個論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1366.wav", + "text": "我也講過很多次了之所以30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1367.wav", + "text": "是我們對房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1368.wav", + "text": "我們是說每個月1萬5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1369.wav", + "text": "就是18萬嘛但是其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1370.wav", + "text": "40%的費用之後的1萬5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1371.wav", + "text": "是完全免稅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1372.wav", + "text": "就是30萬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1373.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1374.wav", + "text": "好謝謝吳怡玎委員\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1375.wav", + "text": "就請邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1376.wav", + "text": "幼兒扣除額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1377.wav", + "text": "2012年訂出的幼兒學齡前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1378.wav", + "text": "扣除額是12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1379.wav", + "text": "那12萬你要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1380.wav", + "text": "2023年嘛2012年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1381.wav", + "text": "的時候12萬那2023年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1382.wav", + "text": "他所要承載的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1383.wav", + "text": "就翻了不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1384.wav", + "text": "幾倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1385.wav", + "text": "兩倍還不止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1386.wav", + "text": "啊所以說實在的在這種情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1387.wav", + "text": "你說2012年12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1388.wav", + "text": "那現在要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1389.wav", + "text": "喊到多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1390.wav", + "text": "才能足夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1391.wav", + "text": "公設民營托嬰中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1392.wav", + "text": "公共托育家園的月費是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1393.wav", + "text": "就8,000塊月費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1394.wav", + "text": "其他縣市基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1395.wav", + "text": "也差距不了多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1396.wav", + "text": "啦再加上生活的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1397.wav", + "text": "食物等等或者是說這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1398.wav", + "text": "已經是家庭非常沉重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1399.wav", + "text": "臺灣嬰兒的出生數目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1400.wav", + "text": "新低去年13萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1401.wav", + "text": "今年連13萬可能都還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1402.wav", + "text": "沒辦法達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1403.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1404.wav", + "text": "上限推及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1405.wav", + "text": "學齡前6歲之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1406.wav", + "text": "特別扣除額能夠到24萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1407.wav", + "text": "然後能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1408.wav", + "text": "生兒育女的壓力坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1409.wav", + "text": "養育一個孩子需要全村的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1410.wav", + "text": "其實現在也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1411.wav", + "text": "不是說他在孤立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1412.wav", + "text": "無援的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1413.wav", + "text": "顯然這已經是非常非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1414.wav", + "text": "這個家庭需要國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1415.wav", + "text": "10年前的特別扣除額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1416.wav", + "text": "額希望能夠再把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1417.wav", + "text": "往上調整到24萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1418.wav", + "text": "好謝謝\n接下來柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1419.wav", + "text": "宣布一下不然有人很急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1420.wav", + "text": "柯總召再來曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1421.wav", + "text": "再來就是陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1422.wav", + "text": "我們是希望表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1423.wav", + "text": "現在少子化的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1424.wav", + "text": "真的是非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1425.wav", + "text": "非常非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1426.wav", + "text": "所以鼓勵要生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1427.wav", + "text": "養育是很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1428.wav", + "text": "辛苦的我們要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1429.wav", + "text": "年輕人有感願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1430.wav", + "text": "生這是國安問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1431.wav", + "text": "所以在特別扣除額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1432.wav", + "text": "額的部分時力黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1433.wav", + "text": "這邊提高到24萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1434.wav", + "text": "我們希望各黨都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1435.wav", + "text": "能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1436.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1437.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1438.wav", + "text": "我剛才聽了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1439.wav", + "text": "費總召很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1440.wav", + "text": "他在財政委員會提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1441.wav", + "text": "後來隔一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1442.wav", + "text": "沈發惠委員也提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1443.wav", + "text": "租賃扣除額基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1444.wav", + "text": "這都還不到一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1445.wav", + "text": "也就是還不到表決期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1446.wav", + "text": "今天我們特別把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1447.wav", + "text": "它放最後上禮拜五把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1448.wav", + "text": "這是基本上是一個德政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1449.wav", + "text": "好的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1450.wav", + "text": "\n我剛才仔細聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1451.wav", + "text": "費總召的講法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1452.wav", + "text": "是以前是從2.5到12" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1453.wav", + "text": "第二個就double" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1454.wav", + "text": "這是一個說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1455.wav", + "text": "張其祿是24萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1456.wav", + "text": "民眾黨走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1457.wav", + "text": "吳怡玎是30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1458.wav", + "text": "這是最高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1459.wav", + "text": "邱顯智也是24萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1460.wav", + "text": "我說的是租金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1461.wav", + "text": "不是那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1462.wav", + "text": "陳椒華" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1463.wav", + "text": "第二個當然要高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1464.wav", + "text": "最後一個大家有一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1465.wav", + "text": "本來是要排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1466.wav", + "text": "現在不排富了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1467.wav", + "text": "每個縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1468.wav", + "text": "了所以這個也不要排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1469.wav", + "text": "這個我們可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1470.wav", + "text": "\n所以第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1471.wav", + "text": "我們提出來是151821" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1472.wav", + "text": "有沒有看到就是他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1473.wav", + "text": "有一個修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1474.wav", + "text": "第三個21" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1475.wav", + "text": "我們當然談一個大家可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1476.wav", + "text": "的我看費委員的講法也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1477.wav", + "text": "第一個15第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1478.wav", + "text": "就是double" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1479.wav", + "text": "也就是22.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1480.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1481.wav", + "text": "我是體諒這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1482.wav", + "text": "協商期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1483.wav", + "text": "勢必不能表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1484.wav", + "text": "現在癥結點大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1485.wav", + "text": "只有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1486.wav", + "text": "就是特別扣除額現在是12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1487.wav", + "text": "15萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1488.wav", + "text": "財政部可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1489.wav", + "text": "18萬財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1490.wav", + "text": "有點勉強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1491.wav", + "text": "可是如果到24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1492.wav", + "text": "萬他們可能會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1493.wav", + "text": "他們反對的話就會給老柯壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1494.wav", + "text": "老柯就會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1495.wav", + "text": "我建議老柯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1496.wav", + "text": "你就不要反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1497.wav", + "text": "我們把12萬調到18萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1498.wav", + "text": "你看怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1499.wav", + "text": "全部18" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1500.wav", + "text": "不是全部18第一胎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1501.wav", + "text": "那是第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1502.wav", + "text": "第一胎到18萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1503.wav", + "text": "第二胎就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1504.wav", + "text": "18萬的50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1505.wav", + "text": "第三胎也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1506.wav", + "text": "固定一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1507.wav", + "text": "第四胎也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1508.wav", + "text": "不排富稅損已經達到將近7億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1509.wav", + "text": "5分鐘以後再談好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1510.wav", + "text": "好休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1511.wav", + "text": "這個協商有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1512.wav", + "text": "我們就照這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1513.wav", + "text": "但是提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1514.wav", + "text": "文字你們就稍微修正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1515.wav", + "text": "共同提案嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1516.wav", + "text": "等一下我要問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1517.wav", + "text": "這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1518.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1519.wav", + "text": "113年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1520.wav", + "text": "歲出兩兆800" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1521.wav", + "text": "多億將近兩兆九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1522.wav", + "text": "你這稅損才多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1523.wav", + "text": "30億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1524.wav", + "text": "對呀30億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1525.wav", + "text": "不行啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1526.wav", + "text": "這個還是太低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1527.wav", + "text": "稅損才多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1528.wav", + "text": "我跟院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1529.wav", + "text": "誠懇地建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1530.wav", + "text": "因為這個案子還不能到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1531.wav", + "text": "表決的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1532.wav", + "text": "我們11月29號才送出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1533.wav", + "text": "我們希望通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1534.wav", + "text": "我沒有苛責財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1535.wav", + "text": "我雖然私下跟他們開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1536.wav", + "text": "像我在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1537.wav", + "text": "立法院財委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1538.wav", + "text": "我對企業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1539.wav", + "text": "從來不把它往下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1540.wav", + "text": "但是綜所稅我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1541.wav", + "text": "每一個人都適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1542.wav", + "text": "多繳一點我都支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1543.wav", + "text": "但是個人的部分尤其是這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1544.wav", + "text": "我剛才開柯總召的開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1545.wav", + "text": "他也不會再生了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1546.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗大概也不會再生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1547.wav", + "text": "院長大概也不會再生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1548.wav", + "text": "我也不會再生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1549.wav", + "text": "沒有你剛才不是說你不會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1550.wav", + "text": "你剛才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1551.wav", + "text": "要太太同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1552.wav", + "text": "啊那個快70歲的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1553.wav", + "text": "先聽我講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1554.wav", + "text": "我個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1555.wav", + "text": "從12萬到15萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1556.wav", + "text": "不排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1557.wav", + "text": "再加上第二胎到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1558.wav", + "text": "第三胎以後通通再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1559.wav", + "text": "第一胎的50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1560.wav", + "text": "院長跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1561.wav", + "text": "這樣稅損多少23億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1562.wav", + "text": "以全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1563.wav", + "text": "來說我們今年的稅收將近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1564.wav", + "text": "可以到3兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1565.wav", + "text": "的10%是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1566.wav", + "text": "然後再到300" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1567.wav", + "text": "再到30" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1568.wav", + "text": "跟院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1569.wav", + "text": "不到千分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1570.wav", + "text": "啦不到我們稅收的千分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1571.wav", + "text": "我們邱委員大家也都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1572.wav", + "text": "他也願意從24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1573.wav", + "text": "降到18" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1574.wav", + "text": "大概稅損是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1575.wav", + "text": "你還要配合到出生率的往下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1576.wav", + "text": "大概在30" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1577.wav", + "text": "到35億之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1578.wav", + "text": "我講的合理吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1579.wav", + "text": "1年稅損是30到35億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1580.wav", + "text": "相對我們綜所稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1581.wav", + "text": "1年現在6,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1582.wav", + "text": "算30" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1583.wav", + "text": "那才多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1584.wav", + "text": "若全國的3兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1585.wav", + "text": "老柯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1586.wav", + "text": "不到千分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1587.wav", + "text": "啦我真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1588.wav", + "text": "這個是嘉惠我們年輕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1589.wav", + "text": "婦女鼓勵她生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1590.wav", + "text": "我要跟各位報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1591.wav", + "text": "現在年輕婦女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1592.wav", + "text": "啊100個只有80個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1593.wav", + "text": "生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1594.wav", + "text": "生第二胎小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1595.wav", + "text": "很少舉例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1596.wav", + "text": "來說我剛才跟曾銘宗開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1597.wav", + "text": "30歲女生都不願意結婚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1598.wav", + "text": "何況要生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1599.wav", + "text": "因為到了週末" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1600.wav", + "text": "他的同學都在外面聚會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1601.wav", + "text": "他在家裡要帶小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1602.wav", + "text": "難道這些婦女不應該去鼓勵一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1603.wav", + "text": "我都沒有意見都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1604.wav", + "text": "我是懇切地啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1605.wav", + "text": "懇切地來談這個事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1606.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1607.wav", + "text": "大家在這裡講話都要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1608.wav", + "text": "當然啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1609.wav", + "text": "你第一次講法就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1610.wav", + "text": "到15" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1611.wav", + "text": "剛才到後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1612.wav", + "text": "結果回到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1613.wav", + "text": "我們現在講話就算數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1614.wav", + "text": "這不是我們個人的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1615.wav", + "text": "而且同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1616.wav", + "text": "我們協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1617.wav", + "text": "就是15萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1618.wav", + "text": "第三個不排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1619.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1620.wav", + "text": "我是把大家的心聲講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1621.wav", + "text": "最後取決於決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1622.wav", + "text": "我就按照當初的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1623.wav", + "text": "我沒有講你們民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1624.wav", + "text": "啦我只是講財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1625.wav", + "text": "這個案子我還要再重申一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1626.wav", + "text": "是我在上禮拜五特別把它列入討論事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1627.wav", + "text": "從來沒有一個人來跟我講這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1628.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1629.wav", + "text": "這是第一個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1630.wav", + "text": "我們讓曾銘宗講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1631.wav", + "text": "如果你們不同意就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1632.wav", + "text": "讓我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1633.wav", + "text": "我還沒有講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1634.wav", + "text": "你要瞭解這個是要報稅人才有扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1635.wav", + "text": "很多人要報稅的時候用不到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1636.wav", + "text": "所以這個有落差很不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1637.wav", + "text": "所以這個要考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1638.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1639.wav", + "text": "就是有報稅的人才用得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1640.wav", + "text": "沒有報稅的人一堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1641.wav", + "text": "這有落差不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1642.wav", + "text": "都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1643.wav", + "text": "那曾銘宗委員就不要再堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1644.wav", + "text": "我們就這樣大家共同提案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1645.wav", + "text": "然後第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1646.wav", + "text": "第二個就是因為不排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1647.wav", + "text": "所以那邊的稅損也達到將近7億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1648.wav", + "text": "今天國家不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1649.wav", + "text": "我們要講一個合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1650.wav", + "text": "邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1651.wav", + "text": "國家也不差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1652.wav", + "text": "那些但是這有一個合理的���輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1653.wav", + "text": "好你先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1654.wav", + "text": "剛剛休息前本來就輪到我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1655.wav", + "text": "啊我本來剛剛就要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1656.wav", + "text": "其實所得稅法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1657.wav", + "text": "第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1658.wav", + "text": "財委會的先進在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1659.wav", + "text": "過去都不敢修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1660.wav", + "text": "嘛為什麼不敢修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1661.wav", + "text": "就怕比照援引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1662.wav", + "text": "所得稅法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1663.wav", + "text": "第十七條的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1664.wav", + "text": "恐怕超過100案200案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1665.wav", + "text": "怕的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1666.wav", + "text": "更多怕援引比照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1667.wav", + "text": "嘛既然大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1668.wav", + "text": "已經有這共識了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1669.wav", + "text": "部裡面怕的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1670.wav", + "text": "嘛你的疑慮已經解除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1671.wav", + "text": "嘛這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1672.wav", + "text": "\n第二點就是國安問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1673.wav", + "text": "嘛既然是國安問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1674.wav", + "text": "稅損一年2030億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1675.wav", + "text": "算什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1676.wav", + "text": "真的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1677.wav", + "text": "你不要講讓我講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1678.wav", + "text": "一年歲出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1679.wav", + "text": "我的想法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1680.wav", + "text": "既然要修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1681.wav", + "text": "就讓它修得有點意義嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1682.wav", + "text": "所以我本來就是主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1683.wav", + "text": "不排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1684.wav", + "text": "但是特別扣除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1685.wav", + "text": "%假設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1686.wav", + "text": "第二胎就是再加50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1687.wav", + "text": "嘛那稅損很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1688.wav", + "text": "啦不過假設你們堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1689.wav", + "text": "但是要讓我講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1690.wav", + "text": "啦剛剛柯總召講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1691.wav", + "text": "第一胎15萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1692.wav", + "text": "第二胎增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1693.wav", + "text": "百分之五十到22.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1694.wav", + "text": "基本上我的態度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1695.wav", + "text": "含淚接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1696.wav", + "text": "啦這個說實在因為我們現在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1697.wav", + "text": "就是現在托嬰的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1698.wav", + "text": "很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1699.wav", + "text": "讓年輕的爸爸媽媽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1700.wav", + "text": "能夠體會到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1701.wav", + "text": "國家對他的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1702.wav", + "text": "這個其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1703.wav", + "text": "非常非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1704.wav", + "text": "當然這個15萬的扣除額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1705.wav", + "text": "一定是不夠的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1706.wav", + "text": "一定是不夠的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1707.wav", + "text": "所以我們版本才會是24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1708.wav", + "text": "要跟財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1709.wav", + "text": "啦因為國家財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1710.wav", + "text": "是靠誰來支撐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1711.wav", + "text": "當然是靠人來支撐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1712.wav", + "text": "是靠人為一個主體來支撐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1713.wav", + "text": "的問題這麼嚴峻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1714.wav", + "text": "就像大家講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1715.wav", + "text": "這已經是一個國安問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1716.wav", + "text": "沒有臺灣人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1717.wav", + "text": "怎麼有辦法有稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1718.wav", + "text": "去支撐這個國家的財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1719.wav", + "text": "\n我剛剛跟院長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1720.wav", + "text": "法國媒體來問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1721.wav", + "text": "在法國可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1722.wav", + "text": "一個婦女平均有2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1723.wav", + "text": "2個小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1724.wav", + "text": "那臺灣的狀況是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1725.wav", + "text": "我跟他說只有0.8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1726.wav", + "text": "他嚇了一跳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1727.wav", + "text": "在臺灣有多嚴峻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1728.wav", + "text": "世界倒數第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1729.wav", + "text": "這絕對是一個非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1730.wav", + "text": "\n所以你應該是要站在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1731.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個角度因為等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1732.wav", + "text": "我們也會討論另外一個房租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1733.wav", + "text": "扣除額的部分你應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1734.wav", + "text": "要站在這個角度就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1735.wav", + "text": "願意生小孩的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1736.wav", + "text": "你要如何去支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1737.wav", + "text": "他並且給予他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1738.wav", + "text": "應該是在這樣的一個角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1739.wav", + "text": "至於稅損我坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1740.wav", + "text": "曾委員提到這個稅損是27億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1741.wav", + "text": "這27億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1742.wav", + "text": "占了3兆裡面的不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1743.wav", + "text": "嘛所以你可以從其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1744.wav", + "text": "方面包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1745.wav", + "text": "這幾年的超徵稅額等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1746.wav", + "text": "都已經這麼多錢了你可以從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1747.wav", + "text": "其他方面去著手但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1748.wav", + "text": "如何能夠讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1749.wav", + "text": "這些新手爸爸媽媽得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1750.wav", + "text": "才是最重要的今年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1751.wav", + "text": "稅收超徵上看3,800億耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1752.wav", + "text": "你這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1753.wav", + "text": "稅損才27億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1754.wav", + "text": "好謝謝\n請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1755.wav", + "text": "陳委員講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1756.wav", + "text": "我們就做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1757.wav", + "text": "因為我身為職業婦女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1758.wav", + "text": "生兒育女要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1759.wav", + "text": "照顧家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1760.wav", + "text": "還要做家事坦白說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1761.wav", + "text": "是很辛苦啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1762.wav", + "text": "所以今天我們要鼓勵職業婦女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1763.wav", + "text": "而且快樂的生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1764.wav", + "text": "我們給他一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1765.wav", + "text": "這樣子的特別扣除額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1766.wav", + "text": "我覺得真的是很好的立意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1767.wav", + "text": "坦白講真的非常有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1768.wav", + "text": "支持的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1769.wav", + "text": "把它納進來討論不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1770.wav", + "text": "至少提高到18" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1771.wav", + "text": "我們也希望財政部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1772.wav", + "text": "頂多就是27億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1773.wav", + "text": "以下嘛所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1774.wav", + "text": "如果做得到的話我還是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1775.wav", + "text": "能夠通過第一胎18" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1776.wav", + "text": "因為我們剛才有初步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1777.wav", + "text": "的共識還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1778.wav", + "text": "\n請柯總召講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1779.wav", + "text": "已經有初步的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1780.wav", + "text": "就照這樣來做是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1781.wav", + "text": "我要講一件事情就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1782.wav", + "text": "在這裡大家都很會講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1783.wav", + "text": "這國安問題怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1784.wav", + "text": "但是在今天以前哪一個委員跟我講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1785.wav", + "text": "這個案子要排進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1786.wav", + "text": "我上禮拜五早上特別6點鐘就去提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1787.wav", + "text": "只有本黨提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1788.wav", + "text": "時代力量有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1789.wav", + "text": "時力有排啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1790.wav", + "text": "我們有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1791.wav", + "text": "但是能不能排是你的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1792.wav", + "text": "我們又沒辦法排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1793.wav", + "text": "好了就初步的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1794.wav", + "text": "我們有提我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1795.wav", + "text": "每個禮拜五都是6點鐘就去排案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1796.wav", + "text": "沒有人有這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1797.wav", + "text": "只有我們談既然這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1798.wav", + "text": "我們要談道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1799.wav", + "text": "又說我們怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1800.wav", + "text": "大家用共識來處理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1801.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1802.wav", + "text": "第二案就照這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1803.wav", + "text": "第三案的部分是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1804.wav", + "text": "就是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1805.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1806.wav", + "text": "租金也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1807.wav", + "text": "也是要用共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1808.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1809.wav", + "text": "租金支出的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1810.wav", + "text": "現在財政部是有答應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1811.wav", + "text": "從列舉扣除額把它改列為特別扣除額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1812.wav", + "text": "每一年每戶1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1813.wav", + "text": "其實是太少啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1814.wav", + "text": "因為以臺北市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1815.wav", + "text": "租金的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1816.wav", + "text": "大概就2萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1817.wav", + "text": "嘛平均租在2萬左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1818.wav", + "text": "所以我是建議提高到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1819.wav", + "text": "24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1820.wav", + "text": "其實這個跟剛剛那個脈絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1821.wav", + "text": "也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1822.wav", + "text": "如果能夠給予年輕世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1823.wav", + "text": "其實根據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1824.wav", + "text": "主計總處2020年的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1825.wav", + "text": "全臺家戶平均月租金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1826.wav", + "text": "也是比較低估的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1827.wav", + "text": "因為光是2020年第2期社會住宅包租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1828.wav", + "text": "代管的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1829.wav", + "text": "臺北市的平均月租差不多2萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1830.wav", + "text": "你可以看到光是這兩個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1831.wav", + "text": "都是看到租金的底線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1832.wav", + "text": "大概是落在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1833.wav", + "text": "像前幾年大安區的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1834.wav", + "text": "8坪獨立套房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1835.wav", + "text": "如果再比對現在網路上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1836.wav", + "text": "出租的資料現在租金大約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1837.wav", + "text": "所以從房價漲到租金漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1838.wav", + "text": "的這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1839.wav", + "text": "整個六都2023年上半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1840.wav", + "text": "的住宅平均租金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1841.wav", + "text": "如果你用20坪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1842.wav", + "text": "是3萬2桃園市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1843.wav", + "text": "也大概在1萬4左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1844.wav", + "text": "所以就這部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1845.wav", + "text": "租金的下限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1846.wav", + "text": "是一直往上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1847.wav", + "text": "包含民間團體例如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1848.wav", + "text": "崔媽媽基金會都有表示過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1849.wav", + "text": "租金應該是由列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1850.wav", + "text": "列舉扣除額改為特別扣除額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1851.wav", + "text": "也應該要調高到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1852.wav", + "text": "這跟時力的提案版本是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1853.wav", + "text": "\n就這個部分的話我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1854.wav", + "text": "能夠去做相應的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1855.wav", + "text": "給予民眾一個長期穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1856.wav", + "text": "財政部也常常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1857.wav", + "text": "講說免繳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1858.wav", + "text": "大概有305萬戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1859.wav", + "text": "所以租稅優惠的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1860.wav", + "text": "對多數的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1861.wav", + "text": "民眾不會有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1862.wav", + "text": "我們認為這個邏輯不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1863.wav", + "text": "租稅優惠的出發點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1864.wav", + "text": "就是要去幫助那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1865.wav", + "text": "有需要幫助的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1866.wav", + "text": "包括這些比較弱勢的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1867.wav", + "text": "所以就這個部分的話我們是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1868.wav", + "text": "能夠給予這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1869.wav", + "text": "有更多租稅上面的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1870.wav", + "text": "謝謝不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1871.wav", + "text": "我再說一次剛剛其實也有說過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1872.wav", + "text": "就是我還是希望1個月是2萬5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1873.wav", + "text": "5理由我也說過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1874.wav", + "text": "因為是2萬5裡面40%的免稅額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1875.wav", + "text": "才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1876.wav", + "text": "5每個月2萬5的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1877.wav", + "text": "等於是1年30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1878.wav", + "text": "其實既然我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1879.wav", + "text": "也是一樣不能表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1880.wav", + "text": "今天在這邊一定要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1881.wav", + "text": "那我是希望調越接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1882.wav", + "text": "30萬當然是越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1883.wav", + "text": "也是希望這樣子的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1884.wav", + "text": "再來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1885.wav", + "text": "這其實是政府的一個表態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1886.wav", + "text": "你到底是不是對於房東比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1887.wav", + "text": "對房客比較苛刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1888.wav", + "text": "還是你其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1889.wav", + "text": "都要幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1890.wav", + "text": "就是讓居住正義實現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1891.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1892.wav", + "text": "這個案子我還是要重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1893.wav", + "text": "費鴻泰委員排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1894.wav", + "text": "我很注意到這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1895.wav", + "text": "大家有一個共識來通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1896.wav", + "text": "所以今天早上來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1897.wav", + "text": "我就特別談這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1898.wav", + "text": "上禮拜也去跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1899.wav", + "text": "曾總召談過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1900.wav", + "text": "了除此之外都是我主動在拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1901.wav", + "text": "大家現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1902.wav", + "text": "大家專心起來都很會講道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1903.wav", + "text": "什麼崔媽媽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1904.wav", + "text": "啦我們要講一個道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1905.wav", + "text": "假如說我們現在有300萬戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1906.wav", + "text": "是不必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1907.wav", + "text": "根本用不上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1908.wav", + "text": "弱勢所謂的年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1909.wav", + "text": "根本用不上這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1910.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1911.wav", + "text": "內政部還有另外的措施就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1912.wav", + "text": "租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1913.wav", + "text": "所以18萬這樣加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1914.wav", + "text": "已經到二萬多塊了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1915.wav", + "text": "這不是用在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1916.wav", + "text": "我們到底用在什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1917.wav", + "text": "當然要很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1918.wav", + "text": "因此我們要把立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1919.wav", + "text": "邏輯和我們整個要嘉惠哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1920.wav", + "text": "我希望大家有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1921.wav", + "text": "不要再互相抹黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1922.wav", + "text": "我右手邊的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1923.wav", + "text": "現在在談的應該是你扣除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1924.wav", + "text": "額到底要多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1925.wav", + "text": "要講清楚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1926.wav", + "text": "我們講18萬嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1927.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1928.wav", + "text": "這樣子的補貼政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1929.wav", + "text": "只是一個短期的預算補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1930.wav", + "text": "政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1931.wav", + "text": "我們希望還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1932.wav", + "text": "朝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1933.wav", + "text": "來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1934.wav", + "text": "啦所以今天的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1935.wav", + "text": "就是為了能有一個比較長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1936.wav", + "text": "明確的居住賦稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1937.wav", + "text": "措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1938.wav", + "text": "讓民眾有長期穩定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1939.wav", + "text": "租屋條件跟能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1940.wav", + "text": "所以也希望能夠朝時力黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1941.wav", + "text": "提出這樣子的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1942.wav", + "text": "內容來通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1943.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1944.wav", + "text": "院長各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1945.wav", + "text": "我在財委會19年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1946.wav", + "text": "我很少對富人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1947.wav", + "text": "去減稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1948.wav", + "text": "基本上是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1949.wav", + "text": "所以對關稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1950.wav", + "text": "你看我從來不碰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1951.wav", + "text": "因為老柯在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1952.wav", + "text": "的我們曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1953.wav", + "text": "當過財政部的次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1954.wav", + "text": "當過金管會的主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1955.wav", + "text": "我們會考慮到我們的財政紀律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1956.wav", + "text": "這個任期的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1957.wav", + "text": "最後一天不是這個會期是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1958.wav", + "text": "這個任期的最後一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1959.wav", + "text": "這個會期當召委也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1960.wav", + "text": "很多人拜託還有所得稅法第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1961.wav", + "text": "還有很多案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1962.wav", + "text": "我都不碰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1963.wav", + "text": "有些案子確實對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1964.wav", + "text": "會有好處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1965.wav", + "text": "我之所以提到這兩個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1966.wav", + "text": "願意拿出來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1967.wav", + "text": "對有錢人來講他根本不在意這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1968.wav", + "text": "啦有錢人不在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1969.wav", + "text": "生小孩啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1970.wav", + "text": "你跟有錢人說鼓勵生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1971.wav", + "text": "生第二胎給1億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1972.wav", + "text": "他不會care這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1973.wav", + "text": "但這確實是一個國安問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1974.wav", + "text": "\n第二件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1975.wav", + "text": "我們在最後一天來談這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1976.wav", + "text": "這個任期沒有其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1977.wav", + "text": "所以所得稅法第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1978.wav", + "text": "就不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1979.wav", + "text": "啦對政府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1980.wav", + "text": "稅損不會有什麼影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1981.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1982.wav", + "text": "如果今天不處理是無法表決的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1983.wav", + "text": "因為它在協商期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1984.wav", + "text": "基本上還是要對柯建銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1985.wav", + "text": "高度肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1986.wav", + "text": "肯定就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1987.wav", + "text": "了不需要高度肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1988.wav", + "text": "在早上6點鐘就把它排到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1989.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1990.wav", + "text": "費很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1991.wav", + "text": "108年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1992.wav", + "text": "然後再朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1993.wav", + "text": "你還為了這個事情暴怒叫我道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1994.wav", + "text": "我說沒有辦法不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1995.wav", + "text": "啊八十幾案要怎麼協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1996.wav", + "text": "我們今天這個在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1997.wav", + "text": "最後給大家一個圓滿的句號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1998.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/1999.wav", + "text": "院長補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2000.wav", + "text": "這個是福國利民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2001.wav", + "text": "照顧中低收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2002.wav", + "text": "這個真的是覺得我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2003.wav", + "text": "再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2004.wav", + "text": "對不對18萬的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2005.wav", + "text": "元剛剛其實有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2006.wav", + "text": "現在已經2023年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2007.wav", + "text": "第2期社會住宅包租代管計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2008.wav", + "text": "它的平均月租金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2009.wav", + "text": "是2萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2010.wav", + "text": "一定是遠低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2011.wav", + "text": "現在的租金行情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2012.wav", + "text": "所以才會想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2013.wav", + "text": "是不是再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2014.wav", + "text": "商榷一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2015.wav", + "text": "比起過去來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2016.wav", + "text": "當然是提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2017.wav", + "text": "如果你用2萬元算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2018.wav", + "text": "1年也是24萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2019.wav", + "text": "可以商榷一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2020.wav", + "text": "不足好就這好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2021.wav", + "text": "那不然就共同提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2022.wav", + "text": "啦我唸一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2023.wav", + "text": "今天的協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2024.wav", + "text": "好我唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2025.wav", + "text": "第一案部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2026.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2027.wav", + "text": "一第9條第十一條條文及第二十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2028.wav", + "text": "立法說明如後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2029.wav", + "text": "附協商內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2030.wav", + "text": "\n二第5條時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2031.wav", + "text": "黨團提案增訂第5條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2032.wav", + "text": "第6條保留送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2033.wav", + "text": "院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2034.wav", + "text": "\n三其餘均照審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2035.wav", + "text": "會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2036.wav", + "text": "協商通過部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2037.wav", + "text": "宣讀後均予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2038.wav", + "text": "保留部分均暫保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2039.wav", + "text": "保留部分院會進行處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2040.wav", + "text": "由各黨團推派1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2041.wav", + "text": "依時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2042.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2043.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2044.wav", + "text": "順序輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2045.wav", + "text": "每人發言時間為3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2046.wav", + "text": "發言完畢後各該保留條文均不再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2047.wav", + "text": "並依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2048.wav", + "text": "上開黨團順序進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2049.wav", + "text": "\n再來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2050.wav", + "text": "第二案跟第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2051.wav", + "text": "印來看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2052.wav", + "text": "要提案吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2053.wav", + "text": "要提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2054.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2055.wav", + "text": "第二案第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2056.wav", + "text": "上述兩案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2057.wav", + "text": "院會併案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2058.wav", + "text": "第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2059.wav", + "text": "照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2060.wav", + "text": "你們就共同提案出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2061.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2062.wav", + "text": "啦我會把版本備妥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2063.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2064.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2065.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2066.wav", + "text": "一方面在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2067.wav", + "text": "溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2068.wav", + "text": "另一方面我這邊有三個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2069.wav", + "text": "宣布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2070.wav", + "text": "第一個案是外交及國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2071.wav", + "text": "第126��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2072.wav", + "text": "文字就修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2073.wav", + "text": "修正如附" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2074.wav", + "text": "件通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2075.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分是有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2076.wav", + "text": "經濟的第111案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2077.wav", + "text": "他們有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2078.wav", + "text": "就是主決議再做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2079.wav", + "text": "修正之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2080.wav", + "text": "\n第三個是內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2081.wav", + "text": "有關於主決議就做這樣的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2082.wav", + "text": "修正如本表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2083.wav", + "text": "第四個部分就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2084.wav", + "text": "賴士葆委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2085.wav", + "text": "100101104" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2086.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2087.wav", + "text": "請高等法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2088.wav", + "text": "繼續跟民民眾溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2089.wav", + "text": "除了這個以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2090.wav", + "text": "已經協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2091.wav", + "text": "刪除的部分也撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2092.wav", + "text": "今天的朝野黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2093.wav", + "text": "到此告一段落散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15359/2094.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/0.wav", + "text": "各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1.wav", + "text": "今天的立法院黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2.wav", + "text": "會議開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3.wav", + "text": "今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4.wav", + "text": "研商的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/5.wav", + "text": "就是繼續研商中華民國113年度中央政府總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/6.wav", + "text": "(公務預算部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/7.wav", + "text": "今天有幾位首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/8.wav", + "text": "因為另有要公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/9.wav", + "text": "所以特別有事先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/10.wav", + "text": "來請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/11.wav", + "text": "首先報告總統府秘書長林佳龍先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/12.wav", + "text": "環境部部長今天也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/13.wav", + "text": "所以等到輪到他的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/14.wav", + "text": "第三個就是邱國正部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/15.wav", + "text": "每個禮拜四他都會跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/16.wav", + "text": "\n就是安排另外的公務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/17.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/18.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法來以上有請假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/19.wav", + "text": "我先跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/20.wav", + "text": "就是總統府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/21.wav", + "text": "的預算現在是不是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/22.wav", + "text": "提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/23.wav", + "text": "林佳龍秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/24.wav", + "text": "是什麼公務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/25.wav", + "text": "去輔選嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/26.wav", + "text": "可不可以講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/27.wav", + "text": "另外環境部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/28.wav", + "text": "不來就是不審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/29.wav", + "text": "他去哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/30.wav", + "text": "那就下午呀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/31.wav", + "text": "沒關係那就跳過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/32.wav", + "text": "他是在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/33.wav", + "text": "沒關係那就下午等他嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/34.wav", + "text": "沒有那回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/35.wav", + "text": "就等他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/36.wav", + "text": "不然就先跳過或等明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/37.wav", + "text": "衛環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/38.wav", + "text": "衛環歸衛環嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/39.wav", + "text": "我這邊時代力量也同意啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/40.wav", + "text": "沒有那回事啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/41.wav", + "text": "講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/42.wav", + "text": "不然就由副秘書長來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/43.wav", + "text": "跟曾總召報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/44.wav", + "text": "林秘書長應該有其他的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/45.wav", + "text": "但絕對不是輔選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/46.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/47.wav", + "text": "好吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/48.wav", + "text": "那你看吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/49.wav", + "text": "我還是希望他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/50.wav", + "text": "我還是希望他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/51.wav", + "text": "沒有比在立法院尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/52.wav", + "text": "游院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/53.wav", + "text": "好吧跳過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/54.wav", + "text": "總統府跳過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/55.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/56.wav", + "text": "不尊重你耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/57.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/58.wav", + "text": "他不尊重你耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/59.wav", + "text": "院長我發言一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/60.wav", + "text": "有關環境部的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/61.wav", + "text": "確實是在衛環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/62.wav", + "text": "今天早上是專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/63.wav", + "text": "不是我們來溝通一下啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/64.wav", + "text": "就是請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/65.wav", + "text": "來溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/66.wav", + "text": "至於那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/67.wav", + "text": "看他的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/68.wav", + "text": "啦因為他第一次當部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/69.wav", + "text": "衛環委員會或是這邊審預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/70.wav", + "text": "當部長也不短了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/71.wav", + "text": "第一次當部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/72.wav", + "text": "第一次審預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/73.wav", + "text": "第一次審中央政府總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/74.wav", + "text": "他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/75.wav", + "text": "總召我們來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/76.wav", + "text": "我們來處理這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/77.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/78.wav", + "text": "我覺得是不是尊重總統府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/79.wav", + "text": "啦因為他們不會直接告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/80.wav", + "text": "是什麼重要會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/81.wav", + "text": "他是用消去法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/82.wav", + "text": "跟政黨選舉的會議啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/83.wav", + "text": "那就延後吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/84.wav", + "text": "等他開完會因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/85.wav", + "text": "他只有5個案啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/86.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/87.wav", + "text": "那就下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/88.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/89.wav", + "text": "就等他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/90.wav", + "text": "總召再稍微商量一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/91.wav", + "text": "我不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/92.wav", + "text": "我們再來稍微溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/93.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/94.wav", + "text": "請院長來裁示一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/95.wav", + "text": "等他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/96.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/97.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/98.wav", + "text": "最好還是到啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/99.wav", + "text": "他不尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/100.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/101.wav", + "text": "他不尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/102.wav", + "text": "朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/103.wav", + "text": "4個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/104.wav", + "text": "公務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/105.wav", + "text": "沒關係等他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/106.wav", + "text": "那就明天嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/107.wav", + "text": "那明天好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/108.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/109.wav", + "text": "那就明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/110.wav", + "text": "等他有空再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/111.wav", + "text": "希望今天早上所有的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/112.wav", + "text": "都能夠完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/113.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/114.wav", + "text": "其實朝野的氣氛很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/115.wav", + "text": "不要因為兩個不來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/116.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/117.wav", + "text": "這個最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/118.wav", + "text": "預算要結束啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/119.wav", + "text": "不來沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/120.wav", + "text": "我們等他明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/121.wav", + "text": "禮拜六也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/122.wav", + "text": "禮拜天也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/123.wav", + "text": "今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/124.wav", + "text": "就剩下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/125.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/126.wav", + "text": "社會福利及衛生環境委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/127.wav", + "text": "這2個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/128.wav", + "text": "加起來差不多有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/129.wav", + "text": "480案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/130.wav", + "text": "今天早上就能夠完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/131.wav", + "text": "結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/132.wav", + "text": "就會讓各部會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/133.wav", + "text": "就是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/134.wav", + "text": "努力希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/135.wav", + "text": "能夠在今天中午之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/136.wav", + "text": "你講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/137.wav", + "text": "的說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/138.wav", + "text": "你們去商量一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/139.wav", + "text": "總統府秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/140.wav", + "text": "氣氛這麼好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/141.wav", + "text": "不然等下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/142.wav", + "text": "等他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/143.wav", + "text": "我很堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/144.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/145.wav", + "text": "我要去休息啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/146.wav", + "text": "院長休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/147.wav", + "text": "我們要走囉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/148.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/149.wav", + "text": "先跳過嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/150.wav", + "text": "審其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/151.wav", + "text": "啊這麼簡單的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/152.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/153.wav", + "text": "答應人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/154.wav", + "text": "請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/155.wav", + "text": "其他的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/156.wav", + "text": "在等我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/157.wav", + "text": "先處理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/158.wav", + "text": "小事變大事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/159.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/160.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/161.wav", + "text": "今天是環境部先開始嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/162.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/163.wav", + "text": "今天是總統府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/164.wav", + "text": "喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/165.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/166.wav", + "text": "老柯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/167.wav", + "text": "你腦筋算清楚啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/168.wav", + "text": "我先瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/169.wav", + "text": "況很混亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/170.wav", + "text": "我報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/171.wav", + "text": "我剛才已經報告過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/172.wav", + "text": "今天有3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/173.wav", + "text": "人請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/174.wav", + "text": "第一個就是總統府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/175.wav", + "text": "他有正式來函" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/176.wav", + "text": "函請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/177.wav", + "text": "就是秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/178.wav", + "text": "因為有公務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/179.wav", + "text": "第二個就是環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/180.wav", + "text": "因為委員會開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/181.wav", + "text": "他去委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/182.wav", + "text": "第三個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/183.wav", + "text": "邱國正部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/184.wav", + "text": "因為他另有要公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/185.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/186.wav", + "text": "午第二輪的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/187.wav", + "text": "他3個案沒有辦法來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/188.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/189.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/190.wav", + "text": "總統府秘書長請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/191.wav", + "text": "各位怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/192.wav", + "text": "跳過吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/193.wav", + "text": "跳過啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/194.wav", + "text": "或者明天後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/195.wav", + "text": "我會等他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/196.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/197.wav", + "text": "不要講悄悄話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/198.wav", + "text": "你就公開講嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/199.wav", + "text": "原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/200.wav", + "text": "原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/201.wav", + "text": "就我沒有原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/202.wav", + "text": "我就等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/203.wav", + "text": "下午明天後天等他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/204.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/205.wav", + "text": "好了假如還沒到的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/206.wav", + "text": "等他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/207.wav", + "text": "一下去通知這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/208.wav", + "text": "開會就要停起來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/209.wav", + "text": "不用停起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/210.wav", + "text": "再重要的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/211.wav", + "text": "這裡最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/212.wav", + "text": "明天也可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/213.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/214.wav", + "text": "一樣一樣來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/215.wav", + "text": "今天是專案報告嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/216.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/217.wav", + "text": "現在還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/218.wav", + "text": "專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/219.wav", + "text": "選副總統還在搞這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/220.wav", + "text": "沒關係等到委員會結束再過來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/221.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/222.wav", + "text": "為了順利進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/223.wav", + "text": "先啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/224.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/225.wav", + "text": "什麼召委同意不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/226.wav", + "text": "我來處理啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/227.wav", + "text": "還要再二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/228.wav", + "text": "還有很繁雜的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/229.wav", + "text": "一定要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/230.wav", + "text": "總預算比什麼都重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/231.wav", + "text": "立法院的專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/232.wav", + "text": "時間到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/233.wav", + "text": "了環境部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/234.wav", + "text": "部長就要來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/235.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/236.wav", + "text": "等一下跟吳欣盈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/237.wav", + "text": "溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/238.wav", + "text": "我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/239.wav", + "text": "叫去專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/240.wav", + "text": "了比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/241.wav", + "text": "所以等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/242.wav", + "text": "輪到環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/243.wav", + "text": "部長一定要過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/244.wav", + "text": "到環境部就請他過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/245.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/246.wav", + "text": "總統還在搞這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/247.wav", + "text": "這是院會耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/248.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/249.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/250.wav", + "text": "讓總統府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/251.wav", + "text": "來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/252.wav", + "text": "跟院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/253.wav", + "text": "及3個黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/254.wav", + "text": "總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/255.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/256.wav", + "text": "我剛剛已經聯絡上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/257.wav", + "text": "我剛剛已經聯絡上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/258.wav", + "text": "佳龍秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/259.wav", + "text": "他現在總統府內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/260.wav", + "text": "馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/261.wav", + "text": "過來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/262.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/263.wav", + "text": "他現在馬上要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/264.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/265.wav", + "text": "還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/266.wav", + "text": "後面先開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/267.wav", + "text": "他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/268.wav", + "text": "他到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/269.wav", + "text": "我們就馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/270.wav", + "text": "來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/271.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/272.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/273.wav", + "text": "副秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/274.wav", + "text": "就麻煩你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/275.wav", + "text": "請國史館館長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/276.wav", + "text": "先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/277.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/278.wav", + "text": "副秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/279.wav", + "text": "沒有委屈一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/280.wav", + "text": "你不要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/281.wav", + "text": "啦這是立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/282.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/283.wav", + "text": "立法院沒有這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/284.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/285.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/286.wav", + "text": "什麼叫他委屈一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/287.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/288.wav", + "text": "你的糾正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/289.wav", + "text": "一下叫他要道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/290.wav", + "text": "那現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/291.wav", + "text": "我們就先進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/292.wav", + "text": "國史館主管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/293.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/294.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/295.wav", + "text": "國史館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/296.wav", + "text": "館長陳儀深先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/297.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/298.wav", + "text": "第6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/299.wav", + "text": "第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/300.wav", + "text": "屬於通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/301.wav", + "text": "就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/302.wav", + "text": "通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/303.wav", + "text": "通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/304.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/305.wav", + "text": "照慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/306.wav", + "text": "我們就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/307.wav", + "text": "總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/308.wav", + "text": "快點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/309.wav", + "text": "同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/310.wav", + "text": "第6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/311.wav", + "text": "通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/312.wav", + "text": "通刪就通刪啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/313.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/314.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/315.wav", + "text": "通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/316.wav", + "text": "所以我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/317.wav", + "text": "通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/318.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/319.wav", + "text": "那就謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/320.wav", + "text": "這樣就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/321.wav", + "text": "讓館長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/322.wav", + "text": "離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/323.wav", + "text": "國史館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/324.wav", + "text": "館長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/325.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/326.wav", + "text": "那就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/327.wav", + "text": "謝謝館長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/328.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/329.wav", + "text": "行政院人事行政總處主管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/330.wav", + "text": "我就介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/331.wav", + "text": "列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/332.wav", + "text": "行政院人事行政總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/333.wav", + "text": "蘇俊榮先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/334.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/335.wav", + "text": "就請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/336.wav", + "text": "第7案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/337.wav", + "text": "第7案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/338.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/339.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/340.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/341.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/342.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/343.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/344.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/345.wav", + "text": "讚聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/346.wav", + "text": "都是通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/347.wav", + "text": "我們通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/348.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/349.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/350.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/351.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/352.wav", + "text": "\n第12案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/353.wav", + "text": "國棟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/354.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/355.wav", + "text": "改凍結30萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/356.wav", + "text": "書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/357.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/358.wav", + "text": "改凍結30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/359.wav", + "text": "書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/360.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/361.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/362.wav", + "text": "決議凍結數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/363.wav", + "text": "書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/364.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/365.wav", + "text": "改凍第2目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/366.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/367.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/368.wav", + "text": "我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/369.wav", + "text": "來講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/370.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/371.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/372.wav", + "text": "沒有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/373.wav", + "text": "請問我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/374.wav", + "text": "人事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/375.wav", + "text": "水源區巡守這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/376.wav", + "text": "人總現在有通過那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/377.wav", + "text": "人力的部分嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/378.wav", + "text": "水源區巡守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/379.wav", + "text": "水利署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/380.wav", + "text": "它已經報過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/381.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/382.wav", + "text": "這個非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/383.wav", + "text": "今天再問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/384.wav", + "text": "增員需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/385.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/386.wav", + "text": "就改凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/387.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/388.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/389.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/390.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/391.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/392.wav", + "text": "邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/393.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/394.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/395.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/396.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/397.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/398.wav", + "text": "凍結40萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/399.wav", + "text": "民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/400.wav", + "text": "這有改嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/401.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/402.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/403.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/404.wav", + "text": "了拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/405.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/406.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/407.wav", + "text": "改主決議好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/408.wav", + "text": "改主決議比較好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/409.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/410.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/411.wav", + "text": "通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/412.wav", + "text": "我們就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/413.wav", + "text": "凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/414.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/415.wav", + "text": "有意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/416.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/417.wav", + "text": "嗎改主決議好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/418.wav", + "text": "比較實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/419.wav", + "text": "沒關係啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/420.wav", + "text": "不要再改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/421.wav", + "text": "就照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/422.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/423.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/424.wav", + "text": "改刪20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/425.wav", + "text": "改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/426.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/427.wav", + "text": "通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/428.wav", + "text": "凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/429.wav", + "text": "改主決議好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/430.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/431.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/432.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/433.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/434.wav", + "text": "第30案遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/435.wav", + "text": "專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/436.wav", + "text": "改書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/437.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/438.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/439.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/440.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/441.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/442.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/443.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/444.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/445.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/446.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/447.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/448.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/449.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/450.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/451.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/452.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/453.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/454.wav", + "text": "那就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/455.wav", + "text": "那就謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/456.wav", + "text": "第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/457.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/458.wav", + "text": "立法院主管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/459.wav", + "text": "列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/460.wav", + "text": "立法院秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/461.wav", + "text": "林志嘉先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/462.wav", + "text": "大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/463.wav", + "text": "請大家看第38案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/464.wav", + "text": "第38案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/465.wav", + "text": "第39案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/466.wav", + "text": "第40案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/467.wav", + "text": "\n第42案改凍結500萬元專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/468.wav", + "text": "改書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/469.wav", + "text": "報告院長我一定要再一次強烈表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/470.wav", + "text": "因為我們的語言發展法已經通過一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/471.wav", + "text": "對於原住民相關語言的推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/472.wav", + "text": "大家都很努力我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/473.wav", + "text": "但我們還是覺得政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/474.wav", + "text": "應該可以做得更快更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/475.wav", + "text": "尤其在立法院院長在臺上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/476.wav", + "text": "我每一次都儘量利用機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/477.wav", + "text": "用母語不管是國是論壇也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/478.wav", + "text": "或者是一般法案討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/479.wav", + "text": "希望能夠把母語重建起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/480.wav", + "text": "但是我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/481.wav", + "text": "議事處這幾年進步非常非常的緩慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/482.wav", + "text": "導致我們所期待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/483.wav", + "text": "並沒有如期在這個會期能夠進入狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/484.wav", + "text": "當然沒有人就沒有經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/485.wav", + "text": "顯然被延滯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/486.wav", + "text": "我同意改凍結第42案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/487.wav", + "text": "凍結500萬元提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/488.wav", + "text": "等一下他似乎要回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/489.wav", + "text": "同意凍結500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/490.wav", + "text": "00要翻譯原住民語言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/491.wav", + "text": "所以要翻譯不是那麼容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/492.wav", + "text": "原住民語言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/493.wav", + "text": "還需要很多加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/494.wav", + "text": "我們會儘量努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/495.wav", + "text": "主計總處多要一點錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/496.wav", + "text": "我們會再努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/497.wav", + "text": "同意凍結500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/498.wav", + "text": "書面報告就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/499.wav", + "text": "第42案凍結500萬元提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/500.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/501.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/502.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/503.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/504.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/505.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/506.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/507.wav", + "text": "做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/508.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/509.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/510.wav", + "text": "建請文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/511.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/512.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/513.wav", + "text": "這是朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/514.wav", + "text": "預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/515.wav", + "text": "由院長主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/516.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/517.wav", + "text": "這是對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/518.wav", + "text": "立法院最基本的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/519.wav", + "text": "一下不到5分鐘就到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/520.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/521.wav", + "text": "請教秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/522.wav", + "text": "賴副總統現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/523.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/524.wav", + "text": "民進黨總統候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/525.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/526.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/527.wav", + "text": "他都搭專機在輔選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/528.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/529.wav", + "text": "有依照規定辦理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/530.wav", + "text": "有依照規定辦理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/531.wav", + "text": "那表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/532.wav", + "text": "有一些是不依照規定辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/533.wav", + "text": "就是要依照規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/534.wav", + "text": "因為這個都有公務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/535.wav", + "text": "的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/536.wav", + "text": "及相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/537.wav", + "text": "會不會假借" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/538.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/539.wav", + "text": "嘛一定是要按照規定來辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/540.wav", + "text": "不一定喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/541.wav", + "text": "搭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/542.wav", + "text": "主計長我又沒問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/543.wav", + "text": "你在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/544.wav", + "text": "打pass" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/545.wav", + "text": "等一下請你出去喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/546.wav", + "text": "你放心啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/547.wav", + "text": "秘書長很有經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/548.wav", + "text": "你不用跟他打pass啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/549.wav", + "text": "不然你先離座一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/550.wav", + "text": "秘書長到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/551.wav", + "text": "賴副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/552.wav", + "text": "搭專機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/553.wav", + "text": "付帳多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/554.wav", + "text": "可不可以講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/555.wav", + "text": "今天審查預算要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/556.wav", + "text": "因為我手頭上沒有這個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/557.wav", + "text": "報告曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/558.wav", + "text": "這個一向是由國防部在做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/559.wav", + "text": "回去我們查一下再跟總召報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/560.wav", + "text": "要多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/561.wav", + "text": "總召我報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/562.wav", + "text": "相關的錢都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/563.wav", + "text": "不是總統府付的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/564.wav", + "text": "今天下班前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/565.wav", + "text": "提供給立法院可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/566.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/567.wav", + "text": "當然不是總統府付的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/568.wav", + "text": "總統府怎麼能付這個錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/569.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/570.wav", + "text": "所以今天下班前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/571.wav", + "text": "應該可以提供給大院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/572.wav", + "text": "跟以前一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/573.wav", + "text": "你有沒有看過資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/574.wav", + "text": "他有給你沒給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/575.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/576.wav", + "text": "下班前給我們資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/577.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/578.wav", + "text": "好謝謝總統府林秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/579.wav", + "text": "接下來環境部有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/580.wav", + "text": "好那我們就進行司法院的部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/581.wav", + "text": "現在開始進行司法院主管部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/582.wav", + "text": "是司法院秘書長吳三龍先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/583.wav", + "text": "院長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/584.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/585.wav", + "text": "接下來就請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/586.wav", + "text": "第57案改主決議有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/587.wav", + "text": "有一點小意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/588.wav", + "text": "小意見好來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/589.wav", + "text": "我還是要跟秘書長再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/590.wav", + "text": "秘書長應該記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/591.wav", + "text": "我有跟你質詢過土地的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/592.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/593.wav", + "text": "後來監察院的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/594.wav", + "text": "跟我這邊討論那個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/595.wav", + "text": "的確是監察院有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/596.wav", + "text": "我為什麼還是要跟秘書長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/597.wav", + "text": "就是因為我們司法的判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/598.wav", + "text": "都是參考行政機關跟監察機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/599.wav", + "text": "他們如果犯錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/600.wav", + "text": "就會冤枉了當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/601.wav", + "text": "所以還是拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/602.wav", + "text": "司法院這個部分一定要務必明察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/603.wav", + "text": "不要變成司法烏龍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/604.wav", + "text": "這樣好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/605.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/606.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/607.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/608.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/609.wav", + "text": "從蔡政府執政以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/610.wav", + "text": "對於司法院的表現其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/611.wav", + "text": "我很多都不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/612.wav", + "text": "比如說懲戒法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/613.wav", + "text": "吳院長現在案子進行情況怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/614.wav", + "text": "現在都有送懲戒法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/615.wav", + "text": "職務法庭在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/616.wav", + "text": "外界罵一頓你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/617.wav", + "text": "監察院彈劾之後你們才跟進對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/618.wav", + "text": "因為監察院也有監察院的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/619.wav", + "text": "按照整個懲戒制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/620.wav", + "text": "司法院也都有啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/621.wav", + "text": "法官評鑑委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/622.wav", + "text": "這些資料其實都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/623.wav", + "text": "併案來審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/624.wav", + "text": "都併案審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/625.wav", + "text": "你們現在處理的進度怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/626.wav", + "text": "評鑑委員會在評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/627.wav", + "text": "通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/628.wav", + "text": "評鑑過了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/629.wav", + "text": "評鑑過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/630.wav", + "text": "結論是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/631.wav", + "text": "評鑑過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/632.wav", + "text": "有建議就是要撤職這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/633.wav", + "text": "都會一併移送職務法庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/634.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/635.wav", + "text": "併案審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/636.wav", + "text": "OK好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/637.wav", + "text": "第57案就改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/638.wav", + "text": "沒有同意就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/639.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/640.wav", + "text": "第59案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/641.wav", + "text": "凍10萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/642.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/643.wav", + "text": "100萬喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/644.wav", + "text": "好凍100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/645.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/646.wav", + "text": "60案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/647.wav", + "text": "\n第61案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/648.wav", + "text": "\n第62案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/649.wav", + "text": "\n第63案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/650.wav", + "text": "\n第64案凍結50萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/651.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/652.wav", + "text": "我們就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/653.wav", + "text": "第58案不是撤案了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/654.wav", + "text": "58案撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/655.wav", + "text": "67案是委員會保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/656.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/657.wav", + "text": "67案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/658.wav", + "text": "68案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/659.wav", + "text": "提書面報告沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/660.wav", + "text": "\n第77案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/661.wav", + "text": "\n第78案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/662.wav", + "text": "\n第79案主決議有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/663.wav", + "text": "哪一第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/664.wav", + "text": "79案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/665.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/666.wav", + "text": "好那就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/667.wav", + "text": "\n第80案主決議有做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/668.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/669.wav", + "text": "\n第81案主決議有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/670.wav", + "text": "好那就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/671.wav", + "text": "\n第82案主決議有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/672.wav", + "text": "85案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/673.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/674.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/675.wav", + "text": "88案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/676.wav", + "text": "第59案怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/677.wav", + "text": "現在送來的第59案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/678.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/679.wav", + "text": "他們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/680.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/681.wav", + "text": "現在就看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/682.wav", + "text": "第88案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/683.wav", + "text": "臺灣高等法院的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/684.wav", + "text": "增列50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/685.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/686.wav", + "text": "的這所有案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/687.wav", + "text": "都是賴士葆提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/688.wav", + "text": "20案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/689.wav", + "text": "其他人沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/690.wav", + "text": "臺灣高等法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/691.wav", + "text": "他的第90案已經撤案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/692.wav", + "text": "賴士葆提了20個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/693.wav", + "text": "全部都是臺高院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/694.wav", + "text": "的他一個人提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/695.wav", + "text": "的這後面一定有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/696.wav", + "text": "他的原因嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/697.wav", + "text": "他沒有來我們是不是現在就來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/698.wav", + "text": "銘宗委員來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/699.wav", + "text": "曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/700.wav", + "text": "提了20案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/701.wav", + "text": "到底怎麼回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/702.wav", + "text": "跟大家講清楚一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/703.wav", + "text": "我這20個案子全部保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/704.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/705.wav", + "text": "高院太惡劣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/706.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/707.wav", + "text": "話今天講的話明天否定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/708.wav", + "text": "明天講的後天否定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/709.wav", + "text": "什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/710.wav", + "text": "你不要管什麼事啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/711.wav", + "text": "當然要講是什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/712.wav", + "text": "染嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/713.wav", + "text": "這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/714.wav", + "text": "不要喘慢慢來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/715.wav", + "text": "我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/716.wav", + "text": "很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/717.wav", + "text": "用費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/718.wav", + "text": "太浪費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/719.wav", + "text": "我要刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/720.wav", + "text": "結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/721.wav", + "text": "他們的人來跟我協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/722.wav", + "text": "一塊錢都不能刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/723.wav", + "text": "結果兩個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/724.wav", + "text": "只有刪個20萬30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/725.wav", + "text": "我說不要刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/726.wav", + "text": "我通通表決都沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/727.wav", + "text": "這麼傲慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/728.wav", + "text": "一塊錢都不能刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/729.wav", + "text": "怎麼會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/730.wav", + "text": "昨天也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/731.wav", + "text": "今天也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/732.wav", + "text": "你不要的理由講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/733.wav", + "text": "嘛我知道你不要的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/734.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/735.wav", + "text": "我有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/736.wav", + "text": "我有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/737.wav", + "text": "他不給刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/738.wav", + "text": "不是這樣吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/739.wav", + "text": "就這樣子啊你問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/740.wav", + "text": "啊一塊都不給刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/741.wav", + "text": "回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/742.wav", + "text": "回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/743.wav", + "text": "一塊錢不給刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/744.wav", + "text": "你要刪哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/745.wav", + "text": "我們來一樣一樣談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/746.wav", + "text": "每一個案都不給刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/747.wav", + "text": "馬上談就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/748.wav", + "text": "其實我們不給刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/749.wav", + "text": "也是有理由的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/750.wav", + "text": "都是用於清潔物品汽油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/751.wav", + "text": "碳粉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/752.wav", + "text": "辦公室維修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/753.wav", + "text": "還有人民重要的郵資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/754.wav", + "text": "還有現在很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/755.wav", + "text": "資安服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/756.wav", + "text": "真的刪了的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/757.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/758.wav", + "text": "那就是很多行政業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/759.wav", + "text": "一定會備受影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/760.wav", + "text": "我們在編列的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/761.wav", + "text": "也是依照每一年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/762.wav", + "text": "所需要的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/763.wav", + "text": "我們的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/764.wav", + "text": "也是不能增列的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/765.wav", + "text": "耶其實我們的郵資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/766.wav", + "text": "跟我們的碳粉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/767.wav", + "text": "到年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/768.wav", + "text": "真的都是在賒欠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/769.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會跟委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/770.wav", + "text": "拜託不要刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/771.wav", + "text": "你有拜託嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/772.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/773.wav", + "text": "你們是用拜託的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/774.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/775.wav", + "text": "不是用命令的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/776.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以命令呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/777.wav", + "text": "我也拜託他給我刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/778.wav", + "text": "我拜託他給我刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/779.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得他浪費太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/780.wav", + "text": "我拜託他給我刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/781.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/782.wav", + "text": "換我拜託一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/783.wav", + "text": "這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/784.wav", + "text": "我們講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/785.wav", + "text": "你也是老委員了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/786.wav", + "text": "了今天很多部會都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/787.wav", + "text": "你一個人堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/788.wav", + "text": "所以你的保留案至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/789.wav", + "text": "六七十案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/790.wav", + "text": "交通部等等都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/791.wav", + "text": "每一個人都很尊重你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/792.wav", + "text": "昨天也請他們去跟你溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/793.wav", + "text": "包括經濟部以及交通部都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/794.wav", + "text": "跟你溝通嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/795.wav", + "text": "我們還是要在這裡解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/796.wav", + "text": "我想各部會沒有這麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/797.wav", + "text": "敢說一塊錢都不能刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/798.wav", + "text": "當然是拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/799.wav", + "text": "詞只是沒有跪求而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/800.wav", + "text": "都是在拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/801.wav", + "text": "我也算跟你拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/802.wav", + "text": "這個院際的分際大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/803.wav", + "text": "我跟大家拜託真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/804.wav", + "text": "我不知道我們的高院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/805.wav", + "text": "這麼的傲慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/806.wav", + "text": "一塊錢都不給刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/807.wav", + "text": "沒有啦他是跟你拜託啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/808.wav", + "text": "我是要看緊人民的荷包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/809.wav", + "text": "那換我講話嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/810.wav", + "text": "我還沒有講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/811.wav", + "text": "大家都是互相的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/812.wav", + "text": "你這麼資深的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/813.wav", + "text": "一定要趕快處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/814.wav", + "text": "今天要第二輪了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/815.wav", + "text": "所以該大家合理來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/816.wav", + "text": "的就合理來談嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/817.wav", + "text": "有些部分本來就有通刪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/818.wav", + "text": "他們聽起來連碳粉都要賒欠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/819.wav", + "text": "我是覺得這個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/820.wav", + "text": "不應該這麼摳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/821.wav", + "text": "司法機關的碳粉還要賒欠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/822.wav", + "text": "一個國家不應該如此運作\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/823.wav", + "text": "你們的預算是獨立分列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/824.wav", + "text": "你們自己編的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/825.wav", + "text": "司法預算是你們自己編的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/826.wav", + "text": "你在編的時候要編的好一點嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/827.wav", + "text": "通常司法院預算很少人在參與那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/828.wav", + "text": "那是你們自己編的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/829.wav", + "text": "你們編的連碳粉都不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/830.wav", + "text": "你們這個怎麼編的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/831.wav", + "text": "你們自己也要檢討嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/832.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/833.wav", + "text": "通常你編過來我們通通沒有刪過行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/834.wav", + "text": "最近都沒有加註意見耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/835.wav", + "text": "基本上還是袒護司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/836.wav", + "text": "因為司法獨立我們是非常尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/837.wav", + "text": "的但是這部分後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/838.wav", + "text": "你也有一個案子賴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/839.wav", + "text": "為了你的選區那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/840.wav", + "text": "不那個選民服務另外說啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/841.wav", + "text": "順興里那個事情嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/842.wav", + "text": "他們要建那個檔案及卷證大樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/843.wav", + "text": "你叫人家底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/844.wav", + "text": "還有一樓空間要怎麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/845.wav", + "text": "那個他們做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/846.wav", + "text": "依法法律上他們做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/847.wav", + "text": "做不到就不要答應人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/848.wav", + "text": "事先答應人家後來做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/849.wav", + "text": "我這個選民服務不要在這裡講穿了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/850.wav", + "text": "你的主題就是在講這個嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/851.wav", + "text": "我們現在就攤開來講沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/852.wav", + "text": "誰答應你什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/853.wav", + "text": "違法答應的誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/854.wav", + "text": "國有公共建築物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/855.wav", + "text": "沒有無償提供啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/856.wav", + "text": "我不要提到這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/857.wav", + "text": "讓謝衣鳯委員講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/858.wav", + "text": "但是柯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/859.wav", + "text": "我都還沒說完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/860.wav", + "text": "答應不算數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/861.wav", + "text": "我知道你要談什麼事情嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/862.wav", + "text": "大家攤開來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/863.wav", + "text": "在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/864.wav", + "text": "我講話我負責嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/865.wav", + "text": "他講話他要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/866.wav", + "text": "你講話你要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/867.wav", + "text": "他們吞都吞不回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/868.wav", + "text": "這樣子是司法院嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/869.wav", + "text": "你告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/870.wav", + "text": "有啊我這裡有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/871.wav", + "text": "台上面嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/872.wav", + "text": "來論告沒有關係嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/873.wav", + "text": "我跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/874.wav", + "text": "我講就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/875.wav", + "text": "88案到第108案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/876.wav", + "text": "已經溝通撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/877.wav", + "text": "賴委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/878.wav", + "text": "這沒關係照常撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/879.wav", + "text": "再來有8個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/880.wav", + "text": "屬於通刪那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/881.wav", + "text": "是通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/882.wav", + "text": "所以就要扣掉還剩下9個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/883.wav", + "text": "有兩個案能夠刪一些那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/884.wav", + "text": "7個案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/885.wav", + "text": "不要講話了老柯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/886.wav", + "text": "不要講話了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/887.wav", + "text": "你講話我都會聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/888.wav", + "text": "我想講話你要保障我的權利好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/889.wav", + "text": "我開始講你好話你總要聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/890.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/891.wav", + "text": "就不要再講了好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/892.wav", + "text": "等一下我要瞭解是哪個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/893.wav", + "text": "哪兩個案要刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/894.wav", + "text": "我們現在就討論其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/895.wav", + "text": "就照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/896.wav", + "text": "88案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/897.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/898.wav", + "text": "增列50萬遵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/899.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/900.wav", + "text": "那這個就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/901.wav", + "text": "增列1,000萬遵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/902.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/903.wav", + "text": "90案跟91案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/904.wav", + "text": "��委員已經同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/905.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/906.wav", + "text": "92案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/907.wav", + "text": "減列30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/908.wav", + "text": "保留吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/909.wav", + "text": "賴委員你的第92案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/910.wav", + "text": "減列5萬就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/911.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/912.wav", + "text": "第92案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/913.wav", + "text": "通刪我們就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/914.wav", + "text": "\n第94案減列30萬減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/915.wav", + "text": "減少一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/916.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/917.wav", + "text": "刪少一點嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/918.wav", + "text": "你對每個部會的通訊費用都這樣搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/919.wav", + "text": "拜託你不要睜眼說瞎話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/920.wav", + "text": "7個案子算什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/921.wav", + "text": "才7個案子而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/922.wav", + "text": "先走完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/923.wav", + "text": "拜託請你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/924.wav", + "text": "睜大眼睛看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/925.wav", + "text": "我每一個案子只有刪30萬20萬20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/926.wav", + "text": "他一毛錢都不給我刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/927.wav", + "text": "那什麼東西啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/928.wav", + "text": "刪少一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/929.wav", + "text": "編列預算的時候有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/930.wav", + "text": "你有刪過他們的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/931.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/932.wav", + "text": "行政院基本上都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/933.wav", + "text": "尊重司法院的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/934.wav", + "text": "嘛顯然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/935.wav", + "text": "秘書長你怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/936.wav", + "text": "讓這種預算送出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/937.wav", + "text": "連一個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/938.wav", + "text": "刪個10萬20萬都沒辦法刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/939.wav", + "text": "一定要照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/940.wav", + "text": "核實編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/941.wav", + "text": "顯示司法院在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/942.wav", + "text": "預算編列上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/943.wav", + "text": "沒有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/944.wav", + "text": "而且有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/945.wav", + "text": "院長講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/946.wav", + "text": "連10萬20萬刪了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/947.wav", + "text": "都會影響它業務的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/948.wav", + "text": "那不就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/949.wav", + "text": "後就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/950.wav", + "text": "所以主計長你評論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/951.wav", + "text": "這有沒有問題你敢不敢講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/952.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/953.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/954.wav", + "text": "按麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/955.wav", + "text": "五院平行我不能夠表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/956.wav", + "text": "我現在請你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/957.wav", + "text": "用專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/958.wav", + "text": "呢有沒有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/959.wav", + "text": "沒有我認為他們都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/960.wav", + "text": "核實編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/961.wav", + "text": "核實到這種程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/962.wav", + "text": "不然我來說一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/963.wav", + "text": "照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/964.wav", + "text": "孟德斯鳩的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/965.wav", + "text": "三權分立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/966.wav", + "text": "民主政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/967.wav", + "text": "三百零多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/968.wav", + "text": "在英國的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/969.wav", + "text": "三百零多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/970.wav", + "text": "國會至上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/971.wav", + "text": "民主政治是國會至上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/972.wav", + "text": "審判獨立是司法權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/973.wav", + "text": "我們不會去干預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/974.wav", + "text": "司法獨立是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/975.wav", + "text": "指審判獨立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/976.wav", + "text": "啊我們沒有干預你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/977.wav", + "text": "所以大家不要用司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/978.wav", + "text": "好像就是說我是獨立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/979.wav", + "text": "國會代表民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/980.wav", + "text": "人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/981.wav", + "text": "民意你們在民意之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/982.wav", + "text": "要謙卑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/983.wav", + "text": "要記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/984.wav", + "text": "我是覺得今天我是有感而發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/985.wav", + "text": "我們的國家因為華人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/986.wav", + "text": "文化圈沒有民主政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/987.wav", + "text": "嘛都受到黨國教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/988.wav", + "text": "都比較早三綱五常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/989.wav", + "text": "儒家三綱五常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/990.wav", + "text": "會有傲慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/991.wav", + "text": "所以一定要記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/992.wav", + "text": "大家互相尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/993.wav", + "text": "沒有說不能刪的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/994.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/995.wav", + "text": "哪有預算不能刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/996.wav", + "text": "預算權是國會的權啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/997.wav", + "text": "審判我們不會去干預你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/998.wav", + "text": "上還是要尊重立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/999.wav", + "text": "沒有說所謂什麼不能刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1000.wav", + "text": "哪有不能刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1001.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1002.wav", + "text": "等一下等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1003.wav", + "text": "我還是要表示一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1004.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂不能刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1005.wav", + "text": "只是他拜託不要刪太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1006.wav", + "text": "這樣而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1007.wav", + "text": "前半段講得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1008.wav", + "text": "不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1009.wav", + "text": "啊包括民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1010.wav", + "text": "但是他前面講得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1011.wav", + "text": "我要跟他敬禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1012.wav", + "text": "要敬禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1013.wav", + "text": "不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1014.wav", + "text": "本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1015.wav", + "text": "你趕快講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1016.wav", + "text": "我對剛剛游院長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1017.wav", + "text": "本來就是啊這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1018.wav", + "text": "剛開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1019.wav", + "text": "我為什麼要請林佳龍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1020.wav", + "text": "秘書長來列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1021.wav", + "text": "為什麼請環境部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1022.wav", + "text": "部長來列席本來就是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1023.wav", + "text": "我剛剛還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1024.wav", + "text": "沒有禮貌糾正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1025.wav", + "text": "總統府副秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1026.wav", + "text": "說讓他委屈了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1027.wav", + "text": "一點都不委屈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1028.wav", + "text": "怎麼會委屈請他先離席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1029.wav", + "text": "請秘書長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1030.wav", + "text": "哪會委屈所以院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1031.wav", + "text": "剛剛那席話基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1032.wav", + "text": "我真的全力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1033.wav", + "text": "也謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1034.wav", + "text": "你是全民的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1035.wav", + "text": "立法院長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1036.wav", + "text": "好謝謝來劉委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1037.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗總召剛剛講的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1038.wav", + "text": "我部分贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1039.wav", + "text": "啦一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1040.wav", + "text": "是這樣子啦當然院長講的話我們都充分尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1041.wav", + "text": "一開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1042.wav", + "text": "不管你提到總統府秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1043.wav", + "text": "或是環境部我們覺得這樣不妥當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1044.wav", + "text": "所以我們也是在曾總召的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1045.wav", + "text": "之下趕快去進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1046.wav", + "text": "你也看到兩位首長都到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1047.wav", + "text": "嘛表示尊重我們在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1048.wav", + "text": "尤其是行使中央政府總預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1049.wav", + "text": "因為預算就是歸立法院來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1050.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛曾銘宗一直說主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1051.wav", + "text": "要表示意見我想他們也都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1052.wav", + "text": "互相尊重我們也會看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1053.wav", + "text": "重我們自己的審查權當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1054.wav", + "text": "他們提出來的預算多還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1055.wav", + "text": "寡最後的決定還是在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1056.wav", + "text": "\n但是我要回歸到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1057.wav", + "text": "第2項就是剛剛賴士葆委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1058.wav", + "text": "院長已經裁決有通刪的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1059.wav", + "text": "跟撤案的項目那我們只是g" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1060.wav", + "text": "ugh一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1061.wav", + "text": "所以我會建議是不是從第94案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1062.wav", + "text": "開始往下走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1063.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有跟賴士葆委員建議就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1064.wav", + "text": "如果它放在一般行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1065.wav", + "text": "下面這樣一個大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1066.wav", + "text": "科目的話下面的項目節就不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1067.wav", + "text": "去特別堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1068.wav", + "text": "因為你所提到要刪的部分包括物品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1069.wav", + "text": "啦租金啦房屋建築" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1070.wav", + "text": "養護費這個部分你太堅持的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1071.wav", + "text": "會影響他們秘書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1072.wav", + "text": "業務上面或是一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1073.wav", + "text": "雜項業務上行使的支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1074.wav", + "text": "我現在都沒有提到說你要刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1075.wav", + "text": "還是減還是凍這個提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1076.wav", + "text": "給賴士葆委員參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1077.wav", + "text": "好賴士葆委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1078.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1079.wav", + "text": "我希望大家耐心聽我把話講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1080.wav", + "text": "院長剛剛講的那句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1081.wav", + "text": "大家都給你鼓掌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1082.wav", + "text": "包括民進黨黨國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1083.wav", + "text": "這樣就100分了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1084.wav", + "text": "開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1085.wav", + "text": "我刪什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1086.wav", + "text": "20萬過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1087.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1088.wav", + "text": "說你一定要給它過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1089.wav", + "text": "我現在只剩7個案要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1090.wav", + "text": "都不給我保留可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1091.wav", + "text": "那就沒這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1092.wav", + "text": "司法院弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1093.wav", + "text": "弄不出這幾十萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1094.wav", + "text": "我打死也不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1095.wav", + "text": "把頭砍下來給我我也不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1096.wav", + "text": "我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1097.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1098.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1099.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1100.wav", + "text": "賴委員你繼續講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1101.wav", + "text": "今天要處理可以按照我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1102.wav", + "text": "我刪多少就刪多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1103.wav", + "text": "因為沒有多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1104.wav", + "text": "加起來大概一百零多萬而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1105.wav", + "text": "通通科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1106.wav", + "text": "就打這麼開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1107.wav", + "text": "如果這樣不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1108.wav", + "text": "剛才賴士葆委員已經說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1109.wav", + "text": "就是100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1110.wav", + "text": "然後科目可以讓司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1111.wav", + "text": "自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1112.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠請司法院回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1113.wav", + "text": "如果不要限制科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1114.wav", + "text": "就不會影響到他們覈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1115.wav", + "text": "然後說到連文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1116.wav", + "text": "的費用都沒有辦法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1117.wav", + "text": "這個情況下是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1118.wav", + "text": "讓他們撙節調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1119.wav", + "text": "預算的審議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1120.wav", + "text": "我贊成啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1121.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1122.wav", + "text": "會計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1123.wav", + "text": "今年113年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1124.wav", + "text": "總預算多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1125.wav", + "text": "司法院主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1126.wav", + "text": "那我們能不能決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1127.wav", + "text": "讓它在司法院的大預算裡面去調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1128.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1129.wav", + "text": "啊我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1130.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1131.wav", + "text": "行政院都按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1132.wav", + "text": "憲法增修條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1133.wav", + "text": "規定都有提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1134.wav", + "text": "附註意見謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1135.wav", + "text": "對司法院的預算都有提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1136.wav", + "text": "附註意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1137.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1138.wav", + "text": "他在說明了他能夠講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1139.wav", + "text": "可不可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1140.wav", + "text": "我只能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1141.wav", + "text": "按照憲法去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1142.wav", + "text": "代表行政院說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1143.wav", + "text": "我按照憲法增修條文提了附註意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1144.wav", + "text": "我們都有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1145.wav", + "text": "每年都有提附註意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1146.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1147.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1148.wav", + "text": "坐在那裡有時候要發揮功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1149.wav", + "text": "你現在就不要用主計長的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1150.wav", + "text": "我從預算上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1151.wav", + "text": "請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1152.wav", + "text": "你現在不是主計長喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1153.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1154.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1155.wav", + "text": "只有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1156.wav", + "text": "總預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1157.wav", + "text": "如果他們是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1158.wav", + "text": "獨立的單位預算是不能夠調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1159.wav", + "text": "如果是單位預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1160.wav", + "text": "高等法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1161.wav", + "text": "今年編多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1162.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1163.wav", + "text": "高院是二十一億多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1164.wav", + "text": "在一般行政項下可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1165.wav", + "text": "一般行政項下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1166.wav", + "text": "17億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1167.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1168.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1169.wav", + "text": "31億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1170.wav", + "text": "17億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1171.wav", + "text": "280萬而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1172.wav", + "text": "這個有問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1173.wav", + "text": "讓柯總召講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1174.wav", + "text": "因為這個院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1175.wav", + "text": "不要生氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1176.wav", + "text": "一開始科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1177.wav", + "text": "我們的思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1178.wav", + "text": "就會比較寬廣一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1179.wav", + "text": "嘛因為這是指定刪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1180.wav", + "text": "既然要科目自行調整的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1181.wav", + "text": "在臺高院17億裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1182.wav", + "text": "刪了多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1183.wav", + "text": "再科目自行調整那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1184.wav", + "text": "這個好辦啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1185.wav", + "text": "賴委員剛才說的17億裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1186.wav", + "text": "你聽我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1187.wav", + "text": "人事費用是16億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1188.wav", + "text": "他們真正能夠使用的這些行政費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1189.wav", + "text": "只剩下1億左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1190.wav", + "text": "稍微思考一沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1191.wav", + "text": "啦7個案就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1192.wav", + "text": "嘛不用浪費這麼多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1193.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1194.wav", + "text": "這7個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1195.wav", + "text": "大家都剛才說好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1196.wav", + "text": "你們現在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1197.wav", + "text": "講到中午也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1198.wav", + "text": "還是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1199.wav", + "text": "在一般行政項下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1200.wav", + "text": "在高院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1201.wav", + "text": "單位預算下調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1202.wav", + "text": "因為41" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1203.wav", + "text": "跟後面的第14頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1204.wav", + "text": "是兩個不同的科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1205.wav", + "text": "的規定要在同一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1206.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1207.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1208.wav", + "text": "那這樣第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1209.wav", + "text": "94案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1210.wav", + "text": "通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1211.wav", + "text": "最後原因還是要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1212.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1213.wav", + "text": "休息一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1214.wav", + "text": "休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1215.wav", + "text": "報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1216.wav", + "text": "考試院秘書長劉建忻先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1217.wav", + "text": "第109案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1218.wav", + "text": "改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1219.wav", + "text": "提書面報告沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1220.wav", + "text": "\n第111案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1221.wav", + "text": "\n第112案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1222.wav", + "text": "但是這邊想就教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1223.wav", + "text": "因為我們這邊有接獲陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1224.wav", + "text": "就是在11月6號晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1225.wav", + "text": "大概9點的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1226.wav", + "text": "財團法人青平台基金會大樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1227.wav", + "text": "大概是中正區中華路那個路段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1228.wav", + "text": "當時你有去參加一個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1229.wav", + "text": "會議裡面有文化部長史哲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1230.wav", + "text": "還有總統候選人賴清德競選辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1231.wav", + "text": "的總幹事潘孟安先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1232.wav", + "text": "他們有提供一些照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1233.wav", + "text": "就是你們在這邊出入的一些照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1234.wav", + "text": "應該要恪守相關的行政中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1235.wav", + "text": "不曉得你這個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1236.wav", + "text": "討論的內容是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1237.wav", + "text": "這邊也有你們出入的一些照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1238.wav", + "text": "包含你搭乘的公務車等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1239.wav", + "text": "我是不是藉這個機會請你這邊說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1240.wav", + "text": "是跟總召報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1241.wav", + "text": "我那天到那邊去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1242.wav", + "text": "是拜訪鄭麗君董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1243.wav", + "text": "鄭麗君董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1244.wav", + "text": "討論什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1245.wav", + "text": "是公務還是私務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1246.wav", + "text": "台過去這麼多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1247.wav", + "text": "一些政策的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1248.wav", + "text": "我跟鄭董事長因為也是私交的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1249.wav", + "text": "所以那天剛好過去找他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1250.wav", + "text": "所以沒有跟潘孟安總幹事見面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1251.wav", + "text": "沒有見面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1252.wav", + "text": "12月4號也在這邊同時出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1253.wav", + "text": "明這個會議是跟他們一起開的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1254.wav", + "text": "12月4號當天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1255.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1256.wav", + "text": "確定沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1257.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1258.wav", + "text": "公務還私務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1259.wav", + "text": "所以你是去拜訪誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1260.wav", + "text": "裡面跟一些朋友交換意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1261.wav", + "text": "是在幫賴清德副總統準備辯論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1262.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1263.wav", + "text": "我希望你們還是要注意一下你們這些行政中立的界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1264.wav", + "text": "請同仁來我們辦公室跟我們說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1265.wav", + "text": "過就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1266.wav", + "text": "還要再說明嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1267.wav", + "text": "說明一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1268.wav", + "text": "因為兩個時間非常的接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1269.wav", + "text": "其實也都是那個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1270.wav", + "text": "在這棟大樓出入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1271.wav", + "text": "入我們合理的懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1272.wav", + "text": "你們是在進行相關競選的活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1273.wav", + "text": "跟相關政見辯論的一個商討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1274.wav", + "text": "我們不希望有這樣的事情發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1275.wav", + "text": "但是你現在的說法我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1276.wav", + "text": "可是我想本於事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1277.wav", + "text": "事實的釐清也要對社會大眾釋疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1278.wav", + "text": "我希望你們還是說明清楚好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1279.wav", + "text": "OK好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1280.wav", + "text": "秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1281.wav", + "text": "你現在職稱是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1282.wav", + "text": "我現在是考試院秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1283.wav", + "text": "下班後呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1284.wav", + "text": "下班後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1285.wav", + "text": "我還是考試院秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1286.wav", + "text": "對你最好不要被發現第三次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1287.wav", + "text": "你已經去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1288.wav", + "text": "跟他見過幾次面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1289.wav", + "text": "一些朋友會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1290.wav", + "text": "意見的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1291.wav", + "text": "合適嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1292.wav", + "text": "也有跟一些朋友做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1293.wav", + "text": "做我們相關政策的意見交換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1294.wav", + "text": "有的時候是拜訪朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1295.wav", + "text": "交換選舉意見合適嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1296.wav", + "text": "沒有我們不會交換選舉意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1297.wav", + "text": "秘書長最好不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1298.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1299.wav", + "text": "消息出來對選情沒有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1300.wav", + "text": "啦下次不要好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1301.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1302.wav", + "text": "請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1303.wav", + "text": "第115案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1304.wav", + "text": "下班以後應該沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1305.wav", + "text": "考試院不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1306.wav", + "text": "請看第115案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1307.wav", + "text": "做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1308.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1309.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1310.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1311.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1312.wav", + "text": "118案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1313.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1314.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1315.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1316.wav", + "text": "我介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1317.wav", + "text": "考選部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1318.wav", + "text": "許舒翔先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1319.wav", + "text": "好我們就進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1320.wav", + "text": "第120案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1321.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1322.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1323.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1324.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1325.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1326.wav", + "text": "\n接下來是銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1327.wav", + "text": "周志宏先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1328.wav", + "text": "第123案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1329.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1330.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1331.wav", + "text": "凍結50萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1332.wav", + "text": "是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1333.wav", + "text": "建請凍結10萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1334.wav", + "text": "然後3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1335.wav", + "text": "本案我們有瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1336.wav", + "text": "陳琬惠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1337.wav", + "text": "鄉鎮市民代表會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1338.wav", + "text": "秘書的職務列等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1339.wav", + "text": "我們已經在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1340.wav", + "text": "檢討當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1341.wav", + "text": "做一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1342.wav", + "text": "比較在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1343.wav", + "text": "什麼時候可以作成決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1344.wav", + "text": "我們保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1345.wav", + "text": "堅持保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1346.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1347.wav", + "text": "第124案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1348.wav", + "text": "這個法律問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1349.wav", + "text": "沒有那麼簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1350.wav", + "text": "125案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1351.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1352.wav", + "text": "第126案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1353.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1354.wav", + "text": "第127案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1355.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1356.wav", + "text": "沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1357.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1358.wav", + "text": "沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1359.wav", + "text": "稍微修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1360.wav", + "text": "是就改提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1361.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1362.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1363.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1364.wav", + "text": "有沒有好第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1365.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1366.wav", + "text": "沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1367.wav", + "text": "公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1368.wav", + "text": "障暨培訓委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1369.wav", + "text": "主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1370.wav", + "text": "兼任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1371.wav", + "text": "國家文官學院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1372.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1373.wav", + "text": "郝培芝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1374.wav", + "text": "女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1375.wav", + "text": "請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1376.wav", + "text": "第132案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1377.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1378.wav", + "text": "有沒有遵照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1379.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1380.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1381.wav", + "text": "我們就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1382.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1383.wav", + "text": "沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1384.wav", + "text": "這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1385.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1386.wav", + "text": "跟謝委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1387.wav", + "text": "過我們做部分文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1388.wav", + "text": "然後改書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1389.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1390.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1391.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1392.wav", + "text": "再來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1393.wav", + "text": "公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1394.wav", + "text": "退休撫卹基金管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1395.wav", + "text": "局長陳銘賢先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1396.wav", + "text": "請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1397.wav", + "text": "第135案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1398.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1399.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1400.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1401.wav", + "text": "做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1402.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1403.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1404.wav", + "text": "考試院就到此告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1405.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1406.wav", + "text": "來監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1407.wav", + "text": "開始討論監察院主管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1408.wav", + "text": "首先介紹監察院列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1409.wav", + "text": "監察院秘書長李俊俋先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1410.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我們就開始進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1411.wav", + "text": "請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1412.wav", + "text": "第137案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1413.wav", + "text": "案都是通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1414.wav", + "text": "抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1415.wav", + "text": "撤案撤案就不討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1416.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1417.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1418.wav", + "text": "第137案是通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1419.wav", + "text": "第138" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1420.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1421.wav", + "text": "第137案就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1422.wav", + "text": "\n請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1423.wav", + "text": "140案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1424.wav", + "text": "凍結1,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1425.wav", + "text": "委員會已經處理過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1426.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1427.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1428.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1429.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1430.wav", + "text": "一樣也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1431.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1432.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1433.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1434.wav", + "text": "我們就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1435.wav", + "text": "143案是院長的特別費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1436.wav", + "text": "我們建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1437.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1438.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1439.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1440.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1441.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1442.wav", + "text": "案凍結10萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1443.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1444.wav", + "text": "都談好了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1445.wav", + "text": "凍結10萬好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1446.wav", + "text": "146" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1447.wav", + "text": "本席今天專程來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1448.wav", + "text": "就是為了這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1449.wav", + "text": "雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1450.wav", + "text": "哪一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1451.wav", + "text": "第146案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1452.wav", + "text": "監察院的人權委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1453.wav", + "text": "我想前言就不再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1454.wav", + "text": "經常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1455.wav", + "text": "看到對於原住民的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1456.wav", + "text": "一些評論也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1457.wav", + "text": "或是作法也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1458.wav", + "text": "讓原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1459.wav", + "text": "我個人看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1460.wav", + "text": "了非常不愉快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1461.wav", + "text": "之前有一個叫羅小雲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1462.wav", + "text": "後來又有大學校長失言說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1463.wav", + "text": "400年前臺灣是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1464.wav", + "text": "衣不蔽體的社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1465.wav", + "text": "明明是在講原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1466.wav", + "text": "傳統服裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1467.wav", + "text": "後來也被媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1468.wav", + "text": "一直到今年4月29號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1469.wav", + "text": "臺中一中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1470.wav", + "text": "臺大也發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1471.wav", + "text": "這樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1472.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1473.wav", + "text": "覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1474.wav", + "text": "��察院的人權委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1475.wav", + "text": "在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1476.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼作為啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1477.wav", + "text": "真的沒有什麼作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1478.wav", + "text": "那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1479.wav", + "text": "我特別要詢問的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1480.wav", + "text": "人權委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1481.wav", + "text": "說近年都有在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1482.wav", + "text": "他們也給我們做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1483.wav", + "text": "了一些說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1484.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1485.wav", + "text": "今天在審預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1486.wav", + "text": "那麼多的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1487.wav", + "text": "關於原住民的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1488.wav", + "text": "居然都提不出相關的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1489.wav", + "text": "人權會已經成立了三年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1490.wav", + "text": "到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1491.wav", + "text": "真的是沒有什麼作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1492.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1493.wav", + "text": "我本來要刪他們的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1494.wav", + "text": "但是又覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1495.wav", + "text": "不給他們經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1496.wav", + "text": "他們就變成沒有事做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1497.wav", + "text": "關於原住民人權的重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1498.wav", + "text": "我要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1499.wav", + "text": "再一次的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1500.wav", + "text": "讓大家重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1501.wav", + "text": "主政的人權會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1502.wav", + "text": "應該要透過這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1503.wav", + "text": "我所提出的這些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1504.wav", + "text": "趕緊急起直追" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1505.wav", + "text": "針對原住民的相關人權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1506.wav", + "text": "真的是有在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1507.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1508.wav", + "text": "有一些作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1509.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1510.wav", + "text": "這個人權委員會已經成立三年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1511.wav", + "text": "不曉得成立了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1512.wav", + "text": "都在做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1513.wav", + "text": "我們都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1514.wav", + "text": "真的都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1515.wav", + "text": "好那我們預算要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1516.wav", + "text": "那就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1517.wav", + "text": "改為主決議好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1518.wav", + "text": "廖委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1519.wav", + "text": "我講一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1520.wav", + "text": "拜託一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1521.wav", + "text": "是併委員會的凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1522.wav", + "text": "然後再改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1523.wav", + "text": "好改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1524.wav", + "text": "凍結的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1525.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1526.wav", + "text": "凍結併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1527.wav", + "text": "凍結併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1528.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1529.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1530.wav", + "text": "這個部分跟廖委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1531.wav", + "text": "文字上我們修正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1532.wav", + "text": "因為這裡指的人權指標的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1533.wav", + "text": "那是行政院人權處的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1534.wav", + "text": "我們人權會是負責督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1535.wav", + "text": "我們要監督這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1536.wav", + "text": "所以文字上是不是可以允許我們修正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1537.wav", + "text": "可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1538.wav", + "text": "文字調整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1539.wav", + "text": "你們是監察院的人權委員會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1540.wav", + "text": "你們是委員會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1541.wav", + "text": "是人權委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1542.wav", + "text": "但是指標是人權處的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1543.wav", + "text": "不是我們監察院的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1544.wav", + "text": "所以這文字上要麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1545.wav", + "text": "文字調整一下好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1546.wav", + "text": "文字做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1547.wav", + "text": "凍結併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1548.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1549.wav", + "text": "那就這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1550.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1551.wav", + "text": "第146案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1552.wav", + "text": "凍結數併委員會決議辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1553.wav", + "text": "理文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1554.wav", + "text": "147案就改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1555.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1556.wav", + "text": "148" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1557.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1558.wav", + "text": "沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1559.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1560.wav", + "text": "這個修正一下文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1561.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1562.wav", + "text": "做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1563.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1564.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1565.wav", + "text": "接下來是法務部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1566.wav", + "text": "休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1567.wav", + "text": "所屬主管收支部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1568.wav", + "text": "\n我現在來介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1569.wav", + "text": "列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1570.wav", + "text": "首先介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1571.wav", + "text": "法務部部長蔡清祥先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1572.wav", + "text": "接下來是廉政署署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1573.wav", + "text": "莊榮松先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1574.wav", + "text": "矯正署署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1575.wav", + "text": "周輝煌先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1576.wav", + "text": "檢察署書記官長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1577.wav", + "text": "吳怡明先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1578.wav", + "text": "再來是臺灣高等檢察署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1579.wav", + "text": "書記官長陳玉萍女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1580.wav", + "text": "臺灣新北地方檢察署主任檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1581.wav", + "text": "江祐丞先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1582.wav", + "text": "還有調查局局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1583.wav", + "text": "王俊力先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1584.wav", + "text": "介紹完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1585.wav", + "text": "現在請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1586.wav", + "text": "第154案改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1587.wav", + "text": "\n第155案凍50萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1588.wav", + "text": "\n第156案改主決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1589.wav", + "text": "\n第158案改主第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1590.wav", + "text": "156案改主決議好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1591.wav", + "text": "第159案凍50萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1592.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1593.wav", + "text": "\n第169案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1594.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1595.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1596.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1597.wav", + "text": "\n第199案併委員會決議辦理提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1598.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1599.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1600.wav", + "text": "\n第205案主決議有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1601.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1602.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1603.wav", + "text": "\n第206案凍10萬元沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1604.wav", + "text": "\n第207案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1605.wav", + "text": "\n第208案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1606.wav", + "text": "\n第209案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1607.wav", + "text": "\n第210案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1608.wav", + "text": "凍比較多一點喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1609.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1610.wav", + "text": "沒有改主決議喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1611.wav", + "text": "沒有改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1612.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1613.wav", + "text": "要不要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1614.wav", + "text": "不改要不要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1615.wav", + "text": "那個暗網的狀況現在是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1616.wav", + "text": "因為這個調查局在承辦當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1617.wav", + "text": "是不是請調查局說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1618.wav", + "text": "好請調查局說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1619.wav", + "text": "是我們跟邱委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1620.wav", + "text": "就是有關於通信監察的建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1621.wav", + "text": "跟實施情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1622.wav", + "text": "這個網路設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1623.wav", + "text": "它是實體隔離的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1624.wav", + "text": "它跟外部其實是沒有聯繫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1625.wav", + "text": "因為我們的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1626.wav", + "text": "所有的聲請單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1627.wav", + "text": "不管是刑事案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1628.wav", + "text": "我們根據法院核的那個票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1629.wav", + "text": "目前情況是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1630.wav", + "text": "\n有關網路上出現的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1631.wav", + "text": "我請我們資通安全處的處長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1632.wav", + "text": "他是專家我請他來做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1633.wav", + "text": "你們相關的行政程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1634.wav", + "text": "我們都瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1635.wav", + "text": "但事實上是資料已經外流了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1636.wav", + "text": "據我們這邊瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1637.wav", + "text": "現在最擔心的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1638.wav", + "text": "還有重要政要的個人資料外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1639.wav", + "text": "是現在資安即國安最重要的原則之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1640.wav", + "text": "現在為什麼詐騙會那麼猖獗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1641.wav", + "text": "變民怨之首" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1642.wav", + "text": "就是這些資料真真假假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1643.wav", + "text": "七分真三分假或是五分真五分假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1644.wav", + "text": "現在這個問題已經嚴重到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1645.wav", + "text": "我們的行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1646.wav", + "text": "甚至情治單位的監聽資訊都已經外流了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1647.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講的都是你們現在在做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1648.wav", + "text": "相關的預防措施跟後面的查處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1649.wav", + "text": "源頭的管理和追蹤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1650.wav", + "text": "這個要怎麼樣防制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1651.wav", + "text": "制才是我們現在關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1652.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1653.wav", + "text": "我希望針對這個部分做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1654.wav", + "text": "偵查不公開的部分我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1655.wav", + "text": "但是目前這個狀況要怎麼樣去防制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1656.wav", + "text": "包含你們要跟數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1657.wav", + "text": "還是相關的法制單位怎麼樣合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1658.wav", + "text": "給國人一個回應和說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1659.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是我們現在比較關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1660.wav", + "text": "好這部分我請我們資通安全處余處長來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1661.wav", + "text": "這個事件我們大家都不樂見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1662.wav", + "text": "在這邊特別跟委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1663.wav", + "text": "我們局裡接到相關訊息以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1664.wav", + "text": "我們第一時間要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1665.wav", + "text": "我們第一時間就要看這個東西的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1666.wav", + "text": "然後我們必須對社會對媒體做迅速的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1667.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是我們必須做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1668.wav", + "text": "今天發生這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1669.wav", + "text": "大概就只有兩種可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1670.wav", + "text": "第一個可能就是所謂假訊息的散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1671.wav", + "text": "我們的內部系統遭到駭侵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1672.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員也特別提到這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1673.wav", + "text": "\n我現在就這兩部分來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1674.wav", + "text": "大家為什麼覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1675.wav", + "text": "說我們第一時間判斷它是認知作戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1676.wav", + "text": "通常我們在講假訊息的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1677.wav", + "text": "想到惡假害然後違反相關的法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1678.wav", + "text": "又不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1679.wav", + "text": "它的訊息出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1680.wav", + "text": "可能會造成國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1681.wav", + "text": "請簡單扼要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1682.wav", + "text": "是是是可能它會造成一些國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1683.wav", + "text": "人民的對立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1684.wav", + "text": "其實以它的態樣來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1685.wav", + "text": "第一個我們當然是檢視它的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1686.wav", + "text": "發現暗網的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1687.wav", + "text": "和爆料公社爆出來的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1688.wav", + "text": "是同步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1689.wav", + "text": "的這和認知作戰的態樣是很相近的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1690.wav", + "text": "第二個是它散播的操作手法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1691.wav", + "text": "我們在講認知作戰的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1692.wav", + "text": "它通常都是在境外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1693.wav", + "text": "拋出一個假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1694.wav", + "text": "然後在國內進行發酵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1695.wav", + "text": "可能有好幾個層次的傳播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1696.wav", + "text": "選擇的是爆料公社" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1697.wav", + "text": "在所謂的訊息農場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1698.wav", + "text": "在所謂的社群平台繼續散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1699.wav", + "text": "因為它已經引起媒體的重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1700.wav", + "text": "所以其實我們後續觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1701.wav", + "text": "在暗網的相關資料就已經下架了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1702.wav", + "text": "好針對跟預算有關的就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1703.wav", + "text": "簡單扼要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1704.wav", + "text": "今天不是質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1705.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1706.wav", + "text": "我主要還是要最後說明一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1707.wav", + "text": "我們執行通訊監察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1708.wav", + "text": "是依照通訊保障及監察法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1709.wav", + "text": "這個法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1710.wav", + "text": "在我們的執行單位來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1711.wav", + "text": "其實我們接到的是法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1712.wav", + "text": "監察書上面的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1713.wav", + "text": "其實很多在個資上面都已經去識別化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1714.wav", + "text": "我想一般的偵辦單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1715.wav", + "text": "對於他們所偵辦的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1716.wav", + "text": "所以我們看到的只是很簡單的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1717.wav", + "text": "然後一切都是自動化處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1718.wav", + "text": "都沒有人工作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1719.wav", + "text": "我們也沒有看到任何個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1720.wav", + "text": "我們就繼續來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1721.wav", + "text": "好跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1722.wav", + "text": "任何人都不能保證說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1723.wav", + "text": "是絕對百分之百" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1724.wav", + "text": "我們基本上的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1725.wav", + "text": "是一個認知作戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1726.wav", + "text": "但是就資安的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1727.wav", + "text": "不斷地在做清點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1728.wav", + "text": "在做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1729.wav", + "text": "這個部分是我們要來強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1730.wav", + "text": "這個部分特別再補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1731.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1732.wav", + "text": "212案撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1733.wav", + "text": "\n第213案凍結10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1734.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1735.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1736.wav", + "text": "改主決議好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1737.wav", + "text": "保留法制委員會就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1738.wav", + "text": "到此告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1739.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請衛環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1740.wav", + "text": "衛環是哪一個部會先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1741.wav", + "text": "衛環哪一個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1742.wav", + "text": "三個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1743.wav", + "text": "資料給我就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1744.wav", + "text": "宣布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1745.wav", + "text": "衛環是哪一個部會先到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1746.wav", + "text": "勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1747.wav", + "text": "勞動部先到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1748.wav", + "text": "勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1749.wav", + "text": "勞動然後是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1750.wav", + "text": "衛生福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1751.wav", + "text": "再來是環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1752.wav", + "text": "環境部最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1753.wav", + "text": "各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1754.wav", + "text": "我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1755.wav", + "text": "繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1756.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1757.wav", + "text": "進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1758.wav", + "text": "勞動部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1759.wav", + "text": "列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1760.wav", + "text": "勞動部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1761.wav", + "text": "許銘春" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1762.wav", + "text": "女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1763.wav", + "text": "現在請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1764.wav", + "text": "第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1765.wav", + "text": "第1案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1766.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1767.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1768.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1769.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1770.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1771.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1772.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1773.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1774.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1775.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1776.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1777.wav", + "text": "\n第10案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1778.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1779.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1780.wav", + "text": "\n第11案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1781.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1782.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1783.wav", + "text": "\n第12案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1784.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1785.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1786.wav", + "text": "\n第13案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1787.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1788.wav", + "text": "\n第15案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1789.wav", + "text": "\n第16案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1790.wav", + "text": "\n第17案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1791.wav", + "text": "院長我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1792.wav", + "text": "社會上現在有這樣的訴求跟聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1793.wav", + "text": "不外是對於現行勞保年金的不信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1794.wav", + "text": "還有對勞退新制不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1795.wav", + "text": "最重要就是對於老年退休保障雙重不足的擔憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1796.wav", + "text": "臺灣勞工普遍低薪進而影響退休金的請領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1797.wav", + "text": "未來即將面對繳多少領延後退的勞保年金改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1798.wav", + "text": "甚至還要繼續接受僅有6%的雇主提撥率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1799.wav", + "text": "1個月即便領三四萬的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1800.wav", + "text": "翻一下他們個人帳戶的提撥累計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1801.wav", + "text": "金額實在是少的可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1802.wav", + "text": "所以無論是年金改革或是勞退的新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1803.wav", + "text": "政府始終只敢要求勞工付出更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1804.wav", + "text": "連政府撥補都是出自於人民的納稅錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1805.wav", + "text": "卻不敢要求企業老闆負擔更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1806.wav", + "text": "所以在這裡先求有再求好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1807.wav", + "text": "我們請勞動部一定要注重我們勞工的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1808.wav", + "text": "這次雖然改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1809.wav", + "text": "但是我們還是要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1810.wav", + "text": "勞動部應該針對提高雇主提撥勞退比例一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1811.wav", + "text": "儘速邀集相關的代表召開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1812.wav", + "text": "蒐集相關意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1813.wav", + "text": "請務必如期提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1814.wav", + "text": "請部長回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1815.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1816.wav", + "text": "這個部分攸關勞工的權益我們會來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1817.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1818.wav", + "text": "好接下來請看第18案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1819.wav", + "text": "第18案併委員會決議辦理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1820.wav", + "text": "\n第19案併委員會決議辦理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1821.wav", + "text": "\n第20案凍結100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1822.wav", + "text": "報告主席那個改凍結20萬已經簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1823.wav", + "text": "改凍結20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1824.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1825.wav", + "text": "\n第22案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1826.wav", + "text": "\n第23案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1827.wav", + "text": "\n第24案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1828.wav", + "text": "\n第25案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1829.wav", + "text": "\n第26案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1830.wav", + "text": "\n第27案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1831.wav", + "text": "\n第28案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1832.wav", + "text": "\n第29案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1833.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1834.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1835.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1836.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1837.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1838.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1839.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1840.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1841.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1842.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1843.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1844.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1845.wav", + "text": "第幾案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1846.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1847.wav", + "text": "你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1848.wav", + "text": "什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1849.wav", + "text": "國內的低薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1850.wav", + "text": "成為國安問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1851.wav", + "text": "你作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1852.wav", + "text": "勞動部的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1853.wav", + "text": "你有沒有什麼想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1854.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1855.wav", + "text": "召其實勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1856.wav", + "text": "在我們權管範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1857.wav", + "text": "裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1858.wav", + "text": "我們一直很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1859.wav", + "text": "這8年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1860.wav", + "text": "就我們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1861.wav", + "text": "所主管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1862.wav", + "text": "基本工資部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1863.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1864.wav", + "text": "8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1865.wav", + "text": "連續調升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1866.wav", + "text": "52.5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1867.wav", + "text": "基層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1868.wav", + "text": "最邊際的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1869.wav", + "text": "我們很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1870.wav", + "text": "在提升他們的薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1871.wav", + "text": "也是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1872.wav", + "text": "基本工資的提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1873.wav", + "text": "也能夠帶動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1874.wav", + "text": "企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1875.wav", + "text": "整個薪資要提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1876.wav", + "text": "也是要靠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1877.wav", + "text": "跨部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1878.wav", + "text": "包括經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1879.wav", + "text": "國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1880.wav", + "text": "一起來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1881.wav", + "text": "一直就這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1882.wav", + "text": "地推出各項方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1883.wav", + "text": "在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1884.wav", + "text": "往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1885.wav", + "text": "提高薪資的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1886.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1887.wav", + "text": "大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1888.wav", + "text": "多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1889.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1890.wav", + "text": "大概240萬左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1891.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1892.wav", + "text": "總數勞工有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1893.wav", + "text": "總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1894.wav", + "text": "大概900萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1895.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1896.wav", + "text": "最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1897.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1898.wav", + "text": "會有效益嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1899.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1900.wav", + "text": "我覺得一定會有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1901.wav", + "text": "一定會有效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1902.wav", + "text": "因為這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1903.wav", + "text": "雖然沒有最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1904.wav", + "text": "基本工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1905.wav", + "text": "的審議辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1906.wav", + "text": "調升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1907.wav", + "text": "而且調升的幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1908.wav", + "text": "過調升的幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1909.wav", + "text": "整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1910.wav", + "text": "審議的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1911.wav", + "text": "更健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1912.wav", + "text": "審議的指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1913.wav", + "text": "也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1914.wav", + "text": "更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1915.wav", + "text": "研究小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1916.wav", + "text": "有專家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1917.wav", + "text": "客觀的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1918.wav", + "text": "評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1919.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1920.wav", + "text": "對未來整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1921.wav", + "text": "最低工資的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1922.wav", + "text": "調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1923.wav", + "text": "民團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1924.wav", + "text": "都不看好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1925.wav", + "text": "我也不看好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1926.wav", + "text": "有少數民團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1927.wav", + "text": "但也有很多勞團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1928.wav", + "text": "很肯定我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1929.wav", + "text": "他們可能沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1930.wav", + "text": "看到重要條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1931.wav", + "text": "他們都看得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1932.wav", + "text": "的通過也都很期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1933.wav", + "text": "朝野的委員的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1934.wav", + "text": "讓我們的法能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1935.wav", + "text": "順利通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1936.wav", + "text": "比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1937.wav", + "text": "��薪不得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1938.wav", + "text": "低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1939.wav", + "text": "前年度CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1940.wav", + "text": "你怎麼不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1941.wav", + "text": "報告總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1942.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1943.wav", + "text": "在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1944.wav", + "text": "有時候我們必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1945.wav", + "text": "要把它定死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1946.wav", + "text": "說不能低於某個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1947.wav", + "text": "其實現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1948.wav", + "text": "有最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1949.wav", + "text": "也有勞團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1950.wav", + "text": "提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1951.wav", + "text": "今天有勞團說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1952.wav", + "text": "是不是用這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1953.wav", + "text": "不得低於某個指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1954.wav", + "text": "他說不見得對勞工有利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1955.wav", + "text": "我們的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1956.wav", + "text": "跟總召報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1957.wav", + "text": "縱使有疫情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1958.wav", + "text": "也全數都反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1959.wav", + "text": "了我們的CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1960.wav", + "text": "甚至參酌GDP等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1961.wav", + "text": "調幅都比CPI還高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1962.wav", + "text": "你的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1963.wav", + "text": "答案都被你講出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1964.wav", + "text": "嘛疫情期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1965.wav", + "text": "就用政府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1966.wav", + "text": "你也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1967.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1968.wav", + "text": "\n所以意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1969.wav", + "text": "就用不得低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1970.wav", + "text": "前年CPI是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1971.wav", + "text": "不敢答應對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1972.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1973.wav", + "text": "法律定在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1974.wav", + "text": "譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1975.wav", + "text": "遇到特殊的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1976.wav", + "text": "連少個一塊錢都不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1977.wav", + "text": "這麼硬的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1978.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1979.wav", + "text": "不見得是好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1980.wav", + "text": "的世界最主要的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1981.wav", + "text": "幾乎都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1982.wav", + "text": "更多的彈性去參酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1983.wav", + "text": "當時的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1984.wav", + "text": "來決定最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1985.wav", + "text": "你又講到重點了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1986.wav", + "text": "���員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1987.wav", + "text": "我希望勞方能夠過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1988.wav", + "text": "你也不答應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1989.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1990.wav", + "text": "的都是勞資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1991.wav", + "text": "還有第三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1992.wav", + "text": "形成的等邊三角形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1993.wav", + "text": "人數都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1994.wav", + "text": "我們一定要重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1995.wav", + "text": "\n現在請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1996.wav", + "text": "38案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1997.wav", + "text": "39案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1998.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/1999.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2000.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2001.wav", + "text": "這案有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2002.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2003.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2004.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2005.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2006.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2007.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2008.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2009.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2010.wav", + "text": "有做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2011.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2012.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2013.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2014.wav", + "text": "\n第45案撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2015.wav", + "text": "有做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2016.wav", + "text": "沒有建議就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2017.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2018.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2019.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2020.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2021.wav", + "text": "\n第49案通刪我們就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2022.wav", + "text": "\n第50案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2023.wav", + "text": "\n第51案併委員會決議辦理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2024.wav", + "text": "\n第52案併委員會決議辦理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2025.wav", + "text": "\n第53案減列150萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2026.wav", + "text": "改凍保險業務150萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2027.wav", + "text": "改凍保險業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2028.wav", + "text": "凍保險業務150萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2029.wav", + "text": "我們就凍結150萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2030.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2031.wav", + "text": "部長這個不要凍結了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2032.wav", + "text": "啦給你刪個20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2033.wav", + "text": "那就改為減列20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2034.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2035.wav", + "text": "54案通刪通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2036.wav", + "text": "\n第55案改為主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2037.wav", + "text": "\n第56案凍結10萬元沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2038.wav", + "text": "\n第58案通刪通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2039.wav", + "text": "\n第59案併委員會決議辦理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2040.wav", + "text": "\n第60案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2041.wav", + "text": "\n第61案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2042.wav", + "text": "\n第62案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2043.wav", + "text": "\n第63案增列500萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2044.wav", + "text": "\n第64案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2045.wav", + "text": "\n第65案改凍結10萬元沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2046.wav", + "text": "\n第66案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2047.wav", + "text": "\n第67案併委員會決議辦理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2048.wav", + "text": "\n第68案也是賴委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2049.wav", + "text": "減列100萬元有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2050.wav", + "text": "這邊改凍5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2051.wav", + "text": "不要凍了減20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2052.wav", + "text": "減20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2053.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2054.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2055.wav", + "text": "\n第69案通刪沒有意見通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2056.wav", + "text": "\n第70案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2057.wav", + "text": "\n第71案主決議做文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2058.wav", + "text": "\n第72案主決議有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2059.wav", + "text": "好就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2060.wav", + "text": "\n現在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2061.wav", + "text": "衛生福利部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2062.wav", + "text": "在這邊介紹列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2063.wav", + "text": "衛生福利部部長薛瑞元先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2064.wav", + "text": "第73案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2065.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2066.wav", + "text": "衛福部都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2067.wav", + "text": "怠惰於做流行病學調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2068.wav", + "text": "我也沒看到衛福部針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2069.wav", + "text": "我們一些工業區做流行病學調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2070.wav", + "text": "在明年的預算好像也沒看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2071.wav", + "text": "環保金爐減量就可以用在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2072.wav", + "text": "工業區的增量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2073.wav", + "text": "因為未來工業區的污染會更嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2074.wav", + "text": "如果衛福部都不做流行病學調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2075.wav", + "text": "這樣住在工業區附近的人就倒楣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2076.wav", + "text": "因為現在科技預���是整體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2077.wav", + "text": "未來我們還是會有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2078.wav", + "text": "部長應該知道重工業區主要在中南部對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2079.wav", + "text": "中南部的人就不是人嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2080.wav", + "text": "這當然不能這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2081.wav", + "text": "降不下來然後現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2082.wav", + "text": "環境部又要去做增量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2083.wav", + "text": "麻煩衛福部跟環境部去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2084.wav", + "text": "他們如果要增量一定要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2085.wav", + "text": "才可以去增量這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2086.wav", + "text": "如果是屬於環境部業務的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2087.wav", + "text": "那當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2088.wav", + "text": "那你們流行病學調查要做啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2089.wav", + "text": "對我們就是要針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2090.wav", + "text": "因為過去在做所謂的流行病學調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2091.wav", + "text": "蒐集的資料都是全國性的並沒有特別對哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2092.wav", + "text": "但你們全國性就看不出來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2093.wav", + "text": "根本就是沒有辦法去凸顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2094.wav", + "text": "陳委員的質詢請衛福部一定要重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2095.wav", + "text": "院長這個非常嚴重啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2096.wav", + "text": "陳委員我們儘量集中回到預算好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2097.wav", + "text": "是回到預算今天就是預算的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2098.wav", + "text": "他們就是不做啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2099.wav", + "text": "你們衛福部真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2100.wav", + "text": "根本就是要廢掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2101.wav", + "text": "這麼重要的事情常年都不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2102.wav", + "text": "好我們就回到預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2103.wav", + "text": "是該做啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2104.wav", + "text": "我們如果有預算一定會去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2105.wav", + "text": "你們不編怎麼會有預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2106.wav", + "text": "我們又不能叫你們加預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2107.wav", + "text": "在科技預算裡面我們就可以來做安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2108.wav", + "text": "好請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2109.wav", + "text": "第74案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2110.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2111.wav", + "text": "好第76案併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2112.wav", + "text": "\n第77案通刪我們通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2113.wav", + "text": "\n第78案減列300萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2114.wav", + "text": "賴大委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2115.wav", + "text": "改刪100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2116.wav", + "text": "減列100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2117.wav", + "text": "科目都自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2118.wav", + "text": "\n第83案凍結60萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2119.wav", + "text": "有關現在中南部肺病肺腺癌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2120.wav", + "text": "的問題衛福部要不要編預算去做普遍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2121.wav", + "text": "該不該做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2122.wav", + "text": "現在這個還是全國性的就是說這些低劑量的CT" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2123.wav", + "text": "擴大但是我們不一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2124.wav", + "text": "可不可以先針對工業區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2125.wav", + "text": "鄰近的先做可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2126.wav", + "text": "因為這樣的目標不是那麼明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2127.wav", + "text": "你是住在北部對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2128.wav", + "text": "你就不重視現在重工業區附近的污染" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2129.wav", + "text": "像我住在南部我都不敢出門啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2130.wav", + "text": "我每次回去外面空氣污染" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2131.wav", + "text": "我就不想出門你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2132.wav", + "text": "很多人就是這樣小孩子也是這樣都要關在家裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2133.wav", + "text": "這種政策是需要全國一體適用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2134.wav", + "text": "我們如果低劑量的CT你們優先重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2135.wav", + "text": "中南部鄰近工業區先做可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2136.wav", + "text": "有限的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2137.wav", + "text": "工業區附近的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2138.wav", + "text": "就不該優先重視嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2139.wav", + "text": "要先普遍做了之後如果鄰近工業區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2140.wav", + "text": "那邊的人的確問題比較多我們再深入去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2141.wav", + "text": "我們還是儘量回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2142.wav", + "text": "那邊空氣污染PM2.5比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2143.wav", + "text": "難道不應該先做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2144.wav", + "text": "PM2.5是一級致癌物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2145.wav", + "text": "PM10也是一級致癌物不該先做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2146.wav", + "text": "一級致癌物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2147.wav", + "text": "這個理由不夠強嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2148.wav", + "text": "換劉世芳委員講話因為他舉手了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2149.wav", + "text": "對因為我也在中南部我當然會非常重視剛剛陳委員講的這個聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2150.wav", + "text": "我建議部長這樣回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2151.wav", + "text": "在衛福部的立場上你們當然會配合科技部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2152.wav", + "text": "但是衛福部也有主管會出席全國科技會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2153.wav", + "text": "跟全臺灣相關的不管是公共衛生的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2154.wav", + "text": "或流行病學又或環境病學的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2155.wav", + "text": "應該一起來評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2156.wav", + "text": "哪一些是最優先執行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2157.wav", + "text": "如果是屬於衛福部應該執行的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2158.wav", + "text": "你就當仁不讓不要說等科技部告訴你才做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2159.wav", + "text": "因為你這樣回應陳委員當然就會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2160.wav", + "text": "好像你不重��他的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2161.wav", + "text": "88案就刪減50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2162.wav", + "text": "賴大委員就刪減50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2163.wav", + "text": "第89案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2164.wav", + "text": "\n第90案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2165.wav", + "text": "第98案凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2166.wav", + "text": "第98案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2167.wav", + "text": "第99案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2168.wav", + "text": "第99案凍結10萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2169.wav", + "text": "第101案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2170.wav", + "text": "第101案也是改凍結10萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2171.wav", + "text": "第100案就改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2172.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2173.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2174.wav", + "text": "文字修正就修正沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2175.wav", + "text": "我們有修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2176.wav", + "text": "第107主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2177.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2178.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2179.wav", + "text": "因為我是老人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2180.wav", + "text": "110案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2181.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2182.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2183.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2184.wav", + "text": "114案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2185.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2186.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2187.wav", + "text": "120案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2188.wav", + "text": "就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2189.wav", + "text": "院長我再講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2190.wav", + "text": "第120" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2191.wav", + "text": "我要再講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2192.wav", + "text": "拜託拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2193.wav", + "text": "還是建議要趕快做流行病學調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2194.wav", + "text": "如果工業區那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2195.wav", + "text": "CT檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2196.wav", + "text": "還是要優先排既" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2197.wav", + "text": "中南部如果早期發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2198.wav", + "text": "早期治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2199.wav", + "text": "也可以顧全很多家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2200.wav", + "text": "疾病嚴重發生的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2201.wav", + "text": "影響家計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2202.wav", + "text": "委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2203.wav", + "text": "我們會來安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2204.wav", + "text": "我想我們都有年紀了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2205.wav", + "text": "還是要為下一代著想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2206.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2207.wav", + "text": "我們會來研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2208.wav", + "text": "部長很重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2209.wav", + "text": "接下來第121案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2210.wav", + "text": "有做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2211.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2212.wav", + "text": "122案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2213.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2214.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2215.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2216.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2217.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2218.wav", + "text": "文字修正是不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2219.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2220.wav", + "text": "第130案保留是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2221.wav", + "text": "等一下看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2222.wav", + "text": "好看一下看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2223.wav", + "text": "我們建議修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2224.wav", + "text": "於公開場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2225.wav", + "text": "好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2226.wav", + "text": "你的意思是不要寫人名就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2227.wav", + "text": "不要寫人名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2228.wav", + "text": "我覺得柯總召已經免疫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2229.wav", + "text": "你沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2230.wav", + "text": "不要寫名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2231.wav", + "text": "但是等一下還有另外一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2232.wav", + "text": "你們還特別在那邊寫名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2233.wav", + "text": "等一下等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2234.wav", + "text": "這個先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2235.wav", + "text": "改一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2236.wav", + "text": "不然先保留做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2237.wav", + "text": "做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2238.wav", + "text": "131案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2239.wav", + "text": "建議修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2240.wav", + "text": "有修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2241.wav", + "text": "有沒有修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2242.wav", + "text": "131" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2243.wav", + "text": "好修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2244.wav", + "text": "有修正嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2245.wav", + "text": "第132案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2246.wav", + "text": "也是修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2247.wav", + "text": "也有修正文字喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2248.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2249.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2250.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2251.wav", + "text": "你都沒有問謝衣鳯書記長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2252.wav", + "text": "這個都是他蓋章的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2253.wav", + "text": "你要尊重一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2254.wav", + "text": "可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2255.wav", + "text": "現在是第132" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2256.wav", + "text": "他們說有修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2257.wav", + "text": "文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2258.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2259.wav", + "text": "不是你那是第132" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2260.wav", + "text": "這個先保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2261.wav", + "text": "因為我還沒看完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2262.wav", + "text": "對啊這個沒有拿來給我們看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2263.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2264.wav", + "text": "要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2265.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2266.wav", + "text": "看他們能不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2267.wav", + "text": "能接受就OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2268.wav", + "text": "這樣可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2269.wav", + "text": "可以喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2270.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2271.wav", + "text": "第132案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2272.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2273.wav", + "text": "那就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2274.wav", + "text": "133案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2275.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2276.wav", + "text": "來曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2277.wav", + "text": "就文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2278.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2279.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2280.wav", + "text": "的人有些死了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2281.wav", + "text": "有些重傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2282.wav", + "text": "你答應我兩年內要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2283.wav", + "text": "你到底什麼時候要處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2284.wav", + "text": "那6,000件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2285.wav", + "text": "那6,000件已經處理你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2286.wav", + "text": "對著麥克風講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2287.wav", + "text": "我們黨團開了67次記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2288.wav", + "text": "你在總質詢時也答應我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2289.wav", + "text": "什麼時候要處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2290.wav", + "text": "人家死的死傷的傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2291.wav", + "text": "你還不趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2292.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2293.wav", + "text": "明年9月底前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2294.wav", + "text": "目前我們大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2295.wav", + "text": "每兩個禮拜會審查一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2296.wav", + "text": "每次會審查大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2297.wav", + "text": "150個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2298.wav", + "text": "大概可以審查300案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2299.wav", + "text": "目前已經處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2300.wav", + "text": "大概7,000案左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2301.wav", + "text": "不不不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2302.wav", + "text": "總共大概是9,000案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2303.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2304.wav", + "text": "我當時在總質詢答應的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2305.wav", + "text": "就是6,000件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2306.wav", + "text": "所以6,000件已經處理得差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2307.wav", + "text": "了但是陸陸續續後面還有新增的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2308.wav", + "text": "我們的同仁說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2309.wav", + "text": "到明年9月大概可以把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2310.wav", + "text": "接下來賴委員有舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2311.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2312.wav", + "text": "偉大的院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2313.wav", + "text": "及各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2314.wav", + "text": "我有一個選民服務案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2315.wav", + "text": "就是6,000案裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2316.wav", + "text": "他送進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2317.wav", + "text": "超過一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2318.wav", + "text": "了沒有人理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2319.wav", + "text": "他很弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2320.wav", + "text": "你說6,000案處理完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2321.wav", + "text": "結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2322.wav", + "text": "我傳給你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2323.wav", + "text": "已經放一年多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2324.wav", + "text": "一個個案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2325.wav", + "text": "是不是再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2326.wav", + "text": "其實國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2327.wav", + "text": "做上述文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2328.wav", + "text": "是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2329.wav", + "text": "在尊重依法的原則下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2330.wav", + "text": "已經經過這麼久的期間了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2331.wav", + "text": "未來應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2332.wav", + "text": "儘快協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2333.wav", + "text": "所有疫苗受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2334.wav", + "text": "讓他們能夠接受保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2335.wav", + "text": "我們的原則就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2336.wav", + "text": "希望你們能夠從速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2337.wav", + "text": "從寬認定並協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2338.wav", + "text": "所有疫苗受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2339.wav", + "text": "好那就謝謝了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2340.wav", + "text": "我再補充最後一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2341.wav", + "text": "我覺得剛才部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2342.wav", + "text": "回答得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2343.wav", + "text": "我希望你的回答就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2344.wav", + "text": "之後已經往生死掉的這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2345.wav", + "text": "超過一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2346.wav", + "text": "到底是怎麼樣的結果趕快出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2347.wav", + "text": "人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2348.wav", + "text": "\n我們接下來看第133案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2349.wav", + "text": "主決議有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2350.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2351.wav", + "text": "就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2352.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2353.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2354.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2355.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2356.wav", + "text": "第134案主決議有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2357.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2358.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2359.wav", + "text": "修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2360.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2361.wav", + "text": "就是疫苗受害者的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2362.wav", + "text": "原則下稍微修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2363.wav", + "text": "但我們還是希望不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2364.wav", + "text": "亡的疫苗受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2365.wav", + "text": "在施打疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2366.wav", + "text": "方面其實還有症狀性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2367.wav", + "text": "受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2368.wav", + "text": "可以從寬從速認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2369.wav", + "text": "儘速給予所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2370.wav", + "text": "疫苗施打的受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2371.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2372.wav", + "text": "政府不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2373.wav", + "text": "有太多的計較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2374.wav", + "text": "我沒有記錯的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2375.wav", + "text": "有因果關係的比率很低對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2376.wav", + "text": "如果確定因果關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2377.wav", + "text": "多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2378.wav", + "text": "有因果關係的比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2379.wav", + "text": "率確實是比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2380.wav", + "text": "5%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2381.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2382.wav", + "text": "但是我們現在的補償是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2383.wav", + "text": "如果沒有辦法判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2384.wav", + "text": "有無因果關係的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2385.wav", + "text": "部長你們叫做衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2386.wav", + "text": "你不要跟這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2387.wav", + "text": "受害者有太多的計較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2388.wav", + "text": "你們對高端實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2389.wav", + "text": "太好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2390.wav", + "text": "走不出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2391.wav", + "text": "根據最近我跟你調的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2392.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2393.wav", + "text": "流感疫苗我們採購幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2394.wav", + "text": "講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2395.wav", + "text": "東洋高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2396.wav", + "text": "還有一個是賽諾菲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2397.wav", + "text": "對我重複一下臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2398.wav", + "text": "灣就是有申請了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2399.wav", + "text": "國光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2400.wav", + "text": "東洋跟高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2401.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2402.wav", + "text": "為什麼人家不打高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2403.wav", + "text": "原因在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2404.wav", + "text": "快打完了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2405.wav", + "text": "在採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2406.wav", + "text": "排序的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2407.wav", + "text": "順序你們唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2408.wav", + "text": "民眾很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2409.wav", + "text": "第一名當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2410.wav", + "text": "國光第二是賽諾菲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2411.wav", + "text": "第三是東洋第四是高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2412.wav", + "text": "對嘛高端最後一名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2413.wav", + "text": "有人要打就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2414.wav", + "text": "了會害死人啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2415.wav", + "text": "沒有啦到現在沒有出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2416.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2417.wav", + "text": "所以你們對照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2418.wav", + "text": "於我要講個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2419.wav", + "text": "對照於蔡政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2420.wav", + "text": "百般呵護高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2421.wav", + "text": "疫苗的購買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2422.wav", + "text": "流感疫苗的購買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2423.wav", + "text": "對高端有夠好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2424.wav", + "text": "但是對一般民眾受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2425.wav", + "text": "你們的因果關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2426.wav", + "text": "又等那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2427.wav", + "text": "部長你能不能同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2428.wav", + "text": "我們書記長講了從速從寬從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2429.wav", + "text": "這個就是現在我們努力的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2430.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛有報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2431.wav", + "text": "其實我們現在每個月的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2432.wav", + "text": "審查案件數已經是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2433.wav", + "text": "非常加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2434.wav", + "text": "你現在就加速啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2435.wav", + "text": "結果你有因果關係的還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2436.wav", + "text": "疾管署現在比率多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2437.wav", + "text": "有因果關係的大概是5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2438.wav", + "text": "是用從寬從速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2439.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2440.wav", + "text": "我不是質詢我請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2441.wav", + "text": "因為有醫生告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2442.wav", + "text": "今年的流感疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2443.wav", + "text": "抓不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2444.wav", + "text": "所以等於打的幾乎跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2445.wav", + "text": "沒有打差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2446.wav", + "text": "你要不要講一下這次抓得準嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2447.wav", + "text": "\n好幾個醫生跟我講說抓不準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2448.wav", + "text": "抓不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2449.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2450.wav", + "text": "我們目前疫苗的採購大概都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2451.wav", + "text": "感染的病毒株是相符合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2452.wav", + "text": "這個在我們實驗室有做過相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2453.wav", + "text": "如果有打疫苗的話就可以有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2454.wav", + "text": "疫情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2455.wav", + "text": "135案剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2456.wav", + "text": "136案主決議有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2457.wav", + "text": "有修正文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2458.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2459.wav", + "text": "修正的部分只有加4個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2460.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2461.wav", + "text": "只有加4個字就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2462.wav", + "text": "爰要求衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2463.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2464.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2465.wav", + "text": "好沒意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2466.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2467.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2468.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2469.wav", + "text": "148案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2470.wav", + "text": "我是不是請我們同仁來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2471.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2472.wav", + "text": "目前國內的核准再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2473.wav", + "text": "是屬於醫療技術類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2474.wav", + "text": "醫療技術類是自體細胞的處理過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2475.wav", + "text": "所以目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2476.wav", + "text": "委員所提的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2477.wav", + "text": "不是說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2478.wav", + "text": "這個主決議你有沒有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2479.wav", + "text": "修正對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2480.wav", + "text": "我們有建議修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2481.wav", + "text": "拿來看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2482.wav", + "text": "有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2483.wav", + "text": "提案人看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2484.wav", + "text": "好提案人看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2485.wav", + "text": "等一下回頭再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2486.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2487.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2488.wav", + "text": "照案通過\n第151" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2489.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2490.wav", + "text": "有做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2491.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2492.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2493.wav", + "text": "��有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2494.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2495.wav", + "text": "照案通過\n第156主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2496.wav", + "text": "有做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2497.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2498.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2499.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2500.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2501.wav", + "text": "委員同意改減列10萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2502.wav", + "text": "好減列10萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2503.wav", + "text": "第209案改為減列10萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2504.wav", + "text": "211" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2505.wav", + "text": "有有修正是凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2506.wav", + "text": "好文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2507.wav", + "text": "凍結200萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2508.wav", + "text": "好凍結200萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2509.wav", + "text": "哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2510.wav", + "text": "就凍結併委員會決議處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2511.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2512.wav", + "text": "但是文字要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2513.wav", + "text": "這樣好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2514.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2515.wav", + "text": "213" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2516.wav", + "text": "案兩案都是通刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2517.wav", + "text": "我們就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2518.wav", + "text": "214" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2519.wav", + "text": "就教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2520.wav", + "text": "這個大概是針對托嬰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2521.wav", + "text": "托嬰中心的監視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2522.wav", + "text": "錄影設備的設置管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2523.wav", + "text": "可是因為我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2524.wav", + "text": "依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2525.wav", + "text": "幼教業老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2526.wav", + "text": "個人的肖像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2527.wav", + "text": "或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2528.wav", + "text": "資安保護上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2529.wav", + "text": "他們有一些不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2530.wav", + "text": "對於這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2531.wav", + "text": "因為這些監視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2532.wav", + "text": "攝影設備的設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2533.wav", + "text": "其實你們的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2534.wav", + "text": "還是要求業者自行管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2535.wav", + "text": "所以在管理上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2536.wav", + "text": "針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2537.wav", + "text": "業者的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2538.wav", + "text": "你們這邊怎麼看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2539.wav", + "text": "這個部分其實是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2540.wav", + "text": "我們要保護的這些幼兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2541.wav", + "text": "自己有沒有受到一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2542.wav", + "text": "虐待或者不當對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2543.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是從基於保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2544.wav", + "text": "角度出發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2545.wav", + "text": "過去許多案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2546.wav", + "text": "的確有設了監視器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2547.wav", + "text": "但是當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2548.wav", + "text": "我們去做調查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2549.wav", + "text": "就調不到他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2550.wav", + "text": "它都刪掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2551.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2552.wav", + "text": "所以我們才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2553.wav", + "text": "能夠上傳到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2554.wav", + "text": "雲裡面去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2555.wav", + "text": "代為做這種影像的保存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2556.wav", + "text": "而不會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2557.wav", + "text": "出事的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2558.wav", + "text": "就是強制它保存的期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2559.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2560.wav", + "text": "要要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2561.wav", + "text": "對這個我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2562.wav", + "text": "但是對於釋字第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2563.wav", + "text": "字第603號解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2564.wav", + "text": "因為現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2565.wav", + "text": "幼教業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2566.wav", + "text": "他們其實在招聘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2567.wav", + "text": "問題也是非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2568.wav", + "text": "這會不會造成一些寒蟬效應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2569.wav", + "text": "他們認為其隱私權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2570.wav", + "text": "跟人性尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2571.wav", + "text": "他們應該要受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2572.wav", + "text": "憲法第22條的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2573.wav", + "text": "實際上監管雲採雲端儲存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2574.wav", + "text": "甚至駭客的問題非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2575.wav", + "text": "在這方面有沒有相關的保護機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2576.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2577.wav", + "text": "其實在法律上面都已經規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2578.wav", + "text": "這一些都必須要設監視器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2579.wav", + "text": "監視器是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2580.wav", + "text": "我是說資料的保存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2581.wav", + "text": "還有保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2582.wav", + "text": "我剛剛解釋的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2583.wav", + "text": "他們業者自行保存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2584.wav", + "text": "沒有保存的部分沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2585.wav", + "text": "嘛但是要怎麼樣落實稽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2586.wav", + "text": "這是一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2587.wav", + "text": "\n第二個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2588.wav", + "text": "資料雲端的保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2589.wav", + "text": "因為這裡面的肖像權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2590.wav", + "text": "除了小朋友之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2591.wav", + "text": "還有這些從業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2592.wav", + "text": "所以現在就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2593.wav", + "text": "暗網的事情就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2594.wav", + "text": "他可能會去網站上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2595.wav", + "text": "再去做一些其他的使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2596.wav", + "text": "包含一些私密影像的保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2597.wav", + "text": "其實現在都是民眾最害怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2598.wav", + "text": "的加上這些托嬰托幼的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2599.wav", + "text": "他們這種寒蟬效應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2600.wav", + "text": "因為現在少子女化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2601.wav", + "text": "如果是國安危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2602.wav", + "text": "也要保護他們這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2603.wav", + "text": "但如果造成這個行業恐慌的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2604.wav", + "text": "其實對於他們在招募上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2605.wav", + "text": "也是有很大的困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2606.wav", + "text": "當我們選擇這些雲的業者的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2607.wav", + "text": "一定是要好好能夠被我們所監督的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2608.wav", + "text": "也就是說它的資安保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2609.wav", + "text": "必須要是足夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2610.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2611.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子給委員做參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2612.wav", + "text": "過去在20年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2613.wav", + "text": "我們希望消防隊的救護車上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2614.wav", + "text": "去裝監視器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2615.wav", + "text": "那時候大部分的消防人員是反對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2616.wav", + "text": "在當時在救護車上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2617.wav", + "text": "保護自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2618.wav", + "text": "對那時候他們比較沒有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2619.wav", + "text": "業者的溝通要做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2620.wav", + "text": "然後相關的法源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2621.wav", + "text": "跟政令的配套機制要能夠落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2622.wav", + "text": "不然我覺得也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2623.wav", + "text": "也會造成很多社會的分裂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2624.wav", + "text": "但是我是覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2625.wav", + "text": "還是應該要完整地來去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2626.wav", + "text": "這兩個案子是不是併一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2627.wav", + "text": "你們兩個都有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2628.wav", + "text": "沒關係我保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2629.wav", + "text": "兩個案都是通刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2630.wav", + "text": "我這案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2631.wav", + "text": "我想要針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2632.wav", + "text": "跟民眾黨的黨團提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2633.wav", + "text": "當然你們說的對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2634.wav", + "text": "希望用一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2635.wav", + "text": "就是把監視影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2636.wav", + "text": "其實我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2637.wav", + "text": "過去衛福部的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2638.wav", + "text": "你們委託的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2639.wav", + "text": "因為你們也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2640.wav", + "text": "嘛業者會發生什麼樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2641.wav", + "text": "其實你們也不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2642.wav", + "text": "那未來我們把這些幼兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2643.wav", + "text": "以及幼保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2644.wav", + "text": "都交給你們衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2645.wav", + "text": "然後產生一個監管雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2646.wav", + "text": "來統一處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2647.wav", + "text": "未來如果這些影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2648.wav", + "text": "發生什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2649.wav", + "text": "那我們都沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2650.wav", + "text": "相關法令上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2651.wav", + "text": "都沒有辦法做到完全的監管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2652.wav", + "text": "尤其是在我們政府部門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2653.wav", + "text": "資料外洩上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2654.wav", + "text": "我們現在也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2655.wav", + "text": "完全有效地解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2656.wav", + "text": "完全有效解決之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2657.wav", + "text": "我們如果過度授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2658.wav", + "text": "給衛福部的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2659.wav", + "text": "你們怎麼樣保障我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2660.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2661.wav", + "text": "因為我們兩案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2662.wav", + "text": "針對這個內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2663.wav", + "text": "我們不希望是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2664.wav", + "text": "保留的話就是只是去表決而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2665.wav", + "text": "我們不希望是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2666.wav", + "text": "這個案子是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2667.wav", + "text": "現在法律的規定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2668.wav", + "text": "所有的托嬰中心都要設監視器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2669.wav", + "text": "該設的地方都要設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2670.wav", + "text": "包括嬰兒車上面都會設監視器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2671.wav", + "text": "而且有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2672.wav", + "text": "它這個硬碟要保留多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2673.wav", + "text": "這個都有法律規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2674.wav", + "text": "如果業者沒有按照法律規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2675.wav", + "text": "沒有設監視器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2676.wav", + "text": "或是它的硬碟沒有保存多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2677.wav", + "text": "這都有罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2678.wav", + "text": "啦它要被罰的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2679.wav", + "text": "這違法的違規的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2680.wav", + "text": "現在這一筆2.6億的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2681.wav", + "text": "是要做什麼它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2682.wav", + "text": "它要把它弄一個全國的監視雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2683.wav", + "text": "就是把所有各地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2684.wav", + "text": "各個業者托嬰中心的硬碟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2685.wav", + "text": "這2.6億是要做這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2686.wav", + "text": "那其實是重複的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2687.wav", + "text": "啦因為各個託嬰中心法律規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2688.wav", + "text": "強制就是要保存硬碟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2689.wav", + "text": "之前不保存是因為沒有法制化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2690.wav", + "text": "我們常常去查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2691.wav", + "text": "不然你要被罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2692.wav", + "text": "去巡查抽查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2693.wav", + "text": "只要它沒保存就要被罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2694.wav", + "text": "所以業者都知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2695.wav", + "text": "現在我們擔心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2696.wav", + "text": "第一個花2.6億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2697.wav", + "text": "重複再把這些資料集中起來放雲端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2698.wav", + "text": "2.6億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2699.wav", + "text": "幾乎都是在做這個雲端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2700.wav", + "text": "管理費是縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2701.wav", + "text": "去管理那個雲端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2702.wav", + "text": "態度上也沒有很支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2703.wav", + "text": "家長認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2704.wav", + "text": "我的小孩子在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2705.wav", + "text": "你知道托嬰中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2706.wav", + "text": "要幫忙洗澡把屎把尿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2707.wav", + "text": "通通看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2708.wav", + "text": "萬一有駭客本來分散的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2709.wav", + "text": "還比較安全一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2710.wav", + "text": "你現在把全國集中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2711.wav", + "text": "一列出來通通被看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2712.wav", + "text": "所以反而危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2713.wav", + "text": "集中的資料有比較安全嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2714.wav", + "text": "對駭客來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2715.wav", + "text": "集中對駭客最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2716.wav", + "text": "他只要突破這個監視雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2717.wav", + "text": "就全部看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2718.wav", + "text": "所以這有比較安全嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2719.wav", + "text": "我的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2720.wav", + "text": "然後專案報告之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2721.wav", + "text": "公聽會開完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2722.wav", + "text": "大家比較有共識之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2723.wav", + "text": "解凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2724.wav", + "text": "也不要去刪除它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2725.wav", + "text": "全數凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2726.wav", + "text": "那不就是先不要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2727.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2728.wav", + "text": "你現在說的大家都聽得懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2729.wav", + "text": "但你只講一部分而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2730.wav", + "text": "這是法律規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2731.wav", + "text": "對啊現在人家已經在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2732.wav", + "text": "你聽我講我都在聽你講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2733.wav", + "text": "好像是輪到我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2734.wav", + "text": "剛剛院長已經裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2735.wav", + "text": "順序應該是換我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2736.wav", + "text": "你但沒關係讓他講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2737.wav", + "text": "剛才邱臣遠總召你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2738.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2739.wav", + "text": "這可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2740.wav", + "text": "要好好討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2741.wav", + "text": "兒少權益保護法第77條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2742.wav", + "text": "已經立法通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2743.wav", + "text": "一定要整個監視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2744.wav", + "text": "錄影保留30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2745.wav", + "text": "沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2746.wav", + "text": "但是你要瞭解常常有很多糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2747.wav", + "text": "還不會說話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2748.wav", + "text": "要調錄影帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2749.wav", + "text": "都調不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2750.wav", + "text": "是很高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2751.wav", + "text": "假如又站在幼兒的立場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2752.wav", + "text": "那是一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2753.wav", + "text": "兩個部分都要考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2754.wav", + "text": "大家要慎重來考慮這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2755.wav", + "text": "這可以全凍嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2756.wav", + "text": "我先問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2757.wav", + "text": "這2.6億都是用在這方面嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2758.wav", + "text": "2.6億是因為要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2759.wav", + "text": "1005百多家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2760.wav", + "text": "所以現在要把它上到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2761.wav", + "text": "平常不可以看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2762.wav", + "text": "有糾紛才可以調下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2763.wav", + "text": "操作不好所以不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2764.wav", + "text": "你是站在哪一個立場上講這個話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2765.wav", + "text": "我也跟衛福部溝通很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2766.wav", + "text": "很嚴重的公共議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2767.wav", + "text": "現在很多縣市都開始做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2768.wav", + "text": "臺中臺北新北都自己做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2769.wav", + "text": "了不相信學校就只能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2770.wav", + "text": "找縣市政府來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2771.wav", + "text": "你要把它全部停下來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2772.wav", + "text": "我覺得大家要好好考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2773.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2774.wav", + "text": "違憲不違憲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2775.wav", + "text": "嘛這很重要公共領域的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2776.wav", + "text": "所以大家要冷靜想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2777.wav", + "text": "我知道他們也想來陳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2778.wav", + "text": "所以現在全國統一來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2779.wav", + "text": "嘛然後在雲端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2780.wav", + "text": "你說會被盜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2781.wav", + "text": "反而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2782.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2783.wav", + "text": "沒有我講一下這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2784.wav", + "text": "我不知道現場的狀況怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2785.wav", + "text": "但是我自己是三個小孩子的父親" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2786.wav", + "text": "我的小朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2787.wav", + "text": "很多也都是學齡前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2788.wav", + "text": "我也很瞭解家長的心情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2789.wav", + "text": "我覺得現在最大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2790.wav", + "text": "是什麼就是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2791.wav", + "text": "監管雲的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2792.wav", + "text": "全部要上傳雲端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2793.wav", + "text": "家長不信任老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2794.wav", + "text": "老師不信任家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2795.wav", + "text": "然後民眾不信任政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2796.wav", + "text": "現在中央政府訂的這個法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2797.wav", + "text": "要全部上到雲端的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2798.wav", + "text": "我們現在擔心的是資料保護的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2799.wav", + "text": "小朋友可能在幼稚園的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2800.wav", + "text": "老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2801.wav", + "text": "可能有換尿布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2802.wav", + "text": "睡午覺或是他們有一些私人影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2803.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有辦法能夠落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2804.wav", + "text": "剛剛上一個協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2805.wav", + "text": "光法務部暗網的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2806.wav", + "text": "這種假訊息的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2807.wav", + "text": "駭客的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2808.wav", + "text": "只要發生了之後各部會甩鍋來甩鍋去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2809.wav", + "text": "你根本沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2810.wav", + "text": "你要求他們做當然沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2811.wav", + "text": "業者一定會有它不同的反應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2812.wav", + "text": "可是問題是管理上有問題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2813.wav", + "text": "這些個人資料的保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2814.wav", + "text": "資安的問題還有肖像的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2815.wav", + "text": "甚至會不會拿來用其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2816.wav", + "text": "你如果有駭客駭進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2817.wav", + "text": "把你的資料全部拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2818.wav", + "text": "然後把它放在網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2819.wav", + "text": "你現在小孩多大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2820.wav", + "text": "你會比我瞭解嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2821.wav", + "text": "小孩都沒辦法說話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2822.wav", + "text": "如果說換尿布或是他在睡午覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2823.wav", + "text": "甚至這些老師很多也是女性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2824.wav", + "text": "這些都在監管的範圍內嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2825.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有訂清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2826.wav", + "text": "整天的行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2827.wav", + "text": "這個都沒有跟民眾講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2828.wav", + "text": "\n其實對民眾來講是資訊安全保護的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2829.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2830.wav", + "text": "\n第二個就是彼此信任的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2831.wav", + "text": "再來就是你們的社會溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2832.wav", + "text": "你有沒有辦法先跟這些業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2833.wav", + "text": "讓他們認為這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2834.wav", + "text": "是他們可以跟你共同去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2835.wav", + "text": "執行的我覺得這個才是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2836.wav", + "text": "不然到時候出了事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2837.wav", + "text": "業者甩家長大家還是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2838.wav", + "text": "彼此分裂及互相對立的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2839.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個政策在執行上就有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2840.wav", + "text": "加上現在這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2841.wav", + "text": "駭客跟資訊安全保護的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2842.wav", + "text": "如果你問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2843.wav", + "text": "個人的意見我覺得是整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2844.wav", + "text": "從法令上從系統上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2845.wav", + "text": "從技術上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2846.wav", + "text": "這個部分數發部有沒有角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2847.wav", + "text": "是不是也應該去做相關的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2848.wav", + "text": "那我這邊的案子是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2849.wav", + "text": "凍結做一個專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2850.wav", + "text": "來說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2851.wav", + "text": "接下來劉世芳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2852.wav", + "text": "我們兩個黨團提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2853.wav", + "text": "都是屬於凍結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2854.wav", + "text": "就表示其實對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2855.wav", + "text": "社家署所提的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2856.wav", + "text": "兒少權益保障法第77條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2857.wav", + "text": "來處理那我們也瞭解到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2858.wav", + "text": "有家長跟社工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2859.wav", + "text": "或者是跟這些幼保老師之間的矛盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2860.wav", + "text": "今天我們所質疑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2861.wav", + "text": "不應該完全由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2862.wav", + "text": "衛福部來一手承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2863.wav", + "text": "為什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2864.wav", + "text": "剛剛有提到我們現在查到的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2865.wav", + "text": "就是新北市臺北市臺中市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2866.wav", + "text": "臺南市及臺東縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2867.wav", + "text": "已經都在執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2868.wav", + "text": "那剛剛邱臣遠委員所提到的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2869.wav", + "text": "的保障或是對肖像權的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2870.wav", + "text": "這個部分當然要要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2871.wav", + "text": "他們做得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2872.wav", + "text": "\n我們也不會反對凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2873.wav", + "text": "但是不要凍結那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2874.wav", + "text": "因為你如果全數凍結的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2875.wav", + "text": "等於是明年度都沒辦法執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2876.wav", + "text": "這些所有的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2877.wav", + "text": "我們又會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2878.wav", + "text": "兒童青少年的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2879.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得第一個凍結可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2880.wav", + "text": "但是凍結不要那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2881.wav", + "text": "不管未來在立法院要舉行公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2882.wav", + "text": "其實我們都不會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2883.wav", + "text": "讓它可以更完整的保護我們的小朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2884.wav", + "text": "但是也可以來保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2885.wav", + "text": "這些托幼老師的工作權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2886.wav", + "text": "這兩者之間我們要取一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2887.wav", + "text": "中間的平衡點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2888.wav", + "text": "那你如果全數凍結的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2889.wav", + "text": "根本就是不同意這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2890.wav", + "text": "全數凍結的話要解凍還要花很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2891.wav", + "text": "講終極答案就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2892.wav", + "text": "不要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2893.wav", + "text": "我要先講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2894.wav", + "text": "是立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2895.wav", + "text": "保護行政院的預算終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2896.wav", + "text": "保護小孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2897.wav", + "text": "我們大家都知道現在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2898.wav", + "text": "根本不夠用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2899.wav", + "text": "我們在討論私人企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2900.wav", + "text": "的個資外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2901.wav", + "text": "例如有一些商城" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2902.wav", + "text": "我們聽到數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2903.wav", + "text": "它沒有辦法管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2904.wav", + "text": "到私人部門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2905.wav", + "text": "而在目前行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2906.wav", + "text": "資安人員也嚴重不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2907.wav", + "text": "的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2908.wav", + "text": "如何將各縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2909.wav", + "text": "人員的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2910.wav", + "text": "全部都交給業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2911.wav", + "text": "無法保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2912.wav", + "text": "所有這些幼兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2913.wav", + "text": "及老師的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2914.wav", + "text": "我們再去問數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2915.wav", + "text": "他們是不是又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2916.wav", + "text": "不足的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2917.wav", + "text": "嚴重不足的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2918.wav", + "text": "這一個所有小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2919.wav", + "text": "雲的設立問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2920.wav", + "text": "即便是各縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2921.wav", + "text": "已經有在實施的委辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2922.wav", + "text": "我們是否應該視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2923.wav", + "text": "目前的委辦情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2924.wav", + "text": "作為未來中央政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2925.wav", + "text": "雲設置的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2926.wav", + "text": "我認為這是有可以討論的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2927.wav", + "text": "接下來劉世芳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2928.wav", + "text": "如果劉世芳委員發言後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2929.wav", + "text": "還沒有共識我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2930.wav", + "text": "當然就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2931.wav", + "text": "剛才謝委員所提到的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2932.wav", + "text": "縣市政府裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2933.wav", + "text": "只有一個臺南是民進黨籍的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2934.wav", + "text": "其他都是國民黨籍的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2935.wav", + "text": "我知道我是說視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2936.wav", + "text": "視他們先辦理的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2937.wav", + "text": "現在是說未來如果要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2938.wav", + "text": "當成兒虐等於是觸犯到刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2939.wav", + "text": "裡面的虐待兒童時應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2940.wav", + "text": "該要有完整的證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2941.wav", + "text": "而不是被這些人洗掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2942.wav", + "text": "所以事實上是中央政府跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2943.wav", + "text": "要互相合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2944.wav", + "text": "不是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2945.wav", + "text": "剛剛你所質疑的有關資安及個資問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2946.wav", + "text": "就讓它訂定得更詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2947.wav", + "text": "因為中央有一定的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2948.wav", + "text": "而每個縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2949.wav", + "text": "都各自有各自的標準的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2950.wav", + "text": "出了問題那才是真的大問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2951.wav", + "text": "資安人員就是不夠嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2952.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2953.wav", + "text": "我提一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2954.wav", + "text": "其實我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2955.wav", + "text": "所以是希望充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2956.wav", + "text": "各縣市也在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2957.wav", + "text": "把它集中起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2958.wav", + "text": "等於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2959.wav", + "text": "已經有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2960.wav", + "text": "現在是要把它弄一個全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2961.wav", + "text": "在一起的監視雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2962.wav", + "text": "有這個必要嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2963.wav", + "text": "還是就分散在各縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2964.wav", + "text": "才能達到目的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2965.wav", + "text": "你去補助各縣市做他們的監管雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2966.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2967.wav", + "text": "下午不一定要討論終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2968.wav", + "text": "終極答案大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2969.wav", + "text": "最後拿出來看是怎麼樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2970.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2971.wav", + "text": "下午再提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2972.wav", + "text": "他們提出報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2973.wav", + "text": "自己去負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2974.wav", + "text": "但是這個議題是兩面問題大家小心一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2975.wav", + "text": "我只是希望充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2976.wav", + "text": "這問題不是只有今天才存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2977.wav", + "text": "存在很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2978.wav", + "text": "他們一直在跟衛福部溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2979.wav", + "text": "我瞭解雙方都有一些看法啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2980.wav", + "text": "就是社會沒共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2981.wav", + "text": "我們才會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2982.wav", + "text": "剛才已經講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2983.wav", + "text": "就暫時保留下午再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2984.wav", + "text": "我們還有討論的機會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2985.wav", + "text": "案就暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2986.wav", + "text": "下午我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2987.wav", + "text": "二輪再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2988.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2989.wav", + "text": "接下來我們就環境部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2990.wav", + "text": "下午再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2991.wav", + "text": "好5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2992.wav", + "text": "剩50個案而已啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2993.wav", + "text": "大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2994.wav", + "text": "剩50個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2995.wav", + "text": "剩下50" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2996.wav", + "text": "50案我們處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2997.wav", + "text": "再來吃飯啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2998.wav", + "text": "現在我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/2999.wav", + "text": "環境部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3000.wav", + "text": "我先介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3001.wav", + "text": "薛富盛先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3002.wav", + "text": "介紹完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3003.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3004.wav", + "text": "我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3005.wav", + "text": "移動污染源環保金爐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3006.wav", + "text": "還是要請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3007.wav", + "text": "環團這邊來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3008.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3009.wav", + "text": "要提出公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3010.wav", + "text": "本席協調這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3011.wav", + "text": "是好就多溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3012.wav", + "text": "啦部長多溝通那我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3013.wav", + "text": "就繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3014.wav", + "text": "最後一句話還是要請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3015.wav", + "text": "部長去瞭解因為你剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3016.wav", + "text": "在質詢說你以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3017.wav", + "text": "主要都是境外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3018.wav", + "text": "這個真的是很有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3019.wav", + "text": "部長可以去看一下我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3020.wav", + "text": "前環保署的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3021.wav", + "text": "有關林園工業區臨海工業區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3022.wav", + "text": "的健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3023.wav", + "text": "他們的致癌風險加總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3024.wav", + "text": "加總都有超過千分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3025.wav", + "text": "之一喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3026.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分真的要請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3027.wav", + "text": "第217案併委員會決議辦理沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3028.wav", + "text": "\n第219改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3029.wav", + "text": "改凍結250萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3030.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3031.wav", + "text": "院長我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3032.wav", + "text": "院長我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3033.wav", + "text": "他已經保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3034.wav", + "text": "沒有我要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3035.wav", + "text": "呀什麼你保留就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3036.wav", + "text": "這你們有溝通完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3037.wav", + "text": "不是這個溝通完了怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3038.wav", + "text": "\n部長剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3039.wav", + "text": "質詢也提到今天要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3040.wav", + "text": "公布報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3041.wav", + "text": "嘛今天可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3042.wav", + "text": "那應該是第222案那個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3043.wav", + "text": "我今天質詢也是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3044.wav", + "text": "報告可以公布那你剛剛也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3045.wav", + "text": "質詢的時候是針對當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3046.wav", + "text": "前署長的那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3047.wav", + "text": "第221案應該是保留吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3048.wav", + "text": "因為在行政院那邊相關案子已經保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3049.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3050.wav", + "text": "行政院第42案也保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3051.wav", + "text": "沒有啊第221案為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3052.wav", + "text": "要保留請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3053.wav", + "text": "沒有要保留啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3054.wav", + "text": "沒有啊沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3055.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有共識這個性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3056.wav", + "text": "案這麼嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3057.wav", + "text": "本來就是要調查有什麼保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3058.wav", + "text": "的柯總召你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3059.wav", + "text": "你保留的原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3060.wav", + "text": "我保留的原因你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3061.wav", + "text": "要包庇嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3062.wav", + "text": "你要包庇你要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3063.wav", + "text": "縱容性騷嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3064.wav", + "text": "我們現在哪一個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3065.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼保留就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3066.wav", + "text": "\n第223案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3067.wav", + "text": "凍結二十分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3068.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3069.wav", + "text": "刪通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3070.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3071.wav", + "text": "刪通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3072.wav", + "text": "剛才都已經讓你講啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3073.wav", + "text": "不是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3074.wav", + "text": "柯總召很沒有道理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3075.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3076.wav", + "text": "是不是要鼓勵性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3077.wav", + "text": "交個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3078.wav", + "text": "我們都溝通過的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3079.wav", + "text": "有什麼問題呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3080.wav", + "text": "那個案子我們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3081.wav", + "text": "都溝通過了哪一個文字有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3082.wav", + "text": "你要講清楚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3083.wav", + "text": "我現在回到第221案啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3084.wav", + "text": "那個已經宣布保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3085.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3086.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3087.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3088.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3089.wav", + "text": "改凍結5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3090.wav", + "text": "改凍結5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3091.wav", + "text": "那要不要提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3092.wav", + "text": "提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3093.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3094.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3095.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3096.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3097.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3098.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3099.wav", + "text": "作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3100.wav", + "text": "處理結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3101.wav", + "text": "之後發布新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3102.wav", + "text": "那為什麼要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3103.wav", + "text": "\n院長都看過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3104.wav", + "text": "你們沒有共識我就保留沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3105.wav", + "text": "發布新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3106.wav", + "text": "為什麼可以發布新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3107.wav", + "text": "我們這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3108.wav", + "text": "發布新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3109.wav", + "text": "等到你們有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3110.wav", + "text": "拿來之後我就宣布通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3111.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3112.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3113.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3114.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3115.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3116.wav", + "text": "我有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3117.wav", + "text": "這文字要修掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3118.wav", + "text": "不不不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3119.wav", + "text": "部長我本來不想講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3120.wav", + "text": "107年時任行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3121.wav", + "text": "院長賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3122.wav", + "text": "親自至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3123.wav", + "text": "並宣布啟動濁水溪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3124.wav", + "text": "治理平台會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3125.wav", + "text": "揚塵的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3126.wav", + "text": "歷經兩期計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3127.wav", + "text": "投入21.7億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3128.wav", + "text": "106年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3129.wav", + "text": "降至110年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3130.wav", + "text": "僅2次的成績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3131.wav", + "text": "治理成績斐然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3132.wav", + "text": "這種選舉的字不要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3133.wav", + "text": "什麼不要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3134.wav", + "text": "你是看到賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3135.wav", + "text": "這些都是實情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3136.wav", + "text": "不然我們文字稍微調整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3137.wav", + "text": "這樣就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3138.wav", + "text": "好再調整一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3139.wav", + "text": "行政院長賴清德改成行政院可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3140.wav", + "text": "這樣就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3141.wav", + "text": "行政院長賴清德改成行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3142.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3143.wav", + "text": "改成行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3144.wav", + "text": "不要啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3145.wav", + "text": "107年時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3146.wav", + "text": "哪個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3147.wav", + "text": "選舉期間不要做這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3148.wav", + "text": "文字稍微調整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3149.wav", + "text": "第二輪再來講不可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3150.wav", + "text": "不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3151.wav", + "text": "那怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3152.wav", + "text": "做政策宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3153.wav", + "text": "我講都是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3154.wav", + "text": "假如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3155.wav", + "text": "有政策宣導之嫌的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3156.wav", + "text": "我們文字稍微調整總可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3157.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3158.wav", + "text": "你修正的文字在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3159.wav", + "text": "我沒看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3160.wav", + "text": "休息文字讓他拿出來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3161.wav", + "text": "調整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3162.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3163.wav", + "text": "不合理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3164.wav", + "text": "改一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3165.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3166.wav", + "text": "院長還有第221案喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3167.wav", + "text": "21案已經宣布了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3168.wav", + "text": "第二輪再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3169.wav", + "text": "第二輪再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3170.wav", + "text": "刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3171.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通案辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3172.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3173.wav", + "text": "好文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3174.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3175.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3176.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3177.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3178.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3179.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3180.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3181.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3182.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3183.wav", + "text": "有做文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3184.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3185.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3186.wav", + "text": "所以主決議就文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3187.wav", + "text": "二輪再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3188.wav", + "text": "二輪可以再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3189.wav", + "text": "啦二輪再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3190.wav", + "text": "不是說這樣就不談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3191.wav", + "text": "了有的可以到二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3192.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3193.wav", + "text": "下午二輪的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3194.wav", + "text": "關鍵性人物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3195.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3196.wav", + "text": "還好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3197.wav", + "text": "啦1點半2點都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3198.wav", + "text": "2點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3199.wav", + "text": "2點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3200.wav", + "text": "2點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3201.wav", + "text": "1點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3202.wav", + "text": "因為還要溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3203.wav", + "text": "不然你們來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3204.wav", + "text": "有一些要整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3205.wav", + "text": "所以原則上明天就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3206.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3207.wav", + "text": "禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3208.wav", + "text": "明天早上要整理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3209.wav", + "text": "要給他們時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3210.wav", + "text": "很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3211.wav", + "text": "禮拜一法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3212.wav", + "text": "禮拜二表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3213.wav", + "text": "所有人的行程都安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3214.wav", + "text": "下午兩點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3215.wav", + "text": "行政院所屬及各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3216.wav", + "text": "在剛開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3217.wav", + "text": "要先進行通案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3218.wav", + "text": "開始進行之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3219.wav", + "text": "我先介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3220.wav", + "text": "列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3221.wav", + "text": "李秘書長李孟諺先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3222.wav", + "text": "再來介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3223.wav", + "text": "行政院主計總處主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3224.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3225.wav", + "text": "大家要發表意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3226.wav", + "text": "主決議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3227.wav", + "text": "謝衣鳯委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3228.wav", + "text": "這一個要重新改寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3229.wav", + "text": "你是說可以做文字修正是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3230.wav", + "text": "對文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3231.wav", + "text": "我們講的很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3232.wav", + "text": "你們現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3233.wav", + "text": "反對���境備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3234.wav", + "text": "現在行政院有成立一個小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3235.wav", + "text": "明年度並沒有這個計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3236.wav", + "text": "這個寫清楚就好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3237.wav", + "text": "啦至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3238.wav", + "text": "我們沒有辦法接受你這樣的改法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3239.wav", + "text": "這裡面都在罵我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3240.wav", + "text": "說蔡政府作法顯然雙標你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3241.wav", + "text": "什麼偷跑之嫌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3242.wav", + "text": "整個文章都在罵我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3243.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以很清楚的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3244.wav", + "text": "我們就沒有在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3245.wav", + "text": "還是怎麼樣那個寫清楚就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3246.wav", + "text": "好好你覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3247.wav", + "text": "我們可以不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3248.wav", + "text": "可是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3249.wav", + "text": "也沒有這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3250.wav", + "text": "這個我們怎麼可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3251.wav", + "text": "數位部不要只顧你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3252.wav", + "text": "你要看看全文嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3253.wav", + "text": "你把國家賣掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3254.wav", + "text": "然後你只顧你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3255.wav", + "text": "來請唐部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3256.wav", + "text": "是因為這一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3257.wav", + "text": "一案從第三行逗號右邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3258.wav", + "text": "據查該計畫仍未獲行政院核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3259.wav", + "text": "然後一路到第二段的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3260.wav", + "text": "最後一個驚嘆號所謂雙標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3261.wav", + "text": "當時我們院核定的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3262.wav", + "text": "還沒有提供給外面參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3263.wav", + "text": "因為我們昨天才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3264.wav", + "text": "收到院的核定函" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3265.wav", + "text": "我們一收到馬上就上網公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3266.wav", + "text": "而且有提供給各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3267.wav", + "text": "所以我們具體建議從據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3268.wav", + "text": "據查該計畫仍未獲行政院核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3269.wav", + "text": "一路到第二段最後一個驚嘆號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3270.wav", + "text": "第一段第二段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3271.wav", + "text": "全部改寫都不要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3272.wav", + "text": "他們擔心的問題直接回答清楚就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3273.wav", + "text": "現在行政院核定已經沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3274.wav", + "text": "他也沒有把文字修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3275.wav", + "text": "拿來給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3276.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3277.wav", + "text": "為什麼只有給民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3278.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3279.wav", + "text": "你們重新寫一個好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3280.wav", + "text": "它前面沒有改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3281.wav", + "text": "了它只有改最後一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3282.wav", + "text": "耶它新的文字修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3283.wav", + "text": "我們都沒有拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3284.wav", + "text": "要寫一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3285.wav", + "text": "來找人來寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3286.wav", + "text": "溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3287.wav", + "text": "他講的又跟它這個不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3288.wav", + "text": "叫數發部誰來改一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3289.wav", + "text": "這個部分其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3290.wav", + "text": "昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3291.wav", + "text": "13日才核定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3292.wav", + "text": "所以我們在提案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3293.wav", + "text": "他的確當時是偷跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3294.wav", + "text": "昨天行政院才核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3295.wav", + "text": "那不諱言這的確是有偷跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3296.wav", + "text": "當然105年的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3297.wav", + "text": "其實當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3298.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3299.wav", + "text": "不然這樣耗著也不是辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3300.wav", + "text": "嘛文字要修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3301.wav", + "text": "就提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3302.wav", + "text": "把版本提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3303.wav", + "text": "文化部主管的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3304.wav", + "text": "首先介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3305.wav", + "text": "文化部部長史哲先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3306.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3307.wav", + "text": "第228案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3308.wav", + "text": "第228案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3309.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3310.wav", + "text": "就是100萬然後交報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3311.wav", + "text": "就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3312.wav", + "text": "委員同意修改文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3313.wav", + "text": "有啊修改文字可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3314.wav", + "text": "就凍100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3315.wav", + "text": "可是只有修改文字啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3316.wav", + "text": "這裡不是改主決議了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3317.wav", + "text": "改主決議了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3318.wav", + "text": "你們改主決議了啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3319.wav", + "text": "我現在就稍微修正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3320.wav", + "text": "在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3321.wav", + "text": "好吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3322.wav", + "text": "有溝通的我們還是照溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3323.wav", + "text": "不然他們那麼辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3324.wav", + "text": "來這邊又改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3325.wav", + "text": "以後他們就不溝通了喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3326.wav", + "text": "228案就改主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3327.wav", + "text": "決議文字修正沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3328.wav", + "text": "就保留對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3329.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3330.wav", + "text": "有沒有不保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3331.wav", + "text": "要不要再考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3332.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3333.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3334.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3335.wav", + "text": "案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3336.wav", + "text": "我們要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3337.wav", + "text": "246" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3338.wav", + "text": "作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3339.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3340.wav", + "text": "第246案修正哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3341.wav", + "text": "看一下好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3342.wav", + "text": "第246案有沒有修第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3343.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3344.wav", + "text": "245案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3345.wav", + "text": "\n第246案文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3346.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3347.wav", + "text": "第247案也是文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3348.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3349.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3350.wav", + "text": "他們都有溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3351.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3352.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3353.wav", + "text": "我們繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3354.wav", + "text": "討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3355.wav", + "text": "國家通訊傳播委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3356.wav", + "text": "主管部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3357.wav", + "text": "首先介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3358.wav", + "text": "列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3359.wav", + "text": "─國家通訊傳播委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3360.wav", + "text": "接下來請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3361.wav", + "text": "第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3362.wav", + "text": "對第1案有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3363.wav", + "text": "時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3364.wav", + "text": "第1案怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3365.wav", + "text": "修正的在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3366.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3367.wav", + "text": "有修正的文字嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3368.wav", + "text": "可不可以併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3369.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3370.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3371.wav", + "text": "他們同意嗎沒有修正是同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3372.wav", + "text": "就是沒有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3373.wav", + "text": "那併委員會決議辦理可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3374.wav", + "text": "好第1案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3375.wav", + "text": "特別費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3376.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3377.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3378.wav", + "text": "陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3379.wav", + "text": "特別費你提一案就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3380.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3381.wav", + "text": "對啊你那三個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3382.wav", + "text": "這些都是全數凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3383.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3384.wav", + "text": "來辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3385.wav", + "text": "不要再到辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3386.wav", + "text": "先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3387.wav", + "text": "等一下程序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3388.wav", + "text": "我們瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3389.wav", + "text": "這個都是特別費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3390.wav", + "text": "因為全數刪除當然不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3391.wav", + "text": "要不要說明一下請他們說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3392.wav", + "text": "為什麼三個案都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3393.wav", + "text": "內容不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3394.wav", + "text": "內容不一樣我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3395.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3396.wav", + "text": "民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3397.wav", + "text": "案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3398.wav", + "text": "我們要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3399.wav", + "text": "都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3400.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3401.wav", + "text": "我們表決的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3402.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3403.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3404.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3405.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3406.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3407.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3408.wav", + "text": "撤案可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3409.wav", + "text": "這麼多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3410.wav", + "text": "總召是說撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3411.wav", + "text": "都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3412.wav", + "text": "我就保留啦好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3413.wav", + "text": "全數保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3414.wav", + "text": "那就保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3415.wav", + "text": "來保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3416.wav", + "text": "這個都是謝書記長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3417.wav", + "text": "要撤一兩案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3418.wav", + "text": "撤一兩案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3419.wav", + "text": "我們全部都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3420.wav", + "text": "第22案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3421.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3422.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3423.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3424.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3425.wav", + "text": "國家運輸安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3426.wav", + "text": "調查委員會主管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3427.wav", + "text": "列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3428.wav", + "text": "國家運輸安全調查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3429.wav", + "text": "主任委員林信得先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3430.wav", + "text": "\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3431.wav", + "text": "第31案我們可以同意刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3432.wav", + "text": "最後一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3433.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3434.wav", + "text": "可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3435.wav", + "text": "證物保留程序已經在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3436.wav", + "text": "對呀你們提出書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3437.wav", + "text": "報告就解凍了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3438.wav", + "text": "所以就這樣可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3439.wav", + "text": "好就刪最後一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3440.wav", + "text": "最後一句是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3441.wav", + "text": "100萬耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3442.wav", + "text": "經本院交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3443.wav", + "text": "同意後始得動支那句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3444.wav", + "text": "可以刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3445.wav", + "text": "就是最後一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3446.wav", + "text": "哪幾個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3447.wav", + "text": "並經本院交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3448.wav", + "text": "同意後始得動支這句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3449.wav", + "text": "可以刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3450.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3451.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3452.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3453.wav", + "text": "我就先處理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3454.wav", + "text": "書面報告就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3455.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3456.wav", + "text": "沒有啊沒有保留啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3457.wav", + "text": "我以為你是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3458.wav", + "text": "後面那一句刪掉是100萬刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3459.wav", + "text": "就是到動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3460.wav", + "text": "就是同意那兩個字拿掉就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3461.wav", + "text": "好啦就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3462.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3463.wav", + "text": "凍結100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3464.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3465.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3466.wav", + "text": "休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3467.wav", + "text": "現在要進行交通部主管部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3468.wav", + "text": "交通部部長王國材先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3469.wav", + "text": "\n現在就請大家看第75案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3470.wav", + "text": "75案跟院長報告已經跟委員這邊溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3471.wav", + "text": "倒數第五行開始之後刪掉文字改請交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3472.wav", + "text": "持續關注道路交通安全議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3473.wav", + "text": "同意改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3474.wav", + "text": "第75案就改主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3475.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3476.wav", + "text": "第77案這邊還是要凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3477.wav", + "text": "凍不併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3478.wav", + "text": "能不要經委員會同意後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3479.wav", + "text": "始得動支就刪掉那幾個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3480.wav", + "text": "好是併委員會決議辦理對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3481.wav", + "text": "經委員會同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3482.wav", + "text": "因為同意的話變成要專案報告就不是書面報告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3483.wav", + "text": "第第77案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3484.wav", + "text": "你這個是6億的十分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3485.wav", + "text": "先保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3486.wav", + "text": "我再跟柯總召溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3487.wav", + "text": "我可不可以說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3488.wav", + "text": "你這裡擬具書面報告OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3489.wav", + "text": "我們是說經本院交通委員會同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3490.wav", + "text": "這些字刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3491.wav", + "text": "就是擬具書面報告始得動支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3492.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3493.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們就寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3494.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3495.wav", + "text": "第幾案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3496.wav", + "text": "第77案怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3497.wav", + "text": "有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3498.wav", + "text": "我們先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3499.wav", + "text": "你們再跟邱總召溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3500.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3501.wav", + "text": "今天已經在第二輪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3502.wav", + "text": "已經同意凍結啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3503.wav", + "text": "他說最後那一句還是要保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3504.wav", + "text": "文字不要刪就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3505.wav", + "text": "提書面報告始得動支啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3506.wav", + "text": "就是經本院交通委員會同意不要刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3507.wav", + "text": "還要經過同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3508.wav", + "text": "可是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3509.wav", + "text": "部長這個不要刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3510.wav", + "text": "一般都是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3511.wav", + "text": "一般都是寫提書面報告始得動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3512.wav", + "text": "這個文字不要刪這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3513.wav", + "text": "我們在交委會也都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3514.wav", + "text": "不會寫經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3515.wav", + "text": "經交通委員會同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3516.wav", + "text": "這本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3517.wav", + "text": "不同意的話它還要再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3518.wav", + "text": "我們所有的都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3519.wav", + "text": "就是書面報告始得動都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3520.wav", + "text": "一般都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3521.wav", + "text": "院長先保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3522.wav", + "text": "不要再保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3523.wav", + "text": "有沒有凍結數沒有凍結數是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3524.wav", + "text": "先保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3525.wav", + "text": "凍百分之十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3526.wav", + "text": "那就保留表決好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3527.wav", + "text": "保留保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3528.wav", + "text": "\n請看第86案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3529.wav", + "text": "減列50萬凍結五分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3530.wav", + "text": "那就保留\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3531.wav", + "text": "交通部就到此告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3532.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3533.wav", + "text": "好啦他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3534.wav", + "text": "們都沒有辦法講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3535.wav", + "text": "介紹列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3536.wav", + "text": "數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3537.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3538.wav", + "text": "看第249案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3539.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3540.wav", + "text": "做得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3541.wav", + "text": "這個有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3542.wav", + "text": "有這些賴委員有簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3543.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3544.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3545.wav", + "text": "等一下請問數發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3546.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3547.wav", + "text": "合併加5,000萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3548.wav", + "text": "委員會是2," + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3549.wav", + "text": "做不到要議處首長喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3550.wav", + "text": "應該是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3551.wav", + "text": "這也是很大的數目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3552.wav", + "text": "做不到也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3553.wav", + "text": "反正這個是期待值而已啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3554.wav", + "text": "沒關係啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3555.wav", + "text": "做不到也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3556.wav", + "text": "沒有議處首長的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3557.wav", + "text": "就這樣通過\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3558.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3559.wav", + "text": "第266案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3560.wav", + "text": "因為這樣會變成7,00對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3561.wav", + "text": "加3,00" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3562.wav", + "text": "這樣可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3563.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3564.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3565.wav", + "text": "第266案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3566.wav", + "text": "是不是通案辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3567.wav", + "text": "有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3568.wav", + "text": "刪減的部分沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3569.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3570.wav", + "text": "它是屬於通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3571.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3572.wav", + "text": "它會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3573.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3574.wav", + "text": "通案辦理通刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3575.wav", + "text": "刪科目就通案辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3576.wav", + "text": "通刪可能會比這個多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3577.wav", + "text": "可能會比這個多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3578.wav", + "text": "5%就比這個多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3579.wav", + "text": "267案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3580.wav", + "text": "這個通案已經處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3581.wav", + "text": "我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3582.wav", + "text": "下午通案的第3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3583.wav", + "text": "是同樣的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3584.wav", + "text": "改成主決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3585.wav", + "text": "併通案第3案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3586.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3587.wav", + "text": "併通案第3案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3588.wav", + "text": "我們剛才第3案已經處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3589.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3590.wav", + "text": "改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3591.wav", + "text": "刪減數就併通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3592.wav", + "text": "我這樣講對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3593.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3594.wav", + "text": "269案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3595.wav", + "text": "減列100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3596.wav", + "text": "這個科目能不能在一般行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3597.wav", + "text": "269案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3598.wav", + "text": "減列100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3599.wav", + "text": "元科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3600.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3601.wav", + "text": "有意見就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3602.wav", + "text": "270案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3603.wav", + "text": "減列1,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3604.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3605.wav", + "text": "有溝通嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3606.wav", + "text": "這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3607.wav", + "text": "你們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3608.wav", + "text": "他們都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3609.wav", + "text": "因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3610.wav", + "text": "只要科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3611.wav", + "text": "可以自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3612.wav", + "text": "上面的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3613.wav", + "text": "項目的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3614.wav", + "text": "應該是OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3615.wav", + "text": "主計長這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3616.wav", + "text": "我是一個協調者我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3617.wav", + "text": "沒有個人的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3618.wav", + "text": "總好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3619.wav", + "text": "就是總數達到1,500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3620.wav", + "text": "這是賴士葆委員要求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3621.wav", + "text": "可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3622.wav", + "text": "賴士葆委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3623.wav", + "text": "都把你們抓去私設刑堂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3624.wav", + "text": "第270案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3625.wav", + "text": "就等於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3626.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3627.wav", + "text": "一共減列1,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3628.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3629.wav", + "text": "就加一個併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3630.wav", + "text": "決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3631.wav", + "text": "全部就是減列1,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3632.wav", + "text": "總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3633.wav", + "text": "計長這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3634.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3635.wav", + "text": "所以還是你同意才有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3636.wav", + "text": "不是我同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3637.wav", + "text": "改減列250萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3638.wav", + "text": "希望科目能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3639.wav", + "text": "提在工作計畫項下來減列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3640.wav", + "text": "就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3641.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3642.wav", + "text": "在科目計畫範圍內調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3643.wav", + "text": "就這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3644.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3645.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3646.wav", + "text": "就是說在第二行的民主網絡之連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3647.wav", + "text": "與創新這個工作計畫項下來減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3648.wav", + "text": "不減資訊服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3649.wav", + "text": "在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3650.wav", + "text": "第2目項下調節啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3651.wav", + "text": "你會不會寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3652.wav", + "text": "把它寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3653.wav", + "text": "要寫清楚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3654.wav", + "text": "我看科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3655.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3656.wav", + "text": "留彈性啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3657.wav", + "text": "對啊它上面寫科目自調嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3658.wav", + "text": "好不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3659.wav", + "text": "276案就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3660.wav", + "text": "通刪嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3661.wav", + "text": "好通刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3662.wav", + "text": "就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3663.wav", + "text": "��個有沒有溝通啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3664.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3665.wav", + "text": "這5,000萬不得了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3666.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3667.wav", + "text": "280案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3668.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3669.wav", + "text": "減列1,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3670.wav", + "text": "萬元科目自行調整對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3671.wav", + "text": "減500好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3672.wav", + "text": "哪一個1億2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3673.wav", + "text": "第280" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3674.wav", + "text": "減500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3675.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3676.wav", + "text": "它才1億2而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3677.wav", + "text": "已經同意1,000它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3678.wav", + "text": "它委員會是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3679.wav", + "text": "500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3680.wav", + "text": "前面已經減過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3681.wav", + "text": "這都溝通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3682.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3683.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3684.wav", + "text": "同意減列還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3685.wav", + "text": "那你們當初為什麼同意減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3686.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3687.wav", + "text": "希望能夠少減一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3688.wav", + "text": "這個項目已經減1,500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3689.wav", + "text": "250在這裡一直減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3690.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3691.wav", + "text": "因為他答應賴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3692.wav", + "text": "沒有啦減少一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3693.wav", + "text": "200好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3694.wav", + "text": "啦300" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3695.wav", + "text": "500啦你剛才就講500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3696.wav", + "text": "好啦500啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3697.wav", + "text": "這是1,500的還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3698.wav", + "text": "我是幫賴士葆委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3699.wav", + "text": "不然你這樣讓人家沒面子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3700.wav", + "text": "他已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3701.wav", + "text": "答應1,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3702.wav", + "text": "現在我們願意500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3703.wav", + "text": "前面已經1,750了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3704.wav", + "text": "那再減250" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3705.wav", + "text": "很好你不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3706.wav", + "text": "500啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3707.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3708.wav", + "text": "250啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3709.wav", + "text": "不要再出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3710.wav", + "text": ",000了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3711.wav", + "text": "這個250就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3712.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3713.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3714.wav", + "text": "第285案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3715.wav", + "text": "你們都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3716.wav", + "text": "你們都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3717.wav", + "text": "賴士葆委員沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3718.wav", + "text": "不是他們都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3719.wav", + "text": "他們都已經同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3720.wav", + "text": "我跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3721.wav", + "text": "已經有凍結十分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3722.wav", + "text": "這邊再減併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3723.wav", + "text": "併委員會就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3724.wav", + "text": "205就是你剛剛提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3725.wav", + "text": "什麼205不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3726.wav", + "text": "你這個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3727.wav", + "text": "你講的就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3728.wav", + "text": "293" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3729.wav", + "text": "因為委員會已經凍結十分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3730.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3731.wav", + "text": "要保留時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3732.wav", + "text": "292案就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3733.wav", + "text": "第285案處理併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3734.wav", + "text": "第285" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3735.wav", + "text": "第317案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3736.wav", + "text": "凍結十分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3737.wav", + "text": "委員會已經凍結2,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3738.wav", + "text": "併委員會好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3739.wav", + "text": "啦資安的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3740.wav", + "text": "這邊是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3741.wav", + "text": "十分之一就是改成書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3742.wav", + "text": "併委員會改書面好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3743.wav", + "text": "這個也很麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3744.wav", + "text": "因為他們都自己去簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3745.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3746.wav", + "text": "他們都已經去簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3747.wav", + "text": "跑到辦公室門關起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3748.wav", + "text": "問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3749.wav", + "text": "表示他可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3750.wav", + "text": "代表他是同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3751.wav", + "text": "對就是他執行上沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3752.wav", + "text": "他可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3753.wav", + "text": "他同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3754.wav", + "text": "到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3755.wav", + "text": "整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3756.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3757.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3758.wav", + "text": "問題是他同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3759.wav", + "text": "我們又不是幫他執行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3760.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3761.wav", + "text": "減少一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3762.wav", + "text": "凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3763.wav", + "text": "凍多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3764.wav", + "text": "5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3765.wav", + "text": "併委員會就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3766.wav", + "text": "委員會已經凍結2," + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3767.wav", + "text": "0萬了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3768.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3769.wav", + "text": "委員會又2,000萬等於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3770.wav", + "text": "凍結7,00" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3771.wav", + "text": "數目滿大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3772.wav", + "text": "很麻煩的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3773.wav", + "text": "因為總共五億多啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3774.wav", + "text": "併委員會好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3775.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3776.wav", + "text": "是資安的是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3777.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3778.wav", + "text": "資安還是慎重一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3779.wav", + "text": "凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3780.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3781.wav", + "text": "元沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3782.wav", + "text": "通刪科目就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3783.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3784.wav", + "text": "接下來第3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3785.wav", + "text": "也是通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3786.wav", + "text": "我們就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3787.wav", + "text": "通刪科目也通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3788.wav", + "text": "元又凍結十分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3789.wav", + "text": "大家要不要再評估看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3790.wav", + "text": "改主決議就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3791.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3792.wav", + "text": "哪一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3793.wav", + "text": "這改主決議就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3794.wav", + "text": "問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3795.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3796.wav", + "text": "問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3797.wav", + "text": "數發部自己去同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3798.wav", + "text": "是因為他們自己去同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3799.wav", + "text": "然後我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3800.wav", + "text": "他們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3801.wav", + "text": "新單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3802.wav", + "text": "他們應該不要同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3803.wav", + "text": "資安對民眾很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3804.wav", + "text": "結果他們自己去同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3805.wav", + "text": "那我們要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3806.wav", + "text": "不是怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3807.wav", + "text": "你不能為行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3808.wav", + "text": "卸責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3809.wav", + "text": "民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3810.wav", + "text": "應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3811.wav", + "text": "我們就只能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3812.wav", + "text": "不能幫他們增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3813.wav", + "text": "他已經有刪減了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3814.wav", + "text": "所以所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3815.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3816.wav", + "text": "提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3817.wav", + "text": "這是資安的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3818.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3819.wav", + "text": "資安不應該減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3820.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3821.wav", + "text": "不然他說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3822.wav", + "text": "就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3823.wav", + "text": "這是行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3824.wav", + "text": "應該說明的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3825.wav", + "text": "他們新單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3826.wav", + "text": "搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3827.wav", + "text": "為什麼你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3828.wav", + "text": "去那裡同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3829.wav", + "text": "了變成我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3830.wav", + "text": "在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3831.wav", + "text": "要替你們說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3832.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3833.wav", + "text": "因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3834.wav", + "text": "這個是給產業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3835.wav", + "text": "輔導經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3836.wav", + "text": "委員會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3837.wav", + "text": "凍十分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3838.wav", + "text": "如果併委員會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3839.wav", + "text": "經費以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3840.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3841.wav", + "text": "講同樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3842.wav", + "text": "因為3,00" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3843.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3844.wav", + "text": "好第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3845.wav", + "text": "第331" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3846.wav", + "text": "委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3847.wav", + "text": "也是凍結十分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3848.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3849.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3850.wav", + "text": "沒意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3851.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3852.wav", + "text": "結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3853.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3854.wav", + "text": "我們繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3855.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3856.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3857.wav", + "text": "我們2點半到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3858.wav", + "text": "已經超過二個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3859.wav", + "text": "大家蠻辛苦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3860.wav", + "text": "要休息喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3861.wav", + "text": "接下來應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3862.wav", + "text": "不多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3863.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3864.wav", + "text": "接下來行政院主管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3865.wav", + "text": "人事行政總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3866.wav", + "text": "首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3867.wav", + "text": "人事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3868.wav", + "text": "蘇俊榮先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3869.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3870.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3871.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3872.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3873.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3874.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3875.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3876.wav", + "text": "就告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3877.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3878.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3879.wav", + "text": "換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3880.wav", + "text": "司法院主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3881.wav", + "text": "介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3882.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3883.wav", + "text": "秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3884.wav", + "text": "吳三龍先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3885.wav", + "text": "院長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3886.wav", + "text": "各位委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3887.wav", + "text": "還有臺灣高等法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3888.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3889.wav", + "text": "高金枝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3890.wav", + "text": "女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3891.wav", + "text": "\n現在就請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3892.wav", + "text": "溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3893.wav", + "text": "有進一步的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3894.wav", + "text": "有溝通啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3895.wav", + "text": "有溝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3896.wav", + "text": "沒有通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3897.wav", + "text": "他說明天早上就會通了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3898.wav", + "text": "這些都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3899.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3900.wav", + "text": "那這樣就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3901.wav", + "text": "就全部保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3902.wav", + "text": "他說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3903.wav", + "text": "給他想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3904.wav", + "text": "他明天就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3905.wav", + "text": "不必啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3906.wav", + "text": "我們先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3907.wav", + "text": "算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3908.wav", + "text": "這個讓它凸顯一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3909.wav", + "text": "為什麼可以這樣搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3910.wav", + "text": "背後的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3911.wav", + "text": "讓社會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3912.wav", + "text": "那就7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3913.wav", + "text": "7個案都保留嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3914.wav", + "text": "對保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3915.wav", + "text": "7個案都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3916.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3917.wav", + "text": "那就告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3918.wav", + "text": "秘書長離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3919.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3920.wav", + "text": "謝謝秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3921.wav", + "text": "\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3922.wav", + "text": "考試院主管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3923.wav", + "text": "銓敘部部長周志宏先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3924.wav", + "text": "\n請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3925.wav", + "text": "改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3926.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3927.wav", + "text": "好同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3928.wav", + "text": "好同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3929.wav", + "text": "這個有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3930.wav", + "text": "有溝有通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3931.wav", + "text": "案就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3932.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3933.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3934.wav", + "text": "我們就看監察院主管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3935.wav", + "text": "監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3936.wav", + "text": "是秘書長李俊俋先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3937.wav", + "text": "\n請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3938.wav", + "text": "這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3939.wav", + "text": "謝謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3940.wav", + "text": "已經撤案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3941.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3942.wav", + "text": "那就撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3943.wav", + "text": "謝謝謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3944.wav", + "text": "我跟秘書長講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3945.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3946.wav", + "text": "秘書長我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3947.wav", + "text": "上個月質詢的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3948.wav", + "text": "後來有跟施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3949.wav", + "text": "施監委討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3950.wav", + "text": "的確是你們之前監察院的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3951.wav", + "text": "我跟你報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3952.wav", + "text": "那個案子已經發過3次新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3953.wav", + "text": "說明是認知不同而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3954.wav", + "text": "不是監委有疏失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3955.wav", + "text": "這個非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3956.wav", + "text": "可是報告內容是有錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3957.wav", + "text": "這個也不是我能處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3958.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3959.wav", + "text": "還是要跟秘書長公開說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3960.wav", + "text": "我回去轉達啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3961.wav", + "text": "那這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3962.wav", + "text": "你不用轉達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3963.wav", + "text": "我是讓你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3964.wav", + "text": "不要訴外裁判好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3965.wav", + "text": "因為施監委他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3966.wav", + "text": "會願意再重新調查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3967.wav", + "text": "表示本席在上個月的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3968.wav", + "text": "是沒有錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3969.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3970.wav", + "text": "就請參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3971.wav", + "text": "脫離現場好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3972.wav", + "text": "接下來就到法務部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3973.wav", + "text": "法務部部長因為另有公務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3974.wav", + "text": "他趕不過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3975.wav", + "text": "有打電話來請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3976.wav", + "text": "向大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3977.wav", + "text": "列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3978.wav", + "text": "蔡碧仲先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3979.wav", + "text": "第211案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3980.wav", + "text": "邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3981.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3982.wav", + "text": "213案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3983.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3984.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3985.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3986.wav", + "text": "我們就告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3987.wav", + "text": "需要解釋嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3988.wav", + "text": "要不要解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3989.wav", + "text": "首先是衛生福利部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3990.wav", + "text": "主管部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3991.wav", + "text": "衛生福利部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3992.wav", + "text": "薛瑞元先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3993.wav", + "text": "現在請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3994.wav", + "text": "看第1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3995.wav", + "text": "128案的主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3996.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3997.wav", + "text": "我們這個有修改文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3998.wav", + "text": "有修改文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/3999.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4000.wav", + "text": "溝通完了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4001.wav", + "text": "有簽字嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4002.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4003.wav", + "text": "看可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4004.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4005.wav", + "text": "看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4006.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4007.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4008.wav", + "text": "有修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4009.wav", + "text": "已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4010.wav", + "text": "謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4011.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4012.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4013.wav", + "text": "好同意第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4014.wav", + "text": "作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4015.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4016.wav", + "text": "就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4017.wav", + "text": "這也是文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4018.wav", + "text": "委員已經簽字了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4019.wav", + "text": "作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4020.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4021.wav", + "text": "就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4022.wav", + "text": "是通刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4023.wav", + "text": "這兩個案我們就通案處理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4024.wav", + "text": "一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4025.wav", + "text": "啊邱委員跟我的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4026.wav", + "text": "全國的監管雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4027.wav", + "text": "我們擔心有資安風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4028.wav", + "text": "所以還是希望他們做好社會溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4029.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4030.wav", + "text": "做好社會溝通再來解凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4031.wav", + "text": "這個案子就不必搞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4032.wav", + "text": "他們已經在溝通了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4033.wav", + "text": "那個資安那就是會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4034.wav", + "text": "大家都還很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4035.wav", + "text": "你要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4036.wav", + "text": "他們溝通我們沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4037.wav", + "text": "但不是溝通好再來解凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4038.wav", + "text": "不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4039.wav", + "text": "那這個案子就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4040.wav", + "text": "我們常常有這種解凍案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4041.wav", + "text": "委員會也常常在處理解凍案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4042.wav", + "text": "怎麼沒有呢這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4043.wav", + "text": "啊凍結就是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4044.wav", + "text": "這不是我發明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4045.wav", + "text": "總召你怎麼這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4046.wav", + "text": "對啦看凍多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4047.wav", + "text": "凍多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4048.wav", + "text": "現在是全數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4049.wav", + "text": "你全數凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4050.wav", + "text": "凍80%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4051.wav", + "text": "讓他們開始執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4052.wav", + "text": "然後就去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4053.wav", + "text": "這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4054.wav", + "text": "好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4055.wav", + "text": "要凍結多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4056.wav", + "text": "不是這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4057.wav", + "text": "是要敦促他們去做社會溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4058.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4059.wav", + "text": "現在人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4060.wav", + "text": "我都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4061.wav", + "text": "都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4062.wav", + "text": "因為來源我都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4063.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4064.wav", + "text": "但是這個有一個很重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4065.wav", + "text": "這不是只有一方面的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4066.wav", + "text": "家長端的你要考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4067.wav", + "text": "如何把這個制度弄好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4068.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4069.wav", + "text": "然後大家好好溝通是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4070.wav", + "text": "但是所謂的溝通不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4071.wav", + "text": "如外面所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4072.wav", + "text": "這個就不必搞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4073.wav", + "text": "這樣立法院廢掉就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4074.wav", + "text": "終極的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4075.wav", + "text": "終極的提案你提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4076.wav", + "text": "我們也提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4077.wav", + "text": "凍結50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4078.wav", + "text": "我們要不要同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4079.wav", + "text": "我們還要開黨團會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4080.wav", + "text": "前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4081.wav", + "text": "你們還要再開會喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4082.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4083.wav", + "text": "去院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4084.wav", + "text": "啦院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4085.wav", + "text": "要再溝通一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4086.wav", + "text": "現在是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4087.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4088.wav", + "text": "我想這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4089.wav", + "text": "大家高度關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4090.wav", + "text": "那最重要的還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4091.wav", + "text": "整個制度的完善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4092.wav", + "text": "個資保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4093.wav", + "text": "還有雲端的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4094.wav", + "text": "這才是最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4095.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4096.wav", + "text": "你們民進黨這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4097.wav", + "text": "我們大家來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4098.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4099.wav", + "text": "然後還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4100.wav", + "text": "工作要處理啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4101.wav", + "text": "就是暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4102.wav", + "text": "我們4個黨團繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4103.wav", + "text": "那看在什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4104.wav", + "text": "3天內還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4105.wav", + "text": "就是提出一個共同的提案出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4106.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4107.wav", + "text": "處理之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4108.wav", + "text": "好處理之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4109.wav", + "text": "處理之前嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4110.wav", + "text": "部長拿這幾個案子出來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4111.wav", + "text": "不行就院會處理嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4112.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4113.wav", + "text": "那就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4114.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4115.wav", + "text": "我們就把它列入會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4116.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4117.wav", + "text": "這個裁示就列入會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4118.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4119.wav", + "text": "那就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4120.wav", + "text": "\n請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4121.wav", + "text": "部長要不要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4122.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4123.wav", + "text": "要不要再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4124.wav", + "text": "剛剛那個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4125.wav", + "text": "其實第一個我們必須要考慮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4126.wav", + "text": "當時為什麼會有這個提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4127.wav", + "text": "他們要求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4128.wav", + "text": "因為小孩子不會哭訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4129.wav", + "text": "不會講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4130.wav", + "text": "尤其是我們的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4131.wav", + "text": "托嬰是2歲以下了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4132.wav", + "text": "所以這是為了保護兒童的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4133.wav", + "text": "這個監管其實是對雙方都有利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4134.wav", + "text": "因為我們的數字是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4135.wav", + "text": "要求都設監視器之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4136.wav", + "text": "到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4137.wav", + "text": "立案的是114案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4138.wav", + "text": "不當對待的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4139.wav", + "text": "其中有10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4140.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會起這個意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4141.wav", + "text": "需要有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4142.wav", + "text": "啦我們也認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4143.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4144.wav", + "text": "但現在重點是資訊的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4145.wav", + "text": "資安的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4146.wav", + "text": "還有國人的疑慮這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4147.wav", + "text": "個資外洩的問題已經太嚴重了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4148.wav", + "text": "而且現在網路駭客非常厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4149.wav", + "text": "被監管的資訊被不當利用到其他的網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4150.wav", + "text": "現在就有在錄對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4151.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4152.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4153.wav", + "text": "今天已經決定了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4154.wav", + "text": "我們3個黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4155.wav", + "text": "這個案子我們都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4156.wav", + "text": "我們會支持好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4157.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4158.wav", + "text": "就這樣謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4159.wav", + "text": "在處理之前再溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4160.wav", + "text": "但是部長你要把它想清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4161.wav", + "text": "他們4個黨團要寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4162.wav", + "text": "到時候你的意見儘量也能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4163.wav", + "text": "謝謝你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4164.wav", + "text": "介紹列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4165.wav", + "text": "環境部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4166.wav", + "text": "薛富盛先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4167.wav", + "text": "大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4168.wav", + "text": "只有1個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4169.wav", + "text": "請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4170.wav", + "text": "經有溝通了對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4171.wav", + "text": "這個溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4172.wav", + "text": "是現在才看到文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4173.wav", + "text": "說明就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4174.wav", + "text": "前環保署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4175.wav", + "text": "一級主管長期性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4176.wav", + "text": "陳情人都有跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4177.wav", + "text": "前環保署陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4178.wav", + "text": "張子敬先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4179.wav", + "text": "他都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4180.wav", + "text": "只有口頭告誡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4181.wav", + "text": "嘛那只有口頭告誡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4182.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4183.wav", + "text": "現在環境部有調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4184.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4185.wav", + "text": "\n有調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4186.wav", + "text": "處理的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4187.wav", + "text": "要對外公布嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4188.wav", + "text": "我想很多受害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4189.wav", + "text": "現在即使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4190.wav", + "text": "這個案子已經調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4191.wav", + "text": "但是他們對於加害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4192.wav", + "text": "還有對於包庇的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4193.wav", + "text": "我想一輩子都沒有辦法走出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4194.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4195.wav", + "text": "本席只是針對這個調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4196.wav", + "text": "要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4197.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4198.wav", + "text": "發布新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4199.wav", + "text": "關於發布新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4200.wav", + "text": "現在環境部把第一行刪掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4201.wav", + "text": "本席認為這個不應該啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4202.wav", + "text": "還有整個執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4203.wav", + "text": "包括院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4204.wav", + "text": "還要為包庇者來包庇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4205.wav", + "text": "所以第一行的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4206.wav", + "text": "請不要刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4207.wav", + "text": "這樣我們就可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4208.wav", + "text": "改凍結250萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4209.wav", + "text": "元有意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4210.wav", + "text": "就是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4211.wav", + "text": "不要刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4212.wav", + "text": "那這樣有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4213.wav", + "text": "我們還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4214.wav", + "text": "可以作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4215.wav", + "text": "後面的文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4216.wav", + "text": "我們可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4217.wav", + "text": "第一行的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4218.wav", + "text": "請不要刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4219.wav", + "text": "你們黨團有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4220.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4221.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4222.wav", + "text": "柯總召你這邊要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4223.wav", + "text": "我剛剛已經說明的很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4224.wav", + "text": "非常多的受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4225.wav", + "text": "針對張子敬前署長的包庇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4226.wav", + "text": "他們到現在還在看醫生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4227.wav", + "text": "還陷入被害的情境中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4228.wav", + "text": "現在只是公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4229.wav", + "text": "這個調查的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4230.wav", + "text": "把處理張子敬前署長的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4231.wav", + "text": "以新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4232.wav", + "text": "我們接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4233.wav", + "text": "發布新聞稿我們會來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4234.wav", + "text": "對啊你接受你就不要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4235.wav", + "text": "陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4236.wav", + "text": "文字稍微調整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4237.wav", + "text": "對啊我們只說調整同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4238.wav", + "text": "第一行的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4239.wav", + "text": "啊就這樣子而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4240.wav", + "text": "陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4241.wav", + "text": "我們其他的接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4242.wav", + "text": "你聽一下這個想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4243.wav", + "text": "其實完全都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4244.wav", + "text": "應該要嚴格的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4245.wav", + "text": "而且調查的結果要完全公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4246.wav", + "text": "但至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4247.wav", + "text": "到底事實是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4248.wav", + "text": "我覺得可以留待調查的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4249.wav", + "text": "調查完跟公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4250.wav", + "text": "大家就一清二楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4251.wav", + "text": "部長他們都看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4252.wav", + "text": "現在就是針對已經調查完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4253.wav", + "text": "發布新聞稿說明這樣而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4254.wav", + "text": "對所以就是在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4255.wav", + "text": "刪掉而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4256.wav", + "text": "前環保署長張子敬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4257.wav", + "text": "涉嫌包庇環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4258.wav", + "text": "之狼之性騷案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4259.wav", + "text": "這個部分不要刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4260.wav", + "text": "啊就這一句而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4261.wav", + "text": "啊這是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4262.wav", + "text": "陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4263.wav", + "text": "講幾句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4264.wav", + "text": "我們如果要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4265.wav", + "text": "通過的話黨團還是要有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4266.wav", + "text": "啦不過我在這邊講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4267.wav", + "text": "如果像這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4268.wav", + "text": "我也是贊成要嚴辦嚴查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4269.wav", + "text": "但是我們國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4270.wav", + "text": "整個體制是民主政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4271.wav", + "text": "你可以有刑事的處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4272.wav", + "text": "可以有民事的處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4273.wav", + "text": "可以有行政的處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4274.wav", + "text": "找機會到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4275.wav", + "text": "就是在國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4276.wav", + "text": "針對我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4277.wav", + "text": "的部長現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4278.wav", + "text": "但是如果放在預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4279.wav", + "text": "好像怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4280.wav", + "text": "沒有他只要發布新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4281.wav", + "text": "而且我們也沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4282.wav", + "text": "他一定有包庇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4283.wav", + "text": "我們只是說涉嫌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4284.wav", + "text": "他們只要把調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4285.wav", + "text": "的內容說明他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4286.wav", + "text": "怎麼處理這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4287.wav", + "text": "就這樣而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4288.wav", + "text": "這是預算提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4289.wav", + "text": "這不是質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4290.wav", + "text": "所以這個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4291.wav", + "text": "因為我們有刑事的追訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4292.wav", + "text": "也可以用民事的追訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4293.wav", + "text": "他也有行政的處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4294.wav", + "text": "沒有我現在只要問清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4295.wav", + "text": "為什麼這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4296.wav", + "text": "現在只是不要把這一行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4297.wav", + "text": "這個文字我們也接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4298.wav", + "text": "啊所以就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4299.wav", + "text": "為什麼要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4300.wav", + "text": "\n謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4301.wav", + "text": "我們今天的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4302.wav", + "text": "審查程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4303.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4304.wav", + "text": "113年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4305.wav", + "text": "中央政府總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4306.wav", + "text": "朝野黨團協商討論程序及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4307.wav", + "text": "決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4308.wav", + "text": "壹討論程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4309.wav", + "text": "協商順序為先行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4310.wav", + "text": "再依審查分配表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4311.wav", + "text": "所排定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4312.wav", + "text": "各委員會歲入歲出部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4313.wav", + "text": "送院會處理項目之順序討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4314.wav", + "text": "再行討論機密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4315.wav", + "text": "預算部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4316.wav", + "text": "已協商過之單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4317.wav", + "text": "如無未決之提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4318.wav", + "text": "則不再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4319.wav", + "text": "一113年度中央政府總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4320.wav", + "text": "預算案(含機密部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4321.wav", + "text": "依協商結論通過外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4322.wav", + "text": "其餘均照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4323.wav", + "text": "各委員會審查會議決議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4324.wav", + "text": "至送院會處理項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4325.wav", + "text": "協商有結論者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4326.wav", + "text": "依協商結論通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4327.wav", + "text": "協商未獲結論者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4328.wav", + "text": "交付表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4329.wav", + "text": "並依表決結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4330.wav", + "text": "另黨團協商之凍結內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4331.wav", + "text": "經併委員會凍結案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4332.wav", + "text": "依協商結論通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4333.wav", + "text": "本中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4334.wav", + "text": "\n二113年度中央政府總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4335.wav", + "text": "先行審議單位預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4336.wav", + "text": "其涉及附屬單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4337.wav", + "text": "預算營業及非營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4338.wav", + "text": "部分均暫照列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4339.wav", + "text": "列俟附屬單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4340.wav", + "text": "預算審議確定後再行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4341.wav", + "text": "\n三113年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4342.wav", + "text": "中央政府總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4343.wav", + "text": "歲出政事別部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4344.wav", + "text": "隨同歲出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4345.wav", + "text": "機關別審議結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4346.wav", + "text": "予以調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4347.wav", + "text": "\n四各委員會審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4348.wav", + "text": "(含機密部分)協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4349.wav", + "text": "均應依通案決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4350.wav", + "text": "辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4351.wav", + "text": "不再逐一於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4352.wav", + "text": "各機關協商結果敘明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4353.wav", + "text": "各機關均應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4354.wav", + "text": "切實依通案決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4355.wav", + "text": "核實分別刪減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4356.wav", + "text": "惟各委員會審查刪減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4357.wav", + "text": "數如逾通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4358.wav", + "text": "決議刪減比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4359.wav", + "text": "以各委員會審查刪減數為準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4360.wav", + "text": "未達通案決議刪減比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4361.wav", + "text": "則增加減列不足之數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4362.wav", + "text": "向大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4363.wav", + "text": "有關於通案刪減用途別的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4364.wav", + "text": "\n113年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4365.wav", + "text": "總預算案針對各機關所屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4366.wav", + "text": "通案刪減用途別項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4367.wav", + "text": "預擬如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4368.wav", + "text": "大陸地區旅費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4369.wav", + "text": "30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4370.wav", + "text": "\n二減列國外旅費及出國教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4371.wav", + "text": "訓練費(不含現行法律明文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4372.wav", + "text": "規定支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4373.wav", + "text": "5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4374.wav", + "text": "不含現行法律明文規定支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4375.wav", + "text": "不含農業部防檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4376.wav", + "text": "衛福部疾管署及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4377.wav", + "text": "1,000萬元以下機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4378.wav", + "text": "\n八減列設備及投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4379.wav", + "text": "(不含現行法律明文規定支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4380.wav", + "text": "資產作價投資及增資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4381.wav", + "text": "台電公司)3.8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4382.wav", + "text": "\n九減列對國內團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4383.wav", + "text": "之捐助及政府機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4384.wav", + "text": "間之補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4385.wav", + "text": "(不含現行法律明文規定支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4386.wav", + "text": "\n十減列對地方政府之補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4387.wav", + "text": "(不含現行法律明文規定支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4388.wav", + "text": "及一般性補助款)4%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4389.wav", + "text": "\n十一前述一至六項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4390.wav", + "text": "允許在業務費科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4391.wav", + "text": "範圍內調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4392.wav", + "text": "\n十二前述九至十項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4393.wav", + "text": "允許在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4394.wav", + "text": "獎補助費科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4395.wav", + "text": "範圍內調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4396.wav", + "text": "\n十三若有特殊困難無法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4397.wav", + "text": "依上開原則調整者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4398.wav", + "text": "可提出其他可刪減項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4399.wav", + "text": "經主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4400.wav", + "text": "審核同意後予以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4401.wav", + "text": "代替補足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4402.wav", + "text": "\n十四如總刪減數未達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4403.wav", + "text": "299億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4404.wav", + "text": "(扣除增資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4405.wav", + "text": "台電公司及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4406.wav", + "text": "撥補勞保基金後約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4407.wav", + "text": "1.12%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4408.wav", + "text": ")另予補足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4409.wav", + "text": "這和今年差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4410.wav", + "text": "大家手上都有也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4411.wav", + "text": "299億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4412.wav", + "text": "另外調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4413.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4414.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4415.wav", + "text": "對於協商結論草稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4416.wav", + "text": "我現在來宣讀一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4417.wav", + "text": "如果有意見再隨時歡迎提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4418.wav", + "text": "\n決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4419.wav", + "text": "一各黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4420.wav", + "text": "113年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4421.wav", + "text": "總預算案之討論程序及決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4422.wav", + "text": "通過針對各機關所屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4423.wav", + "text": "通案刪減用途別項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4424.wav", + "text": "(含行政院主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4425.wav", + "text": "整理之明細內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4426.wav", + "text": ")如附件2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4427.wav", + "text": "通案提案及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4428.wav", + "text": "各委員會通過之協商內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4429.wav", + "text": "(含保留部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4430.wav", + "text": ")如附件3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4431.wav", + "text": "(由各委員會整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4432.wav", + "text": "宣讀本及保留本)" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4433.wav", + "text": "上開附件1-2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4434.wav", + "text": "由財政委員會彙整送各黨團確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4435.wav", + "text": "附件3由各委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4436.wav", + "text": "送各黨團確認後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4437.wav", + "text": "送財政委員會附件1-3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4438.wav", + "text": "由財政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4439.wav", + "text": "於12月18日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4440.wav", + "text": "(星期一)上午10時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4441.wav", + "text": "前送議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4442.wav", + "text": "俾供院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4443.wav", + "text": "\n二本案於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4444.wav", + "text": "12月19日(星期二)院會進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4445.wav", + "text": "非保留部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4446.wav", + "text": "宣讀後均予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4447.wav", + "text": "保留部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4448.wav", + "text": "由時代力量黨團台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4449.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4450.wav", + "text": "各推派1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4451.wav", + "text": "發言順序授權議事處處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4452.wav", + "text": "每人發言時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4453.wav", + "text": "為3分鐘發言完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4454.wav", + "text": "各保留提案均不再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4455.wav", + "text": "即按通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4456.wav", + "text": "各委員會次序進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4457.wav", + "text": "各保留提案之處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4458.wav", + "text": "\n三本次協商各項提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4459.wav", + "text": "均予刊登公報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4460.wav", + "text": "紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4461.wav", + "text": "\n有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4462.wav", + "text": "換言之就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4463.wav", + "text": "表決前講一次就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4464.wav", + "text": "還有法案嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4465.wav", + "text": "決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4466.wav", + "text": "自113年1月1日起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4467.wav", + "text": "本院每一立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4468.wav", + "text": "及各黨團公費助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4469.wav", + "text": "之助理費增加4%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4470.wav", + "text": "每月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4471.wav", + "text": "各為45萬8,990元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4472.wav", + "text": "及57萬3,735元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4473.wav", + "text": "另適用勞動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4474.wav", + "text": "基準法所需加班費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4475.wav", + "text": "不休假加班費等相關經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4476.wav", + "text": "增加4%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4477.wav", + "text": "及11萬4,750元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4478.wav", + "text": "現在預算案協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4479.wav", + "text": "各黨團在簽字中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4480.wav", + "text": "跟大家說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4481.wav", + "text": "下星期二院會各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4482.wav", + "text": "要動員來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4483.wav", + "text": "及有關議案的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4484.wav", + "text": "為了當日表決順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4485.wav", + "text": "本次會議我們就循例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4486.wav", + "text": "不處理臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4487.wav", + "text": "\n現在各黨團都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4488.wav", + "text": "我們就繼續簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4489.wav", + "text": "請各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4490.wav", + "text": "簽完後就依協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4491.wav", + "text": "整理相關資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4492.wav", + "text": "俾供院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4493.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4494.wav", + "text": "是不是禮拜一早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4495.wav", + "text": "禮拜一早上沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4496.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有意見我們就早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4497.wav", + "text": "幾點1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4498.wav", + "text": "0點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4499.wav", + "text": "我們會發通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4500.wav", + "text": "那就10點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4501.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4502.wav", + "text": "所有的幕僚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4503.wav", + "text": "請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4504.wav", + "text": "趕快做資料的整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4505.wav", + "text": "以利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4506.wav", + "text": "接下來會議的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4507.wav", + "text": "還有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4508.wav", + "text": "果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15355/4509.wav", + "text": "協商結論有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/0.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商會議會議開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1.wav", + "text": "我看還不介紹等一下再介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2.wav", + "text": "中華民國113年度中央政府總預算案(公務預算部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3.wav", + "text": ")\n現在我們就開始請各黨團看有沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4.wav", + "text": "還是那句話其實國民黨有這誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/5.wav", + "text": "讓它能夠儘快完成審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/6.wav", + "text": "這是前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/7.wav", + "text": "第二個就是昨天民進黨是個執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/8.wav", + "text": "要面子要裡子還痛罵國民黨一頓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/9.wav", + "text": "這樣不是一個負責任的執政黨該有的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/10.wav", + "text": "廖婉汝提個案子要陸委會來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/11.wav", + "text": "介選傳得沸沸揚揚但是有沒有具體個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/12.wav", + "text": "你要講啊後來陸委會已經跟他說明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/13.wav", + "text": "他當場撤案啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/14.wav", + "text": "作為中華民國的國會議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/15.wav", + "text": "連邀請陸委會來說明這個提案內容都不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/16.wav", + "text": "我不知道耶今夕是何夕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/17.wav", + "text": "也就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/18.wav", + "text": "\n作為執政黨的黨團在柯總召率領之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/19.wav", + "text": "他的幹事長他的書記長竟然開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/20.wav", + "text": "抹黑抹紅國民黨的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/21.wav", + "text": "我不知道啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/22.wav", + "text": "我要問問柯總召啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/23.wav", + "text": "這麼多部長從國防部長財政部長主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/24.wav", + "text": "行政院秘書長也在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/25.wav", + "text": "還有唐鳳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/26.wav", + "text": "我長眼睛沒有看過這種執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/27.wav", + "text": "我不曉得在座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/28.wav", + "text": "5位部會首長長眼睛有沒有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/29.wav", + "text": "我相信你們沒有人有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/30.wav", + "text": "這麼霸道囂張的執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/31.wav", + "text": "柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/32.wav", + "text": "你領導的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/33.wav", + "text": "所以我的要求我的要求還沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/34.wav", + "text": "啊今天要進行後續的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/35.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/36.wav", + "text": "前提是柯建銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/37.wav", + "text": "總召要代表民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/38.wav", + "text": "正式道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/39.wav", + "text": "才有辦法走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/40.wav", + "text": "不然我們就繼續讓它流會吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/41.wav", + "text": "在休會前如期通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/42.wav", + "text": "這是我們的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/43.wav", + "text": "昨天擦槍走火之事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/44.wav", + "text": "應該分為兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/45.wav", + "text": "我想每一個立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/46.wav", + "text": "今年總共提了兩千多個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/47.wav", + "text": "要經過朝野協商以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/48.wav", + "text": "可能會撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/49.wav", + "text": "有可能改主決議嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/50.wav", + "text": "這行之有年大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/51.wav", + "text": "嘛昨天假如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/52.wav", + "text": "假如針對廖婉汝這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/53.wav", + "text": "到底記者會以後撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/54.wav", + "text": "還是溝通以後撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/55.wav", + "text": "都不論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/56.wav", + "text": "但是我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/57.wav", + "text": "因為在朝野協商中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/58.wav", + "text": "這種案子太多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/59.wav", + "text": "各黨有不同立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/60.wav", + "text": "嘛執政黨在捍衛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/61.wav", + "text": "它的執政價值以及執政政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/62.wav", + "text": "在野黨挑戰執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/63.wav", + "text": "是天經地義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/64.wav", + "text": "無可厚非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/65.wav", + "text": "兩邊互相攻防也常常有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/66.wav", + "text": "所以針對廖婉汝委員這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/67.wav", + "text": "不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/68.wav", + "text": "既然有撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/69.wav", + "text": "這個其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/70.wav", + "text": "不管誰在先誰在後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/71.wav", + "text": "凍結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/72.wav", + "text": "大可在朝野協商來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/73.wav", + "text": "不必拿來大作文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/74.wav", + "text": "有點操之過急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/75.wav", + "text": "他們有點操之過急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/76.wav", + "text": "啦來這裡講就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/77.wav", + "text": "你聽我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/78.wav", + "text": "聽我說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/79.wav", + "text": "凍結乃至於刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/80.wav", + "text": "我們都會找各部會趕快去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/81.wav", + "text": "在溝通還沒完成以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/82.wav", + "text": "我不認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/83.wav", + "text": "我們黨團成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/84.wav", + "text": "拿這個出來做攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/85.wav", + "text": "有點操之過急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/86.wav", + "text": "代表我們黨團表示抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/87.wav", + "text": "我們希望今天能夠走下去就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/88.wav", + "text": "另外一個案子就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/89.wav", + "text": "陳玉珍的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/90.wav", + "text": "他要砍4,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/91.wav", + "text": "元這當然匪夷所思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/92.wav", + "text": "這樣海基會就沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/93.wav", + "text": "了他的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/94.wav", + "text": "大家聽起來比較牽強很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/95.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/96.wav", + "text": "到金門去投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/97.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/98.wav", + "text": "中共阻撓讓臺商不能去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/99.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/100.wav", + "text": "招商就不是很理想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/101.wav", + "text": "陳玉珍用這個理由來刪減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/102.wav", + "text": "海基會預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/103.wav", + "text": "了但是沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/104.wav", + "text": "昨天晚上我在看電視的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/105.wav", + "text": "除非答應小三通否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/106.wav", + "text": "否則他堅持刪減到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/107.wav", + "text": "這一點沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/108.wav", + "text": "太多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/109.wav", + "text": "要討論的東西太多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/110.wav", + "text": "像我們進來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/111.wav", + "text": "記者就問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/112.wav", + "text": "我說你不用問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/113.wav", + "text": "我不會回答任何問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/114.wav", + "text": "所以我永遠秉持這個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/115.wav", + "text": "於他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/116.wav", + "text": "衝突乃至於不愉快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/117.wav", + "text": "第二次表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/118.wav", + "text": "抱歉以後我會告訴他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/119.wav", + "text": "技術要好一點不要這樣搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/120.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/121.wav", + "text": "好謝謝曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/122.wav", + "text": "曾總召完了再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/123.wav", + "text": "你這樣的道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/124.wav", + "text": "我接受了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/125.wav", + "text": "但是我要問您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/126.wav", + "text": "國民黨長期執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/127.wav", + "text": "會這樣對待在野黨嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/128.wav", + "text": "罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/129.wav", + "text": "還罵人家一頓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/130.wav", + "text": "我還沒有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/131.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/132.wav", + "text": "昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/133.wav", + "text": "把個人的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/134.wav", + "text": "拿來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/135.wav", + "text": "當作阻擾我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/136.wav", + "text": "都已經這麼久了知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/137.wav", + "text": "預算的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/138.wav", + "text": "只是初步的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/139.wav", + "text": "在院長預算協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/140.wav", + "text": "的時候才會請所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/141.wav", + "text": "部會來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/142.wav", + "text": "甚至有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/143.wav", + "text": "部會已經來我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/144.wav", + "text": "辦公室在昨天之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/145.wav", + "text": "都已經來辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/146.wav", + "text": "了有一些預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/147.wav", + "text": "刪減案也已經都併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/148.wav", + "text": "委員會的刪減案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/149.wav", + "text": "處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/150.wav", + "text": "我們都在加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/151.wav", + "text": "政府預算審理的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/152.wav", + "text": "沒有想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/153.wav", + "text": "要破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/154.wav", + "text": "都已經是慣例的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/155.wav", + "text": "要拿來當作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/156.wav", + "text": "指稱我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/157.wav", + "text": "個人的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/158.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是非常不當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/159.wav", + "text": "這會破���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/160.wav", + "text": "整個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/161.wav", + "text": "互信的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/162.wav", + "text": "這樣子大家怎麼協商下去呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/163.wav", + "text": "我們知道給在野黨協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/164.wav", + "text": "是在立法院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/165.wav", + "text": "你們過半數以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/166.wav", + "text": "也要給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/167.wav", + "text": "在野的小黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/168.wav", + "text": "有表達意見的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/169.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/170.wav", + "text": "如果這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/171.wav", + "text": "怎麼協商下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/172.wav", + "text": "如果破壞那種互信的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/173.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/174.wav", + "text": "你回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/175.wav", + "text": "剛才所發言的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/176.wav", + "text": "的過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/177.wav", + "text": "我在這裡30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/178.wav", + "text": "和當在野黨的時間各一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/179.wav", + "text": "但是做總召只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/180.wav", + "text": "有20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/181.wav", + "text": "所以我非常瞭解立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/182.wav", + "text": "這是一個政治的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/183.wav", + "text": "競技場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/184.wav", + "text": "但是有一些潛規則大家還是要守著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/185.wav", + "text": "比如說以前沒有直播的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/186.wav", + "text": "我跟任何人協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/187.wav", + "text": "到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/188.wav", + "text": "我們私下談的或是在協商中談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/189.wav", + "text": "我絕對不會出去拿來做新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/190.wav", + "text": "或是去攻擊人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/191.wav", + "text": "這是我長期以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/192.wav", + "text": "所以大家才有互信的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/193.wav", + "text": "這樣就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/194.wav", + "text": "啦因為現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/195.wav", + "text": "網路的時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/196.wav", + "text": "所以消息資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/197.wav", + "text": "傳遞很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/198.wav", + "text": "馬上有些質疑的新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/199.wav", + "text": "過去也沒有這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/200.wav", + "text": "所以我在這裡還是比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/201.wav", + "text": "總預算通過就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/202.wav", + "text": "我們要成比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/203.wav", + "text": "不成比例的說法全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/204.wav", + "text": "對院長也不好對整個國家也不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/205.wav", + "text": "我已經講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/206.wav", + "text": "我們會秉持這個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/207.wav", + "text": "我們就不要拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/208.wav", + "text": "彼此攻擊這樣大家才有互信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/209.wav", + "text": "嘛過去你說國民黨長期執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/210.wav", + "text": "國民黨長期執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/211.wav", + "text": "我民國82年進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/212.wav", + "text": "到2000年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/213.wav", + "text": "都是國民黨執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/214.wav", + "text": "那時候我們現在執政比較是案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/215.wav", + "text": "然後各部長去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/216.wav", + "text": "過去根本沒有這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/217.wav", + "text": "根本過去就是坐下來直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/218.wav", + "text": "大家唇槍舌戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/219.wav", + "text": "因為現在的環境變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/220.wav", + "text": "不一樣了有所謂的公督盟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/221.wav", + "text": "提案數所以大家一直製造案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/222.wav", + "text": "像去年總預算大概四五千案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/223.wav", + "text": "到後來再溝通再一直少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/224.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/225.wav", + "text": "提案有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/226.wav", + "text": "的像過去曾經也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/227.wav", + "text": "1個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/228.wav", + "text": "拆成50個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/229.wav", + "text": "一樣刪減0.10.20.30.40.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/230.wav", + "text": "這樣搞法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/231.wav", + "text": "這是衝量給公督盟看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/232.wav", + "text": "的所以立法委員要做自己比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/233.wav", + "text": "我想我們共同這樣勉勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/234.wav", + "text": "勵今天我們對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/235.wav", + "text": "在協商中的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/236.wav", + "text": "在溝通中的不應該拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/237.wav", + "text": "彼此攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/238.wav", + "text": "等到表決完畢要罵再來罵也可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/239.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/240.wav", + "text": "我們就繼續走走下去好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/241.wav", + "text": "是正人君子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/242.wav", + "text": "這你自己講的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/243.wav", + "text": "他們還有伏筆呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/244.wav", + "text": "等三讀通過之後會拿出來操作呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/245.wav", + "text": "還會拿來罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/246.wav", + "text": "我講的很實情喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/247.wav", + "text": "立法院大家都要各負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/248.wav", + "text": "包括今天最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/249.wav", + "text": "我們上台講我們的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/250.wav", + "text": "你們上台講你的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/251.wav", + "text": "就大家罵嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/252.wav", + "text": "即便院會已經結束以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/253.wav", + "text": "有人再出來開記者會再罵一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/254.wav", + "text": "因為坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/255.wav", + "text": "法案是很專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/256.wav", + "text": "從一個角度看以管窺豹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/257.wav", + "text": "從另外一個角度看是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/258.wav", + "text": "所以才會造成政治上很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/259.wav", + "text": "衝突和糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/260.wav", + "text": "因為要很內行看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/261.wav", + "text": "全貌的事實上不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/262.wav", + "text": "我持平而論講啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/263.wav", + "text": "讓徐巧芯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/264.wav", + "text": "有人跑來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/265.wav", + "text": "這也不大好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/266.wav", + "text": "那我們大家共勉之好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/267.wav", + "text": "我們把總預算弄完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/268.wav", + "text": "但是我在這裡建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/269.wav", + "text": "在進行以前可能我們要先談一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/270.wav", + "text": "因為總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/271.wav", + "text": "在整個會期這樣審完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/272.wav", + "text": "總預算是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/273.wav", + "text": "2兆8,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/274.wav", + "text": "這樣叫做對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/275.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天要先談一個總數是什麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/276.wav", + "text": "就今天要談總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/277.wav", + "text": "先談還是明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/278.wav", + "text": "我們談一個總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/279.wav", + "text": "審查預算都有程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/280.wav", + "text": "院長在這裡主持這麼久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/281.wav", + "text": "從通案開始談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/282.wav", + "text": "有時候談不下去就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/283.wav", + "text": "各位要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/284.wav", + "text": "就全部要結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/285.wav", + "text": "我們還有一個法案還沒處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/286.wav", + "text": "就是所得稅法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/287.wav", + "text": "那還是要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/288.wav", + "text": "該通過的法案都處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/289.wav", + "text": "我們希望這一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/290.wav", + "text": "畫上一個圓滿的句號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/291.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/292.wav", + "text": "院長時力黨團在問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/293.wav", + "text": "因為昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/294.wav", + "text": "執政黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/295.wav", + "text": "發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/296.wav", + "text": "發文不當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/297.wav", + "text": "所以我們延宕了昨天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/298.wav", + "text": "今天我們協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/299.wav", + "text": "要不要再繼續進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/300.wav", + "text": "預算提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/301.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/302.wav", + "text": "再審內政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/303.wav", + "text": "一直加班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/304.wav", + "text": "你看大家都站在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/305.wav", + "text": "殷殷期盼他們的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/306.wav", + "text": "能夠有一個著落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/307.wav", + "text": "所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/308.wav", + "text": "我們先談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/309.wav", + "text": "我們明天早上來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/310.wav", + "text": "刪減數多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/311.wav", + "text": "這個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/312.wav", + "text": "然後今天從通案開始談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/313.wav", + "text": "第一組第二組之後一直下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/314.wav", + "text": "嘛現在講要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/315.wav", + "text": "開到幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/316.wav", + "text": "這樣啦明天後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/317.wav", + "text": "好我有一個要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/318.wav", + "text": "啦這幾天在協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/319.wav", + "text": "希望民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/320.wav", + "text": "不要再禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/321.wav", + "text": "禁止他們來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/322.wav", + "text": "了第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/323.wav", + "text": "10點不要到12點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/324.wav", + "text": "10點就很晚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/325.wav", + "text": "今天最晚10點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/326.wav", + "text": "說部會有去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/327.wav", + "text": "心結還沒有打開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/328.wav", + "text": "現在應該心結打開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/329.wav", + "text": "趕快送出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/330.wav", + "text": "他們一直很認真在溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/331.wav", + "text": "今天下午也去溝通每天都在溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/332.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/333.wav", + "text": "因為我們也讓部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/334.wav", + "text": "本來是有兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/335.wav", + "text": "一個是說看晚上要到幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/336.wav", + "text": "另一個是23個通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/337.wav", + "text": "先解決明天再早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/338.wav", + "text": "那就把它講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/339.wav", + "text": "今天晚上到10點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/340.wav", + "text": "那明天幾點開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/341.wav", + "text": "明天早上9點過去都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/342.wav", + "text": "9點到幾點你講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/343.wav", + "text": "啊因為現在選舉到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/344.wav", + "text": "過去我們都是在這裡吃便當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/345.wav", + "text": "剩下4天而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/346.wav", + "text": "對講完嘛明��幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/347.wav", + "text": "9點到幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/348.wav", + "text": "9點到12點12點以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/349.wav", + "text": "休息半個鐘頭1個鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/350.wav", + "text": "嘛有時候發便當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/351.wav", + "text": "嘛這院長裁示就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/352.wav", + "text": "看速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/353.wav", + "text": "好要怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/354.wav", + "text": "要9點還10點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/355.wav", + "text": "如果23個通案講不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/356.wav", + "text": "就一直講講到完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/357.wav", + "text": "應該以時間為一個最基本的主軸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/358.wav", + "text": "啦大家掌握時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/359.wav", + "text": "這樣好好那我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/360.wav", + "text": "今天晚上就到10點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/361.wav", + "text": "大家沒有反對的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/362.wav", + "text": "啦這樣讓各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/363.wav", + "text": "院長等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/364.wav", + "text": "到晚上10點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/365.wav", + "text": "但是各部會很認真去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/366.wav", + "text": "那些部分你們趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/367.wav", + "text": "簽名送上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/368.wav", + "text": "這樣才會快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/369.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/370.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/371.wav", + "text": "就這麼決定啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/372.wav", + "text": "要進行通案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/373.wav", + "text": "行政院秘書長李孟諺先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/374.wav", + "text": "行政院主計總處主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/375.wav", + "text": "朱澤民先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/376.wav", + "text": "接下來財政部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/377.wav", + "text": "莊翠雲女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/378.wav", + "text": "再來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/379.wav", + "text": "數位發展部的唐鳳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/380.wav", + "text": "再來是國防部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/381.wav", + "text": "邱國正部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/382.wav", + "text": "好暫時介紹到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/383.wav", + "text": "好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/384.wav", + "text": "好我們請大家看第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/385.wav", + "text": "看通案的第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/386.wav", + "text": "通案的第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/387.wav", + "text": "是要增列3,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/388.wav", + "text": "這個是台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/389.wav", + "text": "是不是說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/390.wav", + "text": "保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/391.wav", + "text": "不用再說明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/392.wav", + "text": "說明一下好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/393.wav", + "text": "這個昨天有講過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/394.wav", + "text": "啦財政部在11月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/395.wav", + "text": "公布今年10月稅收3兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/396.wav", + "text": "其實這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/397.wav", + "text": "歷年來稅收超徵的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/398.wav", + "text": "平均大概都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/399.wav", + "text": "1,700億到1,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/400.wav", + "text": "也表示今年會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/401.wav", + "text": "再增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/402.wav", + "text": "去做一個相關的增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/403.wav", + "text": "財委會其實已經增列確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/404.wav", + "text": "為150億了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/405.wav", + "text": "稅收估測專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/406.wav", + "text": "所以明年的稅收跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/407.wav", + "text": "應該不會相差太遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/408.wav", + "text": "當時我們提這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/409.wav", + "text": "後來來溝通後是有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/410.wav", + "text": "可以增列100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/411.wav", + "text": "當時現場的官員沒有異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/412.wav", + "text": "但是後來好像回去之後有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/413.wav", + "text": "財政部國會聯絡人來本黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/414.wav", + "text": "溝通的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/415.wav", + "text": "表示這個100億的增列他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/416.wav", + "text": "歉難同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/417.wav", + "text": "所以希望撤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/418.wav", + "text": "撤案或是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/419.wav", + "text": "我們是覺得這樣一個溝通的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/420.wav", + "text": "其實影響了我們的互信原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/421.wav", + "text": "是不是可以增列100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/422.wav", + "text": "財政部要不要簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/423.wav", + "text": "如果沒有共識的話我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/424.wav", + "text": "好不好\n最主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/425.wav", + "text": "稅收超徵的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/426.wav", + "text": "其實多年來這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/427.wav", + "text": "當然3,000億這個數字可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/428.wav", + "text": "這個是已經確定的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/429.wav", + "text": "但是應該優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/430.wav", + "text": "還是透過發現金或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/431.wav", + "text": "某種可能對外界來講是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/432.wav", + "text": "政策性的買票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/433.wav", + "text": "優先還債的部分包含勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/434.wav", + "text": "勞保虧損的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/435.wav", + "text": "台電的問題這個是另外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/436.wav", + "text": "納稅人的錢去補這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/437.wav", + "text": "台電的財務黑洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/438.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為還是要優先還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/439.wav", + "text": "你後面的償還計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/440.wav", + "text": "以勞保為主的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/441.wav", + "text": "應該要把它納入後續的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/442.wav", + "text": "不管是主決議或者是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/443.wav", + "text": "整個預算提案的方向重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/444.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以請財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/445.wav", + "text": "簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/446.wav", + "text": "如果沒有共識我們就保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/447.wav", + "text": "好請莊部長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/448.wav", + "text": "主席以及各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/449.wav", + "text": "大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/450.wav", + "text": "我想這一個提案也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/451.wav", + "text": "督促我們第一個就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/452.wav", + "text": "做預算籌編的時候對於稅課收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/453.wav", + "text": "然後跟實徵數會接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/454.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分在113年估測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/455.wav", + "text": "我們稅課收入的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/456.wav", + "text": "財政部已經成立了估測專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/457.wav", + "text": "除了部本部以外還邀請相關機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/458.wav", + "text": "以及專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/459.wav", + "text": "來組成一個小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/460.wav", + "text": "然後對每個稅目影響的因子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/461.wav", + "text": "都納進去考量一個稅目一個稅目的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/462.wav", + "text": "我們在籌編113年稅課收入的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/463.wav", + "text": "一個調整跟改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/464.wav", + "text": "2兆2,990億比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/465.wav", + "text": "112年已經增加了1,041億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/466.wav", + "text": "事實上就是有調增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/467.wav", + "text": "字然後在財委會的時候也增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/468.wav", + "text": "150億所以在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/469.wav", + "text": "我們建議是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/470.wav", + "text": "就按照財委會當時的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/471.wav", + "text": "按照我們原來送出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/472.wav", + "text": "預算案的數目增加150億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/473.wav", + "text": "來做一個調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/474.wav", + "text": "不好意思對於委員剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/475.wav", + "text": "這100億的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/476.wav", + "text": "我們同仁去溝通的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/477.wav", + "text": "也許表達得不夠明確跟完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/478.wav", + "text": "所以有點誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/479.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分也跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/480.wav", + "text": "邱委員這邊跟您說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/481.wav", + "text": "所以你們同意再增列100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/482.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/483.wav", + "text": "您這邊有提到100億的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/484.wav", + "text": "我們的同仁可能在表達上沒有很完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/485.wav", + "text": "回來研議這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/486.wav", + "text": "就保留一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/487.wav", + "text": "樣的問題不要一直不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/488.wav", + "text": "如果100億也不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/489.wav", + "text": "但是這幾年看起來都超徵超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/490.wav", + "text": "千億所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/491.wav", + "text": "到底你們的監測小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/492.wav", + "text": "我是覺得你的信用前兩年都破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/493.wav", + "text": "了所以在這裡才說你實徵數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/494.wav", + "text": "你的這個估算有誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/495.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這是第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/496.wav", + "text": "\n第二超徵之後的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/497.wav", + "text": "到底是往補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/498.wav", + "text": "還是之前補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/499.wav", + "text": "台電的部分其實財政部都沒有自己的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/500.wav", + "text": "所以你現在到底是要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/501.wav", + "text": "什麼方式來做最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/502.wav", + "text": "超徵之後的處理也是一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/503.wav", + "text": "了有幾個案子差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/504.wav", + "text": "類似的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/505.wav", + "text": "第4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/506.wav", + "text": "第5案第6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/507.wav", + "text": "不多類似的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/508.wav", + "text": "併在一起談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/509.wav", + "text": "沒有啦你這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/510.wav", + "text": "兩個都講一樣的都一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/511.wav", + "text": "我剛講前兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/512.wav", + "text": "估得那麼不準現在你認為它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/513.wav", + "text": "有什麼會讓你有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/514.wav", + "text": "我是想請教柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/515.wav", + "text": "你有什麼信心它真的明年會估得很準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/516.wav", + "text": "這才是關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/517.wav", + "text": "沒有一個人說保證100%準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/518.wav", + "text": "的他已經有一個小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/519.wav", + "text": "估測專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/520.wav", + "text": "他們會很專業去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/521.wav", + "text": "嘛而且明年已經增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/522.wav", + "text": "1,300億了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/523.wav", + "text": "部長再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/524.wav", + "text": "同樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/525.wav", + "text": "剛剛賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/526.wav", + "text": "有提到估測是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/527.wav", + "text": "一定精準但是我必須要跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/528.wav", + "text": "我們已經在改進我們的估測方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/529.wav", + "text": "在113年的時候跟往年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/530.wav", + "text": "都不一樣所以我們的目的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/531.wav", + "text": "每個稅目但是您說能夠準到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/532.wav", + "text": "什麼程度其實因為估測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/533.wav", + "text": "到實徵完成有2年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/534.wav", + "text": "時間這2年時間也會有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/535.wav", + "text": "變動的因素在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/536.wav", + "text": "但是我們一定會盡力做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/537.wav", + "text": "估測能夠精準我想這個在113年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/538.wav", + "text": "已經呈現在我們的改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/539.wav", + "text": "的方式上另外剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/540.wav", + "text": "超出預算數的部分這個錢是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/541.wav", + "text": "怎麼用第一個我們是減少舉債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/542.wav", + "text": "就比如說112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/543.wav", + "text": "在總預算裡面要舉借的1,732億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/544.wav", + "text": "我們都沒有舉借" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/545.wav", + "text": "然後拿去還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/546.wav", + "text": "1,110億在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/547.wav", + "text": "56月的時候就還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/548.wav", + "text": "掉了減少債息的付出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/549.wav", + "text": "同時我們在11月要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/550.wav", + "text": "還債150億所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/551.wav", + "text": "第一個是減少舉借" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/552.wav", + "text": "第二個是我們增加還債\n另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/553.wav", + "text": "如果我們整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/554.wav", + "text": "到結束以後也會累積到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/555.wav", + "text": "歲計賸餘到歲計賸餘的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/556.wav", + "text": "就作為以後年度的融資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/557.wav", + "text": "財源另外對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/558.wav", + "text": "勞保的撥補的部分在歲出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/559.wav", + "text": "預算的部分我記得在113年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/560.wav", + "text": "也有在做這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/561.wav", + "text": "那是歲出的編列部分那在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/562.wav", + "text": "歲入的部分我們如果有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/563.wav", + "text": "比預算數高的話就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/564.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的減少舉借" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/565.wav", + "text": "增加還債或者累計到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/566.wav", + "text": "歲計賸餘大概的作法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/567.wav", + "text": "那我想我們這案雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/568.wav", + "text": "保留但還是要跟主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/569.wav", + "text": "如果勞保視為你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/570.wav", + "text": "債的一種概念的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/571.wav", + "text": "當然就可以在優先償還裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/572.wav", + "text": "符合你們的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/573.wav", + "text": "可是目���它叫潛藏負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/574.wav", + "text": "可以撥補到勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/575.wav", + "text": "吧對不對我想釐清這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/576.wav", + "text": "那其他的部分就是在其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/577.wav", + "text": "未來歲出的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/578.wav", + "text": "不是他剛剛講的債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/579.wav", + "text": "是他的法定上面的一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/580.wav", + "text": "有他說歲計賸餘以後才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/581.wav", + "text": "這在歲出的部分有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/582.wav", + "text": "OK好瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/583.wav", + "text": "好那本案就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/584.wav", + "text": "第1案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/585.wav", + "text": "\n請看第2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/586.wav", + "text": "第2案我來補充說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/587.wav", + "text": "這一次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/588.wav", + "text": "公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/589.wav", + "text": "跟基金預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/590.wav", + "text": "政策行銷費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/591.wav", + "text": "超過21億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/592.wav", + "text": "我長期追蹤這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/593.wav", + "text": "政策行銷費用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/594.wav", + "text": "去路幾乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/595.wav", + "text": "這民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/596.wav", + "text": "用政府的錢洗人民的腦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/597.wav", + "text": "都發包給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/598.wav", + "text": "我就不講像是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/599.wav", + "text": "三立民視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/600.wav", + "text": "對每一年都統刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/601.wav", + "text": "隔年又加了超過20%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/602.wav", + "text": "又送來這典型的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/603.wav", + "text": "藐視立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/604.wav", + "text": "所以以前通案都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/605.wav", + "text": "所以這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/606.wav", + "text": "我們強力主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/607.wav", + "text": "%看看柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/608.wav", + "text": "您看要刪多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/609.wav", + "text": "吧這非常不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/610.wav", + "text": "你假設用廣告行銷費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/611.wav", + "text": "去為政策宣揚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/612.wav", + "text": "我們都贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/613.wav", + "text": "說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/614.wav", + "text": "這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/615.wav", + "text": "我建議我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/616.wav", + "text": "通刪比例的時候再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/617.wav", + "text": "我們不要往下走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/618.wav", + "text": "不行啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/619.wav", + "text": "不是威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/620.wav", + "text": "因為每年都這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/621.wav", + "text": "每年都會吵這��條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/622.wav", + "text": "後來是在通刪裡面去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/623.wav", + "text": "讓陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/624.wav", + "text": "變成政黨的大內宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/625.wav", + "text": "我以這個為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/626.wav", + "text": "像農業部的預算竟然去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/627.wav", + "text": "宣傳落實居住正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/628.wav", + "text": "交通部的預算也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/629.wav", + "text": "大內宣一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/630.wav", + "text": "環境部的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/631.wav", + "text": "用在挺勞工的宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/632.wav", + "text": "希望媒體政策與業務宣傳經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/633.wav", + "text": "我們請執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/634.wav", + "text": "應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/635.wav", + "text": "你不是整天講要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/636.wav", + "text": "政府部門的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/637.wav", + "text": "大內宣怎麼會恰當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/638.wav", + "text": "這怎麼是大內宣呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/639.wav", + "text": "宣導自己的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/640.wav", + "text": "我們就照法令來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/641.wav", + "text": "和去年一樣回到通刪來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/642.wav", + "text": "先保留一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/643.wav", + "text": "去年去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/644.wav", + "text": "年刪20%可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/645.wav", + "text": "有一些排除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/646.wav", + "text": "疾管署農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/647.wav", + "text": "好幾個都排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/648.wav", + "text": "因為疾管署有疾病防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/649.wav", + "text": "排除而且是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/650.wav", + "text": "1,000萬以上的才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/651.wav", + "text": "對去年有像中央銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/652.wav", + "text": "有關鈔票的使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/653.wav", + "text": "政策宣導是希望民眾能愛惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/654.wav", + "text": "使用新臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/655.wav", + "text": "很小像中央銀行才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/656.wav", + "text": "1,000萬以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/657.wav", + "text": "太少的就不刪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/658.wav", + "text": "不過有全部排除的像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/659.wav", + "text": "防檢局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/660.wav", + "text": "衛福部的疾管局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/661.wav", + "text": "這些部會裡哪個部會最誇張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/662.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/663.wav", + "text": "陳吉仲先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/664.wav", + "text": "109年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/665.wav", + "text": "3,500萬去買媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/666.wav", + "text": "亂用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/667.wav", + "text": "到現在審計部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/668.wav", + "text": "亂花錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/669.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/670.wav", + "text": "那是另外一個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/671.wav", + "text": "我也不是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/672.wav", + "text": "協調出來一個結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/673.wav", + "text": "院長我問一下主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/674.wav", + "text": "各部會把他們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/675.wav", + "text": "預算用在與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/676.wav", + "text": "政令宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/677.wav", + "text": "上這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/678.wav", + "text": "比如環境部宣傳軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/679.wav", + "text": "調薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/680.wav", + "text": "環境部宣傳政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/681.wav", + "text": "挺勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/682.wav", + "text": "勞動部宣傳前瞻建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/683.wav", + "text": "水環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/684.wav", + "text": "勞動部宣傳能源轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/685.wav", + "text": "主計長這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/686.wav", + "text": "教育部有宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/687.wav", + "text": "校園安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/688.wav", + "text": "本來部的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/689.wav", + "text": "客委會宣傳客家語言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/690.wav", + "text": "這個據我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/691.wav", + "text": "真的還是假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/692.wav", + "text": "等到通刪決定以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/693.wav", + "text": "再來決定這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/694.wav", + "text": "這個暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/695.wav", + "text": "剛才講過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/696.wav", + "text": "這東西是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/697.wav", + "text": "是臉書上的圖卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/698.wav", + "text": "這樣就行政不中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/699.wav", + "text": "喔如果是臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/700.wav", + "text": "臉書臉書的宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/701.wav", + "text": "臉書宣傳不用錢嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/702.wav", + "text": "這樣行政不中立環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/703.wav", + "text": "去宣傳別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/704.wav", + "text": "政府的那個變成大內宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/705.wav", + "text": "這樣適合嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/706.wav", + "text": "這是行政院的政策轉傳臉書上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/707.wav", + "text": "和所謂經費預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/708.wav", + "text": "一點都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/709.wav", + "text": "講話比較實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/710.wav", + "text": "保留啦好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/711.wav", + "text": "我不要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/712.wav", + "text": "院長我不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/713.wav", + "text": "要保留那統統保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/714.wav", + "text": "為什麼都照你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/715.wav", + "text": "不是照我的我現在講一個道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/716.wav", + "text": "出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/717.wav", + "text": "即便是從你們前總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/718.wav", + "text": "到你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/719.wav", + "text": "就常常在吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/720.wav", + "text": "後來我記得是你提案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/721.wav", + "text": "有用啊你們照幹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/722.wav", + "text": "十幾億而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/723.wav", + "text": "有些部會是公益的廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/724.wav", + "text": "根本沒有花到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/725.wav", + "text": "主計寫個報告好了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/726.wav", + "text": "我們這個資料再提供給主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/727.wav", + "text": "也沒有花錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/728.wav", + "text": "你做圖也要人力吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/729.wav", + "text": "吧做這些圖卡也要人力啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/730.wav", + "text": "PO文也要人力啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/731.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做PO臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/732.wav", + "text": "轉傳嘛哪有需要那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/733.wav", + "text": "傳其他部會的圖卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/734.wav", + "text": "這樣好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/735.wav", + "text": "那個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/736.wav", + "text": "那個是轉傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/737.wav", + "text": "其他部會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/738.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/739.wav", + "text": "這筆錢先來解決啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/740.wav", + "text": "那不是轉傳喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/741.wav", + "text": "這要有人去貼文喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/742.wav", + "text": "政府的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/743.wav", + "text": "各部會的人力去轉傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/744.wav", + "text": "變成大內宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/745.wav", + "text": "用這樣的方式也不院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/746.wav", + "text": "我們就照去年那個版本拿來處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/747.wav", + "text": "去年那個版本在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/748.wav", + "text": "這樣子啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/749.wav", + "text": "去年20%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/750.wav", + "text": "太低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/751.wav", + "text": "前一年30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/752.wav", + "text": "去年20%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/753.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/754.wav", + "text": "111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/755.wav", + "text": "30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/756.wav", + "text": "可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/757.wav", + "text": "主計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/758.wav", + "text": "這個錢誰用你講的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/759.wav", + "text": "誰用還不知道你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/760.wav", + "text": "不要這麼堅持啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/761.wav", + "text": "現在我就是要提醒這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/762.wav", + "text": "再30天就要投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/763.wav", + "text": "在投票之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/764.wav", + "text": "邏輯上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/765.wav", + "text": "因為三個黨我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/766.wav", + "text": "所以說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/767.wav", + "text": "應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/768.wav", + "text": "院長我講一下好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/769.wav", + "text": "去年是1,000萬以上刪20%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/770.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/771.wav", + "text": "30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/772.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/773.wav", + "text": "現在各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/774.wav", + "text": "是編得很節省啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/775.wav", + "text": "因為全部的公務機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/776.wav", + "text": "大概是10億左右啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/777.wav", + "text": "最早從12億一直降下來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/778.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/779.wav", + "text": "還有基金啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/780.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/781.wav", + "text": "增加10%就是22%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/782.wav", + "text": "嘛差不多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/783.wav", + "text": "我還是那句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/784.wav", + "text": "這錢是民進黨用或國民黨用還不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/785.wav", + "text": "我都不在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/786.wav", + "text": "這個是中立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/787.wav", + "text": "我都不在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/788.wav", + "text": "不管誰執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/789.wav", + "text": "不管誰執政都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/790.wav", + "text": "外面會解讀說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/791.wav", + "text": "不在乎的人會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/792.wav", + "text": "表示我很公正啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/793.wav", + "text": "我為人民把關啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/794.wav", + "text": "不是這樣把法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/795.wav", + "text": "這些錢你們都亂用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/796.wav", + "text": "然要把關啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/797.wav", + "text": "因為那個是用在各部會的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/798.wav", + "text": "沒有用在政黨上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/799.wav", + "text": "你要看出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/800.wav", + "text": "為什麼選舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/801.wav", + "text": "說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/802.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/803.wav", + "text": "那個疾管署跟那個所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/804.wav", + "text": "防檢局排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/805.wav", + "text": "好但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/806.wav", + "text": "要求防檢局跟疾管署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/807.wav", + "text": "不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/808.wav", + "text": "只有圖利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/809.wav", + "text": "綠色媒體可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/810.wav", + "text": "公平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/811.wav", + "text": "我也不曉得哪一個媒體是綠色的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/812.wav", + "text": "你不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/813.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/814.wav", + "text": "都不要講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/815.wav", + "text": "口是心非喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/816.wav", + "text": "25%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/817.wav", + "text": "所以是除了農委會防檢局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/818.wav", + "text": "跟衛福部疾管署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/819.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/820.wav", + "text": "這個是第2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/821.wav", + "text": "25%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/822.wav", + "text": "25%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/823.wav", + "text": "25%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/824.wav", + "text": "我耳朵不太好院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/825.wav", + "text": "00萬以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/826.wav", + "text": "的才減列25%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/827.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/828.wav", + "text": "對對對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/829.wav", + "text": "除外就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/830.wav", + "text": "就這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/831.wav", + "text": "\n請看第3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/832.wav", + "text": "第3案國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/833.wav", + "text": "主張全數凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/834.wav", + "text": "我先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/835.wav", + "text": "先不要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/836.wav", + "text": "保留其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/837.wav", + "text": "過去執政黨底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/838.wav", + "text": "政策比貪污還可怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/839.wav", + "text": "我講的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/840.wav", + "text": "數位身分證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/841.wav", + "text": "沒有做啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/842.wav", + "text": "還沒有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/843.wav", + "text": "已經要賠10億啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/844.wav", + "text": "就是因為立法院還沒有通過預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/845.wav", + "text": "他就發包了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/846.wav", + "text": "現在財務損失10億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/847.wav", + "text": "總召你問一下內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/848.wav", + "text": "數位身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/849.wav", + "text": "就是立法院還沒通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/850.wav", + "text": "賠廠商10億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/851.wav", + "text": "該賠就要賠嘛沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/852.wav", + "text": "對啊為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/853.wav", + "text": "為什麼要浪費這10億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/854.wav", + "text": "等計畫通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/855.wav", + "text": "再來吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/856.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/857.wav", + "text": "現在主題是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/858.wav", + "text": "主題是全部凍結啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/859.wav", + "text": "等它把計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/860.wav", + "text": "送來什麼計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/861.wav", + "text": "到底它的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/862.wav", + "text": "可不可行啊先送到立法院來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/863.wav", + "text": "哪一個計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/864.wav", + "text": "行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/865.wav", + "text": "關鍵民生系統精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/866.wav", + "text": "雲端備份及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/867.wav", + "text": "回復計畫啊就是這個計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/868.wav", + "text": "沒有問題啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/869.wav", + "text": "問題多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/870.wav", + "text": "了你為什麼一次要編113到116" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/871.wav", + "text": "請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/872.wav", + "text": "說明嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/873.wav", + "text": "院長我先說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/874.wav", + "text": "力的提案我們就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/875.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/876.wav", + "text": "我要去主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/877.wav", + "text": "等一下會休息啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/878.wav", + "text": "會休息啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/879.wav", + "text": "我要去主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/880.wav", + "text": "我在這裡臨提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/881.wav", + "text": "今天不處理臨提這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/882.wav", + "text": "不好不好不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/883.wav", + "text": "臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/884.wav", + "text": "啦好啦好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/885.wav", + "text": "大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/886.wav", + "text": "還有8分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/887.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/888.wav", + "text": "你們不是說要開到10點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/889.wav", + "text": "有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/890.wav", + "text": "結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/891.wav", + "text": "謝謝讓我們有說明的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/892.wav", + "text": "這是第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/893.wav", + "text": "公共建設大家瞭解4年的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/894.wav", + "text": "常常第一年是去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/895.wav", + "text": "可行性的研擬去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/896.wav", + "text": "作業程序的訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/897.wav", + "text": "比較是擔心520之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/898.wav", + "text": "好像什麼資料備份到海外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/899.wav", + "text": "跟大家說明完全不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/900.wav", + "text": "我們的分年計畫國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/901.wav", + "text": "已經核定明年一整年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/902.wav", + "text": "是用來規劃這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/903.wav", + "text": "訂定相關的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/904.wav", + "text": "但並不是執行所謂的資料備份到海外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/905.wav", + "text": "所以我想是不是有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/906.wav", + "text": "把此案改成主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/907.wav", + "text": "昨天也有書面提供給國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/908.wav", + "text": "第六行逗號右邊開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/909.wav", + "text": "改成請數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/910.wav", + "text": "向立法院交通委員會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/911.wav", + "text": "詳列各計畫名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/912.wav", + "text": "各年度期程及經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/913.wav", + "text": "等細項說明之書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/914.wav", + "text": "因為我們本來明年一整年就是在做規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/915.wav", + "text": "並沒有要跨境傳輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/916.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/917.wav", + "text": "我問一下你這個是先期計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/918.wav", + "text": "核定整體的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/919.wav", + "text": "核定了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/920.wav", + "text": "因為我們先期計畫是由國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/921.wav", + "text": "對你只有先期嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/922.wav", + "text": "那整體的計畫行政院核定了沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/923.wav", + "text": "對整體的計畫目前還在行政院審議中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/924.wav", + "text": "對啊行政院還在審議中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/925.wav", + "text": "那個沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/926.wav", + "text": "有喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/927.wav", + "text": "有關於異地備援的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/928.wav", + "text": "但目前不會有這種情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/929.wav", + "text": "未來會不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/930.wav", + "text": "那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/931.wav", + "text": "13億啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/932.wav", + "text": "搞不好新任政府又不想核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/933.wav", + "text": "那你要編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/934.wav", + "text": "這是明年的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/935.wav", + "text": "這是明年的你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/936.wav", + "text": "那你的頭洗下去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/937.wav", + "text": "你講的是另外一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/938.wav", + "text": "他現在要改這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/939.wav", + "text": "那要再溝通啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/940.wav", + "text": "這先跳過去啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/941.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/942.wav", + "text": "保留不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/943.wav", + "text": "就不再討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/944.wav", + "text": "回頭第二輪我們再來討論好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/945.wav", + "text": "請看第4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/946.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/947.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/948.wav", + "text": "第4案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/949.wav", + "text": "這麼重要的當然要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/950.wav", + "text": "跟財委會做一個專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/951.wav", + "text": "這個不要改書面了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/952.wav", + "text": "了現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/953.wav", + "text": "蔡政府執政期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/954.wav", + "text": "稅收估測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/955.wav", + "text": "嚴重這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/956.wav", + "text": "都是下屆的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/957.wav", + "text": "這麼重��的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/958.wav", + "text": "真的要做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/959.wav", + "text": "定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/960.wav", + "text": "才不會每一次都來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/961.wav", + "text": "\n我們過去在處理總預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/962.wav", + "text": "都有一個原則就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/963.wav", + "text": "1個月改3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/964.wav", + "text": "專案報告改書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/965.wav", + "text": "因為這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/966.wav", + "text": "像我們去年處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/967.wav", + "text": "的書面報告就有3,000多個書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/968.wav", + "text": "所以這個量體很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/969.wav", + "text": "尤其書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/970.wav", + "text": "讓大家都可以永遠都看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/971.wav", + "text": "專案報告來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/972.wav", + "text": "可是專案報告有直播紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/973.wav", + "text": "直播紀錄你又沒有去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/974.wav", + "text": "案件像現在打詐的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/975.wav", + "text": "像數發部的這些相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/976.wav", + "text": "因為這是最後一期的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/977.wav", + "text": "接下來明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/978.wav", + "text": "就有新的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/979.wav", + "text": "還是照我們以前的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/980.wav", + "text": "專案報告改成書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/981.wav", + "text": "好我就宣布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/982.wav", + "text": "就是照過去我來3年多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/983.wav", + "text": "慣例都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/984.wav", + "text": "如果說1個月2個月都改為3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/985.wav", + "text": "專案報告都改為書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/986.wav", + "text": "有意見到時候提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/987.wav", + "text": "對可是這個就是特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/988.wav", + "text": "說大家都不要忘記你是立法委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/989.wav", + "text": "所謂的專案報告只要召委一排的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/990.wav", + "text": "不必他們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/991.wav", + "text": "你要來專案報告這是我們的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/992.wav", + "text": "你要要求你現在給我書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/993.wav", + "text": "他們做得不好我把你叫來專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/994.wav", + "text": "報告是我們在排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/995.wav", + "text": "我們當小學生我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/996.wav", + "text": "我就是覺得你的邏輯很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/997.wav", + "text": "不是重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/998.wav", + "text": "才改為專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/999.wav", + "text": "其他不重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1000.wav", + "text": "都改成書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1001.wav", + "text": "啦不然浪費時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1002.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1003.wav", + "text": "贊成國民黨黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1004.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1005.wav", + "text": "我現在要趕過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1006.wav", + "text": "我們專案休息一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1007.wav", + "text": "我宣布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1008.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告現在已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1009.wav", + "text": "經接近5點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1010.wav", + "text": "院會5點要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1011.wav", + "text": "臨時提案所以我們休息15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1012.wav", + "text": "我先去主持院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1013.wav", + "text": "協商部分於5點10分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1014.wav", + "text": "繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1015.wav", + "text": "\n然後另外還有一件事情就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1016.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1017.wav", + "text": "還有國民黨黨團都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1018.wav", + "text": "結果送到內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1019.wav", + "text": "也請其他的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1020.wav", + "text": "到內政委員會以利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1021.wav", + "text": "利在通案結束後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1022.wav", + "text": "等一下會回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1023.wav", + "text": "晚餐是要休息多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1024.wav", + "text": "晚餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1025.wav", + "text": "6點半還是7點讓你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1026.wav", + "text": "我們有準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1027.wav", + "text": "要6點吃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1028.wav", + "text": "還是要6點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1029.wav", + "text": "要休息1小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1030.wav", + "text": "你們說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1031.wav", + "text": "6點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1032.wav", + "text": "6點到7點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1033.wav", + "text": "6點到7點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1034.wav", + "text": "好6點到7點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1035.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1036.wav", + "text": "明天早上是幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1037.wav", + "text": "9點半好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1038.wav", + "text": "9點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1039.wav", + "text": "我們的人不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1040.wav", + "text": "9點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1041.wav", + "text": "明天早上9點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1042.wav", + "text": "5點10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1043.wav", + "text": "是不是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1044.wav", + "text": "主計總處可不可以刪掉我比較自私一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1045.wav", + "text": "好來是不是修正通過主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1046.wav", + "text": "刪掉什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1047.wav", + "text": "陳委員這邊還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1048.wav", + "text": "修正後的可以提供一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1049.wav", + "text": "有沒有發一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1050.wav", + "text": "照修正後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1051.wav", + "text": "現在如果有修正希望你們要很快送到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1052.wav", + "text": "早點拿出來好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1053.wav", + "text": "不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1054.wav", + "text": "行政院也刪掉那是誰邀集啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1055.wav", + "text": "這樣子喔我建議一下這邊是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1056.wav", + "text": "爰提案要求財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1057.wav", + "text": "也就是行政院召集主計總處這一段文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1058.wav", + "text": "是不是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1059.wav", + "text": "整個位階下降就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1060.wav", + "text": "要求財政部召集相關單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1061.wav", + "text": "召開會議檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1062.wav", + "text": "由財政部來邀集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1063.wav", + "text": "另外就是最後一行的專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1064.wav", + "text": "是不是修正為稅收估測精進書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1065.wav", + "text": "其他相關單位是哪些單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1066.wav", + "text": "其他相關單位我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1067.wav", + "text": "第一個會邀請政府機關包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1068.wav", + "text": "國發會主計總處中央銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1069.wav", + "text": "另外也會邀請相關的專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1070.wav", + "text": "一起來成立一個檢討會議跟估測小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1071.wav", + "text": "所以是包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1072.wav", + "text": "有關的我們都會邀請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1073.wav", + "text": "如果沒有主計總處的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1074.wav", + "text": "是不是對於歲出的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1075.wav", + "text": "我們也會邀請主計總因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1076.wav", + "text": "稅收預測是他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1077.wav", + "text": "所以只是由你們來邀集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1078.wav", + "text": "就把位階往下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1079.wav", + "text": "本來是行政院邀集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1080.wav", + "text": "變成由財政部來邀集就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1081.wav", + "text": "我們曾銘宗總召還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1082.wav", + "text": "要專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1083.wav", + "text": "而不是書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1084.wav", + "text": "這個剛剛不是講好了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1085.wav", + "text": "又改了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1086.wav", + "text": "他也會去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1087.wav", + "text": "財政把脈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1088.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1089.wav", + "text": "下一屆的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1090.wav", + "text": "那就恢復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1091.wav", + "text": "有專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1092.wav", + "text": "其他的文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1093.wav", + "text": "主計總處沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1094.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1095.wav", + "text": "就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1096.wav", + "text": "有專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1097.wav", + "text": "其他就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1098.wav", + "text": "第4案就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1099.wav", + "text": "請看第5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1100.wav", + "text": "有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1101.wav", + "text": "你們修正這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1102.wav", + "text": "希望都發下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1103.wav", + "text": "全部你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1104.wav", + "text": "自己延誤時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1105.wav", + "text": "有修改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1106.wav", + "text": "全部把它發了\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1107.wav", + "text": "第5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1108.wav", + "text": "主決議有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1109.wav", + "text": "修正通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1110.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1111.wav", + "text": "修正成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1112.wav", + "text": "稅課收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1113.wav", + "text": "實徵數超過預算數部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1114.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1115.wav", + "text": "我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1116.wav", + "text": "這個是國民黨團提出來的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1117.wav", + "text": "的你為什麼要改我們的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1118.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1119.wav", + "text": "協商可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1120.wav", + "text": "啊我不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1121.wav", + "text": "啊國民黨的文字是專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1122.wav", + "text": "的你改書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1123.wav", + "text": "我也答應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1124.wav", + "text": "你又給我改文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1125.wav", + "text": "那你就照原來文字改書面就好啦不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1126.wav", + "text": "差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1127.wav", + "text": "不是啦對於改文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1128.wav", + "text": "你至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1129.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1130.wav", + "text": "唉本人在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1131.wav", + "text": "財政部做常次做這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1132.wav", + "text": "我怎麼不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1133.wav", + "text": "尊重委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1134.wav", + "text": "尊重總召的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1135.wav", + "text": "5案的主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1136.wav", + "text": "只有修改二個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1137.wav", + "text": "就是專案改為書面這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1138.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1139.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1140.wav", + "text": "請看第6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1141.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1142.wav", + "text": "第6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1143.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1144.wav", + "text": "新興資本支出及新增計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1145.wav", + "text": "因為立法院的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1146.wav", + "text": "已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1147.wav", + "text": "行政單位一定要執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1148.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1149.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1150.wav", + "text": "第7案就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1151.wav", + "text": "請國防部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1152.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1153.wav", + "text": "我的建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1154.wav", + "text": "就併委員會的決議來作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1155.wav", + "text": "裁定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1156.wav", + "text": "第一個假如說已經建案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1157.wav", + "text": "持續不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1158.wav", + "text": "而且會跟立法院報備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1159.wav", + "text": "如果沒有建案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1160.wav", + "text": "我們要用的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1161.wav", + "text": "作專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1162.wav", + "text": "而且完成建案程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1163.wav", + "text": "再作專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1164.wav", + "text": "相關報告經過外交及國防委員會同意以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1165.wav", + "text": "支這在10月25號已經跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1166.wav", + "text": "建議就按照委員會的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1167.wav", + "text": "那這跟這個主決議有什麼衝突呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1168.wav", + "text": "有衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1169.wav", + "text": "到後年才用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1170.wav", + "text": "我們的期望是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1171.wav", + "text": "因為明年的預算已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1172.wav", + "text": "編列進去我們希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1173.wav", + "text": "動支但在這兩個條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1174.wav", + "text": "下也不會違背" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1175.wav", + "text": "委員所擔憂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1176.wav", + "text": "那兩個條件也算蠻嚴謹的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1177.wav", + "text": "應該都有這個顧慮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1178.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1179.wav", + "text": "您的建議我尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1180.wav", + "text": "你就把我們的主決議改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1181.wav", + "text": "類似的文句吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1182.wav", + "text": "這樣就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1183.wav", + "text": "跟委員會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1184.wav", + "text": "類似的文句就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1185.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1186.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1187.wav", + "text": "我們改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1188.wav", + "text": "改好了就拿過來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1189.wav", + "text": "差不多這樣的意思就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1190.wav", + "text": "改好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1191.wav", + "text": "各黨都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1192.wav", + "text": "改這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1193.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1194.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1195.wav", + "text": "就修正通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1196.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1197.wav", + "text": "請看第9案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1198.wav", + "text": "第9案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1199.wav", + "text": "的文字稍微修正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1200.wav", + "text": "以季報方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1201.wav", + "text": "5個字可能要刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1202.wav", + "text": "因為我們這個計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1203.wav", + "text": "完成的時間是不定期的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1204.wav", + "text": "所以什麼時候完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1205.wav", + "text": "我們就什麼時候上網公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1206.wav", + "text": "那你要把它寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1207.wav", + "text": "那我們就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1208.wav", + "text": "你要有一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1209.wav", + "text": "有沒有固定原來的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1210.wav", + "text": "改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1211.wav", + "text": "我們2月份就會公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1212.wav", + "text": "不用等到4月份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1213.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1214.wav", + "text": "關於這個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1215.wav", + "text": "問題因為秘書長難得來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1216.wav", + "text": "勞工朋友很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1217.wav", + "text": "就是這個實施日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1218.wav", + "text": "由行政院定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1219.wav", + "text": "之大家當然期待越快越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1220.wav", + "text": "可是現在傳出來好像今年不會公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1221.wav", + "text": "所以就這部分請教行政院這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1222.wav", + "text": "自己的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1223.wav", + "text": "因為很快的立院就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1224.wav", + "text": "那麼實施日期有沒有可能在年底就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1225.wav", + "text": "公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1226.wav", + "text": "來不及吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1227.wav", + "text": "對因為行政院定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1228.wav", + "text": "所以我想知道行政院自己有沒有一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1229.wav", + "text": "什麼五一再公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1230.wav", + "text": "這是不太對的一個立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1231.wav", + "text": "我們會在總統府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1232.wav", + "text": "公告這個法案以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1233.wav", + "text": "儘速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1234.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能在年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1235.wav", + "text": "主計長你不要幫他講那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1236.wav", + "text": "你覺得呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1237.wav", + "text": "就是說我們立院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1238.wav", + "text": "很快地通過了可是到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1239.wav", + "text": "實施日期是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1240.wav", + "text": "時候\n所以我希望行政院儘速也確定看看好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1241.wav", + "text": "覺得我們立法上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1242.wav", + "text": "沒有達到實際的效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1243.wav", + "text": "明年4月就要有研議小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1244.wav", + "text": "這是關鍵的一個設計機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1245.wav", + "text": "好不好麻煩你回去跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1246.wav", + "text": "行政院長也說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1247.wav", + "text": "好第9案就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1248.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1249.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1250.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1251.wav", + "text": "第10案照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1252.wav", + "text": "第11案有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1253.wav", + "text": "修正建議請大家參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1254.wav", + "text": "第11案請大家看這一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1255.wav", + "text": "有沒有送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1256.wav", + "text": "我們會按照預算法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1257.wav", + "text": "馬上辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1258.wav", + "text": "就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1259.wav", + "text": "在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1260.wav", + "text": "請看第12案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1261.wav", + "text": "第12案照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1262.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1263.wav", + "text": "環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1264.wav", + "text": "環境部這邊報告已經跟賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1265.wav", + "text": "那邊討論過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1266.wav", + "text": "賴委員也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1267.wav", + "text": "也蓋章了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1268.wav", + "text": "就修正通過對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1269.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1270.wav", + "text": "\n請看第15案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1271.wav", + "text": "人事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1272.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1273.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1274.wav", + "text": "撤案撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1275.wav", + "text": "已經蓋章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1276.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1277.wav", + "text": "16案撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1278.wav", + "text": "\n請看第17案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1279.wav", + "text": "17案照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1280.wav", + "text": "\n請看第18案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1281.wav", + "text": "是不是可以建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1282.wav", + "text": "由專題報告改為書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1283.wav", + "text": "18案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1284.wav", + "text": "專題報告改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1285.wav", + "text": "書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1286.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1287.wav", + "text": "第19案已經發給各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1288.wav", + "text": "了我們是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1289.wav", + "text": "兩個月內就相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1290.wav", + "text": "籌設計畫提出書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1291.wav", + "text": "19案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1292.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1293.wav", + "text": "好請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1294.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1295.wav", + "text": "改書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1296.wav", + "text": "行政不中立的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1297.wav", + "text": "請主委講一下吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1298.wav", + "text": "在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1299.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1300.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1301.wav", + "text": "來快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1302.wav", + "text": "在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1303.wav", + "text": "第20案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1304.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1305.wav", + "text": "修正文字啊文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1306.wav", + "text": "沒意見就文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1307.wav", + "text": "那要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1308.wav", + "text": "有沒有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1309.wav", + "text": "主委先講一下吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1310.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1311.wav", + "text": "這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1312.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1313.wav", + "text": "原民會補助民間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1314.wav", + "text": "文化健康站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1315.wav", + "text": "它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1316.wav", + "text": "是計畫型的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1317.wav", + "text": "不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1318.wav", + "text": "這是社團的補助案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1319.wav", + "text": "沒有問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1320.wav", + "text": "這個健康站照服員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1321.wav", + "text": "是不是有穿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1322.wav", + "text": "相關候選人的競選背心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1323.wav", + "text": "這個才是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1324.wav", + "text": "要是有穿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1325.wav", + "text": "假如他沒有穿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1326.wav", + "text": "就沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1327.wav", + "text": "但是他有穿被抓到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1328.wav", + "text": "的話當然你們就得檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1329.wav", + "text": "即使你們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1330.wav", + "text": "補助民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1331.wav", + "text": "那樣也不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1332.wav", + "text": "上班時間沒有穿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1333.wav", + "text": "您的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1334.wav", + "text": "輔選拉票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1335.wav", + "text": "對這個部分有反彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1336.wav", + "text": "伍麗華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1337.wav", + "text": "有在臉書上澄清過沒有這回事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1338.wav", + "text": "伍麗華委員有他的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1339.wav", + "text": "原民會要來瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1340.wav", + "text": "的照服員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1341.wav", + "text": "應該說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1342.wav", + "text": "伍麗華委員會有他的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1343.wav", + "text": "但是當事人也會有他的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1344.wav", + "text": "所以才要原民會說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1345.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1346.wav", + "text": "看你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1347.wav", + "text": "反映原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1348.wav", + "text": "各種活動在助選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1349.wav", + "text": "網站上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1350.wav", + "text": "或者電視上有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1351.wav", + "text": "照片真的很明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1352.wav", + "text": "所以我們這個案子也是督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1353.wav", + "text": "原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1354.wav", + "text": "可以做但是不要太誇張對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1355.wav", + "text": "那個應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1356.wav", + "text": "應嚴守行政中立這是對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1357.wav", + "text": "後面那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1358.wav", + "text": "有不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1359.wav", + "text": "意見跟看法伍麗華" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1360.wav", + "text": "說沒有這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1361.wav", + "text": "還是你重新修正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1362.wav", + "text": "建議修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1363.wav", + "text": "對文字是不是再重寫一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1364.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1365.wav", + "text": "修正文字再重寫一下等一下先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1366.wav", + "text": "把重點都刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1367.wav", + "text": "那個不是那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1368.wav", + "text": "你那麼會重寫你叫他重寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1369.wav", + "text": "教他一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1370.wav", + "text": "主決議的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1371.wav", + "text": "你們寫一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1372.wav", + "text": "再拿過來大家再看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1373.wav", + "text": "再講\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1374.wav", + "text": "21案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1375.wav", + "text": "第21案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1376.wav", + "text": "21案有跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1377.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1378.wav", + "text": "原則上修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1379.wav", + "text": "一小段文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1380.wav", + "text": "就留著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1381.wav", + "text": "前面一段拿掉後面那一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1382.wav", + "text": "留著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1383.wav", + "text": "不用刪掉對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1384.wav", + "text": "對前面歌功頌德宣揚政績那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1385.wav", + "text": "宣傳政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1386.wav", + "text": "機關利用官方帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1387.wav", + "text": "在選舉期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1388.wav", + "text": "在臉書裡面政府機關本來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1389.wav", + "text": "我們覺得這樣不妥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1390.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1391.wav", + "text": "官方在臉書分享資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1392.wav", + "text": "那我們什麼都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1393.wav", + "text": "連這種都不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1394.wav", + "text": "那我們就全部保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1395.wav", + "text": "等一下每一個案子我都要要求保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1396.wav", + "text": "我們希望避免民眾誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1397.wav", + "text": "或者是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1398.wav", + "text": "執政單位執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1399.wav", + "text": "在選舉期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1400.wav", + "text": "大肆宣傳政府的政績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1401.wav", + "text": "那你這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1402.wav", + "text": "行政不中立的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1403.wav", + "text": "並不適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1404.wav", + "text": "所以就是這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1405.wav", + "text": "他不是說他已經刪掉那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1406.wav", + "text": "刪掉要恢復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1407.wav", + "text": "復原的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1408.wav", + "text": "就是復原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1409.wav", + "text": "秘書長對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1410.wav", + "text": "部會的臉書不會出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1411.wav", + "text": "政黨的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1412.wav", + "text": "不會幫政黨宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1413.wav", + "text": "但是部會的臉書去幫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1414.wav", + "text": "行政院的政績宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1415.wav", + "text": "應該是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1416.wav", + "text": "對啊那這個文字沒有什麼錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1417.wav", + "text": "不會有特定政黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1418.wav", + "text": "個文字保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1419.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1420.wav", + "text": "對歌功頌德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1421.wav", + "text": "宣傳政策啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1422.wav", + "text": "同意修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1423.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1424.wav", + "text": "那這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1425.wav", + "text": "文字就跟剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1426.wav", + "text": "再修正的請再給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1427.wav", + "text": "再修正的請再給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1428.wav", + "text": "請看第22案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1429.wav", + "text": "第22案就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1430.wav", + "text": "只有改一個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1431.wav", + "text": "應改成宜啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1432.wav", + "text": "我不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1433.wav", + "text": "為什麼你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1434.wav", + "text": "嗎我後來當了總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1435.wav", + "text": "你現在就在當總召怎麼後來才當總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1436.wav", + "text": "我做8年立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1437.wav", + "text": "沒有每一年都做啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1438.wav", + "text": "我做了3年總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1439.wav", + "text": "每次到司法及法制去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1440.wav", + "text": "一下子法務部有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1441.wav", + "text": "一下司法院有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1442.wav", + "text": "朝野協商完司法院又有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1443.wav", + "text": "法務部又有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1444.wav", + "text": "浪費國家的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1445.wav", + "text": "兩個機關會銜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1446.wav", + "text": "一個法務部一個行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1447.wav", + "text": "送來的法案常常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1448.wav", + "text": "法務部跟司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1449.wav", + "text": "沒有意見常常還麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1450.wav", + "text": "你這個大總召來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1451.wav", + "text": "沒有關係啦苦一點沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1452.wav", + "text": "不用不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1453.wav", + "text": "這個宜不要應啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1454.wav", + "text": "司法院法務部本來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1455.wav", + "text": "有不同立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1456.wav", + "text": "謝衣鳯就很有經驗嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1457.wav", + "text": "法務部的堅持後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1458.wav", + "text": "因為跟司法院協商溝通以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1459.wav", + "text": "還是用司法院的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1460.wav", + "text": "所以難免會有這種情形問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1461.wav", + "text": "司法院有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1462.wav", + "text": "因為我們行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1463.wav", + "text": "因為五院是平行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1464.wav", + "text": "我們沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1465.wav", + "text": "我們儘量溝通啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1466.wav", + "text": "本來就是到我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1467.wav", + "text": "立法院來我們來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1468.wav", + "text": "我的想法是假設少數案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1469.wav", + "text": "就這樣子嘛但幾乎每個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1470.wav", + "text": "都這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1471.wav", + "text": "你都沒來質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1472.wav", + "text": "後面都我做的我怎麼會不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1473.wav", + "text": "你沒來質詢都不知道啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1474.wav", + "text": "我大概不必質詢就知道你們在搞什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1475.wav", + "text": "到最後都我協商的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1476.wav", + "text": "包括刑事補償也是一樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1477.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1478.wav", + "text": "那就文字修正喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1479.wav", + "text": "好好文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1480.wav", + "text": "就是第22案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1481.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1482.wav", + "text": "好請看第23案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1483.wav", + "text": "第23案農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1484.wav", + "text": "有做文字的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1485.wav", + "text": "是不是可以說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1486.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1487.wav", + "text": "因為整個主決議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1488.wav", + "text": "蛋液要納入農產品的標識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1489.wav", + "text": "識根據我們的食品安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1490.wav", + "text": "衛生管理法第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1491.wav", + "text": "已經是加工的產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1492.wav", + "text": "是一個包裝的食品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1493.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法納入我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1494.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1495.wav", + "text": "第四行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1496.wav", + "text": "蛋液後面的納入農產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1497.wav", + "text": "溯源標識系統上劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1498.wav", + "text": "然後加一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1499.wav", + "text": "蛋液的管理未臻完善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1500.wav", + "text": "第六行開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1501.wav", + "text": "應於六個月儘速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1502.wav", + "text": "強制將蛋液納入農產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1503.wav", + "text": "標識系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1504.wav", + "text": "要求養雞場主動申報不良蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1505.wav", + "text": "同時這幾個字劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1506.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1507.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1508.wav", + "text": "我要提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1509.wav", + "text": "代理部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1510.wav", + "text": "你現在代理一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1511.wav", + "text": "像偉大的前部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1512.wav", + "text": "審計部還沒有轉銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1513.wav", + "text": "對不對有多少錢還沒轉銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1514.wav", + "text": "3,600萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1515.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1516.wav", + "text": "從109年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1517.wav", + "text": "亂用錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1518.wav", + "text": "主計長在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1519.wav", + "text": "很多的主計主任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1520.wav", + "text": "主計處長不敢做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1521.wav", + "text": "臺北市有好幾十億也都還沒有轉銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1522.wav", + "text": "那是你說的不是我說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1523.wav", + "text": "23案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1524.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1525.wav", + "text": "其實講直白的重點就是六個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1526.wav", + "text": "但你現在把它劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1527.wav", + "text": "了基本上應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1528.wav", + "text": "要求單一業者標示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1529.wav", + "text": "這個主決議就是希望你有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1530.wav", + "text": "個時間規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1531.wav", + "text": "你把六個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1532.wav", + "text": "劃掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1533.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1534.wav", + "text": "的範疇所以也沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1535.wav", + "text": "放到農產品的溯源標識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1536.wav", + "text": "所有的雞蛋從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1537.wav", + "text": "蛋場出來以後都有溯源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1538.wav", + "text": "碼可以追溯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1539.wav", + "text": "如果它是用籃子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1540.wav", + "text": "裝的在籃子外面就會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1541.wav", + "text": "溯源碼但是做成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1542.wav", + "text": "液蛋以後是經過加工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1543.wav", + "text": "它是屬於食品的範疇這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1544.wav", + "text": "第一個要說明的所以我們才把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1545.wav", + "text": "蛋液納入農產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1546.wav", + "text": "溯源標識系統劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1547.wav", + "text": "主動申報不良蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1548.wav", + "text": "還有把不良的蛋挑掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1549.wav", + "text": "它是完全沒辦法執行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1550.wav", + "text": "就會把不良蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1551.wav", + "text": "是不是文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1552.wav", + "text": "已經有解釋了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1553.wav", + "text": "嘛我們就文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1554.wav", + "text": "通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1555.wav", + "text": "酌修應強要求變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1556.wav", + "text": "應要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1557.wav", + "text": "蛋製造業加上蛋液" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1558.wav", + "text": "製造業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1559.wav", + "text": "應標示倒數第三個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1560.wav", + "text": "也可以劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1561.wav", + "text": "就照這一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1562.wav", + "text": "我已經裁示了你就不要再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1563.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1564.wav", + "text": "已經裁示了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1565.wav", + "text": "你再講會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1566.wav", + "text": "是很抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1567.wav", + "text": "第23案文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1568.wav", + "text": "接下來我��回頭來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1569.wav", + "text": "文字已經修正好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1570.wav", + "text": "大家沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1571.wav", + "text": "也是修正通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1572.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1573.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1574.wav", + "text": "第20案文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1575.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1576.wav", + "text": "事實真相查清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1577.wav", + "text": "好了好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1578.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1579.wav", + "text": "就是屏東縣政府那部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1580.wav", + "text": "啦屏東縣政府那部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1581.wav", + "text": "拿掉就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1582.wav", + "text": "好我來劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1583.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1584.wav", + "text": "好屏東縣府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1585.wav", + "text": "四個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1586.wav", + "text": "沒關係我改好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1587.wav", + "text": "我們再來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1588.wav", + "text": "通案23案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1589.wav", + "text": "等一下還要看文字以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1590.wav", + "text": "其他的我們都已經有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1591.wav", + "text": "院長第21案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1592.wav", + "text": "文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1593.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1594.wav", + "text": "第20案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1595.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1596.wav", + "text": "處理告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1597.wav", + "text": "那就要休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1598.wav", + "text": "休息前我跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1599.wav", + "text": "我們接下來要審查內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1600.wav", + "text": "所以讓他們準備一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1601.wav", + "text": "及等於我們要休息到7點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1602.wav", + "text": "他們現在在趕工了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1603.wav", + "text": "另外跟院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1604.wav", + "text": "因為你要給同仁或者行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1605.wav", + "text": "那我們要不要切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1606.wav", + "text": "21案有再修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1607.wav", + "text": "確認一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1608.wav", + "text": "提早結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1609.wav", + "text": "假設內政結束也切掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1610.wav", + "text": "第21案的再確認文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1611.wav", + "text": "宣布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1612.wav", + "text": "第21案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1613.wav", + "text": "文字再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1614.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1615.wav", + "text": "再修正的部分有再念一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1616.wav", + "text": "好那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1617.wav", + "text": "7點的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1618.wav", + "text": "通刪的科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1619.wav", + "text": "休息19點準時開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1620.wav", + "text": "見接下來我們就討論通刪的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1621.wav", + "text": "為便於各委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1622.wav", + "text": "編製提案彙整表的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1623.wav", + "text": "加註通刪科目4個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1624.wav", + "text": "以加速協商進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1625.wav", + "text": "113年度總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1626.wav", + "text": "針對各機關通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1627.wav", + "text": "案刪減用途別項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1628.wav", + "text": "是否就依主計總處所擬的這份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1629.wav", + "text": "通刪項目辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1630.wav", + "text": "至於通刪的比例金額等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1631.wav", + "text": "以黨團協商討論再行決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1632.wav", + "text": "這樣有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1633.wav", + "text": "還是我們討論再作出決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1634.wav", + "text": "只是那個項目是不是就先照他們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1635.wav", + "text": "跟主席報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1636.wav", + "text": "這個項目跟往年都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1637.wav", + "text": "但是他們沒有蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1638.wav", + "text": "現在就是我們委員會都不敢蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1639.wav", + "text": "如果可以的話讓他們先蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1640.wav", + "text": "但是那個蓋並不表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1641.wav", + "text": "金額比例還是要依照我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1642.wav", + "text": "通過以後才算確定這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1643.wav", + "text": "113年總共有14項對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1644.wav", + "text": "110年也是12項對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1645.wav", + "text": "增加哪兩項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1646.wav", + "text": "都一樣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1647.wav", + "text": "調整項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1648.wav", + "text": "好項目就確定先讓他們去蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1649.wav", + "text": "我剛才講金額及比例並沒有決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1650.wav", + "text": "我們討論以後就決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1651.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1652.wav", + "text": "遲早要決定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1653.wav", + "text": "我們還要談一個總數刪多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1654.wav", + "text": "所以明天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1655.wav", + "text": "就要決定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1656.wav", + "text": "不可能都未定數嘛包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1657.wav", + "text": "總數要刪多少都要出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1658.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1659.wav", + "text": "明天早上一開始先把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1660.wav", + "text": "大家拿回去想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1661.wav", + "text": "好現在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1662.wav", + "text": "通刪科目就照主計總處的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1663.wav", + "text": "這份就讓他們去蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1664.wav", + "text": "通刪用途別項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1665.wav", + "text": "預擬的部分就明天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1666.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1667.wav", + "text": "其實蓋也不一定來得及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1668.wav", + "text": "通刪就知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1669.wav", + "text": "嘛蓋章也不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1670.wav", + "text": "全部收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1671.wav", + "text": "院長那邊有一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1672.wav", + "text": "就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1673.wav", + "text": "接下來我就向大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1674.wav", + "text": "的總案數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1675.wav", + "text": "371案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1676.wav", + "text": "溝通有結果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1677.wav", + "text": "166案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1678.wav", + "text": "我們把166案已經有溝通結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1679.wav", + "text": "照這個順序來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1680.wav", + "text": "總共有幾案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1681.wav", + "text": "371案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1682.wav", + "text": "有結果的是多少案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1683.wav", + "text": "166案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1684.wav", + "text": "好啦我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1685.wav", + "text": "快一點讓大家早點回去休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1686.wav", + "text": "行政院主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1687.wav", + "text": "剛才介紹過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1688.wav", + "text": "我們看案號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1689.wav", + "text": "第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1690.wav", + "text": "第1案沒有意見我們就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1691.wav", + "text": "第1案因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1692.wav", + "text": "裡面有幾個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1693.wav", + "text": "行政效能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1694.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1695.wav", + "text": "那你有把修正文字寫出來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1696.wav", + "text": "大概刪兩行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1697.wav", + "text": "多的字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1698.wav", + "text": "報告委員就是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1699.wav", + "text": "擬處意見本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1700.wav", + "text": "的第1頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1701.wav", + "text": "第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1702.wav", + "text": "就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1703.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1704.wav", + "text": "2案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1705.wav", + "text": "第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1706.wav", + "text": "在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1707.wav", + "text": "麻煩各部會如果有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1708.wav", + "text": "修正的書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1709.wav", + "text": "就提早發下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1710.wav", + "text": "剛才已經宣布修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1711.wav", + "text": "\n第2案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1712.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1713.wav", + "text": "\n第3案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1714.wav", + "text": "\n第4案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1715.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1716.wav", + "text": "\n第5案文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1717.wav", + "text": "凍結1,0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1718.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1719.wav", + "text": "第第5案文字修正凍結1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1720.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1721.wav", + "text": "\n第6案文字修正凍結1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1722.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1723.wav", + "text": "\n第7案文字修正凍結1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1724.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1725.wav", + "text": "修正凍結1,000元沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1726.wav", + "text": "\n第9案文字修正凍結1,000元沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1727.wav", + "text": "\n第10案文字修正凍結1,000元沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1728.wav", + "text": "12案凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1729.wav", + "text": "第12案有建議修改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1730.wav", + "text": "但是委員可能要討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1731.wav", + "text": "12案有一個建議的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1732.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1733.wav", + "text": "沒有啦我們這個就是希望凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1734.wav", + "text": "它是不是有履行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1735.wav", + "text": "它要以10年40億的慈善支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1736.wav", + "text": "但到現在都沒有去捐這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1737.wav", + "text": "個在委員會時NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1738.wav", + "text": "CC主委有答應要處理了啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1739.wav", + "text": "到現在都沒有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1740.wav", + "text": "委員會是怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1741.wav", + "text": "委員會沒有怎麼處理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1742.wav", + "text": "是不是讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1743.wav", + "text": "這可能是教育部要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1744.wav", + "text": "個機關所做的處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1745.wav", + "text": "就是由那個機關去做監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1746.wav", + "text": "我在質詢陳院長時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1747.wav", + "text": "他的見解也是這樣但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1748.wav", + "text": "但NCC還是一直在講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1749.wav", + "text": "教育部應該要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1750.wav", + "text": "公益信託到底有沒有捐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1751.wav", + "text": "去處理這個問題澈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1752.wav", + "text": "澈底檢討這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1753.wav", + "text": "那你TVBS是衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1754.wav", + "text": "是不是讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1755.wav", + "text": "獨立機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1756.wav", + "text": "是不是我們督促它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1757.wav", + "text": "它在3個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1758.wav", + "text": "請法務部這邊要求相關單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1759.wav", + "text": "在3個月內提出書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1760.wav", + "text": "跟鈞院來做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1761.wav", + "text": "依照文字上修改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1762.wav", + "text": "請法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1763.wav", + "text": "為什麼又跟法務部有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1764.wav", + "text": "公益信託法主管機關是法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1765.wav", + "text": "也提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1766.wav", + "text": "所以你再加入NCC這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1767.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1768.wav", + "text": "沒有你這個上面沒有NCC啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1769.wav", + "text": "你是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1770.wav", + "text": "再加一個NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1771.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1772.wav", + "text": "那修法的部分怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1773.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1774.wav", + "text": "管理機制出了問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1775.wav", + "text": "公益信託法已經在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1776.wav", + "text": "也在排審階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1777.wav", + "text": "已經在進行中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1778.wav", + "text": "職權的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1779.wav", + "text": "你要督促法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1780.wav", + "text": "或是NCC都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1781.wav", + "text": "內政委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1782.wav", + "text": "已經在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1783.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有這還是不一樣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1784.wav", + "text": "在交通委員會已經講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1785.wav", + "text": "很多次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1786.wav", + "text": "還是要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1787.wav", + "text": "要不要留到後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1788.wav", + "text": "保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1789.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1790.wav", + "text": "第12案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1791.wav", + "text": "請看第13案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1792.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1793.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1794.wav", + "text": "\n第15案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1795.wav", + "text": "2萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1796.wav", + "text": "這個我們有修正一些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1797.wav", + "text": "那看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1798.wav", + "text": "修正的文字可以講一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1799.wav", + "text": "我好像有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1800.wav", + "text": "是要改主決議嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1801.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1802.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1803.wav", + "text": "就照行政院改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1804.wav", + "text": "可以改成主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1805.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1806.wav", + "text": "第16案這裡有改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1807.wav", + "text": "了陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1808.wav", + "text": "照現在改的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1809.wav", + "text": "變成主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1810.wav", + "text": "大家沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1811.wav", + "text": "就是文字修正為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1812.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1813.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1814.wav", + "text": "併委員會凍結50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1815.wav", + "text": "是不是可以併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1816.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1817.wav", + "text": "好併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1818.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1819.wav", + "text": "通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1820.wav", + "text": "第19案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1821.wav", + "text": "剛剛賴士葆委員有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1822.wav", + "text": "就是凍結5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1823.wav", + "text": "提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1824.wav", + "text": "19案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1825.wav", + "text": "我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1826.wav", + "text": "就併通刪科目處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1827.wav", + "text": "第20案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1828.wav", + "text": "減列800萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1829.wav", + "text": "通案的第21案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1830.wav", + "text": "這個不能夠說各部會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1831.wav", + "text": "社群平臺都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1832.wav", + "text": "處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1833.wav", + "text": "啊因為這根本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1834.wav", + "text": "跟它的業務一點關係都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1835.wav", + "text": "它在講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1836.wav", + "text": "別人的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1837.wav", + "text": "欸怎麼可以這樣一個機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1838.wav", + "text": "基本上在一個法治國裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1839.wav", + "text": "它就是有它的職掌分配嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1840.wav", + "text": "對不對不然的話幹嘛要設立這些組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1841.wav", + "text": "今天農業部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1842.wav", + "text": "那你自己都沒事做了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1843.wav", + "text": "這個已經通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1844.wav", + "text": "對啊我是跟他講啊我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1845.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1846.wav", + "text": "政府的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1847.wav", + "text": "今天是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1848.wav", + "text": "下面有部會今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1849.wav", + "text": "不是說只有一個行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1850.wav", + "text": "下面沒有任何的組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1851.wav", + "text": "耶\n業務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1852.wav", + "text": "我剛剛在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1853.wav", + "text": "你都沒在聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1854.wav", + "text": "交通部有交通部的組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1855.wav", + "text": "農業部有農業部的組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1856.wav", + "text": "結果你結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1857.wav", + "text": "你現在還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1858.wav", + "text": "我跟他講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1859.wav", + "text": "這個是不允許的這樣不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1860.wav", + "text": "這是你一個人講了算嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1861.wav", + "text": "連講都不可以講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1862.wav", + "text": "現在第20案跟第21案怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1863.wav", + "text": "第20案就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1864.wav", + "text": "併通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1865.wav", + "text": "剛剛各部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1866.wav", + "text": "各部會通案的那個案子是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1867.wav", + "text": "溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1868.wav", + "text": "因為前面已經有通過通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1869.wav", + "text": "這個就併通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1870.wav", + "text": "修改內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1871.wav", + "text": "沒意見我們就照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1872.wav", + "text": "凍結200萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1873.wav", + "text": "21案我們想要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1874.wav", + "text": "對啊第21案還沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1875.wav", + "text": "對啊第21案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1876.wav", + "text": "這個打詐的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1877.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是不能併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1878.wav", + "text": "啦對啊第21案要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1879.wav", + "text": "第21案文字有調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1880.wav", + "text": "第21案要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1881.wav", + "text": "對啊先保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1882.wav", + "text": "溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1883.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1884.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1885.wav", + "text": "是不是併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1886.wav", + "text": "好第22案就併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1887.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1888.wav", + "text": "第23案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1889.wav", + "text": "這是通通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1890.wav", + "text": "就不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1891.wav", + "text": "24案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1892.wav", + "text": "黨團也蓋章了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1893.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1894.wav", + "text": "第24案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1895.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1896.wav", + "text": "有希望能夠改主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1897.wav", + "text": "但是委員還沒有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1898.wav", + "text": "沒有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1899.wav", + "text": "等一下第26案不是我們的是時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1900.wav", + "text": "25案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1901.wav", + "text": "修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1902.wav", + "text": "行政院都還不能夠提出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1903.wav", + "text": "這是非常不應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1904.wav", + "text": "因為2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1905.wav", + "text": "蔡總統上任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1906.wav", + "text": "就說要落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1907.wav", + "text": "國家對排除人民集會遊行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1908.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1909.wav", + "text": "集會遊行法還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1910.wav", + "text": "等等又有很多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1911.wav", + "text": "要求甚至有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1912.wav", + "text": "解散等等制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1913.wav", + "text": "所以這個是非常非常落後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1914.wav", + "text": "然後到現在為止行政院也都還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1915.wav", + "text": "不提出一個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1916.wav", + "text": "這個顯然跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1917.wav", + "text": "人權及轉型正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1918.wav", + "text": "這個部分是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1919.wav", + "text": "你如果說要落實人權及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1920.wav", + "text": "轉型正義的話這種集會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1921.wav", + "text": "遊行的惡法基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1922.wav", + "text": "都是國民黨時代留下來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1923.wav", + "text": "嘛比較法上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1924.wav", + "text": "即使隨便看一個國家你就會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1925.wav", + "text": "不想要讓人民集會遊行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1926.wav", + "text": "法律所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1927.wav", + "text": "針對這一個人權及轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1928.wav", + "text": "正義的經費提案凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1929.wav", + "text": "請問一下時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1930.wav", + "text": "量有沒有我們這一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1931.wav", + "text": "並沒有集會遊行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1932.wav", + "text": "啊沒有人提過行政院也沒有送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1933.wav", + "text": "立法院有沒有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1934.wav", + "text": "邱委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1935.wav", + "text": "這個是過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1936.wav", + "text": "民進黨從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1937.wav", + "text": "2008年野草莓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1938.wav", + "text": "學運的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1939.wav", + "text": "時任黨主席蔡英文總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1940.wav", + "text": "就在自由廣場前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1941.wav", + "text": "人權永久保固書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1942.wav", + "text": "嘛那時候就承諾說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1943.wav", + "text": "未來民進黨無論在朝或在野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1944.wav", + "text": "集會結社自由等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1945.wav", + "text": "這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1946.wav", + "text": "法制來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1947.wav", + "text": "柯總召你應該非常清楚才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1948.wav", + "text": "啊你怎麼還會再問這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1949.wav", + "text": "我比你更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1950.wav", + "text": "你不要這樣亂講一通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1951.wav", + "text": "我都還沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1952.wav", + "text": "你應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1953.wav", + "text": "這個集會遊行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1954.wav", + "text": "從2016年開始民進黨完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1955.wav", + "text": "執政到現在都還沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1956.wav", + "text": "通過一個院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1957.wav", + "text": "跟主席報告這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1958.wav", + "text": "院也有提出一個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1959.wav", + "text": "的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1960.wav", + "text": "是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1961.wav", + "text": "讓我們在三個月內提出書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1962.wav", + "text": "報告凍結是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1963.wav", + "text": "併整個科目凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1964.wav", + "text": "50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1965.wav", + "text": "我們有一個建議的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1966.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1967.wav", + "text": "內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1968.wav", + "text": "還在研擬階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1969.wav", + "text": "它就變主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1970.wav", + "text": "了就沒有凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1971.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1972.wav", + "text": "那當然不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1973.wav", + "text": "你這樣不是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1974.wav", + "text": "你們自己提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1975.wav", + "text": "連終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1976.wav", + "text": "行政濫權都要劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1977.wav", + "text": "這本來就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1978.wav", + "text": "這有什麼好不能夠講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1979.wav", + "text": "民進黨在野的時候也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1980.wav", + "text": "這是一個惡法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1981.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1982.wav", + "text": "我們2020年就提出了你現在還在問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1983.wav", + "text": "現在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1984.wav", + "text": "你沒有提出就是要檢討了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1985.wav", + "text": "我們有提出過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1986.wav", + "text": "啦事實上這一屆都沒有人審過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1987.wav", + "text": "沒審過是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1988.wav", + "text": "第一個沒有院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1989.wav", + "text": "嘛院根本沒有版他到現在還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1990.wav", + "text": "講說他���近要提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1991.wav", + "text": "一個什麼草案之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1992.wav", + "text": "很簡單早就提出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1993.wav", + "text": "現在是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1994.wav", + "text": "保留就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1995.wav", + "text": "就暫時保留回頭再溝通好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1996.wav", + "text": "暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1997.wav", + "text": "第26案就暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1998.wav", + "text": "啦等一下看怎麼樣再溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/1999.wav", + "text": "決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2000.wav", + "text": "\n第28案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2001.wav", + "text": "\n第29案併通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2002.wav", + "text": "這個雖然是通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2003.wav", + "text": "哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2004.wav", + "text": "他有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2005.wav", + "text": "他有特別我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2006.wav", + "text": "他就說要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2007.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2008.wav", + "text": "第29案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2009.wav", + "text": "第30案有一個建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2010.wav", + "text": "併案凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2011.wav", + "text": "有簡單的文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2012.wav", + "text": "只有一行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2013.wav", + "text": "這個想要先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2014.wav", + "text": "我們不想併好第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2015.wav", + "text": "30案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2016.wav", + "text": "31案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2017.wav", + "text": "有簽字這已經同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2018.wav", + "text": "同意併案凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2019.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2020.wav", + "text": "併哪一個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2021.wav", + "text": "併整個科目50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2022.wav", + "text": "好第31案就併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2023.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2024.wav", + "text": "好併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2025.wav", + "text": "是不是也併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2026.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2027.wav", + "text": "他同意我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2028.wav", + "text": "減列10萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2029.wav", + "text": "然後科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2030.wav", + "text": "賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2031.wav", + "text": "10萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2032.wav", + "text": "變少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2033.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2034.wav", + "text": "好減列10萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2035.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2036.wav", + "text": "第33案併通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2037.wav", + "text": "科目辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2038.wav", + "text": "第33案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2039.wav", + "text": "剛剛跟賴委員溝通是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2040.wav", + "text": "他希望減20" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2041.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2042.wav", + "text": "通案會減比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2043.wav", + "text": "併通刪科目辦理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2044.wav", + "text": "第32案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2045.wav", + "text": "科目讓他們自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2046.wav", + "text": "第34案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2047.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2048.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2049.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2050.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2051.wav", + "text": "37案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2052.wav", + "text": "沒有意見照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2053.wav", + "text": "第38案因為裡面有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2054.wav", + "text": "是比較驚悚的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2055.wav", + "text": "如果要修正會是很大幅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2056.wav", + "text": "修正所以是不是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2057.wav", + "text": "這個案子先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2058.wav", + "text": "哪一個部分驚悚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2059.wav", + "text": "進用人員桃色風波不斷這個驚悚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2060.wav", + "text": "哪一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2061.wav", + "text": "桃色風波不斷最近不是才剛發生嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2062.wav", + "text": "哪裡有刺激" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2063.wav", + "text": "\n哪一段驚悚我看不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2064.wav", + "text": "我們有兩行的修正建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2065.wav", + "text": "不是你先告訴我們哪一段驚悚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2066.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以隨便誣衊我們洪孟楷委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2067.wav", + "text": "呢哪一段驚悚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2068.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2069.wav", + "text": "桃色風波不斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2070.wav", + "text": "啊不是事實嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2071.wav", + "text": "是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2072.wav", + "text": "不過秘書長比較古意啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2073.wav", + "text": "所以覺得那樣很驚悚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2074.wav", + "text": "沒有意見照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2075.wav", + "text": "\n第40案主決議沒有意見照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2076.wav", + "text": "\n第41案主決議沒有意見照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2077.wav", + "text": "第42案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2078.wav", + "text": "裡面有提到希望對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2079.wav", + "text": "張子敬政委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2080.wav", + "text": "其實他指控說是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2081.wav", + "text": "有包庇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2082.wav", + "text": "環境部的政風處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2083.wav", + "text": "都有查過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2084.wav", + "text": "都���查證了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2085.wav", + "text": "也已經結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2086.wav", + "text": "修正的意見是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2087.wav", + "text": "能夠同意修正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2088.wav", + "text": "修正的案子在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2089.wav", + "text": "秘書長結案什麼時候公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2090.wav", + "text": "修正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2091.wav", + "text": "好第42案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2092.wav", + "text": "請問結案什麼時候要公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2093.wav", + "text": "已經有給院長看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2094.wav", + "text": "也確認什麼時候要公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2095.wav", + "text": "我們會對外來做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2096.wav", + "text": "沒有意見照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2097.wav", + "text": "\n第44案主決議沒有意見照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2098.wav", + "text": "\n第45案主決議沒有意見照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2099.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2100.wav", + "text": "第46案是對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2101.wav", + "text": "現階段他這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2102.wav", + "text": "針對陳院長在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2103.wav", + "text": "輔選裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2104.wav", + "text": "一些意見這個是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2105.wav", + "text": "能夠保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2106.wav", + "text": "哪一個不符合事實哪一段不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2107.wav", + "text": "事實提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2108.wav", + "text": "假視察真輔選哪一段不符合事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2109.wav", + "text": "我們有具體舉出來喔10月15日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2110.wav", + "text": "出席高雄軟體園區科技大樓開工典禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2111.wav", + "text": "10月30日國3金城交流道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2112.wav", + "text": "我們可以撤案啊哪一段是不正確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2113.wav", + "text": "講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2114.wav", + "text": "11月26日原來安排前往花東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2115.wav", + "text": "視察卻更改行程前往民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2116.wav", + "text": "花東造勢活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2117.wav", + "text": "濫用行政資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2118.wav", + "text": "利用上班時間進行拜票輔選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2119.wav", + "text": "而且這文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2120.wav", + "text": "哪一個不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2121.wav", + "text": "爰此要求行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2122.wav", + "text": "這文字非常的平和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2123.wav", + "text": "我們有建議一段文字是不是可以參考院的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2124.wav", + "text": "你的建議不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2125.wav", + "text": "與事實不符" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2126.wav", + "text": "院的建議在哪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2127.wav", + "text": "我們沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2128.wav", + "text": "建議這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2129.wav", + "text": "好那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2130.wav", + "text": "沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2131.wav", + "text": "謹守行政中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2132.wav", + "text": "啊都沒有謹守行政中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2133.wav", + "text": "您的文字在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2134.wav", + "text": "沒有給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2135.wav", + "text": "你們如果說文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2136.wav", + "text": "東西就要給我們看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2137.wav", + "text": "如果沒有你就不要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2138.wav", + "text": "沒有嚴守行政中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2139.wav", + "text": "個涉及陳建仁的清白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2140.wav", + "text": "要讓他講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2141.wav", + "text": "對啊上臺致詞公然幫民進黨候選人拉票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2142.wav", + "text": "啊陳建仁先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2143.wav", + "text": "他要講清楚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2144.wav", + "text": "假公濟私可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2145.wav", + "text": "怎樣本來就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2146.wav", + "text": "行政中立本來就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2147.wav", + "text": "是這個意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2148.wav", + "text": "好那就等他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2149.wav", + "text": "修正文字拿出來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2150.wav", + "text": "等他們提出文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2151.wav", + "text": "暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2152.wav", + "text": "院長這個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2153.wav", + "text": "涉及到陳建仁院長的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2154.wav", + "text": "我們要慎重處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2155.wav", + "text": "趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2156.wav", + "text": "默認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2157.wav", + "text": "他們寫好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2158.wav", + "text": "我們建議這個案子還是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2159.wav", + "text": "你先拿來看吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2160.wav", + "text": "為什麼要保留是哪一段不符合實情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2161.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2162.wav", + "text": "11月14日赴花東出席社宅動土典禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2163.wav", + "text": "讓民進黨籍候選人穿著競選背心陪同上台\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2164.wav", + "text": "哪一段不是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2165.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2166.wav", + "text": "還是你沒辦法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2167.wav", + "text": "請院長自己來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2168.wav", + "text": "行政中立的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2169.wav", + "text": "文字改不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2170.wav", + "text": "陳建仁先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2171.wav", + "text": "你不認識喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2172.wav", + "text": "這上面都有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2173.wav", + "text": "10月15號出席高雄軟體園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2174.wav", + "text": "具體事證都有寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2175.wav", + "text": "不是他現在說的是陳建仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2176.wav", + "text": "不是立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2177.wav", + "text": "陳建仁院長多次利用公務假視察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2178.wav", + "text": "拉票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2179.wav", + "text": "這不譴責就不錯啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2180.wav", + "text": "要不然院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2181.wav", + "text": "政府的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2182.wav", + "text": "公款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2183.wav", + "text": "主持可以但不用在上面拉票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2184.wav", + "text": "他怎麼拉票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2185.wav", + "text": "你看看10月30日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2186.wav", + "text": "上台致詞時公然幫民進黨候選人拉票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2187.wav", + "text": "他怎麼拉法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2188.wav", + "text": "你講清楚你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2189.wav", + "text": "要假如參加的時候是高雄市的立法委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2190.wav", + "text": "員還有錯嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2191.wav", + "text": "所有的立法委員去他也會感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2192.wav", + "text": "大家都可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2193.wav", + "text": "現任的總部是民進黨的吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2194.wav", + "text": "讓民進黨籍候選人穿競選背心上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2195.wav", + "text": "這是誰提案的來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2196.wav", + "text": "是你提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2197.wav", + "text": "對我提案是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2198.wav", + "text": "怎麼會變我自己說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2199.wav", + "text": "我要瞭解你提案內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2200.wav", + "text": "你們哪個字看不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2201.wav", + "text": "看不懂我們幫你注音沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2202.wav", + "text": "不要說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2203.wav", + "text": "你現在是行政院秘書長喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2204.wav", + "text": "秘書長講不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2205.wav", + "text": "完全執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2206.wav", + "text": "完全護航就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2207.wav", + "text": "行政院長去到任何地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2208.wav", + "text": "反正都會通知當地的立法委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2209.wav", + "text": "沒錯啊但是這邊是通知民進黨的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2210.wav", + "text": "不是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2211.wav", + "text": "喔花東不是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2212.wav", + "text": "或者是活動的行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2213.wav", + "text": "立委候選人或是立委本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2214.wav", + "text": "會上去參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2215.wav", + "text": "你也沒辦法去改變他的穿著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2216.wav", + "text": "沒辦法當場叫他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2217.wav", + "text": "把這個穿著改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2218.wav", + "text": "會提醒大家注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2219.wav", + "text": "就是政務人員跟民選首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2220.wav", + "text": "雖非公務人員行政中立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2221.wav", + "text": "規範對象但是從事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2222.wav", + "text": "與選舉或輔選相關行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2223.wav", + "text": "應該於請假或下班時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2224.wav", + "text": "並且不動用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2225.wav", + "text": "給我們看他是立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2226.wav", + "text": "現任立委你剛剛不是說現任立委可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2227.wav", + "text": "不管哪個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2228.wav", + "text": "議員也有去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2229.wav", + "text": "跟地方有關的當然民意代表都會去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2230.wav", + "text": "啊你們執政的縣市也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2231.wav", + "text": "這個案子就保留嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2232.wav", + "text": "改很多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2233.wav", + "text": "你這這個改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2234.wav", + "text": "只是把所有的事實都改掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2235.wav", + "text": "但是改的內容沒有不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2236.wav", + "text": "說真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2237.wav", + "text": "改的內容是說要怎麼做啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2238.wav", + "text": "爰此要求行政院長陳建仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2239.wav", + "text": "應潔身自愛謹守行政中立這個要保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2240.wav", + "text": "潔身自愛有什麼不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2241.wav", + "text": "這文字一點都不驚悚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2242.wav", + "text": "他已經非常自愛了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2243.wav", + "text": "他已經非常潔身自愛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2244.wav", + "text": "要求再潔身自愛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2245.wav", + "text": "你作文都不通嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2246.wav", + "text": "這樣文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2247.wav", + "text": "有改來了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2248.wav", + "text": "這個文字這樣修改可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2249.wav", + "text": "就是留後面那句嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2250.wav", + "text": "要求潔身自愛前面這一段是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2251.wav", + "text": "還不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2252.wav", + "text": "要求要求潔身自愛不行啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2253.wav", + "text": "要求政務人員及民選首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2254.wav", + "text": "貶義的意味嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2255.wav", + "text": "我叫你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2256.wav", + "text": "那請可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2257.wav", + "text": "如果沒有辦法形成共識就保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2258.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2259.wav", + "text": "沒有意見照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2260.wav", + "text": "第48案因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2261.wav", + "text": "是針對鄭副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2262.wav", + "text": "我們是不是建議這個能夠保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2263.wav", + "text": "48案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2264.wav", + "text": "先不要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2265.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2266.wav", + "text": "第49案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2267.wav", + "text": "裡面有很多我們也覺得不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2268.wav", + "text": "修改所以是不是也建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2269.wav", + "text": "你要針對我們黨團提案說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2270.wav", + "text": "哪些不是事實我們可以刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2271.wav", + "text": "比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2272.wav", + "text": "蛋價上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2273.wav", + "text": "小吃店賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2274.wav", + "text": "快篩這個不是事實嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2275.wav", + "text": "這個有一點像中國時報社論不好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2276.wav", + "text": "什麼中國時報社論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2277.wav", + "text": "政府全力扶植高端公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2278.wav", + "text": "黑箱通過審查這不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2279.wav", + "text": "事實嗎報內線交易不是事實嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2280.wav", + "text": "小吃店賣快篩不是事實嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2281.wav", + "text": "內線交易是已經抓了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2282.wav", + "text": "一人超思公司取得上億進口蛋採購案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2283.wav", + "text": "這些都是事實啊為什麼要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2284.wav", + "text": "為什麼要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2285.wav", + "text": "這些都是國家級詐騙為什麼要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2286.wav", + "text": "你在掩護詐騙嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2287.wav", + "text": "你們沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2288.wav", + "text": "他們要說明啊到底立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2289.wav", + "text": "慎重提出的案子有哪裡是不對的我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2290.wav", + "text": "改嘛如果對的就應該通過啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2291.wav", + "text": "你們黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2292.wav", + "text": "沒有共識就保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2293.wav", + "text": "我們請行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2294.wav", + "text": "說明有什麼不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2295.wav", + "text": "你說那邊的都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2296.wav", + "text": "現在我們有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2297.wav", + "text": "政黨有不同意見就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2298.wav", + "text": "你看這寫了一大篇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2299.wav", + "text": "真正最重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2300.wav", + "text": "最後兩行爰此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2301.wav", + "text": "要求行政院及所屬部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2302.wav", + "text": "要避免濫用國家隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2303.wav", + "text": "損及政府威信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2304.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2305.wav", + "text": "講了這麼多國家隊成立了幾十個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2306.wav", + "text": "40個國家隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2307.wav", + "text": "是不是太多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2308.wav", + "text": "就是你們把國家隊污名化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2309.wav", + "text": "啊這麼好的東西被你們污名化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2310.wav", + "text": "好沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2311.wav", + "text": "我們就保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2312.wav", + "text": "第49案沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2313.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2314.wav", + "text": "我們有建議一些修正的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2315.wav", + "text": "有沒有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2316.wav", + "text": "這個為什麼刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2317.wav", + "text": "行政院宣布投入14億是沒有投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2318.wav", + "text": "是數字寫錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2319.wav", + "text": "還是寫太少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2320.wav", + "text": "或寫太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2321.wav", + "text": "14億成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2322.wav", + "text": "投入14億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2323.wav", + "text": "這6個字刪掉的主要原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2324.wav", + "text": "是寫錯了太少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2325.wav", + "text": "還是太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2326.wav", + "text": "還是你們當時沒說數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2327.wav", + "text": "原因是什麼為什麼要刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2328.wav", + "text": "秘書長這要請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2329.wav", + "text": "文字對照會覺得說好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2330.wav", + "text": "但是打詐成績完全不及格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2331.wav", + "text": "這兩個連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2332.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有投入14億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2333.wav", + "text": "嘛有沒有投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2334.wav", + "text": "但是這個不是1年是2年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2335.wav", + "text": "這個是事實嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2336.wav", + "text": "那這句為什麼要刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2337.wav", + "text": "跟後面這裡有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2338.wav", + "text": "你是指打詐成績完全不合格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2339.wav", + "text": "嗎不然你覺得百姓覺得你打詐成績合格嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2340.wav", + "text": "其實我想大家也都很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2341.wav", + "text": "所以你們自認為你們打詐成績合格嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2342.wav", + "text": "我想也有一些成果啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2343.wav", + "text": "你覺得可以打幾分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2344.wav", + "text": "合格是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2345.wav", + "text": "他要修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2346.wav", + "text": "我們總要知道他修改的原因可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2347.wav", + "text": "我們問說他修改14億是不是真的有投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2348.wav", + "text": "他說有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2349.wav", + "text": "打詐是永遠不會停止的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2350.wav", + "text": "政府打詐成績完全不及格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2351.wav", + "text": "他認為可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2352.wav", + "text": "我問他說大概幾分嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2353.wav", + "text": "回答一下就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2354.wav", + "text": "他可以寫進來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2355.wav", + "text": "我問你怎麼會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2356.wav", + "text": "是行政院在打這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2357.wav", + "text": "這為什麼要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2358.wav", + "text": "沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2359.wav", + "text": "因為沒有對於行政院要投入14億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2360.wav", + "text": "有沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2361.wav", + "text": "我們理性地提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2362.wav", + "text": "他為什麼要刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2363.wav", + "text": "哪一個不一樣沒有14億嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2364.wav", + "text": "因為保留你們都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2365.wav", + "text": "用多數碾壓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2366.wav", + "text": "所以當然你們都要保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2367.wav", + "text": "因為黨團沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2368.wav", + "text": "請看第51案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2369.wav", + "text": "這個也建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2370.wav", + "text": "為什麼每個案都要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2371.wav", + "text": "叫你們做修正有什麼要保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2372.wav", + "text": "呢你們又改了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2373.wav", + "text": "主決議為什麼要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2374.wav", + "text": "我們修了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2375.wav", + "text": "主決議文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2376.wav", + "text": "因為裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2377.wav", + "text": "有蠻多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2378.wav", + "text": "譬如說大撒幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2379.wav", + "text": "啦然後政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2380.wav", + "text": "劫貧濟富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2381.wav", + "text": "大家沒有辦法去接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2382.wav", + "text": "這這個寫得很好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2383.wav", + "text": "內政部沒有導正黑市問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2384.wav", + "text": "忽略最關鍵的房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2385.wav", + "text": "不讓房租領補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2386.wav", + "text": "這個是事實啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2387.wav", + "text": "哪一段是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2388.wav", + "text": "你可以把你覺得不好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2389.wav", + "text": "文字修掉但是我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2390.wav", + "text": "好沒有共識我們保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2391.wav", + "text": "第51案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2392.wav", + "text": "\n請看第52案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2393.wav", + "text": "第52案因為這個牽涉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2394.wav", + "text": "要不要撤中正紀念堂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2395.wav", + "text": "的三軍儀隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2396.wav", + "text": "啦我們建議是不是也保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2397.wav", + "text": "我的提案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2398.wav", + "text": "請國防部可以1年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2399.wav", + "text": "具體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2400.wav", + "text": "嘛事實上之前有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2401.wav", + "text": "撤離過有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2402.wav", + "text": "在阿扁總統的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2403.wav", + "text": "三軍儀隊就有撤離過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2404.wav", + "text": "啊所以你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2405.wav", + "text": "這個到底有什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2406.wav", + "text": "困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2407.wav", + "text": "本來現在的狀況是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2408.wav", + "text": "你要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2409.wav", + "text": "做中正紀念堂的規劃等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2410.wav", + "text": "的撤離本來就是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2411.wav", + "text": "嘛並不是說要等待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2412.wav", + "text": "什麼銅像的處置才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2413.wav", + "text": "去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2414.wav", + "text": "每年都有這一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2415.wav", + "text": "我的提案只是叫他1年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2416.wav", + "text": "撤離中正紀念堂去規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2417.wav", + "text": "本來他就可以提出一個規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2418.wav", + "text": "啊這個題目每年都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2419.wav", + "text": "好那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2420.wav", + "text": "52案的主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2421.wav", + "text": "我們還沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2422.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2423.wav", + "text": "行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2424.wav", + "text": "院本部的就到此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2425.wav", + "text": "告一段落結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2426.wav", + "text": "了接下來就到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2427.wav", + "text": "原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2428.wav", + "text": "亂象都寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2429.wav", + "text": "要進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2430.wav", + "text": "原民會我首先介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2431.wav", + "text": "原民會的列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2432.wav", + "text": "\n接下來就請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2433.wav", + "text": "第53案改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2434.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2435.wav", + "text": "主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2436.wav", + "text": "5案是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2437.wav", + "text": "拿來已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2438.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2439.wav", + "text": "第56案也改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2440.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2441.wav", + "text": "\n第57案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2442.wav", + "text": "也改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2443.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2444.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2445.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2446.wav", + "text": "58案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2447.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2448.wav", + "text": "59案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2449.wav", + "text": "已經改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2450.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2451.wav", + "text": "主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2452.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2453.wav", + "text": "63案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2454.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2455.wav", + "text": "趕快脫離現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2456.wav", + "text": "介紹一下列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2457.wav", + "text": "現在換客家委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2458.wav", + "text": "列席的首長是主任委員楊長鎮先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2459.wav", + "text": "\n接下來就請大家看第70案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2460.wav", + "text": "第70案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2461.wav", + "text": "\n第73案改凍結100萬元沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2462.wav", + "text": "\n第74案併委員會決議辦理沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2463.wav", + "text": "\n第87案主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2464.wav", + "text": "\n第88案主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2465.wav", + "text": "\n第89案主決議文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2466.wav", + "text": "我先來介紹列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2467.wav", + "text": "中選會列席的首長是主任委員李進勇先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2468.wav", + "text": "現在就請大家看中選會第90案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2469.wav", + "text": "第90案溝通後改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2470.wav", + "text": "文字有一點修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2471.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2472.wav", + "text": "是不是就改成主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2473.wav", + "text": "我們有一些文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2474.wav", + "text": "是不是有簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2475.wav", + "text": "沒有簽沒有簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2476.wav", + "text": "有跟黨團溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2477.wav", + "text": "溝通沒有結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2478.wav", + "text": "保留啦院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2479.wav", + "text": "沒有簽沒有簽那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2480.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2481.wav", + "text": "先謝謝召委召委已經同意撤簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2482.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2483.wav", + "text": "對不起撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2484.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2485.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2486.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2487.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2488.wav", + "text": "這個沒有併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2489.wav", + "text": "喔這好像有溝通嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2490.wav", + "text": "\n有跟黨團溝通嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2491.wav", + "text": "93" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2492.wav", + "text": "就是向你溝通就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2493.wav", + "text": "這個我們想要先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2494.wav", + "text": "請委員支持我們會提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2495.wav", + "text": "我想這一案黨��是希望保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2496.wav", + "text": "93案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2497.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2498.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2499.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2500.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2501.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2502.wav", + "text": "改為書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2503.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2504.wav", + "text": "這個好像有溝通也沒有結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2505.wav", + "text": "我是99" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2506.wav", + "text": "改書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2507.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2508.wav", + "text": "主決議改書面報告好沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2509.wav", + "text": "主決議就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2510.wav", + "text": "對不起第96案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2511.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2512.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2513.wav", + "text": "提出專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2514.wav", + "text": "對啦併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2515.wav", + "text": "對不起是改書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2516.wav", + "text": "什麼改提書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2517.wav", + "text": "就是併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2518.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理是沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2519.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理就很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2520.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2521.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2522.wav", + "text": "還有哪一案沒有是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2523.wav", + "text": "文字要修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2524.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2525.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2526.wav", + "text": "保留哪一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2527.wav", + "text": "剛剛第99" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2528.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2529.wav", + "text": "就改成書面了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2530.wav", + "text": "來現在換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2531.wav", + "text": "大陸委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2532.wav", + "text": "首先介紹列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2533.wav", + "text": "主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2534.wav", + "text": "邱太三先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2535.wav", + "text": "接下來請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2536.wav", + "text": "案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2537.wav", + "text": "102案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2538.wav", + "text": "賴士葆委員說這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2539.wav", + "text": "要保留你們沒有過去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2540.wav", + "text": "報告院長跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2541.wav", + "text": "我們本來有跟他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2542.wav", + "text": "訂明天早上11點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2543.wav", + "text": "那因為臨時提早到這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2544.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛有去跟他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2545.wav", + "text": "主任報告但是他的主任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2546.wav", + "text": "好像還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2547.wav", + "text": "希望能夠堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2548.wav", + "text": "他們是希望堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2549.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2550.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2551.wav", + "text": "因為我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2552.wav", + "text": "政府的A級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2553.wav", + "text": "啦所以如果凍結5%對我們來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2554.wav", + "text": "可能我們在相關的業務的推動上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2555.wav", + "text": "改主決議好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2556.wav", + "text": "約11點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2557.wav", + "text": "那就明天去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2558.wav", + "text": "我們已經跟他的主任說明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2559.wav", + "text": "我相信他的主任也轉達給他了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2560.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2561.wav", + "text": "我們尊重一下提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2562.wav", + "text": "你不要亂講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2563.wav", + "text": "所有的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2564.wav", + "text": "的黨鞭都在這裡要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2565.wav", + "text": "不能說這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2566.wav", + "text": "不然剛剛為什麼都不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2567.wav", + "text": "前面幾個案子都給我們保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2568.wav", + "text": "如果說我們併委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2569.wav", + "text": "剛剛是我們黨團說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2570.wav", + "text": "賴士葆委員這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2571.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠併主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2572.wav", + "text": "就以主決議來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2573.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2574.wav", + "text": "黨鞭要做決定這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2575.wav", + "text": "有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2576.wav", + "text": "為什麼你們突然不能保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2577.wav", + "text": "是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2578.wav", + "text": "前面幾案都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2579.wav", + "text": "你們也是現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2580.wav", + "text": "這個比較簡單我們現在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2581.wav", + "text": "委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2582.wav", + "text": "的結論是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2583.wav", + "text": "主要我們是政府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2584.wav", + "text": "委員會一般行政凍結50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2585.wav", + "text": "他說明天要溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2586.wav", + "text": "了你怎麼知道溝通不會成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2587.wav", + "text": "我對陸委會有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2588.wav", + "text": "我們處理掉就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2589.wav", + "text": "這是資訊費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2590.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2591.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2592.wav", + "text": "其實委員會已經凍結50萬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2593.wav", + "text": "我再跟賴士葆委員講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2594.wav", + "text": "這才算總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2595.wav", + "text": "第102案併委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2596.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2597.wav", + "text": "我們已經給民眾黨了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2598.wav", + "text": "改主決議沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2599.wav", + "text": "你們是希望改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2600.wav", + "text": "但黨團還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2601.wav", + "text": "再解凍使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2602.wav", + "text": "你們把相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2603.wav", + "text": "部分寫一寫可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2604.wav", + "text": "不用專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2605.wav", + "text": "用書面就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2606.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2607.wav", + "text": "沒有等一下併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2608.wav", + "text": "併委員會嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2609.wav", + "text": "併委員會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2610.wav", + "text": "委員會是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2611.wav", + "text": "凍結100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2612.wav", + "text": "我們原先是希望凍多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2613.wav", + "text": "不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2614.wav", + "text": "案先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2615.wav", + "text": "你比陳椒華還難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2616.wav", + "text": "併委員會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2617.wav", + "text": "大家都有交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2618.wav", + "text": "但是提書面報告給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2619.wav", + "text": "這邊是不是希望凍更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2620.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2621.wav", + "text": "委員會只凍100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2622.wav", + "text": "我們內政委員會一起努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2623.wav", + "text": "併委員會就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2624.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2625.wav", + "text": "但是要提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2626.wav", + "text": "要提書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2627.wav", + "text": "提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2628.wav", + "text": "請看第107案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2629.wav", + "text": "第107案就是本席提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2630.wav", + "text": "我要特別說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2631.wav", + "text": "請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2632.wav", + "text": "這個案子我提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2633.wav", + "text": "刪除陸委會補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2634.wav", + "text": "給海基會今年增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2635.wav", + "text": "4,500萬預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2636.wav", + "text": "是今年增加的不是原來就有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2637.wav", + "text": "預算裡我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2638.wav", + "text": "海基會原來的人事費用是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2639.wav", + "text": "主管費用6,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2640.wav", + "text": "而這一次增加的4,500萬裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2641.wav", + "text": "預算比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2642.wav", + "text": "人事及行政費用就增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2643.wav", + "text": "2,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2644.wav", + "text": "從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2645.wav", + "text": "9,800萬變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2646.wav", + "text": "1億1,800萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2647.wav", + "text": "增加了2,000萬的人事及行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2648.wav", + "text": "費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2649.wav", + "text": "現在海基會大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2650.wav", + "text": "海基會的功能就是兩岸文書驗證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2651.wav", + "text": "這個做得比較多大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2652.wav", + "text": "今年增加的預算裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2653.wav", + "text": "兩岸文書驗證什麼聯合服務中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2654.wav", + "text": "兩岸婚姻親子關懷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2655.wav", + "text": "司法行政互助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2656.wav", + "text": "等只增加35萬6,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2657.wav", + "text": "但人事行政費增加2,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2658.wav", + "text": "陸委會講這要請海基會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2659.wav", + "text": "說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2660.wav", + "text": "這點我說過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2661.wav", + "text": "結果在還沒有來說明前就給我扣紅帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2662.wav", + "text": "在媒體給我扣帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2663.wav", + "text": "為了中國啊什麼的就刪海基會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2664.wav", + "text": "今年增加的4,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2665.wav", + "text": "裡有2,000萬是人事及行政費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2666.wav", + "text": "6,500萬是主管費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2667.wav", + "text": "換句話說一個月有500萬給主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2668.wav", + "text": "我看過他們主管的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2669.wav", + "text": "他們一年還有1,000萬的獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2670.wav", + "text": "海基會做了什麼事一年可以有1,000萬獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2671.wav", + "text": "每個人一個月薪水都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2672.wav", + "text": "十幾萬二十幾萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2673.wav", + "text": "啊做最多的就是兩岸文書驗證但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2674.wav", + "text": "今年只增加預算35萬多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2675.wav", + "text": "所以我想請問這點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2676.wav", + "text": "我請海基會說明可是海基會沒有來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2677.wav", + "text": "今天我人都在這裡他們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2678.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這個應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2679.wav", + "text": "照本席的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2680.wav", + "text": "然後我也說了如果陸委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2681.wav", + "text": "宣布明年就開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2682.wav", + "text": "來旅遊我這個案子馬上撤掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2683.wav", + "text": "這個不是這樣交換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2684.wav", + "text": "不是什麼交換條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2685.wav", + "text": "這是通刪項目照通刪來就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2686.wav", + "text": "這不是什麼通刪項目不通刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2687.wav", + "text": "解釋一下為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2688.wav", + "text": "這個人事預算這樣增加浮濫編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2689.wav", + "text": "這是獎補助照通刪就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2690.wav", + "text": "可以解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2691.wav", + "text": "請相關單位稍微解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2692.wav", + "text": "不然我不理解為什麼沒有做事的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2693.wav", + "text": "一年要增加2,000萬人事行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2694.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2695.wav", + "text": "報告院長跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2696.wav", + "text": "我想你也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2697.wav", + "text": "那一天我去拜訪你之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2698.wav", + "text": "我有當場聯繫海基會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2699.wav", + "text": "秘書長跟你聯絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2700.wav", + "text": "但是跟你們辦公室好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2701.wav", + "text": "一直還沒有聯絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2702.wav", + "text": "我晚上都在這邊審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2703.wav", + "text": "他就應該過來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2704.wav", + "text": "主題啊為什麼增加2,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2705.wav", + "text": "我的提案人事及行政費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2706.wav", + "text": "中共台辦要求台商不得參加這個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2707.wav", + "text": "努力不夠嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2708.wav", + "text": "到底為什麼要增加2,000萬人事費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2709.wav", + "text": "陳玉珍委員其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2710.wav", + "text": "這個案子衍發生出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2711.wav", + "text": "你寫得也不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2712.wav", + "text": "是減列4,500萬的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2713.wav", + "text": "今年增加4,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2714.wav", + "text": "因為你們都沒有看內部的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2715.wav", + "text": "我們是仔細看預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2716.wav", + "text": "你仔細看預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2717.wav", + "text": "你的案由你自己講說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2718.wav", + "text": "中共台辦要求台商不得參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2719.wav", + "text": "我說的是他們到金門這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2720.wav", + "text": "沒有辦得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2721.wav", + "text": "當然啦我的意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2722.wav", + "text": "中共台辦要求台商不得參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2723.wav", + "text": "海基會考察活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2724.wav", + "text": "當然會引發誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2725.wav", + "text": "你們不查��楚就給它放媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2726.wav", + "text": "不對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2727.wav", + "text": "這個是你整個你的白紙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2728.wav", + "text": "不能這樣誘敵深入嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2729.wav", + "text": "你們這樣就只會扣紅帽子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2730.wav", + "text": "這個也沒有人要扣你紅帽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2731.wav", + "text": "而是講說你為什麼不去譴責老共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2732.wav", + "text": "你看扣你紅帽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2733.wav", + "text": "你多開心啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2734.wav", + "text": "我先請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2735.wav", + "text": "為什麼要增加人事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2736.wav", + "text": "費2,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2737.wav", + "text": "陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2738.wav", + "text": "你昨天還針對媒體講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2739.wav", + "text": "如果讀你這個案的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2740.wav", + "text": "看起來會覺得說這個是中共要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2741.wav", + "text": "台商不得參加海基會活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2742.wav", + "text": "那到底干陸委會有什麼事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2743.wav", + "text": "是陸委會補助海基會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2744.wav", + "text": "因為它的費用是列在陸委會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2745.wav", + "text": "法政處下面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2746.wav", + "text": "啦因為預算是這樣編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2747.wav", + "text": "因為你這個案由的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2748.wav", + "text": "人家閱讀你這個案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2749.wav", + "text": "也會覺得說欸奇怪這是對岸要求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2750.wav", + "text": "那到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2751.wav", + "text": "補助海基會服務台商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2752.wav", + "text": "嘛而且我後來看了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2753.wav", + "text": "你這個寫法剛好被人家說你是紅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2754.wav", + "text": "剛好而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2755.wav", + "text": "我是不是紅的不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2756.wav", + "text": "啦我也不在意你們說我是什麼顏色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2757.wav", + "text": "重點就是要請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2758.wav", + "text": "為什麼要增加2,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2759.wav", + "text": "我到現在也沒有聽到說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2760.wav", + "text": "2,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2761.wav", + "text": "海基會需要2,000萬的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2762.wav", + "text": "事費海基會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2763.wav", + "text": "耶6,500萬的主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2764.wav", + "text": "喔總共1億多的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2765.wav", + "text": "他在講人事費2,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2766.wav", + "text": "譬如說它的員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2767.wav", + "text": "它的員額增加了多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2768.wav", + "text": "還是它加了薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2769.wav", + "text": "還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2770.wav", + "text": "怎麼會人事費突然多了2,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2771.wav", + "text": "包括李德維委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2772.wav", + "text": "也是沒有舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2773.wav", + "text": "講一些話喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2774.wav", + "text": "二個字就好不要講太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2775.wav", + "text": "這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2776.wav", + "text": "剛剛花了那麼多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2777.wav", + "text": "嘛玉珍也很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2778.wav", + "text": "提了這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2779.wav", + "text": "你們講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2780.wav", + "text": "為什麼要增加對海基會的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2781.wav", + "text": "4,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2782.wav", + "text": "講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2783.wav", + "text": "你講的理由如果充分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2784.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2785.wav", + "text": "第一個基本上大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2786.wav", + "text": "陳玉珍委員可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2787.wav", + "text": "認為這2,000萬都是用在所謂的人事費上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2788.wav", + "text": "這個不是我認為是你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2789.wav", + "text": "預算書上寫的喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2790.wav", + "text": "讓他講完吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2791.wav", + "text": "院長跟委員都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2792.wav", + "text": "因為我們公務人員有調薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2793.wav", + "text": "還有考績的晉級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2794.wav", + "text": "這樣也會增加勞健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2795.wav", + "text": "跟退儲金的支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2796.wav", + "text": "所以人事費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2797.wav", + "text": "增加643萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2798.wav", + "text": "包括深化臺商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2799.wav", + "text": "還有跟臺商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2800.wav", + "text": "商陸配的聯繫跟交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2801.wav", + "text": "我們的海基會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2802.wav", + "text": "最近這幾年整個兩岸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2803.wav", + "text": "經貿情勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2804.wav", + "text": "特別是大陸的情勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2805.wav", + "text": "臺商在經營上確實會產生進退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2806.wav", + "text": "或者是轉這樣的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2807.wav", + "text": "啦所以它有一個臺商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2808.wav", + "text": "法律服務的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2809.wav", + "text": "我們陸委會的是臺商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2810.wav", + "text": "提供協助不管是稅務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2811.wav", + "text": "或公司治理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2812.wav", + "text": "他們有這個團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2813.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2814.wav", + "text": "\n第二個各位大概都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2815.wav", + "text": "臺流在那邊的問題越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2816.wav", + "text": "過去一��大概海基會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2817.wav", + "text": "拜託臺商協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2818.wav", + "text": "或者是我們在大陸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2819.wav", + "text": "相關人員協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2820.wav", + "text": "或者是比較不幸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2821.wav", + "text": "甚至逝世的骨灰送回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2822.wav", + "text": "這幾年坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2823.wav", + "text": "人數增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2824.wav", + "text": "過去是一年可能大概80個左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2825.wav", + "text": "現在一年大概都將近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2826.wav", + "text": "所以也增加了快一倍的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2827.wav", + "text": "這每一個都是海基會要協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2828.wav", + "text": "有的家屬不要接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2829.wav", + "text": "那種的我們接回來後國內的地方政府也很痛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2830.wav", + "text": "因為有的要請他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2831.wav", + "text": "幫忙協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2832.wav", + "text": "這個都需要聯繫的這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2833.wav", + "text": "些是就我所知的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2834.wav", + "text": "比較細的項目還有哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2835.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法代他回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2836.wav", + "text": "去跟你做說明原因也在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2837.wav", + "text": "但是大概就我所知道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2838.wav", + "text": "在你剛剛提到的二千多萬裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2839.wav", + "text": "643萬是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2840.wav", + "text": "薪水的調整所衍生下來的其他費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2841.wav", + "text": "我大概可以跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2842.wav", + "text": "各位做這樣的補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2843.wav", + "text": "因為他剛剛講的有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2844.wav", + "text": "不正確不完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2845.wav", + "text": "的法政處長沒有跟你報告完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2846.wav", + "text": "第28頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2847.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說的這個法律業務的確有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2848.wav", + "text": "加錢在4,500萬裡法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2849.wav", + "text": "元兩岸溝通業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2850.wav", + "text": "增加246萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2851.wav", + "text": "這些都跟我說的這一筆2,000萬沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2852.wav", + "text": "救助什麼的這個200萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2853.wav", + "text": "加強臺商聯繫服務增加100萬這都還是另外的喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2854.wav", + "text": "這個我有做比較表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2855.wav", + "text": "做出來我說的這2,000萬是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2856.wav", + "text": "人事及行政費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2857.wav", + "text": "因為你們每一次的預算項目都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2858.wav", + "text": "一樣的好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2859.wav", + "text": "\n它的2,000萬就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2860.wav", + "text": "辦理政府委託事項及人事及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2861.wav", + "text": "寫在第28頁裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2862.wav", + "text": "增加的這個錢裡頭除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2863.wav", + "text": "你說的那個晉級以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2864.wav", + "text": "海基會對外對媒體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2865.wav", + "text": "除了那個晉級以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2866.wav", + "text": "人事費增加的晉級以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2867.wav", + "text": "剩下的是一般行政增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2868.wav", + "text": "709萬3,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2869.wav", + "text": "元請問一般行政的業務費為什麼要增加那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2870.wav", + "text": "做什麼事情要增加七百零多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2871.wav", + "text": "剛剛你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2872.wav", + "text": "出版增加110萬這些我都沒有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2873.wav", + "text": "你還說兩岸要多溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2874.wav", + "text": "那個你們只增加了10萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2875.wav", + "text": "兩岸要多溝通聯繫協調的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2876.wav", + "text": "今年比去年只多了10萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2877.wav", + "text": "所以你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2878.wav", + "text": "人事及行政費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2879.wav", + "text": "你說的正常薪水調漲扣掉以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2880.wav", + "text": "寫的就還有709萬是一般行政費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2881.wav", + "text": "到底做什麼事情要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2882.wav", + "text": "709萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2883.wav", + "text": "來啦這一條時代力量替海基會講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2884.wav", + "text": "講一下基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2885.wav", + "text": "要求台商不得參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2886.wav", + "text": "量級的台商協會會長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2887.wav", + "text": "及台企聯常務副會長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2888.wav", + "text": "中共的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2889.wav", + "text": "啊即便陸委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2890.wav", + "text": "海基會服務臺商而且這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2891.wav", + "text": "法政業務啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2892.wav", + "text": "很多法律上的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2893.wav", + "text": "所以需要對他做支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2894.wav", + "text": "許多必要的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2895.wav", + "text": "返台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2896.wav", + "text": "台陸委會也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2897.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法這個要怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2898.wav", + "text": "陸委會增加法律的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2899.wav", + "text": "有50幾萬我再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2900.wav", + "text": "這不是刪它的預算而是刪它今年比去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2901.wav", + "text": "多增加的4,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2902.wav", + "text": "往年的預算還存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2903.wav", + "text": "今年比去年多增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2904.wav", + "text": "4,500萬多給了4,500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2905.wav", + "text": "萬我說那會用到哪裡嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2906.wav", + "text": "有增加50幾萬兩岸文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2907.wav", + "text": "驗證做最多增加36萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2908.wav", + "text": "你們多增加的是人事及行政費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2909.wav", + "text": "好你說正常的薪水增加這個我接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2910.wav", + "text": "給你多幾百萬還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2911.wav", + "text": "我還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2912.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2913.wav", + "text": "我覺得委員好像把所謂的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2914.wav", + "text": "把剛剛我講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2915.wav", + "text": "他們也許還有更細項的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2916.wav", + "text": "我不知道但是至少就我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2917.wav", + "text": "的我剛剛講的就是要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2918.wav", + "text": "做台商的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2919.wav", + "text": "包括公司治理的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2920.wav", + "text": "包括他未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2921.wav", + "text": "全球布局的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2922.wav", + "text": "那個都包括在內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2923.wav", + "text": "那個不是只有法律所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2924.wav", + "text": "我要講的就是它那裡面就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2925.wav", + "text": "你剛剛只是針對法律的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2926.wav", + "text": "是50幾萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2927.wav", + "text": "對兩岸溝通協調聯繫交流也有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2928.wav", + "text": "246萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2929.wav", + "text": "這跟那個人事都沒有關係喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2930.wav", + "text": "所以它裡面是包括人事費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2931.wav", + "text": "就剛剛講的643" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2932.wav", + "text": "你們自己看一下這個細項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2933.wav", + "text": "其他是行政的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2934.wav", + "text": "行政的費用不是做法務啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2935.wav", + "text": "多了幾千萬的行政費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2936.wav", + "text": "好啦這樣會口渴啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2937.wav", + "text": "為什麼這麼濫用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2938.wav", + "text": "我們去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2939.wav", + "text": "陸委會補助給海基會的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2940.wav", + "text": "一億五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2941.wav", + "text": "一億4008就將近一億五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2942.wav", + "text": "所以照陳玉珍委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2943.wav", + "text": "現在變成一億9004" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2944.wav", + "text": "等於是多加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2945.wav", + "text": "4,500萬對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2946.wav", + "text": "好沒有關係那可不可以請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2947.wav", + "text": "主委主要的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2948.wav", + "text": "等於幾乎加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2949.wav", + "text": "三分之一對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2950.wav", + "text": "那意思也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2951.wav", + "text": "明年海基會的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2952.wav", + "text": "要比現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2953.wav", + "text": "增加三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2954.wav", + "text": "對不對譬如說它原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2955.wav", + "text": "一定會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2956.wav", + "text": "但是增加到多少是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2957.wav", + "text": "很少見的對一個機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2958.wav", + "text": "的預算你的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2959.wav", + "text": "會一次增加三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2960.wav", + "text": "這是非常驚人的所以是不是可以請你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2961.wav", + "text": "說明一下你期許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2962.wav", + "text": "它明年比它現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2963.wav", + "text": "要能夠多做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2964.wav", + "text": "值得你多給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2965.wav", + "text": "它三分之一的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2966.wav", + "text": "這是很驚人的譬如說我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2967.wav", + "text": "不管多少錢我立委的薪水一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2968.wav", + "text": "多了三分之一驚死人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2969.wav", + "text": "啦所以這個部分我倒是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2970.wav", + "text": "陸委會應該講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2971.wav", + "text": "你是基於什麼樣的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2972.wav", + "text": "然後你要一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2973.wav", + "text": "加三分之一的預算補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2974.wav", + "text": "給海基會這個應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2975.wav", + "text": "要講第一個大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2976.wav", + "text": "剛剛有提到因為公務人員調薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2977.wav", + "text": "連動到其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2978.wav", + "text": "保險的費用增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2979.wav", + "text": "還有退儲金的增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2980.wav", + "text": "所以他們自己大概提了643萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2981.wav", + "text": "這個部分很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2982.wav", + "text": "應該是沒有什麼太大的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2983.wav", + "text": "讓主委講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2984.wav", + "text": "沒有共識我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2985.wav", + "text": "會後繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2986.wav", + "text": "第二個部分當然就是業務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2987.wav", + "text": "增加的那是他們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2988.wav", + "text": "提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2989.wav", + "text": "他們的計畫確實是值得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2990.wav", + "text": "鼓勵的所以我們就給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2991.wav", + "text": "估算過去已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2992.wav", + "text": "做可以再增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2993.wav", + "text": "譬如剛剛我所提到的現在台商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2994.wav", + "text": "遇到的問題可能比以前更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2995.wav", + "text": "我想這個大家都可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2996.wav", + "text": "因應整個全球化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2997.wav", + "text": "跟供應鏈生產的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2998.wav", + "text": "所以這主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/2999.wav", + "text": "這條保留就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3000.wav", + "text": "你們會後繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3001.wav", + "text": "不能拿這一條來抹紅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3002.wav", + "text": "這個講了差不多半個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3003.wav", + "text": "沒有人抹紅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3004.wav", + "text": "啊你這個理由還在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3005.wav", + "text": "這個案子講了差不多半個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3006.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3007.wav", + "text": "接下來第108案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3008.wav", + "text": "\n第109案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3009.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3010.wav", + "text": "這個案子賴委員有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3011.wav", + "text": "不過這好像跟我那筆費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3012.wav", + "text": "是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3013.wav", + "text": "其實他是減列500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3014.wav", + "text": "他也是覺得可能太浮濫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3015.wav", + "text": "併案處理好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3016.wav", + "text": "好那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3017.wav", + "text": "113案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3018.wav", + "text": "主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3019.wav", + "text": "沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3020.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3021.wav", + "text": "陸委會就到此告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3022.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3023.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長跟各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3024.wav", + "text": "我們休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3025.wav", + "text": "5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3026.wav", + "text": "5分鐘後我們處理不當黨產處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3027.wav", + "text": "預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3028.wav", + "text": "你們打著轉型正義的旗號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3029.wav", + "text": "現在是建立綠色威權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3030.wav", + "text": "A到被人家追查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3031.wav", + "text": "你們早就說要自己交出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3032.wav", + "text": "像民進黨現在都是A國家的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3033.wav", + "text": "這個話就不要亂講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3034.wav", + "text": "我講的是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3035.wav", + "text": "都自己承認了你們早就宣示要交出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3036.wav", + "text": "不是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3037.wav", + "text": "大家冷靜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3038.wav", + "text": "民進黨明目張膽A錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3039.wav", + "text": "第120案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3040.wav", + "text": "是保留嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3041.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3042.wav", + "text": "為什麼要派員出國考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3043.wav", + "text": "呢國家的錢這樣亂用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3044.wav", + "text": "因為歐洲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3045.wav", + "text": "這麼多年還去不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3046.wav", + "text": "每一年都去還不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3047.wav", + "text": "只有一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3048.wav", + "text": "就輪流去考察就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3049.wav", + "text": "不黨黨產委員會到底有多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3050.wav", + "text": "不黨黨產委員會到底有多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3051.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3052.wav", + "text": "只有刪四十幾萬而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3053.wav", + "text": "不當黨產委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3054.wav", + "text": "不不黨黨產委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3055.wav", + "text": "為什麼每一年都一直去考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3056.wav", + "text": "但是不當黨產委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3057.wav", + "text": "的特別拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3058.wav", + "text": "這個委員會特別拉出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3059.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3060.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3061.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3062.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3063.wav", + "text": "柯總召建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3064.wav", + "text": "那我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3065.wav", + "text": "保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3066.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3067.wav", + "text": "我們換內政部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3068.wav", + "text": "國民黨放水啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3069.wav", + "text": "來介紹列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3070.wav", + "text": "林右昌先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3071.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3072.wav", + "text": "增列300萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3073.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3074.wav", + "text": "改增列100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3075.wav", + "text": "委員同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3076.wav", + "text": "好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3077.wav", + "text": "修改成為增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3078.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3079.wav", + "text": "通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3080.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3081.wav", + "text": "那就併通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3082.wav", + "text": "併通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3083.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3084.wav", + "text": "黨團已經蓋章了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3085.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3086.wav", + "text": "決議凍結民政業務100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3087.wav", + "text": "議凍結100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3088.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3089.wav", + "text": "這個委員會有凍結嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3090.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3091.wav", + "text": "改凍民政業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3092.wav", + "text": "它是民政業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3093.wav", + "text": "併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3094.wav", + "text": "一般行政業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3095.wav", + "text": "凍結100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3096.wav", + "text": "民政業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3097.wav", + "text": "黨團已經蓋章了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3098.wav", + "text": "民政業務有凍結100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3099.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3100.wav", + "text": "凍結民政業務100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3101.wav", + "text": "提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3102.wav", + "text": "併民政業務凍結100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3103.wav", + "text": "元併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3104.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3105.wav", + "text": "凍結100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3106.wav", + "text": "元民政業務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3107.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3108.wav", + "text": "黨團也已經蓋章了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3109.wav", + "text": "改主決議3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3110.wav", + "text": "好改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3111.wav", + "text": "文字修改為3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3112.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3113.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3114.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3115.wav", + "text": "併委員會沒有意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3116.wav", + "text": "有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3117.wav", + "text": "我們部裡面建議改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3118.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3119.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3120.wav", + "text": "它這個是尚未完成溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3121.wav", + "text": "的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3122.wav", + "text": "耶所以洪孟楷委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3123.wav", + "text": "這一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3124.wav", + "text": "只是他們來建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3125.wav", + "text": "報告院長他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3126.wav", + "text": "一大本都沒有跟委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3127.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3128.wav", + "text": "我們可能太臨時這樣開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3129.wav", + "text": "啦因為本來沒有嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3130.wav", + "text": "還是要等他們溝通完再繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3131.wav", + "text": "可能還沒有時間溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3132.wav", + "text": "沒有因為可能我們今天才決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3133.wav", + "text": "才臨時決定要晚上開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3134.wav", + "text": "所以他們沒有時間溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3135.wav", + "text": "那是不是就讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3136.wav", + "text": "去溝通完再繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3137.wav", + "text": "沒有我們現在就決定好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3138.wav", + "text": "現在就決定真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3139.wav", + "text": "我們沒時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3140.wav", + "text": "尚未溝通的這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3141.wav", + "text": "總召裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3142.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3143.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3144.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3145.wav", + "text": "也是併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3146.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3147.wav", + "text": "也併委員會第13" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3148.wav", + "text": "31案是改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3149.wav", + "text": "沒有看到你們有沒有印出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3150.wav", + "text": "那個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3151.wav", + "text": "剛剛休息時間才蓋到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3152.wav", + "text": "改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3153.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3154.wav", + "text": "是3個月不是1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3155.wav", + "text": "第133案已經跟黨團報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3156.wav", + "text": "同意改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3157.wav", + "text": "沒有同意吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3158.wav", + "text": "沒有同意喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3159.wav", + "text": "所以這邊希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3160.wav", + "text": "然後交一個報告吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3161.wav", + "text": "對啊還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3162.wav", + "text": "但溝通未果啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3163.wav", + "text": "你不能說我們就同意改成主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3164.wav", + "text": "喔你這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3165.wav", + "text": "3案就併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3166.wav", + "text": "不是啊併委員會是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3167.wav", + "text": "按照我們努力的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3168.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3169.wav", + "text": "同意改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3170.wav", + "text": "我沒看到有簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3171.wav", + "text": "所謂的溝通不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3172.wav", + "text": "那個預算科目是在部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3173.wav", + "text": "綜規司這個建議的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3174.wav", + "text": "是我們警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3175.wav", + "text": "部裡面跟警政署同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3176.wav", + "text": "都有跟主任當面報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3177.wav", + "text": "他們也同意改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3178.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3179.wav", + "text": "133案併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3180.wav", + "text": "是不是也併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3181.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團已經蓋到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3182.wav", + "text": "黨團已經蓋章了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3183.wav", + "text": "34案怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3184.wav", + "text": "改主決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3185.wav", + "text": "已經蓋章了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3186.wav", + "text": "第134案改主決議嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3187.wav", + "text": "是已經蓋章了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3188.wav", + "text": "改主決議第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3189.wav", + "text": "134案已經拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3190.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3191.wav", + "text": "如果有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3192.wav", + "text": "的要有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3193.wav", + "text": "而且應該趕快去印" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3194.wav", + "text": "現在你們手頭上的趕快印" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3195.wav", + "text": "每一個黨團都要發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3196.wav", + "text": "有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3197.wav", + "text": "你剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3198.wav", + "text": "剛剛拿到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3199.wav", + "text": "大家都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3200.wav", + "text": "有資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3201.wav", + "text": "你們有蓋到章的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3202.wav", + "text": "我沒有那本尚未溝通的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3203.wav", + "text": "尚未溝通的那本是你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3204.wav", + "text": "還是他們發的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3205.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有這是內政部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3206.wav", + "text": "尚未溝通這麼厚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3207.wav", + "text": "這要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3208.wav", + "text": "所以你剛剛那個第133案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3209.wav", + "text": "在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3210.wav", + "text": "連拿都沒拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3211.wav", + "text": "因為我們的案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3212.wav", + "text": "很晚才我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3213.wav", + "text": "連已溝通本也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3214.wav", + "text": "他們沒時間溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3215.wav", + "text": "我們必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3216.wav", + "text": "說個公道話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3217.wav", + "text": "能決的就決一決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3218.wav", + "text": "5點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3219.wav", + "text": "我們要說公道話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3220.wav", + "text": "理解理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3221.wav", + "text": "如果還沒有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3222.wav", + "text": "我們內政委會今天在開會時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3223.wav", + "text": "大家都有聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3224.wav", + "text": "我的宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3225.wav", + "text": "把1個月2個月都改為3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3226.wav", + "text": "這個有宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3227.wav", + "text": "碰到就改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3228.wav", + "text": "有特別的也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3229.wav", + "text": "啦你有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3230.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3231.wav", + "text": "你們都有聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3232.wav", + "text": "現在開始進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3233.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3234.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3235.wav", + "text": "這個文字修正就是內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3236.wav", + "text": "修的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3237.wav", + "text": "第136案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3238.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3239.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3240.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3241.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3242.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3243.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3244.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3245.wav", + "text": "改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3246.wav", + "text": "沒有在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3247.wav", + "text": "可能要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3248.wav", + "text": "麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3249.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3250.wav", + "text": "文字修正併委員會決議辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3251.wav", + "text": "理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3252.wav", + "text": "第141案是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3253.wav", + "text": "廖國棟委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3254.wav", + "text": "廖國棟委員提的這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3255.wav", + "text": "他也沒有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3256.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3257.wav", + "text": "啊應該是沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3258.wav", + "text": "吧這個案子應該內政部也沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3259.wav", + "text": "有跟委員報告過了委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3260.wav", + "text": "委員還沒有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3261.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3262.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3263.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3264.wav", + "text": "廖國棟委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3265.wav", + "text": "有沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3266.wav", + "text": "已經跟委員報告過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3267.wav", + "text": "他有簽名嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3268.wav", + "text": "但是還沒有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3269.wav", + "text": "那這個怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3270.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3271.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3272.wav", + "text": "好改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3273.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3274.wav", + "text": "戶政資料外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3275.wav", + "text": "一直到今年10月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3276.wav", + "text": "檢方也認證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3277.wav", + "text": "去)年10月戶政資料外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3278.wav", + "text": "是我國的戶政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3279.wav", + "text": "資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3280.wav", + "text": "內政部到現在也沒有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3281.wav", + "text": "這個外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3282.wav", + "text": "層面這麼廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3283.wav", + "text": "原因何在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3284.wav", + "text": "而且現在檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3285.wav", + "text": "檢方這邊也認證這是我國的戶政資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3286.wav", + "text": "了究竟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3287.wav", + "text": "戶政的業務資安管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3288.wav", + "text": "出了什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3289.wav", + "text": "應該要怎麼改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3290.wav", + "text": "調查報告來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3291.wav", + "text": "你現在要把我改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3292.wav", + "text": "這個我不會同意啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3293.wav", + "text": "公開調查報告目的何在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3294.wav", + "text": "目的當然就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3295.wav", + "text": "案件這麼嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3296.wav", + "text": "執掌的包括像戶政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3297.wav", + "text": "或者是健保資料勞保資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3298.wav", + "text": "你們沒有妥善的去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3299.wav", + "text": "國人的影響非常深遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3300.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3301.wav", + "text": "這個時代力量講的是有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3302.wav", + "text": "寫並就戶政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3303.wav", + "text": "業務資安業務管理問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3304.wav", + "text": "提出檢討和改善措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3305.wav", + "text": "連這個都要給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3306.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3307.wav", + "text": "而且我只是要求你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3308.wav", + "text": "是我們戶政裡面的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3309.wav", + "text": "了所以檢討改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3310.wav", + "text": "真的是應該吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3311.wav", + "text": "我這樣講很直白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3312.wav", + "text": "有錯要認錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3313.wav", + "text": "知錯能改善莫大焉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3314.wav", + "text": "啊而不是不讓人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3315.wav", + "text": "要你檢討跟改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3316.wav", + "text": "沒有反對檢討改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3317.wav", + "text": "跟改善措施也給人家槓掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3318.wav", + "text": "不讓人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3319.wav", + "text": "你要看這個尚未完成溝通本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3320.wav", + "text": "他改的這個內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3321.wav", + "text": "第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3322.wav", + "text": "一年多的時間了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3323.wav", + "text": "然後檢察官都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3324.wav", + "text": "已經去認證說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3325.wav", + "text": "這個是我國的戶政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3326.wav", + "text": "資料了到現在一年多了你還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3327.wav", + "text": "辦法調查出原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3328.wav", + "text": "這也太離譜啦\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3329.wav", + "text": "另外一個之前的說法是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3330.wav", + "text": "因為檢察官在調查所以你沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3331.wav", + "text": "行政調查那更是鬼扯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3332.wav", + "text": "內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3333.wav", + "text": "來跟我說明的時候我就跟他講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3334.wav", + "text": "我的櫃子上面一大堆各部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3335.wav", + "text": "的國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3336.wav", + "text": "然後警政署也有到處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3337.wav", + "text": "都是行政調查報告哪有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3338.wav", + "text": "司法在調查的時候機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3339.wav", + "text": "不能夠調查這個道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3340.wav", + "text": "這是並行不悖的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3341.wav", + "text": "這個是不是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3342.wav", + "text": "暫時保留會後你們多溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3343.wav", + "text": "看怎麼樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3344.wav", + "text": "如果溝通有結果再提上來這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3345.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3346.wav", + "text": "第144案暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3347.wav", + "text": "145案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3348.wav", + "text": "要不要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3349.wav", + "text": "是有關那個新式身分證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3350.wav", + "text": "暫緩期間預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3351.wav", + "text": "的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3352.wav", + "text": "我們一直有跟黨團來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3353.wav", + "text": "145案柯總召建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3354.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3355.wav", + "text": "\n來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3356.wav", + "text": "第146案併通刪科目處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3357.wav", + "text": "第147案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3358.wav", + "text": "是不是併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3359.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3360.wav", + "text": "部長也知道我們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3361.wav", + "text": "溝通1年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3362.wav", + "text": "就是你們內政部測助的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3363.wav", + "text": "會議召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3364.wav", + "text": "現在有一個共識就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3365.wav", + "text": "不是用年功餉是提高工作費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3366.wav", + "text": "的部分這很確定但是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3367.wav", + "text": "現在我不知道後續開完會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3368.wav", + "text": "之後的實際執行狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3369.wav", + "text": "幫他們要到那個承諾不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3370.wav", + "text": "我本來是希望用凍結的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3371.wav", + "text": "跟���員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3372.wav", + "text": "這個我們在11月29號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3373.wav", + "text": "已經開完會委員也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3374.wav", + "text": "我們本來是要提高4,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3375.wav", + "text": "後來會上我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3376.wav", + "text": "部長跟次長都很贊同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3377.wav", + "text": "就再增加到5,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3378.wav", + "text": "後續我們這個會議紀錄已經給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3379.wav", + "text": "改成5,000以後那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3380.wav", + "text": "錢到底有多少趕快送過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3381.wav", + "text": "我們就報行政院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3382.wav", + "text": "就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3383.wav", + "text": "你們希望改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3384.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3385.wav", + "text": "OK但就是要把後面的這個進度給我一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3386.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3387.wav", + "text": "第147案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3388.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3389.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3390.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3391.wav", + "text": "文字做修正沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3392.wav", + "text": "併通刪科目辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3393.wav", + "text": "第149案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3394.wav", + "text": "併通刪科目辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3395.wav", + "text": "第150案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3396.wav", + "text": "案併通刪科目辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3397.wav", + "text": "案凍結100萬元沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3398.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3399.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3400.wav", + "text": "改改凍結100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3401.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3402.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3403.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3404.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3405.wav", + "text": "好文字做修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3406.wav", + "text": "凍結20萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3407.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3408.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3409.wav", + "text": "有文字修正喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3410.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3411.wav", + "text": "什麼叫文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3412.wav", + "text": "有有第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3413.wav", + "text": "好OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3414.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3415.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3416.wav", + "text": "好那就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3417.wav", + "text": "第156案凍結100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3418.wav", + "text": "文字修正那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3419.wav", + "text": "黨團蓋章了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3420.wav", + "text": "好黨團蓋章了好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3421.wav", + "text": "有文字修正嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3422.wav", + "text": "沒有好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3423.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3424.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3425.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3426.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3427.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3428.wav", + "text": "好有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3429.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3430.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3431.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3432.wav", + "text": "改主決議好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3433.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3434.wav", + "text": "委員說現場處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3435.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3436.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3437.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3438.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3439.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3440.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3441.wav", + "text": "併通刪辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3442.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3443.wav", + "text": "第164案有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3444.wav", + "text": "改主決議文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3445.wav", + "text": "有沒有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3446.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3447.wav", + "text": "這真的要註明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3448.wav", + "text": "了也不知道有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3449.wav", + "text": "這個你們要註明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3450.wav", + "text": "沒有註明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3451.wav", + "text": "這都是休息時間蓋的章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3452.wav", + "text": "晚上7點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3453.wav", + "text": "那你要講一下吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3454.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3455.wav", + "text": "文字有修正嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3456.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3457.wav", + "text": "有沒有改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3458.wav", + "text": "120萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3459.wav", + "text": "沒有取得委員蓋章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3460.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3461.wav", + "text": "25" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3462.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3463.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3464.wav", + "text": "17" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3465.wav", + "text": "改減列10萬元科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3466.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3467.wav", + "text": "這個是設備及投資的通刪項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3468.wav", + "text": "資訊軟硬體的設備及投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3469.wav", + "text": "通刪項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3470.wav", + "text": "通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3471.wav", + "text": "對通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3472.wav", + "text": "哪一個通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3473.wav", + "text": "就是設備及投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3474.wav", + "text": "辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3475.wav", + "text": "再來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3476.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3477.wav", + "text": "文字修正嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3478.wav", + "text": "都有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3479.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3480.wav", + "text": "有部分文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3481.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3482.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3483.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3484.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3485.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3486.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3487.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3488.wav", + "text": "同意凍200" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3489.wav", + "text": "然後文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3490.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3491.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3492.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3493.wav", + "text": "戶政資料外洩一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3494.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3495.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3496.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3497.wav", + "text": "提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3498.wav", + "text": "有沒有跟委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3499.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3500.wav", + "text": "有蓋章嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3501.wav", + "text": "不說就沒有人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3502.wav", + "text": "對他們好像都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3503.wav", + "text": "因為我們案子太" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3504.wav", + "text": "速度的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3505.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3506.wav", + "text": "你們沒講我們不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3507.wav", + "text": "現場處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3508.wav", + "text": "一案你們要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3509.wav", + "text": "要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3510.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3511.wav", + "text": "要講事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3512.wav", + "text": "喔不是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3513.wav", + "text": "會後被查到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3514.wav", + "text": "會不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3515.wav", + "text": "是辦公室主任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3516.wav", + "text": "因為我們這個都有錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3517.wav", + "text": "們是直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3518.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3519.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3520.wav", + "text": "那就沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3521.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3522.wav", + "text": "我們建議改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3523.wav", + "text": "好改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3524.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3525.wav", + "text": "那個凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3526.wav", + "text": "劃掉就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3527.wav", + "text": "就改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3528.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3529.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3530.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3531.wav", + "text": "建議改凍整目100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3532.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3533.wav", + "text": "凍結100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3534.wav", + "text": "文字做修正沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3535.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3536.wav", + "text": "好啦好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3537.wav", + "text": "資訊軟硬體設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3538.wav", + "text": "還沒通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3539.wav", + "text": "通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3540.wav", + "text": "178呢不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3541.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3542.wav", + "text": "81案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3543.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3544.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3545.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3546.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3547.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3548.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3549.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3550.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3551.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3552.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3553.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3554.wav", + "text": "87案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3555.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3556.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3557.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3558.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3559.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3560.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3561.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3562.wav", + "text": "沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3563.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3564.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3565.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3566.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3567.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3568.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3569.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3570.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3571.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3572.wav", + "text": "建議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3573.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3574.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3575.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3576.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3577.wav", + "text": "第197案主決議就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3578.wav", + "text": "再來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3579.wav", + "text": "他本來是要增列900萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3580.wav", + "text": "增列400萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3581.wav", + "text": "有沒有問題歲入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3582.wav", + "text": "歲入增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3583.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3584.wav", + "text": "修改為增列400萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3585.wav", + "text": "因為這兩個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3586.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3587.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3588.wav", + "text": "它是兩個通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3589.wav", + "text": "溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3590.wav", + "text": "他是說現場處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3591.wav", + "text": "他本來是希望自己能來現場表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3592.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3593.wav", + "text": "還是要有一個凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3594.wav", + "text": "結數之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3595.wav", + "text": "精進補助的相關計畫審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3596.wav", + "text": "核定之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3597.wav", + "text": "有書面報告再解凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3598.wav", + "text": "就看國土署這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3599.wav", + "text": "願不願意如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3600.wav", + "text": "果不行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3601.wav", + "text": "我們就先保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3602.wav", + "text": "你說補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3603.wav", + "text": "補助款是有通刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3604.wav", + "text": "委員是不是同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3605.wav", + "text": "就併通刪處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3606.wav", + "text": "總召是希望先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3607.wav", + "text": "\n這跟他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3608.wav", + "text": "的預期不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3609.wav", + "text": "不然先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3610.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3611.wav", + "text": "跟委員建議是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3612.wav", + "text": "併通刪處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3613.wav", + "text": "他不要主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3614.wav", + "text": "作一個主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3615.wav", + "text": "你們改你們的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3616.wav", + "text": "我是建議改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3617.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3618.wav", + "text": "改主決議比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3619.wav", + "text": "對改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3620.wav", + "text": "給他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3621.wav", + "text": "把民眾黨黨團的那個意思表達出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3622.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3623.wav", + "text": "給他們看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3624.wav", + "text": "我沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3625.wav", + "text": "你先改完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3626.wav", + "text": "看完再決定好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3627.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3628.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3629.wav", + "text": "那就暫時保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3630.wav", + "text": "暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3631.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3632.wav", + "text": "晚一點可以回頭來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3633.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3634.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3635.wav", + "text": "洪委員也是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3636.wav", + "text": "要現場講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3637.wav", + "text": "但是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3638.wav", + "text": "其實我們的出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3639.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3640.wav", + "text": "因為疫情停下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3641.wav", + "text": "但是我們疫情前一樣都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3642.wav", + "text": "他只是質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3643.wav", + "text": "為什麼突然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3644.wav", + "text": "冒出這些案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3645.wav", + "text": "因為是通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3646.wav", + "text": "200好併通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3647.wav", + "text": "好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3648.wav", + "text": "再來第201" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3649.wav", + "text": "案改凍300萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3650.wav", + "text": "對改凍300" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3651.wav", + "text": "300萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3652.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3653.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3654.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3655.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3656.wav", + "text": "其實這些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3657.wav", + "text": "都有去溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3658.wav", + "text": "是不是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3659.wav", + "text": "併內委會的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3660.wav", + "text": "來處理就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3661.wav", + "text": "這個就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3662.wav", + "text": "就有來溝通嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3663.wav", + "text": "但是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3664.wav", + "text": "2億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3665.wav", + "text": "我們委員會的決議就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3666.wav", + "text": "這個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3667.wav", + "text": "要求說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3668.wav", + "text": "要有一個書面報告嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3669.wav", + "text": "我們三個月內交書報啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3670.wav", + "text": "就併內委會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3671.wav", + "text": "統一凍結這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3672.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3673.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3674.wav", + "text": "這但是委員沒有答應啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3675.wav", + "text": "他也是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3676.wav", + "text": "本來都說要現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3677.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3678.wav", + "text": "啦就照我們內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3679.wav", + "text": "的決議就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3680.wav", + "text": "這個先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3681.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3682.wav", + "text": "我們確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3683.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3684.wav", + "text": "暫時保留嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3685.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3686.wav", + "text": "案凍結2億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3687.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3688.wav", + "text": "看是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3689.wav", + "text": "第203案凍結2億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3690.wav", + "text": "是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3691.wav", + "text": "他有同意改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3692.wav", + "text": "同意改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3693.wav", + "text": "剛才第199案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3694.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3695.wav", + "text": "我們就回到剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3696.wav", + "text": "暫時保留的第199案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3697.wav", + "text": "現在陳委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3698.wav", + "text": "改為主決議沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3699.wav", + "text": "文字要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3700.wav", + "text": "文字修正對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3701.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3702.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3703.wav", + "text": "子好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3704.wav", + "text": "那現在我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3705.wav", + "text": "202" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3706.wav", + "text": "案剛才說暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3707.wav", + "text": "你們再溝通嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3708.wav", + "text": "案凍結2億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3709.wav", + "text": "改主決議喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3710.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3711.wav", + "text": "好第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3712.wav", + "text": "204" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3713.wav", + "text": "案改凍結第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3714.wav", + "text": "204" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3715.wav", + "text": "同樣的一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3716.wav", + "text": "那就第202案跟第204案都先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3717.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3718.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3719.wav", + "text": "案改凍結100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3720.wav", + "text": "這個是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3721.wav", + "text": "剛才有講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3722.wav", + "text": "這個就照我們委員會的決議就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3723.wav", + "text": "這個他已經有同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3724.wav", + "text": "好凍結100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3725.wav", + "text": "案有同意凍結100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3726.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3727.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3728.wav", + "text": "這有溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3729.wav", + "text": "好通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3730.wav", + "text": "206" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3731.wav", + "text": "他照案通過啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3732.wav", + "text": "他就不用去跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3733.wav", + "text": "就讓你們凍了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3734.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3735.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3736.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3737.wav", + "text": "同意凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3738.wav", + "text": "委員已經有簽字了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3739.wav", + "text": "207" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3740.wav", + "text": "處理好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3741.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3742.wav", + "text": "第207改什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3743.wav", + "text": "207案它上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3744.wav", + "text": "300萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3745.wav", + "text": "300萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3746.wav", + "text": "同意凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3747.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3748.wav", + "text": "你們同意凍結它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3749.wav", + "text": "它放在溝通本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3750.wav", + "text": "你們溝通的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3751.wav", + "text": "每案都同意喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3752.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3753.wav", + "text": "有的也不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3754.wav", + "text": "修正啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3755.wav", + "text": "因為我們的比較早提出啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3756.wav", + "text": "他都有溝通本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3757.wav", + "text": "大部分有溝通好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3758.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3759.wav", + "text": "其實我們每案都有跟陳委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3760.wav", + "text": "他都同意文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3761.wav", + "text": "只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3762.wav", + "text": "是看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3763.wav", + "text": "這樣逐項處理還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3764.wav", + "text": "理還是看委員同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3765.wav", + "text": "是不是整包500萬這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3766.wav", + "text": "你已經跟他講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3767.wav", + "text": "我這樣要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3768.wav", + "text": "因為他已經有簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3769.wav", + "text": "所以他才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3770.wav", + "text": "我看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3771.wav", + "text": "你都已經跟他說好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3772.wav", + "text": "講好就好了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3773.wav", + "text": "因為我看你很多也都是研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3774.wav", + "text": "或是怎麼樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3775.wav", + "text": "我看這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3776.wav", + "text": "凍結這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3777.wav", + "text": "我看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3778.wav", + "text": "不如在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3779.wav", + "text": "第3目國土管理業務這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3780.wav", + "text": "把它改為500萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3781.wav", + "text": "其他都併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3782.wav", + "text": "好嗎併案處理就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3783.wav", + "text": "這樣不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3784.wav", + "text": "因為你當時沒有跟他講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3785.wav", + "text": "不然就你就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3786.wav", + "text": "案你暫時保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3787.wav", + "text": "其他的凍結都併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3788.wav", + "text": "因為這個他已經有簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3789.wav", + "text": "而且他們都已經先溝通好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3790.wav", + "text": "可能就是先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3791.wav", + "text": "然後他們再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3792.wav", + "text": "因為看起來這個數字也不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3793.wav", + "text": "你很多都是要求\n改成請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3794.wav", + "text": "208案也是一樣凍結300" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3795.wav", + "text": "對第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3796.wav", + "text": "208案也是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3797.wav", + "text": "250" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3798.wav", + "text": "250萬嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3799.wav", + "text": "案凍結100萬也是同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3800.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3801.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3802.wav", + "text": "211案改主決議沒有意見通過\n第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3803.wav", + "text": "212案文字修正併委員會同意辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3804.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3805.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3806.wav", + "text": "你們這是在說怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3807.wav", + "text": "你們說到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3808.wav", + "text": "207案你講請國土署儘速研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3809.wav", + "text": "始得動支你也劃掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3810.wav", + "text": "啊你連公開上網後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3811.wav", + "text": "始得動支你也把它劃掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3812.wav", + "text": "這樣你要怎麼解除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3813.wav", + "text": "案你看第210案也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3814.wav", + "text": "你們怎麼會把始得動支全部都劃掉呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3815.wav", + "text": "跟委員那邊直接講好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3816.wav", + "text": "好那你就再溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3817.wav", + "text": "你再溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3818.wav", + "text": "主決議的方式吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3819.wav", + "text": "不知道你怎麼弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3820.wav", + "text": "他們把那個解除條件劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3821.wav", + "text": "對那是主決議的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3822.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3823.wav", + "text": "他是要改主決議還是凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3824.wav", + "text": "沒有啦他還是在凍結啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3825.wav", + "text": "他右上角有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3826.wav", + "text": "他右上角都有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3827.wav", + "text": "你們這樣乾脆就做主決議就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3828.wav", + "text": "做主決議就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3829.wav", + "text": "是真的建議主決議就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3830.wav", + "text": "對啦做主決議就好了啦好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3831.wav", + "text": "這個你要再跟他溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3832.wav", + "text": "因為你已經跟人家講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3833.wav", + "text": "我看就讓他做主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3834.wav", + "text": "不然他們做這樣根本就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3835.wav", + "text": "沒有解除條件了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3836.wav", + "text": "因為你跟委員談的是凍結案嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3837.wav", + "text": "所以你白紙黑字寫數字在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3838.wav", + "text": "本來送到那邊修正版本都是寫改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3839.wav", + "text": "但是他最後送回來還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3840.wav", + "text": "對啊所以你有跟人家談好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3841.wav", + "text": "他後來又寫金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3842.wav", + "text": "這個大咖的你就可以不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3843.wav", + "text": "你這個上面數字都有寫在這裡了啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3844.wav", + "text": "你這一本叫做已溝通本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3845.wav", + "text": "你現在要變成尚未完成溝通本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3846.wav", + "text": "邱顯智你比任何人都更清醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3847.wav", + "text": "寫法都是主決議的寫法啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3848.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3849.wav", + "text": "還是要送內政委員會始得動支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3850.wav", + "text": "這我也同意啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3851.wav", + "text": "所以不要改成主決議嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3852.wav", + "text": "你可以說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3853.wav", + "text": "經內政委員會同意後始得動支加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3854.wav", + "text": "這樣也可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3855.wav", + "text": "不然就書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3856.wav", + "text": "也不知道你為什麼會把它劃掉啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3857.wav", + "text": "他跟你們溝通這樣就代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3858.wav", + "text": "其實這個案子是在弄主決議啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3859.wav", + "text": "是要解凍嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3860.wav", + "text": "解凍的話你不能把始得動支劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3861.wav", + "text": "跟主席報告應該是來來回回兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3862.wav", + "text": "對啦他自己也亂掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3863.wav", + "text": "他自己也亂掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3864.wav", + "text": "一開始他本來也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3865.wav", + "text": "後來他又把金額寫上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3866.wav", + "text": "你已經談出了一個凍的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3867.wav", + "text": "這個錢也不多嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3868.wav", + "text": "只要擬具書面報告之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3869.wav", + "text": "委員會同意就動支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3870.wav", + "text": "這樣就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3871.wav", + "text": "這個總預算多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3872.wav", + "text": "我想那些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3873.wav", + "text": "我們都把文字做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3874.wav", + "text": "就照原來溝通的那個凍結的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3875.wav", + "text": "這樣速度比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3876.wav", + "text": "凍結照現在講的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3877.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3878.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3879.wav", + "text": "按照文字修正後可以解凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3880.wav", + "text": "這樣時代力量可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3881.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3882.wav", + "text": "他本來講的這個凍結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3883.wav", + "text": "就按照凍結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3884.wav", + "text": "然後最後把那個始得動支的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3885.wav", + "text": "留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3886.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3887.wav", + "text": "書面報告來就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3888.wav", + "text": "書面報告來就解凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3889.wav", + "text": "委員會同意就解凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3890.wav", + "text": "現在到第213案了第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3891.wav", + "text": "213案文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3892.wav", + "text": "這沒有意見嘛通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3893.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3894.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3895.wav", + "text": "是不是併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3896.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3897.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3898.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3899.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3900.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3901.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3902.wav", + "text": "\n第221案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3903.wav", + "text": "\n第222案凍結100萬元文字修正沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3904.wav", + "text": "有意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3905.wav", + "text": "沒有意見喔通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3906.wav", + "text": "23案我看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3907.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3908.wav", + "text": "\n第225案文字修正併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3909.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3910.wav", + "text": "\n第226案通刪科目併通刪科目\n第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3911.wav", + "text": "227案凍結50萬這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3912.wav", + "text": "太多了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3913.wav", + "text": "他已經同意撤案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3914.wav", + "text": "凍結300萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3915.wav", + "text": "元這個就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3916.wav", + "text": "委員會就是300萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3917.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3918.wav", + "text": "已經有嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3919.wav", + "text": "已經改過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3920.wav", + "text": "230" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3921.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3922.wav", + "text": "已經改了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3923.wav", + "text": "有改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3924.wav", + "text": "改主決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3925.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3926.wav", + "text": "修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3927.wav", + "text": "好文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3928.wav", + "text": "案文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3929.wav", + "text": "改凍結300萬元沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3930.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3931.wav", + "text": "\n第235案通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3932.wav", + "text": "案文字修正併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3933.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3934.wav", + "text": "\n第237案主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3935.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3936.wav", + "text": "\n第238案主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3937.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3938.wav", + "text": "\n第239案主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3939.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3940.wav", + "text": "\n第240案主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3941.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3942.wav", + "text": "\n第241案主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3943.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3944.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3945.wav", + "text": "案主決議沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3946.wav", + "text": "案主決議文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3947.wav", + "text": "案主決議文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3948.wav", + "text": "\n第247案主決議沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3949.wav", + "text": "\n再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3950.wav", + "text": "來到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3951.wav", + "text": "到警政署了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3952.wav", + "text": "我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3953.wav", + "text": "看大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3954.wav", + "text": "已經改主決議了文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3955.wav", + "text": "第248案有改主決議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3956.wav", + "text": "好第248案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3957.wav", + "text": "有做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3958.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3959.wav", + "text": "改主決議沒有沒有這一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3960.wav", + "text": "我們的審核機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3961.wav", + "text": "因為他這個資料我們也去調了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3962.wav", + "text": "就是民眾申訴的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3963.wav", + "text": "其實這個案量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3964.wav", + "text": "然後被裁定免罰的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3965.wav", + "text": "有13萬所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3966.wav", + "text": "在這個違規取締跟在審核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3967.wav", + "text": "科技執法案件的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3968.wav", + "text": "其實民眾的反映是真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3969.wav", + "text": "蠻多的所以我們才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3970.wav", + "text": "的我覺得是蠻擾民的所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3971.wav", + "text": "也要做一些說明嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3972.wav", + "text": "我們除了內部的稽核強化以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3973.wav", + "text": "還會建立一個相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3974.wav", + "text": "來落實來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3975.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3976.wav", + "text": "因為這邊有做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3977.wav", + "text": "改主決議嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3978.wav", + "text": "我看他們好像有一些文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3979.wav", + "text": "好第249案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3980.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3981.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3982.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3983.wav", + "text": "文字的部分我們看一下好不好雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3984.wav", + "text": "我們看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3985.wav", + "text": "先保留好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3986.wav", + "text": "下第250案就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3987.wav", + "text": "那是第249案第250案是我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3988.wav", + "text": "交通違規的部分嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3989.wav", + "text": "第250案就是主決議嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3990.wav", + "text": "改主決議文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3991.wav", + "text": "主決議文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3992.wav", + "text": "改主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3993.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3994.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3995.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3996.wav", + "text": "併委員會有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3997.wav", + "text": "有簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3998.wav", + "text": "有簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/3999.wav", + "text": "你尚未完成溝通本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4000.wav", + "text": "議我不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4001.wav", + "text": "我在質詢的時候你也答得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4002.wav", + "text": "處在一個依法無據的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4003.wav", + "text": "同仁也非常不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4004.wav", + "text": "因為警察法的第一課就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4005.wav", + "text": "要依法行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4006.wav", + "text": "已經不再採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4007.wav", + "text": "臺灣各地的警察局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4008.wav", + "text": "竟然有這麼多不一樣的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4009.wav", + "text": "而且它是在完全依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4010.wav", + "text": "無據的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4011.wav", + "text": "全臺灣有6,751處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4012.wav", + "text": "並不是交通部法定號誌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4013.wav", + "text": "號誌包括署長及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4014.wav", + "text": "及交通部王國材部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4015.wav", + "text": "也都對這個持非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4016.wav", + "text": "保留的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4017.wav", + "text": "你要去研議一個更合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4018.wav", + "text": "這樣閃好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4019.wav", + "text": "以後大家就知道那個不是警車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4020.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得第一它依法無據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4021.wav", + "text": "據而且會造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4022.wav", + "text": "暫留或是短暫失明等危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4023.wav", + "text": "警察局不就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4024.wav", + "text": "要賠這個錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4025.wav", + "text": "交通應該還是要由專業的來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4026.wav", + "text": "警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4027.wav", + "text": "地方民代的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4028.wav", + "text": "就去裝設這樣的設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4029.wav", + "text": "況且交通部也都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4030.wav", + "text": "我提這個案子基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4031.wav", + "text": "交通安全維護跟交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4032.wav", + "text": "秩序規劃預算凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4033.wav", + "text": "5%你在2個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4034.wav", + "text": "就各直轄縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4035.wav", + "text": "非六都的縣市警局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4036.wav", + "text": "去盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4037.wav", + "text": "到底這個設置有什麼合理性跟必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4038.wav", + "text": "當然要會同交通機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4039.wav", + "text": "我辦會勘會同新竹市交通處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4040.wav", + "text": "設當場新竹市警局是不是臉都綠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4041.wav", + "text": "替代措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4042.wav", + "text": "然後提出一個書面報告針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4043.wav", + "text": "目前這600多處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4044.wav", + "text": "如果我站在你的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4045.wav", + "text": "不就是警局要負這個國家賠償責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4046.wav", + "text": "沒有法律的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4047.wav", + "text": "基本上這個行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4048.wav", + "text": "的正當性基礎會受到動搖我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4049.wav", + "text": "併委員會的決議我們提書面報告好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4050.wav", + "text": "好署長既然都這樣講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4051.wav", + "text": "就是併委員會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4052.wav", + "text": "語重心長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4053.wav", + "text": "連兩任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4054.wav", + "text": "因為交通基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4055.wav", + "text": "主管機關來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4056.wav", + "text": "應該去使用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4057.wav", + "text": "地方如除暴安良等等有很多需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4058.wav", + "text": "他去做的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4059.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4060.wav", + "text": "就併委員決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4061.wav", + "text": "你剛才說要提書面嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4062.wav", + "text": "就併凍提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4063.wav", + "text": "好併凍提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4064.wav", + "text": "就這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4065.wav", + "text": "也是時代力量黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4066.wav", + "text": "剛才是第247" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4067.wav", + "text": "案這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4068.wav", + "text": "主決議文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4069.wav", + "text": "沒有講要文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4070.wav", + "text": "現在要文字修正它有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4071.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4072.wav", + "text": "你是第249" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4073.wav", + "text": "案同意文字修正然後改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4074.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4075.wav", + "text": "好第249" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4076.wav", + "text": "案就改主決議文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4077.wav", + "text": "然後再來第257案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4078.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4079.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4080.wav", + "text": "對不起主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4081.wav", + "text": "第257案要加文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4082.wav", + "text": "好第257案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4083.wav", + "text": "文���修正修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4084.wav", + "text": "改主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4085.wav", + "text": "改主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4086.wav", + "text": "\n第2改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4087.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4088.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4089.wav", + "text": "我們第261案不是改主決議嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4090.wav", + "text": "凍30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4091.wav", + "text": "我們就改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4092.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思我確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4093.wav", + "text": "第259案有改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4094.wav", + "text": "主決議喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4095.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4096.wav", + "text": "好署長我還是要提醒一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4097.wav", + "text": "我之前有跟你質詢過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4098.wav", + "text": "完全都是臺灣人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4099.wav", + "text": "結果警員就誤以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4100.wav", + "text": "他是什麼逃逸外勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4101.wav", + "text": "把人家打得半死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4102.wav", + "text": "這個是非常離譜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4103.wav", + "text": "而且即便是外勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4104.wav", + "text": "即便是移工也不能夠對他做這樣的對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4105.wav", + "text": "把那個孩子弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4106.wav", + "text": "所以就這個部分也真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4107.wav", + "text": "應該要針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4108.wav", + "text": "不要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4109.wav", + "text": "你盤查基本上有一個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4110.wav", + "text": "有道理啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4111.wav", + "text": "你們要加強教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4112.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4113.wav", + "text": "263案撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4114.wav", + "text": "已經撤案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4115.wav", + "text": "撤案喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4116.wav", + "text": "因為我們這邊沒有資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4117.wav", + "text": "我們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4118.wav", + "text": "同意減列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4119.wav", + "text": "20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4120.wav", + "text": "凍結凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4121.wav", + "text": "改主決議吧是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4122.wav", + "text": "案不是改主決議嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4123.wav", + "text": "第265案這邊是寫減列喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4124.wav", + "text": "改改主決議喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4125.wav", + "text": "你們要主動講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4126.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4127.wav", + "text": "好有沒有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4128.wav", + "text": "好文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4129.wav", + "text": "266" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4130.wav", + "text": "案併通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4131.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4132.wav", + "text": "269" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4133.wav", + "text": "案也是併通刪嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4134.wav", + "text": "這是通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4135.wav", + "text": "271" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4136.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4137.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4138.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4139.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4140.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4141.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4142.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4143.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4144.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4145.wav", + "text": "文字修正好文字修正所以是修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4146.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4147.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4148.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4149.wav", + "text": "好照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4150.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4151.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4152.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4153.wav", + "text": "那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4154.wav", + "text": "有拜訪委員辦公室同意撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4155.wav", + "text": "已經撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4156.wav", + "text": "針對這個案子副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4157.wav", + "text": "和政委也召開過好幾次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4158.wav", + "text": "分別由經濟部率同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4159.wav", + "text": "296案這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4160.wav", + "text": "我們的消防員弟兄來到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4161.wav", + "text": "現場的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4162.wav", + "text": "根本不知道危險物品在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4163.wav", + "text": "或者是不是有危險物品嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4164.wav", + "text": "所以這個案子已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4165.wav", + "text": "是法律案至於執行面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4166.wav", + "text": "政委有特別交辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4167.wav", + "text": "幾個面向正在執行當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4168.wav", + "text": "我們的法律案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4169.wav", + "text": "就是針對沒有依照法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4170.wav", + "text": "序執行的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4171.wav", + "text": "刑事法和行政法分別都有加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4172.wav", + "text": "這方面的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4173.wav", + "text": "就是沒有申報的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4174.wav", + "text": "因為明揚就是沒有申報嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4175.wav", + "text": "對工廠輔導法這次也列入修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4176.wav", + "text": "所以這幾個面向的執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4177.wav", + "text": "目前正在如火如荼當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4178.wav", + "text": "各縣市也針對這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4179.wav", + "text": "針對高危險和中危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4180.wav", + "text": "場所正在全面執行當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4181.wav", + "text": "我想這在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4182.wav", + "text": "兩個月的時間應該可以把這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4183.wav", + "text": "盤點清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4184.wav", + "text": "但是基本上你還是要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4185.wav", + "text": "相關的檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4186.wav", + "text": "那一定要做否則的話你根本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4187.wav", + "text": "不會知道像明揚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4188.wav", + "text": "這個例子它根本就沒有申報你又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4189.wav", + "text": "沒有發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4190.wav", + "text": "既然沒有發現更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4191.wav", + "text": "遑論要怎麼去處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4192.wav", + "text": "當然加重處罰是一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4193.wav", + "text": "但是即便這個修法過了你還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4194.wav", + "text": "檢查嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4195.wav", + "text": "你就會知道說這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4196.wav", + "text": "一個長久以來的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4197.wav", + "text": "工廠法這次也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4198.wav", + "text": "修正三個月要做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4199.wav", + "text": "提報所以工廠法提報的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4200.wav", + "text": "跟我們做勾稽就是化學雲那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4201.wav", + "text": "做勾稽我們一方面檢查以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4202.wav", + "text": "另外化學雲那邊也把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4203.wav", + "text": "三個月申報的結果讓我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4204.wav", + "text": "所以會用交叉的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4205.wav", + "text": "來做一個比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4206.wav", + "text": "對啦但是現在這個會期也不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4207.wav", + "text": "審了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4208.wav", + "text": "只是說現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4209.wav", + "text": "在這個法還沒有通過之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4210.wav", + "text": "你還是要去加強比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4211.wav", + "text": "能夠發現這些業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4212.wav", + "text": "是現在同步在作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4213.wav", + "text": "對啊因為實在經不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4214.wav", + "text": "一而再再而三發生這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4215.wav", + "text": "那就把它改成主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4216.wav", + "text": "改主決議沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4217.wav", + "text": "好主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4218.wav", + "text": "已經改好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4219.wav", + "text": "凍結10萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4220.wav", + "text": "凍結10萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4221.wav", + "text": "辦理文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4222.wav", + "text": "好併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4223.wav", + "text": "案併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4224.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4225.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4226.wav", + "text": "好文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4227.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4228.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4229.wav", + "text": "文字修正第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4230.wav", + "text": "305案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4231.wav", + "text": "案建築研究所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4232.wav", + "text": "改主決議好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4233.wav", + "text": "已經談好凍100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4234.wav", + "text": "凍50" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4235.wav", + "text": "這一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4236.wav", + "text": "案改為凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4237.wav", + "text": "50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4238.wav", + "text": "元文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4239.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4240.wav", + "text": "海委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4241.wav", + "text": "現在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4242.wav", + "text": "海洋委員會主管的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4243.wav", + "text": "首先介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4244.wav", + "text": "列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4245.wav", + "text": "海洋委員會主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4246.wav", + "text": "管碧玲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4247.wav", + "text": "強勢回歸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4248.wav", + "text": "我們看第339案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4249.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4250.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4251.wav", + "text": "改主決議好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4252.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4253.wav", + "text": "改主決議嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4254.wav", + "text": "能不能不這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4255.wav", + "text": "併我們委員會就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4256.wav", + "text": "沒有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4257.wav", + "text": "整個文字都快要改完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4258.wav", + "text": "跟委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4259.wav", + "text": "委員有簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4260.wav", + "text": "文字的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4261.wav", + "text": "委員有簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4262.wav", + "text": "啦現在就是凍結10%的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4263.wav", + "text": "能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4264.wav", + "text": "你看有書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4265.wav", + "text": "就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4266.wav", + "text": "你的老同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4267.wav", + "text": "回來改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4268.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4269.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4270.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4271.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4272.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4273.wav", + "text": "提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4274.wav", + "text": "341案併委員會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4275.wav", + "text": "辦理沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4276.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4277.wav", + "text": "344案併委員會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4278.wav", + "text": "辦理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4279.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4280.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4281.wav", + "text": "那就請大家看第348" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4282.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4283.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4284.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4285.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4286.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4287.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4288.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4289.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4290.wav", + "text": "現在已經改為凍結5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4291.wav", + "text": "已經溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4292.wav", + "text": "沒有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4293.wav", + "text": "這一條併委員會就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4294.wav", + "text": "能併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4295.wav", + "text": "大家如果同意我們就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4296.wav", + "text": "355" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4297.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4298.wav", + "text": "就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4299.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4300.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4301.wav", + "text": "所以就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4302.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4303.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4304.wav", + "text": "我們就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4305.wav", + "text": "照案辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4306.wav", + "text": "照案辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4307.wav", + "text": "好就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4308.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4309.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4310.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4311.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4312.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4313.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4314.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4315.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4316.wav", + "text": "好啦今天就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4317.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4318.wav", + "text": "總共保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4319.wav", + "text": "27案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4320.wav", + "text": "明天9點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15351/4321.wav", + "text": "準時開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/0.wav", + "text": "現在四大黨團都已經到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/1.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/2.wav", + "text": "會議開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/3.wav", + "text": "今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/4.wav", + "text": "要進行的協商議題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/5.wav", + "text": "一繼續研商中華民國113年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/6.wav", + "text": "度中央政府總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/7.wav", + "text": "(公務預算部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/8.wav", + "text": ")二研商國會擴建規劃暨監督委員會報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/9.wav", + "text": "討論總務處函送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/10.wav", + "text": "『立法院擴建基地評選分析報告』案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/11.wav", + "text": "三研商民進黨黨團提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/12.wav", + "text": "為立法委員及總統選舉前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/13.wav", + "text": "停開院會及委員會相關事宜案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/14.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們就請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/15.wav", + "text": "來開始發表高見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/16.wav", + "text": "來請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/17.wav", + "text": "好謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/18.wav", + "text": "有關今天朝野協商國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/19.wav", + "text": "有幾點意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/20.wav", + "text": "第一點本來排定今天下午進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/21.wav", + "text": "113年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/22.wav", + "text": "預算的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/23.wav", + "text": "即使我們黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/24.wav", + "text": "在溝通的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/25.wav", + "text": "其實有部分委員有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/26.wav", + "text": "不希望在12月20號之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/27.wav", + "text": "完成審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/28.wav", + "text": "但是我們黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/29.wav", + "text": "還是把它承擔下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/30.wav", + "text": "希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/31.wav", + "text": "在12月20號之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/32.wav", + "text": "完成審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/33.wav", + "text": "這是一個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/34.wav", + "text": "立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/35.wav", + "text": "立法委員審查預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/36.wav", + "text": "是憲法賦予每個委員的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/37.wav", + "text": "委員提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/38.wav", + "text": "凍結預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/39.wav", + "text": "經過相關部會的解釋之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/40.wav", + "text": "基本上都一一解凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/41.wav", + "text": "這個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/42.wav", + "text": "民進黨已經操作一兩天了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/43.wav", + "text": "這個是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/44.wav", + "text": "提出說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/45.wav", + "text": "到底中國大陸介選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/46.wav", + "text": "有沒有具體的事證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/47.wav", + "text": "請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/48.wav", + "text": "陸委會提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/49.wav", + "text": "那我的理解早上已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/50.wav", + "text": "說明之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/51.wav", + "text": "廖婉汝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/52.wav", + "text": "也解除凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/53.wav", + "text": "這麼一個簡單的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/54.wav", + "text": "民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/55.wav", + "text": "不知道是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/56.wav", + "text": "拿給三立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/57.wav", + "text": "民視就在操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/58.wav", + "text": "這禮拜六禮拜天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/59.wav", + "text": "今天最誇張的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/60.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/61.wav", + "text": "但是幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/62.wav", + "text": "書記長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/63.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/64.wav", + "text": "陪同候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/65.wav", + "text": "在民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/66.wav", + "text": "會議室召開會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/67.wav", + "text": "一味地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/68.wav", + "text": "攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/69.wav", + "text": "我們的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/70.wav", + "text": "立法委員連個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/71.wav", + "text": "解凍也不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/72.wav", + "text": "民進黨竟然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/73.wav", + "text": "介入他的幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/74.wav", + "text": "和書記長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/75.wav", + "text": "陪同候選人開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/76.wav", + "text": "抹黑抹紅國民黨候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/77.wav", + "text": "\n我不知道啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/78.wav", + "text": "院長這發生幾種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/79.wav", + "text": "現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/80.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/81.wav", + "text": "民進黨委員不提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/82.wav", + "text": "就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/83.wav", + "text": "要護航也就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/84.wav", + "text": "第二個他基本上不尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/85.wav", + "text": "游院長他也不知道游院長是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/86.wav", + "text": "下午要進行朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/87.wav", + "text": "預算的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/88.wav", + "text": "他根本不理你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/89.wav", + "text": "游錫堃游院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/90.wav", + "text": "啊本來朝野氣氛這麼好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/91.wav", + "text": "趕快完成審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/92.wav", + "text": "能夠停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/93.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/94.wav", + "text": "連個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/95.wav", + "text": "凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/96.wav", + "text": "請陸委會來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/97.wav", + "text": "都不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/98.wav", + "text": "媒體拿來操作我們就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/99.wav", + "text": "連民進黨黨團的幹部都拿去操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/100.wav", + "text": "不尊重游院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/101.wav", + "text": "不尊重立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/102.wav", + "text": "不尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/103.wav", + "text": "在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/104.wav", + "text": "一點都不尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/105.wav", + "text": "我怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/106.wav", + "text": "坐下來跟你們繼續談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/107.wav", + "text": "提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/108.wav", + "text": "連個凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/109.wav", + "text": "來說明都不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/110.wav", + "text": "這在戒嚴時期都不會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/111.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/112.wav", + "text": "清朝有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/113.wav", + "text": "或者是清朝有沒有審查預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/114.wav", + "text": "我相信連帝制的時代都不會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/115.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/116.wav", + "text": "我代表國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/117.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/118.wav", + "text": "既然民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/119.wav", + "text": "不尊重立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/120.wav", + "text": "不尊重游錫堃院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/121.wav", + "text": "不尊重在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/122.wav", + "text": "我們從今天開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/123.wav", + "text": "退出朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/124.wav", + "text": "立法院的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/125.wav", + "text": "等一下讓我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/126.wav", + "text": "稍等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/127.wav", + "text": "他怎麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/128.wav", + "text": "反正有直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/129.wav", + "text": "他們也會去偷看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/130.wav", + "text": "院長各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/131.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/132.wav", + "text": "發言以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/133.wav", + "text": "馬上急速離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/134.wav", + "text": "應該聽一下我們的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/135.wav", + "text": "這是一個公平的對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/136.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/137.wav", + "text": "他剛才所談的是有關於廖婉汝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/138.wav", + "text": "所提的凍結案100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/139.wav", + "text": "他們今天早上開記者會時比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/140.wav", + "text": "著墨的是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/141.wav", + "text": "刪減海基會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/142.wav", + "text": "4,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/143.wav", + "text": "海基會的預算總��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/144.wav", + "text": "一億400多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/145.wav", + "text": ",500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/146.wav", + "text": "議案提出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/147.wav", + "text": "有人翻到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/148.wav", + "text": "過去也常常這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/149.wav", + "text": "有人找媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/150.wav", + "text": "這個各黨都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/151.wav", + "text": "發生過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/152.wav", + "text": "像這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/153.wav", + "text": "各黨對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/154.wav", + "text": "預算的看法不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/155.wav", + "text": "彼此有攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/156.wav", + "text": "並不是今天才開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/157.wav", + "text": "的很久就這樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/158.wav", + "text": "最低工資法他也跑到臉書寫我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/159.wav", + "text": "我聽了就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/160.wav", + "text": "為什麼又cue到我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/161.wav", + "text": "所以嫌貨才是買貨人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/162.wav", + "text": "你看我永遠都坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/163.wav", + "text": "他有在臉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/164.wav", + "text": "一些東西雖然對我來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/165.wav", + "text": "我感覺他在攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/166.wav", + "text": "我但是我覺得無所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/167.wav", + "text": "因為每一個人都有發言的權利和義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/168.wav", + "text": "我尊重你的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/169.wav", + "text": "我也不會說誰罵我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/170.wav", + "text": "我就拒絕協商或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/171.wav", + "text": "跟大家處得非常不愉快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/172.wav", + "text": "選舉在即的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/173.wav", + "text": "難免各黨對於它所比較在意的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/174.wav", + "text": "介入選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/175.wav", + "text": "這個問題是很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/176.wav", + "text": "的當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/177.wav", + "text": "委員要海基會說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/178.wav", + "text": "但後來他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/179.wav", + "text": "也撤案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/180.wav", + "text": "彼此都有這種現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/181.wav", + "text": "預算黨團在開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/182.wav", + "text": "我從來是不去開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/183.wav", + "text": "啦雖然我們黨團每天都由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/184.wav", + "text": "幹事長及書記長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/185.wav", + "text": "\n國民黨也是一樣三黨天天開記者會罵我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/186.wav", + "text": "我們就回敬回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/187.wav", + "text": "每天都在演這齣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/188.wav", + "text": "在野黨攻擊執政黨執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/189.wav", + "text": "當然必須忍受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/190.wav", + "text": "嘛在野黨挑戰執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/191.wav", + "text": "是天經地義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/192.wav", + "text": "而執政黨回應也是天經地義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/193.wav", + "text": "我覺得大可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/194.wav", + "text": "不必如此做文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/195.wav", + "text": "他們提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/196.wav", + "text": "是謝衣鳯委員簽的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/197.wav", + "text": "但是他蓋黨團的章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/198.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗總召要簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/199.wav", + "text": "啦這次不知道為什麼全部謝衣鳯簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/200.wav", + "text": "我們的幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/201.wav", + "text": "和書記長就以這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/202.wav", + "text": "乃至於攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/203.wav", + "text": "吳音寧找來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/204.wav", + "text": "這個都是選舉操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/205.wav", + "text": "啦像我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/206.wav", + "text": "所有的提案要我簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/207.wav", + "text": "但我們都會過濾啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/208.wav", + "text": "基本上比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/209.wav", + "text": "不適合的我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/210.wav", + "text": "內部會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/211.wav", + "text": "\n今天不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/212.wav", + "text": "第一個這沒有所謂不尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/213.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/214.wav", + "text": "也沒有所謂不尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/215.wav", + "text": "立法院都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/216.wav", + "text": "也沒有所謂不尊重朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/217.wav", + "text": "只能勉強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/218.wav", + "text": "這樣對於朝野協商的氛圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/219.wav", + "text": "會有一些質變而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/220.wav", + "text": "啦我們在這裡朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/221.wav", + "text": "我常常跟邱顯智" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/222.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜也跟高金素梅惡惡嚷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/223.wav", + "text": "這是難免的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/224.wav", + "text": "協商就是大家不同意見的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/225.wav", + "text": "只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/226.wav", + "text": "來評斷這些事情而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/227.wav", + "text": "這些都有直播誰都可以看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/228.wav", + "text": "假如因為這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/229.wav", + "text": "也不要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/230.wav", + "text": "啦因為我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/231.wav", + "text": "明天院會就要處理停會案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/232.wav", + "text": "這已經過1個月可以表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/233.wav", + "text": "我們的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/234.wav", + "text": "和國民黨立場都完全一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/235.wav", + "text": "所以算起來這個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/236.wav", + "text": "一二三四五5天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/237.wav", + "text": "下禮拜一二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/238.wav", + "text": "7個工作天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/239.wav", + "text": "\n7個工作天我們要處理哪些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/240.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/241.wav", + "text": "要把總預算先處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/242.wav", + "text": "總預算現在大概有二三千案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/243.wav", + "text": "各部會都盡力在溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/244.wav", + "text": "剩下的我們還有法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/245.wav", + "text": "也要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/246.wav", + "text": "包括房屋稅條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/247.wav", + "text": "上禮拜要跟他們談有關所得稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/248.wav", + "text": "扣除額的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/249.wav", + "text": "在這7個工作天裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/250.wav", + "text": "要全部一一完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/251.wav", + "text": "坦白講這本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/252.wav", + "text": "一個非常緊迫的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/253.wav", + "text": "或許也要談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/254.wav", + "text": "等等問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/255.wav", + "text": "今天走了以後勢必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/256.wav", + "text": "又壓縮了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/257.wav", + "text": "剩下6個工作天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/258.wav", + "text": "這是何其緊張的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/259.wav", + "text": "今天有打電話跟曾銘宗說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/260.wav", + "text": "這個擦槍走火的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/261.wav", + "text": "難免的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/262.wav", + "text": "政治攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/263.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/264.wav", + "text": "敵人攻擊是我的身上的勳章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/265.wav", + "text": "我也不會憂讒畏譏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/266.wav", + "text": "每一個人都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/267.wav", + "text": "所以我還是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/268.wav", + "text": "很懇切地拜託國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/269.wav", + "text": "還是請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/270.wav", + "text": "院長或秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/271.wav", + "text": "我們一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/272.wav", + "text": "假如今天不適合再回來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/273.wav", + "text": "明天表決以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/274.wav", + "text": "這個各黨都要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/275.wav", + "text": "嘛表決後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/276.wav", + "text": "我們是不是有機會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/277.wav", + "text": "那我也會找曾銘宗委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/278.wav", + "text": "再跟他溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/279.wav", + "text": "我希望我們都有共同的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/280.wav", + "text": "他走了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/281.wav", + "text": "剩下我們三個在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/282.wav", + "text": "期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/283.wav", + "text": "這要四個人才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/284.wav", + "text": "大家一起勸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/285.wav", + "text": "勸國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/286.wav", + "text": "回來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/287.wav", + "text": "這是我的基本立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/288.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/289.wav", + "text": "我們不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/290.wav", + "text": "為了這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/291.wav", + "text": "已經覆水難收了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/292.wav", + "text": "我還是會希望我們黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/293.wav", + "text": "在最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/294.wav", + "text": "這一個禮拜的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/295.wav", + "text": "委員之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/296.wav", + "text": "彼此的攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/297.wav", + "text": "還是少一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/298.wav", + "text": "也許有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/299.wav", + "text": "再過幾天以後休會以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/300.wav", + "text": "在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/301.wav", + "text": "以後就再也不會見面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/302.wav", + "text": "所以還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/303.wav", + "text": "難免會有這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/304.wav", + "text": "還是要繼續往下走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/305.wav", + "text": "要對總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/306.wav", + "text": "要對所有法案來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/307.wav", + "text": "我們希望第10屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/308.wav", + "text": "能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/309.wav", + "text": "19號以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/310.wav", + "text": "劃下一個美好的ending" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/311.wav", + "text": "把總預算以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/312.wav", + "text": "法案該處理的都處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/313.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/314.wav", + "text": "我們的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/315.wav", + "text": "其實非常簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/316.wav", + "text": "預算當然是一定要審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/317.wav", + "text": "再有什麼樣的問題都應該到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/318.wav", + "text": "黨團協商這邊來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/319.wav", + "text": "另外一個就是今天的第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/320.wav", + "text": "我們當然再度表示反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/321.wav", + "text": "因為在時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/322.wav", + "text": "已經這麼緊迫的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/323.wav", + "text": "開這也沒有什麼道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/324.wav", + "text": "坦白講現在我們也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/325.wav", + "text": "跑選區但也不能因為這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/326.wav", + "text": "就不審然後提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/327.wav", + "text": "這是大家所不能接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/328.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛柯總召提到我臉書的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/329.wav", + "text": "部分我剛剛看了一下我是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/330.wav", + "text": "轉貼媒體的報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/331.wav", + "text": "不是私人的事情這是公事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/332.wav", + "text": "因為這是最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/333.wav", + "text": "連動而你的說法是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/334.wav", + "text": "權力的擁有者不敢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/335.wav", + "text": "濫用權力這當然不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/336.wav", + "text": "要有最低工資法當然就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/337.wav", + "text": "權力的擁有者然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/338.wav", + "text": "可以讓基本勞工得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/339.wav", + "text": "現在在沒辦法審的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/340.wav", + "text": "之下之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/341.wav", + "text": "又有其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/342.wav", + "text": "預算案還有房屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/343.wav", + "text": "房屋稅條例或者其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/344.wav", + "text": "林林總總的法案的話當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/345.wav", + "text": "又會更壓縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/346.wav", + "text": "就這部分的話再加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/347.wav", + "text": "又要停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/348.wav", + "text": "那到底還剩下多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/349.wav", + "text": "這些法案跟預算所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/350.wav", + "text": "要非常謹慎的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/351.wav", + "text": "各黨代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/352.wav", + "text": "我想民眾黨的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/353.wav", + "text": "非常地明確我們還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/354.wav", + "text": "可以在法定會期內把總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/355.wav", + "text": "完成審查這是基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/356.wav", + "text": "態度但是在整個朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/357.wav", + "text": "協商的過程因為現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/358.wav", + "text": "主要是面臨大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/359.wav", + "text": "各政黨都有非常多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/360.wav", + "text": "政治攻防但是我們認為在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/361.wav", + "text": "總預算的部分因為老實講113年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/362.wav", + "text": "總預算後面到底是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/363.wav", + "text": "哪一個政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/364.wav", + "text": "執政其實都還不確定我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/365.wav", + "text": "大家還是用比較客觀理性的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/366.wav", + "text": "去討論這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/367.wav", + "text": "包含立院黨團之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/368.wav", + "text": "是認為非常重要的所以這一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/369.wav", + "text": "攻防跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/370.wav", + "text": "在野黨委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/371.wav", + "text": "甚至拿出來做政治攻擊我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/372.wav", + "text": "這是大可不必因為預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/373.wav", + "text": "的提案本來就是各政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/374.wav", + "text": "各委員身為民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/375.wav", + "text": "\n再來就是針對第三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/376.wav", + "text": "案的部分我想針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/377.wav", + "text": "停會民眾黨從頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/378.wav", + "text": "到尾都不贊成停會因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/379.wav", + "text": "本會期還有總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/380.wav", + "text": "案跟重大法案待處理我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/381.wav", + "text": "剛剛說總預算的部分希望可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/382.wav", + "text": "在法定會期完成三讀但是其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/383.wav", + "text": "及非營業基金看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/384.wav", + "text": "這個會期是沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/385.wav", + "text": "我們還是認為不應該為了選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/386.wav", + "text": "而怠惰立法跟預算的監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/387.wav", + "text": "包含剛剛談到的最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/388.wav", + "text": "工資法跟囤房稅其實都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/389.wav", + "text": "要去處理尤其是囤房稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/390.wav", + "text": "2.0的房屋稅部分條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/391.wav", + "text": "修正草案這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/392.wav", + "text": "所以針對停會的部分我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/393.wav", + "text": "還是反對\n再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/394.wav", + "text": "是針對這次的預算提案其實部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/395.wav", + "text": "在跟我們協商的時候我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/396.wav", + "text": "是因為這兩屆民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/397.wav", + "text": "實質過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/398.wav", + "text": "在溝通上我覺得還是比較強勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/399.wav", + "text": "像這次財政部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/400.wav", + "text": "通案第1案雖然還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/401.wav", + "text": "提到但我還是簡單講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/402.wav", + "text": "針對常態性稅收超徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/403.wav", + "text": "保留的部分其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/404.wav", + "text": "11月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/405.wav", + "text": "今年前10個月的稅收3兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/406.wav", + "text": "223億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/407.wav", + "text": "全年的稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/408.wav", + "text": "3,000至3,700億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/409.wav", + "text": "在11月22日到立法院備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/410.wav", + "text": "時也表示這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/411.wav", + "text": "稅課收入執行超過預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/412.wav", + "text": "部分會優先還債我想這是各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/413.wav", + "text": "的共識所以民眾黨這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/414.wav", + "text": "在整個的通案提案也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/415.wav", + "text": "提要稅收增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/416.wav", + "text": "金額大家可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/417.wav", + "text": "但是在溝通的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/418.wav", + "text": "12月9日(禮拜五)下午5點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/419.wav", + "text": "財政部到本黨團溝通預算提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/420.wav", + "text": "陳慧綺在溝通過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/421.wav", + "text": "表示財委會已經決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/422.wav", + "text": "在這個部分增列150億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/423.wav", + "text": "而且已經成立稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/424.wav", + "text": "估測專案小組因此明年的稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/425.wav", + "text": "實徵數與預算數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/426.wav", + "text": "應該不會相差太遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/427.wav", + "text": "經過溝通之後針對本黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/428.wav", + "text": "提案他們建議可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/429.wav", + "text": "改增列100億現場官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/430.wav", + "text": "都沒有異議也允諾會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/431.wav", + "text": "文字修正但是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/432.wav", + "text": "(12月11日)不知道為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/433.wav", + "text": "馬上就是可能是回去報告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/434.wav", + "text": "還是怎麼樣今天國會聯絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/435.wav", + "text": "人來本黨團的時候表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/436.wav", + "text": "財政部歉難辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/437.wav", + "text": "該提案還是要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/438.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為中間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/439.wav", + "text": "的溝通其實都是浪費時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/440.wav", + "text": "每次回到上面後就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/441.wav", + "text": "一個一個推翻其實我們花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/442.wav", + "text": "那麼多時間跟各部會溝通這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/443.wav", + "text": "預算案可是實際上到這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/444.wav", + "text": "我們有時候要求你們1個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/445.wav", + "text": "提報告你們就要改3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/446.wav", + "text": "3個月就要改6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/447.wav", + "text": "預算行政部會傲慢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/448.wav", + "text": "溝通品質並不是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/449.wav", + "text": "違反信任原則的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/450.wav", + "text": "我深表遺憾我認為這不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/451.wav", + "text": "一個好的溝通方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/452.wav", + "text": "第10屆最後一個預算會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/453.wav", + "text": "我希望大家還是本著互信原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/454.wav", + "text": "以實事求是的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/455.wav", + "text": "來溝通預算否則以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/456.wav", + "text": "這樣的方式那我們後面就不要溝通了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/457.wav", + "text": "好不好以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/458.wav", + "text": "針對剛才兩位所談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/459.wav", + "text": "一個基本問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/460.wav", + "text": "及法案我們絕對能夠在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/461.wav", + "text": "停會前如期完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/462.wav", + "text": "這點請不要擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/463.wav", + "text": "了很好的安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/464.wav", + "text": "所以用這個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/465.wav", + "text": "來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/466.wav", + "text": "不能停會要開到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/467.wav", + "text": "沒這樣的價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/468.wav", + "text": "值\n至於剛剛談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/469.wav", + "text": "一些個案的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/470.wav", + "text": "邱臣遠委員所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/471.wav", + "text": "個案的問題要在通案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/472.wav", + "text": "來討論尤其你們第一個案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/473.wav", + "text": "提要增加歲入3,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/474.wav", + "text": "坦白說持平而論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/475.wav", + "text": "這個應該可以溝通的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/476.wav", + "text": "因為歲入不可能增加3,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/477.wav", + "text": "至於是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/478.wav", + "text": "在這裡來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/479.wav", + "text": "各部會的意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/480.wav", + "text": "他要去跟你們溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/481.wav", + "text": "溝通有沒有結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/482.wav", + "text": "就算有結果其實都要回到這裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/483.wav", + "text": "因為將來表決是黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/484.wav", + "text": "的立法委員在表決不是部會首長在表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/485.wav", + "text": "所以我們都會負起責任來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/486.wav", + "text": "絕對如你所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/487.wav", + "text": "實事求是\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/488.wav", + "text": "相處四年彼此都有良好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/489.wav", + "text": "互信基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/490.wav", + "text": "應該怎麼溝通大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/491.wav", + "text": "稅收要先拿去還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/492.wav", + "text": "還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/493.wav", + "text": "怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/494.wav", + "text": "都有一定的法基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/495.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/496.wav", + "text": "各黨團有他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/497.wav", + "text": "政策性的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/498.wav", + "text": "我覺得現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/499.wav", + "text": "就進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/500.wav", + "text": "通案的逐條討論的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/501.wav", + "text": "我當然也歡迎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/502.wav", + "text": "但是國民黨不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/503.wav", + "text": "請各位放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/504.wav", + "text": "我們不要為了不停會而不停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/505.wav", + "text": "絕對能夠在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/506.wav", + "text": "19號以後把所有事情完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/507.wav", + "text": "我是非常負責在處理所有法案的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/508.wav", + "text": "包括從委員會一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/509.wav", + "text": "有關停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/510.wav", + "text": "1個月以前就提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/511.wav", + "text": "要大家都同意有點困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/512.wav", + "text": "如果兩大黨都同意而你們不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/513.wav", + "text": "那只有明天表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/514.wav", + "text": "了時間已經到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/515.wav", + "text": "這在議事程序來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/516.wav", + "text": "是已經要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/517.wav", + "text": "的因為我們必須負責讓整個議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/518.wav", + "text": "能順利完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/519.wav", + "text": "所以大家還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/520.wav", + "text": "心平氣和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/521.wav", + "text": "剛才有講到總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/522.wav", + "text": "每一黨都想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/523.wav", + "text": "明年選舉結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/524.wav", + "text": "來當總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/525.wav", + "text": "總預算隨便處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/526.wav", + "text": "所以到底誰用得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/527.wav", + "text": "誰用不到還不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/528.wav", + "text": "每一屆的最後一個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/529.wav", + "text": "大家都會如期完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/530.wav", + "text": "通常刪減數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/531.wav", + "text": "比較保守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/532.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們明天是不是想辦法再回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/533.wav", + "text": "那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/534.wav", + "text": "有關囤房稅大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/535.wav", + "text": "法案比較好處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/536.wav", + "text": "預算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/537.wav", + "text": "都提了幾千個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/538.wav", + "text": "這選民會看的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/539.wav", + "text": "臺灣老百姓會看的所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/540.wav", + "text": "是不是院長我們大家一起努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/541.wav", + "text": "跟國民黨談讓他們明天還是要回來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/542.wav", + "text": "但是明天晚上第一個要談什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/543.wav", + "text": "談刪減數多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/544.wav", + "text": "這是最關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/545.wav", + "text": "大家都知道後面怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/546.wav", + "text": "通案怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/547.wav", + "text": "委辦計畫刪多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/548.wav", + "text": "他一定有辦法把各位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/549.wav", + "text": "需求弄一個天衣無縫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/550.wav", + "text": "表格出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/551.wav", + "text": "一毛錢都不會差的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/552.wav", + "text": "不過遺憾歸遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/553.wav", + "text": "這是我們必須承受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/554.wav", + "text": "能夠再見面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/555.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/556.wav", + "text": "我在這邊跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/557.wav", + "text": "會期總是到12月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/558.wav", + "text": "之��要結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/559.wav", + "text": "尤其這個會期是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/560.wav", + "text": "預算會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/561.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/562.wav", + "text": "大家最好全力以赴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/563.wav", + "text": "儘量溝通協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/564.wav", + "text": "\n我在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/565.wav", + "text": "有四點向大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/566.wav", + "text": "報告第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/567.wav", + "text": "有關預算案部分請各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/568.wav", + "text": "還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/569.wav", + "text": "繼續多溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/570.wav", + "text": "俾能在這會期完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/571.wav", + "text": "預算案的三讀程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/572.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/573.wav", + "text": "\n第二點有關本院擴建案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/574.wav", + "text": "如果各黨團沒有反對意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/575.wav", + "text": "本案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/576.wav", + "text": "原則上在本屆要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/577.wav", + "text": "完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/578.wav", + "text": "繼續處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/579.wav", + "text": "\n第三點有關於停會案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/580.wav", + "text": "請各黨團繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/581.wav", + "text": "後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/582.wav", + "text": "則依議事規範進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/583.wav", + "text": "點本會期是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/584.wav", + "text": "決算會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/585.wav", + "text": "希望預算案大家一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/586.wav", + "text": "決算報告案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/587.wav", + "text": "也請各黨團多斟酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/588.wav", + "text": "考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/589.wav", + "text": "\n如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/590.wav", + "text": "我們現在就散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/591.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15348/592.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/0.wav", + "text": "各位早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/1.wav", + "text": "特別謝謝部長還有各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/2.wav", + "text": "我們現在開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/3.wav", + "text": "議案是軍事營區安全維護條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/4.wav", + "text": "軍事營區安全維護條例在審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/5.wav", + "text": "除了第7條第十六條第二十條第二十四條保留外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/6.wav", + "text": "若委員沒有其他的意見我們就開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/7.wav", + "text": "針對保留的條文進行討論\n現在開始討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/8.wav", + "text": "有不同意見的條文關於第7條第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/9.wav", + "text": "先來跟大家做一些說明好不好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/10.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/11.wav", + "text": "我問一下現在修正動議是協商裡面可以修正動議嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/12.wav", + "text": "還是直接協商條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/13.wav", + "text": "把修正動議的內容寫在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/14.wav", + "text": "就是協商的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/15.wav", + "text": "因為修正動議不是一般在院會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/16.wav", + "text": "兩種方式都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/17.wav", + "text": "那我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/18.wav", + "text": "可以提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/19.wav", + "text": "或者是當場針對文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/20.wav", + "text": "我的意思是協商就是在修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/21.wav", + "text": "了有意見的我們才保留來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/22.wav", + "text": "也就是說我們會把修正動議的內容納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/23.wav", + "text": "原來叫我們提修正動議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/24.wav", + "text": "我就覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/25.wav", + "text": "所有院會當中的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/26.wav", + "text": "照理說保留4條要來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/27.wav", + "text": "就是提出來朝野協商的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/28.wav", + "text": "要如何修正這4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/29.wav", + "text": "那又再一個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/30.wav", + "text": "要誰提還是要連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/31.wav", + "text": "還是要幹嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/32.wav", + "text": "我們覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/33.wav", + "text": "還是不來的人就直接提修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/34.wav", + "text": "就條文來修正就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/35.wav", + "text": "因為保留就是要來協商嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/36.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/37.wav", + "text": "協商就是要來修正內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/38.wav", + "text": "可是再提一個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/39.wav", + "text": "就覺得怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/40.wav", + "text": "我沒有反對這個修正內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/41.wav", + "text": "我也覺得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/42.wav", + "text": "但是程序上對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/43.wav", + "text": "我覺得把他們的修正動議的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/44.wav", + "text": "納入今天協商條文的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/45.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/46.wav", + "text": "就這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/47.wav", + "text": "對我們等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/48.wav", + "text": "跟婉汝委員這邊更新一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/49.wav", + "text": "我們會讓議事人員進行宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/50.wav", + "text": "在協商的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/51.wav", + "text": "因為這個修正動議是整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/52.wav", + "text": "國民黨的委員也有在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/53.wav", + "text": "這個刑責的部分是否應該要拉平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/54.wav", + "text": "所以也聽了在野黨的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/55.wav", + "text": "進行相對應的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/56.wav", + "text": "包含像是後續有一些說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/57.wav", + "text": "也做了一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/58.wav", + "text": "所以在協商的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/59.wav", + "text": "如果有任何意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/60.wav", + "text": "我們都可以進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/61.wav", + "text": "這先跟大家說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/62.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/63.wav", + "text": "所以修正動議是你的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/64.wav", + "text": "對對對這是我的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/65.wav", + "text": "而且當時的確包含像是刑責的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/66.wav", + "text": "當時真的太高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/67.wav", + "text": "針對比例原則或者法制面的邏輯來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/68.wav", + "text": "我們進行所謂的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/69.wav", + "text": "\n在場委員同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/70.wav", + "text": "我們是否先讓議事人員來進行宣讀好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/71.wav", + "text": "一條一條修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/72.wav", + "text": "對因為針對保留的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/73.wav", + "text": "第7條宣讀這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/74.wav", + "text": "對我們先讓他宣讀一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/75.wav", + "text": "唸完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/76.wav", + "text": "趕快宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/77.wav", + "text": "有意見或是如果後續要調整的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/78.wav", + "text": "以上我們是否讓議事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/79.wav", + "text": "\n現在進行保留條文的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/80.wav", + "text": "我們首先先討論第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/81.wav", + "text": "一條一條的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/82.wav", + "text": "請議事人員進行宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/83.wav", + "text": "我想跟現場的同仁說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/84.wav", + "text": "因為無故侵擾我們的營區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/85.wav", + "text": "本來就是絕對不應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/86.wav", + "text": "但是我們如果從第7條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/87.wav", + "text": "看第1項都沒有動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/88.wav", + "text": "第3項為什麼調整是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/89.wav", + "text": "衛哨兵畢竟他相對應的資歷跟官階等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/90.wav", + "text": "如果把所有的責任他如果現場看到人有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/91.wav", + "text": "要進行相對應的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/92.wav", + "text": "甚至做得太超過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/93.wav", + "text": "我想單是一個單兵在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/94.wav", + "text": "他不見得有辦法即刻當下做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/95.wav", + "text": "甚至擔心會有誤判誤判誤判的邏輯發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/96.wav", + "text": "所以我們才在第7條的第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/97.wav", + "text": "─由指揮官值勤軍官士官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/98.wav", + "text": "這裡面是一個權責的歸屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/99.wav", + "text": "以及這個階級上面要去做確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/100.wav", + "text": "因為國防部的���在是為了保家衛國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/101.wav", + "text": "國防部的存在是為了保護人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/102.wav", + "text": "我們不希望有任何的意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/103.wav", + "text": "為了謹慎妥適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/104.wav", + "text": "以及在軍營裡面的指揮領導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/105.wav", + "text": "還有權責的劃分上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/106.wav", + "text": "我們加了一個字在上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/107.wav", + "text": "不要把所有的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/108.wav", + "text": "或者是不要把所有這些當下的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/109.wav", + "text": "全部壓在我們從條文上面讓它更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/110.wav", + "text": "不要讓衛哨兵單獨去進行行使他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/111.wav", + "text": "\n第2條的部分我們可以看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/112.wav", + "text": "因為過去原本是處三年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/113.wav", + "text": "其實當天我們有講到對警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/114.wav", + "text": "公務人員或維安人員還有軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/115.wav", + "text": "不應該有不同的對待和處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/116.wav", + "text": "所以希望依照一個公平性的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/117.wav", + "text": "把它的刑責和其他單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/118.wav", + "text": "\n以上的修正是本人自行提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/119.wav", + "text": "當然過程當中很有幸我今年是擔任召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/120.wav", + "text": "也聽了很多不同黨派國會同仁的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/121.wav", + "text": "因為在上次逐條討論保留的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/122.wav", + "text": "我們國會的委員同仁全體一起來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/123.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/124.wav", + "text": "我們在委員會的會議當中都有討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/125.wav", + "text": "今天國防部法律司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/126.wav", + "text": "來其他法務部的人呢好請上座\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/127.wav", + "text": "因為他可能是義務役的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/128.wav", + "text": "也可能是志願役的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/129.wav", + "text": "他如何去做判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/130.wav", + "text": "包括能不能有效地強制驅離這是很有限的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/131.wav", + "text": "所以我們是覺得要衛哨兵擔任那麼重要的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/132.wav", + "text": "因為有時候到底嚴重性怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/133.wav", + "text": "他無法做實際的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/134.wav", + "text": "所以一般來講改為指揮官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/135.wav", + "text": "值勤軍官士官對無故侵入軍事營區者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/136.wav", + "text": "把當中的衛哨兵拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/137.wav", + "text": "是保障他不要授予他那麼大的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/138.wav", + "text": "因為他如果不執行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/139.wav", + "text": "受到懲處的機會可能很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/140.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得這個修正當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/141.wav", + "text": "我好像很少看到得命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/142.wav", + "text": "們一定會向上呈報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/143.wav", + "text": "一定要強制驅離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/144.wav", + "text": "當然也要告知才能強制驅離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/145.wav", + "text": "不能自己判斷之後就強制驅離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/146.wav", + "text": "可是這個得命強制驅離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/147.wav", + "text": "好像文字上怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/148.wav", + "text": "還是你們也都這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/149.wav", + "text": "請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/150.wav", + "text": "跟主席及各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/151.wav", + "text": "因為它這個文字比較單純就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/152.wav", + "text": "因為軍官士官本身是指揮職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/153.wav", + "text": "是一個領導者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/154.wav", + "text": "所以他可以下令衛哨兵來執行強制驅離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/155.wav", + "text": "在文字上來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/156.wav", + "text": "這個命字其實跟令字一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/157.wav", + "text": "就是下令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/158.wav", + "text": "所以它本身來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/159.wav", + "text": "基本上它其實就是一個命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/160.wav", + "text": "一個行政處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/161.wav", + "text": "兩個意義其實是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/162.wav", + "text": "目前法制上都有這種用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/163.wav", + "text": "但是比較少寫命令兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/164.wav", + "text": "擇一目前比較多是這種寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/165.wav", + "text": "廖委員果然是非常專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/166.wav", + "text": "也跟您的想法是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/167.wav", + "text": "所以當時也是天人交戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/168.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼樣才可以讓法令看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/169.wav", + "text": "更直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/170.wav", + "text": "你們所有的行動都攸關生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/171.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/172.wav", + "text": "委邱臣遠第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/173.wav", + "text": "\n本席主要是針對第2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/174.wav", + "text": "身體自由名譽財產之事恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/175.wav", + "text": "依本條例執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/176.wav", + "text": "軍事營區安全勤務之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/177.wav", + "text": "衛哨兵或值勤軍官士官者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/178.wav", + "text": "的部分這個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/179.wav", + "text": "予以降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/180.wav", + "text": "院版的部分是處三年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/181.wav", + "text": "有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/182.wav", + "text": "拘役或新臺幣三十萬元以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/183.wav", + "text": "罰金召委民進黨的版本這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/184.wav", + "text": "是有把它適度地調降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/185.wav", + "text": "降我剛剛有請教召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/186.wav", + "text": "他的意思是這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/187.wav", + "text": "比照刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/188.wav", + "text": "我想就教一下國防部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/189.wav", + "text": "因為當時你們在定這個刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/190.wav", + "text": "應該有你們的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/191.wav", + "text": "實際執行上的案例狀況是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/192.wav", + "text": "對於一些衛哨兵他們可能在前線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/193.wav", + "text": "有時候是需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/194.wav", + "text": "直接面臨到一些基層群眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/195.wav", + "text": "或者是民意的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/196.wav", + "text": "甚至是陳抗的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/197.wav", + "text": "在怎麼保障他們的權益之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/198.wav", + "text": "畢竟他們有時候會擦槍走火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/199.wav", + "text": "或者是為國家做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/200.wav", + "text": "當時你們在定這個法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/201.wav", + "text": "其實你們的刑度是比刑法稍微高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/202.wav", + "text": "現在民進黨提的版本把它下降了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/203.wav", + "text": "你們這邊的意見如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/204.wav", + "text": "我想瞭解一下實際的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/205.wav", + "text": "還有你們的具體意見好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/206.wav", + "text": "是委員好我跟委員做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/207.wav", + "text": "當時我們在擬定這個草案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/208.wav", + "text": "因為看刑法恐嚇公安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/209.wav", + "text": "罪單純的恐嚇公安第305條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/210.wav", + "text": "是二年以下有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/211.wav", + "text": "這一條的客體是值勤中的衛哨兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/212.wav", + "text": "在行政院研討的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/213.wav", + "text": "是三年以下有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/214.wav", + "text": "審查法案的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/215.wav", + "text": "恐嚇衛哨兵或是妨害他執勤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/216.wav", + "text": "如果是軍人陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/217.wav", + "text": "陸海空軍刑法本來也就有處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/218.wav", + "text": "也不過就是三年以下有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/219.wav", + "text": "因為這個對的可能是一般百姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/220.wav", + "text": "實際上我們主要是希望它有個依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/221.wav", + "text": "所以現在如果調降成二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/222.wav", + "text": "我們覺得應該也足夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/223.wav", + "text": "好我這邊也再補充說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/224.wav", + "text": "當時為什麼會調降的幾個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/225.wav", + "text": "任何的法令當它沒辦法執行的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/226.wav", + "text": "這條法令是不存在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/227.wav", + "text": "甚至有些法令下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/228.wav", + "text": "它沒有執行也怕引起相對應的一些爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/229.wav", + "text": "臺灣是一個民主的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/230.wav", + "text": "任何的言論自由絕對是予以保障的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/231.wav", + "text": "我們就舉一個小小的案例來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/232.wav", + "text": "如果有陳抗的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/233.wav", + "text": "在行政院或者是總統府現場有憲兵的衛哨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/234.wav", + "text": "同時在陳抗的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/235.wav", + "text": "如果民眾數量高達一定狀態的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/236.wav", + "text": "有警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/237.wav", + "text": "當民眾對於兩個單位做一樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/238.wav", + "text": "但是他的罰責卻又不一樣的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/239.wav", + "text": "難免對於社會觀感以及社會評價來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/240.wav", + "text": "這個部分可能會產生相對應的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/241.wav", + "text": "當然國軍是國家主權的絕對代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/242.wav", + "text": "警局是內政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/243.wav", + "text": "兩者的確有所差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/244.wav", + "text": "但是這一條法令出去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/245.wav", + "text": "我們還是希望對於民眾來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/246.wav", + "text": "立法者也是站在民眾的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/247.wav", + "text": "萬一一個擦槍走火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/248.wav", + "text": "我們不希望後續會有不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/249.wav", + "text": "同樣的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/250.wav", + "text": "假設他們正在陳抗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/251.wav", + "text": "但是判決出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/252.wav", + "text": "第一個法官這邊在法院的單位來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/253.wav", + "text": "他必須要依法行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/254.wav", + "text": "但是後續的呈現對於觀感也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/255.wav", + "text": "或者對民眾的衡平性公平性來講會有所差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/256.wav", + "text": "所以我們才把行政院當時候的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/257.wav", + "text": "三年下降到二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/258.wav", + "text": "新臺幣30萬下降到20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/259.wav", + "text": "這個是以上補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/260.wav", + "text": "我是覺得很怪異當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/261.wav", + "text": "那個年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/262.wav", + "text": "大家都一窩蜂的把軍事法庭都取消掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/263.wav", + "text": "但是實際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/264.wav", + "text": "這個對軍人的尊重都沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/265.wav", + "text": "你們本來就是要教導民眾對軍人的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/266.wav", + "text": "現在軍人有時候軍紀很難管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/267.wav", + "text": "就是放到民間法庭根本沒事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/268.wav", + "text": "啊所以取消軍法我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/269.wav", + "text": "真的也是亂源之一啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/270.wav", + "text": "對國防部的領導階層來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/271.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/272.wav", + "text": "也沒有必要一定要降或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/273.wav", + "text": "當然在公平性上是說持平的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/274.wav", + "text": "但實際上對國防部來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/275.wav", + "text": "就是它有它的嚴重性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/276.wav", + "text": "我們要告知你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/277.wav", + "text": "啊就是跟一般的不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/278.wav", + "text": "所以國防部才會採取這種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/279.wav", + "text": "我是覺得可以考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/280.wav", + "text": "為什麼一定要調到跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/281.wav", + "text": "刑法第305條一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/282.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/283.wav", + "text": "委員我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/284.wav", + "text": "我們比第305條的罰金刑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/285.wav", + "text": "還是重一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/286.wav", + "text": "我記得第305條好像是900" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/287.wav", + "text": "我們這邊是新臺幣二十萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/288.wav", + "text": "如果說做這個行為是軍人的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/289.wav", + "text": "陸海空軍刑法第67條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/290.wav", + "text": "本來就還是有處罰的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/291.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/292.wav", + "text": "請問委員們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/293.wav", + "text": "還有現場的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/294.wav", + "text": "針對文字上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/295.wav", + "text": "我們先就兩條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/296.wav", + "text": "我們現在聚焦到第7條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/297.wav", + "text": "第7條整體條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/298.wav", + "text": "調整的文字就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/299.wav", + "text": "從行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/300.wav", + "text": "我們調整成加一個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/301.wav", + "text": "命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/302.wav", + "text": "稍早的一些說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/303.wav", + "text": "不知道大家還有沒有任何意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/304.wav", + "text": "政府採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/305.wav", + "text": "行政訴訟法等等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/306.wav", + "text": "基本上也都是主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/307.wav", + "text": "或者是法官命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/308.wav", + "text": "用命字是比較普遍一點的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/309.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/310.wav", + "text": "我很尊重委員的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/311.wav", + "text": "你的想法是絕對尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/312.wav", + "text": "也有它的道理在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/313.wav", + "text": "但就現行的法規上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/314.wav", + "text": "比較通俗的用法是長這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/315.wav", + "text": "可以接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/316.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/317.wav", + "text": "現場的這些意見都已經表達了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/318.wav", + "text": "也請國防部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/319.wav", + "text": "務必聽進去好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/320.wav", + "text": "這些意見都很珍貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/321.wav", + "text": "我們現在第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/322.wav", + "text": "照修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/323.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/324.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/325.wav", + "text": "下一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/326.wav", + "text": "\n第2條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/327.wav", + "text": "原則上修正的部分就是兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/328.wav", + "text": "三年變兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/329.wav", + "text": "三十萬變二十萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/330.wav", + "text": "補充說明是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/331.wav", + "text": "如果是在民間的刑法來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/332.wav", + "text": "是兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/333.wav", + "text": "當然在我們的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/334.wav", + "text": "不是九千而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/335.wav", + "text": "是二十萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/336.wav", + "text": "現場委員是否有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/337.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/338.wav", + "text": "委我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/339.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/340.wav", + "text": "安全維護條例的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/341.wav", + "text": "我想還是說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/342.wav", + "text": "這個案子還是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/343.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望今天還是可以順利通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/344.wav", + "text": "\n其實本黨團在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/345.wav", + "text": "整個版本草案跟院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/346.wav", + "text": "基本上是一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/347.wav", + "text": "我們大方向支持這個行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/348.wav", + "text": "但是我們認為本法的立法目的是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/349.wav", + "text": "讓國軍面對各項軍事演習訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/350.wav", + "text": "跟營區安全勤務的執行時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/351.wav", + "text": "維護這個軍事演習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/352.wav", + "text": "相關訓練跟營區的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/353.wav", + "text": "國防軍事任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/354.wav", + "text": "遂行均以訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/355.wav", + "text": "行政規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/356.wav", + "text": "跟實施計畫的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/357.wav", + "text": "規範法律位階不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/358.wav", + "text": "所以它涉及的各項人民權益的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/359.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法符合法律保留的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/360.wav", + "text": "不管是推動全民國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/361.wav", + "text": "或是國防軍事任務的執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/362.wav", + "text": "其實都有一定程度的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/363.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/364.wav", + "text": "我們這次的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/365.wav", + "text": "我認為還是要在執行面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/366.wav", + "text": "更加地細緻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/367.wav", + "text": "跟後續的執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/368.wav", + "text": "主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/369.wav", + "text": "衛哨配置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/370.wav", + "text": "安全管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/371.wav", + "text": "應變處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/372.wav", + "text": "包含使用武器的時機程序方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/373.wav", + "text": "SOP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/374.wav", + "text": "補償措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/375.wav", + "text": "跟違反禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/376.wav", + "text": "限制的事項跟罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/377.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/378.wav", + "text": "其實在相關的立法必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/379.wav", + "text": "跟特殊性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/380.wav", + "text": "如果這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/381.wav", + "text": "面沒有辦法很細緻地規範的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/382.wav", + "text": "其實你們在子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/383.wav", + "text": "或是相關執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/384.wav", + "text": "應該要更加地細緻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/385.wav", + "text": "所以本席還是期望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/386.wav", + "text": "國防部最後在通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/387.wav", + "text": "在相關子法的訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/388.wav", + "text": "要儘速從速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/389.wav", + "text": "速向外界跟委員們充分說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/390.wav", + "text": "不要讓民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/391.wav", + "text": "在不經意的情況下觸法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/392.wav", + "text": "對於國軍弟兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/393.wav", + "text": "在相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/394.wav", + "text": "勤務執行規範的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/395.wav", + "text": "可以有所依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/396.wav", + "text": "不會常常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/397.wav", + "text": "無所適從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/398.wav", + "text": "有時候其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/399.wav", + "text": "他們在前線也是非常辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/400.wav", + "text": "尤其這個規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/401.wav", + "text": "必須定期地更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/402.wav", + "text": "有時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/403.wav", + "text": "所以要定期地檢討跟更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/404.wav", + "text": "應該要儘速排除這個現況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/405.wav", + "text": "簡單來講這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/406.wav", + "text": "定下來之後要能夠執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/407.wav", + "text": "能夠落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/408.wav", + "text": "SOP要能夠照表操課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/409.wav", + "text": "然後要能夠滾動式檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/410.wav", + "text": "讓軍事的演習訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/411.wav", + "text": "和營區重要場域的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/412.wav", + "text": "能夠有效地維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/413.wav", + "text": "這樣才有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/414.wav", + "text": "達到本法的立法目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/415.wav", + "text": "這個是我們在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/416.wav", + "text": "提出的一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/417.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/418.wav", + "text": "其實我們國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/419.wav", + "text": "針對營安條例這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/420.wav", + "text": "在國防部來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/421.wav", + "text": "因為現在人力非常缺乏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/422.wav", + "text": "營安條例趕快通過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/423.wav", + "text": "在執行面當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/424.wav", + "text": "包括各營區或者訓場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/425.wav", + "text": "對整個營區的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/426.wav", + "text": "維護會更完備一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/427.wav", + "text": "不然無法可依的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/428.wav", + "text": "這種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/429.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法有一個依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/430.wav", + "text": "以國民黨黨團來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/431.wav", + "text": "我們也非常支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/432.wav", + "text": "軍事營安條例的通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/433.wav", + "text": "但是未來那個條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/434.wav", + "text": "有很多子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/435.wav", + "text": "都還沒有完備吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/436.wav", + "text": "還是都準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/437.wav", + "text": "在草擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/438.wav", + "text": "能不能一起出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/439.wav", + "text": "讓我們瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/440.wav", + "text": "不然的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/441.wav", + "text": "我們法源過了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/442.wav", + "text": "都還沒有出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/443.wav", + "text": "我們也不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/444.wav", + "text": "要重新再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/445.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/446.wav", + "text": "因為有很多執行面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/447.wav", + "text": "是在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/448.wav", + "text": "對我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/449.wav", + "text": "的我們有盤點過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/450.wav", + "text": "應該將來要訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/451.wav", + "text": "7個法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/452.wav", + "text": "4個公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/453.wav", + "text": "已經有用行政規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/454.wav", + "text": "在做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/455.wav", + "text": "這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/456.wav", + "text": "上一次在審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/457.wav", + "text": "好像委員那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/458.wav", + "text": "有寫了修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/459.wav", + "text": "就是這個法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/460.wav", + "text": "施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/461.wav", + "text": "是由行政院來定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/462.wav", + "text": "之這個過了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/463.wav", + "text": "我們後面會很加速地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/464.wav", + "text": "把那7個法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/465.wav", + "text": "和4個公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/466.wav", + "text": "加速啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/467.wav", + "text": "我們一定會儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/468.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/469.wav", + "text": "還是要周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/470.wav", + "text": "有些東西還是要周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/471.wav", + "text": "因為這個有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/472.wav", + "text": "牽涉到訓練部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/473.wav", + "text": "有的到作戰部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/474.wav", + "text": "長我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/475.wav", + "text": "法源過了之後慢慢來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/476.wav", + "text": "不會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/477.wav", + "text": "執行面的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/478.wav", + "text": "還是很難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/479.wav", + "text": "這個我要跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/480.wav", + "text": "我們國防部也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/481.wav", + "text": "工作能夠一路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/482.wav", + "text": "一有法就馬上動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/483.wav", + "text": "但事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/484.wav", + "text": "我們也能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/485.wav", + "text": "做這些工作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/486.wav", + "text": "原因在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/487.wav", + "text": "為了避免規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/488.wav", + "text": "前後不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/489.wav", + "text": "因人而異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/490.wav", + "text": "所以我們定這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/491.wav", + "text": "定法以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/492.wav", + "text": "剛才委員的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/493.wav", + "text": "擬出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/494.wav", + "text": "我們儘快的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/495.wav", + "text": "但是還是要考慮周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/496.wav", + "text": "因為以往很多規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/497.wav", + "text": "也就因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/498.wav", + "text": "隨便講講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/499.wav", + "text": "也不周" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/500.wav", + "text": "延造成後來的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/501.wav", + "text": "定個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/502.wav", + "text": "沒有時間壓迫的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/503.wav", + "text": "你們根本都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/504.wav", + "text": "慢慢來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/505.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/506.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們這麼期盼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/507.wav", + "text": "這個法過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/508.wav", + "text": "不會讓法過了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/509.wav", + "text": "放在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/510.wav", + "text": "都沒辦法施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/511.wav", + "text": "我們一定會儘快地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/512.wav", + "text": "把那7個法規命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/513.wav", + "text": "和4個公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/514.wav", + "text": "我就教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/515.wav", + "text": "7個法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/516.wav", + "text": "4個公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/517.wav", + "text": "是在本會期結束前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/518.wav", + "text": "會出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/519.wav", + "text": "還是本會期結束後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/520.wav", + "text": "才會出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/521.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/522.wav", + "text": "先問一個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/523.wav", + "text": "會比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/524.wav", + "text": "當天其實我們不分朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/525.wav", + "text": "7個法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/526.wav", + "text": "4個公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/527.wav", + "text": "要上路前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/528.wav", + "text": "讓大家先看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/529.wav", + "text": "時間不太" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/530.wav", + "text": "在這個會期結束前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/531.wav", + "text": "可能真的有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/532.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/533.wav", + "text": "我的理解是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/534.wav", + "text": "我們不見得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/535.wav", + "text": "但是可以進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/536.wav", + "text": "類似談話會的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/537.wav", + "text": "你們定下來的草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/538.wav", + "text": "也可以先給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/539.wav", + "text": "先定一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/540.wav", + "text": "大概的草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/541.wav", + "text": "召委做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/542.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/543.wav", + "text": "因為你們各軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/544.wav", + "text": "有什麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/545.wav", + "text": "也要拜託一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/546.wav", + "text": "這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/547.wav", + "text": "今天走到一個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/548.wav", + "text": "但是還有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/549.wav", + "text": "攝影師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/550.wav", + "text": "無人機等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/551.wav", + "text": "非常支持國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/552.wav", + "text": "當天我們是有要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/553.wav", + "text": "勢必要對外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/554.wav", + "text": "做一些說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/555.wav", + "text": "為法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/556.wav", + "text": "在走的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/557.wav", + "text": "也可以邀請他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/558.wav", + "text": "他們也可以提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/559.wav", + "text": "一些意見好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/560.wav", + "text": "7個法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/561.wav", + "text": "4個公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/562.wav", + "text": "是否可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/563.wav", + "text": "因為法源過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/564.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/565.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/566.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/567.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/568.wav", + "text": "講的以一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/569.wav", + "text": "軍事迷來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/570.wav", + "text": "他們攝影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/571.wav", + "text": "你沒有把它規範得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/572.wav", + "text": "拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/573.wav", + "text": "讓我們參考的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/574.wav", + "text": "我們不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/575.wav", + "text": "你們到底怎麼規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/576.wav", + "text": "不然到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/577.wav", + "text": "我們法源過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/578.wav", + "text": "對他們來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/579.wav", + "text": "又有另外的聲音出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/580.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/581.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/582.wav", + "text": "在草案過的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/583.wav", + "text": "我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/584.wav", + "text": "讓這個法源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/585.wav", + "text": "法規命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/586.wav", + "text": "將來定出來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/587.wav", + "text": "本來就一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/588.wav", + "text": "報到院裡面來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/589.wav", + "text": "報之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/590.wav", + "text": "我們來先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/591.wav", + "text": "跟委員再做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/592.wav", + "text": "我們會配合來辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/593.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/594.wav", + "text": "那我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/595.wav", + "text": "進行條文的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/596.wav", + "text": "我們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/597.wav", + "text": "做了廣泛的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/598.wav", + "text": "還有針對未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/599.wav", + "text": "7個法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/600.wav", + "text": "4個公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/601.wav", + "text": "也有進行一些要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/602.wav", + "text": "時間的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/603.wav", + "text": "我們等一下會後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/604.wav", + "text": "我們是否就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/605.wav", + "text": "按照修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/606.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/607.wav", + "text": "那第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/608.wav", + "text": "照修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/609.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/610.wav", + "text": "第十六條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/611.wav", + "text": "由國防部先說明好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/612.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/613.wav", + "text": "第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/614.wav", + "text": "本來是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/615.wav", + "text": "就算不定這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/616.wav", + "text": "如果萬一違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/617.wav", + "text": "執行勤務的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/618.wav", + "text": "也是要國賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/619.wav", + "text": "我們是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/620.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/621.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/622.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/623.wav", + "text": "但是國賠很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/624.wav", + "text": "報告委員在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/625.wav", + "text": "第十五條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/626.wav", + "text": "還有一個補償的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/627.wav", + "text": "補償跟賠償都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/628.wav", + "text": "跟國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/629.wav", + "text": "講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/630.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/631.wav", + "text": "在說明其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/632.wav", + "text": "也有講得非常的清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/633.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/634.wav", + "text": "通過的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/635.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/636.wav", + "text": "心裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/637.wav", + "text": "真正的期待是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/638.wav", + "text": "第十六條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/639.wav", + "text": "永遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/640.wav", + "text": "永遠永遠用不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/641.wav", + "text": "民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/642.wav", + "text": "被傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/643.wav", + "text": "但是當他帶著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/644.wav", + "text": "惡意來刺探" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/645.wav", + "text": "或甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/646.wav", + "text": "有心要攻擊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/647.wav", + "text": "我們就全力反擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/648.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/649.wav", + "text": "第十六條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/650.wav", + "text": "最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/651.wav", + "text": "討論到國賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/652.wav", + "text": "那是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/653.wav", + "text": "真的期待在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/654.wav", + "text": "針對國人的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/655.wav", + "text": "這一條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/656.wav", + "text": "永遠用不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/657.wav", + "text": "各方大家詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/658.wav", + "text": "詳細審視之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/659.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/660.wav", + "text": "我們第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/661.wav", + "text": "就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/662.wav", + "text": "通過好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/663.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/664.wav", + "text": "\n我們下一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/665.wav", + "text": "是第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/666.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/667.wav", + "text": "第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/668.wav", + "text": "主要是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/669.wav", + "text": "準用的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/670.wav", + "text": "最後一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/671.wav", + "text": "勤務準用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/672.wav", + "text": "因為先前第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/673.wav", + "text": "有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/674.wav", + "text": "也是按照第十六條的規範來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/675.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/676.wav", + "text": "第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/677.wav", + "text": "跟第二十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/678.wav", + "text": "其實是相對連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/679.wav", + "text": "第二十四條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/680.wav", + "text": "有沒有任何意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/681.wav", + "text": "想法或提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/682.wav", + "text": "我們第二十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/683.wav", + "text": "就按照院版的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/684.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/685.wav", + "text": "我們合併審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/686.wav", + "text": "維護條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/687.wav", + "text": "現在已協商完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/688.wav", + "text": "非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/689.wav", + "text": "協商的結論如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/690.wav", + "text": "第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/691.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/692.wav", + "text": "第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/693.wav", + "text": "第二十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/694.wav", + "text": "按照院版的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/695.wav", + "text": "其餘均照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/696.wav", + "text": "審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/697.wav", + "text": "黨團的協商代表簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/698.wav", + "text": "但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/699.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/700.wav", + "text": "還有七個法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/701.wav", + "text": "跟四個公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/702.wav", + "text": "大概我們寫一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/703.wav", + "text": "落日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/704.wav", + "text": "會期間至少要提幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/705.wav", + "text": "其實你們都準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/706.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/707.wav", + "text": "他確實有一些是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/708.wav", + "text": "現行的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/709.wav", + "text": "直接就轉成將來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/710.wav", + "text": "法規命令或公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/711.wav", + "text": "那個的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/712.wav", + "text": "我們可以儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/713.wav", + "text": "跟委員約時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/714.wav", + "text": "但是有一兩個是新訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/715.wav", + "text": "不然這個過了以後就送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/716.wav", + "text": "法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/717.wav", + "text": "跟那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/718.wav", + "text": "這一兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/719.wav", + "text": "我請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/720.wav", + "text": "因為這七個法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/721.wav", + "text": "跟四個公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/722.wav", + "text": "就算他現在拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/723.wav", + "text": "不成熟的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/724.wav", + "text": "他一定還是需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/725.wav", + "text": "再調整再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/726.wav", + "text": "我們立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/727.wav", + "text": "邏輯是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/728.wav", + "text": "這個法規因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/729.wav", + "text": "會涉及到國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/730.wav", + "text": "以及人民的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/731.wav", + "text": "得動用相對應的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/732.wav", + "text": "所以我們在這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/733.wav", + "text": "有我們的堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/734.wav", + "text": "一週好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/735.wav", + "text": "我們用一週當單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/736.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/737.wav", + "text": "一週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/738.wav", + "text": "你們條文還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/739.wav", + "text": "準備好的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/740.wav", + "text": "不見得要七加四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/741.wav", + "text": "可能三加一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/742.wav", + "text": "我們也接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/743.wav", + "text": "好我們一週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/744.wav", + "text": "我們把他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/745.wav", + "text": "現有的東西先看完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/746.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/747.wav", + "text": "在一週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/748.wav", + "text": "但是你要提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/749.wav", + "text": "跟我們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/750.wav", + "text": "大概我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/751.wav", + "text": "碰觸到哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/752.wav", + "text": "至於時間的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/753.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/754.wav", + "text": "各個委員時間不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/755.wav", + "text": "所以我們時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/756.wav", + "text": "現在不定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/757.wav", + "text": "但是原則是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/758.wav", + "text": "一週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/759.wav", + "text": "以一週為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/760.wav", + "text": "你的時間我的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/761.wav", + "text": "和大家的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/762.wav", + "text": "都要看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/763.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/764.wav", + "text": "\n那我們就約在臺中好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/765.wav", + "text": "等一下你要簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/766.wav", + "text": "要畫押" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/767.wav", + "text": "不行啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/768.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/769.wav", + "text": "他才有辦法進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/770.wav", + "text": "你不是說我笑一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/771.wav", + "text": "就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/772.wav", + "text": "笑一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/773.wav", + "text": "委員這我來管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/774.wav", + "text": "讓我進行程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/775.wav", + "text": "是否由部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/776.wav", + "text": "直接講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/777.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/778.wav", + "text": "這樣下order之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/779.wav", + "text": "我當然很感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/780.wav", + "text": "召委希望能夠體諒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/781.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/782.wav", + "text": "初步可以講已經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/783.wav", + "text": "但召委的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/784.wav", + "text": "也不為過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/785.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/786.wav", + "text": "程序一樣照走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/787.wav", + "text": "但我們也不會講話黃牛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/788.wav", + "text": "因為國防部這個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/789.wav", + "text": "一個接一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/790.wav", + "text": "一來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/791.wav", + "text": "一定有一個工作節點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/792.wav", + "text": "節點一到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/793.wav", + "text": "假如我們沒有出去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/794.wav", + "text": "我們負責國會的速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/795.wav", + "text": "國會會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/796.wav", + "text": "國會會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/797.wav", + "text": "因為這個協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/798.wav", + "text": "要簽才有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/799.wav", + "text": "送到院裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/800.wav", + "text": "所以到下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/801.wav", + "text": "我們會期已經即將結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/802.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/803.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/804.wav", + "text": "是否掌聲一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/805.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/806.wav", + "text": "感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/807.wav", + "text": "我們未來的營區安全非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/808.wav", + "text": "我們也期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/809.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/810.wav", + "text": "請部長親自下去督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/811.wav", + "text": "我們在金門外島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/812.wav", + "text": "等等的無人機的反制系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/813.wav", + "text": "所有的本會委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/814.wav", + "text": "都很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/815.wav", + "text": "那現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/816.wav", + "text": "的確是delay了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/817.wav", + "text": "我後續真正深刻去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/818.wav", + "text": "中山科學研究院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/819.wav", + "text": "也上質詢臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/820.wav", + "text": "被白罵了好多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/821.wav", + "text": "但是問題根本不在他的身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/822.wav", + "text": "是因為有其他的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/823.wav", + "text": "希望能夠增加國內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/824.wav", + "text": "研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/825.wav", + "text": "跟生產的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/826.wav", + "text": "所以在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/827.wav", + "text": "跟院長說聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/828.wav", + "text": "辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/829.wav", + "text": "也要跟部長說聲辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/830.wav", + "text": "但是我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/831.wav", + "text": "就如同剛剛廖委員的堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/832.wav", + "text": "他的堅持是有其正當性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/833.wav", + "text": "我的認知是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/834.wav", + "text": "在外島的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/835.wav", + "text": "當然無人機的侵擾頻率已經下降了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/836.wav", + "text": "但是這個反制系統到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/837.wav", + "text": "還沒有完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/838.wav", + "text": "下一個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/839.wav", + "text": "我不管是哪裡做出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/840.wav", + "text": "但是它的系統必須能夠整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/841.wav", + "text": "我們的外島需要防護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/842.wav", + "text": "當時我們在外島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/843.wav", + "text": "看到無人機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/844.wav", + "text": "沒有即刻用現代的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/845.wav", + "text": "所以現在我們必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/846.wav", + "text": "求這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/847.wav", + "text": "因為法條有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/848.wav", + "text": "相對應的equipment" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/849.wav", + "text": "這是第一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/850.wav", + "text": "\n第二件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/851.wav", + "text": "昨天我與靜儀委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/852.wav", + "text": "有���清泉崗進行考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/853.wav", + "text": "的確有一群人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/854.wav", + "text": "國家的空優會帶來安心的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/855.wav", + "text": "當然有很多所謂的軍事迷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/856.wav", + "text": "但是他沒有惡意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/857.wav", + "text": "我們陸陸續續已經盤點出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/858.wav", + "text": "二三十個點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/859.wav", + "text": "讓一些軍事營區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/860.wav", + "text": "在未來可以變成景點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/861.wav", + "text": "美國及日本的幾個軍事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/862.wav", + "text": "甚至幫他們的國軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/863.wav", + "text": "非常高的觀光產值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/864.wav", + "text": "光是賣咖啡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/865.wav", + "text": "及伴手禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/866.wav", + "text": "這個還是要對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/867.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/868.wav", + "text": "剛剛講到無人機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/869.wav", + "text": "我覺得好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/870.wav", + "text": "不太對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/871.wav", + "text": "因為當初干擾機要由廠商來研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/872.wav", + "text": "兩間要求他們那個對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/873.wav", + "text": "兩間兩間個別研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/874.wav", + "text": "所以延宕整個反制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/875.wav", + "text": "直升機的生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/876.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/877.wav", + "text": "現在變成經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/878.wav", + "text": "兩兩來研發這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/879.wav", + "text": "怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/880.wav", + "text": "成功每個公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/881.wav", + "text": "成功率本來就大概是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/882.wav", + "text": "是零到時間點的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/883.wav", + "text": "我們沒有辦法完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/884.wav", + "text": "中科院整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/885.wav", + "text": "技術移轉都交給他們了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/886.wav", + "text": "可是他們學到之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/887.wav", + "text": "這些為什麼沒有辦法整合成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/888.wav", + "text": "簡單講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/889.wav", + "text": "以我對這些廠商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/890.wav", + "text": "或者整合的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/891.wav", + "text": "中科院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/892.wav", + "text": "這些整合不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/893.wav", + "text": "不是沒有原因的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/894.wav", + "text": "到最後經濟部是說開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/895.wav", + "text": "開放就是代理商進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/896.wav", + "text": "他們根本不要研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/897.wav", + "text": "就讓代理商來標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/898.wav", + "text": "不管是研發還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/899.wav", + "text": "但是國內一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/900.wav", + "text": "有相對應的研發能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/901.wav", + "text": "也要配合總統府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/902.wav", + "text": "國機國造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/903.wav", + "text": "國艦國造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/904.wav", + "text": "造無人機這件事情這麼小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/905.wav", + "text": "很小很小很小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/906.wav", + "text": "在我們審查預算看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/907.wav", + "text": "它的比例是非常輕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/908.wav", + "text": "現在已經12月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/909.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜以內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/910.wav", + "text": "至少要有一個方案出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/911.wav", + "text": "這個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/912.wav", + "text": "不要再等到明年夏天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/913.wav", + "text": "如果要等到明年8月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/914.wav", + "text": "一定會被罵到臭頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/915.wav", + "text": "相對應的連帶責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/916.wav", + "text": "跟國民沒辦法交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/917.wav", + "text": "請部長在1個月內好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/918.wav", + "text": "不會下禮拜一就會有決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/919.wav", + "text": "至少要把方案定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/920.wav", + "text": "我不管它是哪裡做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/921.wav", + "text": "我們都不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/922.wav", + "text": "而是在金門在馬祖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/923.wav", + "text": "我曾經服役的馬祖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/924.wav", + "text": "無人機的反制系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/925.wav", + "text": "是需要在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/926.wav", + "text": "的我理解它也許看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/927.wav", + "text": "很小感覺很小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/928.wav", + "text": "但是對民心的安定來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/929.wav", + "text": "這個是很重要的好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/930.wav", + "text": "我們今天特別再次感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/931.wav", + "text": "就兩個提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/932.wav", + "text": "一個是7個法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/933.wav", + "text": "4個命令公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/934.wav", + "text": "是需要在一週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/935.wav", + "text": "跟本委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/936.wav", + "text": "進行相對應的說明與溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/937.wav", + "text": "那就是我們的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/938.wav", + "text": "我們的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/939.wav", + "text": "以及無人機的反制系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/940.wav", + "text": "在一個禮拜內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/941.wav", + "text": "要有方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/942.wav", + "text": "不能再這樣拖下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/943.wav", + "text": "因為我們那個時候看預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/944.wav", + "text": "可能真的要等到明年8月後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/945.wav", + "text": "才有辦法���成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/946.wav", + "text": "協商代表已經簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/947.wav", + "text": "我們就散會再次感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15343/948.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/0.wav", + "text": "會議開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1.wav", + "text": "今天要研商的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/3.wav", + "text": "管理利用條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/4.wav", + "text": "等案(如附表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/5.wav", + "text": "這個是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/6.wav", + "text": "黨團提議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/7.wav", + "text": "二研商最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/8.wav", + "text": "草案等案(如附表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/9.wav", + "text": ")這個是民進黨黨團提議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/10.wav", + "text": "好我先向大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/11.wav", + "text": "在開始進行協商之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/12.wav", + "text": "先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/13.wav", + "text": "刑法各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/14.wav", + "text": "已經完成協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/15.wav", + "text": "第6案相關部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/16.wav", + "text": "就可以讓他們先離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/17.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/18.wav", + "text": "要請教各黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/19.wav", + "text": "領導人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/20.wav", + "text": "今天協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/21.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/22.wav", + "text": "不行不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/23.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/24.wav", + "text": "這個是臨時通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/25.wav", + "text": "大家現在選舉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/26.wav", + "text": "行程很多晚上要跑行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/27.wav", + "text": "我本來是建議到5點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/28.wav", + "text": "但是柯建銘說4點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/29.wav", + "text": "要結束我就贊成他了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/30.wav", + "text": "到4點就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/31.wav", + "text": "各位委員同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/32.wav", + "text": "有關於今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/33.wav", + "text": "事實上朝野各黨團之間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/34.wav", + "text": "溝通也滿不錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/35.wav", + "text": "有關第1案原住民保留地的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/36.wav", + "text": "因為還有很多部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/37.wav", + "text": "必須整理牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/38.wav", + "text": "好幾萬戶的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/39.wav", + "text": "對於這一案我跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/40.wav", + "text": "曾委員有一個共識就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/41.wav", + "text": "這個案子往後挪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/42.wav", + "text": "今天比較重點大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/43.wav", + "text": "眾所矚目的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/44.wav", + "text": "最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/45.wav", + "text": "是政治檔案法及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/46.wav", + "text": "國家機密保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/47.wav", + "text": "本來大家都簽好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/48.wav", + "text": "所以第3案第4案也不必了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/49.wav", + "text": "政治檔案法以及第4案國家機密保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/50.wav", + "text": "已經完成協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/51.wav", + "text": "剛才我們私底下已經協商完畢也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/52.wav", + "text": "都簽完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/53.wav", + "text": "對至於第5案以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/54.wav", + "text": "有關房屋稅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/55.wav", + "text": "明天中午還有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/56.wav", + "text": "黨團要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/57.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天速度很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/58.wav", + "text": "就集中在最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/59.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/60.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/61.wav", + "text": "我再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/62.wav", + "text": "現在不必再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/63.wav", + "text": "已經協商完畢都簽完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/64.wav", + "text": "第5案要明天處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/65.wav", + "text": "第5案下次再處理沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/66.wav", + "text": "第5案明天處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/67.wav", + "text": "沒有下次再處理我們擇期再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/68.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/69.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/70.wav", + "text": "兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/71.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/72.wav", + "text": "第7案再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/73.wav", + "text": "我把整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/74.wav", + "text": "重點是第2案最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/75.wav", + "text": "好那我們今天就集中在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/76.wav", + "text": "第1案第2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/77.wav", + "text": "兩位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/78.wav", + "text": "第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/79.wav", + "text": "這個案子已經審查很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/80.wav", + "text": "在內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/81.wav", + "text": "審查完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/82.wav", + "text": "是要黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/83.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/84.wav", + "text": "因為我是召集委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/85.wav", + "text": "所以就負責黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/86.wav", + "text": "所以我在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/87.wav", + "text": "去年9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/88.wav", + "text": "12月9號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/89.wav", + "text": "及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/90.wav", + "text": "今年4月11號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/91.wav", + "text": "召開了4次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/92.wav", + "text": "黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/93.wav", + "text": "4月11號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/94.wav", + "text": "黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/95.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/96.wav", + "text": "當然就是莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/97.wav", + "text": "建議是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/98.wav", + "text": "我們原住民的立委自己先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/99.wav", + "text": "凝聚共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/100.wav", + "text": "召開會前會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/101.wav", + "text": "所以我根據莊瑞雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/102.wav", + "text": "今年5月10號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/103.wav", + "text": "原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/104.wav", + "text": "委員的會前會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/105.wav", + "text": "原住民委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/106.wav", + "text": "共識條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/107.wav", + "text": "完了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/108.wav", + "text": "有了共識條文之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/109.wav", + "text": "在今年1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/110.wav", + "text": "又召開一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/111.wav", + "text": "我主持的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/112.wav", + "text": "黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/113.wav", + "text": "行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/114.wav", + "text": "行政院各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/115.wav", + "text": "對原住民的共識條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/116.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/117.wav", + "text": "所以才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/118.wav", + "text": "由中國國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/119.wav", + "text": "黨團發文給院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/120.wav", + "text": "來召開這個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/121.wav", + "text": "因此今天才會排在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/122.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/123.wav", + "text": "這個意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/124.wav", + "text": "是因為我們國民黨立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/125.wav", + "text": "黨團在11月14號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/126.wav", + "text": "就發文給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/127.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/128.wav", + "text": "把它放在第一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/129.wav", + "text": "是不是就照順序來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/130.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/131.wav", + "text": "各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/132.wav", + "text": "對於我們原住民立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/133.wav", + "text": "所共識的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/134.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/135.wav", + "text": "再往後延都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/136.wav", + "text": "不能是直接就跳過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/137.wav", + "text": "各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/138.wav", + "text": "是不是可以接受說不定他們都接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/139.wav", + "text": "啊對不對說不定他們都接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/140.wav", + "text": "\n因為我在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/141.wav", + "text": "最後一次黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/142.wav", + "text": "的時候有請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/143.wav", + "text": "各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/144.wav", + "text": "把這些條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/145.wav", + "text": "好好的再看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/146.wav", + "text": "一看然後我還特別提到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/147.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/148.wav", + "text": "立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/149.wav", + "text": "在過去還沒有法律的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/150.wav", + "text": "省政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/151.wav", + "text": "在沒有法律的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/152.wav", + "text": "就劃設了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/153.wav", + "text": "24多公頃的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/154.wav", + "text": "原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/155.wav", + "text": "然後在民國76年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/156.wav", + "text": "因為省議員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/157.wav", + "text": "立法委員原住民立委的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/158.wav", + "text": "所以76年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/159.wav", + "text": "開始有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/160.wav", + "text": "增劃編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/161.wav", + "text": "也沒有法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/162.wav", + "text": "就可以增劃編保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/163.wav", + "text": "現在我們既然要立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/164.wav", + "text": "就必須要考量到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/165.wav", + "text": "這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/166.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思是說我才會說請各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/167.wav", + "text": "要考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/168.wav", + "text": "到這個歷史的事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/169.wav", + "text": "既然要立法就要做一個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/170.wav", + "text": "完備的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/171.wav", + "text": "所以是不是我們先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/172.wav", + "text": "審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/173.wav", + "text": "如果各部會都有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/174.wav", + "text": "我們再往後延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/175.wav", + "text": "而不是直接就把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/176.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/177.wav", + "text": "族保留地管理利用條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/178.wav", + "text": "總共有35條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/179.wav", + "text": "剛剛誠如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/180.wav", + "text": "鄭天財委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/181.wav", + "text": "各原住民的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/182.wav", + "text": "包括民進黨的兩位立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/183.wav", + "text": "我們其實都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/184.wav", + "text": "協調出一個原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/185.wav", + "text": "立委的協商條文了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/186.wav", + "text": "而且我們有非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/187.wav", + "text": "絕大部分21條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/188.wav", + "text": "同意行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/189.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/190.wav", + "text": "所以這個原住民族保留地管理利用條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/191.wav", + "text": "有爭議的其實只有幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/192.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/193.wav", + "text": "以及未來我們的生存發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/194.wav", + "text": "我覺得不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/195.wav", + "text": "我們有一個協商的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/196.wav", + "text": "除非各部會有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/197.wav", + "text": "我覺得是可以討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/198.wav", + "text": "而不是說再把我們的原住民族保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/199.wav", + "text": "放在最後再來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/200.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/201.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/202.wav", + "text": "如同剛剛鄭天財委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/203.wav", + "text": "跟高金委提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/204.wav", + "text": "的原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/205.wav", + "text": "管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/206.wav", + "text": "各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/207.wav", + "text": "也沒多大意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/208.wav", + "text": "鄭天財委員召集原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/209.wav", + "text": "所以我們贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/210.wav", + "text": "三讀保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/211.wav", + "text": "原住民的相關權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/212.wav", + "text": "每次都講轉型正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/213.wav", + "text": "我覺得這對原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/214.wav", + "text": "極度不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/215.wav", + "text": "所以我們贊成剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/216.wav", + "text": "鄭天財委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/217.wav", + "text": "跟高金委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/218.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/219.wav", + "text": "好來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/220.wav", + "text": "這個原保條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/221.wav", + "text": "是為了解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/222.wav", + "text": "長期以來原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/223.wav", + "text": "土地上的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/224.wav", + "text": "積弊很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/225.wav", + "text": "原住民族其實也很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/226.wav", + "text": "多少土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/227.wav", + "text": "到現在都不合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/228.wav", + "text": "建物也不合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/229.wav", + "text": "住的不是只有原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/230.wav", + "text": "也有非原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/231.wav", + "text": "所以我希望最低限度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/232.wav", + "text": "至少以院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/233.wav", + "text": "儘早立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/234.wav", + "text": "儘早確保原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/235.wav", + "text": "土地的權益並防止流失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/236.wav", + "text": "是最低限度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/237.wav", + "text": "���家還有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/238.wav", + "text": "沒有我們就進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/239.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/240.wav", + "text": "趕快三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/241.wav", + "text": "報告柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/242.wav", + "text": "有很多原住民的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/243.wav", + "text": "提案可是最後在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/244.wav", + "text": "鄭天財委員的朝野協商之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/245.wav", + "text": "原住民的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/246.wav", + "text": "條文在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/247.wav", + "text": "陳瑩委員都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/248.wav", + "text": "今天就是希望能夠趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/249.wav", + "text": "通過而且我剛剛講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/250.wav", + "text": "行政院版本有35條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/251.wav", + "text": "21條已經通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/252.wav", + "text": "我們是不是針對幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/253.wav", + "text": "協商的意思不就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/254.wav", + "text": "在這裡嗎我希望今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/255.wav", + "text": "能夠儘快討論謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/256.wav", + "text": "好有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/257.wav", + "text": "關於鄭天財委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/258.wav", + "text": "主持的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/259.wav", + "text": "事實上行政院版還有19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/260.wav", + "text": "卡去這個茲事體大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/261.wav", + "text": "就可以談得完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/262.wav", + "text": "應該往後挪一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/263.wav", + "text": "識這19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/264.wav", + "text": "歷史遺留下很多現實的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/265.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/266.wav", + "text": "可能牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/267.wav", + "text": "利益衝突的很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/268.wav", + "text": "能夠解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/269.wav", + "text": "但是可能要一條一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/270.wav", + "text": "竟有19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/271.wav", + "text": "都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/272.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/273.wav", + "text": "高金委員要第三度發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/274.wav", + "text": "柯總召的意見我不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/275.wav", + "text": "大家都知道原住民的保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/276.wav", + "text": "管理利用條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/277.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/278.wav", + "text": "按照柯總召的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/279.wav", + "text": "有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/280.wav", + "text": "不就是要趁著朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/281.wav", + "text": "協商的時候取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/282.wav", + "text": "共識嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/283.wav", + "text": "而不是柯總召一個人在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/284.wav", + "text": "讓原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/285.wav", + "text": "最重要的土地轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/286.wav", + "text": "延宕我認為這是不合情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/287.wav", + "text": "不合理不合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/288.wav", + "text": "內由原住民的族人投出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/289.wav", + "text": "的立法委員我必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/290.wav", + "text": "要堅持今天朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/291.wav", + "text": "協商不就是如此嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/292.wav", + "text": "不能夠因為還有19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/293.wav", + "text": "民進黨政府對不起原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/294.wav", + "text": "夷將主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/295.wav", + "text": "的權益捍衛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/296.wav", + "text": "他現在還在位子上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/297.wav", + "text": "我相信他今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/298.wav", + "text": "最想要通過的就是原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/299.wav", + "text": "族保留地管理利用條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/300.wav", + "text": "而不是像剛剛柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/301.wav", + "text": "所講的因為還有19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/302.wav", + "text": "的爭議然後就把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/303.wav", + "text": "一直延宕這19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/304.wav", + "text": "大家應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/305.wav", + "text": "出來討論更何況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/306.wav", + "text": "在內政委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/307.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/308.wav", + "text": "先取得共識原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/309.wav", + "text": "的委員都已經取得共識了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/310.wav", + "text": "為什麼不能夠討論呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/311.wav", + "text": "更何況原住民立法委員也有兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/312.wav", + "text": "是民進黨的委員我不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/313.wav", + "text": "今天兩位原住民的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/314.wav", + "text": "會同意柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/315.wav", + "text": "所講的我們再延後處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/316.wav", + "text": "朝野協商不通過的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/317.wav", + "text": "這一屆幾乎就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/318.wav", + "text": "滅頂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/319.wav", + "text": "所以我們早上在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/320.wav", + "text": "槍砲彈藥管制條例的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/321.wav", + "text": "我們也出席了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/322.wav", + "text": "部警政署新提的案子啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/323.wav", + "text": "為什麼新提的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/324.wav", + "text": "民進黨認為很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/325.wav", + "text": "我們就可以全力的配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/326.wav", + "text": "然後在內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/327.wav", + "text": "也會在這一屆讓它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/328.wav", + "text": "為什麼原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/329.wav", + "text": "最具有爭議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/330.wav", + "text": "而且最具有原住民轉型正義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/331.wav", + "text": "土地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/332.wav", + "text": "有我們的生命力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/333.wav", + "text": "尊嚴的這樣一個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/334.wav", + "text": "就因為有19條大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/335.wav", + "text": "還有一些意見就不在今天討論呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/336.wav", + "text": "這個我不明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/337.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/338.wav", + "text": "鄭委員高金委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/339.wav", + "text": "其實大家都表達了意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/340.wav", + "text": "我們是不是應該要讓原民會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/341.wav", + "text": "一下你們的立場怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/342.wav", + "text": "是不是在這個過程當中沒有認真去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/343.wav", + "text": "溝通協調才導致現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/344.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法立法完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/345.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/346.wav", + "text": "我還是要再次表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/347.wav", + "text": "因為這次的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/348.wav", + "text": "有廖國棟委員陳瑩委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/349.wav", + "text": "版本數不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/350.wav", + "text": "但是我們在10月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/351.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/352.wav", + "text": "就是四個主題版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/353.wav", + "text": "那我要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/354.wav", + "text": "說實在版本不多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/355.wav", + "text": "但是我們原住民立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/356.wav", + "text": "確實有在10月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/357.wav", + "text": "作出一個協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/358.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/359.wav", + "text": "我們每個人也都很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/360.wav", + "text": "自己的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/361.wav", + "text": "當然今天如果能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/362.wav", + "text": "版本應該是最符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/363.wav", + "text": "我們原住民族人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/364.wav", + "text": "可是我還是要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/365.wav", + "text": "我覺得一屆4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/366.wav", + "text": "8個會期不容易啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/367.wav", + "text": "我是覺得最低限度不要讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/368.wav", + "text": "戛然終止不了了之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/369.wav", + "text": "最低限度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/370.wav", + "text": "我還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/371.wav", + "text": "要不然至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/372.wav", + "text": "就用院版來送協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/373.wav", + "text": "好不好\n謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/374.wav", + "text": "廖委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/375.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/376.wav", + "text": "因為我從很遠的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/377.wav", + "text": "趕回來為了要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/378.wav", + "text": "見證這個非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/379.wav", + "text": "歷史性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/380.wav", + "text": "關於原住民土地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/381.wav", + "text": "這個法案能夠在今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/382.wav", + "text": "院長的協商之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/383.wav", + "text": "得以完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/384.wav", + "text": "一直在等待從第一任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/385.wav", + "text": "開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/386.wav", + "text": "還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/387.wav", + "text": "也無法原諒一直在阻擋的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/388.wav", + "text": "那個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/389.wav", + "text": "所以在這裡還是迫切的希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/390.wav", + "text": "院長就是我們都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/391.wav", + "text": "協商我們自己內部也都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/392.wav", + "text": "協商過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/393.wav", + "text": "希望它快速通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/394.wav", + "text": "拜託我們今天一定要審查好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/395.wav", + "text": "都協商過了嘛我們自己內部都協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/396.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼很大的問題啦院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/397.wav", + "text": "協商是要你們有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/398.wav", + "text": "不是我有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/399.wav", + "text": "這不是首長制啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/400.wav", + "text": "我知道我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/401.wav", + "text": "現在立法院跟過去立法院不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/402.wav", + "text": "不是首長制不是我講了就算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/403.wav", + "text": "你難道有那麼乖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/404.wav", + "text": "要聽我講就算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/405.wav", + "text": "我不是那個意思啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/406.wav", + "text": "我的意思是要往前推動不要一直停留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/407.wav", + "text": "我想這樣啦大家要有民主風度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/408.wav", + "text": "風度協商就是各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/409.wav", + "text": "都是一個個體你們要共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/410.wav", + "text": "互相尊重不要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/411.wav", + "text": "跟你意見不同的就是錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/412.wav", + "text": "這樣不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/413.wav", + "text": "當然當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/414.wav", + "text": "抱歉柯總召因為我剛剛先舉手了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/415.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/416.wav", + "text": "你講話不要亂扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/417.wav", + "text": "我帽子好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/418.wav", + "text": "我沒有扣你帽子因為你剛剛希望原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/419.wav", + "text": "所以我才會針對你的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/420.wav", + "text": "所以我希望就是不要延後嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/421.wav", + "text": "我沒有扣帽子啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/422.wav", + "text": "我很遺憾伍麗華委員在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/423.wav", + "text": "發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/424.wav", + "text": "事實上伍委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/425.wav", + "text": "然後用行政院的版本完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/426.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/427.wav", + "text": "第二個不要忘記了我們原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/428.wav", + "text": "立法委員當時你在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/429.wav", + "text": "鄭天財委員也在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/430.wav", + "text": "我們跟幾個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/431.wav", + "text": "朝野協商各個不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/432.wav", + "text": "版本最後得出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/433.wav", + "text": "原住民立委協商的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/434.wav", + "text": "我很遺憾今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/435.wav", + "text": "根本還沒有再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/436.wav", + "text": "第二次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/437.wav", + "text": "跟部會就是各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/438.wav", + "text": "朝野協商你就已經棄守了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/439.wav", + "text": "我在這裡非常地遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/440.wav", + "text": "我覺得你應該跟我們一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/441.wav", + "text": "跟原基法當時立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/442.wav", + "text": "在協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/443.wav", + "text": "我們原住民的立法委員是站在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/444.wav", + "text": "原住民委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/445.wav", + "text": "協商的條文上面來捍衛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/446.wav", + "text": "我們的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/447.wav", + "text": "而不是就用行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/448.wav", + "text": "至少立法委員的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/449.wav", + "text": "就是在這邊朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/450.wav", + "text": "而不是一味地通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/451.wav", + "text": "行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/452.wav", + "text": "如果一味地通過行政院版本的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/453.wav", + "text": "那麼我們是不是就不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/454.wav", + "text": "第一次的朝野協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/455.wav", + "text": "好不好我希望伍麗華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/456.wav", + "text": "能夠堅持一下我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/457.wav", + "text": "內政委員會裡面的協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/458.wav", + "text": "跟協商最後的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/459.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/460.wav", + "text": "柯總召之後就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/461.wav", + "text": "因為他一直點名我這麼多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/462.wav", + "text": "真的我在旁邊聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/463.wav", + "text": "這個條文我剛剛一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/464.wav", + "text": "經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/465.wav", + "text": "鄭天財委員主持的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/466.wav", + "text": "所有人都來喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/467.wav", + "text": "總共保留19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/468.wav", + "text": "所以這19條有的互相牽扯到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/469.wav", + "text": "互相有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/470.wav", + "text": "要有這個基本觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/471.wav", + "text": "第二個你一直在打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/472.wav", + "text": "原住民委員你們有朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/473.wav", + "text": "就算數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/474.wav", + "text": "這個法不是只有原住民委員可以審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/475.wav", + "text": "大家各黨都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/476.wav", + "text": "這有原漢衝突的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/477.wav", + "text": "很多歷史的問題一定要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/478.wav", + "text": "好不好所以我希望高金素梅委員不要一直說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/479.wav", + "text": "我來否定你們的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/480.wav", + "text": "我是照議事規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/481.wav", + "text": "看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/482.wav", + "text": "這個是正常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/483.wav", + "text": "耶19條你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/484.wav", + "text": "似乎沒有辦法接受你要照你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/485.wav", + "text": "幾個原住民委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/486.wav", + "text": "這當然是不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/487.wav", + "text": "你們一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/488.wav", + "text": "這個是大家要來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/489.wav", + "text": "有19條還沒協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/490.wav", + "text": "不是說你們3個講好我們就要照你們的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/491.wav", + "text": "這是很重要的觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/492.wav", + "text": "那個只有4條而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/493.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/494.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/495.wav", + "text": "我要講的話還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/496.wav", + "text": "我還是要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/497.wav", + "text": "我要說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/498.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/499.wav", + "text": "這個版本不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/500.wav", + "text": "這一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/501.wav", + "text": "真的不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/502.wav", + "text": "再耽擱下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/503.wav", + "text": "因為我們等很多年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/504.wav", + "text": "所以我們也很努力地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/505.wav", + "text": "地一直協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/506.wav", + "text": "我的版本我也很想過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/507.wav", + "text": "啊參與協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/508.wav", + "text": "是在10月31日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/509.wav", + "text": "而這個協商版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/510.wav", + "text": "我們希望就以這個為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/511.wav", + "text": "剛剛有講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/512.wav", + "text": "因為這個是原住民族人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/513.wav", + "text": "意向想望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/514.wav", + "text": "原住民立委的協商版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/515.wav", + "text": "為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/516.wav", + "text": "甚至是到11月10日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/517.wav", + "text": "最後一次的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/518.wav", + "text": "我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/519.wav", + "text": "鄭天財委員廖國棟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/520.wav", + "text": "我們3個人也協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/521.wav", + "text": "就保留了幾條19" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/522.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/523.wav", + "text": "那我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/524.wav", + "text": "10月31" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/525.wav", + "text": "最後一次11月10日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/526.wav", + "text": "我們3個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/527.wav", + "text": "並不是說你們3個講好就算數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/528.wav", + "text": "大家要搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/529.wav", + "text": "你們一直在講你們原住民協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/530.wav", + "text": "抱歉柯總召什麼條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/531.wav", + "text": "當然就要在今天協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/532.wav", + "text": "啊怎麼會今天不協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/533.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/534.wav", + "text": "我只是要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/535.wav", + "text": "既然行政院版也出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/536.wav", + "text": "我只是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/537.wav", + "text": "最低限度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/538.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說千萬不要在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/539.wav", + "text": "這個會期這一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/540.wav", + "text": "屆期不續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/541.wav", + "text": "審我不希望這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/542.wav", + "text": "我要再次表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/543.wav", + "text": "最希望自己的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/544.wav", + "text": "要嘛今天至少原住民立委的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/545.wav", + "text": "協商版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/546.wav", + "text": "就行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/547.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/548.wav", + "text": "我們就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/549.wav", + "text": "伍委員發言完了以後就高金委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/550.wav", + "text": "好現在就高金委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/551.wav", + "text": "好非常謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/552.wav", + "text": "我覺得柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/553.wav", + "text": "一直點名我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/554.wav", + "text": "我點名他的原因是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/555.wav", + "text": "第一他希望今天朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/556.wav", + "text": "的順序能夠顛倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/557.wav", + "text": "這是他講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/558.wav", + "text": "的其實能不能顛倒也是要朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/559.wav", + "text": "等一下要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/560.wav", + "text": "第二件事情就是您剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/561.wav", + "text": "說因為原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/562.wav", + "text": "要協商今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/563.wav", + "text": "不就是要協商這19" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/564.wav", + "text": "條嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/565.wav", + "text": "今天就不用朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/566.wav", + "text": "而是直接在內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/567.wav", + "text": "因為還有19條有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/568.wav", + "text": "這個我不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/569.wav", + "text": "我在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/570.wav", + "text": "是最資深的22年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/571.wav", + "text": "和廖國棟委員一樣我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/572.wav", + "text": "處理任何一件法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/573.wav", + "text": "也沒有互相否定各黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/574.wav", + "text": "原住民族立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/575.wav", + "text": "不同的協商版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/576.wav", + "text": "啊那你怎麼可以氣憤地走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/577.wav", + "text": "出去呢這實在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/578.wav", + "text": "我不理解的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/579.wav", + "text": "原住民族基本法不就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/580.wav", + "text": "有非常多不同委員提出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/581.wav", + "text": "最後我們原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/582.wav", + "text": "族立法委員取得共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/583.wav", + "text": "再討論然後再到朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/584.wav", + "text": "協商最後也讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/585.wav", + "text": "三讀通過了不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/586.wav", + "text": "\n最後我要提醒大家的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/587.wav", + "text": "今天如果在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/588.wav", + "text": "送出去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/589.wav", + "text": "這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/590.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/591.wav", + "text": "我要提醒伍麗華委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/592.wav", + "text": "但是我也要堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/593.wav", + "text": "我也要堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/594.wav", + "text": "我也要堅持如果今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/595.wav", + "text": "因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/596.wav", + "text": "要為了趕快讓它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/597.wav", + "text": "而放棄了原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/598.wav", + "text": "族人還有原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/599.wav", + "text": "立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/600.wav", + "text": "所堅持的立場的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/601.wav", + "text": "我也覺得很可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/602.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/603.wav", + "text": "好謝謝高金委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/604.wav", + "text": "講來講去重點是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/605.wav", + "text": "我看這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/606.wav", + "text": "現在已經發言了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/607.wav", + "text": "13位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/608.wav", + "text": "還有3位已經取得發言權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/609.wav", + "text": "謝衣鳯委員鄭天財委員和曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/610.wav", + "text": "這16位發言完畢以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/611.wav", + "text": "休息個5分鐘你們再溝通意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/612.wav", + "text": "溝通意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/613.wav", + "text": "來謝衣鳯委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/614.wav", + "text": "在場的原民委員也表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/615.wav", + "text": "了其實我們應該要聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/616.wav", + "text": "的意見畢竟他們有提出行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/617.wav", + "text": "版本跟所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/618.wav", + "text": "原民委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/619.wav", + "text": "到底為什麼溝通到現在還有19個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/620.wav", + "text": "保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/621.wav", + "text": "有怎麼樣的疑義沒有辦法過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/622.wav", + "text": "是不是也能夠充分說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/623.wav", + "text": "前進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/624.wav", + "text": "然後可以繼續下面的議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/625.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/626.wav", + "text": "很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/627.wav", + "text": "非常多次的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/628.wav", + "text": "然後原住民立委既然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/629.wav", + "text": "有共識的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/630.wav", + "text": "就誠如剛剛柯總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/631.wav", + "text": "19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/632.wav", + "text": "那就針對這19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/633.wav", + "text": "我們可以一條1分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/634.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/635.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/636.wav", + "text": "我是說這種的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/637.wav", + "text": "\n我是說不要直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/638.wav", + "text": "就說挪到後面我的意思是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/639.wav", + "text": "所以你要很詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/640.wav", + "text": "也可以我們更希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/641.wav", + "text": "而不是馬上就變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/642.wav", + "text": "放在後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/643.wav", + "text": "就是因為只剩下19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/644.wav", + "text": "所以應該很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/645.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/646.wav", + "text": "接下來請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/647.wav", + "text": "既然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/648.wav", + "text": "行政院有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/649.wav", + "text": "那原住民委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/650.wav", + "text": "既然提這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/651.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/652.wav", + "text": "好好溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/653.wav", + "text": "原住民委員會的主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/654.wav", + "text": "恐怕不適任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/655.wav", + "text": "行政院的版本為什麼沒來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/656.wav", + "text": "那真的懷疑喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/657.wav", + "text": "的主委在做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/658.wav", + "text": "啊先讓他講講看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/659.wav", + "text": "啦看會不會快一點謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/660.wav", + "text": "先休息啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/661.wav", + "text": "因為現在是黨團的意見不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/662.wav", + "text": "黨團意見要不要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/663.wav", + "text": "要用哪一個做基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/664.wav", + "text": "很簡單的發言就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/665.wav", + "text": "今天要朝野協商沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/666.wav", + "text": "保留19條大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/667.wav", + "text": "那大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/668.wav", + "text": "不要說原住民你們這邊協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/669.wav", + "text": "一定要大家接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/670.wav", + "text": "沒有這樣就好了OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/671.wav", + "text": "我是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/672.wav", + "text": "最低工資法只有4個條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/673.wav", + "text": "家不要跑啊都坐下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/674.wav", + "text": "啊還是坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/675.wav", + "text": "假如照鄭天財委員講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/676.wav", + "text": "這也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/677.wav", + "text": "柯總召的意見大家怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/678.wav", + "text": "了休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/679.wav", + "text": "之前讓原民會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/680.wav", + "text": "不然行政院版本送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/681.wav", + "text": "也不努力溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/682.wav", + "text": "做什麼主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/683.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/684.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席還有各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/685.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/686.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/687.wav", + "text": "保留的19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/688.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/689.wav", + "text": "都跟行政院院版沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/690.wav", + "text": "大部分都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/691.wav", + "text": "各個委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/692.wav", + "text": "他們加進來的修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/693.wav", + "text": "這19條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/694.wav", + "text": "幾乎都沒有院版的條文在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/695.wav", + "text": "所以在之前我們都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/696.wav", + "text": "想盡辦法請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/697.wav", + "text": "各位委員支持我們的院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/698.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/699.wav", + "text": "也特別跟謝委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/700.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/701.wav", + "text": "真相大白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/702.wav", + "text": "那個都是委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/703.wav", + "text": "休息5分鐘你們說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/704.wav", + "text": "共識馬上出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/705.wav", + "text": "休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/706.wav", + "text": "遊戲規則來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/707.wav", + "text": "剛才聽了原住民主委的一席話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/708.wav", + "text": "這19條都是院版沒有的新增的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/709.wav", + "text": "當然我們尊重原住民委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/710.wav", + "text": "他們對於原住民權益保障上面的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/711.wav", + "text": "這是一個很長期的課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/712.wav", + "text": "在臺灣天空已經至少30年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/713.wav", + "text": "牽涉到的權利義務很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/714.wav", + "text": "我引據最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/715.wav", + "text": "大法庭判出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/716.wav", + "text": "抵押權不可以放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/717.wav", + "text": "進去所謂的抵押權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/718.wav", + "text": "是會被拍賣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/719.wav", + "text": "所以這裡面有抵押權是不可以放進去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/720.wav", + "text": "典當權等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/721.wav", + "text": "牽涉的就非常複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/722.wav", + "text": "那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/723.wav", + "text": "我再度肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/724.wav", + "text": "伍麗華委員包括鄭天財委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/725.wav", + "text": "我都非常瞭解但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/726.wav", + "text": "我們今天務實一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/727.wav", + "text": "我建議是討論全國現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/728.wav", + "text": "矚目的最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/729.wav", + "text": "只有4個條文而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/730.wav", + "text": "4個條文談不攏就是表決而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/731.wav", + "text": "至於後面那19個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/732.wav", + "text": "我個人比較誠懇呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/733.wav", + "text": "請主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/734.wav", + "text": "再去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/735.wav", + "text": "否則永遠吵不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/736.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/737.wav", + "text": "有關於剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/738.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/739.wav", + "text": "還是要請主委再辛苦一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/740.wav", + "text": "跟大家溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/741.wav", + "text": "因為有19條意見還是不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/742.wav", + "text": "大家現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/743.wav", + "text": "最低工資法討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/744.wav", + "text": "討論完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/745.wav", + "text": "如果大家一有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/746.wav", + "text": "我們也可以馬上再繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/747.wav", + "text": "都沒有關係我這邊都開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/748.wav", + "text": "現在我們從最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/749.wav", + "text": "先談好不好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/750.wav", + "text": "請大家先看最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/751.wav", + "text": "草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/752.wav", + "text": "現在大家就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/753.wav", + "text": "要溝通嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/754.wav", + "text": "主委跟你們溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/755.wav", + "text": "你們如果今天要再繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/756.wav", + "text": "我沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/757.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/758.wav", + "text": "開始開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/759.wav", + "text": "草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/760.wav", + "text": "我首先介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/761.wav", + "text": "勞動部部長許銘春女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/762.wav", + "text": "我就介紹到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/763.wav", + "text": "我先跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/764.wav", + "text": "最低工資法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/765.wav", + "text": "社會福利及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/766.wav", + "text": "衛生環境委會於今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/767.wav", + "text": "10月18日完成審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/768.wav", + "text": "保留部分是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/769.wav", + "text": "提案共11條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/770.wav", + "text": "黨團與委員提案1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/771.wav", + "text": "並於11月24日再進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/772.wav", + "text": "最後保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/773.wav", + "text": "行政院提案3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/774.wav", + "text": "黨團與委員提案1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/775.wav", + "text": "所以現在就剩4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/776.wav", + "text": "4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/777.wav", + "text": "我們就用11月24日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/778.wav", + "text": "好那就以這個做基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/779.wav", + "text": "我們首先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/780.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/781.wav", + "text": "第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/782.wav", + "text": "看大家有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/783.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/784.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/785.wav", + "text": "各黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/786.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/787.wav", + "text": "最低工資審議會的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/788.wav", + "text": "第一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/789.wav", + "text": "政府官員部會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/790.wav", + "text": "有經濟部的代表1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/791.wav", + "text": "代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/792.wav", + "text": "對部長上次有講雖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/793.wav", + "text": "部的代表代表勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/794.wav", + "text": "席次都沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/795.wav", + "text": "了這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/796.wav", + "text": "\n第二個是說上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/797.wav", + "text": "召委召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/798.wav", + "text": "黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/799.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到有勞方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/800.wav", + "text": "7人資方代表7人學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/801.wav", + "text": "勞方代表資方代表學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/802.wav", + "text": "學者專家是4人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/803.wav", + "text": "專家也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/804.wav", + "text": "他有一個勞動側委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/805.wav", + "text": "使用側委員(資方的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/806.wav", + "text": ")然後還有公益委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/807.wav", + "text": "日本或者是韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/808.wav", + "text": "日本是六六六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/809.wav", + "text": "結果勞動部的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/810.wav", + "text": "勞動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/811.wav", + "text": "黃維琛司長有來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/812.wav", + "text": "司長的說法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/813.wav", + "text": "我們看到其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/814.wav", + "text": "就是三方機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/815.wav", + "text": "這三方機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/816.wav", + "text": "就是等邊三角形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/817.wav", + "text": "然後學者專家這邊再加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/818.wav", + "text": "我們參考其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/819.wav", + "text": "就是政府方大概就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/820.wav", + "text": "屬於公益方的這個區塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/821.wav", + "text": "三方的代表人數是相等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/822.wav", + "text": "司長是這樣講嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/823.wav", + "text": "但是你的見解是完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/824.wav", + "text": "錯誤的你怎麼可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/825.wav", + "text": "委員會裡面這樣亂講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/826.wav", + "text": "跟韓國都不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/827.wav", + "text": "你自己在勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/828.wav", + "text": "105年的委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/829.wav", + "text": "研究計畫報告裡面說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/830.wav", + "text": "說南韓最低工資委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/831.wav", + "text": "分別有工會代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/832.wav", + "text": "雇主聯合會代表跟代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/833.wav", + "text": "公眾的獨立委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/834.wav", + "text": "日本相同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/835.wav", + "text": "政府部門亦未" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/836.wav", + "text": "直接參與該委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/837.wav", + "text": "運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/838.wav", + "text": "\n我們把日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/839.wav", + "text": "名簿全部找出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/840.wav", + "text": "你可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/841.wav", + "text": "所謂的學者專家代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/842.wav", + "text": "就是那六席嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/843.wav", + "text": "立正大學的經濟部教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/844.wav", + "text": "亞細亞大學經濟部教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/845.wav", + "text": "明治大學法學院教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/846.wav", + "text": "立教大學經濟部教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/847.wav", + "text": "獨立行政法人勞動政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/848.wav", + "text": "研究研修機構的理事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/849.wav", + "text": "跟法政大學的教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/850.wav", + "text": "有哪一個是政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/851.wav", + "text": "所以勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/852.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/853.wav", + "text": "召委在主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/854.wav", + "text": "最低工資法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/855.wav", + "text": "用不正確的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/856.wav", + "text": "在誤導委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/857.wav", + "text": "部長你聽得懂我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/858.wav", + "text": "嗎你可以拿去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/859.wav", + "text": "你們自己的研究也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/860.wav", + "text": "政府的機構政府的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/861.wav", + "text": "不算入公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/862.wav", + "text": "就是這個第三方的學者專家代表裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/863.wav", + "text": "啊你怎麼可以這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/864.wav", + "text": "講這導致什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/865.wav", + "text": "因為你的說法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/866.wav", + "text": "不管是國發會的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/867.wav", + "text": "經濟部的代表也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/868.wav", + "text": "你把他算進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/869.wav", + "text": "所以你說這樣加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/870.wav", + "text": "學者專家只能有4個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/871.wav", + "text": "這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/872.wav", + "text": "這真的很離譜耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/873.wav", + "text": "最低工資審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/874.wav", + "text": "人家的代表都是有名有姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/875.wav", + "text": "他是什麼大學的教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/876.wav", + "text": "也都是有名有姓的專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/877.wav", + "text": "政府的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/878.wav", + "text": "所以你說實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/879.wav", + "text": "的如果勞動部不要有代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/880.wav", + "text": "我也沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/881.wav", + "text": "但是學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/882.wav", + "text": "你過去的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/883.wav", + "text": "跟現在參考日本韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/884.wav", + "text": "韓國就是九九九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/885.wav", + "text": "日本就是六六六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/886.wav", + "text": "六六這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/887.wav", + "text": "專家學者不可能到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/888.wav", + "text": "只剩下7個人嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/889.wav", + "text": "跟國發會的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/890.wav", + "text": "是代表產業界的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/891.wav", + "text": "這個在日本就叫做公益委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/892.wav", + "text": "這個想也知道嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/893.wav", + "text": "他是一側的他代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/894.wav", + "text": "就是跟你有不一樣的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/895.wav", + "text": "邱委員同樣的話不要講45次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/896.wav", + "text": "他這個是錯誤的你應該要譴責他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/897.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/898.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/899.wav", + "text": "講同樣的話你至少要讓人家充分表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/900.wav", + "text": "這是合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/901.wav", + "text": "我覺得第一個事情就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/902.wav", + "text": "你提供的資訊根本是錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/903.wav", + "text": "你這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/904.wav", + "text": "應該有再討論的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/905.wav", + "text": "這不是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/906.wav", + "text": "你這樣唬唬之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/907.wav", + "text": "保留保留之後就柯總召一聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/908.wav", + "text": "令下又60席輾過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/909.wav", + "text": "這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/910.wav", + "text": "這是可以講道理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/911.wav", + "text": "對嗎\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/912.wav", + "text": "你也可以看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/913.wav", + "text": "你不是留學慶應大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/914.wav", + "text": "所以你也可以看嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/915.wav", + "text": "\n基本上這是可以講道理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/916.wav", + "text": "沒有道理學者專家到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/917.wav", + "text": "變成4個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/918.wav", + "text": "你自己勞動部沒有代表就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/919.wav", + "text": "及國發會的代表也算入到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/920.wav", + "text": "學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/921.wav", + "text": "那是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/922.wav", + "text": "現在政府官員就像日本一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/923.wav", + "text": "就像你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/924.wav", + "text": "們自己的報告裡面有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/925.wav", + "text": "政府部門亦未直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/926.wav", + "text": "參與該委員會的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/927.wav", + "text": "但是如果他要列席的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/928.wav", + "text": "日本也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/929.wav", + "text": "我們這邊有找出它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/930.wav", + "text": "它在2023年7月28日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/931.wav", + "text": "勞動基準局的局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/932.wav", + "text": "他要列席大家沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/933.wav", + "text": "對不對但是他不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/934.wav", + "text": "這是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/935.wav", + "text": "賴香伶委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/936.wav", + "text": "比對日本與臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/937.wav", + "text": "我們現在要修法方向的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/938.wav", + "text": "來跟勞動部做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/939.wav", + "text": "但是我相信我們還是要面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/940.wav", + "text": "這個審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/941.wav", + "text": "這種基礎而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/942.wav", + "text": "它還很清楚是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/943.wav", + "text": "雇主必須要接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/944.wav", + "text": "國家訂出來的基本工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/945.wav", + "text": "調漲幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/946.wav", + "text": "並落實如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/947.wav", + "text": "還是會受到很多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/948.wav", + "text": "裁罰或者是權益的剝奪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/949.wav", + "text": "所以這個審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/950.wav", + "text": "的審議權是很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/951.wav", + "text": "的\n基於這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/952.wav", + "text": "前提這個審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/953.wav", + "text": "在現在的基本工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/954.wav", + "text": "審議小組裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/955.wav", + "text": "是沒有擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/956.wav", + "text": "那為什麼在審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/957.wav", + "text": "入法到現在的最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/958.wav", + "text": "之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/959.wav", + "text": "這是第一個大家要爭執和理解的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/960.wav", + "text": "如果可以擴大的話我覺得審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/961.wav", + "text": "擴大到24人左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/962.wav", + "text": "增加勞動部的代表1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/963.wav", + "text": "就可以分擔部長在會上的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/964.wav", + "text": "是我們希望有勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/965.wav", + "text": "代表的原因之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/966.wav", + "text": "這是第一個各家版本我看了都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/967.wav", + "text": "專家學者的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/968.wav", + "text": "因為專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/969.wav", + "text": "現在是4人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/970.wav", + "text": "包括勞方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/971.wav", + "text": "資方代表我認為勞方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/972.wav", + "text": "特別是在資訊和專業上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/973.wav", + "text": "所以學者當然會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/974.wav", + "text": "是更輔助勞方代表做決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/975.wav", + "text": "所以不能夠在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/976.wav", + "text": "就說勞方七資方七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/977.wav", + "text": "好像是均等性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/978.wav", + "text": "反而我覺得學者專家如果七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/979.wav", + "text": "更能夠在大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/980.wav", + "text": "希望的專業度審議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/981.wav", + "text": "把幾個參採指標的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/982.wav", + "text": "專業性以及它的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/983.wav", + "text": "說服各方所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/984.wav", + "text": "學者專家能夠也到七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/985.wav", + "text": "這樣子也讓整個審議的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/986.wav", + "text": "以真正的專業務實性來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/987.wav", + "text": "勞動部不用太堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/988.wav", + "text": "一定要21可以增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/989.wav", + "text": "因為幾乎每一個版本都差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/990.wav", + "text": "所以這裡想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/991.wav", + "text": "各黨團如果沒有太大的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/992.wav", + "text": "我們是不是願意提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/993.wav", + "text": "額度到24人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/994.wav", + "text": "勞動部除勞動部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/995.wav", + "text": "或還有相關比較適合的部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/996.wav", + "text": "也有人這個我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/997.wav", + "text": "現在倒是可以聽聽看部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/998.wav", + "text": "審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/999.wav", + "text": "的重中之重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1000.wav", + "text": "最重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1001.wav", + "text": "剛剛邱顯智委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1002.wav", + "text": "說要不要勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1003.wav", + "text": "代表我不主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1004.wav", + "text": "為什麼到時候還是聽勞動部長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1005.wav", + "text": "最重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1006.wav", + "text": "勞方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1007.wav", + "text": "勞方代表最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1008.wav", + "text": "我不瞞各位說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1009.wav", + "text": "我也在政府機關服務過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1010.wav", + "text": "很多政府聘的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1011.wav", + "text": "專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1012.wav", + "text": "某個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1013.wav", + "text": "他會配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1014.wav", + "text": "政府機關的期望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1015.wav", + "text": "不管是21人或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1016.wav", + "text": "24人我強力主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1017.wav", + "text": "政府機關代表不能太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1018.wav", + "text": "學者OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1019.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1020.wav", + "text": "勞方代表一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1021.wav", + "text": "要讓他某個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1022.wav", + "text": "有機會過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1023.wav", + "text": "這樣才能發揮他該有的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1024.wav", + "text": "政府機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1025.wav", + "text": "像勞動部代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1026.wav", + "text": "聽部長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1027.wav", + "text": "經濟部長經濟部代表也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1028.wav", + "text": "聽部長的國發會也聽部��的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1029.wav", + "text": "這種東西一點功能都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1030.wav", + "text": "所以強力主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1031.wav", + "text": "資方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1032.wav", + "text": "可以降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1033.wav", + "text": "但是勞方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1034.wav", + "text": "要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1035.wav", + "text": "簡單講要在可控制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1036.wav", + "text": "範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1037.wav", + "text": "勞方的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1038.wav", + "text": "至少要平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1039.wav", + "text": "或者要過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1040.wav", + "text": "不然你這個審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1041.wav", + "text": "是假的啦到時候沒辦法執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1042.wav", + "text": "政府機關代表都沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1043.wav", + "text": "都聽部長的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1044.wav", + "text": "你說勞動部的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1045.wav", + "text": "他敢違反部長的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1046.wav", + "text": "嗎那沒用啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1047.wav", + "text": "所以不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1048.wav", + "text": "21人或24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1049.wav", + "text": "人我強烈主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1050.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1051.wav", + "text": "勞方代表至少要9個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1052.wav", + "text": "甚至10個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1053.wav", + "text": "後經濟部不用代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1054.wav", + "text": "某個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1055.wav", + "text": "我是主張勞方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1056.wav", + "text": "要9個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1057.wav", + "text": "經濟部代表不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1058.wav", + "text": "專家學者少1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1059.wav", + "text": "因為政府機關很聰明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1060.wav", + "text": "比較符合政府機關期望的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1061.wav", + "text": "這些專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1062.wav", + "text": "我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1063.wav", + "text": "再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1064.wav", + "text": "經濟部不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1065.wav", + "text": "國發會有1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1066.wav", + "text": "勞方代表9個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1067.wav", + "text": "專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1068.wav", + "text": "可以再少1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1069.wav", + "text": "那就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1070.wav", + "text": "專家學者維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1071.wav", + "text": "不會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1072.wav", + "text": "就是經濟部不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1073.wav", + "text": "嘛這樣還是21個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1074.wav", + "text": "啊增加勞方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1075.wav", + "text": "專家學者少1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1076.wav", + "text": "曾總召您是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1077.wav", + "text": "勞方代表要過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1078.wav", + "text": "增加勞方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1079.wav", + "text": "讓他們某個程度開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1080.wav", + "text": "的時候意見可以過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1081.wav", + "text": "有可能過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1082.wav", + "text": "因為不可能寫到過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1083.wav", + "text": "至少要讓這個委員會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1084.wav", + "text": "勞方的意見能夠充分表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1085.wav", + "text": "開會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1086.wav", + "text": "有機會過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1087.wav", + "text": "有通嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1088.wav", + "text": "有通喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1089.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1090.wav", + "text": "總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1091.wav", + "text": "意思大家都聽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1092.wav", + "text": "差不多10次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1093.wav", + "text": "學者專家這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1094.wav", + "text": "可是大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1095.wav", + "text": "這個法條是第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1096.wav", + "text": "在第十二條有一個研究小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1097.wav", + "text": "研究小組的研究結果還要送給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1098.wav", + "text": "審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1099.wav", + "text": "所以它有不同機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1100.wav", + "text": "我個人的看法就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1101.wav", + "text": "我們不是說日本怎麼樣我們就怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1102.wav", + "text": "各國對於勞資政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1103.wav", + "text": "法體系的面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1104.wav", + "text": "以及現實問題是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1105.wav", + "text": "這樣的話我們以後立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1106.wav", + "text": "就全部抄日本的就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1107.wav", + "text": "日本怎麼樣我們就怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1108.wav", + "text": "我們應該大家理性務實來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1109.wav", + "text": "這邊的差異點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1110.wav", + "text": "顯智委員主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1111.wav", + "text": "學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1112.wav", + "text": "你把他當公益代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1113.wav", + "text": "這邊也是公益代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1114.wav", + "text": "所以並沒有差啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1115.wav", + "text": "就是說這是一個合議制的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1116.wav", + "text": "審議小組向一方傾斜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1117.wav", + "text": "這會有很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1118.wav", + "text": "凡事要顧及平衡性各" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1119.wav", + "text": "各方的意見都要聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1120.wav", + "text": "所以差異點只是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1121.wav", + "text": "那就是21" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1122.wav", + "text": "和25的問題而已邱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1123.wav", + "text": "邱委員應該就只有這樣而已嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1124.wav", + "text": "要理性討論不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1125.wav", + "text": "沒有照這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1126.wav", + "text": "然後以聲量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1127.wav", + "text": "來取勝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1128.wav", + "text": "\n我還是請勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1129.wav", + "text": "大家都好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1130.wav", + "text": "我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1131.wav", + "text": "柯總召剛剛有點誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1132.wav", + "text": "這是勞動部的見解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1133.wav", + "text": "勞動部從頭開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1134.wav", + "text": "我們看到其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1135.wav", + "text": "日本韓國審議會的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1136.wav", + "text": "就是三方機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1137.wav", + "text": "所以這是勞動部的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1138.wav", + "text": "我也支持他這樣的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1139.wav", + "text": "就是等邊三角形嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1140.wav", + "text": "那時候他在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1141.wav", + "text": "黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1142.wav", + "text": "在2023(今)年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1143.wav", + "text": "11月24日的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1144.wav", + "text": "這邊勞動部再多一個代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1145.wav", + "text": "他說如果再多一個代表的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1146.wav", + "text": "變最大了\n他的說法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1147.wav", + "text": "因為參考其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1148.wav", + "text": "政府方就是屬於公益方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1149.wav", + "text": "的區塊這是完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1150.wav", + "text": "錯誤的政府方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1151.wav", + "text": "不是屬於公益方的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1152.wav", + "text": "說法日韓的說法都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1153.wav", + "text": "不是嘛按照你自己的研究計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1154.wav", + "text": "政府公開誰在當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1155.wav", + "text": "他的公益方代表誰在當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1156.wav", + "text": "他的勞方代表誰在當他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1157.wav", + "text": "清清楚楚嘛所以不要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1158.wav", + "text": "騙人\n現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1159.wav", + "text": "到底你要不要按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1160.wav", + "text": "你本來所設計的三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1161.wav", + "text": "機制去設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1162.wav", + "text": "對不對一定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1163.wav", + "text": "天外飛來一筆說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1164.wav", + "text": "我還有一個新的那你有一個新的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1165.wav", + "text": "你要告訴大家耶你要告訴大家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1166.wav", + "text": "你現在就按照什麼樣的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1167.wav", + "text": "都不用參考你就自己發明一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1168.wav", + "text": "也可以只要能夠正當化也OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1169.wav", + "text": "啊如果按照你本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1170.wav", + "text": "的說法就是日本韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1171.wav", + "text": "最低工資法的設計的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1172.wav", + "text": "你這樣沒有道理說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1173.wav", + "text": "你把學者專家只變成4人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1174.wav", + "text": "爭點在這裡嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1175.wav", + "text": "至於其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1176.wav", + "text": "雖然我也是認為如果按照你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1177.wav", + "text": "研究報告的話政府部門是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1178.wav", + "text": "直接參與到該委員會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1179.wav", + "text": "但是他可以列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1180.wav", + "text": "他要列席大家也沒意見嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1181.wav", + "text": "如果你要把他放進去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1182.wav", + "text": "那就是影響現在的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1183.wav", + "text": "但是你至少應該把學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1184.wav", + "text": "調到7人跟資方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1185.wav", + "text": "跟勞方的代表一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1186.wav", + "text": "至少這樣大家還能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1187.wav", + "text": "接受司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1188.wav", + "text": "司長你不能夠都用這種錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1189.wav", + "text": "資訊來誤導大家啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1190.wav", + "text": "接下來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1191.wav", + "text": "請謝衣鳯委員然後曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1192.wav", + "text": "曾總召講完以後我們就請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1193.wav", + "text": "部長來回應一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1194.wav", + "text": "我覺得剛才邱顯智委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1195.wav", + "text": "講得其實有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1196.wav", + "text": "三方審議的模式的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1197.wav", + "text": "或者引用資料的時候應該要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1198.wav", + "text": "所有的委員說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1199.wav", + "text": "完全按照日韓的模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1200.wav", + "text": "我們不一定要完全按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1201.wav", + "text": "日韓的模式但是日韓是怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1202.wav", + "text": "做的至少要跟所有委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1203.wav", + "text": "然後我們再來視情況調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1204.wav", + "text": "我也贊同曾銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1205.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗總召的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1206.wav", + "text": "其實根本在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1207.wav", + "text": "勞動部也不需要代表了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1208.wav", + "text": "我是覺得不需要代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1209.wav", + "text": "因為勞動部長都是主席了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1210.wav", + "text": "在主持的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1211.wav", + "text": "已經可以充分的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1212.wav", + "text": "在這個審議的過程中最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1213.wav", + "text": "要聽各方的意見然後完成一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1214.wav", + "text": "大家對於審議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1215.wav", + "text": "未來的政策裡面能夠實踐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1216.wav", + "text": "想法也就是你們當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1217.wav", + "text": "提三方審議的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1218.wav", + "text": "讓勞動部長可以充分地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1219.wav", + "text": "審議完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1220.wav", + "text": "好曾總召講完就請部長回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1221.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1222.wav", + "text": "建銘兄講的很有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1223.wav", + "text": "這個審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1224.wav", + "text": "必須反映雙方的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1225.wav", + "text": "並達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1226.wav", + "text": "這個法修法才有意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1227.wav", + "text": "也才有它的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1228.wav", + "text": "我覺得偏向資方真的不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1229.wav", + "text": "偏向勞方也不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1230.wav", + "text": "所以我的具體建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1231.wav", + "text": "資方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1232.wav", + "text": "7位加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1233.wav", + "text": "加上國發會就有8位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1234.wav", + "text": "勞動部某個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1235.wav", + "text": "配合政府政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1236.wav", + "text": "所以就變9位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1237.wav", + "text": "勞方9位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1238.wav", + "text": "另外就讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1239.wav", + "text": "這樣的設計都還會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1240.wav", + "text": "偏向資方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1241.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1242.wav", + "text": "會影響決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1243.wav", + "text": "所以勞動部去聘的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1244.wav", + "text": "希望能夠儘量聘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1245.wav", + "text": "比較中性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1246.wav", + "text": "勞動部1個就9人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1247.wav", + "text": "勞方9人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1248.wav", + "text": "因為真的啦其他的條文都不太重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1249.wav", + "text": "這個條文最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1250.wav", + "text": "某種程度也顯示蔡政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1251.wav", + "text": "修最" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1252.wav", + "text": "低工資法到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1253.wav", + "text": "有沒有決心到底是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1254.wav", + "text": "打假球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1255.wav", + "text": "如果審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1256.wav", + "text": "到時候都偏向資方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1257.wav", + "text": "這樣就沒用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1258.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1259.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1260.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1261.wav", + "text": "意見不一會有表決的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1262.wav", + "text": "整個委員人數就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1263.wav", + "text": "必須以基數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1264.wav", + "text": "本來有兩名代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1265.wav", + "text": "我們就決定把勞動部的另外一名代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1266.wav", + "text": "人數變成這樣當初會設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1267.wav", + "text": "基數是因為考慮到後面要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1268.wav", + "text": "麼組成世界主要國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1269.wav", + "text": "基本工資審議委員會的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1270.wav", + "text": "等邊三角形就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1271.wav", + "text": "勞方資方還有第三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1272.wav", + "text": "第三方就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1273.wav", + "text": "公正方所以我們本來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1274.wav", + "text": "資方都7個人沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1275.wav", + "text": "至於當初的公正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1276.wav", + "text": "就包括專家學者跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1277.wav", + "text": "政府方為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1278.wav", + "text": "政府方要放到這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1279.wav", + "text": "之前基本工資審議辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1280.wav", + "text": "訂定的時候也曾經考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1281.wav", + "text": "不然不要有政府方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1282.wav", + "text": "學者可是當時勞方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1283.wav", + "text": "反對他們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1284.wav", + "text": "不能沒有政府的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1285.wav", + "text": "是代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1286.wav", + "text": "他們認為勞動部一定要進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1287.wav", + "text": "角色是不是政府要甩鍋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1288.wav", + "text": "不想為這件事情負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1289.wav", + "text": "政府機關3名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1290.wav", + "text": "當然剛剛邱委員有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1291.wav", + "text": "角色我覺得每個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1292.wav", + "text": "都有他的考量我們通通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1293.wav", + "text": "基本工資審議辦法就有這樣的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1294.wav", + "text": "所以後來把這個放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1295.wav", + "text": "放進去以後其實這幾年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1296.wav", + "text": "運作也都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1297.wav", + "text": "還滿順暢的而且公正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1298.wav", + "text": "都能夠適當地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1299.wav", + "text": "表達出可以讓勞資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1300.wav", + "text": "雙方接受的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1301.wav", + "text": "雙方在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1302.wav", + "text": "就勞資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1303.wav", + "text": "政勞資公正第三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1304.wav", + "text": "這裡面才會有4名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1305.wav", + "text": "勞動部經濟部國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1306.wav", + "text": "因為總體經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1307.wav", + "text": "主要是這三個部會最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1308.wav", + "text": "像邱委員所主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1309.wav", + "text": "專家學者要7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1310.wav", + "text": "4名就會變成11位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1311.wav", + "text": "那這個等邊三角形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1312.wav", + "text": "認為原來這個機制的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1313.wav", + "text": "很順暢而且這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1314.wav", + "text": "其實我們也都跟勞資雙方溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1315.wav", + "text": "他們也認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1316.wav", + "text": "版本謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1317.wav", + "text": "好柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1318.wav", + "text": "第一個剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1319.wav", + "text": "部長講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1320.wav", + "text": "我們要瞭解本來有基本工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1321.wav", + "text": "審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1322.wav", + "text": "未來就走到最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1323.wav", + "text": "工資換言之基本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1324.wav", + "text": "資審議委員會就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1325.wav", + "text": "了架構都是勞資雙方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1326.wav", + "text": "薪資調漲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1327.wav", + "text": "英文總統上來以後調了5次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1328.wav", + "text": "基本工資審議委員會就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1329.wav", + "text": "我們來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1330.wav", + "text": "喔其實立法院最早提出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1331.wav", + "text": "就是坐在我右手邊的吳玉琴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1332.wav", + "text": "委員他在110年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1333.wav", + "text": "度時就提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1334.wav", + "text": "陸續也有8個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1335.wav", + "text": "有8個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1336.wav", + "text": "5月19號排審時才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1337.wav", + "text": "就審不下去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1338.wav", + "text": "行政院院版進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1339.wav", + "text": "大家不要用懷疑的眼光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1340.wav", + "text": "或吃人的眼光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1341.wav", + "text": "或是互相抹黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1342.wav", + "text": "說這是打假球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1343.wav", + "text": "這是何其神聖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1344.wav", + "text": "當然我們也不是殖民立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1345.wav", + "text": "可以參考但不是全部要殖民立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1346.wav", + "text": "各國民情不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1347.wav", + "text": "法律要件不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1348.wav", + "text": "勞動條件也不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1349.wav", + "text": "的既然已經運作這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1350.wav", + "text": "大家應該也充分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1351.wav", + "text": "對這個機制瞭解與肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1352.wav", + "text": "就是把最低工資法立出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1353.wav", + "text": "大家都在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1354.wav", + "text": "嘛趕快讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1355.wav", + "text": "基本工資審議委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1356.wav", + "text": "謝謝剛剛許部長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1357.wav", + "text": "你說這三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1358.wav", + "text": "的設計我贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1359.wav", + "text": "資方勞方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1360.wav", + "text": "另外一方是公正第三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1361.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1362.wav", + "text": "政府機關會是公正第三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1363.wav", + "text": "會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1364.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1365.wav", + "text": "嘛我贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1366.wav", + "text": "但是公正第三方看要怎麼調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1367.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1368.wav", + "text": "我們不是第一天當立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1369.wav", + "text": "也不是做一輩子的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1370.wav", + "text": "政府會是公正第三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1371.wav", + "text": "啊你相信我不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1372.wav", + "text": "啊政府會是公正第三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1373.wav", + "text": "騙好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1374.wav", + "text": "主席謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1375.wav", + "text": "其實真的是要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1376.wav", + "text": "過去的基本工資審議辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1377.wav", + "text": "提升位階" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1378.wav", + "text": "所以工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1379.wav", + "text": "工資的審查不會是第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1380.wav", + "text": "勞資雙方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1381.wav", + "text": "跟學者專家的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1382.wav", + "text": "位階" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1383.wav", + "text": "而它的運作已經算成熟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1384.wav", + "text": "幾乎每年都會審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1385.wav", + "text": "應該很順" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1386.wav", + "text": "因為運作已經這麼久時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1387.wav", + "text": "運作很順" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1388.wav", + "text": "暢所以當行政院提出它的版本的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1389.wav", + "text": "它可能發現一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1390.wav", + "text": "過去它都是由部長擔任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1391.wav", + "text": "召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1392.wav", + "text": "後面的委員是21人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1393.wav", + "text": "然後發現是雙數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1394.wav", + "text": "他們主動把勞動部的代表拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1395.wav", + "text": "讓整個會議的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1396.wav", + "text": "最低工資的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1397.wav", + "text": "可以順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1398.wav", + "text": "因為怕要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1399.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我覺得這不會是一個全新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1400.wav", + "text": "好像還不知道它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1401.wav", + "text": "未來的運作會怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1402.wav", + "text": "它其實是已經運作非常成熟的工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1403.wav", + "text": "我覺得這在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1404.wav", + "text": "在運作上應該沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1405.wav", + "text": "我們在委員會討論的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1406.wav", + "text": "其實我們後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1407.wav", + "text": "也支持行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1408.wav", + "text": "為了讓它能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1409.wav", + "text": "成為單數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1410.wav", + "text": "要不然它現在的運作是22人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1411.wav", + "text": "這是一個很奇怪的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1412.wav", + "text": "針對這個部分我覺得如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1413.wav", + "text": "為它已經是運作很成熟的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1414.wav", + "text": "照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1415.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1416.wav", + "text": "才討論了五條就停下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1417.wav", + "text": "那時候就沒有觸碰到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1418.wav", + "text": "核心關鍵條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1419.wav", + "text": "我覺得今天我們就不需要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1420.wav", + "text": "好像變成時間很緊迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1421.wav", + "text": "但是第二個院版提出來到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1422.wav", + "text": "也沒有多少天其實院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1423.wav", + "text": "如果套用過去的基本工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1424.wav", + "text": "審議小組就不必用什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1425.wav", + "text": "法律位階提升然後強度如何如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1426.wav", + "text": "所以是整個機制已經改變了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1427.wav", + "text": "包括有研究調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1428.wav", + "text": "研究調查之後的資料要公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1429.wav", + "text": "公告之後涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1430.wav", + "text": "最後決策的部分還要再公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1431.wav", + "text": "所以是不同制度不同軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1432.wav", + "text": "不是一樣的東西照本宣科" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1433.wav", + "text": "審議委員會我剛剛已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1434.wav", + "text": "最不濟動用到投票的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1435.wav", + "text": "七七七這件事情還是社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1436.wav", + "text": "比較能夠相信的也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1437.wav", + "text": "什麼意識來主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1438.wav", + "text": "更客觀的提供勞資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1439.wav", + "text": "和公益三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1440.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會想出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1441.wav", + "text": "讓它七七七的設計機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1442.wav", + "text": "這個我相信部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1443.wav", + "text": "你們應該也瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1444.wav", + "text": "跟勞團討論大家也不會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1445.wav", + "text": "七七七這件事情是可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1446.wav", + "text": "的至於勞動部經濟部國發會代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1447.wav", + "text": "或部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1448.wav", + "text": "在裡面的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1449.wav", + "text": "其實我們如果透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1450.wav", + "text": "你們怎麼樣投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1451.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣做一定的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1452.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得從善如流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1453.wav", + "text": "還是讓基本工資審議小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1454.wav", + "text": "提升位階之後的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1455.wav", + "text": "去審定審議資格的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1456.wav", + "text": "不要被架空" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1457.wav", + "text": "不要被架空就要取信於社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1458.wav", + "text": "如果現在七七七這三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1459.wav", + "text": "這樣是比較可以讓社會理解的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1460.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個修法方向是值得大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1461.wav", + "text": "支持的好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1462.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1463.wav", + "text": "事實上也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1464.wav", + "text": "就不會被算入第三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1465.wav", + "text": "到底其他國家有哪一國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1466.wav", + "text": "是這樣做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1467.wav", + "text": "其實從頭到尾勞動部的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1468.wav", + "text": "都是在參考日本和韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1469.wav", + "text": "你們也去做一些研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1470.wav", + "text": "包括南韓的最低工資委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1471.wav", + "text": "還有日本的也都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1472.wav", + "text": "政府部門未直接參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1473.wav", + "text": "該委員會的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1474.wav", + "text": "所以才會說這是一個等邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1475.wav", + "text": "三角形也就是勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1476.wav", + "text": "的公益方都非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1477.wav", + "text": "資方都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1478.wav", + "text": "並且都是由學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1479.wav", + "text": "這是很清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1480.wav", + "text": "因為本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1481.wav", + "text": "部長要當主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1482.wav", + "text": "還加了一個勞動部代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1483.wav", + "text": "1人的話也就是勞動部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1484.wav", + "text": "和勞動部的代表總共2人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1485.wav", + "text": "再加上比較偏產業的經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1486.wav", + "text": "和國發會他們也有2人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1487.wav", + "text": "這樣的話剛好就是可以有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1488.wav", + "text": "等邊三角形的架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1489.wav", + "text": "否則的話你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1490.wav", + "text": "基本上我認為是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1491.wav", + "text": "你打破了本來的等邊三角形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1492.wav", + "text": "只有4人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1493.wav", + "text": "機關代表是公益的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1494.wav", + "text": "就算你當主席好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1495.wav", + "text": "你也只有1位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1496.wav", + "text": "經濟部的代表跟國發會的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1497.wav", + "text": "又有2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1498.wav", + "text": "在日韓的機制裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1499.wav", + "text": "你又獨創了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1500.wav", + "text": "獨步全球的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1501.wav", + "text": "假設你要獨步全球的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1502.wav", + "text": "你也要告訴大家你的正當性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1503.wav", + "text": "基礎何在看不出來呀\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1504.wav", + "text": "所以我才會講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1505.wav", + "text": "我們的機制也設想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1506.wav", + "text": "這個是一個奇數就是25人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1507.wav", + "text": "勞動部部長當主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1508.wav", + "text": "有1個經濟部跟國發會的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1509.wav", + "text": "剩下的就是等邊三角形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1510.wav", + "text": "這個應該是一個比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1511.wav", + "text": "狀況而勞資雙方應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1512.wav", + "text": "否則的話你現在這個算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1513.wav", + "text": "很明顯地一定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1514.wav", + "text": "往產業這方面去傾斜\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1515.wav", + "text": "而且在法制度上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1516.wav", + "text": "不是說獨步全球不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1517.wav", + "text": "真的要獨步全球的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1518.wav", + "text": "就要非常地充分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1519.wav", + "text": "而不是輕巧一句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1520.wav", + "text": "政府機關的代表就是公益代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1521.wav", + "text": "不是呀就顯然不是你的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1522.wav", + "text": "當然也不是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1523.wav", + "text": "\n日本的狀況會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1524.wav", + "text": "會不會有官員當然會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1525.wav", + "text": "它開會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1526.wav", + "text": "一大堆的官員都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1527.wav", + "text": "就像你的研究報告說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1528.wav", + "text": "政府的官員並沒有直接參與到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1529.wav", + "text": "這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1530.wav", + "text": "當然就是能夠���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1531.wav", + "text": "整個呈現出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1532.wav", + "text": "而且勞資雙方本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1533.wav", + "text": "一直在角力的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1534.wav", + "text": "讓學者專家提出專業的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1535.wav", + "text": "學者專家分別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1536.wav", + "text": "專業包括經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1537.wav", + "text": "學的專業包括法學的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1538.wav", + "text": "包括勞動的專業等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1539.wav", + "text": "之類的這樣才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1540.wav", + "text": "把本來比較多元的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1541.wav", + "text": "的時候牽扯到多大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1542.wav", + "text": "\n所以這個是一個很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1543.wav", + "text": "茲事體大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1544.wav", + "text": "如果你的設計基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1545.wav", + "text": "是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1546.wav", + "text": "非常非常危險的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1547.wav", + "text": "語重心長覺得你應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1548.wav", + "text": "只是勞動部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1549.wav", + "text": "當主席的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1550.wav", + "text": "要把產業跟勞動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1551.wav", + "text": "予以兼顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1552.wav", + "text": "我們下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1553.wav", + "text": "已經開了90分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1554.wav", + "text": "現在一事無成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1555.wav", + "text": "看怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1556.wav", + "text": "是不是如果意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1557.wav", + "text": "意見沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1558.wav", + "text": "沒有等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1559.wav", + "text": "我先回應一下我剛剛所聽的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1560.wav", + "text": "所謂獨步全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1561.wav", + "text": "只有日韓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1562.wav", + "text": "兩個制度是全球化嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1563.wav", + "text": "它的制度是獨步全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1564.wav", + "text": "沒有錯啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1565.wav", + "text": "我們為什麼是立法殖民地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1566.wav", + "text": "不是立法殖民地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1567.wav", + "text": "是他自己就是這樣主張啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1568.wav", + "text": "我就跟你說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1569.wav", + "text": "他從頭到尾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1570.wav", + "text": "不是他從頭到尾的主張就是這樣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1571.wav", + "text": "你講話我都靜靜聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1572.wav", + "text": "我現在講話你都插話這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1573.wav", + "text": "我是跟你討論他的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1574.wav", + "text": "因為你沒有參與到委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1575.wav", + "text": "講第一個事情是他在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1576.wav", + "text": "這個說���就是錯誤的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1577.wav", + "text": "次長你自己講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1578.wav", + "text": "等一下等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1579.wav", + "text": "你不能用錯誤的資訊在誤導大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1580.wav", + "text": "說三四遍都說都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1581.wav", + "text": "你等我講完你再講好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1582.wav", + "text": "這樣總可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1583.wav", + "text": "第一個我們來說文解字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1584.wav", + "text": "什麼叫獨步全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1585.wav", + "text": "他說我們和日韓不一樣就是獨步全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1586.wav", + "text": "全球都是日韓體制嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1587.wav", + "text": "不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1588.wav", + "text": "嘛每個國家都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1589.wav", + "text": "是可以辯證的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1590.wav", + "text": "你從反向來辯證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1591.wav", + "text": "你說這個非常危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1592.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1593.wav", + "text": "因為你現在把學者專家變成7個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1594.wav", + "text": "你找來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1595.wav", + "text": "你上面還有3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1596.wav", + "text": "你就傾斜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1597.wav", + "text": "因為這個運作很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1598.wav", + "text": "這是大家一體兩面的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1599.wav", + "text": "所有的正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1600.wav", + "text": "所有邏輯法理都是可以辯證的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1601.wav", + "text": "沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1602.wav", + "text": "你講的才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1603.wav", + "text": "所以沒有所謂獨步全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1604.wav", + "text": "他有去參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1605.wav", + "text": "你這樣參考也是抄他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1606.wav", + "text": "我要再講我們不是立法殖民地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1607.wav", + "text": "每個國情都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1608.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1609.wav", + "text": "第二點你所謂的危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1610.wav", + "text": "你這樣的設計也是危險的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1611.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1612.wav", + "text": "大家要講清楚喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1613.wav", + "text": "第三個我要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1614.wav", + "text": "要讓我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1615.wav", + "text": "以前是審議委員會然後再改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1616.wav", + "text": "然後又少一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1617.wav", + "text": "但是請看第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1618.wav", + "text": "剛才賴香伶委員有談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1619.wav", + "text": "大家看第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1620.wav", + "text": "第十二條有研究小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1621.wav", + "text": "裡面有審議委員4個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1622.wav", + "text": "學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1623.wav", + "text": "他們每4個月要向審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1624.wav", + "text": "之影響報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1625.wav", + "text": "然後審議委員會開會3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1626.wav", + "text": "30天前要把資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1627.wav", + "text": "送給審議委員就是這個研究小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1628.wav", + "text": "所以我們有不同的機制設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1629.wav", + "text": "國家穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1630.wav", + "text": "這是無可厚非的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1631.wav", + "text": "勞動部代表當然無可厚非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1632.wav", + "text": "難道我們要把國家公權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1633.wav", + "text": "誰要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1634.wav", + "text": "這是很慎重的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1635.wav", + "text": "我希望你聽人家講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1636.wav", + "text": "當然你可以不同意我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1637.wav", + "text": "你可以不同意我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1638.wav", + "text": "以上是我基本的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1639.wav", + "text": "好院長我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1640.wav", + "text": "為什麼我會說獨步全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1641.wav", + "text": "是因為勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1642.wav", + "text": "司長怎麼說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1643.wav", + "text": "我們是參考其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1644.wav", + "text": "大概在處理這部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1645.wav", + "text": "政府大概是屬於公益方的區塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1646.wav", + "text": "三方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1647.wav", + "text": "人數相等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1648.wav", + "text": "部長說公正方就會包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1649.wav", + "text": "政府代表機關和學者專家代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1650.wav", + "text": "跟學者專家就是代表公益方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1651.wav", + "text": "日本韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1652.wav", + "text": "我就跟你講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1653.wav", + "text": "不是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1654.wav", + "text": "\n日本韓國人家的公益方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1655.wav", + "text": "都是專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1656.wav", + "text": "所以我才會說你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1657.wav", + "text": "這個版本是獨步全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1658.wav", + "text": "柯總召根本完全都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1659.wav", + "text": "部長跟司長在幹嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1660.wav", + "text": "都是錯誤的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1661.wav", + "text": "他提出的是錯誤的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1662.wav", + "text": "我才會說他這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1663.wav", + "text": "是獨步全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1664.wav", + "text": "因為他的說法是認為他要學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1665.wav", + "text": "日本跟韓國嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1666.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1667.wav", + "text": "要獨步���球的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1668.wav", + "text": "就是你的制度要有一個正當性基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1669.wav", + "text": "你的正當性基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1670.wav", + "text": "完全看不出來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1671.wav", + "text": "這才是一個非常大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1672.wav", + "text": "如果你要當主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1673.wav", + "text": "你要有國發會代表經濟部代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1674.wav", + "text": "你就再加一個勞動部的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1675.wav", + "text": "你就是22" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1676.wav", + "text": "資方跟專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1677.wav", + "text": "那是不是就可以讓你是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1678.wav", + "text": "等邊三角形的架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1679.wav", + "text": "對啊你的制度也是要有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1680.wav", + "text": "根據所在嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1681.wav", + "text": "隨便輕巧一句講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1682.wav", + "text": "這個政府方代表就是公正方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1683.wav", + "text": "你要這樣掩蓋過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1684.wav", + "text": "事實上是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1685.wav", + "text": "我要告訴你的就是你這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1686.wav", + "text": "機制弄出來之後是獨步全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1687.wav", + "text": "但是這個獨步全球的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1688.wav", + "text": "機制運作下去未來會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1689.wav", + "text": "有風險當然有風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1690.wav", + "text": "因為比較法上面從來沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1691.wav", + "text": "一個機制像你這樣子啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1692.wav", + "text": "好謝謝大家因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1693.wav", + "text": "這麼久沒有共識所以本案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1694.wav", + "text": "第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1695.wav", + "text": "什麼意見沒有意見我們就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1696.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1697.wav", + "text": "主席不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1698.wav", + "text": "年度調整幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1699.wav", + "text": "不得低於消費者物價指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1700.wav", + "text": "年增率的漲幅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1701.wav", + "text": "也不得低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1702.wav", + "text": "前一年的最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1703.wav", + "text": "這當然是必然之理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1704.wav", + "text": "其實跟院版的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1705.wav", + "text": "採應參採當然就是可以參採也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1706.wav", + "text": "可以不參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1707.wav", + "text": "物價指數應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1708.wav", + "text": "可以連結在一起這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1709.wav", + "text": "弱勢勞工的購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1710.wav", + "text": "這個到底意義何在\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1711.wav", + "text": "其實比較法上面也有把CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1712.wav", + "text": "年���率當成最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1713.wav", + "text": "最低標準的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1714.wav", + "text": "譬如像法國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1715.wav", + "text": "就明確將最低工資跟物價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1716.wav", + "text": "上漲的幅度相互" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1717.wav", + "text": "有把CPI列為應參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1718.wav", + "text": "指標但是基本上是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1719.wav", + "text": "部分應該要有一個拘束力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1720.wav", + "text": "最低工資獲得保障還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1721.wav", + "text": "跟CPI可以相連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1722.wav", + "text": "院長與會同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1723.wav", + "text": "我們其實也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1724.wav", + "text": "目前的條文裡面僅參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1725.wav", + "text": "CPI年增率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1726.wav", + "text": "及勞工的基本生活權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1727.wav", + "text": "CPI指數是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1728.wav", + "text": "勞工的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1729.wav", + "text": "不得低於CPI年增率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1730.wav", + "text": "而不只是參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1731.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1732.wav", + "text": "也希望不能夠低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1733.wav", + "text": "前一年的最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1734.wav", + "text": "以上好還有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1735.wav", + "text": "請賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1736.wav", + "text": "回到整個最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1737.wav", + "text": "的核心也就是所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1738.wav", + "text": "最後的年增幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1739.wav", + "text": "怎麼訂定出來關於參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1740.wav", + "text": "指標的應與得當時大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1741.wav", + "text": "的爭執就是為什麼只有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1742.wav", + "text": "應作為參採的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1743.wav", + "text": "實在是過於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1744.wav", + "text": "賭在以CPI為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1745.wav", + "text": "成本之間的連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1746.wav", + "text": "有些反映不出來至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1747.wav", + "text": "得參採的部分勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1748.wav", + "text": "列了10項我看各個委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1749.wav", + "text": "也都有多了12項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1750.wav", + "text": "不一樣的部分所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1751.wav", + "text": "能夠再增加一些指標讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1752.wav", + "text": "學者專家勞方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1753.wav", + "text": "資方在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1754.wav", + "text": "指標之間的連動性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1755.wav", + "text": "是比較周延性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1756.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1757.wav", + "text": "既然只是得參採為什麼在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1758.wav", + "text": "項目上面只有那麼少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1759.wav", + "text": "之前我有跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1760.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得看起來大家對於這個部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1761.wav", + "text": "要不要限定不得低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1762.wav", + "text": "消費者物價指數年增率漲幅且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1763.wav", + "text": "不得低於前一年最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1764.wav", + "text": "其實很多的版本也都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1765.wav", + "text": "難道年年漲上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1766.wav", + "text": "會不會有情勢變更經濟狀況不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1767.wav", + "text": "的時候要有一些彈性空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1768.wav", + "text": "已經只有一項叫作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1769.wav", + "text": "應參採大家也瞭解你們的內容的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1770.wav", + "text": "至於得的部分我真的覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1771.wav", + "text": "希望可以多增加一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1772.wav", + "text": "項目再來是沒有公式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1773.wav", + "text": "基本工資審議辦法大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1774.wav", + "text": "目前完全不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1775.wav", + "text": "參採這麼多指標之後公式到底是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1776.wav", + "text": "二分之一的CPI加三分之一的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1777.wav", + "text": "平均年增率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1778.wav", + "text": "還是GDP的各種參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1779.wav", + "text": "這個都沒有內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1780.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1781.wav", + "text": "希望能夠滾動式來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1782.wav", + "text": "面對什麼是應參採及得參採\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1783.wav", + "text": "以及未來如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1784.wav", + "text": "經濟情勢有一些不一樣的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1785.wav", + "text": "我們如何來修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1786.wav", + "text": "作為保障最低生活收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1787.wav", + "text": "跟勞工及其受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1788.wav", + "text": "撫養者的最低生活薪資的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1789.wav", + "text": "這個法最核心的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1790.wav", + "text": "我們黨團版本的第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1791.wav", + "text": "這部分的參採指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1792.wav", + "text": "以及不得低於前一年最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1793.wav", + "text": "的部分還是能夠入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1794.wav", + "text": "讓國人對於這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1795.wav", + "text": "是有期待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1796.wav", + "text": "我首先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1797.wav", + "text": "要跟勞動部部長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1798.wav", + "text": "也跟所有的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1799.wav", + "text": "代表說明我們的名稱叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1800.wav", + "text": "最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1801.wav", + "text": "所謂最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1802.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1803.wav", + "text": "保障名目的最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1804.wav", + "text": "不是保障他們名目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1805.wav", + "text": "啦名目沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1806.wav", + "text": "要保障的是他的實質薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1807.wav", + "text": "他真正的購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1808.wav", + "text": "嘛這才有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1809.wav", + "text": "啊不然物價一直上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1810.wav", + "text": "漲一直上漲前一陣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1811.wav", + "text": "央行總裁在財委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1812.wav", + "text": "也承認過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1813.wav", + "text": "臺灣的低物價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1814.wav", + "text": "未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1815.wav", + "text": "2%左右會是常態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1816.wav", + "text": "主計長也承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1817.wav", + "text": "了你假設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1818.wav", + "text": "定個最低工資法是保障他的名目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1819.wav", + "text": "那沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1820.wav", + "text": "啊物價一直漲一直漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1821.wav", + "text": "便當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1822.wav", + "text": "本來50塊現在100塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1823.wav", + "text": "蚵仔煎本來一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1824.wav", + "text": "30塊現在70塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1825.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1826.wav", + "text": "要定最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1827.wav", + "text": "它的政策意義是要保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1828.wav", + "text": "勞工的實質購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1829.wav", + "text": "能夠維持他的最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1830.wav", + "text": "生活水平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1831.wav", + "text": "啊而且現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1832.wav", + "text": "行政院版的第9條還有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1833.wav", + "text": "第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1834.wav", + "text": "最低工資審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1835.wav", + "text": "應參採消費者物價指數年增率擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1836.wav", + "text": "率擬訂調整幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1837.wav", + "text": "這是第1項第2項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1838.wav", + "text": "的第6款又講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1839.wav", + "text": "民生物價及生產者物價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1840.wav", + "text": "變動情況這兩個又有重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1841.wav", + "text": "只是定義不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1842.wav", + "text": "所以我是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1843.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1844.wav", + "text": "是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1845.wav", + "text": "每一年的調幅不得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1846.wav", + "text": "低於CPI為什麼是CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1847.wav", + "text": "就是實質購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1848.wav", + "text": "嘛像最近幾年就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1849.wav", + "text": "啊你的薪資是負的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1850.wav", + "text": "定也是白定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1851.wav", + "text": "所以這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1852.wav", + "text": "也是重中之重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1853.wav", + "text": "我們一直強烈主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1854.wav", + "text": "必須不得低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1855.wav", + "text": "\n跟各位報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1856.wav", + "text": "這不完全是勞動部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1857.wav", + "text": "其實現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1858.wav", + "text": "連上市上櫃公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1859.wav", + "text": "一年賺一個資本額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1860.wav", + "text": "甚至兩個資本額的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1861.wav", + "text": "這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1862.wav", + "text": "上市上櫃公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1863.wav", + "text": "很多都還低薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1864.wav", + "text": "那你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1865.wav", + "text": "股價漲的老闆拿去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1866.wav", + "text": "你一年賺一個資本額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1867.wav", + "text": "也不願意拿錢出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1868.wav", + "text": "分給勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1869.wav", + "text": "這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1870.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1871.wav", + "text": "最低工資法等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1872.wav", + "text": "還是用租稅手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1873.wav", + "text": "或者我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1874.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1875.wav", + "text": "證交法讓上市上櫃公司的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1876.wav", + "text": "薪資透明化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1877.wav", + "text": "這個都是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1878.wav", + "text": "啊這是我們國民黨的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1879.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1880.wav", + "text": "主席各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1881.wav", + "text": "我想針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1882.wav", + "text": "剛才幾位的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1883.wav", + "text": "行政院版本和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1884.wav", + "text": "其他在野黨版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1885.wav", + "text": "不一樣的地方就是應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1886.wav", + "text": "消費者物價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1887.wav", + "text": "指數年增率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1888.wav", + "text": "在野黨版本是寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1889.wav", + "text": "每年度的調整不得低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1890.wav", + "text": "消費者物價指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1891.wav", + "text": "且不得低於前年最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1892.wav", + "text": "這點我想應該是很確定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1893.wav", + "text": "就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1894.wav", + "text": "往上調吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1895.wav", + "text": "大家也不要有這樣的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1896.wav", + "text": "至於賴香伶委員所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1897.wav", + "text": "要公式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1898.wav", + "text": "你自己也沒有提公式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1899.wav", + "text": "你想要有一個公式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1900.wav", + "text": "式但公式很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1901.wav", + "text": "但是這個版本也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1902.wav", + "text": "\n現在就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1903.wav", + "text": "說得參採的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1904.wav", + "text": "第十一款第十二款而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1905.wav", + "text": "增加一款租金年增率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1906.wav", + "text": "等住宿成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1907.wav", + "text": "賴香伶委員提的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1908.wav", + "text": "事實上談到租金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1909.wav", + "text": "內政部也有一個租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1910.wav", + "text": "現在我們是用所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1911.wav", + "text": "稅扣抵額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1912.wav", + "text": "特扣的部分也有把租金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1913.wav", + "text": "放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1914.wav", + "text": "所以不同的政策工具都有在處理這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1915.wav", + "text": "我相信勞動部也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1916.wav", + "text": "應該都有考慮清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1917.wav", + "text": "基本上我當然認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1918.wav", + "text": "行政版本應該相當完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1919.wav", + "text": "跟主席各位委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1920.wav", + "text": "我想自從有基本工資審議以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1921.wav", + "text": "從來沒有發生這種情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1922.wav", + "text": "從來沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1923.wav", + "text": "未來的最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1924.wav", + "text": "是讓它的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1925.wav", + "text": "更不會發生這種情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1926.wav", + "text": "所以我認為大家可以不用擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1927.wav", + "text": "這個第二個是不是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1928.wav", + "text": "跟CPI綁定在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1929.wav", + "text": "也就是調幅一定不得低於CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1930.wav", + "text": "我跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1931.wav", + "text": "現在適用基本最低工資的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1932.wav", + "text": "除了剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1933.wav", + "text": "邱委員講的第一個就是法國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1934.wav", + "text": "還有曾經讓法國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1935.wav", + "text": "這兩個有跟CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1936.wav", + "text": "綁定在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1937.wav", + "text": "其他的主要國家沒有為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1938.wav", + "text": "因為如果沒辦法斟酌其他的指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1939.wav", + "text": "還有社會經濟情勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1940.wav", + "text": "\n我跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1941.wav", + "text": "我們在2009年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1942.wav", + "text": "民國97年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1943.wav", + "text": "金融海嘯的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1944.wav", + "text": "我們那一年的CPI是3.54" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1945.wav", + "text": "因為金融海嘯而裁員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1946.wav", + "text": "失業的人很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1947.wav", + "text": "23萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1948.wav", + "text": "連一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1949.wav", + "text": "的CPI都不能調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1950.wav", + "text": "最後會受影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1951.wav", + "text": "因為我們最低工資適用的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1952.wav", + "text": "邊際勞工最弱勢的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1953.wav", + "text": "斟酌還是要有一些彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1954.wav", + "text": "關係到他的購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1955.wav", + "text": "但是整體的社經情勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1956.wav", + "text": "只有列一個CPI因為勞資雙方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1957.wav", + "text": "有共識它是應參採指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1958.wav", + "text": "但是其他部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1959.wav", + "text": "大家沒有共識要提升到應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1960.wav", + "text": "用得的方式讓大家能有多一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1961.wav", + "text": "參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1962.wav", + "text": "\n公式的部分現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1963.wav", + "text": "適用的最低工資也都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1964.wav", + "text": "明定計算公式我們認為還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1965.wav", + "text": "基本工資審議委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1966.wav", + "text": "會的委員能審酌各個指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1967.wav", + "text": "會比較有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1968.wav", + "text": "真正照顧到勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1969.wav", + "text": "指標為什麼沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1970.wav", + "text": "或時力所認為的將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1971.wav", + "text": "租金放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1972.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告因為我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1973.wav", + "text": "年增率CPI已經包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1974.wav", + "text": "食衣住行育樂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1975.wav", + "text": "指數都已經在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1976.wav", + "text": "就會有重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1977.wav", + "text": "認列的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1978.wav", + "text": "所以原來的CPI就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1979.wav", + "text": "含括到租金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1980.wav", + "text": "以上說明謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1981.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1982.wav", + "text": "剛剛許部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1983.wav", + "text": "回答得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1984.wav", + "text": "不過你說的是例外情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1985.wav", + "text": "部長曉不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1986.wav", + "text": "歷年來金融海嘯發生過幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1987.wav", + "text": "恐怕你後面的人也沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1988.wav", + "text": "答復我的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1989.wav", + "text": "你不能用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1990.wav", + "text": "極度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1991.wav", + "text": "非常特殊的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1992.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1993.wav", + "text": "第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1994.wav", + "text": "部長你是勞動部的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1995.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講的話應該是經濟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1996.wav", + "text": "講的話你要站在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1997.wav", + "text": "勞工的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1998.wav", + "text": "訂定最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/1999.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講的話應該請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2000.wav", + "text": "經濟部長來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2001.wav", + "text": "不應該是你的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2002.wav", + "text": "讓它訂定進去啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2003.wav", + "text": "你不能用金融海嘯來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2004.wav", + "text": "金融海嘯當然會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2005.wav", + "text": "以後也會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2006.wav", + "text": "只是多久才會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2007.wav", + "text": "一次你用極為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2008.wav", + "text": "極端少數的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2009.wav", + "text": "去否決一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2010.wav", + "text": "可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2011.wav", + "text": "方案何況你剛剛自己講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2012.wav", + "text": "歐洲也有訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2013.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2014.wav", + "text": "還是贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2015.wav", + "text": "啦這個最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2016.wav", + "text": "不能只是一個名目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2017.wav", + "text": "你要保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2018.wav", + "text": "實質購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2019.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2020.wav", + "text": "邱總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2021.wav", + "text": "再沒有共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2022.wav", + "text": "我們就保留部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2023.wav", + "text": "這個問題應該說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2024.wav", + "text": "是實質購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2025.wav", + "text": "因為這叫作最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2026.wav", + "text": "現在這個是最基層的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2027.wav", + "text": "勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2028.wav", + "text": "飛漲的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2029.wav", + "text": "讓他的實質購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2030.wav", + "text": "以便他可以繼續的生活下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2031.wav", + "text": "嘛所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2032.wav", + "text": "應該是從這個角度出發因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2033.wav", + "text": "物價飛漲已經到5%了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2034.wav", + "text": "基本工資只有漲1%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2035.wav", + "text": "而已如果按照這樣的規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2036.wav", + "text": "他的實質購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2037.wav", + "text": "是倒退的他要怎麼生活下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2038.wav", + "text": "應該是站在這樣的一個角度嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2039.wav", + "text": "所以其實很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2040.wav", + "text": "你看第7條只願意接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2041.wav", + "text": "學者專家只有4個名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2042.wav", + "text": "嚴重壓縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2043.wav", + "text": "評估小組的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2044.wav", + "text": "願不願意在審議會前公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2045.wav", + "text": "然後在這個審議的指標上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2046.wav", + "text": "只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2047.wav", + "text": "訂定一個參採的指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2048.wav", + "text": "其實你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2049.wav", + "text": "如果把它跟CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2050.wav", + "text": "連動起來的話它只是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2051.wav", + "text": "樓地板它不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2052.wav", + "text": "一定到多大的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2053.wav", + "text": "只是一個最低的保障嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2054.wav", + "text": "所以這怎麼會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2055.wav", + "text": "因為這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2056.wav", + "text": "會影響到最後他會被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2057.wav", + "text": "解僱等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2058.wav", + "text": "而且你的舉例基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2059.wav", + "text": "都是在一個非常極端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2060.wav", + "text": "現在要問的是通膨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2061.wav", + "text": "如果是一個常態的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2062.wav", + "text": "那通膨本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2063.wav", + "text": "就應該可以反映到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2064.wav", + "text": "基本工資不會調低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2065.wav", + "text": "審議的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2066.wav", + "text": "但是法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2067.wav", + "text": "法就是基於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2068.wav", + "text": "不相信權力的擁有者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2069.wav", + "text": "我們不知道未來的權力擁有者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2070.wav", + "text": "是誰所以相信大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2071.wav", + "text": "也不會反對我們把它明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2072.wav", + "text": "入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2073.wav", + "text": "有一個基本的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2074.wav", + "text": "相信大家應該不會反對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2075.wav", + "text": "這個還是一樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2076.wav", + "text": "等一下看部長你有沒有要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2077.wav", + "text": "我們現在在辯證的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2078.wav", + "text": "甲說乙說的問題啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2079.wav", + "text": "我從甲說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2080.wav", + "text": "但是最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2081.wav", + "text": "剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2082.wav", + "text": "邱顯智委員講的一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2083.wav", + "text": "權力的擁有者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2084.wav", + "text": "他不敢濫用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2085.wav", + "text": "權力啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2086.wav", + "text": "這裡面還有研究小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2087.wav", + "text": "還有學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2088.wav", + "text": "勞動部絕對是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2089.wav", + "text": "以及他的購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2090.wav", + "text": "這方面來著眼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2091.wav", + "text": "所以這是大家的角度觀點不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2092.wav", + "text": "因為參採的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2093.wav", + "text": "嘛假如能夠訂出公式當然最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2094.wav", + "text": "事實上不可能嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2095.wav", + "text": "這是不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2096.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得大家不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2097.wav", + "text": "互相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2098.wav", + "text": "否定啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2099.wav", + "text": "應該是比較寬廣的立場來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2100.wav", + "text": "這只是甲說乙說從不同的角度來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2101.wav", + "text": "但最後的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2102.wav", + "text": "權力擁有者絕對不可能濫用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2103.wav", + "text": "是站在勞工的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2104.wav", + "text": "都會考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2105.wav", + "text": "真正的差異點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2106.wav", + "text": "還有剩下就是剛才我講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2107.wav", + "text": "有關租金這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2108.wav", + "text": "個有不同的政策在處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2109.wav", + "text": "嘛假如真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2110.wav", + "text": "沒有共識的話請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2111.wav", + "text": "院長我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2112.wav", + "text": "你講很多換我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2113.wav", + "text": "其實我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2114.wav", + "text": "如果在一個重大的世界金融風暴的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2115.wav", + "text": "政府或者是立法部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2116.wav", + "text": "都會提出相關因應的特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2117.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛許部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2118.wav", + "text": "以金融風暴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2119.wav", + "text": "來作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2120.wav", + "text": "不應該參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2121.wav", + "text": "不一定要有一個實際的公式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2122.wav", + "text": "但是必須要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2123.wav", + "text": "勞工的實際購買力能夠參酌進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2124.wav", + "text": "才是我們訂最低基本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2125.wav", + "text": "工資的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2126.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我覺得不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2127.wav", + "text": "���用金融風暴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2128.wav", + "text": "因為金融風暴就像COVID-19一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2129.wav", + "text": "我們都會有一個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2130.wav", + "text": "來協助國內的產業以及協助勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2131.wav", + "text": "那怎麼樣在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2132.wav", + "text": "基本公式的時候表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2133.wav", + "text": "購買力這樣子的一個保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2134.wav", + "text": "我覺得這才是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2135.wav", + "text": "在立法的時候必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2136.wav", + "text": "著重的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2137.wav", + "text": "院長我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2138.wav", + "text": "剛才柯總召講說權力的擁有者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2139.wav", + "text": "不會濫用權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2140.wav", + "text": "臺灣的歷史有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2141.wav", + "text": "權力的擁有者濫用權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2142.wav", + "text": "所以我們等一下才要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2143.wav", + "text": "因此就是要透過法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2144.wav", + "text": "把這些權力的擁有者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2145.wav", + "text": "而院版的問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2146.wav", + "text": "它只是一個參採的指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2147.wav", + "text": "個最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2148.wav", + "text": "前一年的最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2149.wav", + "text": "這樣未來才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2150.wav", + "text": "怎麼想我們不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2151.wav", + "text": "嘛所以要透過法透過法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2152.wav", + "text": "不然未來你會遇到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2153.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的狀況沒有人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2154.wav", + "text": "我講一分鐘就好邱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2155.wav", + "text": "委員政治檔案法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2156.wav", + "text": "不是等一下要審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2157.wav", + "text": "大家已經簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2158.wav", + "text": "你自己都簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2159.wav", + "text": "政治檔案法是講轉型正義語意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2160.wav", + "text": "不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2161.wav", + "text": "不一樣的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2162.wav", + "text": "是一樣的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2163.wav", + "text": "啊就是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2164.wav", + "text": "過去有太多的濫用權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2165.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨威權統治的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2166.wav", + "text": "濫用權力導致迫害人民的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2167.wav", + "text": "所以你不能這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2168.wav", + "text": "講我們才說要用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2169.wav", + "text": "民主時代也是要討論法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2170.wav", + "text": "不然的話立法院就要廢除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2171.wav", + "text": "了不然就不要立法院了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2172.wav", + "text": "你就期待一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2173.wav", + "text": "這是什麼樣的權威思想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2174.wav", + "text": "我是真的建議柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2175.wav", + "text": "你不要用權力的這個部分一再重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2176.wav", + "text": "因為這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2177.wav", + "text": "我們的賴副總統跟蔡總統說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2178.wav", + "text": "最低工資要達三萬有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2179.wav", + "text": "沒有啊為什麼漲不上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2180.wav", + "text": "經濟成長率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2181.wav", + "text": "換算到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2182.wav", + "text": "但過去就是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2183.wav", + "text": "第一是沒有公式第二是沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2184.wav", + "text": "將參採指標公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2185.wav", + "text": "所以今天才透過法的重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2186.wav", + "text": "重做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2187.wav", + "text": "那把不能低於前一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2188.wav", + "text": "CPI的這件事情入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2189.wav", + "text": "其實是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2190.wav", + "text": "因為它是研究報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2191.wav", + "text": "所提出來的所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2192.wav", + "text": "\n所以我建議勞動部第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2193.wav", + "text": "一個大部分的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2194.wav", + "text": "都是把不能低於CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2195.wav", + "text": "漲幅作為一個前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2196.wav", + "text": "後面的公式部分我看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2197.wav", + "text": "包括民進黨的蘇治芬委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2198.wav", + "text": "都已經有講公式要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2199.wav", + "text": "跟勞動部討論過後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2200.wav", + "text": "也確知它講的一些現實狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2201.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得要保證一個基礎性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2202.wav", + "text": "第二個這件事情不是千萬勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2203.wav", + "text": "而是邊際勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2204.wav", + "text": "大概有350萬人左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2205.wav", + "text": "我們必須要在法制上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2206.wav", + "text": "讓他們感受到政府的誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2207.wav", + "text": "三萬幾都是用喊的那沒有用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2208.wav", + "text": "請部長回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2209.wav", + "text": "如果大家還是沒有共識就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2210.wav", + "text": "我說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2211.wav", + "text": "CPI我們是一定要考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2212.wav", + "text": "的這是絕對沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2213.wav", + "text": "的而且我們也把它訂在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2214.wav", + "text": "一個應參採的指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2215.wav", + "text": "不能低於CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2216.wav", + "text": "以曾經發生過的金融海嘯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2217.wav", + "text": "的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2218.wav", + "text": "如果以後遇到一些特殊狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2219.wav", + "text": "若完全不能低於CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2220.wav", + "text": "保護勞工的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2221.wav", + "text": "的都是最邊際最弱勢的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2222.wav", + "text": "可能會影響到他的就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2223.wav", + "text": "所以我才認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2224.wav", + "text": "它是一個應參採指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2225.wav", + "text": "但還是要給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2226.wav", + "text": "審議委員一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2227.wav", + "text": "必須斟酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2228.wav", + "text": "第三個我想三萬這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2229.wav", + "text": "當然是一個理想我們也很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2230.wav", + "text": "但也請大家不要忘了我們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2231.wav", + "text": "很多狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2232.wav", + "text": "必須要去考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2233.wav", + "text": "但這個三萬元的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2234.wav", + "text": "好那就保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2235.wav", + "text": "\n我們看下一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2236.wav", + "text": "就是第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2237.wav", + "text": "第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2238.wav", + "text": "大家意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2239.wav", + "text": "院長第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2240.wav", + "text": "院版重要的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2241.wav", + "text": "是在於應該事前公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2242.wav", + "text": "這個研究小組的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2243.wav", + "text": "這樣的一份研究報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2244.wav", + "text": "把這個研究報告做出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2245.wav", + "text": "並且有一些調整建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2246.wav", + "text": "等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2247.wav", + "text": "事前公開嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2248.wav", + "text": "我們實在是完全無法理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2249.wav", + "text": "不能夠公布給社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2250.wav", + "text": "就是公開透明嘛你今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2251.wav", + "text": "先做了一個報告之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2252.wav", + "text": "勞工能夠瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2253.wav", + "text": "然後從這個數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2254.wav", + "text": "現在所面對的各項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2255.wav", + "text": "參考包括剛剛提到的CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2256.wav", + "text": "也好或是其他的參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2257.wav", + "text": "數據跟指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2258.wav", + "text": "就是應該要在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2259.wav", + "text": "這個會議召開前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2260.wav", + "text": "勞動部的官網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2261.wav", + "text": "然後報告公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2262.wav", + "text": "供人民監督跟檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2263.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2264.wav", + "text": "我想差異點只是在這個地方而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2265.wav", + "text": "整個機制的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2266.wav", + "text": "那這個研究小組做什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2267.wav", + "text": "它每4個月要提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2268.wav", + "text": "研究報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2269.wav", + "text": "而且在審議小組開會前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2270.wav", + "text": "30天才拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2271.wav", + "text": "研究小組的報告並不是最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2272.wav", + "text": "有點像專家幕僚或是提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2273.wav", + "text": "他們比較詳細的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2274.wav", + "text": "所以如果在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2275.wav", + "text": "審議小組還沒開會以前把研究小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2276.wav", + "text": "這個報告拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2277.wav", + "text": "會誤以為這就是終局答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2278.wav", + "text": "這樣很麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2279.wav", + "text": "那以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2280.wav", + "text": "照研究小組就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2281.wav", + "text": "嘛包括我們立法院也有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2282.wav", + "text": "那都不是終局答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2283.wav", + "text": "其實它只是一個專業幕僚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2284.wav", + "text": "\n所以差異點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2285.wav", + "text": "先拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2286.wav", + "text": "那外面人家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2287.wav", + "text": "這個讓人有很不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2288.wav", + "text": "因此我覺得比較慎重應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2289.wav", + "text": "照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2290.wav", + "text": "你又把報告先拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2291.wav", + "text": "坦白講對於整個不是很實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2292.wav", + "text": "也不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2293.wav", + "text": "好照行政院版本有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2294.wav", + "text": "有意見喔這個沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2295.wav", + "text": "啦因為聽不出一個理由來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2296.wav", + "text": "本來就是一個民主社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2297.wav", + "text": "那你丟出一個研究報告說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2298.wav", + "text": "這樣就會有什麼樣的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2299.wav", + "text": "那你丟出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2300.wav", + "text": "還是有很多的辯證跟不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2301.wav", + "text": "一定要保密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2302.wav", + "text": "保密的理由是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2303.wav", + "text": "反對的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2304.wav", + "text": "我尊重你的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2305.wav", + "text": "但是我認為本來公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2306.wav", + "text": "就是最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2307.wav", + "text": "曾總召建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2308.wav", + "text": "我們有一個第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2309.wav", + "text": "都還沒討論就保留你也拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2310.wav", + "text": "要尊重我們的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2311.wav", + "text": "院長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2312.wav", + "text": "應該要明文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2313.wav", + "text": "這種廠商連最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2314.wav", + "text": "都不願意去遵守的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2315.wav", + "text": "情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2316.wav", + "text": "這是一個最低的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2317.wav", + "text": "嘛這些違法的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2318.wav", + "text": "應該要列入政府採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2319.wav", + "text": "它連最低工資法都不願意遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2320.wav", + "text": "最低工資它都不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2321.wav", + "text": "給付的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2322.wav", + "text": "政府的採購還讓它來參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2323.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們是希望給勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2324.wav", + "text": "最低工資以上的工作報酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2325.wav", + "text": "應該是一個法律明文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2326.wav", + "text": "賦予雇主最起碼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2327.wav", + "text": "義務那也是我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2328.wav", + "text": "在這邊訂這個最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2329.wav", + "text": "的真正意義所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2330.wav", + "text": "那對於沒有給付給勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2331.wav", + "text": "最低工資的這一些企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2332.wav", + "text": "除了要給予嚴厲的譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2333.wav", + "text": "跟抵制之外政府也應該有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2334.wav", + "text": "具體的作為來捍衛勞工的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2335.wav", + "text": "所以我們的版本是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2336.wav", + "text": "認為應該把它列入政府採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2337.wav", + "text": "的黑名單成為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2338.wav", + "text": "政府採購的拒絕往來戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2339.wav", + "text": "不要因為說一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2340.wav", + "text": "已經連最低工資都不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2341.wav", + "text": "給付的情況之下還能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2342.wav", + "text": "透過政府採購來獲益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2343.wav", + "text": "也可以宣示政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2344.wav", + "text": "對於落實最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2345.wav", + "text": "假設有違法廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2346.wav", + "text": "我覺得我是贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2347.wav", + "text": "的違法廠商不得參與政府採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2348.wav", + "text": "這樣的條文國民黨團是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2349.wav", + "text": "民眾黨團的也是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2350.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2351.wav", + "text": "所有新增版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2352.wav", + "text": "裡面每一個都���得一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2353.wav", + "text": "所以來源應該是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2354.wav", + "text": "啦來源應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2355.wav", + "text": "從勞團還是什麼來源都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2356.wav", + "text": "新增版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2357.wav", + "text": "法規範在談什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2358.wav", + "text": "我們把法規範談的範圍談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2359.wav", + "text": "法規範在談政府採購的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2360.wav", + "text": "它就從政府採購法來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2361.wav", + "text": "而政府採購法對違法廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2362.wav", + "text": "行為重大者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2363.wav", + "text": "本來就可以得停權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2364.wav", + "text": "權採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2365.wav", + "text": "不符合最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2366.wav", + "text": "和另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2367.wav", + "text": "規範採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2368.wav", + "text": "是不一樣的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2369.wav", + "text": "本來法那邊就規範得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2370.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2371.wav", + "text": "我們要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2372.wav", + "text": "你這法是要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2373.wav", + "text": "我可以加倍的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2374.wav", + "text": "大家現在要先把邏輯談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2375.wav", + "text": "基本上我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2376.wav", + "text": "政府採購法本來就規定很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2377.wav", + "text": "你把整個政府採購法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2378.wav", + "text": "尤其第101條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2379.wav", + "text": "好那就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2380.wav", + "text": "院長我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2381.wav", + "text": "柯總召剛剛講說政府採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2382.wav", + "text": "第101條第103條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2383.wav", + "text": "等等有相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2384.wav", + "text": "最低工資法違反的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2385.wav", + "text": "那你是不是要讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2386.wav", + "text": "列為政府採購的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2387.wav", + "text": "拒絕往來戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2388.wav", + "text": "嘛因為你要讓我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2389.wav", + "text": "裡面當然有相當規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2390.wav", + "text": "比如它借用本人的名義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2391.wav", + "text": "或者是擅自偷工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2392.wav", + "text": "減料等等之類的你不要讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2393.wav", + "text": "做政府的生意嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2394.wav", + "text": "同樣的在這個地方其實其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2395.wav", + "text": "三黨包括剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2396.wav", + "text": "討論的其他三個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2397.wav", + "text": "基本上是有共識的只有民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2398.wav", + "text": "跟勞動部沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2399.wav", + "text": "提案基本上可以讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2400.wav", + "text": "要給這些企業一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2401.wav", + "text": "訊息這個訊息就是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2402.wav", + "text": "簡單而且這也很基本就是它要遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2403.wav", + "text": "最低工資法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2404.wav", + "text": "這是一個很卑微的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2405.wav", + "text": "連最低工資都不願意給勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2406.wav", + "text": "你一方面又讓它來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2407.wav", + "text": "然後透過這個來賺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2408.wav", + "text": "因此從政府那邊獲益這是大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2409.wav", + "text": "所不能夠接受的嘛所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2410.wav", + "text": "我也看不出來到底反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2411.wav", + "text": "的理由是什麼啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2412.wav", + "text": "如果這是一個對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2413.wav", + "text": "勞工也是有幫助的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2414.wav", + "text": "的話我真的看不出來為什麼要反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2415.wav", + "text": "應該沒有原住民保留地的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2416.wav", + "text": "你可以下課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2417.wav", + "text": "爭取至少下一次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2418.wav", + "text": "院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2419.wav", + "text": "爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2420.wav", + "text": "對因為晚上有說明會啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2421.wav", + "text": "爭取下一次的院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2422.wav", + "text": "黨團提案就可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2423.wav", + "text": "好OK謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2424.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2425.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2426.wav", + "text": "到這個也要那個也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2427.wav", + "text": "現在政府採購法第101條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2428.wav", + "text": "其實只有對性別歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2429.wav", + "text": "原住民身心障礙或弱勢人權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2430.wav", + "text": "團體歧視這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2431.wav", + "text": "有入所謂的拒絕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2432.wav", + "text": "採購的權益沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2433.wav", + "text": "嚴重違反政府採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2434.wav", + "text": "對要情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2435.wav", + "text": "所以過去地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2436.wav", + "text": "只有把性別歧視的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2437.wav", + "text": "列轉做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2438.wav", + "text": "採購委員會的小組資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2439.wav", + "text": "嚴重delay也有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2440.wav", + "text": "所以我說如果我們在這裡要套用第101" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2441.wav", + "text": "條其實是比較難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2442.wav", + "text": "去直接引用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2443.wav", + "text": "應該是在我們的最低工資法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2444.wav", + "text": "直接定法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2445.wav", + "text": "這101條規範的你只講一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2446.wav", + "text": "有啊只有14款是對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2447.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講勞動裡面的性別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2448.wav", + "text": "沒有你現在講是說違反採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2449.wav", + "text": "的十一款都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2450.wav", + "text": "哪有你這個包括冒用等等都不是勞動法違規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2451.wav", + "text": "現在在講違反勞基法不行啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2452.wav", + "text": "違反性平法有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2453.wav", + "text": "違反就服法不行啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2454.wav", + "text": "我是在講這個啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2455.wav", + "text": "政府採購法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2456.wav", + "text": "規範得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2457.wav", + "text": "那你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2458.wav", + "text": "你認為違反最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2459.wav", + "text": "沒有給付最低工資算不算是違反勞動法令情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2460.wav", + "text": "請勞動部回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2461.wav", + "text": "好勞動部回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2462.wav", + "text": "現在只是想要把它訂定清楚\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2463.wav", + "text": "現在其實題目非常簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2464.wav", + "text": "政府採購法裡面有一款規定說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2465.wav", + "text": "違反勞動法令情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2466.wav", + "text": "就把它列為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2467.wav", + "text": "黑名單現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2468.wav", + "text": "現在我們訂定了一個最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2469.wav", + "text": "薪資未到最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2470.wav", + "text": "違反勞動法令情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2471.wav", + "text": "委員我其實覺得可能要看個案的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2472.wav", + "text": "為明年是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2473.wav", + "text": "27,470" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2474.wav", + "text": "100塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2475.wav", + "text": "那這樣算不算情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2476.wav", + "text": "你就要把它停權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2477.wav", + "text": "情節重大我覺得要看個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2478.wav", + "text": "統統停權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2479.wav", + "text": "差多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2480.wav", + "text": "它的法令規定也是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2481.wav", + "text": "違反勞動法令情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2482.wav", + "text": "對整個因為停權第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2483.wav", + "text": "不是你這個邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2484.wav", + "text": "是經濟部長的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2485.wav", + "text": "你總是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2486.wav", + "text": "廠商如果沒有辦法投標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2487.wav", + "text": "它可以去做其他生意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2488.wav", + "text": "這只是沒有政府的生意而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2489.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟政府採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2490.wav", + "text": "為什麼它在法令的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2491.wav", + "text": "是這樣的一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2492.wav", + "text": "他們一定有充分的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2493.wav", + "text": "啦所以這一題你們提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2494.wav", + "text": "工程會的意見也是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2495.wav", + "text": "其實在原有的法規範已經有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2496.wav", + "text": "他們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2497.wav", + "text": "不需要在這邊訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2498.wav", + "text": "但是你說個案的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2499.wav", + "text": "那當然要具體審酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2500.wav", + "text": "啊我想我們都念法律的情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2501.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法在這邊做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2502.wav", + "text": "的違反你就說它情節重大嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2503.wav", + "text": "這個我覺得不能這樣子來定調吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2504.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的情況叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2505.wav", + "text": "違反勞動法令情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2506.wav", + "text": "也可以請工程會表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2507.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2508.wav", + "text": "工程會這邊大概就採購法的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2509.wav", + "text": "做一個補充給各位委員做參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2510.wav", + "text": "分兩個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2511.wav", + "text": "在選商的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2512.wav", + "text": "在這些勞動有違反的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2513.wav", + "text": "它在選商又過評選就可以做初步的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2514.wav", + "text": "篩選在評分體制裡面優先去避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2515.wav", + "text": "這是第一個在選商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2516.wav", + "text": "的階段不管它用什麼樣的決標方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2517.wav", + "text": "進到履約階段之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2518.wav", + "text": "其實就像剛剛部長所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2519.wav", + "text": "履約階段它違反我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2520.wav", + "text": "契約範本裡面都已經寫得很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2521.wav", + "text": "它必須要符合勞動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2522.wav", + "text": "基準法的最低工資有違反情節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2523.wav", + "text": "重大的時候它會走到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2524.wav", + "text": "終止契約然後會連結到101" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2525.wav", + "text": "\n所以採購法本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2526.wav", + "text": "的停權是根據採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2527.wav", + "text": "的公平合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2528.wav", + "text": "每個法令有它的規範範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2529.wav", + "text": "所以並不是今天違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2530.wav", + "text": "最低工資法就沒有罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2531.wav", + "text": "而是在它這地方有一個罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2532.wav", + "text": "在我們這邊會透過這樣一個連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2533.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛部長才會提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2534.wav", + "text": "採購法裡面的機制不管你在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2535.wav", + "text": "招商階段或是你在履約階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2536.wav", + "text": "情節重大的會帶到這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2537.wav", + "text": "讓它做一個停權避免影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2538.wav", + "text": "嘛那為什麼我們要把它訂在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2539.wav", + "text": "其實就非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2540.wav", + "text": "契約範本的效力不如法律的明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2541.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2542.wav", + "text": "情況之下範本的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2543.wav", + "text": "可能因為個案的情況去修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2544.wav", + "text": "你要做的其實就非常簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2545.wav", + "text": "大家也都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2546.wav", + "text": "你連一個最低工資都不願意給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2547.wav", + "text": "部長你剛剛說的那個不是一個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2548.wav", + "text": "你連最低工資都不願意給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2549.wav", + "text": "基本上你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2550.wav", + "text": "就會被認為是情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2551.wav", + "text": "兩萬多塊都不給人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2552.wav", + "text": "家對不對哪怕是差100塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2553.wav", + "text": "它還是會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2554.wav", + "text": "這是情節重大只是它把它放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2555.wav", + "text": "契約規範的範本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2556.wav", + "text": "啦我們現在的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2557.wav", + "text": "是在哪裡你是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2558.wav", + "text": "把它放在這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2559.wav", + "text": "法律的規範裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2560.wav", + "text": "你剛剛那個想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2561.wav", + "text": "基本上是很替它著想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2562.wav", + "text": "嘛它不做政府的生意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2563.wav", + "text": "其實就是政府給它一個訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2564.wav", + "text": "就是你要照顧勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2565.wav", + "text": "就這麼清楚你如果沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2566.wav", + "text": "照顧勞工的話不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2567.wav", + "text": "一邊讓你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2568.wav", + "text": "連最低工資都不給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2569.wav", + "text": "的情況之下一邊還讓你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2570.wav", + "text": "做政府的生意就是這個訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2571.wav", + "text": "至於它會不會倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2572.wav", + "text": "那是它自己要考量的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2573.wav", + "text": "它可以去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2574.wav", + "text": "其他民間的生意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2575.wav", + "text": "但是我們國家是一個示範性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2576.wav", + "text": "作用我們的規範訂定下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2577.wav", + "text": "也是釋放一個訊息嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2578.wav", + "text": "這個訊息就是你不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2579.wav", + "text": "把最低工資法當塑膠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2580.wav", + "text": "啊它的規範裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2581.wav", + "text": "現在已經有一個契約範本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2582.wav", + "text": "現在差異只是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2583.wav", + "text": "你要不要把它訂定在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2584.wav", + "text": "法規範裡面讓它有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2585.wav", + "text": "法律效果那個法律效果就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2586.wav", + "text": "工程標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2587.wav", + "text": "好因為這個沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2588.wav", + "text": "我們也是保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2589.wav", + "text": "好好我將今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2590.wav", + "text": "協商結論跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2591.wav", + "text": "\n協商主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2592.wav", + "text": "一社會福利及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2593.wav", + "text": "衛生環境委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2594.wav", + "text": "報告併案審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2595.wav", + "text": "行政院函" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2596.wav", + "text": "請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2597.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2598.wav", + "text": "江文昌等17人委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2599.wav", + "text": "徐志榮等25人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2600.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2601.wav", + "text": "委員范雲等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2602.wav", + "text": "委員蔣萬安等18人委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2603.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴等18人委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2604.wav", + "text": "林為洲等16人委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2605.wav", + "text": "廖國棟等16人委員楊瓊瓔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2606.wav", + "text": "等18人及委員張育美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2607.wav", + "text": "等16人分別擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2608.wav", + "text": "最低工資法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2609.wav", + "text": "案\n二逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2610.wav", + "text": "委員蘇治芬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2611.wav", + "text": "等17人委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2612.wav", + "text": "莊競程等21人委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2613.wav", + "text": "李昆澤等19人委員賴瑞隆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2614.wav", + "text": "等16人委員劉建國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2615.wav", + "text": "等16人委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2616.wav", + "text": "王美惠等24人分別擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2617.wav", + "text": "最低工資法草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2618.wav", + "text": "案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2619.wav", + "text": "一協商通過條文第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2620.wav", + "text": "如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2621.wav", + "text": "\n二照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2622.wav", + "text": "第1條第3條第4條第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2623.wav", + "text": "第10條第十六條及第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2624.wav", + "text": "\n三不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2625.wav", + "text": "委員吳玉琴等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2626.wav", + "text": "提案第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2627.wav", + "text": "\n四保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2628.wav", + "text": "第7條第9條第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2629.wav", + "text": "江永昌等17人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2630.wav", + "text": "徐志榮等25人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2631.wav", + "text": "委員林為洲等16人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2632.wav", + "text": "第十五條委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2633.wav", + "text": "范雲等17人時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2634.wav", + "text": "提案第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2635.wav", + "text": "委員蔣萬安等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2636.wav", + "text": "委員廖國棟等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2637.wav", + "text": "提案第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2638.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2639.wav", + "text": "提案第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2640.wav", + "text": "\n五其餘均照審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2641.wav", + "text": "審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2642.wav", + "text": "次授權議事人員調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2643.wav", + "text": "\n七檢附本案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2644.wav", + "text": "立法說明1份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2645.wav", + "text": "\n八台灣民眾黨黨團附帶決議1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2646.wav", + "text": "保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2647.wav", + "text": "\n九本案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2648.wav", + "text": "院會進行處理時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2649.wav", + "text": "協商通過部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2650.wav", + "text": "宣讀後均予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2651.wav", + "text": "保留部分均暫保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2652.wav", + "text": "保留部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2653.wav", + "text": "院會進行處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2654.wav", + "text": "由各黨團推派1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2655.wav", + "text": "人依時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2656.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2657.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團順序輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2658.wav", + "text": "每人發言時間為3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2659.wav", + "text": "發言完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2660.wav", + "text": "各該保留部分均不再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2661.wav", + "text": "並依上開黨團順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2662.wav", + "text": "進行各保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2663.wav", + "text": "黨團版本之處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2664.wav", + "text": "\n看有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2665.wav", + "text": "好沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2666.wav", + "text": "\n我跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2667.wav", + "text": "下午2���半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2668.wav", + "text": "就開始進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2669.wav", + "text": "總預算的密集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2670.wav", + "text": "請各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2671.wav", + "text": "撥出寶貴時間來參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2672.wav", + "text": "還有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2673.wav", + "text": "些還沒有協商完成的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2674.wav", + "text": "各黨團都可以提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2675.wav", + "text": "我們可以調整時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2676.wav", + "text": "只要大家提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2677.wav", + "text": "然後大家有共識我們就調整時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2678.wav", + "text": "來加以協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2679.wav", + "text": "有關於協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2680.wav", + "text": "我們就繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2681.wav", + "text": "今天的會議就到此告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15341/2682.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/0.wav", + "text": "學前特別扣除額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/1.wav", + "text": "我把所有的版本都整理了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/2.wav", + "text": "包括財政部及各個黨團我看都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/3.wav", + "text": "的特別扣除額現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/4.wav", + "text": "不等我自己的版本裡面是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/5.wav", + "text": "大家compromise一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/6.wav", + "text": "這個先跟大家報告待會我們再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/7.wav", + "text": "第3項就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/8.wav", + "text": "我們要鼓勵生育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/9.wav", + "text": "針對第二胎(含第二胎以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/10.wav", + "text": ")我們就調整增加50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/11.wav", + "text": "當然這50%到底是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/12.wav", + "text": "還是要回到剛才所講的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/13.wav", + "text": "到底是維持現在的12萬呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/14.wav", + "text": "這中間有rang" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/15.wav", + "text": "e總共有這三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/16.wav", + "text": "第1項跟第3項大家都沒有爭議對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/17.wav", + "text": "那我們就針對金額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/18.wav", + "text": "論也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/19.wav", + "text": "特別扣除額的金額到底是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/20.wav", + "text": "請大家表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/21.wav", + "text": "還有各位黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/22.wav", + "text": "少子女化是目前的國安危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/23.wav", + "text": "如何讓年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/24.wav", + "text": "願婚敢生樂養其實是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/25.wav", + "text": "第十七條條文的修法上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/26.wav", + "text": "幼童特別扣除額放寬到6歲的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/27.wav", + "text": "感謝財政部同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/28.wav", + "text": "就是剛剛召委講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/29.wav", + "text": "對此台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/30.wav", + "text": "主張直接提高到20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/31.wav", + "text": "讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/32.wav", + "text": "扶養兩個小孩的家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/33.wav", + "text": "尤其是為了配合0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/34.wav", + "text": "0到6歲國家養的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/35.wav", + "text": "打造青年願婚敢生樂養的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/36.wav", + "text": "我們也會積極推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/37.wav", + "text": "少子女化對策的相關修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/38.wav", + "text": "社會對策基本法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/39.wav", + "text": "包含勞工保險法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/40.wav", + "text": "公教人員保險法跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/41.wav", + "text": "農民健康保險法等相關法案的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/42.wav", + "text": "提高生育給付3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/43.wav", + "text": "其實我覺得應該要完整性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/44.wav", + "text": "這個是後續我們還要再繼續努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/45.wav", + "text": "\n有關這次所得稅法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/46.wav", + "text": "第十七條的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/47.wav", + "text": "本黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/48.wav", + "text": "學前特別扣除部分將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/49.wav", + "text": "年齡上限修正為六歲以下之子女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/50.wav", + "text": "這個是有共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/51.wav", + "text": "我再強調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/52.wav", + "text": "就是提高到20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/53.wav", + "text": "大力的來支持這樣一個政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/54.wav", + "text": "使年輕的家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/55.wav", + "text": "能夠感覺到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/56.wav", + "text": "政府是他們的神隊友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/57.wav", + "text": "而不是豬隊友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/58.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/59.wav", + "text": "的這是基本的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/60.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在的出生人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/61.wav", + "text": "已經跌破13萬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/62.wav", + "text": "人口的預期出生指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/63.wav", + "text": "基本上應該都可以預估得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/64.wav", + "text": "所以在有限的資源裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/65.wav", + "text": "讓現在的年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/66.wav", + "text": "能夠有感政府對他們的幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/67.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/68.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/69.wav", + "text": "剛剛我表達了我們的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/70.wav", + "text": "但是有一條我們希望可以保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/71.wav", + "text": "排富的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/72.wav", + "text": "我們希望這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/73.wav", + "text": "可以再進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/74.wav", + "text": "我們希望還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/75.wav", + "text": "把納稅人的錢留在刀口上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/76.wav", + "text": "你就直接講出你們的版本好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/77.wav", + "text": "我們不要再協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/78.wav", + "text": "我們這麼快速的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/79.wav", + "text": "在委員會送出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/80.wav", + "text": "馬上進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/81.wav", + "text": "在立場上都是非常同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/82.wav", + "text": "幫民眾減稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/83.wav", + "text": "幼兒學前特別扣除額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/84.wav", + "text": "在民進黨內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/85.wav", + "text": "包括黃國書委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/86.wav", + "text": "等賴瑞隆委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/87.wav", + "text": "金額部分從12萬到20萬不等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/88.wav", + "text": "大家都是一致同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/89.wav", + "text": "但是對於這個金額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/90.wav", + "text": "目前我們沒有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/91.wav", + "text": "統一的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/92.wav", + "text": "必須在這個會期結束之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/93.wav", + "text": "應該要把它修法完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/94.wav", + "text": "我希望針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/95.wav", + "text": "扣除額的金額部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/96.wav", + "text": "再給我們一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/97.wav", + "text": "院長再做一次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/98.wav", + "text": "然後請召委再來安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/99.wav", + "text": "本會期結束之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/100.wav", + "text": "讓它能夠修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/101.wav", + "text": "目前是12萬到20萬都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/102.wav", + "text": "但是我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/103.wav", + "text": "在這裡應該是要抓一個中間值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/104.wav", + "text": "是希望20" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/105.wav", + "text": "我希望是不是能再給我們一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/106.wav", + "text": "好謝謝楚茵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/107.wav", + "text": "你看一下我們有列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/108.wav", + "text": "了總共有12個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/109.wav", + "text": "民眾黨是20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/110.wav", + "text": "廖婉汝委員是20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/111.wav", + "text": "都是6歲以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/112.wav", + "text": "楊瓊瓔委員是18萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/113.wav", + "text": "郭國文委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/114.wav", + "text": "賴瑞隆委員是20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/115.wav", + "text": "本人提案是第一名12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/116.wav", + "text": "第二名起增加50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/117.wav", + "text": "翁重鈞委員是20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/118.wav", + "text": "萬美玲委員是24萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/119.wav", + "text": "馬文君委員是20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/120.wav", + "text": "楊曜委員是維持12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/121.wav", + "text": "莊競程委員是放寬至6歲以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/122.wav", + "text": "並刪除排富條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/123.wav", + "text": "是6歲維持12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/124.wav", + "text": "召委以及委員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/125.wav", + "text": "我想這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/126.wav", + "text": "大家應該都希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/127.wav", + "text": "因為現在少子女化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/128.wav", + "text": "確實是一個國安的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/129.wav", + "text": "我們上一次的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/130.wav", + "text": "大概就如同剛剛召委所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/131.wav", + "text": "第一個是從5歲調整到6歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/132.wav", + "text": "這個基本都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/133.wav", + "text": "第二個就是排富的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/134.wav", + "text": "大概在上次的討論也都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/135.wav", + "text": "現在就是金額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/136.wav", + "text": "除了金額之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/137.wav", + "text": "還有一個是要不要做階梯式的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/138.wav", + "text": "也就是第一胎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/139.wav", + "text": "12萬要不要做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/140.wav", + "text": "以及第二胎第三胎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/141.wav", + "text": "要不要做階梯式的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/142.wav", + "text": "這個部分也都有不同的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/143.wav", + "text": "基本上大家的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/144.wav", + "text": "都希望這個會期能通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/145.wav", + "text": "過我們財政部也樂見這樣的完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/146.wav", + "text": "所以在金額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/147.wav", + "text": "因為各個版本不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/148.wav", + "text": "能不能取得一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/149.wav", + "text": "稅損可控的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/150.wav", + "text": "我是有請賦稅署幫我精算過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/151.wav", + "text": "你們是拿前年的資料套進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/152.wav", + "text": "就是我們把金額從12萬到15萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/153.wav", + "text": "就是累進增加50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/154.wav", + "text": "沒有排富的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/155.wav", + "text": "因為憑良心講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/156.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是人民的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/157.wav", + "text": "加上排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/158.wav", + "text": "我們鼓勵不管什麼人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/159.wav", + "text": "你只要生小孩就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/160.wav", + "text": "了多生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/161.wav", + "text": "現在50歲以下的年輕朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/162.wav", + "text": "我問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/163.wav", + "text": "好像很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/164.wav", + "text": "只有一二位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/165.wav", + "text": "我是對抗少子女化的尖兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/166.wav", + "text": "我是3個小孩子的父親" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/167.wav", + "text": "這個應該要給獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/168.wav", + "text": "而且我是45歲以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/169.wav", + "text": "你不是天主教徒吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/170.wav", + "text": "這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/171.wav", + "text": "基本上我想我們就不要談了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/172.wav", + "text": "好不好因為不管什麼人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/173.wav", + "text": "願意生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/174.wav", + "text": "就是給你獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/175.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/176.wav", + "text": "剛才楚茵委員有跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/177.wav", + "text": "因為民進黨內還沒有整合好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/178.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天就作如下的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/179.wav", + "text": "我們擇期請游院長再來召開朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/180.wav", + "text": "我會儘快跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/181.wav", + "text": "麻煩你們也跟游院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/182.wav", + "text": "但排富的部分我也非常認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/183.wav", + "text": "就是說不要有排富的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/184.wav", + "text": "也不好算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/185.wav", + "text": "應該是願意要生養的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/186.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們就應該要鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/187.wav", + "text": "就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/188.wav", + "text": "你說像年收入200萬的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/189.wav", + "text": "如果把他排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/190.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/191.wav", + "text": "200萬在臺北市養個小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/192.wav", + "text": "很貴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/193.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/194.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/195.wav", + "text": "排富的部分我們就不談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/196.wav", + "text": "我們再重新估算稅收損失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/197.wav", + "text": "你們當初有算排富嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/198.wav", + "text": "有因為委員的版本都有排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/199.wav", + "text": "只有一位沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/200.wav", + "text": "你們排富的門檻是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/201.wav", + "text": "就是20%稅率以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/202.wav", + "text": "還有鼓勵分開計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/203.wav", + "text": "是不是建議可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/204.wav", + "text": "再重新估算一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/205.wav", + "text": "我們再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/206.wav", + "text": "我們再重新估算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/207.wav", + "text": "儘快的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/208.wav", + "text": "反正我們本來就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/209.wav", + "text": "再召開一次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/210.wav", + "text": "我們具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/211.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/212.wav", + "text": "當然召委今天會做決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/213.wav", + "text": "要把它算出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/214.wav", + "text": "然後稅損是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/215.wav", + "text": "到底要花多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/216.wav", + "text": "我們黨團的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/217.wav", + "text": "當然是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/218.wav", + "text": "就像召委講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/219.wav", + "text": "不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/220.wav", + "text": "每個國民都把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/221.wav", + "text": "當作是一個非常重要的事情的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/222.wav", + "text": "它的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/223.wav", + "text": "我們當然是主張拉到最高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/224.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/225.wav", + "text": "其實我覺得政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/226.wav", + "text": "是可以檢討的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/227.wav", + "text": "就是3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/228.wav", + "text": "3年可以再重新調整一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/229.wav", + "text": "看它實際的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/230.wav", + "text": "不然有時候做了半套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/231.wav", + "text": "效果不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/232.wav", + "text": "其實大家也是花了那麼多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/233.wav", + "text": "反而那個效果並沒有達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/234.wav", + "text": "好吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/235.wav", + "text": "你們再算一算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/236.wav", + "text": "把排富拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/237.wav", + "text": "這個稅損會增加多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/238.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/239.wav", + "text": "像今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/240.wav", + "text": "我們一人退稅6,000塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/241.wav", + "text": "有沒有排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/242.wav", + "text": "沒有排富嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/243.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/244.wav", + "text": "我覺得不管有錢沒錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/245.wav", + "text": "沒錢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/246.wav", + "text": "其實要給他額外的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/247.wav", + "text": "有錢人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/248.wav", + "text": "或是中富的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/249.wav", + "text": "多鼓勵他生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/250.wav", + "text": "因為生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/251.wav", + "text": "日後解決很多問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/252.wav", + "text": "兵役問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/253.wav", + "text": "勞力問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/254.wav", + "text": "你知道我們去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/255.wav", + "text": "臺灣出生率是全世界第幾名嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/256.wav", + "text": "最後一名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/257.wav", + "text": "所以本來有人還要提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/258.wav", + "text": "連我都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/259.wav", + "text": "生第二個小孩送100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/260.wav", + "text": "生第二個小孩送300萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/261.wav", + "text": "���勵他生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/262.wav", + "text": "我想即使這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/263.wav", + "text": "都很難達到預期效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/264.wav", + "text": "啦你想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/265.wav", + "text": "第二個小孩多100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/266.wav", + "text": "替社會多繳多少稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/267.wav", + "text": "要從這樣子的思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/268.wav", + "text": "重賞之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/269.wav", + "text": "希望有成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/270.wav", + "text": "對我非常認同召委所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/271.wav", + "text": "的補助其實只是其中一個方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/272.wav", + "text": "還是要打造一個友善的育兒環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/273.wav", + "text": "然後從整個人口結構跟長期發展來考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/274.wav", + "text": "他會解決國軍召募的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/275.wav", + "text": "產業缺工的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/276.wav", + "text": "私校退場的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/277.wav", + "text": "還有整個我們後面社會福利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/278.wav", + "text": "我們現在的人口結構是頭重腳輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/279.wav", + "text": "但是這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/280.wav", + "text": "如果現在不解決20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/281.wav", + "text": "後會更嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/282.wav", + "text": "所以應該要從這個角度來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/283.wav", + "text": "在稅損可以接受的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/284.wav", + "text": "大力的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/285.wav", + "text": "真的是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/286.wav", + "text": "因為憑良心講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/287.wav", + "text": "現在還有很多東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/288.wav", + "text": "不是只有這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/289.wav", + "text": "就可以鼓勵人家生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/290.wav", + "text": "還有我們托育的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/291.wav", + "text": "像公托要不要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/292.wav", + "text": "公托大家比較放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/293.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/294.wav", + "text": "你到民間托" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/295.wav", + "text": "政府出的那個錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/296.wav", + "text": "縣市政府都有補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/297.wav", + "text": "真的是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/298.wav", + "text": "所得稅法第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/299.wav", + "text": "大家要全力配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/300.wav", + "text": "但是放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/301.wav", + "text": "我跟我太太商量過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/302.wav", + "text": "我們兩個不再生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/303.wav", + "text": "\n我們今天協商結論就請院長儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/304.wav", + "text": "也拜託賦稅署這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/305.wav", + "text": "儘快把它再試算一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/306.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15337/307.wav", + "text": "我們就散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/0.wav", + "text": "能治療師法的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/1.wav", + "text": "\n今天要併案協商的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/2.wav", + "text": "職能治療師法的草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/3.wav", + "text": "併案審查委員吳玉琴等19人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/4.wav", + "text": "委員莊競程等21人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/5.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團分別擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/6.wav", + "text": "職能治療師法第十二條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/7.wav", + "text": "委員吳玉琴等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/8.wav", + "text": "委員林為洲等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/9.wav", + "text": "委員王美惠等25人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/10.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團分別擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/11.wav", + "text": "職能治療師法部分條文修正草案等7案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/12.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/13.wav", + "text": "委員洪申翰等16人擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/14.wav", + "text": "職能治療師法第九條第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/15.wav", + "text": "及第十四條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/16.wav", + "text": "我們也一併來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/17.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/18.wav", + "text": "今年5月17日審查的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/19.wav", + "text": "進行協商保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/20.wav", + "text": "我們當天保留條文只有第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/21.wav", + "text": "提案保留的有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/22.wav", + "text": "委員吳玉琴等19人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/23.wav", + "text": "委員莊競程等21人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/24.wav", + "text": "委員林為洲等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/25.wav", + "text": "委員王美惠等25人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/26.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團及台灣民眾黨黨團等提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/27.wav", + "text": "還有修正動議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/28.wav", + "text": "以及委員邱泰源等3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/29.wav", + "text": "所提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/30.wav", + "text": "就這一本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/31.wav", + "text": "而且有把洪申翰委員的版本放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/32.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/33.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/34.wav", + "text": "大家手上有沒有白色這一本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/35.wav", + "text": "林委員還有王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/36.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/37.wav", + "text": "手上有沒有這一本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/38.wav", + "text": "我們就照這一本來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/39.wav", + "text": "十二條是保留協商的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/40.wav", + "text": "這一本有把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/41.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員的版本也放進來所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/42.wav", + "text": "我們一併來看好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/43.wav", + "text": "各個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/44.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀的洪申翰委��版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/45.wav", + "text": "我們在用這個版本協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/46.wav", + "text": "已經有一些協商共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/47.wav", + "text": "可以請行政部門先報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/48.wav", + "text": "\n請劉司長先報告好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/49.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/50.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/51.wav", + "text": "第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/52.wav", + "text": "因為很多委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/53.wav", + "text": "希望能夠在第二項增列第二款到第五款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/54.wav", + "text": "只是因為在醫療的連續性照護裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/55.wav", + "text": "很難用這樣子的item來分說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/56.wav", + "text": "是需要醫囑或非醫囑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/57.wav", + "text": "我們建議維持原本的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/58.wav", + "text": "如同物理治療師一樣加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/59.wav", + "text": "上但非以疾病治療為目的者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/60.wav", + "text": "\n利用這樣子來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/61.wav", + "text": "這跟2月8日物理治療師的版本是一模一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/62.wav", + "text": "這樣在做後續的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/63.wav", + "text": "跟研議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/64.wav", + "text": "就可以讓物理治療師跟職能治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/65.wav", + "text": "現在這個版本的本文等於跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/66.wav", + "text": "物理治療師法是一樣的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/67.wav", + "text": "然後說明欄的部分有特別把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/68.wav", + "text": "包含在疾病裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/69.wav", + "text": "可能稍微跟物治的說明欄有些不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/70.wav", + "text": "\n不曉得幾位委員有沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/71.wav", + "text": "意見還是覺得可以照這個版本來通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/72.wav", + "text": "請王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/73.wav", + "text": "我們大方向是認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/74.wav", + "text": "照物理治療師的版本來做文字的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/75.wav", + "text": "職業病在內之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/76.wav", + "text": "疾病治療等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/77.wav", + "text": "職業病的範疇會由哪個部分來做定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/78.wav", + "text": "第二個部分是在時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/79.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團的版本中我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/80.wav", + "text": "現在職能治療不是只有在後端來協助他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/81.wav", + "text": "復能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/82.wav", + "text": "如果可以的話我們當然希望能夠從前端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/83.wav", + "text": "避免落入到疾病的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/84.wav", + "text": "的第1項第1款就有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/85.wav", + "text": "不只是評估也希望能夠把指導和諮詢納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/86.wav", + "text": "因為我們希望整體來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/87.wav", + "text": "如果他還沒有很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/88.wav", + "text": "他可能對於職能治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/89.wav", + "text": "有一些概念當他遇到一些生活上的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/90.wav", + "text": "時他可以先去做諮詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/91.wav", + "text": "或許這在推動國人健康上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/92.wav", + "text": "是一個比較全面的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/93.wav", + "text": "所以這兩個部分想請教一下部會的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/94.wav", + "text": "先就第二部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/95.wav", + "text": "做回應因為比較直接當他就是以一個非治療疾病的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/96.wav", + "text": "範疇來做處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/97.wav", + "text": "其實本來就不需要醫囑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/98.wav", + "text": "因為需要醫師醫囑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/99.wav", + "text": "所以在這個分野上面會比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/100.wav", + "text": "而不會用文字限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/101.wav", + "text": "到底第幾款第幾款哪一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/102.wav", + "text": "因為連續性的地方很難切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/103.wav", + "text": "就是針對職業病治療的部分有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/104.wav", + "text": "有關職業病的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/105.wav", + "text": "其實從勞動部的規定裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/106.wav", + "text": "就有職業病專科的醫師來做所謂的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/107.wav", + "text": "還要回過頭來把他周邊的情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/108.wav", + "text": "做一個研析之後才能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/109.wav", + "text": "這個跟那個疾病有沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/110.wav", + "text": "我們平常醫師看到的只是疾病的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/111.wav", + "text": "所以才會特別加註在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/112.wav", + "text": "說明這個職業可能產生的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/113.wav", + "text": "大概以這樣子的範疇來做分別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/114.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/115.wav", + "text": "對現在提出來的協商共識版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/116.wav", + "text": "可以吧我們就照物理治療師法的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/117.wav", + "text": "在後面加一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/118.wav", + "text": "但非以疾病治療為目的者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/119.wav", + "text": "說明欄的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/120.wav", + "text": "都含在疾病裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/121.wav", + "text": "這個部分也是職業病相關團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/122.wav", + "text": "我們就把它說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/123.wav", + "text": "可以嗎是不是就照這樣協商版本來通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/124.wav", + "text": "吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/125.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/126.wav", + "text": "衛福部現在提出來的協商共識版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/127.wav", + "text": "然後說明欄第十二條的立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/128.wav", + "text": "也照衛衛福部的建議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/129.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/130.wav", + "text": "我們在審查會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/131.wav", + "text": "那是不是在說明欄的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/132.wav", + "text": "也授權衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/133.wav", + "text": "看看有沒有文字要再做修正這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/134.wav", + "text": "分就授權衛福部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/135.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/136.wav", + "text": "就是周延性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/137.wav", + "text": "當時沒有去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/138.wav", + "text": "雖有各委員提出的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/139.wav", + "text": "但是沒有一個是行政部門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/140.wav", + "text": "我們就照這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/141.wav", + "text": "看有沒有要做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/142.wav", + "text": "就是照原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/143.wav", + "text": "沒有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/144.wav", + "text": "在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/145.wav", + "text": "第十九條就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/146.wav", + "text": "維持現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/147.wav", + "text": "那個職治團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/148.wav", + "text": "有放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/149.wav", + "text": "第十九條他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/150.wav", + "text": "是維持現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/151.wav", + "text": "這次在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/152.wav", + "text": "就是這樣處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/153.wav", + "text": "\n我們接下來要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/154.wav", + "text": "有關附帶決議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/155.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/156.wav", + "text": "是不是都有這一份附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/157.wav", + "text": "剛剛大家都有一起連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/158.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/159.wav", + "text": "這個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/160.wav", + "text": "應該沒有問題吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/161.wav", + "text": "這需要宣讀嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/162.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/163.wav", + "text": "那是不是請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/164.wav", + "text": "議事人員協助我們宣讀一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/165.wav", + "text": "職能治療師法第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/166.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/167.wav", + "text": "施行後3個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/168.wav", + "text": "邀集中華民國醫師公會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/169.wav", + "text": "全國聯合會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/170.wav", + "text": "台灣復健醫學會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/171.wav", + "text": "環境職業醫學會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/172.wav", + "text": "及相關專業團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/173.wav", + "text": "共同研商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/174.wav", + "text": "非以含職業病在內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/175.wav", + "text": "之疾病治療為目的之範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/176.wav", + "text": "並以函釋明確之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/177.wav", + "text": "以保障民眾福祉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/178.wav", + "text": "建請主管機關加強監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/179.wav", + "text": "稽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/180.wav", + "text": "以確保民眾健康權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/181.wav", + "text": "衛生福利部應積極了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/182.wav", + "text": "物理治療師及職能治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/183.wav", + "text": "之執業狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/184.wav", + "text": "以保障民眾健康福祉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/185.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/186.wav", + "text": "附帶決議我們就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/187.wav", + "text": "但是我想要先釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/188.wav", + "text": "物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/189.wav", + "text": "其實也有類似的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/190.wav", + "text": "修法通過實施後的3個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/191.wav", + "text": "是不是有針對這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/192.wav", + "text": "非以治療為目的的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/193.wav", + "text": "已經有達到一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/194.wav", + "text": "職能治療師物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/195.wav", + "text": "尤其是職能治療在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/196.wav", + "text": "像是精神衛生早療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/197.wav", + "text": "特教議題上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/198.wav", + "text": "都有它非常重要的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/199.wav", + "text": "和重要的職務必須要能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/200.wav", + "text": "一起來協力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/201.wav", + "text": "扮演了非常重要的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/202.wav", + "text": "所以我們很希望的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/203.wav", + "text": "儘快地做到範圍的釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/204.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/205.wav", + "text": "如果一旦沒有清楚定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/206.wav", + "text": "衍生更多的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/207.wav", + "text": "這部分可能真的需要請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/208.wav", + "text": "認真的來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/209.wav", + "text": "達到3個月內能夠清楚地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/210.wav", + "text": "的範疇能夠定清楚以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/211.wav", + "text": "以避免過去大家會看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/212.wav", + "text": "即便修法通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/213.wav", + "text": "大家還是會有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/214.wav", + "text": "在於定義上的模糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/215.wav", + "text": "又或者是不是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/216.wav", + "text": "違反醫師法的可能性等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/217.wav", + "text": "我們希望不要造成這個爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/218.wav", + "text": "所以不只是附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/219.wav", + "text": "也希望衛福部真的能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/220.wav", + "text": "儘快來做推動和協議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/221.wav", + "text": "請衛福部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/222.wav", + "text": "職能治療師跟物理治療師這部���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/223.wav", + "text": "我們大概會再加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/224.wav", + "text": "第一次在做物理治療師的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/225.wav", + "text": "大家對於那部分的想像空間是大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/226.wav", + "text": "然後經過幾次請大家提出來的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/227.wav", + "text": "是來自各個有法律依據的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/228.wav", + "text": "非以疾病治療為目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/229.wav", + "text": "那個範圍就比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/230.wav", + "text": "大概會用正面表列的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/231.wav", + "text": "在提這個概念的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/232.wav", + "text": "物理治療跟醫界這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/233.wav", + "text": "老實講是對範疇的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/234.wav", + "text": "定義不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/235.wav", + "text": "現有的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/236.wav", + "text": "譬如說長照法裡面講了什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/237.wav", + "text": "譬如說像學校的衛生教育裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/238.wav", + "text": "具體討論的時候會比較聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/239.wav", + "text": "所以同樣的模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/240.wav", + "text": "大概在職能治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/241.wav", + "text": "也會以這樣正面表列的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/242.wav", + "text": "我們會儘速以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/243.wav", + "text": "我想真的要催促我們衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/244.wav", + "text": "儘快地讓物治跟職治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/245.wav", + "text": "治所謂非以疾病治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/246.wav", + "text": "趕快界定清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/247.wav", + "text": "這樣未來在執行面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/248.wav", + "text": "才能讓二個師跟我們醫界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/249.wav", + "text": "能夠有所適從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/250.wav", + "text": "大家一起來遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/251.wav", + "text": "我們就是嚴加的稽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/252.wav", + "text": "只要有違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/253.wav", + "text": "我們還是要強力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/254.wav", + "text": "就是不能有醫療行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/255.wav", + "text": "這個附帶決議就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/256.wav", + "text": "宣讀協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/257.wav", + "text": "\n一協商通過條文第十二條如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/258.wav", + "text": "\n二其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/259.wav", + "text": "\n三通過附帶決議1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/260.wav", + "text": "\n四檢附立法說明1份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/261.wav", + "text": "的協商會議就到這邊結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/262.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家的參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15331/263.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15325/0.wav", + "text": "開始進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15325/1.wav", + "text": "就房屋稅條例部分條文修正草案等25案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15325/2.wav", + "text": "委員會議審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15325/3.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15325/4.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝陳椒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15325/5.wav", + "text": "擬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15325/6.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15325/7.wav", + "text": "維持現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15325/8.wav", + "text": "第5條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15325/9.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15325/10.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15324/0.wav", + "text": "果你不排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15324/1.wav", + "text": "屋你有一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15319/0.wav", + "text": "一併都說明過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15319/1.wav", + "text": "版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15319/2.wav", + "text": "有關於第109條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15319/3.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15319/4.wav", + "text": "是不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15319/5.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15319/6.wav", + "text": "這一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15319/7.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/0.wav", + "text": "現在開始協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/1.wav", + "text": "本日協商關於刑事訴訟法部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/2.wav", + "text": "共計二個主題稍後按協商通知排序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/3.wav", + "text": "現在逐案進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/4.wav", + "text": "協商時請參閱審查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/5.wav", + "text": "及逕付二讀提案關係文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/6.wav", + "text": "與會委員如有修正動議或機關有建議內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/7.wav", + "text": "請提出書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/8.wav", + "text": "印發現場進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/9.wav", + "text": "\n首先進行主題一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/10.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/11.wav", + "text": "併案審查司法院行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/12.wav", + "text": "刑事訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/13.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案等4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/14.wav", + "text": "審查會前於5月22日審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/15.wav", + "text": "審查情形保留8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/16.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/17.wav", + "text": "其餘均有審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/18.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/19.wav", + "text": "另院會再將時代力量黨團提案逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/20.wav", + "text": "與相關提案併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/21.wav", + "text": "\n為求效率我們是不是先就保留條文進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/22.wav", + "text": "如果各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/23.wav", + "text": "協商代表對於審查會通過條文有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/24.wav", + "text": "待保留條文處理完畢後再接續進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/25.wav", + "text": "請問委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/26.wav", + "text": "邱委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/27.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/28.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/29.wav", + "text": "我們先請與會機關代表針對協商條文一併說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/30.wav", + "text": "這部分是不是請我們刑事廳長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/31.wav", + "text": "有關於協商條文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/32.wav", + "text": "我逐條來做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/33.wav", + "text": "有關測謊不能當作證據能力的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/34.wav", + "text": "因為我們之前跟法務部之間比較難達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/35.wav", + "text": "目前我們的建議是不予修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/36.wav", + "text": "而且在實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/37.wav", + "text": "關於測謊的證據能力的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/38.wav", + "text": "留待實務來發展以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/39.wav", + "text": "法務部有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/40.wav", + "text": "有有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/41.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/42.wav", + "text": "是不是一併都說明過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/43.wav", + "text": "每一條都說明過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/44.wav", + "text": "就一併說明嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/45.wav", + "text": "鑑定人的相關能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/46.wav", + "text": "相關揭露包括所應該揭露的資訊跟記載的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/47.wav", + "text": "也達成了一定的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/48.wav", + "text": "有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/49.wav", + "text": "在偵查中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/50.wav", + "text": "相關鑑定人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/51.wav", + "text": "我們稱為自然人鑑定這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/52.wav", + "text": "我們跟法務部原先有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/53.wav", + "text": "目前已經有相當的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/54.wav", + "text": "我們把私選鑑定的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/55.wav", + "text": "移列到第208條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/56.wav", + "text": "這部分就保留在偵查中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/57.wav", + "text": "當事人可以請求檢察官選任鑑定人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/58.wav", + "text": "請求方式就依照第106條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/59.wav", + "text": "等等相關規定來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/60.wav", + "text": "在審理中他也可以向法院聲請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/61.wav", + "text": "第109條相關之鑑定人這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/62.wav", + "text": "個部分我們也有達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/63.wav", + "text": "\n有關於第109條之2的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/64.wav", + "text": "就是我們在選任鑑定人之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/65.wav", + "text": "要給被告或辯護人有陳述意見的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/66.wav", + "text": "我們跟法務部這邊也都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/67.wav", + "text": "\n至於第109條之3的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/68.wav", + "text": "我們目前的想法是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/69.wav", + "text": "有關於鑑定物交付的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/70.wav", + "text": "在刑事訴訟法第203條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/71.wav", + "text": "都已經有相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/72.wav", + "text": "保相關證物交付的連續���跟證物的完整性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/73.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/74.wav", + "text": "有不同的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/75.wav", + "text": "應該怎麼去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/76.wav", + "text": "大概也很難做分析或是做不同的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/77.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法全部完整的做規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/78.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們建議先不要增訂\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/79.wav", + "text": "有關於鑑定物可能因為鑑定而耗損的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/80.wav", + "text": "發現鑑定物耗損應該怎麼中止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/81.wav", + "text": "剛剛委任應該注意的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/82.wav", + "text": "我們建議不用特別把它羅列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/83.wav", + "text": "這樣也不會因為委任鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/84.wav", + "text": "卻由法院來裁定命其續行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/85.wav", + "text": "恐怕有委任或選任鑑定關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/86.wav", + "text": "混淆不清的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/87.wav", + "text": "所以我們是建議不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/88.wav", + "text": "\n另外第206條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/89.wav", + "text": "有關於鑑定報告書的一些內容跟記載方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/90.wav", + "text": "用言詞或是書面報告時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/91.wav", + "text": "應該要包括什麼樣的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/92.wav", + "text": "包括鑑定人的專業能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/93.wav", + "text": "是有助於事實的認定鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/94.wav", + "text": "是不是以足夠的事實或資料為基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/95.wav", + "text": "是依據可靠的鑑定方法原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/96.wav", + "text": "又把這個可靠的方法適用在這個鑑定事項上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/97.wav", + "text": "包括鑑定書的記載方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/98.wav", + "text": "原先我們的跟行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/99.wav", + "text": "有點不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/100.wav", + "text": "不過我們現在有相關的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/101.wav", + "text": "傳喚鑑定人部分的裁定可不可以抗告的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/102.wav", + "text": "建議要增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/103.wav", + "text": "但是我們目前已經達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/104.wav", + "text": "因為相關證據調查的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/105.wav", + "text": "訴訟程序上的裁定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/106.wav", + "text": "在刑事訴訟法第404條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/107.wav", + "text": "認為程序裁定是不可以抗告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/108.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議不應該賦予聲請人有抗告權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/109.wav", + "text": "也已經達成共識了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/110.wav", + "text": "2建議不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/111.wav", + "text": "\n再來是第208條這個部分有比較大的變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/112.wav", + "text": "第208條主要是關於機關鑑定的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/113.wav", + "text": "機關鑑定包括第2項的相關機關鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/114.wav", + "text": "是由什麼人來���任鑑定人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/115.wav", + "text": "以及應該遵循的相關實施鑑定的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/116.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們跟行政院版本來有很大的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/117.wav", + "text": "目前我們有達成一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/118.wav", + "text": "就是以行政院版為基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/119.wav", + "text": "我們羅列了相關的一些機關鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/120.wav", + "text": "在什麼狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/121.wav", + "text": "讓機關鑑定的鑑定報告書在書面就取得證據能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/122.wav", + "text": "例如當事人明示同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/123.wav", + "text": "或依法令具有執掌鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/124.wav", + "text": "鑑識等相關機關所實施的鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/125.wav", + "text": "或是經主管機關認證的機構或團體所做的鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/126.wav", + "text": "這些鑑定機關本身就比較有公信力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/127.wav", + "text": "相關的鑑定程序也比較嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/128.wav", + "text": "這部分我們就讓它的書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/129.wav", + "text": "當然如果當事人對於鑑定報告書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/130.wav", + "text": "認為有爭執或交互詰問的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/131.wav", + "text": "用言詞的方式來做陳述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/132.wav", + "text": "甚至可以做交互詰問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/133.wav", + "text": "問這個部分還有一個比較大的變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/134.wav", + "text": "第109條之1有關私選鑑定的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/135.wav", + "text": "我們把它移列到機關鑑定這邊來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/136.wav", + "text": "我們把它放在第208條第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/137.wav", + "text": "就讓當事人在審判中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/138.wav", + "text": "可以直接去委任機關學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/139.wav", + "text": "去做鑑定或是審查他人的鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/140.wav", + "text": "並準用第109條第2項的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/141.wav", + "text": "私選鑑定的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/142.wav", + "text": "另外針對鑑定物的交付方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/143.wav", + "text": "我們也在條文中明列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/144.wav", + "text": "可以準用第106條至第106條之二的一些規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/145.wav", + "text": "法院怎麼交付等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/146.wav", + "text": "就回到第203條的相關規定來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/147.wav", + "text": "這個部分是我們跟行政院法務部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/148.wav", + "text": "後達到共識的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/149.wav", + "text": "\n最後一條是第二百十一條之1的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/150.wav", + "text": "這部分是有關於法律鑑定的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/151.wav", + "text": "跟司法院版本來有不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/152.wav", + "text": "在於法律鑑定的鑑定人到底要不要具結的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/153.wav", + "text": "我們後來討論的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/154.wav", + "text": "我們認為法律意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/155.wav", + "text": "那是一種意見的陳述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/156.wav", + "text": "所以我們就接受法務部的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/157.wav", + "text": "就排除刑訴第二百零二條的一些相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/158.wav", + "text": "也就是不需要做具結以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/159.wav", + "text": "另外還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/160.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛條文有一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/161.wav", + "text": "蔡次長有沒有補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/162.wav", + "text": "沒有補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/163.wav", + "text": "完全如廳長剛剛完整的陳述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/164.wav", + "text": "跟司法院經過非常多次的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/165.wav", + "text": "有達成剛剛廳長所陳述的這些共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/166.wav", + "text": "增訂第106條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/167.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/168.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們的版本是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/169.wav", + "text": "測謊的結果無證據能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/170.wav", + "text": "啦基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/171.wav", + "text": "我也是認為測謊的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/172.wav", + "text": "因為它的爭議真的非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/173.wav", + "text": "應該要排除它的證據能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/174.wav", + "text": "司法院跟法務部現在是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/175.wav", + "text": "先不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/176.wav", + "text": "基本上我們也是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/177.wav", + "text": "如果能夠趕快通過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/178.wav", + "text": "好這一條不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/179.wav", + "text": "\n第109條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/180.wav", + "text": "是不是照司法院行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/181.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/182.wav", + "text": "邱委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/183.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/184.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/185.wav", + "text": "\n增訂第109條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/186.wav", + "text": "1照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/187.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/188.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/189.wav", + "text": "\n增訂第109條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/190.wav", + "text": "2照司法院行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/191.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/192.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/193.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/194.wav", + "text": "\n增訂第109條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/195.wav", + "text": "我們不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/196.wav", + "text": "有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/197.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/198.wav", + "text": "好我們不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/199.wav", + "text": "\n增訂第109條之4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/200.wav", + "text": "我們也是不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/201.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/202.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/203.wav", + "text": "甲案司法院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/204.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/205.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/206.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/207.wav", + "text": "\n增訂第206條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/208.wav", + "text": "不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/209.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/210.wav", + "text": "這個是行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/211.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/212.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/213.wav", + "text": "\n第208條照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/214.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/215.wav", + "text": "這個部分就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/216.wav", + "text": "啦應該說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/217.wav", + "text": "這個版本就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/218.wav", + "text": "囑託這個機關去做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/219.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/220.wav", + "text": "第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/221.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/222.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/223.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/224.wav", + "text": "好照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/225.wav", + "text": "\n增訂第二百十一條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/226.wav", + "text": "是否也照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/227.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/228.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/229.wav", + "text": "我們就照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/230.wav", + "text": "\n現在進行主題二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/231.wav", + "text": "協商刑事訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/232.wav", + "text": "施行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/233.wav", + "text": "增訂第7條之5條文草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/234.wav", + "text": "前於5月22日審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/235.wav", + "text": "審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/236.wav", + "text": "是增訂第7條之5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/237.wav", + "text": "保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/238.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/239.wav", + "text": "須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/240.wav", + "text": "\n首先請與會機關代表說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/241.wav", + "text": "有關於本條是因為刑事訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/242.wav", + "text": "剛剛鑑定章的一些相關調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/243.wav", + "text": "所以有關施行法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/244.wav", + "text": "請求增列第7條之5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/245.wav", + "text": "草案是請求在公布後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/246.wav", + "text": "有重大變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/247.wav", + "text": "對現行司法實務的鑑定運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/248.wav", + "text": "會產生重大的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/249.wav", + "text": "我們為了讓審檢辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/250.wav", + "text": "及鑑定人各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/251.wav", + "text": "有相關配套的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/252.wav", + "text": "除了可以立即實施的條文之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/253.wav", + "text": "有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/254.wav", + "text": "像第206條第4項及第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/255.wav", + "text": "這些相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/256.wav", + "text": "法令整備的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/257.wav", + "text": "是不是建議可以從公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/258.wav", + "text": "期使新制能運作順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/259.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/260.wav", + "text": "法務部有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/261.wav", + "text": "我們跟司法院的意見一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/262.wav", + "text": "邱委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/263.wav", + "text": "這個有需要這麼久嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/264.wav", + "text": "一年因為這個涉及到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/265.wav", + "text": "讓當事人可以自己選任鑑定人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/266.wav", + "text": "嘛有需要給予一年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/267.wav", + "text": "會請求給予緩衝期的主要原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/268.wav", + "text": "是因為我們在第208條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/269.wav", + "text": "增列了許多相關的所謂機關鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/270.wav", + "text": "機關鑑定的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/271.wav", + "text": "我們有強調是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/272.wav", + "text": "依法令具有執掌鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/273.wav", + "text": "鑑識或檢驗等業務的機關才可以實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/274.wav", + "text": "這些機關如果有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/275.wav", + "text": "鑑定書原則上就會有證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/276.wav", + "text": "另外還有一個就是經主管機關認證的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/277.wav", + "text": "或團體所實施的鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/278.wav", + "text": "因為這些機關有的法制尚不完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/279.wav", + "text": "但是現在它實質上就是一個鑑定機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/280.wav", + "text": "例如憲兵指揮部的鑑識中心等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/281.wav", + "text": "它在法制上是沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/282.wav", + "text": "但是實際上它經常是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/283.wav", + "text": "刑事實務上委託鑑定的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/284.wav", + "text": "所以我們要讓它的相關鑑定報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/285.wav", + "text": "書符合第208條的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/286.wav", + "text": "讓它當然取得證據能力的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/287.wav", + "text": "勢必要做一些相關法令的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/288.wav", + "text": "包括組織法或作用法的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/289.wav", + "text": "讓它變成具有相關的法令職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/290.wav", + "text": "來做相關的委託鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/291.wav", + "text": "所以我們提出這樣的建議而且這些機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/292.wav", + "text": "根據法務部的盤點是相當龐大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/293.wav", + "text": "這不是只有單一機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/294.wav", + "text": "而已包括尿液鑑定也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/295.wav", + "text": "衛福部相關認證的機構或團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/296.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/297.wav", + "text": "應該讓它的法令跟制度完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/298.wav", + "text": "\n另外也包括鑑定物現在不是單純交付機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/299.wav", + "text": "可能還有其他的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/300.wav", + "text": "不是我們現在經常用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/301.wav", + "text": "政府機關的鑑定單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/302.wav", + "text": "例如說可能是比較私人的協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/303.wav", + "text": "或是公會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/304.wav", + "text": "對於交付鑑定物的流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/305.wav", + "text": "跟鑑定物的保管這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/306.wav", + "text": "也需要去做一些調整跟認證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/307.wav", + "text": "因為鑑定物有一個唯一性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/308.wav", + "text": "單一性跟同一性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/309.wav", + "text": "沒有保存好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/310.wav", + "text": "可能會影響到後面的審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/311.wav", + "text": "跟相關犯罪事實的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/312.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們是稍微謹慎一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/313.wav", + "text": "涉及到人民的權利自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/314.wav", + "text": "這個應該要特別謹慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/315.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議是不是給我們一些緩衝期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/316.wav", + "text": "來做相關法令的整備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/317.wav", + "text": "邱委員還有意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/318.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/319.wav", + "text": "照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/320.wav", + "text": "並將條次修正為第7條之9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/321.wav", + "text": "\n本日作協商結論如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/322.wav", + "text": "一刑事訴訟法部分條文修正草案等5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/323.wav", + "text": "(一)增訂第106條之1第109條之3第109條之4及第206條之2均不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/324.wav", + "text": "(二)第109條及增訂第109條之二均照司法院行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/325.wav", + "text": "\n(三)增訂第109條之1第208條及增訂第二百十一條之1均照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/326.wav", + "text": "如附件1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/327.wav", + "text": "(四)第206條照司法院行政院提案之(甲案)司法院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/328.wav", + "text": "\n(五)其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/329.wav", + "text": "\n二刑事訴訟法施行法增訂第7條之5條文草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/330.wav", + "text": "增訂第7條之5照協商內容通過並將條次修正為第7條之9如附件2\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/331.wav", + "text": "稍待議事人員將協商結論書面製作完成後即交由委員簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/332.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15318/333.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15311/0.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15311/1.wav", + "text": "的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15311/2.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣促進尤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15311/3.wav", + "text": "如果我們在法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15311/4.wav", + "text": "保留送院會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15311/5.wav", + "text": "\n本案協商到此為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15311/6.wav", + "text": "散會謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/0.wav", + "text": "我們開始今天兩點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/1.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/2.wav", + "text": "證交法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/3.wav", + "text": "第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/4.wav", + "text": "商就是上個會期大家有討論到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/5.wav", + "text": "證券交易法第十四條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/6.wav", + "text": "提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/7.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/8.wav", + "text": "本院謝衣鳯委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/9.wav", + "text": "等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/10.wav", + "text": "具的修正草案逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/11.wav", + "text": "二讀這個大概就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/12.wav", + "text": "對於上市櫃公司的一些員工照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/13.wav", + "text": "福利等等相關的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/14.wav", + "text": "我們現在開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/15.wav", + "text": "我們先請主管機關表達他們對於修正案的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/16.wav", + "text": "委員好我講一下因為加薪這個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/17.wav", + "text": "其實我們基本上都是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/18.wav", + "text": "但是我們現行就有一些措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/19.wav", + "text": "比方對於年度的盈餘結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/20.wav", + "text": "我們認為是由股東員工來共同兼顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/21.wav", + "text": "整個市場平衡的自治事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/22.wav", + "text": "產業規模大小以及營運的型態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/23.wav", + "text": "其實結構都不是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/24.wav", + "text": "所以在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/25.wav", + "text": "直接明定由主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/26.wav", + "text": "跟找勞動部來訂定強制公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/27.wav", + "text": "的規定我們覺得這樣比較不適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/28.wav", + "text": "也許我們現行的作法就夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/29.wav", + "text": "也就是說我們現在對於員工的薪資狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/30.wav", + "text": "是要求它在年報要做揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/31.wav", + "text": "你有做得好我公司也給你加分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/32.wav", + "text": "鼓勵企業要給員工福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/33.wav", + "text": "第三點我們現在有編高薪100指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/34.wav", + "text": "指數如果變成了成分股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/35.wav", + "text": "我想市場的投資力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/36.wav", + "text": "就會介入來投資這個公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/37.wav", + "text": "用這種方式來鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/38.wav", + "text": "這樣的話自然的發展會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/39.wav", + "text": "如果是主管機關的規範因為剛才有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/40.wav", + "text": "到有些公司可能不是很賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/41.wav", + "text": "不是每年賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/42.wav", + "text": "我覺得這可能要很審慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/43.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/44.wav", + "text": "\n鍾委員有沒有要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/45.wav", + "text": "請鍾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/46.wav", + "text": "修法的用意是很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/47.wav", + "text": "因為這幾年來我們上市櫃公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/48.wav", + "text": "獲利都節節創新高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/49.wav", + "text": "但是上市櫃公司的獲利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/50.wav", + "text": "這是社會上一直在討論的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/51.wav", + "text": "我們覺得臺灣整體的薪資水準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/52.wav", + "text": "比起相對國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/53.wav", + "text": "是可以有成長的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/54.wav", + "text": "但是怎麼樣促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/55.wav", + "text": "尤其上市櫃公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/56.wav", + "text": "都是臺灣企業的表率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/57.wav", + "text": "都是比較有競爭力的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/58.wav", + "text": "在公司的績效上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/59.wav", + "text": "回過頭來變成他們的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/60.wav", + "text": "我想這有幾個方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/61.wav", + "text": "在那時候也提出過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/62.wav", + "text": "初期我們用揭露的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/63.wav", + "text": "讓上市公司對員工待遇的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/64.wav", + "text": "做一些揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/65.wav", + "text": "如果我們在法律上去要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/66.wav", + "text": "誠如剛剛所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/67.wav", + "text": "不同的產業型態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/68.wav", + "text": "有不同的利潤基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/69.wav", + "text": "在公司的營收上所占的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/70.wav", + "text": "都不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/71.wav", + "text": "要一致性的去訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/72.wav", + "text": "一個加薪的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/73.wav", + "text": "恐怕在不同產業上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/74.wav", + "text": "會遇到的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/75.wav", + "text": "\n我記得那時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/76.wav", + "text": "我跟主委也提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/77.wav", + "text": "我們比較關注的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/78.wav", + "text": "不患寡而患不均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/79.wav", + "text": "有些公司賺的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/80.wav", + "text": "通通進了高管的口袋裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/81.wav", + "text": "所以我們那時候是提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/82.wav", + "text": "希望將公司管理階層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/83.wav", + "text": "以及受薪階層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/84.wav", + "text": "我們看看它的比例怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/85.wav", + "text": "讓社會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/86.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得用意雖好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/87.wav", + "text": "但是過去看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/88.wav", + "text": "要落實是很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/89.wav", + "text": "所以我們覺得這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/90.wav", + "text": "是不是再送到院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/91.wav", + "text": "大家共同來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/92.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/93.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/94.wav", + "text": "還有謝衣鳯謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/95.wav", + "text": "勞工朋友非常辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/96.wav", + "text": "這幾年感覺經濟成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/97.wav", + "text": "的力度非常強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/98.wav", + "text": "甚至現在整個臺指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/99.wav", + "text": "即將可能破兩萬點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/100.wav", + "text": "現在還在努力在往上爬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/101.wav", + "text": "但是經濟成長的果實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/102.wav", + "text": "卻沒有受到全民的共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/103.wav", + "text": "貧者越貧富者越富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/104.wav", + "text": "我們看到上市櫃公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/105.wav", + "text": "大概有近兩千家公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/106.wav", + "text": "裡面充斥著許多的慣老闆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/107.wav", + "text": "猶記20年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/108.wav", + "text": "可能剛創業的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/109.wav", + "text": "胼手胝足給員工很多的承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/110.wav", + "text": "每一次每一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/111.wav", + "text": "都是說請大家共體時艱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/112.wav", + "text": "忍一下就過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/113.wav", + "text": "可是忍了又忍1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/114.wav", + "text": "0年又過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/115.wav", + "text": "這是一個櫥窗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/116.wav", + "text": "但是當股價已經破100塊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/117.wav", + "text": "還是老話一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/118.wav", + "text": "說面對外在強大的競爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/119.wav", + "text": "我們要多一點的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/120.wav", + "text": "留在公司當研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/121.wav", + "text": "所以所有員工的薪資也沒有調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/122.wav", + "text": "大概所有公股行庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/123.wav", + "text": "也是經過我們在財委會這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/124.wav", + "text": "好不容易同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/125.wav", + "text": "可是當面對從1顆荷包蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/126.wav", + "text": "5塊已經漲到1顆荷包蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/127.wav", + "text": "15塊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/128.wav", + "text": "即便是漲4%5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/129.wav", + "text": "杯水車薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/130.wav", + "text": "對於員工的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/131.wav", + "text": "對於這些辛苦的勞工朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/132.wav", + "text": "又有什麼樣的幫助呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/133.wav", + "text": "\n所以我想國民黨黨團所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/134.wav", + "text": "最主要是要有一股力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/135.wav", + "text": "來促使主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/136.wav", + "text": "大家可以共同來關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/137.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/138.wav", + "text": "否則今天講一講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/139.wav", + "text": "到了明年一樣沒加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/140.wav", + "text": "這個案子如果擺在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/141.wav", + "text": "會加薪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/142.wav", + "text": "也不到10%20%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/143.wav", + "text": "每一次都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/144.wav", + "text": "同樣的劇本不斷在演出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/145.wav", + "text": "當然大家剛剛也都表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/146.wav", + "text": "了所以我們是不是請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/147.wav", + "text": "大家共同思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/148.wav", + "text": "還有點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/149.wav", + "text": "我們這部分就是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/150.wav", + "text": "送院會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/151.wav", + "text": "請院長有機會再來協調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/152.wav", + "text": "\n鍾委員這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/153.wav", + "text": "不曉得還有沒有什麼其他的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/154.wav", + "text": "我們就確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/155.wav", + "text": "保留送院會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/156.wav", + "text": "\n本案協商到此為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15310/157.wav", + "text": "散會謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/0.wav", + "text": "我們是否就依照10月18日大家努力審查的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/1.wav", + "text": "來協商保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/2.wav", + "text": "我們就直接來協商保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/3.wav", + "text": "\n有關行政院保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/4.wav", + "text": "我們看這個資料好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/5.wav", + "text": "報告主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/6.wav", + "text": "第1條的部分是立法理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/7.wav", + "text": "我們這邊建議依行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/8.wav", + "text": "把確保勞工合理之最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/9.wav", + "text": "提高勞工及其家庭生活水準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/10.wav", + "text": "促進勞資和諧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/11.wav", + "text": "的立法理由維持原來的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/12.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/13.wav", + "text": "好經過行政單位再仔細研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/14.wav", + "text": "還是認為行政院原來提的比較適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/15.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/16.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華��員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/17.wav", + "text": "這一條我們有提修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/18.wav", + "text": "時力黨團有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/19.wav", + "text": "沒有第1條沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/20.wav", + "text": "第1條時力沒有意見好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/21.wav", + "text": "\n第1條就按照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/22.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/23.wav", + "text": "請行政部門說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/24.wav", + "text": "第3條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/25.wav", + "text": "要把一些相關的名詞定義在這邊定進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/26.wav", + "text": "而院版的條文是依照勞基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/27.wav", + "text": "我們建議依照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/28.wav", + "text": "比較不會有兩邊重複規定的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/29.wav", + "text": "說明欄的部分也有依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/30.wav", + "text": "上次委員會的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/31.wav", + "text": "來做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/32.wav", + "text": "請委員參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/33.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/34.wav", + "text": "按照原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/35.wav", + "text": "對建議按照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/36.wav", + "text": "上次委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/37.wav", + "text": "紅字的部分我們就加上來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/38.wav", + "text": "請委員參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/39.wav", + "text": "有補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/40.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/41.wav", + "text": "時力沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/42.wav", + "text": "好沒有就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/43.wav", + "text": "立法說明照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/44.wav", + "text": "提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/45.wav", + "text": "\n再來第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/46.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/47.wav", + "text": "罰則的部分因為有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/48.wav", + "text": "監督和處理的罰則會在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/49.wav", + "text": "訂定因為在本法的後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/50.wav", + "text": "已經有拆開來去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/51.wav", + "text": "做另外的規定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/52.wav", + "text": "因為跟委員的版本大概都有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/53.wav", + "text": "連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/54.wav", + "text": "那我們建議第4條第5條是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/55.wav", + "text": "按照行政院的版本就是分成兩條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/56.wav", + "text": "好謝謝行政部門的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/57.wav", + "text": "立法說明這邊好像有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/58.wav", + "text": "應該要能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/59.wav", + "text": "補充的部分我們在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/60.wav", + "text": "補充把勞工請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/61.wav", + "text": "雇主依最低工資給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/62.wav", + "text": "列進說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/63.wav", + "text": "不曉得大家有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/64.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有意見我們就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/65.wav", + "text": "第4條第5條按照行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/66.wav", + "text": "通過立法說明就按照行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/67.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/68.wav", + "text": "第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/69.wav", + "text": "是有關審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/70.wav", + "text": "委員組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/71.wav", + "text": "在原來行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/72.wav", + "text": "是三方委員各七人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/73.wav", + "text": "建議維持原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/74.wav", + "text": "奇數也比較能夠做進一步的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/75.wav", + "text": "處理以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/76.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/77.wav", + "text": "時力對這一條我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/78.wav", + "text": "非常的堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/79.wav", + "text": "主要理由就是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/80.wav", + "text": "勞動部的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/81.wav", + "text": "我們在修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/82.wav", + "text": "有增加一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/83.wav", + "text": "四人增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/84.wav", + "text": "為七人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/85.wav", + "text": "在審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/86.wav", + "text": "部長會擔任召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/87.wav", + "text": "召集人的工作主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/88.wav", + "text": "負責審議會的主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/89.wav", + "text": "與確保議事流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/90.wav", + "text": "的順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/91.wav", + "text": "所以召集人在主持會議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/92.wav", + "text": "應該保持一定程度的中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/93.wav", + "text": "勞動部的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/94.wav", + "text": "代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/95.wav", + "text": "在會議進行說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/96.wav", + "text": "所以增加勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/97.wav", + "text": "代表一人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/98.wav", + "text": "另外針對學者專家的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/99.wav", + "text": "部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/100.wav", + "text": "四名我們認為還不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/101.wav", + "text": "所以為了確保審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/102.wav", + "text": "專業性時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/103.wav", + "text": "時力黨團建議學者專家的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/104.wav", + "text": "提高為七名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/105.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/106.wav", + "text": "好謝謝時力的修正動議大家還有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/107.wav", + "text": "其實也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/108.wav", + "text": "支持勞動部應該有一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/109.wav", + "text": "代表因為部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/110.wav", + "text": "是擔任召集人���其實是會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/111.wav", + "text": "的主持而且是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/112.wav", + "text": "不太參與討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/113.wav", + "text": "所以勞動部應該要有一個代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/114.wav", + "text": "至於奇數的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/115.wav", + "text": "當時確實沒有考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/116.wav", + "text": "人數上好像會變成雙數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/117.wav", + "text": "所以這個解決方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/118.wav", + "text": "當然可以在學者專家上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/119.wav", + "text": "加一人或加幾人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/120.wav", + "text": "一個奇數的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/121.wav", + "text": "可調整的啦所以對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/122.wav", + "text": "我還是再一次表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/123.wav", + "text": "我的版本是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/124.wav", + "text": "認為勞動部應該有一位代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/125.wav", + "text": "如果怕人數是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/126.wav", + "text": "雙數的話可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/127.wav", + "text": "學者專家這邊再加人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/128.wav", + "text": "以上我的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/129.wav", + "text": "好行政部門說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/130.wav", + "text": "跟主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/131.wav", + "text": "各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/132.wav", + "text": "審議會的機制裡面就是三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/133.wav", + "text": "機制三方機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/134.wav", + "text": "裡勞和資就是對等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/135.wav", + "text": "的兩方再來公益方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/136.wav", + "text": "大概就會進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/137.wav", + "text": "等邊三角形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/138.wav", + "text": "又或是學者專家這邊再加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/139.wav", + "text": "人等於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/140.wav", + "text": "非屬勞工非屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/141.wav", + "text": "特別不平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/142.wav", + "text": "的三方架構裡面就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/143.wav", + "text": "最大的一方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/144.wav", + "text": "我們是參考其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/145.wav", + "text": "政府方大概是屬於公益方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/146.wav", + "text": "的這個區塊三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/147.wav", + "text": "的代表是人數相等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/148.wav", + "text": "我們是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/149.wav", + "text": "可否還是按照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/150.wav", + "text": "審議更為周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/151.wav", + "text": "專家代表的討論大概都可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/152.wav", + "text": "這樣的三方架構大致上都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/153.wav", + "text": "還可以運作希望三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/154.wav", + "text": "是平衡的這個部分大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/155.wav", + "text": "勞資雙方都有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/156.wav", + "text": "我是不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/157.wav", + "text": "應該是屬於公正方嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/158.wav", + "text": "嘛公正方的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/159.wav", + "text": "4人到7人應該沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/160.wav", + "text": "的權益應該不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/161.wav", + "text": "有什麼受損的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/162.wav", + "text": "所以增加7人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/163.wav", + "text": "認為還是值得去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/164.wav", + "text": "修正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/165.wav", + "text": "世界最主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/166.wav", + "text": "有最低工資的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/167.wav", + "text": "是三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/168.wav", + "text": "資方還有公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/169.wav", + "text": "就包括政府機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/170.wav", + "text": "代表跟學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/171.wav", + "text": "代表政府機關加學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/172.wav", + "text": "所以如果按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/173.wav", + "text": "公益方會變成11個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/174.wav", + "text": "勞資只有7個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/175.wav", + "text": "如果你原來的版本主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/176.wav", + "text": "扣掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/177.wav", + "text": "三個政府部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/178.wav", + "text": "經濟部國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/179.wav", + "text": "還有學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/180.wav", + "text": "勞動部還沒有加的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/181.wav", + "text": "勞動部還沒加的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/182.wav", + "text": "就是2人而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/183.wav", + "text": "如果按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/184.wav", + "text": "委員你這邊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/185.wav", + "text": "經濟部國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/186.wav", + "text": "再加勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/187.wav", + "text": "縱使扣掉勞動部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/188.wav", + "text": "還是有10個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/189.wav", + "text": "一般就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/190.wav", + "text": "等邊三角形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/191.wav", + "text": "各方都是一樣的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/192.wav", + "text": "所以部長的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/193.wav", + "text": "同意增加勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/194.wav", + "text": "代表1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/195.wav", + "text": "然後學者專家維持4個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/196.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/197.wav", + "text": "這樣就10個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/198.wav", + "text": "通過後可能未來會面臨到要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/199.wav", + "text": "我們現在大部分都是共識決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/200.wav", + "text": "很少用表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/201.wav", + "text": "那用表決的話一定要單數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/202.wav", + "text": "所以才會說勞動部本來有2名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/203.wav", + "text": "代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/204.wav", + "text": "就是現在的基本工資審議辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/205.wav", + "text": "中勞動部是有2個代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/206.wav", + "text": "一個是部長一個是勞動部代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/207.wav", + "text": "我們會有2個所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/208.wav", + "text": "以現在就是22名但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/209.wav", + "text": "22名但考慮到以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/210.wav", + "text": "可能會有表決的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/211.wav", + "text": "所以現在就變成勞動部少一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/212.wav", + "text": "因為部長是召集人兼勞動部代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/213.wav", + "text": "這樣的話就是21位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/214.wav", + "text": "好沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/215.wav", + "text": "我瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/216.wav", + "text": "部長跟勞動部的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/217.wav", + "text": "不過時力黨團建議還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/218.wav", + "text": "先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/219.wav", + "text": "好這一條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/220.wav", + "text": "第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/221.wav", + "text": "第9條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/222.wav", + "text": "應參採指標跟得參採指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/223.wav", + "text": "應參採指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/224.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/225.wav", + "text": "單列一個消費者物價指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/226.wav", + "text": "而得參採指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/227.wav", + "text": "考量進去的指標都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/228.wav", + "text": "版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/229.wav", + "text": "修正動議請說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/230.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/231.wav", + "text": "非常希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/232.wav", + "text": "時力的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/233.wav", + "text": "主要的原因就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/234.wav", + "text": "領取最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/235.wav", + "text": "的只能夠租屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/236.wav", + "text": "但是現在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/237.wav", + "text": "最低工資的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/238.wav", + "text": "應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/239.wav", + "text": "要有兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/240.wav", + "text": "調整的底線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/241.wav", + "text": "就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/242.wav", + "text": "我們增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/243.wav", + "text": "租金年增率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/244.wav", + "text": "等住宿的成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/245.wav", + "text": "我們修正的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/246.wav", + "text": "\n另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/247.wav", + "text": "增加了年度調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/248.wav", + "text": "幅度不得低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/249.wav", + "text": "消費者物價指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/250.wav", + "text": "年增率之漲幅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/251.wav", + "text": "且不得低於前一年最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/252.wav", + "text": "工資那主要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/253.wav", + "text": "認為既然本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/254.wav", + "text": "修法的目的是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/255.wav", + "text": "保障勞工合理的最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/256.wav", + "text": "工資就應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/257.wav", + "text": "參採我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/258.wav", + "text": "地板就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/259.wav", + "text": "整幅度不可以低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/260.wav", + "text": "消費者物價指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/261.wav", + "text": "CPI的年增率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/262.wav", + "text": "尤其在通膨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/263.wav", + "text": "成為現在新常態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/264.wav", + "text": "的未來對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/265.wav", + "text": "領取最低工資的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/266.wav", + "text": "來說物價上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/267.wav", + "text": "對他們的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/268.wav", + "text": "是最大的所以通膨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/269.wav", + "text": "將會直接影響到他們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/270.wav", + "text": "基本生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/271.wav", + "text": "水準所以我們擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/272.wav", + "text": "如果最低工資的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/273.wav", + "text": "幅度低於物價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/274.wav", + "text": "上漲的幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/275.wav", + "text": "事實上沒有辦法來確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/276.wav", + "text": "勞工擁有民生物品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/277.wav", + "text": "的基本購買力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/278.wav", + "text": "會對他們的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/279.wav", + "text": "帶來非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/280.wav", + "text": "大的壓力所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/281.wav", + "text": "我們在第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/282.wav", + "text": "加了年度調整幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/283.wav", + "text": "不得低於消費者物價指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/284.wav", + "text": "年增率的漲幅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/285.wav", + "text": "且不得低於前一年最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/286.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/287.wav", + "text": "行政部門回復一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/288.wav", + "text": "勞動部這邊做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/289.wav", + "text": "一些補充首先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/290.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/291.wav", + "text": "年增率要納進來為一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/292.wav", + "text": "得參採指標這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/293.wav", + "text": "部分其實在這個項次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/294.wav", + "text": "民生物價也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/295.wav", + "text": "消費者物價也好等這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/296.wav", + "text": "如果再把這裡面指標的其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/297.wav", + "text": "一個又抽出來在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/298.wav", + "text": "等於是重複的考慮啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/299.wav", + "text": "我們建議這個住宿成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/300.wav", + "text": "的指標其實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/301.wav", + "text": "原來的消費者物價已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/302.wav", + "text": "建議可以不用再特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/303.wav", + "text": "單列一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/304.wav", + "text": "\n第二個是兩個樓地板的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/305.wav", + "text": "首先先說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/306.wav", + "text": "不能低於前一年最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/307.wav", + "text": "工資從有這個基本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/308.wav", + "text": "工資之前我們是基本工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/309.wav", + "text": "從有設定這個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/310.wav", + "text": "以來沒有哪一年是往下調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/311.wav", + "text": "我們去看各個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/312.wav", + "text": "也都沒有往下調的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/313.wav", + "text": "基本上這一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/314.wav", + "text": "訂定因為沒有這樣子下修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/315.wav", + "text": "的例子\n第二個樓地板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/316.wav", + "text": "不要低於消費者物價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/317.wav", + "text": "指數的年增率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/318.wav", + "text": "感謝委員們有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/319.wav", + "text": "一個保護勞工的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/320.wav", + "text": "想法但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/321.wav", + "text": "我們考量到有時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/322.wav", + "text": "物價有往上走的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/323.wav", + "text": "但是當年度可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/324.wav", + "text": "還要考慮到我們這邊有一些得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/325.wav", + "text": "參採指標例如各產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/326.wav", + "text": "的發展情形和就業狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/327.wav", + "text": "比如說今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/328.wav", + "text": "物價指數如果上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/329.wav", + "text": "率可能狀況不是很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/330.wav", + "text": "失業率的狀況也是高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/331.wav", + "text": "需要做一些考慮那是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/332.wav", + "text": "可能無法十足反應呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/333.wav", + "text": "這個可能在我們委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/334.wav", + "text": "就會要保有一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/335.wav", + "text": "是保有一個彈性讓他可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/336.wav", + "text": "物價反應和就業率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/337.wav", + "text": "看哪一個是要做一些平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/338.wav", + "text": "應該會來做一個平衡的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/339.wav", + "text": "我們建議是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/340.wav", + "text": "保留這個彈性不要把這個樓地板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/341.wav", + "text": "加上去我們看其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/342.wav", + "text": "如果有審議機制的大概也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/343.wav", + "text": "百分之百把CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/344.wav", + "text": "的變動率一定列成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/345.wav", + "text": "不能低於的這個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/346.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/347.wav", + "text": "也謝謝說明不過我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/348.wav", + "text": "的確是對於勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/349.wav", + "text": "的最低工資以及生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/350.wav", + "text": "有正面的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/351.wav", + "text": "好那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/352.wav", + "text": "第9條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/353.wav", + "text": "吳委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/354.wav", + "text": "吳委員的是第幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/355.wav", + "text": "好吳委員的第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/356.wav", + "text": "我們建議還是依照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/357.wav", + "text": "考量通過這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/358.wav", + "text": "好其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/359.wav", + "text": "小組也是有一些連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/360.wav", + "text": "因為我的版本比較是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/361.wav", + "text": "能計算出一個公式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/362.wav", + "text": "剛剛第9條我沒有很堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/363.wav", + "text": "因為上次在審查會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/364.wav", + "text": "上勞動部也是一直說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/365.wav", + "text": "說這個公式非常難訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/366.wav", + "text": "因為訂出來了也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/367.wav", + "text": "有一定的難度因此我也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/368.wav", + "text": "很堅持這個公式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/369.wav", + "text": "對於這個定義我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/370.wav", + "text": "第十一條我也沒有堅持因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/371.wav", + "text": "後面等於是還要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/372.wav", + "text": "研究小組這個議題由研究小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/373.wav", + "text": "這邊來扮演一些比較重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/374.wav", + "text": "所以我可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/375.wav", + "text": "不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/376.wav", + "text": "委員吳玉琴等18人提案的第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/377.wav", + "text": "我們就先不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/378.wav", + "text": "\n接下來是第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/379.wav", + "text": "第10條的部分我們大概在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/380.wav", + "text": "每年的第三季會開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/381.wav", + "text": "二分之一以上的出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/382.wav", + "text": "的時候才會進行表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/383.wav", + "text": "過半數以上來做表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/384.wav", + "text": "要三分之二以上有的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/385.wav", + "text": "二分之一以上等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/386.wav", + "text": "大致上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/387.wav", + "text": "建議是不是可以依照院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/388.wav", + "text": "的條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/389.wav", + "text": "時力第10條沒有修正動議第10條沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/390.wav", + "text": "好如果沒有其他的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/391.wav", + "text": "第10條就按照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/392.wav", + "text": "版通過\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/393.wav", + "text": "第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/394.wav", + "text": "第十二條的部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/395.wav", + "text": "有關研究小組研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/396.wav", + "text": "最低工資法新設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/397.wav", + "text": "在每一年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/398.wav", + "text": "4月先做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/399.wav", + "text": "前一年相關調整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/400.wav", + "text": "研究影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/401.wav", + "text": "然後在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/402.wav", + "text": "第三季開會的30日前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/403.wav", + "text": "要作出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/404.wav", + "text": "研究報告和調整建議方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/405.wav", + "text": "給我們委員會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/406.wav", + "text": "小組的成員我們是以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/407.wav", + "text": "審議會裡面的4位學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/408.wav", + "text": "專家以及另增2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/409.wav", + "text": "位學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/410.wav", + "text": "外加相關的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/411.wav", + "text": "總共11人來做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/412.wav", + "text": "這個是希望能夠用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/413.wav", + "text": "比較客觀的數據來去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/414.wav", + "text": "做一個建議方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/415.wav", + "text": "讓委員可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/416.wav", + "text": "比較實質的聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/417.wav", + "text": "性的討論因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/418.wav", + "text": "因為各個委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/419.wav", + "text": "對於裡面的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/420.wav", + "text": "和組成有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/421.wav", + "text": "比較不一樣的意見但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/422.wav", + "text": "大致上都是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/423.wav", + "text": "這個研究小組可以更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/424.wav", + "text": "我們建議是不是可以先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/425.wav", + "text": "依照現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/426.wav", + "text": "實施上如果真的有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/427.wav", + "text": "其他要改進的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/428.wav", + "text": "以後修法之後我們再來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/429.wav", + "text": "一些調整以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/430.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/431.wav", + "text": "第十二條時力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/432.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/433.wav", + "text": "是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/434.wav", + "text": "第三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/435.wav", + "text": "的最後我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/436.wav", + "text": "這麼用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/437.wav", + "text": "成立了這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/438.wav", + "text": "也進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/439.wav", + "text": "事前的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/440.wav", + "text": "其所參採的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/441.wav", + "text": "研究報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/442.wav", + "text": "應該要公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/443.wav", + "text": "而且要公布在勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/444.wav", + "text": "最低工資審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/445.wav", + "text": "的專屬網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/446.wav", + "text": "所以我們在第三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/447.wav", + "text": "就是加了這一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/448.wav", + "text": "希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/449.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/450.wav", + "text": "有沒有人要再回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/451.wav", + "text": "報告委員上次我們通過的第十一條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/452.wav", + "text": "已經有一個網站會公開會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/453.wav", + "text": "資料及紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/454.wav", + "text": "委員會通過的第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/455.wav", + "text": "就有說會議的議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/456.wav", + "text": "資料和紀錄都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/457.wav", + "text": "在結束後的30日內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/458.wav", + "text": "布因為這一個相關的研究報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/459.wav", + "text": "所以它會是會議資料的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/460.wav", + "text": "併同會議資料一起在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/461.wav", + "text": "會議後30日內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/462.wav", + "text": "公布這可以跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/463.wav", + "text": "做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/464.wav", + "text": "不是在專屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/465.wav", + "text": "會有一個區來公布我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/466.wav", + "text": "是沒有衝突的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/467.wav", + "text": "勞動部的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/468.wav", + "text": "不過現在就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/469.wav", + "text": "研究報告公布的時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/470.wav", + "text": "其實對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/471.wav", + "text": "相關審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/472.wav", + "text": "還有讓民間團體了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/473.wav", + "text": "滿重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/474.wav", + "text": "這一條時力還是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/475.wav", + "text": "在事前公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/476.wav", + "text": "應該是值得政府來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/477.wav", + "text": "做的所以我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/478.wav", + "text": "建議保留謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/479.wav", + "text": "時力建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/480.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我也建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/481.wav", + "text": "因為我們的版本跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/482.wav", + "text": "行政院版的差別是我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/483.wav", + "text": "變成行政院的第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/484.wav", + "text": "我們這邊想要堅持的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/485.wav", + "text": "有關於研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/486.wav", + "text": "勞動部專屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/487.wav", + "text": "網站公布這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/488.wav", + "text": "之前已經講過研究小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/489.wav", + "text": "每年四月會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/490.wav", + "text": "審議報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/491.wav", + "text": "開審議會前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/492.wav", + "text": "一個月他們會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/493.wav", + "text": "報告讓大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/494.wav", + "text": "提出調整方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/495.wav", + "text": "如果這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/496.wav", + "text": "勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/497.wav", + "text": "審議前提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/498.wav", + "text": "那就是少了後段所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/499.wav", + "text": "建議是不是可以把我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/500.wav", + "text": "第9條第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/501.wav", + "text": "或很多專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/502.wav", + "text": "以及社會大眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/503.wav", + "text": "甚至是企業代表都可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/504.wav", + "text": "這個研究的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/505.wav", + "text": "調整之後的產業衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/506.wav", + "text": "提早進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/507.wav", + "text": "自己的因應或者是提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/508.wav", + "text": "去瞭解他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/509.wav", + "text": "我相信這是正向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/510.wav", + "text": "的這並不是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/511.wav", + "text": "不好的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/512.wav", + "text": "我們的第9條第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/513.wav", + "text": "可以加在你們第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/514.wav", + "text": "的後項這是我的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/515.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/516.wav", + "text": "三十天內提出報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/517.wav", + "text": "沒有錯這個跟院版是一樣的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/518.wav", + "text": "民眾黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/519.wav", + "text": "跟院版也沒有衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/520.wav", + "text": "因為它這個講這個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/521.wav", + "text": "要公布於勞動部的網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/522.wav", + "text": "這也沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/523.wav", + "text": "民眾黨團跟時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/524.wav", + "text": "有一點不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/525.wav", + "text": "以民眾黨團的來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/526.wav", + "text": "就先公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/527.wav", + "text": "其實所有研究報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/528.wav", + "text": "使用參考用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/529.wav", + "text": "都還沒有決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/530.wav", + "text": "依照我們上次通過的第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/531.wav", + "text": "整個大會會後的三十日之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/532.wav", + "text": "把會議議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/533.wav", + "text": "因為研究報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/534.wav", + "text": "會是議程的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/535.wav", + "text": "以及會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/536.wav", + "text": "都做完整的公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/537.wav", + "text": "後面讓大家可受公評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/538.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/539.wav", + "text": "是堅持研究報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/540.wav", + "text": "這是有一點差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/541.wav", + "text": "跟院版是沒有衝突的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/542.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/543.wav", + "text": "因為時力已經提出要保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/544.wav", + "text": "司長我們的寫法是在第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/545.wav", + "text": "所以我前項的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/546.wav", + "text": "是建議在你們會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/547.wav", + "text": "開始前三十日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/548.wav", + "text": "所以我們的邏輯是跟他們類近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/549.wav", + "text": "也是要提前嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/550.wav", + "text": "就是開會前你已經給他們了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/551.wav", + "text": "這樣子前項的報告就公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/552.wav", + "text": "布如果需要在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/553.wav", + "text": "我們可以說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/554.wav", + "text": "但是概念上是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/555.wav", + "text": "好這一條就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/556.wav", + "text": "接下來第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/557.wav", + "text": "在前次保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/558.wav", + "text": "大家會關心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/559.wav", + "text": "報給行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/560.wav", + "text": "行政院在不予核定的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/561.wav", + "text": "退回勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/562.wav", + "text": "由審議會再開一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/563.wav", + "text": "再來做審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/564.wav", + "text": "審議結果後再報過去行政院的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/565.wav", + "text": "行政院是不是就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/566.wav", + "text": "第二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/567.wav", + "text": "呈報來做核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/568.wav", + "text": "我們大概在上一次有做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/569.wav", + "text": "報請行政院核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/570.wav", + "text": "各位委員所擔心的部分即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/571.wav", + "text": "第二次行政院會不會再退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/572.wav", + "text": "大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/573.wav", + "text": "的文字部分是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/574.wav", + "text": "就是大家資料裡面有紅字的兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/575.wav", + "text": "報請行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/576.wav", + "text": "予以核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/577.wav", + "text": "指再報的第二次案子就是請行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/578.wav", + "text": "按照這個來核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/579.wav", + "text": "部分也有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/580.wav", + "text": "並將審議結果報送行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/581.wav", + "text": "由行政院予以核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/582.wav", + "text": "如果再審過來再送行政院的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/583.wav", + "text": "就請行政院依照這個來核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/584.wav", + "text": "只是文字上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/585.wav", + "text": "比原來的寫得再清楚一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/586.wav", + "text": "好謝謝\n請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/587.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/588.wav", + "text": "行政院的這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/589.wav", + "text": "加兩個字就表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/590.wav", + "text": "只能退一次是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/591.wav", + "text": "\n很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/592.wav", + "text": "就是只能退一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/593.wav", + "text": "再送就不能再退了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/594.wav", + "text": "就要核定了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/595.wav", + "text": "修正動議是更明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/596.wav", + "text": "啦就是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/597.wav", + "text": "放在第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/598.wav", + "text": "前項審議結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/599.wav", + "text": "行政院應予核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/600.wav", + "text": "不知道是否可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/601.wav", + "text": "修正成時力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/602.wav", + "text": "這樣子的文字是不是會更明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/603.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/604.wav", + "text": "予以核定的意思就是應予核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/605.wav", + "text": "意思一樣比較簡潔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/606.wav", + "text": "啦\n就不用再重複列一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/607.wav", + "text": "好我們就接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/608.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/609.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/610.wav", + "text": "謝謝第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/611.wav", + "text": "就按照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/612.wav", + "text": "立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/613.wav", + "text": "行政院版修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/614.wav", + "text": "接下來第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/615.wav", + "text": "十六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/616.wav", + "text": "報告第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/617.wav", + "text": "是有關最低工資的監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/618.wav", + "text": "和檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/619.wav", + "text": "監督和檢查部分因為勞動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/620.wav", + "text": "基準法已經有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/621.wav", + "text": "監督和檢查的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/622.wav", + "text": "而最低工資其實也會跟其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/623.wav", + "text": "工資等等都有連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/624.wav", + "text": "至於檢查和監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/625.wav", + "text": "部分現在的機制其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/626.wav", + "text": "是可以鏈結得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/627.wav", + "text": "我們建議依照行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/628.wav", + "text": "來做處理其他委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/629.wav", + "text": "版本因為原來的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/630.wav", + "text": "的部分包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/631.wav", + "text": "處罰等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/632.wav", + "text": "這些有另外的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/633.wav", + "text": "就可以把大家的意見都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/634.wav", + "text": "容納進來以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/635.wav", + "text": "先通過第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/636.wav", + "text": "然後要增加第十六條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/637.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/638.wav", + "text": "好第十六條照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/639.wav", + "text": "第十六條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/640.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/641.wav", + "text": "它跟委員江永昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/642.wav", + "text": "提的第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/643.wav", + "text": "委員林為洲等16人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/644.wav", + "text": "第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/645.wav", + "text": "委員范雲等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/646.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團提案第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/647.wav", + "text": "委員蔣萬安等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/648.wav", + "text": "委員廖國棟等16人提案第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/649.wav", + "text": "十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/650.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/651.wav", + "text": "一併討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/652.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/653.wav", + "text": "時力黨團提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/654.wav", + "text": "第十六條之1就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/655.wav", + "text": "同江永昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/656.wav", + "text": "這個部分是類似的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/657.wav", + "text": "十六條之1是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/658.wav", + "text": "為了督促企業落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/659.wav", + "text": "最低工資規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/660.wav", + "text": "應排除違法廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/661.wav", + "text": "參加政府採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/662.wav", + "text": "而且要列入政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/663.wav", + "text": "的黑名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/664.wav", + "text": "也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/665.wav", + "text": "能夠讓整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/666.wav", + "text": "採購的作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/667.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/668.wav", + "text": "我希望勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/669.wav", + "text": "可以參採這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/670.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得這個跟整體法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/671.wav", + "text": "的罰鍰本身的連動性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/672.wav", + "text": "願意法遵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/673.wav", + "text": "而且做到最低標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/674.wav", + "text": "的法遵所以如果違反的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/675.wav", + "text": "不是大家側重的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/676.wav", + "text": "而是應該讓它知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/677.wav", + "text": "這個基本的標準都達不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/678.wav", + "text": "我覺得就要剝奪它在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/679.wav", + "text": "其他商業上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/680.wav", + "text": "一些權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/681.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/682.wav", + "text": "警示性的作用很強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/683.wav", + "text": "必須列在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/684.wav", + "text": "最低工資法因為是單獨立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/685.wav", + "text": "而且是大家期待這麼久的一部法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/686.wav", + "text": "如果只有罰錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/687.wav", + "text": "像其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/688.wav", + "text": "立法例一樣沒有太大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/689.wav", + "text": "但是第十四條的部分民眾黨版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/690.wav", + "text": "是第十四條時代力量黨版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/691.wav", + "text": "好像是第十六條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/692.wav", + "text": "都能夠透過政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/693.wav", + "text": "一些廠商能夠知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/694.wav", + "text": "最基本的法遵是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/695.wav", + "text": "它在投資標的裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/696.wav", + "text": "必須要做到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/697.wav", + "text": "它不是附帶性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/698.wav", + "text": "附隨性的資格以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/699.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/700.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在還在進行的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/701.wav", + "text": "第十六條剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/702.wav", + "text": "第十六條通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/703.wav", + "text": "因為上次在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/704.wav", + "text": "他建議不要在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/705.wav", + "text": "重複訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/706.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/707.wav", + "text": "工程會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/708.wav", + "text": "工程會有來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/709.wav", + "text": "請說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/710.wav", + "text": "各位委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/711.wav", + "text": "在契約裡面已經有明定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/712.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/713.wav", + "text": "廠商應該遵守勞動的相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/714.wav", + "text": "法令也有明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/715.wav", + "text": "如果它今天有違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/716.wav", + "text": "範情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/717.wav", + "text": "就會連動到政府採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/718.wav", + "text": "第101條第1項第十二款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/719.wav", + "text": "我們那時候是建議它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/720.wav", + "text": "它在整個違約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/721.wav", + "text": "時會接到停權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/722.wav", + "text": "的處置事實上是有一個完整的配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/723.wav", + "text": "依行政院版的內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/724.wav", + "text": "如果是契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/725.wav", + "text": "範本就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/726.wav", + "text": "這樣還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/727.wav", + "text": "不如法律的明定啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/728.wav", + "text": "因為契約範本的效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/729.wav", + "text": "力不如法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/730.wav", + "text": "範本內容也可能會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/731.wav", + "text": "修改不如法律明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/732.wav", + "text": "我早上有開一個記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/733.wav", + "text": "就是有違法廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/734.wav", + "text": "兩年又來承攬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/735.wav", + "text": "涉嫌同樣的犯罪行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/736.wav", + "text": "所以如果我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/737.wav", + "text": "能夠在法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/738.wav", + "text": "把它規範地更明確我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/739.wav", + "text": "是可以規避的因為像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/740.wav", + "text": "訂定很重的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/741.wav", + "text": "一些會危害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/742.wav", + "text": "這樣的採購行為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/743.wav", + "text": "認為訂在契約範本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/744.wav", + "text": "還是不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/745.wav", + "text": "我們的法能夠更明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/746.wav", + "text": "讓違法的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/747.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/748.wav", + "text": "參加政府的採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/749.wav", + "text": "並列入黑名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/750.wav", + "text": "重視尤其是勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/751.wav", + "text": "現在職安署的查核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/752.wav", + "text": "如果沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/753.wav", + "text": "有這麼多人力我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/754.wav", + "text": "就讓一些違" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/755.wav", + "text": "法的廠商不要納入採購的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/756.wav", + "text": "如果這樣討論我們這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/757.wav", + "text": "就先保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/758.wav", + "text": "有關這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/759.wav", + "text": "就全部保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/760.wav", + "text": "包括剛剛\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/761.wav", + "text": "\n時代力量的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/762.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/763.wav", + "text": "如果勞動部沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/764.wav", + "text": "現在就決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/765.wav", + "text": "那就保留我們再溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/766.wav", + "text": "我們希望法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/767.wav", + "text": "定得更嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/768.wav", + "text": "追求大家所期待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/769.wav", + "text": "還是合乎行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/770.wav", + "text": "可以順利來照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/771.wav", + "text": "我們勞工的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/772.wav", + "text": "啦\n接下來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/773.wav", + "text": "第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/774.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/775.wav", + "text": "第十七條的部分是有關罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/776.wav", + "text": "就跟我們現行勞基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/777.wav", + "text": "對於基本工資的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/778.wav", + "text": "在額度上面二萬到一百萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/779.wav", + "text": "也有依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/780.wav", + "text": "事業單位規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/781.wav", + "text": "可以加重處罰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/782.wav", + "text": "法定罰鍰最高額二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/783.wav", + "text": "以及公布姓名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/784.wav", + "text": "或是按次處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/785.wav", + "text": "審酌相關違法情形的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/786.wav", + "text": "為量罰輕重的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/787.wav", + "text": "這個部分都跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/788.wav", + "text": "勞基法現在有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/789.wav", + "text": "基本工資的罰則是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/790.wav", + "text": "最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/791.wav", + "text": "這邊特別把它移過來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/792.wav", + "text": "各個委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/793.wav", + "text": "金額上面一點點的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/794.wav", + "text": "基本上其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/795.wav", + "text": "用意都跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/796.wav", + "text": "原來的院版是相同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/797.wav", + "text": "希望支持院版的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/798.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/799.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/800.wav", + "text": "第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/801.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/802.wav", + "text": "第十七條就按照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/803.wav", + "text": "其餘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/804.wav", + "text": "均按照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/805.wav", + "text": "請教主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/806.wav", + "text": "現在就是那個罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/807.wav", + "text": "我當時有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/808.wav", + "text": "我們民眾黨團在第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/809.wav", + "text": "第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/810.wav", + "text": "次數按次處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/811.wav", + "text": "主管機關並得限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/812.wav", + "text": "期令其給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/813.wav", + "text": "是還包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/814.wav", + "text": "勞工人數累計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/815.wav", + "text": "違法次數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/816.wav", + "text": "或未依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/817.wav", + "text": "給付之金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/818.wav", + "text": "作為量罰輕重之基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/819.wav", + "text": "現在很多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/820.wav", + "text": "處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/821.wav", + "text": "像勞基法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/822.wav", + "text": "並沒有特別像依法給付金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/823.wav", + "text": "裁罰的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/824.wav", + "text": "大概都是用事業單位規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/825.wav", + "text": "基本工資處罰的部分你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/826.wav", + "text": "在這裡會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/827.wav", + "text": "這麼多類型的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/828.wav", + "text": "到底你們考慮的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/829.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/830.wav", + "text": "報告委員目前這邊寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/831.wav", + "text": "各個處罰的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/832.wav", + "text": "現在的處罰規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/833.wav", + "text": "都一樣的就是有關工資的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/834.wav", + "text": "因為勞基法也有一些有關工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/835.wav", + "text": "沒有全額直接給付沒有按時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/836.wav", + "text": "基本工資本來也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/837.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個類型就是工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/838.wav", + "text": "沒有依照法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/839.wav", + "text": "工資保障要求來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/840.wav", + "text": "做給付的大概都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/841.wav", + "text": "包括後面的要求限期改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/842.wav", + "text": "這個限期改善就跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/843.wav", + "text": "在講的限期給付是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/844.wav", + "text": "意思你的改善當然就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/845.wav", + "text": "你原來要給的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/846.wav", + "text": "錢少了你把它補足這個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/847.wav", + "text": "地方政府對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/848.wav", + "text": "的改善如果要求你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/849.wav", + "text": "要補付工資結果你不補付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/850.wav", + "text": "我還可以再按次來處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/851.wav", + "text": "這個跟勞基法目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/852.wav", + "text": "的是一樣的所以跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/853.wav", + "text": "在提在關心的是沒有差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/854.wav", + "text": "勞基法現行處罰規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/855.wav", + "text": "是介接一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/856.wav", + "text": "比較不會有一些落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/857.wav", + "text": "已經可以含括了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/858.wav", + "text": "我的內容反而沒有你那麼��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/859.wav", + "text": "應給付金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/860.wav", + "text": "或有關勞工人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/861.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟地方政府裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/862.wav", + "text": "裁罰基準如果再細分類到勞工人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/863.wav", + "text": "未依法給付金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/864.wav", + "text": "的次分類去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/865.wav", + "text": "啦只是我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/866.wav", + "text": "我們自己在做裁罰的地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/867.wav", + "text": "它大概就是依違反的次數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/868.wav", + "text": "然後依事業單位規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/869.wav", + "text": "中大型企業上市上櫃企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/870.wav", + "text": "就用這個企業規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/871.wav", + "text": "金額的分級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/872.wav", + "text": "所以沒有像這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/873.wav", + "text": "未依法給付金額等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/874.wav", + "text": "所以我說你寫這麼細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/875.wav", + "text": "會不會讓地方政府做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/876.wav", + "text": "這個裁罰基準的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/877.wav", + "text": "是多一些依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/878.wav", + "text": "我只是在確認你們的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/879.wav", + "text": "是我們現在是多給它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/880.wav", + "text": "我們其實有跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/881.wav", + "text": "地方政府密切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/882.wav", + "text": "叫違反勞動基準法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/883.wav", + "text": "裁處罰鍰共通性原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/884.wav", + "text": "把所有的縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/885.wav", + "text": "包括我們這邊法條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/886.wav", + "text": "訂的人數也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/887.wav", + "text": "違法次數也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/888.wav", + "text": "未依法給付的金額也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/889.wav", + "text": "都請他們自己衡酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/890.wav", + "text": "要因地制宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/891.wav", + "text": "我們可以允許他因地制宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/892.wav", + "text": "但這幾個部分都是讓他在裁罰的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/893.wav", + "text": "可以來考量的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/894.wav", + "text": "有的時候是你違反的金額比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/895.wav", + "text": "其實就沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/896.wav", + "text": "那它就要去衡酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/897.wav", + "text": "這個違法的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/898.wav", + "text": "要給他裁罰重一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/899.wav", + "text": "對人數多一點情節重一點的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/900.wav", + "text": "它自己就會做一些分類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/901.wav", + "text": "有的縣市政府沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/902.wav", + "text": "完全自己再訂一個裁罰標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/903.wav", + "text": "但是它還是依照共通性原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/904.wav", + "text": "這個我們也看到有的縣市政府是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/905.wav", + "text": "還是哪個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/906.wav", + "text": "有提到不確定法律觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/907.wav", + "text": "那一位還在嗎今天有來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/908.wav", + "text": "對您這樣聽完你的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/909.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/910.wav", + "text": "意見他們法務沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/911.wav", + "text": "我們就接受支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/912.wav", + "text": "好第十七條就照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/913.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/914.wav", + "text": "通通把它處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/915.wav", + "text": "大家如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/916.wav", + "text": "的話其餘均照審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/917.wav", + "text": "第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/918.wav", + "text": "次及援引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/919.wav", + "text": "條次授權議事人員調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/920.wav", + "text": "今天協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/921.wav", + "text": "結束主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/922.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/923.wav", + "text": "補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/924.wav", + "text": "等一下再散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/925.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/926.wav", + "text": "一協商通過條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/927.wav", + "text": "第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/928.wav", + "text": "二照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/929.wav", + "text": "第一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/930.wav", + "text": "第三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/931.wav", + "text": "第四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/932.wav", + "text": "第十六條及第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/933.wav", + "text": "三不予採納委員吳玉琴等18人提案第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/934.wav", + "text": "四保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/935.wav", + "text": "第九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/936.wav", + "text": "第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/937.wav", + "text": "(二)江永昌等17人提案第二十條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/938.wav", + "text": "委員徐志榮等25人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/939.wav", + "text": "委員林為洲等16人提案第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/940.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團提案第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/941.wav", + "text": "委員蔣萬安等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/942.wav", + "text": "委員廖國棟等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/943.wav", + "text": "提案第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/944.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/945.wav", + "text": "五其餘均照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/946.wav", + "text": "審查會審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/947.wav", + "text": "時力黨團是第十六條之1喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/948.wav", + "text": "你剛剛念第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/949.wav", + "text": "對六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/950.wav", + "text": "授權議事人員調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/951.wav", + "text": "宣讀完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/952.wav", + "text": "好有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/953.wav", + "text": "我們今天的會議就到這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15306/954.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/0.wav", + "text": "時間已經到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/1.wav", + "text": "陸海空軍刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/2.wav", + "text": "案現在我們就協商司法及法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/3.wav", + "text": "外交及國防兩委員會併案審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/4.wav", + "text": "行政院函請審議陸海空軍刑法部分條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/5.wav", + "text": "等5案審查會前於111年5月11日審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/6.wav", + "text": "審查結果有保留5個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/7.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/8.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/9.wav", + "text": "我們這邊簡單報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/10.wav", + "text": "是分別以二個條文來規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/11.wav", + "text": "有委員針對有關於敵人的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/12.wav", + "text": "有提出了一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/13.wav", + "text": "我們都有分別到各委員那邊去做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/14.wav", + "text": "委員他們對於院版的內容也都表示同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/15.wav", + "text": "再來就是附帶決議裡有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/16.wav", + "text": "當初劉世芳委員希望我們提交的一份報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/17.wav", + "text": "我們也都有分別到各黨團去跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/18.wav", + "text": "說明不論是在野黨黨團或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/19.wav", + "text": "當初有疑問的一些委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/20.wav", + "text": "我們都已分別去做過說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/21.wav", + "text": "他們對於我們說明的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/22.wav", + "text": "跟我們所提的這些相關條文對照表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/23.wav", + "text": "建議照院版通過的這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/24.wav", + "text": "附帶決議要求的報告都交了還要訂嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/25.wav", + "text": "就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/26.wav", + "text": "是好那沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/27.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛有詢問各黨團的助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/28.wav", + "text": "今天因為我們協商時間排得比較晚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/29.wav", + "text": "加上這個會期比較特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/30.wav", + "text": "可能各黨團的委員都很忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/31.wav", + "text": "不過既然剛才國防部代表說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/32.wav", + "text": "事先都已經先予溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/33.wav", + "text": "了我們就試擬協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/34.wav", + "text": "然後讓各黨團帶回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/35.wav", + "text": "確認是否經過各黨團的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/36.wav", + "text": "假設各黨團願意簽字的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/37.wav", + "text": "我們就送院會進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/38.wav", + "text": "如果不行的話我們就擇期再來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/39.wav", + "text": "是第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/40.wav", + "text": "第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/41.wav", + "text": "第2條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/42.wav", + "text": "以及第22條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/43.wav", + "text": "依照剛才國防部的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/44.wav", + "text": "各黨團的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/45.wav", + "text": "跟之前審查時有意見的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/46.wav", + "text": "都同意照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/47.wav", + "text": "至於第22條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/48.wav", + "text": "照你們的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/49.wav", + "text": "也已經有跟時代力量黨團溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/50.wav", + "text": "過了那我們就不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/51.wav", + "text": "好那我們就以這個方向來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/52.wav", + "text": "擬協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/53.wav", + "text": "再交由各黨團簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/54.wav", + "text": "字\n本日協商結論如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/55.wav", + "text": "第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/56.wav", + "text": "均照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/57.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團提案增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/58.wav", + "text": "第22條之一不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/59.wav", + "text": "審查會保留附帶決議1項予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/60.wav", + "text": "稍待議事人員將協商結論書面製作完成後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15277/61.wav", + "text": "就交由委員簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/0.wav", + "text": "各位黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/1.wav", + "text": "委員先進及行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/2.wav", + "text": "部門代表大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/3.wav", + "text": "我們現在來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/4.wav", + "text": "殯葬管理條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/5.wav", + "text": "增訂第21條之2條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/6.wav", + "text": "委員楊瓊瓔等19人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/7.wav", + "text": "及委員邱議瑩等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/8.wav", + "text": "分別擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/9.wav", + "text": "殯葬管理條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/10.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/11.wav", + "text": "案之黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/12.wav", + "text": "本次協商內政委員會審查完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/13.wav", + "text": "殯葬管理條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/14.wav", + "text": "112年4月27日及5月24日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/15.wav", + "text": "召開會議審查完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/16.wav", + "text": "保留其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/17.wav", + "text": "委員蘇巧慧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/18.wav", + "text": "提案增訂第21條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/19.wav", + "text": "張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/20.wav", + "text": "啊對楊瓊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/21.wav", + "text": "你們這個內政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/22.wav", + "text": "內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/23.wav", + "text": "真的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/24.wav", + "text": "我又不是張瓊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/25.wav", + "text": "因為你比張瓊姿漂亮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/26.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/27.wav", + "text": "看到美女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/28.wav", + "text": "你要體諒我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/29.wav", + "text": "我剛剛一個便當是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/30.wav", + "text": "提案增列第37條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/31.wav", + "text": "總共三條條文交付協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/32.wav", + "text": "\n我們聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/33.wav", + "text": "一下為了爭取立法時效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/34.wav", + "text": "今天就協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/35.wav", + "text": "委員會保留的那些條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/36.wav", + "text": "應該沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/37.wav", + "text": "啦兩位有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/38.wav", + "text": "沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/39.wav", + "text": "剩下的應該都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/40.wav", + "text": "\n我們先開始審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/41.wav", + "text": "你們沒有做成表格嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/42.wav", + "text": "好像跟你們的差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/43.wav", + "text": "它的基準基本上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/44.wav", + "text": "由中央來定對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/45.wav", + "text": "就是已經整個都有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/46.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/47.wav", + "text": "嘛由各個直轄市縣(市)政府來定就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/48.wav", + "text": "我們不用在這裡定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/49.wav", + "text": "好那就是原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/50.wav", + "text": "不予修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/51.wav", + "text": "就原來的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/52.wav", + "text": "不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/53.wav", + "text": "不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/54.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/55.wav", + "text": "這一本白色的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/56.wav", + "text": "上面內政部有建議修正條文的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/57.wav", + "text": "給主席臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/58.wav", + "text": "你們有增加什麼嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/59.wav", + "text": "第21條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/60.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/61.wav", + "text": "他們就同意這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/62.wav", + "text": "就照內政部建議的條文修正通過啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/63.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/64.wav", + "text": "跟蘇巧慧委員提案的差別在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/65.wav", + "text": "沒有啦沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/66.wav", + "text": "內政部的建議條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/67.wav", + "text": "授權給直轄市跟縣(市)政府去做啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/68.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/69.wav", + "text": "你也是尊重蘇巧慧委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/70.wav", + "text": "你們建議直接就授權嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/71.wav", + "text": "在這裡直接授權很好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/72.wav", + "text": "這樣其實更好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/73.wav", + "text": "這個條文我們不能提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/74.wav", + "text": "沒有你們已經修訂啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/75.wav", + "text": "我們的是建議文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/76.wav", + "text": "現在蘇巧慧委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/77.wav", + "text": "項目之標準由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/78.wav", + "text": "藍綠委員跟行政部門內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/79.wav", + "text": "同意共同討論的修正後條文內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/80.wav", + "text": "內政部建議條文啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/81.wav", + "text": "對對對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/82.wav", + "text": "費之標準由直轄市縣(市)政府定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/83.wav", + "text": "這個意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/84.wav", + "text": "你們尊重蘇巧慧委員的提案啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/85.wav", + "text": "然後就把那個條文做更明確的授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/86.wav", + "text": "這樣其實是更好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/87.wav", + "text": "依照協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/88.wav", + "text": "這個你們改得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/89.wav", + "text": "更明確啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/90.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/91.wav", + "text": "依照我們協商的內容通過啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/92.wav", + "text": "協商條文就是內政部建議的這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/93.wav", + "text": "內政部建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/94.wav", + "text": "我們協商通過啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/95.wav", + "text": "我們協商啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/96.wav", + "text": "我們等一下會把整個協商結論唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/97.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/98.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/99.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/100.wav", + "text": "現在有個第35條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/101.wav", + "text": "那時候在審查會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/102.wav", + "text": "好像行政單位要補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/103.wav", + "text": "留現在要加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/104.wav", + "text": "財政部要加說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/105.wav", + "text": "上次有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/106.wav", + "text": "資料在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/107.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/108.wav", + "text": "17人擬具殯葬管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/109.wav", + "text": "這一份修正對照表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/110.wav", + "text": "5月24日的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/111.wav", + "text": "就已經有提出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/112.wav", + "text": "就是並免徵營業稅及營利事業所得稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/113.wav", + "text": "當時會議確實是有決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/114.wav", + "text": "刪掉的理由是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/115.wav", + "text": "這本來就不是營業稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/116.wav", + "text": "跟營利事業所得稅的課稅範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/117.wav", + "text": "所以自然就沒有免徵的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/118.wav", + "text": "立法說明的第四點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/119.wav", + "text": "如果把文字刪掉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/120.wav", + "text": "並免徵上開稅捐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/121.wav", + "text": "就會有一點對不起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/122.wav", + "text": "所以財政部才會去擬這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/123.wav", + "text": "建議的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/124.wav", + "text": "對在說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/125.wav", + "text": "特別再去講清楚就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/126.wav", + "text": "課徵營業稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/127.wav", + "text": "跟營利事業所得稅的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/128.wav", + "text": "啦所以上次也有決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/129.wav", + "text": "是不是就照財政部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/130.wav", + "text": "立法說明來修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/131.wav", + "text": "因為我們看上次會議決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/132.wav", + "text": "的議事錄裡面沒有講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/133.wav", + "text": "我們怕又發生爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/134.wav", + "text": "所以這一次就特別再提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/135.wav", + "text": "等一下他這是立法說明的增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/136.wav", + "text": "等一下我們一樣一樣來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/137.wav", + "text": "我們先不好意思討論那個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/138.wav", + "text": "然後再來討論立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/139.wav", + "text": "啦要增加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/140.wav", + "text": "讓以後執行法律的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/141.wav", + "text": "比較瞭解清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/142.wav", + "text": "啦我們先討論條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/143.wav", + "text": "等一下這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/144.wav", + "text": "我們會另外來跟你討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/145.wav", + "text": "第29頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/146.wav", + "text": "大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/147.wav", + "text": "這一本的第29頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/148.wav", + "text": "為什麼官員沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/149.wav", + "text": "一樣的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/150.wav", + "text": "他們有他們的版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/151.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有這個第29頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/152.wav", + "text": "第36條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/153.wav", + "text": "我們先討論楊瓊瓔跟邱議瑩委員都在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/154.wav", + "text": "時間也很寶貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/155.wav", + "text": "討論第29頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/156.wav", + "text": "他們手上為什麼沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/157.wav", + "text": "司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/158.wav", + "text": "怎麼會沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/159.wav", + "text": "不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/160.wav", + "text": "啦內政部的資料比較簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/161.wav", + "text": "嘛就是直接解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/162.wav", + "text": "但是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/163.wav", + "text": "這個其實主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/164.wav", + "text": "上一次已經有一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/165.wav", + "text": "只是文字怎麼樣去調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/166.wav", + "text": "你們內政部講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/167.wav", + "text": "36條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/168.wav", + "text": "這個資料的第29頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/169.wav", + "text": "我先說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/170.wav", + "text": "私立殯葬事業經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/171.wav", + "text": "營者如果發生經營不善的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/172.wav", + "text": "輔導使用設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/173.wav", + "text": "之消費者組成權益保護團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/174.wav", + "text": "處理權益事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/175.wav", + "text": "這是第1項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/176.wav", + "text": "如果發生這種情形的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/177.wav", + "text": "就要函請金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/178.wav", + "text": "也就是銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/179.wav", + "text": "跟急難支出專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/180.wav", + "text": "剩下的這些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/181.wav", + "text": "或者由它指定的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/182.wav", + "text": "這個指定團體可能就是自救會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/183.wav", + "text": "一般來說可能是自救會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/184.wav", + "text": "來開設的這個專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/185.wav", + "text": "由他們來處理這些費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/186.wav", + "text": "現在我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/187.wav", + "text": "是增加第4項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/188.wav", + "text": "萬一這個設施將來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/189.wav", + "text": "有其他業者願意承接的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/190.wav", + "text": "原來這些直轄市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/191.wav", + "text": "開設的專戶也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/192.wav", + "text": "或者是指定團體開設的專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/193.wav", + "text": "但是我們現行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/194.wav", + "text": "兩位委員的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/195.wav", + "text": "沒有這個部分的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/196.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/197.wav", + "text": "是不是增訂這項機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/198.wav", + "text": "第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/199.wav", + "text": "對第4項的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/200.wav", + "text": "我們是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/201.wav", + "text": "就是私立公墓骨灰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/202.wav", + "text": "因為我們這邊的主詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/203.wav", + "text": "並不是這個設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/204.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/205.wav", + "text": "經營者跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/206.wav", + "text": "上次有討論過這一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/207.wav", + "text": "嘛經營者的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/208.wav", + "text": "我的是設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/209.wav", + "text": "啦好可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/210.wav", + "text": "��個者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/211.wav", + "text": "我們先讓它照這個過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/212.wav", + "text": "兩位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/213.wav", + "text": "對於第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/214.wav", + "text": "就是那個專戶的問題好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/215.wav", + "text": "好這樣比較周延啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/216.wav", + "text": "你先把它借來在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/217.wav", + "text": "政府或者是團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/218.wav", + "text": "如果有人願意要接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/219.wav", + "text": "再把它移轉過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/220.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/221.wav", + "text": "時間的問題喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/222.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/223.wav", + "text": "協商以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/224.wav", + "text": "大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/225.wav", + "text": "這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/226.wav", + "text": "兩位委員沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/227.wav", + "text": "好好就照這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/228.wav", + "text": "以前的什麼時候再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/229.wav", + "text": "還回來的問題啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/230.wav", + "text": "針對修法之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/231.wav", + "text": "5年內未提撥這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/232.wav", + "text": "基金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/233.wav", + "text": "我們這邊是認為6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/234.wav", + "text": "新的急難支出專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/235.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/236.wav", + "text": "稅捐稽徵法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/237.wav", + "text": "稅捐稽徵法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/238.wav", + "text": "第26條有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/239.wav", + "text": "也是針對沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/240.wav", + "text": "如期繳納的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/241.wav", + "text": "可以分期6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/242.wav", + "text": "6個月內要提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/243.wav", + "text": "我們討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/244.wav", + "text": "對如果真的不行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/245.wav", + "text": "我們再分期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/246.wav", + "text": "是經過直轄市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/247.wav", + "text": "縣市政府主管機關核准後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/248.wav", + "text": "主席第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/249.wav", + "text": "的6個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/250.wav", + "text": "這一定做不到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/251.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/252.wav", + "text": "明知道做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/253.wav", + "text": "我們還要定6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/254.wav", + "text": "6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/255.wav", + "text": "然後後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/256.wav", + "text": "如果有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/257.wav", + "text": "跟邱委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/258.wav", + "text": "是5年內就把它攤提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/259.wav", + "text": "而你們的建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/260.wav", + "text": "依照稅捐稽徵法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/261.wav", + "text": "兩個議題去討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/262.wav", + "text": "有沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/263.wav", + "text": "還要弄一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/264.wav", + "text": "6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/265.wav", + "text": "這個意義是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/266.wav", + "text": "因為這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/267.wav", + "text": "啦還是我們就設定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/268.wav", + "text": "在幾年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/269.wav", + "text": "就幾年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/270.wav", + "text": "幹嘛要6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/271.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/272.wav", + "text": "你弄那6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/273.wav", + "text": "你立這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/274.wav", + "text": "怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/275.wav", + "text": "跟委員報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/276.wav", + "text": "依現行制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/277.wav", + "text": "就應該要繳的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/278.wav", + "text": "因為它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/279.wav", + "text": "布修正條文前5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/280.wav", + "text": "從公布到施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/281.wav", + "text": "還有一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/282.wav", + "text": "其實從公布到施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/283.wav", + "text": "已經有一段緩衝時間了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/284.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/285.wav", + "text": "我們現在先討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/286.wav", + "text": "那6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/287.wav", + "text": "啦那個是內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/288.wav", + "text": "自創的6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/289.wav", + "text": "嘛沒人有這一組的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/290.wav", + "text": "公法上很多權利義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/291.wav", + "text": "都是5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/292.wav", + "text": "也沒有什麼6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/293.wav", + "text": "民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/294.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/295.wav", + "text": "你要追稅什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/296.wav", + "text": "或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/297.wav", + "text": "反正我只是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/298.wav", + "text": "政府對人民的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/299.wav", + "text": "很多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/300.wav", + "text": "真的法律上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/301.wav", + "text": "也是這樣子規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/302.wav", + "text": "就往前追嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/303.wav", + "text": "就是5年嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/304.wav", + "text": "這沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/305.wav", + "text": "啦所以這應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/306.wav", + "text": "5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/307.wav", + "text": "不要說3年內提撥嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/308.wav", + "text": "比較小的跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/309.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/310.wav", + "text": "沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/311.wav", + "text": "我們也是這樣來寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/312.wav", + "text": "剛剛其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/313.wav", + "text": "我們同仁也有講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/314.wav", + "text": "應該要繳而未繳的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/315.wav", + "text": "不是追" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/316.wav", + "text": "當然這往下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/317.wav", + "text": "為什麼是6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/318.wav", + "text": "因為本來他現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/319.wav", + "text": "就應該要繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/320.wav", + "text": "就沒繳啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/321.wav", + "text": "所以給他6個月嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/322.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法執行啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/323.wav", + "text": "其實也是依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/324.wav", + "text": "是用36個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/325.wav", + "text": "讓他分期沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/326.wav", + "text": "國稅局可以60個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/327.wav", + "text": "不只啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/328.wav", + "text": "國稅局可以60個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/329.wav", + "text": "攤提啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/330.wav", + "text": "36個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/331.wav", + "text": "國稅局是60個月啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/332.wav", + "text": "抱歉我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/333.wav", + "text": "延期是1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/334.wav", + "text": "分期最長是36期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/335.wav", + "text": "就是3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/336.wav", + "text": "沒有5年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/337.wav", + "text": "我們追稅是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/338.wav", + "text": "1年加3年就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/339.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/340.wav", + "text": "只能擇一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/341.wav", + "text": "延期跟分期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/342.wav", + "text": "只能擇一啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/343.wav", + "text": "但是我們也不一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/344.wav", + "text": "依照你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/345.wav", + "text": "那當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/346.wav", + "text": "提一個小小建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/347.wav", + "text": "這個本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/348.wav", + "text": "應該要繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/349.wav", + "text": "可是因為我們法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/350.wav", + "text": "一直沒過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/351.wav", + "text": "本來應該要繳的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/352.wav", + "text": "你其實要去計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/353.wav", + "text": "那個公司的金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/354.wav", + "text": "我現在要求它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/355.wav", + "text": "6個月之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/356.wav", + "text": "對很多公司來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/357.wav", + "text": "它沒有那麼多的現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/358.wav", + "text": "那個cashflow" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/359.wav", + "text": "是會有一點問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/360.wav", + "text": "你的6個月是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/361.wav", + "text": "比如繳百分之多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/362.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/363.wav", + "text": "大家談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/364.wav", + "text": "又或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/365.wav", + "text": "你就直接讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/366.wav", + "text": "分成3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/367.wav", + "text": "把這些該繳的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/368.wav", + "text": "全部繳完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/369.wav", + "text": "這兩個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/370.wav", + "text": "大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/371.wav", + "text": "聚焦一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/372.wav", + "text": "看看有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/373.wav", + "text": "有的比較小的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/374.wav", + "text": "你叫它一次繳5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/375.wav", + "text": "在5年下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/376.wav", + "text": "應該繳的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/377.wav", + "text": "可能也上億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/378.wav", + "text": "它如何在6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/379.wav", + "text": "不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/380.wav", + "text": "我舉例啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/381.wav", + "text": "比較大間的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/382.wav", + "text": "其實那個金流是大的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/383.wav", + "text": "所以你如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/384.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/385.wav", + "text": "願意做的都還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/386.wav", + "text": "6個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/387.wav", + "text": "我們繳第一期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/388.wav", + "text": "然後後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/389.wav", + "text": "把它分36期繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/390.wav", + "text": "total可以變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/391.wav", + "text": "都是分36期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/392.wav", + "text": "去把它攤提繳完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/393.wav", + "text": "最重要是要收到錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/394.wav", + "text": "最重要是要收到錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/395.wav", + "text": "我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/396.wav", + "text": "它要繳多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/397.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/398.wav", + "text": "我們現在就是立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/399.wav", + "text": "還是要嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/400.wav", + "text": "是多數沒有辦法執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/401.wav", + "text": "的我們也會被社會大眾笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/402.wav", + "text": "他都倒下了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/403.wav", + "text": "我覺得這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/404.wav", + "text": "這樣的文字出去不是很妥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/405.wav", + "text": "你們算一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/406.wav", + "text": "我個人非常贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/407.wav", + "text": "─剛才邱委員也說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/408.wav", + "text": "就是稅捐稽徵法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/409.wav", + "text": "如果是36個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/410.wav", + "text": "我們就是設定在3年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/411.wav", + "text": "你要去攤提啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/412.wav", + "text": "假設以追溯5年來說的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/413.wav", + "text": "大概二億300多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/414.wav", + "text": "有到上億元的其實只有1家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/415.wav", + "text": "我暫停你的發言一下主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/416.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們如果在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/417.wav", + "text": "講金額是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/418.wav", + "text": "這沒意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/419.wav", + "text": "因為有困難的一塊錢都很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/420.wav", + "text": "沒有困難的幾百億元都沒有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/421.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/422.wav", + "text": "所以我認為都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/423.wav", + "text": "了我們要叫他導正軌道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/424.wav", + "text": "然後又要求它在半年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/425.wav", + "text": "等於這個動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/426.wav", + "text": "我不知道意義是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/427.wav", + "text": "但是這種激勵是達不到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/428.wav", + "text": "你看是要分36期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/429.wav", + "text": "繳一筆前期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/430.wav", + "text": "的比如說30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/431.wav", + "text": "後面70%分36期跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/432.wav", + "text": "委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/433.wav", + "text": "其實能不能延期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/434.wav", + "text": "當然這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/435.wav", + "text": "可以去決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/436.wav", + "text": "其實他們本來要繳的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/437.wav", + "text": "1.8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/438.wav", + "text": "收入的1.8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/439.wav", + "text": "5年就是9%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/440.wav", + "text": "最多就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/441.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/442.wav", + "text": "回溯5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/443.wav", + "text": "其實就是這個金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/444.wav", + "text": "額不會大到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/445.wav", + "text": "他5年也就這樣慢慢還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/446.wav", + "text": "也就還完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/447.wav", + "text": "嘛這個就解決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/448.wav", + "text": "其實是有能力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/449.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/450.wav", + "text": "次長我覺得我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/451.wav", + "text": "替業者打算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/452.wav", + "text": "我們沒有辦法達到這種成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/453.wav", + "text": "不缺的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/454.wav", + "text": "所以我個人認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/455.wav", + "text": "期間然後再由縣市政府決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/456.wav", + "text": "要不要予以延期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/457.wav", + "text": "會累死地方的縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/458.wav", + "text": "限期是地方政府還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/459.wav", + "text": "對啊地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/460.wav", + "text": "中央制定法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/461.wav", + "text": "就是要讓地方在執行方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/462.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/463.wav", + "text": "中央與地方有必要合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/464.wav", + "text": "我的感覺是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/465.wav", + "text": "依照稅捐稽徵法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/466.wav", + "text": "如果攤提是36個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/467.wav", + "text": "那我同意3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/468.wav", + "text": "我不堅持5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/469.wav", + "text": "我認為那個邏輯很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/470.wav", + "text": "因為這是欠繳的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/471.wav", + "text": "照理說他應該在立法通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/472.wav", + "text": "原則上馬上就得繳才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/473.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/474.wav", + "text": "但是要執行得來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/475.wav", + "text": "話我們同意可以用3年分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/476.wav", + "text": "3年沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/477.wav", + "text": "但是誰要決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/478.wav", + "text": "如果新竹可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/479.wav", + "text": "雲林不可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/480.wav", + "text": "以你就是要製造地方打架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/481.wav", + "text": "對於這個業者有沒有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/482.wav", + "text": "其實縣市政府比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/483.wav", + "text": "我們就是3針對6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/484.wav", + "text": "那3年這個我們尊重你們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/485.wav", + "text": "就是施行後多久以內提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/486.wav", + "text": "6個月是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/487.wav", + "text": "比如改成1年這樣就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/488.wav", + "text": "3年大家都沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/489.wav", + "text": "其實對於他講的6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/490.wav", + "text": "現在我想了一想6個月也是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/491.wav", + "text": "時間滿短的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/492.wav", + "text": "也是一個理想性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/493.wav", + "text": "的嘛如果真的不行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/494.wav", + "text": "他再去跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/495.wav", + "text": "所以前面的時間你乾脆給他比較久一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/496.wav", + "text": "如果可以交他就交了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/497.wav", + "text": "就不用再多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/498.wav", + "text": "一個他會來問你就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/499.wav", + "text": "麻煩了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/500.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告有的只欠幾萬元���萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/501.wav", + "text": "嘛如果只欠幾萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/502.wav", + "text": "元他也不會自己去申請行政程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/503.wav", + "text": "我們看過那樣的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/504.wav", + "text": "原則上業者是有能力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/505.wav", + "text": "我覺得不需要去為他爭取這個彈性空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/506.wav", + "text": "爭取那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/507.wav", + "text": "不是為誰爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/508.wav", + "text": "這樣這樣縣市政府不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/509.wav", + "text": "很麻煩嗎每個都來申請他要延期什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/510.wav", + "text": "我的意思是6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/511.wav", + "text": "1年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/512.wav", + "text": "1年也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/513.wav", + "text": "啦我也覺得可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/514.wav", + "text": "剛剛那個邏輯不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/515.wav", + "text": "喔1年是延期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/516.wav", + "text": "喔分期是3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/517.wav", + "text": "喔是二選一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/518.wav", + "text": "不是延期加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/519.wav", + "text": "我們是參考它的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/520.wav", + "text": "這樣也就是一樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/521.wav", + "text": "我們沒有延期的這個邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/522.wav", + "text": "分期他也可以提前攤還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/523.wav", + "text": "啊他也可以提前不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/524.wav", + "text": "如果你把它改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/525.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/526.wav", + "text": "指立刻要繳清才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/527.wav", + "text": "那現在我們是把繳清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/528.wav", + "text": "拉成半年繳清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/529.wav", + "text": "你拉到半年也可以拉到1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/530.wav", + "text": "不是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/531.wav", + "text": "不一樣不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/532.wav", + "text": "他們委員就改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/533.wav", + "text": "立即繳清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/534.wav", + "text": "我們在審法案他們尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/535.wav", + "text": "我請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/536.wav", + "text": "立法原意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/537.wav", + "text": "6個月的來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/538.wav", + "text": "依據是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/539.wav", + "text": "也可以18個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/540.wav", + "text": "啊依據是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/541.wav", + "text": "因為這筆錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/542.wav", + "text": "本來就應該立即繳清的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/543.wav", + "text": "對那我們要協助業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/544.wav", + "text": "協助產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/545.wav", + "text": "我們一般緩衝時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/546.wav", + "text": "都會給6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/547.wav", + "text": "什麼依��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/548.wav", + "text": "6個月的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/549.wav", + "text": "比如說攤提3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/550.wav", + "text": "的36個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/551.wav", + "text": "你們早一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/552.wav", + "text": "那訂6個月的依據是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/553.wav", + "text": "6個月的依據是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/554.wav", + "text": "有哪一條法令是規定6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/555.wav", + "text": "訂6個月確實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/556.wav", + "text": "因為我們希望給業者稍微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/557.wav", + "text": "你們沒有法依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/558.wav", + "text": "這就是大家協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/559.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/560.wav", + "text": "大家協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/561.wav", + "text": "我覺得那就已經不是在寬鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/562.wav", + "text": "了因為他按理說是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/563.wav", + "text": "應該立即繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/564.wav", + "text": "就像我們繳所得稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/565.wav", + "text": "大概都有1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/566.wav", + "text": "頂多2個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/567.wav", + "text": "我們現在是在討論問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/568.wav", + "text": "就不是說你堅持立即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/569.wav", + "text": "立即就不用設這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/570.wav", + "text": "沒有所以我沒有堅持立即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/571.wav", + "text": "我說我們給6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/572.wav", + "text": "對那我是請教嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/573.wav", + "text": "我們現在是希望設定1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/574.wav", + "text": "你們現在是希望6個月就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/575.wav", + "text": "聚焦在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/576.wav", + "text": "所以我要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/577.wav", + "text": "6個月的依據是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/578.wav", + "text": "是否有法律規定6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/579.wav", + "text": "他們就是裁量後覺得是6個月但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/580.wav", + "text": "可能委員覺得1年比較適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/581.wav", + "text": "那就看朝野委員的意見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/582.wav", + "text": "們現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/583.wav", + "text": "6個月內要繳清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/584.wav", + "text": "要繳清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/585.wav", + "text": "6個月內繳不清的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/586.wav", + "text": "有困難的再申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/587.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/588.wav", + "text": "是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/589.wav", + "text": "有什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/590.wav", + "text": "還比3年少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/591.wav", + "text": "比如現在我們通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/592.wav", + "text": "你規定6月30號以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/593.wav", + "text": "6月30號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/594.wav", + "text": "6月30號以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/595.wav", + "text": "再向你們申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/596.wav", + "text": "你就要申請了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/597.wav", + "text": "一開始就是二選一了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/598.wav", + "text": "一開始就要二選一了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/599.wav", + "text": "反正一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/600.wav", + "text": "他就是二選一嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/601.wav", + "text": "他要選擇6個月內全部繳清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/602.wav", + "text": "還是選擇36期繳清嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/603.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/604.wav", + "text": "因為很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/605.wav", + "text": "很多人1年就會繳一繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/606.wav", + "text": "不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/607.wav", + "text": "其實那個沒差啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/608.wav", + "text": "他如果要分36期就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/609.wav", + "text": "就還是分36期去繳其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/610.wav", + "text": "都繳得起啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/611.wav", + "text": "那我沒有意見啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/612.wav", + "text": "我沒有意見啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/613.wav", + "text": "但目的就是要解決讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/614.wav", + "text": "假設1年他有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/615.wav", + "text": "有10間可以解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/616.wav", + "text": "1年30間可以解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/617.wav", + "text": "的你就不用拖到3年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/618.wav", + "text": "我現在的依據是這個啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/619.wav", + "text": "你比如說6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/620.wav", + "text": "很可能是10家而1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/621.wav", + "text": "我們的目的結果而論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/622.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/623.wav", + "text": "其實我覺得沒差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/624.wav", + "text": "因為他的年報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/625.wav", + "text": "財報也是以一年份計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/626.wav", + "text": "6個月內他還是可以繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/627.wav", + "text": "他也不一定都在拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/628.wav", + "text": "如果他真的繳不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/629.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/630.wav", + "text": "其實我們已經很善意地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/631.wav", + "text": "提供6個月的繳費期了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/632.wav", + "text": "這不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/633.wav", + "text": "這個就協商嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/634.wav", + "text": "你們覺得要6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/635.wav", + "text": "委員可能覺得1年比較妥當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/636.wav", + "text": "我沒有意見喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/637.wav", + "text": "我現在沒有意見喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/638.wav", + "text": "這個法能夠趕快過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/639.wav", + "text": "能夠讓他們趕快管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/640.wav", + "text": "反正6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/641.wav", + "text": "繳不清的人可以分成3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/642.wav", + "text": "就是兩個方案讓他們二擇一嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/643.wav", + "text": "跟1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/644.wav", + "text": "可是那個還要縣市政府核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/645.wav", + "text": "不是每一個人都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/646.wav", + "text": "縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/647.wav", + "text": "當然會看業者的財務狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/648.wav", + "text": "他必須提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/649.wav", + "text": "我說的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/650.wav", + "text": "你當然要賺30家的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/651.wav", + "text": "收啦收如果不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/652.wav", + "text": "分36個月啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/653.wav", + "text": "收入啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/654.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/655.wav", + "text": "只是把它們導正啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/656.wav", + "text": "政府政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/657.wav", + "text": "再報告委員一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/658.wav", + "text": "對於所有稅費的收取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/659.wav", + "text": "主計單位或財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/660.wav", + "text": "就是有一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/661.wav", + "text": "line嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/662.wav", + "text": "也就是什麼時候繳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/663.wav", + "text": "可能他可以申請延期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/664.wav", + "text": "但一般來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/665.wav", + "text": "針對繳費時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/666.wav", + "text": "我們應該沒有看過1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/667.wav", + "text": "1年內都可以繳的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/668.wav", + "text": "一般來講2個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/669.wav", + "text": "有啦也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/670.wav", + "text": "有時候光是協商時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/671.wav", + "text": "就超過半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/672.wav", + "text": "我們再這樣下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/673.wav", + "text": "你們又一年收不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/674.wav", + "text": "沒關係啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/675.wav", + "text": "我們的判斷是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/676.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/677.wav", + "text": "所有業者都繳得起啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/678.wav", + "text": "啦真的不需要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/679.wav", + "text": "他們又一年收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/680.wav", + "text": "不不是一年收不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/681.wav", + "text": "而是下一屆屆期不連續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/682.wav", + "text": "又要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/683.wav", + "text": "好啦好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/684.wav", + "text": "要是沒成績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/685.wav", + "text": "找你打屁股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/686.wav", + "text": "內政部的照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/687.wav", + "text": "內政部照內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/688.wav", + "text": "還有財政部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/689.wav", + "text": "立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/690.wav", + "text": "要增加一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/691.wav", + "text": "我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/692.wav", + "text": "其實對於財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/693.wav", + "text": "我特別要謝謝你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/694.wav", + "text": "你有特別再上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/695.wav", + "text": "你可能沒有注意聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/696.wav", + "text": "議請你把書面資料送出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/697.wav", + "text": "因為若是用嘴巴講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/698.wav", + "text": "講得不是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/699.wav", + "text": "會議結論上沒有明寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/700.wav", + "text": "請你把文字弄出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/701.wav", + "text": "那我要特別謝謝你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/702.wav", + "text": "把文字寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/703.wav", + "text": "財政部的立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/704.wav", + "text": "這個就是代收代付管理費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/705.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/706.wav", + "text": "經營業者的銷售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/707.wav", + "text": "不算是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/708.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/709.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/710.wav", + "text": "我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/711.wav", + "text": "財政部有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/712.wav", + "text": "立法說明就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/713.wav", + "text": "們條文也修了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/714.wav", + "text": "的因為本來就免徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/715.wav", + "text": "已經說明是免徵了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/716.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/717.wav", + "text": "不會去跟人家徵就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/718.wav", + "text": "現在那句話沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/719.wav", + "text": "因為在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/720.wav", + "text": "沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/721.wav", + "text": "因為它本來就不屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/722.wav", + "text": "要徵的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/723.wav", + "text": "沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/724.wav", + "text": "所以自然不發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/725.wav", + "text": "要不要徵的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/726.wav", + "text": "如果說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/727.wav", + "text": "就會有問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/728.wav", + "text": "好那就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/729.wav", + "text": "財政部建議的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/730.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/731.wav", + "text": "我念一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/732.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/733.wav", + "text": "協商通過條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/734.wav", + "text": "增訂第21條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/735.wav", + "text": "增訂第36條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/736.wav", + "text": "及增訂第37條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/737.wav", + "text": "第35條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/738.wav", + "text": "增訂立法說明如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/739.wav", + "text": "其餘均照審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/740.wav", + "text": "審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/741.wav", + "text": "兩位協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/742.wav", + "text": "請簽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/743.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/744.wav", + "text": "謝謝政次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/745.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/746.wav", + "text": "增訂第21條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/747.wav", + "text": "殉職警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/748.wav", + "text": "義勇警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/749.wav", + "text": "民防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/750.wav", + "text": "消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/751.wav", + "text": "義勇消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/752.wav", + "text": "或其他依法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/753.wav", + "text": "從事於公務之人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/754.wav", + "text": "使用公立殯葬設施免收費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/755.wav", + "text": "前項免費之標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/756.wav", + "text": "由直轄市縣(市)政府定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/757.wav", + "text": "增訂第36條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/758.wav", + "text": "存放設施經營者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/759.wav", + "text": "有第35條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/760.wav", + "text": "第2項第2款之情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/761.wav", + "text": "直轄市縣(市)主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/762.wav", + "text": "應輔導使用公墓骨灰(骸)" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/763.wav", + "text": "存放設施之消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/764.wav", + "text": "組成權益保護團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/765.wav", + "text": "處理權益事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/766.wav", + "text": "情形發生後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/767.wav", + "text": "直轄市縣(市)主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/768.wav", + "text": "應函請金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/769.wav", + "text": "將日常支出專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/770.wav", + "text": "及急難支出專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/771.wav", + "text": "賸餘之全部款項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/772.wav", + "text": "移轉至直轄市縣(市)主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/773.wav", + "text": "開設或其指定團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/774.wav", + "text": "開設之專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/775.wav", + "text": "並得由主管機關或其指定之團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/776.wav", + "text": "提領支應殯葬設施之維護管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/777.wav", + "text": "或善後事宜等費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/778.wav", + "text": "前項主管機關開設或其指定團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/779.wav", + "text": "開設之專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/780.wav", + "text": "其支出準用第35條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/781.wav", + "text": "之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/782.wav", + "text": "第2項之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/783.wav", + "text": "第2項情形之設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/784.wav", + "text": "經直轄市縣(市)主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/785.wav", + "text": "��可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/786.wav", + "text": "由其他殯葬設施經營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/787.wav", + "text": "承接經營者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/788.wav", + "text": "原直轄市縣(市)主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/789.wav", + "text": "或其指定團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/790.wav", + "text": "應將其開設專戶內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/791.wav", + "text": "之賸餘款項轉存至該承接業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/792.wav", + "text": "開設之日常支出專戶及急難支出專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/793.wav", + "text": "\n增訂第37條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/794.wav", + "text": "本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/795.wav", + "text": "中華民國○年○月○日修正之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/796.wav", + "text": "施行前已設立之管理費專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/797.wav", + "text": "應於修正施行後一個月內變更為第35條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/798.wav", + "text": "第2項之日常支出專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/799.wav", + "text": "中華民國○年○月○日修正之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/800.wav", + "text": "施行前已提撥之殯葬設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/801.wav", + "text": "經營管理基金直轄市縣(市)主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/802.wav", + "text": "應於修正施行後三個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/803.wav", + "text": "中華民國○年○月○日修正之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/804.wav", + "text": "公布前五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/805.wav", + "text": "未提撥之殯葬設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/806.wav", + "text": "經營管理基金私立或以公共造產設置之公墓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/807.wav", + "text": "骨灰(骸)存放設施經營者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/808.wav", + "text": "六個月內提撥至急難支出專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/809.wav", + "text": "或於公共造產基金或其他政府基金專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/810.wav", + "text": "補列應有費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/811.wav", + "text": "有財務困難者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/812.wav", + "text": "經直轄市縣(市)主管機關核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/813.wav", + "text": "得於三年內分期提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/814.wav", + "text": "\n違反前項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/815.wav", + "text": "未足額提撥者直轄市縣(市)主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/816.wav", + "text": "應限期三個月內改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/817.wav", + "text": "屆期仍未改善者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/818.wav", + "text": "命其停止販售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/819.wav", + "text": "墓基或骨灰(骸)存放單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/820.wav", + "text": "並移送行政執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/821.wav", + "text": "其不遵從而繼續販售者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15268/822.wav", + "text": "廢止其殯葬設施經營業之經營許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/0.wav", + "text": "距離9點半的開會時間已經超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/1.wav", + "text": "因為等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/2.wav", + "text": "院會可能會表決其他議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/3.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是要預留一下時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/4.wav", + "text": "現在開始開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/5.wav", + "text": "\n各黨團的代表及行政部門的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/6.wav", + "text": "大家早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/7.wav", + "text": "我們今天進行黨團協商的主題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/8.wav", + "text": "併案審查行政院函請審議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/9.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/10.wav", + "text": "廖國棟委員陳瑩委員伍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/11.wav", + "text": "伍麗華委員及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/12.wav", + "text": "提案另外伍麗華委員跟周春米" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/13.wav", + "text": "院會決定逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/14.wav", + "text": "我們就併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/15.wav", + "text": "\n在進行協商之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/16.wav", + "text": "一下內政委員會審查完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/17.wav", + "text": "竣的時候是全案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/18.wav", + "text": "送黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/19.wav", + "text": "本席在去年(" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/20.wav", + "text": "111年)9月23號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/21.wav", + "text": "第一次發文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/22.wav", + "text": "召開黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/23.wav", + "text": "之後於12月9號第二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/24.wav", + "text": "112年)3月24號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/25.wav", + "text": "第三次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/26.wav", + "text": "以及今年(112年)4月11號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/27.wav", + "text": "黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/28.wav", + "text": "均未達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/29.wav", + "text": "協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/30.wav", + "text": "建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/31.wav", + "text": "是不是由原住民的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/32.wav", + "text": "先行召開會前會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/33.wav", + "text": "就做了這樣的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/34.wav", + "text": "所以本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/35.wav", + "text": "今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/36.wav", + "text": "5月22" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/37.wav", + "text": "號及10月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/38.wav", + "text": "及原住民的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/39.wav", + "text": "進行會前會的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/40.wav", + "text": "初步的所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/41.wav", + "text": "共識條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/42.wav", + "text": "都在桌上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/43.wav", + "text": "我們有併案放在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/44.wav", + "text": "是希望能夠對原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/45.wav", + "text": "保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/46.wav", + "text": "當然行政院版及各委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/47.wav", + "text": "能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/48.wav", + "text": "位階" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/49.wav", + "text": "\n本日協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/50.wav", + "text": "基本上就以行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/51.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/52.wav", + "text": "跟原住民立委協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/53.wav", + "text": "的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/54.wav", + "text": "來進行逐條討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/55.wav", + "text": "審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/56.wav", + "text": "所做的對照表都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/57.wav", + "text": "大家的手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/58.wav", + "text": "如果有共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/59.wav", + "text": "修正動議就列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/60.wav", + "text": "所列其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/61.wav", + "text": "的提案到時候如果有共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/62.wav", + "text": "都會併案列入紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/63.wav", + "text": "立委協商條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/64.wav", + "text": "跟行政院版的對照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/65.wav", + "text": "行政部門有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/66.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/67.wav", + "text": "權利回復及管理利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/68.wav", + "text": "條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/69.wav", + "text": "法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/70.wav", + "text": "因為這個涉及到整個保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/71.wav", + "text": "地的管理跟利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/72.wav", + "text": "好那就保留吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/73.wav", + "text": "依行政院提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/74.wav", + "text": "\n第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/75.wav", + "text": "為承認及回復原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/76.wav", + "text": "對於原住民族土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/77.wav", + "text": "之權利規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/78.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地之合理利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/79.wav", + "text": "促進原住民族之生存發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/80.wav", + "text": "制定本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/81.wav", + "text": "這個是原住民立委的協商條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/82.wav", + "text": "行政部門有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/83.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/84.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/85.wav", + "text": "其他部會有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/86.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/87.wav", + "text": "照原住民立委協商條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/88.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/89.wav", + "text": "\n第2條是依行政院提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/90.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講原住民的條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/91.wav", + "text": "在最左邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/92.wav", + "text": "這裡是寫依行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/93.wav", + "text": "提案版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/94.wav", + "text": "第1條有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/95.wav", + "text": "\n第3條依行政院提案版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/96.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/97.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/98.wav", + "text": "原住民立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/99.wav", + "text": "有協商條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/100.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/101.wav", + "text": "第1項第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/102.wav", + "text": "第二目到第四目的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/103.wav", + "text": "跟現在原保地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/104.wav", + "text": "些土地的類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/105.wav", + "text": "按照我們所提草案第21條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/106.wav", + "text": "的程序其實是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/107.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/108.wav", + "text": "不納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/109.wav", + "text": "另外就是委員協商版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/110.wav", + "text": "的原住民團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/111.wav", + "text": "這在原住民族工作權保障法有定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/112.wav", + "text": "了所以我們想說這個是不是也建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/113.wav", + "text": "不納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/114.wav", + "text": "好我利用這個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/115.wav", + "text": "讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/116.wav", + "text": "原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/117.wav", + "text": "還有相關部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/118.wav", + "text": "尤其是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/119.wav", + "text": "涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/120.wav", + "text": "比較多的單位像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/121.wav", + "text": "農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/122.wav", + "text": "財政部國有財產署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/123.wav", + "text": "兩個部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/124.wav", + "text": "涉及比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/125.wav", + "text": "要回顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/126.wav", + "text": "尤其是原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/127.wav", + "text": "要想辦法說服相關的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/128.wav", + "text": "在沒有法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/129.wav", + "text": "政府就劃設了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/130.wav", + "text": "的山地保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/131.wav", + "text": "隨著後來省" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/132.wav", + "text": "省議員立法委員的爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/133.wav", + "text": "所以76年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/134.wav", + "text": "有所謂的增劃編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/135.wav", + "text": "原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/136.wav", + "text": "本來到100年就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/137.wav", + "text": "廖國棟立委還有本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/138.wav", + "text": "向當時的行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/139.wav", + "text": "要求延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/140.wav", + "text": "103年延長了3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/141.wav", + "text": "但3年很快就到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/142.wav", + "text": "所以廖委員還有本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/143.wav", + "text": "又跟行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/144.wav", + "text": "要求不要再定期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/145.wav", + "text": "毛治國院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/146.wav", + "text": "當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/147.wav", + "text": "就問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/148.wav", + "text": "林江義主任委員如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/149.wav", + "text": "不定期限的話是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/150.wav", + "text": "全臺灣都會變成原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/151.wav", + "text": "我們說不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/152.wav", + "text": "一定的基礎規定在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/153.wav", + "text": "所以不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/154.wav", + "text": "因此後來就不定期限了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/155.wav", + "text": "這個都是在沒有法律的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/156.wav", + "text": "現在我們要立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/157.wav", + "text": "蔡總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/158.wav", + "text": "或是夷將主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/159.wav", + "text": "在民國47年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/160.wav", + "text": "看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/161.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/162.wav", + "text": "對不起是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/163.wav", + "text": "1947年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/164.wav", + "text": "民國36年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/165.wav", + "text": "臺灣省土地權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/166.wav", + "text": "清理辦法第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/167.wav", + "text": "規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/168.wav", + "text": "經前臺灣總督府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/169.wav", + "text": "依據土地調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/170.wav", + "text": "清理之結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/171.wav", + "text": "歸公有之土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/172.wav", + "text": "概不發還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/173.wav", + "text": "1947年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/174.wav", + "text": "戒嚴時期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/175.wav", + "text": "訂了這個辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/176.wav", + "text": "寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/177.wav", + "text": "日據時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/178.wav", + "text": "收為官有的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/179.wav", + "text": "臺灣光復之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/180.wav", + "text": "日本沒有把土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/181.wav", + "text": "帶回日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/182.wav", + "text": "但是臺灣省政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/183.wav", + "text": "根據行政院的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/184.wav", + "text": "那時候行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/185.wav", + "text": "還在南京" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/186.wav", + "text": "1947年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/187.wav", + "text": "根據行政院的命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/188.wav", + "text": "訂了這個辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/189.wav", + "text": "歸為公有之土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/190.wav", + "text": "概不發還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/191.wav", + "text": "我們現在要立法要轉型正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/192.wav", + "text": "如果連這個都不處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/193.wav", + "text": "都不討論的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/194.wav", + "text": "有違" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/195.wav", + "text": "自己的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/196.wav", + "text": "良心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/197.wav", + "text": "違反轉型正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/198.wav", + "text": "不是增加很多面積嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/199.wav", + "text": "增加很多面積會不會全部給原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/200.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/201.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/202.wav", + "text": "臺灣光復之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/203.wav", + "text": "沒有法律的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/204.wav", + "text": "當時的臺灣省政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/205.wav", + "text": "劃設了24多公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/206.wav", + "text": "原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/207.wav", + "text": "加上增劃編之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/208.wav", + "text": "現在是26多公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/209.wav", + "text": "增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/210.wav", + "text": "都是直接登記給原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/211.wav", + "text": "還是百分之八十是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/212.wav", + "text": "我跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/213.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/214.wav", + "text": "26多公頃裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/215.wav", + "text": "仍然維持公有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/216.wav", + "text": "的也就是國有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/217.wav", + "text": "有多少呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/218.wav", + "text": "看一下數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/219.wav", + "text": "12萬9,617公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/220.wav", + "text": "26萬公頃裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/221.wav", + "text": "將近13萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/222.wav", + "text": "公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/223.wav", + "text": "還是國有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/224.wav", + "text": "我們不會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/225.wav", + "text": "原住民保留地就全部給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/226.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/227.wav", + "text": "\n我們很尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/228.wav", + "text": "你做道路的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/229.wav", + "text": "或是做林班地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/230.wav", + "text": "就繼續用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/231.wav", + "text": "所以大家不要擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/232.wav", + "text": "我們如果不把這條條文放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/233.wav", + "text": "真的是有虧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/234.wav", + "text": "職守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/235.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/236.wav", + "text": "就用一個大原則好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/237.wav", + "text": "我先請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/238.wav", + "text": "依行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/239.wav", + "text": "各位有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/240.wav", + "text": "每一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/241.wav", + "text": "依行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/242.wav", + "text": "不是有寫依行政院版本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/243.wav", + "text": "原住民立委已經協商過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/244.wav", + "text": "我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/245.wav", + "text": "我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/246.wav", + "text": "是我先講原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/247.wav", + "text": "就是我的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/248.wav", + "text": "原住民立委協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/249.wav", + "text": "條文就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/250.wav", + "text": "就是原住民的立委協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/251.wav", + "text": "認為可以依行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/252.wav", + "text": "版本的就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/253.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/254.wav", + "text": "廖委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/255.wav", + "text": "就是原住民立委協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/256.wav", + "text": "就是原住民協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/257.wav", + "text": "依行政院的版本的通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/258.wav", + "text": "嘛就是按照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/259.wav", + "text": "條文的正式條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/260.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/261.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/262.wav", + "text": "第1條除外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/263.wav", + "text": "第1條照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/264.wav", + "text": "條文這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/265.wav", + "text": "這樣的話就會比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/266.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/267.wav", + "text": "一下子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/268.wav", + "text": "概括就通過也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/269.wav", + "text": "不好關於第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/270.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/271.wav", + "text": "本席必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/272.wav", + "text": "更嚴謹地來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/273.wav", + "text": "條文的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/274.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/275.wav", + "text": "整個26萬公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/276.wav", + "text": "應該是很容易才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/277.wav", + "text": "但是不免地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/278.wav", + "text": "我們還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/279.wav", + "text": "為原住民做更多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/280.wav", + "text": "關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/281.wav", + "text": "或者是權益的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/282.wav", + "text": "維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/283.wav", + "text": "關於第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/284.wav", + "text": "本席希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/285.wav", + "text": "能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/286.wav", + "text": "再增加幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/287.wav", + "text": "我們要定義什麼叫做原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/288.wav", + "text": "我們這整個法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/289.wav", + "text": "沒有任何一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/290.wav", + "text": "說原住民是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/291.wav", + "text": "原住民的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/292.wav", + "text": "那麼這個定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/293.wav", + "text": "現有的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/294.wav", + "text": "所規定的原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/295.wav", + "text": "我想委員也很清楚在原住民身分法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/296.wav", + "text": "裡面就有��義了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/297.wav", + "text": "我來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/298.wav", + "text": "第一個有定義的是原住民族基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/299.wav", + "text": "對原住民有定義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/300.wav", + "text": "就照那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/301.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/302.wav", + "text": "那個條文內容可以再看一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/303.wav", + "text": "基本法或者是那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/304.wav", + "text": "原住民族基本法有定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/305.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/306.wav", + "text": "原住民族基本法的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/307.wav", + "text": "有需要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/308.wav", + "text": "的話我們未來當然還是可以提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/309.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/310.wav", + "text": "這個文字也沒有很複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/311.wav", + "text": "定義原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/312.wav", + "text": "就是一個基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/313.wav", + "text": "就是一個基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/314.wav", + "text": "有規定原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/315.wav", + "text": "是指原住民族之個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/316.wav", + "text": "\n那什麼是原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/317.wav", + "text": "呢係指既存於臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/318.wav", + "text": "而為國家管轄內之傳統民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/319.wav", + "text": "包括阿美族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/320.wav", + "text": "泰雅族排灣族布農族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/321.wav", + "text": "卑南族魯凱族鄒族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/322.wav", + "text": "賽夏族雅美族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/323.wav", + "text": "邵族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/324.wav", + "text": "噶瑪蘭族太魯閣族及其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/325.wav", + "text": "自認為原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/326.wav", + "text": "並經中央原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/327.wav", + "text": "主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/328.wav", + "text": "報請行政院核定之民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/329.wav", + "text": "所以原住民族是這樣定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/330.wav", + "text": "而原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/331.wav", + "text": "之個人就是原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/332.wav", + "text": "學長我補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/333.wav", + "text": "廖委員是我學長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/334.wav", + "text": "我補充就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/335.wav", + "text": "原基法已經有定義了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/336.wav", + "text": "比較詳細的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/337.wav", + "text": "就在原住民身分法那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/338.wav", + "text": "提新的修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/339.wav", + "text": "在這個會期會再審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/340.wav", + "text": "原住民身分法他們有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/341.wav", + "text": "行政院有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/342.wav", + "text": "版本送來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/343.wav", + "text": "我��就先保留反正要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/344.wav", + "text": "對這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/345.wav", + "text": "啦因為等一下院會隨時會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/346.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/347.wav", + "text": "對對對那邊就有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/348.wav", + "text": "什麼是山地原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/349.wav", + "text": "什麼是平地原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/350.wav", + "text": "那邊都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/351.wav", + "text": "而且最近會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/352.wav", + "text": "內政委員會會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/353.wav", + "text": "討論這個原住民身分法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/354.wav", + "text": "原民會有修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/355.wav", + "text": "啦我先唸一下協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/356.wav", + "text": "大家看看有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/357.wav", + "text": "協商通過條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/358.wav", + "text": "二保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/359.wav", + "text": "法案名稱第4條第5條之1第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/360.wav", + "text": "第7條第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/361.wav", + "text": "第十二條第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/362.wav", + "text": "第二十一條第二十二條第二十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/363.wav", + "text": "第二十七條第二十七條之一第二十八條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/364.wav", + "text": "第一章章名第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/365.wav", + "text": "第3條第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/366.wav", + "text": "第二章章名第8條第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/367.wav", + "text": "第10條第十一條第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/368.wav", + "text": "第十四條第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/369.wav", + "text": "第十六條第十七條第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/370.wav", + "text": "第二十五條第二十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15261/371.wav", + "text": "第二十九條第三十條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/0.wav", + "text": "現在開始協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/1.wav", + "text": "本日協商中華民國刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/2.wav", + "text": "第108條之3條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/3.wav", + "text": "協商會議進行前先介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/4.wav", + "text": "法務部蔡清祥部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/5.wav", + "text": "司法院黃麟倫副秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/6.wav", + "text": "大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/7.wav", + "text": "我們現在就開始進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/8.wav", + "text": "併案審查行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/9.wav", + "text": "司法院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/10.wav", + "text": "中華民國刑法第108條之3條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/11.wav", + "text": "修正草案等17案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/12.wav", + "text": "審查會於今年3月9日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/13.wav", + "text": "審查完竣審查結果如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/14.wav", + "text": "第108條之3及委員謝衣鳯等3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/15.wav", + "text": "所提修正動議均保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/16.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/17.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/18.wav", + "text": "\n另院會將委員游毓蘭等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/19.wav", + "text": "委員張育美等20人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/20.wav", + "text": "及委員林德福等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/21.wav", + "text": "提案逕付二讀與相關提案併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/22.wav", + "text": "協商時請參閱協商條文對照表與審查報告及逕付二讀提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/23.wav", + "text": "相關文書與會委員如有修正動議或機關有建議內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/24.wav", + "text": "印發現場進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/25.wav", + "text": "法務部蔡部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/26.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/27.wav", + "text": "法務部體會到社會的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/28.wav", + "text": "我們覺得很不捨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/29.wav", + "text": "主要是仿照酒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/30.wav", + "text": "有抽象的危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/31.wav", + "text": "有具體的危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/32.wav", + "text": "並沒有超乎這個範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/33.wav", + "text": "一款現增加一款抽象危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/34.wav", + "text": "只要按照衛福部濫用藥物尿液檢驗作業準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/35.wav", + "text": "能驗出合乎有吸毒甚至超過閾值的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/36.wav", + "text": "我們就是認為這是抽象的危險犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/37.wav", + "text": "將他列為處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/38.wav", + "text": "這樣對這種毒駕將有嚇阻效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/39.wav", + "text": "也可以滿足外界對我們的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/40.wav", + "text": "以上補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/41.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/42.wav", + "text": "感謝主席給司法院機會來表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/43.wav", + "text": "其實大家都是有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/44.wav", + "text": "每一種的藥性與藥理都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/45.wav", + "text": "即使依照酒精相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/46.wav", + "text": "哪一種的情形到底是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/47.wav", + "text": "只針對五種藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/48.wav", + "text": "跟酒精能不能安全駕駛沒有一點關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/49.wav", + "text": "應該把這麼多種甚至幾百種的藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/50.wav", + "text": "將抽象危險犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/51.wav", + "text": "而不是不管什麼情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/52.wav", + "text": "只要涉及一點點毒品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/53.wav", + "text": "也不知道毒品濃度是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/54.wav", + "text": "通通都構成所謂的抽象危險犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/55.wav", + "text": "其實這跟抽象危險犯的含義不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/56.wav", + "text": "可能會過不了憲法上的比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/57.wav", + "text": "這點我們非常認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/58.wav", + "text": "某種程度就可以去遏止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/59.wav", + "text": "可能會比較周延也過得了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/60.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/61.wav", + "text": "請問在場各黨團的委員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/62.wav", + "text": "有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/63.wav", + "text": "請我們曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/64.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/65.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委排定今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/66.wav", + "text": "每一位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/67.wav", + "text": "在大方向上大家都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/68.wav", + "text": "現在酒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/69.wav", + "text": "很普遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/70.wav", + "text": "毒駕現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/71.wav", + "text": "必須有更嚴格的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/72.wav", + "text": "畢竟常常發生這種事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/73.wav", + "text": "希望今天法律能有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/74.wav", + "text": "但是有些不常見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/75.wav", + "text": "有些真的不常見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/76.wav", + "text": "所以能不能針對五個十個常見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/77.wav", + "text": "就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/78.wav", + "text": "雖然那種東西有七百零多種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/79.wav", + "text": "可是有些連聽都沒聽過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/80.wav", + "text": "因此我的意思是能不能針對大宗的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/81.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/82.wav", + "text": "司法院跟法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/83.wav", + "text": "把案子送出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/84.wav", + "text": "所以看看今天有沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/85.wav", + "text": "達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/86.wav", + "text": "看看有幾種可以定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/87.wav", + "text": "希望能夠朝有共識的目標來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/88.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/89.wav", + "text": "湯蕙禎委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/90.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/91.wav", + "text": "的針對酒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/92.wav", + "text": "部分現在大致都沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/93.wav", + "text": "危險部分來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/94.wav", + "text": "最主要是哪幾種毒品會影響到安全駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/95.wav", + "text": "過去也曾請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/96.wav", + "text": "處理好像也沒有發生什麼樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/97.wav", + "text": "也沒有窒礙難行的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/98.wav", + "text": "可能會因犯罪構成要件不足而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/99.wav", + "text": "而沒辦法起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/100.wav", + "text": "不曉得是不是有這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/101.wav", + "text": "請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/102.wav", + "text": "等一下請洪孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/103.wav", + "text": "洪孟楷委員發言完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/104.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/105.wav", + "text": "\n在他們發言前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/106.wav", + "text": "我先���明在3月時我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/107.wav", + "text": "有提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/108.wav", + "text": "把食藥署的閾值放在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/109.wav", + "text": "達608十多種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/110.wav", + "text": "而食藥署的規定確實沒辦法涵蓋這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/111.wav", + "text": "現在社會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/112.wav", + "text": "我們沒接觸這個層面的人也不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/113.wav", + "text": "但是實際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/114.wav", + "text": "有這麼多樣的毒品在危害這個社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/115.wav", + "text": "然後造成這樣子危險的駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/116.wav", + "text": "人不只是年初的時候有彰化的員警受害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/117.wav", + "text": "我知道10月底的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/118.wav", + "text": "在宜蘭也有婦人在晨運的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/119.wav", + "text": "我覺得這都是非常遺憾的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/120.wav", + "text": "所以我也不會堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/121.wav", + "text": "當初我在3月份所提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/122.wav", + "text": "我們希望可以具體的把毒駕入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/123.wav", + "text": "來遏止相關的犯行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/124.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/125.wav", + "text": "\n請洪孟楷委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/126.wav", + "text": "我想今天召委排這個討論是非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/127.wav", + "text": "的我也echo一下我們的曾銘宗總召所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/128.wav", + "text": "的就是說既然現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/129.wav", + "text": "大家都已經有這個相關共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/130.wav", + "text": "只是說針對毒品的分類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/131.wav", + "text": "你說七百零多種八百多種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/132.wav", + "text": "未來一定還會有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/133.wav", + "text": "更多因為科技的日新月異有可能有更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/134.wav", + "text": "那有沒有可能採行另外一種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/135.wav", + "text": "因為現在我們的毒品分類也有四級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/136.wav", + "text": "嘛就是明定在四級毒品裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/137.wav", + "text": "因為在這四級毒品裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/138.wav", + "text": "你們也會滾動式檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/139.wav", + "text": "有新興毒品出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/140.wav", + "text": "也會去做裁定跟分類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/141.wav", + "text": "表示這樣的新興毒品可能是屬於哪一級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/142.wav", + "text": "它有不同的刑責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/143.wav", + "text": "這樣是不是比較能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/144.wav", + "text": "讓含括的範圍可以更廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/145.wav", + "text": "而且也不會掛一漏萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/146.wav", + "text": "我想這一點是行政部門這邊可以去思考的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/147.wav", + "text": "\n另外一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/148.wav", + "text": "是特別加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/149.wav", + "text": "因為毒駕酒駕大家都非常的深惡痛絕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/150.wav", + "text": "另外一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/151.wav", + "text": "當然行政部門這邊提出來的修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/152.wav", + "text": "是沒有提到這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/153.wav", + "text": "但是本席跟其他委員的版本比較不同之處是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/154.wav", + "text": "因為我們看到太多的統計數據資料都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/155.wav", + "text": "有酒駕有毒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/156.wav", + "text": "你要嚇阻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/157.wav", + "text": "它除了重罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/158.wav", + "text": "還有就是你真的要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/159.wav", + "text": "因為他們再犯的機率非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/160.wav", + "text": "所以我才會在後面規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/161.wav", + "text": "針對如果十年內再犯的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/162.wav", + "text": "致人於死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/163.wav", + "text": "的部分我希望能夠再增列加重刑責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/164.wav", + "text": "或加重罰金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/165.wav", + "text": "致人於死的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/166.wav", + "text": "要改為七年以上有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/167.wav", + "text": "併科部分從原本三百萬元以下罰金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/168.wav", + "text": "變成五百萬元以下罰金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/169.wav", + "text": "重傷者則是處五年到十二年以下的有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/170.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/171.wav", + "text": "我想是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/172.wav", + "text": "\n因為大家都沒有辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/173.wav", + "text": "一而再再而三的犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/174.wav", + "text": "尤其是我們看到太多那種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/175.wav", + "text": "已經被吊扣駕照的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/176.wav", + "text": "很抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/177.wav", + "text": "我們沒有辦法縱容這樣的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/178.wav", + "text": "一而再再而三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/179.wav", + "text": "我在想說是不是在這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/180.wav", + "text": "既然我們有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/181.wav", + "text": "也一併把相關的罰則也給予加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/182.wav", + "text": "告訴大家我們國家的立場態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/183.wav", + "text": "就是禁止任何形式的酒駕跟毒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/184.wav", + "text": "用嚴刑峻罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/185.wav", + "text": "讓那些罰不怕罰不聽的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/186.wav", + "text": "不要自以為有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/187.wav", + "text": "不要因為自以為僥倖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/188.wav", + "text": "可以有嚇阻的作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/189.wav", + "text": "所以這兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/190.wav", + "text": "我想請行政部門可以再斟酌考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/191.wav", + "text": "本席也希望今天能夠有一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/192.wav", + "text": "送出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/193.wav", + "text": "能夠在這個會期裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/194.wav", + "text": "展現我們的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/195.wav", + "text": "我們拒絕毒駕酒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/196.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/197.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/198.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/199.wav", + "text": "時力黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/200.wav", + "text": "我們是沒有提出我們的草案跟修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/201.wav", + "text": "不過我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/202.wav", + "text": "這個的確是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/203.wav", + "text": "但根據衛福部檢測的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/204.wav", + "text": "如果只是侷限在數種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/205.wav", + "text": "毒品的種類那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/206.wav", + "text": "甚至我們也擔心有人吃了感冒藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/207.wav", + "text": "或者某種藥物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/208.wav", + "text": "我們認為法案的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/209.wav", + "text": "譬如說要有複測複驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/210.wav", + "text": "這樣子可以避免出現偽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/211.wav", + "text": "出現偽陽性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/212.wav", + "text": "狀況因為他是服用其他藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/213.wav", + "text": "非毒品卻造成這種陽性反應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/214.wav", + "text": "毒駕造成交通事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/215.wav", + "text": "的不過在相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/216.wav", + "text": "這些的確也是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/217.wav", + "text": "儘量將多樣毒品的檢測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/218.wav", + "text": "檢測的方式還有避免偽陽性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/219.wav", + "text": "不過希望在說明欄能夠把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/220.wav", + "text": "這個樣態或者規定能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/221.wav", + "text": "更明確地明定出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/222.wav", + "text": "本席有提出修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/223.wav", + "text": "而且是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/224.wav", + "text": "分因為那些酒駕累犯是一犯再犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/225.wav", + "text": "犯顯示酒駕的問題的確是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/226.wav", + "text": "層出不窮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/227.wav", + "text": "立法院也多次修法提高罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/228.wav", + "text": "但是這個講實在話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/229.wav", + "text": "它的成效並沒有收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/230.wav", + "text": "它預計要的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/231.wav", + "text": "所以說酒駕累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/232.wav", + "text": "犯最重要應該是要沒收他的車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/233.wav", + "text": "能將他的車輛沒入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/234.wav", + "text": "我認為這是應該要有的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/235.wav", + "text": "站在不管主觀客觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/236.wav", + "text": "大家的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/237.wav", + "text": "我認為這樣才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/238.wav", + "text": "具備嚇阻的作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/239.wav", + "text": "多少會比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/240.wav", + "text": "呢因為111年3月31號正式實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/241.wav", + "text": "到今年已經滿一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/242.wav", + "text": "110年酒駕發生有3萬6,241件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/243.wav", + "text": "總體數跟111年的3萬5127" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/244.wav", + "text": "件相比看似有減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/245.wav", + "text": "少但是累犯仍是一犯再犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/246.wav", + "text": "造成酒駕一直層出不窮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/247.wav", + "text": "所以我認為這個部分還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/248.wav", + "text": "需要比較積極一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/249.wav", + "text": "讓這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/250.wav", + "text": "經常累犯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/251.wav", + "text": "人能夠收到嚇阻的作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/252.wav", + "text": "因為我們經常看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/253.wav", + "text": "酒駕去撞死人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/254.wav", + "text": "所以我今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/255.wav", + "text": "提出這個修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/256.wav", + "text": "也希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/257.wav", + "text": "讓大家取得一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/258.wav", + "text": "能夠進入二讀以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/259.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/260.wav", + "text": "我們再請法務部就以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/261.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席各位委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/262.wav", + "text": "我們都虛心的接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/263.wav", + "text": "現在新興毒品有這麼多種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/264.wav", + "text": "好幾百種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/265.wav", + "text": "沒辦法全部涵蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/266.wav", + "text": "我們如果引用衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/267.wav", + "text": "現在這個濫用藥物尿液檢驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/268.wav", + "text": "作業準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/269.wav", + "text": "大概就涵蓋了百分之九十以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/270.wav", + "text": "而且它已經有標準的閾值了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/271.wav", + "text": "有標準的閾值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/272.wav", + "text": "我們就已經可以處理大部分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/273.wav", + "text": "依照這個閾值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/274.wav", + "text": "超過這個閾值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/275.wav", + "text": "我們就認為是抽象危險犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/276.wav", + "text": "如果說沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/277.wav", + "text": "其實不是沒有處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/278.wav", + "text": "本來就有處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/279.wav", + "text": "是用具體危險犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/280.wav", + "text": "必須要致生公共危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/281.wav", + "text": "多一個條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/282.wav", + "text": "仍然是有處罰的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/283.wav", + "text": "所以我們只是比照酒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/284.wav", + "text": "多一項標準��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/285.wav", + "text": "你超過這個閾值絕對不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/286.wav", + "text": "這是很明顯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/287.wav", + "text": "如果再加上常用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/288.wav", + "text": "現在據衛福部給我們的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/289.wav", + "text": "有22種的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/290.wav", + "text": "就已經達到99%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/291.wav", + "text": "都可以驗出他有毒品反應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/292.wav", + "text": "那就可以處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/293.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這樣來教育民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/294.wav", + "text": "很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/295.wav", + "text": "毒駕就是不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/296.wav", + "text": "不管你是哪一種毒品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/297.wav", + "text": "你既然吸了毒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/298.wav", + "text": "何況最近還有人在倡導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/299.wav", + "text": "不准藥駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/300.wav", + "text": "耶吃藥就不能開車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/301.wav", + "text": "了我們現在是毒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/302.wav", + "text": "已經是認定為毒品了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/303.wav", + "text": "何況是以衛福部的客觀標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/304.wav", + "text": "有閾值的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/305.wav", + "text": "我們才把他提高為抽象危險犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/306.wav", + "text": "至於具體危險犯還是維持原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/307.wav", + "text": "嘛所以司法院認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/308.wav", + "text": "維持原來就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/309.wav", + "text": "我們不過是把一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/310.wav", + "text": "有具體閾值的再抽出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/311.wav", + "text": "說我就是認定你這個是毒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/312.wav", + "text": "不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/313.wav", + "text": "我們只是做這樣一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/314.wav", + "text": "符合社會的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/315.wav", + "text": "來提出這樣修法的請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/316.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/317.wav", + "text": "請簡短說明就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/318.wav", + "text": "其實抽象危險犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/319.wav", + "text": "跟憲法上比例原則的界線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/320.wav", + "text": "而且酒精就是一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/321.wav", + "text": "毒品幾百種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/322.wav", + "text": "每一種藥性都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/323.wav", + "text": "所以沒有辦法用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/324.wav", + "text": "這是司法院的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/325.wav", + "text": "但是剛才幾位委員提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/326.wav", + "text": "我們也高度的重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/327.wav", + "text": "的常用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/328.wav", + "text": "像剛才陳椒華委員也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/329.wav", + "text": "中明白說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/330.wav", + "text": "這一個公告��指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/331.wav", + "text": "到一定的閾值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/332.wav", + "text": "對於安全駕駛就有一般性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/333.wav", + "text": "的抽象危險然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/334.wav", + "text": "合理適當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/335.wav", + "text": "看是要在條文裡面表明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/336.wav", + "text": "衛福部公告危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/337.wav", + "text": "影響安全駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/338.wav", + "text": "還是要在立法理由中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/339.wav", + "text": "像陳椒華委員所說這樣表明清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/340.wav", + "text": "可以接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/341.wav", + "text": "行政院跟司法院的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/342.wav", + "text": "放入食藥署公告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/343.wav", + "text": "大家可以接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/344.wav", + "text": "行政院跟司法院的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/345.wav", + "text": "司法院還要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/346.wav", + "text": "跟主席委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/347.wav", + "text": "我們在立法理由中說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/348.wav", + "text": "就是希望食藥署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/349.wav", + "text": "公告這些常用藥物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/350.wav", + "text": "經過科學檢視證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/351.wav", + "text": "如同酒精一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/352.wav", + "text": "是指這種公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/353.wav", + "text": "足以影響到安全駕駛的公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/354.wav", + "text": "就比較符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/355.wav", + "text": "那如果是陽性呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/356.wav", + "text": "剛才我們都已經說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/357.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/358.wav", + "text": "他有沒有吸跟他有沒有安全駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/359.wav", + "text": "駕駛閾值是不是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/360.wav", + "text": "可能要食藥署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/361.wav", + "text": "是不是應該說他有吸毒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/362.wav", + "text": "就不應該現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/363.wav", + "text": "會不會是陽性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/364.wav", + "text": "有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/365.wav", + "text": "對啊如果已經是陽性了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/366.wav", + "text": "那還需要超過閾值嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/367.wav", + "text": "過去我們在意的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/368.wav", + "text": "以過去酒駕的方式去認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/369.wav", + "text": "導致後來又陸續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/370.wav", + "text": "有毒駕的受害者出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/371.wav", + "text": "那我們是不是還要再堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/372.wav", + "text": "過去我們希望公告一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/373.wav", + "text": "具體危險犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/374.wav", + "text": "我覺得是不是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/375.wav", + "text": "已經檢驗出陽性反應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/376.wav", + "text": "就算毒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/377.wav", + "text": "折衷的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/378.wav", + "text": "是有沒有辦法把你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/379.wav", + "text": "意見整合到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/380.wav", + "text": "跟司法院送出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/381.wav", + "text": "的版本有沒有辦法跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/382.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/383.wav", + "text": "閾值跟安全駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/384.wav", + "text": "由衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/385.wav", + "text": "經過檢驗然後去定出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/386.wav", + "text": "我們就可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/387.wav", + "text": "部長這樣可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/388.wav", + "text": "就在說明欄裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/389.wav", + "text": "就是這個標準裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/390.wav", + "text": "這幾種有閾值的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/391.wav", + "text": "會影響到安全駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/392.wav", + "text": "中說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/393.wav", + "text": "好那我們就按照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/394.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/395.wav", + "text": "主席不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/396.wav", + "text": "就是我們目前的作業準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/397.wav", + "text": "跟我們定的閾值其實基本上原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/398.wav", + "text": "就是這個方法跟這個機器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/399.wav", + "text": "可以判讀出來的最低檢驗濃度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/400.wav", + "text": "而已所以這個閾值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/401.wav", + "text": "在我們毒危條例的判定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/402.wav", + "text": "只是有沒有施用毒品的一個閾值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/403.wav", + "text": "至於它是是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/404.wav", + "text": "安全駕駛與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/405.wav", + "text": "這個其實是我們沒有辦法做出判定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/406.wav", + "text": "討論時就是用閾值判定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/407.wav", + "text": "可是司法院對於超" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/408.wav", + "text": "超過這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/409.wav", + "text": "我們為了這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/410.wav", + "text": "無法遏止相關的犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/411.wav", + "text": "還有人因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/412.wav", + "text": "那是不是我們不要再堅持這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/413.wav", + "text": "只要吸毒就不能開車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/414.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/415.wav", + "text": "我只插一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/416.wav", + "text": "江委員你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/417.wav", + "text": "你要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/418.wav", + "text": "其實是很不想講這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/419.wav", + "text": "食藥署有一個叫做最低可檢驗值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/420.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/421.wav", + "text": "是不是適用毒品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/422.wav", + "text": "閾值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/423.wav", + "text": "接下來是道路交通管理處罰條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/424.wav", + "text": "毒駕的行政的閾值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/425.wav", + "text": "接下來是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/426.wav", + "text": "刑法第108條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/427.wav", + "text": "可罰性的這個閾值是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/428.wav", + "text": "不能安全駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/429.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的只有第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/430.wav", + "text": "就是可檢驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/431.wav", + "text": "出的最低值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/432.wav", + "text": "我沒有任何立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/433.wav", + "text": "但主席今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/434.wav", + "text": "這樣裁示下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/435.wav", + "text": "請問司法院你們判決怎麼判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/436.wav", + "text": "只會有那個值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/437.wav", + "text": "我是贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/438.wav", + "text": "不能毒駕非常贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/439.wav", + "text": "但我也尊重司法院你們以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/440.wav", + "text": "要審判就是審判能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/441.wav", + "text": "下判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/442.wav", + "text": "我們就用最嚴格的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/443.wav", + "text": "主席如果要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/444.wav", + "text": "因為很有可能就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/445.wav", + "text": "打不打槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/446.wav", + "text": "除了我剛剛講會有四種閾值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/447.wav", + "text": "要做參考以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/448.wav", + "text": "如果是酒駕的話很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/449.wav", + "text": "液它是或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/450.wav", + "text": "無論哪一種只要達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/451.wav", + "text": "我要處罰你的標準的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/452.wav", + "text": "都OK而且直接明定那個標準值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/453.wav", + "text": "所以你看在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/454.wav", + "text": "第108條之3當中寫到酒的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/455.wav", + "text": "吐氣標準多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/456.wav", + "text": "但是我剛剛點的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/457.wav", + "text": "食藥署在刑法入罪的條文中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/458.wav", + "text": "居然是參考最低值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/459.wav", + "text": "如果要求法官這樣判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/460.wav", + "text": "我也沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/461.wav", + "text": "你如何去表達一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/462.wav", + "text": "經尿液經檢驗出是陽性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/463.wav", + "text": "這在第4款就處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/464.wav", + "text": "是不是檢驗毛髮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/465.wav", + "text": "要達到什麼值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/466.wav", + "text": "足認不能安全駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/467.wav", + "text": "這兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/468.wav", + "text": "現在強制驗尿已經違憲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/469.wav", + "text": "不接受強制驗尿的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/470.wav", + "text": "在刑法要回到哪裡去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/471.wav", + "text": "在道安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/472.wav", + "text": "現在是非自願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/473.wav", + "text": "不能強制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/474.wav", + "text": "道安歸道安的去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/475.wav", + "text": "可是在刑法上可能要考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/476.wav", + "text": "強制驗尿已經違憲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/477.wav", + "text": "所以這第4款如何執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/478.wav", + "text": "接下來就是我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/479.wav", + "text": "你用其他的值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/480.wav", + "text": "來認定他施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/481.wav", + "text": "施用毒品到不能安全駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/482.wav", + "text": "是根據什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/483.wav", + "text": "我補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/484.wav", + "text": "主席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/485.wav", + "text": "大家的共識都在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/486.wav", + "text": "最低可檢驗值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/487.wav", + "text": "我也沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/488.wav", + "text": "對我們就是按照大家共同的協議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/489.wav", + "text": "用最嚴格的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/490.wav", + "text": "只要檢驗出是陽性反應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/491.wav", + "text": "就是尿液經檢驗出陽性反應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/492.wav", + "text": "就是第108條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/493.wav", + "text": "之3照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/494.wav", + "text": "跟司法院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/495.wav", + "text": "配合第108條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/496.wav", + "text": "之3條文之修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/497.wav", + "text": "請法務部補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/498.wav", + "text": "立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/499.wav", + "text": "函送本院並納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/500.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/501.wav", + "text": "還是請慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/502.wav", + "text": "當然尊重大院的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/503.wav", + "text": "像剛才江委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/504.wav", + "text": "我看還是不要用我做擋箭牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/505.wav", + "text": "你們自己儘量講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/506.wav", + "text": "我已經盡力了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/507.wav", + "text": "因為剛才食藥署都講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/508.wav", + "text": "他們公告的閾值跟安全駕駛是無關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/509.wav", + "text": "如果他們自己說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/510.wav", + "text": "跟安全駕駛無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/511.wav", + "text": "我們能夠用抽象危險犯去涵攝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/512.wav", + "text": "這個我們是相當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/513.wav", + "text": "有疑慮跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/514.wav", + "text": "如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/515.wav", + "text": "第108條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/516.wav", + "text": "照行政院司法院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/517.wav", + "text": "檢附立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/518.wav", + "text": "稍待議事人員將協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/519.wav", + "text": "書面製作完成後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/520.wav", + "text": "就交由委員簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/521.wav", + "text": "下要不要朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/522.wav", + "text": "不用了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/523.wav", + "text": "不用吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/524.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15255/525.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/0.wav", + "text": "各位姐妹兄弟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1.wav", + "text": "現在我們進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/2.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/3.wav", + "text": "今天要研商的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/4.wav", + "text": "是民進黨黨團所提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/5.wav", + "text": "那我們就先請提案人說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/6.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/7.wav", + "text": "各位黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/8.wav", + "text": "立法院在每一屆的最後一個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/9.wav", + "text": "都有提前休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/10.wav", + "text": "一屆是18日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/11.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/12.wav", + "text": "好好地拼連任未來還有4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/13.wav", + "text": "可以來審預算審法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/14.wav", + "text": "這比較實際啦所以立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/15.wav", + "text": "來討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/16.wav", + "text": "過去不管什麼時候休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/17.wav", + "text": "因為一屆要結束不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/18.wav", + "text": "2020年那一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/19.wav", + "text": "只有一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/20.wav", + "text": "因為2016年小英當選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/21.wav", + "text": "總統2020年看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/22.wav", + "text": "也勢必會當選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/23.wav", + "text": "那時候是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/24.wav", + "text": "選完以後蘇嘉全還在當立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/25.wav", + "text": "時候再召集大家來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/26.wav", + "text": "處理總預算1個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/27.wav", + "text": "當然我認為各黨對於總統選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/28.wav", + "text": "大家都有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/29.wav", + "text": "12月19日是禮拜二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/30.wav", + "text": "上一屆是18日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/31.wav", + "text": "這一次開到19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/32.wav", + "text": "19日是最後一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/33.wav", + "text": "大家回去拼選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/34.wav", + "text": "這是一個看起來合理的安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/35.wav", + "text": "啦這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/36.wav", + "text": "我們大家就要有一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/37.wav", + "text": "���預算不論如何要把它完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/38.wav", + "text": "12月15日是禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/39.wav", + "text": "19日是禮拜二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/40.wav", + "text": "這3天是一次會好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/41.wav", + "text": "提早完成當然就提早休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/42.wav", + "text": "之所以保留3天一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/43.wav", + "text": "因為總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/44.wav", + "text": "同時有些比較重大的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/45.wav", + "text": "或是有共識的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/46.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/47.wav", + "text": "第二個既然這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/48.wav", + "text": "我們大家有共識把總預算予以完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/49.wav", + "text": "總預算一定要完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/50.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長還有各黨團黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/51.wav", + "text": "及總統選舉前停開院會及委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/52.wav", + "text": "進行協商我想還是表達一下台灣民眾黨的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/53.wav", + "text": "我們是認為應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/54.wav", + "text": "要建立一個新的政治文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/55.wav", + "text": "所以我們反對停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/56.wav", + "text": "反對對我們反對停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/57.wav", + "text": "我們希望會期進行到12月31日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/58.wav", + "text": "日這有幾個重點我相信各黨團會講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/59.wav", + "text": "過去的慣例第9屆是12月18日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/60.wav", + "text": "就停會第8屆是12月21" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/61.wav", + "text": "日停會前兩屆大概都是停會9天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/62.wav", + "text": "更早之前停會1個禮拜到3個禮拜的都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/63.wav", + "text": "大家可能會說這是過去的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/64.wav", + "text": "是我們希望它可以改變臺灣的政治文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/65.wav", + "text": "\n我們認為慣例是可以打破的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/66.wav", + "text": "好的政治文化是可以建立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/67.wav", + "text": "所以要考慮我們國會的形象以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/68.wav", + "text": "我同意柯總召講的在法定會期內把總預算完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/69.wav", + "text": "昨天審的道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/70.wav", + "text": "最低工資法公民投票不在籍投票法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/71.wav", + "text": "以及所謂的揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/72.wav", + "text": "等非常多的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/73.wav", + "text": "其實還有很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/74.wav", + "text": "在第10屆第8會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/75.wav", + "text": "我們希望可以把這些工作完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/76.wav", + "text": "\n我知道選舉非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/77.wav", + "text": "我個人也正在投入區域立委的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/78.wav", + "text": "但是我們要莫忘初衷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/79.wav", + "text": "不希望我們的國會問政有所打折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/80.wav", + "text": "立法委員也不是只有跑攤和上節目罵人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/81.wav", + "text": "我們認為國會的工作還是相對非常專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/82.wav", + "text": "非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/83.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望建立一個好的政治文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/84.wav", + "text": "把我們能做的事情都做完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/85.wav", + "text": "\n另一個方面我們要談到的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/86.wav", + "text": "立委的職責和建立政黨政治的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/87.wav", + "text": "我知道連任非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/88.wav", + "text": "好的政治文化並予以延續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/89.wav", + "text": "其實各政黨的社會形象也能有所提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/90.wav", + "text": "我覺得這對選舉也是非常有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/91.wav", + "text": "的可以讓更多人民看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/92.wav", + "text": "做為他投下神聖一票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/93.wav", + "text": "我們認為這是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/94.wav", + "text": "的\n基於以上的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/95.wav", + "text": "希望可以審到12月31日以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/96.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/97.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/98.wav", + "text": "\n謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/99.wav", + "text": "我們原則上是同意柯總召所提出來的15" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/100.wav", + "text": "情畢竟從過去以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/101.wav", + "text": "我相信所有民眾也看到這一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/102.wav", + "text": "其實大家在立法院都非常有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/103.wav", + "text": "不管是在預算上面或法案上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/104.wav", + "text": "總預算一定要在這個一次會之前通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/105.wav", + "text": "我認為我們最重要的原則就是在本屆結束之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/106.wav", + "text": "查如果沒有辦法在19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/107.wav", + "text": "那也沒有辦法啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/108.wav", + "text": "或者沒共識的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/109.wav", + "text": "有部分沒有完成的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/110.wav", + "text": "選後也可以再繼續進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/111.wav", + "text": "把所有的總預算都完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/112.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/113.wav", + "text": "來曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/114.wav", + "text": "各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/115.wav", + "text": "今天要朝野協商兩個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/116.wav", + "text": "第一個要不要休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/117.wav", + "text": "過去的慣例來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/118.wav", + "text": "絕大部分都有休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/119.wav", + "text": "所以假設要休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/120.wav", + "text": "國民黨團基本上贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/121.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/122.wav", + "text": "第二點就是剛剛柯總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/123.wav", + "text": "另外一個議題要不要在休會前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/124.wav", + "text": "把所有的預算都完成三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/125.wav", + "text": "國民黨團基本上都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/126.wav", + "text": "但是有三個要留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/127.wav", + "text": "監察院都沒有功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/128.wav", + "text": "了連個糾正都不敢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/129.wav", + "text": "NCC留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/130.wav", + "text": "三立持有中嘉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/131.wav", + "text": "對不對也不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/132.wav", + "text": "第三個數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/133.wav", + "text": "一點功能都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/134.wav", + "text": "基本上其他的OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/135.wav", + "text": "我們也會請我們委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/136.wav", + "text": "的召委配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/137.wav", + "text": "我們也OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/138.wav", + "text": "留下來總要有一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/139.wav", + "text": "留校察看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/140.wav", + "text": "這三個機關太誇張了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/141.wav", + "text": "那我為什麼說要留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/142.wav", + "text": "因為某個程度雖然要選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/143.wav", + "text": "但是我們作為立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/144.wav", + "text": "也要善盡我們審查預算的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/145.wav", + "text": "不然我們對全民沒辦法交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/146.wav", + "text": "\n所以兩個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/147.wav", + "text": "第一個要休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/148.wav", + "text": "基本上支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/149.wav", + "text": "但是總預算要不要在休會前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/150.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/151.wav", + "text": "原則上同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/152.wav", + "text": "但是有三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/153.wav", + "text": "監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/154.wav", + "text": "沒有任何的功能連糾正也不敢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/155.wav", + "text": "所以監察院真的超級誇張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/156.wav", + "text": "不瞞你說我本來要遞出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/157.wav", + "text": "將監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/158.wav", + "text": "跟數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/159.wav", + "text": "留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/160.wav", + "text": "我相信全民會接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/161.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/162.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/163.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/164.wav", + "text": "各位黨團的幹部大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/165.wav", + "text": "我想立法院開議到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/166.wav", + "text": "其實才一個多月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/167.wav", + "text": "所以也沒辦法理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/168.wav", + "text": "為什麼民進黨團這麼早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/169.wav", + "text": "就急於討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/170.wav", + "text": "要休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/171.wav", + "text": "第9屆應該也是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/172.wav", + "text": "11月底12月初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/173.wav", + "text": "才開始協商討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/174.wav", + "text": "要不要提前休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/175.wav", + "text": "竟然11月才過幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/176.wav", + "text": "就在討論要不要提早放假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/177.wav", + "text": "我想這個讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/178.wav", + "text": "每天都辛苦上班的國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/179.wav", + "text": "情何以堪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/180.wav", + "text": "交代得過去嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/181.wav", + "text": "所以時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/182.wav", + "text": "堅決反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/183.wav", + "text": "立法院提前停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/184.wav", + "text": "這個會期最重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/185.wav", + "text": "就是總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/186.wav", + "text": "但是總預算案的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/187.wav", + "text": "到現在進度仍然落後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/188.wav", + "text": "立法委員重要的職責之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/189.wav", + "text": "就是為人民把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/190.wav", + "text": "他們辛苦的納稅錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/191.wav", + "text": "錢各委員會到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/192.wav", + "text": "總預算案都還沒有審完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/193.wav", + "text": "出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/194.wav", + "text": "民進黨就提議要休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/195.wav", + "text": "不上班了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/196.wav", + "text": "這樣合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/197.wav", + "text": "以我在交通委員會為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/198.wav", + "text": "本會期到現在11月初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/199.wav", + "text": "竟然還沒有任何一個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/200.wav", + "text": "機關的公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/201.wav", + "text": "開始審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/202.wav", + "text": "像是交通主管的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/203.wav", + "text": "涵蓋運輸觀光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/204.wav", + "text": "氣象郵政等領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/205.wav", + "text": "單單2024年交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/206.wav", + "text": "本部的公務預算支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/207.wav", + "text": "事實上就高達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/208.wav", + "text": "新臺幣486億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/209.wav", + "text": "更遑論立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/210.wav", + "text": "交通委員會審查的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/211.wav", + "text": "還有包括剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/212.wav", + "text": "曾總召提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/213.wav", + "text": "數發部NCC運安會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/214.wav", + "text": "這些二級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/215.wav", + "text": "時力黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/216.wav", + "text": "要求各委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/217.wav", + "text": "嚴審總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/218.wav", + "text": "不要現在休息跑選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/219.wav", + "text": "選後才來開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/220.wav", + "text": "隨便審一審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/221.wav", + "text": "這對於國會的監督量能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/222.wav", + "text": "是不健康的也是大打折扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/223.wav", + "text": "最後會期有很多法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/224.wav", + "text": "還沒有審完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/225.wav", + "text": "剛剛邱總召也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/226.wav", + "text": "到現在一直裝死擺爛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/227.wav", + "text": "揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/228.wav", + "text": "囤房稅2.0還有最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/229.wav", + "text": "工資法都還沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/230.wav", + "text": "甚至連有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/231.wav", + "text": "關轉型正義的政治檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/232.wav", + "text": "條例民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/233.wav", + "text": "連排都還沒排審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/234.wav", + "text": "這個會期雖然開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/235.wav", + "text": "時間少還有預算要審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/236.wav", + "text": "但是委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/237.wav", + "text": "也不是來不及處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/238.wav", + "text": "就時力黨團自己的紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/239.wav", + "text": "截至上個禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/240.wav", + "text": "各委員會就排了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/241.wav", + "text": "37場考察行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/242.wav", + "text": "有超過四分之一的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/243.wav", + "text": "委員會議程都是考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/244.wav", + "text": "人沒有留在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/245.wav", + "text": "立法院開會結果現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/246.wav", + "text": "預算法案審不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/247.wav", + "text": "立法院還想要提早休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/248.wav", + "text": "真的是說不過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/249.wav", + "text": "\n最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/250.wav", + "text": "不論如何立法院的法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/251.wav", + "text": "會期就是到12月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/252.wav", + "text": "這是人民課予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/253.wav", + "text": "我們立法委員最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/254.wav", + "text": "責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/255.wav", + "text": "這個責任跟義務不應該因為立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/256.wav", + "text": "要跑選舉而改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/257.wav", + "text": "因此時力黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/258.wav", + "text": "到12月底儘速完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/259.wav", + "text": "相關法案及預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/260.wav", + "text": "不要辜負人民的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/261.wav", + "text": "託付跟期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/262.wav", + "text": "所以強烈反對抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/263.wav", + "text": "立法院提前停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/264.wav", + "text": "提前停會不是什麼慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/265.wav", + "text": "我們不要這種說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/266.wav", + "text": "在這裡也要呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/267.wav", + "text": "一起反對提前停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/268.wav", + "text": "好好在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/269.wav", + "text": "善盡職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/270.wav", + "text": "為人民把關政府施政預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/271.wav", + "text": "否則只會凸顯立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/272.wav", + "text": "集體怠惰無法得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/273.wav", + "text": "人民的支持與認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/274.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/275.wav", + "text": "我很仔細聆聽各黨的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/276.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/277.wav", + "text": "所謂新的政治文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/278.wav", + "text": "在這個地方說開會到哪一天才是新的政治文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/279.wav", + "text": "顯現你去想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/280.wav", + "text": "我是不好意思講啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/281.wav", + "text": "新的政治文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/282.wav", + "text": "嗎柯P整天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/283.wav", + "text": "提早休會就是好的文化嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/284.wav", + "text": "集體怠惰是好的文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/285.wav", + "text": "你聽我說讓我講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/286.wav", + "text": "不是啊你要挖苦我我一定要回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/287.wav", + "text": "很多人都會講很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/288.wav", + "text": "我們堅持到最後或是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/289.wav", + "text": "我一一來解釋這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/290.wav", + "text": "新的文化建立不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/291.wav", + "text": "多十幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/292.wav", + "text": "就是新的文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/293.wav", + "text": "在立法院大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/294.wav", + "text": "以現在委員會的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/295.wav", + "text": "剛才陳椒華在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/296.wav", + "text": "你就不會想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/297.wav", + "text": "交通委員會不排的是誰是陳雪生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/298.wav", + "text": "嘛很多都不排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/299.wav", + "text": "大家都去考察嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/300.wav", + "text": "我們講白的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/301.wav", + "text": "啊我從頭開始要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/302.wav", + "text": "我們黨團召兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/303.wav", + "text": "總召又不是只有一位總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/304.wav", + "text": "對啊我們的部分都排完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/305.wav", + "text": "你不要插話好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/306.wav", + "text": "你在講話我都會聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/307.wav", + "text": "我們維持秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/308.wav", + "text": "讓柯總召講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/309.wav", + "text": "然後邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/310.wav", + "text": "我們等一下在這裡爭���也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/311.wav", + "text": "好像講得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/312.wav", + "text": "只有你是多認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/313.wav", + "text": "你有沒有去看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/314.wav", + "text": "裡面我從一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/315.wav", + "text": "總預算付委的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/316.wav", + "text": "我就要求我們的人一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/317.wav", + "text": "總預算先審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/318.wav", + "text": "然後還有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/319.wav", + "text": "專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/320.wav", + "text": "專業法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/321.wav", + "text": "很多都在國民黨的手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/322.wav", + "text": "一人一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/323.wav", + "text": "的老大拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/324.wav", + "text": "你為什麼不趕快排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/325.wav", + "text": "讓柯總召講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/326.wav", + "text": "拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/327.wav", + "text": "我都去拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/328.wav", + "text": "我這邊有表格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/329.wav", + "text": "我來跟曾總召對一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/330.wav", + "text": "我至少每個禮拜都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/331.wav", + "text": "向他請安一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/332.wav", + "text": "拜託總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/333.wav", + "text": "他說好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/334.wav", + "text": "但是持平而論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/335.wav", + "text": "很多立委為了選舉的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/336.wav", + "text": "都在排考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/337.wav", + "text": "察和專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/338.wav", + "text": "所以總預算都沒有審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/339.wav", + "text": "是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/340.wav", + "text": "包括交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/341.wav", + "text": "我們召委手上的是不是都在審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/342.wav", + "text": "所以大家不要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/343.wav", + "text": "要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/344.wav", + "text": "講完啦你等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/345.wav", + "text": "有講話的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/346.wav", + "text": "然後要做臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/347.wav", + "text": "自有公評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/348.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/349.wav", + "text": "我們執政黨至少會很負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/350.wav", + "text": "地把該做的事情做完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/351.wav", + "text": "這是我們的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/352.wav", + "text": "所以我剛才講的部分就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/353.wav", + "text": "天政治就改變了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/354.wav", + "text": "不是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/355.wav", + "text": "政治是非常複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/356.wav", + "text": "的而且選舉高度衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/357.wav", + "text": "\n務實來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/358.wav", + "text": "老是���講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/359.wav", + "text": "同樣的事情講了一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/360.wav", + "text": "還是在講同樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/361.wav", + "text": "難道只有這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/362.wav", + "text": "我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/363.wav", + "text": "大家務實來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/364.wav", + "text": "我剛才講說大家要很負責地把總預算弄完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/365.wav", + "text": "每屆都是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/366.wav", + "text": "這是一個原則性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/367.wav", + "text": "如果連總預算都沒有處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/368.wav", + "text": "的話說會看緊人民荷包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/369.wav", + "text": "選完以後大家都無心了還是一樣地處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/370.wav", + "text": "嗎程序還是一樣內容還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/371.wav", + "text": "嘛這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/372.wav", + "text": "\n第二點至於重大法案我們一定有安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/373.wav", + "text": "你講的那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/374.wav", + "text": "我們自己有自己的安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/375.wav", + "text": "包括政治檔案法等等都是我們送進來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/376.wav", + "text": "我們一定有安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/377.wav", + "text": "大家在院會就已經處理過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/378.wav", + "text": "所以不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/379.wav", + "text": "\n難道政治檔案法是你們提的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/380.wav", + "text": "還是行政院送進來的你們有沒有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/381.wav", + "text": "不可能嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/382.wav", + "text": "你現在講說這個趕快審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/383.wav", + "text": "我們早就來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/384.wav", + "text": "並不是說所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/385.wav", + "text": "大家不要互相攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/386.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/387.wav", + "text": "你們贊成停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/388.wav", + "text": "未來三黨都要選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/389.wav", + "text": "總預算難道認為自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/390.wav", + "text": "不會讓它過嗎不可能嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/391.wav", + "text": "誰用得到都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/392.wav", + "text": "國家要正常地運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/393.wav", + "text": "所以我還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/394.wav", + "text": "適度地停會是必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/395.wav", + "text": "第二點是我來這裡要拜託曾銘宗總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/396.wav", + "text": "你說三個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/397.wav", + "text": "監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/398.wav", + "text": "俋現在在當祕書長他是老同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/399.wav", + "text": "你有什麼東西可以跟他溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/400.wav", + "text": "不要說不能讓它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/401.wav", + "text": "至於NCC跟數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/402.wav", + "text": "這有一個問題啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/403.wav", + "text": "假如所有部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/404.wav", + "text": "總預算也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/405.wav", + "text": "你可以引用預算法第52條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/406.wav", + "text": "預算審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/407.wav", + "text": "可以附帶條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/408.wav", + "text": "總預算還是不會過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/409.wav", + "text": "因為總數不會出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/410.wav", + "text": "這個有實際上作業的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/411.wav", + "text": "所以大家要好好想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/412.wav", + "text": "我們還是要很理性地面對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/413.wav", + "text": "至於重大法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/414.wav", + "text": "你放心我們一定會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/415.wav", + "text": "我比各位都還嚴謹包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/416.wav", + "text": "我們通過136個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/417.wav", + "text": "那是壓得很死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/418.wav", + "text": "拜託謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/419.wav", + "text": "多排一些法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/420.wav", + "text": "這會期上個禮拜我也協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/421.wav", + "text": "了幾個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/422.wav", + "text": "所以大家應該要很理性地來看待整個問政整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/423.wav", + "text": "還是要正常運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/424.wav", + "text": "這是最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/425.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/426.wav", + "text": "有一個不可說的祕密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/427.wav", + "text": "朝野協商這個機制上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/428.wav", + "text": "至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/429.wav", + "text": "我們一定要把自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/430.wav", + "text": "該做的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/431.wav", + "text": "審預算審法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/432.wav", + "text": "不能說沒照我們意思的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/433.wav", + "text": "打假球沒有這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/434.wav", + "text": "立法院不是一個人講的算話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/435.wav", + "text": "老是用這一套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/436.wav", + "text": "在處理政治事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/437.wav", + "text": "人民都會看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/438.wav", + "text": "哪一黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/439.wav", + "text": "大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/440.wav", + "text": "重回來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/441.wav", + "text": "再繼續為國家打拼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/442.wav", + "text": "我還是拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/443.wav", + "text": "要停該停就停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/444.wav", + "text": "天天在吵架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/445.wav", + "text": "天天在考察天天在專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/446.wav", + "text": "難道老百姓就都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/447.wav", + "text": "你們這個是新政治嗎不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/448.wav", + "text": "也不是說某一個黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/449.wav", + "text": "執政法案沒有過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/450.wav", + "text": "打假球這是合議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/451.wav", + "text": "議制的這是民主社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/452.wav", + "text": "我希望大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/453.wav", + "text": "很務實的面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/454.wav", + "text": "我們最後的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/455.wav", + "text": "假如大家有共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/456.wav", + "text": "為什麼今年我們要拿出來提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/457.wav", + "text": "呢每一次都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/458.wav", + "text": "要提前談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/459.wav", + "text": "代力量沒有負責過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/460.wav", + "text": "這個國民黨和我們一樣都有執政過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/461.wav", + "text": "都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/462.wav", + "text": "冗長的而且有法律規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/463.wav", + "text": "的出委員會一個月以後才可以表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/464.wav", + "text": "才可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/465.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/466.wav", + "text": "完全不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/467.wav", + "text": "一個月以後才可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/468.wav", + "text": "完全不可能\n總預算一定報銷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/469.wav", + "text": "沒有當過黨鞭的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/470.wav", + "text": "不知道這個中間的整個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/471.wav", + "text": "很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/472.wav", + "text": "所以大家假如能夠同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/473.wav", + "text": "等一下我這個表格弄出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/474.wav", + "text": "有哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/475.wav", + "text": "大概下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/476.wav", + "text": "衛環那一組就能夠先整合完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/477.wav", + "text": "衛環那一組是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/478.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/479.wav", + "text": "下禮拜衛環那一組審查出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/480.wav", + "text": "接下去就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/481.wav", + "text": "安排財政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/482.wav", + "text": "審查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/483.wav", + "text": "然後送到院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/484.wav", + "text": "院會交下來才可以起算時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/485.wav", + "text": "怎麼是像陳椒華講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/486.wav", + "text": "好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/487.wav", + "text": "都是提早協商\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/488.wav", + "text": "各位不要忘記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/489.wav", + "text": "我們開會的第一天大家都在這裡談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/490.wav", + "text": "什麼時候打算休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/491.wav", + "text": "我說晚一點談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/492.wav", + "text": "今天我們談休會很正常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/493.wav", + "text": "你又拿來誣衊大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/494.wav", + "text": "這何其不道德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/495.wav", + "text": "陳椒華我認為以後你講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/496.wav", + "text": "不可能這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/497.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/498.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/499.wav", + "text": "發言的順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/500.wav", + "text": "邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/501.wav", + "text": "再來是莊瑞雄先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/502.wav", + "text": "但是莊瑞雄先生是第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/503.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/504.wav", + "text": "先讓他發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/505.wav", + "text": "我是副總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/506.wav", + "text": "現在把你升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/507.wav", + "text": "再來是曾銘宗委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/508.wav", + "text": "還有我們各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/509.wav", + "text": "立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/510.wav", + "text": "親愛的夥伴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/511.wav", + "text": "大家不用互相騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/512.wav", + "text": "你要選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/513.wav", + "text": "選我們其他的人都不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/514.wav", + "text": "你要選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/515.wav", + "text": "我要說的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/516.wav", + "text": "我記得我第8屆剛進來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/517.wav", + "text": "選舉要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/518.wav", + "text": "了記得上次也是12月的時候停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/519.wav", + "text": "我說立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/520.wav", + "text": "也會先停下來大家不用開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/521.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/522.wav", + "text": "不管是從第8屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/523.wav", + "text": "以我個人的經驗都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/524.wav", + "text": "要選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/525.wav", + "text": "總統要選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/526.wav", + "text": "立法委員要選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/527.wav", + "text": "你想想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/528.wav", + "text": "看市長選舉和議會選舉也都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/529.wav", + "text": "都有一段期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/530.wav", + "text": "假設我們今天是12月20日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/531.wav", + "text": "20天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/532.wav", + "text": "3個禮拜的時間去跑選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/533.wav", + "text": "合理啦民眾不會罵你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/534.wav", + "text": "啦民眾只會認為這樣才叫做正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/535.wav", + "text": "他現在就要選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/536.wav", + "text": "他也去請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/537.wav", + "text": "侯友宜他要選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/538.wav", + "text": "當然他要請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/539.wav", + "text": "我們立法院要選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/540.wav", + "text": "只差在我們不是請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/541.wav", + "text": "我這不是胡說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/542.wav", + "text": "侯友宜那個叫合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/543.wav", + "text": "那不是亂講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/544.wav", + "text": "我如果去罵侯友宜那才叫我亂講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/545.wav", + "text": "侯友宜要選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/546.wav", + "text": "人家當然要請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/547.wav", + "text": "啊這是法制的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/548.wav", + "text": "嘛你說其他的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/549.wav", + "text": "當然是沒有法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/550.wav", + "text": "都有法定的競選期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/551.wav", + "text": "但那是相同的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/552.wav", + "text": "要去選舉一定有一些競選活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/553.wav", + "text": "活動期間你會去造勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/554.wav", + "text": "會去做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/555.wav", + "text": "我是覺得這個合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/556.wav", + "text": "各黨團當然都可以代表每一個黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/557.wav", + "text": "可是你去看區域立委裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/558.wav", + "text": "你跟他說到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/559.wav", + "text": "還要來開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/560.wav", + "text": "不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/561.wav", + "text": "我也不會去講說這叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/562.wav", + "text": "自欺欺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/563.wav", + "text": "以前都有停會這樣的一個慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/564.wav", + "text": "我也不會去說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/565.wav", + "text": "那個是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/566.wav", + "text": "大家當然可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/567.wav", + "text": "將近兩三個禮拜的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/568.wav", + "text": "大家專心去選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/569.wav", + "text": "去選舉其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/570.wav", + "text": "民主政治的一個常態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/571.wav", + "text": "就是為了贏得選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/572.wav", + "text": "繼續留在國會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/573.wav", + "text": "為你的支持者為你政黨的支持者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/574.wav", + "text": "繼續把你的政黨的理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/575.wav", + "text": "去發揚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/576.wav", + "text": "或者說有志於去服務選民的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/577.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/578.wav", + "text": "\n所以我也覺得不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/579.wav", + "text": "拿這個互相去攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/580.wav", + "text": "你說你的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/581.wav", + "text": "也許是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/582.wav", + "text": "別人講的跟你不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/583.wav", + "text": "也沒有什麼不妥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/584.wav", + "text": "選舉本來就是要時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/585.wav", + "text": "哪有選舉不用時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/586.wav", + "text": "每個委員會都有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/587.wav", + "text": "考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/588.wav", + "text": "甚至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/589.wav", + "text": "有的去考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/590.wav", + "text": "常常也都是被拜託的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/591.wav", + "text": "都是誰在拜託區域的立委在拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/592.wav", + "text": "啊各黨都會碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/593.wav", + "text": "倒也不用因為這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/594.wav", + "text": "覺得它是非常特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/595.wav", + "text": "像考察也是在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/596.wav", + "text": "整個職權行使裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/597.wav", + "text": "正當的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/598.wav", + "text": "確實該去考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/599.wav", + "text": "啊很多地方你不去考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/600.wav", + "text": "你根本就不知道我們整個預算編下去以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/601.wav", + "text": "執行的狀況是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/602.wav", + "text": "\n我反而倒覺得時間比較不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/603.wav", + "text": "以後不考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/604.wav", + "text": "那才奇怪\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/605.wav", + "text": "我倒是比較贊成像過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/606.wav", + "text": "每一屆碰到要選舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/607.wav", + "text": "都會有一段期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/608.wav", + "text": "讓選區域立委的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/609.wav", + "text": "讓他好好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/610.wav", + "text": "他去拼戰其實是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/611.wav", + "text": "幫他的政黨或幫他自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/612.wav", + "text": "打贏這個選戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/613.wav", + "text": "然後重新回來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/614.wav", + "text": "其實都是為這個國家或者說為他的選民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/615.wav", + "text": "為他的政黨去爭取民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/616.wav", + "text": "我倒認為這無可厚非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/617.wav", + "text": "所以是不是也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/618.wav", + "text": "都有很多區域的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/619.wav", + "text": "比較專心的在這兩三個禮拜的期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/620.wav", + "text": "社會上也不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/621.wav", + "text": "覺得有的人在那邊開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/622.wav", + "text": "我覺得是比較人性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/623.wav", + "text": "他因為有職務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/624.wav", + "text": "當市長的人他必須要請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/625.wav", + "text": "除非你認為說立法委員也要請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/626.wav", + "text": "是用請假的方式嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/627.wav", + "text": "我看如果各黨大家做一個決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/628.wav", + "text": "前面有一個慣例在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/629.wav", + "text": "那我覺得可以做一個考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/630.wav", + "text": "啦以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/631.wav", + "text": "謝謝莊委員接下來邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/632.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/633.wav", + "text": "立法院本來就是共識決不同民意的匯集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/634.wav", + "text": "各黨都有主張原則上我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/635.wav", + "text": "但是我們還是要表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/636.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/637.wav", + "text": "第一個我們反對停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/638.wav", + "text": "然柯總召說建立政治文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/639.wav", + "text": "不是只有多開幾天會這我也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/640.wav", + "text": "但這是一個態度的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/641.wav", + "text": "其實我們第10屆國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/642.wav", + "text": "在游錫堃院長的領導之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/643.wav", + "text": "不管是18歲公民權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/644.wav", + "text": "修憲委員會的成立國會遷建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/645.wav", + "text": "甚至是成立國際事務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/646.wav", + "text": "走一個新的路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/647.wav", + "text": "所以我們沒有去攻擊各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/648.wav", + "text": "我們是公開呼籲我希望全體國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/649.wav", + "text": "也來看看各政黨在立法院的表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/650.wav", + "text": "你到底在國會的表現怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/651.wav", + "text": "也會影響你的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/652.wav", + "text": "\n第二個在總預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/653.wav", + "text": "我也贊成柯總召的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/654.wav", + "text": "我們認為還是要在法定會期內審完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/655.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗總召談到NCC監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/656.wav", + "text": "甚至是數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/657.wav", + "text": "國人確實沒有辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/658.wav", + "text": "我這邊也具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/659.wav", + "text": "我們再來看看執政黨會不會護航" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/660.wav", + "text": "給選民的判斷及抉擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/661.wav", + "text": "還是希望在維持財政紀律的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/662.wav", + "text": "原則上我們也是認為總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/663.wav", + "text": "可以在法定會期內審完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/664.wav", + "text": "不需要再加開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/665.wav", + "text": "可以好好協商哪一些優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/666.wav", + "text": "\n另一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/667.wav", + "text": "委員會的預算審查進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/668.wav", + "text": "民眾黨原則上也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/669.wav", + "text": "要先審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/670.wav", + "text": "因為現在的召委是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/671.wav", + "text": "我們民眾黨的吳欣盈委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/672.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們也願意跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/673.wav", + "text": "在相關的預算或法案審查上的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/674.wav", + "text": "國會立法委員的本質是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/675.wav", + "text": "監督預算審查預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/676.wav", + "text": "我們贊成總預算在法定會期內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/677.wav", + "text": "至於細節優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/678.wav", + "text": "還有必須要在委員會審查的相關預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/679.wav", + "text": "為第10屆國會建立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/680.wav", + "text": "大家很喜歡講之前的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/681.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/682.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得也沒有一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/683.wav", + "text": "其他政黨的意思但是我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/684.wav", + "text": "這個是一個好的時機第10屆的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/685.wav", + "text": "我們可以走出不一樣的道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/686.wav", + "text": "謝謝邱總召接下來請陳總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/687.wav", + "text": "就是我們這三位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/688.wav", + "text": "位從第一會期到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/689.wav", + "text": "預算都會拖到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/690.wav", + "text": "比較特別因為1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/691.wav", + "text": "1月要選舉所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/692.wav", + "text": "12月底我們希望除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/693.wav", + "text": "也能夠趕快排審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/694.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的幾個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/695.wav", + "text": "案如揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/696.wav", + "text": "囤房稅2.0以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/697.wav", + "text": "還有我們希望交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/698.wav", + "text": "這個會期完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/699.wav", + "text": "會期結束前能夠修法完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/700.wav", + "text": "或立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/701.wav", + "text": "第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/702.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/703.wav", + "text": "交通委員會其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/704.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/705.wav", + "text": "陳委員也跟我拜託好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/706.wav", + "text": "的兩位召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/707.wav", + "text": "需要有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/708.wav", + "text": "是執政黨一個是在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/709.wav", + "text": "對我來講還有對時力黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/710.wav", + "text": "來講這個都非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/711.wav", + "text": "陳委員能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/712.wav", + "text": "擔任召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/713.wav", + "text": "現勘其實兩位召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/714.wav", + "text": "都排了滿多現勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/715.wav", + "text": "勘誠如剛剛莊委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/716.wav", + "text": "的現勘也是很重要的問政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/717.wav", + "text": "我也不是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/718.wav", + "text": "只是我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/719.wav", + "text": "的安排之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/720.wav", + "text": "在12月底前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/721.wav", + "text": "修法的部分因為昨天才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/722.wav", + "text": "道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/723.wav", + "text": "你突然今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/724.wav", + "text": "就要休會大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/725.wav", + "text": "大家除了重視預算審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/726.wav", + "text": "法案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/727.wav", + "text": "修法立法也是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/728.wav", + "text": "如果到12月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/729.wav", + "text": "才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/730.wav", + "text": "休會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/731.wav", + "text": "這些重要的法案是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/732.wav", + "text": "有機會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/733.wav", + "text": "完竣所以我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/734.wav", + "text": "當然也是希望我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/735.wav", + "text": "在野黨能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/736.wav", + "text": "還有執政黨能夠支持讓這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/737.wav", + "text": "法案能夠儘快審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/738.wav", + "text": "然後來審查完竣三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/739.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/740.wav", + "text": "柯總召提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/741.wav", + "text": "沒有特別要攻擊執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/742.wav", + "text": "我們就是認為這個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/743.wav", + "text": "那人民在看嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/744.wav", + "text": "我也沒有天天在講說要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/745.wav", + "text": "修揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/746.wav", + "text": "柯總召可以舉證一下我哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/747.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/748.wav", + "text": "啦沒有每天在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/749.wav", + "text": "啦所以你剛剛講了很多我也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/750.wav", + "text": "不反駁因為我也是很尊敬你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/751.wav", + "text": "立院這麼多屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/752.wav", + "text": "是非常資深然後大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/753.wav", + "text": "尊敬的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/754.wav", + "text": "誤會就請能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/755.wav", + "text": "人民期待我們要趕快修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/756.wav", + "text": "完成這個真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/757.wav", + "text": "很重要我先說明到這裡謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/758.wav", + "text": "謝衣鳯委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/759.wav", + "text": "再來請曾銘宗委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/760.wav", + "text": "再來洪申翰委員再來劉世芳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/761.wav", + "text": "各黨團的幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/762.wav", + "text": "其實我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/763.wav", + "text": "今天民進黨召開這個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/764.wav", + "text": "很好的啦就如同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/765.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/766.wav", + "text": "所質疑的他可能覺得還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/767.wav", + "text": "還有很多的預算沒有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/768.wav", + "text": "啦其實現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/769.wav", + "text": "11月7號我們訂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/770.wav", + "text": "時間是12" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/771.wav", + "text": "如果今天我們各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/772.wav", + "text": "預算審理的議程都排一排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/773.wav", + "text": "這一屆都已經到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/774.wav", + "text": "最成熟的時候都快要畢業了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/775.wav", + "text": "相處都了解彼此的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/776.wav", + "text": "個性所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/777.wav", + "text": "12月底之前提前幾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/778.wav", + "text": "天完成我認為以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/779.wav", + "text": "運作的程序我相信各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/780.wav", + "text": "這樣子效率的增速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/781.wav", + "text": "所以也不要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/782.wav", + "text": "是為了選舉我覺得大家就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/783.wav", + "text": "把這個部分先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/784.wav", + "text": "完成一樣畢竟在選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/785.wav", + "text": "不同的政黨以及不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/786.wav", + "text": "候選人之間的確有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/787.wav", + "text": "到政府的運作也不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/788.wav", + "text": "國家的前進\n當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/789.wav", + "text": "也不是說休會期間大家就在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/790.wav", + "text": "休息其實每一個人每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/791.wav", + "text": "立法委員即便在選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/792.wav", + "text": "當中還是在選區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/793.wav", + "text": "就是兩套標準你平常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/794.wav", + "text": "雪生委員的時候你都對他很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/795.wav", + "text": "怎麼在這裡修理說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/796.wav", + "text": "國民黨的陳雪生都不審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/797.wav", + "text": "陳雪生委員也是很資深的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/798.wav", + "text": "委員當我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/799.wav", + "text": "協商好了以後我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/800.wav", + "text": "大家都可以按照程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/801.wav", + "text": "共同來進行那當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/802.wav", + "text": "對於各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/803.wav", + "text": "我覺得也可以提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/804.wav", + "text": "最主要我們就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/805.wav", + "text": "政府的預算是不是就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/806.wav", + "text": "我們所主張的就是這幾個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/807.wav", + "text": "當然如果有疑義的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/808.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法審理完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/809.wav", + "text": "我覺得留下來留幾個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/810.wav", + "text": "我覺得這在選後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/811.wav", + "text": "然後在這一屆結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/812.wav", + "text": "之前我認為以大家的效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/813.wav", + "text": "還是有辦法完成的以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/814.wav", + "text": "好謝謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/815.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/816.wav", + "text": "我有三點說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/817.wav", + "text": "第一點有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/818.wav", + "text": "有一些優先法案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/819.wav", + "text": "三讀國民黨團有幾個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/820.wav", + "text": "也希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/821.wav", + "text": "儘快完成三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/822.wav", + "text": "第一個就是房屋稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/823.wav", + "text": "所謂囤房稅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/824.wav", + "text": "我是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/825.wav", + "text": "執政黨不要打假球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/826.wav", + "text": "這是第一點第二點有關公司法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/827.wav", + "text": "中小企業發展條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/828.wav", + "text": "還有證券交易法有關改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/829.wav", + "text": "低薪的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/830.wav", + "text": "國民黨團列為優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/831.wav", + "text": "希望能夠儘速討論通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/832.wav", + "text": "這是第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/833.wav", + "text": "柯總召提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/834.wav", + "text": "預算法第52條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/835.wav", + "text": "我跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/836.wav", + "text": "預算法第52條我幾乎會背" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/837.wav", + "text": "我舉個例來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/838.wav", + "text": "他說是不是不要留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/839.wav", + "text": "但是依照預算法第52條提附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/840.wav", + "text": "或者主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/841.wav", + "text": "審112年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/842.wav", + "text": "預算的時候就在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/843.wav", + "text": "我提的主決議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/844.wav", + "text": "現在民營化的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/845.wav", + "text": "民營化的銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/846.wav", + "text": "每胎生育補助10萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/847.wav", + "text": "當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/848.wav", + "text": "柯總召同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/849.wav", + "text": "各部會也都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/850.wav", + "text": "輸銀跟菸酒公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/851.wav", + "text": "通過到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/852.wav", + "text": "到現在行政院也不做啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/853.wav", + "text": "所以不用審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/854.wav", + "text": "了就算通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/855.wav", + "text": "也不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/856.wav", + "text": "所以說要回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/857.wav", + "text": "預算法第52條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/858.wav", + "text": "不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/859.wav", + "text": "去年才通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/860.wav", + "text": "的也沒有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/861.wav", + "text": "當時大家都沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/862.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/863.wav", + "text": "我們本來是希望NCC監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/864.wav", + "text": "跟數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/865.wav", + "text": "有關監察院的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/866.wav", + "text": "院際之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/867.wav", + "text": "明天會請監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/868.wav", + "text": "來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/869.wav", + "text": "我們會好好質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/870.wav", + "text": "院際之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/871.wav", + "text": "我們就尊重柯總召的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/872.wav", + "text": "監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/873.wav", + "text": "我們就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/874.wav", + "text": "不留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/875.wav", + "text": "我也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/876.wav", + "text": "但是國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/877.wav", + "text": "還是希望要留NCC跟數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/878.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/879.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請洪申翰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/880.wav", + "text": "進到第8會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/881.wav", + "text": "絕大多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/882.wav", + "text": "都是不分區的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/883.wav", + "text": "這不是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/884.wav", + "text": "沒有理由的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/885.wav", + "text": "也不是一件不合理的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/886.wav", + "text": "在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/887.wav", + "text": "所以我特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/888.wav", + "text": "除了謝衣鳯委員以外都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/889.wav", + "text": "原因是什麼這不是不合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/890.wav", + "text": "有三分之二以上的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/891.wav", + "text": "是區域委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/892.wav", + "text": "如果今天坐在這邊絕大多數都是區域委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/893.wav", + "text": "我想討論的內容跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/894.wav", + "text": "這些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/895.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得不是不分區委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/896.wav", + "text": "就特別高尚說區域委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/897.wav", + "text": "並爭取支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/898.wav", + "text": "就是失職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/899.wav", + "text": "我實在是聽不懂為什麼選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/900.wav", + "text": "的這件事情叫做立法委員失職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/901.wav", + "text": "我真的聽不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/902.wav", + "text": "我們有三分之二的委員都是區域委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/903.wav", + "text": "都要向選民爭取支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/904.wav", + "text": "這為什麼是失職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/905.wav", + "text": "這為什麼是怠惰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/906.wav", + "text": "柯P競選連任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/907.wav", + "text": "他也是請假一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/908.wav", + "text": "啊難道當時柯P請假一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/909.wav", + "text": "這是不好的政治文化嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/910.wav", + "text": "也沒有人這樣批評他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/911.wav", + "text": "我們沒有批評喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/912.wav", + "text": "我沒有攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/913.wav", + "text": "我是說當時也沒有人批評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/914.wav", + "text": "不可以重新建立嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/915.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在討論什麼是合理的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/916.wav", + "text": "當時的這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/917.wav", + "text": "大家也沒有批評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/918.wav", + "text": "好好爭取選民的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/919.wav", + "text": "我不覺得這個選舉就是多麼不正當的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/920.wav", + "text": "或者是怠惰這是第一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/921.wav", + "text": "\n第二件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/922.wav", + "text": "並不是為了選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/923.wav", + "text": "或是預算留到之後再審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/924.wav", + "text": "預算事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/925.wav", + "text": "各委員會現在的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/926.wav", + "text": "由民進黨擔任召委的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/927.wav", + "text": "會所排審的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/928.wav", + "text": "我認為普遍看起來還是比較積極的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/929.wav", + "text": "所以並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/930.wav", + "text": "為了兩三個禮拜的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/931.wav", + "text": "大家就不要審預算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/932.wav", + "text": "大家就把該做的事情放下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/933.wav", + "text": "並沒有這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/934.wav", + "text": "攻擊成該做的事情不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/935.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是不成理由的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/936.wav", + "text": "最後我想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/937.wav", + "text": "在合理的時間回到選區裡爭取選民支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/938.wav", + "text": "這怎麼能說是怠惰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/939.wav", + "text": "我實在是想不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/940.wav", + "text": "難道今天大家不用透過選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/941.wav", + "text": "就可以到這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/942.wav", + "text": "來擔任民意代表嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/943.wav", + "text": "這不符合民主的原則吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/944.wav", + "text": "是不是又會被說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/945.wav", + "text": "你又會說怠惰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/946.wav", + "text": "所以回到選區爭取選民支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/947.wav", + "text": "為什麼是怠惰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/948.wav", + "text": "這是最根本的認知問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/949.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/950.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/951.wav", + "text": "我想剛剛我們都有同意一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/952.wav", + "text": "就是立法院其實是合議制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/953.wav", + "text": "可以完成交辦的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/954.wav", + "text": "我們也都知道這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/955.wav", + "text": "是屬於預算會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/956.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團所提的意見就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/957.wav", + "text": "預算我們要審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/958.wav", + "text": "但是我們希望可以加速審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/959.wav", + "text": "空出來一點時間的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/960.wav", + "text": "可不可以按照以往在選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/961.wav", + "text": "跟立委選舉的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/962.wav", + "text": "讓大家可以休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/963.wav", + "text": "也就是院會跟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/964.wav", + "text": "可以稍微休息一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/965.wav", + "text": "但是應該排審的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/966.wav", + "text": "及應該排審的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/967.wav", + "text": "\n我現在看8個委員會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/968.wav", + "text": "以民進黨團跟國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/969.wav", + "text": "居多有一位是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/970.wav", + "text": "民眾黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/971.wav", + "text": "現在在內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/972.wav", + "text": "游毓蘭委員的原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/973.wav", + "text": "就是僑務委員會那是廖婉汝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/974.wav", + "text": "但是我相信我們在一定的時間內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/975.wav", + "text": "那財政的部分只剩下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/976.wav", + "text": "費鴻泰委員的稅務署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/977.wav", + "text": "教育文化委員會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/978.wav", + "text": "鄭麗文的核安會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/979.wav", + "text": "何欣純跟陳雪生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/980.wav", + "text": "他們接著下來就是要排審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/981.wav", + "text": "不要忘記何欣純跟陳雪生兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/982.wav", + "text": "都是區域委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/983.wav", + "text": "再來司法及法制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/984.wav", + "text": "總召所提的監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/985.wav", + "text": "那是林思銘委員在排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/986.wav", + "text": "現在還沒有處理完竣的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/987.wav", + "text": "衛福部主管那是吳欣盈委員在排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/988.wav", + "text": "其實我們要非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/989.wav", + "text": "不管是代表政黨的不分區立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/990.wav", + "text": "或是區域委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/991.wav", + "text": "我要跟大家講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/992.wav", + "text": "我們身為民進黨黨團的幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/993.wav", + "text": "其實是比較痛苦一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/994.wav", + "text": "你知道為什麼嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/995.wav", + "text": "每次院會要不要成案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/996.wav", + "text": "所以我們都是要從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/997.wav", + "text": "我們的區域委員調他們來甲動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/998.wav", + "text": "要簽甲動才可以成會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/999.wav", + "text": "\n同樣的道理每一次委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1000.wav", + "text": "我們如果知道要審預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1001.wav", + "text": "或是審重大法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1002.wav", + "text": "我們委員會幾乎都是以甲動的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1003.wav", + "text": "把所有的區域委員都要調上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1004.wav", + "text": "當然這是我們自己民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1005.wav", + "text": "站在執政黨的立場上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1006.wav", + "text": "一定要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1007.wav", + "text": "因為我們必須要對選民有所交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1008.wav", + "text": "更何況我們在審法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1009.wav", + "text": "或在審預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1010.wav", + "text": "都是有透過國會的對外頻道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1011.wav", + "text": "或是媒體在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1012.wav", + "text": "所以事實上我們從來沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1013.wav", + "text": "很多委員是怠惰都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1014.wav", + "text": "或是不分區委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1015.wav", + "text": "\n但是我們知道選舉確實是非常累人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1016.wav", + "text": "大家都有選舉過的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1017.wav", + "text": "其實真的很累" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1018.wav", + "text": "我們很多區域委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1019.wav", + "text": "來匆匆忙忙選完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1020.wav", + "text": "我想大家都知道民進黨在中南部的委員很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1021.wav", + "text": "很多人像我這樣三更半夜要上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1022.wav", + "text": "或是一大早要搭第一班車的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1023.wav", + "text": "大家都知道全部都是中南部的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1024.wav", + "text": "都變成是立委的專門列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1025.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1026.wav", + "text": "就是要來審法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1027.wav", + "text": "有時候到這邊只是為了一個舉手表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1028.wav", + "text": "而已我們都知道委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1029.wav", + "text": "有他自己選民的交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1030.wav", + "text": "也對政黨要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1031.wav", + "text": "所以我們在外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1032.wav", + "text": "有這樣的審查過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1033.wav", + "text": "我們只是提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1034.wav", + "text": "可不可以加速審查完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1035.wav", + "text": "但是我們沒有要降低審查的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1036.wav", + "text": "包括預算本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1037.wav", + "text": "或是包括法案本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1038.wav", + "text": "因此柯總召所提的才會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1039.wav", + "text": "可不可以3天一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1040.wav", + "text": "剛剛陳椒華委員也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1041.wav", + "text": "其實道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1042.wav", + "text": "也是在非常有共識的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1043.wav", + "text": "昨天已經完成在交通委員會的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1044.wav", + "text": "也是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1045.wav", + "text": "大家覺得這個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1046.wav", + "text": "所以先把預算審查排在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1047.wav", + "text": "先把這個交通法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1048.wav", + "text": "趕快放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1049.wav", + "text": "體察民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1050.wav", + "text": "但是請各位能夠瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1051.wav", + "text": "這樣子的時間裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1052.wav", + "text": "讓它縮短時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1053.wav", + "text": "只有委員會跟院會的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1054.wav", + "text": "縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1055.wav", + "text": "或者是要審查到三更半夜都沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1056.wav", + "text": "比如說我們國防委員會就審查到三更半夜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1057.wav", + "text": "啊用這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1058.wav", + "text": "讓它趕快通過應該通過的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1059.wav", + "text": "我覺得並沒有不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1060.wav", + "text": "都來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1061.wav", + "text": "才算是對選民有所交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1062.wav", + "text": "而是選民會知道你審查的量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1063.wav", + "text": "跟審查的質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1064.wav", + "text": "是不是符合大眾的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1065.wav", + "text": "我想用這樣的方式跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1066.wav", + "text": "可以進入我們今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1067.wav", + "text": "讓區域委員在選舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1068.wav", + "text": "可以有多一點的彈性時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1069.wav", + "text": "面對選民並且來處理更好的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1070.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1071.wav", + "text": "立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1072.wav", + "text": "提前停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1073.wav", + "text": "已經是一個憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1074.wav", + "text": "也不存在所謂誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1075.wav", + "text": "認不認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1076.wav", + "text": "這四年老百" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1077.wav", + "text": "是有不同樓頂沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1078.wav", + "text": "是最資深的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1079.wav", + "text": "我選過六次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1080.wav", + "text": "我們還是回到理性的一面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1081.wav", + "text": "該通過的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1082.wav", + "text": "我們絕對會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1083.wav", + "text": "包括剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1084.wav", + "text": "基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1085.wav", + "text": "這都會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1086.wav", + "text": "該通過的法案大家不要擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1087.wav", + "text": "每一黨都會負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1088.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1089.wav", + "text": "選舉前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1090.wav", + "text": "也可以考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1091.wav", + "text": "又排專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1092.wav", + "text": "趕快把預算審完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1093.wav", + "text": "還是可以考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1094.wav", + "text": "立法委員的職責就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1095.wav", + "text": "審預算審法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1096.wav", + "text": "大家都琅琅上口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1097.wav", + "text": "我們應該有效率地來完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1098.wav", + "text": "還是要拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1099.wav", + "text": "既然兩大黨都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1100.wav", + "text": "希望民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1101.wav", + "text": "也能夠體恤大家的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1102.wav", + "text": "而且大家都在立法院這麼久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1103.wav", + "text": "也瞭解這個情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1104.wav", + "text": "應該是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1105.wav", + "text": "好好審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1106.wav", + "text": "但是剩下NCC和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1107.wav", + "text": "數發部的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1108.wav", + "text": "主計長沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1109.wav", + "text": "算出刪減數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1110.wav", + "text": "到底發生什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1111.wav", + "text": "找你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1112.wav", + "text": "總預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1113.wav", + "text": "預算一定要全部上去啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1114.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1115.wav", + "text": "大家回去想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1116.wav", + "text": "大家回去想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1117.wav", + "text": "總預算要過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1118.wav", + "text": "重要的法案也是要過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1119.wav", + "text": "有效率要集中一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1120.wav", + "text": "院長我還是要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1121.wav", + "text": "現在很重要的是我們剛剛提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1122.wav", + "text": "要負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1123.wav", + "text": "這個部分不是宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1124.wav", + "text": "宣告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1125.wav", + "text": "你聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1126.wav", + "text": "你聽一下宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1127.wav", + "text": "告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1128.wav", + "text": "一今天各黨團對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1129.wav", + "text": "停會的意見不一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1130.wav", + "text": "請各黨團繼續進行溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1131.wav", + "text": "後續就依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1132.wav", + "text": "議事規範來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1133.wav", + "text": "處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1134.wav", + "text": "二跟大家補充報告為配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1135.wav", + "text": "政府組改完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1136.wav", + "text": "法制局已經針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1137.wav", + "text": "本院程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1138.wav", + "text": "組織規程及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1139.wav", + "text": "中央政府總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1140.wav", + "text": "審查程序相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1141.wav", + "text": "條文已單純就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1142.wav", + "text": "組改後各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1143.wav", + "text": "機關名稱的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1144.wav", + "text": "研擬出修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1145.wav", + "text": "草案在法制局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1146.wav", + "text": "網站上提供給各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1147.wav", + "text": "及委員參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1148.wav", + "text": "後續就請各黨團提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1149.wav", + "text": "或共同提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1150.wav", + "text": "再來進行議事程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1151.wav", + "text": "另外有關本院擴建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1152.wav", + "text": "事宜本週四下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1153.wav", + "text": "召開公聽會歡迎各" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1154.wav", + "text": "黨團委員來聽取學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1155.wav", + "text": "專家的看法並發表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1156.wav", + "text": "高見此外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1157.wav", + "text": "預定下週四(11月16日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1158.wav", + "text": ")下午要召開審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1159.wav", + "text": "會來處理提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1160.wav", + "text": "相關審查結果我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1161.wav", + "text": "也會送黨團協商處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1162.wav", + "text": "沒有意見現在我們就告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1163.wav", + "text": "增加的三個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1164.wav", + "text": "啦積極一點是可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1165.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15247/1166.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/0.wav", + "text": "現在開始協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/1.wav", + "text": "\n本日協商關於典試法第31條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/2.wav", + "text": "公務人員考試法第2條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/3.wav", + "text": "專門職業及技術人員考試法第十七條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/4.wav", + "text": "及中華民國刑法第103十七條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/5.wav", + "text": "共4個主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/6.wav", + "text": "稍後按照協商通知順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/7.wav", + "text": "依序進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/8.wav", + "text": "\n協商進行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/9.wav", + "text": "首先先介紹我們到場的曾銘宗總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/10.wav", + "text": "以及湯蕙禎召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/11.wav", + "text": "還有考試院的劉建忻秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/12.wav", + "text": "以及考選部的許舒翔部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/13.wav", + "text": "\n現��逐案進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/14.wav", + "text": "協商時請參照協商條文對照表與審查報告及逕付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/15.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀提案關係文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/16.wav", + "text": "\n與會委員如果有修正動議或機關有建議內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/17.wav", + "text": "請提出書面印發現場進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/18.wav", + "text": "\n現在進行第一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/19.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會併案審查考試院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/20.wav", + "text": "典試法第31條條文修正草案等5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/21.wav", + "text": "本案審查會前於今年的5月3日審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/22.wav", + "text": "審查結果第31條保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/23.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/24.wav", + "text": "另院會將委員傅崐萁等19人提案逕付二讀與相關提案併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/25.wav", + "text": "現在先請與會的機關代表針對保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/26.wav", + "text": "提出說明並與與會的出席委員討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/27.wav", + "text": "\n第31條請考選部許部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/28.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/29.wav", + "text": "有關典試法第31條的修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/30.wav", + "text": "之前在審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/31.wav", + "text": "基本上都贊成我們增訂求償權這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/32.wav", + "text": "沒有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/33.wav", + "text": "另外就是是不是要加重其刑至二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/34.wav", + "text": "有委員認為這一項可能會有雙重加重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/35.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們同意刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/36.wav", + "text": "最後的版本就是我們今天這個書面文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/37.wav", + "text": "這個表列的協商建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/38.wav", + "text": "好那我們就是把並加重其刑至二分之一的部分刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/39.wav", + "text": "我們就按照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/40.wav", + "text": "請問本會委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/41.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/42.wav", + "text": "一下求償權的範圍是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/43.wav", + "text": "就是他如果影響到需要重新舉辦考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/44.wav", + "text": "那所有重新舉辦考試的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/45.wav", + "text": "必須由他來賠償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/46.wav", + "text": "就是說這個人是作弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/47.wav", + "text": "當然就是他應該要去負責這樣的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/48.wav", + "text": "比如說他是洩題的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/49.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/50.wav", + "text": "贊成但是求償權的範圍要不要寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/51.wav", + "text": "你要說因為他衍生的相關費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/52.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/53.wav", + "text": "對他有求償權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/54.wav", + "text": "要不要訂定清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/55.wav", + "text": "就是前面這個他違反第1項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/56.wav", + "text": "就是前面這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/57.wav", + "text": "他如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/58.wav", + "text": "OK好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/59.wav", + "text": "那我們時力的邱總召你還有意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/60.wav", + "text": "我們的秘書長部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/61.wav", + "text": "因為考試的公平與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/62.wav", + "text": "就像之前也有跟秘書長跟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/63.wav", + "text": "討論過非常多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/64.wav", + "text": "這個影響一個人的一生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/65.wav", + "text": "尤其是國家考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/66.wav", + "text": "你讓本來應該上的人沒有上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/67.wav", + "text": "然後本來不應該上的人卻考上了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/68.wav", + "text": "我們這個國家絕對不能夠讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/69.wav", + "text": "力爭上游成為絕響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/70.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/71.wav", + "text": "今天如果沒有一個公平的考試的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/72.wav", + "text": "我們也沒辦法坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/73.wav", + "text": "\n就這個部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/74.wav", + "text": "現在臺灣會查獲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/75.wav", + "text": "國營事業考試舞弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/76.wav", + "text": "當然國家考試比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/77.wav", + "text": "但是國營事業舞弊的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/78.wav", + "text": "還是層出不窮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/79.wav", + "text": "國營事業不是政府機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/80.wav", + "text": "但是公務員在提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/81.wav", + "text": "社會必要的公共服務上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/82.wav", + "text": "也有高度的相似性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/83.wav", + "text": "他手上也有很多的公共資源等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/84.wav", + "text": "相較來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/85.wav", + "text": "現行法對國營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/86.wav", + "text": "刑法的妨害考試公平罪的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/87.wav", + "text": "長期以來怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/88.wav", + "text": "檢察系統通常都是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/89.wav", + "text": "起訴國營事業考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/90.wav", + "text": "舞弊這個次長非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/91.wav", + "text": "實務上對於這樣的情形是否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/92.wav", + "text": "構成詐欺得利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/93.wav", + "text": "這難說哦有時候你詐欺得利起訴之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/94.wav", + "text": "法院也有可能判無罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/95.wav", + "text": "有一些檢察官甚至以不起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/96.wav", + "text": "\n所以時力黨團的刑法修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/97.wav", + "text": "有兩個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/98.wav", + "text": "一個就是國營事業考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/99.wav", + "text": "應該要納入妨害考試罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/100.wav", + "text": "第二個就是區別這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/101.wav", + "text": "作弊集團跟考生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/102.wav", + "text": "大多數的理由是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/103.wav", + "text": "要賺一些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/104.wav", + "text": "那講白了就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/105.wav", + "text": "為了考上拿到一個穩定的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/106.wav", + "text": "他們再犯的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/107.wav", + "text": "其實是不高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/108.wav", + "text": "是為了要謀職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/109.wav", + "text": "為了要賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/110.wav", + "text": "為了要有一個穩定的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/111.wav", + "text": "所以從刑事政策的角度來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/112.wav", + "text": "處罰考生的必要性其實不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/113.wav", + "text": "可能會造成反效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/114.wav", + "text": "畢竟這些人就是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/115.wav", + "text": "沒有好的經濟條件才選擇作弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/116.wav", + "text": "刑事處罰反而可能會惡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/117.wav", + "text": "他們的經濟處境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/118.wav", + "text": "比如說他更難找工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/119.wav", + "text": "導致未來更多犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/120.wav", + "text": "所以第1項的法律效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/121.wav", + "text": "應該要區別作弊集團和考生來處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/122.wav", + "text": "針對作弊集團應該要加重處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/123.wav", + "text": "這是我們第2項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/124.wav", + "text": "不過因為之前秘書長跟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/125.wav", + "text": "就是這一次的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/126.wav", + "text": "應該要針對像是出題老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/127.wav", + "text": "洩題給學生的作弊行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/128.wav", + "text": "來加重處罰作為嚇阻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/129.wav", + "text": "阻我之前也質詢過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/130.wav", + "text": "這當然是不應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/131.wav", + "text": "這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/132.wav", + "text": "第1項規定不應該減輕刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/133.wav", + "text": "反而應該加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/134.wav", + "text": "考試院的主張是有道理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/135.wav", + "text": "如果不涉及作弊集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/136.wav", + "text": "還是要依第1項的規定來論罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/137.wav", + "text": "減輕的刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/138.wav", + "text": "可能沒辦法達到修法的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/139.wav", + "text": "然後你提高刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/140.wav", + "text": "我們也在個案量刑中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/141.wav", + "text": "去適度地區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/142.wav", + "text": "應該要重罰的作弊行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/143.wav", + "text": "跟比較不適合重罰的考生作弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/144.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們今天也尊重大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/145.wav", + "text": "希望能夠透過這次的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/146.wav", + "text": "讓我們的考生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/147.wav", + "text": "在這麼競爭激烈的考試裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/148.wav", + "text": "尤其是國家考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/149.wav", + "text": "能夠更公平地在條件上面去競爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/150.wav", + "text": "也幫國家跟國營事業的選才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/151.wav", + "text": "然後促進公共利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/152.wav", + "text": "可以流動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/153.wav", + "text": "讓力爭上游不至成為絕響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/154.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/155.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/156.wav", + "text": "那現在是不是我們第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/157.wav", + "text": "就按照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/158.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/159.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/160.wav", + "text": "好我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/161.wav", + "text": "接著進行第二案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/162.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會併案審查考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/163.wav", + "text": "函請審議公務人員考試法第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/164.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案等5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/165.wav", + "text": "本案審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/166.wav", + "text": "前於今年5月3日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/167.wav", + "text": "審查完竣審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/168.wav", + "text": "第2條保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/169.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/170.wav", + "text": "須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/171.wav", + "text": "現在先請與會機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/172.wav", + "text": "針對保留條文提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/173.wav", + "text": "並請出席委員討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/174.wav", + "text": "請問本會委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/175.wav", + "text": "湯蕙禎委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/176.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/177.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/178.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就按照考試院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/179.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/180.wav", + "text": "按照考試院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/181.wav", + "text": "現在進行第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/182.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/183.wav", + "text": "併案審查考試院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/184.wav", + "text": "專門職業及技術人員考試法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/185.wav", + "text": "第十七條條文修正草案等6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/186.wav", + "text": "本案審查會前於今年5月3日審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/187.wav", + "text": "審查結果第十七條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/188.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/189.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/190.wav", + "text": "須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/191.wav", + "text": "現在先請與會的機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/192.wav", + "text": "提出說明並請出席委員討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/193.wav", + "text": "現在我們先進行第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/194.wav", + "text": "請問本會委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/195.wav", + "text": "曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/196.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/197.wav", + "text": "這是專門職業及技術人員考試法第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/198.wav", + "text": "增訂像第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/199.wav", + "text": "的規定還是只有針對專門職業及技術人員考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/200.wav", + "text": "公務人員考試法剛才那一條有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/201.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/202.wav", + "text": "OK所以那一條本來就沒意見嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/203.wav", + "text": "內容完全一樣對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/204.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/205.wav", + "text": "OK沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/206.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/207.wav", + "text": "謝謝我們現在第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/208.wav", + "text": "是不是就按照考試院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/209.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/210.wav", + "text": "\n現在進行第四案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/211.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/212.wav", + "text": "併案審查委員張廖萬堅等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/213.wav", + "text": "委員費鴻泰等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/214.wav", + "text": "委員黃世杰等21人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/215.wav", + "text": "委員楊曜等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/216.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團及湯蕙禎委員等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/217.wav", + "text": "分別擬具中華民國刑法第103條條文修正草案等6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/218.wav", + "text": "本案審查會前於今年的5月3日審查完竣審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/219.wav", + "text": "第103條及湯蕙禎委員等3人所提修正動議均保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/220.wav", + "text": "送院會處理並決議院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/221.wav", + "text": "現在先請與會的機關代表針對保留條文提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/222.wav", + "text": "並請出席委員討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/223.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/224.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/225.wav", + "text": "第103條建議採湯蕙禎委員等3人所提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/226.wav", + "text": "考試法在75年1月10號已經廢止對於本條的考試範圍應配合修正以合時宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/227.wav", + "text": "時宜現行第1項刑度過輕有提高刑度的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/228.wav", + "text": "並配合刑罰罰金級距體例一併調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/229.wav", + "text": "對於意圖營利而妨害考試之行為有加重處罰的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/230.wav", + "text": "以符相當性原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/231.wav", + "text": "\n妨害考試範圍不宜納入國營事業理由如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/232.wav", + "text": "第一個本條保護法益是維護國家考試權的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/233.wav", + "text": "國營事業人員考試並非公權力行使範疇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/234.wav", + "text": "第二個國營事業舞弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/235.wav", + "text": "依其行為態樣現行法律已有相關處罰規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/236.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/237.wav", + "text": "好請問我們與會委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/238.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/239.wav", + "text": "剛剛次長有提到國營事業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/240.wav", + "text": "我們的版本跟其他有一些委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/241.wav", + "text": "國營事業這個部分納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/242.wav", + "text": "主要的原因是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/243.wav", + "text": "問題是這個實務上的見解不一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/244.wav", + "text": "啦到底可不可以用詐欺得利罪去起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/245.wav", + "text": "有的檢察官根本直接就不起訴了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/246.wav", + "text": "有的甚至起訴之後也判無罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/247.wav", + "text": "所以才會導致這樣的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/248.wav", + "text": "啊所以時力黨團跟有一些委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/249.wav", + "text": "才會認為國營事業的部分應該要納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/250.wav", + "text": "甚至有一個考試的作弊集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/251.wav", + "text": "問題在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/252.wav", + "text": "它不是政府機關之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/253.wav", + "text": "但是國營事業雖然不是政府機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/254.wav", + "text": "像中油台電等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/255.wav", + "text": "但是它跟公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/256.wav", + "text": "在提供社會上必要的公共服務上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/257.wav", + "text": "其實是有高度的相似性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/258.wav", + "text": "甚至它也經手大量的公共資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/259.wav", + "text": "有時候它甚至不下於中央的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/260.wav", + "text": "也應該要和公務員一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/261.wav", + "text": "進行一定程度的考核把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/262.wav", + "text": "否則的話他用作弊的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/263.wav", + "text": "基本上他的能力跟誠信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/264.wav", + "text": "所以我們才希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/265.wav", + "text": "也能夠納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/266.wav", + "text": "然後去做刑法第103條的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/267.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/268.wav", + "text": "那我們請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/269.wav", + "text": "接著是湯委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/270.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/271.wav", + "text": "我看很多委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/272.wav", + "text": "都把國營事業納進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/273.wav", + "text": "第一個就是其實國營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/274.wav", + "text": "現在的範圍非常廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/275.wav", + "text": "包括財政部交通部經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/276.wav", + "text": "範圍非常廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/277.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/278.wav", + "text": "雖然說不是公權力的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/279.wav", + "text": "但基本上某個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/280.wav", + "text": "也可以講執行準公權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/281.wav", + "text": "所以再請法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/282.wav", + "text": "或者是考選部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/283.wav", + "text": "看看能不能把它納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/284.wav", + "text": "現行法律也有相關處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/285.wav", + "text": "現行法律處罰的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/286.wav", + "text": "內容是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/287.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/288.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/289.wav", + "text": "這個原則一定不能抹滅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/290.wav", + "text": "當然考試法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/291.wav", + "text": "這是公務人員考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/292.wav", + "text": "這些人員考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/293.wav", + "text": "當然我們已經發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/294.wav", + "text": "有一些代考的舞弊集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/295.wav", + "text": "最後只有判詐欺取財" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/296.wav", + "text": "財讓他們獲利那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/297.wav", + "text": "又沒辦法真的拔擢人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/298.wav", + "text": "國營事業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/299.wav", + "text": "在刑法上應該也要規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/300.wav", + "text": "我們不是說公務員才算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/301.wav", + "text": "那個刑罰上你要規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/302.wav", + "text": "所有沒有按照公平競爭考試的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/303.wav", + "text": "都應該要繩之以法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/304.wav", + "text": "\n另外對於中央政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/305.wav", + "text": "行政命令所為的考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/306.wav", + "text": "像公費留學考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/307.wav", + "text": "或者駕照考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/308.wav", + "text": "這些其實都是公務的延伸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/309.wav", + "text": "其實都應該在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/310.wav", + "text": "刑法的規範下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/311.wav", + "text": "不要說這個好像不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/312.wav", + "text": "公務人員考試都不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/313.wav", + "text": "刑法第103條要規範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/314.wav", + "text": "全民都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/315.wav", + "text": "刑法上都要一樣規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/316.wav", + "text": "他要公平競爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/317.wav", + "text": "而不是只有在公務人員部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/318.wav", + "text": "所以外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/319.wav", + "text": "湯委員你現在有提一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/320.wav", + "text": "修正對我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/321.wav", + "text": "你��在是要按照你的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/322.wav", + "text": "還是你要堅持你原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/323.wav", + "text": "我當然是兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/324.wav", + "text": "都我是希望加重之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/325.wav", + "text": "連這個行政命令的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/326.wav", + "text": "還有國營事業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/327.wav", + "text": "我們都認為還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/328.wav", + "text": "我們認為要比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/329.wav", + "text": "不然現在規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/330.wav", + "text": "只有詐欺取財是很奇怪的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/331.wav", + "text": "好請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/332.wav", + "text": "我要補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/333.wav", + "text": "其實現在真正國家的考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/334.wav", + "text": "大規模舞弊反而少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/335.wav", + "text": "很少見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/336.wav", + "text": "反而是國營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/337.wav", + "text": "常見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/338.wav", + "text": "既然各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/339.wav", + "text": "都有把國營事業納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/340.wav", + "text": "我是建議看能不能納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/341.wav", + "text": "發生弊案已經少見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/342.wav", + "text": "真正的還是國營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/343.wav", + "text": "我覺得反而要納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/344.wav", + "text": "好還是我們這案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/345.wav", + "text": "就保留送院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/346.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/347.wav", + "text": "本日作協商結論如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/348.wav", + "text": "典試法第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/349.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案等6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/350.wav", + "text": "第31條照協商內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/351.wav", + "text": "公務人員考試法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/352.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案等5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/353.wav", + "text": "第2條照考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/354.wav", + "text": "提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/355.wav", + "text": "專門職業及技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/356.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案等6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/357.wav", + "text": "保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/358.wav", + "text": "\n稍待議事人員將協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/359.wav", + "text": "結論書面製作完成後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/360.wav", + "text": "即交由委員簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15208/361.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/0.wav", + "text": "─研商第十屆第八會期開議日相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/1.wav", + "text": "好我先說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/2.wav", + "text": "好謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/3.wav", + "text": "各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/4.wav", + "text": "今天朝野協商有關開議日期的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/5.wav", + "text": "那開議日期從過去從第八屆來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/6.wav", + "text": "9月23號第四會期是9月28日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/7.wav", + "text": "第二會期是9月22日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/8.wav", + "text": "2日那基本上假設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/9.wav", + "text": "我們基本上贊成這第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/10.wav", + "text": "但是我們有兩個前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/11.wav", + "text": "就是要提出來要專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/12.wav", + "text": "這段期間立法院休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/13.wav", + "text": "發生很多關注的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/14.wav", + "text": "第一個就是巴西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/15.wav", + "text": "從巴西進口蛋的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/16.wav", + "text": "這個問題我有幾點說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/17.wav", + "text": "第一點就是超思它的資本額只有50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/18.wav", + "text": "結果陳吉仲部長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/19.wav", + "text": "進口8,800萬顆雞蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/20.wav", + "text": "賺了3,800萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/21.wav", + "text": "那各界會質疑它的資金來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/22.wav", + "text": "也認為到底有沒有超額利潤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/23.wav", + "text": "外界認為說你到底有沒有圖利特定人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/24.wav", + "text": "這第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/25.wav", + "text": "第二個問題就是雞蛋的屬性問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/26.wav", + "text": "到底保鮮期多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/27.wav", + "text": "我們國內的雞蛋從養雞場出來生產之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/28.wav", + "text": "大概35天就進行洗選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/29.wav", + "text": "它保存的期限大概25天到30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/30.wav", + "text": "這是國產的雞蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/31.wav", + "text": "但是這一次我們從巴西進口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/32.wav", + "text": "8,800萬顆雞蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/33.wav", + "text": "最後一批是5月底從巴西進口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/34.wav", + "text": "最後1天報關是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/35.wav", + "text": "7月17號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/36.wav", + "text": "到底有效期限是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/37.wav", + "text": "農委會昨天有發新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/38.wav", + "text": "最後的保存期限是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/39.wav", + "text": "再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/40.wav", + "text": "他報關是7月17" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/41.wav", + "text": "保存期限依照農委會的新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/42.wav", + "text": "但是現在外面市場上的雞蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/43.wav", + "text": "像台農蛋品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/44.wav", + "text": "竟然有標到10月5號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/45.wav", + "text": "的昨天台農蛋品的董事長當然有出來道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/46.wav", + "text": "那今天今天在新北市又查獲了8盒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/47.wav", + "text": "喔它的有效期限是標10月7號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/48.wav", + "text": "我很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/49.wav", + "text": "那雞蛋不是只有雞蛋的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/50.wav", + "text": "這個事情變成兩個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/51.wav", + "text": "第一個前面有沒有圖利特定人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/52.wav", + "text": "第二個食品安全的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/53.wav", + "text": "耶你到底8,800萬顆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/54.wav", + "text": "你到底還有多少雞蛋在市面上賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/55.wav", + "text": "你說標錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/56.wav", + "text": "是真的標錯還是故意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/57.wav", + "text": "這關係到2,300萬民眾食安的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/58.wav", + "text": "這段期間陳吉仲部長講了也講不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/59.wav", + "text": "最後更誇張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/60.wav", + "text": "民進黨下令他不能回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/61.wav", + "text": "我們要調資料也不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/62.wav", + "text": "這樣的話就請這個溫暖堅韌的陳內閣來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/63.wav", + "text": "吧這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/64.wav", + "text": "\n第二點是有關登革熱的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/65.wav", + "text": "到今天已經超過6,615例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/66.wav", + "text": "今年重症已經有27個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/67.wav", + "text": "死了9個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/68.wav", + "text": "民進黨不重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/69.wav", + "text": "都派羅一鈞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/70.wav", + "text": "羅一鈞當然有他的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/71.wav", + "text": "但顯然不重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/72.wav", + "text": "嘛連一個署長都不出門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/73.wav", + "text": "連一個次長都不出門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/74.wav", + "text": "連一個部長都不出門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/75.wav", + "text": "這麼重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/76.wav", + "text": "已經死了9個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/77.wav", + "text": "重症27個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/78.wav", + "text": "派羅一鈞去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/79.wav", + "text": "這叫什麼溫暖堅韌的內閣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/80.wav", + "text": "過去是只有在高雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/81.wav", + "text": "臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/82.wav", + "text": "現在是往北燒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/83.wav", + "text": "\n這兩個事情都關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/84.wav", + "text": ",300萬民眾的健康權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/85.wav", + "text": "國民黨團主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/86.wav", + "text": "施政報告沒那麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/87.wav", + "text": "先來做這兩個專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/88.wav", + "text": "覺得報告可以接受了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/89.wav", + "text": "再來做施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/90.wav", + "text": "好謝謝院長還有各黨黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/91.wav", + "text": "還有各位黨團同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/92.wav", + "text": "民眾黨團針對今天協商開議日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/93.wav", + "text": "當然我們先具體表達我們的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/94.wav", + "text": "我們認為目前國事如麻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/95.wav", + "text": "還是建議9月19號下週二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/96.wav", + "text": "超思進口蛋的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/97.wav", + "text": "因為這不只是有食品安全的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/98.wav", + "text": "是不是有溢價請款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/99.wav", + "text": "甚至是專案進口程序的法源依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/100.wav", + "text": "其實最近這兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/101.wav", + "text": "農業部受到非常多的質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/102.wav", + "text": "我想國人也都非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/103.wav", + "text": "效期標示不符的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/104.wav", + "text": "所以在整個食品安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/105.wav", + "text": "溯源管理跟生產履歷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/106.wav", + "text": "甚至是食品安全的層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/107.wav", + "text": "還有後續有沒有相關利益的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/108.wav", + "text": "農業部都應該要對國人講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/109.wav", + "text": "第10屆第8會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/110.wav", + "text": "立法院應該也要肩負民意的付託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/111.wav", + "text": "\n當然登革熱的議題非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/112.wav", + "text": "現在全臺600多例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/113.wav", + "text": "光是南部的臺南就5,775例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/114.wav", + "text": "甚至過去臺北都沒有案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/115.wav", + "text": "這次都有3例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/116.wav", + "text": "我想這個也是非常嚴正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/117.wav", + "text": "大家必須要關注的一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/118.wav", + "text": "所以我們主張9月19號開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/119.wav", + "text": "做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/120.wav", + "text": "\n第二個我想這是我們這一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/121.wav", + "text": "最後一個會期也是我們的預算會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/122.wav", + "text": "所以我想113年公務預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/123.wav", + "text": "本屆在110年12月23號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/124.wav", + "text": "當時的朝野協商結論第四點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/125.wav", + "text": "民眾黨團就有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/126.wav", + "text": "建請財政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/127.wav", + "text": "爾後研擬年度的中央政府總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/128.wav", + "text": "先進行協商納入實際的審查日程草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/129.wav", + "text": "我們希望這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/130.wav", + "text": "還是要能夠在法定會期內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/131.wav", + "text": "負責任的一個表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/132.wav", + "text": "所以希望可以在12月底前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/133.wav", + "text": "還有中央立法委員的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/134.wav", + "text": "我們不希望有過多政治力干擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/135.wav", + "text": "尤其現在新年度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/136.wav", + "text": "包含很多相關部會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/137.wav", + "text": "政策宣傳費的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/138.wav", + "text": "有沒有用大內宣來做輔選之實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/139.wav", + "text": "\n最後雖然這個會期是預算會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/140.wav", + "text": "但是在相關的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/141.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們還是要回應人民的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/142.wav", + "text": "包含這兩個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/143.wav", + "text": "大家對於居住正義交通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/144.wav", + "text": "和最低工資的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/145.wav", + "text": "有三個法案我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/146.wav", + "text": "這個會期應該要儘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/147.wav", + "text": "儘快來通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/148.wav", + "text": "第一個就是道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/149.wav", + "text": "從820的行人路權大遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/150.wav", + "text": "包含我們未來要推動的人本交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/151.wav", + "text": "及撕掉我們在國際媒體上行人地獄的惡名標籤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/152.wav", + "text": "我們呼籲朝野各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/153.wav", + "text": "在這個會期可以儘快的來推動通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/154.wav", + "text": "第二個針對居住正義房屋稅條例修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/155.wav", + "text": "財政部在8月18日也預告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/156.wav", + "text": "囤房稅2.0的修法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/157.wav", + "text": "居住正義我們也不認為是選舉年才要被討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/158.wav", + "text": "但是在最後這個法定會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/159.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠儘快的通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/160.wav", + "text": "第三個針對基本工資調漲的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/161.wav", + "text": "當然各有各的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/162.wav", + "text": "但是在實質的感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/163.wav", + "text": "的薪資很多都是被物價通膨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/164.wav", + "text": "和高房價吃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/165.wav", + "text": "的這是無感的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/166.wav", + "text": "站在我們立法單位的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/167.wav", + "text": "當時也是蔡總統的承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/168.wav", + "text": "我們應該要完成這個未竟之功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/169.wav", + "text": "功其實包含賴副總統也有在他的政見中提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/170.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望在這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/171.wav", + "text": "修法\n最後是數位政府的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/172.wav", + "text": "我想數發部目前對國人來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/173.wav", + "text": "並不符合期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/174.wav", + "text": "包含新聞媒體數位平臺公平發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/175.wav", + "text": "還有數發部後續的執行功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/176.wav", + "text": "我們都可以進一步的去要求跟監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/177.wav", + "text": "我們建議9月19日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/178.wav", + "text": "還有登革熱的專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/179.wav", + "text": "如同我剛剛所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/180.wav", + "text": "相關的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/181.wav", + "text": "希望可以在預算會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/182.wav", + "text": "儘速的來完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/183.wav", + "text": "讓他發言好嗎不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/184.wav", + "text": "就是9月19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/185.wav", + "text": "禮拜二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/186.wav", + "text": "節還有一些節日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/187.wav", + "text": "其實都會延宕我們整個質詢的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/188.wav", + "text": "提早到19號開議還是比較適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/189.wav", + "text": "那開議之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/190.wav", + "text": "進行的專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/191.wav", + "text": "我們認為現在鄰損的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/192.wav", + "text": "非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/193.wav", + "text": "尤其在危老建築這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/194.wav", + "text": "我們可以從大直案看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/195.wav", + "text": "我今天早上也召開了文昌案記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/196.wav", + "text": "所以也希望能夠針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/197.wav", + "text": "全臺工程鄰損天坑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/198.wav", + "text": "做一個專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/199.wav", + "text": "2017年蔡總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/200.wav", + "text": "在司改國是會議有決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/201.wav", + "text": "餽贈不法關說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/202.wav", + "text": "罪蔡總統的任期也不到1年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/203.wav", + "text": "所以也希望在第10屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/204.wav", + "text": "最後這個會期能夠請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/205.wav", + "text": "法務部把相關的修法版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/206.wav", + "text": "包括揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/207.wav", + "text": "還有不法餽贈不法關說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/208.wav", + "text": "最近有關新竹市長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/209.wav", + "text": "是不是涉及不法餽贈的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/210.wav", + "text": "我們也認為第10屆的委員們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/211.wav", + "text": "所以在專報的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/212.wav", + "text": "我們時力黨團也希望能夠增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/213.wav", + "text": "不法餽贈罪司法改革的專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/214.wav", + "text": "\n另外剛剛國民黨團提到的登革熱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/215.wav", + "text": "我家也被噴藥了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/216.wav", + "text": "所以南部真的很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/217.wav", + "text": "所以登革熱的專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/218.wav", + "text": "我們也支持要來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/219.wav", + "text": "\n另外是針對我們之前買的很多疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/220.wav", + "text": "是不是有過期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/221.wav", + "text": "有關疫苗的購買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/222.wav", + "text": "到底未來行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/223.wav", + "text": "可以有專報的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/224.wav", + "text": "還是希望9月19日就開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/225.wav", + "text": "然後未來這個會期的重要法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/226.wav", + "text": "剛剛民眾黨團也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/227.wav", + "text": "道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/228.wav", + "text": "和囤房稅2.0的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/229.wav", + "text": "還有剛剛提到的揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/230.wav", + "text": "也應該趕快來立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/231.wav", + "text": "希望在第10屆最後一個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/232.wav", + "text": "能夠完成相關的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/233.wav", + "text": "請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/234.wav", + "text": "好就如同剛才我們總召所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/235.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/236.wav", + "text": "是9月22日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/237.wav", + "text": "當然除了總召剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/238.wav", + "text": "以及登革熱相關的問題以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/239.wav", + "text": "其實最近民眾大家所關注的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/240.wav", + "text": "還有臺南綠能弊案的相關疑義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/241.wav", + "text": "我們認為都應該要提出專案報告的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/242.wav", + "text": "這樣子才能讓所有的民眾可以瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/243.wav", + "text": "我們也有提出我們的優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/244.wav", + "text": "在低薪三法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/245.wav", + "text": "公司法證券法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/246.wav", + "text": "以及中小企業發展條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/247.wav", + "text": "我們也希望能夠在這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/248.wav", + "text": "通過來改善臺灣民眾的低薪問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/249.wav", + "text": "這樣子的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/250.wav", + "text": "我們也提出了人工生殖法的相關修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/251.wav", + "text": "希望可以解決現在生殖問題的多元化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/252.wav", + "text": "我們都希望能夠另外提出新的解決方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/253.wav", + "text": "希望生育的民眾都可以來生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/254.wav", + "text": "這樣子也可以提高我們目前的生育率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/255.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/256.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/257.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/258.wav", + "text": "我很仔細聆聽各黨的高見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/259.wav", + "text": "我們今天的題目是第8會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/260.wav", + "text": "第8會期開議日期的相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/261.wav", + "text": "各黨有自己的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/262.wav", + "text": "包括法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/263.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/264.wav", + "text": "專報要十幾個才能專" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/265.wav", + "text": "專報完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/266.wav", + "text": "你看陳椒華那個連司法改革也要專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/267.wav", + "text": "我不知道司法院要來這裡專報什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/268.wav", + "text": "司改有很多法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/269.wav", + "text": "你是要針對哪個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/270.wav", + "text": "我是覺得都尊重沒關係啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/271.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/272.wav", + "text": "乃至於上上禮拜我都有跟各黨稍微溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/273.wav", + "text": "有告訴陳椒華" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/274.wav", + "text": "也跟邱臣遠談過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/275.wav", + "text": "我現在是說重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/276.wav", + "text": "似乎比較重要的是開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/277.wav", + "text": "日期什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/278.wav", + "text": "要哪些專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/279.wav", + "text": "民眾黨所謂的專報是兩天可以併一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/280.wav", + "text": "兩個題目可以併一個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/281.wav", + "text": "換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/282.wav", + "text": "和超思的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/283.wav", + "text": "有什麼弊案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/284.wav", + "text": "超思是唯一能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/285.wav", + "text": "它過去也有進口的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/286.wav", + "text": "也幫日本人在處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/287.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/288.wav", + "text": "38家廠商都找來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/289.wav", + "text": "後來只剩下9家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/290.wav", + "text": "沒有各位想像的弊案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/291.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/292.wav", + "text": "我們今天在這裡不用爭吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/293.wav", + "text": "你就問清楚沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/294.wav", + "text": "我贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/295.wav", + "text": "重要事務來做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/296.wav", + "text": "這個我們可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/297.wav", + "text": "超思蛋的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/298.wav", + "text": "我是覺得這不太科學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/299.wav", + "text": "你要專案報告我們也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/300.wav", + "text": "其他的話我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/301.wav", + "text": "到委員會去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/302.wav", + "text": "我們也都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/303.wav", + "text": "預算則是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/304.wav", + "text": "各位不要忘記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/305.wav", + "text": "兩個報告分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/306.wav", + "text": "還是在一起先談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/307.wav", + "text": "分開一天就解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/308.wav", + "text": "一個人就是15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/309.wav", + "text": "要開場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/310.wav", + "text": "要專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/311.wav", + "text": "彼此尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/312.wav", + "text": "辦你天天講弊案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/313.wav", + "text": "什麼婦女人工生殖法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/314.wav", + "text": "那個法都還沒進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/315.wav", + "text": "我們的優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/316.wav", + "text": "我都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/317.wav", + "text": "兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/318.wav", + "text": "分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/319.wav", + "text": "分開我們就面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/320.wav", + "text": "給我插話一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/321.wav", + "text": "不然就是請行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/322.wav", + "text": "在下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/323.wav", + "text": "趕快送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/324.wav", + "text": "就不用專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/325.wav", + "text": "因為行政院一直不送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/326.wav", + "text": "所以才要他專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/327.wav", + "text": "趕快把法案草案送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/328.wav", + "text": "事情而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/329.wav", + "text": "我是建議專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/330.wav", + "text": "明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/331.wav", + "text": "所以你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/332.wav", + "text": "還有時間可以做還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/333.wav", + "text": "總質詢什麼的你都可以問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/334.wav", + "text": "大家在這裡不要爭辯這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/335.wav", + "text": "這是很嚴肅的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/336.wav", + "text": "另外還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/337.wav", + "text": "22日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/338.wav", + "text": "就兩個專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/339.wav", + "text": "22日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/340.wav", + "text": "19日為什麼不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/341.wav", + "text": "取最大數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/342.wav", + "text": "啦取最大數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/343.wav", + "text": "29日星" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/344.wav", + "text": "星期五放假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/345.wav", + "text": "所以26" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/346.wav", + "text": "所以26日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/347.wav", + "text": "我們把它定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/348.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/349.wav", + "text": "總預算也要付委吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/350.wav", + "text": "因為假如是22日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/351.wav", + "text": "不多27日就會開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/352.wav", + "text": "送那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/353.wav", + "text": "總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/354.wav", + "text": "要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/355.wav", + "text": "總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/356.wav", + "text": "1天就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/357.wav", + "text": "你如果要我們因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/358.wav", + "text": "我們現在大家都大人大你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/359.wav", + "text": "都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/360.wav", + "text": "你要說話算話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/361.wav", + "text": "9月底以前財政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/362.wav", + "text": "已經開會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/363.wav", + "text": "10月3日一起付委下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/364.wav", + "text": "27日他們財委會就開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/365.wav", + "text": "而已你在財委會你最瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/366.wav", + "text": "總預算審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/367.wav", + "text": "然後送到院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/368.wav", + "text": "剛才大家講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/369.wav", + "text": "要在這一屆結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/370.wav", + "text": "不要拖到下一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/371.wav", + "text": "了下一屆就新的會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/372.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/373.wav", + "text": "最後一個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/374.wav", + "text": "總預算總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/375.wav", + "text": "質詢各黨自己有不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/376.wav", + "text": "重要性法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/377.wav", + "text": "我們就在委員會去處理就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/378.wav", + "text": "因為都會碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/379.wav", + "text": "啦最低工資我們也會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/380.wav", + "text": "包括什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/381.wav", + "text": "基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/382.wav", + "text": "嘛法案進來的時候版本不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/383.wav", + "text": "我們再來對再來協商再照程序來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/384.wav", + "text": "我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/385.wav", + "text": "各黨在最後一個會期一定會很理性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/386.wav", + "text": "來面對社會的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/387.wav", + "text": "不會胡亂來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/388.wav", + "text": "總預算也能如期完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/389.wav", + "text": "比較期待的是大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/390.wav", + "text": "再做同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/391.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/392.wav", + "text": "同意在22日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/393.wav", + "text": "那時力這邊也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/394.wav", + "text": "跟總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/395.wav", + "text": "我們時力跟民眾都可以有兩個名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/396.wav", + "text": "好那等一下談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/397.wav", + "text": "這樣就確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/398.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/399.wav", + "text": "既然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/400.wav", + "text": "你說要講就要把它講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/401.wav", + "text": "這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/402.wav", + "text": "要不要休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/403.wav", + "text": "當然會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/404.wav", + "text": "你看歷年沒有一次沒有休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/405.wav", + "text": "講就要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/406.wav", + "text": "沒有啦我說往例就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/407.wav", + "text": "第9屆是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/408.wav", + "text": "12月18不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/409.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/410.wav", + "text": "不是選舉完再回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/411.wav", + "text": "到12月底就結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/412.wav", + "text": "往前提前休會是一定會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/413.wav", + "text": "請兩位總召我們��以後再談好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/414.wav", + "text": "休會部分以後再談好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/415.wav", + "text": "讓人家好安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/416.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/417.wav", + "text": "提前歸提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/418.wav", + "text": "選舉完再回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/419.wav", + "text": "處理總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/420.wav", + "text": "這沒有這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/421.wav", + "text": "的所以第9屆是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/422.wav", + "text": "12月18日就休息了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/423.wav", + "text": "第8屆是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/424.wav", + "text": "12月20日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/425.wav", + "text": "第7屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/426.wav", + "text": "差不多是休息兩個禮拜左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/427.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/428.wav", + "text": "過去的慣例就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/429.wav", + "text": "確定的時間再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/430.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/431.wav", + "text": "跟我們一定會各有召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/432.wav", + "text": "我們當召委的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/433.wav", + "text": "都要休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/434.wav", + "text": "這一點大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/435.wav", + "text": "就是說等這個法案預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/436.wav", + "text": "我們有一個結束的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/437.wav", + "text": "預算趕快付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/438.wav", + "text": "趕快審查完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/439.wav", + "text": "這樣不好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/440.wav", + "text": "22號開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/441.wav", + "text": "9月26號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/442.wav", + "text": "預算總質詢付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/443.wav", + "text": "不要再有所謂的什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/444.wav", + "text": "占領主席臺之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/445.wav", + "text": "順便把它寫五二一次會等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/446.wav", + "text": "因為禮拜五就放假了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/447.wav", + "text": "中秋節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/448.wav", + "text": "謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/449.wav", + "text": "有問題再來改有意見再改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/450.wav", + "text": "我不敢唸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/451.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/452.wav", + "text": "決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/453.wav", + "text": "一各黨團同意定於9月22日(星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/454.wav", + "text": ")舉行第10屆第8會期第1次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/455.wav", + "text": "(開議日)本會期自9月22日(星期五)起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/456.wav", + "text": "每週五及次週二視為一次院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/457.wav", + "text": "國是論壇及臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/458.wav", + "text": "依往例處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/459.wav", + "text": "(週五上午9時至10時為國是論壇時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/460.wav", + "text": "週二下午5時��6時處理臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/461.wav", + "text": "質詢期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/462.wav", + "text": "週二下午1時50分至2時30分處理臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/463.wav", + "text": ")第1次會議不處理臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/464.wav", + "text": "與9月22日(星期五)9月26日(星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/465.wav", + "text": ")合併為一次院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/466.wav", + "text": "9月22日(星期五)邀請行政院院長率同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/467.wav", + "text": "相關部會首長列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/468.wav", + "text": "提出有關農業部辦理專案進口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/469.wav", + "text": "雞蛋相關事項之專案報告並備質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/470.wav", + "text": "9月23日(星期六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/471.wav", + "text": ")邀請行政院院長率同相關部會首長列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/472.wav", + "text": "提出登革熱防治相關事宜專案報告並備質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/473.wav", + "text": "上述各專案報告質詢人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/474.wav", + "text": "由民進黨黨團推派11人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/475.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團推派7人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/476.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團及時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/477.wav", + "text": "各推派1人進行未參加黨團委員得優先發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/478.wav", + "text": "每位委員詢答時間15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/479.wav", + "text": "質詢順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/480.wav", + "text": "名單請於9月21日(星期四)中午12時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/481.wav", + "text": "送交議事處彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/482.wav", + "text": "9月26日(星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/483.wav", + "text": ")邀請行政院院長率同各部會首長列席進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/484.wav", + "text": "施政報告並備質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/485.wav", + "text": "報告後隨即進行政黨質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/486.wav", + "text": "當日質詢人數由民進黨黨團推派4人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/487.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團推派2人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/488.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團及時代力量黨團各推派1人進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/489.wav", + "text": "質詢順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/490.wav", + "text": "依時代力量黨團台灣民眾黨黨團國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/491.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團之順序輪流交叉方式進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/492.wav", + "text": "有關質詢期間之順序及人數均依例授權議事處辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/493.wav", + "text": ")邀請行政院院長主計長財政部部長列席報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/494.wav", + "text": "113年度中央政府總預算案編製經過並備質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/495.wav", + "text": "質詢人數由民進黨黨團推派11人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/496.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團推派7人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/497.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團及時代力量黨團各推派1人進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/498.wav", + "text": "未參加黨團委員得優先發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/499.wav", + "text": "質詢順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/500.wav", + "text": "依例授權議事處辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/501.wav", + "text": "名單請於10月2日(星期一)中午12時前送至議事處彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/502.wav", + "text": "議案詢答完畢後即交審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/503.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意不提出復議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/504.wav", + "text": "\n五請財政委員會於10月2日(星期一)下午5時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/505.wav", + "text": "將總預算案審查日程及分配表送交議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/506.wav", + "text": "俾提10月3日(星期二)院會報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/507.wav", + "text": ")合併為一次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/508.wav", + "text": "10月3日(星期二)上午9時至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/509.wav", + "text": "10時為國是論壇時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/510.wav", + "text": "6日(星期五)下午1時50分至2時30分處理臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/511.wav", + "text": "\n有意見的可以提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/512.wav", + "text": "大方向支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/513.wav", + "text": "啦就是第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/514.wav", + "text": "有二次的專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/515.wav", + "text": "民進黨推派11個就不用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/516.wav", + "text": "沒有現在寫到時私底下再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/517.wav", + "text": "啦你們就不用質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/518.wav", + "text": "柯總召如果這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/519.wav", + "text": "就把它寫清楚好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/520.wav", + "text": "我們民眾黨就2個啦好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/521.wav", + "text": "都2個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/522.wav", + "text": "你們評估一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/523.wav", + "text": "時力2個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/524.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15120/525.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/0.wav", + "text": "各位首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1.wav", + "text": "各位女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2.wav", + "text": "各位先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/3.wav", + "text": "大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/4.wav", + "text": "現在我們來進行下午的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/5.wav", + "text": "今天下午會議的主題要研商外役監條例部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/6.wav", + "text": "案相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/7.wav", + "text": "提案的有時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/8.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團國民黨黨團及台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/9.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我來介紹一下列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/10.wav", + "text": "首先介紹法務部部長蔡清祥先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/11.wav", + "text": "接下來介紹法務部矯正署署長周輝煌先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/12.wav", + "text": "接下來也介紹一下司法院的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/13.wav", + "text": "程怡怡副廳長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/14.wav", + "text": "國防部的代表陳恒偉先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/15.wav", + "text": "教育部代表鄭文瑤女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/16.wav", + "text": "王麗雯小姐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/17.wav", + "text": "我就介紹到這裡\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/18.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們就先請提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/19.wav", + "text": "各位委員不好意思我們有你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/20.wav", + "text": "你們都是提案人都可以講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/21.wav", + "text": "啦不好意思\n主席各位協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/22.wav", + "text": "本席謹代表民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/23.wav", + "text": "對於現在在委員會的版本以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/24.wav", + "text": "但我們對於院版有再提修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/25.wav", + "text": "在談這個以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/26.wav", + "text": "我們先確定一個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/27.wav", + "text": "我們在臨時會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/28.wav", + "text": "在月底前要完成修法的有性平三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/29.wav", + "text": "性平三法很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/30.wav", + "text": "禮拜一要表決剩下兩個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/31.wav", + "text": "臺美21世紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/32.wav", + "text": "貿易倡議坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/33.wav", + "text": "這個法外界很關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/34.wav", + "text": "也很期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/35.wav", + "text": "當時朝野協商簽名的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/36.wav", + "text": "但是本席在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/37.wav", + "text": "徵求各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/38.wav", + "text": "既然來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/39.wav", + "text": "了版本不多嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/40.wav", + "text": "我們就大家共同排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/41.wav", + "text": "我們在禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/42.wav", + "text": "那個可能對大家都不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/43.wav", + "text": "早上我也跟曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/44.wav", + "text": "是不是我們這個先確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/45.wav", + "text": "才往下走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/46.wav", + "text": "我先說明一下其實現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/47.wav", + "text": "大家比較注重就是第4條的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/48.wav", + "text": "行政院版本以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/49.wav", + "text": "我們內部已經跟法務部討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/50.wav", + "text": "現在第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/51.wav", + "text": "外役監的積極資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/52.wav", + "text": "是最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/53.wav", + "text": "今天要修的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/54.wav", + "text": "已經是第六次修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/55.wav", + "text": "60年前訂的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/56.wav", + "text": "必須關1年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/57.wav", + "text": "後來修正到6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/58.wav", + "text": "後來又修成3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/59.wav", + "text": "到1994" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/60.wav", + "text": "這個不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/61.wav", + "text": "我們這次修的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/62.wav", + "text": "行政院版本比較重點的就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/63.wav", + "text": "必須要關三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/64.wav", + "text": "這一條線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/65.wav", + "text": "改變非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/66.wav", + "text": "這是有關於積極資格的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/67.wav", + "text": "消極資格上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/68.wav", + "text": "行政院版本有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/69.wav", + "text": "但是這一次我們看了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/70.wav", + "text": "以及重大經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/71.wav", + "text": "所謂重大經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/72.wav", + "text": "我們等一下會把所有的十幾個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/73.wav", + "text": "犯了這些法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/74.wav", + "text": "最輕本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/75.wav", + "text": "刑7年以上就不可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/76.wav", + "text": "不管是貪污或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/77.wav", + "text": "你要繳回所得以後才可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/78.wav", + "text": "我們上個會期有修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/79.wav", + "text": "以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/80.wav", + "text": "了這也應該納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/81.wav", + "text": "了兩條線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/82.wav", + "text": "一條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/83.wav", + "text": "門關的很小了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/84.wav", + "text": "有很多是列舉式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/85.wav", + "text": "方向是朝這個方向去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/86.wav", + "text": "的\n另外有關組織犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/87.wav", + "text": "招募到國外去組織犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/88.wav", + "text": "我們修過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/89.wav", + "text": "也應該加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/90.wav", + "text": "販運的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/91.wav", + "text": "也放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/92.wav", + "text": "等一下各委員可以看看本黨提出的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/93.wav", + "text": "這一條比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/94.wav", + "text": "有關於第6條可能會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/95.wav", + "text": "所以第二十五條可能要保留再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/96.wav", + "text": "以上是本黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/97.wav", + "text": "的修正意見請各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/98.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/99.wav", + "text": "各位同仁還有蔡部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/100.wav", + "text": "我代表國民黨黨團提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/101.wav", + "text": "兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/102.wav", + "text": "第一個部分剛剛柯總召說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/103.wav", + "text": "今天進行朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/104.wav", + "text": "如果沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/105.wav", + "text": "下禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/106.wav", + "text": "完成三讀的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/107.wav", + "text": "放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/108.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/109.wav", + "text": "國民黨全力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/110.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/111.wav", + "text": "第二點是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/112.wav", + "text": "的提案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/113.wav", + "text": "有幾點我提出來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/114.wav", + "text": "第一個是現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/115.wav", + "text": "受有期徒刑執行二個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/116.wav", + "text": "就可以到外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/117.wav", + "text": "了國民黨是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/118.wav", + "text": "受有期徒刑執行要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/119.wav", + "text": "二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/120.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/121.wav", + "text": "第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/122.wav", + "text": "以下幾種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/123.wav", + "text": "所犯最輕本刑為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/124.wav", + "text": "7年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/125.wav", + "text": "即重罪的部分不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/126.wav", + "text": "累犯也不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/127.wav", + "text": "毒品危害防制條例之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/128.wav", + "text": "罪也不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/129.wav", + "text": "第四個部分是犯貪污治罪條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/130.wav", + "text": "或者重大經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/131.wav", + "text": "依法應沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/132.wav", + "text": "追繳的犯罪所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/133.wav", + "text": "這部分要繳回來才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/134.wav", + "text": "這個是我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/135.wav", + "text": "主要條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/136.wav", + "text": "\n另外我們在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/137.wav", + "text": "討論的時候有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/138.wav", + "text": "因為外界也質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/139.wav", + "text": "在審查過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/140.wav", + "text": "可能會有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/141.wav", + "text": "外力的介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/142.wav", + "text": "審查過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/143.wav", + "text": "要錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/144.wav", + "text": "基本上法務部也贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/145.wav", + "text": "我們的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/146.wav", + "text": "這個我也贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/147.wav", + "text": "審查過程中要錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/148.wav", + "text": "讓它更為公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/149.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/150.wav", + "text": "對制度的維持是好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/151.wav", + "text": "這是我們國民黨的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/152.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/153.wav", + "text": "我這邊代表民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/154.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/155.wav", + "text": "這次民眾黨當然也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/156.wav", + "text": "剛才柯總召的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/157.wav", + "text": "就是我們也放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/158.wav", + "text": "協商冷凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/159.wav", + "text": "我們希望下週一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/160.wav", + "text": "就能夠順利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/161.wav", + "text": "把它修法通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/162.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/163.wav", + "text": "主要的修正動議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/164.wav", + "text": "我們這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/165.wav", + "text": "重要的主張包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/166.wav", + "text": "執行有期徒刑逾二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/167.wav", + "text": "始得納入遴選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/168.wav", + "text": "因為院版是三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/169.wav", + "text": "遴選也要排除重大暴力犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/170.wav", + "text": "犯本刑7年以上之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/171.wav", + "text": "就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/172.wav", + "text": "重大經濟犯罪這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/173.wav", + "text": "還有遴選也要排除貪污犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/174.wav", + "text": "這兩個地方院版都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/175.wav", + "text": "另外我們最後一個是刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/176.wav", + "text": "有很多是累犯怎麼樣怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/177.wav", + "text": "這個地方累犯的部分我們都已經刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/178.wav", + "text": "主要就是針對第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/179.wav", + "text": "我想今天重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/180.wav", + "text": "也就是在這一條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/181.wav", + "text": "當然這邊我還有幾個詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/182.wav", + "text": "可能先請行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/183.wav", + "text": "準備一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/184.wav", + "text": "等一下可以幫我們說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/185.wav", + "text": "就是我們在這一次臨時會逐條審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/186.wav", + "text": "遴選過程是否錄音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/187.wav", + "text": "我們等一下請問一下部長你們後來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/188.wav", + "text": "的結果是什麼這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/189.wav", + "text": "\n第二點就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/190.wav", + "text": "如果要是未來進行錄音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/191.wav", + "text": "錄影那麼在遴選結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/192.wav", + "text": "有疑義的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/193.wav", + "text": "你們如何提供外部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/194.wav", + "text": "調閱資料進行檢驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/195.wav", + "text": "這個地方看看部裡面能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/196.wav", + "text": "\n第三個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/197.wav", + "text": "時力黨團國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/198.wav", + "text": "貪污治罪條例者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/199.wav", + "text": "應該排除於遴選門檻之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/200.wav", + "text": "這個我想其實等於就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/201.wav", + "text": "在野黨這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/202.wav", + "text": "大家幾乎共同的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/203.wav", + "text": "能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/204.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/205.wav", + "text": "請邱總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/206.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/207.wav", + "text": "總召各黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/208.wav", + "text": "部長署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/209.wav", + "text": "這個外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/210.wav", + "text": "光是在這邊也審過好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/211.wav", + "text": "我剛剛第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/212.wav", + "text": "聽到柯總召說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/213.wav", + "text": "要繳回犯罪所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/214.wav", + "text": "跟重大經濟犯要繳回犯罪所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/215.wav", + "text": "才可以來參與遴選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/216.wav", + "text": "這個是時力黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/217.wav", + "text": "一直以來的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/218.wav", + "text": "現在民進黨團的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/219.wav", + "text": "也採納這樣的建議我們當然表示肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/220.wav", + "text": "但是我必須要提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/221.wav", + "text": "為什麼外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/222.wav", + "text": "外役監這麼受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/223.wav", + "text": "大家社會各界的矚目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/224.wav", + "text": "其實非常簡單嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/225.wav", + "text": "因為這些貪官污吏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/226.wav", + "text": "這些重大經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/227.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/228.wav", + "text": "他是用一個非常快的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/229.wav", + "text": "從一般監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/230.wav", + "text": "到外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/231.wav", + "text": "然後在外役監去享受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/232.wav", + "text": "也就是說關一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/233.wav", + "text": "然後他可以抵2天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/234.wav", + "text": "關一個月最多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/235.wav", + "text": "竟然達到16天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/236.wav", + "text": "被關一個月之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/237.wav", + "text": "我就縮刑16天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/238.wav", + "text": "奇怪哦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/239.wav", + "text": "這個人明明是一位貪官污吏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/240.wav", + "text": "明明是一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/241.wav", + "text": "重大經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/242.wav", + "text": "甚至他犯罪所得也沒繳回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/243.wav", + "text": "為什麼他很快就假釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/244.wav", + "text": "出在外役監的縮刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/245.wav", + "text": "其實非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/246.wav", + "text": "就是你要去改革外役監的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/247.wav", + "text": "讓社會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/248.wav", + "text": "其實這個縮刑的制度要去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/249.wav", + "text": "我坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/250.wav", + "text": "今天在比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/251.wav", + "text": "監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/252.wav", + "text": "比較這些監獄的法制度來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/253.wav", + "text": "外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/254.wav", + "text": "基本上的定義其實部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/255.wav", + "text": "非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/256.wav", + "text": "下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/257.wav", + "text": "因為我們知道在長期中高度戒護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/258.wav", + "text": "隔絕之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/259.wav", + "text": "不利收容人將來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/260.wav", + "text": "怎麼辦呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/261.wav", + "text": "這要尊重大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/262.wav", + "text": "之前就是你都不尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/263.wav", + "text": "大家的發言所以才會現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/264.wav", + "text": "又來處理如果當初你有仔細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/265.wav", + "text": "聽我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/266.wav", + "text": "如果你有仔細聽我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/267.wav", + "text": "重大經濟犯罪應該繳犯罪所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/268.wav", + "text": "再來處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/269.wav", + "text": "你要讓我講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/270.wav", + "text": "啊你如果有想要講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/271.wav", + "text": "我們也讓你暢所欲言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/272.wav", + "text": "嘛很擔心的就是理由不充分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/273.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/274.wav", + "text": "如果說今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/275.wav", + "text": "院長這不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/276.wav", + "text": "我要講的是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/277.wav", + "text": "它的制度本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/278.wav", + "text": "跟它的縮刑制度的不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/279.wav", + "text": "在哪裡講回來就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/280.wav", + "text": "縮刑這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/281.wav", + "text": "獨步全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/282.wav", + "text": "外役監放假跟他去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/283.wav", + "text": "作業這個跟國外的開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/284.wav", + "text": "監獄跟歐洲或其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/285.wav", + "text": "的開放監獄是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/286.wav", + "text": "但是縮刑這個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/287.wav", + "text": "在外役監是一天抵兩天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/288.wav", + "text": "這是獨步全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/289.wav", + "text": "其實非常清楚第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/290.wav", + "text": "刪除之後回歸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/291.wav", + "text": "一般的累進處遇條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/292.wav", + "text": "\n其實署長在這邊也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/293.wav", + "text": "累進處遇條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/294.wav", + "text": "有縮刑的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/295.wav", + "text": "那你就回到這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/296.wav", + "text": "有期徒刑逾三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/297.wav", + "text": "一年內可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/298.wav", + "text": "大的變革當然要支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/299.wav", + "text": "但是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/300.wav", + "text": "的時候會再度發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/301.wav", + "text": "一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/302.wav", + "text": "又報假釋了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/303.wav", + "text": "時力黨團的主張其實非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/304.wav", + "text": "其實第4條有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/305.wav", + "text": "羅列現在法務部的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/306.wav", + "text": "就是羅列許多沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/307.wav", + "text": "遴選的罪名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/308.wav", + "text": "處理嘛但是我必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/309.wav", + "text": "講你的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/310.wav", + "text": "在哪裡你的重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/311.wav", + "text": "為什麼這個人後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/312.wav", + "text": "可以用飛快的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/313.wav", + "text": "從一般的監獄譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/314.wav", + "text": "多久就去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/315.wav", + "text": "兩年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/316.wav", + "text": "去外役監但是兩年半還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/317.wav", + "text": "還沒關三分之一他就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/318.wav", + "text": "到外役監了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/319.wav", + "text": "去外役監之後又享受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/320.wav", + "text": "縮刑的待遇導致你根本還沒關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/321.wav", + "text": "一半就去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/322.wav", + "text": "這個遴選基本上要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/323.wav", + "text": "讓大家能夠信賴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/324.wav", + "text": "很好的制度但是遴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/325.wav", + "text": "要能夠獨立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/326.wav", + "text": "讓大家認為是公平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/327.wav", + "text": "我們的版本認為要針對遴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/328.wav", + "text": "也要能夠監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/329.wav", + "text": "不應該去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/330.wav", + "text": "臺南的殺警案也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/331.wav", + "text": "為什麼他可以過五關斬六將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/332.wav", + "text": "能夠通過外役監的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/333.wav", + "text": "之後還跑走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/334.wav", + "text": "送黑髮人的慘劇就是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/335.wav", + "text": "我要講的第二個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/336.wav", + "text": "制度應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/337.wav", + "text": "今天處理這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/338.wav", + "text": "機制完全都沒有改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/339.wav", + "text": "不能夠接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/340.wav", + "text": "現在用罪名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/341.wav", + "text": "的學者都對這個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/342.wav", + "text": "有疑慮為什麼我舉一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/343.wav", + "text": "例子一樣是殺人罪好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/344.wav", + "text": "了殺人罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/345.wav", + "text": "首次判有罪的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/346.wav", + "text": "90年代的鄧如雯殺夫案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/347.wav", + "text": "在這個情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/348.wav", + "text": "要把這樣的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/349.wav", + "text": "外役監之外嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/350.wav", + "text": "有比例原則的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/351.wav", + "text": "所以我們的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/352.wav", + "text": "你們把很多罪名羅列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/353.wav", + "text": "而且現在看起來你的版本又更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/354.wav", + "text": "之後是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/355.wav", + "text": "基本上在個案上有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/356.wav", + "text": "過苛的疑慮逾越了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/357.wav", + "text": "讓法務部有依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/358.wav", + "text": "受刑人的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/359.wav", + "text": "經專業公正的審酌後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/360.wav", + "text": "授予這個許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/361.wav", + "text": "讓它有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/362.wav", + "text": "案件可以去做調整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/363.wav", + "text": "現在我們直接到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/364.wav", + "text": "\n請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/365.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/366.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有看了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/367.wav", + "text": "協商建議的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/368.wav", + "text": "協商建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/369.wav", + "text": "貪污治罪條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/370.wav", + "text": "交易法銀行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/371.wav", + "text": "等金融犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/372.wav", + "text": "這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/373.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/374.wav", + "text": "要沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/375.wav", + "text": "如果沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/376.wav", + "text": "沒收就無法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/377.wav", + "text": "來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/378.wav", + "text": "進入外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/379.wav", + "text": "認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/380.wav", + "text": "他們的不法利得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/381.wav", + "text": "應該被沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/382.wav", + "text": "我想這樣的修法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/383.wav", + "text": "正確不過我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/384.wav", + "text": "違反環境法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/385.wav", + "text": "他們的不法利得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/386.wav", + "text": "甚至達數億數十億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/387.wav", + "text": "以上都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/388.wav", + "text": "所以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/389.wav", + "text": "追討犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/390.wav", + "text": "不法利得這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/391.wav", + "text": "應該也要將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/392.wav", + "text": "包括廢棄物清理法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/393.wav", + "text": "水污染防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/394.wav", + "text": "空污法甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/395.wav", + "text": "土石採取法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/396.wav", + "text": "等這些環保法規如果有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/397.wav", + "text": "任何不法利得的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/398.wav", + "text": "要追討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/399.wav", + "text": "為什麼這個非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/400.wav", + "text": "因為目前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/401.wav", + "text": "沒有把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/402.wav", + "text": "我們知道現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/403.wav", + "text": "一些污染的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/404.wav", + "text": "防治整治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/405.wav", + "text": "犯罪所得都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/406.wav", + "text": "讓政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/407.wav", + "text": "公家單位如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/408.wav", + "text": "有污染到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/409.wav", + "text": "通常如果要整治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/410.wav", + "text": "非常多倍甚至數億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/411.wav", + "text": "以上的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/412.wav", + "text": "才有辦法去整治完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/413.wav", + "text": "所以現在常常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/414.wav", + "text": "很多的犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/415.wav", + "text": "就放著沒有辦法去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/416.wav", + "text": "整治所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/417.wav", + "text": "監條例如果沒有把它納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/418.wav", + "text": "我想現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/419.wav", + "text": "他們如果到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/420.wav", + "text": "時候進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/421.wav", + "text": "外役監像剛剛我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/422.wav", + "text": "邱顯智總召所提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/423.wav", + "text": "的縮刑這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/424.wav", + "text": "相信很快就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/425.wav", + "text": "又可以出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/426.wav", + "text": "我們目前看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/427.wav", + "text": "的毒品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/428.wav", + "text": "危害兒童少年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/429.wav", + "text": "經濟貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/430.wav", + "text": "將重大環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/431.wav", + "text": "犯罪不法利得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/432.wav", + "text": "要繳回所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/433.wav", + "text": "才能夠進入外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/434.wav", + "text": "我想這個漏掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/435.wav", + "text": "是非常非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/436.wav", + "text": "不好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/437.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/438.wav", + "text": "應該還是要納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/439.wav", + "text": "我首先還是要肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/440.wav", + "text": "一下法務部在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/441.wav", + "text": "會之後很快速的把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/442.wav", + "text": "我們各個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/443.wav", + "text": "所提出的一些條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/444.wav", + "text": "儘可能納入在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/445.wav", + "text": "第4條的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/446.wav", + "text": "但是本席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/447.wav", + "text": "國民黨團所堅持的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/448.wav", + "text": "累犯的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/449.wav", + "text": "而現在在你們的第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/450.wav", + "text": "第3項第十二款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/451.wav", + "text": "裡面還是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/452.wav", + "text": "已執行完畢之前案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/453.wav", + "text": "均為受六月以下有期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/454.wav", + "text": "徒刑之宣告者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/455.wav", + "text": "這個條文其實是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/456.wav", + "text": "2020年3月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/457.wav", + "text": "的修法也是造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/458.wav", + "text": "這次我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/459.wav", + "text": "可以用81天就完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/460.wav", + "text": "從去年殺警案之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/461.wav", + "text": "總統希望我們能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/462.wav", + "text": "儘速修法卻沒修法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/463.wav", + "text": "一個主要的批評的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/464.wav", + "text": "原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/465.wav", + "text": "其實很多外界是在質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/466.wav", + "text": "當時的修法是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/467.wav", + "text": "個案式的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/468.wav", + "text": "領銜提案的幾個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/469.wav", + "text": "來講其實我覺得也是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/470.wav", + "text": "不可承受之重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/471.wav", + "text": "所以如果今天能夠處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/472.wav", + "text": "我還是主張要照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/473.wav", + "text": "我們國民黨的這個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/474.wav", + "text": "累犯就把它排除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/475.wav", + "text": "因為累犯就是犯罪行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/476.wav", + "text": "因為他之前的犯罪判決確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/477.wav", + "text": "而且執行完畢後在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/478.wav", + "text": "一定的期限內又故意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/479.wav", + "text": "顯然刑罰的執行對於這一類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/480.wav", + "text": "犯罪行為人沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/481.wav", + "text": "達到教化的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/482.wav", + "text": "那我們怎麼能夠期待他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/483.wav", + "text": "會有悛悔之情呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/484.wav", + "text": "甚至具有高度再犯的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/485.wav", + "text": "所以我們以前案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/486.wav", + "text": "所宣告的刑度作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/487.wav", + "text": "是否准予外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/488.wav", + "text": "根本就忽略了他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/489.wav", + "text": "再犯的風險不符合外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/490.wav", + "text": "立法的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/491.wav", + "text": "動議的提案其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/492.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗等3人的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/493.wav", + "text": "第4條第二項第三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/494.wav", + "text": "的但書剛剛我們總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/495.wav", + "text": "也說明了累犯就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/496.wav", + "text": "外役監服刑以收刑罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/497.wav", + "text": "矯正教化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/498.wav", + "text": "之功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/499.wav", + "text": "\n其餘本席的修正動議也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/500.wav", + "text": "針對民眾因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/501.wav", + "text": "妨害公務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/502.wav", + "text": "導致執法之公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/503.wav", + "text": "重傷者不僅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/504.wav", + "text": "妨害公務的執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/505.wav", + "text": "還嚴重影響公共秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/506.wav", + "text": "社會安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/507.wav", + "text": "進而使得公務員傷亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/508.wav", + "text": "惡性重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/509.wav", + "text": "另外殺害一般民眾或直系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/510.wav", + "text": "人身安全危害程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/511.wav", + "text": "甚大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/512.wav", + "text": "在我們一般國人的法律情感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/513.wav", + "text": "上對於這一類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/514.wav", + "text": "的犯罪都認為是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/515.wav", + "text": "惡性很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/516.wav", + "text": "所以被告涉犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/517.wav", + "text": "這些罪都不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/518.wav", + "text": "遴選到外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/519.wav", + "text": "行政院草案的第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/520.wav", + "text": "第2項還包含這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/521.wav", + "text": "以及本席修法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/522.wav", + "text": "裡面的詐欺犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/523.wav", + "text": "違反組織犯罪條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/524.wav", + "text": "現行法第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/525.wav", + "text": "第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/526.wav", + "text": "累犯的但書刪除之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/527.wav", + "text": "其實本席對於行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/528.wav", + "text": "後來的修正版本是予以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/529.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/530.wav", + "text": "現在我們就進入第4條的討論好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/531.wav", + "text": "第4條法務部有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/532.wav", + "text": "大家看一下法務部的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/533.wav", + "text": "當然沒有意見就照法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/534.wav", + "text": "我要先這樣問嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/535.wav", + "text": "我是怕你們大家都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/536.wav", + "text": "就是這個不法利得應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/537.wav", + "text": "沒收因為他的不法利得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/538.wav", + "text": "是很龐大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/539.wav", + "text": "所以在第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/540.wav", + "text": "第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/541.wav", + "text": "至少要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/542.wav", + "text": "廢棄物清理法放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/543.wav", + "text": "如果水污染防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/544.wav", + "text": "跟空污這邊沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/545.wav", + "text": "我是可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/546.wav", + "text": "至少要把廢棄物清理法放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/547.wav", + "text": "那如果三個法都納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/548.wav", + "text": "是最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/549.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/550.wav", + "text": "就是法務部已經有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/551.wav", + "text": "我知道他這個第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/552.wav", + "text": "第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/553.wav", + "text": "要看他的協商建議的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/554.wav", + "text": "有期徒刑逾三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/555.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/556.wav", + "text": "二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/557.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/558.wav", + "text": "是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/559.wav", + "text": "累犯的二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/560.wav", + "text": "啦因為我們的累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/561.wav", + "text": "就是已經被排除在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/562.wav", + "text": "遴選之外所以我們當然就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/563.wav", + "text": "所謂的累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/564.wav", + "text": "逾二分之一我們就直接說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/565.wav", + "text": "你執行要超過二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/566.wav", + "text": "才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/567.wav", + "text": "我們還是要強調一下就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/568.wav", + "text": "累犯到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/569.wav", + "text": "要不要讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/570.wav", + "text": "可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/571.wav", + "text": "最早的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/572.wav", + "text": "版本是不行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/573.wav", + "text": "2020年才修過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/574.wav", + "text": "又開了一個後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/575.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為這次修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/576.wav", + "text": "很大的一個重點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/577.wav", + "text": "把這個後門再把它關掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/578.wav", + "text": "累犯就不能去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/579.wav", + "text": "就是怕他再犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/580.wav", + "text": "嘛你知道嗎外役監讓他更自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/581.wav", + "text": "他可以放假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/582.wav", + "text": "這個累犯表示什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/583.wav", + "text": "就是慣犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/584.wav", + "text": "很容易再犯的人就是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/585.wav", + "text": "你還給這種人去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/586.wav", + "text": "給他自由可以放假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/587.wav", + "text": "所以造成所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/588.wav", + "text": "之前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/589.wav", + "text": "臺南殺警案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/590.wav", + "text": "他就是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/591.wav", + "text": "他就是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/592.wav", + "text": "強盜的累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/593.wav", + "text": "結果他去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/594.wav", + "text": "因為我們那時候2020" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/595.wav", + "text": "年就給累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/596.wav", + "text": "開了一個後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/597.wav", + "text": "所以才有殺警案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/598.wav", + "text": "我如果講得嚴重一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/599.wav", + "text": "給累犯開後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/600.wav", + "text": "這個臺南殺警案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/601.wav", + "text": "不會發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/602.wav", + "text": "因為他不能去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/603.wav", + "text": "當然就不能放假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/604.wav", + "text": "然後逾假不歸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/605.wav", + "text": "逃獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/606.wav", + "text": "然後去殺警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/607.wav", + "text": "所以我們這次修法很大的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/608.wav", + "text": "就是要再把給累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/609.wav", + "text": "開了一個那樣的後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/610.wav", + "text": "\n另外再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/611.wav", + "text": "危害防制條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/612.wav", + "text": "也不要開後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/613.wav", + "text": "像行政院法務部的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/614.wav", + "text": "也有一個但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/615.wav", + "text": "也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/616.wav", + "text": "繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/617.wav", + "text": "危害防制條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/618.wav", + "text": "也可以被遴選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/619.wav", + "text": "我們覺得毒品犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/620.wav", + "text": "就是最容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/621.wav", + "text": "再犯的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/622.wav", + "text": "他戒毒癮就是很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/623.wav", + "text": "你讓他更自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/624.wav", + "text": "在那個地方還可以放假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/625.wav", + "text": "他回去又去吸毒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/626.wav", + "text": "你怎麼可以開個後門給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/627.wav", + "text": "讓他可以去外役監可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/628.wav", + "text": "放假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/629.wav", + "text": "犯毒品危害防制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/630.wav", + "text": "罪的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/631.wav", + "text": "毒犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/632.wav", + "text": "再開一個後門讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/633.wav", + "text": "他可以去外役監\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/634.wav", + "text": "第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/635.wav", + "text": "第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/636.wav", + "text": "及毒駕致死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/637.wav", + "text": "這個也要排除在遴選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/638.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/639.wav", + "text": "剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/640.wav", + "text": "酒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/641.wav", + "text": "也是很容易再犯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/642.wav", + "text": "當然就更不用講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/643.wav", + "text": "很容易再犯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/644.wav", + "text": "有毒癮的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/645.wav", + "text": "還有有酒癮的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/646.wav", + "text": "當然這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/647.wav", + "text": "要致死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/648.wav", + "text": "這是最嚴重的酒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/649.wav", + "text": "遴選的資格之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/650.wav", + "text": "這個是我們再補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/651.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/652.wav", + "text": "我相信各個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/653.wav", + "text": "在談這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/654.wav", + "text": "外役監的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/655.wav", + "text": "是不是先確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/656.wav", + "text": "不然你們是希望什麼人可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/657.wav", + "text": "這個是一個大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/658.wav", + "text": "林為洲委員剛剛提到的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/659.wav", + "text": "你那個講法也不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/660.wav", + "text": "林信吾根本不是因為累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/661.wav", + "text": "2014年的時候根本沒有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/662.wav", + "text": "你說殺人的就不用想要進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/663.wav", + "text": "了和這個也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/664.wav", + "text": "你到底想讓哪一些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/665.wav", + "text": "到外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/666.wav", + "text": "我們在定義的外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/667.wav", + "text": "監到底要幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/668.wav", + "text": "\n第二個大家在談累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/669.wav", + "text": "你說累犯是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/670.wav", + "text": "就是很可惡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/671.wav", + "text": "啊譬如他以前是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/672.wav", + "text": "去之後遇到你林為洲我看你很不爽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/673.wav", + "text": "這也不是惡性那麼重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/674.wav", + "text": "五年之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/675.wav", + "text": "再犯有期徒刑以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/676.wav", + "text": "這樣就叫累犯喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/677.wav", + "text": "這樣就叫累犯喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/678.wav", + "text": "我們要講好回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/679.wav", + "text": "應社會的期待是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/680.wav", + "text": "這是立法院該做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/681.wav", + "text": "但是如果我們整個外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/682.wav", + "text": "你到底是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/683.wav", + "text": "定性為到外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/684.wav", + "text": "照樣報復你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/685.wav", + "text": "這樣就不用外役監了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/686.wav", + "text": "外役監是一個中間處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/687.wav", + "text": "起訴到法院以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/688.wav", + "text": "司法審判就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/689.wav", + "text": "再來在監獄行刑的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/690.wav", + "text": "沒有到外役監的開始有縮刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/691.wav", + "text": "縮刑的部分也要有分數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/692.wav", + "text": "四級還不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/693.wav", + "text": "三級開始才有縮刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/694.wav", + "text": "更長的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/695.wav", + "text": "我相信當初會制定的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/696.wav", + "text": "遴選去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/697.wav", + "text": "所以縮刑的幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/698.wav", + "text": "會變得比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/699.wav", + "text": "這個部分我倒是肯認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/700.wav", + "text": "反而我是贊成邱顯智剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/701.wav", + "text": "那裡遴選的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/702.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼樣把那個標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/703.wav", + "text": "不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/704.wav", + "text": "除了少數不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/705.wav", + "text": "還是這個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/706.wav", + "text": "才符合社會國民的法律感情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/707.wav", + "text": "覺得要稍微報復他一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/708.wav", + "text": "除非我們都不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/709.wav", + "text": "我們回應外界的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/710.wav", + "text": "殺人的不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/711.wav", + "text": "雖然外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/712.wav", + "text": "是中間處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/713.wav", + "text": "他階段性表現得不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/714.wav", + "text": "你是犯重罪所以剝奪剝奪剝奪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/715.wav", + "text": "也可以我們純粹要走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/716.wav", + "text": "報復主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/717.wav", + "text": "社會上如果認為這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/718.wav", + "text": "少數幾種罪名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/719.wav", + "text": "OK但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/720.wav", + "text": "除了這些以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/721.wav", + "text": "還是要理性來討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/722.wav", + "text": "我們到底要讓什麼人去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/723.wav", + "text": "罪的不行合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/724.wav", + "text": "毒品的不行也合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/725.wav", + "text": "社會上也這樣期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/726.wav", + "text": "殺人的也不能去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/727.wav", + "text": "靠腰都是一些俗辣卻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/728.wav", + "text": "變成那一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/729.wav", + "text": "看起來不是重罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/730.wav", + "text": "反正就社會沒那麼討厭的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/731.wav", + "text": "假設還是把它定性成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/732.wav", + "text": "一個爽缺的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/733.wav", + "text": "我們要讓誰去那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/734.wav", + "text": "各位政治家要好好去思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/735.wav", + "text": "我沒有定見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/736.wav", + "text": "但是回應外界的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/737.wav", + "text": "期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/738.wav", + "text": "法律本來就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/739.wav", + "text": "符合國民的法律感情這是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/740.wav", + "text": "絕大多數的民眾認為不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/741.wav", + "text": "犯罪就是要報復報復報復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/742.wav", + "text": "我聽到林為洲說的就都是報復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/743.wav", + "text": "可是這套制度設計出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/744.wav", + "text": "還是有它的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/745.wav", + "text": "大家要想好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/746.wav", + "text": "都已經進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/747.wav", + "text": "這個議題都不是在吵架了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/748.wav", + "text": "這個議題是怎麼樣回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/749.wav", + "text": "社會的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/750.wav", + "text": "以後把這個制度全部都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/751.wav", + "text": "破壞掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/752.wav", + "text": "要把它破壞我也沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/753.wav", + "text": "你說都不要也可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/754.wav", + "text": "以後我們的法律全部都是報復型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/755.wav", + "text": "要走回頭路也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/756.wav", + "text": "我是沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/757.wav", + "text": "真的都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/758.wav", + "text": "你要點名我就回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/759.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/760.wav", + "text": "因為不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/761.wav", + "text": "因為爭執點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/762.wav", + "text": "第2項而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/763.wav", + "text": "不得遴選的問題而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/764.wav", + "text": "\n至於第十四條那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/765.wav", + "text": "行刑累進處遇條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/766.wav", + "text": "規定必須到三級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/767.wav", + "text": "要10分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/768.wav", + "text": "到二級到一級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/769.wav", + "text": "怎麼到外役監裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/770.wav", + "text": "來以後都是加倍的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/771.wav", + "text": "要去改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/772.wav", + "text": "這個我反而就覺得沒有意見喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/773.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/774.wav", + "text": "不然大家一直加碼加碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/775.wav", + "text": "要加碼大家等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/776.wav", + "text": "然後是陳椒華委員林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/777.wav", + "text": "再來是張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/778.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/779.wav", + "text": "現在的狀況是你把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/780.wav", + "text": "現在法務部修法的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/781.wav", + "text": "是羅列很多罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/782.wav", + "text": "最輕本刑十年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/783.wav", + "text": "有期徒刑之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/784.wav", + "text": "最輕本刑十年以上之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/785.wav", + "text": "現在問題來了就是我剛剛提到的那個最" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/786.wav", + "text": "最輕本刑十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/787.wav", + "text": "以上之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/788.wav", + "text": "分則還有一個總則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/789.wav", + "text": "是要有違法性要有責性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/790.wav", + "text": "而這個有責性有高低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/791.wav", + "text": "最輕本刑假設是十年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/792.wav", + "text": "假設在判有罪的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/793.wav", + "text": "部長可以判到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/794.wav", + "text": "判二年多也可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/795.wav", + "text": "大家都非常清楚為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/796.wav", + "text": "比如鄧如雯殺夫案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/797.wav", + "text": "這個案子到最後判二年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/798.wav", + "text": "你把要件放在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/799.wav", + "text": "也許大家認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/800.wav", + "text": "他的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/801.wav", + "text": "明明是一個十年以上有期徒刑之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/802.wav", + "text": "把他排除在外役監的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/803.wav", + "text": "遴選資格之外嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/804.wav", + "text": "羅列這麼多罪名之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/805.wav", + "text": "會有各種不同行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/806.wav", + "text": "的態樣跟法官最後判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/807.wav", + "text": "出來不同的情狀\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/808.wav", + "text": "那個累犯的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/809.wav", + "text": "也是一樣累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/810.wav", + "text": "但書但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/811.wav", + "text": "在個案上不得逾越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/812.wav", + "text": "所欲達成矯治處遇目的之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/813.wav", + "text": "你就要訂一個類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/814.wav", + "text": "監獄行刑法第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/815.wav", + "text": "的這種不得逾越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/816.wav", + "text": "必要限度的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/817.wav", + "text": "也就是說我們的版本裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/818.wav", + "text": "讓法務部可以依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/819.wav", + "text": "他的特殊情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/820.wav", + "text": "比如現在國民法官判下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/821.wav", + "text": "被判七年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/822.wav", + "text": "在學界和實務界都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/823.wav", + "text": "這樣的判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/824.wav", + "text": "跟鄧如雯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/825.wav", + "text": "殺夫案比起來是不是有過苛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/826.wav", + "text": "未來這樣的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/827.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/828.wav", + "text": "願意聲請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/829.wav", + "text": "是不是在一開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/830.wav", + "text": "就要把他排除在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/831.wav", + "text": "是不是有過苛的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/832.wav", + "text": "可以考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/833.wav", + "text": "的是不是能夠訂一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/834.wav", + "text": "專業工作的審酌之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/835.wav", + "text": "再去做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/836.wav", + "text": "一定要積極去面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/837.wav", + "text": "這絕對不是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/838.wav", + "text": "今天外役監的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/839.wav", + "text": "所謂開放監獄的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/840.wav", + "text": "反而是讓這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/841.wav", + "text": "長刑期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/842.wav", + "text": "或中長刑期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/843.wav", + "text": "高度戒護的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/844.wav", + "text": "在他復歸社會之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/845.wav", + "text": "的機會如果是在這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/846.wav", + "text": "針對中高度刑期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/847.wav", + "text": "者以這樣的方式作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/848.wav", + "text": "這是一個很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/849.wav", + "text": "\n現在的問題就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/850.wav", + "text": "為什麼外役監制度不受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/851.wav", + "text": "大家的信賴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/852.wav", + "text": "周科長竟然還被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/853.wav", + "text": "在路上打他這還得了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/854.wav", + "text": "過瞭解之後發現原來這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/855.wav", + "text": "邵先生是作弊進去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/856.wav", + "text": "他根本就不應該進去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/857.wav", + "text": "但是他竟然可以過五關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/858.wav", + "text": "斬六將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/859.wav", + "text": "所以從這個地方也可以知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/860.wav", + "text": "部長你應該也非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/861.wav", + "text": "就是說搞到一個戒護科長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/862.wav", + "text": "收容人叫兄弟去打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/863.wav", + "text": "��所以你們的遴選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/864.wav", + "text": "制度本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/865.wav", + "text": "要有外部性然後要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/866.wav", + "text": "專業的社工心理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/867.wav", + "text": "並且事後能夠做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/868.wav", + "text": "樣未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/869.wav", + "text": "才能讓這樣的事情不致發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/870.wav", + "text": "我回應一下關於剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/871.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/872.wav", + "text": "那個部分剛好可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/873.wav", + "text": "過苛條款進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/874.wav", + "text": "去做一個調和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/875.wav", + "text": "是四級每個月縮刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/876.wav", + "text": "\n我們並不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/877.wav", + "text": "不要縮刑而是說不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/878.wav", + "text": "甚至當有一些權貴進去的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/879.wav", + "text": "全體國人都沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/880.wav", + "text": "就是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/881.wav", + "text": "它的特殊縮刑制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/882.wav", + "text": "差異實在太大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/883.wav", + "text": "多少人可以進去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/884.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/885.wav", + "text": "五萬五千名的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/886.wav", + "text": "收容人只有不到兩千人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/887.wav", + "text": "可以進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/888.wav", + "text": "剩下的五萬三千人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/889.wav", + "text": "是享受一個月縮刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/890.wav", + "text": "刑十六天超過半個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/891.wav", + "text": "所以你要怎麼解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/892.wav", + "text": "就是你不應該讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/893.wav", + "text": "有這麼大的差別待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/894.wav", + "text": "因為你的制度本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/895.wav", + "text": "是為了要讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/896.wav", + "text": "在出監之前的再社會化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/897.wav", + "text": "未來出監的生活所以你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/898.wav", + "text": "側重點應該是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/899.wav", + "text": "可以每天早上上班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/900.wav", + "text": "去作業回來跟人接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/901.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/902.wav", + "text": "有時候回去放假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/903.wav", + "text": "但並不是說在那邊就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/904.wav", + "text": "享受這麼高幅度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/905.wav", + "text": "刑如果這個東西還留著的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/906.wav", + "text": "五萬五千人爭取兩千名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/907.wav", + "text": "剩下五萬三千人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/908.wav", + "text": "眼睜睜的在那邊看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/909.wav", + "text": "看著到底誰到外��監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/910.wav", + "text": "所以這個問題還是會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/911.wav", + "text": "一直存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/912.wav", + "text": "我的問題很簡單就是剛才所提時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/913.wav", + "text": "時力黨團的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/914.wav", + "text": "在第4條第7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/915.wav", + "text": "款的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/916.wav", + "text": "是不是可以納入今天法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/917.wav", + "text": "協商建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/918.wav", + "text": "在第9款後面再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/919.wav", + "text": "這一款然後把它納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/920.wav", + "text": "我剛剛所說的放在第9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/921.wav", + "text": "好接下來請柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/922.wav", + "text": "院長指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/923.wav", + "text": "委員講到林信吾案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/924.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/925.wav", + "text": "把累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/926.wav", + "text": "不能進外役監的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/927.wav", + "text": "去除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/928.wav", + "text": "是在2020" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/929.wav", + "text": "的所以如果當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/930.wav", + "text": "沒有修那個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/931.wav", + "text": "他是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/932.wav", + "text": "本來就是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/933.wav", + "text": "他是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/934.wav", + "text": "他是搶奪超商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/935.wav", + "text": "而且都用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/936.wav", + "text": "搶了好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/937.wav", + "text": "這個請法務部回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/938.wav", + "text": "這個我會把它講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/939.wav", + "text": "所以他就是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/940.wav", + "text": "所謂累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/941.wav", + "text": "然後被送到外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/942.wav", + "text": "才能放假出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/943.wav", + "text": "做了那件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/944.wav", + "text": "所以就是累犯開了那個門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/945.wav", + "text": "他才能去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/946.wav", + "text": "那個時間序很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/947.wav", + "text": "2020" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/948.wav", + "text": "年把這個累犯開了後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/949.wav", + "text": "去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/950.wav", + "text": "累犯這個門要把它關起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/951.wav", + "text": "我們也支持縮刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/952.wav", + "text": "剛剛時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/953.wav", + "text": "力量黨團講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/954.wav", + "text": "不能有特別優惠的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/955.wav", + "text": "這個我們是表示支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/956.wav", + "text": "你就去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/957.wav", + "text": "已經讓���比較輕鬆了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/958.wav", + "text": "你知道外役監有多少好處嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/959.wav", + "text": "很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/960.wav", + "text": "耶他們去上班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/961.wav", + "text": "領的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/962.wav", + "text": "比一般監獄多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/963.wav", + "text": "三四倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/964.wav", + "text": "同樣做那些工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/965.wav", + "text": "工錢也比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/966.wav", + "text": "戒護都比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/967.wav", + "text": "然後又還可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/968.wav", + "text": "放假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/969.wav", + "text": "也可以找親屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/970.wav", + "text": "進到外役監的招待所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/971.wav", + "text": "去過夜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/972.wav", + "text": "還可以生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/973.wav", + "text": "有這麼多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/974.wav", + "text": "縮刑又特別快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/975.wav", + "text": "所以大家擠破頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/976.wav", + "text": "用盡各種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/977.wav", + "text": "特權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/978.wav", + "text": "金錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/979.wav", + "text": "想盡辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/980.wav", + "text": "進外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/981.wav", + "text": "目前很多權貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/982.wav", + "text": "都是在外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/983.wav", + "text": "所以這個已經造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/984.wav", + "text": "是非常不公的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/985.wav", + "text": "不能進外役監的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/986.wav", + "text": "剛剛邱顯智委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/987.wav", + "text": "五萬多受刑人有二千多人去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/988.wav", + "text": "結果都靠特權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/989.wav", + "text": "其他人就繼續苦哈哈地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/990.wav", + "text": "在一般的監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/991.wav", + "text": "有後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/992.wav", + "text": "走後門的人就去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/993.wav", + "text": "這樣可有公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/994.wav", + "text": "嗎而且還讓重刑犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/995.wav", + "text": "累犯都能去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/996.wav", + "text": "當然這個就是這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/997.wav", + "text": "主要要修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/998.wav", + "text": "社會輿論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/999.wav", + "text": "感覺一定要改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1000.wav", + "text": "最主要的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1001.wav", + "text": "版本如果我們認為是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1002.wav", + "text": "好的我們也會支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1003.wav", + "text": "比如剛剛講的縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1004.wav", + "text": "縮刑一般化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1005.wav", + "text": "跟一般的監獄一樣的縮刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1006.wav", + "text": "縮刑方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1007.wav", + "text": "及幅度這個我們支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1008.wav", + "text": "包括法務部剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1009.wav", + "text": "假釋前一年才能進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1010.wav", + "text": "外役監這個我們支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1011.wav", + "text": "現在的狀況是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1012.wav", + "text": "被判長期刑的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1013.wav", + "text": "譬如被判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1014.wav", + "text": "十年以上有期徒刑的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1015.wav", + "text": "服的刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1016.wav", + "text": "在一般監獄很短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1017.wav", + "text": "大部分時間都在外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1018.wav", + "text": "獄爽爽過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1019.wav", + "text": "重刑犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1020.wav", + "text": "主要的刑期是在外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1021.wav", + "text": "這樣講得通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1022.wav", + "text": "有達到什麼教化的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1023.wav", + "text": "\n因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1024.wav", + "text": "大家都講過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1025.wav", + "text": "是為了一個銜接處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1026.wav", + "text": "讓你回社會之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1027.wav", + "text": "讓你的社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1028.wav", + "text": "適應會更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1029.wav", + "text": "順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1030.wav", + "text": "好如果是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1031.wav", + "text": "那應該在你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1032.wav", + "text": "出獄之前的一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1033.wav", + "text": "而不是你刑期的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1034.wav", + "text": "大部分時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1035.wav", + "text": "都給你在外役監爽爽過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1036.wav", + "text": "所以我們也支持法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1037.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1038.wav", + "text": "假釋之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1039.wav", + "text": "出獄之前只有一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1040.wav", + "text": "才能去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1041.wav", + "text": "才有資格聲請去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1042.wav", + "text": "就是要給你銜接處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1043.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1044.wav", + "text": "用外役監代替一般的監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1045.wav", + "text": "給你服刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1046.wav", + "text": "嘛所以這個是原來立法的旨意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1047.wav", + "text": "現在已經被扭曲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1048.wav", + "text": "大家都變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1049.wav", + "text": "我要服刑這麼長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1050.wav", + "text": "我趕快聲請到外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1051.wav", + "text": "我有能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1052.wav", + "text": "我有背景我有後臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1053.wav", + "text": "我就去外役監服刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1054.wav", + "text": "其他沒有能力沒有背景的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1055.wav", + "text": "繼續在最苦的一般監獄服刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1056.wav", + "text": "目前是被扭曲成這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1057.wav", + "text": "如果沒有大魄力的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1058.wav", + "text": "讓這種情況繼續下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1059.wav", + "text": "人民不會接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1060.wav", + "text": "再講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1061.wav", + "text": "好的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1062.wav", + "text": "我們表示支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1063.wav", + "text": "如果能夠綜合出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1064.wav", + "text": "如果大家把法務部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1065.wav", + "text": "好的版本都把它放在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1066.wav", + "text": "變成一個大家共識版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1067.wav", + "text": "那最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1068.wav", + "text": "我們支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1069.wav", + "text": "我想今天我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1070.wav", + "text": "聚焦一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1071.wav", + "text": "我們談的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1072.wav", + "text": "尤其我聽了剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1073.wav", + "text": "各位所談的有很多誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1074.wav", + "text": "我先針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1075.wav", + "text": "林為洲所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1076.wav", + "text": "那個林信吾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1077.wav", + "text": "是不是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1078.wav", + "text": "我們談2020年那一次修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1079.wav", + "text": "就是凡累犯就不可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1080.wav", + "text": "犯罪行為是六個月以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1081.wav", + "text": "而且易科罰金的才可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1082.wav", + "text": "那一次2020年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1083.wav", + "text": "法案通過的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1084.wav", + "text": "是朝野沒有意見通過沒有透過表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1085.wav", + "text": "請各位看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1086.wav", + "text": "我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1087.wav", + "text": "被你們否決什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1088.wav", + "text": "沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1089.wav", + "text": "我們有版本你講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1090.wav", + "text": "處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1091.wav", + "text": "經濟犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1092.wav", + "text": "貪污犯那時候因為對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1093.wav", + "text": "大家還有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1094.wav", + "text": "所以那時候透過表決這兩個沒有過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1095.wav", + "text": "但是到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1096.wav", + "text": "但前一個的犯罪是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1097.wav", + "text": "那個沒有表決請不要忘記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1098.wav", + "text": "你也可以反對我們的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1099.wav", + "text": "到時候表決的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1100.wav", + "text": "不要用爭論的請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1101.wav", + "text": "輪流講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1102.wav", + "text": "輪流講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1103.wav", + "text": "這就是不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1104.wav", + "text": "你假如認為那時候我們這樣的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1105.wav", + "text": "情況是六個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1106.wav", + "text": "那你表決的時候可以反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1107.wav", + "text": "你沒有反對沒有一黨反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1108.wav", + "text": "這是第一個要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1109.wav", + "text": "林信吾的案子是因為累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1110.wav", + "text": "因為這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1111.wav", + "text": "累犯就是前一個犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1112.wav", + "text": "超過五年以後就不算累犯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1113.wav", + "text": "並不是引用這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1114.wav", + "text": "至於林信吾到底是不是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1115.wav", + "text": "等一下請法務部說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1116.wav", + "text": "總要把它弄清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1117.wav", + "text": "你知道關二分之一以後才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1118.wav", + "text": "那個就達假釋標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1119.wav", + "text": "可以報假釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1120.wav", + "text": "所以這一點你們版本寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1121.wav", + "text": "要關到三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1122.wav", + "text": "當然你也認同這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1123.wav", + "text": "你的版本是這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1124.wav", + "text": "毒駕致死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1125.wav", + "text": "這本來就是十年以上不能到外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1126.wav", + "text": "怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1127.wav", + "text": "你先看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1128.wav", + "text": "毒駕致死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1129.wav", + "text": "這個第2款裡面有故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1130.wav", + "text": "故意犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1131.wav", + "text": "然後有關於毒品的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1132.wav", + "text": "現在我們有關毒品犯罪的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1133.wav", + "text": "犯罪條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1134.wav", + "text": "已經修了製造運輸販賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1135.wav", + "text": "都是十年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1136.wav", + "text": "這些都不可能去外役監只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1137.wav", + "text": "這裡有排除條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1138.wav", + "text": "是自己食用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1139.wav", + "text": "或是持有種子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1140.wav", + "text": "那個才可以去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1141.wav", + "text": "所以我們要把版本弄清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1142.wav", + "text": "可以去的只有兩千多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1143.wav", + "text": "實上現在外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1144.wav", + "text": "有將近九個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1145.wav", + "text": "有三個專屬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1146.wav", + "text": "還有六個附設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1147.wav", + "text": "它現在可以裝兩千多個還沒有關滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1148.wav", + "text": "有特權才可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1149.wav", + "text": "什麼樣才可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1150.wav", + "text": "外役監還沒有滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1151.wav", + "text": "就是你沒有把條文看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1152.wav", + "text": "它是有門檻的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1153.wav", + "text": "雖然兩個月就可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1154.wav", + "text": "但是他要累進處遇有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1155.wav", + "text": "一二三四共四級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1156.wav", + "text": "七年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1157.wav", + "text": "七年到十五年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1158.wav", + "text": "要累進處遇三級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1159.wav", + "text": "十五年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1160.wav", + "text": "的累進處遇二級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1161.wav", + "text": "無期徒刑比較重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1162.wav", + "text": "要累進處遇一級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1163.wav", + "text": "所以它有經過汰選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1164.wav", + "text": "並不是如邱顯智所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1165.wav", + "text": "難道我們自己當立法者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1166.wav", + "text": "云把這個一直污衊化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1167.wav", + "text": "我們面對外役監條例的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1168.wav", + "text": "我們可以很冷靜來思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1169.wav", + "text": "當然因為非典型的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1170.wav", + "text": "造成我們社會很shock" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1171.wav", + "text": "大家來修我是贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1172.wav", + "text": "但是講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1173.wav", + "text": "還有邱顯智剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1174.wav", + "text": "有幾個是列舉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1175.wav", + "text": "這裡寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1176.wav", + "text": "因為你反對罪名OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1177.wav", + "text": "可是你的版本也有寫罪名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1178.wav", + "text": "你的版本還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1179.wav", + "text": "你列舉刑法第106條毒品性侵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1180.wav", + "text": "那個那是本來的法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1181.wav", + "text": "我的版本裡面有兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1182.wav", + "text": "列舉上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1183.wav", + "text": "我要跟你解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1184.wav", + "text": "我的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1185.wav", + "text": "的罪就是貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1186.wav", + "text": "和重大經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1187.wav", + "text": "是哪一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1188.wav", + "text": "列舉的是本來的第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1189.wav", + "text": "你把新的版本拿來給大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1190.wav", + "text": "這樣大家要怎麼溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1191.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法對焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1192.wav", + "text": "前項限制於個案上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1193.wav", + "text": "有過苛之虞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1194.wav", + "text": "逾越所欲達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1195.wav", + "text": "矯正處遇目的之必要限度者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1196.wav", + "text": "法務部得依受刑人之聲請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1197.wav", + "text": "你在這裡又開一個門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1198.wav", + "text": "了我不知道這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1199.wav", + "text": "裡面第6條也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1200.wav", + "text": "監獄行刑法裡面也有縮刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1201.wav", + "text": "你怎麼不講呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1202.wav", + "text": "縮刑回歸到監獄行刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1203.wav", + "text": "跟累進處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1204.wav", + "text": "全部不可以修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1205.wav", + "text": "因為在外役監條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1206.wav", + "text": "不是我剛剛講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1207.wav", + "text": "回歸到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1208.wav", + "text": "錄影帶可以倒回去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1209.wav", + "text": "縮刑是不公平的對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1210.wav", + "text": "對其他的收容人不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1211.wav", + "text": "那是以後有關於假釋的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1212.wav", + "text": "我們要把不同的法弄清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1213.wav", + "text": "我我們現在講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1214.wav", + "text": "我們現在講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1215.wav", + "text": "大家不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1216.wav", + "text": "然後把這個一直污名化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1217.wav", + "text": "可以理性討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1218.wav", + "text": "一條一條來沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1219.wav", + "text": "一路修到現在第6次修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1220.wav", + "text": "我們要採取什麼立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1221.wav", + "text": "提的再修正案版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1222.wav", + "text": "已經非常嚴苛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1223.wav", + "text": "我們應該有一個對焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1224.wav", + "text": "現在我們提出來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1225.wav", + "text": "要加重詐欺罪的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1226.wav", + "text": "以前沒有看到這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1227.wav", + "text": "它修正進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1228.wav", + "text": "包括大家所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1229.wav", + "text": "不管是白領階級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1230.wav", + "text": "一定要繳回犯罪所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1231.wav", + "text": "這個我們也放進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1232.wav", + "text": "所以我們要在一個軌道上來談事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1233.wav", + "text": "現在大家不要講好聽的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1234.wav", + "text": "用2020年的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1235.wav", + "text": "去的���家都這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1236.wav", + "text": "為什麼不反對表決不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1237.wav", + "text": "所以我希望大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1238.wav", + "text": "能夠在一個軌道上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1239.wav", + "text": "對焦談話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1240.wav", + "text": "請張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1241.wav", + "text": "其祿委員結束後就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1242.wav", + "text": "劉建國委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1243.wav", + "text": "我在程序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1244.wav", + "text": "還是先建議大家走快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1245.wav", + "text": "因為這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1246.wav", + "text": "已經一個多小時對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1247.wav", + "text": "一個多小時了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1248.wav", + "text": "我還是談一下針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1249.wav", + "text": "的第4條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1250.wav", + "text": "提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1251.wav", + "text": "第2項第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1252.wav", + "text": "跟第9款就是這兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1253.wav", + "text": "其實我想是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1254.wav", + "text": "直白點就是國人當然這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1255.wav", + "text": "為什麼在外面那麼期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1256.wav", + "text": "大家要修正這一次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1257.wav", + "text": "外役監條例其實最主要就是這兩種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1258.wav", + "text": "我直說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1259.wav", + "text": "一個就是貪污罪的這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1260.wav", + "text": "一個就是重大經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1261.wav", + "text": "其實大家就覺得說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1262.wav", + "text": "這些人背後的關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1263.wav", + "text": "比較是什麼就是權勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1264.wav", + "text": "嘛就是有權有勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1265.wav", + "text": "嘛這些人才有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1266.wav", + "text": "其實從第8款第9款來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1267.wav", + "text": "其實法務部這邊建議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1268.wav", + "text": "尤其他是已經要列到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1269.wav", + "text": "貪污治罪條例第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1270.wav", + "text": "7年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1271.wav", + "text": "那你們提供的第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1272.wav", + "text": "犯證券交易法等等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1273.wav", + "text": "到最後也是很明確地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1274.wav", + "text": "是本刑7年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1275.wav", + "text": "而且這些再細查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1276.wav", + "text": "他們貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1277.wav", + "text": "所以基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1278.wav", + "text": "其實外界對我們在乎的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1279.wav", + "text": "就是這種貪污的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1280.wav", + "text": "這種重大經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1281.wav", + "text": "這些有權有勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1282.wav", + "text": "不過我這邊還是要提一個點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1283.wav", + "text": "跟本黨就是民眾黨這邊不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1284.wav", + "text": "因為你們這邊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1285.wav", + "text": "這麼重大罪刑的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1286.wav", + "text": "了但是只要繳回所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1287.wav", + "text": "他們也是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1288.wav", + "text": "有這個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1289.wav", + "text": "坦白說我是覺得如果我們這次真的要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1290.wav", + "text": "修比較能夠回應整個社會觀感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1291.wav", + "text": "其實民眾黨這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1292.wav", + "text": "提的是很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1293.wav", + "text": "犯這兩種的就沒有機會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1294.wav", + "text": "就不要讓他們去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1295.wav", + "text": "啦這樣子就結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1296.wav", + "text": "治罪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1297.wav", + "text": "或是重大經濟犯罪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1298.wav", + "text": "那也不要管你有沒有繳回了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1299.wav", + "text": "大概就是沒有機會去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1300.wav", + "text": "不然的話到時候又發現哪些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1301.wav", + "text": "又可以坐爽監這才是真問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1302.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1303.wav", + "text": "好接下來就劉建國委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1304.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1305.wav", + "text": "我第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1306.wav", + "text": "我要在這邊特別把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1307.wav", + "text": "整個審查外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1308.wav", + "text": "跟各位做個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1309.wav", + "text": "那我希望大家回歸到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1310.wav", + "text": "針對我們已經在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1311.wav", + "text": "修正條文大家可能再細看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1312.wav", + "text": "我們就是在7月20日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1313.wav", + "text": "就已經在委員會審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1314.wav", + "text": "然後出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1315.wav", + "text": "也絕對不是隨隨便便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1316.wav", + "text": "也是考量到很多面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1317.wav", + "text": "向當然有的沒有共識就只好保留協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1318.wav", + "text": "\n各位可以看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1319.wav", + "text": "現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1320.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1321.wav", + "text": "不得遴選的原有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1322.wav", + "text": "好行政院再提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1323.wav", + "text": "提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1324.wav", + "text": "其實它6款增加到13款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1325.wav", + "text": "不得遴選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1326.wav", + "text": "現在增加到幾款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1327.wav", + "text": "現在增加到15款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1328.wav", + "text": "那15款剛剛柯總召有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1329.wav", + "text": "原有的不得遴選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1330.wav", + "text": "第106條之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1331.wav", + "text": "你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1332.wav", + "text": "我們不是把第106條抄過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1333.wav", + "text": "我們的第106條裡面現在對照最新的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1334.wav", + "text": "是犯刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1335.wav", + "text": "第4項後段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1336.wav", + "text": "第103條第2項致重傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1337.wav", + "text": "才有第106條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1338.wav", + "text": "再來是第302條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1339.wav", + "text": "第1項第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1340.wav", + "text": "這些樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1341.wav", + "text": "不是多增加15款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1342.wav", + "text": "我跟各位報告如果各位可以細看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1343.wav", + "text": "你就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1344.wav", + "text": "多的是N倍以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1345.wav", + "text": "是不得遴選的喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1346.wav", + "text": "我不曉得執行機關有沒有辦法去落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1347.wav", + "text": "因為我剛才聽林為洲委員這麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1348.wav", + "text": "邱顯智總召這麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1349.wav", + "text": "我真的有點錯亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1350.wav", + "text": "邱總召所講的是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1351.wav", + "text": "外役監條例是好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1352.wav", + "text": "基本上是遴選的問題上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1353.wav", + "text": "出現了很多不公平的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1354.wav", + "text": "然後再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1355.wav", + "text": "就是在縮刑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1356.wav", + "text": "那縮刑的部分為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1357.wav", + "text": "外役監跟一般的執行監會不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1358.wav", + "text": "我想當時的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1359.wav", + "text": "原意是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1360.wav", + "text": "這個矯正署必須要說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1361.wav", + "text": "不然這樣我覺得好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1362.wav", + "text": "一直沒辦法對焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1363.wav", + "text": "剛剛我又聽林為洲委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1364.wav", + "text": "去外役監統統有特權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1365.wav", + "text": "爽爽過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1366.wav", + "text": "如果再持續這樣講下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1367.wav", + "text": "部長跟署長可以坐在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1368.wav", + "text": "坐得這麼鎮靜我覺得莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1369.wav", + "text": "因為外役監可以有特權去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1370.wav", + "text": "那一定是執行機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1371.wav", + "text": "容許這樣的特權嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1372.wav", + "text": "所以是要跟全國百姓說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1373.wav", + "text": "二千個左右在外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1374.wav", + "text": "統統都是法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1375.wav", + "text": "矯正署給他們特權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1376.wav", + "text": "以謝國人啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1377.wav", + "text": "不用再討論什麼個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1378.wav", + "text": "不要再用誰的案子來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1379.wav", + "text": "今天整個協商針對法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1380.wav", + "text": "因為這全部都有特權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1381.wav", + "text": "你再怎麼修都沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1382.wav", + "text": "因為你修得再怎麼廣泛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1383.wav", + "text": "從六款不得遴選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1384.wav", + "text": "變成十二變成十五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1385.wav", + "text": "變成擴大到N倍以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1386.wav", + "text": "大家還討論這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1387.wav", + "text": "最後有結論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1388.wav", + "text": "特權會不會再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1389.wav", + "text": "如果特權會再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1390.wav", + "text": "我們今天討論這個要幹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1391.wav", + "text": "本來就不會有特權發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1392.wav", + "text": "我也希望他們能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1393.wav", + "text": "透過什麼樣的模式讓大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1394.wav", + "text": "整個外役監的遴選制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1395.wav", + "text": "是社會大眾可以接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1396.wav", + "text": "不會再發生這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1397.wav", + "text": "所以我在看法條的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1398.wav", + "text": "中現行條文六款不得遴選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1399.wav", + "text": "款現在要再修正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1400.wav", + "text": "林林總總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1401.wav", + "text": "我剛剛實在是算不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1402.wav", + "text": "絕對不止十五款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1403.wav", + "text": "啦\n部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1404.wav", + "text": "有機會就應該趁機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1405.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1406.wav", + "text": "我覺得在整個討論過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1407.wav", + "text": "我們就聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1408.wav", + "text": "在這個修正版本來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1409.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員剛才提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1410.wav", + "text": "就是違反廢棄物清理法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1411.wav", + "text": "破壞整個臺灣土地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1412.wav", + "text": "污染整個土地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1413.wav", + "text": "他的這些不法犯罪所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1414.wav", + "text": "他才有辦法進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1415.wav", + "text": "這個我接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1416.wav", + "text": "像這個還要再加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1417.wav", + "text": "要這樣處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1418.wav", + "text": "我也沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1419.wav", + "text": "但我要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1420.wav", + "text": "的是如果一直講去外役監的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1421.wav", + "text": "我覺得部長跟署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1422.wav", + "text": "要以謝國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1423.wav", + "text": "根本不是這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1424.wav", + "text": "因為我第一次說好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1425.wav", + "text": "部長跟署長我不會生氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1426.wav", + "text": "那一天也是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1427.wav", + "text": "討論了一段時間沒辦法有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1428.wav", + "text": "我們才保留出委員會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1429.wav", + "text": "一出委員會協商比那天保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1430.wav", + "text": "多一倍的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1431.wav", + "text": "你告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1432.wav", + "text": "刑法第103條第4項後段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1433.wav", + "text": "是什麼罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1434.wav", + "text": "第103條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1435.wav", + "text": "才會到第106條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1436.wav", + "text": "就原有的現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1437.wav", + "text": "嘛再來第302條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1438.wav", + "text": "第1項第2項後段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1439.wav", + "text": "第303條第302條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1440.wav", + "text": "第1項這是在說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1441.wav", + "text": "這些範圍納入裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1442.wav", + "text": "各位委員今天在這邊協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1443.wav", + "text": "大家知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1444.wav", + "text": "法務部有跟我們說明清楚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1445.wav", + "text": "這些可以納入不得遴選的範圍裡面嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1446.wav", + "text": "我們都還沒說到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1447.wav", + "text": "能快點聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1448.wav", + "text": "大家有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1449.wav", + "text": "快改變這個制度\n有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1450.wav", + "text": "縮刑我認為矯正署有必要說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1451.wav", + "text": "為什麼外役監跟一般執行監不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1452.wav", + "text": "現在外役監真的是爽爽過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1453.wav", + "text": "我相信兩千個或是五萬五千個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1454.wav", + "text": "受刑人不管在一般監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1455.wav", + "text": "執行或是在外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1456.wav", + "text": "我們或多或少都有認識的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1457.wav", + "text": "可以問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1458.wav", + "text": "像現在這種天氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1459.wav", + "text": "極端氣候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1460.wav", + "text": "外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1461.wav", + "text": "工作廠址" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1462.wav", + "text": "址跟一般監獄的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1463.wav", + "text": "工廠一樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1464.wav", + "text": "這個大家要說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1465.wav", + "text": "因為不是故意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1466.wav", + "text": "或者怎麼樣可能在某個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1467.wav", + "text": "有經歷過這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1468.wav", + "text": "要把這個東西講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1469.wav", + "text": "我也希望法務部長跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1470.wav", + "text": "署長有空檔你們就要說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1471.wav", + "text": "不然我會覺得你們一直以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1472.wav", + "text": "都是在縱容特權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1473.wav", + "text": "還是在幫助特權分子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1474.wav", + "text": "讓這些人去那邊什麼爽爽過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1475.wav", + "text": "好好過我絕對不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1476.wav", + "text": "而且我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1477.wav", + "text": "講的話和自己版本要一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1478.wav", + "text": "到底我們在這邊幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1479.wav", + "text": "完後讓法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1480.wav", + "text": "現在請莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1481.wav", + "text": "如果有意見現在就要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1482.wav", + "text": "其實我也反而會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1483.wav", + "text": "法務部今天把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1484.wav", + "text": "這些放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1485.wav", + "text": "這樣把它加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1486.wav", + "text": "他們也是要回應社會期待問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1487.wav", + "text": "我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1488.wav", + "text": "今天的表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1489.wav", + "text": "我如果當法務部官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1490.wav", + "text": "我反而要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1491.wav", + "text": "假設我今天20歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1492.wav", + "text": "我去殺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1493.wav", + "text": "關了20年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1494.wav", + "text": "回到這個社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1495.wav", + "text": "在第4年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1496.wav", + "text": "判3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1497.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1498.wav", + "text": "假設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1499.wav", + "text": "邱顯智" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1500.wav", + "text": "他跟我一樣都去詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1501.wav", + "text": "他不能去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1502.wav", + "text": "我在6年前才出獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1503.wav", + "text": "獄20年前我殺人被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1504.wav", + "text": "被關了20年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1505.wav", + "text": "第6年去詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1506.wav", + "text": "他在4年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1507.wav", + "text": "罵你被判2個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1508.wav", + "text": "詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1509.wav", + "text": "所以你們一直把累犯污名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1510.wav", + "text": "化我認為我們當中的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1511.wav", + "text": "根本就不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1512.wav", + "text": "什麼叫累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1513.wav", + "text": "受刑執行完畢以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1514.wav", + "text": "一部之執行受到赦免以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1515.wav", + "text": "5年內再犯有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1516.wav", + "text": "如果今天犯罪明天犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1517.wav", + "text": "後天犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1518.wav", + "text": "之後又再犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1519.wav", + "text": "這不叫作累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1520.wav", + "text": "加重其刑二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1521.wav", + "text": "累犯是在講這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1522.wav", + "text": "我知道你的心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1523.wav", + "text": "是在回應外界社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1524.wav", + "text": "這個不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1525.wav", + "text": "但是還是要回復到本質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1526.wav", + "text": "監獄行刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1527.wav", + "text": "針對犯人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1528.wav", + "text": "判20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1529.wav", + "text": "那叫作報復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1530.wav", + "text": "嘛聯合國決議一出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1531.wav", + "text": "就說不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1532.wav", + "text": "後我們也有假釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1533.wav", + "text": "者趕快讓他回復到社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1534.wav", + "text": "\n刑事政策犯罪學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1535.wav", + "text": "都不用教育刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1536.wav", + "text": "我也沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1537.wav", + "text": "要負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1538.wav", + "text": "今天時代力量提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1539.wav", + "text": "或各政黨提的民眾黨提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1540.wav", + "text": "有一些其實我覺得都很不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1541.wav", + "text": "我們來回應社會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1542.wav", + "text": "毒品等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1543.wav", + "text": "報復的性質比較重一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1544.wav", + "text": "這個我接受但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1545.wav", + "text": "是比如我剛剛舉的例很輕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1546.wav", + "text": "然後犯詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1547.wav", + "text": "你剝奪邱顯智去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1548.wav", + "text": "的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1549.wav", + "text": "我可以去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1550.wav", + "text": "我6年啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1551.wav", + "text": "啦就不是累犯啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1552.wav", + "text": "我去犯了一個詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1553.wav", + "text": "當然你要給我到外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1554.wav", + "text": "可是他之前才被判2個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1555.wav", + "text": "結果跟我一樣犯詐欺有夠衰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1556.wav", + "text": "他都不能去啊那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1557.wav", + "text": "到底是我比較適合去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1558.wav", + "text": "還是他比較適合去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1559.wav", + "text": "當然是邱顯智比較適合啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1560.wav", + "text": "你這個是自我矛盾耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1561.wav", + "text": "他已經服刑完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1562.wav", + "text": "超過5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1563.wav", + "text": "不就等於無罪之身了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1564.wav", + "text": "你還在講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1565.wav", + "text": "你一直在講累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1566.wav", + "text": "你根本就不知道什麼叫累犯啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1567.wav", + "text": "啊那就按照累犯不能去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1568.wav", + "text": "累犯不能去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1569.wav", + "text": "原來行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1570.wav", + "text": "我們這個法一訂下去以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1571.wav", + "text": "法學教授沒辦法教書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1572.wav", + "text": "下來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1573.wav", + "text": "這些就是要讓法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1574.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席及各位委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1575.wav", + "text": "我還是要說明一下外役監當初立法的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1576.wav", + "text": "主要就是要讓受刑人在離開之前有一個中間處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1577.wav", + "text": "而不純粹只是報復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1578.wav", + "text": "就是他犯了刑之後就讓他受處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1579.wav", + "text": "到整個期滿為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1580.wav", + "text": "這是我們設立外役監的真正目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1581.wav", + "text": "\n當初我們提出行政院版本的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1582.wav", + "text": "其實只是著重在重大的暴力犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1583.wav", + "text": "還有高再犯高逃亡的犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1584.wav", + "text": "當初我們是這樣設定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1585.wav", + "text": "所以很快速地提出條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1586.wav", + "text": "也經過行政院同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1587.wav", + "text": "送到大院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1588.wav", + "text": "送到大院後也經過司法及法制委員會的審查兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1589.wav", + "text": "再開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1590.wav", + "text": "那時就有很多不同的意見再加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1591.wav", + "text": "我們也聆聽各位的意見後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1592.wav", + "text": "再將它做一個調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1593.wav", + "text": "再將它納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1594.wav", + "text": "包括積極的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1595.wav", + "text": "他必須要坐滿三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1596.wav", + "text": "累犯的話要二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1597.wav", + "text": "為什麼要訂三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1598.wav", + "text": "如果訂二分之一的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1599.wav", + "text": "根本就不會再申���去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1600.wav", + "text": "三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1601.wav", + "text": "因為離二分之一假釋前還有一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1602.wav", + "text": "\n除了這個要件之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1603.wav", + "text": "還要一個要件就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1604.wav", + "text": "假釋前一年才可以申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1605.wav", + "text": "不像現在是2個月就可以申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1606.wav", + "text": "太短了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1607.wav", + "text": "尤其他很長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1608.wav", + "text": "大部分時間都在外役監這也不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1609.wav", + "text": "一定要在假釋或期滿前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1610.wav", + "text": "1年才有資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1611.wav", + "text": "這個是積極的要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1612.wav", + "text": "\n關於消極的要件哪些不可以去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1613.wav", + "text": "哇這個意見真的很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1614.wav", + "text": "6款而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1615.wav", + "text": "後來我們初步提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1616.wav", + "text": "變成13款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1617.wav", + "text": "現在綜合大家的意見以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1618.wav", + "text": "15款裡面又涵蓋了很多的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1619.wav", + "text": "大家的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1620.wav", + "text": "大家認為貪污罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1621.wav", + "text": "應該要放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1622.wav", + "text": "那我們也從善如流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1623.wav", + "text": "我們也想辦法把它納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1624.wav", + "text": "而納進去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1625.wav", + "text": "再給他一個機會就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1626.wav", + "text": "不管是重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1627.wav", + "text": "經濟犯罪或是貪污的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1628.wav", + "text": "他能夠把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1629.wav", + "text": "犯罪所得繳出來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1630.wav", + "text": "我聽到很多委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1631.wav", + "text": "是認為可以讓他有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1632.wav", + "text": "也到外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1633.wav", + "text": "因為他也許跟其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1634.wav", + "text": "犯罪人一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1635.wav", + "text": "有自新的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1636.wav", + "text": "\n至於縮刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1637.wav", + "text": "的部分就是讓收容人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1638.wav", + "text": "激勵的作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1639.wav", + "text": "我好好在這邊悔過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1640.wav", + "text": "遵守規定的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1641.wav", + "text": "可以讓刑期縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1642.wav", + "text": "讓他培養一些自我管理的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1643.wav", + "text": "提早回歸社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1644.wav", + "text": "做一個有用的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1645.wav", + "text": "這也是我們當初立了縮刑的一個目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1646.wav", + "text": "在外役監的縮刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1647.wav", + "text": "跟在一般監獄的縮刑差距太大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1648.wav", + "text": "我們也看到這個問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1649.wav", + "text": "該怎麼樣做一個調合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1650.wav", + "text": "我們也希望能夠折衷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1651.wav", + "text": "但是這個又涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1652.wav", + "text": "累進處遇條例的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1653.wav", + "text": "我們現在已經著手在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1654.wav", + "text": "修累進處遇條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1655.wav", + "text": "要讓它合理化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1656.wav", + "text": "讓外役監跟一般監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1657.wav", + "text": "不要差距那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1658.wav", + "text": "甚至也可以一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1659.wav", + "text": "這也是我們在思考的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1660.wav", + "text": "\n我先簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1661.wav", + "text": "希望大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1662.wav", + "text": "也能夠有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1663.wav", + "text": "能夠早日的修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1664.wav", + "text": "當然還有很多需要改正的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1665.wav", + "text": "我們這樣的修法誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1666.wav", + "text": "也回應社會的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1667.wav", + "text": "未來我們還會逐步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1668.wav", + "text": "再做進一步的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1669.wav", + "text": "改善跟修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1670.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1671.wav", + "text": "犯罪那邊要加進去請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1672.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1673.wav", + "text": "建議關於環境法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1674.wav", + "text": "的部分因為涵蓋的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1675.wav", + "text": "範圍看起來也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1676.wav", + "text": "很大而且它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1677.wav", + "text": "文字也不是那麼嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1678.wav", + "text": "我們現在還在思考到底要哪邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1679.wav", + "text": "納進去或是看看委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1680.wav", + "text": "們的意見如果真的要納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1681.wav", + "text": "大家有共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1682.wav", + "text": "我們再把它找出來看怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1683.wav", + "text": "的條文合適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1684.wav", + "text": "\n基本上我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1685.wav", + "text": "有一個死亡結果了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1686.wav", + "text": "不管你是什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1687.wav", + "text": "只要發生死亡結果在我們第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1688.wav", + "text": "就已經排除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1689.wav", + "text": "不管你是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1690.wav", + "text": "故意而造成死亡���結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1691.wav", + "text": "或者本來就是殺人的故意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1692.wav", + "text": "造成死亡結果只要死亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1693.wav", + "text": "就已經排除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1694.wav", + "text": "毒駕也是一樣有造成死亡結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1695.wav", + "text": "或是酒駕有造成死亡結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1696.wav", + "text": "第1款就已經排除掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1697.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1698.wav", + "text": "我想不需要再另外加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1699.wav", + "text": "同樣的10年以上有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1700.wav", + "text": "的重大犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1701.wav", + "text": "也已經排除掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1702.wav", + "text": "委員有一些看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1703.wav", + "text": "其實都已經納在這裡面了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1704.wav", + "text": "以上補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1705.wav", + "text": "現在就照剛才的順序先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1706.wav", + "text": "請為洲再來是邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1707.wav", + "text": "結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1708.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1709.wav", + "text": "不容易達到共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1710.wav", + "text": "我們本來期待共識版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1711.wav", + "text": "各黨團有共識版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1712.wav", + "text": "到禮拜一來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1713.wav", + "text": "但是看起來很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1714.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得這一次外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1715.wav", + "text": "條例的修法主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1716.wav", + "text": "外界的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1717.wav", + "text": "還有外界的爭點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1718.wav", + "text": "就是外界認為現在的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1719.wav", + "text": "要解決什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1720.wav", + "text": "而我把它歸納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1721.wav", + "text": "所以我們國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1722.wav", + "text": "歸納出來我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1723.wav", + "text": "這一次外役監條例的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1724.wav", + "text": "要達到以下三個目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1725.wav", + "text": "否則就是失敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1726.wav", + "text": "就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1727.wav", + "text": "回應外界的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1728.wav", + "text": "以及外界的批評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1729.wav", + "text": "修一些有的沒的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1730.wav", + "text": "無關緊要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1731.wav", + "text": "而人家期待的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1732.wav", + "text": "臨時會來修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1733.wav", + "text": "就是因為外界殷切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1734.wav", + "text": "講話了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1735.wav", + "text": "臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1736.wav", + "text": "這要解決什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1737.wav", + "text": "行政院通過的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1738.wav", + "text": "中累犯是不能到外役監的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1739.wav", + "text": "2020" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1740.wav", + "text": "年被修掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1741.wav", + "text": "累犯可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1742.wav", + "text": "2020年開始的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1743.wav", + "text": "的要講就講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1744.wav", + "text": "這是怎麼修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1745.wav", + "text": "的我唸給大家聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1746.wav", + "text": "其中的奧妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1747.wav", + "text": "原來的條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1748.wav", + "text": "累犯不能接受遴選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1749.wav", + "text": "但已執行完畢之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1750.wav", + "text": "案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1751.wav", + "text": "有期徒刑之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1752.wav", + "text": "宣告者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1753.wav", + "text": "意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1754.wav", + "text": "罪是6個月以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1755.wav", + "text": "比較輕的罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1756.wav", + "text": "且執行完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1757.wav", + "text": "這樣的累犯不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1758.wav", + "text": "可以繼續去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1759.wav", + "text": "結果第一個使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1760.wav", + "text": "此法條的叫做李清福" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1761.wav", + "text": "他第一次犯的罪是6個月以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1762.wav", + "text": "的你知道他第二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1763.wav", + "text": "犯的罪是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1764.wav", + "text": "是貪污罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1765.wav", + "text": "判了10年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1766.wav", + "text": "他反而可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1767.wav", + "text": "大家可以接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1768.wav", + "text": "它只規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1769.wav", + "text": "上一次犯的罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1770.wav", + "text": "累犯前一次所犯的罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1771.wav", + "text": "就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1772.wav", + "text": "但它不規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1773.wav", + "text": "現在所犯的罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1774.wav", + "text": "也要是輕罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1775.wav", + "text": "才能進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1776.wav", + "text": "這反而是放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1777.wav", + "text": "刑期更長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1778.wav", + "text": "反而可以進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1779.wav", + "text": "役監這才是讓社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1780.wav", + "text": "過去犯的罪比較輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1781.wav", + "text": "現在犯的罪比較重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1782.wav", + "text": "反而可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1783.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1784.wav", + "text": "所以我們堅定支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1785.wav", + "text": "恢復到2020年之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1786.wav", + "text": "不能進外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1787.wav", + "text": "剛剛有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1788.wav", + "text": "也不能給他去外役監嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1789.wav", + "text": "我跟你們講如果是輕罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1790.wav", + "text": "刑期都很短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1791.wav", + "text": "進不進外役監的差別沒那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1792.wav", + "text": "進外役監差別大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1793.wav", + "text": "都是刑期長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1794.wav", + "text": "因為它有縮減刑期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1795.wav", + "text": "如果都是犯輕罪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1796.wav", + "text": "累犯其實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1797.wav", + "text": "一般監獄跟去外役監的差異不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1798.wav", + "text": "因為關的時間不長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1799.wav", + "text": "嘛可能時間到就假釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1800.wav", + "text": "他們就不一定要去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1801.wav", + "text": "凡是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1802.wav", + "text": "就不要讓他去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1803.wav", + "text": "我想這不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1804.wav", + "text": "錯殺無辜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1805.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我們認為累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1806.wav", + "text": "不得去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1807.wav", + "text": "這個後門不要開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1808.wav", + "text": "了不要開起來讓累犯還可以去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1809.wav", + "text": "重刑犯不得去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1810.wav", + "text": "以前也沒有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1811.wav", + "text": "重刑犯殺人犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1812.wav", + "text": "殺人犯還可以去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1813.wav", + "text": "而且在外役監裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1814.wav", + "text": "很長的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1815.wav", + "text": "所以重刑犯不得去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1816.wav", + "text": "當然這次法務部的版本都有納入了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1817.wav", + "text": "本刑10年以上或是7年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1818.wav", + "text": "這個大家可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1819.wav", + "text": "我們的版本是犯本刑7年以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1820.wav", + "text": "重刑犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1821.wav", + "text": "殺人犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1822.wav", + "text": "重大的經濟犯罪案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1823.wav", + "text": "及一些槍砲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1824.wav", + "text": "等只要是重刑犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1825.wav", + "text": "第三個重點我快要講完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1826.wav", + "text": "在釋放出獄前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1827.wav", + "text": "不管是假釋或是一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1828.wav", + "text": "剛剛法務部部長也講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1829.wav", + "text": "外役監的用意不是代替" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1830.wav", + "text": "一般監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1831.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1832.wav", + "text": "你們也說得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1833.wav", + "text": "可是現在的情況是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1834.wav", + "text": "刑期越長的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1835.wav", + "text": "在外役監越長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1836.wav", + "text": "他等於用外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1837.wav", + "text": "在代替一般監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1838.wav", + "text": "這樣比較輕鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1839.wav", + "text": "現在的事實是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1840.wav", + "text": "子所以這一定要處理要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1841.wav", + "text": "不是用外役監來代替" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1842.wav", + "text": "一般監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1843.wav", + "text": "這個你自己講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1844.wav", + "text": "不是這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1845.wav", + "text": "是要給你中間處遇進到社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1846.wav", + "text": "儘快回到正常生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1847.wav", + "text": "所以只要1年就夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1848.wav", + "text": "你需要給他在那邊很多年嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1849.wav", + "text": "所以這個我們也支持法務部的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1850.wav", + "text": "就是你在出獄之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1851.wav", + "text": "不管是假釋或是一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1852.wav", + "text": "沒有假釋出獄之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1853.wav", + "text": "一年才能申請去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1854.wav", + "text": "就達到中間處遇的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1855.wav", + "text": "以上我再重複一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1856.wav", + "text": "累犯不得去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1857.wav", + "text": "我們要把這個後門關起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1858.wav", + "text": "重刑犯不得去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1859.wav", + "text": "刑期7年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1860.wav", + "text": "的重刑犯不得去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1861.wav", + "text": "不得遴選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1862.wav", + "text": "再來出獄前一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1863.wav", + "text": "才能去外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1864.wav", + "text": "符合外役監設立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1865.wav", + "text": "剛剛也有其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1866.wav", + "text": "這個設定條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1867.wav", + "text": "消極條件這樣會有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1868.wav", + "text": "有一些不衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1869.wav", + "text": "平或是輕重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1870.wav", + "text": "不平衡的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1871.wav", + "text": "是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1872.wav", + "text": "啦所以反而應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1873.wav", + "text": "遴選制度要去改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1874.wav", + "text": "問題就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1875.wav", + "text": "遴選制度就是人治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1876.wav", + "text": "遴選委員是哪一些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1877.wav", + "text": "遴選過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1878.wav", + "text": "怎麼遴選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1879.wav", + "text": "怎麼評分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1880.wav", + "text": "這個就是受到社會質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1881.wav", + "text": "所以我們才要用法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1882.wav", + "text": "的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1883.wav", + "text": "先把法定在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1884.wav", + "text": "這樣才不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1885.wav", + "text": "弊端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1886.wav", + "text": "這不就是改革的目的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1887.wav", + "text": "如果再回到說我們來研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1888.wav", + "text": "遴選把遴選看能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1889.wav", + "text": "弄好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1890.wav", + "text": "那有達到改革的目的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1891.wav", + "text": "大家真的這樣開完會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1892.wav", + "text": "將來的遴選制度嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1893.wav", + "text": "之前不相信現在就能比較相信嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1894.wav", + "text": "框架先框起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1895.wav", + "text": "其他還是有遴選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1896.wav", + "text": "餘地還是要經過遴選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1897.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1898.wav", + "text": "接下來請邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1899.wav", + "text": "謝院長各位同仁部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1900.wav", + "text": "剛才部長也講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1901.wav", + "text": "說有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1902.wav", + "text": "外役監條例第十四條有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1903.wav", + "text": "的縮刑這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1904.wav", + "text": "跟一般的累進處遇的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1905.wav", + "text": "差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1906.wav", + "text": "這裡有一個問題就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1907.wav", + "text": "剛剛其實林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1908.wav", + "text": "或柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1909.wav", + "text": "其他委員也有一直在提到部長也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1910.wav", + "text": "其實外役監的特性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1911.wav", + "text": "就是中間處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1912.wav", + "text": "這是最關鍵的字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1913.wav", + "text": "它是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1914.wav", + "text": "中間處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1915.wav", + "text": "它不是累進處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1916.wav", + "text": "所以它這個弄錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1917.wav", + "text": "\n那為什麼我國在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1918.wav", + "text": "外役監裡面會長出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1919.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1920.wav", + "text": "這麼特殊的一個縮刑制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1921.wav", + "text": "然後關1天等於關2天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1922.wav", + "text": "\n我自己對這個題目也很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1923.wav", + "text": "所以我去做一些研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1924.wav", + "text": "我國在引入縮刑制度的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1925.wav", + "text": "這個在國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1926.wav", + "text": "的制度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1927.wav", + "text": "行之久年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1928.wav", + "text": "它基本上也讓收容人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1929.wav", + "text": "有一個誘因就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1930.wav", + "text": "在監的時候表現比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1931.wav", + "text": "但是我國在引入這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1932.wav", + "text": "縮刑制度的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1933.wav", + "text": "居然是把它優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1934.wav", + "text": "適用在外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1935.wav", + "text": "而不是一般的監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1936.wav", + "text": "所以到最後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1937.wav", + "text": "演進當它要擴展到法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1938.wav", + "text": "下面四十幾個監所的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1939.wav", + "text": "那我外役監應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1940.wav", + "text": "要比一般的監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1941.wav", + "text": "這其實是錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1942.wav", + "text": "這些中間處遇也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1943.wav", + "text": "這是中間處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1944.wav", + "text": "讓他在復歸社會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1945.wav", + "text": "能夠有一個中間處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1946.wav", + "text": "以便他能夠回到社會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1947.wav", + "text": "再社會化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1948.wav", + "text": "它並不是累進處遇\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1949.wav", + "text": "真的沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1950.wav", + "text": "跟一般監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1951.wav", + "text": "做這樣的差別待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1952.wav", + "text": "我可以同意你可以通盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1953.wav", + "text": "去檢討目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1954.wav", + "text": "法務部所有的監所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1955.wav", + "text": "收容人的縮刑制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1956.wav", + "text": "但是千萬不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1957.wav", + "text": "因為它是外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1958.wav", + "text": "跟不是外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1959.wav", + "text": "挑動收容人間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1960.wav", + "text": "的內部矛盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1961.wav", + "text": "囚犯的囚情完全沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1962.wav", + "text": "任何幫助這真的是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1963.wav", + "text": "需要思考的這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1964.wav", + "text": "重大經濟犯罪放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1965.wav", + "text": "這當然表示肯定但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1966.wav", + "text": "跟我們版本的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1967.wav", + "text": "何在我必須要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1968.wav", + "text": "第一個我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1969.wav", + "text": "認為犯貪污治罪條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1970.wav", + "text": "之罪或法務部調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1971.wav", + "text": "有定義的重大經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1972.wav", + "text": "案件認定要點所定的重大經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1973.wav", + "text": "他應該要先把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1974.wav", + "text": "犯罪所得繳回繳回之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1975.wav", + "text": "他還是有遴選資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1976.wav", + "text": "外役監裡面有33" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1977.wav", + "text": "位是犯貪污治罪條例或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1978.wav", + "text": "法務部調查局定義的重大經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1979.wav", + "text": "犯罪33個裡面只有9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1980.wav", + "text": "個人把犯罪所得繳回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1981.wav", + "text": "其他人連一毛錢都沒有繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1982.wav", + "text": "你可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1983.wav", + "text": "外役監裡面其實最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1984.wav", + "text": "的一個要件叫做悛悔實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1985.wav", + "text": "這完全沒有悛悔實據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1986.wav", + "text": "所以這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1987.wav", + "text": "\n現在問題來了我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1988.wav", + "text": "裡面今天法務部的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1989.wav", + "text": "第1項之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1990.wav", + "text": "但是貪污治罪條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1991.wav", + "text": "其實還是有許多的罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1992.wav", + "text": "但你只是特定說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1993.wav", + "text": "第5條第1項之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1994.wav", + "text": "是不是妥當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1995.wav", + "text": "應該把它納入這個應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1996.wav", + "text": "可以再思考的當然這已經往前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1997.wav", + "text": "進一步我在這個地方已經講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1998.wav", + "text": "這幾年來已經講過非常多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/1999.wav", + "text": "今天當然是有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2000.wav", + "text": "進展但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2001.wav", + "text": "這真的要仔細思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2002.wav", + "text": "因為它的態樣同樣也非常非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2003.wav", + "text": "而且這個跟其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2004.wav", + "text": "犯罪比起來就像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2005.wav", + "text": "你直接列一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2006.wav", + "text": "譬如10年以上有期徒刑之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2007.wav", + "text": "等等這個相較起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2008.wav", + "text": "你只要繳回犯罪所得你還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2009.wav", + "text": "有遴選資格所以其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2010.wav", + "text": "它的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2011.wav", + "text": "手段上還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2012.wav", + "text": "沒有那麼直接的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2013.wav", + "text": "你的版本裡面是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2014.wav", + "text": "規定犯證交法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2015.wav", + "text": "銀行法金融控股公司法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2016.wav", + "text": "農業金融法等等這些金融犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2017.wav", + "text": "要到最輕本刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2018.wav", + "text": "7年以上有期徒刑之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2019.wav", + "text": "只要法務部調查局所認定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2020.wav", + "text": "犯罪所得必須要繳回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2021.wav", + "text": "你的狀況是說如果要到7年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2022.wav", + "text": "以上以證交法為例的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2023.wav", + "text": "這叫做證券交易之背信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2024.wav", + "text": "證券交易之詐欺證券交易之侵占" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2025.wav", + "text": "等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2026.wav", + "text": "要到犯罪所得1億以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2027.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2028.wav", + "text": "太過於狹窄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2029.wav", + "text": "重大經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2030.wav", + "text": "就應該把它放在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2031.wav", + "text": "把犯罪所得繳回而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2032.wav", + "text": "犯罪所得繳回基本上也符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2033.wav", + "text": "外役監條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2034.wav", + "text": "最基本的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2035.wav", + "text": "悛悔實據如果你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2036.wav", + "text": "連犯罪所得都不繳回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2037.wav", + "text": "怎麼能夠表示你有懺悔之意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2038.wav", + "text": "這個部分的話也應該可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2039.wav", + "text": "再一併的去思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2040.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2041.wav", + "text": "主席各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2042.wav", + "text": "剛才聽林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2043.wav", + "text": "和剛才不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2044.wav", + "text": "我都予以肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2045.wav", + "text": "林為洲委員所談的國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2046.wav", + "text": "3個原則他很堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2047.wav", + "text": "那個但書問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2048.wav", + "text": "其實那個但書問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2049.wav", + "text": "這次外役監條例修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2050.wav", + "text": "不是很重點的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2051.wav", + "text": "問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2052.wav", + "text": "國民黨不要拿這個點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2053.wav", + "text": "但書有但書時代力量版本也有但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2054.wav", + "text": "你堅持不能有但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2055.wav", + "text": "這個是小點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2056.wav", + "text": "這不是大點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2057.wav", + "text": "外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2058.wav", + "text": "民國100年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2059.wav", + "text": "我們還是在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2060.wav", + "text": "那時候我在司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2061.wav", + "text": "我提一個提案要把矯正司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2062.wav", + "text": "升格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2063.wav", + "text": "因為我們要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2064.wav", + "text": "委的非常接地氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2065.wav", + "text": "我們常常碰到很多家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2066.wav", + "text": "因為被關家庭裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2067.wav", + "text": "我們整個外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2068.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2069.wav", + "text": "監獄行刑法裡面有一個很重要的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2070.wav", + "text": "就是審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2071.wav", + "text": "und完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2072.wav", + "text": "法官判刑以後接著服監獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2073.wav", + "text": "復歸社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2074.wav", + "text": "還有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2075.wav", + "text": "很多人在家庭的接觸等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2076.wav", + "text": "我們就是希望這些人能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2077.wav", + "text": "以後出來可以改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2078.wav", + "text": "現在所有的受刑人在監獄裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2079.wav", + "text": "─我不要犯規犯責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2080.wav", + "text": "然後好好表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2081.wav", + "text": "我可以有什麼待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2082.wav", + "text": "可以到外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2083.wav", + "text": "外役監又有縮刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2084.wav", + "text": "包括監獄行刑法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2085.wav", + "text": "也有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2086.wav", + "text": "大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2087.wav", + "text": "但關太久的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2088.wav", + "text": "他和社會連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2089.wav", + "text": "復歸社會也會有一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2090.wav", + "text": "所以外役監的功能事實上是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2091.wav", + "text": "整個外役監被污名化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2092.wav", + "text": "因為一兩個非典型的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2093.wav", + "text": "這個我們也必須面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2094.wav", + "text": "我們再來改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2095.wav", + "text": "嘛\n目前提出來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2096.wav", + "text": "我先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2097.wav", + "text": "有關林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2098.wav", + "text": "但書並不是最重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2099.wav", + "text": "第二個這種情況不可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2100.wav", + "text": "本來就是不可去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2101.wav", + "text": "例如十年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2102.wav", + "text": "而且我們還要加七年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2103.wav", + "text": "這個是我們再加進去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2104.wav", + "text": "經過大家的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2105.wav", + "text": "這段時間我們黨團和法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2106.wav", + "text": "務部也一直在思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2107.wav", + "text": "現在已經走到這裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2108.wav", + "text": "坦白講這已經是最嚴格的版本了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2109.wav", + "text": "我說白了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2110.wav", + "text": "啦\n林為洲委員所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2111.wav", + "text": "重刑犯十年以上本來就不能去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2112.wav", + "text": "現在已經沒有累進處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2113.wav", + "text": "這次修法修了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2114.wav", + "text": "就沒有七年以下七年到十五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2115.wav", + "text": "這是完全沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2116.wav", + "text": "的這是非常嚴格的線一畫下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2117.wav", + "text": "你必須要在假釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2118.wav", + "text": "釋前一年才可以申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2119.wav", + "text": "這個說起來是非常少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2120.wav", + "text": "啦這道門是很緊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2121.wav", + "text": "的所以這點我想大家都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2122.wav", + "text": "假釋前一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2123.wav", + "text": "了有不一樣的地方就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2124.wav", + "text": "我們後來修的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2125.wav", + "text": "加嚴了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2126.wav", + "text": "這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2127.wav", + "text": "免得外面說話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2128.wav", + "text": "沒有那麼容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2129.wav", + "text": "啦根本不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2130.wav", + "text": "目前外役監為什麼還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2131.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2132.wav", + "text": "因為它有條件式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2133.wav", + "text": "不是說他怎麼樣都可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2134.wav", + "text": "這是有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2135.wav", + "text": "監獄的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2136.wav", + "text": "是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2137.wav", + "text": "囚情穩定也很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2138.wav", + "text": "三分之一就可以假釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2139.wav", + "text": "監獄就暴動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2140.wav", + "text": "高雄大寮也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2141.wav", + "text": "假釋三振條款一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2142.wav", + "text": "所以我們要考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2143.wav", + "text": "我們是要讓他們出來可以回到社會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2144.wav", + "text": "我們不要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2145.wav", + "text": "\n這個已經不是恩給制了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2146.wav", + "text": "過去監獄就是恩給制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2147.wav", + "text": "可以出去你不能出去就不能出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2148.wav", + "text": "這是恩給制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2149.wav", + "text": "現在是累進處遇加上各種條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2150.wav", + "text": "事實上��代一直在進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2151.wav", + "text": "\n所以我今天要講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2152.wav", + "text": "我們回到一個很理性的面向來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2153.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2154.wav", + "text": "再改都有限了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2155.wav", + "text": "已經十年以上這條線畫下去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2156.wav", + "text": "很多人都不能去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2157.wav", + "text": "而論最需要去的是長期刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2158.wav", + "text": "的復歸社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2159.wav", + "text": "但遇到就沒辦法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2160.wav", + "text": "今天我們在這裡也不能退卻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2161.wav", + "text": "剛才吵歸吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2162.wav", + "text": "回到最後的時候我們這邊的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2163.wav", + "text": "每一條都要理性來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2164.wav", + "text": "至於邱顯智在講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2165.wav", + "text": "他把這個累進處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2166.wav", + "text": "和中間處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2167.wav", + "text": "完全混淆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2168.wav", + "text": "役監當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2169.wav", + "text": "要有中間處遇嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2170.wav", + "text": "但是也需要累進處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2171.wav", + "text": "啊監獄要怎麼管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2172.wav", + "text": "鼓勵人家向上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2173.wav", + "text": "要表現良好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2174.wav", + "text": "這樣的一些功能的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2175.wav", + "text": "那不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2176.wav", + "text": "\n所以我在這裡很持平地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2177.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2178.wav", + "text": "要照法務部的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2179.wav", + "text": "法務部的標準根本就不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2180.wav", + "text": "法律的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2181.wav", + "text": "啦所以我們今天入法是要把誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2182.wav", + "text": "法律不明確的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2183.wav", + "text": "這整個法律就違憲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2184.wav", + "text": "都寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2185.wav", + "text": "所以包括剛才我和講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2186.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2187.wav", + "text": "煙毒犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2188.wav", + "text": "運輸販賣製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2189.wav", + "text": "那個都十年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2190.wav", + "text": "根本不能去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2191.wav", + "text": "了所以還是有一點層次的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2192.wav", + "text": "我們似乎已經走到一個大家要必須共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2193.wav", + "text": "共同來決定一些事情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2194.wav", + "text": "至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2195.wav", + "text": "談了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2196.wav", + "text": "當然就是鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2197.wav", + "text": "嘛並不是每一個人都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2198.wav", + "text": "關一個月可以省14天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2199.wav", + "text": "是4天8天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2200.wav", + "text": "把這個鼓勵功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2201.wav", + "text": "全部拿掉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2202.wav", + "text": "那監獄裡面也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2203.wav", + "text": "啊我們整個法理上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2204.wav", + "text": "而且實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2205.wav", + "text": "完全就是失焦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2206.wav", + "text": "這一點我希望大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2207.wav", + "text": "還是要站在一個立場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2208.wav", + "text": "面對社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2209.wav", + "text": "對立法院的評價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2210.wav", + "text": "我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2211.wav", + "text": "絕對會發生問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2212.wav", + "text": "但是要如何修才可長可久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2213.wav", + "text": "真的大家可能要冷靜一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2214.wav", + "text": "啦已經走到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2215.wav", + "text": "這樣的程度的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2216.wav", + "text": "坦白講這段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2217.wav", + "text": "我們黨團內部也一直在考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2218.wav", + "text": "一直在說到底中間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2219.wav", + "text": "以及如何鼓勵犯人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2220.wav", + "text": "犯人能夠回歸社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2221.wav", + "text": "然後在裡面能夠好好地關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2222.wav", + "text": "我有一個朋友被關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2223.wav", + "text": "他說他一天背心經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2224.wav", + "text": "可以背一百零多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2225.wav", + "text": "可以好可以加分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2226.wav", + "text": "以大家都很計較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2227.wav", + "text": "都是想回到社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2228.wav", + "text": "嘛這個也是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2229.wav", + "text": "監獄的教化功能也必須要存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2230.wav", + "text": "的假如什麼都取消的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2231.wav", + "text": "我不知道矯正署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2232.wav", + "text": "署能夠管教這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2233.wav", + "text": "我以上所談的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2234.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2235.wav", + "text": "各黨團回去想清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2236.wav", + "text": "假如大家講好禮拜一要處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2237.wav", + "text": "各黨去整理自己的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2238.wav", + "text": "好互相尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2239.wav", + "text": "嘛我們不要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2240.wav", + "text": "演野台戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2241.wav", + "text": "一樣這個是我比較懇切拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2242.wav", + "text": "的我也知道劉建國聽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2243.wav", + "text": "大家講話很生氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2244.wav", + "text": "所以他是指桑罵槐啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2245.wav", + "text": "他故意要給法務部好好回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2246.wav", + "text": "因為這個是冷靜的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2247.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2248.wav", + "text": "這樣本案就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2249.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2250.wav", + "text": "可是剛剛我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2251.wav", + "text": "提到的有些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2252.wav", + "text": "大家版本拿出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2253.wav", + "text": "嘛政黨要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2254.wav", + "text": "嘛接下來後面還有好幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2255.wav", + "text": "最重要的是這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2256.wav", + "text": "不是要怎麼修各黨要去負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2257.wav", + "text": "啦不是只有你講的話法務部一定要修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2258.wav", + "text": "各黨回去好好冷靜想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2259.wav", + "text": "那是要成套的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2260.wav", + "text": "一個法下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2261.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2262.wav", + "text": "還有蔡部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2263.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2264.wav", + "text": "這裡有兩點意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2265.wav", + "text": "想要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2266.wav", + "text": "第一點關於第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2267.wav", + "text": "第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2268.wav", + "text": "第10款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2269.wav", + "text": "修正後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2270.wav", + "text": "規定為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2271.wav", + "text": "犯人口販運防制法第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2272.wav", + "text": "第2款之人口販運罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2273.wav", + "text": "把它列為消極條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2274.wav", + "text": "對於這一點我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2275.wav", + "text": "敬表同意沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2276.wav", + "text": "第二點意見是關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2277.wav", + "text": "同條項第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2278.wav", + "text": "跟第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2279.wav", + "text": "以第8款為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2280.wav", + "text": "它是規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2281.wav", + "text": "犯貪污治罪條例第5條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2282.wav", + "text": "之罪就是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2283.wav", + "text": "消極條件但是它有個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2284.wav", + "text": "犯罪所得已經被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2285.wav", + "text": "沒收或者是追徵的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2286.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2287.wav", + "text": "貪污治罪條例第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2288.wav", + "text": "第1項之罪並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2289.wav", + "text": "所有的都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2290.wav", + "text": "犯罪所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2291.wav", + "text": "他只是在期約而已並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2292.wav", + "text": "實際有犯罪所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2293.wav", + "text": "這樣一個規定的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2294.wav", + "text": "他就變成犯第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2295.wav", + "text": "之罪然後他有犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2296.wav", + "text": "所得但是他事後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2297.wav", + "text": "犯罪所得被沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2298.wav", + "text": "他就不會落入這個消極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2299.wav", + "text": "條件了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2300.wav", + "text": "對期約沒有犯罪所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2301.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2302.wav", + "text": "如果碰到沒有犯罪所得的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2303.wav", + "text": "因為他不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2304.wav", + "text": "但書的規定所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2305.wav", + "text": "這樣子會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2306.wav", + "text": "所得也一併再納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2307.wav", + "text": "第8款跟第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2308.wav", + "text": "的但書裡面謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2309.wav", + "text": "條文寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2310.wav", + "text": "這個反正到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2311.wav", + "text": "好最後版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2312.wav", + "text": "還有好幾條是不是要談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2313.wav", + "text": "現在就保留本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2314.wav", + "text": "4條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2315.wav", + "text": "1法務部的建議是不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2316.wav", + "text": "予增訂我們是不是照法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2317.wav", + "text": "的意見這樣處理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2318.wav", + "text": "好就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2319.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2320.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2321.wav", + "text": "要不要說明一下不必吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2322.wav", + "text": "好增訂第4條之1就保留\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2323.wav", + "text": "第6條法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2324.wav", + "text": "的意見是照協商建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2325.wav", + "text": "內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2326.wav", + "text": "沒有意見吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2327.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見我們就這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2328.wav", + "text": "\n第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2329.wav", + "text": "刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2330.wav", + "text": "大家意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2331.wav", + "text": "\n第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2332.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2333.wav", + "text": "法務部的意見是不予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2334.wav", + "text": "修正維持現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2335.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2336.wav", + "text": "大家意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2337.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2338.wav", + "text": "第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2339.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2340.wav", + "text": "修正動議已經撤案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2341.wav", + "text": "已經撤案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2342.wav", + "text": "我撤案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2343.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2344.wav", + "text": "沒有吧講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2345.wav", + "text": "我是看手頭上書面的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2346.wav", + "text": "啊保留就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2347.wav", + "text": "好保留就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2348.wav", + "text": "協商建議內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2349.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2350.wav", + "text": "好就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2351.wav", + "text": "條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2352.wav", + "text": "第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2353.wav", + "text": "3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2354.wav", + "text": "各黨團回去想一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2355.wav", + "text": "溝通看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2356.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2357.wav", + "text": "協商的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2358.wav", + "text": "我也唸一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2359.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會併案審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2360.wav", + "text": "行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2361.wav", + "text": "外役監條例部分條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2362.wav", + "text": "一第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2363.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2364.wav", + "text": "增訂第4條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2365.wav", + "text": "及第十四條均保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2366.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2367.wav", + "text": "\n二第6條及第25條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2368.wav", + "text": "均照協商內容通過如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2369.wav", + "text": "\n三第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2370.wav", + "text": "刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2371.wav", + "text": "\n四其餘均照審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2372.wav", + "text": "審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2373.wav", + "text": "\n五檢附本案立法說明1份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2374.wav", + "text": "院會進行處理時非保留部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2375.wav", + "text": "宣讀後均予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2376.wav", + "text": "保留部分均暫保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2377.wav", + "text": "保留部分院會進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2378.wav", + "text": "處理前由各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2379.wav", + "text": "推派1人依時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2380.wav", + "text": "力量黨團台灣民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2381.wav", + "text": "黨黨團國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2382.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2383.wav", + "text": "順序輪流發言每人發言時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2384.wav", + "text": "為3分鐘發言完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2385.wav", + "text": "各該保留條文均不再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2386.wav", + "text": "並依上開黨團順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2387.wav", + "text": "進行各保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2388.wav", + "text": "黨團版本之處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2389.wav", + "text": "只是法務部提出的版本範圍真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2390.wav", + "text": "剛才司法院特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2391.wav", + "text": "其實剛剛我們都沒有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2392.wav", + "text": "那個也是在回應社會期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2393.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們都沒有討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2394.wav", + "text": "對我們要擴充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2395.wav", + "text": "範圍已經非常廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2396.wav", + "text": "了因為剛才林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2397.wav", + "text": "的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2398.wav", + "text": "確實社會輿論也是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2399.wav", + "text": "這是沒有錯喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2400.wav", + "text": "但是如果林為洲委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2401.wav", + "text": "就是一個實際的現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2402.wav", + "text": "那我們今天是要處理制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2403.wav", + "text": "還是要處理特權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2404.wav", + "text": "我當然支持要處理特權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2405.wav", + "text": "所以我才會做這樣的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2406.wav", + "text": "現在沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2407.wav", + "text": "以前也沒有特權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2408.wav", + "text": "我是覺得大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2409.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2410.wav", + "text": "已經非常嚴苛了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2411.wav", + "text": "事實上也沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2412.wav", + "text": "一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2413.wav", + "text": "兩個月到現在已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2414.wav", + "text": "要三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2415.wav", + "text": "這個我們就是共同面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2416.wav", + "text": "嘛所以為什麼在委員會大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2417.wav", + "text": "大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2418.wav", + "text": "一起來面對這個制度的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2419.wav", + "text": "但是我希望大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2420.wav", + "text": "對於教化功能上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2421.wav", + "text": "所以我才希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2422.wav", + "text": "法務部長跟署長要正視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2423.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2424.wav", + "text": "我們本來累犯就規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2425.wav", + "text": "不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2426.wav", + "text": "但是但書的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2427.wav", + "text": "把林委員還有其他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2428.wav", + "text": "貪污的你無論哪一黨都別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15108/2429.wav", + "text": "我們就散會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/0.wav", + "text": "各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1.wav", + "text": "各位部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2.wav", + "text": "各位女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/3.wav", + "text": "開始開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/4.wav", + "text": "今天開會的事由是要研商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/5.wav", + "text": "性別工作平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/6.wav", + "text": "性騷擾防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/7.wav", + "text": "及性別平等教育法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/8.wav", + "text": "相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/9.wav", + "text": "我在這邊先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/10.wav", + "text": "今天的議程第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/11.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/12.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/13.wav", + "text": "112年7月24日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/14.wav", + "text": "由召集委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/15.wav", + "text": "張其祿先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/16.wav", + "text": "召集黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/17.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/18.wav", + "text": "各黨團代表都已經簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/19.wav", + "text": "所以本案就不必再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/20.wav", + "text": "與本案有關的教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/21.wav", + "text": "等各部會代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/22.wav", + "text": "可以先行離席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/23.wav", + "text": "\n現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/24.wav", + "text": "部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/25.wav", + "text": "首先介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/26.wav", + "text": "勞動部部長許銘春" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/27.wav", + "text": "女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/28.wav", + "text": "行政院人事行政總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/29.wav", + "text": "人事長蘇俊榮先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/30.wav", + "text": "介紹完畢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/31.wav", + "text": "在進行協商前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/32.wav", + "text": "性別工作平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/33.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案及性騷擾防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/34.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/35.wav", + "text": "等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/36.wav", + "text": "社會福利及衛生環境委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/37.wav", + "text": "分別於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/38.wav", + "text": "7月24日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/39.wav", + "text": "25日完成審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/40.wav", + "text": "保留部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/41.wav", + "text": "行政院提案及黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/42.wav", + "text": "與委員提案之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/43.wav", + "text": "時效本次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/44.wav", + "text": "本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/45.wav", + "text": "擬援例從保留之行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/46.wav", + "text": "提案條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/47.wav", + "text": "先進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/48.wav", + "text": "黨團與委員提案的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/49.wav", + "text": "均列入紀錄刊登公報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/50.wav", + "text": "各位協商代表對上述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/51.wav", + "text": "黨團及委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/52.wav", + "text": "保留條文如仍有異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/53.wav", + "text": "我們於俟後討論時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/54.wav", + "text": "再進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/55.wav", + "text": "請問各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/56.wav", + "text": "\n現在就進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/57.wav", + "text": "性別工作平等法部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/58.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/59.wav", + "text": "保留之法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/60.wav", + "text": "是不是就照行政院提案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/61.wav", + "text": "法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/62.wav", + "text": "意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/63.wav", + "text": "是不是我們依照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/64.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/65.wav", + "text": "主席我幫為洲發言一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/66.wav", + "text": "的時候一開始的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/67.wav", + "text": "是叫做兩性工作平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/68.wav", + "text": "後來因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/69.wav", + "text": "這裡面涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/70.wav", + "text": "到第三性等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/71.wav", + "text": "所以正名為性別工作平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/72.wav", + "text": "實施多年以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/73.wav", + "text": "我們非常清楚會講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/74.wav", + "text": "所有人大概都知道講的是性別平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/75.wav", + "text": "教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/76.wav", + "text": "至於在職場的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/77.wav", + "text": "即性別工作平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/78.wav", + "text": "我們運作這十幾二十年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/79.wav", + "text": "都是這樣認定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/80.wav", + "text": "林為洲委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/81.wav", + "text": "有道理的原因我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/82.wav", + "text": "同意我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/83.wav", + "text": "臺北市警察局稱為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/84.wav", + "text": "臺北市政府警察局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/85.wav", + "text": "有些縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/86.wav", + "text": "覺得好像加了政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/87.wav", + "text": "比較高級比較高尚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/88.wav", + "text": "所以就會改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/89.wav", + "text": "比如現在我們叫屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/90.wav", + "text": "縣政府警察局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/91.wav", + "text": "可是這一改其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/92.wav", + "text": "警察局內部就會有人告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/93.wav", + "text": "他們的同仁就會跟我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/94.wav", + "text": "哇老師你知道他們改是改得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/95.wav", + "text": "很爽只改這兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/96.wav", + "text": "可是我們要花多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/97.wav", + "text": "所有的臂章也要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/98.wav", + "text": "文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/99.wav", + "text": "的標記全部都要重新再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/100.wav", + "text": "做如果站在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/101.wav", + "text": "替政府省公帑的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/102.wav", + "text": "部分而且我們運作多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/103.wav", + "text": "性別工作平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/104.wav", + "text": "好像也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/105.wav", + "text": "只是內容我們利用這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/106.wav", + "text": "加以修法所以我是舉我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/107.wav", + "text": "警察單位裡面有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/108.wav", + "text": "警察局為了加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/109.wav", + "text": "這兩個字所造成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/110.wav", + "text": "必須要花費我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/111.wav", + "text": "我必須要幫他發言但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/112.wav", + "text": "我不堅持我只是把他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/113.wav", + "text": "理由講出來謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/114.wav", + "text": "好那現在法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/115.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/116.wav", + "text": "是不是法案名稱就先依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/117.wav", + "text": "建議照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/118.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好好那就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/119.wav", + "text": "\n第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/120.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有意見也照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/121.wav", + "text": "行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/122.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長因為這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/123.wav", + "text": "有接到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/124.wav", + "text": "陳情譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/125.wav", + "text": "如果是公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/126.wav", + "text": "他們的申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/127.wav", + "text": "之後如果不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/128.wav", + "text": "就沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/129.wav", + "text": "跟主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/130.wav", + "text": "再去申訴所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/131.wav", + "text": "在第2條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/132.wav", + "text": "針對行政院提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/133.wav", + "text": "版本第2項是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/134.wav", + "text": "可以把第38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/135.wav", + "text": "及第38條之一的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/136.wav", + "text": "後續就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/137.wav", + "text": "進行相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/138.wav", + "text": "申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/139.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/140.wav", + "text": "動部回答一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/141.wav", + "text": "跟主席及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/142.wav", + "text": "各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/143.wav", + "text": "歷來就是有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/144.wav", + "text": "很完整的體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/145.wav", + "text": "規定處理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/146.wav", + "text": "目前的運作並沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/147.wav", + "text": "如果說還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/148.wav", + "text": "再把它拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/149.wav", + "text": "我們的公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/150.wav", + "text": "要到臺北市勞工局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/151.wav", + "text": "變成要到臺北市勞工局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/152.wav", + "text": "那可以再開一個門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/153.wav", + "text": "讓他們如果遇到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/154.wav", + "text": "這樣的狀況沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/155.wav", + "text": "申訴可以再進行申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/156.wav", + "text": "嗎就是另外再開一個門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/157.wav", + "text": "我覺得軍公教體系是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/158.wav", + "text": "啦的確會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/159.wav", + "text": "申訴以後似乎沒有參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/160.wav", + "text": "的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/161.wav", + "text": "軍公教相關的規範裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/162.wav", + "text": "譬如開會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/163.wav", + "text": "讓被害人有參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/164.wav", + "text": "開會陳述意見的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/165.wav", + "text": "一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/166.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/167.wav", + "text": "不過剛才陳委員提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/168.wav", + "text": "也是一個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/169.wav", + "text": "我想我們會把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/170.wav", + "text": "委員所提示的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/171.wav", + "text": "也就是讓被害人對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/172.wav", + "text": "懲處程度有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/173.wav", + "text": "陳述意見的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/174.wav", + "text": "而且要納入最終懲處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/175.wav", + "text": "決定的重要參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/176.wav", + "text": "我覺得大家care的是這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/177.wav", + "text": "這部分我們會把它納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/178.wav", + "text": "因為這樣才有一層保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/179.wav", + "text": "不然大家會怕官官相護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/180.wav", + "text": "或是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/181.wav", + "text": "的這部分我們會把它納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/182.wav", + "text": "因為我們有罰款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/183.wav", + "text": "申訴的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/184.wav", + "text": "這部分我們會把它列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/185.wav", + "text": "這一條就照行政院版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/186.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/187.wav", + "text": "那第2條就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/188.wav", + "text": "\n第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/189.wav", + "text": "不好意思關於第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/190.wav", + "text": "民眾黨有一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/191.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/192.wav", + "text": "可不可以考慮加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/193.wav", + "text": "上在中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/194.wav", + "text": "領域外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/195.wav", + "text": "違反本法者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/196.wav", + "text": "適用行政法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/197.wav", + "text": "第6條第3項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/198.wav", + "text": "因為我們聽到的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/199.wav", + "text": "空服員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/200.wav", + "text": "工作場域不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/201.wav", + "text": "是在中華民國領域內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/202.wav", + "text": "工作平等的保護必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/203.wav", + "text": "落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/204.wav", + "text": "是這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/205.wav", + "text": "為了空服員的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/206.wav", + "text": "所以可以加這句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/207.wav", + "text": "請考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/208.wav", + "text": "這樣有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/209.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/210.wav", + "text": "它規範了雇主的防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/211.wav", + "text": "義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/212.wav", + "text": "雇主在訂定相關的懲處規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/213.wav", + "text": "時其實不管是在領域內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/214.wav", + "text": "都一樣是可以訂定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/215.wav", + "text": "他們這次其實有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/216.wav", + "text": "只是對那個處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/217.wav", + "text": "不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/218.wav", + "text": "處分的輕重不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/219.wav", + "text": "但事實上是有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/220.wav", + "text": "所以沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/221.wav", + "text": "好那這樣就照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/222.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/223.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請看第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/224.wav", + "text": "第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/225.wav", + "text": "行政院版本有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/226.wav", + "text": "依照勞動部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/227.wav", + "text": "修正意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/228.wav", + "text": "請各位委員看一下第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/229.wav", + "text": "就在第4頁那時林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/230.wav", + "text": "等人建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/231.wav", + "text": "要建立性別平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/232.wav", + "text": "人才資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/233.wav", + "text": "第五項中間這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/234.wav", + "text": "有加了一句中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/235.wav", + "text": "應建立性別平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/236.wav", + "text": "人才資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/237.wav", + "text": "就是加這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/238.wav", + "text": "其他就是都照原來的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/239.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/240.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/241.wav", + "text": "在之前的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/242.wav", + "text": "在第8項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/243.wav", + "text": "第2款第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/244.wav", + "text": "要加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/245.wav", + "text": "這些機關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/246.wav", + "text": "合夥人等等不知道現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/247.wav", + "text": "是不是可以把它納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/248.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/249.wav", + "text": "我們會把它納在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/250.wav", + "text": "立法理由欄把它說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/251.wav", + "text": "委員那時候有同意我現在在第5頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/252.wav", + "text": "這邊已經有把你的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/253.wav", + "text": "在立法理由欄裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/254.wav", + "text": "做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/255.wav", + "text": "已經納進來了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/256.wav", + "text": "最右邊這一欄的第八點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/257.wav", + "text": "這個就是立法理由的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/258.wav", + "text": "在第八點有把你那天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/259.wav", + "text": "最高負責人包括大解法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/260.wav", + "text": "禁止事業單位代表人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/261.wav", + "text": "實際負責人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/262.wav", + "text": "行政院版修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/263.wav", + "text": "請看第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/264.wav", + "text": "是不是也照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/265.wav", + "text": "勞動部建議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/266.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/267.wav", + "text": "時力之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/268.wav", + "text": "的修正意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/269.wav", + "text": "今天我們也有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/270.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/271.wav", + "text": "我們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/272.wav", + "text": "不知道可不可以參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/273.wav", + "text": "主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/274.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/275.wav", + "text": "一項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/276.wav", + "text": "針對採取適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/277.wav", + "text": "措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/278.wav", + "text": "防治性騷擾發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/279.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/280.wav", + "text": "僱用受僱者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/281.wav", + "text": "十人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/282.wav", + "text": "請問有修正了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/283.wav", + "text": "是不是都改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/284.wav", + "text": "三十人以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/285.wav", + "text": "也請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/286.wav", + "text": "跟主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/287.wav", + "text": "和委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/288.wav", + "text": "十人到二十九人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/289.wav", + "text": "要訂定申訴管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/290.wav", + "text": "不過十人以下的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/291.wav", + "text": "我們未來在準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/292.wav", + "text": "會把相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/293.wav", + "text": "全部都在裡面規定清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/294.wav", + "text": "讓他們好遵循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/295.wav", + "text": "那時候委員有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/296.wav", + "text": "如果知悉而不是申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/297.wav", + "text": "喔可能傳聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/298.wav", + "text": "或聽別人說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/299.wav", + "text": "有人性騷擾A性騷擾B" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/300.wav", + "text": "雇主知悉以後要去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/301.wav", + "text": "那時候委員有建議說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/302.wav", + "text": "也要問一下被害人的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/303.wav", + "text": "看他要不要申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/304.wav", + "text": "有加依被害人意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/305.wav", + "text": "協助其提起申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/306.wav", + "text": "另外就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/307.wav", + "text": "那時候委員也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/308.wav", + "text": "因為我們本來只有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/309.wav", + "text": "地方主管機關要規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/310.wav", + "text": "整合相關資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/311.wav", + "text": "來協助雇主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/312.wav", + "text": "辦理性騷擾防治措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/313.wav", + "text": "委員建議也應該要提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/314.wav", + "text": "給被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/315.wav", + "text": "所以我們在第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/316.wav", + "text": "13頁這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/317.wav", + "text": "大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/318.wav", + "text": "第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/319.wav", + "text": "這邊有加一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/320.wav", + "text": "地方主管機關應規劃整合相關資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/321.wav", + "text": "提供或轉介被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/322.wav", + "text": "運用並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/323.wav", + "text": "協助雇主加一個並後面都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/324.wav", + "text": "所以委員的意見希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/325.wav", + "text": "地方主管機關要把資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/326.wav", + "text": "給被害人這個都有納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/327.wav", + "text": "這樣可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/328.wav", + "text": "喔請陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/329.wav", + "text": "有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/330.wav", + "text": "第1項第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/331.wav", + "text": "就是僱用受僱者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/332.wav", + "text": "這邊是十人以上未達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/333.wav", + "text": "把十人以上拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/334.wav", + "text": "力黨團認為這個非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/335.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/336.wav", + "text": "那本案就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/337.wav", + "text": "第十三條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/338.wav", + "text": "第十三條之1是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/339.wav", + "text": "也照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/340.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見請蘇委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/341.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/342.wav", + "text": "因為我在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/343.wav", + "text": "其實有就第十三條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/344.wav", + "text": "和第三十二條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/345.wav", + "text": "因為上一次沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/346.wav", + "text": "是不是有機會在這裡至少留個紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/347.wav", + "text": "可以瞭解一下並請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/348.wav", + "text": "問部內的意見到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/349.wav", + "text": "為什麼這一次還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/350.wav", + "text": "因為大家現在有個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/351.wav", + "text": "但我還是希望我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/352.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有被採納的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/353.wav", + "text": "可以留個紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/354.wav", + "text": "好蘇委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/355.wav", + "text": "這個部分沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/356.wav", + "text": "對於這個條文我沒有太大的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/357.wav", + "text": "不過因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/358.wav", + "text": "本來提第十一條修法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/359.wav", + "text": "有特別提到一個防搶退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/360.wav", + "text": "的條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/361.wav", + "text": "就是因為有太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/362.wav", + "text": "性騷擾被申訴之後立刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/363.wav", + "text": "現在在所有公部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/364.wav", + "text": "幾乎比比皆是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/365.wav", + "text": "過去我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/366.wav", + "text": "性平法就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/367.wav", + "text": "教育機關裡面是有可是教師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/368.wav", + "text": "但是這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/369.wav", + "text": "在審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/370.wav", + "text": "因為調平司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/371.wav", + "text": "的黃司長說這個跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/372.wav", + "text": "這一次的性騷擾防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/373.wav", + "text": "沒有直接關係他實在是對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/374.wav", + "text": "太不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/375.wav", + "text": "我看到銓敘部其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/376.wav", + "text": "滿支持本席的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/377.wav", + "text": "說這個跟退撫法施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/378.wav", + "text": "細則實務相符" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/379.wav", + "text": "十一條在當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/380.wav", + "text": "並沒有把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/381.wav", + "text": "本席的重點放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/382.wav", + "text": "我還是很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/383.wav", + "text": "修法之後能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/384.wav", + "text": "針對這一部分特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/385.wav", + "text": "因為過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/386.wav", + "text": "真的很多都是直接先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/387.wav", + "text": "我看到你們的第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/388.wav", + "text": "還滿符合我自己想像中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/389.wav", + "text": "重點是在執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/390.wav", + "text": "我們法律修出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/391.wav", + "text": "在執行上千萬不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/392.wav", + "text": "變成有漏洞謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/393.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/394.wav", + "text": "我的提案當然在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/395.wav", + "text": "委員會裡面有審查過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/396.wav", + "text": "但是我仍然有一些疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/397.wav", + "text": "請勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/398.wav", + "text": "可以回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/399.wav", + "text": "就是第十三條之1和第三十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/400.wav", + "text": "裡面所提到的其實我們也是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/401.wav", + "text": "能夠有多做一個補充性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/402.wav", + "text": "的救助管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/403.wav", + "text": "也就是說他在受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/404.wav", + "text": "上面有這些沒有辦法獲得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/405.wav", + "text": "申訴的時候可以尋求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/406.wav", + "text": "地方主管機關來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/407.wav", + "text": "尋求協助的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/408.wav", + "text": "這一條路到底還存在不存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/409.wav", + "text": "也就是兩者都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/410.wav", + "text": "裡面如果沒有辦法有其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/411.wav", + "text": "申訴或救濟管道的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/412.wav", + "text": "可不可以尋求地方主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/413.wav", + "text": "來協助這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/414.wav", + "text": "協商的時候有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/415.wav", + "text": "其他的考慮但是是不是可以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/416.wav", + "text": "勞動部再對外說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/417.wav", + "text": "因為我已經提到他的身分別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/418.wav", + "text": "可能會因為時日境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/419.wav", + "text": "改變最後能夠協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/420.wav", + "text": "是在公部門裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/421.wav", + "text": "行政機關才能夠介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/422.wav", + "text": "處理他的申訴跟其他的行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/423.wav", + "text": "的管道這個部分如果有放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/424.wav", + "text": "原來行政院的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/425.wav", + "text": "修正版本裡面的話我就不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/426.wav", + "text": "堅持但是請勞動部多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/427.wav", + "text": "做說明一下謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/428.wav", + "text": "被申訴人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/429.wav", + "text": "就是不是只有具權勢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/430.wav", + "text": "被害人才有退避的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/431.wav", + "text": "只要有發生狀況就應該能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/432.wav", + "text": "也算是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/433.wav", + "text": "干預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/434.wav", + "text": "我們為什麼這邊會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/435.wav", + "text": "限於具權勢者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/436.wav", + "text": "而且要情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/437.wav", + "text": "在必要的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/438.wav", + "text": "我們賦予雇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/439.wav", + "text": "雇主有這樣的權限可以停職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/440.wav", + "text": "退避權的行使在法律上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/441.wav", + "text": "像職安法的退避權是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/442.wav", + "text": "在有立即的危險下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/443.wav", + "text": "才能夠去發動有生命危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/444.wav", + "text": "如果是一般的行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/445.wav", + "text": "本來就可以調整職務了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/446.wav", + "text": "保護被害人讓他們能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/447.wav", + "text": "澈底分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/448.wav", + "text": "不會在同一個場域裡面繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/449.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/450.wav", + "text": "退避權要更擴張但我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/451.wav", + "text": "會考慮比較多因為退避權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/452.wav", + "text": "勞基法或職安法的相關規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/453.wav", + "text": "規定是比較嚴格的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/454.wav", + "text": "這也算是一種工作權的侵犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/455.wav", + "text": "所以我們會比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/456.wav", + "text": "認為要保守一點謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/457.wav", + "text": "有權勢者這部分來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/458.wav", + "text": "他有這樣的情事就一定可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/459.wav", + "text": "時讓雇主有更多衡酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/460.wav", + "text": "衡酌的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/461.wav", + "text": "謝謝游委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/462.wav", + "text": "其實現在對於公務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/463.wav", + "text": "第32條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/464.wav", + "text": "3就有可以停職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/465.wav", + "text": "的規定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/466.wav", + "text": "當然如果還有不足的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/467.wav", + "text": "會再來檢視檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/468.wav", + "text": "劉委員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/469.wav", + "text": "雇主沒有處理也就是雇主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/470.wav", + "text": "規定如果���是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/471.wav", + "text": "最高負責人的性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/472.wav", + "text": "是一般人的性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/473.wav", + "text": "基本上是內部要先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/474.wav", + "text": "把它拉出來地方勞政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/475.wav", + "text": "侵害的人是一般人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/476.wav", + "text": "的話也可以直接走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/477.wav", + "text": "地方勞政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/478.wav", + "text": "對加進去了那天在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/479.wav", + "text": "已經加進去了針對您擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/480.wav", + "text": "雇主未為處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/481.wav", + "text": "就直接可以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/482.wav", + "text": "有加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/483.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/484.wav", + "text": "被害人的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/485.wav", + "text": "可是我們看到過去在實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/486.wav", + "text": "有很多案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/487.wav", + "text": "案例有沒有讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/488.wav", + "text": "沒有很多都是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/489.wav", + "text": "甚至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/490.wav", + "text": "有的是書面審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/491.wav", + "text": "有的是連性平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/492.wav", + "text": "平會都沒有開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/493.wav", + "text": "前年9月發生在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/494.wav", + "text": "的偷拍案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/495.wav", + "text": "為例因為申訴人一再要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/496.wav", + "text": "召開性平會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/497.wav", + "text": "沒開然後他也向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/498.wav", + "text": "一樣是沒開所以他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/499.wav", + "text": "認為他的聲音不會被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/500.wav", + "text": "聽到所以我很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/501.wav", + "text": "在你們未來的細則裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/502.wav", + "text": "一定要讓申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/503.wav", + "text": "人有機會去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/504.wav", + "text": "陳述這個我覺得無論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/505.wav", + "text": "如何一定要放進去好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/506.wav", + "text": "部長他講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/507.wav", + "text": "一定要放進去這個沒有問題吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/508.wav", + "text": "現在是有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/509.wav", + "text": "可以請專業人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/510.wav", + "text": "或團體來協助調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/511.wav", + "text": "而且是實質調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/512.wav", + "text": "未來我們在準則裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/513.wav", + "text": "主管機關它要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/514.wav", + "text": "一些大原則都已經有按照委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/515.wav", + "text": "第十三條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/516.wav", + "text": "3位委員都有說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/517.wav", + "text": "照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/518.wav", + "text": "好那沒意見就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/519.wav", + "text": "行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/520.wav", + "text": "\n接下來就增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/521.wav", + "text": "第32條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/522.wav", + "text": "是不是照行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/523.wav", + "text": "修正意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/524.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/525.wav", + "text": "這個都有納入大家的意見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/526.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/527.wav", + "text": "\n接下來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/528.wav", + "text": "勞動部是建議照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/529.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/530.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/531.wav", + "text": "我們就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/532.wav", + "text": "增訂第38條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/533.wav", + "text": "建議照行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/534.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/535.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/536.wav", + "text": "條在處罰的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/537.wav", + "text": "我們認為還是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/538.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/539.wav", + "text": "增加時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/540.wav", + "text": "的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/541.wav", + "text": "包括我們有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/542.wav", + "text": "雇主不得以降低其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/543.wav", + "text": "受僱者各項福利措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/544.wav", + "text": "之方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/545.wav", + "text": "規避第9條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/546.wav", + "text": "違反者處新臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/547.wav", + "text": "罰鍰到30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/548.wav", + "text": "元以上150萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/549.wav", + "text": "主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/550.wav", + "text": "在公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/551.wav", + "text": "布加害人的姓名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/552.wav", + "text": "名稱負責人姓名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/553.wav", + "text": "公告日期等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/554.wav", + "text": "相關的規定我們也希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/555.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/556.wav", + "text": "辦法接受我們是建議要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/557.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/558.wav", + "text": "我也認為在委員會的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/559.wav", + "text": "林為洲委員溫玉霞委員跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/560.wav", + "text": "賴香伶等5人所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/561.wav", + "text": "修正動議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/562.wav", + "text": "有提到一個非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/563.wav", + "text": "其他受僱者各項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/564.wav", + "text": "福利措施之方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/565.wav", + "text": "規避第9條之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/566.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/567.wav", + "text": "為什麼說很重要我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/568.wav", + "text": "嘉義縣警察局的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/569.wav", + "text": "偷拍案22個月來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/570.wav", + "text": "科長被降調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/571.wav", + "text": "他說是平階的叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/572.wav", + "text": "可是在警察的實務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/573.wav", + "text": "上面就會認為你從一個主管被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/574.wav", + "text": "降調為這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/575.wav", + "text": "然後就會蜚短流長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/576.wav", + "text": "各種流言都會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/577.wav", + "text": "了所以那種就是各種形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/578.wav", + "text": "我就舉這樣子一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/579.wav", + "text": "是讓各位知道為什麼要把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/580.wav", + "text": "放進去它是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/581.wav", + "text": "的用各種形式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/582.wav", + "text": "因為大部分你們都採納了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/583.wav", + "text": "但針對雇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/584.wav", + "text": "雇主用其他降低他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/585.wav", + "text": "的各種措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/586.wav", + "text": "這個部分為什麼不能放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/587.wav", + "text": "能夠說明一下嗎謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/588.wav", + "text": "王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/589.wav", + "text": "針對第38條之1我也想補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/590.wav", + "text": "雇主不得以降低其他受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/591.wav", + "text": "僱者的各項福利措施的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/592.wav", + "text": "當時在審查的時候就有提到像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/593.wav", + "text": "空服業當時在男性及女性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/594.wav", + "text": "福利政策在制服上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/595.wav", + "text": "給予的費用其實是不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/596.wav", + "text": "當時提出這樣子的反映之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/597.wav", + "text": "結果是把男性的費用降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/598.wav", + "text": "其實是希望能夠推動讓大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/599.wav", + "text": "一致地往前提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/600.wav", + "text": "一致地往前進步而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/601.wav", + "text": "因為有不公平的待遇之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/602.wav", + "text": "地差我覺得這其實是違反了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/603.wav", + "text": "我們的初衷希望能夠推動性平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/604.wav", + "text": "其實不含在薪資裡面因為薪資的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/605.wav", + "text": "比較清楚比較嚴謹所以當時是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/606.wav", + "text": "福利金的方式補充的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/607.wav", + "text": "但我們會認為這些福利措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/608.wav", + "text": "也應該要衡平也應該要兼顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/609.wav", + "text": "我們所謂性別平等的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/610.wav", + "text": "一個要思考的方式也希望能夠瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/611.wav", + "text": "為什麼最後還是覺得不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/612.wav", + "text": "請部長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/613.wav", + "text": "主席我就剛剛3位委員的提問說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/614.wav", + "text": "其實剛剛3位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/615.wav", + "text": "關心性別歧視的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/616.wav", + "text": "這我們也都認同但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/617.wav", + "text": "因為這次修法是性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/618.wav", + "text": "騷擾防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/619.wav", + "text": "性別歧視這個因為他們剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/620.wav", + "text": "的是第9條第9條是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/621.wav", + "text": "性工法的第二章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/622.wav", + "text": "性別歧視的禁止這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/623.wav", + "text": "範圍沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/624.wav", + "text": "我覺得委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/625.wav", + "text": "我本來是想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/626.wav", + "text": "因為我們這次還是focus在第三章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/627.wav", + "text": "性騷擾的防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/628.wav", + "text": "有關於性別歧視的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/629.wav", + "text": "我是認為下一次我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/630.wav", + "text": "可能整體的性別歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/631.wav", + "text": "再來做整體的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/632.wav", + "text": "部長我剛剛舉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/633.wav", + "text": "那個完全是他是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/634.wav", + "text": "偷拍案的被害人這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/635.wav", + "text": "就在性別工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/636.wav", + "text": "平等法裡面他是在職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/637.wav", + "text": "他在警察局裡面被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/638.wav", + "text": "偷拍了兩年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/639.wav", + "text": "也報導了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/640.wav", + "text": "委員如果是性騷擾的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/641.wav", + "text": "現行的第36" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/642.wav", + "text": "條就有寫說雇主不得因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/643.wav", + "text": "受僱者提出本法之申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/644.wav", + "text": "或協助他人申訴而予以解僱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/645.wav", + "text": "調職或其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/646.wav", + "text": "不利之處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/647.wav", + "text": "而且也有罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/648.wav", + "text": "第38條如果違反這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/649.wav", + "text": "個規定的話會處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/650.wav", + "text": "2萬元到30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/651.wav", + "text": "元的罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/652.wav", + "text": "我會提請那個申訴人再去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/653.wav", + "text": "員個案的部分我們再來了解可以幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/654.wav", + "text": "王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/655.wav", + "text": "性騷擾的性平法來修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/656.wav", + "text": "我覺得這定義有點奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/657.wav", + "text": "當然是因為有很多性騷擾的案件我們希望能夠修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/658.wav", + "text": "但是並不代表修法的時候我們只能處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/659.wav", + "text": "性騷擾的部分吧我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/660.wav", + "text": "在提修法版本的時候好像沒有限定說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/661.wav", + "text": "只能修性騷擾相關的其他性平法不能修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/662.wav", + "text": "這部分我們又認同的話為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/663.wav", + "text": "不能一併修而是必須要堅持到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/664.wav", + "text": "下次如果要針對性別歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/665.wav", + "text": "來修性工法的時候我們才能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/666.wav", + "text": "修這個部分我覺得我們修法其實一直都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/667.wav", + "text": "的部分應該要修正的部分就來修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/668.wav", + "text": "怎麼會是先有一個只能修某部法案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/669.wav", + "text": "的某個部分這是有明文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/670.wav", + "text": "的嗎我自己是不清楚這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/671.wav", + "text": "劉委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/672.wav", + "text": "我來請教一下剛剛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/673.wav", + "text": "所提到的第36條它真正的原旨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/674.wav", + "text": "說明一下因為在我們的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/675.wav", + "text": "其實性騷擾也是屬於性別歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/676.wav", + "text": "的一環兩個是沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/677.wav", + "text": "完全脫離的如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/678.wav", + "text": "要對雇主牽涉到性別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/679.wav", + "text": "工作的不平等或者是牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/680.wav", + "text": "性騷擾的部分當然應該受到同樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/681.wav", + "text": "的處罰甚至要加重所以是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/682.wav", + "text": "請部長再說明一下因為剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/683.wav", + "text": "部長在第一次說明的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/684.wav", + "text": "針對有一些委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/685.wav", + "text": "各項福利措施在第36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/686.wav", + "text": "裡面已經有規範了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/687.wav", + "text": "那你規範的方式是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/688.wav", + "text": "可以再說明一下如果能夠涵蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/689.wav", + "text": "你剛剛所說的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/690.wav", + "text": "不得降低其他受僱者各項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/691.wav", + "text": "福利措施包括要調職轉職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/692.wav", + "text": "或降職或是減薪等等這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/693.wav", + "text": "如果可以涵蓋在內的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/694.wav", + "text": "我認為一條條文就可以處理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/695.wav", + "text": "不用再多說多做一些條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/696.wav", + "text": "會有點畫蛇添足是不是再請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/697.wav", + "text": "部長多做補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/698.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/699.wav", + "text": "部長我先問你一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/700.wav", + "text": "有關於不得降低其他受僱者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/701.wav", + "text": "各項福利措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/702.wav", + "text": "在勞基法上面就有規定得很嚴格了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/703.wav", + "text": "嘛是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/704.wav", + "text": "在勞基法上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/705.wav", + "text": "本來你要降低各種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/706.wav", + "text": "福利措施這個很嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/707.wav", + "text": "任何勞動條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/708.wav", + "text": "的更動一定要經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/709.wav", + "text": "當事人同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/710.wav", + "text": "那很嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/711.wav", + "text": "他講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/712.wav", + "text": "和勞基法那邊比較相似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/713.wav", + "text": "放在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/714.wav", + "text": "我是覺得立法例上有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/715.wav", + "text": "好那就請你綜合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/716.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/717.wav", + "text": "我們就來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/718.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/719.wav", + "text": "如果是因為性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/720.wav", + "text": "跟性騷相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/721.wav", + "text": "而有這些對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/722.wav", + "text": "對待的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/723.wav", + "text": "第36條的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/724.wav", + "text": "就很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/725.wav", + "text": "提出本法之申訴或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/726.wav", + "text": "協助他人申訴而予以解僱調職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/727.wav", + "text": "或其他不利之處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/728.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說如果各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/729.wav", + "text": "所講的案子是跟性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/730.wav", + "text": "有關的會在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/731.wav", + "text": "性別歧視的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/732.wav", + "text": "我們也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/733.wav", + "text": "因為我們這次說真的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/734.wav", + "text": "我們為了跟其他處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/735.wav", + "text": "要平衡的話其實要整體來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/736.wav", + "text": "如果單修這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/737.wav", + "text": "而且是修到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/738.wav", + "text": "跟性別歧視相關的那會不會整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/739.wav", + "text": "會有失衡的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/740.wav", + "text": "勞基法規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/741.wav", + "text": "我要補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/742.wav", + "text": "部長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/743.wav", + "text": "其實第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/744.wav", + "text": "我們第38條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/745.wav", + "text": "第1項沒有動它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/746.wav", + "text": "像是規定雇主違反第7條到第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/747.wav", + "text": "啦所以不是沒罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/748.wav", + "text": "而且罰滿重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/749.wav", + "text": "是30萬到150萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/750.wav", + "text": "我要先說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/751.wav", + "text": "這個部分是有處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/752.wav", + "text": "第9條有處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/753.wav", + "text": "所以王委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/754.wav", + "text": "應該是不用擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/755.wav", + "text": "我們在第1項就有處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/756.wav", + "text": "這次沒有動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/757.wav", + "text": "這樣是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/758.wav", + "text": "大家同意通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/759.wav", + "text": "還是要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/760.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/761.wav", + "text": "增訂第38條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/762.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/763.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/764.wav", + "text": "增訂第38條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/765.wav", + "text": "是不是照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/766.wav", + "text": "勞動部的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/767.wav", + "text": "照行政院版修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/768.wav", + "text": "時力的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/769.wav", + "text": "在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/770.wav", + "text": "增訂的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/771.wav", + "text": "最後一項─第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/772.wav", + "text": "依前二條第1項及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/773.wav", + "text": "第2項規定裁處罰鍰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/774.wav", + "text": "應審酌與違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/775.wav", + "text": "行為有關之人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/776.wav", + "text": "違反情節累計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/777.wav", + "text": "違法次數之金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/778.wav", + "text": "金額為量罰輕重之標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/779.wav", + "text": "希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/780.wav", + "text": "將這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/781.wav", + "text": "把它加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/782.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/783.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/784.wav", + "text": "在裁處罰鍰的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/785.wav", + "text": "應該審酌的這些情節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/786.wav", + "text": "一般行政機關在裁處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/787.wav", + "text": "時都會審酌其實不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/788.wav", + "text": "特別再規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/789.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/790.wav", + "text": "沒有意見這一條就通過好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/791.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/792.wav", + "text": "\n接下來第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/793.wav", + "text": "建議照行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/794.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/795.wav", + "text": "\n我就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/796.wav", + "text": "有意見再隨時提出來修正好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/797.wav", + "text": "\n協商主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/798.wav", + "text": "併案審查行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/799.wav", + "text": "函請審議性別工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/800.wav", + "text": "平等法部分條文修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/801.wav", + "text": "一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/802.wav", + "text": "協商通過條文第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/803.wav", + "text": "增訂第三十二條之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/804.wav", + "text": "增訂第三十八條之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/805.wav", + "text": "如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/806.wav", + "text": "\n二照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/807.wav", + "text": "法案名稱第2條增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/808.wav", + "text": "第十三條之1第三十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/809.wav", + "text": "\n三保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/810.wav", + "text": "第十三條第三十八條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/811.wav", + "text": "\n四其餘均照審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/812.wav", + "text": "\n五本案院會進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/813.wav", + "text": "時協商通過部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/814.wav", + "text": "宣讀後均予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/815.wav", + "text": "保留部分均暫保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/816.wav", + "text": "保留部分院會進行處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/817.wav", + "text": "由各黨團推派1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/818.wav", + "text": "人依時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/819.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/820.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/821.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團順序輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/822.wav", + "text": "每人發言時間為3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/823.wav", + "text": "發言完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/824.wav", + "text": "各該保留條文均不再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/825.wav", + "text": "並依上開黨團順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/826.wav", + "text": "進行各保留條文黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/827.wav", + "text": "版本之處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/828.wav", + "text": "\n六本案各黨團及委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/829.wav", + "text": "提案及修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/830.wav", + "text": "均列入公報紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/831.wav", + "text": "\n七檢附本案立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/832.wav", + "text": "說明1份如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/833.wav", + "text": "等一下馬上繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/834.wav", + "text": "有需要去洗手間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/835.wav", + "text": "的就去一下休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/836.wav", + "text": "啦不要太不人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/837.wav", + "text": "性騷擾防治法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/838.wav", + "text": "首��介紹衛生福利部部長薛瑞元先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/839.wav", + "text": "再來介紹行政院人事行政總處副人事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/840.wav", + "text": "懷敍先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/841.wav", + "text": "介紹完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/842.wav", + "text": "是不是照衛福部建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/843.wav", + "text": "\n請游委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/844.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/845.wav", + "text": "很多因為宗教信仰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/846.wav", + "text": "或是假宗教之名行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/847.wav", + "text": "大家平常都會給予完全的信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/848.wav", + "text": "而去尋求宗教的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/849.wav", + "text": "身心狀況特別脆弱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/850.wav", + "text": "的所以我們當時所有朝野的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/851.wav", + "text": "權勢性騷擾指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/852.wav", + "text": "對於因教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/853.wav", + "text": "醫療公務業務求職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/854.wav", + "text": "好像只有衛福部是堅決反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/855.wav", + "text": "就可以涵蓋在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/856.wav", + "text": "在我們的社會上是比較特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/857.wav", + "text": "的我們希望在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/858.wav", + "text": "真正正派的宗教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/859.wav", + "text": "如果照衛福部這樣的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/860.wav", + "text": "那就只要講指對於因教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/861.wav", + "text": "直接接或其他相類關係就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/862.wav", + "text": "但沒有嘛你們的條文前面也列舉滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/863.wav", + "text": "我不知道他們為什麼這麼堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/864.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/865.wav", + "text": "針對本條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/866.wav", + "text": "大概有三個地方可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/867.wav", + "text": "我們要討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/868.wav", + "text": "第一個是一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/869.wav", + "text": "性侵害犯罪以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/870.wav", + "text": "對其他人實施違反其意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/871.wav", + "text": "而與性或性別有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/872.wav", + "text": "范雲委員有做一些文字調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/873.wav", + "text": "寫在說明欄裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/874.wav", + "text": "這一點我們等一下再討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/875.wav", + "text": "\n第二點有關於宗教問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/876.wav", + "text": "等其他相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/877.wav", + "text": "我們在說明欄也改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/878.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/879.wav", + "text": "其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/880.wav", + "text": "其他相類關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/881.wav", + "text": "如因演藝活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/882.wav", + "text": "政治活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/883.wav", + "text": "政黨宗教信仰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/884.wav", + "text": "偶像崇拜等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/885.wav", + "text": "利用權勢或機會對其為性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/886.wav", + "text": "把這個範圍再擴大一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/887.wav", + "text": "解釋清楚一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/888.wav", + "text": "你只有講到宗教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/889.wav", + "text": "在說明欄寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/890.wav", + "text": "\n另外司法院對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/891.wav", + "text": "最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/892.wav", + "text": "倒數第二行監督照護指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/893.wav", + "text": "之人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/894.wav", + "text": "可能有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/895.wav", + "text": "而要增加一些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/896.wav", + "text": "等一下請司法院說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/897.wav", + "text": "大概是這三個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/898.wav", + "text": "所謂與性或性別有關的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/899.wav", + "text": "性傾向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/900.wav", + "text": "性別特質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/901.wav", + "text": "性別認同的相關行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/902.wav", + "text": "這部分我們就把它放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/903.wav", + "text": "如果又要寫到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/904.wav", + "text": "法條文字裡面的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/905.wav", + "text": "其實就會變成非常冗長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/906.wav", + "text": "\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/907.wav", + "text": "有委員提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/908.wav", + "text": "光是把宗教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/909.wav", + "text": "列進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/910.wav", + "text": "這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/911.wav", + "text": "我們提出來修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/912.wav", + "text": "其實也包括像演藝活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/913.wav", + "text": "政治活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/914.wav", + "text": "政黨等這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/915.wav", + "text": "其實也應該都算在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/916.wav", + "text": "裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/917.wav", + "text": "但是如果這樣子再列下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/918.wav", + "text": "的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/919.wav", + "text": "越列會越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/920.wav", + "text": "現在司法院這邊也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/921.wav", + "text": "意見想要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/922.wav", + "text": "列進來的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/923.wav", + "text": "越列越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/924.wav", + "text": "列舉不完會有這樣子的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/925.wav", + "text": "司法院少年及家事廳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/926.wav", + "text": "謝廳長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/927.wav", + "text": "整個刑罰體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/928.wav", + "text": "尤其是現在性騷擾防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/929.wav", + "text": "第25條其實是一個特別刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/930.wav", + "text": "這個特別刑法要回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/931.wav", + "text": "我們刑法的第202條有個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/932.wav", + "text": "權勢性侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/933.wav", + "text": "關於刑法第202條各位如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/934.wav", + "text": "手上有資料的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/935.wav", + "text": "會看到是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/936.wav", + "text": "比照現在的性騷法第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/937.wav", + "text": "就會發現它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/938.wav", + "text": "它對於權勢性侵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/939.wav", + "text": "有親屬監護教養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/940.wav", + "text": "但是在我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/941.wav", + "text": "性騷法第2條並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/942.wav", + "text": "這個在我們的罪刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/943.wav", + "text": "法定還有這樣一個犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/944.wav", + "text": "行為的行為態樣當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/945.wav", + "text": "如果沒有透過法律保留的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/946.wav", + "text": "尤其是在特別刑法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/947.wav", + "text": "把它明確規範將來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/948.wav", + "text": "可能會在事實認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/949.wav", + "text": "跟構成要件的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/950.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們其實對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/951.wav", + "text": "有一個建議的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/952.wav", + "text": "可能要去參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/953.wav", + "text": "刑法第202條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/954.wav", + "text": "因為我們知道性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/955.wav", + "text": "其實是在猥褻行為之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/956.wav", + "text": "情節是比較輕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/957.wav", + "text": "修正動議是關於第2條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/958.wav", + "text": "等一下法務部應該也有一個關於第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/959.wav", + "text": "刑事廳的文法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/960.wav", + "text": "法理的補充謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/961.wav", + "text": "委員們大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/962.wav", + "text": "我是司法院刑事廳文家倩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/963.wav", + "text": "今天主要針對第2條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/964.wav", + "text": "希望提出一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/965.wav", + "text": "修正主要是昨天有跟法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/966.wav", + "text": "再溝通過今天有再跟法務部溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/967.wav", + "text": "因為第2條跟第25條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/968.wav", + "text": "的權勢性騷擾罪是連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/969.wav", + "text": "所以就是說第2條的構成要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/970.wav", + "text": "要夠明確我們才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/971.wav", + "text": "適用到第25條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/972.wav", + "text": "刑法處遇才能夠有法律明確性原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/973.wav", + "text": "構成要件不夠明確的話到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/974.wav", + "text": "這樣子的行為態樣要不要受到處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/975.wav", + "text": "可能會有一點疑義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/976.wav", + "text": "因親屬監護教養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/977.wav", + "text": "還有加一個扶助為什麼要加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/978.wav", + "text": "這個主要是因為在刑法的體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/979.wav", + "text": "上在刑法第202條權勢性交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/980.wav", + "text": "猥褻是有這些犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/981.wav", + "text": "權勢性騷擾沒有這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/982.wav", + "text": "犯罪態樣這樣是表示這些犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/983.wav", + "text": "態樣不需要被處罰嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/984.wav", + "text": "可能會解釋可以利用相類關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/985.wav", + "text": "去解釋可是因為刑法第202" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/986.wav", + "text": "條它也有一個相類關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/987.wav", + "text": "但是刑法第202條在有相類關係的前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/988.wav", + "text": "下它還是有列舉了親屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/989.wav", + "text": "監護教養救濟扶助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/990.wav", + "text": "也就是說如果今天我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/991.wav", + "text": "性騷擾防治法裡面的權勢性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/992.wav", + "text": "沒有這些態樣的時候有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/993.wav", + "text": "會被理解成為是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/994.wav", + "text": "有意的排除如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/995.wav", + "text": "有意排除掉這些親屬監護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/996.wav", + "text": "教養救濟扶助等這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/997.wav", + "text": "狀況不會列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/998.wav", + "text": "權勢性騷擾的範圍的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/999.wav", + "text": "可能會導致權勢性騷擾的處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1000.wav", + "text": "範圍過窄因為權勢性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1001.wav", + "text": "交猥褻其實是比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1002.wav", + "text": "嚴重的犯罪態樣如果比較嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1003.wav", + "text": "的犯罪態樣都處罰這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1004.wav", + "text": "類型的話為什麼比較輕的權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1005.wav", + "text": "勢性騷擾舉重以明輕理論上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1006.wav", + "text": "比較輕的權勢性騷擾的處罰範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1007.wav", + "text": "應該是更廣泛的才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1008.wav", + "text": "我們是基於法律明確性原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1009.wav", + "text": "規範清楚因為剛好法務部等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1010.wav", + "text": "會提到第25條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1011.wav", + "text": "他們提出的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1012.wav", + "text": "動議就是把第25條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1013.wav", + "text": "修正為利用第2條第2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1014.wav", + "text": "項之權勢或機會而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1015.wav", + "text": "犯之所以關鍵會在於第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1016.wav", + "text": "第2項到底要怎麼解釋的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1017.wav", + "text": "所以我們的意見如同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1018.wav", + "text": "剛才所述謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1019.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1020.wav", + "text": "我請問一下讓它說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1021.wav", + "text": "因為剛才司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1022.wav", + "text": "有解釋過它的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1023.wav", + "text": "了我的建議是它所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1024.wav", + "text": "謂的動議部分因為我這邊沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1025.wav", + "text": "看到因為要等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1026.wav", + "text": "拿到了之後它再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1027.wav", + "text": "然後我們對照它的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1028.wav", + "text": "我們才可以知道它在講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1029.wav", + "text": "我們現在手頭上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1030.wav", + "text": "沒有資料它在講東西的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1031.wav", + "text": "對不然我們不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1032.wav", + "text": "它在講什麼東西好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1033.wav", + "text": "暫時保留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1034.wav", + "text": "先討論後面的好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1035.wav", + "text": "等一下回頭啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1036.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請看第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1037.wav", + "text": "第3條衛福部建議照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1038.wav", + "text": "行政院版通過大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1039.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見就通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1040.wav", + "text": "\n現在看第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1041.wav", + "text": "第6條衛福部也建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1042.wav", + "text": "照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1043.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1044.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見我們也通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1045.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請大家看第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1046.wav", + "text": "第7條衛福部也建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1047.wav", + "text": "照行政院版修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1048.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長跟各黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1049.wav", + "text": "人數門檻的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1050.wav", + "text": "機構獨自承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1051.wav", + "text": "主管機構也要主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1052.wav", + "text": "就是有一些所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1053.wav", + "text": "這個部分應該還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1054.wav", + "text": "申訴的管道能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1055.wav", + "text": "因為臺灣還是以中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1056.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們希望行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1057.wav", + "text": "還是就他們現在的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1058.wav", + "text": "再說明清楚好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1059.wav", + "text": "你的意思是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1060.wav", + "text": "我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1061.wav", + "text": "提案是第7條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1062.wav", + "text": "就是政府機關機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1063.wav", + "text": "部隊學校機構或僱用人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1064.wav", + "text": "應該防治性騷擾行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1065.wav", + "text": "的發生於知悉有性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1066.wav", + "text": "的情形要採取立即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1067.wav", + "text": "有效的糾正跟補救措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1068.wav", + "text": "尤其前項措施應該設立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1069.wav", + "text": "申訴管道協調處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1070.wav", + "text": "且訂定性騷擾防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1071.wav", + "text": "措施並公開揭示之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1072.wav", + "text": "尤其為了預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1073.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關應訂定性騷擾防治的準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1074.wav", + "text": "其內容應該包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1075.wav", + "text": "申訴管道跟懲處辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1076.wav", + "text": "還有教育訓練的方案跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1077.wav", + "text": "\n之前跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1078.wav", + "text": "主管機關溝通的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1079.wav", + "text": "好像有談到就是他們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1080.wav", + "text": "有受限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1081.wav", + "text": "他們有一個相關的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1082.wav", + "text": "對於這些中小型企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1083.wav", + "text": "的保護還有申訴管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1084.wav", + "text": "應該要把它明確化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1085.wav", + "text": "在上位法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1086.wav", + "text": "不要去做這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1087.wav", + "text": "衛福部要不要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1088.wav", + "text": "再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1089.wav", + "text": "第7條主要是在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1090.wav", + "text": "場所的主人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1091.wav", + "text": "除了組織的成員之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1092.wav", + "text": "還有受僱人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1093.wav", + "text": "十人以上才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1094.wav", + "text": "需要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1095.wav", + "text": "\n我打個比方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1096.wav", + "text": "一間麵店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1097.wav", + "text": "就是夫妻兩個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1098.wav", + "text": "也沒有受僱人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1099.wav", + "text": "就是兩個成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1100.wav", + "text": "頂多就五個人六個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1101.wav", + "text": "只有兩個桌子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1102.wav", + "text": "這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1103.wav", + "text": "加起來不到十個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1104.wav", + "text": "你也要他設申訴管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1105.wav", + "text": "啦所以現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1106.wav", + "text": "那還是應該要有配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1107.wav", + "text": "比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1108.wav", + "text": "地方政府還是用什麼樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1109.wav", + "text": "讓他有一個申訴的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1110.wav", + "text": "可以去依循���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1111.wav", + "text": "很多中小型企業怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1112.wav", + "text": "企業是用它裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1113.wav", + "text": "不管是企業或是組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1114.wav", + "text": "你不能因為人數的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1115.wav", + "text": "就沒有把它納入管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1116.wav", + "text": "否則很多五個人六個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1117.wav", + "text": "的你說九個人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1118.wav", + "text": "可能他本身就已經相對弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1119.wav", + "text": "可能對於老闆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1120.wav", + "text": "組織裡面也有從屬關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1121.wav", + "text": "的他就不敢去反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1122.wav", + "text": "映這個部分如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1123.wav", + "text": "你沒有辦法這樣去規定的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1124.wav", + "text": "有沒有相關的配套措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1125.wav", + "text": "我們是認為在上位法上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1126.wav", + "text": "不應該去把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1127.wav", + "text": "做人數上的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1128.wav", + "text": "稍等一下還有人要發表意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1129.wav", + "text": "再來請林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1130.wav", + "text": "第2項第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1131.wav", + "text": "協助被害人申訴及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1132.wav", + "text": "保全相關證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1133.wav", + "text": "原來行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1134.wav", + "text": "版本的條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1135.wav", + "text": "有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1136.wav", + "text": "於必要時保全相關證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1137.wav", + "text": "委員會開會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1138.wav", + "text": "就把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1139.wav", + "text": "於必要時去掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1140.wav", + "text": "就是說他不能有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1141.wav", + "text": "主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1142.wav", + "text": "或是機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1143.wav", + "text": "說他可以決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1144.wav", + "text": "什麼是必要時什麼是不必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1145.wav", + "text": "那時候大家有討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1146.wav", + "text": "所以把這個於必要時去掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1147.wav", + "text": "就是說你就是要協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1148.wav", + "text": "被害人申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1149.wav", + "text": "及保全相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1150.wav", + "text": "證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1151.wav", + "text": "所以才會有這個保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1152.wav", + "text": "條文寫在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1153.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望是按照這個保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1154.wav", + "text": "條文這樣的修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1155.wav", + "text": "來通過而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1156.wav", + "text": "按照原來行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1157.wav", + "text": "條文這個是我們委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1158.wav", + "text": "有討論過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1159.wav", + "text": "所以不是原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1160.wav", + "text": "其實時代力量黨團的版本也是比較類似民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1161.wav", + "text": "有提到如果它是一個麵攤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1162.wav", + "text": "攤只有兩個人在上班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1163.wav", + "text": "不管你了不好意思抱歉是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1164.wav", + "text": "當然不是嘛既然是三個人五個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1165.wav", + "text": "其實我們也應該要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1166.wav", + "text": "當然我可以理解在人數少的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1167.wav", + "text": "他可能沒有辦法成立什麼委員會等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1168.wav", + "text": "申訴委員會或處理委員會等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1169.wav", + "text": "的確是有困難的但我們還是得要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1170.wav", + "text": "給他有一個處理的機制或者是協助的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1171.wav", + "text": "所以時代力量黨團版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1172.wav", + "text": "的寫法是會希望能夠在這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1173.wav", + "text": "公眾得以出入的場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1174.wav", + "text": "應該設立申訴管道協調處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1175.wav", + "text": "這管道有可能是在我們的公部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1176.wav", + "text": "但是也要採取適當的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1177.wav", + "text": "來協助在十人以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1178.wav", + "text": "假設發生這樣的事情的時候我們仍然必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1179.wav", + "text": "要給協助\n我想大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1180.wav", + "text": "應該理解的是我們並不是說十人以下發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1181.wav", + "text": "就不好意思你倒楣你自己要在小公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1182.wav", + "text": "工作絕對不是這樣的意旨所以我們會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1183.wav", + "text": "10人以下也應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1184.wav", + "text": "不論幾個人其實都應該有這樣的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1185.wav", + "text": "或是這樣的處理機制當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1186.wav", + "text": "並不是強制說10人以下也要有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1187.wav", + "text": "很清楚的委員會成立等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1188.wav", + "text": "的部分但是這個處理的機制和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1189.wav", + "text": "適當的措施我覺得是絕對必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1190.wav", + "text": "而且跟人數是沒有相關性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1191.wav", + "text": "我想請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1192.wav", + "text": "再說明一下像剛剛邱臣遠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1193.wav", + "text": "在問的時候我就直接想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1194.wav", + "text": "我們在上一場處理有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1195.wav", + "text": "所規範的部分是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1196.wav", + "text": "受僱者跟勞雇關係的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1197.wav", + "text": "它當然準用包括有勞基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1198.wav", + "text": "在內然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1199.wav", + "text": "特別處理到性別平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1200.wav", + "text": "衛福部所處理的部分尤其是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1201.wav", + "text": "這一條所要處理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1202.wav", + "text": "是特別指公眾出入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1203.wav", + "text": "的場所跟公共場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1204.wav", + "text": "所以它在內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1205.wav", + "text": "這些族群的人不一定是屬於老闆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1206.wav", + "text": "僱員或者是有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1207.wav", + "text": "不是剛才部長所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1208.wav", + "text": "處理這樣的預防措施的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1209.wav", + "text": "在原來行政院所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1210.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1211.wav", + "text": "衛福部要訂定相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1212.wav", + "text": "準則的時候大概就不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1213.wav", + "text": "像有所謂的10人以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1214.wav", + "text": "或30人以上這樣子必須要有公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1215.wav", + "text": "的防治措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1216.wav", + "text": "然後必須要有協調的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1217.wav", + "text": "要通知主管機關或是通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1218.wav", + "text": "警察機關到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1219.wav", + "text": "也就是說你要設立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1220.wav", + "text": "如果確實是公共場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1221.wav", + "text": "在那邊吃飯吃麵吃點心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1222.wav", + "text": "而真的有性騷擾事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1223.wav", + "text": "發生的時候可以找誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1224.wav", + "text": "幫忙但是你把它訂死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1225.wav", + "text": "的時候就會跟原來的性別平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1226.wav", + "text": "工作法裡面的非常相像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1227.wav", + "text": "所以我要跟各位委員講的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1228.wav", + "text": "是要給它弄清楚它這個是屬於公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1229.wav", + "text": "共出入的場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1230.wav", + "text": "而不是屬於中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1231.wav", + "text": "小企業的企業機構裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1232.wav", + "text": "的部分所以它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1233.wav", + "text": "處置的方法本來就不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1234.wav", + "text": "該地的主管機關是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1235.wav", + "text": "屬於地方政府或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1236.wav", + "text": "衛生局或者是警察局你要把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1237.wav", + "text": "說清楚講明白你只要說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1238.wav", + "text": "講明白一個是性騷擾防治法適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1239.wav", + "text": "就可以了而不必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1240.wav", + "text": "把所有的文字全部都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1241.wav", + "text": "是不是就請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1242.wav", + "text": "相關部門來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1243.wav", + "text": "看誰要先說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1244.wav", + "text": "\n請衛福部我還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1245.wav", + "text": "再強調一下這個就是所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1246.wav", + "text": "的場所主人即公共場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1247.wav", + "text": "或公眾可以出入的場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1248.wav", + "text": "所以在計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1249.wav", + "text": "人數的時候是包括它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1250.wav", + "text": "內部人員跟外部顧客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1251.wav", + "text": "加起來10人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1252.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1253.wav", + "text": "至於如果它的規模小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1254.wav", + "text": "不會有到10個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1255.wav", + "text": "比方在那個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1256.wav", + "text": "如果發生性騷擾事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1257.wav", + "text": "的時候可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1258.wav", + "text": "通報到哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1259.wav", + "text": "專線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1260.wav", + "text": "哪一個機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1261.wav", + "text": "但是要在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1262.wav", + "text": "設立申訴管道來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1263.wav", + "text": "協調處理恐怕就做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1264.wav", + "text": "啦所以它頂多是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1265.wav", + "text": "可以做到這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1266.wav", + "text": "因為出出入入的人加起來就不到10個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1267.wav", + "text": "設立一個管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1268.wav", + "text": "來處理大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1269.wav", + "text": "做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1270.wav", + "text": "啦所以會有配套措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1271.wav", + "text": "比方我們可以印個貼紙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1272.wav", + "text": "貼在它那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1273.wav", + "text": "馬上處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1274.wav", + "text": "可以打110" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1275.wav", + "text": "報警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1276.wav", + "text": "社會局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1277.wav", + "text": "或者是113" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1278.wav", + "text": "諮詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1279.wav", + "text": "那也可以找社會局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1280.wav", + "text": "來做這個案件的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1281.wav", + "text": "意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1282.wav", + "text": "那是第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1283.wav", + "text": "法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1284.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1285.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1286.wav", + "text": "必要時要去掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1287.wav", + "text": "不是照原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1288.wav", + "text": "保全相關證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1289.wav", + "text": "保全相關證據是一定要���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1290.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1291.wav", + "text": "通知警察機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1292.wav", + "text": "還是需要他們剛剛唸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1293.wav", + "text": "照行政院版通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1294.wav", + "text": "那就不是行政院照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1295.wav", + "text": "修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1296.wav", + "text": "聽了衛福部的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1297.wav", + "text": "針對公共場所的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1298.wav", + "text": "我們當然也沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1299.wav", + "text": "一定要去設立管道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1300.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得重點還是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1301.wav", + "text": "政策的落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1302.wav", + "text": "也就是你們的配套措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1303.wav", + "text": "不管你是要貼貼紙還是加強宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1304.wav", + "text": "我希望你們還是要定期去盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1305.wav", + "text": "到時候這個申訴案件的數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1306.wav", + "text": "跟實際發生的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1307.wav", + "text": "定時地去追蹤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1308.wav", + "text": "因為問題常常都是藏在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1309.wav", + "text": "小角落裡面在黑暗的角落裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1310.wav", + "text": "確實這種問題會比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1311.wav", + "text": "但是如果是一般的中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1312.wav", + "text": "或小型的受僱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1313.wav", + "text": "有其他的法律去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1314.wav", + "text": "訂定我覺得那個執行上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1315.wav", + "text": "還是要定期地去管控和盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1316.wav", + "text": "好不好這個部分我們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1317.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1318.wav", + "text": "這個所謂的公共場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1319.wav", + "text": "假設是像貼貼紙這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1320.wav", + "text": "它不算是所謂的協調處理的申訴管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1321.wav", + "text": "嘛因為就我們之前的理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1322.wav", + "text": "它只要有處理有貼了就算是它已經有設立了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1323.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1324.wav", + "text": "如果現在認為10人以上才必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1325.wav", + "text": "10人以下我們也覺得應該要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1326.wav", + "text": "或用配套措施來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1327.wav", + "text": "但是這個配套措施在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1328.wav", + "text": "以及它的強制性在哪裡其實我是沒有看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1329.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的這個公共場所當然是包含了服務的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1330.wav", + "text": "情況下里民活動中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1331.wav", + "text": "可能就會只有一兩個志工在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1332.wav", + "text": "只有民政課裡面的幾個人而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1333.wav", + "text": "這樣算不算10人以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1334.wav", + "text": "\n發生類似這樣的情況時我們仍然必須給他一個協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1335.wav", + "text": "的空間或是一個管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1336.wav", + "text": "而這個管道就如同我剛剛說的我打110" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1337.wav", + "text": "打相關的申訴專線或是縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1338.wav", + "text": "的申訴專線算不算是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1339.wav", + "text": "這個協調處理機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1340.wav", + "text": "如果不是它叫做什麼規範在哪邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1341.wav", + "text": "好說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1342.wav", + "text": "不叫設立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1343.wav", + "text": "申訴管道來協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1344.wav", + "text": "因為這裡有一個設立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1345.wav", + "text": "的機制現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1346.wav", + "text": "10人以上的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1347.wav", + "text": "要設立這個管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1348.wav", + "text": "但是10人以下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1349.wav", + "text": "只有一個警示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1350.wav", + "text": "這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1351.wav", + "text": "個還是不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1352.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1353.wav", + "text": "我想這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1354.wav", + "text": "文字的寫法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1355.wav", + "text": "至於我剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1356.wav", + "text": "這些配套措施要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1357.wav", + "text": "落實在10人以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1358.wav", + "text": "的確不是很好寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1359.wav", + "text": "寫在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1360.wav", + "text": "也可以就會變成在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1361.wav", + "text": "公共場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1362.wav", + "text": "的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1363.wav", + "text": "該怎麼樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1364.wav", + "text": "這個我想在說明欄也可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1365.wav", + "text": "里民活動中心不可能只有10人以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1366.wav", + "text": "就不要用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1367.wav", + "text": "本案要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1368.wav", + "text": "那就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1369.wav", + "text": "還是怎麼樣再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1370.wav", + "text": "在說明欄補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1371.wav", + "text": "我還是希望文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1372.wav", + "text": "在本文裡面應該要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1373.wav", + "text": "因為不能只有談到10人30人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1374.wav", + "text": "而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1375.wav", + "text": "好沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1376.wav", + "text": "就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1377.wav", + "text": "你們大家再溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1378.wav", + "text": "文字看要怎麼拿捏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1379.wav", + "text": "看是要在說明欄還是要在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1380.wav", + "text": "你們再協調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1381.wav", + "text": "本條就暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1382.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1383.wav", + "text": "\n請看第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1384.wav", + "text": "沒意見照衛福部的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1385.wav", + "text": "行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1386.wav", + "text": "第8條我可不可請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1387.wav", + "text": "所說的政府機關(構)部隊學校機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1388.wav", + "text": "或僱用人\n這個部分有沒有包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1389.wav", + "text": "所謂的幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1390.wav", + "text": "托兒所幼兒園算不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1391.wav", + "text": "怎麼沒聲音了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1392.wav", + "text": "麻煩回應一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1393.wav", + "text": "第8條請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1394.wav", + "text": "因為性別平等教育法裡面的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1395.wav", + "text": "沒有包括幼兒園跟托兒所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1396.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分包不包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1397.wav", + "text": "因為性騷擾在這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1398.wav", + "text": "機構裡面發生的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1399.wav", + "text": "也是有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1400.wav", + "text": "請教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1401.wav", + "text": "教育部補充說明性別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1402.wav", + "text": "的適用範圍是各級學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1403.wav", + "text": "所以從國小國中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1404.wav", + "text": "高中到大專以上都算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1405.wav", + "text": "不過幼兒園的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1406.wav", + "text": "它不屬於性平法的適用範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1407.wav", + "text": "它如果發生性騷擾事件的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1408.wav", + "text": "會先從性騷法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1409.wav", + "text": "也就是由衛福部來當主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1410.wav", + "text": "機關對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1411.wav", + "text": "我們幼兒教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1412.wav", + "text": "照顧法裡頭有規範處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1413.wav", + "text": "的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1414.wav", + "text": "但是幼兒教育法裡面有寫到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1415.wav", + "text": "性騷擾這幾個字嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1416.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話應該移由原來的主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1417.wav", + "text": "機關衛福部來主管有關性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1418.wav", + "text": "相關的議題吧是不是請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1419.wav", + "text": "衛福部來回應一下好不好我們不想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1420.wav", + "text": "把它漏掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1421.wav", + "text": "是在幼照法裡頭有特別包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1422.wav", + "text": "括他在幼兒園發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1423.wav", + "text": "性騷是幼照法可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1424.wav", + "text": "處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1425.wav", + "text": "好那沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1426.wav", + "text": "第8條就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1427.wav", + "text": "行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1428.wav", + "text": "\n請看第十四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1429.wav", + "text": "十四條如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1430.wav", + "text": "也照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1431.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見\n請林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1432.wav", + "text": "第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1433.wav", + "text": "這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1434.wav", + "text": "是最核心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1435.wav", + "text": "條文就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1436.wav", + "text": "要如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1437.wav", + "text": "申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1438.wav", + "text": "要向誰申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1439.wav", + "text": "大家都知道這一次我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1440.wav", + "text": "主要就是針對這一次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1441.wav", + "text": "#MeToo風潮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1442.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1443.wav", + "text": "那麼多例子裡面其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1444.wav", + "text": "我們最主要要修法解決的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1445.wav", + "text": "吃案的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1446.wav", + "text": "以及內部自我包庇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1447.wav", + "text": "機構自我包庇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1448.wav", + "text": "的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1449.wav", + "text": "按照這個紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1450.wav", + "text": "百分之八十以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1451.wav", + "text": "被性騷的人都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1452.wav", + "text": "去申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1453.wav", + "text": "為什麼因為認為申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1454.wav", + "text": "都無效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1455.wav", + "text": "所以我們才要修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1456.wav", + "text": "表示之前的法都沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1457.wav", + "text": "保護到被性騷的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1458.wav", + "text": "這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1459.wav", + "text": "申訴無門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1460.wav", + "text": "啊或是申訴無效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1461.wav", + "text": "不會開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1462.wav", + "text": "外部委員幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1463.wav", + "text": "內部委員幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1464.wav", + "text": "百分之八十都是這種例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1465.wav", + "text": "耶所以我們要解決這個核心問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1466.wav", + "text": "要讓被騷擾者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1467.wav", + "text": "能夠去申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1468.wav", + "text": "願意去申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1469.wav", + "text": "然後申訴之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1470.wav", + "text": "不會被吃案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1471.wav", + "text": "所以我說這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1472.wav", + "text": "是最核心的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1473.wav", + "text": "\n好我們來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1474.wav", + "text": "的時候事實上我們是反對這樣的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1475.wav", + "text": "因為那個跟原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1476.wav", + "text": "舊的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1477.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1478.wav", + "text": "要申訴的話要向誰申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1479.wav", + "text": "機關就只能向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1480.wav", + "text": "那個機關申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1481.wav", + "text": "那跟現在不是一樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1482.wav", + "text": "譬如行為人是一個教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1483.wav", + "text": "我現在隨便舉例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1484.wav", + "text": "就只能對學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1485.wav", + "text": "提申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1486.wav", + "text": "沒有外部的申訴管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1487.wav", + "text": "然後學校再去開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1488.wav", + "text": "跟現在的法律不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1489.wav", + "text": "一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1490.wav", + "text": "將來還是會有這種問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1491.wav", + "text": "機構名譽或利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1492.wav", + "text": "而不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1493.wav", + "text": "處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1494.wav", + "text": "然後造成吃案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1495.wav", + "text": "現在這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1496.wav", + "text": "還是對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1497.wav", + "text": "機構來提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1498.wav", + "text": "那時候我們是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1499.wav", + "text": "我等一下有第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1500.wav", + "text": "困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1501.wav", + "text": "啦你們如果覺得這樣就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1502.wav", + "text": "在內部去申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1503.wav", + "text": "只是把年限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1504.wav", + "text": "延長一年變成幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1505.wav", + "text": "然後申訴的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1506.wav", + "text": "還是同樣向現在法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1507.wav", + "text": "的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1508.wav", + "text": "內部如果不開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1509.wav", + "text": "那就還是不成案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1510.wav", + "text": "這樣有效嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1511.wav", + "text": "效嗎不要打假球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1512.wav", + "text": "啦如果要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1513.wav", + "text": "就要處理這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1514.wav", + "text": "好接下來請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1515.wav", + "text": "李委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1516.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1517.wav", + "text": "我想拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1518.wav", + "text": "衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1519.wav", + "text": "還有今天與會的不管是司法院也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1520.wav", + "text": "現在堅持的第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1521.wav", + "text": "其實你是併入原來第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1522.wav", + "text": "的部分把它也併入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1523.wav", + "text": "對嘛對不對為什麼都沒有人有反應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1524.wav", + "text": "是原來第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1525.wav", + "text": "也把它併進去了嗎\n對啊就講一聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1526.wav", + "text": "為什麼大家都沒有反應是什麼狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1527.wav", + "text": "好那我就要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1528.wav", + "text": "原來我們在提修正的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1529.wav", + "text": "因為有些人不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1530.wav", + "text": "識別性我們講要保密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1531.wav", + "text": "要去識別性而主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1532.wav", + "text": "除可依相關法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1533.wav", + "text": "請求協助其實我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1534.wav", + "text": "協助是不必要的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1535.wav", + "text": "侵權行為的話你可以主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1536.wav", + "text": "損害賠償林林總總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1537.wav", + "text": "它加上去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1538.wav", + "text": "我要請教司法院跟法務部的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1539.wav", + "text": "性騷擾事件發生之日起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1540.wav", + "text": "逾五年者不得提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1541.wav", + "text": "這跟原來侵權行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1542.wav", + "text": "法律上面他原來可以主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1543.wav", + "text": "侵權行為的10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1544.wav", + "text": "把它縮短的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1545.wav", + "text": "的專家在這裡簡單來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1546.wav", + "text": "修正之後從新從輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1547.wav", + "text": "修正之後性騷擾的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1548.wav", + "text": "可以減免以及可以主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1549.wav", + "text": "這是你們已經知道了還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1550.wav", + "text": "本來是可以主張的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1551.wav", + "text": "因為你這樣的規定之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1552.wav", + "text": "今天我們在這邊討論性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1553.wav", + "text": "事件民怨沸騰但是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1554.wav", + "text": "的修法究竟是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1555.wav", + "text": "解決民怨究竟是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1556.wav", + "text": "針對這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1557.wav", + "text": "是讓有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1558.wav", + "text": "問題的人可以很容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1559.wav", + "text": "跳脫他原來應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1560.wav", + "text": "有的責任有沒有這個顧慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1561.wav", + "text": "我並不是說一定有我只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1562.wav", + "text": "請教你有沒有這樣的顧慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1563.wav", + "text": "修法是不是真的能夠解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1564.wav", + "text": "問題還是虛晃一招" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1565.wav", + "text": "司法院跟法務部因為都是你們都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1566.wav", + "text": "法律人一般如果我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1567.wav", + "text": "提起訴訟我們撤回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1568.wav", + "text": "對不對司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1569.wav", + "text": "這問題很簡單你就先回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1570.wav", + "text": "是不是就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1571.wav", + "text": "我們撤回了之後可不可以再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1572.wav", + "text": "撤回之後可不可以再提我今天到法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1573.wav", + "text": "去提起一個\n還是我剛剛講的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1574.wav", + "text": "你沒有在聽不同的程序可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1575.wav", + "text": "會有不同的效果有些是會限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1576.wav", + "text": "好譬如說我請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1577.wav", + "text": "一個侵權行為的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1578.wav", + "text": "然後我撤回之後我可不可以再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1579.wav", + "text": "還沒經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1580.wav", + "text": "時效的部分他可不可以再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1581.wav", + "text": "可以可以對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1582.wav", + "text": "你講得很理直氣壯我就是等你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1583.wav", + "text": "在性騷擾的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1584.wav", + "text": "他撤回之後就不可以再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1585.wav", + "text": "究竟今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1586.wav", + "text": "修法把它修成這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1587.wav", + "text": "的目的在哪裡拜託回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1588.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1589.wav", + "text": "首先是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1590.wav", + "text": "林為洲委員所提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1591.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1592.wav", + "text": "你那個寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1593.wav", + "text": "和跟騷一樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1594.wav", + "text": "修正動議跟原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1595.wav", + "text": "完全不一樣的結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1596.wav", + "text": "現在把它結合在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1597.wav", + "text": "了所以前面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1598.wav", + "text": "跟院版是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1599.wav", + "text": "啦後面接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1600.wav", + "text": "多了一個警察機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1601.wav", + "text": "受理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1602.wav", + "text": "要進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1603.wav", + "text": "然後可以有一個所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1604.wav", + "text": "書面告誡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1605.wav", + "text": "要有這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1606.wav", + "text": "程序不過因為這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1607.wav", + "text": "有性騷擾行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1608.wav", + "text": "之犯罪嫌疑者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1609.wav", + "text": "有一點要去思考了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1610.wav", + "text": "就是說他經調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1611.wav", + "text": "有犯罪嫌疑的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1612.wav", + "text": "自然就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1613.wav", + "text": "刑事偵查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1614.wav", + "text": "刑事偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1615.wav", + "text": "程序的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1616.wav", + "text": "都可能會有像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1617.wav", + "text": "這些是可以來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1618.wav", + "text": "的但是如果經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1619.wav", + "text": "調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1620.wav", + "text": "性騷行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1621.wav", + "text": "但是還不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1622.wav", + "text": "犯罪行為的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1623.wav", + "text": "也要用這個方法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1624.wav", + "text": "如果要用的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1625.wav", + "text": "則這個文字就不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1626.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1627.wav", + "text": "一般的性騷擾案件的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1628.wav", + "text": "確他如果報警之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1629.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1630.wav", + "text": "跟騷法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1631.wav", + "text": "去給一個書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1632.wav", + "text": "書面告誡後面會有它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1633.wav", + "text": "效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1634.wav", + "text": "這類行為的時候會有保護令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1635.wav", + "text": "一個效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1636.wav", + "text": "性騷法裡面後面沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1637.wav", + "text": "所以開立這個書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1638.wav", + "text": "告誡的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1639.wav", + "text": "就不是那麼明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1640.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1641.wav", + "text": "也請委員再酌\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1642.wav", + "text": "李委員剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1643.wav", + "text": "有一部分是有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1644.wav", + "text": "司法院跟法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1645.wav", + "text": "他們的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1646.wav", + "text": "態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1647.wav", + "text": "第一個保密的部分你不願意保密的理由在哪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1648.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1649.wav", + "text": "第10條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1650.wav", + "text": "另外就是有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1651.wav", + "text": "程序的部分我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1652.wav", + "text": "侵權行為的部分是屬於民事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1653.wav", + "text": "這邊所訂定的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1654.wav", + "text": "在行政上面的申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1655.wav", + "text": "所謂它的���效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1656.wav", + "text": "其實是可以有不一樣的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1657.wav", + "text": "它有不一樣的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1658.wav", + "text": "所以我的問題是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1659.wav", + "text": "你當然可以有不同的期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1660.wav", + "text": "你今天規定的就是因為怕它不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1661.wav", + "text": "但我的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1662.wav", + "text": "為什麼你要把它縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1663.wav", + "text": "你一定有你的理由嘛但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1664.wav", + "text": "那個那個知悉後兩年的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1665.wav", + "text": "是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1666.wav", + "text": "跟侵權行為的知悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1667.wav", + "text": "的只是它最長的時效就是發生之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1668.wav", + "text": "我們把它縮短成5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1669.wav", + "text": "主要是因為性騷擾的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1670.wav", + "text": "要成立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1671.wav", + "text": "這個證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1672.wav", + "text": "事實上要保存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1673.wav", + "text": "是非常困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1674.wav", + "text": "的所以如果時間拉太長的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1675.wav", + "text": "事實上我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1676.wav", + "text": "當然對於被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1677.wav", + "text": "也許就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1678.wav", + "text": "他可以有比較長的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1679.wav", + "text": "可以提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1680.wav", + "text": "但是拉長到那麼長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1681.wav", + "text": "本來就有一些困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1682.wav", + "text": "但是對行為人來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1683.wav", + "text": "他所受的不利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1684.wav", + "text": "益就會非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1685.wav", + "text": "對不起我打個岔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1686.wav", + "text": "你應該逆向思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1687.wav", + "text": "為什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1688.wav", + "text": "因為性騷擾的被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1689.wav", + "text": "他有心理的創傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1690.wav", + "text": "他跟一般的侵權行為反而是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1691.wav", + "text": "他可能要在他的心理創傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1692.wav", + "text": "撫平之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1693.wav", + "text": "他才會想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1694.wav", + "text": "他要怎麼樣主張他的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1695.wav", + "text": "你單純的因為他沒有辦法舉證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1696.wav", + "text": "所以就封殺他的這個請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1697.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1698.wav", + "text": "他能不能夠舉證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1699.wav", + "text": "那個是當事人的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1700.wav", + "text": "他不是因為你行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1701.wav", + "text": "認為時間長了他舉證不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1702.wav", + "text": "因為他在受傷害之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1703.wav", + "text": "他是需要一段時間來撫平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1704.wav", + "text": "的在那段的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1705.wav", + "text": "裡他腦筋裡面都是那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1706.wav", + "text": "你要他很理智地去想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1707.wav", + "text": "我有什麼可以主張的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1708.wav", + "text": "他不會去想那些的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1709.wav", + "text": "所以你不但沒有把它延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1710.wav", + "text": "你反而因為你認為他很難舉證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1711.wav", + "text": "但能不能夠舉證成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1712.wav", + "text": "那是被害人的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1713.wav", + "text": "我想這是兩個方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1714.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1715.wav", + "text": "還沒有辦法平復的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1716.wav", + "text": "表示說他已經知悉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1717.wav", + "text": "知悉的話本來就是二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1718.wav", + "text": "你很殘酷耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1719.wav", + "text": "站在一個客觀的人所講的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1720.wav", + "text": "來講因為你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1721.wav", + "text": "他有一個心理的創傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1722.wav", + "text": "你完全沒有考慮到他心理的創傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1723.wav", + "text": "不要用這麼冷酷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1724.wav", + "text": "這麼客觀的一個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1725.wav", + "text": "你要想到一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1726.wav", + "text": "他會想到主張他自己的權利時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1727.wav", + "text": "他必須已經回復到平常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1728.wav", + "text": "態現在只是問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1729.wav", + "text": "為什麼你不能夠回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1730.wav", + "text": "一般的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1731.wav", + "text": "然後你要把它縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1732.wav", + "text": "你的理由就是說因為他舉證困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1733.wav", + "text": "他舉證困難是他的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1734.wav", + "text": "你自己聽聽看你這樣說有沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1735.wav", + "text": "我們在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1736.wav", + "text": "這種性騷案件的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1737.wav", + "text": "也必須兩造都要取得平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1738.wav", + "text": "本來的時限只有1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1739.wav", + "text": "我們把它延長為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1740.wav", + "text": "這已經算是延長了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1741.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1742.wav", + "text": "而是延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1743.wav", + "text": "只是剛剛委員提到是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1744.wav", + "text": "跟侵權行為做比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1745.wav", + "text": "但是侵權行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1746.wav", + "text": "侵權行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1747.wav", + "text": "並沒有做規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1748.wav", + "text": "所以他仍然在10年之內的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1749.wav", + "text": "還是可以提出損害賠償的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1750.wav", + "text": "這部分並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1751.wav", + "text": "等一下我的第三個問題還沒有回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1752.wav", + "text": "第三個問題沒回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1753.wav", + "text": "院長還有各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1754.wav", + "text": "法務部這邊的意見是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1755.wav", + "text": "針對剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1756.wav", + "text": "李委員的意見應該是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1757.wav", + "text": "不同的責任譬如說民事責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1758.wav", + "text": "行政責任跟刑事責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1759.wav", + "text": "他本來就有各該的要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1760.wav", + "text": "這個修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1761.wav", + "text": "是針對行政申訴程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1762.wav", + "text": "所以他其實是延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1763.wav", + "text": "而不是縮短了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1764.wav", + "text": "民事侵權行為損害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1765.wav", + "text": "賠償10年的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1766.wav", + "text": "行政院版大家通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1767.wav", + "text": "法條裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1768.wav", + "text": "懲罰性的違約金都可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1769.wav", + "text": "2年跟10年請求權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1770.wav", + "text": "時效範圍內來請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1771.wav", + "text": "所以沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1772.wav", + "text": "縮短他權利的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1773.wav", + "text": "那這個案子裡頭應該是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1774.wav", + "text": "已經延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1775.wav", + "text": "本來的行政程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1776.wav", + "text": "因為本來的程序是申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1777.wav", + "text": "期間只有1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1778.wav", + "text": "現在放寬成2年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1779.wav", + "text": "特別的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1780.wav", + "text": "他還有一些特別的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1781.wav", + "text": "都是往後延長的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1782.wav", + "text": "這個是我必須先做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1783.wav", + "text": "就法務部所屬而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1784.wav", + "text": "我們主要主管的只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1785.wav", + "text": "刑事責任的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1786.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的那個民事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1787.wav", + "text": "法務部這邊但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1788.wav", + "text": "委員這邊提到的那個應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1789.wav", + "text": "來講的話對於時效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1790.wav", + "text": "我們一般來講會有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1791.wav", + "text": "時效停止或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1792.wav", + "text": "要不要特別的情況去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1793.wav", + "text": "做一個考量但是這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1794.wav", + "text": "跟剛剛委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1795.wav", + "text": "所以應該這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1796.wav", + "text": "在這裡頭針對民事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1797.wav", + "text": "民事的部分是維持原狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1798.wav", + "text": "行政的程序部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1799.wav", + "text": "拉長了時效的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1800.wav", + "text": "那刑事部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1801.wav", + "text": "因為法定刑的提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1802.wav", + "text": "也延長了他的追訴權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1803.wav", + "text": "而言從修法的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1804.wav", + "text": "而言都有保護到被害人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1805.wav", + "text": "權益這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1806.wav", + "text": "法務部的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1807.wav", + "text": "就是在規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1808.wav", + "text": "你要如何提出申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1809.wav", + "text": "向誰提出申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1810.wav", + "text": "以及申訴的有效期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1811.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團這邊都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1812.wav", + "text": "你在幾年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1813.wav", + "text": "可以提出申訴將原來一年提高到兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1814.wav", + "text": "申訴的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1815.wav", + "text": "簡單講要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1816.wav", + "text": "他一個雙軌的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1817.wav", + "text": "就是除了對機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1818.wav", + "text": "學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1819.wav", + "text": "公司行號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1820.wav", + "text": "你被性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1821.wav", + "text": "擾你只能對你自己的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1822.wav", + "text": "機構學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1823.wav", + "text": "跟行號去提申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1824.wav", + "text": "然後他不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1825.wav", + "text": "呢像現在的狀況不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1826.wav", + "text": "而不處理就吃案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1827.wav", + "text": "沒有外部申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1828.wav", + "text": "到底這次修法是只要跨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1829.wav", + "text": "延長一點點罰則把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1830.wav", + "text": "提高一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1831.wav", + "text": "\n還是要跨大步一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1832.wav", + "text": "讓將來的性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1833.wav", + "text": "擾案件真的被遏止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1834.wav", + "text": "解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1835.wav", + "text": "但是我們在委員會提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1836.wav", + "text": "大力改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1837.wav", + "text": "所以我們這條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1838.wav", + "text": "才會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1839.wav", + "text": "本來我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1840.wav", + "text": "是寫在第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1841.wav", + "text": "不知道案件加害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1842.wav", + "text": "屬於哪一個單位的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1843.wav", + "text": "就可以向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1844.wav", + "text": "向警察機關申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1845.wav", + "text": "因為你不知道他屬於哪一個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1846.wav", + "text": "只有那種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1847.wav", + "text": "警察機關申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1848.wav", + "text": "只有在那種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1849.wav", + "text": "我不知道他屬於哪個學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1850.wav", + "text": "哪個機關哪個機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1851.wav", + "text": "所以只能向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1852.wav", + "text": "主管機關或警察機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1853.wav", + "text": "這是第三款規定的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1854.wav", + "text": "即使是在機構內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1855.wav", + "text": "受到性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1856.wav", + "text": "即除了內部申訴之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1857.wav", + "text": "有沒有機會可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1858.wav", + "text": "把第十七條原來我們修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1859.wav", + "text": "動議的第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1860.wav", + "text": "併到第十四條來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1861.wav", + "text": "開書面告誡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1862.wav", + "text": "是如果是在跟騷法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1863.wav", + "text": "只要有嫌疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1864.wav", + "text": "即可但跟騷法也不是判定後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1865.wav", + "text": "才開書面告誡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1866.wav", + "text": "跟騷法是警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1867.wav", + "text": "經過調查認為有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1868.wav", + "text": "跟騷行為即有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1869.wav", + "text": "書面告誡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1870.wav", + "text": "為什麼要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1871.wav", + "text": "而且沒經過法院判定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1872.wav", + "text": "因為要制止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1873.wav", + "text": "這種行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1874.wav", + "text": "大家都知道不管跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1875.wav", + "text": "跟騷或性騷都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1876.wav", + "text": "慣性很多都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1877.wav", + "text": "慣犯也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1878.wav", + "text": "在調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1879.wav", + "text": "的時機點通通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1880.wav", + "text": "要等到法院審判確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1881.wav", + "text": "很多次了所以跟騷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1882.wav", + "text": "書面告誡當警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1883.wav", + "text": "可疑或嫌疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1884.wav", + "text": "重大就開書面告誡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1885.wav", + "text": "當然書面告誡到最後如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1886.wav", + "text": "再不遵守才會到法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1887.wav", + "text": "開保護令屆時就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1888.wav", + "text": "有限制人身自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1889.wav", + "text": "書面告誡最主要就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1890.wav", + "text": "制止繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1891.wav", + "text": "有這種行為這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1892.wav", + "text": "制度我們希望把跟騷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1893.wav", + "text": "通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1894.wav", + "text": "依據警察單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1895.wav", + "text": "警政署所給我們的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1896.wav", + "text": "80%的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1897.wav", + "text": "後都不再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1898.wav", + "text": "警政署給我們的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1899.wav", + "text": "\n如果性騷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1900.wav", + "text": "也能夠用這樣的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1901.wav", + "text": "當有書面告誡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1902.wav", + "text": "一樣不會再有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1903.wav", + "text": "這樣的行為發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1904.wav", + "text": "就沒有第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1905.wav", + "text": "我們會再提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1906.wav", + "text": "更完整的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1907.wav", + "text": "我請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1908.wav", + "text": "你們把跟騷全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1909.wav", + "text": "還要告誡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1910.wav", + "text": "其實性騷擾就直接報警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1911.wav", + "text": "直接處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1912.wav", + "text": "比較好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1913.wav", + "text": "性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1914.wav", + "text": "現在沒有報警察處理的條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1915.wav", + "text": "哪一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1916.wav", + "text": "請部會回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1917.wav", + "text": "好啦你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1918.wav", + "text": "性騷的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1919.wav", + "text": "有言語性騷還有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1920.wav", + "text": "行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1921.wav", + "text": "我知道啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1922.wav", + "text": "只有行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1923.wav", + "text": "不明才能夠去報警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1924.wav", + "text": "全部都到警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1925.wav", + "text": "我們先對焦一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1926.wav", + "text": "最多數的那一部分不能報警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1927.wav", + "text": "行為人不明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1928.wav", + "text": "才能報警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1929.wav", + "text": "我們先對焦一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1930.wav", + "text": "我們就讓部長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1931.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1932.wav", + "text": "第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1933.wav", + "text": "今天提出來的修正動議的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1934.wav", + "text": "前面你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1935.wav", + "text": "只有行為人不明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1936.wav", + "text": "其實你這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1937.wav", + "text": "條文寫得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1938.wav", + "text": "跟院版的是完全一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1939.wav", + "text": "我是從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1940.wav", + "text": "文字來做對照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1941.wav", + "text": "並沒有在你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1942.wav", + "text": "修正動議條文裡面顯現出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1943.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1944.wav", + "text": "\n第二點把跟騷跟性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1945.wav", + "text": "這兩個去做比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1946.wav", + "text": "有一點不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1947.wav", + "text": "跟騷是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1948.wav", + "text": "他在有這些跟蹤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1949.wav", + "text": "可能會有更嚴重的侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1950.wav", + "text": "遏止掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1951.wav", + "text": "書面告誡之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1952.wav", + "text": "做了就做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1953.wav", + "text": "騷擾就騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1954.wav", + "text": "了所以是進入到申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1955.wav", + "text": "馬上就要去做處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1956.wav", + "text": "\n我們沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1957.wav", + "text": "辦法去假定說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1958.wav", + "text": "他這次性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1959.wav", + "text": "之後一定會有下一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1960.wav", + "text": "在做預防性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1961.wav", + "text": "處理的時候其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1962.wav", + "text": "效果比要弱的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1963.wav", + "text": "成立然後要給他處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1964.wav", + "text": "現在法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1965.wav", + "text": "就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1966.wav", + "text": "啊沒有修法也是像你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1967.wav", + "text": "一樣啊你修法以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1968.wav", + "text": "有改變嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1969.wav", + "text": "也是向內部申訴成立委員會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1970.wav", + "text": "書面告誡的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1971.wav", + "text": "那我只問一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1972.wav", + "text": "行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1973.wav", + "text": "有所屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1974.wav", + "text": "學校機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1975.wav", + "text": "啦你就向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1976.wav", + "text": "那些機構政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1977.wav", + "text": "機關來提申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1978.wav", + "text": "\n跟現在沒有修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1979.wav", + "text": "嘛不然現在的法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1980.wav", + "text": "向誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1981.wav", + "text": "機構再去開會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1982.wav", + "text": "現在問題是機構就不開會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1983.wav", + "text": "不是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1984.wav", + "text": "現在現實就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1985.wav", + "text": "#MeToo不都是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1986.wav", + "text": "環保署就不開會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1987.wav", + "text": "環保署我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1988.wav", + "text": "對啊你今天開了記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1989.wav", + "text": "有沒有申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1990.wav", + "text": "有開會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1991.wav", + "text": "向原機構去申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1992.wav", + "text": "結果機構都沒開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1993.wav", + "text": "我們要解決的就是這個問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1994.wav", + "text": "所以才會希望說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1995.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1996.wav", + "text": "向警察機關申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1997.wav", + "text": "人有申訴哪有不開會的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1998.wav", + "text": "民進黨內就是這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/1999.wav", + "text": "的你忘了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2000.wav", + "text": "民進黨內有申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2001.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2002.wav", + "text": "國民黨的是沒有向國民黨內申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2003.wav", + "text": "是最近他才報出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2004.wav", + "text": "民進黨內是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2005.wav", + "text": "內部有申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2006.wav", + "text": "黨內沒開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2007.wav", + "text": "你自己在混淆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2008.wav", + "text": "對法律不了解然後自己發明一套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2009.wav", + "text": "我很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2010.wav", + "text": "申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2011.wav", + "text": "要向誰申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2012.wav", + "text": "你要向誰申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2013.wav", + "text": "還是向機構申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2014.wav", + "text": "第十四條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2015.wav", + "text": "請大家看第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2016.wav", + "text": "主席我有個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2017.wav", + "text": "這一條可以保留但是我有個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2018.wav", + "text": "衛福部回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2019.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣看出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2020.wav", + "text": "你的這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2021.wav", + "text": "就是包括剛才提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2022.wav", + "text": "的譬如說民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2023.wav", + "text": "那一些都是含在你這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2024.wav", + "text": "修法的範圍之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2025.wav", + "text": "有一個處理的順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2026.wav", + "text": "如果是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2027.wav", + "text": "教育法裡面的話就依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2028.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法的規定去做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2029.wav", + "text": "屬於工作場域的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2030.wav", + "text": "就是在性騷法這邊來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2031.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2032.wav", + "text": "衛福部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2033.wav", + "text": "一道防線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2034.wav", + "text": "前面都不符合了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2035.wav", + "text": "那就是由性騷法來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2036.wav", + "text": "衛福部這邊做最後的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2037.wav", + "text": "網羅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2038.wav", + "text": "讓他不會被漏接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2039.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2040.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣子的先後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2041.wav", + "text": "次序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2042.wav", + "text": "好我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2043.wav", + "text": "衛福部是建議照行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2044.wav", + "text": "政院版通過有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2045.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2046.wav", + "text": "\n請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2047.wav", + "text": "第25條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2048.wav", + "text": "第25條跟第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2049.wav", + "text": "李委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2050.wav", + "text": "我很快啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2051.wav", + "text": "用語而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2052.wav", + "text": "剛才我們收到的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2053.wav", + "text": "是按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2054.wav", + "text": "司法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2055.wav", + "text": "版本司法院的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2056.wav", + "text": "有一個建議是要把第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2057.wav", + "text": "第2項的部分予以修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2058.wav", + "text": "你的用語是受自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2059.wav", + "text": "監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2060.wav", + "text": "你那個自己指的是行為人嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2061.wav", + "text": "司法院的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2062.wav", + "text": "原來文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2063.wav", + "text": "你直接把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2064.wav", + "text": "刑法的條文搬過來但是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2065.wav", + "text": "自己指的是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2066.wav", + "text": "是被害人還是行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2067.wav", + "text": "性騷法第十七條的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2068.wav", + "text": "所使用的名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2069.wav", + "text": "是行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2070.wav", + "text": "性騷法第十七條用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2071.wav", + "text": "你要讓它一致呢還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2072.wav", + "text": "第十七條這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2073.wav", + "text": "規範的可能要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2074.wav", + "text": "我不是講它的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2075.wav", + "text": "我是講你用的名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2076.wav", + "text": "啦你現在把刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2077.wav", + "text": "的東西一字不漏的直接搬過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2078.wav", + "text": "但問題是你在性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2079.wav", + "text": "法用的名詞是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2080.wav", + "text": "嘛我只是舉例說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2081.wav", + "text": "專心一下好不好所以你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2082.wav", + "text": "是堅持不改還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2083.wav", + "text": "跟性騷法裡面的名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2084.wav", + "text": "讓它一致性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2085.wav", + "text": "我現在問的是司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2086.wav", + "text": "委員第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2087.wav", + "text": "可能跟第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2088.wav", + "text": "對啦所以我的意思他沒有在聽我講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2089.wav", + "text": "啦\n柯總召你有聽到我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2090.wav", + "text": "就是說他現在把它定義成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2091.wav", + "text": "那就把它跟性騷的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2092.wav", + "text": "一樣是行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2093.wav", + "text": "還是說你不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2094.wav", + "text": "不要的理由是什麼因為第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2095.wav", + "text": "裡面所用的名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2096.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2097.wav", + "text": "到底結論是怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2098.wav", + "text": "他說是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2099.wav", + "text": "我們如果換成行為人恐怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2100.wav", + "text": "不一定完全能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2101.wav", + "text": "所以我們才對啊請他講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2102.wav", + "text": "因為他剛才的回答我問他說自己是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2103.wav", + "text": "司法院的回答是自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2104.wav", + "text": "己是行為人嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2105.wav", + "text": "那我們在讀的時候我們都知道自己到底是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2106.wav", + "text": "了如果是行為人你就寫行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2107.wav", + "text": "嘛如果不是行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2108.wav", + "text": "除了行為人之外還有其他的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2109.wav", + "text": "你就說行為人或什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2110.wav", + "text": "你現在要把刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2111.wav", + "text": "的規定直接搬過來我沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2112.wav", + "text": "但問題是名詞上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2113.wav", + "text": "的使用還是要一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2114.wav", + "text": "委員這部分其實是一個選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2115.wav", + "text": "如果從特別刑法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2116.wav", + "text": "規定來看要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2117.wav", + "text": "盡可能跟普通刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2118.wav", + "text": "是一致的因為這個部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2119.wav", + "text": "罪刑法定的要求而且刑事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2120.wav", + "text": "不法在證明程度上必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2121.wav", + "text": "是最嚴格的那當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2122.wav", + "text": "會有像委員剛剛提到的第十七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2123.wav", + "text": "(構)的規避跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2124.wav", + "text": "這其實是一個法律跟法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2125.wav", + "text": "之間怎麼樣去詮釋的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2126.wav", + "text": "只要不妨礙解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2127.wav", + "text": "第202十八條這樣的法明確性是比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2128.wav", + "text": "合適的以上補充謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2129.wav", + "text": "你要不要寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2130.wav", + "text": "第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2131.wav", + "text": "我我是說現在的名詞不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2132.wav", + "text": "啦你知道跟法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2133.wav", + "text": "上面的名詞不一致但是他的理由就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2134.wav", + "text": "他要跟刑法一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2135.wav", + "text": "性騷的規定一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2136.wav", + "text": "自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2137.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2138.wav", + "text": "召委我還是要請教一下因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2139.wav", + "text": "之前已經討論那麼久都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2140.wav", + "text": "用原來的司法院又提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2141.wav", + "text": "這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2142.wav", + "text": "它的周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2143.wav", + "text": "性可能要跟大家講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2144.wav", + "text": "它的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2145.wav", + "text": "因為的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2146.wav", + "text": "是有它的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2147.wav", + "text": "只是因為現在的名詞不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2148.wav", + "text": "因為這個是特別法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2149.wav", + "text": "所以必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2150.wav", + "text": "還有那個法務部也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2151.wav", + "text": "他的版本也出來了就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2152.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2153.wav", + "text": "權勢性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2154.wav", + "text": "他在講的時候我覺得他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2155.wav", + "text": "但問題只是說既然你在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2156.wav", + "text": "定義權勢性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2157.wav", + "text": "對吧那你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2158.wav", + "text": "又搞一個要透過解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2159.wav", + "text": "然後又不用一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2160.wav", + "text": "名詞我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2161.wav", + "text": "這個是比較怪的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2162.wav", + "text": "啦行為人啊因為他剛剛也講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2163.wav", + "text": "是行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2164.wav", + "text": "院長我講一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2165.wav", + "text": "十七條裡面就是李貴敏委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2166.wav", + "text": "所謂的自己改成行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2167.wav", + "text": "這是整合的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2168.wav", + "text": "就是司法院跟我們的行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2169.wav", + "text": "系統包括衛福部他們同不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2170.wav", + "text": "把它全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2171.wav", + "text": "一律改成行為人那這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2172.wav", + "text": "對於性騷擾防治法裡面從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2173.wav", + "text": "開始的定義到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2174.wav", + "text": "的各項申訴管道的話看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2175.wav", + "text": "會比較一致但是如果司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2176.wav", + "text": "跟衛福部不一樣的話那這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2177.wav", + "text": "部法律要修正通過會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2178.wav", + "text": "有困擾所以現在是要請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2179.wav", + "text": "你們能不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2180.wav", + "text": "還是你們很堅持主張要各自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2181.wav", + "text": "做自己的如果各自要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2182.wav", + "text": "自己的怕會影響到其他法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2183.wav", + "text": "在衡平性處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2184.wav", + "text": "的說明欄裡面把它說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2185.wav", + "text": "在適用的時候才不會碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2186.wav", + "text": "困擾所以這有兩種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2187.wav", + "text": "選擇可能要趕快做個決定如果沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2188.wav", + "text": "辦法的話第2條這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2189.wav", + "text": "就會出現非常大的困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2190.wav", + "text": "好怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2191.wav", + "text": "對於李委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2192.wav", + "text": "的建議有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2193.wav", + "text": "報告院長其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2194.wav", + "text": "剛剛李委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2195.wav", + "text": "成行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2196.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2197.wav", + "text": "因為在解釋上面並不會有太大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2198.wav", + "text": "差異現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2199.wav", + "text": "當然就是說司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2200.wav", + "text": "和法務部這邊在考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2201.wav", + "text": "刑法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2202.wav", + "text": "在第202條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2203.wav", + "text": "是用自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2204.wav", + "text": "第202條是已經這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2205.wav", + "text": "然後現在到性騷法第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2206.wav", + "text": "第25條也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2207.wav", + "text": "成立犯罪的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2208.wav", + "text": "性騷法第25條的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2209.wav", + "text": "刑法第202條的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2210.wav", + "text": "是一致的那假設說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2211.wav", + "text": "這樣子是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2212.wav", + "text": "性騷法第25條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2213.wav", + "text": "就仍然要維持自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2214.wav", + "text": "寫法如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2215.wav", + "text": "第25條要維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2216.wav", + "text": "這樣的寫法那恐怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2217.wav", + "text": "第2條就不宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2218.wav", + "text": "去把它改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2219.wav", + "text": "因為這個在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2220.wav", + "text": "第2條的權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2221.wav", + "text": "權勢性騷擾會跟後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2222.wav", + "text": "第25條其實是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2223.wav", + "text": "連動的如果寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2224.wav", + "text": "不同的話反而不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2225.wav", + "text": "所以司法院的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2226.wav", + "text": "對司法院來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2227.wav", + "text": "它有體系完整性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2228.wav", + "text": "一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2229.wav", + "text": "那衛福部這邊其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2230.wav", + "text": "並沒有太大的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2231.wav", + "text": "因為我們在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2232.wav", + "text": "行政的違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2233.wav", + "text": "的部分的話用自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2234.wav", + "text": "或者是用行為人我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2235.wav", + "text": "都可以理解都可以解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2236.wav", + "text": "得通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2237.wav", + "text": "現在碰到困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2238.wav", + "text": "我的意見就是這樣子就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2239.wav", + "text": "衛福部說他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2240.wav", + "text": "們沒有困難在執行上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2241.wav", + "text": "來講他們沒有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2242.wav", + "text": "既然你要制定一部法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2243.wav", + "text": "尤其今天經過立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2244.wav", + "text": "這個修正的討論你可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2245.wav", + "text": "把它規定清楚為什麼你還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2246.wav", + "text": "用的名詞要再透過解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2247.wav", + "text": "的方式去做這個我已經不太能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2248.wav", + "text": "理解就是說你在這個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2249.wav", + "text": "你講的是行為人他其實就是行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2250.wav", + "text": "人嘛你可以把別的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2251.wav", + "text": "的概念納入我是OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2252.wav", + "text": "的所以剛才司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2253.wav", + "text": "前面在解釋的時候然後我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2254.wav", + "text": "看了他的用語之後我也可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2255.wav", + "text": "為什麼司法院會有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2256.wav", + "text": "主張但是如果你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2257.wav", + "text": "堅持就是要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2258.wav", + "text": "一個不同的法律你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2259.wav", + "text": "記不記得剛剛衛福部薛部長在之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2260.wav", + "text": "一直強調這個談的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2261.wav", + "text": "行政這個談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2262.wav", + "text": "不是刑事的或者談的不是民事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2263.wav", + "text": "剛才我們在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2264.wav", + "text": "衛福部一再強調的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2265.wav", + "text": "我們今天是在討論行政的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2266.wav", + "text": "部分好那你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2267.wav", + "text": "才講了這個前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2268.wav", + "text": "然後自己又給自己打了一巴掌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2269.wav", + "text": "那我也覺得很奇怪司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2270.wav", + "text": "如果有這個意見為什麼會是今天提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2271.wav", + "text": "呢難道不是在委員會裡面審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2272.wav", + "text": "的時候就應該提怎麼會到朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2273.wav", + "text": "協商的時候再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2274.wav", + "text": "基本上來講我們還是尊重司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2275.wav", + "text": "人民的最後一道防線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2276.wav", + "text": "是司法公平正義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2277.wav", + "text": "最後一道防線但是在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2278.wav", + "text": "我們作為一個民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2279.wav", + "text": "我們也懇求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2280.wav", + "text": "既然是司法的最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2281.wav", + "text": "一道防線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2282.wav", + "text": "已經有疑義的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2283.wav", + "text": "是不是我們在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2284.wav", + "text": "就不要再經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2285.wav", + "text": "還要授權相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2286.wav", + "text": "的單位去解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2287.wav", + "text": "然後將來雙方的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2288.wav", + "text": "在攻防時或者是相關的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2289.wav", + "text": "還要去解釋各自主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2290.wav", + "text": "拖延這是我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2291.wav", + "text": "卑微的要求請行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2292.wav", + "text": "考慮謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2293.wav", + "text": "我想針對剛剛李貴敏委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2294.wav", + "text": "所提的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2295.wav", + "text": "如果是司法院所提的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2296.wav", + "text": "是沒有牽涉到剛剛所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2297.wav", + "text": "刑法第202條嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2298.wav", + "text": "也就是說我們在處理性騷擾防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2299.wav", + "text": "的時候其實有很多是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2300.wav", + "text": "行政調查的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2301.wav", + "text": "就比較不受司法院所謂的刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2302.wav", + "text": "或是你所謂的特別刑法的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2303.wav", + "text": "那你一定要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2304.wav", + "text": "自己放進去不願意做任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2305.wav", + "text": "修改的話我不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2306.wav", + "text": "有沒有這樣的用法就是在自己後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2307.wav", + "text": "表示都可以適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2308.wav", + "text": "不是可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2309.wav", + "text": "我們如果沒有協調清楚的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2310.wav", + "text": "會有困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2311.wav", + "text": "因為剛才司法院已經講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2312.wav", + "text": "所謂的自己因為我在前面有先問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2313.wav", + "text": "司法院也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2314.wav", + "text": "所謂的自己就是行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2315.wav", + "text": "我剛剛前面先確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2316.wav", + "text": "這是誰他講是行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2317.wav", + "text": "只是他不願意改用語他講的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2318.wav", + "text": "就是因為刑法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2319.wav", + "text": "的條文就是用自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2320.wav", + "text": "所以他要把它直接搬過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2321.wav", + "text": "但是刑法是刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2322.wav", + "text": "你今天已經知道人家有疑義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2323.wav", + "text": "像我今天會提出來因為在有疑義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2324.wav", + "text": "的情況之下為什麼你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2325.wav", + "text": "不把它釐清你還要讓它變成一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2326.wav", + "text": "需要去問需要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2327.wav", + "text": "解釋為什麼需要呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2328.wav", + "text": "一個是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2329.wav", + "text": "一個就是大家折衷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2330.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2331.wav", + "text": "第25條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2332.wav", + "text": "就照法務部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2333.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2334.wav", + "text": "司法院的意見是在今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2335.wav", + "text": "朝野協商才提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2336.wav", + "text": "原來在委員會的時候沒有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2337.wav", + "text": "而司法院的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2338.wav", + "text": "我提出來的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2339.wav", + "text": "你已經知道人家對於所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2340.wav", + "text": "自己是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2341.wav", + "text": "有問題了嘛而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2342.wav", + "text": "你的用語沒有��己這個用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2343.wav", + "text": "你的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2344.wav", + "text": "裡面只有行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2345.wav", + "text": "的用語沒有自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2346.wav", + "text": "嘛現在他在解釋的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2347.wav", + "text": "他說自己就是行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2348.wav", + "text": "但問題是將來在適用這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2349.wav", + "text": "條文的人他沒有看過今天的朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2350.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2351.wav", + "text": "呢所以我才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2352.wav", + "text": "你就把自己改成行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2353.wav", + "text": "人不是很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2354.wav", + "text": "司法院有沒有意見自己改為行為人有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2355.wav", + "text": "如果改成行為人會不會覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2356.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2357.wav", + "text": "我的中文程度不是太好但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2358.wav", + "text": "我認為自己監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2359.wav", + "text": "的文字裡面就這樣比較順" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2360.wav", + "text": "因為後面還有之人你如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2361.wav", + "text": "又再寫行為人的話會不會之人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2362.wav", + "text": "又要拿掉了主席我可不可以補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2363.wav", + "text": "罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2364.wav", + "text": "第21條行政裁罰就有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2365.wav", + "text": "是受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2366.wav", + "text": "自己監督照護之人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2367.wav", + "text": "利用權勢或機會為性騷擾者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2368.wav", + "text": "得加重科處罰鍰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2369.wav", + "text": "至二分之一性騷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2370.wav", + "text": "現行法其實就用自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2371.wav", + "text": "就是在第21條本來就有這樣的文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2372.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2373.wav", + "text": "院長你要用什麼名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2374.wav", + "text": "基本上來講我沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2375.wav", + "text": "因為司法院要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2376.wav", + "text": "堅持為了自己的就主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2377.wav", + "text": "一定要堅持我沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2378.wav", + "text": "但你如果說你一定要用自己的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2379.wav", + "text": "那第十七條是不是要把它改成自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2380.wav", + "text": "我們現在在討論性騷的時候你前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2381.wav", + "text": "用了一個自己你先拉出來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2382.wav", + "text": "那個是刑法的規定好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2383.wav", + "text": "你現在在解釋說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2384.wav", + "text": "性騷法的時候你又說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2385.wav", + "text": "因為跟騷法裡面但那二個都不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2386.wav", + "text": "這個條���啊所以我才講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2387.wav", + "text": "說你的名詞應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2388.wav", + "text": "一致性嘛如果你喜歡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2389.wav", + "text": "自己OK啊那第十七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2390.wav", + "text": "條就改成自己我也沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2391.wav", + "text": "啊我的意見只是在於說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2392.wav", + "text": "你要用什麼名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2393.wav", + "text": "通常來講它都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2394.wav", + "text": "有一致性對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2395.wav", + "text": "你那麼喜歡用自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2396.wav", + "text": "為什麼第十七條不用自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2397.wav", + "text": "對不對你為什麼第十七條又要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2398.wav", + "text": "用一個行為人也就是說當你用不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2399.wav", + "text": "的名詞的時候的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2400.wav", + "text": "會在日後發生爭議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2401.wav", + "text": "讓大家有各自主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2402.wav", + "text": "的一個依據今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2403.wav", + "text": "我們既然在立法院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2404.wav", + "text": "審查外界對於立法院的審查已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2405.wav", + "text": "諸多的批評了我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2406.wav", + "text": "建議就是當問題發生的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2407.wav", + "text": "為什麼不能夠在這個時間檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2408.wav", + "text": "然後把它丟出去之後然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2409.wav", + "text": "將來讓行政單位或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2410.wav", + "text": "讓司法單位或者法務單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2411.wav", + "text": "他們再解決呢可以解決的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2412.wav", + "text": "事情為什麼現在不解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2413.wav", + "text": "好如果第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2414.wav", + "text": "也改為一樣不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2415.wav", + "text": "不行嘛那個完全不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2416.wav", + "text": "等一下本案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2417.wav", + "text": "大家沒有共識就保留了等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2418.wav", + "text": "第十七條講的行為人和第二條兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2419.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以兩個把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2420.wav", + "text": "同樣都用自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2421.wav", + "text": "被調查人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2422.wav", + "text": "當然有行為人嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2423.wav", + "text": "像加害者嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2424.wav", + "text": "所以這個和那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2425.wav", + "text": "權勢是自己用權勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2426.wav", + "text": "兩個規範不一樣怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2427.wav", + "text": "名詞要改一致呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2428.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2429.wav", + "text": "那這樣很好因為你提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2430.wav", + "text": "那也講清楚第十七條的行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2431.wav", + "text": "你指的是誰加害人嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2432.wav", + "text": "當然有加害人好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2433.wav", + "text": "那你的第2條修正的自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2434.wav", + "text": "是指誰加害人嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2435.wav", + "text": "不是他是不是加害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2436.wav", + "text": "也是加害人嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2437.wav", + "text": "是啊那不是就是你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2438.wav", + "text": "自己監督的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2439.wav", + "text": "為了要達到你堅持的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2440.wav", + "text": "然後你去扭曲它的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2441.wav", + "text": "我覺得它就沒有意思了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2442.wav", + "text": "嘛你就不是在誠心討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2443.wav", + "text": "十七條除了加害人之外有誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2444.wav", + "text": "的東西你堅持可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2445.wav", + "text": "但是你就是講理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2446.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2447.wav", + "text": "給他回答一下嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2448.wav", + "text": "回答清楚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2449.wav", + "text": "這一條在處理的不僅僅是權勢性騷的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2450.wav", + "text": "它還包括一般性騷的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2451.wav", + "text": "是啦但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2452.wav", + "text": "不管是權勢性也好還是一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2453.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2454.wav", + "text": "所以那個行為人不是自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2455.wav", + "text": "單獨在處理那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2456.wav", + "text": "權勢性騷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2457.wav", + "text": "第十七條如果把它改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2458.wav", + "text": "自己的話一般的性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2459.wav", + "text": "進不去第十七條的程序裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2460.wav", + "text": "所以我才講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2461.wav", + "text": "行為人就是行為人嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2462.wav", + "text": "對不對你硬要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2463.wav", + "text": "那個薛部長還在偷笑我覺得真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2464.wav", + "text": "不要啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2465.wav", + "text": "就是不需要你們都要當好人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2466.wav", + "text": "然後我們為民眾希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2467.wav", + "text": "能夠很釐清的人當壞人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2468.wav", + "text": "這個沒有好人壞人的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2469.wav", + "text": "你今天講一個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2470.wav", + "text": "十七條處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2471.wav", + "text": "事情是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2472.wav", + "text": "誰不知道它不一樣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2473.wav", + "text": "啊第2條就是在講權勢誰不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2474.wav", + "text": "如果都一樣還要第十七條幹嘛呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2475.wav", + "text": "不是這��子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2476.wav", + "text": "不一樣當然是不一樣不然你為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2477.wav", + "text": "需要兩個法條就是因為它處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2478.wav", + "text": "的不一樣可是你今天講的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2479.wav", + "text": "是不是在指加害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2480.wav", + "text": "處理的東西不一樣你把名詞窄化的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2481.wav", + "text": "沒有把名詞窄化啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2482.wav", + "text": "他明明講的我剛才才在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2483.wav", + "text": "問他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2484.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2485.wav", + "text": "柯總召我在第一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2486.wav", + "text": "問的時候我在主張之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2487.wav", + "text": "我是先請教司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2488.wav", + "text": "說你的自己指的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2489.wav", + "text": "誰喔我是先請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2490.wav", + "text": "教喔我沒有自己決定喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2491.wav", + "text": "所以司法院的回答是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2492.wav", + "text": "所謂的自己就是行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2493.wav", + "text": "我現在是回復剛才詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2494.wav", + "text": "的過程既然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2495.wav", + "text": "涵攝的範圍不一樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2496.wav", + "text": "沒有嘛它就一模一樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2497.wav", + "text": "涵攝範圍不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2498.wav", + "text": "回答清楚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2499.wav", + "text": "來來來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2500.wav", + "text": "院長還有各位委員不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2501.wav", + "text": "法務部因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2502.wav", + "text": "是對刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2503.wav", + "text": "剛剛這邊來講其實當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2504.wav", + "text": "所指的是行為人或加害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2505.wav", + "text": "有時候我們在法條用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2506.wav", + "text": "語時是要看前後文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2507.wav", + "text": "這裡來講主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2508.wav", + "text": "強調那個相對性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2509.wav", + "text": "也就是說它的權勢性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2510.wav", + "text": "騷寫得很清楚是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2511.wav", + "text": "對於因什麼樣的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2512.wav", + "text": "受自己這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2513.wav", + "text": "是一個相對性的介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2514.wav", + "text": "所以其實從第2條的定義裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2515.wav", + "text": "我們也可以看到前後文裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2516.wav", + "text": "都有出現所謂自己或他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2517.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個介紹詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2518.wav", + "text": "這個跟後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2519.wav", + "text": "我們在申訴的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2520.wav", + "text": "叫行為人這個的界定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2521.wav", + "text": "雖然是同一個人但是用語不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2522.wav", + "text": "其實有時候有前後文的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2523.wav", + "text": "是用語的問題而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2524.wav", + "text": "就是因為用語的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2525.wav", + "text": "我們才講說把用語的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2526.wav", + "text": "讓它清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2527.wav", + "text": "這個我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2528.wav", + "text": "我表示一下看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2529.wav", + "text": "這個地方在講行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2530.wav", + "text": "是像一般在講比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2531.wav", + "text": "比如說我是政府機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2532.wav", + "text": "行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2533.wav", + "text": "第二條其實大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2534.wav", + "text": "它是在看第二條的本文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2535.wav", + "text": "說對於他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2536.wav", + "text": "底下這個在自己監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2537.wav", + "text": "是相對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2538.wav", + "text": "前面提到對他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2539.wav", + "text": "來實施違反他的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2540.wav", + "text": "在說性騷擾就是指性侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2541.wav", + "text": "犯罪以外的對他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2542.wav", + "text": "實施違反他的意願這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2543.wav", + "text": "所以最後你看那個第二項才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2544.wav", + "text": "去講到其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2545.wav", + "text": "相類關係受自己監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2546.wav", + "text": "是這個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2547.wav", + "text": "啦大家講得其實都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2548.wav", + "text": "有點道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2549.wav", + "text": "但是有一點誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2550.wav", + "text": "了這個條文跟其他的條文真的是無涉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2551.wav", + "text": "這個條文純粹就是在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2552.wav", + "text": "第一項跟第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2553.wav", + "text": "它在做定義性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2554.wav", + "text": "第一項在做定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2555.wav", + "text": "這個性騷擾的定義是對他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2556.wav", + "text": "實施違反他意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2557.wav", + "text": "與性或性別相關的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2558.wav", + "text": "是在講說受到自己監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2559.wav", + "text": "那這樣就保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2560.wav", + "text": "第2條沒有共識保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2561.wav", + "text": "\n第25條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2562.wav", + "text": "就依照法務部的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2563.wav", + "text": "意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2564.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2565.wav", + "text": "現在就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2566.wav", + "text": "它其實一點都不會跑掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2567.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2568.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄講得最清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2569.wav", + "text": "我再宣布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2570.wav", + "text": "第2條就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2571.wav", + "text": "\n第25條就照法務部建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2572.wav", + "text": "的修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2573.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2574.wav", + "text": "我有一個程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2575.wav", + "text": "如果第2條保留的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2576.wav", + "text": "第25條也要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2577.wav", + "text": "利用第2條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2578.wav", + "text": "現在第2項的內容都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2579.wav", + "text": "是什麼內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2580.wav", + "text": "啊現在第2條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2581.wav", + "text": "法務部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2582.wav", + "text": "法務部這邊做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2583.wav", + "text": "其實當初就是為免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2584.wav", + "text": "所以我們很簡言地就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2585.wav", + "text": "依第2條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2586.wav", + "text": "無論將來大院這邊怎麼樣做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2587.wav", + "text": "第25條不會受影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2588.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2589.wav", + "text": "那就第25條還是照法務部的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2590.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2591.wav", + "text": "\n請大家看第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2592.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見照院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2593.wav", + "text": "版通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2594.wav", + "text": "好\n請大家看第34條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2595.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有意見也照院版的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2596.wav", + "text": "通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2597.wav", + "text": "有意見就隨時提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2598.wav", + "text": "協商主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2599.wav", + "text": "本院社會福利及衛生環境委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2600.wav", + "text": "報告併案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2601.wav", + "text": "審查行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2602.wav", + "text": "函請審議性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2603.wav", + "text": "防治法修正草案等40案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2604.wav", + "text": "\n協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2605.wav", + "text": "一協商通過條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2606.wav", + "text": "第25條如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2607.wav", + "text": "\n二照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2608.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2609.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2610.wav", + "text": "之各章章名及條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2611.wav", + "text": "本案院會進行處理時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2612.wav", + "text": "非保留部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2613.wav", + "text": "宣讀後均予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2614.wav", + "text": "院會進行處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2615.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2616.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2617.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2618.wav", + "text": "順序輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2619.wav", + "text": "每人發言時間為3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2620.wav", + "text": "發言完畢後各該保留條文均不再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2621.wav", + "text": "並依上開黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2622.wav", + "text": "順序進行各保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2623.wav", + "text": "條文黨團版本之處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2624.wav", + "text": "\n六本案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2625.wav", + "text": "各黨團委員提案及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2626.wav", + "text": "修正動議均列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2627.wav", + "text": "公報紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2628.wav", + "text": "\n七檢附" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2629.wav", + "text": "本案立法說明1份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2630.wav", + "text": "如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2631.wav", + "text": "看有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2632.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2633.wav", + "text": "一方面大家在簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2634.wav", + "text": "各黨團在簽的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2635.wav", + "text": "我現在想要請教大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2636.wav", + "text": "今天協商的性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2637.wav", + "text": "已經有相關的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2638.wav", + "text": "了因為有保留條文要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2639.wav", + "text": "各黨團也要草擬保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2640.wav", + "text": "條文的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2641.wav", + "text": "也有附帶決議要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2642.wav", + "text": "所以現在要跟各黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2643.wav", + "text": "各黨團來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2644.wav", + "text": "請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2645.wav", + "text": "各黨團要星期幾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2646.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2647.wav", + "text": "要這個禮拜五還是下週一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2648.wav", + "text": "動員來院會進行表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2649.wav", + "text": "跟處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2650.wav", + "text": "補充報告一下性平法三法無須表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2651.wav", + "text": "之無爭議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2652.wav", + "text": "宣讀共需三個半小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2653.wav", + "text": "左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2654.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2655.wav", + "text": "宣讀就要三個半小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2656.wav", + "text": "了需要半天的院會來進行宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2657.wav", + "text": "這是不用表決的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2658.wav", + "text": "如果要表決還要很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2659.wav", + "text": "早��有跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2660.wav", + "text": "曾總召溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2661.wav", + "text": "今天我們面對的一個問題就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2662.wav", + "text": "別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2663.wav", + "text": "議至於這些要唸的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2664.wav", + "text": "在禮拜五就處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2665.wav", + "text": "因為明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2666.wav", + "text": "禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2667.wav", + "text": "就先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2668.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2669.wav", + "text": "宣讀條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2670.wav", + "text": "下禮拜一颱風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2671.wav", + "text": "再來表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2672.wav", + "text": "最後一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2673.wav", + "text": "外役監條例沒有要處理就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2674.wav", + "text": "政黨還沒有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2675.wav", + "text": "政黨沒有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2676.wav", + "text": "你們有承諾說要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2677.wav", + "text": "臨時會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2678.wav", + "text": "你是在講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2679.wav", + "text": "你有沒有來參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2680.wav", + "text": "一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2681.wav", + "text": "外役監條例已經出委員會了為什麼不協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2682.wav", + "text": "院長為什麼不協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2683.wav", + "text": "委員會的政黨協商還沒有完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2684.wav", + "text": "直接院長協商我們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2685.wav", + "text": "也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2686.wav", + "text": "但是坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2687.wav", + "text": "外役監條例現在法務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2688.wav", + "text": "法務部大概還要整理版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2689.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣一定會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2690.wav", + "text": "誰敢打假球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2691.wav", + "text": "臨時會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2692.wav", + "text": "你有對媒體講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2693.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2694.wav", + "text": "委員會的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2695.wav", + "text": "而且臨時會一開始朝野有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2696.wav", + "text": "朝野協商的時候就簽過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2697.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2698.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2699.wav", + "text": "沒有逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2700.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2701.wav", + "text": "啦沒有逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2702.wav", + "text": "朝野協商時有談這兩個法一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2703.wav", + "text": "院長我們還是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2704.wav", + "text": "我隨時可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2705.wav", + "text": "我隨時待命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2706.wav", + "text": "你們講好就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2707.wav", + "text": "院長那什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2708.wav", + "text": "呢協商明天或後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2709.wav", + "text": "好那我們來提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2710.wav", + "text": "好啊好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2711.wav", + "text": "我看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2712.wav", + "text": "只要你們有提出來我都隨時處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2713.wav", + "text": "我這邊時間都會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2714.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2715.wav", + "text": "就是大家知道一下就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2716.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2717.wav", + "text": "沒有不同意見的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2718.wav", + "text": "有共識的我們就禮拜五把它宣讀完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2719.wav", + "text": "要表決的就禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2720.wav", + "text": "單單有共識要宣讀的就要三個半小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2721.wav", + "text": "讓大家知道一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2722.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2723.wav", + "text": "禮拜五宣讀我們再來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2724.wav", + "text": "外役監條例禮拜一一起表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2725.wav", + "text": "提出要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2726.wav", + "text": "好其他沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2727.wav", + "text": "請大家儘量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2728.wav", + "text": "大家沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2729.wav", + "text": "協商會議就到此告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15105/2730.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/0.wav", + "text": "開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/2.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/3.wav", + "text": "的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/4.wav", + "text": "是行政院函請審議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/5.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/6.wav", + "text": "等25案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/7.wav", + "text": "報告一下協商背景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/8.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/9.wav", + "text": "行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/10.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/11.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/12.wav", + "text": "案等25案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/13.wav", + "text": "係經教育及文化委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/14.wav", + "text": "於112年7月20日召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/15.wav", + "text": "第10屆第7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/16.wav", + "text": "會期第2次臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/17.wav", + "text": "第1次全體委員會會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/18.wav", + "text": "併案審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/19.wav", + "text": "須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/20.wav", + "text": "審查的結果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/21.wav", + "text": "我們保留第十七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/22.wav", + "text": "共6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/23.wav", + "text": "跟各位報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/24.wav", + "text": "本日協商以討論委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/25.wav", + "text": "保留的條文為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/26.wav", + "text": "因委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/27.wav", + "text": "時已有多所討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/28.wav", + "text": "在各條協商前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/29.wav", + "text": "我們是不是要先請教育部提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/30.wav", + "text": "要是有委員仍有垂詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/31.wav", + "text": "我們再進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/32.wav", + "text": "今天因為有陳培瑜委員等3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/33.wav", + "text": "我們先討論保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/34.wav", + "text": "最後再討論陳培瑜委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/35.wav", + "text": "等3人的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/36.wav", + "text": "就是上次的保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/37.wav", + "text": "有好幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/38.wav", + "text": "都是一些救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/39.wav", + "text": "的相關程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/40.wav", + "text": "所以我們這邊是不是也先請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/41.wav", + "text": "做一個整體的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/42.wav", + "text": "跟我們報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/43.wav", + "text": "之後因為條文是相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/44.wav", + "text": "所以如果我們能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/45.wav", + "text": "認同教育部所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/46.wav", + "text": "因為他們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/47.wav", + "text": "跟各黨團溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/48.wav", + "text": "通如果大家可以接受的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/49.wav", + "text": "精準一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/50.wav", + "text": "就不會落入很特別的細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/51.wav", + "text": "我們就先從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/52.wav", + "text": "還是一樣先請部長來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/53.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席還有各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/54.wav", + "text": "因為連動到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/55.wav", + "text": "十條這5個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/56.wav", + "text": "也確實針對原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/57.wav", + "text": "我們所考量到比較核心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/58.wav", + "text": "幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/59.wav", + "text": "我也把這次我們就申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/60.wav", + "text": "救濟因為這個關係到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/61.wav", + "text": "整體相關的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/62.wav", + "text": "幾個重要核心精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/63.wav", + "text": "行政院版所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/64.wav", + "text": "就是希望比較能夠以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/65.wav", + "text": "有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/66.wav", + "text": "友善跟可信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/67.wav", + "text": "被害人保護中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/68.wav", + "text": "跟救濟包含委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/69.wav", + "text": "審議當天所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/70.wav", + "text": "幾個關鍵點我們來做這樣的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/71.wav", + "text": "第一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/72.wav", + "text": "確實委員都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/73.wav", + "text": "提到過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/74.wav", + "text": "還有可能時效上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/75.wav", + "text": "也比較冗長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/76.wav", + "text": "當然當天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/77.wav", + "text": "委員討論也特別考量到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/78.wav", + "text": "依法必須成立性別平等教育委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/79.wav", + "text": "這個功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/80.wav", + "text": "應該也要考慮也避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/81.wav", + "text": "他們最後把這個地方都弱化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/82.wav", + "text": "統統把它過渡到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/83.wav", + "text": "只是過水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/84.wav", + "text": "然後回到學校的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/85.wav", + "text": "這個也會影響長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/86.wav", + "text": "在整個推動上分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/87.wav", + "text": "而且也應該課責的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/88.wav", + "text": "委員的指教下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/89.wav", + "text": "目前就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/90.wav", + "text": "開始思考我們後續可以怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/91.wav", + "text": "對行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/92.wav", + "text": "如果是校長教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/93.wav", + "text": "要全部外聘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/94.wav", + "text": "或相關的這部分是大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/95.wav", + "text": "關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/96.wav", + "text": "也就是在校園內的成人對學生這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/97.wav", + "text": "但學生對學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/98.wav", + "text": "大家反而會比較願意了解之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/99.wav", + "text": "要考慮到學生這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/100.wav", + "text": "相互的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/101.wav", + "text": "甚至也提出這種修復式正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/102.wav", + "text": "的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/103.wav", + "text": "因此在申復的部分教育部也考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/104.wav", + "text": "把這個做一個分流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/105.wav", + "text": "委員可以看到那個流程表裡面最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/106.wav", + "text": "我們做改變的一個思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/107.wav", + "text": "如果行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/108.wav", + "text": "是校長或教職員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/109.wav", + "text": "我們希望跟學生對學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/110.wav", + "text": "屬於學生對學生我們就維持原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/111.wav", + "text": "申復程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/112.wav", + "text": "因為那個過程還有學校應該去進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/113.wav", + "text": "很多教育的事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/114.wav", + "text": "加害人是屬於校長教職員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/115.wav", + "text": "這個就是我們講的可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/116.wav", + "text": "權勢型的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/117.wav", + "text": "校園性別事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/118.wav", + "text": "因此在這一次的申復裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/119.wav", + "text": "我們把它做一個分流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/120.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/121.wav", + "text": "都要走學校的申復的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/122.wav", + "text": "性平會的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/123.wav", + "text": "但如果加害人是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/124.wav", + "text": "受害人是學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/125.wav", + "text": "我們覺得這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/126.wav", + "text": "應該考量到是可以由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/127.wav", + "text": "被害人他如果想要跟學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/128.wav", + "text": "也可以但也可以直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/129.wav", + "text": "跟學校的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/130.wav", + "text": "提出申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/131.wav", + "text": "這個是一個比較大的分流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/132.wav", + "text": "\n這一點當然也考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/133.wav", + "text": "一方面可以讓學校的性平委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/134.wav", + "text": "仍然也要注意到它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/135.wav", + "text": "如果是學生也是委員過去擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/136.wav", + "text": "會不會在學校繞了好久好久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/137.wav", + "text": "始終繞不出來繞了2年3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/138.wav", + "text": "所以應該拉回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/139.wav", + "text": "當然在後面的制度設計裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/140.wav", + "text": "我也跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/141.wav", + "text": "第一個學校的性平委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/142.wav", + "text": "對學校是以課責的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/143.wav", + "text": "對於學校的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/144.wav", + "text": "我們是採賦權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/145.wav", + "text": "賦權的意思是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/146.wav", + "text": "以前退回去學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/147.wav", + "text": "學校繞了好多天繞了好久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/148.wav", + "text": "又回到原來的樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/149.wav", + "text": "這次甚至我們評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/150.wav", + "text": "是因為處理的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/151.wav", + "text": "程序有瑕疵當然要讓它回去程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/152.wav", + "text": "終局的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/153.wav", + "text": "建議應該判幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/154.wav", + "text": "但是學校弄出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/155.wav", + "text": "停聘的時間又不符合大家的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/156.wav", + "text": "所以我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/157.wav", + "text": "賦權的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/158.wav", + "text": "這個時間如果經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/159.wav", + "text": "主管機關層級的性別平等委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/160.wav", + "text": "會做逕為改核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/161.wav", + "text": "這個跟以往是有很大很大的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/162.wav", + "text": "我們評估到委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/163.wav", + "text": "在之前審議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/164.wav", + "text": "還有我們這一次整個修法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/165.wav", + "text": "核心精神來做的一個大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/166.wav", + "text": "方向的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/167.wav", + "text": "等一下我請司長就相對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/168.wav", + "text": "條文還有在每個程序裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/169.wav", + "text": "我們的設計是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/170.wav", + "text": "委員對於這樣申復救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/171.wav", + "text": "的核心處理精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/172.wav", + "text": "覺得可以的話我想相關的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/173.wav", + "text": "也是依照這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/174.wav", + "text": "全體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/175.wav", + "text": "之後我們再來看看後面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/176.wav", + "text": "這是我想要跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/177.wav", + "text": "這幾天我們整理後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/178.wav", + "text": "調整以上我先大要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/179.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明\n細節部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/180.wav", + "text": "說明也有一個比較詳細的流程表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/181.wav", + "text": "讓委員知道並且一併參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/182.wav", + "text": "這可以讓委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/183.wav", + "text": "申復跟救濟的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/184.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/185.wav", + "text": "先謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/186.wav", + "text": "就是希望尤其在申復跟救濟上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/187.wav", + "text": "又出現內部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/188.wav", + "text": "所以這是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/189.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/190.wav", + "text": "召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/191.wav", + "text": "還有各位委員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/192.wav", + "text": "請大家拿出我們手上的這張流程圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/193.wav", + "text": "抱歉我們有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/194.wav", + "text": "大圖輸出不過還是太小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/195.wav", + "text": "太遠看不清楚可能看紙本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/196.wav", + "text": "會比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/197.wav", + "text": "我從流程圖由上往下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/198.wav", + "text": "跟大家說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/199.wav", + "text": "第31條說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/200.wav", + "text": "如果有校園性別事件的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/201.wav", + "text": "申請人或檢舉人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/202.wav", + "text": "都可以提出申請調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/203.wav", + "text": "性平會收到之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/204.wav", + "text": "會依據第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/205.wav", + "text": "審查是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/206.wav", + "text": "受理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/207.wav", + "text": "其中有三種情況不受理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/208.wav", + "text": "第一個不是性平法所屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/209.wav", + "text": "的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/210.wav", + "text": "或是申請人檢舉人沒有真實姓名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/211.wav", + "text": "這三種情況不予受理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/212.wav", + "text": "如果申請人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/213.wav", + "text": "覺得不受理沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/214.wav", + "text": "可以依照第32條第4項提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/215.wav", + "text": "申復就會再重新做審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/216.wav", + "text": "之後就會由性平會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/217.wav", + "text": "進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/218.wav", + "text": "目前調查的方法跟規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/219.wav", + "text": "就是得設跟應設調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/220.wav", + "text": "小組來調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/221.wav", + "text": "如果是生對生就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/222.wav", + "text": "是得設如果是師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/223.wav", + "text": "對生就是應設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/224.wav", + "text": "這裡有個很關鍵的環節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/225.wav", + "text": "是有規範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/226.wav", + "text": "必須是人才庫的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/227.wav", + "text": "有多少是外部的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/228.wav", + "text": "條是有規定的必須要符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/229.wav", + "text": "如果調查小組的組成不合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/230.wav", + "text": "最後的調查結果就是有缺失的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/231.wav", + "text": "\n再繼續往下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/232.wav", + "text": "調查完畢之後會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/233.wav", + "text": "調查報告跟處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/234.wav", + "text": "建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/235.wav", + "text": "接著性平會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/236.wav", + "text": "調查報告跟處理建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/237.wav", + "text": "這是依照第36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/238.wav", + "text": "審查通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/239.wav", + "text": "調查報告跟處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/240.wav", + "text": "建議就會交給權責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/241.wav", + "text": "做處理老師的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/242.wav", + "text": "就會有教評會考績會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/243.wav", + "text": "公懲會學生有獎懲會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/244.wav", + "text": "這些就會提給權責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/245.wav", + "text": "請大家注意一下這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/246.wav", + "text": "性平會審議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/247.wav", + "text": "最後的審查結果適當不適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/248.wav", + "text": "\n尤其是調查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/249.wav", + "text": "最後提出的處理建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/250.wav", + "text": "有沒有符合比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/251.wav", + "text": "是不是一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/252.wav", + "text": "性平會會進行審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/253.wav", + "text": "如果性平會的審查不恰當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/254.wav", + "text": "後續也會有一個導正的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/255.wav", + "text": "\n接著下一關移送到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/256.wav", + "text": "權責單位也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/257.wav", + "text": "終身解聘最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/258.wav", + "text": "提給權責單位卻沒有終身解聘或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/259.wav", + "text": "4年變1年或者本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/260.wav", + "text": "要解聘變成只記大過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/261.wav", + "text": "這都是由權責單位做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/262.wav", + "text": "但可能最後的處理結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/263.wav", + "text": "跟性平會通過的調查報告跟處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/264.wav", + "text": "這可能也是必須要特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/265.wav", + "text": "審核的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/266.wav", + "text": "就會通知申請人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/267.wav", + "text": "被害人檢舉人還有行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/268.wav", + "text": "通知完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/269.wav", + "text": "相關的這些人員有沒有不服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/270.wav", + "text": "服如果大家都服就結案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/271.wav", + "text": "如果不服就會進入申復程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/272.wav", + "text": "就卡關在第37條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/273.wav", + "text": "如果是教職員工只能向學校申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/274.wav", + "text": "如果是校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/275.wav", + "text": "只能向主管機關申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/276.wav", + "text": "如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/277.wav", + "text": "教職員工對學生的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/278.wav", + "text": "跑完學校申復之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/279.wav", + "text": "後續還會跳到學校的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/280.wav", + "text": "救濟程序就會有學生的申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/281.wav", + "text": "再申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/282.wav", + "text": "流程真的滿長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/283.wav", + "text": "所以上次有委員討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/284.wav", + "text": "涉及師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/285.wav", + "text": "師對生的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/286.wav", + "text": "是不是可以選擇不要回到學校申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/287.wav", + "text": "能不能直接跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/288.wav", + "text": "主管機關申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/289.wav", + "text": "復這幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/290.wav", + "text": "我們內部很充分地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/291.wav", + "text": "增設一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/292.wav", + "text": "師對生的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/293.wav", + "text": "主管機關申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/294.wav", + "text": "復\n接著大家看黃色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/295.wav", + "text": "的圖案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/296.wav", + "text": "都是我們仔細討論之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/297.wav", + "text": "如果他直接向主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/298.wav", + "text": "申復主管機關可以怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/299.wav", + "text": "處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/300.wav", + "text": "可能會先審核行為人是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/301.wav", + "text": "校長或教職員工是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/302.wav", + "text": "就繼續處理如果不是就回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/303.wav", + "text": "一般的申復機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/304.wav", + "text": "跟主管機關申復還是向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/305.wav", + "text": "學校申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/306.wav", + "text": "如果向學校申復就回到學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/307.wav", + "text": "如果向主管機關申復就由主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/308.wav", + "text": "來受理前面兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/309.wav", + "text": "人跟行為人自己本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/310.wav", + "text": "也都在斟酌我們就先從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/311.wav", + "text": "主管機關受理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/312.wav", + "text": "主管機關受理申復之後就依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/313.wav", + "text": "第37條及第38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/314.wav", + "text": "原本的第37條是賦予他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/315.wav", + "text": "可以向主管機關申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/316.wav", + "text": "復第3項就有談到經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/317.wav", + "text": "申復審議的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/318.wav", + "text": "如果發現重大瑕疵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/319.wav", + "text": "或是足以影響原調查認定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/320.wav", + "text": "新事實新證據的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/321.wav", + "text": "可以要求學校的性平會重新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/322.wav", + "text": "調查這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/323.wav", + "text": "而且重新調查不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/324.wav", + "text": "再2加1加1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/325.wav", + "text": "要求重新調查的時候必須要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/326.wav", + "text": "要在40日內完成調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/327.wav", + "text": "以及如果他要求重新調查的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/328.wav", + "text": "就必須重新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/329.wav", + "text": "另組調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/330.wav", + "text": "因為已有重大瑕疵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/331.wav", + "text": "很重大足以影響調查的新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/332.wav", + "text": "事實新證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/333.wav", + "text": "所以要重組調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/334.wav", + "text": "\n接下來如果他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/335.wav", + "text": "問題並不是出現在調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/336.wav", + "text": "小組或是性別會的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/337.wav", + "text": "而是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/338.wav", + "text": "後續處理的權責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/339.wav", + "text": "包括教評會考績會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/340.wav", + "text": "如果問題出現在這些地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/341.wav", + "text": "主管機關經過審核之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/342.wav", + "text": "如果有逕行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/343.wav", + "text": "改核的需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/344.wav", + "text": "就可以依照性別會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/345.wav", + "text": "講的是大專的這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/346.wav", + "text": "因為大專在教師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/347.wav", + "text": "裡依照大學自治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/348.wav", + "text": "治賦予大學相當的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/349.wav", + "text": "所以大學的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/350.wav", + "text": "可能沒辦法逕行改核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/351.wav", + "text": "所以後面我們會創設另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/352.wav", + "text": "一個處理方式是交回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/353.wav", + "text": "學校依法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/354.wav", + "text": "但我們會追究相關人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/355.wav", + "text": "的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/356.wav", + "text": "如果他接受就結案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/357.wav", + "text": "如果不接受後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/358.wav", + "text": "就會依照他的身分別再尋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/359.wav", + "text": "尋求救濟就會接到第39條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/360.wav", + "text": "第39條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/361.wav", + "text": "因為身分不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/362.wav", + "text": "有校長跟教師的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/363.wav", + "text": "有職員跟公務員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/364.wav", + "text": "有學生的部分我們目前有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/365.wav", + "text": "教師申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/366.wav", + "text": "評議的相關規定公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/367.wav", + "text": "的規定申復學生是依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/368.wav", + "text": "學生的申訴規定處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/369.wav", + "text": "我就先做以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/370.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/371.wav", + "text": "有做到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/372.wav", + "text": "大的綜整把整個申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/373.wav", + "text": "重新完整地盤點一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/374.wav", + "text": "這些相關的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/375.wav", + "text": "按照這個系統來安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/376.wav", + "text": "綜合的總體討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/377.wav", + "text": "因為每一條都是相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/378.wav", + "text": "所以我們可以做一個大體的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/379.wav", + "text": "\n先請張廖萬堅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/380.wav", + "text": "我想教育部今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/381.wav", + "text": "作出這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/382.wav", + "text": "也有做分流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/383.wav", + "text": "我們上個禮拜四在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/384.wav", + "text": "審查的時候其實可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/385.wav", + "text": "校園發生的性騷擾或性霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/386.wav", + "text": "八成都是生對生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/387.wav", + "text": "或職員對生的大概占二成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/388.wav", + "text": "不到或是二成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/389.wav", + "text": "性侵的案件大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/390.wav", + "text": "只有一成師對生大概一成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/391.wav", + "text": "生對生還是占九成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/392.wav", + "text": "所以這等於是做一個分流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/393.wav", + "text": "如果師對生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/394.wav", + "text": "或者我們那時候講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/395.wav", + "text": "怕受害人一直在學校繞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/396.wav", + "text": "事實上我們有很多個案在協助處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/397.wav", + "text": "不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/398.wav", + "text": "不相信學校第二次申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/399.wav", + "text": "復公平或不公平當然也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/400.wav", + "text": "主要就是在學校裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/401.wav", + "text": "拖的時間太長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/402.wav", + "text": "所以外界認為如果第一次在學校裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/403.wav", + "text": "即使第二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/404.wav", + "text": "這些性平會的成員不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/405.wav", + "text": "但他們還是在學校繞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/406.wav", + "text": "家長會代表校長聘任的即使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/407.wav", + "text": "不同人但是代表的團體都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/408.wav", + "text": "都會讓外界有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/409.wav", + "text": "所以這一次的這個我支持\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/410.wav", + "text": "那生對生的部分其實占八九成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/411.wav", + "text": "這八九成部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/412.wav", + "text": "還是在學校但我認為這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/413.wav", + "text": "這還是需要更友善一點譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/414.wav", + "text": "我們有提到被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/415.wav", + "text": "被害人如果是生對生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/416.wav", + "text": "當然對於老師或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/417.wav", + "text": "家長團體的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/418.wav", + "text": "我們會寧願相信他們都比較客觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/419.wav", + "text": "不會去偏袒哪一方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/420.wav", + "text": "也比較不會有師師相護的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/421.wav", + "text": "\n可是如果是被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/422.wav", + "text": "能不能直接提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/423.wav", + "text": "這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/424.wav", + "text": "我比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/425.wav", + "text": "一樣會有一些個案是生對生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/426.wav", + "text": "而家長不滿學校的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/427.wav", + "text": "然後再處理檢視結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/428.wav", + "text": "如果調查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/429.wav", + "text": "都一樣的話可能還是維持原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/430.wav", + "text": "還是一樣在學校裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/431.wav", + "text": "\n我知道你們分流之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/432.wav", + "text": "當然有比較好一點比較友善一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/433.wav", + "text": "這些一樣都是性平案件的受害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/434.wav", + "text": "疑似受害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/435.wav", + "text": "他在調查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/436.wav", + "text": "會不會有這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/437.wav", + "text": "我想請教育部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/438.wav", + "text": "能夠瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/439.wav", + "text": "更簡化的話那是最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/440.wav", + "text": "啦當然今天這樣子大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/441.wav", + "text": "可以解決我們版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/442.wav", + "text": "之間的歧異大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/443.wav", + "text": "會比較有共識一點我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/444.wav", + "text": "我們先請委員一輪之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/445.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/446.wav", + "text": "目前我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/447.wav", + "text": "看到這個版本師對生的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/448.wav", + "text": "已經拉出去了很感謝教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/449.wav", + "text": "這個改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/450.wav", + "text": "但我們還是要提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/451.wav", + "text": "院版第37條我們想要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/452.wav", + "text": "強調一件事情也請教育部研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/453.wav", + "text": "重大瑕疵這個要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/454.wav", + "text": "會有很多處理跟討論上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/455.wav", + "text": "爭議我們當時在提自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/456.wav", + "text": "版本的時候其實我們把相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/457.wav", + "text": "條文寫得非常明確我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/458.wav", + "text": "其實是參考訴訟法所以這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/459.wav", + "text": "在第39條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/460.wav", + "text": "目前如果案件重複管轄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/461.wav", + "text": "和當事人向法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/462.wav", + "text": "救濟的權利沒有處理到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/463.wav", + "text": "這個部分想請問教育部打算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/464.wav", + "text": "要怎麼保障被害人我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/465.wav", + "text": "知道教育部在處理相關流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/466.wav", + "text": "的時候有可能是因為不想讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/467.wav", + "text": "案件直接跑到中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/468.wav", + "text": "申訴評議委員會這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/469.wav", + "text": "跟我們想要簡化程序的理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/470.wav", + "text": "剛剛快速看了一下有沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/471.wav", + "text": "可以這樣調整目前教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/472.wav", + "text": "的版本是申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/473.wav", + "text": "申訴再申訴訴願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/474.wav", + "text": "然後到法院有沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/475.wav", + "text": "改成申復申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/476.wav", + "text": "然後下一步就是訴願或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/477.wav", + "text": "呼應剛剛張廖萬堅委員講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/478.wav", + "text": "再簡化那個流程以免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/479.wav", + "text": "再度造成所謂校園事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/480.wav", + "text": "十的案件生對生的部分這麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/481.wav", + "text": "複雜所以關於條文的修正簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/482.wav", + "text": "的說就是拿掉再申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/483.wav", + "text": "我們留申訴就好再簡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/484.wav", + "text": "一層以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/485.wav", + "text": "好謝謝陳委員再請游毓蘭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/486.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/487.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/488.wav", + "text": "我首先要先肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/489.wav", + "text": "一下教育部這次在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/490.wav", + "text": "團版本的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/491.wav", + "text": "修正精神比如說第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/492.wav", + "text": "修正學校性平會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/493.wav", + "text": "調查小組要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/494.wav", + "text": "納入外部委員以提升它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/495.wav", + "text": "調查公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/496.wav", + "text": "教育人員如果涉犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/497.wav", + "text": "性侵害性騷擾或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/498.wav", + "text": "性霸凌情節重大者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/499.wav", + "text": "在調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/500.wav", + "text": "期間要先對行為人停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/501.wav", + "text": "職務以確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/502.wav", + "text": "調查的公正性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/503.wav", + "text": "第三個對被害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/504.wav", + "text": "人提供法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/505.wav", + "text": "扶助以保護弱勢的被害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/506.wav", + "text": "修正條文比如說第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/507.wav", + "text": "36條案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/508.wav", + "text": "24小時內未通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/509.wav", + "text": "變造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/510.wav", + "text": "湮滅隱匿證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/511.wav", + "text": "的罰鍰提高到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/512.wav", + "text": "100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/513.wav", + "text": "以遏止包庇及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/514.wav", + "text": "吃案以及第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/515.wav", + "text": "調查申請或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/516.wav", + "text": "這次國民黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/517.wav", + "text": "修法其實是希望能夠接住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/518.wav", + "text": "校園性平事件的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/519.wav", + "text": "每一個被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/520.wav", + "text": "所以提高罰鍰來有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/521.wav", + "text": "嚇阻校園性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/522.wav", + "text": "侵害性騷擾及性霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/523.wav", + "text": "事件的發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/524.wav", + "text": "以及保護被害人權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/525.wav", + "text": "同時也將調查申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/526.wav", + "text": "的受理期限縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/527.wav", + "text": "能不能請教育部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/528.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/529.wav", + "text": "建議對學校來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/530.wav", + "text": "是不是窒礙難行如果不接受修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/531.wav", + "text": "對於師對生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/532.wav", + "text": "性騷擾案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/533.wav", + "text": "有什麼可以積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/534.wav", + "text": "預防跟處置的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/535.wav", + "text": "\n第二個這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/536.wav", + "text": "這次本席有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/537.wav", + "text": "十七條的保留條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/538.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/539.wav", + "text": "考績會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/540.wav", + "text": "申評會或教評會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/541.wav", + "text": "性別比例做了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/542.wav", + "text": "規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/543.wav", + "text": "而我比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/544.wav", + "text": "通過之前其實就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/545.wav", + "text": "在教育部的性平會任職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/546.wav", + "text": "然後也參與很多學校的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/547.wav", + "text": "性平調查工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/548.wav", + "text": "我在想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/549.wav", + "text": "如果只對他們的性別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/550.wav", + "text": "比例做規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/551.wav", + "text": "在運作上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/552.wav", + "text": "有沒有解決真正的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/553.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能針對性平會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/554.wav", + "text": "的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/555.wav", + "text": "發生教評會考績會根本不買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/556.wav", + "text": "帳的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/557.wav", + "text": "這種情形其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/558.wav", + "text": "我就碰過好幾件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/559.wav", + "text": "\n我很希望藉由這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/560.wav", + "text": "的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/561.wav", + "text": "能夠整體提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/562.wav", + "text": "跟主導性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/563.wav", + "text": "所以將來有沒有可能在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/564.wav", + "text": "教評會考績會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/565.wav", + "text": "處理這些事件的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/566.wav", + "text": "我用英文來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/567.wav", + "text": "它應該要有一個adhoc" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/568.wav", + "text": "就是類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/569.wav", + "text": "類似專案小組成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/570.wav", + "text": "不是只有性別比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/571.wav", + "text": "具有性平專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/572.wav", + "text": "的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/573.wav", + "text": "在處理這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/574.wav", + "text": "案件上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/575.wav", + "text": "至少要有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/576.wav", + "text": "二個或是有固定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/577.wav", + "text": "讓他們的意見可以呈現出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/578.wav", + "text": "這第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/579.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜修法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/580.wav", + "text": "比如說去年在臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/581.wav", + "text": "市所發生的狼師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/582.wav", + "text": "20年前是個國中老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/583.wav", + "text": "現在已經是校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/584.wav", + "text": "我們現在去補破網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/585.wav", + "text": "對於校長跟教育人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/586.wav", + "text": "在調查期間的停職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/587.wav", + "text": "立刻就弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/588.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得這個又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/589.wav", + "text": "放得太寬了一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/590.wav", + "text": "就是直接立即停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/591.wav", + "text": "在這邊是不是應該要經由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/592.wav", + "text": "也就是我們有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/593.wav", + "text": "在性別平等教育法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/594.wav", + "text": "就去肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/595.wav", + "text": "性平會的專業性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/596.wav", + "text": "讓他們在關鍵的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/597.wav", + "text": "都能夠提供他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/598.wav", + "text": "專業的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/599.wav", + "text": "跟評核或是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/600.wav", + "text": "未來還要經過怎麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/601.wav", + "text": "再訓練我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/602.wav", + "text": "其實性平法在這部分是做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/603.wav", + "text": "最多的我們從過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/604.wav", + "text": "修法之後不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/605.wav", + "text": "教師的訓練等等這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/606.wav", + "text": "都有在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/607.wav", + "text": "在這部分我們要如何進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/608.wav", + "text": "把關但是要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/609.wav", + "text": "他們的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/610.wav", + "text": "不但要讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/611.wav", + "text": "被肯定還要能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/612.wav", + "text": "繼續累積下去所以以上是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/613.wav", + "text": "我今天希望在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/614.wav", + "text": "所做的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/615.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/616.wav", + "text": "這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/617.wav", + "text": "本席要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/618.wav", + "text": "范雲委員版本的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/619.wav", + "text": "就是校園性別事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/620.wav", + "text": "如果移送上述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/621.wav", + "text": "述委員會處理被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/622.wav", + "text": "得具當事人地位這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/623.wav", + "text": "我看到范雲委員的版本也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/624.wav", + "text": "人本基金會的反映它也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/625.wav", + "text": "來溝通這件事情的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/626.wav", + "text": "以及目前缺乏這個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/627.wav", + "text": "導致被害學生的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/628.wav", + "text": "受到侵害的問題這點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/629.wav", + "text": "其實我也一直非常關心\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/630.wav", + "text": "\n本席過去接到的相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/631.wav", + "text": "陳情中也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/632.wav", + "text": "學生或者是他的家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/633.wav", + "text": "提到他們在這些委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/634.wav", + "text": "會處理的過程之中沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/635.wav", + "text": "任何的位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/636.wav", + "text": "相當必要的當事人地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/637.wav", + "text": "了他們甚至連詢問都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/638.wav", + "text": "以及反駁的其實只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/639.wav", + "text": "結果出來也都沒有被告知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/640.wav", + "text": "甚至還要其他人幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/641.wav", + "text": "告知才知道可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/642.wav", + "text": "之前發生過滿多行為人已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/643.wav", + "text": "被輕輕放下的懲處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/644.wav", + "text": "來說我認為這個狀況真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/645.wav", + "text": "非常不公平啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/646.wav", + "text": "有很多的爭議包含被害學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/647.wav", + "text": "家長和協助的民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/648.wav", + "text": "團體因此難以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/649.wav", + "text": "信任這些委員會或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/650.wav", + "text": "常常會有一些被認為處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/651.wav", + "text": "偏頗不利被害學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/652.wav", + "text": "等等的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/653.wav", + "text": "黑箱包庇的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/654.wav", + "text": "並且可能因此二度受傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/655.wav", + "text": "些質疑大部分都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/656.wav", + "text": "規定本身的問題嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/657.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到部分的案件中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/658.wav", + "text": "這些委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/659.wav", + "text": "乃至於被指控的行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/660.wav", + "text": "可能也會因此而感到無奈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/661.wav", + "text": "有可能未必有偏頗的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/662.wav", + "text": "也許這些委員確實真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/663.wav", + "text": "有審酌很多情況或有出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/664.wav", + "text": "被害人不知道的證據等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/665.wav", + "text": "���定不夠完善的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/666.wav", + "text": "之下就會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/667.wav", + "text": "因為被害人沒有當事人地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/668.wav", + "text": "導致這些事情沒有辦法被釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/669.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法被告知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/670.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這些委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/671.wav", + "text": "在處理的時候其實真的應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/672.wav", + "text": "要讓被害人具有當事人地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/673.wav", + "text": "這是一個滿重要的變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/674.wav", + "text": "也希望大家可以一起來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/675.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/676.wav", + "text": "品妤委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/677.wav", + "text": "那個部分我的意見一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/678.wav", + "text": "因為它也一起連動到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/679.wav", + "text": "所以當時一起保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/680.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個改變還是滿有意義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/681.wav", + "text": "也滿有回應到我們的意見但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/682.wav", + "text": "可以申復的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/683.wav", + "text": "有一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/684.wav", + "text": "想要釐清\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/685.wav", + "text": "只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/686.wav", + "text": "具有行政處分的性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/687.wav", + "text": "才可以提訴願和行政訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/688.wav", + "text": "譬如說申復後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/689.wav", + "text": "如果主管機關性平會要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/690.wav", + "text": "考績會和教評會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/691.wav", + "text": "作出懲處結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/692.wav", + "text": "對於被害人來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/693.wav", + "text": "這個是行政處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/694.wav", + "text": "是你們所講的吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/695.wav", + "text": "就怎麼樣的申復是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/696.wav", + "text": "有或沒有行政處分的性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/697.wav", + "text": "因為如果只是對行為人而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/698.wav", + "text": "算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/699.wav", + "text": "那就會等於學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/700.wav", + "text": "無法針對懲戒的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/701.wav", + "text": "進行申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/702.wav", + "text": "復這部分教育部是不是可以釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/703.wav", + "text": "剛剛是在討論程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/704.wav", + "text": "我想搭配條文來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/705.wav", + "text": "我們保留的幾個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/706.wav", + "text": "就剛剛部長司長所說明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/707.wav", + "text": "其實相關的是第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/708.wav", + "text": "我建議這5個條文可以一起來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/709.wav", + "text": "就處理的程序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/710.wav", + "text": "謝謝教育部參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/711.wav", + "text": "我們上一次討論的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/712.wav", + "text": "所以在第三十七條的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/713.wav", + "text": "做了比較大幅的制度更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/714.wav", + "text": "我基本上是接受這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/715.wav", + "text": "生對生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/716.wav", + "text": "可以交學校或主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/717.wav", + "text": "但是其他類的就是直接外送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/718.wav", + "text": "這個程序我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/719.wav", + "text": "有參採委員的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/720.wav", + "text": "所以第三十七條條文我基本上也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/721.wav", + "text": "可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/722.wav", + "text": "\n至於剛剛幾位委員所提的賴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/723.wav", + "text": "賴品妤委員跟范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/724.wav", + "text": "說被害人可不可以具備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/725.wav", + "text": "其實你們的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/726.wav", + "text": "的第1項裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/727.wav", + "text": "申請人被害人及行為人對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/728.wav", + "text": "什麼處理不服者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/729.wav", + "text": "其實在條文裡面他們的第37條第39" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/730.wav", + "text": "條都已經參採范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/731.wav", + "text": "跟賴品妤委員所提醒的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/732.wav", + "text": "讓被害人具備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/733.wav", + "text": "他的當事人地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/734.wav", + "text": "所以也許就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/735.wav", + "text": "不需要在第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/736.wav", + "text": "第二項再加一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/737.wav", + "text": "我建議從條文對應來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/738.wav", + "text": "\n所以如果以這個系列的討論上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/739.wav", + "text": "我基本上是認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/740.wav", + "text": "今天提會討論的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/741.wav", + "text": "所以如果大家覺得OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/742.wav", + "text": "已經到協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/743.wav", + "text": "我們還是要對應條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/744.wav", + "text": "\n最後一個要處理的就是第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/745.wav", + "text": "對於他的這些免職後續的裁處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/746.wav", + "text": "要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/747.wav", + "text": "所以今天是這兩大塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/748.wav", + "text": "我建議剛剛的討論就搭配條文來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/749.wav", + "text": "我基本上是支持院版條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/750.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/751.wav", + "text": "我們請教育部再統一說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/752.wav", + "text": "等一下說明完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/753.wav", + "text": "會一併來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/754.wav", + "text": "我們今天提會討論條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/755.wav", + "text": "以��針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/756.wav", + "text": "師對生得逕行向主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/757.wav", + "text": "申復已經切出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/758.wav", + "text": "對於原來的生對生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/759.wav", + "text": "還是得要尋求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/760.wav", + "text": "如何能夠更友善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/761.wav", + "text": "我們剛才討論了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/762.wav", + "text": "就是他一旦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/763.wav", + "text": "跟學校提出申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/764.wav", + "text": "申復的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/765.wav", + "text": "應該可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/766.wav", + "text": "視同學校申訴的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/767.wav", + "text": "就跳過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/768.wav", + "text": "那就跑到主管機關來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/769.wav", + "text": "這個條文我們同仁正在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/770.wav", + "text": "研擬當中等一下大家可以聽聽看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/771.wav", + "text": "對文字的部分是不是同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/772.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/773.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分陳培瑜委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/774.wav", + "text": "有關心對於申復的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/775.wav", + "text": "事由可不可以更明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/776.wav", + "text": "一點如同陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/777.wav", + "text": "所擬的這些項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/778.wav", + "text": "我想應該都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/779.wav", + "text": "提出申復因為滿明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/780.wav", + "text": "我們是想跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/781.wav", + "text": "陳委員商量我們能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/782.wav", + "text": "準則裡面因為我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/783.wav", + "text": "確實有提醒的作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/784.wav", + "text": "沒問題這個部分我剛剛也跟張廖委員請教過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/785.wav", + "text": "因為現場實務的樣態很多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/786.wav", + "text": "所以期待這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/787.wav", + "text": "子法或是準則趕快訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/788.wav", + "text": "現場的老師家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/789.wav", + "text": "在討論這個議題的時候他們確實想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/790.wav", + "text": "知道這個所謂重大瑕疵被認定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/791.wav", + "text": "部分也不希望讓老師增加現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/792.wav", + "text": "工作的負擔這個沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/793.wav", + "text": "謝謝謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/794.wav", + "text": "第三個部分剛才有委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/795.wav", + "text": "問題跟委員報告在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/796.wav", + "text": "目前法令的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/797.wav", + "text": "條文第25條當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/798.wav", + "text": "在行政院審查的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/799.wav", + "text": "其實為了要三法對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/800.wav", + "text": "提供保護人必要的協助跟保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/801.wav", + "text": "在行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/802.wav", + "text": "版當中已經有把法律協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/803.wav", + "text": "納入提供的服務範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/804.wav", + "text": "了所以我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/805.wav", + "text": "就不用再增加條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/806.wav", + "text": "\n另外剛才有委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/807.wav", + "text": "變造等等有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/808.wav", + "text": "於性騷擾或性霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/809.wav", + "text": "證據的部分我們也覺得很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/810.wav", + "text": "所以除了原本的第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/811.wav", + "text": "43條的罰鍰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/812.wav", + "text": "繼續維持以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/813.wav", + "text": "我們在第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/814.wav", + "text": "增列第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/815.wav", + "text": "他的情節如果重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/816.wav", + "text": "可能可以解聘跟免職的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/817.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得確實很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/818.wav", + "text": "所以已經增加了第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/819.wav", + "text": "第2項\n另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/820.wav", + "text": "20天以內要做回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/821.wav", + "text": "通知受理或不受理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/822.wav", + "text": "我們也覺得20天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/823.wav", + "text": "是有一點長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/824.wav", + "text": "了不過跟委員報告以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/825.wav", + "text": "以實務現場來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/826.wav", + "text": "很多學校可能都會透過開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/827.wav", + "text": "性平會的方式來進行審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/828.wav", + "text": "是否受理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/829.wav", + "text": "所以時間確實是需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/830.wav", + "text": "20天不過也有學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/831.wav", + "text": "用比較簡便的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/832.wav", + "text": "他可能就不是開性平大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/833.wav", + "text": "他可能就是組成一個3人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/834.wav", + "text": "審查小組這個可以加速進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/835.wav", + "text": "也許10天內就可以達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/836.wav", + "text": "不過我們有考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/837.wav", + "text": "因為各校的狀況不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/838.wav", + "text": "尤其是涵蓋國小國中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/839.wav", + "text": "高中大學也許在生態上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/840.wav", + "text": "需要保留一點點彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/841.wav", + "text": "讓學校在運作上比較容易處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/842.wav", + "text": "寒暑假期間會更困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/843.wav", + "text": "所以建議還是能夠允許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/844.wav", + "text": "我們保留有二十天的彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/845.wav", + "text": "賴品妤委員還有范雲委員都有談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/846.wav", + "text": "不好意思我還提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/847.wav", + "text": "平會的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/848.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/849.wav", + "text": "這個目前在第37條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/850.wav", + "text": "第4項我們有增列了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/851.wav", + "text": "條文可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/852.wav", + "text": "也就是當主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/853.wav", + "text": "機關在申復審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/854.wav", + "text": "的時候發現它的處理有違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/855.wav", + "text": "或不當我們可以依照性平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/856.wav", + "text": "會的建議逕行改針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/857.wav", + "text": "或教育人員調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/858.wav", + "text": "你們只是由學校來決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/859.wav", + "text": "要不要再加上一個性平會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/860.wav", + "text": "我們有加上情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/861.wav", + "text": "就是並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/862.wav", + "text": "有案件發生就立刻停職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/863.wav", + "text": "應該還是有情節重大的考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/864.wav", + "text": "才做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/865.wav", + "text": "誰來決定情節重不重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/866.wav", + "text": "主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/867.wav", + "text": "游委員不好意思第35條我們已經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/868.wav", + "text": "的專業性有沒有被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/869.wav", + "text": "認定不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/870.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/871.wav", + "text": "另外賴委員還有范委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/872.wav", + "text": "關心第十七條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/873.wav", + "text": "就是被害人的知情權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/874.wav", + "text": "跟陳述意見的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/875.wav", + "text": "我們剛才有發了另外一份資料給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/876.wav", + "text": "性平法還有防治準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/877.wav", + "text": "裡頭有很多的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/878.wav", + "text": "大家可以參考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/879.wav", + "text": "性平法第二十一條提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/880.wav", + "text": "到申請調查的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/881.wav", + "text": "要交由所設的性平會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/882.wav", + "text": "調查處理任何人不得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/883.wav", + "text": "另設調查機制違者其調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/884.wav", + "text": "無效我想說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/885.wav", + "text": "它當初的條文設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/886.wav", + "text": "主要是要保護被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/887.wav", + "text": "不要一直被重複詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/888.wav", + "text": "也不要被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/889.wav", + "text": "未具性平意識的人詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/890.wav", + "text": "調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/891.wav", + "text": "必須要有��平專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/892.wav", + "text": "有性平意識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/893.wav", + "text": "當事人充分陳述意見跟答辯的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/894.wav", + "text": "最後調查的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/895.wav", + "text": "在調查報告當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/896.wav", + "text": "是必須載明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/897.wav", + "text": "\n然後最重要的一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/898.wav", + "text": "各位可以看一下第3頁的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/899.wav", + "text": "我們的防治準則有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/900.wav", + "text": "將來如果有學生提申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/901.wav", + "text": "申復審議小組進行的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/902.wav", + "text": "程序第五點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/903.wav", + "text": "得視需要給予申復人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/904.wav", + "text": "陳述意見之機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/905.wav", + "text": "所設性平會相關委員或調查小組成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/906.wav", + "text": "列席說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/907.wav", + "text": "因為我們配合第37條的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/908.wav", + "text": "師對生的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/909.wav", + "text": "他已經可以直接向主管機關申復了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/910.wav", + "text": "主管機關的申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/911.wav", + "text": "審議小組將來審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/912.wav", + "text": "會依照它申復的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/913.wav", + "text": "可以視需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/914.wav", + "text": "邀請申復人來提供陳述意見的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/915.wav", + "text": "所以第37條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/916.wav", + "text": "修正後的條文跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/917.wav", + "text": "防治準則第31條第3項第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/918.wav", + "text": "就可以接在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/919.wav", + "text": "就會讓當事人有陳述意見的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/920.wav", + "text": "大家有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/921.wav", + "text": "有一些已經通過的條文我們後來發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/922.wav", + "text": "只有對申請人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/923.wav", + "text": "以及檢舉人提供說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/924.wav", + "text": "或者回報處理的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/925.wav", + "text": "不太對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/926.wav", + "text": "其實被害人應該是很關鍵的一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/927.wav", + "text": "已經通過的第25條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/928.wav", + "text": "還有第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/929.wav", + "text": "裡面必須要增列被害人的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/930.wav", + "text": "文字我們都會把它加上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/931.wav", + "text": "等一下有修正動議會另外做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/932.wav", + "text": "針對剛剛的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/933.wav", + "text": "我還是沒有聽到回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/934.wav", + "text": "我剛剛問的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/935.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的申復決定是屬於有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/936.wav", + "text": "或沒有行政處分性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/937.wav", + "text": "性平會做出一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/938.wav", + "text": "跟教評會做出的懲處結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/939.wav", + "text": "這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/940.wav", + "text": "是不是算行政處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/941.wav", + "text": "以臺大的公衛事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/942.wav", + "text": "不算是行政處分我可以往上級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/943.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/944.wav", + "text": "這裡頭有一個很困難的地方是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/945.wav", + "text": "做後續處置的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/946.wav", + "text": "做處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/947.wav", + "text": "對於被害人其實沒有處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/948.wav", + "text": "通常在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/949.wav", + "text": "他是很難循程序提起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/950.wav", + "text": "訴願或行政訴訟的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/951.wav", + "text": "可能是唯一的例外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/952.wav", + "text": "當他申請調查之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/953.wav", + "text": "最後的結果是不成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/954.wav", + "text": "這種情況可能就會構成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/955.wav", + "text": "要不要救援一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/956.wav", + "text": "因為前面的學生又沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/957.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/958.wav", + "text": "校方的懲處過輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/959.wav", + "text": "通常是過輕對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/960.wav", + "text": "那這個就會回到我們剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/961.wav", + "text": "的部分我覺得分流這個部分我現在是沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/962.wav", + "text": "我們現在是針對師對生的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/963.wav", + "text": "這裡面的漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/964.wav", + "text": "所以才會有剛剛賴品妤委員跟我這邊所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/965.wav", + "text": "當事人地位的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/966.wav", + "text": "我還是希望可以保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/967.wav", + "text": "我先補充因為第37條我們現在增加了第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/968.wav", + "text": "這個是過去沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/969.wav", + "text": "而且在討論的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/970.wav", + "text": "我們內部花了很多時間討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/971.wav", + "text": "甚至有事先跟銓敘部徵詢意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/972.wav", + "text": "就是為了要創設一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/973.wav", + "text": "機制如果我們發現他違法或不當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/974.wav", + "text": "主管機關依照性平會的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/975.wav", + "text": "是可以逕行改核的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/976.wav", + "text": "這種情況可能對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/977.wav", + "text": "高中以下的問題可以確實解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/978.wav", + "text": "但大專還是有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/979.wav", + "text": "教師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/980.wav", + "text": "考量到大學自治的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/981.wav", + "text": "對大專以上的那一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/982.wav", + "text": "它仍然給予大專很大的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/983.wav", + "text": "那一塊我們就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/984.wav", + "text": "第37條第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/985.wav", + "text": "後面講的要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/986.wav", + "text": "交回學校依法處理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/987.wav", + "text": "目前法律的規定確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/988.wav", + "text": "有所不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/989.wav", + "text": "那個可能涉及到大學自治的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/990.wav", + "text": "剛剛主席本來是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/991.wav", + "text": "先不要講到第44" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/992.wav", + "text": "條可是因為游委員已經講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/993.wav", + "text": "想一個比較好的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/994.wav", + "text": "去協助我們剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/995.wav", + "text": "我們問的如果他是有惡意的動機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/996.wav", + "text": "偽造變造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/997.wav", + "text": "湮滅跟隱匿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/998.wav", + "text": "他們做了這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/999.wav", + "text": "但是我剛剛跟張廖委員請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1000.wav", + "text": "很多教育現場的樣態確實非常多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1001.wav", + "text": "老師可能不是刻意或是惡意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1002.wav", + "text": "他可能是在為了保護學生的這個情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1003.wav", + "text": "所以有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1004.wav", + "text": "請教育部去想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1005.wav", + "text": "有沒有什麼辦法就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1006.wav", + "text": "它有各種的考量各種的樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1007.wav", + "text": "但是又要考慮到惡意的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1008.wav", + "text": "有幾個可能性請教育部想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1009.wav", + "text": "也許我們等一下可以快速做出決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1010.wav", + "text": "你們可以訂子法或是細則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1011.wav", + "text": "來規範那個樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1012.wav", + "text": "到底是在什麼情況下他做出這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1013.wav", + "text": "惡意的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1014.wav", + "text": "就必須要予以解聘或者免職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1015.wav", + "text": "有這麼重的懲罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1016.wav", + "text": "還是說你們是透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1017.wav", + "text": "主管機關認定他的相關行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1018.wav", + "text": "因為目前你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1019.wav", + "text": "送來提院討論的版本寫的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1020.wav", + "text": "有關機關查證屬實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1021.wav", + "text": "對嗎可是又回到那個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1022.wav", + "text": "如果這個案件就是學校內的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1023.wav", + "text": "又是由學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1024.wav", + "text": "自己內部的單位來決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1025.wav", + "text": "這個證據被編造被湮滅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1026.wav", + "text": "是不是惡意的好像又回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1027.wav", + "text": "那個死胡同裡面去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1028.wav", + "text": "的這個部分拿掉而是由主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1029.wav", + "text": "來查證屬實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1030.wav", + "text": "他有這樣的行為我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1031.wav", + "text": "予以免職解聘等相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1032.wav", + "text": "懲處或是你們把子法或細則寫得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1033.wav", + "text": "更清楚把這個樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1034.wav", + "text": "讓學校老師知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1035.wav", + "text": "我是站在保護學生的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1036.wav", + "text": "還是我是惡意的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1037.wav", + "text": "是為了保護我的同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1038.wav", + "text": "我想這樣的討論教育部應該就比較可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1039.wav", + "text": "我們在為學生擔心的那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1040.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1041.wav", + "text": "用的是經學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1042.wav", + "text": "或有關機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1043.wav", + "text": "二擇一就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1044.wav", + "text": "有關機關可以做到這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1045.wav", + "text": "可是這個有關機關的寫法我覺得還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1046.wav", + "text": "會讓人有點擔心要嘛就是寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1047.wav", + "text": "張廖萬堅委員現場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1048.wav", + "text": "實務也許我們是透過子法跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1049.wav", + "text": "細則來討論把這個樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1050.wav", + "text": "態寫得更清楚其實真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1051.wav", + "text": "主要是要懲罰那些有惡意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1052.wav", + "text": "之間的這種行為啦我相信司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1053.wav", + "text": "應該明白我們並不是要去動到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1054.wav", + "text": "其他那些認真守法的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1055.wav", + "text": "我們也想要保護那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1056.wav", + "text": "為了保護學生的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1057.wav", + "text": "把它明文寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1058.wav", + "text": "我們還是會擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1059.wav", + "text": "就是剛剛所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1060.wav", + "text": "性平會的懲處不夠或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1061.wav", + "text": "性平會的懲處考績會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1062.wav", + "text": "跟教評會並不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1063.wav", + "text": "通常都是做更輕的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1064.wav", + "text": "的部分有一個但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1065.wav", + "text": "就是如果考績或教評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1066.wav", + "text": "會有變動性平會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1067.wav", + "text": "之懲處的時候能夠讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1068.wav", + "text": "被害學生有一個陳述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1069.wav", + "text": "意見的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1070.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子的話我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1071.wav", + "text": "不放當事人地位才能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1072.wav", + "text": "也到關鍵條文了我必須上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1073.wav", + "text": "\n我是覺得你們修改的方向我已經大致可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1074.wav", + "text": "接受那就是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1075.wav", + "text": "這個疑慮的部分我們還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1076.wav", + "text": "我等一下要去衛環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1077.wav", + "text": "就是剛才范委員說的有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1078.wav", + "text": "陳述的部分我們在申復的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1079.wav", + "text": "可以讓當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1080.wav", + "text": "來陳述意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1081.wav", + "text": "這塊在現行的防治準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1082.wav", + "text": "好你如果放在立法說明中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1083.wav", + "text": "我們就OK好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1084.wav", + "text": "確定喔要給我們看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1085.wav", + "text": "我們相信你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1086.wav", + "text": "你說原本就有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1087.wav", + "text": "臺大公衛的那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1088.wav", + "text": "它就完全沒有處理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1089.wav", + "text": "就是我那天質詢部長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1090.wav", + "text": "有提到的例子他們懲處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1091.wav", + "text": "停職3年結果後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1092.wav", + "text": "只有1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1093.wav", + "text": "申復是這次第37條第1項才放進去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1094.wav", + "text": "對臺大的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1095.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1096.wav", + "text": "那謝謝范委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1097.wav", + "text": "也是有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1098.wav", + "text": "先得出一個結論這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1099.wav", + "text": "\n我們先從第十七條開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1100.wav", + "text": "學校相關委員會的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1101.wav", + "text": "任一性別委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1102.wav", + "text": "應占委員總數三分之一以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1103.wav", + "text": "這個主要的爭點是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1104.wav", + "text": "經移送相關委員會後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1105.wav", + "text": "被害人是否具有當事人的地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1106.wav", + "text": "范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1107.wav", + "text": "剛才關切的就是這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1108.wav", + "text": "這樣就是能不能把當事人地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1109.wav", + "text": "的部分反正現在你們要把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1110.wav", + "text": "加在立法說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1111.wav", + "text": "現在如果把它放在立法說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1112.wav", + "text": "這樣可不可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1113.wav", + "text": "申請人及行為人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1114.wav", + "text": "申復機制現在比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1115.wav", + "text": "大的爭點是在申請人要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1116.wav", + "text": "學生能不能直接向學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1117.wav", + "text": "所屬主管機關申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1118.wav", + "text": "我想這個地方教育部已經做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1119.wav", + "text": "直接就可以嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1120.wav", + "text": "\n當然這邊主要就是陳培瑜委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1121.wav", + "text": "剛才再修正的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1122.wav", + "text": "你們現在能夠出得來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1123.wav", + "text": "的話看要不要現在通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1124.wav", + "text": "各位委員看看可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1125.wav", + "text": "剛才提到的就是師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1126.wav", + "text": "對生對生的部分他們有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1127.wav", + "text": "他向學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1128.wav", + "text": "所為的申復決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1129.wav", + "text": "視同向學校申訴決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1130.wav", + "text": "就不用再多一次了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1131.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1132.wav", + "text": "大家看一下條文行不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1133.wav", + "text": "特別是陳委員\n下一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1134.wav", + "text": "多一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1135.wav", + "text": "讓我們先研擬一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1136.wav", + "text": "意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1137.wav", + "text": "向學校申復的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1138.wav", + "text": "視同向學校申訴的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1139.wav", + "text": "就跳過這段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1140.wav", + "text": "可以再進行申對就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1141.wav", + "text": "不要再來一次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1142.wav", + "text": "\n處長你看起來很為難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1143.wav", + "text": "是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1144.wav", + "text": "先跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1145.wav", + "text": "申復是學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1146.wav", + "text": "依照性平會的調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1147.wav", + "text": "跟最終處理結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1148.wav", + "text": "以生對生來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1149.wav", + "text": "包括成立不成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1150.wav", + "text": "包括對這個學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1151.wav", + "text": "要不要記過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1152.wav", + "text": "行政懲處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1153.wav", + "text": "被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1154.wav", + "text": "也可以提起申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1155.wav", + "text": "如果被駁回的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1156.wav", + "text": "才會有所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1157.wav", + "text": "這個被記過的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1158.wav", + "text": "學生申訴的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1159.wav", + "text": "因為他被記過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1160.wav", + "text": "他才是這個記過的當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1161.wav", + "text": "如果這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1162.wav", + "text": "的調查結果是記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1163.wav", + "text": "他是不提起學生申訴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1164.wav", + "text": "\n對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1165.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1166.wav", + "text": "他對於這個申復的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1167.wav", + "text": "除非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1168.wav", + "text": "是他的申請調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1169.wav", + "text": "不成立了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1170.wav", + "text": "可以提起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1171.wav", + "text": "學生申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1172.wav", + "text": "因為是學校對他申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1173.wav", + "text": "的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1174.wav", + "text": "再不服的話還可以提起再申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1175.wav", + "text": "但這種類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1176.wav", + "text": "因為他自己沒有被行政處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1177.wav", + "text": "在目前實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1178.wav", + "text": "是進不了法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1179.wav", + "text": "只是我們給他申訴再申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1180.wav", + "text": "可以針對他的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1181.wav", + "text": "如果被師師相護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1182.wav", + "text": "或是對於要河蟹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1183.wav", + "text": "河蟹生生的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1184.wav", + "text": "他被擋下來是不成立的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1185.wav", + "text": "他可以就學生申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1186.wav", + "text": "再申訴再去做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1187.wav", + "text": "處長那你們部裡面的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1188.wav", + "text": "如果加這一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1189.wav", + "text": "因為後面的學生申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1190.wav", + "text": "那你們內部先協調一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1191.wav", + "text": "因為你們順便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1192.wav", + "text": "卡在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1193.wav", + "text": "第37條我們就先暫保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1194.wav", + "text": "\n我們直接先到第38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1195.wav", + "text": "於接獲重新調查之要求時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1196.wav", + "text": "應另組調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1197.wav", + "text": "它的爭點是調查小組成員是否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1198.wav", + "text": "不得與原調查小組重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1199.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就照院版通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1200.wav", + "text": "好第38條按院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1201.wav", + "text": "\n我們再往下走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1202.wav", + "text": "39條的要旨是申請人或行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1203.wav", + "text": "對申復結果不服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1204.wav", + "text": "得於接獲書面通知之次日起三十日內提起救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1205.wav", + "text": "這邊的主要爭點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1206.wav", + "text": "行為人為教職員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1207.wav", + "text": "學生仍須於校內救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1208.wav", + "text": "可否向主管機關救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1209.wav", + "text": "這個地方好像也解決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1210.wav", + "text": "所以是不是可以請主席保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1211.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1212.wav", + "text": "好那第39條就先跟第37條一起暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1213.wav", + "text": "主要的要旨是學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1214.wav", + "text": "性平委員會調查審議程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1215.wav", + "text": "如果有違法情形之監督機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1216.wav", + "text": "是否可與申復機制一併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1217.wav", + "text": "這個地方我們是不是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1218.wav", + "text": "按照院版好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1219.wav", + "text": "那我們就按照院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1220.wav", + "text": "\n再來是最後一條第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1221.wav", + "text": "學校校長等違反通報義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1222.wav", + "text": "致再度發生校園性侵害事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1223.wav", + "text": "應予以解聘或免職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1224.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1225.wav", + "text": "我們倒回來一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1226.wav", + "text": "第4條是按照提會版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1227.wav", + "text": "更正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1228.wav", + "text": "不是院版是提會版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1229.wav", + "text": "這個地方的爭點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1230.wav", + "text": "如果非屬故意而未通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1231.wav", + "text": "即予以解聘或免職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1232.wav", + "text": "是不是有懲處過重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1233.wav", + "text": "這一條剛剛次長有來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1234.wav", + "text": "是經學校或有關機關查證屬實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1235.wav", + "text": "次長是說可不可以改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1236.wav", + "text": "經學校或主管機關查證屬實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1237.wav", + "text": "我們覺得這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1238.wav", + "text": "目前應該是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1239.wav", + "text": "堅委員請教過他也覺得這樣是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1240.wav", + "text": "主管機關不要有關機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1241.wav", + "text": "好我個人也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1242.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1243.wav", + "text": "經學校或主管機關查證屬實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1244.wav", + "text": "就予以解聘免職終止契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1245.wav", + "text": "我們法制處說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1246.wav", + "text": "因為也有可能是警察機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1247.wav", + "text": "在偵查的過程當中發現的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1248.wav", + "text": "如果只有寫主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1249.wav", + "text": "反而會被限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1250.wav", + "text": "那我另外請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1251.wav", + "text": "剛剛我的同事提醒我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1252.wav", + "text": "現在我們是把性侵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1253.wav", + "text": "性霸凌性騷擾分開寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1254.wav", + "text": "到時候假設真的有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1255.wav", + "text": "因為隱匿了性侵的證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1256.wav", + "text": "被解聘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1257.wav", + "text": "那他會不會去憲法法庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1258.wav", + "text": "聲請相關比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1259.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛有幫你們想到這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1260.wav", + "text": "的問題但我們還是想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1261.wav", + "text": "回到之前逐條審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1262.wav", + "text": "我們的立場也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1263.wav", + "text": "當有相關證據被湮滅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1264.wav", + "text": "隱匿這個問題在性騷擾性霸凌部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1265.wav", + "text": "時我們覺得還是要處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1266.wav", + "text": "育部再研議要怎麼寫是比較適當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1267.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1268.wav", + "text": "之前教師法第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1269.wav", + "text": "有一個解聘終身的要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1270.wav", + "text": "叫行為不檢有損師道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1271.wav", + "text": "只要行為不檢有損師道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1272.wav", + "text": "不管他的情節輕重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1273.wav", + "text": "都一律解聘終身不得聘任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1274.wav", + "text": "這就是委員所關切的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1275.wav", + "text": "會不會違憲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1276.wav", + "text": "確實它是會違憲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1277.wav", + "text": "所以被宣告違憲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1278.wav", + "text": "還有情節重大的性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1279.wav", + "text": "跟性霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1280.wav", + "text": "有這部分就是解聘終身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1281.wav", + "text": "如果情節比較輕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1282.wav", + "text": "就解聘一到四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1283.wav", + "text": "因為有情節最重大的解聘終身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1284.wav", + "text": "跟一到四年的區別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1285.wav", + "text": "所以不會有違憲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1286.wav", + "text": "至於現行規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1287.wav", + "text": "針對性侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1288.wav", + "text": "隱匿是性侵害的要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1289.wav", + "text": "沒有通報的也是性侵害的要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1290.wav", + "text": "就是解聘終身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1291.wav", + "text": "教師法也是一樣的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1292.wav", + "text": "所以到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1293.wav", + "text": "那麼多年教師團認為這二款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1294.wav", + "text": "沒有違憲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1295.wav", + "text": "所以我們上次才會特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1296.wav", + "text": "如果把有情節光譜的性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1297.wav", + "text": "一律比照性侵害辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1298.wav", + "text": "那就會有違憲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1299.wav", + "text": "現在把它分成二類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1300.wav", + "text": "是情節比較輕微的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1301.wav", + "text": "所以我們上次跟委員建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1302.wav", + "text": "所舉的例子就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1303.wav", + "text": "說黃色笑話的性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1304.wav", + "text": "這樣就不會有違憲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1305.wav", + "text": "我上次在這邊跟您強調過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1306.wav", + "text": "我要再次跟您強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1307.wav", + "text": "我們強調的是做出隱匿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1308.wav", + "text": "變造證據這樣的動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1309.wav", + "text": "而不是指性侵性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1310.wav", + "text": "擾性霸凌的情節輕重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1311.wav", + "text": "我們講的不是那件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1312.wav", + "text": "做出這些相關行為的處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1313.wav", + "text": "所以沒有情節輕重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1314.wav", + "text": "沒有光譜的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1315.wav", + "text": "但我們還是必須考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1316.wav", + "text": "堅委員告訴我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1317.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會再一次向次長請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1318.wav", + "text": "針對這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1319.wav", + "text": "針對性騷擾性霸凌的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1320.wav", + "text": "證據做出這些行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1321.wav", + "text": "因為關鍵他為什麼要做出這樣的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1322.wav", + "text": "去變造隱匿證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1323.wav", + "text": "跟性霸凌也其心可議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1324.wav", + "text": "如果是惡意或刻意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1325.wav", + "text": "為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1326.wav", + "text": "可以快速討論出寫法那這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1327.wav", + "text": "就不用保留是不是請主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1328.wav", + "text": "協助我們目前增列第2項是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1329.wav", + "text": "機關查證屬實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1330.wav", + "text": "有解聘免職終止契約關係或終止運用關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1331.wav", + "text": "之必要者應依相關法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1332.wav", + "text": "辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1333.wav", + "text": "法據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1334.wav", + "text": "至於什麼情況是有必要者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1335.wav", + "text": "也都會做細部規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1336.wav", + "text": "就是在立法說明裡直接寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1337.wav", + "text": "我們會在防治準則中把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1338.wav", + "text": "準則還是立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1339.wav", + "text": "在立法說明裡說要在防治準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1340.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1341.wav", + "text": "討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1342.wav", + "text": "警察機關的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1343.wav", + "text": "有關機關彈性比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1344.wav", + "text": "寫主管機關會被限縮反而到時候警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1345.wav", + "text": "發現了卻無法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1346.wav", + "text": "照提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1347.wav", + "text": "照提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1348.wav", + "text": "中把要件是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1349.wav", + "text": "條等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1350.wav", + "text": "處理\n這邊還有一些修正動議我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1351.wav", + "text": "我快速地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1352.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1353.wav", + "text": "增列性平會委員資格等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1354.wav", + "text": "辦法授權學校主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1355.wav", + "text": "訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1356.wav", + "text": "\n第9條酌修文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1357.wav", + "text": "第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1358.wav", + "text": "改成被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1359.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1360.wav", + "text": "\n第36條酌修文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1361.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1362.wav", + "text": "\n第48條增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1363.wav", + "text": "增修本次修正條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1364.wav", + "text": "施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1365.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1366.wav", + "text": "第37條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1367.wav", + "text": "申復時間從20天延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1368.wav", + "text": "為30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1369.wav", + "text": "給當事人有更充分的時間做準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1370.wav", + "text": "與處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1371.wav", + "text": "但行為人為校長教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1372.wav", + "text": "職員或工友者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1373.wav", + "text": "申請人或被害人得逕向主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1374.wav", + "text": "機關申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1375.wav", + "text": "經申復審議結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1376.wav", + "text": "如有重大瑕疵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1377.wav", + "text": "或足以影響調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1378.wav", + "text": "認定的新事實新證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1379.wav", + "text": "可以要求性平會重新調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1380.wav", + "text": "陳培瑜委員有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1381.wav", + "text": "附帶決議我們會依照這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1382.wav", + "text": "附帶決議將來在準則中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1383.wav", + "text": "的事由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1384.wav", + "text": "要重新調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1385.wav", + "text": "者必須縮短時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1386.wav", + "text": "限期在40日內完成調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1387.wav", + "text": "以避免原來法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1388.wav", + "text": "規定是二個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1389.wav", + "text": "可以延長一次再一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1390.wav", + "text": "最長總共會拉到四個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1391.wav", + "text": "這對於事情處理可能會延宕太久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1392.wav", + "text": "所以我們限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1393.wav", + "text": "必須在限期40日內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1394.wav", + "text": "完成重新調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1395.wav", + "text": "\n增加第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1396.wav", + "text": "就是主管機關經過第1項但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1397.wav", + "text": "申復審議結果發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1398.wav", + "text": "學校的處理結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1399.wav", + "text": "這裡的學校的處理結果指的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1400.wav", + "text": "前面所講教評會考績會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1401.wav", + "text": "這些單位的處理結果如果違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1402.wav", + "text": "或不當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1403.wav", + "text": "必要時可依所設之性平會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1404.wav", + "text": "處理建議對於學校處理結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1405.wav", + "text": "逕行改核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1406.wav", + "text": "核後面一段則敘明理由交回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1407.wav", + "text": "學校依法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1408.wav", + "text": "追究相關責任這主要是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1409.wav", + "text": "專科以上學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1410.wav", + "text": "因為專科以上學校部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1411.wav", + "text": "逕行改核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1412.wav", + "text": "畢竟涉及大學自治所以只能交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1413.wav", + "text": "回學校依法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1414.wav", + "text": "但要追究相關人員責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1415.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1416.wav", + "text": "害人部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1417.wav", + "text": "也說明他對於申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1418.wav", + "text": "30日內可以提起救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1419.wav", + "text": "法律別有規定者依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1420.wav", + "text": "規定下面就是依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1421.wav", + "text": "校長教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1422.wav", + "text": "申訴評議相關法規來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1423.wav", + "text": "做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1424.wav", + "text": "公務人員部分就依照公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1425.wav", + "text": "任用法公務人員保障法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1426.wav", + "text": "學生就依照學生的申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1427.wav", + "text": "提起申訴來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1428.wav", + "text": "如果他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1429.wav", + "text": "申復之後對於申復的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1430.wav", + "text": "結果不服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1431.wav", + "text": "申訴再申訴時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1432.wav", + "text": "設立一條就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1433.wav", + "text": "他向學校申復的決定可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1434.wav", + "text": "視同向學校提起申訴的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1435.wav", + "text": "後來我們仔細考慮一下就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1436.wav", + "text": "向學校申復的決定可能有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1437.wav", + "text": "幾種不同的樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1438.wav", + "text": "也有可能是申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1439.wav", + "text": "有理由最後發回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1440.wav", + "text": "重新調查重新處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1441.wav", + "text": "這種情況好像不太適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1442.wav", + "text": "直接切過去視同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1443.wav", + "text": "學生的申訴決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1444.wav", + "text": "37條第39條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1445.wav", + "text": "但我們一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1446.wav", + "text": "增加一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1447.wav", + "text": "來說明清楚就是涉及到幾種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1448.wav", + "text": "不同樣態的申復決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1449.wav", + "text": "我們會把有關於這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1450.wav", + "text": "特殊的情況它是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1451.wav", + "text": "視同學校申訴決定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1452.wav", + "text": "也許這些規定將來納入準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1453.wav", + "text": "裡來做規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1454.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1455.wav", + "text": "各位委員我來做補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1456.wav", + "text": "生對生的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1457.wav", + "text": "在流程圖就是會回到原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1458.wav", + "text": "跟學校的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1459.wav", + "text": "那個審議小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1460.wav", + "text": "裡面去做一些申復的動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1461.wav", + "text": "關於生對生的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1462.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1463.wav", + "text": "走學校這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1464.wav", + "text": "申復了以後後面會有各種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1465.wav", + "text": "包含可能他有一些違失或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1466.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1467.wav", + "text": "所以跟學校申復了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1468.wav", + "text": "對於學生的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1469.wav", + "text": "既然沒有終局性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1470.wav", + "text": "因為還要回到這個流程去做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1471.wav", + "text": "是沒辦法直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1472.wav", + "text": "做有關申訴的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1473.wav", + "text": "我們研訂了一個高級中等學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1474.wav", + "text": "學生申訴及再申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1475.wav", + "text": "評議委員會組織及運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1476.wav", + "text": "自治組織對學校之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1477.wav", + "text": "懲處其他措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1478.wav", + "text": "或決議認為違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1479.wav", + "text": "或不當致損害其權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1480.wav", + "text": "對於這個學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1481.wav", + "text": "必須對學校的懲處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1482.wav", + "text": "還有它的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1483.wav", + "text": "或者它的決議要做成決定以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1484.wav", + "text": "他才有辦法去申訴這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1485.wav", + "text": "跟學校申復的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1486.wav", + "text": "還沒有作成這樣的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1487.wav", + "text": "所以他申訴的部分沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1488.wav", + "text": "申訴的標的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1489.wav", + "text": "但是剛剛委員關心的部分就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1490.wav", + "text": "申訴的部分可不可以簡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1491.wav", + "text": "還是維持我們現在提案版本的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1492.wav", + "text": "但是針對這種性平事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1493.wav", + "text": "的申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1494.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的那個申訴辦法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1495.wav", + "text": "有申訴再申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1496.wav", + "text": "但是對於性平案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1497.wav", + "text": "如果已經有申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1498.wav", + "text": "已經有處理結果的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1499.wav", + "text": "是不是可以在高中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1500.wav", + "text": "或者高中以下的那個申訴辦法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1501.wav", + "text": "對於學生申訴再申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1502.wav", + "text": "這個程序的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1503.wav", + "text": "是不是可以予以簡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1504.wav", + "text": "我們建議是不是用附帶決議的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1505.wav", + "text": "我們就有關申訴的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1506.wav", + "text": "來研議做簡化的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1507.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1508.wav", + "text": "謝謝次長附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1509.wav", + "text": "好像現在正在擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1510.wav", + "text": "能不能擬一下趕快給陳委員看一下行不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1511.wav", + "text": "37條是不是按照提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1512.wav", + "text": "提會版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1513.wav", + "text": "再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1514.wav", + "text": "好還有陳培瑜委員的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1515.wav", + "text": "也擺在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1516.wav", + "text": "還有我的放到說明文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1517.wav", + "text": "那個已經在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1518.wav", + "text": "通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1519.wav", + "text": "為第37條跟第39條要一起看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1520.wav", + "text": "還是回到第39條來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1521.wav", + "text": "就是它可不可以不經再申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1522.wav", + "text": "因為第39條以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1523.wav", + "text": "如果第39條過了第37條我們就動不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1524.wav", + "text": "我們知道現在教育部已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1525.wav", + "text": "聽懂我們的訴求了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1526.wav", + "text": "也知道學生可能在學校遇到的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1527.wav", + "text": "但是這個樣態這麼多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1528.wav", + "text": "我們可不可以再有一些討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1529.wav", + "text": "是不是可以用附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1530.wav", + "text": "就是針對學校的校長教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1531.wav", + "text": "還有公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1532.wav", + "text": "還有包含學校的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1533.wav", + "text": "它會有分管道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1534.wav", + "text": "學生的部分就回到學生的申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1535.wav", + "text": "那個部分應該不是適合在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1536.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法來規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1537.wav", + "text": "那個應該回到申訴的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1538.wav", + "text": "申訴的相關規定是依照國民教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1539.wav", + "text": "和高級中等教育法的規定去做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1540.wav", + "text": "的所以我們會比較建議第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1541.wav", + "text": "第39條就委員所關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1542.wav", + "text": "的生對生那個申訴程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1543.wav", + "text": "能不能簡化的部分用附帶決議的方式處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1544.wav", + "text": "我們已經有研擬這個附帶決議的文字了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1545.wav", + "text": "我們可不可以先看一下附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1546.wav", + "text": "主席我們快速看一下附帶決議好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1547.wav", + "text": "主席不好意思我們快速看一下附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1548.wav", + "text": "關於學校學生的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1549.wav", + "text": "因為我們剛剛在講就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1550.wav", + "text": "學校學生申訴後不服的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1551.wav", + "text": "救濟方式有二種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1552.wav", + "text": "一個是向學校申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1553.wav", + "text": "另一個是向主管機關申復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1554.wav", + "text": "二種樣態可是這邊因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1555.wav", + "text": "所屬學校提起申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1556.wav", + "text": "如果一般學生看法條的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1557.wav", + "text": "就會不知道向主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1558.wav", + "text": "機關申復這個狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1559.wav", + "text": "不服的話可以怎麼處理所以這邊是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1560.wav", + "text": "這種樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1561.wav", + "text": "因為你這邊是在講相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1562.wav", + "text": "echo一下剛剛范雲委員說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1563.wav", + "text": "我們還是有很大的concern" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1564.wav", + "text": "因為基於很多學校現場的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1565.wav", + "text": "其實我們在想的也不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1566.wav", + "text": "只有學生的部分一旦老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1567.wav", + "text": "要協助學生處理相關的流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1568.wav", + "text": "我們也聽了很多現場老師的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1569.wav", + "text": "意見就是這個樣態多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1570.wav", + "text": "如果要考慮到相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1571.wav", + "text": "流程的通暢與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1572.wav", + "text": "簡化但是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1573.wav", + "text": "用附帶決議我們覺得會有一個很大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1574.wav", + "text": "法制上的問題就是憲法保障救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1575.wav", + "text": "救濟的權利是不是可以用附帶決議來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1576.wav", + "text": "替代這個部分也要請法制再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1577.wav", + "text": "考慮一下哦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1578.wav", + "text": "如果真的還是需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1579.wav", + "text": "討論時間但是我們今天還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1580.wav", + "text": "有其他工作流程安排的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1581.wav", + "text": "是不是可以允許第37條和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1582.wav", + "text": "保留再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1583.wav", + "text": "我跟主席和委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1584.wav", + "text": "因為我內部也瞭解過這三四天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1585.wav", + "text": "其實在研究有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1586.wav", + "text": "\n如果我們現在很快的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1587.wav", + "text": "一定要在母法訂結果又會產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1588.wav", + "text": "另外一個其他的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1589.wav", + "text": "這是我們反覆在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1590.wav", + "text": "的所以剛才提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1591.wav", + "text": "屬於學生再申訴的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1592.wav", + "text": "是不是可以允許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1593.wav", + "text": "因為這是在做法律修正的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1594.wav", + "text": "我想是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1595.wav", + "text": "只是說如果要在法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1596.wav", + "text": "上細到這麼細去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1597.wav", + "text": "我覺得有它的限制我只能這樣跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1598.wav", + "text": "這個實務上的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1599.wav", + "text": "避免為了維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1600.wav", + "text": "最後又給學生做了很多的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1601.wav", + "text": "因為剛才在談那個流程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1602.wav", + "text": "確實它不是終局的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1603.wav", + "text": "但是在這裡一旦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1604.wav", + "text": "就把這個部分直接減縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1605.wav", + "text": "對學生未必是一個最好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1606.wav", + "text": "權益的維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1607.wav", + "text": "溝通一下因為這是最後了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1608.wav", + "text": "那就是看執政黨黨版自己決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1609.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1610.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1611.wav", + "text": "剛剛經過熱烈的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1612.wav", + "text": "修正後通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1613.wav", + "text": "陳培瑜委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1614.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1615.wav", + "text": "還有一個立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1616.wav", + "text": "一第十七條及第三十八" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1617.wav", + "text": "條照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1618.wav", + "text": "修正通過如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1619.wav", + "text": "共2項如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1620.wav", + "text": "五檢附立法說明一份如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15103/1621.wav", + "text": "我們簽署後就散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/0.wav", + "text": "會議開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1.wav", + "text": "今天是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/2.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/3.wav", + "text": "研商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/4.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/5.wav", + "text": "柯建銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/6.wav", + "text": "劉世芳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/7.wav", + "text": "及委員曾銘宗謝衣鳯林思銘等37人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/8.wav", + "text": "分別所提召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/9.wav", + "text": "第10屆第七會期第二次臨時會相關事宜案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/10.wav", + "text": "院長各位協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/11.wav", + "text": "大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/12.wav", + "text": "終於又到碰面的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/13.wav", + "text": "但大家要開會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/14.wav", + "text": "氛圍很濃烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/15.wav", + "text": "我們今天也感謝院長召集朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/16.wav", + "text": "商上禮拜五我們已經針對臨時會的提案送案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/17.wav", + "text": "那我現在簡單的描述一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/18.wav", + "text": "民主進步黨對於臨時會的看法第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/19.wav", + "text": "性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/20.wav", + "text": "當然在上次第一次臨時會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/21.wav", + "text": "大家在協商中都有講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/22.wav", + "text": "第二個就是臺美21世紀貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/23.wav", + "text": "第三個就是外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/24.wav", + "text": "我們在這一次臨時會希望處理的法案是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/25.wav", + "text": "當然等一下各黨團如果有不同的意見我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/26.wav", + "text": "這是我們的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/27.wav", + "text": "今天早上有協商然後下午就有談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/28.wav", + "text": "時間就是從今天開始到7月31日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/29.wav", + "text": "我現在所談的就是本黨的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/30.wav", + "text": "當然如果有什麼調整我們再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/31.wav", + "text": "時間大致是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/32.wav", + "text": "這樣安排的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/33.wav", + "text": "我們要請院長來做備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/34.wav", + "text": "對於一個法案如此的慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/35.wav", + "text": "這是史上第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/36.wav", + "text": "院長來做法案的備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/37.wav", + "text": "第二個有關於臺美21世紀貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/38.wav", + "text": "我們也提案請院長來做備詢因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/39.wav", + "text": "這是一個國家重大事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/40.wav", + "text": "是有關臺灣和美國之間關係的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/41.wav", + "text": "以及彼此之間的合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/42.wav", + "text": "亞太地區的和平安全等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/43.wav", + "text": "我相信對這個法大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/44.wav", + "text": "我們也提案要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/45.wav", + "text": "禮拜三院長來備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/46.wav", + "text": "接下去剩下幾天就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/47.wav", + "text": "本週四本週五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/48.wav", + "text": "乃至於到下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/49.wav", + "text": "週四週五到下禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/50.wav", + "text": "都是委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/51.wav", + "text": "下禮拜二以後當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/52.wav", + "text": "有出委員會以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/53.wav", + "text": "做整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/54.wav", + "text": "然後接下去就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/55.wav", + "text": "是在下禮拜剩下的4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/56.wav", + "text": "4天進行密集性的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/57.wav", + "text": "委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/58.wav", + "text": "當然臺美21世紀貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/59.wav", + "text": "在過去應該是經濟委員會主審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/60.wav", + "text": "這幾個委員會我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/61.wav", + "text": "看院會是怎麼交下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/62.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/63.wav", + "text": "都是開聯席會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/64.wav", + "text": "有關於性平教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/65.wav", + "text": "這是在教育委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/66.wav", + "text": "可能是張其祿委員主審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/67.wav", + "text": "那我要特別拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/68.wav", + "text": "尤其修改幅度比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/69.wav", + "text": "我們在委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/70.wav", + "text": "可能要密集審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/71.wav", + "text": "3天把它審出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/72.wav", + "text": "朝野要協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/73.wav", + "text": "而協商以後���同意見再來表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/74.wav", + "text": "所以今天朝野協商第一個一定要確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/75.wav", + "text": "所有法案我們都把它撈進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/76.wav", + "text": "到上個禮拜五為止的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/77.wav", + "text": "我們要把它撈進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/78.wav", + "text": "這裡面包括國民黨黨團有增加版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/79.wav", + "text": "以及民眾黨也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/80.wav", + "text": "時代力量也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/81.wav", + "text": "各黨團的都放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/82.wav", + "text": "這樣可能會有八十幾個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/83.wav", + "text": "三法裡面有提案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/84.wav", + "text": "到上個禮拜五截止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/85.wav", + "text": "而今天陸續送的可能來不及了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/86.wav", + "text": "全部都放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/87.wav", + "text": "當然各黨都會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/88.wav", + "text": "有新的委員送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/89.wav", + "text": "以前我們都把它放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/90.wav", + "text": "給大家平等問政的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/91.wav", + "text": "已經不復議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/92.wav", + "text": "這個程序性很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/93.wav", + "text": "等一下議事人員也會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/94.wav", + "text": "接下來我們會碰到一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/95.wav", + "text": "到月底為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/96.wav", + "text": "上次我們有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/97.wav", + "text": "過性平三法7月底完成立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/98.wav", + "text": "排除朝野協商期一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/99.wav", + "text": "有關於臺美21世紀貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/100.wav", + "text": "也是排除朝野協商期一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/101.wav", + "text": "我們希望大家能夠有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/102.wav", + "text": "至於外役監條例如果有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/103.wav", + "text": "要排除的話我們也可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/104.wav", + "text": "本黨對於這次臨時會所作的一些看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/105.wav", + "text": "好謝謝柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/106.wav", + "text": "接下來請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/107.wav", + "text": "院長所有各黨團的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/108.wav", + "text": "希望他召開不管是性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/109.wav", + "text": "不管是臺美21世紀貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/110.wav", + "text": "或者是外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/111.wav", + "text": "都是我們優先發動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/112.wav", + "text": "在他們的外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/113.wav", + "text": "其實在上上會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/114.wav", + "text": "陳委員歐珀已經排審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/115.wav", + "text": "但是沒有出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/116.wav", + "text": "導致現在這次臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/117.wav", + "text": "我們繼續審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/118.wav", + "text": "還是在委員會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/119.wav", + "text": "如果過去已經出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/120.wav", + "text": "我們現在就只是再朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/121.wav", + "text": "以及黨團協商馬上就可以出委員會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/122.wav", + "text": "\n今天我們來討論這些事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/123.wav", + "text": "也是國民黨主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/124.wav", + "text": "關於性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/125.wav", + "text": "我們當時也談到不只涵蓋三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/126.wav", + "text": "也有相關的八法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/127.wav", + "text": "也是民進黨先提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/128.wav", + "text": "但是民進黨又退縮到原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/129.wav", + "text": "你們的性平三法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/130.wav", + "text": "沒有對於其他相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/131.wav", + "text": "我們現在講話要正經一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/132.wav", + "text": "是你跟我講的啊拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/133.wav", + "text": "是你跟我講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/134.wav", + "text": "你跟我說八法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/135.wav", + "text": "我們就是三加三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/136.wav", + "text": "其中兩個我們沒提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/137.wav", + "text": "對上次是你給我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/138.wav", + "text": "說你們黨團助理自己準備的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/139.wav", + "text": "那是你給我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/140.wav", + "text": "我還說那個讓我拍照可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/141.wav", + "text": "你就說好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/142.wav", + "text": "上一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/143.wav", + "text": "我們在討論大法官的同意權的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/144.wav", + "text": "提出了三加三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/145.wav", + "text": "我認為即便在7月底之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/146.wav", + "text": "我們有效率的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/147.wav", + "text": "我們開委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/148.wav", + "text": "都可以如期完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/149.wav", + "text": "不只是性平相關的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/150.wav", + "text": "21世紀貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/151.wav", + "text": "也是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/152.wav", + "text": "目前民進黨主張的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/153.wav", + "text": "由經濟委員會排審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/154.wav", + "text": "納入4個委員會聯席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/155.wav", + "text": "但是國民黨主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/156.wav", + "text": "要把8個委員會都納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/157.wav", + "text": "畢竟未來的臺美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/158.wav", + "text": "21世紀貿易倡議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/159.wav", + "text": "會涵蓋的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/160.wav", + "text": "不只目前這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/161.wav", + "text": "還有勞動環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/162.wav", + "text": "農業數位貿易標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/163.wav", + "text": "國營事業非市場政��與做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/164.wav", + "text": "相關的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/165.wav", + "text": "我們國會本來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/166.wav", + "text": "應該要事前參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/167.wav", + "text": "避免未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/168.wav", + "text": "臺灣跟美國再次締約的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/169.wav", + "text": "我們再來反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/170.wav", + "text": "那反而會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/171.wav", + "text": "破壞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/172.wav", + "text": "信賴的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/173.wav", + "text": "所以我們要求讓國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/174.wav", + "text": "事前可以參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/175.wav", + "text": "所以希望這次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/176.wav", + "text": "審查是8個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/177.wav", + "text": "共同聯席審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/178.wav", + "text": "不要有一個月的冷凍期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/179.wav", + "text": "能夠在這次臨時會前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/180.wav", + "text": "其實我們預估過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/181.wav", + "text": "只要我們能有效率的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/182.wav", + "text": "在7月底之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/183.wav", + "text": "我們可以把這3個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/184.wav", + "text": "都可以如期的結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/185.wav", + "text": "也不會拖延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/186.wav", + "text": "各位同仁的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/187.wav", + "text": "我們就在7月底之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/188.wav", + "text": "把這3個案子同樣的結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/189.wav", + "text": "\n再來談到外役監條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/190.wav", + "text": "外役監條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/191.wav", + "text": "為什麼目前會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/192.wav", + "text": "發生這麼多爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/193.wav", + "text": "國民黨除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/194.wav", + "text": "提出我們黨團的版本以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/195.wav", + "text": "我們要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/196.wav", + "text": "過程必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/197.wav", + "text": "公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/198.wav", + "text": "要錄音錄影全程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/199.wav", + "text": "公開給大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/200.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/201.wav", + "text": "已經發生了這麼多問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/202.wav", + "text": "民眾想瞭解的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/203.wav", + "text": "是審查過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/204.wav", + "text": "有什麼樣子的問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/205.wav", + "text": "\n才會導致有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/206.wav", + "text": "這是所謂為權貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/207.wav", + "text": "開了一個條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/208.wav", + "text": "監如果不是蔡部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/209.wav", + "text": "所說的爽監的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/210.wav", + "text": "那請公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/211.wav", + "text": "審理過程能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/212.wav", + "text": "錄音錄影公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/213.wav", + "text": "讓全民知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/214.wav", + "text": "讓我們知道這是一個合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/215.wav", + "text": "懲戒原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/216.wav", + "text": "而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/217.wav", + "text": "為權貴開後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/218.wav", + "text": "\n首先謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/219.wav", + "text": "召集今天朝野的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/220.wav", + "text": "包括上次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/221.wav", + "text": "臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/222.wav", + "text": "所以這次有三批" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/223.wav", + "text": "包括性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/224.wav", + "text": "臺美貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/225.wav", + "text": "還有外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/226.wav", + "text": "如同剛剛我們謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/227.wav", + "text": "書記長提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/228.wav", + "text": "都是國民黨主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/229.wav", + "text": "提出來希望回應社會的需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/230.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/231.wav", + "text": "相關目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/232.wav", + "text": "最需要的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/233.wav", + "text": "所以謝謝院長也謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/234.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/235.wav", + "text": "第二點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/236.wav", + "text": "老柯可能健忘了上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/237.wav", + "text": "公開講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/238.wav", + "text": "錄音可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/239.wav", + "text": "調出來就是當時講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/240.wav", + "text": "我們國民黨以為是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/241.wav", + "text": "性平三法結果你講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/242.wav", + "text": "性平八法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/243.wav", + "text": "結果我們這次回去檢討之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/244.wav", + "text": "除了性平三法之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/245.wav", + "text": "又提出了三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/246.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/247.wav", + "text": "變成我們國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/248.wav", + "text": "性平六法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/249.wav", + "text": "這一部分我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/250.wav", + "text": "檢討之後認為其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/251.wav", + "text": "不需要修了但是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/252.wav", + "text": "覺得還是其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/253.wav", + "text": "三法有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/254.wav", + "text": "希望也納入這次的臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/255.wav", + "text": "這是第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/256.wav", + "text": "第三點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/257.wav", + "text": "各位知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/258.wav", + "text": "外界為什麼呼聲這麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/259.wav", + "text": "希望外役監條例要趕快修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/260.wav", + "text": "它有幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/261.wav", + "text": "第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/262.wav", + "text": "它的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/263.wav", + "text": "比如說國民黨主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/264.wav", + "text": "累犯就不要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/265.wav", + "text": "比如說重大經濟犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/266.wav", + "text": "或者是酒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/267.wav", + "text": "致死或者毒駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/268.wav", + "text": "這些都不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/269.wav", + "text": "讓他到外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/270.wav", + "text": "所以希望條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/271.wav", + "text": "能夠更為嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/272.wav", + "text": "另外就是最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/273.wav", + "text": "的除了條件嚴謹以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/274.wav", + "text": "其實最重要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/275.wav", + "text": "它的審查過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/276.wav", + "text": "現在雖然號稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/277.wav", + "text": "委外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/278.wav", + "text": "就是外部的委員超過半數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/279.wav", + "text": "但是我們理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/280.wav", + "text": "這些外部的委員都會配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/281.wav", + "text": "主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/282.wav", + "text": "的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/283.wav", + "text": "所以才導致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/284.wav", + "text": "最近有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/285.wav", + "text": "不應該到外役監的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/286.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨強烈主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/287.wav", + "text": "以後外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/288.wav", + "text": "公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/289.wav", + "text": "必須公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/290.wav", + "text": "也就是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/291.wav", + "text": "錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/292.wav", + "text": "甚至線上直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/293.wav", + "text": "讓外界來監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/294.wav", + "text": "某個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/295.wav", + "text": "他符不符合規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/296.wav", + "text": "因為可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/297.wav", + "text": "符合外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/298.wav", + "text": "要到外役監了可能有100個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/299.wav", + "text": "啊那為什麼只有其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/300.wav", + "text": "1個2個3個過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/301.wav", + "text": "可能有很大的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/302.wav", + "text": "我覺得必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/303.wav", + "text": "錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/304.wav", + "text": "甚至線上直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/305.wav", + "text": "這樣才有辦法杜絕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/306.wav", + "text": "才有辦法真的讓外役監正面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/307.wav", + "text": "的功能進一步發揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/308.wav", + "text": "負面的效應減到最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/309.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/310.wav", + "text": "謝謝接下來請邱總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/311.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長還有各黨團的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/312.wav", + "text": "感謝院長召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/313.wav", + "text": "其實民眾黨一開始就要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/314.wav", + "text": "要送到國會做實質審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/315.wav", + "text": "從善如流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/316.wav", + "text": "實質審查我們臺灣沒有理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/317.wav", + "text": "這部分我認為還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/318.wav", + "text": "遵照審查的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/319.wav", + "text": "含了一些勞動的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/320.wav", + "text": "中小企業專章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/321.wav", + "text": "貿易便捷化等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/322.wav", + "text": "所以我們也主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/323.wav", + "text": "8大委員會應該要聯審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/324.wav", + "text": "雖然剛剛柯總召講到以經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/325.wav", + "text": "聯合外交及國防司法跟財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/326.wav", + "text": "的主張是要8個委員會聯審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/327.wav", + "text": "這是當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/328.wav", + "text": "協商大家就已經有共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/329.wav", + "text": "儘快把相關法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/330.wav", + "text": "做實質的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/331.wav", + "text": "儘快在7月底通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/332.wav", + "text": "這我們是同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/333.wav", + "text": "當時協商時確實有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/334.wav", + "text": "不只是性平三法而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/335.wav", + "text": "而是針對相關性平的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/336.wav", + "text": "所以這部分既然各黨有不同的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/337.wav", + "text": "\n外役監條例其實是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/338.wav", + "text": "這一段協商之後的期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/339.wav", + "text": "社會非常關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/340.wav", + "text": "的議題這有幾個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/341.wav", + "text": "第一個當然就是回應社會的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/342.wav", + "text": "不管是2014年的夜店殺警案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/343.wav", + "text": "還是去年的臺南殺警案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/344.wav", + "text": "我想司法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/345.wav", + "text": "人民信任政府的最後一道防線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/346.wav", + "text": "昨天在凱道上的遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/347.wav", + "text": "其實也非常多的年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/348.wav", + "text": "表達這樣子的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/349.wav", + "text": "所以我想外役監的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/350.wav", + "text": "現在各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/351.wav", + "text": "包含行政院版大概有25個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/352.wav", + "text": "但是我認為不需要預設立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/353.wav", + "text": "我們認為在相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/354.wav", + "text": "審查過程的公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/355.wav", + "text": "不管是累犯經濟犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/356.wav", + "text": "還是貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/357.wav", + "text": "現在很多外役監的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/358.wav", + "text": "其實讓社會大眾認為是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/359.wav", + "text": "特權權貴的後花園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/360.wav", + "text": "甚至是度假中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/361.wav", + "text": "國家的威信來講是一個非常大的破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/362.wav", + "text": "這部分我們必須要做更細緻的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/363.wav", + "text": "因為這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/364.wav", + "text": "還要經過委員會的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/365.wav", + "text": "中間還有非常嚴謹的討論過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/366.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/367.wav", + "text": "這部分不要先預設立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/368.wav", + "text": "\n最後是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/369.wav", + "text": "民眾黨團另外一個訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/370.wav", + "text": "還有詐騙的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/371.wav", + "text": "出國打工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/372.wav", + "text": "詐騙手法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/373.wav", + "text": "這也是現在民怨之首的前幾名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/374.wav", + "text": "打詐國家隊或打詐2.0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/375.wav", + "text": "其實成效都有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/376.wav", + "text": "也沒有辦法回應人民的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/377.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/378.wav", + "text": "資通安全管理法跟個人資料保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/379.wav", + "text": "的修法應該要納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/380.wav", + "text": "臨時會的議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/381.wav", + "text": "這兩個法案目前都是一讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/382.wav", + "text": "委員會還沒有做相關的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/383.wav", + "text": "因為現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/384.wav", + "text": "詐騙的案件數量跟詐騙金額數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/385.wav", + "text": "與日俱增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/386.wav", + "text": "民進黨政府在資安的防護上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/387.wav", + "text": "目前看來成效有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/388.wav", + "text": "尤其去年10月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/389.wav", + "text": "全國戶役政資料被發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/390.wav", + "text": "在國外網站公開販售這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/391.wav", + "text": "其實對於資安上的漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/392.wav", + "text": "是非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/393.wav", + "text": "尤其明年1月適逢總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/394.wav", + "text": "我想相關的認知作戰數位作戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/395.wav", + "text": "都會非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/396.wav", + "text": "但這個前提就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/397.wav", + "text": "個資外洩會造成詐騙成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/398.wav", + "text": "機率非常高的一個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/399.wav", + "text": "第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/400.wav", + "text": "民進黨政府執政下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/401.wav", + "text": "不管在國際關係上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/402.wav", + "text": "一直在高喊所謂的民主聯盟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/403.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/404.wav", + "text": "支持臺灣自由民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/405.wav", + "text": "我們當然也都是同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/406.wav", + "text": "也是樂觀其成大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/407.wav", + "text": "在相關議題上的合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/408.wav", + "text": "其實資通安全個資保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/409.wav", + "text": "所謂的GDPR" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/410.wav", + "text": "也就是歐盟一般資料保護規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/411.wav", + "text": "相關的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/412.wav", + "text": "這個主張是本黨吳欣盈委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/413.wav", + "text": "的所以相關的修法我們也會把它納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/414.wav", + "text": "歐盟的一些原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/415.wav", + "text": "跟具有效益的風險評估機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/416.wav", + "text": "改善我國的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/417.wav", + "text": "安全防護能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/418.wav", + "text": "\n在修法的過程上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/419.wav", + "text": "如何提升數位公民意識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/420.wav", + "text": "來對抗這些假訊息跟個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/421.wav", + "text": "我想這個是現在國人非常期待跟重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/422.wav", + "text": "這兩個法案可以納入臨時會的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/423.wav", + "text": "確實比較趕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/424.wav", + "text": "如果有必要再延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/425.wav", + "text": "臨時會的時間或者是8月再加開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/426.wav", + "text": "我想民眾黨這邊也不預設立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/427.wav", + "text": "我們都會給與支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/428.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/429.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長召開這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/430.wav", + "text": "黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/431.wav", + "text": "處理臨時會的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/432.wav", + "text": "時力黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/433.wav", + "text": "跟外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/434.wav", + "text": "的這個議程基本上是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/435.wav", + "text": "支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/436.wav", + "text": "外役監條例剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/437.wav", + "text": "實幾位黨團代表都有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/438.wav", + "text": "它最主要的問題在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/439.wav", + "text": "就是大家會認為為什麼有權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/440.wav", + "text": "有勢的人到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/441.wav", + "text": "可以到外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/442.wav", + "text": "因為外役監坐1天牢可以抵2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/443.wav", + "text": "2天而且還可以放假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/444.wav", + "text": "法官胡景彬他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/445.wav", + "text": "貪污3億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/446.wav", + "text": "有法官貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/447.wav", + "text": "結果竟然貪污3億元之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/448.wav", + "text": "到最後他還可以到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/449.wav", + "text": "外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/450.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/451.wav", + "text": "主張貪污重大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/452.wav", + "text": "經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/453.wav", + "text": "你至少要讓他把犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/454.wav", + "text": "所得繳回來他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/455.wav", + "text": "貪污3億元連一角都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/456.wav", + "text": "繳回而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/457.wav", + "text": "拿3億的過程之中不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/458.wav", + "text": "經手多少案件都亂判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/459.wav", + "text": "害多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/460.wav", + "text": "結果到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/461.wav", + "text": "最後好不容易判了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/462.wav", + "text": "3億裡面連一毛錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/463.wav", + "text": "他竟然可以到外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/464.wav", + "text": "也可以放假也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/465.wav", + "text": "關1天抵2天一下子就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/466.wav", + "text": "大家都無法接受的我在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/467.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會一再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/468.wav", + "text": "主張應該要修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/469.wav", + "text": "這個法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/470.wav", + "text": "也沒人支持啦坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/471.wav", + "text": "我覺得外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/472.wav", + "text": "大家其實針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/473.wav", + "text": "這個問題就是權貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/474.wav", + "text": "林益世也可以到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/475.wav", + "text": "趙嘉寶也可以到外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/476.wav", + "text": "李清福也可以到外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/477.wav", + "text": "這些達官貴人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/478.wav", + "text": "位居高位的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/479.wav", + "text": "然後可以到外役監去這才是最" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/480.wav", + "text": "我們要讓人民覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/481.wav", + "text": "我們是認真地在對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/482.wav", + "text": "這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/483.wav", + "text": "應該是要針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/484.wav", + "text": "對權貴就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/485.wav", + "text": "選要公開透明這是最基本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/486.wav", + "text": "的要求嘛可是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/487.wav", + "text": "這一些貪污跟重大經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/488.wav", + "text": "犯罪我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/489.wav", + "text": "主張是認為他至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/490.wav", + "text": "犯罪所得繳回來至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/491.wav", + "text": "其他那些修法我坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/492.wav", + "text": "講今天你如果是一位無權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/493.wav", + "text": "無勢的人法務部旗下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/494.wav", + "text": "有6萬多名的收容人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/495.wav", + "text": "無權無勢的收容人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/496.wav", + "text": "他犯了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/497.wav", + "text": "很嚴重的犯罪你不必煩惱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/498.wav", + "text": "無權無勢的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/499.wav", + "text": "的都是有權有勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/500.wav", + "text": "然後背後都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/501.wav", + "text": "有背景的這就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/502.wav", + "text": "現在修法的主要癥結點\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/503.wav", + "text": "\n再來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/504.wav", + "text": "我們是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/505.wav", + "text": "條例應該要排到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/506.wav", + "text": "臨時會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/507.wav", + "text": "就像昨天的遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/508.wav", + "text": "其實大多數的人都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/509.wav", + "text": "居住正義的問題深惡痛絕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/510.wav", + "text": "七年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/511.wav", + "text": "民進黨終於在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/512.wav", + "text": "但是你到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/513.wav", + "text": "有沒有這樣的決心還是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/514.wav", + "text": "你要打假球因為下個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/515.wav", + "text": "已經是最後一個會期下一個會期又要選舉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/516.wav", + "text": "囤房稅的問題你到底有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/517.wav", + "text": "看到年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/518.wav", + "text": "買不起房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/519.wav", + "text": "沒辦法生小孩的痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/520.wav", + "text": "這就是我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/521.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望認真對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/522.wav", + "text": "這個事情不要打假球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/523.wav", + "text": "排審\n第三個就是性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/524.wav", + "text": "因為我國的性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/525.wav", + "text": "亂七八糟有非常多架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/526.wav", + "text": "搞得即便被害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/527.wav", + "text": "勇敢站出來都非常困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/528.wav", + "text": "除了這個性平三法之外希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/529.wav", + "text": "加拿大是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/530.wav", + "text": "根本沒有追訴權時效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/531.wav", + "text": "德國是30歲才開始起算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/532.wav", + "text": "追訴權時效直到他成年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/533.wav", + "text": "兒少的時候小朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/534.wav", + "text": "的時候被性侵但是���成年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/535.wav", + "text": "可以自己站出來你有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/536.wav", + "text": "自己的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/537.wav", + "text": "根據澳洲的研究事實上如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/538.wav", + "text": "你在小朋友的時候被性侵的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/539.wav", + "text": "要經過24年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/540.wav", + "text": "才能夠長出這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/541.wav", + "text": "草案希望考量到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/542.wav", + "text": "兒少性侵的特殊性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/543.wav", + "text": "讓追訴權時效從被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/544.wav", + "text": "成年之後才開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/545.wav", + "text": "的部分我們當然非常樂見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/546.wav", + "text": "臺美能夠有更緊密的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/547.wav", + "text": "貿易安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/548.wav", + "text": "條約締結法第8條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/549.wav", + "text": "立法院審議但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/550.wav", + "text": "是目前行政院用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/551.wav", + "text": "臺美貿易協定的方式以協定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/552.wav", + "text": "送立法院查照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/553.wav", + "text": "社會各界跟專家也有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/554.wav", + "text": "意見我們希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/555.wav", + "text": "讓立法院積極行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/556.wav", + "text": "立法權把臺美貿易協定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/557.wav", + "text": "審議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/558.wav", + "text": "大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/559.wav", + "text": "我昨天有去71" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/560.wav", + "text": "6的遊行現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/561.wav", + "text": "非常多年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/562.wav", + "text": "而且昨天的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/563.wav", + "text": "居住正義還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/564.wav", + "text": "司法改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/565.wav", + "text": "在司改國是會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/566.wav", + "text": "是會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/567.wav", + "text": "也有結論說要制定揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/568.wav", + "text": "我個人有非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/569.wav", + "text": "多親身經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/570.wav", + "text": "譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/571.wav", + "text": "掩埋場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/572.wav", + "text": "它的廢水流到下游" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/573.wav", + "text": "當地的公所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/574.wav", + "text": "檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/575.wav", + "text": "結果有人來敲門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/576.wav", + "text": "有人來威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/577.wav", + "text": "這只是我要講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/578.wav", + "text": "非常多需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/579.wav", + "text": "整個制度面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/580.wav", + "text": "能夠更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/581.wav", + "text": "這種政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/582.wav", + "text": "目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/583.wav", + "text": "除了剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/584.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/585.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/586.wav", + "text": "揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/587.wav", + "text": "現在當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/588.wav", + "text": "院版還沒進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/589.wav", + "text": "不管是這個臨時會或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/590.wav", + "text": "未來還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/591.wav", + "text": "臨時會的時候我們希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/592.wav", + "text": "決定也請各" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/593.wav", + "text": "黨團支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/594.wav", + "text": "讓揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/595.wav", + "text": "進入臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/596.wav", + "text": "那再來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/597.wav", + "text": "剛剛兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/598.wav", + "text": "臺美貿易協定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/599.wav", + "text": "時力也支持就是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/600.wav", + "text": "進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/601.wav", + "text": "聯席審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/602.wav", + "text": "囤房稅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/603.wav", + "text": "囤房稅2.0提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/604.wav", + "text": "4.8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/605.wav", + "text": "這個真的是不痛不癢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/606.wav", + "text": "所以希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/607.wav", + "text": "還是可以提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/608.wav", + "text": "比較好的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/609.wav", + "text": "趕快定案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/610.wav", + "text": "畢竟這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/611.wav", + "text": "提高到4.8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/612.wav", + "text": "%希望能夠將時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/613.wav", + "text": "將時力的版本納入我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/614.wav", + "text": "2021年就提出至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/615.wav", + "text": "到10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/616.wav", + "text": "那就是包括空屋稅囤房稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/617.wav", + "text": "我們可以一起來檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/618.wav", + "text": "的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/619.wav", + "text": "民間團體或住在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/620.wav", + "text": "鄰避設施附近的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/621.wav", + "text": "居民大家的檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/622.wav", + "text": "真的非常非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/623.wav", + "text": "所以也希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/624.wav", + "text": "行政院趕快把版本送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/625.wav", + "text": "也呼應716" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/626.wav", + "text": "年輕族群的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/627.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長也感謝四個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/628.wav", + "text": "黨團今天一起來參加這個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/629.wav", + "text": "謝衣鳯委員跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/630.wav", + "text": "曾總召都特別��到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/631.wav", + "text": "有八法的問題我在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/632.wav", + "text": "時序上先跟二位解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/633.wav", + "text": "就是從上個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/634.wav", + "text": "開始我們社會上引起很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/635.wav", + "text": "涵蓋的職場包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/636.wav", + "text": "我們是以當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/637.wav", + "text": "還沒有修正以前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/638.wav", + "text": "三個包括性別平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/639.wav", + "text": "教育法性別工作平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/640.wav", + "text": "法及性騷防制法來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/641.wav", + "text": "有提到性侵的部分或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/642.wav", + "text": "相關的法條一起來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/643.wav", + "text": "討論的過程當中我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/644.wav", + "text": "性別工作或性別教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/645.wav", + "text": "相關的性騷擾防制法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/646.wav", + "text": "修正案其實是做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/647.wav", + "text": "大幅度的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/648.wav", + "text": "因為從一開始到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/649.wav", + "text": "大概有一二十年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/650.wav", + "text": "性騷擾防制三法的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/651.wav", + "text": "來處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/652.wav", + "text": "我們認為應該就足夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/653.wav", + "text": "了但是如果國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/654.wav", + "text": "覺得性平三法不夠因為行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/655.wav", + "text": "送進來請我們審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/656.wav", + "text": "了可以請國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/657.wav", + "text": "再審議一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/658.wav", + "text": "性騷防制三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/659.wav", + "text": "的修正草案內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/660.wav", + "text": "目前社會上所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/661.wav", + "text": "關心的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/662.wav", + "text": "\n我今天要講的重點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/663.wav", + "text": "委員民進黨三位委員從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/664.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/665.wav", + "text": "美國國會把這樣一個貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/666.wav", + "text": "放到國會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/667.wav", + "text": "但他們有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/668.wav", + "text": "框架式的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/669.wav", + "text": "他們把它當成審查的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/670.wav", + "text": "按照他們的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/671.wav", + "text": "說送進來的是查照案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/672.wav", + "text": "其實美國行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/673.wav", + "text": "他們的參眾兩院之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/674.wav", + "text": "行政部門通過其實就可以開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/675.wav", + "text": "來執行並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/676.wav", + "text": "什麼扞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/677.wav", + "text": "扞格的地方但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/678.wav", + "text": "我們也尊重立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/679.wav", + "text": "有監督行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/680.wav", + "text": "的權責如果有貿易協定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/681.wav", + "text": "或貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/682.wav", + "text": "當然可以討論所以當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/683.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團提到要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/684.wav", + "text": "查照改成審查的時候我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/685.wav", + "text": "態度就是開放所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/686.wav", + "text": "目前如果要把它改成審查的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/687.wav", + "text": "應該是站在開放的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/688.wav", + "text": "上來看但是我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/689.wav", + "text": "希望能夠尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/690.wav", + "text": "或者是單獨的獨立的經濟體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/691.wav", + "text": "跟經濟體之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/692.wav", + "text": "在處理貿易倡議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/693.wav", + "text": "要有一定的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/694.wav", + "text": "這樣的規範要用符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/695.wav", + "text": "國際版本的規範和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/696.wav", + "text": "標準來看待至於剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/697.wav", + "text": "黨團提到是不是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/698.wav", + "text": "放到八個委員會來聯審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/699.wav", + "text": "我個人認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/700.wav", + "text": "應該是尊重我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/701.wav", + "text": "應該是哪幾個委員會來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/702.wav", + "text": "就我所瞭解裡面的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/703.wav", + "text": "含括的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/704.wav", + "text": "會比較多是在於財經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/705.wav", + "text": "外交及國防當然一定有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/706.wav", + "text": "另外有一部分和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/707.wav", + "text": "貪腐有關的是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/708.wav", + "text": "法制上面所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/709.wav", + "text": "是不是一定要八個委員會我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/710.wav", + "text": "要尊重專業上面在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/711.wav", + "text": "怎麼處理會比較好而不是八個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/712.wav", + "text": "委員會全部囊括進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/713.wav", + "text": "我瞭解至少交通的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/714.wav", + "text": "或者是文化教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/715.wav", + "text": "它涵蓋的面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/716.wav", + "text": "幾乎是沒有這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/717.wav", + "text": "提供給各位參考\n當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/718.wav", + "text": "還有外役監處理的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/719.wav", + "text": "大家也都知道很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/720.wav", + "text": "對外役監原來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/721.wav", + "text": "的這個��向有一些不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/722.wav", + "text": "尤其是集中在第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/723.wav", + "text": "條文的修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/724.wav", + "text": "未來如果外役監在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/725.wav", + "text": "臨時會討論的時候我們當然就尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/726.wav", + "text": "在外役監處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/727.wav", + "text": "的修正案版本我們一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/728.wav", + "text": "可以面對社會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/729.wav", + "text": "對我們的期待如果可以把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/730.wav", + "text": "立法委員來講是一個比較好的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/731.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/732.wav", + "text": "謝謝劉委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/733.wav", + "text": "還有各黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/734.wav", + "text": "代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/735.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/736.wav", + "text": "柯總召每次在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/737.wav", + "text": "都說臨時會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/738.wav", + "text": "當做是一個特效藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/739.wav", + "text": "大家的心態我們可以理解回應社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/740.wav", + "text": "的期待不是壞事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/741.wav", + "text": "我先來回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/742.wav", + "text": "我們的法律專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/743.wav", + "text": "邱顯智剛剛講的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/744.wav", + "text": "\n時效這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/745.wav", + "text": "我們都讀同一本書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/746.wav", + "text": "書本來以前大家都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/747.wav", + "text": "時效是基於法的安定性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/748.wav", + "text": "我是比較沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/749.wav", + "text": "但是這個真的要慎思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/750.wav", + "text": "是不是要在臨時會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/751.wav", + "text": "因為這個已經是差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/752.wav", + "text": "幾百年大家讀的書都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/753.wav", + "text": "你說回應社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/754.wav", + "text": "甚至於還沒有到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/755.wav", + "text": "入罪化的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/756.wav", + "text": "你把時效弄得很長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/757.wav", + "text": "變成是刑法的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/758.wav", + "text": "或者重罪的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/759.wav", + "text": "時效反而又很短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/760.wav", + "text": "這個怎麼來說服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/761.wav", + "text": "我們不是只有回應社會而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/762.wav", + "text": "大家的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/763.wav", + "text": "大家的心都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/764.wav", + "text": "的對外界的感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/765.wav", + "text": "靈敏度應該都差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/766.wav", + "text": "但是以大家現在的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/767.wav", + "text": "在回應民粹的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/768.wav", + "text": "變成外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/769.wav", + "text": "監還真的讓外界以為那個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/770.wav", + "text": "是在選好人好事代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/771.wav", + "text": "不是那個機構是讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/772.wav", + "text": "中間矯正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/773.wav", + "text": "讓他回歸到社會之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/774.wav", + "text": "在這個機構裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/775.wav", + "text": "要重新做人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/776.wav", + "text": "也可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/777.wav", + "text": "我說實在話也可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/778.wav", + "text": "所以這個都顛覆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/779.wav", + "text": "了我們在討論不是我們立法院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/780.wav", + "text": "大家自己講得很爽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/781.wav", + "text": "我們要講好會有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/782.wav", + "text": "很正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/783.wav", + "text": "就是你看在哪一個層面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/784.wav", + "text": "譬如曾銘宗總召剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/785.wav", + "text": "回應社會民粹都對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/786.wav", + "text": "但我舉個例好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/787.wav", + "text": "某甲現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/788.wav", + "text": "本來可以到外役監去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/789.wav", + "text": "你說他是累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/790.wav", + "text": "是啊有期徒刑二個月以上全部都叫累犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/791.wav", + "text": "沒有你曾經被判二個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/792.wav", + "text": "和這個有什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/793.wav", + "text": "和這個有什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/794.wav", + "text": "是你如何去說理的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/795.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/796.wav", + "text": "臨時會裡面大家本來都希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/797.wav", + "text": "之後院長就不要再開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/798.wav", + "text": "了把臨時會常態化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/799.wav", + "text": "現在不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/800.wav", + "text": "特效藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/801.wav", + "text": "八個委員會全部都進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/802.wav", + "text": "在我看來連陳歐珀上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/803.wav", + "text": "當召委的那個審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/804.wav", + "text": "如果各位當召委還是這樣審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/805.wav", + "text": "啊各黨全部的講法都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/806.wav", + "text": "啊版本沒有整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/807.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗當召委你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/808.wav", + "text": "大家的意見都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/809.wav", + "text": "啊比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/810.wav", + "text": "國民黨當初的講法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/811.wav", + "text": "這個話要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/812.wav", + "text": "各黨來回應社會是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/813.wav", + "text": "但互相指責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/814.wav", + "text": "就不對了因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/815.wav", + "text": "陳歐珀沒有來你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/816.wav", + "text": "國民黨的講法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/817.wav", + "text": "和時代力量的邱顯智" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/818.wav", + "text": "現在的主張不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/819.wav", + "text": "我還是尊重你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/820.wav", + "text": "我還是認你們為當初的講法是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/821.wav", + "text": "邱顯智的講法就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/822.wav", + "text": "就是說你要先定性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/823.wav", + "text": "先決定放到外役監是要放什麼人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/824.wav", + "text": "全世界各國的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/825.wav", + "text": "全部都在放重刑犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/826.wav", + "text": "關8年之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/827.wav", + "text": "放到中間處遇機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/828.wav", + "text": "再讓他回歸社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/829.wav", + "text": "我們會被批評反制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/830.wav", + "text": "直接丟進社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/831.wav", + "text": "耶大家還知道吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/832.wav", + "text": "不是講到資訊要揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/833.wav", + "text": "公開透明嗎為什麼到最後沒有辦法通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/834.wav", + "text": "很簡單之所以沒辦法通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/835.wav", + "text": "假設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/836.wav", + "text": "我期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/837.wav", + "text": "我不是歪樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/838.wav", + "text": "你住在那邊當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/839.wav", + "text": "資訊透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/840.wav", + "text": "後當初為什麼會沒辦法過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/841.wav", + "text": "好啦連重罪的你都不敢揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/842.wav", + "text": "你看這個法案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/843.wav", + "text": "大家奇奇怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/844.wav", + "text": "輕罪的全部都來揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/845.wav", + "text": "\n我的意思就是慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/846.wav", + "text": "對於各黨的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/847.wav", + "text": "我都很崇拜你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/848.wav", + "text": "很好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/849.wav", + "text": "要效率我覺得也都很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/850.wav", + "text": "我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/851.wav", + "text": "我希望大家省思一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/852.wav", + "text": "大家想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/853.wav", + "text": "不管是國民黨提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/854.wav", + "text": "或者時代力量提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/855.wav", + "text": "這一些都有它的法理基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/856.wav", + "text": "民主進步黨都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/857.wav", + "text": "尤其在臺美的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/858.wav", + "text": "上一次我就講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/859.wav", + "text": "好啊你們要逐條審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/860.wav", + "text": "歡迎啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/861.wav", + "text": "如果國民黨沒有提我們就主動提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/862.wav", + "text": "聚焦一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/863.wav", + "text": "我們大家一起來促成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/864.wav", + "text": "都沒有批評的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/865.wav", + "text": "院長我澄清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/866.wav", + "text": "我沒有住帝寶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/867.wav", + "text": "要亂講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/868.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是要收他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/869.wav", + "text": "沒有住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/870.wav", + "text": "我們還是拉回程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/871.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/872.wav", + "text": "大家都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/873.wav", + "text": "為國家為社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/874.wav", + "text": "希望能夠修出更好的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/875.wav", + "text": "太多意氣之爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/876.wav", + "text": "講實在話以現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/877.wav", + "text": "立法院的生態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/878.wav", + "text": "民進黨想過的法律哪個過不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/879.wav", + "text": "民進黨不想過的法律哪個過得了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/880.wav", + "text": "不要說那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/881.wav", + "text": "了如果學長要說得那麼激烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/882.wav", + "text": "那我們就繼續講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/883.wav", + "text": "講到12點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/884.wav", + "text": "等一下你們進去表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/885.wav", + "text": "不要說得那麼激烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/886.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/887.wav", + "text": "有關臺美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/888.wav", + "text": "倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/889.wav", + "text": "我們主張是8個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/890.wav", + "text": "也是好意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/891.wav", + "text": "喔假設裡面在審的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/892.wav", + "text": "超越剛剛講的那4個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/893.wav", + "text": "那也要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/894.wav", + "text": "你還是要到朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/895.wav", + "text": "反而更慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/896.wav", + "text": "了所以國民黨是好意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/897.wav", + "text": "將囤房稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/898.wav", + "text": "111年2月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/899.wav", + "text": "我就提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/900.wav", + "text": "了提案在財委會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/901.wav", + "text": "沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/902.wav", + "text": "講了一大堆問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/903.wav", + "text": "說沒辦法歸戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/904.wav", + "text": "現在行政院通過的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/905.wav", + "text": "是可以歸戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/906.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/907.wav", + "text": "囤房稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/908.wav", + "text": "而且條文只有一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/909.wav", + "text": "有必要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/910.wav", + "text": "也把它納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/911.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/912.wav", + "text": "在財委會吵了兩三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/913.wav", + "text": "我是111年2月就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/914.wav", + "text": "每個會期都審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/915.wav", + "text": "財政部不管是以前的蘇建榮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/916.wav", + "text": "都兩手一攤說問題很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/917.wav", + "text": "可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/918.wav", + "text": "行政院版本也通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/919.wav", + "text": "既然通過這麼急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/920.wav", + "text": "就把它納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/921.wav", + "text": "到臨時會來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/922.wav", + "text": "要就快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/923.wav", + "text": "我們剛才的主張就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/924.wav", + "text": "剛剛莊瑞雄委員有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/925.wav", + "text": "刑罰權的追訴到某一定的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/926.wav", + "text": "比如20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/927.wav", + "text": "或幾年就不能夠追訴了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/928.wav", + "text": "現在要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/929.wav", + "text": "性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/930.wav", + "text": "類似這樣的侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/931.wav", + "text": "層出不窮而且非常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/932.wav", + "text": "法案能夠接住所有的被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/933.wav", + "text": "財物被偷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/934.wav", + "text": "又或者是被詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/935.wav", + "text": "我不會有一種難以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/936.wav", + "text": "狀況但是在性犯罪會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/937.wav", + "text": "尤其是對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/938.wav", + "text": "對於兒少因為現在要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/939.wav", + "text": "的性平三法就是在處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/940.wav", + "text": "所謂的#MeToo運動是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/941.wav", + "text": "其他人出來的鼓勵之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/942.wav", + "text": "也勇敢站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/943.wav", + "text": "因為他是小孩子所以他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/944.wav", + "text": "要經過很長的時間才能夠站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/945.wav", + "text": "在這個脈絡裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/946.wav", + "text": "第83條條文的修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/947.wav", + "text": "意識到這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/948.wav", + "text": "我們現在討論程序我覺得這是可以談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/949.wav", + "text": "否則的話民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/950.wav", + "text": "提出了一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/951.wav", + "text": "個臨時會的agenda之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/952.wav", + "text": "大家來盍各言爾志" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/953.wav", + "text": "最後柯總召收一個尾說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/954.wav", + "text": "好沒共識大家就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/955.wav", + "text": "這樣就沒有開會的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/956.wav", + "text": "就性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/957.wav", + "text": "像我手上有好幾個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/958.wav", + "text": "來陳情13歲的時候被性侵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/959.wav", + "text": "現在三十幾歲結果20年的追訴時效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/960.wav", + "text": "已經過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/961.wav", + "text": "很心酸的事情\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/962.wav", + "text": "\n再來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/963.wav", + "text": "都已經提出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/964.wav", + "text": "相對的草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/965.wav", + "text": "是不是展現這樣的決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/966.wav", + "text": "沒有幾條就可以處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/967.wav", + "text": "一併在這個臨時會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/968.wav", + "text": "加以處理可能是一個妥善的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/969.wav", + "text": "作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/970.wav", + "text": "\n至於臺美貿易協定的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/971.wav", + "text": "其實非常清楚根據條約締結法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/972.wav", + "text": "第3條第1項第3款就是有關人民的權利義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/973.wav", + "text": "第4款則是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/974.wav", + "text": "涉及國防外交財政或經濟上利益等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/975.wav", + "text": "國家重要事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/976.wav", + "text": "第5款的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/977.wav", + "text": "是內容與國內法律內容不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/978.wav", + "text": "或涉及國內法律之變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/979.wav", + "text": "所以這當然會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/980.wav", + "text": "主張是外交經濟財政跟司法聯席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/981.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/982.wav", + "text": "執政黨提出來的時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/983.wav", + "text": "我想請教第一個是程序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/984.wav", + "text": "委員會可不可以就直接召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/985.wav", + "text": "這是第一個詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/986.wav", + "text": "這樣子就可以把委員會的時間再多一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/987.wav", + "text": "\n第二個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/988.wav", + "text": "如果禮拜三是進行臺美貿易倡議部分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/989.wav", + "text": "過去有沒有慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/990.wav", + "text": "這是我的詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/991.wav", + "text": "\n為什麼要這樣問呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/992.wav", + "text": "除了性平三法之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/993.wav", + "text": "外加揭弊保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/994.wav", + "text": "囤房稅外役監條例也是三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/995.wav", + "text": "就必須提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/996.wav", + "text": "如果再加上貿易倡議部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/997.wav", + "text": "基本上我看這個時間安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/998.wav", + "text": "是不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/999.wav", + "text": "所以等一下就教執政黨有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1000.wav", + "text": "關時間規劃部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1001.wav", + "text": "是不是可以照這個程序往前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1002.wav", + "text": "\n第二個剛剛講到莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1003.wav", + "text": "提到的幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1004.wav", + "text": "就是說修法好不容易進步到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1005.wav", + "text": "要往回走嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1006.wav", + "text": "我們是不是在走一個明確的愚民路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1007.wav", + "text": "我想這次大家對於外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1008.wav", + "text": "本來柯總召也不是很贊同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1009.wav", + "text": "但是因為總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1010.wav", + "text": "也下令之後我們說要列入討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1011.wav", + "text": "所以列入討論跟列入審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1012.wav", + "text": "是不一樣的基於這樣的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1013.wav", + "text": "我覺得是不是委員會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1014.wav", + "text": "就是我剛剛講的時程上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1015.wav", + "text": "專責處理的部分還是要能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1016.wav", + "text": "審慎不是因為臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1017.wav", + "text": "好像糊弄過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1018.wav", + "text": "因為我看了一下目前我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1019.wav", + "text": "司法委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1020.wav", + "text": "他也在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1021.wav", + "text": "我想他也可以就今天討論的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1022.wav", + "text": "還有相關各版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1023.wav", + "text": "所以我不認為這是民粹修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1024.wav", + "text": "還是應該以正視聽也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1025.wav", + "text": "有一些重大暴力犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1026.wav", + "text": "或者是一些遴選的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1027.wav", + "text": "這次能夠正本清源來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1028.wav", + "text": "又是做什麼後花園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1029.wav", + "text": "好謝謝賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1030.wav", + "text": "接下來請謝衣鳯委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1031.wav", + "text": "謝委員發言完畢我們就讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1032.wav", + "text": "執政黨回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1033.wav", + "text": "好我簡單回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1034.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄委員對我們提出的質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1035.wav", + "text": "其實因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1036.wav", + "text": "不是質疑是我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1037.wav", + "text": "時就有討論我們本來是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1038.wav", + "text": "把性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1039.wav", + "text": "同時舉辦但柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1040.wav", + "text": "提議要分開舉行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1041.wav", + "text": "臨時會要審查的議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1042.wav", + "text": "但這一次也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1043.wav", + "text": "大家認為臺美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1044.wav", + "text": "21世紀貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1045.wav", + "text": "以及外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1046.wav", + "text": "重要的關注焦點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1047.wav", + "text": "所以希望可以在這次的臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1048.wav", + "text": "共同來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1049.wav", + "text": "我們也審酌了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1050.wav", + "text": "如果我們能有效率的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1051.wav", + "text": "在這一次的臨時會也可以完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1052.wav", + "text": "\n當然剛才劉世芳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1053.wav", + "text": "你們所謂的三法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1054.wav", + "text": "就如同邱顯智委員所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1055.wav", + "text": "在這一次的#MeToo" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1056.wav", + "text": "事件裡面有一個兒少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1057.wav", + "text": "其實就涵蓋了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1058.wav", + "text": "兒少福利及保護法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1059.wav", + "text": "所以我們才涵蓋了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1060.wav", + "text": "三加三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1061.wav", + "text": "這也是在回應社會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1062.wav", + "text": "希望臺美21世紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1063.wav", + "text": "貿易倡議可以納入8個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1064.wav", + "text": "會共同審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1065.wav", + "text": "不是說要看熱鬧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1066.wav", + "text": "讓大家都來談一談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1067.wav", + "text": "其實我們本來就希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1068.wav", + "text": "國會能夠事前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1069.wav", + "text": "不會導致未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1070.wav", + "text": "如果萬一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1071.wav", + "text": "我們再締結另外的合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1072.wav", + "text": "之間的互信所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1073.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們希望8個委員會共同審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1074.wav", + "text": "而是國會事前參與的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1075.wav", + "text": "接下來我們就請執政黨來回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1076.wav", + "text": "剛才很仔細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1077.wav", + "text": "聆聽各黨的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1078.wav", + "text": "我全部予以尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1079.wav", + "text": "我們講一個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1080.wav", + "text": "今天在這裡不是在爭功諉過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1081.wav", + "text": "或是誰來推給誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1082.wav", + "text": "什麼三法八法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1083.wav", + "text": "現在都不是談這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1084.wav", + "text": "我們共同承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1085.wav", + "text": "也有兩個召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1086.wav", + "text": "所以今天回到比較實際性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1087.wav", + "text": "��一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1088.wav", + "text": "我剛才一開頭就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1089.wav", + "text": "我們的提案是性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1090.wav", + "text": "然後再加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1091.wav", + "text": "臺美21世紀貿易的議程以及外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1092.wav", + "text": "而言現在講起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1093.wav", + "text": "包括各黨現在提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1094.wav", + "text": "到上禮拜五為止至少八十幾個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1095.wav", + "text": "當然有行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1096.wav", + "text": "版本它是最完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1097.wav", + "text": "可能很多都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1098.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1099.wav", + "text": "要拜託張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1100.wav", + "text": "因為教育委員會有兩個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1101.wav", + "text": "的來看待這個法怎麼修比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1102.wav", + "text": "這是完全沒有政治性的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1103.wav", + "text": "這是我在這裡的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1104.wav", + "text": "而這個我們已經答應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1105.wav", + "text": "月底要完成上次就簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1106.wav", + "text": "院是這樣開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1107.wav", + "text": "院會時就沒有委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1108.wav", + "text": "所以不可能禮拜二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1109.wav", + "text": "在備詢的時候委員會也會開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1110.wav", + "text": "所以我們可以想像出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1111.wav", + "text": "規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1112.wav", + "text": "各委員會組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1113.wav", + "text": "這從來沒有破例過按" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1114.wav", + "text": "按照這樣想起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1115.wav", + "text": "我們的時間必須好好掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1116.wav", + "text": "都沒有這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1117.wav", + "text": "除非是有時候全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1118.wav", + "text": "國民黨不管就開院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1119.wav", + "text": "院會從來沒有破例過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1120.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗委員也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1121.wav", + "text": "\n我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1122.wav", + "text": "這裡面牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1123.wav", + "text": "邱顯智要修刑法第83條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1124.wav", + "text": "追訴權請求的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1125.wav", + "text": "顯智是引進德國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1126.wav", + "text": "瑞士奧地利等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1127.wav", + "text": "但法制化是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1128.wav", + "text": "沒有很實際的事證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1129.wav", + "text": "加30年的話就是55歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1130.wav", + "text": "沒有關係啦每個國家的法制不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1131.wav", + "text": "你要在一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1132.wav", + "text": "個案上去突破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1133.wav", + "text": "以及平衡性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1134.wav", + "text": "因為假如你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1135.wav", + "text": "性侵很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1136.wav", + "text": "那相對剝奪生命的時候是不是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1137.wav", + "text": "有一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1138.wav", + "text": "你發言完畢以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1139.wav", + "text": "我不跟你作任何爭辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1140.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1141.wav", + "text": "訴權的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1142.wav", + "text": "告訴請求權的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1143.wav", + "text": "這一次我們只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1144.wav", + "text": "在性平三法修申訴期的延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1145.wav", + "text": "以及加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1146.wav", + "text": "還有權勢的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1147.wav", + "text": "這是我們這次的修法重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1148.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1149.wav", + "text": "送到行政院以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1150.wav", + "text": "本黨內部就開始討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1151.wav", + "text": "鄧政委一直要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1152.wav", + "text": "趕在行政院通過以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1153.wav", + "text": "就要去向各黨團說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1154.wav", + "text": "我說沒有關係等行政院通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1155.wav", + "text": "在行政院通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1156.wav", + "text": "國民黨也說這個要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1157.wav", + "text": "列入臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1158.wav", + "text": "我們本來就預計這個題目在臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1159.wav", + "text": "所以我們都有做好準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1160.wav", + "text": "這一點大家看法是一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1161.wav", + "text": "的國家是大家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1162.wav", + "text": "送進來都是查照改審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1163.wav", + "text": "至於送進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1164.wav", + "text": "送進來要查照改審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1165.wav", + "text": "大家沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1166.wav", + "text": "大家說要嚴審所有的法都嚴審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1167.wav", + "text": "這是口頭禪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1168.wav", + "text": "嘛所以剛才劉世芳委員講的沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1169.wav", + "text": "想像得到的是以後會不會可能有第二輪會有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1170.wav", + "text": "我們放進去沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1171.wav", + "text": "我想這一點大家應該也有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1172.wav", + "text": "查照改審查也沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1173.wav", + "text": "大家都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1174.wav", + "text": "本次臨時會我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1175.wav", + "text": "限期完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1176.wav", + "text": "個別溝通的時候大家都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1177.wav", + "text": "我很欽佩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1178.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄委員的發言法理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1179.wav", + "text": "他到底是臺大法律系的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1180.wav", + "text": "他來這裡敢講出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1181.wav", + "text": "很多的實情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1182.wav", + "text": "很多的法案內容衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1183.wav", + "text": "要講這種話的人必須有相當勇氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1184.wav", + "text": "審查要公開直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1185.wav", + "text": "大家想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1186.wav", + "text": "審查外役監的外部委員要公開直播的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1187.wav", + "text": "哪一個人要去當外役監" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1188.wav", + "text": "所以我們要掌握實情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1189.wav", + "text": "都有去識別化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1190.wav", + "text": "我們要有程度上的信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1191.wav", + "text": "這樣搞來搞去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1192.wav", + "text": "不天堂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1193.wav", + "text": "外役監在臺灣已經60年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1194.wav", + "text": "已經走過60年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1195.wav", + "text": "從聯合國開始已經將近70年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1196.wav", + "text": "算是全世界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1197.wav", + "text": "對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1198.wav", + "text": "刑期的教化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1199.wav", + "text": "已經從恩給制改過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1200.wav", + "text": "過去是恩給制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1201.wav", + "text": "我要給你出去就出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1202.wav", + "text": "不給你出去就不出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1203.wav", + "text": "在已經以教化為重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1204.wav", + "text": "很糾葛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1205.wav", + "text": "所以上次才會審到一半的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1206.wav", + "text": "臺下沒有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1207.wav", + "text": "也不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1208.wav", + "text": "所以結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1209.wav", + "text": "是我剛才一開始講過我們開到7月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1210.wav", + "text": "前面兩個限期完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1211.wav", + "text": "至於外役監能夠有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1212.wav", + "text": "大家的看法都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1213.wav", + "text": "委員曾銘宗委員大家的看法是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1214.wav", + "text": "的\n另外有關於談到囤房稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1215.wav", + "text": "要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1216.wav", + "text": "民進黨在整個居住正義上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1217.wav", + "text": "走到上次的平均地權條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1218.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1219.wav", + "text": "租賃市場條例等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1220.wav", + "text": "一直走供給面一直增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1221.wav", + "text": "都更也要一直做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1222.wav", + "text": "這個是一個很長的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1223.wav", + "text": "房價不可能說一天就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1224.wav", + "text": "是打炒房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1225.wav", + "text": "所以談到囤房稅沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1226.wav", + "text": "我們也必須承認過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1227.wav", + "text": "財政部比較保守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1228.wav", + "text": "時代力量只提1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1229.wav", + "text": "空屋稅要10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1230.wav", + "text": "那個絕對做不到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1231.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天大家站在一個立場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1232.wav", + "text": "我們要居住正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1233.wav", + "text": "但是我們的目的是要打炒房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1234.wav", + "text": "所以這次行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1235.wav", + "text": "還有比較重要的是稅基和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1236.wav", + "text": "率的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1237.wav", + "text": "你說行政院因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1238.wav", + "text": "這次要遊行然後去改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1239.wav", + "text": "我也承認沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1240.wav", + "text": "政策本來就是要與時俱進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1241.wav", + "text": "但是行政院法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1242.wav", + "text": "在開議以前一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1243.wav", + "text": "員會好好審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1244.wav", + "text": "今天沒有行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1245.wav", + "text": "有個別委員提一兩條就要來審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1246.wav", + "text": "而且難得共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1247.wav", + "text": "要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1248.wav", + "text": "我們最急的處理通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1249.wav", + "text": "假如各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1250.wav", + "text": "要召開第3次臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1251.wav", + "text": "我都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1252.wav", + "text": "其他我當然尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1253.wav", + "text": "當然今天各黨團都會開黨團會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1254.wav", + "text": "黨團會議開完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1255.wav", + "text": "我們也要尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1256.wav", + "text": "我們黨部內部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1257.wav", + "text": "下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1258.wav", + "text": "談話會的時候我們會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1259.wav", + "text": "大家來對一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1260.wav", + "text": "有可以包的就包在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1261.wav", + "text": "我不希望這是一個站在對立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1262.wav", + "text": "互相指責謾罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1263.wav", + "text": "讓人家看笑話的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1264.wav", + "text": "請各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1265.wav", + "text": "好接下來我來簡單報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1266.wav", + "text": "我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1267.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛柯總召也講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1268.wav", + "text": "中午的時候民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1269.wav", + "text": "還有黨團會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1270.wav", + "text": "這個是在討論議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1271.wav", + "text": "程序的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1272.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1273.wav", + "text": "這個口頭禪已經沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1274.wav", + "text": "我現在是要稱讚你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1275.wav", + "text": "我是要稱讚你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1276.wav", + "text": "這次臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1277.wav", + "text": "這三個議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1278.wav", + "text": "基本上我剛剛講的其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1279.wav", + "text": "臺美21世紀貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1280.wav", + "text": "和性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1281.wav", + "text": "議題應該可以抱持一個開放的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1282.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1283.wav", + "text": "我要講的是比如刑法第83條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1284.wav", + "text": "這是開放態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1285.wav", + "text": "這是開放態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1286.wav", + "text": "過去二十年後來修法改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1287.wav", + "text": "但是有一些基本上也是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1288.wav", + "text": "他小的時候受到性侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1289.wav", + "text": "的真實案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1290.wav", + "text": "如果大家有關心的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1291.wav", + "text": "因為性犯罪是很特殊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1292.wav", + "text": "所以才會考量到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1293.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1294.wav", + "text": "囤房稅的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1295.wav", + "text": "已經談太久太久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1296.wav", + "text": "院會也已經在處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1297.wav", + "text": "所以如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1298.wav", + "text": "能夠在臨時會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1299.wav", + "text": "第83條一樣你把它擺到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1300.wav", + "text": "一個議程裡面去討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1301.wav", + "text": "至於有沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1302.wav", + "text": "或許有共識或許沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1303.wav", + "text": "那是另外一回事但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1304.wav", + "text": "基本上有一個討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1305.wav", + "text": "表示大家認真面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1306.wav", + "text": "去處理這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1307.wav", + "text": "應該是大家可以接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1308.wav", + "text": "一個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1309.wav", + "text": "我現在跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1310.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家剛才踴躍的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1311.wav", + "text": "現在各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1312.wav", + "text": "針對臨時會的特定時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1313.wav", + "text": "邀請行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1314.wav", + "text": "院長做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1315.wav", + "text": "臺美倡議及性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1316.wav", + "text": "外役監條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1317.wav", + "text": "有一定的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1318.wav", + "text": "至於臨時會其餘特定議案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1319.wav", + "text": "還沒有一定的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1320.wav", + "text": "所以談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1321.wav", + "text": "會進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1322.wav", + "text": "現在我先就有共識的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1323.wav", + "text": "宣讀一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1324.wav", + "text": "我現在就宣讀一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1325.wav", + "text": "決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1326.wav", + "text": "一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1327.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1328.wav", + "text": "7月17日(星期一)下午至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1329.wav", + "text": "7月31日(星期一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1330.wav", + "text": ")召開第7會期第2次臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1331.wav", + "text": "7月17日(星期一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1332.wav", + "text": "18日(星期二)及19日(星期三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1333.wav", + "text": ")為第1次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1334.wav", + "text": "7月20日(星期四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1335.wav", + "text": ")召開委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1336.wav", + "text": "7月26日(星期三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1337.wav", + "text": ")27日(星期四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1338.wav", + "text": ")為第2次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1339.wav", + "text": "定於7月18日(星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1340.wav", + "text": ")邀請行政院院長率同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1341.wav", + "text": "相關部會首長列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1342.wav", + "text": "提出性騷擾防治相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1343.wav", + "text": "事宜專案報告並備質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1344.wav", + "text": "質詢人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1345.wav", + "text": "由民進黨黨團推派11人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1346.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團推派7人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1347.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1348.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團各推派1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1349.wav", + "text": "進行未參加黨團委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1350.wav", + "text": "得優先發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1351.wav", + "text": "每位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1352.wav", + "text": "詢答時間15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1353.wav", + "text": "質詢順序依例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1354.wav", + "text": "名單請於7月17日(星期一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1355.wav", + "text": ")下午3時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1356.wav", + "text": "送交議事處彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1357.wav", + "text": "逾時視同放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1358.wav", + "text": "\n三定於7月19日(星期三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1359.wav", + "text": ")邀請行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1360.wav", + "text": "率同相關部會首長列席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1361.wav", + "text": "提出關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1362.wav", + "text": "貿易協定專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1363.wav", + "text": "質詢人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1364.wav", + "text": "由民進黨黨團推派11人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1365.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團推派7人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1366.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1367.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團各推派1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1368.wav", + "text": "進行未參加黨團委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1369.wav", + "text": "得優先發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1370.wav", + "text": "每位委員詢答時間15分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1371.wav", + "text": "質詢順序依例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1372.wav", + "text": "名單請於7月18日(星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1373.wav", + "text": "逾時視同放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1374.wav", + "text": "台北經濟文化代表處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1375.wav", + "text": "與美國在台協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1376.wav", + "text": "關於臺灣與美國間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1377.wav", + "text": "貿易協定』案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1378.wav", + "text": "於專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1379.wav", + "text": "詢答完畢後即交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1380.wav", + "text": "財政司法及法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1381.wav", + "text": "四委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1382.wav", + "text": "並不提出復議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1383.wav", + "text": "\n四本次臨時會所列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1384.wav", + "text": "特定議案尚未交付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1385.wav", + "text": "委員會審查者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1386.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意不提出復議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1387.wav", + "text": "函送委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1388.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1389.wav", + "text": "大家有意見我們就來修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1390.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1391.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1392.wav", + "text": "剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1393.wav", + "text": "有講8個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1394.wav", + "text": "的也有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1395.wav", + "text": "6個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1396.wav", + "text": "現在出來變成4個委員我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1397.wav", + "text": "在注意聽大家講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1398.wav", + "text": "你現在大家講話都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1399.wav", + "text": "\n坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1400.wav", + "text": "我說4個他說8個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1401.wav", + "text": "我們尊重議事處的排案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1402.wav", + "text": "教育和交通可能沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1403.wav", + "text": "那就把它寫進去把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1404.wav", + "text": "教育交通排除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1405.wav", + "text": "其他都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1406.wav", + "text": "我們的質詢名額可以再多1個嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1407.wav", + "text": "我們事後再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1408.wav", + "text": "現在就要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1409.wav", + "text": "就6個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1410.wav", + "text": "就6個這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1411.wav", + "text": "共識的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1412.wav", + "text": "交通教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1413.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1414.wav", + "text": "進到第二輪的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1415.wav", + "text": "委員會多一點是沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1416.wav", + "text": "這個很實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1417.wav", + "text": "未來還會回到院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1418.wav", + "text": "還有朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1419.wav", + "text": "大家發言的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1420.wav", + "text": "然後自己要寫什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1421.wav", + "text": "排除朝野協商一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1422.wav", + "text": "以及臺美21世紀貿易議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1423.wav", + "text": "等一下這個也加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1424.wav", + "text": "臺美21世紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1425.wav", + "text": "期一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1426.wav", + "text": "我們好好討論都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1427.wav", + "text": "推派代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1428.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1429.wav", + "text": "大家和諧為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1430.wav", + "text": "補一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1431.wav", + "text": "外役監條例在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1432.wav", + "text": "都沒有交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1433.wav", + "text": "是在下午的談話會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1434.wav", + "text": "沒有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1435.wav", + "text": "新的沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1436.wav", + "text": "各黨還會提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1437.wav", + "text": "我們是提性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1438.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1439.wav", + "text": "加上臺美21世紀和外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1440.wav", + "text": "資安還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1441.wav", + "text": "個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1442.wav", + "text": "上個會期5月31日才修完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1443.wav", + "text": "這是程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1444.wav", + "text": "這是程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1445.wav", + "text": "那外個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1446.wav", + "text": "個資和資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1447.wav", + "text": "個資5月31日才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1448.wav", + "text": "修正完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1449.wav", + "text": "裡面沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1450.wav", + "text": "這是程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1451.wav", + "text": "下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1452.wav", + "text": "外役監現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1453.wav", + "text": "朝野共識沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1454.wav", + "text": "兩個限期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1455.wav", + "text": "儘量完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1456.wav", + "text": "把它寫上去好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1457.wav", + "text": "剛才柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1458.wav", + "text": "提到的兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1459.wav", + "text": "大家都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1460.wav", + "text": "不要浪費大家的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1461.wav", + "text": "你大概看一下改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1462.wav", + "text": "6個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1463.wav", + "text": "有共識的就處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1464.wav", + "text": "法案都會進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1465.wav", + "text": "外役監有共識就處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1466.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1467.wav", + "text": "名單要在今天下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1468.wav", + "text": "3點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1469.wav", + "text": "提出因為還要時間作業及抽籤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1470.wav", + "text": "明天總是要正常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1471.wav", + "text": "明天是上午就開始了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1472.wav", + "text": "9點就開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1473.wav", + "text": "今天5點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1474.wav", + "text": "OK5點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1475.wav", + "text": "第二天的明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1476.wav", + "text": "那個沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1477.wav", + "text": "明天中午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1478.wav", + "text": "中午或5點都沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1479.wav", + "text": "我補充報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1480.wav", + "text": "就是大家繼續簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1481.wav", + "text": "我補充報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1482.wav", + "text": "\n有關本次臨時會循例舉行談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1483.wav", + "text": "進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1484.wav", + "text": "針對各黨團有共識及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1485.wav", + "text": "柯委員總召等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1486.wav", + "text": "曾委員銘宗等所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1487.wav", + "text": "特定議案分別進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1488.wav", + "text": "談話會訂於今天下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1489.wav", + "text": "2點半舉行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1490.wav", + "text": "1點半開始簽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1491.wav", + "text": "本次協商會議就到此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1492.wav", + "text": "下午我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1493.wav", + "text": "2點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1494.wav", + "text": "簽好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1495.wav", + "text": "簽一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1496.wav", + "text": "簽一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1497.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1498.wav", + "text": "散會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1499.wav", + "text": "但是請大家各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15091/1500.wav", + "text": "一定要簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/0.wav", + "text": "今天要協商的議題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1.wav", + "text": "研商委員柯建銘等62人及委員曾銘宗等37人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/2.wav", + "text": "分別所提召開第10屆第7會期第1次臨時會相關事宜案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/3.wav", + "text": "提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/4.wav", + "text": "我們先提案我先講反正兩案都要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/5.wav", + "text": "嘛老實講這個臨時會大家依憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/6.wav", + "text": "法第69條來召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/7.wav", + "text": "我們在上禮拜五提出有關臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/8.wav", + "text": "的召集提案內容是這樣寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/9.wav", + "text": "今天開朝野協商當然是必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/10.wav", + "text": "召集談話會然後轉為院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/11.wav", + "text": "因為我們要行使大法官同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/12.wav", + "text": "所以依照憲法總統必須提名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/13.wav", + "text": "過去一般像這個時候都是5月底以前總統提進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/14.wav", + "text": "什麼時候行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/15.wav", + "text": "當然等一下我們再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/16.wav", + "text": "提出內容就是6月14日上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/17.wav", + "text": "午談話會下午院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/18.wav", + "text": "要有一個公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/19.wav", + "text": "19日開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/20.wav", + "text": "20日全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/21.wav", + "text": "因為只有4個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/22.wav", + "text": "上午2位下午2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/23.wav", + "text": "大概一個早上就結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/24.wav", + "text": "22日就端午節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/25.wav", + "text": "\n我在這裡先感謝朝野立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/26.wav", + "text": "在上個會期我們共同努力完成很多法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/27.wav", + "text": "這裡面我想大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/28.wav", + "text": "總共172個議案136個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/29.wav", + "text": "這中間有關臨時會什麼時候召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/30.wav", + "text": "事實上在5月31日以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/31.wav", + "text": "差不多5月中各黨都有陸續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/32.wav", + "text": "交換一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/33.wav", + "text": "因為這牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/34.wav", + "text": "各黨都有委員安排出國等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/35.wav", + "text": "所以大家都有互相交換一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/36.wav", + "text": "我記得也跟曾銘宗委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/37.wav", + "text": "於5月中旬左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/38.wav", + "text": "在游院長辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/39.wav", + "text": "大家有交換意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/40.wav", + "text": "就是我們大家努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/41.wav", + "text": "在5月底以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/42.wav", + "text": "把該通過的法案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/43.wav", + "text": "在最後一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/44.wav", + "text": "然後我們差不多6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/45.wav", + "text": "14日就開始臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/46.wav", + "text": "就是剛才我講的時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/47.wav", + "text": "跟各黨團也打過招呼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/48.wav", + "text": "禮拜四我特別跟曾銘宗委員碰面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/49.wav", + "text": "大概就再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/50.wav", + "text": "案我打電話給邱臣遠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/51.wav", + "text": "他剛剛從日本回來也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/52.wav", + "text": "也打電話邱顯智委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/53.wav", + "text": "我們私底下先溝通一下有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/54.wav", + "text": "立法院必須要處理的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/55.wav", + "text": "當然我在這裡很慎重地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/56.wav", + "text": "大家都有交換一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/57.wav", + "text": "我記得上禮拜四我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/58.wav", + "text": "還跟曾銘宗委員講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/59.wav", + "text": "最近有些性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/60.wav", + "text": "性平的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/61.wav", + "text": "都在想這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/62.wav", + "text": "要修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/63.wav", + "text": "我想各黨乃至於每個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/64.wav", + "text": "都有在想這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/65.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/66.wav", + "text": "部分行政及立法必須要合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/67.wav", + "text": "朝野也必須要合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/68.wav", + "text": "社會要有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/69.wav", + "text": "我們看到發生問題的不只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/70.wav", + "text": "政黨自己本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/71.wav", + "text": "包括行政部門也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/72.wav", + "text": "媒體圈也有總之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/73.wav", + "text": "總之最近大家都看到一些現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/74.wav", + "text": "這是性平的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/75.wav", + "text": "我們大家都是嚴肅地來面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/76.wav", + "text": "我跟曾銘宗委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/77.wav", + "text": "我們跟行政部門溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/78.wav", + "text": "下會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/79.wav", + "text": "用優先法案來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/80.wav", + "text": "質詢請院長做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/81.wav", + "text": "在總質詢時另外排一個專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/82.wav", + "text": "溝通過程是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/83.wav", + "text": "這兩天謝衣鳯委員有開一個記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/84.wav", + "text": "要修性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/85.wav", + "text": "我也知道這種情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/86.wav", + "text": "今天我們看到國民黨提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/87.wav", + "text": "日切兩次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/88.wav", + "text": "不處理同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/89.wav", + "text": "我想大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/90.wav", + "text": "有共識的是大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/91.wav", + "text": "法官同意權要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/92.wav", + "text": "以及性平三法要不要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/93.wav", + "text": "完各黨意見再綜合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/94.wav", + "text": "各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/95.wav", + "text": "如同剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/96.wav", + "text": "柯總召所提到的有兩點我贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/97.wav", + "text": "上會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/98.wav", + "text": "在朝野共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/99.wav", + "text": "有很好的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/100.wav", + "text": "也通過很多國營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/101.wav", + "text": "事業等相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/102.wav", + "text": "預算案及法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/103.wav", + "text": "因此過去朝野合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/104.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/105.wav", + "text": "\n第二點有關臨時會召開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/106.wav", + "text": "柯總召有跟我溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/107.wav", + "text": "也有通電話也有碰面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/108.wav", + "text": "這是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/109.wav", + "text": "有兩個問題要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/110.wav", + "text": "第一個是大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/111.wav", + "text": "我們本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/112.wav", + "text": "樂見行使同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/113.wav", + "text": "但現在我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/114.wav", + "text": "送出四個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/115.wav", + "text": "看新聞有看報紙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/116.wav", + "text": "這四個人在媒體上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/117.wav", + "text": "評價其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/118.wav", + "text": "都有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/119.wav", + "text": "都有爭議都有重大爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/120.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/121.wav", + "text": "面對這四個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/122.wav", + "text": "人要不要行使同意權我們有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/123.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/124.wav", + "text": "性騷擾事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/125.wav", + "text": "從民進黨的中央黨部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/126.wav", + "text": "發生在職場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/127.wav", + "text": "到它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/128.wav", + "text": "資政等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/129.wav", + "text": "我們統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/130.wav", + "text": "包括婚外情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/131.wav", + "text": "超過70個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/132.wav", + "text": "要名單的話我可以給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/133.wav", + "text": "所以情況非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/134.wav", + "text": "而且外界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/135.wav", + "text": "也有呼聲要趕快修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/136.wav", + "text": "\n因此性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/137.wav", + "text": "性別工作平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/138.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/139.wav", + "text": "及性騷擾防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/140.wav", + "text": "我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/141.wav", + "text": "都沒辦法在法定會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/142.wav", + "text": "哪有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/143.wav", + "text": "第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/144.wav", + "text": "朝野及各界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/145.wav", + "text": "有共識的時候這個時間來修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/146.wav", + "text": "比較容易達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/147.wav", + "text": "等這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/148.wav", + "text": "下會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/149.wav", + "text": "最好的修法時點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/150.wav", + "text": "就過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/151.wav", + "text": "在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/152.wav", + "text": "我可以告訴民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/153.wav", + "text": "我們國民黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/154.wav", + "text": "準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/155.wav", + "text": "所以基於這三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/156.wav", + "text": "國民黨主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/157.wav", + "text": "臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/158.wav", + "text": "就來修性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/159.wav", + "text": "不要等到下會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/160.wav", + "text": "其實我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/161.wav", + "text": "等一兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/162.wav", + "text": "請行政院送版本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/163.wav", + "text": "但是不要等到下會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/164.wav", + "text": "到下會期就表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/165.wav", + "text": "民進黨面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/166.wav", + "text": "這個問題沒有誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/167.wav", + "text": "所以我們國民黨主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/168.wav", + "text": "臨時會就來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/169.wav", + "text": "性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/170.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/171.wav", + "text": "柯總召所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/172.wav", + "text": "希望行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/173.wav", + "text": "送版本以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/174.wav", + "text": "院長做專案報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/175.wav", + "text": "告其實這都可以在臨時會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/176.wav", + "text": "不一定要到下會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/177.wav", + "text": "我們立法院應該要快速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/178.wav", + "text": "回應社會的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/179.wav", + "text": "行政院的立法局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/180.wav", + "text": "我們立法院絕對自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/181.wav", + "text": "有能力提出這樣一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/182.wav", + "text": "個法案來通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/183.wav", + "text": "所以我們請民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/184.wav", + "text": "也拿出你們的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/185.wav", + "text": "我們共同來修性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/186.wav", + "text": "讓社會看到我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/187.wav", + "text": "對於立法是非常積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/188.wav", + "text": "不會怠惰請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/189.wav", + "text": "邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/190.wav", + "text": "各黨黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/191.wav", + "text": "鞭針對剛剛柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/192.wav", + "text": "跟曾總召的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/193.wav", + "text": "我們也表達一下民眾黨的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/194.wav", + "text": "針對臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/195.wav", + "text": "民進黨柯總召也提出大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/196.wav", + "text": "被提名人的同意權行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/197.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜確實也有跟我這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/198.wav", + "text": "先做過臨時會的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/199.wav", + "text": "在期程上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/200.wav", + "text": "這個當然可以先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/201.wav", + "text": "但是這一次被提名的幾位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/202.wav", + "text": "包含尤伯祥陳忠五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/203.wav", + "text": "其實他們都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/204.wav", + "text": "濃厚的政治色彩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/205.wav", + "text": "也有民進黨立委質疑尤伯祥過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/206.wav", + "text": "的一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/207.wav", + "text": "所以我想這部分還是要有一些時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/208.wav", + "text": "尤其在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/209.wav", + "text": "司法改革上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/210.wav", + "text": "我想大法官是要作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/211.wav", + "text": "憲政的守護者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/212.wav", + "text": "也不希望在提名的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/213.wav", + "text": "有所質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/214.wav", + "text": "所以還是必須讓社會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/215.wav", + "text": "多一些時間去檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/216.wav", + "text": "因此這邊具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/217.wav", + "text": "先來處理大法官這部分我們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/218.wav", + "text": "民眾黨主張嚴審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/219.wav", + "text": "所以在詢答部分我們希望可以有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/220.wav", + "text": "是否可以再進行第二輪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/221.wav", + "text": "審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/222.wav", + "text": "\n至於剛剛國民黨團所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/223.wav", + "text": "性平三法的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/224.wav", + "text": "原則上我們也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/225.wav", + "text": "因為最近性平的風暴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/226.wav", + "text": "在職場的一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/227.wav", + "text": "所以立法院身為我國最高民意機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/228.wav", + "text": "我們應該要快速地反映民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/229.wav", + "text": "因此我們具體建議在大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/230.wav", + "text": "同意權行使之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/231.wav", + "text": "第二段臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/232.wav", + "text": "來處理性平三法的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/233.wav", + "text": "因為本黨團也啟動相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/234.wav", + "text": "修法的專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/235.wav", + "text": "適度的社會溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/236.wav", + "text": "在7月底之前我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/237.wav", + "text": "可以把這個部分也納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/238.wav", + "text": "或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/239.wav", + "text": "另外的這些行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/240.wav", + "text": "我想我們還是一切以立法院的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/241.wav", + "text": "為最主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/242.wav", + "text": "所以對於臨時會民眾黨認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/243.wav", + "text": "還是要快速來反映民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/244.wav", + "text": "\n第三點我們要表達的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/245.wav", + "text": "在這個月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/246.wav", + "text": "我們也非常樂見臺美21世紀貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/247.wav", + "text": "貿易便捷化反貪腐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/248.wav", + "text": "中小企業專章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/249.wav", + "text": "等5項已經達成初步的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/250.wav", + "text": "雖然行政院到時候還是要送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/251.wav", + "text": "程序完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/252.wav", + "text": "但是據我們所知現在可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/253.wav", + "text": "是要送查照案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/254.wav", + "text": "但我們還是呼籲行政單位還有立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/255.wav", + "text": "角色我們還是希望要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/256.wav", + "text": "送立法院做審查案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/257.wav", + "text": "條文審議來回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/258.wav", + "text": "雙邊貿易的基本原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/259.wav", + "text": "我想臨時會也是一個時機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/260.wav", + "text": "尤其臺美21世紀貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/261.wav", + "text": "下個階段大概就要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/262.wav", + "text": "勞工環保及農業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/263.wav", + "text": "等3個深水區議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/264.wav", + "text": "跟農民的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/265.wav", + "text": "我們不希望立法院到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/266.wav", + "text": "仍然只是通過查照案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/267.wav", + "text": "而不做實質的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/268.wav", + "text": "我們不希望國會成為橡皮圖章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/269.wav", + "text": "要先行表達我們的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/270.wav", + "text": "以上三點請各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/271.wav", + "text": "等一下經過第二輪的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/272.wav", + "text": "之後再來做相關的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/273.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/274.wav", + "text": "我想主要是針對大法官的人事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/275.wav", + "text": "同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/276.wav", + "text": "其實大法官任命是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/277.wav", + "text": "時代力量一直都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/278.wav", + "text": "我們的職責就是應該要對於這些被提名人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/279.wav", + "text": "以確保大法官職位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/280.wav", + "text": "是交給正確適合的人的手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/281.wav", + "text": "還有民間團體其實有針對這幾位被提名人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/282.wav", + "text": "提出了一些疑點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/283.wav", + "text": "我們認為如果是因為選舉到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/284.wav", + "text": "我們就要來匆促地審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/285.wav", + "text": "讓立法院隨意做背書這是萬萬不可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/286.wav", + "text": "所以我們反對僅規劃用1個禮拜的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/287.wav", + "text": "1天公聽會1天審查1天投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/288.wav", + "text": "就要來通過大法官的人事案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/289.wav", + "text": "臨時會開議期間到全院委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/290.wav", + "text": "的公聽會所需要的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/291.wav", + "text": "依據立法院職權行使法第57條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/292.wav", + "text": "規定應該至少要有5天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/293.wav", + "text": "所以如果6月14日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/294.wav", + "text": "開始召開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/295.wav", + "text": "公聽會應該要在6月19日左右舉行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/296.wav", + "text": "同時公聽會到審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/297.wav", + "text": "有一些時間因為必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/298.wav", + "text": "給立法院充足的時間來做整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/299.wav", + "text": "做為民意代表我們絕對有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/300.wav", + "text": "專家學者們和民間團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/301.wav", + "text": "在公聽會上提出來的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/302.wav", + "text": "還有要蒐集大家更多的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/303.wav", + "text": "實質的嚴格的來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/304.wav", + "text": "大法官適任與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/305.wav", + "text": "也不會讓公聽會流於形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/306.wav", + "text": "只是講完而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/307.wav", + "text": "所以我希望在這個公聽會之後也應該要在一周後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/308.wav", + "text": "再召開全院的審查會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/309.wav", + "text": "所以如果剛才提到公聽會是在5天之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/310.wav", + "text": "也就是14日加5天即19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/311.wav", + "text": "舉行而具體的審議時間大約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/312.wav", + "text": "會是落在月底26日左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/313.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得大法官的審查真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/314.wav", + "text": "非常重要因為它其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/315.wav", + "text": "包括了很多的功能像是解釋憲法等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/316.wav", + "text": "不應該因為選舉就匆促地進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/317.wav", + "text": "同意所以我們還是希望大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/318.wav", + "text": "審查的部分能夠來嚴格執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/319.wav", + "text": "\n另外剛剛大家也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/320.wav", + "text": "最近的確有很大一波的性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/321.wav", + "text": "也一直都有看到性別平���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/322.wav", + "text": "這幾個法案裡面有很多需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/323.wav", + "text": "補足的部分我當然非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/324.wav", + "text": "樂見在這個時間朝野各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/325.wav", + "text": "儘快來補足性平三法部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/326.wav", + "text": "的不足但是我們的確還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/327.wav", + "text": "希望能夠儘快來做審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/328.wav", + "text": "也提出來說這是勢在必行的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/329.wav", + "text": "希望院版能夠儘快送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/330.wav", + "text": "同時時代力量黨團也會提出我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/331.wav", + "text": "版本但如果大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/332.wav", + "text": "在這第一次臨時會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/333.wav", + "text": "來處理性平三法可能有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/334.wav", + "text": "匆促又或者是時間過短我覺得也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/335.wav", + "text": "考慮先處理完大法官的部分之後再來處理性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/336.wav", + "text": "我覺得在臨時會通過這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/337.wav", + "text": "大家都願意的話我們時代力量當然也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/338.wav", + "text": "樂觀其成也希望能夠儘快來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/339.wav", + "text": "因為性平的教育性別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/340.wav", + "text": "工作平等法等等早就都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/341.wav", + "text": "延宕許久了趁這一波大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/342.wav", + "text": "都對這個事件越來越有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/343.wav", + "text": "的時候對性騷擾的認知是越來越多越來越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/344.wav", + "text": "清楚的情況之下來補足法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/345.wav", + "text": "不足絕對是有必要的謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/346.wav", + "text": "從2008年以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/347.wav", + "text": "社會各界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/348.wav", + "text": "一再對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/349.wav", + "text": "大法官的提名審查過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/350.wav", + "text": "不停地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/351.wav", + "text": "有一些批判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/352.wav", + "text": "年的時候蔡總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/353.wav", + "text": "提名的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/354.wav", + "text": "是5月27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/355.wav", + "text": "日同意權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/356.wav", + "text": "行使是6月27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/357.wav", + "text": "日只有1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/358.wav", + "text": "是5月31" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/359.wav", + "text": "如果照剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/360.wav", + "text": "柯總召說的是6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/361.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/362.wav", + "text": "本席在這裡還是要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/363.wav", + "text": "我們不要一再地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/364.wav", + "text": "所定的半半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/365.wav", + "text": "任期交錯制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/366.wav", + "text": "我們知道這一次如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/367.wav", + "text": "不提名大法官我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/368.wav", + "text": "任務行使還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/369.wav", + "text": "足夠的就是即使有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/370.wav", + "text": "4名大法官缺額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/371.wav", + "text": "在目前憲法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/372.wav", + "text": "法庭運作上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/373.wav", + "text": "11名大法官還是可以進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/374.wav", + "text": "審理所以我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/375.wav", + "text": "民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/376.wav", + "text": "半半任期交錯制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/377.wav", + "text": "一再錯下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/378.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/379.wav", + "text": "就是至少要1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/380.wav", + "text": "月以上所以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/381.wav", + "text": "這裡強烈建議就是包括大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/382.wav", + "text": "審查同意權等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/383.wav", + "text": "我們能夠到7月以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/384.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/385.wav", + "text": "黨團也有一些建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/386.wav", + "text": "當然我是以我個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/387.wav", + "text": "的想法之前記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/388.wav", + "text": "我有提到所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/389.wav", + "text": "還是要表達就是不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/390.wav", + "text": "去破壞整個憲政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/391.wav", + "text": "體制還有讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/392.wav", + "text": "民間社會能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/393.wav", + "text": "總統提出的四名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/394.wav", + "text": "的時間做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/395.wav", + "text": "做一些更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/396.wav", + "text": "審視\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/397.wav", + "text": "再來就是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/398.wav", + "text": "被質疑最多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/399.wav", + "text": "尤伯祥律師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/400.wav", + "text": "他有被質疑教唆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/401.wav", + "text": "司法院應該將尤伯祥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/402.wav", + "text": "被提名人被指涉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/403.wav", + "text": "案件的卷宗資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/404.wav", + "text": "列為審查資料的一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/405.wav", + "text": "畢竟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/406.wav", + "text": "出來指責尤伯祥被提名人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/407.wav", + "text": "是當時的承審法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/408.wav", + "text": "還有檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/409.wav", + "text": "這個事件非同小可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/410.wav", + "text": "我必須要說唯有真正落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/411.wav", + "text": "爭議審查才能真正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/412.wav", + "text": "遴選出適當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/413.wav", + "text": "大法官人選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/414.wav", + "text": "各黨團支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/415.wav", + "text": "我們7月以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/416.wav", + "text": "再行使大法官的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/417.wav", + "text": "仔細聽各黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/418.wav", + "text": "從最後一個陳椒華委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/419.wav", + "text": "不要破壞憲政體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/420.wav", + "text": "憲法增修條文第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/421.wav", + "text": "第1項到第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/422.wav", + "text": "交錯任期制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/423.wav", + "text": "也就是大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/424.wav", + "text": "法官任期8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/425.wav", + "text": "個別計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/426.wav", + "text": "這個是2003年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/427.wav", + "text": "2003年就是阿扁執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/428.wav", + "text": "所以當時李登輝總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/429.wav", + "text": "在任1997年第四次修憲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/430.wav", + "text": "他已經把整個制度想好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/431.wav", + "text": "意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/432.wav", + "text": "你這任總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/433.wav", + "text": "可以提名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/434.wav", + "text": "下任總統也可以提名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/435.wav", + "text": "次都你提名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/436.wav", + "text": "現在下一任總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/437.wav", + "text": "9月底的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/438.wav", + "text": "還有一次大法官七個同意權行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/439.wav", + "text": "換句話說明年的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/440.wav", + "text": "不管是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/441.wav", + "text": "他會再提名七個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/442.wav", + "text": "就會碰到這種制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/443.wav", + "text": "\n所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/444.wav", + "text": "有八個人做4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/445.wav", + "text": "有七個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/446.wav", + "text": "個人是做8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/447.wav", + "text": "4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/448.wav", + "text": "提名咨文進來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/449.wav", + "text": "有七位是做8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/450.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/451.wav", + "text": "有八位做4年的通過一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/452.wav", + "text": "那時候是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/453.wav", + "text": "後來因為憲法上有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/454.wav", + "text": "任期分開計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/455.wav", + "text": "到底後面提名是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/456.wav", + "text": "繼任或是分開計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/457.wav", + "text": "有點爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/458.wav", + "text": "第一個我要回應的就是我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/459.wav", + "text": "把這點說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/460.wav", + "text": "並沒有所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/461.wav", + "text": "破��憲政體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/462.wav", + "text": "破壞交錯任期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/463.wav", + "text": "並沒有這個疑慮請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/464.wav", + "text": "大家放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/465.wav", + "text": "\n至於大法官同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/466.wav", + "text": "的行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/467.wav", + "text": "各委員對大法官的提名人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/468.wav", + "text": "有不同意見我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/469.wav", + "text": "伯祥的問題大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/470.wav", + "text": "2003年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/471.wav", + "text": "整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/472.wav", + "text": "為當事人進行主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/473.wav", + "text": "以前是職權進行主義法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/474.wav", + "text": "2003年的時候當事人進行主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/475.wav", + "text": "就要交叉詰問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/476.wav", + "text": "所以關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/477.wav", + "text": "你剛才提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/478.wav", + "text": "伯祥的這個案子是在2005" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/479.wav", + "text": "法官檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/480.wav", + "text": "當事人這是一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/481.wav", + "text": "那條線要怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/482.wav", + "text": "始終沒有規範清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/483.wav", + "text": "只有在律師倫理規範中規範清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/484.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/485.wav", + "text": "在行使同意權的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/486.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼問我們都予以尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/487.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/488.wav", + "text": "並不是像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/489.wav", + "text": "4個都有重大爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/490.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個有待爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/491.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/492.wav", + "text": "我大概做個結論歸納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/493.wav", + "text": "第一個國民黨沒有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/494.wav", + "text": "所謂大法官同意權行使的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/495.wav", + "text": "臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/496.wav", + "text": "剛才我仔細聽了邱臣遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/497.wav", + "text": "遠總召的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/498.wav", + "text": "我覺得這部分可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/499.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/500.wav", + "text": "剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/501.wav", + "text": "時代力量也表示這點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/502.wav", + "text": "我們要了解要修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/503.wav", + "text": "我們希望是好好地修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/504.wav", + "text": "剛才曾總召所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/505.wav", + "text": "現在沒有處理的話會退燒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/506.wav", + "text": "這題目不會下禮拜不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/507.wav", + "text": "沒有退燒的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/508.wav", + "text": "我聽到說退燒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/509.wav", + "text": "過去就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/510.wav", + "text": "我們立法院是行政院的立法局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/511.wav", + "text": "因為法案的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/512.wav", + "text": "尤其是這樣大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/513.wav", + "text": "性平三法的立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/514.wav", + "text": "2002年阿扁執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/515.wav", + "text": "有性別工作平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/516.wav", + "text": "2004年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/517.wav", + "text": "有性別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/518.wav", + "text": "2006年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/519.wav", + "text": "這是我們的立法沿革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/520.wav", + "text": "沿革這些法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/521.wav", + "text": "提出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/522.wav", + "text": "有經過很多次的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/523.wav", + "text": "我要向各位報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/524.wav", + "text": "性騷擾大概修了2次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/525.wav", + "text": "幅度不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/526.wav", + "text": "最後一次是在2009年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/527.wav", + "text": "性別工作平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/528.wav", + "text": "修了8次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/529.wav", + "text": "11月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/530.wav", + "text": "不久前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/531.wav", + "text": "從200220072008" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/532.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/533.wav", + "text": "所以我的看法就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/534.wav", + "text": "我們要把這個法修好的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/535.wav", + "text": "澈底合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/536.wav", + "text": "朝野也要澈底合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/537.wav", + "text": "社會的能量要進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/538.wav", + "text": "包括學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/539.wav", + "text": "包括今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/540.wav", + "text": "我們黨團成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/541.wav", + "text": "蘇巧慧等幾個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/542.wav", + "text": "還在開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/543.wav", + "text": "為什麼要開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/544.wav", + "text": "公聽會討論得很細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/545.wav", + "text": "包括勞動部覺得他們回去要把它再調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/546.wav", + "text": "有沒有一致性中間有沒有落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/547.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/548.wav", + "text": "所以行政院說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/549.wav", + "text": "剛才包括邱臣遠總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/550.wav", + "text": "時代力量都有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/551.wav", + "text": "我們可以開第二次臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/552.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/553.wav", + "text": "我們叫行政院早一點送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/554.wav", + "text": "7月底送來的話我們8月就可以開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/555.wav", + "text": "很多立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/556.wav", + "text": "各黨團一起把這個整理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/557.wav", + "text": "一起來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/558.wav", + "text": "沒有這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/559.wav", + "text": "我還是希望大家一起來沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/560.wav", + "text": "用這樣的調整方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/561.wav", + "text": "面對這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/562.wav", + "text": "我想大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/563.wav", + "text": "希望這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/564.wav", + "text": "論現在才發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/565.wav", + "text": "還有很多機制上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/566.wav", + "text": "有的他根本不講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/567.wav", + "text": "等等還有外部的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/568.wav", + "text": "要怎麼進來包括法律扶助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/569.wav", + "text": "包括教育等等要進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/570.wav", + "text": "平重大工程的一個時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/571.wav", + "text": "以國民黨這樣的排法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/572.wav", + "text": "我看一下3天委員會而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/573.wav", + "text": "那就表示逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/574.wav", + "text": "3天委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/575.wav", + "text": "之後就是處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/576.wav", + "text": "這個不是很適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/577.wav", + "text": "啦大家好好來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/578.wav", + "text": "開2次會也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/579.wav", + "text": "依照憲法我們的職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/580.wav", + "text": "第2次開臨時會再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/581.wav", + "text": "我們幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/582.wav", + "text": "說若是這樣我們臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/583.wav", + "text": "在開大法官同意權的期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/584.wav", + "text": "專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/585.wav", + "text": "我上次跟你說我們下會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/586.wav", + "text": "先進來做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/587.wav", + "text": "聽取大家意見行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/588.wav", + "text": "把這個法好好修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/589.wav", + "text": "我們就趕快來開第2次臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/590.wav", + "text": "這樣讓每個委員都可以發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/591.wav", + "text": "好好地去討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/592.wav", + "text": "每一個黨把自己的版本寫好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/593.wav", + "text": "今天國民黨突然丟出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/594.wav", + "text": "他們有修3個法內容我還沒看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/595.wav", + "text": "但是現在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/596.wav", + "text": "也有一些委員個別提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/597.wav", + "text": "大部分都是民進黨立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/598.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/599.wav", + "text": "性騷也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/600.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/601.wav", + "text": "啦我們現在不是爭這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/602.wav", + "text": "那些點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/603.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/604.wav", + "text": "這些法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/605.wav", + "text": "我自己在這段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/606.wav", + "text": "和我們黨團內部也都非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/607.wav", + "text": "認真看待這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/608.wav", + "text": "要如何處理的完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/609.wav", + "text": "有賴朝野一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/610.wav", + "text": "68個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/611.wav", + "text": "很多委員提了部分條文修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/612.wav", + "text": "院要有能量好好地盤整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/613.wav", + "text": "它在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/614.wav", + "text": "性平調查行政調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/615.wav", + "text": "包括發生在各機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/616.wav", + "text": "沒有處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/617.wav", + "text": "這個法就會不見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/618.wav", + "text": "了不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/619.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我希望我們建立在一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/620.wav", + "text": "可以理性討論的立場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/621.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/622.wav", + "text": "請謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/623.wav", + "text": "院長各位與會同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/624.wav", + "text": "大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/625.wav", + "text": "剛才柯總召說到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/626.wav", + "text": "大法官的被提名人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/627.wav", + "text": "尤伯祥律師的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/628.wav", + "text": "我認為柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/629.wav", + "text": "應該是口誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/630.wav", + "text": "因為我們都沒看過卷宗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/631.wav", + "text": "剛才陳椒華委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/632.wav", + "text": "在審理大法官的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/633.wav", + "text": "能把相關的判決送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/634.wav", + "text": "或者是訴訟的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/635.wav", + "text": "我相信當時審理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/636.wav", + "text": "法官以及檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/637.wav", + "text": "最清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/638.wav", + "text": "而在公布大法官的提名之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/639.wav", + "text": "那個審理的法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/640.wav", + "text": "以及檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/641.wav", + "text": "公開地說明他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/642.wav", + "text": "缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/643.wav", + "text": "那都是很久以前的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/644.wav", + "text": "我不知道柯總召有沒有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/645.wav", + "text": "我相信是沒有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/646.wav", + "text": "你看到的應該是跟我們一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/647.wav", + "text": "從網路上面download下來的判決書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/648.wav", + "text": "當初審理的法官跟檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/649.wav", + "text": "都有相關疑義的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/650.wav", + "text": "其實我們今天也是負責任地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/651.wav", + "text": "尊重憲政體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/652.wav", + "text": "為全民共同來審理大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/653.wav", + "text": "有沒有重大爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/654.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們書記長講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/655.wav", + "text": "檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/656.wav", + "text": "承審法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/657.wav", + "text": "還有我們敬重的蘇治芬委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/658.wav", + "text": "都有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/659.wav", + "text": "只有你們沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/660.wav", + "text": "當然有重大爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/661.wav", + "text": "啊承審法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/662.wav", + "text": "檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/663.wav", + "text": "還有你們的資深" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/664.wav", + "text": "都質疑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/665.wav", + "text": "你們還強行通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/666.wav", + "text": "他們他們2個不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/667.wav", + "text": "我們要走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/668.wav", + "text": "你最好坐好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/669.wav", + "text": "不然我們就散會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/670.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/671.wav", + "text": "到底開不開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/672.wav", + "text": "不開我們就走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/673.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/674.wav", + "text": "我還沒講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/675.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/676.wav", + "text": "說不會退燒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/677.wav", + "text": "有關性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/678.wav", + "text": "這一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/679.wav", + "text": "已經3年半了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/680.wav", + "text": "這過程當中包括民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/681.wav", + "text": "提了超過30個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/682.wav", + "text": "到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/683.wav", + "text": "7個會期過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/684.wav", + "text": "一次也沒有排審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/685.wav", + "text": "現在休會期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/686.wav", + "text": "臨時會不開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/687.wav", + "text": "又擺在倉庫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/688.wav", + "text": "強烈主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/689.wav", + "text": "就把臨時會的議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/690.wav", + "text": "排進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/691.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/692.wav", + "text": "報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/693.wav", + "text": "大法官的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/694.wav", + "text": "是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/695.wav", + "text": "因為這4位大法官8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/696.wav", + "text": "要到任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/697.wav", + "text": "大法官當然對於國家的體制來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/698.wav", + "text": "也是一個嚴肅的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/699.wav", + "text": "所以那個時候柯總召有跟大家談好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/700.wav", + "text": "6月中開始來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/701.wav", + "text": "這個是為了他們8月底要到任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/702.wav", + "text": "剛才有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/703.wav", + "text": "包括陳椒華委員講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/704.wav", + "text": "交錯任期制是錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/705.wav", + "text": "其實如果總統新任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/706.wav", + "text": "8年有連任的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/707.wav", + "text": "這15位大法官不管有沒有交錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/708.wav", + "text": "都一定會提名到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/709.wav", + "text": "這8位都會新任提名到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/710.wav", + "text": "數學上就一定會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/711.wav", + "text": "是因為他們本來以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/712.wav", + "text": "大法官的審理就一定會照步驟走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/713.wav", + "text": "有一任特別的4年另外是8年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/714.wav", + "text": "然後變成4年交錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/715.wav", + "text": "8人團跟7人團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/716.wav", + "text": "他們當時沒有想到有人會辭職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/717.wav", + "text": "會轉任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/718.wav", + "text": "4年一半一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/719.wav", + "text": "這個先跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/720.wav", + "text": "問題剛才柯總召講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/721.wav", + "text": "就是法官檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/722.wav", + "text": "辯方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/723.wav", + "text": "不同的權利義務跟位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/724.wav", + "text": "所以法官跟檢察官對於辯方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/725.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/726.wav", + "text": "這個滿正常的尤其是制度從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/727.wav", + "text": "當事人進行主義的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/728.wav", + "text": "本來法官跟檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/729.wav", + "text": "就會對於辯方這樣的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/730.wav", + "text": "尤伯祥被提名人的這件事情你們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/731.wav", + "text": "有爭議是本來那個位置就不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/732.wav", + "text": "審查就是法官方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/733.wav", + "text": "檢方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/734.wav", + "text": "也會有提名人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/735.wav", + "text": "然後辯就是律師界也會有提名人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/736.wav", + "text": "\n像你們認為尤伯祥這個案子被質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/737.wav", + "text": "其實全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/738.wav", + "text": "律師聯合會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/739.wav", + "text": "就支持尤伯祥的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/740.wav", + "text": "學界也有支持他的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/741.wav", + "text": "可爭議事項本來就可以在審查裡面去進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/742.wav", + "text": "大家要去好好地詢問都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/743.wav", + "text": "要求資料也都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/744.wav", + "text": "關於性平三法我跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/745.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/746.wav", + "text": "在法律沒有變的狀況之下現在突然爆很多案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/747.wav", + "text": "它其實架構都沒有變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/748.wav", + "text": "是社會氣氛的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/749.wav", + "text": "所以讓被害人願意站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/750.wav", + "text": "去修法在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/751.wav", + "text": "不管是對剛才曾總召統計的或是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/752.wav", + "text": "這些也不溯及既往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/753.wav", + "text": "這次要不要有第二次的臨時會再說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/754.wav", + "text": "可以討論要怎麼進行但是不要好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/755.wav", + "text": "為了這個事情就不處理大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/756.wav", + "text": "因為大法官還是有8月底的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/757.wav", + "text": "然後性平三法看要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/758.wav", + "text": "大家討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/759.wav", + "text": "所要表達的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/760.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/761.wav", + "text": "在半半任期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/762.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/763.wav", + "text": "如果要尊重這樣的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/764.wav", + "text": "的話這次4名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/765.wav", + "text": "大法官也不用再提名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/766.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/767.wav", + "text": "說他不能提名是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/768.wav", + "text": "的只是不提名也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/769.wav", + "text": "不會影響大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/770.wav", + "text": "剛剛謝委員有再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/771.wav", + "text": "把尤伯祥被提名人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/772.wav", + "text": "所被指涉案件的卷宗資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/773.wav", + "text": "\n再來性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/774.wav", + "text": "很重要但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/775.wav", + "text": "我們知道這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/776.wav", + "text": "檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/777.wav", + "text": "消息外露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/778.wav", + "text": "媒體刊出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/779.wav", + "text": "所以揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/780.wav", + "text": "跟吹哨者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/781.wav", + "text": "重要我也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/782.wav", + "text": "拜託各朝野政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/783.wav", + "text": "吹哨者保護法揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/784.wav", + "text": "完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/785.wav", + "text": "這是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/786.wav", + "text": "的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/787.wav", + "text": "7月底之前也請行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/788.wav", + "text": "能將揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/789.wav", + "text": "吹哨者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/790.wav", + "text": "一併與性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/791.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/792.wav", + "text": "剛才陳椒華委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/793.wav", + "text": "這4個不要提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/794.wav", + "text": "上禮拜六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/795.wav", + "text": "憲判字第8號出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/796.wav", + "text": "現在大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/797.wav", + "text": "的案件非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/798.wav", + "text": "大法官審理案件法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/799.wav", + "text": "現在改為憲法訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/800.wav", + "text": "要三分之二同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/801.wav", + "text": "所以每年大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/802.wav", + "text": "必須二分之一同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/803.wav", + "text": "經過不斷的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/804.wav", + "text": "所以才有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/805.wav", + "text": "1997年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/806.wav", + "text": "第四次修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/807.wav", + "text": "這樣的情況底下我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/808.wav", + "text": "這4個大法官不補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/809.wav", + "text": "2011年提名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/810.wav", + "text": "羅昌發湯德宗黃璽君" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/811.wav", + "text": "陳碧玉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/812.wav", + "text": "他們送進來後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/813.wav", + "text": "在6月14日就處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/814.wav", + "text": "就是現在這4個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/815.wav", + "text": "林俊益黃虹霞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/816.wav", + "text": "這在6月12日就處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/817.wav", + "text": "也就是5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/818.wav", + "text": "我們必須負起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/819.wav", + "text": "讓大法官能趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/820.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/821.wav", + "text": "\n至於把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/822.wav", + "text": "他的卷宗送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/823.wav", + "text": "這一點我去瞭解一下我不太清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/824.wav", + "text": "因為卷宗可能很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/825.wav", + "text": "且判決書都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/826.wav", + "text": "教唆證人的問題可以請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/827.wav", + "text": "一下有一位法官叫錢建榮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/828.wav", + "text": "他有篇文章寫得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/829.wav", + "text": "網路上也有很多諸如此類的文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/830.wav", + "text": "面對刑事訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/831.wav", + "text": "當時2003年修時沒有把交叉詰問這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/832.wav", + "text": "規範得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/833.wav", + "text": "因為這是有不同階段的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/834.wav", + "text": "現在只是照律���公會裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/835.wav", + "text": "將來這一塊是不是要補足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/836.wav", + "text": "提案討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/837.wav", + "text": "\n第三個我們今天只談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/838.wav", + "text": "大法官以及性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/839.wav", + "text": "你可以寫在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/840.wav", + "text": "性平三法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/841.wav", + "text": "也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/842.wav", + "text": "但我尊重你的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/843.wav", + "text": "其實陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/844.wav", + "text": "你不知道揭弊者保護法已經在立法院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/845.wav", + "text": "不必再等行政院送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/846.wav", + "text": "現在爭點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/847.wav", + "text": "公和私夾雜在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/848.wav", + "text": "我們是比較贊成先處理公的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/849.wav", + "text": "私的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/850.wav", + "text": "企業都把它包進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/851.wav", + "text": "了一個很複雜的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/852.wav", + "text": "我們沒有能力這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/853.wav", + "text": "所以在立法院一直停很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/854.wav", + "text": "因為當初行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/855.wav", + "text": "邱太三當部長時是主張先公後私" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/856.wav", + "text": "後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/857.wav", + "text": "公私一起送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/858.wav", + "text": "所以大家就不敢審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/859.wav", + "text": "這點我要特別說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/860.wav", + "text": "尤其現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/861.wav", + "text": "北檢檢察長鄭銘謙以前曾在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/862.wav", + "text": "廉政署當署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/863.wav", + "text": "他也一直說這個要趕快審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/864.wav", + "text": "這點我想並不是行政院沒有送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/865.wav", + "text": "很誠懇地跟各位委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/866.wav", + "text": "大家都很理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/867.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗委員說可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/868.wav", + "text": "我說不要8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/869.wav", + "text": "8月底才送來9月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/870.wav", + "text": "審查就7月底送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/871.wav", + "text": "我們8月好好來審讓各黨都能提版本進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/872.wav", + "text": "行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/873.wav", + "text": "在院會先做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/874.wav", + "text": "然後再付委審查這個我們都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/875.wav", + "text": "假如可以照這樣來處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/876.wav", + "text": "們今天就照這樣的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/877.wav", + "text": "剛才都有跟各黨黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/878.wav", + "text": "溝通大家也都覺得OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/879.wav", + "text": "來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/880.wav", + "text": "好請邱總謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/881.wav", + "text": "我也同意剛剛柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/882.wav", + "text": "和曾總召的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/883.wav", + "text": "我想大法官的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/884.wav", + "text": "臨時會可以先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/885.wav", + "text": "我們希望在7月底之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/886.wav", + "text": "來進行相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/887.wav", + "text": "那中間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/888.wav", + "text": "早一點啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/889.wav", + "text": "然後行政院長要來做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/890.wav", + "text": "第二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/891.wav", + "text": "不要8月初啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/892.wav", + "text": "8月底才送要進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/893.wav", + "text": "9月的時候當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/894.wav", + "text": "就7月底把它送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/895.wav", + "text": "8月初我們馬上開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/896.wav", + "text": "把它處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/897.wav", + "text": "開議以後是開議的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/898.wav", + "text": "讓各黨團能夠提出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/899.wav", + "text": "能夠召開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/900.wav", + "text": "把很多問題爬梳清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/901.wav", + "text": "讓社會的意見也進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/902.wav", + "text": "讓團體的意見也進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/903.wav", + "text": "而且該嚴的嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/904.wav", + "text": "還有該補的漏洞也補起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/905.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們不要到8月才來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/906.wav", + "text": "其實一個月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/907.wav", + "text": "已經夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/908.wav", + "text": "現在才6月初而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/909.wav", + "text": "行政院人才這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/910.wav", + "text": "院長找幾個部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/911.wav", + "text": "然後再加幕僚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/912.wav", + "text": "來共同討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/913.wav", + "text": "其實他們都有在做對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/914.wav", + "text": "7月就送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/915.wav", + "text": "很難限期完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/916.wav", + "text": "7月中以前送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/917.wav", + "text": "我比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/918.wav", + "text": "建議的是以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/919.wav", + "text": "是沒意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/920.wav", + "text": "我請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/921.wav", + "text": "現在時間上是怎麼安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/922.wav", + "text": "就是大法官的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/923.wav", + "text": "我們是到7月以後再審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/924.wav", + "text": "剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/925.wav", + "text": "卷宗資料送進來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/926.wav", + "text": "然後我們再來審閱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/927.wav", + "text": "請大家支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/928.wav", + "text": "跟公聽會都是到8月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/929.wav", + "text": "一起一併進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/930.wav", + "text": "這樣子就是如我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/931.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/932.wav", + "text": "我們就不用那麼匆促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/933.wav", + "text": "草率不到三個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/934.wav", + "text": "就要做出決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/935.wav", + "text": "要用一個很奇怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/936.wav", + "text": "讓我真的很難catchyou" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/937.wav", + "text": "你catch不到我就再講一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/938.wav", + "text": "如果是7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/939.wav", + "text": "7月中我當然也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/940.wav", + "text": "啊如果7月中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/941.wav", + "text": "溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/942.wav", + "text": "那個禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/943.wav", + "text": "報告讓大家問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/944.wav", + "text": "法案從來沒有這樣處理過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/945.wav", + "text": "游院長也當過行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/946.wav", + "text": "了開第二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/947.wav", + "text": "排除朝野協商1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/948.wav", + "text": "我想這沒有政治案件應該要通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/949.wav", + "text": "啦有什麼好的意見都可以納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/950.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/951.wav", + "text": "大概就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/952.wav", + "text": "二三對調OK啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/953.wav", + "text": "二三對調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/954.wav", + "text": "在時序上會比較好比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/955.wav", + "text": "這是第一次臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/956.wav", + "text": "7月14日以前把版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/957.wav", + "text": "我們在7月底完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/958.wav", + "text": "當然這必須排除朝野協商1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/959.wav", + "text": "送進來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/960.wav", + "text": "行政院長率各部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/961.wav", + "text": "針對修法先作專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/962.wav", + "text": "因為這牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/963.wav", + "text": "好幾個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/964.wav", + "text": "有勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/965.wav", + "text": "月底以前完成立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/966.wav", + "text": "這樣就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/967.wav", + "text": "再加一個7月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/968.wav", + "text": "其他應該都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/969.wav", + "text": "二三對調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/970.wav", + "text": "二三對調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/971.wav", + "text": "7月底以前完成立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/972.wav", + "text": "那就代表我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/973.wav", + "text": "不必等1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/974.wav", + "text": "啦委員會好好討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/975.wav", + "text": "一定請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/976.wav", + "text": "問這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/977.wav", + "text": "是說7月底才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/978.wav", + "text": "行使人事同意權嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/979.wav", + "text": "沒有啦你中文稍微看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/980.wav", + "text": "你這個都沒寫我看不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/981.wav", + "text": "同意權是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/982.wav", + "text": "也許不只三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/983.wav", + "text": "因為相關法令很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/984.wav", + "text": "這個時程不寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/985.wav", + "text": "我們看不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/986.wav", + "text": "我來說白話文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/987.wav", + "text": "大法官同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/988.wav", + "text": "投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/989.wav", + "text": "相關時程我們會提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/990.wav", + "text": "我來宣讀一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/991.wav", + "text": "\n決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/992.wav", + "text": "一各黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/993.wav", + "text": "本(第7)會期休會期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/994.wav", + "text": "先召開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/995.wav", + "text": "處理司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/996.wav", + "text": "大法官人事同意權案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/997.wav", + "text": "\n二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/998.wav", + "text": "舉行全院委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/999.wav", + "text": "談話會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1000.wav", + "text": "第7會期第1次臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1001.wav", + "text": "相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1002.wav", + "text": "\n三各黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1003.wav", + "text": "為完備性騷擾防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1004.wav", + "text": "請各黨團委員及行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1005.wav", + "text": "於7月14日前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1006.wav", + "text": "提出性騷擾防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1007.wav", + "text": "相關法律修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1008.wav", + "text": "臨時會進行審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1009.wav", + "text": "並於臨時會期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1010.wav", + "text": "邀請行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1011.wav", + "text": "率相關部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1012.wav", + "text": "就性騷擾防治相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1013.wav", + "text": "至立法院進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1014.wav", + "text": "專案報告並備質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1015.wav", + "text": "上開法案不受黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1016.wav", + "text": "協商期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1017.wav", + "text": "1個月之限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1018.wav", + "text": "於7月底完成立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1019.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意為完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1020.wav", + "text": "性騷擾防治之法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1021.wav", + "text": "性騷擾防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1022.wav", + "text": "等相關法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1023.wav", + "text": "也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1024.wav", + "text": "不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1025.wav", + "text": "也許只有三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1026.wav", + "text": "也許不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1027.wav", + "text": "到時候再看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1028.wav", + "text": "等相關法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1029.wav", + "text": "等相關法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1030.wav", + "text": "針對剛剛所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1031.wav", + "text": "要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1032.wav", + "text": "沈伯洋的卷宗資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1033.wav", + "text": "送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1034.wav", + "text": "送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1035.wav", + "text": "希望能夠列入第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1036.wav", + "text": "行使同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1037.wav", + "text": "有提出建議也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1038.wav", + "text": "舉行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1039.wav", + "text": "而審查會則希望在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1040.wav", + "text": "月底舉行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1041.wav", + "text": "這點希望能夠寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1042.wav", + "text": "我想我們之間有差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1043.wav", + "text": "6月底去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1044.wav", + "text": "對於不同意見我們就到院會處理只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1045.wav", + "text": "只能這樣而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1046.wav", + "text": "卷宗資料已經是二十幾年前了找不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1047.wav", + "text": "找得到還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1048.wav", + "text": "沒有二十幾年吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1049.wav", + "text": "年當事人進行主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1050.wav", + "text": "已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1051.wav", + "text": "所以要訪問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1052.wav", + "text": "相對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1053.wav", + "text": "可不可以提供要送到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1054.wav", + "text": "司法院他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1055.wav", + "text": "送進來我們就列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1056.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1057.wav", + "text": "不是既然答應你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1058.wav", + "text": "至於能夠送到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1059.wav", + "text": "找得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1060.wav", + "text": "些都可以看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1061.wav", + "text": "所以總召的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1062.wav", + "text": "以只能這樣而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1063.wav", + "text": "不然怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1064.wav", + "text": "對就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1065.wav", + "text": "院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1066.wav", + "text": "下午開院會我們就處理程序雖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1067.wav", + "text": "然你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1068.wav", + "text": "一個人持不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1069.wav", + "text": "不然怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1070.wav", + "text": "好至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1071.wav", + "text": "到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1072.wav", + "text": "程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1073.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1074.wav", + "text": "接下來我考慮要開始集中在侯友宜身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1075.wav", + "text": "三天完成的那個我說不可能做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1076.wav", + "text": "有那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1077.wav", + "text": "我向大家再報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1078.wav", + "text": "一目前黨團協商共識正在簽字中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1079.wav", + "text": "我們就繼續簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1080.wav", + "text": "\n二談話會定於星期三上午10時舉行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1081.wav", + "text": "9時開始簽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1082.wav", + "text": "另依110年10月5日協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1083.wav", + "text": "議場於當日上午7時開正門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15079/1084.wav", + "text": "\n三現在散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/0.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1.wav", + "text": "協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/2.wav", + "text": "現在開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/3.wav", + "text": "我先介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/4.wav", + "text": "列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/5.wav", + "text": "金融監督管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/6.wav", + "text": "主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/7.wav", + "text": "黃天牧先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/8.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/9.wav", + "text": "各位總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/10.wav", + "text": "各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/11.wav", + "text": "5月10日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/12.wav", + "text": "臺中捷運重大運輸事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/13.wav", + "text": "成立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/14.wav", + "text": "因為異物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/15.wav", + "text": "異物入侵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/16.wav", + "text": "從太魯閣案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/17.wav", + "text": "軌道安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/18.wav", + "text": "我國一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/19.wav", + "text": "學者喪生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/20.wav", + "text": "是在處理一個系統性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/21.wav", + "text": "因為已經發生過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/22.wav", + "text": "好幾起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/23.wav", + "text": "公共工程有關的法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/24.wav", + "text": "法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/25.wav", + "text": "是不是有系統性的缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/26.wav", + "text": "以及類似的原因導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/27.wav", + "text": "憾事反覆發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/28.wav", + "text": "林淑雅老師的告別式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/29.wav", + "text": "上我們看到總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/30.wav", + "text": "以及司法院的許宗力院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/31.wav", + "text": "和監察院陳菊院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/32.wav", + "text": "及NGO���都到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/33.wav", + "text": "這樣的事情是非常不應該發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/34.wav", + "text": "由立法院成立一個調閱委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/35.wav", + "text": "有關要調閱的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/36.wav", + "text": "因為這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/37.wav", + "text": "臺中市政府及中捷公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/38.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/39.wav", + "text": "它們有各式各樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/40.wav", + "text": "各項應變設計文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/41.wav", + "text": "等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/42.wav", + "text": "也希望能夠澈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/43.wav", + "text": "澈底發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/44.wav", + "text": "系統性法制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/45.wav", + "text": "吊臂入侵軌道個案的公安部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/46.wav", + "text": "能夠向內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/47.wav", + "text": "及臺中市政府調閱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/48.wav", + "text": "這些建案的施工計畫書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/49.wav", + "text": "塔式起重機具安全管理計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/50.wav", + "text": "准予備查之核可函等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/51.wav", + "text": "希望大家可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/52.wav", + "text": "支持能夠健全我國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/53.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/54.wav", + "text": "各位委員同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/55.wav", + "text": "邱顯智委員所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/56.wav", + "text": "以及運安的問題等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/57.wav", + "text": "要成立院級的調閱委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/58.wav", + "text": "本院到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/59.wav", + "text": "還沒有成立過院級的調閱委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/60.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/61.wav", + "text": "個沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/62.wav", + "text": "那個是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/63.wav", + "text": "調閱小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/64.wav", + "text": "現在沒有一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/65.wav", + "text": "有能力有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/66.wav", + "text": "再加一個議程進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/67.wav", + "text": "第三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/68.wav", + "text": "有關本案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/69.wav", + "text": "尤其是林教授的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/70.wav", + "text": "大家都很遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/71.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/72.wav", + "text": "運安會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/73.wav", + "text": "現在是代理主委新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/74.wav", + "text": "第一個就是要調查這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/75.wav", + "text": "本案已經在調查中了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/76.wav", + "text": "也不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/77.wav", + "text": "在地方發生一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/78.wav", + "text": "就是在臺中市政府發生一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/79.wav", + "text": "就由立法院來成立調閱委員��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/80.wav", + "text": "而且是院級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/81.wav", + "text": "假如這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/82.wav", + "text": "這個體制也不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/83.wav", + "text": "況且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/84.wav", + "text": "檢察官所有單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/85.wav", + "text": "調閱委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/86.wav", + "text": "我不相信比公權力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/87.wav", + "text": "包括檢察官介入了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/88.wav", + "text": "還有運安會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/89.wav", + "text": "交通部都已經在處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/90.wav", + "text": "還有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/91.wav", + "text": "這個必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/92.wav", + "text": "嗎最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/93.wav", + "text": "今天也沒有這個議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/94.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/95.wav", + "text": "你說系統性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/96.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/97.wav", + "text": "法制面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/98.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/99.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/100.wav", + "text": "臺中市發生的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/101.wav", + "text": "那以後在地方發生的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/102.wav", + "text": "都來這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/103.wav", + "text": "提出要成立調閱委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/104.wav", + "text": "那竹北發生了天坑那件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/105.wav", + "text": "是不是也要成立調閱委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/106.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/107.wav", + "text": "中央地方的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/108.wav", + "text": "要分清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/109.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/110.wav", + "text": "誰主責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/111.wav", + "text": "誰業管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/112.wav", + "text": "都應該是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/113.wav", + "text": "不宜啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/114.wav", + "text": "沒有如此的程序可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/115.wav", + "text": "也做過很多報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/116.wav", + "text": "我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/117.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/118.wav", + "text": "應該是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/119.wav", + "text": "我在第一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/120.wav", + "text": "裡面就有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/121.wav", + "text": "現在有數個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/122.wav", + "text": "在對這個事故進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/123.wav", + "text": "各個調查機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/124.wav", + "text": "各有其職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/125.wav", + "text": "針對本件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/126.wav", + "text": "案件所涉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/127.wav", + "text": "刑事責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/128.wav", + "text": "去做調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/129.wav", + "text": "那剛剛所講運安會的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/130.wav", + "text": "是側重於發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/131.wav", + "text": "在個案事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/132.wav", + "text": "缺失等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/133.wav", + "text": "因為像太魯閣事故也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/134.wav", + "text": "由運安會去做調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/135.wav", + "text": "等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/136.wav", + "text": "地方議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/137.wav", + "text": "是針對臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/138.wav", + "text": "捷運管理階段的問責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/139.wav", + "text": "還有監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/140.wav", + "text": "是側重於事件人員跟機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/141.wav", + "text": "違失的問責部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/142.wav", + "text": "因為法有明文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/143.wav", + "text": "有這個職責所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/144.wav", + "text": "國會的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/145.wav", + "text": "它主要當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/146.wav", + "text": "側重在我剛剛講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/147.wav", + "text": "之後是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/148.wav", + "text": "用一般性的法規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/149.wav", + "text": "去防免像這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/150.wav", + "text": "一個可能性的系統性的問題出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/151.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/152.wav", + "text": "議程的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/153.wav", + "text": "我就是想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/154.wav", + "text": "如果各黨團同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/155.wav", + "text": "我只是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/156.wav", + "text": "如果大家同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/157.wav", + "text": "我們是不是能夠有這樣的議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/158.wav", + "text": "要不要成立這個調閱委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/159.wav", + "text": "\n我最後要補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/160.wav", + "text": "立法院作為中央民意代表機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/161.wav", + "text": "是可以去做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/162.wav", + "text": "的第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/163.wav", + "text": "軌道我們會認為軌道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/164.wav", + "text": "是最安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/165.wav", + "text": "那為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/166.wav", + "text": "也會發生這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/167.wav", + "text": "這個類似的案件也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/168.wav", + "text": "我們在一開始看到新聞的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/169.wav", + "text": "臂掉下來去砸中這個列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/170.wav", + "text": "這輛列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/171.wav", + "text": "的前方已經有一個吊臂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/172.wav", + "text": "結果這輛列車卻又這樣開過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/173.wav", + "text": "才造成這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/174.wav", + "text": "所以我們當然會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/175.wav", + "text": "第一個這個系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/176.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法自己偵測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/177.wav", + "text": "讓它停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/178.wav", + "text": "讓它斷電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/179.wav", + "text": "然後在看到前面的狀況的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/180.wav", + "text": "所以是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/181.wav", + "text": "在軌道的設計上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/182.wav", + "text": "有什麼樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/183.wav", + "text": "\n最後一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/184.wav", + "text": "因為這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/185.wav", + "text": "臺中的捷運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/186.wav", + "text": "在這個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/187.wav", + "text": "事實上它是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/188.wav", + "text": "國家重大建設工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/189.wav", + "text": "它是由交通部主管兼委託主辦機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/190.wav", + "text": "是一個國家重大工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/191.wav", + "text": "然後再點交移交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/192.wav", + "text": "之後交通部會同臺中市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/193.wav", + "text": "交付中捷營運前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/194.wav", + "text": "本案是用OT的方式營運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/195.wav", + "text": "甫經營不久就發生這樣的事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/196.wav", + "text": "它是不是有關於公共工程的法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/197.wav", + "text": "主要是法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/198.wav", + "text": "上面的缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/199.wav", + "text": "而亟待我們去修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/200.wav", + "text": "假設我們成立一個調閱委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/201.wav", + "text": "然後去處理之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/202.wav", + "text": "用一般性的法規範去修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/203.wav", + "text": "然後補正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/204.wav", + "text": "所以有這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/205.wav", + "text": "我看你這裡寫的法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/206.wav", + "text": "法制和調閱委員會沒有什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/207.wav", + "text": "法制就是將來要提什麼法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/208.wav", + "text": "我還是再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/209.wav", + "text": "立法院委員會就這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/210.wav", + "text": "5月11日的時候就已經對外宣告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/211.wav", + "text": "初步調查報告拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/212.wav", + "text": "時間快到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/213.wav", + "text": "在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/214.wav", + "text": "用法制面能夠做到什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/215.wav", + "text": "\n法制面也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/216.wav", + "text": "更大的能量要針對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/217.wav", + "text": "成立一個調閱委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/218.wav", + "text": "我知道你的用意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/219.wav", + "text": "大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/220.wav", + "text": "程序走到這裡來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/221.wav", + "text": "沒有再另外一個程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/222.wav", + "text": "了程序也走到這裡來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/223.wav", + "text": "從來沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/224.wav", + "text": "一個人有能力去改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/225.wav", + "text": "任何議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/226.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/227.wav", + "text": "大概就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/228.wav", + "text": "就看要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/229.wav", + "text": "話已經講得這麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/230.wav", + "text": "了好了啦不要再演了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/231.wav", + "text": "我知道你的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/232.wav", + "text": "如果大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/233.wav", + "text": "能夠同意變更的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/234.wav", + "text": "當然也是一個作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/235.wav", + "text": "運安會就去調查啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/236.wav", + "text": "報告就快出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/237.wav", + "text": "你們也沒辦法同意就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/238.wav", + "text": "沒有這個議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/239.wav", + "text": "大家很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/240.wav", + "text": "我們大家都對這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/241.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/242.wav", + "text": "就是商量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/243.wav", + "text": "這樣是不是一個好的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/244.wav", + "text": "沒有這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/245.wav", + "text": "第二個也不是這樣的處理方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/246.wav", + "text": "運安會的調查報告就要出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/247.wav", + "text": "我們立法院就法制面成立調閱委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/248.wav", + "text": "我從來沒有看過什麼叫做法制面的調閱委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/249.wav", + "text": "法制面調閱委員會的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/250.wav", + "text": "未來調閱之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/251.wav", + "text": "要去處理這些一般性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/252.wav", + "text": "就法制面嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/253.wav", + "text": "你們要修法就修法嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/254.wav", + "text": "修法要成立調閱委員會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/255.wav", + "text": "要成立調閱委員會才能修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/256.wav", + "text": "瞭解它的系統性缺失之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/257.wav", + "text": "我不相信我們立法院能夠在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/258.wav", + "text": "做什麼事情我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/259.wav", + "text": "系統性的缺失不就是運安會要去處理的事情嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/260.wav", + "text": "不論是港口的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/261.wav", + "text": "都是運安會要去處理系統性缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/262.wav", + "text": "才能夠從根本上結構上去改善這個問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/263.wav", + "text": "如果說委員這邊對運安會的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/264.wav", + "text": "有任何疑義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/265.wav", + "text": "���們可以來質詢運安會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/266.wav", + "text": "或是質詢交通部嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/267.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/268.wav", + "text": "立法院也在成立調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/269.wav", + "text": "調資料要怎麼調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/270.wav", + "text": "我很同意剛剛講要做系統性的阻絕式處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/271.wav", + "text": "甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/272.wav", + "text": "臺中市政府在中間的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/273.wav", + "text": "以及後續的調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/274.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/275.wav", + "text": "運安會或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/276.wav", + "text": "甚至要不要從監察院去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/277.wav", + "text": "我覺得都很有討論空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/278.wav", + "text": "但是立法院這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/279.wav", + "text": "我會覺得整個程序上好像不是很合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/280.wav", + "text": "運安會的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/281.wav", + "text": "它涉及的是這個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/282.wav", + "text": "我後面的調閱就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/283.wav", + "text": "希望能夠把這個事情的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/284.wav", + "text": "系統來龍去脈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/285.wav", + "text": "一開始設計的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/286.wav", + "text": "臺北市政府捷運工程局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/287.wav", + "text": "及臺中市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/288.wav", + "text": "中捷公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/289.wav", + "text": "臺中都會區大眾捷運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/290.wav", + "text": "文心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/291.wav", + "text": "北屯線建設計畫三方契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/292.wav", + "text": "它的行控中心有關異物入侵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/293.wav", + "text": "軌道之軟硬體應變設計文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/294.wav", + "text": "去瞭解它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/295.wav", + "text": "到底存在什麼樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/296.wav", + "text": "應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/297.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/298.wav", + "text": "我看這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/299.wav", + "text": "這個案子是不是你們私下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/300.wav", + "text": "大家再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/301.wav", + "text": "互相瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/302.wav", + "text": "溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/303.wav", + "text": "再提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/304.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/305.wav", + "text": "那現在我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/306.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/307.wav", + "text": "院長我要講一個程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/308.wav", + "text": "這個不在程序範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/309.wav", + "text": "可以搞這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/310.wav", + "text": "在程序範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/311.wav", + "text": "我們要處理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/312.wav", + "text": "講的是排在院會議程的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/313.wav", + "text": "這個會期要處理的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/314.wav", + "text": "全部卡在院會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/315.wav", + "text": "為了這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/316.wav", + "text": "我們今天才要協商嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/317.wav", + "text": "這裡面當然和關鍵基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/318.wav", + "text": "有一個案子─" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/319.wav", + "text": "第三十案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/320.wav", + "text": "傳染病防治法增訂第74條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/321.wav", + "text": "也逕付二讀了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/322.wav", + "text": "\n這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/323.wav", + "text": "第三十案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/324.wav", + "text": "沒有第三十案啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/325.wav", + "text": "傳染病防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/326.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/327.wav", + "text": "對要延長2年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/328.wav", + "text": "防疫補償要給人家嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/329.wav", + "text": "要延長到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/330.wav", + "text": "聽我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/331.wav", + "text": "傳染病防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/332.wav", + "text": "第74條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/333.wav", + "text": "排在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/334.wav", + "text": "議事日程第三十案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/335.wav", + "text": "現在院會已經進行到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/336.wav", + "text": "第十六案特殊教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/337.wav", + "text": "這是在議場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/338.wav", + "text": "的議程裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/339.wav", + "text": "第三十案是什麼案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/340.wav", + "text": "就是傳染病防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/341.wav", + "text": "1防疫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/342.wav", + "text": "特別條例已經結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/343.wav", + "text": "但是防疫補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/344.wav", + "text": "所以是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/345.wav", + "text": "這個比較單純" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/346.wav", + "text": "比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/347.wav", + "text": "比較急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/348.wav", + "text": "等一下請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/349.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/350.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/351.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/352.wav", + "text": "條例還在不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/353.wav", + "text": "個條例還在不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/354.wav", + "text": "新增的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/355.wav", + "text": "紓困條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/356.wav", + "text": "因為那個條例落日了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/357.wav", + "text": "所以需要有一個請求權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/358.wav", + "text": "讓它可以繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/359.wav", + "text": "那個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/360.wav", + "text": "修應該在那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/361.wav", + "text": "不要急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/362.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/363.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/364.wav", + "text": "我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/365.wav", + "text": "談那個的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/366.wav", + "text": "請衛福部進來好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/367.wav", + "text": "這是行政院的案子嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/368.wav", + "text": "大家都同意了也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/369.wav", + "text": "跟你打過招呼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/370.wav", + "text": "你也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/371.wav", + "text": "所以我今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/372.wav", + "text": "這個要列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/373.wav", + "text": "我贊成啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/374.wav", + "text": "但是應該在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/375.wav", + "text": "原來的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/376.wav", + "text": "那個等一下再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/377.wav", + "text": "我跟你打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/378.wav", + "text": "呼是要在這裡協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/379.wav", + "text": "主席請教請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/380.wav", + "text": "議程先確認啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/381.wav", + "text": "到底要不要放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/382.wav", + "text": "放入議程而已嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/383.wav", + "text": "我並沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/384.wav", + "text": "叫你一定要答應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/385.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/386.wav", + "text": "這是合理的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/387.wav", + "text": "我說我贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/388.wav", + "text": "但是要修哪裡嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/389.wav", + "text": "既然火氣這麼大就不要協商啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/390.wav", + "text": "因為看起來是有共識嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/391.wav", + "text": "我讓民眾黨講一下謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/392.wav", + "text": "大家火氣不要那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/393.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/394.wav", + "text": "颱風轉向了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/395.wav", + "text": "柯總召只是希望把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/396.wav", + "text": "今天協商的議程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/397.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/398.wav", + "text": "至於同意不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/399.wav", + "text": "放哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/400.wav", + "text": "等一下再說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/401.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/402.wav", + "text": "這個我們同意啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/403.wav", + "text": "所以我說大方向支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/404.wav", + "text": "但是修哪裡啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/405.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/406.wav", + "text": "你火氣那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/407.wav", + "text": "我是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/408.wav", + "text": "正說明而已納入程序啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/409.wav", + "text": "這個有議程的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/410.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/411.wav", + "text": "但是修哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/412.wav", + "text": "剛才沒有議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/413.wav", + "text": "的都可以討論這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/414.wav", + "text": "這個是真正有議程的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/415.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/416.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/417.wav", + "text": "開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/418.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/419.wav", + "text": "增訂第107條之4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/420.wav", + "text": "還有銀行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/421.wav", + "text": "增訂第102條之7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/422.wav", + "text": "增訂第102條之8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/423.wav", + "text": "期貨交易法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/424.wav", + "text": "增訂第一百十二條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/425.wav", + "text": "增訂第一百十二條之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/426.wav", + "text": "大家如果沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/427.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/428.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/429.wav", + "text": "銀行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/430.wav", + "text": "跟期貨交易法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/431.wav", + "text": "這三個其實內容完全一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/432.wav", + "text": "罰則是不是太輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/433.wav", + "text": "其實處理一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/434.wav", + "text": "就可以處理三個證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/435.wav", + "text": "證交法的第107條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/436.wav", + "text": "它講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/437.wav", + "text": "以竊取毀壞或其他非法方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/438.wav", + "text": "危害證券交易所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/439.wav", + "text": "證券集中保管事業之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/440.wav", + "text": "資通系統設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/441.wav", + "text": "處一年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/442.wav", + "text": "七年以下有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/443.wav", + "text": "得併科新臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/444.wav", + "text": "我認為這個罰責太輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/445.wav", + "text": "看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/446.wav", + "text": "要不要調或者是請法務部表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/447.wav", + "text": "這東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/448.wav", + "text": "只有一年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/449.wav", + "text": "這個都太輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/450.wav", + "text": "看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/451.wav", + "text": "法務部有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/452.wav", + "text": "\n第107條之1樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/453.wav", + "text": "這個更嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/454.wav", + "text": "對證券交易所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/455.wav", + "text": "證券櫃檯買賣中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/456.wav", + "text": "危害其功能運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/457.wav", + "text": "到時候股市都不能交易了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/458.wav", + "text": "你才處一年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/459.wav", + "text": "所以看看吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/460.wav", + "text": "看看要怎麼增加吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/461.wav", + "text": "其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/462.wav", + "text": "主管部會來做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/463.wav", + "text": "都是同一個模組出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/464.wav", + "text": "就是當初法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/465.wav", + "text": "有一個立法的模板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/466.wav", + "text": "相同的修法架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/467.wav", + "text": "依照危害程度的輕重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/468.wav", + "text": "在刑責上做不同的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/469.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛曾總召所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/470.wav", + "text": "的賴士葆委員也有提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/471.wav", + "text": "但是這個案子牽一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/472.wav", + "text": "牽一髮而動全身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/473.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/474.wav", + "text": "曾總召的確講得沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/475.wav", + "text": "像證券交易系統這些都滿重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/476.wav", + "text": "但是也許其他部會也會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/477.wav", + "text": "它的系統很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/478.wav", + "text": "所以這部分金管會沒有特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/479.wav", + "text": "因為這是一個package" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/480.wav", + "text": "就是看各黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/481.wav", + "text": "因為22個提案可能都要連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/482.wav", + "text": "不然的話為什麼我特別高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/483.wav", + "text": "其他部會也許也會有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/484.wav", + "text": "因為這22種情況不一樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/485.wav", + "text": "金管會是整個股市交易系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/486.wav", + "text": "到時候股市不交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/487.wav", + "text": "衍生的經濟金融的衝擊很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/488.wav", + "text": "我不是講說別的部會不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/489.wav", + "text": "都很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/490.wav", + "text": "我倒不覺得要依照法務部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/491.wav", + "text": "全部要一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/492.wav", + "text": "你要一致也可以啊!全部調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/493.wav", + "text": "有一些是真的很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/494.wav", + "text": "有一些真的沒那麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/495.wav", + "text": "每一種情況都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/496.wav", + "text": "我是覺得如果讓股市都不能交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/497.wav", + "text": "開什麼玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/498.wav", + "text": "只處一年以上七年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/499.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/500.wav", + "text": "我是不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/501.wav", + "text": "其他的再逐步看謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/502.wav", + "text": "我也支持曾總召的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/503.wav", + "text": "雖然法務部在修法建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/504.wav", + "text": "特別是罰則的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/505.wav", + "text": "有給你們一個框架性的處理原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/506.wav", + "text": "包括一致性層級化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/507.wav", + "text": "有關涉及到實體設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/508.wav", + "text": "或者是資通系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/509.wav", + "text": "所造成的社會危害程度應該是不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/510.wav", + "text": "罰則一致性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/511.wav", + "text": "是在指什麼的一致性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/512.wav", + "text": "還是以災損後造成的社會影響性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/513.wav", + "text": "現在看起來金融3個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/514.wav", + "text": "不管是證交銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/515.wav", + "text": "包括跟國外的交易匯兌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/516.wav", + "text": "會不會是比較實質性可以估算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/517.wav", + "text": "這個就500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/518.wav", + "text": "我是覺得略輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/519.wav", + "text": "真的是略輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/520.wav", + "text": "但是後面有一個危害國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/521.wav", + "text": "這個是5,000萬嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/522.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/523.wav", + "text": "軟體的有點是電腦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/524.wav", + "text": "後面為什麼講意圖危害國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/525.wav", + "text": "或社會安定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/526.wav", + "text": "這個是要以前兩項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/527.wav", + "text": "前兩項意圖危害這部分的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/528.wav", + "text": "之前好像在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/529.wav", + "text": "也有委員在質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/530.wav", + "text": "就是這個到底要怎麼樣認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/531.wav", + "text": "所以這兩個還是先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/532.wav", + "text": "再看框架性怎麼定好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/533.wav", + "text": "這個有不同樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/534.wav", + "text": "法務部要說明嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/535.wav", + "text": "跟主席以及各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/536.wav", + "text": "按照司法院釋字804號解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/537.wav", + "text": "應與行為所生之危害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/538.wav", + "text": "行為人責任之輕重相稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/539.wav", + "text": "始符合憲法罪刑相當原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/540.wav", + "text": "而與憲法第23條比例原則無違" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/541.wav", + "text": "主要是考量到他的這個行為所生的危害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/542.wav", + "text": "以及行為人責任的輕重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/543.wav", + "text": "比方以政府採購法第87條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/544.wav", + "text": "的暴力圍標也是一年以上七年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/545.wav", + "text": "但是它的罰金刑是300萬以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/546.wav", + "text": "那麼以貪污治罪條例第十一條第1項來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/547.wav", + "text": "行賄罪也是一年以上七年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/548.wav", + "text": "但是它罰金刑是300萬以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/549.wav", + "text": "又比如兒少性剝削防制條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/550.wav", + "text": "它也是一年以上七年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/551.wav", + "text": "但是它的罰金刑也是300萬元以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/552.wav", + "text": "所以這次的設計500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/553.wav", + "text": "可以說已經是相當程度的提高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/554.wav", + "text": "以及主管機關的政策決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/555.wav", + "text": "我們也是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/556.wav", + "text": "因為這是一個政策判斷的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/557.wav", + "text": "它是否與這個行為的危害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/558.wav", + "text": "跟行為人責任輕重是否相稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/559.wav", + "text": "有關這部分我們依然尊重大院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/560.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/561.wav", + "text": "有22個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/562.wav", + "text": "剛才講過我這樣聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/563.wav", + "text": "所有立法邏輯都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/564.wav", + "text": "啦也就是樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/565.wav", + "text": "一個是實體性設施的破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/566.wav", + "text": "一個是資通系統的破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/567.wav", + "text": "但是修法重點就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/568.wav", + "text": "它有分層級化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/569.wav", + "text": "竊取毀害或其他危險動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/570.wav", + "text": "影響正常運作是一至七年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/571.wav", + "text": "那就重了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/572.wav", + "text": "三到十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/573.wav", + "text": "造成人員重傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/574.wav", + "text": "那是五年到十二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/575.wav", + "text": "致死是七年以上無期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/576.wav", + "text": "大概每一個法的樣態都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/577.wav", + "text": "我記得在委員會審查還沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/578.wav", + "text": "還沒出委員會朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/579.wav", + "text": "因為第一個層級是一年到七年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/580.wav", + "text": "聽說國民黨認為500萬太少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/581.wav", + "text": "要600萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/582.wav", + "text": "假如這樣我們也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/583.wav", + "text": "啦保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/584.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/585.wav", + "text": "這3個都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/586.wav", + "text": "22個法都這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/587.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/588.wav", + "text": "其他再往下看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/589.wav", + "text": "這3個我都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/590.wav", + "text": "到時候表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/591.wav", + "text": "我們要表達國民黨的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/592.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/593.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/594.wav", + "text": "那就明天表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/595.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/596.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/597.wav", + "text": "沒有當場要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/598.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/599.wav", + "text": "看你們要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/600.wav", + "text": "你希望是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/601.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/602.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/603.wav", + "text": "一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/604.wav", + "text": "我覺得太低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/605.wav", + "text": "罰金至少5,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/606.wav", + "text": "這是經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/607.wav", + "text": "你們不要把它當成一般犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/608.wav", + "text": "這是經濟犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/609.wav", + "text": "如果是後面的那些條文也就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/610.wav", + "text": "經濟犯罪的金額都很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/611.wav", + "text": "平常也存在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/612.wav", + "text": "以前沒有這樣重的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/613.wav", + "text": "證券市場的存在也很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/614.wav", + "text": "強調破壞金融秩序的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/615.wav", + "text": "你現在是覺得刑期怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/616.wav", + "text": "是要增加到多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/617.wav", + "text": "刑責和罰金可以分開來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/618.wav", + "text": "我希望刑責可以處三年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/619.wav", + "text": "第2項一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/620.wav", + "text": "是三上十下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/621.wav", + "text": "下一項就是五到七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/622.wav", + "text": "三上十下是意圖危害國家安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/623.wav", + "text": "全或社會安定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/624.wav", + "text": "那邊就是五到十二了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/625.wav", + "text": "竊取毀壞或其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/626.wav", + "text": "危害功能正常以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/627.wav", + "text": "其他方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/628.wav", + "text": "危害證券交易所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/629.wav", + "text": "我覺得處三年以上沒什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/630.wav", + "text": "證交所無法正常運作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/631.wav", + "text": "假如這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/632.wav", + "text": "證券市場不是存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/633.wav", + "text": "好久都這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/634.wav", + "text": "因為以前沒有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/635.wav", + "text": "我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/636.wav", + "text": "你說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/637.wav", + "text": "證券交易所和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/638.wav", + "text": "證券櫃檯買賣中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/639.wav", + "text": "其他那22個其實也都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/640.wav", + "text": "滿重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/641.wav", + "text": "也就是說把它挑選出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/642.wav", + "text": "治療傳染病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/643.wav", + "text": "中都不要規定的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/644.wav", + "text": "就是適用刑法第3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/645.wav", + "text": "一年以上七年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/646.wav", + "text": "因為本來第305條的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/647.wav", + "text": "是規定無故輸入他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/648.wav", + "text": "處三年以下有期徒刑第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/649.wav", + "text": "305條是處五年以下有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/650.wav", + "text": "第306條是處三年以下有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/651.wav", + "text": "處一年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/652.wav", + "text": "七年以下有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/653.wav", + "text": "就是因為若是處五年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/654.wav", + "text": "三年以下三年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/655.wav", + "text": "成一年以上七年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/656.wav", + "text": "就不能易科罰金了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/657.wav", + "text": "七年以下也就是可以判到七年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/658.wav", + "text": "因為這些機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/659.wav", + "text": "(構)比較重要所以這裡已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/660.wav", + "text": "意圖危害國家安全或社會安定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/661.wav", + "text": "定犯前二項之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/662.wav", + "text": "者處三年至十年就是你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/663.wav", + "text": "那個所以更嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/664.wav", + "text": "就會處三年至十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/665.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/666.wav", + "text": "我還可以讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/667.wav", + "text": "這些東西真的都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/668.wav", + "text": "危及股票市場的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/669.wav", + "text": "我也不堅持如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/670.wav", + "text": "如果你們執政黨都不care我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/671.wav", + "text": "們在野黨管你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/672.wav", + "text": "至少罰金科五百萬元以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/673.wav", + "text": "老柯你講你要提高到多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/674.wav", + "text": "經濟犯罪科五百萬元誰理你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/675.wav", + "text": "才五百萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/676.wav", + "text": "而已若說這是刑事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/677.wav", + "text": "犯罪但我也是好意提出來要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/678.wav", + "text": "你們執政黨都不care我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/679.wav", + "text": "還管你咧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/680.wav", + "text": "讓我講一下好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/681.wav", + "text": "上禮拜五我們通過了選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/682.wav", + "text": "剛才邱顯智委員談到了刑法的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/683.wav", + "text": "而我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/684.wav", + "text": "國民黨也都有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/685.wav", + "text": "的加重詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/686.wav", + "text": "深偽進行網路詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/687.wav", + "text": "那個已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/688.wav", + "text": "加重詐欺罪是處一年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/689.wav", + "text": "\n另外我們和國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/690.wav", + "text": "不一樣的地方是我們再提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/691.wav", + "text": "了一個刑法第302條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/692.wav", + "text": "都是加重詐欺罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/693.wav", + "text": "三人以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/694.wav", + "text": "就是加重詐欺現在都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/695.wav", + "text": "改為三人以上就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/696.wav", + "text": "然後有限制自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/697.wav", + "text": "或是凌虐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/698.wav", + "text": "凌虐這個就是一上七下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/699.wav", + "text": "加重詐欺的罪就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/700.wav", + "text": "剛才邱顯智講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/701.wav", + "text": "有關刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/702.wav", + "text": "每個法都有它的法邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/703.wav", + "text": "以及理論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/704.wav", + "text": "現在就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/705.wav", + "text": "我記得這個也是一上七下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/706.wav", + "text": "已經加重過去沒有這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/707.wav", + "text": "我不知道我講錯的話法務部再指導一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/708.wav", + "text": "我們禮拜五剛剛通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/709.wav", + "text": "的選罷法就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/710.wav", + "text": "我們提了刑法第302" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/711.wav", + "text": "柬埔寨條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/712.wav", + "text": "有關於結合犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/713.wav", + "text": "那個後來委員會都沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/714.wav", + "text": "也沒有送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/715.wav", + "text": "曾委員我印象中所及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/716.wav", + "text": "國民黨說要有一致性的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/717.wav", + "text": "點你現在是要多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/718.wav", + "text": "選罷法上個禮拜通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/719.wav", + "text": "緩刑都不能都終身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/720.wav", + "text": "討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/721.wav", + "text": "裡面有這個加重詐欺的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/722.wav", + "text": "加重詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/723.wav", + "text": "一般是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/724.wav", + "text": "緩刑終身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/725.wav", + "text": "選罷法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/726.wav", + "text": "我們有提到犯加重詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/727.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/728.wav", + "text": "聽你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/729.wav", + "text": "刑期不動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/730.wav", + "text": "防制是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/731.wav", + "text": "跟主席及各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/732.wav", + "text": "我們刑法的設計是有層級性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/733.wav", + "text": "的嚴重性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/734.wav", + "text": "就失去它的衡平性了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/735.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/736.wav", + "text": "7的構成要件寫的是危害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/737.wav", + "text": "具體危險犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/738.wav", + "text": "還不是實害犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/739.wav", + "text": "好啦我具體建議1,200啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/740.wav", + "text": "是這個是危險犯不是實害犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/741.wav", + "text": "危險犯和實害犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/742.wav", + "text": "是不一樣的層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/743.wav", + "text": "那個是定上限啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/744.wav", + "text": "最簡單的舉例就是比方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/745.wav", + "text": "意圖要殺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/746.wav", + "text": "殺人預備及已經著手殺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/747.wav", + "text": "也是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/748.wav", + "text": "的部分是不是請各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/749.wav", + "text": "層級性的考量衡平性的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/750.wav", + "text": "來做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/751.wav", + "text": "至於決定多少金額我們還是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/752.wav", + "text": "大院的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/753.wav", + "text": "刑度是不動啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/754.wav", + "text": "但是現在是罰金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/755.wav", + "text": "的部分要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/756.wav", + "text": "召金融業務你熟悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/757.wav", + "text": "我現在在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/758.wav", + "text": "證交法後面的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/759.wav", + "text": "它大概都是2億以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/760.wav", + "text": "的就是看它裡面的你也不能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/761.wav", + "text": "不在它的體例內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/762.wav", + "text": "兆豐銀行疑似洗錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/763.wav", + "text": "被罰多少57億臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/764.wav", + "text": "那是美國罰的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/765.wav", + "text": "啊對呀就等你講這句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/766.wav", + "text": "所以我們也要提高啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/767.wav", + "text": "針對這一條就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/768.wav", + "text": "針對這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/769.wav", + "text": "金管會我請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/770.wav", + "text": "我在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/771.wav", + "text": "證交法第107條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/772.wav", + "text": "一樣是一年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/773.wav", + "text": "七年以下就得併科" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/774.wav", + "text": "所以你們有沒有去對過在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/775.wav", + "text": "證交法裡面在這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/776.wav", + "text": "本來已經有罰金的體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/777.wav", + "text": "他是故意犯又是關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/778.wav", + "text": "基礎設施的你們至少要比這個高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/779.wav", + "text": "兩個去對一下比較合理嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/780.wav", + "text": "證交法很少修啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/781.wav", + "text": "罰金我們修過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/782.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/783.wav", + "text": "那不知道在罰什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/784.wav", + "text": "後有調過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/785.wav", + "text": "後來我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/786.wav", + "text": "財委會銀行法部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/787.wav", + "text": "的罰鍰大部分都調過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/788.wav", + "text": "曾委員這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/789.wav", + "text": "後面意圖影響安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/790.wav", + "text": "如果影響穩定市場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/791.wav", + "text": "好就這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/792.wav", + "text": "只有證交法是1,003" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/793.wav", + "text": "3個啦其他2個比照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/794.wav", + "text": "你認為其他的沒那麼嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/795.wav", + "text": "當初體例是一致性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/796.wav", + "text": "這樣改以後就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/797.wav", + "text": "全部通過了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/798.wav", + "text": "這樣啦22案都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/799.wav", + "text": "因為都有一個套路了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/800.wav", + "text": "要不要看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/801.wav", + "text": "下來遇到其他部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/802.wav", + "text": "我們好那就好這樣就決定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/803.wav", + "text": "寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/804.wav", + "text": "後面還有看總共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/805.wav", + "text": "2個對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/806.wav", + "text": "我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/807.wav", + "text": "證交法這3案有這樣一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/808.wav", + "text": "方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/809.wav", + "text": "所以是不是其他部會你們趕快自己去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/810.wav", + "text": "這些關鍵基礎設施的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/811.wav", + "text": "還有大眾捷運法鐵路法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/812.wav", + "text": "你們都去想想看怎麼調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/813.wav", + "text": "刑度不太動啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/814.wav", + "text": "因為刑度已經加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/815.wav", + "text": "但是罰金要去動啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/816.wav", + "text": "我跟大家報告請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/817.wav", + "text": "大家聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/818.wav", + "text": "如果有不同意見再提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/819.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/820.wav", + "text": "一證券交易法增訂第107條之3及第107條之4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/821.wav", + "text": "均照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/822.wav", + "text": "詳如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/823.wav", + "text": "\n二銀行法增訂第102條之7及第102條之8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/824.wav", + "text": "均照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/825.wav", + "text": "詳如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/826.wav", + "text": "\n三期貨交易法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/827.wav", + "text": "增訂第一百十二條之1及第一百十二條之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/828.wav", + "text": "均照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/829.wav", + "text": "\n協商結論簽好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/830.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/831.wav", + "text": "接下來我們就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/832.wav", + "text": "研商經濟委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/833.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/834.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/835.wav", + "text": "現在我們要研商的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/836.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會的強化關鍵基礎設施保護法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/837.wav", + "text": "一共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/838.wav", + "text": "我介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/839.wav", + "text": "列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/840.wav", + "text": "王美花女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/841.wav", + "text": "數位發展部資通安全署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/842.wav", + "text": "林春吟女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/843.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們就開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/844.wav", + "text": "針對這6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/845.wav", + "text": "一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/846.wav", + "text": "柯你提示一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/847.wav", + "text": "他就會聽你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/848.wav", + "text": "現在是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/849.wav", + "text": "在經濟委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/850.wav", + "text": "我們改成1,00" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/851.wav", + "text": "0了其他加重的部分都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/852.wav", + "text": "時力有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/853.wav", + "text": "就照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/854.wav", + "text": "都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/855.wav", + "text": "支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/856.wav", + "text": "6個案都照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/857.wav", + "text": "其他沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/858.wav", + "text": "了吧6個案都一起通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/859.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/860.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/861.wav", + "text": "第一案至第六案照協商條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/862.wav", + "text": "其餘條文均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/863.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/864.wav", + "text": "不多要準備一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/865.wav", + "text": "傳染病防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/866.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/867.wav", + "text": "因為部長已經來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/868.wav", + "text": "順便問他一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/869.wav", + "text": "就是賴副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/870.wav", + "text": "昨天在回答學生問題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/871.wav", + "text": "有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/872.wav", + "text": "如果兩岸爆發戰爭遭封鎖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/873.wav", + "text": "臺灣陷入能源缺口時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/874.wav", + "text": "相關單位正在規劃如何把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/875.wav", + "text": "已停機的核能機組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/876.wav", + "text": "緊急使用以備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/877.wav", + "text": "不時之用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/878.wav", + "text": "這個部分可否請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/879.wav", + "text": "進一步的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/880.wav", + "text": "或是澄清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/881.wav", + "text": "因為大家也會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/882.wav", + "text": "這樣的講法是否表示要延長或修改現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/883.wav", + "text": "除役計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/884.wav", + "text": "就現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/885.wav", + "text": "還沒有到期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/886.wav", + "text": "所以還在運轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/887.wav", + "text": "核一核二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/888.wav", + "text": "是已經運轉到期了沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/889.wav", + "text": "但是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/890.wav", + "text": "這個乾貯設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/891.wav", + "text": "不是還不能啟用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/892.wav", + "text": "就是還沒有開始興建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/893.wav", + "text": "政府相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/894.wav", + "text": "執照或許可我們還沒拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/895.wav", + "text": "但是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/896.wav", + "text": "爐心裡面的燃料棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/897.wav", + "text": "確實還拿不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/898.wav", + "text": "所以台電就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/899.wav", + "text": "核一核二的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/900.wav", + "text": "還是會做安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/901.wav", + "text": "維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/902.wav", + "text": "這是第一個現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/903.wav", + "text": "昨天學生問到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/904.wav", + "text": "極端的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/905.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/906.wav", + "text": "發生重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/907.wav", + "text": "天災等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/908.wav", + "text": "針對這樣的外來極端狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/909.wav", + "text": "所造成的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/910.wav", + "text": "如果有這樣緊急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/911.wav", + "text": "需要的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/912.wav", + "text": "在政府裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/913.wav", + "text": "就整個政府的韌性來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/914.wav", + "text": "能源的韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/915.wav", + "text": "也是非常重要的一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/916.wav", + "text": "所以我們在討論的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/917.wav", + "text": "維護國家的能源安全下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/918.wav", + "text": "怎麼使用既有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/919.wav", + "text": "再生能源等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/920.wav", + "text": "當然也有討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/921.wav", + "text": "的很緊急的核能狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/922.wav", + "text": "觸及到核能反應器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/923.wav", + "text": "設施的管制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/924.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/925.wav", + "text": "也需要核能的安全主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/926.wav", + "text": "及核能專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/927.wav", + "text": "大家來研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/928.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能在非常特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/929.wav", + "text": "而且如果在這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/930.wav", + "text": "使用方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/931.wav", + "text": "但是這個部分一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/932.wav", + "text": "會包括立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/933.wav", + "text": "溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/934.wav", + "text": "包括社會的共識等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/935.wav", + "text": "非常極端的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/936.wav", + "text": "這個要怎麼去討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/937.wav", + "text": "所以這個講法並不表示要延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/938.wav", + "text": "或修改現有的除役計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/939.wav", + "text": "也就是說政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/940.wav", + "text": "非核家園的立場應該是不變的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/941.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/942.wav", + "text": "院裡面有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/943.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/944.wav", + "text": "賴副總統的講法它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/945.wav", + "text": "它的狀態是2025" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/946.wav", + "text": "之後還是2025" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/947.wav", + "text": "沒講喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/948.wav", + "text": "我的理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/949.wav", + "text": "是確實沒有特別講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/950.wav", + "text": "但是因為現在核二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/951.wav", + "text": "因為現在核心裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/952.wav", + "text": "的燃料棒還沒有拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/953.wav", + "text": "反應爐的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/954.wav", + "text": "還是做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/955.wav", + "text": "安全的維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/956.wav", + "text": "我看到的是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/957.wav", + "text": "特別講是什麼時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/958.wav", + "text": "沒有錯喔因為賴副總統講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/959.wav", + "text": "除役之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/960.wav", + "text": "但是維持在可用狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/961.wav", + "text": "萬一有緊急狀況可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/962.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/963.wav", + "text": "極端狀態的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/964.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/965.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/966.wav", + "text": "你怎麼認為是用極端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/967.wav", + "text": "就我的理解賴副總統講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/968.wav", + "text": "沒有特別極端喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/969.wav", + "text": "你否決了賴副總統的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/970.wav", + "text": "他講話沒有很極端喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/971.wav", + "text": "他說除役之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/972.wav", + "text": "現在不是委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/973.wav", + "text": "大家一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/974.wav", + "text": "講很極端的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/975.wav", + "text": "學生的題目就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/976.wav", + "text": "我想請教最後一題部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/977.wav", + "text": "你們有開過相關的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/978.wav", + "text": "是什麼時候召開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/979.wav", + "text": "讓我們知道就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/980.wav", + "text": "就是它有召開緊急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/981.wav", + "text": "備用計畫的會議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/982.wav", + "text": "什麼時候開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/983.wav", + "text": "整個國家的韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/984.wav", + "text": "包括供應鏈韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/985.wav", + "text": "在國家裡面就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/986.wav", + "text": "有討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/987.wav", + "text": "這個會議很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/988.wav", + "text": "包括物資供應產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/989.wav", + "text": "都有討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/990.wav", + "text": "我的問題你還沒答復我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/991.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/992.wav", + "text": "賴副總統沒有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/993.wav", + "text": "他的前提是說除役之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/994.wav", + "text": "維持它的可用狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/995.wav", + "text": "隨時可以救援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/996.wav", + "text": "那我請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/997.wav", + "text": "它維持在可用狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/998.wav", + "text": "維護成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/999.wav", + "text": "非常巨大你有沒有評估過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1000.wav", + "text": "確實學生問的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1001.wav", + "text": "臺灣被封鎖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1002.wav", + "text": "學生確實是這樣問的沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1003.wav", + "text": "所以他是順著學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1004.wav", + "text": "這樣的詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1005.wav", + "text": "在回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1006.wav", + "text": "要怎麼處理的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1007.wav", + "text": "機關還有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1008.wav", + "text": "技術性及各種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1009.wav", + "text": "可行性的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1010.wav", + "text": "這個部分還有包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1011.wav", + "text": "我是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1012.wav", + "text": "中華民國不要被封鎖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1013.wav", + "text": "打從心裡面希望這種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1014.wav", + "text": "不要發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1015.wav", + "text": "但是你不曉得什麼時候發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1016.wav", + "text": "學生講的是被封鎖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1017.wav", + "text": "那它2025年之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1018.wav", + "text": "就除役了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1019.wav", + "text": "了你要維持到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1020.wav", + "text": "可用狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1021.wav", + "text": "那成本很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1022.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1023.wav", + "text": "核子安全主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1024.wav", + "text": "維護的成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1025.wav", + "text": "到什麼安全階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1026.wav", + "text": "是要由他們肯認的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1027.wav", + "text": "還是回歸本題謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1028.wav", + "text": "另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1029.wav", + "text": "繼續研商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1030.wav", + "text": "也是強化關鍵基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1031.wav", + "text": "設施保護法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1032.wav", + "text": "交通的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1033.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1034.wav", + "text": "民用航空法商港法氣象法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1035.wav", + "text": "鐵路法公路法郵政法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1036.wav", + "text": "大眾捷運法電信管理法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1037.wav", + "text": "介紹一下列席首" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1038.wav", + "text": "交通部政務次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1039.wav", + "text": "陳彥伯先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1040.wav", + "text": "國家通訊傳播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1041.wav", + "text": "委員會主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1042.wav", + "text": "陳耀祥先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1043.wav", + "text": "我們現在就來開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1044.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1045.wav", + "text": "我想就跟剛才一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1046.wav", + "text": "500萬變1,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1047.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1048.wav", + "text": "這樣子就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1049.wav", + "text": "陳耀祥先離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1050.wav", + "text": "我唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1051.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1052.wav", + "text": "一民用航空法第101條之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1053.wav", + "text": "一百十九條之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1054.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1055.wav", + "text": "等2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1056.wav", + "text": "二商港法增訂部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1057.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案等2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1058.wav", + "text": "三氣象法部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1059.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1060.wav", + "text": "等2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1061.wav", + "text": "四鐵路法部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1062.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案等4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1063.wav", + "text": "五公路法部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1064.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案等2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1065.wav", + "text": "六郵政法第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1066.wav", + "text": "第35條之1第35條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1067.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1068.wav", + "text": "大眾捷運法部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1069.wav", + "text": "等3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1070.wav", + "text": "八電信管理法第72條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1071.wav", + "text": "第72條之一第95條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1072.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1073.wav", + "text": "等3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1074.wav", + "text": "以上各案均照協商內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1075.wav", + "text": "我簽主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1076.wav", + "text": "可不可以有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1077.wav", + "text": "通過就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1078.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1079.wav", + "text": "不用講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1080.wav", + "text": "果決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1081.wav", + "text": "我說你果決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1082.wav", + "text": "那個我們會幫你修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1083.wav", + "text": "沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1084.wav", + "text": "啦就是交通部這邊裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1085.wav", + "text": "有文字以前叫做資訊設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1086.wav", + "text": "的現在都改成資通設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1087.wav", + "text": "議事人員處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1088.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1089.wav", + "text": "醫療法等3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1090.wav", + "text": "我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1091.wav", + "text": "我們繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1092.wav", + "text": "衛生福利部的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1093.wav", + "text": "是有關醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1094.wav", + "text": "全民健康保險法傳染病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1095.wav", + "text": "防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1096.wav", + "text": "等3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1097.wav", + "text": "\n我現在介紹列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1098.wav", + "text": "衛生福利部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1099.wav", + "text": "政務次長王必勝先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1100.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1101.wav", + "text": "醫療法等3案大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1102.wav", + "text": "一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1103.wav", + "text": "有同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1104.wav", + "text": "賴委員同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1105.wav", + "text": "\n協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1106.wav", + "text": "一醫療法增訂第105條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1107.wav", + "text": "之1及第105" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1108.wav", + "text": "條之2條文草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1109.wav", + "text": "案均照協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1110.wav", + "text": "全民健康保險法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1111.wav", + "text": "增訂第8條之1及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1112.wav", + "text": "第8條之2條文草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1113.wav", + "text": "案均照協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1114.wav", + "text": "條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1115.wav", + "text": "增訂第61條之1及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1116.wav", + "text": "第61條之2條文草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1117.wav", + "text": "案案均照協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1118.wav", + "text": "條文通過如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1119.wav", + "text": "協商結論是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1120.wav", + "text": "了有關傳染病防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1121.wav", + "text": "傳染病防治法第74條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1122.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1123.wav", + "text": "有關延長兩年請求權的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1124.wav", + "text": "好我宣告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1125.wav", + "text": "請大家聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1126.wav", + "text": "行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1127.wav", + "text": "傳染病防治法增訂第74條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1128.wav", + "text": "之1條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1129.wav", + "text": "照行政院提案條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1130.wav", + "text": "大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1131.wav", + "text": "傳染病防治法第74條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1132.wav", + "text": "這一條是新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1133.wav", + "text": "嚴重特殊傳染性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1134.wav", + "text": "肺炎防治及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1135.wav", + "text": "紓困" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1136.wav", + "text": "振興特別條例實施期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1137.wav", + "text": "符合該條例所定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1138.wav", + "text": "防疫補償要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1139.wav", + "text": "而未於該條例實施期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1140.wav", + "text": "屆滿前申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1141.wav", + "text": "且其兩年請求權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1142.wav", + "text": "時效尚未完成者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1143.wav", + "text": "於該條例實施期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1144.wav", + "text": "屆滿兩年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1145.wav", + "text": "仍得依該條例規定申請防疫補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1146.wav", + "text": "\n內容沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1147.wav", + "text": "但是修在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1148.wav", + "text": "法制上有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1149.wav", + "text": "這個東西你要修到特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1150.wav", + "text": "怎麼會在傳染病防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1151.wav", + "text": "我的想法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1152.wav", + "text": "部分它不得不修在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1153.wav", + "text": "所以它不能夠在那個條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1154.wav", + "text": "放這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1155.wav", + "text": "必須要放在傳染病防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1156.wav", + "text": "內容大家同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1157.wav", + "text": "嘛因為這確實是一個請求權的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1158.wav", + "text": "條例雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1159.wav", + "text": "已經失效了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1160.wav", + "text": "但是在請求權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1161.wav", + "text": "時效尚未完成的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1162.wav", + "text": "你依然可以在這個期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1163.wav", + "text": "受疫情影響的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1164.wav", + "text": "基本上也能夠顧慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1165.wav", + "text": "他的請求權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1166.wav", + "text": "然後在這個規定裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1167.wav", + "text": "還是可以申請防疫補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1168.wav", + "text": "我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1169.wav", + "text": "大方向我贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1170.wav", + "text": "那個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1171.wav", + "text": "要到6月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1172.wav", + "text": "失效的時候你們就要想到這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1173.wav", + "text": "你們不能到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1174.wav", + "text": "但是顯然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1175.wav", + "text": "是衛福部失職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1176.wav", + "text": "對不對它沒想到這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1177.wav", + "text": "修在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1178.wav", + "text": "是不得不的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1179.wav", + "text": "6月底就失效了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1180.wav", + "text": "本條例沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1181.wav", + "text": "修卻要修到傳染病防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1182.wav", + "text": "這很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1183.wav", + "text": "但是這真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1184.wav", + "text": "是你沒注意到但不用道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1185.wav", + "text": "了因為你們道歉也不值錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1186.wav", + "text": "你至少說你沒注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1187.wav", + "text": "我接受好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1188.wav", + "text": "防疫的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1189.wav", + "text": "然後這個請求權時效是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1190.wav", + "text": "6月30日以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1191.wav", + "text": "的兩年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1192.wav", + "text": "不對第一個是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1193.wav", + "text": "把日期明列會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1194.wav", + "text": "\n第二個想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1195.wav", + "text": "還是沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1196.wav", + "text": "這個時間到了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1197.wav", + "text": "會不會還是可能有救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1198.wav", + "text": "務實來看這是一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1199.wav", + "text": "我們整個請次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1200.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1201.wav", + "text": "是我先回答賴委員問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1202.wav", + "text": "它指的是被居家隔離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1203.wav", + "text": "或居家檢疫產生的防疫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1204.wav", + "text": "是接種救濟那是要經過判定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1205.wav", + "text": "不受這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1206.wav", + "text": "所以這個是另外一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1207.wav", + "text": "\n再回答曾總召的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1208.wav", + "text": "這個部分其實我們一直都有想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1209.wav", + "text": "疫情什麼時候會結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1210.wav", + "text": "居家檢疫居家隔離在去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1211.wav", + "text": "11月的時候就已經都停止了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1212.wav", + "text": "但是我們不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1213.wav", + "text": "它什麼時候會結束所以必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1214.wav", + "text": "產生的這些相關補償費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1215.wav", + "text": "所以我們把它放在第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1216.wav", + "text": "COVID-19本身在那個時間點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1217.wav", + "text": "第五類傳染病所以把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1218.wav", + "text": "放在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1219.wav", + "text": "防疫紓困條例到6月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1220.wav", + "text": "屆止嗎當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1221.wav", + "text": "在審說要6月底屆止的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1222.wav", + "text": "你就要注意這個問題啊你那時候沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1223.wav", + "text": "注意到對不對我們那時候其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1224.wav", + "text": "已經在準備修法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1225.wav", + "text": "傳染病防治法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1226.wav", + "text": "是要修很多條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1227.wav", + "text": "討論等等那是在那個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1228.wav", + "text": "就有在進行作業但是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1229.wav", + "text": "有很多條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1230.wav", + "text": "後來我們就決定因為時效的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1231.wav", + "text": "先就這一條之後再去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1232.wav", + "text": "修其他的條文是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1233.wav", + "text": "當初在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1234.wav", + "text": "COVID-19的期間有非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1235.wav", + "text": "多疫苗的受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1236.wav", + "text": "受害救濟的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1237.wav", + "text": "審理等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1238.wav", + "text": "這個有沒有包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1239.wav", + "text": "疫苗受害的救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1240.wav", + "text": "怎麼處理以及你們現在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1241.wav", + "text": "的進度如何因為當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1242.wav", + "text": "的速度非常緩慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1243.wav", + "text": "你們當初也答應過要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1244.wav", + "text": "的進度是如何報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1245.wav", + "text": "連的部分跟這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1246.wav", + "text": "是沒有關係它沒有兩年的時限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1247.wav", + "text": "限就是等到判定出來結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1248.wav", + "text": "如果是需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1249.wav", + "text": "補償的那就給補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1250.wav", + "text": "跟這個沒有關連沒有兩年的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1251.wav", + "text": "所以沒有放在這裡面就算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1252.wav", + "text": "是這個特別條例結束了也不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1253.wav", + "text": "有這個問題\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1254.wav", + "text": "也順便報告一下我們現在的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1255.wav", + "text": "答應於兩年內處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1256.wav", + "text": "到的數字都會把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1257.wav", + "text": "處理到我們現在也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1258.wav", + "text": "請地方政府一起幫忙調病歷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1259.wav", + "text": "歷審議這些相關的病例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1260.wav", + "text": "都在處理當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1261.wav", + "text": "薛部長答應本席兩年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1262.wav", + "text": "進度非常地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1263.wav", + "text": "慢啊我們開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1264.wav", + "text": "56次記者會他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1265.wav", + "text": "也不理我們啊後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1266.wav", + "text": "總質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1267.wav", + "text": "薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1268.wav", + "text": "答應我們兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1269.wav", + "text": "還有一年多可以做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1270.wav", + "text": "他那時候答應的數字會做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1271.wav", + "text": "但是因為後面還有增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1272.wav", + "text": "那個部分我們還會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1273.wav", + "text": "其實沒有這麼多這些專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1274.wav", + "text": "有在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1275.wav", + "text": "我們在院會做過主決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1276.wav", + "text": "好加油啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1277.wav", + "text": "\n這個案就照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1278.wav", + "text": "提案條文通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1279.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1280.wav", + "text": "\n從速離開好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1281.wav", + "text": "脫離現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1282.wav", + "text": "不然等一下變成委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1283.wav", + "text": "明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1284.wav", + "text": "還有一個貨物稅啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1285.wav", + "text": "曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1286.wav", + "text": "明天我們10點開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1287.wav", + "text": "還有一個貨物稅我等一下再跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1288.wav", + "text": "那後天表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1289.wav", + "text": "10點開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1290.wav", + "text": "九百零多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1291.wav", + "text": "大後天表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1292.wav", + "text": "差不多一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1293.wav", + "text": "6月中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1294.wav", + "text": "一個禮拜就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1295.wav", + "text": "應該是14日到21" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1296.wav", + "text": "日22日端午節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1297.wav", + "text": "嘛投票而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1298.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1299.wav", + "text": "你們講好就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1300.wav", + "text": "接下來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1301.wav", + "text": "國科會跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1302.wav", + "text": "原能會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1303.wav", + "text": "今天列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1304.wav", + "text": "首先介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1305.wav", + "text": "再來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1306.wav", + "text": "原能會主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1307.wav", + "text": "張靜文女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1308.wav", + "text": "研商的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1309.wav", + "text": "應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1310.wav", + "text": "沒有特別意見吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1311.wav", + "text": "這大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1312.wav", + "text": "因為關鍵基礎設施總共有22個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1313.wav", + "text": "你們是最後一組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1314.wav", + "text": "萬全部統一好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1315.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1316.wav", + "text": "協商結論一協商通過條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1317.wav", + "text": "太空發展法第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1318.wav", + "text": "之1及第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1319.wav", + "text": "之二核子事故緊急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1320.wav", + "text": "應變法第三十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1321.wav", + "text": "二維持現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1322.wav", + "text": "太空發展法第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1323.wav", + "text": "及核子事故緊急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1324.wav", + "text": "應變法第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1325.wav", + "text": "三其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1326.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1327.wav", + "text": "國營事業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1328.wav", + "text": "剩一個貨物稅條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15075/1329.wav", + "text": "到期了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15074/0.wav", + "text": "個調閱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15074/1.wav", + "text": "我們但是現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15074/2.wav", + "text": "均照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15074/3.wav", + "text": "第105條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15074/4.wav", + "text": "其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15073/0.wav", + "text": "協商會議現在開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15073/1.wav", + "text": "上任了第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15073/2.wav", + "text": "這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15073/3.wav", + "text": "去所以是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15073/4.wav", + "text": "意見我們就這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15073/5.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15070/0.wav", + "text": "進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15070/1.wav", + "text": "職人員選舉罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15070/2.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15070/3.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15068/0.wav", + "text": "08條條文修正草案文字上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15068/1.wav", + "text": "這邊散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15069/0.wav", + "text": "沒有\n今" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/0.wav", + "text": "公職人員選舉罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/1.wav", + "text": "第108條修正案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/2.wav", + "text": "黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/3.wav", + "text": "本修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/4.wav", + "text": "在今年5月3日跟4日詢答並審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/5.wav", + "text": "也已提報院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/6.wav", + "text": "看看國民黨等一下會不會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/7.wav", + "text": "我先請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/8.wav", + "text": "針對公職人員選舉罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/9.wav", + "text": "第108條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/10.wav", + "text": "文字上有沒有要再修正的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15067/11.wav", + "text": "員對公職人員選舉罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15062/0.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案及刑事訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15062/1.wav", + "text": "送院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15062/2.wav", + "text": "03十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15062/3.wav", + "text": "秘書長所提協" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15062/4.wav", + "text": "書長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15062/5.wav", + "text": "兩位委員也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15062/6.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15062/7.wav", + "text": "協商完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15062/8.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/0.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/1.wav", + "text": "及刑事訴訟法施行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/2.wav", + "text": "增訂第7條之6條文草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/3.wav", + "text": "共計兩個主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/4.wav", + "text": "稍後按協商通知排序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/5.wav", + "text": "依序進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/6.wav", + "text": "現在逐案進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/7.wav", + "text": "協商時請參閱審查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/8.wav", + "text": "關係文書與會委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/9.wav", + "text": "如有修正動議或機關有建議內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/10.wav", + "text": "請提書面印發現場進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/11.wav", + "text": "協商刑事訴訟法部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/12.wav", + "text": "等兩案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/13.wav", + "text": "審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/14.wav", + "text": "前於5月10日審查完竣審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/15.wav", + "text": "為第208條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/16.wav", + "text": "及第307條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/17.wav", + "text": "均保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/18.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/19.wav", + "text": "其餘均有審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/20.wav", + "text": "並決議院會��論前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/21.wav", + "text": "須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/22.wav", + "text": "與會機關代表說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/23.wav", + "text": "並請出席委員討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/24.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/25.wav", + "text": "規範獨任範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/26.wav", + "text": "這兩項條文本來是連結的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/27.wav", + "text": "針對獨任的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/28.wav", + "text": "在第2款加上第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/29.wav", + "text": "207條第1項之傷害罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/30.wav", + "text": "第3款是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/31.wav", + "text": "第5款加上第304條第1項之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/32.wav", + "text": "第6款加上毒品條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/33.wav", + "text": "第10條第1項之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/34.wav", + "text": "施用第一級毒品罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/35.wav", + "text": "第十一條第四項之持有第二級毒品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/36.wav", + "text": "純質淨重二十公克以上罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/37.wav", + "text": "刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/38.wav", + "text": "詐欺罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/39.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/40.wav", + "text": "跟它有裁判上一罪關係之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/41.wav", + "text": "違反洗錢防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/42.wav", + "text": "第十四條第十五條之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/43.wav", + "text": "在第八款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/44.wav", + "text": "新修的洗錢防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/45.wav", + "text": "第十五條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/46.wav", + "text": "之無正當理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/47.wav", + "text": "收集帳戶帳號罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/48.wav", + "text": "法院認為案情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/49.wav", + "text": "繁雜或有特殊情形者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/50.wav", + "text": "於第一次審判期日前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/51.wav", + "text": "經聽取當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/52.wav", + "text": "辯護人代理人及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/53.wav", + "text": "輔佐人之意見後得行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/54.wav", + "text": "合議審判就是一種轉軌的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/55.wav", + "text": "設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/56.wav", + "text": "我們在第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/57.wav", + "text": "第2款加上第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/58.wav", + "text": "207條第1項之傷害罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/59.wav", + "text": "第9款加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/60.wav", + "text": "毒品條例第10條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/61.wav", + "text": "之施用第一級毒品罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/62.wav", + "text": "第十一條第四項之持有第二級毒品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/63.wav", + "text": "純質淨重二十公克以上罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/64.wav", + "text": "就是這兩款而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/65.wav", + "text": "發回原審法院之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/66.wav", + "text": "發交其他第二審法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/67.wav", + "text": "這樣的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/68.wav", + "text": "這些部分是我們已經與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/69.wav", + "text": "與法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/70.wav", + "text": "談妥的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/71.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/72.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/73.wav", + "text": "秘書長已經說明完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/74.wav", + "text": "法務部是否有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/75.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/76.wav", + "text": "提案的修正動議一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/77.wav", + "text": "好謝謝\n兩位委員有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/78.wav", + "text": "沒有的話我們是不是就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/79.wav", + "text": "\n好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/80.wav", + "text": "\n處理第307條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/81.wav", + "text": "\n請林秘書長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/82.wav", + "text": "跟主席報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/83.wav", + "text": "兩位委員也沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/84.wav", + "text": "刑事訴訟法施行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/85.wav", + "text": "增訂第7條之6條文草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/86.wav", + "text": "審查會一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/87.wav", + "text": "在5月10日審查完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/88.wav", + "text": "之6保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/89.wav", + "text": "增訂第7條之6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/90.wav", + "text": "是不是能請本院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/91.wav", + "text": "李廳長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/92.wav", + "text": "在施行法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/93.wav", + "text": "一併授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/94.wav", + "text": "好了解\n請陳次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/95.wav", + "text": "一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/96.wav", + "text": "一刑事訴訟法部分條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/97.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/98.wav", + "text": "第208條之1及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/99.wav", + "text": "第307條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/100.wav", + "text": "均照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/101.wav", + "text": "如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/102.wav", + "text": "其餘均照審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/103.wav", + "text": "會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/104.wav", + "text": "\n二刑事訴訟法施行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/105.wav", + "text": "照司法院行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/106.wav", + "text": "請出席委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/107.wav", + "text": "我們已經協商完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/108.wav", + "text": "你就要離開了要不要講幾句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/109.wav", + "text": "還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/110.wav", + "text": "非常感謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/111.wav", + "text": "與各位委員的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/112.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/113.wav", + "text": "也感謝秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/114.wav", + "text": "一直為臺灣的司法改革努力不懈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15061/115.wav", + "text": "謝謝你祝你一路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/0.wav", + "text": "民國112年度中央政府總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/1.wav", + "text": "附屬單位預算及綜計表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/2.wav", + "text": "─營業及非營業部分案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/3.wav", + "text": "現在我們就開始第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/4.wav", + "text": "一案對不對先第一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/5.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/6.wav", + "text": "跟國民黨溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/7.wav", + "text": "我希望大家能夠在今天朝野協商把這個事情先談定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/8.wav", + "text": "下週一週三是委員會時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/9.wav", + "text": "那我們現在很多法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/10.wav", + "text": "包括國營事業等所有法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/11.wav", + "text": "予以完成的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/12.wav", + "text": "已因為很多重大法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/13.wav", + "text": "商看起來還有四十幾個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/14.wav", + "text": "還有國營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/15.wav", + "text": "是不是在這一點上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/16.wav", + "text": "請各黨團能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/17.wav", + "text": "我們加開院會下星期一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/18.wav", + "text": "星期三加開院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/19.wav", + "text": "換言之就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/20.wav", + "text": "本週五到下星期三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/21.wav", + "text": "就算一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/22.wav", + "text": "協商比較能夠有充裕的時間好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/23.wav", + "text": "以上請各黨團能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/24.wav", + "text": "所以要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/25.wav", + "text": "原來是星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/26.wav", + "text": "就加個3天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/27.wav", + "text": "所以就是希望31日休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/28.wav", + "text": "委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/29.wav", + "text": "你的希望是這樣請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/30.wav", + "text": "加開院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/31.wav", + "text": "我們主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/32.wav", + "text": "預算協商完畢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/33.wav", + "text": "院長明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/34.wav", + "text": "就先協商礦業法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/35.wav", + "text": "還有再生能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/36.wav", + "text": "法跟公視法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/37.wav", + "text": "本來星期五二一次會要加開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/38.wav", + "text": "五一二三一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/39.wav", + "text": "原則上民眾黨同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/40.wav", + "text": "簽這一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/41.wav", + "text": "下禮拜是沒有委員會囉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/42.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/43.wav", + "text": "下禮拜不開委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/44.wav", + "text": "都開院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/45.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/46.wav", + "text": "一二三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/47.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/48.wav", + "text": "就下課了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/49.wav", + "text": "要安排出國的趕快出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/50.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/51.wav", + "text": "院長我剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/52.wav", + "text": "是不是回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/53.wav", + "text": "就是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/54.wav", + "text": "就開始協商礦業法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/55.wav", + "text": "再生能源法還有公視法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/56.wav", + "text": "等一下再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/57.wav", + "text": "部分決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/58.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意5月29日(星期一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/59.wav", + "text": ")5月31日(星期三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/60.wav", + "text": ")加開院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/61.wav", + "text": "與5月26日(星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/62.wav", + "text": ")5月30日(星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/63.wav", + "text": ")合併為一次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/64.wav", + "text": "當次會議不處理臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/65.wav", + "text": "國民黨先簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/66.wav", + "text": "週五表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/67.wav", + "text": "第二案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/68.wav", + "text": "第二案我剛才已經唸過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/69.wav", + "text": "但是現在要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/70.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/71.wav", + "text": "既然黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/72.wav", + "text": "那就不介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/73.wav", + "text": "進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/74.wav", + "text": "一共有13案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/75.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/76.wav", + "text": "各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/77.wav", + "text": "上一次本來要審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/78.wav", + "text": "營業非營業基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/79.wav", + "text": "合庫金控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/80.wav", + "text": "的資產管理公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/81.wav", + "text": "超級誇張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/82.wav", + "text": "我相信在座的每一位都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/83.wav", + "text": "贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/84.wav", + "text": "1個董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/85.wav", + "text": "進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/86.wav", + "text": "可以再請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/87.wav", + "text": "其他7個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/88.wav", + "text": "現在財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/89.wav", + "text": "檢查報告出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/90.wav", + "text": "怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/91.wav", + "text": "才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/92.wav", + "text": "符合比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/93.wav", + "text": "也可以符合社會的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/94.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/95.wav", + "text": "或是總召要不要提示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/96.wav", + "text": "部長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/97.wav", + "text": "院長以及各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/98.wav", + "text": "決議要求提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/99.wav", + "text": "本部已經在5月17日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/100.wav", + "text": "依限提出調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/101.wav", + "text": "對於這次調查本部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/102.wav", + "text": "秉持著誠實面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/103.wav", + "text": "在調查報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/104.wav", + "text": "我們對於相關的缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/105.wav", + "text": "這裡面的缺失包含蔡前董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/106.wav", + "text": "任用親信及其子──合庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/107.wav", + "text": "創投的副總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/108.wav", + "text": "與親信出差重疊集中特定區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/109.wav", + "text": "報支不當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/110.wav", + "text": "沒有就關係人建檔落實查核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/111.wav", + "text": "我們也都提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/112.wav", + "text": "具體改進措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/113.wav", + "text": "會要求合庫AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/114.wav", + "text": "同時要求金控也要確實的督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/115.wav", + "text": "針對金控要改進的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/116.wav", + "text": "我們也都提出了改進措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/117.wav", + "text": "也都在這個報告裡面提出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/118.wav", + "text": "因此在這份報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/119.wav", + "text": "並不包庇也不避諱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/120.wav", + "text": "我們會要求他們一定要能夠落實執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/121.wav", + "text": "後續的公股強化管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/122.wav", + "text": "以上是我們在報告裡面所涵蓋的一些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/123.wav", + "text": "也已經在5月17日提送到大院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/124.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/125.wav", + "text": "院長各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/126.wav", + "text": "員及各位與會同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/127.wav", + "text": "合庫金控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/128.wav", + "text": "旗下AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/129.wav", + "text": "跟檢討報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/130.wav", + "text": "我還是覺得這裡面有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/131.wav", + "text": "未盡周詳的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/132.wav", + "text": "嚴重的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/133.wav", + "text": "譬如說在合庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/134.wav", + "text": "金控裡面不單純是它的AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/135.wav", + "text": "興推薦他的兒子到合庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/136.wav", + "text": "金控下面另外一家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/137.wav", + "text": "結果另外一家子公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/138.wav", + "text": "蔡見興的兒子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/139.wav", + "text": "沒有任何的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/140.wav", + "text": "公告沒有任何的甄選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/141.wav", + "text": "資料統統都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/142.wav", + "text": "就直接去上班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/143.wav", + "text": "他們所管理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/144.wav", + "text": "旗下這些子公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/145.wav", + "text": "在人事上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/146.wav", + "text": "有多麼地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/147.wav", + "text": "公器私用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/148.wav", + "text": "這兩個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/149.wav", + "text": "雖然你們有提到一些它的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/150.wav", + "text": "也跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/151.wav", + "text": "一個主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/152.wav", + "text": "再補充你們在這兩份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/153.wav", + "text": "報告裡面的不足之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/154.wav", + "text": "譬如我剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/155.wav", + "text": "公股金控的子公司怎麼可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/156.wav", + "text": "如此私人任用到這種地步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/157.wav", + "text": "他進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/158.wav", + "text": "把他的親信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/159.wav", + "text": "家人等統統都拉進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/160.wav", + "text": "不只如此他還可以推薦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/161.wav", + "text": "別人去其他的子公司任用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/162.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講了連口試筆試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/163.wav", + "text": "什麼試都沒有那個紀錄都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/164.wav", + "text": "所以我在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/165.wav", + "text": "希望未來我們公股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/166.wav", + "text": "金控的子公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/167.wav", + "text": "公開招考的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/168.wav", + "text": "我今天得到一個最新的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/169.wav", + "text": "不只合庫金控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/170.wav", + "text": "連華南金控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/171.wav", + "text": "另外一個也是子公司AMC的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/172.wav", + "text": "董事長請辭了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/173.wav", + "text": "對不對我也知道你們有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/174.wav", + "text": "做一些處理因為我手上有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/175.wav", + "text": "爆料我都還沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/176.wav", + "text": "這裡面還沒有浮上檯面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/177.wav", + "text": "的部分有多少我們只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/178.wav", + "text": "要開始處理要開始瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/179.wav", + "text": "而已確實財政部一介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/180.wav", + "text": "之後當事人就請辭了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/181.wav", + "text": "不能再如此藏污納垢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/182.wav", + "text": "了這是其一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/183.wav", + "text": "\n第二點是關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/184.wav", + "text": "剛剛也有提到事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/185.wav", + "text": "高度集中且具有高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/186.wav", + "text": "風險另外譬如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/187.wav", + "text": "如詐領出差費的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/188.wav", + "text": "的出差費就占一家公司的一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/189.wav", + "text": "這不是很離譜嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/190.wav", + "text": "嘛這邊有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/191.wav", + "text": "背信跟圖利的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/192.wav", + "text": "我們不能只停留在行政上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/193.wav", + "text": "如果連行政報告都發現有這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/194.wav", + "text": "問題我認為就要去追究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/195.wav", + "text": "所以這是第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/196.wav", + "text": "公股金控下面的AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/197.wav", + "text": "特別針對都更危老" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/198.wav", + "text": "的代墊款這是我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/199.wav", + "text": "政策我個人都很支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/200.wav", + "text": "包含銀行及我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/201.wav", + "text": "都更危老的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/202.wav", + "text": "貸款但是你們不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/203.wav", + "text": "亂來這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/204.wav", + "text": "還有根本沒有去向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/205.wav", + "text": "主管機關申請的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/206.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以就把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/207.wav", + "text": "它連申請都沒有去申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/208.wav", + "text": "所以我也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/209.wav", + "text": "你們去加強控管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/210.wav", + "text": "承辦都更危老" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/211.wav", + "text": "不應該貸放\n所以我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/212.wav", + "text": "作出這三點主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/213.wav", + "text": "各黨團能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/214.wav", + "text": "我要再講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/215.wav", + "text": "今天合庫金控的子公司出了這麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/216.wav", + "text": "大的問題合庫金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/217.wav", + "text": "控的董事長雷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/218.wav", + "text": "仲達當然難辭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/219.wav", + "text": "你們現在已經將他內定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/220.wav", + "text": "去兆豐金控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/221.wav", + "text": "當董事長其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/222.wav", + "text": "這是非常不合理的第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/223.wav", + "text": "他已經70歲了早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/224.wav", + "text": "部規定公股公派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/225.wav", + "text": "董事長總經理的年齡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/226.wav", + "text": "他連延任都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/227.wav", + "text": "他現在在避風頭因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/228.wav", + "text": "我們正好在處理所以他大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/229.wav", + "text": "六月中旬還是會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/230.wav", + "text": "走馬上任可是其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/231.wav", + "text": "在出了這麼多包之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/232.wav", + "text": "高升到兆豐金控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/233.wav", + "text": "我覺得這很難說得過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/234.wav", + "text": "要提醒財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/235.wav", + "text": "關於要如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/236.wav", + "text": "公股金控子公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/237.wav", + "text": "這些管理的缺失人事的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/238.wav", + "text": "缺失放款的缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/239.wav", + "text": "本席在這邊有以上三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/240.wav", + "text": "主決議希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/241.wav", + "text": "大家能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/242.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/243.wav", + "text": "本人在財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/244.wav", + "text": "長期主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/245.wav", + "text": "公股管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/246.wav", + "text": "常次政次做了5年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/247.wav", + "text": "就管這個業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/248.wav", + "text": "跟各位報告這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/249.wav", + "text": "用四個字來形容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/250.wav", + "text": "大開眼界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/251.wav", + "text": "大開眼界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/252.wav", + "text": "興是個AMC的董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/253.wav", + "text": "他哪有辦法安排他兒子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/254.wav", + "text": "到合庫金控的關係企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/255.wav", + "text": "沒有替他安排嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/256.wav", + "text": "所以這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/257.wav", + "text": "不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/258.wav", + "text": "8個人都走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/259.wav", + "text": "就沒事喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/260.wav", + "text": "假設這8個人走了就沒事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/261.wav", + "text": "我不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/262.wav", + "text": "我不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/263.wav", + "text": "這一次的營業非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/264.wav", + "text": "營業基金要不要審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/265.wav", + "text": "下個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/266.wav", + "text": "財政部的預算我就不審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/267.wav", + "text": "都讓你全部表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/268.wav", + "text": "財政部誰負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/269.wav", + "text": "8個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/270.wav", + "text": "財政部說這個人走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/271.wav", + "text": "走了就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/272.wav", + "text": "我沒有質詢的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/273.wav", + "text": "你長期在行政機關服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/274.wav", + "text": "當過縣長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/275.wav", + "text": "當過總統府秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/276.wav", + "text": "當過行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/277.wav", + "text": "我只是跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/278.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/279.wav", + "text": "都走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/280.wav", + "text": "這樣就可以結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/281.wav", + "text": "你把中華民國政府當什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/282.wav", + "text": "這個事情沒有給社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/283.wav", + "text": "一個公開合理的交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/284.wav", + "text": "不是這個預算不審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/285.wav", + "text": "下會期的公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/286.wav", + "text": "哪有這種社會哪有這種政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/287.wav", + "text": "財政部放任蔡見興多少年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/288.wav", + "text": "了從1個人可以搞到8個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/289.wav", + "text": "連兒子都進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/290.wav", + "text": "我是不願意講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/291.wav", + "text": "連小三都可以進來當副理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/292.wav", + "text": "這什麼世界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/293.wav", + "text": "他小三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/294.wav", + "text": "有什麼專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/295.wav", + "text": "可以進到合庫的AMC當副理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/296.wav", + "text": "簡直莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/297.wav", + "text": "我再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/298.wav", + "text": "這個事情沒有給社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/299.wav", + "text": "一個交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/300.wav", + "text": "下會期財政部預算拒審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/301.wav", + "text": "就讓你開花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/302.wav", + "text": "我這邊也要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/303.wav", + "text": "對財政部的不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/304.wav", + "text": "在公股行庫的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/305.wav", + "text": "我也多次質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/306.wav", + "text": "就是一些涉案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/307.wav", + "text": "有弊端的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/308.wav", + "text": "還可以從涉案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/309.wav", + "text": "變成吹哨者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/310.wav", + "text": "質詢之後我們看到財政部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/311.wav", + "text": "管理作為其實非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/312.wav", + "text": "消極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/313.wav", + "text": "要有guts拿出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/314.wav", + "text": "該有的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/315.wav", + "text": "那請前任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/316.wav", + "text": "蘇部長出來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/317.wav", + "text": "他現在還在金融研訓院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/318.wav", + "text": "看誰要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/319.wav", + "text": "我們沒有把這個事情升高到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/320.wav", + "text": "賴清德院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/321.wav", + "text": "已經很客氣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/322.wav", + "text": "蔡見興的是賴清德院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/323.wav", + "text": "報到行政院核定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/324.wav", + "text": "我們已經很客氣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/325.wav", + "text": "財政部說8個人走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/326.wav", + "text": "沒事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/327.wav", + "text": "那你把中華民國政府當什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/328.wav", + "text": "不是當塑膠啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/329.wav", + "text": "當垃圾啦���跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/330.wav", + "text": "沒有人這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/331.wav", + "text": "財政部說8個人走了就沒事了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/332.wav", + "text": "大家比照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/333.wav", + "text": "反正走了就好了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/334.wav", + "text": "\n不可以這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/335.wav", + "text": "我是覺得有錯就認錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/336.wav", + "text": "要如何改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/337.wav", + "text": "當然是應該處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/338.wav", + "text": "我想大家都坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/339.wav", + "text": "我有講過一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/340.wav", + "text": "蔡見興所帶進來的那些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/341.wav", + "text": "能夠繼續留在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/342.wav", + "text": "合庫資產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/343.wav", + "text": "垢你們也要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/344.wav", + "text": "提出所謂的報告出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/345.wav", + "text": "這報告剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/346.wav", + "text": "部長也談了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/347.wav", + "text": "你們對報告有所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/348.wav", + "text": "不足的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/349.wav", + "text": "這也可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/350.wav", + "text": "我不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/351.wav", + "text": "這個案子無限擴張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/352.wav", + "text": "這個案子也不需要罷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/353.wav", + "text": "罷審總預算罷審這個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/354.wav", + "text": "我們會非常務實地面對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/355.wav", + "text": "我上次在這裡也講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/356.wav", + "text": "我們不可能包庇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/357.wav", + "text": "很多事情都這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/358.wav", + "text": "政府單位這麼多泛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/359.wav", + "text": "出過事情的也不少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/360.wav", + "text": "我們現在回到主題王" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/361.wav", + "text": "也是我們一直在想的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/362.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/363.wav", + "text": "財政部也針對這次事件以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/364.wav", + "text": "有提出很多改進方案嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/365.wav", + "text": "我相信這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/366.wav", + "text": "要求合理的我們都應該接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/367.wav", + "text": "所以包括華南AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/368.wav", + "text": "那是兩年前的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/369.wav", + "text": "所以就代表有在清查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/370.wav", + "text": "往好的方向去改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/371.wav", + "text": "讓它不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/372.wav", + "text": "發生弊案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/373.wav", + "text": "這個我們沒有理由反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/374.wav", + "text": "我也會贊成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/375.wav", + "text": "我先講立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/376.wav", + "text": "合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/377.wav", + "text": "這個我自己看了也覺得怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/378.wav", + "text": "怎麼都在南部幾家公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/379.wav", + "text": "而且到60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/380.wav", + "text": "做都更就可以貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/381.wav", + "text": "款雖然辦法是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/382.wav", + "text": "我們也看不出來有什麼弊病繳息正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/383.wav", + "text": "但是這些都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/384.wav", + "text": "一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/385.wav", + "text": "剛才講到都更代墊款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/386.wav", + "text": "因為都更土地不是你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/387.wav", + "text": "你怎麼可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/388.wav", + "text": "借錢換計畫以後就可以去借錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/389.wav", + "text": "這個所有權人太多嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/390.wav", + "text": "為什麼這個辦法早年就一直存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/391.wav", + "text": "這應該是AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/392.wav", + "text": "去找人在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/393.wav", + "text": "做資產管理的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/394.wav", + "text": "沒有了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/395.wav", + "text": "可能有的銀行借不到就跑到這裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/396.wav", + "text": "那會不會發生一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/397.wav", + "text": "風控的管理也是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/398.wav", + "text": "這些我們都能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/399.wav", + "text": "\n回到一個核心問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/400.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/401.wav", + "text": "兩個人身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/402.wav", + "text": "有沒有牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/403.wav", + "text": "背信圖利的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/404.wav", + "text": "我是OK的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/405.wav", + "text": "因為我們也曾經發生過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/406.wav", + "text": "小企業聯合輔導中心總經理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/407.wav", + "text": "後來去當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/408.wav", + "text": "中小企業信保董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/409.wav", + "text": "有人檢舉他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/410.wav", + "text": "我們也是移送啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/411.wav", + "text": "上任一個月就下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/412.wav", + "text": "也是移送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/413.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/414.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/415.wav", + "text": "或詐欺等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/416.wav", + "text": "官能夠處理而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/417.wav", + "text": "啊你要去追究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/418.wav", + "text": "我也沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/419.wav", + "text": "這個我們可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/420.wav", + "text": "所以不用嗆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/421.wav", + "text": "這個大開眼界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/422.wav", + "text": "啦責任看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/423.wav", + "text": "開眼界的事情很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/424.wav", + "text": "我沒看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/425.wav", + "text": "我沒看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/426.wav", + "text": "你聽我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/427.wav", + "text": "我公股管理做了5年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/428.wav", + "text": "誰也不敢用他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/429.wav", + "text": "所以很多事情是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/430.wav", + "text": "啦泛公股底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/431.wav", + "text": "財政部已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/432.wav", + "text": "要送一個辦法出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/433.wav", + "text": "我們沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/434.wav", + "text": "這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/435.wav", + "text": "應該到一個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/436.wav", + "text": "或一個收尾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/437.wav", + "text": "了到底它是一個很小的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/438.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/439.wav", + "text": "很多人也不認識他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/440.wav", + "text": "當然發生這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/441.wav", + "text": "我們是非常遺憾的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/442.wav", + "text": "我們不希望我們執政底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/443.wav", + "text": "又發生這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/444.wav", + "text": "過去我不方便講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/445.wav", + "text": "這樣好你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/446.wav", + "text": "你的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/447.wav", + "text": "等等就拿出來讓大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/448.wav", + "text": "就這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/449.wav", + "text": "我們往下走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/450.wav", + "text": "剛剛王鴻薇委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/451.wav", + "text": "補充嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/452.wav", + "text": "口頭補充的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/453.wav", + "text": "這不行啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/454.wav", + "text": "行不通啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/455.wav", + "text": "地方政府有人貪瀆或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/456.wav", + "text": "難道首長就要下臺嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/457.wav", + "text": "誰都不希望發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/458.wav", + "text": "所以要把這個弄清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/459.wav", + "text": "我沒有說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/460.wav", + "text": "蘇部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/461.wav", + "text": "縱容那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/462.wav", + "text": "吹哨者保護法趕快來審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/463.wav", + "text": "出這些弊端管理都出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/464.wav", + "text": "柯總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/465.wav", + "text": "召對不起我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/466.wav", + "text": "我剛才有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/467.wav", + "text": "因為現在不是只有AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/468.wav", + "text": "還有它的創投公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/469.wav", + "text": "其實這件事情之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/470.wav", + "text": "有關合庫金控相��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/471.wav", + "text": "的子公司一堆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/472.wav", + "text": "檢舉統統到我這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/473.wav", + "text": "這裡面其實我必須講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/474.wav", + "text": "我剛剛特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/475.wav", + "text": "雷仲達那個董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/476.wav", + "text": "的問題真的非常非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/477.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/478.wav", + "text": "出現這麼多狗屁倒灶的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/479.wav", + "text": "這裡面還有好多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/480.wav", + "text": "前副總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/481.wav", + "text": "一天兩天後就立刻退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/482.wav", + "text": "為了什麼呢就是要給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/483.wav", + "text": "比較高的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/484.wav", + "text": "退休之後再回聘過來去當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/485.wav", + "text": "他合庫證券的董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/486.wav", + "text": "我相信柯總召應該都聽過這些事情\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/487.wav", + "text": "\n我剛才特別講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/488.wav", + "text": "如果這樣子的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/489.wav", + "text": "董事長他下面發生這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/490.wav", + "text": "事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/491.wav", + "text": "前幾天5月中一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/492.wav", + "text": "以內他高升到兆豐金去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/493.wav", + "text": "當董事長我現在聽到的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/494.wav", + "text": "因為現在要避風頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/495.wav", + "text": "6月中讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/496.wav", + "text": "去兆豐這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/497.wav", + "text": "可以看嗎你想想看人家兆豐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/498.wav", + "text": "所以我要講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/499.wav", + "text": "讓我們這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/500.wav", + "text": "公股體系裡面其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/501.wav", + "text": "現在合庫已經是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/502.wav", + "text": "怒火中燒啦所以為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/503.wav", + "text": "華南金控也會有人來跟我爆料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/504.wav", + "text": "金你覺得兆豐金下面的人能夠服氣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/505.wav", + "text": "上次他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/506.wav", + "text": "還沒有去時他就叫兆豐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/507.wav", + "text": "金的總經理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/508.wav", + "text": "副總帶隊去跟他報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/509.wav", + "text": "我為什麼會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/510.wav", + "text": "當然是兆豐金的人很不爽嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/511.wav", + "text": "對不對所以我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/512.wav", + "text": "是都要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/513.wav", + "text": "不是只有處理蔡見興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/514.wav", + "text": "雷仲達真的要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/515.wav", + "text": "你還要讓他去兆豐金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/516.wav", + "text": "我們到底要怎麼審我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/517.wav", + "text": "至於誰爆什麼料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/518.wav", + "text": "但是我沒有你詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/519.wav", + "text": "他們都有處理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/520.wav", + "text": "上禮拜就走人了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/521.wav", + "text": "禮拜一就請辭了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/522.wav", + "text": "其實那件事情有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/523.wav", + "text": "爆料的時候才請辭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/524.wav", + "text": "所以在這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/525.wav", + "text": "那是兩年前的事情查過一次其實沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/526.wav", + "text": "當事人坦白講也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/527.wav", + "text": "了但是怕什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/528.wav", + "text": "當事人也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/529.wav", + "text": "這件事有點不公平不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/530.wav", + "text": "我們今天主要是針對你提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/531.wav", + "text": "四點你的決議拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/532.wav", + "text": "讓大家看一下看是否要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/533.wav", + "text": "假如沒有的話我們就先處理不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/534.wav", + "text": "我也有意見王" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/535.wav", + "text": "薇委員講得有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/536.wav", + "text": "都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/537.wav", + "text": "合庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/538.wav", + "text": "AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/539.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/540.wav", + "text": "就是講這8個人嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/541.wav", + "text": "你聽我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/542.wav", + "text": "你剛剛有講一件很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/543.wav", + "text": "這很有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/544.wav", + "text": "我也完全贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/545.wav", + "text": "8個人都到蔡見興主管的AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/546.wav", + "text": "他自己做他負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/547.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/548.wav", + "text": "這樣才有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/549.wav", + "text": "我是先回應你因為你講說比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/550.wav", + "text": "你聽我說嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/551.wav", + "text": "假設這8個人全部在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/552.wav", + "text": "合庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/553.wav", + "text": "就可以處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/554.wav", + "text": "要處理蔡見興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/555.wav", + "text": "是他的金控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/556.wav", + "text": "這不是蔡見興所能處理的事所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/557.wav", + "text": "就別再拗了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/558.wav", + "text": "所有泛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/559.wav", + "text": "該處理的就處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/560.wav", + "text": "我們只是要求合乎比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/561.wav", + "text": "誰包庇就誰負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/562.wav", + "text": "財政部沒有責任嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/563.wav", + "text": "根本就不可能去包庇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/564.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以包庇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/565.wav", + "text": "就不你們兩人是不是私下溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/566.wav", + "text": "休息10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/567.wav", + "text": "也表達肯定的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/568.wav", + "text": "不過還有但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/569.wav", + "text": "不能說財政部都沒有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/570.wav", + "text": "我也知道事情不在他任內發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/571.wav", + "text": "但部長至少要代替蘇前部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/572.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/573.wav", + "text": "不會啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/574.wav", + "text": "不成比例啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/575.wav", + "text": "我說的你也別生氣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/576.wav", + "text": "我剛剛一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/577.wav", + "text": "2010年的時候臺灣金聯董事長陳松柱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/578.wav", + "text": "濫發獎金鬧得天翻地覆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/579.wav", + "text": "花了700多萬元自己想發給誰就發給誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/580.wav", + "text": "當年的部長和次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/581.wav", + "text": "好你要講我們就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/582.wav", + "text": "案是本人處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/583.wav", + "text": "我可以講故事給你聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/584.wav", + "text": "我希望在這裡可以理性討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/585.wav", + "text": "你叫現任的部長去道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/586.wav", + "text": "我是覺得不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/587.wav", + "text": "我可以代表民進黨黨團表示深度遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/588.wav", + "text": "這點是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/589.wav", + "text": "在我們執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/590.wav", + "text": "而且蘇部長也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/591.wav", + "text": "王委員剛才也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/592.wav", + "text": "OK只要這件事有處理就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/593.wav", + "text": "我們就到此為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/594.wav", + "text": "這種事然後把整個辦法訂清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/595.wav", + "text": "趕快看是要如何除弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/596.wav", + "text": "有任何bug都把它處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/597.wav", + "text": "避免再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/598.wav", + "text": "這才比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/599.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/600.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/601.wav", + "text": "本來我是不想提這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/602.wav", + "text": "的他提的是國民黨執政時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/603.wav", + "text": "臺灣金聯資產管理公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/604.wav", + "text": "財政部派了一個董事長叫陳松柱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/605.wav", + "text": "當時部長是李述德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/606.wav", + "text": "本人擔任常次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/607.wav", + "text": "有人檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/608.wav", + "text": "半年啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/609.wav", + "text": "不像這次財政部已經拖了5年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/610.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/611.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/612.wav", + "text": "我說他上任半年就處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/613.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/614.wav", + "text": "事情爆發後又搞半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/615.wav", + "text": "在財政部處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/616.wav", + "text": "我比你還清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/617.wav", + "text": "我調卷給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/618.wav", + "text": "啦本人處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/619.wav", + "text": "你放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/620.wav", + "text": "2010年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/621.wav", + "text": "我天天在關心國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/622.wav", + "text": "啦上任半年就把他移送法辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/623.wav", + "text": "你不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/624.wav", + "text": "的話問財政部公股管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/625.wav", + "text": "拿出來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/626.wav", + "text": "我們這個時候一發現就馬上處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/627.wav", + "text": "什麼檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/628.wav", + "text": "我都不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/629.wav", + "text": "你看了就會傻眼了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/630.wav", + "text": "我只是沒有拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/631.wav", + "text": "108年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/632.wav", + "text": "當時雜誌就有他的照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/633.wav", + "text": "他跟我們講的那個小三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/634.wav", + "text": "在旅館同進同出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/635.wav", + "text": "108年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/636.wav", + "text": "連雜誌都有爆料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/637.wav", + "text": "然後有給財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/638.wav", + "text": "但是統統沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/639.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/640.wav", + "text": "你看雜誌都登叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/641.wav", + "text": "代理前部長說聲抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/642.wav", + "text": "啊拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/643.wav", + "text": "蔡政府怎麼姿態這麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/644.wav", + "text": "啊這樣還要再拖嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/645.wav", + "text": "你還要再拖嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/646.wav", + "text": "我沒有要拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/647.wav", + "text": "對於這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/648.wav", + "text": "好好說啦不要走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/649.wav", + "text": "你現在的意思是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/650.wav", + "text": "108年雜誌都登" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/651.wav", + "text": "發生這個事情表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/652.wav", + "text": "遺憾是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/653.wav", + "text": "包括我也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/654.wav", + "text": "但是我替他道歉也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/655.wav", + "text": "他替他道歉也不對稱啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/656.wav", + "text": "這種事情大家都不希望發生嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/657.wav", + "text": "走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/658.wav", + "text": "不會再進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/659.wav", + "text": "了我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/660.wav", + "text": "我不會再上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/661.wav", + "text": "不然明天再上來啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/662.wav", + "text": "\n見怪不怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/663.wav", + "text": "擇期再見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/664.wav", + "text": "但是今天可能沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/665.wav", + "text": "明天啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15055/666.wav", + "text": "立法院就是如此啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15046/0.wav", + "text": "會議審查完竣審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15046/1.wav", + "text": "額問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15046/2.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15046/3.wav", + "text": "謝羅召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15046/4.wav", + "text": "我們在個別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/0.wav", + "text": "增訂第107條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/1.wav", + "text": "及第107條之4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/2.wav", + "text": "第一百十二條之1及第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/3.wav", + "text": "一百十二條之二條文草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/4.wav", + "text": "議因為其他委員還在路上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/5.wav", + "text": "不過剛剛都已經有在電話中協調過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/6.wav", + "text": "本來有一些意見我們都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/7.wav", + "text": "有聯絡過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/8.wav", + "text": "主要的方向大概都沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/9.wav", + "text": "在金額的部分究竟是五百萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/10.wav", + "text": "如果有其他委員到了再請他們表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/11.wav", + "text": "意見如果沒有特別表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/12.wav", + "text": "我們就保留送院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/13.wav", + "text": "這個部分也是列在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/14.wav", + "text": "重要的設施範圍裡面嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/15.wav", + "text": "那關貿網路公司算不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/16.wav", + "text": "目前不算那個是財政部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/17.wav", + "text": "有列的就是這幾項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/18.wav", + "text": "對就是金融下面的次領域包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/19.wav", + "text": "銀行證券期貨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/20.wav", + "text": "就是四個證券一個銀行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/21.wav", + "text": "財金公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/22.wav", + "text": "央行沒有列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/23.wav", + "text": "央行沒有央行也不是我們金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/24.wav", + "text": "能夠處理的它是獨立單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/25.wav", + "text": "石油管理法水利法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/26.wav", + "text": "自來水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/27.wav", + "text": "還有原子能委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/28.wav", + "text": "跟主席報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/29.wav", + "text": "行政院就是匡列這8個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/30.wav", + "text": "就是剛剛主席提到��這8個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/31.wav", + "text": "行政院整個檢討的方案之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/32.wav", + "text": "央行本身是關鍵基礎設施沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/33.wav", + "text": "這8個部會目前是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/34.wav", + "text": "更攸關我們民生安全性的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/35.wav", + "text": "所以當時檢討的時候就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/36.wav", + "text": "有人討論過央行嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/37.wav", + "text": "沒提出沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/38.wav", + "text": "是不是漏掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/39.wav", + "text": "其實央行滿重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/40.wav", + "text": "央行的印製廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/41.wav", + "text": "造幣廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/42.wav", + "text": "還有一個文園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/43.wav", + "text": "裡面黃金放那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/44.wav", + "text": "但卻沒有被列進去好奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/45.wav", + "text": "看看來不來得及你們再反映看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/46.wav", + "text": "這是行政院國土辦整個召集的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/47.wav", + "text": "其他F4的部分有沒有人要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/48.wav", + "text": "委馬上到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/49.wav", + "text": "報告主席應該沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/50.wav", + "text": "經112年4月27日財政委員會第10屆第7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/51.wav", + "text": "7會期第9次會議審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/52.wav", + "text": "竣審查結果保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/53.wav", + "text": "並經決議須經黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/54.wav", + "text": "因為其中罰金的金額問題還牽涉到總共8個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/55.wav", + "text": "然後送院長協商不曉得大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/56.wav", + "text": "謝謝羅召委特別召開今天這個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/57.wav", + "text": "我很認同召委的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/58.wav", + "text": "因為總共有22部法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/59.wav", + "text": "又牽涉到8個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/60.wav", + "text": "如果我們在個別的法案當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/61.wav", + "text": "把這些金額的部分自行擬定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/62.wav", + "text": "金額出現一些差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/63.wav", + "text": "我認為就是保留送院會由院長來進行朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/64.wav", + "text": "把22部法案做一個比較統一的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/65.wav", + "text": "──不論是金額或罰則上的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/66.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是在立法上比較嚴謹的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/67.wav", + "text": "所以我同意召委的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/68.wav", + "text": "委請張委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/69.wav", + "text": "我們那邊也審了二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/70.wav", + "text": "因為我們還是期待要有立法的協調性而罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/71.wav", + "text": "不管是比例或者一致上比較相近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/72.wav", + "text": "這個可能還要做一個比較總體性的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/73.wav", + "text": "因��民眾黨同意做這樣的安排謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/74.wav", + "text": "以上三案均保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/75.wav", + "text": "送請院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/76.wav", + "text": "\n今天的協商到此為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15045/77.wav", + "text": "現在宣布散會謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15041/0.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15041/1.wav", + "text": "這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/0.wav", + "text": "這個法案原則上是所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/1.wav", + "text": "跟關鍵基礎設施有關的作用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/2.wav", + "text": "主要的目的是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/3.wav", + "text": "上次的協商其實比較大的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/4.wav", + "text": "我們會尊重大院的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/5.wav", + "text": "但是對我們來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/6.wav", + "text": "這個是法律體系上面衡平性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/7.wav", + "text": "可能要整體做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/8.wav", + "text": "最主要的爭點可能是集中在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/9.wav", + "text": "當然委員也有詢問到所謂實體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/10.wav", + "text": "我們在上一次其實也有做了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/11.wav", + "text": "實體主要是針對重要設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/12.wav", + "text": "虛擬是針對重要設備的核心資訊通訊系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/13.wav", + "text": "有比較清楚地做了這兩個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/14.wav", + "text": "大致上的狀況是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/15.wav", + "text": "子一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/16.wav", + "text": "我看今天來的委員也沒有幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/17.wav", + "text": "乾脆就直接送院長協商好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/18.wav", + "text": "我剛才看了一下幾個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/19.wav", + "text": "包括楊瓊瓔委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/20.wav", + "text": "基本上很多都是把罰金從五百萬元變成六百" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/21.wav", + "text": "百萬元這個可能也牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/22.wav", + "text": "在其他委員會裡面也一樣有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/23.wav", + "text": "意圖破壞關鍵基礎設施的相關法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/24.wav", + "text": "至第六案就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/25.wav", + "text": "好\n今天協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/26.wav", + "text": "一第一案至第六案保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/27.wav", + "text": "請院長召集黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/28.wav", + "text": "自來水法第8條及第97條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15043/29.wav", + "text": "均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1.wav", + "text": "是的配合剛才吳思瑤委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2.wav", + "text": "新增第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/3.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/4.wav", + "text": "是我們的提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/5.wav", + "text": "包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/6.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/7.wav", + "text": "都有提到能不能給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/8.wav", + "text": "個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/9.wav", + "text": "教育部也可以給予一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/10.wav", + "text": "善意的幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/11.wav", + "text": "加列一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/12.wav", + "text": "就是協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/13.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/14.wav", + "text": "要訂定相關的補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/15.wav", + "text": "正向回應兩位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/16.wav", + "text": "對這方面的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/17.wav", + "text": "張廖委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/18.wav", + "text": "\n第二點是有關吳思瑤委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/19.wav", + "text": "加列一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/20.wav", + "text": "我們覺得很有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/21.wav", + "text": "其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/22.wav", + "text": "把現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/23.wav", + "text": "也謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/24.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/25.wav", + "text": "我們完全認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/26.wav", + "text": "以上兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/27.wav", + "text": "兩位委員所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/28.wav", + "text": "我們增加有關補助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/29.wav", + "text": "子法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/30.wav", + "text": "一個是吳思瑤委員所提的臨時動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/31.wav", + "text": "我們也很認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/32.wav", + "text": "以上補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/33.wav", + "text": "席簡要向大家說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/34.wav", + "text": "請大家看大本最右邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/35.wav", + "text": "提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/36.wav", + "text": "第6條原本行政院的提案是一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/37.wav", + "text": "但我們針對第6條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/38.wav", + "text": "提修正條文內容請看附表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/39.wav", + "text": "教育部為了回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/40.wav", + "text": "多數委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/41.wav", + "text": "包括婉諭委員也非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/42.wav", + "text": "不管是機構團體或自學學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/43.wav", + "text": "希望實驗教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/44.wav", + "text": "也能夠挹注國家資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/45.wav", + "text": "教育部的處理方法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/46.wav", + "text": "增加第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/47.wav", + "text": "文字內容是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/48.wav", + "text": "為協助前項實驗教育之發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/49.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關應訂定相關補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/50.wav", + "text": "\n也就是用一項補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/51.wav", + "text": "未來針對機構團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/52.wav", + "text": "甚至是學生的部分要怎麼處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/53.wav", + "text": "相關補助規定另定之這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/54.wav", + "text": "部分不會在第6條條文中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/55.wav", + "text": "因為教育部後來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/56.wav", + "text": "提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/57.wav", + "text": "和時代力量黨團版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/58.wav", + "text": "有一個滿大的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/59.wav", + "text": "所以本席想做釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/60.wav", + "text": "我們把政府補助放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/61.wav", + "text": "就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/62.wav", + "text": "非學校型態要包含機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/63.wav", + "text": "但我們也知道現在有一些經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/64.wav", + "text": "可以申請用來補助團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/65.wav", + "text": "這個意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/66.wav", + "text": "就會被政府的國民教育排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/67.wav", + "text": "本席想請教的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/68.wav", + "text": "是不是仍然包含這兩個部分而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/69.wav", + "text": "個人的部分仍然被排除在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/70.wav", + "text": "我們當初提出修法的請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/71.wav", + "text": "關於第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/72.wav", + "text": "提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/73.wav", + "text": "精神差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/74.wav", + "text": "目前提會討論的版本一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/75.wav", + "text": "和現在教育部增加的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/76.wav", + "text": "一致針對實驗教育發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/77.wav", + "text": "由中央政府訂定相關補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/78.wav", + "text": "請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/79.wav", + "text": "教育部補充說明回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/80.wav", + "text": "委也謝謝張召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/81.wav", + "text": "召委關於王委員所提的意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/82.wav", + "text": "原來的提案是提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/83.wav", + "text": "這部分包含剛才您所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/84.wav", + "text": "並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/85.wav", + "text": "您之前也有提到政府補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/86.wav", + "text": "現場比較有幫助的方式處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/87.wav", + "text": "會針對機構和團體的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/88.wav", + "text": "增加補助方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/89.wav", + "text": "的確在這樣的討論之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/90.wav", + "text": "雖然有些委員接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/91.wav", + "text": "了但是民間也捲起一股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/92.wav", + "text": "非常大的聲量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/93.wav", + "text": "個人的部分不應該被排除在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/94.wav", + "text": "仍然沒有表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/95.wav", + "text": "但是非學校型態包含機構團體和個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/96.wav", + "text": "教育部長一定知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/97.wav", + "text": "本來在條文中的設計就是希望個人的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/98.wav", + "text": "比照高中的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/99.wav", + "text": "每一個類型都應該給予協助補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/100.wav", + "text": "或者如果要排除在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/101.wav", + "text": "不應該只把個人排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/102.wav", + "text": "政府會給予什麼樣的補助或協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/103.wav", + "text": "實我們這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/104.wav", + "text": "已經包含學校型態非學校型態的各種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/105.wav", + "text": "個人部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/106.wav", + "text": "多諮詢一下現場的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/107.wav", + "text": "因為各類型的相關團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/108.wav", + "text": "我要特別說明這部分並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/109.wav", + "text": "沒有排除個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/110.wav", + "text": "但是要怎麼補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/111.wav", + "text": "是不是容我們未來訂定子法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/112.wav", + "text": "用另外的子法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/113.wav", + "text": "請林委員宜瑾第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/114.wav", + "text": "國中小階段的義務教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/115.wav", + "text": "建設公立學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/116.wav", + "text": "而現行規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/117.wav", + "text": "是為了保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/118.wav", + "text": "但假如要透過全面性的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/119.wav", + "text": "本席覺得不宜\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/120.wav", + "text": "本席覺得國民教育權這項概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/121.wav", + "text": "國家和教師這三方權利平衡的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/122.wav", + "text": "對於沒有辦法全權決定自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/123.wav", + "text": "該受什麼教育的孩子來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/124.wav", + "text": "說當然不是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/125.wav", + "text": "本席覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/126.wav", + "text": "全面性的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/127.wav", + "text": "就是一種鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/128.wav", + "text": "但我們並不是要鼓勵學生在國民教育階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/129.wav", + "text": "\n如果我們要彌平階級間的選擇權不平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/130.wav", + "text": "本席覺得除了補助應該排富之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/131.wav", + "text": "也應該百分百排除補習班的介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/132.wav", + "text": "就是排除所謂的偽自學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/133.wav", + "text": "實是真拼升學的歪風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/134.wav", + "text": "就會變成一種諷刺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/135.wav", + "text": "這些狀況至少要杜絕所謂的偽自學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/136.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/137.wav", + "text": "本席先暫時脫離一下主席身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/138.wav", + "text": "就自己對條文的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/139.wav", + "text": "做以下說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/140.wav", + "text": "對於這個條文的討論也耗時已久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/141.wav", + "text": "現在走到最後的協商如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/142.wav", + "text": "婉諭委員代表時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/143.wav", + "text": "寫的很清楚前提就是���障學生的學習權和家長的教育選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/144.wav", + "text": "因為現在的條文也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/145.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/146.wav", + "text": "\n國民教育階段得辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/147.wav", + "text": "時代力量的版本是寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/148.wav", + "text": "實驗內容期程範圍申請條件程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/149.wav", + "text": "政府補助及其他相關事項之辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/150.wav", + "text": "由教育部會商後定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/151.wav", + "text": "本席認為時代力量這個條文的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/152.wav", + "text": "因為剛才署長也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/153.wav", + "text": "過教育部的第2項是針對前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/154.wav", + "text": "不只包含非學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/155.wav", + "text": "\n所以以條文論條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/156.wav", + "text": "本席認為教育部的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/157.wav", + "text": "以及非學校型態的實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/158.wav", + "text": "在第1項中的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/159.wav", + "text": "都由中央主管機關訂定相關補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/160.wav", + "text": "本席認為這樣更全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/161.wav", + "text": "而且未來用子法的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/162.wav", + "text": "包括以什麼樣的條件形式給予政策的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/163.wav", + "text": "這樣訂定會更周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/164.wav", + "text": "\n另外說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/165.wav", + "text": "本席提出的修正動議增列第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/166.wav", + "text": "補習及進修教育法所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/167.wav", + "text": "定之短期補習教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/168.wav", + "text": "不得視為第1項非學校型態實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/169.wav", + "text": "其實這就是把我們當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/170.wav", + "text": "在討論過程中沒有剔除的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/171.wav", + "text": "補教法予以排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/172.wav", + "text": "把這一項放進來會更周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/173.wav", + "text": "因為我們都知道這部分不適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/174.wav", + "text": "本席認為教育部的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/175.wav", + "text": "未來用子法的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/176.wav", + "text": "現在回到主席的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/177.wav", + "text": "還有其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/178.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/179.wav", + "text": "還有家長的教育選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/180.wav", + "text": "以快速改變的體制中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/181.wav", + "text": "學習時可能會出現一些狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/182.wav", + "text": "另外一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/183.wav", + "text": "其實我們也需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/184.wav", + "text": "鼓勵部分的實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/185.wav", + "text": "如果有好的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/186.wav", + "text": "這次所做的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/187.wav", + "text": "是母法把這個空間留出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/188.wav", + "text": "本席認為大家不會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/189.wav", + "text": "甚至是支持你們給予補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/190.wav", + "text": "逐步增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/191.wav", + "text": "哪些群落來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/192.wav", + "text": "版本這個會議可能會開不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/193.wav", + "text": "對剛才吳思瑤委員修正的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/194.wav", + "text": "本席是滿支持的先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/195.wav", + "text": "未來教育部給予補助之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/196.wav", + "text": "和公立學校一起分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/197.wav", + "text": "這樣大家都能得到好處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/198.wav", + "text": "畢竟這都是納稅人一起支持的本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/199.wav", + "text": "本席希望教育部未來也能兼顧到這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/200.wav", + "text": "分以上本席發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/201.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/202.wav", + "text": "范雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/203.wav", + "text": "宜瑾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/204.wav", + "text": "思瑤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/205.wav", + "text": "未來用子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/206.wav", + "text": "處理可以有更清楚的討論空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/207.wav", + "text": "請陳委員培瑜第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/208.wav", + "text": "有關實驗教育的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/209.wav", + "text": "就是訂定相關子法予以補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/210.wav", + "text": "也可以邀請其他委員一起參與討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/211.wav", + "text": "包括大家關注的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/212.wav", + "text": "及相關的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/213.wav", + "text": "文化資源等問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/214.wav", + "text": "本席還是要再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/215.wav", + "text": "非學校型態包含個人團體和機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/216.wav", + "text": "只有針對團體和機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/217.wav", + "text": "或者大家訴求的就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/218.wav", + "text": "個人也能夠列入補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/219.wav", + "text": "範圍但是這個補助要不要排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/220.wav", + "text": "要不要有其他的要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/221.wav", + "text": "席覺得這是可以討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/222.wav", + "text": "但不能一旦選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/223.wav", + "text": "就完全沒有辦法享受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/224.wav", + "text": "本席想要釐清的是這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/225.wav", + "text": "\n剛才署長的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/226.wav", + "text": "並沒有排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/227.wav", + "text": "但是也沒有表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/228.wav", + "text": "所以本席覺得這個部分還是要釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/229.wav", + "text": "對個人的補助也能夠納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/230.wav", + "text": "入未來實驗教育的補助範疇之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/231.wav", + "text": "也確實會提出這樣的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/232.wav", + "text": "本席對條文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/233.wav", + "text": "因為我們長期以來推動實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/234.wav", + "text": "並不是反對國民教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/235.wav", + "text": "為你選擇國民教育之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/236.wav", + "text": "而且這部分的補助並不是鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/237.wav", + "text": "只是給予選擇的可能性而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/238.wav", + "text": "所以本席希望能夠先確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/239.wav", + "text": "會把個人實驗教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/240.wav", + "text": "請彭署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/241.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/242.wav", + "text": "的剛好在座幾位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/243.wav", + "text": "所以我們也希望藉由各界的幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/244.wav", + "text": "沒有排除對個人的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/245.wav", + "text": "以前沒有這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/246.wav", + "text": "我們的協助補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/247.wav", + "text": "更放寬的幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/248.wav", + "text": "關於這方面的幫忙因為很多委員也有高見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/249.wav", + "text": "是不是容我們整合這些意見我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/250.wav", + "text": "會和有關單位會商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/251.wav", + "text": "剛才培瑜委員也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/252.wav", + "text": "到是不是可以向委員做一些說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/253.wav", + "text": "聆聽各位聽到的一些心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/254.wav", + "text": "甚至是比較偏鄉的地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/255.wav", + "text": "像這些意見是不是容我們思考更周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/256.wav", + "text": "我相信可能沒有辦法一步到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/257.wav", + "text": "目前所說的前項各類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/258.wav", + "text": "其實都已經包含至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/259.wav", + "text": "至於幫忙補助的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/260.wav", + "text": "是不是容我們和大家會商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/261.wav", + "text": "關於設算單位成本等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/262.wav", + "text": "是不是可以設算單位成本給個人補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/263.wav", + "text": "這件事情我無法在這裡回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/264.wav", + "text": "委員也有聽到嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/265.wav", + "text": "是不是容我聆聽完大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/266.wav", + "text": "這樣未來訂定子法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/267.wav", + "text": "啦這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/268.wav", + "text": "因為本席代理范雲委員主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/269.wav", + "text": "整部國民教育法關切了太多面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/270.wav", + "text": "第6條主要是處理實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/271.wav", + "text": "的部分本席認為國民教育法在處理實驗教育的條文當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/272.wav", + "text": "就是講述原則性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/273.wav", + "text": "和國家對於實驗教育採取支持的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/274.wav", + "text": "而且是擴大補助的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/275.wav", + "text": "\n所以在這個條文的第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/276.wav", + "text": "提到國家絕對全力支持實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/277.wav", + "text": "增列的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/278.wav", + "text": "是回應各界的聲音我們會擴大對實驗教育的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/279.wav", + "text": "第3項是新增的條文和補習進修的部分有關因為兩者的軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/280.wav", + "text": "我們這次修正的條文有幾十條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/281.wav", + "text": "這一條是在處理實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/282.wav", + "text": "用子法處理畢竟會比較周全本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/283.wav", + "text": "本席認為委員們如果主張實驗教育的其他部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/284.wav", + "text": "\n國民教育法處理的是整個國民教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/285.wav", + "text": "在條文推進上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/286.wav", + "text": "本席再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/287.wav", + "text": "第1項是保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/288.wav", + "text": "協助以文字明定國家對實驗教育的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/289.wav", + "text": "增定的第2項是過去沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/290.wav", + "text": "擴大對實驗教育的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/291.wav", + "text": "未來在子法的修法過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/292.wav", + "text": "中一定要和更多團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/293.wav", + "text": "會商也請所有立委一起參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/294.wav", + "text": "這樣才會更周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/295.wav", + "text": "\n本席覺得國民教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/296.wav", + "text": "在實驗教育的部分真的只能以方向性基本性的方式處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/297.wav", + "text": "而且它已經處理的非常完備本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/298.wav", + "text": "本席懇求各位今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/299.wav", + "text": "是否可以參酌剛才委員提出的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/300.wav", + "text": "包括張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/301.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/302.wav", + "text": "還有行政院提會討論的修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/303.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/304.wav", + "text": "位置交還給范雲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/305.wav", + "text": "關於增列的第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/306.wav", + "text": "大家應該都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/307.wav", + "text": "至於第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/308.wav", + "text": "就剛才聽起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/309.wav", + "text": "多數委員都支持這樣的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/310.wav", + "text": "為協助前項實驗教育之發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/311.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關應訂定相關補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/312.wav", + "text": "是不是能請大家支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/313.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/314.wav", + "text": "就是不用特別排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/315.wav", + "text": "除雖然現在是說沒有排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/316.wav", + "text": "但實際上就是沒有給予協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/317.wav", + "text": "而且你們一直說不出所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/318.wav", + "text": "席還是要和署長強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/319.wav", + "text": "這不是一時提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/320.wav", + "text": "的想法其實從本席上任的第一年就開始談這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/321.wav", + "text": "而且在實驗教育現場也談論非常多年這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/322.wav", + "text": "這點署長非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/323.wav", + "text": "所以不需要誆本席說這件事你們一直都有提到只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/324.wav", + "text": "到底能夠給個人的實驗教育哪些協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/325.wav", + "text": "這件事情從我們上任第一年問到現在都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/326.wav", + "text": "這樣並不是今天一時之間沒有辦法回答\n本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/327.wav", + "text": "\n本席可以接受這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/328.wav", + "text": "但本席還是希望能夠透過附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/329.wav", + "text": "或是立法說明的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/330.wav", + "text": "當然關於協助的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/331.wav", + "text": "也需要持續釐清或是做不同程度的協助這些都是可以討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/332.wav", + "text": "如果教育部能夠接受我們用立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/333.wav", + "text": "的方式或是待會提出附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/334.wav", + "text": "當然相關協助或補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/335.wav", + "text": "個人實驗教育的部分就是完全被排除在外本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/336.wav", + "text": "但是擬一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/337.wav", + "text": "至於附帶決議要怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/338.wav", + "text": "先讓條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/339.wav", + "text": "另外補一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/340.wav", + "text": "但是附帶決議的文字怎麼處理還可以再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/341.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/342.wav", + "text": "我們可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/343.wav", + "text": "但是我們也很擔心待會附帶決議又做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/344.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法納入這些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/345.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們是不是可以先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/346.wav", + "text": "和教育部討論附帶決議的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/347.wav", + "text": "要嘛就是不要通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/348.wav", + "text": "也可能會是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/349.wav", + "text": "好本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/350.wav", + "text": "如果這個附帶決議要這麼寫本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/351.wav", + "text": "因為本席也認識非常多自學的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/352.wav", + "text": "如同王婉諭委員一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/353.wav", + "text": "其中也有另外一種聲音就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/354.wav", + "text": "當這個東西有可能被濫用的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/355.wav", + "text": "其實婉諭委員剛才也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/356.wav", + "text": "就是排富條款的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/357.wav", + "text": "是不是也把這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/358.wav", + "text": "所以���席才會向婉諭委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/359.wav", + "text": "其實其他委員有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/360.wav", + "text": "就這一條攸關實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/361.wav", + "text": "細則的部分用子法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/362.wav", + "text": "說未來想要在實驗教育相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/363.wav", + "text": "中如何明定細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/364.wav", + "text": "其實實驗教育三法也可以修法提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/365.wav", + "text": "因為這個條文卡住本席覺得很可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/366.wav", + "text": "連這一條還有四條條文要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/367.wav", + "text": "所以我們等一下回來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/368.wav", + "text": "大家再思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/369.wav", + "text": "但本席要強調宜瑾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/370.wav", + "text": "我們要尊重不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/371.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/372.wav", + "text": "現在把主持工作交還范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/373.wav", + "text": "\n現在處理第41條另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/374.wav", + "text": "條關於戶外教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/375.wav", + "text": "哪一位委員要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/376.wav", + "text": "員提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/377.wav", + "text": "獲得張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/378.wav", + "text": "范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/379.wav", + "text": "和其他委員的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/380.wav", + "text": "非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/381.wav", + "text": "第37條上次對於戶外教育的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/382.wav", + "text": "我們已經綜整一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/383.wav", + "text": "大家都可以同意的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/384.wav", + "text": "為豐富學生經驗及強化與真實情境連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/385.wav", + "text": "學校應推動走出課室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/386.wav", + "text": "提供學生探究實作與體驗課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/387.wav", + "text": "其推動之經費來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/388.wav", + "text": "收費基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/389.wav", + "text": "單位人員分工與權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/390.wav", + "text": "風險管理及其他相關事項之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/391.wav", + "text": "在第1項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/392.wav", + "text": "我們維持上次委員會審查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/393.wav", + "text": "意見就是走出課室提供體驗課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/394.wav", + "text": "另外增加探究和實作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/395.wav", + "text": "本席覺得這樣會更周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/396.wav", + "text": "走出課室的這些體驗課程所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/397.wav", + "text": "經費來源收費基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/398.wav", + "text": "人員的分工與權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/399.wav", + "text": "本席覺得這樣非常周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/400.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/401.wav", + "text": "針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/402.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員在嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/403.wav", + "text": "其他兩位提案委員都不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/404.wav", + "text": "國教署要不要表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/405.wav", + "text": "用吳思瑤委員的版本可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/406.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委及委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/407.wav", + "text": "我們剛才看了這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/408.wav", + "text": "關於文字國教署認為不需要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/409.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員的版本沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/410.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/411.wav", + "text": "第37條依照吳思瑤委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/412.wav", + "text": "修正動議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/413.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/414.wav", + "text": "大家可以看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/415.wav", + "text": "原本的院版通過囉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/416.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/417.wav", + "text": "關於學生權益的救濟體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/418.wav", + "text": "在大本的第4頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/419.wav", + "text": "也有和教育部做過溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/420.wav", + "text": "謝謝剛才委員們幫忙連署\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/421.wav", + "text": "先請吳委員思瑤發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/422.wav", + "text": "第44條是有關學生的申訴再申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/423.wav", + "text": "會後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/424.wav", + "text": "我們幾位委員也有再和教育部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/425.wav", + "text": "其中有幾個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/426.wav", + "text": "的地方就是我們對學生的懲處或決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/427.wav", + "text": "得由法定代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/428.wav", + "text": "代為向學校提出申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/429.wav", + "text": "納入此外因為我們認為實際照顧者和法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/430.wav", + "text": "因此當初我們希望提出申訴的期限是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/431.wav", + "text": "30天或40天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/432.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/433.wav", + "text": "對教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/434.wav", + "text": "本席記得還有一個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/435.wav", + "text": "40天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/436.wav", + "text": "外我們認為既然有法定代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/437.wav", + "text": "可以的這三個爭點在這次的修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/438.wav", + "text": "所以本席支持今天提會討論的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/439.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/440.wav", + "text": "能夠讓申訴的時間增加到40天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/441.wav", + "text": "還有修正家長和代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/442.wav", + "text": "關於通知的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/443.wav", + "text": "本席希望能夠增加通知學生及其法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/444.wav", + "text": "原來的文字好像漏掉通知的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/445.wav", + "text": "並通知學生及其法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/446.wav", + "text": "國教���是不是可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/447.wav", + "text": "最後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/448.wav", + "text": "原來是並通知學生之法定代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/449.wav", + "text": "和法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/450.wav", + "text": "等你們在行政作業上應該沒有問題嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/451.wav", + "text": "至少學生本人有被通知到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/452.wav", + "text": "就是增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/453.wav", + "text": "並通知學生及其法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/454.wav", + "text": "或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/455.wav", + "text": "對還有或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/456.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/457.wav", + "text": "及其之的之應該取消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/458.wav", + "text": "螢幕上的修正文字通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/459.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/460.wav", + "text": "關於學生申訴評議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/461.wav", + "text": "請大家看大本的第7頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/462.wav", + "text": "大家有拿到資料可以一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/463.wav", + "text": "國教署是不是可以一起回應包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/464.wav", + "text": "括附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/465.wav", + "text": "的部分原本委員會也有保留附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/466.wav", + "text": "這部分請你們一起回應好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/467.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/468.wav", + "text": "委原來談到第44條第45條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/469.wav", + "text": "委員希望能夠彰顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/470.wav", + "text": "現在看到的附帶決議第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/471.wav", + "text": "我們覺得應該做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/472.wav", + "text": "尤其是第二行有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/473.wav", + "text": "就是在申訴前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/474.wav", + "text": "應該有一些機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/475.wav", + "text": "讓學生可以受到保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/476.wav", + "text": "想要表達的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/477.wav", + "text": "也有管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/478.wav", + "text": "可以表示這部分我們充分支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/479.wav", + "text": "而且也會落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/480.wav", + "text": "我們瞭解教育部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/481.wav", + "text": "考慮到行政訴訟的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/482.wav", + "text": "實所以我們覺得要針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/483.wav", + "text": "校長信箱這樣的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/484.wav", + "text": "而且學校和地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/485.wav", + "text": "的申訴管道這樣也許很多問題就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/486.wav", + "text": "解決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/487.wav", + "text": "\n如果沒有委員要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/488.wav", + "text": "不同意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/489.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就依照院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/490.wav", + "text": "院版的文字通過再加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/491.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/492.wav", + "text": "好感謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/493.wav", + "text": "以上是第45條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/494.wav", + "text": "立法說明大家手上有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/495.wav", + "text": "我們先回頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/496.wav", + "text": "保留的第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/497.wav", + "text": "請吳委員思瑤發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/498.wav", + "text": "是不是讓每個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/499.wav", + "text": "就我個人的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/500.wav", + "text": "我不希望因為這個條文而影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/501.wav", + "text": "國民教育法這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/502.wav", + "text": "大法的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/503.wav", + "text": "所以我再一次講我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/504.wav", + "text": "第1項能夠維持現在提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/505.wav", + "text": "提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/506.wav", + "text": "第2項新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/507.wav", + "text": "更高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/508.wav", + "text": "執法要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/509.wav", + "text": "不設前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/510.wav", + "text": "不設型態的實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/511.wav", + "text": "都要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/512.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關訂定相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/513.wav", + "text": "補助規定這樣第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/514.wav", + "text": "的文字會是最全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/515.wav", + "text": "也最彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/516.wav", + "text": "方向性規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/517.wav", + "text": "所以我認為第2項的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/518.wav", + "text": "接受我個人是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/519.wav", + "text": "可以接受我也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/520.wav", + "text": "大家接受至於第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/521.wav", + "text": "剛剛已經建議放上來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/522.wav", + "text": "\n如果今天多數委員都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/523.wav", + "text": "有這樣的共識我非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/524.wav", + "text": "期待我們可以送出協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/525.wav", + "text": "然後加速後面二三讀的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/526.wav", + "text": "期程在此懇請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/527.wav", + "text": "再次強調針對實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/528.wav", + "text": "的各種其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/529.wav", + "text": "要有修法的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/530.wav", + "text": "其實上一屆修過實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/531.wav", + "text": "三法都還可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/532.wav", + "text": "針對實驗教育三法討論是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/533.wav", + "text": "有更周延的修正必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/534.wav", + "text": "而不是在國民教育法裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/535.wav", + "text": "處理所以我再做一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/536.wav", + "text": "最終意見的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/537.wav", + "text": "思瑤其他委員有沒有要表達意見\n請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/538.wav", + "text": "我覺得預算的花用方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/539.wav", + "text": "發展的價值思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/540.wav", + "text": "並不是高中有補助自學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/541.wav", + "text": "然後我們就可以推演出國中小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/542.wav", + "text": "也要比照辦理的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/543.wav", + "text": "因為高中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/544.wav", + "text": "跟國中小不同的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/545.wav", + "text": "後者是義務教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/546.wav", + "text": "高中階段是自願入學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/547.wav", + "text": "非義務教育強度不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/548.wav", + "text": "所以國家政策目的有所不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/549.wav", + "text": "管制的鬆緊當然也有會不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/550.wav", + "text": "\n我再次重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/551.wav", + "text": "選擇特定教育理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/552.wav", + "text": "的自學申請者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/553.wav", + "text": "我們當然很清楚知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/554.wav", + "text": "很難透過事前的整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/555.wav", + "text": "計畫審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/556.wav", + "text": "跟事後的訪視評鑑來把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/557.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/558.wav", + "text": "害怕會有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/559.wav", + "text": "想要方便衝刺升學考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/560.wav", + "text": "而申請在家自學的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/561.wav", + "text": "這種就叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/562.wav", + "text": "偽自學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/563.wav", + "text": "就明顯不符合所謂實驗教育的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/564.wav", + "text": "如果要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/565.wav", + "text": "普發所謂的學費補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/566.wav", + "text": "以教育選擇權為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/567.wav", + "text": "我覺得本質上還是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/568.wav", + "text": "教育當作商品化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/569.wav", + "text": "就是要平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/570.wav", + "text": "是近便可得的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/571.wav", + "text": "優質公辦教育我覺得這還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/572.wav", + "text": "除了這個基礎之外我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/573.wav", + "text": "當然支持其他所謂的選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/574.wav", + "text": "可是我覺得那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/575.wav", + "text": "絕對不是所謂的普例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/576.wav", + "text": "不是通則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/577.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/578.wav", + "text": "有加入訂定相關補助的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/579.wav", + "text": "我確實也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/580.wav", + "text": "呼應剛才王委員婉諭所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/581.wav", + "text": "不管是為了照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/582.wav", + "text": "有積極選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/583.wav", + "text": "有這樣能量的家長的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/584.wav", + "text": "偏鄉孩子的家庭狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/585.wav", + "text": "一旦有這樣的個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/586.wav", + "text": "是不是可以真的如願照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/587.wav", + "text": "到所有的小孩所以剛剛我也再次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/588.wav", + "text": "排富部分不管稍後大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/589.wav", + "text": "的討論如何或者是後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/590.wav", + "text": "教育部在這個議題上能夠做全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/591.wav", + "text": "的增列所以我也很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/592.wav", + "text": "我們可以在後續的諸多討論上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/593.wav", + "text": "我相信每一個委員不管在服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/594.wav", + "text": "的選區或者像我是不分區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/595.wav", + "text": "我們都會認識到非常多不同角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/596.wav", + "text": "不同家庭及不同教育選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/597.wav", + "text": "型態的家長是不是也讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/598.wav", + "text": "我們有機會把這樣的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/599.wav", + "text": "在訂定相關補助規定裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/600.wav", + "text": "把不同樣態的孩子的需求都放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/601.wav", + "text": "一併考量謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/602.wav", + "text": "附帶決議提出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/603.wav", + "text": "我們能夠理解署長所說的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/604.wav", + "text": "在補助之內但現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/605.wav", + "text": "上的確在選擇個人實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/606.wav", + "text": "的情況之下是非常難享受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/607.wav", + "text": "到這個協助即便我知道他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/608.wav", + "text": "擁有學籍理論上他們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/609.wav", + "text": "回到學校使用圖書館或是參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/610.wav", + "text": "學校的活動但實際上我相信署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/611.wav", + "text": "和部長一定非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/612.wav", + "text": "有多少實驗教育個人自學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/613.wav", + "text": "的情況是被學校拒絕在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/614.wav", + "text": "其實很難去使用到這些空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/615.wav", + "text": "\n而我認為如果我們要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/616.wav", + "text": "他涵蓋進來不單單是補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/617.wav", + "text": "而已包含協助的部分我覺得也是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/618.wav", + "text": "接受的主要的訴求是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/619.wav", + "text": "於當他一旦選擇了個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/620.wav", + "text": "教育的協助對象之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/621.wav", + "text": "上沒有排除但實際上他可能就被排除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/622.wav", + "text": "我們還是希望能夠解決掉這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/623.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望法規及附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/624.wav", + "text": "\n另外我也想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/625.wav", + "text": "現在非學實驗教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/626.wav", + "text": "就不含補習及進修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/627.wav", + "text": "教育法的部分應該是要依照私校法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/628.wav", + "text": "又或者是依照補習班的相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/629.wav", + "text": "理解這裡多寫可能是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/630.wav", + "text": "但是我也擔心如果本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/631.wav", + "text": "就已經不含了其實也不需要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/632.wav", + "text": "看起來意見滿清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/633.wav", + "text": "大家對於剛剛吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/634.wav", + "text": "提出來的修正條文即為協" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/635.wav", + "text": "助前項實驗教育之發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/636.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/637.wav", + "text": "應訂定相關補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/638.wav", + "text": "教育部說其中並沒有排除個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/639.wav", + "text": "也可以補助個人可是也有委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/640.wav", + "text": "持滿強烈的反對意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/641.wav", + "text": "就先通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/642.wav", + "text": "另外一種選擇至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/643.wav", + "text": "理我們是不是在附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/644.wav", + "text": "也表達一下意見好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/645.wav", + "text": "審到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/646.wav", + "text": "很高興大家集結了智慧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/647.wav", + "text": "並且已經快完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/648.wav", + "text": "現在針對這一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/649.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/650.wav", + "text": "我們用最大的善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/651.wav", + "text": "委員也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/652.wav", + "text": "以前沒有這一條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/653.wav", + "text": "儘可能幫忙到機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/654.wav", + "text": "現在有這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/655.wav", + "text": "有這一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/656.wav", + "text": "但是幫忙的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/657.wav", + "text": "就如委員今天聽到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/658.wav", + "text": "其實有很多可以容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/659.wav", + "text": "國教署或教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/660.wav", + "text": "剛才我們也已經講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/661.wav", + "text": "了它所含納的非常廣泛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/662.wav", + "text": "比以前更寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/663.wav", + "text": "更強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/664.wav", + "text": "以前只有一個行政規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/665.wav", + "text": "現在是一個子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/666.wav", + "text": "\n今天也聽到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/667.wav", + "text": "不管是吳委員的論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/668.wav", + "text": "或是條文本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/669.wav", + "text": "就含納了兩大類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/670.wav", + "text": "並沒有說要排除誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/671.wav", + "text": "再加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/672.wav", + "text": "我們跟實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/673.wav", + "text": "實盟等等的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/674.wav", + "text": "處理了多少原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/675.wav", + "text": "所沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/676.wav", + "text": "委員可能也知道國教署教育部及縣市的用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/677.wav", + "text": "剛才也舉到有一些縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/678.wav", + "text": "在工作的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/679.wav", + "text": "需要再協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/680.wav", + "text": "那些的協助也會包含在以後推動的過程內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/681.wav", + "text": "\n所以我要特別跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/682.wav", + "text": "也分享一種心情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/683.wav", + "text": "這個做法是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/684.wav", + "text": "有強度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/685.wav", + "text": "但是實際的做法是不是容我們周延一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/686.wav", + "text": "作以上補充謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/687.wav", + "text": "我們已經討論得差不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/688.wav", + "text": "你最後一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/689.wav", + "text": "補習班的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/690.wav", + "text": "剛剛應該已經處理了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/691.wav", + "text": "因為外界擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/692.wav", + "text": "拿掉以後會有不同的思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/693.wav", + "text": "所以我們不要讓他們擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/694.wav", + "text": "有沒有要做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/695.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/696.wav", + "text": "附帶決議如果要再修正就再討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/697.wav", + "text": "好不好原條文都通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/698.wav", + "text": "我先唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/699.wav", + "text": "就如同這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/700.wav", + "text": "修正草案的協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/701.wav", + "text": "第6條第37條第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/702.wav", + "text": "修正通過如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/703.wav", + "text": "第41條第45條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/704.wav", + "text": "照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/705.wav", + "text": "會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/706.wav", + "text": "附帶決議一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/707.wav", + "text": "附件四其餘均照審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/708.wav", + "text": "會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/709.wav", + "text": "五檢附立法說明一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/710.wav", + "text": "我們先休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/711.wav", + "text": "今日會議有手語老師翻譯和同步聽打服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/712.wav", + "text": "此請發言委員到質詢台發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/713.wav", + "text": "翻譯老師畫面的轉播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/714.wav", + "text": "議事轉播網際網路多媒體視訊隨選系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/715.wav", + "text": "手語翻譯老師有李振輝老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/716.wav", + "text": "及張俊仁老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/717.wav", + "text": "解健彬老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/718.wav", + "text": "陳敬家老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/719.wav", + "text": "黃姿綝老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/720.wav", + "text": "謝謝他們今天為大家服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/721.wav", + "text": "條條文先從第6條開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/722.wav", + "text": "就是鑑輔會成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/723.wav", + "text": "增加特殊教育相關家長團體代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/724.wav", + "text": "及同級衛生主管機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/725.wav", + "text": "也增加了支持服務的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/726.wav", + "text": "並在第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/727.wav", + "text": "增列鑑輔會委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/728.wav", + "text": "的規定這是上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/729.wav", + "text": "審查會已經達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/730.wav", + "text": "並做成決定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/731.wav", + "text": "辦理第1項鑑定學前教育階段業務時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/732.wav", + "text": "第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/733.wav", + "text": "規定辦理之學前教育階段兒童發展評估結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/734.wav", + "text": "於本項規定其實在第一次跟第二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/735.wav", + "text": "但萬委員美玲還是滿堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/736.wav", + "text": "的希望能夠增列相關文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/737.wav", + "text": "針此我再做以下補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/738.wav", + "text": "說明經過我們很審慎的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/739.wav", + "text": "有幾點意見要讓各位委員知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/740.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/741.wav", + "text": "包括醫療院所的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/742.wav", + "text": "晤談等等資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/743.wav", + "text": "醫療單位所提供的評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/744.wav", + "text": "其實只是可以參考的條件之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/745.wav", + "text": "不是必備的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/746.wav", + "text": "即使沒有評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/747.wav", + "text": "還是可以經由特教老師的評估晤談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/748.wav", + "text": "觀察來做判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/749.wav", + "text": "如果在本條增列該項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/750.wav", + "text": "可能會讓大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/751.wav", + "text": "這個報告是必須取得的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/752.wav", + "text": "這樣反而限縮了他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/753.wav", + "text": "取得特教資格服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/754.wav", + "text": "的可能而且會增加他去接受醫院評估的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/755.wav", + "text": "這是我們的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/756.wav", + "text": "考量故建議不要增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/757.wav", + "text": "第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/758.wav", + "text": "政府應建立六歲以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/759.wav", + "text": "兒童發展的評估機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/760.wav", + "text": "對於發展遲緩兒童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/761.wav", + "text": "應按其需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/762.wav", + "text": "給予早療醫療就學及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/763.wav", + "text": "家庭支持方面的特殊照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/764.wav", + "text": "父母及監護人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/765.wav", + "text": "要配合政府這些特殊照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/766.wav", + "text": "第3項規定的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/767.wav", + "text": "早期療癒所需要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/768.wav", + "text": "各項服務的銜接及協調機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/769.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關會同衛生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/770.wav", + "text": "教育主管機關規劃辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/771.wav", + "text": "換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/772.wav", + "text": "在兒權法第31條已予明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/773.wav", + "text": "而且是由兒權法主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/774.wav", + "text": "即社政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/775.wav", + "text": "教育主管機關規劃辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/776.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議可以免列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/777.wav", + "text": "說明得很詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/778.wav", + "text": "而且本法在委員會中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/779.wav", + "text": "很多都已經進入提會討論版本請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/780.wav", + "text": "無委員要對本條表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/781.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/782.wav", + "text": "的話第6條就依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/783.wav", + "text": "提會討論版本文字通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/784.wav", + "text": "有關學生鑑定基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/785.wav", + "text": "以及是否設置專職人員處理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/786.wav", + "text": "經過多方討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/787.wav", + "text": "第十八條已進入法案協商階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/788.wav", + "text": "建議採納本席的提案版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/789.wav", + "text": "因為根據第一線特教老師的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/790.wav", + "text": "心評工作真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/791.wav", + "text": "被大部分特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/792.wav", + "text": "了每學年的心理評量季節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/793.wav", + "text": "老師真的要耗費很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/794.wav", + "text": "去從事心評工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/795.wav", + "text": "本席上次也講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/796.wav", + "text": "每個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/797.wav", + "text": "從施測到撰寫完報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/798.wav", + "text": "需要兩天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/799.wav", + "text": "一般來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/800.wav", + "text": "每位特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/801.wav", + "text": "都需要對6至10位學生進行施測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/802.wav", + "text": "因此本席的提案較諸院版增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/803.wav", + "text": "明確規定前項所述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/804.wav", + "text": "心理評量人員應該要以專任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/805.wav", + "text": "如果真的沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/806.wav", + "text": "而且老師願意兼任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/807.wav", + "text": "也應該給予合理待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/808.wav", + "text": "以及工作上的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/809.wav", + "text": "規定應該算是最中庸的處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/810.wav", + "text": "前項評估人員以專任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/811.wav", + "text": "教師自願兼任時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/812.wav", + "text": "應給予合理之待遇及工作上之協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/813.wav", + "text": "跟各位同仁多多支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/814.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/815.wav", + "text": "經委員會審查之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/816.wav", + "text": "教育部有再做過一些對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/817.wav", + "text": "跟綜整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/818.wav", + "text": "包括跟本席做過討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/819.wav", + "text": "所以我建議第十八條應當跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/820.wav", + "text": "一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/821.wav", + "text": "討論我們現在要處理的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/822.wav", + "text": "心評人員到底能不能夠專職化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/823.wav", + "text": "或是現階段做不做得到專職化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/824.wav", + "text": "特教老師認為專職化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/825.wav", + "text": "有利於減輕他們的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/826.wav", + "text": "認為應當由特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/827.wav", + "text": "繼續執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/828.wav", + "text": "不過要讓特教老師肩負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/829.wav", + "text": "這些心評工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/830.wav", + "text": "就必須給予他合理的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/831.wav", + "text": "員會審查結束到今天協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/832.wav", + "text": "繼續跟第一線的特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/833.wav", + "text": "包括一些專業的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/834.wav", + "text": "對話認為可將第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/835.wav", + "text": "修正為前項學生及幼兒的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/836.wav", + "text": "鑑定基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/837.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/838.wav", + "text": "意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/839.wav", + "text": "還是由特教老師來肩負的話則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/840.wav", + "text": "則其相關的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/841.wav", + "text": "必要的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/842.wav", + "text": "等都要一併考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/843.wav", + "text": "就是考量到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/844.wav", + "text": "給予第一線工作loading" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/845.wav", + "text": "辛苦的特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/846.wav", + "text": "合宜的工作協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/847.wav", + "text": "我們要搭配看第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/848.wav", + "text": "最後一項新增條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/849.wav", + "text": "各級主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/850.wav", + "text": "高級中等以下學校或幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/851.wav", + "text": "指定增置由主管機關統籌運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/852.wav", + "text": "及調派之編制內特殊教育教師員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/853.wav", + "text": "用以協助辦理第十八條第一項所定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/854.wav", + "text": "鑑定評估作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/855.wav", + "text": "及辦理第一項所定特殊教育資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/856.wav", + "text": "及特殊教育輔導團業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/857.wav", + "text": "或前項所定支持網絡業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/858.wav", + "text": "即要求中央的教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/859.wav", + "text": "地方政府教育局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/860.wav", + "text": "可以彈性調派調度的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/861.wav", + "text": "而且是用編制內特教老師的員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/862.wav", + "text": "來協助也就是從外部來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/863.wav", + "text": "校園內特教老師進行心評工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/864.wav", + "text": "用增加權益的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/865.wav", + "text": "也就是給予他合理的待遇提升跟補助來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/866.wav", + "text": "這是第一軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/867.wav", + "text": "第二軌就是用外部的心評人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/868.wav", + "text": "來協助而且是編制員額內的特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/869.wav", + "text": "是有相當的訓練跟專業且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/870.wav", + "text": "對於教育線的第一現場是非常熟悉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/871.wav", + "text": "人員第5條最後一項就是第二軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/872.wav", + "text": "用外部的資源彈性地協助有需要的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/873.wav", + "text": "該學校老師認為心評工作loading過重的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/874.wav", + "text": "我們可以做到而且合理可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/875.wav", + "text": "負擔又可給予他擔負心評工作的額外補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/876.wav", + "text": "把兩軌都放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/877.wav", + "text": "第一軌放在第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/878.wav", + "text": "第二軌放在第5條最後一項新增條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/879.wav", + "text": "因此本席建議大家可以照今天的提會討論版本內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/880.wav", + "text": "我們台灣民眾黨對這部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/881.wav", + "text": "規定評估人員的資格以專任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/882.wav", + "text": "如果是兼任者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/883.wav", + "text": "應予以必要的協助跟補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/884.wav", + "text": "其實跟剛才林委員宜瑾的意見基本上是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/885.wav", + "text": "直接在條文中寫得這麼明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/886.wav", + "text": "的話當然我們也可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/887.wav", + "text": "評估人員的資格及權益寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/888.wav", + "text": "提到會局部加入專職人員為輔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/889.wav", + "text": "如果真的要這樣寫本席倒建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/890.wav", + "text": "立法說明還是回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/891.wav", + "text": "就是說這點也許可以不寫入條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/892.wav", + "text": "但是至少在說明中會比較接近我們提出的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/893.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣子會更折衷一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/894.wav", + "text": "讓大家看得更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/895.wav", + "text": "不然的話你們說會局部加入專職人員為輔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/896.wav", + "text": "到底什麼時候才會達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/897.wav", + "text": "其實我們寫的文字也沒有那麼強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/898.wav", + "text": "如果是兼職則要給予協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/899.wav", + "text": "其實精神上是差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/900.wav", + "text": "的我覺得對這個部分大家可以再稍微思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/901.wav", + "text": "折衷一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/902.wav", + "text": "請王委員婉諭發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/903.wav", + "text": "這一條其實就是大家最有疑慮或最多爭議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/904.wav", + "text": "但心評工作卻有非常多複雜的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/905.wav", + "text": "是不是會影響到學生受教權等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/906.wav", + "text": "因為他可能會有一段時間沒有辦法進行教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/907.wav", + "text": "的原因我們時代力量黨團版本所提修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/908.wav", + "text": "我們相信這些絕對不可能一步到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/909.wav", + "text": "下如何認定多少才是一個合理的案量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/910.wav", + "text": "如何在合理的案量之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/911.wav", + "text": "平不影響到他們教學的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/912.wav", + "text": "建議參酌時代力量黨團所提修正動議第3項針對在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/913.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/914.wav", + "text": "請問還有無委員要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/915.wav", + "text": "如果沒有委員要發言的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/916.wav", + "text": "本席也簡單講一下對這一條的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/917.wav", + "text": "\n本席原本提出的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/918.wav", + "text": "跟林委員宜瑾版本的意思一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/919.wav", + "text": "就是評估人員以專任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/920.wav", + "text": "教師自願兼任時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/921.wav", + "text": "應給予合理之待遇及工作上之協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/922.wav", + "text": "目的就是要解決目前心評工作的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/923.wav", + "text": "第一個困境就是耗時長負擔重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/924.wav", + "text": "如果一個學期有2至7個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/925.wav", + "text": "就要花上140個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/926.wav", + "text": "可是代課卻是看得到吃不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/927.wav", + "text": "元跟他們付出的時數不成比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/928.wav", + "text": "最後一個就是目前測驗工具缺漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/929.wav", + "text": "設置特教輔導團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/930.wav", + "text": "特教老師但本席也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/931.wav", + "text": "有將本席剛才提到的心評工作困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/932.wav", + "text": "比如工具的部分費用太低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/933.wav", + "text": "排課抵節數等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/934.wav", + "text": "如果不採用林宜瑾委員和本席所提修正條文的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/935.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/936.wav", + "text": "首先要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/937.wav", + "text": "的是依照現行特教法規定提供特教服務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/938.wav", + "text": "13類身心障礙學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/939.wav", + "text": "其中有9類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/940.wav", + "text": "就可以確定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/941.wav", + "text": "並不需要特教老師特別多做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/942.wav", + "text": "但另外有4個類別很特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/943.wav", + "text": "真的不能沒有特教老師的協助跟參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/944.wav", + "text": "這4類分別是學習障礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/945.wav", + "text": "這4個類別除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/946.wav", + "text": "平常的觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/947.wav", + "text": "跟晤談紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/948.wav", + "text": "做綜合的研判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/949.wav", + "text": "因為這些老師在平常教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/950.wav", + "text": "以及輔導他的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/951.wav", + "text": "中對這個孩子狀況的理解更為深入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/952.wav", + "text": "可以很清楚的判斷他的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/953.wav", + "text": "可以作為一個很有力的證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/954.wav", + "text": "特教老師在學生的鑑定當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/955.wav", + "text": "是不能缺少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/956.wav", + "text": "一環在英美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/957.wav", + "text": "或其他先進國家確實有由心理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/958.wav", + "text": "或者教育診斷師等專責人員來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/959.wav", + "text": "的情況不過他們是以團隊的方式進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/960.wav", + "text": "在團隊成員當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/961.wav", + "text": "仍然有特教老師存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/962.wav", + "text": "跟我們鑑定標準所定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/963.wav", + "text": "需要輔以特教老師的觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/964.wav", + "text": "晤談等等資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/965.wav", + "text": "是一樣的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/966.wav", + "text": "所以英美跟其他國家的專責人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/967.wav", + "text": "也並不是獨立完成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/968.wav", + "text": "但是我們也看到目前國內的鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/969.wav", + "text": "確實出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/970.wav", + "text": "譬如有些學校可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/971.wav", + "text": "沒有設資源班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/972.wav", + "text": "沒有特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/973.wav", + "text": "要別的學校幫個案做鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/974.wav", + "text": "又或者有些學校的案量很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/975.wav", + "text": "但就只有這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/976.wav", + "text": "老師真的承擔不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/977.wav", + "text": "負擔太重了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/978.wav", + "text": "這些都是現實的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/979.wav", + "text": "所以需要有一個調控的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/980.wav", + "text": "我們覺得這樣的調控機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/981.wav", + "text": "可能不一定要設在各個學校裡可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/982.wav", + "text": "吳委員已經有提到我們在第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/983.wav", + "text": "有關特教資源中心的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/984.wav", + "text": "規定主管機關可以擇定學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/985.wav", + "text": "增置特殊教育老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/986.wav", + "text": "來協助辦理這邊所講的鑑定工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/987.wav", + "text": "可是這個鑑定工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/988.wav", + "text": "其實是很短期很密集的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/989.wav", + "text": "之外的平常時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/990.wav", + "text": "則可從事特教資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/991.wav", + "text": "或特教行政支持網絡的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/992.wav", + "text": "這樣在人力上就可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/993.wav", + "text": "充分有效的運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/994.wav", + "text": "這些資源中心的老師確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/995.wav", + "text": "可以有效的share掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/996.wav", + "text": "過程當中可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/997.wav", + "text": "待遇太苛刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/998.wav", + "text": "案量太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/999.wav", + "text": "沒有工具等等這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1000.wav", + "text": "確實是需要處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1001.wav", + "text": "所以剛才也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1002.wav", + "text": "就是提醒要注意這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1003.wav", + "text": "同時在立法說明裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1004.wav", + "text": "即剛才提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1005.wav", + "text": "他們必須要有合理的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1006.wav", + "text": "不是特教老師要去處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1007.wav", + "text": "或者特教資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1008.wav", + "text": "對於權益這兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1009.wav", + "text": "要含括哪些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1010.wav", + "text": "做充分的陳述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1011.wav", + "text": "讓大家放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1012.wav", + "text": "將來在子法中可以明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1013.wav", + "text": "大家剛才很關注的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1014.wav", + "text": "必須要被重視被解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1015.wav", + "text": "擬了一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1016.wav", + "text": "等一下大家可以來檢視一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1017.wav", + "text": "這個文字是不是OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1018.wav", + "text": "以及不少的特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1019.wav", + "text": "特教老師參與鑑定工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1020.wav", + "text": "有助於更清楚觀察到學生的需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1021.wav", + "text": "幫助他得以通過鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1022.wav", + "text": "之後的IEP擬定執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1023.wav", + "text": "可以更一氣呵成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1024.wav", + "text": "我們也關注到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1025.wav", + "text": "資源班的師生比要調降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1026.wav", + "text": "需要參與協助鑑定的個案量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1027.wav", + "text": "一定會相當程度的降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1028.wav", + "text": "而且有了相關配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1029.wav", + "text": "再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1030.wav", + "text": "剛剛幾位委員提到以專任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1031.wav", + "text": "任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1032.wav", + "text": "比較需要陪伴了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1033.wav", + "text": "以及後續特教服務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1034.wav", + "text": "如果是抽出來由專任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1035.wav", + "text": "並且評估他以後的教學需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1036.wav", + "text": "會變成對不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1037.wav", + "text": "可是委員的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1038.wav", + "text": "果不是專任的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1039.wav", + "text": "是整合後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1040.wav", + "text": "就是我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1041.wav", + "text": "有些學校在實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1042.wav", + "text": "我們不能夠矇著眼睛當看不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1043.wav", + "text": "的問題是有自己的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1044.wav", + "text": "自己來做心評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1045.wav", + "text": "可是又有案量太多忙不過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1046.wav", + "text": "以及學校沒有這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1047.wav", + "text": "經過受訓的老師可以來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1048.wav", + "text": "為了要解決這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1049.wav", + "text": "是不是一定要全採專任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1050.wav", + "text": "我們直面問題來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1051.wav", + "text": "有些學校可能沒有人能夠做心評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1052.wav", + "text": "有些學校是案量太" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1053.wav", + "text": "自己的學生自己做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1054.wav", + "text": "以及有些學校沒有可以做心評的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1055.wav", + "text": "我們現在是要幫這些學校解決他的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1056.wav", + "text": "所以我們就提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1057.wav", + "text": "那些人就可以去協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1058.wav", + "text": "協助校內沒有人有資格做心評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1059.wav", + "text": "約略是一年的1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1060.wav", + "text": "1月多到3月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1061.wav", + "text": "直接去處理問題的所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1062.wav", + "text": "這些問題還需要有配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1063.wav", + "text": "縣市給的報酬不一定相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1064.wav", + "text": "我們就會額外爭取經費來協助他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1065.wav", + "text": "所以剛才碰到兩個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1066.wav", + "text": "是專任這個方式能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1067.wav", + "text": "符合需求剛才我已經跟大家做了實況上的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1068.wav", + "text": "量太滿或是沒有人可以做心評的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1069.wav", + "text": "這樣的專人我們已經設了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1070.wav", + "text": "這一批專人在中心那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1071.wav", + "text": "即便這樣還是有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1072.wav", + "text": "他覺得縣市間不應該不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1073.wav", + "text": "看全國的案量是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1074.wav", + "text": "經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1075.wav", + "text": "我們教育部來爭取支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1076.wav", + "text": "讓縣市間不會有差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1077.wav", + "text": "讓他做心評的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1078.wav", + "text": "可以換算節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1079.wav", + "text": "用這種整體配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1080.wav", + "text": "來解決現在心評老師的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1081.wav", + "text": "我個人也跑了很多國小國中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1082.wav", + "text": "高中甚至輔導團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1083.wav", + "text": "切切實實的就委員關心的向度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1084.wav", + "text": "做一個盤整之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1085.wav", + "text": "一方面爭取資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1086.wav", + "text": "二方面對於專職的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1087.wav", + "text": "我們用這樣比較完整的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1088.wav", + "text": "來解決目前面臨的困局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1089.wav", + "text": "謝謝署長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1090.wav", + "text": "據我們的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1091.wav", + "text": "經過剛才司長和署長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1092.wav", + "text": "十八條和第五十條的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1093.wav", + "text": "就是基於配套的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1094.wav", + "text": "才能真的幫助這些在第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1095.wav", + "text": "這麼辛苦的特教老師呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1096.wav", + "text": "第12頁的立法說明從這裡可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1097.wav", + "text": "非常清楚的看到所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1098.wav", + "text": "權益包含哪些在此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1099.wav", + "text": "同時我們將其在評鑑期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1100.wav", + "text": "心評工作和鑑定工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1101.wav", + "text": "可合理的減少其工作負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1102.wav", + "text": "這也是我們蒐集了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1103.wav", + "text": "一些老師的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1104.wav", + "text": "第二個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1105.wav", + "text": "第二項寫得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1106.wav", + "text": "要花時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1107.wav", + "text": "評估後寫報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1108.wav", + "text": "也要花許多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1109.wav", + "text": "所以對於撰寫專業評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1110.wav", + "text": "應給予合理的報酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1111.wav", + "text": "本席在此要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1112.wav", + "text": "你們要真的訂出合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1113.wav", + "text": "第三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1114.wav", + "text": "很多委員都有提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1115.wav", + "text": "政策上在軟硬體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1116.wav", + "text": "方面需給予足夠的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1117.wav", + "text": "他需要的一些施測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1118.wav", + "text": "施測的工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1119.wav", + "text": "一定要給足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1120.wav", + "text": "然後簡化他的相關作業程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1121.wav", + "text": "這些都要檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1122.wav", + "text": "\n所以依立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1123.wav", + "text": "在第十八條的文字用了三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1124.wav", + "text": "第一是調整節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1125.wav", + "text": "第二是給與合理待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1126.wav", + "text": "第三是其他工具相當的配給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1127.wav", + "text": "補足都要做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1128.wav", + "text": "這就是我同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1129.wav", + "text": "用增加權益兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1130.wav", + "text": "含括這三個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1131.wav", + "text": "\n第5條的第二個配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1132.wav", + "text": "就是剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1133.wav", + "text": "我們設在校外的特教資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1134.wav", + "text": "去支援人數不夠的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1135.wav", + "text": "或者是心評期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1136.wav", + "text": "今年剛好進來的學生特別多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1137.wav", + "text": "剛好在心評工作是爆量的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1138.wav", + "text": "用這種外部彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1139.wav", + "text": "而且是專業的特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1140.wav", + "text": "來兼任的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1141.wav", + "text": "人力的有效運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1142.wav", + "text": "然後能夠來減緩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1143.wav", + "text": "特教老師的評估作業loading" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1144.wav", + "text": "過重的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1145.wav", + "text": "\n所以兩個條文這樣的配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1146.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常的全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1147.wav", + "text": "希望大家能夠支持現在的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1148.wav", + "text": "聽起來大家應該都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1149.wav", + "text": "那我就再做清楚的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1150.wav", + "text": "希望能夠讓大家接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1151.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳思瑤委員幫忙說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1152.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1153.wav", + "text": "因為這個心評的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1154.wav", + "text": "我想各位委員都很關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1155.wav", + "text": "我們在第一現場的所有老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1156.wav", + "text": "一直都希望這個議題能夠確實得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1157.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛司長還有署長的說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1158.wav", + "text": "也是經過非常詳細的討論跟評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1159.wav", + "text": "所以才會在第十八條搭配第五十條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1160.wav", + "text": "來解決這個目前現場所處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1161.wav", + "text": "相關問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1162.wav", + "text": "\n剛才司長署長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1163.wav", + "text": "加上剛才吳委員也來做補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1164.wav", + "text": "我也特別跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1165.wav", + "text": "特教學生的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1166.wav", + "text": "以及目前我們需要持續去進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1167.wav", + "text": "一定是一個可以及時到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1168.wav", + "text": "像心評工作經過實際上的了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1169.wav", + "text": "也都知道對於現在具有心評訓練的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1170.wav", + "text": "特教老師其工作負擔真的是超過負荷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1171.wav", + "text": "在之前第一階段的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1172.wav", + "text": "我覺得那只是一個基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1173.wav", + "text": "所以剛才委員所提到的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1174.wav", + "text": "雖然用權益兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1175.wav", + "text": "但是教育部事實上是已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1176.wav", + "text": "非常深入的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1177.wav", + "text": "不管對工作時間轉換服務的節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1178.wav", + "text": "工作的報酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1179.wav", + "text": "以及合理負擔的數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1180.wav", + "text": "很詳細的評估\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1181.wav", + "text": "\n我也跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1182.wav", + "text": "在之前另外的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1183.wav", + "text": "針對有關資源班生師比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1184.wav", + "text": "這個其實我也透過附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1185.wav", + "text": "來同意應該逐年來改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1186.wav", + "text": "可以共同協助心評工作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1187.wav", + "text": "特教老師的一個未來的來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1188.wav", + "text": "所以我想如果從這樣綜整來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1189.wav", + "text": "確實我們希望以這樣的方式來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1190.wav", + "text": "但又需要特教老師的幫忙之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1191.wav", + "text": "我們希望在這個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1192.wav", + "text": "\n第5條也是之前委員們都關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1193.wav", + "text": "各縣市的特教資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1194.wav", + "text": "是一個推動特教非常重要的專業單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1195.wav", + "text": "當時也在評估這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1196.wav", + "text": "應該要能夠建立比較永續的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1197.wav", + "text": "這個人員又不希望像過去這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1198.wav", + "text": "動輒都是用借調的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1199.wav", + "text": "委員們又擔心會影響到特教孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1200.wav", + "text": "為什麼把第5條做成加置員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1201.wav", + "text": "的都是在鑑輔會之前的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1202.wav", + "text": "這個部分可以來協助有特教生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1203.wav", + "text": "但沒有相關特教老師的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1204.wav", + "text": "的但長期特教資源中心的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1205.wav", + "text": "就會是用專任而不是用借調的員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1206.wav", + "text": "也在委員的指教之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1207.wav", + "text": "評估出目前這樣的一個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1208.wav", + "text": "\n對於特教老師們的投入跟辛勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1209.wav", + "text": "我自己在內部也要求同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1210.wav", + "text": "這些雖然當時我們還在討論過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1211.wav", + "text": "包含特教助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1212.wav", + "text": "會在113年的經費來做反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1213.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠以最快的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1214.wav", + "text": "對於剛才所談到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1215.wav", + "text": "包含我們這次在整個立法上面構想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1216.wav", + "text": "第5條的這些都能夠在113年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1217.wav", + "text": "心評工作的特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1218.wav", + "text": "我想這個議題教育部應該要直接面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1219.wav", + "text": "希望能夠透過這樣的方式來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1220.wav", + "text": "\n委員剛才所提相關的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1221.wav", + "text": "我也建議可以透過附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1222.wav", + "text": "讓行政機關在這件事情上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1223.wav", + "text": "可以具體的落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1224.wav", + "text": "也回應我們第一現場老師們的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1225.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員們從討論到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1226.wav", + "text": "教育部也很務實的去提到這樣的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1227.wav", + "text": "跟未來人員人力還有怎麼樣去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1228.wav", + "text": "增加協助減輕老師們的負擔這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1229.wav", + "text": "我想我們就透過這個模式把它具體化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1230.wav", + "text": "我也以這樣的態度跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1231.wav", + "text": "如果委員們也能夠同意目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1232.wav", + "text": "第十八條跟第五十條這樣的條文設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1233.wav", + "text": "也希望我們透過附帶決議的一些具體的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1234.wav", + "text": "來做為後續落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1235.wav", + "text": "也是委員對行政機關的期待跟要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1236.wav", + "text": "我請教部長一個問題就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1237.wav", + "text": "就是關於增置員額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1238.wav", + "text": "我們非常開心看到這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1239.wav", + "text": "所以在第5條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1240.wav", + "text": "是不是我們日後可以逐漸的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1241.wav", + "text": "在特教資源中心跟特殊教育輔導團裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1242.wav", + "text": "都逐漸會由專任的員額調派過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1243.wav", + "text": "對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1244.wav", + "text": "我應該說資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1245.wav", + "text": "因為輔導團比較不像這個屬性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1246.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1247.wav", + "text": "那個員額是增置員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1248.wav", + "text": "不是又從學校把他調過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1249.wav", + "text": "其實我們已經實質討論到第5條的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1250.wav", + "text": "那兩條是連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1251.wav", + "text": "的我的建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1252.wav", + "text": "看完之後我們再回來確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1253.wav", + "text": "因為第十八條剛剛就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1254.wav", + "text": "以增加評估人員的權益的這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1255.wav", + "text": "但是說明中剛剛有很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1256.wav", + "text": "把特教老師兼任的那些問題包括抵減時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1257.wav", + "text": "還有就是工具跟評估的專業支持都有寫進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1258.wav", + "text": "其實剛剛部長也有講到第5條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1259.wav", + "text": "所以我建議第十八條暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1260.wav", + "text": "我們再回來第十八條確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1261.wav", + "text": "然後再進入最後一條──第二十三條好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1262.wav", + "text": "\n第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1263.wav", + "text": "附帶決議就待會一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1264.wav", + "text": "第5條是在第22頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1265.wav", + "text": "我們就直接來看這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1266.wav", + "text": "這樣大家的疑問就可以一起解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1267.wav", + "text": "還有特教輔導團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1268.wav", + "text": "特教的支持網絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1269.wav", + "text": "還有資源中心設置的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1270.wav", + "text": "等於是至少這邊是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1271.wav", + "text": "有專職化的人員可以借調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1272.wav", + "text": "學校的特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1273.wav", + "text": "有沒有委員要表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1274.wav", + "text": "還是教育部有沒有要再說明\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1275.wav", + "text": "我想大方向沒有太大的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1276.wav", + "text": "因為的確特殊教育老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1277.wav", + "text": "已經算是一個非常吃重的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1278.wav", + "text": "而且人數其實相對是不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1279.wav", + "text": "還需要增加的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1280.wav", + "text": "院版提出來修正的第4項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1281.wav", + "text": "特殊教育教師員額來協助心評的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1282.wav", + "text": "可是原本的心評工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1283.wav", + "text": "其實不只是特殊教育的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1284.wav", + "text": "可能還包含了具有輔導專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1285.wav", + "text": "心理等專長的指導老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1286.wav", + "text": "又或者是現職合格的輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1287.wav", + "text": "心理專業人員等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1288.wav", + "text": "和統籌運用的範圍限縮在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1289.wav", + "text": "特教老師是有特別的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1290.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1291.wav", + "text": "更寬廣的心評人員的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1292.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1293.wav", + "text": "這個是特教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1294.wav", + "text": "也是特教資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1295.wav", + "text": "所以是對準這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1296.wav", + "text": "部分基本上能夠有資格的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1297.wav", + "text": "您剛才講的那類人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1298.wav", + "text": "他本來在執行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1299.wav", + "text": "因為這是特教法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1300.wav", + "text": "能夠做規範的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1301.wav", + "text": "屬於特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1302.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1303.wav", + "text": "看一下螢幕上的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1304.wav", + "text": "就增加的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1305.wav", + "text": "我唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1306.wav", + "text": "各級主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1307.wav", + "text": "得於公立高級中等以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1308.wav", + "text": "學校或幼兒園指定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1309.wav", + "text": "增置由主管機關統籌運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1310.wav", + "text": "及調派之編制內特殊教育教師員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1311.wav", + "text": "用以協助辦理第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1312.wav", + "text": "第一項所定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1313.wav", + "text": "鑑定評估作業及辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1314.wav", + "text": "第一項所定特殊教育資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1315.wav", + "text": "及特殊教育輔導團業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1316.wav", + "text": "或前項所定支持網絡業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1317.wav", + "text": "增加的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1318.wav", + "text": "就是我們今天提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1319.wav", + "text": "委員會版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1320.wav", + "text": "有沒有委員有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1321.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1322.wav", + "text": "提會討論版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1323.wav", + "text": "剛剛的第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1324.wav", + "text": "101112頁的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1325.wav", + "text": "剛剛的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1326.wav", + "text": "其實有把大家擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1327.wav", + "text": "文字的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1328.wav", + "text": "就是增加評估人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1329.wav", + "text": "之資格及權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1330.wav", + "text": "權益至少剛剛有很具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1331.wav", + "text": "把我們很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1332.wav", + "text": "減輕特教老師做評估的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1333.wav", + "text": "問題包含抵減節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1334.wav", + "text": "合理報酬評估工具的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1335.wav", + "text": "與評估專業的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1336.wav", + "text": "都有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1337.wav", + "text": "林宜瑾委員要先走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1338.wav", + "text": "他有跟我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1339.wav", + "text": "經過教育部的說明之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1340.wav", + "text": "他可以接受提會討論的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1341.wav", + "text": "我也可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1342.wav", + "text": "我們逐步專業化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1343.wav", + "text": "目前是做到局部專職化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1344.wav", + "text": "負擔過長的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1345.wav", + "text": "你們都有具體講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1346.wav", + "text": "另外還有附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1347.wav", + "text": "但我想我們先把第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1348.wav", + "text": "條文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1349.wav", + "text": "提會討論的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1350.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1351.wav", + "text": "第十八條有兩個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1352.wav", + "text": "審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1353.wav", + "text": "當時沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1354.wav", + "text": "保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1355.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1356.wav", + "text": "問題是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1357.wav", + "text": "只是要請你們於三個月內如何減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1358.wav", + "text": "其實這裡面有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1359.wav", + "text": "併案好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1360.wav", + "text": "好另外還有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1361.wav", + "text": "我看內容也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1362.wav", + "text": "就是要你們納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1363.wav", + "text": "評估人員以專業為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1364.wav", + "text": "大家看完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1365.wav", + "text": "因為這是你們教育部OK的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1366.wav", + "text": "你們提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1367.wav", + "text": "今天可能有一些委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1368.wav", + "text": "事前有跟我們研商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1369.wav", + "text": "到時候能不能補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1370.wav", + "text": "我們應該可以補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1371.wav", + "text": "吧今天沒有來的能否補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1372.wav", + "text": "我們今天先簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1373.wav", + "text": "你們後面還是可以補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1374.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1375.wav", + "text": "主席裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1376.wav", + "text": "因為他已經事先聲明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1377.wav", + "text": "我們就讓他補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1378.wav", + "text": "表示他很在意這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1379.wav", + "text": "林宜瑾委員剛剛也有交代了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1380.wav", + "text": "他們兩位都非常在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1381.wav", + "text": "也很關心這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1382.wav", + "text": "我們就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1383.wav", + "text": "如何逐步落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1384.wav", + "text": "我們也會繼續監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1385.wav", + "text": "其實我們剛剛講的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1386.wav", + "text": "都應該節數化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1387.wav", + "text": "然後調整融合的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1388.wav", + "text": "都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1389.wav", + "text": "工具的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1390.wav", + "text": "非必要的重新鑑定應該避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1391.wav", + "text": "督導地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1392.wav", + "text": "特教資源中心的建制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1393.wav", + "text": "制教師的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1394.wav", + "text": "簡化評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1395.wav", + "text": "以及剛剛有講到研議學前發展遲緩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1396.wav", + "text": "到國小1年級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1397.wav", + "text": "還有評估工作撰寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1398.wav", + "text": "綜合報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1399.wav", + "text": "要給予合理費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1400.wav", + "text": "大家關心的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1401.wav", + "text": "附帶決議處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1402.wav", + "text": "\n現在處理第23條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1403.wav", + "text": "關於學生申訴再申訴機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1404.wav", + "text": "因為當時是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1405.wav", + "text": "我們等國教法處理完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1406.wav", + "text": "精神原則應該一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1407.wav", + "text": "請大家翻到第14頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1408.wav", + "text": "也是我們今天最後一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1409.wav", + "text": "\n這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1410.wav", + "text": "有沒有委員要先發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1411.wav", + "text": "或是教育部要直接說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1412.wav", + "text": "吳司長是不是要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1413.wav", + "text": "上次第23條會保留的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1414.wav", + "text": "是因為在國教法第4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1415.wav", + "text": "有同樣的申訴規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1416.wav", + "text": "國中國小階段的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1417.wav", + "text": "兩邊作法可能需要同步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1418.wav", + "text": "所以才保留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1419.wav", + "text": "國教法在討論這塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1420.wav", + "text": "我們有做了一些文字的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1421.wav", + "text": "也有提供一些文字修正的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1422.wav", + "text": "是否請李處長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1423.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1424.wav", + "text": "今天提供會場上的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1425.wav", + "text": "最主要就是配合國教法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1426.wav", + "text": "因為國教法學生的教育階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1427.wav", + "text": "都是15歲以下的學童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1428.wav", + "text": "所以必須由他的法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1429.wav", + "text": "由其法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1430.wav", + "text": "實際照顧者代為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1431.wav", + "text": "這是一種類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1432.wav", + "text": "如果他已經是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1433.wav", + "text": "高級中等教育階段的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1434.wav", + "text": "特殊教育學生的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1435.wav", + "text": "就可以由學生單獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1436.wav", + "text": "這是配合高級中等教育法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1437.wav", + "text": "申訴可以單獨提起的體例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1438.wav", + "text": "後段是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1439.wav", + "text": "提起訴願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1440.wav", + "text": "要移轉管轄的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1441.wav", + "text": "要通知原來誤提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1442.wav", + "text": "實際照顧者或高級中等教育階段的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1443.wav", + "text": "特殊教育學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1444.wav", + "text": "這是第2項的補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1445.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分要再跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1446.wav", + "text": "補充說明的地方就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1447.wav", + "text": "原來的第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1448.wav", + "text": "法定代理人實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1449.wav", + "text": "可以就鑑定安置輔導的部分來提起申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1450.wav", + "text": "就跟第2項不太一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1451.wav", + "text": "所以我們會建議修正為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1452.wav", + "text": "得由學生或幼兒之法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1453.wav", + "text": "或由高級中等以上教育階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1454.wav", + "text": "特殊教育學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1455.wav", + "text": "後面是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1456.wav", + "text": "好有沒有委員要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1457.wav", + "text": "相關期限是在子法裡面定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1458.wav", + "text": "因為特殊教育法的立法體例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1459.wav", + "text": "與國民教育法不太一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1460.wav", + "text": "前項申訴之範圍期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1461.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1462.wav", + "text": "這個部分在國民教育階段的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1463.wav", + "text": "是要給與40天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1464.wav", + "text": "會在子法裡面配合辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1465.wav", + "text": "以上補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1466.wav", + "text": "對這就是我的疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1467.wav", + "text": "剛剛國教法是很清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1468.wav", + "text": "我們增加了實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1469.wav", + "text": "在特教的部分還有高級中學的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1470.wav", + "text": "這個都OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1471.wav", + "text": "而申訴之提起有一定的期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1472.wav", + "text": "在國教法是40天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1473.wav", + "text": "而且是以書面為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1474.wav", + "text": "但現在特教法同樣的這一條就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1475.wav", + "text": "這個部分是由相關事項之辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1476.wav", + "text": "就是你會另外訂一個辦法就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1477.wav", + "text": "所以不需要寫進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1478.wav", + "text": "那我就在這裡確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1479.wav", + "text": "日期跟形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1480.wav", + "text": "就比照40天內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1481.wav", + "text": "以及書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1482.wav", + "text": "對吧好如果是這樣我就沒有問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1483.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1484.wav", + "text": "所以現在就是幾天的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1485.wav", + "text": "至少不要低於40天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1486.wav", + "text": "你們子法再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1487.wav", + "text": "然後通知也要包含學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1488.wav", + "text": "那個也可以修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1489.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1490.wav", + "text": "已經有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1491.wav", + "text": "學生及法定代理人都要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1492.wav", + "text": "報告委員因為國民教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1493.wav", + "text": "跟特殊教育法的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1494.wav", + "text": "和提起處理結果的規範不太一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1495.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的是申訴處理結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1496.wav", + "text": "要通知可以申請的法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1497.wav", + "text": "實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1498.wav", + "text": "跟高中教育階段的學生以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1499.wav", + "text": "還有所有的學生都要通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1500.wav", + "text": "這個條文在特教法裡面是沒有規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1501.wav", + "text": "都是在子法裡面規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1502.wav", + "text": "可是我看你第23條提委員會的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1503.wav", + "text": "並通知學生及其法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1504.wav", + "text": "那個是誤提起訴願的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1505.wav", + "text": "移轉管轄的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1506.wav", + "text": "譬如原來提起的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1507.wav", + "text": "法定代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1508.wav", + "text": "但是提錯地方了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1509.wav", + "text": "從訴願機關移轉回申訴委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1510.wav", + "text": "員會來並通知提起人弄錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1511.wav", + "text": "所以這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1512.wav", + "text": "跟處理結果的通知是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1513.wav", + "text": "好我這邊有一個提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1514.wav", + "text": "我知道你們現在的概念是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1515.wav", + "text": "是希望把實際照顧者也放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1516.wav", + "text": "和實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1517.wav", + "text": "如果他們彼此意見有矛盾的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1518.wav", + "text": "你們細節上要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1519.wav", + "text": "比如說有一種可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1520.wav", + "text": "但法定代理人是爸爸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1521.wav", + "text": "他們都拿到通知之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1522.wav", + "text": "另外一方卻不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1523.wav", + "text": "那這個怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1524.wav", + "text": "已經有做處理了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1525.wav", + "text": "這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1526.wav", + "text": "我想詢問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1527.wav", + "text": "在法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1528.wav", + "text": "和實際照顧者這個條文的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1529.wav", + "text": "出現在很多地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1530.wav", + "text": "其實都有張委員所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1531.wav", + "text": "說明中都有說得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1532.wav", + "text": "主要還是法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1533.wav", + "text": "只有在法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1534.wav", + "text": "譬如說入監服刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1535.wav", + "text": "或者因為什麼情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1536.wav", + "text": "找不到法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1537.wav", + "text": "他一定有實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1538.wav", + "text": "這個時候實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1539.wav", + "text": "的角色才會出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1540.wav", + "text": "在立法說明中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1541.wav", + "text": "有完整的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1542.wav", + "text": "這邊我是有點不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1543.wav", + "text": "啦當然法條體例不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1544.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1545.wav", + "text": "在國教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1546.wav", + "text": "我們是改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1547.wav", + "text": "通知回來要給本人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1548.wav", + "text": "及法定代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1549.wav", + "text": "然後受理訴願機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1550.wav", + "text": "和結果為什麼結果不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1551.wav", + "text": "也通知特��學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1552.wav", + "text": "及法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1553.wav", + "text": "因為這樣一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1554.wav", + "text": "啊都已經在訴願了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1555.wav", + "text": "不能等同於國教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1556.wav", + "text": "國教生的位置嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1557.wav", + "text": "高級中等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1558.wav", + "text": "國教法裡頭有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1559.wav", + "text": "關申訴的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1560.wav", + "text": "其實在特教法的子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1561.wav", + "text": "特教學生的申訴辦法裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1562.wav", + "text": "都會規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1563.wav", + "text": "只是考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1564.wav", + "text": "這些條文如果統統放進母" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1565.wav", + "text": "有很多細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1566.wav", + "text": "不是司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1567.wav", + "text": "針對這裡已經文字化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1568.wav", + "text": "加個學生就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1569.wav", + "text": "跟剛剛一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1570.wav", + "text": "並通知學生及學生法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1571.wav", + "text": "一樣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1572.wav", + "text": "跟我們剛剛國教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1573.wav", + "text": "不一樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1574.wav", + "text": "剛才那個是申訴的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1575.wav", + "text": "耶那為什麼更高層不能通知本人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1576.wav", + "text": "因為訴願通常都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1577.wav", + "text": "由法定代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1578.wav", + "text": "喔是因為法律原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1579.wav", + "text": "不能通知本人嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1580.wav", + "text": "因為增加進去是多通知一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1581.wav", + "text": "本來不是提起的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1582.wav", + "text": "如果委員會這邊認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1583.wav", + "text": "這樣是比較完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1584.wav", + "text": "也就是提起的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1585.wav", + "text": "但是移轉管轄的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1586.wav", + "text": "也一併通知學生的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1587.wav", + "text": "加進去是無害啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1588.wav", + "text": "但就是說有沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1589.wav", + "text": "無害我們就加入吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1590.wav", + "text": "多通知一個應該OK吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1591.wav", + "text": "吧特教生本人應該被尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1592.wav", + "text": "無害的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1593.wav", + "text": "就要通知了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1594.wav", + "text": "後面就不用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1595.wav", + "text": "特教生本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1596.wav", + "text": "好通知學生及其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1597.wav", + "text": "法定代理人然後實際���顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1598.wav", + "text": "然後或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1599.wav", + "text": "好文字順一下就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1600.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛這邊才修過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1601.wav", + "text": "螢幕上修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1602.wav", + "text": "學生本人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1603.wav", + "text": "跟剛剛國教法那邊一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1604.wav", + "text": "至少有寫出來的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1605.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1606.wav", + "text": "並通知學生及其法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1607.wav", + "text": "或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1608.wav", + "text": "那後面高級中等學校就不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1609.wav", + "text": "喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1610.wav", + "text": "都是學生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1611.wav", + "text": "前面已經將學生包含進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1612.wav", + "text": "非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1613.wav", + "text": "這樣文字還更精簡第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1614.wav", + "text": "大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1615.wav", + "text": "有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1616.wav", + "text": "對學生與幼兒鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1617.wav", + "text": "如有爭議得由學生或幼兒之法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1618.wav", + "text": "實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1619.wav", + "text": "代為或由高級中等以上教育階段特殊教育學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1620.wav", + "text": "向主管機關提起申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1621.wav", + "text": "OK嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1622.wav", + "text": "條修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1623.wav", + "text": "第52條請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1624.wav", + "text": "問在第幾頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1625.wav", + "text": "因為那個不是在保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1626.wav", + "text": "是我們事後發現的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1627.wav", + "text": "第52條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1628.wav", + "text": "有關於特教評鑑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1629.wav", + "text": "因為大家手上沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1630.wav", + "text": "這邊有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1631.wav", + "text": "要注意看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1632.wav", + "text": "因為第1項是對學校的評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1633.wav", + "text": "第2項是對主管機關的評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1634.wav", + "text": "那文字敘寫不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1635.wav", + "text": "第1項是每四年至少應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1636.wav", + "text": "第2項是應至少每四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1637.wav", + "text": "兩邊其實意思是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1638.wav", + "text": "但是敘寫的文字不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1639.wav", + "text": "我們是建議修正第2項文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1640.wav", + "text": "比照第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1641.wav", + "text": "就是每四年至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1642.wav", + "text": "每四年至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1643.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1644.wav", + "text": "委員有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1645.wav", + "text": "每四年至少應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1646.wav", + "text": "都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1647.wav", + "text": "下面是中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1648.wav", + "text": "每四年至少好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1649.wav", + "text": "果委員沒有其他反對意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1650.wav", + "text": "教育部的修正文字第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1651.wav", + "text": "有兩個新的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1652.wav", + "text": "大家手上有拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1653.wav", + "text": "有沒有任何意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1654.wav", + "text": "在看附帶決議之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1655.wav", + "text": "我還是要提醒一下教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1656.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1657.wav", + "text": "我們針對國教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1658.wav", + "text": "委員如果對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1659.wav", + "text": "當初沒有保留協商的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1660.wav", + "text": "要提出來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1661.wav", + "text": "我們在會議之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1662.wav", + "text": "要先提出向主席報准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1663.wav", + "text": "而且我們要有附帶臨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1664.wav", + "text": "那你現在突然冒出了這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1665.wav", + "text": "當然是補破網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1666.wav", + "text": "但是程序還是程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1667.wav", + "text": "我們委員是這樣要求我們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1668.wav", + "text": "你們應該也這樣要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1669.wav", + "text": "才是對委員會的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1670.wav", + "text": "本席謝謝吳思瑤委員的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1671.wav", + "text": "因為吳思瑤委員比較資深" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1672.wav", + "text": "教育部這樣處理並不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1673.wav", + "text": "因為你今天的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1674.wav", + "text": "沒什麼爭議所以OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1675.wav", + "text": "否則你其實應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1676.wav", + "text": "也要拜託委員幫你提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1677.wav", + "text": "要不然我們手上都沒有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1678.wav", + "text": "我們所有委員都要一起負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1679.wav", + "text": "你要找人提案連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1680.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1681.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳思瑤委員提醒大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1682.wav", + "text": "也請教育部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1683.wav", + "text": "要提出修正文字的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1684.wav", + "text": "已經通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1685.wav", + "text": "用修正動議的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1686.wav", + "text": "\n附帶決議1的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1687.wav", + "text": "教育部有沒有什麼要說明和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1688.wav", + "text": "要不要表達一下意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1689.wav", + "text": "有兩個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1690.wav", + "text": "現在大家手上都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1691.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委跟四位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1692.wav", + "text": "委員請看第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1693.wav", + "text": "一個個案不低於1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1694.wav", + "text": "這點我們朝這個方向來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1695.wav", + "text": "因為我們也去看了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1696.wav", + "text": "有些報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1697.wav", + "text": "如果用字數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1698.wav", + "text": "可能也不一定對老師有利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1699.wav", + "text": "是不是就用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1700.wav", + "text": "不要低於1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1701.wav", + "text": "因為現在縣市在執行過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1702.wav", + "text": "可能礙於經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1703.wav", + "text": "的確有可能低於1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1704.wav", + "text": "現在我們新的年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1705.wav", + "text": "部長剛才已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1706.wav", + "text": "我們來幫縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1707.wav", + "text": "處理到位未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1708.wav", + "text": "我們是否就採一種標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1709.wav", + "text": "比較不會讓老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1710.wav", + "text": "和縣市在執行的時候不好處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1711.wav", + "text": "我們就用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1712.wav", + "text": "怕有些字數少的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1713.wav", + "text": "老師其實很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1714.wav", + "text": "如果只是因為字少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1715.wav", + "text": "又要讓他寫那麼多字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1716.wav", + "text": "其實有些也沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1717.wav", + "text": "我們就給請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1718.wav", + "text": "針對這個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1719.wav", + "text": "我想詢問一下教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1720.wav", + "text": "剛剛的第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1721.wav", + "text": "對於這些特殊教育老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1722.wav", + "text": "在做鑑定工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1723.wav", + "text": "要給與他的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1724.wav", + "text": "權益的部分要怎麼弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1725.wav", + "text": "你們本來就要訂一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1726.wav", + "text": "子法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1727.wav", + "text": "所以既然有一個子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1728.wav", + "text": "現在又有一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1729.wav", + "text": "撰寫稿件的基準費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1730.wav", + "text": "會不會有一點怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1731.wav", + "text": "因為他其實是更多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1732.wav", + "text": "就是說他的權益面向更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1733.wav", + "text": "不是只有撰寫報告的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1734.wav", + "text": "婉諭委員是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1735.wav", + "text": "能夠有個保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1736.wav", + "text": "希望你們提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1737.wav", + "text": "搞不好我們比這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1738.wav", + "text": "更優渥也不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1739.wav", + "text": "中央政府各級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1740.wav", + "text": "出席費跟稿費支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1741.wav", + "text": "我質詢過後就有所提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1742.wav", + "text": "就是我有爭取到提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1743.wav", + "text": "所以這當然是比照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1744.wav", + "text": "所有公務機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1745.wav", + "text": "包括學校都要一併提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1746.wav", + "text": "因此我很想得到你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1747.wav", + "text": "答案搞不好比這個更優渥啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1748.wav", + "text": "有需要針對權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1749.wav", + "text": "合理待遇的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1750.wav", + "text": "這是我比較不太理解的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1751.wav", + "text": "\n我當然支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1752.wav", + "text": "要用最新上路的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1753.wav", + "text": "甚至要給得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1754.wav", + "text": "給得更優渥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1755.wav", + "text": "只是教育部要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1756.wav", + "text": "委員的立意都是非常良善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1757.wav", + "text": "而且希望要求你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1758.wav", + "text": "做到更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1759.wav", + "text": "保障老師權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1760.wav", + "text": "只是我覺得好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1761.wav", + "text": "你們說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1762.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1763.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛我們就講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1764.wav", + "text": "現狀就是1," + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1765.wav", + "text": "0元當然我們要改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1766.wav", + "text": "可是剛剛也有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1767.wav", + "text": "會抵減節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1768.wav", + "text": "節數這邊涉及到的是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1769.wav", + "text": "不只是心評而是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1770.wav", + "text": "全部的學校出席費及稿費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1771.wav", + "text": "支給要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1772.wav", + "text": "所以這點要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1773.wav", + "text": "今天主題更大的部分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1774.wav", + "text": "這邊王委員有要說明嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1775.wav", + "text": "我想先釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1776.wav", + "text": "以字數來做處理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1777.wav", + "text": "其實是已經通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1778.wav", + "text": "而且公布修正的部分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1779.wav", + "text": "\n只是在我們現在的心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1780.wav", + "text": "作業參考原則之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1781.wav", + "text": "原本依照支給要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1782.wav", + "text": "其實應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1783.wav", + "text": "要每次1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1784.wav", + "text": "每千字多少錢來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1785.wav", + "text": "而是這個支給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1786.wav", + "text": "在2022年12月20" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1787.wav", + "text": "只是在這樣的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1788.wav", + "text": "如果沒有做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1789.wav", + "text": "其實是沒有辦法符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1790.wav", + "text": "現在新通過的支給要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1791.wav", + "text": "所以應該是要配合這個要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1792.wav", + "text": "來做相對應的協調和調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1793.wav", + "text": "\n當然今天有新的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1794.wav", + "text": "是大家一起提案通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1795.wav", + "text": "一起納入併案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1796.wav", + "text": "這沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1797.wav", + "text": "但是我認為這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1798.wav", + "text": "還是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1799.wav", + "text": "去年已經通過的要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1800.wav", + "text": "在這個參考原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1801.wav", + "text": "已經是比較低的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1802.wav", + "text": "已經有新的要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1803.wav", + "text": "通過是比較高的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1804.wav", + "text": "跟著新的要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1805.wav", + "text": "一起做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1806.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1807.wav", + "text": "所以王婉諭委員的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1808.wav", + "text": "是可以併入原來第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1809.wav", + "text": "也是類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1810.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛你們給資料時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1811.wav", + "text": "還沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1812.wav", + "text": "第十八條新的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1813.wav", + "text": "新的部分一起處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1814.wav", + "text": "因為兩個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1815.wav", + "text": "好像都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1816.wav", + "text": "跟大家意見一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1817.wav", + "text": "\n因為剛剛已經通過一些原則了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1818.wav", + "text": "現在又有附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1819.wav", + "text": "要求教育部整體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1820.wav", + "text": "相關的更細節的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1821.wav", + "text": "我想補充說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1822.wav", + "text": "併案我覺得沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1823.wav", + "text": "等這些統計資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1824.wav", + "text": "因為我們看到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1825.wav", + "text": "比較爭議的心評人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1826.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有專職化的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1827.wav", + "text": "其實大家對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1828.wav", + "text": "到底會不會影響到教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1829.wav", + "text": "又或者是否適量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1830.wav", + "text": "或家長團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1831.wav", + "text": "其實都有一些不同的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1832.wav", + "text": "我覺得問題就在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1833.wav", + "text": "並沒有那麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1834.wav", + "text": "還是希望教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1835.wav", + "text": "在未來的調整方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1836.wav", + "text": "上能夠朝著這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1837.wav", + "text": "來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1838.wav", + "text": "就是把相關資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1839.wav", + "text": "平均案量接案次數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1840.wav", + "text": "等分配的統計資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1841.wav", + "text": "能夠逐年讓大家理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1842.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1843.wav", + "text": "謝謝王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1844.wav", + "text": "這個是否有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1845.wav", + "text": "在第十八條附帶決議中還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1846.wav", + "text": "現在是附帶決議2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1847.wav", + "text": "因為附帶決議1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1848.wav", + "text": "剛剛王婉諭委員有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1849.wav", + "text": "其實意思是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1850.wav", + "text": "就是待遇的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1851.wav", + "text": "或者抵節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1852.wav", + "text": "都要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1853.wav", + "text": "現在附帶決議2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1854.wav", + "text": "比較是關於公開相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1855.wav", + "text": "合格人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1856.wav", + "text": "分配等統計指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1857.wav", + "text": "就是公開的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1858.wav", + "text": "教育部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1859.wav", + "text": "同意或者是修正後同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1860.wav", + "text": "還是要用併入的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1861.wav", + "text": "請回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1862.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1863.wav", + "text": "謝謝王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1864.wav", + "text": "王委員現在所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1865.wav", + "text": "我們檢視一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1866.wav", + "text": "剛剛幾位委員共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1867.wav", + "text": "擬的第十八條七點附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1868.wav", + "text": "基本上王委員所提的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1869.wav", + "text": "在我們去處理相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1870.wav", + "text": "事項的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1871.wav", + "text": "應該要有的基本訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1872.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1873.wav", + "text": "目前看到委員所擬的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1874.wav", + "text": "是委員們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1875.wav", + "text": "大家一起共提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1876.wav", + "text": "是指我們要處理好那些事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1877.wav", + "text": "那自然會做到王委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1878.wav", + "text": "要有那些數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1879.wav", + "text": "我們才能決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1880.wav", + "text": "因此初步來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1881.wav", + "text": "如果單獨看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1882.wav", + "text": "王委員所提的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1883.wav", + "text": "我們沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1884.wav", + "text": "但因為它本來就會併到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1885.wav", + "text": "一定要做的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1886.wav", + "text": "謝謝王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1887.wav", + "text": "若要單獨同意這個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1888.wav", + "text": "我們沒有特別的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1889.wav", + "text": "但也跟王委員特別報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1890.wav", + "text": "我們在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1891.wav", + "text": "那七點附帶決議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1892.wav", + "text": "一定是要基於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1893.wav", + "text": "這些透明的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1894.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見就同意吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1895.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1896.wav", + "text": "請吳委員思瑤發言婉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1897.wav", + "text": "婉諭委員的這個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1898.wav", + "text": "因為我不了解現況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1899.wav", + "text": "就是說每位心評人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1900.wav", + "text": "每學年的總案量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1901.wav", + "text": "以不高於十案為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1902.wav", + "text": "我不曉得現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1903.wav", + "text": "average是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1904.wav", + "text": "所以我沒有辦法判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1905.wav", + "text": "十案不得高於或低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1906.wav", + "text": "是否合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1907.wav", + "text": "因為我們如果要通過這個條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1908.wav", + "text": "文就必須很慎重的來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1909.wav", + "text": "我的認知是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1910.wav", + "text": "我們有兩個配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1911.wav", + "text": "一個是以權益的方式補強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1912.wav", + "text": "一個就是剛剛第5條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1913.wav", + "text": "最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1914.wav", + "text": "在各縣市的特資中心裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1915.wav", + "text": "要去增置新的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1916.wav", + "text": "就是要減少他們的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1917.wav", + "text": "去減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1918.wav", + "text": "減輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1919.wav", + "text": "特教老師在第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1920.wav", + "text": "\n但是因為我不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1921.wav", + "text": "現在的心評人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1922.wav", + "text": "每學年不高於十案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1923.wav", + "text": "我沒有價值評論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1924.wav", + "text": "因為我不知道現況是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1925.wav", + "text": "所以現在當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1926.wav", + "text": "有委員的提案說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1927.wav", + "text": "不得高於十案為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1928.wav", + "text": "我就沒有辦法去判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1929.wav", + "text": "我可不可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1930.wav", + "text": "或者我們這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1931.wav", + "text": "能不能夠通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1932.wav", + "text": "這點你們要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1933.wav", + "text": "也許是二十案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1934.wav", + "text": "也許是十五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1935.wav", + "text": "也許是五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1936.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法做價值評價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1937.wav", + "text": "所以你們必須要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1938.wav", + "text": "我不知道這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1939.wav", + "text": "是怎麼來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1940.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1941.wav", + "text": "不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1942.wav", + "text": "因為時間已經滿晚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1943.wav", + "text": "我們經協商很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1944.wav", + "text": "我們其實只有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1945.wav", + "text": "四個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1946.wav", + "text": "因為有委員有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1947.wav", + "text": "我們是否就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1948.wav", + "text": "到院會再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1949.wav", + "text": "王委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1950.wav", + "text": "這些尤其第三段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1951.wav", + "text": "是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1952.wav", + "text": "特別跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1953.wav", + "text": "我們在處理這個事情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1954.wav", + "text": "一定都會考慮這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1955.wav", + "text": "第十八條來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1956.wav", + "text": "用第十八條的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1957.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1958.wav", + "text": "請王委員婉諭發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1959.wav", + "text": "我想補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1960.wav", + "text": "第一段的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1961.wav", + "text": "不是我們要求不高於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1962.wav", + "text": "十案為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1963.wav", + "text": "而是這是現行原則中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1964.wav", + "text": "的第十二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1965.wav", + "text": "裡面就有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1966.wav", + "text": "總案量不得高於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1967.wav", + "text": "十案為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1968.wav", + "text": "超過十案的多有所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1969.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1970.wav", + "text": "到底超過多少是有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1971.wav", + "text": "我們還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1972.wav", + "text": "能夠有個清楚的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1973.wav", + "text": "因為過去我們是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1974.wav", + "text": "一年接多少案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1975.wav", + "text": "其實都沒有得到相關的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1976.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1977.wav", + "text": "的確是應該要能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1978.wav", + "text": "更加地瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1979.wav", + "text": "如果國教署這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1980.wav", + "text": "都已經同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1981.wav", + "text": "我想就是直接通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1982.wav", + "text": "其實沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1983.wav", + "text": "因為在野黨提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1984.wav", + "text": "就一定要併案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1985.wav", + "text": "我想也沒有這樣的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1986.wav", + "text": "其實就是讓它照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1987.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1988.wav", + "text": "瑤發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1989.wav", + "text": "我是不能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1990.wav", + "text": "我只是提出詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1991.wav", + "text": "就要被扣上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1992.wav", + "text": "這是在野黨委員提的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1993.wav", + "text": "就不予支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1994.wav", + "text": "絕對不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1995.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1996.wav", + "text": "婉諭委員絕對不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1997.wav", + "text": "我們非常認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1998.wav", + "text": "現行的原則是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/1999.wav", + "text": "每位心評人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2000.wav", + "text": "以不高於十案為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2001.wav", + "text": "第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2002.wav", + "text": "增加他的權益待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2003.wav", + "text": "然後在第五十條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2004.wav", + "text": "增加其人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2005.wav", + "text": "有另外一個外部補給的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2006.wav", + "text": "當然就會比這個loading更低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2007.wav", + "text": "就是要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2008.wav", + "text": "這樣子的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2009.wav", + "text": "各個縣市的特資中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2010.wav", + "text": "評估要增加多少專置人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2011.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2012.wav", + "text": "當然必須針對各縣市的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2013.wav", + "text": "跟工作負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2014.wav", + "text": "現在的工作時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2015.wav", + "text": "案量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2016.wav", + "text": "接案次數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2017.wav", + "text": "最後一項增置的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2018.wav", + "text": "要去評估的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2019.wav", + "text": "所以再清楚論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2020.wav", + "text": "如果這樣講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2021.wav", + "text": "再請幾位委員增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2022.wav", + "text": "連署附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2023.wav", + "text": "\n我再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2024.wav", + "text": "從來沒有任何人在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2025.wav", + "text": "因為不同政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2026.wav", + "text": "提出了不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2027.wav", + "text": "就採取反對的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2028.wav", + "text": "我要非常嚴厲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2029.wav", + "text": "抗議這種說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2030.wav", + "text": "在特教法的審議過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2031.wav", + "text": "共同為特教來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2032.wav", + "text": "所以這樣的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2033.wav", + "text": "在最後這一刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2034.wav", + "text": "被提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2035.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2036.wav", + "text": "剛剛有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2037.wav", + "text": "大家今天已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2038.wav", + "text": "討論了兩個多小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2039.wav", + "text": "很多東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2040.wav", + "text": "現在有理解了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2041.wav", + "text": "目前本來就有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2042.wav", + "text": "不高於十案為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2043.wav", + "text": "是國教署還是學務司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2044.wav", + "text": "剛剛已經說明過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2045.wav", + "text": "這個是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2046.wav", + "text": "的因為我們現行也會這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2047.wav", + "text": "好可以的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2048.wav", + "text": "也建議大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2049.wav", + "text": "因為我們大家其實都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2050.wav", + "text": "超越黨派在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2051.wav", + "text": "特教跟國教的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2052.wav", + "text": "我們國教已經幾乎都同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2053.wav", + "text": "都是共同修正的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2054.wav", + "text": "特教法其實也幾乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2055.wav", + "text": "已經沒有保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2056.wav", + "text": "是否就請大家一起簽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2057.wav", + "text": "針對整個特教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2058.wav", + "text": "特殊教育法修正草案案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2059.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2060.wav", + "text": "第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2061.wav", + "text": "第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2062.wav", + "text": "第二十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2063.wav", + "text": "第五十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2064.wav", + "text": "修正通過如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2065.wav", + "text": "通過原審查會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2066.wav", + "text": "及新增附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2067.wav", + "text": "其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2068.wav", + "text": "檢附立法說明1份如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2069.wav", + "text": "\n謝謝大家辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2070.wav", + "text": "簽名的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2071.wav", + "text": "在那邊請大家簽名一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2072.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2073.wav", + "text": "都通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2074.wav", + "text": "沒有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2075.wav", + "text": "我們也恭喜教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15035/2076.wav", + "text": "國教法跟特教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1.wav", + "text": "是的配合剛才吳思瑤委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2.wav", + "text": "新增第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/3.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/4.wav", + "text": "是我們的提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/5.wav", + "text": "上次有幾位委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/6.wav", + "text": "包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/7.wav", + "text": "都有提到能不能給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/8.wav", + "text": "個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/9.wav", + "text": "教育部也可以給予一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/10.wav", + "text": "善意的幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/11.wav", + "text": "加列一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/12.wav", + "text": "就是協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/13.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/14.wav", + "text": "要訂定相關的補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/15.wav", + "text": "正向回應兩位委員對這方面的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/16.wav", + "text": "張廖委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/17.wav", + "text": "\n第二點是有關吳思瑤委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/18.wav", + "text": "加列一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/19.wav", + "text": "我們覺得很有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/20.wav", + "text": "其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/21.wav", + "text": "把現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/22.wav", + "text": "也謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/23.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/24.wav", + "text": "我們完全認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/25.wav", + "text": "以上兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/26.wav", + "text": "兩位委員所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/27.wav", + "text": "我們增加有關補助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/28.wav", + "text": "子法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/29.wav", + "text": "一個是吳思瑤委員所提的臨時動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/30.wav", + "text": "我們也很認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/31.wav", + "text": "以上補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/32.wav", + "text": "席簡要向大家說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/33.wav", + "text": "請大家看大本最右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/34.wav", + "text": "提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/35.wav", + "text": "第6條原本行政院的提案是一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/36.wav", + "text": "但我們針對第6條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/37.wav", + "text": "提修正條文內容請看附表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/38.wav", + "text": "教育部為了回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/39.wav", + "text": "多數委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/40.wav", + "text": "包括婉諭委員也非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/41.wav", + "text": "不管是機構團體或自學學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/42.wav", + "text": "希望實驗教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/43.wav", + "text": "也能夠挹注國家資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/44.wav", + "text": "教育部的處理方法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/45.wav", + "text": "增加第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/46.wav", + "text": "文字內容是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/47.wav", + "text": "為協助前項實驗教育之發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/48.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關應訂定相關補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/49.wav", + "text": "\n也就是用一項補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/50.wav", + "text": "未來針對機構團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/51.wav", + "text": "甚至是學生的部分要怎麼處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/52.wav", + "text": "部分不會在第6條條文中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/53.wav", + "text": "因為教育部後來的提會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/54.wav", + "text": "討論版本和時代力量黨團版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/55.wav", + "text": "有一個滿大的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/56.wav", + "text": "所以本席想做釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/57.wav", + "text": "我們把政府補助放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/58.wav", + "text": "就是希望非學校型態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/59.wav", + "text": "但我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/60.wav", + "text": "現在有一些經費可以申請用來補助團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/61.wav", + "text": "這個意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/62.wav", + "text": "就會被政府的國民教育排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/63.wav", + "text": "本席想請教的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/64.wav", + "text": "依照現在教育部的提會版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/65.wav", + "text": "是不是仍然包含這兩個部分而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/66.wav", + "text": "個人的部分仍然被排除在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/67.wav", + "text": "我們當初提出修法的請張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/68.wav", + "text": "關於第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/69.wav", + "text": "提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/70.wav", + "text": "精神差不多是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/71.wav", + "text": "也就是訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/72.wav", + "text": "目前提會討論的版本一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/73.wav", + "text": "民眾黨的意見和現在教育部增加的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/74.wav", + "text": "一致針對實驗教育發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/75.wav", + "text": "由中央政府訂定相關補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/76.wav", + "text": "請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/77.wav", + "text": "教育部補充說明回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/78.wav", + "text": "也謝謝張召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/79.wav", + "text": "關於王委員所提的意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/80.wav", + "text": "原來的提案是提到非學校型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/81.wav", + "text": "這部分包含剛才您所提的非學校型態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/82.wav", + "text": "並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/83.wav", + "text": "除外另外您之前也有提到政府補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/84.wav", + "text": "會針對機構和團體的部分增加補助方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/85.wav", + "text": "的確在這樣的討論之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/86.wav", + "text": "雖然有些委員接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/87.wav", + "text": "了但是民間也捲起一股非常大的聲量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/88.wav", + "text": "個人的部分不應該被排除在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/89.wav", + "text": "仍然沒有表示個人是否涵蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/90.wav", + "text": "但是非學校型態包含機構團體和個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/91.wav", + "text": "教育部長一定知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/92.wav", + "text": "我們期待以及我們本來在條文中的設計就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/93.wav", + "text": "比照高中的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/94.wav", + "text": "每一個類型都應該給予協助補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/95.wav", + "text": "或者如果要排除在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/96.wav", + "text": "不應該只把個人排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/97.wav", + "text": "接受國民教育時當他選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/98.wav", + "text": "實驗教育的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/99.wav", + "text": "政府會給予什麼樣的補助或協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/100.wav", + "text": "其實我們這樣寫已經包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/101.wav", + "text": "個人部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/102.wav", + "text": "多諮詢一下現場的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/103.wav", + "text": "因為各類型的相關團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/104.wav", + "text": "我要特別說明這部分並沒有排除個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/105.wav", + "text": "但是要怎麼補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/106.wav", + "text": "是不是容我們未來訂定子法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/107.wav", + "text": "用另外的子法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/108.wav", + "text": "請林委員宜瑾第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/109.wav", + "text": "國中小階段的義務教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/110.wav", + "text": "建設公立學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/111.wav", + "text": "是為了保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/112.wav", + "text": "假如要透過全面性的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/113.wav", + "text": "鼓勵學生脫離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/114.wav", + "text": "本席覺得不宜\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/115.wav", + "text": "本席覺得國民教育權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/116.wav", + "text": "國家和教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/117.wav", + "text": "這三方權利平衡的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/118.wav", + "text": "對於沒有辦法全權��定自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/119.wav", + "text": "該受什麼教育的孩子來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/120.wav", + "text": "說當然不是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/121.wav", + "text": "本席覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/122.wav", + "text": "全面性的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/123.wav", + "text": "就是一種鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/124.wav", + "text": "但我們並不是要鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/125.wav", + "text": "學生在國民教育階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/126.wav", + "text": "階級間的選擇權不平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/127.wav", + "text": "本席覺得除了補助應該排富之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/128.wav", + "text": "百分百排除補習班的介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/129.wav", + "text": "就是排除所謂的偽自學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/130.wav", + "text": "辦義務教育公立學校來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/131.wav", + "text": "就會變成一種諷刺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/132.wav", + "text": "這些狀況至少要杜絕所謂的偽自學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/133.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/134.wav", + "text": "本席先暫時脫離一下主席身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/135.wav", + "text": "就自己對條文的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/136.wav", + "text": "做以下說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/137.wav", + "text": "已經審查很長一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/138.wav", + "text": "也耗時已久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/139.wav", + "text": "現在走到最後的協商如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/140.wav", + "text": "以條文論條文的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/141.wav", + "text": "婉諭委員代表時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/142.wav", + "text": "因為現在的條文也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/143.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/144.wav", + "text": "\n國民教育階段得辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/145.wav", + "text": "時代力量的版本是寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/146.wav", + "text": "實驗內容期程範圍申請條件程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/147.wav", + "text": "政府補助及其他相關事項之辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/148.wav", + "text": "由教育部會商後定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/149.wav", + "text": "本席認為時代力量這個條文的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/150.wav", + "text": "其實就是教育部現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/151.wav", + "text": "因為剛才署長也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/152.wav", + "text": "過教育部的第2項是針對前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/153.wav", + "text": "不只包含非學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/154.wav", + "text": "\n所以以條文論條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/155.wav", + "text": "本席認為教育部的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/156.wav", + "text": "以及非學校型態的實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/157.wav", + "text": "在第1項中的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/158.wav", + "text": "都由中央主管機關訂定相關補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/159.wav", + "text": "本席認為這樣更全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/160.wav", + "text": "而且未來用子法的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/161.wav", + "text": "包括以什麼樣的條件形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/162.wav", + "text": "給予政策的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/163.wav", + "text": "這樣訂定會更周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/164.wav", + "text": "\n另外說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/165.wav", + "text": "第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/166.wav", + "text": "補習及進修教育法所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/167.wav", + "text": "定之短期補習教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/168.wav", + "text": "不得視為第1項非學校型態實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/169.wav", + "text": "其實這就是把我們當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/170.wav", + "text": "在討論過程中沒有剔除的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/171.wav", + "text": "補教法予以排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/172.wav", + "text": "把這一項放進來會更周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/173.wav", + "text": "這部分不適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/174.wav", + "text": "本席認為教育部的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/175.wav", + "text": "席個人的意見\n現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/176.wav", + "text": "在回到主席的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/177.wav", + "text": "還有其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/178.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/179.wav", + "text": "還有家長的教育選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/180.wav", + "text": "以快速改變的體制中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/181.wav", + "text": "學習時可能會出現一些狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/182.wav", + "text": "另外一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/183.wav", + "text": "其實我們也需要鼓勵部分的實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/184.wav", + "text": "如果有好的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/185.wav", + "text": "這次所做的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/186.wav", + "text": "國民教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/187.wav", + "text": "是母法把這個空間留出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/188.wav", + "text": "本席認為大家不會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/189.wav", + "text": "甚至是支持你們給予補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/190.wav", + "text": "並且做整體考量後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/191.wav", + "text": "後予以逐步增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/192.wav", + "text": "哪些群落來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/193.wav", + "text": "版本這個會議可能會開不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/194.wav", + "text": "對剛才吳思瑤委員修正的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/195.wav", + "text": "本席是滿支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/196.wav", + "text": "教育部給予補助之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/197.wav", + "text": "和公立學校一起分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/198.wav", + "text": "這樣大家都能得到好處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/199.wav", + "text": "畢竟這都是納稅人一起支持的本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/200.wav", + "text": "分以上本席發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/201.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/202.wav", + "text": "宜瑾思瑤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/203.wav", + "text": "未來用子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/204.wav", + "text": "處理可以有更清楚的討論空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/205.wav", + "text": "請陳委員培瑜第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/206.wav", + "text": "一起提出來有關實驗教育的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/207.wav", + "text": "就是訂定相關子法予以補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/208.wav", + "text": "後續立法時是否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/209.wav", + "text": "也可以邀請其他委員一起參與討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/210.wav", + "text": "包括大家關注的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/211.wav", + "text": "及相關的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/212.wav", + "text": "文化資源等問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/213.wav", + "text": "本席還是要再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/214.wav", + "text": "的確本席完全理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/215.wav", + "text": "非學校型態包含個人團體和機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/216.wav", + "text": "只有針對團體和機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/217.wav", + "text": "或者大家訴求的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/218.wav", + "text": "範圍但是這個補助要不要排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/219.wav", + "text": "要不要有其他的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/220.wav", + "text": "席覺得這是可以討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/221.wav", + "text": "但不能一旦選擇個人實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/222.wav", + "text": "就完全沒有辦法享受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/223.wav", + "text": "本席想要釐清的是這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/224.wav", + "text": "\n剛才署長的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/225.wav", + "text": "並沒有排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/226.wav", + "text": "但是也沒有表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/227.wav", + "text": "所以本席覺得這個部分還是要釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/228.wav", + "text": "對個人的補助也能夠納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/229.wav", + "text": "入未來實驗教育的補助範疇之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/230.wav", + "text": "也確實會提出這樣的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/231.wav", + "text": "本席對條文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/232.wav", + "text": "因為我們長期以來推動實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/233.wav", + "text": "並不是反對國民教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/234.wav", + "text": "為你選擇國民教育之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/235.wav", + "text": "而且這部分的補助並不是鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/236.wav", + "text": "只是給予選擇的可能性而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/237.wav", + "text": "所以本席希望能夠先確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/238.wav", + "text": "個人實驗教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/239.wav", + "text": "請彭署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/240.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/241.wav", + "text": "的剛好在座幾位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/242.wav", + "text": "所以我們也希望藉由各界的幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/243.wav", + "text": "沒有排除對個人的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/244.wav", + "text": "以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/245.wav", + "text": "以前沒有這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/246.wav", + "text": "我們的協助補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/247.wav", + "text": "更放寬的幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/248.wav", + "text": "關於這方面的幫忙因為很多委員也有高見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/249.wav", + "text": "是不是容我們整合這些意見我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/250.wav", + "text": "會和有關單位會商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/251.wav", + "text": "培瑜委員也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/252.wav", + "text": "到是不是可以向委員做一些說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/253.wav", + "text": "聆聽各位聽到的一些心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/254.wav", + "text": "甚至是比較偏鄉的地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/255.wav", + "text": "要不要有額外更好的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/256.wav", + "text": "像這些意見是不是容我們思考更周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/257.wav", + "text": "的做法在法律授權下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/258.wav", + "text": "可能沒有辦法一步到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/259.wav", + "text": "目前所說的前項各類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/260.wav", + "text": "補助的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/261.wav", + "text": "是不是容我們和大家會商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/262.wav", + "text": "對個人的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/263.wav", + "text": "可是關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/264.wav", + "text": "關於設算單位成本等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/265.wav", + "text": "是不是容我們再就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/266.wav", + "text": "是不是可以設算單位成本給個人補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/267.wav", + "text": "這件事情我無法在這裡回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/268.wav", + "text": "我聽到很多委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/269.wav", + "text": "委員也有聽到嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/270.wav", + "text": "是不是容我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/271.wav", + "text": "未來訂定子法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/272.wav", + "text": "啦這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/273.wav", + "text": "因為本席代理范雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/274.wav", + "text": "國民教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/275.wav", + "text": "整部國民教育法關切了太多面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/276.wav", + "text": "第6條主要是處理實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/277.wav", + "text": "在處理實驗教育的條文當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/278.wav", + "text": "就是講述原則性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/279.wav", + "text": "和國家對於實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/280.wav", + "text": "採取支持的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/281.wav", + "text": "而且是擴大補助的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/282.wav", + "text": "\n所以在這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/283.wav", + "text": "的第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/284.wav", + "text": "提到國家絕對全力支持實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/285.wav", + "text": "增列的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/286.wav", + "text": "是回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/287.wav", + "text": "第3項是新增的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/288.wav", + "text": "我們這次修正的條文有幾十條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/289.wav", + "text": "這一條是在處理實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/290.wav", + "text": "用子法處理畢竟會比較周全本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/291.wav", + "text": "如果主張實驗教育的其他部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/292.wav", + "text": "\n國民教育法處理的是整個國民教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/293.wav", + "text": "正在條文推進上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/294.wav", + "text": "本席再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/295.wav", + "text": "第1項是保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/296.wav", + "text": "協助以文字明定國家對實驗教育的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/297.wav", + "text": "增定的第2項是過去沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/298.wav", + "text": "擴大對實驗教育的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/299.wav", + "text": "未來在子法的修法過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/300.wav", + "text": "中一定要和更多團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/301.wav", + "text": "會商也請所有立委一起參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/302.wav", + "text": "這樣才會更周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/303.wav", + "text": "\n本席覺得國民教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/304.wav", + "text": "在實驗教育的部分真的只能以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/305.wav", + "text": "方向性基本性的方式處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/306.wav", + "text": "而且它已經處理的非常完備本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/307.wav", + "text": "本席懇求各位今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/308.wav", + "text": "是否可以參酌剛才委員提出的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/309.wav", + "text": "包括張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/310.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/311.wav", + "text": "還有行政院提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/312.wav", + "text": "提會討論的修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/313.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/314.wav", + "text": "位置交還給范雲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/315.wav", + "text": "關於增列的第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/316.wav", + "text": "大家應該都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/317.wav", + "text": "至於第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/318.wav", + "text": "就剛才聽起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/319.wav", + "text": "多數委員都支持這樣的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/320.wav", + "text": "為協助前項實驗教育之發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/321.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/322.wav", + "text": "應訂定相關補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/323.wav", + "text": "和個人都予以含括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/324.wav", + "text": "是很全面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/325.wav", + "text": "是不是能請大家支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/326.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/327.wav", + "text": "就是不用特別排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/328.wav", + "text": "除雖然現在是說沒有排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/329.wav", + "text": "但實際上就是沒有給予協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/330.wav", + "text": "而且你們一直說不出所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/331.wav", + "text": "席還是要和署長強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/332.wav", + "text": "這不是一時提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/333.wav", + "text": "就開始談這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/334.wav", + "text": "而且在實驗教育現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/335.wav", + "text": "場也談論非常多年這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/336.wav", + "text": "這點署長非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/337.wav", + "text": "所以不需要誆本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/338.wav", + "text": "到底能夠給個人的實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/339.wav", + "text": "一直沒有辦法說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/340.wav", + "text": "這件事情從我們上任第一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/341.wav", + "text": "這樣並不是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/342.wav", + "text": "一時之間沒有辦法回答\n本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/343.wav", + "text": "\n本席可以接受這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/344.wav", + "text": "能夠透過附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/345.wav", + "text": "或是立法說明的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/346.wav", + "text": "都要給予協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/347.wav", + "text": "當然關於協助的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/348.wav", + "text": "如果教育部能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/349.wav", + "text": "我們用立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/350.wav", + "text": "的方式或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/351.wav", + "text": "商討這個補助規定的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/352.wav", + "text": "當然相關協助或補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/353.wav", + "text": "個人實驗教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/354.wav", + "text": "就是完全被排除在外本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/355.wav", + "text": "但是擬一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/356.wav", + "text": "至於附帶決議要怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/357.wav", + "text": "先讓條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/358.wav", + "text": "另外補一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/359.wav", + "text": "但是附帶決議的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/360.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/361.wav", + "text": "我們可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/362.wav", + "text": "但是我們也很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/363.wav", + "text": "待會附帶決議又做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/364.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法納入這些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/365.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們是不是可以先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/366.wav", + "text": "附帶決議的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/367.wav", + "text": "要嘛就是不要通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/368.wav", + "text": "也可能會是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/369.wav", + "text": "思瑤委員本席可以補充意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/370.wav", + "text": "如果這個附帶決議要這麼寫本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/371.wav", + "text": "另外一種聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/372.wav", + "text": "因為本席也認識非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/373.wav", + "text": "自學的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/374.wav", + "text": "如同王婉諭委員一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/375.wav", + "text": "其中也有另外一種聲音就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/376.wav", + "text": "當這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/377.wav", + "text": "有可能被濫用的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/378.wav", + "text": "其實婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/379.wav", + "text": "剛才也有提到就是排富條款的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/380.wav", + "text": "是不是也把這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/381.wav", + "text": "所以本席才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/382.wav", + "text": "對於自學是否補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/383.wav", + "text": "其實其他委員有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/384.wav", + "text": "就這一條攸關實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/385.wav", + "text": "細則的部分用子法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/386.wav", + "text": "說未來想要��實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/387.wav", + "text": "其實實驗教育三法也可以修法提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/388.wav", + "text": "國民教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/389.wav", + "text": "因為這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/390.wav", + "text": "還有四條條文要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/391.wav", + "text": "我們等一下回來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/392.wav", + "text": "大家再思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/393.wav", + "text": "但本席要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/394.wav", + "text": "宜瑾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/395.wav", + "text": "我們要尊重不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/396.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/397.wav", + "text": "現在把主持工作交還范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/398.wav", + "text": "\n現在處理第41條另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/399.wav", + "text": "條關於戶外教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/400.wav", + "text": "哪一位委員要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/401.wav", + "text": "員提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/402.wav", + "text": "第37條本席提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/403.wav", + "text": "獲得張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/404.wav", + "text": "范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/405.wav", + "text": "和其他委員的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/406.wav", + "text": "非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/407.wav", + "text": "第37條上次對於戶外教育的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/408.wav", + "text": "我們已經綜整一份大家都可以同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/409.wav", + "text": "為豐富學生經驗及強化與真實情境連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/410.wav", + "text": "學校應推動走出課室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/411.wav", + "text": "提供學生探究實作與體驗課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/412.wav", + "text": "其推動之經費來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/413.wav", + "text": "收費基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/414.wav", + "text": "單位人員分工與權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/415.wav", + "text": "風險管理及其他相關事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/416.wav", + "text": "之自治法規由直轄市縣(市)主管機關定之\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/417.wav", + "text": "在第1項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/418.wav", + "text": "我們維持上次委員會審查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/419.wav", + "text": "另外增加探究和實作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/420.wav", + "text": "本席覺得這樣會更周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/421.wav", + "text": "為了落實走出課室的這些體驗課程所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/422.wav", + "text": "經費來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/423.wav", + "text": "收費基準人員的分工與權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/424.wav", + "text": "責就用子法處理本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/425.wav", + "text": "席覺得這樣非常周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/426.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳思瑤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/427.wav", + "text": "針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/428.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員在嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/429.wav", + "text": "其他兩位提案委員都不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/430.wav", + "text": "國教署要不要表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/431.wav", + "text": "用吳思瑤委員的版本可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/432.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委及委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/433.wav", + "text": "我們剛才看了這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/434.wav", + "text": "於文字國教署認為不需要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/435.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員的版本沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/436.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/437.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤委員的修正動議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/438.wav", + "text": "大家可以看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/439.wav", + "text": "原本的院版通過囉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/440.wav", + "text": "囉謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/441.wav", + "text": "理第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/442.wav", + "text": "救濟體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/443.wav", + "text": "在大本的第4頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/444.wav", + "text": "因為之前本席有表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/445.wav", + "text": "也有和教育部做過溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/446.wav", + "text": "謝謝剛才委員們幫忙連署\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/447.wav", + "text": "吳委員思瑤發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/448.wav", + "text": "第44條是有關學生的申訴再申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/449.wav", + "text": "會後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/450.wav", + "text": "我們幾位委員也有再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/451.wav", + "text": "和教育部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/452.wav", + "text": "建議的修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/453.wav", + "text": "其中有幾個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/454.wav", + "text": "對學生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/455.wav", + "text": "得由法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/456.wav", + "text": "代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/457.wav", + "text": "實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/458.wav", + "text": "納入此外因為我們認為實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/459.wav", + "text": "和法定代理人相對來說都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/460.wav", + "text": "成人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/461.wav", + "text": "有充足的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/462.wav", + "text": "30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/463.wav", + "text": "或40天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/464.wav", + "text": "對不對對教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/465.wav", + "text": "本席記得還有一個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/466.wav", + "text": "外我們認為既然有法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/467.wav", + "text": "代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/468.wav", + "text": "以書面為之也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/469.wav", + "text": "可以的這三個爭點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/470.wav", + "text": "所以本席支持今天提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/471.wav", + "text": "提會討論的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/472.wav", + "text": "能夠讓申訴的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/473.wav", + "text": "增加到40天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/474.wav", + "text": "還有修正家長和代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/475.wav", + "text": "的部分另外還有關於通知的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/476.wav", + "text": "本席希望能夠增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/477.wav", + "text": "通知學生及其法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/478.wav", + "text": "原來的文字好像漏掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/479.wav", + "text": "通知的部分並通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/480.wav", + "text": "國教署是不是可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/481.wav", + "text": "原來是並通知學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/482.wav", + "text": "之法定代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/483.wav", + "text": "和法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/484.wav", + "text": "等你們在行政作業上應該沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/485.wav", + "text": "至少學生本人有被通知到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/486.wav", + "text": "就是增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/487.wav", + "text": "並通知學生及其法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/488.wav", + "text": "或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/489.wav", + "text": "對還有或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/490.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的建議可以我們來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/491.wav", + "text": "如果沒有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/492.wav", + "text": "螢幕上的修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/493.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/494.wav", + "text": "關於學生申訴評議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/495.wav", + "text": "請大家看大本的第7頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/496.wav", + "text": "這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/497.wav", + "text": "和教育部溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/498.wav", + "text": "大家有拿到資料可以一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/499.wav", + "text": "國教署是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/500.wav", + "text": "一起回應包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/501.wav", + "text": "這部分請你們一起回應好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/502.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/503.wav", + "text": "原來談到第44條第45條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/504.wav", + "text": "委員希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/505.wav", + "text": "能夠彰顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/506.wav", + "text": "現在看到的附帶決議第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/507.wav", + "text": "我們覺得應該做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/508.wav", + "text": "尤其是第二行有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/509.wav", + "text": "就是在申訴前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/510.wav", + "text": "應該有一些機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/511.wav", + "text": "讓學生可以受到保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/512.wav", + "text": "想要表達的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/513.wav", + "text": "也有管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/514.wav", + "text": "而且也會落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/515.wav", + "text": "召委和辦公室同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/516.wav", + "text": "過也開過會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/517.wav", + "text": "我們是把它容納在第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/518.wav", + "text": "也就是現在的第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/519.wav", + "text": "就能夠解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/520.wav", + "text": "就整體而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/521.wav", + "text": "我們會落實附帶決議所提的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/522.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/523.wav", + "text": "新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/524.wav", + "text": "大家有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/525.wav", + "text": "我們瞭解教育部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/526.wav", + "text": "考慮到行政訴訟的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/527.wav", + "text": "而且學校和地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/528.wav", + "text": "比較容易的申訴管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/529.wav", + "text": "這樣也許很多問題就可以解決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/530.wav", + "text": "沒有委員要表達不同意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/531.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/532.wav", + "text": "院版的文字通過再加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/533.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/534.wav", + "text": "好感謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/535.wav", + "text": "以上是第45條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/536.wav", + "text": "立法說明大家手上有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/537.wav", + "text": "我們先回頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/538.wav", + "text": "保留的第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/539.wav", + "text": "請吳委員思瑤發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/540.wav", + "text": "是不是讓每個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/541.wav", + "text": "就我個人的立場我不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/542.wav", + "text": "因為這個條文而影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/543.wav", + "text": "國民教育法這個大法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/544.wav", + "text": "的修正所以我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/545.wav", + "text": "第1項能夠維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/546.wav", + "text": "現在提會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/547.wav", + "text": "版本第2項新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/548.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/549.wav", + "text": "更高的執法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/550.wav", + "text": "不設前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/551.wav", + "text": "不設型態的實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/552.wav", + "text": "都要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/553.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關訂定相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/554.wav", + "text": "補助規定這樣第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/555.wav", + "text": "的文字會是最全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/556.wav", + "text": "也最彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/557.wav", + "text": "根本大法的方向性規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/558.wav", + "text": "所以我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/559.wav", + "text": "第2項的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/560.wav", + "text": "應當接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/561.wav", + "text": "我個人是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/562.wav", + "text": "接受我也希望大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/563.wav", + "text": "接受至於第3項剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/564.wav", + "text": "已經建議放上來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/565.wav", + "text": "\n如果今天多數委員都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/566.wav", + "text": "有這樣的共識我非常期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/567.wav", + "text": "我們可以送出協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/568.wav", + "text": "然後加速後面二三讀的期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/569.wav", + "text": "在此懇請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/570.wav", + "text": "次強調��對實驗教育的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/571.wav", + "text": "各種其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/572.wav", + "text": "要有修法的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/573.wav", + "text": "其實上一屆修過實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/574.wav", + "text": "三法都還可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/575.wav", + "text": "針對實驗教育三法討論是不是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/576.wav", + "text": "更周延的修正必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/577.wav", + "text": "而不是在國民教育法裡頭處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/578.wav", + "text": "所以我再做一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/579.wav", + "text": "最終意見的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/580.wav", + "text": "吳委員思瑤其他委員有沒有要表達意見\n請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/581.wav", + "text": "我覺得預算的花用方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/582.wav", + "text": "發展的價值思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/583.wav", + "text": "並不是高中有補助自學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/584.wav", + "text": "然後我們就可以推演出國中小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/585.wav", + "text": "也要比照辦理的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/586.wav", + "text": "因為高中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/587.wav", + "text": "跟國中小不同的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/588.wav", + "text": "後者是義務教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/589.wav", + "text": "高中階段是自願入學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/590.wav", + "text": "非義務教育強度不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/591.wav", + "text": "所以國家政策目的有所不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/592.wav", + "text": "管制的鬆緊當然也有會不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/593.wav", + "text": "\n我再次重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/594.wav", + "text": "選擇特定教育理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/595.wav", + "text": "的自學申請者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/596.wav", + "text": "我們當然很清楚知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/597.wav", + "text": "事前的整個計畫審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/598.wav", + "text": "跟事後的訪視評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/599.wav", + "text": "來把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/600.wav", + "text": "會有一些想要方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/601.wav", + "text": "衝刺升學考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/602.wav", + "text": "而申請在家自學的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/603.wav", + "text": "這種就叫偽自學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/604.wav", + "text": "就明顯不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/605.wav", + "text": "所謂實驗教育的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/606.wav", + "text": "如果要把普發所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/607.wav", + "text": "學費補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/608.wav", + "text": "選擇權為基本論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/609.wav", + "text": "我覺得本質上還是把教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/610.wav", + "text": "當作商品化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/611.wav", + "text": "就是要平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/612.wav", + "text": "是近便可得的優質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/613.wav", + "text": "公辦教育我覺得這還是國教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/614.wav", + "text": "基礎之外我們當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/615.wav", + "text": "支持其他所謂的選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/616.wav", + "text": "權可是我覺得那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/617.wav", + "text": "絕對不是所謂的普例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/618.wav", + "text": "不是通則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/619.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/620.wav", + "text": "看到這個修正條文第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/621.wav", + "text": "有加入訂定相關補助的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/622.wav", + "text": "我確實也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/623.wav", + "text": "呼應剛才王委員婉諭所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/624.wav", + "text": "不管是為了照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/625.wav", + "text": "有這樣能量的家長的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/626.wav", + "text": "孩子的家庭狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/627.wav", + "text": "一旦有這樣的個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/628.wav", + "text": "是不是可以真的如願照顧到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/629.wav", + "text": "所有的小孩所以剛剛我也再次呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/630.wav", + "text": "排富部分不管稍後大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/631.wav", + "text": "的討論如何或者是後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/632.wav", + "text": "訂定的相關補助規定我都希望教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/633.wav", + "text": "在這個議題上能夠做全面的考量\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/634.wav", + "text": "\n也因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/635.wav", + "text": "的增列所以我也很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/636.wav", + "text": "條文通過然後我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/637.wav", + "text": "可以在後續的諸多討論上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/638.wav", + "text": "我相信每一個委員不管在服務的選區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/639.wav", + "text": "或者像我是不分區我們都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/640.wav", + "text": "會認識到非常多不同角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/641.wav", + "text": "不同家庭及不同教育選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/642.wav", + "text": "型態的家長是不是也讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/643.wav", + "text": "有機會把這樣的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/644.wav", + "text": "跟教育部及國教署討論在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/645.wav", + "text": "訂定相關補助規定裡面把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/646.wav", + "text": "不同樣態的孩子的需求都放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/647.wav", + "text": "一併考量謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/648.wav", + "text": "夠理解署長所說的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/649.wav", + "text": "協助不見得是受限在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/650.wav", + "text": "補助之內但現狀上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/651.wav", + "text": "的確在選擇個人實驗教育的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/652.wav", + "text": "情況之下是非常難享受到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/653.wav", + "text": "協助即便我知道他們擁有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/654.wav", + "text": "學籍理論上他們可以回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/655.wav", + "text": "學校使用圖書館或是參加學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/656.wav", + "text": "的活動但實際上我相信署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/657.wav", + "text": "和部長一定非常清楚有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/658.wav", + "text": "實驗教育個人自學的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/659.wav", + "text": "是被學校拒絕在外其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/660.wav", + "text": "很難去使用到這些空間\n而我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/661.wav", + "text": "認為如果我們要把他涵蓋進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/662.wav", + "text": "不單單是補助而已包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/663.wav", + "text": "協助的部分我覺得也是可以接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/664.wav", + "text": "當他一旦選擇了個人實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/665.wav", + "text": "的協助對象之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/666.wav", + "text": "排除但實際上他可能就被排除了我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/667.wav", + "text": "還是希望能夠解決掉這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/668.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望法規及附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/669.wav", + "text": "\n另外我也想請教一下現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/670.wav", + "text": "非學實驗教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/671.wav", + "text": "就我理解應該本來就不含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/672.wav", + "text": "教育法的部分應該是要依照私校法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/673.wav", + "text": "又或者是依照補習班的相關條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/674.wav", + "text": "去做申請或是設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/675.wav", + "text": "這裡多寫可能是好事但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/676.wav", + "text": "我也擔心如果本來就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/677.wav", + "text": "不含了其實也不需要在這裡特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/678.wav", + "text": "了看起來意見滿清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/679.wav", + "text": "大家對於剛剛吳思瑤委員提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/680.wav", + "text": "的修正條文即為協" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/681.wav", + "text": "助前項實驗教育之發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/682.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/683.wav", + "text": "訂定相關補助規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/684.wav", + "text": "教育部說其中並沒有排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/685.wav", + "text": "滿強烈的反對意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/686.wav", + "text": "條文本身並沒有排除另外一種選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/687.wav", + "text": "理我們是不是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/688.wav", + "text": "是之後再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/689.wav", + "text": "也表達一下意見好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/690.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/691.wav", + "text": "審到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/692.wav", + "text": "很高興大家集結了智慧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/693.wav", + "text": "並且已經快完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/694.wav", + "text": "現在針對這一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/695.wav", + "text": "條文和意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/696.wav", + "text": "我們用最大的善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/697.wav", + "text": "來含納我們能夠執行的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/698.wav", + "text": "以前沒有這一條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/699.wav", + "text": "儘可能幫忙到機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/700.wav", + "text": "現在有這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/701.wav", + "text": "有這一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/702.wav", + "text": "但是幫忙的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/703.wav", + "text": "就如委員今天���到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/704.wav", + "text": "其實有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/705.wav", + "text": "可以容國教署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/706.wav", + "text": "或教育部未來訂定的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/707.wav", + "text": "更周延一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/708.wav", + "text": "剛才我們也已經講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/709.wav", + "text": "了它所含納的非常廣泛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/710.wav", + "text": "比以前更寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/711.wav", + "text": "更強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/712.wav", + "text": "以前只有一個行政規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/713.wav", + "text": "現在是一個子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/714.wav", + "text": "\n今天也聽到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/715.wav", + "text": "不管是吳委員的論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/716.wav", + "text": "或是條文本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/717.wav", + "text": "就含納了兩大類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/718.wav", + "text": "並沒有說要排除誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/719.wav", + "text": "再加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/720.wav", + "text": "歷來從103年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/721.wav", + "text": "我們跟實驗教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/722.wav", + "text": "實盟等等的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/723.wav", + "text": "處理了多少原來所沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/724.wav", + "text": "委員可能也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/725.wav", + "text": "國教署教育部及縣市的用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/726.wav", + "text": "剛才也舉到有一些縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/727.wav", + "text": "在工作的過程中需要再協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/728.wav", + "text": "那些的協助也會包含在以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/729.wav", + "text": "推動的過程內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/730.wav", + "text": "\n所以我要特別跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/731.wav", + "text": "也分享一種心情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/732.wav", + "text": "有強度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/733.wav", + "text": "但是實際的做法是不是容我們周延一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/734.wav", + "text": "作以上補充謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/735.wav", + "text": "論得差不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/736.wav", + "text": "你最後一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/737.wav", + "text": "補習班的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/738.wav", + "text": "剛剛應該已經處理了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/739.wav", + "text": "所以我們不要讓他們擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/740.wav", + "text": "有沒有要做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/741.wav", + "text": "至少條文都已經確定通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/742.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/743.wav", + "text": "不好附帶決議如果要再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/744.wav", + "text": "就再討論一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/745.wav", + "text": "我先唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/746.wav", + "text": "剛才召委裁示第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/747.wav", + "text": "就如同這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/748.wav", + "text": "修正草案的協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/749.wav", + "text": "第37條第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/750.wav", + "text": "修正通過如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/751.wav", + "text": "第41條第45條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/752.wav", + "text": "照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/753.wav", + "text": "會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/754.wav", + "text": "附帶決議一項如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/755.wav", + "text": "其餘均照審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/756.wav", + "text": "審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/757.wav", + "text": "檢附立法說明一份如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/758.wav", + "text": "我們先休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/759.wav", + "text": "以利手語翻譯老師畫面的轉播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/760.wav", + "text": "聽打服務請至立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/761.wav", + "text": "議事轉播網際網路多媒體視訊隨選系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/762.wav", + "text": "李振輝老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/763.wav", + "text": "及張俊仁老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/764.wav", + "text": "解健彬老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/765.wav", + "text": "陳敬家老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/766.wav", + "text": "黃姿綝老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/767.wav", + "text": "謝謝他們今天為大家服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/768.wav", + "text": "條條文先從第6條開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/769.wav", + "text": "第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/770.wav", + "text": "第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/771.wav", + "text": "就是鑑輔會成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/772.wav", + "text": "增加特殊教育相關家長團體代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/773.wav", + "text": "及同級衛生主管機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/774.wav", + "text": "支持服務的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/775.wav", + "text": "並在第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/776.wav", + "text": "增列鑑輔會委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/777.wav", + "text": "的規定這是上次審查會已經達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/778.wav", + "text": "並做成決定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/779.wav", + "text": "辦理第1項鑑定學前教育階段業務時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/780.wav", + "text": "依兒童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/781.wav", + "text": "及少年福利與權益保障法第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/782.wav", + "text": "規定辦理之學前教育階段兒童發展評估結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/783.wav", + "text": "萬委員美玲還是滿堅持的希望能夠增列相關文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/784.wav", + "text": "針此我再做以下補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/785.wav", + "text": "說明經過我們很審慎的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/786.wav", + "text": "有幾點意見要讓各位委員知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/787.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/788.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/789.wav", + "text": "醫療院所的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/790.wav", + "text": "晤談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/791.wav", + "text": "等等資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/792.wav", + "text": "醫療單位所提供的評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/793.wav", + "text": "其實只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/794.wav", + "text": "可以參考的條件之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/795.wav", + "text": "不是必備的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/796.wav", + "text": "即使沒有評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/797.wav", + "text": "還是可以經由特教老師的評估晤談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/798.wav", + "text": "觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/799.wav", + "text": "來做判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/800.wav", + "text": "如果在本條增列該項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/801.wav", + "text": "讓大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/802.wav", + "text": "這個報告是必須取得的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/803.wav", + "text": "這樣反而限縮了他取得特教資格服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/804.wav", + "text": "醫院評估的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/805.wav", + "text": "這是我們的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/806.wav", + "text": "考量故建議不要增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/807.wav", + "text": "第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/808.wav", + "text": "政府應建立六歲以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/809.wav", + "text": "兒童發展的評估機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/810.wav", + "text": "對於發展遲緩兒童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/811.wav", + "text": "應按其需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/812.wav", + "text": "給予早療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/813.wav", + "text": "醫療就學及家庭支持方面的特殊照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/814.wav", + "text": "父母及監護人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/815.wav", + "text": "要配合政府這些特殊照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/816.wav", + "text": "第3項規定的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/817.wav", + "text": "早期療癒所需要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/818.wav", + "text": "篩檢通報評估治療教育等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/819.wav", + "text": "各項服務的銜接及協調機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/820.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/821.wav", + "text": "會同衛生教育主管機關規劃辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/822.wav", + "text": "換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/823.wav", + "text": "在兒權法第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/824.wav", + "text": "而且是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/825.wav", + "text": "即社政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/826.wav", + "text": "會同衛生教育主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/827.wav", + "text": "規劃辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/828.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議可以免列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/829.wav", + "text": "已經說明得很詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/830.wav", + "text": "而且本法在委員會中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/831.wav", + "text": "很多都已經進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/832.wav", + "text": "無委員要對本條表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/833.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/834.wav", + "text": "就依照提會討論版本文字通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/835.wav", + "text": "\n現在處理第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/836.wav", + "text": "專職人員處理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/837.wav", + "text": "經過多方討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/838.wav", + "text": "法案協商階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/839.wav", + "text": "採納本席的提案版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/840.wav", + "text": "因為根據第一線特教老師的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/841.wav", + "text": "心評工作真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/842.wav", + "text": "被大部分特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/843.wav", + "text": "了每學年的心理評量季節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/844.wav", + "text": "老師真的要耗費很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/845.wav", + "text": "去從事心評工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/846.wav", + "text": "本席上次也講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/847.wav", + "text": "每個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/848.wav", + "text": "從施測到撰寫完報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/849.wav", + "text": "需要兩天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/850.wav", + "text": "一般來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/851.wav", + "text": "每位特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/852.wav", + "text": "都需要對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/853.wav", + "text": "6至10位學生進行施測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/854.wav", + "text": "測換算下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/855.wav", + "text": "至一個月的工作天因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/856.wav", + "text": "增列了第三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/857.wav", + "text": "明確規定前項所述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/858.wav", + "text": "心理評量人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/859.wav", + "text": "應該要以專任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/860.wav", + "text": "如果真的沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/861.wav", + "text": "而且老師願意兼任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/862.wav", + "text": "也應該給予合理待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/863.wav", + "text": "以及工作上的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/864.wav", + "text": "算是最中庸的處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/865.wav", + "text": "前項評估人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/866.wav", + "text": "以專任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/867.wav", + "text": "教師自願兼任時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/868.wav", + "text": "應給予合理之待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/869.wav", + "text": "及工作上之協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/870.wav", + "text": "跟各位同仁多多支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/871.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/872.wav", + "text": "經委員會審查之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/873.wav", + "text": "教育部有再做過一些對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/874.wav", + "text": "跟綜整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/875.wav", + "text": "包括跟本席做過討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/876.wav", + "text": "一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/877.wav", + "text": "討論我們現在要處理的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/878.wav", + "text": "心評人員到底能不能夠專職化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/879.wav", + "text": "或是現階段做不做得到專職化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/880.wav", + "text": "一派特教老師認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/881.wav", + "text": "專職化有利於減輕他們的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/882.wav", + "text": "應當由特教老師繼續執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/883.wav", + "text": "不過要讓特教老師肩負這些心評工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/884.wav", + "text": "就必須給予他合理的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/885.wav", + "text": "到今天協商的這段期間本席也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/886.wav", + "text": "包括一些專業的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/887.wav", + "text": "對話��為可將第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/888.wav", + "text": "修正為前項學生及幼兒的鑑定基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/889.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/890.wav", + "text": "如果心評工作還是由特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/891.wav", + "text": "來肩負的話則其相關的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/892.wav", + "text": "必要的支持等都要一併考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/893.wav", + "text": "就是考量到給予第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/894.wav", + "text": "工作loading辛苦的特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/895.wav", + "text": "合宜的工作協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/896.wav", + "text": "最後一項新增條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/897.wav", + "text": "各級主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/898.wav", + "text": "高級中等以下學校或幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/899.wav", + "text": "指定增置由主管機關統籌運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/900.wav", + "text": "及調派之編制內特殊教育教師員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/901.wav", + "text": "額用以協助辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/902.wav", + "text": "第十八條第一項所定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/903.wav", + "text": "鑑定評估作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/904.wav", + "text": "及辦理第一項所定特殊教育資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/905.wav", + "text": "及特殊教育輔導團業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/906.wav", + "text": "或前項所定支持網絡業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/907.wav", + "text": "即要求中央的教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/908.wav", + "text": "地方政府教育局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/909.wav", + "text": "可以彈性調派調度的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/910.wav", + "text": "而且是用編制內特教老師的員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/911.wav", + "text": "來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/912.wav", + "text": "也就是從外部來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/913.wav", + "text": "校園內特教老師進行心評工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/914.wav", + "text": "用增加權益的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/915.wav", + "text": "也就是給予他合理的待遇提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/916.wav", + "text": "跟補助來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/917.wav", + "text": "來協助而且是編制員額內的特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/918.wav", + "text": "是有相當的訓練跟專業且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/919.wav", + "text": "對於教育線的第一現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/920.wav", + "text": "場是非常熟悉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/921.wav", + "text": "人員第5條最後一項就是第二軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/922.wav", + "text": "用外部的資源彈性地協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/923.wav", + "text": "有需要的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/924.wav", + "text": "我們可以做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/925.wav", + "text": "而且合理可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/926.wav", + "text": "的既可有效減輕心評老師工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/927.wav", + "text": "把兩軌都放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/928.wav", + "text": "第一軌放在第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/929.wav", + "text": "第二軌放在第5條最後一項新增條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/930.wav", + "text": "因此本席建議大家可以照今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/931.wav", + "text": "的提會討論版本內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/932.wav", + "text": "其實大家已經討論過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/933.wav", + "text": "我們台灣民眾黨對這部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/934.wav", + "text": "就是規定評估人員的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/935.wav", + "text": "以專任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/936.wav", + "text": "如果是兼任者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/937.wav", + "text": "應予以必要的協助跟補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/938.wav", + "text": "其實跟剛才林委員宜瑾的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/939.wav", + "text": "直接在條文中寫得這麼明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/940.wav", + "text": "的話當然我們也可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/941.wav", + "text": "評估人員的資格及權益寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/942.wav", + "text": "提到會局部加入專職人員為輔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/943.wav", + "text": "如果真的要這樣寫本席倒建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/944.wav", + "text": "我們民眾黨跟林宜瑾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/945.wav", + "text": "就是說這點也許可以不寫入條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/946.wav", + "text": "但是至少在說明中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/947.wav", + "text": "會比較接近我們提出的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/948.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣子會更折衷一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/949.wav", + "text": "讓大家看得更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/950.wav", + "text": "不然的話你們說會局部加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/951.wav", + "text": "專職人員為輔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/952.wav", + "text": "到底什麼時候才會達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/953.wav", + "text": "這是非常漸進式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/954.wav", + "text": "其實我們寫的文字也沒有那麼強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/955.wav", + "text": "如果是兼職則要給予協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/956.wav", + "text": "其實精神上是差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/957.wav", + "text": "部分大家可以再稍微思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/958.wav", + "text": "折衷一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/959.wav", + "text": "這一條其實就是大家最有疑慮或最多爭議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/960.wav", + "text": "放在教學上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/961.wav", + "text": "但心評工作卻有非常多複雜的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/962.wav", + "text": "是不是會影響到學生受教權等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/963.wav", + "text": "因為他可能會有一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/964.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法進行教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/965.wav", + "text": "覺得應該朝著專職或是專責的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/966.wav", + "text": "的原因我們時代力量黨團版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/967.wav", + "text": "以及專責評估的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/968.wav", + "text": "我們相信這些絕對不可能一步到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/969.wav", + "text": "下如何認定多少才是一個合理的案量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/970.wav", + "text": "如何在合理的案量之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/971.wav", + "text": "平不影響到他們教學的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/972.wav", + "text": "修正動議第3項針對在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/973.wav", + "text": "設置合理員額的��分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/974.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/975.wav", + "text": "請問還有無委員要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/976.wav", + "text": "如果沒有委員要發言的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/977.wav", + "text": "本席也簡單講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/978.wav", + "text": "對這一條的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/979.wav", + "text": "\n本席原本提出的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/980.wav", + "text": "跟林委員宜瑾版本的意思一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/981.wav", + "text": "就是評估人員以專任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/982.wav", + "text": "教師自願兼任時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/983.wav", + "text": "應給予合理之待遇及工作上之協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/984.wav", + "text": "目的就是要解決目前心評工作的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/985.wav", + "text": "第一個困境就是耗時長負擔重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/986.wav", + "text": "如果一個學期有2至7個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/987.wav", + "text": "就要花上140個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/988.wav", + "text": "可是代課卻是看得到吃不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/989.wav", + "text": "元跟他們付出的時數不成比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/990.wav", + "text": "最後一個就是目前測驗工具缺漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/991.wav", + "text": "有將本席剛才提到的心評工作困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/992.wav", + "text": "比如工具的部分費用太低排課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/993.wav", + "text": "如果不採用林宜瑾委員和本席所提修正條文的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/994.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/995.wav", + "text": "依照現行特教法規定提供特教服務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/996.wav", + "text": "13類身心障礙學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/997.wav", + "text": "其中有9類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/998.wav", + "text": "就可以確定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/999.wav", + "text": "並不需要特教老師特別多做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1000.wav", + "text": "但另外有4個類別很特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1001.wav", + "text": "真的不能沒有特教老師的協助跟參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1002.wav", + "text": "這4類分別是學習障礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1003.wav", + "text": "這4個類別除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1004.wav", + "text": "平常的觀察跟晤談紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1005.wav", + "text": "做綜合的研判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1006.wav", + "text": "因為這些老師在平常教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1007.wav", + "text": "以及輔導他的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1008.wav", + "text": "中對這個孩子狀況的理解更為深入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1009.wav", + "text": "可以很清楚的判斷他的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1010.wav", + "text": "可以作為一個很有力的證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1011.wav", + "text": "特教老師在學生的鑑定當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1012.wav", + "text": "是不能缺少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1013.wav", + "text": "一環在英美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1014.wav", + "text": "或其他先進國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1015.wav", + "text": "確實有由心理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1016.wav", + "text": "或者教育診斷師等專責人���來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1017.wav", + "text": "的情況不過他們是以團隊的方式進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1018.wav", + "text": "在團隊成員當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1019.wav", + "text": "仍然有特教老師存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1020.wav", + "text": "跟我們鑑定標準所定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1021.wav", + "text": "需要輔以特教老師的觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1022.wav", + "text": "晤談等等資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1023.wav", + "text": "是一樣的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1024.wav", + "text": "所以英美跟其他國家的專責人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1025.wav", + "text": "任務中是一定要存在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1026.wav", + "text": "但是我們也看到目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1027.wav", + "text": "國內的鑑定確實出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1028.wav", + "text": "可能沒有設資源班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1029.wav", + "text": "沒有特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1030.wav", + "text": "要別的學校幫個案做鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1031.wav", + "text": "又或者有些學校的案量很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1032.wav", + "text": "但就只有這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1033.wav", + "text": "老師真的承擔不了負擔太重了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1034.wav", + "text": "這些都是現實的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1035.wav", + "text": "所以需要有一個調控的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1036.wav", + "text": "我們覺得這樣的調控機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1037.wav", + "text": "可能不一定要設在各個學校裡可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1038.wav", + "text": "剛才吳委員已經有提到我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1039.wav", + "text": "第5條有關特教資源中心的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1040.wav", + "text": "規定主管機關可以擇定學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1041.wav", + "text": "增置特殊教育老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1042.wav", + "text": "來協助辦理這邊所講的鑑定工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1043.wav", + "text": "可是這個鑑定工作其實是很短期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1044.wav", + "text": "很密集的需在一個月或一個半月內就要完成的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1045.wav", + "text": "之外的平常時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1046.wav", + "text": "則可從事特教資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1047.wav", + "text": "或特教行政支持網絡的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1048.wav", + "text": "這樣在人力上就可以做充分有效的運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1049.wav", + "text": "這些資源中心的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1050.wav", + "text": "確實可以有效的share掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1051.wav", + "text": "過程當中可能待遇太苛刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1052.wav", + "text": "案量太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1053.wav", + "text": "沒有工具等等這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1054.wav", + "text": "確實是需要處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1055.wav", + "text": "所以剛才也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1056.wav", + "text": "提醒要注意這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1057.wav", + "text": "同時在立法說明裡增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1058.wav", + "text": "即剛才提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1059.wav", + "text": "他們必須要有合理��待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1060.wav", + "text": "不是特教老師要去處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1061.wav", + "text": "問題而是行政單位或者特教資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1062.wav", + "text": "對於權益這兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1063.wav", + "text": "要含括哪些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1064.wav", + "text": "做充分的陳述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1065.wav", + "text": "讓大家放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1066.wav", + "text": "將來在子法中可以明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1067.wav", + "text": "大家剛才很關注的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1068.wav", + "text": "必須要被重視被解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1069.wav", + "text": "擬了一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1070.wav", + "text": "等一下大家可以來檢視一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1071.wav", + "text": "這個文字是不是OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1072.wav", + "text": "以及不少的特教老師也都明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1073.wav", + "text": "特教老師參與鑑定工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1074.wav", + "text": "有助於更清楚觀察到學生的需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1075.wav", + "text": "幫助他得以通過鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1076.wav", + "text": "之後的IEP擬定執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1077.wav", + "text": "可以更一氣呵成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1078.wav", + "text": "我們也關注到資源班的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1079.wav", + "text": "需要參與協助鑑定的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1080.wav", + "text": "量一定會相當程度的降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1081.wav", + "text": "再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1082.wav", + "text": "剛剛幾位委員提到以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1083.wav", + "text": "專任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1084.wav", + "text": "比較需要陪伴了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1085.wav", + "text": "以及後續特教服務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1086.wav", + "text": "那幾類是一定要有特教老師參與在內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1087.wav", + "text": "如果是抽出來由專任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1088.wav", + "text": "並且評估他以後的教學需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1089.wav", + "text": "的話那一部分會變成對不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1090.wav", + "text": "可是委員的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1091.wav", + "text": "果不是專任的話好像有的人會很累" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1092.wav", + "text": "是整合後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1093.wav", + "text": "就是我們知道有些學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1094.wav", + "text": "在實務上真的無法負荷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1095.wav", + "text": "我們不能夠矇著眼睛當看不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1096.wav", + "text": "的問題是有自己的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1097.wav", + "text": "自己來做心評比較好的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1098.wav", + "text": "可是又有案量太多忙不過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1099.wav", + "text": "以及學校沒有這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1100.wav", + "text": "經過受訓的老師可以來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1101.wav", + "text": "為了要解決這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1102.wav", + "text": "是不是一定要全採專任為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1103.wav", + "text": "我們直面問題來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1104.wav", + "text": "有些學校可能沒有人能夠做心評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1105.wav", + "text": "心評有些學校是案量太" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1106.wav", + "text": "自己的學生自己做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1107.wav", + "text": "但現在是案量太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1108.wav", + "text": "以及有些學校沒有可以做心評的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1109.wav", + "text": "我們現在是要幫這些學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1110.wav", + "text": "解決他的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1111.wav", + "text": "所以我們就提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1112.wav", + "text": "那些人就可以去協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1113.wav", + "text": "協助校內沒有人有資格做心評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1114.wav", + "text": "約略是一年的1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1115.wav", + "text": "1月多到3月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1116.wav", + "text": "是直接去處理問題的所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1117.wav", + "text": "這些問題還需要有配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1118.wav", + "text": "縣市給的報酬不一定相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1119.wav", + "text": "我們就會額外爭取經費來協助他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1120.wav", + "text": "所以剛才碰到兩個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1121.wav", + "text": "一個是專任這個方式能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1122.wav", + "text": "符合需求剛才我已經跟大家做了實況上的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1123.wav", + "text": "量太滿或是沒有人可以做心評的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1124.wav", + "text": "這樣的專人我們已經設了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1125.wav", + "text": "即便這樣還是有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1126.wav", + "text": "他覺得縣市間不應該不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1127.wav", + "text": "看全國的案量是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1128.wav", + "text": "我們教育部來爭取支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1129.wav", + "text": "讓縣市間不會有差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1130.wav", + "text": "讓他做心評的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1131.wav", + "text": "可以換算節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1132.wav", + "text": "用這種整體配套來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1133.wav", + "text": "現在心評老師的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1134.wav", + "text": "我個人也跑了很多國小國中高中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1135.wav", + "text": "甚至輔導團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1136.wav", + "text": "切切實實的就委員關心的向度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1137.wav", + "text": "做一個盤整之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1138.wav", + "text": "一方面爭取資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1139.wav", + "text": "二方面對於專職的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1140.wav", + "text": "我們用這樣比較完整的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1141.wav", + "text": "來解決目前面臨的困局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1142.wav", + "text": "謝謝署長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1143.wav", + "text": "據我們的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1144.wav", + "text": "經過剛才司長和署長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1145.wav", + "text": "和第五十條的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1146.wav", + "text": "就是基於配套的思���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1147.wav", + "text": "才能真的幫助這些在第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1148.wav", + "text": "這麼辛苦的特教老師呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1149.wav", + "text": "第12頁的立法說明從這裡可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1150.wav", + "text": "非常清楚的看到所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1151.wav", + "text": "權益包含哪些在此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1152.wav", + "text": "同時我們將其在評鑑期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1153.wav", + "text": "心評工作和鑑定工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1154.wav", + "text": "可合理的減少其工作負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1155.wav", + "text": "這也是我們蒐集了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1156.wav", + "text": "一些老師的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1157.wav", + "text": "間接的授課服務節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1158.wav", + "text": "第二個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1159.wav", + "text": "是立法說明的第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1160.wav", + "text": "寫得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1161.wav", + "text": "評估後寫報告也要花許多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1162.wav", + "text": "所以對於撰寫專業評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1163.wav", + "text": "應給予合理的報酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1164.wav", + "text": "本席在此要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1165.wav", + "text": "你們要真的訂出合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1166.wav", + "text": "第三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1167.wav", + "text": "很多委員都有提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1168.wav", + "text": "政策上在軟硬體方面需給予足夠的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1169.wav", + "text": "施測的工具一定要給足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1170.wav", + "text": "然後簡化他的相關作業程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1171.wav", + "text": "這些都要檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1172.wav", + "text": "\n所以依立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1173.wav", + "text": "在第十八條的文字用了三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1174.wav", + "text": "第一是調整節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1175.wav", + "text": "第二是給與合理待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1176.wav", + "text": "第三是其他工具相當的配給補足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1177.wav", + "text": "都要做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1178.wav", + "text": "這就是我同意用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1179.wav", + "text": "增加權益兩個字含括這三個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1180.wav", + "text": "\n第5條的第二個配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1181.wav", + "text": "就是剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1182.wav", + "text": "我們設在校外的特教資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1183.wav", + "text": "去支援人數不夠的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1184.wav", + "text": "或者是心評期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1185.wav", + "text": "今年剛好進來的學生特別多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1186.wav", + "text": "剛好在心評工作是爆量的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1187.wav", + "text": "用這種外部彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1188.wav", + "text": "而且是專業的特教老師來兼任的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1189.wav", + "text": "人力的有效運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1190.wav", + "text": "然後能夠來減緩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1191.wav", + "text": "特教老師的評估作業loading過重的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1192.wav", + "text": "\n所以兩個條文這樣的配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1193.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常的全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1194.wav", + "text": "希望大家能夠支持現在的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1195.wav", + "text": "聽起來大家應該都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1196.wav", + "text": "那我就再做清楚的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1197.wav", + "text": "希望能夠讓大家接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1198.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳思瑤委員幫忙說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1199.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1200.wav", + "text": "因為這個心評的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1201.wav", + "text": "我想各位委員都很關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1202.wav", + "text": "我們在第一現場的所有老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1203.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛司長還有署長的說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1204.wav", + "text": "也是經過非常詳細的討論跟評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1205.wav", + "text": "所以才會在第十八條搭配第五十條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1206.wav", + "text": "來解決這個目前現場所處理的相關問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1207.wav", + "text": "\n剛才司長署長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1208.wav", + "text": "加上剛才吳委員也來做補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1209.wav", + "text": "我也特別跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1210.wav", + "text": "特教學生的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1211.wav", + "text": "以及目前我們需要持續去進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1212.wav", + "text": "一定是一個可以及時到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1213.wav", + "text": "像心評工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1214.wav", + "text": "經過實際上的了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1215.wav", + "text": "也都知道對於現在具有心評訓練的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1216.wav", + "text": "特教老師其工作負擔真的是超過負荷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1217.wav", + "text": "教育部在之前第一階段的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1218.wav", + "text": "我覺得那只是一個基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1219.wav", + "text": "所以剛才委員所提到的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1220.wav", + "text": "雖然用權益兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1221.wav", + "text": "但是教育部事實上是已經有非常深入的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1222.wav", + "text": "不管對工作時間轉換服務的節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1223.wav", + "text": "工作的報酬以及合理負擔的數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1224.wav", + "text": "\n我也跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1225.wav", + "text": "在之前另外的條文針對有關資源班生師比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1226.wav", + "text": "這個其實我也透過附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1227.wav", + "text": "來同意應該逐年來改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1228.wav", + "text": "可以共同協助心評工作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1229.wav", + "text": "特教老師的一個未來的來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1230.wav", + "text": "所以我想如果從這樣綜整來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1231.wav", + "text": "確實我們希望以這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1232.wav", + "text": "來處理心評工作很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1233.wav", + "text": "但又需要特教老師的幫忙之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1234.wav", + "text": "我們希望在這個階段做這樣的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1235.wav", + "text": "\n第5條也是之前委員們都關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1236.wav", + "text": "各縣市的特教資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1237.wav", + "text": "是一個推動特教非常重要的專業單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1238.wav", + "text": "當時也在評估這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1239.wav", + "text": "應該要能夠建立比較永續的專職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1240.wav", + "text": "這個人員又不希望像過去這樣動輒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1241.wav", + "text": "都是用借調的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1242.wav", + "text": "委員們又擔心會影響到特教孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1243.wav", + "text": "為什麼把第5條做成加置員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1244.wav", + "text": "的都是在鑑輔會之前的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1245.wav", + "text": "這個部分可以來協助有特教生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1246.wav", + "text": "但沒有相關特教老師的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1247.wav", + "text": "的但長期特教資源中心的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1248.wav", + "text": "就會是用專任而不是用借調的員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1249.wav", + "text": "所以這個概念是教育部經過整體現場的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1250.wav", + "text": "也在委員的指教之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1251.wav", + "text": "評估出目前這樣的一個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1252.wav", + "text": "\n對於特教老師們的投入跟辛勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1253.wav", + "text": "我自己在內部也要求同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1254.wav", + "text": "一定要把特教老師們的工作條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1255.wav", + "text": "雖然當時我們還在討論過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1256.wav", + "text": "包含特教助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1257.wav", + "text": "會在113年的經費來做反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1258.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠以最快的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1259.wav", + "text": "對於剛才所談到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1260.wav", + "text": "包含我們這次在整個立法上面構想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1261.wav", + "text": "第5條的這些都能夠在113年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1262.wav", + "text": "心評工作的特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1263.wav", + "text": "我想這個議題教育部應該要直接面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1264.wav", + "text": "希望能夠透過這樣的方式來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1265.wav", + "text": "\n委員剛才所提相關的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1266.wav", + "text": "我也建議可以透過附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1267.wav", + "text": "讓行政機關在這件事情上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1268.wav", + "text": "可以具體的落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1269.wav", + "text": "也回應我們第一現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1270.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員們從討論到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1271.wav", + "text": "教育部也很務實的去提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1272.wav", + "text": "這樣的工作跟未來人員人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1273.wav", + "text": "增加協助���輕老師們的負擔這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1274.wav", + "text": "我想我們就透過這個模式把它具體化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1275.wav", + "text": "我也以這樣的態度跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1276.wav", + "text": "如果委員們也能夠同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1277.wav", + "text": "目前第十八條跟第五十條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1278.wav", + "text": "這樣的條文設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1279.wav", + "text": "我們透過附帶決議的一些具體的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1280.wav", + "text": "來做為後續落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1281.wav", + "text": "也是委員對行政機關的期待跟要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1282.wav", + "text": "好謝謝潘部長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1283.wav", + "text": "我請教部長一個問題就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1284.wav", + "text": "就是關於增置員額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1285.wav", + "text": "我們非常開心看到這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1286.wav", + "text": "所以在第5條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1287.wav", + "text": "是不是我們日後可以逐漸的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1288.wav", + "text": "在特教資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1289.wav", + "text": "跟特殊教育輔導團裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1290.wav", + "text": "都逐漸會由專任的員額調派過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1291.wav", + "text": "我應該說資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1292.wav", + "text": "因為輔導團比較不像這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1293.wav", + "text": "對資源中心我們第5條的立法就是要往這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1294.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1295.wav", + "text": "那個員額是增置員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1296.wav", + "text": "不是又從學校把他調過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1297.wav", + "text": "其實我們已經實質討論到第5條的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1298.wav", + "text": "那兩條是連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1299.wav", + "text": "的我的建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1300.wav", + "text": "看完之後我們再回來確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1301.wav", + "text": "因為第十八條剛剛就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1302.wav", + "text": "以增加評估人員的權益的這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1303.wav", + "text": "但是說明中剛剛有很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1304.wav", + "text": "把特教老師兼任的那些問題包括抵減時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1305.wav", + "text": "還有就是工具跟評估的專業支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1306.wav", + "text": "都有寫進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1307.wav", + "text": "第5條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1308.wav", + "text": "所以我建議第十八條暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1309.wav", + "text": "第5條討論完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1310.wav", + "text": "我們再回來第十八條確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1311.wav", + "text": "\n第5條附帶決議就待會一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1312.wav", + "text": "第5條是在第22頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1313.wav", + "text": "我們就直接來看這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1314.wav", + "text": "這樣大家的疑問就可以一起解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1315.wav", + "text": "還有特教輔導團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1316.wav", + "text": "特教的支持網絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1317.wav", + "text": "還有資源中心設置的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1318.wav", + "text": "等於是至少這邊是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1319.wav", + "text": "有專職化的人員可以借調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1320.wav", + "text": "學校的特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1321.wav", + "text": "有沒有委員要表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1322.wav", + "text": "還是教育部有沒有要再說明\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1323.wav", + "text": "我想大方向沒有太大的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1324.wav", + "text": "因為的確特殊教育老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1325.wav", + "text": "已經算是一個非常吃重的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1326.wav", + "text": "而且人數其實相對是不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1327.wav", + "text": "還需要增加的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1328.wav", + "text": "院版提出來修正的第4項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1329.wav", + "text": "特殊教育教師員額來協助心評的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1330.wav", + "text": "可是原本的心評工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1331.wav", + "text": "其實不只是特殊教育的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1332.wav", + "text": "可能還包含了具有輔導專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1333.wav", + "text": "心理等專長的指導老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1334.wav", + "text": "又或者是現職合格的輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1335.wav", + "text": "心理專業人員等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1336.wav", + "text": "和統籌運用的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1337.wav", + "text": "限縮在特教老師是有特別的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1338.wav", + "text": "或是這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1339.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有考慮到更寬廣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1340.wav", + "text": "心評人員的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1341.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員我剛好藉這個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1342.wav", + "text": "向委員說明這個是特教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1343.wav", + "text": "也是特教資源中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1344.wav", + "text": "老師的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1345.wav", + "text": "所以是對準這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1346.wav", + "text": "部分基本上能夠有資格的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1347.wav", + "text": "您剛才講的那類人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1348.wav", + "text": "他本來在執行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1349.wav", + "text": "因為這是特教法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1350.wav", + "text": "這個專法內能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1351.wav", + "text": "做規範的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1352.wav", + "text": "屬於特教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1353.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1354.wav", + "text": "就增加的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1355.wav", + "text": "我唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1356.wav", + "text": "各級主管機關得於公立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1357.wav", + "text": "高級中等以下學校或幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1358.wav", + "text": "指定增置由主管機關統籌運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1359.wav", + "text": "及調派之編制內特殊教育教師員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1360.wav", + "text": "用以協助辦理第十八條第一項所定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1361.wav", + "text": "鑑定評估作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1362.wav", + "text": "及辦理第一項所定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1363.wav", + "text": "特殊教育資源中心及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1364.wav", + "text": "特殊教育輔導團業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1365.wav", + "text": "或前項所定支持網絡業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1366.wav", + "text": "增加的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1367.wav", + "text": "提的委員會版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1368.wav", + "text": "有沒有委員有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1369.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1370.wav", + "text": "提會討論版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1371.wav", + "text": "\n現在回來討論剛剛的第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1372.wav", + "text": "101112頁的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1373.wav", + "text": "剛剛的說明其實有把大家擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1374.wav", + "text": "文字的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1375.wav", + "text": "就是增加評估人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1376.wav", + "text": "之資格及權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1377.wav", + "text": "權益至少剛剛有很具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1378.wav", + "text": "把我們很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1379.wav", + "text": "減輕特教老師做評估的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1380.wav", + "text": "問題包含抵減節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1381.wav", + "text": "合理報酬評估工具的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1382.wav", + "text": "與評估專業的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1383.wav", + "text": "都有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1384.wav", + "text": "\n因為剛剛林宜瑾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1385.wav", + "text": "他有跟我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1386.wav", + "text": "經過教育部的說明之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1387.wav", + "text": "他可以接受提會討論的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1388.wav", + "text": "我也可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1389.wav", + "text": "逐步專業化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1390.wav", + "text": "目前是做到局部專職化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1391.wav", + "text": "負擔過長的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1392.wav", + "text": "你們都有具體講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1393.wav", + "text": "另外還有附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1394.wav", + "text": "但我想我們先把第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1395.wav", + "text": "條文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1396.wav", + "text": "提會討論的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1397.wav", + "text": "第十八條有兩個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1398.wav", + "text": "審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1399.wav", + "text": "當時沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1400.wav", + "text": "保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1401.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1402.wav", + "text": "是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1403.wav", + "text": "只是要請你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1404.wav", + "text": "於三個月內如何減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1405.wav", + "text": "其實這裡面有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1406.wav", + "text": "請問是併哪案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1407.wav", + "text": "好另外還有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1408.wav", + "text": "是陳椒華委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1409.wav", + "text": "我看內容也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1410.wav", + "text": "就是要你們納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1411.wav", + "text": "評估人員以專業為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1412.wav", + "text": "大家看完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1413.wav", + "text": "因為這是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1414.wav", + "text": "教育部OK的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1415.wav", + "text": "你們提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1416.wav", + "text": "今天可能有一些委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1417.wav", + "text": "事前有跟我們研商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1418.wav", + "text": "到時候能不能補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1419.wav", + "text": "我們應該可以補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1420.wav", + "text": "吧今天沒有來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1421.wav", + "text": "我們今天先簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1422.wav", + "text": "你們後面還是可以補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1423.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1424.wav", + "text": "補簽並不影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1425.wav", + "text": "主席裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1426.wav", + "text": "因為他已經事先聲明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1427.wav", + "text": "我們就讓他補簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1428.wav", + "text": "林宜瑾委員剛剛也有交代了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1429.wav", + "text": "也很關心這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1430.wav", + "text": "我們也會繼續監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1431.wav", + "text": "其實我們剛剛講的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1432.wav", + "text": "都應該節數化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1433.wav", + "text": "然後調整融合的部分都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1434.wav", + "text": "鑑定的原則工具的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1435.wav", + "text": "特教資源中心的建制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1436.wav", + "text": "制教師的支持簡化評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1437.wav", + "text": "以及剛剛有講到研議學前發展遲緩到國小1年級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1438.wav", + "text": "還有評估工作撰寫的綜合報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1439.wav", + "text": "督導各縣市要給予合理費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1440.wav", + "text": "我想這些都是剛剛大家關心的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1441.wav", + "text": "\n現在處理第23條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1442.wav", + "text": "關於學生申訴再申訴機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1443.wav", + "text": "因為當時是說我們等國教法處理完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1444.wav", + "text": "精神原則應該一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1445.wav", + "text": "請大家翻到第14頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1446.wav", + "text": "也是我們今天最後一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1447.wav", + "text": "\n這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1448.wav", + "text": "有沒有委員要先發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1449.wav", + "text": "或是教育部要直接說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1450.wav", + "text": "吳司長是不是要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1451.wav", + "text": "上次第23條會保留的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1452.wav", + "text": "是因為在國教法第4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1453.wav", + "text": "有同樣的申訴規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1454.wav", + "text": "尤其涉及到國中國小階段的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1455.wav", + "text": "兩邊作法可能需要同步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1456.wav", + "text": "所以才保留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1457.wav", + "text": "國教法在討論這塊我們有做了一些文字的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1458.wav", + "text": "也有提供一些文字修正的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1459.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1460.wav", + "text": "今天提供會場上的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1461.wav", + "text": "最主要就是配合國教法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1462.wav", + "text": "因為國教法學生的教育階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1463.wav", + "text": "都是15歲以下的學童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1464.wav", + "text": "所以必須由他的法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1465.wav", + "text": "由其法定代理人實際照顧者代為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1466.wav", + "text": "這是一種類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1467.wav", + "text": "如果他已經是高級中等教育階段的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1468.wav", + "text": "特殊教育學生的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1469.wav", + "text": "就可以由學生單獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1470.wav", + "text": "這是配合高級中等教育法的申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1471.wav", + "text": "可以單獨提起的體例來運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1472.wav", + "text": "提起訴願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1473.wav", + "text": "要移轉管轄的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1474.wav", + "text": "要通知原來誤提的法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1475.wav", + "text": "實際照顧者或高級中等教育階段的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1476.wav", + "text": "特殊教育學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1477.wav", + "text": "這是第2項的補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1478.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1479.wav", + "text": "要再跟委員補充說明的地方就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1480.wav", + "text": "原來的第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1481.wav", + "text": "學生或幼兒的法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1482.wav", + "text": "實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1483.wav", + "text": "可以就鑑定安置輔導的部分來提起申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1484.wav", + "text": "就跟第2項不太一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1485.wav", + "text": "所以我們會建議修正為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1486.wav", + "text": "得由學生或幼兒之法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1487.wav", + "text": "實際照顧者代為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1488.wav", + "text": "高級中等以上教育階段特殊教育學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1489.wav", + "text": "向主管機關提起申訴後面是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1490.wav", + "text": "相關期限是在子法裡面定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1491.wav", + "text": "因為特殊教育法的立法體例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1492.wav", + "text": "與國民教育法不太一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1493.wav", + "text": "第1項申訴第2項申訴及再申訴前項申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1494.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1495.wav", + "text": "這個部分在國民教育階段的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1496.wav", + "text": "會在子法裡面配合辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1497.wav", + "text": "以上補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1498.wav", + "text": "對這就是我的疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1499.wav", + "text": "剛剛國教法是很清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1500.wav", + "text": "我們增加了實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1501.wav", + "text": "在特教的部分還有高級中學的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1502.wav", + "text": "這個都OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1503.wav", + "text": "而申訴之提起有一定的期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1504.wav", + "text": "在國教法是40天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1505.wav", + "text": "現在特教法同樣的這一條就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1506.wav", + "text": "這個部分是由相關事項之辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1507.wav", + "text": "就是你會另外訂一個辦法就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1508.wav", + "text": "所以不需要寫進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1509.wav", + "text": "那我就在這裡確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1510.wav", + "text": "就比照40天內以及書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1511.wav", + "text": "對吧好如果是這樣我就沒有問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1512.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1513.wav", + "text": "員所以現在就是幾天的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1514.wav", + "text": "你們子法再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1515.wav", + "text": "然後通知也要包含學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1516.wav", + "text": "那個也可以修改就像剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1517.wav", + "text": "已經有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1518.wav", + "text": "學生及法定代理人都要有對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1519.wav", + "text": "請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1520.wav", + "text": "報告委員因為國民教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1521.wav", + "text": "跟特殊教育法的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1522.wav", + "text": "和提起處理結果的規範不太一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1523.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1524.wav", + "text": "申訴處理結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1525.wav", + "text": "要通知可以申請的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1526.wav", + "text": "法定代理人實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1527.wav", + "text": "跟高中教育階段的學生以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1528.wav", + "text": "還有所有的學生都要通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1529.wav", + "text": "這個條文在特教法裡面是沒有規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1530.wav", + "text": "都是在子法裡面規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1531.wav", + "text": "可是我看你第23條提委員會的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1532.wav", + "text": "並通知學生及其法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1533.wav", + "text": "那個是誤提起訴願的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1534.wav", + "text": "移轉管轄的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1535.wav", + "text": "譬如原來提起的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1536.wav", + "text": "法定代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1537.wav", + "text": "但是提錯地方了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1538.wav", + "text": "從訴願機關移轉回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1539.wav", + "text": "員會來並通知提起人弄錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1540.wav", + "text": "所以這個地方跟處理結果的通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1541.wav", + "text": "是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1542.wav", + "text": "請張委員其祿發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1543.wav", + "text": "好我這邊有一個提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1544.wav", + "text": "我知道你們現在的概念是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1545.wav", + "text": "是希望把實際照顧者也放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1546.wav", + "text": "和實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1547.wav", + "text": "如果他們彼此意見有矛盾的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1548.wav", + "text": "你們細節上要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1549.wav", + "text": "比如說有一種可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1550.wav", + "text": "但法定代理人是爸爸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1551.wav", + "text": "他們都拿到通知之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1552.wav", + "text": "一方願意提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1553.wav", + "text": "另外一方卻不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1554.wav", + "text": "那這個怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1555.wav", + "text": "內部已經有做處理了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1556.wav", + "text": "這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1557.wav", + "text": "司長或署長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1558.wav", + "text": "和實際照顧者這個條文的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1559.wav", + "text": "出現在很多地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1560.wav", + "text": "張委員所擔心的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1561.wav", + "text": "而我們在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1562.wav", + "text": "中都有說得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1563.wav", + "text": "主要還是法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1564.wav", + "text": "譬如說入監服刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1565.wav", + "text": "或者因為什麼情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1566.wav", + "text": "這個時候實際照顧者的角色才會出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1567.wav", + "text": "在立法說明中有完整的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1568.wav", + "text": "這邊我是有點不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1569.wav", + "text": "啦當然法條體例不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1570.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說第一層的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1571.wav", + "text": "申訴結果通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1572.wav", + "text": "在國教法我們是改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1573.wav", + "text": "通知回來要給本人及法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1574.wav", + "text": "代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1575.wav", + "text": "那這邊因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1576.wav", + "text": "訴願然後受理訴願機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1577.wav", + "text": "和結果為什麼結果不能也通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1578.wav", + "text": "特教學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1579.wav", + "text": "及法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1580.wav", + "text": "因為這樣一致啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1581.wav", + "text": "多通知一個特教生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1582.wav", + "text": "不能等同於國教法國教生的位置嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1583.wav", + "text": "高級中等教育法國教法裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1584.wav", + "text": "有關申訴的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1585.wav", + "text": "其實在特教法的子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1586.wav", + "text": "特教學生的申訴辦法裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1587.wav", + "text": "都會規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1588.wav", + "text": "只是考慮到這些條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1589.wav", + "text": "如果統統放進母法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1590.wav", + "text": "文字量會非常的大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1591.wav", + "text": "有很多細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1592.wav", + "text": "加個學生就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1593.wav", + "text": "跟剛剛一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1594.wav", + "text": "並通知學生及學生法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1595.wav", + "text": "代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1596.wav", + "text": "不一樣不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1597.wav", + "text": "剛才那個是申訴的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1598.wav", + "text": "更高層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1599.wav", + "text": "因為訴願通常都是由法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1600.wav", + "text": "代理人或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1601.wav", + "text": "喔是因為法律原因不能通知本人嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1602.wav", + "text": "因為增加進去是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1603.wav", + "text": "多通知一個本來不是提起的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1604.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1605.wav", + "text": "委員會這邊認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1606.wav", + "text": "這樣是比較完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1607.wav", + "text": "也就是提起的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1608.wav", + "text": "但是移轉管轄的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1609.wav", + "text": "也一併通知學生的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1610.wav", + "text": "加進去是無害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1611.wav", + "text": "啦但就是說有沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1612.wav", + "text": "無害我們就加入吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1613.wav", + "text": "多通知一個應該OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1614.wav", + "text": "吧特教生本人應該被尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1615.wav", + "text": "無害的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1616.wav", + "text": "就要通知了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1617.wav", + "text": "後面就不用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1618.wav", + "text": "好文字順一下就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1619.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛這邊才修過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1620.wav", + "text": "螢幕上修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1621.wav", + "text": "學生本人跟剛剛國教法那邊一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1622.wav", + "text": "至少有寫出來的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1623.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1624.wav", + "text": "並通知學生及其法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1625.wav", + "text": "或實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1626.wav", + "text": "那後面高級中等學校就不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1627.wav", + "text": "非常好這樣文字還更精簡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1628.wav", + "text": "第1項大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1629.wav", + "text": "有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1630.wav", + "text": "對學生與幼兒鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1631.wav", + "text": "安置輔導及支持服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1632.wav", + "text": "如有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1633.wav", + "text": "得由學生或幼兒之法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1634.wav", + "text": "實際照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1635.wav", + "text": "代為或由高級中等以上教育階段特殊教育學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1636.wav", + "text": "向主管機關提起申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1637.wav", + "text": "主管機關應提供申訴服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1638.wav", + "text": "OK嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1639.wav", + "text": "第52條請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1640.wav", + "text": "問在第幾頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1641.wav", + "text": "第52條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1642.wav", + "text": "是有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1643.wav", + "text": "特教評鑑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1644.wav", + "text": "請於螢幕顯示好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1645.wav", + "text": "因為大家手上沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1646.wav", + "text": "因為第1項是對學校的評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1647.wav", + "text": "第2項是對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1648.wav", + "text": "主管機關的評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1649.wav", + "text": "那文字敘寫不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1650.wav", + "text": "第1項是每四年至少應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1651.wav", + "text": "第2項是應至少每四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1652.wav", + "text": "兩邊其實意思是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1653.wav", + "text": "但是敘寫的文字不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1654.wav", + "text": "我們是建議修正第2項文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1655.wav", + "text": "比照第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1656.wav", + "text": "就是每四年至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1657.wav", + "text": "每四年至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1658.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1659.wav", + "text": "委員有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1660.wav", + "text": "每四年至少應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1661.wav", + "text": "都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1662.wav", + "text": "每四年至少好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1663.wav", + "text": "果委員沒有其他反對意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1664.wav", + "text": "教育部的修正文字第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1665.wav", + "text": "有兩個新的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1666.wav", + "text": "大家手上有拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1667.wav", + "text": "有沒有任何意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1668.wav", + "text": "在看附帶決議之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1669.wav", + "text": "我還是要提醒一下教育部應該要注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1670.wav", + "text": "注意程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1671.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們針對國教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1672.wav", + "text": "委員如果對於當初沒有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1673.wav", + "text": "協商的條文要提出來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1674.wav", + "text": "我們在會議之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1675.wav", + "text": "要先提出向主席報准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1676.wav", + "text": "而且我們要有附帶臨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1677.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1678.wav", + "text": "那你現在突然冒出了這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1679.wav", + "text": "但是程序還是程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1680.wav", + "text": "我們委員是這樣要求我們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1681.wav", + "text": "你們應該也這樣要求才是對委員會的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1682.wav", + "text": "本席謝謝吳思瑤委員的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1683.wav", + "text": "因為吳思瑤委員比較資深" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1684.wav", + "text": "他知道教育部這樣處理並不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1685.wav", + "text": "因為你今天的文字沒什麼爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1686.wav", + "text": "所以OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1687.wav", + "text": "否則你其實應該也要拜託委員幫你提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1688.wav", + "text": "要不然我們手上都沒有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1689.wav", + "text": "我們所有委員都要一起負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1690.wav", + "text": "你要找人提案連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1691.wav", + "text": "好謝謝吳思瑤委員提醒大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1692.wav", + "text": "也請教育部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1693.wav", + "text": "要提出修正文字的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1694.wav", + "text": "已經通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1695.wav", + "text": "\n附帶決議1的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1696.wav", + "text": "教育部有沒有什麼要說明和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1697.wav", + "text": "要不要表達一下意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1698.wav", + "text": "有兩個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1699.wav", + "text": "現在大家手上都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1700.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委跟四位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1701.wav", + "text": "委員請看第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1702.wav", + "text": "一個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1703.wav", + "text": "這點我們朝這個方向來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1704.wav", + "text": "因為我們也去看了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1705.wav", + "text": "有些報告如果用字數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1706.wav", + "text": "可能也不一定對老師有利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1707.wav", + "text": "是不是就用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1708.wav", + "text": "不要低於1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1709.wav", + "text": "因為現在縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1710.wav", + "text": "在執行過程可能礙於經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1711.wav", + "text": "的確有可能低於1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1712.wav", + "text": "現在我們新的年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1713.wav", + "text": "部長剛才已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1714.wav", + "text": "我們來幫縣市處理到位未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1715.wav", + "text": "我們是否就採一種標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1716.wav", + "text": "比較不會讓老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1717.wav", + "text": "和縣市在執行的時候不好處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1718.wav", + "text": "我們就用一份1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1719.wav", + "text": "用字數怕有些字數少的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1720.wav", + "text": "老師其實很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1721.wav", + "text": "如果只是因為字少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1722.wav", + "text": "又要讓他寫那麼多字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1723.wav", + "text": "其實有些也沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1724.wav", + "text": "我們就給請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1725.wav", + "text": "針對這個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1726.wav", + "text": "我想詢問一下教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1727.wav", + "text": "這應該就是回到剛剛的第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1728.wav", + "text": "對於這些特殊教育老師在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1729.wav", + "text": "鑑定工作要給與他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1730.wav", + "text": "權益的部分要怎麼弄你們本來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1731.wav", + "text": "要訂一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1732.wav", + "text": "子法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1733.wav", + "text": "所以既然有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1734.wav", + "text": "子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1735.wav", + "text": "現在又有一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1736.wav", + "text": "撰寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1737.wav", + "text": "稿件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1738.wav", + "text": "會不會有一點怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1739.wav", + "text": "因為他其實是更多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1740.wav", + "text": "就是說他的權益面向更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1741.wav", + "text": "不是只有撰寫報告的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1742.wav", + "text": "婉諭委員是希望能夠有個保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1743.wav", + "text": "希望你們提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1744.wav", + "text": "比這個更優渥也不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1745.wav", + "text": "出席費跟稿費支給要點剛好是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1746.wav", + "text": "我質詢過後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1747.wav", + "text": "所以這當然是比照所有公務機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1748.wav", + "text": "包括學校都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1749.wav", + "text": "想當然耳的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1750.wav", + "text": "我很想得到你們的答案搞不好比這個更優渥啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1751.wav", + "text": "針對權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1752.wav", + "text": "合理待遇的部分針對文稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1753.wav", + "text": "這是我比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1754.wav", + "text": "不太理解的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1755.wav", + "text": "\n我當然支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1756.wav", + "text": "要用最新上路的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1757.wav", + "text": "甚至要給得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1758.wav", + "text": "給得更優渥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1759.wav", + "text": "只是教育部要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1760.wav", + "text": "委員的立意都是非常良善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1761.wav", + "text": "而且希望要求你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1762.wav", + "text": "做到更好保障老師權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1763.wav", + "text": "只是我覺得好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1764.wav", + "text": "你們說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1765.wav", + "text": "我也同意吳思瑤委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1766.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛我們就講過現狀就是1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1767.wav", + "text": "元當然我們要改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1768.wav", + "text": "不應也不會低於1,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1769.wav", + "text": "元可是剛剛也有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1770.wav", + "text": "會抵減節數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1771.wav", + "text": "節數這邊涉及到的是一個更大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1772.wav", + "text": "中央機關不只是心評而是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1773.wav", + "text": "全部的學校出席費及稿費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1774.wav", + "text": "支給要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1775.wav", + "text": "所以這點要不要就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1776.wav", + "text": "討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1777.wav", + "text": "這邊王委員有要說明嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1778.wav", + "text": "我想先釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1779.wav", + "text": "其實是已經通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1780.wav", + "text": "而且公布修正的部分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1781.wav", + "text": "\n只是在我們現在的心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1782.wav", + "text": "心評培訓及作業參考原則之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1783.wav", + "text": "原本依照支給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1784.wav", + "text": "支給要點要一起做調整的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1785.wav", + "text": "每千字多少錢來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1786.wav", + "text": "而是這個支給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1787.wav", + "text": "不低於1,000元的參考原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1788.wav", + "text": "如果沒有做調整其實是沒有辦法符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1789.wav", + "text": "現在新通過的支給要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1790.wav", + "text": "所以應該是要配合這個要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1791.wav", + "text": "來做相對應的協調和調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1792.wav", + "text": "\n當然今天有新的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1793.wav", + "text": "是大家一起提案通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1794.wav", + "text": "我覺得是可以一起納入併案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1795.wav", + "text": "這沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1796.wav", + "text": "但是我認為這個部分還是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1797.wav", + "text": "依照去年已經通過的要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1798.wav", + "text": "已經有新的要點通過是比較高的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1799.wav", + "text": "其實就應該跟著新的要點一起做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1800.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1801.wav", + "text": "所以王婉諭委員的意思是可以併入原來第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1802.wav", + "text": "也是類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1803.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員因為剛剛你們給資料時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1804.wav", + "text": "還沒有看到第十八條新的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1805.wav", + "text": "是不是就併入新的部分一起處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1806.wav", + "text": "因為兩個意見好像都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1807.wav", + "text": "跟大家意見一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1808.wav", + "text": "就是要合理的權益心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1809.wav", + "text": "的部分都應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1810.wav", + "text": "\n因為剛剛已經通過一些原則了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1811.wav", + "text": "現在又有附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1812.wav", + "text": "相關的更細節的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1813.wav", + "text": "我想補充說明一下併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1814.wav", + "text": "這些統計資訊能夠更加公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1815.wav", + "text": "比較爭議的心評人員到底有沒有專職化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1816.wav", + "text": "的情況下其實大家對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1817.wav", + "text": "到底會不會影響到教學又或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1818.wav", + "text": "否適量無論在老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1819.wav", + "text": "學生或家長團體其實都有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1820.wav", + "text": "不同的衝突我覺得問題就在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1821.wav", + "text": "其實相關資訊並沒有那麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1822.wav", + "text": "在未來的調整方向上能夠朝著這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1823.wav", + "text": "來做處理就是把相關資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1824.wav", + "text": "平均案量接案次數等分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1825.wav", + "text": "的統計資料能夠逐年讓大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1826.wav", + "text": "進行討論謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1827.wav", + "text": "謝謝王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1828.wav", + "text": "這個是否有在第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1829.wav", + "text": "附帶決議中還是要另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1830.wav", + "text": "現在是附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1831.wav", + "text": "2因為附帶決議1剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1832.wav", + "text": "剛王婉諭委員有同意併入原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1833.wav", + "text": "的第十八條其實意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1834.wav", + "text": "是一樣的就是待遇的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1835.wav", + "text": "或者抵節數都要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1836.wav", + "text": "現在附帶決議2比較是關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1837.wav", + "text": "公開相關的合格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1838.wav", + "text": "案量接案次數分配等統計指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1839.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1840.wav", + "text": "公開的部分教育部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1841.wav", + "text": "同意或者是修正後同意還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1842.wav", + "text": "謝謝王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1843.wav", + "text": "王委員現在所提的我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1844.wav", + "text": "檢視一下剛剛幾位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1845.wav", + "text": "委員共同擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1846.wav", + "text": "基本上王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1847.wav", + "text": "所提的是在我們去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1848.wav", + "text": "處理相關事項的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1849.wav", + "text": "有的基本訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1850.wav", + "text": "所以我們目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1851.wav", + "text": "看到委員所擬的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1852.wav", + "text": "是委員們大家一起共提的七點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1853.wav", + "text": "我們要處理好那些事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1854.wav", + "text": "那自然會做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1855.wav", + "text": "王委員所提的要有那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1856.wav", + "text": "數據我們才能決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1857.wav", + "text": "因此初步來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1858.wav", + "text": "但因為它本來就會併到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1859.wav", + "text": "一定要做的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1860.wav", + "text": "所以首先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1861.wav", + "text": "要單獨同意這個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1862.wav", + "text": "我們沒有特別的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1863.wav", + "text": "但也跟王委員特別報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1864.wav", + "text": "七點附帶決議的時候一定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1865.wav", + "text": "要基於這些透明的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1866.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見就同意吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1867.wav", + "text": "是\n請吳委員思瑤發言婉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1868.wav", + "text": "婉諭委員的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1869.wav", + "text": "因為我不了解現況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1870.wav", + "text": "就是說每位心評人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1871.wav", + "text": "每學年的總案量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1872.wav", + "text": "以不高於十案為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1873.wav", + "text": "我不曉得現在的average是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1874.wav", + "text": "所以我沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1875.wav", + "text": "十案不得高於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1876.wav", + "text": "或低於是否合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1877.wav", + "text": "因為我們如果要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1878.wav", + "text": "通過這個條文就必須很慎重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1879.wav", + "text": "來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1880.wav", + "text": "我的認知是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1881.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1882.wav", + "text": "兩個配套一個是以權益的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1883.wav", + "text": "方式補強一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1884.wav", + "text": "剛剛第5條的最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1885.wav", + "text": "在各縣市的特資中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1886.wav", + "text": "裡頭要去增置新的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1887.wav", + "text": "就是要減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1888.wav", + "text": "他們的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1889.wav", + "text": "去減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1890.wav", + "text": "減輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1891.wav", + "text": "做心評工作的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1892.wav", + "text": "\n但是因為我不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1893.wav", + "text": "現在的心評人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1894.wav", + "text": "每學年不高於十案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1895.wav", + "text": "我沒有價值評論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1896.wav", + "text": "因為我不知道現況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1897.wav", + "text": "是如何所以現在當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1898.wav", + "text": "有委員的提案說不得高於十案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1899.wav", + "text": "為原則我就沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1900.wav", + "text": "去判斷我可不可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1901.wav", + "text": "或者我們這裡能不能夠通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1902.wav", + "text": "這點你們要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1903.wav", + "text": "也許是二十案也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1904.wav", + "text": "是十五案也許是五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1905.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1906.wav", + "text": "價值評價所以你們必須要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1907.wav", + "text": "我不知道這個數字是怎麼來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1908.wav", + "text": "不同的意見因為時間已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1909.wav", + "text": "滿晚了16時14分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1910.wav", + "text": "我們經協商很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1911.wav", + "text": "我們其實只有協商四個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1912.wav", + "text": "我是建議因為有委員有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1913.wav", + "text": "我們是否就保留到院會再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1914.wav", + "text": "要再補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1915.wav", + "text": "我是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1916.wav", + "text": "王委員所提的這些尤其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1917.wav", + "text": "第三段是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1918.wav", + "text": "剛才也特別跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1919.wav", + "text": "報告我們在處理這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1920.wav", + "text": "事情的時候一定都會考慮這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1921.wav", + "text": "第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1922.wav", + "text": "來處理用第十八條的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1923.wav", + "text": "來處理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1924.wav", + "text": "我想補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1925.wav", + "text": "不是我們要求不高於十案為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1926.wav", + "text": "而是這是現行原則中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1927.wav", + "text": "的第十二點裡面就有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1928.wav", + "text": "總案量不得高於十案為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1929.wav", + "text": "就我們現在所知超過十案的多有所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1930.wav", + "text": "到底超過多少是有的我們還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1931.wav", + "text": "能夠有個清楚的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1932.wav", + "text": "接多少案其實都沒有得到相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1933.wav", + "text": "資訊所以我覺得這部分的確是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1934.wav", + "text": "應該要能夠更加地瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1935.wav", + "text": "這邊都已經同意我想就是直接通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1936.wav", + "text": "其實沒有必要因為在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1937.wav", + "text": "提的就一定要併案我想也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1938.wav", + "text": "這樣的原則既然沒有意見其實就是讓它照案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1939.wav", + "text": "通過謝謝請吳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1940.wav", + "text": "瑤發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1941.wav", + "text": "我是不能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1942.wav", + "text": "我只是提出詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1943.wav", + "text": "就要被扣上這是在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1944.wav", + "text": "委員提的案子就不予支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1945.wav", + "text": "絕對不是這樣好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1946.wav", + "text": "婉諭委員絕對不是我們非常認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1947.wav", + "text": "現行的原則是每位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1948.wav", + "text": "心評人員每學年的總案量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1949.wav", + "text": "以不高於十案為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1950.wav", + "text": "第十八條增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1951.wav", + "text": "他的權益待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1952.wav", + "text": "然後在第五十條增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1953.wav", + "text": "其人力有另外一個外部補給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1954.wav", + "text": "loading更低就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1955.wav", + "text": "多少專置人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1956.wav", + "text": "所以我們當然必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1957.wav", + "text": "跟工作負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1958.wav", + "text": "去了解他們現在的工作時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1959.wav", + "text": "案量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1960.wav", + "text": "最後一項增置的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1961.wav", + "text": "要去評估的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1962.wav", + "text": "所以再清楚論述如果這樣講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1963.wav", + "text": "要通過OK那就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1964.wav", + "text": "再請幾位委員增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1965.wav", + "text": "連署附帶決議才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1966.wav", + "text": "條件\n我再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1967.wav", + "text": "從來沒有任何人在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1968.wav", + "text": "因為不同政黨提出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1969.wav", + "text": "不同意見就採取反對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1970.wav", + "text": "態度我要非常嚴厲的抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1971.wav", + "text": "在特教法的審議過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1972.wav", + "text": "的委員共同為特教來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1973.wav", + "text": "努力所以這樣的說法在最後這一刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1974.wav", + "text": "被提出來我覺得非常遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1975.wav", + "text": "剛剛有講到因為第一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1976.wav", + "text": "大家今天已經討論了兩個多小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1977.wav", + "text": "真的也閱讀了很多東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1978.wav", + "text": "其實現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1979.wav", + "text": "有理解了就是按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1980.wav", + "text": "現行辦法的第十二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1981.wav", + "text": "目前本來就有規定不高於十案為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1982.wav", + "text": "回應一下好嗎是國教署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1983.wav", + "text": "剛剛已經說明過這個是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1984.wav", + "text": "的因為我們現行也會這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1985.wav", + "text": "也建議大家因為我們大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1986.wav", + "text": "其實都是超越黨派在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1987.wav", + "text": "特教跟國教的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1988.wav", + "text": "剛剛也看到我們國教已經幾乎都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1989.wav", + "text": "同意了都是共同修正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1990.wav", + "text": "版本特教法其實也幾乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1991.wav", + "text": "已經沒有保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1992.wav", + "text": "是否就請大家一起簽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1993.wav", + "text": "針對整個特教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1994.wav", + "text": "政院函請審議特殊教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1995.wav", + "text": "修正草案案協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1996.wav", + "text": "第6條第十八條第二十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1997.wav", + "text": "修正通過如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1998.wav", + "text": "件二通過原審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/1999.wav", + "text": "會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2000.wav", + "text": "及新增附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2001.wav", + "text": "共2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2002.wav", + "text": "其餘均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2003.wav", + "text": "照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2004.wav", + "text": "檢附立法說明1份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2005.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2006.wav", + "text": "大家真的很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2007.wav", + "text": "簽名的東西在那邊請大家簽名一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2008.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2009.wav", + "text": "都通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2010.wav", + "text": "沒有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2011.wav", + "text": "我們也恭喜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15034/2012.wav", + "text": "國教法跟特教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/0.wav", + "text": "條文內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/1.wav", + "text": "回應委員會審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/2.wav", + "text": "提出修法的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/3.wav", + "text": "這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/4.wav", + "text": "到只是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/5.wav", + "text": "\n附帶決議2的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/6.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/7.wav", + "text": "他們的壓力用這樣的方式去減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/8.wav", + "text": "因為我不瞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/9.wav", + "text": "可以支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/10.wav", + "text": "我們這裡能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/11.wav", + "text": "有協商我是建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/12.wav", + "text": "提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15033/13.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/0.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/1.wav", + "text": "我們臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/2.wav", + "text": "懇請委員支持行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/3.wav", + "text": "所有委員的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/4.wav", + "text": "部法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/5.wav", + "text": "建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/6.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/7.wav", + "text": "這個法律名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/8.wav", + "text": "分就是因為要當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/9.wav", + "text": "案件很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/10.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/11.wav", + "text": "經過委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/12.wav", + "text": "正第36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/13.wav", + "text": "三次審查通過的條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/14.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/15.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/16.wav", + "text": "決議我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/17.wav", + "text": "就不予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15018/18.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/0.wav", + "text": "我們今天進行入出國及移民法修正草案的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/1.wav", + "text": "我們修正草案一共有19案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/2.wav", + "text": "經過內政委員會在今年的3月8日3月9日3月20日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/3.wav", + "text": "還有4月17日詢答審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/4.wav", + "text": "我們保留的條文有第22條第23條第29條第62條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/5.wav", + "text": "跟增訂第74條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/6.wav", + "text": "還有第85條及附帶決議兩項共計7項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/7.wav", + "text": "現在就保留的部分進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/8.wav", + "text": "或可能為難民或申請庇護者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/9.wav", + "text": "料可以取得停留或居留許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/10.wav", + "text": "這個部分在4月17日第三次審查會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/11.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/12.wav", + "text": "而且各國都有專法來因應加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/13.wav", + "text": "有可能開了大門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/14.wav", + "text": "卻沒有相關的配套措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/15.wav", + "text": "以致造成我們國家的一個困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/16.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員也再召集本署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/17.wav", + "text": "目前我們是用個案的方式做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/18.wav", + "text": "而且也會落實不遣返的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/19.wav", + "text": "暫行的機制來協助當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/20.wav", + "text": "在臺滯留期間的工作與就學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/21.wav", + "text": "還有參與社會保險的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/22.wav", + "text": "並且在4月24日那次的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/23.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/24.wav", + "text": "22條時代力量黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/25.wav", + "text": "就是因為我國沒有針對難民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/26.wav", + "text": "或是庇護者訂定明確的處理機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/27.wav", + "text": "所以導致來臺尋求庇護的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/28.wav", + "text": "僅能透過民間團體個別協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/29.wav", + "text": "法制上也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/30.wav", + "text": "合法獲得停留居留許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/31.wav", + "text": "也無法自立更生來穩定生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/32.wav", + "text": "或是就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/33.wav", + "text": "雖然內政部總是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/34.wav", + "text": "難民的議題要立專法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/35.wav", + "text": "但是現況就是難民法的訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/36.wav", + "text": "遇到嚴重阻礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/37.wav", + "text": "路程遙遙無期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/38.wav", + "text": "所以專法確定前的制度如何接住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/39.wav", + "text": "前來尋求的庇護者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/40.wav", + "text": "勢必仍然是要思考的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/41.wav", + "text": "所以請內政部一定要儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/42.wav", + "text": "針對尋求庇護者個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/43.wav", + "text": "研擬暫時安置的因應方案及生活照顧機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/44.wav", + "text": "請機關務必要趕快來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/45.wav", + "text": "以上是時力的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/46.wav", + "text": "首先非常謝謝召委安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/47.wav", + "text": "今天入出國及移民法的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/48.wav", + "text": "針對第22條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/49.wav", + "text": "是不爭的事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/50.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛陳椒華委員提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/51.wav", + "text": "剛剛陳椒華委員也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/52.wav", + "text": "最多只能依照外國人停留居留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/53.wav", + "text": "及永久居留辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/54.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法就醫就學跟就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/55.wav", + "text": "仍然是非法居留的外國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/56.wav", + "text": "也因為是非法居留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/57.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法工作沒有勞健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/58.wav", + "text": "長期仰賴民間團體的接濟為生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/59.wav", + "text": "提供正當化法源依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/60.wav", + "text": "如果有機會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/61.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/62.wav", + "text": "請洪委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/63.wav", + "text": "保護臺灣這些尋求庇護者的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/64.wav", + "text": "希望以解決問題為導向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/65.wav", + "text": "難民政策沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/66.wav", + "text": "主要是能處理來到臺灣尋求庇護者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/67.wav", + "text": "\n移民署在上次協商後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/68.wav", + "text": "到底其他部會能不能買單跟運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/69.wav", + "text": "其實我還是有提出一些疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/70.wav", + "text": "所以除了移民署以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/71.wav", + "text": "後來我也再開了一次協調會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/72.wav", + "text": "找勞動部保險司勞發署勞保局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/73.wav", + "text": "衛福部社保司健保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/74.wav", + "text": "及教育部一起來協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/75.wav", + "text": "等於是把一個尋求庇護者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/76.wav", + "text": "在臺灣所需要相關權利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/77.wav", + "text": "在上次協商之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/78.wav", + "text": "尋求庇護人士在臺灣等待中轉的期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/79.wav", + "text": "他被設定是在等待中轉的期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/80.wav", + "text": "可以依照外國人停留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/81.wav", + "text": "居留及永久居留辦法第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/82.wav", + "text": "由移民署來核發所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/83.wav", + "text": "臨時外僑登記證給他一個類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/84.wav", + "text": "這個所謂臨時外僑登記證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/85.wav", + "text": "後來我們在協調會上面也確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/86.wav", + "text": "移民署在給外僑登記證的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/87.wav", + "text": "會一併行文給涉及個案權利的相關機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/88.wav", + "text": "就像我剛剛說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/89.wav", + "text": "的勞動部衛福部教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/90.wav", + "text": "在公文上面會說明這些人是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/91.wav", + "text": "類推居留身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/92.wav", + "text": "他們給我的回復是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/93.wav", + "text": "這是可行的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/94.wav", + "text": "這個類推居留身分的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/95.wav", + "text": "他們會啟動相關的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/96.wav", + "text": "尋求庇護人士相關權利的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/97.wav", + "text": "包括在臺的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/98.wav", + "text": "就學參與社會保險等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/99.wav", + "text": "\n經過了這個跨部會的確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/100.wav", + "text": "基本上我認為這個作法應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/101.wav", + "text": "可以運作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/102.wav", + "text": "我召開了兩次協調會來確認這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/103.wav", + "text": "當然我有要求移民署為了避免這些外籍人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/104.wav", + "text": "因為不會說中文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/105.wav", + "text": "各機關辦理相關程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/106.wav", + "text": "的問題所以移民署有承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/107.wav", + "text": "如果個案有需求的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/108.wav", + "text": "移民署會提供通譯人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/109.wav", + "text": "也就是說目前這些可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/110.wav", + "text": "因為各種政治原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/111.wav", + "text": "而滯留在臺灣等待中轉的尋求庇護者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/112.wav", + "text": "他們可以到移民署各地的服務站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/113.wav", + "text": "提出相關證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/114.wav", + "text": "進入審查程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/115.wav", + "text": "經過移民署跟相關單位的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/116.wav", + "text": "也就是包括發文以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/117.wav", + "text": "認有具體事由無法執行強制驅逐出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/118.wav", + "text": "就會啟動這套模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/119.wav", + "text": "由移民署核發臨時外僑登記證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/120.wav", + "text": "發文剛剛那幾個相關的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/121.wav", + "text": "讓他可以在臺灣工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/122.wav", + "text": "就學辦理保險跟維持他基本的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/123.wav", + "text": "我想跟移民署再確認一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/124.wav", + "text": "是可以運作的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/125.wav", + "text": "第22條的部分我就不堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/126.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/127.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/128.wav", + "text": "這樣意見就會比較接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/129.wav", + "text": "事實上我本人是有參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/130.wav", + "text": "相關部會的同仁也都有參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/131.wav", + "text": "整個程序確實是這樣的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/132.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/133.wav", + "text": "當事人跟移民署提出申請之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/134.wav", + "text": "是不是符合事實狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/135.wav", + "text": "除了會核發臨時外僑登記證之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/136.wav", + "text": "還會函發相關部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/137.wav", + "text": "俾利各部會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/138.wav", + "text": "核發相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/139.wav", + "text": "包括工作教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/140.wav", + "text": "育及保險的部分以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/141.wav", + "text": "好沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/142.wav", + "text": "嘛這樣可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/143.wav", + "text": "就按照行政院的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/144.wav", + "text": "有關第23條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/145.wav", + "text": "原則上上次已討論通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/146.wav", + "text": "但是其中第9款跟第10款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/147.wav", + "text": "可能還有委員有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/148.wav", + "text": "有關第9款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/149.wav", + "text": "舉例來說主要是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/150.wav", + "text": "國人與外籍配偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/151.wav", + "text": "在海外如果發生結婚生子工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/152.wav", + "text": "這位外籍配偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/153.wav", + "text": "可能因為他的依親對象不存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/154.wav", + "text": "失所附麗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/155.wav", + "text": "導致他無法入境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/156.wav", + "text": "當然子女返臺是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/157.wav", + "text": "但是配偶就無法入境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/158.wav", + "text": "所以他會拿不到簽證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/159.wav", + "text": "我們就在這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/160.wav", + "text": "增加了一個款項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/161.wav", + "text": "遇到這樣的情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/162.wav", + "text": "帶著孩子返臺入境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/163.wav", + "text": "從停留改辦居留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/164.wav", + "text": "拿到合法居留身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/165.wav", + "text": "所以本次本款是新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/166.wav", + "text": "的先前有委員提案說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/167.wav", + "text": "希望把未再婚三個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/168.wav", + "text": "有照顧未成年子女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/169.wav", + "text": "需要的人能夠進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/170.wav", + "text": "如果當事人已經再婚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/171.wav", + "text": "如果他是跟國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/172.wav", + "text": "再婚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/173.wav", + "text": "他可以拿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/174.wav", + "text": "另外一個依親簽證進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/175.wav", + "text": "的但如果這位外籍配偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/176.wav", + "text": "是跟外籍人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/177.wav", + "text": "在國外組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/178.wav", + "text": "這位外籍人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/179.wav", + "text": "如果還要再依親這位外籍配偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/180.wav", + "text": "我們認為可能會產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/181.wav", + "text": "新的衍生性人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/182.wav", + "text": "有限度的開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/183.wav", + "text": "因為目前國內的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/184.wav", + "text": "並沒有開放大依小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/185.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是謹守這個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/186.wav", + "text": "\n第二個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/187.wav", + "text": "第10款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/188.wav", + "text": "與外籍配偶離婚之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/189.wav", + "text": "規定他有未成年子女要照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/190.wav", + "text": "本來就可以一直居留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/191.wav", + "text": "這沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/192.wav", + "text": "但是有人會一時不慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/193.wav", + "text": "忘記延期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/194.wav", + "text": "導致他成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/195.wav", + "text": "逾期居留的人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/196.wav", + "text": "他就必須離境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/197.wav", + "text": "讓他可以申請停留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/198.wav", + "text": "重新入境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/199.wav", + "text": "然後再轉居留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/200.wav", + "text": "是有這樣的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/201.wav", + "text": "所以我們是要協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/202.wav", + "text": "這樣的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/203.wav", + "text": "能夠重新再入臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/204.wav", + "text": "這兩點的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/205.wav", + "text": "希望委員支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/206.wav", + "text": "未再婚部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/207.wav", + "text": "當���很多委員都提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/208.wav", + "text": "提到是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/209.wav", + "text": "把未再婚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/210.wav", + "text": "這個字眼拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/211.wav", + "text": "我們來限外籍配偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/212.wav", + "text": "再婚的這個外國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/213.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以做到這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/214.wav", + "text": "他已經跟外國人結婚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/215.wav", + "text": "還是未成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/216.wav", + "text": "媽媽可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/217.wav", + "text": "還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/218.wav", + "text": "與外籍配偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/219.wav", + "text": "結婚的那個外籍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/220.wav", + "text": "士不讓他入籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/221.wav", + "text": "好我簡單解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/222.wav", + "text": "第9款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/223.wav", + "text": "也是擔心這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/224.wav", + "text": "雖然我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/225.wav", + "text": "內政部是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/226.wav", + "text": "衍生性移民的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/227.wav", + "text": "但是我要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/228.wav", + "text": "我們的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/229.wav", + "text": "不應該以有否再婚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/230.wav", + "text": "來做區別待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/231.wav", + "text": "其他法律是如此訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/232.wav", + "text": "訂定限制人民選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/233.wav", + "text": "是否要再婚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/234.wav", + "text": "是一件奇怪的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/235.wav", + "text": "所以我們的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/236.wav", + "text": "還是要放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/237.wav", + "text": "兼顧兒童最佳利益家庭團聚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/238.wav", + "text": "這樣的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/239.wav", + "text": "\n第10款也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/240.wav", + "text": "同樣的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/241.wav", + "text": "也是要保護兒童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/242.wav", + "text": "最佳利益家庭的團聚權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/243.wav", + "text": "所以除了合法的居留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/244.wav", + "text": "我們是不是也應該納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/245.wav", + "text": "合法停留的態樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/246.wav", + "text": "來達到保護更多家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/247.wav", + "text": "目的以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/248.wav", + "text": "有關衍生性人口的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/249.wav", + "text": "確實是我們主要的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/250.wav", + "text": "如果委員覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/251.wav", + "text": "未再婚要拿掉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/252.wav", + "text": "可能會產生的衍生性人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/253.wav", + "text": "至於停留的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/254.wav", + "text": "我們覺得可能放得太寬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/255.wav", + "text": "基本上我們當時限定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/256.wav", + "text": "合法居留是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/257.wav", + "text": "希望他跟臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/258.wav", + "text": "是有一定連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/259.wav", + "text": "的而且他是曾經在臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/260.wav", + "text": "合法居留的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/261.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/262.wav", + "text": "其實是要解決少數的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/263.wav", + "text": "並沒有要正式地大開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/264.wav", + "text": "因為目前國家的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/265.wav", + "text": "並沒有開放大依小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/266.wav", + "text": "這個原則還是要守住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/267.wav", + "text": "請署長再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/268.wav", + "text": "這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/269.wav", + "text": "當然政府部門有它考慮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/270.wav", + "text": "點尤其這些衍生性人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/271.wav", + "text": "是不是要有一定的連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/272.wav", + "text": "當然我們原來的本意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/273.wav", + "text": "能夠照顧到這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/274.wav", + "text": "配偶死亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/275.wav", + "text": "或者不小心又出境的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/276.wav", + "text": "這些配偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/277.wav", + "text": "現在我也大致瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/278.wav", + "text": "對於未再婚這個字眼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/279.wav", + "text": "可能比較會有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/280.wav", + "text": "為什麼要去干涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/281.wav", + "text": "人家要不要再婚的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/282.wav", + "text": "但是如果把這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/283.wav", + "text": "拿掉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/284.wav", + "text": "我們也擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/285.wav", + "text": "他在國外的再婚對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/286.wav", + "text": "他可以再依親" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/287.wav", + "text": "的話等於是依附的這個配偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/288.wav", + "text": "一樣可以到臺灣來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/289.wav", + "text": "我們把這個未再婚拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/290.wav", + "text": "但我們希望再回到第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/291.wav", + "text": "第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/292.wav", + "text": "我們在但書的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/293.wav", + "text": "但經核准居留的配偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/294.wav", + "text": "是依照第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/295.wav", + "text": "或第10款的規定許可的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/296.wav", + "text": "就限定他不得再申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/297.wav", + "text": "換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/298.wav", + "text": "我想我們就可以解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/299.wav", + "text": "這是一個解決的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/300.wav", + "text": "在但書裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/301.wav", + "text": "好因為各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/302.wav", + "text": "比較在意的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/303.wav", + "text": "你放那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/304.wav", + "text": "樣問題也可以解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/305.wav", + "text": "再修正的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/306.wav", + "text": "請各位委員看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/307.wav", + "text": "第23條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/308.wav", + "text": "持停留期限在六十日以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/309.wav", + "text": "且未經簽證核發機關加註限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/310.wav", + "text": "不准延期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/311.wav", + "text": "或其他限制之有效簽證入國之外國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/312.wav", + "text": "有下列情況之一者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/313.wav", + "text": "得向移民署申請居留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/314.wav", + "text": "經許可者核發外僑居留證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/315.wav", + "text": "一配偶為現在在臺灣地區居住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/316.wav", + "text": "且設有戶籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/317.wav", + "text": "或獲准居留之我國國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/318.wav", + "text": "或經核准居留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/319.wav", + "text": "或永久居留之外國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/320.wav", + "text": "或經核准居留之香港或澳門居民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/321.wav", + "text": "但該經核准居留之配偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/322.wav", + "text": "係依第9款或第10款規定經許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/323.wav", + "text": "或經中央勞動主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/324.wav", + "text": "這些都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/325.wav", + "text": "大家再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/326.wav", + "text": "這裡規定依第9款或第10款規定經許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/327.wav", + "text": "應該可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/328.wav", + "text": "就按照內政部建議的修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/329.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/330.wav", + "text": "政院原本的版本在第1項但書的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/331.wav", + "text": "事實上是有一點放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/332.wav", + "text": "就是外來人口在臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/333.wav", + "text": "他參加請願跟合法集會遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/334.wav", + "text": "限當然在這幾次的審查會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/335.wav", + "text": "委員有一些建議就是對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/336.wav", + "text": "也予以保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/337.wav", + "text": "但是我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/338.wav", + "text": "特別是在疫情之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/339.wav", + "text": "事實上疫情對我國的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/340.wav", + "text": "真的是滿大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/341.wav", + "text": "現階段不管在國際秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/342.wav", + "text": "或是兩岸關係方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/343.wav", + "text": "都起了很大的變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/344.wav", + "text": "對我們國家安全的挑戰影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/345.wav", + "text": "也越來越大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/346.wav", + "text": "考量到大陸地區人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/347.wav", + "text": "來臺灣參加集會遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/348.wav", + "text": "並製造事端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/349.wav", + "text": "但書回歸到修正前原本的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/350.wav", + "text": "規定就是只有限於合法居留者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/351.wav", + "text": "請願跟合法集會遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/352.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/353.wav", + "text": "請各位委員看第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/354.wav", + "text": "其他部分就是照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/355.wav", + "text": "是照行政院的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/356.wav", + "text": "如果各位委員沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/357.wav", + "text": "那我們就按照內政部建議的條文通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/358.wav", + "text": "如果不是合法居留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/359.wav", + "text": "他可能是停留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/360.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/361.wav", + "text": "他是以合法身分進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/362.wav", + "text": "但是他也不是在非法的處境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/363.wav", + "text": "不是非法的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/364.wav", + "text": "而是有合法的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/365.wav", + "text": "他就有相關的集會遊行權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/366.wav", + "text": "不見得只是居留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/367.wav", + "text": "其實我剛剛有就這個部分做過說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/368.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/369.wav", + "text": "因為合法居留者跟臺灣的連結度是比較高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/370.wav", + "text": "至於停留者的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/371.wav", + "text": "對停留者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/372.wav", + "text": "特別是我們臺灣的國情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/373.wav", + "text": "真的是比較特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/374.wav", + "text": "在疫情之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/375.wav", + "text": "我們可以看得到現在整個國際秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/376.wav", + "text": "事實上也是怕大陸地區人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/377.wav", + "text": "但是他也可能用外國的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/378.wav", + "text": "用停留的身分進來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/379.wav", + "text": "參加我們的集會遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/380.wav", + "text": "這個部分都是我們不願意見到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/381.wav", + "text": "臺灣是一艘航空母艦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/382.wav", + "text": "但是在航空母艦裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/383.wav", + "text": "我們不允許有任何一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/384.wav", + "text": "整個行政部門在考量這一點的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/385.wav", + "text": "我們確實是有比較謹慎地去考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/386.wav", + "text": "當然這個部分還是麻煩委員支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/387.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/388.wav", + "text": "時力黨團的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/389.wav", + "text": "對集會遊行權益予以保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/390.wav", + "text": "保障外國人在我國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/391.wav", + "text": "有證停留或無證停留的居留期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/392.wav", + "text": "都可以有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/393.wav", + "text": "請願或合法集會遊行的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/394.wav", + "text": "譬如說失聯移工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/395.wav", + "text": "欲參與移工倡議團體的請願遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/396.wav", + "text": "那抗議者本身因移工政策而落入失聯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/397.wav", + "text": "他們沒有光明正大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/398.wav", + "text": "轉換雇主及工作情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/399.wav", + "text": "像這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/400.wav", + "text": "我們也希望能夠為他們爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/401.wav", + "text": "有可以參加遊行的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/402.wav", + "text": "再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/403.wav", + "text": "委員所提到的公政公約裡面的相關規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/404.wav", + "text": "理一般性意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/405.wav", + "text": "力只是作為法院和其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/406.wav", + "text": "第21條後段的但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/407.wav", + "text": "還有包括國際人權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/408.wav", + "text": "公約第十一條第二項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/409.wav", + "text": "可以來限制集會遊行的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/410.wav", + "text": "周邊的一些民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/411.wav", + "text": "這兩個國家跟我們的國情相近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/412.wav", + "text": "參加相關的請願和集會遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/413.wav", + "text": "國情真的是比較特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/414.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/415.wav", + "text": "行政部門的說明其實也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/416.wav", + "text": "等等做說明其實我們在修這部法令的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/417.wav", + "text": "要去參考其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/418.wav", + "text": "也感謝在場委員的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/419.wav", + "text": "這一條就按照內政部的建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/420.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/421.wav", + "text": "本次行政院院版未修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/422.wav", + "text": "主要是由鄭天財委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/423.wav", + "text": "以及陳委員以信等人提出修正版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/424.wav", + "text": "他們首先希望因前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/425.wav", + "text": "歧視致權利受不法侵害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/426.wav", + "text": "當中致權利受不法侵害等文字予以刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/427.wav", + "text": "然後再新增第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/428.wav", + "text": "主管機關知有第1項之公然歧視行為者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/429.wav", + "text": "應主動依職權調查之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/430.wav", + "text": "以下我就針對這兩個點做回應說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/431.wav", + "text": "首先是針對致權利受不法侵害要予以刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/432.wav", + "text": "的部分我們認為目前現行的第62條在執行上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/433.wav", + "text": "是由內政部組成申訴的審議小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/434.wav", + "text": "小組裡面有機關專家學者律師等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/435.wav", + "text": "針對歧視案件進行審認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/436.wav", + "text": "歧視行為的構成要件必須佐以證據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/437.wav", + "text": "也就是說有人格權受不法侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/438.wav", + "text": "或是相關的權益受不法侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/439.wav", + "text": "我們才有辦法去審斷案件能否成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/440.wav", + "text": "也就是說當事人必須要權利受不法侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/441.wav", + "text": "這樣處罰歧視行為也才有它的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/442.wav", + "text": "所以我們要先舉證歧視行為存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/443.wav", + "text": "然後再由審議委員來審斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/444.wav", + "text": "這個申訴人的權利是否受不法侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/445.wav", + "text": "所以如果把致權利受不法侵害這個必要構成要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/446.wav", + "text": "我們就失去一個判斷的準據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/447.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議不要刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/448.wav", + "text": "\n第二個是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/449.wav", + "text": "是否要增加一個依職權調查的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/450.wav", + "text": "其實它是一個不確定的法律概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/451.wav", + "text": "所以定義上恐怕過於寬泛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/452.wav", + "text": "也會引發寒蟬效應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/453.wav", + "text": "可能國人就不敢自由表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/454.wav", + "text": "我們可以看在刑法上有公然侮辱罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/455.wav", + "text": "但是它是告訴乃論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/456.wav", + "text": "論民事上如果要主張他受辱的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/457.wav", + "text": "他也必須要證明他的人格權受侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/458.wav", + "text": "才能請求損害賠償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/459.wav", + "text": "也都是屬於被動受理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/460.wav", + "text": "其實是一個主觀感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/461.wav", + "text": "如果我們只是以媒體披露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/462.wav", + "text": "或者是任意第三人舉發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/463.wav", + "text": "就認定這個叫做公然歧視行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/464.wav", + "text": "要行政部門依職權主動調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/465.wav", + "text": "這個可能會產生手段跟目的間欠缺合理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/466.wav", + "text": "恐有過度干預言論自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/467.wav", + "text": "有違比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/468.wav", + "text": "\n再來就是實務上調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/469.wav", + "text": "時機上也很敏感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/470.wav", + "text": "到底要何時調查如何發動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/471.wav", + "text": "如果兩造候選人對於有質疑性的言論彼此攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/472.wav", + "text": "可能行政部門就會流於政爭的工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/473.wav", + "text": "事實上行政院最近因為臺中一中的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/474.wav", + "text": "行政院要訂定一個綜合性的平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/475.wav", + "text": "它也列入了國家人權行動計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/476.wav", + "text": "所以明年就會提一個綜合性的平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/477.wav", + "text": "現行的各歧視法規其實散見在各法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/478.wav", + "text": "包括性平教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/479.wav", + "text": "就業服務法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/480.wav", + "text": "還有身心障礙法等等都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/481.wav", + "text": "所以近期也要開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/482.wav", + "text": "我們希望可以在行政院的平等法有一個綜合性立法之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/483.wav", + "text": "其他各機關的各作用法再跟著進行修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/484.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/485.wav", + "text": "這個是很詳實很扎實的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/486.wav", + "text": "而我們原住民族的立委已經爭取了7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/487.wav", + "text": "7年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/488.wav", + "text": "第一個這個法律名稱就不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/489.wav", + "text": "難道臺灣的族群不平等嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/490.wav", + "text": "沒有不平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/491.wav", + "text": "只有偶爾會產生歧視的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/492.wav", + "text": "所以這個法律名稱就不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/493.wav", + "text": "那個法通過之後這個就刪除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/494.wav", + "text": "就不用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/495.wav", + "text": "而不是說再修正就刪除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/496.wav", + "text": "提到因前項歧視致權利受不法侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/497.wav", + "text": "所以到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/498.wav", + "text": "沒有一件被罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/499.wav", + "text": "何況刪除了致權利受不法侵害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/500.wav", + "text": "還是主管機關來審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/501.wav", + "text": "權限還是在你們那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/502.wav", + "text": "所以這個有什麼好擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/503.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的那些都不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/504.wav", + "text": "我們就講就業服務法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/505.wav", + "text": "雇主對求職的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/506.wav", + "text": "或者是雇主對所僱用的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/507.wav", + "text": "不得以種族階級語言思想宗教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/508.wav", + "text": "為由予以歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/509.wav", + "text": "就只有講歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/510.wav", + "text": "就是不能以這個理由歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/511.wav", + "text": "它也沒有說致權利受不法侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/512.wav", + "text": "沒有這句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/513.wav", + "text": "就業服務法沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/514.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/515.wav", + "text": "就業服務法的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/516.wav", + "text": "30萬以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/517.wav", + "text": "到150萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/518.wav", + "text": "入出國移民法的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/519.wav", + "text": "只有五千元以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/520.wav", + "text": "所以是完全掌握在你們主管機關的手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/521.wav", + "text": "連這個都不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/522.wav", + "text": "非常大的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/523.wav", + "text": "為什麼要堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/524.wav", + "text": "又不是第一次在中華民國的法律出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/525.wav", + "text": "原來就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/526.wav", + "text": "啦就業服務法就有了就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/527.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/528.wav", + "text": "這個大部分會用在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/529.wav", + "text": "從國外來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/530.wav", + "text": "勞工身上而我們現在正缺工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/531.wav", + "text": "最需要勞工的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/532.wav", + "text": "基本上入出國移民法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/533.wav", + "text": "從國外來的這些勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/534.wav", + "text": "所以怎麼會那麼堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/535.wav", + "text": "呢我當公務員30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/536.wav", + "text": "當立法委員也有十幾年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/537.wav", + "text": "又不是沒有別的法律可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/538.wav", + "text": "就業服務法就沒有致權益受不法侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/539.wav", + "text": "者沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/540.wav", + "text": "啊你講的那些都等於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/541.wav", + "text": "沒有意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/542.wav", + "text": "為什麼其他的法律不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/543.wav", + "text": "就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/544.wav", + "text": "何況還是給主管機關自己做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/545.wav", + "text": "尤其申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/546.wav", + "text": "是由主管機關決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/547.wav", + "text": "權限那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/548.wav", + "text": "所以我拜託我們所有的立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/549.wav", + "text": "我談這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/550.wav", + "text": "已經很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/551.wav", + "text": "談我也質詢過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/552.wav", + "text": "很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/553.wav", + "text": "能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/554.wav", + "text": "致權益受不法侵害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/555.wav", + "text": "這幾個字刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/556.wav", + "text": "我想時力可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/557.wav", + "text": "鄭天財委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/558.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/559.wav", + "text": "請行政部門再說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/560.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/561.wav", + "text": "我想再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/562.wav", + "text": "現行我們在處理申訴小組時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/563.wav", + "text": "確實從98年到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/564.wav", + "text": "共有29案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/565.wav", + "text": "有1案撤銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/566.wav", + "text": "5案不受理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/567.wav", + "text": "23案不成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/568.wav", + "text": "之案子透過我們的分析主要是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/569.wav", + "text": "也就是沒有辦法證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/570.wav", + "text": "相關歧視行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/571.wav", + "text": "事實存在的大概有6件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/572.wav", + "text": "無法說明有何種權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/573.wav", + "text": "受到不法侵害的其實只有5件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/574.wav", + "text": "大部分是非屬歧視範疇的有8件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/575.wav", + "text": "譬如說一般民眾的消費糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/576.wav", + "text": "相互謾罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/577.wav", + "text": "也有人就業金卡沒有被獲准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/578.wav", + "text": "也說是歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/579.wav", + "text": "或者是銀行開戶被拒絕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/580.wav", + "text": "以及學校沒有辦客語教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/581.wav", + "text": "等投訴的標的主要是這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/582.wav", + "text": "所以其不成立的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/583.wav", + "text": "不全然都是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/584.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法舉證權利受不法侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/585.wav", + "text": "再退一步而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/586.wav", + "text": "剛才委員有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/587.wav", + "text": "就服法為什麼能夠操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/588.wav", + "text": "因為基本上就服法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/589.wav", + "text": "中的權益受不法侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/590.wav", + "text": "是在於其就業權益受損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/591.wav", + "text": "通常會來申訴的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/592.wav", + "text": "他可能應聘未獲聘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/593.wav", + "text": "\n但是我們的條文沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/594.wav", + "text": "我們沒有就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/595.wav", + "text": "也沒有性平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/596.wav", + "text": "致權益受不法侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/597.wav", + "text": "那請問要罵一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/598.wav", + "text": "罵兩句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/599.wav", + "text": "還是罵十句才開罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/600.wav", + "text": "是沒有辦法定義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/601.wav", + "text": "它是一個抽象的模糊空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/602.wav", + "text": "如果有歧視言論就罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/603.wav", + "text": "那移民署會不會成為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/604.wav", + "text": "一個言論審查的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/605.wav", + "text": "我們對於民眾的言論自由權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/606.wav", + "text": "會不會有一定程度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/607.wav", + "text": "干涉跟影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/608.wav", + "text": "是不是可以再審慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/609.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/610.wav", + "text": "��那句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/611.wav", + "text": "我還不願意講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/612.wav", + "text": "這種歧視的言語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/613.wav", + "text": "是言論自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/614.wav", + "text": "你現在又講第二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/615.wav", + "text": "我前面已經讓了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/616.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/617.wav", + "text": "有深深的感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/618.wav", + "text": "這是言論自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/619.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/620.wav", + "text": "他不是那個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/621.wav", + "text": "講兩次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/622.wav", + "text": "我很仔細在聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/623.wav", + "text": "我懂你的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/624.wav", + "text": "你說要罰多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/625.wav", + "text": "到底要不要罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/626.wav", + "text": "真的全部掌握在你們手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/627.wav", + "text": "我也沒有要去改這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/628.wav", + "text": "我只不過希望致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/629.wav", + "text": "致權利受不法之侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/630.wav", + "text": "這只有幾千塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/631.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/632.wav", + "text": "真的很難舉證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/633.wav", + "text": "誰一天到晚拿著錄音筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/634.wav", + "text": "錄音機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/635.wav", + "text": "啊真的很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/636.wav", + "text": "這有一個麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/637.wav", + "text": "所以就不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/638.wav", + "text": "了不要讓自己困在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/639.wav", + "text": "讓中華民國政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/640.wav", + "text": "還要舉證這個權利受不法之侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/641.wav", + "text": "確實在法律上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/642.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/643.wav", + "text": "涉及到感受問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/644.wav", + "text": "我懂你的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/645.wav", + "text": "我們腦袋瓜裝的不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/646.wav", + "text": "但是我可以接受你的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/647.wav", + "text": "但就是每一個人裝的不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/648.wav", + "text": "看法會有不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/649.wav", + "text": "但是我們的法系又和他們的不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/650.wav", + "text": "所以你在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/651.wav", + "text": "我反而和你看法不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/652.wav", + "text": "我會擔心他們的權力過大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/653.wav", + "text": "這個幾乎是我們在民法上講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/654.wav", + "text": "的或是憲法上講的人格權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/655.wav", + "text": "說沒有權利遭受損害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/656.wav", + "text": "那是不是只要感覺不舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/657.wav", + "text": "這樣我還確實擔心行政部門的權力過大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/658.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/659.wav", + "text": "除非中華民國的歧視這兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/660.wav", + "text": "抽象啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/661.wav", + "text": "沒有啦天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/662.wav", + "text": "歧視這一個辭是非常非常模糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/663.wav", + "text": "除非是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/664.wav", + "text": "歧視真的有層次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/665.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/666.wav", + "text": "那個不應該在這邊規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/667.wav", + "text": "入出國及移民法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/668.wav", + "text": "來解決什麼叫做歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/669.wav", + "text": "或者政府部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/670.wav", + "text": "我知道啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/671.wav", + "text": "喊8年我們不是要求他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/672.wav", + "text": "應該不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/673.wav", + "text": "耶這個案我就是要讓它過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/674.wav", + "text": "我很負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/675.wav", + "text": "要來達成大家最大的公約數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/676.wav", + "text": "好啦這個就表決啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/677.wav", + "text": "送去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/678.wav", + "text": "院會留一條表決沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/679.wav", + "text": "一條不要啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/680.wav", + "text": "這整個案都是你的業績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/681.wav", + "text": "啊要給你做業績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/682.wav", + "text": "賺100分你不賺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/683.wav", + "text": "你實在是這一條你休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/684.wav", + "text": "這一條我處理\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/685.wav", + "text": "我們這一條就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/686.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/687.wav", + "text": "對移民署來講是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/688.wav", + "text": "比較高的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/689.wav", + "text": "如果一個法令的構成要件裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/690.wav", + "text": "把它拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/691.wav", + "text": "都不用有造成任何損害的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/692.wav", + "text": "我記得我們從唸法律到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/693.wav", + "text": "個訴訟標的都是問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/694.wav", + "text": "你講不舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/695.wav", + "text": "不舒服要怎麼累積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/696.wav", + "text": "至於底限法律有彈性有最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/697.wav", + "text": "所以這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/698.wav", + "text": "慢慢講沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/699.wav", + "text": "這一條就不予修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/700.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/701.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/702.wav", + "text": "行政部門有提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/703.wav", + "text": "再修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/704.wav", + "text": "因為前面幾次討論的癥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/705.wav", + "text": "主要是在第2項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/706.wav", + "text": "我們政院原來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/707.wav", + "text": "針對逾期停留或居留的外來人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/708.wav", + "text": "是處罰新台幣3萬到15萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/709.wav", + "text": "幾次的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/710.wav", + "text": "好像委員們都認為這個可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/711.wav", + "text": "會太影響新住民的權益所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/712.wav", + "text": "政院有提出相對應的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/713.wav", + "text": "鍰部分降到1萬到5萬元以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/714.wav", + "text": "基本上大部分的委員都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/715.wav", + "text": "支持這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/716.wav", + "text": "的主要原因是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/717.wav", + "text": "有牽涉到第29條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/718.wav", + "text": "因為第29條本來是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/719.wav", + "text": "所以這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/720.wav", + "text": "當時也同時保留以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/721.wav", + "text": "好謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/722.wav", + "text": "針對這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/723.wav", + "text": "聯移工已經高達8萬3,000人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/724.wav", + "text": "大幅提高罰鍰的這種作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/725.wav", + "text": "不希望這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/726.wav", + "text": "版有參照召委的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/727.wav", + "text": "降到1至5萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/728.wav", + "text": "算是勉強接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/729.wav", + "text": "加註因此這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/730.wav", + "text": "我們其實都儘量折衷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/731.wav", + "text": "把大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/732.wav", + "text": "可以更順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/733.wav", + "text": "保留的條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/734.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/735.wav", + "text": "有關第85條主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/736.wav", + "text": "已經移到第74條之1第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/737.wav", + "text": "這一條在上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/738.wav", + "text": "4月17日第三次的審查會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/739.wav", + "text": "主要是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/740.wav", + "text": "牽涉到第22條的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/741.wav", + "text": "針對第85條在場委員有沒有其他不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/742.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/743.wav", + "text": "第85條就按照行政院的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/744.wav", + "text": "再修正第十五條的再修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/745.wav", + "text": "外國人的部分而外國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/746.wav", + "text": "外國人的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/747.wav", + "text": "我們在第三十六條增列第五項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/748.wav", + "text": "可能就變成要準用第三十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/749.wav", + "text": "本來只有第三項跟第四項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/750.wav", + "text": "調整為第三項至第五項以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/751.wav", + "text": "沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/752.wav", + "text": "第十五條按照再修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/753.wav", + "text": "本來是1至10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/754.wav", + "text": "我們已經調整到1至7年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/755.wav", + "text": "所以配合修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/756.wav", + "text": "我們就按照內政部的再修正文字通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/757.wav", + "text": "本條文第十二項的內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/758.wav", + "text": "要修正為主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/759.wav", + "text": "第二十三條那時候已經經過委員會修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/760.wav", + "text": "所以併予修正本條第十一項相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/761.wav", + "text": "條有兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/762.wav", + "text": "居留原因不符之活動或工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/763.wav", + "text": "現在或工作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/764.wav", + "text": "任何人不得使外國人從事前項本文之活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/765.wav", + "text": "這是第一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/766.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分是針對第5項有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/767.wav", + "text": "上次第三次審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/768.wav", + "text": "針對排除律師在場權的但書部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/769.wav", + "text": "本來是分為兩個區塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/770.wav", + "text": "第一個區塊是有危害國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/771.wav", + "text": "另外一個區塊是有危害社會秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/772.wav", + "text": "認為危害社會秩序部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/773.wav", + "text": "可能範圍太過於廣泛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/774.wav", + "text": "為了確保當事人聘請律師在場的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/775.wav", + "text": "再酌予修正修正為但其在場有危害國家安全之虞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/776.wav", + "text": "原本或社會秩序文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/777.wav", + "text": "好是不是就照內政部再修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/778.wav", + "text": "其實第36條和第65條的這個部分是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/779.wav", + "text": "但很不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/780.wav", + "text": "只提到第65" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/781.wav", + "text": "條所以我還是再講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/782.wav", + "text": "第36條第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/783.wav", + "text": "以及第65條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/784.wav", + "text": "針對剛才提到的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/785.wav", + "text": "但其在場有危害國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/786.wav", + "text": "或社會秩序之虞這段文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/787.wav", + "text": "其實那個時候我也有參" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/788.wav", + "text": "但審完之後回去想想不對勁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/789.wav", + "text": "當時跟內政部討論的內容是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/790.wav", + "text": "過於廣泛和模糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/791.wav", + "text": "結果可能造成實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/792.wav", + "text": "出現很多沒有危害國家的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/793.wav", + "text": "卻沒有辦法委任律師的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/794.wav", + "text": "和程序利益受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/795.wav", + "text": "對社會秩序認定上的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/796.wav", + "text": "所以我認為除了顧及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/797.wav", + "text": "國家安全的限制外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/798.wav", + "text": "在查驗許可入境後接受面談的申請人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/799.wav", + "text": "他們得委任律師在場的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/800.wav", + "text": "署看起來移民署是有參考這個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/801.wav", + "text": "或社會秩序這段文字刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/802.wav", + "text": "但其在場有危害國家安全之虞等文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/803.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/804.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/805.wav", + "text": "對是一起的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/806.wav", + "text": "部分我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/807.wav", + "text": "署先看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/808.wav", + "text": "嗎\n好審查會保留的那兩個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/809.wav", + "text": "我們就不予採納\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/810.wav", + "text": "現在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/811.wav", + "text": "你們有看過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/812.wav", + "text": "好增列的兩個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/813.wav", + "text": "就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15017/814.wav", + "text": "大家辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15015/0.wav", + "text": "二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15015/1.wav", + "text": "一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15015/2.wav", + "text": "二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15015/3.wav", + "text": "有意見若是柯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15015/4.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15015/5.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15015/6.wav", + "text": "的建議條文原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15015/7.wav", + "text": "日的委員會中時力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/0.wav", + "text": "會議現在進行併案協商洗錢防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/1.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/2.wav", + "text": "審查會於112年4月27日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/3.wav", + "text": "將行政院提案等3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/4.wav", + "text": "併案審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/5.wav", + "text": "審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/6.wav", + "text": "增訂第十五條之1及第十五條之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/7.wav", + "text": "提案之關係文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/8.wav", + "text": "與會委員如有修正動議或機關有建議內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/9.wav", + "text": "請提書面印發現場進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/10.wav", + "text": "\n處理增訂第6條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/11.wav", + "text": "\n提案黨團是否要先說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/12.wav", + "text": "還是要請機關代表先回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/13.wav", + "text": "還是各位沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/14.wav", + "text": "對時代力量黨團提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/15.wav", + "text": "請黃次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/16.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團所提案的第6條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/17.wav", + "text": "與DNFBP的相關義務規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/18.wav", + "text": "或DNFBP的相關規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/19.wav", + "text": "而且各金融機關與DNFBP大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/20.wav", + "text": "概已經各有自己的KYC或CDD等相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/21.wav", + "text": "內稽或內控規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/22.wav", + "text": "所以事實上沒有必要在洗錢法制法裡重複規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/23.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/24.wav", + "text": "\n第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/25.wav", + "text": "不確定的法律概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/26.wav", + "text": "譬如說應付出合理努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/27.wav", + "text": "計畫而產生風險於公眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/28.wav", + "text": "這些都是不確定的法律概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/29.wav", + "text": "卻會連動到後面的裁罰規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/30.wav", + "text": "以及DNFBP會產生一定的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/31.wav", + "text": "要件不明確的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/32.wav", + "text": "\n各位委員有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/33.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/34.wav", + "text": "1\n請曾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/35.wav", + "text": "上一次討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/36.wav", + "text": "不曉得現在法務部意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/37.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/38.wav", + "text": "基於整個法規範的比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/39.wav", + "text": "等各方面考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/40.wav", + "text": "我們有個建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/41.wav", + "text": "不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/42.wav", + "text": "慢慢來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/43.wav", + "text": "1,000萬元我不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/44.wav", + "text": "而且全部都不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/45.wav", + "text": "你看以下這些都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/46.wav", + "text": "冒用政府機關或公務員名義犯之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/47.wav", + "text": "以電視廣播電子通訊網際網路或其他媒體等傳播工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/48.wav", + "text": "對公眾散布而犯之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/49.wav", + "text": "以電腦合成或其他科技方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/50.wav", + "text": "製作關於他人不實影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/51.wav", + "text": "聲音或電磁紀錄之方法犯之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/52.wav", + "text": "假設沒有提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/53.wav", + "text": "罰金那我整個案子都不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/54.wav", + "text": "對於這件事你要聽聽民眾的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/55.wav", + "text": "元啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/56.wav", + "text": "外界不接受我也不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/57.wav", + "text": "我不協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/58.wav", + "text": "那就解散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/59.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/60.wav", + "text": "\n假如不接受我就不協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/61.wav", + "text": "到院長那邊去並向全民轉播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/62.wav", + "text": "曾總召的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/63.wav", + "text": "只不過對於提高金額曾總召可能還沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/64.wav", + "text": "現在已經因為曾總召的指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/65.wav", + "text": "建議啦經過曾總召建議表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/66.wav", + "text": "最後提高到1,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/67.wav", + "text": "元所以法務部是有提高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/68.wav", + "text": "第十五條之1就是本黨提案的第十四條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/69.wav", + "text": "行政院版本是採用條列方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/70.wav", + "text": "上次好像提到要把第二款刪除也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/71.wav", + "text": "就是三人共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/72.wav", + "text": "犯之這一點我想確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/73.wav", + "text": "im.B這個類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/74.wav", + "text": "術影響人數上千人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/75.wav", + "text": "到警局備案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/76.wav", + "text": "特別是檢察機關的受理情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/77.wav", + "text": "以及第一時間怎麼樣預防這些嫌犯脫產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/78.wav", + "text": "的第一件事第二是有沒有可能成立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/79.wav", + "text": "類似165的聯防機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/80.wav", + "text": "就可以視案件規模組成專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/81.wav", + "text": "修法也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/82.wav", + "text": "是否可以聯合性地對金融防詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/83.wav", + "text": "就是讓嫌犯不敢輕易觸法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/84.wav", + "text": "元我想國人都不會接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/85.wav", + "text": "所以若提高到一個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/86.wav", + "text": "警政法務與金融單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/87.wav", + "text": "共同打擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/88.wav", + "text": "這部分是要一併處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/89.wav", + "text": "賴委員提到的第2款已經拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/90.wav", + "text": "元就看各位的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/91.wav", + "text": "當時法務部是贊成提高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/92.wav", + "text": "是否柯總召不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/93.wav", + "text": "那請柯總召來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/94.wav", + "text": "柯總召有意見就請他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/95.wav", + "text": "不然就到院長那邊協商好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/96.wav", + "text": "\n是不是柯總召有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/97.wav", + "text": "請柯總召來吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/98.wav", + "text": "我也支持柯總召要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/99.wav", + "text": "最後到了院那邊又全部被翻案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/100.wav", + "text": "我昨天真的快要氣炸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/101.wav", + "text": "我也在這裡表達抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/102.wav", + "text": "不然協商完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/103.wav", + "text": "曾總召你要針對他那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/104.wav", + "text": "是你跟他的事但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/105.wav", + "text": "我們要就事論事嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/106.wav", + "text": "法務部不是沒有應你的要求提高罰金而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/107.wav", + "text": "是提高的金額不合你的意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/108.wav", + "text": "應該這樣講才對嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/109.wav", + "text": "召委不是要合我的意而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/110.wav", + "text": "全民的意啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/111.wav", + "text": "你卻指稱沒提高這就沒道理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/112.wav", + "text": "那就請柯總召來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/113.wav", + "text": "這個要求合理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/114.wav", + "text": "叫他來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/115.wav", + "text": "就邀請他來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/116.wav", + "text": "會來對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/117.wav", + "text": "\n處理增訂第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/118.wav", + "text": "有委員江永昌等所提修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/119.wav", + "text": "有協商的建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/120.wav", + "text": "在4月27日的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/121.wav", + "text": "中時力黨團原本爭取到第十五條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/122.wav", + "text": "增訂告誡後個案轉介的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/123.wav", + "text": "時力黨團的立場並沒有改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/124.wav", + "text": "也就是為了處理日益增加的人頭帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/125.wav", + "text": "除了增訂人頭帳戶罪之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/126.wav", + "text": "面對一開始讓人頭帳戶增加的社會經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/127.wav", + "text": "還有結構等因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/128.wav", + "text": "所以不能只靠告誡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/129.wav", + "text": "不能當人頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/130.wav", + "text": "遠離各種犯罪情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/131.wav", + "text": "等其他樣態要打破這樣的惡性循環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/132.wav", + "text": "需要更多行動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/133.wav", + "text": "把低收入戶文字入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/134.wav", + "text": "因為確實有衛福部擔憂的福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/135.wav", + "text": "污名化問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/136.wav", + "text": "可能也會讓這個群體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/137.wav", + "text": "與洗錢犯罪不當地連結在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/138.wav", + "text": "這其實也並非時力黨團的原意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/139.wav", + "text": "廣義的經濟上不利處境者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/140.wav", + "text": "包括因為所得分配不均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/141.wav", + "text": "因為實質薪資降低等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/142.wav", + "text": "社會結構因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/143.wav", + "text": "而更難堅持採取法律期待行為的這群人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/144.wav", + "text": "例如所謂工作貧窮等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/145.wav", + "text": "因為不正交付帳戶罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/146.wav", + "text": "可能處罰的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/147.wav", + "text": "有很大機率就是這一群人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/148.wav", + "text": "我們希望國家做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/149.wav", + "text": "也不限於既有社會救助法的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/150.wav", + "text": "受到告誡之觸法者的經濟困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/151.wav", + "text": "在他們因為同樣經濟理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/152.wav", + "text": "再次違法前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/153.wav", + "text": "從復權角度建立機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/154.wav", + "text": "盡可能從經濟或生活必需品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/155.wav", + "text": "安置就業教育訓練投資等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/156.wav", + "text": "各方面介入支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/157.wav", + "text": "協助他們穩定經濟生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/158.wav", + "text": "遠離犯罪情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/159.wav", + "text": "在現行體制下能採取的措施有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/160.wav", + "text": "也牽涉到社會救助法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/161.wav", + "text": "以及國家整體社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/162.wav", + "text": "勞動政策本身的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/163.wav", + "text": "但我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/164.wav", + "text": "至少要將這樣的理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/165.wav", + "text": "這樣的政策方向入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/166.wav", + "text": "不然只能眼睜睜地看著一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/167.wav", + "text": "滑落社會安全網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/168.wav", + "text": "也造成更大的社會成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/169.wav", + "text": "\n在能夠預防的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/170.wav", + "text": "預防於經濟上倫理上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/171.wav", + "text": "都是更合理的選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/172.wav", + "text": "所以時力黨團建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/173.wav", + "text": "第十五條之2還是先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/174.wav", + "text": "誠摯希望相關部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/175.wav", + "text": "我們不會要求一步到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/176.wav", + "text": "但是我們應該更積極地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/177.wav", + "text": "以上是時力黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/178.wav", + "text": "通報機制與社會救助機制的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/179.wav", + "text": "還有衛福部等相關機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/180.wav", + "text": "已經有機制處理所以對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/181.wav", + "text": "這項處分特別在洗錢防制法中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/182.wav", + "text": "至於詳細理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/183.wav", + "text": "衛福部有來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/184.wav", + "text": "沒有嘛衛福部沒有來喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/185.wav", + "text": "他們表示的意見就是我剛才向各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/186.wav", + "text": "沒有必要為了告誡這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/187.wav", + "text": "特別在洗錢法制法裡加以規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/188.wav", + "text": "我也希望法務部把這個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/189.wav", + "text": "帶回給相關部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/190.wav", + "text": "\n請賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/191.wav", + "text": "在等待柯總召的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/192.wav", + "text": "��問題畢竟這種對象當然也不希望再犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/193.wav", + "text": "是大家可以討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/194.wav", + "text": "但是針對現行做法除了保護權益之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/195.wav", + "text": "在現有犯罪的偵查程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/196.wav", + "text": "中他們也很想知道怎麼樣保護自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/197.wav", + "text": "當然也可以選擇向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/198.wav", + "text": "由於檢察官已針對這起個案成立專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/199.wav", + "text": "所以檢察官會指揮相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/200.wav", + "text": "全力偵查這起個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/201.wav", + "text": "然檢察官手上就有了被害人的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/202.wav", + "text": "所以無論是到司法警察機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/203.wav", + "text": "或到檢察機關提起告訴告發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/204.wav", + "text": "最後都會回到專責檢察官手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/205.wav", + "text": "我就第一部分這樣向委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/206.wav", + "text": "\n第二部分是如何避免脫產針對這起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/207.wav", + "text": "包括主謀已有5人被羈押" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/208.wav", + "text": "在內檢察官都已查扣所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/209.wav", + "text": "如果有其他犯罪所得只要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/210.wav", + "text": "可以扣押的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/211.wav", + "text": "產如果被害人發現自己的財產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/212.wav", + "text": "也可以向檢察官說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/213.wav", + "text": "檢察官會馬上第一時間查扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/214.wav", + "text": "還有一個建議就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/215.wav", + "text": "就是檢調能不能建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/216.wav", + "text": "他們希望有個網頁可以直接登打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/217.wav", + "text": "到時候你們可以就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/218.wav", + "text": "就查扣公司資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/219.wav", + "text": "這部分可不可以研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/220.wav", + "text": "但還要一一打電話提醒這些受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/221.wav", + "text": "登記所以是否可以建立登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/222.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/223.wav", + "text": "研議看看好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/224.wav", + "text": "這要再研議看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/225.wav", + "text": "偵查中案件如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/226.wav", + "text": "由於那些資料都是被害犯罪情節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/227.wav", + "text": "擔心有資訊外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/228.wav", + "text": "可能會有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/229.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/230.wav", + "text": "你們研議看看好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/231.wav", + "text": "也在第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/232.wav", + "text": "指出已下令全國各地檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/233.wav", + "text": "如果受理這起個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/234.wav", + "text": "都要集中到北檢做專案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/235.wav", + "text": "其實臺高檢在第一時間發布的新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/236.wav", + "text": "就有做出這樣的呼籲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/237.wav", + "text": "我相信國人與全國各地檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/238.wav", + "text": "都已經知道這個情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/239.wav", + "text": "如果各地檢署受理到相關案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/240.wav", + "text": "都會集中到臺北地檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/241.wav", + "text": "專案檢察官手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/242.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/243.wav", + "text": "但或許次長也可以發個新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/244.wav", + "text": "官如果收到類似狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/245.wav", + "text": "內部公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/246.wav", + "text": "在第一時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/247.wav", + "text": "已經發布新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/248.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/249.wav", + "text": "先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/250.wav", + "text": "\n現在休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/251.wav", + "text": "經過冗長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/252.wav", + "text": "冗長的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/253.wav", + "text": "作以下宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/254.wav", + "text": "對增訂第十五條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/255.wav", + "text": "增訂第十五條之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/256.wav", + "text": "本日協商過程公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/257.wav", + "text": "發言內容均已錄音錄影並列入紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/258.wav", + "text": "討論過程中有共識之部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/259.wav", + "text": "作為後續協商依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/260.wav", + "text": "因仍有條文內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/261.wav", + "text": "留待繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/262.wav", + "text": "依例不做結論簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/263.wav", + "text": "後續依立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/264.wav", + "text": "職權行使法第十二章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/265.wav", + "text": "相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/266.wav", + "text": "另定期繼續協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15014/267.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/0.wav", + "text": "繼續研商再生醫療法草案再生醫療製劑條例草案二案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1.wav", + "text": "(民進黨黨團提議)" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2.wav", + "text": "案(時代力量黨團提議)" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/3.wav", + "text": ")三研商文化創意產業發展法部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/4.wav", + "text": "等案(民進黨黨團提議)" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/5.wav", + "text": "首先介紹衛生福利部部長薛瑞元先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/6.wav", + "text": "農業部交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/7.wav", + "text": "在進行協商前有關本次協商之再生醫療法草案等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/8.wav", + "text": "委員會召委吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/9.wav", + "text": "於4月21日及26日分別召集黨團協商時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/10.wav", + "text": "保留行政院提案第3條第9條第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/11.wav", + "text": "共七條條文其餘條文均獲得協商共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/12.wav", + "text": "因此為爭取立法時效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/13.wav", + "text": "本案援例徵詢各位協商代表同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/14.wav", + "text": "本次協商擬從上述之保留條文先進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/15.wav", + "text": "已在委員會完成協商之條文仍有異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/16.wav", + "text": "在事後討論時再行進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/17.wav", + "text": "請問各位委員代表有沒有異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/18.wav", + "text": "有異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/19.wav", + "text": "我們今天還有提修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/20.wav", + "text": "我們先將保留條文討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/21.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/22.wav", + "text": "我要請衛福部解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/23.wav", + "text": "再生醫療製劑及再生醫療技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/24.wav", + "text": "因為在委員會已經講得很清楚即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/25.wav", + "text": "應該要在說明欄寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/26.wav", + "text": "的部分細胞到底是自體細胞異體細胞異種細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/27.wav", + "text": "這也要寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/28.wav", + "text": "且異種細胞異體細胞的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/29.wav", + "text": "也要在說明欄裡面寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/30.wav", + "text": "本來有討論協調的文字都不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/31.wav", + "text": "我只好請衛福部從頭再說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/32.wav", + "text": "那麼民眾如何區分何謂再生醫療製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/33.wav", + "text": "何謂再生醫療技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/34.wav", + "text": "為什麼技術可以去治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/35.wav", + "text": "就是說再生醫療技術是一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/36.wav", + "text": "你現在都不放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/37.wav", + "text": "全部都拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/38.wav", + "text": "我要請衛福部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/39.wav", + "text": "這樣子我們要怎麼瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/40.wav", + "text": "我先提出第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/41.wav", + "text": "\n我要先跟院長抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/42.wav", + "text": "因為之前在協商討論過的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/43.wav", + "text": "現在衛福部全部拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/44.wav", + "text": "所以今天我們需要院長主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/45.wav", + "text": "才能夠對關心的大眾有一個交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/46.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長還有各位黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/47.wav", + "text": "鞭我們先針對第3條發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/48.wav", + "text": "再生技術部分其實我們也知道這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/49.wav", + "text": "使用經體外培養增殖或衍生的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/50.wav", + "text": "其實它也具有高風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/51.wav", + "text": "高技術門檻的特性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/52.wav", + "text": "大家比較有討論的一個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/53.wav", + "text": "所以在使用的受體上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/54.wav", + "text": "頗有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/55.wav", + "text": "而且再生醫療產業鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/56.wav", + "text": "相對來講比較長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/57.wav", + "text": "也非常專業分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/58.wav", + "text": "其實要仰賴醫療機構跟生技產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/59.wav", + "text": "這部分確實要把它明定清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/60.wav", + "text": "衛福部也要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/61.wav", + "text": "是不是要侷限在再生醫療的領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/62.wav", + "text": "並與一般性的生技醫藥產業有所區別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/63.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們認為應該要配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/64.wav", + "text": "生技醫藥產業發展條例第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/65.wav", + "text": "合併討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/66.wav", + "text": "外明定再生醫療生技醫藥公司的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/67.wav", + "text": "非常多的一個爭議點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/68.wav", + "text": "進行這個討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/69.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/70.wav", + "text": "本條例第3條第1款已經講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/71.wav", + "text": "再生醫療是指利用基因細胞及其衍生物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/72.wav", + "text": "用以治療修復或替代人體細胞組織及器官之製劑或技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/73.wav", + "text": "所以包括兩部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/74.wav", + "text": "一個是製劑一個是技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/75.wav", + "text": "第3款規定再生醫療技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/76.wav", + "text": "指於人體執行再生醫療之技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/77.wav", + "text": "但不包括下列技術在內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/78.wav", + "text": "這些技術其實要寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/79.wav", + "text": "包含輸血是輸血的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/80.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/81.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/82.wav", + "text": "再來第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/83.wav", + "text": "周邊血造血幹細胞移植統統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/84.wav", + "text": "統統要加技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/85.wav", + "text": "還有人工生殖技術是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/86.wav", + "text": "都是技術吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/87.wav", + "text": "這樣清不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/88.wav", + "text": "我覺得恐怕真的要寫清楚一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/89.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/90.wav", + "text": "就是第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/91.wav", + "text": "但那個東西恐怕要寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/92.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/93.wav", + "text": "請柯總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/94.wav", + "text": "剛才陳椒華委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/95.wav", + "text": "表示上次協商已經有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/96.wav", + "text": "為什麼又拿下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/97.wav", + "text": "我就針對這個程序性問題先談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/98.wav", + "text": "沒有人簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/99.wav", + "text": "只是在協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/100.wav", + "text": "討論包括第3條說明欄要不要改等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/101.wav", + "text": "怎麼會說拿起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/102.wav", + "text": "呢因為後來第二次協商時爭辯得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/103.wav", + "text": "辯得很厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/104.wav", + "text": "所以後來吳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/105.wav", + "text": "玉琴委員就送院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/106.wav", + "text": "這個問題我們要先釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/107.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/108.wav", + "text": "\n邱臣遠委員講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/109.wav", + "text": "有關生技醫藥產業發展條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/110.wav", + "text": "它的前身是生技新藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/111.wav", + "text": "產業發展條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/112.wav", + "text": "那是在2004年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/113.wav", + "text": "後來這個法也落日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/114.wav", + "text": "它是針對整個生技醫藥產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/115.wav", + "text": "當然包括再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/116.wav", + "text": "他們跟本法的關聯度是不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/117.wav", + "text": "生技醫藥產業發展條例是有通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/118.wav", + "text": "我們現在回到主題就是再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/119.wav", + "text": "再生醫療製劑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/120.wav", + "text": "應該是比較沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/121.wav", + "text": "這個部分有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/122.wav", + "text": "若干條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/123.wav", + "text": "看起來保留也是越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/124.wav", + "text": "我們就逐條來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/125.wav", + "text": "並沒有剛才所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/126.wav", + "text": "講好又拿起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/127.wav", + "text": "沒有這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/128.wav", + "text": "我先簡單補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/129.wav", + "text": "幾個簡單的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/130.wav", + "text": "第一個剛剛邱臣遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/131.wav", + "text": "生技醫藥產業發展條例第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/132.wav", + "text": "再生醫療生技醫藥公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/133.wav", + "text": "這個醫藥公司本來就有參照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/134.wav", + "text": "生技醫藥產業發展條例的第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/135.wav", + "text": "是廣泛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/136.wav", + "text": "因為是再生醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/137.wav", + "text": "也參照第4條的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/138.wav", + "text": "有做一些修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/139.wav", + "text": "依公司法設立的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/140.wav", + "text": "所從事的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/141.wav", + "text": "研發製造或受託開發製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/142.wav", + "text": "與再生醫療相關製劑或技術之公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/143.wav", + "text": "這已經是參照第4條來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/144.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/145.wav", + "text": "\n第二點回答曾銘宗委員��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/146.wav", + "text": "問題就是下列技術不包括在內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/147.wav", + "text": "這四款包括輸血使用血液製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/148.wav", + "text": "周邊血造血幹細胞移植" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/149.wav", + "text": "等這幾個都是醫學已經常用的專有名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/150.wav", + "text": "我們都沒有在後面加技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/151.wav", + "text": "可是我們醫療這邊都認為它是一個技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/152.wav", + "text": "因為它已經算是常規在使用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/153.wav", + "text": "維持原本的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/154.wav", + "text": "\n再來回答陳椒華委員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/155.wav", + "text": "為什麼文字的部分我們呈現的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/156.wav", + "text": "回到原本院版的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/157.wav", + "text": "然後我要再補充陳椒華委員希望我們解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/158.wav", + "text": "製劑跟技術有什麼差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/159.wav", + "text": "是指我們使用體外培養的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/160.wav", + "text": "這個細胞沒有去做一些再處理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/161.wav", + "text": "它只是做一個增殖或衍生的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/162.wav", + "text": "因為它具有一些風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/163.wav", + "text": "它真的是小規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/164.wav", + "text": "要客製化為這個病人來做處理至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/165.wav", + "text": "於我們平常使用的製劑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/166.wav", + "text": "可能會使用到譬如說像抗生素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/167.wav", + "text": "就是針對這個病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/168.wav", + "text": "所以技術跟製劑的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/169.wav", + "text": "一個是比較大批商品化的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/170.wav", + "text": "另一個是客製化的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/171.wav", + "text": "我們以此來做一個區別以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/172.wav", + "text": "或是委員會協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/173.wav", + "text": "大家對本文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/174.wav", + "text": "其實沒有太多的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/175.wav", + "text": "比較多的是我們是不是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/176.wav", + "text": "所謂的再生製劑指的是商品化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/177.wav", + "text": "規格化這種標準比較一致的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/178.wav", + "text": "然後再生技術是指規模比較小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/179.wav", + "text": "或是客製化的部分不屬於製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/180.wav", + "text": "或者是我們也曾經提到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/181.wav", + "text": "在這個異體或是異種的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/182.wav", + "text": "並不是說不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/183.wav", + "text": "當我們在使用這樣的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/184.wav", + "text": "或是這樣的來源的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/185.wav", + "text": "應該要符合原本現在就有的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/186.wav", + "text": "現在提到的申請或是作業規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/187.wav", + "text": "其實��是現在既有的規範了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/188.wav", + "text": "我們是不是應該在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/189.wav", + "text": "說得更加清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/190.wav", + "text": "讓大家不至於有不同的理解或是誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/191.wav", + "text": "所以在這個說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/192.wav", + "text": "既然剛才司長解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/193.wav", + "text": "那麼似乎把它寫上去並沒有什麼疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/194.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/195.wav", + "text": "在說明欄的部分可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/196.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/197.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/198.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/199.wav", + "text": "是時力在第3條的說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/200.wav", + "text": "就是希望能夠讓說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/201.wav", + "text": "誠如行政院版的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/202.wav", + "text": "再生技術是使用的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/203.wav", + "text": "高技術門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/204.wav", + "text": "的我們知道它是高風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/205.wav", + "text": "中我們是希望把剛剛司長也有提到的小規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/206.wav", + "text": "就是再生技術所使用的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/207.wav", + "text": "是小規模客製化的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/208.wav", + "text": "另外因為它是高風險的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/209.wav", + "text": "體細胞治療人體試驗申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/210.wav", + "text": "與操作規範中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/211.wav", + "text": "也是明定細胞包括自體異體及異種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/212.wav", + "text": "我們今天可以用的再生技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/213.wav", + "text": "就是包括所有的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/214.wav", + "text": "即自體異體及異種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/215.wav", + "text": "又因為是高風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/216.wav", + "text": "高技術門檻的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/217.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望能夠在說明欄裡寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/218.wav", + "text": "要符合前衛生署92年公布的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/219.wav", + "text": "體細胞治療人體試驗申請與操作規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/220.wav", + "text": "\n假如今天說明欄沒有把這些文字放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/221.wav", + "text": "表示我們這個法是很寬鬆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/222.wav", + "text": "使用豬的細胞牛的細胞兔子的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/223.wav", + "text": "任何其他哺乳類的細胞還有異體的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/224.wav", + "text": "高風險就是免疫排斥與基因轉移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/225.wav", + "text": "比如豬的基因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/226.wav", + "text": "身上之後會不會因為到人的基因上而導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/227.wav", + "text": "而這個風險我們應該寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/228.wav", + "text": "也就是要符合前衛生署的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/229.wav", + "text": "讓我們所進行的再生技術是安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/230.wav", + "text": "是高品質的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/231.wav", + "text": "現在我們看到衛福部給我們的都沒有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/232.wav", + "text": "如果沒有寫那要如何保證這是安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/233.wav", + "text": "在原本第3條文字將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/234.wav", + "text": "將技術跟製劑分開處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/235.wav", + "text": "尤其是這邊所提到的再生技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/236.wav", + "text": "是體外培養所增殖或衍生之細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/237.wav", + "text": "這就已經是客製化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/238.wav", + "text": "因為你不會把別人的細胞複製之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/239.wav", + "text": "打在第二個人身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/240.wav", + "text": "這會引起排斥所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/241.wav", + "text": "至於小規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/242.wav", + "text": "上次在委員會協商時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/243.wav", + "text": "我就提到所謂的小規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/244.wav", + "text": "在法律文字上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/245.wav", + "text": "到底是幾顆細胞叫小規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/246.wav", + "text": "治療幾次叫小規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/247.wav", + "text": "這樣的文字下去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/248.wav", + "text": "只是徒具形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/249.wav", + "text": "尤其是在臨床或執行的技術端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/250.wav", + "text": "對醫療人員來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/251.wav", + "text": "可能會不知道可以怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/252.wav", + "text": "因為不知道這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/253.wav", + "text": "到底是不是小規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/254.wav", + "text": "\n再來剛剛椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/255.wav", + "text": "提的我還是肯定椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/256.wav", + "text": "他其實很認真地找了很多資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/257.wav", + "text": "可是我發現你判讀可能有一點問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/258.wav", + "text": "因為在2003年11月4日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/259.wav", + "text": "衛署醫字第0920202477號公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/260.wav", + "text": "就是你剛剛所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/261.wav", + "text": "體細胞治療人體試驗申請與操作規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/262.wav", + "text": "你可以看到其中所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/263.wav", + "text": "體細胞療法的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/264.wav", + "text": "就提到這裡所規範的體細胞療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/265.wav", + "text": "同種異體或異種異體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/266.wav", + "text": "也就是你一直強調異種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/267.wav", + "text": "是不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/268.wav", + "text": "但是在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/269.wav", + "text": "它就放在體細胞治療裡面的其中一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/270.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說會造成影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/271.wav", + "text": "其實可能有點不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/272.wav", + "text": "因為第二頁就有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/273.wav", + "text": "確保生物安全性及公共衛生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/274.wav", + "text": "是避免在做這些培養過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/275.wav", + "text": "污染到外面的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/276.wav", + "text": "所以在這個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/277.wav", + "text": "應有事先防範及確保研究人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/278.wav", + "text": "工作環境及週圍之安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/279.wav", + "text": "\n92年的申請與操作規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/280.wav", + "text": "如果從這個文字上來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/281.wav", + "text": "第一本來在民國92年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/282.wav", + "text": "就有提到體細胞治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/283.wav", + "text": "同種異體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/284.wav", + "text": "異種異體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/285.wav", + "text": "第二個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/286.wav", + "text": "在這邊所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/287.wav", + "text": "其所確保的生物安全性及公共衛生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/288.wav", + "text": "不是打進去那個人的生物安全性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/289.wav", + "text": "所提的是不要在實驗室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/290.wav", + "text": "做這些mix的過程中散出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/291.wav", + "text": "而造成後續一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/292.wav", + "text": "我們講的人工做出來的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/293.wav", + "text": "導致環境的污染" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/294.wav", + "text": "就像我們2020年在提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/295.wav", + "text": "所謂的COVID-19" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/296.wav", + "text": "是不是實驗室病毒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/297.wav", + "text": "在實驗過程逸散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/298.wav", + "text": "那個是在講實驗室管理規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/299.wav", + "text": "這個標題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/300.wav", + "text": "它叫做人體試驗申請與操作規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/301.wav", + "text": "這是規範實驗室不要把細胞污染到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/302.wav", + "text": "不是你要實施的那個對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/303.wav", + "text": "跑到外面來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/304.wav", + "text": "以上補充謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/305.wav", + "text": "看起來這一條大家意見很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/306.wav", + "text": "都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/307.wav", + "text": "是不是我們依照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/308.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/309.wav", + "text": "動物的細胞打到人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/310.wav", + "text": "會有風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/311.wav", + "text": "麻煩院長請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/312.wav", + "text": "說明一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/313.wav", + "text": "我先說一下好嗎我要幫醫生講個話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/314.wav", + "text": "不會有醫生自己去抽一個動物細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/315.wav", + "text": "不用做任何P就可以打到人身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/316.wav", + "text": "不要這樣我們不是怪醫秦博士好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/317.wav", + "text": "是不同人的細胞使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/318.wav", + "text": "還有不同動物的細胞使用在人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/319.wav", + "text": "會不會有風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/320.wav", + "text": "這邊要寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/321.wav", + "text": "到底有什麼樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/322.wav", + "text": "好不好可不可以請衛福部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/323.wav", + "text": "請部長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/324.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/325.wav", + "text": "這個是為國人的健康把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/326.wav", + "text": "你不讓他說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/327.wav", + "text": "那就是把國人當白老鼠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/328.wav", + "text": "如果大家意見還是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/329.wav", + "text": "我們請他說清楚好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/330.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/331.wav", + "text": "如果他還沒說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/332.wav", + "text": "你不能講行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/333.wav", + "text": "一定會害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/334.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/335.wav", + "text": "院長我們拜託你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/336.wav", + "text": "這些技術都是新的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/337.wav", + "text": "不管是剛剛陳委員提到的異種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/338.wav", + "text": "當然都會有一些風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/339.wav", + "text": "都有可能包括陳委員剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/340.wav", + "text": "等等這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/341.wav", + "text": "所以第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/342.wav", + "text": "因為排斥它可能會不成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/343.wav", + "text": "因為排斥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/344.wav", + "text": "可能會產生不良的作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/345.wav", + "text": "這個問題要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/346.wav", + "text": "一定是在進行這些技術之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/347.wav", + "text": "必須要經過人體試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/348.wav", + "text": "這就是我們這部法規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/349.wav", + "text": "你必須要先做人體試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/350.wav", + "text": "人體試驗有了一個結果之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/351.wav", + "text": "來申請我們才會核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/352.wav", + "text": "可能產生排斥現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/353.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/354.wav", + "text": "不要講說這麼小的一個細胞治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/355.wav", + "text": "大到像心臟的移植" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/356.wav", + "text": "都有可以抗排斥的藥物來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/357.wav", + "text": "並不是無解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/358.wav", + "text": "還是有解的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/359.wav", + "text": "但是必須要去做試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/360.wav", + "text": "才能夠知道可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/361.wav", + "text": "所做的結果是好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/362.wav", + "text": "來申請我們才有可能通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/363.wav", + "text": "我們已經討論很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/364.wav", + "text": "了我想先確認一下現在的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/365.wav", + "text": "現在的狀況是各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/366.wav", + "text": "對第3條條文本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/367.wav", + "text": "其實沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/368.wav", + "text": "現在是對現在還是會有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/369.wav", + "text": "講清楚就會有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/370.wav", + "text": "沒講清楚我就會有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/371.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員請尊重我的發言好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/372.wav", + "text": "包括現在我們手上拿到的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/373.wav", + "text": "這個修正動議是陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/374.wav", + "text": "以時代力量為名提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/375.wav", + "text": "第九版修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/376.wav", + "text": "跟我們之前在協商過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/377.wav", + "text": "那麼這樣一版一版下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/378.wav", + "text": "我們對條文本身的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/379.wav", + "text": "其實是沒有意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/380.wav", + "text": "現在大家是對說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/381.wav", + "text": "有意見如果以剛剛陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/382.wav", + "text": "甚至是剛剛醫藥司這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/383.wav", + "text": "講的部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/384.wav", + "text": "我們中華民國臺灣現在既有的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/385.wav", + "text": "其實對所謂的異體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/386.wav", + "text": "不過話說回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/387.wav", + "text": "其實跟它現在的第九版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/388.wav", + "text": "第九次提的修正動議的這個規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/389.wav", + "text": "是我們本來就已經在做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/390.wav", + "text": "我們在做的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/391.wav", + "text": "就是應該要遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/392.wav", + "text": "這些已經存在的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/393.wav", + "text": "這邊有多了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/394.wav", + "text": "再生製劑為商品化規格化製程加工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/395.wav", + "text": "的文字反而是藥品這兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/396.wav", + "text": "不是很接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/397.wav", + "text": "討論如果這個規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/398.wav", + "text": "是我們現在都已經在做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/399.wav", + "text": "也就是說他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/400.wav", + "text": "只是把現在的東西再寫一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/401.wav", + "text": "跟現行的狀況有沒有差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/402.wav", + "text": "因為我們的條文本身沒有差但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/403.wav", + "text": "但說明的部分有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/404.wav", + "text": "跟現行的部分又沒差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/405.wav", + "text": "那寫上去到底有沒有困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/406.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/407.wav", + "text": "這兩個字會不會有差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/408.wav", + "text": "請邱議瑩委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/409.wav", + "text": "我們在委員會協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/410.wav", + "text": "其實大家對第3條的本文是沒有意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/411.wav", + "text": "包括林為洲委員也都全程參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/412.wav", + "text": "也跟國民黨曾總召報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/413.wav", + "text": "對於說明欄的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/414.wav", + "text": "我是不是能夠請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/415.wav", + "text": "再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/416.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/417.wav", + "text": "剛剛陳椒華委員的這一版修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/418.wav", + "text": "因為我已經記不清楚是第幾版了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/419.wav", + "text": "你現在是要用這一版來討論的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/420.wav", + "text": "請看一下說明欄的第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/421.wav", + "text": "談到異體異種的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/422.wav", + "text": "就我們實際的操作面來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/423.wav", + "text": "有沒有窒礙難行的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/424.wav", + "text": "這是第一個我們想要請問的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/425.wav", + "text": "又寫到再生製劑為商品化規格化製程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/426.wav", + "text": "加工達一致標準且一致化之藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/427.wav", + "text": "其實再生製劑的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/428.wav", + "text": "在製劑條例的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/429.wav", + "text": "就會把它定義的非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/430.wav", + "text": "了這樣的寫法好像跟我們製劑條例裡面的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/431.wav", + "text": "是不是會比較完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/432.wav", + "text": "\n第三我想要特別拜託一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/433.wav", + "text": "大家都同意沒有意見的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/434.wav", + "text": "不應該今天在黨政協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/435.wav", + "text": "又拿出來說我等一下還會有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/436.wav", + "text": "我等一下還要再翻案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/437.wav", + "text": "這樣就會沒完沒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/438.wav", + "text": "每天就一直不斷在這裡無限輪迴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/439.wav", + "text": "以上也跟院長報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/440.wav", + "text": "\n再生醫療不管是技術或者是製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/441.wav", + "text": "劑都必須要拿到藥證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/442.wav", + "text": "都必須要拿到許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/443.wav", + "text": "都必須經過很嚴格的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/444.wav", + "text": "在衛福部那一端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/445.wav", + "text": "沒有一個醫生是要害死病人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/446.wav", + "text": "拿那種沒有經過安全審查藥證的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/447.wav", + "text": "來打到人體裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/448.wav", + "text": "所以不應該在我們處理這個草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/449.wav", + "text": "的時候說我們把它放很鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/450.wav", + "text": "說我們��顧病人安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/451.wav", + "text": "讓網路一天到晚不斷地來霸凌我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/452.wav", + "text": "霸凌我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/453.wav", + "text": "我告訴你我不怕你的霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/454.wav", + "text": "這個案子我弄了六年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/455.wav", + "text": "我是一個癌症的病患" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/456.wav", + "text": "我知道再生醫療技術對癌症的病人有多重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/457.wav", + "text": "我也知道安全性對一個病人的健康來講有多重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/458.wav", + "text": "你可以持續不斷地霸凌我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/459.wav", + "text": "但是我告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/460.wav", + "text": "我還是要持續地來推這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/461.wav", + "text": "從立法技術來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/462.wav", + "text": "因為第3條是本法用詞定義如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/463.wav", + "text": "所以再生醫療包括製劑和技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/464.wav", + "text": "製劑的部分很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/465.wav", + "text": "是指人體執行再生醫療之技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/466.wav", + "text": "但下列技術不包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/467.wav", + "text": "其他經中央主管機關公告之技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/468.wav", + "text": "\n也把它排掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/469.wav", + "text": "那我要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/470.wav", + "text": "再生醫療技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/471.wav", + "text": "就是假設這五款沒有排掉的部分統統都在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/472.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/473.wav", + "text": "要先確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/474.wav", + "text": "喔邱醫師對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/475.wav", + "text": "我外行人看覺得再生醫療技術可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/476.wav", + "text": "包山包海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/477.wav", + "text": "海耶現在只有把這五款拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/478.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/479.wav", + "text": "還有一個保留條款是其他經中央主管機關公告之技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/480.wav", + "text": "要排掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/481.wav", + "text": "我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/482.wav", + "text": "這樣的立法技術有沒有排乾淨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/483.wav", + "text": "不然到時候會出狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/484.wav", + "text": "啊還有這個立法很特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/485.wav", + "text": "就是經過行政院公告後不適用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/486.wav", + "text": "這我還是第一次看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/487.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/488.wav", + "text": "因為這是但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/489.wav", + "text": "但下列技術不包括在內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/490.wav", + "text": "其他經行政院公告之技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/491.wav", + "text": "這是少見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/492.wav", + "text": "除了排掉的這五款之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/493.wav", + "text": "我是外行人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/494.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得可能會排不乾淨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/495.wav", + "text": "它有第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/496.wav", + "text": "它說新的技術喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/497.wav", + "text": "這個不適用那個不適用這樣很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/498.wav", + "text": "嘛我只是好意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/499.wav", + "text": "啦到底有沒有排乾淨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/500.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/501.wav", + "text": "非常敬佩大家對於這麼重要的醫療發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/502.wav", + "text": "人民健康照顧的一個法案如此重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/503.wav", + "text": "其實我們可以追根究柢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/504.wav", + "text": "來看原來為什麼有這兩個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/505.wav", + "text": "在衛福部已經有一個特管辦法一直在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/506.wav", + "text": "就是希望能配合民眾需要醫療在發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/507.wav", + "text": "但也是要嚴格審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/508.wav", + "text": "喔一個一個做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/509.wav", + "text": "有時候都要申請很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/510.wav", + "text": "那個技術才可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/511.wav", + "text": "申請五年多了現在差不多兩百多項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/512.wav", + "text": "項各個醫療院所都在發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/513.wav", + "text": "特管辦法都在嚴格審查\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/514.wav", + "text": "其實這個法只是把特管辦法法律化而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/515.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/516.wav", + "text": "因為其實這五六年來一開始是要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/517.wav", + "text": "是要做再生醫療製劑那個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/518.wav", + "text": "它裡面的重中之重是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/519.wav", + "text": "是conditionalapproval" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/520.wav", + "text": "就是附加條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/521.wav", + "text": "原來是講初步療效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/522.wav", + "text": "效後來依我們大家的共識把它變成第二期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/523.wav", + "text": "它只要經過審查以後就可以出來賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/524.wav", + "text": "這個就是所謂的再生醫療製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/525.wav", + "text": "劑我倒是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/526.wav", + "text": "也可以邀請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/527.wav", + "text": "其實那個部分是大量生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/528.wav", + "text": "至於再生醫療這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/529.wav", + "text": "原來特管辦法已經實行了五六年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/530.wav", + "text": "所以我要問一下衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/531.wav", + "text": "特管辦法這五六年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/532.wav", + "text": "有做得不順暢的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/533.wav", + "text": "有被人家說不倫理的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/534.wav", + "text": "有被人家說不安全的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/535.wav", + "text": "我跟你講我所有服務案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/536.wav", + "text": "都是說拜託可不可以快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/537.wav", + "text": "醫院申請了2個月3個月半年都還不下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/538.wav", + "text": "實在沒有辦法再發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/539.wav", + "text": "病人在那邊等著一個一個要治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/540.wav", + "text": "所以剛才邱議瑩講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/541.wav", + "text": "是醫師要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/542.wav", + "text": "倫理的問題醫師團體要去承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/543.wav", + "text": "講成這樣今天所有一個一個做都不會賺錢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/544.wav", + "text": "啦\n我舉個例子恩慈療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/545.wav", + "text": "可是真的需要產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/546.wav", + "text": "需要再生醫療製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/547.wav", + "text": "製劑第二期以後去大量製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/548.wav", + "text": "那個才是產業商業化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/549.wav", + "text": "但這是科學的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/550.wav", + "text": "需要而去研究如果醫院要做這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/551.wav", + "text": "縮小範圍或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/552.wav", + "text": "的我覺得這對醫療人員是非常不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/553.wav", + "text": "的並且對需要的病人是非常殘忍的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/554.wav", + "text": "現在這個再生醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/555.wav", + "text": "有超越原來特管辦法的範圍嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/556.wav", + "text": "應該沒有嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/557.wav", + "text": "你們的安全有比較放鬆嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/558.wav", + "text": "嚴謹性有比較不好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/559.wav", + "text": "讓醫療院所好好治療病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/560.wav", + "text": "一直在誣衊我覺得這是不好的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/561.wav", + "text": "我先弄清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/562.wav", + "text": "我發言請你尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/563.wav", + "text": "各位要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/564.wav", + "text": "用心的治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/565.wav", + "text": "而再生醫療製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/566.wav", + "text": "製劑是針對特定的適應症在治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/567.wav", + "text": "所以完全不一樣的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/568.wav", + "text": "不要用這個製劑把很多名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/569.wav", + "text": "應該說技術是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/570.wav", + "text": "連我都不知道未來有什麼技術啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/571.wav", + "text": "你現在要把技術定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/572.wav", + "text": "有這麼厲害嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/573.wav", + "text": "再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/574.wav", + "text": "如果沒有共識我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/575.wav", + "text": "因為之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/576.wav", + "text": "修正動議是要放在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/577.wav", + "text": "你講的那個不是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/578.wav", + "text": "不包括異種細胞是你要求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/579.wav", + "text": "不是啦我先講完嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/580.wav", + "text": "後來我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/581.wav", + "text": "如果放在說明可以的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/582.wav", + "text": "對於本文就可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/583.wav", + "text": "但是現在說明也沒有放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/584.wav", + "text": "所以對本文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/585.wav", + "text": "我就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/586.wav", + "text": "要求不包括異種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/587.wav", + "text": "要放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/588.wav", + "text": "並不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/589.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/590.wav", + "text": "\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/591.wav", + "text": "到底跟特管一不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/592.wav", + "text": "這當然跟特管不一樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/593.wav", + "text": "因為今天行政院版本在第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/594.wav", + "text": "初步有療效就可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/595.wav", + "text": "也不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/596.wav", + "text": "剛剛有委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/597.wav", + "text": "技術跟製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/598.wav", + "text": "製劑都要有許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/599.wav", + "text": "不對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/600.wav", + "text": "有初步療效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/601.wav", + "text": "根本不需要有許可就可以用啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/602.wav", + "text": "所以今天第9條就是一個大後門嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/603.wav", + "text": "因為第9條是大後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/604.wav", + "text": "第3條就很有問題你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/605.wav", + "text": "你異體跟異種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/606.wav", + "text": "我們講話要照實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/607.wav", + "text": "我還沒有發言完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/608.wav", + "text": "什麼亂講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/609.wav", + "text": "我今天可以公開辯論啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/610.wav", + "text": "你隨便誹謗人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/611.wav", + "text": "我們可以公開辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/612.wav", + "text": "看你敢不敢來辯論啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/613.wav", + "text": "到底誰霸凌誰啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/614.wav", + "text": "誰在罵誰啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/615.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/616.wav", + "text": "你要主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/617.wav", + "text": "把國人當白老鼠的法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/618.wav", + "text": "等一下我要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/619.wav", + "text": "我們沒有講清楚的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/620.wav", + "text": "我們絕對不可以隨便保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/621.wav", + "text": "我反對陳椒華亂扣帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/622.wav", + "text": "什麼叫把國人當白老鼠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/623.wav", + "text": "我們找專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/624.wav", + "text": "啊我們衛福部要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/625.wav", + "text": "為什麼動物細胞可以打在人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/626.wav", + "text": "身上你在說明欄裡面都不願意講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/627.wav", + "text": "為什麼第9條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/628.wav", + "text": "初步療效就可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/629.wav", + "text": "什麼叫初步療效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/630.wav", + "text": "你自己剛剛說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/631.wav", + "text": "一定要測試有沒有免疫排斥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/632.wav", + "text": "但是第9條放得這麼鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/633.wav", + "text": "只要有初步療效就可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/634.wav", + "text": "而動物細胞的部分你到底要做多少的試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/635.wav", + "text": "才能保證是沒有初步療效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/636.wav", + "text": "這是一個非常大的漏洞啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/637.wav", + "text": "委員讓我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/638.wav", + "text": "我知道你的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/639.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天就是把定義講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/640.wav", + "text": "之前衛福部醫事司都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/641.wav", + "text": "因為目前沒有在用異體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/642.wav", + "text": "異種細胞只有用自體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/643.wav", + "text": "所以我們就把它寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/644.wav", + "text": "就是只用自體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/645.wav", + "text": "就是這麼簡單啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/646.wav", + "text": "我剛好擔任召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/647.wav", + "text": "也讓陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/648.wav", + "text": "瞭解我們真的很認真在討論法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/649.wav", + "text": "沒有要把病人當白老鼠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/650.wav", + "text": "再來陳椒華委員對第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/651.wav", + "text": "條文的部分並沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/652.wav", + "text": "但說明欄的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/653.wav", + "text": "希望能增加異種跟異體細胞即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/654.wav", + "text": "其實一開始他的條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/655.wav", + "text": "而今天看到的文字是包含了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/656.wav", + "text": "對此我必須說明的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/657.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員提到的體細胞治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/658.wav", + "text": "在92年就有這個辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/659.wav", + "text": "其實它就包括了異種異體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/660.wav", + "text": "其實是有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/661.wav", + "text": "看到的是92年的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/662.wav", + "text": "但是沒有用啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/663.wav", + "text": "只用自體啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/664.wav", + "text": "就是沒有那些case啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/665.wav", + "text": "陳委員這個技術的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/666.wav", + "text": "我們不能在這邊就關起門來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/667.wav", + "text": "我看到這至少是92年的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/668.wav", + "text": "現在經過那麼多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/669.wav", + "text": "也都在執行沒有限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/670.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/671.wav", + "text": "不是在這邊再框一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/672.wav", + "text": "沒有在執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/673.wav", + "text": "吳委員是第一次講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/674.wav", + "text": "對我第一次講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/675.wav", + "text": "而且我是召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/676.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得我們的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/677.wav", + "text": "應該要更對焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/678.wav", + "text": "而且是有具體的討論結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/679.wav", + "text": "而不是你不聽大家的勸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/680.wav", + "text": "我們也勸不了你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/681.wav", + "text": "這樣可能就要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/682.wav", + "text": "衛福部部長講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/683.wav", + "text": "現在有在做異種嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/684.wav", + "text": "有在做異體嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/685.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/686.wav", + "text": "異種現在真正在用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/687.wav", + "text": "研究可能有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/688.wav", + "text": "現在沒有在治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/689.wav", + "text": "現在都在研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/690.wav", + "text": "我也沒有反對研究啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/691.wav", + "text": "異體的部分是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/692.wav", + "text": "我們還沒有開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/693.wav", + "text": "當然就沒有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/694.wav", + "text": "異體我們現在還沒開放所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/695.wav", + "text": "就沒有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/696.wav", + "text": "這個通過後開放屆時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/697.wav", + "text": "就會有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/698.wav", + "text": "我很持平地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/699.wav", + "text": "我有很認真聽請你的講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/700.wav", + "text": "第一個剛才也講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/701.wav", + "text": "你現在改說明欄是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/702.wav", + "text": "異體是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/703.wav", + "text": "我不承認第九版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/704.wav", + "text": "我們只是把同樣的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/705.wav", + "text": "透過衛福部給我們的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/706.wav", + "text": "我們把它修一修而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/707.wav", + "text": "把風險講清楚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/708.wav", + "text": "各位不用這樣群體在那邊唬弄嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/709.wav", + "text": "我們沒有群體唬弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/710.wav", + "text": "我是站高山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/711.wav", + "text": "我是很持平地看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/712.wav", + "text": "不用這樣形容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/713.wav", + "text": "我都是很持平地看待讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/714.wav", + "text": "再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/715.wav", + "text": "在上一屆就有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/716.wav", + "text": "2018年就有特管辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/717.wav", + "text": "用第9條是把特管辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/718.wav", + "text": "那三款包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/719.wav", + "text": "等等放在條文裡面恩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/720.wav", + "text": "希望在充滿抹黑及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/721.wav", + "text": "之下完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/722.wav", + "text": "生醫療法在上一屆沒有辦法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/723.wav", + "text": "本來要用三個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/724.wav", + "text": "包括再生醫療發展法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/725.wav", + "text": "和日本的立法例一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/726.wav", + "text": "後來改為兩個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/727.wav", + "text": "就分流了製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/728.wav", + "text": "醫療橫豎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/729.wav", + "text": "豎我曾經當過醫生再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/730.wav", + "text": "再生醫療細胞治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/731.wav", + "text": "科學是一直發展的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/732.wav", + "text": "現在還沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/733.wav", + "text": "當然是沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/734.wav", + "text": "在研究中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/735.wav", + "text": "我們不能阻礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/736.wav", + "text": "整個醫學發展的進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/737.wav", + "text": "這都是要拿來救人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/738.wav", + "text": "都要人體試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/739.wav", + "text": "都是很嚴謹的把關除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/740.wav", + "text": "CDC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/741.wav", + "text": "一個小組在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/742.wav", + "text": "我們希望這個法立出來能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/743.wav", + "text": "技術是越來越進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/744.wav", + "text": "的版本又要重新寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/745.wav", + "text": "立法院不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/746.wav", + "text": "你一個人說要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/747.wav", + "text": "樣邏輯不能跳來跳去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/748.wav", + "text": "我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/749.wav", + "text": "用平常心來看待這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/750.wav", + "text": "看一看從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/751.wav", + "text": "從2018年的特管辦法到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/752.wav", + "text": "就像剛才邱泰源委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/753.wav", + "text": "及邱議瑩委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/754.wav", + "text": "醫生要為很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/755.wav", + "text": "他也非常了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/756.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/757.wav", + "text": "承認第九版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/758.wav", + "text": "不能這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/759.wav", + "text": "這樣真的沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/760.wav", + "text": "到院會去處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/761.wav", + "text": "大家不要有情緒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/762.wav", + "text": "慢慢講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/763.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/764.wav", + "text": "如果要繼續講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/765.wav", + "text": "因為他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/766.wav", + "text": "舉手舉很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/767.wav", + "text": "保留好了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/768.wav", + "text": "這要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/769.wav", + "text": "我們才能對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/770.wav", + "text": "關心的團體學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/771.wav", + "text": "如果要講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/772.wav", + "text": "現在是輪到邱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/773.wav", + "text": "我簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/774.wav", + "text": "現在不是意氣用事的時候我向曾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/775.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員已經提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/776.wav", + "text": "九個版本的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/777.wav", + "text": "現在陳椒華委員說他不承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/778.wav", + "text": "心酸的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/779.wav", + "text": "寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/780.wav", + "text": "他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/781.wav", + "text": "說明欄第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/782.wav", + "text": "使用異種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/783.wav", + "text": "異體細胞之來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/784.wav", + "text": "體細胞治療人體試驗中的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/785.wav", + "text": "申請操作規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/786.wav", + "text": "及相關安全規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/787.wav", + "text": "我剛剛也問衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/788.wav", + "text": "這有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/789.wav", + "text": "我們是可以接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/790.wav", + "text": "可是現在提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/791.wav", + "text": "又說他不承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/792.wav", + "text": "又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/793.wav", + "text": "框一個大帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/794.wav", + "text": "我們在放水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/795.wav", + "text": "要把人體當白老鼠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/796.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/797.wav", + "text": "太過於嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/798.wav", + "text": "也太過於民粹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/799.wav", + "text": "曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/800.wav", + "text": "我向您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/801.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/802.wav", + "text": "零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/803.wav", + "text": "到有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/804.wav", + "text": "從有細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/805.wav", + "text": "現在的醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/806.wav", + "text": "已經進步到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/807.wav", + "text": "沒有細胞的細胞治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/808.wav", + "text": "陪陳椒華" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/809.wav", + "text": "玩了九個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/810.wav", + "text": "現在連這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/811.wav", + "text": "他都說他不承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/812.wav", + "text": "我不知道我們是要被他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/813.wav", + "text": "一直裝肖仔下去還是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/814.wav", + "text": "我看這一條保留請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/815.wav", + "text": "大家看第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/816.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/817.wav", + "text": "我最後再強調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/818.wav", + "text": "不是啦我要強調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/819.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/820.wav", + "text": "所用的再生技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/821.wav", + "text": "都是自體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/822.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/823.wav", + "text": "我很簡單地再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/824.wav", + "text": "我們希望在說明欄裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/825.wav", + "text": "要用異種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/826.wav", + "text": "不要用在治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/827.wav", + "text": "我們不反對你們去研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/828.wav", + "text": "但是要把這部分寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/829.wav", + "text": "就是用異體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/830.wav", + "text": "再生製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/831.wav", + "text": "目前都是用自體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/832.wav", + "text": "所以請你去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/833.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/834.wav", + "text": "我們要把白老鼠講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/835.wav", + "text": "\n我今天講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/836.wav", + "text": "為什麼這樣會變成白老鼠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/837.wav", + "text": "都是自體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/838.wav", + "text": "但你同意用異體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/839.wav", + "text": "又同意用異種細胞的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/840.wav", + "text": "就是把我們的國人當白老鼠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/841.wav", + "text": "大家如果有異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/842.wav", + "text": "可以請衛福部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/843.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們現在都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/844.wav", + "text": "自體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/845.wav", + "text": "你卻同意用異體異種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/846.wav", + "text": "這難道不是把國人當白老鼠嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/847.wav", + "text": "不要誣衊醫療專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/848.wav", + "text": "剛才已經說明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/849.wav", + "text": "請大家看第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/850.wav", + "text": "把國人當白老鼠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/851.wav", + "text": "你要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/852.wav", + "text": "大家不能草率通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/853.wav", + "text": "不能攻擊我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/854.wav", + "text": "就毀謗我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/855.wav", + "text": "國人當白老鼠就是一個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/856.wav", + "text": "請問各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/857.wav", + "text": "這一條已經講1個小時了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/858.wav", + "text": "那就保留不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/859.wav", + "text": "講了就保留好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/860.wav", + "text": "第3條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/861.wav", + "text": "第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/862.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/863.wav", + "text": "椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/864.wav", + "text": "第9條是非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/865.wav", + "text": "版第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/866.wav", + "text": "第2款及第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/867.wav", + "text": "款是執行人體試驗結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/868.wav", + "text": "就可以執行再生技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/869.wav", + "text": "然後也不需要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/870.wav", + "text": "申請藥品許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/871.wav", + "text": "或者是有附款許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/872.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/873.wav", + "text": "人體試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/874.wav", + "text": "結果證實初步療效就可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/875.wav", + "text": "了怎麼證明初步療效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/876.wav", + "text": "這個就是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/877.wav", + "text": "及團體大家在反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/878.wav", + "text": "只要不含基因改造或轉殖之人類細胞及其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/879.wav", + "text": "衍生物之細胞治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/880.wav", + "text": "那不是很寬鬆嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/881.wav", + "text": "不是很好騙嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/882.wav", + "text": "很多醫療機構就說都符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/883.wav", + "text": "我們的法制定的這麼鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/884.wav", + "text": "讓大家可以賺大錢的法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/885.wav", + "text": "現在針對條文你要修正哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/886.wav", + "text": "你對條文有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/887.wav", + "text": "我們的修正動議啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/888.wav", + "text": "在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/889.wav", + "text": "修正動議啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/890.wav", + "text": "我們有提修正動議第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/891.wav", + "text": "在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/892.wav", + "text": "4月21日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/893.wav", + "text": "衛福部自己提出來的再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/894.wav", + "text": "衛福部又把它拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/895.wav", + "text": "所以我們的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/896.wav", + "text": "事實上是衛福部曾經在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/897.wav", + "text": "4月21日28日提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/898.wav", + "text": "這個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/899.wav", + "text": "也曾是衛福部提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/900.wav", + "text": "比較符合安全的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/901.wav", + "text": "也就是有把剛剛所說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/902.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/903.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/904.wav", + "text": "第9條請依照我們提出來的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/905.wav", + "text": "請問衛福部的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/906.wav", + "text": "先回答陳椒華委員這邊的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/907.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/908.wav", + "text": "從我們預告之後到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/909.wav", + "text": "我們會有這個版本出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/910.wav", + "text": "那時候的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/911.wav", + "text": "的考量是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/912.wav", + "text": "大家如果都不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/913.wav", + "text": "其實第8條第9條要一起看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/914.wav", + "text": "而第8條跟第9條一起看的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/915.wav", + "text": "其實第8條就是所有的都要經過申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/916.wav", + "text": "這個程序裡面的把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/917.wav", + "text": "其實會在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/918.wav", + "text": "第8條裡面申請的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/919.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/920.wav", + "text": "只是在申請裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/921.wav", + "text": "我們要來限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/922.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/923.wav", + "text": "不會有一個動物實驗在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/924.wav", + "text": "這樣我們光行政審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/925.wav", + "text": "可能就會收到這樣的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/926.wav", + "text": "行政程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/927.wav", + "text": "就又會回到特管辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/928.wav", + "text": "一直被人家講就是行政程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/929.wav", + "text": "所以第9條其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/930.wav", + "text": "更明確的限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/931.wav", + "text": "來我們這邊申請的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/932.wav", + "text": "案子把過去的特管辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/933.wav", + "text": "特管辦法在處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/934.wav", + "text": "其實就會是我們在特管辦法裡面的第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/935.wav", + "text": "也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/936.wav", + "text": "有了人體試驗的結果才來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/937.wav", + "text": "至於第三款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/938.wav", + "text": "其實就是特管辦法裡面的第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/939.wav", + "text": "已經有了初步的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/940.wav", + "text": "就是我們正面表列的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/941.wav", + "text": "部分門檻比較低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/942.wav", + "text": "自體使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/943.wav", + "text": "有6項細胞可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/944.wav", + "text": "它其實就是把現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/945.wav", + "text": "特管辦法入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/946.wav", + "text": "特管辦法入法這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/947.wav", + "text": "是因為過去我們在執行裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/948.wav", + "text": "誠如剛剛委員所講的它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/949.wav", + "text": "算是醫療法中的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/950.wav", + "text": "所以管理的對象是醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/951.wav", + "text": "對於其他相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/952.wav", + "text": "包括再生醫療廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/953.wav", + "text": "不是由醫療機構提出來的廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/954.wav", + "text": "這部分的管理架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/955.wav", + "text": "其實是比較鬆散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/956.wav", + "text": "的所以我們也會希望這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/957.wav", + "text": "拉成一個專法來處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/958.wav", + "text": "可以去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/959.wav", + "text": "所以才會在這個設計上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/960.wav", + "text": "建議往這個方向去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/961.wav", + "text": "那時候是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/962.wav", + "text": "經過大家很多的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/963.wav", + "text": "我們原本的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/964.wav", + "text": "如果這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/965.wav", + "text": "照院版的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/966.wav", + "text": "其實是講不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/967.wav", + "text": "講不清楚的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/968.wav", + "text": "如果我又只動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/969.wav", + "text": "時代力量提出來的這個版本的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/970.wav", + "text": "會造成我原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/971.wav", + "text": "細胞治療的架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/972.wav", + "text": "要銜接的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/973.wav", + "text": "又要做更詳細的解說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/974.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/975.wav", + "text": "以院版這邊的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/976.wav", + "text": "希望委員這邊有一些共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/977.wav", + "text": "這樣的話在條文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/978.wav", + "text": "會比較容易做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/979.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/980.wav", + "text": "行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/981.wav", + "text": "執行人體試驗結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/982.wav", + "text": "證實其安全性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/983.wav", + "text": "初步療效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/984.wav", + "text": "由誰來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/985.wav", + "text": "診斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/986.wav", + "text": "在執行上會面臨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/987.wav", + "text": "怎麼執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/988.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/989.wav", + "text": "請王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/990.wav", + "text": "我想跟大家說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/991.wav", + "text": "在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/992.wav", + "text": "其實衛福部有提出修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/993.wav", + "text": "也就是現在時代力量的這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/994.wav", + "text": "其實當時我們是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/995.wav", + "text": "也認為這樣其實可以比較明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/996.wav", + "text": "這些適用的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/997.wav", + "text": "或是嚴重失能的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/998.wav", + "text": "符合這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/999.wav", + "text": "條件的我們才給予相關的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1000.wav", + "text": "所以我們其實是支持院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1001.wav", + "text": "後來自己主動做修正的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1002.wav", + "text": "但當時在審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1003.wav", + "text": "的時候反而是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1004.wav", + "text": "有一些民進黨委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1005.wav", + "text": "我還是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1006.wav", + "text": "我們現在這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1007.wav", + "text": "自己主動提出來的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1008.wav", + "text": "是更加明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1009.wav", + "text": "因為如果回到最初的院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1010.wav", + "text": "可能擔心的還是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1011.wav", + "text": "他可能還沒有到這麼嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1012.wav", + "text": "我們就要有某種程度的放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1013.wav", + "text": "或是某種程度的提前讓他做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1014.wav", + "text": "包括在有初步療效的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1015.wav", + "text": "就要拿來使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1016.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是比較危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1017.wav", + "text": "或是比較難以說清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1018.wav", + "text": "這也是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1019.wav", + "text": "時代力量是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1020.wav", + "text": "衛福部的修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1021.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1022.wav", + "text": "不得執行再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1023.wav", + "text": "應該是大家的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1024.wav", + "text": "但申請藥品許可證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1025.wav", + "text": "這個還是有其他多種考量的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1026.wav", + "text": "所以本黨的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1027.wav", + "text": "為施行再生醫療的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1028.wav", + "text": "醫療機構應該履行病人知情權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1029.wav", + "text": "這是我們在第9條的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1030.wav", + "text": "酌予參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1031.wav", + "text": "我澄清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1032.wav", + "text": "我現在先澄清幾個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1033.wav", + "text": "所謂現在時代力量的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1034.wav", + "text": "的但是後來不見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1035.wav", + "text": "了我稍微查詢一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1036.wav", + "text": "是在委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1037.wav", + "text": "沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1038.wav", + "text": "沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1039.wav", + "text": "我們今天要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1040.wav", + "text": "剛剛衛福部也已經講得很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1041.wav", + "text": "第1款是恩慈療法這本來就在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1042.wav", + "text": "第2款是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1043.wav", + "text": "特管辦法第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1044.wav", + "text": "也要人體試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1045.wav", + "text": "假如只有維持一款的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1046.wav", + "text": "那所有以前的特管辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1047.wav", + "text": "也不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1048.wav", + "text": "了什麼都不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1049.wav", + "text": "了是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1050.wav", + "text": "所有這些行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1051.wav", + "text": "大家都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1052.wav", + "text": "要如何救人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1053.wav", + "text": "不要把它想成全部要牟利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1054.wav", + "text": "持平而論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1055.wav", + "text": "恩慈條款到這裡還是要付錢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1056.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1057.wav", + "text": "要收多少錢整個審查程序都很嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1058.wav", + "text": "所以這是有一套程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1059.wav", + "text": "程序的存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1060.wav", + "text": "我們在審查法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1061.wav", + "text": "大家沒有辦法建立在一個非常理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1062.wav", + "text": "過去一路走來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1063.wav", + "text": "從108年走來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1064.wav", + "text": "我們就在努力的途徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1065.wav", + "text": "你要全部倒推到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1066.wav", + "text": "只有一款而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1067.wav", + "text": "那什麼都不必做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1068.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1069.wav", + "text": "還沒講的先講好講清楚不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1070.wav", + "text": "還沒講的先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1071.wav", + "text": "講邱理事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1072.wav", + "text": "邱議瑩委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1073.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1074.wav", + "text": "這些要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1075.wav", + "text": "都要先審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1076.wav", + "text": "才去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1077.wav", + "text": "不是我們喊說要做就做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1078.wav", + "text": "有三個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1079.wav", + "text": "一個是恩慈療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1080.wav", + "text": "一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1081.wav", + "text": "一定要經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1082.wav", + "text": "這個其實就是符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1083.wav", + "text": "特管辦法第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1084.wav", + "text": "你要讓他有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1085.wav", + "text": "藥物試驗要分第一期第二期第三期第四期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1086.wav", + "text": "人體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1087.wav", + "text": "這是很難處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1088.wav", + "text": "你就不救他的命嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1089.wav", + "text": "很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1090.wav", + "text": "招5個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1091.wav", + "text": "初步效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1092.wav", + "text": "這樣就可以送給衛福部審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1093.wav", + "text": "臺灣拚到現在這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1094.wav", + "text": "這也是各醫院在處理的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1095.wav", + "text": "另外第三個就是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1096.wav", + "text": "特管辦法的第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1097.wav", + "text": "那已經是正面表列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1098.wav", + "text": "說這些可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1099.wav", + "text": "的現在第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1100.wav", + "text": "這三個通通要再審查才能再去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1101.wav", + "text": "現在所有的醫院都要關起來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1102.wav", + "text": "病人都沒機會治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1103.wav", + "text": "嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1104.wav", + "text": "我剛剛也有請教衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1105.wav", + "text": "審查辦法有比特管辦法放鬆嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1106.wav", + "text": "\n範圍也沒有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1107.wav", + "text": "只是讓它變成有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1108.wav", + "text": "去做火車頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1109.wav", + "text": "這邊的技術也是要發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1110.wav", + "text": "經濟部這部條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1111.wav", + "text": "有一項叫做再生醫療也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1112.wav", + "text": "寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1113.wav", + "text": "你要發展技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1114.wav", + "text": "要發展製品藥品器材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1115.wav", + "text": "通通要發展啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1116.wav", + "text": "現在慢慢發展得不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1117.wav", + "text": "你把它都不要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1118.wav", + "text": "人民求救" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1119.wav", + "text": "利受到嚴重的損傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1120.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1121.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我簡短針對第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1122.wav", + "text": "衛福部對於第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1123.wav", + "text": "個是針對特殊的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1124.wav", + "text": "少量個案特殊個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1125.wav", + "text": "第二個是特管辦法第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1126.wav", + "text": "第三個是特管辦法第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1127.wav", + "text": "這三個其實那時候沒有講得那麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1128.wav", + "text": "修正文字就是今天時代力量拿出來的修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1129.wav", + "text": "最後大家沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1130.wav", + "text": "我這邊的理由就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1131.wav", + "text": "修正完的這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1132.wav", + "text": "我反而看不懂它到底是在因應什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1133.wav", + "text": "對於我來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1134.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法看出來它這邊提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1135.wav", + "text": "我們讓特管辦法真的入到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1136.wav", + "text": "我們的再生醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1137.wav", + "text": "所以如果以今��衛福部的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1138.wav", + "text": "第9條這邊其實能夠去因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1139.wav", + "text": "對照這三款分別對照的東西的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1140.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1141.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1142.wav", + "text": "我還是要表示一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1143.wav", + "text": "就是第9條的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1144.wav", + "text": "其實是要跟第8條連動來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1145.wav", + "text": "第8條是所有都要經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1146.wav", + "text": "這些核可的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1147.wav", + "text": "第9條是到危及生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1148.wav", + "text": "也就是無藥可醫的這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1149.wav", + "text": "情形如果我們能夠證明它有初步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1150.wav", + "text": "療效的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1151.wav", + "text": "它其實是可以緊急處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1152.wav", + "text": "我跟幾位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1153.wav", + "text": "舉一個簡單的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1154.wav", + "text": "在幾年前日本曾經用這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1155.wav", + "text": "叫平岡麗美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1156.wav", + "text": "的病人平岡麗美有非常嚴重的心肌內膜炎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1157.wav", + "text": "她的心臟衰竭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1158.wav", + "text": "當時在日本研發的心臟層片技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1159.wav", + "text": "其實還沒有拿到藥證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1160.wav", + "text": "還沒有完全做完人體試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1161.wav", + "text": "但是日本為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1162.wav", + "text": "澤芳樹教授可以將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1163.wav", + "text": "心臟層片這樣的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1164.wav", + "text": "移植到平岡麗美小姐身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1165.wav", + "text": "平岡麗美小姐現在非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1166.wav", + "text": "健康地活著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1167.wav", + "text": "而日本也因為這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1168.wav", + "text": "他們的心臟層片技術後來不斷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1169.wav", + "text": "發展到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1170.wav", + "text": "也能夠技轉到臺灣來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1171.wav", + "text": "臺灣有一家生技公司拿到日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1172.wav", + "text": "技轉的技術也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1173.wav", + "text": "研發心臟層片的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1174.wav", + "text": "所以我們要講第9條的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1175.wav", + "text": "基本上就是因為這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1176.wav", + "text": "來設立如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1177.wav", + "text": "它是圖利我可以很清楚地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1178.wav", + "text": "告訴大家它圖利的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1179.wav", + "text": "病人它圖利的只有病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1180.wav", + "text": "只有病人的健康才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1181.wav", + "text": "這個條文最大的受益者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1182.wav", + "text": "非常感謝邱議瑩委員的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1183.wav", + "text": "其實這個部分正是我們這個修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1184.wav", + "text": "所涵蓋的部分就是對於生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1185.wav", + "text": "或者是嚴重失能的疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1186.wav", + "text": "得以開放這樣子的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1187.wav", + "text": "所以我其實非常贊同邱議瑩委員的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1188.wav", + "text": "也就是說應該要用這個方式來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1189.wav", + "text": "另外我覺得需要釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1190.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得現在的爭議就是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1191.wav", + "text": "院版最初的第2款和第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1192.wav", + "text": "是不是符合特管辦法的第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1193.wav", + "text": "以我現在的了解也請衛福部等一下說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1194.wav", + "text": "主要是針對所應該具有的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1195.wav", + "text": "應該要有一些載明的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1196.wav", + "text": "並沒有看到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1197.wav", + "text": "有初步療效就可以來作使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1198.wav", + "text": "或者是有免除許可的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1199.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠就這個部分來做釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1200.wav", + "text": "如何對應到第十三條第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1201.wav", + "text": "說明清楚我覺得我們並不是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1202.wav", + "text": "在今天要卡的特別緊而是我們擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1203.wav", + "text": "在再生醫療法通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1204.wav", + "text": "會讓我們原本的部分有所放鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1205.wav", + "text": "而這個放鬆是大家所擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1206.wav", + "text": "大家其實有一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1207.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是很清楚的就是剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1208.wav", + "text": "假設他是在危及生命或是嚴重失能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1209.wav", + "text": "且沒有適當藥品的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1210.wav", + "text": "我想大家都同意應該要開這個門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1211.wav", + "text": "或是應該要讓它能夠有免經許可的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1212.wav", + "text": "朝野各黨都達到共識的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1213.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就聚焦回來討論第2款和第3款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1214.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1215.wav", + "text": "協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1216.wav", + "text": "剛剛也有講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1217.wav", + "text": "很清楚就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1218.wav", + "text": "修正動議第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1219.wav", + "text": "再配合第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1220.wav", + "text": "走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1221.wav", + "text": "第8條的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1222.wav", + "text": "這樣就不會牴觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1223.wav", + "text": "這個特管辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1224.wav", + "text": "而且比較不會引起民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1225.wav", + "text": "病友的擔憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1226.wav", + "text": "也沒有限制技術的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1227.wav", + "text": "在第一次協商也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1228.wav", + "text": "就是用時力今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1229.wav", + "text": "修正的第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1230.wav", + "text": "再配合第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1231.wav", + "text": "連動的一併看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1232.wav", + "text": "就可以處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1233.wav", + "text": "也沒有特管辦法第十四條的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1234.wav", + "text": "你說特管辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1235.wav", + "text": "這個部分真的是一個大漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1236.wav", + "text": "啊所以總結就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1237.wav", + "text": "用修正的第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1238.wav", + "text": "配合連動第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1239.wav", + "text": "這樣就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1240.wav", + "text": "來走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1241.wav", + "text": "可以來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1242.wav", + "text": "就沒有這個特管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1243.wav", + "text": "會鎖死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1244.wav", + "text": "的技術等等相關的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1245.wav", + "text": "也就是說第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1246.wav", + "text": "不要動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1247.wav", + "text": "等於如果不是危及生命的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1248.wav", + "text": "之下可以走第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1249.wav", + "text": "的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1250.wav", + "text": "也就是沒有鎖死說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1251.wav", + "text": "特管辦法已經開放的技術在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1252.wav", + "text": "我們現在部版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1253.wav", + "text": "或是我們修正的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1254.wav", + "text": "不能走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1255.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1256.wav", + "text": "這樣有共識嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1257.wav", + "text": "沒有共識所以保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1258.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1259.wav", + "text": "再講一下我剛剛講的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1260.wav", + "text": "好嗎我剛剛講的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1261.wav", + "text": "麻煩司長或部長回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1262.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1263.wav", + "text": "請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1264.wav", + "text": "第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1265.wav", + "text": "請司長回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1266.wav", + "text": "大家都講保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1267.wav", + "text": "所以本案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1268.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的對不對好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1269.wav", + "text": "請大家看第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1270.wav", + "text": "十一條有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1271.wav", + "text": "通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1272.wav", + "text": "好那就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1273.wav", + "text": "院長我們有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1274.wav", + "text": "第十一條我們有提修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1275.wav", + "text": "關於第十一條主要還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1276.wav", + "text": "在最後一條那時候衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1277.wav", + "text": "四項的部分有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1278.wav", + "text": "所設的醫療機構或學校法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1279.wav", + "text": "所設的學校如果要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1280.wav", + "text": "設立公司的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1281.wav", + "text": "或是設置藥品公司的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1282.wav", + "text": "因為有其公益性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1283.wav", + "text": "所以必須在這邊做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1284.wav", + "text": "但是我們也想請教的是關於這個把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1285.wav", + "text": "就是所謂的主管機關核准這個核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1286.wav", + "text": "是依照什麼樣的規範或是什麼樣的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1287.wav", + "text": "來釐清大家的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1288.wav", + "text": "因為大家所擔心的就是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1289.wav", + "text": "倫理的問題假設是由醫療法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1290.wav", + "text": "或是學校法人來設立一個公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1291.wav", + "text": "醫療法人之下的醫療機構為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1292.wav", + "text": "遊說或是鼓勵民眾來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1293.wav", + "text": "再生醫療我想這是大家所不樂見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1294.wav", + "text": "\n我還是要再次強調我覺得再生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1295.wav", + "text": "醫療法的推動是大家都支持的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1296.wav", + "text": "但是裡面的嚴格把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1297.wav", + "text": "和必須要做的核准或是審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1298.wav", + "text": "是不能少的所以是不是能夠先釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1299.wav", + "text": "醫療法人所設的機構或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1300.wav", + "text": "學校法人所設的在學校底下如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1301.wav", + "text": "醫藥公司的時候我們的把關機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1302.wav", + "text": "之前也有提到如果它是一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1303.wav", + "text": "公司的設立也應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1304.wav", + "text": "能夠進行把關而不是有所差異的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1305.wav", + "text": "重點還是在於如何把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1306.wav", + "text": "這個醫藥公司所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1307.wav", + "text": "進行的實驗或是進行的藥劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1308.wav", + "text": "藥品是符合大家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1309.wav", + "text": "需求而且是有安全把關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1310.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1311.wav", + "text": "關於第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1312.wav", + "text": "時代力量的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1313.wav", + "text": "裡面並沒有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1314.wav", + "text": "這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1315.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1316.wav", + "text": "的部分所以我們認為要一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1317.wav", + "text": "不論是不是法人所設立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1318.wav", + "text": "只要是再生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1319.wav", + "text": "醫療生技公司應該都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1320.wav", + "text": "一併要做嚴格的把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1321.wav", + "text": "所以並不是只有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1322.wav", + "text": "醫療法人的部分另外開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1323.wav", + "text": "一個不同的路徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1324.wav", + "text": "所謂的開路徑其實是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1325.wav", + "text": "依照公司法去設公司這個都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1326.wav", + "text": "沒有問題不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1327.wav", + "text": "對於醫療法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1328.wav", + "text": "和學校的法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1329.wav", + "text": "來講它要另外去設公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1330.wav", + "text": "的話需要有一些依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1331.wav", + "text": "我並不是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1332.wav", + "text": "有沒有足夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1333.wav", + "text": "另外spinoff去做公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1334.wav", + "text": "但是醫療法人的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1335.wav", + "text": "是不清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1336.wav", + "text": "所以我們才希望在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1337.wav", + "text": "把它寫進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1338.wav", + "text": "我有一點困惑耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1339.wav", + "text": "來跟我們溝通和說明的是這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1340.wav", + "text": "其實都跟原本的是一樣的而現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1341.wav", + "text": "部長是說不知道學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1342.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠有設立這樣子的法規我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1343.wav", + "text": "很奇怪就是衛福部在不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1344.wav", + "text": "場合有不同的解釋這反而讓我覺得有所擔憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1345.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1346.wav", + "text": "我這邊再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1347.wav", + "text": "所謂spinoff出去公司的這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1348.wav", + "text": "是做細胞操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1349.wav", + "text": "而細胞操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1350.wav", + "text": "其實就會回到我們在講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1351.wav", + "text": "在醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1352.wav", + "text": "做所謂的細胞操作的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1353.wav", + "text": "因為它是有病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1354.wav", + "text": "所以才去做這樣的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1355.wav", + "text": "的規範的時候我們這個叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1356.wav", + "text": "做GTP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1357.wav", + "text": "醫院可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1358.wav", + "text": "幫另外一個醫院做可是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1359.wav", + "text": "擔心的是如果當它幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1360.wav", + "text": "的多的時候會不會產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1361.wav", + "text": "上的困擾所以我們才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1362.wav", + "text": "在安全把關的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1363.wav", + "text": "成公司用管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1364.wav", + "text": "實驗室GMP這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1365.wav", + "text": "的實驗室來確保安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1366.wav", + "text": "的就是其實在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1367.wav", + "text": "因為這個通常都是要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1368.wav", + "text": "特殊的技術包括培養皿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1369.wav", + "text": "我不知道它可不可以稱為專利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1370.wav", + "text": "這樣的概念來處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1371.wav", + "text": "也就是為什麼部長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1372.wav", + "text": "出去的一些程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1373.wav", + "text": "在我們這個地方寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1374.wav", + "text": "的話其實是可以保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1375.wav", + "text": "我覺得要把它拆開來一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1376.wav", + "text": "安全的規範一個是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1377.wav", + "text": "這樣子可以鼓勵大家一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1378.wav", + "text": "行政院版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1379.wav", + "text": "第十一條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1380.wav", + "text": "請看第二十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1381.wav", + "text": "第二十七條照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1382.wav", + "text": "版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1383.wav", + "text": "第27條通過保留也要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1384.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1385.wav", + "text": "照行政院版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1386.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1387.wav", + "text": "請看第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1388.wav", + "text": "照行政院版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1389.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1390.wav", + "text": "照行政院版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1391.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1392.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1393.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1394.wav", + "text": "修正動議衛福" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1395.wav", + "text": "衛福部有沒有看到他們的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1396.wav", + "text": "時力的第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1397.wav", + "text": "就是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1398.wav", + "text": "醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1399.wav", + "text": "或保存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1400.wav", + "text": "組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1401.wav", + "text": "細胞組織的來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1402.wav", + "text": "就是以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1403.wav", + "text": "有意思能力之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1404.wav", + "text": "成年��為限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1405.wav", + "text": "但是現在就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1406.wav", + "text": "胎兒無行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1407.wav", + "text": "能力的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1408.wav", + "text": "排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1409.wav", + "text": "院版的第十六條是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1410.wav", + "text": "如果家裡有疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1411.wav", + "text": "的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1412.wav", + "text": "就像電影姊姊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1413.wav", + "text": "未出生前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1414.wav", + "text": "同意以後的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1415.wav", + "text": "可以讓姊姊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1416.wav", + "text": "姊使用醫療姊姊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1417.wav", + "text": "疾病因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1418.wav", + "text": "我們所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1419.wav", + "text": "讓胎兒或無行為能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1420.wav", + "text": "的人可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1421.wav", + "text": "由別人代替他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1422.wav", + "text": "可以當成治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1423.wav", + "text": "修正動議就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1424.wav", + "text": "第1項除胎兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1425.wav", + "text": "無行為能力人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1426.wav", + "text": "第4項我們也有修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1427.wav", + "text": "第十六條照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1428.wav", + "text": "版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1429.wav", + "text": "請衛福部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1430.wav", + "text": "啊我們剛剛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1431.wav", + "text": "修正動議要請衛福部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1432.wav", + "text": "院長會議詢問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1433.wav", + "text": "其實第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1434.wav", + "text": "本來在協商的時候就已經照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1435.wav", + "text": "行政院版通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1436.wav", + "text": "所以它本來就不在我們今天要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1437.wav", + "text": "的法條裡頭了它本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1438.wav", + "text": "已經通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1439.wav", + "text": "依法就可以提出啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1440.wav", + "text": "你尊重一下我的講話好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1441.wav", + "text": "偉大的陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1442.wav", + "text": "我在講話你可以尊重一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1443.wav", + "text": "如果現在又要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1444.wav", + "text": "就是我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1445.wav", + "text": "這整個會議就會一直在那裡無限輪迴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1446.wav", + "text": "的法條又一直回來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1447.wav", + "text": "一直在這裡無限輪迴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1448.wav", + "text": "比較完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1449.wav", + "text": "無行為能力的應該取得法定代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1450.wav", + "text": "監護人的同意嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1451.wav", + "text": "衛福部版本是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1452.wav", + "text": "比較完整嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1453.wav", + "text": "你現在把胎兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1454.wav", + "text": "無行為能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1455.wav", + "text": "這樣以後能不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1456.wav", + "text": "臍帶血幹細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1457.wav", + "text": "這樣以後臍帶血幹細胞能不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1458.wav", + "text": "為什麼你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1459.wav", + "text": "們反對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1460.wav", + "text": "這沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1461.wav", + "text": "當然在議事程序上其實我們本來就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1462.wav", + "text": "提修正動議我想這也是要尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1463.wav", + "text": "各黨團的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1464.wav", + "text": "應該要支持這樣的訂定我們特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1465.wav", + "text": "兒和受宣告輔助之人或無意識能力人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1466.wav", + "text": "人排除的部分會特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1467.wav", + "text": "我們的確希望能夠避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1468.wav", + "text": "道德倫理的風險以及對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1469.wav", + "text": "兒童最佳權益的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1470.wav", + "text": "如果當我們談的是年幼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1471.wav", + "text": "代為決定這樣是一個對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1472.wav", + "text": "嗎又或者是的確發生過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1473.wav", + "text": "的也就是剛才提到的姐姐守護者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1474.wav", + "text": "孩子們其實有表意權但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1475.wav", + "text": "父母卻代為幫他們決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1476.wav", + "text": "donor的情況這是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1477.wav", + "text": "一個合理且合倫理的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1478.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是大家要思考的我剛剛所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1479.wav", + "text": "當孩子他有表達意見的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1480.wav", + "text": "在一個非常不對等的情況包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1481.wav", + "text": "甚至母親懷孕只是為了要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1482.wav", + "text": "救手足之情況下這其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1483.wav", + "text": "是有道德和倫理風險上的考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1484.wav", + "text": "我覺得這部分大家真的要深思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1485.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會提出這樣的修正道德倫理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1486.wav", + "text": "風險是值得爭辯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1487.wav", + "text": "他們有完整的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1488.wav", + "text": "什麼就怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1489.wav", + "text": "如果我的目的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1490.wav", + "text": "就是針對無行為能力的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1491.wav", + "text": "那是不是反而變成我沒有辦法對無行為能力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1492.wav", + "text": "那位當事人取得他的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1493.wav", + "text": "你們結果會不會變成這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1494.wav", + "text": "們處理的是捐贈者來源提供者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1495.wav", + "text": "不是無行為能力人的治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1496.wav", + "text": "不是如果我本身就是無行為能力者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1497.wav", + "text": "我也要治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1498.wav", + "text": "所以我需要拿我這個無行為能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1499.wav", + "text": "因為你們這樣的文字會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1500.wav", + "text": "我連治我自己都不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1501.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1502.wav", + "text": "你知道意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1503.wav", + "text": "因為是顯有益於特定人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1504.wav", + "text": "才可以達到後面的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1505.wav", + "text": "所以如果我本身因為某種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1506.wav", + "text": "而沒有行為能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1507.wav", + "text": "基於醫療需要我拿我的細胞來治療我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1508.wav", + "text": "自己結果因為寫了這個進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1509.wav", + "text": "是不是我就不行治療我自己了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1510.wav", + "text": "我一樣是這個疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1511.wav", + "text": "或是胎盤幹細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1512.wav", + "text": "已經非常非常久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1513.wav", + "text": "條文中有明確的寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1514.wav", + "text": "也就是不是在這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1515.wav", + "text": "而是在後面的條文就有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1516.wav", + "text": "不能為了要做治療就特別去搞一個胚胎出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1517.wav", + "text": "做再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1518.wav", + "text": "規定而且我們也通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1519.wav", + "text": "\n另外我會擔心一件事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1520.wav", + "text": "我們在所謂的胎兒幹細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1521.wav", + "text": "在小朋友剛出生的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1522.wav", + "text": "取他的臍帶血取他的胎盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1523.wav", + "text": "這個過程事實上是不可能取得胎兒同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1524.wav", + "text": "所以如果照這個邏輯來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1525.wav", + "text": "以後我們所有臍帶血幹細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1526.wav", + "text": "是不是統統都不能取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1527.wav", + "text": "因為那是伴隨胎兒出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1528.wav", + "text": "附隨的東西啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1529.wav", + "text": "我想這個條文並不是堅持時代力量黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1530.wav", + "text": "比如說剛才鄭運鵬委員的說法其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1531.wav", + "text": "我覺得自體當然沒有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1532.wav", + "text": "我們現在比較顧及的是剛才提到異體的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1533.wav", + "text": "他是一個沒有辦法自己作表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1534.wav", + "text": "又或者是在一個權利和表達能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1535.wav", + "text": "不對等的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1536.wav", + "text": "應該都還是以自體做處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1537.wav", + "text": "乙型地中海型貧血是用異體做治療的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1538.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這部分應該要有幾個層次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1539.wav", + "text": "黨團的版本一個字都不能調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1540.wav", + "text": "而是我們應該要依照不同的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1541.wav", + "text": "我們剛才所提的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1542.wav", + "text": "你們是不讓他們處理不是風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1543.wav", + "text": "陳委員你講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1544.wav", + "text": "講完就照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1545.wav", + "text": "院長不是這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1546.wav", + "text": "無行為能力的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1547.wav", + "text": "我們排除自體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1548.wav", + "text": "這個部分就是非自體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1549.wav", + "text": "無行為能力的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1550.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1551.wav", + "text": "就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1552.wav", + "text": "胎兒或者是嬰兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1553.wav", + "text": "父母不要幫他決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1554.wav", + "text": "我們這個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1555.wav", + "text": "一個很重要的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1556.wav", + "text": "我們不要幫他決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1557.wav", + "text": "他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1558.wav", + "text": "血液或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1559.wav", + "text": "他未來的細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1560.wav", + "text": "是可以給別人用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1561.wav", + "text": "這個就先把它排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1562.wav", + "text": "嘛這個就是有所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1563.wav", + "text": "倫理和道德的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1564.wav", + "text": "排除自體非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1565.wav", + "text": "無行為能力人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1566.wav", + "text": "這個部分在第1項我們把它納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1567.wav", + "text": "請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1568.wav", + "text": "我們不要去幫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1569.wav", + "text": "還沒有出生或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1570.wav", + "text": "他沒有辦法自己決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1571.wav", + "text": "我們就去幫他去決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1572.wav", + "text": "他的血液細胞是可以來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1573.wav", + "text": "這樣子的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1574.wav", + "text": "已經發展到這個地步不會把人當人放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1575.wav", + "text": "在那邊沒事去拿細胞來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1576.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1577.wav", + "text": "病要用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1578.wav", + "text": "沒有等他長大同意以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1579.wav", + "text": "嘛不要他還沒長大就幫他決定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1580.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1581.wav", + "text": "一協商通過條文第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1582.wav", + "text": "第5條第十九條第二十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1583.wav", + "text": "第二十八條如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1584.wav", + "text": "\n二照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1585.wav", + "text": "第3條第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1586.wav", + "text": "\n三保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1587.wav", + "text": "第3條第9條第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1588.wav", + "text": "第十六條第二十七條第二十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1589.wav", + "text": "第三十一條第三十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1590.wav", + "text": "\n四不予採納委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1591.wav", + "text": "蘇巧慧等16人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1592.wav", + "text": "第六章章名時代力量黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1593.wav", + "text": "團提案第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1594.wav", + "text": "其餘均照審查會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1595.wav", + "text": "結果通過\n六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1596.wav", + "text": "協商通過部分宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1597.wav", + "text": "後均予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1598.wav", + "text": "保留部分均暫保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1599.wav", + "text": "保留部分院會進行處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1600.wav", + "text": "由各黨團推派1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1601.wav", + "text": "依時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1602.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1603.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1604.wav", + "text": "黨團順序輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1605.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1606.wav", + "text": "再生醫療製劑條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1607.wav", + "text": "第3條的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1608.wav", + "text": "那時候也保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1609.wav", + "text": "現在才要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1610.wav", + "text": "好各位一邊簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1611.wav", + "text": "名我來向大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1612.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1613.wav", + "text": "再生醫療製劑條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1614.wav", + "text": "等案本案由於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1615.wav", + "text": "社會福利及衛生環境委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1616.wav", + "text": "召委吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1617.wav", + "text": "於4月21日召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1618.wav", + "text": "黨團協商時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1619.wav", + "text": "所有保留條文均獲得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1620.wav", + "text": "協商共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1621.wav", + "text": "因此本席徵詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1622.wav", + "text": "各位委員是否同意就依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1623.wav", + "text": "4月21日之協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1624.wav", + "text": "結論通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1625.wav", + "text": "有保留啊第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1626.wav", + "text": "有保留啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1627.wav", + "text": "這資料給我們看啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1628.wav", + "text": "資料在哪裡我們沒看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1629.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團對第3條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1630.wav", + "text": "說明欄有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1631.wav", + "text": "我們要看院版的說明在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1632.wav", + "text": "現在要討論啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1633.wav", + "text": "只有說明欄很少針對說明欄保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1634.wav", + "text": "給我們看一下啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1635.wav", + "text": "院版在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1636.wav", + "text": "院版的資料在哪裡衛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1637.wav", + "text": "福部要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1638.wav", + "text": "說明一下第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1639.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1640.wav", + "text": "報告行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1641.wav", + "text": "是再生醫療製劑之定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1642.wav", + "text": "又再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1643.wav", + "text": "製劑屬藥事法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1644.wav", + "text": "第6條規定之藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1645.wav", + "text": "這樣就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1646.wav", + "text": "商品化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1647.wav", + "text": "規格化製程加工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1648.wav", + "text": "且一致化之藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1649.wav", + "text": "不包括再生醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1650.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1651.wav", + "text": "我還沒講完好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1652.wav", + "text": "沒關係你繼續講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1653.wav", + "text": "請大家看時代力量的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1654.wav", + "text": "技術都不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1655.wav", + "text": "我要嚴重抗議衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1656.wav", + "text": "故意不把製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1657.wav", + "text": "跟技術講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1658.wav", + "text": "問題大家對技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1659.wav", + "text": "跟製劑都不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1660.wav", + "text": "你們到底在幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1661.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1662.wav", + "text": "以前協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1663.wav", + "text": "放進來現在又拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1664.wav", + "text": "當然有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1665.wav", + "text": "技術是什麼都寫不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1666.wav", + "text": "為什麼不講清楚你們在怕什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1667.wav", + "text": "製劑是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1668.wav", + "text": "商品化規格化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1669.wav", + "text": "製程加工達標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1670.wav", + "text": "之一致化藥品為什麼不講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1671.wav", + "text": "好啦第3條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1672.wav", + "text": "為什麼不寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1673.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1674.wav", + "text": "一第1條修正通過如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1675.wav", + "text": "第1條為確保再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1676.wav", + "text": "製劑之安全品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1677.wav", + "text": "及有效性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1678.wav", + "text": "維護病人權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1679.wav", + "text": "特制定本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1680.wav", + "text": "本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1681.wav", + "text": "未規定者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1682.wav", + "text": "者依藥事法及其他相關法律之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1683.wav", + "text": "(本條立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1684.wav", + "text": "與行政院提案同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1685.wav", + "text": ")二照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1686.wav", + "text": "第9條第21條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1687.wav", + "text": "三保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1688.wav", + "text": "四通過附帶決議2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1689.wav", + "text": "如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1690.wav", + "text": "五其餘均照審查會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1691.wav", + "text": "結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1692.wav", + "text": "本案院會進行處理時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1693.wav", + "text": "協商通過部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1694.wav", + "text": "宣讀後均予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1695.wav", + "text": "保留部分均暫保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1696.wav", + "text": "保留部分院會進行處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1697.wav", + "text": "由各黨團推派1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1698.wav", + "text": "依時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1699.wav", + "text": "黨團台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1700.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1701.wav", + "text": "順序輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1702.wav", + "text": "每人發言時間為3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1703.wav", + "text": "發言完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1704.wav", + "text": "各該保留條文均不再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1705.wav", + "text": "並依上開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1706.wav", + "text": "黨團順序進行各保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1707.wav", + "text": "條文黨團版本之處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1708.wav", + "text": "礦業法擇期再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1709.wav", + "text": "講文創好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1710.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1711.wav", + "text": "文創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1712.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1713.wav", + "text": "來講文創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1714.wav", + "text": "文創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1715.wav", + "text": "現在就進行文化創意產業發展法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1716.wav", + "text": "文化創意產業發展法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1717.wav", + "text": "查結果保留第10條之1及第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1718.wav", + "text": "共2條另保留附帶決議7案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1719.wav", + "text": "召集委員范雲針對行政院函請審議文化創意產業發展法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1720.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案案等27案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1721.wav", + "text": "業已於112年5月4日進行黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1722.wav", + "text": "三協商重點保留條文第10條之1及第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1723.wav", + "text": "先看第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1724.wav", + "text": "再來就看第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1725.wav", + "text": "首先介紹文化部部長史哲先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1726.wav", + "text": "再來是財政部政務次長李慶華女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1727.wav", + "text": "我們就介紹到此\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1728.wav", + "text": "第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1729.wav", + "text": "這個部分的要旨是黃牛票的遏止機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1730.wav", + "text": "其爭點在於是不是要提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1731.wav", + "text": "罰鍰倍數刑度以及訂定檢舉獎勵辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1732.wav", + "text": "支持行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1733.wav", + "text": "我想這個案子大家應該很熟悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1734.wav", + "text": "就是近來疫情之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1735.wav", + "text": "演唱會大爆發以後所產生的黃牛的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1736.wav", + "text": "就是針對演唱會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1737.wav", + "text": "增訂第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1738.wav", + "text": "罰鍰為票面金額的十倍到五十倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1739.wav", + "text": "如果是運用機器碼以虛偽方式來搶票的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1740.wav", + "text": "我們這次是處刑罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1741.wav", + "text": "罰─三年以下有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1742.wav", + "text": "或併科新臺幣三百萬元以下罰金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1743.wav", + "text": "但是我必須說這個罰鍰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1744.wav", + "text": "的就是十到五十倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1745.wav", + "text": "刑責的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1746.wav", + "text": "其實也是相當高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1747.wav", + "text": "已經從一年提高到三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1748.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1749.wav", + "text": "請王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1750.wav", + "text": "我想表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1751.wav", + "text": "其實在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1752.wav", + "text": "是照吳思瑤委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1753.wav", + "text": "應該是國民黨沒有委員出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1754.wav", + "text": "其實都已經有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1755.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要回到委員會的協商版本來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1756.wav", + "text": "而不要再回到最初的行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1757.wav", + "text": "因為這其實已經經過多次討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1758.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1759.wav", + "text": "同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1760.wav", + "text": "大家同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1761.wav", + "text": "照委員會協商版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1762.wav", + "text": "委員會協商版本的內容是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1763.wav", + "text": "和行政院的版本有沒有差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1764.wav", + "text": "從只有地方政府變成也有中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1765.wav", + "text": "對於委員會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1766.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1767.wav", + "text": "第一案第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1768.wav", + "text": "1就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1769.wav", + "text": "\n請看第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1770.wav", + "text": "第十二條的要旨是有關政府協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1771.wav", + "text": "和獎補助事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1772.wav", + "text": "爭點是票券" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1773.wav", + "text": "販售是否應採實名制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1774.wav", + "text": "這個部分誰要來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1775.wav", + "text": "我來幫忙解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1776.wav", + "text": "希望能夠推動實名制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1777.wav", + "text": "也有表達他們未來會積極推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1778.wav", + "text": "可是希望不要放在法條中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1779.wav", + "text": "因為放在法條中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1780.wav", + "text": "文化部會有一些困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1781.wav", + "text": "就變得好像一定要立刻做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1782.wav", + "text": "應該是王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1783.wav", + "text": "所以就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1784.wav", + "text": "我就幫忙說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1785.wav", + "text": "不是嗎OK那講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1786.wav", + "text": "好那就請王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1787.wav", + "text": "不好意思我幫召委補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1788.wav", + "text": "召委可能誤會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1789.wav", + "text": "\n當時在第十二條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1790.wav", + "text": "其實我們一開始是有堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1791.wav", + "text": "然後吳思瑤委員也有提出修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1792.wav", + "text": "後來一樣是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1793.wav", + "text": "照吳思瑤委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1794.wav", + "text": "修正之後大家沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1795.wav", + "text": "但是當時其實文化部有承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1796.wav", + "text": "立法說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1797.wav", + "text": "把實名制三個字放進去這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1798.wav", + "text": "就可以完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1799.wav", + "text": "這是第一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1800.wav", + "text": "第二是本文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1801.wav", + "text": "其實是沒有疑慮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1802.wav", + "text": "是因為後來國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1803.wav", + "text": "沒有簽協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1804.wav", + "text": "\n我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1805.wav", + "text": "我們收歛一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1806.wav", + "text": "是不是修正文字讓大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1807.wav", + "text": "如同委員會上的協商結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1808.wav", + "text": "就是有把實名制這幾個字放進去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1809.wav", + "text": "就照委員會的共識通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1810.wav", + "text": "這樣是不是比較簡單一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1811.wav", + "text": "當時的協調是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1812.wav", + "text": "第一個我們在第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1813.wav", + "text": "增加第二十項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1814.wav", + "text": "維護文化創意產業票券市場價格及交易秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1815.wav", + "text": "不要把實名制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1816.wav", + "text": "放在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1817.wav", + "text": "而是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1818.wav", + "text": "我記得是說附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1819.wav", + "text": "對是放在附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1820.wav", + "text": "我的紀錄是附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1821.wav", + "text": "所以想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1822.wav", + "text": "法條文字沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1823.wav", + "text": "然後要放在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1824.wav", + "text": "或是附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1825.wav", + "text": "是說要經過討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1826.wav", + "text": "就是你們帶回去思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1827.wav", + "text": "我們就放在附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1828.wav", + "text": "所以附帶決議在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1829.wav", + "text": "是釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1830.wav", + "text": "啦就是依照共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1831.wav", + "text": "應該就沒有問題沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1832.wav", + "text": "有講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1833.wav", + "text": "到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1834.wav", + "text": "所以文化部的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1835.wav", + "text": "是要放在附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1836.wav", + "text": "第一個實名制可能短期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1837.wav", + "text": "內沒有那麼快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1838.wav", + "text": "所以造成擾民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1839.wav", + "text": "啦很多東西要實名制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1840.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1841.wav", + "text": "造成比賽都很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1842.wav", + "text": "所以我們不要層意太高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1843.wav", + "text": "啦已經在抓黃牛就夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1844.wav", + "text": "而且課予刑責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1845.wav", + "text": "了所以有關實名制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1846.wav", + "text": "以後再談好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1847.wav", + "text": "我們當初就是因為這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1848.wav", + "text": "所以其實已經有討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1849.wav", + "text": "放在第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1850.wav", + "text": "就是只有鼓勵補助獎勵的形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1851.wav", + "text": "也照這個版本通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1852.wav", + "text": "要不要放在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1853.wav", + "text": "或是附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1854.wav", + "text": "但是其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1855.wav", + "text": "自己在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1856.wav", + "text": "已經提到第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1857.wav", + "text": "是不是就照這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1858.wav", + "text": "因為這是文化部提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1859.wav", + "text": "立法說明怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1860.wav", + "text": "主管機關依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1861.wav", + "text": "依此獎勵補助或行政協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1862.wav", + "text": "推動藝文表演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1863.wav", + "text": "票券正常流通及維護市場交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1864.wav", + "text": "秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1865.wav", + "text": "以有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1866.wav", + "text": "遏止黃牛票券氾濫問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1867.wav", + "text": "這個條文你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1868.wav", + "text": "就有這些精神了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1869.wav", + "text": "立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1870.wav", + "text": "已經有納入這個精神了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1871.wav", + "text": "看王婉諭委員這邊是不是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1872.wav", + "text": "可以立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1873.wav", + "text": "已經把要推動實名制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1874.wav", + "text": "因為其實滿多委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1875.wav", + "text": "希望能夠逐步推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1876.wav", + "text": "文化部如果在立法說明中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1877.wav", + "text": "可以把這個精神放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1878.wav", + "text": "其實大家就可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1879.wav", + "text": "我只想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1880.wav", + "text": "有實名制這幾個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1881.wav", + "text": "出現在立法說明裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1882.wav", + "text": "裡我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1883.wav", + "text": "文化部評估之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1884.wav", + "text": "覺得不適宜的部分是在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1885.wav", + "text": "因為它只是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1886.wav", + "text": "立法說明的部分而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1887.wav", + "text": "我坦白跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1888.wav", + "text": "因為這個售票市場涉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1889.wav", + "text": "涉及層面很廣大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1890.wav", + "text": "有部分的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1891.wav", + "text": "其實是把實名制當成萬靈丹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1892.wav", + "text": "但是實名制事實上是對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1893.wav", + "text": "絕大多數的觀眾也產生了困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1894.wav", + "text": "立法修法的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1895.wav", + "text": "但是不要在說明文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1896.wav", + "text": "或者是現行條文上加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1897.wav", + "text": "是衝突的焦點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1898.wav", + "text": "一定會造成衝突的焦點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1899.wav", + "text": "你到現場的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1900.wav", + "text": "如何證明你是自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1901.wav", + "text": "這樣很麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1902.wav", + "text": "那就用附帶決議處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1903.wav", + "text": "不是用附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1904.wav", + "text": "你要在說明欄處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1905.wav", + "text": "現在照你這樣是放在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1906.wav", + "text": "你要同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1907.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1908.wav", + "text": "好如果同意那就這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1909.wav", + "text": "委員會已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1910.wav", + "text": "27條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1911.wav", + "text": "投資抵減的實施年限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1912.wav", + "text": "行政院的版本是實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1913.wav", + "text": "行政院得視實際情況延長一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1914.wav", + "text": "也就是十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1915.wav", + "text": "嘛我主張恢復行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1916.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1917.wav", + "text": "延長成二十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1918.wav", + "text": "沒有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1919.wav", + "text": "沒有二十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1920.wav", + "text": "五年延五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1921.wav", + "text": "你現在延五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1922.wav", + "text": "這是行政院版本對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1923.wav", + "text": "跟主席和各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1924.wav", + "text": "我們原來院版的版本是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1925.wav", + "text": "實施期限五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1926.wav", + "text": "然後可以報行政院延長一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1927.wav", + "text": "所以是五加所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1928.wav", + "text": "樣不延長十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1929.wav", + "text": "OK那樣可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1930.wav", + "text": "投資抵減一定有年限的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1931.wav", + "text": "好因為過去最長都是十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1932.wav", + "text": "所以最長還是十年對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1933.wav", + "text": "10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1934.wav", + "text": "第27條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1935.wav", + "text": "第27條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1936.wav", + "text": "跟第十二條等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1937.wav", + "text": "我們立法說明都有酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1938.wav", + "text": "酌予文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1939.wav", + "text": "請大家確認一下謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1940.wav", + "text": "的立法說明也有文字補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1941.wav", + "text": "所以有增加立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1942.wav", + "text": "第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1943.wav", + "text": "你增加後面的第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1944.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1945.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1946.wav", + "text": "就是要說明有關檢舉獎金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1947.wav", + "text": "入法以及立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1948.wav", + "text": "OK要保密嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1949.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1950.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1951.wav", + "text": "還有第幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1952.wav", + "text": "27條之1是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1953.wav", + "text": "對因為剛剛只有講到十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1954.wav", + "text": "立法說明也有做一些微調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1955.wav", + "text": "立法說明就寫十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1956.wav", + "text": "我看你第7款寫十年嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1957.wav", + "text": "對我說立法說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1958.wav", + "text": "也隨之變更為十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1959.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1960.wav", + "text": "第3條就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1961.wav", + "text": "我宣讀一下協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1962.wav", + "text": "\n協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1963.wav", + "text": "一協商通過條文第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1964.wav", + "text": "第十二條如後附" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1965.wav", + "text": "\n二原審查會保留附帶決議7案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1966.wav", + "text": "理\n三其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1967.wav", + "text": "\n四檢附立法說明一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1968.wav", + "text": "附帶決議有7項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1969.wav", + "text": "院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1970.wav", + "text": "我剛剛沒有聽得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1971.wav", + "text": "請問附帶決議是已經處理完了保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1972.wav", + "text": "留送院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1973.wav", + "text": "可是委員會已經同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1974.wav", + "text": "附帶決議你們已經同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1975.wav", + "text": "附帶決議原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1976.wav", + "text": "是國民黨沒簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1977.wav", + "text": "原則上就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1978.wav", + "text": "是統一把它弄清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1979.wav", + "text": "院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1980.wav", + "text": "委員會都已經通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1981.wav", + "text": "為什麼還要送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1982.wav", + "text": "今天要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1983.wav", + "text": "照委員會的審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1984.wav", + "text": "國民黨會反對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1985.wav", + "text": "請國民黨簽一簽不就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1986.wav", + "text": "委員會沒同意的就是沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1987.wav", + "text": "但委員會有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1988.wav", + "text": "簽就是沒不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1989.wav", + "text": "表決的時候還會再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1990.wav", + "text": "都會一併處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1991.wav", + "text": "沒有簽就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1992.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1993.wav", + "text": "感恩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1994.wav", + "text": "公視法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1995.wav", + "text": "協商得怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1996.wav", + "text": "委員會協商結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1997.wav", + "text": "國民黨的委員沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1998.wav", + "text": "不是我是說公視法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/1999.wav", + "text": "我來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2000.wav", + "text": "不然來這裡談好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2001.wav", + "text": "直接到這裡談嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2002.wav", + "text": "視法有沒有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2003.wav", + "text": "應該沒什麼爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2004.wav", + "text": "你當然都講沒爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2005.wav", + "text": "你一簽就沒爭議就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2006.wav", + "text": "好不行的話我們就再排來這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2007.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2008.wav", + "text": "我想確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2009.wav", + "text": "所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2010.wav", + "text": "超過票面價格或販售的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2011.wav", + "text": "其實是含上架就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2012.wav", + "text": "當時法務部也同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2013.wav", + "text": "現在立法說明沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2014.wav", + "text": "為後來決定不要放嗎還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2015.wav", + "text": "要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2016.wav", + "text": "上架這件事情列為販售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2017.wav", + "text": "這件事情要在立法說明說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2018.wav", + "text": "以解決大家的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2019.wav", + "text": "放在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2020.wav", + "text": "販售就包含上架的各種形態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2021.wav", + "text": "是當時是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2022.wav", + "text": "有疑慮所以法務部是說就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2023.wav", + "text": "它放在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2024.wav", + "text": "沒有上架怎麼販售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2025.wav", + "text": "應該是這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2026.wav", + "text": "上架算不算在罰的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2027.wav", + "text": "內當時對此是有疑慮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2028.wav", + "text": "所以法務部說用立法說明來處理就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2029.wav", + "text": "現在我想請教的是法務部後來是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2030.wav", + "text": "不同意放立法說明我只是想要釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2031.wav", + "text": "所以就沒有另外再寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2032.wav", + "text": "就含各種型態包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2033.wav", + "text": "上架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2034.wav", + "text": "不用放立法說明也沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2035.wav", + "text": "是不是你們再溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2036.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2037.wav", + "text": "那麼會議就到此了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2038.wav", + "text": "到底算不算販售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2039.wav", + "text": "當時在委員會曾經過一番討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2040.wav", + "text": "大家也都同意上架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2041.wav", + "text": "屬於販售法務部也說這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2042.wav", + "text": "會放在立法說明避免大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2043.wav", + "text": "有這樣的疑慮故而當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2044.wav", + "text": "法務部承諾會放在立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2045.wav", + "text": "說明但現在並沒有在立法說明看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2046.wav", + "text": "又或者是文化部的意見不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2047.wav", + "text": "以致跟審查會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2048.wav", + "text": "跟我們在委員會審查的結果不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2049.wav", + "text": "這是我想釐清的部分畢竟當時有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2050.wav", + "text": "要放立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2051.wav", + "text": "我們確實有想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2052.wav", + "text": "王委員提出這問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2053.wav", + "text": "在立法理由裡說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2054.wav", + "text": "可以更清晰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2055.wav", + "text": "只是後來我們並沒有收到文化部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2056.wav", + "text": "任何的立法理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2057.wav", + "text": "想就這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2058.wav", + "text": "或什麼的或許可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2059.wav", + "text": "再清晰一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2060.wav", + "text": "一種行為一發生當然可以罰但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2061.wav", + "text": "文意解釋沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2062.wav", + "text": "這不用再另外規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2063.wav", + "text": "一旦遂行就是一種犯罪行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2064.wav", + "text": "當時有說要放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2065.wav", + "text": "也就是行政機關沒有想要認真處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2066.wav", + "text": "現在是文化部不給他們放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2067.wav", + "text": "沒有這問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2068.wav", + "text": "e法務部要罰人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2069.wav", + "text": "只要行為一發生就可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2070.wav", + "text": "一上架就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2071.wav", + "text": "就文意解釋來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2072.wav", + "text": "他放在口袋裡就不能罰他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15009/2073.wav", + "text": "好謝謝大家散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15000/0.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案這兩部法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15000/1.wav", + "text": "讓這個共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/0.wav", + "text": "我們今天進行總統副總統選舉罷免法及公職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1.wav", + "text": "剩下很少條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/2.wav", + "text": "文需要協商希望今天可以達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/3.wav", + "text": "兩部法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/4.wav", + "text": "的協商這幾十年才修一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/5.wav", + "text": "3月15日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/6.wav", + "text": "3月16日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/7.wav", + "text": "3月27日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/8.wav", + "text": "3月29日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/9.wav", + "text": "竣有關保留的幾條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/10.wav", + "text": "希望今天再占用大家一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/11.wav", + "text": "總統副總統選舉罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/12.wav", + "text": "增訂第47條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/13.wav", + "text": "第9條及第96條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/14.wav", + "text": "公職人員選舉罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/15.wav", + "text": "保留條文第26條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/16.wav", + "text": "增訂第51條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/17.wav", + "text": "第104條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/18.wav", + "text": "橫的這本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/19.wav", + "text": "的先從總統副總統選舉罷免法修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/20.wav", + "text": "大家看第9頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/21.wav", + "text": "這個就是深偽條款的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/22.wav", + "text": "造謠的情況比較嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/23.wav", + "text": "因為它有惡假害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/24.wav", + "text": "嘛所以基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/25.wav", + "text": "我們認為深偽部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/26.wav", + "text": "應該特別再加重處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/27.wav", + "text": "會不會有數位仲介法的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/28.wav", + "text": "其實不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/29.wav", + "text": "啦因為深偽條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/30.wav", + "text": "並沒有賦予行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/31.wav", + "text": "任何下架或移除的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/32.wav", + "text": "力這個都是必須要由當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/33.wav", + "text": "自己來發動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/34.wav", + "text": "所以它不會有這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/35.wav", + "text": "同時這中間會經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/36.wav", + "text": "檢察機關的鑑識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/37.wav", + "text": "所以基本上比較不會有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/38.wav", + "text": "希望委員會能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/39.wav", + "text": "各位委員有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/40.wav", + "text": "也有他們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/41.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/42.wav", + "text": "第9頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/43.wav", + "text": "第47條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/44.wav", + "text": "是深偽條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/45.wav", + "text": "那就照行政院提案條文通過\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/46.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/47.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/48.wav", + "text": "這兩條應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/49.wav", + "text": "同樣是與這一條連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/50.wav", + "text": "連動的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/51.wav", + "text": "事實上是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/52.wav", + "text": "連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/53.wav", + "text": "所以這兩條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/54.wav", + "text": "一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/55.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/56.wav", + "text": "就是連動處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/57.wav", + "text": "因為這是罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/58.wav", + "text": "則的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/59.wav", + "text": "意圖營利要罰多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/60.wav", + "text": "沒意見我們就照這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/61.wav", + "text": "版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/62.wav", + "text": "一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/63.wav", + "text": "但是我們有修正過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/64.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/65.wav", + "text": "保留條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/66.wav", + "text": "是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/67.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/68.wav", + "text": "我們修正後的條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/69.wav", + "text": "上是總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/70.wav", + "text": "副總統選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/71.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/72.wav", + "text": "所以這部法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/73.wav", + "text": "就完整通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/74.wav", + "text": "論那就送院會\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/75.wav", + "text": "我們保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/76.wav", + "text": "4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/77.wav", + "text": "第26條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/78.wav", + "text": "可能大家會討論比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/79.wav", + "text": "從剛剛那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/80.wav", + "text": "相關的深偽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/81.wav", + "text": "深偽條款來做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/82.wav", + "text": "這樣比較有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/83.wav", + "text": "51條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/84.wav", + "text": "其實它跟總統副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/85.wav", + "text": "也是深偽條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/86.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有什麼特別意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/87.wav", + "text": "我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/88.wav", + "text": "想跟大家確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/89.wav", + "text": "是跟總統選罷法一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/90.wav", + "text": "是有電磁紀錄的那個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/91.wav", + "text": "還是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/92.wav", + "text": "因為後面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/93.wav", + "text": "又有電磁紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/94.wav", + "text": "那是下一條在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/95.wav", + "text": "再下一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/96.wav", + "text": "文那是罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/97.wav", + "text": "只是在說深偽的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/98.wav", + "text": "司長這樣對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/99.wav", + "text": "所以第51條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/100.wav", + "text": "就照行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/101.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/102.wav", + "text": "對如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/103.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有意見就通過\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/104.wav", + "text": "第104條是罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/105.wav", + "text": "這個罰則就是剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/106.wav", + "text": "副主委所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/107.wav", + "text": "這個電磁紀錄是我們修正過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/108.wav", + "text": "112年4月13日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/109.wav", + "text": "各位委員有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/110.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/111.wav", + "text": "見這一條就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/112.wav", + "text": "這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/113.wav", + "text": "一百十條事實上也是連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/114.wav", + "text": "差別在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/115.wav", + "text": "第5頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/116.wav", + "text": "剛剛已經說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/117.wav", + "text": "就是照修正後的那個版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/118.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/119.wav", + "text": "我們當初保留的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/120.wav", + "text": "第三項跟第五項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/121.wav", + "text": "配合增列媒體未留下紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/122.wav", + "text": "我們那時候事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/123.wav", + "text": "還有項次也要修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/124.wav", + "text": "第8項和第9項是配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/125.wav", + "text": "是配合深偽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/126.wav", + "text": "科長說明第一百" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/127.wav", + "text": "十條主要是第三項第五項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/128.wav", + "text": "這個部分是配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/129.wav", + "text": "剛才已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/130.wav", + "text": "審竣的第五十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/131.wav", + "text": "之三有關深偽移除機制的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/132.wav", + "text": "罰則部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/133.wav", + "text": "這個條文的第八項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/134.wav", + "text": "第九項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/135.wav", + "text": "我們就配合修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/136.wav", + "text": "原本都是依第五項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/137.wav", + "text": "處罰的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/138.wav", + "text": "就照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/139.wav", + "text": "第三項第五項是連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/140.wav", + "text": "我們就讓它通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/141.wav", + "text": "項次的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/142.wav", + "text": "我們就把它改成第六項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/143.wav", + "text": "援引的處罰項次改為第六項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/144.wav", + "text": "所以這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/145.wav", + "text": "\n接著我們回頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/146.wav", + "text": "選罷法第51條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/147.wav", + "text": "要不要現在一起修先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/148.wav", + "text": "然後我們再來討論再修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/149.wav", + "text": "先處理保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/150.wav", + "text": "或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/151.wav", + "text": "比較多的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/152.wav", + "text": "你們要修的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/153.wav", + "text": "要討論比較久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/154.wav", + "text": "你們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/155.wav", + "text": "我們就先把它修一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/156.wav", + "text": "因為後面會討論比較久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/157.wav", + "text": "第26條會討論比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/158.wav", + "text": "你很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/159.wav", + "text": "對我們有準備現在請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/160.wav", + "text": "文字發給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/161.wav", + "text": "我們大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/162.wav", + "text": "因為我們修了這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/163.wav", + "text": "一個修了74條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/164.wav", + "text": "一個修了66條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/165.wav", + "text": "有些文字項次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/166.wav", + "text": "項次會稍微改動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/167.wav", + "text": "所以要把整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/168.wav", + "text": "部法律整個看過一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/169.wav", + "text": "我們現在只剩第26條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/170.wav", + "text": "剩下大部分都是已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/171.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/172.wav", + "text": "他們有詳細的把整部法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/173.wav", + "text": "看了一遍看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/174.wav", + "text": "前後要一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/175.wav", + "text": "就是這一類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/176.wav", + "text": "問題大家現在手上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/177.wav", + "text": "再修正條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/178.wav", + "text": "就是有一些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/179.wav", + "text": "要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/180.wav", + "text": "向委員報告一下大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/181.wav", + "text": "大家手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/182.wav", + "text": "賴委員手上有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/183.wav", + "text": "邱委員已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/184.wav", + "text": "陳琬惠委員有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/185.wav", + "text": "第32條的再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/186.wav", + "text": "是因為上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/187.wav", + "text": "我們在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/188.wav", + "text": "有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/189.wav", + "text": "保證金發還的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/190.wav", + "text": "原本我們想把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/191.wav", + "text": "選舉人總數改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/192.wav", + "text": "可能不太好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/193.wav", + "text": "還是回復到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/194.wav", + "text": "原來的選舉人總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/195.wav", + "text": "作為發還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/196.wav", + "text": "所以我們把它改回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/197.wav", + "text": "但是改回來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/198.wav", + "text": "所以不要提高門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/199.wav", + "text": "對改回來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/200.wav", + "text": "如果是改為選舉人總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/201.wav", + "text": "依照現行的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/202.wav", + "text": "應該要先扣除逕遷戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/203.wav", + "text": "來算選舉人總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/204.wav", + "text": "否則對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/205.wav", + "text": "基層的里長選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/206.wav", + "text": "問題會非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/207.wav", + "text": "很多人的戶籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/208.wav", + "text": "都直接遷到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/209.wav", + "text": "戶政事務所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/210.wav", + "text": "這種人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/211.wav", + "text": "如果不先扣掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/212.wav", + "text": "可能會造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/213.wav", + "text": "基層的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/214.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法拿回保證金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/215.wav", + "text": "對保證金就拿不回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/216.wav", + "text": "他已經當選都沒辦法拿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/217.wav", + "text": "遷移不明的都被遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/218.wav", + "text": "先把那個部分扣掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/219.wav", + "text": "再來算選舉人總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/220.wav", + "text": "OK這個有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/221.wav", + "text": "提及第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/222.wav", + "text": "移到第6項前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/223.wav", + "text": "嘛好第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/224.wav", + "text": "修正為這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/225.wav", + "text": "可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/226.wav", + "text": "比較符合實情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/227.wav", + "text": "也不要提高門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/228.wav", + "text": "比如說總統選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/229.wav", + "text": "跟里長選舉還是有一些不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/230.wav", + "text": "不能造成他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/231.wav", + "text": "他的困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/232.wav", + "text": "內政部建議再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/233.wav", + "text": "條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/234.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/235.wav", + "text": "主要是我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/236.wav", + "text": "修正上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/237.wav", + "text": "修正意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/238.wav", + "text": "最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/239.wav", + "text": "選舉公報應於投票日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/240.wav", + "text": "二日前送達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/241.wav", + "text": "選舉區內各戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/242.wav", + "text": "並應於選舉委員會網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/243.wav", + "text": "或以其他適當方式公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/244.wav", + "text": "修正跟今天提供之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/245.wav", + "text": "字略有差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/246.wav", + "text": "原來��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/247.wav", + "text": "送達選舉區內各戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/248.wav", + "text": "並張貼適當地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/249.wav", + "text": "就是資訊要公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/250.wav", + "text": "還要再上網就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/251.wav", + "text": "增加上網公告這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/252.wav", + "text": "我們配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/253.wav", + "text": "對所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/254.wav", + "text": "我們建議文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/255.wav", + "text": "再把它配合其他條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/256.wav", + "text": "其他條文因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/257.wav", + "text": "沒有寫到中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/258.wav", + "text": "都是寫選舉委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/259.wav", + "text": "同一條也都是寫選舉委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/260.wav", + "text": "所以我們最後那個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/261.wav", + "text": "希望改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/262.wav", + "text": "並應於選舉委員會網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/263.wav", + "text": "或以其他適當方式公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/264.wav", + "text": "你要用或以其他方式嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/265.wav", + "text": "其他適當方式公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/266.wav", + "text": "用網站不也挺好的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/267.wav", + "text": "可以包括張貼適當地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/268.wav", + "text": "那你就變成二選一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/269.wav", + "text": "也可以但是我們網頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/270.wav", + "text": "一定會公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/271.wav", + "text": "改為及的話網站就一定要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/272.wav", + "text": "我們尊重大院但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/273.wav", + "text": "有沒有張貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/274.wav", + "text": "本來就有張貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/275.wav", + "text": "如果是或這樣變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/276.wav", + "text": "就變成二選一嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/277.wav", + "text": "現在很少人會跑去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/278.wav", + "text": "所以改成及好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/279.wav", + "text": "建議用或彈性會比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/280.wav", + "text": "但是你們都是會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/281.wav", + "text": "我們不會選擇只用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/282.wav", + "text": "張貼適當地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/283.wav", + "text": "讓你們比較有彈性就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/284.wav", + "text": "但是你還是會做啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/285.wav", + "text": "對比較有彈性如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/286.wav", + "text": "為什麼會擔心寫及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/287.wav", + "text": "你知道我的意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/288.wav", + "text": "寫這樣子你也會做啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/289.wav", + "text": "因為時代也是這樣在走的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/290.wav", + "text": "實際執行上有沒有困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/291.wav", + "text": "我們建議做文字的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/292.wav", + "text": "並應於選舉委���會網站公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/293.wav", + "text": "並以其他適當方式公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/294.wav", + "text": "也可以啦這樣應該是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/295.wav", + "text": "對應於此我們的修正理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/296.wav", + "text": "也要做修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/297.wav", + "text": "且以其他適當方式公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/298.wav", + "text": "前面的話就是並應於選舉委員會網站公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/299.wav", + "text": "且以其他適當方式公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/300.wav", + "text": "好等一下你把文字寫上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/301.wav", + "text": "等一下我們一邊審你一邊準備起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/302.wav", + "text": "著下一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/303.wav", + "text": "還是這一條等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/304.wav", + "text": "第74條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/305.wav", + "text": "有關第74條主要是我們上次審議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/306.wav", + "text": "把虛偽遷徙戶籍的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/307.wav", + "text": "也納為遞補的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/308.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在必須把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/309.wav", + "text": "第98條之1第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/310.wav", + "text": "虛偽遷徙戶籍的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/311.wav", + "text": "也納入第74條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/312.wav", + "text": "所以如果落選後來補的那個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/313.wav", + "text": "就可以對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/314.wav", + "text": "因為原來沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/315.wav", + "text": "連動修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/316.wav", + "text": "個大家沒意見啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/317.wav", + "text": "這個應該是沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/318.wav", + "text": "建議再修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/319.wav", + "text": "另外請中選會準備一下文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/320.wav", + "text": "第74條就照內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/321.wav", + "text": "內政部建議再修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/322.wav", + "text": "\n第一百十條呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/323.wav", + "text": "修了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/324.wav", + "text": "對第6次修了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/325.wav", + "text": "也是條次的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/326.wav", + "text": "這個是因為第九十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/327.wav", + "text": "修正的結果所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/328.wav", + "text": "條就照內政部建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/329.wav", + "text": "再修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/330.wav", + "text": "你們說明有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/331.wav", + "text": "第3頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/332.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/333.wav", + "text": "中選會看一下是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/334.wav", + "text": "你就修成一致好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/335.wav", + "text": "我們會再處理一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/336.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/337.wav", + "text": "接著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/338.wav", + "text": "賴委員還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/339.wav", + "text": "我們先講賴委員的這個這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/340.wav", + "text": "這是之前所保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/341.wav", + "text": "修正動議即農會法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/342.wav", + "text": "\n請賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/343.wav", + "text": "我先來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/344.wav", + "text": "當時我主張保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/345.wav", + "text": "原因主要有兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/346.wav", + "text": "農漁會深入地方事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/347.wav", + "text": "除了協助農漁民外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/348.wav", + "text": "其實它同時也會處理金融事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/349.wav", + "text": "所以它應該才是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/350.wav", + "text": "具有重大影響力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/351.wav", + "text": "跟公共利益的人民團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/352.wav", + "text": "重要性可能不小於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/353.wav", + "text": "政黨公職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/354.wav", + "text": "因為農漁會過去有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/355.wav", + "text": "賄選的案例跟爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/356.wav", + "text": "所以在農會法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/357.wav", + "text": "漁會法裡面也都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/358.wav", + "text": "行賄收賄等相關反黑金的刑事處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/359.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/360.wav", + "text": "我主張保留的原因是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/361.wav", + "text": "農漁會並不是一般的人民團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/362.wav", + "text": "他們其實也有和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/363.wav", + "text": "其他人民團體不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/364.wav", + "text": "公共利益跟影響力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/365.wav", + "text": "也有相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/366.wav", + "text": "其立法精神和選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/367.wav", + "text": "其實完全相同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/368.wav", + "text": "所以當時我才會提出這個草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/369.wav", + "text": "改成修正動議都要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/370.wav", + "text": "這個我要先說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/371.wav", + "text": "\n還有一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/372.wav", + "text": "我一定要跟民政司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/373.wav", + "text": "我會堅持保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/374.wav", + "text": "之前花了一個月左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/375.wav", + "text": "給了我三次回復內容是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/376.wav", + "text": "都只有農漁會是人民團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/377.wav", + "text": "連結性低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/378.wav", + "text": "真的是非常不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/379.wav", + "text": "除了沒有回答到我的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/380.wav", + "text": "你們也沒有給出完整的答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/381.wav", + "text": "我也要肯定內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/382.wav", + "text": "我後來說的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/383.wav", + "text": "我能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/384.wav", + "text": "也提供給各位委員參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/385.wav", + "text": "上禮拜有說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/386.wav", + "text": "目前一般公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/387.wav", + "text": "金融機構政黨農漁會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/388.wav", + "text": "或其他人民團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/389.wav", + "text": "都有訂賄選妨害投票的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/390.wav", + "text": "政黨相較農漁會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/391.wav", + "text": "更具有公職人員的相關性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/392.wav", + "text": "但是目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/393.wav", + "text": "如果違反政黨法相關的賄選罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/394.wav", + "text": "是沒有納入選罷法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/395.wav", + "text": "所以民政司告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/396.wav", + "text": "他們覺得如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/397.wav", + "text": "在這個狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/398.wav", + "text": "把農漁會納入的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/399.wav", + "text": "民政司的舉例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/400.wav", + "text": "我也可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/401.wav", + "text": "就是在組織犯罪防制條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/402.wav", + "text": "法官法和兩岸人民關係條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/403.wav", + "text": "等相關專法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/404.wav", + "text": "也都有不得登記為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/405.wav", + "text": "公職候選人的明文限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/406.wav", + "text": "這是基於專屬法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/407.wav", + "text": "對相關權利義務的特別規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/408.wav", + "text": "所以它其實是跟選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/409.wav", + "text": "脫鉤處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/410.wav", + "text": "也有談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/411.wav", + "text": "也許可以這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/412.wav", + "text": "所以後來民政司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/413.wav", + "text": "這樣子的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/414.wav", + "text": "我就可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/415.wav", + "text": "因此我可以不堅持保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/416.wav", + "text": "但是我要再強調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/417.wav", + "text": "之前會一直堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/418.wav", + "text": "是因為民政司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/419.wav", + "text": "連續三次給我的回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/420.wav", + "text": "都只有一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/421.wav", + "text": "要多溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/422.wav", + "text": "真的是草草帶過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/423.wav", + "text": "所以我不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/424.wav", + "text": "要妥善處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/425.wav", + "text": "所以一直到這次協商前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/426.wav", + "text": "的第四次回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/427.wav", + "text": "才給我完整的說明回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/428.wav", + "text": "我想如果第一次討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/429.wav", + "text": "就給出這樣的回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/430.wav", + "text": "其實就沒有什麼問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/431.wav", + "text": "民政司可以在逐條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/432.wav", + "text": "就把你們的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/433.wav", + "text": "完整說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/434.wav", + "text": "讓更多委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/435.wav", + "text": "可以一起來參與討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/436.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/437.wav", + "text": "謝謝賴委員很用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/438.wav", + "text": "民政司也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/439.wav", + "text": "像我們這麼認真地審法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/440.wav", + "text": "你們也要多做一點溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/441.wav", + "text": "\n我們的想法是一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/442.wav", + "text": "這個部分就不予保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/443.wav", + "text": "第1款第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/444.wav", + "text": "民主社會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/445.wav", + "text": "(我們是一個民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/446.wav", + "text": ")會有很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/447.wav", + "text": "它的第一個結構是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/448.wav", + "text": "把特定的罪章挑出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/449.wav", + "text": "整個是一個罪章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/450.wav", + "text": "它的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/451.wav", + "text": "等於是一部特別刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/452.wav", + "text": "下一個動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/453.wav", + "text": "它的法律效果叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/454.wav", + "text": "終身不得參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/455.wav", + "text": "後面這個影響就大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/456.wav", + "text": "在一個民主國家裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/457.wav", + "text": "參政權就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/458.wav", + "text": "你可以去參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/459.wav", + "text": "跟過去帝制或獨裁國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/460.wav", + "text": "他們到現在都沒辦法參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/461.wav", + "text": "啊所以很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/462.wav", + "text": "中國的維權律師來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/463.wav", + "text": "我跟他們聊天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/464.wav", + "text": "他們都很羨慕我們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/465.wav", + "text": "你們要選就選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/466.wav", + "text": "所以要去對這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/467.wav", + "text": "而且是終身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/468.wav", + "text": "表示你剝奪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/469.wav", + "text": "他在這個共同體裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/470.wav", + "text": "一個非常重要的公民權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/471.wav", + "text": "當一個人被這個共同體宣判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/472.wav", + "text": "說他終身不得參選的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/473.wav", + "text": "請問他還是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/474.wav", + "text": "這個國家的公民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/475.wav", + "text": "\n如果他是一個臺灣人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/476.wav", + "text": "我宣判你終身都不能參選了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/477.wav", + "text": "請問他還是臺灣人嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/478.wav", + "text": "這個共同體的一分子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/479.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/480.wav", + "text": "打5折以上了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/481.wav", + "text": "所以這是一個非常嚴肅的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/482.wav", + "text": "也說很多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/483.wav", + "text": "具體提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/484.wav", + "text": "我的具體建議就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/485.wav", + "text": "不要這樣區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/486.wav", + "text": "前面這些貪污治罪條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/487.wav", + "text": "這些和臺灣這個共同體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/488.wav", + "text": "比較相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/489.wav", + "text": "終身不得參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/490.wav", + "text": "但是後面這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/491.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/492.wav", + "text": "毒品危害防制條例百百種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/493.wav", + "text": "現在有一半的收容人是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/494.wav", + "text": "你說他終身不得參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/495.wav", + "text": "理由是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/496.wav", + "text": "是意圖販賣而持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/497.wav", + "text": "或轉讓大麻種子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/498.wav", + "text": "不是大麻而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/499.wav", + "text": "是大麻的種子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/500.wav", + "text": "這樣是判二年以下有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/501.wav", + "text": "搞不好只判幾個月而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/502.wav", + "text": "可是最後的法律效果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/503.wav", + "text": "終身不得參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/504.wav", + "text": "這樣有沒有輕重失衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/505.wav", + "text": "\n我再舉一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/506.wav", + "text": "販賣而持有或轉讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/507.wav", + "text": "不是罌粟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/508.wav", + "text": "你要拿去種的種子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/509.wav", + "text": "是處三年以下有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/510.wav", + "text": "所以他也有可能被判幾個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/511.wav", + "text": "結果其法律效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/512.wav", + "text": "也是終身不得參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/513.wav", + "text": "是所以我跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/514.wav", + "text": "這可以舉出很多例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/515.wav", + "text": "我再舉一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/516.wav", + "text": "砲我對這個最深惡痛絕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/517.wav", + "text": "我一天到晚都在找刑事局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/518.wav", + "text": "我找刑事局調查局的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/519.wav", + "text": "是要他們去辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/520.wav", + "text": "真的拿出公權力來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/521.wav", + "text": "我為什麼覺得這個很離譜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/522.wav", + "text": "未經許可轉讓出租或出借子彈者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/523.wav", + "text": "也不是買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/524.wav", + "text": "是出借子彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/525.wav", + "text": "槍也會有點關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/526.wav", + "text": "如果要這樣講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/527.wav", + "text": "我們就規定只要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/528.wav", + "text": "我們也不會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/529.wav", + "text": "我要跟你舉例的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/530.wav", + "text": "比如像這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/531.wav", + "text": "處六個月以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/532.wav", + "text": "五年以下有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/533.wav", + "text": "七個月之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/534.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/535.wav", + "text": "你這輩子連里長都不能選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/536.wav", + "text": "所以這是個嚴重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/537.wav", + "text": "本來我們沒辦法選立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/538.wav", + "text": "我們才開始有第二屆的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/539.wav", + "text": "1996年我大學的時候我們才開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/540.wav", + "text": "都可以選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/541.wav", + "text": "過去我們無法想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/542.wav", + "text": "陳玉珍可以選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/543.wav", + "text": "怎麼想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/544.wav", + "text": "從前的人說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/545.wav", + "text": "我要選總統就被抓去關了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/546.wav", + "text": "所以現在的狀況反而是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/547.wav", + "text": "你去限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/548.wav", + "text": "我們好不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/549.wav", + "text": "好不容易是華人世界唯一的民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/550.wav", + "text": "也是世界上所稱羨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/551.wav", + "text": "臺灣民主成就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/552.wav", + "text": "因為你認為治安很差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/553.wav", + "text": "我一天到晚在找調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/554.wav", + "text": "他們都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/555.wav", + "text": "拜託各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/556.wav", + "text": "你解決問題的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/557.wav", + "text": "不是拿公職人員選舉罷免法來開刀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/558.wav", + "text": "又往後倒退一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/559.wav", + "text": "我也是很贊成你的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/560.wav", + "text": "是在解決你的頭還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/561.wav", + "text": "是在解決什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/562.wav", + "text": "你有沒有提出具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/563.wav", + "text": "修正給我們大家來討論給我看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/564.wav", + "text": "我的版本就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/565.wav", + "text": "我的意思就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/566.wav", + "text": "比較法上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/567.wav", + "text": "比較世界各國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/568.wav", + "text": "你去看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/569.wav", + "text": "我們臺灣有多少人在外國讀法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/570.wav", + "text": "包括現在的司法院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/571.wav", + "text": "其實我們對於國外的法制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/572.wav", + "text": "是瞭解的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/573.wav", + "text": "其他的國家也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/574.wav", + "text": "不是這樣搞的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/575.wav", + "text": "人家怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/576.wav", + "text": "如果你真的要去限制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/577.wav", + "text": "那有一個期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/578.wav", + "text": "我現在來講我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/579.wav", + "text": "我的版本就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/580.wav", + "text": "如果你被判三年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/581.wav", + "text": "不能參選的期限是五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/582.wav", + "text": "如果你被判五年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/583.wav", + "text": "可能就限制七年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/584.wav", + "text": "以此類推等於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/585.wav", + "text": "我不會去區分罪名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/586.wav", + "text": "不然人家直接簡單問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/587.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/588.wav", + "text": "有一些立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/589.wav", + "text": "他被判刑卻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/590.wav", + "text": "卻還在當立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/591.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/592.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/593.wav", + "text": "這些當里長的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/594.wav", + "text": "誤入歧途也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/595.wav", + "text": "可能犯了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/596.wav", + "text": "現在羅列的罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/597.wav", + "text": "比如邱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/598.wav", + "text": "委員你的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/599.wav", + "text": "可不可以讓大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/600.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/601.wav", + "text": "我們黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/602.wav", + "text": "上面不是有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/603.wav", + "text": "我的版本在這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/604.wav", + "text": "可以給我看一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/605.wav", + "text": "因為學理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/606.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/607.wav", + "text": "如果你真的要做這種事情的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/608.wav", + "text": "你應該是參照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/609.wav", + "text": "這種國外的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/610.wav", + "text": "就是用刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/611.wav", + "text": "有一些特定的罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/612.wav", + "text": "今天人家就問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/613.wav", + "text": "證券交易之背信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/614.wav", + "text": "證券交易之詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/615.wav", + "text": "騙十幾億的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/616.wav", + "text": "騙了這麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/617.wav", + "text": "為什麼還在當立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/618.wav", + "text": "那你要怎麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/619.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/620.wav", + "text": "現在當里長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/621.wav", + "text": "你隨便卡到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/622.wav", + "text": "像這種毒品危害防制條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/623.wav", + "text": "的連這種判幾個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/624.wav", + "text": "像我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/625.wav", + "text": "出借子彈罪判七個月而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/626.wav", + "text": "終身都不能參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/627.wav", + "text": "這是完全比例失衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/628.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/629.wav", + "text": "我們請莊委員發表一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/630.wav", + "text": "的是邱委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/631.wav", + "text": "大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/632.wav", + "text": "這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/633.wav", + "text": "叫做戇仔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/634.wav", + "text": "叫做空仔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/635.wav", + "text": "只有我們四個坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/636.wav", + "text": "你知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/637.wav", + "text": "這個條文叫做得罪人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/638.wav", + "text": "這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/639.wav", + "text": "行政院在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/640.wav", + "text": "我再來舉個例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/641.wav", + "text": "啦其實我最在意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/642.wav", + "text": "跟邱顯智講的一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/643.wav", + "text": "就是輕重失衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/644.wav", + "text": "刑法重傷罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/645.wav", + "text": "處五年以上有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/646.wav", + "text": "了人家一隻腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/647.wav", + "text": "再去自首" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/648.wav", + "text": "搞不好判三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/649.wav", + "text": "再去跟人家和解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/650.wav", + "text": "搞不好刑度更低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/651.wav", + "text": "可以繼續選立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/652.wav", + "text": "當立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/653.wav", + "text": "結果判幾個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/654.wav", + "text": "各位長官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/655.wav", + "text": "的我要講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/656.wav", + "text": "輕重有沒有失衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/657.wav", + "text": "你們也是法律人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/658.wav", + "text": "你們修法修這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/659.wav", + "text": "了我在講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/660.wav", + "text": "一直都是輕重失衡的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/661.wav", + "text": "我都不點名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/662.wav", + "text": "他還點名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/663.wav", + "text": "選立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/664.wav", + "text": "輕罪的卻連選里長都不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/665.wav", + "text": "你要給我一個論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/666.wav", + "text": "讓我來跟社會大眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/667.wav", + "text": "對話這樣才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/668.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/669.wav", + "text": "有沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/670.wav", + "text": "副主委有沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/671.wav", + "text": "我們就撇開你的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/672.wav", + "text": "現在就是大家來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/673.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼樣去跟社會大眾講假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/674.wav", + "text": "一隻腳剁掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/675.wav", + "text": "不能回復就是重傷了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/676.wav", + "text": "或者把人家的手砍掉就是重傷了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/677.wav", + "text": "嘛我把人家的一眼挖出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/678.wav", + "text": "算重傷了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/679.wav", + "text": "來自首必減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/680.wav", + "text": "再來和解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/681.wav", + "text": "邱顯智當法官他怎麼判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/682.wav", + "text": "一定輕判嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/683.wav", + "text": "還沒有講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/684.wav", + "text": "這個是邏輯的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/685.wav", + "text": "我們要先解決邏輯問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/686.wav", + "text": "\n為什麼重罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/687.wav", + "text": "可以參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/688.wav", + "text": "不行我舉我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/689.wav", + "text": "讓大家參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/690.wav", + "text": "今天我到邱顯智那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/691.wav", + "text": "邱顯智跟我說要把履歷表寄來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/692.wav", + "text": "戶頭要順便拿過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/693.wav", + "text": "他要匯薪水給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/694.wav", + "text": "但我不知道邱顯智這麼壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/695.wav", + "text": "被我發現後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/696.wav", + "text": "問老闆怎麼拿我的帳戶去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/697.wav", + "text": "好吧給你8,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/698.wav", + "text": "他就給我8,00" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/699.wav", + "text": "被檢察官抓到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/700.wav", + "text": "我變成共犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/701.wav", + "text": "我沒有啦那是邱顯智拿我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/702.wav", + "text": "我胸無大志" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/703.wav", + "text": "我只是要選村長跟里長而已但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/704.wav", + "text": "我卻一輩子不能選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/705.wav", + "text": "邱顯智匯這些錢他賺了幾億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/706.wav", + "text": "他可以繼續選立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/707.wav", + "text": "他也可以參選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/708.wav", + "text": "我這個去求職的帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/709.wav", + "text": "被用到的人也是違反洗錢防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/710.wav", + "text": "我也可以緩刑但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/711.wav", + "text": "結果我��能參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/712.wav", + "text": "你們告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/713.wav", + "text": "你們把這一款放進來的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/714.wav", + "text": "是什麼你們是說要跟總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/715.wav", + "text": "副總統選舉罷免法一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/716.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/717.wav", + "text": "你們的理由是這個吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/718.wav", + "text": "不然你們要給我們一個理由啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/719.wav", + "text": "重罪可以繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/720.wav", + "text": "參選這是要我們怎麼審嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/721.wav", + "text": "嘛重罪可以參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/722.wav", + "text": "輕罪不得參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/723.wav", + "text": "這是第一個好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/724.wav", + "text": "那你們繼續講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/725.wav", + "text": "我我建議直接進入法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/726.wav", + "text": "這個我們在審查過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/727.wav", + "text": "不我跟召委報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/728.wav", + "text": "不會卡關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/729.wav", + "text": "立法委員就做價值判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/730.wav", + "text": "他們也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/731.wav", + "text": "司長有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/732.wav", + "text": "我也支持你們的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/733.wav", + "text": "啊現在不就在修法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/734.wav", + "text": "這個是一個價值的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/735.wav", + "text": "我先講我的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/736.wav", + "text": "讓大家一起來做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/737.wav", + "text": "各黨團都不得罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/738.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們立法要擔心得罪人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/739.wav", + "text": "啊我們是做價值判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/740.wav", + "text": "我要進入核心問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/741.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/742.wav", + "text": "委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/743.wav", + "text": "委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/744.wav", + "text": "我再問你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/745.wav", + "text": "就我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/746.wav", + "text": "我認為各個政黨如果要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/747.wav", + "text": "採取高道德標準的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/748.wav", + "text": "就採取我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/749.wav", + "text": "胎哥都不能參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/750.wav", + "text": "我請教了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/751.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/752.wav", + "text": "雖然我你是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/753.wav", + "text": "律師就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/754.wav", + "text": "律師了律師在這裡說這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/755.wav", + "text": "我覺得也有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/756.wav", + "text": "呢或者判九年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/757.wav", + "text": "呢好了你們現在規定一審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/758.wav", + "text": "十年以上也不得參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/759.wav", + "text": "同一個邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/760.wav", + "text": "啊如果二審判九年呢不要說無罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/761.wav", + "text": "了那一款當然我們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/762.wav", + "text": "不予採納可是你們現在態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/763.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/764.wav", + "text": "堅持你們也要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/765.wav", + "text": "白忙一場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/766.wav", + "text": "這個涉及到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/767.wav", + "text": "這個都會留下紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/768.wav", + "text": "這個案是你們國民黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/769.wav", + "text": "法理上都通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/770.wav", + "text": "現在時代力量和國民黨都拿這個來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/771.wav", + "text": "的但有人拜託也不是不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/772.wav", + "text": "法理上通不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/773.wav", + "text": "的問題\n所以我倒覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/774.wav", + "text": "行政院提出這樣一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/775.wav", + "text": "院版我可以知道你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/776.wav", + "text": "苦心說要澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/777.wav", + "text": "吏治更高的道德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/778.wav", + "text": "標準都對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/779.wav", + "text": "至於各政黨提出的在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/780.wav", + "text": "法理上會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/781.wav", + "text": "有輕重失衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/782.wav", + "text": "當然有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/783.wav", + "text": "不然你們就沒辦法回答我的問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/784.wav", + "text": "嘛為什麼你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/785.wav", + "text": "可以容許一個去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/786.wav", + "text": "砍斷人家一隻腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/787.wav", + "text": "砍斷人家一隻手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/788.wav", + "text": "內政部講一下你們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/789.wav", + "text": "先讓他們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/790.wav", + "text": "等一下我的時間都留給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/791.wav", + "text": "我主張全案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/792.wav", + "text": "讓更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/793.wav", + "text": "我們就照我們審的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/794.wav", + "text": "當然到了院會還可以再提出來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/795.wav", + "text": "這有什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/796.wav", + "text": "真的會陷我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/797.wav", + "text": "律師就是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/798.wav", + "text": "為這有違反比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/799.wav", + "text": "莊委員說了一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/800.wav", + "text": "我們一款一款來討論好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/801.wav", + "text": "大家不要一直講理論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/802.wav", + "text": "我說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/803.wav", + "text": "十年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/804.wav", + "text": "有期徒刑���罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/805.wav", + "text": "但沒定讞的就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/806.wav", + "text": "我問了部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/807.wav", + "text": "也問了主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/808.wav", + "text": "主委說是比照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/809.wav", + "text": "總統副總統舉罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/810.wav", + "text": "這在開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/811.wav", + "text": "所以那一款我們已經不予採納了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/812.wav", + "text": "現在在做這個體系的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/813.wav", + "text": "等你們用這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/814.wav", + "text": "們終身都不能參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/815.wav", + "text": "說實在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/816.wav", + "text": "共同體的member終身都往外推耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/817.wav", + "text": "連在監獄服刑褫奪公權的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/818.wav", + "text": "刑法中都已經改了我問過很多次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/819.wav", + "text": "刑法都已經改了都可以去投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/820.wav", + "text": "這表示什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/821.wav", + "text": "表示我們臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/822.wav", + "text": "修正了這麼多其實裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/823.wav", + "text": "很多法律都是很進步的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/824.wav", + "text": "都是要讓這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/825.wav", + "text": "共同體可以增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/826.wav", + "text": "嘛結果你們弄這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/827.wav", + "text": "一點你們就是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/828.wav", + "text": "所以到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/829.wav", + "text": "為什麼只有我們這2個傻瓜坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/830.wav", + "text": "其他人都嚇死了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/831.wav", + "text": "今天反對這個就好像是在支持黑道但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/832.wav", + "text": "重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/833.wav", + "text": "不是這樣做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/834.wav", + "text": "嘛你們要掃黑排黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/835.wav", + "text": "你們應該每一個環節都要注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/836.wav", + "text": "做打詐你們要怎麼打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/837.wav", + "text": "把頭腦動到這上面來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/838.wav", + "text": "\n我要講的是即便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/839.wav", + "text": "你們要用這個的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/840.wav", + "text": "這是一個法治國家最起碼的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/841.wav", + "text": "一個人如果只判七個月而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/842.wav", + "text": "要他終身不得參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/843.wav", + "text": "講不過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/844.wav", + "text": "嘛就像剛剛莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/845.wav", + "text": "所提其實召委也有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/846.wav", + "text": "可能被判七個月就終身不得參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/847.wav", + "text": "有的真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/848.wav", + "text": "經濟犯罪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/849.wav", + "text": "像是證券交易之背信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/850.wav", + "text": "證券交易之詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/851.wav", + "text": "他一樣在選立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/852.wav", + "text": "這有什麼道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/853.wav", + "text": "也不是找最弱勢最" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/854.wav", + "text": "例子我也非常欣然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/855.wav", + "text": "讓他舉例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/856.wav", + "text": "因為確實在實務上發生很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/857.wav", + "text": "各種類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/858.wav", + "text": "結果都會用到幫助詐欺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/859.wav", + "text": "看起來都很像被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/860.wav", + "text": "最後他也是終身不得參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/861.wav", + "text": "\n我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/862.wav", + "text": "說實在的也是在不得已的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/863.wav", + "text": "你們既然提出這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/864.wav", + "text": "瓜先不要走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/865.wav", + "text": "不然我們如果要保留就按照邱顯智" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/866.wav", + "text": "員的版本來保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/867.wav", + "text": "讓游院長他們按照這個版本再做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/868.wav", + "text": "我當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/869.wav", + "text": "我們還是聽一下內政部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/870.wav", + "text": "所有人的版本我都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/871.wav", + "text": "那就照這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/872.wav", + "text": "是我的意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/873.wav", + "text": "院版有它的價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/874.wav", + "text": "本來就需要共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/875.wav", + "text": "莊委員都講這麼多理論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/876.wav", + "text": "我們來進入實務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/877.wav", + "text": "內政部要不要講一點話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/878.wav", + "text": "是尊重我們的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/879.wav", + "text": "還是堅持你們的院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/880.wav", + "text": "你講得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/881.wav", + "text": "啊所以到底是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/882.wav", + "text": "還是不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/883.wav", + "text": "講到最後到底是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/884.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/885.wav", + "text": "我們現場還有兩位在有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/886.wav", + "text": "是因為針對黑金槍毒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/887.wav", + "text": "我們採取比較高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/888.wav", + "text": "現在大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/889.wav", + "text": "基本上當然我們也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/890.wav", + "text": "委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/891.wav", + "text": "不過我也特別要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/892.wav", + "text": "在這裡提醒當初我們在訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/893.wav", + "text": "定院版時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/894.wav", + "text": "是針對當初的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/895.wav", + "text": "我們認為黑金槍毒是大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/896.wav", + "text": "標準所以我們把門關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/897.wav", + "text": "等我們當然尊重委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/898.wav", + "text": "因為我想這個到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/899.wav", + "text": "還是要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/900.wav", + "text": "有事情她待會會回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/901.wav", + "text": "我們3個不能決定別人的生死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/902.wav", + "text": "不是啦我們來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/903.wav", + "text": "這樣子可不可以因為我們剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/904.wav", + "text": "已經決定七十幾條了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/905.wav", + "text": "剩下這一條有什麼不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/906.wav", + "text": "大家可以看看是不是要按照這個還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/907.wav", + "text": "是可以這樣通過大家可以看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/908.wav", + "text": "你要保留我也沒意見這也是你的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/909.wav", + "text": "我們那時候討論第6款和第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/910.wav", + "text": "第7款緩刑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/911.wav", + "text": "大家應該比較沒有爭議緩刑是更輕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/912.wav", + "text": "是怎樣我一樣一樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/913.wav", + "text": "我來講我先講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/914.wav", + "text": "這邊的條款等一下還有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/915.wav", + "text": "意見你講那麼久不能換我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/916.wav", + "text": "你聽我講我是在替你講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/917.wav", + "text": "你要什麼我很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/918.wav", + "text": "所以我就跟你說我尊重保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/919.wav", + "text": "這樣不我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/920.wav", + "text": "你說服不了他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/921.wav", + "text": "等一下再換他們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/922.wav", + "text": "第6款先講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/923.wav", + "text": "洗錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/924.wav", + "text": "這幾款修正後的保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/925.wav", + "text": "不在此限暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/926.wav", + "text": "條文\n現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/927.wav", + "text": "有一個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/928.wav", + "text": "今天剛剛提的這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/929.wav", + "text": "大家手上有看到這一份嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/930.wav", + "text": "就是第6款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/931.wav", + "text": "黑槍氾濫的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/932.wav", + "text": "三年以上未滿五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/933.wav", + "text": "五年以上未滿七年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/934.wav", + "text": "有期徒刑之刑確定未滿七年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/935.wav", + "text": "七年以上未滿十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/936.wav", + "text": "有期徒刑之刑確定未滿十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/937.wav", + "text": "等一下我們再繼續討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/938.wav", + "text": "我們兩個人意見不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/939.wav", + "text": "不過有一致的部分先唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/940.wav", + "text": "是第6款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/941.wav", + "text": "或經判處免刑者亦同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/942.wav", + "text": "但緩刑期滿未經撤銷或判決免刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/943.wav", + "text": "邱委員的建議就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/944.wav", + "text": "把這兩個拿開用時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/945.wav", + "text": "三年以上未滿五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/946.wav", + "text": "我跟你的版本差別是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/947.wav", + "text": "槍砲彈藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/948.wav", + "text": "我的版本是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/949.wav", + "text": "就是按照幾年這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/950.wav", + "text": "但是另外一個重點來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/951.wav", + "text": "來了你從這個條文就可以看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/952.wav", + "text": "絕對沒有人來跟我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/953.wav", + "text": "說要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/954.wav", + "text": "因為我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/955.wav", + "text": "我的版本就是雨露均霑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/956.wav", + "text": "我這個版本是沒有分罪名的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/957.wav", + "text": "今天如果有一個人背信被證券交易法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/958.wav", + "text": "判刑四年好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/959.wav", + "text": "他就會被我的版本限制到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/960.wav", + "text": "所以我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/961.wav", + "text": "不會這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/962.wav", + "text": "最開始應該沒有採納你的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/963.wav", + "text": "沒有這是我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/964.wav", + "text": "這是最開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/965.wav", + "text": "的最開始那時候已經審查過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/966.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/967.wav", + "text": "我的版本基本上就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/968.wav", + "text": "所以我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/969.wav", + "text": "跟院版的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/970.wav", + "text": "現在講的是之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/971.wav", + "text": "你現在講的是最新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/972.wav", + "text": "不要再回到過去講對對沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/973.wav", + "text": "我的版本限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/974.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/975.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/976.wav", + "text": "針對這一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/977.wav", + "text": "內政部這邊說尊重我們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/978.wav", + "text": "各位委員呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/979.wav", + "text": "司長說沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/980.wav", + "text": "我跟你的意見不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/981.wav", + "text": "我的是比你的多限制非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/982.wav", + "text": "範圍廣很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/983.wav", + "text": "人就有4種意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/984.wav", + "text": "先讓司長講一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/985.wav", + "text": "只要司長講話變成5種意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/986.wav", + "text": "但是全部都保留送院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/987.wav", + "text": "就是這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/988.wav", + "text": "但是你個人是支持我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/989.wav", + "text": "他沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/990.wav", + "text": "你的那個價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/991.wav", + "text": "他支持你的價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/992.wav", + "text": "不一定支持你的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/993.wav", + "text": "我可以舉個例子譬如我剛剛講在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/994.wav", + "text": "判七個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/995.wav", + "text": "所以我的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/996.wav", + "text": "我們4個人已經有4個不同的意見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/997.wav", + "text": "希望本案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/998.wav", + "text": "我是怕今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/999.wav", + "text": "要讓更多委員參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1000.wav", + "text": "這樣才是負責任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1001.wav", + "text": "行政部門的意見都你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1002.wav", + "text": "那那是大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1003.wav", + "text": "我不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1004.wav", + "text": "我在預測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1005.wav", + "text": "啦到最後通過的跟我們的想法都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1006.wav", + "text": "莊委員那就照你的意見你也來簽個名吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1007.wav", + "text": "就不用再協商了第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1008.wav", + "text": "第26條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1009.wav", + "text": "先簽總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1010.wav", + "text": "九十幾條都修過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1011.wav", + "text": "9條和第96" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1012.wav", + "text": "選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1013.wav", + "text": "我說的是選罷法也審過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1014.wav", + "text": "對所以要簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1015.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1016.wav", + "text": "內政部要不要表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1017.wav", + "text": "審查到最後就只剩兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1018.wav", + "text": "我們也修了這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1019.wav", + "text": "院長主持協商的時候還是要再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1020.wav", + "text": "要選總統的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1021.wav", + "text": "你不能把臺灣的共同體變得這麼窄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1022.wav", + "text": "我們來處理公職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1023.wav", + "text": "先照我們所審查的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1024.wav", + "text": "再重新翻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1025.wav", + "text": "26條第1款是關於內亂外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1026.wav", + "text": "第3款是曾犯第97條第98條第99條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1027.wav", + "text": "第五款是曾犯組織犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1028.wav", + "text": "原住民的相關句子也放在這裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1029.wav", + "text": "也寫進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1030.wav", + "text": "謝謝第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1031.wav", + "text": "免刑的我也把你的意見寫進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1032.wav", + "text": "但我們審過一遍的結果大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1033.wav", + "text": "受保安處分之裁判確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1034.wav", + "text": "清算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1035.wav", + "text": "第十二款是曾受免除職務之懲戒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1036.wav", + "text": "第十五款是受監護或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1037.wav", + "text": "輔助宣告尚未撤銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1038.wav", + "text": "版本就是變成這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1039.wav", + "text": "對但這是委員提案版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1040.wav", + "text": "大家能支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1041.wav", + "text": "不是修正後的院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1042.wav", + "text": "還是哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1043.wav", + "text": "就是修正後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1044.wav", + "text": "修正後的院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1045.wav", + "text": "你今天準備的這一份嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1046.wav", + "text": "是4月13" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1047.wav", + "text": "是這一份嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1048.wav", + "text": "有什麼差別我看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1049.wav", + "text": "你們可不可以也看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1050.wav", + "text": "我看我們審查通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1051.wav", + "text": "國安組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1052.wav", + "text": "毒品有罪判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1053.wav", + "text": "緩刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1054.wav", + "text": "加原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1055.wav", + "text": "組織這個沒有錯嘛\n組織這個沒有改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1056.wav", + "text": "司長看一下是不是這一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1057.wav", + "text": "你要不要看一下科長你看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1058.wav", + "text": "這是不是4月13日那份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1059.wav", + "text": "份現在行政院的版本就是4月13日的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1060.wav", + "text": "沒關係不然照它的修正版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1061.wav", + "text": "也可以反正到時候還要討論你還是會再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1062.wav", + "text": "我們要確定一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1063.wav", + "text": "我們今天討論的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1064.wav", + "text": "容你再簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1065.wav", + "text": "\n邱顯智委員先簽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1066.wav", + "text": "不然等一下再找你嗎就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1067.wav", + "text": "剛剛那幾條已經有過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1068.wav", + "text": "這幾條都過了要刪掉你先看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1069.wav", + "text": "對對對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1070.wav", + "text": "剩下我一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1071.wav", + "text": "你們看一下是不是這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1072.wav", + "text": "這是正確的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1073.wav", + "text": "我們附這個嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1074.wav", + "text": "沒關係就用你們的他到時候還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1075.wav", + "text": "會再講30分鐘嘛反正我們到時候還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1076.wav", + "text": "要再去院長���邊講30分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1077.wav", + "text": "因為這個到時候院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1078.wav", + "text": "我看一下是不是這兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1079.wav", + "text": "說我有這兩個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1080.wav", + "text": "我們是不是把這兩個都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1081.wav", + "text": "併案放在裡頭可以這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1082.wav", + "text": "\n因為內政部希望是這個嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1083.wav", + "text": "行政院修正版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1084.wav", + "text": "啦我們是這個提案版嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1085.wav", + "text": "嘛\n我看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1086.wav", + "text": "啦事實上我是把他的也納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1087.wav", + "text": "啦就這兩個來調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1088.wav", + "text": "可以多兩個嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1089.wav", + "text": "行政院的修正版啦這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1090.wav", + "text": "啦科長看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1091.wav", + "text": "就這個版本嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1092.wav", + "text": "好你註明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1093.wav", + "text": "一個是行政院修正版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1094.wav", + "text": "一個是邱顯智和我們提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1095.wav", + "text": "協商好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1096.wav", + "text": "對對對沒關係就提這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1097.wav", + "text": "就這兩個併案讓甲乙兩案去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1098.wav", + "text": "協商啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1099.wav", + "text": "都給科長看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1100.wav", + "text": "才不會有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1101.wav", + "text": "我們的黨團助理也都看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1102.wav", + "text": "看這個版對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1103.wav", + "text": "行政院的一個是我們提出來的反正這兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1104.wav", + "text": "甲案乙案就送上去協商啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1105.wav", + "text": "這樣可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1106.wav", + "text": "剩下的我來宣告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1107.wav", + "text": "朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1108.wav", + "text": "就很容易了嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1109.wav", + "text": "在那兩點就甲案乙案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1110.wav", + "text": "\n我來唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1111.wav", + "text": "今天我們協商總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1112.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1113.wav", + "text": "今天協商通過的條文為第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1114.wav", + "text": "增訂第47條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1115.wav", + "text": "第9條及第96條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1116.wav", + "text": "項次條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1117.wav", + "text": "條次引述條文之文字及相關法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1118.wav", + "text": "用語授權主席及議事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1119.wav", + "text": "審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1120.wav", + "text": "免法的部分就不用送朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1121.wav", + "text": "免法��家都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1122.wav", + "text": "了\n有關今天協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1123.wav", + "text": "罷免法部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1124.wav", + "text": "我們修了74條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1125.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1126.wav", + "text": "第32條第47條增訂第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1127.wav", + "text": "51條之3第74條第104條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1128.wav", + "text": "我們會附附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1129.wav", + "text": "注意看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1130.wav", + "text": "保留條文為第二十六條我們保留了兩個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1131.wav", + "text": "就是行政院的再修正版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1132.wav", + "text": "再建議修正版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1133.wav", + "text": "這個是我們在黨團協商提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1134.wav", + "text": "的就將甲案乙案送到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1135.wav", + "text": "朝野協商讓游院長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1136.wav", + "text": "但是委員會通過的還是要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1137.wav", + "text": "因為後面就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1138.wav", + "text": "不用再討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1139.wav", + "text": "條文條次引述條文之文字及相關法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1140.wav", + "text": "用語授權主席及議事人員整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1141.wav", + "text": "大家沒意見吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1142.wav", + "text": "好謝謝大家辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14999/1143.wav", + "text": "\n今天會議到此結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/0.wav", + "text": "須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/1.wav", + "text": "將委員楊瓊瓔等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/2.wav", + "text": "自委員會抽出逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/3.wav", + "text": "與相關提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/4.wav", + "text": "併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/5.wav", + "text": "就保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/6.wav", + "text": "保留條文處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/7.wav", + "text": "併說明並請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/8.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/9.wav", + "text": "問各位附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/10.wav", + "text": "第1條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/11.wav", + "text": "第2條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/15001/12.wav", + "text": "附帶決議還有一個修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/0.wav", + "text": "本日協商關於農業部組織法草案等相關法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/1.wav", + "text": "經濟部組織法修正草案等相關法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/2.wav", + "text": "交通部組織法修正草案等相關法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/3.wav", + "text": "及核能安全委員會組織法草案\n等相關法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/4.wav", + "text": "共計4個主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/5.wav", + "text": "稍後按協商通知排序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/6.wav", + "text": "依序進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/7.wav", + "text": "逐案進行協商協商時請參閱審查報告及逕付二讀提案關係文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/8.wav", + "text": "與會委員如有修正動議或機關有建議內容請提出書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/9.wav", + "text": "印發給現場進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/10.wav", + "text": "農業部組織法草案等相關法案共16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/11.wav", + "text": "審查會先前已於4月10日審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/12.wav", + "text": "審查結果除了第1案農業部組織法草案第5條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/13.wav", + "text": "第5案農業部林業及自然保育署組織法草案第5條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/14.wav", + "text": "其餘均有審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/15.wav", + "text": "並決議在院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/16.wav", + "text": "另院會再將委員楊瓊瓔等16人擬具農業部組織法草案逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/17.wav", + "text": "委員蘇治芬等16人擬具農業部組織法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/18.wav", + "text": "自委員會抽出逕付二讀與相關提案併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/19.wav", + "text": "為求效率我們先就保留條文進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/20.wav", + "text": "如各位協商代表對審查會通過條文有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/21.wav", + "text": "待保留條文處理完畢後再接續進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/22.wav", + "text": "請問各位有無意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/23.wav", + "text": "如果沒有我們先請與會機關代表針對保留條文一併說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/24.wav", + "text": "並請出席委員討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/25.wav", + "text": "\n請農委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/26.wav", + "text": "在行政院有一個水庫集水區保育綱要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/27.wav", + "text": "裡面牽扯到包括經濟部農委會交通部環保署內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/28.wav", + "text": "其實在目前的作業不管從法識面計畫面或執行面都有明確的分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/29.wav", + "text": "做集水區區域特別集中計畫或是哪個機關來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/30.wav", + "text": "如果委員針對特定的區域需要我們來處理以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/31.wav", + "text": "以個案方式我們都樂意去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/32.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/33.wav", + "text": "我覺得副主委根本沒有做功課就來亂講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/34.wav", + "text": "耶現在都很好我們95年水庫集水區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/35.wav", + "text": "或者現在水源區都沒有問題了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/36.wav", + "text": "你們農委會所負責的水保或者水質相關的都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/37.wav", + "text": "怎麼會這樣子說呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/38.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員提出來關切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/39.wav", + "text": "我覺得你要做功課再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/40.wav", + "text": "現在就是各部會明顯不足才會這麼辛苦去提出這個要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/41.wav", + "text": "嘛你今天卻說都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/42.wav", + "text": "簡直在胡說八道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/43.wav", + "text": "應該這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/44.wav", + "text": "但以現行的運作方式是由各部會一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/45.wav", + "text": "現行的運作就是有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/46.wav", + "text": "而且問題很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/47.wav", + "text": "簡直是病入膏肓了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/48.wav", + "text": "95年是生病而現在是病入膏肓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/49.wav", + "text": "所以95年水庫集水區保育綱要就是說要成立管理單位嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/50.wav", + "text": "而你還不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/51.wav", + "text": "你講這什麼話怎麼能解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/52.wav", + "text": "這麼多年現在總算要組改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/53.wav", + "text": "就是要趁組改時把這個問題解決嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/54.wav", + "text": "這完全是不負責任不做功課的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/55.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/56.wav", + "text": "什麼關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/57.wav", + "text": "你自己要做功課再來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/58.wav", + "text": "啊至少你要去聽聽看上次你們主委怎麼講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/59.wav", + "text": "其實集水區的問題本來就是由經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/60.wav", + "text": "跟我們環保署以及內政部一起來運作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/61.wav", + "text": "現在的運作就是沒有辦法有效的解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/62.wav", + "text": "沒有特定區的管理機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/63.wav", + "text": "所以現在巡查人力也不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/64.wav", + "text": "現在問題就是這樣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/65.wav", + "text": "你都不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/66.wav", + "text": "就說現在的機制運作的很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/67.wav", + "text": "及水利的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/68.wav", + "text": "現在組改要來解決啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/69.wav", + "text": "所以95年時才說10年要完成組改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/70.wav", + "text": "然後要成立管理單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/71.wav", + "text": "就是95年就發現這個問題很嚴重但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/72.wav", + "text": "但現在你們組改又不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/73.wav", + "text": "說現在運作很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/74.wav", + "text": "這誰可以接受啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/75.wav", + "text": "都有逐年在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/76.wav", + "text": "但是有些問題確實是因為氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/77.wav", + "text": "你又推給氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/78.wav", + "text": "怎麼會這樣呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/79.wav", + "text": "這一定是有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/80.wav", + "text": "現在的機制其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/81.wav", + "text": "現在的問題就是沒解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/82.wav", + "text": "但你剛剛說都解決得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/83.wav", + "text": "你告訴我怎麼解決得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/84.wav", + "text": "人力不夠巡查也不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/85.wav", + "text": "你怎麼會說現在運作得很好呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/86.wav", + "text": "水質越來越差你知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/87.wav", + "text": "以現在的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/88.wav", + "text": "現在的運作也都沒有管到水質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/89.wav", + "text": "副主委你不用急著一直回應嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/90.wav", + "text": "\n洪委員要表達意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/91.wav", + "text": "做一些說明這個是可以理解的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/92.wav", + "text": "但是我真的覺得你剛才回答說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/93.wav", + "text": "現在這些機制運作得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/94.wav", + "text": "這個只是徒增讓大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/95.wav", + "text": "想要吐槽的動力而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/96.wav", + "text": "因為有非常多地方都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/97.wav", + "text": "列舉出現在運作上的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/98.wav", + "text": "所以我真的不覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/99.wav", + "text": "農委會現在這個回答方式是好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/100.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/101.wav", + "text": "應該是可以解決把它做得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/102.wav", + "text": "應該是集所有公務機關可以使用的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/103.wav", + "text": "用最好的協調方式去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/104.wav", + "text": "我剛剛的發言是抗議啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/105.wav", + "text": "現在我們要透過組改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/106.wav", + "text": "把問題提出來然後予以解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/107.wav", + "text": "我們現在就是要來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/108.wav", + "text": "就要針對水庫集水區(流域)的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/109.wav", + "text": "但是沒有啊所以我們現在才來問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/110.wav", + "text": "在水庫集水區的水保部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/111.wav", + "text": "於經濟部的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/112.wav", + "text": "我有提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/113.wav", + "text": "如果我們在這次組改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/114.wav", + "text": "沒有時間來處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/115.wav", + "text": "因為這個是跨部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/116.wav", + "text": "的工作這個在水庫集水區保育綱要裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/117.wav", + "text": "就是需要跨部會來整合的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/118.wav", + "text": "所以我的附帶決議就是請行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/119.wav", + "text": "行政院人事行政總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/120.wav", + "text": "經濟部農委會環保署在本次組改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/121.wav", + "text": "時一併檢討相關工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/122.wav", + "text": "也就是行政院要成立專責的組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/123.wav", + "text": "專責的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/124.wav", + "text": "讓分散在各部會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/125.wav", + "text": "能夠整合來執行他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/126.wav", + "text": "實際上應該做的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/127.wav", + "text": "因為現在沒有整合嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/128.wav", + "text": "第8屆的時候有整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/129.wav", + "text": "那時候是要整合環資部但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/130.wav", + "text": "也沒辦法去做到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/131.wav", + "text": "所以現在行政院一定要有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/132.wav", + "text": "專責的協調單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/133.wav", + "text": "來負責跨部會協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/134.wav", + "text": "然後在政策綱領的訂定跟預算的分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/135.wav", + "text": "上要變成一個實質的運作單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/136.wav", + "text": "農委會水保局林務局經濟部水利署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/137.wav", + "text": "污水下水道的相關單位都要整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/138.wav", + "text": "水庫集水區的相關保育工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/139.wav", + "text": "\n目前很重要的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/140.wav", + "text": "水質以往都沒有被重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/141.wav", + "text": "我們要怎麼樣訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/142.wav", + "text": "我們在附帶決議二的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/143.wav", + "text": "就是要求增加相關的巡查人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/144.wav", + "text": "我今天是已經沒有辦法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/145.wav", + "text": "人總也跟我提過來不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/146.wav", + "text": "本來是主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/147.wav", + "text": "現在改為附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/148.wav", + "text": "來不及的部分能在本屆任期內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/149.wav", + "text": "能夠完成使其能實質的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/150.wav", + "text": "這是今天我對於農業部組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/151.wav", + "text": "所提出的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/152.wav", + "text": "就是要能夠同意這樣來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/153.wav", + "text": "還好主委來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/154.wav", + "text": "不然你們很危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/155.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請洪申翰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/156.wav", + "text": "這些相關自然資源的管理跟治理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/157.wav", + "text": "需要一個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/158.wav", + "text": "或是跟過去有不一樣方式的整合工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/159.wav", + "text": "就像剛才所說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/160.wav", + "text": "的這些自然資源的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/161.wav", + "text": "坦白說現在是存在著滿多問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/162.wav", + "text": "並不像剛剛副主委所說的沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/163.wav", + "text": "陳委員所提的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/164.wav", + "text": "我先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/165.wav", + "text": "我提議保留的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/166.wav", + "text": "因為水庫的集水區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/167.wav", + "text": "尤其是關於水庫的相關管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/168.wav", + "text": "其實主責單位應該是經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/169.wav", + "text": "可能會跟農委會有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/170.wav", + "text": "但假如是以水庫為主要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/171.wav", + "text": "其實主責是經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/172.wav", + "text": "也許還包括行政院可以再討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/173.wav", + "text": "怎麼去處理這個問題的一些方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/174.wav", + "text": "但我認為這個問題是需要處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/175.wav", + "text": "這是我的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/176.wav", + "text": "接下來請陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/177.wav", + "text": "我其實是不反對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/178.wav", + "text": "不過我覺得主責的就是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/179.wav", + "text": "而且以土地的管理來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/180.wav", + "text": "經濟部根本沒有土地的管理權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/181.wav", + "text": "所以由行政院來成立一個主責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/182.wav", + "text": "負責協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/183.wav", + "text": "這個是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/184.wav", + "text": "經濟部在目前的水利法之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/185.wav", + "text": "只有管到水庫蓄水範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/186.wav", + "text": "在不夠的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/187.wav", + "text": "情況下經濟部根本沒辦法主責啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/188.wav", + "text": "我當然也不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/189.wav", + "text": "但是它包不下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/190.wav", + "text": "吃不下啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/191.wav", + "text": "我要主委同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/192.wav", + "text": "水保的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/193.wav", + "text": "如果未來我們透過協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/194.wav", + "text": "大範圍的自來水保護區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/195.wav", + "text": "因為目前劃設變更都是經濟部水利署負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/196.wav", + "text": "但是我們只靠水利署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/197.wav", + "text": "只靠經濟部是沒有辦法做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/198.wav", + "text": "水庫集水區大範圍面積的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/199.wav", + "text": "管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/200.wav", + "text": "所以本席所提出的主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/201.wav", + "text": "或是經濟部這邊來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/202.wav", + "text": "林務局也要提撥相關人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/203.wav", + "text": "還有內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/204.wav", + "text": "這樣才有辦法把這個工作做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/205.wav", + "text": "能夠好好來討論相關的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/206.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/207.wav", + "text": "請主委回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/208.wav", + "text": "主席各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/209.wav", + "text": "因為早上參加經濟委員會安排的考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/210.wav", + "text": "這個理念就是把山水土林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/211.wav", + "text": "整合在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/212.wav", + "text": "為國家永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/213.wav", + "text": "這個理念我們完全贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/214.wav", + "text": "這是第一個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/215.wav", + "text": "\n第二個有關未來的農業部感謝所有委員的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/216.wav", + "text": "要把山水土林整合在一個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/217.wav", + "text": "是不可能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/218.wav", + "text": "全部歸於農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/219.wav", + "text": "而且林務局將來是變成林務及自然保育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/220.wav", + "text": "不只是負責林業的生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/221.wav", + "text": "自然保育更是重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/222.wav", + "text": "所以未來只要���是水庫集水區域的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/223.wav", + "text": "範圍其相關所有水土保持工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/224.wav", + "text": "林相的維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/225.wav", + "text": "等等這些都是要由未來的農業部負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/226.wav", + "text": "這是第二個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/227.wav", + "text": "農產品安全或環境安全為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/228.wav", + "text": "這三個都非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/229.wav", + "text": "或是委員之前非常在乎的灌排不分離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/230.wav", + "text": "這個也是有在院裡跨部會協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/231.wav", + "text": "所以實際上不可能會有所謂行政院的一個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/232.wav", + "text": "來解決所有的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/233.wav", + "text": "所以是否就依委員主決議的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/234.wav", + "text": "由行政院來跨部會協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/235.wav", + "text": "尤其是集水區(域)裡面所有的水土保持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/236.wav", + "text": "或是相關工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/237.wav", + "text": "的確不可能院突然再成立一個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/238.wav", + "text": "反而是應把合作協調的機制建立起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/239.wav", + "text": "以及委員所期待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/240.wav", + "text": "會更容易達到這樣一個願景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/241.wav", + "text": "只要把文中成立一個專責單位的部分劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/242.wav", + "text": "但若是集水區以外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/243.wav", + "text": "其實在權責上很清楚的就是由農業部負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/244.wav", + "text": "我不知道你說的文字修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/245.wav", + "text": "不需要成立一個專責單位嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/246.wav", + "text": "體上是由行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/247.wav", + "text": "來做整合在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/248.wav", + "text": "才能實際落實相關的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/249.wav", + "text": "因為之前水庫集水區管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/250.wav", + "text": "綱要是提到要成立水庫集水區的管理單位但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/251.wav", + "text": "但現在我們沒有辦法依照那個綱要來成立管理單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/252.wav", + "text": "即現在管理單位的層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/253.wav", + "text": "現在就是要行政院在實質上有一個單位來整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/254.wav", + "text": "未來農委會水保局林務局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/255.wav", + "text": "所以如果行政院沒有一個單位來做整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/256.wav", + "text": "未來還是一樣各做各的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/257.wav", + "text": "那就沒有辦法有效地做好管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/258.wav", + "text": "因為我們沒有辦法配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/259.wav", + "text": "之前95年的綱要來做特定區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/260.wav", + "text": "但我們目前也不能夠過於鬆散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/261.wav", + "text": "所以行政院還是要負起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/262.wav", + "text": "因為這次就是行政院在討論組改的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/263.wav", + "text": "沒有把這���納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/264.wav", + "text": "所以行政院還是要負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/265.wav", + "text": "專責單位來負責協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/266.wav", + "text": "負責協調的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/267.wav", + "text": "或是行政院再去討論要如何來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/268.wav", + "text": "總之我們就是提出這個附帶決議讓行政院決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/269.wav", + "text": "因為你提的是由行政院層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/270.wav", + "text": "召集成立這樣一個專責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/271.wav", + "text": "基本上今天列席都是部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/272.wav", + "text": "所以應該沒有一個人可以去答復這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/273.wav", + "text": "\n其二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/274.wav", + "text": "所以協商可能到最後還是要送到院長那邊協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/275.wav", + "text": "再加上後面還有很多部會在等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/276.wav", + "text": "好不好農委會如果有好的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/277.wav", + "text": "也請將修正的文字提供給陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/278.wav", + "text": "或許可以加快速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/279.wav", + "text": "這樣應該可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/280.wav", + "text": "我講一句話陳主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/281.wav", + "text": "這個單位只是一個協調機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/282.wav", + "text": "所以還是要有一個具體的協調機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/283.wav", + "text": "而不是一個會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/284.wav", + "text": "那個效果真的是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/285.wav", + "text": "我們會再跟陳委員討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/286.wav", + "text": "論看看主決議的文字要如何修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/287.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/288.wav", + "text": "所以附帶決議第1案我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/289.wav", + "text": "\n請問各位附帶決議第2案有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/290.wav", + "text": "其實在整個組改的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/291.wav", + "text": "我們都一定會優先考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/292.wav", + "text": "在執行相關業務上所需要的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/293.wav", + "text": "但是要跟委員報告的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/294.wav", + "text": "因為集水區的區域很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/295.wav", + "text": "我們會建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/296.wav", + "text": "不管是經濟部或農委會(未來的農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/297.wav", + "text": "要善用資訊科技設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/298.wav", + "text": "事實上他們應是混搭的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/299.wav", + "text": "外該補的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/300.wav", + "text": "員也應適當的依照業務的量能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/301.wav", + "text": "新的業務若需要人員去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/302.wav", + "text": "我們一定會補上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/303.wav", + "text": "但是我們也要提醒農委會及經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/304.wav", + "text": "要善用相關科技設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/305.wav", + "text": "所以本人建議為了公務人員的生命安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/306.wav", + "text": "是可以用科技設備來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/307.wav", + "text": "可以通過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/308.wav", + "text": "從人總的說明就可以知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/309.wav", + "text": "它的面積真的太大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/310.wav", + "text": "檢討之後該增加的就增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/311.wav", + "text": "我的附帶決議也是這樣的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/312.wav", + "text": "就請各位支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/313.wav", + "text": "陳委員我是建議先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/314.wav", + "text": "甚至我真的認為相關的整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/315.wav", + "text": "甚至不只是水庫集水區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/316.wav", + "text": "可能還包括更多其他的自然資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/317.wav", + "text": "像我自己也一直跟行政院要求希望推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/318.wav", + "text": "這些相關自然資源整合的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/319.wav", + "text": "我覺得重點是機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/320.wav", + "text": "不是只有開一次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/321.wav", + "text": "我是建議先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/322.wav", + "text": "就算人事長現在同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/323.wav", + "text": "也一樣會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/324.wav", + "text": "因為到時黨團要簽字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/325.wav", + "text": "召委我同意保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/326.wav", + "text": "只是這個範圍已經很大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/327.wav", + "text": "集中在水庫集水區(流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/328.wav", + "text": "至於如果有其他的那就另外再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/329.wav", + "text": "了謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/330.wav", + "text": "至於農業部組織法草案第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/331.wav", + "text": "還有農業部林業及自然保育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/332.wav", + "text": "組織法草案也一樣保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/333.wav", + "text": "併案送院會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/334.wav", + "text": "謝謝現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/335.wav", + "text": "現在處理主題二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/336.wav", + "text": "經濟部組織法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/337.wav", + "text": "等相關法案共11案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/338.wav", + "text": "審查會於4月12日審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/339.wav", + "text": "審查結果保留條文有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/340.wav", + "text": "經濟部組織法修正草案第2條第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/341.wav", + "text": "經濟部產業發展署組織法草案第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/342.wav", + "text": "經濟部能源署組織法草案第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/343.wav", + "text": "經濟部中小及新創企業署組織法草案第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/344.wav", + "text": "經濟部水利署組織法草案第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/345.wav", + "text": "經濟部礦業管理及地質調查中心組織法草案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/346.wav", + "text": "及第1條至第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/347.wav", + "text": "其餘均依審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/348.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/349.wav", + "text": "院會再將委員楊瓊瓔等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/350.wav", + "text": "擬具經濟部組織法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/351.wav", + "text": "等20案分別逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/352.wav", + "text": "自委員會抽出逕付二讀與相關提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/353.wav", + "text": "併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/354.wav", + "text": "如果各位協商代表對審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/355.wav", + "text": "會通過條文有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/356.wav", + "text": "待保留條文處理完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/357.wav", + "text": "再接續進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/358.wav", + "text": "請問各位有無意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/359.wav", + "text": "主席太快了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/360.wav", + "text": "現在保留是從第2條嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/361.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/362.wav", + "text": "經濟部組織法修正草案第2條跟第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/363.wav", + "text": "我剛才都有宣讀過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/364.wav", + "text": "我們要求在組改的時候改名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/365.wav", + "text": "第一個是第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/366.wav", + "text": "要改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/367.wav", + "text": "地質及礦業管理中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/368.wav", + "text": "就是這個名稱要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/369.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/370.wav", + "text": "請問這部分是不是已經同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/371.wav", + "text": "請說明一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/372.wav", + "text": "你說第幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/373.wav", + "text": "哪一個組織法的第幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/374.wav", + "text": "經濟部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/375.wav", + "text": "經濟部組織法只有第2條跟第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/376.wav", + "text": "第2條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/377.wav", + "text": "就是名稱的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/378.wav", + "text": "第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/379.wav", + "text": "第5條就是礦業管理跟地質調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/380.wav", + "text": "我們的修正動議就是針對這個名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/381.wav", + "text": "第10款是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/382.wav", + "text": "要改為地質及礦業管理中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/383.wav", + "text": "在第5條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/384.wav", + "text": "第2條比較沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/385.wav", + "text": "就是地質調查及礦業管理中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/386.wav", + "text": "那個名稱要改過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/387.wav", + "text": "次級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/388.wav", + "text": "然後第1條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/389.wav", + "text": "我先請洪申翰委員講一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/390.wav", + "text": "因為他舉手很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/391.wav", + "text": "礦業管理及地質調查中心組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/392.wav", + "text": "我們其實有提一個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/393.wav", + "text": "對不起這個修正動議的名稱是寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/394.wav", + "text": "經濟部地質與礦業中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/395.wav", + "text": "但我原本的意思應該是要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/396.wav", + "text": "經濟部地質調查與礦業管理中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/397.wav", + "text": "就是把經濟部的原案改成地質調查與礦業管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/398.wav", + "text": "包括第1條也是把地質調查跟礦業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/399.wav", + "text": "這些相關的條文都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/400.wav", + "text": "我就一併講完所以名稱改成經濟部地質調查與礦業管理中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/401.wav", + "text": "第1條改成經濟部為辦理全國地質調查及礦業土石資源管理業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/402.wav", + "text": "特設地質調查與礦業管理中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/403.wav", + "text": "請看我提議的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/404.wav", + "text": "第7款為其他有關地質調查及礦業土石資源及管理事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/405.wav", + "text": "以上是我今天提出的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/406.wav", + "text": "上次所提的修正動議今天好像都沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/407.wav", + "text": "關於第5條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/408.wav", + "text": "之前在協商的時候有提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/409.wav", + "text": "經濟部是不是可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/410.wav", + "text": "這部分就是把名稱對調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/411.wav", + "text": "也就是地質調查及礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/412.wav", + "text": "業管理中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/413.wav", + "text": "所以基本上就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/414.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在是協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/415.wav", + "text": "如果有需要就再提修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/416.wav", + "text": "今天沒有再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/417.wav", + "text": "但還是有這個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/418.wav", + "text": "請把名稱對調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/419.wav", + "text": "經濟部部長要不要簡單回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/420.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員一直很關心地質調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/421.wav", + "text": "放在前或放在後的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/422.wav", + "text": "確實也會涉及到經濟部組織法第2條第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/423.wav", + "text": "以及礦業管理及地質調查中心組織法的全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/424.wav", + "text": "因為它是整套的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/425.wav", + "text": "經濟部就這部分的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/426.wav", + "text": "絕對沒有要矮化地質調查的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/427.wav", + "text": "只是委員一直非常在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/428.wav", + "text": "應該誰在前誰在後的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/429.wav", + "text": "非常非常多的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/430.wav", + "text": "而且一做不是三五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/431.wav", + "text": "可能二十年內都非常忙碌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/432.wav", + "text": "絕對沒有要貶抑地質調查的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/433.wav", + "text": "我先作一個簡單的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/434.wav", + "text": "先請賴委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/435.wav", + "text": "再換陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/436.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/437.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到礦業管理及地質調查中心組織法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/438.wav", + "text": "我們接到一些學界的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/439.wav", + "text": "也還不完全瞭解經濟部現在的政策性方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/440.wav", + "text": "現在條文是全案保留嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/441.wav", + "text": "經濟部是不是應該再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/442.wav", + "text": "再擇期跟學界的朋友們溝通清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/443.wav", + "text": "包括剛剛講到法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/444.wav", + "text": "涵蓋性應該要廣以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/445.wav", + "text": "以及這個中心的核心業務為何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/446.wav", + "text": "應該要把定性訂清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/447.wav", + "text": "今天要審經濟部的好幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/448.wav", + "text": "地調的部分是不是可以暫時再保留一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/449.wav", + "text": "這是我的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/450.wav", + "text": "因為國民黨黨團沒有出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/451.wav", + "text": "\n請陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/452.wav", + "text": "因為照你剛剛說明的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/453.wav", + "text": "反正誰在前誰在後都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/454.wav", + "text": "我在多次質詢中都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/455.wav", + "text": "說明由於整個世界對於地質調查的重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/456.wav", + "text": "而設有地質調查所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/457.wav", + "text": "我們只是維持這個名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/458.wav", + "text": "讓地質調查的重要性能凸顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/459.wav", + "text": "並且不會被矮化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/460.wav", + "text": "我順便講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/461.wav", + "text": "因為我疏忽了所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/462.wav", + "text": "我們沒有再提修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/463.wav", + "text": "還是一樣會再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/464.wav", + "text": "今天我們多個黨團也都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/465.wav", + "text": "把地質調查放在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/466.wav", + "text": "也希望經濟部能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/467.wav", + "text": "剛剛一直有跟各位說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/468.wav", + "text": "因為國民黨團都沒有到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/469.wav", + "text": "基本上還是會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/470.wav", + "text": "有提修正動議再修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/471.wav", + "text": "還有附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/472.wav", + "text": "送院會協商好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/473.wav", + "text": "附帶決議再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/474.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/475.wav", + "text": "我提了二個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/476.wav", + "text": "那二個附帶決議其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/477.wav", + "text": "跟剛剛農業部是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/478.wav", + "text": "為什麼經濟部的部分我們還是要再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/479.wav", + "text": "���界當然是覺得水庫集水區用水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/480.wav", + "text": "跟經濟部是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/481.wav", + "text": "但是事實上經濟部目前的編制人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/482.wav", + "text": "絕對是不夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/483.wav", + "text": "也沒有權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/484.wav", + "text": "也希望經濟部能夠去重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/485.wav", + "text": "能夠講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/486.wav", + "text": "就是希望能夠成立北中南東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/487.wav", + "text": "水庫集水區管理的分署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/488.wav", + "text": "我在院協商也會提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/489.wav", + "text": "只是如果那個困難度更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/490.wav", + "text": "總的疏忽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/491.wav", + "text": "假如經濟部是主要的用水單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/492.wav", + "text": "也希望經濟部能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/493.wav", + "text": "譬如說由水利署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/494.wav", + "text": "因為我之前修正動議的分署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/495.wav", + "text": "是寫在水利署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/496.wav", + "text": "就是比照臺北水源特定區管理單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/497.wav", + "text": "所以還是希望未來的整合移撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/498.wav", + "text": "能夠移撥到水利署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/499.wav", + "text": "在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/500.wav", + "text": "能夠讓水庫集水區的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/501.wav", + "text": "讓一個病入膏肓的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/502.wav", + "text": "能夠有起死回生的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/503.wav", + "text": "剛剛已經有宣讀過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/504.wav", + "text": "還有一個修正再修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/505.wav", + "text": "就一併保留送院會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/506.wav", + "text": "\n謝謝經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/507.wav", + "text": "\n接續進行主題三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/508.wav", + "text": "交通部組織法修正草案等相關法案共9案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/509.wav", + "text": "審查會於4月13日審查完竣審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/510.wav", + "text": "保留條文有交通部組織法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/511.wav", + "text": "第5條交通部觀光署組織法草案第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/512.wav", + "text": "交通部鐵道局組織法修正草案第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/513.wav", + "text": "之前保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/514.wav", + "text": "還是要一併保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/515.wav", + "text": "是統統保留你剛剛沒有唸到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/516.wav", + "text": "保留條文繼續保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/517.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/518.wav", + "text": "其餘均依審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/519.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/520.wav", + "text": "另院會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/521.wav", + "text": "再將委員劉建國等16人擬具交通部中央氣象署組織法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/522.wav", + "text": "等5案分別逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/523.wav", + "text": "及自委員會抽出逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/524.wav", + "text": "與相關提案併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/525.wav", + "text": "主席抱歉抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/526.wav", + "text": "主席經濟部水利署組織法草案保留你有唸嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/527.wav", + "text": "剛剛我沒有聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/528.wav", + "text": "經濟部水利署組織法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/529.wav", + "text": "原有保留的條文全部保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/530.wav", + "text": "再增加二個附帶決議及修正再修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/531.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/532.wav", + "text": "報告委員我是交通部政務次長胡湘麟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/533.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛我沒有寫上我的職稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/534.wav", + "text": "稱這邊跟委員會報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/535.wav", + "text": "剛剛所提的有3個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/536.wav", + "text": "今天要討論的我分別說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/537.wav", + "text": "第一個組織法修正草案第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/538.wav", + "text": "因為這涉及到鐵道局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/539.wav", + "text": "不單是在辦理高鐵車站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/540.wav", + "text": "特定區的場站開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/541.wav", + "text": "還有其他車站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/542.wav", + "text": "能夠照院版文字保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/543.wav", + "text": "交通部觀光署組織法第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/544.wav", + "text": "同時可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/545.wav", + "text": "主要是考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/546.wav", + "text": "能夠可以考慮進用一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/547.wav", + "text": "對於這些個別業務比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/548.wav", + "text": "正常公務人員以外的系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/549.wav", + "text": "\n第三個案子有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/550.wav", + "text": "鐵道局組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/551.wav", + "text": "這部分也是牽扯到職能的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/552.wav", + "text": "除了剛剛談的場站開發之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/553.wav", + "text": "另外有涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/554.wav", + "text": "在執行相關工程建設的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/555.wav", + "text": "因為這部分在執行上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/556.wav", + "text": "過去幾年的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/557.wav", + "text": "如果把鐵道產業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/558.wav", + "text": "有所提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/559.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/560.wav", + "text": "這些都按照院版文字保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/561.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/562.wav", + "text": "陳委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/563.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/564.wav", + "text": "就因為溝通得還不是很完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/565.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/566.wav", + "text": "我們就照原有保留條文繼續保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/567.wav", + "text": "送院會協商好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/568.wav", + "text": "好謝謝次長謝謝交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/569.wav", + "text": "核能安全委員會組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/570.wav", + "text": "草案等相關法案共2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/571.wav", + "text": "審查會於4月24日審查完竣審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/572.wav", + "text": "保留條文有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/573.wav", + "text": "核能安全委員會組織法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/574.wav", + "text": "名稱第1條至第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/575.wav", + "text": "等於是全案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/576.wav", + "text": "國家原子能科技研究院設置條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/577.wav", + "text": "第二章章名及第三條至第四十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/578.wav", + "text": "其餘均依審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/579.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/580.wav", + "text": "另院會再將委員張廖萬堅等22人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/581.wav", + "text": "擬具核能安全委員會組織法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/582.wav", + "text": "等5案分別逕付二讀及自委員會抽出逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/583.wav", + "text": "與相關提案併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/584.wav", + "text": "原子能科技研究院組織法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/585.wav", + "text": "經審視希望能夠依照行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/586.wav", + "text": "保留送院會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/587.wav", + "text": "其實未來的整合或者是協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/588.wav", + "text": "甚至跟地方政府的協調都會出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/589.wav", + "text": "舉個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/590.wav", + "text": "一個三級機構怎麼去做好整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/591.wav", + "text": "還有跟地方政府的協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/592.wav", + "text": "所以還是希望行政院還有人總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/593.wav", + "text": "能夠好好的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/594.wav", + "text": "萬一發生核安問題一個三級單位怎麼去做協調跟整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/595.wav", + "text": "這不是一個很好的組改結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/596.wav", + "text": "就繼續保留送院會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/597.wav", + "text": "因仍有黨團代表未出席討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/598.wav", + "text": "無法達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/599.wav", + "text": "本日協商過程公開發言內容均已錄音錄影並列入紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/600.wav", + "text": "討論過程中有共識之部分將做後續協商依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/601.wav", + "text": "因仍有條文內容留待繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/602.wav", + "text": "依例不做結論簽名後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/603.wav", + "text": "續依立法院職權行使法第十二章相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/604.wav", + "text": "另定期繼續協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14996/605.wav", + "text": "\n今天到此謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14990/0.wav", + "text": "現在開始進行協商本日協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14990/1.wav", + "text": "本席莊瑞雄委員等16人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14990/2.wav", + "text": ")其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14990/3.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14989/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14989/1.wav", + "text": "是不是還是維持本來行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14989/2.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14989/3.wav", + "text": "針對這個法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14989/4.wav", + "text": "合本法或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14989/5.wav", + "text": "者是如果行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14989/6.wav", + "text": "西到底有沒有符合本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14989/7.wav", + "text": "今天也沒有任何的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14989/8.wav", + "text": "行政院的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14989/9.wav", + "text": "請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/0.wav", + "text": "現在開始進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/1.wav", + "text": "本日協商的議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/2.wav", + "text": "是海洋污染防治法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/3.wav", + "text": "併案審查行政院及各黨團委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/4.wav", + "text": "民眾黨黨團提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/5.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/6.wav", + "text": "本席莊瑞雄委員等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/7.wav", + "text": "提案在今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/8.wav", + "text": "院會將會逕付二讀併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/9.wav", + "text": "在此也先納入一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/10.wav", + "text": "待會兒院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/11.wav", + "text": "本案在今年4月19日20日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/12.wav", + "text": "沒有保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/13.wav", + "text": "委員會仍決議須經黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/14.wav", + "text": "請問各位委員各位列席機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/15.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他建議修正意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/16.wav", + "text": "第66條時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/17.wav", + "text": "有提出修正動議(參閱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/18.wav", + "text": "第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/19.wav", + "text": "或本法授權訂定之法規命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/20.wav", + "text": "提起公民訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/21.wav", + "text": "\n這部分是公民團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/22.wav", + "text": "也呼籲了很多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/23.wav", + "text": "因為很多環保法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/24.wav", + "text": "包括環評法水污法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/25.wav", + "text": "在此也希望海委會能夠接納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/26.wav", + "text": "以上說明謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/27.wav", + "text": "其實在我們內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/28.wav", + "text": "大家都很盡心盡力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/29.wav", + "text": "大家花了很多心思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/30.wav", + "text": "坐下來都不斷地針對不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/31.wav", + "text": "針對陳椒華委員剛剛的提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/32.wav", + "text": "來做一個回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/33.wav", + "text": "我們在第66條第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/34.wav", + "text": "當行為人違反的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/35.wav", + "text": "有以下相關的公��訴訟程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/36.wav", + "text": "在其他的環保法規都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/37.wav", + "text": "所以我們在這個地方也比照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/38.wav", + "text": "新提到關於行政機關疏於執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/39.wav", + "text": "但這段的關鍵點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/40.wav", + "text": "沒有特別提到所謂的污染行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/41.wav", + "text": "沒有污染行為人時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/42.wav", + "text": "如果有發生類似海污的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/43.wav", + "text": "其實主管機關都會很積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/44.wav", + "text": "去進行相關的清除和辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/45.wav", + "text": "基本上是沒有疑慮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/46.wav", + "text": "我們查過其他的環保法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/47.wav", + "text": "其實包括環評和水污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/48.wav", + "text": "並沒有看到類似的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/49.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議是不是還是維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/50.wav", + "text": "本來行政院草案的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/51.wav", + "text": "請黃世杰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/52.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳椒華委員的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/53.wav", + "text": "還有各種環保法規的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/54.wav", + "text": "有一些公民團體確實非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/55.wav", + "text": "用力在推這一類的公民訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/56.wav", + "text": "但是我必須要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/57.wav", + "text": "因為我有跟他們討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/58.wav", + "text": "這在我國的現行法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/59.wav", + "text": "會出現一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/60.wav", + "text": "因為這部分其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/61.wav", + "text": "想要引進美國的公民訴訟體例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/62.wav", + "text": "例這邊的問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/63.wav", + "text": "所謂的疏於執行本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/64.wav", + "text": "或本法授權訂定之法規命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/65.wav", + "text": "者到底是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/66.wav", + "text": "因為他們之前提來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/67.wav", + "text": "其實是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/68.wav", + "text": "如果法律要求你固定一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/69.wav", + "text": "他們想要針對這個法規命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/70.wav", + "text": "本身是否符合本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/71.wav", + "text": "都一直不去把它訂出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/72.wav", + "text": "他們要有一個課予義務的訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/73.wav", + "text": "又由法院來令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/74.wav", + "text": "令行政機關趕快來訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/75.wav", + "text": "或是訂定符合該法規的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/76.wav", + "text": "可是這部分在我國法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/77.wav", + "text": "是沒有辦法去做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/78.wav", + "text": "的法規命令訂定程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/79.wav", + "text": "都沒有應行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/80.wav", + "text": "在母法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/81.wav", + "text": "訂一個審查的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/82.wav", + "text": "不然法院受理這種訴訟它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/83.wav", + "text": "它要怎麼去審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/84.wav", + "text": "你訂的東西到底有沒有符合本法或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/85.wav", + "text": "者後面就會牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/86.wav", + "text": "SocialPolicy" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/87.wav", + "text": "即社會政策是否應由法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/88.wav", + "text": "作為決策機關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/89.wav", + "text": "\n所以我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/90.wav", + "text": "因為誠如剛剛召委所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/91.wav", + "text": "我們在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/92.wav", + "text": "很進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/93.wav", + "text": "但是在對於整個行政法的體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/94.wav", + "text": "可能都還有疑慮的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/95.wav", + "text": "我建議還是依照行政院原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/96.wav", + "text": "原來的版本通過會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/97.wav", + "text": "關於相關公民團體所重視的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/98.wav", + "text": "其中包括一些開發案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/99.wav", + "text": "或是一些違反法規的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/100.wav", + "text": "許多是政府單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/101.wav", + "text": "這是團體們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/102.wav", + "text": "誠如剛剛黃委員及署長說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/103.wav", + "text": "我們時代力量是幫團體表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/104.wav", + "text": "這樣的情形有其嚴重性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/105.wav", + "text": "也希望海委會海保署能夠重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/106.wav", + "text": "今天也沒有任何的保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/107.wav", + "text": "我們就是表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/108.wav", + "text": "意見也希望後續能夠針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/109.wav", + "text": "各黨團沒有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/110.wav", + "text": "第66條就按照行政院的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/111.wav", + "text": "因為其他黨團也沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/112.wav", + "text": "附帶決議1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/113.wav", + "text": "1時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/114.wav", + "text": "附帶決議1經過溝通以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/115.wav", + "text": "後我們曾經有一些修改的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/116.wav", + "text": "所以現在的這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/117.wav", + "text": "我們可以遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/118.wav", + "text": "剩下的就是三個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/119.wav", + "text": "要完成指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/120.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠延長到五個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/121.wav", + "text": "可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/122.wav", + "text": "修正通過\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/123.wav", + "text": "附帶決議2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/124.wav", + "text": "個月附帶決議2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/125.wav", + "text": "再修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/126.wav", + "text": "\n處理附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/127.wav", + "text": "我們可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/128.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/129.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/130.wav", + "text": "也是修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/131.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/132.wav", + "text": "附帶決議三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/133.wav", + "text": "會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/134.wav", + "text": "\n在海洋三法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/135.wav", + "text": "很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/136.wav", + "text": "其他海保的部分我們再看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/137.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/138.wav", + "text": "跟召委和各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/139.wav", + "text": "幾個條文是我們上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/140.wav", + "text": "配合處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/141.wav", + "text": "第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/142.wav", + "text": "新增第六款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/143.wav", + "text": "其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/144.wav", + "text": "第六款補助及獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/145.wav", + "text": "海洋污染防治研究及技術開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/146.wav", + "text": "我們後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/147.wav", + "text": "要修正成補助與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/148.wav", + "text": "就加個與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/149.wav", + "text": "將補助『及』" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/150.wav", + "text": "就是用字用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/151.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/152.wav", + "text": "好還有第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/153.wav", + "text": "海域或這三個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/154.wav", + "text": "第四十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/155.wav", + "text": "刪除海域或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/156.wav", + "text": "或第五十五條第一項第三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/157.wav", + "text": "跟同條說明欄第四項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/158.wav", + "text": "也要刪除海域或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/159.wav", + "text": "這些都是配合文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/160.wav", + "text": "有授權就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/161.wav", + "text": "授權以後我們提交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/162.wav", + "text": "好你們把它整理一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/163.wav", + "text": "對法制用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/164.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/165.wav", + "text": "除了文字修正外還有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/166.wav", + "text": "來\n管主委去海委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/167.wav", + "text": "如果做得有聲有色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/168.wav", + "text": "也是內政委員會的榮譽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/169.wav", + "text": "我們都大力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/170.wav", + "text": "我們有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/171.wav", + "text": "我們的海巡跟馬來西亞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/172.wav", + "text": "有國際合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/173.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/174.wav", + "text": "等一下請大家重簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/175.wav", + "text": "法制用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/176.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/177.wav", + "text": "出席的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/178.wav", + "text": "海洋女神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/179.wav", + "text": "主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14988/180.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/0.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1.wav", + "text": "函送立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/2.wav", + "text": "擴建基地評選分析報告案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/3.wav", + "text": "社會福利基本法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/4.wav", + "text": "等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/5.wav", + "text": "現在開始進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/6.wav", + "text": "第一案為本院總務處函送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/7.wav", + "text": "立法院擴建基地評選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/8.wav", + "text": "分析報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/9.wav", + "text": "雖然是總務性質的院務行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/10.wav", + "text": "但涉及本院全體委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/11.wav", + "text": "循例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/12.wav", + "text": "是要尊重各黨團意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/13.wav", + "text": "過去在第二屆的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/14.wav", + "text": "也有由當時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/15.wav", + "text": "副院長擔任召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/16.wav", + "text": "各黨團依政黨比例推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/17.wav", + "text": "院址的推動和討論的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/18.wav", + "text": "循此精神針對總務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/19.wav", + "text": "的分析報告我們就單純" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/20.wav", + "text": "依前例組成委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/21.wav", + "text": "將分析報告交予委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/22.wav", + "text": "以開放的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/23.wav", + "text": "進行後續討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/24.wav", + "text": "三將來委員會討論完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/25.wav", + "text": "其結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/26.wav", + "text": "再由我和各位黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/27.wav", + "text": "鞭進行朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/28.wav", + "text": "最後再由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/29.wav", + "text": "院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/30.wav", + "text": "四我先唸一下協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/31.wav", + "text": "草稿給各黨團簽署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/32.wav", + "text": "如果有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/33.wav", + "text": "我們再來修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/34.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/35.wav", + "text": "112年5月3日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/36.wav", + "text": "決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/37.wav", + "text": "一有關總務處函送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/38.wav", + "text": "立法院擴建基地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/39.wav", + "text": "評選分析報告一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/40.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/41.wav", + "text": "國會擴建規劃暨監督委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/42.wav", + "text": "進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/43.wav", + "text": "以院長為召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/44.wav", + "text": "其餘委員依政黨比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/45.wav", + "text": "由民進黨黨團推派6人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/46.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團推派4人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/47.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/48.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團各推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/49.wav", + "text": "1人組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/50.wav", + "text": "名單請於5月18日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/51.wav", + "text": "(星期四)中午12時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/52.wav", + "text": "送至議事處彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/53.wav", + "text": "本案於委員會完成討論後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/54.wav", + "text": "其結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/55.wav", + "text": "先由院長召集黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/56.wav", + "text": "再送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/57.wav", + "text": "相關工作人員由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/58.wav", + "text": "本院總務處公報處議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/59.wav", + "text": "游院長到各地去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/60.wav", + "text": "訪視的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/61.wav", + "text": "基本上我都有參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/62.wav", + "text": "我也肯定游院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/63.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/64.wav", + "text": "其實以中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/65.wav", + "text": "高達2兆7,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/66.wav", + "text": "地標的立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/67.wav", + "text": "是輕而易舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/68.wav", + "text": "建好之後第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/69.wav", + "text": "會有很多訪賓來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/70.wav", + "text": "其實是多重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/71.wav", + "text": "也會增進該地區的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/72.wav", + "text": "這是好事一件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/73.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/74.wav", + "text": "基本上是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/75.wav", + "text": "這個大方向這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/76.wav", + "text": "\n第二點我倒是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/77.wav", + "text": "覺得召集人由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/78.wav", + "text": "很長一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/79.wav", + "text": "了副院長都沒有參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/80.wav", + "text": "所以我建議召集人還是由院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/81.wav", + "text": "擔任因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/82.wav", + "text": "做了三分之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/83.wav", + "text": "中間給副院長插進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/84.wav", + "text": "他只有臺中場才有參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/85.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/86.wav", + "text": "敦請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/87.wav", + "text": "委員會的召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/88.wav", + "text": "朝野協商時再來朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/89.wav", + "text": "我是做這樣的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/90.wav", + "text": "尤其既然朝野都有參與了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/91.wav", + "text": "到朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/92.wav", + "text": "時我覺得問題不會太大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/93.wav", + "text": "所以我很慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/94.wav", + "text": "也很誠懇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/95.wav", + "text": "我就是希望這個召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/96.wav", + "text": "還是麻煩院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/97.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/98.wav", + "text": "立法院的擴建或遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/99.wav", + "text": "這30年來在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/100.wav", + "text": "或多或少都有討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/101.wav", + "text": "在82年5月就審總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/102.wav", + "text": "那時吵了很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/103.wav", + "text": "後來把這個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/104.wav", + "text": "砍掉停建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/105.wav", + "text": "那時也有各種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/106.wav", + "text": "什麼論點都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/107.wav", + "text": "店等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/108.wav", + "text": "所有立法院院長都有思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/109.wav", + "text": "這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/110.wav", + "text": "王金平院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/111.wav", + "text": "乃至於今天的游院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/112.wav", + "text": "也包括前任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/113.wav", + "text": "花了最多苦心和意志力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/114.wav", + "text": "他很想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/115.wav", + "text": "完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/116.wav", + "text": "\n身為國會議員我們當然都曾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/117.wav", + "text": "場每一個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/118.wav", + "text": "的議場都是代表國家的象徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/119.wav", + "text": "管是美國還是日本我想大家都看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/120.wav", + "text": "美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/121.wav", + "text": "地鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/122.wav", + "text": "自民國38年遷臺以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/123.wav", + "text": "最早是在中山堂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/124.wav", + "text": "所以當初並不是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/125.wav", + "text": "國會所建立但也沿用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/126.wav", + "text": "到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/127.wav", + "text": "225席現在是113" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/128.wav", + "text": "人這很驚人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/129.wav", + "text": "當然平常你們看不到人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/130.wav", + "text": "在委員會開會時才看到一些職員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/131.wav", + "text": "\n我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/132.wav", + "text": "各縣市去查看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/133.wav", + "text": "等我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/134.wav", + "text": "們今天只是面對一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/135.wav", + "text": "當一位國會議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/136.wav", + "text": "在民國八十幾年時預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/137.wav", + "text": "從三百零多編到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/138.wav", + "text": "兩百四十左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/139.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/140.wav", + "text": "更加困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/141.wav", + "text": "現在是在講擴建案還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/142.wav", + "text": "還是擴建案我們這裡會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/143.wav", + "text": "是在外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/144.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/145.wav", + "text": "游院長上次有談過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/146.wav", + "text": "牽涉到文化部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/147.wav", + "text": "及院際的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/148.wav", + "text": "這一屆第一個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/149.wav", + "text": "後來這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/150.wav", + "text": "時交給總務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/151.wav", + "text": "\n過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/152.wav", + "text": "也牽扯到幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/153.wav", + "text": "這個委員會絕對是特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/154.wav", + "text": "第10條有紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/155.wav", + "text": "紀律委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/156.wav", + "text": "修憲委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/157.wav", + "text": "第10條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/158.wav", + "text": "特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/159.wav", + "text": "這就是要以特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/160.wav", + "text": "講的就是林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/161.wav", + "text": "2000年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/162.wav", + "text": "民進黨執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/163.wav", + "text": "有人在立法院提案成立兩岸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/164.wav", + "text": "事務小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/165.wav", + "text": "立法院也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/166.wav", + "text": "兩岸的事務並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/167.wav", + "text": "立法院能夠完全主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/168.wav", + "text": "那牽涉到國安等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/169.wav", + "text": "民進黨執政國民黨當然想在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/170.wav", + "text": "題目上發揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/171.wav", + "text": "箝制執政黨的兩岸政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/172.wav", + "text": "雖然兩岸政策事務小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/173.wav", + "text": "有成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/174.wav", + "text": "但是成立以後運作不了了之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/175.wav", + "text": "為什麼有這個小組成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/176.wav", + "text": "這是比照1997年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/177.wav", + "text": "(民國86年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/178.wav", + "text": "所以立法院有成立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/179.wav", + "text": "加入WTO" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/180.wav", + "text": "由立法院各黨團成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/181.wav", + "text": "進行各種修法等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/182.wav", + "text": "\n我講這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/183.wav", + "text": "立法院要好好來討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/184.wav", + "text": "我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/185.wav", + "text": "實在很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/186.wav", + "text": "在這裡用特種委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/187.wav", + "text": "我看立法院常常有委員提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/188.wav", + "text": "有關於勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/189.wav", + "text": "什麼年金改革特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/190.wav", + "text": "等等我們先講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/191.wav", + "text": "在這個地方就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/192.wav", + "text": "應該把擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/193.wav", + "text": "那個小組的研發成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/194.wav", + "text": "要給大家現場稍微瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/195.wav", + "text": "現在拿得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/196.wav", + "text": "沒有先prepare" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/197.wav", + "text": "就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/198.wav", + "text": "成立特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/199.wav", + "text": "下不為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/200.wav", + "text": "其他再來什麼特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/201.wav", + "text": "其實坦白講都很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/202.wav", + "text": "因為立法院各委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/203.wav", + "text": "組織法說得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/204.wav", + "text": "要派政黨比例代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/205.wav", + "text": "以前的小組也是照這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/206.wav", + "text": "方式WTO那個小組也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/207.wav", + "text": "成立特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/208.wav", + "text": "一大堆特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/209.wav", + "text": "還要定義特種委員大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/210.wav", + "text": "家要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/211.wav", + "text": "在這種精神底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/212.wav", + "text": "過去是連預算都編列進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/213.wav", + "text": "─1993年是連預算都編進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/214.wav", + "text": "是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/215.wav", + "text": "審查中央政府總預算的時候被刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/216.wav", + "text": "那時候朝野對立很厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/217.wav", + "text": "也曾經被討論編進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/218.wav", + "text": "當然現在我們不能說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/219.wav", + "text": "現在是九牛一毛啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/220.wav", + "text": "我們的廳舍能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/221.wav", + "text": "有一個比較像樣的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/222.wav", + "text": "問題我希望下禮拜能夠安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/223.wav", + "text": "立法院組織法修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/224.wav", + "text": "包括國際事務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/225.wav", + "text": "有一些很努力的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/226.wav", + "text": "與想法我們都很敬佩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/227.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/228.wav", + "text": "���然下會期才能開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/229.wav", + "text": "在短暫的半會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/230.wav", + "text": "總預算審完以後接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/231.wav", + "text": "變成政府真正的行政措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/232.wav", + "text": "也是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/233.wav", + "text": "我不知道這樣講可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/234.wav", + "text": "我起一個頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/235.wav", + "text": "這一屆不編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/236.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法編預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/237.wav", + "text": "都被刪掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/238.wav", + "text": "搞這個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/239.wav", + "text": "不想反攻大陸臺灣獨立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/240.wav", + "text": "我們都為了這件大事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/241.wav", + "text": "為了效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/242.wav", + "text": "我現在是把所有可能的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/243.wav", + "text": "真的需要遷就快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/244.wav", + "text": "一點愈慢遷成本愈高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/245.wav", + "text": "合適的地方愈少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/246.wav", + "text": "就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/247.wav", + "text": "國民黨給你支持你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/248.wav", + "text": "成立國會擴建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/249.wav", + "text": "規劃暨監督委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/250.wav", + "text": "也支持院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/251.wav", + "text": "擔任召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/252.wav", + "text": "下不為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/253.wav", + "text": "是不是要解散落日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/254.wav", + "text": "成立之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/255.wav", + "text": "之前有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/256.wav", + "text": "邀請一些專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/257.wav", + "text": "包括中正紀念堂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/258.wav", + "text": "空總華山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/259.wav", + "text": "藝文特區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/260.wav", + "text": "時力認為適合的地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/261.wav", + "text": "要有幾個特性包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/262.wav", + "text": "包括廣大的腹地空間便捷的交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/263.wav", + "text": "來表達意見的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/264.wav", + "text": "人具高度民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/265.wav", + "text": "以這樣的前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/266.wav", + "text": "滿適合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/267.wav", + "text": "地點剛剛我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/268.wav", + "text": "也看到時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/269.wav", + "text": "時力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/270.wav", + "text": "等在野黨也有名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/271.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/272.wav", + "text": "表達支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/273.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/274.wav", + "text": "黨鞭民眾黨的主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/275.wav", + "text": "的主張很簡單我們當然支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/276.wav", + "text": "這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/277.wav", + "text": "諮詢委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/278.wav", + "text": "也有七次的專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/279.wav", + "text": "及六次的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/280.wav", + "text": "剛才柯總召在談這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/281.wav", + "text": "特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/282.wav", + "text": "我覺得可以商榷一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/283.wav", + "text": "要是把它變成真的很正式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/284.wav", + "text": "這一屆國會就會到這邊結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/285.wav", + "text": "假如變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/286.wav", + "text": "比較有效地運作又變成是下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/287.wav", + "text": "組成這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/288.wav", + "text": "到底能不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/289.wav", + "text": "前面這個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/290.wav", + "text": "這件事一定要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/291.wav", + "text": "最重要的功能就是提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/292.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/293.wav", + "text": "把政策方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/294.wav", + "text": "定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/295.wav", + "text": "表決做最終的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/296.wav", + "text": "它到底該不該是一個特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/297.wav", + "text": "要不要這樣子勞師動眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/298.wav", + "text": "我覺得反而不一定要這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/299.wav", + "text": "就不會是柯總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/300.wav", + "text": "我們好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/301.wav", + "text": "又多設或者怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/302.wav", + "text": "如果我們真的想趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/303.wav", + "text": "叫做擴建規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/304.wav", + "text": "暨監督委員會我比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/305.wav", + "text": "它怎麼負監督的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/306.wav", + "text": "有監督嗎還是它就是規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/307.wav", + "text": "總務處要不要先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/308.wav", + "text": "報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/309.wav", + "text": "有關未來這個特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/310.wav", + "text": "加一個監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/311.wav", + "text": "是讓這個委員會監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/312.wav", + "text": "工作小組包括剛才院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/313.wav", + "text": "宣讀的總務處公報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/314.wav", + "text": "處議事處等等是針對我們這些幕僚小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/315.wav", + "text": "我們把這些工作做完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/316.wav", + "text": "送到這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/317.wav", + "text": "給各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/318.wav", + "text": "再送到大會它監督的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/319.wav", + "text": "絕對有監督的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/320.wav", + "text": "是不是照剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/321.wav", + "text": "這個草稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/322.wav", + "text": "事實上它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/323.wav", + "text": "因為我們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/324.wav", + "text": "分析了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/325.wav", + "text": "作業事實上都做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/326.wav", + "text": "了做這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/327.wav", + "text": "只有一個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/328.wav", + "text": "就是選一個地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/329.wav", + "text": "這屆只要選地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/330.wav", + "text": "地點選定以後下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/331.wav", + "text": "的院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/332.wav", + "text": "定怎麼興建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/333.wav", + "text": "工程的部分就交給他們了看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/334.wav", + "text": "要怎麼規劃要不要開國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/335.wav", + "text": "怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/336.wav", + "text": "我們這一屆如果能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/337.wav", + "text": "把地點定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/338.wav", + "text": "就功德圓滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/339.wav", + "text": "了所以這個委員會事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/340.wav", + "text": "而已其中有26個地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/341.wav", + "text": "可以看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/342.wav", + "text": "而且是用科學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/343.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/344.wav", + "text": "院長當召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/345.wav", + "text": "無庸置疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/346.wav", + "text": "針對這是特種委員會還是一個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/347.wav", + "text": "如果是依照立法院組織法第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/348.wav", + "text": "成立的特種委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/349.wav", + "text": "要有組織規程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/350.wav", + "text": "很多都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/351.wav", + "text": "一般委員會就是小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/352.wav", + "text": "們自己取的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/353.wav", + "text": "我剛才的發言其實就是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/354.wav", + "text": "就是說如果是特種的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/355.wav", + "text": "比小組位子高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/356.wav", + "text": "但不是regular組織法裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/357.wav", + "text": "假如這樣的話就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/358.wav", + "text": "那第二個就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/359.wav", + "text": "不管是特種委員會或任何委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/360.wav", + "text": "立法院任何法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/361.wav", + "text": "本來就是屆期不連續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/362.wav", + "text": "我們這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/363.wav", + "text": "這又是一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/364.wav", + "text": "我也可以選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/365.wav", + "text": "至少往前在規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/366.wav", + "text": "在推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/367.wav", + "text": "只有這個意義而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/368.wav", + "text": "內容是什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/369.wav", + "text": "有改嗎有改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/370.wav", + "text": "那就進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/371.wav", + "text": "以及行政院人事行政總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/372.wav", + "text": "現在我們要進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/373.wav", + "text": "在進行協商前有關本次協商的社會福利基本法草案等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/374.wav", + "text": "社會福利及衛生環境委員會召委吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/375.wav", + "text": "於4月26日召集黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/376.wav", + "text": "僅保留行政院提案第4條及第十九條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/377.wav", + "text": "其餘條文皆獲協商共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/378.wav", + "text": "因此為爭取立法時效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/379.wav", + "text": "本席徵詢各位協商代表之同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/380.wav", + "text": "本次協商擬從保留之行政院提案第4條及第十九條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/381.wav", + "text": "先進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/382.wav", + "text": "如各位協商代表對已在委員會完成之協商條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/383.wav", + "text": "容有疑義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/384.wav", + "text": "後面我們討論的時候再進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/385.wav", + "text": "請問各位委員這樣可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/386.wav", + "text": "那我們現在就開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/387.wav", + "text": "社會福利基本法草案保留的第4條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/388.wav", + "text": "針對第4條看大家的意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/389.wav", + "text": "我先來說明第4條的部分嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/390.wav", + "text": "第4條就是看大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/391.wav", + "text": "有意見要請教時再請你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/392.wav", + "text": "對第4條如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/393.wav", + "text": "我們是不是依照衛福部建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/394.wav", + "text": "就照行政院院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/395.wav", + "text": "關於時代力量黨團版本之前在委員會討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/396.wav", + "text": "其實有滿多委員也一直覺得應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/397.wav", + "text": "一起來重視原因就在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/398.wav", + "text": "之所以稱為社會福利基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/399.wav", + "text": "基本法是一個比較上位涵蓋較廣的概念在此情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/400.wav", + "text": "有一些我覺得具指標性及意涵的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/401.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團版本第4條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/402.wav", + "text": "跟院版的差異主要是是來自於消除一切形式歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/403.wav", + "text": "原本都希望能夠具備的概念性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/404.wav", + "text": "因為後面所列舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/405.wav", + "text": "的包括性別性傾向性別認同等部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/406.wav", + "text": "可能會有掛一漏萬的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/407.wav", + "text": "的狀況所以我們會希望在開頭的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/408.wav", + "text": "就已經把消除一些歧視的部分放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/409.wav", + "text": "或者是一些協助之申請的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/410.wav", + "text": "常常會遇到的是整體上包括民間主流的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/411.wav", + "text": "或者有時候甚至是承辦人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/412.wav", + "text": "會有一個想像覺得好像必須要是看起來很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/413.wav", + "text": "才會認為他符合這種辛苦的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/414.wav", + "text": "或是很難生存的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/415.wav", + "text": "然後才願意給予協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/416.wav", + "text": "我們希望當我們在談論這個基本法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/417.wav", + "text": "放進去避免未來我們在操作相關補助或協助的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/418.wav", + "text": "從外觀外貌上看不到一個人的匱乏就覺得他不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/419.wav", + "text": "因此時代力量黨團還是滿希望能夠堅持這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/420.wav", + "text": "但我覺得這個上位的概念還是必須要放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/421.wav", + "text": "不然就由衛福部說明針對王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/422.wav", + "text": "有必要加容貌體態嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/423.wav", + "text": "沒有我剛剛提到的是過去其實大家都會有一個想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/424.wav", + "text": "主流上還是會有歧視的情況就是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/425.wav", + "text": "他貧窮或是辛苦就要有一個貧窮的樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/426.wav", + "text": "導致他們在申請相關補助上的確遇到一些困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/427.wav", + "text": "我覺得文字措辭可以看怎麼樣形容是大家覺得比較合理可以接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/428.wav", + "text": "謝謝有關委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/429.wav", + "text": "對於要不要把消除一切形式歧視放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/430.wav", + "text": "我上次在委員會有跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/431.wav", + "text": "其實我們去查本國的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/432.wav", + "text": "大概只有消除對婦女的一切形式歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/433.wav", + "text": "還有對種族的歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/434.wav", + "text": "那個法的本義就是在消除各式各樣的歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/435.wav", + "text": "是在確保所有的民眾所有的國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/436.wav", + "text": "如果要消除一切的歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/437.wav", + "text": "它不會是在這個法裡面去處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/438.wav", + "text": "是不是要有一個完整的不歧視的法或者是平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/439.wav", + "text": "我是覺得應該要回到這樣一個專門的法規去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/440.wav", + "text": "是不是可以不要增加所謂的消除一切形式歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/441.wav", + "text": "\n第二個就是外觀或外貌這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/442.wav", + "text": "其實單純講外觀或外貌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/443.wav", + "text": "因為對我們來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/444.wav", + "text": "我們可能想到的外觀外貌反而是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/445.wav", + "text": "身障者的外貌是否和大家不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/446.wav", + "text": "可是我要講的是所有福利的提供都不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/447.wav", + "text": "看他的外貌還是看他的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/448.wav", + "text": "或中低收入戶也都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/449.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂的一定是什麼樣的形象才是低收或中低收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/450.wav", + "text": "啦所以我覺得委員如果擔心我們在福利提供的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/451.wav", + "text": "是否會有一些刻板印象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/452.wav", + "text": "這部分是不是可以採附帶決議的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/453.wav", + "text": "也能夠有這樣的觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/454.wav", + "text": "而不是在法規裡面增加這樣一個類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/455.wav", + "text": "王委員用附帶決議可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/456.wav", + "text": "如果附帶決議都已經可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/457.wav", + "text": "其實在法規上加這一項也沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/458.wav", + "text": "我們希望大家都有一個一律平等的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/459.wav", + "text": "既然性別性傾向族群等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/460.wav", + "text": "也是希望能夠達到一律平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/461.wav", + "text": "我們只是多加了一個可能在實務現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/462.wav", + "text": "我不太認為也不理解如果站在平等的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/463.wav", + "text": "為什麼我剛才提到的這些可以放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/464.wav", + "text": "然後所謂的外觀容貌又或者是外貌體態(這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/465.wav", + "text": "衛福部使用的字眼)等等不能放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/466.wav", + "text": "差別在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/467.wav", + "text": "因為這些的確都是不應該造成差異的原因之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/468.wav", + "text": "尤其是我們剛剛提到的在實務現場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/469.wav", + "text": "相對來說可能比起性別性傾向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/470.wav", + "text": "傾向族群更容易發生的就是外貌體態的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/471.wav", + "text": "召集人要不要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/472.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/473.wav", + "text": "一直很強調外貌體態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/474.wav", + "text": "可是因為外貌體態這4個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/475.wav", + "text": "寫出來我們大家的想像都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/476.wav", + "text": "原來講的是好手好腳的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/477.wav", + "text": "我們的福利輸送沒辦法達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/478.wav", + "text": "其實會更容易讓大家有不同的想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/479.wav", + "text": "所以才建議不要這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/480.wav", + "text": "\n可是對於今天衛福部提出來的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/481.wav", + "text": "我也覺得稍微有一點意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/482.wav", + "text": "我覺得如果要這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/483.wav", + "text": "其實最重要的是在社會福利的相關事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/484.wav", + "text": "相關工作人員在提供福利的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/485.wav", + "text": "是依照相關法規而且本於專業的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/486.wav", + "text": "應該是因為專業的評估而去提供適當的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/487.wav", + "text": "所以我反而覺得國民無分性別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/488.wav", + "text": "這些其實可以拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/489.wav", + "text": "民接受社會福利的機會應該一律平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/490.wav", + "text": "各級政府社會福利事業單位及相關專業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/491.wav", + "text": "在提供服務的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/492.wav", + "text": "應依相關法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/493.wav", + "text": "提供適切服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/494.wav", + "text": "條文裡面的文字再敘述一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/495.wav", + "text": "社會福利的提供應該是以專業的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/496.wav", + "text": "提供適切服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/497.wav", + "text": "這應該是最高原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/498.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/499.wav", + "text": "我想在第1項的部分就是國家應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/500.wav", + "text": "肯認多元文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/501.wav", + "text": "然後最後一句是接受社會福利之機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/502.wav", + "text": "一律平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/503.wav", + "text": "我們接受平等的這樣一個內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/504.wav", + "text": "或者是我們加進來的容貌體態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/505.wav", + "text": "那我針對容貌體態來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/506.wav", + "text": "大家非常重視外表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/507.wav", + "text": "譬如高矮胖瘦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/508.wav", + "text": "不只是所謂好手好腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/509.wav", + "text": "尤其是外觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/510.wav", + "text": "膚色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/511.wav", + "text": "這些大概都是容貌體態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/512.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們把這個入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/513.wav", + "text": "如果這部分入法以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/514.wav", + "text": "我們就會更容易去強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/515.wav", + "text": "你不必太在意你的高矮胖瘦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/516.wav", + "text": "接受社會福利機會一律平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/517.wav", + "text": "符合現代我們所面臨到的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/518.wav", + "text": "而容貌體態的確是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/519.wav", + "text": "我們這一代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/520.wav", + "text": "譬如有些人比較胖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/521.wav", + "text": "他就容易被歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/522.wav", + "text": "這個目前的確是存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/523.wav", + "text": "所以很多人特別強調要去改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/524.wav", + "text": "或者是壓抑他自己的容貌體態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/525.wav", + "text": "然後去贏取別人的喜歡等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/526.wav", + "text": "所以還是建議能夠把容貌體態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/527.wav", + "text": "另外我也想再請教一下衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/528.wav", + "text": "基本上我們當然理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/529.wav", + "text": "我們希望這些機會和福利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/530.wav", + "text": "接受可能性是一律平等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/531.wav", + "text": "但却不寫外貌體態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/532.wav", + "text": "這個差異和這個選擇的標的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/533.wav", + "text": "其實我也覺得有點疑惑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/534.wav", + "text": "那宗教這些其實都不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/535.wav", + "text": "啊我們如何在列舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/536.wav", + "text": "只提某些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/537.wav", + "text": "比如說像剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/538.wav", + "text": "老實講我覺得對於社經地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/539.wav", + "text": "或者是政治理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/540.wav", + "text": "大家的想像也會不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/541.wav", + "text": "所以我想知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/542.wav", + "text": "衛福部當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/543.wav", + "text": "或是院版當初提這個法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/544.wav", + "text": "如何去取決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/545.wav", + "text": "哪些列舉需要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/546.wav", + "text": "哪些列舉不需要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/547.wav", + "text": "請衛福部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/548.wav", + "text": "很多的人權公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/549.wav", + "text": "像CRCCRPD等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/550.wav", + "text": "它都有一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/551.wav", + "text": "所謂的不歧視平等原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/552.wav", + "text": "接受福利的機會一律平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/553.wav", + "text": "方面有時候可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/554.wav", + "text": "還要再多一點的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/555.wav", + "text": "年齡的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/556.wav", + "text": "我們還要有不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/557.wav", + "text": "社會福利平等的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/558.wav", + "text": "我們要針對不同的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/559.wav", + "text": "不同的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/560.wav", + "text": "它才能夠得到平等的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/561.wav", + "text": "比較是一個平等的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/562.wav", + "text": "是站在這樣一個立場來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/563.wav", + "text": "其實外貌外觀這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/564.wav", + "text": "確實我們看過其他的公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/565.wav", + "text": "都還沒有這樣一個型態進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/566.wav", + "text": "聽起來大家對這個詞的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/567.wav", + "text": "見解又非常不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/568.wav", + "text": "回到剛剛吳委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/569.wav", + "text": "其實我們就應該回歸到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/570.wav", + "text": "這個應該才是最實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/571.wav", + "text": "兩公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/572.wav", + "text": "國際公約第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/573.wav", + "text": "就有把膚色納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/574.wav", + "text": "我們這邊是用種族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/575.wav", + "text": "但是這裡也有種族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/576.wav", + "text": "啊第2條第1款就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/577.wav", + "text": "代表種族和膚色是兩回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/578.wav", + "text": "所以如果能把膚色容貌體態納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/579.wav", + "text": "的話就會更周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/580.wav", + "text": "把容貌體態納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/581.wav", + "text": "好像就會讓容貌體態的歧視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/582.wav", + "text": "一直存在否則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/583.wav", + "text": "否則社會上並沒有這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/584.wav", + "text": "─接受社會福利的機會一律平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/585.wav", + "text": "剛才次長也講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/586.wav", + "text": "不同的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/587.wav", + "text": "機構本來就cover了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/588.wav", + "text": "為什麼在這裡一定要加入容貌體態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/589.wav", + "text": "是從哪裡來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/590.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/591.wav", + "text": "哪個地方有容貌體態這樣的文字如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/592.wav", + "text": "國家應認同多元文化但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/593.wav", + "text": "另一個觀念的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/594.wav", + "text": "所以我對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/595.wav", + "text": "容貌體態非常不解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/596.wav", + "text": "好像我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/597.wav", + "text": "老人會受到歧視嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/598.wav", + "text": "社會福利機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/599.wav", + "text": "服務的機會一律平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/600.wav", + "text": "難道我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/601.wav", + "text": "好像我們國家有這個問題一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/602.wav", + "text": "4個字到底是從哪裡來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/603.wav", + "text": "你看起來沒有餓到啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/604.wav", + "text": "你有需要申請嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/605.wav", + "text": "你看起來生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/606.wav", + "text": "有需要申請嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/607.wav", + "text": "是對如果照你剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/608.wav", + "text": "如果認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/609.wav", + "text": "不是我們在立法時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/610.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/611.wav", + "text": "我也認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/612.wav", + "text": "所以我們是不是可以回來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/613.wav", + "text": "哪些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/614.wav", + "text": "差異的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/615.wav", + "text": "的性別或社經地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/616.wav", + "text": "所以我們要不要回來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/617.wav", + "text": "哪些部分要同時一起刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/618.wav", + "text": "我必須老實講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/619.wav", + "text": "我實在是看不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/620.wav", + "text": "哪些東西要放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/621.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/622.wav", + "text": "我可以先發言嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/623.wav", + "text": "剛剛次長有解��如果要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/624.wav", + "text": "一樣一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/625.wav", + "text": "加或一樣一樣刪減的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/626.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/627.wav", + "text": "這樣可能很難處理吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/628.wav", + "text": "我沒有堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/629.wav", + "text": "而不要放那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/630.wav", + "text": "常常是政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/631.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法接受別人的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/632.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分還是要回到理論上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/633.wav", + "text": "我覺得我也能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/634.wav", + "text": "比如社經地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/635.wav", + "text": "又或者是性別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/636.wav", + "text": "提供的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/637.wav", + "text": "不同待遇的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/638.wav", + "text": "其實可以列出這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/639.wav", + "text": "差異性的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/640.wav", + "text": "列這幾項就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/641.wav", + "text": "其他都不要列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/642.wav", + "text": "不然我實在不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/643.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的政治理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/644.wav", + "text": "在上面地域的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/645.wav", + "text": "政治理念的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/646.wav", + "text": "放上去過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/647.wav", + "text": "為什麼這邊要放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/648.wav", + "text": "而實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/649.wav", + "text": "這跟本黨不是太有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/650.wav", + "text": "還是講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/651.wav", + "text": "也不太懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/652.wav", + "text": "我覺得衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/653.wav", + "text": "直接這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/654.wav", + "text": "說實話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/655.wav", + "text": "所有國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/656.wav", + "text": "接受社會福利之機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/657.wav", + "text": "會一律平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/658.wav", + "text": "就可以結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/659.wav", + "text": "今天要把所有東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/660.wav", + "text": "都放上去或都不放上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/661.wav", + "text": "就永遠都走不出這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/662.wav", + "text": "樣就落入套套邏輯中了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/663.wav", + "text": "就最好都不要排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/664.wav", + "text": "或有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/665.wav", + "text": "會拿這一條來跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/666.wav", + "text": "為什麼我有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/667.wav", + "text": "我就不能領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/668.wav", + "text": "或是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/669.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/670.wav", + "text": "寫得愈多反而愈麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/671.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/672.wav", + "text": "排富不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/673.wav", + "text": "福利就有排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/674.wav", + "text": "有些是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/675.wav", + "text": "這裡所講的社經地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/676.wav", + "text": "高的和低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/677.wav", + "text": "我們當然對低的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/678.wav", + "text": "這邊要一律平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/679.wav", + "text": "不要有社經地位的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/680.wav", + "text": "所以你看你這二者寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/681.wav", + "text": "的其實是矛盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/682.wav", + "text": "就是他的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/683.wav", + "text": "一律平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/684.wav", + "text": "可是他的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/685.wav", + "text": "並不代表不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/686.wav", + "text": "因為你排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/687.wav", + "text": "你就不想要給他了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/688.wav", + "text": "不是得到相同的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/689.wav", + "text": "所以寫上去其實更困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/690.wav", + "text": "可是當你寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/691.wav", + "text": "一切國民的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/692.wav", + "text": "反而會造成剛剛委員所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/693.wav", + "text": "那個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/694.wav", + "text": "既然大家沒有辦法有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/695.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/696.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/697.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/698.wav", + "text": "請大家看第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/699.wav", + "text": "請問對第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/700.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/701.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/702.wav", + "text": "依照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/703.wav", + "text": "十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/704.wav", + "text": "沒有我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/705.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/706.wav", + "text": "第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/707.wav", + "text": "照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/708.wav", + "text": "\n好謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/709.wav", + "text": "\n我就宣讀今天的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/710.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/711.wav", + "text": "長請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/712.wav", + "text": "附帶決議會一起處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/713.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/714.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/715.wav", + "text": "一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/716.wav", + "text": "第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/717.wav", + "text": "第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/718.wav", + "text": "第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/719.wav", + "text": "第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/720.wav", + "text": "第二十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/721.wav", + "text": "第二十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/722.wav", + "text": "及第三十條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/723.wav", + "text": "協商通過條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/724.wav", + "text": "第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/725.wav", + "text": "保留送院會處理第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/726.wav", + "text": "\n四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/727.wav", + "text": "不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/728.wav", + "text": "委員范雲等19人提案第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/729.wav", + "text": "委員張育美等19人提案第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/730.wav", + "text": "委員蘇巧慧等32人提案第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/731.wav", + "text": "委員范雲等19人提案第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/732.wav", + "text": "及委員賴品妤等16人提案第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/733.wav", + "text": "委員蘇巧慧等32人提案第二十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/734.wav", + "text": "委員張育美等19人提案第二十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/735.wav", + "text": "及委員蘇巧慧等32人提案第二十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/736.wav", + "text": "委員吳玉琴等17人提案第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/737.wav", + "text": "\n七本案院會進行處理時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/738.wav", + "text": "協商通過部分宣讀後均予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/739.wav", + "text": "保留部分均暫予保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/740.wav", + "text": "保留部分院會進行處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/741.wav", + "text": "由各黨團推派1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/742.wav", + "text": "人依時代力量黨團台灣民眾黨黨團國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/743.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團順序輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/744.wav", + "text": "每人發言時間為3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/745.wav", + "text": "發言順序授權議事處辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/746.wav", + "text": "發言完畢後各該保留條文均不再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/747.wav", + "text": "並依上開黨團順序進行各保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/748.wav", + "text": "黨團版本之處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/749.wav", + "text": "\n八檢附立法說明1份(如附件)\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/750.wav", + "text": "看大家有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/751.wav", + "text": "研商環境部組織法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/752.wav", + "text": "子我介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/753.wav", + "text": "首先介紹行政院環境保護署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/754.wav", + "text": "署長張子敬先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/755.wav", + "text": "行政院人事行政總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/756.wav", + "text": "副人事長懷敍先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/757.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們就開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/758.wav", + "text": "一共有6個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/759.wav", + "text": "子我們先從名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/760.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/761.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/762.wav", + "text": "就照行政院提案通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/763.wav", + "text": "有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/764.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/765.wav", + "text": "升格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/766.wav", + "text": "要成為部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/767.wav", + "text": "目前有幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/768.wav", + "text": "也就是在95年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/769.wav", + "text": "要因為行政院組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/770.wav", + "text": "討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/771.wav", + "text": "都沒有公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/772.wav", + "text": "所以民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/773.wav", + "text": "也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/774.wav", + "text": "行政院各部會都在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/775.wav", + "text": "到現在做了大幅度的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/776.wav", + "text": "我在之前的質詢也講了很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/777.wav", + "text": "不是反對它成為環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/778.wav", + "text": "但是我們有一些要講清楚的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/779.wav", + "text": "環保署不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/780.wav", + "text": "變成環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/781.wav", + "text": "那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/782.wav", + "text": "因為現在的巡守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/783.wav", + "text": "環保署好像沒有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/784.wav", + "text": "不知道以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/785.wav", + "text": "環境保護署變成環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/786.wav", + "text": "之後水庫集水區的巡守污染的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/787.wav", + "text": "會不會做因為目前只有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/788.wav", + "text": "進水庫水質的檢測而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/789.wav", + "text": "我想還是要先確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/790.wav", + "text": "環境部未來的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/791.wav", + "text": "方面怎麼加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/792.wav", + "text": "因為你畢竟升格了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/793.wav", + "text": "我先問一下這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/794.wav", + "text": "院長各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/795.wav", + "text": "好我想陳委員所關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/796.wav", + "text": "第一個就是水庫集水區管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/797.wav", + "text": "其實那個是在水利署底下設立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/798.wav", + "text": "像臺北水源特定區管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/799.wav", + "text": "有關水污染的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/800.wav", + "text": "一定還是我們的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/801.wav", + "text": "組織法草案的第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/802.wav", + "text": "水污染防治還是都在我們環境部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/803.wav", + "text": "所以這個不會有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/804.wav", + "text": "這麼大的範圍裡面的環保業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/805.wav", + "text": "但環保的業務是會加強嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/806.wav", + "text": "好那我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/807.wav", + "text": "好如果這樣名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/808.wav", + "text": "名稱的部分我們就照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/809.wav", + "text": "提案通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/810.wav", + "text": "第1條大家有沒有意見如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/811.wav", + "text": "第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/812.wav", + "text": "就照行政院版本通過\n處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/813.wav", + "text": "\n處理第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/814.wav", + "text": "在第7款第8款有文字的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/815.wav", + "text": "看起來這個文字調應該是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/816.wav", + "text": "院長我再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/817.wav", + "text": "高山海洋就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/818.wav", + "text": "所有的環境管理你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/819.wav", + "text": "都會確實去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/820.wav", + "text": "是不是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/821.wav", + "text": "前面幾款是有關司的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/822.wav", + "text": "部分然後第7款是有關所屬機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/823.wav", + "text": "第8款是有關所屬機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/824.wav", + "text": "我們在條文裡都寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/825.wav", + "text": "我可不可以再確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/826.wav", + "text": "原來法的主管機關就是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/827.wav", + "text": "我們還是都會照著執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/828.wav", + "text": "好我再確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/829.wav", + "text": "水源區的水質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/830.wav", + "text": "水質調查是放在第7款嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/831.wav", + "text": "飲用水水質管理水體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/832.wav", + "text": "是我們的水質保護司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/833.wav", + "text": "有一個所謂的環境管理及執法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/834.wav", + "text": "那個部分是未來的環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/835.wav", + "text": "就是有關實際執行時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/836.wav", + "text": "會是在環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/837.wav", + "text": "我剛剛特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/838.wav", + "text": "未來在水庫集水區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/839.wav", + "text": "會做全面性調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/840.wav", + "text": "而不是只落在水庫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/841.wav", + "text": "我們都在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/842.wav", + "text": "未來的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/843.wav", + "text": "水質調查應該要全面性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/844.wav", + "text": "包括地下水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/845.wav", + "text": "可以這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/846.wav", + "text": "要求嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/847.wav", + "text": "地下水我們都有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/848.wav", + "text": "所以其實也是全面性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/849.wav", + "text": "但是當然不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/850.wav", + "text": "以後會不會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/851.wav", + "text": "我只是要確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/852.wav", + "text": "這個沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/853.wav", + "text": "因為法的主管機關是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/854.wav", + "text": "我們哪裡做得不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/855.wav", + "text": "我們可以再加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/856.wav", + "text": "是不是可以承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/857.wav", + "text": "你們升格以後會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/858.wav", + "text": "我們當然要盡力去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/859.wav", + "text": "這個沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/860.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處理第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/861.wav", + "text": "第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/862.wav", + "text": "大家有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/863.wav", + "text": "第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/864.wav", + "text": "環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/865.wav", + "text": "成立之後的次級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/866.wav", + "text": "也就是三級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/867.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/868.wav", + "text": "中央行政機關組織基準法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/869.wav", + "text": "有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/870.wav", + "text": "全部只有70個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/871.wav", + "text": "三級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/872.wav", + "text": "所以這個會涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/873.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/874.wav", + "text": "都在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/875.wav", + "text": "立委的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/876.wav", + "text": "環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/877.wav", + "text": "的三級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/878.wav", + "text": "現在是幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/879.wav", + "text": "機構不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/880.wav", + "text": "環保署現有是3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/881.wav", + "text": "機構不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/882.wav", + "text": "是有3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/883.wav", + "text": "你現在增加1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/884.wav", + "text": "就會涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/885.wav", + "text": "其他的會被排擠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/886.wav", + "text": "還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/887.wav", + "text": "舉個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/888.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/889.wav", + "text": "就有不同的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/890.wav", + "text": "對於行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/891.wav", + "text": "役政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/892.wav", + "text": "要把現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/893.wav", + "text": "營建署之下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/894.wav", + "text": "國家公園組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/895.wav", + "text": "提升到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/896.wav", + "text": "署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/897.wav", + "text": "然後它的職掌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/898.wav", + "text": "還要跨越國家公園的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/899.wav", + "text": "範圍之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/900.wav", + "text": "包括濕地的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/901.wav", + "text": "國家公園區域範圍之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/902.wav", + "text": "整個全臺灣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/903.wav", + "text": "四周都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/904.wav", + "text": "所以這個都很有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/905.wav", + "text": "我的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/906.wav", + "text": "是環保署現在的三級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/907.wav", + "text": "從3個變成4個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/908.wav", + "text": "的三級機關的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/909.wav", + "text": "就會影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/910.wav", + "text": "我先講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/911.wav", + "text": "但是立法委員有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/912.wav", + "text": "內政部組織法是內政部組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/913.wav", + "text": "拿到這裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/914.wav", + "text": "我當然要談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/915.wav", + "text": "一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/916.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/917.wav", + "text": "第7屆立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/918.wav", + "text": "本來原民會組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/919.wav", + "text": "要通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/920.wav", + "text": "裡面就是要成立原住民族文化園區管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/921.wav", + "text": "很可惜那次沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/922.wav", + "text": "拖到第8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/923.wav", + "text": "8屆的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/924.wav", + "text": "局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/925.wav", + "text": "民會本來就有文化園區管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/926.wav", + "text": "就不讓我們成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/927.wav", + "text": "整體地去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/928.wav", + "text": "考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/929.wav", + "text": "到底70個是哪70個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/930.wav", + "text": "不要到時候先通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/931.wav", + "text": "結果後來都沒得談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/932.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/933.wav", + "text": "我要請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/934.wav", + "text": "我們現在把事業廢棄物放在資源循環署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/935.wav", + "text": "廢棄物的清除處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/936.wav", + "text": "放在環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/937.wav", + "text": "我們知道事業廢棄物是很大的量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/938.wav", + "text": "資源循環署跟環境管理署有什麼差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/939.wav", + "text": "據我所知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/940.wav", + "text": "廢管處變資源循環署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/941.wav", + "text": "以後環保局的業務是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/942.wav", + "text": "沒有納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/943.wav", + "text": "是不是可以把營建廢棄物也納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/944.wav", + "text": "請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/945.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/946.wav", + "text": "謝謝其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/947.wav", + "text": "其實原來紅色的部分是因為委員關心好像廢棄物不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/948.wav", + "text": "所以我們才又把它寫上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/949.wav", + "text": "其實我們現在在修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/950.wav", + "text": "事業廢棄物及一般廢棄物會��起來管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/951.wav", + "text": "所謂一起來管就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/952.wav", + "text": "跟傳統把它分成一般廢棄物及事業廢棄物不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/953.wav", + "text": "在這裡之所以寫成兩個單位是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/954.wav", + "text": "所有的廢棄物未來資源循環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/955.wav", + "text": "都是資源循環署要去負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/956.wav", + "text": "在服務民生收集垃圾清運清潔隊的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/957.wav", + "text": "因為這是屬於地方執行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/958.wav", + "text": "所以執行的部分會放在環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/959.wav", + "text": "\n就像剛剛講說有關環境管理和執法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/960.wav", + "text": "執法的部分也會在環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/961.wav", + "text": "所以現在是這樣子分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/962.wav", + "text": "其實是配合我們現在要提出來的廢清法修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/963.wav", + "text": "所以不是傳統照事廢一般廢這樣來分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/964.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/965.wav", + "text": "剛剛的營建廢棄物要放在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/966.wav", + "text": "如果要講它的性質當然是屬於事業廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/967.wav", + "text": "但未來我們不會依照產源去分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/968.wav", + "text": "而是依照它可以再循環利用去做管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/969.wav", + "text": "我想上次在委員會也有要求我們做了一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/970.wav", + "text": "署長如果是這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/971.wav", + "text": "未來的一般和事業廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/972.wav", + "text": "就是像現在這樣的處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/973.wav", + "text": "並沒有負責事業廢棄物的清除處理事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/974.wav", + "text": "啊法這樣寫並不適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/975.wav", + "text": "沒有其實我們本來就是要用資源循環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/976.wav", + "text": "跟資源回收去管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/977.wav", + "text": "但是因為在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/978.wav", + "text": "委員會覺得廢棄物沒有出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/979.wav", + "text": "好像廢棄物就不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/980.wav", + "text": "所以我們才用紅色的在這次修正才拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/981.wav", + "text": "其實在未來我剛剛講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/982.wav", + "text": "環境管理署因為牽涉到地方政府清潔隊的收運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/983.wav", + "text": "清潔隊的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/984.wav", + "text": "或是地方這些焚化爐的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/985.wav", + "text": "所以會在環境管理署裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/986.wav", + "text": "但所有收來的都會從資源的角度統一管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/987.wav", + "text": "所以未來不會因為是家戶出來的啤酒瓶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/988.wav", + "text": "就屬於家戶垃圾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/989.wav", + "text": "從事業出來的啤酒瓶就是事業廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/990.wav", + "text": "那個是不合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/991.wav", + "text": "所以未來修法我們會把它調過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/992.wav", + "text": "這個已經配合修法的理念把它分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/993.wav", + "text": "是可不可以把營建廢棄物放在說明那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/994.wav", + "text": "就是營建廢棄物是屬於事業廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/995.wav", + "text": "講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/996.wav", + "text": "其實那個一定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/997.wav", + "text": "我們現在的管理就是了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/998.wav", + "text": "我們現在所做的管理就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/999.wav", + "text": "寫在說明可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1000.wav", + "text": "說明把它加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1001.wav", + "text": "或者是附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1002.wav", + "text": "就是寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1003.wav", + "text": "營建剩餘土石方和營建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1004.wav", + "text": "廢棄物的管理的確有它的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1005.wav", + "text": "我們把它寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1006.wav", + "text": "這樣好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1007.wav", + "text": "上一次的委員會要我們去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1008.wav", + "text": "有關廢棄物處理的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1009.wav", + "text": "其實我們已經大概就有提出這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1010.wav", + "text": "未來有關於營建廢棄物的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1011.wav", + "text": "確實是我們要改善的一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1012.wav", + "text": "署長因為這個很細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1013.wav", + "text": "可不可以在我們送院會前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1014.wav", + "text": "把文字給我們確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1015.wav", + "text": "我們再跟委員講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1016.wav", + "text": "我們未來修法的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1017.wav", + "text": "其實我們都有照顧到這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1018.wav", + "text": "你們再溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1019.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1020.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們鄭委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1021.wav", + "text": "三級機關最高是70個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1022.wav", + "text": "每個機關都在爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1023.wav", + "text": "能用到最適讓它發揮最大的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1024.wav", + "text": "那就先用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1025.wav", + "text": "到底行政院有沒有統一規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1026.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1027.wav", + "text": "事實上我們這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1028.wav", + "text": "送來的整個行政院組改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1029.wav", + "text": "所有法案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1030.wav", + "text": "對70個局署都已經全部有規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1031.wav", + "text": "境部先審或後審而產生問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1032.wav", + "text": "目前整個送來的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1033.wav", + "text": "是未來的國民年金局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1034.wav", + "text": "所以整個行政院對於70個局署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1035.wav", + "text": "都已經規劃好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1036.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1037.wav", + "text": "這個就是行政院人事行政總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1038.wav", + "text": "國有土地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1039.wav", + "text": "是國產署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1040.wav", + "text": "它是署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1041.wav", + "text": "負責林班地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1042.wav", + "text": "局原住民族委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1043.wav", + "text": "負責原住民保留地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1044.wav", + "text": "非常大的面積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1045.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1046.wav", + "text": "它不只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1047.wav", + "text": "跟原住民保留地有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1048.wav", + "text": "我們很多的法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1049.wav", + "text": "都跟原民會的土地管理有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1050.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1051.wav", + "text": "我們一直要求行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1052.wav", + "text": "在組改的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1053.wav", + "text": "必須要針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1054.wav", + "text": "原住民族土地的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1055.wav", + "text": "你們都是用你們自己的思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1056.wav", + "text": "\n立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1057.wav", + "text": "當然按照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1058.wav", + "text": "的規劃是不會超過70個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1059.wav", + "text": "現在在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1060.wav", + "text": "已經完成審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1061.wav", + "text": "或是還沒有排審的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1062.wav", + "text": "就超過70個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1063.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1064.wav", + "text": "是要通盤地去考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1065.wav", + "text": "你們都講很多次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1066.wav", + "text": "我們要在一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1067.wav", + "text": "個對話基礎上來談這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1068.wav", + "text": "你今天是要談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1069.wav", + "text": "原住民文化管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1070.wav", + "text": "或原住民土地管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1071.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在已經訂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1072.wav", + "text": "擔任行政院長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1073.wav", + "text": "也是這樣一直走來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1074.wav", + "text": "我想大家都經歷過這個歷程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1075.wav", + "text": "後來改來改去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1076.wav", + "text": "已經走到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1077.wav", + "text": "處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1078.wav", + "text": "中央政府組織基準法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1079.wav", + "text": "也訂下來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1080.wav", + "text": "我們今天是在討論環保署的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1081.wav", + "text": "及一個研究單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1082.wav", + "text": "這四個署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1083.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1084.wav", + "text": "鄭委員的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1085.wav", + "text": "樣本來三個變四個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1086.wav", + "text": "你的意思是三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1087.wav", + "text": "嗎那是不可得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1088.wav", + "text": "役政署要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1089.wav", + "text": "是因為有人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1090.wav", + "text": "並不是一定會按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1091.wav", + "text": "現在還有國家公園管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1092.wav", + "text": "國土規劃署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1093.wav", + "text": "哪來這麼多署給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1094.wav", + "text": "所以他們內部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1095.wav", + "text": "都有協調過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1096.wav", + "text": "那個我們到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1097.wav", + "text": "內政部組織法再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1098.wav", + "text": "原住民又談到役政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1099.wav", + "text": "有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1100.wav", + "text": "我們就保留如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1101.wav", + "text": "如果要刪減成三個署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1102.wav", + "text": "請問哪一個署要刪減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1103.wav", + "text": "你講看看嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1104.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1105.wav", + "text": "這樣才能夠對焦嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1106.wav", + "text": "第8屆的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1107.wav", + "text": "就是用這種理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1108.wav", + "text": "然後就變不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1109.wav", + "text": "這一次完全不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1110.wav", + "text": "也在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1111.wav", + "text": "這已經彙整過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1112.wav", + "text": "很多次都講定了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1113.wav", + "text": "我要趁這個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1114.wav", + "text": "再跟署長確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1115.wav", + "text": "營建事業廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1116.wav", + "text": "及營建剩餘土石方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1117.wav", + "text": "定義可不可以確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1118.wav", + "text": "含有百分之多少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1119.wav", + "text": "廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1120.wav", + "text": "是屬於營建廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1121.wav", + "text": "我們是不是再跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1122.wav", + "text": "在我們修法的構想裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1123.wav", + "text": "那個東西都會放在裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1124.wav", + "text": "面因為我們也想解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1125.wav", + "text": "所以在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1126.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法去表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1127.wav", + "text": "也就是廢清法修法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1128.wav", + "text": "不知道要等到何年何月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1129.wav", + "text": "譬如營建剩餘土石方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1130.wav", + "text": "如果含有3%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1131.wav", + "text": "你們之前告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1132.wav", + "text": "含有3%的廢棄物就屬於營建廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1133.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣認定我已經跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1134.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1135.wav", + "text": "我們修法就是要解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1136.wav", + "text": "現在在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1137.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1138.wav", + "text": "所以我才會跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1139.wav", + "text": "可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1140.wav", + "text": "我可以接受我們再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1141.wav", + "text": "因為這的確是很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1142.wav", + "text": "長在行政院原版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1143.wav", + "text": "資源循環署有清除處理的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1144.wav", + "text": "在環境管理署本來沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1145.wav", + "text": "現在在資源循環署裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1146.wav", + "text": "加了事業廢棄物的清除處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1147.wav", + "text": "然後在環境管理署裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1148.wav", + "text": "加了一般廢棄物的清除處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1149.wav", + "text": "你們要不要把它放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1150.wav", + "text": "同一個署裡面去處理就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1151.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1152.wav", + "text": "的就是針對我們現在比較熟悉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1153.wav", + "text": "清潔隊的那一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1154.wav", + "text": "都會在環境管理署去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1155.wav", + "text": "至於事業廢棄物的部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1156.wav", + "text": "部分在法的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1157.wav", + "text": "事業廢棄物的清除處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1158.wav", + "text": "是事業的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1159.wav", + "text": "還是要有一個管理系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1160.wav", + "text": "管理系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1161.wav", + "text": "跟資源回收的觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1162.wav", + "text": "清運的管理系統會是分開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1163.wav", + "text": "院長現在據我所知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1164.wav", + "text": "這個事業廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1165.wav", + "text": "都是督察總隊在協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1166.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1167.wav", + "text": "只有執法的部分在督察總隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1168.wav", + "text": "也就是督察總隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1169.wav", + "text": "未來會改為環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1170.wav", + "text": "所以執法也在環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1171.wav", + "text": "還是環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1172.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1173.wav", + "text": "它的制度法規管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1174.wav", + "text": "都會在資源循環署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1175.wav", + "text": "但是到了現地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1176.wav", + "text": "例如它有被棄置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1177.wav", + "text": "及稽查的處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1178.wav", + "text": "會在環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1179.wav", + "text": "而整個制度會在資源循環署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1180.wav", + "text": "設署的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1181.wav", + "text": "因為署是有決策的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1182.wav", + "text": "局就是直接執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1183.wav", + "text": "我稍微請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1184.wav", + "text": "因為過去的修法歷程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1185.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1186.wav", + "text": "我只是請教署長一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1187.wav", + "text": "到有好幾位委員也在詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1188.wav", + "text": "雖然有分為一般的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1189.wav", + "text": "有事業的等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1190.wav", + "text": "但是現在又分在兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1191.wav", + "text": "不同的署裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1192.wav", + "text": "立法中會不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1193.wav", + "text": "誰在決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1194.wav", + "text": "我覺得因為這都是設署的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1195.wav", + "text": "有沒有重疊的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1196.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1197.wav", + "text": "規劃法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1198.wav", + "text": "其實我們會把它分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1199.wav", + "text": "民間清運有不同的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1200.wav", + "text": "未來我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1201.wav", + "text": "在資源循環署管理的觀點下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1202.wav", + "text": "兩個應該走相同的規格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1203.wav", + "text": "我們要提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1204.wav", + "text": "如此公私才會一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1205.wav", + "text": "未來我們會去修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1206.wav", + "text": "環境衛生的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1207.wav", + "text": "我們希望重新去把法更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1208.wav", + "text": "第一線在做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1209.wav", + "text": "所以未來各自主管的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1210.wav", + "text": "也會不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1211.wav", + "text": "是不是我們就照協商條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1212.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1213.wav", + "text": "就照協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1214.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1215.wav", + "text": "等於是第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1216.wav", + "text": "處理名稱如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1217.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1218.wav", + "text": "我們就照行政院的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1219.wav", + "text": "第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1220.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1221.wav", + "text": "行政院的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1222.wav", + "text": "接下來處理第四案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1223.wav", + "text": "資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1224.wav", + "text": "循環署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1225.wav", + "text": "草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1226.wav", + "text": "就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1227.wav", + "text": "第1條也照行政院的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1228.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1229.wav", + "text": "也是照協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1230.wav", + "text": "陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1231.wav", + "text": "現在是資源循環署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1232.wav", + "text": "第2條的第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1233.wav", + "text": "一般廢棄物的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1234.wav", + "text": "政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1235.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1236.wav", + "text": "這個執行是執行什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1237.wav", + "text": "如果像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1238.wav", + "text": "剛剛說的一般廢棄物是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1239.wav", + "text": "管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1240.wav", + "text": "有關它的減量跟資源循環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1241.wav", + "text": "回收的部分會在這裡推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1242.wav", + "text": "回收基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1243.wav", + "text": "為什麼把事業廢棄物放在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1244.wav", + "text": "管理署跟資源循環署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1245.wav", + "text": "有關廢棄物的分工你們還是要寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1246.wav", + "text": "因為業務上真的有高度重疊性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1247.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1248.wav", + "text": "可是如果照你這樣講其實現在很多事業廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1249.wav", + "text": "以後督察總隊就是管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1250.wav", + "text": "資源循環署大部分都是一堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1251.wav", + "text": "坐在辦公室裡面的人他們怎麼去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1252.wav", + "text": "這真的是有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1253.wav", + "text": "確實我們是資源循環署跟環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1254.wav", + "text": "環境管理署會偏比較地方執行的輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1255.wav", + "text": "所以清潔隊的管理照顧那部分會在環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1256.wav", + "text": "修法希望把綠色設計源頭減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1257.wav", + "text": "都修到資源循環的這個法裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1258.wav", + "text": "所以未來不是純粹像現在只有末端的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1259.wav", + "text": "我們希望從源頭去做一些改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1260.wav", + "text": "不過我還是建議你把部分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1261.wav", + "text": "事業廢棄物業務分到資源循環署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1262.wav", + "text": "但是環境管理署那邊還是要把事業廢棄物納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1263.wav", + "text": "未來他們還是要協助事業廢棄物的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1264.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告我剛剛講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1265.wav", + "text": "未來事業廢棄物只有執法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1266.wav", + "text": "會在環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1267.wav", + "text": "因為我們的稽查會在環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1268.wav", + "text": "制度的設計法規都會在資源循環署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1269.wav", + "text": "所以資源循環署設計的所謂資源循環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1270.wav", + "text": "也會在資源循環署整體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1271.wav", + "text": "不會同樣一個東西因為來源不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1272.wav", + "text": "結果處理的法規不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1273.wav", + "text": "對啊你剛剛講執法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1274.wav", + "text": "事業廢棄物還是要在環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1275.wav", + "text": "所以環境管理署還是必須要去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1276.wav", + "text": "事業廢棄物執法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1277.wav", + "text": "我剛剛的意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1278.wav", + "text": "這樣子的話你在業務分工方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1279.wav", + "text": "譬如說事業廢棄物執法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1280.wav", + "text": "還是要寫進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1281.wav", + "text": "未來就包括違反空氣違反水污法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1282.wav", + "text": "都是在環境管理署執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1283.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1284.wav", + "text": "所以我們就寫環境執法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1285.wav", + "text": "就是相關環保法規的違法執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1286.wav", + "text": "都在環境管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1287.wav", + "text": "那這樣的話我們是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1288.wav", + "text": "也照協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1289.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1290.wav", + "text": "\n處理第五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1291.wav", + "text": "吧這個已經過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1292.wav", + "text": "就照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1293.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處理第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1294.wav", + "text": "第1條也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1295.wav", + "text": "好就照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1296.wav", + "text": "這是第五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1297.wav", + "text": "第六案也是名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1298.wav", + "text": "6案之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1299.wav", + "text": "名稱也是照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1300.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處理第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1301.wav", + "text": "第1條沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1302.wav", + "text": "也是照行政院提案通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1303.wav", + "text": "第七案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1304.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1305.wav", + "text": "國家環境研究院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1306.wav", + "text": "地下水的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1307.wav", + "text": "相關背景什麼可以放進來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1308.wav", + "text": "因為我看你們還是只加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1309.wav", + "text": "環境污染的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1310.wav", + "text": "要去建立背景值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1311.wav", + "text": "並不是污染了才調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1312.wav", + "text": "要訂在哪一個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1313.wav", + "text": "可不可以說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1314.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1315.wav", + "text": "其實原來有關監測的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1316.wav", + "text": "當然原來有一部分是在我們的檢驗所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1317.wav", + "text": "有一部分是在業務單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1318.wav", + "text": "好比說地下水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1319.wav", + "text": "我們是比較傾向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1320.wav", + "text": "所以如果是一般的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1321.wav", + "text": "環境品質監測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1322.wav", + "text": "是不是要移過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1323.wav", + "text": "我們會去考慮它的量能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1324.wav", + "text": "環境研究檢測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1325.wav", + "text": "算嗎就是非污染就要做檢測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1326.wav", + "text": "所以未來這個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1327.wav", + "text": "如果看它的第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1328.wav", + "text": "可是我剛剛的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1329.wav", + "text": "就像我剛剛講的地下水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1330.wav", + "text": "需要進一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1331.wav", + "text": "就會由研究院從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1332.wav", + "text": "我再強調一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1333.wav", + "text": "就像現在內政部在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1334.wav", + "text": "全面性的環境調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1335.wav", + "text": "我們現在都有在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1336.wav", + "text": "而且是各部門都在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1337.wav", + "text": "整個事情一定有人做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1338.wav", + "text": "這沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1339.wav", + "text": "就通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1340.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1341.wav", + "text": "就照協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1342.wav", + "text": "也照協商建議條文通過好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1343.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1344.wav", + "text": "照行政院提案通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1345.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1346.wav", + "text": "遍\n協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1347.wav", + "text": "一環境部組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1348.wav", + "text": "草案共11案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1349.wav", + "text": ")名稱及第1條均照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1350.wav", + "text": ")第2條及第5條均照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1351.wav", + "text": "1(三)其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1352.wav", + "text": "二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1353.wav", + "text": "環境部氣候變遷署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1354.wav", + "text": "組織法草案共5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1355.wav", + "text": "名稱及第1條均照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1356.wav", + "text": ")其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1357.wav", + "text": "三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1358.wav", + "text": "環境部資源循環署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1359.wav", + "text": "組織法草案共3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1360.wav", + "text": ")名稱及第1條均照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1361.wav", + "text": ")第2條照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1362.wav", + "text": "2(三)其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1363.wav", + "text": "四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1364.wav", + "text": "環境部化學物質管理署組織法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1365.wav", + "text": ")名稱及第1條均照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1366.wav", + "text": ")其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1367.wav", + "text": "五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1368.wav", + "text": "環境部環境管理署組織法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1369.wav", + "text": ")名稱及第1條均照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1370.wav", + "text": "其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1371.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1372.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1373.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1374.wav", + "text": "如果沒有我們今天會議就到此告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14982/1375.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/0.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/1.wav", + "text": "我們現在就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/2.wav", + "text": "開始今天的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/3.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/4.wav", + "text": "今天的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/5.wav", + "text": "最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/6.wav", + "text": "繼續研商中華民國112年度中央政府總預算案附屬單位預算及綜計表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/7.wav", + "text": "─營業及非營業部分案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/8.wav", + "text": "\n我先介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/9.wav", + "text": "首先介紹的是財政部部長莊翠雲女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/10.wav", + "text": "接下來是金管會主任委員黃天牧先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/11.wav", + "text": "再來是行政院主計總處主計長朱澤民先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/12.wav", + "text": "中央銀行總裁楊金龍先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/13.wav", + "text": "經濟部部長王美花女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/14.wav", + "text": "農委會副主任委員陳添壽先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/15.wav", + "text": "勞動部部長許銘春女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/16.wav", + "text": "衛福部政務次長王必勝先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/17.wav", + "text": "交通部政務次長胡湘麟先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/18.wav", + "text": "再來是行政院公共工程委員會副處長胡培中先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/19.wav", + "text": "\n我們就先讓黨團大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/20.wav", + "text": "綜合討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/21.wav", + "text": "程序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/22.wav", + "text": "因為今天是審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/23.wav", + "text": "112年度營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/24.wav", + "text": "非營業基金的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/25.wav", + "text": "金額有二三兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/26.wav", + "text": "呢假如用得好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/27.wav", + "text": "很多事業就會經營得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/28.wav", + "text": "尤其現在經濟不好的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/29.wav", + "text": "真的可以刺激經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/30.wav", + "text": "像今年可能連保2都有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/31.wav", + "text": "所以這也是當時朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/32.wav", + "text": "國民黨團傾全力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/33.wav", + "text": "趕快讓它通過以刺激經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/34.wav", + "text": "但是近期我們的王鴻薇委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/35.wav", + "text": "舉發有關合庫金控的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/36.wav", + "text": "合庫金控的事情非常誇張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/37.wav", + "text": "等一下王鴻薇委員會跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/38.wav", + "text": "雖然合庫已經民營化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/39.wav", + "text": "但是跟我們公股公營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/40.wav", + "text": "基金營業基金類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/41.wav", + "text": "假設這種東西不清不楚不查辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/42.wav", + "text": "那審什麼預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/43.wav", + "text": "審假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/44.wav", + "text": "嗎審假的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/45.wav", + "text": "所以我們才提出第13案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/46.wav", + "text": "並希望將其提到第1案來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/47.wav", + "text": "是希望先查清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/48.wav", + "text": "並跟大家做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/49.wav", + "text": "才要做後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/50.wav", + "text": "我的要求很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/51.wav", + "text": "第一個請財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/52.wav", + "text": "進行查辦相關的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/53.wav", + "text": "到底是誇張到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/54.wav", + "text": "第二個請金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/55.wav", + "text": "去做金檢專案檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/56.wav", + "text": "該怎麼處理就怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/57.wav", + "text": "我們也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/58.wav", + "text": "所以我先做以上的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/59.wav", + "text": "現在請王鴻薇委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/60.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長我們的總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/61.wav", + "text": "還有各位與會者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/62.wav", + "text": "我跟大家說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/63.wav", + "text": "事實上從上個禮拜開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/64.wav", + "text": "合庫的基層同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/65.wav", + "text": "跟我反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/66.wav", + "text": "就是合庫金控��下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/67.wav", + "text": ")一些胡作非為的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/68.wav", + "text": "我在星期一的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/69.wav", + "text": "有召開記者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/70.wav", + "text": "合庫AMC的董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/71.wav", + "text": "蔡見興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/72.wav", + "text": "合庫AMC之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/73.wav", + "text": "包含他的兒子去當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/74.wav", + "text": "合庫創投公司的經理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/75.wav", + "text": "然後更離譜的是把他的侄子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/76.wav", + "text": "也引進到合庫AMC來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/77.wav", + "text": "還有他過去的家族公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/78.wav", + "text": "他最重要的事業夥伴的女兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/79.wav", + "text": "也把他納入合庫AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/80.wav", + "text": "了高雄客運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/81.wav", + "text": "負責人即副董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/82.wav", + "text": "就是由他把他牽引進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/83.wav", + "text": "也就是他事業夥伴女兒的堂哥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/84.wav", + "text": "所以形成了一個堂妹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/85.wav", + "text": "像這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/86.wav", + "text": "在全世界來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/87.wav", + "text": "是嚴重違反公司治理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/88.wav", + "text": "在國外的話應該都會被重重的罰款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/89.wav", + "text": "召開記者會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/90.wav", + "text": "有這麼離譜的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/91.wav", + "text": "結果蔡見興在第一時間說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/92.wav", + "text": "我搞錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/93.wav", + "text": "他為人很正直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/94.wav", + "text": "是因為他的兒子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/95.wav", + "text": "他的侄子都非常優秀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/96.wav", + "text": "我們也不了解是否優秀的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/97.wav", + "text": "就可以直接引進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/98.wav", + "text": "他們相關的關係企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/99.wav", + "text": "或直接到他的公司來任職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/100.wav", + "text": "然後合庫竟然還說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/101.wav", + "text": "他非常有績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/102.wav", + "text": "結果這個事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/103.wav", + "text": "事實上真的嚴重違反社會觀感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/104.wav", + "text": "財政部大家看到這個事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/105.wav", + "text": "結果蔡見興董事長在昨天請辭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/106.wav", + "text": "可是我跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/107.wav", + "text": "因為這件事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/108.wav", + "text": "今天財政部跟金管會都在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/109.wav", + "text": "我必須要提出來的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/110.wav", + "text": "為什麼在這一次的爆料裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/111.wav", + "text": "我告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/112.wav", + "text": "其實我都還想保護我的爆料人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/113.wav", + "text": "所以我說有些資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/114.wav", + "text": "有些表格我們要不要修一修啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/115.wav", + "text": "不要一看出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/116.wav", + "text": "都是他們提供給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/117.wav", + "text": "的但他們說沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/118.wav", + "text": "因為他們已經受夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/119.wav", + "text": "因為其實他們長期都有跟合庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/120.wav", + "text": "有跟財政部檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/121.wav", + "text": "也有跟金管會檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/122.wav", + "text": "但是長期都沒有辦法去動搖蔡見興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/123.wav", + "text": "我今天召開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/124.wav", + "text": "不是只有他的侄子兒子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/125.wav", + "text": "我在記者會裡面也做了很多的保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/126.wav", + "text": "的小三當他的秘書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/127.wav", + "text": "護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/128.wav", + "text": "這個小三長期做他的秘書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/129.wav", + "text": "也把她引進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/130.wav", + "text": "還有很多他的什麼朋友的兒子也引進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/131.wav", + "text": "我直接說是高雄非常有關係的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/132.wav", + "text": "也直接把他推薦進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/133.wav", + "text": "這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/134.wav", + "text": "裡面包含他那個小三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/135.wav", + "text": "每個禮拜都跟他出差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/136.wav", + "text": "浮報加班費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/137.wav", + "text": "浮報出差費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/138.wav", + "text": "浮報交通費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/139.wav", + "text": "長期以往歷經很長的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/140.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/141.wav", + "text": "今天為什麼我們合庫這麼大的一個公股金控公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/142.wav", + "text": "它下面的子公司管理竟如此鬆散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/143.wav", + "text": "而且可以被一個人把持這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/144.wav", + "text": "而基層的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/145.wav", + "text": "甚至有些離職的員工都告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/146.wav", + "text": "他們之前統統都爆料過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/147.wav", + "text": "包含雜誌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/148.wav", + "text": "還拍到他跟小三同進同出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/149.wav", + "text": "他還可以不動如山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/150.wav", + "text": "啊這些他們都有提供給我們資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/151.wav", + "text": "可是我要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/152.wav", + "text": "如果今天財政部跟金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/153.wav", + "text": "不對這件事情徹查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/154.wav", + "text": "包含我還提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/155.wav", + "text": "我在這邊要要求金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/156.wav", + "text": "你們怎麼可以對金控底下的這個AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/157.wav", + "text": "的一個案子十幾二十億所在多有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/158.wav", + "text": "就是都更的貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/159.wav", + "text": "他把它修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/160.wav", + "text": "改成只要提出申請就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/161.wav", + "text": "改成什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/162.wav", + "text": "不需要提出申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/163.wav", + "text": "當地主管機關劃定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/164.wav", + "text": "是都更地區就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/165.wav", + "text": "因為這樣衍生出什麼案件呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/166.wav", + "text": "這個案件就是還沒有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/167.wav", + "text": "合庫AMC要求墊付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/168.wav", + "text": "然後直接撥款10億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/169.wav", + "text": "元直接撥款給他10億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/170.wav", + "text": "元可以這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/171.wav", + "text": "還沒有提出都更的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/172.wav", + "text": "就撥款10億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/173.wav", + "text": "元等他提出申請後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/174.wav", + "text": "再撥款給他10億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/175.wav", + "text": "元可以這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/176.wav", + "text": "只為了量身訂做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/177.wav", + "text": "了還好總召提醒我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/178.wav", + "text": "財政部發布的新聞稿寫什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/179.wav", + "text": "呢說他是基於什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/180.wav", + "text": "他規劃個鬼啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/181.wav", + "text": "照理講你們應該要查辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/182.wav", + "text": "說他是生涯規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/183.wav", + "text": "呢如果你們的態度是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/184.wav", + "text": "所有的附屬單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/185.wav", + "text": "呢這個事情當然要徹查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/186.wav", + "text": "不能隨著蔡見興個人請辭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/187.wav", + "text": "就一了百了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/188.wav", + "text": "沒有這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/189.wav", + "text": "包含他所引進的這些人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/190.wav", + "text": "這些人都是他引進來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/191.wav", + "text": "把他的兒子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/192.wav", + "text": "小三朋友的兒子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/193.wav", + "text": "他就全部都錄用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/194.wav", + "text": "錄用之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/195.wav", + "text": "這些人當然要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/196.wav", + "text": "包含他有沒有浮報交通費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/197.wav", + "text": "整個貸放合不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/198.wav", + "text": "有沒有關係人的貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/199.wav", + "text": "這些都必須查清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/200.wav", + "text": "光是讓蔡見興走人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/201.wav", + "text": "這叫做斷尾求生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/202.wav", + "text": "是沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/203.wav", + "text": "符合社會大眾的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/204.wav", + "text": "我直接就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/205.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/206.wav", + "text": "即便蔡見興已經請辭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/207.wav", + "text": "更多資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/208.wav", + "text": "這些資料不是我很厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/209.wav", + "text": "我變出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/210.wav", + "text": "而是這些基層員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/211.wav", + "text": "他們作為吹哨者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/212.wav", + "text": "有一個很好的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/213.wav", + "text": "跟大家做這樣的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/214.wav", + "text": "賴士葆委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/215.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/216.wav", + "text": "我們黨團的訴求很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/217.wav", + "text": "也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/218.wav", + "text": "因為大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/219.wav", + "text": "特別是柯總召也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/220.wav", + "text": "在國民黨執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/221.wav", + "text": "有好幾年的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/222.wav", + "text": "點早一個禮拜晚一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/223.wav", + "text": "不是那麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/224.wav", + "text": "要先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/225.wav", + "text": "所以我們把第13案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/226.wav", + "text": "列為這次討論的第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/227.wav", + "text": "而且要很嚴肅的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/228.wav", + "text": "財政部莊部長人在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/229.wav", + "text": "如果這個沒有處理好是你包庇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/230.wav", + "text": "我們可以去告你因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/231.wav", + "text": "很嚴重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/232.wav", + "text": "蔡見興可以一手遮天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/233.wav", + "text": "統統進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/234.wav", + "text": "現在他卻斷尾求生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/235.wav", + "text": "還沒有查清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/236.wav", + "text": "他就斷尾求生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/237.wav", + "text": "也要一起走人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/238.wav", + "text": "啊很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/239.wav", + "text": "大家都非常瞭解AMC是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/240.wav", + "text": "講難聽一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/241.wav", + "text": "它有點類似討債公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/242.wav", + "text": "AMC就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/243.wav", + "text": "的這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/244.wav", + "text": "不良債權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/245.wav", + "text": ",000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/246.wav", + "text": "元但你可能用200萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/247.wav", + "text": "元100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/248.wav", + "text": "元這個認真說起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/249.wav", + "text": "是包賺的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/250.wav", + "text": "就會有人專門在做這個事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/251.wav", + "text": "興的家族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/252.wav", + "text": "專家在搞這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/253.wav", + "text": "幾乎全部集中在高雄市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/254.wav", + "text": "這個很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/255.wav", + "text": "嘛合庫董事長雷仲達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/256.wav", + "text": "也是從高雄來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/257.wav", + "text": "有沒有魄力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/258.wav", + "text": "要來處理這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/259.wav", + "text": "大家都在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/260.wav", + "text": "一再的向合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/261.wav", + "text": "效循著正常體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/262.wav", + "text": "都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/263.wav", + "text": "用了所以只好循著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/264.wav", + "text": "民意代表體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/265.wav", + "text": "今天就有效了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/266.wav", + "text": "這是第一個我們要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/267.wav", + "text": "的我們要把這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/268.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/269.wav", + "text": "財政部金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/270.wav", + "text": "真的要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/271.wav", + "text": "去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/272.wav", + "text": "一兩個禮拜就OK了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/273.wav", + "text": "要不要做而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/274.wav", + "text": "如果你沒有任何的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/275.wav", + "text": "認真去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/276.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/277.wav", + "text": "一個禮拜就能處理完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/278.wav", + "text": "我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/279.wav", + "text": "對黃主委來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/280.wav", + "text": "是這麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/281.wav", + "text": "有高段的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/282.wav", + "text": "那麼內行的人處理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/283.wav", + "text": "檢查局檢查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/284.wav", + "text": "AMC是最容易上下其手的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/285.wav", + "text": "我剛剛說過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/286.wav", + "text": "他是用很低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/287.wav", + "text": "去買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/288.wav", + "text": "然後拿到的債權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/289.wav", + "text": "這麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/290.wav", + "text": "合庫為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/291.wav", + "text": "可以長期縱容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/292.wav", + "text": "蔡家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/293.wav", + "text": "合庫的AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/294.wav", + "text": "蔡家的家族企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/295.wav", + "text": "上下其手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/296.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/297.wav", + "text": "我要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/298.wav", + "text": "及抗議一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/299.wav", + "text": "現在行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/300.wav", + "text": "柯總召而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/301.wav", + "text": "都只看柯總召而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/302.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/303.wav", + "text": "我具體來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/304.wav", + "text": "藐視國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/305.wav", + "text": "他雖然有來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/306.wav", + "text": "你在這裡這麼資深" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/307.wav", + "text": "把螺絲上緊一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/308.wav", + "text": "啦你的預算執行數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/309.wav", + "text": "都是預算數的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/310.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/311.wav", + "text": "實際上的收入是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/312.wav", + "text": "預算數的56倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/313.wav", + "text": "結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/314.wav", + "text": "我要增加國發會的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/315.wav", + "text": "卻不讓我增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/316.wav", + "text": "我要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/317.wav", + "text": "中油的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/318.wav", + "text": "不讓我增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/319.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/320.wav", + "text": "最藐視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/321.wav", + "text": "在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/322.wav", + "text": "了我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/323.wav", + "text": "呼籲我們的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/324.wav", + "text": "睛看經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/325.wav", + "text": "好好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/326.wav", + "text": "監督一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/327.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/328.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會的長官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/329.wav", + "text": "國發會的長官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/330.wav", + "text": "中油董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/331.wav", + "text": "也不來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/332.wav", + "text": "中油派一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/333.wav", + "text": "副總過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/334.wav", + "text": "不可以增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/335.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/336.wav", + "text": "到時候表決都會贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/337.wav", + "text": "啊他說去表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/338.wav", + "text": "不要說到我這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/339.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/340.wav", + "text": "算已經從經濟委員會出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/341.wav", + "text": "不可以再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/342.wav", + "text": "這樣是要協商什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/343.wav", + "text": "我們的職權全部被閹割掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/344.wav", + "text": "喔經濟部長國發會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/345.wav", + "text": "我提出最嚴重的抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/346.wav", + "text": "中油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/347.wav", + "text": "必須增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/348.wav", + "text": "他們預算的執行數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/349.wav", + "text": "都是預算數的5到6倍之多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/350.wav", + "text": "就代表他們的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/351.wav", + "text": "都是低估的低估的低估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/352.wav", + "text": "討價還價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/353.wav", + "text": "只願意讓我增加幾千萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/354.wav", + "text": "元剛開始是不願意增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/355.wav", + "text": "的有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/356.wav", + "text": "嗎這樣藐視在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/357.wav", + "text": "我們國會就不要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/358.wav", + "text": "嘛國會可以拆掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/359.wav", + "text": "所以我要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/360.wav", + "text": "啦對於預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/361.wav", + "text": "做得不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/362.wav", + "text": "你看你放水放到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/363.wav", + "text": "他們列的預算數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/364.wav", + "text": "都只有執行數的五分之一到六分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/365.wav", + "text": "幹什麼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/366.wav", + "text": "螺絲這麼鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/367.wav", + "text": "然後我們要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/368.wav", + "text": "我替你把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/369.wav", + "text": "居然是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/370.wav", + "text": "是當在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/371.wav", + "text": "不存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/372.wav", + "text": "啊我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/373.wav", + "text": "藉這個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/374.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/375.wav", + "text": "如果不給我們一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/376.wav", + "text": "我們從頭到尾就杯葛到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/377.wav", + "text": "營業及非營業基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/378.wav", + "text": "前歷次協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/379.wav", + "text": "也都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/380.wav", + "text": "不管朝野各黨都希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/381.wav", + "text": "不要像過去一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/382.wav", + "text": "到12月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/383.wav", + "text": "變成決算了還在審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/384.wav", + "text": "查這個是過去立法院的陋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/385.wav", + "text": "剛才賴士葆委員所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/386.wav", + "text": "我必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/387.wav", + "text": "澄清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/388.wav", + "text": "國民黨執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/389.wav", + "text": "只有一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/390.wav", + "text": "沒有審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/391.wav", + "text": "可是那是你們執政啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/392.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有杯葛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/393.wav", + "text": "那一年剛好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/394.wav", + "text": "發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/395.wav", + "text": "是你們不審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/396.wav", + "text": "當時我還一直拜託王金平院長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/397.wav", + "text": "這個要審一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/398.wav", + "text": "至少立法院的遮羞布也要處理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/399.wav", + "text": "我要先澄清這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/400.wav", + "text": "我們回顧一下之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/401.wav", + "text": "查這個原則是不變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/402.wav", + "text": "的當然今天面對一個新的變局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/403.wav", + "text": "我必須要坦然承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/404.wav", + "text": "踢爆的這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/405.wav", + "text": "時也覺得很shock" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/406.wav", + "text": "我也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/407.wav", + "text": "這一點我們不會護短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/408.wav", + "text": "所以昨天馬上請他請辭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/409.wav", + "text": "是涉案調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/410.wav", + "text": "或身體不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/411.wav", + "text": "那個大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/412.wav", + "text": "就是叫他走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/413.wav", + "text": "已經走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/414.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/415.wav", + "text": "我們在這個場域裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/416.wav", + "text": "部會首長或董事長請辭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/417.wav", + "text": "的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/418.wav", + "text": "就是要他走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/419.wav", + "text": "人其次我們要面對的問題就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/420.wav", + "text": "我們希望二個能脫鉤處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/421.wav", + "text": "啦賴士葆委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/422.wav", + "text": "可是這一次來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/423.wav", + "text": "我希望在5月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/424.wav", + "text": "我們後面還有很多法案要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/425.wav", + "text": "大家都是在understanding" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/426.wav", + "text": "有默契的安排下來進行這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/427.wav", + "text": "況且本來出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/428.wav", + "text": "時只有12個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/429.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/430.wav", + "text": "時大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/431.wav", + "text": "律定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/432.wav", + "text": "到上禮拜三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/433.wav", + "text": "截止收案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/434.wav", + "text": "在這個過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/435.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/436.wav", + "text": "有很多部會也沒有來找我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/437.wav", + "text": "就是有沒有去進行溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/438.wav", + "text": "比如說曾銘宗委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/439.wav", + "text": "今天早上我問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/440.wav", + "text": "有沒有去跟曾委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/441.wav", + "text": "他們說昨天約好今天早上10點20" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/442.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/443.wav", + "text": "中油台電很多人都有去找你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/444.wav", + "text": "你沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/445.wav", + "text": "這麼多年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/446.wav", + "text": "我看你審查預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/447.wav", + "text": "都是要增加收入嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/448.wav", + "text": "增加8億10億20億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/449.wav", + "text": "所有國營事業員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/450.wav", + "text": "這是何等大事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/451.wav", + "text": "啊過去我們也不敢這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/452.wav", + "text": "貿然要求他們要多賺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/453.wav", + "text": "績效獎金都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/454.wav", + "text": "所以先有這個分寸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/455.wav", + "text": "能夠增加多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/456.wav", + "text": "再來談都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/457.wav", + "text": "乃至要刪減多少都可以談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/458.wav", + "text": "但他們真的做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/459.wav", + "text": "我問過中油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/460.wav", + "text": "也問過台電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/461.wav", + "text": "他們真的做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/462.wav", + "text": "我有很認真去瞭解他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/463.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/464.wav", + "text": "談到蔡見興的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/465.wav", + "text": "我們必須面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/466.wav", + "text": "你們提出來沒有專" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/467.wav", + "text": "專案報告沒有金檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/468.wav", + "text": "完成以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/469.wav", + "text": "就停審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/470.wav", + "text": "昨天包括今天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/471.wav", + "text": "我都一再跟曾銘宗委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/472.wav", + "text": "拜託讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/473.wav", + "text": "拆開來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/474.wav", + "text": "我們一定會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/475.wav", + "text": "我不管等一下財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/476.wav", + "text": "他們怎麼回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/477.wav", + "text": "我們一定要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/478.wav", + "text": "我也贊成一定要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/479.wav", + "text": "過去包括公視的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/480.wav", + "text": "你記得嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/481.wav", + "text": "那時候莊豐嘉的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/482.wav", + "text": "在協商預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/483.wav", + "text": "嗆聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/484.wav", + "text": "我也覺得他應該離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/485.wav", + "text": "這種沒什麼好護短的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/486.wav", + "text": "談到公司治理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/487.wav", + "text": "這本來就是應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/488.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/489.wav", + "text": "過去多少有一些耳聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/490.wav", + "text": "但是我不知道那是真的假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/491.wav", + "text": "因為都零星的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/492.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/493.wav", + "text": "所有民進黨黨團成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/494.wav", + "text": "大家都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/495.wav", + "text": "了講白的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/496.wav", + "text": "\n要處理這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/497.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/498.wav", + "text": "一個是金檢一個是專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/499.wav", + "text": "金檢要派人進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/500.wav", + "text": "至少也要5天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/501.wav", + "text": "進去查帳前跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/502.wav", + "text": "講要準備哪些資料給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/503.wav", + "text": "然後還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/504.wav", + "text": "進去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/505.wav", + "text": "必須要很嚴肅面對的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/506.wav", + "text": "至少要5天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/507.wav", + "text": "還要再找合庫A" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/508.wav", + "text": "合庫AMC的人來對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/509.wav", + "text": "看要補充什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/510.wav", + "text": "這個時間我們可以來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/511.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/512.wav", + "text": "檢查局的局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/513.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/514.wav", + "text": "應該是金管會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/515.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/516.wav", + "text": "檢查局局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/517.wav", + "text": "你在李進誠後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/518.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/519.wav", + "text": "大家都是內行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/520.wav", + "text": "今天的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/521.wav", + "text": "是我們贊成要面對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/522.wav", + "text": "也要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/523.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/524.wav", + "text": "也要好好地處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/525.wav", + "text": "不是虛應故事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/526.wav", + "text": "專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/527.wav", + "text": "有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/528.wav", + "text": "都更只有劃定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/529.wav", + "text": "還沒有開始都更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/530.wav", + "text": "就可以貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/531.wav", + "text": "我第一次聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/532.wav", + "text": "這也是不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/533.wav", + "text": "我今天講坦白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/534.wav", + "text": "他們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/535.wav", + "text": "早上我也對他們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/536.wav", + "text": "你們真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/537.wav", + "text": "要勇於承擔面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/538.wav", + "text": "剛才講的金檢的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/539.wav", + "text": "要進場去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/540.wav", + "text": "第二部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/541.wav", + "text": "整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/542.wav", + "text": "也要對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/543.wav", + "text": "AMC這家公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/544.wav", + "text": "的人事引進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/545.wav", + "text": "還有管理面的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/546.wav", + "text": "這些都要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/547.wav", + "text": "我不認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/548.wav", + "text": "蔡見興所引進來那些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/549.wav", + "text": "還有在公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/550.wav", + "text": "存在的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/551.wav", + "text": "我直覺的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/552.wav", + "text": "既然發生問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/553.wav", + "text": "我們應該給他時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/554.wav", + "text": "我們也會好好的監督這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/555.wav", + "text": "這不是只有國民黨的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/556.wav", + "text": "這是所有立法委員的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/557.wav", + "text": "乃至於執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/558.wav", + "text": "必須負起更大的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/559.wav", + "text": "所以我今天很懇切地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/560.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/561.wav", + "text": "我們面對結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/562.wav", + "text": "有些對我過度的捧場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/563.wav", + "text": "我很難接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/564.wav", + "text": "AMC的存在你們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/565.wav", + "text": "那是幾年前銀行有呆帳問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/566.wav", + "text": "才有的AMC現在已經沒有什麼生意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/567.wav", + "text": "做才一直做業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/568.wav", + "text": "業外的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/569.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/570.wav", + "text": "每一個銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/571.wav", + "text": "臺灣金聯也是AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/572.wav", + "text": "可是現在AMC存在的空間並不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/573.wav", + "text": "除非再一次金融風暴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/574.wav", + "text": "了也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/575.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂的什麼都聽我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/576.wav", + "text": "我說真的你們要去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/577.wav", + "text": "我也看了一些裡面的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/578.wav", + "text": "940個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/579.wav", + "text": "有的刪減數減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/580.wav", + "text": "有的說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/581.wav", + "text": "你要增加這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/582.wav", + "text": "我剛才講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/583.wav", + "text": "那你有沒有跟賴士葆講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/584.wav", + "text": "做不到的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/585.wav", + "text": "我們所有員工的績效獎金都沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/586.wav", + "text": "可以增加多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/587.wav", + "text": "我們都可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/588.wav", + "text": "我今天坐在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/589.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂什麼全部都看我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/590.wav", + "text": "我都有請他們去跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/591.wav", + "text": "12案增加到940個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/592.wav", + "text": "差不多就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/593.wav", + "text": "所以我今天說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/594.wav", + "text": "一個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/595.wav", + "text": "我們應該是要分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/596.wav", + "text": "我們等一下聽他們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/597.wav", + "text": "我在昨天和今天就是一直跟你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/598.wav", + "text": "溝通這個事情而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/599.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/600.wav", + "text": "我來問好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/601.wav", + "text": "宗發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/602.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/603.wav", + "text": "亞洲台灣商會聯合總會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/604.wav", + "text": "來拜訪立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/605.wav", + "text": "我有答應在5點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/606.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/607.wav", + "text": "可以我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/608.wav", + "text": "4點半以前就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/609.wav", + "text": "召說他有耳聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/610.wav", + "text": "他早就知道這些事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/611.wav", + "text": "是你昨天就告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/612.wav", + "text": "我昨天沒有告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/613.wav", + "text": "我才沒有告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/614.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/615.wav", + "text": "你們要調查多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/616.wav", + "text": "院長還有各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/617.wav", + "text": "這個調查其實已經開始了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/618.wav", + "text": "就是從禮拜一開始調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/619.wav", + "text": "然後金控已經開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/620.wav", + "text": "由稽核處跟業務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/621.wav", + "text": "開始進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/622.wav", + "text": "那部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/623.wav", + "text": "也會去看他們調查的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/624.wav", + "text": "所以我們一個月以內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/625.wav", + "text": "可以提出報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/626.wav", + "text": "一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/627.wav", + "text": "一定會被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/628.wav", + "text": "柯總召罵死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/629.wav", + "text": "而且不能只有合庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/630.wav", + "text": "你們的人要進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/631.wav", + "text": "是我們當然一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/632.wav", + "text": "財政部和金管會都會進去合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/633.wav", + "text": "合庫本身也會查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/634.wav", + "text": "主委做專案調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/635.wav", + "text": "總召你當過我們的長官跟局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/636.wav", + "text": "我們可以儘量配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/637.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/638.wav", + "text": "我們在檢查之前要先放表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/639.wav", + "text": "放表就是說我需要什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/640.wav", + "text": "不是到的時候才跟他要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/641.wav", + "text": "我先跟他說我需要什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/642.wav", + "text": "比方說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/643.wav", + "text": "王委員說這邊有5個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/644.wav", + "text": "有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/645.wav", + "text": "那我們針對這幾個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/646.wav", + "text": "還有關係人的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/647.wav", + "text": "我要的這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/648.wav", + "text": "請他先準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/649.wav", + "text": "過了兩三天就下去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/650.wav", + "text": "如果要查得很細密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/651.wav", + "text": "寫初步的初稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/652.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/653.wav", + "text": "檢查報告並不是我們說了算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/654.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/655.wav", + "text": "我們寫完之後還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/656.wav", + "text": "有沒有什麼不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/657.wav", + "text": "在大家溝通之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/658.wav", + "text": "我們也不見得會接受他所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/659.wav", + "text": "然後在最後才寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/660.wav", + "text": "檢查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/661.wav", + "text": "如果要壓縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/662.wav", + "text": "我們就儘量壓縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/663.wav", + "text": "我還是必須說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/664.wav", + "text": "我們不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/665.wav", + "text": "隨便寫寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/666.wav", + "text": "另外我還要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/667.wav", + "text": "總召報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/668.wav", + "text": "也跟各位長官報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/669.wav", + "text": "金管會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/670.wav", + "text": "監理資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/671.wav", + "text": "基本上是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/672.wav", + "text": "吸收社會資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/673.wav", + "text": "作為最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/674.wav", + "text": "不是由社會資金來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/675.wav", + "text": "所以它不是我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/676.wav", + "text": "特許金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/677.wav", + "text": "那我們是怎麼監管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/678.wav", + "text": "其實這也要謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/679.wav", + "text": "他在當我們主委的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/680.wav", + "text": "在103年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/681.wav", + "text": "訂了一個金控公司(銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/682.wav", + "text": ")轉投資資產管理公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/683.wav", + "text": "營運原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/684.wav", + "text": "我們是間接透過金控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/685.wav", + "text": "不只是查AMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/686.wav", + "text": "我們還要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/687.wav", + "text": "合庫金控有沒有善盡其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/688.wav", + "text": "其督導子公司的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/689.wav", + "text": "這個也要去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/690.wav", + "text": "剛才受到柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/691.wav", + "text": "你講得很客氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/692.wav", + "text": "對於我剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/693.wav", + "text": "對於基金的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/694.wav", + "text": "每一次的執行數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/695.wav", + "text": "都是預算數的5倍到6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/696.wav", + "text": "這個數字都在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/697.wav", + "text": "請他來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/698.wav", + "text": "而且你剛才講好像我怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/699.wav", + "text": "他們來溝通的人都很瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/700.wav", + "text": "我要增加多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/701.wav", + "text": "他們做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/702.wav", + "text": "我就少一個零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/703.wav", + "text": "耶我是少一個零剛才有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/704.wav", + "text": "剛才有一個案子是這樣沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/705.wav", + "text": "很多案子我都是少一個零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/706.wav", + "text": "有的我還少兩個零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/707.wav", + "text": "我都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/708.wav", + "text": "我人真的很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/709.wav", + "text": "結果他們就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/710.wav", + "text": "代表他們有去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/711.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/712.wav", + "text": "他的肢體語言就告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/713.wav", + "text": "中油的長官就是這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/714.wav", + "text": "要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/715.wav", + "text": "來就一副那個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/716.wav", + "text": "那我們不就廢掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/717.wav", + "text": "為什麼出經濟委員會以後就不能動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/718.wav", + "text": "不知道誰表達上有不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/719.wav", + "text": "我們黨團堅持的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/720.wav", + "text": "再一個月就休會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/721.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜一定可以搞定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/722.wav", + "text": "而且我們的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/723.wav", + "text": "剩不到5個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/724.wav", + "text": "這都可以一直溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/725.wav", + "text": "就可以處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/726.wav", + "text": "你就讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/727.wav", + "text": "維護一點國會的尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/728.wav", + "text": "這樣事情就會快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/729.wav", + "text": "好講結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/730.wav", + "text": "趕快去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/731.wav", + "text": "查完再繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/732.wav", + "text": "他是說兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/733.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/734.wav", + "text": "要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/735.wav", + "text": "結論要先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/736.wav", + "text": "是說一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/737.wav", + "text": "院長要開會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/738.wav", + "text": "今天可以到此為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/739.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜做得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/740.wav", + "text": "3個禮拜不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/741.wav", + "text": "要休會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/742.wav", + "text": "應該統統處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/743.wav", + "text": "今天講什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/744.wav", + "text": "就是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/745.wav", + "text": "做得到就講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/746.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/747.wav", + "text": "有一定的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/748.wav", + "text": "訂一個日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/749.wav", + "text": "本席具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/750.wav", + "text": "定一個日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/751.wav", + "text": "一定做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/752.wav", + "text": "兩個多禮拜5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/753.wav", + "text": "5月15日怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/754.wav", + "text": "儘量改為3個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/755.wav", + "text": "3個禮拜好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/756.wav", + "text": "3個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/757.wav", + "text": "3個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/758.wav", + "text": "5月15日查出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/759.wav", + "text": "反正沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/760.wav", + "text": "接近3個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/761.wav", + "text": "差不多3個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/762.wav", + "text": "如果這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/763.wav", + "text": "我這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/764.wav", + "text": "差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/765.wav", + "text": "一口價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/766.wav", + "text": "我們應該要進入協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/767.wav", + "text": "你要杯葛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/768.wav", + "text": "具到最後沒有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/769.wav", + "text": "就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/770.wav", + "text": "這樣要怎麼院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/771.wav", + "text": "院長要開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/772.wav", + "text": "你就讓院長去開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/773.wav", + "text": "3個禮拜後再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/774.wav", + "text": "他答應要提早了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/775.wav", + "text": "你也應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/776.wav", + "text": "應該要脫鉤來處理嘛他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/777.wav", + "text": "一定會弄出來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/778.wav", + "text": "就不能表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/779.wav", + "text": "報告出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/780.wav", + "text": "讓大家提早休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/781.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/782.wav", + "text": "今天開會到此為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14961/783.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/1.wav", + "text": "最主要是繼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/2.wav", + "text": "翠雲女士接下來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/3.wav", + "text": "管會主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/4.wav", + "text": "的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/5.wav", + "text": "這有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/6.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/7.wav", + "text": "因為他的兒子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/8.wav", + "text": "提供給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/9.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/10.wav", + "text": "一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/11.wav", + "text": "沒有把他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/12.wav", + "text": "是我要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/13.wav", + "text": "對這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/14.wav", + "text": "都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/15.wav", + "text": "代表他們的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/16.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/17.wav", + "text": "維護立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/18.wav", + "text": "然一定會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14960/19.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/0.wav", + "text": "大家早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1.wav", + "text": "商主題有兩項法案第一案是本社會福利及衛生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2.wav", + "text": "環境委員會併案審查完竣之行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/3.wav", + "text": "及院會決定逕付二讀與上述提案併案協商之委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/4.wav", + "text": "蘇巧慧等16人及委員楊瓊瓔等23人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/5.wav", + "text": "今日上午院會報告事項已排入委員莊競程等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/6.wav", + "text": "分別擬具之再生醫療法草案及再生醫療製劑條例草案等2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/7.wav", + "text": "雙法能夠儘速制定也回應國人對本次修法的殷殷期盼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/8.wav", + "text": "如各位協商代表對於本委員會通過之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/9.wav", + "text": "這樣才能讓我們的進度可以順利地走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/10.wav", + "text": "下去是不是可以這樣處理各位委員沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/11.wav", + "text": "從委員會保留之條文進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/12.wav", + "text": "這個部分應該比較沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/13.wav", + "text": "開始大家可以看到今天衛福部整理了一大本的資料給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/14.wav", + "text": "因為我想衛福部應該跟各位委員有很充分多次的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/15.wav", + "text": "是不是請薛部長先來做個說明謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/16.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/17.wav", + "text": "今天我們所提供的再生醫療法草案的條文對照表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/18.wav", + "text": "其實是多了最左邊的這一欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/19.wav", + "text": "即建議再修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/20.wav", + "text": "只是我們提出來的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/21.wav", + "text": "這個建議是我們在這一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/22.wav", + "text": "位委員所蒐集到委員密切關心的一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/23.wav", + "text": "我們綜合這些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/24.wav", + "text": "提出來的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/25.wav", + "text": "也就是建議修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/26.wav", + "text": "從第二欄的條文來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/27.wav", + "text": "如果中間有保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/28.wav", + "text": "為了讓今天的協商能夠順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/29.wav", + "text": "我們做這樣的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/30.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/31.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/32.wav", + "text": "我想我們召開協商前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/33.wav", + "text": "部裡面應該已經跟各委員都做了一些溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/34.wav", + "text": "待會我們看保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/35.wav", + "text": "第1條也是保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/36.wav", + "text": "上次在保留的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/37.wav", + "text": "蘇巧慧委員建議將安全放在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/38.wav", + "text": "衛福部在這次的再修正條文是把安全品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/39.wav", + "text": "這個順序稍微調動一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/40.wav", + "text": "是不是以這樣的文字通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/41.wav", + "text": "這個已經做了一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/42.wav", + "text": "接下來的保留條文是第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/43.wav", + "text": "第3條是定義的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/44.wav", + "text": "衛福部沒有提出相關的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/45.wav", + "text": "尤其在說明欄裡你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/46.wav", + "text": "有做一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/47.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員溝通之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/48.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠容許我們在說明的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/49.wav", + "text": "呈現像陳椒華委員特別在意製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/50.wav", + "text": "製劑的部分是否能夠講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/51.wav", + "text": "不是以製備特定的對象或小規模的這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/52.wav", + "text": "所以我們在提案說明的第2項提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/53.wav", + "text": "再生醫療製劑的定義係參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/54.wav", + "text": "歐洲藥物管理局對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/55.wav", + "text": "Advancedtherapymedicinalproduct" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/56.wav", + "text": "其分類另" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/57.wav", + "text": "另定於再生醫療製劑條例草案第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/58.wav", + "text": "又再生製劑為商品化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/59.wav", + "text": "規格化製程加工達標準且一致化之藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/60.wav", + "text": "不包括本法第3條第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/61.wav", + "text": "小規模客製化之再生醫療技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/62.wav", + "text": "特別強調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/63.wav", + "text": "製劑部分不是針對小規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/64.wav", + "text": "\n而針對技術的部分即第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/65.wav", + "text": "再生技術係指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/66.wav", + "text": "使用經體外培養所增殖或衍生之細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/67.wav", + "text": "屬小規模客製化使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/68.wav", + "text": "具有高風險高技術門檻之特性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/69.wav", + "text": "爰第3款第一目至第三目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/70.wav", + "text": "將未經體外培養且技術成熟安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/71.wav", + "text": "把委員特別在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/72.wav", + "text": "希望我們能夠強調的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/73.wav", + "text": "在說明欄進行修正以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/74.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員今天又提出一個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/75.wav", + "text": "衛福部有把文字放在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/76.wav", + "text": "我的修正動議是把說明的部分納進法條裡面來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/77.wav", + "text": "在第3條第3款有關再生醫療技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/78.wav", + "text": "的部分加入包括製備為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/79.wav", + "text": "治療特定對象之小規模客製化產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/80.wav", + "text": "等文字修正動議還要再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/81.wav", + "text": "的是不包括異體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/82.wav", + "text": "現在條文裡再生技術的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/83.wav", + "text": "如果沒有納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/84.wav", + "text": "是不是在說明欄一定也要放進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/85.wav", + "text": "異種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/86.wav", + "text": "其實異體是不是也不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/87.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/88.wav", + "text": "那就是將不包括異種細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/89.wav", + "text": "至少放在法律裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/90.wav", + "text": "這是第3款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/91.wav", + "text": "第2款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/92.wav", + "text": "時力黨團的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/93.wav", + "text": "有加非為製備為治療特定對象之小規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/94.wav", + "text": "等文字其用意就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/95.wav", + "text": "比較不會混淆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/96.wav", + "text": "大家對於再生技術跟再生製劑的區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/97.wav", + "text": "能夠更明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/98.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/99.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該是愈簡潔明瞭愈好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/100.wav", + "text": "至於陳椒華委員關心的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/101.wav", + "text": "其實在提案說明裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/102.wav", + "text": "已經把它完全完整納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/103.wav", + "text": "就照原來的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/104.wav", + "text": "完整地放在後面的提案說明欄裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/105.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/106.wav", + "text": "請林靜儀委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/107.wav", + "text": "我覺得已經很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/108.wav", + "text": "尤其如果要在原來的法條裡寫下小規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/109.wav", + "text": "我們是不是要重新在法條裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/110.wav", + "text": "再定義此處所謂之小規模是多少數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/111.wav", + "text": "可能會出現在定義上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/112.wav", + "text": "又要去定義什麼叫做小規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/113.wav", + "text": "我是認為在母法中間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/114.wav", + "text": "寫下這樣的文字會徒增後來在應用上的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/115.wav", + "text": "衛福部這樣的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/116.wav", + "text": "目前可供參考的國際標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/117.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣子OK了謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/118.wav", + "text": "製劑的部分強調非為製備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/119.wav", + "text": "為治療特定對象之小規模客製化產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/120.wav", + "text": "的差異寫在母法裡還是說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/121.wav", + "text": "欄你們都要說清楚差異在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/122.wav", + "text": "另外當然我也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/123.wav", + "text": "加入不包括異種細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/124.wav", + "text": "不是異體細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/125.wav", + "text": "講清楚是異種細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/126.wav", + "text": "意思就是不包括人以外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/127.wav", + "text": "異種細胞的治療技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/128.wav", + "text": "這個部分寫在母法裡應該會更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/129.wav", + "text": "所以等一下請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/130.wav", + "text": "就是剛剛林為洲委員講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/131.wav", + "text": "的異種細胞的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/132.wav", + "text": "因為異種是不同種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/133.wav", + "text": "第二件事情是寫在本文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/134.wav", + "text": "跟寫在提案說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/135.wav", + "text": "因為第3條的本文主要是在講定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/136.wav", + "text": "客製化這些都需要再做重新的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/137.wav", + "text": "在這個定義裡面又要再重新定義的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/138.wav", + "text": "所以會建議在本條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/139.wav", + "text": "就維持行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/140.wav", + "text": "我們這邊是可以接受以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/141.wav", + "text": "是不是就照原來行政院的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/142.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員所關心的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/143.wav", + "text": "已經補充了只差了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/144.wav", + "text": "再生醫療技術不包含異種來源之細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/145.wav", + "text": "讓這個條文能夠簡潔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/146.wav", + "text": "然後大家可以通過這個定義的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/147.wav", + "text": "\n請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/148.wav", + "text": "食藥署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/149.wav", + "text": "尤其食藥署給了我非常多國外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/150.wav", + "text": "包括日本韓國的法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/151.wav", + "text": "可是他們的法條都寫很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/152.wav", + "text": "寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/153.wav", + "text": "厚厚一疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/154.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛你說文字要簡潔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/155.wav", + "text": "曠日費時再去寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/156.wav", + "text": "當然也是理由之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/157.wav", + "text": "啦但是簡潔不是最好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/158.wav", + "text": "這點我們還是要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/159.wav", + "text": "這個邏輯還是要談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/160.wav", + "text": "當然最重要的是安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/161.wav", + "text": "這個大家都是有共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/162.wav", + "text": "當然表決我們也會輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/163.wav", + "text": "將不包含異種細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/164.wav", + "text": "就是不包括異種細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/165.wav", + "text": "7個字而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/166.wav", + "text": "嘛至於包括製備為治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/167.wav", + "text": "客製化產品那個不要沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/168.wav", + "text": "但是不包括異種細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/169.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/170.wav", + "text": "在第3款裡面要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/171.wav", + "text": "異種來源之細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/172.wav", + "text": "可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/173.wav", + "text": "你的修正動議裡面也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/174.wav", + "text": "沒有你原來的修正動議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/175.wav", + "text": "我現在說不行嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/176.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/177.wav", + "text": "我們要確定你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/178.wav", + "text": "我現在在跟醫事司說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/179.wav", + "text": "那我們也可以表達我們的陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/180.wav", + "text": "我們只是釐清你的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/181.wav", + "text": "因為原來是在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/182.wav", + "text": "現在你要把它放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/183.wav", + "text": "你要不要提出你的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/184.wav", + "text": "那你法條裡面的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/185.wav", + "text": "我們再寫再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/186.wav", + "text": "我是建議這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/187.wav", + "text": "文字不是寫越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/188.wav", + "text": "表示我們越有知識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/189.wav", + "text": "定義的東西就是越簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/190.wav", + "text": "越清楚明瞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/191.wav", + "text": "有一些大家覺得應該備註" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/192.wav", + "text": "把它放在提案說明裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/193.wav", + "text": "去說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/194.wav", + "text": "剛剛陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/195.wav", + "text": "您又提到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/196.wav", + "text": "異種細胞的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/197.wav", + "text": "修正動議裡頭也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/198.wav", + "text": "所以我們才詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/199.wav", + "text": "說可是你自己的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/200.wav", + "text": "也沒有這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/201.wav", + "text": "你現在自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/202.wav", + "text": "要再加上去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/203.wav", + "text": "你要不要再提一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/204.wav", + "text": "再修正動議出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/205.wav", + "text": "大家比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/206.wav", + "text": "今天不是來意氣用事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/207.wav", + "text": "我們大家都希望這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/208.wav", + "text": "能夠順利地通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/209.wav", + "text": "您的意見也很受到尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/210.wav", + "text": "所以也把您所有的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/211.wav", + "text": "都放在提案說明裡頭了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/212.wav", + "text": "我覺得大家不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/213.wav", + "text": "在這裡意氣用事的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/214.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/215.wav", + "text": "如果還有一些爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/216.wav", + "text": "我們就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/217.wav", + "text": "我們有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/218.wav", + "text": "都放在說明欄來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/219.wav", + "text": "但如果大家還是不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/220.wav", + "text": "如果有再提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/221.wav", + "text": "我就拜託衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/222.wav", + "text": "不包括異種細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/223.wav", + "text": "讓我知道這樣等一下我寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/224.wav", + "text": "的就不用再花時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/225.wav", + "text": "請邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/226.wav", + "text": "衛福部已經說可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/227.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/228.wav", + "text": "他們還要討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/229.wav", + "text": "\n請邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/230.wav", + "text": "所有的相關法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/231.wav", + "text": "一定會想說它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/232.wav", + "text": "到底要我做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/233.wav", + "text": "這個就是為了救人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/234.wav", + "text": "conditionalapproval" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/235.wav", + "text": "我們都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/236.wav", + "text": "也經過了多少時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/237.wav", + "text": "多少年大家的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/238.wav", + "text": "所以你要加任何一個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/239.wav", + "text": "也覺得它很多用詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/240.wav", + "text": "所以這個立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/241.wav", + "text": "好好重新寫一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/242.wav", + "text": "而不是把一段拿下來就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/243.wav", + "text": "單單什麼叫做再生製劑連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/244.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/245.wav", + "text": "劑還是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/246.wav", + "text": "我們的病人都那麼衰弱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/247.wav", + "text": "他拿著細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/248.wav", + "text": "我跟你講都不成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/249.wav", + "text": "很可憐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/250.wav", + "text": "結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/251.wav", + "text": "三個禮拜後又復發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/252.wav", + "text": "請同情這些人好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/253.wav", + "text": "一定不能來考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/254.wav", + "text": "研究一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/255.wav", + "text": "別人健康的細胞來培養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/256.wav", + "text": "雖然現在的技術還沒有到這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/257.wav", + "text": "但是你不能中斷這種技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/258.wav", + "text": "我們一定要往這方面想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/259.wav", + "text": "不要一直想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/260.wav", + "text": "啊又要退縮到完全沒有發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/261.wav", + "text": "沒有前瞻性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/262.wav", + "text": "所謂的第一個法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/263.wav", + "text": "又退縮到那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/264.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個法大概就不用設立了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/265.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/266.wav", + "text": "要站在人民的立場來考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/267.wav", + "text": "方面一定要請衛福部提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/268.wav", + "text": "要怎麼管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/269.wav", + "text": "這個我絕對支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/270.wav", + "text": "但是要考慮到人民的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/271.wav", + "text": "需求我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/272.wav", + "text": "原來的版本我們經過這麼久的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/273.wav", + "text": "支持原來的行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/274.wav", + "text": "於立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/275.wav", + "text": "整體來講可能會因為討論以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/276.wav", + "text": "而有所變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/277.wav", + "text": "我覺得要留點空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/278.wav", + "text": "這裡一定要完全訂死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/279.wav", + "text": "今天會送出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/280.wav", + "text": "我建議今天還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/281.wav", + "text": "儘量能夠出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/282.wav", + "text": "但是最後在總協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/283.wav", + "text": "可能還會調整文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/284.wav", + "text": "你要調我都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/285.wav", + "text": "但是先不要加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/286.wav", + "text": "整個原來的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/287.wav", + "text": "衛福部也要站在人民的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/288.wav", + "text": "看看當時設立這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/289.wav", + "text": "還是要堅持這種核心價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/290.wav", + "text": "沒有特別意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/291.wav", + "text": "其實這個還不周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/292.wav", + "text": "要讓它周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/293.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得隨便動法條內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/294.wav", + "text": "已經經過那麼多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/295.wav", + "text": "包括行政院那麼多專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/296.wav", + "text": "都討論過的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/297.wav", + "text": "恐怕會把這個法毀掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/298.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/299.wav", + "text": "我必須說陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/300.wav", + "text": "剛剛提出來的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/301.wav", + "text": "確實有一些新的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/302.wav", + "text": "客製化都有討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/303.wav", + "text": "再生醫療技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/304.wav", + "text": "不包含異種來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/305.wav", + "text": "我想行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/306.wav", + "text": "一定還要再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/307.wav", + "text": "所以這一條是不是先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/308.wav", + "text": "因為這不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/309.wav", + "text": "主席製備為治療特定對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/310.wav", + "text": "之小規模客製化產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/311.wav", + "text": "不是新的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/312.wav", + "text": "不是我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/313.wav", + "text": "至少有溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/314.wav", + "text": "衛福部的法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/315.wav", + "text": "在第9條的說明早就有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/316.wav", + "text": "所以這不是新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/317.wav", + "text": "是我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/318.wav", + "text": "然後我的修正動議也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/319.wav", + "text": "跟衛福部溝通過兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/320.wav", + "text": "兩次之後在製劑這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/321.wav", + "text": "本來我們堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/322.wav", + "text": "一定要用人類細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/323.wav", + "text": "所以這個就是溝通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/324.wav", + "text": "然後在溝通的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/325.wav", + "text": "再生醫療技術不要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/326.wav", + "text": "異種細胞也溝通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/327.wav", + "text": "只是昨天我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/328.wav", + "text": "修正的時候忘了加上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/329.wav", + "text": "讓他們有時間再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/330.wav", + "text": "斟酌一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/331.wav", + "text": "好第3條就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/332.wav", + "text": "有做了再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/333.wav", + "text": "有綜整大家的意見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/334.wav", + "text": "綜整各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/335.wav", + "text": "之前的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/336.wav", + "text": "再加上上次委員會討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/337.wav", + "text": "的當時在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/338.wav", + "text": "就我們講的審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/339.wav", + "text": "這個名詞確定是審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/340.wav", + "text": "審議會裡面的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/341.wav", + "text": "可能要有比較明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/342.wav", + "text": "把醫療科技倫理法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/343.wav", + "text": "及其他相關專業學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/344.wav", + "text": "專家的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/345.wav", + "text": "已經納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/346.wav", + "text": "這是第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/347.wav", + "text": "文字的第一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/348.wav", + "text": "針對那一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/349.wav", + "text": "專家委員的背景\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/350.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/351.wav", + "text": "因為大家都很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/352.wav", + "text": "的問題可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/353.wav", + "text": "在這個地方強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/354.wav", + "text": "議事利益迴避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/355.wav", + "text": "及其他應遵行事項之辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/356.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/357.wav", + "text": "以這樣的模式來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/358.wav", + "text": "在上次討論過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/359.wav", + "text": "利益迴避的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/360.wav", + "text": "希望我們能夠加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/361.wav", + "text": "明請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/362.wav", + "text": "辦理事項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/363.wav", + "text": "第2項第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/364.wav", + "text": "審議只有這個沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/365.wav", + "text": "那一些機構或團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/366.wav", + "text": "到底要不要經過這個審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/367.wav", + "text": "因為我的修正動議第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/368.wav", + "text": "剛好跟這個有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/369.wav", + "text": "我就順便在這裡先提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/370.wav", + "text": "未來核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/371.wav", + "text": "也放在第5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/372.wav", + "text": "條請參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/373.wav", + "text": "請林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/374.wav", + "text": "第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/375.wav", + "text": "我自己的修正動議內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/376.wav", + "text": "有附款許可之審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/377.wav", + "text": "因為從第1款到第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/378.wav", + "text": "只有這一款是審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/379.wav", + "text": "其他都是諮詢的性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/380.wav", + "text": "意思是這個審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/381.wav", + "text": "不管叫什麼名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/382.wav", + "text": "我們叫它審議會好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/383.wav", + "text": "其實是一個諮詢單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/384.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/385.wav", + "text": "不是一個決策單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/386.wav", + "text": "到最後還是要回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/387.wav", + "text": "專業的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/388.wav", + "text": "我們在委員會已經討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/389.wav", + "text": "因為這個審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/390.wav", + "text": "到底是不是一個行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/391.wav", + "text": "能不能接受所謂行政處分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/392.wav", + "text": "這個都定位不清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/393.wav", + "text": "所以最好它還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/394.wav", + "text": "不要打破現有的規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/395.wav", + "text": "變成一個可以審議決定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/396.wav", + "text": "因為它不是機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/397.wav", + "text": "因此我們還是把第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/398.wav", + "text": "這個意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/399.wav", + "text": "兩道關卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/400.wav", + "text": "審議會先審查並提出意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/401.wav", + "text": "再生醫療製劑技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/402.wav", + "text": "專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/403.wav", + "text": "跟醫事司是專業的機關吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/404.wav", + "text": "讓他們最後做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/405.wav", + "text": "也要負起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/406.wav", + "text": "的開宗明義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/407.wav", + "text": "大家都在強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/408.wav", + "text": "最重要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/409.wav", + "text": "是安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/410.wav", + "text": "安全還擺到第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/411.wav", + "text": "了所以我還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/412.wav", + "text": "將第7款的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/413.wav", + "text": "還是由食藥署醫事司來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/414.wav", + "text": "請邱議瑩委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/415.wav", + "text": "林為洲委員的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/416.wav", + "text": "這跟本席原來的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/417.wav", + "text": "所以這條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/418.wav", + "text": "當時保留的情形是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/419.wav", + "text": "食藥署對於任何一個藥證的核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/420.wav", + "text": "對於任何一個製劑的核發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/421.wav", + "text": "本來就有一個很嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/422.wav", + "text": "很專業的審查機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/423.wav", + "text": "的諮詢性質其實遠大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/424.wav", + "text": "因此如果林為洲���員也支持的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/425.wav", + "text": "支持我原來的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/426.wav", + "text": "實質審查部分還是回到食藥署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/427.wav", + "text": "第1項第2款及第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/428.wav", + "text": "扮演一個審查或諮詢的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/429.wav", + "text": "已經將第2款及第3款拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/430.wav", + "text": "只針對治療危及生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/431.wav", + "text": "或嚴重失能之疾病來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/432.wav", + "text": "所以我就沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/433.wav", + "text": "第5條配合修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/434.wav", + "text": "如果第9條等一下是照行政院的版本處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/435.wav", + "text": "我也支持行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/436.wav", + "text": "等一下請衛福部一起回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/437.wav", + "text": "所以甚至連名稱都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/438.wav", + "text": "這件事情非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/439.wav", + "text": "或是我們依據該版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/440.wav", + "text": "各自提出的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/441.wav", + "text": "就算有這個審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/442.wav", + "text": "其實我們都明白最後把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/443.wav", + "text": "最後的決定者還是衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/444.wav", + "text": "說明目前版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/445.wav", + "text": "審議會下面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/446.wav", + "text": "各項事件裡面有諮詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/447.wav", + "text": "款的文字是用審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/448.wav", + "text": "如果我沒有記錯的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/449.wav", + "text": "是把兩次關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/450.wav", + "text": "比單純只寫衛福部審核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/451.wav", + "text": "我的理解是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/452.wav", + "text": "唯獨第7款用審議的原因是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/453.wav", + "text": "一併再說明一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/454.wav", + "text": "會出現在哪一條的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/455.wav", + "text": "請你們也再次說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/456.wav", + "text": "嘛你們回答的時候請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/457.wav", + "text": "至少要回答這二個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/458.wav", + "text": "真的非常感佩為洲兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/459.wav", + "text": "這麼關心人民的健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/460.wav", + "text": "也都把安全擺在第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/461.wav", + "text": "我們也都非常同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/462.wav", + "text": "上次巧慧委員把安全擺在第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/463.wav", + "text": "符合時代潮流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/464.wav", + "text": "這是不變的真理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/465.wav", + "text": "所以我們要怎麼樣讓人民安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/466.wav", + "text": "醫療品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/467.wav", + "text": "用盡智慧心血發明出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/468.wav", + "text": "驗證給病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/469.wav", + "text": "醫療給病人使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/470.wav", + "text": "所以不管是審議或者是那一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/471.wav", + "text": "那一種議都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/472.wav", + "text": "最重要的是對人民交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/473.wav", + "text": "馬上就要用很多金錢的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/474.wav", + "text": "要給他安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/475.wav", + "text": "在很多討論當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/476.wav", + "text": "這些比較會面對民眾的行政部門長官們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/477.wav", + "text": "其實也都認為審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/478.wav", + "text": "審議是一件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/479.wav", + "text": "能夠對人民交代的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/480.wav", + "text": "\n這個部分大家可以看一下經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/481.wav", + "text": "經濟部審再生能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/482.wav", + "text": "但是發照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/483.wav", + "text": "也是讓能源局去發照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/484.wav", + "text": "職多一個好好的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/485.wav", + "text": "然後所有可能會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/486.wav", + "text": "病人或病人可能會用到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/487.wav", + "text": "再生醫療相關製品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/488.wav", + "text": "理論上都應該要審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/489.wav", + "text": "這是一個精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/490.wav", + "text": "這個有需要改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/491.wav", + "text": "\n為什麼要怕審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/492.wav", + "text": "我實在想不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/493.wav", + "text": "審議不是對人民很好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/494.wav", + "text": "審議也不會影響到行政部門的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/495.wav", + "text": "反而把level提高到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/496.wav", + "text": "衛福部部長次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/497.wav", + "text": "也許是次長部長來主持這樣一個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/498.wav", + "text": "都是專業的人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/499.wav", + "text": "關於專業人才要怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/500.wav", + "text": "由他們把關以後提供意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/501.wav", + "text": "還是衛福部負責的行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/502.wav", + "text": "架構不是很美好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/503.wav", + "text": "今天我們所有擔心的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/504.wav", + "text": "理論上都要在這裡審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/505.wav", + "text": "也不用把什麼拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/506.wav", + "text": "這個條文的第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/507.wav", + "text": "再生醫療製劑條例第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/508.wav", + "text": "其實是連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/509.wav", + "text": "附款許可部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/510.wav", + "text": "再生醫療審議會審議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/511.wav", + "text": "等一下醫事司跟食藥署還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/512.wav", + "text": "一併說明審議會跟行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/513.wav", + "text": "機關裁量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/514.wav", + "text": "我先補充一下意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/515.wav", + "text": "基本上我對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/516.wav", + "text": "對於是審議會或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/517.wav", + "text": "委員說的如果它只是諮詢性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/518.wav", + "text": "講的其實是有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/519.wav", + "text": "在conditionalapproval這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/520.wav", + "text": "諮詢性質的定義就非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/521.wav", + "text": "清楚如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/522.wav", + "text": "其實支持行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/523.wav", + "text": "的提案我沒有問題以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/524.wav", + "text": "邱議瑩委員也支持\n請吳署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/525.wav", + "text": "首先有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/526.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/527.wav", + "text": "裡面對於再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/528.wav", + "text": "製劑簡稱再生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/529.wav", + "text": "委員報告對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/530.wav", + "text": "有附款的許可我們針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/531.wav", + "text": "的是那一些危及生命或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/532.wav", + "text": "嚴重失能的疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/533.wav", + "text": "但是這樣子的一個申請案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/534.wav", + "text": "它必須要完成臨床試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/535.wav", + "text": "的第二期才可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/536.wav", + "text": "申請這個有附款的許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/537.wav", + "text": "傳統對於藥品許可證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/538.wav", + "text": "要完成第三期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/539.wav", + "text": "臨床試驗大家心裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/540.wav", + "text": "一定還是會有一點疑惑啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/541.wav", + "text": "但事實上我們對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/542.wav", + "text": "我跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/543.wav", + "text": "的各位可以看到在前段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/544.wav", + "text": "的部分廠商開始送件了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/545.wav", + "text": "我們就會開始認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/546.wav", + "text": "它是否符合申請的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/547.wav", + "text": "我們也會確認它的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/548.wav", + "text": "我們就會針對技術性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/549.wav", + "text": "部分完成審查在技術性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/550.wav", + "text": "資料審查部分有食藥署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/551.wav", + "text": "跟醫藥品查驗中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/552.wav", + "text": "(CDE)審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/553.wav", + "text": "報告產生之後如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/554.wav", + "text": "醫學諮議小組的我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/555.wav", + "text": "會進到小組裡面討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/556.wav", + "text": "討論之後對於這種有附款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/557.wav", + "text": "許可的以及依我們看它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/558.wav", + "text": "有機會成功的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/559.wav", + "text": "我們就會送到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/560.wav", + "text": "衛福部的再生醫療審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/561.wav", + "text": "核予有附款許可的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/562.wav", + "text": "合適性還有它對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/563.wav", + "text": "於相關附款的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/564.wav", + "text": "我們要求它必須繼續再做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/565.wav", + "text": "療效的驗證以及要如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/566.wav", + "text": "收錢要收多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/567.wav", + "text": "還有相關的救濟措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/568.wav", + "text": "統統都要很明確地說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/569.wav", + "text": "再生醫療審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/570.wav", + "text": "如果也覺得它是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/571.wav", + "text": "決議核予有附款許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/572.wav", + "text": "最後再發證但發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/573.wav", + "text": "有附款許可還是食藥署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/574.wav", + "text": "過去我們對於所有許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/575.wav", + "text": "現在是多了一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/576.wav", + "text": "就是在部的這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/577.wav", + "text": "有一個再生醫療審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/578.wav", + "text": "我們覺得對於這種只有完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/579.wav", + "text": "第二期臨床試驗它不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/580.wav", + "text": "拿我們的許可證可是要有附款許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/581.wav", + "text": "才能用到病人身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/582.wav", + "text": "所以大家對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/583.wav", + "text": "如果用審議我們也不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/584.wav", + "text": "的決定以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/585.wav", + "text": "這一個審議會的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/586.wav", + "text": "我先稱之為審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/587.wav", + "text": "稱其為審議會的原因是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/588.wav", + "text": "我們就是強調其中有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/589.wav", + "text": "傾向這個除了剛剛吳署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/590.wav", + "text": "說的部分這是我的補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/591.wav", + "text": "如果把申請案也拉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/592.wav", + "text": "這個審議會的話其實這樣會造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/593.wav", + "text": "行政效率的延宕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/594.wav", + "text": "因為每一個申請案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/595.wav", + "text": "有疑義的部分大概都會拉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/596.wav", + "text": "有疑義的部分所以我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/597.wav", + "text": "建議再修正條文的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/598.wav", + "text": "內容以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/599.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/600.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/601.wav", + "text": "我剛剛的問題並不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/602.wav", + "text": "每一個案子都要拉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/603.wav", + "text": "審議會我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/604.wav", + "text": "醫療機構申請的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/605.wav", + "text": "案子你們會有委辦的單位嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/606.wav", + "text": "嘛我剛剛的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/607.wav", + "text": "這些委辦單位的核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/608.wav", + "text": "要不要到審議會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/609.wav", + "text": "進行核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/610.wav", + "text": "可是實際上因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/611.wav", + "text": "的第8條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/612.wav", + "text": "委辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/613.wav", + "text": "未來很重要的再生技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/614.wav", + "text": "的核准你們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/615.wav", + "text": "由委辦單位去進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/616.wav", + "text": "去執行對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/617.wav", + "text": "不是核准的部分是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/618.wav", + "text": "醫事司這邊我們其實跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/619.wav", + "text": "食藥署是一樣的因為最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/620.wav", + "text": "民眾如果對於我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/621.wav", + "text": "發出去不許可的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/622.wav", + "text": "其實是回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/623.wav", + "text": "沒關係那我的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/624.wav", + "text": "就到第8條再討論謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/625.wav", + "text": "剛剛聽完食藥署說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/626.wav", + "text": "後我們就比較清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/627.wav", + "text": "講到審議其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/628.wav", + "text": "主要是針對附款許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/629.wav", + "text": "部分的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/630.wav", + "text": "但是這個審議還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/631.wav", + "text": "很多規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/632.wav", + "text": "等所以只有在附款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/633.wav", + "text": "許可的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/634.wav", + "text": "來審議其他的都還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/635.wav", + "text": "回歸到食藥署比如正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/636.wav", + "text": "還是要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/637.wav", + "text": "完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/638.wav", + "text": "才會發藥證等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/639.wav", + "text": "但如果是這樣你在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/640.wav", + "text": "這樣的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/641.wav", + "text": "再生製劑的第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/642.wav", + "text": "在再生製劑那邊才會寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/643.wav", + "text": "附款許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/644.wav", + "text": "才是要經過審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/645.wav", + "text": "這樣講會比較清楚啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/646.wav", + "text": "大家才不會認為所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/647.wav", + "text": "製劑統統是這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/648.wav", + "text": "俎代庖幫你們做決定不管叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/649.wav", + "text": "名稱外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/650.wav", + "text": "會有這樣的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/651.wav", + "text": "所以到最後如果他們的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/652.wav", + "text": "太大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/653.wav", + "text": "要競逐角力的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/654.wav", + "text": "那是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/655.wav", + "text": "不樂見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/656.wav", + "text": "所以如果是這樣我們到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/657.wav", + "text": "所以這個保留嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/658.wav", + "text": "是先保留因為這兩個條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/659.wav", + "text": "連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/660.wav", + "text": "我們就先保留之後討論到那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/661.wav", + "text": "的時候再一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/662.wav", + "text": "不是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/663.wav", + "text": "你不是說連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/664.wav", + "text": "就是要一起處理我們已經在協商了就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/665.wav", + "text": "立法說明裡面有沒有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/666.wav", + "text": "這裡處理掉再生製劑第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/667.wav", + "text": "才能一併處理啊你現在又保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/668.wav", + "text": "到再生製劑第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/669.wav", + "text": "有沒有寫針對這個審議是限定在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/670.wav", + "text": "附款許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/671.wav", + "text": "好像不需要是在說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/672.wav", + "text": "第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/673.wav", + "text": "的法條文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/674.wav", + "text": "對它已經很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/675.wav", + "text": "的寫有附款許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/676.wav", + "text": "剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/677.wav", + "text": "都是諮詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/678.wav", + "text": "第7款的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/679.wav", + "text": "是審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/680.wav", + "text": "我再請問最後一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/681.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/682.wav", + "text": "接受也就是附" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/683.wav", + "text": "到時候會規範在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/684.wav", + "text": "的所以有包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/685.wav", + "text": "一些剛剛你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/686.wav", + "text": "收費等各方面規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/687.wav", + "text": "不會讓病人在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/688.wav", + "text": "絕望沒有選擇的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/689.wav", + "text": "你知道我們擔心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/690.wav", + "text": "的製劑條例會有詳細規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/691.wav", + "text": "組成再生醫療審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/692.wav", + "text": "因為審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/693.wav", + "text": "力道比較輕審議力道比較強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/694.wav", + "text": "所以這裡既然要賦予它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/695.wav", + "text": "劑有附款許可之審議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/696.wav", + "text": "衛福部現在再生醫療法這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/697.wav", + "text": "版本中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/698.wav", + "text": "應組成再生醫療審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/699.wav", + "text": "謝謝剛剛食藥署的說明我覺得這樣聽起來就很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/700.wav", + "text": "我們現在最深水區的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/701.wav", + "text": "其實就是有附款許可這塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/702.wav", + "text": "上次也提過我們理解它為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/703.wav", + "text": "要走附款許可因為它等不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/704.wav", + "text": "足夠數量等不到一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/705.wav", + "text": "到第三期我們為什麼今天要修這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/706.wav", + "text": "就是因為如果每個東西都要等到第三期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/707.wav", + "text": "我們有很多病人在等待過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/708.wav", + "text": "連最後一個可能的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/709.wav", + "text": "都會沒有我們不希望讓病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/710.wav", + "text": "沒有這個已經具有一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/711.wav", + "text": "他這個治療機會我相信我們今天在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/712.wav", + "text": "修這個法應該在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/713.wav", + "text": "的人都同意希望今天修這些法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/714.wav", + "text": "是讓有機會用再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/715.wav", + "text": "治療的病人有可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/716.wav", + "text": "賦予法律上的權限現在很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/717.wav", + "text": "醫療人員告訴我們說他們有這個技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/718.wav", + "text": "我必須強調我們現在的精神在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/719.wav", + "text": "製劑條例中附款許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/720.wav", + "text": "會先經過食藥署也就是在整個流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/721.wav", + "text": "上假設我今天有一個需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/722.wav", + "text": "走附款許可的流程因為它沒有辦法到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/723.wav", + "text": "一個審議食藥署審議是審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/724.wav", + "text": "data是不是符合他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/725.wav", + "text": "資料審完之後會進到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/726.wav", + "text": "這邊所說的中央主管機關的再生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/727.wav", + "text": "醫療審議會這個審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/728.wav", + "text": "以今天提到的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/729.wav", + "text": "除了科技以外因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/730.wav", + "text": "剛剛食藥署那邊是就科技技術的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/731.wav", + "text": "data來看但在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/732.wav", + "text": "這邊中央主管機關的審議會它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/733.wav", + "text": "包含倫理法律跟其他相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/734.wav", + "text": "說你們那邊的data看起來可以可是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/735.wav", + "text": "在倫理道德處理程序上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/736.wav", + "text": "會不會對病人有一定程度的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/737.wav", + "text": "這邊審過了它才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/738.wav", + "text": "能夠再回到食藥署去發證我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/739.wav", + "text": "整體的流程是這樣的剛剛其實我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/740.wav", + "text": "員有在這邊討論這樣子的兩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/741.wav", + "text": "個把關是對於我們必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/742.wav", + "text": "走附款許可這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/743.wav", + "text": "流程做雙重把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/744.wav", + "text": "它對於病人來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/745.wav", + "text": "可減少不必要的剝削避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/746.wav", + "text": "病人在資訊不對等的情況下受到傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/747.wav", + "text": "同時也保障病人有機會接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/748.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法做到三期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/749.wav", + "text": "我也必須說那也會出現一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/750.wav", + "text": "很久就我們的紀錄食藥署都審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/751.wav", + "text": "再生醫療審議會我為什麼要這樣補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/752.wav", + "text": "或新藥許可裡面它在食藥署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/753.wav", + "text": "先審了一輪健保還要再審一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/754.wav", + "text": "我們還有一個醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/755.wav", + "text": "因為它是自費項目還要經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/756.wav", + "text": "審一次價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/757.wav", + "text": "還要再經過健保署審健保署審完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/758.wav", + "text": "自費的還要再經過地方衛生主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/759.wav", + "text": "\n所以大家最詬病的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/760.wav", + "text": "在食藥署那等了很久等那邊審完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/761.wav", + "text": "還不能同步還要再等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/762.wav", + "text": "健保署我們現行的藥品是走這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/763.wav", + "text": "流程大家最詬病的就是等好久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/764.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛說的這兩個把關的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/765.wav", + "text": "我相信各位委員應該都一致同意這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/766.wav", + "text": "兩個把關就是要保障病人安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/767.wav", + "text": "保障倫理上面沒有太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/768.wav", + "text": "我們目前沒有辦法考慮到的瑕疵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/769.wav", + "text": "但是在這個過程裡面我們必須承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/770.wav", + "text": "會有病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/771.wav", + "text": "為什麼我要等這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/772.wav", + "text": "然後我們就只能告訴他說我們必須要雙重把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/773.wav", + "text": "因為是採附款許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/774.wav", + "text": "我理解我也支持簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/775.wav", + "text": "說我支持行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/776.wav", + "text": "的第5條再修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/777.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個版本用審議這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/778.wav", + "text": "我接受而且我認為這樣的話是雙重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/779.wav", + "text": "把關應該有達到我們大家希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/780.wav", + "text": "保障倫理以及其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/781.wav", + "text": "醫學專業的部分謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/782.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員還有其他不同意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/783.wav", + "text": "還是我們就支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/784.wav", + "text": "沒有我要謝謝他們的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/785.wav", + "text": "衛福部有把倫理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/786.wav", + "text": "放進好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/787.wav", + "text": "因為這個條文大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/788.wav", + "text": "也充分討論了而且大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/789.wav", + "text": "也支持雙重把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/790.wav", + "text": "但就是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/791.wav", + "text": "這個程序會拖很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/792.wav", + "text": "這個部分請行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/793.wav", + "text": "在未來的行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/794.wav", + "text": "作業上能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/795.wav", + "text": "配合得更快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/796.wav", + "text": "行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/797.wav", + "text": "再修正動議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/798.wav", + "text": "協商通過可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/799.wav", + "text": "第5條就這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/800.wav", + "text": "大家很高興喔再來進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/801.wav", + "text": "第9條高興之餘我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/802.wav", + "text": "可不可以補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/803.wav", + "text": "我贊成通過啦恭喜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/804.wav", + "text": "趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/805.wav", + "text": "第8條是已經通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/806.wav", + "text": "如果有要處理的話待會第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/807.wav", + "text": "因為很多在發展這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/808.wav", + "text": "擔心審查的流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/809.wav", + "text": "都滿長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/810.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/811.wav", + "text": "跟大家說明一下因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/812.wav", + "text": "因為法已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/813.wav", + "text": "的前提下可以快速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/814.wav", + "text": "華委員最在意倫理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/815.wav", + "text": "我我是說怎麼樣讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/816.wav", + "text": "生技業者能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/817.wav", + "text": "傳統的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/818.wav", + "text": "那就沒有辦法突破嘛應該有一些突破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/819.wav", + "text": "的方式因為有法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/820.wav", + "text": "快速行政部門未來是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/821.wav", + "text": "對病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/822.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分可能是未來也需要注意的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/823.wav", + "text": "感謝大家繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/824.wav", + "text": "再修正動議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/825.wav", + "text": "在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/826.wav", + "text": "討論過之後對於第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/827.wav", + "text": "其實��家最大的疑慮是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/828.wav", + "text": "我們在再生醫療這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/829.wav", + "text": "\n可是實際上我們回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/830.wav", + "text": "第9條重新再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/831.wav", + "text": "做一些討論的時候本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/832.wav", + "text": "現況就是將細胞治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/833.wav", + "text": "還有就是處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/834.wav", + "text": "溝通以及聽到很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/835.wav", + "text": "的意見因此我們修正的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/836.wav", + "text": "危及生命或嚴重失能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/837.wav", + "text": "之疾病且國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/838.wav", + "text": "尚無適當之藥品而執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/839.wav", + "text": "倫理審查委員會核准之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/840.wav", + "text": "證明二治療計畫書三病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/841.wav", + "text": "同意書四細胞治療製備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/842.wav", + "text": "場所之證明前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/843.wav", + "text": "項各款得檢附相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/844.wav", + "text": "機關定之以這樣子來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/845.wav", + "text": "就是限縮到我們只處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/846.wav", + "text": "恩慈療法的部分以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/847.wav", + "text": "好謝謝這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/848.wav", + "text": "有做了比較大幅度的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/849.wav", + "text": "我覺得也更清楚只針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/850.wav", + "text": "恩慈療法的部分來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/851.wav", + "text": "大家覺得這個條文可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/852.wav", + "text": "\n請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/853.wav", + "text": "因為我有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/854.wav", + "text": "我就先說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/855.wav", + "text": "我的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/856.wav", + "text": "的院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/857.wav", + "text": "版今天看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/858.wav", + "text": "新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/859.wav", + "text": "再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/860.wav", + "text": "有比較大的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/861.wav", + "text": "我是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/862.wav", + "text": "好謝謝\n請林靜儀委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/863.wav", + "text": "覺得衛福部這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/864.wav", + "text": "跟原來版本的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/865.wav", + "text": "我有對錯條文嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/866.wav", + "text": "沒有它真的做滿大幅的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/867.wav", + "text": "對啊變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/868.wav", + "text": "變化這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/869.wav", + "text": "是原本院版條文中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/870.wav", + "text": "中第1款針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/871.wav", + "text": "恩慈療法的部分我們就拉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/872.wav", + "text": "上面去把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/873.wav", + "text": "下列情形之一者這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/874.wav", + "text": "治療危及生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/875.wav", + "text": "這邊往上然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/876.wav", + "text": "個案的這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/877.wav", + "text": "也就是平常在講的恩慈療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/878.wav", + "text": "這部分正式的把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/879.wav", + "text": "講得比較清楚即所謂恩慈療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/880.wav", + "text": "目的是在於治療危及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/881.wav", + "text": "生命或嚴重失能之疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/882.wav", + "text": "且國內尚無適當之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/883.wav", + "text": "藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/884.wav", + "text": "改成治療危及生命或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/885.wav", + "text": "嚴重失能之疾病且國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/886.wav", + "text": "尚無適當之藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/887.wav", + "text": "這段是只會cover" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/888.wav", + "text": "恩慈療法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/889.wav", + "text": "還是你們有可能會把什麼疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/890.wav", + "text": "或其他的東西都放在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/891.wav", + "text": "連現有沒有藥品的現有治療還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/892.wav", + "text": "研發的全都包在這裡頭了而不會只有恩慈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/893.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法理解為什麼你說前面這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/894.wav", + "text": "不會cover到其他東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/895.wav", + "text": "因為這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/896.wav", + "text": "單一個案的申請是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/897.wav", + "text": "IRB要同意的證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/898.wav", + "text": "治療計畫書跟病人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/899.wav", + "text": "要有證明以這樣的模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/900.wav", + "text": "來處理單一個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/901.wav", + "text": "要回到第8條來做申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/902.wav", + "text": "藥品或醫療器材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/903.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/904.wav", + "text": "我們目前再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/905.wav", + "text": "我們跟食藥署有討論過相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/906.wav", + "text": "藥品來做一個稱呼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/907.wav", + "text": "複合性的也是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/908.wav", + "text": "藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/909.wav", + "text": "我還是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/910.wav", + "text": "我可不可以發言一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/911.wav", + "text": "再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/912.wav", + "text": "你把它定義成藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/913.wav", + "text": "但是站在醫療專業的立場我必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/914.wav", + "text": "要嚴重抗議這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/915.wav", + "text": "是第一個未來真理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/916.wav", + "text": "再呈現那是以後的事情我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/917.wav", + "text": "先把人民照顧好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/918.wav", + "text": "大家再來討論第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/919.wav", + "text": "產業發展條例裡面已經很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/920.wav", + "text": "把再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/921.wav", + "text": "層面當然我們也是很尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/922.wav", + "text": "它也是有藥品它也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/923.wav", + "text": "有醫材它也是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/924.wav", + "text": "甚至還有製品但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/925.wav", + "text": "但給我們全臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/926.wav", + "text": "有一個更寬廣的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/927.wav", + "text": "不是很好嗎結果卻把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/928.wav", + "text": "所有的文字包括剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/929.wav", + "text": "醫事司所回答的他自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/930.wav", + "text": "違反那四大方向變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/931.wav", + "text": "連立法說明也是用藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/932.wav", + "text": "醫界已經提出一個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/933.wav", + "text": "完整的專法但是不被採用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/934.wav", + "text": "那就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/935.wav", + "text": "但是你不能把真理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/936.wav", + "text": "把醫療專業或者把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/937.wav", + "text": "管理條例裡面的用詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/938.wav", + "text": "你有沒有去問過經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/939.wav", + "text": "為什麼要把這個放進去你有沒有問過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/940.wav", + "text": "努力工作者他們對於醫材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/941.wav", + "text": "相關的藥物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/942.wav", + "text": "組織細胞這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/943.wav", + "text": "了這個部分讓人非常擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/944.wav", + "text": "請你定義一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/945.wav", + "text": "只要有疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/946.wav", + "text": "我們就想辦法在這個法裡面讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/947.wav", + "text": "醫療的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/948.wav", + "text": "基於幾百年來大家努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/949.wav", + "text": "累積的經驗技術大家想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/950.wav", + "text": "我還是要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/951.wav", + "text": "研究再生醫療相關細胞治療團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/952.wav", + "text": "讓生命科學人士沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/953.wav", + "text": "發揮他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/954.wav", + "text": "一生的經驗跟知識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/955.wav", + "text": "是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/956.wav", + "text": "的也經過很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/957.wav", + "text": "像林靜儀委員也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/958.wav", + "text": "原來的規定基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/959.wav", + "text": "也保障安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/960.wav", + "text": "可以有更多的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/961.wav", + "text": "包括已經危及生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/962.wav", + "text": "等等那我請問一下若是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/963.wav", + "text": "皮膚燒傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/964.wav", + "text": "則這個能用嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/965.wav", + "text": "然後它可以去治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/966.wav", + "text": "民眾的生命健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/967.wav", + "text": "我就覺得應該讓它去發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/968.wav", + "text": "如果不能用第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/969.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/970.wav", + "text": "林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/971.wav", + "text": "這是衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/972.wav", + "text": "提的再修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/973.wav", + "text": "現在是民進黨的委員都反對所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/974.wav", + "text": "邱委員剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/975.wav", + "text": "就是國內尚無適當之藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/976.wav", + "text": "藥品沒有辦法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/977.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法治癒治療的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/978.wav", + "text": "才會用這種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/979.wav", + "text": "這個本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/980.wav", + "text": "我們希望的處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/981.wav", + "text": "因為大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/982.wav", + "text": "從醫生的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/983.wav", + "text": "從醫療機構的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/984.wav", + "text": "從希望可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/985.wav", + "text": "有發展的業者角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/986.wav", + "text": "都希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/987.wav", + "text": "但是病人的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/988.wav", + "text": "也要考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/989.wav", + "text": "我一直在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/990.wav", + "text": "過去特管條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/991.wav", + "text": "用過九百零多個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/992.wav", + "text": "例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/993.wav", + "text": "到底那些例子後來的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/994.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/995.wav", + "text": "我們都沒有辦法拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/996.wav", + "text": "很明確的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/997.wav", + "text": "療法大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/998.wav", + "text": "病人在沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/999.wav", + "text": "通常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1000.wav", + "text": "就只能接受建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1001.wav", + "text": "但是要付出昂貴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1002.wav", + "text": "代價而且還不一定能夠知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1003.wav", + "text": "那個療效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1004.wav", + "text": "所以很難按照過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1005.wav", + "text": "的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1006.wav", + "text": "然後判斷要不要接受這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1007.wav", + "text": "療法但是這要付出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1008.wav", + "text": "會變得很弱勢你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1009.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1010.wav", + "text": "的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1011.wav", + "text": "要慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1012.wav", + "text": "要品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1013.wav", + "text": "先做特別的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1014.wav", + "text": "然後才能給予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1015.wav", + "text": "予這樣的治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1016.wav", + "text": "民進黨委員在反對衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1017.wav", + "text": "事前都沒有溝通嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1018.wav", + "text": "得比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1019.wav", + "text": "周全一點但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1020.wav", + "text": "民進黨委員卻在反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1021.wav", + "text": "說明一下你們這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1022.wav", + "text": "調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1023.wav", + "text": "是基於什麼樣的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1024.wav", + "text": "因為等一下要請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1025.wav", + "text": "衛福部回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1026.wav", + "text": "我講一下我的意見原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1027.wav", + "text": "技術如果有這種特殊狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1028.wav", + "text": "才可以而且要進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1029.wav", + "text": "的時候我卻看不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1030.wav", + "text": "醫療機構要執行再生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1031.wav", + "text": "新的文字反而沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1032.wav", + "text": "很明確的講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1033.wav", + "text": "你是誰要向什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1034.wav", + "text": "人申請什麼東西做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1035.wav", + "text": "事情這些都沒有講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1036.wav", + "text": "新的第9條是在寫某一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1037.wav", + "text": "細則或某一個實施辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1038.wav", + "text": "我覺得原來的文字版本滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1039.wav", + "text": "滿清楚提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1040.wav", + "text": "醫療機構要執行再生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1041.wav", + "text": "醫療技術如果是剛剛所說的在那種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1042.wav", + "text": "非常特殊的狀況之下也就是我們前面所說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1043.wav", + "text": "附款許可的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1044.wav", + "text": "那就可以走這樣的程序我對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1045.wav", + "text": "文字的認知是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1046.wav", + "text": "請部長來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1047.wav", + "text": "版本文字寫得比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1048.wav", + "text": "清楚比較明瞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1049.wav", + "text": "根本看不懂我會覺得它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1050.wav", + "text": "規定以後要申請再生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1051.wav", + "text": "治療都必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1052.wav", + "text": "危及生命或嚴重失能才能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1053.wav", + "text": "去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1054.wav", + "text": "原來的版本講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1055.wav", + "text": "幾位委員的意見是想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1056.wav", + "text": "行政院版第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1057.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1058.wav", + "text": "如果有人反對的話我們就保留吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1059.wav", + "text": "這一條就保留但還是讓部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1060.wav", + "text": "說明一下好不好\n現在請薛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1061.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1062.wav", + "text": "各位委員可能必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1063.wav", + "text": "把第9條和第8條一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1064.wav", + "text": "看目前第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1065.wav", + "text": "再生製劑和再生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1066.wav", + "text": "技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1067.wav", + "text": "程序效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1068.wav", + "text": "所有的再生醫療包括製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1069.wav", + "text": "和技術都必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1070.wav", + "text": "申請核准通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1071.wav", + "text": "之後才可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1072.wav", + "text": "針對這一些申請核准的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1073.wav", + "text": "製劑的部分有所謂的附款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1074.wav", + "text": "許可但在技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1075.wav", + "text": "的部分沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1076.wav", + "text": "其實第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1077.wav", + "text": "本來就是想要補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1078.wav", + "text": "那個洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1079.wav", + "text": "也就是原先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1080.wav", + "text": "在製劑的部分有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1081.wav", + "text": "附款許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1082.wav", + "text": "亦即針對特別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1083.wav", + "text": "附款許可的差異點在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1084.wav", + "text": "呢就是它沒有做完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1085.wav", + "text": "應該做的臨床試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1086.wav", + "text": "就來申請了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1087.wav", + "text": "我們基於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1088.wav", + "text": "可能會危及生命嚴重失能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1089.wav", + "text": "也就是有條件的通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1090.wav", + "text": "技術的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1091.wav", + "text": "就技術問題而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1092.wav", + "text": "本來有三款第1款就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1093.wav", + "text": "所謂的恩慈療法原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1094.wav", + "text": "文是尚無適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1095.wav", + "text": "之藥品或醫療器材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1096.wav", + "text": "我們現在把醫療器材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1097.wav", + "text": "拿掉是不是妥當大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1098.wav", + "text": "可以再進一步討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1099.wav", + "text": "需要用到細胞治療的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1100.wav", + "text": "目前大概沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1101.wav", + "text": "特別的醫療器材可以使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1102.wav", + "text": "但可能有醫療器材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1103.wav", + "text": "藥品來處理所以我們當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1104.wav", + "text": "把醫療器材放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1105.wav", + "text": "不過第1款講的本來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1106.wav", + "text": "至於第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1107.wav", + "text": "文規定有一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1108.wav", + "text": "就是依照第8條來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1109.wav", + "text": "本來就不需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1110.wav", + "text": "要經過製劑條例規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1111.wav", + "text": "去申請許可證或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1112.wav", + "text": "附款許可唯有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1113.wav", + "text": "在製劑的情況下才會跑到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1114.wav", + "text": "許可證或附款許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1115.wav", + "text": "所以在執行技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1116.wav", + "text": "審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1117.wav", + "text": "司審查但對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1118.wav", + "text": "再生醫療技術的恩慈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1119.wav", + "text": "又沒有特別規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1120.wav", + "text": "\n有關第2款和第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1121.wav", + "text": "執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1122.wav", + "text": "證實其安全性及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1123.wav", + "text": "初步療效的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1124.wav", + "text": "會不會太大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1125.wav", + "text": "生命危險或嚴重失能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1126.wav", + "text": "第1款第2款就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1127.wav", + "text": "沒有這些狀況的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1128.wav", + "text": "只是因為執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1129.wav", + "text": "人體試驗的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1130.wav", + "text": "證實其安全性及初步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1131.wav", + "text": "療效如果已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1132.wav", + "text": "證實是安全且有療效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1133.wav", + "text": "的本來就可以回到第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1134.wav", + "text": "申請不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1135.wav", + "text": "在這裡特別規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1136.wav", + "text": "其實第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1137.wav", + "text": "的意思是不需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1138.wav", + "text": "需要把人體試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1139.wav", + "text": "全程做完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1140.wav", + "text": "說會造成各界疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1141.wav", + "text": "認為大家都會採用第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1142.wav", + "text": "就會造成混亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1143.wav", + "text": "要人體試驗結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1144.wav", + "text": "如果這是結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1145.wav", + "text": "就是回到第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1146.wav", + "text": "如果沒有這種結論性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1147.wav", + "text": "必須依照第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1148.wav", + "text": "提供不含基因改造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1149.wav", + "text": "或轉殖之人類細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1150.wav", + "text": "及其衍生物之細胞治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1151.wav", + "text": "不必完成全部的人體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1152.wav", + "text": "依照第9條來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1153.wav", + "text": "可能放得太寬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1154.wav", + "text": "不需要開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1155.wav", + "text": "有委員認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1156.wav", + "text": "辦法已經通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1157.wav", + "text": "可以回到第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1158.wav", + "text": "可能會討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1159.wav", + "text": "已經公告的我們可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1160.wav", + "text": "也就是那些還是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1161.wav", + "text": "做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1162.wav", + "text": "\n為什麼這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1163.wav", + "text": "沒有做完全程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1164.wav", + "text": "人體試驗但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1165.wav", + "text": "嚴重失能的疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1166.wav", + "text": "技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1167.wav", + "text": "所以文字上寫國內尚無" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1168.wav", + "text": "適當之藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1169.wav", + "text": "大家討論的結果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1170.wav", + "text": "要把醫療器材加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1171.wav", + "text": "不是不能接受接下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1172.wav", + "text": "接下來是而執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1173.wav", + "text": "再生技術所以第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1174.wav", + "text": "管的是再生技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1175.wav", + "text": "完成全程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1176.wav", + "text": "在必要的時候或有這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1177.wav", + "text": "狀況的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1178.wav", + "text": "可以來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1179.wav", + "text": "而申請的對象是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1180.wav", + "text": "個別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1181.wav", + "text": "病人是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1182.wav", + "text": "嚴重失能的疾病\n所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1183.wav", + "text": "把它寫進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1184.wav", + "text": "我們覺得也是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1185.wav", + "text": "或者在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1186.wav", + "text": "中去強調就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1187.wav", + "text": "還沒有完成全程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1188.wav", + "text": "人體試驗的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1189.wav", + "text": "要特別准許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1190.wav", + "text": "適用於個別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1191.wav", + "text": "病人的話我們仍然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1192.wav", + "text": "需要有一些資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1193.wav", + "text": "才能夠審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1194.wav", + "text": "人體試驗都沒有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1195.wav", + "text": "那我們是不會同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1196.wav", + "text": "的所以我們會有人體試驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1197.wav", + "text": "倫理委員會核准的證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1198.wav", + "text": "也就是說的確是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1199.wav", + "text": "人體試驗的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1200.wav", + "text": "這個病人的治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1201.wav", + "text": "計畫書是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1202.wav", + "text": "病人是否已經知情同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1203.wav", + "text": "製備細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1204.wav", + "text": "合法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1205.wav", + "text": "是符合條件的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1206.wav", + "text": "\n當然如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1207.wav", + "text": "委員覺得這樣還不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1208.wav", + "text": "需要再增加哪些條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1209.wav", + "text": "比方說依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1210.wav", + "text": "依照現在的特管辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1211.wav", + "text": "參與或執行完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1212.wav", + "text": "之人體試驗成果報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1213.wav", + "text": "或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1214.wav", + "text": "用其他國內外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1215.wav", + "text": "相關的文獻報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1216.wav", + "text": "如果這個也要同時檢附的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1217.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1218.wav", + "text": "也可以接受啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1219.wav", + "text": "但如果大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1220.wav", + "text": "這個東西還沒有出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1221.wav", + "text": "就提不出來結果就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1222.wav", + "text": "少掉這種機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1223.wav", + "text": "我想這也是一個考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1224.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1225.wav", + "text": "因為這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1226.wav", + "text": "確實有比較大幅度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1227.wav", + "text": "先保留\n因為大家意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1228.wav", + "text": "還沒有共識這一條就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1229.wav", + "text": "最後還是請行政部門再來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1230.wav", + "text": "後就可以用餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1231.wav", + "text": "當導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1232.wav", + "text": "十一條有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1233.wav", + "text": "客製化是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1234.wav", + "text": "立一個公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1235.wav", + "text": "是在外面成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1236.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1237.wav", + "text": "我有提出修正動議在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1238.wav", + "text": "之前就有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1239.wav", + "text": "了小規模在醫院裡面使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1240.wav", + "text": "這個是細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1241.wav", + "text": "治療的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1242.wav", + "text": "劑是不太一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1243.wav", + "text": "所以免依藥事法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1244.wav", + "text": "之規定取得藥品製造業許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1245.wav", + "text": "但是在我的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1246.wav", + "text": "其實主要就是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1247.wav", + "text": "像剛剛衛福部部長所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1248.wav", + "text": "甚至藥品這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1249.wav", + "text": "甚至提供給醫療機構之外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1250.wav", + "text": "其他醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1251.wav", + "text": "使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1252.wav", + "text": "所以要想像到有這種可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1253.wav", + "text": "所以我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1254.wav", + "text": "前項執行細胞操作之機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1255.wav", + "text": "之規定取得藥品製造業許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1256.wav", + "text": "照其執行細胞操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1257.wav", + "text": "西藥藥品優良製造規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1258.wav", + "text": "西藥藥品優良運銷規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1259.wav", + "text": "及其他中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1260.wav", + "text": "主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1261.wav", + "text": "就是說它畢竟還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1262.wav", + "text": "要有製作的場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1263.wav", + "text": "然後要保存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1264.wav", + "text": "這些如果沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1265.wav", + "text": "規範我們也很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1266.wav", + "text": "它的有效性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1267.wav", + "text": "還有安全性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1268.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會增加這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1269.wav", + "text": "像部長所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1270.wav", + "text": "量越來越大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1271.wav", + "text": "那就應該要另做規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1272.wav", + "text": "所以在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1273.wav", + "text": "第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1274.wav", + "text": "操作案量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1275.wav", + "text": "病人數或其他事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1276.wav", + "text": "達一定規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1277.wav", + "text": "就要怎麼樣就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1278.wav", + "text": "開始要有新的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1279.wav", + "text": "主要是為了避免醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1280.wav", + "text": "甚至要提供給其他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1281.wav", + "text": "用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1282.wav", + "text": "在那時候就要做另外的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1283.wav", + "text": "但是你們這一項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1284.wav", + "text": "也是定義不清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1285.wav", + "text": "對這部分可能要再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1286.wav", + "text": "是不是要另定規範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1287.wav", + "text": "如果大家達不到共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1288.wav", + "text": "那也只好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1289.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1290.wav", + "text": "關於林委員剛剛的提問其實前面已經有稍微說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1291.wav", + "text": "可是您剛才不在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1292.wav", + "text": "有需要再請他們說明嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1293.wav", + "text": "還是要先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1294.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1295.wav", + "text": "這一條是不是就先保留不再討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1296.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1297.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1298.wav", + "text": "第十六條請大家翻到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1299.wav", + "text": "針對第10條有一個修正動議好像沒有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1300.wav", + "text": "0條已經沒有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1301.wav", + "text": "我們我們現在進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1302.wav", + "text": "第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1303.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1304.wav", + "text": "如果沒有太多爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1305.wav", + "text": "其實我們在跟各委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1306.wav", + "text": "沒有提出特別的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1307.wav", + "text": "依照行政院的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1308.wav", + "text": "其實在委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1309.wav", + "text": "時意見分歧的不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1310.wav", + "text": "第十六條是否就照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1311.wav", + "text": "謝謝\n我們進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1312.wav", + "text": "第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1313.wav", + "text": "\n請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1314.wav", + "text": "劉司長說明關於第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1315.wav", + "text": "胚胎幹細胞這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1316.wav", + "text": "如果做研究的話應該要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1317.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣的管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1318.wav", + "text": "希望大家是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1319.wav", + "text": "參採我們新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1320.wav", + "text": "提出來的再修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1321.wav", + "text": "也就是說原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1322.wav", + "text": "涉及到再生醫療研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1323.wav", + "text": "涉及胚胎或胚胎幹細胞的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1324.wav", + "text": "的時候是以禁止為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1325.wav", + "text": "所以就是把我們現行的人體胚胎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1326.wav", + "text": "及胚胎幹細胞研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1327.wav", + "text": "倫理政策指引的行政規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1328.wav", + "text": "提升到法律的位階" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1329.wav", + "text": "整個體制完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1330.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1331.wav", + "text": "請林靜儀委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1332.wav", + "text": "再生醫療研究對於胚胎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1333.wav", + "text": "或胚胎幹細胞我們當時希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1334.wav", + "text": "能夠保障的就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1335.wav", + "text": "倫理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1336.wav", + "text": "製造雜交體等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1337.wav", + "text": "大概都有提到人類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1338.wav", + "text": "生殖細胞而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1339.wav", + "text": "而這邊寫的製造雜交體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1340.wav", + "text": "其實是動物的你也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1341.wav", + "text": "把它管進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1342.wav", + "text": "希望做的事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1343.wav", + "text": "再生醫療研究不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1344.wav", + "text": "使用到人體胚胎的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1345.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1346.wav", + "text": "我們這邊主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1347.wav", + "text": "是跟人體相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1348.wav", + "text": "的是人跟獸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1349.wav", + "text": "所以不需要特別在前面提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1350.wav", + "text": "再生醫療研究涉及人體胚胎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1351.wav", + "text": "或人體胚胎幹細胞不用把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1352.wav", + "text": "人體標在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1353.wav", + "text": "有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1354.wav", + "text": "文字修正嗎還是就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1355.wav", + "text": "的再修正動議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1356.wav", + "text": "靜儀委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1357.wav", + "text": "照行政院的再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1358.wav", + "text": "動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1359.wav", + "text": "原來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1360.wav", + "text": "經主管機關核准外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1361.wav", + "text": "原本是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1362.wav", + "text": "原則禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1363.wav", + "text": "原本的寫法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1364.wav", + "text": "原則禁止例外情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1365.wav", + "text": "主管機關核准原本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1366.wav", + "text": "概念是這樣我講的是原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1367.wav", + "text": "的可是在跟各個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1368.wav", + "text": "溝通甚至有很多法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1369.wav", + "text": "核准這件事情其實會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1370.wav", + "text": "因為我們本來就有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1371.wav", + "text": "所謂的人體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1372.wav", + "text": "胚胎及胚胎幹細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1373.wav", + "text": "倫理研究政策指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1374.wav", + "text": "這是一個指引也就是一個行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1375.wav", + "text": "指導這個地方就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1376.wav", + "text": "幹細胞的研究然後我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1377.wav", + "text": "把它入法變成法治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1378.wav", + "text": "治精神比較完備的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1379.wav", + "text": "一個體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1380.wav", + "text": "也就是在第十九條新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1381.wav", + "text": "修正文字裡頭我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1382.wav", + "text": "直接在法律在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1383.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法裡面宣示人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1384.wav", + "text": "體胚胎不可以作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1385.wav", + "text": "再生醫療研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1386.wav", + "text": "絕對都不可以這條路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1387.wav", + "text": "這個門完全都沒有了的意思對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1388.wav", + "text": "不能做這七款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1389.wav", + "text": "所以研究是可以做但是你不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1390.wav", + "text": "以下面這七款方式為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1391.wav", + "text": "醫院的醫療研究團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1392.wav", + "text": "的專家做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1393.wav", + "text": "我絕對重視安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1394.wav", + "text": "也希望管嚴一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1395.wav", + "text": "但問題是醫學的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1396.wav", + "text": "一定要讓它有空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1397.wav", + "text": "而且在醫院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1398.wav", + "text": "都不敢做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1399.wav", + "text": "啊大家都很小心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1400.wav", + "text": "謹守倫理跟專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1401.wav", + "text": "不要以為大家都想做這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1402.wav", + "text": "臺大說你們如果繼續不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1403.wav", + "text": "研究可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1404.wav", + "text": "但不得以下列方式為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1405.wav", + "text": "我覺得它是寫法不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1406.wav", + "text": "我們從這兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1407.wav", + "text": "來比較第一行完全一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1408.wav", + "text": "胚胎幹細胞的逗點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1409.wav", + "text": "前面都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1410.wav", + "text": "然後接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1411.wav", + "text": "應該說原來的版本是除申請中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1412.wav", + "text": "主管機關核准者外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1413.wav", + "text": "不得以下列方式為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1414.wav", + "text": "所以之前如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1415.wav", + "text": "我的印象沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1416.wav", + "text": "的話上一輪的討論就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1417.wav", + "text": "你們這裡是不是又幫人家開了一個門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1418.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1419.wav", + "text": "你雖然說我們不能夠用下面這七款方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1420.wav", + "text": "來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1421.wav", + "text": "好像很為倫理把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1422.wav", + "text": "但是這裡用除字你開了一扇門給人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1423.wav", + "text": "看起來衛福部是接受上一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1424.wav", + "text": "大家的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1425.wav", + "text": "所以把那個除的部分先拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1426.wav", + "text": "更嚴謹地把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1427.wav", + "text": "反正這7種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1428.wav", + "text": "現在都不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1429.wav", + "text": "到時候立法委員再來修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1430.wav", + "text": "法是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1431.wav", + "text": "就是授權立法委員再修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1432.wav", + "text": "我沒有什麼特別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1433.wav", + "text": "我只是純就文字來表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1434.wav", + "text": "第一個一定要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1435.wav", + "text": "醫療團隊在研究這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1436.wav", + "text": "各界真的不用擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1437.wav", + "text": "倫理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1438.wav", + "text": "它這裡看起來對醫生是信賴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1439.wav", + "text": "可能不信任中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1440.wav", + "text": "除申請中央主管機關核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1441.wav", + "text": "機關的核准權拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1442.wav", + "text": "它是不信任衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1443.wav", + "text": "所以衛福部現在是自廢武功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1444.wav", + "text": "從法律專家來看是完全不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1445.wav", + "text": "這樣對於醫療的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1446.wav", + "text": "研究發展會不會有影響我只是擔心這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1447.wav", + "text": "林靜儀委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1448.wav", + "text": "就我的理解因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1449.wav", + "text": "生產科會蒐集很多臍帶幹細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1450.wav", + "text": "和胚胎幹細胞這是從臍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1451.wav", + "text": "臍帶那邊來的胚胎等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1452.wav", + "text": "像這種臍帶及胚胎幹細胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1453.wav", + "text": "是可以做研究的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1454.wav", + "text": "但是如果我要把它拿來做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1455.wav", + "text": "人獸合成雜交體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1456.wav", + "text": "或者是用人工生殖方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1457.wav", + "text": "這些不可以拿來做研究對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1458.wav", + "text": "就是把目前在研究上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1459.wav", + "text": "本來不可以做的這些合成胚胎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1460.wav", + "text": "明文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1461.wav", + "text": "從辦法拉到再生醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1462.wav", + "text": "再讓這個過程加一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1463.wav", + "text": "─從規定變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1464.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法裡面的把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1465.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個邏輯OK所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1466.wav", + "text": "目前合法的研究還是可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1467.wav", + "text": "幹細胞研究照常可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1468.wav", + "text": "OK瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1469.wav", + "text": "剛剛林委員的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1470.wav", + "text": "衛福部這一次新修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1471.wav", + "text": "所以大家都可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1472.wav", + "text": "第十九條就照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1473.wav", + "text": "的再修正動議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1474.wav", + "text": "翻到第58頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1475.wav", + "text": "因為蘇巧慧委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1476.wav", + "text": "是逕付二讀的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1477.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1478.wav", + "text": "他在第58頁的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1479.wav", + "text": "有列第六章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1480.wav", + "text": "監督及預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1481.wav", + "text": "巧慧委員這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1482.wav", + "text": "我們是不是不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1483.wav", + "text": "因為在章名的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1484.wav", + "text": "已經通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1485.wav", + "text": "相關的章名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1486.wav", + "text": "了我們就不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1487.wav", + "text": "因為是院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1488.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1489.wav", + "text": "請大家看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1490.wav", + "text": "也有一些修正的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1491.wav", + "text": "之前施行過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1492.wav", + "text": "醫療機構必須在每年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1493.wav", + "text": "終了後六個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1494.wav", + "text": "或者我們通知的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1495.wav", + "text": "期限內提出結果報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1496.wav", + "text": "針對第8條第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1497.wav", + "text": "是我們之前的條文裡面很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1498.wav", + "text": "委員在上一次委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1499.wav", + "text": "是說我們是不是需要定期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1500.wav", + "text": "公開相關的一些統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1501.wav", + "text": "新增添的文字是中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1502.wav", + "text": "應定期公開前項報告統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1503.wav", + "text": "之醫療品質資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1504.wav", + "text": "因為我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1505.wav", + "text": "細胞治療的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1506.wav", + "text": "第四期的癌症病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1507.wav", + "text": "接受細胞治療因為本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1508.wav", + "text": "癒後就不好所以在癒後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1509.wav", + "text": "再加上個案沒有辦法像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1510.wav", + "text": "傳統醫學研究有所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1511.wav", + "text": "對照組的部分所以很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1512.wav", + "text": "死亡率是跟這個醫療直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1513.wav", + "text": "有關還是無關因為它都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1514.wav", + "text": "屬於我們細胞治療的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1515.wav", + "text": "其實就會針對醫療品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1516.wav", + "text": "的部分我們覺得這樣子比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1517.wav", + "text": "的權利以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1518.wav", + "text": "再修正的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1519.wav", + "text": "24條其實修正得更完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1520.wav", + "text": "資訊公開是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1521.wav", + "text": "我們就照行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1522.wav", + "text": "你要再補充嗎對我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1523.wav", + "text": "是中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1524.wav", + "text": "應定期公開第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1525.wav", + "text": "報告統計之醫療品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1526.wav", + "text": "資訊好要再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1527.wav", + "text": "對我們等一下會再把這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1528.wav", + "text": "再修正改成中央主管機關應定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1529.wav", + "text": "期公開第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1530.wav", + "text": "報告統計之醫療品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1531.wav", + "text": "資訊是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1532.wav", + "text": "的話請他們印出文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1533.wav", + "text": "給我們我們就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1534.wav", + "text": "剛剛再修正的再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1535.wav", + "text": "翻到67" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1536.wav", + "text": "27條有嗎通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1537.wav", + "text": "我們今天要開到2點對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1538.wav", + "text": "開會通知是寫開到2點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1539.wav", + "text": "兩個法案都要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1540.wav", + "text": "如果處理不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1541.wav", + "text": "那要再開一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1542.wav", + "text": "但是我希望今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1543.wav", + "text": "保留條文如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1544.wav", + "text": "需要的話我們可以進到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1545.wav", + "text": "院長那邊協商當然一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1546.wav", + "text": "會有那個程序我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1547.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1548.wav", + "text": "下一次處理再生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1549.wav", + "text": "醫療製劑條例因為再生醫療製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1550.wav", + "text": "所以處理起來應該會更快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1551.wav", + "text": "前面的再生醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1552.wav", + "text": "處理完大概再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1553.wav", + "text": "是我們不會再回頭處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1554.wav", + "text": "保留的保留的就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1555.wav", + "text": "不再處理我們待會兒再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1556.wav", + "text": "保留的條文怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1557.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法的部分再來我建議再開一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1558.wav", + "text": "再開一次的話可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1559.wav", + "text": "反正這個會期我們都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1560.wav", + "text": "希望可以三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1561.wav", + "text": "好我們本會期三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1562.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1563.wav", + "text": "來得更仔細更專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1564.wav", + "text": "大家更專注所以我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1565.wav", + "text": "委召集謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1566.wav", + "text": "保留條文第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1567.wav", + "text": "意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1568.wav", + "text": "保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1569.wav", + "text": "第28條請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1570.wav", + "text": "說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1571.wav", + "text": "67頁是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1572.wav", + "text": "罰則的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1573.wav", + "text": "28條以後都是罰則請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1574.wav", + "text": "衛福部跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1575.wav", + "text": "委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1576.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1577.wav", + "text": "我提一下我的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1578.wav", + "text": "大家可以翻到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1579.wav", + "text": "最右手邊的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1580.wav", + "text": "我的修正動議提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1581.wav", + "text": "對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1582.wav", + "text": "不法的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1583.wav", + "text": "比如說違反第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1584.wav", + "text": "非醫療機構執行再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1585.wav", + "text": "還有違反第21條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1586.wav", + "text": "的規定非醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1587.wav", + "text": "機構為再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1588.wav", + "text": "廣告這個部分我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1589.wav", + "text": "是不是可以提高非法或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1590.wav", + "text": "醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1591.wav", + "text": "罰鍰我的寫法是二百萬到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1592.wav", + "text": "維持二十萬到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1593.wav", + "text": "二百萬的罰款等於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1594.wav", + "text": "就罰了而且罰得重是從二百萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1595.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1596.wav", + "text": "源委員我先請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1597.wav", + "text": "衛福部這兩個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1598.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法罰得比較重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1599.wav", + "text": "有沒有這樣的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1600.wav", + "text": "因為有人這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1601.wav", + "text": "這兩個到底罰得怎麼樣可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1602.wav", + "text": "可以比較一下再生醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1603.wav", + "text": "較重嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1604.wav", + "text": "等一下請一起說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1605.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1606.wav", + "text": "我還是覺得我們一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1607.wav", + "text": "管得很嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1608.wav", + "text": "額度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1609.wav", + "text": "達幾千萬好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1610.wav", + "text": "你是要罰院所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1611.wav", + "text": "還是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1612.wav", + "text": "非法是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1613.wav", + "text": "會罰到二百萬到二千萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1614.wav", + "text": "第1款是違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1615.wav", + "text": "第7條的規定就是非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1616.wav", + "text": "醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1617.wav", + "text": "執行再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1618.wav", + "text": "非醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1619.wav", + "text": "為再生醫療廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1620.wav", + "text": "就這兩款的部分提高罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1621.wav", + "text": "這種狀況都要找到行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1622.wav", + "text": "管理範圍下就有其限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1623.wav", + "text": "但是傳統的醫療法罰得比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1624.wav", + "text": "層層關係下我們是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1625.wav", + "text": "參照吳玉琴委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1626.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1627.wav", + "text": "的提案在罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1628.wav", + "text": "部分有好幾個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1629.wav", + "text": "為應也請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1630.wav", + "text": "謝謝剛剛司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1631.wav", + "text": "司長的補充我支持吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1632.wav", + "text": "這件事情我非常肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1633.wav", + "text": "因為過去常常出現一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1634.wav", + "text": "就是密醫罪罰得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1635.wav", + "text": "的人去執行醫療業務發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1636.wav", + "text": "安全是第一優先其次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1637.wav", + "text": "如果是合法的執行這個程序我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1638.wav", + "text": "當然贊成非法執行我們當然不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1639.wav", + "text": "它不是醫療機構竟然去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1640.wav", + "text": "再生醫療我真的覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1641.wav", + "text": "所以我支持吳玉琴委員這個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1642.wav", + "text": "得公布跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1643.wav", + "text": "應公布這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1644.wav", + "text": "應跟得的部分就是公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1645.wav", + "text": "是時間差的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1646.wav", + "text": "用一個得字給行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1647.wav", + "text": "一個行政裁量的空間因此建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1648.wav", + "text": "的版本以上補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1649.wav", + "text": "好謝謝但是如果可以還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1650.wav", + "text": "儘量能夠公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1651.wav", + "text": "的部分就請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1652.wav", + "text": "參考\n第28條是不是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1653.wav", + "text": "三人所提出的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1654.wav", + "text": "修正動議通過\n處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1655.wav", + "text": "的結��有沒有一些要調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1656.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1657.wav", + "text": "溝通的時候好像也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1658.wav", + "text": "唯一有的就是剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1659.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1660.wav", + "text": "提應跟得的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1661.wav", + "text": "是違反第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1662.wav", + "text": "爭議不大但是主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1663.wav", + "text": "是前面的條文還在保留中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1664.wav", + "text": "二十九條暫時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1665.wav", + "text": "有沒有涉及前面的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1666.wav", + "text": "前面的條文都過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1667.wav", + "text": "對應該第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1668.wav", + "text": "比較沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1669.wav", + "text": "第3條前面條文都過了所以是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1670.wav", + "text": "照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1671.wav", + "text": "的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1672.wav", + "text": "謝謝那就照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1673.wav", + "text": "版本通過\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1674.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處理第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1675.wav", + "text": "也是罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1676.wav", + "text": "因為第十九條我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1677.wav", + "text": "做了一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1678.wav", + "text": "禁止以那七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1679.wav", + "text": "款的部分我們只是把文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1680.wav", + "text": "第十九條規定進行涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1681.wav", + "text": "胚胎或胚胎幹細胞之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1682.wav", + "text": "再生研究的部分罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1683.wav", + "text": "罰則是處五萬至五十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1684.wav", + "text": "這條大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1685.wav", + "text": "主要是第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1686.wav", + "text": "的部分還在保留中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1687.wav", + "text": "不然其他的是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1688.wav", + "text": "暫時保留因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1689.wav", + "text": "第十一條還沒確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1690.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1691.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1692.wav", + "text": "對第32條主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1693.wav", + "text": "是卡在第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1694.wav", + "text": "都還是合併保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1695.wav", + "text": "後來因為第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1696.wav", + "text": "條次有一些些改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1697.wav", + "text": "版本裡面違反第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1698.wav", + "text": "第二項的部分這個地方我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1699.wav", + "text": "的條次就往上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1700.wav", + "text": "好其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1701.wav", + "text": "第十一條是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1702.wav", + "text": "所以這條也必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1703.wav", + "text": "連帶保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1704.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1705.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1706.wav", + "text": "第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1707.wav", + "text": "劉司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1708.wav", + "text": "對於廣告的話我們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1709.wav", + "text": "前面都有提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1710.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳玉琴委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1711.wav", + "text": "的部分已經拉高到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1712.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1713.wav", + "text": "採納是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1714.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1715.wav", + "text": "有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1716.wav", + "text": "這部分再請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1717.wav", + "text": "回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1718.wav", + "text": "條文針對廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1719.wav", + "text": "的部分都有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1720.wav", + "text": "又提高了處二百萬至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1721.wav", + "text": "二千萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1722.wav", + "text": "是不是我們暫時先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1723.wav", + "text": "這樣處理裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1724.wav", + "text": "剛剛已經談了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1725.wav", + "text": "所以是不是這一條就不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1726.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1727.wav", + "text": "我再確認一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1728.wav", + "text": "好儘快好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1729.wav", + "text": "建議是不予採納謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1730.wav", + "text": "\n再來處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1731.wav", + "text": "處理行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1732.wav", + "text": "應該不是太大的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1733.wav", + "text": "是不是照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1734.wav", + "text": "版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1735.wav", + "text": "\n再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1736.wav", + "text": "法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1737.wav", + "text": "的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1738.wav", + "text": "保留條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1739.wav", + "text": "第3條第9條第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1740.wav", + "text": "後面的罰則是配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1741.wav", + "text": "第十一條沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1742.wav", + "text": "二十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1743.wav", + "text": "那個是第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1744.wav", + "text": "的部分對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1745.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛保留第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1746.wav", + "text": "第十一條還沒有通過所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1747.wav", + "text": "正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1748.wav", + "text": "\n因為我們剛剛的處理原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1749.wav", + "text": "是先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1750.wav", + "text": "的先處理對於已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1751.wav", + "text": "包括剛剛衛福部的第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1752.wav", + "text": "和委員提案的第8條第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1753.wav", + "text": "處理\n好現在就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1754.wav", + "text": "第8條第10條和第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1755.wav", + "text": "這是已經通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1756.wav", + "text": "衛福部提出文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1757.wav", + "text": "也有委員提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1758.wav", + "text": "所以我們來處理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1759.wav", + "text": "是已經通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1760.wav", + "text": "上次在委員會討論通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1761.wav", + "text": "再生技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1762.wav", + "text": "要向中央主管機關申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1763.wav", + "text": "核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1764.wav", + "text": "第2項規定中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1765.wav", + "text": "可以委辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1766.wav", + "text": "委辦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1767.wav", + "text": "有委辦機構委辦法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1768.wav", + "text": "或團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1769.wav", + "text": "原來還沒有修正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1770.wav", + "text": "院版第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1771.wav", + "text": "要去申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1772.wav", + "text": "所以這兩個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1773.wav", + "text": "有一點連帶的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1774.wav", + "text": "團體去核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1775.wav", + "text": "有沒有安全有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1776.wav", + "text": "是提供不含基因改造或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1777.wav", + "text": "轉殖人類細胞等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1778.wav", + "text": "這種核准如果未來是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1779.wav", + "text": "核准的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1780.wav", + "text": "相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1781.wav", + "text": "就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1782.wav", + "text": "去訂出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1783.wav", + "text": "所以本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1784.wav", + "text": "第2項的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1785.wav", + "text": "原來是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1786.wav", + "text": "\n我剛剛針對第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1787.wav", + "text": "的發言就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1788.wav", + "text": "這些委辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1789.wav", + "text": "團體的核可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1790.wav", + "text": "是不是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1791.wav", + "text": "去做核可還是中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1792.wav", + "text": "主管機關核准就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1793.wav", + "text": "好了如果是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1794.wav", + "text": "以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1795.wav", + "text": "核准的項目可能是比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1796.wav", + "text": "簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1797.wav", + "text": "看看這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1798.wav", + "text": "是不是按照我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1799.wav", + "text": "修正動議的提醒就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1800.wav", + "text": "有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1801.wav", + "text": "規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1802.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1803.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1804.wav", + "text": "實在是不太想發脾氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1805.wav", + "text": "但我實在是聽不懂陳椒華委員在說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1806.wav", + "text": "什麼叫委辦單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1807.wav", + "text": "可以核可申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1808.wav", + "text": "的案件委辦單位怎麼能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1809.wav", + "text": "核可申請的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1810.wav", + "text": "能不能成為委辦單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1811.wav", + "text": "來審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1812.wav", + "text": "我實在是聽不懂您的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1813.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1814.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1815.wav", + "text": "不用不用不用你越說明越亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1816.wav", + "text": "更加證明您對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1817.wav", + "text": "再生醫療其實是不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1818.wav", + "text": "你才沒有在看法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1819.wav", + "text": "你根本不知道什麼是再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1820.wav", + "text": "醫事司來做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1821.wav", + "text": "去通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1822.wav", + "text": "我請邱委員尊重議事的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1823.wav", + "text": "進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1824.wav", + "text": "我提出修正動議就是衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1825.wav", + "text": "要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1826.wav", + "text": "你要不要生氣是你的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1827.wav", + "text": "那你不要指責我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1828.wav", + "text": "啊我現在也是講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1829.wav", + "text": "那你如果聽不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1830.wav", + "text": "我可以再說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1831.wav", + "text": "你如果完全不懂什麼是再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1832.wav", + "text": "我也可以改天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1833.wav", + "text": "你不用教我我比你還懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1834.wav", + "text": "你比我還懂你拿出證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1835.wav", + "text": "先熄火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1836.wav", + "text": "我努力了6年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1837.wav", + "text": "我努力了6年你努力多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1838.wav", + "text": "你不要在這裡大聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1839.wav", + "text": "你懂你拿出證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1840.wav", + "text": "請醫事司來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1841.wav", + "text": "事情的話是依據行政程序法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1842.wav", + "text": "我先把條文唸一次給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1843.wav", + "text": "行政機關得依法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1844.wav", + "text": "將其權限之一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1845.wav", + "text": "委託民間團體或個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1846.wav", + "text": "辦理前項情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1847.wav", + "text": "應將委託事項及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1848.wav", + "text": "法規依據公告之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1849.wav", + "text": "並刊登政府公報或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1850.wav", + "text": "除另有約定外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1851.wav", + "text": "由行政機關支付之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1852.wav", + "text": "其實重點只是來做所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1853.wav", + "text": "因為這邊專業審查的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1854.wav", + "text": "大概不是我們一般行政人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1855.wav", + "text": "可以做處理的公權力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1856.wav", + "text": "行使還是會回到醫事司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1857.wav", + "text": "這個地方來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1858.wav", + "text": "所以委員擔心的部分我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1859.wav", + "text": "覺得行政程序法裡面就已經包含了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1860.wav", + "text": "所以建議是依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1861.wav", + "text": "陳委員還要再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1862.wav", + "text": "我聽不懂可以問吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1863.wav", + "text": "是是我是說因為它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1864.wav", + "text": "行政程序法已經有一定的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1865.wav", + "text": "我先確認原來的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1866.wav", + "text": "這些機構辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1867.wav", + "text": "是核准的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1868.wav", + "text": "還是在中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1869.wav", + "text": "醫事司這邊是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1870.wav", + "text": "好這樣OK我瞭解了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1871.wav", + "text": "就照行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1872.wav", + "text": "保持原來的照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1873.wav", + "text": "版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1874.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處理第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1875.wav", + "text": "請林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1876.wav", + "text": "上次我們本來沒有什麼特別問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1877.wav", + "text": "不過因為上次我有提到原來的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1878.wav", + "text": "裡面執行再生醫療的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1879.wav", + "text": "醫師要是相關領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1880.wav", + "text": "之專科醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1881.wav", + "text": "這個部分我會建議用部定專科醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1882.wav", + "text": "有很多身分的專科醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1883.wav", + "text": "可是這樣子可能沒有辦法符合我們所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1884.wav", + "text": "真正在那個相關領域的專科" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1885.wav", + "text": "所以我在修正動議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1886.wav", + "text": "是特別想要把它設定為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1887.wav", + "text": "部定專科醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1888.wav", + "text": "這個部分上次好像有拿出來和衛福部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1889.wav", + "text": "我們建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1890.wav", + "text": "維持行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1891.wav", + "text": "我們在立法說明的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1892.wav", + "text": "有做一些調整因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1893.wav", + "text": "這個名詞在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1894.wav", + "text": "法律裡面我們找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1895.wav", + "text": "我知道你們正在推動啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1896.wav", + "text": "對所以我們這邊調整的文字建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1897.wav", + "text": "這樣就是如同我們書面資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1898.wav", + "text": "第25頁右下角的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1899.wav", + "text": "紅字為確保再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1900.wav", + "text": "執行之安全參酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1901.wav", + "text": "醫師法第7條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1902.wav", + "text": "第3項及專科醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1903.wav", + "text": "分科及甄審辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1904.wav", + "text": "等對於專科醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1905.wav", + "text": "資格及訓練等要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1906.wav", + "text": "原來文字不動然後你們在說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1907.wav", + "text": "那邊去強調是怎麼樣子的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1908.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1909.wav", + "text": "我們還是照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1910.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1911.wav", + "text": "\n我們來處理衛福部在第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1912.wav", + "text": "翻到第65頁的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1913.wav", + "text": "原來我們是照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1914.wav", + "text": "但因為前面條文有一些變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1915.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1916.wav", + "text": "它其實是連動因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1917.wav", + "text": "我們修正了第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1918.wav", + "text": "在執行第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1919.wav", + "text": "再生技術的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1920.wav", + "text": "發生的不良反應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1921.wav", + "text": "要有一些救濟的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1922.wav", + "text": "對於救濟措施的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1923.wav", + "text": "就改成針對第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1924.wav", + "text": "這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1925.wav", + "text": "變成要先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1926.wav", + "text": "是不是因為它和第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1927.wav", + "text": "有關第9條保留這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1928.wav", + "text": "順著第9條調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1929.wav", + "text": "之後才做的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1930.wav", + "text": "主席我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1931.wav", + "text": "進行到這裡我們保留的條文其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1932.wav", + "text": "不多就是第3條第9條第十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1933.wav", + "text": "文因為第9條剛剛的變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1934.wav", + "text": "有點大對不對然後第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1935.wav", + "text": "大家也還要思考一下所以在這幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1936.wav", + "text": "下看起來會議應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1937.wav", + "text": "還會再有下一次是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1938.wav", + "text": "今天再生醫療法的部分就先到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1939.wav", + "text": "這裡我們趕快來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1940.wav", + "text": "製劑部分看能不能run過一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1941.wav", + "text": "時間都有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1942.wav", + "text": "是不是可以先以這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1943.wav", + "text": "的方式進行是謝謝我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1944.wav", + "text": "第27條我們還是先保留因為它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1945.wav", + "text": "跟第9條有連動性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1946.wav", + "text": "第3條可不可以先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1947.wav", + "text": "沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1948.wav", + "text": "因為還有一個再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1949.wav", + "text": "最後時代力量的第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1950.wav", + "text": "時代力量是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1951.wav", + "text": "我說明一下可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1952.wav", + "text": "裁罰的原則就是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1953.wav", + "text": "時候罰罰的次數等等請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1954.wav", + "text": "好再跟你說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1955.wav", + "text": "的第33條我們就不予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1956.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法草案我們就先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1957.wav", + "text": "條第9條第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1958.wav", + "text": "然後連帶的因為第十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1959.wav", + "text": "十一條保留所以第二十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1960.wav", + "text": "條也先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1961.wav", + "text": "一併保留請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1962.wav", + "text": "這些保留條文可能大家還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1963.wav", + "text": "再生醫療製劑條例草案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1964.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家的耐性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1965.wav", + "text": "保留條文第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1966.wav", + "text": "一樣是不是就照再修正版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1967.wav", + "text": "的再修正版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1968.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1969.wav", + "text": "安全品質及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1970.wav", + "text": "加個性字兩邊一樣沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1971.wav", + "text": "沒關係啦不用再好加個性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1972.wav", + "text": "字兩邊文字一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1973.wav", + "text": "文字再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1974.wav", + "text": "的文字通過\n處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1975.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1976.wav", + "text": "這是有關定義的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1977.wav", + "text": "我們現在是針對保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1978.wav", + "text": "處理所以進行到第3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1979.wav", + "text": "有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1980.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1981.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1982.wav", + "text": "在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1983.wav", + "text": "醫療製劑不包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1984.wav", + "text": "再生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1985.wav", + "text": "醫療法第3條第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1986.wav", + "text": "小規模客製化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1987.wav", + "text": "之再生醫療技術所得之產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1988.wav", + "text": "再生醫療製劑屬藥師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1989.wav", + "text": "第6條規定之藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1990.wav", + "text": "的文字一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1991.wav", + "text": "先作這樣說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1992.wav", + "text": "請吳署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1993.wav", + "text": "陳委員所提的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1994.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1995.wav", + "text": "立法說明欄的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1996.wav", + "text": "你們會再提上來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1997.wav", + "text": "第3條的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1998.wav", + "text": "還是照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/1999.wav", + "text": "但立法說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2000.wav", + "text": "採陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2001.wav", + "text": "所提出的立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2002.wav", + "text": "是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2003.wav", + "text": "不要一條一條處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2004.wav", + "text": "因為有時候有連貫關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2005.wav", + "text": "空間來描述得更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2006.wav", + "text": "先不要把文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2007.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2008.wav", + "text": "我就建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2009.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2010.wav", + "text": "和剛剛的法案審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2011.wav", + "text": "差異太大了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2012.wav", + "text": "所審查的再生醫療法差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2013.wav", + "text": "拜託邱委員去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2014.wav", + "text": "看一下再生醫療法的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2015.wav", + "text": "其實這些文字和那邊的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2016.wav", + "text": "是差不多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2017.wav", + "text": "本席還是建議能夠通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2018.wav", + "text": "衛福部都已經同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2019.wav", + "text": "這樣子的話是不是每一條都要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2020.wav", + "text": "不是說明欄的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2021.wav", + "text": "如果說明欄的文字合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2022.wav", + "text": "那大家都來保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2023.wav", + "text": "我不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2024.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2025.wav", + "text": "可不可以再講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2026.wav", + "text": "溝通兩次花了很多時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2027.wav", + "text": "的結果先確認文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2028.wav", + "text": "之後才提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2029.wav", + "text": "這些都有溝通過的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2030.wav", + "text": "因為文字剛提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2031.wav", + "text": "所以對其他委員來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2032.wav", + "text": "還需要一點時間思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2033.wav", + "text": "因為按照這樣的審查邏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2034.wav", + "text": "互相來保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2035.wav", + "text": "啊讓我們的審查更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2036.wav", + "text": "有水準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2037.wav", + "text": "因為你提出的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2038.wav", + "text": "大家可能需要一點時間閱讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2039.wav", + "text": "進行詳實的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2040.wav", + "text": "至於說明欄可能需要一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2041.wav", + "text": "因為第3條的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2042.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2043.wav", + "text": "是要加進去的提案說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2044.wav", + "text": "是不是讓食藥署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2045.wav", + "text": "他們同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2046.wav", + "text": "委員也要消化一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2047.wav", + "text": "我資質駑鈍需要看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2048.wav", + "text": "他們有同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2049.wav", + "text": "剛剛吳署長有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2050.wav", + "text": "這裡有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2051.wav", + "text": "署長你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2052.wav", + "text": "也來打個招呼吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2053.wav", + "text": "他說你們同意但我們都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2054.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡捍衛行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2055.wav", + "text": "剛剛食藥署署長有說同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2056.wav", + "text": "我在講話你聽完好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2057.wav", + "text": "你大聲什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2058.wav", + "text": "我們需要一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2059.wav", + "text": "現在繼續開會主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2060.wav", + "text": "主席我先詢問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2061.wav", + "text": "是在提案說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2062.wav", + "text": "剛剛再生醫療法提案說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2063.wav", + "text": "也是保留因為還要再順文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2064.wav", + "text": "所以是不是條文的部分就先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2065.wav", + "text": "因為大家對條文都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2066.wav", + "text": "陳委員也對條文沒有意見就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2067.wav", + "text": "對本文的文字是沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2068.wav", + "text": "的所以文字就先通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2069.wav", + "text": "然後提案說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2070.wav", + "text": "併醫療法第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2071.wav", + "text": "大家對於行政院版第3條的文字是沒有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2072.wav", + "text": "的但是說明欄的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2073.wav", + "text": "文字可能也都要一致性地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2074.wav", + "text": "所以是不是可以把說明欄的部分做保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2075.wav", + "text": "說明文字那時候大家是沒有意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2076.wav", + "text": "還沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2077.wav", + "text": "在說明的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2078.wav", + "text": "不管有沒有保留反正要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2079.wav", + "text": "順文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2080.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2081.wav", + "text": "再麻煩衛福部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2082.wav", + "text": "所以委員所加的後面這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2083.wav", + "text": "我們會調得跟再生醫療法都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2084.wav", + "text": "對於立法說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2085.wav", + "text": "順好的文字再讓我們看好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2086.wav", + "text": "立法說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2087.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們還是先做保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2088.wav", + "text": "請行政部門再提供後續的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2089.wav", + "text": "請大家翻到第4頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2090.wav", + "text": "第4條本來是陳椒華委員委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2091.wav", + "text": "不過剛剛委員已經說可以不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2092.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望就照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2093.wav", + "text": "從條文到說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2094.wav", + "text": "通過因為最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2095.wav", + "text": "相關所有製劑的各個分類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2096.wav", + "text": "我的說明其實跟第3條是類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2097.wav", + "text": "我們本來的比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2098.wav", + "text": "委員的只有一小段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2099.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議維持原來行政院版本的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2100.wav", + "text": "\n這裡是對於定義的分類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2101.wav", + "text": "其實會比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2102.wav", + "text": "第4條是不是照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2103.wav", + "text": "說明欄也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2104.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2105.wav", + "text": "食藥署報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2106.wav", + "text": "那時候大家對於再生醫療審議會之審議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2107.wav", + "text": "還有一些疑惑需要再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2108.wav", + "text": "不過剛剛的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2109.wav", + "text": "已經很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2110.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法第5條是相連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2111.wav", + "text": "大家在概念上都已經很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2112.wav", + "text": "是不是第6條可以照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2113.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2114.wav", + "text": "在第15頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2115.wav", + "text": "在第9條這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2116.wav", + "text": "我們希望可以維持行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2117.wav", + "text": "因為在委員的提案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2118.wav", + "text": "有的是要增加國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2119.wav", + "text": "尚無適當藥物或合適替代療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2120.wav", + "text": "或者醫療迫切需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2121.wav", + "text": "等文字但是事實上在有附款許可的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2122.wav", + "text": "部分我們是針對危及生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2123.wav", + "text": "或者嚴重失能的疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2124.wav", + "text": "覺得這樣的疾病規範已經夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2125.wav", + "text": "所以請求以行政院版本通過以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2126.wav", + "text": "是不是大家對於行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2127.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2128.wav", + "text": "也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2129.wav", + "text": "好同意謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2130.wav", + "text": "第9條就照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2131.wav", + "text": "食藥署報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2132.wav", + "text": "第21條是屬於罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2133.wav", + "text": "因為前面沒有條文的變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2134.wav", + "text": "所以是跟原來的都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2135.wav", + "text": "這是罰則的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2136.wav", + "text": "沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2137.wav", + "text": "喔因為前面的條文幾乎都沒有保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2138.wav", + "text": "所以對於罰則的部分應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2139.wav", + "text": "可以支持行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2140.wav", + "text": "這條就照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2141.wav", + "text": "醫療製劑條例沒有保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2142.wav", + "text": "只有說明欄的部分要配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2143.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法來做文字的確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2144.wav", + "text": "不好意思再給我一點點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2145.wav", + "text": "有關再生醫療製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2146.wav", + "text": "在委員會有保留兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2147.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2148.wav", + "text": "還有今天提出來一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2149.wav", + "text": "我們是不是也來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2150.wav", + "text": "把這三個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2151.wav", + "text": "發給各委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2152.wav", + "text": "蘇巧慧委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2153.wav", + "text": "有兩個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2154.wav", + "text": "請行政部門看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2155.wav", + "text": "再生醫療製劑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2156.wav", + "text": "請吳署長看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2157.wav", + "text": "還有我提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2158.wav", + "text": "第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2159.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2160.wav", + "text": "是委員會保留的兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2161.wav", + "text": "是蘇巧慧委員提的兩案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2162.wav", + "text": "另外一案是再生醫療那一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2163.wav", + "text": "說明附帶決議有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2164.wav", + "text": "有意見要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2165.wav", + "text": "附帶決議第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2166.wav", + "text": "確定沒有受傳染性病原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2167.wav", + "text": "或其他疾病的污染" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2168.wav", + "text": "這個我們可以遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2169.wav", + "text": "就是附帶決議第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2170.wav", + "text": "第2項呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2171.wav", + "text": "第2項有一些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2172.wav", + "text": "且明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2173.wav", + "text": "到最後這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2174.wav", + "text": "我們建議可以劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2175.wav", + "text": "因為對於提供相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2176.wav", + "text": "安全資料給許可證所有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2177.wav", + "text": "真的是沒有辦法完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2178.wav", + "text": "去除掉辨識當事人的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2179.wav", + "text": "我們是建議以個資法來保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2180.wav", + "text": "應該就有足夠的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2181.wav", + "text": "可以不要讓他們的資料出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2182.wav", + "text": "第2項的附帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2183.wav", + "text": "附帶決議是有修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2184.wav", + "text": "蘇委員已經同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2185.wav", + "text": "請提供給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2186.wav", + "text": "我來做確認好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2187.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2188.wav", + "text": "第2項附帶決議就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2189.wav", + "text": "有關再生醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2190.wav", + "text": "製劑條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2191.wav", + "text": "第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2192.wav", + "text": "還有照行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2193.wav", + "text": "通過條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2194.wav", + "text": "條有關通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2195.wav", + "text": "其餘是照審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2196.wav", + "text": "審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2197.wav", + "text": "檢附本案立法說明一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2198.wav", + "text": "第3條的立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2199.wav", + "text": "就再生醫療法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2200.wav", + "text": "今天再生醫療製劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2201.wav", + "text": "雙法要一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2202.wav", + "text": "就會一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2203.wav", + "text": "下次再次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2204.wav", + "text": "再做確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2205.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2206.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2207.wav", + "text": "今天還沒確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2208.wav", + "text": "我們現在唯一還沒確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2209.wav", + "text": "的是第3條的立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2210.wav", + "text": "下次也一併來做確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2211.wav", + "text": "因為它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2212.wav", + "text": "跟再生醫療法連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2213.wav", + "text": "再生醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2214.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2215.wav", + "text": "還加上行政院版第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2216.wav", + "text": "所以我們可能要擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2217.wav", + "text": "擇期再來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2218.wav", + "text": "這部分也辛苦大家了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2219.wav", + "text": "大家對於今天會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2220.wav", + "text": "還有沒有什麼要詢問的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2221.wav", + "text": "我們下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2222.wav", + "text": "儘快安排協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2223.wav", + "text": "我們還會另外發通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2224.wav", + "text": "就先到這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2225.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14943/2226.wav", + "text": "辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/0.wav", + "text": "委員會審查考試院行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/1.wav", + "text": "公務人員退休撫卹基金管理條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/2.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/3.wav", + "text": "委員謝衣鳯等16人擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/4.wav", + "text": "公務人員退休撫卹基金管理條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/5.wav", + "text": "第5條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/6.wav", + "text": "委員曾銘宗等19人擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/7.wav", + "text": "公務人員退休撫卹基金管理條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/8.wav", + "text": "修正草案以上共計兩案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/9.wav", + "text": "\n現在進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/10.wav", + "text": "我們現在有協商的對照條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/11.wav", + "text": "和審查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/12.wav", + "text": "還有逕付二讀的關係文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/13.wav", + "text": "如果現場委員還有其他的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/14.wav", + "text": "我們就進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/15.wav", + "text": "目前除了上述條文以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/16.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團也提出一個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/17.wav", + "text": "不曉得行政機關有沒有拿到修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/18.wav", + "text": "所擬具公務人員退休撫卹基金管理條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/19.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/20.wav", + "text": "\n提案的時間是在109年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/21.wav", + "text": "就是考試院已經有改過條次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/22.wav", + "text": "在委員會已經審議通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/23.wav", + "text": "我們就不予審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/24.wav", + "text": "就是按照現行條文通過不予修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/25.wav", + "text": "這樣子好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/26.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/27.wav", + "text": "好第1條維持現行條文不予修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/28.wav", + "text": "第2條在委員會審議的時候有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/29.wav", + "text": "請問各位在場的委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/30.wav", + "text": "請問考試院或銓敘部就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/31.wav", + "text": "我們也不堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/32.wav", + "text": "能夠納進去的就趕快納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/33.wav", + "text": "好不好這樣子效率才會快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/34.wav", + "text": "我們也不堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/35.wav", + "text": "好是不是第4條和第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/36.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團修正動議裡面所提及的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/37.wav", + "text": "──是否能夠納入現行的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/38.wav", + "text": "做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/39.wav", + "text": "都是以基管會──還是委員會制時候的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/40.wav", + "text": "但是現在基管會的組織已經改成管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/41.wav", + "text": "因此沒有委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/42.wav", + "text": "不會再有本會委員的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/43.wav", + "text": "所以這兩條是不是可以暫時不修正依照考試院的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/44.wav", + "text": "通過因為這個設計原來是舊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/45.wav", + "text": "基管會是委員制的時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/46.wav", + "text": "這樣設計是OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/47.wav", + "text": "但現在已經是管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/48.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/49.wav", + "text": "第4條沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/50.wav", + "text": "第6條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/51.wav", + "text": "是給你們更大的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/52.wav", + "text": "可以聘請一些專業的聘用人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/53.wav", + "text": "第4條沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/54.wav", + "text": "第6條委員的意見我們基本上也很感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/55.wav", + "text": "啦但是在文字上可能也要改成是本局而不是本會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/56.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/57.wav", + "text": "還是第幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/58.wav", + "text": "可以納到第幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/59.wav", + "text": "修正條文第4條做文字修正嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/60.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以這樣建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/61.wav", + "text": "因為第4條我們在基金之用途裡面有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/62.wav", + "text": "──三本基金投資運用稽核及績效管理所需之經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/63.wav", + "text": "這邊就可以用經費來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/64.wav", + "text": "如果照委員的意見是希望我們能夠用在用人費用上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/65.wav", + "text": "可以文字上做一些調整也可以達到委員的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/66.wav", + "text": "你說可以達到那個目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/67.wav", + "text": "請將文字發給大家看看行不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/68.wav", + "text": "我們現在進行的是第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/69.wav", + "text": "然後發給各位委員參酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/70.wav", + "text": "我們處理到第4條的時候再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/71.wav", + "text": "現在第2條是按照考試院提案通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/72.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/73.wav", + "text": "委員曾銘宗等19人提案第5條就不予採納好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/74.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/75.wav", + "text": "委員曾銘宗等19人提案第6條就不予採納好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/76.wav", + "text": "第4條的部分你們的文字應該還沒修正好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/77.wav", + "text": "我們正在印" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/78.wav", + "text": "好等一下再進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/79.wav", + "text": "\n請賴香伶委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/80.wav", + "text": "我想請教第2條與第4條的關連性未來有公務人員新制是個人帳戶的提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/81.wav", + "text": "所以在這個制度上的監理還有主政性質上是不是以這個法為所有的統籌辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/82.wav", + "text": "如果是個人帳戶制的話有所謂可以自選與投資的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/83.wav", + "text": "我看第4條的基金用途還有第2條的關連性請你們再做一次說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/84.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告因為這是公務人員退休撫卹基金管理條例這是指現職人員的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/85.wav", + "text": "跟個人帳戶制的不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/86.wav", + "text": "個人帳戶制是另外依照個人帳戶制的退休撫卹法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/87.wav", + "text": "所以它是有另外的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/88.wav", + "text": "跟這個是沒有關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/89.wav", + "text": "這個是現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/90.wav", + "text": "就是現行退休撫卹基金管理走一個管理局的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/91.wav", + "text": "同時把監理會的組成類似由基層代表等等做監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/92.wav", + "text": "我們會放在銓敘部的對在銓敘部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/93.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的個人帳戶新制那個是公務人員退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/94.wav", + "text": "我們把它簡稱叫做個人帳戶制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/95.wav", + "text": "它有一個儲金監理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/96.wav", + "text": "我上次有質詢說這裡有一個委員會那裡有一個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/97.wav", + "text": "所以這些人的關連性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/98.wav", + "text": "像公務人員部分有公務人員的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/99.wav", + "text": "教育人員部分的個人帳戶制單獨也有教育人員自己的監理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/100.wav", + "text": "會有他們自己的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/101.wav", + "text": "所以我們目前公務人員退休撫卹基金的監理會是原來就有一個監理會是機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/102.wav", + "text": "我們現在把它裁掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/103.wav", + "text": "一個就是公保準備金一個就是個人帳戶制的儲金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/104.wav", + "text": "另一個是現行公教人員的退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/105.wav", + "text": "它有3個不同的基金制度與監理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/106.wav", + "text": "我們原則上會跟教育人員的同時看看是不是也一起開聯席會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/107.wav", + "text": "但是基金不同所以監理委員會的組成是不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/108.wav", + "text": "然後這個組織條例也不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/109.wav", + "text": "會有3個相關的管理條例嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/110.wav", + "text": "沒有3個管理條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/111.wav", + "text": "有3個不同的監理會設置辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/112.wav", + "text": "管理條例的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/113.wav", + "text": "所以它規範的是我們如何自行運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/114.wav", + "text": "另外將來的個人帳戶制還有公保準備金是委託其他機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/115.wav", + "text": "委外的單位可以代操" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/116.wav", + "text": "曾總召提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/117.wav", + "text": "讓你們可以聘一些專業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/118.wav", + "text": "那個是在我們自行操作的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/119.wav", + "text": "現在自行操作部分的專業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/120.wav", + "text": "是我們自行運用的部分需要有投資專業的人來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/121.wav", + "text": "OK現在這些是已經進用或者用什麼方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/122.wav", + "text": "我們現在少數用聘用但是人數很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/123.wav", + "text": "人數可以稍微多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/124.wav", + "text": "再回到剛才有爭議的第4條及第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/125.wav", + "text": "請問是不是就按照考試院行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/126.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/127.wav", + "text": "\n接下來是委員曾銘宗等19人提案第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/128.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/129.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/130.wav", + "text": "\n委員曾銘宗等19人提案第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/131.wav", + "text": "是不是就不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/132.wav", + "text": "\n委員曾銘宗等19人提案第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/133.wav", + "text": "是不是就不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/134.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/135.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/136.wav", + "text": "\n委員曾銘宗等19人提案第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/137.wav", + "text": "是不是就不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/138.wav", + "text": "好好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/139.wav", + "text": "\n那第十二條是不是就按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/140.wav", + "text": "考試院行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/141.wav", + "text": "\n現在回到第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/142.wav", + "text": "請問各位委員是不是已經收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/143.wav", + "text": "好我有問好請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/144.wav", + "text": "我要請教銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/145.wav", + "text": "你們文字要這樣改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/146.wav", + "text": "那有沒有達到我原來提案的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/147.wav", + "text": "就是可以讓你們有一定的彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/148.wav", + "text": "能夠聘請一些專業的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/149.wav", + "text": "因為其實相對於一定的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/150.wav", + "text": "你們基金那麼龐大嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/151.wav", + "text": "你們一年花個幾百萬幾千萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/152.wav", + "text": "能夠請到真正好的人進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/153.wav", + "text": "能夠提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/154.wav", + "text": "你不要說1%啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/155.wav", + "text": "0.5%0.25%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/156.wav", + "text": "你們增加的績效就不得了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/157.wav", + "text": "啦其實你們現在沒有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/158.wav", + "text": "所以給你們一定的彈性嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/159.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/160.wav", + "text": "這個也是參考委員之前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/161.wav", + "text": "版本第7條規定的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/162.wav", + "text": "所以沒有問題對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/163.wav", + "text": "基本上我們認為這樣應該就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/164.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/165.wav", + "text": "像金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/166.wav", + "text": "起一般的大概就多一兩萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/167.wav", + "text": "檢查局更高可能到3萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/168.wav", + "text": "可以請到比較好的公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/169.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/170.wav", + "text": "而在一般行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/171.wav", + "text": "沒有專業加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/172.wav", + "text": "給給你們一定的彈性的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/173.wav", + "text": "也可以達到我原來的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/174.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/175.wav", + "text": "不要說哪一天你跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/176.wav", + "text": "沒辦法喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/177.wav", + "text": "確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/178.wav", + "text": "向委員報告可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/179.wav", + "text": "可以就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/180.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/181.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/182.wav", + "text": "考試院行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/183.wav", + "text": "的文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/184.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/185.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/186.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/187.wav", + "text": "現在進行第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/188.wav", + "text": "請問在場委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/189.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/190.wav", + "text": "是刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/191.wav", + "text": "因為過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/192.wav", + "text": "我們國民黨黨團的意見是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/193.wav", + "text": "基金的監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/194.wav", + "text": "其實只要經過考試院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/195.wav", + "text": "不需要再經行政院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/196.wav", + "text": "是不是可以按照我的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/197.wav", + "text": "沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/198.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/199.wav", + "text": "就按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/200.wav", + "text": "本席等16人的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/201.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/202.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/203.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/204.wav", + "text": "提案第5條第6條不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/205.wav", + "text": "\n五第5條照委員謝衣鳯等16人提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/206.wav", + "text": "\n六其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/207.wav", + "text": "請問在場的黨團代表有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/208.wav", + "text": "好那我們就按照這個協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14926/209.wav", + "text": "通過等議事人員將協商結論製作完成後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/0.wav", + "text": "委行政院各黨團及委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1.wav", + "text": "計有13個版本審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/2.wav", + "text": "行政院提案各黨團及委員提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/3.wav", + "text": "條第八十一條第八十三條及第八十四條等條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/4.wav", + "text": "還有台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/5.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團及個人新增提案的保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/6.wav", + "text": "其他條文我們就照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/7.wav", + "text": "也決議在院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/8.wav", + "text": "本案送出經濟委員會到現在剛好4個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/9.wav", + "text": "我想大致上應該已有一些初步溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/10.wav", + "text": "所以今天我們就來進行協商\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/11.wav", + "text": "\n請王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/12.wav", + "text": "礦業法就像剛才召委講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/13.wav", + "text": "在這4個月當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/14.wav", + "text": "經濟部同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/15.wav", + "text": "其實是密集拜會了非常多的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/16.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員陳瑩委員陳琬惠委員陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/17.wav", + "text": "孔文吉委員林淑芬委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/18.wav", + "text": "一次我也非常謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/19.wav", + "text": "在這個細部的溝通中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/20.wav", + "text": "也有所了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/21.wav", + "text": "縮小了彼此的歧見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/22.wav", + "text": "大致上重點是對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/23.wav", + "text": "是不是可以做得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/24.wav", + "text": "以及我們跟環保署要如何互相協同作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/25.wav", + "text": "部分包括一開始礦業用地需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/26.wav", + "text": "容進行開採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/27.wav", + "text": "以及政府有沒有做好相關管控等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/28.wav", + "text": "也謝謝各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/29.wav", + "text": "大家在一些意見上已經有比較聚焦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/30.wav", + "text": "如果有必要我們會再補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/31.wav", + "text": "也會把委員關切的點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/32.wav", + "text": "在相關立法說明中寫得更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/33.wav", + "text": "方式等一下我們會有一個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/34.wav", + "text": "詳細說明保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/35.wav", + "text": "跟委員協商的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/36.wav", + "text": "另外就幾個比較關鍵的問題點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/37.wav", + "text": "我們也會再補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/38.wav", + "text": "這個部分如果主席同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/39.wav", + "text": "以上做簡單的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/40.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/41.wav", + "text": "那就請經濟部把彙整過的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/42.wav", + "text": "分送給各黨團委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/43.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我們就一邊發放資料一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/44.wav", + "text": "請徐局長召委各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/45.wav", + "text": "謝謝在跟委員報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/46.wav", + "text": "委員給了我們很多指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/47.wav", + "text": "現在同仁手上發的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/48.wav", + "text": "就是我們就相關條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/49.wav", + "text": "我們把它整理在這張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/50.wav", + "text": "第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/51.wav", + "text": "部分當初委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/52.wav", + "text": "還有上次開會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/53.wav", + "text": "把得改成應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/54.wav", + "text": "應有關礦業管理資料庫的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/55.wav", + "text": "委員也同意我們在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/56.wav", + "text": "說明請各位委員看第2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/57.wav", + "text": "2頁紅字的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/58.wav", + "text": "中有關資料庫的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/59.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/60.wav", + "text": "因為這都已經經過溝通了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/61.wav", + "text": "看看各位委員有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/62.wav", + "text": "要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/63.wav", + "text": "我們希望今天能夠順利出協商會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/64.wav", + "text": "議如果還有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/65.wav", + "text": "當然就保留給院長那邊去做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/66.wav", + "text": "也希望能夠讓人民感受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/67.wav", + "text": "是有相關的進度在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/68.wav", + "text": "\n請各位委員看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/69.wav", + "text": "主要大概會分為一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/70.wav", + "text": "各個議題的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/71.wav", + "text": "剛剛局長也有說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/72.wav", + "text": "局長有要再補充的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/73.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/74.wav", + "text": "這些都已經溝通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/75.wav", + "text": "看看各位委員對哪幾個部分還有意見的就提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/76.wav", + "text": "主要是關於建置礦業的資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/77.wav", + "text": "現在行政院版已經把它擺在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/78.wav", + "text": "這個我沒什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/79.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/80.wav", + "text": "我的版本是規定每五年定期檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/81.wav", + "text": "討現在行政院版還是10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/82.wav", + "text": "沒有已經改成5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/83.wav", + "text": "院版修正條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/84.wav", + "text": "我們的拜會情形是同意將10年縮短為5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/85.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/86.wav", + "text": "列入說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/87.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/88.wav", + "text": "謝謝請陳委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/89.wav", + "text": "將得改為應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/90.wav", + "text": "所以同意現在的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/91.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/92.wav", + "text": "就是照新的修正意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/93.wav", + "text": "\n處理第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/94.wav", + "text": "第8條那時候委員是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/95.wav", + "text": "建議條文增加原住民採取礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/96.wav", + "text": "委員也同意我們在立法說明去做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/97.wav", + "text": "請各位委員看第4頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/98.wav", + "text": "就是原住民得依本條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/99.wav", + "text": "在既有礦業權範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/100.wav", + "text": "尚未核定礦業用地之區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/101.wav", + "text": "進行非營利採取礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/102.wav", + "text": "物這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/103.wav", + "text": "當初跟委員報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/104.wav", + "text": "委員同意放在立法說明謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/105.wav", + "text": "各位委員是不是就把它放到立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/106.wav", + "text": "這一條就照他們的修正建議通過好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/107.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/108.wav", + "text": "這個在原基法裡面都有講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/109.wav", + "text": "就是原住民可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/110.wav", + "text": "文字上他把它放到立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/111.wav", + "text": "基於傳統文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/112.wav", + "text": "祭儀或自用等非營利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/113.wav", + "text": "目的而採取礦物免申辦礦業權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/114.wav", + "text": "如果能夠放在條文是最好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/115.wav", + "text": "為什麼一定要放在立法��明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/116.wav", + "text": "我們在說明的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/117.wav", + "text": "有跟委員報告過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/118.wav", + "text": "就是在立法說明這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/119.wav", + "text": "這樣說明已經很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/120.wav", + "text": "因為除了第8條的說明以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/121.wav", + "text": "其實原基法第十九條也有相關的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/122.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為寫在立法說明就會很清楚謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/123.wav", + "text": "把它加到立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/124.wav", + "text": "這個是不是就照溝通協調過的結果通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/125.wav", + "text": "第8條有有剛剛我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/126.wav", + "text": "\n再來是第十一條請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/127.wav", + "text": "第十一條也是委員關心礦業權分割時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/128.wav", + "text": "應該要邀請地方政府專家及學者來共同審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/129.wav", + "text": "我們拜會委員時也跟委員講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/130.wav", + "text": "這部分放在立法說明來呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/131.wav", + "text": "委員也同意我們的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/132.wav", + "text": "立法說明在第五頁紅字的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/133.wav", + "text": "主管機關為分割審查認為有必要時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/134.wav", + "text": "得邀集地方政府專家及學者參與審查併予敘明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/135.wav", + "text": "各位委員第十一條是不是也一樣增加立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/136.wav", + "text": "現在我的版本是主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/137.wav", + "text": "不是只有主管機關同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/138.wav", + "text": "必須要邀請地方政府專家和學者共同來審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/139.wav", + "text": "是否要做分割" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/140.wav", + "text": "但是現在礦務局都是擺在說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/141.wav", + "text": "我是直接寫在條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/142.wav", + "text": "在立法說明放上去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/143.wav", + "text": "其實將來他們也必須要參採這個立法說明的意旨去進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/144.wav", + "text": "孔委員可以嗎好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/145.wav", + "text": "加入立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/146.wav", + "text": "\n再來是第十四條請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/147.wav", + "text": "第十四條第十五條是有關礦業權展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/148.wav", + "text": "限尚未准駁的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/149.wav", + "text": "礦業權期滿是否要停工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/150.wav", + "text": "委員的關心大概都是focus在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/151.wav", + "text": "我們礦務局特別跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/152.wav", + "text": "有關礦業權的展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/153.wav", + "text": "限其實只是未來可申請探採礦的權利延續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/154.wav", + "text": "都是在礦業用地核定以後才開始做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/155.wav", + "text": "依照核定的相關計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/156.wav", + "text": "比如環說書水保開採及施工計畫��容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/157.wav", + "text": "我們會實施採礦的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/158.wav", + "text": "相關計畫的高程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/159.wav", + "text": "程和採礦的總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/160.wav", + "text": "會在相關圖說裡去做展延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/161.wav", + "text": "延並會納入核准處分的附款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/162.wav", + "text": "由權責機關進行管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/163.wav", + "text": "重點就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/164.wav", + "text": "或達到開採總量時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/165.wav", + "text": "我們就會要求停工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/166.wav", + "text": "並不是無限制進行開採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/167.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/168.wav", + "text": "所以我們是建議能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/169.wav", + "text": "依照院版的條文來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/170.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/171.wav", + "text": "意思上第十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/172.wav", + "text": "第十四條是探礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/173.wav", + "text": "第十四條的部分其實非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/174.wav", + "text": "爭點就是在展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/175.wav", + "text": "你本來有一個處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/176.wav", + "text": "這個處分有一個期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/177.wav", + "text": "期限就是四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/178.wav", + "text": "這個期限到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/179.wav", + "text": "限到底是什麼時候要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/180.wav", + "text": "以及准駁之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/181.wav", + "text": "有沒有一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/182.wav", + "text": "問題是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/183.wav", + "text": "時力黨團的版本針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/184.wav", + "text": "現在討論的探礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/185.wav", + "text": "權期滿至主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/186.wav", + "text": "如果你要把原探礦權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/187.wav", + "text": "就應該要停止探礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/188.wav", + "text": "這是合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/189.wav", + "text": "的因為在委員會審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/190.wav", + "text": "都會覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/191.wav", + "text": "到底主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/192.wav", + "text": "你總是要做一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/193.wav", + "text": "個永遠都不判決的庭期嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/194.wav", + "text": "准駁就超過四年\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/195.wav", + "text": "到底是一個舊權利的延續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/196.wav", + "text": "還是新權利的賦予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/197.wav", + "text": "判字第936號判決已經非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/198.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得你們也要尊重一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/199.wav", + "text": "就是認為礦業權的展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/200.wav", + "text": "是一種新權利的賦予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/201.wav", + "text": "它是一個新權利賦予的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/202.wav", + "text": "在確定准許探礦權的展限而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/203.wav", + "text": "讓業者無限制繼續探" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/204.wav", + "text": "礦真的是不合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/205.wav", + "text": "經過一年你連一個探礦權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/206.wav", + "text": "都沒辦法做一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/207.wav", + "text": "我會覺得你這個機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/208.wav", + "text": "到底是不是有能力去進行這樣的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/209.wav", + "text": "那也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/210.wav", + "text": "答案其實非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/211.wav", + "text": "應該也是一個新權利的賦予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/212.wav", + "text": "包括林淑芬委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/213.wav", + "text": "民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/214.wav", + "text": "我們都可以看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/215.wav", + "text": "也是一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/216.wav", + "text": "如果申請採礦權展限的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/217.wav", + "text": "都一直不准駁的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/218.wav", + "text": "業者還繼續挖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/219.wav", + "text": "總是要設一個期限啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/220.wav", + "text": "這是一個最起碼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/221.wav", + "text": "管理沒有道理說這個許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/222.wav", + "text": "是一個授益性質的行政處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/223.wav", + "text": "在期限已到的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/224.wav", + "text": "到底要不要給予一個展限的處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/225.wav", + "text": "分就繼續的延續下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/226.wav", + "text": "這是完全沒有道理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/227.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/228.wav", + "text": "因為有些部分已經經過一些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/229.wav", + "text": "大家可能還需要一點點的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/230.wav", + "text": "處理完再回來處理這個好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/231.wav", + "text": "先把已經達成共識的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/232.wav", + "text": "還需要再回頭講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/233.wav", + "text": "好不好第十四條第十五條先留下來第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/234.wav", + "text": "對我就是擔心大家待會都要忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/235.wav", + "text": "不見得都能夠留到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/236.wav", + "text": "好有幾位委員要先發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/237.wav", + "text": "言我們先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/238.wav", + "text": "不好意思可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/239.wav", + "text": "有您的允許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/240.wav", + "text": "簡單說一下好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/241.wav", + "text": "第一2050水泥業碳中和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/242.wav", + "text": "每十年政策環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/243.wav", + "text": "礦權展限要環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/244.wav", + "text": "及原民協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/245.wav", + "text": "第三廠商回饋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/246.wav", + "text": "用在公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/247.wav", + "text": "共利益或集體消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/248.wav", + "text": "關閉協助員工安置及轉型輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/249.wav", + "text": "謝謝您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/250.wav", + "text": "關於第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/251.wav", + "text": "我還是要發言一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/252.wav", + "text": "雖然經過很多次的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/253.wav", + "text": "因為第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/254.wav", + "text": "提到採礦權要以20年為限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/255.wav", + "text": "得申請展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/256.wav", + "text": "每次展限不得超過20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/257.wav", + "text": "其實這一項沒有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/258.wav", + "text": "但第二項提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/259.wav", + "text": "採礦權期滿到主管機關就展限申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/260.wav", + "text": "為准駁之期間內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/261.wav", + "text": "採礦權視為存續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/262.wav", + "text": "大家對這一條很有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/263.wav", + "text": "祖先同意就永遠同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/264.wav", + "text": "所以我們就一直訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/265.wav", + "text": "展限應該也要辦理諮商同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/266.wav", + "text": "本席很高興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/267.wav", + "text": "昨天經濟部有來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/268.wav", + "text": "表示第四十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/269.wav", + "text": "業者在申請礦業用地的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/270.wav", + "text": "應檢具開採及施工相關書圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/271.wav", + "text": "高程及總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/272.wav", + "text": "核定之後會納入核定的處分附款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/273.wav", + "text": "不論展延與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/274.wav", + "text": "只要它挖的高程總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/275.wav", + "text": "面積超過核定的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/276.wav", + "text": "即要求停工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/277.wav", + "text": "諮商同意環評等等程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/278.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個說明很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/279.wav", + "text": "對應目前的法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/280.wav", + "text": "還是完全找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/281.wav", + "text": "看不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/282.wav", + "text": "所以我們特別要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/283.wav", + "text": "如果業者超過核定的總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/284.wav", + "text": "面積仍然繼續開採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/285.wav", + "text": "稽查的程序為何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/286.wav", + "text": "希望能夠明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/287.wav", + "text": "而達到開採高程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/288.wav", + "text": "跟總量的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/289.wav", + "text": "需重新辦理環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/290.wav", + "text": "諮商同意等申請程序的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/291.wav", + "text": "希望還是要找得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/292.wav", + "text": "相對應的明確條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/293.wav", + "text": "以上兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/294.wav", + "text": "希望一定要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/295.wav", + "text": "明確化相對應的權利跟義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/296.wav", + "text": "本席做這樣的意見表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/297.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/298.wav", + "text": "我現在再看一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/299.wav", + "text": "回頭再想一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/300.wav", + "text": "第十四條第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/301.wav", + "text": "我突然發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/302.wav", + "text": "這一條不會是問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/303.wav", + "text": "為什麼不會是問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/304.wav", + "text": "呢因為礦權跟礦業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/305.wav", + "text": "兩個是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/306.wav", + "text": "嘛礦權的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/307.wav", + "text": "以亞泥為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/308.wav", + "text": "那麼大的──全臺灣第一大礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/309.wav", + "text": "你們3個月就核定了礦權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/310.wav", + "text": "我們都知道對環境把關的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/311.wav", + "text": "是在礦業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/312.wav", + "text": "但我們現在這裡講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/313.wav", + "text": "礦權而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/314.wav", + "text": "即採礦或是探礦的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/315.wav", + "text": "所以最大一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/316.wav", + "text": "探礦權以4年為限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/317.wav", + "text": "更長一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/318.wav", + "text": "可是你們都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/319.wav", + "text": "要照你們的版本才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/320.wav", + "text": "我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/321.wav", + "text": "展限在准駁之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/322.wav", + "text": "礦權都可以繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/323.wav", + "text": "如果礦業用地的總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/324.wav", + "text": "或者是探採的高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/325.wav", + "text": "也都還繼續在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/326.wav", + "text": "這個都沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/327.wav", + "text": "所以這只是行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/328.wav", + "text": "我們的版本不可行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/329.wav", + "text": "困難在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/330.wav", + "text": "行政程序的流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/331.wav", + "text": "你們的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/332.wav", + "text": "會產生在哪個部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/333.wav", + "text": "你要告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/334.wav", + "text": "譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/335.wav", + "text": "諮商同意權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/336.wav", + "text": "其實是啟動就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/337.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/338.wav", + "text": "亞泥3個月就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/339.wav", + "text": "應該沒有這麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/340.wav", + "text": "曠日廢時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/341.wav", + "text": "你們私底下來溝通都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/342.wav", + "text": "沒有我們審很久很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/343.wav", + "text": "我說好那你把所有案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/344.wav", + "text": "拿出來整理案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/345.wav", + "text": "給我們看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/346.wav", + "text": "都只審3個月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/347.wav", + "text": "哪有比亞泥更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/348.wav", + "text": "比亞泥需要審更久的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/349.wav", + "text": "應該不是問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/350.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/351.wav", + "text": "跟礦業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/352.wav", + "text": "如果我們不堅持展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/353.wav", + "text": "就要環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/354.wav", + "text": "而把對環境衝擊的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/355.wav", + "text": "放在礦業用地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/356.wav", + "text": "如果我們不再以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/357.wav", + "text": "時間為管制標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/358.wav", + "text": "20年到了就來環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/359.wav", + "text": "而是以你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/360.wav", + "text": "或者是新申請設礦時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/361.wav", + "text": "環評裡面的開採總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/362.wav", + "text": "或者水平高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/363.wav", + "text": "就只剩下行政作業而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/364.wav", + "text": "我其實是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/365.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛淑芬委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/366.wav", + "text": "的其實過去爭執的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/367.wav", + "text": "要不要諮商同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/368.wav", + "text": "不再爭這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/369.wav", + "text": "對於這些礦業權的展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/370.wav", + "text": "限因為這涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/371.wav", + "text": "很多相關的權利人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/372.wav", + "text": "最長多久時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/373.wav", + "text": "明確的審核結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/374.wav", + "text": "反而變成最不確定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/375.wav", + "text": "所以你們可以拿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/376.wav", + "text": "時間大概都落在什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/377.wav", + "text": "就算再多抓一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/378.wav", + "text": "多抓一點緩衝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/379.wav", + "text": "我覺得大家也不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/380.wav", + "text": "不能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/381.wav", + "text": "狀況或實際狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/382.wav", + "text": "都會讓大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/383.wav", + "text": "好像充滿了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/384.wav", + "text": "時間上的不確定性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/385.wav", + "text": "各種狀況的不確定性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/386.wav", + "text": "大家會怪罪的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/387.wav", + "text": "經濟部過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/388.wav", + "text": "時坦白說也都會希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/389.wav", + "text": "其他部會給一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/390.wav", + "text": "可是你們自己的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/391.wav", + "text": "可以完成或必須完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/392.wav", + "text": "審查都可以按照經驗來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/393.wav", + "text": "匡給大家一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/394.wav", + "text": "絕對做不到的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/395.wav", + "text": "就由過去的經驗來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/396.wav", + "text": "我覺得大家都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/397.wav", + "text": "但是現在這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/398.wav", + "text": "大家反而覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/399.wav", + "text": "的不確定性是來自於礦務局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/400.wav", + "text": "我覺得這並不是一件好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/401.wav", + "text": "不會對制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/402.wav", + "text": "應該直接在行政的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/403.wav", + "text": "率讓大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/404.wav", + "text": "你們的相關作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/405.wav", + "text": "是一個明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/406.wav", + "text": "不確定性可以變少的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/407.wav", + "text": "才會增加對這個機制的信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/408.wav", + "text": "若說明完還是沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/409.wav", + "text": "我們就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/410.wav", + "text": "謝謝幾位委員的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/411.wav", + "text": "礦業權或採礦權的展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/412.wav", + "text": "在權利的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/413.wav", + "text": "我們可以讓它延續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/414.wav", + "text": "在這個範圍內找一塊地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/415.wav", + "text": "事實上所有的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/416.wav", + "text": "在我們溝通的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/417.wav", + "text": "都認為真正有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/418.wav", + "text": "生產量的是那個地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/419.wav", + "text": "環評也是那個地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/420.wav", + "text": "水保也是針對那個地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/421.wav", + "text": "所以那個地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/422.wav", + "text": "會有環評結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/423.wav", + "text": "跟水保結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/424.wav", + "text": "最終高程跟最終採量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/425.wav", + "text": "跟礦業權的延續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/426.wav", + "text": "第十四條的探礦權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/427.wav", + "text": "限做不出准駁坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/428.wav", + "text": "很少碰到第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/429.wav", + "text": "是一樣的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/430.wav", + "text": "重點是第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/431.wav", + "text": "在採礦權申請展限期間在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/432.wav", + "text": "期間在還沒准駁之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/433.wav", + "text": "視為存續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/434.wav", + "text": "者都來申請礦業權展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/435.wav", + "text": "也都期滿了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/436.wav", + "text": "有六十七十案在手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/437.wav", + "text": "所以這兩條其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/438.wav", + "text": "法律邏輯要一致的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/439.wav", + "text": "林淑芬委員剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/440.wav", + "text": "但是一直沒有決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/441.wav", + "text": "要不要准展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/442.wav", + "text": "就可以繼續開採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/443.wav", + "text": "這是不合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/444.wav", + "text": "所以這是我們在跟委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/445.wav", + "text": "的情形委員們關切的是這個點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/446.wav", + "text": "總量也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/447.wav", + "text": "其實都是要follow" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/448.wav", + "text": "的超過就是不可以\n有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/449.wav", + "text": "關這個問題點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/450.wav", + "text": "內就像剛才委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/451.wav", + "text": "也會把它講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/452.wav", + "text": "這個總量都已經滿了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/453.wav", + "text": "了就不能再繼續開採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/454.wav", + "text": "不管有沒有展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/455.wav", + "text": "這其實是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/456.wav", + "text": "剛才伍委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/457.wav", + "text": "但我們現在的作法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/458.wav", + "text": "在立法說明裡寫清楚因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/459.wav", + "text": "跟林淑芬委員在溝通的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/460.wav", + "text": "主要是這個問題點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/461.wav", + "text": "補充一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/462.wav", + "text": "好那我們講完就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/463.wav", + "text": "我覺得部長也很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/464.wav", + "text": "在看待這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/465.wav", + "text": "這是一個處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/466.wav", + "text": "在到期的前一年或兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/467.wav", + "text": "就可以申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/468.wav", + "text": "有可能到了前兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/469.wav", + "text": "就申請又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/470.wav", + "text": "或者最慢在一年前一定要申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/471.wav", + "text": "要不要設一個期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/472.wav", + "text": "包括時代力量黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/473.wav", + "text": "大概都是一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/474.wav", + "text": "一年就應該要做一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/475.wav", + "text": "你可以看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/476.wav", + "text": "如果是在到期前兩年申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/477.wav", + "text": "再加上這一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/478.wav", + "text": "有三年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/479.wav", + "text": "讓主管機關去做一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/480.wav", + "text": "或者是在前一年申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/481.wav", + "text": "又逾一年做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/482.wav", + "text": "等於是有兩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/483.wav", + "text": "或是第十五條的採礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/484.wav", + "text": "去做一個決定嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/485.wav", + "text": "這不可思議啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/486.wav", + "text": "以我們臺灣的行政效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/487.wav", + "text": "我覺得問題在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/488.wav", + "text": "現在有六十七十件就是超過3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/489.wav", + "text": "這不可思議嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/490.wav", + "text": "部長你滿誠實的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/491.wav", + "text": "如果超過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/492.wav", + "text": "那就不應該展限了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/493.wav", + "text": "表示你沒辦法做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/494.wav", + "text": "以亞泥為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/495.wav", + "text": "2016年就申請了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/496.wav", + "text": "到現在已經擱置了六七年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/497.wav", + "text": "因為我們在修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/498.wav", + "text": "我們立法院訂了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/499.wav", + "text": "附款要求不可以准駁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/500.wav", + "text": "因為到底適用新法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/501.wav", + "text": "還是舊法──不得為准駁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/502.wav", + "text": "所以我們當時才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/503.wav", + "text": "或修法的過程就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/504.wav", + "text": "愈明確愈好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/505.wav", + "text": "但是剛好就是以這六七年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/506.wav", + "text": "如果第十四條第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/507.wav", + "text": "沒有把准駁期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/508.wav", + "text": "訂出來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/509.wav", + "text": "它的確可以六年或七年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/510.wav", + "text": "只要行政裁量敢的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/511.wav", + "text": "即便不是特殊政治因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/512.wav", + "text": "公務人員也有可能是──" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/513.wav", + "text": "我送個紅包給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/514.wav", + "text": "你幫我多延一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/515.wav", + "text": "反正我的環說書還有空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/516.wav", + "text": "我申請展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/517.wav", + "text": "但是再一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/518.wav", + "text": "我的用地總量開採就滿了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/519.wav", + "text": "真的再申請展限的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/520.wav", + "text": "其實行政成本很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/521.wav", + "text": "所以我也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/522.wav", + "text": "你幫我慢一年二年核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/523.wav", + "text": "我就採滿了採完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/524.wav", + "text": "我也不採了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/525.wav", + "text": "這個空間有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/526.wav", + "text": "有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/527.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/528.wav", + "text": "拿這種極端的案子出來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/529.wav", + "text": "不過就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/530.wav", + "text": "規範愈明確愈好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/531.wav", + "text": "你們不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/532.wav", + "text": "我們立法院的理由是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/533.wav", + "text": "我們要求你可以提早申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/534.wav", + "text": "申請開始到期滿前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/535.wav", + "text": "駁你們說你們的困難是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/536.wav", + "text": "因為要跑很多關卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/537.wav", + "text": "所以對自己的行政效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/538.wav", + "text": "並沒有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/539.wav", + "text": "我剛才第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/540.wav", + "text": "就是告訴你想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/541.wav", + "text": "你們行政效率會卡在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/542.wav", + "text": "沒有地方可以卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/543.wav", + "text": "因為這只是礦權核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/544.wav", + "text": "它不是礦業用地核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/545.wav", + "text": "所以沒有非常複雜的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/546.wav", + "text": "包括原住民諮商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/547.wav", + "text": "要在礦權核定之前好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/548.wav", + "text": "可是我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/549.wav", + "text": "諮商的版本就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/550.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/551.wav", + "text": "因為溝通的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/552.wav", + "text": "我沒有想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/553.wav", + "text": "事實上變成真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/554.wav", + "text": "只有純粹的行政審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/555.wav", + "text": "沒有涉及到用地審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/556.wav", + "text": "行政審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/557.wav", + "text": "就要環評這種東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/558.wav", + "text": "也沒有要在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/559.wav", + "text": "我沒有堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/560.wav", + "text": "我們就實質去把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/561.wav", + "text": "環境衝擊就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/562.wav", + "text": "有類似的機制就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/563.wav", + "text": "我們就對用地把關就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/564.wav", + "text": "所以看起來這裡是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/565.wav", + "text": "不太會造成阻礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/566.wav", + "text": "老實說就要設限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/567.wav", + "text": "你們一直說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/568.wav", + "text": "我們已經講了很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/569.wav", + "text": "很多個月很多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/570.wav", + "text": "請拿出來給我們看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/571.wav", + "text": "你告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/572.wav", + "text": "你過去核定礦權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/573.wav", + "text": "我就說以亞泥為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/574.wav", + "text": "才三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/575.wav", + "text": "哪有窒礙難行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/576.wav", + "text": "那你告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/577.wav", + "text": "你們以前窒礙難行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/578.wav", + "text": "每次要搞好幾年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/579.wav", + "text": "礦權核定請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/580.wav", + "text": "請你拿出來給我們看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/581.wav", + "text": "你們都拿不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/582.wav", + "text": "所以今天在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/583.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/584.wav", + "text": "因為你們怠惰不拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/585.wav", + "text": "我們真的沒有辦法信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/586.wav", + "text": "老實說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/587.wav", + "text": "最後再回來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/588.wav", + "text": "同一個系列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/589.wav", + "text": "請礦務局先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/590.wav", + "text": "其實委員所關心的就是設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/591.wav", + "text": "需不需要取得原住民諮商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/592.wav", + "text": "我們在拜訪的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/593.wav", + "text": "委員都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/594.wav", + "text": "申請礦業用地的時候才要啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/595.wav", + "text": "都是同樣的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/596.wav", + "text": "同意院版的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/597.wav", + "text": "十七條我們有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/598.wav", + "text": "我們當然肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/599.wav", + "text": "願意把經濟效益評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/600.wav", + "text": "納入修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/601.wav", + "text": "但是綜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/602.wav", + "text": "綜觀行政院版的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/603.wav", + "text": "在第十七條第二十條條文的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/604.wav", + "text": "都牽涉到經濟效益評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/605.wav", + "text": "但是在立法說明裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/606.wav", + "text": "卻沒有相應的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/607.wav", + "text": "有關這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/608.wav", + "text": "到底是要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/609.wav", + "text": "要如何來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/610.wav", + "text": "相較之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/611.wav", + "text": "時力黨團第十五條的立法說明中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/612.wav", + "text": "對於申請開採量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/613.wav", + "text": "及礦場環境維護計畫等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/614.wav", + "text": "有比較詳細的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/615.wav", + "text": "還有在立法說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/616.wav", + "text": "破壞或降低環境或生態功能之損失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/617.wav", + "text": "及其復育所需費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/618.wav", + "text": "對土地所有權人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/619.wav", + "text": "與利害關係人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/620.wav", + "text": "以及當地居民所造成的損失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/621.wav", + "text": "我有提到礦業權之展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/622.wav", + "text": "之賦予為行政法院的見解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/623.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡所羅列出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/624.wav", + "text": "或最高行政法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/625.wav", + "text": "對於礦業權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/626.wav", + "text": "你們應該要將這些標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/627.wav", + "text": "經審查認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/628.wav", + "text": "礦場經營價值低於成本或不相當者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/629.wav", + "text": "主管機關應駁回採礦權設定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/630.wav", + "text": "或展限之申請或廢止採礦權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/631.wav", + "text": "造成不必要之環境破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/632.wav", + "text": "及對人民權益產生負面影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/633.wav", + "text": "\n林淑芬委員及賴瑞隆召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/634.wav", + "text": "在第十七條的立法說明中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/635.wav", + "text": "其實跟時力黨團一樣也有明確的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/636.wav", + "text": "對於經濟效益評估到底要評估什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/637.wav", + "text": "以及效益高低的判準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/638.wav", + "text": "我們希望經濟部能夠將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/639.wav", + "text": "第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/640.wav", + "text": "即第一項採礦權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/641.wav", + "text": "位於原住民族土地者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/642.wav", + "text": "主管機關應先徵詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/643.wav", + "text": "礦區所在之原住民族同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/644.wav", + "text": "其徵詢及其他相關事項之辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/645.wav", + "text": "由主管機關會同中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/646.wav", + "text": "原住民族主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/647.wav", + "text": "一定要納入的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/648.wav", + "text": "在原住民族地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/649.wav", + "text": "大家都有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/650.wav", + "text": "只有針對環境敏感地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/651.wav", + "text": "及國家公園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/652.wav", + "text": "我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/653.wav", + "text": "除了環境敏感地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/654.wav", + "text": "及國家公園之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/655.wav", + "text": "經濟效益評估認定不應開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/656.wav", + "text": "及設定礦業權有妨害公益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/657.wav", + "text": "個部分行政院版本都沒有列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/658.wav", + "text": "入\n在此我非常堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/659.wav", + "text": "要照原住民族基本法的相關規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/660.wav", + "text": "有列入說明就好但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/661.wav", + "text": "我看說明中也是寫得不清不楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/662.wav", + "text": "還有第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/663.wav", + "text": "第31條等一下會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/664.wav", + "text": "\n第21條的部分請礦務局說明第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/665.wav", + "text": "21條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/666.wav", + "text": "分委員關心的是申請人申請增減其所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/667.wav", + "text": "申請區域之面積要有學者來共同審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/668.wav", + "text": "我們在立法說明的部分已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/669.wav", + "text": "就礦業申請人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/670.wav", + "text": "增減其所申請區域之面積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/671.wav", + "text": "主管機關仍得依第31條第3項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/672.wav", + "text": "邀請專家學者參與審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/673.wav", + "text": "在立法說明中有很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/674.wav", + "text": "各位委員請問是否就納入立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/675.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是要放在條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/676.wav", + "text": "第21條有關礦區面積之增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/677.wav", + "text": "是由你們主管機關核定就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/678.wav", + "text": "你們在說明欄裡寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/679.wav", + "text": "邀請地方政府專家及學者共同審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/680.wav", + "text": "那麼為什麼不直接列入條文呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/681.wav", + "text": "這邊再跟委員補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/682.wav", + "text": "第21條指的是礦業申請人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/683.wav", + "text": "這個就是他還在申請設權的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/684.wav", + "text": "這個不是已經核准的礦區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/685.wav", + "text": "而礦業申請案本來在第31條就有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/686.wav", + "text": "來共同審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/687.wav", + "text": "所以第21條指的是礦業申請案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/688.wav", + "text": "我們在說明欄再做一個增強的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/689.wav", + "text": "就好這不是一個已經核定礦區的增減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/690.wav", + "text": "以上補充謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/691.wav", + "text": "好謝謝孔委員可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/692.wav", + "text": "我們就照這樣來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/693.wav", + "text": "礦業區面積的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/694.wav", + "text": "不能照礦業權者他們的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/695.wav", + "text": "他們要什麼就做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/696.wav", + "text": "比如說在南澳鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/697.wav", + "text": "要參與專家跟學者也來共同審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/698.wav", + "text": "好謝謝第21條就先保留\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/699.wav", + "text": "處理第31條跟第33條請礦務局說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/700.wav", + "text": "第31條主要有幾個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/701.wav", + "text": "第一個委員關心的就是說明會程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/702.wav", + "text": "要增加回覆辦理情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/703.wav", + "text": "在跟委員報告說明的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/704.wav", + "text": "委員原則上同意行政院版條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/705.wav", + "text": "另外我們有一個配套子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/706.wav", + "text": "會授權在配套的子法裡面做規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/707.wav", + "text": "第二個委員關心的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/708.wav", + "text": "核准時要通知土地及地上物所有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/709.wav", + "text": "這部分跟委員報告說明的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/710.wav", + "text": "他同意行政院版本的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/711.wav", + "text": "另外一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/712.wav", + "text": "第三個委員特別關心的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/713.wav", + "text": "原住民地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/714.wav", + "text": "要另外與原民會會商訂定說明會程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/715.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們在立法說明第15頁裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/716.wav", + "text": "特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/717.wav", + "text": "的紅字部分該辦法涉及原住民族事務部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/718.wav", + "text": "由主管機關會商中央原住民族事務主管機關定之\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/719.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/720.wav", + "text": "主席這個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/721.wav", + "text": "你們現在公告在鄉公所可是沒有人去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/722.wav", + "text": "你只有刊登公開展覽書圖文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/723.wav", + "text": "很多村民都不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/724.wav", + "text": "如果我們要走原住民族基本法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/725.wav", + "text": "是不是依本席的最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/726.wav", + "text": "由主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/727.wav", + "text": "於原住民族地區者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/728.wav", + "text": "由主管機關會同中央原住民族事務主管機關定之因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/729.wav", + "text": "這個資訊一定要公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/730.wav", + "text": "你只有貼在公告欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/731.wav", + "text": "沒人去看呀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/732.wav", + "text": "呀原住民又非常被動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/733.wav", + "text": "不可能去看公告欄嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/734.wav", + "text": "你要召開說明會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/735.wav", + "text": "我覺得他們什麼都放在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/736.wav", + "text": "什麼都做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/737.wav", + "text": "還不如放在條文就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/738.wav", + "text": "後續如果涉及到原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/739.wav", + "text": "這個內容寫了以後一定要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/740.wav", + "text": "這個沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/741.wav", + "text": "訂定相關辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/742.wav", + "text": "時也會跟原民會會銜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/743.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/744.wav", + "text": "就列入條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/745.wav", + "text": "最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/746.wav", + "text": "不要放在說明欄好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/747.wav", + "text": "不一定都在原住民地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/748.wav", + "text": "有的會有的不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/749.wav", + "text": "如果涉及到原住民地區的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/750.wav", + "text": "我們一定會去會商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/751.wav", + "text": "中央原住民族事務主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/752.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/753.wav", + "text": "部長你看看我這個條文的最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/754.wav", + "text": "於原住民族地區者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/755.wav", + "text": "由主管機關會同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/756.wav", + "text": "中央原住民族事務主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/757.wav", + "text": "之規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/758.wav", + "text": "先保留吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/759.wav", + "text": "好第31條先保留第3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/760.wav", + "text": "可以嗎第33" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/761.wav", + "text": "第33條我們是不是就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/762.wav", + "text": "院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/763.wav", + "text": "好謝謝所以第31條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/764.wav", + "text": "第33條照院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/765.wav", + "text": "有關事實上我們把所有的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/766.wav", + "text": "都放在第47條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/767.wav", + "text": "都要提出關礦計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/768.wav", + "text": "我們也跟委員討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/769.wav", + "text": "了第34條因為這些都涉及關礦計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/770.wav", + "text": "所以委員也同意在第47條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/771.wav", + "text": "來呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/772.wav", + "text": "這是我們在討論協商第34條時所提到的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/773.wav", + "text": "第35條也是類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/774.wav", + "text": "第35條也是有關關礦計畫我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/775.wav", + "text": "我跟委員討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/776.wav", + "text": "委員也表示同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/777.wav", + "text": "因為它裡面有兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/778.wav", + "text": "礦業權展限的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/779.wav", + "text": "及國土計畫主管機關的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/780.wav", + "text": "礦業用地的申請過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/781.wav", + "text": "這個條文都寫得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/782.wav", + "text": "\n第47條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/783.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以直接跳到第第47" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/784.wav", + "text": "整個說明完我們再一併第4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/785.wav", + "text": "第47條就是在講關礦計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/786.wav", + "text": "我們也同意在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/787.wav", + "text": "裡去補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/788.wav", + "text": "我們也特別準備一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/789.wav", + "text": "比立法說明更深入的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/790.wav", + "text": "因為這裡的說明只講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/791.wav", + "text": "有關勞工權益的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/792.wav", + "text": "比如剛剛委員特別關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/793.wav", + "text": "最終高程水保開採總量等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/794.wav", + "text": "我們在第47條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/795.wav", + "text": "另外一份新的立法說明裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/796.wav", + "text": "有再做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/797.wav", + "text": "我們等一下會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/798.wav", + "text": "還沒有我們等一下會發給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/799.wav", + "text": "請發送給委員們好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/800.wav", + "text": "第47條的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/801.wav", + "text": "時力黨團也是肯定礦務局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/802.wav", + "text": "將礦場的關閉計畫納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/803.wav", + "text": "應檢具的文件裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/804.wav", + "text": "但是還是希望你們在審核礦場關閉計畫的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/805.wav", + "text": "務必積極檢視對於關閉工廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/806.wav", + "text": "協助勞工轉型的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/807.wav", + "text": "\n第35條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/808.wav", + "text": "原核定礦業用地是否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/809.wav", + "text": "需要重新徵得環保主管機關及國土計畫主管機關的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/810.wav", + "text": "要要求重新踐行原住民族基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/811.wav", + "text": "我們認為時力黨團版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/812.wav", + "text": "因為目前好像沒有針對這樣子來做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/813.wav", + "text": "所以時力黨團認為要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/814.wav", + "text": "其他委員有沒有要提問\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/815.wav", + "text": "這個法修了這麼久的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/816.wav", + "text": "限要做什麼樣子的把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/817.wav", + "text": "我希望等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/818.wav", + "text": "經濟部礦務局還是應該要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/819.wav", + "text": "因為過去大家是用時間這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/820.wav", + "text": "但現在如果有另外的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/821.wav", + "text": "我知道你們來跟委員們談的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/822.wav", + "text": "是希望接下來用所謂的總量跟最終高程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/823.wav", + "text": "如果到了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/824.wav", + "text": "會再開啟一個重新把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/825.wav", + "text": "這部分我覺得還是要請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/826.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/827.wav", + "text": "你們剛發下來的這份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/828.wav", + "text": "你們還是把這部分寫在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/829.wav", + "text": "說明的第八點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/830.wav", + "text": "但是我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/831.wav", + "text": "如果真的要用總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/832.wav", + "text": "跟最終高程做為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/833.wav", + "text": "包括程序要再重新啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/834.wav", + "text": "不管是環評也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/835.wav", + "text": "如果它是一個檢核點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/836.wav", + "text": "我認為還是應該要把它放到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/837.wav", + "text": "母法的條文中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/838.wav", + "text": "一個非常核心的關鍵邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/839.wav", + "text": "這個關鍵邏輯應該放在母法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/840.wav", + "text": "而不應該只是放在說明欄裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/841.wav", + "text": "大家討論一下後都非常有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/842.wav", + "text": "修正的第8點說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/843.wav", + "text": "是我們大家都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/844.wav", + "text": "不過我還是要再說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/845.wav", + "text": "因為邱顯智委員可能不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/846.wav", + "text": "可以馬上理解我們的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/847.wav", + "text": "是一個新權利的賦予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/848.wav", + "text": "就要重新再跑一次行政流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/849.wav", + "text": "但是經過這麼久的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/850.wav", + "text": "我們大概可以同意一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/851.wav", + "text": "就是我們不要爭執在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/852.wav", + "text": "新舊權利的爭點上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/853.wav", + "text": "我們就好好來談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/854.wav", + "text": "因為採礦直接就在山林裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/855.wav", + "text": "我們不再藉著新權利賦予的時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/856.wav", + "text": "那我們還有什麼辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/857.wav", + "text": "這是退而求其次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/858.wav", + "text": "我們大家認為勉強可以接受\n那麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/859.wav", + "text": "對環境的把關機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/860.wav", + "text": "都是舊礦要做一次性環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/861.wav", + "text": "在這次的一次性補做環評中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/862.wav", + "text": "也是會把關到水土保持相關議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/863.wav", + "text": "包括環境影響說明書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/864.wav", + "text": "開採施工計畫圖等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/865.wav", + "text": "這些在審查時就會匡列到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/866.wav", + "text": "只要這一次環評通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/867.wav", + "text": "那一個礦業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/868.wav", + "text": "就終止了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/869.wav", + "text": "所以你一定要去申請新的礦業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/870.wav", + "text": "可是你申請新的礦業用地時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/871.wav", + "text": "就要再一次環評如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/872.wav", + "text": "賦予的實質內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/873.wav", + "text": "只是形式上不是綁在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/874.wav", + "text": "礦業權展限時去把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/875.wav", + "text": "而是在礦業用地權利終止時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/876.wav", + "text": "再重新去把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/877.wav", + "text": "第47條用的文字是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/878.wav", + "text": "因為第1項裡面講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/879.wav", + "text": "必須要把使用面積告訴你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/880.wav", + "text": "所以��前大家吵架就是吵在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/881.wav", + "text": "因為採礦的面積是沒有在變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/882.wav", + "text": "的他是往下挖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/883.wav", + "text": "所以是開採水平在變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/884.wav", + "text": "面積都不變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/885.wav", + "text": "你們現在也不講面積了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/886.wav", + "text": "或採取總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/887.wav", + "text": "核定時的最終高程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/888.wav", + "text": "和採取總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/889.wav", + "text": "就講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/890.wav", + "text": "而不是只是立法說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/891.wav", + "text": "在第1項放了這樣的文字的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/892.wav", + "text": "環評法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/893.wav", + "text": "程最低水平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/894.wav", + "text": "權利自然就會停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/895.wav", + "text": "終止於什麼條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/896.wav", + "text": "達到了就要重新開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/897.wav", + "text": "依據法律保留原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/898.wav", + "text": "讓法律清清楚楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/899.wav", + "text": "業者也清清楚楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/900.wav", + "text": "讓整個行政程序不用有糾葛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/901.wav", + "text": "不用訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/902.wav", + "text": "我覺得在法律裡面規定清楚是最好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/903.wav", + "text": "就是要規定清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/904.wav", + "text": "法律為什麼要規定清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/905.wav", + "text": "就是為了要避免在將來發生紛爭的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/906.wav", + "text": "各說各話沒辦法仲裁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/907.wav", + "text": "所以在這個規範上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/908.wav", + "text": "其實你的說明欄第八點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/909.wav", + "text": "針對礦業用地的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/910.wav", + "text": "核定之後的水土保持計畫環境影響說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/911.wav", + "text": "書等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/912.wav", + "text": "這個應該是要在條文裡面去規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/913.wav", + "text": "這樣一來第一個才能夠很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/914.wav", + "text": "而且法律條文基本上才有規範的效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/915.wav", + "text": "所以這個其實也是一個非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/916.wav", + "text": "其實重點在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/917.wav", + "text": "重點在於你如果遲遲不去准駁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/918.wav", + "text": "因為它是一個新的許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/919.wav", + "text": "如果你遲遲不許可的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/920.wav", + "text": "請問主管機關能夠駁回申請嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/921.wav", + "text": "嘛他繼續挖了5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/922.wav", + "text": "申請等於是一個生米煮成熟飯的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/923.wav", + "text": "而且你怎麼去界定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/924.wav", + "text": "結果你到最後��了一個決定竟然是他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/925.wav", + "text": "他不應該繼續挖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/926.wav", + "text": "那你要怎麼樣去處理這個法律關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/927.wav", + "text": "其實在這個邏輯上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/928.wav", + "text": "或者是一個能夠讓你可以決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/929.wav", + "text": "已經是一個最低的標準了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/930.wav", + "text": "我相信你今天如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/931.wav", + "text": "就會產生一個結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/932.wav", + "text": "──你只能做一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/933.wav", + "text": "就是一定要准許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/934.wav", + "text": "這是大家所不樂見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/935.wav", + "text": "然後不管是院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/936.wav", + "text": "但是在展限這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/937.wav", + "text": "你沒有去設定一個期限的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/938.wav", + "text": "機關拖延到最後沒有其他路走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/939.wav", + "text": "只能一而再再而三地去展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/940.wav", + "text": "這是大家所不樂見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/941.wav", + "text": "這樣的良法美意到最後一定會落空的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/942.wav", + "text": "就是主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/943.wav", + "text": "應該會同有關機關協助礦業權人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/944.wav", + "text": "提出產業轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/945.wav", + "text": "環境復育及勞工安置計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/946.wav", + "text": "輔導處理後續處置事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/947.wav", + "text": "這一項沒有列到行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/948.wav", + "text": "如果要放在立法說明我也沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/949.wav", + "text": "第34條第35條第47條我們就先保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/950.wav", + "text": "也請經濟部再回去思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/951.wav", + "text": "第41條委員是關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/952.wav", + "text": "非法取得礦業權的撤銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/953.wav", + "text": "因為我們在條文裡面有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/954.wav", + "text": "利害關係人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/955.wav", + "text": "我們向委員報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/956.wav", + "text": "委員同意院版的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/957.wav", + "text": "好第41條我們是不是就照院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/958.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/959.wav", + "text": "\n處理第42條請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/960.wav", + "text": "第42條委員關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/961.wav", + "text": "的是在原住民地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/962.wav", + "text": "也有把它講得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/963.wav", + "text": "對於業者所提事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/964.wav", + "text": "事由涉原住民族事務者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/965.wav", + "text": "要求業者提出證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/966.wav", + "text": "倘有需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/967.wav", + "text": "時則洽地方或中央原住民族事務主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/968.wav", + "text": "我們在立法說明中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/969.wav", + "text": "明中已經有補充說明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/970.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/971.wav", + "text": "這個我絕對反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/972.wav", + "text": "第42條就是原住民的霸王條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/973.wav", + "text": "在原住民地區採礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/974.wav", + "text": "沒有開採實績但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/975.wav", + "text": "績但有正當理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/976.wav", + "text": "最後你們主管機關就核准了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/977.wav", + "text": "但有正當理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/978.wav", + "text": "這個但書情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/979.wav", + "text": "如果是位在原住民地區的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/980.wav", + "text": "主管機關應會商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/981.wav", + "text": "中央原住民族事務主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/982.wav", + "text": "共同來審議這個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/983.wav", + "text": "而不是由礦務局自己決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/984.wav", + "text": "那你們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/985.wav", + "text": "現在要放到立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/986.wav", + "text": "倘有需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/987.wav", + "text": "時則洽地方或中央原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/988.wav", + "text": "什麼叫倘有需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/989.wav", + "text": "每次都不需要每次都是你們礦務局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/990.wav", + "text": "自己核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/991.wav", + "text": "第42條我們先保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/992.wav", + "text": "我堅持一定要放在條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/993.wav", + "text": "條請礦務局說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/994.wav", + "text": "委員關心的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/995.wav", + "text": "有三個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/996.wav", + "text": "第一個是原住民的地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/997.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/998.wav", + "text": "委員同意依照行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/999.wav", + "text": "的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1000.wav", + "text": "要釐清諮商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1001.wav", + "text": "同意過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1002.wav", + "text": "需不需要停工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1003.wav", + "text": "我們跟委員特別說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1004.wav", + "text": "諮商過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1005.wav", + "text": "會不會停工其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1006.wav", + "text": "因為礦業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1007.wav", + "text": "還有存在所以還是繼續在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1008.wav", + "text": "生產如果諮商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1009.wav", + "text": "不同意以後才會有後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1010.wav", + "text": "的處理我想這部分我們跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1011.wav", + "text": "講得很清楚委員也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1012.wav", + "text": "院版的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1013.wav", + "text": "不同意的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1014.wav", + "text": "是不是應該重新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1015.wav", + "text": "申請諮商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1016.wav", + "text": "我想這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1017.wav", + "text": "我們一直都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1018.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告在原住民諮商裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1019.wav", + "text": "我們是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1020.wav", + "text": "原住民部落的主體性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1021.wav", + "text": "跟他們相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1022.wav", + "text": "整個過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1023.wav", + "text": "我們會在立法說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1024.wav", + "text": "如何辦理原住民諮商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1025.wav", + "text": "研提一個注意事項還有指導方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1026.wav", + "text": "這個指導方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1027.wav", + "text": "一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1028.wav", + "text": "會商原住民族主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1029.wav", + "text": "諮商以後同意的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1030.wav", + "text": "如果未來要核定礦業用地的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1031.wav", + "text": "同意事項列為處分的附款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1032.wav", + "text": "在補辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1033.wav", + "text": "原住民諮商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1034.wav", + "text": "也會在土地的承攬契約裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1035.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1036.wav", + "text": "要不要有時間事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1037.wav", + "text": "是要尊重部落的主體性跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1038.wav", + "text": "自主性以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1039.wav", + "text": "謝謝說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1040.wav", + "text": "因為我跟洪申翰委員共提的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1041.wav", + "text": "礦業權者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1042.wav", + "text": "應於礦業用地核定前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1043.wav", + "text": "依原住民族基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1044.wav", + "text": "第21條規定辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1045.wav", + "text": "並敘明同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1046.wav", + "text": "事項之效期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1047.wav", + "text": "這個部分其實經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1048.wav", + "text": "目前的草案跟說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1049.wav", + "text": "是用院版第48條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1050.wav", + "text": "第5條說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1051.wav", + "text": "的內容補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1052.wav", + "text": "尊重部落的自主權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1053.wav", + "text": "可由業者及部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1054.wav", + "text": "雙方合意來決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1055.wav", + "text": "諮商同意有效期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1056.wav", + "text": "等等未來核定礦業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1057.wav", + "text": "用地將會把諮商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1058.wav", + "text": "同意事項列為處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1059.wav", + "text": "附款具有對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1060.wav", + "text": "廠商的拘束效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1061.wav", + "text": "\n所以如果依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1062.wav", + "text": "現有的草案然後剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1063.wav", + "text": "條文提到有總量及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1064.wav", + "text": "高程的限制達到後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1065.wav", + "text": "則需重新辦理相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1066.wav", + "text": "環評及諮商同意程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1067.wav", + "text": "的前提下我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1068.wav", + "text": "非常可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1069.wav", + "text": "用指引來取代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1070.wav", + "text": "但是相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1071.wav", + "text": "的文字應該要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1072.wav", + "text": "讓部落跟廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1073.wav", + "text": "更清楚我們還是強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1074.wav", + "text": "如果沒有入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1075.wav", + "text": "會非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1076.wav", + "text": "應該要依據指引的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1077.wav", + "text": "訂定相關諮商同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1078.wav", + "text": "內容及承諾事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1079.wav", + "text": "不過我還是要再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1080.wav", + "text": "其實對於指引的出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1081.wav", + "text": "我們都非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1082.wav", + "text": "滿意只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1083.wav", + "text": "還是要把相關的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1084.wav", + "text": "這個美意會大打折扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1085.wav", + "text": "以上說明謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1086.wav", + "text": "48條其實也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1087.wav", + "text": "爭議的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1088.wav", + "text": "的期限就算它跟產線脫鉤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1089.wav", + "text": "有一個明確的期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1090.wav", + "text": "本文裡面但是後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1091.wav", + "text": "礦務局說他們接下來會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1092.wav", + "text": "訂定所謂的事項指引用這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1093.wav", + "text": "種方法來處理就像剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1094.wav", + "text": "現在也接受了用事項指引的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1095.wav", + "text": "但我自己是希望在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1096.wav", + "text": "母法的本文將事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1097.wav", + "text": "然後在說明欄裡面應該要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1098.wav", + "text": "應該包括的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1099.wav", + "text": "項目是同意期限礦產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1100.wav", + "text": "的開採面積高程總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1101.wav", + "text": "開採年限等等相關的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1102.wav", + "text": "應該要寫在說明欄裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1103.wav", + "text": "讓大家知道目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1104.wav", + "text": "是有義務要來訂定事項指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1105.wav", + "text": "而不是今天我們講完後你說會訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1106.wav", + "text": "定但之後可能就不訂定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1107.wav", + "text": "或者之後就不更新了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1108.wav", + "text": "本文中但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1109.wav", + "text": "事項指引應該包含哪些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1110.wav", + "text": "期限面積高程總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1111.wav", + "text": "年限等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1112.wav", + "text": "要放在說明欄裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1113.wav", + "text": "經濟部或目的事業主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1114.wav", + "text": "機關在規劃事項指引時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1115.wav", + "text": "至少要有的必要的元素是哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1116.wav", + "text": "即便是經濟部最新提出來的這一本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1117.wav", + "text": "48條第48條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1118.wav", + "text": "原住民權益的影響非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1119.wav", + "text": "並與原住民族地區非常有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1120.wav", + "text": "只有針對公有土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1121.wav", + "text": "而我的修正條文是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1122.wav", + "text": "原住民族地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1123.wav", + "text": "還有原住民族土地部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1124.wav", + "text": "周邊一定範圍內的公有土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1125.wav", + "text": "第二個第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1126.wav", + "text": "有牽涉到一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1127.wav", + "text": "經過部落諮商同意後被否決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1128.wav", + "text": "不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1129.wav", + "text": "但是卻沒有時間的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1130.wav", + "text": "又再召開部落會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1131.wav", + "text": "可能要規定清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1132.wav", + "text": "再行諮商部落同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1133.wav", + "text": "你不能說我這個月不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1134.wav", + "text": "是不是要有一個期限的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1135.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣恢復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1136.wav", + "text": "48條及第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1137.wav", + "text": "礦務局都說列入說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1138.wav", + "text": "所有原住民權益的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1139.wav", + "text": "你們全部列入說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1140.wav", + "text": "沒有一個是同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1141.wav", + "text": "48條及第5條我堅持也要放在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1142.wav", + "text": "請經濟部也回去就剛剛幾個委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1143.wav", + "text": "再思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1144.wav", + "text": "第53條請礦務局說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1145.wav", + "text": "第53條委員關心在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1146.wav", + "text": "的處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1147.wav", + "text": "地面改成土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1148.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們跟委員報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1149.wav", + "text": "各位第53條是不是就照院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1150.wav", + "text": "後60天要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1151.wav", + "text": "事實上我們跟委員報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1152.wav", + "text": "第一個調處時間是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1153.wav", + "text": "會到60天並不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1154.wav", + "text": "我們沒有這樣的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1155.wav", + "text": "所以特別跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1156.wav", + "text": "新租的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1157.wav", + "text": "如果沒有拿到土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1158.wav", + "text": "所有權人的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1159.wav", + "text": "他是無法用這個土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1160.wav", + "text": "如果續租土地時就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1161.wav", + "text": "就要按照契約的條款辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1162.wav", + "text": "而不是他想用或他不想用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1163.wav", + "text": "這個我們跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1164.wav", + "text": "照行政院的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1165.wav", + "text": "第55條參考一下我的版本好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1166.wav", + "text": "沒有講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1167.wav", + "text": "請看一下我的第55條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1168.wav", + "text": "有包括石油礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1169.wav", + "text": "和天然氣礦的礦業權者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1170.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1171.wav", + "text": "你們都沒講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1172.wav", + "text": "第55條是不是能夠保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1173.wav", + "text": "好第55條先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1174.wav", + "text": "\n再來是第62條請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1175.wav", + "text": "62條是礦產權利金委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1176.wav", + "text": "委員是關心權利金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1177.wav", + "text": "的用途之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1178.wav", + "text": "都沒有辦法從礦產權利金去支用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1179.wav", + "text": "執行礦場關閉所有的必要費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1180.wav", + "text": "並不是由主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1181.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們已跟委員做過說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1182.wav", + "text": "委員同意行政院所提的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1183.wav", + "text": "這個不同意啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1184.wav", + "text": "的礦產權利金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1185.wav", + "text": "是要從下而上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1186.wav", + "text": "不是由上而下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1187.wav", + "text": "──上面怎麼指定分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1188.wav", + "text": "你們就分配了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1189.wav", + "text": "拿多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1190.wav", + "text": "鄉公所拿多少然後部落能夠拿多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1191.wav", + "text": "我們會在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1192.wav", + "text": "回饋的內容回饋的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1193.wav", + "text": "程序及其他相關事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1194.wav", + "text": "在法條中去授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1195.wav", + "text": "子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1196.wav", + "text": "在我們的條文中會規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1197.wav", + "text": "之內容計算方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1198.wav", + "text": "等授權主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1199.wav", + "text": "已經有規定這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1200.wav", + "text": "我希望把它列入條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1201.wav", + "text": "礦區所在地之村里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1202.wav", + "text": ")不我們一個一個來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1203.wav", + "text": "目前在國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1204.wav", + "text": "會涉及到第62條的其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1205.wav", + "text": "中油公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1206.wav", + "text": "按照行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1207.wav", + "text": "關於第63條委員希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1208.wav", + "text": "把分配比率寫在母法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1209.wav", + "text": "這恐怕還要再跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1210.wav", + "text": "當地溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1211.wav", + "text": "分配比率不要寫在母法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1212.wav", + "text": "這一條先保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1213.wav", + "text": "因為這個是我們原住民長期的痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1214.wav", + "text": "縣政府在決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1215.wav", + "text": "好第63條我們就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1216.wav", + "text": "有提到這些簽證的技師是哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1217.wav", + "text": "補辦環評的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1218.wav", + "text": "我們跟委員報告說明的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1219.wav", + "text": "委員大概都對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1220.wav", + "text": "這個全面補辦環評的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1221.wav", + "text": "條文給予肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1222.wav", + "text": "都同意院版的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1223.wav", + "text": "也特別提醒我們像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1224.wav", + "text": "要補辦環評的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1225.wav", + "text": "是什麼時候停工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1226.wav", + "text": "等等對此我們在第47條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1227.wav", + "text": "納入環評的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1228.wav", + "text": "事實上在環評檢查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1229.wav", + "text": "都是在礦業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1230.wav", + "text": "有效的期間來做這些檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1231.wav", + "text": "而這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1232.wav", + "text": "提到即第64" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1233.wav", + "text": "頁的第十二點提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1234.wav", + "text": "礦業權者依第8項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1235.wav", + "text": "辦理環境影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1236.wav", + "text": "或核准之因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1237.wav", + "text": "對策之情形將由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1238.wav", + "text": "主管機關負責執行追蹤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1239.wav", + "text": "及現場監督管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1240.wav", + "text": "主管機關於辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1241.wav", + "text": "前揭追蹤及管理時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1242.wav", + "text": "將會同中央環境保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1243.wav", + "text": "主管機關訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1244.wav", + "text": "聯合檢查機制並參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1245.wav", + "text": "檢查以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1246.wav", + "text": "好請各位委員看一下增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1247.wav", + "text": "增列的第十二點立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1248.wav", + "text": "我們就照院版通過增列那個部分的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1249.wav", + "text": "的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1250.wav", + "text": "我們現在是把它放在礦業用地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1251.wav", + "text": "部分來做把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1252.wav", + "text": "所以我們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1253.wav", + "text": "或是開採總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1254.wav", + "text": "礦業用地權利終止與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1255.wav", + "text": "說書裡面的承諾或審查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1256.wav", + "text": "結論進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1257.wav", + "text": "100萬噸是不是已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1258.wav", + "text": "關於權利的終止與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1259.wav", + "text": "的精神所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1260.wav", + "text": "要符合的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1261.wav", + "text": "聯合稽查的機制也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1262.wav", + "text": "書的內容環境審查相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1263.wav", + "text": "文書的監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1264.wav", + "text": "你們不能各自做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1265.wav", + "text": "各自的上次我們抓到的那個礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1266.wav", + "text": "就是礦務局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1267.wav", + "text": "去檢查沒問題環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1268.wav", + "text": "去檢查也沒問題但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1269.wav", + "text": "事實上他們都已經開採過量了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1270.wav", + "text": "當時就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1271.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會說共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1272.wav", + "text": "的文字要入法一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1273.wav", + "text": "這樣你們才不會各自為政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1274.wav", + "text": "因為你們管礦業法人家是管環評法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1275.wav", + "text": "主管機關要做的並不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1276.wav", + "text": "把關環境機制包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1277.wav", + "text": "做這部分要不要也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1278.wav", + "text": "具體的寫上去這是第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1279.wav", + "text": "第一個要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1280.wav", + "text": "的另外一個是後續追蹤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1281.wav", + "text": "和查核計畫聯合檢查機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1282.wav", + "text": "應依環評法礦業法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1283.wav", + "text": "礦場安全法等相關法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1284.wav", + "text": "作適法之處置然後要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1285.wav", + "text": "類似這樣的機制是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1286.wav", + "text": "放到條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1287.wav", + "text": "何精簡請大家再思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1288.wav", + "text": "就是這樣子而已其實精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1289.wav", + "text": "都相通也有共識了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1290.wav", + "text": "但是沒有放到法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1291.wav", + "text": "裡面我們就覺得好像不安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1292.wav", + "text": "我想請問一下礦務局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1293.wav", + "text": "為什麼要把二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1294.wav", + "text": "二公頃刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1295.wav", + "text": "礦業用地少於二公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1296.wav", + "text": "但是它的產量卻超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1297.wav", + "text": "這部分是不是可以說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1298.wav", + "text": "為什麼要把二公頃拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1299.wav", + "text": "寬鬆的第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1300.wav", + "text": "如果後續開發計畫有變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1301.wav", + "text": "或是在長期開發後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1302.wav", + "text": "是很容易產生變化的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1303.wav", + "text": "的時間是長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1304.wav", + "text": "所以可預期環境確實會產生變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1305.wav", + "text": "出現變化且欠缺後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1306.wav", + "text": "追蹤監督及管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1307.wav", + "text": "以目前行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1308.wav", + "text": "業法來看似乎只打算在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1309.wav", + "text": "立法說明中納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1310.wav", + "text": "我們可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1311.wav", + "text": "把這些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1312.wav", + "text": "疑問卻是同樣存在的也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1313.wav", + "text": "這些狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1314.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1315.wav", + "text": "也要請部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1316.wav", + "text": "要揭露在哪裡怎麼揭露等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1317.wav", + "text": "大小礦因為大小礦都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1318.wav", + "text": "所以大小礦都應該進行環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1319.wav", + "text": "後續也應該有完善的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1320.wav", + "text": "揭露並且公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1321.wav", + "text": "利害關係人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1322.wav", + "text": "是一個微小的個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1323.wav", + "text": "請經濟部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1324.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1325.wav", + "text": "門檻主要是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1326.wav", + "text": "就已經核定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1327.wav", + "text": "並沒有環評法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1328.wav", + "text": "在84年環評法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1329.wav", + "text": "以上才需要做環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1330.wav", + "text": "其他人有無要補充的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1331.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1332.wav", + "text": "第77條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1333.wav", + "text": "要公告這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1334.wav", + "text": "違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1335.wav", + "text": "者的姓名名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1336.wav", + "text": "衡酌行為之嚴重情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1337.wav", + "text": "及影響程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1338.wav", + "text": "裁量是否公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1339.wav", + "text": "行為人之姓名名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1340.wav", + "text": "或違法事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1341.wav", + "text": "且需特別注意少年事件處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1342.wav", + "text": "之相關隱私保護法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1343.wav", + "text": "至於違法情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1344.wav", + "text": "可能就是很短期的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1345.wav", + "text": "盜採礦石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1346.wav", + "text": "這對生態的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1347.wav", + "text": "其實不是很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1348.wav", + "text": "已有提高罰金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1349.wav", + "text": "因此可否請委員支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1350.wav", + "text": "委員是否就照院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1351.wav", + "text": "好第77條及第78條照院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1352.wav", + "text": "用新法或舊法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1353.wav", + "text": "委員目前我們手上有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1354.wav", + "text": "駁我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1355.wav", + "text": "已經進來的適用舊法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1356.wav", + "text": "時間不超過五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1357.wav", + "text": "過渡完畢即適用新法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1358.wav", + "text": "為避免行政紛爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1359.wav", + "text": "確實會產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1360.wav", + "text": "行政訴訟的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1361.wav", + "text": "大家務實一點就勉強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1362.wav", + "text": "能承諾我們那就是資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1363.wav", + "text": "公開透明是很重要的把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1364.wav", + "text": "剛剛一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1365.wav", + "text": "是在礦業用地上而真正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1366.wav", + "text": "把關機制則是開採的總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1367.wav", + "text": "及水平高度因此這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1368.wav", + "text": "施工計畫書圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1369.wav", + "text": "年度施工計畫書圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1370.wav", + "text": "環評追蹤及礦場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1371.wav", + "text": "你們一直說這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1372.wav", + "text": "資訊透明與否其實和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1373.wav", + "text": "有時候地點是在山上你們也沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1374.wav", + "text": "每天去看但如果公開上網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1375.wav", + "text": "蓋一棟房子挖個地基都要做環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1376.wav", + "text": "山林裡直接挖掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1377.wav", + "text": "一起來監督如此在法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1378.wav", + "text": "需要這樣對環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1379.wav", + "text": "資訊公開透明並建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1380.wav", + "text": "委員發言完再一起說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1381.wav", + "text": "希望能有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1382.wav", + "text": "妥適的平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1383.wav", + "text": "76條的說明在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1384.wav", + "text": "在剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1385.wav", + "text": "包括主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1386.wav", + "text": "事業主管機關中央環保主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1387.wav", + "text": "法第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1388.wav", + "text": "但環調報告依目前的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1389.wav", + "text": "好像沒有公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1390.wav", + "text": "調查報告是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1391.wav", + "text": "立法說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1392.wav", + "text": "增加文字規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1393.wav", + "text": "後續的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1394.wav", + "text": "報告可以上網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1395.wav", + "text": "就是在你們的紅字部分看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1396.wav", + "text": "要怎麼把這些文字加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1397.wav", + "text": "今天全程參與審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1398.wav", + "text": "我們在經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1399.wav", + "text": "原住民族基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1400.wav", + "text": "後來原住民族基本法的部分你們全部放在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1401.wav", + "text": "沒有一個是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1402.wav", + "text": "條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1403.wav", + "text": "不尊重原住民權益的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1404.wav", + "text": "還是在護航這些財團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1405.wav", + "text": "原民會的條文──原住民族基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1406.wav", + "text": "全部放在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1407.wav", + "text": "有些條文特別是第42條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1408.wav", + "text": "拜託你們一定要放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1409.wav", + "text": "不是視為同意就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1410.wav", + "text": "現在很多礦的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1411.wav", + "text": "並沒有採礦的實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1412.wav", + "text": "就可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1413.wav", + "text": "全部都放在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1414.wav", + "text": "沒有一個是放在條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1415.wav", + "text": "中所以我剛剛堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1416.wav", + "text": "的前面幾條就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1417.wav", + "text": "但是後面那幾條我堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1418.wav", + "text": "請經濟部回去考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1419.wav", + "text": "是不是把它放在條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1420.wav", + "text": "等於也跟放在條文沒什麼兩樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1421.wav", + "text": "好這個再請經濟部評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1422.wav", + "text": "用附帶決議的方式也請��濟部再思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1423.wav", + "text": "提出附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1424.wav", + "text": "請他們針對我剛剛的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1425.wav", + "text": "說明是不是可以把文字放在說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1426.wav", + "text": "我們會再調整看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1427.wav", + "text": "看看要怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1428.wav", + "text": "也不一定要放在這一條可能有好幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1429.wav", + "text": "所以我們再調整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1430.wav", + "text": "這個再請經濟部回去整體整理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1431.wav", + "text": "42條的部分我們再看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1432.wav", + "text": "剛剛林委員特別講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1433.wav", + "text": "第91條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1434.wav", + "text": "事實上我們的相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1435.wav", + "text": "配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1436.wav", + "text": "公開建置一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1437.wav", + "text": "個資訊透明的網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1438.wav", + "text": "子法會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1439.wav", + "text": "已經有在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1440.wav", + "text": "這麼久的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1441.wav", + "text": "礦業用地如果是正常開採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1442.wav", + "text": "可以開採22年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1443.wav", + "text": "可是你的礦業權只給它20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1444.wav", + "text": "那它就要申請展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1445.wav", + "text": "可是它如果申請展限的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1446.wav", + "text": "來做環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1447.wav", + "text": "這二年讓它再多挖一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1448.wav", + "text": "對業者可能會有利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1449.wav", + "text": "啦我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1450.wav", + "text": "作弊的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1451.wav", + "text": "礦業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1452.wav", + "text": "所以這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1453.wav", + "text": "礦業用地跟礦權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1454.wav", + "text": "的期限不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1455.wav", + "text": "會有這種作弊的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1456.wav", + "text": "你的決定等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1457.wav", + "text": "如果是5年之後再准駁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1458.wav", + "text": "駁讓大家上下其手的空間太大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1459.wav", + "text": "機關不可能像法院審判一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1460.wav", + "text": "是公開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1461.wav", + "text": "你在准駁的過程中把它pending" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1462.wav", + "text": "5年然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1463.wav", + "text": "在這5年的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1464.wav", + "text": "所以不可能一個行政處分的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1465.wav", + "text": "是這樣的而且這個是展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1466.wav", + "text": "展限是什麼意思展限就是本來已經有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1467.wav", + "text": "原處分了它的���成要件事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1468.wav", + "text": "是很確定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1469.wav", + "text": "本來已經有一個行政處分後來要再繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1470.wav", + "text": "展限的話你們應該可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1471.wav", + "text": "很便利的去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1472.wav", + "text": "怎麼會像你今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1473.wav", + "text": "告訴大家的你要去展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1474.wav", + "text": "一個處分但它事先一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1475.wav", + "text": "二年已經申請了如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1476.wav", + "text": "按照我們的版本在一年之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1477.wav", + "text": "這樣加起來已經3年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1478.wav", + "text": "你說連著二三年的時間都沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1479.wav", + "text": "做出一個決定以致於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1480.wav", + "text": "沒辦法去訂一個展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1481.wav", + "text": "的期間這是不合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1482.wav", + "text": "你這個時間是一個沒有限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1483.wav", + "text": "期間的你可能5年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1484.wav", + "text": "再做決定甚至10年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1485.wav", + "text": "再做決定都可以你覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1486.wav", + "text": "這是在一個法治國家應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1487.wav", + "text": "有的情形嗎這是不合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1488.wav", + "text": "嘛\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1489.wav", + "text": "一個不確定性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1490.wav", + "text": "搞不好人家到最後根本就不用再去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1491.wav", + "text": "展限了這中間有很多上下其手的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1492.wav", + "text": "而我要講的第二個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1493.wav", + "text": "你到最後根本沒有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1494.wav", + "text": "拒絕他的空間生米煮成熟飯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1495.wav", + "text": "了它又繼續挖了5年10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1496.wav", + "text": "如果到最後的結果是認為它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1497.wav", + "text": "它不應該得到這個展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1498.wav", + "text": "請問他在這5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1499.wav", + "text": "10年之間繼續挖的行為對臺灣的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1500.wav", + "text": "對臺灣水土保持的破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1501.wav", + "text": "這個要找誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1502.wav", + "text": "來追究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1503.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1504.wav", + "text": "我覺得一年的展限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1505.wav", + "text": "限期間如果不行的話就全部都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1506.wav", + "text": "已經二三年已經綽綽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1507.wav", + "text": "綽綽有餘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1508.wav", + "text": "我還是要再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1509.wav", + "text": "環保署說明一下這個環調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1510.wav", + "text": "報告到底有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1511.wav", + "text": "公開於環保署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1512.wav", + "text": "上去是最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1513.wav", + "text": "第76條這邊一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1514.wav", + "text": "這個環調報告是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1515.wav", + "text": "要上網的我再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1516.wav", + "text": "一次環保署是否也可以說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1517.wav", + "text": "不管是準用第5條或準用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1518.wav", + "text": "受理的環評書件我們一律都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1519.wav", + "text": "上網公開也都有公開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1520.wav", + "text": "會議民眾也可以都有所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1521.wav", + "text": "都有以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1522.wav", + "text": "有要再說明嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1523.wav", + "text": "\n另外有些委員的提案或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1524.wav", + "text": "在溝通過後是建議不予增訂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1525.wav", + "text": "是業者的事以及地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1526.wav", + "text": "政府的事所以我們跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1527.wav", + "text": "委員報告後委員同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1528.wav", + "text": "等民眾黨黨團時代力量黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1529.wav", + "text": "第68頁也是同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1530.wav", + "text": "不增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1531.wav", + "text": "你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1532.wav", + "text": "有溝通過委員同意不增列的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1533.wav", + "text": "就說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1534.wav", + "text": "第66頁也是不增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1535.wav", + "text": "請委員看一下第66頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1536.wav", + "text": "委員林淑芬等20人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1537.wav", + "text": "提案第77條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1538.wav", + "text": "等17人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1539.wav", + "text": "7條這些都是講違規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1540.wav", + "text": "採礦場址之整復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1541.wav", + "text": "我們跟委員報告以後他們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1542.wav", + "text": "不增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1543.wav", + "text": "直接講結論就好了其他部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1544.wav", + "text": "也請一併說明第6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1545.wav", + "text": "也是同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1546.wav", + "text": "不增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1547.wav", + "text": "第81條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1548.wav", + "text": "同意院版條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1549.wav", + "text": "第72頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1550.wav", + "text": "同意行政院條文不增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1551.wav", + "text": "也同意院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1552.wav", + "text": "條文刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1553.wav", + "text": "的第74條同意院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1554.wav", + "text": "條文刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1555.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1556.wav", + "text": "檢舉獎勵的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1557.wav", + "text": "院版條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1558.wav", + "text": "不增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1559.wav", + "text": "公益訴訟部分我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1560.wav", + "text": "認為不應該增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1561.wav", + "text": "鄰接礦區界線平均分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1562.wav", + "text": "條文刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1563.wav", + "text": "因為跟第74條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1564.wav", + "text": "連動而保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1565.wav", + "text": "留即地下礦場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1566.wav", + "text": "同意院版條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1567.wav", + "text": "同意行政院版條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1568.wav", + "text": "有關新舊法這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1569.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1570.wav", + "text": "並自核准展限日起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1571.wav", + "text": "不得超過5年之規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1572.wav", + "text": "本部建議以附帶決議方式辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1573.wav", + "text": "第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1574.wav", + "text": "一樣同意行政院的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1575.wav", + "text": "不增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1576.wav", + "text": "第93條也是同意行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1577.wav", + "text": "條文不增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1578.wav", + "text": "第94條也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1579.wav", + "text": "同意行政院的條文不增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1580.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1581.wav", + "text": "請議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1582.wav", + "text": "剛剛那幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1583.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第79條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1584.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團提案第63條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1585.wav", + "text": "之3委員賴瑞隆等1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1586.wav", + "text": "17人提案第79條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1587.wav", + "text": "條文均不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1588.wav", + "text": "委員林淑芬等人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1589.wav", + "text": "第83條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1590.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第83條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1591.wav", + "text": "委員陳瑩等人提案第72條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1592.wav", + "text": "之1委員賴瑞隆等人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1593.wav", + "text": "提案第83條條文均不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1594.wav", + "text": "提案第84條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1595.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第84條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1596.wav", + "text": "委員孔文吉等人提案第82條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1597.wav", + "text": "委員賴瑞隆等人提案第84條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1598.wav", + "text": "委員蘇治芬等人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1599.wav", + "text": "第82條條文均同意行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1600.wav", + "text": "提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1601.wav", + "text": "本案予以刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1602.wav", + "text": "委員林淑芬等20人提案第85條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1603.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第85條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1604.wav", + "text": "委員孔文吉等人提案第83條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1605.wav", + "text": "委員賴瑞隆等人提案第85條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1606.wav", + "text": "委員蘇治芬等人提案第83條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1607.wav", + "text": "條文均同意行政院提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1608.wav", + "text": "本案予以刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1609.wav", + "text": "委員賴瑞隆等17人提案第86條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1610.wav", + "text": "照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1611.wav", + "text": "委員林淑芬等20人提案第87條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1612.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第87條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1613.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團提案第74條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1614.wav", + "text": "委員賴瑞隆等人提案第87條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1615.wav", + "text": "同意照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1616.wav", + "text": "委員林淑芬等20人提案第88條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1617.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第88條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1618.wav", + "text": "委員賴瑞隆等17人提案第88條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1619.wav", + "text": "條文均同意行政院提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1620.wav", + "text": "本案予以刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1621.wav", + "text": "委員林淑芬等20人提案第91條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1622.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第91條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1623.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團提案第77條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1624.wav", + "text": "委員賴瑞隆等人提案第91條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1625.wav", + "text": "委員洪申翰等20人提案第77條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1626.wav", + "text": "之一條文均不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1627.wav", + "text": "改提案以附帶決議處理本案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1628.wav", + "text": "委員林淑芬等20人提案第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1629.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1630.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團提案第77條之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1631.wav", + "text": "委員賴瑞隆等人提案第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1632.wav", + "text": "條文均不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1633.wav", + "text": "委員林淑芬等20人提案第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1634.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1635.wav", + "text": "委員賴瑞隆等17人提案第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1636.wav", + "text": "條文均不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1637.wav", + "text": "委員林淑芬等20人提案第94條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1638.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第94條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1639.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團提案第77條之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1640.wav", + "text": "委員賴瑞隆等人提案第94條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1641.wav", + "text": "更正委員林淑芬等20人提案第86條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1642.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第86條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1643.wav", + "text": "委員賴瑞隆等17人提案第86條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1644.wav", + "text": "均不予增訂委員林淑芬等20人提案第87條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1645.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提案第87條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1646.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團提案第74條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1647.wav", + "text": "委員賴瑞隆等人提案第87條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1648.wav", + "text": "條黨團及委員所提增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1649.wav", + "text": "訂其餘均照委員會審查報告通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1650.wav", + "text": "在院長協商前能夠和各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1651.wav", + "text": "好我們就照剛才宣讀的文字通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1652.wav", + "text": "也請經濟部持續協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1653.wav", + "text": "我們希望在院長協商前能夠有更好的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1654.wav", + "text": "需要整理的相關文字也請經濟部持續整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1655.wav", + "text": "\n謝謝各位大家辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14922/1656.wav", + "text": "我們希望這個會期能夠順利完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/0.wav", + "text": "行政院主計總處朱澤民先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1.wav", + "text": "提案黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/2.wav", + "text": "負責人正常會期是到5月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/3.wav", + "text": "至於會不會延會臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/4.wav", + "text": "那是再議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/5.wav", + "text": "但至少在5月底以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/6.wav", + "text": "我們有一些法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/7.wav", + "text": "和預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/8.wav", + "text": "該處理的就應該處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/9.wav", + "text": "游院長召集協商第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/10.wav", + "text": "是對於國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/11.wav", + "text": "營業的都已經出委員會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/12.wav", + "text": "所以可以開始來安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/13.wav", + "text": "處理有關於國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/14.wav", + "text": "今天是開始大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/15.wav", + "text": "我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/16.wav", + "text": "經過協商以後爭點不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/17.wav", + "text": "什麼時候提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/18.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/19.wav", + "text": "\n第二點有關道交條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/20.wav", + "text": "總共有70個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/21.wav", + "text": "後來大家一直加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/22.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/23.wav", + "text": "現在加到73個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/24.wav", + "text": "只有保留6個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/25.wav", + "text": "交通部覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/26.wav", + "text": "有3個條文可能要再微調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/27.wav", + "text": "這6個條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/28.wav", + "text": "違規記點的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/29.wav", + "text": "所以一起保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/30.wav", + "text": "而已經通過但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/31.wav", + "text": "還要再調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/32.wav", + "text": "的有3個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/33.wav", + "text": "大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/34.wav", + "text": "交通安全的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/35.wav", + "text": "是大家所關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/36.wav", + "text": "也到了應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/37.wav", + "text": "要處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/38.wav", + "text": "上個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/39.wav", + "text": "和這個會期都一直在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/40.wav", + "text": "召委劉世芳委員很負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/41.wav", + "text": "經出委員會且召集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/42.wav", + "text": "就是有關於道交條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/43.wav", + "text": "憲法訴訟從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/44.wav", + "text": "大法官審理案件法改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/45.wav", + "text": "憲法訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/46.wav", + "text": ")年1月已經開始了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/47.wav", + "text": "憲判1號2號3號一直出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/48.wav", + "text": "當初立法說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/49.wav", + "text": "明沒有很周延的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/50.wav", + "text": "要再做一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/51.wav", + "text": "必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/52.wav", + "text": "協商的條文大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/53.wav", + "text": "有5條左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/54.wav", + "text": "今天就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/55.wav", + "text": "從國營事業預算開始談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/56.wav", + "text": "法案我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/57.wav", + "text": "國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/58.wav", + "text": "的部分今天談的應該是比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/59.wav", + "text": "程序性的對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/60.wav", + "text": "剛開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/61.wav", + "text": "對如果談好就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/62.wav", + "text": "有關營業及非營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/63.wav", + "text": "基金部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/64.wav", + "text": "我先請教現在還有多少提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/65.wav", + "text": "12案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/66.wav", + "text": "所以到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/67.wav", + "text": "會有一個時程出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/68.wav", + "text": "大家可能還會提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/69.wav", + "text": "下會期大家忙得要死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/70.wav", + "text": "下會期有公務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/71.wav", + "text": "選舉又到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/72.wav", + "text": "所以時程上我贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/73.wav", + "text": "大方向我支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/74.wav", + "text": "版本這麼多你怎麼協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/75.wav", + "text": "其實版本很多都雷同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/76.wav", + "text": "抄來抄去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/77.wav", + "text": "好等一下要談嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/78.wav", + "text": "另外有關憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/79.wav", + "text": "訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/80.wav", + "text": "我們立法院都很尊重司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/81.wav", + "text": "我們都很尊重他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/82.wav", + "text": "們但是你看現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/83.wav", + "text": "這樣提出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/84.wav", + "text": "而且還經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/85.wav", + "text": "會銜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/86.wav", + "text": "又來改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/87.wav", + "text": "司法院這樣的修法品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/88.wav", + "text": "我不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/89.wav", + "text": "尤其今天我不要討論憲法訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/90.wav", + "text": "今天不要沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/91.wav", + "text": "但是這個有實務上一定要修的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/92.wav", + "text": "對啊那先道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/93.wav", + "text": "不不是道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/94.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/95.wav", + "text": "大費周章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/96.wav", + "text": "實施幾個月就說窒礙難行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/97.wav", + "text": "你不要幫他解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/98.wav", + "text": "最高的司法機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/99.wav", + "text": "修法的東西出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/100.wav", + "text": "出來幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/101.wav", + "text": "卻說裡面有窒礙難行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/102.wav", + "text": "條都不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/103.wav", + "text": "他們的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/104.wav", + "text": "今天一定不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/105.wav", + "text": "再說吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/106.wav", + "text": "們搞了半天上會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/107.wav", + "text": "結果實施沒多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/108.wav", + "text": "還有那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/109.wav", + "text": "那是上一屆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/110.wav", + "text": "國民法官法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/111.wav", + "text": "現在個位數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/112.wav", + "text": "憲法訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/113.wav", + "text": "實施也沒多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/114.wav", + "text": "就說有很多條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/115.wav", + "text": "窒礙難行開什麼玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/116.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/117.wav", + "text": "哪個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/118.wav", + "text": "是開什麼玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/119.wav", + "text": "我跟你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/120.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/121.wav", + "text": "還有各黨黨團黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/122.wav", + "text": "最重要還是處理112年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/123.wav", + "text": "中央政府總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/124.wav", + "text": "營業非營業的相關進度跟時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/125.wav", + "text": "可以說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/126.wav", + "text": "預算第二輪的提案跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/127.wav", + "text": "速審所以具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/128.wav", + "text": "應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/129.wav", + "text": "以前正式完成營業非營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/130.wav", + "text": "預算的三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/131.wav", + "text": "剛剛聽到委員會保留的提案大概還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/132.wav", + "text": "12案所以接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/133.wav", + "text": "應該要進行朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/134.wav", + "text": "後續的這些提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/135.wav", + "text": "爾後中央政府總預算案營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/136.wav", + "text": "及非營業部分的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/137.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨還是要建請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/138.wav", + "text": "應該採預算法中針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/139.wav", + "text": "預算審查時程的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/140.wav", + "text": "配合實務處理流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/141.wav", + "text": "各黨團協商審查日程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/142.wav", + "text": "雖仍無法與公務預算同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/143.wav", + "text": "三讀通過但最起碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/144.wav", + "text": "要能夠在預算執行的當年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/145.wav", + "text": "及早完成三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/146.wav", + "text": "尤其我們民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/147.wav", + "text": "雖然贊成速審這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/148.wav", + "text": "112年度中央政府總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/149.wav", + "text": "審查的品質也不能低落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/150.wav", + "text": "在立法院第10屆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/151.wav", + "text": "最後一年尤其下個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/152.wav", + "text": "地方區域選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/153.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望相關期程能夠往前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/154.wav", + "text": "拉我們也會拿出我們認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/155.wav", + "text": "負責監督施政的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/156.wav", + "text": "民意\n在接下來第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/157.wav", + "text": "輪的預算提案朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/158.wav", + "text": "協商以及表決的流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/159.wav", + "text": "我想在速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/160.wav", + "text": "之下希望今天可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/161.wav", + "text": "可以確定相關期程我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/162.wav", + "text": "希望三讀的時間是在5月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/163.wav", + "text": "也希望今天能夠達到具體共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/164.wav", + "text": "花在刀口上這是我們基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/165.wav", + "text": "態度謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/166.wav", + "text": "接下來請游委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/167.wav", + "text": "院長還有在座的各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/168.wav", + "text": "曾總召所主張針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/169.wav", + "text": "對司法院部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/170.wav", + "text": "不管是國民法官法或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/171.wav", + "text": "憲法法庭訴訟法部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/172.wav", + "text": "他的見解基本上我個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/173.wav", + "text": "是贊成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/174.wav", + "text": "我們在司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/175.wav", + "text": "針對司法院所提出的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/176.wav", + "text": "我們都儘量配合但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/177.wav", + "text": "顯然他們在一開始的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/178.wav", + "text": "按照他們應該要有的期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/179.wav", + "text": "立法院在這部分應該表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/180.wav", + "text": "一點立場不要讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/181.wav", + "text": "朝令夕改一樣尤其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/182.wav", + "text": "司法是國家非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/183.wav", + "text": "我是贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/184.wav", + "text": "席主張今天無論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/185.wav", + "text": "如何要針對道交條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/186.wav", + "text": "的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/187.wav", + "text": "會期可是劉世芳召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/188.wav", + "text": "非常認真而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/189.wav", + "text": "委員也提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/190.wav", + "text": "不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/191.wav", + "text": "條和第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/192.wav", + "text": "主持協商而我們私下也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/193.wav", + "text": "進行了很多次討論尤其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/194.wav", + "text": "或行政院都已經把改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/195.wav", + "text": "交通安全列為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/196.wav", + "text": "有效防制酒後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/197.wav", + "text": "駕車行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/198.wav", + "text": "行為對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/199.wav", + "text": "無照駕駛或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/200.wav", + "text": "惡意逼車等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/201.wav", + "text": "不當駕駛違規行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/202.wav", + "text": "的管理以及最重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/203.wav", + "text": "先進國家交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/204.wav", + "text": "違規記點制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/205.wav", + "text": "我覺得今天無論如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/206.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/207.wav", + "text": "好謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/208.wav", + "text": "中央政府112年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/209.wav", + "text": "總預算案附屬單位預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/210.wav", + "text": "時代力量這邊也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/211.wav", + "text": "會期結束前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/212.wav", + "text": "於應該什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/213.wav", + "text": "力量的立場當然是越快越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/214.wav", + "text": "畢竟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/215.wav", + "text": "我們不希望再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/216.wav", + "text": "這已經是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/217.wav", + "text": "人民笑話的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/218.wav", + "text": "所以當然是越快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/219.wav", + "text": "可以在4月底前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/220.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/221.wav", + "text": "道路交通管理處罰條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/222.wav", + "text": "交通安全事故其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/223.wav", + "text": "比去年還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/224.wav", + "text": "在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/225.wav", + "text": "安全的部分其實和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/226.wav", + "text": "會期已經出委員會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/227.wav", + "text": "只有5個條文我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/228.wav", + "text": "透過政黨協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/229.wav", + "text": "第三個部分有關憲法訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/230.wav", + "text": "法部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/231.wav", + "text": "條文的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/232.wav", + "text": "各政黨要盡責地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/233.wav", + "text": "針對法案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/234.wav", + "text": "還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/235.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/236.wav", + "text": "剛才各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/237.wav", + "text": "最後共識當然是國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/238.wav", + "text": "愈快愈好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/239.wav", + "text": "這是共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/240.wav", + "text": "一定要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/241.wav", + "text": "大概是一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/242.wav", + "text": "這是有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/243.wav", + "text": "游毓蘭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/244.wav", + "text": "是不多6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/245.wav", + "text": "道交條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/246.wav", + "text": "\n至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/247.wav", + "text": "憲法訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/248.wav", + "text": "的部分坦白講是上一屆修的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/249.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/250.wav", + "text": "111年1月1日開始改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/251.wav", + "text": "憲判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/252.wav", + "text": "憲法法庭憲判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/253.wav", + "text": "一直出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/254.wav", + "text": "上一屆修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/255.wav", + "text": "時代力量也有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/256.wav", + "text": "國民黨鄭天財委員也有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/257.wav", + "text": "都有一些看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/258.wav", + "text": "要調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/259.wav", + "text": "調整絕對是必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/260.wav", + "text": "我們希望大家理性來面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/261.wav", + "text": "看院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/262.wav", + "text": "走下去再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/263.wav", + "text": "假設願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/264.wav", + "text": "討論道交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/265.wav", + "text": "但是憲法法庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/266.wav", + "text": "你們也有人提版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/267.wav", + "text": "但是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/268.wav", + "text": "這個不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/269.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/270.wav", + "text": "這個上個會期就可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/271.wav", + "text": "沒關係那你們表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/272.wav", + "text": "今天一定不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/273.wav", + "text": "但是還是要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/274.wav", + "text": "沒關係啊你去表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/275.wav", + "text": "太早了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/276.wav", + "text": "下禮拜三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/277.wav", + "text": "一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/278.wav", + "text": "要到19日就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/279.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/280.wav", + "text": "下午5點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/281.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/282.wav", + "text": "呢這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/283.wav", + "text": "然後雙向溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/284.wav", + "text": "雙向溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/285.wav", + "text": "我贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/286.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/287.wav", + "text": "沒有因為各部會都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/288.wav", + "text": "耶兩天一定不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/289.wav", + "text": "我也主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/290.wav", + "text": "好好審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/291.wav", + "text": "溝通一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/292.wav", + "text": "是一個禮拜內收件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/293.wav", + "text": "就溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/294.wav", + "text": "後26日開始密集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/295.wav", + "text": "這樣可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/296.wav", + "text": "確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/297.wav", + "text": "4月開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/298.wav", + "text": "密集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/299.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/300.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/301.wav", + "text": "主計長就請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/302.wav", + "text": "沒有講到話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/303.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/304.wav", + "text": "在協商之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/305.wav", + "text": "部會要來跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/306.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/307.wav", + "text": "委員在辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/308.wav", + "text": "我沒碰過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/309.wav", + "text": "啊外交部連個司長都不來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/310.wav", + "text": "怎麼會沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/311.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/312.wav", + "text": "共和國總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/313.wav", + "text": "他他對我們很友好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/314.wav", + "text": "總統要來這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/315.wav", + "text": "對方有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/316.wav", + "text": "他和議長都要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/317.wav", + "text": "由總統來演講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/318.wav", + "text": "叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/319.wav", + "text": "他要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/320.wav", + "text": "想來我們這裡演講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/321.wav", + "text": "馬拉總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/322.wav", + "text": "��是我是回來尊重各黨的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/323.wav", + "text": "演講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/324.wav", + "text": "現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/325.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/326.wav", + "text": "確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/327.wav", + "text": "這張先簽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/328.wav", + "text": "我先唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/329.wav", + "text": "決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/330.wav", + "text": "一請各黨團於4月19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/331.wav", + "text": "(星期三)下午5時前將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/332.wav", + "text": "112年度中央政府總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/333.wav", + "text": "附屬單位預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/334.wav", + "text": "營業及非營業部分之提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/335.wav", + "text": "交各該委員會整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/336.wav", + "text": "付印相關提案後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/337.wav", + "text": "於4月21日(星期五)下午5時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/338.wav", + "text": "提供各黨團及相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/339.wav", + "text": "行政部門參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/340.wav", + "text": "請行政部門先行向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/341.wav", + "text": "提案委員及黨團進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/342.wav", + "text": "雙向說明落實溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/343.wav", + "text": "以利4月26日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/344.wav", + "text": "(星期三)進行密集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/345.wav", + "text": "\n三各黨團同意4月25日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/346.wav", + "text": "邀請瓜地馬拉共和國總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/347.wav", + "text": "賈麥岱閣下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/348.wav", + "text": "請本院委員踴躍參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/349.wav", + "text": "當日上午除進行議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/350.wav", + "text": "所列事項外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/351.wav", + "text": "相關國賓演講儀程作業事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/352.wav", + "text": "授權秘書長依規定辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/353.wav", + "text": "當次會議不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/354.wav", + "text": "臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/355.wav", + "text": "這個先簽現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/356.wav", + "text": "開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/357.wav", + "text": "案先介紹交通部王國材部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/358.wav", + "text": "部長路政司林福山司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/359.wav", + "text": "討論交通部建議的修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/360.wav", + "text": "我都尊重大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/361.wav", + "text": "總共12條12條剛剛不是講3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/362.wav", + "text": "這是不是全部都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/363.wav", + "text": "哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/364.wav", + "text": "剛剛不是講說只有3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/365.wav", + "text": "總共條文27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/366.wav", + "text": "出委員會以後有6條是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/367.wav", + "text": "6條裡面大部分都是要記點的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/368.wav", + "text": "然後還有3條必須要調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/369.wav", + "text": "所以應該是9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/370.wav", + "text": "有12條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/371.wav", + "text": "請交通部看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/372.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀有增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/373.wav", + "text": "不一樣的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/374.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛聽起來有保留條文幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/375.wav", + "text": "但是我們之前黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/376.wav", + "text": "都是從第7條之1開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/377.wav", + "text": "所以是不是請交通部報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/378.wav", + "text": "到底所謂保留條文是哪幾條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/379.wav", + "text": "逐條開始進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/380.wav", + "text": "還是這在委員會裡面已經不予討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/381.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/382.wav", + "text": "有關道路交通管理處罰條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/383.wav", + "text": "上一個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/384.wav", + "text": "還有大家一直很重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/385.wav", + "text": "就是未禮讓行人的罰則提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/386.wav", + "text": "原來我們有46項民眾檢舉項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/387.wav", + "text": "在這一次第7條之1裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/388.wav", + "text": "有委員提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/389.wav", + "text": "我們也接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/390.wav", + "text": "協商的時候是保留6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/391.wav", + "text": "現在協商有再增加6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/392.wav", + "text": "3條是跟我們行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/393.wav", + "text": "審查通過的版本一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/394.wav", + "text": "我先講一下重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/395.wav", + "text": "第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/396.wav", + "text": "關於民眾檢舉項目的增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/397.wav", + "text": "這一次大概總共增加10項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/398.wav", + "text": "46項希望變成56項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/399.wav", + "text": "我們表示尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/400.wav", + "text": "其中有很多就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/401.wav", + "text": "不注意來往行人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/402.wav", + "text": "轉彎沒有減速慢行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/403.wav", + "text": "這是第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/404.wav", + "text": "不要在處罰條例裡面規定要訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/405.wav", + "text": "定幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/406.wav", + "text": "而是訂定一個range" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/407.wav", + "text": "這個range在下面相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/408.wav", + "text": "裁罰細則裡面再去訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/409.wav", + "text": "我們就不用在每次對於執法的重點有改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/410.wav", + "text": "做一個很大的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/411.wav", + "text": "但是委員可以透過提案方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/412.wav", + "text": "要求我們在執行細則裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/413.wav", + "text": "包括過去的一些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/414.wav", + "text": "也大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/415.wav", + "text": "但是民眾已經等了一個會期所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/416.wav", + "text": "以麻煩各位委員支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/417.wav", + "text": "總共有12條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/418.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/419.wav", + "text": "包括羅致政委員以及民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/420.wav", + "text": "是因為上次在交通委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/421.wav", + "text": "有漏掉本來是不予修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/422.wav", + "text": "但是為了要配合講習的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/423.wav", + "text": "習的部分把它刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/424.wav", + "text": "所以我們再提出來做一個確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/425.wav", + "text": "因此總共有12條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/426.wav", + "text": "\n誠如剛剛部長所報告的關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/427.wav", + "text": "於第7條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/428.wav", + "text": "這次羅致政委員及民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/429.wav", + "text": "6項原則上都是有關於保護行人的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/430.wav", + "text": "全部都把它吸納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/431.wav", + "text": "含在交通委員會審查通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/432.wav", + "text": "第三個部分就是剛剛部長所報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/433.wav", + "text": "的當時保留6條出交通委員會保留的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/434.wav", + "text": "之所以這次提出協商確認的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/435.wav", + "text": "總共有12條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/436.wav", + "text": "其實大家都已經有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/437.wav", + "text": "條之1開始好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/438.wav", + "text": "行政院版本是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/439.wav", + "text": "所以並沒有那麼多條從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/440.wav", + "text": "7條之1時力黨團有提出一個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/441.wav", + "text": "我不知道交通部看了沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/442.wav", + "text": "第7款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/443.wav", + "text": "為避免有心民眾利用救護車開道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/444.wav", + "text": "尾隨在勤務中急駛中的救護車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/445.wav", + "text": "為了避免尾隨的車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/446.wav", + "text": "所以我們把第45條第1項第十一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/447.wav", + "text": "第7條之1的第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/448.wav", + "text": "現在有很多地下式消防栓同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/449.wav", + "text": "同時考量消防車的車長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/450.wav", + "text": "納入禁止臨時停車之可檢舉項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/451.wav", + "text": "在第7條之1第1項第十三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/452.wav", + "text": "再把第五十六條第1項第三款加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/453.wav", + "text": "增加這兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/454.wav", + "text": "為了讓整個安全性增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/455.wav", + "text": "應該是沒有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/456.wav", + "text": "的也請大家支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/457.wav", + "text": "要開放還可以再加入新的項目的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/458.wav", + "text": "因為本席一開始提案的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/459.wav", + "text": "其實有幾項是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/460.wav", + "text": "比如說在高速公路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/461.wav", + "text": "快速道路上違規的開放檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/462.wav", + "text": "或者是在橋樑隧道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/463.wav", + "text": "圓環行人穿越道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/464.wav", + "text": "快車道對臨時停車或停車的開放檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/465.wav", + "text": "這些都是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/466.wav", + "text": "的可是當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/467.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該把它加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/468.wav", + "text": "現在都有放在裡面是委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/469.wav", + "text": "員提的4項都放進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/470.wav", + "text": "我提的4項都有放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/471.wav", + "text": "我想我們的修法方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/472.wav", + "text": "跟剛才陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/473.wav", + "text": "我相信剛剛交通部已經同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/474.wav", + "text": "開放到高速公路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/475.wav", + "text": "快速道路或設站管制之道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/476.wav", + "text": "這大概是確定的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/477.wav", + "text": "第二個應該是涉及到我們講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/478.wav", + "text": "就是行人穿越的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/479.wav", + "text": "對一些部分的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/480.wav", + "text": "也要有所調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/481.wav", + "text": "所以我們又提了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/482.wav", + "text": "行經行人穿越道不暫停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/483.wav", + "text": "讓行人及攜帶白手杖或導盲犬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/484.wav", + "text": "視覺功能障礙者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/485.wav", + "text": "也可以列為檢舉的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/486.wav", + "text": "做一個正確及明確的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/487.wav", + "text": "讓第7條之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/488.wav", + "text": "之1的綜合性修法可以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/489.wav", + "text": "你們都想辦法把它納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/490.wav", + "text": "所以你們提一個交通部的建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/491.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/492.wav", + "text": "跟院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/493.wav", + "text": "建議條文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/494.wav", + "text": "及葉毓蘭委員的那部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/495.wav", + "text": "都已經放進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/496.wav", + "text": "因為是今天提出來的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/497.wav", + "text": "原則上我們認為應該可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/498.wav", + "text": "因為時力黨團提出增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/499.wav", + "text": "於這兩個行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/500.wav", + "text": "我們修正文字後再來提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/501.wav", + "text": "依照交通部建議條文修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/502.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/503.wav", + "text": "那時力的部分呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/504.wav", + "text": "處理下一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/505.wav", + "text": "依照本來交通部建議的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/506.wav", + "text": "修正第8款及第十五款再修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/507.wav", + "text": "同意要把版本調好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/508.wav", + "text": "這要不要調過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/509.wav", + "text": "要吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/510.wav", + "text": "時力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/511.wav", + "text": "交通部會有新的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/512.wav", + "text": "處理第21條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/513.wav", + "text": "這是逕付二讀案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/514.wav", + "text": "陳秀寳等18人的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/515.wav", + "text": "陳秀寳委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/516.wav", + "text": "在我們的條文已經有吸納進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/517.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/518.wav", + "text": "是不予處理還是照你們的建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/519.wav", + "text": "就依照陳秀寳委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/520.wav", + "text": "跟審查會通過的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/521.wav", + "text": "依照審查會通過的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/522.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/523.wav", + "text": "依照審查會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/524.wav", + "text": "的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/525.wav", + "text": "\n處理第三案的第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/526.wav", + "text": "這是審查會保留的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/527.wav", + "text": "是不是說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/528.wav", + "text": "是不是已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/529.wav", + "text": "交通部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/530.wav", + "text": "在第二次和劉世芳委員協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/531.wav", + "text": "大家都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/532.wav", + "text": "好按照審查會的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/533.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/534.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/535.wav", + "text": "\n請看到第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/536.wav", + "text": "第39頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/537.wav", + "text": "只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/538.wav", + "text": "還有一個小意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/539.wav", + "text": "再拿來確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/540.wav", + "text": "漏掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/541.wav", + "text": "配合第24條原來講習辦法的適用條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/542.wav", + "text": "定原來第31條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/543.wav", + "text": "規定單獨留六歲孩童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/544.wav", + "text": "所以建議依照行政院版的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/545.wav", + "text": "他很客氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/546.wav", + "text": "\n依照行政院版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/547.wav", + "text": "文字有���有調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/548.wav", + "text": "文字有沒有調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/549.wav", + "text": "沒有就按照行政院版的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/550.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/551.wav", + "text": "第35條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/552.wav", + "text": "原來行政院版本是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/553.wav", + "text": "對於第7項跟第9項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/554.wav", + "text": "這個部分在交委會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/555.wav", + "text": "也有通過所以建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/556.wav", + "text": "依照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/557.wav", + "text": "跟魯明哲委員的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/558.wav", + "text": "你說哪一個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/559.wav", + "text": "明哲委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/560.wav", + "text": "依照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/561.wav", + "text": "及魯明哲委員所提建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/562.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/563.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/564.wav", + "text": "第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/565.wav", + "text": "原來是逕付二讀案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/566.wav", + "text": "44條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/567.wav", + "text": "因為逕付二讀陳秀寳委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/568.wav", + "text": "提案已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/569.wav", + "text": "已經在審查通過的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/570.wav", + "text": "已經納入了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/571.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/572.wav", + "text": "不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/573.wav", + "text": "不予處理是吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/574.wav", + "text": "依照審查會通過的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/575.wav", + "text": "就已經納入了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/576.wav", + "text": "照審查會通過的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/577.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/578.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/579.wav", + "text": "一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/580.wav", + "text": "也是按照審查會通過的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/581.wav", + "text": "陳秀寳委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/582.wav", + "text": "已經有納入了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/583.wav", + "text": "所以也依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/584.wav", + "text": "照審查會通過的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/585.wav", + "text": "處理第63條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/586.wav", + "text": "違規記點授權在裁罰細則要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/587.wav", + "text": "命令去處理就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/588.wav", + "text": "椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/589.wav", + "text": "時力黨團針對記點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/590.wav", + "text": "還是希望能夠保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/591.wav", + "text": "法律保留的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/592.wav", + "text": "其實我自己去參酌了世界各國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/593.wav", + "text": "比較先進國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/594.wav", + "text": "也符合法律保留原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/595.wav", + "text": "我還是很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/596.wav", + "text": "今天能把這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/597.wav", + "text": "做個定論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/598.wav", + "text": "不要讓國人殷殷期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/599.wav", + "text": "一直保留保留保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/600.wav", + "text": "而沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/601.wav", + "text": "劉世芳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/602.wav", + "text": "我們在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/603.wav", + "text": "修正的時候已經討論過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/604.wav", + "text": "游毓蘭委員提到的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/605.wav", + "text": "我能夠認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/606.wav", + "text": "如果把違規點數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/607.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/608.wav", + "text": "在第一線執法的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/609.wav", + "text": "會覺得綁手綁腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/610.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/611.wav", + "text": "其他的交通事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/612.wav", + "text": "我們又要再回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/613.wav", + "text": "一定會造成很大困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/614.wav", + "text": "可能已經距離現在3年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/615.wav", + "text": "是不是可以從這樣的觀點來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/616.wav", + "text": "給予第一線執法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/617.wav", + "text": "者尤其是交警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/618.wav", + "text": "目前為止很少有人說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/619.wav", + "text": "交通警察在違規記點的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/620.wav", + "text": "產生很多跟民眾的爭執" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/621.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/622.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/623.wav", + "text": "也就是說我們不要在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/624.wav", + "text": "道交條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/625.wav", + "text": "定得非常非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/626.wav", + "text": "而是授權給授權給交通部跟內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/627.wav", + "text": "沒有有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/628.wav", + "text": "現在我們罰款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/629.wav", + "text": "也是這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/630.wav", + "text": "要不然會很怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/631.wav", + "text": "整部會寫得太細王" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/632.wav", + "text": "王委員剛才有舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/633.wav", + "text": "會造成修法困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/634.wav", + "text": "光是在之前的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/635.wav", + "text": "四次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/636.wav", + "text": "是非常需要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/637.wav", + "text": "而且也希望這個修法效率非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/638.wav", + "text": "我相信立法院的各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/639.wav", + "text": "所以我們看到在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/640.wav", + "text": "以及點數的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/641.wav", + "text": "因為空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/642.wav", + "text": "無疑就表示立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/643.wav", + "text": "的立法委員們直接放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/644.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/645.wav", + "text": "才是一個比較完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/646.wav", + "text": "好那就保留一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/647.wav", + "text": "嘛堅持嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/648.wav", + "text": "\n第63條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/649.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/650.wav", + "text": "跟違規記點有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/651.wav", + "text": "但這兩條次其實跟違規記點無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/652.wav", + "text": "它是汽車的違規紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/653.wav", + "text": "所以建議第63條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/654.wav", + "text": "跟第63條之2都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/655.wav", + "text": "按照行政院版的條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/656.wav", + "text": "它跟違規記點無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/657.wav", + "text": "好\n請王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/658.wav", + "text": "我們要特別提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/659.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/660.wav", + "text": "在第63條之1的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/661.wav", + "text": "行政院原本的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/662.wav", + "text": "是希望三個月內達兩次後就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/663.wav", + "text": "吊銷其牌照一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/664.wav", + "text": "而時代力量黨團版本是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/665.wav", + "text": "希望一年內達三次以上者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/666.wav", + "text": "吊扣牌照的部分達兩個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/667.wav", + "text": "為什麼說改為一年之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/668.wav", + "text": "紀錄達三次者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/669.wav", + "text": "原因是我們看到原本的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/670.wav", + "text": "是三個月內達三次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/671.wav", + "text": "但我們看到的往往是可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/672.wav", + "text": "他只要再規避一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/673.wav", + "text": "在一個月內小心謹慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/674.wav", + "text": "這麼嚴重的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/675.wav", + "text": "每個道路使用者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/676.wav", + "text": "都應該要謹言慎行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/677.wav", + "text": "就是時間拉長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/678.wav", + "text": "讓他們在這段期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/679.wav", + "text": "這樣才有辦法整體提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/680.wav", + "text": "我國臺灣的交通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/681.wav", + "text": "大家支持時代力量黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/682.wav", + "text": "依照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/683.wav", + "text": "你們是不同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/684.wav", + "text": "支持時代力量黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/685.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/686.wav", + "text": "那就保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/687.wav", + "text": "啦好這兩��都保留第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/688.wav", + "text": "交通部好請交通部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/689.wav", + "text": "1是在講三個月內吊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/690.wav", + "text": "是處罰條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/691.wav", + "text": "條之2是要處理處罰駕駛人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/692.wav", + "text": "找不到真正駕駛人的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/693.wav", + "text": "我們要回過頭來處罰車主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/694.wav", + "text": "但是車主沒有駕駛執照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/695.wav", + "text": "我想整個條例的處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/696.wav", + "text": "部分不能只看單條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/697.wav", + "text": "要講求一個比較衡平的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/698.wav", + "text": "所以當時在行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/699.wav", + "text": "達三次就吊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/700.wav", + "text": "吊扣牌照一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/701.wav", + "text": "就是針對另外一種處罰不到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/702.wav", + "text": "狀況但若有汽車就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/703.wav", + "text": "回過頭來處罰汽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/704.wav", + "text": "所以希望依照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/705.wav", + "text": "時力有沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/706.wav", + "text": "司長我可不可以問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/707.wav", + "text": "每三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/708.wav", + "text": "還是一年當中的三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/709.wav", + "text": "一年中有前面三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/710.wav", + "text": "後面九個月就亂做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/711.wav", + "text": "但是據我瞭解不是這個算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/712.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/713.wav", + "text": "是每三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/714.wav", + "text": "對啊完全沒有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/715.wav", + "text": "應該是按照交通部所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/716.wav", + "text": "你們完全沒有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/717.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/718.wav", + "text": "一年當中反而會讓他有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/719.wav", + "text": "偷雞摸狗之嫌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/720.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得按照交通部的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/721.wav", + "text": "其實就是按照他累積的次數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/722.wav", + "text": "數往前推三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/723.wav", + "text": "只要符合我就扣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/724.wav", + "text": "不是一月到三月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/725.wav", + "text": "是每三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/726.wav", + "text": "數學的算法是這樣算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/727.wav", + "text": "好是不是尊重交通部的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/728.wav", + "text": "都暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/729.wav", + "text": "第66條是陳秀寳委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/730.wav", + "text": "這個部分原則上審查會的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/731.wav", + "text": "都已經吸納進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/732.wav", + "text": "處理第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/733.wav", + "text": "第92條的部分是跟記點一起的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/734.wav", + "text": "所以第63條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/735.wav", + "text": "第92條就必須要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/736.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/737.wav", + "text": "不好意思我再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/738.wav", + "text": "回頭問一下第35條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/739.wav", + "text": "比如說警察不能夠對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/740.wav", + "text": "哪一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/741.wav", + "text": "第35條強制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/742.wav", + "text": "游委員你說哪一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/743.wav", + "text": "我就是想要知道一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/744.wav", + "text": "因為對於交通警察來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/745.wav", + "text": "就是讓他們到醫療機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/746.wav", + "text": "去強制抽血的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/747.wav", + "text": "我們還是很希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/748.wav", + "text": "有一些法律的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/749.wav", + "text": "否則動輒得咎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/750.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/751.wav", + "text": "這個部分我大概做個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/752.wav", + "text": "需要訂定得更完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/753.wav", + "text": "這部分也承蒙劉世" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/754.wav", + "text": "劉世芳委員之前有提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/755.wav", + "text": "在司法院院及法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/756.wav", + "text": "因為憲判字第1號判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/757.wav", + "text": "在去年2月25日發布之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/758.wav", + "text": "在這兩年裡要怎麼去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/759.wav", + "text": "所以現行警察執法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/760.wav", + "text": "都完全按照那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/761.wav", + "text": "我們必須要在明年2月25日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/762.wav", + "text": "日再提出一個修正版本出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/763.wav", + "text": "這個部分會再跟司法院還有法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/764.wav", + "text": "酒後肇事沒辦法當場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/765.wav", + "text": "在落日之前我們會有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/766.wav", + "text": "一個抽血一個驗尿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/767.wav", + "text": "比較急的先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/768.wav", + "text": "我們再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/769.wav", + "text": "這個部分要司法院法務部還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/770.wav", + "text": "警政署都要有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/771.wav", + "text": "我希望能夠看到行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/772.wav", + "text": "院版進來我們再來處理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/773.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/774.wav", + "text": "第86條民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/775.wav", + "text": "有關於第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/776.wav", + "text": "86條修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/777.wav", + "text": "汽車駕駛人有下列情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/778.wav", + "text": "致人受傷或死亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/779.wav", + "text": "這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/780.wav", + "text": "有提第6款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/781.wav", + "text": "行車速度超過規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/782.wav", + "text": "最高時速60公里以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/783.wav", + "text": "是否能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/784.wav", + "text": "86條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/785.wav", + "text": "有這個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/786.wav", + "text": "造成受傷或死亡者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/787.wav", + "text": "者應該加重處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/788.wav", + "text": "請教柯總召第6款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/789.wav", + "text": "行車速度超過規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/790.wav", + "text": "之最高時速40公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/791.wav", + "text": "以上是指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/792.wav", + "text": "指比如說限速100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/793.wav", + "text": "危險駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/794.wav", + "text": "定危險駕駛原來是超過時速60公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/795.wav", + "text": "已經下修到40" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/796.wav", + "text": "所以黨團這次提案版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/797.wav", + "text": "是更嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/798.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/799.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/800.wav", + "text": "你要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/801.wav", + "text": "我們有兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/802.wav", + "text": "這一條沒有問題我要等下一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/803.wav", + "text": "因為被跳過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/804.wav", + "text": "第86條沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/805.wav", + "text": "好第86條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/806.wav", + "text": "就照民進黨黨團提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/807.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/808.wav", + "text": "這是同一案剛剛只有處理我們修正動議第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/809.wav", + "text": "第22條和第93" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/810.wav", + "text": "同一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/811.wav", + "text": "不能只處理一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/812.wav", + "text": "整份修正動議一起處理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/813.wav", + "text": "最後一頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/814.wav", + "text": "最後兩案是連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/815.wav", + "text": "22條主要是在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/816.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠直接使用機車在這樣的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/817.wav", + "text": "其實大部分都有一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/818.wav", + "text": "跟行駛機車的注意事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/819.wav", + "text": "和道路規則可能不盡相同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/820.wav", + "text": "所以這部分其實應該加以調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/821.wav", + "text": "實施前取得的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/822.wav", + "text": "我們認為這是一個不合理的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/823.wav", + "text": "之前已經取得汽車駕照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/824.wav", + "text": "且能夠行駛機車的部分也應該有個落日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/825.wav", + "text": "原條文然後由第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/826.wav", + "text": "來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/827.wav", + "text": "希望能夠用一個落日期限讓它逐步處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/828.wav", + "text": "主要還是希望能夠落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/829.wav", + "text": "汽車駕照者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/830.wav", + "text": "第22條跟第93條是配在一起的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/831.wav", + "text": "是以往取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/832.wav", + "text": "汽車駕駛執照是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/833.wav", + "text": "騎輕型機車就是50cc以下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/834.wav", + "text": "委員會討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/835.wav", + "text": "從這次修正條文之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/836.wav", + "text": "先取得汽車駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/837.wav", + "text": "執照的就不能再去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/838.wav", + "text": "騎輕型機車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/839.wav", + "text": "但可能有些人都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/840.wav", + "text": "這部分修正完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/841.wav", + "text": "包括以前騎車很多年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/842.wav", + "text": "也統統不能再騎了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/843.wav", + "text": "所以當時交委會也審查通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/844.wav", + "text": "修正規定要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/845.wav", + "text": "是建議不要溯及既往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/846.wav", + "text": "而且這個部分在交通委員會也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/847.wav", + "text": "曾討論過也有修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/848.wav", + "text": "好那就尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/849.wav", + "text": "我們處理的部分是他們是否危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/850.wav", + "text": "所以本來就應該要溯及既往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/851.wav", + "text": "針對過去已經拿到汽車駕照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/852.wav", + "text": "可以騎輕型機車的部分給他們一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/853.wav", + "text": "讓他們能夠考過輕型機車的駕照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/854.wav", + "text": "其實這樣對交通安全才是比較好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/855.wav", + "text": "保障我覺得這是讓民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/856.wav", + "text": "信賴以及能讓我們交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/857.wav", + "text": "更加安全的修法方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/858.wav", + "text": "已經取得汽車駕照並適用於輕型機車情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/859.wav", + "text": "就算這樣不安全我們也不管因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/860.wav", + "text": "我覺得這不是一個對的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/861.wav", + "text": "主席我來講一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/862.wav", + "text": "主席我講一下可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/863.wav", + "text": "我覺得剛剛時代力量所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/864.wav", + "text": "他不堅持嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/865.wav", + "text": "他堅持啊怎麼不堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/866.wav", + "text": "是堅持還是不堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/867.wav", + "text": "這個溯及既往的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/868.wav", + "text": "一般來講在法理上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/869.wav", + "text": "我還是勸說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/870.wav", + "text": "我覺得這不是權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/871.wav", + "text": "而且我們並不是直接讓他不能騎車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/872.wav", + "text": "而是給他一段適用期間讓他在這段期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/873.wav", + "text": "但適用期間是多久你要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/874.wav", + "text": "院長可能聽不懂他的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/875.wav", + "text": "所以就可以犧牲交通安全和人民的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/876.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/877.wav", + "text": "可不可以問一下交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/878.wav", + "text": "人民的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/879.wav", + "text": "218萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/880.wav", + "text": "218萬人都要重新去考輕型機車的駕照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/881.wav", + "text": "時間可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/882.wav", + "text": "你不能這樣把帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/883.wav", + "text": "戴上去什麼都重來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/884.wav", + "text": "法律不溯及既往是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/885.wav", + "text": "一種原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/886.wav", + "text": "我是不是還要重考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/887.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/888.wav", + "text": "們堅持就照你們的意思保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/889.wav", + "text": "影響還滿大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/890.wav", + "text": "車都要再來考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/891.wav", + "text": "道交的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/892.wav", + "text": "有一些法制用字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/893.wav", + "text": "用語的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/894.wav", + "text": "請法制局楊局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/895.wav", + "text": "法制局報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/896.wav", + "text": "我們幫委員準備了兩份資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/897.wav", + "text": "因為怕大家找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/898.wav", + "text": "表2摺起來的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/899.wav", + "text": "是針對委員會沒有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/900.wav", + "text": "總共有四個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/901.wav", + "text": "針對摺起來的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/902.wav", + "text": "我先報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/903.wav", + "text": "也就是委員會沒有保留的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/904.wav", + "text": "因為有些用字用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/905.wav", + "text": "會通過了不正確的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/906.wav", + "text": "第45條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/907.wav", + "text": "針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/908.wav", + "text": "它有特別去修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/909.wav", + "text": "但是這一條漏掉沒有修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/910.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議這個部分要照法制用字用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/911.wav", + "text": "大家可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/912.wav", + "text": "像20" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/913.wav", + "text": "對這個也是必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/914.wav", + "text": "要修的因為這都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/915.wav", + "text": "法律統一用字用語的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/916.wav", + "text": "對比較嚴重的是第85條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/917.wav", + "text": "之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/918.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/919.wav", + "text": "4月19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/920.wav", + "text": "曾經修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/921.wav", + "text": "把微型電動二輪車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/922.wav", + "text": "可能沒有注意到不小心把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/923.wav", + "text": "我們去年修的條文給蓋過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/924.wav", + "text": "如果照審查會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/925.wav", + "text": "以後微型電動二輪車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/926.wav", + "text": "的管理規範就不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/927.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分可能要再補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/928.wav", + "text": "回去\n大家可以看到第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/929.wav", + "text": "的部分審查會通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/930.wav", + "text": "寫的是汽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/931.wav", + "text": "所有人但是因為微型電動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/932.wav", + "text": "二輪車納進去以後它就不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/933.wav", + "text": "僅限於汽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/934.wav", + "text": "所以應該是要照現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/935.wav", + "text": "條文的寫法寫為車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/936.wav", + "text": "所有人這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/937.wav", + "text": "也是要一併做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/938.wav", + "text": "\n另外就是標點符號的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/939.wav", + "text": "部分請大家看到第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/940.wav", + "text": "改掉了現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/941.wav", + "text": "所以我們也建議把它改回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/942.wav", + "text": "這是沒有保留的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/943.wav", + "text": "等一下不要講太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/944.wav", + "text": "來好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/945.wav", + "text": "45條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/946.wav", + "text": "其實這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/947.wav", + "text": "漏修了我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/948.wav", + "text": "剛剛第85條的部分是第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/949.wav", + "text": "還有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/950.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/951.wav", + "text": "這個就是剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/952.wav", + "text": "也是單純的法制用字用語問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/953.wav", + "text": "改成條文的公布日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/954.wav", + "text": "會跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/955.wav", + "text": "沒有保留的第22條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/956.wav", + "text": "第1項第5款的規範方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/957.wav", + "text": "不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/958.wav", + "text": "也會跟現行條文第71條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/959.wav", + "text": "第4項的規範不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/960.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議還是維持現���條文的規範模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/961.wav", + "text": "三讀日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/962.wav", + "text": "為了大家方便看我們已經把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/963.wav", + "text": "審查會通過的第22條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/964.wav", + "text": "以及現行條文第71條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/965.wav", + "text": "第4項的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/966.wav", + "text": "貼在表格的最後方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/967.wav", + "text": "我們希望同一部法律裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/968.wav", + "text": "規範方式應該要一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/969.wav", + "text": "\n最後是第十二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/970.wav", + "text": "請各位看到第3頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/971.wav", + "text": "法律用字用語的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/972.wav", + "text": "罰金我們是用科" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/973.wav", + "text": "罰鍰才用處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/974.wav", + "text": "委員會審查通過的條文就是這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/975.wav", + "text": "要做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/976.wav", + "text": "應該是決定的定而不是言字旁的訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/977.wav", + "text": "訂以上併予說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/978.wav", + "text": "好有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/979.wav", + "text": "日期3月26日不用改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/980.wav", + "text": "最後一項文字科" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/981.wav", + "text": "科和處請法務部表示一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/982.wav", + "text": "好日期就先照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/983.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/984.wav", + "text": "\n我唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/985.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/986.wav", + "text": "一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/987.wav", + "text": "協商通過條文第7條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/988.wav", + "text": ")\n二照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/989.wav", + "text": "第24條第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/990.wav", + "text": "\n三保留條文第22條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/991.wav", + "text": "第63條第63條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/992.wav", + "text": "第63條之二第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/993.wav", + "text": "\n四其餘均照審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/994.wav", + "text": "審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/995.wav", + "text": "第63條之二第22條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/996.wav", + "text": "93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/997.wav", + "text": "保留6條溯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/998.wav", + "text": "溯不溯及既往這個是一起的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/999.wav", + "text": "文字調整部分就自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1000.wav", + "text": "請大家趕快簽名還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1001.wav", + "text": "道交的部分討論告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1002.wav", + "text": "現在在簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1003.wav", + "text": "表決的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1004.wav", + "text": "發言時我們再來討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1005.wav", + "text": "一黨一個就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1006.wav", + "text": "一黨一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1007.wav", + "text": "逐條也會有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1008.wav", + "text": "再協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1009.wav", + "text": "啦原則上是一黨一人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1010.wav", + "text": "沒有說到逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1011.wav", + "text": "現在國民黨不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14915/1012.wav", + "text": "\n現在散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14914/0.wav", + "text": "結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14914/1.wav", + "text": "好意思是剩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14914/2.wav", + "text": "的時候發言時我們再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14914/3.wav", + "text": "一黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14914/4.wav", + "text": "說到逐條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/0.wav", + "text": "我們今天繼續進行原住民族保留地管理利用條例草案的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/1.wav", + "text": "和廖國棟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/2.wav", + "text": "我們今天除了協商之前已經付委且在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/3.wav", + "text": "另外有委員周春米林宜瑾賴瑞隆等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/4.wav", + "text": "擬具的原住民族保留地管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/5.wav", + "text": "草案我們也併案來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/6.wav", + "text": "另外對於委員陳瑩等人所提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/7.wav", + "text": "等一下在討論到相關條文的時候我們也一併來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/8.wav", + "text": "之前發了好幾次的會議通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/9.wav", + "text": "但是因為很多的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/10.wav", + "text": "行政院的提案是原住民族保留地管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/11.wav", + "text": "廖委員的版本是原住民保留地權利回復條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/12.wav", + "text": "陳委員的版本是原住民族繼留地法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/13.wav", + "text": "本席的版本是原住民族保留地管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/14.wav", + "text": "是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/15.wav", + "text": "綜合各版本的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/16.wav", + "text": "我們是不是用原住民族保留地權利回復及管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/17.wav", + "text": "這樣的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/18.wav", + "text": "行政院各部會有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/19.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/20.wav", + "text": "剛剛主席提到針對名稱部分再加列權利回復這四個字關於這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/21.wav", + "text": "我們在草擬院版當時也有考慮過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/22.wav", + "text": "但是我們考量到這個權利回復也是管理的範疇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/23.wav", + "text": "之一所以我們建議委員是不是就維持院版的名稱也就是原住民族保留地管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/24.wav", + "text": "你可以接受院版的名稱嗎\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/25.wav", + "text": "因為我們保留地相關的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/26.wav", + "text": "經營多時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/27.wav", + "text": "我們真的希望能夠快點進入實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/28.wav", + "text": "地方部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/29.wav", + "text": "甚至聽到有買賣什麼情形統統都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/30.wav", + "text": "希望能夠儘速──" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/31.wav", + "text": "如果大家今天能夠都協商好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/32.wav", + "text": "儘速的完成整個協商的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/33.wav", + "text": "然後進入院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/34.wav", + "text": "所以對於名稱本席不再堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/35.wav", + "text": "請鄭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/36.wav", + "text": "我查了一下我們相關的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/37.wav", + "text": "若用到權利規範的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/38.wav", + "text": "都是在威權時期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/39.wav", + "text": "或白色恐怖相關的才有用權利回復這4個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/40.wav", + "text": "但是從過去立法例上來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/41.wav", + "text": "一定是政府的不當介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/42.wav", + "text": "違法介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/43.wav", + "text": "或者這是有共識的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/44.wav", + "text": "在實質內容上面都有做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/45.wav", + "text": "但是行政院沒有用權利回復是有它的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/46.wav", + "text": "在這一點上面我是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/47.wav", + "text": "每一個版本的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/48.wav", + "text": "所有的文字變成一個集合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/49.wav", + "text": "就把它全部納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/50.wav", + "text": "在這邊使用是非常奇怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/51.wav", + "text": "意見是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/52.wav", + "text": "不要把大家的概念都集合在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/53.wav", + "text": "變成一部法律的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/54.wav", + "text": "這個並不是適當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/55.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/56.wav", + "text": "我是很訝異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/57.wav", + "text": "原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/58.wav", + "text": "啦按照夷將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/59.wav", + "text": "夷將主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/60.wav", + "text": "長期的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/61.wav", + "text": "他第一次當原民會的副主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/62.wav", + "text": "開始就一直強調權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/63.wav", + "text": "其實是有根據的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/64.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/65.wav", + "text": "把我們的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/66.wav", + "text": "全部收為官有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/67.wav", + "text": "日本離開了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/68.wav", + "text": "土地並沒有被帶走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/69.wav", + "text": "喔當時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/70.wav", + "text": "國民政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/71.wav", + "text": "把它變成一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/72.wav", + "text": "辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/73.wav", + "text": "──只要是日本收為官有的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/74.wav", + "text": "概不發還其實還是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/75.wav", + "text": "鵬委員所提的那個事情其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/76.wav", + "text": "把��收為官有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/77.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我滿支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/78.wav", + "text": "的法案名稱\n請伍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/79.wav", + "text": "有這樣的一個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/80.wav", + "text": "名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/81.wav", + "text": "希望大家基於望文生義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/82.wav", + "text": "用這個法案名稱就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/83.wav", + "text": "理解它的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/84.wav", + "text": "就是要去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/85.wav", + "text": "權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/86.wav", + "text": "要怎麼管理利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/87.wav", + "text": "所以希望一般的普羅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/88.wav", + "text": "大眾能夠看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/89.wav", + "text": "法案名稱就可以知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/90.wav", + "text": "這部法是要處理什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/91.wav", + "text": "就是基於這樣的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/92.wav", + "text": "所以希望能夠擁有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/93.wav", + "text": "這樣的名稱謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/94.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/95.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/96.wav", + "text": "就是原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/97.wav", + "text": "保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/98.wav", + "text": "權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/99.wav", + "text": "及管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/100.wav", + "text": "權利回復跟管理不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/101.wav", + "text": "還是有很大的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/102.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/103.wav", + "text": "這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/104.wav", + "text": "其實已經把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/105.wav", + "text": "剛剛主席所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/106.wav", + "text": "對於原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/107.wav", + "text": "承認及回復原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/108.wav", + "text": "土地的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/109.wav", + "text": "權利在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/110.wav", + "text": "已經納列了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/111.wav", + "text": "條例的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/112.wav", + "text": "我們當時也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/113.wav", + "text": "討論到這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/114.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有提到過所以我們最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/115.wav", + "text": "折衷院版的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/116.wav", + "text": "還是建議委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/117.wav", + "text": "是不是我們就用原住民族保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/118.wav", + "text": "管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/119.wav", + "text": "好好名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/120.wav", + "text": "條文的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/121.wav", + "text": "啦謝謝鄭委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/122.wav", + "text": "建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/123.wav", + "text": "法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/124.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/125.wav", + "text": "總則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/126.wav", + "text": "各版本都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/127.wav", + "text": "第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/128.wav", + "text": "就跟這個法律名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/129.wav", + "text": "也會有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/130.wav", + "text": "為承認及回復原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/131.wav", + "text": "對於原住民族土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/132.wav", + "text": "第1條就有回復兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/133.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/134.wav", + "text": "條的第一句話是為承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/135.wav", + "text": "之合理利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/136.wav", + "text": "促進原住民族之生存發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/137.wav", + "text": "原住民族土地及自然資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/138.wav", + "text": "差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/139.wav", + "text": "就是為回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/140.wav", + "text": "精神又一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/141.wav", + "text": "有很大的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/142.wav", + "text": "在哪裡呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/143.wav", + "text": "原住民族基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/144.wav", + "text": "我這邊寫的是第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/145.wav", + "text": "為什麼是第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/146.wav", + "text": "行政院版是原基法第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/147.wav", + "text": "第3項你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/148.wav", + "text": "就完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/149.wav", + "text": "因為從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/150.wav", + "text": "有原住民族基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/151.wav", + "text": "開始陳水扁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/152.wav", + "text": "總統執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/153.wav", + "text": "或是馬英九總統執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/154.wav", + "text": "所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/155.wav", + "text": "都是叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/156.wav", + "text": "土海法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/157.wav", + "text": "所以你現在依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/158.wav", + "text": "原基法第2條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/159.wav", + "text": "拿去用了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/160.wav", + "text": "以後土海法根本就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/161.wav", + "text": "狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/162.wav", + "text": "因此我才會用第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/163.wav", + "text": "政府承認原住民族土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/164.wav", + "text": "及自然資源權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/165.wav", + "text": "我才會用原基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/166.wav", + "text": "不是原民會說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/167.wav", + "text": "因為原基法第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/168.wav", + "text": "第1項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/169.wav", + "text": "政府承認原住民族土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/170.wav", + "text": "及自然資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/171.wav", + "text": "利第3項是規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/172.wav", + "text": "原住民族或原住民所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/173.wav", + "text": "使用之土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/174.wav", + "text": "海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/175.wav", + "text": "其回復取得處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/176.wav", + "text": "計畫管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/177.wav", + "text": "及利用等事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/178.wav", + "text": "另以法律定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/179.wav", + "text": "其實我們在前幾年也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/180.wav", + "text": "提出土海法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/181.wav", + "text": "但是我們知道這個困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/182.wav", + "text": "有山有海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/183.wav", + "text": "所以採分流立法的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/184.wav", + "text": "提出原住民族保留地管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/185.wav", + "text": "現在重點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/186.wav", + "text": "原基法第2條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/187.wav", + "text": "是包括海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/188.wav", + "text": "然後原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/189.wav", + "text": "土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/190.wav", + "text": "是包含傳統領域土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/191.wav", + "text": "但是今天的草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/192.wav", + "text": "沒有包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/193.wav", + "text": "傳統領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/194.wav", + "text": "也沒有包含海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/195.wav", + "text": "所以你用第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/196.wav", + "text": "也不合啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/197.wav", + "text": "用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/198.wav", + "text": "──不然的話原基法第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/199.wav", + "text": "也不要用用憲法就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/200.wav", + "text": "這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/201.wav", + "text": "還可以接受的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/202.wav", + "text": "今天提原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/203.wav", + "text": "族保留地管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/204.wav", + "text": "不代表未來不會再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/205.wav", + "text": "海域方面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/206.wav", + "text": "但是它已經被引用第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/207.wav", + "text": "2條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/208.wav", + "text": "已經被你引用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/209.wav", + "text": "既然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/210.wav", + "text": "依原基法第2條第3項就要包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/211.wav", + "text": "傳統領域跟海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/212.wav", + "text": "因為法律的授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/213.wav", + "text": "是在第2條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/214.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/215.wav", + "text": "沒有授權我們也是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/216.wav", + "text": "的其他委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/217.wav", + "text": "召委的意見跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/218.wav", + "text": "原民會就不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/219.wav", + "text": "而且時代力量跟民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/220.wav", + "text": "沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/221.wav", + "text": "好那第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/222.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/223.wav", + "text": "理第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/224.wav", + "text": "政院版是原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/225.wav", + "text": "族保留地之權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/226.wav", + "text": "也是權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/227.wav", + "text": "大家要記得啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/228.wav", + "text": "\n所以前面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/229.wav", + "text": "法律名稱就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/230.wav", + "text": "希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/231.wav", + "text": "的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/232.wav", + "text": "對於原住民族保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/233.wav", + "text": "之權利回復取得處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/234.wav", + "text": "計畫管理及利用等事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/235.wav", + "text": "依本條例之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/236.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/237.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/238.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/239.wav", + "text": "\n行政院版還可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/240.wav", + "text": "行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/241.wav", + "text": "我只是增加了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/242.wav", + "text": "要處理的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/243.wav", + "text": "把它寫得越詳盡越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/244.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/245.wav", + "text": "其他其實跟院版都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/246.wav", + "text": "各位有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/247.wav", + "text": "就照行政院提案通過\n處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/248.wav", + "text": "理第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/249.wav", + "text": "為原住民族委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/250.wav", + "text": "在直轄市為直轄市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/251.wav", + "text": ")政府本條例之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/252.wav", + "text": "執行機關為鄉(鎮市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/253.wav", + "text": "\n這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/254.wav", + "text": "廖委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/255.wav", + "text": "有增加自治區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/256.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/257.wav", + "text": "還是可以先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/258.wav", + "text": "接受行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/259.wav", + "text": "因為將來我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/260.wav", + "text": "政府我們多年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/261.wav", + "text": "一直主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/262.wav", + "text": "自治區政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/263.wav", + "text": "將來如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/264.wav", + "text": "走到這一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/265.wav", + "text": "的時候是不是我們又要回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/266.wav", + "text": "再修這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/267.wav", + "text": "我聽聽大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/268.wav", + "text": "各位委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/269.wav", + "text": "針對第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/270.wav", + "text": "因為廖委員有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/271.wav", + "text": "關於自治區及原住民族土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/272.wav", + "text": "及海域調查處理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/273.wav", + "text": "這部分我想跟主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/274.wav", + "text": "各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/275.wav", + "text": "就是關於自治區及原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/276.wav", + "text": "族土地及海域調查處理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/277.wav", + "text": "目前沒有法源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/278.wav", + "text": "所以它的權能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/279.wav", + "text": "應該另外以法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/280.wav", + "text": "定之其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/281.wav", + "text": "可以同意用院版請鄭運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/282.wav", + "text": "我的意見就跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/283.wav", + "text": "行政院版不一樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/284.wav", + "text": "更不用講廖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/285.wav", + "text": "廖國棟委員的也不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/286.wav", + "text": "不知道鄉鎮市公所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/287.wav", + "text": "原住民族的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/288.wav", + "text": "鄉鎮市自治區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/289.wav", + "text": "有一個統一的處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/290.wav", + "text": "這些我都很懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/291.wav", + "text": "所以這一條我是建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/292.wav", + "text": "運鵬委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/293.wav", + "text": "先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/294.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/295.wav", + "text": "是本條例用詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/296.wav", + "text": "定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/297.wav", + "text": "原住民保留地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/298.wav", + "text": "定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/299.wav", + "text": "看一下原民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/300.wav", + "text": "草案說明原民會要記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/301.wav", + "text": "如果你們有其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/302.wav", + "text": "條文涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/303.wav", + "text": "我們討論的條文時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/304.wav", + "text": "主動提出來包括內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/305.wav", + "text": "也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/306.wav", + "text": "到時候你們主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/307.wav", + "text": "抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/308.wav", + "text": "版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/309.wav", + "text": "及各委員版本第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/310.wav", + "text": "的前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/311.wav", + "text": "有本席的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/312.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/313.wav", + "text": "內容為為辦理本條例原住民族基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/314.wav", + "text": "國土地計畫法都市計畫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/315.wav", + "text": "區域計畫法水土保持法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/316.wav", + "text": "水利法海岸管理法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/317.wav", + "text": "濕地保育法等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/318.wav", + "text": "有關原住民族土地或部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/319.wav", + "text": "土地所定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/320.wav", + "text": "原住民族委員會設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/321.wav", + "text": "原住民族土地管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/322.wav", + "text": "不受中央行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/323.wav", + "text": "機關組織基準法第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/324.wav", + "text": "33條第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/325.wav", + "text": "規定之限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/326.wav", + "text": "這個最主要是因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/327.wav", + "text": "的人力真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/328.wav", + "text": "管理國有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/329.wav", + "text": "土地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/330.wav", + "text": "有國產署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/331.wav", + "text": "這些有涉及到管理國有土地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/332.wav", + "text": "一些國有土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/333.wav", + "text": "管理了很多的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/334.wav", + "text": "但是就是一個處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/335.wav", + "text": "也會涉及到剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/336.wav", + "text": "委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/337.wav", + "text": "鄉鎮公所作為執行機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/338.wav", + "text": "確實是一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/339.wav", + "text": "所以我才會提出這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/340.wav", + "text": "機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/341.wav", + "text": "大家能夠正視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/342.wav", + "text": "讓原住民族委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/343.wav", + "text": "能夠設原住民族土地管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/344.wav", + "text": "各位有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/345.wav", + "text": "\n請谷縱副主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/346.wav", + "text": "鄭委員的版本條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/347.wav", + "text": "各目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/348.wav", + "text": "行政權分工的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/349.wav", + "text": "以及本會組織變動的事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/350.wav", + "text": "所以這是不是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/351.wav", + "text": "還要再去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/352.wav", + "text": "研議跟相關部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/353.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/354.wav", + "text": "我們是建議採院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/355.wav", + "text": "人事行政總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/356.wav", + "text": "機關組織基準法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/357.wav", + "text": "\n等一下再請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/358.wav", + "text": "廖國棟委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/359.wav", + "text": "跟委員會報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/360.wav", + "text": "行政院版所定的原保地管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/361.wav", + "text": "業務分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/362.wav", + "text": "它主要是由原民會來辦理政策規劃跟協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/363.wav", + "text": "地方鄉鎮市公所來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/364.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/365.wav", + "text": "基本上避免機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/366.wav", + "text": "疊床架屋以及權責不清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/367.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/368.wav", + "text": "不要以成立新機關的方式處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/369.wav", + "text": "另外依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/370.wav", + "text": "中央行政機關組織基準法第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/371.wav", + "text": "第3項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/372.wav", + "text": "法規規定機關之組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/373.wav", + "text": "為了符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/374.wav", + "text": "基準法的規定所以這個部分還是建議不予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/375.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/376.wav", + "text": "在廖國棟委員發言之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/377.wav", + "text": "作用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/378.wav", + "text": "有訂這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/379.wav", + "text": "類似條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/380.wav", + "text": "不少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/381.wav", + "text": "博物館法就有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/382.wav", + "text": "博物館法就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/383.wav", + "text": "設博物館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/384.wav", + "text": "國立原住民族博物館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/385.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/386.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/387.wav", + "text": "其他的更有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/388.wav", + "text": "啦像促進轉型正義條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/389.wav", + "text": "不當黨產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/390.wav", + "text": "處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/391.wav", + "text": "都是從作用法裡面就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/392.wav", + "text": "訂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/393.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/394.wav", + "text": "不要一到原住民就不行了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/395.wav", + "text": "這是我常跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/396.wav", + "text": "講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/397.wav", + "text": "因為本席的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/398.wav", + "text": "好幾年前就提出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/399.wav", + "text": "那個時候的思維是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/400.wav", + "text": "稍微簡單了點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/401.wav", + "text": "今天看到大家所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/402.wav", + "text": "內容都各有豐富度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/403.wav", + "text": "原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/404.wav", + "text": "我是支持院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/405.wav", + "text": "大家可以一起參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/406.wav", + "text": "看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/407.wav", + "text": "其中特別規定到原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/408.wav", + "text": "除已依法撥用徵收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/409.wav", + "text": "出現過但我現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/410.wav", + "text": "只是在定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/411.wav", + "text": "各個名詞而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/412.wav", + "text": "碰到什麼狀況的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/413.wav", + "text": "要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/414.wav", + "text": "再一次地使用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/415.wav", + "text": "自治區所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/416.wav", + "text": "只是我們現在的思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/417.wav", + "text": "好像還沒有自治區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/418.wav", + "text": "所以我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/419.wav", + "text": "支持院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/420.wav", + "text": "廖委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/421.wav", + "text": "我們是先談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/422.wav", + "text": "是上面那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/423.wav", + "text": "右邊上面的那部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/424.wav", + "text": "部分本席的第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/425.wav", + "text": "先保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/426.wav", + "text": "\n處理行政院版第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/427.wav", + "text": "廖國棟委員提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/428.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/429.wav", + "text": "陳委員提案第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/430.wav", + "text": "還有伍麗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/431.wav", + "text": "\n我先講我的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/432.wav", + "text": "有幾個比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/433.wav", + "text": "重要的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/434.wav", + "text": "原住民保留地的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/435.wav", + "text": "這部分行政院版就寫得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/436.wav", + "text": "比較簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/437.wav", + "text": "只規定指原住民族保留地經原住民依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/438.wav", + "text": "取得所有權之保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/439.wav", + "text": "而我對原住民保留地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/440.wav", + "text": "定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/441.wav", + "text": "五目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/442.wav", + "text": "第一個是既有原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/443.wav", + "text": "第二個是增劃編原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/444.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/445.wav", + "text": "這是很明確要這樣分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/446.wav", + "text": "的然後還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/447.wav", + "text": "舊部落及其耕墾之公有土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/448.wav", + "text": "最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/449.wav", + "text": "權利清理辦法第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/450.wav", + "text": "規定概不發還之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/451.wav", + "text": "土地\n都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/452.wav", + "text": "劃為原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/453.wav", + "text": "目是經政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/454.wav", + "text": "徵收徵用接收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/455.wav", + "text": "登記為公有及國營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/456.wav", + "text": "事業之土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/457.wav", + "text": "第一句就規定要權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/458.wav", + "text": "了所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/459.wav", + "text": "就應該都要把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/460.wav", + "text": "放回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/461.wav", + "text": "原住民族宗教團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/462.wav", + "text": "而我是以原住民團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/463.wav", + "text": "宗教團體等各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/464.wav", + "text": "原民會要不要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/465.wav", + "text": "原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/466.wav", + "text": "原住民機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/467.wav", + "text": "法人或團體等用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/468.wav", + "text": "其實分別在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/469.wav", + "text": "原基法第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/470.wav", + "text": "和原住民族工作權保障法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/471.wav", + "text": "施行細則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/472.wav", + "text": "第8條都有定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/473.wav", + "text": "所以本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/474.wav", + "text": "應該不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/475.wav", + "text": "再重複訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/476.wav", + "text": "繼留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/477.wav", + "text": "的名詞解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/478.wav", + "text": "其定義跟院版的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/479.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/480.wav", + "text": "相同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/481.wav", + "text": "所以建議沿用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/482.wav", + "text": "避免混淆或是產生爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/483.wav", + "text": "第二個部分就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/484.wav", + "text": "關於氏族部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/485.wav", + "text": "族群等主體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/486.wav", + "text": "其總總概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/487.wav", + "text": "待我們原住民的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/488.wav", + "text": "氏族或是部落族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/489.wav", + "text": "具備人格權後再研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/490.wav", + "text": "修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/491.wav", + "text": "所以現階段建議還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/492.wav", + "text": "維持院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/493.wav", + "text": "另外針對主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/494.wav", + "text": "(鄭委員)版本第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/495.wav", + "text": "第三目到第五目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/496.wav", + "text": "的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/497.wav", + "text": "原住民保留地定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/498.wav", + "text": "有點沒有相符" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/499.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/500.wav", + "text": "的程序來辦理所以我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/501.wav", + "text": "是不是採院版的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/502.wav", + "text": "的名詞混淆或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/503.wav", + "text": "產生爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/504.wav", + "text": "我再強調一次因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/505.wav", + "text": "原民會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/506.wav", + "text": "版本就算是院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/507.wav", + "text": "整個內容裡面哪裡有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/508.wav", + "text": "自治區政府這件事情有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/509.wav", + "text": "我不知道是沒有嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/510.wav", + "text": "所以你們現在沒有那個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/511.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/512.wav", + "text": "這個地方本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/513.wav", + "text": "是有點引以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/514.wav", + "text": "你們是已經放棄了所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/515.wav", + "text": "的自治區政府嗎你們的立場現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/516.wav", + "text": "沒有自治區政府嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/517.wav", + "text": "我想這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/518.wav", + "text": "法案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/519.wav", + "text": "只談關於土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/520.wav", + "text": "的法案自治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/521.wav", + "text": "區會涉及到行政轄區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/522.wav", + "text": "包括各目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/523.wav", + "text": "或是法律的這個部分所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/524.wav", + "text": "只針對土地的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/525.wav", + "text": "的這個部分我們原民會當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/526.wav", + "text": "也持續在推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/527.wav", + "text": "還是有在推動嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/528.wav", + "text": "跟召集人報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/529.wav", + "text": "剛剛召集人特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/530.wav", + "text": "你那個條文中有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/531.wav", + "text": "原住民保留地定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/532.wav", + "text": "定義的部分因為我們這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/533.wav", + "text": "的立法其實是為了提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/534.wav", + "text": "法律位階所以我們是著墨在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/535.wav", + "text": "既有保留地現有的法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/536.wav", + "text": "去做一些處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/537.wav", + "text": "至於委員講的那個當然是涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/538.wav", + "text": "涉及得更廣它可能已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/539.wav", + "text": "有點類似在傳領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/540.wav", + "text": "這個部分沒有處理我們前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/541.wav", + "text": "有提到它是分流處理所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/542.wav", + "text": "那個區塊事實上是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/543.wav", + "text": "放在下一個階段的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/544.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣所以就沒有把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/545.wav", + "text": "完全歸到這次這個立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/546.wav", + "text": "好我現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/547.wav", + "text": "要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/548.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/549.wav", + "text": "在場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/550.wav", + "text": "都沒有很資深" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/551.wav", + "text": "負責保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/552.wav", + "text": "業務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/553.wav", + "text": "我來說明我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/554.wav", + "text": "了之後你們就可以回顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/555.wav", + "text": "行政院版原住民保留地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/556.wav", + "text": "定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/557.wav", + "text": "是不如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/558.wav", + "text": "的我來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/559.wav", + "text": "山地保留地當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/560.wav", + "text": "劃24萬公頃的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/561.wav", + "text": "第一次國民政府劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/562.wav", + "text": "24萬公頃山地保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/563.wav", + "text": "的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/564.wav", + "text": "依法取得所有權之保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/565.wav", + "text": "不是喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/566.wav", + "text": "現使用的土地喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/567.wav", + "text": "24萬公頃就這樣劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/568.wav", + "text": "原住民現使用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/569.wav", + "text": "再慢慢給他權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/570.wav", + "text": "還有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/571.wav", + "text": "還是保留公有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/572.wav", + "text": "原住民保留地喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/573.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/574.wav", + "text": "24萬公頃一劃的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/575.wav", + "text": "國民政府的時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/576.wav", + "text": "隨著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/577.wav", + "text": "我們的國民大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/578.wav", + "text": "還有立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/579.wav", + "text": "還有省議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/580.wav", + "text": "尤其是夷將主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/581.wav", + "text": "還我土地運動之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/582.wav", + "text": "就開始有所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/583.wav", + "text": "增劃編原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/584.wav", + "text": "杜張梅莊處長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/585.wav", + "text": "第一次增劃編原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/586.wav", + "text": "不是按照現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/587.wav", + "text": "不是喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/588.wav", + "text": "也是跟那個24萬公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/589.wav", + "text": "一樣是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/590.wav", + "text": "整塊整塊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/591.wav", + "text": "是這樣劃的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/592.wav", + "text": "你們可以查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/593.wav", + "text": "你看他們都太年輕了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/594.wav", + "text": "你們可以查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/595.wav", + "text": "第一次增劃編保留地是整塊整塊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/596.wav", + "text": "如果你們現在把它定成這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/597.wav", + "text": "會不如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/598.wav", + "text": "所以真正符合的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/599.wav", + "text": "是現在原住民保留地的5目這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/600.wav", + "text": "符合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/601.wav", + "text": "何況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/602.wav", + "text": "對於權利回復法規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/603.wav", + "text": "臺灣省土地權利清理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/604.wav", + "text": "辦法第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/605.wav", + "text": "日本收為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/606.wav", + "text": "官有的土地蓋不發還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/607.wav", + "text": "我們現在當然要利用這個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/608.wav", + "text": "把權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/609.wav", + "text": "版第1條第一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/610.wav", + "text": "回復權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/611.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/612.wav", + "text": "請你們回去再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/613.wav", + "text": "所以你回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/614.wav", + "text": "要轉達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/615.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/616.wav", + "text": "會裡面原則上都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/617.wav", + "text": "接受也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/618.wav", + "text": "但是要跟委員說明的是剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/619.wav", + "text": "剛我們一開始說這個法的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/620.wav", + "text": "事實上原住民族保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/621.wav", + "text": "管理辦法裡面的定義幾乎類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/622.wav", + "text": "原住民保留地事實上只是把它拆開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/623.wav", + "text": "來再做比較細緻的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/624.wav", + "text": "\n另外提到增劃編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/625.wav", + "text": "編的部分委員講得沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/626.wav", + "text": "整個區塊劃進來可是當時在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/627.wav", + "text": "劃這個區塊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/628.wav", + "text": "內部的參據還是有參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/629.wav", + "text": "做全國調查時候的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/630.wav", + "text": "78年79年那次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/631.wav", + "text": "整體化的部分雖然沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/632.wav", + "text": "很明確講是不是7721" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/633.wav", + "text": "的參據還是依據那個時候調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/634.wav", + "text": "劃哪些土地進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/635.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/636.wav", + "text": "跟委員做補充說明以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/637.wav", + "text": "對啊所以現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/638.wav", + "text": "第5條第2款第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/639.wav", + "text": "一目到第五目的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/640.wav", + "text": "原民會才有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/641.wav", + "text": "依據去做調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/642.wav", + "text": "才可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/643.wav", + "text": "劃設原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/644.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/645.wav", + "text": "我在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/646.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/647.wav", + "text": "跟原住民保留地這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/648.wav", + "text": "反而邏輯很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/649.wav", + "text": "嗎我不曉得你最聰明的腦筋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/650.wav", + "text": "特別要處理什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/651.wav", + "text": "我對你一向是崇拜的但是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/652.wav", + "text": "這一條我就看不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/653.wav", + "text": "所以我看還是先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/654.wav", + "text": "好我們可以保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/655.wav", + "text": "但我簡要說明一下其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/656.wav", + "text": "我的概念就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/657.wav", + "text": "以前的山地保留地後來名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/658.wav", + "text": "改為原住民保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/659.wav", + "text": "一開始劃24萬公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/660.wav", + "text": "後來第一次增劃編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/661.wav", + "text": "第2款第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/662.wav", + "text": "的概念你們回去再跟主委報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/663.wav", + "text": "行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/664.wav", + "text": "廖委員版第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/665.wav", + "text": "陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/666.wav", + "text": "本席版本第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/667.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/668.wav", + "text": "之前的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/669.wav", + "text": "家翻到第19頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/670.wav", + "text": "有廖委員版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/671.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/672.wav", + "text": "原住民保留地除已依法撥用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/673.wav", + "text": "徵收價購或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/674.wav", + "text": "由原住民取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/675.wav", + "text": "所有權者外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/676.wav", + "text": "管理機關為原住民族委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/677.wav", + "text": "原住民族自治區成立後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/678.wav", + "text": "其所有權登記為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/679.wav", + "text": "自治區所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/680.wav", + "text": "是不是我們就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/681.wav", + "text": "廖委員同意的話我們就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/682.wav", + "text": "有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/683.wav", + "text": "\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/684.wav", + "text": "是行政院版第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/685.wav", + "text": "廖委員第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/686.wav", + "text": "現在只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/687.wav", + "text": "本席的條次不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/688.wav", + "text": "就是第6條原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/689.wav", + "text": "原民會要不要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/690.wav", + "text": "各版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/691.wav", + "text": "有哪些差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/692.wav", + "text": "這樣比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/693.wav", + "text": "跟主席和委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/694.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/695.wav", + "text": "應該都類似只有鄭��員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/696.wav", + "text": "即主席的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/697.wav", + "text": "有提到關於原保地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/698.wav", + "text": "其實我們在行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/699.wav", + "text": "已經有增訂土審會的組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/700.wav", + "text": "我們會另外以辦法定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/701.wav", + "text": "所以這部分是不是建議維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/702.wav", + "text": "各位委員對於第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/703.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席因為這一條一定會跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/704.wav", + "text": "原來的第4條有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/705.wav", + "text": "相關因為本來的定義不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/706.wav", + "text": "跟主席的定義也不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/707.wav", + "text": "所以這一條也是隨同保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/708.wav", + "text": "因為定義不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/709.wav", + "text": "架構不同這一條就不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/710.wav", + "text": "或誰的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/711.wav", + "text": "這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/712.wav", + "text": "我看我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/713.wav", + "text": "如果按照這樣的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/714.wav", + "text": "剛才有共識的一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/715.wav", + "text": "就是那麼一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/716.wav", + "text": "我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/717.wav", + "text": "從公務員出身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/718.wav", + "text": "你在省政府待了那麼多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/719.wav", + "text": "還當主管所以你應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/720.wav", + "text": "最熟悉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/721.wav", + "text": "要先整理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/722.wav", + "text": "再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/723.wav", + "text": "否則我們會一直保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/724.wav", + "text": "他的意見我們不會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/725.wav", + "text": "你的土地定義不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/726.wav", + "text": "很難整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/727.wav", + "text": "很難在這種時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/728.wav", + "text": "大家可以接受的架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/729.wav", + "text": "才有辦法做這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/730.wav", + "text": "我也謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/731.wav", + "text": "鄭委員能夠排這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/732.wav", + "text": "協商很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/733.wav", + "text": "我一直在等終於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/734.wav", + "text": "討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/735.wav", + "text": "很珍惜這個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/736.wav", + "text": "繼續談下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/737.wav", + "text": "還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/738.wav", + "text": "會說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/739.wav", + "text": "我們現在討論的這一條院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/740.wav", + "text": "第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/741.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/742.wav", + "text": "先不考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/743.wav", + "text": "自治區的話其他是不是都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/744.wav", + "text": "都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/745.wav", + "text": "主席的版本不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/746.wav", + "text": "對所以我們是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/747.wav", + "text": "土審會的組織及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/748.wav", + "text": "運作包括相關的事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/749.wav", + "text": "另以辦法定之是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/750.wav", + "text": "鄭委員關切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/751.wav", + "text": "本席跟行政院版本不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/752.wav", + "text": "最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/753.wav", + "text": "委員的版本在這裡直接明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/754.wav", + "text": "審查會組成的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/755.wav", + "text": "及相關具有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/756.wav", + "text": "原住民身分的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/757.wav", + "text": "但我們其實在第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/758.wav", + "text": "就會提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/759.wav", + "text": "土審會的成員等等相關部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/760.wav", + "text": "部分另以辦法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/761.wav", + "text": "在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/762.wav", + "text": "在第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/763.wav", + "text": "不是在我的第6條哪個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/764.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/765.wav", + "text": "我的修正動議在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/766.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/767.wav", + "text": "有放在這本嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/768.wav", + "text": "我們自己有整理出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/769.wav", + "text": "因為他不是內政委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/770.wav", + "text": "沒有提過這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/771.wav", + "text": "我看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/772.wav", + "text": "版本整理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/773.wav", + "text": "一下很多案子都在趕流行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/774.wav", + "text": "協商連來都不來辦公室隨便提一提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/775.wav", + "text": "委員都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/776.wav", + "text": "把這件事當作一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/777.wav", + "text": "當然每一個人在時間上有不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/778.wav", + "text": "難免但是我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/779.wav", + "text": "他們的條文這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/780.wav", + "text": "版本怎麼來的我就不方便講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/781.wav", + "text": "我們真的要有點成績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/782.wav", + "text": "好像又回復到我們在審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/783.wav", + "text": "我今天是把時間空下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/784.wav", + "text": "真的要來跟大家一起努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/785.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/786.wav", + "text": "召開會前會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/787.wav", + "text": "整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/788.wav", + "text": "先不用黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/789.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/790.wav", + "text": "我先用會前會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/791.wav", + "text": "其實我以前都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/792.wav", + "text": "就是利用會前會的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/793.wav", + "text": "這樣就可以節省各黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/794.wav", + "text": "我們又多一個邦交國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/795.wav", + "text": "一定支持你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/796.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/797.wav", + "text": "參採剛才委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/798.wav", + "text": "意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/799.wav", + "text": "就黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/800.wav", + "text": "協商來講另" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/801.wav", + "text": "定期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/802.wav", + "text": "另外再安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/803.wav", + "text": "非原住民委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14908/804.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/0.wav", + "text": "我們就先開始好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/2.wav", + "text": "民眾黨有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/3.wav", + "text": "他們等一下會到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/4.wav", + "text": "他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/5.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商會議開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/6.wav", + "text": "\n今天要協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/7.wav", + "text": "繼續研商行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/8.wav", + "text": "中央政府疫後強化經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/9.wav", + "text": "與社會韌性及全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/10.wav", + "text": "經濟成果特別預算案案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/11.wav", + "text": "相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/12.wav", + "text": "依3月16日協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/13.wav", + "text": "結論辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/14.wav", + "text": "協商前跟大家說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/15.wav", + "text": "本日特別預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/16.wav", + "text": "要協商的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/17.wav", + "text": "含委員會保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/18.wav", + "text": "總共有148案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/19.wav", + "text": "今天協商完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/20.wav", + "text": "明天就要完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/21.wav", + "text": "三讀程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/22.wav", + "text": "下週二捷克眾議院議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/23.wav", + "text": "艾達莫娃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/24.wav", + "text": "將於院會進行演講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/25.wav", + "text": "請本院委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/26.wav", + "text": "踴躍參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/27.wav", + "text": "這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/28.wav", + "text": "我們會頒授國會獎章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/29.wav", + "text": "給艾達莫娃議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/30.wav", + "text": "因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/31.wav", + "text": "秘書處函送的獎章辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/32.wav", + "text": "修正備查案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/33.wav", + "text": "明天院會也會增列報告事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/34.wav", + "text": "因為這次來訪的外賓人數比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/35.wav", + "text": "會使用到旁聽席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/36.wav", + "text": "所以下週二上午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/37.wav", + "text": "院會就會暫停旁聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/38.wav", + "text": "會期本院經費稽核委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/39.wav", + "text": "循例要重新組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/40.wav", + "text": "依政黨比例5211" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/41.wav", + "text": "協商結論草稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/42.wav", + "text": "就請各黨團幫忙簽署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/43.wav", + "text": "現在開始特別預算案的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/44.wav", + "text": "\n先介紹今天列席的官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/45.wav", + "text": "首先介紹行政院主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/46.wav", + "text": "主計長朱澤民先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/47.wav", + "text": "再來介紹財政部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/48.wav", + "text": "莊翠雲女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/49.wav", + "text": "龔明鑫先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/50.wav", + "text": "介紹就到此告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/51.wav", + "text": "\n大家如果同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/52.wav", + "text": "游院長各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/53.wav", + "text": "主要是因為要發600塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/54.wav", + "text": "因為600塊的事情所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/55.wav", + "text": "基本上也都保留保留保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/56.wav", + "text": "這個案子如果全部保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/57.wav", + "text": "就等於是全部通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/58.wav", + "text": "所以我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/59.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠類似總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/60.wav", + "text": "的處理方式因為這個有太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/61.wav", + "text": "能不能先決定一個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/62.wav", + "text": "看看能夠通刪多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/63.wav", + "text": "這樣來喬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/64.wav", + "text": "因為我們在審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/65.wav", + "text": "幾乎都完全沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/66.wav", + "text": "嘛大概全部砍不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/67.wav", + "text": "元等於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/68.wav", + "text": "完全來這裡處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/69.wav", + "text": "我先提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/70.wav", + "text": "我記得那時候我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/71.wav", + "text": "是不是先扣掉1,300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/72.wav", + "text": "元絕對不能動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/73.wav", + "text": "600" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/74.wav", + "text": "部分我們希望明天就能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/75.wav", + "text": "其他的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/76.wav", + "text": "如果有一個總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/77.wav", + "text": "比如說看你們多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/78.wav", + "text": "各單位自己回去喬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/79.wav", + "text": "因為這裡面有很多空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/80.wav", + "text": "有很多不同角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/81.wav", + "text": "這裡不能動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/82.wav", + "text": "那裡不能動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/83.wav", + "text": "等於審都沒有必要審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/84.wav", + "text": "具體建議在討論這個之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/85.wav", + "text": "如果柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/86.wav", + "text": "比如說有些業務費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/87.wav", + "text": "我們在委員會要刪的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/88.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/89.wav", + "text": "完全都沒有處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/90.wav", + "text": "所以我具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/91.wav", + "text": "看看總召能不能夠同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/92.wav", + "text": "定一個數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/93.wav", + "text": "很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/94.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/95.wav", + "text": "柯總召說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/96.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/97.wav", + "text": "剛才所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/98.wav", + "text": "我記得在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/99.wav", + "text": "委員會開始審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/100.wav", + "text": "他也提過類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/101.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/102.wav", + "text": "我從那天開始想到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/103.wav", + "text": "有點困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/104.wav", + "text": "這個和總預算不大一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/105.wav", + "text": "先扣掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/106.wav", + "text": "先扣掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/107.wav", + "text": "但這個和總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/108.wav", + "text": "這個只有3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/109.wav", + "text": "都有特殊用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/110.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/111.wav", + "text": "經濟韌性的發展等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/112.wav", + "text": "每一個部會都搶錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/113.wav", + "text": "錢搶得很厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/114.wav", + "text": "應該怎麼配都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/115.wav", + "text": "這個有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/116.wav", + "text": "過這個形成的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/117.wav", + "text": "這次和總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/118.wav", + "text": "當我們先進入協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/119.wav", + "text": "最後我們再來談這一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/120.wav", + "text": "行政部門也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/121.wav", + "text": "可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/122.wav", + "text": "其他委員不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/123.wav", + "text": "大家都有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/124.wav", + "text": "不是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/125.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/126.wav", + "text": "刪不到一億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/127.wav", + "text": "一定要刪多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/128.wav", + "text": "大家都很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/129.wav", + "text": "我有注意看電視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/130.wav", + "text": "你們都有在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/131.wav", + "text": "大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/132.wav", + "text": "一團和氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/133.wav", + "text": "氣也都很理性在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/134.wav", + "text": "像這種預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/135.wav", + "text": "刪的都不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/136.wav", + "text": "我知道啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/137.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/138.wav", + "text": "像總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/139.wav", + "text": "你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/140.wav", + "text": "2%就兩百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/141.wav", + "text": "了那看起來很壯觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/142.wav", + "text": "總預算是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/143.wav", + "text": "散布在各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/144.wav", + "text": "但這些都是有特殊目的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/145.wav", + "text": "的我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/146.wav", + "text": "既然我們都尊重委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/147.wav", + "text": "委員會已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/148.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/149.wav", + "text": "保留二十幾案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/150.wav", + "text": "那二十幾案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/151.wav", + "text": "可能是比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/152.wav", + "text": "的有600" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/153.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/154.wav", + "text": "妥協的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/155.wav", + "text": "是比較小的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/156.wav", + "text": "所以都保留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/157.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/158.wav", + "text": "過去都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/159.wav", + "text": "也曾經保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/160.wav", + "text": "到院長主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/161.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/162.wav", + "text": "有公督盟的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/163.wav", + "text": "所以到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/164.wav", + "text": "並不是以刪減為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/165.wav", + "text": "或當作主要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/166.wav", + "text": "爭執點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/167.wav", + "text": "做好比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/168.wav", + "text": "啦所以請賴士葆委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/169.wav", + "text": "委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/170.wav", + "text": "大家都討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/171.wav", + "text": "很完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/172.wav", + "text": "了上次有一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/173.wav", + "text": "我記得那次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/174.wav", + "text": "應該是前瞻的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/175.wav", + "text": "我們就尊重委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/176.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/177.wav", + "text": "我有些刪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/178.wav", + "text": "行政部門也同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/179.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/180.wav", + "text": "這次都沒有把你翻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/181.wav", + "text": "啦現在保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/182.wav", + "text": "都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/183.wav", + "text": "部會做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/184.wav", + "text": "的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/185.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/186.wav", + "text": "農委會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/187.wav", + "text": "鍾委員你不用擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/188.wav", + "text": "我不會堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/189.wav", + "text": "但是其他部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/190.wav", + "text": "像經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/191.wav", + "text": "拿了這麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/192.wav", + "text": "點嗎一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/193.wav", + "text": "1,400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/194.wav", + "text": "不要動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/195.wav", + "text": "千分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/196.wav", + "text": "萬分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/197.wav", + "text": "是兩千多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/198.wav", + "text": "經濟部都集中在台電的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/199.wav", + "text": "還有三百零多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/200.wav", + "text": "我們不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/201.wav", + "text": "其實3,800億裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/202.wav", + "text": "有些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/203.wav", + "text": "也沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/204.wav", + "text": "只是為了編列而編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/205.wav", + "text": "比如說文化部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/206.wav", + "text": "各項藝文振興方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/207.wav", + "text": "發放藝文消費券抵用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/208.wav", + "text": "擴大藝文消費及振興藝文產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/209.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/210.wav", + "text": "因為涉及到通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/211.wav", + "text": "我要請教一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/212.wav", + "text": "因為這個都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/213.wav", + "text": "而且朝野協商過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/214.wav", + "text": "的防疫紓困特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/215.wav", + "text": "裡面總共編了870億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/216.wav", + "text": "要給中小企業信保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/217.wav", + "text": "我再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/218.wav", + "text": "編了870億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/219.wav", + "text": "現在撥多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/220.wav", + "text": "撥了150億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/221.wav", + "text": "元防疫紓困預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/222.wav", + "text": "經濟部亂編預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/223.wav", + "text": "編了870億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/224.wav", + "text": "結果到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/225.wav", + "text": "才撥了150億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/226.wav", + "text": "到現在其他都沒撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/227.wav", + "text": "表示當時預���亂編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/228.wav", + "text": "最嚴重的問題是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/229.wav", + "text": "翁重鈞提過兩次我提了一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/230.wav", + "text": "這些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/231.wav", + "text": "必須專款專用不可以挪用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/232.wav", + "text": "只能用於中小企業信保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/233.wav", + "text": "我要問主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/234.wav", + "text": "有沒有已經挪用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/235.wav", + "text": "已經撥入的就不能夠移用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/236.wav", + "text": "我們都沒有流用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/237.wav", + "text": "那個只是原來編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/238.wav", + "text": "600億的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/239.wav", + "text": "其中100億這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/240.wav", + "text": "後來我們變聰明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/241.wav", + "text": "不是撥入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/242.wav", + "text": "你很聰明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/243.wav", + "text": "用撥入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/244.wav", + "text": "撥入當然專款專用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/245.wav", + "text": "不然瘋了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/246.wav", + "text": "撥入當然專款專用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/247.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/248.wav", + "text": "我怎麼會騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/249.wav", + "text": "我唸給你聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/250.wav", + "text": "附帶決議我都帶來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/251.wav", + "text": "你講的第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/252.wav", + "text": "原來600億的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/253.wav", + "text": "我後來都寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/254.wav", + "text": "專款專用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/255.wav", + "text": "你竟然挪用那870億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/256.wav", + "text": "主計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/257.wav", + "text": "原預算600億的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/258.wav", + "text": "是撥入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/259.wav", + "text": "後來我們學聰明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/260.wav", + "text": "再提三次附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/261.wav", + "text": "你可能沒有仔細看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/262.wav", + "text": "你去查清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/263.wav", + "text": "我可以把原決議給你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/264.wav", + "text": "有空間可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/265.wav", + "text": "沒有空間處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/266.wav", + "text": "這是第一次吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/267.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/268.wav", + "text": "講的是本預算600億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/269.wav", + "text": "你寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/270.wav", + "text": "撥入的話不可以挪用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/271.wav", + "text": "廢話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/272.wav", + "text": "撥入就撥進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/273.wav", + "text": "當然專款專用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/274.wav", + "text": "我跟翁重鈞學聰明了決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/275.wav", + "text": "在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/276.wav", + "text": "先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/277.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/278.wav", + "text": "你通過了主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/279.wav", + "text": "從紓困開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/280.wav", + "text": "每一次都吵同樣問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/281.wav", + "text": "他只有這一招而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/282.wav", + "text": "本人也要提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/283.wav", + "text": "我唸給你聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/284.wav", + "text": "在這裡吵過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/285.wav", + "text": "不你先跟我解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/286.wav", + "text": "條例寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/287.wav", + "text": "是可以流用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/288.wav", + "text": "條例就是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/289.wav", + "text": "但他叫人家不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/290.wav", + "text": "他每次都吵這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/291.wav", + "text": "你當時也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/292.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/293.wav", + "text": "那是另外一我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/294.wav", + "text": "什麼依法行事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/295.wav", + "text": "視同法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/296.wav", + "text": "條例是寫可以流用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/297.wav", + "text": "併同通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/298.wav", + "text": "決議違反法律無效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/299.wav", + "text": "你當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/300.wav", + "text": "乎沒仔細看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/301.wav", + "text": "我怎麼沒仔細看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/302.wav", + "text": "我很仔細聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/303.wav", + "text": "我知道你在講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/304.wav", + "text": "我故意不跟你們吵架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/305.wav", + "text": "我們講真的不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/306.wav", + "text": "必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/307.wav", + "text": "三四年來都說這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/308.wav", + "text": "我請院長處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/309.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/310.wav", + "text": "各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/311.wav", + "text": "要做通則上的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/312.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/313.wav", + "text": "講過很多次要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/314.wav", + "text": "錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/315.wav", + "text": "或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/316.wav", + "text": "當時你說在預估經濟成長時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/317.wav", + "text": "電子業與機械業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/318.wav", + "text": "總之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/319.wav", + "text": "問題在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/320.wav", + "text": "跟進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/321.wav", + "text": "這樣的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/322.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣的政策實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/323.wav", + "text": "這變成是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/324.wav", + "text": "差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/325.wav", + "text": "\n民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/326.wav", + "text": "有勞保撥補問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/327.wav", + "text": "有台電中油虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/328.wav", + "text": "問題乃至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/329.wav", + "text": "其他的居住正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/330.wav", + "text": "當然知道啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/331.wav", + "text": "堅持到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/332.wav", + "text": "因為我們對國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/333.wav", + "text": "沒有期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/334.wav", + "text": "我們對國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/335.wav", + "text": "有什麼期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/336.wav", + "text": "但民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/337.wav", + "text": "發言時讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/338.wav", + "text": "我非常感動因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/339.wav", + "text": "們就是要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/340.wav", + "text": "艱苦人站在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/341.wav", + "text": "艱苦人站在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/342.wav", + "text": "講這我是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/343.wav", + "text": "做一般性的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/344.wav", + "text": "一般性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/345.wav", + "text": "第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/346.wav", + "text": "當然就是一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/347.wav", + "text": "一般性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/348.wav", + "text": "你故意在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/349.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/350.wav", + "text": "你要主持一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/351.wav", + "text": "他都不讓人講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/352.wav", + "text": "發現金的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/353.wav", + "text": "會出現在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/354.wav", + "text": "撥補的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/355.wav", + "text": "我講的是一般性問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/356.wav", + "text": "所出現的問題是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/357.wav", + "text": "勞保撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/358.wav", + "text": "健保撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/359.wav", + "text": "及台電中油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/360.wav", + "text": "虧損要撥補時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/361.wav", + "text": "這是最基本的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/362.wav", + "text": "也就是解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/363.wav", + "text": "現在虧損的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/364.wav", + "text": "制度性改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/365.wav", + "text": "方案在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/366.wav", + "text": "針對勞保改革提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/367.wav", + "text": "最卑微要求僅是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/368.wav", + "text": "還有送進草案提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/369.wav", + "text": "勞保要怎麼改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/370.wav", + "text": "這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/371.wav", + "text": "卻連草案都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/372.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/373.wav", + "text": "實可以問一下主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/374.wav", + "text": "有可能再多出3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/375.wav", + "text": "來做分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/376.wav", + "text": "嗎明年有沒有可能再多出3,800" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/377.wav", + "text": "沒有的話怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/378.wav", + "text": "所以還是要回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/379.wav", + "text": "要告訴我們臺灣社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/380.wav", + "text": "改革方案在哪裡現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/381.wav", + "text": "是一般性問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/382.wav", + "text": "那麼接下來就是居住問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/383.wav", + "text": "前設定臺北為850萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/384.wav", + "text": "其他縣市為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/385.wav", + "text": "我和賴士葆委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/386.wav", + "text": "在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/387.wav", + "text": "財政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/388.wav", + "text": "已經針對這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/389.wav", + "text": "非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/390.wav", + "text": "激動的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/391.wav", + "text": "因為我與他的見解恰恰相反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/392.wav", + "text": "竟涉及分配問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/393.wav", + "text": "為什麼你們會決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/394.wav", + "text": "其他縣市為700萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/395.wav", + "text": "臺北就是850萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/396.wav", + "text": "每一個臺灣人在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/397.wav", + "text": "國家面前應該是平等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/398.wav", + "text": "看不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/399.wav", + "text": "至少要補到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/400.wav", + "text": "最艱苦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/401.wav", + "text": "房貸負擔率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/402.wav", + "text": "最高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/403.wav", + "text": "背到哇哇叫的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/404.wav", + "text": "我在講一般性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/405.wav", + "text": "講交通問題就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/406.wav", + "text": "不要激動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/407.wav", + "text": "交通的問題更離譜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/408.wav", + "text": "你都沒有來你看電視而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/409.wav", + "text": "現在是現場給你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/410.wav", + "text": "交通問題更離譜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/411.wav", + "text": "你現在就花了這兩百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/412.wav", + "text": "元去解決北北基桃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/413.wav", + "text": "這也是一個區域的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/414.wav", + "text": "除了臺北以外的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/415.wav", + "text": "大眾運輸交通工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/416.wav", + "text": "是很不好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/417.wav", + "text": "包括新竹市也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/418.wav", + "text": "南部更不用講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/419.wav", + "text": "所以這兩百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/420.wav", + "text": "元到最後分配到的地方是哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/421.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/422.wav", + "text": "要怎麼分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/423.wav", + "text": "才能夠支持最艱苦的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/424.wav", + "text": "這才一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/425.wav", + "text": "\n所以我要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/426.wav", + "text": "這個3,800億元特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/427.wav", + "text": "你們並沒有替最辛苦的人設想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/428.wav", + "text": "們的政策沒有支持到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/429.wav", + "text": "在臺灣社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/430.wav", + "text": "那些很辛苦的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/431.wav", + "text": "最不樂見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/432.wav", + "text": "有很多細節的預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/433.wav", + "text": "但是總體來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/434.wav", + "text": "一個國家的正當性及基礎在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/435.wav", + "text": "應該是要去支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/436.wav", + "text": "這些最辛苦的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/437.wav", + "text": "主席各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/438.wav", + "text": "不能講沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/439.wav", + "text": "聽起來有一點像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/440.wav", + "text": "高鐵已經開到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/441.wav", + "text": "大家都要站在最窮苦的人身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/442.wav", + "text": "我要強調的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/443.wav", + "text": "剛才柯總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/444.wav", + "text": "數字會說話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/445.wav", + "text": "院長前瞻預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/446.wav", + "text": "好像不是你當院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/447.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/448.wav", + "text": "不是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/449.wav", + "text": "前瞻預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/450.wav", + "text": "我們砍多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/451.wav", + "text": "我就講數字會說話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/452.wav", + "text": "戰機購案用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/453.wav", + "text": "根本不能動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/454.wav", + "text": "要刪多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/455.wav", + "text": "你就說統統不能刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/456.wav", + "text": "要買美國飛機誰敢講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/457.wav", + "text": "沒有人敢講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/458.wav", + "text": "但其他的行政費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/459.wav", + "text": "還是刪了千分之一點三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/460.wav", + "text": "結果現在只有刪了600多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/461.wav", + "text": "也有13億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/462.wav", + "text": "51億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/463.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/464.wav", + "text": "結果現在只有砍了600多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/465.wav", + "text": "沒意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/466.wav", + "text": "召協商如果真的要尊重在野黨的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/467.wav", + "text": "通刪的科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/468.wav", + "text": "比如業務費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/469.wav", + "text": "就可以大筆一揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/470.wav", + "text": "全部砍10%或多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/471.wav", + "text": "我再強調一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/472.wav", + "text": "前瞻預算砍了千分之六點一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/473.wav", + "text": "2,400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/474.wav", + "text": "海空戰機預算還砍了千分之一點三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/475.wav", + "text": "結果我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/476.wav", + "text": "連千分之一都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/477.wav", + "text": "千分之一就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/478.wav", + "text": ",400總共2,400" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/479.wav", + "text": ",400" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/480.wav", + "text": "台電的不能扣掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/481.wav", + "text": "好啦扣掉剩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/482.wav", + "text": "1,400" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/483.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/484.wav", + "text": "你先講清楚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/485.wav", + "text": "你剛才講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/486.wav", + "text": "勞保的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/487.wav", + "text": "你寫的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/488.wav", + "text": "和我們寫的一樣都要撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/489.wav", + "text": "勞健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/490.wav", + "text": "台電中油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/491.wav", + "text": "你寫的和我一樣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/492.wav", + "text": "你說勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/493.wav", + "text": "他提出一個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/494.wav", + "text": "明年還要1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/495.wav", + "text": "元耶你要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/496.wav", + "text": "差異在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/497.wav", + "text": "這是最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/498.wav", + "text": "之前就有送過我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/499.wav", + "text": "忘了告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/500.wav", + "text": "算案再編1,000億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/501.wav", + "text": "元民進黨執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/502.wav", + "text": "總共編了1,470億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/503.wav", + "text": "難道沒有在照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/504.wav", + "text": "一直撥補是杯水車薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/505.wav", + "text": "我就跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/506.wav", + "text": "撥補是杯水車薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/507.wav", + "text": "但是撥補之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/508.wav", + "text": "還是要去解決源頭的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/509.wav", + "text": "事關國家財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/510.wav", + "text": "你這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/511.wav", + "text": "我沒辦法接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/512.wav", + "text": "怎麼會沒辦法接受呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/513.wav", + "text": "大家說話不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/514.wav", + "text": "自己還在罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/515.wav", + "text": "你的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/516.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/517.wav", + "text": "你要撥補的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/518.wav", + "text": "當然現在已經是虧損了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/519.wav", + "text": "但是現在的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/520.wav", + "text": "是不是要有一個改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/521.wav", + "text": "就這麼簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/522.wav", + "text": "改革方案就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/523.wav", + "text": "錢趕快下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/524.wav", + "text": "錢下去是杯水車薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/525.wav", + "text": "那明年有沒有3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/526.wav", + "text": "你有沒有這麼多超徵稅額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/527.wav", + "text": "請教一下王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/528.wav", + "text": "還是回到我們原本的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/529.wav", + "text": "就是對於特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/530.wav", + "text": "這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/531.wav", + "text": "我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/532.wav", + "text": "870億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/533.wav", + "text": "到中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/534.wav", + "text": "去專款專用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/535.wav", + "text": "目前撥補的情況是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/536.wav", + "text": "我覺得是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/537.wav", + "text": "從這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/538.wav", + "text": "源頭的主題來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/539.wav", + "text": "把它釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/540.wav", + "text": "過去在特別預算所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/541.wav", + "text": "這些主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/542.wav", + "text": "我們的政府部門是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/543.wav", + "text": "按照主決議在進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/544.wav", + "text": "休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/545.wav", + "text": "經過分組理性溝通各" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/546.wav", + "text": "我們希望這個錢要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/547.wav", + "text": "真的用在有需要的地方這是毫無疑義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/548.wav", + "text": "我們先講第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/549.wav", + "text": "但是基於賴士葆委員在第一次審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/550.wav", + "text": "我以為他今天不會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/551.wav", + "text": "結果他又跑出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/552.wav", + "text": "沒有關係我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/553.wav", + "text": "總共刪除1.2億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/554.wav", + "text": "就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/555.wav", + "text": "至於增加這5,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/556.wav", + "text": "科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/557.wav", + "text": "\n第二個結論有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/558.wav", + "text": "流用的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/559.wav", + "text": "雖然法有明文規定可以流用但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/560.wav", + "text": "曾總召他們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/561.wav", + "text": "院會上非常堅持也提了一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/562.wav", + "text": "剛才協商以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/563.wav", + "text": "曾總召要求一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/564.wav", + "text": "以後中小企業信保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/565.wav", + "text": "有需要的時候你一定要把它補足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/566.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣我沒有違反你的原意吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/567.wav", + "text": "有關紓困的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/568.wav", + "text": "本預算後來經過四次追加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/569.wav", + "text": "這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/570.wav", + "text": "編了870億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/571.wav", + "text": "要給中小企業信保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/572.wav", + "text": "去做貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/573.wav", + "text": "因為國內有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/574.wav", + "text": "160萬家中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/575.wav", + "text": "當時主決議是說不可以流用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/576.wav", + "text": "主計長也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/577.wav", + "text": "那時候因為防疫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/578.wav", + "text": "特別需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/579.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/580.wav", + "text": "但我要請主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/581.wav", + "text": "長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/582.wav", + "text": "一下你現在只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/583.wav", + "text": "撥150億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/584.wav", + "text": "中小企業信保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/585.wav", + "text": "有需要的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/586.wav", + "text": "再繼續撥有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/587.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/588.wav", + "text": "中小企業因為防疫而增加的任何部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/589.wav", + "text": "主計總處一定會編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/590.wav", + "text": "適足的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/591.wav", + "text": "不會因為這個而造成它的營運虧損謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/592.wav", + "text": "陳陳椒華第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/593.wav", + "text": "從第1案開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/594.wav", + "text": "喔不要再大體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/595.wav", + "text": "有關刪除的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/596.wav", + "text": "因為依照預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/597.wav", + "text": "並不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/598.wav", + "text": "921震災這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/599.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/600.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂的特別預算不能編預備金嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/601.wav", + "text": "莫拉克也有9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/602.wav", + "text": "每次的特別預算都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/603.wav", + "text": "什麼時候生小孩要多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/604.wav", + "text": "主計長要不要回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/605.wav", + "text": "因為現在你可以自己調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/606.wav", + "text": "第一個是預備金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/607.wav", + "text": "第二個是媒體宣傳費的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/608.wav", + "text": "都應該要刪除一定的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/609.wav", + "text": "讓他講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/610.wav", + "text": "跳來跳去就沒時間了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/611.wav", + "text": "只要用在我們編列的科目裡面就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/612.wav", + "text": "對就是這本預算書上有的科目才可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/613.wav", + "text": "預備金不會用到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/614.wav", + "text": "別的地方去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/615.wav", + "text": "不會用到戰機上面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/616.wav", + "text": "對對對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/617.wav", + "text": "有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/618.wav", + "text": "在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/619.wav", + "text": "法定的用途都在這裡就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/620.wav", + "text": "就是這本裡面都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/621.wav", + "text": "特別條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/622.wav", + "text": "當然優先刪除預備金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/623.wav", + "text": "要怎麼調是他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/624.wav", + "text": "要調哪些項目我尊重大院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/625.wav", + "text": "這個預備金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/626.wav", + "text": "其實編這個沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/627.wav", + "text": "這個真的應該刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/628.wav", + "text": "但是要表決就表決吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/629.wav", + "text": "最後院長裁示total刪除1.2億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/630.wav", + "text": "元其實我是含淚接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/631.wav", + "text": "因為戰機是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/632.wav", + "text": "是2,500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/633.wav", + "text": "的事我們還可以刪到千分之一點三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/634.wav", + "text": "結果現在連千分之一都刪不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/635.wav", + "text": "趕快給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/636.wav", + "text": "好那我們現在就開始從這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/637.wav", + "text": "但是我們的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/638.wav", + "text": "媒體宣傳的部分要回一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/639.wav", + "text": "是要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/640.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/641.wav", + "text": "我們讓台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/642.wav", + "text": "各黨派是這個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/643.wav", + "text": "本來也有提全數減列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/644.wav", + "text": "列如果不行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/645.wav", + "text": "你說哪一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/646.wav", + "text": "預備金啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/647.wav", + "text": "預備金到預備金部分再編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/648.wav", + "text": "編13億5,000萬元的預備金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/649.wav", + "text": "以前的前例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/650.wav", + "text": "本就不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/651.wav", + "text": "莫拉克風災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/652.wav", + "text": "都跟這個不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/653.wav", + "text": "哪有不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/654.wav", + "text": "抱歉我們提一個都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/655.wav", + "text": "都是特別預算哪有不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/656.wav", + "text": "如果有需要你就告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/657.wav", + "text": "要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/658.wav", + "text": "支持剛剛民眾黨所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/659.wav", + "text": "就是先涷起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/660.wav", + "text": "大家在前面的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/661.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/662.wav", + "text": "我們現在是不是從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/663.wav", + "text": "這個不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/664.wav", + "text": "一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/665.wav", + "text": "是普發現金1萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/666.wav", + "text": "合併好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/667.wav", + "text": "\n合併成一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/668.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/669.wav", + "text": "第4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/670.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/671.wav", + "text": "這個就是有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/672.wav", + "text": "撥補的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/673.wav", + "text": "現在我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/674.wav", + "text": "我提一個建請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/675.wav", + "text": "在財務調度許可下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/676.wav", + "text": "可以提前撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/677.wav", + "text": "就是這樣而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/678.wav", + "text": "我們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/679.wav", + "text": "但是以我的案為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/680.wav", + "text": "3個人領銜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/681.wav", + "text": "會有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/682.wav", + "text": "幾個人都沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/683.wav", + "text": "院長等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/684.wav", + "text": "第4案有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/685.wav", + "text": "可以提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/686.wav", + "text": "可以提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/687.wav", + "text": "你不是也喜歡撥補嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/688.wav", + "text": "不是但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/689.wav", + "text": "但這個又調整為提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/690.wav", + "text": "然後也沒有任何一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/691.wav", + "text": "改革的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/692.wav", + "text": "什麼叫改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/693.wav", + "text": "給你還要提改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/694.wav", + "text": "你的案子和我的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/695.wav", + "text": "都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/696.wav", + "text": "提前於112年度去撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/697.wav", + "text": "沒有撥補其他方案都是假的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/698.wav", + "text": "我有個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/699.wav", + "text": "你看我的第5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/700.wav", + "text": "第5案是要撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/701.wav", + "text": "這個是許部長答復我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/702.wav", + "text": "撥補200億做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/703.wav", + "text": "現在潛在負債11兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/704.wav", + "text": "每一年增加5,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/705.wav", + "text": "就是不提出改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/706.wav", + "text": "拖延要放給下一任政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/707.wav", + "text": "要不然你就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/708.wav", + "text": "你就是打算不改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/709.wav", + "text": "這個應該是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/710.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/711.wav", + "text": "想清楚一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/712.wav", + "text": "你本來是一年一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/713.wav", + "text": "讓它可以提出一個改革的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/714.wav", + "text": "嘛你現在還提前去讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/715.wav", + "text": "樣它就不用改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/716.wav", + "text": "應該是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/717.wav", + "text": "支持補嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/718.wav", + "text": "大家的想法是說支持補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/719.wav", + "text": "根本性的問題還是要去改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/720.wav", + "text": "在這個同時你也要思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/721.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣正本清源解決這個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/722.wav", + "text": "這才是比較健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/723.wav", + "text": "也是一個長久之計先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/724.wav", + "text": "你看我提的第5案就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/725.wav", + "text": "我們二個看法一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/726.wav", + "text": "英雄所見略同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/727.wav", + "text": "在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/728.wav", + "text": "要求政府未提出改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/729.wav", + "text": "方案完成立法前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/730.wav", + "text": "每年至少撥補1,000億到1,500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/731.wav", + "text": "要改革是陳建仁講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/732.wav", + "text": "所以本來逐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/733.wav", + "text": "是比較合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/734.wav", + "text": "而不是用這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/735.wav", + "text": "本來對馬英九就沒有任何期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/736.wav", + "text": "了你在比馬英九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/737.wav", + "text": "不然他怎麼會下臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/738.wav", + "text": "時財務沒有這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/739.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/740.wav", + "text": "就是你們要做得比國民黨還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/741.wav", + "text": "嘛對臺灣這個共同體有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/742.wav", + "text": "國民黨已經沒有期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/743.wav", + "text": "了所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/744.wav", + "text": "執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/745.wav", + "text": "可以提出一個有建設性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/746.wav", + "text": "對臺灣有幫助的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/747.wav", + "text": "對民進黨更沒有期待啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/748.wav", + "text": "第4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/749.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/750.wav", + "text": "第4案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/751.wav", + "text": "你自己的人都講說要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/752.wav", + "text": "他說的不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/753.wav", + "text": "我對於你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/754.wav", + "text": "但希望你贊成我的第5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/755.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/756.wav", + "text": "一案一案來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/757.wav", + "text": "第4案先通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/758.wav", + "text": "就保留啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/759.wav", + "text": "第幾案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/760.wav", + "text": "都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/761.wav", + "text": "\n第7案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/762.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/763.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/764.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/765.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/766.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/767.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/768.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/769.wav", + "text": "了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/770.wav", + "text": "第6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/771.wav", + "text": "讓許部長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/772.wav", + "text": "我寫了半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/773.wav", + "text": "這麼快就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/774.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/775.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/776.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/777.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/778.wav", + "text": "請許部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/779.wav", + "text": "是曾委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/780.wav", + "text": "行政院將基本工資調至3萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/781.wav", + "text": "也是我們努力的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/782.wav", + "text": "的基本工資審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/783.wav", + "text": "要共同決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/784.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/785.wav", + "text": "這一案作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/786.wav", + "text": "爰要求勞動部應定期召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/787.wav", + "text": "基本工資審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/788.wav", + "text": "檢討基本工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/789.wav", + "text": "這也只能這樣研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/790.wav", + "text": "蔡總統上任後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/791.wav", + "text": "調了7次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/792.wav", + "text": "調到今年的2萬6,400元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/793.wav", + "text": "時薪也從12" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/794.wav", + "text": "調到108十幾元了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/795.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/796.wav", + "text": "啊為什麼沒辦法做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/797.wav", + "text": "第9案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/798.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/799.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/800.wav", + "text": "研議而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/801.wav", + "text": "還是要寫進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/802.wav", + "text": "目標朝向3萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/803.wav", + "text": "只是改成研議而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/804.wav", + "text": "沒有拿掉3萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/805.wav", + "text": "第10案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/806.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/807.wav", + "text": "第10案是修正成怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/808.wav", + "text": "基本工資審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/809.wav", + "text": "檢討基本工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/810.wav", + "text": "不要我要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/811.wav", + "text": "好那第10案就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/812.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/813.wav", + "text": "建請文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/814.wav", + "text": "11案主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/815.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/816.wav", + "text": "第12案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/817.wav", + "text": "因為你們花了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/818.wav", + "text": "3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/819.wav", + "text": "元做一個專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/820.wav", + "text": "真的是很正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/821.wav", + "text": "了你一定要來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/822.wav", + "text": "照我的提案通過跟排不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/823.wav", + "text": "這麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/824.wav", + "text": "的預算又花了3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/825.wav", + "text": "都可以啦做一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/826.wav", + "text": "總召主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/827.wav", + "text": "到了三個月後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/828.wav", + "text": "不是委員會的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/829.wav", + "text": "立法院的問題歸立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/830.wav", + "text": "但他得要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/831.wav", + "text": "花了3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/832.wav", + "text": "元來立法院做個專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/833.wav", + "text": "同意同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/834.wav", + "text": "專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/835.wav", + "text": "對三個月報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/836.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/837.wav", + "text": "立法院的問題我們自己解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/838.wav", + "text": "這個不太實際吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/839.wav", + "text": "結束後再來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/840.wav", + "text": "他們有一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/841.wav", + "text": "剛開始好文字改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/842.wav", + "text": "結束後三個月可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/843.wav", + "text": "結束是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/844.wav", + "text": "預算執行結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/845.wav", + "text": "後面有一個總案的案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/846.wav", + "text": "到明年嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/847.wav", + "text": "114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/848.wav", + "text": "這個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/849.wav", + "text": "執行到114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/850.wav", + "text": "114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/851.wav", + "text": "亂來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/852.wav", + "text": "期中報告是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/853.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/854.wav", + "text": "這麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/855.wav", + "text": "一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/856.wav", + "text": "每年來報告一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/857.wav", + "text": "一年一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/858.wav", + "text": "一年一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/859.wav", + "text": "不要走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/860.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛柯總召講說三個月太短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/861.wav", + "text": "一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/862.wav", + "text": "三個月修正為一年好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/863.wav", + "text": "每年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/864.wav", + "text": "每年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/865.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/866.wav", + "text": "第16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/867.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/868.wav", + "text": "先一年好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/869.wav", + "text": "好一年好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/870.wav", + "text": "院長等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/871.wav", + "text": "第16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/872.wav", + "text": "是民眾黨提的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/873.wav", + "text": "算於施行屆滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/874.wav", + "text": "3月底前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/875.wav", + "text": "就是完畢以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/876.wav", + "text": "114年12月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/877.wav", + "text": "那我們兩案併一案好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/878.wav", + "text": "我們這一案就是併成一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/879.wav", + "text": "建議下個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/880.wav", + "text": "結束前先報告一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/881.wav", + "text": "就是這一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/882.wav", + "text": "下個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/883.wav", + "text": "就是本屆結束前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/884.wav", + "text": "至少報告一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/885.wav", + "text": "本屆結束前至少報告一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/886.wav", + "text": "好全部都是錢大家要拚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/887.wav", + "text": "樣才有鼓勵效應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/888.wav", + "text": "到時候大家都在選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/889.wav", + "text": "一年後啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/890.wav", + "text": "一年後好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/891.wav", + "text": "我看就一年啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/892.wav", + "text": "滿一年的時候來做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/893.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/894.wav", + "text": "\n第13案主決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/895.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/896.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/897.wav", + "text": "一個月改三個月好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/898.wav", + "text": "明明都是一個月怎麼改三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/899.wav", + "text": "那我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/900.wav", + "text": "統一改為三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/901.wav", + "text": "所以第15案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/902.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/903.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/904.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/905.wav", + "text": "就是一年以後除了進度之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/906.wav", + "text": "經濟效益也一併報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/907.wav", + "text": "這個主要是進度第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/908.wav", + "text": "16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/909.wav", + "text": "併第12案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/910.wav", + "text": "就是第16案跟第12案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/911.wav", + "text": "都是每一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/912.wav", + "text": "對兩案併在一起啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/913.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/914.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/915.wav", + "text": "\n第17案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/916.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/917.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/918.wav", + "text": "把它修改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/919.wav", + "text": "第三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/920.wav", + "text": "就改為三個月\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/921.wav", + "text": "第18案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/922.wav", + "text": "二週是不是也改成三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/923.wav", + "text": "第18案就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/924.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/925.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/926.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/927.wav", + "text": "\n第19案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/928.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/929.wav", + "text": "好沒意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/930.wav", + "text": "\n第20案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/931.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/932.wav", + "text": "有作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/933.wav", + "text": "沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/934.wav", + "text": "邱委員已經同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/935.wav", + "text": "有一些文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/936.wav", + "text": "就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/937.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/938.wav", + "text": "時間改為三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/939.wav", + "text": "所以這個主決議就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/940.wav", + "text": "\n第24案主決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/941.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/942.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/943.wav", + "text": "第27案主決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/944.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/945.wav", + "text": "一審內政部組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/946.wav", + "text": "大家喝休息一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/947.wav", + "text": "休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/948.wav", + "text": "現在列席的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/949.wav", + "text": "財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/950.wav", + "text": "剛剛有介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/951.wav", + "text": "了現在增加教育部的潘部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/952.wav", + "text": "\n第35案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/953.wav", + "text": "\n第36案主決議文字修正沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/954.wav", + "text": "\n第37案主決議文字修正沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/955.wav", + "text": "\n接下來是教育部\n第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/956.wav", + "text": "38案主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/957.wav", + "text": "\n第39案主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/958.wav", + "text": "\n第40案主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/959.wav", + "text": "有修正嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/960.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/961.wav", + "text": "那個本來就改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/962.wav", + "text": "本來就改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/963.wav", + "text": "所以就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/964.wav", + "text": "王部長在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/965.wav", + "text": "\n請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/966.wav", + "text": "這個就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/967.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/968.wav", + "text": "沒有意見保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/969.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/970.wav", + "text": "第45案因為它要求要緩漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/971.wav", + "text": "才可以動支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/972.wav", + "text": "這個沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/973.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/974.wav", + "text": "第45案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/975.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/976.wav", + "text": "\n第46案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/977.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/978.wav", + "text": "有同意改主決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/979.wav", + "text": "然後文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/980.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/981.wav", + "text": "對同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/982.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/983.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/984.wav", + "text": "\n第47案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/985.wav", + "text": "第47案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/986.wav", + "text": "對第47案改主決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/987.wav", + "text": "第47案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/988.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/989.wav", + "text": "第49案委員同意改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/990.wav", + "text": "應該是漏刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/991.wav", + "text": "所以是不是建議就改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/992.wav", + "text": "凍結的部分是不是可以改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/993.wav", + "text": "是不是可以凍啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/994.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/995.wav", + "text": "委員已經同意改主決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/996.wav", + "text": "49案就改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/997.wav", + "text": "文字要不要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/998.wav", + "text": "文字要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/999.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1000.wav", + "text": "\n第50案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1001.wav", + "text": "\n第51案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1002.wav", + "text": "\n第52案主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1003.wav", + "text": "文字有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1004.wav", + "text": "他沒有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1005.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員沒有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1006.wav", + "text": "那好第49案改為保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1007.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1008.wav", + "text": "\n現在看第52案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1009.wav", + "text": "52案有跟委員報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1010.wav", + "text": "委員有蓋章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1011.wav", + "text": "但是黨團沒有蓋章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1012.wav", + "text": "是不是可以按照我們修正的文字通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1013.wav", + "text": "第幾案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1014.wav", + "text": "林委員有同意修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1015.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1016.wav", + "text": "等一下他們叫我們三年不得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1017.wav", + "text": "請經濟部提出電價調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1018.wav", + "text": "說明書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1019.wav", + "text": "告就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1020.wav", + "text": "那就文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1021.wav", + "text": "52案主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1022.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1023.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1024.wav", + "text": "要文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1025.wav", + "text": "也要文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1026.wav", + "text": "檢討錯誤的能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1027.wav", + "text": "那我要加修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1028.wav", + "text": "為嚴重錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1029.wav", + "text": "你還不承認錯誤啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1030.wav", + "text": "那我要加兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1031.wav", + "text": "那什麼正確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1032.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1033.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1034.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1035.wav", + "text": "案既然要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1036.wav", + "text": "要求政府檢討錯誤對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1037.wav", + "text": "我要寫嚴重錯誤加兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1038.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1039.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1040.wav", + "text": "加兩個字嚴重錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1041.wav", + "text": "嚴重錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1042.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1043.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1044.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1045.wav", + "text": "修正以後保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1046.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1047.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1048.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1049.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1050.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1051.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1052.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1053.wav", + "text": "55案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1054.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1055.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1056.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1057.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1058.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1059.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1060.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1061.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1062.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1063.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1064.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1065.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1066.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1067.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1068.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1069.wav", + "text": "\n第60案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1070.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1071.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1072.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1073.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1074.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1075.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1076.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1077.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1078.wav", + "text": "可不可以請經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1079.wav", + "text": "能夠嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1080.wav", + "text": "善用公帑去做輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1081.wav", + "text": "或者是下不為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1082.wav", + "text": "以後不能用公帑去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1083.wav", + "text": "輔導違法工廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1084.wav", + "text": "好第63案就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1085.wav", + "text": "因為沒有共識就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1086.wav", + "text": "通過保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1087.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1088.wav", + "text": "64案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1089.wav", + "text": "主決議也是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1090.wav", + "text": "65案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1091.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1092.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1093.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1094.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1095.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1096.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1097.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1098.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1099.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1100.wav", + "text": "做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1101.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1102.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1103.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1104.wav", + "text": "50億改成5億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1105.wav", + "text": "就是那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1106.wav", + "text": "寫錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1107.wav", + "text": "那就文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1108.wav", + "text": "所以第69案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1109.wav", + "text": "我問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1110.wav", + "text": "前面講有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1111.wav", + "text": "870萬還沒有撥補完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1112.wav", + "text": "現在又搞個5億要幹嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1113.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1114.wav", + "text": "撥不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1115.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1116.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1117.wav", + "text": "只有稅籍登記的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1118.wav", + "text": "這些中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1119.wav", + "text": "沒有再保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1120.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1121.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1122.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1123.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1124.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1125.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1126.wav", + "text": "70案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1127.wav", + "text": "現在換交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1128.wav", + "text": "已經跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1129.wav", + "text": "這個本來就已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1130.wav", + "text": "中小企業這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1131.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1132.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1133.wav", + "text": "它變成書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1134.wav", + "text": "你改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1135.wav", + "text": "書面就沒有凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1136.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1137.wav", + "text": "哪有改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1138.wav", + "text": "本來就沒有改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1139.wav", + "text": "保留保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1140.wav", + "text": "黨團不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1141.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1142.wav", + "text": "介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1143.wav", + "text": "部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1144.wav", + "text": "介紹交通部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1145.wav", + "text": "王" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1146.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1147.wav", + "text": "就是交通部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1148.wav", + "text": "70案凍結1%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1149.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1150.wav", + "text": "案同樣凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1151.wav", + "text": "因為在委員會已經凍3,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1152.wav", + "text": "建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1153.wav", + "text": "建議什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1154.wav", + "text": "建議再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1155.wav", + "text": "併案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1156.wav", + "text": "併案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1157.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1158.wav", + "text": "這個不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1159.wav", + "text": "啊這個是不一樣的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1160.wav", + "text": "你們要把國際觀光客送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1161.wav", + "text": "針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1162.wav", + "text": "有一個是希望你們去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1163.wav", + "text": "做一些宣傳跟積極推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1164.wav", + "text": "這有什麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1165.wav", + "text": "這個願意做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1166.wav", + "text": "所以第70案是OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1167.wav", + "text": "第71案呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1168.wav", + "text": "凍結數併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1169.wav", + "text": "啊其他的請他們提一個書面報告嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1170.wav", + "text": "你要求的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1171.wav", + "text": "去寫沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1172.wav", + "text": "凍結數併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1173.wav", + "text": "其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1174.wav", + "text": "你們要求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1175.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1176.wav", + "text": "因為委員會已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1177.wav", + "text": "所以這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1178.wav", + "text": "提案內容的資料我們都肯定可以做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1179.wav", + "text": "現在只是凍結的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1180.wav", + "text": "這個不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1181.wav", + "text": "一個很基礎的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1182.wav", + "text": "就是文字上修正為書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1183.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1184.wav", + "text": "第70案第71案第72案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1185.wav", + "text": "的凍結數併委員會併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1186.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1187.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議���理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1188.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1189.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1190.wav", + "text": "第75案凍結數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1191.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1192.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1193.wav", + "text": "76案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1194.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1195.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1196.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1197.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1198.wav", + "text": "有意見再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1199.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1200.wav", + "text": "委員同意改書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1201.wav", + "text": "檢討報告改為書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1202.wav", + "text": "對第78案改書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1203.wav", + "text": "好改書面報告第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1204.wav", + "text": "78案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1205.wav", + "text": "做文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1206.wav", + "text": "改書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1207.wav", + "text": "好那就文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1208.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1209.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1210.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1211.wav", + "text": "\n第82案主決議做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1212.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1213.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1214.wav", + "text": "凍結100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1215.wav", + "text": "是不是併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1216.wav", + "text": "好是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1217.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1218.wav", + "text": "那文字要不要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1219.wav", + "text": "好那文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1220.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1221.wav", + "text": "第84案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1222.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1223.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1224.wav", + "text": "要改書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1225.wav", + "text": "有一個書面檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1226.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1227.wav", + "text": "做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1228.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1229.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1230.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1231.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1232.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1233.wav", + "text": "也是一樣修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1234.wav", + "text": "好文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1235.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1236.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1237.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1238.wav", + "text": "要改書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1239.wav", + "text": "好改書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1240.wav", + "text": "所以第88案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1241.wav", + "text": "做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1242.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1243.wav", + "text": "檢討報告就是書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1244.wav", + "text": "再來第89案遵照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1245.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1246.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1247.wav", + "text": "接下來處理勞動部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1248.wav", + "text": "請大家看勞動部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1249.wav", + "text": "案是不是就照原來的保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1250.wav", + "text": "案改了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1251.wav", + "text": "案是我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1252.wav", + "text": "改掉了三分之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1253.wav", + "text": "我已經分辨不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1254.wav", + "text": "那是我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1255.wav", + "text": "結果原來是我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1256.wav", + "text": "那就通過就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1257.wav", + "text": "要照我原來的通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1258.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1259.wav", + "text": "這個不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1260.wav", + "text": "試圖提出一個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1261.wav", + "text": "就是合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1262.wav", + "text": "因為你看剛剛交通部也都是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1263.wav", + "text": "有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1264.wav", + "text": "文字改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1265.wav", + "text": "也改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1266.wav", + "text": "改到我認不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1267.wav", + "text": "這是我的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1268.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1269.wav", + "text": "你這個撥補應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1270.wav", + "text": "90案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1271.wav", + "text": "第91案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1272.wav", + "text": "第92案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1273.wav", + "text": "第93案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1274.wav", + "text": "\n請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1275.wav", + "text": "第94案主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1276.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1277.wav", + "text": "第94案我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1278.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1279.wav", + "text": "院長等一下第93" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1280.wav", + "text": "案這個部分你沒有辦法接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1281.wav", + "text": "讓你去蒐集各方的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1282.wav", + "text": "你可以開一個會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1283.wav", + "text": "不管那個名稱���做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1284.wav", + "text": "勞保改革國是會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1285.wav", + "text": "還是叫做什麼樣的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1286.wav", + "text": "然後可以去蒐集大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1287.wav", + "text": "啊這個不是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1288.wav", + "text": "對啊那為什麼不能通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1289.wav", + "text": "還要凍結預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1290.wav", + "text": "名稱叫做勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1291.wav", + "text": "召開的國是會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1292.wav", + "text": "嘛不是總統召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1293.wav", + "text": "也不是行政院召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1294.wav", + "text": "的是勞動部召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1295.wav", + "text": "所以你要叫什麼名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1296.wav", + "text": "我們不care這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1297.wav", + "text": "已經保留我們就不要再講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1298.wav", + "text": "但是你至少要去蒐集大家和專家學者的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1299.wav", + "text": "認真地來對待這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1300.wav", + "text": "早點講嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1301.wav", + "text": "你就不要有國是會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1302.wav", + "text": "委員會就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1303.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1304.wav", + "text": "他說不要叫國是會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1305.wav", + "text": "國是會議刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1306.wav", + "text": "那就修正我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1307.wav", + "text": "我是說叫什麼名稱沒差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1308.wav", + "text": "我們那個時候在開委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1309.wav", + "text": "就有講到國是會議是不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1310.wav", + "text": "馬上召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1311.wav", + "text": "我不知道原來你是care這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1312.wav", + "text": "好暫時保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1313.wav", + "text": "一下再講好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1314.wav", + "text": "\n第95案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1315.wav", + "text": "主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1316.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1317.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1318.wav", + "text": "等一下院長第92案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1319.wav", + "text": "第92案的部分改成主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1320.wav", + "text": "可以你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1321.wav", + "text": "先保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1322.wav", + "text": "因為我是看第92案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1323.wav", + "text": "案的文字改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1324.wav", + "text": "至少要有共識喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1325.wav", + "text": "92" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1326.wav", + "text": "92" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1327.wav", + "text": "案有一個修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1328.wav", + "text": "同意這個修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1329.wav", + "text": "凍結改掉嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1330.wav", + "text": "第92案修正文字同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1331.wav", + "text": "92" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1332.wav", + "text": "案按照修正的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1333.wav", + "text": "93案不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1334.wav", + "text": "改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1335.wav", + "text": "留了很多部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1336.wav", + "text": "92案你要3個月內提出報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1337.wav", + "text": "可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1338.wav", + "text": "我們有修正文字喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1339.wav", + "text": "修正文字在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1340.wav", + "text": "修正文字在新的這本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1341.wav", + "text": "92" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1342.wav", + "text": "3個月提書面報告啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1343.wav", + "text": "他改的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1344.wav", + "text": "勞動部改的3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1345.wav", + "text": "3個月提出書面報告啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1346.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1347.wav", + "text": "不是書面報告的問題嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1348.wav", + "text": "也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1349.wav", + "text": "保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1350.wav", + "text": "精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1351.wav", + "text": "間隔年限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1352.wav", + "text": "或檢討勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1353.wav", + "text": "精算方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1354.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1355.wav", + "text": "財務結構調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1356.wav", + "text": "你做的出來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1357.wav", + "text": "因應勞保制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1358.wav", + "text": "因應勞保制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1359.wav", + "text": "結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1360.wav", + "text": "上一屆他就有提出草案了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1361.wav", + "text": "怎麼會做不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1362.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1363.wav", + "text": "你3個月提出報告啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1364.wav", + "text": "3個月的時間啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1365.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1366.wav", + "text": "他改的文字是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1367.wav", + "text": "對制度去做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1368.wav", + "text": "保留再講啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1369.wav", + "text": "報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1370.wav", + "text": "是希望我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1371.wav", + "text": "如果照我們修正的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1372.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1373.wav", + "text": "不要這麼久啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1374.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1375.wav", + "text": "我們現在是3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1376.wav", + "text": "你就研議要幾年再說啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1377.wav", + "text": "柯總召說3個月能研議出來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1378.wav", + "text": "研議縮短��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1379.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1380.wav", + "text": "3個月要提出報告啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1381.wav", + "text": "我知道啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1382.wav", + "text": "你去想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1383.wav", + "text": "現在就是3年嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1384.wav", + "text": "你自己想好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1385.wav", + "text": "搞半天你們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1386.wav", + "text": "還搞不懂提案內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1387.wav", + "text": "還搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1388.wav", + "text": "我們是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1389.wav", + "text": "3年跟2年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1390.wav", + "text": "其實是差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1391.wav", + "text": "不然就保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1392.wav", + "text": "好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1393.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1394.wav", + "text": "那第96案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1395.wav", + "text": "有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1396.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1397.wav", + "text": "修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1398.wav", + "text": "你的早就保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1399.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1400.wav", + "text": "沒意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1401.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1402.wav", + "text": "96" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1403.wav", + "text": "案委員沒有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1404.wav", + "text": "沒有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1405.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1406.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1407.wav", + "text": "96案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1408.wav", + "text": "98案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1409.wav", + "text": "委員不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1410.wav", + "text": "我們修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1411.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1412.wav", + "text": "第99案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1413.wav", + "text": "我們要修改但委員不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1414.wav", + "text": "好就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1415.wav", + "text": "100案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1416.wav", + "text": "101案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1417.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1418.wav", + "text": "我們進行到農" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1419.wav", + "text": "農委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1420.wav", + "text": "我介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1421.wav", + "text": "陳吉仲主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1422.wav", + "text": "101案改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1423.wav", + "text": "改主決議嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1424.wav", + "text": "建議改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1425.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1426.wav", + "text": "好像已經跟委員談好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1427.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1428.wav", + "text": "OK啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1429.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1430.wav", + "text": "沒有它只有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1431.wav", + "text": "沒有說改成主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1432.wav", + "text": "啊你們那時候也同意吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1433.wav", + "text": "凍結數怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1434.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1435.wav", + "text": "他們有談好同意要凍結了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1436.wav", + "text": "這個沒有辦法凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1437.wav", + "text": "因為這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1438.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1439.wav", + "text": "這個不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1440.wav", + "text": "這個我在院會提出質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1441.wav", + "text": "我問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1442.wav", + "text": "這個農村送暖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1443.wav", + "text": "我還特別要求大仁哥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1444.wav", + "text": "暖的部分譬如幸福餐盒已經開始在賣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1445.wav", + "text": "這個月在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1446.wav", + "text": "一週賣8,000盒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1447.wav", + "text": "而且都是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1448.wav", + "text": "\n然後4月1日開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1449.wav", + "text": "每個禮拜要10萬盒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1450.wav", + "text": "所以是不是可以不要凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1451.wav", + "text": "因為這個是要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1452.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會同意以後才能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1453.wav", + "text": "動支會影響到後面的執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1454.wav", + "text": "而且我們全部要在農漁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1455.wav", + "text": "漁村社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1456.wav", + "text": "這條撤案好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1457.wav", + "text": "本來有凍1,000萬是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1458.wav", + "text": "刪1,000萬啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1459.wav", + "text": "本來委員會第1項就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1460.wav", + "text": "刪減1,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1461.wav", + "text": "併刪1,000萬啦好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1462.wav", + "text": "不然改主決議啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1463.wav", + "text": "改主決議啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1464.wav", + "text": "102案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1465.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1466.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1467.wav", + "text": "改成三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1468.wav", + "text": "都是三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1469.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1470.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1471.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1472.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1473.wav", + "text": "全部都改為三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1474.wav", + "text": "都修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1475.wav", + "text": "105案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1476.wav", + "text": "沒有意見也通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1477.wav", + "text": "是不是都改成三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1478.wav", + "text": "那就文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1479.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1480.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1481.wav", + "text": "對修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1482.wav", + "text": "第107案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1483.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1484.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1485.wav", + "text": "好那就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1486.wav", + "text": "三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1487.wav", + "text": "三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1488.wav", + "text": "好文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1489.wav", + "text": "\n第109案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1490.wav", + "text": "做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1491.wav", + "text": "好文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1492.wav", + "text": "在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1493.wav", + "text": "在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1494.wav", + "text": "給大家最新的第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1495.wav", + "text": "110案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1496.wav", + "text": "第109案企業參與是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1497.wav", + "text": "文字修正那個企業參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1498.wav", + "text": "這是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1499.wav", + "text": "東埔蚋溪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1500.wav", + "text": "溪是什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1501.wav", + "text": "可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1502.wav", + "text": "企業參與那個可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1503.wav", + "text": "因為碳權啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1504.wav", + "text": "跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1505.wav", + "text": "其實我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1506.wav", + "text": "正在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1507.wav", + "text": "的2050淨零排放裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1508.wav", + "text": "增匯的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1509.wav", + "text": "歡迎企業ESG" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1510.wav", + "text": "在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1511.wav", + "text": "可以有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1512.wav", + "text": "他們可以轉成所謂的碳權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1513.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1514.wav", + "text": "應該執行林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1515.wav", + "text": "這個沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1516.wav", + "text": "上面一定要種樹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1517.wav", + "text": "這個是一個正面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1518.wav", + "text": "我想是不是做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1519.wav", + "text": "所以第109" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1520.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1521.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1522.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1523.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1524.wav", + "text": "ESG啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1525.wav", + "text": "現在換你們不同意是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1526.wav", + "text": "你怎麼第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1527.wav", + "text": "第110案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1528.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1529.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1530.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1531.wav", + "text": "第111案我發言一下第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1532.wav", + "text": "111案就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1533.wav", + "text": "曾總召是不是考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1534.wav", + "text": "水保局和農再相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1535.wav", + "text": "農村送暖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1536.wav", + "text": "暖要送志工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1537.wav", + "text": "總是要把道路處理好一點啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1538.wav", + "text": "這一題我是覺得現在社會需要你們考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1539.wav", + "text": "就改成主決議啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1540.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1541.wav", + "text": "好撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1542.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1543.wav", + "text": "案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1544.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1545.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1546.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1547.wav", + "text": "讓他們自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1548.wav", + "text": "減列多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1549.wav", + "text": "減列1,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1550.wav", + "text": "這些都是農村所必要的第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1551.wav", + "text": "121" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1552.wav", + "text": "案是關於農糧署的都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1553.wav", + "text": "撤案了除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1554.wav", + "text": "還有淨零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1555.wav", + "text": "所需要的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1556.wav", + "text": "如果改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1557.wav", + "text": "改主決議好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1558.wav", + "text": "好第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1559.wav", + "text": "121案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1560.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1561.wav", + "text": "第122案撤案就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1562.wav", + "text": "剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1563.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1564.wav", + "text": "第122案撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1565.wav", + "text": "就改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1566.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1567.wav", + "text": "123" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1568.wav", + "text": "也撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1569.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1570.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1571.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1572.wav", + "text": "委員同意改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1573.wav", + "text": "好改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1574.wav", + "text": "126案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1575.wav", + "text": "127案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1576.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1577.wav", + "text": "就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1578.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1579.wav", + "text": "129案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1580.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1581.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1582.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1583.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1584.wav", + "text": "131案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1585.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1586.wav", + "text": "132案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1587.wav", + "text": "我們現在總數已經刪1.2億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1588.wav", + "text": "保留第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1589.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1590.wav", + "text": "這個也要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1591.wav", + "text": "沒有快速惡化啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1592.wav", + "text": "調保費就沒有快速惡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1593.wav", + "text": "作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1594.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1595.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1596.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1597.wav", + "text": "文化部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1598.wav", + "text": "文化部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1599.wav", + "text": "已同意改主決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1600.wav", + "text": "等一下我確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1601.wav", + "text": "拜託併第137案一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1602.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1603.wav", + "text": "因為王委員不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1604.wav", + "text": "文化部在特別預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1605.wav", + "text": "編列22億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1606.wav", + "text": "元媒體政策跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1607.wav", + "text": "業務宣導費就編了3,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1608.wav", + "text": "萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1609.wav", + "text": "因為費用這麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1610.wav", + "text": "是各部會裡面最高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1611.wav", + "text": "特別預算媒體宣傳費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1612.wav", + "text": "總共才7,400萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1613.wav", + "text": "元文化部就占了3,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1614.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1615.wav", + "text": "3,000萬元到底是怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1616.wav", + "text": "編列的到底要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1617.wav", + "text": "這個提案主要的目的是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1618.wav", + "text": "主席在前面已經統刪1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1619.wav", + "text": "結論都還沒出來我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1620.wav", + "text": "覺得文宣費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1621.wav", + "text": "不可以統刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1622.wav", + "text": "刪���們還會文化部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1623.wav", + "text": "要你們說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1624.wav", + "text": "我剛剛跟主計長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1625.wav", + "text": "你那個裡面也要包含這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1626.wav", + "text": "宣傳的費用但你也沒有回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1627.wav", + "text": "沒有回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1628.wav", + "text": "結論就是答應了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1629.wav", + "text": "來這個事情都沒有解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1630.wav", + "text": "我先幫文化部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1631.wav", + "text": "不過因為其實我們在委員會協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1632.wav", + "text": "其實都有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1633.wav", + "text": "文化部的成年禮金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1634.wav", + "text": "它因為有在使用的年紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1635.wav", + "text": "包括有往上延伸的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1636.wav", + "text": "當時就講這個部分也要宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1637.wav", + "text": "讓他們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1638.wav", + "text": "不過到底怎麼用請部長先講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1639.wav", + "text": "我知道很多在野黨是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1640.wav", + "text": "在這一次其實拿到的不夠多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1641.wav", + "text": "啊當時我記得在詢答的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1642.wav", + "text": "包括很多在野黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1643.wav", + "text": "都這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1644.wav", + "text": "你這3,000萬元到底用在什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1645.wav", + "text": "是否可以講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1646.wav", + "text": "\n請你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1647.wav", + "text": "簡單說明文化部這次整個預算是22.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1648.wav", + "text": "是最少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1649.wav", + "text": "因為成年禮金已經從從18歲變成18192021歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1650.wav", + "text": "所以說這個政策針對這個年齡層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1651.wav", + "text": "多做了一些宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1652.wav", + "text": "這是其一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1653.wav", + "text": "\n其二成年禮金其實最主要是消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1654.wav", + "text": "做節目宣傳藝文的採購的宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1655.wav", + "text": "請這些青少年朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1656.wav", + "text": "跟這些藝文團體進行消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1657.wav", + "text": "這不是在宣傳我們自己文化部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1658.wav", + "text": "也不是在宣傳政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1659.wav", + "text": "其實是在幫民間宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1660.wav", + "text": "聽不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1661.wav", + "text": "這個說法還是非常籠統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1662.wav", + "text": "元然後第3年編列570萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1663.wav", + "text": "元問題是說這個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1664.wav", + "text": "三讀通過到總統公布之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1665.wav", + "text": "已經是4月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1666.wav", + "text": "你就編了1,315萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1667.wav", + "text": "那到底是要花在哪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1668.wav", + "text": "成年禮金的實施期間是一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1669.wav", + "text": "從今年6月到明年6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1670.wav", + "text": "我當主席我們講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1671.wav", + "text": "也溝通過了就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1672.wav", + "text": "因為它本身成年禮金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1673.wav", + "text": "的使用除了年齡之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1674.wav", + "text": "哪些範圍可以使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1675.wav", + "text": "也必須跟民眾做宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1676.wav", + "text": "包括有哪些的藝文展演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1677.wav", + "text": "是可以使用文化禮金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1678.wav", + "text": "確實必須跟民眾溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1679.wav", + "text": "這些東西其實事實上我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1680.wav", + "text": "委員會的時候都有特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1681.wav", + "text": "提過為什麼需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1682.wav", + "text": "這部分的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1683.wav", + "text": "但是我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1684.wav", + "text": "在這樣的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1685.wav", + "text": "實際去讓民眾了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1686.wav", + "text": "是有其必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1687.wav", + "text": "連鎖書店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1688.wav", + "text": "所以像這個表演藝術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1689.wav", + "text": "等等其實他們都唉唉叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1690.wav", + "text": "所以我們這次為什麼編列了一些宣傳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1691.wav", + "text": "其實就是希望幫這些過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1692.wav", + "text": "消費得比較少的藝文的種類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1693.wav", + "text": "多幫他們做點宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1694.wav", + "text": "吸引成年禮金去他們那邊消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1695.wav", + "text": "所以我一直說這不是在幫文化部消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1696.wav", + "text": "其實是在幫民間宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1697.wav", + "text": "文化部的公務預算裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1698.wav", + "text": "本來就有媒體政策與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1699.wav", + "text": "業務宣導費用對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1700.wav", + "text": "特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1701.wav", + "text": "主計長這個說不太過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1702.wav", + "text": "放這麼高的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1703.wav", + "text": "可是聽到現在還是無法說服我為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1704.wav", + "text": "麼要花這個錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1705.wav", + "text": "案也要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1706.wav", + "text": "做廣告行銷費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1707.wav", + "text": "院長等一下這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1708.wav", + "text": "這3,000萬\n可否解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1709.wav", + "text": "大概就是以1%到2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1710.wav", + "text": "的方式來編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1711.wav", + "text": "什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1712.wav", + "text": "整個預算規模的1%到2%來編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1713.wav", + "text": "100萬就編1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1714.wav", + "text": "所以整個宣傳經費編百分之一點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1715.wav", + "text": "藝文產業及文化產業發聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1716.wav", + "text": "這些表演藝術團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1717.wav", + "text": "這次的藝Fun券就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1718.wav", + "text": "製造業或其他相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1719.wav", + "text": "經濟紅利來讓全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1720.wav", + "text": "我相信有很多文創產業者都在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1721.wav", + "text": "有多一點宣傳費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1722.wav", + "text": "或買票都好既然有成年禮金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1723.wav", + "text": "藝文團體或表演團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1724.wav", + "text": "做宣傳我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1725.wav", + "text": "這三年來他們確實最慘之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1726.wav", + "text": "發言也尊重大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1727.wav", + "text": "從藝文相關產業出身的人所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1728.wav", + "text": "我一定要幫他們發聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1729.wav", + "text": "如果能攤到全國這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1730.wav", + "text": "信對他們來說是很需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1731.wav", + "text": "因為史部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1732.wav", + "text": "圖利特定媒體懂我意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1733.wav", + "text": "3,000萬又拿給少數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1734.wav", + "text": "我的理解是不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1735.wav", + "text": "媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1736.wav", + "text": "部的作法真的與別的部會不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1737.wav", + "text": "宣傳費是7,400萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1738.wav", + "text": "但文化部的宣傳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1739.wav", + "text": "公務體系作宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1740.wav", + "text": "這是大家所關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1741.wav", + "text": "就是用預算的1%編列但話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1742.wav", + "text": "不是這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1743.wav", + "text": "的因為其他部會沒有這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1744.wav", + "text": "這3,000多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1745.wav", + "text": "不是在宣傳說有成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1746.wav", + "text": "禮金1,200點很棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1747.wav", + "text": "這些小團體不可能做廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1748.wav", + "text": "譬如在彰化或桃園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1749.wav", + "text": "的成年禮金叫他們來看表演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1750.wav", + "text": "而不是宣傳文化部好棒棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1751.wav", + "text": "他們沒有針對你說的那個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1752.wav", + "text": "別團體沒有這項規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1753.wav", + "text": "他是用預算的1%去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1754.wav", + "text": "連到底要補助多少團體都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1755.wav", + "text": "元的結果他的回答居然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1756.wav", + "text": "居然是用預算的1%來計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1757.wav", + "text": "你的說法當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1758.wav", + "text": "你要補助多少團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1759.wav", + "text": "力氣去宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1760.wav", + "text": "團體預算的編列方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1761.wav", + "text": "就不會是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1762.wav", + "text": "我聽你知道我的意思我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1763.wav", + "text": "了他匡列之後有多少團體來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1764.wav", + "text": "只能在這個預算裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1765.wav", + "text": "這個案討論很久了就保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1766.wav", + "text": "因為沒有共識就保留我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1767.wav", + "text": "還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1768.wav", + "text": "特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1769.wav", + "text": "預算的編列應該不是用這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1770.wav", + "text": "以我剛剛的建議是說你要統刪的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1771.wav", + "text": "要特別注意這個部分你也不承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1772.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1773.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過\n第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1774.wav", + "text": "第141案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1775.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1776.wav", + "text": "我們也就都保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1777.wav", + "text": "第146" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1778.wav", + "text": "146案第147" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1779.wav", + "text": "全部刪除的提案就併成一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1780.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1781.wav", + "text": "第147案是我們的耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1782.wav", + "text": "國民黨的提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1783.wav", + "text": "弄成一案啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1784.wav", + "text": "因為全數刪除已經是極致了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1785.wav", + "text": "都要保留就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1786.wav", + "text": "第146案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1787.wav", + "text": "都是全數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1788.wav", + "text": "現在根本看不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1789.wav", + "text": "像剛剛講的有921" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1790.wav", + "text": "震災或是莫拉克風災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1791.wav", + "text": "這樣特殊的情事所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1792.wav", + "text": "以要這樣做但現在看不出來將來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1793.wav", + "text": "在執行的時候有預期之外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1794.wav", + "text": "例如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1795.wav", + "text": "現在已經講預備金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1796.wav", + "text": "就是用在特別條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1797.wav", + "text": "正面列舉的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1798.wav", + "text": "不會去弄到什麼莫拉克風災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1799.wav", + "text": "那是你的舉例嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1800.wav", + "text": "那不是我的舉例那是過去的前例啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1801.wav", + "text": "都會用在這筆預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1802.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1803.wav", + "text": "一定會出問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1804.wav", + "text": "因為很多是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1805.wav", + "text": "不可預測的數目嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1806.wav", + "text": "例如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1807.wav", + "text": "的出生數目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1808.wav", + "text": "社會需要保障的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1809.wav", + "text": "隨時都可能會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1810.wav", + "text": "所以我們需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1811.wav", + "text": "這個所以是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1812.wav", + "text": "可以用第148案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1813.wav", + "text": "修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1814.wav", + "text": "而且給那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1815.wav", + "text": "人數不一定固定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1816.wav", + "text": "全臺灣的人數不固定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1817.wav", + "text": "嗎是固定的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1818.wav", + "text": "這些都是可以預估的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1819.wav", + "text": "可以預估的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1820.wav", + "text": "就不會跟你談這麼久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1821.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1822.wav", + "text": "這個不要啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1823.wav", + "text": "他們二個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1824.wav", + "text": "就保留那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1825.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1826.wav", + "text": "召有同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1827.wav", + "text": "148案又匡住一些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1828.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1829.wav", + "text": "既然有第148案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1830.wav", + "text": "前面二案就不要表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1831.wav", + "text": "148案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1832.wav", + "text": "你們那些都不需要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1833.wav", + "text": "你看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1834.wav", + "text": "有文字修正嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1835.wav", + "text": "這個方向當然沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1836.wav", + "text": "但我是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1837.wav", + "text": "而這四次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1838.wav", + "text": "這個我支持這個沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1839.wav", + "text": "啊但是不妨害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1840.wav", + "text": "沒有存在的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1841.wav", + "text": "個你到底是哪一種邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1842.wav", + "text": "是你跟我勸說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1843.wav", + "text": "我支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1844.wav", + "text": "這個不衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1845.wav", + "text": "我支持往前更進一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1846.wav", + "text": "這個就只有這四次而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1847.wav", + "text": "總召我說一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1848.wav", + "text": "有沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1849.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1850.wav", + "text": "的初稿唸給大家聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1851.wav", + "text": "地點都不談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1852.wav", + "text": "疫後強化經濟與社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1853.wav", + "text": "韌性及全民共享經濟成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1854.wav", + "text": "特別預算案相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1855.wav", + "text": "決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1856.wav", + "text": "一協商通過內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1857.wav", + "text": "及保留部分如後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1858.wav", + "text": "附由財政委員會整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1859.wav", + "text": "餘照聯席會議審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1860.wav", + "text": "通過送各黨團確認後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1861.wav", + "text": "於3月24日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1862.wav", + "text": "(星期二)上午9時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1863.wav", + "text": "送議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1864.wav", + "text": "\n二本案於院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1865.wav", + "text": "進行處理時非保留部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1866.wav", + "text": "宣讀後均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1867.wav", + "text": "進行處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1868.wav", + "text": "由各黨團推派代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1869.wav", + "text": "各一人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1870.wav", + "text": "發言順序依時眾國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1871.wav", + "text": "之黨團順序進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1872.wav", + "text": "每人發言時間為3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1873.wav", + "text": "發言完畢後個案就不再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1874.wav", + "text": "即按保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1875.wav", + "text": "案號依序表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1876.wav", + "text": "\n三本次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1877.wav", + "text": "各項提案均予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1878.wav", + "text": "刊登公報紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1879.wav", + "text": "有沒有要修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1880.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1881.wav", + "text": "院長可不可以爭取2人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1882.wav", + "text": "各黨都2人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1883.wav", + "text": "其實時間差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1884.wav", + "text": "你已經講很多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1885.wav", + "text": "我幫大家爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1886.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1887.wav", + "text": "由各黨團推派代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1888.wav", + "text": "各2人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1889.wav", + "text": "3個要不同的人不能1個人講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1890.wav", + "text": "你這樣講很難聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1891.wav", + "text": "支持3個但是也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1892.wav", + "text": "剛剛我的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1893.wav", + "text": "不衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1894.wav", + "text": "可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1895.wav", + "text": "你們不用講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1896.wav", + "text": "不然3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1897.wav", + "text": "啦其實時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1898.wav", + "text": "沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1899.wav", + "text": "民進黨不用發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1900.wav", + "text": "一定會發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1901.wav", + "text": "不要再爭辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1902.wav", + "text": "現在趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1903.wav", + "text": "簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1904.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1905.wav", + "text": "這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1906.wav", + "text": "比例就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1907.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1908.wav", + "text": "簽好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1909.wav", + "text": "還有沒有什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1910.wav", + "text": "院長等一下預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1911.wav", + "text": "預備金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1912.wav", + "text": "費鴻泰賴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1913.wav", + "text": "張其祿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1914.wav", + "text": "有一個全數減列的案子一表決下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1915.wav", + "text": "後面都不用表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1916.wav", + "text": "預備金的刪除只剩下時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1917.wav", + "text": "國民黨沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1918.wav", + "text": "國民黨用第148" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1919.wav", + "text": "所以合併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1920.wav", + "text": "國民黨是第148" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1921.wav", + "text": "第148案往前小進一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1922.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1923.wav", + "text": "案由不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1924.wav", + "text": "案由不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1925.wav", + "text": "繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1926.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14870/1927.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/0.wav", + "text": "現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/1.wav", + "text": "我們表定12時30分要開始進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/2.wav", + "text": "法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/3.wav", + "text": "退輔會勞動部還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/4.wav", + "text": "發展觀光條例第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/5.wav", + "text": "及第7條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/6.wav", + "text": "條第3項本來有一個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/7.wav", + "text": "就是各目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/8.wav", + "text": "本於權責訂定相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/9.wav", + "text": "管理辦法之特定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/10.wav", + "text": "對象住宿場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/11.wav", + "text": "104年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/12.wav", + "text": "通過予以刪除並且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/13.wav", + "text": "增訂了第7條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/14.wav", + "text": "2既有業者有10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/15.wav", + "text": "申辦旅館業登記證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/16.wav", + "text": "的過渡期所以基於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/17.wav", + "text": "信賴保護原則業者現在可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/18.wav", + "text": "經營到114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/19.wav", + "text": "這個案子將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/20.wav", + "text": "原來是講非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/21.wav", + "text": "以營利為目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/22.wav", + "text": "且供特定對象住宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/23.wav", + "text": "之場所但是實務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/24.wav", + "text": "上卻發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/25.wav", + "text": "很多業者已經提供不特定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/26.wav", + "text": "對象住宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/27.wav", + "text": "而且的確是以營利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/28.wav", + "text": "業其實沒有差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/29.wav", + "text": "了所以很多旅館業者也是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/30.wav", + "text": "基於產業公平經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/31.wav", + "text": "的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/32.wav", + "text": "提出修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/33.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/34.wav", + "text": "合法的旅宿實際上已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/35.wav", + "text": "一萬四千多家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/36.wav", + "text": "在旅館的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/37.wav", + "text": "足夠了而且在很多時段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/38.wav", + "text": "跟地區其實已經供過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/39.wav", + "text": "表示競爭激烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/40.wav", + "text": "所以如果我們今天要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/41.wav", + "text": "放寬這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/42.wav", + "text": "以特定對象為住宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/43.wav", + "text": "緩衝期十年之後還能繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/44.wav", + "text": "加入的話恐怕會引起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/45.wav", + "text": "合法旅宿業者的反彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/46.wav", + "text": "經過了多次的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/47.wav", + "text": "討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/48.wav", + "text": "各目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/49.wav", + "text": "98家其中有2家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/50.wav", + "text": "已經輔導合法化成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/51.wav", + "text": "剩下的96家裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/52.wav", + "text": "依各目的事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/53.wav", + "text": "主管機關評估有大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/54.wav", + "text": "35家可以合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/55.wav", + "text": "取得旅館業的登記證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/56.wav", + "text": "退場或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/57.wav", + "text": "再做其他使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/58.wav", + "text": "所以基於以上的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/59.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/60.wav", + "text": "維持原條文不予修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/61.wav", + "text": "\n至於其他公營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/62.wav", + "text": "警光會館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/63.wav", + "text": "而林務局的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/64.wav", + "text": "���依照規費法來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/65.wav", + "text": "輔導成功的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/66.wav", + "text": "本局還是建議維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/67.wav", + "text": "現有條文的規定不予修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/68.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/69.wav", + "text": "謝謝觀光局副局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/70.wav", + "text": "有沒有相關意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/71.wav", + "text": "大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/72.wav", + "text": "這個條文的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/73.wav", + "text": "大概是從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/74.wav", + "text": "前年開始針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/75.wav", + "text": "針對露營場的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/76.wav", + "text": "合法化的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/77.wav", + "text": "已經行之多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/78.wav", + "text": "現在則是一個延伸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/79.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/80.wav", + "text": "相關的管理辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/81.wav", + "text": "是不是已經要納管了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/82.wav", + "text": "該不該納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/83.wav", + "text": "這個案例來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/84.wav", + "text": "即使露營場的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/85.wav", + "text": "辦法訂定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/86.wav", + "text": "文字卻還是沒納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/87.wav", + "text": "嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/88.wav", + "text": "因為很多納管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/89.wav", + "text": "項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/90.wav", + "text": "在齊柏林看見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/91.wav", + "text": "臺灣紀錄片裡所看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/92.wav", + "text": "問題而且很多是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/93.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/94.wav", + "text": "如果現在有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/95.wav", + "text": "是違反規定的我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/96.wav", + "text": "看看交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/97.wav", + "text": "輔導機制我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/98.wav", + "text": "是不是先做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/99.wav", + "text": "對於有需要或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/100.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/101.wav", + "text": "可以執行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/102.wav", + "text": "再去修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/103.wav", + "text": "讓它納進來所以我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/104.wav", + "text": "維持現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/105.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他委員要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/106.wav", + "text": "剛剛觀光局的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/107.wav", + "text": "有2家現在已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/108.wav", + "text": "輔導合法化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/109.wav", + "text": "請教一下觀光局有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/110.wav", + "text": "剩下的業者要如何協助他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/111.wav", + "text": "申請合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/112.wav", + "text": "現在的狀況是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/113.wav", + "text": "是教育部的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/114.wav", + "text": "青年活動中心住宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/115.wav", + "text": "廢止了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/116.wav", + "text": "措施或什麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/117.wav", + "text": "行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/118.wav", + "text": "是不是說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/119.wav", + "text": "是主席各位委員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/120.wav", + "text": "輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/121.wav", + "text": "的青年活動中心的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/122.wav", + "text": "所以目前它的目的事業主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/123.wav", + "text": "機關還沒有確認下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/124.wav", + "text": "要等目的事業主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/125.wav", + "text": "機關確認之後再去確認它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/126.wav", + "text": "它是不是要再進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/127.wav", + "text": "輔導以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/128.wav", + "text": "好謝謝\n請鄭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/129.wav", + "text": "這個部分因為牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/130.wav", + "text": "落日條款裡面的97家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/131.wav", + "text": "對象大家都知道他們過去跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/132.wav", + "text": "政府有很深的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/133.wav", + "text": "有關係如果10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/134.wav", + "text": "如果立法院這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/135.wav", + "text": "用一個特定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/136.wav", + "text": "名詞款項把它包一包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/137.wav", + "text": "不落日這不但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/138.wav", + "text": "失信於民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/139.wav", + "text": "也是不對的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/140.wav", + "text": "對於產業也好對於各種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/141.wav", + "text": "福利措施也好到最後都沒辦法落日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/142.wav", + "text": "這是一件很麻煩的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/143.wav", + "text": "的部分以政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/144.wav", + "text": "修法再讓它獨立出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/145.wav", + "text": "然後永無寧日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/146.wav", + "text": "\n第二個對於現有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/147.wav", + "text": "觀光旅遊業者及旅館業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/148.wav", + "text": "來說也會變成不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/149.wav", + "text": "競爭所以將這一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/150.wav", + "text": "放進去其實是不需要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/151.wav", + "text": "也不應該有什麼特定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/152.wav", + "text": "的人都會面對到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/153.wav", + "text": "安全跟品質的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/154.wav", + "text": "所以這種特定對象我們也要顧慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/155.wav", + "text": "嘛而且這種特定對象也沒有寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/156.wav", + "text": "誰是特定對象啊以後大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/157.wav", + "text": "都來爭取自己是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/158.wav", + "text": "特定對象就永���寧日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/159.wav", + "text": "了所以這一款民進黨黨團反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/160.wav", + "text": "論發展觀光條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/161.wav", + "text": "教師會館勞工育樂中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/162.wav", + "text": "林務局招待所農委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/163.wav", + "text": "森林遊樂區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/164.wav", + "text": "青年活動中心公教會館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/165.wav", + "text": "警光會館廟宇香客大樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/166.wav", + "text": "及醫院等12類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/167.wav", + "text": "觀光局副局長你剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/168.wav", + "text": "97家是不是這12類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/169.wav", + "text": "你說有2家已經合法化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/170.wav", + "text": "原來是叫勞動學苑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/171.wav", + "text": "現在變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/172.wav", + "text": "統一渡假村鹿港文創會館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/173.wav", + "text": "第二家是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/174.wav", + "text": "蘭花會館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/175.wav", + "text": "我們政府機關的還是BOT還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/176.wav", + "text": "私人擁有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/177.wav", + "text": "而且已經取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/178.wav", + "text": "旅館所以這2家的地還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/179.wav", + "text": "年限然後他們也取得了旅館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/180.wav", + "text": "這12大類其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/181.wav", + "text": "它不只是像剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/182.wav", + "text": "的政府或政黨相關看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/183.wav", + "text": "這12大類也包羅萬象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/184.wav", + "text": "沒有出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/185.wav", + "text": "不過其實第10款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/186.wav", + "text": "特定對象住宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/187.wav", + "text": "的部分已經明白確定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/188.wav", + "text": "提供特定旅客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/189.wav", + "text": "換言之這樣子的修正它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/190.wav", + "text": "某種程度上也不是開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/191.wav", + "text": "啟什麼大門而是執行的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/192.wav", + "text": "假設這樣的場所提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/193.wav", + "text": "非特定住宿對象我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/194.wav", + "text": "要處罰它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/195.wav", + "text": "這也是剛剛觀光局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/196.wav", + "text": "副局長講到的怕是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/197.wav", + "text": "非特定對象等於是讓一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/198.wav", + "text": "執行面的問題啊如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/199.wav", + "text": "住但今天教師會館開放給一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/200.wav", + "text": "重罰嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/201.wav", + "text": "啦不過因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/202.wav", + "text": "個別表達不同的意見看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/203.wav", + "text": "是沒有一個聚焦點但這也相對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/204.wav", + "text": "如果今天大家沒有其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/205.wav", + "text": "意見要回復的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/206.wav", + "text": "委員會的協商就先告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/207.wav", + "text": "送到院長也許院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/208.wav", + "text": "有比較大的智慧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/209.wav", + "text": "來處理看起來我的智慧還是有限啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/210.wav", + "text": "所以沒有辦法當院長我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/211.wav", + "text": "送院會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/212.wav", + "text": "這樣大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/213.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見的話我們就全案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14866/214.wav", + "text": "送院會協商\n今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/0.wav", + "text": "民共享經濟成果特別預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/1.wav", + "text": "相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/2.wav", + "text": "提案的是國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/3.wav", + "text": "和民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/4.wav", + "text": "柯委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/5.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/6.wav", + "text": "各位協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/7.wav", + "text": "我今天在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/8.wav", + "text": "提一個建議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/9.wav", + "text": "有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/10.wav", + "text": "但是大家都有共識能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/11.wav", + "text": "愈快愈好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/12.wav", + "text": "在這個原則底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/13.wav", + "text": "今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/14.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/15.wav", + "text": "提一個可行性的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/16.wav", + "text": "就是可能方式是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/17.wav", + "text": "今天是星期四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/18.wav", + "text": "我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/19.wav", + "text": "目前的時間來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/20.wav", + "text": "都可能安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/21.wav", + "text": "整個程序的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/22.wav", + "text": "我先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/23.wav", + "text": "結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/24.wav", + "text": "今天星期四假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/25.wav", + "text": "假如下星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/26.wav", + "text": "表決的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/27.wav", + "text": "就可以往下談下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/28.wav", + "text": "表決的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/29.wav", + "text": "下星期一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/30.wav", + "text": "截止收案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/31.wav", + "text": "期二程序委員會必須排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/32.wav", + "text": "因為原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/33.wav", + "text": "本下星期五是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/34.wav", + "text": "質詢要把議程變更為處理法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/35.wav", + "text": "所以下星期二程序委員會要去安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/36.wav", + "text": "至於收案時間是下星期一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/37.wav", + "text": "傍晚或下星期二傍晚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/38.wav", + "text": "尊重大家的決定如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/39.wav", + "text": "們星期三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/40.wav", + "text": "或星期四來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/41.wav", + "text": "下星期五就可以處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/42.wav", + "text": "這是目前可能的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/43.wav", + "text": "為什麼這樣安排呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/44.wav", + "text": "期五表決通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/45.wav", + "text": "現在不管多少案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/46.wav", + "text": "一天一定可以結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/47.wav", + "text": "束因為預算案必須比較精準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/48.wav", + "text": "我問過議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/49.wav", + "text": "他們要整理資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/50.wav", + "text": "最快下星期六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/51.wav", + "text": "上班上班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/52.wav", + "text": "送給總統府總統簽署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/53.wav", + "text": "日生效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/54.wav", + "text": "生效日就是所謂的D-Day" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/55.wav", + "text": "要有5天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/56.wav", + "text": "的時間這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/57.wav", + "text": "要做什麼事情呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/58.wav", + "text": "主計總處同意這個預算通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/59.wav", + "text": "國庫署撥給臺銀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/60.wav", + "text": "要清算預償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/61.wav", + "text": "臺銀再撥給財金公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/62.wav", + "text": "這個差不多要3天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/63.wav", + "text": "沒有這個差不多3天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/64.wav", + "text": "財金公司差不多3天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/65.wav", + "text": "幾天都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/66.wav", + "text": "反正這個程序差不多是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/67.wav", + "text": "然後再撥給各銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/68.wav", + "text": "所以這5個工作天是必須的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/69.wav", + "text": "月底以前這些手續都完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/70.wav", + "text": "然後清明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/71.wav", + "text": "清明節放假以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/72.wav", + "text": "4月6日以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/73.wav", + "text": "就可以開始陸續去處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/74.wav", + "text": "第一優先是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/75.wav", + "text": "那個有四個弱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/76.wav", + "text": "的先再來是預登記的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/77.wav", + "text": "再來是ATM的再來是臨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/78.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/79.wav", + "text": "目前看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/80.wav", + "text": "假如不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/81.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/82.wav", + "text": "4月11日(禮拜二)表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/83.wav", + "text": "可能4月6日以後就領得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/84.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/85.wav", + "text": "這是目前能夠想像出最快的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/86.wav", + "text": "還有什麼我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/87.wav", + "text": "重點是下禮拜五就表決第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/88.wav", + "text": "提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/89.wav", + "text": "我們看到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/90.wav", + "text": "就可以上網登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/91.wav", + "text": "如果行政院的程序比我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/92.wav", + "text": "應該要想辦法我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/93.wav", + "text": "能不能在3月21日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/94.wav", + "text": "1日也完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/95.wav", + "text": "有共識針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/96.wav", + "text": "這些程序問題我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/97.wav", + "text": "想辦法看怎麼解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/98.wav", + "text": "我們就把提案拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/99.wav", + "text": "行政院都說他們3月22日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/100.wav", + "text": "日我們怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/101.wav", + "text": "比他們慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/102.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/103.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/104.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/105.wav", + "text": "從早期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/106.wav", + "text": "就希望發現金1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/107.wav", + "text": "行政院的版本更早提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/108.wav", + "text": "整個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/109.wav", + "text": "通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/110.wav", + "text": "行政院希望發6,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/111.wav", + "text": "我們也接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/112.wav", + "text": "特別條例的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/113.wav", + "text": "蔡政府講準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/114.wav", + "text": "也常常有民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/115.wav", + "text": "能夠趕快發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/116.wav", + "text": "楊瓊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/117.wav", + "text": "召委儘快排審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/118.wav", + "text": "排審查之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/119.wav", + "text": "朝野協商也協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/120.wav", + "text": "特別預算予以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/121.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/122.wav", + "text": "發文給院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/123.wav", + "text": "希望趕快進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/124.wav", + "text": "下一個問題來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/125.wav", + "text": "我們希望儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/126.wav", + "text": "能夠早一天就早一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/127.wav", + "text": "因為民進黨政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/128.wav", + "text": "蔡政府說已經準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/129.wav", + "text": "隨時可以發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/130.wav", + "text": "我昨天在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/131.wav", + "text": "財委會問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/132.wav", + "text": "所以我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/133.wav", + "text": "能夠快一天就快一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/134.wav", + "text": "因此我具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/135.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/136.wav", + "text": "來得及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/137.wav", + "text": "因為行政院都已經準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/138.wav", + "text": "怎麼會來不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/139.wav", + "text": "假設這個時候行政院還來不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/140.wav", + "text": "看誰負責這個事情要打屁股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/141.wav", + "text": "不可以來不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/142.wav", + "text": "也不可以把來不及的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/143.wav", + "text": "推給立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/144.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨強烈主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/145.wav", + "text": "明天(禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/146.wav", + "text": "下班前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/147.wav", + "text": "禮拜一麻煩院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/148.wav", + "text": "禮拜二表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/149.wav", + "text": "國民黨具體的意見就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/150.wav", + "text": "下禮拜三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/151.wav", + "text": "主要的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/152.wav", + "text": "是我們知道這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/153.wav", + "text": "有一些項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/154.wav", + "text": "本來是在總預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/155.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/156.wav", + "text": "也一直都是有意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/157.wav", + "text": "我們也希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/158.wav", + "text": "安排在禮拜三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/159.wav", + "text": "收案禮拜五表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/160.wav", + "text": "安排應該還是比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/161.wav", + "text": "張委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/162.wav", + "text": "各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/163.wav", + "text": "黨團協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/164.wav", + "text": "民眾黨也說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/165.wav", + "text": "希望在3月24日院會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/166.wav", + "text": "期待4月發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/167.wav", + "text": "也是希望越快越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/168.wav", + "text": "所以基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/169.wav", + "text": "收案的時間可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/170.wav", + "text": "週三週四還是要有兩天協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/171.wav", + "text": "說我們雖然希望越快越好但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/172.wav", + "text": "我們還是有一些重要的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/173.wav", + "text": "發現金之外的那好幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/174.wav", + "text": "是不是足夠的問題其實我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/175.wav", + "text": "但是我們還是必須要把主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/176.wav", + "text": "剛才那個時程的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/177.wav", + "text": "還是有兩天可以進行程序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/178.wav", + "text": "要預登記我們��邊沒有一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/179.wav", + "text": "那還要預登記預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/180.wav", + "text": "天22日開始預登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/181.wav", + "text": "不管怎麼樣那個差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/182.wav", + "text": "不到幾天我們希望有秩序的完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/183.wav", + "text": "感謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/184.wav", + "text": "每個黨團一定會有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/185.wav", + "text": "來提案現在有25案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/186.wav", + "text": "我記得上次有一次只剩下一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/187.wav", + "text": "以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/188.wav", + "text": "收案以後又變成300案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/189.wav", + "text": "我們還是要尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/190.wav", + "text": "因為有的人不在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/191.wav", + "text": "有的當初沒有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/192.wav", + "text": "所以我還是很誠懇的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/193.wav", + "text": "具體建議禮拜五沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/194.wav", + "text": "收案到禮拜三也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/195.wav", + "text": "禮拜四馬上要密集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/196.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/197.wav", + "text": "我是禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/198.wav", + "text": "收案以後各部會去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/199.wav", + "text": "禮拜五表決剛好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/200.wav", + "text": "那個時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/201.wav", + "text": "包括宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/202.wav", + "text": "收案到禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/203.wav", + "text": "傍晚也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/204.wav", + "text": "我們再回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/205.wav", + "text": "就是建議禮拜二至少在下班前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/206.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/207.wav", + "text": "我還要講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/208.wav", + "text": "從條例審查開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/209.wav", + "text": "不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/210.wav", + "text": "財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/211.wav", + "text": "不管是國安會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/212.wav", + "text": "都講準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/213.wav", + "text": "半天到現在還沒準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/214.wav", + "text": "我們不要等一下表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/215.wav", + "text": "我們表決輸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/216.wav", + "text": "我們退席抗議就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/217.wav", + "text": "退席抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/218.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/219.wav", + "text": "搞了半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/220.wav", + "text": "而院長也總是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/221.wav", + "text": "準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/222.wav", + "text": "主計長你也講過都準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/223.wav", + "text": "錢準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/224.wav", + "text": "昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/225.wav", + "text": "莊翠雲部長說準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/226.wav", + "text": "而今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/227.wav", + "text": "柯總召說還沒有準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/228.wav", + "text": "因為他們都不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/229.wav", + "text": "他說隨時好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/230.wav", + "text": "你聽我不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/231.wav", + "text": "不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/232.wav", + "text": "騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/233.wav", + "text": "我問過多少人昨天你也在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/234.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/235.wav", + "text": "準備好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/236.wav", + "text": "隨時都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/237.wav", + "text": "你說都準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/238.wav", + "text": "問國發會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/239.wav", + "text": "也都準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/240.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/241.wav", + "text": "要整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/242.wav", + "text": "現在現在我們有幾個政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/243.wav", + "text": "啊只有一個蔡政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/244.wav", + "text": "耶不是馬政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/245.wav", + "text": "而今天朝野協商說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/246.wav", + "text": "還沒準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/247.wav", + "text": "那我們詢答時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/248.wav", + "text": "陳院長也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/249.wav", + "text": "龔主委也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/250.wav", + "text": "莊部長也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/251.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/252.wav", + "text": "啊我們就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/253.wav", + "text": "21日表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/254.wav", + "text": "提案就是到明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/255.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/256.wav", + "text": "對每個黨負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/257.wav", + "text": "啊你們也不提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/258.wav", + "text": "黨團的提案都在各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/259.wav", + "text": "各黨一定有很多人要提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/260.wav", + "text": "沒關係我們就是希望明天下班前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/261.wav", + "text": "禮拜一麻煩院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/262.wav", + "text": "來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/263.wav", + "text": "禮拜二表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/264.wav", + "text": "那程序委員會怎麼變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/265.wav", + "text": "下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/266.wav", + "text": "就是禮拜二的程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/267.wav", + "text": "禮拜五是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/268.wav", + "text": "我們朝野協商就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/269.wav", + "text": "是朝野協商就OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/270.wav", + "text": "K現在我要說明讓你清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/271.wav", + "text": "金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/272.wav", + "text": "財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/273.wav", + "text": "都要整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/274.wav", + "text": "還有13家銀行要進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/275.wav", + "text": "現在可能有15家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/276.wav", + "text": "一直納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/277.wav", + "text": "有錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/278.wav", + "text": "你說對不起蔡政府真的還沒有準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/279.wav", + "text": "我們就OK了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/280.wav", + "text": "沒有這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/281.wav", + "text": "立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/282.wav", + "text": "要提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/283.wav", + "text": "也有我們的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/284.wav", + "text": "你老是總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/285.wav", + "text": "召你在3天內給我發出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/286.wav", + "text": "你現在說來不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/287.wav", + "text": "我們立法院來得及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/288.wav", + "text": "啊但現在你所說的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/289.wav", + "text": "是不能提早至21日表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/290.wav", + "text": "是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/291.wav", + "text": "涉及到金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/292.wav", + "text": "數位發展部的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/293.wav", + "text": "整合對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/294.wav", + "text": "有宣傳期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/295.wav", + "text": "也有立法院的提案立法院的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/296.wav", + "text": "說起來你21日表決跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/297.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/298.wav", + "text": "民眾天天打電話來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/299.wav", + "text": "我們今天講好大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/300.wav", + "text": "我們還要在這裡協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/301.wav", + "text": "這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/302.wav", + "text": "結果搞了半天說還沒沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/303.wav", + "text": "我們說真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/304.wav", + "text": "沒人在騙你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/305.wav", + "text": "拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/306.wav", + "text": "最重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/307.wav", + "text": "他們就有說希望是下禮拜對不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/308.wav", + "text": "國民黨代表他們兩個政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/309.wav", + "text": "的黨團就說那我一定要明天收案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/310.wav", + "text": "好尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/311.wav", + "text": "我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/312.wav", + "text": "下禮拜二表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/313.wav", + "text": "我們要走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/314.wav", + "text": "表決提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/315.wav", + "text": "啊那你們要下禮拜五就下禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/316.wav", + "text": "明天下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/317.wav", + "text": "下禮拜二收案截止的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/318.wav", + "text": "我代表國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/319.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/320.wav", + "text": "剛才休息協商的時候大家有交換一下意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/321.wav", + "text": "持平而論要讓各黨有足夠的時間去提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/322.wav", + "text": "所以還是禮拜二中午截止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/323.wav", + "text": "不好截止收案以後各部會把提案拿回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/324.wav", + "text": "禮拜三要趕快去拜託各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/325.wav", + "text": "然後禮拜四下午2點或2點半協商禮拜五表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/326.wav", + "text": "這樣所有的程序都很完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/327.wav", + "text": "禮拜二下午2點好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/328.wav", + "text": "整理然後各部會拿回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/329.wav", + "text": "那就多一個小時3點好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/330.wav", + "text": "剛吃飽飯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/331.wav", + "text": "們你們一定有很多提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/332.wav", + "text": "如果沒有這個程序就要馬上表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/333.wav", + "text": "也不大好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/334.wav", + "text": "\n很感謝取得曾總召的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/335.wav", + "text": "那就是24日表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/336.wav", + "text": "23日下午協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/337.wav", + "text": "收案到禮拜二下午3點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/338.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/339.wav", + "text": "可以對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/340.wav", + "text": "禮拜二下午3點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/341.wav", + "text": "因為我們也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/342.wav", + "text": "雖然我們也許知道結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/343.wav", + "text": "但過程還是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/344.wav", + "text": "不過要是急著表決不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/345.wav", + "text": "一次把它處理完就是到時候有多少人上去發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/346.wav", + "text": "這個要不要先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/347.wav", + "text": "再談禮拜四協商完畢以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/348.wav", + "text": "幾個人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/349.wav", + "text": "各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/350.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團從一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/351.wav", + "text": "就都走在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/352.wav", + "text": "而且走在2個禮拜之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/353.wav", + "text": "行政院才把草案送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/354.wav", + "text": "特別預算送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/355.wav", + "text": "國民黨的召委楊瓊瓔積極排案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/356.wav", + "text": "楚茵委員當然也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/357.wav", + "text": "積極在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/358.wav", + "text": "因為有很多民眾來陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/359.wav", + "text": "希望能夠儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/360.wav", + "text": "拿到現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/361.wav", + "text": "我每一次問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/362.wav", + "text": "莊翠雲部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/363.wav", + "text": "他們都說已經準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/364.wav", + "text": "協商我們才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/365.wav", + "text": "們才發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/366.wav", + "text": "對於過去他們幾位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/367.wav", + "text": "說準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/368.wav", + "text": "最嚴重的譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/369.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/370.wav", + "text": "希望盡快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/371.wav", + "text": "希望在3月21日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/372.wav", + "text": "也就是下個禮拜二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/373.wav", + "text": "就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/374.wav", + "text": "趕快完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/375.wav", + "text": "特別預算的法定程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/376.wav", + "text": "趕快發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/377.wav", + "text": "但是民進黨說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/378.wav", + "text": "來不及來不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/379.wav", + "text": "一定要到3月24日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/380.wav", + "text": "因為準備來不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/381.wav", + "text": "了原來說準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/382.wav", + "text": "行政院沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/383.wav", + "text": "積極準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/384.wav", + "text": "沒有把該做的準備準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/385.wav", + "text": "除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/386.wav", + "text": "給予譴責之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/387.wav", + "text": "我們也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/388.wav", + "text": "我最後一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/389.wav", + "text": "這是把程序完整化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/390.wav", + "text": "讓各黨團也提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/391.wav", + "text": "整個程序完成化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/392.wav", + "text": "不存在所謂準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/393.wav", + "text": "但是我們立法院也要有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/394.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/395.wav", + "text": "也要讓立法院的過程完整一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/396.wav", + "text": "宣布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/397.wav", + "text": "決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/398.wav", + "text": "一請各黨團於3月21日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/399.wav", + "text": "(星期二)下午3時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/400.wav", + "text": "將中央政府疫後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/401.wav", + "text": "強化經濟與社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/402.wav", + "text": "及全民共享經濟成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/403.wav", + "text": "特別預算案之提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/404.wav", + "text": "送至財政委員會彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/405.wav", + "text": "逾時不再收案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/406.wav", + "text": "\n二財政委員會收案後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/407.wav", + "text": "於3月22日(星期三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/408.wav", + "text": ")上午9時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/409.wav", + "text": "提供各黨團及相關行政部門參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/410.wav", + "text": "後續3月23日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/411.wav", + "text": "協商之進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/412.wav", + "text": "\n三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/413.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意定於3月24日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/414.wav", + "text": ")院會表決處理上開特別預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/415.wav", + "text": "完成三讀程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/416.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意不提出復議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/417.wav", + "text": "當日院會僅列上開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/418.wav", + "text": "特別預算案討論事項1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/419.wav", + "text": "不進行施政質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/420.wav", + "text": "另3月24日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/421.wav", + "text": ")28日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/422.wav", + "text": "(星期二)及31日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/423.wav", + "text": "(星期五)合併為一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/424.wav", + "text": "議該次院會不處理臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/425.wav", + "text": "3/24是表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/426.wav", + "text": "要來啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/427.wav", + "text": "我來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/428.wav", + "text": "鞭報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/429.wav", + "text": "因為如果按照大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/430.wav", + "text": "3月24日星期五要表決這個特別預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/431.wav", + "text": "另外3月28日星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/432.wav", + "text": "的早上是因為我們上一次的協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/433.wav", + "text": "這是請捷克的議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/434.wav", + "text": "大家就會來到院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/435.wav", + "text": "那星期二的下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/436.wav", + "text": "我們就繼續施政質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/437.wav", + "text": "那31日本來是2天一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/438.wav", + "text": "31日是清明節連假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/439.wav", + "text": "之前的1天院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/440.wav", + "text": "它是1天的院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/441.wav", + "text": "所以我們乾脆把3天合做一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/442.wav", + "text": "等於大家簽到就簽1次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/443.wav", + "text": "合在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/444.wav", + "text": "程序上會比較簡明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/445.wav", + "text": "所以才會有3天一次會的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/446.wav", + "text": "今天只是程序性的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/447.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/448.wav", + "text": "程序委員會要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/449.wav", + "text": "那個程序就會按照這個來排院會的議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/450.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/451.wav", + "text": "下禮拜二程序委員會要排議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/452.wav", + "text": "講不然程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/453.wav", + "text": "不能這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/454.wav", + "text": "那是不是同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/455.wav", + "text": "同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/456.wav", + "text": "話我就簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/457.wav", + "text": "現在我們就一面簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/458.wav", + "text": "一面向大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/459.wav", + "text": "國民議會議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/460.wav", + "text": "因為我們上次協���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/461.wav", + "text": "大家都同意他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/462.wav", + "text": "來演講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/463.wav", + "text": "捷克這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/464.wav", + "text": "將近170人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/465.wav", + "text": "要來臺灣訪問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/466.wav", + "text": "分成兩部飛機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/467.wav", + "text": "所以很盛大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/468.wav", + "text": "但是進到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/469.wav", + "text": "不會那麼多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/470.wav", + "text": "因為我們列席座位的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/471.wav", + "text": "再次建議事實上上次有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/472.wav", + "text": "因為這個會上國際媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/473.wav", + "text": "請大家盛裝出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/474.wav", + "text": "院長你就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/475.wav", + "text": "這是請求也是命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/476.wav", + "text": "全部給我甲動過來好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/477.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/478.wav", + "text": "那個會上國際媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/479.wav", + "text": "有的座位有空的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/480.wav", + "text": "就不好看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/481.wav", + "text": "而且會被看出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/482.wav", + "text": "這個是民進黨的委員沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/483.wav", + "text": "盛裝出席最主要就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/484.wav", + "text": "大家穿得比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/485.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/486.wav", + "text": "大家如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/487.wav", + "text": "總理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/488.wav", + "text": "韋德齊跟後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/489.wav", + "text": "親臺派的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/490.wav", + "text": "的總統是親中的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/491.wav", + "text": "所以總理就跟著他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/492.wav", + "text": "現在都是跟我們很要好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/493.wav", + "text": "議會議長才38歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/494.wav", + "text": "有人要跟他們合照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/495.wav", + "text": "我想我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/496.wav", + "text": "留下紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/497.wav", + "text": "年輕人以後都有可能再去捷克" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/498.wav", + "text": "克可以去找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/499.wav", + "text": "請大家動員簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/500.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/501.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14852/502.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14851/0.wav", + "text": "第一個提一個可行性的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14851/1.wav", + "text": "說不我們立法院他們要提我們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/0.wav", + "text": "及全民共享經濟成果特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1.wav", + "text": "及國民黨黨團擬具稅收超徵全民共享發放特別條例草案2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/2.wav", + "text": "2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/3.wav", + "text": "\n現在我先介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/4.wav", + "text": "今天與會的機關首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/5.wav", + "text": "首先介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/6.wav", + "text": "國家發展委員會主任委員龔明鑫先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/7.wav", + "text": "其次介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/8.wav", + "text": "經濟部部長王美花女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/9.wav", + "text": "內政部政務次長花敬群先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/10.wav", + "text": "財政部部長莊翠雲女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/11.wav", + "text": "勞動部部長許銘春女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/12.wav", + "text": "行政院主計總處主計長朱澤民先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/13.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我們就來進行今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/14.wav", + "text": "法案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/15.wav", + "text": "提案人要不要先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/16.wav", + "text": "提案人先說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/17.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/18.wav", + "text": "各部會列席的首長及各黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/19.wav", + "text": "特別條例我想今天我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/20.wav", + "text": "協商完畢以後明天在院會要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/21.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/22.wav", + "text": "這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/23.wav", + "text": "各黨團都有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/24.wav", + "text": "條文也不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/25.wav", + "text": "在上禮拜朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/26.wav", + "text": "國民黨和民眾黨有再提出再修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/27.wav", + "text": "本席也代表民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/28.wav", + "text": "提出針對行政院版本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/29.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/30.wav", + "text": "各黨對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/31.wav", + "text": "發放現金的部分我們跟國民黨的差異大概在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/32.wav", + "text": "上禮拜五我們有稍微跟國民黨聊一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/33.wav", + "text": "互相妥協的空間並不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/34.wav", + "text": "\n至於第3條條文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/35.wav", + "text": "當然是比較關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/36.wav", + "text": "國民黨認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/37.wav", + "text": "不應該有其他換句話說我們原來第9款有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/38.wav", + "text": "很可能被誤解為有空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/39.wav", + "text": "所以後來我們第3條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/40.wav", + "text": "減輕就學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/41.wav", + "text": "學貸部分的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/42.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/43.wav", + "text": "還有擴大藝文消費及振興藝文產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/44.wav", + "text": "進入第3條的時候我們再請相關部會詳細說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/45.wav", + "text": "我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/46.wav", + "text": "可以談的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/47.wav", + "text": "包括第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/48.wav", + "text": "分期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/49.wav", + "text": "一次編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/50.wav", + "text": "公債法第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/51.wav", + "text": "5條第7項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/52.wav", + "text": "我們認為不必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/53.wav", + "text": "因為本來就不會超過公債法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/54.wav", + "text": "我知道曾銘宗委員很在意財政紀律的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/55.wav", + "text": "可以做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/56.wav", + "text": "最後就是施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/57.wav", + "text": "以上就是我們這次有稍微做的一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/58.wav", + "text": "來就教於各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/59.wav", + "text": "是不是請院長等一下協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/60.wav", + "text": "協商進入逐條的時候再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/61.wav", + "text": "以上是本黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/62.wav", + "text": "提案說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/63.wav", + "text": "好\n請另外一位提案代表人曾銘宗委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/64.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/65.wav", + "text": "立法院各位同仁各部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/66.wav", + "text": "我謹代表國民黨提出幾點說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/67.wav", + "text": "第一點國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/68.wav", + "text": "比行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/69.wav", + "text": "的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/70.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/71.wav", + "text": "早了兩個禮拜提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/72.wav", + "text": "國民黨是提出發放現金的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/73.wav", + "text": "這個是國民黨長期主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/74.wav", + "text": "那為什麼提出發放現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/75.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/76.wav", + "text": "蔡政府執政到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/77.wav", + "text": "稅收超收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/78.wav", + "text": "超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/79.wav", + "text": "一兆兩千億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/80.wav", + "text": "元過去超收的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/81.wav", + "text": "都拿去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/82.wav", + "text": "編特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/83.wav", + "text": "錢也沒用在刀口上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/84.wav", + "text": "與其這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/85.wav", + "text": "不如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/86.wav", + "text": "發放現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/87.wav", + "text": "給民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/88.wav", + "text": "因為這段期間低薪的情況非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/89.wav", + "text": "去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/90.wav", + "text": "實質薪資負成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/91.wav", + "text": "前一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/92.wav", + "text": "實質薪資也是負成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/93.wav", + "text": "所以兩千三百萬的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/94.wav", + "text": "很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/95.wav", + "text": "真的非常需要政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/96.wav", + "text": "發一筆現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/97.wav", + "text": "國民黨的主張是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/98.wav", + "text": "每人發一萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/99.wav", + "text": "早在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/100.wav", + "text": "行政院版本送來之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/101.wav", + "text": "\n後來我們看到行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/102.wav", + "text": "國民黨也認為裡面有一些是可行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/103.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/104.wav", + "text": "挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/105.wav", + "text": "紓解全民健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/106.wav", + "text": "嚴重虧損的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/107.wav", + "text": "這100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/108.wav", + "text": "也接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/109.wav", + "text": "我們黨團經過廣泛交換意見之後也把它納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/110.wav", + "text": "所以修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/111.wav", + "text": "除了普發現金之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/112.wav", + "text": "挹注全民健康保險勞工保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/113.wav", + "text": "以及台灣電力公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/114.wav", + "text": "改善財務等等都納進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/115.wav", + "text": "這是第二點說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/116.wav", + "text": "\n第三點說明原來行政院的版本有一個其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/117.wav", + "text": "要強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/118.wav", + "text": "社會經濟韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/119.wav", + "text": "這個部分的金額高達1004百億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/120.wav", + "text": "元但是國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/121.wav", + "text": "強力主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/122.wav", + "text": "不可以空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/123.wav", + "text": "因為錢要用在刀口上所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/124.wav", + "text": "不希望空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/125.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/126.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜五朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/127.wav", + "text": "雖然沒有寫成決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/128.wav", + "text": "但柯總召也有善意回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/129.wav", + "text": "我們有達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/130.wav", + "text": "他說會初步回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/131.wav", + "text": "那我們今天也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/132.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/133.wav", + "text": "民進黨提的版本的第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/134.wav", + "text": "已經把過去行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/135.wav", + "text": "送來的第9款其他項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/136.wav", + "text": "了我也代表國民黨黨團表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/137.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯總召善意的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/138.wav", + "text": "好不好以上三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/139.wav", + "text": "看起來氣氛不錯喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/140.wav", + "text": "院長各位黨團的代表各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/141.wav", + "text": "各位委員各位部會的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/142.wav", + "text": "財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/143.wav", + "text": "應該要正視這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/144.wav", + "text": "就是這幾年稅收的估算落差這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/145.wav", + "text": "不叫超徵稅額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/146.wav", + "text": "你沒有估算到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/147.wav", + "text": "然後讓這個情況一而再再而三的發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/148.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/149.wav", + "text": "應該要給國人一個合理的交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/150.wav", + "text": "本來預估是4,500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/151.wav", + "text": "究竟為什麼這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/152.wav", + "text": "會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/153.wav", + "text": "會不會過幾天又改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/154.wav", + "text": "這個部分財政部跟主計總處應該要說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/155.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分就是面對這樣嚴重失準的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/156.wav", + "text": "有何改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/157.wav", + "text": "的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/158.wav", + "text": "要怎麼改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/159.wav", + "text": "否則我們是不是每一年都要坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/160.wav", + "text": "來處理這個所謂超徵稅額的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/161.wav", + "text": "不應該常態化監察院也有提出過相關的糾正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/162.wav", + "text": "要求要遵守國家財政收支和預算編列相關法令的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/163.wav", + "text": "嚴守財政紀律這是非常基本的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/164.wav", + "text": "不應該讓特別預算常態化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/165.wav", + "text": "政府的每一分錢都來自人民的血汗錢應該要把它用在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/166.wav", + "text": "真正緊急迫切的需要上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/167.wav", + "text": "\n再來特別預算只有在什麼樣的情況之下有正當性就是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/168.wav", + "text": "預算法上面的條文全部都盤整一遍之後你會發現只有優先關注在弱勢族群上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/169.wav", + "text": "然後穩健國家照顧體系才有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/170.wav", + "text": "要發現金的前提應該是真正照顧這些社會上的弱勢者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/171.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/172.wav", + "text": "第3條的部分其實本來我們的版本裡面就提到免除學貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/173.wav", + "text": "我們也樂見民進黨團今天的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/174.wav", + "text": "第3條裡面也加了減免學貸的這個部分但是到底要怎麼減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/175.wav", + "text": "時力黨團所提出第3條的版本裡面基本上都是關注在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/176.wav", + "text": "弱勢族群身上這又回到我剛剛說的大原則譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/177.wav", + "text": "之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/178.wav", + "text": "時力黨團就會認為這樣的說法太過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/179.wav", + "text": "等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/180.wav", + "text": "刪掉本來行政院版本的得經立法院同意延長之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/181.wav", + "text": "雖然跟我們的版本差距1年但是這個方向我們基本��也是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/182.wav", + "text": "再去做相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/183.wav", + "text": "延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/184.wav", + "text": "這個條例裡面的預算條例裡面有提到因為要繞過政府採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/185.wav", + "text": "相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/186.wav", + "text": "基本上我們是反對的立場因為政府的標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/187.wav", + "text": "法務部陳明堂次長也在這邊應該非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/188.wav", + "text": "其實政府採購法第105條只有規定不適用招標決標的事由啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/189.wav", + "text": "所以你根本不需要\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/190.wav", + "text": "這個條例不適用招標條款的話為什麼政府採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/191.wav", + "text": "第105條不能夠適用所以這個沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/192.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/193.wav", + "text": "按照規定來如果你按照這個規定通過條例且條例通過了預算之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/194.wav", + "text": "這些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/195.wav", + "text": "它的採購它的招標它的決標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/196.wav", + "text": "通盤地處理不需要在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/197.wav", + "text": "政府採購法相關規定去做相應的處理以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/198.wav", + "text": "好台灣民眾黨由張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/199.wav", + "text": "疫後條例表達一些看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/200.wav", + "text": "但是我們還是要先講清楚一下這個觀念到底是怎麼來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/201.wav", + "text": "的剛才時力黨團邱總召也講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/202.wav", + "text": "一事我必須這樣講回到這個事情的英文層面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/203.wav", + "text": "徵就英文的字眼就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/204.wav", + "text": "很簡單來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/205.wav", + "text": "就是你的稅收你的taxrevenue收來之後結果發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/206.wav", + "text": "比當初預期的要多很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/207.wav", + "text": "\n我們這次也很清楚的知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/208.wav", + "text": "為什麼這幾年會特別多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/209.wav", + "text": "等產業他們的營所稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/210.wav", + "text": "比我們預期的要多所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/211.wav", + "text": "造成有這個surplus" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/212.wav", + "text": "其實這有一個對應就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/213.wav", + "text": "的狀況坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/214.wav", + "text": "某種程度有點機會財的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/215.wav", + "text": "因為剛好這幾年機會特別好是一種windfallprofit" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/216.wav", + "text": "這幾年好不容易因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/217.wav", + "text": "而多出來這些錢但我們必須直說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/218.wav", + "text": "接著景氣會不會再繼續這麼好也很難說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/219.wav", + "text": "跟我們私人財政有點不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/220.wav", + "text": "但是政府常常是量出為入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/221.wav", + "text": "可能要支出多少然後開始要徵多少稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/222.wav", + "text": "坦白說如果這個觀念OK的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/223.wav", + "text": "大概就是基於過去那幾個概念一直編下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/224.wav", + "text": "但是剛好碰到這個機會點因而多了這些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/225.wav", + "text": "為什麼要講那麼多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/226.wav", + "text": "因為這就是多出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/227.wav", + "text": "就是因為景氣特別好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/228.wav", + "text": "光是一個台積電在這400多億當中就貢獻了五百零多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/229.wav", + "text": "我覺得他講的是真的實話這個我還是要先講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/230.wav", + "text": "所謂真的實話就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/231.wav", + "text": "如果真的有surplus如果是還稅於民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/232.wav", + "text": "因為是它繳來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/233.wav", + "text": "但是我還是必須拉回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/234.wav", + "text": "談這件事情本身這個多出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/235.wav", + "text": "也是因為整體社會的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/236.wav", + "text": "所以當然這個經濟果實要回饋全民這樣我們也可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/237.wav", + "text": "一來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/238.wav", + "text": "還債是一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/239.wav", + "text": "其實政府債務過去這幾年因為相關特別條例所以這方面編列得非常的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/240.wav", + "text": "是各種特別條例等等就將近有二兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/241.wav", + "text": "所以特別預算加上公務預算其實我們還是赤字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/242.wav", + "text": "好不容易多了這樣一個windfallprofit" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/243.wav", + "text": "比較充裕寬裕的資源之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/244.wav", + "text": "我們到底要怎麼來用這個錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/245.wav", + "text": "當時蘇建榮前部長自己就已經提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/246.wav", + "text": "按照概念本來就應該拿去還債才對因為在我們的公務預算當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/247.wav", + "text": "每次還債的比例其實都編列得不太夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/248.wav", + "text": "本來每次我們可以編6%結果卻只編列5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/249.wav", + "text": "這表示我們並沒有拿那麼多錢去還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/250.wav", + "text": "則我們要問一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/251.wav", + "text": "那潛藏負債呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/252.wav", + "text": "所以民眾黨才在第3條直接先點出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/253.wav", + "text": "勞動部長也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/254.wav", + "text": "所以是不是應該回到那個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/255.wav", + "text": "應該更加重視才對其實你們編出來的數字才只有三百零億而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/256.wav", + "text": "才只有三百零億而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/257.wav", + "text": "我們也知道勞健保在相關的補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/258.wav", + "text": "上如果1年撥補一千多億搞不好還是救不回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/259.wav", + "text": "所以事實上為什麼這次民眾黨不管在附帶決議或者等一下討論條文時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/260.wav", + "text": "夠高一點點再多一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/261.wav", + "text": "\n另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/262.wav", + "text": "我們可以贊成一件事就是在過去幾年為什麼景氣特別好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/263.wav", + "text": "台積電特別好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/264.wav", + "text": "或者是航商特別好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/265.wav", + "text": "當然它的經濟果實也來自全民的貢獻這點我們並沒有否認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/266.wav", + "text": "我們不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/267.wav", + "text": "還稅就還給台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/268.wav", + "text": "以發現金的方式把它發出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/269.wav", + "text": "當然我要坦白說這其實也不是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/270.wav", + "text": "香港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/271.wav", + "text": "新加坡等等其實也都做過這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/272.wav", + "text": "部分還是要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/273.wav", + "text": "所有黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/274.wav", + "text": "民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/275.wav", + "text": "其實之所以多了這筆錢好不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/276.wav", + "text": "因為景氣的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/277.wav", + "text": "所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/278.wav", + "text": "的surplus那我們是不是應該真正審慎好好使用我們說經濟果實可以共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/279.wav", + "text": "可以接受\n第二個既然還債的觀念可以通的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/280.wav", + "text": "那就是潛藏負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/281.wav", + "text": "既然這麼多勞保健保這些都會出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/282.wav", + "text": "那為什麼不撥補他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/283.wav", + "text": "所以這個地方才是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/284.wav", + "text": "按照預算法第83條我們知道很多的特別預算根本一點都不特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/285.wav", + "text": "但既然我們還是要往這個方向走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/286.wav", + "text": "就要把這個錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/287.wav", + "text": "普惠給大家沒有關係我們就是秉持兩大觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/288.wav", + "text": "還債還潛藏負債跟全民共享這個經濟果實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/289.wav", + "text": "這就是本黨這次主要的修正跟相關附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/290.wav", + "text": "主要的大方向以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/291.wav", + "text": "我們就直接進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/292.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/293.wav", + "text": "因為這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/294.wav", + "text": "所以大家應該都討論得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/295.wav", + "text": "我看名稱就先保留因為名稱大家談過很多遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/296.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/297.wav", + "text": "好名稱保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/298.wav", + "text": "看國民黨如果國民黨認為不用保留大家意見就可以取得一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/299.wav", + "text": "要不要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/300.wav", + "text": "請問民進黨團願不願意支持國民黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/301.wav", + "text": "不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/302.wav", + "text": "名稱先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/303.wav", + "text": "第1條沒有意見就通過以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/304.wav", + "text": "行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/305.wav", + "text": "就剛剛提到的基本上其正當性其實是相當低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/306.wav", + "text": "因為你要編列特別預算但在特別預算裡面你所要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/307.wav", + "text": "總預算就可以處理那為什麼還要編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/308.wav", + "text": "特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/309.wav", + "text": "能有正當性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/310.wav", + "text": "然後減輕人民的負擔以保障弱勢族群重點在保障弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/311.wav", + "text": "經濟成果制定本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/312.wav", + "text": "為什麼要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/313.wav", + "text": "做這樣的規定其實我剛剛提到預算法第83條裡面有關特別預算的法定事由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/314.wav", + "text": "跟大法官釋字463號解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/315.wav", + "text": "裡面的所謂的預算單一性原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/316.wav", + "text": "不管怎麼解釋因為第123款不可能符合嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/317.wav", + "text": "所以你只能從第4款去做解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/318.wav", + "text": "但是這個特別預算應當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/319.wav", + "text": "而且僅僅只能為了不可預期的迫切的額外的巨額支出加以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/320.wav", + "text": "編列否則的話你用常態性的一般性的單一性的預算去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/321.wav", + "text": "編列就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/322.wav", + "text": "在這種情況之下其實國發會主委也在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/323.wav", + "text": "你再怎麼強調預期今年的經濟不景氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/324.wav", + "text": "其實如果你夠仔細的話因為你都有做相關的經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/325.wav", + "text": "成長或是經濟景氣不景氣的預測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/326.wav", + "text": "那你去年的總預算的編列本來就應該制定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/327.wav", + "text": "所以此次特別預算所支應的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/328.wav", + "text": "雖然都算是合理的政策目標但其實可以看到從第3條以下幾乎都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/329.wav", + "text": "從內政交通等等到現在民進黨團提出的修正動議所加入的教育文化等等都是一般性常態性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/330.wav", + "text": "業務基本上政府本來就應該制訂相關的計畫該編列的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/331.wav", + "text": "幫助越來越弱勢的國民走過難關也就是針對這些風險耐受性較低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/332.wav", + "text": "受疫情衝擊而面臨危機的脆弱國民如果政府不即時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/333.wav", + "text": "立刻現在馬上通過這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/334.wav", + "text": "條例預算給予援助的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/335.wav", + "text": "那麼他們將難以維繫正當正常的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/336.wav", + "text": "本席再次強調把資源集中給脆弱群體以此來分配國家資源分配這些超徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/337.wav", + "text": "我們就該條文提出修正動議並希望能往這方向努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/338.wav", + "text": "國民黨的修正動議是這樣規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/339.wav", + "text": "為讓全民共享稅收超徵成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/340.wav", + "text": "以振興經濟刺激民間消費動能並減輕人民負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/341.wav", + "text": "穩定民生物價延緩全民健康保險基金與勞工保險基金收支短絀之危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/342.wav", + "text": "特制訂本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/343.wav", + "text": "這是我們的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/344.wav", + "text": "樣比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/345.wav", + "text": "因為行政院送來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/346.wav", + "text": "還是原條文仍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/347.wav", + "text": "舊是強化經濟與社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/348.wav", + "text": "及由全民共享經濟成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/349.wav", + "text": "我覺得行政院的第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/350.wav", + "text": "我認為國民黨的新動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/351.wav", + "text": "更符合整個條例的立法意旨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/352.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/353.wav", + "text": "時力所談到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/354.wav", + "text": "我很仔細聽他的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/355.wav", + "text": "他講了半天其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/356.wav", + "text": "我們有減輕人民負擔時力的也有弱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/357.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/358.wav", + "text": "穩定民生物價也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/359.wav", + "text": "只是全民共享這點你講到了合理而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/360.wav", + "text": "我們講的當然就是為因應疫情全球經濟挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/361.wav", + "text": "你說的是對經濟生活的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/362.wav", + "text": "其實差不多一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/363.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/364.wav", + "text": "我認為國民黨的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/365.wav", + "text": "比較窄化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/366.wav", + "text": "只提到勞保與健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/367.wav", + "text": "而民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/368.wav", + "text": "並沒有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/369.wav", + "text": "因為其實沒有什麼不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/370.wav", + "text": "既然說在第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/371.wav", + "text": "既然第3條就有這個意涵存在那麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/372.wav", + "text": "於合理這部分也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/373.wav", + "text": "即便是發現金但我認為發放也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/374.wav", + "text": "更明確明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/375.wav", + "text": "既然是特別條例就應該有它的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/376.wav", + "text": "又或者是有一個特別的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/377.wav", + "text": "不論是對於經濟生活的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/378.wav", + "text": "又或者是保障弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/379.wav", + "text": "又或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/380.wav", + "text": "由全民合理來共享經濟成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/381.wav", + "text": "其實都是有它的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/382.wav", + "text": "必須要在第1條的部分就先清楚的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/383.wav", + "text": "一次的立法理由是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/384.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/385.wav", + "text": "說實話我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/386.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/387.wav", + "text": "每一筆預算的編列都一定要合理啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/388.wav", + "text": "而且接下來在預算審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/389.wav", + "text": "也會針對它的合理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/390.wav", + "text": "包括數字的規模到底合不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/391.wav", + "text": "去進行審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/392.wav", + "text": "其實如果要加上合理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/393.wav", + "text": "其實每句話都可以加入合理二個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/394.wav", + "text": "合理減輕人民負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/395.wav", + "text": "合理穩定民生物價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/396.wav", + "text": "合理調整產業體質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/397.wav", + "text": "其實每一個都可以加入合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/398.wav", + "text": "這二個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/399.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/400.wav", + "text": "每一個事情其實都應該會要求合理啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/401.wav", + "text": "每個事情都是合理合法合憲的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/402.wav", + "text": "沒有哪一個事情特別要強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/403.wav", + "text": "強調是不是合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/404.wav", + "text": "合理的部分等到預算編列時再來看嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/405.wav", + "text": "我覺得剛才大家都非常平和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/406.wav", + "text": "在討論這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/407.wav", + "text": "民進黨團答應我們的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/408.wav", + "text": "對於我們認為是空白授權的第3條第9款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/409.wav", + "text": "願意做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/410.wav", + "text": "其他經行政院核可之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/411.wav", + "text": "強化經濟及社會韌性有關事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/412.wav", + "text": "既然民進黨的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/413.wav", + "text": "都已經修掉這個部分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/414.wav", + "text": "我認為在第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/415.wav", + "text": "也應該要做稍微的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/416.wav", + "text": "行政院的版本可以參考各黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/417.wav", + "text": "會有一個共識也增加效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/418.wav", + "text": "建議是不是可以請財政部跟主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/419.wav", + "text": "先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/420.wav", + "text": "就這個一而再再而三的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/421.wav", + "text": "所謂的超徵稅額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/422.wav", + "text": "你的預估都沒有辦法準確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/423.wav", + "text": "還一直在調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/424.wav", + "text": "是不是未來也還會發生這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/425.wav", + "text": "所以我們每年都要來制定一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/426.wav", + "text": "特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/427.wav", + "text": "然後編列特別預算去處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/428.wav", + "text": "在相關部會回答以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/429.wav", + "text": "我先講一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/430.wav", + "text": "框架和邏輯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/431.wav", + "text": "量提出來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/432.wav", + "text": "到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/433.wav", + "text": "後面包括後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/434.wav", + "text": "排除某某法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/435.wav", + "text": "既然是同一個框架的行政作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/436.wav", + "text": "包括政府合理作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/437.wav", + "text": "政府做任何事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/438.wav", + "text": "你們一定要加入合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/439.wav", + "text": "而我們沒有加入合理就不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/440.wav", + "text": "沒有這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/441.wav", + "text": "嘛你看你整個版本的寫法框架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/442.wav", + "text": "包括政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/443.wav", + "text": "要排除預算法等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/444.wav", + "text": "你和我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/445.wav", + "text": "我們不一樣的地方只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/446.wav", + "text": "政府採購法的部分而已嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/447.wav", + "text": "嘛這代表你現在挑戰的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/448.wav", + "text": "是你自己矛盾啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/449.wav", + "text": "你不能一直講這樣不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/450.wav", + "text": "這個是很基本的邏輯框架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/451.wav", + "text": "\n至於國民黨所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/452.wav", + "text": "他們既然要求我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/453.wav", + "text": "不可以有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/454.wav", + "text": "所謂的空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/455.wav", + "text": "我們也已經把它寫清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/456.wav", + "text": "照道理講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/457.wav", + "text": "這個大家應該是有共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/458.wav", + "text": "寫清楚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/459.wav", + "text": "列得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/460.wav", + "text": "你們是沒有還有經濟韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/461.wav", + "text": "而我們都寫出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/462.wav", + "text": "看起來你們的版本比較窄化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/463.wav", + "text": "這樣就可以了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/464.wav", + "text": "嘛只是突然跳到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/465.wav", + "text": "因為有一些是時代力量的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/466.wav", + "text": "後來我有看到民進黨團的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/467.wav", + "text": "我基本上看到值得稱讚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/468.wav", + "text": "我就會稱讚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/469.wav", + "text": "值得批判的我們當然是會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/470.wav", + "text": "對啦所以你可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/471.wav", + "text": "嘛我們在第3條這邊寫免除學貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/472.wav", + "text": "時候我在委員會也講了一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/473.wav", + "text": "就是認為青年人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/474.wav", + "text": "年輕學生的學貸問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/475.wav", + "text": "非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/476.wav", + "text": "然後被壓得喘不過氣來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/477.wav", + "text": "除了在學生時候的學貸之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/478.wav", + "text": "畢業之後找工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/479.wav", + "text": "民進黨團的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/480.wav", + "text": "現在看到他們在第3條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/481.wav", + "text": "了減輕就學貸款人的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/482.wav", + "text": "就是說你們也願意接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/483.wav", + "text": "我們的意見及這樣的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/484.wav", + "text": "我們當然非常肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/485.wav", + "text": "所以到最後這個文字長的會一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/486.wav", + "text": "是因為你們有參酌這樣的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/487.wav", + "text": "我們當然也是大大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/488.wav", + "text": "正面肯定嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/489.wav", + "text": "是抄我們的框架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/490.wav", + "text": "我先寫怎麼會是抄你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/491.wav", + "text": "這跟余正煌跟林智堅的不是一樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/492.wav", + "text": "誰先寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/493.wav", + "text": "你現在主張是我抄你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/494.wav", + "text": "但我的先寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/495.wav", + "text": "有部分不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/496.wav", + "text": "我是余鼓掌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/497.wav", + "text": "鼓掌通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/498.wav", + "text": "好那回到正軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/499.wav", + "text": "所以我就跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/500.wav", + "text": "你對的我一定會稱讚你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/501.wav", + "text": "長得一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/502.wav", + "text": "我回到正題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/503.wav", + "text": "我是要讓主計長跟財政部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/504.wav", + "text": "他找我吵架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/505.wav", + "text": "我們現在是要說合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/506.wav", + "text": "我很無奈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/507.wav", + "text": "不是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/508.wav", + "text": "有不同意見很正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/509.wav", + "text": "第一個我的要求是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/510.wav", + "text": "主計長跟財政部長等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/511.wav", + "text": "可以回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/512.wav", + "text": "因為這個確實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/513.wav", + "text": "到底為什麼低估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/514.wav", + "text": "我的重點是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/515.wav", + "text": "這個特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/516.wav", + "text": "主計長應該聽得懂我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/517.wav", + "text": "規定現在一二三款都不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/518.wav", + "text": "如果第4款要符合的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/519.wav", + "text": "的方向去解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/520.wav", + "text": "你聽我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/521.wav", + "text": "嘛我說你要有正當性的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/522.wav", + "text": "去照顧真正的弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/523.wav", + "text": "這樣才有正當性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/524.wav", + "text": "所以我才會在這邊說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/525.wav", + "text": "怎麼會長得一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/526.wav", + "text": "當然不一樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/527.wav", + "text": "只有一句話就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/528.wav", + "text": "普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/529.wav", + "text": "但按照我的這個邏輯的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/530.wav", + "text": "我就會說不對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/531.wav", + "text": "而是應該要去優先照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/532.wav", + "text": "這些弱勢者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/533.wav", + "text": "所以我的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/534.wav", + "text": "如果要發現金的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/535.wav", + "text": "就必須要針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/536.wav", + "text": "我們設計的這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/537.wav", + "text": "定要優先對最近一年之綜合所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/538.wav", + "text": "總額合計未達申報標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/539.wav", + "text": "或綜合所得稅率未達百分之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/540.wav", + "text": "所以我才會講所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/541.wav", + "text": "不合理是在講這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/542.wav", + "text": "每部法律的第1條就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/543.wav", + "text": "定錨說這部法律到底要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/544.wav", + "text": "所以為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/545.wav", + "text": "在第1條裡面加入保障弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/546.wav", + "text": "所以你的導向就會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/547.wav", + "text": "是普發現金嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/548.wav", + "text": "應該是要優先照顧弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/549.wav", + "text": "因為政府最重要的核心任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/550.wav", + "text": "就是在進行財富的重分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/551.wav", + "text": "就會變成全民合理共享經濟成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/552.wav", + "text": "這個合理本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/553.wav", + "text": "其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/554.wav", + "text": "政府首要任務也就是照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/555.wav", + "text": "社會弱勢者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/556.wav", + "text": "我們在楊瓊瓔委員所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/557.wav", + "text": "主持的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/558.wav", + "text": "中針對第1條已經爭辯過不少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/559.wav", + "text": "啦今天如果再用這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/560.wav", + "text": "寶貴時間來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/561.wav", + "text": "我個人當然覺得又是讓我們國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/562.wav", + "text": "對於這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/563.wav", + "text": "為什麼要制定這個共享條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/564.wav", + "text": "為什麼要把超徵稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/565.wav", + "text": "用特別預算再來一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/566.wav", + "text": "這個是不是大撒幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/567.wav", + "text": "是不是再一次對公務預算本來要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/568.wav", + "text": "再追加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/569.wav", + "text": "堆疊上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/570.wav", + "text": "我想這個當然執政黨要去面對民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/571.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得在第1條的概念裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/572.wav", + "text": "國之根本維護世代正義的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/573.wav", + "text": "精簡而且是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/574.wav", + "text": "回應到底明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/575.wav", + "text": "有超徵的時候要不要再來一次呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/576.wav", + "text": "後年又有超收的時候還要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/577.wav", + "text": "再來一次所以正本清源還是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/578.wav", + "text": "這是不是一個要優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/579.wav", + "text": "解決世代負擔的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/580.wav", + "text": "開宗明義如果要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/581.wav", + "text": "防疫掛鉤的話我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/582.wav", + "text": "覺得期期以為不可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/583.wav", + "text": "因為現在正在進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/584.wav", + "text": "特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/585.wav", + "text": "也就是我們的COVID-19的防疫及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/586.wav", + "text": "振興特別條例還沒結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/587.wav", + "text": "到6月30日才結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/588.wav", + "text": "所以現在我質疑三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/589.wav", + "text": "預算的關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/590.wav", + "text": "如果要做產業的振興要做弱勢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/591.wav", + "text": "協助到底要用112年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/592.wav", + "text": "預算來優先做不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/593.wav", + "text": "部分用6月底以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/594.wav", + "text": "還有特別預算的一些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/595.wav", + "text": "最後又回到我們新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/596.wav", + "text": "這幾款幾項的這個疫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/597.wav", + "text": "疫後強化經濟與社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/598.wav", + "text": "這其實是一個很混淆的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/599.wav", + "text": "那主計長也在這裡我那一天也有問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/600.wav", + "text": "可是他們沒有回應這個預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/601.wav", + "text": "使用分配以及每一期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/602.wav", + "text": "是不是各部會就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/603.wav", + "text": "權責自己去做調配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/604.wav", + "text": "或者這是一個限制的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/605.wav", + "text": "這必須還是要讓公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/606.wav", + "text": "能夠依法行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/607.wav", + "text": "小金庫在那邊挪用我覺得這樣是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/608.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望對第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/609.wav", + "text": "言歸正傳就是回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/610.wav", + "text": "執政黨想要普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/611.wav", + "text": "執政黨想要利用這一次超收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/612.wav", + "text": "的部分去跟國人說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/613.wav", + "text": "因為大家很辛苦所以再發一些現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/614.wav", + "text": "給大家第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/615.wav", + "text": "普發現金應該放在你們版本第3條的第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/616.wav", + "text": "結果你們卻把它放在最後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/617.wav", + "text": "所以這個是邏輯上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/618.wav", + "text": "問題\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/619.wav", + "text": "如果我們希望能夠解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/620.wav", + "text": "一部分的基金虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/621.wav", + "text": "甚至基金的潛藏負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/622.wav", + "text": "放到第1條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/623.wav", + "text": "作為開宗明義的宗旨這樣也是不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/624.wav", + "text": "所以我在這裡是期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/625.wav", + "text": "疫後這幾個字刪除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/626.wav", + "text": "然後就正本清源回歸你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/627.wav", + "text": "兩個主目的你希望振興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/628.wav", + "text": "經濟提升消費減輕負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/629.wav", + "text": "勞健保撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/630.wav", + "text": "把國民黨的部分再做一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/631.wav", + "text": "修正我覺得就符合現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/632.wav", + "text": "了不要再規定什麼疫後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/633.wav", + "text": "強化經濟與社會韌性因為你現在的錢還沒用完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/634.wav", + "text": "你還有剩幾百億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/635.wav", + "text": "就是上次8,400億用剩的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/636.wav", + "text": "作一點回應跟說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/637.wav", + "text": "的發言還有鄭運鵬委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/638.wav", + "text": "鄭運鵬委員是第十四位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/639.wav", + "text": "他發言完以後我們就請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/640.wav", + "text": "我們就保留請問這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/641.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長在上個星期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/642.wav", + "text": "大家就沒有共識了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/643.wav", + "text": "各位在野黨朋友要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/644.wav", + "text": "這應該沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/645.wav", + "text": "從我們的修正動議上就看得出我們的誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/646.wav", + "text": "而且擴大到說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/647.wav", + "text": "甚至對後面幾條我們都有做了調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/648.wav", + "text": "可以看得到\n這整部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/649.wav", + "text": "經濟成果的共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/650.wav", + "text": "不管哪一個版本都有自己的合理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/651.wav", + "text": "但是在前提上面大家就都不一樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/652.wav", + "text": "跟我們的看法是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/653.wav", + "text": "沒有超徵這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/654.wav", + "text": "然後我們來解釋這筆錢怎麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/655.wav", + "text": "那時代力量要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/656.wav", + "text": "邱委員到底是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/657.wav", + "text": "我們大家都在詮釋自己版本的合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/658.wav", + "text": "所以你們版本第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/659.wav", + "text": "裡面寫合理這兩個字就不太合理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/660.wav", + "text": "公共政策是多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/661.wav", + "text": "的你所講的弱勢強勢跟別人的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/662.wav", + "text": "不一樣這是在解釋它的合理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/663.wav", + "text": "譬如說你提出來的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/664.wav", + "text": "我們當然是在缺口上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/665.wav", + "text": "會去解決懸崖到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/666.wav", + "text": "或者是真的有急需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/667.wav", + "text": "你們所寫到的這些團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/668.wav", + "text": "包含項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/669.wav", + "text": "有很多其實在這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/670.wav", + "text": "並不需要特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/671.wav", + "text": "的特別預算去處理這個應該很明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/672.wav", + "text": "\n再者我們認為疫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/673.wav", + "text": "疫後國外觀光客來到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/674.wav", + "text": "應該要優先去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/675.wav", + "text": "觀光公車上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/676.wav", + "text": "不能夠用國內外形象廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/677.wav", + "text": "或國外觀光客來旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/678.wav", + "text": "所以這個合理並不是你寫了這兩個字就會合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/679.wav", + "text": "這是大家互相的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/680.wav", + "text": "第1條其實爭議不會那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/681.wav", + "text": "對於那些紓困的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/682.wav", + "text": "這些在某種程度上是形容性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/683.wav", + "text": "你所提出來的東西也不見得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/684.wav", + "text": "大家都認為很合理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/685.wav", + "text": "這是我的看法我覺得第1條就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/686.wav", + "text": "好那我們就照剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/687.wav", + "text": "講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/688.wav", + "text": "民眾黨講的要還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/689.wav", + "text": "其實只有補勞健保的虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/690.wav", + "text": "並不是還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/691.wav", + "text": "債你沒有拿去還債嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/692.wav", + "text": "只是補償勞健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/693.wav", + "text": "的虧損而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/694.wav", + "text": "那是化為負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/695.wav", + "text": "所以大家會有不同的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/696.wav", + "text": "我剛才有講要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/697.wav", + "text": "首長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/698.wav", + "text": "如果還是沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/699.wav", + "text": "我們這個部分就保留然後討論下一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/700.wav", + "text": "首先我要對賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/701.wav", + "text": "說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/702.wav", + "text": "關於疫後的特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/703.wav", + "text": "否流用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/704.wav", + "text": "一事上次的肺炎特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/705.wav", + "text": "預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/706.wav", + "text": "之所以能夠流用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/707.wav", + "text": "是因為災害防救法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/708.wav", + "text": "是可以流用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/709.wav", + "text": "而這個部分跟災害防救法無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/710.wav", + "text": "所以不會跨機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/711.wav", + "text": "跨計畫別的流用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/712.wav", + "text": "就是完全回到預算法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/713.wav", + "text": "所以它不會有流用的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/714.wav", + "text": "擔心的事情不會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/715.wav", + "text": "也就是說預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/716.wav", + "text": "編列多少就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/717.wav", + "text": "多少不得流用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/718.wav", + "text": "了\n至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/719.wav", + "text": "邱委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/720.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們的估計不準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/721.wav", + "text": "因為前一兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/722.wav", + "text": "烏戰爭的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/723.wav", + "text": "是千變萬化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/724.wav", + "text": "強烈的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/725.wav", + "text": "所以我們在110年編預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/726.wav", + "text": "六七月會編預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/727.wav", + "text": "處估的經濟成長率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/728.wav", + "text": "是3.92" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/729.wav", + "text": "%我做3.92" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/730.wav", + "text": "%經濟成長率的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/731.wav", + "text": "被所有媒體笑說是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/732.wav", + "text": "全宇宙最樂觀的估計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/733.wav", + "text": "結果實際的成長率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/734.wav", + "text": "因為我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/735.wav", + "text": "在疫情期間的表現良好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/736.wav", + "text": "很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/737.wav", + "text": "所以我們實際的經濟成長率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/738.wav", + "text": "是6.53" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/739.wav", + "text": "6.53" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/740.wav", + "text": "證券交易所得稅增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/741.wav", + "text": "營利事業所得稅也增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/742.wav", + "text": "個人所得稅也增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/743.wav", + "text": "所以才會造成財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/744.wav", + "text": "因為經濟情況變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/745.wav", + "text": "萬千我們編預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/746.wav", + "text": "是在六七月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/747.wav", + "text": "就編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/748.wav", + "text": "實際執行的時候經濟情況變好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/749.wav", + "text": "所以稅收就變好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/750.wav", + "text": "了因此才會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/751.wav", + "text": "所謂稅收的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/752.wav", + "text": "實徵數大於預估數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/753.wav", + "text": "至於邱委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/754.wav", + "text": "第83條的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/755.wav", + "text": "不契合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/756.wav", + "text": "不定期或數年一次之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/757.wav", + "text": "重大政事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/758.wav", + "text": "並不限於那三種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/759.wav", + "text": "這是重大政事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/760.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會編在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/761.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/762.wav", + "text": "我們稅收的實收數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/763.wav", + "text": "大於預算數的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/764.wav", + "text": "剛才主計長已經講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/765.wav", + "text": "大概有將近一年半至兩年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/766.wav", + "text": "所以相關的估測值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/767.wav", + "text": "有時候會因為國際經濟情勢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/768.wav", + "text": "當然財政部也在考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/769.wav", + "text": "其他更多因素讓它更為精準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/770.wav", + "text": "所以部裡面也成立了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/771.wav", + "text": "稅收估算專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/772.wav", + "text": "邀請主計總處國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/773.wav", + "text": "等機關以及邀請財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/774.wav", + "text": "經濟等方面的專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/775.wav", + "text": "學者一起來參與這個估算小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/776.wav", + "text": "希望我們未來的測算能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/777.wav", + "text": "更為接近事實的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/778.wav", + "text": "做以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/779.wav", + "text": "我看這一條沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/780.wav", + "text": "那就保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/781.wav", + "text": "剛才已經講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/782.wav", + "text": "他剛剛談到流用這個概念我理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/783.wav", + "text": "但是我想請教一下比如說第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/784.wav", + "text": "針對弱勢提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/785.wav", + "text": "關照服務這個在社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/786.wav", + "text": "救助都有相關的預算所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/787.wav", + "text": "這次你要編列的時候它會從哪個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/788.wav", + "text": "地方開始支用是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/789.wav", + "text": "新訂辦法還是要把原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/790.wav", + "text": "的辦法擴充這個會涉及到你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/791.wav", + "text": "使用預算來源的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/792.wav", + "text": "最單純的是以房貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/793.wav", + "text": "擴大性中產以下等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/794.wav", + "text": "是不是原來的300億元用完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/795.wav", + "text": "去支用這個是政事別還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/796.wav", + "text": "提出那個預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/797.wav", + "text": "都會列得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/798.wav", + "text": "說明要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/799.wav", + "text": "還有那個房子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/800.wav", + "text": "要怎麼做我們都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/801.wav", + "text": "在預算書上講得很明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/802.wav", + "text": "計畫別就不得跨計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/803.wav", + "text": "移用至於房貸那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/804.wav", + "text": "規定是不是可以請花次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/805.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/806.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/807.wav", + "text": "房貸那個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/808.wav", + "text": "其實是針對已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/809.wav", + "text": "買房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/810.wav", + "text": "而且貸款中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/811.wav", + "text": "所得比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/812.wav", + "text": "買的房子也比較便宜的這些家戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/813.wav", + "text": "的一種協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/814.wav", + "text": "所以它不是房貸補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/815.wav", + "text": "它不是房貸補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/816.wav", + "text": "它的邏輯不一樣它是協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/817.wav", + "text": "它也是一樣針對疫情過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/818.wav", + "text": "這些人其實經濟本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/819.wav", + "text": "就不是非常好可是在支撐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/820.wav", + "text": "的這些家庭的一個津貼的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/821.wav", + "text": "所以我想這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/822.wav", + "text": "或者是過去我們對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/823.wav", + "text": "房貸的補貼是完全不一樣的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/824.wav", + "text": "這是不一樣的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/825.wav", + "text": "因為房貸補貼是針對他買房子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/826.wav", + "text": "的支持但這個不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/827.wav", + "text": "所以為什麼是3萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/828.wav", + "text": "同樣一個基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/829.wav", + "text": "大家一次發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/830.wav", + "text": "可以很清楚看到它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/831.wav", + "text": "它不是在補貼購屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/832.wav", + "text": "而是這些人的辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/833.wav", + "text": "好第1條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/834.wav", + "text": "\n現在請大家看第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/835.wav", + "text": "對第2條如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/836.wav", + "text": "是不是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/837.wav", + "text": "院長各位委員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/838.wav", + "text": "我想還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/839.wav", + "text": "為什麼時代力量要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/840.wav", + "text": "要合理的共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/841.wav", + "text": "核心價值就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/842.wav", + "text": "時代力量主張應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/843.wav", + "text": "排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/844.wav", + "text": "如果沒有排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/845.wav", + "text": "這樣子的分配是不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/846.wav", + "text": "陳委員因為你比較晚到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/847.wav", + "text": "剛才講過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/848.wav", + "text": "因為你沒有早一點來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/849.wav", + "text": "我現在講第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/850.wav", + "text": "你就不要重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/851.wav", + "text": "第2條你就講第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/852.wav", + "text": "是我是在講第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/853.wav", + "text": "第2條時代力量的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/854.wav", + "text": "第2條你們沒有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/855.wav", + "text": "第2條後面有合理共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/856.wav", + "text": "有提修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/857.wav", + "text": "院長這樣瞭解嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/858.wav", + "text": "我是在講第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/859.wav", + "text": "接下來大家有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/860.wav", + "text": "是不是照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/861.wav", + "text": "行政院版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/862.wav", + "text": "跟第1條一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/863.wav", + "text": "要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/864.wav", + "text": "主管機關就是國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/865.wav", + "text": "預算編列當然是各部會編來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/866.wav", + "text": "嘛就這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/867.wav", + "text": "通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/868.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/869.wav", + "text": "\n第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/870.wav", + "text": "我看還是保留吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/871.wav", + "text": "第3條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/872.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/873.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/874.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/875.wav", + "text": "它有排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/876.wav", + "text": "我們的主張是認為要排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/877.wav", + "text": "我們的第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/878.wav", + "text": "因為行政院版是普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/879.wav", + "text": "應該要對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/880.wav", + "text": "最近一年之綜合所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/881.wav", + "text": "總額合計未達申報標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/882.wav", + "text": "或綜合所��稅率未達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/883.wav", + "text": "津貼因為這部分就是牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/884.wav", + "text": "剛剛主計長雖然有提到是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/885.wav", + "text": "是用預算法第83條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/886.wav", + "text": "但第4款也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/887.wav", + "text": "它的特別是在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/888.wav", + "text": "其實並沒有清楚說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/889.wav", + "text": "沒辦法正當化第83條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/890.wav", + "text": "第1項第4款的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/891.wav", + "text": "疫情下衝擊最激烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/892.wav", + "text": "最弱的人能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/893.wav", + "text": "給予他這樣的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/894.wav", + "text": "所以整個概念應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/895.wav", + "text": "是這樣\n第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/896.wav", + "text": "全民健康保險基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/897.wav", + "text": "勞工保險基金及台灣電力公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/898.wav", + "text": "這樣的撥補也是杯水車薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/899.wav", + "text": "也都在這邊你們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/900.wav", + "text": "撥補的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/901.wav", + "text": "處理因為不是年年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/902.wav", + "text": "都要編這筆特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/903.wav", + "text": "通過這個特別條例不然還得了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/904.wav", + "text": "究竟你們制度上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/905.wav", + "text": "解方在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/906.wav", + "text": "撥補的部分其實在上週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/907.wav", + "text": "四黨團協商我們也說明過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/908.wav", + "text": "政府對於國民的老年照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/909.wav", + "text": "應該不分職種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/910.wav", + "text": "制度性的改革應該是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/911.wav", + "text": "提高居住品質的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/912.wav", + "text": "剛剛花次長也講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/913.wav", + "text": "補貼300億元是不一樣的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/914.wav", + "text": "做這個房貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/915.wav", + "text": "的補貼有許多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/916.wav", + "text": "專家學者都提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/917.wav", + "text": "非常嚴厲的批判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/918.wav", + "text": "在於你們的房貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/919.wav", + "text": "補貼講來講去讓人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/920.wav", + "text": "多麼了不起的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/921.wav", + "text": "結果講來講去原來只有一次性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/922.wav", + "text": "的發3萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/923.wav", + "text": "你們一次性的發3萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/924.wav", + "text": "元要怎麼解決臺灣現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/925.wav", + "text": "高漲甚至引發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/926.wav", + "text": "減輕居住負擔跟提高居住品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/927.wav", + "text": "即便通過這個條文後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/928.wav", + "text": "政府方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/929.wav", + "text": "都不知道你們到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/930.wav", + "text": "要做什麼那規範的目的何在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/931.wav", + "text": "規範目的就是寫的時候要有可預測性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/932.wav", + "text": "嘛寫了之後沒有可預測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/933.wav", + "text": "\n所以時力的版本其實非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/934.wav", + "text": "清楚你們如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/935.wav", + "text": "補貼第一個部分3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/936.wav", + "text": "3萬元根本杯水車薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/937.wav", + "text": "第二個部分連臺北市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/938.wav", + "text": "都設定1,200" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/939.wav", + "text": "萬元以下以及貸款850" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/940.wav", + "text": "萬元以下甚至劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/941.wav", + "text": "需要補助的人補不到也可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/942.wav", + "text": "補到不需要補助的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/943.wav", + "text": "這不是在增加供給面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/944.wav", + "text": "而是在增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/945.wav", + "text": "需求面在需求面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/946.wav", + "text": "增高情況下你們不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/947.wav", + "text": "解決高房價的問題反而去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/948.wav", + "text": "而又再度推升房價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/949.wav", + "text": "只是我們在講許多專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/950.wav", + "text": "都已經提出這個是萬萬不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/951.wav", + "text": "\n時力黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/952.wav", + "text": "針對第1項第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/953.wav", + "text": "條文非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/954.wav", + "text": "非常久了過去花次長也一直在主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/955.wav", + "text": "解方就是優先興建社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/956.wav", + "text": "住宅優先興建社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/957.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/958.wav", + "text": "我要再次強調減輕經濟弱勢者的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/959.wav", + "text": "居住負擔包括租屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/960.wav", + "text": "需要的經濟弱勢者等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/961.wav", + "text": "之類的這才是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/962.wav", + "text": "解決的辦法\n今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/963.wav", + "text": "我們在談這個條文時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/964.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/965.wav", + "text": "讓政策可以定錨往這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/966.wav", + "text": "方向前進才是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/967.wav", + "text": "正本清源之道否則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/968.wav", + "text": "沒有解決本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/969.wav", + "text": "高房價的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/970.wav", + "text": "反而又製造更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/971.wav", + "text": "應該是在座的大家所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/972.wav", + "text": "不樂見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/973.wav", + "text": "我要請經濟部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/974.wav", + "text": "清楚我們知道台電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/975.wav", + "text": "現在連年虧損非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/976.wav", + "text": "一個部分等一下請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/977.wav", + "text": "部長說明一下謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/978.wav", + "text": "在學貸的部分的確青年世代是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/979.wav", + "text": "必須要關注且要關照的一個族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/980.wav", + "text": "黨團提出的修正動議把學貸部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/981.wav", + "text": "納進去雖然不是免除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/982.wav", + "text": "能夠朝這個方向給予肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/983.wav", + "text": "同時我們也看到增加了第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/984.wav", + "text": "擴大藝文消費及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/985.wav", + "text": "回到藝文活動的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/986.wav", + "text": "其實所有的文化生活不單單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/987.wav", + "text": "是只有看展看電影而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/988.wav", + "text": "包括觀看體育賽事等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/989.wav", + "text": "其實都一樣是屬於文化生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/990.wav", + "text": "的一部分而且除了藝文活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/991.wav", + "text": "活動也一樣非常需要現場觀眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/992.wav", + "text": "才有辦法讓它的產業繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/993.wav", + "text": "穩定下去這也是受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/994.wav", + "text": "疫情影響非常嚴重的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/995.wav", + "text": "族群不只是文化也就是所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/996.wav", + "text": "演唱演藝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/997.wav", + "text": "之類的包括體育其實也是一樣\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/998.wav", + "text": "\n過去的確是因為我們在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/999.wav", + "text": "文化禮金預算大部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1000.wav", + "text": "以為是來自於文化部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1001.wav", + "text": "今天我們如果用特別預算來提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1002.wav", + "text": "的時候相對應來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1003.wav", + "text": "其實都是文化生活的一部分只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1004.wav", + "text": "因為臺灣把文化和體育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1005.wav", + "text": "而導致體育相關的賽事是沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1006.wav", + "text": "補充到的我覺得這其實要一併來做思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1007.wav", + "text": "所以不論是從文化生活的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1008.wav", + "text": "角度從活動的型態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1009.wav", + "text": "又或者是我們過去提到青年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1010.wav", + "text": "族群心理壓力很沉重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1011.wav", + "text": "或者是吸毒問題普遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1012.wav", + "text": "氾濫的情況之下其實都很需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1013.wav", + "text": "鼓勵的方式來讓他們有其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1014.wav", + "text": "興趣來減輕這樣的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1015.wav", + "text": "應該只談的是文化禮金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1016.wav", + "text": "��化相關的產業裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1017.wav", + "text": "只有談到藝文活動而是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1018.wav", + "text": "把相關體育賽事部分涵蓋進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1019.wav", + "text": "這個擴大不是只有年齡層的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1020.wav", + "text": "擴大是不是應該從涵蓋範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1021.wav", + "text": "的擴大其實是比較合理的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1022.wav", + "text": "也希望大家能夠一起來思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1023.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1024.wav", + "text": "我們針對第3條已經辯論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1025.wav", + "text": "很多次雖然拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1026.wav", + "text": "各款裡面我們還是要檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1027.wav", + "text": "原來COVID-19防疫特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1028.wav", + "text": "條例振興的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1029.wav", + "text": "補助的部分救助的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1030.wav", + "text": "津貼的部分到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1031.wav", + "text": "看起來如果再加上這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1032.wav", + "text": "用一個新的名詞─創造社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1033.wav", + "text": "韌性以及全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1034.wav", + "text": "還是對於特定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1035.wav", + "text": "空間資源然後開始又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1036.wav", + "text": "擇定一些對象來設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1037.wav", + "text": "新的辦法新的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1038.wav", + "text": "這樣的門檻到底是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1039.wav", + "text": "疊床架屋呢還是新瓶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1040.wav", + "text": "新酒只是加一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1041.wav", + "text": "顏色夢幻一下變化一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1042.wav", + "text": "麻醉一下現在大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1043.wav", + "text": "什麼高房價問題低薪問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1044.wav", + "text": "等等這一件事情放到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1045.wav", + "text": "這3,800億裡面你到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1046.wav", + "text": "它變多變廣達到效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1047.wav", + "text": "呢其實檢視起來是很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1048.wav", + "text": "部長們都在這裡應該心裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1049.wav", + "text": "比我更明白到底為什麼還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1050.wav", + "text": "個別部會特定性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1051.wav", + "text": "對象的挹注我真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1052.wav", + "text": "覺得不需要再用這個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1053.wav", + "text": "是問題就是個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1054.wav", + "text": "回歸現在也要講不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1055.wav", + "text": "房貸交通運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1056.wav", + "text": "或者是弱勢關懷的部分還是那個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1057.wav", + "text": "最後你們會搞死公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1058.wav", + "text": "讓公務員不知道錢從哪裡發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1059.wav", + "text": "發不完的KPI還要找人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1060.wav", + "text": "來幫忙申請還要幫他申請還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1061.wav", + "text": "做完你們的數據我是覺得夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1062.wav", + "text": "\n我們的第3條還是很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1063.wav", + "text": "單純就是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1064.wav", + "text": "該要止血的該會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1065.wav", + "text": "變癌末的想辦法去拯救" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1066.wav", + "text": "一下花一點預算去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1067.wav", + "text": "一下所以第一個我們的第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1068.wav", + "text": "裡面還是強調先回歸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1069.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召講得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1070.wav", + "text": "勞保健保沒有辦法補到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1071.wav", + "text": "現在去年的救一救而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1072.wav", + "text": "光這一點也阿彌陀佛了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1073.wav", + "text": "\n是不是把這個再擴大一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1074.wav", + "text": "柯總召你的一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1075.wav", + "text": "可以嗎對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1076.wav", + "text": "我在講我的第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1077.wav", + "text": "對啊你剛剛說是還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1078.wav", + "text": "這不是還債啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1079.wav", + "text": "補償虧損而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1080.wav", + "text": "總召請你不要這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1081.wav", + "text": "因為你們把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1082.wav", + "text": "300億給勞保200億給健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1083.wav", + "text": "500億給台電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1084.wav", + "text": "做什麼用能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1085.wav", + "text": "解決什麼問題嗎這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1086.wav", + "text": "為什麼不讓世代子孫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1087.wav", + "text": "知道我們一定要正視勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1088.wav", + "text": "潛藏負債去年虧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1089.wav", + "text": "106年到現在是虧了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1090.wav", + "text": "1009百多億你只補了1,100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1091.wav", + "text": "得早一點快一點多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1092.wav", + "text": "是不是可以把你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1093.wav", + "text": "是不是可以先一點來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1094.wav", + "text": "問題嘛這個態度跟誠懇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1095.wav", + "text": "性跟世代要不要接受政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1096.wav", + "text": "用這種方式勉為過關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1097.wav", + "text": "所以我們的第3條原則講得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1098.wav", + "text": "很清楚\n第二個才是普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1099.wav", + "text": "到現在還沒有講清楚執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1100.wav", + "text": "然後曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1101.wav", + "text": "之間差了4,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1102.wav", + "text": "如果你再包山包海把九項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1103.wav", + "text": "十項案子列上去你就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1104.wav", + "text": "錢做事情所以項次別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1105.wav", + "text": "搞不好應該再減少一點然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1106.wav", + "text": "真的是救到比較需要的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1107.wav", + "text": "要不要有分級的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1108.wav", + "text": "讓比較窮困的能多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1109.wav", + "text": "這是你們可以改變的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1110.wav", + "text": "可是上次協商到現在沒有任何改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1111.wav", + "text": "只把第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1112.wav", + "text": "空白授權拿掉我覺得誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1113.wav", + "text": "不夠之外是沒有靈巧地去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1114.wav", + "text": "面對現在社會能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1115.wav", + "text": "看到執政黨誠意的一個改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1116.wav", + "text": "陳院長剛上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1117.wav", + "text": "把這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1118.wav", + "text": "正本清源的先提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1119.wav", + "text": "目前草案第5條提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1120.wav", + "text": "的是勞保1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1121.wav", + "text": "健保500億另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1122.wav", + "text": "很多人現在在意的就是公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1123.wav", + "text": "退撫基金也有破產問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1124.wav", + "text": "為什麼一樣是公共年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1125.wav", + "text": "公共基金的虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1126.wav", + "text": "直接寫挹注全民健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1127.wav", + "text": "撫基金也有破產的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1128.wav", + "text": "所以我們才提出公共年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1129.wav", + "text": "一視同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1130.wav", + "text": "希望能夠儘速在這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1131.wav", + "text": "特別條例中展現國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1132.wav", + "text": "要救年金解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1133.wav", + "text": "危機的決心麻煩柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1134.wav", + "text": "請劉世芳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1135.wav", + "text": "以後就曾總召發言再柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1136.wav", + "text": "我的發言可能跟其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1137.wav", + "text": "委員不一樣因為有關普發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1138.wav", + "text": "現金的部分看起來四個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1139.wav", + "text": "都沒有人反對只不過金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1140.wav", + "text": "民進黨是主張6,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1141.wav", + "text": "國民黨主張1萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1142.wav", + "text": "但是我的重點是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1143.wav", + "text": "誰可以領到這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1144.wav", + "text": "普發現金的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1145.wav", + "text": "有稍微提到普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1146.wav", + "text": "我會覺得對資格條件的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1147.wav", + "text": "要考量到跟以往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1148.wav", + "text": "振興券的發放是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1149.wav", + "text": "就是不論年齡只要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1150.wav", + "text": "是本國國民都可以發放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1151.wav", + "text": "在執行上會有困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1152.wav", + "text": "現金發放要以什麼樣的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1153.wav", + "text": "行政院提案規定是到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1154.wav", + "text": "前出生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1155.wav", + "text": "但是剛剛財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1156.wav", + "text": "普發現金可能會在六個月或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1157.wav", + "text": "主管機關在設定本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1158.wav", + "text": "條例請領資格的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1159.wav", + "text": "希望可以把它改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1160.wav", + "text": "對齊也就是只要是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1161.wav", + "text": "發放現金的截止日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1162.wav", + "text": "那一天以前出生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1163.wav", + "text": "的國民都可以請領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1164.wav", + "text": "當然這個部分仍然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1165.wav", + "text": "解釋謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1166.wav", + "text": "接下來請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1167.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1168.wav", + "text": "我剛剛一開始就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1169.wav", + "text": "有關空白授權的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1170.wav", + "text": "民進黨的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1171.wav", + "text": "但是我們要仔細看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1172.wav", + "text": "你看第1項第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1173.wav", + "text": "減輕居住負擔及提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1174.wav", + "text": "居住品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1175.wav", + "text": "第3款加強照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1176.wav", + "text": "弱勢族群及提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1177.wav", + "text": "關懷服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1178.wav", + "text": "推動產業及中小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1179.wav", + "text": "企業升級轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1180.wav", + "text": "這每一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1181.wav", + "text": "的範圍都非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1182.wav", + "text": "廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1183.wav", + "text": "其實我也知道你們要做什麼都已經確定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1184.wav", + "text": "嘛你就把它寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1185.wav", + "text": "減輕居住負擔及提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1186.wav", + "text": "居住品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1187.wav", + "text": "現在不寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1188.wav", + "text": "到時候特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1189.wav", + "text": "送來還是得寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1190.wav", + "text": "所以我是建議這三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1191.wav", + "text": "不清楚的部分要寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1192.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1193.wav", + "text": "\n第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1194.wav", + "text": "前幾天內政部已經公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1195.wav", + "text": "房��補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1196.wav", + "text": "臺北市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1197.wav", + "text": "以下你應該很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1198.wav", + "text": "問一下銀行就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1199.wav", + "text": "現在房屋貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1200.wav", + "text": "首次購屋貸款都是八成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1201.wav", + "text": "1,062.5萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1202.wav", + "text": "臺北市以外是700萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1203.wav", + "text": "貸放的話這房子只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1204.wav", + "text": "\n所以這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1205.wav", + "text": "我覺得恐怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1206.wav", + "text": "問一下銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1207.wav", + "text": "會比較合適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1208.wav", + "text": "來都只能買套房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1209.wav", + "text": "啦在臺北市850萬連套房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1210.wav", + "text": "都買不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1211.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1212.wav", + "text": "邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1213.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1214.wav", + "text": "針對剛才幾位的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1215.wav", + "text": "我很仔細地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1216.wav", + "text": "聆聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1217.wav", + "text": "我先從大家在法條上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1218.wav", + "text": "所顯現的來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1219.wav", + "text": "和我們的第3條也差不了多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1220.wav", + "text": "當然最大的差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1221.wav", + "text": "異點應該是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1222.wav", + "text": "至於有關減輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1223.wav", + "text": "減輕居住負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1224.wav", + "text": "差異而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1225.wav", + "text": "帶決議也提到退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1226.wav", + "text": "公教人員退撫新制的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1227.wav", + "text": "我在此先跟大家講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1228.wav", + "text": "包括剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1229.wav", + "text": "民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1230.wav", + "text": "對於這筆錢要怎麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1231.wav", + "text": "當然最主要是勞保1,000億以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1232.wav", + "text": "健保500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1233.wav", + "text": "元就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1234.wav", + "text": "和我們的一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1235.wav", + "text": "你剛才再提一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1236.wav", + "text": "撥補公共年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1237.wav", + "text": "可是你這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1238.wav", + "text": "我看你的第4條也沒有任何預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1239.wav", + "text": "撥補公共年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1240.wav", + "text": "的安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1241.wav", + "text": "公教人員退撫新制的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1242.wav", + "text": "去年年底立法院已經三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1243.wav", + "text": "而且今年7月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1244.wav", + "text": "要開始實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1245.wav", + "text": "而我們接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1246.wav", + "text": "以及朝野立委的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1247.wav", + "text": "也把撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1248.wav", + "text": "就是將來政府必須每年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1249.wav", + "text": "新制公教人員退撫新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1250.wav", + "text": "基金的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1251.wav", + "text": "我們現在講的是兩個不同的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1252.wav", + "text": "一個是公教人員退撫新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1253.wav", + "text": "到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1254.wav", + "text": "來想要有一些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1255.wav", + "text": "撥補公共年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1256.wav", + "text": "但是你的第4條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1257.wav", + "text": "我是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1258.wav", + "text": "在處理什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1259.wav", + "text": "你要回應當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1260.wav", + "text": "我知道有些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1261.wav", + "text": "公教團體也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1262.wav", + "text": "在這裡能夠有一些撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1263.wav", + "text": "但那部法的規定是在7月以後才開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1264.wav", + "text": "實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1265.wav", + "text": "政府也每年要撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1266.wav", + "text": "了在這裡你雖然有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1267.wav", + "text": "\n第二點關於勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1268.wav", + "text": "的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1269.wav", + "text": "你也講到自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1270.wav", + "text": "蘇院長開始到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1271.wav", + "text": "總共已經補了1,070億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1272.wav", + "text": "這時候再補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1273.wav", + "text": "2023年我們要補450億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1274.wav", + "text": "元等一下我想部長也會說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1275.wav", + "text": "我們在談的是國民黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1276.wav", + "text": "版本是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1277.wav", + "text": "勞健保及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1278.wav", + "text": "台電的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1279.wav", + "text": "我相信對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1280.wav", + "text": "經濟韌性以及將來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1281.wav", + "text": "經濟發展上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1282.wav", + "text": "我們的版本應該是最好的安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1283.wav", + "text": "是不是請各位委員能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1284.wav", + "text": "邱總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1285.wav", + "text": "勞保年金及健保的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1286.wav", + "text": "財務缺口我們認為有這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1287.wav", + "text": "的一筆特別預算這些應該優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1288.wav", + "text": "共識就是普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1289.wav", + "text": "的部分普發現金民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1290.wav", + "text": "排不排富的這件事情民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1291.wav", + "text": "發現金還是要簡政便民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1292.wav", + "text": "政便民以過去幾次的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1293.wav", + "text": "一些資格上的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1294.wav", + "text": "造成很多基層公務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1295.wav", + "text": "人員和相關體系的困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1296.wav", + "text": "其實衍生出來的隱形成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1297.wav", + "text": "社會上有非常多需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1298.wav", + "text": "所碰到的包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1299.wav", + "text": "俄烏戰爭以及低薪通膨高房價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1300.wav", + "text": "高房價還是所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1301.wav", + "text": "民怨之首那為什麼我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1302.wav", + "text": "整個修正動議後來會調整成這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1303.wav", + "text": "包含看到內政部這次提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1304.wav", + "text": "所謂居住三箭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1305.wav", + "text": "其實是換湯不換藥根本就畫錯重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1306.wav", + "text": "不管是利息的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1307.wav", + "text": "真正的問題還是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1308.wav", + "text": "不合理的高房價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1309.wav", + "text": "像這樣用短期的財務方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1310.wav", + "text": "去挹注其實是造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1311.wav", + "text": "一個市場上的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1312.wav", + "text": "是不是反而變相在替這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1313.wav", + "text": "廠商解套這是大家現在最大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1314.wav", + "text": "疑慮\n所以在沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1315.wav", + "text": "辦法很確定這個政策能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1316.wav", + "text": "到位的時候我們還是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1317.wav", + "text": "包含行政院的相關的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1318.wav", + "text": "不管是提升經濟韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1319.wav", + "text": "減輕居住負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1320.wav", + "text": "提升居住品質其實這些方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1321.wav", + "text": "都對可是在公務預算當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1322.wav", + "text": "其實都已經在執行了包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1323.wav", + "text": "我們後來為什麼把台電拿掉因為台電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1324.wav", + "text": "的部分公務預算已經撥補了1,500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1325.wav", + "text": "了怎麼樣能夠有效的精準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1326.wav", + "text": "縮短所謂的世代對立跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1327.wav", + "text": "經濟果實分配不均的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1328.wav", + "text": "這才是我們今天應該討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1329.wav", + "text": "的重點\n本席再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1330.wav", + "text": "以及財政紀律的原則之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1331.wav", + "text": "健保跟勞保財務缺口的撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1332.wav", + "text": "至於發現金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1333.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分大家也有共識我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1334.wav", + "text": "把它通過以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1335.wav", + "text": "看起來好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1336.wav", + "text": "是沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1337.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1338.wav", + "text": "王委員發言完畢如果還沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1339.wav", + "text": "我們這一條就保留這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1340.wav", + "text": "好那就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1341.wav", + "text": "讓經濟部回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1342.wav", + "text": "然後就保留\n現在請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1343.wav", + "text": "的主管列席是不是也請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1344.wav", + "text": "國發會這邊能夠把這樣的聲音帶回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1345.wav", + "text": "國發會回應一下\n另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1346.wav", + "text": "我們也看到第1款裡面有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1347.wav", + "text": "特別提到全民健保基金勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1348.wav", + "text": "像公務人員退撫基金雖然已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1349.wav", + "text": "有相關辦法應該要來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1350.wav", + "text": "其實大家都完全不清楚我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1351.wav", + "text": "被影響到的相關對象之所以都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1352.wav", + "text": "很擔心的也就是即便已經說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1353.wav", + "text": "要逐年撥補但是並沒有具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1354.wav", + "text": "的計畫他們會擔心未來撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1355.wav", + "text": "的額度到底是否足夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1356.wav", + "text": "提出附帶決議的方式來提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1357.wav", + "text": "對於這些相關的團體及對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1358.wav", + "text": "應該如何來做一個適時的回應讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1359.wav", + "text": "不要有這樣的擔憂又或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1360.wav", + "text": "如何能夠避免他們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1361.wav", + "text": "現在的特別條例只補助了勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1362.wav", + "text": "只補助了台電等相關部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1363.wav", + "text": "而退撫基金這邊其實也需要撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1364.wav", + "text": "卻完全沒有下一步的進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1365.wav", + "text": "所以是不是應該請相關部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1366.wav", + "text": "未來能有一個更為聚焦的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1367.wav", + "text": "一個比較良好的回應希望能夠針對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1368.wav", + "text": "部分清楚地告訴他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1369.wav", + "text": "這個撥補計畫的具體時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1370.wav", + "text": "具體內容以及具體如何來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1371.wav", + "text": "執行讓大家能夠比較放心我想現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1372.wav", + "text": "有這個聲音主要就是因為會擔憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1373.wav", + "text": "如果我們這次沒有把這個預算編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1374.wav", + "text": "進去會不會未來的撥補仍然不足以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1375.wav", + "text": "資源被吃掉的情況下未來會不會沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1376.wav", + "text": "公教退撫的部分來所以我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1377.wav", + "text": "的是如果我們這個條例沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1378.wav", + "text": "也希望相關部會應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1379.wav", + "text": "好好地進行溝通針對比較明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1380.wav", + "text": "計畫比較明確的時程比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1381.wav", + "text": "良好的溝通避免這樣的爭議或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1382.wav", + "text": "這樣的擔憂持續存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1383.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團剛才的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1384.wav", + "text": "稍微回應一下如果沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1385.wav", + "text": "禮金可以適用的範圍的確是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1386.wav", + "text": "比較在藝文活動方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1387.wav", + "text": "剛才委員提到是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1388.wav", + "text": "要擴大它的範圍\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1389.wav", + "text": "對在特別條例裡面因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1390.wav", + "text": "使用範圍現在主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1391.wav", + "text": "還是在藝文活動裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1392.wav", + "text": "可不可以擴大範圍的部分我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1393.wav", + "text": "我們跟相關部會再來做一些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1394.wav", + "text": "以上好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1395.wav", + "text": "就是俄烏戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1396.wav", + "text": "三四倍以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1397.wav", + "text": "而且持續這麼長久的時間這在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1398.wav", + "text": "歷史上也是非常非常少見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1399.wav", + "text": "的所以各國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1400.wav", + "text": "第一個它先反映了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1401.wav", + "text": "變成全球的通膨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1402.wav", + "text": "之後仍舊沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1403.wav", + "text": "缺口所以各國接著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1404.wav", + "text": "要嘛去補助住戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1405.wav", + "text": "要嘛去補助電力公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1406.wav", + "text": "要把電力公司收歸國有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1407.wav", + "text": "所以這是各國非常普遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1408.wav", + "text": "的一個現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1409.wav", + "text": "那在台電的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1410.wav", + "text": "各位委員也看到去年台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1411.wav", + "text": "就家庭用電來講用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1412.wav", + "text": "損讓物價穩定讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1413.wav", + "text": "大家不要像其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1414.wav", + "text": "我們就是看到其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1415.wav", + "text": "臺灣的政策在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1416.wav", + "text": "工業用電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1417.wav", + "text": "上有適度的上漲但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1418.wav", + "text": "在很多弱勢的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1419.wav", + "text": "以及一般的家庭用戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1420.wav", + "text": "不太去上漲也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1421.wav", + "text": "讓國內的幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1422.wav", + "text": "目標同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1423.wav", + "text": "去兼顧但是確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1424.wav", + "text": "這個真的是幾十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1425.wav", + "text": "來少見的現象所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1426.wav", + "text": "能夠挹注台電的話至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1427.wav", + "text": "對台電的經營及穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1428.wav", + "text": "供電還是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1429.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1430.wav", + "text": "購買這個部分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1431.wav", + "text": "撥補嗎是這樣嗎對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1432.wav", + "text": "就是能夠主要在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1433.wav", + "text": "有關於第3條因為沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1434.wav", + "text": "送院會處理\n請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1435.wav", + "text": "看第4條第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1436.wav", + "text": "也是保留送院會處理看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1437.wav", + "text": "大家意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1438.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就針對第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1439.wav", + "text": "政府採購法這可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1440.wav", + "text": "有點做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1441.wav", + "text": "是不是照行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1442.wav", + "text": "就照審查會的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1443.wav", + "text": "不是第4條我剛剛有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1444.wav", + "text": "對採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1445.wav", + "text": "的問題我要講一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1446.wav", + "text": "還是你要先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1447.wav", + "text": "規定把這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1448.wav", + "text": "特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1449.wav", + "text": "採購跟決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1450.wav", + "text": "決標等等之類的都繞過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1451.wav", + "text": "政府採購法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1452.wav", + "text": "這個當然是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1453.wav", + "text": "正好相反事實上政府採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1454.wav", + "text": "法裡面其實就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1455.wav", + "text": "不適用政府採購法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1456.wav", + "text": "政府採購法第105條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1457.wav", + "text": "就有相關的規定其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1458.wav", + "text": "非常清楚的所以我們看不出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1459.wav", + "text": "有什麼道理院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1460.wav", + "text": "政府採購法相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1461.wav", + "text": "所以針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1462.wav", + "text": "看機關要不要做個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1463.wav", + "text": "看不出來為什麼要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1464.wav", + "text": "請回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1465.wav", + "text": "等一下可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1466.wav", + "text": "對只有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1467.wav", + "text": "普發現金這一項排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1468.wav", + "text": "其他的全部都適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1469.wav", + "text": "因為普發現金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1470.wav", + "text": "規模是全國性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1471.wav", + "text": "規模非常非常之大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1472.wav", + "text": "然後它還有時程上的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1473.wav", + "text": "限制如果用招標法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1474.wav", + "text": "好幾個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1475.wav", + "text": "時程上會有一些延宕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1476.wav", + "text": "程序上來講因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1477.wav", + "text": "會委託一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1478.wav", + "text": "財團法人就是公部門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1479.wav", + "text": "一些財團法人這個部分如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1480.wav", + "text": "要用招標的話我們又很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1481.wav", + "text": "因為這個是普發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1482.wav", + "text": "且錢的問題也要比較慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1483.wav", + "text": "所以基本上都要我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1484.wav", + "text": "法人來執行是比較妥當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1485.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1486.wav", + "text": "好那沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1487.wav", + "text": "採購法第105條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1488.wav", + "text": "只有普發現金這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1489.wav", + "text": "有這個部分而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1490.wav", + "text": "我看就保留因為審查會也建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1491.wav", + "text": "可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1492.wav", + "text": "修正動議通過這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1493.wav", + "text": "這個修正動議是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1494.wav", + "text": "第10款普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1495.wav", + "text": "的相關業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1496.wav", + "text": "招標又要搞好幾個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1497.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法適用政府採購法第105" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1498.wav", + "text": "條上面所指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1499.wav", + "text": "不用去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1500.wav", + "text": "我的問題在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1501.wav", + "text": "加強說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1502.wav", + "text": "為什麼不適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1503.wav", + "text": "它的原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1504.wav", + "text": "那就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1505.wav", + "text": "照修正動議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1506.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1507.wav", + "text": "\n請大家看第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1508.wav", + "text": "第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1509.wav", + "text": "有沒有如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1510.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1511.wav", + "text": "民進黨團的修正動議通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1512.wav", + "text": "請賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1513.wav", + "text": "還是要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1514.wav", + "text": "因為涉及到各版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1515.wav", + "text": "修訂的一致性邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1516.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1517.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1518.wav", + "text": "好第5條也保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1519.wav", + "text": "請看第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1520.wav", + "text": "第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1521.wav", + "text": "也沒有人有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1522.wav", + "text": "應該沒有意見第6條就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1523.wav", + "text": "\n請看第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1524.wav", + "text": "第7條第2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1525.wav", + "text": "2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1526.wav", + "text": "本條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1527.wav", + "text": "得經立法院同意延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1528.wav", + "text": "之這部分我們不要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1529.wav", + "text": "第2項不必了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1530.wav", + "text": "我們有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1531.wav", + "text": "剩下就是到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1532.wav", + "text": "每個版本都不大一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1533.wav", + "text": "可能要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1534.wav", + "text": "日民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1535.wav", + "text": "所以施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1536.wav", + "text": "期間不大一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1537.wav", + "text": "我們不延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1538.wav", + "text": "所以你的是接近我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1539.wav", + "text": "不延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1540.wav", + "text": "但是我們時間比較長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1541.wav", + "text": "我們的時間比較長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1542.wav", + "text": "我們就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1543.wav", + "text": "照行政院我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1544.wav", + "text": "因為國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1545.wav", + "text": "本來只有發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1546.wav", + "text": "所以原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1547.wav", + "text": "到年底可以發完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1548.wav", + "text": "現在因為增加一些項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1549.wav", + "text": "所以我們後來的修正動議是到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1550.wav", + "text": "明年5月19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1551.wav", + "text": "倒覺得不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1552.wav", + "text": "其實民進黨可以再檢討一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1553.wav", + "text": "你不要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1554.wav", + "text": "114年12月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1555.wav", + "text": "不要那麼長啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1556.wav", + "text": "我是建議可以再談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1557.wav", + "text": "那麼長的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1558.wav", + "text": "等一下我們叫行政部門再解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1559.wav", + "text": "為什麼要到2025年12" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1560.wav", + "text": "12月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1561.wav", + "text": "等一下再說明沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1562.wav", + "text": "我想藉這個機會再跟經濟部長談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1563.wav", + "text": "南部已經非常非常多天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1564.wav", + "text": "不下雨了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1565.wav", + "text": "現在很多團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1566.wav", + "text": "也表示是不是跟空污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1567.wav", + "text": "那等一下再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1568.wav", + "text": "所以拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1569.wav", + "text": "一定要趕快去做陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1570.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1571.wav", + "text": "我們先把這一條討論好好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1572.wav", + "text": "有沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1573.wav", + "text": "沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1574.wav", + "text": "好沒有共識就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1575.wav", + "text": "\n現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1576.wav", + "text": "保留四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1577.wav", + "text": "是第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1578.wav", + "text": "是吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1579.wav", + "text": "其他保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1580.wav", + "text": "保留名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1581.wav", + "text": "要不要再讓步一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1582.wav", + "text": "不要保留吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1583.wav", + "text": "名稱不要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1584.wav", + "text": "名稱不要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1585.wav", + "text": "就照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1586.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1587.wav", + "text": "好名稱通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1588.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1589.wav", + "text": "這個先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1590.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1591.wav", + "text": "確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1592.wav", + "text": "請部長稍微回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1593.wav", + "text": "我們把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1594.wav", + "text": "先簽完再來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1595.wav", + "text": "請經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1596.wav", + "text": "第一點有關這兩天的空污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1597.wav", + "text": "把境外的污染物吹進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1598.wav", + "text": "的第二點這樣的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1599.wav", + "text": "我們會儘量降載南部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1600.wav", + "text": "燃煤機組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1601.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1602.wav", + "text": "跟降雨量的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1603.wav", + "text": "做個研究調查可不可以趕快想辦法改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1604.wav", + "text": "不然都沒有水了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1605.wav", + "text": "之前有研究過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1606.wav", + "text": "我們可以再去注意一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1607.wav", + "text": "麻煩不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1608.wav", + "text": "歸咎於境外好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1609.wav", + "text": "附帶決議要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1610.wav", + "text": "附帶決議明天當場處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1611.wav", + "text": "不會處理附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1612.wav", + "text": "4比4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1613.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1614.wav", + "text": "我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1615.wav", + "text": "唸完之後大家有意見可以提出來修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1616.wav", + "text": "\n立法院黨團協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1617.wav", + "text": "協商主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1618.wav", + "text": "一本院國民黨黨團擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1619.wav", + "text": "稅收超徵全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1620.wav", + "text": "發放特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1621.wav", + "text": "及行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1622.wav", + "text": "疫後強化經濟與社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1623.wav", + "text": "韌性及全民共享經濟成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1624.wav", + "text": "特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1625.wav", + "text": "2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1626.wav", + "text": "\n開會時間112年2月20日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1627.wav", + "text": "(星期一)下午2時40分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1628.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1629.wav", + "text": "一法案名稱第2條第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1630.wav", + "text": "條文照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1631.wav", + "text": "提案條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1632.wav", + "text": "\n二第4條條文照協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1633.wav", + "text": "條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1634.wav", + "text": "\n三第1條第3條第5條第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1635.wav", + "text": "條文均保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1636.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1637.wav", + "text": "\n四審查會附帶決議7項保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1638.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1639.wav", + "text": "\n五協商通過之條文與立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1640.wav", + "text": "說明如後附" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1641.wav", + "text": "\n六本案院會進行處理時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1642.wav", + "text": "廣泛討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1643.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團推派1人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1644.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團推派3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1645.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團推派3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1646.wav", + "text": "順序輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1647.wav", + "text": "每人發言時間為3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1648.wav", + "text": "逐條討論時各黨團均不發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1649.wav", + "text": "並依上開黨團順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1650.wav", + "text": "進行各保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1651.wav", + "text": "黨團版本之處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1652.wav", + "text": "逐條發言1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1653.wav", + "text": "1個人也才發言3分鐘而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1654.wav", + "text": "所以也不會占用太多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1655.wav", + "text": "一個人太少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1656.wav", + "text": "因為有4條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1657.wav", + "text": "但每一條都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1658.wav", + "text": "如果不能逐條發言的話在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1659.wav", + "text": "不然就大體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1660.wav", + "text": "或者是逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1661.wav", + "text": "各自1個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1662.wav", + "text": "保留4條而已啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1663.wav", + "text": "保留4條啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1664.wav", + "text": "至少大體要多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1665.wav", + "text": "不然就大體多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1666.wav", + "text": "大體就都3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1667.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1668.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1669.wav", + "text": "保留一條一樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1670.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1671.wav", + "text": "那我們多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1672.wav", + "text": "沒關係啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1673.wav", + "text": "5個啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1674.wav", + "text": "沒有啦保留4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1675.wav", + "text": "4個人講就差不多沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1676.wav", + "text": "大體討論歸大體討論啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1677.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1678.wav", + "text": "一種是大體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1679.wav", + "text": "3311嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1680.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1681.wav", + "text": "你剛才是說3311" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1682.wav", + "text": "一次講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1683.wav", + "text": "保留的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1684.wav", + "text": "每1個多1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1685.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1686.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1687.wav", + "text": "3311啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1688.wav", + "text": "再加4個1啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1689.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1690.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1691.wav", + "text": "大力稱讚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1692.wav", + "text": "減輕學貸啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1693.wav", + "text": "邏輯要通好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1694.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1695.wav", + "text": "OK下課下課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14787/1696.wav", + "text": "家簽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/0.wav", + "text": "我們現在要協商國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1.wav", + "text": "擬具稅收超徵全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/2.wav", + "text": "發放特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/3.wav", + "text": "\n以及行政院函請審議疫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/4.wav", + "text": "疫後強化經濟���社會韌性及全民共享經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/5.wav", + "text": "成果特別條例草案2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/6.wav", + "text": "本案在112年1月17日(星期二)18日(星期三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/7.wav", + "text": ")舉行第10屆第6會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/8.wav", + "text": "經濟內政財政交通社會福利及衛生環境5個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/9.wav", + "text": "第1次聯席會議進行審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/10.wav", + "text": "審查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/11.wav", + "text": "為所有提案(含修正動議及附帶決議7項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/12.wav", + "text": ")均予保留提報院會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/13.wav", + "text": "院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/14.wav", + "text": "\n本案是因為行政院因應本院以及社會民意的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/15.wav", + "text": "提出本特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/16.wav", + "text": "運用財政餘裕用於強化經濟與社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/17.wav", + "text": "挹注勞健保及台電以及全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/18.wav", + "text": "普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/19.wav", + "text": "特別條例的重點並非防疫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/20.wav", + "text": "而是因應經濟情勢普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/21.wav", + "text": "以及刺激消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/22.wav", + "text": "特別條例經過立法院三讀通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/23.wav", + "text": "行政院應隨即送出特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/24.wav", + "text": "經立法院三讀相關預算始得動支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/25.wav", + "text": "支我們希望今天的協商能夠有一個圓滿的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/26.wav", + "text": "召委各位委員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/27.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團擬具的稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/28.wav", + "text": "超徵全民共享發放特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/29.wav", + "text": "疫後強化經濟與社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/30.wav", + "text": "及全民共享經濟成果特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/31.wav", + "text": "會議中特別做一些說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/32.wav", + "text": "剛才主席提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/33.wav", + "text": "經過這一個月以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/34.wav", + "text": "事實上行政院有持續地檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/35.wav", + "text": "立法委員所提出的很多想法跟意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/36.wav", + "text": "很多的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/37.wav", + "text": "基本上還是希望行政院可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/38.wav", + "text": "因應COVID-19疫後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/39.wav", + "text": "面對全世界的經濟挑戰之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/40.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣來減輕人民的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/41.wav", + "text": "然後穩定民生物價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/42.wav", + "text": "維持經濟的成長動能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/43.wav", + "text": "這些聲音事實上我們也都聽到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/44.wav", + "text": "尤其是六都的市長們都非常期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/45.wav", + "text": "希望這個方案可以儘快實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/46.wav", + "text": "這個方案將來就會放在���個特別預算裡面實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/47.wav", + "text": "中低收入以下房貸族的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/48.wav", + "text": "事實上六都的市長也多有期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/49.wav", + "text": "這些林林總總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/50.wav", + "text": "我們都聽到了各界反映的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/51.wav", + "text": "這些訴求我們都會彙整起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/52.wav", + "text": "那我們會把這些訴求如實地反映在特別預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/53.wav", + "text": "以上說明與報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/54.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/55.wav", + "text": "我們現在直接進入協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/56.wav", + "text": "有行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/57.wav", + "text": "國民黨版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/58.wav", + "text": "以及邱顯智委員等修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/59.wav", + "text": "同時再補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/60.wav", + "text": "國民黨的再修正動議(參閱附錄)" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/61.wav", + "text": "所以我們一併併入討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/62.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/63.wav", + "text": "國民黨版的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/64.wav", + "text": "還有邱顯智委員等3人所提出的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/65.wav", + "text": "國民黨團提出來的名稱是稅收超收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/66.wav", + "text": "全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/67.wav", + "text": "發放現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/68.wav", + "text": "特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/69.wav", + "text": "我們這個名稱才符合事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/70.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/71.wav", + "text": "法案的名稱就照國民黨版的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/72.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/73.wav", + "text": "國民黨團民眾黨團的修正動議以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/74.wav", + "text": "及我們的修正版本裡面都有把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/75.wav", + "text": "國民黨團也有對台電的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/76.wav", + "text": "所以我們的方向趨於一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/77.wav", + "text": "但是名稱上我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/78.wav", + "text": "應該是比較沒有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/79.wav", + "text": "是行政院版的比較完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/80.wav", + "text": "剛剛曾總召所講的稅收超徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/81.wav", + "text": "超徵這2個字本來就不是法律名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/82.wav", + "text": "以後會誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/83.wav", + "text": "因為稅收不只是中央有地方也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/84.wav", + "text": "本來就是因為大家對這2個字有誤解才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/85.wav", + "text": "不只是讓預算找到方向也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/86.wav", + "text": "所以名稱的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/87.wav", + "text": "我是建議用行政院版就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/88.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/89.wav", + "text": "各位同仁各位部會的同仁大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/90.wav", + "text": "條例的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/91.wav", + "text": "是跟院版一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/92.wav", + "text": "就是疫後強化經濟與社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/93.wav", + "text": "及全民共享經濟成果特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/94.wav", + "text": "但是其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/95.wav", + "text": "這樣可能會比較精確一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/96.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/97.wav", + "text": "或者是國內需求變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/98.wav", + "text": "跟全球經濟的轉變等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/99.wav", + "text": "其實大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/100.wav", + "text": "而且可以預估得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/101.wav", + "text": "應當好好正視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/102.wav", + "text": "也就是我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/103.wav", + "text": "而且一而再再而三地發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/104.wav", + "text": "應該給國人一個合理的交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/105.wav", + "text": "近期財政部又上修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/106.wav", + "text": "去年稅收的超徵數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/107.wav", + "text": "到5,237億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/108.wav", + "text": "元這個部分等一下也要說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/109.wav", + "text": "決算就算決議要發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/110.wav", + "text": "大前提是絕對不能夠舉債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/111.wav", + "text": "而且我們是反對無差別地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/112.wav", + "text": "普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/113.wav", + "text": "也就是要有條件地發給現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/114.wav", + "text": "這個等一下我們會再來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/115.wav", + "text": "也應該要請財政部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/116.wav", + "text": "究竟為什麼一而再再而三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/117.wav", + "text": "發生這種稅收短估的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/118.wav", + "text": "而因此引起現在這樣的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/119.wav", + "text": "我們現在是針對法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/120.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/121.wav", + "text": "這沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/122.wav", + "text": "反正這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/123.wav", + "text": "這是短估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/124.wav", + "text": "稅收超徵真正的英文是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/125.wav", + "text": "是taxrevenuesurplus" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/126.wav", + "text": "多出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/127.wav", + "text": "的稅收當然說成短估也有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/128.wav", + "text": "但更重要的是整個經濟成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/129.wav", + "text": "特定的半導體產業等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/130.wav", + "text": "比如台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/131.wav", + "text": "還有寬餘資源到底怎麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/132.wav", + "text": "我們沒有特別堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/133.wav", + "text": "怎麼來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/134.wav", + "text": "這個surplus既然多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/135.wav", + "text": "我們是不是要把它花在刀口上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/136.wav", + "text": "這才是比較大的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/137.wav", + "text": "以上先表達一點意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/138.wav", + "text": "待會也請一併說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/139.wav", + "text": "名稱部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/140.wav", + "text": "我支持國民黨的稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/141.wav", + "text": "超徵全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/142.wav", + "text": "發放特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/143.wav", + "text": "當我們提出特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/144.wav", + "text": "為因應國防緊急設施或戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/145.wav", + "text": "國家經濟重大變故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/146.wav", + "text": "重大災變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/147.wav", + "text": "我們曾針對COVID-19" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/148.wav", + "text": "因為這是政府遭逢重大的變故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/149.wav", + "text": "等於是在比較沒辦法掌控的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/150.wav", + "text": "我們提出特別預算是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/151.wav", + "text": "疫後強化經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/152.wav", + "text": "與社會韌性及全民共享經濟成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/153.wav", + "text": "我認為這部分應該屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/154.wav", + "text": "COVID-19特別預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/155.wav", + "text": "跟我們今天要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/156.wav", + "text": "用超徵稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/157.wav", + "text": "是截然不同的兩種類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/158.wav", + "text": "所以我個人的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/159.wav", + "text": "還是支持國民黨的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/160.wav", + "text": "以及發放現金的金額是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/161.wav", + "text": "我們把它作成一個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/162.wav", + "text": "條例是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/163.wav", + "text": "疫後強化經濟與社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/164.wav", + "text": "我認為應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/165.wav", + "text": "是特別預算的追加預算才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/166.wav", + "text": "中它們分屬於兩種不同性質的預算方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/167.wav", + "text": "所以我個人還是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/168.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/169.wav", + "text": "各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/170.wav", + "text": "針對我們現在討論的法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/171.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團似乎還是堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/172.wav", + "text": "是支持行政院版的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/173.wav", + "text": "也有他們所堅持的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/174.wav", + "text": "是不是容許主席做這樣的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/175.wav", + "text": "既然三方的意見非常分歧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/176.wav", + "text": "我們還是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/177.wav", + "text": "\n現在進入實質討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/178.wav", + "text": "針對第1條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/179.wav", + "text": "召委進行得很順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/180.wav", + "text": "而且很有績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/181.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團原來提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/182.wav", + "text": "第1條是為讓全民共享稅收超徵成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/183.wav", + "text": "並振興經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/184.wav", + "text": "刺激民間消費動能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/185.wav", + "text": "將稅收超徵金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/186.wav", + "text": "以發放新臺幣(以下稱現金)方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/187.wav", + "text": "與全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/188.wav", + "text": "特制定本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/189.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團當時比行政院更快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/190.wav", + "text": "所以這個條例本來就是發現金的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/191.wav", + "text": "但是經過這段期間的醞釀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/192.wav", + "text": "最高原則還是希望維持發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/193.wav", + "text": "發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/194.wav", + "text": "我們常常接到民眾的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/195.wav", + "text": "因為很多民眾過不下去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/196.wav", + "text": "看看民進黨能不能接受我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/197.wav", + "text": "這是全民的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/198.wav", + "text": "假設你們不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/199.wav", + "text": "我們退而求其次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/200.wav", + "text": "以振興經濟刺激民間消費動能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/201.wav", + "text": "並減輕人民負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/202.wav", + "text": "穩定民生物價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/203.wav", + "text": "延緩全民健康保險基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/204.wav", + "text": "與勞工保險基金收支短絀之危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/205.wav", + "text": "除了發現金以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/206.wav", + "text": "另有1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/207.wav", + "text": "元要補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/208.wav", + "text": "還有電費部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/209.wav", + "text": "這些都有寫明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/210.wav", + "text": "也沒有所謂的空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/211.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團願意退一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/212.wav", + "text": "一步把它納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/213.wav", + "text": "就是國民黨堅持每人發現金1萬元但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/214.wav", + "text": "假設民進黨也非常堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/215.wav", + "text": "健保勞保及電費部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/216.wav", + "text": "因為涉及到全民權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/217.wav", + "text": "國民黨願意退一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/218.wav", + "text": "所以第1條的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/219.wav", + "text": "我們做這樣的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/220.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/221.wav", + "text": "賴香伶委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/222.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席及各黨的委員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/223.wav", + "text": "幫我們上了一課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/224.wav", + "text": "提出特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/225.wav", + "text": "防疫特別條例的追加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/226.wav", + "text": "預算這個概念我想大家並不是不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/227.wav", + "text": "因為有超徵稅額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/228.wav", + "text": "是希望從經濟韌性及社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/229.wav", + "text": "各方面都提出必要的支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/230.wav", + "text": "但我們要很遺憾地表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/231.wav", + "text": "並不是每年例行性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/232.wav", + "text": "如何運用到最大效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/233.wav", + "text": "甚至是在兼顧財政紀律之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/234.wav", + "text": "普發現金作為次要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/235.wav", + "text": "解決民生困頓的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/236.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個上位概念不能放掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/237.wav", + "text": "旨但整個預算來源是什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/238.wav", + "text": "其實不是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/239.wav", + "text": "才有提到類似財源的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/240.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得第1條應該正本清源回歸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/241.wav", + "text": "還要以還債為優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/242.wav", + "text": "而現在最困頓最需要國家挹注的就是勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/243.wav", + "text": "關於勞保潛在虧損10.83兆之事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/244.wav", + "text": "是不容其他政黨以意識型態抹去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/245.wav", + "text": "甚至不去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/246.wav", + "text": "所以我也呼應剛剛曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/247.wav", + "text": "在第1條明示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/248.wav", + "text": "條例的精神亦即能夠解決健保勞保債務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/249.wav", + "text": "這是我的發言謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/250.wav", + "text": "或者是勞工保險收支短絀的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/251.wav", + "text": "而讓它能夠永續地存續下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/252.wav", + "text": "全民利益及勞工利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/253.wav", + "text": "基本上這個前提我可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/254.wav", + "text": "但是我也要再重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/255.wav", + "text": "剛剛我講到的理論基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/256.wav", + "text": "也就是我們總召所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/257.wav", + "text": "維持原來的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/258.wav", + "text": "就是特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/259.wav", + "text": "怎麼去發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/260.wav", + "text": "發放現金是發多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/261.wav", + "text": "要怎麼去彌補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/262.wav", + "text": "換句話說剛剛賴委員所談到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/263.wav", + "text": "即怎麼去還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/264.wav", + "text": "這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/265.wav", + "text": "就是達到賴委員剛剛所談到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/266.wav", + "text": "\n第二個健保或者勞保虧損的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/267.wav", + "text": "在總預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/268.wav", + "text": "這樣處理是絕對符合法令規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/269.wav", + "text": "而且本來就應該��這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/270.wav", + "text": "至於防疫之後的相關振興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/271.wav", + "text": "的部分應該是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/272.wav", + "text": "延續有關振興的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/273.wav", + "text": "\n所以基本上我還是要釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/274.wav", + "text": "我個人支持黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/275.wav", + "text": "因為國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/276.wav", + "text": "所提的原始法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/277.wav", + "text": "也最符合法法令規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/278.wav", + "text": "其他的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/279.wav", + "text": "國民黨支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/280.wav", + "text": "全民相關利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/281.wav", + "text": "但是有些應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/282.wav", + "text": "編列在明年的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/283.wav", + "text": "COVID-19特別預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/284.wav", + "text": "追加預算部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/285.wav", + "text": "其實這應該要分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/286.wav", + "text": "結果破壞了預算制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/287.wav", + "text": "第83條特別預算的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/288.wav", + "text": "\n所以個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/289.wav", + "text": "一方面支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/290.wav", + "text": "大家對於健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/291.wav", + "text": "撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/292.wav", + "text": "另一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/293.wav", + "text": "黨團的原始提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/294.wav", + "text": "那我們提出的修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/295.wav", + "text": "但是我們絕對不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/296.wav", + "text": "行政院這種提案方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/297.wav", + "text": "因為行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/298.wav", + "text": "人才這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/299.wav", + "text": "主計人員這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/300.wav", + "text": "法令你們都比我們清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/301.wav", + "text": "為什麼你們就是要破壞預算制度呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/302.wav", + "text": "為什麼就是不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/303.wav", + "text": "根據預算法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/304.wav", + "text": "來編列預算呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/305.wav", + "text": "所以我支持黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/306.wav", + "text": "提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/307.wav", + "text": "邱顯智委員發言本黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/308.wav", + "text": "草案有特別提到對經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/309.wav", + "text": "生活之衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/310.wav", + "text": "減輕人民負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/311.wav", + "text": "保障弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/312.wav", + "text": "重點是合理的共享經濟成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/313.wav", + "text": "首先我必須要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/314.wav", + "text": "預算法第83條的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/315.wav", + "text": "其實就是一個特別預算的法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/316.wav", + "text": "事由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/317.wav", + "text": "因為它是在一個特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/318.wav", + "text": "情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/319.wav", + "text": "編列而由於是特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/320.wav", + "text": "所以要有法定事由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/321.wav", + "text": "因此在第1款到第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/322.wav", + "text": "都非常清楚提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/323.wav", + "text": "預算是在災難發生後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/324.wav", + "text": "即假設發生天災事變的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/325.wav", + "text": "為了臨時性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/326.wav", + "text": "額外的巨額支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/327.wav", + "text": "所以第1款第3款都非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/328.wav", + "text": "第4款是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/329.wav", + "text": "比較概括的條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/330.wav", + "text": "第4款不管再怎麼解釋都應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/331.wav", + "text": "要指出到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/332.wav", + "text": "有什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/333.wav", + "text": "超出原來編列總額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/334.wav", + "text": "預算時所可以預想到的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/335.wav", + "text": "而且還沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/336.wav", + "text": "以透過預備金追加預算的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/337.wav", + "text": "必須要訴諸最後的手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/338.wav", + "text": "用特別預算來加以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/339.wav", + "text": "釋字第463號解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/340.wav", + "text": "都已經說得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/341.wav", + "text": "在解釋本文裡提到預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/342.wav", + "text": "政府就未來一年間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/343.wav", + "text": "之計畫所預期之收入及支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/344.wav", + "text": "編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/345.wav", + "text": "以使國家機關正常運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/346.wav", + "text": "並規範國家之財政原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/347.wav", + "text": "應制定單一之預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/348.wav", + "text": "這其實非常清楚\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/349.wav", + "text": "所以時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/350.wav", + "text": "實際上在這種情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/351.wav", + "text": "正當性是非常非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/352.wav", + "text": "低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/353.wav", + "text": "這次比較像是分享經濟的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/354.wav", + "text": "紅利而非還稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/355.wav", + "text": "稅於民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/356.wav", + "text": "所以一來國發會再怎麼強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/357.wav", + "text": "今年的景氣不景氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/358.wav", + "text": "政府若夠仔細的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/359.wav", + "text": "去年總預算編列時就應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/360.wav", + "text": "制定這樣的施政計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/361.wav", + "text": "而這樣的特別預算所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/362.wav", + "text": "支應的項目雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/363.wav", + "text": "是符合合理的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/364.wav", + "text": "目標但是除了發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/365.wav", + "text": "以外我們必須要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/366.wav", + "text": "其他強化經濟韌性計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/367.wav", + "text": "幾乎都只能算是一般的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/368.wav", + "text": "常態性的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/369.wav", + "text": "政府本來就應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/370.wav", + "text": "在平時制定計畫編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/371.wav", + "text": "預算根本很難說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/372.wav", + "text": "編列特別預算之正當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/373.wav", + "text": "性的根據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/374.wav", + "text": "如果有任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/375.wav", + "text": "緊急情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/376.wav", + "text": "足以正當化編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/377.wav", + "text": "這樣的特別預算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/378.wav", + "text": "那時力黨團認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/379.wav", + "text": "耐受性較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/380.wav", + "text": "受疫情衝擊而面臨危機之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/381.wav", + "text": "脆弱的國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/382.wav", + "text": "若政府不即時援助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/383.wav", + "text": "他們將難以維持正常生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/384.wav", + "text": "人會變成再也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/385.wav", + "text": "無法繼續承受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/386.wav", + "text": "任何一次經濟的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/387.wav", + "text": "才能夠正當化這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/388.wav", + "text": "特別條例及特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/389.wav", + "text": "這次立法目的的修正動議我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/390.wav", + "text": "希望強調能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/391.wav", + "text": "把資源集中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/392.wav", + "text": "給脆弱群體也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/393.wav", + "text": "合理分配國家資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/394.wav", + "text": "促進公共利益及遵守財政紀律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/395.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/396.wav", + "text": "謝謝楊瓊瓔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/397.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團還有時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/398.wav", + "text": "黨團邱顯智委員所提的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/399.wav", + "text": "我想要一次來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/400.wav", + "text": "提供我的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/401.wav", + "text": "第一個這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/402.wav", + "text": "最主要是根據疫後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/403.wav", + "text": "也就是過去三年期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/404.wav", + "text": "在經濟甚至在社會韌性上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/405.wav", + "text": "造成的損害及傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/406.wav", + "text": "藉由這次全民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/407.wav", + "text": "剛剛國民黨黨團所提的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/408.wav", + "text": "修正動議大概是這一個月當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/409.wav", + "text": "有很多選民反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/410.wav", + "text": "所以提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/411.wav", + "text": "元現在增加了3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/412.wav", + "text": "保險基金及台灣電力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/413.wav", + "text": "公司的挹注但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/414.wav", + "text": "我要一再強調疫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/415.wav", + "text": "疫後的部分不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/416.wav", + "text": "這些事情而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/417.wav", + "text": "的第3條除了剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/418.wav", + "text": "才提到的全民健康保險基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/419.wav", + "text": "其實還有剛才時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/420.wav", + "text": "黨團邱顯智委員所提到的弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/421.wav", + "text": "在疫情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/422.wav", + "text": "發生時的弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/423.wav", + "text": "有哪一些年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/424.wav", + "text": "的關係因此在行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/425.wav", + "text": "所提出的第3條中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/426.wav", + "text": "方案其中已經涵蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/427.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/428.wav", + "text": "修正動議的部分一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/429.wav", + "text": "居住的負擔一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/430.wav", + "text": "照顧弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/431.wav", + "text": "擴大公共運輸補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/432.wav", + "text": "另外還有產業及中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/433.wav", + "text": "現在大家都在搶國際觀光客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/434.wav", + "text": "我們當然希望我們的國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/435.wav", + "text": "從以往的1200萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/436.wav", + "text": "儘速上升到5600萬甚至上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/437.wav", + "text": "族群此外當然還有普發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/438.wav", + "text": "沒有反對的意見只是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/439.wav", + "text": "是多少所以其實在經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/440.wav", + "text": "入其中剛才國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/441.wav", + "text": "所提的只有四項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/442.wav", + "text": "討論反而會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/443.wav", + "text": "這樣比較能夠照顧到全民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/444.wav", + "text": "預算法的部分剛才非常專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/445.wav", + "text": "翁重鈞委員所提到的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/446.wav", + "text": "不管是各部會行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/447.wav", + "text": "以及主計單位的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/448.wav", + "text": "當然都是按照預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/449.wav", + "text": "的所有法條內容來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/450.wav", + "text": "預算或決算的事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/451.wav", + "text": "不管是年度預算特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/452.wav", + "text": "發放如果有重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/453.wav", + "text": "發放的話這些主計單位的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/454.wav", + "text": "員就違反預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/455.wav", + "text": "統統都要送到監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/456.wav", + "text": "所以要相信他們的專業程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/457.wav", + "text": "會比較好因此我認為到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/458.wav", + "text": "黨團所提之修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/459.wav", + "text": "並沒有完全超出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/460.wav", + "text": "第3條的方案通過謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/461.wav", + "text": "針對第1條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/462.wav", + "text": "綜合各政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/463.wav", + "text": "委員所提意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/464.wav", + "text": "共識少部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/465.wav", + "text": "內容仍有歧異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/466.wav", + "text": "但很高興大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/467.wav", + "text": "都是以民為主我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/468.wav", + "text": "不管是勞保健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/469.wav", + "text": "真正照顧到全民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/470.wav", + "text": "\n行政部門針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/471.wav", + "text": "剛才委員所提的這些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/472.wav", + "text": "要提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/473.wav", + "text": "不一定啦哪有一定是國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/474.wav", + "text": "有沒有哪個部會要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/475.wav", + "text": "我也希望我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/476.wav", + "text": "只是在文字調整方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/477.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/478.wav", + "text": "委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/479.wav", + "text": "我想最近的狀況的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/480.wav", + "text": "有幾個非常特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/481.wav", + "text": "的重大政事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/482.wav", + "text": "三年來的疫情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/483.wav", + "text": "100年來最大的疫情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/484.wav", + "text": "見解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/485.wav", + "text": "文字已經都這麼清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/486.wav", + "text": "對所以我現在要解釋在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/487.wav", + "text": "這樣一個特別的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/488.wav", + "text": "我們為什麼要提出這個特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/489.wav", + "text": "條例因為臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/490.wav", + "text": "經濟在這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/491.wav", + "text": "想像主委我還是要打斷你的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/492.wav", + "text": "大家的時間非常寶貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/493.wav", + "text": "還要解釋為什麼會提出大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/494.wav", + "text": "已經實質在討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/495.wav", + "text": "嘛針對第1條的部分我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/496.wav", + "text": "聚焦在第1條的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/497.wav", + "text": "我特別給你們機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/498.wav", + "text": "在你們的版本可以調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/499.wav", + "text": "什麼文字\n這樣大家討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/500.wav", + "text": "我是說我們為什麼要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/501.wav", + "text": "維持我們所提文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/502.wav", + "text": "的重要用意就是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/503.wav", + "text": "因為我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/504.wav", + "text": "經濟表現特別好所以為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/505.wav", + "text": "要有全民共享經濟成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/506.wav", + "text": "的字眼因為主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/507.wav", + "text": "經濟成果要讓全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/508.wav", + "text": "除了共享之外事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/509.wav", + "text": "有需要幫助的地方所以才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/510.wav", + "text": "並且也要維持經濟的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/511.wav", + "text": "成長動能所以這些字眼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/512.wav", + "text": "理由是在這裡以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/513.wav", + "text": "針對委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/514.wav", + "text": "再修正版本以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/515.wav", + "text": "剛才所有委員所提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/516.wav", + "text": "你能否說明這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/517.wav", + "text": "還是你就是維持你們的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/518.wav", + "text": "也可以這麼說好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/519.wav", + "text": "有關他們所提出的是否有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/520.wav", + "text": "可以融入的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/521.wav", + "text": "我們希望維持原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/522.wav", + "text": "次我們就不用請他們說明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/523.wav", + "text": "我們自己討論就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/524.wav", + "text": "好針對第1條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/525.wav", + "text": "還是有很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/526.wav", + "text": "的歧異但至少有一點共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/527.wav", + "text": "我們還是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/528.wav", + "text": "\n另外行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/529.wav", + "text": "部分因為大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/530.wav", + "text": "好不容易一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/531.wav", + "text": "委員所提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/532.wav", + "text": "的見解說明有無" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/533.wav", + "text": "增刪減的建言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/534.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/535.wav", + "text": "是第2條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/536.wav", + "text": "鄭運鵬委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/537.wav", + "text": "第2條就相對簡單一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/538.wav", + "text": "不管是預算編列規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/539.wav", + "text": "其他部會在執行這個很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/540.wav", + "text": "如果不行的話就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/541.wav", + "text": "就是主管機關的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/542.wav", + "text": "但執行的都是其他機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/543.wav", + "text": "三個在野黨的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/544.wav", + "text": "其實照行政院版本沒有差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/545.wav", + "text": "因為有影響實質內容的其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/546.wav", + "text": "是第1條及第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/547.wav", + "text": "黨團的鄭委員所說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/548.wav", + "text": "的差異不大我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/549.wav", + "text": "行政院也可以考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/550.wav", + "text": "採照國民黨團的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/551.wav", + "text": "因為我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/552.wav", + "text": "第2條是寫主管機關為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/553.wav", + "text": "國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/554.wav", + "text": "且負責預算編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/555.wav", + "text": "之規劃與推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/556.wav", + "text": "其實就已經將所有項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/557.wav", + "text": "都列出因為即便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/558.wav", + "text": "是各部會負責推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/559.wav", + "text": "方案但一定要有主責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/560.wav", + "text": "修正動議中也非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/561.wav", + "text": "寫出主責單位為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/562.wav", + "text": "國家發展委員會我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/563.wav", + "text": "行政院可以考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/564.wav", + "text": "所以應該考量是否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/565.wav", + "text": "能夠接受國民黨團的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/566.wav", + "text": "是在負責強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/567.wav", + "text": "社會韌性及全民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/568.wav", + "text": "如同我剛才在討論第1條時提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/569.wav", + "text": "提到應該將資源集中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/570.wav", + "text": "分配國家資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/571.wav", + "text": "促進公共利益及遵守財政紀律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/572.wav", + "text": "這個部分是重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/573.wav", + "text": "並且只有在將資源集中給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/574.wav", + "text": "脆弱群體這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/575.wav", + "text": "及特別預算才有正當性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/576.wav", + "text": "預算法上的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/577.wav", + "text": "的部分其實主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/578.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/579.wav", + "text": "國民黨版本是更加詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/580.wav", + "text": "地將文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/581.wav", + "text": "說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/582.wav", + "text": "請行政部門國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/583.wav", + "text": "這個差異很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/584.wav", + "text": "我們還是堅持行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/585.wav", + "text": "因為執行推動的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/586.wav", + "text": "還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/587.wav", + "text": "大家再好好想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/588.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/589.wav", + "text": "\n接下來是第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/590.wav", + "text": "很多位委員已經垂詢過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/591.wav", + "text": "例大家最主要的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/592.wav", + "text": "點就在於它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/593.wav", + "text": "到底夠不夠特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/594.wav", + "text": "按照預算法第83條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/595.wav", + "text": "所謂重大政事那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/596.wav", + "text": "有一點點符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/597.wav", + "text": "寫法概念比如從第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/598.wav", + "text": "就不是很凸顯那個精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/599.wav", + "text": "要做這些的特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/600.wav", + "text": "原因為何關於特別的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/601.wav", + "text": "永續講直白一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/602.wav", + "text": "因為這些就是潛藏負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/603.wav", + "text": "多的這些tax" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/604.wav", + "text": "revenue的surplus要用在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/605.wav", + "text": "其實只有兩個方向可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/606.wav", + "text": "全民雖然這些企業賺了錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/607.wav", + "text": "但是他們能夠成功也是因為全民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/608.wav", + "text": "這些錢回饋給大家這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/609.wav", + "text": "部分沒有問題第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/610.wav", + "text": "就是還債啦政府既" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/611.wav", + "text": "不按一般的公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/612.wav", + "text": "編列稅課來還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/613.wav", + "text": "現在多了這個surplus至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/614.wav", + "text": "你要還一還那些潛藏負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/615.wav", + "text": "強調的勞保就要破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/616.wav", + "text": "了我們賴委員剛才也已經強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/617.wav", + "text": "這些事情迫在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/618.wav", + "text": "眉睫\n關於第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/619.wav", + "text": "最精簡的寫法我們民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/620.wav", + "text": "黨團這邊提出再次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/621.wav", + "text": "修正這部分很簡單就是維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/622.wav", + "text": "基金財務永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/623.wav", + "text": "年金跟健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/624.wav", + "text": "事情還有發現金其實就是這些目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/625.wav", + "text": "寫清楚這部分才能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/626.wav", + "text": "這個條例夠特別不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/627.wav", + "text": "都看不出特別在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/628.wav", + "text": "經濟這本來就是政府一直在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/629.wav", + "text": "你就講清楚你的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/630.wav", + "text": "以上是民眾黨再次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/631.wav", + "text": "剛才也特別說明了\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/632.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/633.wav", + "text": "作為主責機關將第3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/634.wav", + "text": "條包裹式地臚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/635.wav", + "text": "9款最後還有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/636.wav", + "text": "跟特別預算宗旨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/637.wav", + "text": "以及未來各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/638.wav", + "text": "在本預算或今年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/639.wav", + "text": "預算的使用調配之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/640.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣子反而讓部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/641.wav", + "text": "在行政執行的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/642.wav", + "text": "雖然有部分的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/643.wav", + "text": "具共通性但關於支用的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/644.wav", + "text": "到底是自己的本預算先用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/645.wav", + "text": "還是將舊有賸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/646.wav", + "text": "透過這次新的特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/647.wav", + "text": "來支用講難聽一點我覺得這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/648.wav", + "text": "讓行政單位有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/649.wav", + "text": "其手的空間這是不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/650.wav", + "text": "不如精簡以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/651.wav", + "text": "也就是剛剛張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/652.wav", + "text": "稅額超徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/653.wav", + "text": "或者是解決特定目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/654.wav", + "text": "的條例\n所以我們還是重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/655.wav", + "text": "希望能把第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/656.wav", + "text": "在具目的性的效能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/657.wav", + "text": "讓社會各界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/658.wav", + "text": "跟國人能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/659.wav", + "text": "特別條例像過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/660.wav", + "text": "不管是前瞻或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/661.wav", + "text": "相關部分這幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/662.wav", + "text": "蔡政府已經用了2.2兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/663.wav", + "text": "來做特別預算這一次還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/664.wav", + "text": "要用這個方式嗎本人期期以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/665.wav", + "text": "不可所以我們希望國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/666.wav", + "text": "推行政務效能的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/667.wav", + "text": "不要以放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/668.wav", + "text": "來進行這次特別條例的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/669.wav", + "text": "協商\n第二個我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/670.wav", + "text": "有兩個方向是國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/671.wav", + "text": "要共同面對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/672.wav", + "text": "除了發放現金就是還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/673.wav", + "text": "重責大任如果落在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/674.wav", + "text": "這一次的特別條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/675.wav", + "text": "能夠把這個方向定位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/676.wav", + "text": "未來不管是哪一個政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/677.wav", + "text": "在2024年執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/678.wav", + "text": "他們要面對10兆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/679.wav", + "text": "勞保虧損潛藏負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/680.wav", + "text": "就有一個延續性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/681.wav", + "text": "可���性因此我們覺得把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/682.wav", + "text": "還債入法同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/683.wav", + "text": "立法延續性是重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/684.wav", + "text": "希望各個政黨都能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/685.wav", + "text": "我們民眾黨的版本以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/686.wav", + "text": "我個人覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/687.wav", + "text": "黨團的原始提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/688.wav", + "text": "是最好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/689.wav", + "text": "剛剛我從頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/690.wav", + "text": "預算法精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/691.wav", + "text": "特別預算常態化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/692.wav", + "text": "這是破壞預算制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/693.wav", + "text": "預算法的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/694.wav", + "text": "蕩然無存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/695.wav", + "text": "行政院提到的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/696.wav", + "text": "這些都是對於全民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/697.wav", + "text": "也是攸關國家經濟發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/698.wav", + "text": "跟全民應有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/699.wav", + "text": "權益基本上我都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/700.wav", + "text": "支持但我還是要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/701.wav", + "text": "強調我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/702.wav", + "text": "劉世芳委員提到的我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/703.wav", + "text": "基金缺口包括保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/704.wav", + "text": "基金勞保基金或者全民健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/705.wav", + "text": "當然還有很多其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/706.wav", + "text": "你們今天把它條列出來9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/707.wav", + "text": "我們都很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/708.wav", + "text": "不代表我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/709.wav", + "text": "應該把它納入這一次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/710.wav", + "text": "預算制度中經常講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/711.wav", + "text": "跟基金預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/712.wav", + "text": "這些屬於年度預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/713.wav", + "text": "關於年度預算的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/714.wav", + "text": "每一個單位機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/715.wav", + "text": "或者行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/716.wav", + "text": "第一預備金第二預備金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/717.wav", + "text": "還有所謂的流入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/718.wav", + "text": "跟流出也就是流用的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/719.wav", + "text": "雖然有一個整體的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/720.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/721.wav", + "text": "它有流用的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/722.wav", + "text": "有第一預備金與第二預備金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/723.wav", + "text": "設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/724.wav", + "text": "在執行的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/725.wav", + "text": "可以有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/726.wav", + "text": "彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/727.wav", + "text": "既然預算已經達到這樣的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/728.wav", + "text": "接下來如果在沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/729.wav", + "text": "調整的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/730.wav", + "text": "才有所謂的追加預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/731.wav", + "text": "事業增加或者依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/732.wav", + "text": "律必須增加機關經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/733.wav", + "text": "才有所謂特別預算的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/734.wav", + "text": "嘛基本上特別預算都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/735.wav", + "text": "都是很嚴謹的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/736.wav", + "text": "當國家遭逢重大災變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/737.wav", + "text": "天災人禍或是戰爭之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/738.wav", + "text": "或是沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/739.wav", + "text": "解決的時候才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/740.wav", + "text": "編特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/741.wav", + "text": "我們絕對不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/742.wav", + "text": "把特別預算常態化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/743.wav", + "text": "變成一般預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/744.wav", + "text": "\n因此我個人不是反對編列這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/745.wav", + "text": "應該照預算法的規定編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/746.wav", + "text": "行政院提出來的這9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/747.wav", + "text": "9款比方說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/748.wav", + "text": "勞保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/749.wav", + "text": "電力公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/750.wav", + "text": "減輕居住負擔及提高居" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/751.wav", + "text": "哪一款不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/752.wav", + "text": "施政計畫中所追求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/753.wav", + "text": "年度預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/754.wav", + "text": "為什麼你今天要把它提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/755.wav", + "text": "編列在特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/756.wav", + "text": "第二個假設屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/757.wav", + "text": "疫後所造成的民生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/758.wav", + "text": "疫後要怎麼去振興產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/759.wav", + "text": "COVID-19特別預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/760.wav", + "text": "追加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/761.wav", + "text": "也不屬於特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/762.wav", + "text": "所以整體看來我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/763.wav", + "text": "再一次論述我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/764.wav", + "text": "還是覺得國民黨當時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/765.wav", + "text": "提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/766.wav", + "text": "是最精準的也是最好的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/767.wav", + "text": "你們人比較多沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/768.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/769.wav", + "text": "歷史會檢驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/770.wav", + "text": "你們就是亂來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/771.wav", + "text": "尤其是主計處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/772.wav", + "text": "這不是他決定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/773.wav", + "text": "他很無奈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/774.wav", + "text": "啦這真的可以編進特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/775.wav", + "text": "都是年度預算應該要編的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/776.wav", + "text": "你幹嘛用特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/777.wav", + "text": "你如果覺得沒尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/778.wav", + "text": "不要提出這個特別預算讓大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/779.wav", + "text": "感謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/780.wav", + "text": "從過年前到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/781.wav", + "text": "這樣辛苦地審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/782.wav", + "text": "這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/783.wav", + "text": "可是頭髮都沒有亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/784.wav", + "text": "還非常漂亮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/785.wav", + "text": "還好頭髮還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/786.wav", + "text": "非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/787.wav", + "text": "其實國民黨團當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/788.wav", + "text": "提出這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/789.wav", + "text": "就是因為經濟成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/790.wav", + "text": "並不是由全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/791.wav", + "text": "而是有些產業好有些產業不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/792.wav", + "text": "但是目前全球都面臨到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/793.wav", + "text": "通膨等因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/794.wav", + "text": "以及目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/795.wav", + "text": "貨幣政策導致利率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/796.wav", + "text": "這個特別條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/797.wav", + "text": "起先只訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/798.wav", + "text": "發放現金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/799.wav", + "text": "但是行政院並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/800.wav", + "text": "按照國民黨團的作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/801.wav", + "text": "也許過年後的現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/802.wav", + "text": "我們就不是在這裡協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/803.wav", + "text": "預算以及如何發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/804.wav", + "text": "動議才會加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/805.wav", + "text": "過去各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/806.wav", + "text": "都相對同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/807.wav", + "text": "挹注全民健保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/808.wav", + "text": "以及勞保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/809.wav", + "text": "還有台電公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/810.wav", + "text": "對於我們的醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/811.wav", + "text": "對於勞工的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/812.wav", + "text": "各黨能共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/813.wav", + "text": "來推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/814.wav", + "text": "加速這個協商的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/815.wav", + "text": "是因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/816.wav", + "text": "沒有從善如流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/817.wav", + "text": "沒有在過年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/818.wav", + "text": "就通過這個發現金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/819.wav", + "text": "條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/820.wav", + "text": "不然我們現在就會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/821.wav", + "text": "關於發現金的特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/822.wav", + "text": "以及發放的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/823.wav", + "text": "我們現在還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/824.wav", + "text": "繼續在這裡協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/825.wav", + "text": "所以我們才希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/826.wav", + "text": "納入這三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/827.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/828.wav", + "text": "希望各黨團都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/829.wav", + "text": "共同來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/830.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/831.wav", + "text": "也是深水區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/832.wav", + "text": "我看起來各黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/833.wav", + "text": "大概對於現金跟全民健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/834.wav", + "text": "勞工保險基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/835.wav", + "text": "跟台電的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/836.wav", + "text": "但是其他包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/837.wav", + "text": "減輕居住負擔照顧弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/838.wav", + "text": "擴大公共運輸的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/839.wav", + "text": "協助中小企業升級轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/840.wav", + "text": "甚至到吸引國際觀光客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/841.wav", + "text": "政黨的版本都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/842.wav", + "text": "因為牽涉到整體預算分配的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/843.wav", + "text": "所以我建議大家發言完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/844.wav", + "text": "我想這一條就保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/845.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/846.wav", + "text": "第一個撥補全民健康保險基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/847.wav", + "text": "勞工保險基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/848.wav", + "text": "跟台灣電力公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/849.wav", + "text": "保險社會安全網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/850.wav", + "text": "跟公共服務機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/851.wav", + "text": "虧損了這是非常不應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/852.wav", + "text": "虧損填補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/853.wav", + "text": "之下要用特別預算來做填補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/854.wav", + "text": "這是非常不應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/855.wav", + "text": "應該是在針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/856.wav", + "text": "要減輕居住負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/857.wav", + "text": "及提高居住品質這個意義不明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/858.wav", + "text": "優先興建社會住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/859.wav", + "text": "以及提高居住品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/860.wav", + "text": "我們的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/861.wav", + "text": "應該是非常清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/862.wav", + "text": "去興建社會住宅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/863.wav", + "text": "也是意義不明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/864.wav", + "text": "應該是要擴大社會福利的給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/865.wav", + "text": "這是第三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/866.wav", + "text": "第四個是提升公共運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/867.wav", + "text": "擴大公共運輸的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/868.wav", + "text": "其實這個已經引起非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/869.wav", + "text": "多的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/870.wav", + "text": "更何況你說要減輕通勤族群的交通負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/871.wav", + "text": "到底是要怎麼減輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/872.wav", + "text": "弱勢跟偏鄉的交通服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/873.wav", + "text": "這是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/874.wav", + "text": "發現金津貼的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/875.wav", + "text": "這性質上是一種津貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/876.wav", + "text": "應該是針對最近一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/877.wav", + "text": "之綜合所得總額合計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/878.wav", + "text": "未達申報標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/879.wav", + "text": "或綜合所得稅率未達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/880.wav", + "text": "20%者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/881.wav", + "text": "發給現金津貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/882.wav", + "text": "也就是發給社會弱勢者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/883.wav", + "text": "第六個其實非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/884.wav", + "text": "或房貸等等各種貸款的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/885.wav", + "text": "導致整個年輕世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/886.wav", + "text": "能夠關注到學貸的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/887.wav", + "text": "\n我想這如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/888.wav", + "text": "如果一一細談的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/889.wav", + "text": "恐怕會花費非常多的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/890.wav", + "text": "撥補也是同樣的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/891.wav", + "text": "政府對於國民的老年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/892.wav", + "text": "照顧應該不分職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/893.wav", + "text": "第3條行政院版所列出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/894.wav", + "text": "這些基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/895.wav", + "text": "為什麼退撫基金看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/896.wav", + "text": "比勞保基金穩健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/897.wav", + "text": "是因為經過了年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/898.wav", + "text": "但是那只是延後破產而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/899.wav", + "text": "甚至因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/900.wav", + "text": "這個退撫新制的實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/901.wav", + "text": "而提前產生了缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/902.wav", + "text": "所以這一次民間團體倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/903.wav", + "text": "撥補退撫基金入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/904.wav", + "text": "跟所有退休年金的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/905.wav", + "text": "原本應該都是一起進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/906.wav", + "text": "但是最後卻因為勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/907.wav", + "text": "所以一直遲延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/908.wav", + "text": "狀況但此次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/909.wav", + "text": "年改的公教人員對這個政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/910.wav", + "text": "也有很大的關係所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/911.wav", + "text": "政府特別是銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/912.wav", + "text": "教育部跟主計總處應該儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/913.wav", + "text": "提出一���完整的分年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/914.wav", + "text": "的撥補計畫並且去評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/915.wav", + "text": "納入特別預算且優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/916.wav", + "text": "支應這其實攸關了國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/917.wav", + "text": "的承諾跟人民的信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/918.wav", + "text": "最後本席必須要強調不管是撥補勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/919.wav", + "text": "基金也好退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/920.wav", + "text": "也好對於國家照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/921.wav", + "text": "基本上只是解燃眉之急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/922.wav", + "text": "的方式之一而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/923.wav", + "text": "所以要怎麼針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/924.wav", + "text": "讓它能夠有穩健的制度改革跟相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/925.wav", + "text": "配套這才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/926.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/927.wav", + "text": "國民黨團有提出修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/928.wav", + "text": "我們本來只有希望發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/929.wav", + "text": "現在增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/930.wav", + "text": "挹注全民健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/931.wav", + "text": "這個金額相對比較小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/932.wav", + "text": "是挹注勞工保險基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/933.wav", + "text": "相關的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/934.wav", + "text": "全民健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/935.wav", + "text": "呢許部長在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/936.wav", + "text": "我每個會期都跟他討教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/937.wav", + "text": "他給我的回應是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/938.wav", + "text": "不知道多久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/939.wav", + "text": "還在創造共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/940.wav", + "text": "但是各位很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/941.wav", + "text": "現在的潛在負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/942.wav", + "text": "超過10兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/943.wav", + "text": "精算是在2028" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/944.wav", + "text": "年破產現在預估可能會更早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/945.wav", + "text": "多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/946.wav", + "text": "杯水車薪沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/947.wav", + "text": "啊但是國民黨還是願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/948.wav", + "text": "會害了這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/949.wav", + "text": "杯水車薪嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/950.wav", + "text": "只是給民進黨一個藉口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/951.wav", + "text": "改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/952.wav", + "text": "國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/953.wav", + "text": "很堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/954.wav", + "text": "1,000億元到1,500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/955.wav", + "text": "元看看你能不能做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/956.wav", + "text": "台電去年跟今年預估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/957.wav", + "text": "元你能撥補它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/958.wav", + "text": "一樣是杯水車薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/959.wav", + "text": "也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/960.wav", + "text": "��涉及全民電費的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/961.wav", + "text": "我們要支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/962.wav", + "text": "基本的解決方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/963.wav", + "text": "杯水車薪沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/964.wav", + "text": "雖然國民黨還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/965.wav", + "text": "願意支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/966.wav", + "text": "但是也建議民進黨趕快把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/967.wav", + "text": "解決方案拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/968.wav", + "text": "許部長每次碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/969.wav", + "text": "我都覺得我們每次都問他這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/970.wav", + "text": "我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/971.wav", + "text": "這個超乎許部長的能力範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/972.wav", + "text": "了但是你不解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/973.wav", + "text": "民進黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/974.wav", + "text": "最後一款是其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/975.wav", + "text": "經行政院核可之強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/976.wav", + "text": "經濟及社會韌性有關事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/977.wav", + "text": "國民黨強烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/978.wav", + "text": "反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/979.wav", + "text": "不可以空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/980.wav", + "text": "不可以空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/981.wav", + "text": "沒關係到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/982.wav", + "text": "院長協商層級時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/983.wav", + "text": "國民黨會強力反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/984.wav", + "text": "強力反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/985.wav", + "text": "你要協助中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/986.wav", + "text": "就要寫進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/987.wav", + "text": "或者要協助哪個產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/988.wav", + "text": "學貸免利息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/989.wav", + "text": "絕對不允許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/990.wav", + "text": "空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/991.wav", + "text": "21日想要強行通過也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/992.wav", + "text": "但是我在這裡奉勸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/993.wav", + "text": "民進黨你會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/994.wav", + "text": "後續的朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/995.wav", + "text": "跟總質詢的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/996.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/997.wav", + "text": "接下來請劉世芳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/998.wav", + "text": "謝謝楊瓊瓔召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/999.wav", + "text": "這麼有耐心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1000.wav", + "text": "聽我們發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1001.wav", + "text": "我想針對剛剛包括民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1002.wav", + "text": "員及曾銘宗召委所提的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1003.wav", + "text": "提出我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1004.wav", + "text": "民眾黨所提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1005.wav", + "text": "跟原本民眾黨所提的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1006.wav", + "text": "原本民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1007.wav", + "text": "所提的部分幾乎就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1008.wav", + "text": "行政院提案裡面的9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1009.wav", + "text": "只不過次序不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1010.wav", + "text": "\n我要回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1011.wav", + "text": "第一個我們今天所要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1012.wav", + "text": "協商的是提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1013.wav", + "text": "疫後的特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1014.wav", + "text": "不是疫後的特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1015.wav", + "text": "條例沒有過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1016.wav", + "text": "預算是不會送到立法院審查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1017.wav", + "text": "其實非常了解預算審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1018.wav", + "text": "程序不管是歲入歲出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1019.wav", + "text": "或是第一預備金第二預備金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1020.wav", + "text": "其實我剛剛有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1021.wav", + "text": "絕對不可能違反原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1022.wav", + "text": "本預算條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1023.wav", + "text": "條文這個絕對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1024.wav", + "text": "今天我們提出這個特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1025.wav", + "text": "是要非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1026.wav", + "text": "地告訴社會大眾是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1027.wav", + "text": "護國神山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1028.wav", + "text": "特別預算時都是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1029.wav", + "text": "而朝野有不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1030.wav", + "text": "這次真的是因為我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1031.wav", + "text": "護國神山或是相關半導體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1032.wav", + "text": "產業比較會賺錢而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1033.wav", + "text": "是在疫情發生期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1034.wav", + "text": "所以希望我們國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1035.wav", + "text": "是朝著社會福利國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1036.wav", + "text": "的方向進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1037.wav", + "text": "\n所謂的社會福利國家就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1038.wav", + "text": "希望能夠照顧弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1039.wav", + "text": "所得比較高的部分可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1040.wav", + "text": "時代力量邱顯智委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1041.wav", + "text": "把教育部門容納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1042.wav", + "text": "進來但是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1043.wav", + "text": "行政院所提的提案條文中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1044.wav", + "text": "照顧弱勢族群及提供關懷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1045.wav", + "text": "可以取消大學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1046.wav", + "text": "畢業就是負債這樣還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1047.wav", + "text": "再來討論的話我個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1048.wav", + "text": "認為並無不妥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1049.wav", + "text": "也可以放在第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1050.wav", + "text": "款經過行政院核可之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1051.wav", + "text": "強化經濟跟社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1052.wav", + "text": "有��事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1053.wav", + "text": "\n不管是哪一個黨團我們都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1054.wav", + "text": "不希望有所謂的空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1055.wav", + "text": "但是如果可以說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1056.wav", + "text": "講明白未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1057.wav", + "text": "在特別條例通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1058.wav", + "text": "特別預算的編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1059.wav", + "text": "只要有比較好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1060.wav", + "text": "希望我們能夠編列進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1061.wav", + "text": "的部分在討論期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1062.wav", + "text": "放進去我覺得這是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1063.wav", + "text": "但是我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1064.wav", + "text": "行政院所提的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1065.wav", + "text": "應該已經可以涵蓋我剛剛所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1066.wav", + "text": "臺灣朝著一個社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1067.wav", + "text": "福利國家的方向前進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1068.wav", + "text": "而不是將其模糊化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1069.wav", + "text": "像民眾黨團變成是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1070.wav", + "text": "模糊化的概念比如他有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1071.wav", + "text": "要撥補公共年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1072.wav", + "text": "我剛才在問翁重鈞委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1073.wav", + "text": "公共年金的概念到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1074.wav", + "text": "因為我不是那麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1075.wav", + "text": "所以我希望可以維持原來行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1076.wav", + "text": "第3條的條文謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1077.wav", + "text": "各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1078.wav", + "text": "我們也請行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1079.wav", + "text": "讓全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1080.wav", + "text": "對於提出的寶貴意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1081.wav", + "text": "也請行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1082.wav", + "text": "好好再思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1083.wav", + "text": "還是先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1084.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處理第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1085.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1086.wav", + "text": "關於第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1087.wav", + "text": "版本的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1088.wav", + "text": "是普發現金之發放相關業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1089.wav", + "text": "得不適用政府採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1090.wav", + "text": "招標決標之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1091.wav", + "text": "其實政府採購法第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1092.wav", + "text": "105條就有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1093.wav", + "text": "不適用招標決標之事由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1094.wav", + "text": "相關施政如果符合即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1095.wav", + "text": "可不適用招標決標之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1096.wav", + "text": "所以無須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1097.wav", + "text": "另予規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1098.wav", + "text": "如果要堅持則要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1099.wav", + "text": "原因我覺得這很奇怪為什麼你會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1100.wav", + "text": "放一個條文在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1101.wav", + "text": "\n更重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1102.wav", + "text": "不論預算財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1103.wav", + "text": "支用目的為何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1104.wav", + "text": "不論是通常預算還是特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1105.wav", + "text": "一旦相關業務需要透過採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1106.wav", + "text": "政府本來就有義務確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1107.wav", + "text": "採購有品質有效率及採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1108.wav", + "text": "過程的廉政性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1109.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為政府採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1110.wav", + "text": "因此我基本上不認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1111.wav", + "text": "能夠預先一律排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1112.wav", + "text": "採購法招標決標相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1113.wav", + "text": "適用於本法編列的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1114.wav", + "text": "預算進行採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1115.wav", + "text": "而且這筆錢這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1116.wav", + "text": "還是應該要排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1117.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛劉世芳委員有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1118.wav", + "text": "他也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1119.wav", + "text": "對青年世代最好的投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1120.wav", + "text": "所以我們有足夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1121.wav", + "text": "財力與資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1122.wav", + "text": "那麼是否要透過政府補償銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1123.wav", + "text": "等等讓銀行免除學生的學貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1124.wav", + "text": "讓下一代在沒有額外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1125.wav", + "text": "負擔的情況下擁有更好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1126.wav", + "text": "發展這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1127.wav", + "text": "事實上真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1128.wav", + "text": "要嚴肅地思考應該去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1129.wav", + "text": "剛剛劉世芳委員有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1130.wav", + "text": "這個在第9款也有涵蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1131.wav", + "text": "但是問題來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1132.wav", + "text": "第3條第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1133.wav", + "text": "基本上就是非常概括的條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1134.wav", + "text": "經行政院核可之強化經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1135.wav", + "text": "與社會韌性有關事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1136.wav", + "text": "天啊到底這是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1137.wav", + "text": "也沒有辦法講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1138.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1139.wav", + "text": "要能夠具體地將其明示出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1140.wav", + "text": "大概是後端執行跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1141.wav", + "text": "一般比較原則性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1142.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1143.wav", + "text": "因為前面第1條與第3條也沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1144.wav", + "text": "比較沒有那麼複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1145.wav", + "text": "但是如果有細節的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1146.wav", + "text": "我想我們不需要差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1147.wav", + "text": "三分之一的部會首長都在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1148.wav", + "text": "各黨團之後如果可以有共識就我們自己來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1149.wav", + "text": "就儘量將其保留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1150.wav", + "text": "細節我們再慢慢推敲文字好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1151.wav", + "text": "不可能空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1152.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望藉由多方討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1153.wav", + "text": "如何認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1154.wav", + "text": "我想這是全民必須要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1155.wav", + "text": "\n我特別在此說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1156.wav", + "text": "今天會運用這麼寶貴的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1157.wav", + "text": "目的就是讓雙方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1158.wav", + "text": "提出寶貴的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1159.wav", + "text": "也請行政部門用心聆聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1160.wav", + "text": "不是讓部會首長在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1161.wav", + "text": "而已因為這個是全民共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1162.wav", + "text": "在看的一個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1163.wav", + "text": "首先政院版第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1164.wav", + "text": "第1項規定預算編製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1165.wav", + "text": "不受預算法第23條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1166.wav", + "text": "規定之限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1167.wav", + "text": "即政府經常收支應保持平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1168.wav", + "text": "非因預算年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1169.wav", + "text": "有異常情形資本收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1170.wav", + "text": "公債與賖借收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1171.wav", + "text": "及以前年度歲計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1172.wav", + "text": "用第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1173.wav", + "text": "所需經費來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1174.wav", + "text": "不受公共債務法第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1175.wav", + "text": "第7項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1176.wav", + "text": "這次特別預算的支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1177.wav", + "text": "到底會舉用多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1178.wav", + "text": "債務來支應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1179.wav", + "text": "因為很顯然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1180.wav", + "text": "的第1項跟第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1181.wav", + "text": "及預算法第23條的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1182.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1183.wav", + "text": "講明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1184.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1185.wav", + "text": "的舉債的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1186.wav", + "text": "但未來的日子卻是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1187.wav", + "text": "舉債累累" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1188.wav", + "text": "這個部分應該要能夠清楚��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1189.wav", + "text": "提到我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1190.wav", + "text": "有一個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1191.wav", + "text": "我想我們也是蒐集各方意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1192.wav", + "text": "特別是近期大家都看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1193.wav", + "text": "不管是勞健保虧損議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1194.wav", + "text": "跟未來調整部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1195.wav", + "text": "都一再引起國人的重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1196.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得我們修正的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1197.wav", + "text": "並沒有任何的扞格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1198.wav", + "text": "也謝謝劉世芳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1199.wav", + "text": "他同時也指教我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1200.wav", + "text": "談到的公共年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1201.wav", + "text": "我想今天在座很多雖然是行政官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1202.wav", + "text": "但跟學界的相關性也是很高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1203.wav", + "text": "其實公共年金的出處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1204.wav", + "text": "已經很明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1205.wav", + "text": "由國家舉辦照顧老人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1206.wav", + "text": "安養保障的各種基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1207.wav", + "text": "國民年金及公教退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1208.wav", + "text": "等都是公共年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1209.wav", + "text": "所以這個並沒有法律上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1210.wav", + "text": "文意不清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1211.wav", + "text": "第三個我倒是要指教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1212.wav", + "text": "我查遍所有的法律條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1213.wav", + "text": "根本沒有看過普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1214.wav", + "text": "這四個字到底概念上是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1215.wav", + "text": "因此我們做了一個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1216.wav", + "text": "叫做發放現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1217.wav", + "text": "基本上我們是從證券相關的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1218.wav", + "text": "去援引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1219.wav", + "text": "文字錙銖必較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1220.wav", + "text": "除了倉促之外用語的不精準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1221.wav", + "text": "以及他們在界定問題上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1222.wav", + "text": "猶有模糊空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1223.wav", + "text": "應該會讓大家對於特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1224.wav", + "text": "有所擔心甚至會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1225.wav", + "text": "不應該擴張到第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1226.wav", + "text": "的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1227.wav", + "text": "我想我們都是善意提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1228.wav", + "text": "也希望能夠精進集中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1229.wav", + "text": "\n回到第5條部分民眾黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1230.wav", + "text": "條文很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1231.wav", + "text": "現金現在大概是你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1232.wav", + "text": "1,800億和1,500億左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1233.wav", + "text": "的規格之外我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1234.wav", + "text": "3,800億一次性編足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1235.wav", + "text": "之中能夠對勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1236.wav", + "text": "相關挹注不得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1237.wav", + "text": "低於1,000億我們是明確地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1238.wav", + "text": "入法同時挹注健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1239.wav", + "text": "部分是不得低於500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1240.wav", + "text": "所以加起來是1,500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1241.wav", + "text": "1,500億再加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1242.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的發放現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1243.wav", + "text": "1,500億大概加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1244.wav", + "text": "至於剩下的部分我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1245.wav", + "text": "覺得其他像公共年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1246.wav", + "text": "部分及剛剛提到公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1247.wav", + "text": "退撫基金也有2.5兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1248.wav", + "text": "同時國民年金未來也有一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1249.wav", + "text": "請國發會能夠在這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1250.wav", + "text": "綜理的時候一併考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1251.wav", + "text": "國家公共年金的永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1252.wav", + "text": "方案以這一次為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1253.wav", + "text": "要求各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1254.wav", + "text": "包括勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1255.wav", + "text": "能夠真的提出相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1256.wav", + "text": "草案儘速送到行政院\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1257.wav", + "text": "\n我們期待這次的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1258.wav", + "text": "能夠達成催促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1259.wav", + "text": "畢竟超徵稅額的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1260.wav", + "text": "如果沒有必要性通常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1261.wav", + "text": "政府就移用到下個年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1262.wav", + "text": "移用來移用去累積之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1263.wav", + "text": "可能在一個時間內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1264.wav", + "text": "又提出一個特別條例來作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1265.wav", + "text": "百年遇到的疫情會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1266.wav", + "text": "有一個來臨的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1267.wav", + "text": "所以我認為全民的健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1268.wav", + "text": "與健康為目的的勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1269.wav", + "text": "跟健保的考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1270.wav", + "text": "能夠在這次裡面成為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1271.wav", + "text": "大家的共識以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1272.wav", + "text": "第5條其實是比較針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1273.wav", + "text": "會牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1274.wav", + "text": "跟第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1275.wav", + "text": "即我們設定這個條例的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1276.wav", + "text": "目標及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1277.wav", + "text": "適用與支用的範疇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1278.wav", + "text": "所以如果前面的條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1279.wav", + "text": "保留沒有共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1280.wav", + "text": "直接保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1281.wav", + "text": "因為不太可能前面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1282.wav", + "text": "沒有共識但反而在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1283.wav", + "text": "甚至相關支用的額度上限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1284.wav", + "text": "有共識我覺得這非常困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1285.wav", + "text": "所以我建議在這個邏輯下就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1286.wav", + "text": "行政部門也有聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1287.wav", + "text": "各方的意見不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1288.wav", + "text": "直接將3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1289.wav", + "text": "一次編足或者分期編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1290.wav", + "text": "抑或是其中最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1291.wav", + "text": "如果尚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1292.wav", + "text": "有以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1293.wav", + "text": "年度歲計賸餘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1294.wav", + "text": "可供移用時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1295.wav", + "text": "但是在最後一項行政院版裡提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1296.wav", + "text": "不受公共債務法第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1297.wav", + "text": "第7項規定之限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1298.wav", + "text": "這部分仍舊還是有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1299.wav", + "text": "在充分討論後我們還是做保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1300.wav", + "text": "為主管機關單位應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1301.wav", + "text": "應專案列管及考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1302.wav", + "text": "所以第6條就直接做保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1303.wav", + "text": "關於時間部分當然我們到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1304.wav", + "text": "不要再去延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1305.wav", + "text": "說實在的這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1306.wav", + "text": "的正當性都有一點存疑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1307.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望不要再去延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1308.wav", + "text": "邱顯智委員的發言我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1309.wav", + "text": "列入紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1310.wav", + "text": "各位同仁我們運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1311.wav", + "text": "將近一個半鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1312.wav", + "text": "的時間我非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1313.wav", + "text": "各政黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1314.wav", + "text": "大家都真的非常用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1315.wav", + "text": "各政黨探求民瘼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1316.wav", + "text": "所提出的寶貴意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1317.wav", + "text": "我們希望透過這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1318.wav", + "text": "可以聽到各方的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1319.wav", + "text": "在文字方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1320.wav", + "text": "可以再做怎麼樣的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1321.wav", + "text": "我們希望大家繼續用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1322.wav", + "text": "報告法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1323.wav", + "text": "保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1324.wav", + "text": "附帶決議及新增的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1325.wav", + "text": "修正動議我們將請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1326.wav", + "text": "游院長召集黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14785/1327.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/0.wav", + "text": "現在有人主張2月14日開議另外還有17日21日都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1.wav", + "text": "從第2屆到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/2.wav", + "text": "報到至於什麼時候開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/3.wav", + "text": "呢游院長那時候是2月26日開議謝長廷的時候是2月25日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/4.wav", + "text": "沒有一個人超過2月因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/5.wav", + "text": "憲法規定行政院必須對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/6.wav", + "text": "立法院在2月底以前一定要開始總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/7.wav", + "text": "這是第一個要件也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/8.wav", + "text": "底限是在2月底以前要開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/9.wav", + "text": "至於什麼時候開始呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/10.wav", + "text": "我們延會兩次等於是延會再延會開到1月19" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/11.wav", + "text": "即便臨時會也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/12.wav", + "text": "這是第一個先決條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/13.wav", + "text": "大家都知道特別條例要趕快通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/14.wav", + "text": "然後特別預算才能審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/15.wav", + "text": "我是不是可以提出如下建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/16.wav", + "text": "如果17日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/17.wav", + "text": "的話已經算是歷屆以來最早開議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/18.wav", + "text": "如果要實際開議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/19.wav", + "text": "那麼下禮拜可能要請楊瓊瓔召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/20.wav", + "text": "在委員會先行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/21.wav", + "text": "為實際上是下禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/22.wav", + "text": "所以下禮拜請楊瓊瓔委員先行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/23.wav", + "text": "禮拜四或禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/24.wav", + "text": "二)總質詢就開始了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/25.wav", + "text": "星期四)的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/26.wav", + "text": "有行政院院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/27.wav", + "text": "總統公告生效以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/28.wav", + "text": "2月底就放假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/29.wav", + "text": "了所以可能在3月3日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/30.wav", + "text": ")行政院長必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/31.wav", + "text": "針對特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/32.wav", + "text": "當然這中間總質詢已經開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/33.wav", + "text": "問完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/34.wav", + "text": "3月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/35.wav", + "text": "那一週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/36.wav", + "text": "財政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/37.wav", + "text": "所以從這樣的落點看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/38.wav", + "text": "委員會完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/39.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/40.wav", + "text": "大概是3月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/41.wav", + "text": "財政委員會召委要排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/42.wav", + "text": "會即便3次的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/43.wav", + "text": "3月9日就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/44.wav", + "text": "所以大概4月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/45.wav", + "text": "11日(星期二)就可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/46.wav", + "text": "表決預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/47.wav", + "text": "提案分下去可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/48.wav", + "text": "因為中間有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/49.wav", + "text": "乃至於14日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/50.wav", + "text": "相關的時間都差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/51.wav", + "text": "當然我相信大家應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/52.wav", + "text": "會比較贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/53.wav", + "text": "先來處理條例再來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/54.wav", + "text": "因為要付委審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/55.wav", + "text": "接下來的那個禮拜可能召委都要選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/56.wav", + "text": "出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/57.wav", + "text": "了各委員會的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/58.wav", + "text": "預算下來沒有委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/59.wav", + "text": "審查怎麼可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/60.wav", + "text": "這樣的安排應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/61.wav", + "text": "各方考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/62.wav", + "text": "拜託各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/63.wav", + "text": "是不是可以往這方面來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/64.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/65.wav", + "text": "提案黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/66.wav", + "text": "各位黨團總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/67.wav", + "text": "各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/68.wav", + "text": "新年快樂時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/69.wav", + "text": "發文給院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/70.wav", + "text": "能夠在14日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/71.wav", + "text": "14日原因是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/72.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/73.wav", + "text": "第一項第三款及第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/74.wav", + "text": "項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/75.wav", + "text": "事實發生就是新任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/76.wav", + "text": "的行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/77.wav", + "text": "就職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/78.wav", + "text": "院長就職是新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/79.wav", + "text": "後的兩週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/80.wav", + "text": "向立法院提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/81.wav", + "text": "施政方針報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/82.wav", + "text": "並備質詢有這樣的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/83.wav", + "text": "之後隔天2月1日其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/84.wav", + "text": "會期的開始所以我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/85.wav", + "text": "14日的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/86.wav", + "text": "能夠按照立法院職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/87.wav", + "text": "行使法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/88.wav", + "text": "進行施政方針的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/89.wav", + "text": "由楊瓊瓔委員先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/90.wav", + "text": "召開委員會的協商等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/91.wav", + "text": "因為這是法律規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/92.wav", + "text": "所以不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/93.wav", + "text": "應該在2月14日的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/94.wav", + "text": "開議並且在當天讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/95.wav", + "text": "新的閣揆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/96.wav", + "text": "依照立法院職權行使法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/97.wav", + "text": "向立法院提出施政方針報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/98.wav", + "text": "議事處有一些回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/99.wav", + "text": "民國91年2月1日行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/100.wav", + "text": "院長張俊雄辭職由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/101.wav", + "text": "游院長接任行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/102.wav", + "text": "的時候是在2月26日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/103.wav", + "text": "施政方針報告95" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/104.wav", + "text": "院長總辭蘇貞昌院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/105.wav", + "text": "2月21日向立法院進行施政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/106.wav", + "text": "101年2月6日吳敦義辭職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/107.wav", + "text": "由陳接任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/108.wav", + "text": "在2月24日向立法院進行施政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/109.wav", + "text": "報告等等它要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/110.wav", + "text": "的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/111.wav", + "text": "沒有遵守這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/112.wav", + "text": "用這個慣例去蓋過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/113.wav", + "text": "非常清楚的法律明文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/114.wav", + "text": "規定這其實對憲政秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/115.wav", + "text": "也會造成不良的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/116.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/117.wav", + "text": "在2月14日的時候開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/118.wav", + "text": "並且讓新的院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/119.wav", + "text": "趕快按照法律的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/120.wav", + "text": "的報告這應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/121.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長還有各黨代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/122.wav", + "text": "我想民眾黨團的態度非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/123.wav", + "text": "我們希望在2月14日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/124.wav", + "text": "開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/125.wav", + "text": "當然剛才柯總召有講因為有過去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/126.wav", + "text": "道立法院職權行使法第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/127.wav", + "text": "的規定新任行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/128.wav", + "text": "應於就職後兩週內向立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/129.wav", + "text": "提出施政方針之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/130.wav", + "text": "不管是全民共享條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/131.wav", + "text": "後面的預算編列還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/132.wav", + "text": "非常多包含年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/133.wav", + "text": "社會治安甚至現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/134.wav", + "text": "的美中臺關係其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/135.wav", + "text": "這也是今天黨團協商的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/136.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望還是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/137.wav", + "text": "2月14日來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/138.wav", + "text": "全民共享經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/139.wav", + "text": "規劃其實也是在前任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/140.wav", + "text": "陳建仁院長上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/141.wav", + "text": "在相關的態度和議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/142.wav", + "text": "上我們希望還是由新任閣揆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/143.wav", + "text": "到立法院來做備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/144.wav", + "text": "在他到職後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/145.wav", + "text": "兩週所以14日是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/146.wav", + "text": "相對來講比較適切的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/147.wav", + "text": "陳建仁院長也擔任年改小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/148.wav", + "text": "我們也主張希望針對這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/149.wav", + "text": "後續是不是可以來安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/150.wav", + "text": "相關的專案報告即針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/151.wav", + "text": "勞保年金和健保的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/152.wav", + "text": "為什麼\n因為這次在全民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/153.wav", + "text": "共享條例裡面包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/154.wav", + "text": "撥補台電的500億和勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/155.wav", + "text": "健保分別為勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/156.wav", + "text": "300億健保200億相對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/157.wav", + "text": "來講在比例上是有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/158.wav", + "text": "這部分我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/159.wav", + "text": "主張讓陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/160.wav", + "text": "內閣團隊儘速來到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/161.wav", + "text": "進行相關備詢報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/162.wav", + "text": "以上是我們的主張謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/163.wav", + "text": "謝謝請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/164.wav", + "text": "我先請教問題剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/165.wav", + "text": "邱顯智委員和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/166.wav", + "text": "邱臣遠委員他們兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/167.wav", + "text": "都提到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/168.wav", + "text": "職權行使法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/169.wav", + "text": "上的運作或是怎樣是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/170.wav", + "text": "可以先說明一下誰要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/171.wav", + "text": "因為這涉及到法律的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/172.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/173.wav", + "text": "剛才黨鞭提到第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/174.wav", + "text": "第三款規定新任行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/175.wav", + "text": "在我們實際的議事例比方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/176.wav", + "text": "像前任閣揆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/177.wav", + "text": "蘇貞昌也是在休會期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/178.wav", + "text": "就任行政院長那時候本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/179.wav", + "text": "院實際的例子是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/180.wav", + "text": "2月15日才請他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/181.wav", + "text": "來做報告也是超過兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/182.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/183.wav", + "text": "它有一二三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/184.wav", + "text": "當然有關立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/185.wav", + "text": "的蘇院長是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/186.wav", + "text": "就任照理兩週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/187.wav", + "text": "就要來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/188.wav", + "text": "在2月而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/189.wav", + "text": "而賴清德新任行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/190.wav", + "text": "是106年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/191.wav", + "text": "他是新任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/192.wav", + "text": "他什麼時候來9月底9月27日來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/193.wav", + "text": "來我剛才談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/194.wav", + "text": "24日都沒有兩週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/195.wav", + "text": "乃至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/196.wav", + "text": "游院長坐在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/197.wav", + "text": "他是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/198.wav", + "text": "當然職權行使法有不同的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/199.wav", + "text": "我們並不是那麼死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/200.wav", + "text": "現在就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/201.wav", + "text": "整個程序上的安排大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/202.wav", + "text": "覺得假如17日已經算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/203.wav", + "text": "提早這樣可以的話過去也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/204.wav", + "text": "去也有案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/205.wav", + "text": "而且每一個案例都是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/206.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/207.wav", + "text": "既然過去剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/208.wav", + "text": "柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/209.wav", + "text": "有這麼多案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/210.wav", + "text": "基於這些案例國民黨的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/211.wav", + "text": "有幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/212.wav", + "text": "第一點就是因為上會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/213.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/214.wav", + "text": "第二點第十屆到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/215.wav", + "text": "的日期分別是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/216.wav", + "text": "1日之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/217.wav", + "text": "國民黨也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/218.wav", + "text": "為了回應全民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/219.wav", + "text": "能夠趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/220.wav", + "text": "發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/221.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/222.wav", + "text": "也建議可以提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/223.wav", + "text": "議當天就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/224.wav", + "text": "討論特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/225.wav", + "text": "到時候民進黨一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/226.wav", + "text": "會強行通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/227.wav", + "text": "全力支持沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/228.wav", + "text": "是3,800億裡面還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/229.wav", + "text": "1,400億怎麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/230.wav", + "text": "是空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/231.wav", + "text": "的部分我希望院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/232.wav", + "text": "協商的時候要請行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/233.wav", + "text": "要協助中小企業我們支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/234.wav", + "text": "要協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/235.wav", + "text": "弱勢我們也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/236.wav", + "text": "我相信對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/237.wav", + "text": "整個條例的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/238.wav", + "text": "會更順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/239.wav", + "text": "尤其很快就要進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/240.wav", + "text": "新院長的總質詢我們不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/241.wav", + "text": "在這個過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/242.wav", + "text": "引發朝野的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/243.wav", + "text": "在協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/244.wav", + "text": "特別條例的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/245.wav", + "text": "是能夠達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/246.wav", + "text": "走過程到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/247.wav", + "text": "又強行表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/248.wav", + "text": "但是就這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/249.wav", + "text": "我們是贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/250.wav", + "text": "2月17日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/251.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/252.wav", + "text": "各黨團黨鞭同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/253.wav", + "text": "我們民眾黨當然是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/254.wav", + "text": "各黨團今天協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/255.wav", + "text": "結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/256.wav", + "text": "最重要的是要先協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/257.wav", + "text": "疫後特別條例這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/258.wav", + "text": "我們也必須直說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/259.wav", + "text": "編列這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/260.wav", + "text": "或是主要條文的是蘇院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/261.wav", + "text": "陳揆也有自己的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/262.wav", + "text": "希望儘速把這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/263.wav", + "text": "錢發下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/264.wav", + "text": "裡面包山包海這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/265.wav", + "text": "統包夾帶的方式確實是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/266.wav", + "text": "如果這一塊能夠先避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/267.wav", + "text": "不用談那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/268.wav", + "text": "這件事為主的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/269.wav", + "text": "而且坦白說陳院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/270.wav", + "text": "接收之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/271.wav", + "text": "蘇內閣的主張因為蘇內閣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/272.wav", + "text": "所以在概念上已經有了新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/273.wav", + "text": "終目標現在在程序上當然我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/274.wav", + "text": "也可��彈性地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/275.wav", + "text": "中能夠儘速同時也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/276.wav", + "text": "符合陳院長講的要趕快把錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/277.wav", + "text": "上在日程上我們是可以保持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/278.wav", + "text": "一些彈性以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/279.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/280.wav", + "text": "我覺得議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/281.wav", + "text": "基本上是沒有對到題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/282.wav", + "text": "你的回答是過去的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/283.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/284.wav", + "text": "現在的問題是立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/285.wav", + "text": "是不是規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/286.wav", + "text": "應該在就職後兩週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/287.wav", + "text": "向立法院提出施政方針報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/288.wav", + "text": "這是第十六條第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/289.wav", + "text": "的問題是法律或憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/290.wav", + "text": "本來就是在綁住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/291.wav", + "text": "不遵守相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/292.wav", + "text": "所以預先地把憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/293.wav", + "text": "把這些國家重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/294.wav", + "text": "權力機關的運作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/295.wav", + "text": "訂定下來這是法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/296.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/297.wav", + "text": "訂的而且條文中第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/298.wav", + "text": "非常清楚寫明是應那是應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/299.wav", + "text": "不是可以權宜作變動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/300.wav", + "text": "在規範面上是非常清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/301.wav", + "text": "預先就寫好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/302.wav", + "text": "院長在就職之後必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/303.wav", + "text": "到立法院說明他到底要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/304.wav", + "text": "是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/305.wav", + "text": "綁住有權力的人我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/306.wav", + "text": "很基本的過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/307.wav", + "text": "沒有遵守法律的規定那是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/308.wav", + "text": "有權力的人不願意受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/309.wav", + "text": "這個規範所拘束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/310.wav", + "text": "作出這樣的決定因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/311.wav", + "text": "開議的決定然後他不遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/312.wav", + "text": "自己所訂的立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/313.wav", + "text": "有規範就按照規範來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/314.wav", + "text": "除非我們不清楚這個規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/315.wav", + "text": "如果規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/316.wav", + "text": "是他應該在兩週內來報告這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/317.wav", + "text": "大家都清楚的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/318.wav", + "text": "我們應該按照這個規範來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/319.wav", + "text": "行政院院���就職當然另當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/320.wav", + "text": "有空間讓各黨可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/321.wav", + "text": "現在這麼清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/322.wav", + "text": "他在兩週內來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/323.wav", + "text": "我們做一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/324.wav", + "text": "所訂定的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/325.wav", + "text": "狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/326.wav", + "text": "我講一下好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/327.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/328.wav", + "text": "現在邱顯智委員所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/329.wav", + "text": "有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/330.wav", + "text": "的問題這主要有三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/331.wav", + "text": "在什麼時候修的1999" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/332.wav", + "text": "年1月12日三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/333.wav", + "text": "(阿扁執政以前)即國民黨執政時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/334.wav", + "text": "最後通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/335.wav", + "text": "的當年我也參加整個國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/336.wav", + "text": "五法的修正立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/337.wav", + "text": "院職權行使法是有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/338.wav", + "text": "以後即1999" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/339.wav", + "text": "年以後到現在目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/340.wav", + "text": "這麼多案例為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/341.wav", + "text": "都沒有都按照兩週內呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/342.wav", + "text": "合議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/343.wav", + "text": "甚至經過表決的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/344.wav", + "text": "只要不違憲都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/345.wav", + "text": "\n我為什麼要引用這個呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/346.wav", + "text": "因為過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/347.wav", + "text": "曾參與過職權行使法的修正我知道嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/348.wav", + "text": "也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/349.wav", + "text": "都是有經過表決議決的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/350.wav", + "text": "所以這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/351.wav", + "text": "最主要是憲法增修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/352.wav", + "text": "增修條文第3條規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/353.wav", + "text": "行政院要對立法院負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/354.wav", + "text": "這是不是大家違法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/355.wav", + "text": "這是經過大家討論過或議決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/356.wav", + "text": "大法官釋字做這樣的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/357.wav", + "text": "包括游院長也是2月26日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/358.wav", + "text": "日這個問題當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/359.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有發現大家都知道嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/360.wav", + "text": "我覺得今天我們又不是基於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/361.wav", + "text": "立法院裡面只要不違憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/362.wav", + "text": "任何大家談好的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/363.wav", + "text": "與法規條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/364.wav", + "text": "有差異的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/365.wav", + "text": "都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/366.wav", + "text": "就是從1993年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/367.wav", + "text": "因為沒有經過表決這個法案卻通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/368.wav", + "text": "解釋出來是這樣的緣由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/369.wav", + "text": "大法官釋字也處理了很多事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/370.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/371.wav", + "text": "這個應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/372.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/373.wav", + "text": "當然它給大家一個國會自治的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/374.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/375.wav", + "text": "這是立法形成的空間可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/376.wav", + "text": "可是這是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/377.wav", + "text": "的除非我們認為立法院職權行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/378.wav", + "text": "是沒有辦法拘束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/379.wav", + "text": "國會議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/380.wav", + "text": "看起來不是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/381.wav", + "text": "因為我們每次有什麼問題都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/382.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/383.wav", + "text": "白紙黑字地定在那邊了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/384.wav", + "text": "它是法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/385.wav", + "text": "因為它叫立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/386.wav", + "text": "法律條例通則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/387.wav", + "text": "這4種如果把它寫成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/388.wav", + "text": "法律條例通則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/389.wav", + "text": "的話它就是法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/390.wav", + "text": "立法機關所通過的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/391.wav", + "text": "拘束的效力除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/392.wav", + "text": "除非我們認為它是沒效的而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/393.wav", + "text": "而立法院職權行使法拘束的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/394.wav", + "text": "是誰就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/395.wav", + "text": "因為它是寫應不是寫得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/396.wav", + "text": "遵守這樣的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/397.wav", + "text": "而且我們應該要做示範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/398.wav", + "text": "就是國家通過的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/399.wav", + "text": "確實有被遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/400.wav", + "text": "過去沒有遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/401.wav", + "text": "但是那個慣例基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/402.wav", + "text": "也不會讓法律達到破棄之效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/403.wav", + "text": "這個是非常清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/404.wav", + "text": "我們認為這些慣例比較對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/405.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛柯總召講說過去都沒有遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/406.wav", + "text": "但是我也是真的很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/407.wav", + "text": "為什麼過去都沒有遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/408.wav", + "text": "這樣的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/409.wav", + "text": "是因為大家不願意受到這個拘束嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/410.wav", + "text": "總之現在在實然跟應然���之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/411.wav", + "text": "產生落差了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/412.wav", + "text": "政治運作的狀況產生落差的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/413.wav", + "text": "如果我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/414.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/415.wav", + "text": "那也要透過修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/416.wav", + "text": "去解決嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/417.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/418.wav", + "text": "我覺得就跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/419.wav", + "text": "你遵守道交條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/420.wav", + "text": "不應該闖紅燈一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/421.wav", + "text": "本來就應該要遵守嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/422.wav", + "text": "主席還有幾位總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/423.wav", + "text": "我沒有特別要著墨第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/424.wav", + "text": "但是我想就教剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/425.wav", + "text": "柯總召談到的幾個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/426.wav", + "text": "共享條例的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/427.wav", + "text": "那是基於14日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/428.wav", + "text": "可能能夠進行委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/429.wav", + "text": "您剛剛好像是這樣子建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/430.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/431.wav", + "text": "下禮拜就是4個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/432.wav", + "text": "的聯席會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/433.wav", + "text": "進行審議然後17" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/434.wav", + "text": "日就一定進入表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/435.wav", + "text": "表決之後在21日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/436.wav", + "text": "才進行總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/437.wav", + "text": "我記得之前有講到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/438.wav", + "text": "條例還有包括這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/439.wav", + "text": "剛剛顯智在講第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/440.wav", + "text": "我也同意但是現在是不是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/441.wav", + "text": "更務實地來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/442.wav", + "text": "就是現在剩下下禮拜了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/443.wav", + "text": "今天已經禮拜五了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/444.wav", + "text": "如何進行4個委員會的聯席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/445.wav", + "text": "版本包括附帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/446.wav", + "text": "決議或是當時提的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/447.wav", + "text": "動議其實還很多怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/448.wav", + "text": "協議跟態度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/449.wav", + "text": "延續過去蘇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/450.wav", + "text": "院長的團隊所以我們很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/451.wav", + "text": "如果一開始進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/452.wav", + "text": "就是大家開誠布公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/453.wav", + "text": "就事論事在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/454.wav", + "text": "超收預算的配置以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/455.wav", + "text": "相關七個條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/456.wav", + "text": "可以尊重在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/457.wav", + "text": "或是勞健保財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/458.wav", + "text": "這樣的共識先行才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/459.wav", + "text": "17日的表決順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/460.wav", + "text": "第一個這麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/461.wav", + "text": "的共享條例都能夠達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/462.wav", + "text": "朝野和諧完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/463.wav", + "text": "讓國人看到嶄新的國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/464.wav", + "text": "跟嶄新的行政團隊我覺得是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/465.wav", + "text": "剛剛顯智說的我也有聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/466.wav", + "text": "但是是不是更務實來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/467.wav", + "text": "到底是14日開始4委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/468.wav", + "text": "聯席還是下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/469.wav", + "text": "的一三四叫做委員會就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/470.wav", + "text": "進行這個還是請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/471.wav", + "text": "討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/472.wav", + "text": "我針對剛才以上幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/473.wav", + "text": "委員的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/474.wav", + "text": "因為賴香伶委員所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/475.wav", + "text": "下禮拜4個委員會聯席並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/476.wav", + "text": "這個意思也就是說法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/477.wav", + "text": "在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/478.wav", + "text": "大家都知道出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/479.wav", + "text": "出委員會要不要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/480.wav", + "text": "要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/481.wav", + "text": "的話會經過一個程序那個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/482.wav", + "text": "職權行使法查不到的也沒有法定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/483.wav", + "text": "也就是說委員會召委先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/484.wav", + "text": "召集協商不是聯席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/485.wav", + "text": "這沒有法定要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/486.wav", + "text": "還是當時的4個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/487.wav", + "text": "都可以參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/488.wav", + "text": "沒有強制性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/489.wav", + "text": "但長期以來就是不成文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/490.wav", + "text": "委員會中心主義大家都尊重委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/491.wav", + "text": "所以委員會先協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/492.wav", + "text": "但協商一定沒有結果如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/493.wav", + "text": "如果有結果的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/494.wav", + "text": "名漏一個都不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/495.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法另外規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/496.wav", + "text": "慢慢協商若不協商就不會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/497.wav", + "text": "就會跑到院會去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/498.wav", + "text": "你現在講的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/499.wav", + "text": "假如我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/500.wav", + "text": "同意17日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/501.wav", + "text": "議下禮拜這些相關的協商程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/502.wav", + "text": "就展開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/503.wav", + "text": "我不相信這個協商會有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/504.wav", + "text": "一定會到院長這裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/505.wav", + "text": "你聽我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/506.wav", + "text": "和張其祿委員的意見都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/507.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/508.wav", + "text": "你比較關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/509.wav", + "text": "的你看看你們的版本長得怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/510.wav", + "text": "和我們長得完全一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/511.wav", + "text": "就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/512.wav", + "text": "我們回到原來的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/513.wav", + "text": "包括游院長在這裡主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/514.wav", + "text": "否有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/515.wav", + "text": "不敢太樂觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/516.wav", + "text": "大家先表態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/517.wav", + "text": "都有第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/518.wav", + "text": "嘛你們長得跟我們一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/519.wav", + "text": "只是少其他而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/520.wav", + "text": "你們兩個都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/521.wav", + "text": "邱臣遠委員又跑出來講一個答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/522.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/523.wav", + "text": "我現在回到另外一個命題上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/524.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/525.wav", + "text": "所有的提案內容在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/526.wav", + "text": "就是他們召集一下程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/527.wav", + "text": "開議第一天就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/528.wav", + "text": "17日一定會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/529.wav", + "text": "的我一開始有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/530.wav", + "text": "可能禮拜三禮拜四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/531.wav", + "text": "來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/532.wav", + "text": "下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/533.wav", + "text": "就可以請院長來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/534.wav", + "text": "一定要尊重一下委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/535.wav", + "text": "員一直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/536.wav", + "text": "所謂的使然必然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/537.wav", + "text": "直抓住這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/538.wav", + "text": "以後國會就這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/539.wav", + "text": "我講最簡單的就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/540.wav", + "text": "大家都講好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/541.wav", + "text": "沒有開委員會都簽好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/542.wav", + "text": "院會處理也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/543.wav", + "text": "宣讀過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/544.wav", + "text": "你們又回來說要開委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/545.wav", + "text": "我們就同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/546.wav", + "text": "大法官尊重國會的自主權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/547.wav", + "text": "反正大家都講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/548.wav", + "text": "不違背憲法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/549.wav", + "text": "2號的精神也大致如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/550.wav", + "text": "所以國會才能運轉下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/551.wav", + "text": "讓大家去協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/552.wav", + "text": "假如不是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/553.wav", + "text": "早就依照兩週內了何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/554.wav", + "text": "來開議日的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/555.wav", + "text": "王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/556.wav", + "text": "我想經過黨團協商之後的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/557.wav", + "text": "是可以再調整開議日期這沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/558.wav", + "text": "但是前提應該是回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/559.wav", + "text": "如果是14天內應該要進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/560.wav", + "text": "窒礙難行之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/561.wav", + "text": "不然本來就應該依照法律本質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/562.wav", + "text": "及協商日期來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/563.wav", + "text": "在2月13日到16日這週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/564.wav", + "text": "由楊瓊瓔委員召集委員會的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/565.wav", + "text": "參加這樣的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/566.wav", + "text": "過過場面就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/567.wav", + "text": "但是做為一個認真監督的在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/568.wav", + "text": "其實我們必須要在委員會善盡職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/569.wav", + "text": "好好地就這些法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/570.wav", + "text": "都是有可能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/571.wav", + "text": "如果我們連這四個委員會的委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/572.wav", + "text": "員及召委都沒有辦法先開議決定之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/573.wav", + "text": "這樣子委員會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/574.wav", + "text": "其實沒有實質上的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/575.wav", + "text": "王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/576.wav", + "text": "我希望我希望把很多遊戲規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/577.wav", + "text": "現在可以來溝通凡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/578.wav", + "text": "凡是委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/579.wav", + "text": "開議以後一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/580.wav", + "text": "就會趕快把各" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/581.wav", + "text": "就延用舊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/582.wav", + "text": "長久以來就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/583.wav", + "text": "你不能現在卡一個等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/584.wav", + "text": "召委是誰要重新來等沒有這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/585.wav", + "text": "一定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/586.wav", + "text": "當時送出的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/587.wav", + "text": "長期以來就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/588.wav", + "text": "但是開議以後一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/589.wav", + "text": "都會定案包括你們要重新抽籤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/590.wav", + "text": "等這些都是一樣要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/591.wav", + "text": "這樣真的會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/592.wav", + "text": "非常混亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/593.wav", + "text": "2月1日已經是新的會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/594.wav", + "text": "每個委員到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/595.wav", + "text": "是屬於哪個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/596.wav", + "text": "重新抽籤或安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/597.wav", + "text": "到16日要開委員會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/598.wav", + "text": "到底誰屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/599.wav", + "text": "的成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/600.wav", + "text": "啊所以這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/601.wav", + "text": "也是會有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/602.wav", + "text": "比較簡單的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/603.wav", + "text": "就是2月14日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/604.wav", + "text": "然後也遵守這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/605.wav", + "text": "來立法院備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/606.wav", + "text": "之後委員會就繼續召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/607.wav", + "text": "你們設定一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/608.wav", + "text": "比較不會有爭議的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/609.wav", + "text": "去大翻轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/610.wav", + "text": "你要看立法院職權行使法第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/611.wav", + "text": "議案出委員會以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/612.wav", + "text": "一定是召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/613.wav", + "text": "然後在院會當說明人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/614.wav", + "text": "這在出委員會當天就定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/615.wav", + "text": "你現在從頭再來說到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/616.wav", + "text": "底經濟委員會等各6個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/617.wav", + "text": "大風吹搬完以後我們再來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/618.wav", + "text": "的委員會每次都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/619.wav", + "text": "由各黨派代表去參與協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/620.wav", + "text": "委員會的朝野協商也是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/621.wav", + "text": "院會尤其是黨鞭來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/622.wav", + "text": "委員會都是各黨派代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/623.wav", + "text": "你要重新創設一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/624.wav", + "text": "不是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/625.wav", + "text": "為了到底誰屬於那個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/626.wav", + "text": "屬於哪個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/627.wav", + "text": "是不是確定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/628.wav", + "text": "今天的委員會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/629.wav", + "text": "這不是法定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/630.wav", + "text": "當然是尊重委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/631.wav", + "text": "委員會朝野協商時都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/632.wav", + "text": "席互相抵制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/633.wav", + "text": "你不要把這個再無限放大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/634.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們建立在可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/635.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/636.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/637.wav", + "text": "各黨團的黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/638.wav", + "text": "首先我要抗議一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/639.wav", + "text": "我們不同調的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/640.wav", + "text": "當然我們會各自表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/641.wav", + "text": "但是最後我們黨團內會做整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/642.wav", + "text": "經過大家剛才的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/643.wav", + "text": "可以合情合理合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/644.wav", + "text": "國會有其自主的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/645.wav", + "text": "我們也同意2月17日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/646.wav", + "text": "開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/647.wav", + "text": "這是民眾黨的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/648.wav", + "text": "但是下個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/649.wav", + "text": "及院長協商要儘快排出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/650.wav", + "text": "我想各黨在協商時都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/651.wav", + "text": "柯總召也不用預設立場認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/652.wav", + "text": "一定會破裂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/653.wav", + "text": "不用先做結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/654.wav", + "text": "\n而我們立法院現在最重要的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/655.wav", + "text": "是國會自主的形象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/656.wav", + "text": "及社會對我們的觀感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/657.wav", + "text": "所以有關中間的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/658.wav", + "text": "不管是委員會的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/659.wav", + "text": "朝野在委員會進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/660.wav", + "text": "或是院長召集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/661.wav", + "text": "甚至到後面預算編列之後的總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/662.wav", + "text": "我們都會秉持著嚴審的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/663.wav", + "text": "這是我們民眾黨的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/664.wav", + "text": "藍綠兩黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/665.wav", + "text": "申翰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/666.wav", + "text": "召委的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/667.wav", + "text": "其實這裡提到的召委不是新的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/668.wav", + "text": "當時是林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/669.wav", + "text": "而後來協商也是林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/670.wav", + "text": "來召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/671.wav", + "text": "所有委員都可以參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/672.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/673.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/674.wav", + "text": "我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/675.wav", + "text": "因為三黨都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/676.wav", + "text": "我們也沒辦法不然要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/677.wav", + "text": "好但我還是要說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/678.wav", + "text": "置變成這樣的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/679.wav", + "text": "一個先例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/680.wav", + "text": "剛才柯總召提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/681.wav", + "text": "提到大法官釋字第342號解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/682.wav", + "text": "我幫他補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/683.wav", + "text": "國安三法亂成一團的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/684.wav", + "text": "這個法案的通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/685.wav", + "text": "到底有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/686.wav", + "text": "這樣通過有重大明顯的瑕疵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/687.wav", + "text": "自治來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/688.wav", + "text": "不應該到這樣的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/689.wav", + "text": "大法官認為還是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/690.wav", + "text": "超過國會自治的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/691.wav", + "text": "而現在立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/692.wav", + "text": "第十六條第一項第三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/693.wav", + "text": "白紙黑字明文地寫在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/694.wav", + "text": "很多例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/695.wav", + "text": "說過去都沒有遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/696.wav", + "text": "立法院通過的立法院職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/697.wav", + "text": "第十六條第一項第三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/698.wav", + "text": "當然你的立場會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/699.wav", + "text": "可以透過協商去打破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/700.wav", + "text": "你的態度是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/701.wav", + "text": "但我的立場跟你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/702.wav", + "text": "恰恰相反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/703.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/704.wav", + "text": "了我也同意了我現在要跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/705.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/706.wav", + "text": "用這麼粗糙的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/707.wav", + "text": "所以你才提起大法官解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/708.wav", + "text": "現在的狀況就是立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/709.wav", + "text": "法院職權行使法已經有相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/710.wav", + "text": "要做表率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/711.wav", + "text": "一般人民也會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/712.wav", + "text": "立法委員制定通過的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/713.wav", + "text": "連立法委員都不遵守的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/714.wav", + "text": "人民為什麼要遵守國家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/715.wav", + "text": "法律呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/716.wav", + "text": "不管是立法院職權行使法也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/717.wav", + "text": "有權力的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/718.wav", + "text": "有權力的政治人物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/719.wav", + "text": "應該要認真地來對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/720.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/721.wav", + "text": "這樣我們就決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/722.wav", + "text": "\n不過剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/723.wav", + "text": "17" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/724.wav", + "text": "不然就要修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/725.wav", + "text": "你覺得那個不好就要把它改掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/726.wav", + "text": "否則它存在的話你就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/727.wav", + "text": "遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/728.wav", + "text": "我向各位報告決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/729.wav", + "text": "一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/730.wav", + "text": "第10屆第7會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/731.wav", + "text": "第1次會議(開議日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/732.wav", + "text": "本會期自2月17" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/733.wav", + "text": "日(星期五)起每週五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/734.wav", + "text": "及次週二視為一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/735.wav", + "text": "院會國是論壇及臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/736.wav", + "text": "依往例處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/737.wav", + "text": "(週五上午9時至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/738.wav", + "text": "0時為國是論壇時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/739.wav", + "text": "週二下午5時至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/740.wav", + "text": "至6時處理臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/741.wav", + "text": "質詢期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/742.wav", + "text": "週二下午1時50分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/743.wav", + "text": "至2時30分處理臨時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/744.wav", + "text": "提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/745.wav", + "text": "24日(星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/746.wav", + "text": "第1次會議不處理臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/747.wav", + "text": "有關稅收超徵全民共享法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/748.wav", + "text": "於2月17日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/749.wav", + "text": "(星期五)院會進行表決處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/750.wav", + "text": "不受黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/751.wav", + "text": "期1個月之限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/752.wav", + "text": "並完成立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/753.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/754.wav", + "text": "不提出復議本次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/755.wav", + "text": "討論事項僅列上開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/756.wav", + "text": "議案\n三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/757.wav", + "text": "2月21日(星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/758.wav", + "text": ")邀請行政院院長率同各部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/759.wav", + "text": "列席進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/760.wav", + "text": "施政方針及施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/761.wav", + "text": "並備質詢報告後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/762.wav", + "text": "隨即進行政黨質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/763.wav", + "text": "當日質詢人數由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/764.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團推派4人國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/765.wav", + "text": "推派2人台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/766.wav", + "text": "及時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/767.wav", + "text": "各推派1人進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/768.wav", + "text": "質詢順序依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/769.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/770.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/771.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團之順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/772.wav", + "text": "輪流交叉方式進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/773.wav", + "text": "有關質詢期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/774.wav", + "text": "之順序及人數均依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/775.wav", + "text": "\n四行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/776.wav", + "text": "如於3月2日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/777.wav", + "text": "依上開條例編製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/778.wav", + "text": "之特別預算案至立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/779.wav", + "text": "院時各黨團同意將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/780.wav", + "text": "其列入3月3日(星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/781.wav", + "text": ")院會報告事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/782.wav", + "text": "並於同日邀請行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/783.wav", + "text": "院長主計長財政部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/784.wav", + "text": "國家發展委員會主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/785.wav", + "text": "及相關部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/786.wav", + "text": "列席報告該預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/787.wav", + "text": "編製經過並備質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/788.wav", + "text": "質詢人數由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/789.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團推派11人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/790.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團推派7人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/791.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/792.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團各推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/793.wav", + "text": "1人進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/794.wav", + "text": "未參加黨團委員得優先發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/795.wav", + "text": "質詢順序依例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/796.wav", + "text": "授權議事處辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/797.wav", + "text": "議案詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/798.wav", + "text": "完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/799.wav", + "text": "即交審查各黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/800.wav", + "text": "不提出復議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/801.wav", + "text": "上述名單請於3月2日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/802.wav", + "text": "(星期四)中午12時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/803.wav", + "text": "送至議事處彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/804.wav", + "text": "會期程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/805.wav", + "text": "依政黨比例由民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/806.wav", + "text": "推派11人國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/807.wav", + "text": "推派6人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/808.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團及時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/809.wav", + "text": "各推派1人代表組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/810.wav", + "text": "名單請於2月23日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/811.wav", + "text": "(星期四)中午12時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/812.wav", + "text": "送至議事處彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/813.wav", + "text": "上述名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/814.wav", + "text": "送交議事處後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/815.wav", + "text": "即不予更換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/816.wav", + "text": "\n六各黨團同意3月28日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/817.wav", + "text": "邀請捷克" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/818.wav", + "text": "捷克眾議院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/819.wav", + "text": "議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/820.wav", + "text": "捷克的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/821.wav", + "text": "國民議會議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/822.wav", + "text": "而已38歲的議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/823.wav", + "text": "他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/824.wav", + "text": "比照韋德齊議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/825.wav", + "text": "邀請他來演講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/826.wav", + "text": "好啦沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/827.wav", + "text": "3月28日(星期二)上午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/828.wav", + "text": "邀請捷克眾議院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/829.wav", + "text": "議長艾達莫娃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/830.wav", + "text": "於本院議場發表演講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/831.wav", + "text": "請本院委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/832.wav", + "text": "踴躍參加相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/833.wav", + "text": "儀程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/834.wav", + "text": "授權秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/835.wav", + "text": "依規定辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/836.wav", + "text": "院長我有個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/837.wav", + "text": "開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/838.wav", + "text": "依我剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/839.wav", + "text": "法律規定就是希望他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/840.wav", + "text": "就職後兩週內來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/841.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠讓行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/842.wav", + "text": "17日來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/843.wav", + "text": "報告並備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/844.wav", + "text": "要到2月21日了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/845.wav", + "text": "我想你不要咬著這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/846.wav", + "text": "職權行使法修了之後到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/847.wav", + "text": "就是因為大法官釋字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/848.wav", + "text": "澈底針對國會制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/849.wav", + "text": "只要你不違憲不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/850.wav", + "text": "只要有共識就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/851.wav", + "text": "包括立法院組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/852.wav", + "text": "國際事務也可以修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/853.wav", + "text": "畢竟法律要精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/854.wav", + "text": "希望大家能夠儘快認真做事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/855.wav", + "text": "現在是看要怎麼做會比較合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/856.wav", + "text": "你剛剛提司法院大不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/857.wav", + "text": "這不是憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/858.wav", + "text": "這是你破壞了法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/859.wav", + "text": "的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/860.wav", + "text": "是當國安三法亂成一團的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/861.wav", + "text": "看這個程序有沒有違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/862.wav", + "text": "我不知道是誰給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/863.wav", + "text": "這個錯誤的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/864.wav", + "text": "怎麼會用大法官釋字第342號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/865.wav", + "text": "解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/866.wav", + "text": "你也非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/867.wav", + "text": "國會的自主行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/868.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/869.wav", + "text": "因為當時在通過的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/870.wav", + "text": "亂成一團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/871.wav", + "text": "你的主張是說這個不應該這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/872.wav", + "text": "嘛你的主張是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/873.wav", + "text": "啊所以你的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/874.wav", + "text": "跟你現在提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/875.wav", + "text": "跟我說這件事是顛倒的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/876.wav", + "text": "人家給你的訊息你要過濾一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/877.wav", + "text": "你要知道你本來的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/878.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/879.wav", + "text": "聽我說我知道你的個性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/880.wav", + "text": "不是我的個性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/881.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/882.wav", + "text": "為什麼會去釋憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/883.wav", + "text": "那是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/884.wav", + "text": "很重要的大法官解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/885.wav", + "text": "所以立法院後來依據這個大法官解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/886.wav", + "text": "尊重國會的自主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/887.wav", + "text": "他甚至講到只要不違憲的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/888.wav", + "text": "違背法令以及規定都無所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/889.wav", + "text": "這是屬於國會自主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/890.wav", + "text": "講個最簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/891.wav", + "text": "如果你這樣解釋的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/892.wav", + "text": "你在民主國會待了30" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/893.wav", + "text": "院長跟柯總召都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/894.wav", + "text": "因為你通過了國會五法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/895.wav", + "text": "讓臺灣國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/896.wav", + "text": "可以往前更進一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/897.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法也是國會五法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/898.wav", + "text": "其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/899.wav", + "text": "之一但現在解釋怎麼變成說國會五法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/900.wav", + "text": "一點都不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/901.wav", + "text": "白紙黑字寫在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/902.wav", + "text": "你要為這個東西辯護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/903.wav", + "text": "不是這樣辯護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/904.wav", + "text": "的如果你要辯護的話是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/905.wav", + "text": "行政院院長應在兩周內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/906.wav", + "text": "像過去議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/907.wav", + "text": "或是過去許多的惡例其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/908.wav", + "text": "但是現在問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/909.wav", + "text": "1月31日他就職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/910.wav", + "text": "像上一次蘇院長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/911.wav", + "text": "是在會期中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/912.wav", + "text": "所以蘇嘉全院長才會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/913.wav", + "text": "會期從2月1日開始算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/914.wav", + "text": "你如果去看過去行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/915.wav", + "text": "沒有在兩個禮拜之內來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/916.wav", + "text": "做施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/917.wav", + "text": "其實當時大多數的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/918.wav", + "text": "會期都不是民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/919.wav", + "text": "所以當時有透過朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/920.wav", + "text": "既然2月17日已經不在兩周內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/921.wav", + "text": "你講2月17日他一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/922.wav", + "text": "來做施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/923.wav", + "text": "這也是超過兩周了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/924.wav", + "text": "好像是民進黨這邊或柯建銘總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/925.wav", + "text": "這不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/926.wav", + "text": "我現在跟你講這不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/927.wav", + "text": "現在在這邊談總是要有個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/928.wav", + "text": "所以你不要講得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/929.wav", + "text": "好像都是柯總召的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/930.wav", + "text": "不是他剛才是這樣講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/931.wav", + "text": "決定事項第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/932.wav", + "text": "稅收超徵全民共享法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/933.wav", + "text": "目前為止在所有的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/934.wav", + "text": "既然我們是要正式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/935.wav", + "text": "朝野協商決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/936.wav", + "text": "我們沒有一個草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/937.wav", + "text": "是叫稅收超徵全民共享法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/938.wav", + "text": "這種錯誤的名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/939.wav", + "text": "會引起誤會不要以訛傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/940.wav", + "text": "我看這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/941.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/942.wav", + "text": "開議日我已經同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/943.wav", + "text": "而且我說的是很卑微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/944.wav", + "text": "很基本的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/945.wav", + "text": "兩週內要來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/946.wav", + "text": "日超過二週了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/947.wav", + "text": "我們為什麼不能讓他來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/948.wav", + "text": "而且法律是規定應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/949.wav", + "text": "除非今天行政院說他有什麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/950.wav", + "text": "我相信他也不會有困難才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/951.wav", + "text": "那麼就是2月17日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/952.wav", + "text": "讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/953.wav", + "text": "及未來的藍圖進行報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/954.wav", + "text": "這有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/955.wav", + "text": "再延到2月21日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/956.wav", + "text": "才讓他來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/957.wav", + "text": "講不出個道理嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/958.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是很基本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/959.wav", + "text": "很卑微的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/960.wav", + "text": "你聽人家講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/961.wav", + "text": "你的意思我能夠瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/962.wav", + "text": "談17日是要處理特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/963.wav", + "text": "發言等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/964.wav", + "text": "並行不並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/965.wav", + "text": "不悖啊這難處在哪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/966.wav", + "text": "既然沒有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/967.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜內你都同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/968.wav", + "text": "為什麼一定要慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/969.wav", + "text": "過完年百工百業都開工多久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/970.wav", + "text": "為什麼一定要讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/971.wav", + "text": "1月31日就職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/972.wav", + "text": "我們是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/973.wav", + "text": "趕快發不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/974.wav", + "text": "1月31日他就就職了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/975.wav", + "text": "難道他2月1日到現在都沒在做事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/976.wav", + "text": "他當然有在做事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/977.wav", + "text": "對所以臺灣社會希望瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/978.wav", + "text": "新的院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/979.wav", + "text": "對臺灣未來的願景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/980.wav", + "text": "當天要處理特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/981.wav", + "text": "又要總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/982.wav", + "text": "如果你這樣的話我不會簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/983.wav", + "text": "我不會簽因為這樣我沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/984.wav", + "text": "我們已經同意17日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/985.wav", + "text": "歷年以來都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/986.wav", + "text": "42號解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/987.wav", + "text": "你今天才發現你假如有這個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/988.wav", + "text": "你不能這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/989.wav", + "text": "子你當初提出大法官解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/990.wav", + "text": "不就是認為國民黨在國會惡搞嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/991.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/992.wav", + "text": "現在法律這樣規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/993.wav", + "text": "\n關於大家在溝通的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/994.wav", + "text": "有稍微修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/995.wav", + "text": "\n二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/996.wav", + "text": "2月17日(星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/997.wav", + "text": ")邀請行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/998.wav", + "text": "率同各部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/999.wav", + "text": "列席進行施政方針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1000.wav", + "text": "及施政報告並備質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1001.wav", + "text": "報告後隨即進行政黨質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1002.wav", + "text": "當日質詢人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1003.wav", + "text": "由民進黨黨團推派4人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1004.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團推派2人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1005.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團及時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1006.wav", + "text": "各推派1人進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1007.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1008.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1009.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1010.wav", + "text": "��順序輪流交叉方式進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1011.wav", + "text": "有關質詢期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1012.wav", + "text": "之順序及人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1013.wav", + "text": "均依例授權議事處辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1014.wav", + "text": "有關國民黨黨團擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1015.wav", + "text": "稅收超徵全民共享發放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1016.wav", + "text": "特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1017.wav", + "text": "及行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1018.wav", + "text": "函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1019.wav", + "text": "疫後強化經濟與社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1020.wav", + "text": "及全民共享經濟成果特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1021.wav", + "text": "於2月21日(星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1022.wav", + "text": ")院會進行表決處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1023.wav", + "text": "並完成立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1024.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意不提出復議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1025.wav", + "text": "本次會議討論事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1026.wav", + "text": "僅列上開議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1027.wav", + "text": "以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1028.wav", + "text": "台聯黨團成立的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1029.wav", + "text": "因為黨產要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1030.wav", + "text": "後來也是透過表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1031.wav", + "text": "我現在很怕我回應你結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1032.wav", + "text": "又會有變數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1033.wav", + "text": "所以我現在不會回應你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1034.wav", + "text": "原來是在第2張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1035.wav", + "text": "很謝謝大家願意讓他來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1036.wav", + "text": "臺灣很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1037.wav", + "text": "各位都簽好字了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1038.wav", + "text": "今天非常謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14783/1039.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/0.wav", + "text": "所以我在10點20分要離開這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/1.wav", + "text": "會不會再回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/2.wav", + "text": "團的建議與要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/3.wav", + "text": "針對疫後強化經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/4.wav", + "text": "特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/5.wav", + "text": "\n現在開始進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/6.wav", + "text": "行廣泛討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/7.wav", + "text": "並且也在院會宣讀過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/8.wav", + "text": "一次會代表什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/9.wav", + "text": "院會才有所謂的一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/10.wav", + "text": "之前的延會本來就沒有委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/11.wav", + "text": "這次也一樣大家都簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/12.wav", + "text": "行政院版和國民黨版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/13.wav", + "text": "時力及民眾黨沒有提版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/14.wav", + "text": "這是目前的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/15.wav", + "text": "\n今天要朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/16.wav", + "text": "各黨團的看法��們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/17.wav", + "text": "要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/18.wav", + "text": "我以為你要先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/19.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/20.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/21.wav", + "text": "我們的主張是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/22.wav", + "text": "開聯席委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/23.wav", + "text": "由包括經濟財政內政等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/24.wav", + "text": "行政院版的特別條例第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/25.wav", + "text": "所規定的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/26.wav", + "text": "是包山包海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/27.wav", + "text": "挹注勞健保基金及台電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/28.wav", + "text": "減輕居住負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/29.wav", + "text": "擴大公共運輸補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/30.wav", + "text": "推動中小企業升級轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/31.wav", + "text": "擴大吸引國際觀光客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/32.wav", + "text": "地照顧農漁民權益普發現金等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/33.wav", + "text": "是一個完全概括的空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/34.wav", + "text": "即其他經行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/35.wav", + "text": "核可之強化經濟及社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/36.wav", + "text": "有關事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/37.wav", + "text": "這到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/38.wav", + "text": "在這個沒有講清楚的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/39.wav", + "text": "具體要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/40.wav", + "text": "怎麼做都不知道的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/41.wav", + "text": "我們是反對將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/42.wav", + "text": "這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/43.wav", + "text": "讀應該要交付聯席委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/44.wav", + "text": "進行實質審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/45.wav", + "text": "人民負責的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/46.wav", + "text": "所以我們是希望召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/47.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/48.wav", + "text": "各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/49.wav", + "text": "很明確就是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/50.wav", + "text": "趕快還稅於民發放現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/51.wav", + "text": "簡單明瞭不複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/52.wav", + "text": "剛才邱顯智委員也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/53.wav", + "text": "聽起來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/54.wav", + "text": "未來要審查的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/55.wav", + "text": "行政院真的希望能夠把現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/56.wav", + "text": "我認為我們國民黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/57.wav", + "text": "真的非常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/58.wav", + "text": "單純" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/59.wav", + "text": "如果真的要還稅於民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/60.wav", + "text": "3條第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/61.wav", + "text": "也說要全民發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/62.wav", + "text": "我們就先執行全民發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/63.wav", + "text": "那我們國民黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/64.wav", + "text": "真的很清楚很明瞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/65.wav", + "text": "就是發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/66.wav", + "text": "我們趕快在年前把它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/67.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/68.wav", + "text": "各位同仁能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/69.wav", + "text": "我們逕付二讀然後趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/70.wav", + "text": "筆錢交付到人民的手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/71.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長還有各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/72.wav", + "text": "團黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/73.wav", + "text": "鞭民眾黨的態度非常的明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/74.wav", + "text": "共享經濟果實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/75.wav", + "text": "但是我們反對債留子孫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/76.wav", + "text": "我們也要求程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/77.wav", + "text": "所以針對這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/78.wav", + "text": "特別條例的部分我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/79.wav", + "text": "拿後代子孫口袋的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/80.wav", + "text": "來讓現在的人共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/81.wav", + "text": "我們也主張刪除特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/82.wav", + "text": "預算經費來源就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/83.wav", + "text": "改以移用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/84.wav", + "text": "前年度歲計賸餘及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/85.wav", + "text": "111年度經審計部完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/86.wav", + "text": "的空白授權也要斷絕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/87.wav", + "text": "刪除行政院草案第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/88.wav", + "text": "第9款其他經行政院核可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/89.wav", + "text": "之強化經濟及社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/90.wav", + "text": "韌性有關事項這個空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/91.wav", + "text": "條款以符合授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/92.wav", + "text": "避免變成空白支票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/93.wav", + "text": "第二個特別預算施行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/94.wav", + "text": "期間我們認為不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/95.wav", + "text": "拖到2025年年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/96.wav", + "text": "變成一個長期空白授權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/97.wav", + "text": "支票所以施行期間應該縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/98.wav", + "text": "為2024年6月30日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/99.wav", + "text": "屆滿也就是針對這一次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/100.wav", + "text": "第三個就是我們剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/101.wav", + "text": "的刪除預算經費來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/102.wav", + "text": "面對國債債臺高築不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/103.wav", + "text": "借錢發現金再增加國債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/104.wav", + "text": "相關的行政單位跟主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/105.wav", + "text": "應該在初期的預估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/106.wav", + "text": "就要更加精準不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/107.wav", + "text": "舉借債務的方式去支應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/108.wav", + "text": "第四個最重要我們要實現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/109.wav", + "text": "世代正義要確保下一代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/110.wav", + "text": "都領得到年金健康有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/111.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為本次撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/112.wav", + "text": "勞健保基金不得少於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/113.wav", + "text": "15%數額上大概差不多是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/114.wav", + "text": "570億左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/115.wav", + "text": "以上是我們主張的四個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/116.wav", + "text": "我們希望這個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/117.wav", + "text": "還是要回歸到聯席委員會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/118.wav", + "text": "做實質審查謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/119.wav", + "text": "還有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/120.wav", + "text": "你們先講今" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/121.wav", + "text": "今天是你們要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/122.wav", + "text": "你的底線才是重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/123.wav", + "text": "我來將近3年好像沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/124.wav", + "text": "這麼客氣過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/125.wav", + "text": "我現在先講也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/126.wav", + "text": "我要知道你的底線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/127.wav", + "text": "我馬上就通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/128.wav", + "text": "嘛那我們要了解你們的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/129.wav", + "text": "你們先講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/130.wav", + "text": "請謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/131.wav", + "text": "院長各黨團的幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/132.wav", + "text": "我們要求召開朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/133.wav", + "text": "是因為行政院送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/134.wav", + "text": "3,800億的特別條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/135.wav", + "text": "上禮拜的延會協商大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/136.wav", + "text": "討論得非常充分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/137.wav", + "text": "行政院估計的1,450" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/138.wav", + "text": "億元其實這1,800" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/139.wav", + "text": "億裡面你們已經預留了350" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/140.wav", + "text": "另外1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/141.wav", + "text": "撥補勞健保及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/142.wav", + "text": "台電虧損的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/143.wav", + "text": "是數字的問題我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/144.wav", + "text": "大家在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/145.wav", + "text": "討論也是相對的單純" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/146.wav", + "text": "只是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/147.wav", + "text": "經濟及社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/148.wav", + "text": "韌性的相關經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/149.wav", + "text": "對於各黨團來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/150.wav", + "text": "的確是給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/151.wav", + "text": "予行政院一個模糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/152.wav", + "text": "授權的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/153.wav", + "text": "尤其是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/154.wav", + "text": "這1,000億沒有進到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/155.wav", + "text": "委員會做實質審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/156.wav", + "text": "知道這個跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/157.wav", + "text": "已經超編的3,700億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/158.wav", + "text": "預算到底有沒有重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/159.wav", + "text": "的部分再者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/160.wav", + "text": "這個條例的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/161.wav", + "text": "延續到兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/162.wav", + "text": "之後有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/163.wav", + "text": "涉及到這1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/164.wav", + "text": "元會不會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/165.wav", + "text": "執政黨綁樁的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/166.wav", + "text": "工具所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/167.wav", + "text": "3,800億的特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/168.wav", + "text": "才會要求一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/169.wav", + "text": "到委員會做實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/170.wav", + "text": "超收稅額發放現金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/171.wav", + "text": "其實是相對單純" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/172.wav", + "text": "而且朝野各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/173.wav", + "text": "也相對容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/174.wav", + "text": "去溝通及同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/175.wav", + "text": "即便目前還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/176.wav", + "text": "一些黨團對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/177.wav", + "text": "為什麼要發放現金以及如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/178.wav", + "text": "發放有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/179.wav", + "text": "但還是相對單純容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/180.wav", + "text": "在這個會期內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/181.wav", + "text": "協商然後順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/182.wav", + "text": "的通過行政院也說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/183.wav", + "text": "他們對於發放現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/184.wav", + "text": "發放的流程都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/185.wav", + "text": "規劃當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/186.wav", + "text": "行政團隊所說都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/187.wav", + "text": "在規劃當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/188.wav", + "text": "為什麼今天要送一個3,800" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/189.wav", + "text": "億的特別預算是包裹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/190.wav", + "text": "的而且讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/191.wav", + "text": "發放現金的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/192.wav", + "text": "是延緩的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/193.wav", + "text": "如果是一個好的政策延遲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/194.wav", + "text": "就不會是一個好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/195.wav", + "text": "結果現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/196.wav", + "text": "現在民進黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/197.wav", + "text": "相對比較有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/198.wav", + "text": "的部分要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/199.wav", + "text": "儘速來討論在本會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/200.wav", + "text": "討論出一個結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/201.wav", + "text": "讓民眾能夠安心過年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/202.wav", + "text": "我想上述的發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/203.wav", + "text": "都有講過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/204.wav", + "text": "整個預算在行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/205.wav", + "text": "地方有問題然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/206.wav", + "text": "裹表決是一種不負責任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/207.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣合乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/208.wav", + "text": "延會只剩下這幾天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/209.wav", + "text": "要達到最大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/210.wav", + "text": "民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/211.wav", + "text": "暴力式的在表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/212.wav", + "text": "時過半的輾壓過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/213.wav", + "text": "我還是要再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/214.wav", + "text": "時代力量等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/215.wav", + "text": "在野黨被迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/216.wav", + "text": "修正動議因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/217.wav", + "text": "的意見或者是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/218.wav", + "text": "一些款項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/219.wav", + "text": "普發現金之外這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/220.wav", + "text": "在委員會進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/221.wav", + "text": "式的通過這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/222.wav", + "text": "真的是非常非常的不妥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/223.wav", + "text": "這樣的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/224.wav", + "text": "如果是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/225.wav", + "text": "就會引起反彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/226.wav", + "text": "所以我在這裡還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/227.wav", + "text": "有爭議的部分一定還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/228.wav", + "text": "要付委如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/229.wav", + "text": "不要付委的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/230.wav", + "text": "可能某些項目我們還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/231.wav", + "text": "請張委員院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/232.wav", + "text": "剛才本黨邱總召之所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/233.wav", + "text": "嚴謹的審查程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/234.wav", + "text": "是因為這裡面涉及太多複雜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/235.wav", + "text": "關經濟社會韌性的這部分基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/236.wav", + "text": "是有點空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/237.wav", + "text": "這個概念變成是我們要避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/238.wav", + "text": "亦即這件事情會不會造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/239.wav", + "text": "是這樣一方面我們很急著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/240.wav", + "text": "比如至少2月底之前就能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/241.wav", + "text": "也要避免藉由這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/242.wav", + "text": "結果我們在有些項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/243.wav", + "text": "上面反而是被搭了便車很粗糙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/244.wav", + "text": "地就被帶過去甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/245.wav", + "text": "這些資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/246.wav", + "text": "很明確的授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/247.wav", + "text": "記者會提及關於這次的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/248.wav", + "text": "來源雖然現在是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/249.wav", + "text": "來看確實是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/250.wav", + "text": "當時也說超徵400多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/251.wav", + "text": "億而最後歲計賸餘大概不到3,000億基" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/252.wav", + "text": "於以上的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/253.wav", + "text": "一開始在進行第一輪發言的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/254.wav", + "text": "到底要如何我們這邊還是先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/255.wav", + "text": "單純的針對趕快發下現金這點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/256.wav", + "text": "我們當然可以支持程序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/257.wav", + "text": "也許是這樣但如果這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/258.wav", + "text": "涉及要很複雜地去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/259.wav", + "text": "有一個嚴謹的審查程序因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/260.wav", + "text": "各黨團最終的討論如果把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/261.wav", + "text": "單純化一點只談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/262.wav", + "text": "發現金的那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/263.wav", + "text": "以更快速的程序走完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/264.wav", + "text": "需要經過比較嚴謹的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/265.wav", + "text": "程序委員會的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/266.wav", + "text": "同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/267.wav", + "text": "我先講個程序的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/268.wav", + "text": "禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/269.wav", + "text": "協商之後大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/270.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/271.wav", + "text": "結論後來院會也宣讀過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/272.wav", + "text": "不過柯總召於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/273.wav", + "text": "13日下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/274.wav", + "text": "寫臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/275.wav", + "text": "罵在野3個黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/276.wav", + "text": "既然你簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/277.wav", + "text": "那你還在臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/278.wav", + "text": "罵在野黨包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/279.wav", + "text": "國民黨時代力量民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/280.wav", + "text": "這樣真的是不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/281.wav", + "text": "這是要怎麼簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/282.wav", + "text": "朝野協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/283.wav", + "text": "簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/284.wav", + "text": "罵我本來還不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/285.wav", + "text": "耶記者來問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/286.wav", + "text": "啊那以後我不敢簽朝野協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/287.wav", + "text": "喔不可以這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/288.wav", + "text": "柯總召你這樣不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/289.wav", + "text": "我要抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/290.wav", + "text": "後事後你罵我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/291.wav", + "text": "而你也去簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/292.wav", + "text": "等於罵院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/293.wav", + "text": "耶你先回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/294.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/295.wav", + "text": "簽名簽名��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/296.wav", + "text": "也不要簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/297.wav", + "text": "朝野協商之後就不可以回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/298.wav", + "text": "寫臉書罵人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/299.wav", + "text": "哪院長你要抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/300.wav", + "text": "你是召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/301.wav", + "text": "啊以前常常發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/302.wav", + "text": "這就是我講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/303.wav", + "text": "還罵你一頓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/304.wav", + "text": "沒有這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/305.wav", + "text": "\n再講今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/306.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/307.wav", + "text": "所以提了這個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/308.wav", + "text": "行政院昨天也講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/309.wav", + "text": "他們特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/310.wav", + "text": "完成三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/311.wav", + "text": "讀就可以送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/312.wav", + "text": "這表示國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/313.wav", + "text": "一貫的主張是正確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/314.wav", + "text": "本逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/315.wav", + "text": "發現金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/316.wav", + "text": "併國民黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/317.wav", + "text": "朝野協商趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/318.wav", + "text": "讓它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/319.wav", + "text": "既然行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/320.wav", + "text": "預算編好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/321.wav", + "text": "金啦這是國民黨主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/322.wav", + "text": "國民黨發現金的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/323.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/324.wav", + "text": "趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/325.wav", + "text": "完成法定程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/326.wav", + "text": "行政院特別預算編好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/327.wav", + "text": "趕快送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/328.wav", + "text": "加班我們都願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/329.wav", + "text": "行政院送來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/330.wav", + "text": "金額高達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/331.wav", + "text": "3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/332.wav", + "text": "其中第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/333.wav", + "text": "第9款是其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/334.wav", + "text": "經行政院核可之強化經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/335.wav", + "text": "及社會靭性有關事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/336.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨強烈主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/337.wav", + "text": "3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/338.wav", + "text": "包山包海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/339.wav", + "text": "還空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/340.wav", + "text": "的這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/341.wav", + "text": "要履行程序正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/342.wav", + "text": "到委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/343.wav", + "text": "今天付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/344.wav", + "text": "二三走走看嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/345.wav", + "text": "嘛真的不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/346.wav", + "text": "我們也履行承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/347.wav", + "text": "留個半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/348.wav", + "text": "完成總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/349.wav", + "text": "和歷年相比並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/350.wav", + "text": "比較遲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/351.wav", + "text": "去年是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/352.wav", + "text": "所以絕對沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/353.wav", + "text": "延遲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/354.wav", + "text": "總預算三讀程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/355.wav", + "text": "以上是國民黨的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/356.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/357.wav", + "text": "黨團回好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/358.wav", + "text": "我很清晰地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/359.wav", + "text": "但是稍微刺激到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/360.wav", + "text": "對於整個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/361.wav", + "text": "13日結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/362.wav", + "text": "因為所謂的發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/363.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/364.wav", + "text": "你發言的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/365.wav", + "text": "是說大家拚看看看年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/366.wav", + "text": "可不可以發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/367.wav", + "text": "這個沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/368.wav", + "text": "林思銘委員也講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/369.wav", + "text": "了法都還沒通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/370.wav", + "text": "法通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/371.wav", + "text": "就會有結論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/372.wav", + "text": "法通過以後還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/373.wav", + "text": "總統公告3天就過年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/374.wav", + "text": "了行政院長要把預算送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/375.wav", + "text": "預算也不必審查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/376.wav", + "text": "你到底在講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/377.wav", + "text": "柯總召不會做我來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/378.wav", + "text": "保證4天就把現金發下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/379.wav", + "text": "你今天也是這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/380.wav", + "text": "要到上個禮拜四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/381.wav", + "text": "才送為什麼不開臨時院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/382.wav", + "text": "趕快送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/383.wav", + "text": "差3天而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/384.wav", + "text": "可能排除朝野協商1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/385.wav", + "text": "你在想什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/386.wav", + "text": "你們在野黨可以6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/387.wav", + "text": "那是一回事我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/388.wav", + "text": "我跟你講我們的版本和行政院差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/389.wav", + "text": "我們也很嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/390.wav", + "text": "它還抄我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/391.wav", + "text": "好啦讓我說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/392.wav", + "text": "第3條嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/393.wav", + "text": "你你們這樣送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/394.wav", + "text": "為差3天就來得及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/395.wav", + "text": "因為它是禮拜四嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/396.wav", + "text": "提早開院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/397.wav", + "text": "你是禮拜一送來它禮拜它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/398.wav", + "text": "它為什麼要比我們慢啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/399.wav", + "text": "它可以比我們快啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/400.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂比快慢的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/401.wav", + "text": "可行性怎麼樣以及大家的政策理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/402.wav", + "text": "有沒有一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/403.wav", + "text": "一定要遵守立法院的程序嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/404.wav", + "text": "果是緣木求魚天方夜譚的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/405.wav", + "text": "你現在還在這裡講說過年前要發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/406.wav", + "text": "大家都很清楚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/407.wav", + "text": "會寫臉書就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/408.wav", + "text": "其實在擋總預算的不是只有國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/409.wav", + "text": "我發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/410.wav", + "text": "都沒有簽總預算嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/411.wav", + "text": "你們三個黨都沒有簽嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/412.wav", + "text": "好像只有在討論這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/413.wav", + "text": "用這個來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/414.wav", + "text": "綁總預算可是我們的重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/415.wav", + "text": "總預算嘛這個會期是總預算嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/416.wav", + "text": "定有優先順序緩急輕重嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/417.wav", + "text": "更何況是總預算比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/418.wav", + "text": "還是發現金比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/419.wav", + "text": "這個大家都知道嘛發現金也有發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/420.wav", + "text": "但是除了發現金以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/421.wav", + "text": "我們還要做其他事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/422.wav", + "text": "這是各黨可以主張的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/423.wav", + "text": "\n你不用一直舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/424.wav", + "text": "舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/425.wav", + "text": "把上禮拜的全部回顧一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/426.wav", + "text": "我們的重點是總預算可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/427.wav", + "text": "是今天都沒有在講總預算耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/428.wav", + "text": "總預算被放到旁邊去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/429.wav", + "text": "這是有主從關係的現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/430.wav", + "text": "卻用這個來綁總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/431.wav", + "text": "大家都很清楚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/432.wav", + "text": "我們執政當然是總預算比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/433.wav", + "text": "你問國人是總預算比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/434.wav", + "text": "我們要了解啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/435.wav", + "text": "要趕快發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/436.wav", + "text": "而且要在過年前發出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/437.wav", + "text": "國家還有很多重大政事耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/438.wav", + "text": "中臺關係包括兩岸危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/439.wav", + "text": "通膨等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/440.wav", + "text": "都是重大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/441.wav", + "text": "總預算裡面有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/442.wav", + "text": "所以我們要搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/443.wav", + "text": "緩急輕重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/444.wav", + "text": "只有占14%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/445.wav", + "text": "併總預算來談嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/446.wav", + "text": "他們都反對說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/447.wav", + "text": "我們都可以尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/448.wav", + "text": "但是各位上禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/449.wav", + "text": "院長協商最後在簽的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/450.wav", + "text": "要把文字看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/451.wav", + "text": "有院會才有一次會嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/452.wav", + "text": "所以沒有委員會了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/453.wav", + "text": "沒有寫清楚沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/454.wav", + "text": "楚絕對要寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/455.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/456.wav", + "text": "沒有交代委員會啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/457.wav", + "text": "有沒有委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/458.wav", + "text": "但這個文字早晚簽都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/459.wav", + "text": "也可以談啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/460.wav", + "text": "總預算怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/461.wav", + "text": "不是只有這個然後總預算不必處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/462.wav", + "text": "民眾黨時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/463.wav", + "text": "包括你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/464.wav", + "text": "行政院的版本到委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/465.wav", + "text": "天下有這種事情嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/466.wav", + "text": "通過以後委員會還審什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/467.wav", + "text": "你的版本不必審嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/468.wav", + "text": "單純" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/469.wav", + "text": "好像自己在設計自己在爽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/470.wav", + "text": "不是兒戲嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/471.wav", + "text": "這就是兒戲啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/472.wav", + "text": "馬上通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/473.wav", + "text": "立法院可以拆成這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/474.wav", + "text": "創了這例子我們也不會答應啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/475.wav", + "text": "你不要用總預算來綁一切嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/476.wav", + "text": "我們今天要講就連總預算一起來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/477.wav", + "text": "不是只講發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/478.wav", + "text": "我們的兩個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/479.wav", + "text": "那就是兩個版本趕快逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/480.wav", + "text": "但還有朝野協商的一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/481.wav", + "text": "那是最快的途徑而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/482.wav", + "text": "不協商1個月嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/483.wav", + "text": "朝野協商1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/484.wav", + "text": "他們不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/485.wav", + "text": "他們比較沒有經驗不知道這樣寫就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/486.wav", + "text": "經過解釋後都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/487.wav", + "text": "\n好我們今天要重新談要開委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/488.wav", + "text": "也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/489.wav", + "text": "全部付委也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/490.wav", + "text": "討論途徑的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/491.wav", + "text": "但是總預算要一起來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/492.wav", + "text": "不是只有你們講總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/493.wav", + "text": "政治是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/494.wav", + "text": "所以大家要有誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/495.wav", + "text": "你們不要一天變一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/496.wav", + "text": "一天發明一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/497.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/498.wav", + "text": "馬上就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/499.wav", + "text": "其他就不必審了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/500.wav", + "text": "我希望你們黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/501.wav", + "text": "坦白講你要有一定的高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/502.wav", + "text": "你在駡我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/503.wav", + "text": "什麼善意提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/504.wav", + "text": "照你的才有高度啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/505.wav", + "text": "那是你家的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/506.wav", + "text": "政治要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/507.wav", + "text": "你不可以對我們國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/508.wav", + "text": "因為今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/509.wav", + "text": "我是說你不能一天發明一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/510.wav", + "text": "因為今天你又發明一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/511.wav", + "text": "你以前有沒有講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/512.wav", + "text": "朝野協商是動態的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/513.wav", + "text": "你為什麼上個禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/514.wav", + "text": "可以在臉書發文罵朝野三黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/515.wav", + "text": "我是說你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/516.wav", + "text": "綁架總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/517.wav", + "text": "朝野你簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/518.wav", + "text": "你在綁我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/519.wav", + "text": "不是他明明知道但是又體恤你總召的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/520.wav", + "text": "才會有今天的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/521.wav", + "text": "已經簽了你們才說不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/522.wav", + "text": "平均地權條例綁總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/523.wav", + "text": "我昨天還是跟他講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/524.wav", + "text": "故意要跟人家吵架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/525.wav", + "text": "的他也在駡我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/526.wav", + "text": "哪有說執政黨今天要講你好話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/527.wav", + "text": "不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/528.wav", + "text": "朝野有攻防但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/529.wav", + "text": "你不要你也罵我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/530.wav", + "text": "柯建銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/531.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/532.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/533.wav", + "text": "其實今天國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/534.wav", + "text": "提出這個並不是要卡你們的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/535.wav", + "text": "上禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/536.wav", + "text": "延會的協商裡我們提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/537.wav", + "text": "先處理特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/538.wav", + "text": "條例再處理總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/539.wav", + "text": "讓我們總召講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/540.wav", + "text": "你們如果繼續這樣我就喊休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/541.wav", + "text": "超過10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/542.wav", + "text": "了柯總召不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/543.wav", + "text": "精簡一點好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/544.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/545.wav", + "text": "我接續剛才謝衣鳯講的一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/546.wav", + "text": "你們沒有卡我們總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/547.wav", + "text": "我們這個一定要把總預算一起來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/548.wav", + "text": "9日以前一定會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/549.wav", + "text": "朝野協商不是簽過了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/550.wav", + "text": "你說1月16日到19好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/551.wav", + "text": "19日以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/552.wav", + "text": "總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/553.wav", + "text": "是120案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/554.wav", + "text": "已經簽給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/555.wav", + "text": "還沒簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/556.wav", + "text": "19日已經寫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/557.wav", + "text": "我講白了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/558.wav", + "text": "民眾黨已經在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/559.wav", + "text": "總預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/560.wav", + "text": "朝野協商簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/561.wav", + "text": "就是看你們簽不簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/562.wav", + "text": "我們有一個但書19日以後一定會過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/563.wav", + "text": "間要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/564.wav", + "text": "我們可以談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/565.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/566.wav", + "text": "沒有這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/567.wav", + "text": "你不要對在野黨的黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/568.wav", + "text": "指指點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/569.wav", + "text": "啦這一點我不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/570.wav", + "text": "第一輪還沒有發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/571.wav", + "text": "說年底要發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/572.wav", + "text": "你剛才也說年底要發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/573.wav", + "text": "我們說的話要穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/574.wav", + "text": "嘛我們儘量往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/575.wav", + "text": "走到哪裡算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/576.wav", + "text": "我也可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/577.wav", + "text": "雖然大家簽完名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/578.wav", + "text": "就交付委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/579.wav", + "text": "好好審查沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/580.wav", + "text": "但是我們儘量用比較有誠意的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/581.wav", + "text": "照程序來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/582.wav", + "text": "各位什麼事情都可以談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/583.wav", + "text": "今天我們不要讓全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/584.wav", + "text": "全國民眾誤會認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/585.wav", + "text": "這是不可能的事情我們必須要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/586.wav", + "text": "任\n第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/587.wav", + "text": "我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/588.wav", + "text": "如果你們想要好好審查大家都是可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/589.wav", + "text": "都無濟於事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/590.wav", + "text": "啦因為各位要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/591.wav", + "text": "你現在問這個部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/592.wav", + "text": "可能內閣改組後他就不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/593.wav", + "text": "現在還有二個部會首長還沒補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/594.wav", + "text": "齊所以比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/595.wav", + "text": "負責的應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/596.wav", + "text": "下會期再來好好審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/597.wav", + "text": "這都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/598.wav", + "text": "本必須送委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/599.wav", + "text": "啦我們好好來談都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/600.wav", + "text": "但是礙於法律程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/601.wav", + "text": "最後大家要對決的就是所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/602.wav", + "text": "發現金這也有可能我們都要尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/603.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/604.wav", + "text": "把負債先補一補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/605.wav", + "text": "每一黨各有主張他們也可以提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/606.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/607.wav", + "text": "但是我們要保留給人家提修正案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/608.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得要實際一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/609.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嘛要怎麼談都可以談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/610.wav", + "text": "但是總預算一定要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/611.wav", + "text": "我們就可以好好來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/612.wav", + "text": "我昨天有去拜會邱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/613.wav", + "text": "我們改一改之後他們只剩下1個案子要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/614.wav", + "text": "十幾個案子現在當事人已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/615.wav", + "text": "就縮為一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/616.wav", + "text": "如果講得通就講講不通就算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/617.wav", + "text": "了所以大家可以收斂起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/618.wav", + "text": "我們下會期好好來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/619.wav", + "text": "我都沒有問題改付委好好審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/620.wav", + "text": "院長可不可以請國民黨釐清一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/621.wav", + "text": "你們現在的主張是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/622.wav", + "text": "行政院版付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/623.wav", + "text": "付委這很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/624.wav", + "text": "啊同樣一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/625.wav", + "text": "然後一個要逕付二讀一個要付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/626.wav", + "text": "完全不通的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/627.wav", + "text": "表示一下意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/628.wav", + "text": "邱臣遠總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/629.wav", + "text": "還有很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/630.wav", + "text": "郭委員有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/631.wav", + "text": "第一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/632.wav", + "text": "既然朝野協商有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/633.wav", + "text": "就應該照結論走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/634.wav", + "text": "實在是不宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/635.wav", + "text": "又推翻每次的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/636.wav", + "text": "不管用什麼理由跟藉口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/637.wav", + "text": "推翻朝野協商的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/638.wav", + "text": "第一個比方說我們花那麼多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/639.wav", + "text": "第一次延會朝野協商處理了4,700案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/640.wav", + "text": "都已經談完了要簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/641.wav", + "text": "那國民黨就找個理由說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/642.wav", + "text": "罵幹部所以就不簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/643.wav", + "text": "好那我們認了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/644.wav", + "text": "然後接下來這個禮拜又延會一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/645.wav", + "text": "延會的協商結論裡面很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/646.wav", + "text": "就是一次院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/647.wav", + "text": "定在院會之外的時間才能開委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/648.wav", + "text": "所以不要跟我講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/649.wav", + "text": "當時我們的協商結論沒有寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/650.wav", + "text": "如果稍微把相關的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/651.wav", + "text": "就很清楚是沒有委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/652.wav", + "text": "所以現在又要推翻上次朝野協商的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/653.wav", + "text": "銘宗總召又講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/654.wav", + "text": "我們19日留個半天來審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/655.wav", + "text": "沒有這個印象的話很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/656.wav", + "text": "另外寫一個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/657.wav", + "text": "19日半天只處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/658.wav", + "text": "保留的120案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/659.wav", + "text": "這樣就解決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/660.wav", + "text": "如果你願意這麼清楚地寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/661.wav", + "text": "那我們還有很多可以談的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/662.wav", + "text": "更不要講現在提出來所謂國民黨版逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/663.wav", + "text": "然後行政院版付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/664.wav", + "text": "這邊在審這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/665.wav", + "text": "兩個版��都過那怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/666.wav", + "text": "很奇怪啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/667.wav", + "text": "我們兩個版本都逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/668.wav", + "text": "兩個版本都逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/669.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/670.wav", + "text": "都聽你們講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/671.wav", + "text": "民眾黨也好時代力量也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/672.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/673.wav", + "text": "下午三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/674.wav", + "text": "然後各位有不同的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/675.wav", + "text": "希望延到隔天的中午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/676.wav", + "text": "剛剛民眾黨提出很多不同的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/677.wav", + "text": "時力也有一些反對或是新的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/678.wav", + "text": "你們都沒有提出特別條例啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/679.wav", + "text": "如果你們有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/680.wav", + "text": "應該提出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/681.wav", + "text": "嚴審我們可以提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/682.wav", + "text": "這有什麼好消遣的為什麼不能講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/683.wav", + "text": "我說的事實我又不是捏造的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/684.wav", + "text": "第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/685.wav", + "text": "第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/686.wav", + "text": "才是總召的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/687.wav", + "text": "你說要保留1天來處理總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/688.wav", + "text": "員也說要嚴審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/689.wav", + "text": "我跟幹事長的問題一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/690.wav", + "text": "就是哪個部分要嚴審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/691.wav", + "text": "是在嚴審預算不是在嚴審法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/692.wav", + "text": "法條不可能嚴審那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/693.wav", + "text": "你要有施行細則的概念還有子法的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/694.wav", + "text": "等等你想不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/695.wav", + "text": "的所以我所以我才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/696.wav", + "text": "其實朝野政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/697.wav", + "text": "也可以共同提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/698.wav", + "text": "提出法案的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/699.wav", + "text": "也可以不是不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/700.wav", + "text": "朝野協商也可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/701.wav", + "text": "可以處理啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/702.wav", + "text": "謝委員可以處理不是不能處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/703.wav", + "text": "我不是要跟你吵架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/704.wav", + "text": "我只是在說一個善意的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/705.wav", + "text": "這有好幾個方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/706.wav", + "text": "體諒在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/707.wav", + "text": "各位總召的心情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/708.wav", + "text": "反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/709.wav", + "text": "兩個版本都應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/710.wav", + "text": "嚴格去審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/711.wav", + "text": "\n我再講1分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/712.wav", + "text": "總預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/713.wav", + "text": "完全不是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/714.wav", + "text": "我感覺你這個都在黑龍繞桌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/715.wav", + "text": "總預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/716.wav", + "text": "平均地權條例之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/717.wav", + "text": "結果花敬群馬上就講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/718.wav", + "text": "過去買的都不算數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/719.wav", + "text": "這完全是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/720.wav", + "text": "我要跟你講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/721.wav", + "text": "總預算這個問題禮拜五的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/722.wav", + "text": "我們就說總預算應該要先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/723.wav", + "text": "是國民兩黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/724.wav", + "text": "硬要把這個條例插進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/725.wav", + "text": "才造成這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/726.wav", + "text": "那時候柯總召就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/727.wav", + "text": "是不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/728.wav", + "text": "你應該當場去駁斥他嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/729.wav", + "text": "結果搞到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/730.wav", + "text": "變成預算要跟著國民黨在走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/731.wav", + "text": "所以搞到最後才會有這個進退維谷的狀況嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/732.wav", + "text": "因為有外賓訪問本院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/733.wav", + "text": "我們先休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/734.wav", + "text": "繼續進行溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/735.wav", + "text": "溝通有結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/736.wav", + "text": "我們再來進行院會的處理程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14775/737.wav", + "text": "\n現在休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/0.wav", + "text": "有話就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1.wav", + "text": "延會這段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/2.wav", + "text": "朝野之間對於總預算及法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/3.wav", + "text": "到昨天為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/4.wav", + "text": "的\n總預算在禮拜二晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/5.wav", + "text": "第二輪協商完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/6.wav", + "text": ",721" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/7.wav", + "text": "案剩下120案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/8.wav", + "text": "我想大家印象還很深刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/9.wav", + "text": "那天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/10.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/11.wav", + "text": "刪減數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/12.wav", + "text": "及委辦經費相關的通案刪減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/13.wav", + "text": "比率都已經拿出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/14.wav", + "text": "應該是簽名後表決處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/15.wav", + "text": "我們看到一個新的題目也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/16.wav", + "text": "發現金的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/17.wav", + "text": "民進黨要發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/18.wav", + "text": "一再信誓旦旦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/19.wav", + "text": "總預算完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/20.wav", + "text": "各位都是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/21.wav", + "text": "非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/22.wav", + "text": "國家預算支出必須要有法源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/23.wav", + "text": "就和過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/24.wav", + "text": "特別預算的法源通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/25.wav", + "text": "這個時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/26.wav", + "text": "是非常科學的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/27.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/28.wav", + "text": "4天內就能夠發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/29.wav", + "text": "就能發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/30.wav", + "text": "如果柯建銘不會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/31.wav", + "text": "總召就讓你來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/32.wav", + "text": "請不要班門弄斧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/33.wav", + "text": "斧關公面前耍大刀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/34.wav", + "text": "為什麼這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/35.wav", + "text": "總要有法源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/36.wav", + "text": "嘛一定要有特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/37.wav", + "text": "這個禮拜送出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/38.wav", + "text": "政院在禮拜四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/39.wav", + "text": "通過院會也送出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/40.wav", + "text": "前後相差不到兩三天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/41.wav", + "text": "這當然要按照程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/42.wav", + "text": "講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/43.wav", + "text": "不要再烏龍轉桌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/44.wav", + "text": "做政治操作也是沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/45.wav", + "text": "的把責任推來推去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/46.wav", + "text": "也沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/47.wav", + "text": "每天都在直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/48.wav", + "text": "每天都在看電視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/49.wav", + "text": "不要以為臺灣的老百姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/50.wav", + "text": "看不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/51.wav", + "text": "民進黨不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/52.wav", + "text": "兩邊的條例都送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/53.wav", + "text": "來了今天是延會的最後一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/54.wav", + "text": "所以總預算先經過大家簽名以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/55.wav", + "text": "就表決完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/56.wav", + "text": "接著討論特別條例看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/57.wav", + "text": "是要延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/58.wav", + "text": "我都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/59.wav", + "text": "現在有兩個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/60.wav", + "text": "也可能有其他版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/61.wav", + "text": "聽說民眾黨也想送條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/62.wav", + "text": "看起來似乎是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/63.wav", + "text": "站在另外一個立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/64.wav", + "text": "檯面上講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/65.wav", + "text": "一一慎重表態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/66.wav", + "text": "我們來講程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/67.wav", + "text": "現在送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/68.wav", + "text": "國民黨是8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/69.wav", + "text": "我們是7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/70.wav", + "text": "要排除預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/71.wav", + "text": "公債法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/72.wav", + "text": "財政紀律法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/73.wav", + "text": "乃至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/74.wav", + "text": "採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/75.wav", + "text": "民進黨的版本都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/76.wav", + "text": "我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/77.wav", + "text": "元沒有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/78.wav", + "text": "今年7月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/79.wav", + "text": "決算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/80.wav", + "text": "那是看得到用不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/81.wav", + "text": "的公司賺多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/82.wav", + "text": "一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/83.wav", + "text": "董事會通過到股東大會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/84.wav", + "text": "那個是一定的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/85.wav", + "text": "我們現在排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/86.wav", + "text": "可以不必舉債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/87.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/88.wav", + "text": "我們是包括台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/89.wav", + "text": "韌性經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/90.wav", + "text": "扶持中小企業等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/91.wav", + "text": "發現金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/92.wav", + "text": "數字不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/93.wav", + "text": "0\n我們是整包3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/94.wav", + "text": "所以法的邏輯上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/95.wav", + "text": "和立法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/96.wav", + "text": "技術上完全不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/97.wav", + "text": "講可能的時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/98.wav", + "text": "即便臨時會處理也是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/99.wav", + "text": "兩個不一樣的法案進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/100.wav", + "text": "來可能有第三第四個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/101.wav", + "text": "案我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/102.wav", + "text": "但是至少檯面上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/103.wav", + "text": "我們3,800億的規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/104.wav", + "text": "是發現金600億還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/105.wav", + "text": "我們沒有在拚政治別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/106.wav", + "text": "你是經濟學博士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/107.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/108.wav", + "text": "即便召開臨時會頂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/109.wav", + "text": "付委以後逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/110.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀可以表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/111.wav", + "text": "一個月要4黨同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/112.wav", + "text": "請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/113.wav", + "text": "民眾黨會同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/114.wav", + "text": "請問時代力量會同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/115.wav", + "text": "即便同意這兩個版本要怎麼弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/116.wav", + "text": "一天講得出來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/117.wav", + "text": "\n講十天也講不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/118.wav", + "text": "到最後一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/119.wav", + "text": "預算送進來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/120.wav", + "text": "院長來備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/121.wav", + "text": "備詢以後這些預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/122.wav", + "text": "要不要付委一定會付委審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/123.wav", + "text": "我相信很難排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/124.wav", + "text": "朝野協商一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/125.wav", + "text": "在政治立場上在野黨沒有不嚴審的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/126.wav", + "text": "這樣的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/127.wav", + "text": "過去前瞻其實走了三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/128.wav", + "text": "所以在2017年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/129.wav", + "text": "三次臨時會開到8月31日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/130.wav", + "text": "隔天9月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/131.wav", + "text": "立法院又開始報到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/132.wav", + "text": "中間我們看到國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/133.wav", + "text": "潑水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/134.wav", + "text": "文場武場大家一起對幹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/135.wav", + "text": "處理法案的過程是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/136.wav", + "text": "你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/137.wav", + "text": "照你的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/138.wav", + "text": "可以馬上發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/139.wav", + "text": "還有軟體的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/140.wav", + "text": "至少要一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/141.wav", + "text": "已經如火如荼的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/142.wav", + "text": "一通過它馬上發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/143.wav", + "text": "絕對沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/144.wav", + "text": "但是一個月內要把這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/145.wav", + "text": "全部設計好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/146.wav", + "text": "那是相當大的工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/147.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/148.wav", + "text": "我講一個最簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/149.wav", + "text": "曾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/150.wav", + "text": "即便第一關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/151.wav", + "text": "我們兩個版本不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/152.wav", + "text": "另外還有民眾黨和時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/153.wav", + "text": "馬上通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/154.wav", + "text": "總統公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/155.wav", + "text": "過年也結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/156.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/157.wav", + "text": "的面對社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/158.wav", + "text": "不要一直把老百姓當作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/159.wav", + "text": "是可以操縱玩弄的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/160.wav", + "text": "在臺灣的天空" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/161.wav", + "text": "一直蔓延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/162.wav", + "text": "最後受傷的是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/163.wav", + "text": "要欺騙老百姓的政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/164.wav", + "text": "我們是一個非常負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/165.wav", + "text": "能夠快儘量快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/166.wav", + "text": "我講過一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/167.wav", + "text": "只要能夠快儘量快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/168.wav", + "text": "但今天要如何樂為呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/169.wav", + "text": "\n最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/170.wav", + "text": "我還是要跟大家講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/171.wav", + "text": "國民黨今天之所以這樣突然翻盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/172.wav", + "text": "當然我們能夠瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/173.wav", + "text": "天經地義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/174.wav", + "text": "又何況現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/175.wav", + "text": "閣揆可能要換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/176.wav", + "text": "禮拜天黨主席選完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/177.wav", + "text": "我們所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/178.wav", + "text": "換不換是總統的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/179.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法在這邊評斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/180.wav", + "text": "這段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/181.wav", + "text": "國民黨看到民進黨有很多的政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/182.wav", + "text": "工程要進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/183.wav", + "text": "所以馬上見縫插針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/184.wav", + "text": "就給你總預算不簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/185.wav", + "text": "嘛這樣的一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/186.wav", + "text": "政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/187.wav", + "text": "違背過去的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/188.wav", + "text": "這種政治操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/189.wav", + "text": "坦白講是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/190.wav", + "text": "非常惡劣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/191.wav", + "text": "而且司馬昭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/192.wav", + "text": "之心路人皆知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/193.wav", + "text": "我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/194.wav", + "text": "在上次選舉贏了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/195.wav", + "text": "頭要適可而止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/196.wav", + "text": "易經上有一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/197.wav", + "text": "退避才能保平安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/198.wav", + "text": "你以為你已經大贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/199.wav", + "text": "會讓你有想像不到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/200.wav", + "text": "結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/201.wav", + "text": "\n我在這裡非常誠懇的呼籲朝野各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/202.wav", + "text": "大家可以理性來談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/203.wav", + "text": "終究這是一個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/204.wav", + "text": "實際的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/205.wav", + "text": "我希望能夠秉持這次臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/206.wav", + "text": "20個重大法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/207.wav", + "text": "最後一哩路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/208.wav", + "text": "就是總預算只要6個鐘頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/209.wav", + "text": "6個鐘頭表決完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/210.wav", + "text": "時會就��開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/211.wav", + "text": "能夠走多久算多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/212.wav", + "text": "我們絕對奉陪到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/213.wav", + "text": "我都會尊重朝野黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/214.wav", + "text": "所以在這裡做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/215.wav", + "text": "最誠懇的呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/216.wav", + "text": "剛才議事組也把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/217.wav", + "text": "我們禮拜二晚上沒有簽的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/218.wav", + "text": "了懇請還沒簽的政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/219.wav", + "text": "趕快簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/220.wav", + "text": "我聽說民眾黨要簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/221.wav", + "text": "那這個球就在國民黨手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/222.wav", + "text": "結果還是枉然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/223.wav", + "text": "這樣搞有用嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/224.wav", + "text": "以上是我個人淺見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/225.wav", + "text": "請國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/226.wav", + "text": "讓延會功虧一簣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/227.wav", + "text": "我表示一下意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/228.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/229.wav", + "text": "前瞻基礎建設特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/230.wav", + "text": "我們黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/231.wav", + "text": "事實上有把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/232.wav", + "text": "包括前瞻特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/233.wav", + "text": "條例在內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/234.wav", + "text": "過去制定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/235.wav", + "text": "時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/236.wav", + "text": "等一下也可以給大家參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/237.wav", + "text": "前瞻8,400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/238.wav", + "text": "2017年3月23日行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/239.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/240.wav", + "text": "一讀會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/241.wav", + "text": "到最後三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/242.wav", + "text": "有關前瞻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/243.wav", + "text": "一讀是在2017年3月31日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/244.wav", + "text": "2017年7月5日總共近4個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/245.wav", + "text": "振興經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/246.wav", + "text": "消費券發放特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/247.wav", + "text": "是在2008年11月24日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/248.wav", + "text": "2008年11月28日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/249.wav", + "text": "這個條例的通過計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/250.wav", + "text": "13天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/251.wav", + "text": "新式戰機採購特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/252.wav", + "text": "於2019年9月20日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/253.wav", + "text": "至2019年10月28日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/254.wav", + "text": "三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/255.wav", + "text": "將近1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/256.wav", + "text": "嚴重特殊傳染性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/257.wav", + "text": "肺炎防治及紓困振興特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/258.wav", + "text": "2月20日經行政院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/259.wav", + "text": "隔天付一讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/260.wav", + "text": "是在2020年2月25日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/261.wav", + "text": "才6天這是最短的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/262.wav", + "text": "9月24日經行政院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/263.wav", + "text": "也在當天送至立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/264.wav", + "text": "11月23日大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/265.wav", + "text": "2個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/266.wav", + "text": "\n換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/267.wav", + "text": "只是要處理這個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/268.wav", + "text": "談到過去的幾個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/269.wav", + "text": "預算審查等因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/270.wav", + "text": "應該是一個不可能的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/271.wav", + "text": "特別指出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/272.wav", + "text": "就特別預算這個是在預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/273.wav", + "text": "憲法的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/274.wav", + "text": "否則預算法就失去其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/275.wav", + "text": "情事之一提出特別預算一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/276.wav", + "text": "國防緊急設施或戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/277.wav", + "text": "一次之重大政事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/278.wav", + "text": "事要合乎這四項才能提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/279.wav", + "text": "特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/280.wav", + "text": "做嚴格解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/281.wav", + "text": "依據監察院調查報告在109年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/282.wav", + "text": "已經出現了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/283.wav", + "text": "特別預算編列常態化的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/284.wav", + "text": "情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/285.wav", + "text": "即便要用這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/286.wav", + "text": "也應該要嚴格審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/287.wav", + "text": "及逐條討論以至三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/288.wav", + "text": "是3,800億不是3,800元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/289.wav", + "text": "元\n針對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/290.wav", + "text": "分享全民的經濟果實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/291.wav", + "text": "比如全民健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/292.wav", + "text": "減輕居住負擔及提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/293.wav", + "text": "居住品質加強照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/294.wav", + "text": "弱勢等方面包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/295.wav", + "text": "擴大公共運輸補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/296.wav", + "text": "但還是要進一步問及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/297.wav", + "text": "到底這個規劃為何在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/298.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣的情況之下叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/299.wav", + "text": "減輕居住負擔及提高居住品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/300.wav", + "text": "執政的行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/301.wav", + "text": "都必須清楚向立法院做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/302.wav", + "text": "所以就這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/303.wav", + "text": "我們認為應該從嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/304.wav", + "text": "從嚴審查並且要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/305.wav", + "text": "仔細地關照到各個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/306.wav", + "text": "代表及黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/307.wav", + "text": "鞭民眾黨黨團的立場非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/308.wav", + "text": "針對中央政府總預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/309.wav", + "text": "總預算的部分我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/310.wav", + "text": "主張要速審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/311.wav", + "text": "所以我們也呼籲各黨理性看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/312.wav", + "text": "我們同意今天來做相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/313.wav", + "text": "表決什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/314.wav", + "text": "預算好拍手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/315.wav", + "text": "還有120案其實這些都是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/316.wav", + "text": "民生法案包含個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/317.wav", + "text": "及勞動權益等問題我希望民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/318.wav", + "text": "還是要本著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/319.wav", + "text": "以蒼生為念以民眾為本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/320.wav", + "text": "就不要再擋了該通過就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/321.wav", + "text": "表決案的第一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/322.wav", + "text": "\n第二個重點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/323.wav", + "text": "我們的預算提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/324.wav", + "text": "提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/325.wav", + "text": "啦\n第二個就是針對特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/326.wav", + "text": "特別預算的編列和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/327.wav", + "text": "確實在預算法第83條當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/328.wav", + "text": "狀況的規定不管是國防上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/329.wav", + "text": "的需求經濟的變動還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/330.wav", + "text": "也有提到第4款的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/331.wav", + "text": "在這麼短的時間確實是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/332.wav", + "text": "我想大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/333.wav", + "text": "要重新回到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/334.wav", + "text": "當時在提出還稅於民的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/335.wav", + "text": "超徵4,500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/336.wav", + "text": "大家必須去思考的\n再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/337.wav", + "text": "我還是要表達一下我們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/338.wav", + "text": "已經將近一個月3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/339.wav", + "text": "禮拜了可是行政院行政怠惰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/340.wav", + "text": "昨天才以最後壓線的方式提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/341.wav", + "text": "出草案而且是包裹式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/342.wav", + "text": "當時談到的1,400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/343.wav", + "text": "各黨雖然都有各自的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/344.wav", + "text": "台電的虧損這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/345.wav", + "text": "的細節都還沒有出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/346.wav", + "text": "甚至是擴大租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/347.wav", + "text": "其實這個政策過去都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/348.wav", + "text": "失敗的案例我們不希望這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/349.wav", + "text": "政策買票的疑慮尤其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/350.wav", + "text": "現在內閣有可能要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/351.wav", + "text": "總辭或部分改組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/352.wav", + "text": "基於責任政治的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/353.wav", + "text": "這一個部分我們認為應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/354.wav", + "text": "揆確定之後再來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/355.wav", + "text": "不只是這1,400億要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/356.wav", + "text": "還稅於民另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/357.wav", + "text": "除了有太多的政策內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/358.wav", + "text": "和細節不明確各黨團可能也都還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/359.wav", + "text": "提出相對應的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/360.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/361.wav", + "text": "由院長召開朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/362.wav", + "text": "我們是主張在特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/363.wav", + "text": "審查上應該要從嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/364.wav", + "text": "過於粗糙淪為執政黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/365.wav", + "text": "橡皮圖章或是幫他們背書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/366.wav", + "text": "這個我們是不同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/367.wav", + "text": "超徵稅收常態化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/368.wav", + "text": "決策過程中是相對粗糙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/369.wav", + "text": "而且連續的髮夾彎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/370.wav", + "text": "我們不希望立法院做為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/371.wav", + "text": "後續幫他們背書的工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/372.wav", + "text": "所以民眾黨的態度非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/373.wav", + "text": "中央政府總預算我們支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/374.wav", + "text": "我們要求嚴審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/375.wav", + "text": "才能處理我們要求在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/376.wav", + "text": "2月1日報到之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/377.wav", + "text": "提早開議處理這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/378.wav", + "text": "\n所以在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/379.wav", + "text": "國家財政包含特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/380.wav", + "text": "預算常態化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/381.wav", + "text": "今年可能要邁向6兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/382.wav", + "text": "而且稅收超徵也呈常態化的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/383.wav", + "text": "我們認為這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/384.wav", + "text": "應該要更加細緻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/385.wav", + "text": "更加明確地討論包含未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/386.wav", + "text": "要如何定期等比例地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/387.wav", + "text": "撥補所謂世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/388.wav", + "text": "更明確更細緻地討論可是目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/389.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/390.wav", + "text": "所有本院同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/391.wav", + "text": "們都稱讚柯總召是認真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/392.wav", + "text": "人我相信今天與會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/393.wav", + "text": "各黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/394.wav", + "text": "全心全意的���出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/395.wav", + "text": "我相信這是大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/396.wav", + "text": "共同可以感受到的所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/397.wav", + "text": "柯總召不應該在剛才的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/398.wav", + "text": "謾罵我們國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/399.wav", + "text": "就是用了很多形容詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/400.wav", + "text": "我也有點忘記了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/401.wav", + "text": "我對於不好的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/402.wav", + "text": "我都很容易忘記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/403.wav", + "text": "但是我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/404.wav", + "text": "說的他認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/405.wav", + "text": "預算要速審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/406.wav", + "text": "但是我們知道今年度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/407.wav", + "text": "超過3,700億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/408.wav", + "text": "元現在又有一個特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/409.wav", + "text": "3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/410.wav", + "text": "元這裡面會不會有重複的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/411.wav", + "text": "我認為要一起審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/412.wav", + "text": "快要4年都快要畢業了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/413.wav", + "text": "我們對於大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/414.wav", + "text": "有充分的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/415.wav", + "text": "即便你用了很多形容詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/416.wav", + "text": "以後可以不要用形容詞我都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/417.wav", + "text": "你要講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/418.wav", + "text": "我們就可以儘速的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/419.wav", + "text": "就如同剛才民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/420.wav", + "text": "所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/421.wav", + "text": "對於這3,800億元包裹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/422.wav", + "text": "我認為朝野對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/423.wav", + "text": "勞健保以及用電補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/424.wav", + "text": "應該做充分的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/425.wav", + "text": "其實是有相當的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/426.wav", + "text": "1,800億元現金發放的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/427.wav", + "text": "大家也有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/428.wav", + "text": "最主要的就是在於1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/429.wav", + "text": "經濟社會韌性的提升上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/430.wav", + "text": "這個部分到底跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/431.wav", + "text": "今年度的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/432.wav", + "text": "有沒有高度重疊的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/433.wav", + "text": "我覺得大家應該要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/434.wav", + "text": "充分的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/435.wav", + "text": "尤其由行政單位提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/436.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分如果沒有提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/437.wav", + "text": "大家共同討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/438.wav", + "text": "這都是人民的納稅錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/439.wav", + "text": "我們如果重複的編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/440.wav", + "text": "浪費納稅錢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/441.wav", + "text": "額還稅於民就沒有意義了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/442.wav", + "text": "\n再來各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/443.wav", + "text": "都有政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/444.wav", + "text": "決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/445.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡的所有黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/446.wav", + "text": "不只在立法院有職務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/447.wav", + "text": "我相信絕大部分的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/448.wav", + "text": "在他們的政黨裡面都有職務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/449.wav", + "text": "每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/450.wav", + "text": "立委都身兼了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/451.wav", + "text": "各黨團的政黨職務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/452.wav", + "text": "但是政治工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/453.wav", + "text": "問題的解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/454.wav", + "text": "不能拿到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/455.wav", + "text": "所有臺灣民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/456.wav", + "text": "對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/457.wav", + "text": "你們自己解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/458.wav", + "text": "閣揆要誰你們自己回去解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/459.wav", + "text": "這是你們自己解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/460.wav", + "text": "的事我覺得邱臣遠剛才為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/461.wav", + "text": "還要幫你們解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/462.wav", + "text": "還要等新閣揆上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/463.wav", + "text": "我們再來審這些特別預算特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/464.wav", + "text": "臺灣的民眾可以等嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/465.wav", + "text": "我們在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/466.wav", + "text": "就是在監督預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/467.wav", + "text": "監督這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/468.wav", + "text": "啊我們就是在審預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/469.wav", + "text": "啊這幾天以來我們拚死拚活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/470.wav", + "text": "大家共同來審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/471.wav", + "text": "困難幾乎是不可能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/472.wav", + "text": "任務但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/473.wav", + "text": "我們都做同學做3年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/474.wav", + "text": "是不是有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/475.wav", + "text": "大家共同以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/476.wav", + "text": "有效率的方式來審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/477.wav", + "text": "就有爭議有疑義的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/478.wav", + "text": "共同審理我們都願意接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/479.wav", + "text": "你們的3,800億元了不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/480.wav", + "text": "你們就退來審我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/481.wav", + "text": "更快啊是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/482.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/483.wav", + "text": "討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/484.wav", + "text": "接下來請李" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/485.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/486.wav", + "text": "郭國文委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/487.wav", + "text": "張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/488.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/489.wav", + "text": "都有登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/490.wav", + "text": "各黨團的幹部都在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/491.wav", + "text": "剛剛我稍微晚一點進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/492.wav", + "text": "但是我大概聽了一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/493.wav", + "text": "對於這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/494.wav", + "text": "特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/495.wav", + "text": "我只有用四個字來形容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/496.wav", + "text": "聽完大家的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/497.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/498.wav", + "text": "遙遙無期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/499.wav", + "text": "因為大家去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/500.wav", + "text": "舉以前的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/501.wav", + "text": "甚至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/502.wav", + "text": "我們現在講個超實際的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/503.wav", + "text": "行政院昨天通過的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/504.wav", + "text": "包山包海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/505.wav", + "text": "國民黨是主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/506.wav", + "text": "所以是2,350億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/507.wav", + "text": "假如是原本民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/508.wav", + "text": "講的6,000元的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/509.wav", + "text": "其實是1,400億元左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/510.wav", + "text": "現在行政院送來的是3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/511.wav", + "text": "元包山包海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/512.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/513.wav", + "text": "非常複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/514.wav", + "text": "按照大家剛剛的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/515.wav", + "text": "不好意思我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/516.wav", + "text": "9月大概都拿不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/517.wav", + "text": "因為又要嚴審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/518.wav", + "text": "又要包台電的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/519.wav", + "text": "又要包勞健保的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/520.wav", + "text": "民眾要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/521.wav", + "text": "還稅於民的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/522.wav", + "text": "大家就忘了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/523.wav", + "text": "其實不止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/524.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/525.wav", + "text": "各黨派的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/526.wav", + "text": "很早就提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/527.wav", + "text": "國民黨當時就希望趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/528.wav", + "text": "\n但是柯總召在內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/529.wav", + "text": "行政院就始終不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/530.wav", + "text": "一直拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/531.wav", + "text": "拖到昨天的行政院院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/532.wav", + "text": "講白了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/533.wav", + "text": "按照我們原來的會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/534.wav", + "text": "並沒有去考量那麼多政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/535.wav", + "text": "也沒有去盤算什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/536.wav", + "text": "閣揆換不換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/537.wav", + "text": "那不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/538.wav", + "text": "而重點是朝野政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/539.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣來回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/540.wav", + "text": "民意的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/541.wav", + "text": "連踏一步都不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/542.wav", + "text": "踏出一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/543.wav", + "text": "喔大家剛剛都講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/544.wav", + "text": "這個條例多複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/545.wav", + "text": "假如說連踏出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/546.wav", + "text": "一步都不願意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/547.wav", + "text": "就一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/548.wav", + "text": "我就是要這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/549.wav", + "text": "啦然後現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/550.wav", + "text": "還稅於民連一步都不願意踏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/551.wav", + "text": "也講了一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/552.wav", + "text": "民眾聽不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/553.wav", + "text": "為什麼會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/554.wav", + "text": "變成這麼複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/555.wav", + "text": "這樣講不好意思跟國民黨無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/556.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/557.wav", + "text": "112年的中央政府總預算以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/558.wav", + "text": "你再來這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/559.wav", + "text": "這有緩急輕重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/560.wav", + "text": "你剛剛有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/561.wav", + "text": "今天處理總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/562.wav", + "text": "然後我們馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/563.wav", + "text": "16日以後來開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/564.wav", + "text": "處理特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/565.wav", + "text": "國民黨沒有高明到哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/566.wav", + "text": "但是你們不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/567.wav", + "text": "忘記法定的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/568.wav", + "text": "我不知道我們總召剛剛講了沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/569.wav", + "text": "其實中央政府總預算去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/570.wav", + "text": "前年通過的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/571.wav", + "text": "也有一月二十幾日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/572.wav", + "text": "沒差這幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/573.wav", + "text": "之前也罵我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/574.wav", + "text": "啊說我們什麼300多案的案海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/575.wav", + "text": "是案海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/576.wav", + "text": "大家在這邊拚來拚去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/577.wav", + "text": "其實現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/578.wav", + "text": "加8案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/579.wav", + "text": "秘密預算不過120案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/580.wav", + "text": "也是按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/581.wav", + "text": "原來預定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/582.wav", + "text": "時程走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/583.wav", + "text": "都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/584.wav", + "text": "真的很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/585.wav", + "text": "假如按照剛剛大家講的有這麼多問題的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/586.wav", + "text": "抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/587.wav", + "text": "我認為那真的是談不下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/588.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/589.wav", + "text": "通過這個條例以及後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/590.wav", + "text": "特別預算整個處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/591.wav", + "text": "再加上發放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/592.wav", + "text": "我直接講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/593.wav", + "text": "遙遙無期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/594.wav", + "text": "接下來請羅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/595.wav", + "text": "我承諾我不會有太多形容詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/596.wav", + "text": "我講的大概都是我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/597.wav", + "text": "的事實呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/598.wav", + "text": "還有整個論述的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/599.wav", + "text": "呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/600.wav", + "text": "我覺得國民黨的訴求看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/601.wav", + "text": "很簡單所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/602.wav", + "text": "先處理特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/603.wav", + "text": "再來處理中央政府總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/604.wav", + "text": "但它造成的問題與複雜的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/605.wav", + "text": "可能就會影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/606.wav", + "text": "兩個包括特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/607.wav", + "text": "加上中央政府總預算的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/608.wav", + "text": "理由很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/609.wav", + "text": "在12月底的朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/610.wav", + "text": "這次延會是到13日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/611.wav", + "text": "13日當時的承諾就是13日之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/612.wav", + "text": "完成中央政府總預算以及相關的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/613.wav", + "text": "這是當時的承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/614.wav", + "text": "如果今天到最後一天突然要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/615.wav", + "text": "翻掉之前的所有承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/616.wav", + "text": "那下一個承諾是不是突然在最後一天又被翻掉呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/617.wav", + "text": "所以至少聽到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/618.wav", + "text": "包括時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/619.wav", + "text": "包括民眾黨都承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/620.wav", + "text": "原來的那個承諾在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/621.wav", + "text": "也就是今天應該把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/622.wav", + "text": "中央政府總預算審完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/623.wav", + "text": "而為了讓今天能夠審完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/624.wav", + "text": "我們也做了很多努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/625.wav", + "text": "從4007百多案一直談到120案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/626.wav", + "text": "這個時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/627.wav", + "text": "我們已經處理掉三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/628.wav", + "text": "再往下大概中午就��以處理完就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/629.wav", + "text": "關係照這個速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/630.wav", + "text": "下禮拜我們有整整四天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/631.wav", + "text": "可以處理特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/632.wav", + "text": "為什麼不這麼做呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/633.wav", + "text": "突然插進這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/634.wav", + "text": "然後開始要複雜化整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/635.wav", + "text": "\n第二個關於120案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/636.wav", + "text": "大家都知道是很辛苦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/637.wav", + "text": "大家也互相釋出善意和誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/638.wav", + "text": "共識事實上本來在今天是可以順利處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/639.wav", + "text": "的如果處理完的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/640.wav", + "text": "基本上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/641.wav", + "text": "我們一定會承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/642.wav", + "text": "拜託院長馬上召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/643.wav", + "text": "來處理特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/644.wav", + "text": "而且是專心處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/645.wav", + "text": "雖然下禮拜看起來有四個工作天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/646.wav", + "text": "可是至少要留一天到半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/647.wav", + "text": "來處理你們所承諾的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/648.wav", + "text": "案除非你們是糊弄我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/649.wav", + "text": "總預算不處理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/650.wav", + "text": "只剩下兩個半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/651.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/652.wav", + "text": "好啦延會也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/653.wav", + "text": "嘛就算有三天好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/654.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/655.wav", + "text": "就算有三天好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/656.wav", + "text": "三個整天來處理這個條例處理得完嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/657.wav", + "text": "你們剛剛已經提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/658.wav", + "text": "各政黨之間對於這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/659.wav", + "text": "有些意見並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/660.wav", + "text": "你們對於發現金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/661.wav", + "text": "部分沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/662.wav", + "text": "是不是國民黨承諾三天可以處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/663.wav", + "text": "如果不是的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/664.wav", + "text": "萬一有任何政黨說要拉下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/665.wav", + "text": "那就要一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/666.wav", + "text": "加上剛才柯總召也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/667.wav", + "text": "就算立法院很快的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/668.wav", + "text": "三天內審完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/669.wav", + "text": "根據中央法規標準法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/670.wav", + "text": "是公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/671.wav", + "text": "三天後才生效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/672.wav", + "text": "就算再怎麼拚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/673.wav", + "text": "法案生效也是要等到過年後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/674.wav", + "text": "這不是要指定日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/675.wav", + "text": "我現在講的是即使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/676.wav", + "text": "再快的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/677.wav", + "text": "除非國民黨今天承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/678.wav", + "text": "下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/679.wav", + "text": "三天內審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/680.wav", + "text": "除了國民黨和行政院之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/681.wav", + "text": "可能民眾黨和時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/682.wav", + "text": "也有自己的版本要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/683.wav", + "text": "併案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/684.wav", + "text": "既然這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/685.wav", + "text": "那今天為什麼不專心處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/686.wav", + "text": "總預算呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/687.wav", + "text": "\n至於剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/688.wav", + "text": "和特別預算一起談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/689.wav", + "text": "才能看出來有沒有重複編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/690.wav", + "text": "審完總預算之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/691.wav", + "text": "如果發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/692.wav", + "text": "特別條例有些重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/693.wav", + "text": "這樣才對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/694.wav", + "text": "這個為什麼不能做呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/695.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這些都是藉口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/696.wav", + "text": "和理由啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/697.wav", + "text": "因為你們到時候如果整體包裹通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/698.wav", + "text": "不會啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/699.wav", + "text": "因為還要審預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/700.wav", + "text": "因為後面還要審預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/701.wav", + "text": "就可以通過多少預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/702.wav", + "text": "還要審預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/703.wav", + "text": "不要吵不要吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/704.wav", + "text": "我來講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/705.wav", + "text": "特別條例通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/706.wav", + "text": "預算編列進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/707.wav", + "text": "你們一看預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/708.wav", + "text": "有重複的地方把它刪掉就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/709.wav", + "text": "啊這是後面的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/710.wav", + "text": "你們可以全部都通過啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/711.wav", + "text": "我現在是理性在跟你討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/712.wav", + "text": "要什麼就可以有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/713.wav", + "text": "換我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/714.wav", + "text": "輪流一下嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/715.wav", + "text": "等一下嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/716.wav", + "text": "換我不要緊啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/717.wav", + "text": "很認真聽你們講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/718.wav", + "text": "老柯你講幾次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/719.wav", + "text": "院長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/720.wav", + "text": "曾總召聽我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/721.wav", + "text": "郭委員發言之後是張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/722.wav", + "text": "邱顯智委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/723.wav", + "text": "各黨團的三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/724.wav", + "text": "剛剛國民黨有一點誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/725.wav", + "text": "誤會在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/726.wav", + "text": "民眾黨也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/727.wav", + "text": "他們的態度很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/728.wav", + "text": "基本上他們傾向分開處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/729.wav", + "text": "至於分開處理的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/730.wav", + "text": "定期會就處理年度預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/731.wav", + "text": "如果再延會或開臨時會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/732.wav", + "text": "這個態度是他們剛剛講出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/733.wav", + "text": "的假設現在混在一起要嚴審的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/734.wav", + "text": "會變成遙遙無期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/735.wav", + "text": "輕重緩急的狀況來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/736.wav", + "text": "年度預算的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/737.wav", + "text": "遠遠大過於特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/738.wav", + "text": "接下來要編列的3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/739.wav", + "text": "所以從重要性來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/740.wav", + "text": "這個當然要先通過啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/741.wav", + "text": "預算會不會有重複的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/742.wav", + "text": "預算重複的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/743.wav", + "text": "也不是現在才會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/744.wav", + "text": "是之後特別預算送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/745.wav", + "text": "才會知道有沒有重複的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/746.wav", + "text": "我們現階段先通過這個年度預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/747.wav", + "text": "我們花了這麼多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/748.wav", + "text": "在處理這個年度預算的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/749.wav", + "text": "處理完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/750.wav", + "text": "我們要加速這個特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/751.wav", + "text": "再處理特別預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/752.wav", + "text": "就可以依序來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/753.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們幹事長已經講得非常清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/754.wav", + "text": "認為有比較好的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/755.wav", + "text": "這個也不妨礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/756.wav", + "text": "至少我們先通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/757.wav", + "text": "那沒有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/758.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/759.wav", + "text": "你要先休息喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/760.wav", + "text": "你要休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/761.wav", + "text": "我這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/762.wav", + "text": "呀我們3個都跟你不一樣意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/763.wav", + "text": "就國民黨跟我們不一樣而已啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/764.wav", + "text": "事實是你有不同的意見啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/765.wav", + "text": "沒關係要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/766.wav", + "text": "要論理嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/767.wav", + "text": "為什麼我講到一半你就插嘴呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/768.wav", + "text": "為什麼講到一半你就插嘴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/769.wav", + "text": "就休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/770.wav", + "text": "你就要嗆聲我跟你講話你就要嗆聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/771.wav", + "text": "你就是準備來嗆聲的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/772.wav", + "text": "好休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/773.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠如期地把中央政府總預算審查完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/774.wav", + "text": "坦白說這件事是這樣就是大家真的努力了很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/775.wav", + "text": "其實我知道在座這邊所有的大概都曾經挑燈夜戰過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/776.wav", + "text": "所以這是為什麼民眾黨黨團還是認為我們先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/777.wav", + "text": "\n但是另外一個東西就是這一次我們也希望大家能夠取得一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/778.wav", + "text": "就是關於特別條例這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/779.wav", + "text": "當然民眾黨這邊也是沒有問題可以配合大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/780.wav", + "text": "甚至直白說其實再加長甚至開到過年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/781.wav", + "text": "反正如果能夠儘速我們當然也完全支持這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/782.wav", + "text": "的特別緊急等等因素也就是第83條講的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/783.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是要給國人比較明確的交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/784.wav", + "text": "我們一直比較期待的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/785.wav", + "text": "其實在這裡面我們並沒有看到真正對於債務的償還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/786.wav", + "text": "它到底有沒有機會讓經濟果實真的更均等地回到國民身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/787.wav", + "text": "這個可能是我們比較在乎的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/788.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是有很多很多值得商榷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/789.wav", + "text": "我覺得如果我們能兩全其美就是今天不管是總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/790.wav", + "text": "審查就算下禮拜一要開始也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/791.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是我們黨支持的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/792.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/793.wav", + "text": "3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/794.wav", + "text": "這3,800億要用在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/795.wav", + "text": "強化經濟社會韌性及全民共享經濟成果之執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/796.wav", + "text": "我要問柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/797.wav", + "text": "我要告訴大家不到400個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/798.wav", + "text": "不到400個字要花3,800億要怎麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/799.wav", + "text": "坦白講我是很擔心很憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/800.wav", + "text": "誠如剛剛張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/801.wav", + "text": "講的沒有一個字交代要還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/802.wav", + "text": "全部都不是用來還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/803.wav", + "text": "如果要使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/804.wav", + "text": "包裹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/805.wav", + "text": "這些業務的執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/806.wav", + "text": "是規定在特別條例第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/807.wav", + "text": "發放相關業務或是執行的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/808.wav", + "text": "都會產生很多的不公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/809.wav", + "text": "沒有經過委員會質詢怎麼講得清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/810.wav", + "text": "你說的400個字是從哪裡開始算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/811.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/812.wav", + "text": "第2款到第7款1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/813.wav", + "text": "第8款及第9款1,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/814.wav", + "text": "這邊很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/815.wav", + "text": "不要故意說好像我對錢多少都不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/816.wav", + "text": "現在這些錢怎麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/817.wav", + "text": "如果沒有經過委員會這麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/818.wav", + "text": "如果不是還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/819.wav", + "text": "但要怎麼用也是要透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/820.wav", + "text": "委員會的質詢說明後再好好使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/821.wav", + "text": "是不是要包裹在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/822.wav", + "text": "我想大家還是要理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/823.wav", + "text": "為預算把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/824.wav", + "text": "這是立法院該盡的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/825.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/826.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/827.wav", + "text": "時曾銘宗總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/828.wav", + "text": "說不協商總預算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/829.wav", + "text": "今天好不容易轉圜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/830.wav", + "text": "政治性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/831.wav", + "text": "回到400多案表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/832.wav", + "text": "第一個對國人來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/833.wav", + "text": "畢竟公務部門的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/834.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/835.wav", + "text": "所以這還是不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/836.wav", + "text": "待會兒我也很想要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/837.wav", + "text": "一百零多個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/838.wav", + "text": "公務員以及相關的施政作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/839.wav", + "text": "必須要共同處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/840.wav", + "text": "\n再者有關特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/841.wav", + "text": "我看了這7條特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/842.wav", + "text": "用語不受法制上相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/843.wav", + "text": "規範就貿然送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/844.wav", + "text": "不管延會與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/845.wav", + "text": "這個要嚴審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/846.wav", + "text": "出於以下幾個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/847.wav", + "text": "第一個第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/848.wav", + "text": "每一條的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/849.wav", + "text": "都被無限地延伸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/850.wav", + "text": "想像的空間很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/851.wav", + "text": "這是不好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/852.wav", + "text": "畢竟就只有3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/853.wav", + "text": "元畢竟只有蔡總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/854.wav", + "text": "定調的四大面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/855.wav", + "text": "我看很多執政黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/856.wav", + "text": "或者是其他黨團都在加碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/857.wav", + "text": "都在講一些延伸性的想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/858.wav", + "text": "都在開始複製之前講的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/859.wav", + "text": "議題好像可以解救國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/860.wav", + "text": "解救大家於水深火熱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/861.wav", + "text": "這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/862.wav", + "text": "明明就不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/863.wav", + "text": "所以這七條必須要在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/864.wav", + "text": "匡定及確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/865.wav", + "text": "主責機關是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/866.wav", + "text": "現在的施行辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/867.wav", + "text": "及執行期程是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/868.wav", + "text": "因為整個是到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/869.wav", + "text": "2025年12月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/870.wav", + "text": "如果明年度又發生第二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/871.wav", + "text": "可以再加碼嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/872.wav", + "text": "給我們上了很多課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/873.wav", + "text": "一來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/874.wav", + "text": "元再逐年到4,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/875.wav", + "text": "元對於政治性的操作跟調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/876.wav", + "text": "我也要請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/877.wav", + "text": "會不會有如是狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/878.wav", + "text": "請兩位總召給我們釋疑一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/879.wav", + "text": "你最後一個問題是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/880.wav", + "text": "你不是一下就可以聽懂我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/881.wav", + "text": "當時我們的紓困條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/882.wav", + "text": "不是2,400億元嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/883.wav", + "text": "(2020年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/884.wav", + "text": "在所謂的增長上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/885.wav", + "text": "這次24個字的全民共享條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/886.wav", + "text": "是訂死3,800億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/887.wav", + "text": "還是明年也有發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/888.wav", + "text": "可以用同條例再去提高它的額度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/889.wav", + "text": "這要講清楚說明白好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/890.wav", + "text": "現在請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/891.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/892.wav", + "text": "不好意思我不是點名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/893.wav", + "text": "沒關係謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/894.wav", + "text": "其實在座的每位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/895.wav", + "text": "也代表各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/896.wav", + "text": "都希望把事情做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/897.wav", + "text": "我有幾點說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/898.wav", + "text": "第一點羅致政委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/899.wav", + "text": "本來就講好要簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/900.wav", + "text": "我們本來準備簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/901.wav", + "text": "開記者會來罵我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/902.wav", + "text": "啊我們那麼配合你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/903.wav", + "text": "你卻帶頭開記者會罵我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/904.wav", + "text": "在這種情況底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/905.wav", + "text": "我們還要簽下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/906.wav", + "text": "啊這是你自己闖的禍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/907.wav", + "text": "第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/908.wav", + "text": "柯總召剛剛一開始說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/909.wav", + "text": "關公面前耍大刀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/910.wav", + "text": "你不是關公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/911.wav", + "text": "本人也不會耍大刀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/912.wav", + "text": "國民黨的主張是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/913.wav", + "text": "第一個看這個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/914.wav", + "text": "務必要延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/915.wav", + "text": "延會先審特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/916.wav", + "text": "日或者是到過年期間我們也奉陪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/917.wav", + "text": "但保留1天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/918.wav", + "text": "來完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/919.wav", + "text": "112年度的特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/920.wav", + "text": "各位很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/921.wav", + "text": "你把資料調出來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/922.wav", + "text": "在月底通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/923.wav", + "text": "跟歷年比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/924.wav", + "text": "的你們不要再罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/925.wav", + "text": "國民黨讓預算d" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/926.wav", + "text": "ay再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/927.wav", + "text": "都符合慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/928.wav", + "text": "在這樣的前提下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/929.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/930.wav", + "text": "主張要先審查特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/931.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛謝委員說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/932.wav", + "text": "現在又送來3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/933.wav", + "text": "其中有沒有什麼重複的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/934.wav", + "text": "當然要好好審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/935.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/936.wav", + "text": "回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/937.wav", + "text": "全民的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/938.wav", + "text": "大家期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/939.wav", + "text": "趕快發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/940.wav", + "text": "在年前已經來不及了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/941.wav", + "text": "但總是要儘快嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/942.wav", + "text": "各位很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/943.wav", + "text": "不然下會期開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/944.wav", + "text": "還要總質詢當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/945.wav", + "text": "委員會選出來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/946.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/947.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/948.wav", + "text": "還有一個楊姓的民眾打電話來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/949.wav", + "text": "趕快發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/950.wav", + "text": "他們需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/951.wav", + "text": "這筆6,000元的現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/952.wav", + "text": "民眾嗷嗷待哺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/953.wav", + "text": "這是第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/954.wav", + "text": "回應民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/955.wav", + "text": "回應行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/956.wav", + "text": "羅秉成政務委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/957.wav", + "text": "還講希" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/958.wav", + "text": "希望我們立法院儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/959.wav", + "text": "特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/960.wav", + "text": "提行政院會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/961.wav", + "text": "第一段就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/962.wav", + "text": "2)年度全球經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/963.wav", + "text": "面對嚴峻挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/964.wav", + "text": "政府將以穩定經濟民生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/965.wav", + "text": "為最優先任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/966.wav", + "text": "行政院都這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/967.wav", + "text": "了我作為在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/968.wav", + "text": "最優先任務耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/969.wav", + "text": "國民黨是希望拼經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/970.wav", + "text": "拼民生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/971.wav", + "text": "所以我們把時間倒過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/972.wav", + "text": "先審這個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/973.wav", + "text": "有共識趕快過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/974.wav", + "text": "拚拚看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/975.wav", + "text": "拚到某個程度之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/976.wav", + "text": "真的沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/977.wav", + "text": "沒有共識就沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/978.wav", + "text": "嘛保留1天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/979.wav", + "text": "完成112年度總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/980.wav", + "text": "在1月29日之前通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/981.wav", + "text": "都沒有de" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/982.wav", + "text": "ay再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/983.wav", + "text": "這是國民黨提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/984.wav", + "text": "最理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/985.wav", + "text": "也最合乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/986.wav", + "text": "現在社會需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/987.wav", + "text": "也回應行政院的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/988.wav", + "text": "穩定經濟民生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/989.wav", + "text": "為最優先的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/990.wav", + "text": "你們民進黨不回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/991.wav", + "text": "讓國民黨來回應喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/992.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/993.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/994.wav", + "text": "我覺得現在這一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/995.wav", + "text": "真的是一個鬧劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/996.wav", + "text": "它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/997.wav", + "text": "的主要來源是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/998.wav", + "text": "主要來源是營利事業所得稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/999.wav", + "text": "營利事業所得稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1000.wav", + "text": "光是前11個月的實徵淨額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1001.wav", + "text": "元總共超徵了4,500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1002.wav", + "text": "政府在前年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1003.wav", + "text": "低估了臺灣的經濟景氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1004.wav", + "text": "跟企業的獲利能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1005.wav", + "text": "所以在電子業跟機械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1006.wav", + "text": "主計總處本來所編列的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1007.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼處理的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1008.wav", + "text": "其實政府最重要的功能是分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1009.wav", + "text": "普發現金給每一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1010.wav", + "text": "財富重分配的職能了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1011.wav", + "text": "所以基本上我們對這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1012.wav", + "text": "是持非常保留的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1013.wav", + "text": "要發現金給每個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1014.wav", + "text": "民進黨也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1015.wav", + "text": "不只支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1016.wav", + "text": "還把本來的普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1017.wav", + "text": "6,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1018.wav", + "text": "加碼變成3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1019.wav", + "text": "第3條裡面的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1020.wav", + "text": "超徵稅額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1021.wav", + "text": "現在鬧到最後變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1022.wav", + "text": "不只是普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1023.wav", + "text": "反而還要搞到3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1024.wav", + "text": "元搞到3,800億元之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1025.wav", + "text": "這個條例送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1026.wav", + "text": "我剛剛就講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1027.wav", + "text": "歷來的特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1028.wav", + "text": "特別條例是一個很嚴重的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1029.wav", + "text": "這在預算法上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1030.wav", + "text": "毋寧是一個例外中的又例外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1031.wav", + "text": "就是極端例外的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1032.wav", + "text": "所以你要非常謹慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1033.wav", + "text": "歷來的特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1034.wav", + "text": "傳染性肺炎防治及紓困振興條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1035.wav", + "text": "(因為它有非常緊急的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1036.wav", + "text": ")此外都是經過行政院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1037.wav", + "text": "我為何說這是一場鬧劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1038.wav", + "text": "我們誠實的說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1039.wav", + "text": "先不管中央政府總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1040.wav", + "text": "而去處理特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1041.wav", + "text": "過年前有辦法領到錢嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1042.wav", + "text": "持平來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1043.wav", + "text": "這是不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1044.wav", + "text": "大家都非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1045.wav", + "text": "這是不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1046.wav", + "text": "今天行政院送來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1047.wav", + "text": "內容已經到3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1048.wav", + "text": "元等於增加200多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1049.wav", + "text": "元要再做其他的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1050.wav", + "text": "然後寥寥數語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1051.wav", + "text": "的唯一方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1052.wav", + "text": "就是一讀之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1053.wav", + "text": "都不用經過委員會黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1054.wav", + "text": "統統都不用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1055.wav", + "text": "這樣對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1056.wav", + "text": "我們是絕對不可能接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1057.wav", + "text": "這是200多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1058.wav", + "text": "元每一分錢都是人民的血汗錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1059.wav", + "text": "不應該用的地方會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1060.wav", + "text": "所以這不是一個負責任的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1061.wav", + "text": "反而是中央政府總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1062.wav", + "text": "要怎麼運作的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1063.wav", + "text": "這應該要理性來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1064.wav", + "text": "至於這個條例怎麼解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1065.wav", + "text": "這個條例就是依照過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1066.wav", + "text": "怎麼解決就怎麼解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1067.wav", + "text": "啊就是要一讀會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1068.wav", + "text": "一讀會之後要委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1069.wav", + "text": "委員會之後要黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1070.wav", + "text": "廣泛討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1071.wav", + "text": "二讀逐條討論三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1072.wav", + "text": "讓一個嚴謹的立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1073.wav", + "text": "能夠順利進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1074.wav", + "text": "這才應該是一個理性面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1075.wav", + "text": "負責任的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1076.wav", + "text": "謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1077.wav", + "text": "我平常都非常尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1078.wav", + "text": "時代力量邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1079.wav", + "text": "在法律上的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1080.wav", + "text": "但是他剛才引出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1081.wav", + "text": "我覺得他可能只引用到部分學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1082.wav", + "text": "實際的經濟情況是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1083.wav", + "text": "雖然是在經濟擴張的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1084.wav", + "text": "我們知道內需產業有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1085.wav", + "text": "很多的餐廳旅宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1086.wav", + "text": "以及非常多的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1087.wav", + "text": "其實並沒有享受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1088.wav", + "text": "外銷產業的經濟擴張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1089.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們要在這時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1090.wav", + "text": "提出審查這個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1091.wav", + "text": "不是鬧劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1092.wav", + "text": "其實國民黨民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1093.wav", + "text": "都非常嚴肅地看待這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1094.wav", + "text": "我們在考驗自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1095.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法增加立法效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1096.wav", + "text": "我們是在考驗自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1097.wav", + "text": "所以才會在這裡要求延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1098.wav", + "text": "各黨團的幹部都非常認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1099.wav", + "text": "在這次的預算協商中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1100.wav", + "text": "大家也是花時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1101.wav", + "text": "的3,800億元預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1102.wav", + "text": "我們說了嘛有1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1103.wav", + "text": "跟台電虧損這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1104.wav", + "text": "這只是數字的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1105.wav", + "text": "大家都有共識了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1106.wav", + "text": "還有1,800億元發現金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1107.wav", + "text": "大家也有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1108.wav", + "text": "最重要的是1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1109.wav", + "text": "元提高經濟跟社會韌性的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1110.wav", + "text": "到底內容是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1111.wav", + "text": "我們都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1112.wav", + "text": "最後總統的結論而來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1113.wav", + "text": "要因應未來的變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1114.wav", + "text": "這實在非常模糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1115.wav", + "text": "在經濟情勢變動的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1116.wav", + "text": "到底要採取什麼樣的策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1117.wav", + "text": "這是不知的未知的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1118.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得大家是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1119.wav", + "text": "應該要朝向有共識的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1120.wav", + "text": "不要把它當作一場鬧劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1121.wav", + "text": "在完成一個不可能的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1122.wav", + "text": "大家來共同努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1123.wav", + "text": "如果提早通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1124.wav", + "text": "民進黨可以去解決你們的政治問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1125.wav", + "text": "各黨都有各黨的政治問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1126.wav", + "text": "可以去解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1127.wav", + "text": "但是民眾的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1128.wav", + "text": "一定要優先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1129.wav", + "text": "所以我們國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1130.wav", + "text": "絕對支持延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1131.wav", + "text": "即便超過了過年期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1132.wav", + "text": "只要在歷年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1133.wav", + "text": "總預算通過的期間內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1134.wav", + "text": "跟總預算的共同審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1135.wav", + "text": "我們國民黨都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1136.wav", + "text": "接下來請王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1137.wav", + "text": "個全民普發現金這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1138.wav", + "text": "到底對象是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1139.wav", + "text": "真的是全民嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1140.wav", + "text": "現在如果是外籍人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1141.wav", + "text": "在臺灣可能也可以發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1142.wav", + "text": "減輕人民經濟負擔的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1143.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1144.wav", + "text": "加碼在弱勢者的身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1145.wav", + "text": "我覺得這其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1146.wav", + "text": "我們看到特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1147.wav", + "text": "裡非常重要的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1148.wav", + "text": "才用特別條例來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1149.wav", + "text": "不過以剛才所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1150.wav", + "text": "嚴重特殊傳染性肺炎為例我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1151.wav", + "text": "當時的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1152.wav", + "text": "我們都花了6天來審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1153.wav", + "text": "我們明明就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1154.wav", + "text": "這次的特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1155.wav", + "text": "因為不只是條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1156.wav", + "text": "還有預算也必須要送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1157.wav", + "text": "如果是在這樣的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1158.wav", + "text": "其實延會就有點荒謬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1159.wav", + "text": "把這些事情處理掉的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1160.wav", + "text": "綁住總預算的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1161.wav", + "text": "我覺得是不宜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1162.wav", + "text": "讓總預算能夠先行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1163.wav", + "text": "大家真的覺得這個特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1164.wav", + "text": "及特別條例很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1165.wav", + "text": "就一路開下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1166.wav", + "text": "把預算也處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1167.wav", + "text": "大家趕快來普發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1168.wav", + "text": "如果兩大黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1169.wav", + "text": "支持普發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1170.wav", + "text": "而且要儘速解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1171.wav", + "text": "就應該朝這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1172.wav", + "text": "怎麼會是先審幾天然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1173.wav", + "text": "休息之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1174.wav", + "text": "再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1175.wav", + "text": "兩大黨所共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1176.wav", + "text": "要不要把條例處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1177.wav", + "text": "預算接著處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1178.wav", + "text": "不管開到幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1179.wav", + "text": "不管開幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1180.wav", + "text": "我們就是趕快處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1181.wav", + "text": "如果沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1182.wav", + "text": "善盡我們立法委員的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1183.wav", + "text": "所有的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1184.wav", + "text": "所有的財務分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1185.wav", + "text": "都應該要嚴格把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1186.wav", + "text": "不只是普發的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1187.wav", + "text": "把提綱裡的1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1188.wav", + "text": "元提高相關的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1189.wav", + "text": "等等這些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1190.wav", + "text": "現在看到只有短短的幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1191.wav", + "text": "用一個充足的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1192.wav", + "text": "好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1193.wav", + "text": "我覺得這才是對不起人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1194.wav", + "text": "所以我希望大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1195.wav", + "text": "還是能夠好好考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1196.wav", + "text": "一直僵持在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1197.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法往前進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1198.wav", + "text": "不管是總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1199.wav", + "text": "或者是特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1200.wav", + "text": "其實沒有太大的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1201.wav", + "text": "這才是對不起人民的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1202.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1203.wav", + "text": "我想看起來各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1204.wav", + "text": "歧見非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1205.wav", + "text": "大家都說要凝聚共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1206.wav", + "text": "但是看起來今天是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1207.wav", + "text": "沒有共識的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1208.wav", + "text": "還是表達一下我們的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1209.wav", + "text": "確實有非常多需要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1210.wav", + "text": "我們還是主張兩個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1211.wav", + "text": "應該要在二個基礎點上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1212.wav", + "text": "第一個就是要優先還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1213.wav", + "text": "第二個就是社會公益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1214.wav", + "text": "經濟果實的重分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1215.wav", + "text": "這個分配不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1216.wav", + "text": "只是民進黨單方面做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1217.wav", + "text": "所以這應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1218.wav", + "text": "還是要有一個嚴謹的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1219.wav", + "text": "我也要在這邊公開譴責行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1220.wav", + "text": "因為行政院的行政怠惰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1221.wav", + "text": "在整個還稅於民的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1222.wav", + "text": "最後才壓線送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1223.wav", + "text": "透過包裹式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1224.wav", + "text": "對此我們給予譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1225.wav", + "text": "其實這個早在上個禮拜前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1226.wav", + "text": "就可以提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1227.wav", + "text": "各黨都還有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1228.wav", + "text": "可以做更細緻的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1229.wav", + "text": "對於中央政府總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1230.wav", + "text": "我們還是主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1231.wav", + "text": "應該要儘快地完成速審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1232.wav", + "text": "是我們必須要去強調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1233.wav", + "text": "至於在延會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1234.wav", + "text": "在朝野協商上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1235.wav", + "text": "大家要取得一定程度的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1236.wav", + "text": "否則這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1237.wav", + "text": "基本上是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1238.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1239.wav", + "text": "不給我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1240.wav", + "text": "院長1分鐘就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1241.wav", + "text": "因為這次總預算保留的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1242.wav", + "text": "事實上也不是什麼爭議太大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1243.wav", + "text": "如果執政黨願意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1244.wav", + "text": "就全部通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1245.wav", + "text": "這是第一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1246.wav", + "text": "我回應一下謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1247.wav", + "text": "其實我們擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1248.wav", + "text": "不是我們的效率不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1249.wav", + "text": "而是怕行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1250.wav", + "text": "在1,000億元的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1251.wav", + "text": "是擔心短時間沒辦法好好地審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1252.wav", + "text": "我們支持陳委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1253.wav", + "text": "其實這樣的話今天就可以結束總預算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1254.wav", + "text": "你說什麼提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1255.wav", + "text": "執政黨只要不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1256.wav", + "text": "全部通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1257.wav", + "text": "就不要異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1258.wav", + "text": "120案就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1259.wav", + "text": "這是一個很好的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1260.wav", + "text": "對啊今天總預算就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1261.wav", + "text": "這樣也很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1262.wav", + "text": "也有人點名要我回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1263.wav", + "text": "我也很認真聽各位講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1264.wav", + "text": "剛才曾銘宗說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1265.wav", + "text": "他不是關公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1266.wav", + "text": "但我修正這���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1267.wav", + "text": "我願意就有道而正焉聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1268.wav", + "text": "聽大家講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1269.wav", + "text": "我來發表我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1270.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1271.wav", + "text": "臨時會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1272.wav", + "text": "另外也有附帶條件就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1273.wav", + "text": "不能表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1274.wav", + "text": "要全部投降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1275.wav", + "text": "我要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1276.wav", + "text": "法律上疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1277.wav", + "text": "的或是大家不同立場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1278.wav", + "text": "立法院從來沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1279.wav", + "text": "總預算大家都無異議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1280.wav", + "text": "這是不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1281.wav", + "text": "各黨有各黨的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1282.wav", + "text": "我知道陳椒華" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1283.wav", + "text": "一直在意某些事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1284.wav", + "text": "那是小事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1285.wav", + "text": "啊那是你在協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1286.wav", + "text": "要表決就是講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1287.wav", + "text": "講好的還可以再協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1288.wav", + "text": "是立法院的習近平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1289.wav", + "text": "我給你捧場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1290.wav", + "text": "的都是正辦的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1291.wav", + "text": "哪有說總預算不要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1292.wav", + "text": "全部通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1293.wav", + "text": "那我們在協商什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1294.wav", + "text": "各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1295.wav", + "text": "每個人的政治立場都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1296.wav", + "text": "而且我們之所以沒有辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1297.wav", + "text": "有的是與法律背離的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1298.wav", + "text": "你們提出有但書的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1299.wav", + "text": "即使今天要處理總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1300.wav", + "text": "但是這種但書我們也不會接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1301.wav", + "text": "所以我們要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1302.wav", + "text": "國民黨反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1303.wav", + "text": "剛才有人問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1304.wav", + "text": "包括賴香伶委員問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1305.wav", + "text": "這和我們的政治性工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1306.wav", + "text": "一點關係都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1307.wav", + "text": "不是我能夠瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1308.wav", + "text": "這是脫鉤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1309.wav", + "text": "絕對是脫鉤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1310.wav", + "text": "的你們不要想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1311.wav", + "text": "的\n第二個要回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1312.wav", + "text": "是各黨有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1313.wav", + "text": "其實邱顯智講得最清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1314.wav", + "text": "就是他們反對發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1315.wav", + "text": "邏輯很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1316.wav", + "text": "你支持我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1317.wav", + "text": "讚美別人是不會吝嗇的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1318.wav", + "text": "算是公正評價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1319.wav", + "text": "後面還有但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1320.wav", + "text": "他就是不贊成發現金的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1321.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1322.wav", + "text": "我們是贊成發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1323.wav", + "text": "還要增加經濟韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1324.wav", + "text": "跟國民黨差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1325.wav", + "text": "樣用我希望邏輯不要顛倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1326.wav", + "text": "他說不發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1327.wav", + "text": "他們的邏輯很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1328.wav", + "text": "不要發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1329.wav", + "text": "他們反對發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1330.wav", + "text": "這是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1331.wav", + "text": "的但是民眾黨就比較奇怪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1332.wav", + "text": "又要發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1333.wav", + "text": "還債就沒有發現金的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1334.wav", + "text": "大家審完的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1335.wav", + "text": "中央政府總預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1336.wav", + "text": "元錢從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1337.wav", + "text": "2021年決算過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1338.wav", + "text": "已經編列在裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1339.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1340.wav", + "text": "要發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1341.wav", + "text": "那我們就一併處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1342.wav", + "text": "增加經濟韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1343.wav", + "text": "還有將勞保健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1344.wav", + "text": "這是大家在邏輯上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1345.wav", + "text": "一定要搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1346.wav", + "text": "的不要讓他們互相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1347.wav", + "text": "國民黨比較麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1348.wav", + "text": "國民黨一方面主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1349.wav", + "text": "剛剛有民眾打電話來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1350.wav", + "text": "要趕快發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1351.wav", + "text": "這個比喻不大好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1352.wav", + "text": "他還提到羅秉成的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1353.wav", + "text": "羅秉成說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1354.wav", + "text": "優先解決經濟困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1355.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1356.wav", + "text": "行政院嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1357.wav", + "text": "你聽我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1358.wav", + "text": "民生為優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1359.wav", + "text": "不相違背的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1360.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1361.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1362.wav", + "text": "這根本不違背" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1363.wav", + "text": "所以我的看法是這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1364.wav", + "text": "顯智一直堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1365.wav", + "text": "這樣\n預算等於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1366.wav", + "text": "法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1367.wav", + "text": "憲法位階" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1368.wav", + "text": "這要搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1369.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1370.wav", + "text": "讓你聽不懂的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1371.wav", + "text": "一下又講到德國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1372.wav", + "text": "一下又講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1373.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1374.wav", + "text": "不主張發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1375.wav", + "text": "但是今天我們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1376.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1377.wav", + "text": "要求各黨一定要怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1378.wav", + "text": "我們都非常尊重各黨的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1379.wav", + "text": "在尊重各黨的立場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1380.wav", + "text": "我們都很清楚看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1381.wav", + "text": "即便這個條例送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1382.wav", + "text": "民眾黨可能會送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1383.wav", + "text": "時代力量不主張發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1384.wav", + "text": "就沒有所謂的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1385.wav", + "text": "版本名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1386.wav", + "text": "那是一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1387.wav", + "text": "邏輯要先搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1388.wav", + "text": "想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1389.wav", + "text": "反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1390.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1391.wav", + "text": "只要臨時會一開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1392.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1393.wav", + "text": "就可以表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1394.wav", + "text": "到這裡就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1395.wav", + "text": "因為如果要繼續往下走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1396.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1397.wav", + "text": "排除朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1398.wav", + "text": "野協商一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1399.wav", + "text": "不可能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1400.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1401.wav", + "text": "不可能的話就下課就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1402.wav", + "text": "提早開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1403.wav", + "text": "所以可能的路徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1404.wav", + "text": "可能的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1405.wav", + "text": "大家可以想像得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1406.wav", + "text": "即便開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1407.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1408.wav", + "text": "\n至於特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1409.wav", + "text": "所謂特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1410.wav", + "text": "並不是你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1411.wav", + "text": "太多了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1412.wav", + "text": "振興經濟方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1413.wav", + "text": "是特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1414.wav", + "text": "什麼都是特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1415.wav", + "text": "只要在財政紀律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1416.wav", + "text": "維持下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1417.wav", + "text": "都可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1418.wav", + "text": "我們還有舉債空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1419.wav", + "text": "但是都相當克制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1420.wav", + "text": "公債有15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1421.wav", + "text": "所以也不會再去舉債了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1422.wav", + "text": "我非常反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1423.wav", + "text": "常常講一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1424.wav", + "text": "騙人的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1425.wav", + "text": "什麼特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1426.wav", + "text": "沒有那麼嚴重啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1427.wav", + "text": "我沒有說你騙人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1428.wav", + "text": "沒有那麼嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1429.wav", + "text": "啦都會依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1430.wav", + "text": "如馬英九時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1431.wav", + "text": "擴大公共建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1432.wav", + "text": "元所以這一年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1433.wav", + "text": "特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1434.wav", + "text": "依法完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1435.wav", + "text": "這在第4款都可以處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1436.wav", + "text": "是不要講說鬧劇好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1437.wav", + "text": "立場不一樣可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1438.wav", + "text": "國民黨跟我立場也不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1439.wav", + "text": "但國民黨那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1440.wav", + "text": "比較傾向鬧劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1441.wav", + "text": "什麼你才是鬧劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1442.wav", + "text": "我們才沒有鬧劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1443.wav", + "text": "我剛才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1444.wav", + "text": "我們是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1445.wav", + "text": "為什麼被你說成鬧劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1446.wav", + "text": "你自己在自貶你要等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1447.wav", + "text": "我們希望喜劇收場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1448.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1449.wav", + "text": "因為國民黨說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1450.wav", + "text": "根本就做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1451.wav", + "text": "我說真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1452.wav", + "text": "我們今天要來講結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1453.wav", + "text": "我看大家的表情比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1454.wav", + "text": "今天講到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1455.wav", + "text": "必須要有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1456.wav", + "text": "他���可能做任何變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1457.wav", + "text": "有能力在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1458.wav", + "text": "贊成我們的意見馬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1459.wav", + "text": "我也體恤他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1460.wav", + "text": "柯總召我們是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1461.wav", + "text": "舉債發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1462.wav", + "text": "你不要講錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1463.wav", + "text": "你不要斷章取義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1464.wav", + "text": "你沒有在注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1465.wav", + "text": "的發現金沒有舉債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1466.wav", + "text": "時代力量的主張是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1467.wav", + "text": "所以你不要斷章取義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1468.wav", + "text": "讓外界誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1469.wav", + "text": "時代力量反對發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1470.wav", + "text": "還是要跟你講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1471.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1472.wav", + "text": "這裡面沒有舉債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1473.wav", + "text": "第二個你現在講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1474.wav", + "text": "坦白講我非常respect" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1475.wav", + "text": "他講話很精準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1476.wav", + "text": "我的主張是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1477.wav", + "text": "民進黨的鬧劇就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1478.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1479.wav", + "text": "你想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1480.wav", + "text": "你不要講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1481.wav", + "text": "你不要講話好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1482.wav", + "text": "民進黨沒有拿香跟著拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1483.wav", + "text": "民進黨是非常負責認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1484.wav", + "text": "看待每一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1485.wav", + "text": "我們面對所有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1486.wav", + "text": "這是我們執政的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1487.wav", + "text": "你假如拿我來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1488.wav", + "text": "當你的沙包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1489.wav", + "text": "你的聲量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1490.wav", + "text": "但你講到民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1491.wav", + "text": "講到民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1492.wav", + "text": "我一定跟他罵到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1493.wav", + "text": "我們希望喜劇停下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1494.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1495.wav", + "text": "結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1496.wav", + "text": "既然他們是黨團會議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1497.wav", + "text": "的他們不可能簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1498.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡講都沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1499.wav", + "text": "我們面對現實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1500.wav", + "text": "到底要延會還是臨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1501.wav", + "text": "會就現在講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1502.wav", + "text": "延會最簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1503.wav", + "text": "這一點有共識等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1504.wav", + "text": "到幾日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1505.wav", + "text": "到月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1506.wav", + "text": "16日到19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1507.wav", + "text": "我們都面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1508.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1509.wav", + "text": "啦你們剛才不是說不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1510.wav", + "text": "延會是要討論什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1511.wav", + "text": "我現在講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1512.wav", + "text": "我們這次是用延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1513.wav", + "text": "從16日到19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1514.wav", + "text": "這個大家先確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1515.wav", + "text": "就是召開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1516.wav", + "text": "今天要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1517.wav", + "text": "16日開議到19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1518.wav", + "text": "我們都面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1519.wav", + "text": "第一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1520.wav", + "text": "要討論特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1521.wav", + "text": "我也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1522.wav", + "text": "因為總預算沒有簽把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1523.wav", + "text": "擺前面也沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1524.wav", + "text": "我都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1525.wav", + "text": "很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1526.wav", + "text": "直接地面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1527.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1528.wav", + "text": "大家可以想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1529.wav", + "text": "臨時會一開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1530.wav", + "text": "總要有程序委員會吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1531.wav", + "text": "程序委員會開完之後正式開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1532.wav", + "text": "一起付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1533.wav", + "text": "他們反對就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1534.wav", + "text": "接下去要排除朝野協商一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1535.wav", + "text": "我們都審過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1536.wav", + "text": "紓困特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1537.wav", + "text": "也是在條例上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1538.wav", + "text": "排除朝野協商一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1539.wav", + "text": "但是他口頭上講預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1540.wav", + "text": "預算卡到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1541.wav", + "text": "所以進入法律程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1542.wav", + "text": "意就無法突破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1543.wav", + "text": "最後一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1544.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1545.wav", + "text": "下午來表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1546.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1547.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1548.wav", + "text": "我們就來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1549.wav", + "text": "後續程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1550.wav", + "text": "你剛剛的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1551.wav", + "text": "假如沒有延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1552.wav", + "text": "民進黨會提臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1553.wav", + "text": "剛剛的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1554.wav", + "text": "總預算呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1555.wav", + "text": "總預算一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1556.wav", + "text": "今天不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1557.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1558.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1559.wav", + "text": "我倒是要問一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1560.wav", + "text": "禮拜二晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1561.wav", + "text": "大家講好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1562.wav", + "text": "要簽的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1563.wav", + "text": "你們三黨都跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1564.wav", + "text": "了到現在你們也沒有簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1565.wav", + "text": "要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1566.wav", + "text": "還一直罵國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1567.wav", + "text": "這什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1568.wav", + "text": "不要黜臭他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1569.wav", + "text": "你不要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1570.wav", + "text": "講下去要開花了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1571.wav", + "text": "先說要不要買便當吃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1572.wav", + "text": "不用不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1573.wav", + "text": "正面面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1574.wav", + "text": "大家要有誠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1575.wav", + "text": "這不是鬧劇也不是什麼劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1576.wav", + "text": "各自解讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1577.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1578.wav", + "text": "你叫行政部門資料寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1579.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1580.wav", + "text": "要讓人怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1581.wav", + "text": "第3條說沒有400字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1582.wav", + "text": "所有過去的特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1583.wav", + "text": "條例就是講一個匡列的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1584.wav", + "text": "我是說它的說明沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1585.wav", + "text": "說明沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1586.wav", + "text": "你要逕付二讀就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1587.wav", + "text": "你自己想清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1588.wav", + "text": "從沒有到最後表決而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1589.wav", + "text": "就沒有所謂的說明喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1590.wav", + "text": "家要想清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1591.wav", + "text": "我們要嚴審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1592.wav", + "text": "的不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1593.wav", + "text": "所以現在就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1594.wav", + "text": "很直接面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1595.wav", + "text": "不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1596.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1597.wav", + "text": "總召說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1598.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀是可以表決的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1599.wav", + "text": "你不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1600.wav", + "text": "那是另外一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1601.wav", + "text": "表決的時候你們可以表態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1602.wav", + "text": "照法律程序來講就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1603.wav", + "text": "請院長裁示一下就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1604.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1605.wav", + "text": "是不是你先問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1606.wav", + "text": "現在有兩個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1607.wav", + "text": "我們討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1608.wav", + "text": "兩個選項先決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1609.wav", + "text": "是要延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1610.wav", + "text": "還是要開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1611.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1612.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1613.wav", + "text": "兩個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1614.wav", + "text": "院長我表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1615.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1616.wav", + "text": "我要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1617.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1618.wav", + "text": "一項一項來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1619.wav", + "text": "我先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1620.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1621.wav", + "text": "我先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1622.wav", + "text": "我們當然是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1623.wav", + "text": "因為這個涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1624.wav", + "text": "3,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1625.wav", + "text": "3,800億裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1626.wav", + "text": "除了發現金之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1627.wav", + "text": "其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1628.wav", + "text": "經濟韌性的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1629.wav", + "text": "談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1630.wav", + "text": "所以這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1631.wav", + "text": "要延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1632.wav", + "text": "還是臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1633.wav", + "text": "對啦延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1634.wav", + "text": "民眾黨的態度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1635.wav", + "text": "如果大家有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1636.wav", + "text": "我們贊成延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1637.wav", + "text": "但是我們反對逕付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1638.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1639.wav", + "text": "我們的態度是嚴審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1640.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1641.wav", + "text": "院長都要來備詢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1642.wav", + "text": "所以基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1643.wav", + "text": "延會我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1644.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1645.wav", + "text": "延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1646.wav", + "text": "應該是支持延會啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1647.wav", + "text": "不然怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1648.wav", + "text": "來先簽一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1649.wav", + "text": "處理兩個事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1650.wav", + "text": "第一個是時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1651.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1652.wav", + "text": "延到月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1653.wav", + "text": "時間沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1654.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1655.wav", + "text": "啊你聽他鬼扯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1656.wav", + "text": "要過年了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1657.wav", + "text": "要除夕了啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1658.wav", + "text": "16日到19日先決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1659.wav", + "text": "先寫起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1660.wav", + "text": "內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1661.wav", + "text": "內容就處理兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1662.wav", + "text": "總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1663.wav", + "text": "及特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1664.wav", + "text": "特別條例先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1665.wav", + "text": "第一個處理特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1666.wav", + "text": "第二個處理總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1667.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1668.wav", + "text": "其他就照議事程序處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1669.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1670.wav", + "text": "要簽啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1671.wav", + "text": "簽了就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1672.wav", + "text": "因為馬上要處理喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1673.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1674.wav", + "text": "是處理兩案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1675.wav", + "text": "先特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1676.wav", + "text": "再總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1677.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1678.wav", + "text": "還有一個啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1679.wav", + "text": "公務人員那個也要表決一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1680.wav", + "text": "就全部結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1681.wav", + "text": "面照程序照法律來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1682.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1683.wav", + "text": "不能說我要怎樣就怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1684.wav", + "text": "我最公道啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1685.wav", + "text": "立法院有一個大法官你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1686.wav", + "text": "你是關公喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1687.wav", + "text": "我是鍾馗啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1688.wav", + "text": "向大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1689.wav", + "text": "決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1690.wav", + "text": "一各黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1691.wav", + "text": "1月19日(星期四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1692.wav", + "text": "1月16日(星期一)至19日(星期四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1693.wav", + "text": "第16次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1694.wav", + "text": "並不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1695.wav", + "text": "臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1696.wav", + "text": "二第16次會議議程草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1697.wav", + "text": "逕送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1698.wav", + "text": "院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1699.wav", + "text": "議程報告事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1700.wav", + "text": "僅列第15次會議議事錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1701.wav", + "text": "行政院所提疫後強化經濟與社會韌性及全民共享經濟成果特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1702.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1703.wav", + "text": "稅收超徵全民共享發放特別條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1704.wav", + "text": "及各黨團委員提出之有關上開稅收超徵全民共享法案相關提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1705.wav", + "text": "請於1月13日(星期五)下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1706.wav", + "text": "3時前送至議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1707.wav", + "text": "逾時不予納入第16次會議議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1708.wav", + "text": "三討論事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1709.wav", + "text": "除上開法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1710.wav", + "text": "尚未完成處理之中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1711.wav", + "text": "112年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1712.wav", + "text": "算案及公務人員任用法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1713.wav", + "text": "意見第二點的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1714.wav", + "text": "我們認為收案期間太短了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1715.wav", + "text": "你寫一下很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1716.wav", + "text": "明天下午啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1717.wav", + "text": "下午可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1718.wav", + "text": "明天下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1719.wav", + "text": "柯總召不是說明天下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1720.wav", + "text": "明天下午啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1721.wav", + "text": "禮拜一早上啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1722.wav", + "text": "不是禮拜一早上來不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1723.wav", + "text": "明天下午啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1724.wav", + "text": "明天下午叫院長秘書長這邊安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1725.wav", + "text": "有人去收案就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1726.wav", + "text": "收案而已嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1727.wav", + "text": "加班費要發喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1728.wav", + "text": "1月14日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1729.wav", + "text": "星期六)下午5時前好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1730.wav", + "text": "1月14日下午5時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1731.wav", + "text": "其實這個條例真的要做很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1732.wav", + "text": "只是看你怎麼做嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1733.wav", + "text": "我不相信他寫得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1734.wav", + "text": "分要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1735.wav", + "text": "還有其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1736.wav", + "text": "啦要不要講先處理特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1737.wav", + "text": "你們不簽也沒辦法處理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1738.wav", + "text": "我在這裡先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1739.wav", + "text": "先處理特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1740.wav", + "text": "一定是要調整到你甘願嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1741.wav", + "text": "不要再折磨我們嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1742.wav", + "text": "已經改成1月14日下午5時前這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1743.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1744.wav", + "text": "我要先簽那一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1745.wav", + "text": "我這一張是先處理總預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1746.wav", + "text": "這一張是鬧劇版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1747.wav", + "text": "喜劇收場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1748.wav", + "text": "好啦高興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1749.wav", + "text": "高興就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1750.wav", + "text": "啦恭禧發財啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1751.wav", + "text": "兔年行大運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1752.wav", + "text": "下午就不用開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1753.wav", + "text": "大家看到這個就自動解散了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1754.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1755.wav", + "text": "名了下午院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1756.wav", + "text": "我們可能要下去唸協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1757.wav", + "text": "另外針對中華民國總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1758.wav", + "text": "所以今天會下一個決議訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1759.wav", + "text": "訂於下次會議處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1760.wav", + "text": "至於公務人員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1761.wav", + "text": "也是下次會議去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1762.wav", + "text": "我們就可以散會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1763.wav", + "text": "下午5時前提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1764.wav", + "text": "\n延會要簽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1765.wav", + "text": "院會禮拜一要簽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1766.wav", + "text": "然後就處理報告事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1767.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1768.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1769.wav", + "text": "條例怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1770.wav", + "text": "這麼快就有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1771.wav", + "text": "不可能一天就通過拚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1772.wav", + "text": "那是不可能的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1773.wav", + "text": "下午院會照常開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1774.wav", + "text": "要唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1775.wav", + "text": "院長你做你的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1776.wav", + "text": "跟他們沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1777.wav", + "text": "要讓大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1778.wav", + "text": "今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1779.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1780.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1781.wav", + "text": "沒意見就散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14772/1782.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/0.wav", + "text": "我跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/2.wav", + "text": "現在開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/3.wav", + "text": "研商公務人員任用法第22條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/4.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/5.wav", + "text": "現在要先綜合討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/6.wav", + "text": "還是直接進入議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/7.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/8.wav", + "text": "兩條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/9.wav", + "text": "兩條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/10.wav", + "text": "第22條及第28條修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/11.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/12.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/13.wav", + "text": "第22條比較單純" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/14.wav", + "text": "友善的育嬰環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/15.wav", + "text": "一南一北" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/16.wav", + "text": "第22條我們委員會就沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/17.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/18.wav", + "text": "第22條就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/19.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/20.wav", + "text": "請提案委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/21.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/22.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/23.wav", + "text": "各位黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/24.wav", + "text": "我們黨團有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/25.wav", + "text": "或受緩刑宣告期滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/26.wav", + "text": "而未經撤銷者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/27.wav", + "text": "不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/28.wav", + "text": "我們的修正動議條文A" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/29.wav", + "text": "但因協助發現防止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/30.wav", + "text": "追究他人貪污行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/31.wav", + "text": "而受免刑宣告者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/32.wav", + "text": "一個公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/33.wav", + "text": "再任公務員的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/34.wav", + "text": "111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/35.wav", + "text": "憲裁字第254號裁定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/36.wav", + "text": "中有三位大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/37.wav", + "text": "提出不同意見書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/38.wav", + "text": "包括黃瑞明大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/39.wav", + "text": "黃虹霞大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/40.wav", + "text": "跟詹森林大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/41.wav", + "text": "等他們的不同意見書裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/42.wav", + "text": "其實都有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/43.wav", + "text": "我國法制上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/44.wav", + "text": "的一個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/45.wav", + "text": "貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/46.wav", + "text": "然後被判有罪之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/47.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/48.wav", + "text": "釋字第66號解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/49.wav", + "text": "但是比緩刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/50.wav", + "text": "更輕微的免刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/51.wav", + "text": "終身沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/52.wav", + "text": "再任公務員\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/53.wav", + "text": "\n關於吹哨者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/54.wav", + "text": "就終身不得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/55.wav", + "text": "任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/56.wav", + "text": "新竹縣家畜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/57.wav", + "text": "疾病防治所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/58.wav", + "text": "士他的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/59.wav", + "text": "其實也都有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/60.wav", + "text": "後挺身而出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/61.wav", + "text": "在他挺身而出的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/62.wav", + "text": "新竹地院也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/63.wav", + "text": "他這樣的作法值得嘉許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/64.wav", + "text": "所以特別給他免刑的寬典" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/65.wav", + "text": "但是他的同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/66.wav", + "text": "認罪之後判了緩刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/67.wav", + "text": "緩刑當然是比免刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/68.wav", + "text": "還更嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/69.wav", + "text": "結果這些真的認罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/70.wav", + "text": "且確實有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/71.wav", + "text": "做這樣行為的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/72.wav", + "text": "因為大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/73.wav", + "text": "釋字第66號解釋的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/74.wav", + "text": "因此他們又可以回任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/75.wav", + "text": "卻沒辦法回任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/76.wav", + "text": "我剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/77.wav", + "text": "大法官不同意見書裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/78.wav", + "text": "其實也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/79.wav", + "text": "這種狀況並不是一個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/80.wav", + "text": "一直有發生這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/81.wav", + "text": "考試院銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/82.wav", + "text": "其實有做過解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/83.wav", + "text": "憲裁字第254號裁定中它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/84.wav", + "text": "有特別提出銓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/85.wav", + "text": "銓敘部在106年8月11日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/86.wav", + "text": "部法三字第106" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/87.wav", + "text": "4253227號函裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/88.wav", + "text": "犯貪污治罪條例判刑有罪確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/89.wav", + "text": "而獲緩刑宣告的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/90.wav", + "text": "其實可以在緩刑期滿之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/91.wav", + "text": "再任公務員的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/92.wav", + "text": "就是司法院釋字第66號解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/93.wav", + "text": "它是公務人員任用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/94.wav", + "text": "第28條第1項第4款的例外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/95.wav", + "text": "所以事實上銓敘部認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/96.wav", + "text": "被判緩刑的人可以再任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/97.wav", + "text": "秘書長這應該沒有問題吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/98.wav", + "text": "吧現在有問題的是被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/99.wav", + "text": "回任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/100.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/101.wav", + "text": "支持讓這些人可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/102.wav", + "text": "說實在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/103.wav", + "text": "如果不是因為���些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/104.wav", + "text": "恐怕也沒有辦法因而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/105.wav", + "text": "查獲這樣的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/106.wav", + "text": "發現防止追究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/107.wav", + "text": "而受免刑宣告的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/108.wav", + "text": "回任公務員的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/109.wav", + "text": "當然他們未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/110.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠再回任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/111.wav", + "text": "即便我們讓這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/112.wav", + "text": "可以有再回任公務員的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/113.wav", + "text": "但要不要回任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/114.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠回任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/115.wav", + "text": "當然是由行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/116.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/117.wav", + "text": "剛才我忘記介紹我現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/118.wav", + "text": "補充介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/119.wav", + "text": "列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/120.wav", + "text": "以便大家詢問今天列席的首" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/121.wav", + "text": "考試院秘書長劉建忻先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/122.wav", + "text": "及銓敘部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/123.wav", + "text": "周志宏先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/124.wav", + "text": "介紹完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/125.wav", + "text": "委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/126.wav", + "text": "及林思銘召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/127.wav", + "text": "上次召集協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/128.wav", + "text": "我們在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/129.wav", + "text": "也辯論了很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/130.wav", + "text": "因為今天成員不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/131.wav", + "text": "所以我還是簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/132.wav", + "text": "我先說明法律意見的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/133.wav", + "text": "剛才邱顯智委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/134.wav", + "text": "憲法法庭不受理裁定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/135.wav", + "text": "所以他所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/136.wav", + "text": "引用的見解是少數意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/137.wav", + "text": "也就是不同意見書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/138.wav", + "text": "那是沒有拘束力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/139.wav", + "text": "他所引用的理據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/140.wav", + "text": "是延伸一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/141.wav", + "text": "過去錯誤的法律解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/142.wav", + "text": "應該說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/143.wav", + "text": "原先解釋的時候不一定錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/144.wav", + "text": "後來的法條已經變更而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/145.wav", + "text": "銓敘部相關行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/146.wav", + "text": "乃至於法院不察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/147.wav", + "text": "而繼續錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/148.wav", + "text": "引用這樣的法律解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/149.wav", + "text": "也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/150.wav", + "text": "釋字第66號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/151.wav", + "text": "關於釋字第66號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/152.wav", + "text": "我們有去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/153.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/154.wav", + "text": "它並非憲法位階的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/155.wav", + "text": "我們的憲法裡面有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/156.wav", + "text": "過去的大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/157.wav", + "text": "憲法解釋及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/158.wav", + "text": "統一解釋法令之權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/159.wav", + "text": "釋字第66號雖然是釋字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/160.wav", + "text": "但它只是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/161.wav", + "text": "統一法令的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/162.wav", + "text": "所以它並不具備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/163.wav", + "text": "憲法解釋的效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/164.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/165.wav", + "text": "\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/166.wav", + "text": "它的內容是什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/167.wav", + "text": "它的內容其實是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/168.wav", + "text": "民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/169.wav", + "text": "四十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/170.wav", + "text": "的法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/171.wav", + "text": "所作的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/172.wav", + "text": "而當時的立法者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/173.wav", + "text": "在那個條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/174.wav", + "text": "並沒有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/175.wav", + "text": "貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/176.wav", + "text": "及其他犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/177.wav", + "text": "作如同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/178.wav", + "text": "民國75年的時候訂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/179.wav", + "text": "如果我們看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/180.wav", + "text": "現行法的第四款及第五款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/181.wav", + "text": "它對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/182.wav", + "text": "犯貪污罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/183.wav", + "text": "及犯貪污罪以外之罪的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/184.wav", + "text": "未來能不能再任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/185.wav", + "text": "有一個非常清楚的價值選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/186.wav", + "text": "是不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/187.wav", + "text": "所以釋字第66號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/188.wav", + "text": "是在舊法的時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/189.wav", + "text": "那個條文和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/190.wav", + "text": "和現在完全不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/191.wav", + "text": "它是在舊法的時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/192.wav", + "text": "如果是緩刑期滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/193.wav", + "text": "依照當時我國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/194.wav", + "text": "所繼受的刑法學說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/195.wav", + "text": "認為緩刑宣告期滿之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/196.wav", + "text": "罪和刑的宣告都失去效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/197.wav", + "text": "這其實是一個錯誤的刑法解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/198.wav", + "text": "然後根據那個錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/199.wav", + "text": "刑法解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/200.wav", + "text": "縱然他是犯貪污罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/201.wav", + "text": "視同沒有犯過這個罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/202.wav", + "text": "所以就讓他可以再回任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/203.wav", + "text": "公務人員任用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/204.wav", + "text": "重新立法作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/205.wav", + "text": "作出現在我們所看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/206.wav", + "text": "價值選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/207.wav", + "text": "之後應該就不能夠再被適用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/208.wav", + "text": "\n我再解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/209.wav", + "text": "我會這樣子講呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/210.wav", + "text": "我們可以看第4款的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/211.wav", + "text": "及第5款的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/212.wav", + "text": "第4款規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/213.wav", + "text": "曾服公務有貪污行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/214.wav", + "text": "經有罪判決確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/215.wav", + "text": "或通緝有案尚未結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/216.wav", + "text": "也就是他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/217.wav", + "text": "認為不適宜再任公務員的界線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/218.wav", + "text": "確實有貪污行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/219.wav", + "text": "而且是有罪的判決確定後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/220.wav", + "text": "就不能再任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/221.wav", + "text": "這與後來刑罰的宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/222.wav", + "text": "罰金緩刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/223.wav", + "text": "還是有期徒刑抓進去關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/224.wav", + "text": "這些都無所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/225.wav", + "text": "這是當時的立法選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/226.wav", + "text": "第5款規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/227.wav", + "text": "如果不是貪污罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/228.wav", + "text": "而是前二款以外之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/229.wav", + "text": "即不是內亂外患" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/230.wav", + "text": "不是貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/231.wav", + "text": "那就要判處有期徒刑以上之刑確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/232.wav", + "text": "而尚未執行或執行未畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/233.wav", + "text": "規定也就是受緩刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/234.wav", + "text": "宣告者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/235.wav", + "text": "這什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/236.wav", + "text": "其實就是把界線放得很寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/237.wav", + "text": "即使緩刑尚未期滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/238.wav", + "text": "也當作已經執行完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/239.wav", + "text": "換句話說這是非常寬鬆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/240.wav", + "text": "更生人條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/241.wav", + "text": "法院有罪判決確定後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/242.wav", + "text": "就不應再擔任公務員但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/243.wav", + "text": "不察釋字第66號解釋的時空背景已經換了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/244.wav", + "text": "貪污公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/245.wav", + "text": "也延伸到公職人員選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/246.wav", + "text": "對於賄選與貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/247.wav", + "text": "亦採相同方式加以規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/248.wav", + "text": "的錯誤解釋延續影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/249.wav", + "text": "也有可能是因為個人關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/250.wav", + "text": "受刑罰後不適合執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/251.wav", + "text": "所以反而以別條款的理由判了緩刑或免刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/252.wav", + "text": "確實做過這件事是沒有關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/253.wav", + "text": "的兩款以維持原來正確的價值選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/254.wav", + "text": "亦即曾經犯過貪污行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/255.wav", + "text": "者就不適合再任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/256.wav", + "text": "這是基於我們對執行公務者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/257.wav", + "text": "除非我們的社會價值改變了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/258.wav", + "text": "認為應該給更生人更多機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/259.wav", + "text": "甚至連這樣的罪刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/260.wav", + "text": "\n至於錯誤的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/261.wav", + "text": "所帶來的錯誤執行結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/262.wav", + "text": "逝者已矣來者可追" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/263.wav", + "text": "不管法務部或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/264.wav", + "text": "考試院銓敘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/265.wav", + "text": "應該重新認識過去對法律解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/266.wav", + "text": "或犯過貪污罪者均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/267.wav", + "text": "哥倫比亞大學畢業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/268.wav", + "text": "又有實務經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/269.wav", + "text": "為什麼我還要講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/270.wav", + "text": "這是為了個案立法而去綁的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/271.wav", + "text": "過去黃國昌和林永頌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/272.wav", + "text": "為林永頌是個案律師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/273.wav", + "text": "時代力量永遠都是在弄個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/274.wav", + "text": "每次我在這裡跟他吵架都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/275.wav", + "text": "都是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/276.wav", + "text": "是在綁個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/277.wav", + "text": "因為在吹哨者條文的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/278.wav", + "text": "我開記者會乒乒乓乓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/279.wav", + "text": "所以他們天天在喊吹哨者條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/280.wav", + "text": "就是為了這個個案要回溯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/281.wav", + "text": "假如可以回溯的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/282.wav", + "text": "我來回溯說阿扁沒罪就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/283.wav", + "text": "我來寫個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/284.wav", + "text": "這是法的穩定性嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/285.wav", + "text": "在法理上錯誤的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/286.wav", + "text": "在騙大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/287.wav", + "text": "這綁得太清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/288.wav", + "text": "了你講的戴立紳那個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/289.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/290.wav", + "text": "他害死多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/291.wav", + "text": "害人家去關然後他自己免關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/292.wav", + "text": "這個案情你瞭解嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/293.wav", + "text": "不能以個案訴訟律師林永頌的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/294.wav", + "text": "你就要替他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/295.wav", + "text": "非常不道德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/296.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/297.wav", + "text": "你在吹哨者條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/298.wav", + "text": "時弄不來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/299.wav", + "text": "就要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/300.wav", + "text": "弄這個門一開的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/301.wav", + "text": "前面幾款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/302.wav", + "text": "包括第3款第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/303.wav", + "text": "內亂外患罪也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/304.wav", + "text": "了因為第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/305.wav", + "text": "這樣排除的話就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/306.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/307.wav", + "text": "剛才黃世杰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/308.wav", + "text": "杰委員講得這麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/309.wav", + "text": "再清楚不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/310.wav", + "text": "了我們在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/311.wav", + "text": "為了一個人的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/312.wav", + "text": "協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/313.wav", + "text": "都不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/314.wav", + "text": "因為有人被關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/315.wav", + "text": "為了個案來解脫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/316.wav", + "text": "這是道德嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/317.wav", + "text": "如果修法可以回溯既往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/318.wav", + "text": "那空間太大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/319.wav", + "text": "不可不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/320.wav", + "text": "對於這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/321.wav", + "text": "跟黃世杰委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/322.wav", + "text": "當然我們就是很客觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/323.wav", + "text": "來分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/324.wav", + "text": "現在關鍵就是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/325.wav", + "text": "我們的刑事政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/326.wav", + "text": "對於貪污犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/327.wav", + "text": "到底可否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/328.wav", + "text": "回任公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/329.wav", + "text": "如果是判緩刑跟免刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/330.wav", + "text": "到底可否回任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/331.wav", + "text": "現行司法院大法官會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/332.wav", + "text": "就是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/333.wav", + "text": "嘛緩刑可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/334.wav", + "text": "現在我們講免刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/335.wav", + "text": "免刑是比緩刑更輕的判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/336.wav", + "text": "這是一個法理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/337.wav", + "text": "緩刑都可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/338.wav", + "text": "你說免刑不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/339.wav", + "text": "我們常常在從事整個判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/340.wav", + "text": "實務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/341.wav", + "text": "今天貪污犯可以被判緩刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/342.wav", + "text": "或是被判到免刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/343.wav", + "text": "那真的是法官考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/344.wav", + "text": "再考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/345.wav", + "text": "非常少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/346.wav", + "text": "所以如果他是被判緩刑免刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/347.wav", + "text": "我想大法官才會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/348.wav", + "text": "他可以回任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/349.wav", + "text": "所以我們不能用你們的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/350.wav", + "text": "邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/351.wav", + "text": "你們是大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/352.wav", + "text": "根本沒有這個權限去解釋說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/353.wav", + "text": "現在都已經是這樣的解釋了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/354.wav", + "text": "你們卻不願意依照法理去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/355.wav", + "text": "一直說這是個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/356.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/357.wav", + "text": "案是他自己講說什麼戴那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/358.wav", + "text": "那是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/359.wav", + "text": "剛好實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/360.wav", + "text": "上一屆處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/361.wav", + "text": "下我們都很理性來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/362.wav", + "text": "當然這是一個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/363.wav", + "text": "但是從這個個案我們發現問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/364.wav", + "text": "啊所以我們立法者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/365.wav", + "text": "才去補救" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/366.wav", + "text": "是在這裡處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/367.wav", + "text": "這不是溯及的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/368.wav", + "text": "現在是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/369.wav", + "text": "補救這個立法漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/370.wav", + "text": "這是漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/371.wav", + "text": "我有聽啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/372.wav", + "text": "但是他的意見跟我不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/373.wav", + "text": "有不同意見我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/374.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/375.wav", + "text": "我先回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/376.wav", + "text": "斷章取義實在是很不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/377.wav", + "text": "另外一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/378.wav", + "text": "你先讓我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/379.wav", + "text": "我講完之後你再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/380.wav", + "text": "啊我覺得你應該要多做功課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/381.wav", + "text": "都不知道事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/382.wav", + "text": "不是啦說實在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/383.wav", + "text": "你應該要多多做功課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/384.wav", + "text": "民進黨作為一個執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/385.wav", + "text": "應該是值得一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/386.wav", + "text": "能夠更認真學習的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/387.wav", + "text": "\n第一個部分就是個案的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/388.wav", + "text": "但是就像我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/389.wav", + "text": "在憲法法庭的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/390.wav", + "text": "裁定裡面其實在後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/391.wav", + "text": "就提到了你只要看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/392.wav", + "text": "在第8頁這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/393.wav", + "text": "就有提到像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/394.wav", + "text": "這一類的事情是一個個案嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/395.wav", + "text": "不是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/396.wav", + "text": "因為你的自首或自白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/397.wav", + "text": "白而查獲其他正犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/398.wav", + "text": "你可以免刑或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/399.wav", + "text": "減輕其刑這表示什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/400.wav", + "text": "類似這樣的案件非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/401.wav", + "text": "裁定裡面就有舉例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/402.wav", + "text": "比如說最高法院109年度臺上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/403.wav", + "text": "字第4816號刑事判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/404.wav", + "text": "就有這樣的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/405.wav", + "text": "比如說媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/406.wav", + "text": "檢察官葉雪鵬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/407.wav", + "text": "曾經著文去討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/408.wav", + "text": "所以這個在法學界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/409.wav", + "text": "怎麼會是一個個案呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/410.wav", + "text": "這是一個實際上存在的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/411.wav", + "text": "是因為你不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/412.wav", + "text": "在臺灣高檢署的法律常識問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/413.wav", + "text": "也是律師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/414.wav", + "text": "有關免刑跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/415.wav", + "text": "銓敘部都已經做出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/416.wav", + "text": "說明表示緩刑可以回任再任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/417.wav", + "text": "公務員了而免刑不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/418.wav", + "text": "到底這個原因何在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/419.wav", + "text": "釐清的嘛緩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/420.wav", + "text": "緩刑當然是比免刑還更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/421.wav", + "text": "嚴重啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/422.wav", + "text": "他還要再進去被關而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/423.wav", + "text": "而免刑連刑都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/424.wav", + "text": "\n現在回到一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/425.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣免刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/426.wav", + "text": "的狀況是針對犯罪行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/427.wav", + "text": "顯可憫恕者在最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/428.wav", + "text": "法定刑度以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/429.wav", + "text": "減輕其刑仍嫌過重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/430.wav", + "text": "宣告之刑法特別處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/431.wav", + "text": "嘛這在刑法第59條跟第61條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/432.wav", + "text": "有規定而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/433.wav", + "text": "而緩刑是針對二年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/434.wav", + "text": "有期徒刑拘役或罰金之宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/435.wav", + "text": "第74條有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/436.wav", + "text": "所以兩相對照下受免刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/437.wav", + "text": "判決跟受緩刑宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/438.wav", + "text": "免刑的情節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/439.wav", + "text": "顯然較後者輕微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/440.wav", + "text": "緩刑者可以再任公務員的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/441.wav", + "text": "基於罪罰相當原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/442.wav", + "text": "免刑者應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/443.wav", + "text": "也要比照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/444.wav", + "text": "可以再任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/445.wav", + "text": "啊我要講的就是我剛剛一直強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/446.wav", + "text": "他能不能再任是機關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/447.wav", + "text": "權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/448.wav", + "text": "我請柯總召注意一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/449.wav", + "text": "在判刑的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/450.wav", + "text": "會斟酌各式各樣的情狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/451.wav", + "text": "所以才有刑法第59條第61條的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/452.wav", + "text": "當一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/453.wav", + "text": "就表示他的犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/454.wav", + "text": "情節輕微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/455.wav", + "text": "顯可憫恕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/456.wav", + "text": "有可能是因為他去自白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/457.wav", + "text": "等等狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/458.wav", + "text": "而讓大家可以去查獲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/459.wav", + "text": "講也提到他是戴罪立功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/460.wav", + "text": "嘛所以法院才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/461.wav", + "text": "認為在這種情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/462.wav", + "text": "要給予他免刑的寬典" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/463.wav", + "text": "典在實務上有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/464.wav", + "text": "類似這樣的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/465.wav", + "text": "他是一個基層公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/466.wav", + "text": "就有這樣的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/467.wav", + "text": "新竹市政府環保局的清潔隊員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/468.wav", + "text": "因為覺得一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/469.wav", + "text": "老阿嬤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/470.wav", + "text": "非常窮苦所以就把一些紙箱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/471.wav", + "text": "給她" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/472.wav", + "text": "行為被新竹地院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/473.wav", + "text": "依貪污治罪條例判刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/474.wav", + "text": "連在這樣的狀況之下他還被判緩刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/475.wav", + "text": "判緩刑是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/476.wav", + "text": "再回任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/477.wav", + "text": "而戴立紳的狀況是比這個狀況還更輕微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/478.wav", + "text": "但是他沒有辦法回任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/479.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這個事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/480.wav", + "text": "可以講道理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/481.wav", + "text": "嚴刑峻罰的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/482.wav", + "text": "你要看個案的情狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/483.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/484.wav", + "text": "其情可憫恕的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/485.wav", + "text": "我們當然也要對個案的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/486.wav", + "text": "去做判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/487.wav", + "text": "\n最後一個就要講到為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/488.wav", + "text": "或是銓敘部要認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/489.wav", + "text": "判緩刑的也應該有一個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/490.wav", + "text": "可以回任其實非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/491.wav", + "text": "當你這個條文一定下去的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/492.wav", + "text": "他是終身都不能夠做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/493.wav", + "text": "公務員那我們就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/494.wav", + "text": "回頭過來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/495.wav", + "text": "一個人被判緩刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/496.wav", + "text": "可以再回任公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/497.wav", + "text": "但是被判免刑比前者更輕微的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/498.wav", + "text": "他這輩子像戴立紳這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/499.wav", + "text": "像其他我剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/500.wav", + "text": "最高法院很多案例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/501.wav", + "text": "的這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/502.wav", + "text": "他即便被判免刑他都沒有再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/503.wav", + "text": "了這樣的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/504.wav", + "text": "是不是有違比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/505.wav", + "text": "明顯的所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/506.wav", + "text": "支持這樣一個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/507.wav", + "text": "讓犯錯的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/508.wav", + "text": "受到處罰但是同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/509.wav", + "text": "在情節輕微的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/510.wav", + "text": "情況之下他也有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/511.wav", + "text": "回任公務員的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/512.wav", + "text": "我覺得這應該是一個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/513.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/514.wav", + "text": "本來的版本是說受免刑宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/515.wav", + "text": "這已經很輕微了或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/516.wav", + "text": "受緩刑宣告期滿而未經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/517.wav", + "text": "撤銷的設一個但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/518.wav", + "text": "在我們已經把緩刑拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/519.wav", + "text": "因為緩刑本來在銓敘部的函釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/520.wav", + "text": "或是大法官第66號��釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/521.wav", + "text": "裡面都已經可以回任公務員了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/522.wav", + "text": "這是臺灣現行的法制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/523.wav", + "text": "免刑的狀況我們又把它更限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/524.wav", + "text": "因為免刑的狀況也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/525.wav", + "text": "有許多種狀況但是我們把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/526.wav", + "text": "又更限縮在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/527.wav", + "text": "他是因為協助發現防止追究他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/528.wav", + "text": "貪污行為而受免刑宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/529.wav", + "text": "這種吹哨者的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/530.wav", + "text": "我相信那個但書的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/531.wav", + "text": "又更限縮的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/532.wav", + "text": "我講一下好了我講話都很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/533.wav", + "text": "黃世杰賴香院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/534.wav", + "text": "他一直點名說我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/535.wav", + "text": "你院長說按照順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/536.wav", + "text": "你又要插隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/537.wav", + "text": "等一下我會講得很清楚很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/538.wav", + "text": "大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/539.wav", + "text": "至少他點名我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/540.wav", + "text": "我應該要適度地回應嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/541.wav", + "text": "他早上開記者會罵我是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/542.wav", + "text": "臺灣的習近平什麼的我都無所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/543.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/544.wav", + "text": "你說我不用功坐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/545.wav", + "text": "在這裡我不回兩句也難過嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/546.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/547.wav", + "text": "我通常對邱顯智都採用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/548.wav", + "text": "寬恕的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/549.wav", + "text": "因為你跟他生氣氣不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/550.wav", + "text": "但是罵我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/551.wav", + "text": "你們這個黨的政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/552.wav", + "text": "這已經不是時代力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/553.wav", + "text": "做的事情了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/554.wav", + "text": "好不容易有這麼多年輕人曾經追逐過你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/555.wav", + "text": "問政典範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/556.wav", + "text": "而不是走偏門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/557.wav", + "text": "\n我現在針對問題回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/558.wav", + "text": "要挑戰我用功的人其實他自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/559.wav", + "text": "要先考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/560.wav", + "text": "我在這裡對於這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/561.wav", + "text": "為什麼突然會跟你唱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/562.wav", + "text": "不同意見書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/563.wav", + "text": "現在是溯及既往的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/564.wav", + "text": "我們立法者要如此嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/565.wav", + "text": "那以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/566.wav", + "text": "很多都來溯及既往啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/567.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/568.wav", + "text": "去協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/569.wav", + "text": "發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/570.wav", + "text": "防止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/571.wav", + "text": "實情不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/572.wav", + "text": "有人是被害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/573.wav", + "text": "者他隱匿了資料去害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/574.wav", + "text": "然後自己得到免刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/575.wav", + "text": "這是他的律師很強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/576.wav", + "text": "現在這個案子已經在再審了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/577.wav", + "text": "人家發覺新事實新證據了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/578.wav", + "text": "這個案子已經走到這裡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/579.wav", + "text": "過去在吹哨者條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/580.wav", + "text": "因為當事者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/581.wav", + "text": "的律師是林永頌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/582.wav", + "text": "吹哨者條例一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/583.wav", + "text": "回溯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/584.wav", + "text": "所以引起我的注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/585.wav", + "text": "我們立法者為單一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/586.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/587.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/588.wav", + "text": "根本沒有辦法討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/589.wav", + "text": "跟在委員會一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/590.wav", + "text": "現在就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/591.wav", + "text": "剛才是會議休息中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/592.wav", + "text": "我現在宣布繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/593.wav", + "text": "\n對第28條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/594.wav", + "text": "因為還有很多委員要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/595.wav", + "text": "但是我看各黨團沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/596.wav", + "text": "所以第28條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/597.wav", + "text": "賴香伶委員你比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/598.wav", + "text": "感謝你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/599.wav", + "text": "院長考試院對這個要回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/600.wav", + "text": "你也不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/601.wav", + "text": "28條保留啦繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/602.wav", + "text": "這一張請大家簽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/603.wav", + "text": "就照程序處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/604.wav", + "text": "要簽啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/605.wav", + "text": "現在我們就繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/606.wav", + "text": "\n現在針對菸害防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/607.wav", + "text": "法我在這裡向大家介紹列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/608.wav", + "text": "首先介紹衛生福利部政務次長王必勝先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/609.wav", + "text": "以及教育部政務次長蔡清華先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/610.wav", + "text": "我就介紹到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/611.wav", + "text": "現在針對菸害防制法草案的審查協商結果一共有28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/612.wav", + "text": "這個案子昨天下午朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/613.wav", + "text": "昨天下午朝野協商完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/614.wav", + "text": "講真的也沒有人通知我來簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/615.wav", + "text": "今天早上民進黨黨團就開個記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/616.wav", + "text": "它的標題是拖延立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/617.wav", + "text": "放任菸害持續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/618.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/619.wav", + "text": "我可不可以說副院長身體不舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/620.wav", + "text": "今天沒辦法開院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/621.wav", + "text": "就是拖延立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/622.wav", + "text": "有這種事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/623.wav", + "text": "\n有這種事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/624.wav", + "text": "我再來唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/625.wav", + "text": "法案擱置在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/626.wav", + "text": "今天民進黨黨團緊急召開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/627.wav", + "text": "痛批國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/628.wav", + "text": "拖延民生重大法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/629.wav", + "text": "為了政治盤算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/630.wav", + "text": "犧牲全民健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/631.wav", + "text": "我想請問我政治盤算什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/632.wav", + "text": "我政治盤算什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/633.wav", + "text": "我在政治盤算什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/634.wav", + "text": "大家講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/635.wav", + "text": "大家講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/636.wav", + "text": "說國民黨不顧朝野協商共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/637.wav", + "text": "哪裡不顧朝野協商共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/638.wav", + "text": "講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/639.wav", + "text": "如果今天不簽署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/640.wav", + "text": "嚴重影響立法進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/641.wav", + "text": "那蔡其昌副院長身體不舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/642.wav", + "text": "有沒有嚴重影響立法的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/643.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/644.wav", + "text": "有還是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/645.wav", + "text": "我可以明天開個記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/646.wav", + "text": "我就把他的照片跟他的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/647.wav", + "text": "然後把你的標題改一改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/648.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/649.wav", + "text": "懷疑國民黨是否想以拖延菸防法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/650.wav", + "text": "作為延會的藉口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/651.wav", + "text": "我不想延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/652.wav", + "text": "絕對不延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/653.wav", + "text": "我絕對不延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/654.wav", + "text": "講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/655.wav", + "text": "就到13日晚上12點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/656.wav", + "text": "我不需要這種藉口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/657.wav", + "text": "不用給我扣這個帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/658.wav", + "text": "不用給我扣這個帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/659.wav", + "text": "有人說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/660.wav", + "text": "朝野協商是希望所有政黨委員能夠有最大共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/661.wav", + "text": "歷經5次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/662.wav", + "text": "如果還是淪為表決大戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/663.wav", + "text": "國民黨是在開全民玩笑嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/664.wav", + "text": "國民黨此舉是否為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/665.wav", + "text": "沒收立委補選的遮羞布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/666.wav", + "text": "這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/667.wav", + "text": "貴黨的委員在今天早上記者會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/668.wav", + "text": "我們沒有簽這個名是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/669.wav", + "text": "立委補選的遮羞布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/670.wav", + "text": "啊我們總召在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/671.wav", + "text": "扣我們這麼大的帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/672.wav", + "text": "你要我怎麼跟你協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/673.wav", + "text": "有這個必要嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/674.wav", + "text": "\n有這個必要嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/675.wav", + "text": "我很少生氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/676.wav", + "text": "你也太過分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/677.wav", + "text": "你不用說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/678.wav", + "text": "我們不要延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/679.wav", + "text": "不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/680.wav", + "text": "換我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/681.wav", + "text": "好啦你們都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/682.wav", + "text": "一起回答好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/683.wav", + "text": "衛環委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/684.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/685.wav", + "text": "終於在昨天下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/686.wav", + "text": "有一致的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/687.wav", + "text": "所以等於沒有保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/688.wav", + "text": "本來這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/689.wav", + "text": "就不須再協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/690.wav", + "text": "因為沒有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/691.wav", + "text": "啊直接就可以二三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/692.wav", + "text": "也不用表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/693.wav", + "text": "因為沒有保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/694.wav", + "text": "每一個條文都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/695.wav", + "text": "有經過共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/696.wav", + "text": "的但是昨天突然接到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/697.wav", + "text": "院長說今天3點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/698.wav", + "text": "要協商這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/699.wav", + "text": "所以就產生一些想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/700.wav", + "text": "已經不用再朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/701.wav", + "text": "不用院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/702.wav", + "text": "還要協商什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/703.wav", + "text": "就直接送二三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/704.wav", + "text": "也不用表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/705.wav", + "text": "我召集了5次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/706.wav", + "text": "也覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/707.wav", + "text": "你們怎麼又再發一個會議通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/708.wav", + "text": "今天3點要來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/709.wav", + "text": "是不是你們又要反悔了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/710.wav", + "text": "就像第三次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/711.wav", + "text": "有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/712.wav", + "text": "第四次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/713.wav", + "text": "我們是在擔心這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/714.wav", + "text": "所以我們就很緊張地在觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/715.wav", + "text": "不然今天根本不用協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/716.wav", + "text": "你們知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/717.wav", + "text": "\n不用協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/718.wav", + "text": "啊就直接到院會去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/719.wav", + "text": "為什麼會發個通知出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/720.wav", + "text": "說今天又要來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/721.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/722.wav", + "text": "昨天你們沒有簽出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/723.wav", + "text": "才會有這樣的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/724.wav", + "text": "請大家稍安勿躁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/725.wav", + "text": "好我把話講完1分鐘把它講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/726.wav", + "text": "因為我們擔心這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/727.wav", + "text": "當然會來參加這個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/728.wav", + "text": "結果你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/729.wav", + "text": "打人喊救人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/730.wav", + "text": "我們是擔心你們翻盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/731.wav", + "text": "又來個大轉變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/732.wav", + "text": "結果你們今天早上開個記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/733.wav", + "text": "反而怪罪國民黨在拖延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/734.wav", + "text": "我們拖延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/735.wav", + "text": "我們已經經過5次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/736.wav", + "text": "把它完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/737.wav", + "text": "而且中間的轉折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/738.wav", + "text": "都是你們民進黨改變態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/739.wav", + "text": "啊國健署在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/740.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/741.wav", + "text": "是不是你們本來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/742.wav", + "text": "加熱菸載具可以管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/743.wav", + "text": "後來第四次又說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/744.wav", + "text": "不能管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/745.wav", + "text": "現在第五次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/746.wav", + "text": "(昨天)又回到可以管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/747.wav", + "text": "我們接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/748.wav", + "text": "啊所以我們在擔心這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/749.wav", + "text": "會不會又變盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/750.wav", + "text": "結果你們今天早上開那個記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/751.wav", + "text": "反而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/752.wav", + "text": "在怪罪國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/753.wav", + "text": "說我們在拖延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/754.wav", + "text": "如果今天不用協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/755.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/756.wav", + "text": "是因為今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/757.wav", + "text": "有這個3點的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/758.wav", + "text": "所以我們尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/759.wav", + "text": "今天就來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/760.wav", + "text": "了總召也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/761.wav", + "text": "既然院長召開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/762.wav", + "text": "我們當然要來聽院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/763.wav", + "text": "為什麼要再召開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/764.wav", + "text": "大家來聽看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/765.wav", + "text": "所以暫時沒有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/766.wav", + "text": "這樣你們就去開記者會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/767.wav", + "text": "我們要拖延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/768.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/769.wav", + "text": "即使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/770.wav", + "text": "我們先簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/771.wav", + "text": "院長已經說3點要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/772.wav", + "text": "我們還是要來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/773.wav", + "text": "總是要尊重院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/774.wav", + "text": "說今天3點要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/775.wav", + "text": "所以大家就來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/776.wav", + "text": "甚至協商當場就簽名就完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/777.wav", + "text": "就OK了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/778.wav", + "text": "一般是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/779.wav", + "text": "但是你們發了協商通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/780.wav", + "text": "我們當然就尊重院長發的協商通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/781.wav", + "text": "你就開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/782.wav", + "text": "變成我們在阻擋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/783.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/784.wav", + "text": "態度大轉變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/785.wav", + "text": "參與協商的委員都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/786.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/787.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/788.wav", + "text": "我們在上上禮拜第三次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/789.wav", + "text": "黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/790.wav", + "text": "就已經有結論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/791.wav", + "text": "才會有第五次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/792.wav", + "text": "才會拖到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/793.wav", + "text": "才火燒屁股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/794.wav", + "text": "不然上上禮拜就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/795.wav", + "text": "我把事情還原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/796.wav", + "text": "啦現在感覺都沒有互信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/797.wav", + "text": "你們是故意罵我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/798.wav", + "text": "看我們會不會不簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/799.wav", + "text": "說你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/800.wav", + "text": "又是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/801.wav", + "text": "你們早上先罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/802.wav", + "text": "後大家就不簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/803.wav", + "text": "不了了之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/804.wav", + "text": "案子不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/805.wav", + "text": "這樣正中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/806.wav", + "text": "正中你們下懷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/807.wav", + "text": "原來行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/808.wav", + "text": "就是不想管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/809.wav", + "text": "加熱菸載具的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/810.wav", + "text": "讓青少年都可以買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/811.wav", + "text": "你們原來的版本就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/812.wav", + "text": "回到原來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/813.wav", + "text": "我們現在擔心的是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/814.wav", + "text": "我把這個過程講完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/815.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/816.wav", + "text": "洲委員剛才有說到一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/817.wav", + "text": "我解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/818.wav", + "text": "有提到明天下午3點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/819.wav", + "text": "要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/820.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/821.wav", + "text": "今天3點的協商是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/822.wav", + "text": "第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/823.wav", + "text": "是因為公務人員任用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/824.wav", + "text": "之後這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/825.wav", + "text": "才加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/826.wav", + "text": "其他的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/827.wav", + "text": "進行第三輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/828.wav", + "text": "可以拿來這裡協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/829.wav", + "text": "昨天是這樣講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/830.wav", + "text": "我想跟你解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/831.wav", + "text": "因為你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/832.wav", + "text": "對這個有疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/833.wav", + "text": "我們有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/834.wav", + "text": "把菸害防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/835.wav", + "text": "所以我們就擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/836.wav", + "text": "你們又改變態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/837.wav", + "text": "事實的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/838.wav", + "text": "我來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/839.wav", + "text": "沒有人通知你要簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/840.wav", + "text": "我先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/841.wav", + "text": "其他黨團都簽完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/842.wav", + "text": "正本就在國民黨黨團辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/843.wav", + "text": "你們的助理有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/844.wav", + "text": "那為什麼你們的助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/845.wav", + "text": "沒有請你們簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/846.wav", + "text": "這我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/847.wav", + "text": "我沒辦法解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/848.wav", + "text": "剛其他黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/849.wav", + "text": "尤其是民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/850.wav", + "text": "我們請民眾黨幫忙簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/851.wav", + "text": "民眾黨簽完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/852.wav", + "text": "我就跟曾總召說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/853.wav", + "text": "其他黨團都簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/854.wav", + "text": "你們林為洲委員很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/855.wav", + "text": "協商出來的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/856.wav", + "text": "請問國民黨要不要簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/857.wav", + "text": "這樣我們明天就能立刻處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/858.wav", + "text": "當時國民黨總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/859.wav", + "text": "場就說黨團內部可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/860.wav", + "text": "還有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/861.wav", + "text": "可是你們的協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/862.wav", + "text": "都已經談出結論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/863.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/864.wav", + "text": "協商預算過程一直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/865.wav", + "text": "都還沒有簽出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/866.wav", + "text": "因果關係及時序是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/867.wav", + "text": "才會有這樣的呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/868.wav", + "text": "等個半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/869.wav", + "text": "早上又開記者會罵我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/870.wav", + "text": "只要簽了就不用協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/871.wav", + "text": "今天副院長身體不舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/872.wav", + "text": "你也過不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/873.wav", + "text": "沒有人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/874.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/875.wav", + "text": "他舉很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/876.wav", + "text": "手抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/877.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/878.wav", + "text": "原來國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/879.wav", + "text": "之前衛福部在上一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/880.wav", + "text": "送的版本也是雙禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/881.wav", + "text": "後來這次變成一開一禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/882.wav", + "text": "大家是勉強在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/883.wav", + "text": "找到一個可接受的底線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/884.wav", + "text": "本來支持雙禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/885.wav", + "text": "所以站在黨團的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/886.wav", + "text": "當然必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/887.wav", + "text": "稍微說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/888.wav", + "text": "這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/889.wav", + "text": "黨團也都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/890.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員也都在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/891.wav", + "text": "他們要看一下條文的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/892.wav", + "text": "我們所有黨團的成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/893.wav", + "text": "大家當過黨團幹部的人都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/894.wav", + "text": "這本來就��程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/895.wav", + "text": "但是不能說因為這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/896.wav", + "text": "而且我們都已經接獲通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/897.wav", + "text": "昨天就說是不另通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/898.wav", + "text": "但是今天的協商法案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/899.wav", + "text": "就有菸害防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/900.wav", + "text": "所以我們當然就覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/901.wav", + "text": "今天來聽聽看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/902.wav", + "text": "到底是什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/903.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛林為洲委員說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/904.wav", + "text": "協商5次下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/905.wav", + "text": "到第3次時談好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/906.wav", + "text": "第4次又變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/907.wav", + "text": "又要把加熱器當3C產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/908.wav", + "text": "又不管了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/909.wav", + "text": "後來也是經過大家不斷地協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/910.wav", + "text": "再加上家長教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/911.wav", + "text": "及醫生在關心這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/912.wav", + "text": "大家也都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/913.wav", + "text": "如果不是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/914.wav", + "text": "林為洲召委的不斷協調之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/915.wav", + "text": "當然包括了吳玉琴委員還有時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/916.wav", + "text": "大家都一起在投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/917.wav", + "text": "可是終究中間行政部門的轉折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/918.wav", + "text": "態度一直改來改去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/919.wav", + "text": "這是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/920.wav", + "text": "啊如果不是因為今天林為洲委員很堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/921.wav", + "text": "大家勉強都可以接受的底線版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/922.wav", + "text": "大家才有可能簽簽字就結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/923.wav", + "text": "結果沒想到早上還要被民進黨開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/924.wav", + "text": "在喊救人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/925.wav", + "text": "過程之中是誰在變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/926.wav", + "text": "啊國民黨的立場沒有變過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/927.wav", + "text": "我們還退讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/928.wav", + "text": "耶從雙禁退讓到勉強可接受的底限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/929.wav", + "text": "就是把加熱器納管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/930.wav", + "text": "才接受這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/931.wav", + "text": "結果反而民進黨還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/932.wav", + "text": "開記者會來修理國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/933.wav", + "text": "我先講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/934.wav", + "text": "我先舉手的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/935.wav", + "text": "給他講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/936.wav", + "text": "你再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/937.wav", + "text": "然後就告一段落好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/938.wav", + "text": "院長各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/939.wav", + "text": "聽我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/940.wav", + "text": "你不聽我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/941.wav", + "text": "大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/942.wav", + "text": "我真的不聽你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/943.wav", + "text": "先坐一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/944.wav", + "text": "我也參加了好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/945.wav", + "text": "為洲委員主持的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/946.wav", + "text": "也都各有退讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/947.wav", + "text": "像85%的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/948.wav", + "text": "%但這些大家都有共識了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/949.wav", + "text": "如果沒有其他意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/950.wav", + "text": "我們就不用再討論內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/951.wav", + "text": "然後我們就去二三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/952.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/953.wav", + "text": "大家冷靜一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/954.wav", + "text": "嘛這中間可能有一些誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/955.wav", + "text": "我沒有誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/956.wav", + "text": "聽我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/957.wav", + "text": "如果有誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/958.wav", + "text": "還是民進黨這個記者會開得太快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/959.wav", + "text": "罵得不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/960.wav", + "text": "我是黨團總召代表民進黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/961.wav", + "text": "今天早上誰去開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/962.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/963.wav", + "text": "至少黨團總召代表民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/964.wav", + "text": "我在這裡跟國民黨表示抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/965.wav", + "text": "沒關係你接受不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/966.wav", + "text": "我要講我的感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/967.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/968.wav", + "text": "我跟邱顯智委員天天在吵架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/969.wav", + "text": "他今天開記者會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/970.wav", + "text": "我是臺灣的習近平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/971.wav", + "text": "那天還爆粗話罵我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/972.wav", + "text": "我們的版本就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/973.wav", + "text": "這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/974.wav", + "text": "他也是在臉書罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/975.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/976.wav", + "text": "但是對我來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/977.wav", + "text": "我們是要把法案通過為要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/978.wav", + "text": "應該是一個大家非常有共識的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/979.wav", + "text": "從2016年以後討論到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/980.wav", + "text": "我認為這個法案簡單講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/981.wav", + "text": "度共識為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/982.wav", + "text": "這個沒有通過電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/983.wav", + "text": "繼續危害年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/984.wav", + "text": "真的很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/985.wav", + "text": "幾萬個學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/986.wav", + "text": "條文是��十幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/987.wav", + "text": "不是只有這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/988.wav", + "text": "什麼加熱菸的而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/989.wav", + "text": "第一點大家要考慮這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/990.wav", + "text": "這很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/991.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/992.wav", + "text": "我們是一個法治國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/993.wav", + "text": "我看這菸害防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/994.wav", + "text": "上一屆討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/995.wav", + "text": "好像非常敏感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/996.wav", + "text": "我是覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/997.wav", + "text": "我們處理敏感法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/998.wav", + "text": "高度政治性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/999.wav", + "text": "需要攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1000.wav", + "text": "這完全沒有什麼意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1001.wav", + "text": "臺灣的社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1002.wav", + "text": "我們是法治國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1003.wav", + "text": "然後也有專賣店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1004.wav", + "text": "我們行政院政策已定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1005.wav", + "text": "就是一禁一管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1006.wav", + "text": "所以我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1007.wav", + "text": "這沒有什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1008.wav", + "text": "都要把它弄好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1009.wav", + "text": "中間一些不愉快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1010.wav", + "text": "為什麼會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1011.wav", + "text": "洲委員對這個法案很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1012.wav", + "text": "而且他很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1013.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1014.wav", + "text": "朝野協商當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1015.wav", + "text": "不是立法院法定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1016.wav", + "text": "但是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1017.wav", + "text": "出委員會一個月要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1018.wav", + "text": "就是出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1019.wav", + "text": "能夠先把它處理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1020.wav", + "text": "到院長這裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1021.wav", + "text": "到院長這裡講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1022.wav", + "text": "超過一個月講不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1023.wav", + "text": "就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1024.wav", + "text": "法律所以對於曾經參與協商的所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1025.wav", + "text": "所有委員我表示高度的尊重跟敬佩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1026.wav", + "text": "也簽名了大家都簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1027.wav", + "text": "我第一個拿給時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1028.wav", + "text": "量也簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1029.wav", + "text": "了我親自交給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1030.wav", + "text": "沒關係你聽我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1031.wav", + "text": "到底簽了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1032.wav", + "text": "你都不置可否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1033.wav", + "text": "所以造成一些誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1034.wav", + "text": "我們都沒有看到你簽的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1035.wav", + "text": "因為正本在你那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1036.wav", + "text": "所以這真的很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1037.wav", + "text": "我一點意見都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1038.wav", + "text": "因為這個東西大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1039.wav", + "text": "共識很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1040.wav", + "text": "這個很簡單的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1041.wav", + "text": "而且是很重要的民生法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1042.wav", + "text": "但是這也沒有政治性李" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1043.wav", + "text": "那就道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1044.wav", + "text": "因為你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1045.wav", + "text": "沒有簽出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1046.wav", + "text": "所以院長就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1047.wav", + "text": "簽出來就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1048.wav", + "text": "因為沒有人看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1049.wav", + "text": "白白給你們罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1050.wav", + "text": "邱顯智每天都罵我你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1051.wav", + "text": "委員過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1052.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1053.wav", + "text": "林為洲當總召的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1054.wav", + "text": "天天罵民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1055.wav", + "text": "院長先確定簽了沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1056.wav", + "text": "人還有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1057.wav", + "text": "跟你道歉沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1058.wav", + "text": "這件事情的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1059.wav", + "text": "是民進黨的態度所以大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1060.wav", + "text": "會快結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1061.wav", + "text": "就是這樣的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1062.wav", + "text": "但是不要又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1063.wav", + "text": "到總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1064.wav", + "text": "什麼委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1065.wav", + "text": "這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1066.wav", + "text": "每天都在發誓講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1067.wav", + "text": "要延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1068.wav", + "text": "不要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1069.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1070.wav", + "text": "最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1071.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1072.wav", + "text": "最後最後請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1073.wav", + "text": "就菸害防制法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1074.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1075.wav", + "text": "昨天柯總召拿給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1076.wav", + "text": "但是我要跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1077.wav", + "text": "國民黨的立場是雙禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1078.wav", + "text": "禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1079.wav", + "text": "10點鐘開黨團大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1080.wav", + "text": "還是雙禁啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1081.wav", + "text": "晚上拿給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1082.wav", + "text": "我總要跟我們同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1083.wav", + "text": "溝通一下吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1084.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1085.wav", + "text": "你們早上開什麼記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1086.wav", + "text": "啊害我們兩個人的辦公室被打爆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1087.wav", + "text": "道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1088.wav", + "text": "這麼便宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1089.wav", + "text": "朝野沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1090.wav", + "text": "我們沒有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1091.wav", + "text": "這麼配合民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1092.wav", + "text": "還被罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1093.wav", + "text": "朝野沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1094.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1095.wav", + "text": "不延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1096.wav", + "text": "要延會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1097.wav", + "text": "提案我們撤回來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1098.wav", + "text": "國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1099.wav", + "text": "不延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1100.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1101.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1102.wav", + "text": "拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1103.wav", + "text": "一下每天在這邊發誓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1104.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1105.wav", + "text": "啦\n我跟你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1106.wav", + "text": "你溝通失敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1107.wav", + "text": "不是溝通失敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1108.wav", + "text": "你溝通沒有效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1109.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1110.wav", + "text": "你不知道國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1111.wav", + "text": "都不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1112.wav", + "text": "後面的政治問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1113.wav", + "text": "你要看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1114.wav", + "text": "然後要延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1115.wav", + "text": "他現在不敢延會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1116.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1117.wav", + "text": "正本他們拿回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1118.wav", + "text": "沒收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1119.wav", + "text": "沒簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1120.wav", + "text": "剛才也說要簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1121.wav", + "text": "這都出怪招啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1122.wav", + "text": "大家都看得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1123.wav", + "text": "我們把應該做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1124.wav", + "text": "做完就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1125.wav", + "text": "我們還是要讓媒體知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1126.wav", + "text": "我們到目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1127.wav", + "text": "還沒有看到國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1128.wav", + "text": "簽字的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1129.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1130.wav", + "text": "目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1131.wav", + "text": "延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1132.wav", + "text": "會期只有到13日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1133.wav", + "text": "日(星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1134.wav", + "text": ")大家辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1135.wav", + "text": "有關協商結論相關問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1136.wav", + "text": "我們還是請各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1137.wav", + "text": "再持續地積極溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1138.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1139.wav", + "text": "明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1140.wav", + "text": "院會先進行有協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1141.wav", + "text": "議案的立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1142.wav", + "text": "至於相關議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1143.wav", + "text": "如有完成協商結論者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1144.wav", + "text": "我們就賡續進行立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1145.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14770/1146.wav", + "text": "現在散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/0.wav", + "text": "我們現在就開始今天的協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1.wav", + "text": "今天的協商議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2.wav", + "text": "和前2天都一樣繼續研商中華民國112年度中央政府總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3.wav", + "text": "公務預算部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/4.wav", + "text": "在協商之前我先介紹列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/5.wav", + "text": "為外交部部長吳釗燮先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/6.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們處理外交部的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/7.wav", + "text": "院長我要程序發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/8.wav", + "text": "院長時代力量與各政黨都是非常樂意參加協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/9.wav", + "text": "但是針對協商的發言拜託院長一定要公正處理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/10.wav", + "text": "但是我在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/11.wav", + "text": "不要大小眼對於某些政黨發言的客氣度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/12.wav", + "text": "我想也不要有特權就是你發言比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/13.wav", + "text": "如果我們發言比較多我們也要節制一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/14.wav", + "text": "我同意院長的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/15.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/16.wav", + "text": "我們是立法院黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/17.wav", + "text": "是要協商預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/18.wav", + "text": "一共要協商4,800案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/19.wav", + "text": "這都是因為在委員會質詢的時候沒有辦法解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/20.wav", + "text": "才不得已在這裡提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/21.wav", + "text": "也不是一定非得故意要在這裡質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/22.wav", + "text": "也請院長能夠所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/23.wav", + "text": "認你在質詢啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/24.wav", + "text": "我沒有其實大家可以統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/25.wav", + "text": "我個人在這幾天的協商到底講話幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/26.wav", + "text": "講話時間多少都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/27.wav", + "text": "統計我並不是為了我個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/28.wav", + "text": "但是大家也要互相尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/29.wav", + "text": "不要讓人家感覺對小黨就特別不客氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/30.wav", + "text": "對啦互相尊重我希望你也尊重別人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/31.wav", + "text": "是我願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/32.wav", + "text": "我現在再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/33.wav", + "text": "請大家幫幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/34.wav", + "text": "我們是協商不是質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/35.wav", + "text": "所以如果有質詢的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/36.wav", + "text": "我會提醒請大家不要繼續質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/37.wav", + "text": "質詢好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/38.wav", + "text": "請大家看第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/39.wav", + "text": "第1案增列2,000萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/40.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/41.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/42.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/43.wav", + "text": "\n第2案增列1,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/44.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/45.wav", + "text": "\n第3案通刪\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/46.wav", + "text": "第4案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/47.wav", + "text": "第6案撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/48.wav", + "text": "通刪就不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/49.wav", + "text": "這是特別這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/50.wav", + "text": "案表決好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/51.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/52.wav", + "text": "好第10案再來問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/53.wav", + "text": "\n第10案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/54.wav", + "text": "減列1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/55.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/56.wav", + "text": "你就不要發言我會很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/57.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/58.wav", + "text": "好客氣一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/59.wav", + "text": "併到第10案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/60.wav", + "text": "經很客氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/61.wav", + "text": "併成一案都併入第10案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/62.wav", + "text": "已經同意刪1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/63.wav", + "text": "啦那我就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/64.wav", + "text": "開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/65.wav", + "text": "要減就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/66.wav", + "text": "我提問好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/67.wav", + "text": "任內斷了幾個邦交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/68.wav", + "text": "這跟特別費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/69.wav", + "text": "我問你你就要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/70.wav", + "text": "在蔡政府的任內我們跟美國的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/71.wav", + "text": "跟日本的關係跟歐洲的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/72.wav", + "text": "都有長足進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/73.wav", + "text": "請你針對我的問題回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/74.wav", + "text": "要不然國民黨退席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/75.wav", + "text": "我問你斷了幾個邦交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/76.wav", + "text": "國你跟我講美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/77.wav", + "text": "如果委員是問我的任內的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/78.wav", + "text": "我說蔡政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/79.wav", + "text": "你看都沒注意聽8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/80.wav", + "text": "6個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/81.wav", + "text": "還要問旁邊喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/82.wav", + "text": "好那這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/83.wav", + "text": "現在是有錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/84.wav", + "text": "對於全國的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/85.wav", + "text": "我刪你們的特別費1萬元你覺得合不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/86.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是原則的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/87.wav", + "text": "不是如果說斷絕邦交國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/88.wav", + "text": "可能也要看我們在其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/89.wav", + "text": "應該是兩個擺在一起看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/90.wav", + "text": "你有沒有看中華民國外交史你是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/91.wav", + "text": "這樣好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/92.wav", + "text": "沒有你們要保留我們就全部撤喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/93.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/94.wav", + "text": "我還沒問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/95.wav", + "text": "院長我就透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/96.wav", + "text": "今天公開提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/97.wav", + "text": "國會議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/98.wav", + "text": "去外交部抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/99.wav", + "text": "現在是換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/100.wav", + "text": "不要質詢我啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/101.wav", + "text": "那個不算是我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/102.wav", + "text": "院長這算不算質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/103.wav", + "text": "我現在宣布休息結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/104.wav", + "text": "變成刪減1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/105.wav", + "text": "元合併到第10案對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/106.wav", + "text": "那就刪減1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/107.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/108.wav", + "text": "併委員會議決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/109.wav", + "text": "也併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/110.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/111.wav", + "text": "第23案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/112.wav", + "text": "建議併委員會決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/113.wav", + "text": "有沒有去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/114.wav", + "text": "有有啦陳以信的原則都是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/115.wav", + "text": "我我要講給部長聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/116.wav", + "text": "我當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/117.wav", + "text": "國會議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/118.wav", + "text": "只有外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/119.wav", + "text": "次長到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/120.wav", + "text": "我那裡去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/121.wav", + "text": "各部會有些是主委部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/122.wav", + "text": "只有外交部我沒看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/123.wav", + "text": "連局���都很少見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/124.wav", + "text": "我不曉得外交部怎麼那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/125.wav", + "text": "部長你有幾個次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/126.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/127.wav", + "text": "部會為什麼外交部特別大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/128.wav", + "text": "這不是我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/129.wav", + "text": "我們很多委員都有這樣的看法喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/130.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/131.wav", + "text": "為什麼外交部這麼傲慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/132.wav", + "text": "外交部沒有傲慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/133.wav", + "text": "外交部是要問各委員的辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/134.wav", + "text": "哪一個人去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/135.wav", + "text": "協商預算會比較好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/136.wav", + "text": "我們都是遵照各個委員辦公室的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/137.wav", + "text": "意思來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/138.wav", + "text": "部長你真的問過我們辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/139.wav", + "text": "我這裡有表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/140.wav", + "text": "他們都有去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/141.wav", + "text": "當然不是部長去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/142.wav", + "text": "對啊部長不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/143.wav", + "text": "我想請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/144.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/145.wav", + "text": "有試著去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/146.wav", + "text": "那他怎麼說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/147.wav", + "text": "他有同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/148.wav", + "text": "因為這個是會有紀錄的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/149.wav", + "text": "你的職稱是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/150.wav", + "text": "能不能講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/151.wav", + "text": "臺日協秘書長周學佑報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/152.wav", + "text": "我們有向委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/153.wav", + "text": "你去溝通時他怎麼說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/154.wav", + "text": "他並沒有因為陳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/155.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/156.wav", + "text": "先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/157.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/158.wav", + "text": "院長我很尊重你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/159.wav", + "text": "但是6年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/160.wav", + "text": "沒有哪個次長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/161.wav", + "text": "預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/162.wav", + "text": "我怎麼可能見他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/163.wav", + "text": "一般的話坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/164.wav", + "text": "包括我們黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/165.wav", + "text": "也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/166.wav", + "text": "不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/167.wav", + "text": "他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/168.wav", + "text": "都對你們民進黨比較禮遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/169.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/170.wav", + "text": "所有黨都是法案主任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/171.wav", + "text": "他們根本見不到你們委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/172.wav", + "text": "嘛時間地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/173.wav", + "text": "都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/174.wav", + "text": "一點都沒有誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/175.wav", + "text": "休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/176.wav", + "text": "我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/177.wav", + "text": "我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/178.wav", + "text": "所以請大家包涵跟諒解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/179.wav", + "text": "大家有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/180.wav", + "text": "而且沒辦法取得共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/181.wav", + "text": "我就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/182.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/183.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/184.wav", + "text": "我有一個程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/185.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/186.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/187.wav", + "text": "國民黨已發文請院長召集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/188.wav", + "text": "我們要發現金的法案也送出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/189.wav", + "text": "沒有送出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/190.wav", + "text": "只是你們有公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/191.wav", + "text": "我們也請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/192.wav", + "text": "我不知道你要送到哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/193.wav", + "text": "現在沒有程序可以送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/194.wav", + "text": "請院長協商啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/195.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/196.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/197.wav", + "text": "要不要延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/198.wav", + "text": "現在是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/199.wav", + "text": "很多人都講一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/200.wav", + "text": "能6個月以內發完就不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/201.wav", + "text": "我的前提是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/202.wav", + "text": "如果在過年前沒有通過特別條例跟預算就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/203.wav", + "text": "就沒有辦法執行這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/204.wav", + "text": "你聽我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/205.wav", + "text": "你說6個月嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/206.wav", + "text": "我們講一個比較實際的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/207.wav", + "text": "後我知道你只有八條而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/208.wav", + "text": "排除公債法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/209.wav", + "text": "財政紀律法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/210.wav", + "text": "我們大家在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/211.wav", + "text": "件如果在12" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/212.wav", + "text": "再來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/213.wav", + "text": "以後一定會遇到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/214.wav", + "text": "因為行政院的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/215.wav", + "text": "會出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/216.wav", + "text": "送過來我們就休會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/217.wav", + "text": "我們這次到13日的議程都定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/218.wav", + "text": "也沒有再開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/219.wav", + "text": "程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/220.wav", + "text": "要如何成為一個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/221.wav", + "text": "讓它在立法院變成報告事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/222.wav", + "text": "上勢必要朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/223.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/224.wav", + "text": "我們再來面對這一題否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/225.wav", + "text": "則現在講都沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/226.wav", + "text": "因為行政院的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/227.wav", + "text": "會在禮拜四出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/228.wav", + "text": "我相信啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/229.wav", + "text": "一句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/230.wav", + "text": "還有兩個在野黨時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/231.wav", + "text": "差距就很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/232.wav", + "text": "呢所以大家要想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/233.wav", + "text": "我贊逕付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/234.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀可以表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/235.wav", + "text": "你要排朝野協商一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/236.wav", + "text": "要四黨都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/237.wav", + "text": "所以你有沒有想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/238.wav", + "text": "怎麼可能4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/239.wav", + "text": "你聽我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/240.wav", + "text": "兩件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/241.wav", + "text": "第一個是要不要延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/242.wav", + "text": "今天我們在議場有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/243.wav", + "text": "涉及到13日以後的行程安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/244.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/245.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/246.wav", + "text": "是延會之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/247.wav", + "text": "原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/248.wav", + "text": "這一題大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/249.wav", + "text": "包括我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/250.wav", + "text": "我們都裝作13日以後沒有事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/251.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/252.wav", + "text": "走多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/253.wav", + "text": "你自己想像只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/254.wav", + "text": "要一天就散戲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/255.wav", + "text": "因為大家沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/256.wav", + "text": "還有預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/257.wav", + "text": "還要院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/258.wav", + "text": "有可能4天之內完成嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/259.wav", + "text": "不可能的事情嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/260.wav", + "text": "法案要排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/261.wav", + "text": "冷凍期一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/262.wav", + "text": "其他各黨會同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/263.wav", + "text": "我們兩個不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/264.wav", + "text": "就要吵多久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/265.wav", + "text": "所以這個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/266.wav", + "text": "大概大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/267.wav", + "text": "走到這裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/268.wav", + "text": "可能的想像就是如此嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/269.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/270.wav", + "text": "時間保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/271.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/272.wav", + "text": "我剛才在門口就跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/273.wav", + "text": "總預算過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/274.wav", + "text": "不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/275.wav", + "text": "我們兩個抓去撞牆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/276.wav", + "text": "不可能沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/277.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/278.wav", + "text": "隔天來不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/279.wav", + "text": "我要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/280.wav", + "text": "真的大家要試看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/281.wav", + "text": "嘗試走這條路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/282.wav", + "text": "我建議就是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/283.wav", + "text": "延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/284.wav", + "text": "然後再延會就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/285.wav", + "text": "不要再開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/286.wav", + "text": "那要不要延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/287.wav", + "text": "用延會的比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/288.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/289.wav", + "text": "我你也要出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/290.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/291.wav", + "text": "我沒有要出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/292.wav", + "text": "為什麼你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/293.wav", + "text": "本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/294.wav", + "text": "國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/295.wav", + "text": "需要發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/296.wav", + "text": "過年前發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/297.wav", + "text": "你不覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/298.wav", + "text": "或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/299.wav", + "text": "過完年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/300.wav", + "text": "哦不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/301.wav", + "text": "我急的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/302.wav", + "text": "你統統不急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/303.wav", + "text": "然過年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/304.wav", + "text": "你要提早開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/305.wav", + "text": "這是直播的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/306.wav", + "text": "你是一個專業人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/307.wav", + "text": "你也瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/308.wav", + "text": "這整個過程有多困難光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/309.wav", + "text": "是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/310.wav", + "text": "就是個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/311.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/312.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/313.wav", + "text": "還要開程序委員會當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/314.wav", + "text": "然假設你要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/315.wav", + "text": "然後再排報告事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/316.wav", + "text": "報告事項以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/317.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/318.wav", + "text": "付委審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/319.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/320.wav", + "text": "你要改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/321.wav", + "text": "為排入朝野協" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/322.wav", + "text": "個月馬上改列討論事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/323.wav", + "text": "有可能嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/324.wav", + "text": "你自己想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/325.wav", + "text": "不可能的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/326.wav", + "text": "就是1個月以後的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/327.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/328.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/329.wav", + "text": "你急我不急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/330.wav", + "text": "你就自己會有邏輯上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/331.wav", + "text": "我補充說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/332.wav", + "text": "我講這個是很專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/333.wav", + "text": "我補充說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/334.wav", + "text": "明我們總召的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/335.wav", + "text": "你只要不聽我的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/336.wav", + "text": "你馬上會面對這個問題不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/337.wav", + "text": "不會有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/338.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/339.wav", + "text": "我當然知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/340.wav", + "text": "你說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/341.wav", + "text": "從立法面來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/342.wav", + "text": "以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/343.wav", + "text": "到底會不會遇到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/344.wav", + "text": "朝野不一致的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/345.wav", + "text": "可是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/346.wav", + "text": "當然會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/347.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/348.wav", + "text": "總召說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/349.wav", + "text": "如果經濟情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/350.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/351.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/352.wav", + "text": "發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/353.wav", + "text": "是一個良善的政策也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/354.wav", + "text": "反對發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/355.wav", + "text": "我們再來談這個事情好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/356.wav", + "text": "因為今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/357.wav", + "text": "我們在這邊討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/358.wav", + "text": "也怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/359.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/360.wav", + "text": "我們很肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/361.wav", + "text": "國民黨很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/362.wav", + "text": "也有提一個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/363.wav", + "text": "但是這一定要行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/364.wav", + "text": "才有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/365.wav", + "text": "併案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/366.wav", + "text": "院會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/367.wav", + "text": "禮拜三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/368.wav", + "text": "沒有看到臨時院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/369.wav", + "text": "所以說星期四嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/370.wav", + "text": "我們就星期五那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/371.wav", + "text": "趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/372.wav", + "text": "大家如果同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/373.wav", + "text": "期五協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/374.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/375.wav", + "text": "看是要延會或是臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/376.wav", + "text": "我們用延會當然最單純只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/377.wav", + "text": "只要有一黨反對延會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/378.wav", + "text": "列入表決事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/379.wav", + "text": "1個月以後才可以表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/380.wav", + "text": "就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/381.wav", + "text": "因為星期五就13" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/382.wav", + "text": "如果那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/383.wav", + "text": "要延會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/384.wav", + "text": "也來得及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/385.wav", + "text": "我們來討論嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/386.wav", + "text": "我們來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/387.wav", + "text": "那之前討論好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/388.wav", + "text": "比較會沒有共星" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/389.wav", + "text": "期五再星" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/390.wav", + "text": "期五來討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/391.wav", + "text": "討論好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/392.wav", + "text": "禮拜五它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/393.wav", + "text": "它一到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/394.wav", + "text": "我們馬上就開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/395.wav", + "text": "好既然院長都說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/396.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/397.wav", + "text": "及各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/398.wav", + "text": "都是有誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/399.wav", + "text": "就禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/400.wav", + "text": "來討論這個事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/401.wav", + "text": "因為除了在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/402.wav", + "text": "立法面以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/403.wav", + "text": "整個在行政面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/404.wav", + "text": "還有整個經濟面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/405.wav", + "text": "我們都應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/406.wav", + "text": "也是我們的國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/407.wav", + "text": "所以我們也不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/408.wav", + "text": "讓公務體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/409.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法做這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/410.wav", + "text": "至少要一個月以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/411.wav", + "text": "還有軟體設計等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/412.wav", + "text": "很長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/413.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/414.wav", + "text": "認為立法不能怠惰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/415.wav", + "text": "應該要優先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/416.wav", + "text": "這個事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/417.wav", + "text": "我們希望各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/418.wav", + "text": "做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/419.wav", + "text": "大家應該都聽得懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/420.wav", + "text": "總預算過後我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/421.wav", + "text": "馬上來協商這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/422.wav", + "text": "再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/423.wav", + "text": "看什麼事情都不用講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/424.wav", + "text": "我最後講一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/425.wav", + "text": "國民黨本來是很有誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/426.wav", + "text": "的第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/427.wav", + "text": "我們也希望延會到19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/428.wav", + "text": "法案也提出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/429.wav", + "text": "但反而行政單位不急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/430.wav", + "text": "你們寫的法案我也會寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/431.wav", + "text": "寫個八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/432.wav", + "text": "也可以開臨時院會那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/433.wav", + "text": "法財劃法嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/434.wav", + "text": "送行政院院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/435.wav", + "text": "民民眾黨第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/436.wav", + "text": "我覺得臨時會延會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/437.wav", + "text": "我贊同院長的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/438.wav", + "text": "因為行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/439.wav", + "text": "對案如果沒有提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/440.wav", + "text": "當然我們也肯定國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/441.wav", + "text": "提出相關的特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/442.wav", + "text": "但我在這裡要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/443.wav", + "text": "誠摯地呼籲各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/444.wav", + "text": "因為這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/445.wav", + "text": "子必須要有幾個要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/446.wav", + "text": "第二個行政院相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/447.wav", + "text": "版本出來後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/448.wav", + "text": "1,400億元發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/449.wav", + "text": "會不會包含在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/450.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/451.wav", + "text": "還有很多必須嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/452.wav", + "text": "還是必須等到行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/453.wav", + "text": "版本出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/454.wav", + "text": "如果版本出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/455.wav", + "text": "禮拜五就馬上召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/456.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/457.wav", + "text": "才有辦法繼續走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/458.wav", + "text": "民眾黨黨團的態度非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/459.wav", + "text": "要在一定的額度內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/460.wav", + "text": "當然還是要遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/461.wav", + "text": "相關的財政紀律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/462.wav", + "text": "尤其另外的1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/463.wav", + "text": "元撥補勞健保虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/464.wav", + "text": "以及1,000億元的提升經濟韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/465.wav", + "text": "部分這些相關細節都沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/466.wav", + "text": "我們也要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/467.wav", + "text": "行政院的特別條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/468.wav", + "text": "進來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/469.wav", + "text": "到底是包含哪些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/470.wav", + "text": "結果又包含另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/471.wav", + "text": "大家必須要審慎地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/472.wav", + "text": "地思考這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/473.wav", + "text": "我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/474.wav", + "text": "大家不要去爭功諉過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/475.wav", + "text": "見縫插針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/476.wav", + "text": "不是說民進黨不想發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/477.wav", + "text": "我絕對不會接受這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/478.wav", + "text": "想一想一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/479.wav", + "text": "我認為這個要非常謹慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/480.wav", + "text": "其實主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/481.wav", + "text": "在前幾天也有說明過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/482.wav", + "text": "為什麼會超徵稅額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/483.wav", + "text": "就是因為主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/484.wav", + "text": "且其因素是多重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/485.wav", + "text": "包括外在的國際情勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/486.wav", + "text": "導致臺灣的電子業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/487.wav", + "text": "及機械這兩個行業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/488.wav", + "text": "超乎預期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/489.wav", + "text": "其實就像剛卸任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/490.wav", + "text": "財政部長蘇建榮所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/491.wav", + "text": "在這樣經濟成長的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/492.wav", + "text": "有些社會上的弱勢者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/493.wav", + "text": "並沒有分享到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/494.wav", + "text": "所以才需要國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/495.wav", + "text": "來進行社會之重分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/496.wav", + "text": "且沒有排富條款的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/497.wav", + "text": "話事實上並沒有照顧到這些弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/498.wav", + "text": "應該優先去還債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/499.wav", + "text": "而不是再去花更多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/500.wav", + "text": "甚至有可能會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/501.wav", + "text": "所以這個其實是要非常謹慎好差不多了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/502.wav", + "text": "院長我想大家的意見都不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/503.wav", + "text": "同所有黨團意見都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/504.wav", + "text": "送進來之後再來召開黨團協商好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/505.wav", + "text": "我看這樣好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/506.wav", + "text": "這個部分大家有共識是15" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/507.wav", + "text": "1313日禮拜五協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/508.wav", + "text": "有助於大家想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/509.wav", + "text": "協商有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/510.wav", + "text": "14日15日是假日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/511.wav", + "text": "星期一在院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/512.wav", + "text": "就逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/513.wav", + "text": "還有程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/514.wav", + "text": "日就通過不復議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/515.wav", + "text": "送到總統那裡公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/516.wav", + "text": "總統公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/517.wav", + "text": "碼要一天吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/518.wav", + "text": "下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/519.wav", + "text": "絕對不是由行政院去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/520.wav", + "text": "各地方政府去發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/521.wav", + "text": "各地方政府如果不合作是要怎麼發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/522.wav", + "text": "地方政府會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/523.wav", + "text": "我是提出來讓大家參考啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/524.wav", + "text": "不要一直講會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/525.wav", + "text": "4天內發錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/526.wav", + "text": "不要給人家不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/527.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/528.wav", + "text": "就不像發紅包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/529.wav", + "text": "中央政府沒辦法直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/530.wav", + "text": "發一定要跟地方政府配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/531.wav", + "text": "給大家做參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/532.wav", + "text": "我們現在就針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/533.wav", + "text": "剛才第24案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/534.wav", + "text": "院長舉辦共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/535.wav", + "text": "24案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/536.wav", + "text": "24第24案第25案剛剛已洽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/537.wav", + "text": "願意改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/538.wav", + "text": "24案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/539.wav", + "text": "第25案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/540.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/541.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/542.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/543.wav", + "text": "了是不是可以請國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/544.wav", + "text": "看一下第13案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/545.wav", + "text": "個案驗收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/546.wav", + "text": "知道意思就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/547.wav", + "text": "不要留主決議好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/548.wav", + "text": "第13案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/549.wav", + "text": "我在想我們就一路看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/550.wav", + "text": "你們先記起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/551.wav", + "text": "再回頭等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/552.wav", + "text": "24案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/553.wav", + "text": "第25案都改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/554.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/555.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/556.wav", + "text": "沒有意��通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/557.wav", + "text": "改凍結50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/558.wav", + "text": "元沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/559.wav", + "text": "29" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/560.wav", + "text": "案通刪通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/561.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/562.wav", + "text": "第29案我們要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/563.wav", + "text": "29案通刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/564.wav", + "text": "通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/565.wav", + "text": "30案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/566.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/567.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/568.wav", + "text": "改凍結100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/569.wav", + "text": "元沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/570.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/571.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/572.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/573.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/574.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/575.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/576.wav", + "text": "36案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/577.wav", + "text": "凍結十分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/578.wav", + "text": "是不是要併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/579.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/580.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/581.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/582.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/583.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/584.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/585.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/586.wav", + "text": "我們來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/587.wav", + "text": "39案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/588.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/589.wav", + "text": "40案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/590.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/591.wav", + "text": "外交部替吳怡農助選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/592.wav", + "text": "總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/593.wav", + "text": "黑熊學院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/594.wav", + "text": "到黑熊學院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/595.wav", + "text": "我記得這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/596.wav", + "text": "也有很多委員質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/597.wav", + "text": "外交部應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/598.wav", + "text": "已經都說明過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/599.wav", + "text": "你們再跟提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/600.wav", + "text": "再說明一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/601.wav", + "text": "誰提案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/602.wav", + "text": "就暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/603.wav", + "text": "改主決議就好第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/604.wav", + "text": "40案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/605.wav", + "text": "\n第44案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/606.wav", + "text": "不同意併委員會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/607.wav", + "text": "這個保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/608.wav", + "text": "不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/609.wav", + "text": "保留是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/610.wav", + "text": "改主決議可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/611.wav", + "text": "不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/612.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/613.wav", + "text": "\n第46案凍結360萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/614.wav", + "text": "陳以信委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/615.wav", + "text": "併委員會好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/616.wav", + "text": "同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/617.wav", + "text": "同意啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/618.wav", + "text": "對那邊已經凍3,600萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/619.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/620.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/621.wav", + "text": "我們也併委員會決議辦理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/622.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/623.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/624.wav", + "text": "\n第48案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/625.wav", + "text": "\n第49案通刪通案辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/626.wav", + "text": "案併委員會決議辦理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/627.wav", + "text": "因為委員會已經凍結7,000萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/628.wav", + "text": "我們就併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/629.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/630.wav", + "text": "\n第65案第66案都併委員會決議辦理沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/631.wav", + "text": "\n第67案通刪通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/632.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/633.wav", + "text": "如果大家不反對就併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/634.wav", + "text": "賴委員說要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/635.wav", + "text": "獎補助是通案嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/636.wav", + "text": "先保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/637.wav", + "text": "\n第79案跟第80案併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/638.wav", + "text": "\n第81案改主決議沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/639.wav", + "text": "\n第88案也通刪通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/640.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/641.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理就是照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/642.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/643.wav", + "text": "好那就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/644.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/645.wav", + "text": "建請修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/646.wav", + "text": "3案主決議修正文字沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/647.wav", + "text": "建請修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/648.wav", + "text": "好修正文字沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/649.wav", + "text": "建請修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/650.wav", + "text": "修正文字沒有意見修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/651.wav", + "text": "看一下第95案的文字修正我們剛拿到案子不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/652.wav", + "text": "我請教一下外交部這個修正文字是有跟提案委員溝通過還是你們自己建議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/653.wav", + "text": "自己建議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/654.wav", + "text": "是這樣子某種程度上不管今天是哪一個委員提的案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/655.wav", + "text": "有沒有尊重人啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/656.wav", + "text": "這是黨團提案就是現在跟你們討論因為黨團提案的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/657.wav", + "text": "沒有錯但是我的意思是行政部門沒有跟個別委員溝通沒有跟提案委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/658.wav", + "text": "第95案保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/659.wav", + "text": "第95案我們就保留吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/660.wav", + "text": "第95案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/661.wav", + "text": "96案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/662.wav", + "text": "第96案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/663.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/664.wav", + "text": "第97案就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/665.wav", + "text": "98案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/666.wav", + "text": "第98案保留是吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/667.wav", + "text": "98案保留是吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/668.wav", + "text": "我看第98案也保留吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/669.wav", + "text": "因為他不只是刪除是根本已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/670.wav", + "text": "照他們的意思來寫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/671.wav", + "text": "我覺得這變成是一個新的提案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/672.wav", + "text": "第幾案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/673.wav", + "text": "95案第96案第98案先保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/674.wav", + "text": "然後怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/675.wav", + "text": "如果以後外交部要這樣乾脆外交部寫一些提案給我們提好了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/676.wav", + "text": "外交部根本就變成是你們自己在做文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/677.wav", + "text": "然後也不跟提案委員討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/678.wav", + "text": "今天不是只站在國民黨黨團的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/679.wav", + "text": "我覺得各黨團都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/680.wav", + "text": "面對到這樣的我覺得都是行政部門不尊重立法部門的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/681.wav", + "text": "是不是先保留然後再溝通嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/682.wav", + "text": "好第98案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/683.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/684.wav", + "text": "第99案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/685.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/686.wav", + "text": "有意見就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/687.wav", + "text": "第99案也保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/688.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/689.wav", + "text": "修正文字有沒有等一下我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/690.wav", + "text": "看一下第98" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/691.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/692.wav", + "text": "沒人這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/693.wav", + "text": "這個是外交部的提案這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/694.wav", + "text": "不他幫你寫得很整齊啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/695.wav", + "text": "很好看啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/696.wav", + "text": "派員跟委員溝通啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/697.wav", + "text": "你可以更改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/698.wav", + "text": "跟大家討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/699.wav", + "text": "你不可以整個改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/700.wav", + "text": "這是不尊重啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/701.wav", + "text": "沒關係因為他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/702.wav", + "text": "不同意我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/703.wav", + "text": "不院長不是不同意保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/704.wav", + "text": "中華民國的外交部怎麼這樣子啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/705.wav", + "text": "不是改文字而是自己打完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/706.wav", + "text": "中國國民黨立法院黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/707.wav", + "text": "好啦建議先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/708.wav", + "text": "溝通一下啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/709.wav", + "text": "第100案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/710.wav", + "text": "不好意思院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/711.wav", + "text": "我必須要在這裡說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/712.wav", + "text": "因為外交部目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/713.wav", + "text": "給委員參考他們修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/714.wav", + "text": "文字的部分都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/715.wav", + "text": "把他們修正的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/716.wav", + "text": "看起來就像是他們寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/717.wav", + "text": "其實大部分都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/718.wav", + "text": "國民黨原本的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/719.wav", + "text": "但是到底外交部改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/720.wav", + "text": "修改各部會都會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/721.wav", + "text": "在哪個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/722.wav", + "text": "主決議哪個部分做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/723.wav", + "text": "要我們在這裡看這是他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/724.wav", + "text": "自己在拖時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/725.wav", + "text": "沒有追蹤修訂的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/726.wav", + "text": "我我建議外交部從第1案開始哪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/727.wav", + "text": "有人這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/728.wav", + "text": "該保留就保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/729.wav", + "text": "不喜歡的就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/730.wav", + "text": "第100案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/731.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/732.wav", + "text": "第101案已跟委員辦公室溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/733.wav", + "text": "同意文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/734.wav", + "text": "後沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/735.wav", + "text": "修正在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/736.wav", + "text": "我知道可是問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/737.wav", + "text": "各部會來修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/738.wav", + "text": "而不是像你們這樣全篇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/739.wav", + "text": "寫成一個新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/740.wav", + "text": "這個是有修正委員同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/741.wav", + "text": "嘛在哪裡把它畫出來就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/742.wav", + "text": "同意有沒有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/743.wav", + "text": "鵬去輔導一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/744.wav", + "text": "沒有啦同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/745.wav", + "text": "委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/746.wav", + "text": "外交部還是要在原提案上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/747.wav", + "text": "然後要給委員確認並簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/748.wav", + "text": "若用打新的一份出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/749.wav", + "text": "這樣沒有辦法審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/750.wav", + "text": "這個第101案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/751.wav", + "text": "跟原來的提案差很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/752.wav", + "text": "很多很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/753.wav", + "text": "有溝通要給委員簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/754.wav", + "text": "委員如果都沒簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/755.wav", + "text": "我建議外交部這份新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/756.wav", + "text": "你們全部都保留然後重新溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/757.wav", + "text": "啦如果是委員有簽字的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/758.wav", + "text": "同意的你們再拿出來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/759.wav", + "text": "這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/760.wav", + "text": "要保留的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/761.wav", + "text": "請外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/762.wav", + "text": "院長就剩下第101" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/763.wav", + "text": "我們不知道到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/764.wav", + "text": "啦應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/765.wav", + "text": "看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/766.wav", + "text": "\n這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/767.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/768.wav", + "text": "102案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/769.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/770.wav", + "text": "沒有意見我們就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/771.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/772.wav", + "text": "有作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/773.wav", + "text": "沒有意見我們就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/774.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/775.wav", + "text": "好那就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/776.wav", + "text": "\n第108案主決議已經有作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/777.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/778.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/779.wav", + "text": "\n第109案主決議也有作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/780.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/781.wav", + "text": "好那就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/782.wav", + "text": "作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/783.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/784.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/785.wav", + "text": "116案主決議照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/786.wav", + "text": "好那就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/787.wav", + "text": "這個怎麼可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/788.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/789.wav", + "text": "機密提案��公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/790.wav", + "text": "是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/791.wav", + "text": "這個是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/792.wav", + "text": "要不要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/793.wav", + "text": "是同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/794.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/795.wav", + "text": "它原來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/796.wav", + "text": "在機密預算的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/797.wav", + "text": "後來修正文字之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/798.wav", + "text": "改成公開的主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/799.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/800.wav", + "text": "我們就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/801.wav", + "text": "案併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/802.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/803.wav", + "text": "\n第120案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/804.wav", + "text": "就通案辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/805.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/806.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/807.wav", + "text": "報告主席改減列20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/808.wav", + "text": "元科目自調已經經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/809.wav", + "text": "好科目自行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/810.wav", + "text": "126案第127案第128案第129" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/811.wav", + "text": "案通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/812.wav", + "text": "通通刪就通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/813.wav", + "text": "第130案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/814.wav", + "text": "案改凍結50萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/815.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/816.wav", + "text": "第131案改凍結100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/817.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/818.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/819.wav", + "text": "3案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/820.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/821.wav", + "text": "好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/822.wav", + "text": "剩下的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/823.wav", + "text": "我們就自行調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/824.wav", + "text": "我們自己來協調就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/825.wav", + "text": "因為有一些保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/826.wav", + "text": "提案如果保留到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/827.wav", + "text": "院會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/828.wav", + "text": "所以請外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/829.wav", + "text": "跟提案的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/830.wav", + "text": "趕快溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/831.wav", + "text": "我們可以修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/832.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/833.wav", + "text": "沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/834.wav", + "text": "現在有沒有要回頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/835.wav", + "text": "第13案是第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/836.wav", + "text": "13案是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/837.wav", + "text": "發包案的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/838.wav", + "text": "你用主決議��方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/839.wav", + "text": "要求他們提檢討報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/840.wav", + "text": "那為什麼他們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/841.wav", + "text": "因為委員辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/842.wav", + "text": "是不是也有跟他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/843.wav", + "text": "討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/844.wav", + "text": "這樣主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/845.wav", + "text": "不然第13案先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/846.wav", + "text": "好好先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/847.wav", + "text": "履約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/848.wav", + "text": "要求他們做什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/849.wav", + "text": "對可是因為它是公開招標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/850.wav", + "text": "既然是公開招標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/851.wav", + "text": "這是履約爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/852.wav", + "text": "我們就先把第13案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/853.wav", + "text": "它連公司都寫出來了履約爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/854.wav", + "text": "用主決議處理比較不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/855.wav", + "text": "好第13案就暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/856.wav", + "text": "\n還有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/857.wav", + "text": "還有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/858.wav", + "text": "要再考慮一下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/859.wav", + "text": "接下來我們要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/860.wav", + "text": "機密預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/861.wav", + "text": "外交部機密預算部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/862.wav", + "text": "原有協商提案1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/863.wav", + "text": "經溝通後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/864.wav", + "text": "同意改為公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/865.wav", + "text": "在此宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/866.wav", + "text": "112年度公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/867.wav", + "text": "外交部機密預算部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/868.wav", + "text": "照外交及國防委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/869.wav", + "text": "審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/870.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/871.wav", + "text": "它已經改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/872.wav", + "text": "公開所以就沒有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/873.wav", + "text": "其他的都處理完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/874.wav", + "text": "就已經在這個案子又改成公開的主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/875.wav", + "text": "外交及國防委員會審過了那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/876.wav", + "text": "我們都不用協商嗎不用需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/877.wav", + "text": "需要協商的1案已經改成公開主決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/878.wav", + "text": "剛才有1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/879.wav", + "text": "1案已經改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/880.wav", + "text": "委員會審過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/881.wav", + "text": "這就是其中一個案現在已經改成公開主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/882.wav", + "text": "國防外交的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/883.wav", + "text": "我們在協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/884.wav", + "text": "公開的都已經過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/885.wav", + "text": "那外交呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/886.wav", + "text": "外交本來有1個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/887.wav", + "text": "它改公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/888.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/889.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的那個改成公開的主決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/890.wav", + "text": "第二輪的通案對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/891.wav", + "text": "通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/892.wav", + "text": "那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/893.wav", + "text": "國防部有4個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/894.wav", + "text": "再來是通案內政外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/895.wav", + "text": "經濟財政教育交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/896.wav", + "text": "司法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/897.wav", + "text": "這樣一輪我們一個一個來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/898.wav", + "text": "總共還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/899.wav", + "text": "現在是不是先讓外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/900.wav", + "text": "離開好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/901.wav", + "text": "580案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/902.wav", + "text": "有關外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/903.wav", + "text": "想辦法再協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/904.wav", + "text": "如果協商一有結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/905.wav", + "text": "就給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/906.wav", + "text": "然後你們現在可以先離席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/907.wav", + "text": "好謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/908.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/909.wav", + "text": "請大家就位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/910.wav", + "text": "第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/911.wav", + "text": "的協商先從通案開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/912.wav", + "text": "講一口價就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/913.wav", + "text": "有沒有談的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/914.wav", + "text": "我們講有行情的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/915.wav", + "text": "金額隨便加的都沒意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/916.wav", + "text": "好大家意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/917.wav", + "text": "他已經建議出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/918.wav", + "text": "問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/919.wav", + "text": "這個是很專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/920.wav", + "text": "你你是比他專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/921.wav", + "text": "比誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/922.wav", + "text": "你要問的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/923.wav", + "text": "這樣我反而講不下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/924.wav", + "text": "不要不會啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/925.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/926.wav", + "text": "你原來編出稅課收入多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/927.wav", + "text": "原來編的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/928.wav", + "text": "比去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/929.wav", + "text": "增加14.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/930.wav", + "text": "也就是增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/931.wav", + "text": "2,711億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/932.wav", + "text": "在委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/933.wav", + "text": "又增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/934.wav", + "text": "81.5億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/935.wav", + "text": "元換句話說兩個加起來大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/936.wav", + "text": "2,792億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/937.wav", + "text": "元\n剛才柯總召的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/938.wav", + "text": "我們是不是再加100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/939.wav", + "text": "變成181.5億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/940.wav", + "text": "總共加到多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/941.wav", + "text": "這樣大概接近3,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/942.wav", + "text": "去年的預算數比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/943.wav", + "text": "增加3,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/944.wav", + "text": "好今天已經公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/945.wav", + "text": "布去年超收多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/946.wav", + "text": "後面是零頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/947.wav", + "text": "3,824" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/948.wav", + "text": "那個最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/949.wav", + "text": "統籌分配稅款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/950.wav", + "text": "不管什麼稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/951.wav", + "text": "那是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/952.wav", + "text": "給地方的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/953.wav", + "text": "我知道這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/954.wav", + "text": "去年的總數稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/955.wav", + "text": "對那是全國數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/956.wav", + "text": "總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/957.wav", + "text": "增加4,950" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/958.wav", + "text": "3,824" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/959.wav", + "text": "2,892" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/960.wav", + "text": "年9月以後就開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/961.wav", + "text": "已經往下掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/962.wav", + "text": "所以我是說這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/963.wav", + "text": "要給我們一點彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/964.wav", + "text": "增加的2,892億元是跟以前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/965.wav", + "text": "預算數比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/966.wav", + "text": "但是你跟去年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/967.wav", + "text": "超收比還是負成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/968.wav", + "text": "但我們還是增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/969.wav", + "text": "哪會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/970.wav", + "text": "你現在比預算數增加2,892" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/971.wav", + "text": "但是你去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/972.wav", + "text": "超收3,824" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/973.wav", + "text": "億元所以還是負成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/974.wav", + "text": "最主要是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/975.wav", + "text": "上市櫃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/976.wav", + "text": "再來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/977.wav", + "text": "它的經濟成長率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/978.wav", + "text": "6.53%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/979.wav", + "text": "去年的經濟成長率是3.06" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/980.wav", + "text": "但是稅收超收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/981.wav", + "text": "整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/982.wav", + "text": "我的意思是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/983.wav", + "text": "經濟有往下所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/984.wav", + "text": "希望能給我們一點彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/985.wav", + "text": "不要拉太高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/986.wav", + "text": "部長我再問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/987.wav", + "text": "去年與前年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/988.wav", + "text": "6.53" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/989.wav", + "text": "但稅收還超收這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/990.wav", + "text": "目前就已經是3.05" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/991.wav", + "text": "所以已經是往下調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/992.wav", + "text": "的營所稅增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/993.wav", + "text": "但並不是每個產業都很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/994.wav", + "text": "是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/995.wav", + "text": "院長抱歉我請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/996.wav", + "text": "如果這樣子是增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/997.wav", + "text": "是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/998.wav", + "text": "就是增加100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/999.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1000.wav", + "text": "立院的品質不能100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1001.wav", + "text": "元200億元這樣的喊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1002.wav", + "text": "啊應該是要算比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1003.wav", + "text": "總預算是1兆2兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1004.wav", + "text": "元那100億元沒有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1005.wav", + "text": "100億元或200億元那都是相對數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1006.wav", + "text": "應該要說我們增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1007.wav", + "text": "了1%或是增加0.5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1008.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1009.wav", + "text": "我們同仁算出來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1010.wav", + "text": "增加0.8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1011.wav", + "text": "都是貴黨的精英在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1012.wav", + "text": "然後他們審查的結果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1013.wav", + "text": "增加81億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1014.wav", + "text": "元到這裡後我們增加1倍算是差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1015.wav", + "text": "我們馬上來決定就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1016.wav", + "text": "用比例來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1017.wav", + "text": "應該是用比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1018.wav", + "text": "我們也都在財政委員會待過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1019.wav", + "text": "財政委員會的費鴻泰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1020.wav", + "text": "委員會送來的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1021.wav", + "text": "不過是81.5億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1022.wav", + "text": "來到這邊就多了100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1023.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨提這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1024.wav", + "text": "主要還是希望相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1025.wav", + "text": "的財政部還有主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1026.wav", + "text": "在相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1027.wav", + "text": "預估上要更準確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1028.wav", + "text": "更務實其實就近7年稅收超徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1029.wav", + "text": "及舉債的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1030.wav", + "text": "一方面低報然後超徵的的數額過大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1031.wav", + "text": "另一方面又用特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1032.wav", + "text": "去做常態化的舉債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1033.wav", + "text": "已經審議了金額大概是81億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1034.wav", + "text": "元今天有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1035.wav", + "text": "平均數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1036.wav", + "text": "就像2016年超收額度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1037.wav", + "text": "是1,278億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1038.wav", + "text": "元2017年是960億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1039.wav", + "text": "元諸如此類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1040.wav", + "text": "到了2020年則是短徵222億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1041.wav", + "text": "元這2年確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1042.wav", + "text": "我們必須承認是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1043.wav", + "text": "COVID-19相關半導體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1044.wav", + "text": "第四季也開始轉藍燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1045.wav", + "text": "今年的景氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1046.wav", + "text": "說實在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1047.wav", + "text": "也不是那麼樂觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1048.wav", + "text": "所以針對今天的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1049.wav", + "text": "務實精準的預估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1050.wav", + "text": "如果說今天大家也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1051.wav", + "text": "再增列100億元原則上民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1052.wav", + "text": "是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1053.wav", + "text": "其實我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1054.wav", + "text": "那時候你們在算歲入歲出的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1055.wav", + "text": "一定有一些相關的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1056.wav", + "text": "背景知識以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1057.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得以後你們的專業我們也不要信了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1058.wav", + "text": "我們講結論就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1059.wav", + "text": "讓時代力量講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1060.wav", + "text": "增加嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1061.wav", + "text": "我想要瞭解一下就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1062.wav", + "text": "歲入比去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1063.wav", + "text": "問題是歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1064.wav", + "text": "歷年來創新高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1065.wav", + "text": "因為增長幅度很大歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1066.wav", + "text": "編列比去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1067.wav", + "text": "增加多少亦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1068.wav", + "text": "那大概是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1069.wav", + "text": "差額大概是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1070.wav", + "text": "編列在特別預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1071.wav", + "text": "我們現在移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1072.wav", + "text": "到歲出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1073.wav", + "text": "4,680" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1074.wav", + "text": "億元因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1075.wav", + "text": "一般預算來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1076.wav", + "text": "最主要是去年跟前年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1077.wav", + "text": "增加來得多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1078.wav", + "text": "其實在過去一年是赤字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1079.wav", + "text": "增加數都是瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1080.wav", + "text": "現在就是新的年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1081.wav", + "text": "可能經濟的成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1082.wav", + "text": "也不是很樂觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1083.wav", + "text": "們一個比較寬鬆的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1084.wav", + "text": "執政黨團有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1085.wav", + "text": "181.5億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1086.wav", + "text": "元可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1087.wav", + "text": "大家同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1088.wav", + "text": "我數字有說錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1089.wav", + "text": "嗎181.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1090.wav", + "text": "200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1091.wav", + "text": "連同委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1092.wav", + "text": "81" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1093.wav", + "text": "81.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1094.wav", + "text": "81.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1095.wav", + "text": "就200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1096.wav", + "text": "元啦通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1097.wav", + "text": "一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1098.wav", + "text": "好那就通過啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1099.wav", + "text": "啦\n第13案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1100.wav", + "text": "有建議修改文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1101.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下對第1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1102.wav", + "text": "主決議的修改文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1103.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1104.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1105.wav", + "text": "程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1106.wav", + "text": "因為第二輪的確都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1107.wav", + "text": "一些比較有爭議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1108.wav", + "text": "案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1109.wav", + "text": "如果每個案子討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1110.wav", + "text": "超過15分鐘就予以保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1111.wav", + "text": "這樣好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1112.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有共識我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1113.wav", + "text": "15分鐘也夠長了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1114.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1115.wav", + "text": "沒有的話主決議就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1116.wav", + "text": "就文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1117.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1118.wav", + "text": "16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1119.wav", + "text": "已經有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1120.wav", + "text": "第13案保留一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1121.wav", + "text": "第13案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1122.wav", + "text": "第13案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1123.wav", + "text": "16案已經有文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1124.wav", + "text": "修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1125.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1126.wav", + "text": "保留一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1127.wav", + "text": "就是第13案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1128.wav", + "text": "請記錄下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1129.wav", + "text": "\n現在處理內政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1130.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1131.wav", + "text": "在繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1132.wav", + "text": "內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1133.wav", + "text": "行政院主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1134.wav", + "text": "分\n第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1135.wav", + "text": "2案也是通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1136.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1137.wav", + "text": "對他這也可以保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1138.wav", + "text": "就叫賴士葆自己來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1139.wav", + "text": "這是我的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1140.wav", + "text": "第3案我只問一件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1141.wav", + "text": "事現在中央行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1142.wav", + "text": "有那麼多的任務編組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1143.wav", + "text": "什麼會報不會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1144.wav", + "text": "的到底有沒有照編列的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1145.wav", + "text": "來開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1146.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1147.wav", + "text": "治安會報上一次開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1148.wav", + "text": "是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1149.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告後天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1150.wav", + "text": "還要再開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1151.wav", + "text": "治安會報條例的規定是二個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1152.wav", + "text": "要開一次由行政院院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1153.wav", + "text": "上一次開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1154.wav", + "text": "是不是去年9月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1155.wav", + "text": "去年9月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1156.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1157.wav", + "text": "那就是坐實了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1158.wav", + "text": "我這個提案的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1159.wav", + "text": "治安會報應該二個月召開一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1160.wav", + "text": "結果現在最新一期的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1161.wav", + "text": "治安會報居然是去年9月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1162.wav", + "text": "已經高達四個多月沒有開會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1163.wav", + "text": "這中間的過程有發生什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1164.wav", + "text": "臺南發生88槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1165.wav", + "text": "青埔等那麼多地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1166.wav", + "text": "有人蛇勒索" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1167.wav", + "text": "集團犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1168.wav", + "text": "治安都不重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1169.wav", + "text": "是不是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1170.wav", + "text": "沒有任何討論的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1171.wav", + "text": "第3案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1172.wav", + "text": "是不是併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1173.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1174.wav", + "text": "建請修正文字改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1175.wav", + "text": "也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1176.wav", + "text": "請回答我一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1177.wav", + "text": "去年303大停電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1178.wav", + "text": "問過行政院長蘇貞昌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1179.wav", + "text": "蘇院長說一個月內要回覆國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1180.wav", + "text": "我們只問303大停電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1181.wav", + "text": "到底臺灣經濟損失多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1182.wav", + "text": "有沒有推估過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1183.wav", + "text": "院長口頭承諾說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1184.wav", + "text": "會請經濟部進行推估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1185.wav", + "text": "並且告訴國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1186.wav", + "text": "303大停電那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1187.wav", + "text": "到底造成我們的經濟損失多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1188.wav", + "text": "都已經報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1189.wav", + "text": "沒有經濟部沒有報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1190.wav", + "text": "經濟部從頭到尾沒有報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1191.wav", + "text": "就是因為沒有報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1192.wav", + "text": "所以我才來問行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1193.wav", + "text": "是要跟委員解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1194.wav", + "text": "產業用戶的型態很多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1195.wav", + "text": "好啦我想應該是講不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1196.wav", + "text": "那就保留吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1197.wav", + "text": "好第19案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1198.wav", + "text": "建請修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1199.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1200.wav", + "text": "可以嗎修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1201.wav", + "text": "第56案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1202.wav", + "text": "好第56案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1203.wav", + "text": "60案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1204.wav", + "text": "建請修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1205.wav", + "text": "是不是可以照修正文字通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1206.wav", + "text": "涉外民事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1207.wav", + "text": "有沒有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1208.wav", + "text": "的部分也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1209.wav", + "text": "有溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1210.wav", + "text": "但委員還不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1211.wav", + "text": "好那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1212.wav", + "text": "協商如果大家沒有共識要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1213.wav", + "text": "那就快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1214.wav", + "text": "今天晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1215.wav", + "text": "三輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1216.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1217.wav", + "text": "看起來12點處理不代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1218.wav", + "text": "性的��留就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1219.wav", + "text": "下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1220.wav", + "text": "這是原住民族委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1221.wav", + "text": "行政院主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1222.wav", + "text": "保留8案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1223.wav", + "text": "哪幾案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1224.wav", + "text": "院長再check一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1225.wav", + "text": "已經保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1226.wav", + "text": "改主決議有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1227.wav", + "text": "第99案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1228.wav", + "text": "改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1229.wav", + "text": "原住民委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1230.wav", + "text": "了他們有努力溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1231.wav", + "text": "啦謝謝主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1232.wav", + "text": "\n有關中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1233.wav", + "text": "我們的這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1234.wav", + "text": "是希望做文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1235.wav", + "text": "請邱委員能夠諒解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1236.wav", + "text": "真的是有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1237.wav", + "text": "尤其是我們跟監所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1238.wav", + "text": "沒有任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1239.wav", + "text": "這個我有問過法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1240.wav", + "text": "法務部的立場是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1241.wav", + "text": "配合中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1242.wav", + "text": "所以這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1243.wav", + "text": "好中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1244.wav", + "text": "第174案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1245.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1246.wav", + "text": "210案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1247.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1248.wav", + "text": "再來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1249.wav", + "text": "不當黨產處理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1250.wav", + "text": "不當黨產處理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1251.wav", + "text": "有2個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1252.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1253.wav", + "text": "是內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1254.wav", + "text": "代理部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1255.wav", + "text": "已經到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1256.wav", + "text": "院長這一案要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1257.wav", + "text": "這個有講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1258.wav", + "text": "院長等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1259.wav", + "text": "247案要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1260.wav", + "text": "這是你們提案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1261.wav", + "text": "啊你們提案凍結100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1262.wav", + "text": "人家沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1263.wav", + "text": "要讓你們凍結100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1264.wav", + "text": "可以啦就凍結100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1265.wav", + "text": "247案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1266.wav", + "text": "凍結100萬吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1267.wav", + "text": "委員會凍100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1268.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1269.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1270.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1271.wav", + "text": "書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1272.wav", + "text": "251案提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1273.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1274.wav", + "text": "都是涉外民事都是同一第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1275.wav", + "text": "253案因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1276.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員說都沒來談過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1277.wav", + "text": "以後再講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1278.wav", + "text": "沒有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1279.wav", + "text": "因為你這個部分跟司法院都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1280.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1281.wav", + "text": "謝謝\n第254案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1282.wav", + "text": "好像滿大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1283.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1284.wav", + "text": "第269案改主決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1285.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1286.wav", + "text": "案改凍結科目凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1287.wav", + "text": "50萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1288.wav", + "text": "案凍結50萬元改科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1289.wav", + "text": "案到第389" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1290.wav", + "text": "案合併為1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1291.wav", + "text": "凍結100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1292.wav", + "text": "文字做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1293.wav", + "text": "院長我們這邊想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1294.wav", + "text": "什麼時候要出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1295.wav", + "text": "這是戶政資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1296.wav", + "text": "因為你們來講的時候也說這是戶政資料外洩的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1297.wav", + "text": "那應該沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1298.wav", + "text": "你們來溝通的時候都這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1299.wav", + "text": "現在就是說戶政資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1300.wav", + "text": "我們當然不排除它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1301.wav", + "text": "是以戶政資料為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1302.wav", + "text": "但是這部分調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1303.wav", + "text": "跟委員跟大眾來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1304.wav", + "text": "沒有啦這個沒什麼好說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1305.wav", + "text": "很多種可能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1306.wav", + "text": "情況並不是戶政司的系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1307.wav", + "text": "對我知道我了解這是戶政資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1308.wav", + "text": "但是流失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1309.wav", + "text": "你去調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1310.wav", + "text": "也許不是你的問題我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1311.wav", + "text": "就是兩個月提出調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1312.wav", + "text": "給國人一個交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1313.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1314.wav", + "text": "凍結100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1315.wav", + "text": "文字修正為兩個月內提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1316.wav", + "text": "書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1317.wav", + "text": "凍結數是併委員會的凍結數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1318.wav", + "text": "那就這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1319.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1320.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1321.wav", + "text": "第395案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1322.wav", + "text": "上次的第398" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1323.wav", + "text": "案等4案合併減列5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1324.wav", + "text": "併入第391" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1325.wav", + "text": "因為上次第391案刪了50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1326.wav", + "text": "你現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1327.wav", + "text": "我講一下好了內政資訊業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1328.wav", + "text": "第391案上次黨團協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1329.wav", + "text": "已經刪了50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1330.wav", + "text": "元這些都是內政資訊業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1331.wav", + "text": "案都是內政資訊業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1332.wav", + "text": "內政資訊業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1333.wav", + "text": "四億800多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1334.wav", + "text": "\n賴士葆委員的4個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1335.wav", + "text": "總預算多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1336.wav", + "text": "趕快講一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1337.wav", + "text": "沒有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1338.wav", + "text": "你們已經寫在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1339.wav", + "text": "了就表示你們有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1340.wav", + "text": "那我們尊重委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1341.wav", + "text": "好我再唸一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1342.wav", + "text": "就照他們已經溝通的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1343.wav", + "text": "404案改減列15萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1344.wav", + "text": "元沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1345.wav", + "text": "第403案呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1346.wav", + "text": "不同意不同意第403案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1347.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1348.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1349.wav", + "text": "其他的就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1350.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1351.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1352.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1353.wav", + "text": "433案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1354.wav", + "text": "有作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1355.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1356.wav", + "text": "內政部有沒有作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1357.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1358.wav", + "text": "案主決議作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1359.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1360.wav", + "text": "他們要改書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1361.wav", + "text": "那保���好了保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1362.wav", + "text": "那不是一樣的案子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1363.wav", + "text": "前面都一樣嘛已經併過一案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1364.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1365.wav", + "text": "案併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1366.wav", + "text": "464第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1367.wav", + "text": "464改凍結1,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1368.wav", + "text": "好第466案改凍結1,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1369.wav", + "text": "案有沒有新的消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1370.wav", + "text": "不然就凍結15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1371.wav", + "text": "第467案改主決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1372.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1373.wav", + "text": "案改凍結300萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1374.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1375.wav", + "text": "因為他們都有做溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1376.wav", + "text": "案都改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1377.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1378.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1379.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1380.wav", + "text": "那不是已經改主決議了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1381.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有我沒有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1382.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1383.wav", + "text": "我在跟曾委員聊天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1384.wav", + "text": "517案第518" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1385.wav", + "text": "所以均改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1386.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1387.wav", + "text": "案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1388.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1389.wav", + "text": "第524案應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1390.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1391.wav", + "text": "併第533" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1392.wav", + "text": "併第533" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1393.wav", + "text": "併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1394.wav", + "text": "啦但是他有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1395.wav", + "text": "案併在一起然後凍100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1396.wav", + "text": "100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1397.wav", + "text": "是因為現在都是婦幼大隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1398.wav", + "text": "所以他希望能夠在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1399.wav", + "text": "婦幼大隊中增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1400.wav", + "text": "專案性的小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1401.wav", + "text": "來提供足夠的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1402.wav", + "text": "因應剛剛通過的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1403.wav", + "text": "這個好像在委員會沒有凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1404.wav", + "text": "所以他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1405.wav", + "text": "改主決議啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1406.wav", + "text": "我們會調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1407.wav", + "text": "專責單位我們會調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1408.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1409.wav", + "text": "它會跟第533案併在一起嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1410.wav", + "text": "好像他後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1411.wav", + "text": "還有一個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1412.wav", + "text": "沒有凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1413.wav", + "text": "也可以併委員會決議辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1414.wav", + "text": "理就變成委員會的減列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1415.wav", + "text": "委員會的這樣也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1416.wav", + "text": "那就併委員會然後提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1417.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1418.wav", + "text": "改主決議因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1419.wav", + "text": "你說同上第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1420.wav", + "text": "517案第518案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1421.wav", + "text": "保留一個就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1422.wav", + "text": "我再講一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1423.wav", + "text": "526案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1424.wav", + "text": "第527案改主決議第528案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1425.wav", + "text": "以上3案沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1426.wav", + "text": "案均改主決議沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1427.wav", + "text": "案有提主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1428.wav", + "text": "有關於它的刪減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1429.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1430.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1431.wav", + "text": "一個主決議嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1432.wav", + "text": "就變成一個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1433.wav", + "text": "子一個案子就是主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1434.wav", + "text": "主決議這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1435.wav", + "text": "546第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1436.wav", + "text": "546案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1437.wav", + "text": "好第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1438.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1439.wav", + "text": "都保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1440.wav", + "text": "如果是同一個案子保留一個就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1441.wav", + "text": "576案併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1442.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1443.wav", + "text": "已經有做文字修正沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1444.wav", + "text": "600" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1445.wav", + "text": "這是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1446.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1447.wav", + "text": "邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1448.wav", + "text": "你們在第234" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1449.wav", + "text": "第600案都一個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1450.wav", + "text": "子都同一個案由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1451.wav", + "text": "你要保留那麼多嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1452.wav", + "text": "科目不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1453.wav", + "text": "保留下去就是同樣的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1454.wav", + "text": "有關於剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1455.wav", + "text": "但是保留滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1456.wav", + "text": "我們請內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1457.wav", + "text": "還是要派人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1458.wav", + "text": "如果是同樣的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1459.wav", + "text": "希望他專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1460.wav", + "text": "沒關係可以再跟他如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1461.wav", + "text": "他是報告好幾份還是要一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1462.wav", + "text": "因為之前他們這個沒有來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1463.wav", + "text": "案由都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1464.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1465.wav", + "text": "不用在這邊講內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1466.wav", + "text": "於內政部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1467.wav", + "text": "我剛才已經有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1468.wav", + "text": "請內政部一定要派人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1469.wav", + "text": "人想辦法溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1470.wav", + "text": "減少保留數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1471.wav", + "text": "沒有意見我們就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1472.wav", + "text": "啦謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1473.wav", + "text": "部不必來\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1474.wav", + "text": "就座現在針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1475.wav", + "text": "國防部主管及所屬部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1476.wav", + "text": "到底有幾案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1477.wav", + "text": "還有國安局2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1478.wav", + "text": "636萬1,000關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1479.wav", + "text": "三軍儀隊駐防中正紀念堂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1480.wav", + "text": "非屬一般性表演項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1481.wav", + "text": "它是可以協助支援執行場域的突發狀況處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1482.wav", + "text": "建議是不是可以維持現行作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1483.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1484.wav", + "text": "這個因為促轉會已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1485.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1486.wav", + "text": "好那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1487.wav", + "text": "\n第382案凍結1,003萬7,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1488.wav", + "text": "已經有凍結1,000萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1489.wav", + "text": "建議是不是能夠併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1490.wav", + "text": "這個可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1491.wav", + "text": "我們是希望能夠就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1492.wav", + "text": "如果不行就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1493.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1494.wav", + "text": "如果國防部同意專案報告的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1495.wav", + "text": "可以改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1496.wav", + "text": "改主決議好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1497.wav", + "text": "但是他要同意專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1498.wav", + "text": "啊這個重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1499.wav", + "text": "建議是不是以書面報告的方式處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1500.wav", + "text": "那就沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1501.wav", + "text": "專案報告也要召委願意排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1502.wav", + "text": "如果召委不排他們要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1503.wav", + "text": "對啊但是至少改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1504.wav", + "text": "你們到底想幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1505.wav", + "text": "希望他作專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1506.wav", + "text": "因為這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1507.wav", + "text": "錢花下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1508.wav", + "text": "不凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1509.wav", + "text": "主決議加專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1510.wav", + "text": "這樣可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1511.wav", + "text": "免凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1512.wav", + "text": "主決議加專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1513.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1514.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1515.wav", + "text": "已經決議要排專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1516.wav", + "text": "主決議加專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1517.wav", + "text": "免凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1518.wav", + "text": "不排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1519.wav", + "text": "再來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1520.wav", + "text": "有關行政專機的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1521.wav", + "text": "目前已經按照相關規定付費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1522.wav", + "text": "並報繳國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1523.wav", + "text": "建議維持現行的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1524.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1525.wav", + "text": "462" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1526.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1527.wav", + "text": "國防部4個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1528.wav", + "text": "是保留2個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1529.wav", + "text": "保留2個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1530.wav", + "text": "511" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1531.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1532.wav", + "text": "特別費保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1533.wav", + "text": "是陳明通局長\n第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1534.wav", + "text": "511" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1535.wav", + "text": "\n第531案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1536.wav", + "text": "保留也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1537.wav", + "text": "可以給你表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1538.wav", + "text": "報告院長我還是要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1539.wav", + "text": "很確定是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1540.wav", + "text": "冤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1541.wav", + "text": "明天法院要開庭了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1542.wav", + "text": "所有的證據包括曾銘宗委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1543.wav", + "text": "溫玉霞委員都有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1544.wav", + "text": "這是一個冤案我在這邊必須說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1545.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1546.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1547.wav", + "text": "謝謝國安局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1548.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1549.wav", + "text": "明天就要開庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1550.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1551.wav", + "text": "換經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1552.wav", + "text": "一下列席的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1553.wav", + "text": "首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1554.wav", + "text": "國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1555.wav", + "text": "副主任委員高仙桂女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1556.wav", + "text": "\n好現在我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1557.wav", + "text": "開始看國發會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1558.wav", + "text": "預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1559.wav", + "text": "\n第7案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1560.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1561.wav", + "text": "\n第17案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1562.wav", + "text": "至第111案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1563.wav", + "text": "院長我們這個會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1564.wav", + "text": "併案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1565.wav", + "text": "但是他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1566.wav", + "text": "跟我的不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1567.wav", + "text": "他們能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1568.wav", + "text": "有一個具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1569.wav", + "text": "我提出來的每一個項目都是參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1570.wav", + "text": "日本政府全球暖化對策計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1571.wav", + "text": "的減碳計畫是46" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1572.wav", + "text": "%那國發會去年底提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1573.wav", + "text": "的目標只有24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1574.wav", + "text": "但是我必須講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1575.wav", + "text": "他應該做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1576.wav", + "text": "結果他全部都把我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1577.wav", + "text": "劃掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1578.wav", + "text": "能否去參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1579.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1580.wav", + "text": "因為我這個是在幫助他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1581.wav", + "text": "這麼認真已經幫他整理出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1582.wav", + "text": "2050也是要淨零碳排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1583.wav", + "text": "人家2050也是要淨零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1584.wav", + "text": "碳排結果日本2030" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1585.wav", + "text": "的減碳目標是46" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1586.wav", + "text": "那就要告訴我怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1587.wav", + "text": "才能夠達到2050" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1588.wav", + "text": "所以我才跟他講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1589.wav", + "text": "日本政府的全球暖化對策計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1590.wav", + "text": "可以盤點這些項目去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1591.wav", + "text": "子其實非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1592.wav", + "text": "我變成1個案就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1593.wav", + "text": "希望他可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1594.wav", + "text": "參考這樣的對策計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1595.wav", + "text": "並且也要遵守聯合國氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1596.wav", + "text": "專門委員會的科學意見邱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1597.wav", + "text": "邱委員保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1598.wav", + "text": "日本的東西叫我們臺灣照著做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1599.wav", + "text": "沒有同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1600.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1601.wav", + "text": "我們2030只有24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1602.wav", + "text": "%人家已經46%了可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1603.wav", + "text": "是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1604.wav", + "text": "除非你是故意要跳票否則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1605.wav", + "text": "話每一個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1606.wav", + "text": "你們到底是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1607.wav", + "text": "怎麼想的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1608.wav", + "text": "首先我還是謝謝邱委員把這個併案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1609.wav", + "text": "那為什麼我們會修改這個文字呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1610.wav", + "text": "其實邱委員裡面有策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1611.wav", + "text": "事實上跟我們12項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1612.wav", + "text": "關鍵策略的策略是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1613.wav", + "text": "完全相同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1614.wav", + "text": "至於項目的部分我們會建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1615.wav", + "text": "刪除是因為其實每個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1616.wav", + "text": "淨零碳排的進程都不太會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1617.wav", + "text": "一樣我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1618.wav", + "text": "一定會依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1619.wav", + "text": "委員提示的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1620.wav", + "text": "書面報告中可以納入的部分一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1621.wav", + "text": "會全力納入謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1622.wav", + "text": "策略改成12項因為它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1623.wav", + "text": "項目完全一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1624.wav", + "text": "策略都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1625.wav", + "text": "因為每個國家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1626.wav", + "text": "不一樣有些東西我們還在發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1627.wav", + "text": "環境也不一樣嘛環境也不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1628.wav", + "text": "所以是不是容許我們參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1629.wav", + "text": "委員的這些建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1630.wav", + "text": "一定會儘量納入參考的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1631.wav", + "text": "會跟你講說這個做不到啦拜託啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1632.wav", + "text": "所以這個表應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1633.wav", + "text": "我們講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1634.wav", + "text": "參考沒關係但不能照著表來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1635.wav", + "text": "是我們一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1636.wav", + "text": "參考委員表列的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1637.wav", + "text": "就不要刪除嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1638.wav", + "text": "就整個改為參考就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1639.wav", + "text": "這怎麼可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1640.wav", + "text": "這個本來就是要給你參考的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1641.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1642.wav", + "text": "你如果沒辦法執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1643.wav", + "text": "也要寫清楚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1644.wav", + "text": "這個先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1645.wav", + "text": "謝謝邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1646.wav", + "text": "第17案至第111案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1647.wav", + "text": "合併成1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1648.wav", + "text": "謝謝邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1649.wav", + "text": "接下來我們看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1650.wav", + "text": "案3個案都併委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1651.wav", + "text": "會決議辦理沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1652.wav", + "text": "\n第129案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1653.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1654.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1655.wav", + "text": "我們建議修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1656.wav", + "text": "有沒有修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1657.wav", + "text": "對就是修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1658.wav", + "text": "案有沒有跟提案人溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1659.wav", + "text": "因為我們本來想併前面那個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1660.wav", + "text": "因為其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1661.wav", + "text": "這裡稍微文字調整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1662.wav", + "text": "案不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1663.wav", + "text": "只是改3個月還有前面一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1664.wav", + "text": "這個第184案不要併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1665.wav", + "text": "它自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1666.wav", + "text": "第184案就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1667.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1668.wav", + "text": "太好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1669.wav", + "text": "是經濟部我們現在就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1670.wav", + "text": "繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1671.wav", + "text": "列席首長經濟部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1672.wav", + "text": "王美花女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1673.wav", + "text": "在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1674.wav", + "text": "\n請大家看經濟部主管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1675.wav", + "text": "第274案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1676.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1677.wav", + "text": "10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1678.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1679.wav", + "text": "案凍結10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1680.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1681.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1682.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1683.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1684.wav", + "text": "第314案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1685.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1686.wav", + "text": "請尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1687.wav", + "text": "第321案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1688.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1689.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1690.wav", + "text": "曾委員剛剛有跟您口頭說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1691.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1692.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1693.wav", + "text": "348" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1694.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1695.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1696.wav", + "text": "經濟部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1697.wav", + "text": "建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1698.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1699.wav", + "text": "經濟部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1700.wav", + "text": "專案報告改為書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1701.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1702.wav", + "text": "專案改為書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1703.wav", + "text": "就照文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1704.wav", + "text": "建議跟剛剛一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1705.wav", + "text": "專案報告改成書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1706.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1707.wav", + "text": "464案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1708.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1709.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告已經蓋章了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1710.wav", + "text": "蓋章了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1711.wav", + "text": "那就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1712.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1713.wav", + "text": "因為同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1714.wav", + "text": "修正文字後通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1715.wav", + "text": "\n這個主決議就文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1716.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1717.wav", + "text": "第568案剛剛跟曾委員報告說明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1718.wav", + "text": "了委員有口頭同意文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1719.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1720.wav", + "text": "有口頭同意但還沒簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1721.wav", + "text": "民眾黨今天怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1722.wav", + "text": "要保留第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1723.wav", + "text": "574案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1724.wav", + "text": "再來就看農" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1725.wav", + "text": "農委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1726.wav", + "text": "部長礦業法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1727.wav", + "text": "趕快礦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1728.wav", + "text": "九點多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1729.wav", + "text": "剛來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1730.wav", + "text": "委員會主管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1731.wav", + "text": "現在列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1732.wav", + "text": "陳吉仲主委已經在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1733.wav", + "text": "介紹完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1734.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1735.wav", + "text": "好第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1736.wav", + "text": "622" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1737.wav", + "text": "623" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1738.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1739.wav", + "text": "一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1740.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1741.wav", + "text": "第583案不是通案嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1742.wav", + "text": "你要跟曾總召謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1743.wav", + "text": "結束囉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1744.wav", + "text": "主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1745.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1746.wav", + "text": "介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1747.wav", + "text": "財政部代理部長阮清華先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1748.wav", + "text": "主計長朱澤民先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1749.wav", + "text": "請大家看第50案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1750.wav", + "text": "第50案我們要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1751.wav", + "text": "這個是不是還是讓部長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1752.wav", + "text": "凍結的是特支費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1753.wav", + "text": "沒關係第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1754.wav", + "text": "第50案我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1755.wav", + "text": "財政部有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1756.wav", + "text": "這個案子我上次也報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1757.wav", + "text": "因為這個是在法院協調的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1758.wav", + "text": "這個沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1759.wav", + "text": "那一天我們曾總召有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1760.wav", + "text": "說你在可以寫的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1761.wav", + "text": "時代力量不會這麼容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1762.wav", + "text": "善罷干休好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1763.wav", + "text": "不是善罷干休的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1764.wav", + "text": "這個案子我比誰都清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1765.wav", + "text": "沒關係啦完全沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1766.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1767.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1768.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席謝謝各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1769.wav", + "text": "金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1770.wav", + "text": "金管會還是要來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1771.wav", + "text": "撤案歸撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1772.wav", + "text": "還是要來報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1773.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1774.wav", + "text": "因為這3個案子都是陳玉珍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1775.wav", + "text": "委員跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1776.wav", + "text": "我也有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1777.wav", + "text": "所以我想要要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1778.wav", + "text": "撤案歸撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1779.wav", + "text": "但我希望要書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1780.wav", + "text": "哪一個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1781.wav", + "text": "第一個高齡社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1782.wav", + "text": "我這樣講超實際的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1783.wav", + "text": "大家看新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1784.wav", + "text": "打潘維剛3個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1785.wav", + "text": "這兩天的報紙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1786.wav", + "text": "怎麼會發生這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1787.wav", + "text": "高齡社會的相關服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1788.wav", + "text": "這不是開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1789.wav", + "text": "我們要求個書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1790.wav", + "text": "託啦院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1791.wav", + "text": "0案雖然撤案但是要書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1792.wav", + "text": "合併在一起報告好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1793.wav", + "text": "好這可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1794.wav", + "text": "寫一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1795.wav", + "text": "我先宣示一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1796.wav", + "text": "3個案子都撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1797.wav", + "text": "但是合併一個案提一個書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1798.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1799.wav", + "text": "就改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1800.wav", + "text": "很奇怪我看不李" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1801.wav", + "text": "委員就是3個案子合併成一個主決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1802.wav", + "text": "這樣才會有書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1803.wav", + "text": "接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1804.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1805.wav", + "text": "教育及文化委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1806.wav", + "text": "的預算進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1807.wav", + "text": "國立故宮博物院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1808.wav", + "text": "列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1809.wav", + "text": "吳密察院長現在已經在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1810.wav", + "text": "來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1811.wav", + "text": "故宮博物院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1812.wav", + "text": "的第23案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1813.wav", + "text": "沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1814.wav", + "text": "50萬元加專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1815.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1816.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1817.wav", + "text": "凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1818.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1819.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1820.wav", + "text": "報告院長其實重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1821.wav", + "text": "只在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1822.wav", + "text": "蘭千山館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1823.wav", + "text": "不然就照案通過好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1824.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1825.wav", + "text": "蘭千山館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1826.wav", + "text": "怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1827.wav", + "text": "有溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1828.wav", + "text": "吳怡玎委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1829.wav", + "text": "同意修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1830.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1831.wav", + "text": "這個是我簽的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1832.wav", + "text": "不只是吳怡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1833.wav", + "text": "我直接問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1834.wav", + "text": "蘭千山館怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1835.wav", + "text": "你給我一個答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1836.wav", + "text": "其他就很好講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1837.wav", + "text": "這個我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1838.wav", + "text": "也已經跟吳怡玎委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1839.wav", + "text": "我們有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1840.wav", + "text": "寄存的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1841.wav", + "text": "根據這個寄存的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1842.wav", + "text": "我們會跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1843.wav", + "text": "蘭千山館來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1844.wav", + "text": "協商如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1845.wav", + "text": "繼續下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1846.wav", + "text": "就是你會讓它繼續下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1847.wav", + "text": "協商繼續下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1848.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1849.wav", + "text": "依照新的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1850.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1851.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1852.wav", + "text": "蘭千山館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1853.wav", + "text": "那個空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1854.wav", + "text": "真的很有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1855.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1856.wav", + "text": "院長願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1857.wav", + "text": "繼續跟人家協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1858.wav", + "text": "我們就改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1859.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1860.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1861.wav", + "text": "我們真的是善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1862.wav", + "text": "就麻煩院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1863.wav", + "text": "第30案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1864.wav", + "text": "免凍沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1865.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1866.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1867.wav", + "text": "的部分現在介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1868.wav", + "text": "教育部部長潘文忠先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1869.wav", + "text": "教育部的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1870.wav", + "text": "撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1871.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1872.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1873.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1874.wav", + "text": "第67案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1875.wav", + "text": "好提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1876.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1877.wav", + "text": "併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1878.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1879.wav", + "text": "181案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1880.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1881.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1882.wav", + "text": "我們就遵照比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1883.wav", + "text": "182案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1884.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1885.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1886.wav", + "text": "文字修正沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1887.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1888.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長謝謝各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1889.wav", + "text": "原能會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1890.wav", + "text": "部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1891.wav", + "text": "現在介紹列席首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1892.wav", + "text": "原能會有打電話來請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1893.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1894.wav", + "text": "\n原能會只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1895.wav", + "text": "一個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1896.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1897.wav", + "text": "不是已經有溝通了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1898.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1899.wav", + "text": "這個案子比較特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1900.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1901.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1902.wav", + "text": "啊因為他也特別過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1903.wav", + "text": "原能會只有一個案他為了這個案來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1904.wav", + "text": "結果卻百分之百退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1905.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1906.wav", + "text": "因為這個案子真的比較特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1907.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1908.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1909.wav", + "text": "跟我們曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1910.wav", + "text": "另外談這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1911.wav", + "text": "現在先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1912.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1913.wav", + "text": "488案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1914.wav", + "text": "改凍100萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1915.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1916.wav", + "text": "因為民眾黨還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1917.wav", + "text": "對文化發展非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1918.wav", + "text": "相關效能跟預期開發的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1919.wav", + "text": "我們同意改凍50萬元不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1920.wav", + "text": "書面報告還是要提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1921.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1922.wav", + "text": "第488案就這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1923.wav", + "text": "凍50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1924.wav", + "text": "主決議文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1925.wav", + "text": "國民黨也非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1926.wav", + "text": "精進方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1927.wav", + "text": "要特別努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1928.wav", + "text": "要拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1929.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1930.wav", + "text": "525案的主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1931.wav", + "text": "還是要通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1932.wav", + "text": "我們先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1933.wav", + "text": "案是文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1934.wav", + "text": "還是通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1935.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1936.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1937.wav", + "text": "好沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1938.wav", + "text": "他說通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1939.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1940.wav", + "text": "那就文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1941.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1942.wav", + "text": "你們去修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1943.wav", + "text": "537案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1944.wav", + "text": "通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1945.wav", + "text": "有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1946.wav", + "text": "我可不可以看一下修正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1947.wav", + "text": "文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1948.wav", + "text": "我們要學柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1949.wav", + "text": "所以也要看一下第537" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1950.wav", + "text": "這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1951.wav", + "text": "沒有時間了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1952.wav", + "text": "你要做就做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1953.wav", + "text": "也做過一些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1954.wav", + "text": "第537案要怎麼修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1955.wav", + "text": "我的意見是沒那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1956.wav", + "text": "我們基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1957.wav", + "text": "就是希望他們能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1958.wav", + "text": "的內容是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1959.wav", + "text": "就由他們看要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1960.wav", + "text": "讓他們去研" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1961.wav", + "text": "那樣沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1962.wav", + "text": "我們就OK改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1963.wav", + "text": "改為研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1964.wav", + "text": "就這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1965.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1966.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1967.wav", + "text": "我們已經把後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1968.wav", + "text": "的這些都刪掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1969.wav", + "text": "就是讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1970.wav", + "text": "去跟各界溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1971.wav", + "text": "確保多元意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1972.wav", + "text": "能夠進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1973.wav", + "text": "你們去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1974.wav", + "text": "有修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1975.wav", + "text": "有修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1976.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1977.wav", + "text": "我們對相關的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1978.wav", + "text": "還是有一點疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1979.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1980.wav", + "text": "562" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1981.wav", + "text": "也建議修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1982.wav", + "text": "稍等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1983.wav", + "text": "沒有看就喊保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1984.wav", + "text": "沒有意見好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1985.wav", + "text": "文化部就告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1986.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1987.wav", + "text": "國科會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1988.wav", + "text": "介紹一下國科會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1989.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1990.wav", + "text": "596案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1991.wav", + "text": "598案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1992.wav", + "text": "案還是第596" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1993.wav", + "text": "596案啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1994.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1995.wav", + "text": "看一下好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1996.wav", + "text": "有林智堅的就保留這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1997.wav", + "text": "個撤就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1998.wav", + "text": "嘛什麼保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/1999.wav", + "text": "596案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2000.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2001.wav", + "text": "案文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2002.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2003.wav", + "text": "修正是對未來的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2004.wav", + "text": "修正了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2005.wav", + "text": "598案文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2006.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過\n第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2007.wav", + "text": "599" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2008.wav", + "text": "案保留對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2009.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2010.wav", + "text": "600" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2011.wav", + "text": "案文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2012.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2013.wav", + "text": "等一下第600案在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2014.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2015.wav", + "text": "這完全改變方式了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2016.wav", + "text": "照這個可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2017.wav", + "text": "有沒有好第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2018.wav", + "text": "600案撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2019.wav", + "text": "611" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2020.wav", + "text": "第611案撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2021.wav", + "text": "全部撤啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2022.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2023.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2024.wav", + "text": "院長保留一案OK嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2025.wav", + "text": "不是啦你們講好就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2026.wav", + "text": "第599" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2027.wav", + "text": "599案沒有講到人名第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2028.wav", + "text": "要求行政部門應該要中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2029.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2030.wav", + "text": "你看裡面沒有林智堅的名字喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2031.wav", + "text": "有隱含到柯建銘的樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2032.wav", + "text": "柯總召的名字進入主決議也是很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2033.wav", + "text": "你要保留哪一案第599" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2034.wav", + "text": "這個沒有針對任何人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2035.wav", + "text": "這個是行政機關啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2036.wav", + "text": "我們要求他們提出調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2037.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2038.wav", + "text": "我看一起表決就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2039.wav", + "text": "話大家要共同面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2040.wav", + "text": "違法失職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2041.wav", + "text": "第598案文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2042.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2043.wav", + "text": "是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2044.wav", + "text": "要要照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2045.wav", + "text": "案其文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2046.wav", + "text": "國科會每年挹注委辦計畫怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2047.wav", + "text": "不夠明確等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2048.wav", + "text": "600案文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2049.wav", + "text": "柯總召你看一下第599案你覺得哪裡不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2050.wav", + "text": "你你覺得哪裡很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2051.wav", + "text": "追究相關人員很好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2052.wav", + "text": "你看最後一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2053.wav", + "text": "你們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2054.wav", + "text": "二個禮拜內提出調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2055.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2056.wav", + "text": "國科會已經提告你還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2057.wav", + "text": "沒有錯請內部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2058.wav", + "text": "請內部提出調查報告這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2059.wav", + "text": "開不開庭沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2060.wav", + "text": "國科會有沒有提告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2061.wav", + "text": "我們已經依法辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2062.wav", + "text": "前部長主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2063.wav", + "text": "依法辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2064.wav", + "text": "跟有沒有提告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2065.wav", + "text": "國科會提告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2066.wav", + "text": "中華大學民事提告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2067.wav", + "text": "可以問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2068.wav", + "text": "已經完全提告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2069.wav", + "text": "柯總召不會講假話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2070.wav", + "text": "我怎麼是這種人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2071.wav", + "text": "管理局副局長回答就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2072.wav", + "text": "局長回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2073.wav", + "text": "依法提告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2074.wav", + "text": "保留第599" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2075.wav", + "text": "其他案應該全部撤了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2076.wav", + "text": "是不是第600案文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2077.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2078.wav", + "text": "其他的撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2079.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2080.wav", + "text": "結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2081.wav", + "text": "換交通部主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2082.wav", + "text": "首先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2083.wav", + "text": "國家通訊傳播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2084.wav", + "text": "凍結十分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2085.wav", + "text": "一是不是併委員會決議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2086.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2087.wav", + "text": "第7案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2088.wav", + "text": "案是通刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2089.wav", + "text": "所以是通案處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2090.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2091.wav", + "text": "通刪怎麼會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2092.wav", + "text": "通刪保留也沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2093.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2094.wav", + "text": "改一個就可以了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2095.wav", + "text": "那就併案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2096.wav", + "text": "椒華老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2097.wav", + "text": "讓他們寫書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2098.wav", + "text": "大約15分鐘前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2099.wav", + "text": "NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2100.wav", + "text": "同仁才來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2101.wav", + "text": "溝通但是也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2102.wav", + "text": "溝通完整所以我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2103.wav", + "text": "跟鏡電視有關的都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2104.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2105.wav", + "text": "如果他們有誠意就早一點來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2106.wav", + "text": "這要看時間或是去擲筊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2107.wav", + "text": "你們剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2108.wav", + "text": "要說明什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2109.wav", + "text": "如果他們有誠意就早點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2110.wav", + "text": "來溝通嘛現在真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2111.wav", + "text": "刪的部分就改主決議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2112.wav", + "text": "在這裡馬上講就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2113.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2114.wav", + "text": "我們在桌面上有給各位一份資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2115.wav", + "text": "因為今天時力黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2116.wav", + "text": "一共提了7個關鍵點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2117.wav", + "text": "他也有做了一個主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2118.wav", + "text": "案後面是我們做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2119.wav", + "text": "3案21個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2120.wav", + "text": "對照成相關的主決議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2121.wav", + "text": "同樣的話題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2122.wav", + "text": "重點我們做一個書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2123.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們有跟委員溝通委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2124.wav", + "text": "希望我們作成專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2125.wav", + "text": "可是現在委員又不同意我們不知道該怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2126.wav", + "text": "主決議是不是就併第49案至第55" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2127.wav", + "text": "刪事實上不必談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2128.wav", + "text": "全部在通案就處理掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2129.wav", + "text": "現在陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2130.wav", + "text": "是不是可以商量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2131.wav", + "text": "議我回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2132.wav", + "text": "我們也有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2133.wav", + "text": "針對洪耀福" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2134.wav", + "text": "前秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2135.wav", + "text": "但你這裡全部拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2136.wav", + "text": "全部拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2137.wav", + "text": "怎麼會是按" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2138.wav", + "text": "照剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2139.wav", + "text": "這位發言的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2140.wav", + "text": "有針對我們提案的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2141.wav", + "text": "我剛剛也說通刪部分還沒有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2142.wav", + "text": "所以先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2143.wav", + "text": "你剛才說要提主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2144.wav", + "text": "再搞很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2145.wav", + "text": "算了表決就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2146.wav", + "text": "你提了主決議他也不會滿意總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2147.wav", + "text": "召我不跟你浪費時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2148.wav", + "text": "你不要這樣口出惡言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2149.wav", + "text": "我太瞭解你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2150.wav", + "text": "我不想浪費大家的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2151.wav", + "text": "院長請他們盡早來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2152.wav", + "text": "先保留等溝通完成我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2153.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2154.wav", + "text": "案是通刪科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2155.wav", + "text": "通案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2156.wav", + "text": "暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2157.wav", + "text": "18案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2158.wav", + "text": "第18案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2159.wav", + "text": "沒有第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2160.wav", + "text": "18案第19案不能這樣全數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2161.wav", + "text": "減列都等於零了哪有這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2162.wav", + "text": "我們要表決啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2163.wav", + "text": "我們也有立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2164.wav", + "text": "20案怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2165.wav", + "text": "邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2166.wav", + "text": "我回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2167.wav", + "text": "已經談了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2168.wav", + "text": "一個會期現在還在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2169.wav", + "text": "邱總召你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2170.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2171.wav", + "text": "都是同樣一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2172.wav", + "text": "只有71萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2173.wav", + "text": "1,000元國民黨又喊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2174.wav", + "text": "時代力量不是國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2175.wav", + "text": "撤案第19" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2176.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2177.wav", + "text": "我們現在就談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2178.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團邱總召提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2179.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2180.wav", + "text": "我今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2181.wav", + "text": "出席菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2182.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2183.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2184.wav", + "text": "平均地權條例我沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2185.wav", + "text": "鏡電視的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2186.wav", + "text": "19案到第26案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2187.wav", + "text": "就併為1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2188.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2189.wav", + "text": "第33案就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2190.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2191.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2192.wav", + "text": "國民黨的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2193.wav", + "text": "跟時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2194.wav", + "text": "沒有併案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2195.wav", + "text": "分流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2196.wav", + "text": "你們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2197.wav", + "text": "案撤1個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2198.wav", + "text": "保留1個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2199.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2200.wav", + "text": "案就照陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2201.wav", + "text": "講的保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2202.wav", + "text": "第34案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2203.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2204.wav", + "text": "窒礙難行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2205.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2206.wav", + "text": "這案保留第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2207.wav", + "text": "49案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2208.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2209.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2210.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2211.wav", + "text": "第52案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2212.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2213.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2214.wav", + "text": "第54案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2215.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2216.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2217.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2218.wav", + "text": "NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2219.wav", + "text": "不是大聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2220.wav", + "text": "就可以解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2221.wav", + "text": "不是複製貼上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2222.wav", + "text": "做成不同案子就可以解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2223.wav", + "text": "你們那麼多案都是複製貼上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2224.wav", + "text": "就是1案而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2225.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2226.wav", + "text": "NCC就可以離場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2227.wav", + "text": "陳主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2228.wav", + "text": "針對相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2229.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2230.wav", + "text": "關心一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2231.wav", + "text": "各各電視台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2232.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2233.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2234.wav", + "text": "業者來開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2235.wav", + "text": "萬一出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2236.wav", + "text": "也會影響到選務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2237.wav", + "text": "發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2238.wav", + "text": "所以這部分還是請主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2239.wav", + "text": "主委我請教一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2240.wav", + "text": "每一個電視台都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2241.wav", + "text": "說派多少人去投票所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2242.wav", + "text": "有一些電視台說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2243.wav", + "text": "8成的投票所都有派人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2244.wav", + "text": "有一些電視台說百分之百" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2245.wav", + "text": "NCC在這幾次的大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2246.wav", + "text": "找電視台來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2247.wav", + "text": "有沒有相關數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2248.wav", + "text": "那是電視台的廣告話術還是他們真的有派人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2249.wav", + "text": "我們有去查證過他們有人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2250.wav", + "text": "就請他們提供資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2251.wav", + "text": "當然我們不曉得他派去哪一個投開票所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2252.wav", + "text": "因為這個可能是他們自己的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2253.wav", + "text": "只是他們告訴你們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2254.wav", + "text": "但你們沒有查證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2255.wav", + "text": "報告院長下一個部會在等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2256.wav", + "text": "了如果他們覺得這個很重要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2257.wav", + "text": "請召委再排專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2258.wav", + "text": "因為你現在也問不出答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2259.wav", + "text": "不是問不出答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2260.wav", + "text": "是主委沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2261.wav", + "text": "確切地回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2262.wav", + "text": "這個是電視台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2263.wav", + "text": "給你的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2264.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2265.wav", + "text": "下個會期我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2266.wav", + "text": "好好來請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2267.wav", + "text": "給我的這份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2268.wav", + "text": "請問主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2269.wav", + "text": "你知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2270.wav", + "text": "下次來溝通是不是可以不要把它拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2271.wav", + "text": "請回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2272.wav", + "text": "有些是媒體的報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2273.wav", + "text": "有些東西也不見得完全是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2274.wav", + "text": "我們當然對這個文字的表達有一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2275.wav", + "text": "因為你拿掉的都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2276.wav", + "text": "洪耀福的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2277.wav", + "text": "讓人家覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2278.wav", + "text": "所以希望來溝通的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2279.wav", + "text": "是不是可以不要這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2280.wav", + "text": "列席的首長交通部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2281.wav", + "text": "王國材先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2282.wav", + "text": "109案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2283.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團的案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2284.wav", + "text": "等一下我看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2285.wav", + "text": "109" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2286.wav", + "text": "也是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2287.wav", + "text": "妥善地處理勞工的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2288.wav", + "text": "另外一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2289.wav", + "text": "因為我是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2290.wav", + "text": "再送交通委員會同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2291.wav", + "text": "是不是就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2292.wav", + "text": "處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2293.wav", + "text": "就刪除經本院交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2294.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2295.wav", + "text": "就是再另外有一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2296.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2297.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2298.wav", + "text": "那就不併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2299.wav", + "text": "不併委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2300.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2301.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2302.wav", + "text": "還是有凍結對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2303.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2304.wav", + "text": "凍結十分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2305.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2306.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2307.wav", + "text": "提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2308.wav", + "text": "委員會已經凍結十分之對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2309.wav", + "text": "已經凍結過了可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2310.wav", + "text": "提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2311.wav", + "text": "那不凍結了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2312.wav", + "text": "內容不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2313.wav", + "text": "保留就是表示你要凍結嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2314.wav", + "text": "我們保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2315.wav", + "text": "院長這案要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2316.wav", + "text": "因為他們所講的部分不是現在民航局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2317.wav", + "text": "管理的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2318.wav", + "text": "我們就保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2319.wav", + "text": "第305案就是主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2320.wav", + "text": "提書面報告對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2321.wav", + "text": "免凍嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2322.wav", + "text": "第306案就是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2323.wav", + "text": "396" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2324.wav", + "text": "委員會已經加了3,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2325.wav", + "text": "396" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2326.wav", + "text": "告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2327.wav", + "text": "院長等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2328.wav", + "text": "請問邱顯智委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2329.wav", + "text": "你原來第391案那個人孔蓋是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2330.wav", + "text": "運研所這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2331.wav", + "text": "我看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2332.wav", + "text": "今天沒有講第391" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2333.wav", + "text": "391案先保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2334.wav", + "text": "上次沒有保留先保留我瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2335.wav", + "text": "我知道上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2336.wav", + "text": "要保留第391" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2337.wav", + "text": "案你看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2338.wav", + "text": "391" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2339.wav", + "text": "案今天沒有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2340.wav", + "text": "沒有第391" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2341.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2342.wav", + "text": "王部長柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2343.wav", + "text": "要保留第391" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2344.wav", + "text": "忽然弄出來這樣是在做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2345.wav", + "text": "沒有這個先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2346.wav", + "text": "再講好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2347.wav", + "text": "不是啊你不能這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2348.wav", + "text": "那我隨便過了也可以這樣喊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2349.wav", + "text": "你總是要給我一個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2350.wav", + "text": "我給你一個理由是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2351.wav", + "text": "人家交通部作為一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2352.wav", + "text": "這交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2353.wav", + "text": "根本沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2354.wav", + "text": "人家已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2355.wav", + "text": "讓部長說一下拿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2356.wav", + "text": "拿來大家討論啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2357.wav", + "text": "拿來大家討論嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2358.wav", + "text": "大家來討論啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2359.wav", + "text": "有人這樣搞的喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2360.wav", + "text": "你不要緊張嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2361.wav", + "text": "不是不要緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2362.wav", + "text": "這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2363.wav", + "text": "什麼轉��這裡來搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2364.wav", + "text": "人家交通部都已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2365.wav", + "text": "那是一個交通安全的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2366.wav", + "text": "大家冷靜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2367.wav", + "text": "現在已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2368.wav", + "text": "你這樣就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2369.wav", + "text": "是針對我來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2370.wav", + "text": "什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2371.wav", + "text": "這個沒有人針對誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2372.wav", + "text": "因為這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2373.wav", + "text": "了結果來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2374.wav", + "text": "我這個案有問題這什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2375.wav", + "text": "講不過去嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2376.wav", + "text": "一個安全的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2377.wav", + "text": "我今天是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2378.wav", + "text": "臺灣交通的傷亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2379.wav", + "text": "所以才提這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2380.wav", + "text": "這到底是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2381.wav", + "text": "我要瞭解這案的法的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2382.wav", + "text": "人家部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2383.wav", + "text": "都已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2384.wav", + "text": "人家部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2385.wav", + "text": "繼續開會因為還有一百零多案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2386.wav", + "text": "了\n首先看總統府的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2387.wav", + "text": "這個違反促轉條例的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2388.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2389.wav", + "text": "第20案主決議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2390.wav", + "text": "再來國史館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2391.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就修正通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2392.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2393.wav", + "text": "再來是人事行政總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2394.wav", + "text": "接下來就看人事行政總處第36案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2395.wav", + "text": "第36案希望它會議紀錄公減列1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2396.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2397.wav", + "text": "他說沒辦法做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2398.wav", + "text": "第43案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2399.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2400.wav", + "text": "請看第151案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2401.wav", + "text": "沒有資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2402.wav", + "text": "大家都有只有你沒有真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2403.wav", + "text": "昨天鄭正鈐為了這個案子來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2404.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2405.wav", + "text": "修正的文字在哪邊來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2406.wav", + "text": "51案修正文字謝謝提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2407.wav", + "text": "剛剛沒有給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2408.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2409.wav", + "text": "我們可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2410.wav", + "text": "這���司法院提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2411.wav", + "text": "這個案子和昨天的是差在什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2412.wav", + "text": "不對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2413.wav", + "text": "下面有劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2414.wav", + "text": "你怎麼可以講這種話呢變得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2415.wav", + "text": "完全不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2416.wav", + "text": "這會不會影響你們的預算我直接問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2417.wav", + "text": "有沒有凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2418.wav", + "text": "沒有他改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2419.wav", + "text": "現在就變成司法院加強宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2420.wav", + "text": "人家都大放送了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2421.wav", + "text": "改主決議司法院加強宣導第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2422.wav", + "text": "151案改主決議沒有意見照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2423.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2424.wav", + "text": "第166案保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2425.wav", + "text": "接下來監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2426.wav", + "text": "監察院有溝通嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2427.wav", + "text": "跟主席報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2428.wav", + "text": "我們有參考昨天委員的高見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2429.wav", + "text": "有做了修改版本可不可以現在發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2430.wav", + "text": "有主決議5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2431.wav", + "text": "讓國民黨團先看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2432.wav", + "text": "他們如果同意就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2433.wav", + "text": "不好意思沒有第166案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2434.wav", + "text": "你說的是第166案嗎第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2435.wav", + "text": "我們是從第211案開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2436.wav", + "text": "有先讓提案人看嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2437.wav", + "text": "沒有因為提案人都是黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2438.wav", + "text": "黨團的委員都很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2439.wav", + "text": "可以報告了嗎請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2440.wav", + "text": "就讓他們說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2441.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2442.wav", + "text": "昨天他本來已經簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2443.wav", + "text": "應該要調整較為適切一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2444.wav", + "text": "就是期許我們監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2445.wav", + "text": "提振辦案效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2446.wav", + "text": "是不是可以容許我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2447.wav", + "text": "因為本來的文字也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2448.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2449.wav", + "text": "因為我認為立法權跟監察權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2450.wav", + "text": "本來就應該各自尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2451.wav", + "text": "為什麼要他們提書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2452.wav", + "text": "這表示你在干涉監察委員的辦案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2453.wav", + "text": "劉委員這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2454.wav", + "text": "書面說明可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2455.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2456.wav", + "text": "書面報告說明啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2457.wav", + "text": "沒有那就報告那是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2458.wav", + "text": "書面說明什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2459.wav", + "text": "提書面說明的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2460.wav", + "text": "你就會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2461.wav", + "text": "是哪位監察委員在辦什麼案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2462.wav", + "text": "及裡面的相關資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2463.wav", + "text": "司法劉委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2464.wav", + "text": "我們擔任立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2465.wav", + "text": "站在立法院的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2466.wav", + "text": "監察院說明真的不為過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2467.wav", + "text": "否則秘書長不用坐在這裡啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2468.wav", + "text": "秘書長是來維護他們的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2469.wav", + "text": "來來來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2470.wav", + "text": "秘書長不只來維護他們的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2471.wav", + "text": "秘書長還要來這邊說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2472.wav", + "text": "我們當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2473.wav", + "text": "但我們想要瞭解啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2474.wav", + "text": "你想要瞭解但你在干涉他們辦案啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2475.wav", + "text": "我沒有干涉他們辦案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2476.wav", + "text": "說明都不行嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2477.wav", + "text": "我們只是請他們說明嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2478.wav", + "text": "秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2479.wav", + "text": "可不可以說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2480.wav", + "text": "講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2481.wav", + "text": "監察院可不可以跟立法院說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2482.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2483.wav", + "text": "秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2484.wav", + "text": "監察院可不可以跟立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2485.wav", + "text": "來說明相關問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2486.wav", + "text": "不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2487.wav", + "text": "你就走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2488.wav", + "text": "休息一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2489.wav", + "text": "不用休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2490.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2491.wav", + "text": "我們只是要求他說明嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2492.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2493.wav", + "text": "我的想法跟李委員不太相同的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2494.wav", + "text": "我剛才已經表示過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2495.wav", + "text": "我的意思是立法權跟監察權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2496.wav", + "text": "我還沒講完耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2497.wav", + "text": "我說報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2498.wav", + "text": "我來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2499.wav", + "text": "結果你就開始插嘴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2500.wav", + "text": "插嘴不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2501.wav", + "text": "當然可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2502.wav", + "text": "好休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2503.wav", + "text": "繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2504.wav", + "text": "請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2505.wav", + "text": "這一張李德維先生柯建銘先生都有簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2506.wav", + "text": "\n第251案第252案第255案第259案主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2507.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召說都保留好保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2508.wav", + "text": "法務部部長蔡清祥先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2509.wav", + "text": "\n請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2510.wav", + "text": "第266案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2511.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2512.wav", + "text": "這個都併到第266案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2513.wav", + "text": "第267案第268案第270案都併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2514.wav", + "text": "院長第267案第268案第270案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2515.wav", + "text": "接下來第296案第297案第316案第321案第322" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2516.wav", + "text": "好全部併到第266" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2517.wav", + "text": "應該是說那些只留第266" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2518.wav", + "text": "\n第376案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2519.wav", + "text": "沒有意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2520.wav", + "text": "\n第389案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2521.wav", + "text": "第389案跟第418案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2522.wav", + "text": "應該要跟法務部長讚賞一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2523.wav", + "text": "這表示你們有努力溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2524.wav", + "text": "有的部會都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2525.wav", + "text": "家就介紹列席首長首先介紹勞動部部長許銘春女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2526.wav", + "text": "兩案是第35" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2527.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2528.wav", + "text": "這兩案都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2529.wav", + "text": "\n你們好歹用個50%讓他回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2530.wav", + "text": "做個伴手禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2531.wav", + "text": "太困難了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2532.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2533.wav", + "text": "支持柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2534.wav", + "text": "7案都保留都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2535.wav", + "text": "都保留那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2536.wav", + "text": "好啦保留有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2537.wav", + "text": "6案藥的部分我們有刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2538.wav", + "text": "不要啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2539.wav", + "text": "在精神還在嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2540.wav", + "text": "椒華老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2541.wav", + "text": "已經換人了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2542.wav", + "text": "我們花了很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2543.wav", + "text": "薛瑞元部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2544.wav", + "text": "已經在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2545.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2546.wav", + "text": "有意見保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2547.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2548.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼理由保留啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2549.wav", + "text": "要不要我唸一遍給你聽那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2550.wav", + "text": "我們藥都劃掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2551.wav", + "text": "可是現在這個修正藥拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2552.wav", + "text": "心生恐懼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2553.wav", + "text": "我們請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2554.wav", + "text": "現在就改成這樣而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2555.wav", + "text": "跟健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2556.wav", + "text": "完全沒有關係啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2557.wav", + "text": "那有什麼理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2558.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2559.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2560.wav", + "text": "立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2561.wav", + "text": "所以第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2562.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2563.wav", + "text": "已經改好的這一案去表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2564.wav", + "text": "我們要用這一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2565.wav", + "text": "因為我們跟部會談好了啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2566.wav", + "text": "我們要用這一案表決不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2567.wav", + "text": "對啊我們用這一案啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2568.wav", + "text": "這樣才能夠遮羞就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2569.wav", + "text": "什麼遮羞啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2570.wav", + "text": "講這種話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2571.wav", + "text": "建請案而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2572.wav", + "text": "這樣不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2573.wav", + "text": "要講個道理來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2574.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2575.wav", + "text": "先為什麼要搞這個的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2576.wav", + "text": "先講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2577.wav", + "text": "這不是叫搞啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2578.wav", + "text": "這個是根據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2579.wav", + "text": "要有效治療憂鬱症" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2580.wav", + "text": "跟強迫症的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2581.wav", + "text": "難以支應了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2582.wav", + "text": "能夠給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2583.wav", + "text": "們有更多的扶助啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2584.wav", + "text": "這到底有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2585.wav", + "text": "我們也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2586.wav", + "text": "全部都重來好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2587.wav", + "text": "我們的也都全部重來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2588.wav", + "text": "你要這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2589.wav", + "text": "沒有你講到一個特殊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2590.wav", + "text": "沒有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2591.wav", + "text": "我們那個劃掉啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2592.wav", + "text": "你看一下這個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2593.wav", + "text": "部長覺得這個有什麼問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2594.wav", + "text": "你們不能做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2595.wav", + "text": "你回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2596.wav", + "text": "哪一個窒礙難行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2597.wav", + "text": "抱歉陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2598.wav", + "text": "我們是黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2599.wav", + "text": "現在黨團沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2600.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2601.wav", + "text": "文字我們再討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2602.wav", + "text": "這樣好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2603.wav", + "text": "這個案子實在弄的太粗糙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2604.wav", + "text": "你們以後應該不會這樣搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2605.wav", + "text": "不要用這樣的文字來形容好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2606.wav", + "text": "改過的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2607.wav", + "text": "用改過的版本去表決有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2608.wav", + "text": "剛剛發的這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2609.wav", + "text": "最新的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2610.wav", + "text": "讓總召看一下最新的版本好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2611.wav", + "text": "因為總召看的是另外一個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2612.wav", + "text": "衛福部也同意用這個版本請司長過來一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2613.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2614.wav", + "text": "請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2615.wav", + "text": "跟柯總召說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2616.wav", + "text": "心理及口腔健康業務部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2617.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2618.wav", + "text": "原本的文字如果都已經修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2619.wav", + "text": "然後變成這個主決議的版本是可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2620.wav", + "text": "各黨團應該是沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2621.wav", + "text": "因為這很中性啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2622.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2623.wav", + "text": "第一次的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2624.wav", + "text": "我們願意修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2625.wav", + "text": "願意協商啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2626.wav", + "text": "幹嘛來協商呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2627.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2628.wav", + "text": "已經第二次了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2629.wav", + "text": "這樣可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2630.wav", + "text": "但是引以為戒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2631.wav", + "text": "以後不要再這樣搞好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2632.wav", + "text": "你要道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2633.wav", + "text": "你幹嘛用這種口氣講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2634.wav", + "text": "柯總召真的是要請宵夜啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2635.wav", + "text": "主席這個文字修正通過啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2636.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2637.wav", + "text": "這個支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2638.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2639.wav", + "text": "你們現在態度怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2640.wav", + "text": "可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2641.wav", + "text": "尊重啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2642.wav", + "text": "好同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2643.wav", + "text": "再修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2644.wav", + "text": "156案改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2645.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2646.wav", + "text": "再修正的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2647.wav", + "text": "本來就沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2648.wav", + "text": "怎麼再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2649.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2650.wav", + "text": "他有兩個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2651.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2652.wav", + "text": "前面那個沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2653.wav", + "text": "我怎麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2654.wav", + "text": "再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2655.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2656.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2657.wav", + "text": "以後提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2658.wav", + "text": "大家引以為戒好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2659.wav", + "text": "367" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2660.wav", + "text": "367" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2661.wav", + "text": "看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2662.wav", + "text": "簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2663.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2664.wav", + "text": "什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2665.wav", + "text": "他們的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2666.wav", + "text": "簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2667.wav", + "text": "看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2668.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2669.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2670.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2671.wav", + "text": "改主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2672.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2673.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2674.wav", + "text": "相關部會首長坐在後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2675.wav", + "text": "怎麼都不講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2676.wav", + "text": "他們都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2677.wav", + "text": "這個是托嬰中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2678.wav", + "text": "跟月子中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2679.wav", + "text": "長跟柯總召報告一下啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2680.wav", + "text": "還是提一個書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2681.wav", + "text": "法你是做不到的喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2682.wav", + "text": "主要是一個研議的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2683.wav", + "text": "事你能夠做得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2684.wav", + "text": "六個月的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2685.wav", + "text": "草案預告內容而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2686.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2687.wav", + "text": "目前法案也是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2688.wav", + "text": "預告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2689.wav", + "text": "預告就是你們要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2690.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2691.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2692.wav", + "text": "依���行政院秘書長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2693.wav", + "text": "一項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2694.wav", + "text": "法律案跟法規命令案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2695.wav", + "text": "要先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2696.wav", + "text": "廣為徵詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2697.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2698.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2699.wav", + "text": "整部法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2700.wav", + "text": "一個預告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2701.wav", + "text": "是一部新的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2702.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2703.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2704.wav", + "text": "算是一部新訂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2705.wav", + "text": "原來是什麼法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2706.wav", + "text": "原來是兒童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2707.wav", + "text": "及少年福利與權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2708.wav", + "text": "保障法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2709.wav", + "text": "裡面有關托兒少對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2710.wav", + "text": "你要把這一部分拉出來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2711.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2712.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2713.wav", + "text": "我們已經跟民團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2714.wav", + "text": "還有外部地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2715.wav", + "text": "等有先開過會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2716.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2717.wav", + "text": "兒權法這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2718.wav", + "text": "現在也還在開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2719.wav", + "text": "兩邊要比較一致性的搭配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2720.wav", + "text": "大概六個月可以把大致上相關的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2721.wav", + "text": "草案內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2722.wav", + "text": "我怕你會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2723.wav", + "text": "會有風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2724.wav", + "text": "他們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2725.wav", + "text": "提兒童托育服務法沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2726.wav", + "text": "大家要去研究一下沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2727.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2728.wav", + "text": "但是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2729.wav", + "text": "提出研議結果就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2730.wav", + "text": "有修法方向就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2731.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2732.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2733.wav", + "text": "看委員是不是可以改為修法方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2734.wav", + "text": "你預告就是確定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2735.wav", + "text": "我們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2736.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2737.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2738.wav", + "text": "那就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2739.wav", + "text": "就是改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2740.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2741.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2742.wav", + "text": "改修法方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2743.wav", + "text": "啊因為這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2744.wav", + "text": "各方有不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2745.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2746.wav", + "text": "午才跟部長談過這件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2747.wav", + "text": "件很嚴肅的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2748.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2749.wav", + "text": "好的事情我們絕對不會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2750.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2751.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2752.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2753.wav", + "text": "那衛福部就到此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2754.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2755.wav", + "text": "我們要繼續開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2756.wav", + "text": "請大家就位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2757.wav", + "text": "列席的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2758.wav", + "text": "環保署署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2759.wav", + "text": "張子敬先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2760.wav", + "text": "我們現在來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2761.wav", + "text": "環保署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2762.wav", + "text": "案到第470" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2763.wav", + "text": "跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2764.wav", + "text": "提案委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2765.wav", + "text": "同意改為一個主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2766.wav", + "text": "簽名了在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2767.wav", + "text": "各位委員桌上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2768.wav", + "text": "我同意改成主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2769.wav", + "text": "我有提供一個圖表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2770.wav", + "text": "就按照這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2771.wav", + "text": "改成主決議的書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2772.wav", + "text": "給我們好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2773.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2774.wav", + "text": "剛有發了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2775.wav", + "text": "執政黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2776.wav", + "text": "等一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2777.wav", + "text": "各黨團看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2778.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2779.wav", + "text": "一共95案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2780.wav", + "text": "併為1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2781.wav", + "text": "提主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2782.wav", + "text": "主決議我們看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2783.wav", + "text": "我都已經跟他談好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2784.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2785.wav", + "text": "有什麼意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2786.wav", + "text": "也可以不要主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2787.wav", + "text": "意思是要用強迫的就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2788.wav", + "text": "你這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2789.wav", + "text": "不是啦報告六個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2790.wav", + "text": "很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2791.wav", + "text": "我有一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2792.wav", + "text": "提供12項關鍵戰略的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2793.wav", + "text": "你看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2794.wav", + "text": "中文不太好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2795.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2796.wav", + "text": "大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2797.wav", + "text": "那個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2798.wav", + "text": "應該是寫錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2799.wav", + "text": "寫錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2800.wav", + "text": "對應該戈字旁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2801.wav", + "text": "這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2802.wav", + "text": "寫錯字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2803.wav", + "text": "寫錯字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2804.wav", + "text": "你敢挑戰時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2805.wav", + "text": "附帶決議的部分請署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2806.wav", + "text": "署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2807.wav", + "text": "加強部屬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2808.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2809.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2810.wav", + "text": "那我要宣布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2811.wav", + "text": "嗎我宣布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2812.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2813.wav", + "text": "還有1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2814.wav", + "text": "我宣布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2815.wav", + "text": "併為1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2816.wav", + "text": "改為主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2817.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2818.wav", + "text": "接下來請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2819.wav", + "text": "我們就不要吵了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2820.wav", + "text": "你們要討論一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2821.wav", + "text": "署長講一下話吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2822.wav", + "text": "是希望我們在3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2823.wav", + "text": "這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2824.wav", + "text": "研擬提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2825.wav", + "text": "修署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2826.wav", + "text": "署長那你要多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2827.wav", + "text": "3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2828.wav", + "text": "要多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2829.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2830.wav", + "text": "內先提出修法方向的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2831.wav", + "text": "書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2832.wav", + "text": "上次第一輪的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2833.wav", + "text": "我也有報告說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2834.wav", + "text": "其實我們自己也很急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2835.wav", + "text": "我們會儘快來修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2836.wav", + "text": "那我們就保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2837.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2838.wav", + "text": "早點說就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2839.wav", + "text": "繼續保留\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2840.wav", + "text": "\n到一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2841.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2842.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2843.wav", + "text": "謝謝署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2844.wav", + "text": "第三輪繼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2845.wav", + "text": "第三輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2846.wav", + "text": "第三輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2847.wav", + "text": "十八輪都陪你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2848.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2849.wav", + "text": "總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2850.wav", + "text": "第二輪協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2851.wav", + "text": "已經完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2852.wav", + "text": "我唸一下協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2853.wav", + "text": "大家要聽一下喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2854.wav", + "text": "立法院黨團協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2855.wav", + "text": "時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2856.wav", + "text": "112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2857.wav", + "text": "1月6日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2858.wav", + "text": "38分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2859.wav", + "text": "112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2860.wav", + "text": "1月7日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2861.wav", + "text": "112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2862.wav", + "text": "1月9日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2863.wav", + "text": "112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2864.wav", + "text": "1月10日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2865.wav", + "text": "地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2866.wav", + "text": "紅樓302" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2867.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2868.wav", + "text": "本(112)年度總預算案之討論程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2869.wav", + "text": "及決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2870.wav", + "text": "如附件1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2871.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2872.wav", + "text": "針對各機關所屬通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2873.wav", + "text": "刪減用途別項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2874.wav", + "text": "(含行政院主計總處整理之明細內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2875.wav", + "text": ")如附件2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2876.wav", + "text": "通案提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2877.wav", + "text": "及各委員會通過之協商內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2878.wav", + "text": "(含保留部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2879.wav", + "text": "由各委員會整理宣讀本及保留本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2880.wav", + "text": "上開附件1-2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2881.wav", + "text": "由財政委員會彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2882.wav", + "text": "送各黨團確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2883.wav", + "text": "附件3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2884.wav", + "text": "由各委員會送各黨團確認後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2885.wav", + "text": "送財政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2886.wav", + "text": "附件1-3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2887.wav", + "text": "由財政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2888.wav", + "text": "於1月11日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2889.wav", + "text": ")下午5��前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2890.wav", + "text": "送議事處俾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2891.wav", + "text": "院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2892.wav", + "text": "\n二本案於1月12日(星期四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2893.wav", + "text": ")院會進行處理時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2894.wav", + "text": "非保留部分宣讀後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2895.wav", + "text": "均予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2896.wav", + "text": "保留部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2897.wav", + "text": "均暫保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2898.wav", + "text": "保留部分進行處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2899.wav", + "text": "由時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2900.wav", + "text": "民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2901.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2902.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2903.wav", + "text": "發言順序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2904.wav", + "text": "授權議事處處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2905.wav", + "text": "每人發言時間為3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2906.wav", + "text": "發言完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2907.wav", + "text": "各保留提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2908.wav", + "text": "均不再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2909.wav", + "text": "即按通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2910.wav", + "text": "各委員會次序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2911.wav", + "text": "進行各保留提案之處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2912.wav", + "text": "各項提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2913.wav", + "text": "均予刊登公報紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2914.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2915.wav", + "text": "第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2916.wav", + "text": "我們建議多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2917.wav", + "text": "啦本黨1人才3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2918.wav", + "text": "各黨團3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2919.wav", + "text": "至少三長可以上去講啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2920.wav", + "text": "我們講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2921.wav", + "text": "至少三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2922.wav", + "text": "至少3人至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2923.wav", + "text": "至多3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2924.wav", + "text": "各推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2925.wav", + "text": "3人不想推派到3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2926.wav", + "text": "但最多推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2927.wav", + "text": "有委屈的一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2928.wav", + "text": "怎麼講得完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2929.wav", + "text": "各推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2930.wav", + "text": "至多3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2931.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2932.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2933.wav", + "text": "那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2934.wav", + "text": "通刪比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2935.wav", + "text": "通刪比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2936.wav", + "text": "要再唸嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2937.wav", + "text": "昨天加兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2938.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2939.wav", + "text": "確定一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2940.wav", + "text": "是星期四處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2941.wav", + "text": "就是1月12日(星期四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2942.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2943.wav", + "text": "那個通刪比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2944.wav", + "text": "你都還會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2945.wav", + "text": "翻出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2946.wav", + "text": "還要唸嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2947.wav", + "text": "9時開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2948.wav", + "text": "10時開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2949.wav", + "text": "9時開始唸嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2950.wav", + "text": "如果他們有送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2951.wav", + "text": "9時開始唸宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2952.wav", + "text": "唸1個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2953.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2954.wav", + "text": "10時開始發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2955.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2956.wav", + "text": "總預算是一回事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2957.wav", + "text": "法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2958.wav", + "text": "公務人員任用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2959.wav", + "text": "好像不處理的樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2960.wav", + "text": "要不要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2961.wav", + "text": "明天要做什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2962.wav", + "text": "明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2963.wav", + "text": "可以讀嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2964.wav", + "text": "簽了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2965.wav", + "text": "要來這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2966.wav", + "text": "每黨都要簽那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2967.wav", + "text": "我們還沒簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2968.wav", + "text": "很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2969.wav", + "text": "你們最在意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2970.wav", + "text": "我們兩個在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2971.wav", + "text": "也都簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2972.wav", + "text": "簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2973.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2974.wav", + "text": "正本在曾銘宗手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2975.wav", + "text": "卡在你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2976.wav", + "text": "總召單純化啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2977.wav", + "text": "一樣一樣來現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2978.wav", + "text": "在是要單純化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2979.wav", + "text": "明天還有一些法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2980.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2981.wav", + "text": "一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2982.wav", + "text": "可以讀的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2983.wav", + "text": "案件審理法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2984.wav", + "text": "要唸很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2985.wav", + "text": "一百零多分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2986.wav", + "text": "六十幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2987.wav", + "text": "柯總召讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2988.wav", + "text": "曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2989.wav", + "text": "來協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2990.wav", + "text": "朝野有什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2991.wav", + "text": "11時會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2992.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2993.wav", + "text": "國民黨唯一提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2994.wav", + "text": "我們明天把它協商完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2995.wav", + "text": "在總預算時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2996.wav", + "text": "不然就明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2997.wav", + "text": "下午2時協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2998.wav", + "text": "法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/2999.wav", + "text": "時好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3000.wav", + "text": "常會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3001.wav", + "text": "33時好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3002.wav", + "text": "4條而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3003.wav", + "text": "100天也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3004.wav", + "text": "這一條你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3005.wav", + "text": "還有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3006.wav", + "text": "不然就表決嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3007.wav", + "text": "明天下午3時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3008.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3009.wav", + "text": "剩下還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3010.wav", + "text": "地籍法你們還沒有簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3011.wav", + "text": "簽物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3012.wav", + "text": "物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3013.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3014.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3015.wav", + "text": "那就這樣子囉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3016.wav", + "text": "今天就到這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3017.wav", + "text": "我們各自再看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3018.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3019.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3020.wav", + "text": "差不多大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3021.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3022.wav", + "text": "明天下午3時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14768/3023.wav", + "text": "法案協商不另行書面通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/0.wav", + "text": "我們現在就開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/1.wav", + "text": "點我們都是我想請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/2.wav", + "text": "他有同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/3.wav", + "text": "議委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/4.wav", + "text": "的好謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/5.wav", + "text": "也沒有13日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/6.wav", + "text": "在講都沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/7.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/8.wav", + "text": "發現金那就儘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/9.wav", + "text": "針不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/10.wav", + "text": "第我在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/11.wav", + "text": "我們就等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/12.wav", + "text": "意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/13.wav", + "text": "們來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/14.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/15.wav", + "text": "再跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/16.wav", + "text": "邊再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/17.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/18.wav", + "text": "\n第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/19.wav", + "text": "理沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/20.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/21.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/22.wav", + "text": "我們看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/23.wav", + "text": "是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/24.wav", + "text": "那這個這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/25.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣要不要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/26.wav", + "text": "公開的主決議是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/27.wav", + "text": "決議辦理沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/28.wav", + "text": "主決議沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/29.wav", + "text": "那為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/30.wav", + "text": "我們因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/31.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/32.wav", + "text": "可是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/33.wav", + "text": "所以就沒有這就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/34.wav", + "text": "一個其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/35.wav", + "text": "我們講一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/36.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/37.wav", + "text": "稅就是我知道這個就是2," + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/38.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/39.wav", + "text": "在我們來看故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/40.wav", + "text": "文字你們都已經有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/41.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/42.wav", + "text": "我們好現在來看第5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/43.wav", + "text": "已經有一案這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/44.wav", + "text": "意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/45.wav", + "text": "議是不是就沒關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/46.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/47.wav", + "text": "所以我們當然對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/48.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/49.wav", + "text": "團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/50.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/51.wav", + "text": "就是運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/52.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/53.wav", + "text": "就是針對我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/54.wav", + "text": "對人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/55.wav", + "text": "112年1月10日(星" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/56.wav", + "text": "內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/57.wav", + "text": "本案於1月1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/58.wav", + "text": "到時候讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/59.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/60.wav", + "text": "要再唸嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/61.wav", + "text": "昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/62.wav", + "text": "確定一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14767/63.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/0.wav", + "text": "各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1.wav", + "text": "各部會代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2.wav", + "text": "各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3.wav", + "text": "大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4.wav", + "text": "現在進行今天的立法院黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5.wav", + "text": "研商的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/6.wav", + "text": "一繼續研商溫室氣體減量及管理法修正草案等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/7.wav", + "text": "二研商公務人員任用法第22條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/8.wav", + "text": "等案\n接下來我來介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/9.wav", + "text": "今天列席的行政院首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/10.wav", + "text": "首先介紹行政院環境保護署署長張子敬先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/11.wav", + "text": "再來介紹司法院副秘書長黃麟倫先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/12.wav", + "text": "再來介紹經濟部政務次長曾文生先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/13.wav", + "text": "再來介紹交通部政務次長陳彥伯先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/14.wav", + "text": "再來介紹原住民族委員會副主任委員鍾興華先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/15.wav", + "text": "以上介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/16.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們開始進行今天議題的意見交換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/17.wav", + "text": "昨天非常謝謝大家的辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/18.wav", + "text": "昨天溫室氣體減量法修正草案審查跟協商的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/19.wav", + "text": "暫時保留的一共還有十個條次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/20.wav", + "text": "包括第2條第4條第5條第8條第10條第十七條第二十八條第二十九條第三十二條及第三十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/21.wav", + "text": "現在就針對這十個條文依序看大家有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/22.wav", + "text": "\n請曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/23.wav", + "text": "昨天協調通過的第36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/24.wav", + "text": "金管會認為在文字上不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/25.wav", + "text": "他有重新擬訂文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/26.wav", + "text": "是不是請金管會說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/27.wav", + "text": "我們要從前面的條次開始還是直接要從第36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/28.wav", + "text": "36條屬於昨天協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/29.wav", + "text": "金管會希望文字稍微調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/30.wav", + "text": "因為將來他們負責交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/31.wav", + "text": "有一些交易秩序等等他們比較專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/32.wav", + "text": "所以文字要寫完整一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/33.wav", + "text": "我想曾銘宗委員的意思就是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/34.wav", + "text": "環保署也沒有意見對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/35.wav", + "text": "這一條昨天協商通過要再改我們先處理也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/36.wav", + "text": "好啦那就第36條先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/37.wav", + "text": "處理完再依序照昨天保留的好因為這已經是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/38.wav", + "text": "昨天協調通過的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/39.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/40.wav", + "text": "不是讓署長來講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/41.wav", + "text": "沒有金管會先說明請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/42.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/43.wav", + "text": "因為後來我們增加了第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/44.wav", + "text": "就是中央主管機關得委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/45.wav", + "text": "中央金融主管機關這個項次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/46.wav", + "text": "次我們是建議這個項次擺在第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/47.wav", + "text": "第4項委託中央金融主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/48.wav", + "text": "第3項要移到第4項把它改成前三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/49.wav", + "text": "原來的第3項變第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/50.wav", + "text": "帳戶開立應檢具之資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/51.wav", + "text": "帳戶管理扣減排放額度移轉與交易之對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/52.wav", + "text": "至於次數限制我們建議把它劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/53.wav", + "text": "交易會有一點難度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/54.wav", + "text": "後面接的文字一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/55.wav", + "text": "就是手續費及其他應遵行事項之辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/56.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/57.wav", + "text": "第3項涉及額度之交易事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/58.wav", + "text": "應會商中央金融主管機關同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/59.wav", + "text": "也就是在這個單張中把原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/60.wav", + "text": "第3項和第4項對調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/61.wav", + "text": "對調後第3項的文字不動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/62.wav", + "text": "還要把交易次數限制劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/63.wav", + "text": "對把次數限制劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/64.wav", + "text": "上第3項涉及額度之交易事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/65.wav", + "text": "應會商中央金融主管機關同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/66.wav", + "text": "大家有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/67.wav", + "text": "這在執行上是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/68.wav", + "text": "額度的交易事宜要會商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/69.wav", + "text": "是不是有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/70.wav", + "text": "如果金管會覺得這樣改比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/71.wav", + "text": "我們基本上會尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/72.wav", + "text": "但若因為這樣的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/73.wav", + "text": "請容許我們順一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/74.wav", + "text": "涉及到的其他條文是不是要一起更動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/75.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/76.wav", + "text": "應該沒有涉及吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/77.wav", + "text": "授權給他們吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/78.wav", + "text": "建議修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/79.wav", + "text": "第36條的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/80.wav", + "text": "罰則怎麼會變呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/81.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/82.wav", + "text": "如果大家都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/83.wav", + "text": "也都同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/84.wav", + "text": "本條就照現在這一張的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/85.wav", + "text": "建議修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/86.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/87.wav", + "text": "要特別附帶一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/88.wav", + "text": "其他條文項次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/89.wav", + "text": "如有涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/90.wav", + "text": "就配合變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/91.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/92.wav", + "text": "回頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/93.wav", + "text": "保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/94.wav", + "text": "保留條文就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/95.wav", + "text": "是開頭的第2條和第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/96.wav", + "text": "兩條都重新看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/97.wav", + "text": "部分環保署已稍微修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/98.wav", + "text": "了請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/99.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/100.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/101.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/102.wav", + "text": "不論有沒有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/103.wav", + "text": "完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/104.wav", + "text": "修正條文內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/105.wav", + "text": "已經明定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/106.wav", + "text": "主辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/107.wav", + "text": "部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/108.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/109.wav", + "text": "我在此增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/110.wav", + "text": "文字就是前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/111.wav", + "text": "修正動議新增了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/112.wav", + "text": "中央有關機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/113.wav", + "text": "應會同永續會秘書處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/114.wav", + "text": "及中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/115.wav", + "text": "定期召開工作會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/116.wav", + "text": "以追蹤檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/117.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷業務之執行成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/118.wav", + "text": "因為我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/119.wav", + "text": "並不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/120.wav", + "text": "在野黨提出把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/121.wav", + "text": "把永續會改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/122.wav", + "text": "會辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/123.wav", + "text": "雖然一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/124.wav", + "text": "後我們也瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/125.wav", + "text": "目前行政院永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/126.wav", + "text": "的秘書處並不是環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/127.wav", + "text": "而是國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/128.wav", + "text": "說實在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/129.wav", + "text": "國家永續會秘書處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/130.wav", + "text": "轉到國發會以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/131.wav", + "text": "所有的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/132.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/133.wav", + "text": "不被認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/134.wav", + "text": "永續會的秘書處仍然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/135.wav", + "text": "在國發會的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/136.wav", + "text": "不知道後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/137.wav", + "text": "會不會有什麼改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/138.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/139.wav", + "text": "在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/140.wav", + "text": "及環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/141.wav", + "text": "也就是中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/142.wav", + "text": "納入後續各主辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/143.wav", + "text": "的目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/144.wav", + "text": "在召開會議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/145.wav", + "text": "永續會秘書處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/146.wav", + "text": "及環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/147.wav", + "text": "定期召開工作會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/148.wav", + "text": "來追蹤檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/149.wav", + "text": "以上說明請支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/150.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/151.wav", + "text": "洪委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/152.wav", + "text": "針對第2條跟第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/153.wav", + "text": "大家就一併講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/154.wav", + "text": "在行政院的機制是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/155.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/156.wav", + "text": "我們很清楚知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/157.wav", + "text": "是說避免疊床架屋等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/158.wav", + "text": "但也必須承認一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/159.wav", + "text": "有點像大堆頭這樣的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/160.wav", + "text": "不見得能在特定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/161.wav", + "text": "重要的工作事務上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/162.wav", + "text": "做比較對焦的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/163.wav", + "text": "過去的狀況是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/164.wav", + "text": "我有質詢過蘇院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/165.wav", + "text": "蘇院長也有承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/166.wav", + "text": "永續會的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/167.wav", + "text": "跟運作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/168.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷所需要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/169.wav", + "text": "希望能提出檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/170.wav", + "text": "覺得我們可以提一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/171.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/172.wav", + "text": "這個附帶決議是要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/173.wav", + "text": "永續會的組成跟運作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/174.wav", + "text": "應檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/175.wav", + "text": "以符合接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/176.wav", + "text": "跨部會氣候變遷政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/177.wav", + "text": "制定協調整合的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/178.wav", + "text": "我自己是希望我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/179.wav", + "text": "也可以提一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/180.wav", + "text": "讓永續會接下來的改造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/181.wav", + "text": "更符合我們對這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/182.wav", + "text": "很多功能的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/183.wav", + "text": "環保署或是經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/184.wav", + "text": "可以正面的回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/185.wav", + "text": "我覺得真的有點像是狗吠火車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/186.wav", + "text": "能源部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/187.wav", + "text": "占了我們排碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/188.wav", + "text": "整部法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/189.wav", + "text": "我不知道到底是為了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/190.wav", + "text": "如果我們真的要減碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/191.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以放過能源部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/192.wav", + "text": "整部法不強調能源部門要減碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/193.wav", + "text": "最大宗的排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/194.wav", + "text": "我不知道為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/195.wav", + "text": "可以整個忽略掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/196.wav", + "text": "其他製造部門運輸部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/197.wav", + "text": "建築部門服務業農業部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/198.wav", + "text": "你自己看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/199.wav", + "text": "你們的溫室氣體排放統計手冊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/200.wav", + "text": "是怎麼分部門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/201.wav", + "text": "為什麼可以獨獨漏掉能源部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/202.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/203.wav", + "text": "吳欣盈委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/204.wav", + "text": "我們還是要補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/205.wav", + "text": "民眾黨主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/206.wav", + "text": "先碳費後碳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/207.wav", + "text": "應該在行政院版的第8條新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/208.wav", + "text": "綠色稅制之研擬推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/209.wav", + "text": "由財政部主辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/210.wav", + "text": "綠色稅制不用訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/211.wav", + "text": "財政部也可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/212.wav", + "text": "是依照這樣的邏輯那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/213.wav", + "text": "整個條文就不用寫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/214.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/215.wav", + "text": "麻煩您再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/216.wav", + "text": "考慮一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/217.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/218.wav", + "text": "請邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/219.wav", + "text": "第一個問題應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/220.wav", + "text": "現在永續會的執行長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/221.wav", + "text": "變成是國發會的主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/222.wav", + "text": "所以在下面設一個小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/223.wav", + "text": "依照世界其他各國的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/224.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/225.wav", + "text": "等一下也要請署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/226.wav", + "text": "到底是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/227.wav", + "text": "因為這個小組確實也應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/228.wav", + "text": "有實際上的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/229.wav", + "text": "比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/230.wav", + "text": "它的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/231.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/232.wav", + "text": "過到���它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/233.wav", + "text": "它能不能有專責人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/234.wav", + "text": "能夠負責這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/235.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/236.wav", + "text": "是部會權責入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/237.wav", + "text": "從善如流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/238.wav", + "text": "部會權責入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/239.wav", + "text": "不過我們認為少了三個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/240.wav", + "text": "一個部分是財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/241.wav", + "text": "一個部分是衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/242.wav", + "text": "而未來勢必會以徵收碳稅為主要原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/243.wav", + "text": "也找過賦稅署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/244.wav", + "text": "財政部的權責入法然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/245.wav", + "text": "後它又一直在推託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/246.wav", + "text": "在這樣的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/247.wav", + "text": "我們要如何因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/248.wav", + "text": "讓財政部去處理這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/249.wav", + "text": "才能夠有效地分配應對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/250.wav", + "text": "衛福部應該要去負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/251.wav", + "text": "之國民身心健康保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/252.wav", + "text": "跟公共衛生的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/253.wav", + "text": "現在越來越頻繁地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/254.wav", + "text": "所造成的熱傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/255.wav", + "text": "為例比如說每個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/256.wav", + "text": "夏天你都會越來越頻繁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/257.wav", + "text": "地看到我們的郵差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/258.wav", + "text": "等等的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/259.wav", + "text": "所以針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/260.wav", + "text": "警告高溫帶來的威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/261.wav", + "text": "高溫甚至會影響人類行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/262.wav", + "text": "不應該置身事外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/263.wav", + "text": "並且要有一個積極地應對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/264.wav", + "text": "他們的軍方都有應對氣候變遷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/265.wav", + "text": "白皮書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/266.wav", + "text": "而我們只是要求要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/267.wav", + "text": "把它的權責入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/268.wav", + "text": "並且在遇到的時候要積極應對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/269.wav", + "text": "個最低的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/270.wav", + "text": "也是一個最起碼的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/271.wav", + "text": "椒華第二次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/272.wav", + "text": "我再解釋一下剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/273.wav", + "text": "在各個主辦機關入法之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/274.wav", + "text": "假如一個月開一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/275.wav", + "text": "工作會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/276.wav", + "text": "請問這個工作會議是要自己開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/277.wav", + "text": "還是中央主管機關要一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/278.wav", + "text": "秘書處要不要一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/279.wav", + "text": "現在工作執行的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/280.wav", + "text": "至於人力的部分秘書處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/281.wav", + "text": "目前是國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/282.wav", + "text": "目前是環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/283.wav", + "text": "這些人力有沒有辦法去參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/284.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/285.wav", + "text": "對於這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/286.wav", + "text": "工作會議要怎麼召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/287.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/288.wav", + "text": "才能夠有效地完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/289.wav", + "text": "包括碳費徵收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/290.wav", + "text": "以及後續各工作小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/291.wav", + "text": "昨天這個案子討論了一個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/292.wav", + "text": "我們說再溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/293.wav", + "text": "後來有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/294.wav", + "text": "轍現在林委員要發表意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/295.wav", + "text": "等林委員發表意見後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/296.wav", + "text": "我們就繼續保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/297.wav", + "text": "沒有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/298.wav", + "text": "完全沒有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/299.wav", + "text": "林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/300.wav", + "text": "這次我看到新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/301.wav", + "text": "是有把國民黨黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/302.wav", + "text": "有把這部分再放回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/303.wav", + "text": "但是在主辦單位方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/304.wav", + "text": "卻把財政部放在協辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/305.wav", + "text": "整個誘因機制裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/306.wav", + "text": "如果企業願意配合舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/307.wav", + "text": "說能夠有一些貸款機制等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/308.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/309.wav", + "text": "可以按照國民黨黨團原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/310.wav", + "text": "能把財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/311.wav", + "text": "放回原來的主辦單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/312.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/313.wav", + "text": "滿不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/314.wav", + "text": "第4條有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/315.wav", + "text": "短中長期要入法我是指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/316.wav", + "text": "第4條請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/317.wav", + "text": "很大部分的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/318.wav", + "text": "沒有差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/319.wav", + "text": "我不知道到底溝通了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/320.wav", + "text": "所以是不是先讓我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/321.wav", + "text": "到底溝通哪幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/322.wav", + "text": "哪幾條有變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/323.wav", + "text": "我們就直接討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/324.wav", + "text": "他們連回應都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/325.wav", + "text": "我們至少要讓他們回應吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/326.wav", + "text": "至少讓他們回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/327.wav", + "text": "留下會議紀錄啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/328.wav", + "text": "不是都沒有回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/329.wav", + "text": "現在就是在溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/330.wav", + "text": "現在就是在溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/331.wav", + "text": "最主要是各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/332.wav", + "text": "都要同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/333.wav", + "text": "因為是合議制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/334.wav", + "text": "你們都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/335.wav", + "text": "我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/336.wav", + "text": "他們也不敢有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/337.wav", + "text": "現在不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/338.wav", + "text": "全部都是部會的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/339.wav", + "text": "而是各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/340.wav", + "text": "我們現在再怎麼罵他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/341.wav", + "text": "也沒有沒有一個黨的意見是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/342.wav", + "text": "院長要不要請他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/343.wav", + "text": "這個小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/344.wav", + "text": "的組成到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/345.wav", + "text": "量能是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/346.wav", + "text": "我們現在針對第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/347.wav", + "text": "第8條都沒有回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/348.wav", + "text": "剛才我已經裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/349.wav", + "text": "你們沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/350.wav", + "text": "這樣會要怎麼開你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/351.wav", + "text": "他有把你們的部分採納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/352.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/353.wav", + "text": "剛才那個已經裁示保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/354.wav", + "text": "已經決定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/355.wav", + "text": "了我們現在就針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/356.wav", + "text": "等一下還會回來處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/357.wav", + "text": "理是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/358.wav", + "text": "剛剛第2條第8條是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/359.wav", + "text": "等一下還會回來確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/360.wav", + "text": "他要表決了已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/361.wav", + "text": "已經第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/362.wav", + "text": "就是要表決了是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/363.wav", + "text": "那我們就請他們回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/364.wav", + "text": "如果你們後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/365.wav", + "text": "有共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/366.wav", + "text": "就不一定會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/367.wav", + "text": "我並不是說你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/368.wav", + "text": "我只是說保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/369.wav", + "text": "而保留有很多可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/370.wav", + "text": "保留之後還是有可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/371.wav", + "text": "我覺得大���各自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/372.wav", + "text": "沒有不讓他們發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/373.wav", + "text": "我現在不是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/374.wav", + "text": "要他們發言嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/375.wav", + "text": "剛剛大家都問了問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/376.wav", + "text": "至少要有會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/377.wav", + "text": "昨天講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/378.wav", + "text": "難道就沒有會議紀錄嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/379.wav", + "text": "委員會講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/380.wav", + "text": "剛剛第8條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/381.wav", + "text": "讓他講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/382.wav", + "text": "讓他也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/383.wav", + "text": "他可以回應大家的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/384.wav", + "text": "第2條跟第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/385.wav", + "text": "回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/386.wav", + "text": "如果還是沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/387.wav", + "text": "我們就進入第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/388.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/389.wav", + "text": "第一個是永續會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/390.wav", + "text": "因為原來永續會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/391.wav", + "text": "的秘書處在環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/392.wav", + "text": "現在改到國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/393.wav", + "text": "因為賦予它的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/394.wav", + "text": "任務是不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/395.wav", + "text": "所以大家的印象可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/396.wav", + "text": "還是原來在環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/397.wav", + "text": "其實現在改到國發會以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/398.wav", + "text": "它負責的還包括氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/399.wav", + "text": "不會像原來那樣且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/400.wav", + "text": "且任務也不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/401.wav", + "text": "永續會都已經發揮了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/402.wav", + "text": "我們預期要的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/403.wav", + "text": "當然我知道各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/404.wav", + "text": "到底它的人力資源夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/405.wav", + "text": "因為移到國發會之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/406.wav", + "text": "已經增加了一個專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/407.wav", + "text": "就是有關氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/408.wav", + "text": "與淨零轉型的小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/409.wav", + "text": "這是直接由執行長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/410.wav", + "text": "則暫時是由環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/411.wav", + "text": "負責所以環保署有關這部分的人力資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/412.wav", + "text": "都會投在這個專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/413.wav", + "text": "所以暫時是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/414.wav", + "text": "當然委員關心它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/415.wav", + "text": "它長期的人力資源等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/416.wav", + "text": "一定會幫它做這部分的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/417.wav", + "text": "有關能源部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/418.wav", + "text": "我昨天有稍微回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/419.wav", + "text": "如果有需要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/420.wav", + "text": "再請曾次長跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/421.wav", + "text": "有沒有部會主責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/422.wav", + "text": "答案是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/423.wav", + "text": "就是經濟部主辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/424.wav", + "text": "在第1款和第2款都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/425.wav", + "text": "能源部門的排放有兩個元素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/426.wav", + "text": "第一是單位電的排碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/427.wav", + "text": "第二是用電度數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/428.wav", + "text": "這兩個元素拆成兩條寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/429.wav", + "text": "第1條是每一度電的碳排係數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/430.wav", + "text": "是在第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/431.wav", + "text": "再生能源及能源科技發展這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/432.wav", + "text": "我們要發展這些新的能源科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/433.wav", + "text": "來降低每度電的碳排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/434.wav", + "text": "這是濃度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/435.wav", + "text": "第二個部分就是總量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/436.wav", + "text": "總量是所有的人用電要節約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/437.wav", + "text": "必須由經濟部主辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/438.wav", + "text": "和所有各部會一起協辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/439.wav", + "text": "這一題寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/440.wav", + "text": "我具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/441.wav", + "text": "就是各中央目的事業主管機關協辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/442.wav", + "text": "寫得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/443.wav", + "text": "第3款也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/444.wav", + "text": "總召說得好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/445.wav", + "text": "第4款也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/446.wav", + "text": "我講第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/447.wav", + "text": "我們比照第4款的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/448.wav", + "text": "運輸管理大眾運輸系統發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/449.wav", + "text": "及其他運輸部門溫室氣體減量事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/450.wav", + "text": "我們比照第4款的寫法好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/451.wav", + "text": "能源科技發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/452.wav", + "text": "及其他能源部門溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/453.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/454.wav", + "text": "第3款就有溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/455.wav", + "text": "這三款裡面寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/456.wav", + "text": "第3款是指製造部門的溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/457.wav", + "text": "這是指能源使用的節約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/458.wav", + "text": "並沒有涉及能源的製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/459.wav", + "text": "不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/460.wav", + "text": "我告訴你如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/461.wav", + "text": "如果現在的電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/462.wav", + "text": "力百分之百都是再生能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/463.wav", + "text": "但現在中小企業最煩惱的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/464.wav", + "text": "是之後要收碳費對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/465.wav", + "text": "我告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/466.wav", + "text": "他們都不知道有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/467.wav", + "text": "七成最少六成以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/468.wav", + "text": "其碳費繳納就是它的用電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/469.wav", + "text": "如果我們的電百分之百是再生能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/470.wav", + "text": "請說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/471.wav", + "text": "現在這個法針對中小企業有要收碳費嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/472.wav", + "text": "我們現在是由大到小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/473.wav", + "text": "但是因為現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/474.wav", + "text": "就是目前看的這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/475.wav", + "text": "我們一直對外講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/476.wav", + "text": "收碳費是由大到小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/477.wav", + "text": "我想大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/478.wav", + "text": "我們常常講287家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/479.wav", + "text": "是我們第一階段盤點的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/480.wav", + "text": "已經達到八成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/481.wav", + "text": "所以我們會從大的開始收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/482.wav", + "text": "主席請問可以說明嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/483.wav", + "text": "我先說第一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/484.wav", + "text": "臺灣的電力市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/485.wav", + "text": "在電業法現在已經有轉供機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/486.wav", + "text": "就是事實上可以直接買再生能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/487.wav", + "text": "現在非常多企業都在做這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/488.wav", + "text": "所以它不是一個封閉式電力系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/489.wav", + "text": "所以現在包含需要用的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/490.wav", + "text": "都在自己投資興建再生能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/491.wav", + "text": "全世界都用這個方法在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/492.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/493.wav", + "text": "就是自用的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/494.wav", + "text": "自己也投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/495.wav", + "text": "甚至投資以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/496.wav", + "text": "像我們看到能源市場的波動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/497.wav", + "text": "它反而拿到更便宜的電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/498.wav", + "text": "這是現在全球能源市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/499.wav", + "text": "在發生的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/500.wav", + "text": "這是第一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/501.wav", + "text": "\n第二件事情是電力業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/502.wav", + "text": "有沒有碳排管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/503.wav", + "text": "當然有在電業法裡面就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/504.wav", + "text": "罰多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/505.wav", + "text": "第三個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/506.wav", + "text": "如果收費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/507.wav", + "text": "依照第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/508.wav", + "text": "沒有全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/509.wav", + "text": "吳委員簡單來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/510.wav", + "text": "用電的排碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/511.wav", + "text": "電力的排碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/512.wav", + "text": "全部收電力公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/513.wav", + "text": "沒有全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/514.wav", + "text": "那哪些要收電力公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/515.wav", + "text": "我那時候就跟署長講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/516.wav", + "text": "你還有一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/517.wav", + "text": "刪掉的那一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/518.wav", + "text": "因為直接排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/519.wav", + "text": "和間接排放都課的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/520.wav", + "text": "一定會重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/521.wav", + "text": "你可以分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/522.wav", + "text": "為直接排放10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/523.wav", + "text": "間接排放90%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/524.wav", + "text": "我們至少要給台電一點壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/525.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說電台電公司的自用電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/526.wav", + "text": "電業法罰多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/527.wav", + "text": "台電公司的自用電絕對要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/528.wav", + "text": "法是一個管制的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/529.wav", + "text": "我先說幾個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/530.wav", + "text": "第一個罰1,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/531.wav", + "text": "第二個沒有開罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/532.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/533.wav", + "text": "現在不是用罰款來解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/534.wav", + "text": "所有用到電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/535.wav", + "text": "而去生產電給別人用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/536.wav", + "text": "用到電的這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/537.wav", + "text": "全部要繳碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/538.wav", + "text": "線損要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/539.wav", + "text": "那些自用的電力設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/540.wav", + "text": "全部都要繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/541.wav", + "text": "但是它是機制設計的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/542.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/543.wav", + "text": "做碳盤查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/544.wav", + "text": "不管是範疇一範疇二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/545.wav", + "text": "也就是所謂的直接間接用電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/546.wav", + "text": "為什麼用這樣規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/547.wav", + "text": "事實上就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/548.wav", + "text": "課責能夠明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/549.wav", + "text": "課到使用者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/550.wav", + "text": "是使用者要付費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/551.wav", + "text": "但是我跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/552.wav", + "text": "現在這個制度設計有什麼問題呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/553.wav", + "text": "大戶可以自己去買綠電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/554.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/555.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/556.wav", + "text": "要課徵的是208十幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/557.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/558.wav", + "text": "署長能不能保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/559.wav", + "text": "次長能不能保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/560.wav", + "text": "我們剛開始課徵的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/561.wav", + "text": "這208十幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/562.wav", + "text": "它要的綠電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/563.wav", + "text": "夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/564.wav", + "text": "開始課徵的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/565.wav", + "text": "能不能保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/566.wav", + "text": "它完全買到綠電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/567.wav", + "text": "要看臺灣當時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/568.wav", + "text": "綠電供應狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/569.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/570.wav", + "text": "它如果買不到綠電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/571.wav", + "text": "就是跟台電買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/572.wav", + "text": "發展速度最快的之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/573.wav", + "text": "不被支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/574.wav", + "text": "疏忽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/575.wav", + "text": "在低碳飲食的推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/576.wav", + "text": "也有提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/577.wav", + "text": "希望能夠將低碳飲食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/578.wav", + "text": "低碳飲食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/579.wav", + "text": "是指在生產包裝運銷消費過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/580.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/581.wav", + "text": "儘量降低的飲食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/582.wav", + "text": "在地食物及減少剩食的面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/583.wav", + "text": "希望能夠放在說明欄裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/584.wav", + "text": "署長我剛剛聽得不是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/585.wav", + "text": "這個小組的召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/586.wav", + "text": "是國發會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/587.wav", + "text": "環保署未來會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/588.wav", + "text": "國發會主委擔任小組召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/589.wav", + "text": "有環保署的公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/590.wav", + "text": "在這個小組裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/591.wav", + "text": "這個部分可能要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/592.wav", + "text": "稍微清楚說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/593.wav", + "text": "我們當然希望能夠有專人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/594.wav", + "text": "你們能夠跟人總要多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/595.wav", + "text": "是負責永續發展的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/596.wav", + "text": "現在因為任務不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/597.wav", + "text": "把氣候變遷比較大的分量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/598.wav", + "text": "加在永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/599.wav", + "text": "大家關心它會支撐不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/600.wav", + "text": "所以我剛剛講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/601.wav", + "text": "因應這個任務的交付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/602.wav", + "text": "設置了一個專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/603.wav", + "text": "專門針對氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/604.wav", + "text": "這個專案小組是由龔主委直接指揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/605.wav", + "text": "但是現在的秘書作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/606.wav", + "text": "全部是環保署在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/607.wav", + "text": "現在因為任務一下子轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/608.wav", + "text": "它沒辦法一下子增長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/609.wav", + "text": "所以現在是我們在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/610.wav", + "text": "因此在功能上沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/611.wav", + "text": "未來如果永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/612.wav", + "text": "要把這個工作統整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/613.wav", + "text": "署長回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/614.wav", + "text": "早上委員有跟我們提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/615.wav", + "text": "今天發的資料第6頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/616.wav", + "text": "有附註上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/617.wav", + "text": "到時候我們會把它放上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/618.wav", + "text": "講的差不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/619.wav", + "text": "針對第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/620.wav", + "text": "包括林奕華委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/621.wav", + "text": "已經修正在第十一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/622.wav", + "text": "財政部能不能放到主辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/623.wav", + "text": "財政部有財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/624.wav", + "text": "的像剛才我們處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/625.wav", + "text": "36條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/626.wav", + "text": "金管會主辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/627.wav", + "text": "財政部變成協辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/628.wav", + "text": "我們說真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/629.wav", + "text": "這一條要不要討論出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/630.wav", + "text": "出一個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/631.wav", + "text": "各執己見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/632.wav", + "text": "我們就保留方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/633.wav", + "text": "方才陳椒華委員說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/634.wav", + "text": "低碳飲食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/635.wav", + "text": "了有關於永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/636.wav", + "text": "剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/637.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員也提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/638.wav", + "text": "永續會沒有這項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/639.wav", + "text": "項工作未來有新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/640.wav", + "text": "生命和功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/641.wav", + "text": "而且是非常重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/642.wav", + "text": "國發會來做秘書的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/643.wav", + "text": "所有的部會都要投入進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/644.wav", + "text": "我們可以照案通過吳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/645.wav", + "text": "那是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/646.wav", + "text": "第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/647.wav", + "text": "不一定是台電是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/648.wav", + "text": "能源部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/649.wav", + "text": "是第28條的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/650.wav", + "text": "因為你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/651.wav", + "text": "我跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/652.wav", + "text": "第8條是整個大方向的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/653.wav", + "text": "總召我告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/654.wav", + "text": "你剛才談到的製造部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/655.wav", + "text": "那是節約用電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/656.wav", + "text": "以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/657.wav", + "text": "使用者免責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/658.wav", + "text": "全部叫台電付錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/659.wav", + "text": "我沒有說使用者免責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/660.wav", + "text": "你在第28條的論述就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/661.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/662.wav", + "text": "你要叫台電全部負責嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/663.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/664.wav", + "text": "我不可能叫台電全部負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/665.wav", + "text": "可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/666.wav", + "text": "台電一定要有壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/667.wav", + "text": "這個法完全沒有給台電壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/668.wav", + "text": "在這部法台電完全沒有壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/669.wav", + "text": "台電的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/670.wav", + "text": "只有電業法的1,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/671.wav", + "text": "元而且去年還沒有處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/672.wav", + "text": "員發言前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/673.wav", + "text": "我們還是要把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/674.wav", + "text": "跳到第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/675.wav", + "text": "林奕華委員昨天講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/676.wav", + "text": "我也請他們修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/677.wav", + "text": "第十一款但他又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/678.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/679.wav", + "text": "也是一樣的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/680.wav", + "text": "因為講的系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/681.wav", + "text": "包括碳費碳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/682.wav", + "text": "兩者系統完全是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/683.wav", + "text": "包含你講的第28條系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/684.wav", + "text": "和這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/685.wav", + "text": "的立法意旨完全是背離了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/686.wav", + "text": "這是有很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/687.wav", + "text": "所以還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/688.wav", + "text": "在軌道上來討論事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/689.wav", + "text": "我是很尊重大家意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/690.wav", + "text": "我都在旁邊一直聆聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/691.wav", + "text": "能源部門的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/692.wav", + "text": "我講一下我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/693.wav", + "text": "你會看到幾件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/694.wav", + "text": "我們一般講的能源政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/695.wav", + "text": "一個是供給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/696.wav", + "text": "一個是需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/697.wav", + "text": "能源政策就是供給跟需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/698.wav", + "text": "\n供給的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/699.wav", + "text": "就是在第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/700.wav", + "text": "再生能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/701.wav", + "text": "跟能源科技發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/702.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/703.wav", + "text": "現在我們在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/704.wav", + "text": "天然氣電廠的低碳化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/705.wav", + "text": "比方說要加氨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/706.wav", + "text": "這就是能源科技發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/707.wav", + "text": "比方說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/708.wav", + "text": "接下來我們開始讓燃煤電廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/709.wav", + "text": "也是用能源科技發展的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/710.wav", + "text": "來處理此問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/711.wav", + "text": "供給的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/712.wav", + "text": "就是在第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/713.wav", + "text": "需求的部分有兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/714.wav", + "text": "即能源使用效率的提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/715.wav", + "text": "及節約能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/716.wav", + "text": "第三個是製造業部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/717.wav", + "text": "所以你用能源政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/718.wav", + "text": "是供給跟需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/719.wav", + "text": "找到其對應的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/720.wav", + "text": "我再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/721.wav", + "text": "綠色稅制的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/722.wav", + "text": "及衛福部的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/723.wav", + "text": "因為你分配給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/724.wav", + "text": "這麼多的部會之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/725.wav", + "text": "各部會齊心協力把事情做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/726.wav", + "text": "未來應該要走入歷史而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/727.wav", + "text": "而碳稅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/728.wav", + "text": "應該是由財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/729.wav", + "text": "衛福部的部分也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/730.wav", + "text": "面對極端氣候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/731.wav", + "text": "婦女或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/732.wav", + "text": "各種職業的熱傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/733.wav", + "text": "等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/734.wav", + "text": "都應該要做妥善因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/735.wav", + "text": "剛剛署長回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/736.wav", + "text": "在永續會下面的小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/737.wav", + "text": "不管是署長副署長來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/738.wav", + "text": "實話是令人憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/739.wav", + "text": "也非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/740.wav", + "text": "是沒辦法承載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/741.wav", + "text": "所以我們需要設一個小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/742.wav", + "text": "變成國發會的主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/743.wav", + "text": "由國發會主委擔任小組召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/744.wav", + "text": "就是應該要去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/745.wav", + "text": "你有足夠的量能承擔這樣的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/746.wav", + "text": "有可能會再做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/747.wav", + "text": "剛剛財政部或衛福部的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/748.wav", + "text": "等一下也請財政部跟衛福部回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/749.wav", + "text": "你的答案是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/750.wav", + "text": "你的要求是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/751.wav", + "text": "財政部跟衛福部依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/752.wav", + "text": "法也希望把它的任務放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/753.wav", + "text": "還有國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/754.wav", + "text": "那個大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/755.wav", + "text": "永續會會有新的生命和功能存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/756.wav", + "text": "它不再是過去的永續會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/757.wav", + "text": "你要改成什麼組織架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/758.wav", + "text": "還是院長負責嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/759.wav", + "text": "鑫這個當然是更進一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/760.wav", + "text": "另外有一個小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/761.wav", + "text": "我們現在要問的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/762.wav", + "text": "因為原本環保署的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/763.wav", + "text": "你是希望怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/764.wav", + "text": "樣要有幾個人你現在講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/765.wav", + "text": "我都有找人總來問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/766.wav", + "text": "人總當然是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/767.wav", + "text": "它所需要的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/768.wav", + "text": "人總希望能夠盡力配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/769.wav", + "text": "它就是必須要講出它的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/770.wav", + "text": "現在聽起來大家很擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/771.wav", + "text": "是它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/772.wav", + "text": "在好像沒有一個規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/773.wav", + "text": "負載這麼龐大的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/774.wav", + "text": "弄一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/775.wav", + "text": "把它寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/776.wav", + "text": "這樣是一個方法嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/777.wav", + "text": "我們總是要有結論嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/778.wav", + "text": "沒有說解決方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/779.wav", + "text": "你這樣講我怎麼知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/780.wav", + "text": "我現在是在幫它解決它的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/781.wav", + "text": "我跟你講它比你更在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/782.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在就是在督促它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/783.wav", + "text": "幫它解決它的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/784.wav", + "text": "你一直在演講啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/785.wav", + "text": "因為我們的主張是會報但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/786.wav", + "text": "大家知道過去永續會的功能是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/787.wav", + "text": "都是蘇院長主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/788.wav", + "text": "永續會如果要做的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/789.wav", + "text": "就應該要當真來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/790.wav", + "text": "絕對當真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/791.wav", + "text": "現在它提出這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/792.wav", + "text": "它要負責任地去告訴大家它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/793.wav", + "text": "它的量能是什麼以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/794.wav", + "text": "因為環保署本來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/795.wav", + "text": "公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/796.wav", + "text": "有環保署的公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/797.wav", + "text": "應該做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/798.wav", + "text": "我跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/799.wav", + "text": "取得發言權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/800.wav", + "text": "的就是吳欣盈委員跟吳怡玎委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/801.wav", + "text": "昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/802.wav", + "text": "今天又討論了將近1個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/803.wav", + "text": "他們2位發言以後應該就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/804.wav", + "text": "達到1個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/805.wav", + "text": "2位吳委員講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/806.wav", + "text": "就不再發言了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/807.wav", + "text": "剛剛在釐清財政部跟環保署權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/808.wav", + "text": "針對綠色稅制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/809.wav", + "text": "由財政部主辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/810.wav", + "text": "部分你們是同意還是不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/811.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/812.wav", + "text": "基本上這本來就是財政部的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/813.wav", + "text": "寫不寫它都可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/814.wav", + "text": "沒有把所有的分工寫進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/815.wav", + "text": "因為其實寫不完一定都會有漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/816.wav", + "text": "第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/817.wav", + "text": "就有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/818.wav", + "text": "規定其他的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/819.wav", + "text": "由永續會協調指定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/820.wav", + "text": "其實就是彌補這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/821.wav", + "text": "意見跟疑慮也許可以用這一款來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/822.wav", + "text": "這樣就不會有漏掉的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/823.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/824.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/825.wav", + "text": "接下來是吳怡玎委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/826.wav", + "text": "簡單講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/827.wav", + "text": "我再強調一次能源部門是最大的排碳部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/828.wav", + "text": "所以我很在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/829.wav", + "text": "製造部門你寫兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/830.wav", + "text": "一個是能源的節約使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/831.wav", + "text": "一個是製造部門的溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/832.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/833.wav", + "text": "一個是運輸管理大眾運輸發展系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/834.wav", + "text": "及其他運輸部門溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/835.wav", + "text": "還有一個是低碳能源運具使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/836.wav", + "text": "你也寫了兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/837.wav", + "text": "我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/838.wav", + "text": "三大部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/839.wav", + "text": "就是能源運輸製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/840.wav", + "text": "順序是能源製造運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/841.wav", + "text": "製造跟運輸你都寫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/842.wav", + "text": "能源竟然沒有放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/843.wav", + "text": "你剛剛跟我解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/844.wav", + "text": "因為再生能源及能源科技發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/845.wav", + "text": "就會造成能源部門的溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/846.wav", + "text": "但我告訴你一個最具體的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/847.wav", + "text": "並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/848.wav", + "text": "2021年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/849.wav", + "text": "我們的再生能源是不是增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/850.wav", + "text": "我們的量能是不是增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/851.wav", + "text": "我們的能源科技發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/852.wav", + "text": "也進步了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/853.wav", + "text": "我們的排碳係數是增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/854.wav", + "text": "也就是能源部門的碳排是增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/855.wav", + "text": "所以這個不一定是等號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/856.wav", + "text": "我要的很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/857.wav", + "text": "它其實是一個表態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/858.wav", + "text": "表示這個政府真的重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/859.wav", + "text": "真的要督促能源部門減碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/860.wav", + "text": "因為我們高雄的冬天沒辦法呼吸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/861.wav", + "text": "碳排差不多跟空氣污染" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/862.wav", + "text": "只要碳排降下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/863.wav", + "text": "我們的空氣污染就會降下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/864.wav", + "text": "所以我非常care" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/865.wav", + "text": "你的能源部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/866.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有想要減碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/867.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/868.wav", + "text": "第2條跟第8條已經討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/869.wav", + "text": "沒有共識我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/870.wav", + "text": "第4條大家的意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/871.wav", + "text": "這個還是要請署長回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/872.wav", + "text": "就是20302040" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/873.wav", + "text": "說實在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/874.wav", + "text": "這個當然肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/875.wav", + "text": "但是刪去第3項之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/876.wav", + "text": "事實上我們就非常確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/877.wav", + "text": "2050年的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/878.wav", + "text": "所以在這個情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/879.wav", + "text": "基本上是非常起碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/880.wav", + "text": "也是非常合理的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/881.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/882.wav", + "text": "我認為這個一定要放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/883.wav", + "text": "因為大家都在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/884.wav", + "text": "但看到的成果都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/885.wav", + "text": "現在不是我們國家的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/886.wav", + "text": "不只有我們自己的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/887.wav", + "text": "全世界已經超前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/888.wav", + "text": "那我們怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/889.wav", + "text": "如果我們連目標都不訂下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/890.wav", + "text": "大家要以什麼為目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/891.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這真的很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/892.wav", + "text": "歐盟地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/893.wav", + "text": "那我們怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/894.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/895.wav", + "text": "當然政府現在也是全面性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/896.wav", + "text": "連我們做一個水圳路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/897.wav", + "text": "也要朝向減碳的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/898.wav", + "text": "本來就應該設定目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/899.wav", + "text": "不要因為以前設定的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/900.wav", + "text": "達不到而一改再改沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/901.wav", + "text": "你設定後讓大家全力去努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/902.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/903.wav", + "text": "我的建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/904.wav", + "text": "我們能不能先有個共識就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/905.wav", + "text": "起碼訂一個中期目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/906.wav", + "text": "2050之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/907.wav", + "text": "起碼訂一個中期目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/908.wav", + "text": "至於要訂哪一年要減多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/909.wav", + "text": "量請行政部門提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/910.wav", + "text": "我們再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/911.wav", + "text": "其實大家就只是希望不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/912.wav", + "text": "要只訂一個2050" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/913.wav", + "text": "會覺得那個距離很遙遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/914.wav", + "text": "對我們來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/915.wav", + "text": "那麼久以後的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/916.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們都很難去負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/917.wav", + "text": "所以我們訂一個中期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/918.wav", + "text": "目標當然也希望是短中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/919.wav", + "text": "期反正大家討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/920.wav", + "text": "但是我希望不只是2050" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/921.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/922.wav", + "text": "包括後面會有檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/923.wav", + "text": "但是如果沒有明定目標的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/924.wav", + "text": "其實也很難檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/925.wav", + "text": "尤其是每四年檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/926.wav", + "text": "行動綱領也是每四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/927.wav", + "text": "現在是2023年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/928.wav", + "text": "訂在2035年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/929.wav", + "text": "我們還是訂個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/930.wav", + "text": "我想大家已經講了非常多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/931.wav", + "text": "所以希望還是能夠把它訂下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/932.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/933.wav", + "text": "訂定其實是很科學的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/934.wav", + "text": "包括各位可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/935.wav", + "text": "我們現在提出NDC2030" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/936.wav", + "text": "從模型去跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/937.wav", + "text": "因素然後去訂下這個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/938.wav", + "text": "更長期的其實現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/939.wav", + "text": "因為科技的發展也不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/940.wav", + "text": "所以很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/941.wav", + "text": "現在就訂出一個數字來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/942.wav", + "text": "這一部分會在第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/943.wav", + "text": "每五年為一期的階段管制目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/944.wav", + "text": "定每一期要在下一期的前二年要提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/945.wav", + "text": "所以這個機制的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/946.wav", + "text": "已經逼著行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/947.wav", + "text": "必須一期一期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/948.wav", + "text": "把這個目標提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/949.wav", + "text": "原來大家擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/950.wav", + "text": "民眾的參與資訊的公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/951.wav", + "text": "所以我們也參考各位委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/952.wav", + "text": "把相關公聽會的程序寫得更為周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/953.wav", + "text": "在一個嚴謹的程序上來完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/954.wav", + "text": "所以在整個實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/955.wav", + "text": "不要定在法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/956.wav", + "text": "但是我們把其機制定好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/957.wav", + "text": "讓行政部門照著這個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/958.wav", + "text": "去逐期把它提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/959.wav", + "text": "因為大家都發表很多意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/960.wav", + "text": "現在的回答就是在第10條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/961.wav", + "text": "然後前二年還要提出檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/962.wav", + "text": "院長我還是講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/963.wav", + "text": "五年要去訂一個管制目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/964.wav", + "text": "但是沒有一個依循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/965.wav", + "text": "中期目標定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/966.wav", + "text": "每五年定的管制目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/967.wav", + "text": "才有辦法有效地去把它訂出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/968.wav", + "text": "這在第10條裡面寫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/969.wav", + "text": "我看這樣第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/970.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/971.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/972.wav", + "text": "第4條實在不應該保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/973.wav", + "text": "因為當初你們有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/974.wav", + "text": "我們把第3項刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/975.wav", + "text": "中期目標就是在第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/976.wav", + "text": "因為第10條已經有五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/977.wav", + "text": "了事實上這一條是可以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/978.wav", + "text": "看大家的意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/979.wav", + "text": "我們通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/980.wav", + "text": "\n請大家看第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/981.wav", + "text": "\n請孔文吉委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/982.wav", + "text": "第5條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/983.wav", + "text": "但後面的七款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/984.wav", + "text": "我跟廖國棟委員還有賴惠員委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/985.wav", + "text": "我們有提案增訂第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/986.wav", + "text": "針對受溫室氣體影響的弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/987.wav", + "text": "原住民族給予適當的補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/988.wav", + "text": "維護該族群生存健康的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/989.wav", + "text": "但你們就沒有列入啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/990.wav", + "text": "前面第1項你有加原住民族權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/991.wav", + "text": "後面這七款又沒有列原住民族的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/992.wav", + "text": "部分然後你就把第8款刪掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/993.wav", + "text": "所以我想問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/994.wav", + "text": "因為現在國際的潮流是承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/995.wav", + "text": "原住民族的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/996.wav", + "text": "承認原住民的主權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/997.wav", + "text": "跟自然資源主權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/998.wav", + "text": "COP26跟COP27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/999.wav", + "text": "都是承認原住民的主權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1000.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們在這一款沒有辦法納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1001.wav", + "text": "所以我們應該要承認原住民的主權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1002.wav", + "text": "跟自然資源權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1003.wav", + "text": "納入原住民決策參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1004.wav", + "text": "還有相關氣候變遷計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1005.wav", + "text": "必須要跟原住民族諮商取得同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1006.wav", + "text": "然後我們還要設立原住民族氣候變遷基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1007.wav", + "text": "為什麼你前面加了一個原住民族權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1008.wav", + "text": "但後面那七款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1009.wav", + "text": "又沒有原住民族相關權益的保障條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1010.wav", + "text": "這是我的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1011.wav", + "text": "怡玎及曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1012.wav", + "text": "主席這個部分滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1013.wav", + "text": "因應氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1014.wav", + "text": "政府相關法律及政策之規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1015.wav", + "text": "劃管理原則如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1016.wav", + "text": "因為我昨天也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1017.wav", + "text": "是在談有關國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1018.wav", + "text": "跟重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1019.wav", + "text": "重大政策的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1020.wav", + "text": "應該考量氣候變遷調適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1021.wav", + "text": "並將氣候變遷影響納入評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1022.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得既然我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1023.wav", + "text": "再來要把2050年當作目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1024.wav", + "text": "也都會有一個所謂定期的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1025.wav", + "text": "包括國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1026.wav", + "text": "也好或是縣市也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1027.wav", + "text": "還有一些重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1028.wav", + "text": "本來就應該要把它考量在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1029.wav", + "text": "我覺得這應該很符合這部法的原則跟精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1030.wav", + "text": "當我們有一些政策跟建設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1031.wav", + "text": "重大考量的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1032.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1033.wav", + "text": "這是我昨天問的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1034.wav", + "text": "今天請環保署署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1035.wav", + "text": "一定要回答我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1036.wav", + "text": "很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1037.wav", + "text": "開了一個談話會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1038.wav", + "text": "他們討論到能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1039.wav", + "text": "主持人的結語很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1040.wav", + "text": "臺灣的能源政策排除核能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1041.wav", + "text": "簡直就是瘋了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1042.wav", + "text": "它用madness這個字來形容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1043.wav", + "text": "就是瘋了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1044.wav", + "text": "我們今天在討論的這部法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1045.wav", + "text": "曾經叫做溫室氣體管理法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1046.wav", + "text": "現在叫做氣候變遷因應法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1047.wav", + "text": "我想請問署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1048.wav", + "text": "如何透過非核來減溫室氣體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1049.wav", + "text": "來因應氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1050.wav", + "text": "就是如何透過非核來減碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1051.wav", + "text": "請署長給我一個科學的答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1052.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1053.wav", + "text": "非常贊成剛剛孔委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1054.wav", + "text": "的第1項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1055.wav", + "text": "有講原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1056.wav", + "text": "但在後面這些真正的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1057.wav", + "text": "卻根本沒有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1058.wav", + "text": "昨天怡玎委員也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1059.wav", + "text": "裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1060.wav", + "text": "逐步落實非核家園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1061.wav", + "text": "頭看你的政策要去哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1062.wav", + "text": "為什麼在這時候又跑出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1063.wav", + "text": "要逐步落實非核家園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1064.wav", + "text": "這麼一個願景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1065.wav", + "text": "我覺得放在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1066.wav", + "text": "也非常地奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1067.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1068.wav", + "text": "在第5條也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1069.wav", + "text": "我們也多次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1070.wav", + "text": "的確還是很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1071.wav", + "text": "取消對於化石燃料的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1072.wav", + "text": "而且是逐步取消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1073.wav", + "text": "嘛因為我們要逐步減碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1074.wav", + "text": "逐步減碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1075.wav", + "text": "有目標有管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1076.wav", + "text": "如果有這樣子的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1077.wav", + "text": "主要碳排的能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1078.wav", + "text": "尤其是化石燃料的能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1079.wav", + "text": "我們把它入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1080.wav", + "text": "就是逐步取消化石燃料補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1081.wav", + "text": "這樣子對後續我們要達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1082.wav", + "text": "2050年淨零碳排的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1083.wav", + "text": "其實才有希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1084.wav", + "text": "應該要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1085.wav", + "text": "原住民族權益的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1086.wav", + "text": "如果沒有辦法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1087.wav", + "text": "我們還是堅持這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1088.wav", + "text": "不應該通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1089.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1090.wav", + "text": "對應民眾黨黨團版本的第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1091.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷行動綱領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1092.wav", + "text": "跟各項計畫中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1093.wav", + "text": "還是要訂定公正轉型相關的專章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1094.wav", + "text": "孔文吉委員剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1095.wav", + "text": "\n另外配合公民訴訟專章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1096.wav", + "text": "將氣候治理重要的原則入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1097.wav", + "text": "尤其是污染者付費的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1098.wav", + "text": "預警原則永續發展原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1099.wav", + "text": "版本的第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1100.wav", + "text": "至第52條公民訴訟專章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1101.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1102.wav", + "text": "我們是參考國際環境法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1103.wav", + "text": "將氣候治理的重要原則入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1104.wav", + "text": "原則上這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1105.wav", + "text": "還是表達一下本黨團的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1106.wav", + "text": "如果各黨大家沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1107.wav", + "text": "太大的共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1108.wav", + "text": "我們建議還是保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1109.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1110.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1111.wav", + "text": "第1項我們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1112.wav", + "text": "也支持加入原住民權益的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1113.wav", + "text": "跟其他建議的文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1114.wav", + "text": "第2款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1115.wav", + "text": "擬定逐步降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1116.wav", + "text": "化石燃料依賴之中長期策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1117.wav", + "text": "第3項其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1118.wav", + "text": "因應氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1119.wav", + "text": "政府相關法律與政策之規劃管理原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1120.wav", + "text": "所以其實已經是一個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1121.wav", + "text": "了就這大方向來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1122.wav", + "text": "非核家園這樣的方向我們當然贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1123.wav", + "text": "例不應該是降低化石燃料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1124.wav", + "text": "你說依賴之中長期策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1125.wav", + "text": "這個講得非常不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1126.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做依賴之中長期策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1127.wav", + "text": "其實就是取消化石燃料的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1128.wav", + "text": "把它作為一個中長期的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1129.wav", + "text": "而且是你的原則就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1130.wav", + "text": "就往這個方向推進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1131.wav", + "text": "基本上對減碳是有大大的幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1132.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望在原則性的規範裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1133.wav", + "text": "逐步取消化石燃料的補貼之中長期策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1134.wav", + "text": "訂定再生能源中長期目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1135.wav", + "text": "逐步落實非核家園的願景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1136.wav", + "text": "有一個部分我要呼應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1137.wav", + "text": "剛剛講到民眾黨想要訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1138.wav", + "text": "公正轉型的專章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1139.wav", + "text": "其實在我們昨天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1140.wav", + "text": "第46條已經新增了一條公正轉型的條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1141.wav", + "text": "針對公正轉型的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1142.wav", + "text": "把它機制化跟法制化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1143.wav", + "text": "第一個有這個條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1144.wav", + "text": "\n第二個其實在我們昨天協商的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1145.wav", + "text": "看起來各黨對於第33條也有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1146.wav", + "text": "在碳費基金的用途上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1147.wav", + "text": "增加了公正轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1148.wav", + "text": "也就是有計畫有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1149.wav", + "text": "其次定義的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1150.wav", + "text": "在昨天通過的第三章裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1151.wav", + "text": "也把公正轉型的定義放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1152.wav", + "text": "也放入了原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1153.wav", + "text": "其中的一個重要成分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1154.wav", + "text": "裡面已經變成一個滿大的亮點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1155.wav", + "text": "至少這個部分我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1156.wav", + "text": "剛才已經有很多委員發表高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1157.wav", + "text": "也請張署長回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1158.wav", + "text": "張署長回應完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1159.wav", + "text": "我們就讓執政黨發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1160.wav", + "text": "因為在野黨有很多寶貴的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1161.wav", + "text": "看執政黨的態度怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1162.wav", + "text": "\n請張署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1163.wav", + "text": "第一個有關國土計畫納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1164.wav", + "text": "我們現在修正的第7款裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1165.wav", + "text": "調適能力等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1166.wav", + "text": "所以這個應該是可以含括的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1167.wav", + "text": "第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1168.wav", + "text": "直轄市縣(市)政府的國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1169.wav", + "text": "要載明氣候變遷的調適計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1170.wav", + "text": "所以這個應該是有納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1171.wav", + "text": "核能的部分我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1172.wav", + "text": "減碳並不是非核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1173.wav", + "text": "減碳目標不是要核或是不要核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1174.wav", + "text": "而是怎麼樣把碳減下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1175.wav", + "text": "所以我想在能源部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1176.wav", + "text": "他們對於各種可能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1177.wav", + "text": "節能能源效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1178.wav", + "text": "都在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1179.wav", + "text": "碳的排放剛剛委員詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1180.wav", + "text": "達到淨零排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1181.wav", + "text": "核才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1182.wav", + "text": "我們現在條文裡面有的這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1183.wav", + "text": "原來在環境基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1184.wav", + "text": "裡面就有寫到非核家園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1185.wav", + "text": "現行原來的溫室氣體減量及管理法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1186.wav", + "text": "就有這一個條文我們這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1187.wav", + "text": "並沒有去改動它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1188.wav", + "text": "逐步取消化石燃料的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1189.wav", + "text": "各位要稍微瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1190.wav", + "text": "我們現在講2050" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1191.wav", + "text": "淨零排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1192.wav", + "text": "我們可能真的沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1193.wav", + "text": "全部把它消除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1194.wav", + "text": "去把它平衡回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1195.wav", + "text": "所以我們原來寫的逐步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1196.wav", + "text": "逐步降低也是希望儘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1197.wav", + "text": "儘量去降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1198.wav", + "text": "但是降到最後沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1199.wav", + "text": "也許我們要面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1200.wav", + "text": "怎麼去解決這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1201.wav", + "text": "意思應該是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1202.wav", + "text": "沒有這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1203.wav", + "text": "討論以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1204.wav", + "text": "第1項裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1205.wav", + "text": "看起來沒有對應的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1206.wav", + "text": "連在一起但沒有特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1207.wav", + "text": "獨立出來這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1208.wav", + "text": "這倒是可以討論看看要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1209.wav", + "text": "以上簡單的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1210.wav", + "text": "好最後我們就看執政黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1211.wav", + "text": "我們能不能取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1212.wav", + "text": "完全的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1213.wav", + "text": "假如非核非碳都講不下來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1214.wav", + "text": "你要叫我們把不用拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1215.wav", + "text": "改非碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1216.wav", + "text": "這不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1217.wav", + "text": "他剛已經我的說明很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1218.wav", + "text": "這個不是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1219.wav", + "text": "一個人堅持就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1220.wav", + "text": "就可以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1221.wav", + "text": "也很堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1222.wav", + "text": "這點如果沒有辦法解決後面都不用如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1223.wav", + "text": "我們先來講也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1224.wav", + "text": "現在就是每項都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1225.wav", + "text": "又講到公民訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1226.wav", + "text": "文去我們應該要聚焦大家有誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1227.wav", + "text": "我們當然可以來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1228.wav", + "text": "我們會答應嗎不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1229.wav", + "text": "我非常感謝各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1230.wav", + "text": "都支持原住民權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1231.wav", + "text": "益條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1232.wav", + "text": "我有想出方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1233.wav", + "text": "在政府的相關法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1234.wav", + "text": "和政策的規劃管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1235.wav", + "text": "原則方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1236.wav", + "text": "你不要第1項有原住民族權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1237.wav", + "text": "後面又沒有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1238.wav", + "text": "而後面全部都忽視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1239.wav", + "text": "原住民族權益條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1240.wav", + "text": "所以我主張並堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1241.wav", + "text": "要把它列進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1242.wav", + "text": "還沒開始協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1243.wav", + "text": "你講的問題要如何用另外一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1244.wav", + "text": "持平而論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1245.wav", + "text": "我們都可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1246.wav", + "text": "即便這條要表決的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1247.wav", + "text": "我也會把你的東西放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1248.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1249.wav", + "text": "第8款這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1250.wav", + "text": "我們一個禮拜前就寫好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1251.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1252.wav", + "text": "孔委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1253.wav", + "text": "再另案處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1254.wav", + "text": "請看第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1255.wav", + "text": "第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1256.wav", + "text": "就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1257.wav", + "text": "第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1258.wav", + "text": "會跟聽證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1259.wav", + "text": "第10條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1260.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處理第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1261.wav", + "text": "第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1262.wav", + "text": "昨天的結論是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1263.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員有另外一個寫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1264.wav", + "text": "三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1265.wav", + "text": "行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1266.wav", + "text": "至於洪申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1267.wav", + "text": "三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1268.wav", + "text": "就寫成一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1269.wav", + "text": "反正無傷大雅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1270.wav", + "text": "你現在又要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1271.wav", + "text": "我並不反對原來的第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1272.wav", + "text": "只是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1273.wav", + "text": "第九款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1274.wav", + "text": "的部分加上原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1275.wav", + "text": "或部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1276.wav", + "text": "那是那一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1277.wav", + "text": "的所以政府推動調適能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1278.wav", + "text": "建構事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1279.wav", + "text": "中也要把原住民族納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1280.wav", + "text": "你每一條都要加上原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1281.wav", + "text": "調適能力建構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1282.wav", + "text": "我們昨天就講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1283.wav", + "text": "第十七條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1284.wav", + "text": "只有兩個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1285.wav", + "text": "你跟洪申翰委員的附帶決議加在一起好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1286.wav", + "text": "加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1287.wav", + "text": "有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1288.wav", + "text": "可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1289.wav", + "text": "啦就是融入綜合性與以社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1290.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1291.wav", + "text": "就加幾個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1292.wav", + "text": "其他氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1293.wav", + "text": "中的其他可以代表一切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1294.wav", + "text": "了我對原住民相當尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1295.wav", + "text": "全部只剩下這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1296.wav", + "text": "就只加上這幾個字我們也不會反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1297.wav", + "text": "列舉不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1298.wav", + "text": "要不然就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1299.wav", + "text": "用附帶決議提出好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1300.wav", + "text": "時代力量這麼關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1301.wav", + "text": "行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1302.wav", + "text": "所以就不要再堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1303.wav", + "text": "我們大家就一起讓其通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1304.wav", + "text": "我不是堅持我的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1305.wav", + "text": "雖然要表決但我有把這個部分放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1306.wav", + "text": "這樣夠尊重了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1307.wav", + "text": "示特別尊重我覺得不需要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1308.wav", + "text": "我們永遠都弄不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1309.wav", + "text": "我今天講的不只是立法原則和普遍性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1310.wav", + "text": "要加最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1311.wav", + "text": "我建議還是要加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1312.wav", + "text": "我有聽進去你的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1313.wav", + "text": "第十七條就暫時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1314.wav", + "text": "先暫時通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1315.wav", + "text": "等一下我們再想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1316.wav", + "text": "暫時通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1317.wav", + "text": "沒有暫時通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1318.wav", + "text": "共同提案也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1319.wav", + "text": "我們不必再去共同提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1320.wav", + "text": "我們跟他們共同提案是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1321.wav", + "text": "這不是做給誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1322.wav", + "text": "沒有要做給誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1323.wav", + "text": "第十七條留到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1324.wav", + "text": "第十七條就暫時放著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1325.wav", + "text": "請大家看第第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1326.wav", + "text": "第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1327.wav", + "text": "是否就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1328.wav", + "text": "行政院提案版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1329.wav", + "text": "你要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1330.wav", + "text": "收支管理辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1331.wav", + "text": "那本來預算法就有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1332.wav", + "text": "照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1333.wav", + "text": "不要再講這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1334.wav", + "text": "溫管基金來源包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1335.wav", + "text": "碳稅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1336.wav", + "text": "基金收入來源要包含碳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1337.wav", + "text": "昨天有談到稅收能不能撥入基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1338.wav", + "text": "現在社會福利支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1339.wav", + "text": "很多都是稅收指定的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1340.wav", + "text": "例如特種貨物及勞務稅條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1341.wav", + "text": "第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1342.wav", + "text": "第2項特種貨物及勞務稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1343.wav", + "text": "稅課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1344.wav", + "text": "收入分配及運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1345.wav", + "text": "辦法第3條的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1346.wav", + "text": "特種貨物及勞務稅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1347.wav", + "text": "優先撥入國民年金保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1348.wav", + "text": "昨天環保署已經確定把權責納入第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1349.wav", + "text": "的法律本文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1350.wav", + "text": "並不是放在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1351.wav", + "text": "但是民眾黨團主張先碳費後碳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1352.wav", + "text": "應該在行政院版的第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1353.wav", + "text": "新增綠色稅制之研議及推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1354.wav", + "text": "由財政部來主辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1355.wav", + "text": "昨天環保署長有說到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1356.wav", + "text": "綠色稅制不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1357.wav", + "text": "定財政部也可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1358.wav", + "text": "我想照這個邏輯的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1359.wav", + "text": "整個條文是不是就不用寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1360.wav", + "text": "了所以交通部也可以自己來做相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1361.wav", + "text": "運具的自動化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1362.wav", + "text": "我們的態度還是非常的明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1363.wav", + "text": "就這個部分我們還是要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1364.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有共識的話我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1365.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1366.wav", + "text": "32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1367.wav", + "text": "就保留\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1368.wav", + "text": "\n請看第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1369.wav", + "text": "第33條就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1370.wav", + "text": "我們個別委員都有不同的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1371.wav", + "text": "有人是放在第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1372.wav", + "text": "有人是放在第33條像我的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1373.wav", + "text": "這個基金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1374.wav", + "text": "應該要有一條基金管理單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1375.wav", + "text": "基金管理單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1376.wav", + "text": "由主管機關定之這沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1377.wav", + "text": "可是應該要有納入這樣的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1378.wav", + "text": "其實個別委員都有其個別精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1379.wav", + "text": "然後稀里呼嚕大家就讓它過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1380.wav", + "text": "你這裡要寫明啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1381.wav", + "text": "要在這邊寫明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1382.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1383.wav", + "text": "要講的話要從孔委員先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1384.wav", + "text": "我們講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1385.wav", + "text": "我知道過不了就過不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1386.wav", + "text": "每個部會都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1387.wav", + "text": "並列但是第33條的最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1388.wav", + "text": "第1項第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1389.wav", + "text": "至第5款以第十三款的補助獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1390.wav", + "text": "對象申請資格條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1391.wav", + "text": "審查時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1392.wav", + "text": "間等由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1393.wav", + "text": "應該是會同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1394.wav", + "text": "中央目的事業主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1395.wav", + "text": "之我特別加了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1396.wav", + "text": "涉及原住民族地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1397.wav", + "text": "及離島地區者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1398.wav", + "text": "應優先補助或獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1399.wav", + "text": "因為每個單位都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1400.wav", + "text": "不是只有環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1401.wav", + "text": "這是對應民眾黨團的第36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1402.wav", + "text": "溫管基金用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1403.wav", + "text": "輔導產業勞工及脆弱群體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1404.wav", + "text": "進行綠色轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1405.wav", + "text": "公正轉型之工作事項與補助事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1406.wav", + "text": "也要用於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1407.wav", + "text": "森林碳匯及海洋碳匯的研究等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1408.wav", + "text": "是我們第36條的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1409.wav", + "text": "我們先表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1410.wav", + "text": "我向大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1411.wav", + "text": "因為這條昨天保留且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1412.wav", + "text": "昨天已經談很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1413.wav", + "text": "如果沒有新的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1414.wav", + "text": "請大家儘量精簡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1415.wav", + "text": "發言繼續保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1416.wav", + "text": "我們先講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1417.wav", + "text": "說實在這條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1418.wav", + "text": "因為這是臺灣有史以來第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1419.wav", + "text": "是為了因應氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1420.wav", + "text": "我跟環保署講過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1421.wav", + "text": "因為第28條好不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1422.wav", + "text": "課徵了碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1423.wav", + "text": "不過第29條與第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1424.wav", + "text": "是衝突的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1425.wav", + "text": "而第29條與第28條也是衝突的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1426.wav", + "text": "第28條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1427.wav", + "text": "好不容易把錢收進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1428.wav", + "text": "錢這樣是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1429.wav", + "text": "如果和稅做比較的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1430.wav", + "text": "財政部在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1431.wav", + "text": "租稅優惠時是非常小心翼翼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1432.wav", + "text": "是一件很嚴重的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1433.wav", + "text": "所以就是要一整本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1434.wav", + "text": "審查產創條例一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1435.wav", + "text": "利大於弊的前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1436.wav", + "text": "雖然稅損這麼多但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1437.wav", + "text": "而促進了產業發展等等所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1438.wav", + "text": "以整體來講是利大於弊不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1439.wav", + "text": "的狀況卻不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1440.wav", + "text": "28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1441.wav", + "text": "課徵碳費後第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1442.wav", + "text": "什麼都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1443.wav", + "text": "預期這樣的碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1444.wav", + "text": "收入會因為訂出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1445.wav", + "text": "優惠而減少多少統統都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1446.wav", + "text": "研發部門做獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1447.wav", + "text": "所以我認為第29條根本不該存在因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1448.wav", + "text": "課徵碳費所以收到錢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1449.wav", + "text": "徵收到新的碳費了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1450.wav", + "text": "而且這優惠還是空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1451.wav", + "text": "可能完全沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1452.wav", + "text": "評估有沒有利大於弊的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1453.wav", + "text": "所以我認為第29條根本不該存在\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1454.wav", + "text": "事業投資溫室氣體減量技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1455.wav", + "text": "的第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1456.wav", + "text": "事業是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1457.wav", + "text": "是這二百零多家嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1458.wav", + "text": "事業到底是什麼根本不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1459.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1460.wav", + "text": "它跟第28條也是衝突的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1461.wav", + "text": "你把碳費徵收進來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1462.wav", + "text": "這些事業做什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1463.wav", + "text": "這些事業也不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1464.wav", + "text": "因為我們的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1465.wav", + "text": "舊的鍋爐換一個新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1466.wav", + "text": "這樣就有可能��一些量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1467.wav", + "text": "不是耶我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1468.wav", + "text": "宗旨應該是第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1469.wav", + "text": "─輔導補助獎勵溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1470.wav", + "text": "工作事項研究跟開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1471.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1472.wav", + "text": "是希望他們用新的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1473.wav", + "text": "研發新的技術開發新的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1474.wav", + "text": "所以第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1475.wav", + "text": "是完全合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1476.wav", + "text": "鼓勵他們去做新的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1477.wav", + "text": "但是第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1478.wav", + "text": "是完全衝突的跟你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1479.wav", + "text": "政策是衝突的所以第33" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1480.wav", + "text": "錯誤的方向\n總的來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1481.wav", + "text": "第28條第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1482.wav", + "text": "及第33條尤其第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1483.wav", + "text": "28條搭配第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1484.wav", + "text": "是合理的但是第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1485.wav", + "text": "是完全衝突的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1486.wav", + "text": "一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1487.wav", + "text": "必須要負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1488.wav", + "text": "的去指出它的錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1489.wav", + "text": "誤我們的目標是什麼我們的目標就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1490.wav", + "text": "胡蘿蔔和棒子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1491.wav", + "text": "搭配胡蘿蔔與棒子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1492.wav", + "text": "但是中間卻突出了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1493.wav", + "text": "第29條完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1494.wav", + "text": "要達成的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1495.wav", + "text": "假設大家坐在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1496.wav", + "text": "好不容易引頸企盼弄出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1497.wav", + "text": "臺灣有史以來的碳費的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1498.wav", + "text": "結果卻沒辦法把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1499.wav", + "text": "這樣就是不對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1500.wav", + "text": "嘛所以這是負責任的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1501.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1502.wav", + "text": "你在做這些優惠的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1503.wav", + "text": "重點在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1504.wav", + "text": "嘛都應該要有相關的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1505.wav", + "text": "但它卻完全都沒有接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1506.wav", + "text": "事實上這個溝通很多遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1507.wav", + "text": "了行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1508.wav", + "text": "在第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1509.wav", + "text": "有這樣的一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1510.wav", + "text": "非常重要的一個關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1511.wav", + "text": "就是後續的執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1512.wav", + "text": "底是走後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1513.wav", + "text": "或是像剛剛邱總召所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1514.wav", + "text": "這些可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1515.wav", + "text": "所以行政機關後續的執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1516.wav", + "text": "是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1517.wav", + "text": "的我們希望這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1518.wav", + "text": "能夠真正用在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1519.wav", + "text": "升級所以我還是要再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1520.wav", + "text": "那我們就繼續保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1521.wav", + "text": "主席因為我有提出一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1522.wav", + "text": "我建議時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1523.wav", + "text": "執政黨團─民進黨團看看有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1524.wav", + "text": "院長我們還有一個公民訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1525.wav", + "text": "也有談到有關公民訴訟的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1526.wav", + "text": "我們覺得這是一個非常起碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1527.wav", + "text": "環保署在針對這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1528.wav", + "text": "環評等等相關的訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1529.wav", + "text": "其實也有公民訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1530.wav", + "text": "我現在在談公民訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1531.wav", + "text": "公民訴訟的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1532.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員剛剛所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1533.wav", + "text": "部落拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1534.wav", + "text": "原住民族就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1535.wav", + "text": "我們肯定時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1536.wav", + "text": "增加及原住民族對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1537.wav", + "text": "原住民族含括到部落啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1538.wav", + "text": "這樣可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1539.wav", + "text": "原住民族含括部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1540.wav", + "text": "前面也是這樣寫第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1541.wav", + "text": "修正通過就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1542.wav", + "text": "增加及原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1543.wav", + "text": "整理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1544.wav", + "text": "你的那個不用再說了那個保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1545.wav", + "text": "公民訴訟一定保留不必再演講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1546.wav", + "text": "我私下再聽你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1547.wav", + "text": "這樣的訴訟去解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1548.wav", + "text": "不他只是想要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1549.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1550.wav", + "text": "對象不一樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1551.wav", + "text": "報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1552.wav", + "text": "初步的協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1553.wav", + "text": "如果有意見就再來修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1554.wav", + "text": "讓大家知道我們真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1555.wav", + "text": "很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1556.wav", + "text": "111年12月9日(星期五)11時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1557.wav", + "text": "4分至14時19分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1558.wav", + "text": "111年12月16日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1559.wav", + "text": "協商主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1560.wav", + "text": "社會福利及衛生環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1561.wav", + "text": "經濟財政內政交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1562.wav", + "text": "教育及文化六委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1563.wav", + "text": "報告併案審查行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1564.wav", + "text": "函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1565.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1566.wav", + "text": "管理法修正草案等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1567.wav", + "text": "20案及逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1568.wav", + "text": "併案協商等9案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1569.wav", + "text": "\n協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1570.wav", + "text": "(一)第2條第6條第十三條第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1571.wav", + "text": "第二十條第二十一條第三十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1572.wav", + "text": "第三十五條第五章章名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1573.wav", + "text": "第四十三條第五十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1574.wav", + "text": "及第五十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1575.wav", + "text": "均照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1576.wav", + "text": "第十八條第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1577.wav", + "text": "第二十七條第三十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1578.wav", + "text": "第四十二條及新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1579.wav", + "text": "照協商條文通過如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1580.wav", + "text": "\n(三)其餘照審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1581.wav", + "text": "通過之法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1582.wav", + "text": "各章章名及條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1583.wav", + "text": "\n二保留部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1584.wav", + "text": "第4條第5條第8條第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1585.wav", + "text": "第28條第29條第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1586.wav", + "text": "第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1587.wav", + "text": "\n三審查會第46條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1588.wav", + "text": "變更為第47條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1589.wav", + "text": "以下條次依序遞延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1590.wav", + "text": "變更及本法條文內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1591.wav", + "text": "條次調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1592.wav", + "text": "授權議事人員處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1593.wav", + "text": "\n四通過審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1594.wav", + "text": "附帶決議共9項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1595.wav", + "text": "\n五本案院會進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1596.wav", + "text": "時協商通過部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1597.wav", + "text": "予以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1598.wav", + "text": "保留部分均暫保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1599.wav", + "text": "保留部分院會進行處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1600.wav", + "text": "1人依時代力量黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1601.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1602.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團順序輪流發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1603.wav", + "text": "每人發言時間為3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1604.wav", + "text": "發言完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1605.wav", + "text": "各該保留條文均不再發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1606.wav", + "text": "並依上開黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1607.wav", + "text": "順序進行各保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1608.wav", + "text": "條文黨團版本之處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1609.wav", + "text": "\n六本法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1610.wav", + "text": "各黨團委員提案及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1611.wav", + "text": "修正動議均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1612.wav", + "text": "列入公報紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1613.wav", + "text": "\n七檢附本案立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1614.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1615.wav", + "text": "好像沒寫到我們所提的公民訴訟部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1616.wav", + "text": "的是不是每一個條文各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1617.wav", + "text": "推派一人發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1618.wav", + "text": "都有各自的爭議嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1619.wav", + "text": "我們照慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1620.wav", + "text": "你自己去調配就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1621.wav", + "text": "不要啦二個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1622.wav", + "text": "二個人3分鐘比較好講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1623.wav", + "text": "因為這個沒有每一條了啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1624.wav", + "text": "都已經包裹各" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1625.wav", + "text": "黨團推派二人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1626.wav", + "text": "我聽你演講沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1627.wav", + "text": "我拿便當到你家去聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1628.wav", + "text": "附帶決議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1629.wav", + "text": "附帶決議就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1630.wav", + "text": "當天處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1631.wav", + "text": "的因為附帶決議可能會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1632.wav", + "text": "院長我的第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1633.wav", + "text": "你找他就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1634.wav", + "text": "請問是明天要處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1635.wav", + "text": "明天處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1636.wav", + "text": "後天都是要處理總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1637.wav", + "text": "下禮拜表決的時候再一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1638.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1639.wav", + "text": "今天是6日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1640.wav", + "text": "6日扣掉禮拜天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1641.wav", + "text": "還有7個工作天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1642.wav", + "text": "所以大家可能要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1643.wav", + "text": "有所覺悟大概晚上都要加班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1644.wav", + "text": "就這樣拜託大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1645.wav", + "text": "4007百多案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1646.wav", + "text": "每案唸1分鐘的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1647.wav", + "text": "我們現在坐在這裡都唸不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1648.wav", + "text": "所以大家要知道怎麼去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1649.wav", + "text": "的能夠��的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1650.wav", + "text": "拜託儘量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1651.wav", + "text": "院長這個法有確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1652.wav", + "text": "下禮拜一要處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1653.wav", + "text": "應該是下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1654.wav", + "text": "應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1655.wav", + "text": "反正已經這樣決定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1656.wav", + "text": "本會期一定都要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1657.wav", + "text": "下禮拜一嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1658.wav", + "text": "有可能什麼時候時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1659.wav", + "text": "處理有一個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1660.wav", + "text": "大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1661.wav", + "text": "要空出那段時間來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1662.wav", + "text": "不然再拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1663.wav", + "text": "秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1664.wav", + "text": "明天禮拜五下班前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1665.wav", + "text": "告訴各黨團什麼時候處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1666.wav", + "text": "最快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1667.wav", + "text": "他們是想要知道什麼時候要開會表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1668.wav", + "text": "那下禮拜一處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1669.wav", + "text": "反正大家standby就好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1670.wav", + "text": "我們會隨時通知大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1671.wav", + "text": "發紅包那個也可以一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1672.wav", + "text": "請問接下來是產創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1673.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1674.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1675.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1676.wav", + "text": "我們跟孔文吉委員談一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1677.wav", + "text": "列席官員分別是經濟部王美花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1678.wav", + "text": "財政部賦稅署李雅晶副署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1679.wav", + "text": "部分的協商最主要有兩條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1680.wav", + "text": "和第72條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1681.wav", + "text": "綜合講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1682.wav", + "text": "各位委員同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1683.wav", + "text": "我代表他表達和大家一致就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1684.wav", + "text": "就照行政院版本其他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1685.wav", + "text": "對施行日期都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1686.wav", + "text": "我會保留是因為黃國書委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1687.wav", + "text": "有意見所以才保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1688.wav", + "text": "我代表民進黨黨團把它拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1689.wav", + "text": "所以我們對施行日期就不必談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1690.wav", + "text": "我們就聚焦在第10條之2就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1691.wav", + "text": "這一條而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1692.wav", + "text": "大家對施行日期都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1693.wav", + "text": "部會同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1694.wav", + "text": "是大家現在比較關注的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1695.wav", + "text": "主要還是針對中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1696.wav", + "text": "民眾黨黨團的態度還是針對中小企業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1697.wav", + "text": "相關權益和優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1698.wav", + "text": "要保障他們的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1699.wav", + "text": "目前的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1700.wav", + "text": "技術創新且居國際供應鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1701.wav", + "text": "關鍵地位之公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1702.wav", + "text": "到底是指哪一些公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1703.wav", + "text": "我們現在比較擔心的是通過後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1704.wav", + "text": "會不會只保護到極少數的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1705.wav", + "text": "提出的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1706.wav", + "text": "至於第72條剛才已經談過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1707.wav", + "text": "民眾黨在此重申一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1708.wav", + "text": "這次修正產業創新條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1709.wav", + "text": "實際上就是要因應目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1710.wav", + "text": "全球挖角我國半導體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1711.wav", + "text": "跟高科技產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1712.wav", + "text": "尤其是我們護國神山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1713.wav", + "text": "對於政府爭取產業根留臺灣的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1714.wav", + "text": "本黨團對於這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1715.wav", + "text": "跟精神是給予肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1716.wav", + "text": "的但是在上次委員會協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1717.wav", + "text": "本黨團主張審議投資補助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1718.wav", + "text": "專家委員會成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1719.wav", + "text": "應該在子法中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1720.wav", + "text": "名列各界組成人員的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1721.wav", + "text": "我們認為這相關的比例非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1722.wav", + "text": "很高興經濟部也認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1723.wav", + "text": "但是本黨團也提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1724.wav", + "text": "多項實務的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1725.wav", + "text": "提醒經濟部必須儘速釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1726.wav", + "text": "所以針對這一次的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1727.wav", + "text": "我們認為還是有一些倉促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1728.wav", + "text": "還是有很多問題需要釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1729.wav", + "text": "像是法案中的重要名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1730.wav", + "text": "跟範圍的明確定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1731.wav", + "text": "子法或者是專家委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1732.wav", + "text": "不希望是形同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1733.wav", + "text": "先通過法案再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1734.wav", + "text": "不要讓人家感覺是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1735.wav", + "text": "甚至是個案審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1736.wav", + "text": "這是大家比較擔心的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1737.wav", + "text": "如果我們沒有辦法明確界定適用的類別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1738.wav", + "text": "跟門檻等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1739.wav", + "text": "那麼稅式支出評估只能用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1740.wav", + "text": "粗略的數據來推算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1741.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法精準的計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1742.wav", + "text": "跟補助的抵減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1743.wav", + "text": "國際上各國為了競爭半導體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1744.wav", + "text": "所匡列補助的總額度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1745.wav", + "text": "提列527億美元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1746.wav", + "text": "補助建廠大約是1.63兆臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1747.wav", + "text": "也提出6,170億日圓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1748.wav", + "text": "補助建廠大概是1,357億臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1749.wav", + "text": "印度是100億美元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1750.wav", + "text": "南韓是10兆韓元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1751.wav", + "text": "中國是3,300億人民幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1752.wav", + "text": "歐盟大於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1753.wav", + "text": "430億歐元相當於1.4兆臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1754.wav", + "text": "我想經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1755.wav", + "text": "應該要更詳實地納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1756.wav", + "text": "國際上相關的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1757.wav", + "text": "評估臺版晶片法的優惠措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1758.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有辦法產生相關的誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1759.wav", + "text": "還有相關的人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1760.wav", + "text": "甚至吸引外來的投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1761.wav", + "text": "這個量能跟誘因是不是真的足夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1762.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分還是要跟國際接軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1763.wav", + "text": "\n最後本黨團還是要重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1764.wav", + "text": "租稅抵免半導體一些新的製程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1765.wav", + "text": "包含耗水耗電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1766.wav", + "text": "這跟我們的能源政策都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1767.wav", + "text": "正相關相關的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1768.wav", + "text": "只會持續的增加所以經濟部應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1769.wav", + "text": "向產業界跟國人說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1770.wav", + "text": "未來要如何滿足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1771.wav", + "text": "台積電等半導體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1772.wav", + "text": "廠商的用水用電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1773.wav", + "text": "民眾黨黨團最關心中小企業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1774.wav", + "text": "我們認為應該要把中小企業列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1775.wav", + "text": "受補助的對象所以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1776.wav", + "text": "子法中規定不得低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1777.wav", + "text": "多少的比例應該要明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1778.wav", + "text": "納入上次王美花部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1779.wav", + "text": "認為對中小企業在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1780.wav", + "text": "產創條例第10條跟第10條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1781.wav", + "text": "已經有納入設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1782.wav", + "text": "抵減的租稅減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1783.wav", + "text": "已經有修改讓天使投資人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1784.wav", + "text": "投資新創產業享有優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1785.wav", + "text": "但是這跟實際上的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1786.wav", + "text": "顧及半導體全球競爭力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1787.wav", + "text": "同時更應該全盤考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1788.wav", + "text": "我國產業長期的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1789.wav", + "text": "尤其是要怎麼樣透過這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1790.wav", + "text": "我們的中小企業來做相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1791.wav", + "text": "轉型因此我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1792.wav", + "text": "建請經濟部將中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1793.wav", + "text": "列入受補助的對象要明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1794.wav", + "text": "的納入否則就應該同步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1795.wav", + "text": "放寬第10條及第10條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1796.wav", + "text": "針對策略產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1797.wav", + "text": "最高補助的上限與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1798.wav", + "text": "第10條之二的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1799.wav", + "text": "相同有研發支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1800.wav", + "text": "以同步照顧具有關鍵地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1801.wav", + "text": "或策略產業的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1802.wav", + "text": "使臺灣的產業能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1803.wav", + "text": "更加的多元更紮實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1804.wav", + "text": "然後這個政策才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1805.wav", + "text": "升級及轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1806.wav", + "text": "\n我們針對剛剛的敘述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1807.wav", + "text": "要提出幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1808.wav", + "text": "有沒有估算如果台積電等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1809.wav", + "text": "相關的半導體產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1810.wav", + "text": "到海外投資設廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1811.wav", + "text": "臺灣將會損失多少原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1812.wav", + "text": "應該在國內創設的工作機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1813.wav", + "text": "的風險評估尤其是台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1814.wav", + "text": "如果去美國日本歐洲設廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1815.wav", + "text": "會不會影響臺灣高科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1816.wav", + "text": "產業垂直或水平整合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1817.wav", + "text": "生態圈跟規模經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1818.wav", + "text": "評估上是否考量有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1819.wav", + "text": "多少產值會因為產創條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1820.wav", + "text": "的修法而根留臺灣對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1821.wav", + "text": "針對國家財政跟租稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1822.wav", + "text": "的影響有跟財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1823.wav", + "text": "進行過討論我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1824.wav", + "text": "在一些產業政策上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1825.wav", + "text": "其實經濟部和財政部常常因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1826.wav", + "text": "有一些矛盾你們對重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1827.wav", + "text": "針對相關個案來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1828.wav", + "text": "討論關於這個部分我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1829.wav", + "text": "希望王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1830.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1831.wav", + "text": "列席的行政官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1832.wav", + "text": "大家午安大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1833.wav", + "text": "在我的版本裡面同樣是強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1834.wav", + "text": "納入因為中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1835.wav", + "text": "的員工占了八成以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1836.wav", + "text": "可是我們看到行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1837.wav", + "text": "的版本開宗明義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1838.wav", + "text": "就是為了要鞏固" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1839.wav", + "text": "供應鏈的地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1840.wav", + "text": "而且要是居國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1841.wav", + "text": "供應鏈中關鍵地位的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1842.wav", + "text": "這很明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1843.wav", + "text": "就已經是量身訂做是為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1844.wav", + "text": "來做我覺得這是一件很不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1845.wav", + "text": "就在於我剛剛所講的中小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1846.wav", + "text": "企業其實是我們國家安定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1847.wav", + "text": "產創條例這種鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1848.wav", + "text": "產創條例的行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1849.wav", + "text": "出來之後我們看到媒體報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1850.wav", + "text": "老對於這個部分都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1851.wav", + "text": "產業界大老的批評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1852.wav", + "text": "是什麼但是我們很務實地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1853.wav", + "text": "為什麼經濟部沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1854.wav", + "text": "尤其我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1855.wav", + "text": "重在半導體的方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1856.wav", + "text": "那其他產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1857.wav", + "text": "要能夠適應世界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1858.wav", + "text": "的潮流難道不是也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1859.wav", + "text": "努力並讓自己的企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1860.wav", + "text": "轉型然後才可以跟上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1861.wav", + "text": "跟上國際的潮流嗎所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1862.wav", + "text": "我覺得當我們要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1863.wav", + "text": "這樣的動作時真正需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1864.wav", + "text": "鼓勵的反而是我們的中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1865.wav", + "text": "我們要鼓勵它轉型要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1866.wav", + "text": "鼓勵它投入研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1867.wav", + "text": "這個才是最重要的而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1868.wav", + "text": "我要提的第一點第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1869.wav", + "text": "我們也要知道同樣的如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1870.wav", + "text": "容易可是對於中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1871.wav", + "text": "來講如果對它沒��一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1872.wav", + "text": "你要叫他們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1873.wav", + "text": "投入研發而且研發常常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1874.wav", + "text": "未必能有回收所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1875.wav", + "text": "等於是截斷所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1876.wav", + "text": "中小企業能夠轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1877.wav", + "text": "的契機因此我們在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1878.wav", + "text": "經濟部以及行政官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1879.wav", + "text": "能夠體諒民情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1880.wav", + "text": "一併納入\n另外我要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1881.wav", + "text": "譬如說這裡面有提及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1882.wav", + "text": "及前瞻創新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1883.wav", + "text": "研究發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1884.wav", + "text": "前瞻創新研究發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1885.wav", + "text": "然後裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1886.wav", + "text": "不夠所以我只是想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1887.wav", + "text": "在我們現在已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1888.wav", + "text": "都是著重在半導體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1889.wav", + "text": "政府行政官員的眼裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1890.wav", + "text": "\n這一點也要拜託行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1891.wav", + "text": "說明一下以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1892.wav", + "text": "剛剛前面兩位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1893.wav", + "text": "已經講過了這到底是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1894.wav", + "text": "臺版晶片法我們是不是只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1895.wav", + "text": "少數的產業其實在我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1896.wav", + "text": "看來這不只是專注在少數的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1897.wav", + "text": "產業更是專注在少數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1898.wav", + "text": "的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1899.wav", + "text": "十隻手指頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1900.wav", + "text": "差不多而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1901.wav", + "text": "如果真的認同這個產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1902.wav", + "text": "很重要我們要它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1903.wav", + "text": "根留臺灣應該說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1904.wav", + "text": "晶片法的部分臺灣跟國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1905.wav", + "text": "歐美或其他日韓不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1906.wav", + "text": "一樣的地方是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1907.wav", + "text": "我們的投資是好幾十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1908.wav", + "text": "年下來的我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1909.wav", + "text": "技術相對先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1910.wav", + "text": "我們的產業研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1911.wav", + "text": "能力相對是走在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1912.wav", + "text": "前面的但是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1913.wav", + "text": "真的要把它根留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1914.wav", + "text": "我們應該要想想如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1915.wav", + "text": "讓這個根" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1916.wav", + "text": "更盤根" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1917.wav", + "text": "錯節我們知��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1918.wav", + "text": "一個很粗的根跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1919.wav", + "text": "十個甚至上百個細細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1920.wav", + "text": "的根比起來上百個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1921.wav", + "text": "細細的根是比較容易留在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1922.wav", + "text": "的以白話來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1923.wav", + "text": "國外希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1924.wav", + "text": "把這些產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1925.wav", + "text": "拉走的話它要拉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1926.wav", + "text": "不是只有一家公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1927.wav", + "text": "而已它要拉的難度提高了是好幾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1928.wav", + "text": "家公司這才是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1929.wav", + "text": "應該做的所以我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1930.wav", + "text": "很簡單除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1931.wav", + "text": "對於公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1932.wav", + "text": "本身投資在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1933.wav", + "text": "它內部的研發費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1934.wav", + "text": "可以租稅抵減之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1935.wav", + "text": "公司投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1936.wav", + "text": "在其他新創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1937.wav", + "text": "公司當然不是做任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1938.wav", + "text": "也講了你們定義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1939.wav", + "text": "前瞻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1940.wav", + "text": "到時候如果你們有很明確定義的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1941.wav", + "text": "這也是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1942.wav", + "text": "也是從事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1943.wav", + "text": "前瞻創新的公司才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1944.wav", + "text": "適用如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1945.wav", + "text": "可以讓這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1946.wav", + "text": "出去而不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1947.wav", + "text": "只是幾家公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1948.wav", + "text": "少數公司越來越壯大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1949.wav", + "text": "最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1950.wav", + "text": "要拔走太容易了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1951.wav", + "text": "我們應該利用這個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1952.wav", + "text": "把這個租稅條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1953.wav", + "text": "可以擴張更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1954.wav", + "text": "讓這個產業真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1955.wav", + "text": "可以根留臺灣而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1956.wav", + "text": "我們去扶植幾個少數公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1957.wav", + "text": "都不知道是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1958.wav", + "text": "為哪一國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1959.wav", + "text": "國民扶植了謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1960.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1961.wav", + "text": "雖然只有兩條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1962.wav", + "text": "但是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1963.wav", + "text": "委員會協調幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1964.wav", + "text": "都沒有達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1965.wav", + "text": "我有幾個問題請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1966.wav", + "text": "依法納稅依法減稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1967.wav", + "text": "而且要授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1968.wav", + "text": "要規定很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1969.wav", + "text": "譬如現在的第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1970.wav", + "text": "為強化產業國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1971.wav", + "text": "競爭優勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1972.wav", + "text": "並鞏固我國產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1973.wav", + "text": "全球供應鏈之地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1974.wav", + "text": "於我國境內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1975.wav", + "text": "進行技術創新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1976.wav", + "text": "且居" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1977.wav", + "text": "國際供應鏈關鍵地位之公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1978.wav", + "text": "這到底是指哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1979.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1980.wav", + "text": "希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1981.wav", + "text": "納進去適用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1982.wav", + "text": "那我要問問經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1983.wav", + "text": "到底有幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1984.wav", + "text": "一家二家三家五家十家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1985.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1986.wav", + "text": "當然有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1987.wav", + "text": "啊這是我的理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1988.wav", + "text": "啦為什麼台積電1年賺幾百億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1989.wav", + "text": "我要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1990.wav", + "text": "部長的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1991.wav", + "text": "你們有什麼具體的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1992.wav", + "text": "可以把台積電留在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1993.wav", + "text": "送到美國去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1994.wav", + "text": "好到誰好到Intel" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1995.wav", + "text": "亞利桑那州那個廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1996.wav", + "text": "跟Intel廠的車程差1個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1997.wav", + "text": "人家薪水是34倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1998.wav", + "text": "Intel去了根本就在幫人家訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/1999.wav", + "text": "但是你怎麼把台積電留在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2000.wav", + "text": "它哪care" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2001.wav", + "text": "一年少多少稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2002.wav", + "text": "當然對它的成本降低有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2003.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2004.wav", + "text": "外界網路在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2005.wav", + "text": "國民黨時期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2006.wav", + "text": "創立培養台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2007.wav", + "text": "你不要笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2008.wav", + "text": "本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2009.wav", + "text": "你曉不曉得當時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2010.wav", + "text": "開發基金就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2011.wav", + "text": "啊到現在開發基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2012.wav", + "text": "還是台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2013.wav", + "text": "最大個人股東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2014.wav", + "text": "美國拉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2015.wav", + "text": "日本拉德國拉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2016.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2017.wav", + "text": "台積電每個國家都在拉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2018.wav", + "text": "我建議的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2019.wav", + "text": "大方向我支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2020.wav", + "text": "但是請部長告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2021.wav", + "text": "你用什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2022.wav", + "text": "具體方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2023.wav", + "text": "留在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2024.wav", + "text": "它才有辦法真正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2025.wav", + "text": "成為護國神山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2026.wav", + "text": "要不然一直推一直推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2027.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2028.wav", + "text": "距離Intel只有1個小時的車程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2029.wav", + "text": "我們台積電的優勢在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2030.wav", + "text": "就是良率嘛人嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2031.wav", + "text": "到時候就被挖走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2032.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2033.wav", + "text": "大方向我支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2034.wav", + "text": "你要寫明確我支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2035.wav", + "text": "用什麼具體措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2036.wav", + "text": "把台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2037.wav", + "text": "的關鍵優勢留在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2038.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2039.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2040.wav", + "text": "這個法在經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2041.wav", + "text": "也討論過非常多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2042.wav", + "text": "但是爭議非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2043.wav", + "text": "主要就是這個號稱臺版晶片法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2044.wav", + "text": "但是你可以細看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2045.wav", + "text": "這個內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2046.wav", + "text": "從頭到尾就是這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2047.wav", + "text": "這一條在法律上的定性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2048.wav", + "text": "是什麼這是一個租稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2049.wav", + "text": "優惠的法律條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2050.wav", + "text": "我要講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2051.wav", + "text": "依照憲法規定租稅是法定主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2052.wav", + "text": "要由法律來訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2053.wav", + "text": "法律明確性原則法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2054.wav", + "text": "要訂得非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2055.wav", + "text": "讓一般人民可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2056.wav", + "text": "據以審查這是法律的特性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2057.wav", + "text": "但是你可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2058.wav", + "text": "於我國境內進行技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2059.wav", + "text": "創新且居國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2060.wav", + "text": "供應鏈關鍵地位之公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2061.wav", + "text": "這個是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2062.wav", + "text": "不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2063.wav", + "text": "更嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2064.wav", + "text": "去做等於又是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2065.wav", + "text": "在其他法律裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2066.wav", + "text": "內容範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2067.wav", + "text": "訂清楚基本上就已經違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2068.wav", + "text": "授權明確性原則這個是大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2069.wav", + "text": "再三強調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2070.wav", + "text": "更何況這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2071.wav", + "text": "有關租稅優惠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2072.wav", + "text": "法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2073.wav", + "text": "租稅法定主義以及後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2074.wav", + "text": "的法律明確性原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2075.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2076.wav", + "text": "一個非常嚴重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2077.wav", + "text": "依照其他國家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2078.wav", + "text": "晶片法案的時候不會有人像我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2079.wav", + "text": "這樣做我舉個例子韓國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2080.wav", + "text": "加強保護國家高科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2081.wav", + "text": "戰略產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2082.wav", + "text": "競爭力特別措施法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2083.wav", + "text": "它是一部法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2084.wav", + "text": "日本的經濟安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2085.wav", + "text": "保障推進法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2086.wav", + "text": "也是一部法律它把國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2087.wav", + "text": "必須要推進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2088.wav", + "text": "核心技術的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2089.wav", + "text": "委員會的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2090.wav", + "text": "乃至於它的權責都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2091.wav", + "text": "入法而且它不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2092.wav", + "text": "只有租稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2093.wav", + "text": "優惠這一項若" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2094.wav", + "text": "若要把我國核心的關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2095.wav", + "text": "技術核心關鍵產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2096.wav", + "text": "怎麼會只有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2097.wav", + "text": "第一個你們號稱這是臺版晶片法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2098.wav", + "text": "為什麼保護我國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2099.wav", + "text": "限制在這些最大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2100.wav", + "text": "企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2101.wav", + "text": "是在保護這個產業鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2102.wav", + "text": "當然有中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2103.wav", + "text": "公司的大小作定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2104.wav", + "text": "工業局本來就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2105.wav", + "text": "條文至少應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2106.wav", + "text": "要把國際供應鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2107.wav", + "text": "關鍵地位之公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2108.wav", + "text": "國際供應鏈關鍵地位之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2109.wav", + "text": "技術也就是把公司改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2110.wav", + "text": "技術\n因為核心是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2111.wav", + "text": "要保護這個技術然後再調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2112.wav", + "text": "其他文字的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2113.wav", + "text": "的空白授權我就不再贅述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2114.wav", + "text": "也是非常有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2115.wav", + "text": "各黨團都有代表發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2116.wav", + "text": "過了現在讓王部長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2117.wav", + "text": "一直請你們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2118.wav", + "text": "我怎麼對他交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2119.wav", + "text": "最近3年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2120.wav", + "text": "無違反環境保護勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2121.wav", + "text": "或食品安全衛生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2122.wav", + "text": "相關法律且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2123.wav", + "text": "情節重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2124.wav", + "text": "情事針對情節重大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2125.wav", + "text": "經濟部等一下要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2126.wav", + "text": "再講清楚因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2127.wav", + "text": "這樣的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2128.wav", + "text": "如果沒有說清楚等於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2129.wav", + "text": "有寫和沒寫是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2130.wav", + "text": "請釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2131.wav", + "text": "但沒有舉例條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2132.wav", + "text": "與我國境內進行技術創新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2133.wav", + "text": "其實是跨境的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2134.wav", + "text": "要如何決定它是在我國境內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2135.wav", + "text": "你們用公司作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2136.wav", + "text": "是指公司要符合下列條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2137.wav", + "text": "而不是以剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2138.wav", + "text": "所說的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2139.wav", + "text": "當你們在擬這個草案時心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2140.wav", + "text": "就把中小企業排除在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2141.wav", + "text": "能夠符合你們開宗明義所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2142.wav", + "text": "已經居於國際供應鏈的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2143.wav", + "text": "關鍵地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2144.wav", + "text": "也拜託財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2145.wav", + "text": "當初在作稅式支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2146.wav", + "text": "如同媒體所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2147.wav", + "text": "稅式支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2148.wav", + "text": "我想民眾其實也很想瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2149.wav", + "text": "特別拜託一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2150.wav", + "text": "最後再讓柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2151.wav", + "text": "做整體的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2152.wav", + "text": "訂定這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2153.wav", + "text": "確實有它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2154.wav", + "text": "比較特定的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2155.wav", + "text": "民眾黨邱總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2156.wav", + "text": "國際競爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2157.wav", + "text": "各國甚至用大額的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2158.wav", + "text": "來吸引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2159.wav", + "text": "當然現在所有的國家都聚焦在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2160.wav", + "text": "半導體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2161.wav", + "text": "那也是因為半導體在現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2162.wav", + "text": "先進科技裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2163.wav", + "text": "占有非常重要的地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2164.wav", + "text": "在製造的這一端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2165.wav", + "text": "比較欠缺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2166.wav", + "text": "所以都提出大額的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2167.wav", + "text": "那對臺灣來講臺灣本來就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2168.wav", + "text": "半導體的群聚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2169.wav", + "text": "但是臺灣怎麼樣讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2170.wav", + "text": "臺灣的產業做得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2171.wav", + "text": "這是我們主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2172.wav", + "text": "擔心的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2173.wav", + "text": "我們也覺得我們要思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2174.wav", + "text": "臺灣要怎麼走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2175.wav", + "text": "但是這一個條文確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2176.wav", + "text": "沒有只限半導體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2177.wav", + "text": "我們的出發點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2178.wav", + "text": "只限半導體因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2179.wav", + "text": "對現在的臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2180.wav", + "text": "來講比如我們常常舉例的電動車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2181.wav", + "text": "其實都已經在國際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2182.wav", + "text": "占有越來越重要的地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2183.wav", + "text": "這就是為什麼我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2184.wav", + "text": "這個條文裡面沒有指定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2185.wav", + "text": "它在國際上占有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2186.wav", + "text": "市占率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2187.wav", + "text": "或者占有不可取代的地位等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2188.wav", + "text": "都可以是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2189.wav", + "text": "零組件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2190.wav", + "text": "這裡所謂的國際供應鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2191.wav", + "text": "企業對臺灣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2192.wav", + "text": "產業跟臺灣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2193.wav", + "text": "大的外溢效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2194.wav", + "text": "不管是對臺灣經濟的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2195.wav", + "text": "也好對國家的重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2196.wav", + "text": "性也好設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2197.wav", + "text": "想要給予這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2198.wav", + "text": "像剛才委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2199.wav", + "text": "在中小企業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2200.wav", + "text": "目前的第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2201.wav", + "text": "都有相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2202.wav", + "text": "租稅優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2203.wav", + "text": "而且非常重要的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2204.wav", + "text": "我們對中小企業是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2205.wav", + "text": "重視的所以政府有非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2206.wav", + "text": "中小企業是更為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2207.wav", + "text": "有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2208.wav", + "text": "的這是第一個第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2209.wav", + "text": "在這個條文的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2210.wav", + "text": "下委員也都提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2211.wav", + "text": "似乎有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2212.wav", + "text": "不確定的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2213.wav", + "text": "規定就是考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2214.wav", + "text": "到它會適用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2215.wav", + "text": "舉例的這幾個產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2216.wav", + "text": "變動非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2217.wav", + "text": "快事實上在這兩三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2218.wav", + "text": "年的變動就跟過往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2219.wav", + "text": "差別很大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2220.wav", + "text": "在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2221.wav", + "text": "做了明確的規範訂定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2222.wav", + "text": "在國內的有效稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2223.wav", + "text": "12%明年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2224.wav", + "text": "部分是為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2225.wav", + "text": "OECD最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2226.wav", + "text": "一個門檻就是企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2227.wav", + "text": "明年以後要達到15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2228.wav", + "text": "是一個高的門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2229.wav", + "text": "那高的門檻也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2230.wav", + "text": "呼應到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2231.wav", + "text": "未來我們可以跟國際說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2232.wav", + "text": "比較多的優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2233.wav", + "text": "呼應的因此在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2234.wav", + "text": "我們就是用這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2235.wav", + "text": "適度限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2236.wav", + "text": "大法官會議解釋指出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2237.wav", + "text": "以法律或者有法律明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2238.wav", + "text": "做規範所以這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2239.wav", + "text": "條文我們會留待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2240.wav", + "text": "很多需要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2241.wav", + "text": "子法訂的部分原因在於子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2242.wav", + "text": "裡面除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2243.wav", + "text": "都要隨時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2244.wav", + "text": "相關的學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2245.wav", + "text": "因為不同行業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2246.wav", + "text": "學者專家不同我們也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2247.wav", + "text": "上次委員提了我們就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2248.wav", + "text": "次吳怡玎委員特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2249.wav", + "text": "鼓勵部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2250.wav", + "text": "創條例第23條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2251.wav", + "text": "之1之二等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2252.wav", + "text": "來扶植新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2253.wav", + "text": "條第10條之一更重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2254.wav", + "text": "的是政府對於新創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2255.wav", + "text": "有技術創新的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2256.wav", + "text": "獎勵措施以資鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2257.wav", + "text": "基金也有相關的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2258.wav", + "text": "處工業局及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2259.wav", + "text": "商業司等特別就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2260.wav", + "text": "新創的創新給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2261.wav", + "text": "有更好的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2262.wav", + "text": "目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2263.wav", + "text": "在我們的所得稅法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2264.wav", + "text": "新創如果有股利或盈餘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2265.wav", + "text": "到大公司的營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2266.wav", + "text": "營利所得而課稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2267.wav", + "text": "目前的規範是用後端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2268.wav", + "text": "的部分讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2269.wav", + "text": "這個大公司去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2270.wav", + "text": "投資新創的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2271.wav", + "text": "不會當作是大公司自身的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2272.wav", + "text": "課稅所以如果現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2273.wav", + "text": "前端又要給他們做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2274.wav", + "text": "恐怕會有重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2275.wav", + "text": "營利事業所得稅查核準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2276.wav", + "text": "新創公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2277.wav", + "text": "而發生投資損失的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2278.wav", + "text": "那個大公司都還可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2279.wav", + "text": "認列是他們的投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2280.wav", + "text": "損失目前在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2281.wav", + "text": "稅方面的相關機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2282.wav", + "text": "至於獎勵的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2283.wav", + "text": "很用心對中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2284.wav", + "text": "和新創事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2285.wav", + "text": "有相關的獎勵制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2286.wav", + "text": "大致上我先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2287.wav", + "text": "做以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2288.wav", + "text": "剛才李貴敏委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2289.wav", + "text": "財政部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2290.wav", + "text": "財政部有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2291.wav", + "text": "要發表意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2292.wav", + "text": "主席及各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2293.wav", + "text": "財政部報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2294.wav", + "text": "我們都是依據OECD" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2295.wav", + "text": "所發展出來的稅式支出評估方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2296.wav", + "text": "所以會有最初收入損失法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2297.wav", + "text": "就是這個租稅優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2298.wav", + "text": "一出去的時候第一波的租稅減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2299.wav", + "text": "亦即稅損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2300.wav", + "text": "這就是最初收入損失法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2301.wav", + "text": "另一個是最終收入損失法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2302.wav", + "text": "也就是藉由這些租稅優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2303.wav", + "text": "關聯效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2304.wav", + "text": "另一個是等額支出法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2305.wav", + "text": "亦即如果不採行租稅優惠的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2306.wav", + "text": "要達到相同的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2307.wav", + "text": "多少金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2308.wav", + "text": "收入損失法是淨效益1.77億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2309.wav", + "text": "等額支出法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2310.wav", + "text": "659.94億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2311.wav", + "text": "簡單講一下研發那塊的估算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2312.wav", + "text": "我國在國際市場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2313.wav", + "text": "重要性產業所投入的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2314.wav", + "text": "研發費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2315.wav", + "text": "(2016年至2021" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2316.wav", + "text": "年)研發費用每年平均大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2317.wav", + "text": "研發費用的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2318.wav", + "text": "經驗大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2319.wav", + "text": "40%是屬於前瞻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2320.wav", + "text": "在最初收入損失法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2321.wav", + "text": "研發支出大概是817億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2322.wav", + "text": "25%和15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2323.wav", + "text": "也就是抵減率的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2324.wav", + "text": "所以稅損是81.7億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2325.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣的估算方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2326.wav", + "text": "本來是輪到柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2327.wav", + "text": "不好意思院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2328.wav", + "text": "我要做程序發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2329.wav", + "text": "\n第一個我剛剛有詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2330.wav", + "text": "是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2331.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有問嘛我說現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2332.wav", + "text": "然後是第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2333.wav", + "text": "的方法計算用什麼樣的方法是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2334.wav", + "text": "民間所質疑的為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2335.wav", + "text": "特定的公司然後按" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2336.wav", + "text": "照那個特定公司的全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2337.wav", + "text": "\n為什麼我會問這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2338.wav", + "text": "問題再補充一下就是說如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2339.wav", + "text": "尤其它持股的外資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2340.wav", + "text": "很多在這個情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2341.wav", + "text": "因為它享有這樣的特定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2342.wav", + "text": "樣對國人是不是公平因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2343.wav", + "text": "在第10條之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2344.wav", + "text": "中小企業的如果第10條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2345.wav", + "text": "很明確地講說已經排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2346.wav", + "text": "那麼中小企業適用的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2347.wav", + "text": "只有第10條之1和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2348.wav", + "text": "你既然第10條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2349.wav", + "text": "排除掉中小企業第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2350.wav", + "text": "跟第10條之1到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2351.wav", + "text": "目前為止已經適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2352.wav", + "text": "的中小企業有多少家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2353.wav", + "text": "我們就可以用那個金額瞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2354.wav", + "text": "八成以上的中小企業他們所受到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2355.wav", + "text": "產業的待遇不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2356.wav", + "text": "這樣子國人是不是能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2357.wav", + "text": "再次強調我沒有反對但我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2358.wav", + "text": "應該只有涵蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2359.wav", + "text": "特定的而是應該要把中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2360.wav", + "text": "也納入因為中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2361.wav", + "text": "是我們社會安定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2362.wav", + "text": "的一個很重要的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2363.wav", + "text": "好不好\n剛才我做的程序發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2364.wav", + "text": "拜託針對沒有回答的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2365.wav", + "text": "予以回答謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2366.wav", + "text": "請大家聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2367.wav", + "text": "李貴敏委員剛才講了一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2368.wav", + "text": "很關鍵性的話就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2369.wav", + "text": "他沒有反對這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2370.wav", + "text": "我想在座各位繞來繞去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2371.wav", + "text": "直接反對這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2372.wav", + "text": "的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2373.wav", + "text": "大概沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2374.wav", + "text": "就是要讓這個法案對根留臺灣有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2375.wav", + "text": "嘛比較極致的就是曾銘宗講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2376.wav", + "text": "Intel的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2377.wav", + "text": "台積電有沒有需要的問題人家不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2378.wav", + "text": "我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2379.wav", + "text": "這句話不是這樣解釋才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2380.wav", + "text": "一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2381.wav", + "text": "大家講說全���界對於重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2382.wav", + "text": "國家關鍵性產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2383.wav", + "text": "有競爭力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2384.wav", + "text": "全世界都這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2385.wav", + "text": "每一個國家都是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2386.wav", + "text": "來談這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2387.wav", + "text": "共同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2388.wav", + "text": "我亦復如是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2389.wav", + "text": "我們從整個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2390.wav", + "text": "的產業政策開始談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2391.wav", + "text": "國家產業政策已經有它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2392.wav", + "text": "租稅政策的工具對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2393.wav", + "text": "的獎勵投資條例開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2394.wav", + "text": "是不是就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2395.wav", + "text": "農業時代走入工業時代包括加工出口區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2396.wav", + "text": "等等一路扶植下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2397.wav", + "text": "民國75年成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2398.wav", + "text": "就是民進黨成立的那一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2399.wav", + "text": "嚴了我在新竹科學園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2400.wav", + "text": "區工作了10年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2401.wav", + "text": "園區一開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2402.wav", + "text": "我就在裡面當醫生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2403.wav", + "text": "看著整個園區成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2404.wav", + "text": "我在那裡工作10年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2405.wav", + "text": "是在我的選區裡面包括工研" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2406.wav", + "text": "清交大等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2407.wav", + "text": "我看了整個國家產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2408.wav", + "text": "我們國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2409.wav", + "text": "我們現在的機會點在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2410.wav", + "text": "我們現在的優勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2411.wav", + "text": "我們都要很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2412.wav", + "text": "從一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2413.wav", + "text": "獎投條例開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2414.wav", + "text": "後來民國八十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2415.wav", + "text": "我想在座經濟委員會的人都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2416.wav", + "text": "那時候有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2417.wav", + "text": "促進產業升級條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2418.wav", + "text": "促進產業升級條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2419.wav", + "text": "落日以後才有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2420.wav", + "text": "今天的產創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2421.wav", + "text": "所以這個是整個國家在法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2422.wav", + "text": "讓產業轉移的一個很重要的法典和法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2423.wav", + "text": "並不是在處理中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2424.wav", + "text": "我們對於中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2425.wav", + "text": "0條之1第10條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2426.wav", + "text": "兩個不一樣的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2427.wav", + "text": "這對它是不公平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2428.wav", + "text": "剛剛開始的時候各位有沒有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2429.wav", + "text": "它裡面的第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2430.wav", + "text": "為什麼有這個因為六輕的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2431.wav", + "text": "我們要石化產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2432.wav", + "text": "接下來有什麼有產業別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2433.wav", + "text": "看哪個產業可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2434.wav", + "text": "就是投資在RDRD現在還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2435.wav", + "text": "自動化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2436.wav", + "text": "有很多是功能別的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2437.wav", + "text": "那年我進了立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2438.wav", + "text": "包括環境保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2439.wav", + "text": "包括節約能源都加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2440.wav", + "text": "那時候的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2441.wav", + "text": "還有股東投資抵減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2442.wav", + "text": "還有所謂的創投" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2443.wav", + "text": "VC現在VC都取消掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2444.wav", + "text": "了是因為國家的政策工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2445.wav", + "text": "造成稅損我們必須重新檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2446.wav", + "text": "尤其自動化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2447.wav", + "text": "的稅損是幾千億元的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2448.wav", + "text": "現在每一樣都是自動化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2449.wav", + "text": "所以這個並不是我們重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2450.wav", + "text": "加持的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2451.wav", + "text": "\n我們今天走到這個地方來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2452.wav", + "text": "已經走到另外一個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2453.wav", + "text": "也就是產創條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2454.wav", + "text": "我想各位都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2455.wav", + "text": "產創條例在去年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2456.wav", + "text": "才修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2457.wav", + "text": "就是為了中小企業包括第10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2458.wav", + "text": "當然有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2459.wav", + "text": "關於關鍵產業也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2460.wav", + "text": "中小企業適用得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2461.wav", + "text": "我們還有修很多法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2462.wav", + "text": "事實上我們也修一些法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2463.wav", + "text": "讓中小企業能夠起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2464.wav", + "text": "或是扶持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2465.wav", + "text": "他們大家可以去回顧一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2466.wav", + "text": "這中間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2467.wav", + "text": "我們修了哪些法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2468.wav", + "text": "但是我今天要很具體地講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2469.wav", + "text": "我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2470.wav", + "text": "山群包括剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2471.wav", + "text": "這很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2472.wav", + "text": "我們在國際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2473.wav", + "text": "最有競爭力的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2474.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂去臺灣化的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2475.wav", + "text": "臺灣所有半導體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2476.wav", + "text": "董事長不管是張忠謀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2477.wav", + "text": "包括Frank" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2478.wav", + "text": "老闆都是我的老朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2479.wav", + "text": "臺灣的高科技產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2480.wav", + "text": "臺灣的半導體產業能夠起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2481.wav", + "text": "第一個是要感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2482.wav", + "text": "過去有促產條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2483.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2484.wav", + "text": "半導體產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2485.wav", + "text": "在臺灣製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2486.wav", + "text": "RD我們人最多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2487.wav", + "text": "這是我們的強項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2488.wav", + "text": "是全世界最便宜的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2489.wav", + "text": "沒辦法才過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2490.wav", + "text": "的但是那占台積電的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2491.wav", + "text": "是非常少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2492.wav", + "text": "的所以各位所憂慮的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2493.wav", + "text": "和你要關心問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2494.wav", + "text": "不要成為一個對撞的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2495.wav", + "text": "委員說人才不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2496.wav", + "text": "本來就是政府要解決的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2497.wav", + "text": "過去新竹寶二水庫等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2498.wav", + "text": "都是在處理水電的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2499.wav", + "text": "才能夠扶植台積電上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2500.wav", + "text": "扶植臺灣半導體產業上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2501.wav", + "text": "今天我們沒有否認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2502.wav", + "text": "在李國鼎時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2503.wav", + "text": "的結果在國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2504.wav", + "text": "時期是李國鼎先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2505.wav", + "text": "但是這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2506.wav", + "text": "並不代表台積電是我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2507.wav", + "text": "那時候國家花了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2508.wav", + "text": "講白了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2509.wav", + "text": "水電等等都是國家在處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2510.wav", + "text": "今日的成就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2511.wav", + "text": "是臺灣最珍貴的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2512.wav", + "text": "也是臺灣最有競爭力的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2513.wav", + "text": "授權不明確或違憲的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2514.wav", + "text": "國家在處理這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2515.wav", + "text": "案子的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2516.wav", + "text": "包括經濟部包括整個國家在處理這個案子的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2517.wav", + "text": "除了中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2518.wav", + "text": "智慧機械以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2519.wav", + "text": "另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2520.wav", + "text": "具有前瞻性最有關鍵性領導地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2521.wav", + "text": "的產業我們當然要保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2522.wav", + "text": "是12%到15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2523.wav", + "text": "坦白講這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2524.wav", + "text": "都很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2525.wav", + "text": "他們必須提前和全球一致\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2526.wav", + "text": "所以我今天在這裡懇求拜託各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2527.wav", + "text": "我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2528.wav", + "text": "大家並沒有明白表示說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2529.wav", + "text": "大概沒有這個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2530.wav", + "text": "雖然有一些關切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2531.wav", + "text": "也是合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2532.wav", + "text": "我們不要把它連在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2533.wav", + "text": "包括本黨黨團成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2534.wav", + "text": "關心中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2535.wav", + "text": "在經濟委員會裡我算是待最久的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2536.wav", + "text": "2000年我當總召以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2537.wav", + "text": "就離開經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2538.wav", + "text": "我曾經在經濟委員會待了7年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2539.wav", + "text": "初期法案的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2540.wav", + "text": "包括在美國壓力底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2541.wav", + "text": "我們設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2542.wav", + "text": "設置IC底下的保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2543.wav", + "text": "部長在這裡應該都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2544.wav", + "text": "用專利法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2545.wav", + "text": "來阻止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2546.wav", + "text": "來搞我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2547.wav", + "text": "專利法修正的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2548.wav", + "text": "跑來找我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2549.wav", + "text": "說專利法不要修美國是在欺負我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2550.wav", + "text": "因為美國根本沒有刑責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2551.wav", + "text": "對財務損失的補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2552.wav", + "text": "有一天張忠謀和他一定會被抓去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2553.wav", + "text": "絕對沒有辦法發展起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2554.wav", + "text": "那一年聯電剛好在發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2555.wav", + "text": "486CPU" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2556.wav", + "text": "馬上就被摧毀掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2557.wav", + "text": "所以你要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2558.wav", + "text": "在整個國際競爭力全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2559.wav", + "text": "這是一個非常嚴峻的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2560.wav", + "text": "挑戰我們好不容易走到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2561.wav", + "text": "最引以為傲且具有競爭力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2562.wav", + "text": "變成全球最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2563.wav", + "text": "單一廠商而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2564.wav", + "text": "對於稅損的部分剛才有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2565.wav", + "text": "剛財政部都有說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2566.wav", + "text": "很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2567.wav", + "text": "所以我在這裡拜託大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2568.wav", + "text": "就和我們剛才在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2569.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2570.wav", + "text": "有關溫室氣體減量的第29條第33條等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2571.wav", + "text": "邱顯智一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2572.wav", + "text": "我們要有蘿蔔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2573.wav", + "text": "也要有棍子產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2574.wav", + "text": "產業轉型需要incentive" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2575.wav", + "text": "你說incentive卻又把它弄不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2576.wav", + "text": "坦白講我是不能接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2577.wav", + "text": "我今天要很誠懇地在這裡拜託大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2578.wav", + "text": "臺灣面對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2579.wav", + "text": "美國都在做晶片法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2580.wav", + "text": "美國又再給我們壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2581.wav", + "text": "在國際商戰上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2582.wav", + "text": "如何保持我們的優勝領先地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2583.wav", + "text": "我們不要忘記還有韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2584.wav", + "text": "所以各位今天這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2585.wav", + "text": "和中小企業的保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2586.wav", + "text": "及中小企業的優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2587.wav", + "text": "要怎麼修我都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2588.wav", + "text": "況且我知道委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2589.wav", + "text": "時也有做一個決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2590.wav", + "text": "未來是不是產創條例有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2591.wav", + "text": "乃至於第23條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2592.wav", + "text": "第23條之二等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2593.wav", + "text": "要修的話可以再重新考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2594.wav", + "text": "我沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2595.wav", + "text": "啊那時候我們修到連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2596.wav", + "text": "金融沙盒都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2597.wav", + "text": "啊連沙盒都在處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2598.wav", + "text": "我們其實希望天使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2599.wav", + "text": "新創都能夠起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2600.wav", + "text": "這些都好不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2601.wav", + "text": "坦白講新創公司要起來1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2602.wav", + "text": "但是我們國家還是要扶植" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2603.wav", + "text": "這是普遍性的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2604.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2605.wav", + "text": "我剛才講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2606.wav", + "text": "要把這個留在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2607.wav", + "text": "你要知道台積電不是只有一家公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2608.wav", + "text": "其相關的供應商及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2609.wav", + "text": "牢固的穩定基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2610.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2611.wav", + "text": "這是國家安全上很重要的時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2612.wav", + "text": "今天不是只有台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2613.wav", + "text": "而已這個法案適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2614.wav", + "text": "假如有10家的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2615.wav", + "text": "我希望能夠有20家也無所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2616.wav", + "text": "但一定的國際規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2617.wav", + "text": "我們還是要follow" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2618.wav", + "text": "我們不能亂用租稅政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2619.wav", + "text": "合來講我很懇切地拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2620.wav", + "text": "假如針對中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2621.wav", + "text": "來處理這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2622.wav", + "text": "系統混在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2623.wav", + "text": "混在一起講是對抗的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2624.wav", + "text": "可能讓人看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2625.wav", + "text": "是用這個理由來反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2626.wav", + "text": "理由是不構成衝突的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2627.wav", + "text": "我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2628.wav", + "text": "請大家冷靜想一想這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2629.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2630.wav", + "text": "只剩下一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2631.wav", + "text": "啦應該大家有共識才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2632.wav", + "text": "如果要表決我不必在這裡講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2633.wav", + "text": "那麼多話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2634.wav", + "text": "但我不忍心看到我們立法院是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2635.wav", + "text": "方式來處理重大法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2636.wav", + "text": "應該可以溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2637.wav", + "text": "至於相關的規範要明確一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2638.wav", + "text": "我相信經濟部及財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2639.wav", + "text": "一定會去做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2640.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2641.wav", + "text": "執政黨總召這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2642.wav", + "text": "是不是我們就照他們的意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2643.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2644.wav", + "text": "要他們回答清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2645.wav", + "text": "不是我的意思是他們要回答我們的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2646.wav", + "text": "我們要把原則方向講定大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2647.wav", + "text": "要有共同共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2648.wav", + "text": "中小企業就講中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2649.wav", + "text": "那是另外一塊的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2650.wav", + "text": "對於這一塊有什麼釋疑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2651.wav", + "text": "沒有講清楚沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2652.wav", + "text": "我是樂見大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2653.wav", + "text": "越談越清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2654.wav", + "text": "而且共識度越高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2655.wav", + "text": "就變成是這個會期很重要的法案一起通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2656.wav", + "text": "我們一定贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2657.wav", + "text": "但我們不希望有這種驕傲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2658.wav", + "text": "法案的精神與內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2659.wav", + "text": "李貴敏委員吳怡玎委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2660.wav", + "text": "希望能夠把這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2661.wav", + "text": "修好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2662.wav", + "text": "做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2663.wav", + "text": "然後柯總召說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2664.wav", + "text": "他在科學園區工作10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2665.wav", + "text": "臺灣有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2666.wav", + "text": "關鍵技術的產業鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2667.wav", + "text": "它提供了臺灣許多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2668.wav", + "text": "經濟成長及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2669.wav", + "text": "許多的就業機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2670.wav", + "text": "我們要怎麼去保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2671.wav", + "text": "這一個產業鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2672.wav", + "text": "我覺得核心的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2673.wav", + "text": "是在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2674.wav", + "text": "產創條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2675.wav", + "text": "我覺得立意是好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2676.wav", + "text": "的但我覺得觀念是錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2677.wav", + "text": "現在包括日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2678.wav", + "text": "它是怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2679.wav", + "text": "這個問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2680.wav", + "text": "事實上產創條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2681.wav", + "text": "產業升級的一個對策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2682.wav", + "text": "以韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2683.wav", + "text": "的加強保護國家高科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2684.wav", + "text": "戰略產業競爭力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2685.wav", + "text": "跟日本的經濟安全保障推進法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2686.wav", + "text": "其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2687.wav", + "text": "著重在相關的技術認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2688.wav", + "text": "亦即保護的是技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2689.wav", + "text": "而不是公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2690.wav", + "text": "所要保護的核心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2691.wav", + "text": "焦點始終應該放在技術上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2692.wav", + "text": "必須要訂定一個總體的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2693.wav", + "text": "在這個計畫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2694.wav", + "text": "相關的技術去認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2695.wav", + "text": "有一個認定的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2696.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的技術才值得國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2697.wav", + "text": "傾全力去保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2698.wav", + "text": "要比照日韓的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2699.wav", + "text": "訂定計畫跟成立一個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2700.wav", + "text": "去做相關技術的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2701.wav", + "text": "所以我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2702.wav", + "text": "這個條文我剛剛講的為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2703.wav", + "text": "這會落入讓人們一直在質疑你們是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2704.wav", + "text": "在保護一個特定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2705.wav", + "text": "大公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2706.wav", + "text": "訂的時候位居國際供應鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2707.wav", + "text": "關鍵地位之公司請問臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2708.wav", + "text": "有幾家公司能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2709.wav", + "text": "符合這個條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2710.wav", + "text": "定義所以我才說我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2711.wav", + "text": "是真的是想要把這個法修好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2712.wav", + "text": "改成技術日本韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2713.wav", + "text": "都是這樣做而且日本韓國做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2714.wav", + "text": "的不只是租稅優惠他們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2715.wav", + "text": "非常多的相關措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2716.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2717.wav", + "text": "用這樣的方式去處理當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2718.wav", + "text": "會惹起這樣的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2719.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛部長有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2720.wav", + "text": "大法官解釋認為在租稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2721.wav", + "text": "方面其實授權命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2722.wav", + "text": "也可以但是我必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2723.wav", + "text": "補充一點所謂租稅法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2724.wav", + "text": "定永遠指的是它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2725.wav", + "text": "它比其他法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2726.wav", + "text": "有更高的要求亦即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2727.wav", + "text": "亦即法律必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2728.wav", + "text": "而且讓一般的人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2729.wav", + "text": "司法審查可以據以為審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2730.wav", + "text": "所以現在回過頭來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2731.wav", + "text": "你們違反了兩個東西第一個叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2732.wav", + "text": "法律明確性原則這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2733.wav", + "text": "並不清楚不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2734.wav", + "text": "減免了什麼不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2735.wav", + "text": "並且是不是有特定的大公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2736.wav", + "text": "這個疑慮第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2737.wav", + "text": "就是授權不清楚違反了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2738.wav", + "text": "授權明確性的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2739.wav", + "text": "這個授權理論上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2740.wav", + "text": "應該是要能夠讓大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2741.wav", + "text": "在做這樣的租稅優惠時到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2742.wav", + "text": "底所指涉的東西是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2743.wav", + "text": "第三個我覺得更危險的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2744.wav", + "text": "法律的特性永遠是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2745.wav", + "text": "最一般的人跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2746.wav", + "text": "抽象的事物法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2747.wav", + "text": "的特性就是對一般抽象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2748.wav", + "text": "而不是特定具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2749.wav", + "text": "如果法律訂定出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2750.wav", + "text": "之後它只能是針對特定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2751.wav", + "text": "的人跟具體的事物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2752.wav", + "text": "那可能是行政處分而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2753.wav", + "text": "法律這樣也違反了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2754.wav", + "text": "基本原則\n所以總體來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2755.wav", + "text": "不是針對中小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2756.wav", + "text": "企業我必須要修正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2757.wav", + "text": "這當然不是針對大企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2758.wav", + "text": "也不是針對中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2759.wav", + "text": "這應該是針對技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2760.wav", + "text": "新竹科學園區裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2761.wav", + "text": "也有新創公司就像柯總召講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2762.wav", + "text": "的新創公司他們非常辛苦也有小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2763.wav", + "text": "中企業也有大企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2764.wav", + "text": "對不對所以這個分類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2765.wav", + "text": "的類型在這個條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2766.wav", + "text": "不應該是用公司去區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2767.wav", + "text": "而應該是用技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2768.wav", + "text": "區分即便他們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2769.wav", + "text": "好幾個年輕人他們擁有一個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2770.wav", + "text": "關鍵的技術在我國產業鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2771.wav", + "text": "裡面基於非常關鍵的地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2772.wav", + "text": "我們給他這樣的優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2773.wav", + "text": "又何妨即便是個小公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2774.wav", + "text": "只有幾個人而已是在車庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2775.wav", + "text": "裡面常常都有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2776.wav", + "text": "傳說在這個車庫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2777.wav", + "text": "關鍵技術那來保護它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2778.wav", + "text": "又何妨呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2779.wav", + "text": "\n所以放眼國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2780.wav", + "text": "美國日本韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2781.wav", + "text": "統統都是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2782.wav", + "text": "技術在做保護而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2783.wav", + "text": "用公司在做類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2784.wav", + "text": "我回答一下好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2785.wav", + "text": "過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2786.wav", + "text": "我們整個產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2787.wav", + "text": "政策升級調整包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2788.wav", + "text": "我們弄了很多政策工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2789.wav", + "text": "產業升級條例包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2790.wav", + "text": "今天的產創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2791.wav", + "text": "功能別就是技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2792.wav", + "text": "也有產業別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2793.wav", + "text": "別國民黨執政時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2794.wav", + "text": "曾經也改了一個新興重要關鍵性產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2795.wav", + "text": "這就是產業別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2796.wav", + "text": "產業兼公司別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2797.wav", + "text": "因為focus在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2798.wav", + "text": "精準打擊在什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2799.wav", + "text": "假如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2800.wav", + "text": "各位假如還記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2801.wav", + "text": "吳敦義在當行政院長時針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2802.wav", + "text": "中小企業發展條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2803.wav", + "text": "他弄了一個僱用本國勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2804.wav", + "text": "抵稅那一年還把營所稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2805.wav", + "text": "降低到17%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2806.wav", + "text": "國際情勢及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2807.wav", + "text": "當時的經濟環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2808.wav", + "text": "中小企業僱用本國勞工可以抵稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2809.wav", + "text": "所以我們可以瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2810.wav", + "text": "我們對中小企業有中小企業發展基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2811.wav", + "text": "也有中小企業條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2812.wav", + "text": "底下規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2813.wav", + "text": "信保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2814.wav", + "text": "也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2815.wav", + "text": "我相信我們今天講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2816.wav", + "text": "都是以善意為出發點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2817.wav", + "text": "談同一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2818.wav", + "text": "我並不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2819.wav", + "text": "關鍵性零組件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2820.wav", + "text": "國際金融環境不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2821.wav", + "text": "產業環境的變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2822.wav", + "text": "過去也曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2823.wav", + "text": "提出66項關鍵性零組件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2824.wav", + "text": "就是採功能別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2825.wav", + "text": "別現在就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2826.wav", + "text": "今天講的我都聽得懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2827.wav", + "text": "大家也都很在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2828.wav", + "text": "神山群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2829.wav", + "text": "這裡的護國神山群不是只有半導體產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2830.wav", + "text": "而已將來5G能夠進來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2831.wav", + "text": "我也不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2832.wav", + "text": "我們就是在這樣level" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2833.wav", + "text": "瞭解過去的產業發展史再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2834.wav", + "text": "去看待的時候就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2835.wav", + "text": "並不只是台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2836.wav", + "text": "此污名化台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2837.wav", + "text": "這樣並不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2838.wav", + "text": "稅制改變時能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2839.wav", + "text": "有個提早因應的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2840.wav", + "text": "公平準備機制而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2841.wav", + "text": "這部分還望各位諒解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2842.wav", + "text": "我有個程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2843.wav", + "text": "要跟大家交換意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2844.wav", + "text": "現在取得發言權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2845.wav", + "text": "有陳椒華委員李貴敏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2846.wav", + "text": "\n我現在要跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2847.wav", + "text": "我怕大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2848.wav", + "text": "所以就先說明我們備有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2849.wav", + "text": "是不是待產創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2850.wav", + "text": "條例這個案子協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2851.wav", + "text": "總預算目前尚有4007百多案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2852.wav", + "text": "就開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2853.wav", + "text": "有4007百多案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2854.wav", + "text": "我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2855.wav", + "text": "明天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2856.wav", + "text": "照這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2857.wav", + "text": "來看今天還要協商5個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2858.wav", + "text": "至於第八案的公務人員任用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2859.wav", + "text": "那個很簡單一定會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2860.wav", + "text": "照順序排下去一定會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2861.wav", + "text": "而且所有法案都會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2862.wav", + "text": "除了公務人員任用法之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2863.wav", + "text": "處理完以後明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2864.wav", + "text": "協商因為有4007百多案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2865.wav", + "text": "如果不密集協商的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2866.wav", + "text": "有所延宕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2867.wav", + "text": "沒有關係明天再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2868.wav", + "text": "我知道了你要談什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2869.wav", + "text": "我要協商延長會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2870.wav", + "text": "我們都會面對好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2871.wav", + "text": "明天早上再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2872.wav", + "text": "所以明天是不是9時就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2873.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2874.wav", + "text": "總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2875.wav", + "text": "總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2876.wav", + "text": "我們明天先討論三9時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2877.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2878.wav", + "text": "我每天我財委會五點半就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2879.wav", + "text": "我今天到現在還沒有吃飯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2880.wav", + "text": "我昨天就沒吃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2881.wav", + "text": "開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2882.wav", + "text": "還有5個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2883.wav", + "text": "子我們是要先吃便當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2884.wav", + "text": "吃完再繼續協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2885.wav", + "text": "就吃飯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2886.wav", + "text": "我這樣建議好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2887.wav", + "text": "假如大家能夠體會到中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2888.wav", + "text": "另外一個條文在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2889.wav", + "text": "今天是處理這一個前瞻性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2890.wav", + "text": "關鍵性的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2891.wav", + "text": "假如各位對於經濟部還有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2892.wav", + "text": "不放心的我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2893.wav", + "text": "就做一些附帶決議來要求它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2894.wav", + "text": "它這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2895.wav", + "text": "嘛因為那個還在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2896.wav", + "text": "朝野協商還要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2897.wav", + "text": "所有法案都會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2898.wav", + "text": "個案子討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2899.wav", + "text": "確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2900.wav", + "text": "有一個決定以後再吃便當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2901.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2902.wav", + "text": "大家沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2903.wav", + "text": "喔\n明天9時開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2904.wav", + "text": "總預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2905.wav", + "text": "總預算案以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2906.wav", + "text": "我們就繼續發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2907.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員李貴敏委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2908.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2909.wav", + "text": "剛剛聽了柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2910.wav", + "text": "從六輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2911.wav", + "text": "到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2912.wav", + "text": "我還是要提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2913.wav", + "text": "經濟部還是要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2914.wav", + "text": "就是現在缺水的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2915.wav", + "text": "尤其南部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2916.wav", + "text": "400多天都沒下雨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2917.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2918.wav", + "text": "當然就是會鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2919.wav", + "text": "擴張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2920.wav", + "text": "但是我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2921.wav", + "text": "電到底有沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2922.wav", + "text": "類似台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2923.wav", + "text": "產業環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2924.wav", + "text": "其實我們根本都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2925.wav", + "text": "但是它的環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2926.wav", + "text": "還是那麼便宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2927.wav", + "text": "所以我們從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2928.wav", + "text": "現在的產創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2929.wav", + "text": "柯總召剛剛講的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2930.wav", + "text": "時空背景都已經過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2931.wav", + "text": "那麼優渥的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2932.wav", + "text": "讓這種產業再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2933.wav", + "text": "無限制的擴張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2934.wav", + "text": "所以我在這裡還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2935.wav", + "text": "建提醒經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2936.wav", + "text": "有些狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2937.wav", + "text": "你一直沒有處理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2938.wav", + "text": "要去調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2939.wav", + "text": "或是用電大戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2940.wav", + "text": "執行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2941.wav", + "text": "現在的問題還是存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2942.wav", + "text": "長期缺水以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2943.wav", + "text": "也沒有辦法去耕作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2944.wav", + "text": "所以我不是說我反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2945.wav", + "text": "但是的確現在很多事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2946.wav", + "text": "的問題沒解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2947.wav", + "text": "並不是像柯總召剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2948.wav", + "text": "臺灣的確是有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2949.wav", + "text": "環境去鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2950.wav", + "text": "做這樣子的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2951.wav", + "text": "創新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2952.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2953.wav", + "text": "我是建議這個問題真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2954.wav", + "text": "要面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2955.wav", + "text": "譬如說你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2956.wav", + "text": "一直說再生水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2957.wav", + "text": "我們用很多再生水但是就沒有再生水的水源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2958.wav", + "text": "再生水又那麼貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2959.wav", + "text": "的確是讓大家有誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2960.wav", + "text": "好像臺灣可以無限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2961.wav", + "text": "去發展這些半導體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2962.wav", + "text": "柯總召我希望你可以聽清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2963.wav", + "text": "現在問題真的很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2964.wav", + "text": "柯總召你要專心聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2965.wav", + "text": "其實很多人都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2966.wav", + "text": "產業的發展從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2967.wav", + "text": "創投開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2968.wav", + "text": "到扶植半導體產業我都一路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2969.wav", + "text": "跟著他們一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2970.wav", + "text": "可以算是半導體寶寶所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2971.wav", + "text": "我絕對不會反對任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2972.wav", + "text": "有助於國家產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2973.wav", + "text": "的事這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2974.wav", + "text": "走來從我們沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2975.wav", + "text": "半導體產業到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2976.wav", + "text": "我希望對於臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2977.wav", + "text": "所有經濟發展有利的都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2978.wav", + "text": "能夠得到國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2979.wav", + "text": "的資助這是第一點所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2980.wav", + "text": "我沒有任何惡意但是我很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2981.wav", + "text": "不能夠理解的是如同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2982.wav", + "text": "是如同我剛剛前面提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2983.wav", + "text": "的為什麼中小企業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2984.wav", + "text": "這個是我很不能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2985.wav", + "text": "這個條文是為了非中小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2986.wav", + "text": "的中小企業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2987.wav", + "text": "我們可以做出一個決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2988.wav", + "text": "中小企業納入這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2989.wav", + "text": "要比照中小企業的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2990.wav", + "text": "行政單位什麼時候把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2991.wav", + "text": "中小企業的部分提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2992.wav", + "text": "那個委員會就有做決議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2993.wav", + "text": "時候我們今天也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2994.wav", + "text": "到底中小企業部分是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2995.wav", + "text": "時候提出來的為什麼中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2996.wav", + "text": "你不要擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2997.wav", + "text": "第二個我覺得應該要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2998.wav", + "text": "你現在說中小企業的是第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/2999.wav", + "text": "和第10條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3000.wav", + "text": "可是你的第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3001.wav", + "text": "目前為止提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3002.wav", + "text": "有多少家然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3003.wav", + "text": "你給它的獎勵是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3004.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個東西都要出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3005.wav", + "text": "還有其他幾條第23條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3006.wav", + "text": "你適用在中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3007.wav", + "text": "的部分到如今為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3008.wav", + "text": "他們享受到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3009.wav", + "text": "有多少\n你都應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3010.wav", + "text": "說清楚講明白因為民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3011.wav", + "text": "你為了特定企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3012.wav", + "text": "量身訂做對於這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3013.wav", + "text": "誤會如果不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3014.wav", + "text": "在第一時間就把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3015.wav", + "text": "講名字像剛剛陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3016.wav", + "text": "黃崇仁黃崇仁不是在第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3017.wav", + "text": "就跳出來說你這是為誰量身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3018.wav", + "text": "訂做的所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3019.wav", + "text": "很多東西你都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3020.wav", + "text": "說清楚講明白像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3021.wav", + "text": "剛才我為什麼會提程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3022.wav", + "text": "還是沒有說你不能夠把中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3023.wav", + "text": "同時納入的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3024.wav", + "text": "這一條是為了這個關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3025.wav", + "text": "的一個在全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3026.wav", + "text": "供應鏈的可是你沒有說你為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3027.wav", + "text": "不能把中小企業同時納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3028.wav", + "text": "的原因這也是另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3029.wav", + "text": "一個原因我問說當你在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3030.wav", + "text": "做稅式支出的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3031.wav", + "text": "黃董事長提到的你是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3032.wav", + "text": "不是為了單一企業而且是為了那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3033.wav", + "text": "單一企業做的我覺得這個你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3034.wav", + "text": "很可以回答你不需要去迴避說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3035.wav", + "text": "我是按照OECD" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3036.wav", + "text": "的什麼計算標準那個不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3037.wav", + "text": "拜託行政單位要針對問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3038.wav", + "text": "回答不要老是去改委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3039.wav", + "text": "你想要回答的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3040.wav", + "text": "想要回答的問題就去把委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3041.wav", + "text": "題目改變了那個不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3042.wav", + "text": "我們的問題你的稅式支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3043.wav", + "text": "是不是為了單一企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3044.wav", + "text": "或者是譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3045.wav", + "text": "你在講5G的部分我猜你在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3046.wav", + "text": "聯發科或者是相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3047.wav", + "text": "的你應該要講清楚說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3048.wav", + "text": "明白你今天的稅式支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3049.wav", + "text": "是不是為了特定企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3050.wav", + "text": "其實你很可以在第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3051.wav", + "text": "就解釋清楚然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3052.wav", + "text": "外資的部分如果真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3053.wav", + "text": "像黃董事長所提到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3054.wav", + "text": "訂做的話那麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3055.wav", + "text": "台積電的外資持股比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3056.wav", + "text": "是多少你為它享受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3057.wav", + "text": "的外資優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3058.wav", + "text": "因為你的稅式支出\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3059.wav", + "text": "知道嘛所以我要特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3060.wav", + "text": "發言到現在為止我還是不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3061.wav", + "text": "一定是跨國的嘛它怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3062.wav", + "text": "講半導體產業等一下我馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3063.wav", + "text": "我要行政單位回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3064.wav", + "text": "委員在主導的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3065.wav", + "text": "行政單位好對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3066.wav", + "text": "柯總召講的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3067.wav", + "text": "行政單位要買單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3068.wav", + "text": "我講的部分錯你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3069.wav", + "text": "可以挑戰我他們也可以挑戰我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3070.wav", + "text": "我講黃崇仁的故事給你聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3071.wav", + "text": "不是我不要聽黃崇仁的故事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3072.wav", + "text": "rank的名字就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3073.wav", + "text": "力晶半導體嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3074.wav", + "text": "我剛剛也講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3075.wav", + "text": "MorrisFrank" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3076.wav", + "text": "我講英文講是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3077.wav", + "text": "就是因為講出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3078.wav", + "text": "所以我們這些包括從semicon" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3079.wav", + "text": "到DRAM他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3080.wav", + "text": "這中間有很多產業故事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3081.wav", + "text": "不我不是要聽那個故事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3082.wav", + "text": "我現在的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3083.wav", + "text": "有一天他也會進入這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3084.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3085.wav", + "text": "民間的疑點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3086.wav", + "text": "很快地在第一時間就釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3087.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3088.wav", + "text": "不是依著黃崇仁提出的疑點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3089.wav", + "text": "我跟他私下討論也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3090.wav", + "text": "我瞭解力晶半導體整個成長的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3091.wav", + "text": "他曾經負債100多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3092.wav", + "text": "我也去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3093.wav", + "text": "半導體產業的起伏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3094.wav", + "text": "DRAMSRAM以及我們國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3095.wav", + "text": "現在到底是怎麼一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3096.wav", + "text": "全部跑到銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3097.wav", + "text": "全部倒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3098.wav", + "text": "TMC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3099.wav", + "text": "所以這有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3100.wav", + "text": "不同的時空背景及政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3101.wav", + "text": "要回答的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3102.wav", + "text": "有一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3103.wav", + "text": "來各位可以去想一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3104.wav", + "text": "方式假如對中小企業有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3105.wav", + "text": "好好從其他相關法可是沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3106.wav", + "text": "水沒電你又給它優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3107.wav", + "text": "稅率然後水優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3108.wav", + "text": "電又優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3109.wav", + "text": "你也知道現在問題越來越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3110.wav", + "text": "所以抗爭就越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3111.wav", + "text": "你又講到另外一個題目了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3112.wav", + "text": "水電的部分本來就是政府要處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3113.wav", + "text": "你現在講沒水沒電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3114.wav", + "text": "臺灣半導體產業不應該發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3115.wav", + "text": "先把它趕出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3116.wav", + "text": "我要回答李貴敏委員一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3117.wav", + "text": "不是說趕出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3118.wav", + "text": "現在是講租稅優惠的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3119.wav", + "text": "你卻講到總量管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3120.wav", + "text": "你說要留在境內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3121.wav", + "text": "過去我們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3122.wav", + "text": "N-1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3123.wav", + "text": "疑慮包括到大陸去有N-1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3124.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3125.wav", + "text": "聯電後來也到大陸設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3126.wav", + "text": "設廠都是N-1疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3127.wav", + "text": "不可能把我們最好的技術放出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3128.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3129.wav", + "text": "他剛才講的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3130.wav", + "text": "根留臺灣的問題就是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3131.wav", + "text": "接下來吳怡玎委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3132.wav", + "text": "還要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3133.wav", + "text": "講完我們就做決定好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3134.wav", + "text": "是要保留還是通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3135.wav", + "text": "我不知道柯總召聽得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3136.wav", + "text": "到嗎老實說我也支持這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3137.wav", + "text": "但是我只希望它能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3138.wav", + "text": "更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3139.wav", + "text": "不是壞的點名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3140.wav", + "text": "鈺創的董事長當時以AIonChip" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3141.wav", + "text": "聯盟會長的名義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3142.wav", + "text": "他說半導體去臺化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3143.wav", + "text": "確實是很多人關注的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3144.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3145.wav", + "text": "臺版晶片法案應擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3146.wav", + "text": "鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3147.wav", + "text": "創新能量並非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3148.wav", + "text": "聚焦提供大型製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3149.wav", + "text": "公司租稅減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3150.wav", + "text": "未來AI人工智慧發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3151.wav", + "text": "百花齊放是鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3152.wav", + "text": "年輕人投入新創及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3153.wav", + "text": "創業最好的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3154.wav", + "text": "臺灣如果能夠仿傚以色列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3155.wav", + "text": "鼓勵青創的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3156.wav", + "text": "將能延續半導體製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3157.wav", + "text": "的優勢為整體半導體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3158.wav", + "text": "產業帶來另一股強大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3159.wav", + "text": "創新的動能如此一來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3160.wav", + "text": "去臺化的問題也不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3161.wav", + "text": "存在\n之所以這樣子講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3162.wav", + "text": "其實很明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3163.wav", + "text": "業界也認為我們對於新創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3164.wav", + "text": "的鼓勵是不夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3165.wav", + "text": "就像是剛剛部長講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3166.wav", + "text": "我們對新創有後端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3167.wav", + "text": "的稅負減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3168.wav", + "text": "這非常有趣因為你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3169.wav", + "text": "投入了假設我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3170.wav", + "text": "公司自己內部研發的投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3171.wav", + "text": "就馬上可以抵減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3172.wav", + "text": "並不用等到它賺錢才來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3173.wav", + "text": "抵減但是如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3174.wav", + "text": "投資外面的新創你必須要等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3175.wav", + "text": "到它賺錢才來抵減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3176.wav", + "text": "或者是你的投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3177.wav", + "text": "有損失了才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3178.wav", + "text": "來抵減但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3179.wav", + "text": "公司內部的投資就不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3180.wav", + "text": "這樣子再來談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3181.wav", + "text": "政府的獎勵跟扶植" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3182.wav", + "text": "有關政府的獎勵扶助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3183.wav", + "text": "我們要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3184.wav", + "text": "才知道整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3185.wav", + "text": "業界要的是什麼市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3186.wav", + "text": "是什麼我們希望整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3187.wav", + "text": "是市場導向而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3188.wav", + "text": "大政府導向所以如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3189.wav", + "text": "能夠把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3190.wav", + "text": "租稅減免當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3191.wav", + "text": "做是政府的工具但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3192.wav", + "text": "透過這些已經是市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3193.wav", + "text": "的龍頭來做投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3194.wav", + "text": "我想這會是更好的謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3195.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3196.wav", + "text": "你講的是盧董事長的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3197.wav", + "text": "他的話裡面包括很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3198.wav", + "text": "我先問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3199.wav", + "text": "就通過好不好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3200.wav", + "text": "就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3201.wav", + "text": "這個案通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3202.wav", + "text": "我先唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3203.wav", + "text": "大家要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3204.wav", + "text": "唸協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3205.wav", + "text": "一增訂第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3206.wav", + "text": "之2條文照協商條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3207.wav", + "text": "\n二第72條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3208.wav", + "text": "條文照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3209.wav", + "text": "附帶決議7項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3210.wav", + "text": "這樣有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3211.wav", + "text": "有有新的就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3212.wav", + "text": "一併處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3213.wav", + "text": "要放進去才要簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3214.wav", + "text": "我們就一起放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3215.wav", + "text": "看你們如果可以通過就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3216.wav", + "text": "沒有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3217.wav", + "text": "總召先簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3218.wav", + "text": "總召不用給總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3219.wav", + "text": "這張給你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3220.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3221.wav", + "text": "這附帶決議沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3222.wav", + "text": "邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3223.wav", + "text": "我們都是老立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3224.wav", + "text": "朝野協商講法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3225.wav", + "text": "沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3226.wav", + "text": "這個附帶決議一定要過才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3227.wav", + "text": "就簽下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3228.wav", + "text": "寫得更完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3229.wav", + "text": "可以我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3230.wav", + "text": "我講的話你們應該聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3231.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3232.wav", + "text": "了我就可以宣布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3233.wav", + "text": "休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3234.wav", + "text": "休息30分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3235.wav", + "text": "請大家用餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3236.wav", + "text": "現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3237.wav", + "text": "5時54分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3238.wav", + "text": "時繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3239.wav", + "text": "中華民國刑法部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3240.wav", + "text": "列席的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3241.wav", + "text": "各部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3242.wav", + "text": "法務部部長蔡清祥先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3243.wav", + "text": "關於中華民國刑法部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3244.wav", + "text": "我們就從第10條開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3245.wav", + "text": "委員會已經通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3246.wav", + "text": "處理第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3247.wav", + "text": "\n第10條大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3248.wav", + "text": "沒有意見我們就按照行政院版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3249.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3250.wav", + "text": "\n請看第91條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3251.wav", + "text": "第10條的部分之前有疑義的應該是在性隱私的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3252.wav", + "text": "你現在要講哪一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3253.wav", + "text": "第10條我剛剛有舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3254.wav", + "text": "已經宣布通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3255.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有舉手啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3256.wav", + "text": "其實就有談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3257.wav", + "text": "因為目前仍然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3258.wav", + "text": "性慾這件事情其實是非常的主觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3259.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法客觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3260.wav", + "text": "所以如果用客觀上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3261.wav", + "text": "足以引起性慾或羞恥的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3262.wav", + "text": "就會是一個衝突的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3263.wav", + "text": "所以時代力量黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3264.wav", + "text": "是希望能夠用相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3265.wav", + "text": "還有污名化的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3266.wav", + "text": "因為這些人其實是被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3267.wav", + "text": "我們如果認為被害人會引起羞恥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3268.wav", + "text": "所以針對第10條部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3269.wav", + "text": "我們還是希望能夠討論和保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3270.wav", + "text": "請司法院回答好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3271.wav", + "text": "大法官有解釋過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3272.wav", + "text": "這是大法官的用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3273.wav", + "text": "就是指客觀上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3274.wav", + "text": "足以引起別人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3275.wav", + "text": "應該是就猥褻的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3276.wav", + "text": "不是就性私密的定義吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3277.wav", + "text": "已經跟不上時代對於性的定義了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3278.wav", + "text": "當時是對猥褻的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3279.wav", + "text": "不是針對性私密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3280.wav", + "text": "在委員會討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3281.wav", + "text": "問題就是在第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3282.wav", + "text": "前三款大概都符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3283.wav", + "text": "一般所認定的具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3284.wav", + "text": "是以性器官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3285.wav", + "text": "或是跟性交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3286.wav", + "text": "有關性交行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3287.wav", + "text": "在前面也有定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3288.wav", + "text": "就是把大法官對猥褻的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3289.wav", + "text": "那時候為什麼會把這個寫進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3290.wav", + "text": "據我瞭解是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3291.wav", + "text": "這個定義的條文後面會連結到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3292.wav", + "text": "接下來我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3293.wav", + "text": "繼續協商審��的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3294.wav", + "text": "原來在這兩個法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3295.wav", + "text": "的下架機制就是有使用猥褻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3296.wav", + "text": "我們這邊在定義性影像的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3297.wav", + "text": "其定義就不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3298.wav", + "text": "只有單純跟性器官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3299.wav", + "text": "性交有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3300.wav", + "text": "而必須要含括到原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3301.wav", + "text": "在那兩個法裡面也有包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3302.wav", + "text": "的猥褻影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3303.wav", + "text": "我們當然也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3304.wav", + "text": "長期以來確實是一個很困難定義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3305.wav", + "text": "概念不管在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3306.wav", + "text": "比較上法或是我國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3307.wav", + "text": "歷來的法學上面都是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3308.wav", + "text": "很困難的用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3309.wav", + "text": "雖然困難但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3310.wav", + "text": "因為這個概念已經很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3311.wav", + "text": "所以實務上還是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3312.wav", + "text": "相對穩定的見解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3313.wav", + "text": "可以來做參照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3314.wav", + "text": "所以你要完全認為它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3315.wav", + "text": "就是違反法律明確性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3316.wav", + "text": "原則可能在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3317.wav", + "text": "實務執行上我們已經用了這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3318.wav", + "text": "或許不是真的那麼不明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3319.wav", + "text": "\n另外一點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3320.wav", + "text": "我們也擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3321.wav", + "text": "如果把第4款拿掉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3322.wav", + "text": "會不會產生一些我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3323.wav", + "text": "應該要保障的性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3324.wav", + "text": "的情形譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3325.wav", + "text": "被拿來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3326.wav", + "text": "而讓被害人覺得很不舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3327.wav", + "text": "的這些影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3328.wav", + "text": "也可能不是百分之百都直接裸露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3329.wav", + "text": "性器官或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3330.wav", + "text": "特定的姿勢或是穿得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3331.wav", + "text": "像這一類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3332.wav", + "text": "概念如果我們只保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3333.wav", + "text": "這個定義的前三款的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3334.wav", + "text": "我們要連結到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3335.wav", + "text": "四法聯防所想要的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3336.wav", + "text": "有效地去阻止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3337.wav", + "text": "這些讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3338.wav", + "text": "飽受不快跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3339.wav", + "text": "取回或者是刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3340.wav", + "text": "發生被散布的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3341.wav", + "text": "行為人繩之以法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3342.wav", + "text": "如果我們在定義上把這一款直接拿掉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3343.wav", + "text": "會不會造成一些漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3344.wav", + "text": "反而讓一些性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3345.wav", + "text": "我們想要保護被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3346.wav", + "text": "的部分變得比較窄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3347.wav", + "text": "所以我們在幾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3348.wav", + "text": "考慮思量之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3349.wav", + "text": "覺得雖然有一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3350.wav", + "text": "明確性的問題但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3351.wav", + "text": "為了要更完整地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3352.wav", + "text": "來保護相關的法益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3353.wav", + "text": "在實務上對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3354.wav", + "text": "文字其實是有實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3355.wav", + "text": "案例長期穩定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3356.wav", + "text": "見解及可茲參考的前提下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3357.wav", + "text": "我建議保留這一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3358.wav", + "text": "這是我的看法謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3359.wav", + "text": "款保留因為我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3360.wav", + "text": "委員會中有討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3361.wav", + "text": "因為或羞恥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3362.wav", + "text": "是一個傳統猥褻的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3363.wav", + "text": "可是很多婦女會覺得那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3364.wav", + "text": "或羞恥的部分反而讓女性感覺到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3365.wav", + "text": "更羞恥所以如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3366.wav", + "text": "保留原來其他的文字只拿掉或羞恥的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3367.wav", + "text": "用一些比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3368.wav", + "text": "新興的覺得尊重女性跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3369.wav", + "text": "性慾或是相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3370.wav", + "text": "文字而不要再用傳統的或羞恥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3371.wav", + "text": "這個文字來提它我是提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3372.wav", + "text": "這個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3373.wav", + "text": "是建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3374.wav", + "text": "司法院和法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3375.wav", + "text": "來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3376.wav", + "text": "我們也贊同司法院的見解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3377.wav", + "text": "因為這是大法官會議解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3378.wav", + "text": "的文字所以我們是按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3379.wav", + "text": "這個文字來訂定因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3380.wav", + "text": "實務上會有一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3381.wav", + "text": "個案的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3382.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議還是留著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3383.wav", + "text": "解釋的用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3384.wav", + "text": "\n請王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3385.wav", + "text": "不是啦剛才其實很清楚大法官解釋的是猥褻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3386.wav", + "text": "我其實可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3387.wav", + "text": "認同剛才黃世杰委員的說法就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3388.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的情況下我其實是可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3389.wav", + "text": "\n三個字就好了其他定義不變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3390.wav", + "text": "因為或羞恥這些字還是在譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3391.wav", + "text": "黃委員是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3392.wav", + "text": "不拿掉我來講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3393.wav", + "text": "其實這個是中文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3394.wav", + "text": "語意與法律用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3395.wav", + "text": "的概念之間有點落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3396.wav", + "text": "這邊所謂的羞恥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3397.wav", + "text": "不是指被害人本身很羞恥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3398.wav", + "text": "而是指那個照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3399.wav", + "text": "的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3400.wav", + "text": "因為這是過去傳統對猥褻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3401.wav", + "text": "就包含這個定義如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3402.wav", + "text": "只用性慾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3403.wav", + "text": "來定義的話會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3404.wav", + "text": "長期穩定的見解是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3405.wav", + "text": "這二個要件都寫在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3406.wav", + "text": "因為它是或也不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3407.wav", + "text": "並不是同時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3408.wav", + "text": "所以如果你把它拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3409.wav", + "text": "會不會造成改變現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3410.wav", + "text": "實務上認定這個範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3411.wav", + "text": "的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3412.wav", + "text": "這部分我覺得實務機關要好好做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3413.wav", + "text": "我們才可以把它拿掉如果會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3414.wav", + "text": "的話一樣會造成保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3415.wav", + "text": "我們就照行政院跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3416.wav", + "text": "司法院會銜的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3417.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3418.wav", + "text": "是非常落後和非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3419.wav", + "text": "不夠進步非常以譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3420.wav", + "text": "往前一步但我們在這條仍然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3421.wav", + "text": "覺得沒有辦法好好地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3422.wav", + "text": "還是會對性影像的內容有所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3423.wav", + "text": "偏頗或者是有所污名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3424.wav", + "text": "院長我提具體建議好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3425.wav", + "text": "我們很理解最前端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3426.wav", + "text": "個都很有意見但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3427.wav", + "text": "我擔心的是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3428.wav", + "text": "的想法都跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3429.wav", + "text": "所以我念茲在茲我不是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3430.wav", + "text": "談論這個理論的正確性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3431.wav", + "text": "我所擔心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3432.wav", + "text": "我們改動文字之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3433.wav", + "text": "會不會讓長期穩定的司法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3434.wav", + "text": "見解有變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3435.wav", + "text": "這一條讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3436.wav", + "text": "主管機關法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3437.wav", + "text": "研究一下有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3438.wav", + "text": "這個疑慮如果沒有我們可以考慮把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3439.wav", + "text": "拿掉好不好讓你們研究一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3440.wav", + "text": "實務見解到底會不會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3441.wav", + "text": "總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3442.wav", + "text": "我知道大家對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3443.wav", + "text": "這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3444.wav", + "text": "會有一些不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3445.wav", + "text": "看法和見解但我的立場是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3446.wav", + "text": "用詞的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3447.wav", + "text": "這裡所謂客觀上足以引起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3448.wav", + "text": "並不是只有指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3449.wav", + "text": "被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3450.wav", + "text": "對被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3451.wav", + "text": "客觀上引起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3452.wav", + "text": "所以王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3453.wav", + "text": "從這個角度再去思考的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3454.wav", + "text": "這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3455.wav", + "text": "好我們照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3456.wav", + "text": "行政院跟司法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3457.wav", + "text": "版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3458.wav", + "text": "暫時這樣剛才已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3459.wav", + "text": "我就說我沒有要同意今" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3460.wav", + "text": "要協商嗎如果大家各自堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3461.wav", + "text": "己見的話我還是建議就是保留送表決好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3462.wav", + "text": "這裡一直都是在有這樣的爭議的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3463.wav", + "text": "如果我們沒有要好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3464.wav", + "text": "那就不要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3465.wav", + "text": "因為的確就是有爭議而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3466.wav", + "text": "一直以來都是有這樣的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3467.wav", + "text": "等同於猥褻其實就是有模糊的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3468.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這個才是必須審視的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3469.wav", + "text": "先保留再講好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3470.wav", + "text": "第10條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3471.wav", + "text": "\n請看第91條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3472.wav", + "text": "法務部有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3473.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3474.wav", + "text": "也有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3475.wav", + "text": "按法務部修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3476.wav", + "text": "通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3477.wav", + "text": "數位性暴力四法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3478.wav", + "text": "主要除了今天我們討論的刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3479.wav", + "text": "之外其實還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3480.wav", + "text": "透過跨部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3481.wav", + "text": "聯防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3482.wav", + "text": "所以主要還是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3483.wav", + "text": "事前完備相關法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3484.wav", + "text": "嚇阻目前新型態的犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3485.wav", + "text": "完整保護被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3486.wav", + "text": "在遭遇不幸之後能夠透過完善的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3487.wav", + "text": "制度取得主導權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3488.wav", + "text": "不再受到威脅需要透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3489.wav", + "text": "司法建立強調尊嚴跟同理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3490.wav", + "text": "保護制度明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3491.wav", + "text": "犯罪被害人受相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3492.wav", + "text": "保護服務經濟補助等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3493.wav", + "text": "並透過公私合力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3494.wav", + "text": "來協助深化服務的規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3495.wav", + "text": "文字上的定義問題我們雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3496.wav", + "text": "認為刑法第10條應該將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3497.wav", + "text": "引起羞恥等主觀判定的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3498.wav", + "text": "刪除但在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3499.wav", + "text": "我們還是尊重主管機關的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3500.wav", + "text": "\n回到我們今天談到的第9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3501.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團提出相關修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3502.wav", + "text": "主要是要設立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3503.wav", + "text": "對於停止強制治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3504.wav", + "text": "加害人的行為監督機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3505.wav", + "text": "將停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3506.wav", + "text": "強制治療期間的加害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3507.wav", + "text": "付保護管束以示周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3508.wav", + "text": "藉由這樣的條文內容期望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3509.wav", + "text": "將社會安全網的不足之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3510.wav", + "text": "更加完善地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3511.wav", + "text": "各黨團可以支持我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3512.wav", + "text": "修正動議以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3513.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員提供的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3514.wav", + "text": "不過付保護管束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3515.wav", + "text": "假釋或緩刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3516.wav", + "text": "而這已經是刑後強制治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3517.wav", + "text": "表示已經沒有刑的存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3518.wav", + "text": "所以不能再由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3519.wav", + "text": "現有體制是不合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3520.wav", + "text": "因此還是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3521.wav", + "text": "接往社區處遇方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3522.wav", + "text": "這個在性防法已經有相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3523.wav", + "text": "可以接續得上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3524.wav", + "text": "的意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3525.wav", + "text": "跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3526.wav", + "text": "各位委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3527.wav", + "text": "因為是刑後強制治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3528.wav", + "text": "就停止停止之後就是回到社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3529.wav", + "text": "協商時有提出一個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3530.wav", + "text": "動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3531.wav", + "text": "其中第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3532.wav", + "text": "就有增加或刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3533.wav", + "text": "第91條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3534.wav", + "text": "第2項但書規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3535.wav", + "text": "裁定停止強制治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3536.wav", + "text": "後回到社區要繼續接受社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3537.wav", + "text": "所以我們已經把它銜接到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3538.wav", + "text": "社區治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3539.wav", + "text": "1就照法務部建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3540.wav", + "text": "修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3541.wav", + "text": "這邊的資料有點混亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3542.wav", + "text": "主要是因為我們在委員會審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3543.wav", + "text": "是上個會期的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3544.wav", + "text": "事實上在這二三年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3545.wav", + "text": "都非常熱門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3546.wav", + "text": "所以累積了很多委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3547.wav", + "text": "各種不同的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3548.wav", + "text": "他們把相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3549.wav", + "text": "放在刑法不同的章節裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3550.wav", + "text": "所以條號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3551.wav", + "text": "有點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3552.wav", + "text": "但其實內容大部分是大同小異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3553.wav", + "text": "可是我想經過這兩年的討論後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3554.wav", + "text": "大家應該會有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3555.wav", + "text": "了大部分委員提案的實際內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3556.wav", + "text": "大家同不同意而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3557.wav", + "text": "文上唯一有比較多出入的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3558.wav", + "text": "大概就是關於非關性影像的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3559.wav", + "text": "深偽部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3560.wav", + "text": "這個部分要不要在這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3561.wav", + "text": "和四法聯防的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3562.wav", + "text": "一起綁定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3563.wav", + "text": "我想這個大家可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3564.wav", + "text": "接下來的審查就直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3565.wav", + "text": "主大家覺得院版的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3566.wav", + "text": "可以把各委員或黨團的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3567.wav", + "text": "這樣效率會好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3568.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3569.wav", + "text": "如果看這一本的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3570.wav", + "text": "第十五章之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3571.wav", + "text": "增訂的第三百十九條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3572.wav", + "text": "就照行政院跟司法院提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3573.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3574.wav", + "text": "有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3575.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3576.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見我們依照法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3577.wav", + "text": "建議條文通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3578.wav", + "text": "16頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3579.wav", + "text": "院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3580.wav", + "text": "百十九條之2只是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3581.wav", + "text": "在第16頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3582.wav", + "text": "大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3583.wav", + "text": "事實上法務部的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3584.wav", + "text": "請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3585.wav", + "text": "法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3586.wav", + "text": "院版是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3587.wav", + "text": "以他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3588.wav", + "text": "法供他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3589.wav", + "text": "觀覽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3590.wav", + "text": "而犯第一項之罪者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3591.wav", + "text": "刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3592.wav", + "text": "是差在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3593.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3594.wav", + "text": "供人觀覽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3595.wav", + "text": "就是指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3596.wav", + "text": "如果沒有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3597.wav", + "text": "我們是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3598.wav", + "text": "是不是可以說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3599.wav", + "text": "是以強暴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3600.wav", + "text": "脅迫恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3601.wav", + "text": "而言都一樣是被拍攝了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3602.wav", + "text": "下更為嚴重嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3603.wav", + "text": "不論是否使用暴力的方式被拍攝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3604.wav", + "text": "其實都一樣地嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3605.wav", + "text": "都是違反其意願的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3606.wav", + "text": "不管在怎樣的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3607.wav", + "text": "\n在我們的版本中比較希望第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3608.wav", + "text": "還要再區分他是否被迫或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3609.wav", + "text": "或是未經同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3610.wav", + "text": "也就是在不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3611.wav", + "text": "如果在未經積極同意的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3612.wav", + "text": "一旦被拍攝且有散布播送的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3613.wav", + "text": "就應該同樣地嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3614.wav", + "text": "立法例的部分是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3615.wav", + "text": "只要未經同意應該都是不被允許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3616.wav", + "text": "這邊也是想請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3617.wav", + "text": "因為原本我是希望將恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3618.wav", + "text": "性影像的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3619.wav", + "text": "放在刑法第三百十九條之1之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3620.wav", + "text": "二之三的後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3621.wav", + "text": "現在看起來你們不希望放在這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3622.wav", + "text": "裡而是放在犯保法及性防法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3623.wav", + "text": "我們擔心的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3624.wav", + "text": "就是原本放在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3625.wav", + "text": "二分之一而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3626.wav", + "text": "因為不需要散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3627.wav", + "text": "布只要是恐嚇本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3628.wav", + "text": "就可以讓受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3629.wav", + "text": "去做一些原本不想做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3630.wav", + "text": "我希望這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3631.wav", + "text": "如果不放在刑法裡的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3632.wav", + "text": "我們要如何確保這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3633.wav", + "text": "可不可以回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3634.wav", + "text": "二的差別在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3635.wav", + "text": "之一的差別是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3636.wav", + "text": "指他是用偷拍的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3637.wav", + "text": "之二的話是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3638.wav", + "text": "強拍的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3639.wav", + "text": "違反其個人意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3640.wav", + "text": "沒有經過同意而無故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3641.wav", + "text": "用偷拍的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3642.wav", + "text": "這兩個還是有一個程度的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3643.wav", + "text": "因此我們就分別訂定出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3644.wav", + "text": "不同的刑責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3645.wav", + "text": "\n如果這兩種行為他是有意圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3646.wav", + "text": "其他的散播方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3647.wav", + "text": "我們仍然有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3648.wav", + "text": "不同的處罰規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3649.wav", + "text": "來做區別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3650.wav", + "text": "這是第一個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3651.wav", + "text": "我們刑法裡面也有各種不同的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3652.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3653.wav", + "text": "單純的恐怖也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3654.wav", + "text": "包括用強制脅迫恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3655.wav", + "text": "還有恐嚇取財" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3656.wav", + "text": "在刑法的體例上都已經有分別的規定在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3657.wav", + "text": "��沒有必要在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3658.wav", + "text": "再重新訂定一個恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3659.wav", + "text": "就是散播性影像的一個特別規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3660.wav", + "text": "呢這兩個作以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3661.wav", + "text": "照法務部建議條文通過可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3662.wav", + "text": "就是站在我們的立場上偷拍跟強拍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3663.wav", + "text": "還是不同的狀態嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3664.wav", + "text": "嘛對於被害人來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3665.wav", + "text": "不論是偷拍或強拍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3666.wav", + "text": "一旦這樣的東西被散布了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3667.wav", + "text": "其實是一樣嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3668.wav", + "text": "並用嚴重的態度來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3669.wav", + "text": "我覺得不論是偷拍或強拍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3670.wav", + "text": "或是被圖利者的角度來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3671.wav", + "text": "其實都是一樣的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3672.wav", + "text": "都是嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3673.wav", + "text": "但是嚴重的程度還是有區別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3674.wav", + "text": "我們的區別就是用不同的刑度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3675.wav", + "text": "也許大家會比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3676.wav", + "text": "且容易接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3677.wav", + "text": "我本來是要回答范雲委員的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3678.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3679.wav", + "text": "其實刑法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3680.wav", + "text": "有沒有強暴脅迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3681.wav", + "text": "如果你有強暴威脅或恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3682.wav", + "text": "竊盜與強盜就不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3683.wav", + "text": "我們是行為刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3684.wav", + "text": "不是行為結果刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3685.wav", + "text": "強盜跟竊盜就一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3686.wav", + "text": "了都是我的東西被拿走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3687.wav", + "text": "了但是侵害的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3688.wav", + "text": "罪質是不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3689.wav", + "text": "我們在討論刑法保護法益時當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3690.wav", + "text": "然有強暴脅迫行為跟沒有的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3691.wav", + "text": "其所侵害的法益是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3692.wav", + "text": "即侵害了更多的法益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3693.wav", + "text": "所以我們在刑度上會增加上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3694.wav", + "text": "等於去抹殺了這個區別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3695.wav", + "text": "反而刑度會往下降我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3696.wav", + "text": "我是這樣建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3697.wav", + "text": "\n我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3698.wav", + "text": "因為我們在委員會討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3699.wav", + "text": "因為有連動性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3700.wav", + "text": "即我們現在刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3701.wav", + "text": "修的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3702.wav", + "text": "第一個是違反意願拍攝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3703.wav", + "text": "不管是偷拍或強拍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3704.wav", + "text": "第二個是違反意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3705.wav", + "text": "散布出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3706.wav", + "text": "這是等一下要講的第三百十九條之3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3707.wav", + "text": "及後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3708.wav", + "text": "但是實務上有一種情形好像被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3709.wav", + "text": "漏掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3710.wav", + "text": "也就是我沒有違反意願拍攝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3711.wav", + "text": "有可能我們本來是男女朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3712.wav", + "text": "有親密關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3713.wav", + "text": "所以對方擁有我的性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3714.wav", + "text": "他擁有我的性影像是合法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3715.wav", + "text": "以前是經過我同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3716.wav", + "text": "關係生變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3717.wav", + "text": "對方拿這些影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3718.wav", + "text": "來對我威脅恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3719.wav", + "text": "不管是要求我做一些我不願意做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3720.wav", + "text": "或者是單純的恐嚇我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3721.wav", + "text": "傷害我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3722.wav", + "text": "包括恐嚇危安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3723.wav", + "text": "這些類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3724.wav", + "text": "而言因為他還沒有實際去散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3725.wav", + "text": "所以可能還沒有該當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3726.wav", + "text": "而是單純的該當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3727.wav", + "text": "強制罪恐嚇危安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3728.wav", + "text": "或是恐嚇取財在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3729.wav", + "text": "這種情形下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3730.wav", + "text": "因為四法聯防連動到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3731.wav", + "text": "性侵害犯罪防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3732.wav", + "text": "及犯罪被害人保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3733.wav", + "text": "下的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3734.wav", + "text": "與保護令都是跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3735.wav", + "text": "這一章的罪名有關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3736.wav", + "text": "所以很多民團提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3737.wav", + "text": "是不是應該在這邊把那些行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3738.wav", + "text": "但是那樣子會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3739.wav", + "text": "違反刑法的論理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3740.wav", + "text": "理剛剛我們為什麼要去斤斤計較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3741.wav", + "text": "到底法益侵害多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3742.wav", + "text": "這是有一個比例原則在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3743.wav", + "text": "我們如果去破壞這個衡平的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3744.wav", + "text": "其實會引起很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3745.wav", + "text": "未來在釋憲的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3746.wav", + "text": "也不一定能夠通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3747.wav", + "text": "等一下處理那兩個機制的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3748.wav", + "text": "不管是在犯保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3749.wav", + "text": "法或性侵害犯罪防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3750.wav", + "text": "當中都有把剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3751.wav", + "text": "范委員所提到的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3752.wav", + "text": "介接到那一些防治的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3753.wav", + "text": "性影像還沒有被散布出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3754.wav", + "text": "但是當他被威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3755.wav", + "text": "恐嚇的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3756.wav", + "text": "一樣可以啟動保護令的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3757.wav", + "text": "和下架的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3758.wav", + "text": "我們會在相關的法令中處理它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3759.wav", + "text": "而不是在刑法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3760.wav", + "text": "多定一個罪名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3761.wav", + "text": "這是我們目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3762.wav", + "text": "想到比較好的解決方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3763.wav", + "text": "范委員剛剛所講的那個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3764.wav", + "text": "我們會在另外兩個法當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3765.wav", + "text": "中加以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3766.wav", + "text": "為了處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3767.wav", + "text": "而個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3768.wav", + "text": "個別加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3769.wav", + "text": "在比例上會有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3770.wav", + "text": "裡面也有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3771.wav", + "text": "現在把它拿出來一起看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3772.wav", + "text": "還有性侵害犯罪防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3773.wav", + "text": "這樣就能迎刃而解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3774.wav", + "text": "後面處理起來就會很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3775.wav", + "text": "都有關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3776.wav", + "text": "現在就把它拿出來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3777.wav", + "text": "那本案呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3778.wav", + "text": "你是建議現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3779.wav", + "text": "就看還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3780.wav", + "text": "十九條之2已經涵蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3781.wav", + "text": "會亂掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3782.wav", + "text": "一起看才會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3783.wav", + "text": "就一起看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3784.wav", + "text": "要叫誰拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3785.wav", + "text": "那是不同委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3786.wav", + "text": "是衛福部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3787.wav", + "text": "我看這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3788.wav", + "text": "另外再找時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3789.wav", + "text": "核對不然的話現在就停在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3790.wav", + "text": "先發下來讓大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3791.wav", + "text": "如果大家覺得OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3792.wav", + "text": "就讓它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3793.wav", + "text": "讓大家瞄一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3794.wav", + "text": "先讓這部分走過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3795.wav", + "text": "我們都有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3796.wav", + "text": "了等一下你看一下第35條就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3797.wav", + "text": "這是完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3798.wav", + "text": "剛剛這一條大家顧慮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3799.wav", + "text": "不能介接一些保護的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3800.wav", + "text": "其實我們已經考慮到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3801.wav", + "text": "如果不把它放在刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3802.wav", + "text": "也會放在性侵害犯罪防治法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3803.wav", + "text": "第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3804.wav", + "text": "就有準用保護措施的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3805.wav", + "text": "所以應該很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3806.wav", + "text": "第二個在犯保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3807.wav", + "text": "第35條我們也會用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3808.wav", + "text": "羈押替代處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3809.wav", + "text": "來做一些相關的行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3810.wav", + "text": "保護措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3811.wav", + "text": "讓這一條能夠很容易地通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3812.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員你有沒有看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3813.wav", + "text": "了是不是讓它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3814.wav", + "text": "還有一份犯保法第35條可不可以也發一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3815.wav", + "text": "再來是相對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3816.wav", + "text": "我們有拿到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3817.wav", + "text": "然後犯保法第35條是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3818.wav", + "text": "也可以確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3819.wav", + "text": "已經圍阻沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3820.wav", + "text": "了你不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3821.wav", + "text": "所以他們擔心的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3822.wav", + "text": "你看原先那一條就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3823.wav", + "text": "所以這整個是有關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3824.wav", + "text": "的可以關鍵性地連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3825.wav", + "text": "還要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3826.wav", + "text": "是報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3827.wav", + "text": "現在是犯保法的部分也一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3828.wav", + "text": "來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3829.wav", + "text": "我們有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3830.wav", + "text": "這樣我要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3831.wav", + "text": "現在還沒討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3832.wav", + "text": "這一條先通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3833.wav", + "text": "這一條先通過再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3834.wav", + "text": "大家都有看了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3835.wav", + "text": "犯罪防治法修正第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3836.wav", + "text": "最下面新加的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3837.wav", + "text": "中間為什麼漏掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3838.wav", + "text": "第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3839.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3840.wav", + "text": "為什麼在第三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3841.wav", + "text": "沒有是因為第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3842.wav", + "text": "的保護是指影像已經上傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3843.wav", + "text": "到網路我們要把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3844.wav", + "text": "移除下架可以它這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3845.wav", + "text": "只是在恐嚇階段所以它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3846.wav", + "text": "沒有出現把影像上架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3847.wav", + "text": "可是它潛在地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3848.wav", + "text": "也可能被上架加上去不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3849.wav", + "text": "那是用前項第2項去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3850.wav", + "text": "它已經在上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3851.wav", + "text": "這樣可以瞭解了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3852.wav", + "text": "大家還有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3853.wav", + "text": "王委員這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3854.wav", + "text": "我還是想表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3855.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們在談這些性私密時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3856.wav", + "text": "還是一樣會在Yesmeansyes" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3857.wav", + "text": "的情況之下就是一定要經過他同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3858.wav", + "text": "所以未經同意其實都是一樣嚴重的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3859.wav", + "text": "我們還是希望用第三百十九條之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3860.wav", + "text": "不是特別用立法來做區別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3861.wav", + "text": "但是我也是可以接受暫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3862.wav", + "text": "暫時先用不同的樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3863.wav", + "text": "因為對於普遍社會大眾來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3864.wav", + "text": "可能還是會認為偷拍跟強拍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3865.wav", + "text": "大家在思考這個法案時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3866.wav", + "text": "就照法務部修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3867.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3868.wav", + "text": "法制局有提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3869.wav", + "text": "少一個元字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3870.wav", + "text": "之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3871.wav", + "text": "這個沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3872.wav", + "text": "了有一個元字漏掉把它補上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3873.wav", + "text": "我這邊想要說明並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3874.wav", + "text": "並請各位審酌一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3875.wav", + "text": "在時代力量版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3876.wav", + "text": "未經他人同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3877.wav", + "text": "無故持有保存其私密之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3878.wav", + "text": "這個在於當他持有這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3879.wav", + "text": "照片雖然他還沒有散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3880.wav", + "text": "布還沒有交付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3881.wav", + "text": "但是他已經有這樣的意圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3882.wav", + "text": "出現之情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3883.wav", + "text": "其實就是已經有意圖要犯前項之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3884.wav", + "text": "意圖要去散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3885.wav", + "text": "長期都會被這些事情所束縛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3886.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是希望能在第三百十九條之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3887.wav", + "text": "3的涵蓋範圍是比較寬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3888.wav", + "text": "包含意圖犯罪者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3889.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3890.wav", + "text": "即意圖犯罪而且是未經同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3891.wav", + "text": "以及無故持有或保存影像的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3892.wav", + "text": "部分應該要涵蓋進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3893.wav", + "text": "我希望大家思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3894.wav", + "text": "不同的犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3895.wav", + "text": "類比和犯罪樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3896.wav", + "text": "意圖散布我覺得對於當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3897.wav", + "text": "來說其實都是非常沉重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3898.wav", + "text": "現在我們在修這個法案也就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3899.wav", + "text": "能涵蓋到這些範圍你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3900.wav", + "text": "你的在大本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3901.wav", + "text": "回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3902.wav", + "text": "我們的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3903.wav", + "text": "沒有把持有納進來但是如果他持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3904.wav", + "text": "並有意圖要散布的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3905.wav", + "text": "我們在實務上也許可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3906.wav", + "text": "和條文來加以處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3907.wav", + "text": "他有這個意圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3908.wav", + "text": "已經做了散布這還是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3909.wav", + "text": "程度上的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3910.wav", + "text": "如果他真的有這個意圖要散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3911.wav", + "text": "是持有中還沒有散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3912.wav", + "text": "我們可以用未遂來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3913.wav", + "text": "王委員能不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3914.wav", + "text": "照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3915.wav", + "text": "和司法院的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3916.wav", + "text": "要如何定義所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3917.wav", + "text": "著手散布之類的部分要如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3918.wav", + "text": "處理因為現實上我們會看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3919.wav", + "text": "意圖散布著手散布或完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3920.wav", + "text": "散布其實很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3921.wav", + "text": "有一個客觀的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3922.wav", + "text": "所以想請教在實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3923.wav", + "text": "如何來做區別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3924.wav", + "text": "若單純持有我們很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3925.wav", + "text": "認定他將來要做什麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3926.wav", + "text": "如果能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3927.wav", + "text": "認定他是有意圖要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3928.wav", + "text": "我們就有相關的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3929.wav", + "text": "他如果還沒有著手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3930.wav", + "text": "還沒有實施他有這個意圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3931.wav", + "text": "我們還是可以用未遂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3932.wav", + "text": "去認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3933.wav", + "text": "好王委員要繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3934.wav", + "text": "先回應一下柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3935.wav", + "text": "我們的版本是在大本第16頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3936.wav", + "text": "時代力量提案是第三百十九條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3937.wav", + "text": "第二項對應到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3938.wav", + "text": "三我們是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3939.wav", + "text": "意圖散布和著手散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3940.wav", + "text": "有實務的空間去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3941.wav", + "text": "什麼情況下會被認為是意圖散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3942.wav", + "text": "做個說明或者實務上有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3943.wav", + "text": "過這樣的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3944.wav", + "text": "大概什麼情況會落入意圖散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3945.wav", + "text": "著手散布在刑法處理個案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3946.wav", + "text": "我們可以很明確地認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3947.wav", + "text": "他已經有行為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3948.wav", + "text": "這都要留待個案上去做認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3949.wav", + "text": "現在在法條上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3950.wav", + "text": "分辨可能比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3951.wav", + "text": "困難一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3952.wav", + "text": "行政院和司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3953.wav", + "text": "版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3954.wav", + "text": "條之4大家有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3955.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3956.wav", + "text": "我我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3957.wav", + "text": "更加解釋所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3958.wav", + "text": "前條性影像之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3959.wav", + "text": "包括剛才范雲委員也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3960.wav", + "text": "如果把恐嚇散布的狀況也放進立法理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3961.wav", + "text": "是不是會更加完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3962.wav", + "text": "5是指罪已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3963.wav", + "text": "犯罪物品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3964.wav", + "text": "恐嚇罪去處罰當然恐嚇罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3965.wav", + "text": "那邊就可以做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3966.wav", + "text": "不要在這邊又特別針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3967.wav", + "text": "恐嚇的部分納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3968.wav", + "text": "這完全是沒收的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3969.wav", + "text": "罪有構成才會有後續的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3970.wav", + "text": "和在這邊的用意其實是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3971.wav", + "text": "一直想要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3972.wav", + "text": "性私密影像恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3973.wav", + "text": "威脅他人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3974.wav", + "text": "樣態包含到這裡面來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3975.wav", + "text": "這也是其中一個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3976.wav", + "text": "持有這個性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3977.wav", + "text": "雖然不知道真的假的總之你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3978.wav", + "text": "已經有威脅恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3979.wav", + "text": "被害人這樣行為的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3980.wav", + "text": "其實很多情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3981.wav", + "text": "都可以被認為是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3982.wav", + "text": "未經同意要散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3983.wav", + "text": "我拿這件事情來恐嚇你的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3984.wav", + "text": "其實已經可以被認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3985.wav", + "text": "定如果你不按照我的意思做我就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3986.wav", + "text": "散布那個威脅行為著手的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3987.wav", + "text": "密接性很強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3988.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望留待司法實務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3989.wav", + "text": "用這個角度把它包含進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3990.wav", + "text": "自然它也是屬於犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3991.wav", + "text": "本章之罪的物品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3992.wav", + "text": "也會適用第三百十九條之五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3993.wav", + "text": "這是我的見解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3994.wav", + "text": "讓部長跟大家參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3995.wav", + "text": "所以意圖的部分是拿掉了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3996.wav", + "text": "未遂犯的概念就可以處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3997.wav", + "text": "很大一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3998.wav", + "text": "如果他真的完全沒有要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/3999.wav", + "text": "連著手都還不能認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4000.wav", + "text": "可不可以直接拉到意圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4001.wav", + "text": "用意圖這個主觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4002.wav", + "text": "不法構成要件是非常remote" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4003.wav", + "text": "連故意都不是的意圖上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4004.wav", + "text": "去定的話其實是有點疑慮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4005.wav", + "text": "這個是刑法上面討論出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4006.wav", + "text": "我們先這樣走走看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4007.wav", + "text": "如果真的發生極端案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4008.wav", + "text": "我們再來修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4009.wav", + "text": "和司法院提案通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4010.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4011.wav", + "text": "沒有意見我們照法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4012.wav", + "text": "建議條文通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4013.wav", + "text": "我還是想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4014.wav", + "text": "是用告訴乃論罪來定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4015.wav", + "text": "偽影像卻是非告訴乃論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4016.wav", + "text": "是否為真實的影像或是所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4017.wav", + "text": "偽影像應該都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4018.wav", + "text": "都是性私密影像的散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4019.wav", + "text": "在這樣情況下是不是都應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4020.wav", + "text": "這是比較合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4021.wav", + "text": "因為傷害是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4022.wav", + "text": "又或者造成的結果是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4023.wav", + "text": "要不要回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4024.wav", + "text": "王委員提的大概就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4025.wav", + "text": "告訴乃論的範圍要多大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4026.wav", + "text": "您希望大一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4027.wav", + "text": "時代力量的版本不論真偽都是屬於性私密影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4028.wav", + "text": "都應該屬於告訴乃論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4029.wav", + "text": "我們是有分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4030.wav", + "text": "的我先說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4031.wav", + "text": "我們後來有一個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4032.wav", + "text": "就是將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4033.wav", + "text": "未遂犯納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4034.wav", + "text": "本來是沒有納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4035.wav", + "text": "但我們希望把未遂犯也納入即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4036.wav", + "text": "未遂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4037.wav", + "text": "也要告訴乃論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4038.wav", + "text": "委員是希望告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4039.wav", + "text": "告訴乃論的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4040.wav", + "text": "被害人而言他應該要有這樣的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4041.wav", + "text": "以尊重當事人的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4042.wav", + "text": "真人影像或偽影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4043.wav", + "text": "都由當事人決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4044.wav", + "text": "要擴大尊重當事人的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4045.wav", + "text": "要不要提告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4046.wav", + "text": "是但我們也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4047.wav", + "text": "有些東西是社會法益的侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4048.wav", + "text": "社會法益的侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4049.wav", + "text": "它不是個人而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4050.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4051.wav", + "text": "保留第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4052.wav", + "text": "要不要也讓第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4053.wav", + "text": "這個要不要先簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4054.wav", + "text": "要先簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4055.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4056.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4057.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4058.wav", + "text": "能夠再討論一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4059.wav", + "text": "下達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4060.wav", + "text": "大概會有67條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4061.wav", + "text": "條文都會因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4062.wav", + "text": "名詞而保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4063.wav", + "text": "第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4064.wav", + "text": "後面才走得下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4065.wav", + "text": "那後面牽扯太多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4066.wav", + "text": "我可不可以趁這個空檔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4067.wav", + "text": "我們聽聽林秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4068.wav", + "text": "剛剛黃世杰委員的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4069.wav", + "text": "足以引起性慾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4070.wav", + "text": "提後段的或羞恥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4071.wav", + "text": "會造成一個大漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4072.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4073.wav", + "text": "有些性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4074.wav", + "text": "不一定會引起性慾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4075.wav", + "text": "但會讓人感到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4076.wav", + "text": "我們只是為了要擴大保護的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4077.wav", + "text": "希望王委員可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4078.wav", + "text": "王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4079.wav", + "text": "不過我還是要提醒一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4080.wav", + "text": "我覺得引起羞恥的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4081.wav", + "text": "還是會把這個影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4082.wav", + "text": "認為是羞恥事情的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4083.wav", + "text": "更加污名化的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4084.wav", + "text": "呈現在法條條文的設計上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4085.wav", + "text": "會讓受害者更難以放下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4086.wav", + "text": "因為覺得自己被看光光了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4087.wav", + "text": "見不得人了而受到更深的創傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4088.wav", + "text": "就是希望能夠保護受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4089.wav", + "text": "或是看到影片的人可能要覺得羞恥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4090.wav", + "text": "覺得不好意思才會是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4091.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這部分還是希望大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4092.wav", + "text": "可以更積極地思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4093.wav", + "text": "未來有沒有可能是用一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4094.wav", + "text": "比較正面的態度去看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4095.wav", + "text": "而不是用引起羞恥這樣子的語言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4096.wav", + "text": "請林秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4097.wav", + "text": "這個是雙層的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4098.wav", + "text": "像會覺得不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4099.wav", + "text": "如果要有負面的形象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4100.wav", + "text": "應該是說這個行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4101.wav", + "text": "的這種行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4102.wav", + "text": "是很不可取的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4103.wav", + "text": "是一個很可恥的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4104.wav", + "text": "這是另外一層的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4105.wav", + "text": "值得譴責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4106.wav", + "text": "我大概可以理解現狀上很難再去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4107.wav", + "text": "把它寫得更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4108.wav", + "text": "之後會提一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4109.wav", + "text": "希望能夠研議未來在文字上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4110.wav", + "text": "附帶決議寫一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4111.wav", + "text": "最後一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4112.wav", + "text": "才算是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4113.wav", + "text": "散布的未遂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4114.wav", + "text": "可以問一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4115.wav", + "text": "未遂的話是著手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4116.wav", + "text": "就算是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4117.wav", + "text": "威脅要到什麼程度才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4118.wav", + "text": "算是散布的未遂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4119.wav", + "text": "通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4120.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4121.wav", + "text": "中華民國刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4122.wav", + "text": "施行法增訂第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4123.wav", + "text": "之4的條文草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4124.wav", + "text": "就是我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4125.wav", + "text": "只有一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4126.wav", + "text": "沒有意見我們先通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4127.wav", + "text": "嘛把刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4128.wav", + "text": "法務部建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4129.wav", + "text": "法務部有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4130.wav", + "text": "一個修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4131.wav", + "text": "大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4132.wav", + "text": "照法務部的修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4133.wav", + "text": "我要唸一遍嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4134.wav", + "text": "這兩個先簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4135.wav", + "text": "我只唸協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4136.wav", + "text": "一第10條增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4137.wav", + "text": "第三百十九條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4138.wav", + "text": "三百十九條之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4139.wav", + "text": "至第三百十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4140.wav", + "text": "之五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4141.wav", + "text": "均照行政院司法院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4142.wav", + "text": "\n二第91條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4143.wav", + "text": "增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4144.wav", + "text": "第三百十九條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4145.wav", + "text": "第三百十九條之六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4146.wav", + "text": "均照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4147.wav", + "text": "三其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4148.wav", + "text": "\n四本法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4149.wav", + "text": "各黨團委員提案及修正動議均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4150.wav", + "text": "列入公報紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4151.wav", + "text": "有關中華民國刑法施行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4152.wav", + "text": "增訂第9條之4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4153.wav", + "text": "條文草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4154.wav", + "text": "照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4155.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4156.wav", + "text": "我是不是補充建議一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4157.wav", + "text": "就是說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4158.wav", + "text": "修正通過的說明理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4159.wav", + "text": "是不是授權法務部來做文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4160.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4161.wav", + "text": "說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4162.wav", + "text": "什麼時候會提供出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4163.wav", + "text": "因為禮貌上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4164.wav", + "text": "還是要讓各黨團大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4165.wav", + "text": "禮拜一以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4166.wav", + "text": "就是你提出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4167.wav", + "text": "我們在下一次朝野黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4168.wav", + "text": "這樣比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4169.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4170.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛是說明理由會在院會處理前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4171.wav", + "text": "先提出來的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4172.wav", + "text": "所以院會預計是禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4173.wav", + "text": "下禮拜的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4174.wav", + "text": "拜六也可以邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4175.wav", + "text": "邊處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4176.wav", + "text": "你儘快明天拿出來好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4177.wav", + "text": "說明很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4178.wav", + "text": "我們只是把剛剛各位討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4179.wav", + "text": "修正的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4180.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4181.wav", + "text": "現在馬上改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4182.wav", + "text": "說明欄不是本來就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4183.wav", + "text": "你是要改說明欄嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4184.wav", + "text": "把說明欄寫得更完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4185.wav", + "text": "看能不能下班前提供給大家瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4186.wav", + "text": "如果OK我們就來院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4187.wav", + "text": "麻煩要參酌一下各黨團的立法理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4188.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4189.wav", + "text": "因為這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4190.wav", + "text": "而且不是表決的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4191.wav", + "text": "可能禮拜六院會就要處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4192.wav", + "text": "因為我們挑的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4193.wav", + "text": "要漸漸消化掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4194.wav", + "text": "送來說明欄沒有很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4195.wav", + "text": "明天早上送過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4196.wav", + "text": "說明欄送給議事處明天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4197.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4198.wav", + "text": "我們就要進行下一個法案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4199.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4200.wav", + "text": "一說如果碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4201.wav", + "text": "暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4202.wav", + "text": "再回頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4203.wav", + "text": "滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4204.wav", + "text": "我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4205.wav", + "text": "協商犯罪被害人保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4206.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4207.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4208.wav", + "text": "犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4209.wav", + "text": "被害人保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4210.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4211.wav", + "text": "看第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4212.wav", + "text": "我們就討論保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4213.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4214.wav", + "text": "法務部有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4215.wav", + "text": "是不是照法務部建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4216.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4217.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見通過\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4218.wav", + "text": "再看第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4219.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4220.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4221.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4222.wav", + "text": "好接下來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4223.wav", + "text": "大家如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4224.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4225.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4226.wav", + "text": "再來看第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4227.wav", + "text": "第9條如果大家沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4228.wav", + "text": "提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4229.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4230.wav", + "text": "那就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4231.wav", + "text": "請看第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4232.wav", + "text": "第十五條大家如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4233.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4234.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4235.wav", + "text": "這個法務部有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4236.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4237.wav", + "text": "第十五條就依照法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4238.wav", + "text": "建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4239.wav", + "text": "因為有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4240.wav", + "text": "法務部也有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4241.wav", + "text": "我們依照法務部建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4242.wav", + "text": "第26條法務部也有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4243.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4244.wav", + "text": "請王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4245.wav", + "text": "把我的版本列上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4246.wav", + "text": "因為上次在委員會協商時是有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4247.wav", + "text": "這次的資料裡面卻沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4248.wav", + "text": "\n第26條應該講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4249.wav", + "text": "當被害人對於刑事訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4250.wav", + "text": "過程及進行的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4251.wav", + "text": "必須要能夠透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4252.wav", + "text": "聲請才有獲知平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4253.wav", + "text": "使用權的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4254.wav", + "text": "我們可以理解的是當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4255.wav", + "text": "這種重大事情發生的時候其實被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4256.wav", + "text": "可能在當下都沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4257.wav", + "text": "來處理所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4258.wav", + "text": "希望應該還是用主動告知的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4259.wav", + "text": "式不是透過被害人的聲請而是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4260.wav", + "text": "積極處理除非被害人說他不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4261.wav", + "text": "說被害人不要的時候才不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4262.wav", + "text": "因此應該要積極主動地來讓這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4263.wav", + "text": "被害人能夠有被告知的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4264.wav", + "text": "所以我們本來寫的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4265.wav", + "text": "定期告知案件進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4266.wav", + "text": "基本上我們是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4267.wav", + "text": "被害人的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4268.wav", + "text": "會告訴他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4269.wav", + "text": "資訊獲知的平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4270.wav", + "text": "只要他同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4271.wav", + "text": "我們會透過這個平台來告知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4272.wav", + "text": "所以要不要主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4273.wav", + "text": "我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4274.wav", + "text": "尊重當事人的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4275.wav", + "text": "可能他家裡的人都會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4276.wav", + "text": "通過的情況是當他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4277.wav", + "text": "聲請之後他就會收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4278.wav", + "text": "通知還是他要自己上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4279.wav", + "text": "查詢才知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4280.wav", + "text": "會告訴他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4281.wav", + "text": "在這個平台上可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4282.wav", + "text": "得到他要的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4283.wav", + "text": "是透過這個平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4284.wav", + "text": "台包括用電腦或手機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4285.wav", + "text": "他要的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4286.wav", + "text": "或是用email方式寄給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4287.wav", + "text": "我們尊重當事人的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4288.wav", + "text": "我們有不同的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4289.wav", + "text": "所以想釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4290.wav", + "text": "不只是他上平台去看進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4291.wav", + "text": "比如一旦有進度的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4292.wav", + "text": "可以用手機簡訊或是email通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4293.wav", + "text": "有這樣的選項嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4294.wav", + "text": "因為要當事人或是家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4295.wav", + "text": "持續上去看平台是不容易的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4296.wav", + "text": "但我覺得如果現在所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4297.wav", + "text": "通知服務已經包含了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4298.wav", + "text": "一旦發生進度的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4299.wav", + "text": "就會有一個通知告訴他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4300.wav", + "text": "現在已經有變化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4301.wav", + "text": "讓被害人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4302.wav", + "text": "會告訴他整個訴訟進行到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4303.wav", + "text": "因為看了報紙才知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4304.wav", + "text": "現在是怎麼樣進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4305.wav", + "text": "所以這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4306.wav", + "text": "還包括法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4307.wav", + "text": "瞭解所以這個通知其實就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4308.wav", + "text": "包含主動發簡訊或是把e" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4309.wav", + "text": "il告知當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4310.wav", + "text": "第26條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4311.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4312.wav", + "text": "請看第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4313.wav", + "text": "第27條法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4314.wav", + "text": "也有建議修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4315.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4316.wav", + "text": "有經過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4317.wav", + "text": "協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4318.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4319.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4320.wav", + "text": "\n請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4321.wav", + "text": "第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4322.wav", + "text": "第28條法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4323.wav", + "text": "也有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4324.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見我們依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4325.wav", + "text": "版本通過這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4326.wav", + "text": "好就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4327.wav", + "text": "\n請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4328.wav", + "text": "第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4329.wav", + "text": "第32條法務部也有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4330.wav", + "text": "建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4331.wav", + "text": "建議條文如果沒有意見照建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4332.wav", + "text": "通過這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4333.wav", + "text": "院長等一下因為今天才拿到建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4334.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4335.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4336.wav", + "text": "法務部的建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4337.wav", + "text": "都有綜合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4338.wav", + "text": "綜合大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4339.wav", + "text": "對但沒有先送出來實在是來不及消化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4340.wav", + "text": "簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4341.wav", + "text": "原來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4342.wav", + "text": "強制性地不能報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4343.wav", + "text": "或記載犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4344.wav", + "text": "包括第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4345.wav", + "text": "要受處罰的規定也一起刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4346.wav", + "text": "不會引起一些爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4347.wav", + "text": "通傳會報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4348.wav", + "text": "被害人所以它是規範所有類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4349.wav", + "text": "報導是一個原則禁止的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4350.wav", + "text": "對於這種報導被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4351.wav", + "text": "的新聞目前原則禁止的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4352.wav", + "text": "只有針對特定類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4353.wav", + "text": "比如說兒少性剝削防制條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4354.wav", + "text": "就是原則禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4355.wav", + "text": "但因為它的犯罪類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4356.wav", + "text": "及犯罪被害人其實已經是比較特定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4357.wav", + "text": "這個修法將其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4358.wav", + "text": "擴大到所有犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4359.wav", + "text": "類型統統都包含在內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4360.wav", + "text": "這樣的話其所要考慮的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4361.wav", + "text": "就非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4362.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4363.wav", + "text": "它會影響到新聞自由目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4364.wav", + "text": "在實務上針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4365.wav", + "text": "犯罪被害人身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4366.wav", + "text": "假設其對於隱私保護有需要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4367.wav", + "text": "就可以根據個資法來請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4368.wav", + "text": "向通傳會檢舉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4369.wav", + "text": "我們也會依據廣電法第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4370.wav", + "text": "十一條及衛廣法第二十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4371.wav", + "text": "規定處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4372.wav", + "text": "我想釐清一下現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4373.wav", + "text": "犯罪被害人或其家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4374.wav", + "text": "媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4375.wav", + "text": "並且應該在十日內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4376.wav", + "text": "處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4377.wav", + "text": "是這是強制性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4378.wav", + "text": "另外想請教在實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4379.wav", + "text": "將理由書給被害人或家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4380.wav", + "text": "家屬或被害人如仍然有意見會透過什麼方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4381.wav", + "text": "繼續處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4382.wav", + "text": "應該要有倫理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4383.wav", + "text": "第1項跟後面在講的其實是不同的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4384.wav", + "text": "家屬的名譽及隱私" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4385.wav", + "text": "本來個資法就在處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4386.wav", + "text": "電臺經過查證結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4387.wav", + "text": "認為有錯誤的話就必須要去更正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4388.wav", + "text": "本來就應該負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4389.wav", + "text": "可以請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4390.wav", + "text": "吳委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4391.wav", + "text": "NCC可不可以再稍微說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4392.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4393.wav", + "text": "文字是不得報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4394.wav", + "text": "或記載其姓名住居所或其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4395.wav", + "text": "足資識別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4396.wav", + "text": "身分之資訊其實是在保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4397.wav", + "text": "被害人而後面的文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4398.wav", + "text": "報導錯誤才能更正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4399.wav", + "text": "但如果這個畫面一直不斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4400.wav", + "text": "重複出現其實對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4401.wav", + "text": "於被害人是一個很大的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4402.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4403.wav", + "text": "是因為第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4404.wav", + "text": "錯誤而是不斷重複地出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4405.wav", + "text": "其實就是一個很大傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4406.wav", + "text": "這個部分你要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4407.wav", + "text": "因為目前第1項本身在講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4408.wav", + "text": "他就本來就可以依照個資法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4409.wav", + "text": "可以接近麥克風一點說話嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4410.wav", + "text": "我這裡聽不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4411.wav", + "text": "就可以依據個資法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4412.wav", + "text": "請求予以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4413.wav", + "text": "刪除或是為必要的遮蔽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4414.wav", + "text": "須遮蔽讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4415.wav", + "text": "不至於出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4416.wav", + "text": "請王委員我想再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4417.wav", + "text": "釐清一下是否跟吳委員的意見是接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4418.wav", + "text": "的我們雖然在第1項已經有課予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4419.wav", + "text": "應注意保護或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4420.wav", + "text": "維護他的名譽或隱私" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4421.wav", + "text": "或是事發當時的畫面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4422.wav", + "text": "違反個資法因為它並沒有個人資訊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4423.wav", + "text": "由當事人直接申訴的話用自律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4424.wav", + "text": "公約的方式他們會啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4425.wav", + "text": "其實我們還是會有相關處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4426.wav", + "text": "曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4427.wav", + "text": "第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4428.wav", + "text": "的最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4429.wav", + "text": "媒體業者應於接到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4430.wav", + "text": "要求後十日內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4431.wav", + "text": "在該報導播送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4432.wav", + "text": "之原節目或同一時段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4433.wav", + "text": "之節目或刊登" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4434.wav", + "text": "10天內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4435.wav", + "text": "會不會太長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4436.wav", + "text": "10天前播了什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4437.wav", + "text": "這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4438.wav", + "text": "0天太長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4439.wav", + "text": "你記不記得10天前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4440.wav", + "text": "電視播什麼我看都不記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4441.wav", + "text": "這時間點太長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4442.wav", + "text": "因為在衛廣法跟廣電法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4443.wav", + "text": "沒關係從這個法開始改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4444.wav", + "text": "我要求3天內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4445.wav", + "text": "3天時間太長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4446.wav", + "text": "了我都不記得上個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4447.wav", + "text": "談了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4448.wav", + "text": "目前在實務上他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4449.wav", + "text": "在作業上已經做這麼多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4450.wav", + "text": "了你總要給人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4451.wav", + "text": "一些查證的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4452.wav", + "text": "你還要查一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4453.wav", + "text": "因為有些事情可能還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4454.wav", + "text": "可以在一兩天處理得完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4455.wav", + "text": "臺灣在吵什麼我都不記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4456.wav", + "text": "時間太長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4457.wav", + "text": "其他法也一起改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4458.wav", + "text": "啊要求更正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4459.wav", + "text": "OK啦當事人20天內更正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4460.wav", + "text": "法務部有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4461.wav", + "text": "我也是贊成縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4462.wav", + "text": "但是同時我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4463.wav", + "text": "因為現在定義裡面只有被害人或其家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4464.wav", + "text": "或委託基金會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4465.wav", + "text": "但是基金會的設立與否我相信等一下會有討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4466.wav", + "text": "所以我想問一下如果是在委託人的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4467.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠提出這樣子的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4468.wav", + "text": "請大家試想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4469.wav", + "text": "就是當事情發生的時候其實當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4470.wav", + "text": "或是其家屬都處在一個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4471.wav", + "text": "慌亂非常挫折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4472.wav", + "text": "和非常害怕的環境之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4473.wav", + "text": "光是要好好生活都不容易了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4474.wav", + "text": "如何讓被害人或其家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4475.wav", + "text": "發生的情況會是他們提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4476.wav", + "text": "這樣的不舒服然後委由現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4477.wav", + "text": "有把委託的概念放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4478.wav", + "text": "請法務部在這部分能夠參酌考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4479.wav", + "text": "大家想像一下當你的家裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4480.wav", + "text": "發生重大事故時其實你當下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4481.wav", + "text": "失序是你沒有辦法處理到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4482.wav", + "text": "這件事情的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4483.wav", + "text": "委託的部分拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4484.wav", + "text": "這還是會非常限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4485.wav", + "text": "處理這件事情的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4486.wav", + "text": "我想釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4487.wav", + "text": "如果這個委託是本人授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4488.wav", + "text": "同意的根本不需要定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4489.wav", + "text": "委任授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4490.wav", + "text": "代理等法律行為本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4491.wav", + "text": "都可以做不需要寫都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4492.wav", + "text": "可以做除非要將其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4493.wav", + "text": "變成一個獨立的申請權主體才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4494.wav", + "text": "需要特別寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4495.wav", + "text": "本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4496.wav", + "text": "按照法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4497.wav", + "text": "建議條文但是其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4498.wav", + "text": "這樣通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4499.wav", + "text": "好修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4500.wav", + "text": "\n請看第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4501.wav", + "text": "審查會有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4502.wav", + "text": "比較周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4503.wav", + "text": "文若大家沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4504.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4505.wav", + "text": "第35條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4506.wav", + "text": "法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4507.wav", + "text": "也有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4508.wav", + "text": "本黨團有提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4509.wav", + "text": "主要是將第35條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4510.wav", + "text": "的保護命令新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4511.wav", + "text": "第二十八章之一之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4512.wav", + "text": "亦能作為聲請保護命令之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4513.wav", + "text": "依據將禁止被告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4514.wav", + "text": "重製散布播送交付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4515.wav", + "text": "公然陳列或以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4516.wav", + "text": "觀覽被害人性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4517.wav", + "text": "並且在第3款新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4518.wav", + "text": "被告需要將持有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4519.wav", + "text": "之被害人性影像交付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4520.wav", + "text": "周延相關法律的規範保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4521.wav", + "text": "被害人權益\n剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4522.wav", + "text": "其實法務部有來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4523.wav", + "text": "在剛才經過溝通之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4524.wav", + "text": "也請法務部納入參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4525.wav", + "text": "目前看到法務部修正的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4526.wav", + "text": "也有參採我們的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4527.wav", + "text": "可以針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4528.wav", + "text": "更完整地保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4529.wav", + "text": "一下剛才我們討論的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4530.wav", + "text": "請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4531.wav", + "text": "民眾黨的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4532.wav", + "text": "我們都已經納進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4533.wav", + "text": "當然有做比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4534.wav", + "text": "邱總召的建議未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4535.wav", + "text": "執行面如果有需要再改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4536.wav", + "text": "的地方我們會來改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4537.wav", + "text": "林秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4538.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4539.wav", + "text": "法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4540.wav", + "text": "最後提出這個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4541.wav", + "text": "確實是我們折衝很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4542.wav", + "text": "目前法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4543.wav", + "text": "提出的修正動議是參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4544.wav", + "text": "了各個黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4545.wav", + "text": "當然也包括民眾黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4546.wav", + "text": "邱總召的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4547.wav", + "text": "我有幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4548.wav", + "text": "的接受適當之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4549.wav", + "text": "科技設備監控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4550.wav", + "text": "刑事訴訟法第一百十六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4551.wav", + "text": "條之2第1項第四款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4552.wav", + "text": "就有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4553.wav", + "text": "在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4554.wav", + "text": "應該不需要再重複規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4555.wav", + "text": "第2項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4556.wav", + "text": "我們非但參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4557.wav", + "text": "各黨團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4558.wav", + "text": "以未違反意願而取得之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4559.wav", + "text": "性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4560.wav", + "text": "刑法第304條第305" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4561.wav", + "text": "了\n另外邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4562.wav", + "text": "的修正動議裡面有提到被害人的聲請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4563.wav", + "text": "即如果讓被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4564.wav", + "text": "可以聲請刑事保護命令的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4565.wav", + "text": "刑事程序的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4566.wav", + "text": "審檢辯三角關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4567.wav", + "text": "被害人如果有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4568.wav", + "text": "需求只需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4569.wav", + "text": "對檢察官作請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4570.wav", + "text": "檢察官聲請就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4571.wav", + "text": "如果是在偵查中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4572.wav", + "text": "請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4573.wav", + "text": "犯保法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4574.wav", + "text": "第36條的規定可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4575.wav", + "text": "請檢察官發保護命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4576.wav", + "text": "所以這部分應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4577.wav", + "text": "不需要再做這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4578.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4579.wav", + "text": "好我們就照法務部建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4580.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4581.wav", + "text": "\n處理第38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4582.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4583.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4584.wav", + "text": "剛剛我有想到一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4585.wav", + "text": "取回放到犯保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4586.wav", + "text": "我有一個疑問因為對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4587.wav", + "text": "受害人來講的話應該很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4588.wav", + "text": "行為人加害人趕快交出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4589.wav", + "text": "所以他們會希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4590.wav", + "text": "能不能透過警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4591.wav", + "text": "可是當然在這邊大家是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4592.wav", + "text": "有一個比較高的門檻因為這涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4593.wav", + "text": "擁有的物為什麼可以要他拿出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4594.wav", + "text": "若是放在犯保法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4595.wav", + "text": "警察在第一時間點就不能要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4596.wav", + "text": "行為人交付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4597.wav", + "text": "要等法官跟檢察官但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4598.wav", + "text": "到時候不聲請呢因為這邊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4599.wav", + "text": "文字是得依職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4600.wav", + "text": "或檢察官之聲請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4601.wav", + "text": "其中第二點是禁止重製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4602.wav", + "text": "第三點是提出或交付被害人之性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4603.wav", + "text": "就是不聲請則被害人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4604.wav", + "text": "權益不就變成由檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4605.wav", + "text": "一人決定嗎可不可以回應這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4606.wav", + "text": "問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4607.wav", + "text": "當事人如果跟檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4608.wav", + "text": "要求的話檢察官會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4609.wav", + "text": "酌量考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4610.wav", + "text": "必要時一定會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4611.wav", + "text": "如果不提出一定會向當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4612.wav", + "text": "交付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4613.wav", + "text": "要不要由警察在第一��間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4614.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4615.wav", + "text": "那是要構成犯罪的前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4616.wav", + "text": "下才會來執行這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4617.wav", + "text": "當然是犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4618.wav", + "text": "所以是檢察官要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4619.wav", + "text": "扣押" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4620.wav", + "text": "我補充說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4621.wav", + "text": "檢察官只要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4622.wav", + "text": "搜索扣押就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4623.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4624.wav", + "text": "部分我沒有聽懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4625.wav", + "text": "抱歉因為我對這個法律不是很瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4626.wav", + "text": "職權做這些事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4627.wav", + "text": "當事人如果有要求但檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4628.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4629.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4630.wav", + "text": "講過很多遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4631.wav", + "text": "不代表黨團的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4632.wav", + "text": "我個人的立場是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4633.wav", + "text": "其實這邊的關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4634.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4635.wav", + "text": "檢察官的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4636.wav", + "text": "因為刑事保護令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4637.wav", + "text": "是依附於強制處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4638.wav", + "text": "所以當然是檢察官的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4639.wav", + "text": "有聲請權的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4640.wav", + "text": "則強制處分變成是被害人可以去聲請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4641.wav", + "text": "這在體例上確實很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4642.wav", + "text": "性私密影像落在他人手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4643.wav", + "text": "在還沒有散播出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4644.wav", + "text": "我們若是要用最快的方式去遏止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4645.wav", + "text": "這種情況的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4646.wav", + "text": "則這個保護命令應該是民事保護令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4647.wav", + "text": "民事法律關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4648.wav", + "text": "只是在講程序並非依附於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4649.wav", + "text": "刑事強制處分上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4650.wav", + "text": "這是美國法的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4651.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4652.wav", + "text": "其實也不是沒有民事保護令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4653.wav", + "text": "家庭暴力防治法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4654.wav", + "text": "行政院也針對這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4655.wav", + "text": "因親密關係或過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4656.wav", + "text": "過去有親密關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4657.wav", + "text": "性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4658.wav", + "text": "像轉為恐怖情人後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4659.wav", + "text": "再威脅恐嚇���情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4660.wav", + "text": "家防法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4661.wav", + "text": "民事保護令已經有把這個樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4662.wav", + "text": "訂定進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4663.wav", + "text": "了在衛福部跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4664.wav", + "text": "法務部司法院討論過後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4665.wav", + "text": "有一個草案我們是希望它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4666.wav", + "text": "儘快送到立法院來通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4667.wav", + "text": "被害人可以主動去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4668.wav", + "text": "聲請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4669.wav", + "text": "然後以違反保護令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4670.wav", + "text": "會有刑事處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4671.wav", + "text": "心理拘束讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4672.wav", + "text": "持有這些性影像的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4673.wav", + "text": "不要再做這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4674.wav", + "text": "當然如果他做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4675.wav", + "text": "這些威脅恐嚇的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4676.wav", + "text": "它本身仍然是犯罪行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4677.wav", + "text": "所以可以說是雙軌並進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4678.wav", + "text": "如果被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4679.wav", + "text": "選擇去提告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4680.wav", + "text": "偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4681.wav", + "text": "跟這邊的刑事保護令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4682.wav", + "text": "如果是親密關係中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4683.wav", + "text": "這個其實是大部分案件的來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4684.wav", + "text": "所以那個地方如果修法完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4685.wav", + "text": "其實應該大部分的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4686.wav", + "text": "不管走刑事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4687.wav", + "text": "或走民事保護令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4688.wav", + "text": "它都會有完整的保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4689.wav", + "text": "希望那個部分大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4690.wav", + "text": "趕快來補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4691.wav", + "text": "在這邊我們是一個妥協的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4692.wav", + "text": "也就是說在刑事保護命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4693.wav", + "text": "的架構底下還是不能破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4694.wav", + "text": "所以在這邊我們用這種方式來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4695.wav", + "text": "但並不是我們就放棄了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4696.wav", + "text": "在補強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4697.wav", + "text": "黃世杰委員的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4698.wav", + "text": "司法院法務部為什麼自己沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4699.wav", + "text": "解釋要黃委員解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4700.wav", + "text": "我再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4701.wav", + "text": "黃委員說的有一點我不完全同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4702.wav", + "text": "因為也有可能不是親密關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4703.wav", + "text": "嘛但是之前同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4704.wav", + "text": "部分你用家防法就沒辦法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4705.wav", + "text": "另外一個是速度的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4706.wav", + "text": "可不可以用一個附帶決議補上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4707.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4708.wav", + "text": "現在現行法就有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4709.wav", + "text": "我跟委員解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4710.wav", + "text": "如果我們要通過目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4711.wav", + "text": "根據第36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4712.wav", + "text": "這些事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4713.wav", + "text": "沒有發的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4714.wav", + "text": "準用刑事訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4715.wav", + "text": "第401條第401條提起抗告或是準抗告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4716.wav", + "text": "這個有救濟的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4717.wav", + "text": "另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4718.wav", + "text": "剛剛黃委員又提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4719.wav", + "text": "我們的家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4720.wav", + "text": "準備要設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4721.wav", + "text": "來交付性影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4722.wav", + "text": "我想那個可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4723.wav", + "text": "緩不濟急我說實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4724.wav", + "text": "的那個在執行會發生困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4725.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4726.wav", + "text": "等一下等一下你現在是要推翻你們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4727.wav", + "text": "協商通過的草案嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4728.wav", + "text": "黃委員我們沒有不敬的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4729.wav", + "text": "我只是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4730.wav", + "text": "大家應該要注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4731.wav", + "text": "證據保全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4732.wav", + "text": "只要提告訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4733.wav", + "text": "偵查中就可以請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4734.wav", + "text": "搜索扣押" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4735.wav", + "text": "我必須要做這樣的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4736.wav", + "text": "我來講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4737.wav", + "text": "剛剛有大哉問為什麼是黃委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4738.wav", + "text": "並不是說你不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4739.wav", + "text": "因為黃委員他們同事間講的比較親切一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4740.wav", + "text": "比較平民化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4741.wav", + "text": "都聽得懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4742.wav", + "text": "我們做一個附帶決議來處理就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4743.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4744.wav", + "text": "不好李次長這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4745.wav", + "text": "家暴法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4746.wav", + "text": "家暴法我們本來就已經送到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4747.wav", + "text": "已經在會銜了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4748.wav", + "text": "那有沒有這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4749.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4750.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4751.wav", + "text": "司法院不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4752.wav", + "text": "我們同意照目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4753.wav", + "text": "家暴法修的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4754.wav", + "text": "啦已經會銜了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4755.wav", + "text": "嘛現在已經在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4756.wav", + "text": "他們有來好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4757.wav", + "text": "那就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4758.wav", + "text": "第35條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4759.wav", + "text": "就照法務部建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4760.wav", + "text": "范委員剛才的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4761.wav", + "text": "就考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4762.wav", + "text": "提附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4763.wav", + "text": "\n請大家看第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4764.wav", + "text": "38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4765.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4766.wav", + "text": "我們就照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4767.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4768.wav", + "text": "41條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4769.wav", + "text": "法務部也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4770.wav", + "text": "綜合大家的意見提出建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4771.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4772.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見的話我們就通過\n處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4773.wav", + "text": "第48條是對應到時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4774.wav", + "text": "力量黨團版本的第79條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4775.wav", + "text": "但是好像沒有列出來不過我就講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4776.wav", + "text": "因為其實這個在委員會也討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4777.wav", + "text": "修復促進者能夠有這些性別平權的意識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4778.wav", + "text": "尊重多元同時秉持著專業和中立的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4779.wav", + "text": "但實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4780.wav", + "text": "修復促進者的品質和程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4781.wav", + "text": "非常的不一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4782.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4783.wav", + "text": "在促進者的培訓認證和實習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4784.wav", + "text": "督導遴聘等等都應該要有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4785.wav", + "text": "辦法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4786.wav", + "text": "所以希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4787.wav", + "text": "不要用這麼大的框架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4788.wav", + "text": "這些專業和原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4789.wav", + "text": "關於如何讓他具備的這件事情就應該要有相關的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4790.wav", + "text": "所以還是希望能夠審酌參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4791.wav", + "text": "時代力量版本的第79條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4792.wav", + "text": "但是這次沒有把它放上來我也不知道為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4793.wav", + "text": "謝謝王委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4794.wav", + "text": "應該做的事情法務部都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4795.wav", + "text": "至於有沒有必要在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4796.wav", + "text": "地僵化地規定要做哪些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4797.wav", + "text": "不如由實務上我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4798.wav", + "text": "該做的我們就來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4799.wav", + "text": "用職權訂定的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4800.wav", + "text": "來處理就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4801.wav", + "text": "所以沒有說一定要在這個條文上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4802.wav", + "text": "很明白地規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4803.wav", + "text": "做哪些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4804.wav", + "text": "如果超過這些事情的範圍沒有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4805.wav", + "text": "的部分我們就不需要做嗎我們還是會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4806.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4807.wav", + "text": "行使的意思是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4808.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣讓促進者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4809.wav", + "text": "能夠更精進他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4810.wav", + "text": "作為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4811.wav", + "text": "自己內部會有一個明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4812.wav", + "text": "那個規範可不可以變成一個辦法讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4813.wav", + "text": "能夠更具有明確性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4814.wav", + "text": "如果需要的話我們把它弄成辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4815.wav", + "text": "我們原本在第79條就提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4816.wav", + "text": "前項促進者之培訓認證以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4817.wav", + "text": "實習應由司法主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4818.wav", + "text": "會同中央主管機關以辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4819.wav", + "text": "定之如果本來裡面就已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4820.wav", + "text": "這樣的規範是不是就讓它變成一個正式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4821.wav", + "text": "辦法讓大家可以有所依循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4822.wav", + "text": "因為的確雖然長期以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4823.wav", + "text": "我們很努力在推動修復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4824.wav", + "text": "促進但是實務上真的有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4825.wav", + "text": "很大的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4826.wav", + "text": "我們保持彈性可以隨時來調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4827.wav", + "text": "辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4828.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4829.wav", + "text": "是要做同樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4830.wav", + "text": "他要把辦法寫在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4831.wav", + "text": "你是希望保留一點彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4832.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4833.wav", + "text": "免得在這個部分太僵化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4834.wav", + "text": "好第48條照行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4835.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4836.wav", + "text": "寫一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4837.wav", + "text": "51條法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4838.wav", + "text": "有綜合大家的意見提出建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4839.wav", + "text": "大家如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4840.wav", + "text": "的話我們也通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4841.wav", + "text": "第55條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4842.wav", + "text": "大家沒有意見的話我們照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4843.wav", + "text": "行照院版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4844.wav", + "text": "第57條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4845.wav", + "text": "第57條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4846.wav", + "text": "第1項是各類犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4847.wav", + "text": "被害補償金之金額如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4848.wav", + "text": "都有規定嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4849.wav", + "text": "\n法務部寫的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4850.wav", + "text": "前項各款所定數額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4851.wav", + "text": "於中央主計機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4852.wav", + "text": "發布之消費者物價指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4853.wav", + "text": "累計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4854.wav", + "text": "主管機關應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4855.wav", + "text": "報請行政院核定調整之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4856.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4857.wav", + "text": "的比例是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4858.wav", + "text": "按照前面的百分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4859.wav", + "text": "五調多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4860.wav", + "text": "應該寫個依比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4861.wav", + "text": "這條是鄭運鵬委員提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4862.wav", + "text": "他也是好意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4863.wav", + "text": "這種寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4864.wav", + "text": "和我們當初年金改革的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4865.wav", + "text": "所以我們是可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4866.wav", + "text": "按比例調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4867.wav", + "text": "按累積的比例調整超" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4868.wav", + "text": "調是要調多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4869.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法全部反映可以這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4870.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4871.wav", + "text": "它有幾個參考指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4872.wav", + "text": "但是這個到底調整多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4873.wav", + "text": "可能真的要寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4874.wav", + "text": "我們本來只有說按照社會經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4875.wav", + "text": "報行政院核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4876.wav", + "text": "來調整現在是更具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4877.wav", + "text": "按照物價指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4878.wav", + "text": "當成長率達到5%以上的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4879.wav", + "text": "但是調整多少就要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4880.wav", + "text": "政府的財政或當時的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4881.wav", + "text": "物價指數調要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4882.wav", + "text": "報行政院核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4883.wav", + "text": "第67條寫正負5%時應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4884.wav", + "text": "予調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4885.wav", + "text": "但是後面也有一句話要報行政院核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4886.wav", + "text": "啦所以還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4887.wav", + "text": "要調多少他們還是要報行政院核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4888.wav", + "text": "金額很龐大政府負擔不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4889.wav", + "text": "所以騙騙公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4890.wav", + "text": "金額不大啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4891.wav", + "text": "這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4892.wav", + "text": "第57條一年要花多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4893.wav", + "text": "沒多少錢吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4894.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4895.wav", + "text": "一年要多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4896.wav", + "text": "我們現在估一年將近五億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4897.wav", + "text": "騙騙公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4898.wav", + "text": "5%才多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4899.wav", + "text": "太少了按照比例調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4900.wav", + "text": "王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4901.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4902.wav", + "text": "補償金的範圍怎麼訂出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4903.wav", + "text": "之前的說法是參照現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4904.wav", + "text": "平均補償的狀況來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4905.wav", + "text": "但是我們一直以來在談的就是補償金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4906.wav", + "text": "符合現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4907.wav", + "text": "我們只有這筆費用而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4908.wav", + "text": "並不是增加費用反而是用人數來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4909.wav", + "text": "這其實很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4910.wav", + "text": "尤其是原條文的第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4911.wav", + "text": "針對死亡的部分加起來大概可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4912.wav", + "text": "已經覺得補償金不足的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4913.wav", + "text": "更加限縮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4914.wav", + "text": "120萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4915.wav", + "text": "減少自己的責任嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4916.wav", + "text": "還是希望能體貼犯罪被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4917.wav", + "text": "元現在反而也是下降到120萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4918.wav", + "text": "整體的預算不增加的清況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4919.wav", + "text": "這很奇怪啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4920.wav", + "text": "因為這是關於國家的責任如何去補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4921.wav", + "text": "而不是在於我的pool就是這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4922.wav", + "text": "你們要自己去分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4923.wav", + "text": "採取定額的話能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4924.wav", + "text": "就不用去瞭解有多少家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4925.wav", + "text": "還要計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4926.wav", + "text": "採取的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4927.wav", + "text": "會比較複雜而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4928.wav", + "text": "比較延宕如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4929.wav", + "text": "現在更方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4930.wav", + "text": "另外請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4931.wav", + "text": "損害賠償所以這只���救急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4932.wav", + "text": "快速讓喪家能夠處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4933.wav", + "text": "應該說我當初定義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4934.wav", + "text": "補償金是希望國家能負起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4935.wav", + "text": "這樣的責任能夠一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4936.wav", + "text": "因為急難救助有急難救助的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4937.wav", + "text": "這個在之前就討論過補償金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4938.wav", + "text": "絕對不是救急的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4939.wav", + "text": "就是當事人已經死亡的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4940.wav", + "text": "我們還要去判斷還要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4941.wav", + "text": "這部分要調降我覺得滿不合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4942.wav", + "text": "能協助的對象已經是這麼限縮的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4943.wav", + "text": "最高的定額而不是把它限縮下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4944.wav", + "text": "應該要回復到原本最高就是210萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4945.wav", + "text": "元重傷補償金就是180萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4946.wav", + "text": "元但原本是可以到180萬元的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4947.wav", + "text": "我們現在一直在談的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4948.wav", + "text": "過去的犯罪被害人保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4949.wav", + "text": "國家不夠積極協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4950.wav", + "text": "國家不該站在這個角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4951.wav", + "text": "而是應該主動來協助被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4952.wav", + "text": "所以這部分其實是要更審酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4953.wav", + "text": "更要積極處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4954.wav", + "text": "我們在補償金的部分卻是用限縮的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4955.wav", + "text": "財政GDP的規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4956.wav", + "text": "遺屬補償金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4957.wav", + "text": "新臺幣102十萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4958.wav", + "text": "元重傷補償金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4959.wav", + "text": "元性侵害補償金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4960.wav", + "text": "我本來是想要調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4961.wav", + "text": "重傷補償金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4962.wav", + "text": "比非洲國家還低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4963.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4964.wav", + "text": "過兩天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4965.wav", + "text": "立法院就要花1,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4966.wav", + "text": "差不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4967.wav", + "text": "部長犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4968.wav", + "text": "被害人補償金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4969.wav", + "text": "重傷是18" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4970.wav", + "text": "0萬元我覺得至少應該要維持原本的水準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4971.wav", + "text": "我再講一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4972.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4973.wav", + "text": "我們是用現在的推估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4974.wav", + "text": "大概要4億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4975.wav", + "text": "如果用200萬元來計算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4976.wav", + "text": "我們推估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4977.wav", + "text": "大概需要九億多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4978.wav", + "text": "好第57條暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4979.wav", + "text": "\n請大家看第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4980.wav", + "text": "59條如果大家沒有意見我們按照行政院的版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4981.wav", + "text": "稍等我一下我先看一下現在的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4982.wav", + "text": "因為我們的條文都被拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4983.wav", + "text": "王委員你還是要事前看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4984.wav", + "text": "他今天才給我要怎麼事前看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4985.wav", + "text": "你們應該對這個法案有你們的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4986.wav", + "text": "這次都沒有列上來我也覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4987.wav", + "text": "協商本來就是要所有版本都列在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4988.wav", + "text": "怎麼會我們的版本不見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4989.wav", + "text": "了還要叫我們另外自己準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4990.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得他們應該提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4991.wav", + "text": "同時應該把大家的版本列上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4992.wav", + "text": "這是行政院的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4993.wav", + "text": "為什麼會今天才看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4994.wav", + "text": "現在是照行政院的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4995.wav", + "text": "對所以我們的理由是一樣的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4996.wav", + "text": "被害人如果沒有滿18歲就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4997.wav", + "text": "所以應該是希望能夠爭取我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4998.wav", + "text": "當被害人對其被害有故意或重大過失者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/4999.wav", + "text": "應該要斟酌其具體情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5000.wav", + "text": "並且免除被害補償金的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5001.wav", + "text": "應該把未滿18歲的部分排除在條文之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5002.wav", + "text": "最主要還是希望能夠協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5003.wav", + "text": "如果純粹用年齡來區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5004.wav", + "text": "我們也很擔心會有一些道德危險的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5005.wav", + "text": "比如他自己本身也參與犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5006.wav", + "text": "誘發犯罪或是挑釁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5007.wav", + "text": "而造成死亡或傷害的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5008.wav", + "text": "也要全部補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5009.wav", + "text": "這點我們要看個案的情節來判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5010.wav", + "text": "完全用年齡的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5011.wav", + "text": "原因就在於當犯罪被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5012.wav", + "text": "或其遺屬與犯罪行為人之關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5013.wav", + "text": "有失妥當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5014.wav", + "text": "比如他可能有吸毒行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5015.wav", + "text": "要如何避免過去大家所詬病的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5016.wav", + "text": "問題─沒有辦法直接認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5017.wav", + "text": "他與這次的行為發生是否有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5018.wav", + "text": "我們尊重委員會的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5019.wav", + "text": "到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5020.wav", + "text": "來判斷它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5021.wav", + "text": "是不是有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5022.wav", + "text": "失當的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5023.wav", + "text": "之前的審議其實就是會有這樣的爭執" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5024.wav", + "text": "甚至有檢討被害人的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5025.wav", + "text": "未來要如何避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5026.wav", + "text": "請林司長再補充說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5027.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5028.wav", + "text": "我做個補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5029.wav", + "text": "這一條除了剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5030.wav", + "text": "部長說明有道德風險以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5031.wav", + "text": "我們要特別說明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5032.wav", + "text": "的第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5033.wav", + "text": "被害有可歸責的事由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5034.wav", + "text": "被害人的部分有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5035.wav", + "text": "要求過苛所以這次只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5036.wav", + "text": "侷限在故意跟重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5037.wav", + "text": "人對於被害的行為也有故意或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5038.wav", + "text": "重大過失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5039.wav", + "text": "完全把它排除在減除的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5040.wav", + "text": "範圍這部分真的確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5041.wav", + "text": "\n另外第2款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5042.wav", + "text": "最主要是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5043.wav", + "text": "有吸毒的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5044.wav", + "text": "如果他是被害人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5045.wav", + "text": "家屬那給了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5046.wav", + "text": "會不會有問題這是第2款的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5047.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5048.wav", + "text": "剛才委員所提到的這些情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5049.wav", + "text": "在審酌院版的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5050.wav", + "text": "已經參考相關的各種情狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5051.wav", + "text": "還有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5052.wav", + "text": "但這裡的認定是非常模糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5053.wav", + "text": "的比如因自己交友不慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5054.wav", + "text": "有所調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5055.wav", + "text": "也就是故意或重大過失這款沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5056.wav", + "text": "對其他情事做定義使其更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5057.wav", + "text": "可能會一直發生的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5058.wav", + "text": "第2款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5059.wav", + "text": "最主要還是著眼於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5060.wav", + "text": "譬如剛才所舉例的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5061.wav", + "text": "父母親虐待子女致死那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5062.wav", + "text": "人既是家人卻也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5063.wav", + "text": "被害人的家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5064.wav", + "text": "可能也有輕微過失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5065.wav", + "text": "犯罪被害補償金社會會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5066.wav", + "text": "大概是處理這種情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5067.wav", + "text": "這部分會在第1款處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5068.wav", + "text": "原來有可歸責的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5069.wav", + "text": "必須減除但現在已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5070.wav", + "text": "限縮在故意與重大過失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5071.wav", + "text": "的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5072.wav", + "text": "大家如果沒有意見第59條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5073.wav", + "text": "是不是照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5074.wav", + "text": "請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5075.wav", + "text": "行政院版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5076.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5077.wav", + "text": "法務部有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5078.wav", + "text": "大家沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5079.wav", + "text": "就依照法務部建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5080.wav", + "text": "審議補償會持續放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5081.wav", + "text": "像是在檢討他是否有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5082.wav", + "text": "必要申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5083.wav", + "text": "能移除並在地檢署之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5084.wav", + "text": "犯保協會或以基金會的方式來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5085.wav", + "text": "地檢的檢察量能有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5086.wav", + "text": "往往需要審議非常久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5087.wav", + "text": "於規定期間內審議完畢且比例是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5088.wav", + "text": "非常高的第二若設在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5089.wav", + "text": "來看會使得審議會變得有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5090.wav", + "text": "像在檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5091.wav", + "text": "請吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5092.wav", + "text": "的主張比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5093.wav", + "text": "相近也就是希望補償金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5094.wav", + "text": "法務部還是強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5095.wav", + "text": "要在地方檢察署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5096.wav", + "text": "分署請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5097.wav", + "text": "這部分如果到保護機構的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5098.wav", + "text": "這樣分工不是會比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5099.wav", + "text": "處理簡便性在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5100.wav", + "text": "設置於地檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5101.wav", + "text": "其實放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5102.wav", + "text": "檢察署對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5103.wav", + "text": "我們來講是一個負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5104.wav", + "text": "為這樣可以讓工作更順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5105.wav", + "text": "大家也可以利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5106.wav", + "text": "檢察署的行政資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5107.wav", + "text": "不在檢察署的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5108.wav", + "text": "委員來決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5109.wav", + "text": "所以大家也不要有顧忌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5110.wav", + "text": "認為放在地檢署會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5111.wav", + "text": "其實這樣反而會有方便性能夠提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5112.wav", + "text": "行政資源讓這個工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5113.wav", + "text": "做得更順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5114.wav", + "text": "至於真正的決定權還是在於外部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5115.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5116.wav", + "text": "好如果沒有意見的話就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5117.wav", + "text": "法務部建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5118.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5119.wav", + "text": "\n王委員還有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5120.wav", + "text": "我想確認一下因為現在各類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5121.wav", + "text": "專門學識之人是不得少於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5122.wav", + "text": "二分之一所以其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5123.wav", + "text": "檢察人員的比例也可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5124.wav", + "text": "將近二分之一對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5125.wav", + "text": "我們主要是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5126.wav", + "text": "審議委員會的同質性過高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5127.wav", + "text": "因為過去多是由檢察官來兼辦審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5128.wav", + "text": "才會有我們剛剛提到的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5129.wav", + "text": "情況現在雖然有訂定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5130.wav", + "text": "但是不得少於二分之一就是有可能還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5131.wav", + "text": "不是一定要二分之一留給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5132.wav", + "text": "檢察署的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5133.wav", + "text": "我們還是會聘請很多的專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5134.wav", + "text": "包括法律醫學心理社會工作者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5135.wav", + "text": "及犯罪防治等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5136.wav", + "text": "這些專家來參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5137.wav", + "text": "一個性別還有他的專類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5138.wav", + "text": "不得少於二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5139.wav", + "text": "並不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5140.wav", + "text": "各類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5141.wav", + "text": "加起來大部分還是都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5142.wav", + "text": "外面的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5143.wav", + "text": "那就照法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5144.wav", + "text": "建議條文通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5145.wav", + "text": "好通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5146.wav", + "text": "對第62條如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5147.wav", + "text": "就照行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5148.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5149.wav", + "text": "\n請再看第64條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5150.wav", + "text": "對第64條如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5151.wav", + "text": "也照行政院版通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5152.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5153.wav", + "text": "\n請看第68條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5154.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有我剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5155.wav", + "text": "那要不要調一下影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5156.wav", + "text": "第64條你有舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5157.wav", + "text": "應該是資料認定之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5158.wav", + "text": "調查到完全終結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5159.wav", + "text": "三個月內以書面為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5160.wav", + "text": "但我想請教實際上現在超過三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5161.wav", + "text": "以上完成的有多少三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5162.wav", + "text": "以內完成的有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5163.wav", + "text": "因為我相信這樣的設計並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5164.wav", + "text": "但就我們知道其實滿多不是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5165.wav", + "text": "三個月內完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5166.wav", + "text": "是我坦白承認我們有些案子是拖得比較久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5167.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5168.wav", + "text": "可以知道一下多少比例嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5169.wav", + "text": "我們現在一定要想辦法縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5170.wav", + "text": "給付所以會比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5171.wav", + "text": "我們初步是訂定三個月內一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5172.wav", + "text": "做一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5173.wav", + "text": "是從提出審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5174.wav", + "text": "還是偵查完後三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5175.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有就是知道這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5176.wav", + "text": "事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5177.wav", + "text": "64條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5178.wav", + "text": "可以嗎第64條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5179.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見的話就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5180.wav", + "text": "照院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5181.wav", + "text": "照院版通過\n請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5182.wav", + "text": "對第68條有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5183.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5184.wav", + "text": "對第69條有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5185.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5186.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5187.wav", + "text": "\n再來看第71條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5188.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5189.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5190.wav", + "text": "\n請看第75條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5191.wav", + "text": "對第75條有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5192.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5193.wav", + "text": "院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5194.wav", + "text": "條文通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5195.wav", + "text": "好\n請看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5196.wav", + "text": "第82條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5197.wav", + "text": "王委員第幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5198.wav", + "text": "委員會發言的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5199.wav", + "text": "嘛已經把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5200.wav", + "text": "該納進來的人都納進來了第7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5201.wav", + "text": "9條因為是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5202.wav", + "text": "才提出來的可以給我們1分鐘看一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5203.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5204.wav", + "text": "76條審查會已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5205.wav", + "text": "應該是沒有決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5206.wav", + "text": "建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5207.wav", + "text": "針對第82條法務部也有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5208.wav", + "text": "可以啦監察人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5209.wav", + "text": "\n請看第84條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5210.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5211.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5212.wav", + "text": "依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5213.wav", + "text": "有提出建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5214.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5215.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5216.wav", + "text": "建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5217.wav", + "text": "在審查會已經通過了對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5218.wav", + "text": "所提修正動議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5219.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5220.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5221.wav", + "text": "不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5222.wav", + "text": "要把第三章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5223.wav", + "text": "本來就應該納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5224.wav", + "text": "先談第101" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5225.wav", + "text": "有問題沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5226.wav", + "text": "先談第101" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5227.wav", + "text": "101" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5228.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5229.wav", + "text": "主要還是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5230.wav", + "text": "原本的犯罪被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5231.wav", + "text": "補償金是國家代償的性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5232.wav", + "text": "但是在我們這次的修法當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5233.wav", + "text": "其實是把它改為國家責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5234.wav", + "text": "的概念在進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5235.wav", + "text": "所以在原犯罪被害人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5236.wav", + "text": "之下如果我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5237.wav", + "text": "好像國家自己在第一審的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5238.wav", + "text": "認為被判有罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5239.wav", + "text": "所以就給了補償金但是在後來的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5240.wav", + "text": "又判定無罪時又要追回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5241.wav", + "text": "其實就有點像國家自己質疑國家的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5242.wav", + "text": "是一個國家責任的話不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5243.wav", + "text": "要求返還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5244.wav", + "text": "已作成被害補償金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5245.wav", + "text": "的決議者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5246.wav", + "text": "你們���時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5247.wav", + "text": "之前沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5248.wav", + "text": "會什麼時候通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5249.wav", + "text": "因為上次是說在協商時可以再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5250.wav", + "text": "出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5251.wav", + "text": "出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5252.wav", + "text": "對於本來之前通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5253.wav", + "text": "的條文當然可以在協商時再提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5254.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5255.wav", + "text": "這個有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5256.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5257.wav", + "text": "他提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5258.wav", + "text": "再修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5259.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5260.wav", + "text": "剛剛特別指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5261.wav", + "text": "由我來補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5262.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5263.wav", + "text": "原來的第101條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5264.wav", + "text": "在本法修正通過前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5265.wav", + "text": "已經補償出去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5266.wav", + "text": "對加害人的求償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5267.wav", + "text": "但是現在如果按照修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5268.wav", + "text": "動議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5269.wav", + "text": "變成對於在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5270.wav", + "text": "本法修正通過前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5271.wav", + "text": "對於加害人的求償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5272.wav", + "text": "這會造成一個很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5273.wav", + "text": "這是第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5274.wav", + "text": "修正動議最主要處理的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5275.wav", + "text": "有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5276.wav", + "text": "被害人已經發給補償金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5277.wav", + "text": "但是在二審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5278.wav", + "text": "譬如改判無罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5279.wav", + "text": "但是在返還這部分他認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5280.wav", + "text": "一年內可申請覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5281.wav", + "text": "但是問題來了這個時間事動態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5282.wav", + "text": "的那兩年三年可不可以申請覆議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5283.wav", + "text": "這就變成會產生一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5284.wav", + "text": "跟公平性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5285.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為這個修正動議在實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5286.wav", + "text": "可能會造成一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5287.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5288.wav", + "text": "你這個修正動議是要讓他免責嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5289.wav", + "text": "施行前的部分還是依照施行前的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5290.wav", + "text": "進行求償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5291.wav", + "text": "已經申請的部分不應該返還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5292.wav", + "text": "因為之前是可以返還的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5293.wav", + "text": "追回來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5294.wav", + "text": "所以就是修正前的部分已經作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5295.wav", + "text": "作成補償的也不要再追" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5296.wav", + "text": "還就是兩件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5297.wav", + "text": "這個我補充說明一下王委員有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5298.wav", + "text": "疑慮的部分其實在第6條我們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5299.wav", + "text": "在現行法的第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5300.wav", + "text": "款明定經查明其係不得申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5301.wav", + "text": "犯罪被害補償金者全部返還之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5302.wav", + "text": "這個是在現行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5303.wav", + "text": "他就一定要全部返還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5304.wav", + "text": "但是現在在第6條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5305.wav", + "text": "我們已經把這一款拿掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5306.wav", + "text": "所以實際上不會發生王委員所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5307.wav", + "text": "提到的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5308.wav", + "text": "所以你提出的第101條修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5309.wav", + "text": "就變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5310.wav", + "text": "王委員那此案是不是就撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5311.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5312.wav", + "text": "王委員是不是撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5313.wav", + "text": "還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5314.wav", + "text": "可不可以撤案還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5315.wav", + "text": "了解好我們先把它撤掉好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5316.wav", + "text": "好第101條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5317.wav", + "text": "\n請看第103條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5318.wav", + "text": "法務部有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5319.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5320.wav", + "text": "審查會也通過了對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5321.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5322.wav", + "text": "我想請問法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5323.wav", + "text": "第三章是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5324.wav", + "text": "剛才第35條的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5325.wav", + "text": "有準備時間所以才需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5326.wav", + "text": "納入做一個公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5327.wav", + "text": "就是要授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5328.wav", + "text": "對要一個緩衝期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5329.wav", + "text": "因為這部分保留了好幾章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5330.wav", + "text": "二三五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5331.wav", + "text": "好幾個章節都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5332.wav", + "text": "實施大概要多久因為我們對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5333.wav", + "text": "法的期待也蠻高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5334.wav", + "text": "希望能夠儘速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5335.wav", + "text": "是跟委員報告一下其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5336.wav", + "text": "像第二章的保護服務有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5337.wav", + "text": "資源的部分當然我們會在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5338.wav", + "text": "行政院的經費支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5339.wav", + "text": "實施第三章的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5340.wav", + "text": "真的是基於保護命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5341.wav", + "text": "不管是對院檢都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5342.wav", + "text": "一個新的制度所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5343.wav", + "text": "一定要有一個緩衝期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5344.wav", + "text": "本法通過之後我們會審慎的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5345.wav", + "text": "至於第五章跟第六章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5346.wav", + "text": "第五章是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5347.wav", + "text": "變動犯罪補償金原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5348.wav", + "text": "給付的問題現在改成國家的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5349.wav", + "text": "但是這個法通過以後也許會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5350.wav", + "text": "變成九億十億所以還是需要有一個緩衝期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5351.wav", + "text": "保護機構保護機構現有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5352.wav", + "text": "的犯罪被害人保護協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5353.wav", + "text": "的任期滿了之後在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5354.wav", + "text": "採互選的方式董事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5355.wav", + "text": "成員也都已經大幅改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5356.wav", + "text": "是用多元的方式進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5357.wav", + "text": "行政院訂定緩衝期來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5358.wav", + "text": "執行以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5359.wav", + "text": "本席還是希望能夠有比較明確的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5360.wav", + "text": "因為每次都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5361.wav", + "text": "能不能有個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5362.wav", + "text": "啊因為一拖就拖很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5363.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5364.wav", + "text": "謝謝王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5365.wav", + "text": "剛才第57條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5366.wav", + "text": "暫時保留現在回到第57條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5367.wav", + "text": "總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5368.wav", + "text": "把部長帶出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5369.wav", + "text": "協商結論唸一下\n協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5370.wav", + "text": "一第4條第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5371.wav", + "text": "第31條第38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5372.wav", + "text": "第48條第55條第59條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5373.wav", + "text": "第6條第62條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5374.wav", + "text": "第64條第68條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5375.wav", + "text": "第69條第71條第75條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5376.wav", + "text": "及第84條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5377.wav", + "text": "提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5378.wav", + "text": "\n二第3條第5條第十五條第二十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5379.wav", + "text": "第三十二條第三十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5380.wav", + "text": "第三十五條第四十一條第五十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5381.wav", + "text": "第六十一條第七十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5382.wav", + "text": "及第103條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5383.wav", + "text": "均照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5384.wav", + "text": "詳如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5385.wav", + "text": "\n三第57條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5386.wav", + "text": "暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5387.wav", + "text": "送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5388.wav", + "text": "暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5389.wav", + "text": "其餘均照審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5390.wav", + "text": "會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5391.wav", + "text": "各黨團委員提案及修正動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5392.wav", + "text": "議均列入公報紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5393.wav", + "text": "我們現在處理第六案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5394.wav", + "text": "性侵害犯罪防治法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5395.wav", + "text": "行政院版保留共9個條次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5396.wav", + "text": "如下第7條第十一條第十三條第三十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5397.wav", + "text": "看大家的意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5398.wav", + "text": "我們就處理保留的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5399.wav", + "text": "第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5400.wav", + "text": "請問大家對第7條有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5401.wav", + "text": "第7條照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5402.wav", + "text": "衛福部的修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5403.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5404.wav", + "text": "\n處理第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5405.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見就照行政院提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5406.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5407.wav", + "text": "第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5408.wav", + "text": "第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5409.wav", + "text": "有修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5410.wav", + "text": "就是加警察機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5411.wav", + "text": "照衛福部的修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5412.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5413.wav", + "text": "十三條有幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5414.wav", + "text": "我們在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5415.wav", + "text": "衛福部就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5416.wav", + "text": "已經有直接建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5417.wav", + "text": "而且阿中部長當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5418.wav", + "text": "還有答應大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5419.wav", + "text": "還是要有24小時內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5420.wav", + "text": "先行限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5421.wav", + "text": "瀏覽或移除的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5422.wav", + "text": "可能有一些網路業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5423.wav", + "text": "會覺得窒礙難行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5424.wav", + "text": "版本都是規定24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5425.wav", + "text": "當時也有跟數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5426.wav", + "text": "像PTT覺得因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5427.wav", + "text": "因為義工人數比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5428.wav", + "text": "所以做不到那我們可以規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5429.wav", + "text": "有一個但書的規定因為我覺得如果完全把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5430.wav", + "text": "24小時拿掉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5431.wav", + "text": "這樣似乎不太妥當\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5432.wav", + "text": "除了這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5433.wav", + "text": "180天的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5434.wav", + "text": "還有就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5435.wav", + "text": "能夠保留一個被害人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5436.wav", + "text": "申訴管道並公開揭示之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5437.wav", + "text": "因為有很多網路業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5438.wav", + "text": "都沒有處理這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5439.wav", + "text": "我就先講以上這兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5440.wav", + "text": "王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5441.wav", + "text": "內先行限制瀏覽或移除之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5442.wav", + "text": "包括對上傳者的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5443.wav", + "text": "就是希望能夠更積極的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5444.wav", + "text": "第二我想要提出一個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5445.wav", + "text": "其實在兒少保護的部分原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5446.wav", + "text": "應該要一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5447.wav", + "text": "用在對成人方面的限制上還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5448.wav", + "text": "倒數第2項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5449.wav", + "text": "不是以營利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5450.wav", + "text": "所要求的法定期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5451.wav", + "text": "位解釋並說明你們的立場是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5452.wav", + "text": "向各位做簡單的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5453.wav", + "text": "關於范委員剛才所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5454.wav", + "text": "24小時確實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5455.wav", + "text": "對他們有要求24小時內但是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5456.wav", + "text": "所以它並不是唯一的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5457.wav", + "text": "\n其實當時會這樣立法的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5458.wav", + "text": "其實是各式各樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5459.wav", + "text": "目前實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5460.wav", + "text": "其實他們一接到我們的通知就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5461.wav", + "text": "它會立刻產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5462.wav", + "text": "針對不同的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5463.wav", + "text": "都全部課予在24小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5464.wav", + "text": "目前在實務上其實是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5465.wav", + "text": "所以我們是不是可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5466.wav", + "text": "所有的平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5467.wav", + "text": "都必須要統一系統的時候我們再來考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5468.wav", + "text": "這樣或許比較不會違反比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5469.wav", + "text": "要保留還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5470.wav", + "text": "關於這一題我是看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5471.wav", + "text": "跟你的解釋不大一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5472.wav", + "text": "它規定得很清楚就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5473.wav", + "text": "��們在這裡可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5474.wav", + "text": "譬如說PTT或是這個平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5475.wav", + "text": "業者情有可原的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5476.wav", + "text": "有一個例外的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5477.wav", + "text": "可是現在完全拿掉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5478.wav", + "text": "一個規範了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5479.wav", + "text": "你剛才有提及比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5480.wav", + "text": "如果在歐盟澳洲可以做到的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5481.wav", + "text": "我不知道這個比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5482.wav", + "text": "有什麼問題因為這個部分其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5483.wav", + "text": "已經是犯法的行為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5484.wav", + "text": "這是一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5485.wav", + "text": "因為目前有一些論壇其實侵害的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5486.wav", + "text": "更厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5487.wav", + "text": "你必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5488.wav", + "text": "假設你用硬性的一個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5489.wav", + "text": "硬性的一個規定的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5490.wav", + "text": "在實務適用上真的會出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5491.wav", + "text": "請王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5492.wav", + "text": "我想大家的意見都是比較接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5493.wav", + "text": "24小時是一個原則例外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5494.wav", + "text": "這是在委員會大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5495.wav", + "text": "七弄八弄變成這樣這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5496.wav", + "text": "這個暫停一下我們把上面那一條先處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5497.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5498.wav", + "text": "57條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5499.wav", + "text": "我們先處理第57條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5500.wav", + "text": "57條現在是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5501.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5502.wav", + "text": "我希望大家能夠好好來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5503.wav", + "text": "因為過去的制度是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5504.wav", + "text": "過去的制度有代位求償要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5505.wav", + "text": "現在是定額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5506.wav", + "text": "不能扣來扣去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5507.wav", + "text": "所以過去死亡真的能夠領到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5508.wav", + "text": "的只有五十幾萬元而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5509.wav", + "text": "0萬元如果要再加沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5510.wav", + "text": "趁主計長還沒有回電話以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5511.wav", + "text": "我們把它解決掉就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5512.wav", + "text": "一口價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5513.wav", + "text": "0萬元然後重傷補償是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5514.wav", + "text": "我們也提高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5515.wav", + "text": "將補償金提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5516.wav", + "text": "這已經改變很多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5517.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5518.wav", + "text": "現在大家都同意我們就照這樣好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5519.wav", + "text": "好那就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5520.wav", + "text": "我想補充說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5521.wav", + "text": "平均五十幾萬元的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5522.wav", + "text": "是因為我們財政的總額沒有變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5523.wav", + "text": "最高加起來是不能超過210萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5524.wav", + "text": "所以其實並不能用51萬元來計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5525.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個還是要說明清楚啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5526.wav", + "text": "我是覺得可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5527.wav", + "text": "現在就是因為在國家責任的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5528.wav", + "text": "還有我們財務預算整體應該來做個評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5529.wav", + "text": "用180萬元為上限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5530.wav", + "text": "可是我覺得這個脈絡還是得在這邊跟大家說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5531.wav", + "text": "夠領210萬元的很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5532.wav", + "text": "我理解但是過去的審議制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5533.wav", + "text": "真的是很難看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5534.wav", + "text": "我還是要講以前的審議制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5535.wav", + "text": "一個是代位的問題一個是審議機制的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5536.wav", + "text": "所以我還是想特別提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5537.wav", + "text": "還是務必要請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5538.wav", + "text": "要求的時間內完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5539.wav", + "text": "不然那個法規就是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5540.wav", + "text": "在3個月內要完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5541.wav", + "text": "但是不合3個月以內的非常之多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5542.wav", + "text": "其實這就已經失去國家責任的問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5543.wav", + "text": "而且沒有辦法讓被害人覺得有被安慰到的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5544.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5545.wav", + "text": "我要先走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5546.wav", + "text": "簽完再走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5547.wav", + "text": "先簽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5548.wav", + "text": "沒有已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5549.wav", + "text": "我要走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5550.wav", + "text": "不要啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5551.wav", + "text": "很快嘛快要結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5552.wav", + "text": "少性剝削防制條例關鍵條文只有一條是不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5553.wav", + "text": "不是明天要我佛慈悲好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5554.wav", + "text": "什麼意思我我說給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5555.wav", + "text": "沒關係現在不要講不好看這是直播不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5556.wav", + "text": "跟各位報告大家辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5557.wav", + "text": "現在已經晚上9點18分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5558.wav", + "text": "大家辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5559.wav", + "text": "一今天協商有結論的法案請各黨團簽署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5560.wav", + "text": "二尚未完成簽署的請委員會幕僚協調各黨團繼續完成簽署後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5561.wav", + "text": "送議事處俾供院會進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5562.wav", + "text": "三今天的法案協商就到此告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5563.wav", + "text": "四明天早上9時開始進行總預算案密集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5564.wav", + "text": "好今天未審完的兩個法案先審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5565.wav", + "text": "請各黨團到紅樓302會議室進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14759/5566.wav", + "text": "現在散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/0.wav", + "text": "法院黨團協商會議今天會議研商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/1.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/2.wav", + "text": "因為我們剛剛有聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/3.wav", + "text": "用嘛比較極致的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/4.wav", + "text": "有沒有需要的問題人家不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/5.wav", + "text": "我們現在要談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/6.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/7.wav", + "text": "須審視的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/8.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們還是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/9.wav", + "text": "回到我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/10.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/11.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14758/12.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/0.wav", + "text": "各位先進大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1.wav", + "text": "現在我們來進行立法院黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2.wav", + "text": "今天協商的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/3.wav", + "text": "包括一繼續研商溫室氣體減量及管理法修正草案等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/4.wav", + "text": "(如議案列表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/5.wav", + "text": ")二研商公務人員任用法第22條條文修正草案等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/6.wav", + "text": "(國民黨黨團提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/7.wav", + "text": "繼續進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/8.wav", + "text": "協商在進行之前我在這邊介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/9.wav", + "text": "首先介紹行政院環境保護署署長張子敬先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/10.wav", + "text": "再來介紹經濟部政務次長曾文生先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/11.wav", + "text": "再來介紹交通部政務次長陳彥伯先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/12.wav", + "text": "再來介紹海洋委員會主任秘書劉國列先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/13.wav", + "text": "再來介紹原住民族委員會副主任委員鍾興華先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/14.wav", + "text": "再來介紹司法院副秘書長黃麟倫先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/15.wav", + "text": "以上介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/16.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們就來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/17.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量及管理法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/18.wav", + "text": "看看大家有沒有要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/19.wav", + "text": "這個法出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/20.wav", + "text": "出了委員會以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/21.wav", + "text": "有經過朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/22.wav", + "text": "保留20條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/23.wav", + "text": "條文我們在這裡再增加1條就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/24.wav", + "text": "第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/25.wav", + "text": "當然各黨要增加哪一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/26.wav", + "text": "我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/27.wav", + "text": "針對這幾條條文做協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/28.wav", + "text": "保留這20條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/29.wav", + "text": "條文有提出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/30.wav", + "text": "請大家參酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/31.wav", + "text": "酌我看到各黨都有提出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/32.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員有提第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/33.wav", + "text": "第十八條的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/34.wav", + "text": "等一下我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/35.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/36.wav", + "text": "與會的各位部次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/37.wav", + "text": "這個條文保留得相當多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/38.wav", + "text": "保留了20條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/39.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷因應法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/40.wav", + "text": "的影響太大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/41.wav", + "text": "所以就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/42.wav", + "text": "還在跟環保署在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/43.wav", + "text": "就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/44.wav", + "text": "保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/45.wav", + "text": "機關應該要再去思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/46.wav", + "text": "就是讓這樣的一部法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/47.wav", + "text": "未來通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/48.wav", + "text": "能夠達到它的效用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/49.wav", + "text": "我早上也有跟副署長談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/50.wav", + "text": "其實德國聯邦憲法法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/51.wav", + "text": "在2021年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/52.wav", + "text": "就作出一個判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/53.wav", + "text": "德國氣候變遷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/54.wav", + "text": "於氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/55.wav", + "text": "事實上不只是對現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/56.wav", + "text": "住在臺灣這塊島嶼上的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/57.wav", + "text": "也侵害了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/58.wav", + "text": "未來世代的自由權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/59.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/60.wav", + "text": "就像我們提到第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/61.wav", + "text": "邱顯智總召抱歉我再說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/62.wav", + "text": "如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/63.wav", + "text": "機關重新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/64.wav", + "text": "去做考慮事實上我們是可以理性地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/65.wav", + "text": "對話的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/66.wav", + "text": "有的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/67.wav", + "text": "其實是可以再做思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/68.wav", + "text": "的譬如像第29條第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/69.wav", + "text": "因為你好不容易去訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/70.wav", + "text": "我們當然是希望訂碳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/71.wav", + "text": "在好不容易訂了碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/72.wav", + "text": "的情況之下你後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/73.wav", + "text": "又開了一個優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/74.wav", + "text": "你要讓我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/75.wav", + "text": "他知道我在講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/76.wav", + "text": "發表意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/77.wav", + "text": "在這種情況之下你又開了一個後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/78.wav", + "text": "好不容易建立一個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/79.wav", + "text": "但你又開了一個後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/80.wav", + "text": "而且你的後門第29條第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/81.wav", + "text": "空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/82.wav", + "text": "假設我們今天通過第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/83.wav", + "text": "我們也不知道通過了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/84.wav", + "text": "這才是最嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/85.wav", + "text": "嚴肅來思考負責任的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/86.wav", + "text": "不只是對我們這個世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/87.wav", + "text": "也是對未來世代的臺灣人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/88.wav", + "text": "負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/89.wav", + "text": "直接進入逐條來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/90.wav", + "text": "但是剛才林奕華委員有舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/91.wav", + "text": "你稍微簡短講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/92.wav", + "text": "我們就進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/93.wav", + "text": "剛才有跟總召拜託就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/94.wav", + "text": "第42條通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/95.wav", + "text": "做比較明確的入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/96.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是要提一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/97.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠把短中長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/98.wav", + "text": "的目標入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/99.wav", + "text": "還有關於碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/100.wav", + "text": "碳稅希望有中央和地方合作的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/101.wav", + "text": "碳費的話有沒有可能有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/102.wav", + "text": "碳稅的日出條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/103.wav", + "text": "而碳費日落的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/104.wav", + "text": "我們也希望可以入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/105.wav", + "text": "碳排基金我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/106.wav", + "text": "一樣能把部分的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/107.wav", + "text": "用在減碳計畫和減碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/108.wav", + "text": "很高比例都用在獎勵企業的減碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/109.wav", + "text": "論但有些理念的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/110.wav", + "text": "理念的東西講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/111.wav", + "text": "到那一個條文我們有不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/112.wav", + "text": "但是有一個很重要的事我要拜託院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/113.wav", + "text": "跟柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/114.wav", + "text": "我覺得氣候變遷因應法難得修一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/115.wav", + "text": "不要討論講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/116.wav", + "text": "論講一講就說保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/117.wav", + "text": "因為每次都用表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/118.wav", + "text": "這種法儘量不要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/119.wav", + "text": "拜託一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/120.wav", + "text": "我們還是依照慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/121.wav", + "text": "我們現在進入逐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/122.wav", + "text": "逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/123.wav", + "text": "碰到意見不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/124.wav", + "text": "我們就暫時先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/125.wav", + "text": "往前都走一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/126.wav", + "text": "再回頭來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/127.wav", + "text": "這樣來處理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/128.wav", + "text": "\n現在就請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/129.wav", + "text": "第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/130.wav", + "text": "第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/131.wav", + "text": "行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/132.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/133.wav", + "text": "規定不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/134.wav", + "text": "我相信院長也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/135.wav", + "text": "在座有很多行政官員在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/136.wav", + "text": "我當公務員那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/137.wav", + "text": "涉及到各部會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/138.wav", + "text": "權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/139.wav", + "text": "有時候不是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/140.wav", + "text": "所以國民黨黨版是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/141.wav", + "text": "把各部會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/142.wav", + "text": "權責訂清楚不然到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/143.wav", + "text": "到底是財政部還是金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/144.wav", + "text": "不清不楚真的不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/145.wav", + "text": "我真的是好意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/146.wav", + "text": "我們很尊重各黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/147.wav", + "text": "第3頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/148.wav", + "text": "誰的第3頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/149.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/150.wav", + "text": "在第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/151.wav", + "text": "我們的後來修正就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/152.wav", + "text": "把您剛才的建議放到第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/153.wav", + "text": "你參考一下我們的第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/154.wav", + "text": "就是把你剛才提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/155.wav", + "text": "中央目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/156.wav", + "text": "的分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/157.wav", + "text": "用第8條的方式處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/158.wav", + "text": "這樣不會在第2條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/159.wav", + "text": "我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/160.wav", + "text": "第4頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/161.wav", + "text": "應該是小本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/162.wav", + "text": "有紅字這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/163.wav", + "text": "剛才發的小本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/164.wav", + "text": "不要寫在第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/165.wav", + "text": "我們把它寫在第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/166.wav", + "text": "這樣第2條就不會太混雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/167.wav", + "text": "原來第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/168.wav", + "text": "只有職掌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/169.wav", + "text": "但是沒有各部會的目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/170.wav", + "text": "是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/171.wav", + "text": "這樣寫第2條就會很乾淨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/172.wav", + "text": "就是中央目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/173.wav", + "text": "針對職掌和所謂的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/174.wav", + "text": "分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/175.wav", + "text": "看第8條就清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/176.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/177.wav", + "text": "你要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/178.wav", + "text": "我們就不用一個一個問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/179.wav", + "text": "這樣會更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/180.wav", + "text": "行政院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/181.wav", + "text": "然後第8條再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/182.wav", + "text": "馬上看第8條也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/183.wav", + "text": "第2條和第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/184.wav", + "text": "我們其實在第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/185.wav", + "text": "再生能源及能源科技的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/186.wav", + "text": "但是我們要強調的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/187.wav", + "text": "是從溫室氣體管理法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/188.wav", + "text": "演變過來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/189.wav", + "text": "主要是要減碳因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/190.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/191.wav", + "text": "效應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/192.wav", + "text": "其實再生能源是解方之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/193.wav", + "text": "但不是全部的解方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/194.wav", + "text": "所以我們的建議是寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/195.wav", + "text": "潔淨能源而不是再生能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/196.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/197.wav", + "text": "第四點是交通部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/198.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/199.wav", + "text": "建築部門溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/200.wav", + "text": "服務業溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/201.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/202.wav", + "text": "幾乎各個部門的溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/203.wav", + "text": "都在這個條文裡面\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/204.wav", + "text": "其實溫室氣體排放最大宗是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/205.wav", + "text": "能源部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/206.wav", + "text": "能源使用效率提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/207.wav", + "text": "也就是節約能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/208.wav", + "text": "並沒有提到能源部門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/209.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量這其實很好笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/210.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/211.wav", + "text": "加入能源部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/212.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/213.wav", + "text": "當然主管機關就是經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/214.wav", + "text": "因為底下是能源局和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/215.wav", + "text": "台電主管的謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/216.wav", + "text": "我聽懂吳怡玎委員的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/217.wav", + "text": "但我要跟你講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/218.wav", + "text": "一開始環保署的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/219.wav", + "text": "就是某某主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/220.wav", + "text": "如同你剛剛說的教育主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/221.wav", + "text": "交通主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/222.wav", + "text": "等什麼什麼主管機關一開始是用這個方式寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/223.wav", + "text": "可是後來有滿多專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/224.wav", + "text": "學者認為這個寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/225.wav", + "text": "很容易漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/226.wav", + "text": "運具電動化算誰的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/227.wav", + "text": "這跟交通部有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/228.wav", + "text": "跟經濟部也有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/229.wav", + "text": "我只是舉這個例子而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/230.wav", + "text": "所以後來環保署這邊才討論出一個新的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/231.wav", + "text": "就是把具體的工作事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/232.wav", + "text": "寫在主體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/233.wav", + "text": "誰協辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/234.wav", + "text": "所以像運具電動化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/235.wav", + "text": "這麼重要的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/236.wav", + "text": "經濟部協辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/237.wav", + "text": "不然按照原本的交通主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/238.wav", + "text": "的狀況來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/239.wav", + "text": "其實會寫不進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/240.wav", + "text": "因為它也有涉及經濟部的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/241.wav", + "text": "現在把它倒回來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/242.wav", + "text": "誰協辦這樣可以把主辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/243.wav", + "text": "和協辦都放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/244.wav", + "text": "因為有些工作是跨部會的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/245.wav", + "text": "所以用這個方式來表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/246.wav", + "text": "潔淨能源其實我們在協商時都談過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/247.wav", + "text": "再生能源和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/248.wav", + "text": "能源科技發展裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/249.wav", + "text": "就是把一些新的能源技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/250.wav", + "text": "也放在能源科技發展裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/251.wav", + "text": "其實是包括在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/252.wav", + "text": "所以你的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/253.wav", + "text": "再生能源屬於能源科技的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/254.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/255.wav", + "text": "新的能源科技發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/256.wav", + "text": "可能包括核融合它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/257.wav", + "text": "它是放在能源科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/258.wav", + "text": "發展裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/259.wav", + "text": "那請問一下能源部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/260.wav", + "text": "的溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/261.wav", + "text": "吳委員我跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/262.wav", + "text": "對總召沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/263.wav", + "text": "請寫進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/264.wav", + "text": "我問個程序的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/265.wav", + "text": "這是朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/266.wav", + "text": "不這是程序的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/267.wav", + "text": "他的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/268.wav", + "text": "曾委員沒有關係啦朝野協商是大家都可以發言的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/269.wav", + "text": "沒有人這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/270.wav", + "text": "立法委員在主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/271.wav", + "text": "在決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/272.wav", + "text": "邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/273.wav", + "text": "請陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/274.wav", + "text": "部會權責入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/275.wav", + "text": "我們也非常肯定環保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/276.wav", + "text": "將部會權責入法放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/277.wav", + "text": "我們的版本跟他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/278.wav", + "text": "在財政部的部分我們希望財" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/279.wav", + "text": "參照各國碳費終究是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/280.wav", + "text": "跟環保署談的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/281.wav", + "text": "的路徑是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/282.wav", + "text": "要徵碳費碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/283.wav", + "text": "基本上是特別公課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/284.wav", + "text": "但是它的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/285.wav", + "text": "並不如碳稅這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/286.wav", + "text": "收進來之後進行社會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/287.wav", + "text": "重分配等等之類的情狀所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/288.wav", + "text": "碳費終究是要落日的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/289.wav", + "text": "徵收碳稅為主要原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/290.wav", + "text": "所分配到的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/291.wav", + "text": "氣候調適的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/292.wav", + "text": "第三個是國防部國防部應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/293.wav", + "text": "也有事情做基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/294.wav", + "text": "的演練並且進行相關的盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/295.wav", + "text": "這是部會權責入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/296.wav", + "text": "其實有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/297.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷因應與能源轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/298.wav", + "text": "會報應該要有一個會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/299.wav", + "text": "院版的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/300.wav", + "text": "現在出現一個問題即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/301.wav", + "text": "永續會長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/302.wav", + "text": "功能不彰這是不爭的事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/303.wav", + "text": "在這麼龐大任務的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/304.wav", + "text": "之下以永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/305.wav", + "text": "邱委員你已經講到第2條去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/306.wav", + "text": "是在這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/307.wav", + "text": "量能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/308.wav", + "text": "到底夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/309.wav", + "text": "有沒有足夠的編制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/310.wav", + "text": "等一下請環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/311.wav", + "text": "來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/312.wav", + "text": "究竟你是認為現有的分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/313.wav", + "text": "已經足以駕馭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/314.wav", + "text": "還是要如何去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/315.wav", + "text": "其實在我們對話的過程之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/316.wav", + "text": "環保署也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/317.wav", + "text": "設計有一個會報的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/318.wav", + "text": "人總的中央行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/319.wav", + "text": "組織基準法第5條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/320.wav", + "text": "人總及財政部找來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/321.wav", + "text": "針對這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/322.wav", + "text": "不管是參考日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/323.wav", + "text": "人家是有一個專責機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/324.wav", + "text": "具有充足的人力跟量能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/325.wav", + "text": "還有專責人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/326.wav", + "text": "等一下也請機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/327.wav", + "text": "回應如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/328.wav", + "text": "的要求以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/329.wav", + "text": "請陳委員發言再請吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/330.wav", + "text": "等兩位發言完以後再請環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/331.wav", + "text": "針對吳委員的建議就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/332.wav", + "text": "能源部門的溫室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/333.wav", + "text": "氣體減量本席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/334.wav", + "text": "非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/335.wav", + "text": "能源使用效率提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/336.wav", + "text": "及能源節約事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/337.wav", + "text": "不知道是不是就能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/338.wav", + "text": "第2項第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/339.wav", + "text": "製造及能源部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/340.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/341.wav", + "text": "這是我的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/342.wav", + "text": "就是在第3款的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/343.wav", + "text": "加3個字就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/344.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/345.wav", + "text": "\n針對剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/346.wav", + "text": "邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/347.wav", + "text": "也有提到的永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/348.wav", + "text": "當然目前永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/349.wav", + "text": "有沒有法制的編制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/350.wav", + "text": "這個部分還是讓人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/351.wav", + "text": "換了院長以後它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/352.wav", + "text": "推行功能或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/353.wav", + "text": "所以我是建議我們在這個法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/354.wav", + "text": "要把永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/355.wav", + "text": "的身分明定清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/356.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/357.wav", + "text": "很簡單地說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/358.wav", + "text": "主辦的部分從第4頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/359.wav", + "text": "現在我們是不是先讓他回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/360.wav", + "text": "再繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/361.wav", + "text": "好你講完後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/362.wav", + "text": "我是希望環保署講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/363.wav", + "text": "立法原則裡面第2條跟第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/364.wav", + "text": "當然輕重不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/365.wav", + "text": "放到前面的權責機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/366.wav", + "text": "落實的執行性跟放在第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/367.wav", + "text": "是永續會轄下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/368.wav", + "text": "跨十幾個部門的協調整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/369.wav", + "text": "這本來就是不同屬性的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/370.wav", + "text": "例所以請你們說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/371.wav", + "text": "第二個你增列的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/372.wav", + "text": "職掌者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/373.wav", + "text": "這個職掌者是不是就是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/374.wav", + "text": "第8條下面列舉的各款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/375.wav", + "text": "如果是那麼職掌的關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/376.wav", + "text": "跟執法員主責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/377.wav", + "text": "單位是不是永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/378.wav", + "text": "永續會在行政的關係上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/379.wav", + "text": "是一個任務型編組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/380.wav", + "text": "主要的主委就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/381.wav", + "text": "造成的效果跟用職掌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/382.wav", + "text": "去分類的第8條的關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/383.wav", + "text": "因為陳椒華委員以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/384.wav", + "text": "是永續會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/385.wav", + "text": "督考之責嗎還是他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/386.wav", + "text": "也負決策之責所以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/387.wav", + "text": "立法例裡面要把第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/388.wav", + "text": "跟第2條的關聯性說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/389.wav", + "text": "這樣子比較能夠讓大家同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/390.wav", + "text": "不管是用會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/391.wav", + "text": "各位很清楚永續會過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/392.wav", + "text": "真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/393.wav", + "text": "不彰氣候變遷幾乎涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/394.wav", + "text": "都很難置身事外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/395.wav", + "text": "行政院院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/396.wav", + "text": "了而且事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/397.wav", + "text": "真的涉及到非常廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/398.wav", + "text": "所以我是強烈主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/399.wav", + "text": "不要用永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/400.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷會報或者委員會都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/401.wav", + "text": "啦游院長當過行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/402.wav", + "text": "已經績效不彰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/403.wav", + "text": "這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/404.wav", + "text": "重視氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/405.wav", + "text": "有些開會有些不開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/406.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷這麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/407.wav", + "text": "成立一個專責委員會或會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/408.wav", + "text": "你都不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/409.wav", + "text": "我覺得這表示你根本不重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/410.wav", + "text": "而且這個事情到時要落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/411.wav", + "text": "由院長召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/412.wav", + "text": "一個氣候變遷因應會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/413.wav", + "text": "我覺得才符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/414.wav", + "text": "它的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/415.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/416.wav", + "text": "國民黨也沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/417.wav", + "text": "是要到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/418.wav", + "text": "真的能夠做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/419.wav", + "text": "我們的產業也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/420.wav", + "text": "才有辦法融入世界的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/421.wav", + "text": "但假設你們不成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/422.wav", + "text": "我們也沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/423.wav", + "text": "第2條及第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/424.wav", + "text": "大家的意見很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/425.wav", + "text": "我們今天的案子也滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/426.wav", + "text": "所以如果一直停留在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/427.wav", + "text": "既然第2條及第8條的意見這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/428.wav", + "text": "是不是我們再協調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/429.wav", + "text": "暫時保留繼續往下走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/430.wav", + "text": "等一下再回頭來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/431.wav", + "text": "包括環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/432.wav", + "text": "我的問題比較簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/433.wav", + "text": "國民黨團版本的第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/434.wav", + "text": "後有兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/435.wav", + "text": "分在條文上面沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/436.wav", + "text": "所以想確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/437.wav", + "text": "第一個是在國民黨團的第十二項提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/438.wav", + "text": "之誘因機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/439.wav", + "text": "的但現在的建議修正條文並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/440.wav", + "text": "沒有這個第十二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/441.wav", + "text": "項想瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/442.wav", + "text": "為什麼會被拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/443.wav", + "text": "對於勞工權益就業安全保障的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/444.wav", + "text": "會比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/445.wav", + "text": "公正轉型之推動事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/446.wav", + "text": "所以我想要確認國民黨團原來第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/447.wav", + "text": "2項強調勞工權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/448.wav", + "text": "有沒有包括在公正轉型的推動事項中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/449.wav", + "text": "中我覺得這個部分也要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/450.wav", + "text": "我們才知道國民黨團所列出的點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/451.wav", + "text": "條文之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/452.wav", + "text": "所以第2項有沒有在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/453.wav", + "text": "另外第十二項為什麼會不見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/454.wav", + "text": "總召所說原住民族的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/455.wav", + "text": "洪委員發言後再請環保署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/456.wav", + "text": "我們就focus在第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/457.wav", + "text": "及第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/458.wav", + "text": "有關第8條的部分當初我們的主張就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/459.wav", + "text": "明文入法即有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/460.wav", + "text": "哪些單位負責哪個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/461.wav", + "text": "提到氣體減量誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/462.wav", + "text": "的部分為什麼會拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/463.wav", + "text": "這個等一下請說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/464.wav", + "text": "因為減量誘因其實相對是重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/465.wav", + "text": "十八款的部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/466.wav", + "text": "共同討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/467.wav", + "text": "因為在這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/468.wav", + "text": "二十項裡面大家都寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/469.wav", + "text": "變遷的氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/470.wav", + "text": "運具減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/471.wav", + "text": "事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/472.wav", + "text": "到最後會不會每個都扣一個大帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/473.wav", + "text": "說這是公正轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/474.wav", + "text": "每個都要適用這一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/475.wav", + "text": "一點還是說某個事項要轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/476.wav", + "text": "就是公正如果原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/477.wav", + "text": "被轉型的就是不公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/478.wav", + "text": "會不會反而讓民眾有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/479.wav", + "text": "事只要被轉型的就是不公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/480.wav", + "text": "轉型之後的才叫公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/481.wav", + "text": "我認為這樣好像也有點不妥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/482.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/483.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長各位委員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/484.wav", + "text": "我綜合跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/485.wav", + "text": "做一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/486.wav", + "text": "因為第2條主要是規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/487.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關及目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/488.wav", + "text": "的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/489.wav", + "text": "為什麼會將大家所關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/490.wav", + "text": "主協辦放到第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/491.wav", + "text": "有關國家相關的協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/492.wav", + "text": "分工整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/493.wav", + "text": "是由永續會來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/494.wav", + "text": "因為永續會是根據環境基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/495.wav", + "text": "是由院長擔任主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/496.wav", + "text": "所以各部會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/497.wav", + "text": "首長幾乎都是委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/498.wav", + "text": "因此其實它的組成是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/499.wav", + "text": "足夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/500.wav", + "text": "當然大家也一直很關心永續會的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/501.wav", + "text": "因為以前永續會只負責永續發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/502.wav", + "text": "所以放在環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/503.wav", + "text": "這裡由環保署當幕僚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/504.wav", + "text": "所以大家一直覺得它開會好像很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/505.wav", + "text": "功能也不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/506.wav", + "text": "為了讓它能夠足以扮演這個角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/507.wav", + "text": "所以我們已經把永續會的秘書處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/508.wav", + "text": "改由國發會負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/509.wav", + "text": "也由國發會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/510.wav", + "text": "主委來擔任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/511.wav", + "text": "執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/512.wav", + "text": "所以各位可以看到在我們宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/513.wav", + "text": "2050淨零排放的目標之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/514.wav", + "text": "不管是我們2050路徑的提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/515.wav", + "text": "或是最近提出的NDC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/516.wav", + "text": "龔主委所主導的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/517.wav", + "text": "這個機制底下來把這些做起來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/518.wav", + "text": "以前的績效不彰那是以前的運作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/519.wav", + "text": "現在它被賦予的責任不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/520.wav", + "text": "它運作方式不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/521.wav", + "text": "它的功能在強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/522.wav", + "text": "所以從這一陣子所提出的東西來看它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/523.wav", + "text": "所以我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/524.wav", + "text": "讓永續會負責是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/525.wav", + "text": "在第8條各位可以看到我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/526.wav", + "text": "設計永續會擔任協調分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/527.wav", + "text": "各部會的分工寫在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/528.wav", + "text": "第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/529.wav", + "text": "會不會有哪些沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/530.wav", + "text": "放進來這也是我們原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/531.wav", + "text": "我們就是擔心這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/532.wav", + "text": "但是因為很多委員都覺得應該要寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/533.wav", + "text": "所以我們也尊重大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/534.wav", + "text": "因為會擔心像剛剛所提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/535.wav", + "text": "所以在第8條最後的第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/536.wav", + "text": "因為第1項寫的是永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/537.wav", + "text": "所以第2款我們就加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/538.wav", + "text": "如果沒有在這裡面寫到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/539.wav", + "text": "部分由永續會負責來協調指定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/540.wav", + "text": "希望把它補起來\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/541.wav", + "text": "有關綠色誘因的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/542.wav", + "text": "我們現在希望透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/543.wav", + "text": "碳費的收取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/544.wav", + "text": "以及它的交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/545.wav", + "text": "來形成一些誘因機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/546.wav", + "text": "讓它可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/547.wav", + "text": "不需要在這裡寫因為財政部本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/548.wav", + "text": "就可以定至於它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/549.wav", + "text": "因為歐盟的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/550.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會提出所謂碳費先行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/551.wav", + "text": "至於稅是不是要上來就要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/552.wav", + "text": "效果如果它達不到我們預期的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/553.wav", + "text": "如果它可以達到效果我們其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/554.wav", + "text": "就可以繼續去推沒有什麼不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/555.wav", + "text": "但不會因為沒有日出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/556.wav", + "text": "而妨礙到稅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/557.wav", + "text": "成立這是我跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/558.wav", + "text": "報告的\n另外剛剛有委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/559.wav", + "text": "心所謂的公正轉型請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/560.wav", + "text": "各位可以翻到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/561.wav", + "text": "所以各位可以看到最底下有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/562.wav", + "text": "說明欄的補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/563.wav", + "text": "所謂的勞工所以剛剛有委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/564.wav", + "text": "公正轉型的主要用意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/565.wav", + "text": "因為20" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/566.wav", + "text": "排放的轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/567.wav", + "text": "可能受到傷害的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/568.wav", + "text": "部分我們要怎麼樣在這個過程裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/569.wav", + "text": "去照顧到他們減少他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/570.wav", + "text": "公正轉型比較主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/571.wav", + "text": "就各位委員剛剛提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/572.wav", + "text": "出來的幾個意見跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/573.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/574.wav", + "text": "院長他沒有回答我的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/575.wav", + "text": "他完全跳過我的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/576.wav", + "text": "孔委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/577.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/578.wav", + "text": "行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/579.wav", + "text": "所提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/580.wav", + "text": "事實上我們上一次開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/581.wav", + "text": "的時候本來是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/582.wav", + "text": "原民會最大的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/583.wav", + "text": "是有把原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/584.wav", + "text": "本來行政院版本是沒有原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/585.wav", + "text": "裡面什麼部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/586.wav", + "text": "都有環保署也有國發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/587.wav", + "text": "會也有經濟部也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/588.wav", + "text": "被忽略的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/589.wav", + "text": "第十九款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/590.wav", + "text": "最後今天有把它列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/591.wav", + "text": "不要忘記我們整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/592.wav", + "text": "臺灣的資源包括森林主權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/593.wav", + "text": "碳權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/594.wav", + "text": "臺灣三分之二的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/595.wav", + "text": "全部都在原住民地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/596.wav", + "text": "你們可以忽視原民會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/597.wav", + "text": "所以院長這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/598.wav", + "text": "能夠把它納入到第十九款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/599.wav", + "text": "第二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/600.wav", + "text": "我沒意見你把它納入到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/601.wav", + "text": "第8條第十九款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/602.wav", + "text": "能夠尊重跟承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/603.wav", + "text": "原住民族的自然主權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/604.wav", + "text": "高興就放了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/605.wav", + "text": "謝謝孔委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/606.wav", + "text": "再溝通好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/607.wav", + "text": "因為大家停在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/608.wav", + "text": "爭點在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/609.wav", + "text": "再溝通好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/610.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/611.wav", + "text": "能源部門的溫室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/612.wav", + "text": "氣體減量主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/613.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/614.wav", + "text": "抱歉因為其實能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/615.wav", + "text": "部門真正主要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/616.wav", + "text": "不是它自己部門的消耗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/617.wav", + "text": "而是產生能源供給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/618.wav", + "text": "使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/619.wav", + "text": "減少它的排碳第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/620.wav", + "text": "等這些新能源能夠讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/621.wav", + "text": "第二個就是產業去提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/622.wav", + "text": "效率提升能源效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/623.wav", + "text": "它就可以減少碳排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/624.wav", + "text": "能源部門去盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/625.wav", + "text": "當然它占一個很大的比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/626.wav", + "text": "可是實際上它的碳排都是供給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/627.wav", + "text": "能源給其他部門使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/628.wav", + "text": "所以我們在第1款與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/629.wav", + "text": "第2款有關再生能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/630.wav", + "text": "及能源科技與能源使用效率提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/631.wav", + "text": "及能源節約這些都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/632.wav", + "text": "可以改善能源部門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/633.wav", + "text": "排碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/634.wav", + "text": "你可以跟我解釋為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/635.wav", + "text": "運輸管理大眾運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/636.wav", + "text": "系統發展及其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/637.wav", + "text": "運輸部門溫室氣體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/638.wav", + "text": "減量寫進了第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/639.wav", + "text": "可是你的第5款也將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/640.wav", + "text": "低碳能源運具使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/641.wav", + "text": "寫進去了為什麼這裡沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/642.wav", + "text": "重複為什麼這裡寫進去就是重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/643.wav", + "text": "為什麼發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/644.wav", + "text": "能源科技再加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/645.wav", + "text": "一個能源部門的溫室氣體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/646.wav", + "text": "減量由經濟部負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/647.wav", + "text": "就是重複為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/648.wav", + "text": "交通部門就不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/649.wav", + "text": "重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/650.wav", + "text": "反駁委員說重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/651.wav", + "text": "以重要性來講其實在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/652.wav", + "text": "已經包括了能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/653.wav", + "text": "第2條與第8條就暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/654.wav", + "text": "等一下回頭好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/655.wav", + "text": "\n現在請大家看第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/656.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/657.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見沒有意見就照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/658.wav", + "text": "提案通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/659.wav", + "text": "已增加第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/660.wav", + "text": "第3款嘛大家看一下紅字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/661.wav", + "text": "第3條是否照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/662.wav", + "text": "照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/663.wav", + "text": "有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/664.wav", + "text": "紅字那本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/665.wav", + "text": "不然就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/666.wav", + "text": "民進黨修正版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/667.wav", + "text": "這個修正版本是經過委員會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/668.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/669.wav", + "text": "既然有經過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/670.wav", + "text": "有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/671.wav", + "text": "修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/672.wav", + "text": "\n請看第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/673.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/674.wav", + "text": "第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/675.wav", + "text": "在野黨有意見我們就把它劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/676.wav", + "text": "就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/677.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/678.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/679.wav", + "text": "發言一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/680.wav", + "text": "現在的問題會是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/681.wav", + "text": "因為它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/682.wav", + "text": "訂了一個2050的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/683.wav", + "text": "目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/684.wav", + "text": "2050的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/685.wav", + "text": "因為第3項刪除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/686.wav", + "text": "它基本上就是淨零排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/687.wav", + "text": "但是現在的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/688.wav", + "text": "主要國家基本上都是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/689.wav", + "text": "碳排的話那麼你要怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/690.wav", + "text": "達到淨零碳排你不可能到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/691.wav", + "text": "2040的時候有一個階段性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/692.wav", + "text": "所以我們的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/693.wav", + "text": "基本上也是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/694.wav", + "text": "兩個大重點一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/695.wav", + "text": "透過短中期的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/696.wav", + "text": "入法也就是將2030" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/697.wav", + "text": "2040的目標入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/698.wav", + "text": "才能確保我們有逐步地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/699.wav", + "text": "按部就班的減碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/700.wav", + "text": "排放的目標邁進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/701.wav", + "text": "曾經問過署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/702.wav", + "text": "乃至於歐洲國家基本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/703.wav", + "text": "上他們都把2030" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/704.wav", + "text": "的目標大概訂在40%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/705.wav", + "text": "上下因為署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/706.wav", + "text": "上次的回答是說你並不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/707.wav", + "text": "但是我相信你現在應該有清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/708.wav", + "text": "嘛\n我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/709.wav", + "text": "目標是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/710.wav", + "text": "訂在24%跟日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/711.wav", + "text": "比起來是差一大截" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/712.wav", + "text": "2030減量的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/713.wav", + "text": "是24%的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/714.wav", + "text": "2030到2050" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/715.wav", + "text": "你要如何能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/716.wav", + "text": "達到2050淨零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/717.wav", + "text": "淨零請署長等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/718.wav", + "text": "回答所以我們基本上認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/719.wav", + "text": "2040" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/720.wav", + "text": "應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/721.wav", + "text": "這才是一個循序漸進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/722.wav", + "text": "往2050邁進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/723.wav", + "text": "辦法以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/724.wav", + "text": "有吳委員羅委員及曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/725.wav", + "text": "我們依照順序繼續進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/726.wav", + "text": "最後是林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/727.wav", + "text": "\n現在請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/728.wav", + "text": "目前只有看到2050的長期目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/729.wav", + "text": "短中長期的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/730.wav", + "text": "然後才可以階段性的追蹤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/731.wav", + "text": "好嗎謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/732.wav", + "text": "這一題跟這有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/733.wav", + "text": "第一個就是把第3項拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/734.wav", + "text": "這也是在委員會協商時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/735.wav", + "text": "各委員有意見的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/736.wav", + "text": "不要保留這種彈性覺得好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/737.wav", + "text": "所以第3項拿掉應該沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/738.wav", + "text": "接下來第二個問題就要請環保署回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/739.wav", + "text": "雖然大家都同意2050" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/740.wav", + "text": "這個都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/741.wav", + "text": "但203020352040這樣的階段性目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/742.wav", + "text": "有沒有哪個國家是入法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/743.wav", + "text": "大家是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/744.wav", + "text": "政策宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/745.wav", + "text": "有沒有哪個國家是用法律的方式去規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/746.wav", + "text": "是多數國家還是只有少數國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/747.wav", + "text": "這一塊請環保署在回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/748.wav", + "text": "時稍微具體一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/749.wav", + "text": "第4條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/750.wav", + "text": "是國家溫室氣體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/751.wav", + "text": "長期減量目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/752.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體淨零排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/753.wav", + "text": "這個目標是訂在27年後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/754.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/755.wav", + "text": "過了27年後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/756.wav", + "text": "年輕的可能還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/757.wav", + "text": "院長可能還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/758.wav", + "text": "我可能不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/759.wav", + "text": "音容宛在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/760.wav", + "text": "啦大家都音容宛在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/761.wav", + "text": "這個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/762.wav", + "text": "不負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/763.wav", + "text": "第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/764.wav", + "text": "我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/765.wav", + "text": "是不訂短期目標也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/766.wav", + "text": "不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/767.wav", + "text": "那些人才在緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/768.wav", + "text": "27年後的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/769.wav", + "text": "前幾年都浪費掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/770.wav", + "text": "也沒人在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/771.wav", + "text": "訂27年後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/772.wav", + "text": "誰在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/773.wav", + "text": "基本上大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/774.wav", + "text": "我的部分在第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/775.wav", + "text": "中期目標其實我們有考量到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/776.wav", + "text": "如果我們以2050年(民國139年)" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/777.wav", + "text": "要淨零碳排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/778.wav", + "text": "所以我是用94年為基準年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/779.wav", + "text": "如果比照124年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/780.wav", + "text": "降50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/781.wav", + "text": "我是覺得中期目標可以訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/782.wav", + "text": "但是要訂多少比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/783.wav", + "text": "如果環保署希望訂一個更可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/784.wav", + "text": "但為什麼要訂一個中期目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/785.wav", + "text": "這樣我們才有辦法來檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/786.wav", + "text": "我們的減碳目標是不是有達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/787.wav", + "text": "假如我們原來收了碳費或碳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/788.wav", + "text": "達標了超過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/789.wav", + "text": "我們可能還可以因為這樣再減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/790.wav", + "text": "那未來就可以再來增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/791.wav", + "text": "就少了一些人為干預的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/792.wav", + "text": "我們可以更客觀地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/793.wav", + "text": "來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/794.wav", + "text": "到時候碳費碳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/795.wav", + "text": "尤其如果提早達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/796.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得設一個中期目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/797.wav", + "text": "是滿重要也滿有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/798.wav", + "text": "覺得124年我們是不是可以達到50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/799.wav", + "text": "有不同的意見大家可以再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/800.wav", + "text": "就我們剛剛聽下來大部分委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/801.wav", + "text": "意見都覺得應該訂一個中期目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/802.wav", + "text": "多一個檢核點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/803.wav", + "text": "是不是可以達到淨零碳排這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/804.wav", + "text": "多了一個檢核點這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/805.wav", + "text": "這才是一個對未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/806.wav", + "text": "世代比較負責任的入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/807.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/808.wav", + "text": "其實之前一直吵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/809.wav", + "text": "一直吵了很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/810.wav", + "text": "他們在第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/811.wav", + "text": "五年的階段管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/812.wav", + "text": "目標我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/813.wav", + "text": "如果第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/814.wav", + "text": "不訂的話是不是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/815.wav", + "text": "中期的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/816.wav", + "text": "說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/817.wav", + "text": "不訂的話以上建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/818.wav", + "text": "也可以回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/819.wav", + "text": "歐盟的氣候法相較1990" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/820.wav", + "text": "%我們要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/821.wav", + "text": "加拿大跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/822.wav", + "text": "臺灣的人均碳排排名是接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/823.wav", + "text": "的可是事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/824.wav", + "text": "你可以看到它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/825.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/826.wav", + "text": "也把它入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/827.wav", + "text": "了可見其實人家比我們努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/828.wav", + "text": "非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/829.wav", + "text": "就是說2050" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/830.wav", + "text": "淨零碳排如果中期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/831.wav", + "text": "20302040沒有訂目標的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/832.wav", + "text": "的話到底你的減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/833.wav", + "text": "就會發生一個狀況就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/834.wav", + "text": "沒有實質的監督跟去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/835.wav", + "text": "調整的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/836.wav", + "text": "到最後的結果就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/837.wav", + "text": "把這個燙手山芋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/838.wav", + "text": "又留給下一代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/839.wav", + "text": "這個不是我們要認真面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/840.wav", + "text": "即將面臨的更極端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/841.wav", + "text": "更頻繁的氣候災害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/842.wav", + "text": "我剛剛其實也有提到這其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/843.wav", + "text": "攸關我們子孫的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/844.wav", + "text": "我們應該要有明確的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/845.wav", + "text": "檢核點一個查核點以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/846.wav", + "text": "都要求2030其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/847.wav", + "text": "很簡單你訂一個2050" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/848.wav", + "text": "知道是微乎其微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/849.wav", + "text": "當時也是訂2050" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/850.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望訂一個比較明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/851.wav", + "text": "民進黨委員也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/852.wav", + "text": "是不是多數國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/853.wav", + "text": "2030都有入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/854.wav", + "text": "的定義現在全世界有將近200個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/855.wav", + "text": "就是要超過100個國家請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/856.wav", + "text": "有沒有超過100個國家入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/857.wav", + "text": "2050淨零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/858.wav", + "text": "我想沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/859.wav", + "text": "我們不是在比爛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/860.wav", + "text": "我們是要為下一代負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/861.wav", + "text": "所以不要跟我說大部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/862.wav", + "text": "為什麼歐盟要入法\n為什麼加拿大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/863.wav", + "text": "要入法他們是笨蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/864.wav", + "text": "環保署有沒有調查過其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/865.wav", + "text": "的立法有沒有入法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/866.wav", + "text": "這個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/867.wav", + "text": "我想我們這邊也有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/868.wav", + "text": "德國的聯邦憲法法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/869.wav", + "text": "也有宣布他們要修改氣候保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/870.wav", + "text": "所以確實德國在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/871.wav", + "text": "有訂期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/872.wav", + "text": "我想你待會可以針對這部分做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/873.wav", + "text": "如果我們剛剛講到永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/874.wav", + "text": "各部會減碳目標值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/875.wav", + "text": "那離2050這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/876.wav", + "text": "點以十年或幾年做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/877.wav", + "text": "達標來講到底有什麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/878.wav", + "text": "自己的KPI或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/879.wav", + "text": "有什麼窒礙難行之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/880.wav", + "text": "也請環保署作說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/881.wav", + "text": "因為你們修改的三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/882.wav", + "text": "變兩項那你們第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/883.wav", + "text": "也是說要達到前項目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/884.wav", + "text": "各級政府講的是地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/885.wav", + "text": "跟各團體事業單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/886.wav", + "text": "國人要共商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/887.wav", + "text": "這樣的減碳目標值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/888.wav", + "text": "所以本來就已經預設你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/889.wav", + "text": "要有一個階段性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/890.wav", + "text": "有不同做法的話我覺得這對國人來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/891.wav", + "text": "所以應該是透過立法的手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/892.wav", + "text": "和技術性把這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/893.wav", + "text": "才不至於因為各個政府之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/894.wav", + "text": "地方跟中央對抗或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/895.wav", + "text": "造成這件事情會有所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/896.wav", + "text": "延宕所以我認為大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/897.wav", + "text": "的目標是一致的\n至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/898.wav", + "text": "國發會好像上個禮拜有公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/899.wav", + "text": "概念下到底這個又是怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/900.wav", + "text": "規劃出來的國發會又是依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/901.wav", + "text": "什麼來訂的也請國發會的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/902.wav", + "text": "現在就請張署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/903.wav", + "text": "說明張署長說完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/904.wav", + "text": "如果沒有共識的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/905.wav", + "text": "現在超過1個小時了我們只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/906.wav", + "text": "\n請張署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/907.wav", + "text": "是謝謝各位委員的指教我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/908.wav", + "text": "大家關心的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/909.wav", + "text": "我們指定的2050要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/910.wav", + "text": "現在有入法的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/911.wav", + "text": "大概只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/912.wav", + "text": "8個加歐盟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/913.wav", + "text": "我們原來之所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/914.wav", + "text": "建議不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/915.wav", + "text": "現在就把階段的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/916.wav", + "text": "會提出24%加減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/917.wav", + "text": "1為什麼不直接提25%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/918.wav", + "text": "其實是要有一些科學的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/919.wav", + "text": "去做計算包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/920.wav", + "text": "用模型去計算而不是隨便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/921.wav", + "text": "寫一個數字但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/922.wav", + "text": "我們也不是說那就不要訂目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/923.wav", + "text": "好像不負責任所以各位可以看到我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/924.wav", + "text": "的第10條在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/925.wav", + "text": "頁其實我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/926.wav", + "text": "參考了各位委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/927.wav", + "text": "要訂出每五年一期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/928.wav", + "text": "的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/929.wav", + "text": "也規定在下一期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/930.wav", + "text": "開始的前兩年要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/931.wav", + "text": "檢討下一期的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/932.wav", + "text": "所以是有這個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/933.wav", + "text": "那麼在第10條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/934.wav", + "text": "這次也有提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/935.wav", + "text": "公聽會的程序周延讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/936.wav", + "text": "民眾的參與資訊的公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/937.wav", + "text": "更周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/938.wav", + "text": "也就是我們要誠實去面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/939.wav", + "text": "逐期地訂出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/940.wav", + "text": "可行的目標\n像剛剛委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/941.wav", + "text": "提到說我們溫管法到現在是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/942.wav", + "text": "減量有限我們訂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/943.wav", + "text": "較2005年減2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/944.wav", + "text": "實際上我們減了1.88%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/945.wav", + "text": "雖然沒有達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/946.wav", + "text": "但是至少我們去檢核我們的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/947.wav", + "text": "不夠要怎麼再去改讓下一期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/948.wav", + "text": "能夠追上來所以我想訂目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/949.wav", + "text": "主要的目的是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/950.wav", + "text": "每個國家當然不同有的國家訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/951.wav", + "text": "得很高因為每個國家的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/952.wav", + "text": "不一樣應該要依照我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/953.wav", + "text": "環境去訂可以執行可以達到的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/954.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會建議不要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/955.wav", + "text": "直接寫下去因為寫下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/956.wav", + "text": "檢討因為已經有這個機制了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/957.wav", + "text": "行政部門一定要提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/958.wav", + "text": "逐期的目標我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/959.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員做好第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/960.wav", + "text": "再溝通好不好就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/961.wav", + "text": "暫時保留第4條併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/962.wav", + "text": "好等一下再看\n現在請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/963.wav", + "text": "有建議修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/964.wav", + "text": "我們是不是照建議修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/965.wav", + "text": "通過好不好\n請吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/966.wav", + "text": "我的版本是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/967.wav", + "text": "原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/968.wav", + "text": "條文的第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/969.wav", + "text": "也就是你們建議的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/970.wav", + "text": "裡面為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/971.wav", + "text": "確保國家能源安全應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/972.wav", + "text": "擬定逐步降低化石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/973.wav", + "text": "燃料依賴之中長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/974.wav", + "text": "期策略這個完全沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/975.wav", + "text": "接著訂定再生能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/976.wav", + "text": "不夠好最好是潔淨能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/977.wav", + "text": "因為再生能源其實是潔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/978.wav", + "text": "潔淨能源之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/979.wav", + "text": "逐步落實非核家園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/980.wav", + "text": "叫做氣候變遷因應法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/981.wav", + "text": "是從溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/982.wav", + "text": "核改成非碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/983.wav", + "text": "為什麼非核家園可以達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/984.wav", + "text": "可不可以解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/985.wav", + "text": "配合民眾黨第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/986.wav", + "text": "至第52條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/987.wav", + "text": "的公民訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/988.wav", + "text": "專章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/989.wav", + "text": "參考國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/990.wav", + "text": "治理重要原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/991.wav", + "text": "為因應氣候變遷政府相關法律及政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/992.wav", + "text": "之規劃管理原則如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/993.wav", + "text": "我覺得有些東西是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/994.wav", + "text": "也是很高位的東西但是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/995.wav", + "text": "被納入所以我提案多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/996.wav", + "text": "全國國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/997.wav", + "text": "直轄市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/998.wav", + "text": "縣(市)國土計畫之擬定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/999.wav", + "text": "國家各項重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1000.wav", + "text": "建設及重大政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1001.wav", + "text": "計畫應考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1002.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷調適並將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1003.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷影響納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1004.wav", + "text": "評估我覺得這應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1005.wav", + "text": "的以長遠計畫來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1006.wav", + "text": "本來我們就預計2050氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1007.wav", + "text": "所以在做相關重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1008.wav", + "text": "及政策還有國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1009.wav", + "text": "畫時應該就要把這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1010.wav", + "text": "納入到評估的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1011.wav", + "text": "所以我提案增加這一款希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1012.wav", + "text": "能得到大家的支持謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1013.wav", + "text": "我們的版本跟行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1014.wav", + "text": "的差異應該是在第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1015.wav", + "text": "第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1016.wav", + "text": "院版是寫為確保國家能源安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1017.wav", + "text": "應擬定逐步降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1018.wav", + "text": "化石燃料依賴之中長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1019.wav", + "text": "策略而我們版本是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1020.wav", + "text": "應逐步取消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1021.wav", + "text": "化石燃料補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1022.wav", + "text": "應該說在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1023.wav", + "text": "其最終的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1024.wav", + "text": "也是取消而非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1025.wav", + "text": "降低而已這其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1026.wav", + "text": "非常清楚地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1027.wav", + "text": "地在2009年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1028.wav", + "text": "低效率化石燃料的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1029.wav", + "text": "化石燃料依賴之中長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1030.wav", + "text": "策略\n講得不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1031.wav", + "text": "燃料依賴是什麼\n我們的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1032.wav", + "text": "其實非常清楚就是逐步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1033.wav", + "text": "立刻要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1034.wav", + "text": "把目標訂清楚就是逐步取消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1035.wav", + "text": "化石燃料的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1036.wav", + "text": "版本中的依賴中長期策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1037.wav", + "text": "意思不太清楚我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1038.wav", + "text": "補貼就是補貼然後逐步去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1039.wav", + "text": "把它取消至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1040.wav", + "text": "至於逐步取消化石燃料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1041.wav", + "text": "補貼這部分事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1042.wav", + "text": "現在大家的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1043.wav", + "text": "環保署等一下應該也要回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1044.wav", + "text": "是不是認同這樣的趨勢如果你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1045.wav", + "text": "認同這樣的趨勢的話就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1046.wav", + "text": "應該要把這個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1047.wav", + "text": "用這樣的方式去明確化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1048.wav", + "text": "\n再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1049.wav", + "text": "高度補貼化石燃料的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1050.wav", + "text": "國家做統計如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1051.wav", + "text": "的30%轉移至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1052.wav", + "text": "可減少11%至18%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1053.wav", + "text": "的碳排放量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1054.wav", + "text": "更可減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1055.wav", + "text": "25%的全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1056.wav", + "text": "碳排放量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1057.wav", + "text": "死亡的人數也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1058.wav", + "text": "也可以因此減半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1059.wav", + "text": "趨勢最終是希望完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1060.wav", + "text": "取消這樣的補貼而不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1061.wav", + "text": "逐步降低而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1062.wav", + "text": "力認真地去看待這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1063.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1064.wav", + "text": "逐步落實非核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1065.wav", + "text": "第一個這是原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1066.wav", + "text": "是現行法的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1067.wav", + "text": "第二個這個是依照環境基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1068.wav", + "text": "裡面就有這樣的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1069.wav", + "text": "所以當初訂的時候才會把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1070.wav", + "text": "訂下去所以這次我們並沒有去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1071.wav", + "text": "修正它即還是要逐步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1072.wav", + "text": "落實非核家園願景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1073.wav", + "text": "\n對於化石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1074.wav", + "text": "邱委員講得沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1075.wav", + "text": "大國他們希望這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1076.wav", + "text": "去做但是每個國家其實有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1077.wav", + "text": "它不同的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1078.wav", + "text": "是不排除的如果有機會如果我們做得好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1079.wav", + "text": "維持原條文應該還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1080.wav", + "text": "可以達到相同的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1081.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1082.wav", + "text": "有建議修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1083.wav", + "text": "建議修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1084.wav", + "text": "你們有同意了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1085.wav", + "text": "原住民族權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1086.wav", + "text": "第3項第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1087.wav", + "text": "參酌國內外最新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1088.wav", + "text": "照建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1089.wav", + "text": "院長我的部分他都沒有回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1090.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的即增加的那一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1091.wav", + "text": "還有那麼多委員要發表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1092.wav", + "text": "意見我們就從陳椒華委員開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1093.wav", + "text": "我的部分他並沒有回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1094.wav", + "text": "請陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1095.wav", + "text": "非核家園的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1096.wav", + "text": "我想這也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1097.wav", + "text": "環團朋友長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1098.wav", + "text": "努力的所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1099.wav", + "text": "本席建議這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1100.wav", + "text": "還是要維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1101.wav", + "text": "不要更動以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1102.wav", + "text": "好謝謝陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1103.wav", + "text": "\n請孔委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1104.wav", + "text": "院長是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1105.wav", + "text": "修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1106.wav", + "text": "相關的文字也納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1107.wav", + "text": "原住民族權益擺進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1108.wav", + "text": "我跟廖國棟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1109.wav", + "text": "還有賴惠員委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1110.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1111.wav", + "text": "受溫室氣體影響之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1112.wav", + "text": "弱勢族群原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1113.wav", + "text": "給予適當補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1114.wav", + "text": "維護該族群生存健康權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1115.wav", + "text": "為什麼這個沒有納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1116.wav", + "text": "呢我們來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1117.wav", + "text": "Glasgow會議正式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1118.wav", + "text": "尊重承認原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1119.wav", + "text": "JustandAmbitious" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1120.wav", + "text": "其中針對原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1121.wav", + "text": "的土地跟山林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1122.wav", + "text": "跟著這個國際潮流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1123.wav", + "text": "特別提出來的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1124.wav", + "text": "修正動議你們一直到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1125.wav", + "text": "納入因應氣候變遷就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1126.wav", + "text": "受溫室氣體影響之弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1127.wav", + "text": "加入了原住民族權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1128.wav", + "text": "並擺在第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1129.wav", + "text": "\n謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1130.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1131.wav", + "text": "剛才林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1132.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1133.wav", + "text": "剛剛一直提到環境基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1134.wav", + "text": "裡面有非核家園這幾個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1135.wav", + "text": "這幾個字第一點我們現在修正的是氣候變遷因應法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1136.wav", + "text": "並不是在修正環境基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1137.wav", + "text": "再來這部法裡面也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1138.wav", + "text": "告訴我環境基本法是它的上位法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1139.wav", + "text": "所以我不確定為什麼環境基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1140.wav", + "text": "裡面有這四個字但我們在這裡卻不能把它刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1141.wav", + "text": "重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1142.wav", + "text": "就科學來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1143.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1144.wav", + "text": "署長也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1145.wav", + "text": "如果國科會也有在場也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1146.wav", + "text": "如何透過非核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1147.wav", + "text": "來達到溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1148.wav", + "text": "不然為什麼我們要在這裡放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1149.wav", + "text": "非核家園這四個字呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1150.wav", + "text": "看是哪個部會要來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1151.wav", + "text": "我先報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1152.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員所提的其實我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1153.wav", + "text": "其實就有把原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1154.wav", + "text": "我現在強調的是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1155.wav", + "text": "國際潮流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1156.wav", + "text": "剝奪損害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1157.wav", + "text": "原住民土地應給予補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1158.wav", + "text": "那為什麼臺灣沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1159.wav", + "text": "現在我們原民會的立場是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1160.wav", + "text": "原民會說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1161.wav", + "text": "其實有關原民會的部分因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1162.wav", + "text": "去年就跟環保署有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1163.wav", + "text": "具體文字的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1164.wav", + "text": "已經有一些共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1165.wav", + "text": "所以以現在的版本來做這樣的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1166.wav", + "text": "應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1167.wav", + "text": "積極而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1168.wav", + "text": "多配合國際潮流好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1169.wav", + "text": "這個國際潮流去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1170.wav", + "text": "跟今年都是對原住民的自然主權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1171.wav", + "text": "而且已經開始行動了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1172.wav", + "text": "我們還是再溝通好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1173.wav", + "text": "我的問題很簡單我只是要問他為什麼不回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1174.wav", + "text": "剛才他每個問題都回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1175.wav", + "text": "不具什麼爭議性的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1176.wav", + "text": "有重大政策時要納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1177.wav", + "text": "調適氣候變遷影響納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1178.wav", + "text": "評估這個我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1179.wav", + "text": "請署長再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1180.wav", + "text": "這為什麼不能被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1181.wav", + "text": "採納我想聽聽環保署的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1182.wav", + "text": "到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1183.wav", + "text": "去做相關的調適規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1184.wav", + "text": "所以我們沒有特別在這裡把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1185.wav", + "text": "提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1186.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷調適能力的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1187.wav", + "text": "我們有列到第7款裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1188.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1189.wav", + "text": "暫時保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1190.wav", + "text": "第8條剛才已經保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1191.wav", + "text": "繼續處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1192.wav", + "text": "第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1193.wav", + "text": "\n第9條有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1194.wav", + "text": "修正建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1195.wav", + "text": "條文請大家看一下是否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1196.wav", + "text": "可以照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1197.wav", + "text": "修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1198.wav", + "text": "跟我們剛剛在討論前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1199.wav", + "text": "年亦即2050淨零碳排的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1200.wav", + "text": "既然我們剛才有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1201.wav", + "text": "你們不願意在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1202.wav", + "text": "剛剛也講說是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1203.wav", + "text": "這要推估不是喊數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1204.wav", + "text": "我也同意我們不是喊數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1205.wav", + "text": "不是今天我們訂了這個法令之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1206.wav", + "text": "在第9條部分的checkpoint" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1207.wav", + "text": "就是我們每五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1208.wav", + "text": "或是每幾年的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1209.wav", + "text": "相對重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1210.wav", + "text": "各有不同版本有二年有三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1211.wav", + "text": "有四年有五年現在行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1212.wav", + "text": "提出五年是最長的但我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1213.wav", + "text": "如果以今年2023年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1214.wav", + "text": "通過這部法令之後到2050年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1215.wav", + "text": "五年開一次檢討會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1216.wav", + "text": "我們只有5次的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1217.wav", + "text": "我怎麼有辦法確認這5次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1218.wav", + "text": "到2050年達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1219.wav", + "text": "淨零碳排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1220.wav", + "text": "三年是一個討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1221.wav", + "text": "空間四年是一個討論空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1222.wav", + "text": "本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1223.wav", + "text": "沒有一定堅持是三年或四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1224.wav", + "text": "但是我認為五年實在太長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1225.wav", + "text": "五年等於超過一個總統的任期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1226.wav", + "text": "沒有連任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1227.wav", + "text": "2050淨零碳排的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1228.wav", + "text": "所以我認為至少一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1229.wav", + "text": "限縮跟總統任期一致至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1230.wav", + "text": "四年一次的檢討會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1231.wav", + "text": "這樣比較符合相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1232.wav", + "text": "共識及標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1233.wav", + "text": "政府任職的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1234.wav", + "text": "都可以面對淨零碳排的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1235.wav", + "text": "好好負責任的在他任期上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1236.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這一條應該要堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1237.wav", + "text": "洪委員說要跟總統任期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1238.wav", + "text": "有委員提出二年的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1239.wav", + "text": "要跟任期切在一起是不可能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1240.wav", + "text": "今年通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1241.wav", + "text": "至於剛才談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1242.wav", + "text": "345的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1243.wav", + "text": "你剛才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1244.wav", + "text": "有三年四年五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1245.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1246.wav", + "text": "我們當初提五年是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1247.wav", + "text": "它後面還有相關推動的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1248.wav", + "text": "如果太近的話可能大家會一直都在弄那些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1249.wav", + "text": "所以委員覺得要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1250.wav", + "text": "要四年也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1251.wav", + "text": "大家討論看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1252.wav", + "text": "實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1253.wav", + "text": "來討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1254.wav", + "text": "我們的版本主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1255.wav", + "text": "我先想請教署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1256.wav", + "text": "提到國家因應氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1257.wav", + "text": "行動綱領的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1258.wav", + "text": "會有哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1259.wav", + "text": "這點等一下請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1260.wav", + "text": "其實我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1261.wav", + "text": "寫得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1262.wav", + "text": "減量的階段管制目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1263.wav", + "text": "推動的策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1264.wav", + "text": "預期的效益與管考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1265.wav", + "text": "第3項即把第1項的行動綱領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1266.wav", + "text": "應該包括什麼寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1267.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1268.wav", + "text": "個到底要幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1269.wav", + "text": "檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1270.wav", + "text": "坦白講我認為院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1271.wav", + "text": "真的太長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1272.wav", + "text": "了因為2050很快就到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1273.wav", + "text": "包括加拿大等其他八個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1274.wav", + "text": "也有做政策上的宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1275.wav", + "text": "40%至45%之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1276.wav", + "text": "2030要減到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1277.wav", + "text": "24%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1278.wav", + "text": "在太長了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1279.wav", + "text": "我們的版本是三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1280.wav", + "text": "因為臺灣每四年選一次總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1281.wav", + "text": "是四年如果改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1282.wav", + "text": "有一個總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1283.wav", + "text": "那麼他是不是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1284.wav", + "text": "沒有相應的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1285.wav", + "text": "這也是有可能會發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1286.wav", + "text": "其實最後一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1287.wav", + "text": "是從委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1288.wav", + "text": "協商來的不知道大家是否還有印象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1289.wav", + "text": "原本只寫定期檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1290.wav", + "text": "我記得當時是邱委員提五年檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1291.wav", + "text": "我說五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1292.wav", + "text": "我們的版本都是三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1293.wav", + "text": "那時候是五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1294.wav", + "text": "我參與過綱領的修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1295.wav", + "text": "通常綱領修訂完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1296.wav", + "text": "就是修正院的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1297.wav", + "text": "院的計畫修完後就是修部會計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1298.wav", + "text": "部會計畫修完後就是修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1299.wav", + "text": "地方政府計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1300.wav", + "text": "通常從上到下一輪下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1301.wav", + "text": "期間還需要公民參與機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1302.wav", + "text": "我在馬政府時代參與過這件事所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1303.wav", + "text": "知道修完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1304.wav", + "text": "突然又馬上要再修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1305.wav", + "text": "我覺得可以留一個彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1306.wav", + "text": "為什麼這句話的前一句話是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1307.wav", + "text": "參酌聯合國氣候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1308.wav", + "text": "變化綱要公約及其協議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1309.wav", + "text": "意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1310.wav", + "text": "每年都會開COP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1311.wav", + "text": "每年的COP會有不同結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1312.wav", + "text": "也許某些年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1313.wav", + "text": "會有特定重大結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1314.wav", + "text": "故不宜訂定固定的period" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1315.wav", + "text": "或幾年才能修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1316.wav", + "text": "而其實我們可能一年後就該修正了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1317.wav", + "text": "不該太短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1318.wav", + "text": "我們在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1319.wav", + "text": "就是留一個彈性但不會太近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1320.wav", + "text": "我不知道大家還記不記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1321.wav", + "text": "當時討論的脈絡是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1322.wav", + "text": "我必須說一下這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1323.wav", + "text": "真的從上到下跑完一輪可能就二年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1324.wav", + "text": "了然後馬上又要再修一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1325.wav", + "text": "當時很多人參與的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1326.wav", + "text": "是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1327.wav", + "text": "謝謝洪委員提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1328.wav", + "text": "確實我們這邊寫的是至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1329.wav", + "text": "每五年檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1330.wav", + "text": "啦所以它不是一定要到五年才能檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1331.wav", + "text": "邱委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1332.wav", + "text": "當然在這一次我們修正的綱領裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1333.wav", + "text": "會包括減緩跟調適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1334.wav", + "text": "這二大部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1335.wav", + "text": "但是它到底要包括什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1336.wav", + "text": "其實我們在現行的溫管法施行細則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1337.wav", + "text": "裡面就已經把行動綱領要訂定的東西明定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1338.wav", + "text": "包括氣候變遷的未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1339.wav", + "text": "調適減緩遭遇的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1340.wav", + "text": "願景目標基本原則內涵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1341.wav", + "text": "及後續怎麼推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1342.wav", + "text": "其實在細則裡面已經寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1343.wav", + "text": "了所以我們才沒有在母法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1344.wav", + "text": "我們是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1345.wav", + "text": "再溝通好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1346.wav", + "text": "我1分鐘就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1347.wav", + "text": "事實上時力的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1348.wav", + "text": "就是五年檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1349.wav", + "text": "是指提出國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1350.wav", + "text": "自定貢獻報告書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1351.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1352.wav", + "text": "修正動議是五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1353.wav", + "text": "行動��領的部分所謂行動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1354.wav", + "text": "綱領就是我們要去訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1355.wav", + "text": "定管制目標推動期程策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1356.wav", + "text": "部分五年檢討才一次那就太久了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1357.wav", + "text": "還是請環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1358.wav", + "text": "那麼久才檢討一次因為這樣各部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1359.wav", + "text": "或是預期效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1360.wav", + "text": "事務官都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1361.wav", + "text": "下臺了然後五年才到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1362.wav", + "text": "這樣根本就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1363.wav", + "text": "很難接軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1364.wav", + "text": "所以事實上三年還是比較合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1365.wav", + "text": "這次我們在審查預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1366.wav", + "text": "也發現各部會大概都會提一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1367.wav", + "text": "要減多少所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1368.wav", + "text": "我也贊成把我原來二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1369.wav", + "text": "樣也符合現在各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1370.wav", + "text": "所做的一些相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1371.wav", + "text": "規劃\n另外剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1372.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員提到那個流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1373.wav", + "text": "但我覺得我們可以來簡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1374.wav", + "text": "因為現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1375.wav", + "text": "這個事情是會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1376.wav", + "text": "因應相關不斷產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1377.wav", + "text": "是比較可以符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1378.wav", + "text": "跟著時代及世界的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1379.wav", + "text": "腳步來走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1380.wav", + "text": "五年的意思是可以三年也可以二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1381.wav", + "text": "但是那樣會變成給行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1382.wav", + "text": "太多的裁量權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1383.wav", + "text": "我覺得是比較具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1384.wav", + "text": "也可以在比較短的時間之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1385.wav", + "text": "這樣也符合現在我們審查預算時所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1386.wav", + "text": "看到各部會都是以三年為目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1387.wav", + "text": "嘛那我們就把它變成以三年來做為一個週期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1388.wav", + "text": "我不知道大家知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1389.wav", + "text": "我來解釋一下這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1390.wav", + "text": "綱領是最上位的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1391.wav", + "text": "通常綱領修完後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1392.wav", + "text": "就要修院的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1393.wav", + "text": "院的計畫修完後就要修部會的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1394.wav", + "text": "部會的計畫修完後就要修地方政府的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1395.wav", + "text": "所以只要綱領一動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1396.wav", + "text": "這個流程就要重新再跑一遍再跑一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1397.wav", + "text": "的時間很長喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1398.wav", + "text": "不是我是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1399.wav", + "text": "是但我要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1400.wav", + "text": "它不是只是我把綱領修完就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1401.wav", + "text": "的事情而是綱領一動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1402.wav", + "text": "下面所有層次的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1403.wav", + "text": "全部都要連著大動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1404.wav", + "text": "因為綱領是最上位的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1405.wav", + "text": "剛剛洪委員說要二年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1406.wav", + "text": "組織都可以精簡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1407.wav", + "text": "即使是二年多我們定三年其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1408.wav", + "text": "也是可以cover的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1409.wav", + "text": "嘛為什麼要訂定為至少三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1410.wav", + "text": "呢因為現在的科技日新月異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1411.wav", + "text": "現在能不能用核融合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1412.wav", + "text": "跟三年後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1413.wav", + "text": "或三年前能不能核融合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1414.wav", + "text": "的為什麼COP是每年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1415.wav", + "text": "都開啊COP為什麼不二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1416.wav", + "text": "或三年開一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1417.wav", + "text": "的討論及結果來制定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1418.wav", + "text": "政策方向嘛所以老實說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1419.wav", + "text": "我覺得三年聽起來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1420.wav", + "text": "可行的你剛剛說整個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1421.wav", + "text": "跑完要二年多嘛那麼三年其實是可以cover的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1422.wav", + "text": "是OK的啊我覺得減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1423.wav", + "text": "當然再來一次啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1424.wav", + "text": "就再來一次啊只要在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1425.wav", + "text": "它之前跑完好了主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1426.wav", + "text": "我講一個比較公允的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1427.wav", + "text": "綱領是最上位的計畫沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1428.wav", + "text": "所以綱領也不會隨便動啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1429.wav", + "text": "不會因為五年檢討一次綱領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1430.wav", + "text": "就會隨便變動嘛在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1431.wav", + "text": "官員大家確認嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1432.wav", + "text": "我們在第4條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1433.wav", + "text": "139年淨零碳排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1434.wav", + "text": "這是不是綱領是嘛是最上位計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1435.wav", + "text": "嘛我不會因為五年檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1436.wav", + "text": "0年或145年我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1437.wav", + "text": "長期目標就是139年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1438.wav", + "text": "淨零碳排嘛我們現在要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1439.wav", + "text": "這個路徑到底是不是139年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1440.wav", + "text": "可以走到淨零碳排的這條路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1441.wav", + "text": "所以如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1442.wav", + "text": "五年一次的話你們現在又不肯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1443.wav", + "text": "在第4條裡面把2030放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1444.wav", + "text": "那麼現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1445.wav", + "text": "通過這個法到2030只有開一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1446.wav", + "text": "耶如果2030達不到呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1447.wav", + "text": "我不在這個位子你也不在這個位子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1448.wav", + "text": "然後大家就當成沒這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1449.wav", + "text": "了不可能嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1450.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們才會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1451.wav", + "text": "如果綱領是一個上位目標的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1452.wav", + "text": "我不認為它會隨時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1453.wav", + "text": "變動也不會因為4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1454.wav", + "text": "不太會變我們要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1455.wav", + "text": "這一件事情是開會確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1456.wav", + "text": "我們是不是有逐步達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1457.wav", + "text": "這個目標如果達不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1458.wav", + "text": "行政部門加油所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1459.wav", + "text": "我們當然需要比較適時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1460.wav", + "text": "的時間剛剛柯總召說今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1461.wav", + "text": "開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1462.wav", + "text": "每四年一次我不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1463.wav", + "text": "跟著總統大選的任期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1464.wav", + "text": "總統要選舉的時候就來開會不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1465.wav", + "text": "一任政府裡面會開一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1466.wav", + "text": "這樣的會議這就是國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1467.wav", + "text": "重大的一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1468.wav", + "text": "這樣做的好處是什麼好處是每一任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1469.wav", + "text": "政府上任之後都會把這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1470.wav", + "text": "核心的施政方向也至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1471.wav", + "text": "一定會面對一次這樣的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1472.wav", + "text": "誰執政都一樣國民黨會執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1473.wav", + "text": "民進黨會執政都有執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1474.wav", + "text": "但是每一任政府都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1475.wav", + "text": "應該面對這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1476.wav", + "text": "檢討一次的話到2050是開6次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1477.wav", + "text": "現在我們就是要確認到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1478.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣可以把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1479.wav", + "text": "路徑確定在2050" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1480.wav", + "text": "的時候達到淨零碳排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1481.wav", + "text": "所以我真的堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1482.wav", + "text": "沒有加但書也不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1483.wav", + "text": "把2030的目標放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1484.wav", + "text": "那麼在第9條就一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1485.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1486.wav", + "text": "溫暖化對策計畫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1487.wav", + "text": "有11個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1488.wav", + "text": "檢討這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1489.wav", + "text": "其實非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1490.wav", + "text": "最低限度嘛日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1491.wav", + "text": "的計畫基本上是比我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1492.wav", + "text": "複雜非常多而且它是在一個總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1493.wav", + "text": "計畫裡面去規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1494.wav", + "text": "所以我要講的就是其實這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1495.wav", + "text": "態度的問題啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1496.wav", + "text": "每五年才檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1497.wav", + "text": "一次這樣沒開幾次就到2050了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1498.wav", + "text": "甚至就像剛剛所講的有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1499.wav", + "text": "不到半次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1500.wav", + "text": "於氣候變遷的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1501.wav", + "text": "事實上這就是展現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1502.wav", + "text": "出一個態度嘛至少三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1503.wav", + "text": "這樣按部就班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1504.wav", + "text": "2050就可以做到嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1505.wav", + "text": "你在前面的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1506.wav", + "text": "沒有認真去做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1507.wav", + "text": "差不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1508.wav", + "text": "我在旁邊仔細聽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1509.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1510.wav", + "text": "每五年檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1511.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷的協議及發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1512.wav", + "text": "這是綱領嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1513.wav", + "text": "行動綱領是三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1514.wav", + "text": "大包小啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1515.wav", + "text": "常常會變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1516.wav", + "text": "了而洪委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1517.wav", + "text": "綱領很少在變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1518.wav", + "text": "我是覺得這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1519.wav", + "text": "大家講了這麼久才通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1520.wav", + "text": "才通過一條這一條我們就好好談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1521.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1522.wav", + "text": "是不是時代力量的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1523.wav", + "text": "第3項不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1524.wav", + "text": "我們來談大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1525.wav", + "text": "比較能夠接近的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1526.wav", + "text": "當初最早提出至少五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1527.wav", + "text": "又五包三的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1528.wav", + "text": "此案沒有什麼政治因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1529.wav", + "text": "這個計畫能夠做得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1530.wav", + "text": "我希望這一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1531.wav", + "text": "至少有點成就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1532.wav", + "text": "是否改成至少每四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1533.wav", + "text": "比我們都內行得多他長期參與這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1534.wav", + "text": "坦白講這完全沒有行政效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1535.wav", + "text": "而且整個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1536.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1537.wav", + "text": "是不是就改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1538.wav", + "text": "至少每四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1539.wav", + "text": "這樣就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1540.wav", + "text": "大家都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1541.wav", + "text": "第9條就改為四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1542.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1543.wav", + "text": "請大家看第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1544.wav", + "text": "第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1545.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1546.wav", + "text": "沒有意見我們就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1547.wav", + "text": "修正院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1548.wav", + "text": "第10條我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1549.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1550.wav", + "text": "是希望能夠用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1551.wav", + "text": "聽證會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1552.wav", + "text": "四年也好五年也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1553.wav", + "text": "四年才舉行一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1554.wav", + "text": "就會變成盍各言爾志" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1555.wav", + "text": "志到最後的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1556.wav", + "text": "來監督行政部門是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1557.wav", + "text": "非常不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1558.wav", + "text": "其實就是要確保行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1559.wav", + "text": "在制定淨零路徑的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1560.wav", + "text": "要能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1561.wav", + "text": "並且保障公民參與的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1562.wav", + "text": "所以在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1563.wav", + "text": "已經沒有將短中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1564.wav", + "text": "期的目標入法的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1565.wav", + "text": "我們更要能夠明確地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1566.wav", + "text": "接下來的階段管制目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1567.wav", + "text": "的科學要求跟標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1568.wav", + "text": "但是看了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1569.wav", + "text": "爾志講完之後只要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1570.wav", + "text": "回應到底參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1571.wav", + "text": "或不參採對機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1572.wav", + "text": "來講完全沒有任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1573.wav", + "text": "對於公民的意見當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1574.wav", + "text": "也不具有責任所以時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1575.wav", + "text": "應該要有聽證的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1576.wav", + "text": "這應該是不難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1577.wav", + "text": "因為每四年才舉辦一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1578.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1579.wav", + "text": "請吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1580.wav", + "text": "我同意剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1581.wav", + "text": "邱總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1582.wav", + "text": "我的版本是訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1583.wav", + "text": "兩年為一期的階段管制目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1584.wav", + "text": "\n我們剛剛已經將行動綱領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1585.wav", + "text": "但是我們總不能把所有東西都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1586.wav", + "text": "四年的時候才訂一個管制目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1587.wav", + "text": "那所有的東西都擠在一起這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1588.wav", + "text": "已經通過的條文就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1589.wav", + "text": "我們的資料都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1590.wav", + "text": "太慢了竟然每一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1591.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體都要到隔年的年中才出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1592.wav", + "text": "的資料行動綱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1593.wav", + "text": "綱領這部分是一定要從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1594.wav", + "text": "五年降到四年的可是我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1595.wav", + "text": "你更應該push到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1596.wav", + "text": "降到二年這樣我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1597.wav", + "text": "管制才會更有效率謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1598.wav", + "text": "我想這一題可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1599.wav", + "text": "很難取得共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1600.wav", + "text": "我講白的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1601.wav", + "text": "第十二條就是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1602.wav", + "text": "要新增設置學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1603.wav", + "text": "在這種情況底下假如大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1604.wav", + "text": "我們就暫時保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1605.wav", + "text": "暫時保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1606.wav", + "text": "暫時保留的意思是說有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1607.wav", + "text": "等一下會回頭大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1608.wav", + "text": "如果調整成聽證才有意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1609.wav", + "text": "啊因為照你剛才所講是不希望用聽證的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1610.wav", + "text": "第一輪先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1611.wav", + "text": "等於大家再溝通就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1612.wav", + "text": "暫時保留\n處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1613.wav", + "text": "第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1614.wav", + "text": "有關永續會和推動會的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1615.wav", + "text": "大家是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1616.wav", + "text": "可以同意照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1617.wav", + "text": "會報是永續會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1618.wav", + "text": "地方叫推動會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1619.wav", + "text": "我想這只是名稱而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1620.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼好堅持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1621.wav", + "text": "同樣都是那些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1622.wav", + "text": "啦這些人是組成永續會還是推動會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1623.wav", + "text": "其實都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1624.wav", + "text": "地方政府就是推動會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1625.wav", + "text": "行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1626.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1627.wav", + "text": "一條一條的列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1628.wav", + "text": "學者跟民間團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1629.wav", + "text": "都認為這個寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1630.wav", + "text": "致所以後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1631.wav", + "text": "跟團體和學界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1632.wav", + "text": "一起討論大家建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1633.wav", + "text": "把第十七條條文改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1634.wav", + "text": "現在我提的修正動議的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1635.wav", + "text": "它會化為三個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1636.wav", + "text": "在這些工作的項目下面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1637.wav", + "text": "一樣是要做的但是化為三個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1638.wav", + "text": "第一個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1639.wav", + "text": "十七條的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1640.wav", + "text": "調適專章的第一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1641.wav", + "text": "第十七條的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1642.wav", + "text": "當時從委員會開始雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1643.wav", + "text": "一開始環保署就提出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1644.wav", + "text": "但是那個版本寫的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1645.wav", + "text": "很奇怪所以有很多學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1646.wav", + "text": "跟民間團體就討論對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1647.wav", + "text": "這一條應該怎麼調整怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1648.wav", + "text": "相對會讓它比較有層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1649.wav", + "text": "有目標有邏輯比較順比較通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1650.wav", + "text": "而不是把一堆的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1651.wav", + "text": "這樣的方式去寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1652.wav", + "text": "所以後來大家跟學界朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1653.wav", + "text": "及民間團體一起提出就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1654.wav", + "text": "第一個是以科學為基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1655.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷的風險報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1656.wav", + "text": "第二個是發展因地制宜由下而上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1657.wav", + "text": "或以社區原住民族為本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1658.wav", + "text": "第三個是強化脆弱群體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1659.wav", + "text": "因應氣候變遷衝擊之能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1660.wav", + "text": "並充分考慮人權潛在之影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1661.wav", + "text": "我們做調適工作的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1662.wav", + "text": "來進行調適工作的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1663.wav", + "text": "大概是用這個邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1664.wav", + "text": "去調整第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1665.wav", + "text": "就是把原本的好幾項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1666.wav", + "text": "做一個綜整變成是這三大類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1667.wav", + "text": "修正條文我是想就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1668.wav", + "text": "依照政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1669.wav", + "text": "對於政院版本其實當初我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1670.wav", + "text": "所以到最後整理出這10個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1671.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團這邊再提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1672.wav", + "text": "為基礎也是在原來版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1673.wav", + "text": "嘛但是它會變成簡化了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1674.wav", + "text": "包括像第5款建構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1675.wav", + "text": "綠色金融機制及推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1676.wav", + "text": "簡化掉了因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1677.wav", + "text": "沒有的話我倒是建議應該維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1678.wav", + "text": "原來的版本因為原來的版本應該是我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1679.wav", + "text": "委員會就已經有經過兩三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1680.wav", + "text": "輪的討論所以說才維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1681.wav", + "text": "現在這個行政院提出來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1682.wav", + "text": "現在是雙洪之爭就對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1683.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1684.wav", + "text": "這是3款跟10款之爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1685.wav", + "text": "沒有關係這在委員會有討論過現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1686.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1687.wav", + "text": "這樣會不會簡化太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1688.wav", + "text": "我們就請署長來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1689.wav", + "text": "對於原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1690.wav", + "text": "的這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1691.wav", + "text": "以原住民族或部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1692.wav", + "text": "為本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1693.wav", + "text": "對其他各款是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1694.wav", + "text": "洪委員所提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1695.wav", + "text": "把一些我們也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1696.wav", + "text": "很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1697.wav", + "text": "新興產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1698.wav", + "text": "還有人才培育及公民意識提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1699.wav", + "text": "比較完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1700.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1701.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位委員的指教我想調適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1702.wav", + "text": "就是新增的原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1703.wav", + "text": "並沒有這一章所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1704.wav", + "text": "原來提出來的時候就是儘量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1705.wav", + "text": "試著把它寫得比較完整一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1706.wav", + "text": "在委員會討論的時候其實沒有太多的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1707.wav", + "text": "但是洪委員一直覺得我們這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1708.wav", + "text": "所以他今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1709.wav", + "text": "提出這個修正動議那我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1710.wav", + "text": "建議是不是可以照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1711.wav", + "text": "院版通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1712.wav", + "text": "謝謝洪申翰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1713.wav", + "text": "委員的好意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1714.wav", + "text": "行政院版本本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1715.wav", + "text": "把它修成只有3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1716.wav", + "text": "這樣很多內容都沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1717.wav", + "text": "比如說剛剛所講的最明顯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1718.wav", + "text": "的業務就是因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1719.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷調適需求建構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1720.wav", + "text": "綠色金融機制及推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1721.wav", + "text": "不合適而且我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1722.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1723.wav", + "text": "即使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1724.wav", + "text": "再專業但是這是經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1725.wav", + "text": "行政院政委召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1726.wav", + "text": "各部會之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1727.wav", + "text": "提出來的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1728.wav", + "text": "署長你同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1729.wav", + "text": "你再怎麼專業你把人家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1730.wav", + "text": "很多都不見了這樣真的不合適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1731.wav", + "text": "第9款剛剛有加了文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1732.wav", + "text": "麻煩再確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1733.wav", + "text": "因為我知道這一款會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1734.wav", + "text": "當時在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1735.wav", + "text": "討論第十七條的時候這個第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1736.wav", + "text": "被外界批評的狀況就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1737.wav", + "text": "它裡面規定了很多事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1738.wav", + "text": "但是沒有說誰要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1739.wav", + "text": "它沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1740.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1741.wav", + "text": "在第8條裡面多數其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1742.wav", + "text": "寫的是減碳的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1743.wav", + "text": "調適的專章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1744.wav", + "text": "所以當時第十七條的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1745.wav", + "text": "最受批評的地方包括在我們開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1746.wav", + "text": "這個條文原本的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1747.wav", + "text": "並沒有寫誰要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1748.wav", + "text": "做所以雖然寫了很多事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1749.wav", + "text": "但是它沒有說是由哪一個部會去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1750.wav", + "text": "變成很多可能是無頭公案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1751.wav", + "text": "所以那時候大家才想說是不是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1752.wav", + "text": "調成這些其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1753.wav", + "text": "每一個部會要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1754.wav", + "text": "規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1755.wav", + "text": "所以包括每一個部會要去規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1756.wav", + "text": "的調適工作都要以科學為本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1757.wav", + "text": "每一個部會要去規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1758.wav", + "text": "不同的調適工作都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1759.wav", + "text": "有社區為本的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1760.wav", + "text": "都要去評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1761.wav", + "text": "脆弱群體這變成是原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1762.wav", + "text": "原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1763.wav", + "text": "寫誰要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1764.wav", + "text": "所以很多人擔心因為沒有寫誰要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1765.wav", + "text": "那講了跟沒講其實沒有差太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1766.wav", + "text": "所以後來覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1767.wav", + "text": "那就乾脆把這個條文的概念跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1768.wav", + "text": "邏輯變成是做每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1769.wav", + "text": "調適規劃工作都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1770.wav", + "text": "有的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1771.wav", + "text": "洪委員的意思所以我們民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1772.wav", + "text": "版反而更有務實性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1773.wav", + "text": "剛剛講到的連專責單位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1774.wav", + "text": "應該是保留現有的第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1775.wav", + "text": "然後最後再加一項就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1776.wav", + "text": "所謂的施行細則或子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1777.wav", + "text": "子法的部分來明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1778.wav", + "text": "它的專責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1779.wav", + "text": "階段性期程我覺得這樣就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1780.wav", + "text": "解決剛剛大家的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1781.wav", + "text": "這是我的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1782.wav", + "text": "能要確認一下是哪一位洪委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1783.wav", + "text": "我也很怕被誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1784.wav", + "text": "是洪委員孟楷的意見其實民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1785.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員剛剛提的我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1786.wav", + "text": "真的是多慮了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1787.wav", + "text": "為什麼呢我們在第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1788.wav", + "text": "其實就已經明定排碳負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1789.wav", + "text": "排碳是這個部會負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1790.wav", + "text": "到了調適就變成另外一個部會負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1791.wav", + "text": "綠色金融機制調適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1792.wav", + "text": "排碳綠色金融機制是金管會負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1793.wav", + "text": "不可能調適的時候突然變成是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1794.wav", + "text": "其他部會嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1795.wav", + "text": "你所謂的這些調適其實講的都還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1796.wav", + "text": "該是哪個部會負責我想這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1797.wav", + "text": "很清楚很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1798.wav", + "text": "寫了洋洋灑灑卻沒有人負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1799.wav", + "text": "那我同意可以像剛剛賴委員香伶講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1800.wav", + "text": "多加一條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1801.wav", + "text": "比照第8條那個負責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1802.wav", + "text": "有主辦有協辦或是等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1803.wav", + "text": "但是其實不加這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1804.wav", + "text": "我認為也不會影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1805.wav", + "text": "之後部會的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1806.wav", + "text": "因為本來同一個法令裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1807.wav", + "text": "該負責的部會就是那個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1808.wav", + "text": "不可能會變嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1809.wav", + "text": "我們剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1810.wav", + "text": "聽了洪申翰委員的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1811.wav", + "text": "在他提出來的修正動議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1812.wav", + "text": "對於原本行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1813.wav", + "text": "應該調適部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1814.wav", + "text": "應該做的所有政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1815.wav", + "text": "都是沒有意見只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1816.wav", + "text": "對於誰來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1817.wav", + "text": "除了在剛才我們提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1818.wav", + "text": "各部會負責的事項以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1819.wav", + "text": "是不是應該在本條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1820.wav", + "text": "其他部會該做的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1821.wav", + "text": "項而不是該做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1822.wav", + "text": "沒做把它簡化成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1823.wav", + "text": "一個概略性一個策略性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1824.wav", + "text": "這是不妥適的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1825.wav", + "text": "這樣好像是來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1826.wav", + "text": "不同意那我們是不是應該看怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1827.wav", + "text": "改變得更完善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1828.wav", + "text": "以符合大家的期待我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1829.wav", + "text": "這才是最好的solution" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1830.wav", + "text": "請柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1831.wav", + "text": "環保署有不同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1832.wav", + "text": "環保署的態度怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1833.wav", + "text": "他是要維持吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1834.wav", + "text": "他是要維持原來的第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1835.wav", + "text": "對我們原來提出來是建議這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1836.wav", + "text": "但是我們一直知道洪委員對這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1837.wav", + "text": "是有一些意見跟我們也討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1838.wav", + "text": "只有二擇一而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1839.wav", + "text": "這一條如果我們可以內部說服洪委員的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1840.wav", + "text": "這一條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1841.wav", + "text": "我聽得懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1842.wav", + "text": "也贊成洪委員申翰的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1843.wav", + "text": "他用三個面向來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1844.wav", + "text": "各部會主辦協辦都很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1845.wav", + "text": "所以列舉不完坦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1846.wav", + "text": "一下子原住民一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1847.wav", + "text": "既然這個是我們內部來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1848.wav", + "text": "接受大家的意見我們就照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1849.wav", + "text": "最後我們我們會做決定好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1850.wav", + "text": "就是時力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1851.wav", + "text": "修正動議第2頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1852.wav", + "text": "第二案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1853.wav", + "text": "加原住民族或部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1854.wav", + "text": "這個部分就現在暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1855.wav", + "text": "第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1856.wav", + "text": "就暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1857.wav", + "text": "\n處理第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1858.wav", + "text": "第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1859.wav", + "text": "原來是有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1860.wav", + "text": "第十八條的提案在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1861.wav", + "text": "請洪委員申翰說明一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1862.wav", + "text": "第十八條也是關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1863.wav", + "text": "調適的第二個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1864.wav", + "text": "第十八條主要處理的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1865.wav", + "text": "關於科學評估的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1866.wav", + "text": "在科學評估的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1867.wav", + "text": "在COP27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1868.wav", + "text": "也就是兩個月前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1869.wav", + "text": "開了COP27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1870.wav", + "text": "當時我們確實是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1871.wav", + "text": "通過了第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1872.wav", + "text": "在委員會通過的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1873.wav", + "text": "跟黨團爭取儘量還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1874.wav", + "text": "斜線畫的各級政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1875.wav", + "text": "於必要時得依據前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1876.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷科學報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1877.wav", + "text": "規劃早期預警及系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1878.wav", + "text": "監測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1879.wav", + "text": "這個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1880.wav", + "text": "要去處理的是預警機制的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1881.wav", + "text": "從去年COP27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1882.wav", + "text": "在談調適問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1883.wav", + "text": "最重要的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1884.wav", + "text": "因為大家不希望把調適計畫做出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1885.wav", + "text": "沒有預警機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1886.wav", + "text": "所以現在在國際審查裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1887.wav", + "text": "調適計畫都會要求要有預警機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1888.wav", + "text": "所以在這裡面加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1889.wav", + "text": "大家在調適上面最新的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1890.wav", + "text": "就變成各級政府於必要時得依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1891.wav", + "text": "前項科學報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1892.wav", + "text": "應該規劃早期預警及系統監測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1893.wav", + "text": "是加了這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1894.wav", + "text": "反正已經增加預警機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1895.wav", + "text": "尤其是氣候變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1896.wav", + "text": "國際上也都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1897.wav", + "text": "我只是好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1898.wav", + "text": "為什麼要刪掉具各級政府所需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1899.wav", + "text": "空間尺度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1900.wav", + "text": "這確實也是跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1901.wav", + "text": "一些專家學者討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1902.wav", + "text": "的他們覺得不一定需要把各級政府所需空間尺度放在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1903.wav", + "text": "它在法律上的名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1904.wav", + "text": "會造成一些誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1905.wav", + "text": "很簡單這裡其實不是只有調適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1906.wav", + "text": "這是有關氣候變遷科學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1907.wav", + "text": "而氣候變遷科學其實含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1908.wav", + "text": "再生能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1909.wav", + "text": "再生能源規劃到底能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1910.wav", + "text": "發電量多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1911.wav", + "text": "這是一般民眾想要知道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1912.wav", + "text": "當政府告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1913.wav", + "text": "2025年能夠達到多少風力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1914.wav", + "text": "達到多少光電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1915.wav", + "text": "吳委員我非常瞭解你很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1916.wav", + "text": "後面增加沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1917.wav", + "text": "前面不要刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1918.wav", + "text": "我是建議行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1919.wav", + "text": "維持然後再增加洪申翰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1920.wav", + "text": "我這邊也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1921.wav", + "text": "十八條原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1922.wav", + "text": "前面的各級政府所需空間尺度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1923.wav", + "text": "本來通過的條文就沒有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1924.wav", + "text": "各級政府所需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1925.wav", + "text": "空間尺度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1926.wav", + "text": "我們當初覺得這會有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1927.wav", + "text": "因為各級政府要的東西不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1928.wav", + "text": "怎麼可能提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1929.wav", + "text": "所有需要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1930.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1931.wav", + "text": "通過的時候就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1932.wav", + "text": "這不是行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1933.wav", + "text": "行政版本裡面沒有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1934.wav", + "text": "行政院版本在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1935.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1936.wav", + "text": "我原本也很希望可以把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1937.wav", + "text": "我原本也很希望把各級政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1938.wav", + "text": "這個加上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1939.wav", + "text": "但是確實是跟幾個學者及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1940.wav", + "text": "都能夠由政府來提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1941.wav", + "text": "那個做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1942.wav", + "text": "是操作性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1943.wav", + "text": "而且行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1944.wav", + "text": "原來沒有這段文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1945.wav", + "text": "預警系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1946.wav", + "text": "是洪申翰委員的修正動議這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1947.wav", + "text": "就照建議修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1948.wav", + "text": "是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1949.wav", + "text": "的建議修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1950.wav", + "text": "各級政府沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1951.wav", + "text": "就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1952.wav", + "text": "也有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1953.wav", + "text": "十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1954.wav", + "text": "剛剛已經討論是四年一期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1955.wav", + "text": "了那我們應該是把訂立五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1956.wav", + "text": "年為一期變成四年為一期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1957.wav", + "text": "其他部分我比較沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1958.wav", + "text": "好五年改為四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1959.wav", + "text": "第十九條就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1960.wav", + "text": "是五年改為四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1961.wav", + "text": "可是院長剛剛第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1962.wav", + "text": "這裡可以過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1963.wav", + "text": "四年那個有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1964.wav", + "text": "那個沒有保留調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1965.wav", + "text": "有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1966.wav", + "text": "好第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1967.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1968.wav", + "text": "十七條剛剛是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1969.wav", + "text": "請看第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1970.wav", + "text": "照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1971.wav", + "text": "還有縣市政府的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1972.wav", + "text": "它每年都要編寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1973.wav", + "text": "所以我加了一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1974.wav", + "text": "變遷因應推動會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1975.wav", + "text": "收到直轄市縣市政府每年編寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1976.wav", + "text": "調適執行方案成果報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1977.wav", + "text": "最遲應於3個月內完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1978.wav", + "text": "相關核定程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1979.wav", + "text": "只有直轄市對就縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1980.wav", + "text": "對於氣候變遷因應推動會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1981.wav", + "text": "需要比較短的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1982.wav", + "text": "我們原來的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1983.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷因應推動會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1984.wav", + "text": "分現在林委員所提是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1985.wav", + "text": "要限制在多少時間內核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1986.wav", + "text": "這等於是多了氣候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1987.wav", + "text": "變遷因應推動會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1988.wav", + "text": "要不要這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1989.wav", + "text": "林委員妳不要拿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1990.wav", + "text": "有些縣市政府真的會寫不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1991.wav", + "text": "現在是每年都一定要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1992.wav", + "text": "法條是訂每年都要編寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1993.wav", + "text": "那我問一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1994.wav", + "text": "如果沒有經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1995.wav", + "text": "它可不可以對外公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1996.wav", + "text": "再對外公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1997.wav", + "text": "要核定啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1998.wav", + "text": "啊這樣來講沒有核定喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/1999.wav", + "text": "文字裡面寫得很清楚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2000.wav", + "text": "應該還好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2001.wav", + "text": "妳要改3個月會更麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2002.wav", + "text": "是不是照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2003.wav", + "text": "\n請看第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2004.wav", + "text": "第27條有一個建議修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2005.wav", + "text": "紅字的部分就是扣除排放量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2006.wav", + "text": "或抵銷超額量之比率等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2007.wav", + "text": "原來行政院條文是訂1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2008.wav", + "text": "因為這是境外碳權的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2009.wav", + "text": "當然我們希望境外碳權不要太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2010.wav", + "text": "訂定後以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2011.wav", + "text": "所以不要訂比例啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2012.wav", + "text": "原意大概是這樣是不是請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2013.wav", + "text": "請環保署說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2014.wav", + "text": "法定既有就是十分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2015.wav", + "text": "我們沒有更改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2016.wav", + "text": "沒辦法因應情勢的變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2017.wav", + "text": "改成由中央主管機關參酌相關國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2018.wav", + "text": "際公約訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2019.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2020.wav", + "text": "27條照協商條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2021.wav", + "text": "也有修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2022.wav", + "text": "在院版原本的提案也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2023.wav", + "text": "修正的條文也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2024.wav", + "text": "之直接排放源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2025.wav", + "text": "得檢具提供電力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2026.wav", + "text": "消費之排放量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2027.wav", + "text": "證明文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2028.wav", + "text": "向中央主管機關申請扣除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2029.wav", + "text": "前項第1款之排放量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2030.wav", + "text": "\n白話文就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2031.wav", + "text": "我們要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2032.wav", + "text": "用電的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2033.wav", + "text": "收碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2034.wav", + "text": "或是任何發電業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2035.wav", + "text": "收碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2036.wav", + "text": "只能跟台電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2037.wav", + "text": "買電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2038.wav", + "text": "台電的排碳係數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2039.wav", + "text": "節約能源製造業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2040.wav", + "text": "節約能源頂多大概就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2041.wav", + "text": "可是他沒有選擇他只能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2042.wav", + "text": "跟台電買電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2043.wav", + "text": "台電的電又這麼髒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2044.wav", + "text": "完全不用負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2045.wav", + "text": "碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2046.wav", + "text": "這是一個非常奇怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2047.wav", + "text": "要跟你收碳費因為你用電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2048.wav", + "text": "不好意思我的電非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2049.wav", + "text": "髒因為我們的排碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2050.wav", + "text": "係數大概是0.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2051.wav", + "text": "我們竟然對台電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2052.wav", + "text": "跑了完全沒有壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2053.wav", + "text": "把壓力全部放在製造業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2054.wav", + "text": "自己要節約能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2055.wav", + "text": "但是它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2056.wav", + "text": "不知道的是它再怎麼節約能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2057.wav", + "text": "而且用的電是很髒的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2058.wav", + "text": "整個應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2059.wav", + "text": "刪除謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2060.wav", + "text": "我們的版本基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2061.wav", + "text": "就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2062.wav", + "text": "第3項有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2063.wav", + "text": "寫─第1項碳費之費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2064.wav", + "text": "年度調漲之漲幅不得低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2065.wav", + "text": "未能達成各期階段管制目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2066.wav", + "text": "時應再增加五分之一以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2067.wav", + "text": "之所以是這樣的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2068.wav", + "text": "當然就是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2069.wav", + "text": "由母法授權碳費的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2070.wav", + "text": "調漲機制就是在母法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2071.wav", + "text": "避免外在的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2072.wav", + "text": "第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2073.wav", + "text": "環保署現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2074.wav", + "text": "已經有把碳費審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2075.wav", + "text": "請署長也可以就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2076.wav", + "text": "的審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2077.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2078.wav", + "text": "現在的費率審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2079.wav", + "text": "的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2080.wav", + "text": "有費率審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2081.wav", + "text": "會的組成這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2082.wav", + "text": "部分也是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2083.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2084.wav", + "text": "審議會的組成包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2085.wav", + "text": "專家學者及民間團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2086.wav", + "text": "代表不得少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2087.wav", + "text": "於審議會總人數三分之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2088.wav", + "text": "不一定要放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2089.wav", + "text": "法裡面的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2090.wav", + "text": "至少這個文字要放相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2091.wav", + "text": "會的組織與運作辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2092.wav", + "text": "還是中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2093.wav", + "text": "主管機關要另定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2094.wav", + "text": "要放進來但是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2095.wav", + "text": "環保署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2096.wav", + "text": "修正條文裡面是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2097.wav", + "text": "看到這些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2098.wav", + "text": "說明以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2099.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2100.wav", + "text": "也有一個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2101.wav", + "text": "我的版本本來是第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2102.wav", + "text": "沒關係我們現在在討論第二十八條最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2103.wav", + "text": "我關心的是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2104.wav", + "text": "我們開宗明義說要分階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2105.wav", + "text": "大概再說明一下我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2106.wav", + "text": "80%以上臺灣的中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2107.wav", + "text": "是非常關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2108.wav", + "text": "這個條文是授權給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2109.wav", + "text": "中央主管單位來定所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2110.wav", + "text": "碳費徵收對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2111.wav", + "text": "計算方式等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2112.wav", + "text": "甚至在這一條裡面有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2113.wav", + "text": "這個制度的設計是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2114.wav", + "text": "中小企業製造業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2115.wav", + "text": "進行輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2116.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是非常重要的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2117.wav", + "text": "到底是先碳費再碳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2118.wav", + "text": "還是只有碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2119.wav", + "text": "還是未來碳費落日之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2120.wav", + "text": "就以碳稅為整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2121.wav", + "text": "的工具為了讓業界及國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2122.wav", + "text": "作為達到減碳目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2123.wav", + "text": "環保署要說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2124.wav", + "text": "政策\n第二個現在的版本裡面確實沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2125.wav", + "text": "一定要先保留不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2126.wav", + "text": "碳費及碳稅的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2127.wav", + "text": "國際的立法趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2128.wav", + "text": "\n再來我同意剛才何欣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2129.wav", + "text": "欣純委員講到的問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2130.wav", + "text": "如何處理直接排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2131.wav", + "text": "間接排放排放種類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2132.wav", + "text": "規模等等這也要透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2133.wav", + "text": "工具達到我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2134.wav", + "text": "也許保留之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2135.wav", + "text": "下次環保署可以提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2136.wav", + "text": "大家說明為什麼設一個審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2137.wav", + "text": "定階段性的目標不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2138.wav", + "text": "跟國際接軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2139.wav", + "text": "以及跟國人報告的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2140.wav", + "text": "所以希望你們用data說服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2141.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們也有提出條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2142.wav", + "text": "我認為中央應該收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2143.wav", + "text": "碳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2144.wav", + "text": "地方要讓他們得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2145.wav", + "text": "地方應該是合作的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2146.wav", + "text": "中央收稅是要用於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2147.wav", + "text": "普發碳紅利還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2148.wav", + "text": "做弱勢的公正轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2149.wav", + "text": "其實還是可以採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2150.wav", + "text": "舉例來說像房地合一稅就可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2151.wav", + "text": "在我們想要專款專用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2152.wav", + "text": "地方的部分為什麼說得收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2153.wav", + "text": "碳費因為它可以用在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2154.wav", + "text": "在地方的減碳跟轉型事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2155.wav", + "text": "哪些部分要如何做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2156.wav", + "text": "不代表一定要可是可以給地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2157.wav", + "text": "地方是合作的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2158.wav", + "text": "像花東如果希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2159.wav", + "text": "訂定地方的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2160.wav", + "text": "一天我質詢的時候提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2161.wav", + "text": "你要跟國際接軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2162.wav", + "text": "還有剛剛講到的要讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2163.wav", + "text": "碳稅才有辦法進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2164.wav", + "text": "我們希望碳稅跟碳費之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2165.wav", + "text": "能夠有落日跟日出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2166.wav", + "text": "如果中央跟地方沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2167.wav", + "text": "有得以銜接的條款謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2168.wav", + "text": "曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2169.wav", + "text": "講話之前向大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2170.wav", + "text": "時間的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2171.wav", + "text": "列席的行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2172.wav", + "text": "官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2173.wav", + "text": "氣體減量及管理法修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2174.wav", + "text": "草案無關的可以先行離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2175.wav", + "text": "這個還沒有談好其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2176.wav", + "text": "可以先離席\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2177.wav", + "text": "第3項規定第1項碳費之徵收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2178.wav", + "text": "費率由中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2179.wav", + "text": "主管機關所設之費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2180.wav", + "text": "審議委員會\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2181.wav", + "text": "這個牽涉非常廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2182.wav", + "text": "所以這一條等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2183.wav", + "text": "會的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2184.wav", + "text": "很重要要寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2185.wav", + "text": "否則到時候人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2186.wav", + "text": "質疑它的正當性你要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2187.wav", + "text": "委員會的組成必須公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2188.wav", + "text": "透明我覺得要在這裡寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2189.wav", + "text": "拜託環保署趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2190.wav", + "text": "擬條文因為這很重要而且金額很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2191.wav", + "text": "所以一定要有一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2192.wav", + "text": "謝謝我講一下針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2193.wav", + "text": "針對這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2194.wav", + "text": "我大概聽了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2195.wav", + "text": "中央碳稅地方碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2196.wav", + "text": "台電的問題第2項的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2197.wav", + "text": "在說明欄寫清楚就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2198.wav", + "text": "了要短時間內講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2199.wav", + "text": "清楚再一個鐘頭也不會有共識先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2200.wav", + "text": "好那第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2201.wav", + "text": "第29條是不是照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2202.wav", + "text": "建議修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2203.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2204.wav", + "text": "院長第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2205.wav", + "text": "我有提一個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2206.wav", + "text": "因為這個條文主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2207.wav", + "text": "的精神就是讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2208.wav", + "text": "一些企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2209.wav", + "text": "可以提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2210.wav", + "text": "自主減量計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2211.wav", + "text": "由環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2212.wav", + "text": "核定優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2213.wav", + "text": "的費率這會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2214.wav", + "text": "幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2215.wav", + "text": "這個部分其實是為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2216.wav", + "text": "企業開一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2217.wav", + "text": "後門讓它有方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2218.wav", + "text": "協調的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2219.wav", + "text": "高污染排放高溫室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2220.wav", + "text": "氣體排放的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2221.wav", + "text": "可以透過這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2222.wav", + "text": "得補貼或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2223.wav", + "text": "這7年減碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2224.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2225.wav", + "text": "29條刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2226.wav", + "text": "你要建議刪除以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2227.wav", + "text": "我知道你要講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2228.wav", + "text": "環團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2229.wav", + "text": "對於大用戶的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2230.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2231.wav", + "text": "這個調整之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2232.wav", + "text": "把轉換低碳燃料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2233.wav", + "text": "提升能源效率等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2234.wav", + "text": "其實我有跟環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2235.wav", + "text": "28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2236.wav", + "text": "其實我們是主張碳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2237.wav", + "text": "如果要碳費的話也應該有個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2238.wav", + "text": "落日條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2239.wav", + "text": "現在第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2240.wav", + "text": "第一次規定了碳費之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2241.wav", + "text": "結果在第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2242.wav", + "text": "核定優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2243.wav", + "text": "對於費率要怎麼訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2244.wav", + "text": "全部都是空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2245.wav", + "text": "一個你不知道內容的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2246.wav", + "text": "所謂的碳費優惠費率到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2247.wav", + "text": "會不會變成廠商根本都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2248.wav", + "text": "究竟是繳了之後你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2249.wav", + "text": "的結果是完全不用繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2250.wav", + "text": "反對這樣的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2251.wav", + "text": "之後過了一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2252.wav", + "text": "第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2253.wav", + "text": "規定碳費第29條是一個優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2254.wav", + "text": "第33條也是一個補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2255.wav", + "text": "以為不可不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2256.wav", + "text": "用這樣的方式然後又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2257.wav", + "text": "到最後是各個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2258.wav", + "text": "壓力團體各方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2259.wav", + "text": "不應該用這樣的方式處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2260.wav", + "text": "院版當然比較像剛剛邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2261.wav", + "text": "提到的空白授權因為人事行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2262.wav", + "text": "部門自己去訂所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2263.wav", + "text": "而現在民進黨黨團提的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2264.wav", + "text": "是有一些benchmark就是有些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2265.wav", + "text": "條件比方轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2266.wav", + "text": "轉換低碳燃料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2267.wav", + "text": "負排放技術提升能源效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2268.wav", + "text": "使用再生能源製程改善等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2269.wav", + "text": "之類如果大家有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2270.wav", + "text": "我們也可以保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2271.wav", + "text": "是不是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2272.wav", + "text": "在此還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2273.wav", + "text": "請各位委員及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2274.wav", + "text": "各政黨支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2275.wav", + "text": "本席參與環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2276.wav", + "text": "運動多年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2277.wav", + "text": "臺灣有很多污染的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2278.wav", + "text": "效率污染" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2279.wav", + "text": "防制措施的高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2280.wav", + "text": "對於臺灣來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2281.wav", + "text": "的機會但是第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2282.wav", + "text": "這樣訂定以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2283.wav", + "text": "這些比較有污染的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2284.wav", + "text": "還是會阻礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2285.wav", + "text": "臺灣的產業升級所以還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2286.wav", + "text": "請大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2287.wav", + "text": "支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2288.wav", + "text": "這個條文不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2289.wav", + "text": "負排放的技術就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2290.wav", + "text": "等就會減少排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2291.wav", + "text": "那為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2292.wav", + "text": "優惠費率因為其實已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2293.wav", + "text": "如果採用這些技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2294.wav", + "text": "他們設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2295.wav", + "text": "技術的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2296.wav", + "text": "資金這是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2297.wav", + "text": "他們採用了這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2298.wav", + "text": "技術本來就會減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2299.wav", + "text": "他們本來排放100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2300.wav", + "text": "只跟他們收60噸的80%是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2301.wav", + "text": "確實剛剛大家在問這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2302.wav", + "text": "工具之間的關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2303.wav", + "text": "到底達到的效果是讓他們減排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2304.wav", + "text": "或者是補��他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2305.wav", + "text": "們未來可以轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2306.wav", + "text": "這34條看起來都是為了這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2307.wav", + "text": "方向只是現在大家在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2308.wav", + "text": "的第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2309.wav", + "text": "是以每噸300元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2310.wav", + "text": "起徵署長是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2311.wav", + "text": "還是沒有訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2312.wav", + "text": "所以是不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2313.wav", + "text": "既然到目前都不知道就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2314.wav", + "text": "訂一個優惠的費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2315.wav", + "text": "前提是有轉換低碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2316.wav", + "text": "你們是已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2317.wav", + "text": "一定的信心而認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2318.wav", + "text": "這些高污染性的產業會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2319.wav", + "text": "做這件事所以可以用這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2320.wav", + "text": "條款來讓他們接受我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2321.wav", + "text": "定碳費這是第一個疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2322.wav", + "text": "做這件事情要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2323.wav", + "text": "訂定這個條款現在的起徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2324.wav", + "text": "費率各方還不知道所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2325.wav", + "text": "的狀況先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2326.wav", + "text": "在法律裡面訂清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2327.wav", + "text": "要向國人說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2328.wav", + "text": "不管是第28條第29" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2329.wav", + "text": "條及未來第33" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2330.wav", + "text": "條我建議都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2331.wav", + "text": "協商依據把報告寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2332.wav", + "text": "包括起徵價是多少都應該讓國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2333.wav", + "text": "暫時保留\n處理第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2334.wav", + "text": "第32條照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2335.wav", + "text": "版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2336.wav", + "text": "可以喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2337.wav", + "text": "32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2338.wav", + "text": "有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2339.wav", + "text": "最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2340.wav", + "text": "第6款之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2341.wav", + "text": "加上一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2342.wav", + "text": "本基金設溫室氣體管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2343.wav", + "text": "基金委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2344.wav", + "text": "負責基金之收支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2345.wav", + "text": "管理及運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2346.wav", + "text": "因為主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2347.wav", + "text": "這個管理基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2348.wav", + "text": "審議會的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2349.wav", + "text": "第32條很重要就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2350.wav", + "text": "現在有溫室氣體管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2351.wav", + "text": "運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2352.wav", + "text": "考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2353.wav", + "text": "應該要設立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2354.wav", + "text": "管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2355.wav", + "text": "但是第32條沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2356.wav", + "text": "所以建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2357.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2358.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2359.wav", + "text": "民眾黨的立場是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2360.wav", + "text": "基金收入來源要包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2361.wav", + "text": "碳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2362.wav", + "text": "32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2363.wav", + "text": "我先講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2364.wav", + "text": "要設立一個管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2365.wav", + "text": "可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2366.wav", + "text": "嘛所有基金的收支管理辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2367.wav", + "text": "在預算法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2368.wav", + "text": "了所以沒有在設管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2369.wav", + "text": "的因為依法本來就有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2370.wav", + "text": "嘛沒有在設管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2371.wav", + "text": "如果不需要設管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2372.wav", + "text": "基金的收支管理運用考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2373.wav", + "text": "相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2374.wav", + "text": "管理辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2375.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2376.wav", + "text": "管理委員會其實是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2377.wav", + "text": "依照預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2378.wav", + "text": "它就會訂定一個基金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2379.wav", + "text": "統一訂定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2380.wav", + "text": "(由主計總處訂定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2381.wav", + "text": "審計都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2382.wav", + "text": "所以這個本來就有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2383.wav", + "text": "好第32條就照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2384.wav", + "text": "政府循預算程序之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2385.wav", + "text": "撥款就有稅的概念在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2386.wav", + "text": "了啊所以有沒有碳稅都不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2387.wav", + "text": "因為這一條本來就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2388.wav", + "text": "把稅預算撥進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2389.wav", + "text": "對啊所以要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2390.wav", + "text": "課徵碳稅啊所以保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2391.wav", + "text": "但是碳稅還沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2392.wav", + "text": "定案所以我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2393.wav", + "text": "一下啦好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2394.wav", + "text": "第32條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2395.wav", + "text": "碳稅是完全不一樣的系統和概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2396.wav", + "text": "第32條先保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2397.wav", + "text": "我的版本其實是在各項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2398.wav", + "text": "之後加一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2399.wav", + "text": "設立專責的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2400.wav", + "text": "現在各個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2401.wav", + "text": "能源局也好環保署也好相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2402.wav", + "text": "相關數字常常都對不上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2403.wav", + "text": "做但是沒有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2404.wav", + "text": "統整的機關來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2405.wav", + "text": "政策建議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2406.wav", + "text": "這個研究機關非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2407.wav", + "text": "就比如說我們之後要先跟誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2408.wav", + "text": "課這個碳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2409.wav", + "text": "是跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2410.wav", + "text": "大戶課還是像我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2411.wav", + "text": "你必須提出一些數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2412.wav", + "text": "為什麼要這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2413.wav", + "text": "看是誰先課或者是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2414.wav", + "text": "說服大家為什麼要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2415.wav", + "text": "所以我是希望這個基金的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2416.wav", + "text": "可以加一個專責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2417.wav", + "text": "輔助這個決策單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2418.wav", + "text": "謝謝好請何欣純委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2419.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長我只有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2420.wav", + "text": "有一個部分用來輔導這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2421.wav", + "text": "中小企業傳統產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2422.wav", + "text": "解釋清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2423.wav", + "text": "一般的中小企業包括很多的加工廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2424.wav", + "text": "老闆跟老闆娘根本看不懂什麼叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2425.wav", + "text": "公正轉型這四個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2426.wav", + "text": "這是第一個\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2427.wav", + "text": "是用於扶植跟輔導他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2428.wav", + "text": "來適應跟調適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2429.wav", + "text": "還有未來能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2430.wav", + "text": "真正達到淨零碳排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2431.wav", + "text": "我想這個方向一定要請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2432.wav", + "text": "環保署好好地說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2433.wav", + "text": "我希望可以聽得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2434.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2435.wav", + "text": "請林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2436.wav", + "text": "我們如果比照原來的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2437.wav", + "text": "辦理溫室氣體減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2438.wav", + "text": "維持原來的補助及獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2439.wav", + "text": "事業投資溫室氣體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2440.wav", + "text": "減量技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2441.wav", + "text": "我想詢問一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2442.wav", + "text": "因為在CBAM有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2443.wav", + "text": "不能有��何形式的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2444.wav", + "text": "那這個第四點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2445.wav", + "text": "獎勵事業投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2446.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量技術的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2447.wav", + "text": "算不算跟CBAM" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2448.wav", + "text": "是衝突的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2449.wav", + "text": "能不能稍微說明一下這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2450.wav", + "text": "接下來請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2451.wav", + "text": "環保署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2452.wav", + "text": "建議修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2453.wav", + "text": "有規定溫室氣體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2454.wav", + "text": "管理基金應優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2455.wav", + "text": "用於前項第4款及第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2456.wav", + "text": "的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2457.wav", + "text": "修正動議也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2458.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2459.wav", + "text": "我們支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2460.wav", + "text": "環保署的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2461.wav", + "text": "公正轉型的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2462.wav", + "text": "的條文是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2463.wav", + "text": "補助的第1項第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2464.wav", + "text": "這個問題跟我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2465.wav", + "text": "提到的第二十九條一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2466.wav", + "text": "未來其實會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2467.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個是搬石頭砸自己的腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2468.wav", + "text": "我其實也有跟你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2469.wav", + "text": "及獎勵事業投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2470.wav", + "text": "溫室氣體減量技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2471.wav", + "text": "第5款倒是還好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2472.wav", + "text": "減量工作的研究跟開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2473.wav", + "text": "是在做研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2474.wav", + "text": "但是第四款是直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2475.wav", + "text": "針對這一個事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2476.wav", + "text": "不可因為這個有利益迴避的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2477.wav", + "text": "第二十九條好不容易有徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2478.wav", + "text": "碳費這也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2479.wav", + "text": "我國有史以來的第一次徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2480.wav", + "text": "了碳費之後你在第三十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2481.wav", + "text": "第1項第四款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2482.wav", + "text": "補助而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2483.wav", + "text": "這個補助是針對你所課徵的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2484.wav", + "text": "申請資格條件審查程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2485.wav", + "text": "方式等等都是由環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2486.wav", + "text": "去訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2487.wav", + "text": "等於又是空白授權出去如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2488.wav", + "text": "今天通過的話通過一個不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2489.wav", + "text": "什麼內容的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2490.wav", + "text": "是期期以為不可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2491.wav", + "text": "應該把第4款刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2492.wav", + "text": "我覺得第5款還有點道理但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2493.wav", + "text": "第4款應該要刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2494.wav", + "text": "相關的規劃跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2495.wav", + "text": "清楚地說明因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2496.wav", + "text": "授權明確性原則是非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2497.wav", + "text": "的即便要授權也應該要具體明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2498.wav", + "text": "也應該要能夠知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2499.wav", + "text": "可預測性在哪裡這是大法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2500.wav", + "text": "的要求所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2501.wav", + "text": "就這個部分的話當然這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2502.wav", + "text": "這樣的規定是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2503.wav", + "text": "洪委員感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2504.wav", + "text": "我很快速講第32條或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2505.wav", + "text": "管理會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2506.wav", + "text": "監督運作收支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2507.wav", + "text": "保管跟運作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2508.wav", + "text": "我看到其他委員也有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2509.wav", + "text": "所以我想確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2510.wav", + "text": "要放在哪裡放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2511.wav", + "text": "跟何欣純委員剛剛講的其實也是類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2512.wav", + "text": "公正轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2513.wav", + "text": "會不會真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2514.wav", + "text": "我知道跟我們剛剛討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2515.wav", + "text": "的第8條其實也是一樣類似的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2516.wav", + "text": "講的才叫公正不配合的都叫不公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2517.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2518.wav", + "text": "用詞是不是要寫得更明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2519.wav", + "text": "或是更白話有關這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2520.wav", + "text": "我想應該要來討論請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2521.wav", + "text": "公正轉型不是指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2522.wav", + "text": "誰說的才是公正誰說的不是公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2523.wav", + "text": "公正轉型是來自於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2524.wav", + "text": "現在在氣候政策裡面非常重要的一個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2525.wav", + "text": "叫做JustTransition" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2526.wav", + "text": "JustTransition" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2527.wav", + "text": "在現在的公約裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2528.wav", + "text": "都訂有相關的章節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2529.wav", + "text": "在臺灣就翻譯成公正轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2530.wav", + "text": "它不是說誰公正誰不公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2531.wav", + "text": "這一條其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2532.wav", + "text": "過去在民間包括有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2533.wav", + "text": "中小企業就像剛剛何欣純委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2534.wav", + "text": "一直希望爭取的我舉例公正轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2535.wav", + "text": "就是像我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2536.wav", + "text": "傳統的機車行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2537.wav", + "text": "可以修電動機車的機車行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2538.wav", + "text": "這一個轉變的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2539.wav", + "text": "趨勢下面它必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2540.wav", + "text": "被迫改變的這就是公正轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2541.wav", + "text": "過去之前環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2542.wav", + "text": "不願意把公正轉型放為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2543.wav", + "text": "碳費的用途很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2544.wav", + "text": "民間團體包括這些中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2545.wav", + "text": "包括像這樣的自營作業者即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2546.wav", + "text": "會受到氣候政策的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2547.wav", + "text": "而需要被迫改變的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2548.wav", + "text": "他們很需要政府有一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2549.wav", + "text": "資金資源去協助他們改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2550.wav", + "text": "所以才會一直爭取希望把它放到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2551.wav", + "text": "碳費基金的用途裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2552.wav", + "text": "這是公正轉型的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2553.wav", + "text": "我先解釋到這邊它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2554.wav", + "text": "它不是說誰公正誰不公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2555.wav", + "text": "我大概聽一下大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2556.wav", + "text": "的意見跟看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2557.wav", + "text": "剛才何欣純委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2558.wav", + "text": "講到公正轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2559.wav", + "text": "洪委員也談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2560.wav", + "text": "公正轉型公正轉型在第3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2561.wav", + "text": "3條的定義就有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2562.wav", + "text": "何欣純委員的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2563.wav", + "text": "中小企業是不是要把說明欄寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2564.wav", + "text": "因為這個名詞大家聽不太懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2565.wav", + "text": "這沒有關係這也可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2566.wav", + "text": "至於時代力量他們二人的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2567.wav", + "text": "支持行政院版本把第4款第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2568.wav", + "text": "優先劃掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2569.wav", + "text": "但是邱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2570.wav", + "text": "邱顯智委員連第4款都不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2571.wav", + "text": "胡蘿蔔與棒子的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2572.wav", + "text": "去改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2573.wav", + "text": "沒有優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2574.wav", + "text": "補助的你放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2575.wav", + "text": "我認為第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2576.wav", + "text": "主席我可不可以建議就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2577.wav", + "text": "修正條文可不可以用一個決議的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2578.wav", + "text": "來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2579.wav", + "text": "希望有一些原則規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2580.wav", + "text": "用附帶決議的方式來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2581.wav", + "text": "也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2582.wav", + "text": "不要動條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2583.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2584.wav", + "text": "33條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2585.wav", + "text": "照修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2586.wav", + "text": "這個就寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2587.wav", + "text": "的對象或者是條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2588.wav", + "text": "都還是一個空白授權的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2589.wav", + "text": "所以我們也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2590.wav", + "text": "不是啦我們也不知道到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2591.wav", + "text": "一般立法例都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2592.wav", + "text": "沒有這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2593.wav", + "text": "大概我們的規劃是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2594.wav", + "text": "讓他很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2595.wav", + "text": "某一個人我們私相授受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2596.wav", + "text": "一定會有類似補助辦法或是專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2597.wav", + "text": "計畫然後才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2598.wav", + "text": "如果有一個補助辦法我們依照法規程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2599.wav", + "text": "一定會有公聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2600.wav", + "text": "所以這不會是黑箱作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2601.wav", + "text": "好那就照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2602.wav", + "text": "不能夠這樣就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2603.wav", + "text": "尤其是像第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2604.wav", + "text": "十二款其他有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2605.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷調適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2606.wav", + "text": "這到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2607.wav", + "text": "請環保署再和邱總召溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2608.wav", + "text": "36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2609.wav", + "text": "是不是也照建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2610.wav", + "text": "增加了最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2611.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2612.wav", + "text": "得委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2613.wav", + "text": "中央金融主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2614.wav", + "text": "第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2615.wav", + "text": "及前條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2616.wav", + "text": "所定額度之交易事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2617.wav", + "text": "這是我在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2618.wav", + "text": "委員會協商的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2619.wav", + "text": "因為本條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2620.wav", + "text": "規定以後會有個交易平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2621.wav", + "text": "台說是短期間可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2622.wav", + "text": "但若這個交易平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2623.wav", + "text": "不公開也不透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2624.wav", + "text": "成立碳權交易所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2625.wav", + "text": "新加坡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2626.wav", + "text": "印尼和馬來西亞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2627.wav", + "text": "統統都成立了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2628.wav", + "text": "我們的很多大企業都還到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2629.wav", + "text": "新加坡去買碳權去交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2630.wav", + "text": "要在短期間成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2631.wav", + "text": "交易平台我沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2632.wav", + "text": "能讓證交所去成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2633.wav", + "text": "以我要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2634.wav", + "text": "到時候環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2635.wav", + "text": "或行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2636.wav", + "text": "要委託你們成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2637.wav", + "text": "碳權交易所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2638.wav", + "text": "會尊重環保署的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2639.wav", + "text": "屆時我們會配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2640.wav", + "text": "協助辦理只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2641.wav", + "text": "應該會比較清楚我們是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2642.wav", + "text": "到時候相關子法及交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2643.wav", + "text": "規範還請環保署予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2644.wav", + "text": "我簡單補充一下碳權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2645.wav", + "text": "查核運用管理等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2646.wav", + "text": "裡所以金管會就只負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2647.wav", + "text": "交易的部分畢竟牽涉到金融" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2648.wav", + "text": "的部分他們比較專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2649.wav", + "text": "好本案就照修正動議條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2650.wav", + "text": "\n處理第五章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2651.wav", + "text": "教育宣導及獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2652.wav", + "text": "還沒有已經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2653.wav", + "text": "第五章章名教育宣導及獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2654.wav", + "text": "沒問題沒問題通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2655.wav", + "text": "\n處理第43條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2656.wav", + "text": "那第42條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2657.wav", + "text": "跟院長和大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2658.wav", + "text": "我們原本修正通過的第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2659.wav", + "text": "42條沒有保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2660.wav", + "text": "我們今天只討論保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2661.wav", + "text": "剛才有說這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2662.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2663.wav", + "text": "精細的修正\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2664.wav", + "text": "教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2665.wav", + "text": "在職教育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2666.wav", + "text": "學校要推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2667.wav", + "text": "但是事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2668.wav", + "text": "的是氣候變遷教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2669.wav", + "text": "政策的高度在國民教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2670.wav", + "text": "體系中去推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2671.wav", + "text": "像目前的英國義大利德國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2672.wav", + "text": "等國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2673.wav", + "text": "都有相關的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2674.wav", + "text": "一定要與永續發展教育進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2675.wav", + "text": "整合所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2676.wav", + "text": "我在這邊才又分為兩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2677.wav", + "text": "點一個是於各級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2678.wav", + "text": "學校推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2679.wav", + "text": "以永續發展為導向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2680.wav", + "text": "之氣候變遷教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2681.wav", + "text": "培育師資研發與編製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2682.wav", + "text": "教材培育未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2683.wav", + "text": "因應氣候變遷之跨領域人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2684.wav", + "text": "再多一點是鼓勵各級政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2685.wav", + "text": "企業民間團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2686.wav", + "text": "支持與強化氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2687.wav", + "text": "教育結合環境教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2688.wav", + "text": "終身教育及在職教育之相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2689.wav", + "text": "措施也就是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2690.wav", + "text": "整體2050淨零碳排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2691.wav", + "text": "觀念可以接軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2692.wav", + "text": "也跟聯合國教科文組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2693.wav", + "text": "這部分是不是可以拜託一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2694.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2695.wav", + "text": "好請署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2696.wav", + "text": "我想這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2697.wav", + "text": "應該只是把它寫得比較細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2698.wav", + "text": "一點而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2699.wav", + "text": "假如可以我們就接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2700.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2701.wav", + "text": "第42條就修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2702.wav", + "text": "林委員把第5款第6款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2703.wav", + "text": "下來處理第43條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2704.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2705.wav", + "text": "我們的版本第五章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2706.wav", + "text": "專章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2707.wav", + "text": "就是我們的版本裡面有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2708.wav", + "text": "談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2709.wav", + "text": "第43條照行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2710.wav", + "text": "版本通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2711.wav", + "text": "新增的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2712.wav", + "text": "第46條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2713.wav", + "text": "是民進黨黨團提出的新增條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2714.wav", + "text": "主要是有關公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2715.wav", + "text": "其中一個戰略就是公正轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2716.wav", + "text": "我們希望公正轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2717.wav", + "text": "方案研擬的過程應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2718.wav", + "text": "法制化也就是各部會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2719.wav", + "text": "自己的公正轉型計畫每個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2720.wav", + "text": "針對未來可能會受影響的產業或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2721.wav", + "text": "受影響的群體提出公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2722.wav", + "text": "國發會因為國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2723.wav", + "text": "是這個法裡面公正轉型的主辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2724.wav", + "text": "機關送到國發會後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2725.wav", + "text": "用公私協力方式彙整彙整完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2726.wav", + "text": "再送到行政院用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2727.wav", + "text": "提出來的公正轉型計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2728.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2729.wav", + "text": "這個部分條次可能要調整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2730.wav", + "text": "抱歉這裡要更正就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2731.wav", + "text": "剛剛第54條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2732.wav", + "text": "因為增列了一個條文所以應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2733.wav", + "text": "我是說條文裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2734.wav", + "text": "就是第54條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2735.wav", + "text": "59條要改什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2736.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2737.wav", + "text": "第58條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2738.wav", + "text": "就照行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2739.wav", + "text": "院長我們的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2740.wav", + "text": "氣候公民訴訟專章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2741.wav", + "text": "是許多國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2742.wav", + "text": "訴訟制度發展的初期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2743.wav", + "text": "把所有的行政行為都納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2744.wav", + "text": "司法審查對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2745.wav", + "text": "在我國一直存在法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2746.wav", + "text": "命令直接侵害人民權利時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2747.wav", + "text": "人民無法向行政法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2748.wav", + "text": "提出救濟的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2749.wav", + "text": "缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2750.wav", + "text": "於是我們提出這個公民訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2751.wav", + "text": "在公民針對這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2752.wav", + "text": "時可以透過訴訟方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2753.wav", + "text": "作為救濟課題過於抽象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2754.wav", + "text": "等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2755.wav", + "text": "疑慮其實法規命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2756.wav", + "text": "救濟在許多國家已經行之有年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2757.wav", + "text": "就像我剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2758.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2759.wav", + "text": "限縮幾個救濟標的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2760.wav", + "text": "不提出本法明定的幾個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2761.wav", + "text": "制度至於行政機關擔心過度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2762.wav", + "text": "即將要升格為環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2763.wav", + "text": "未來環保署可能有更多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2764.wav", + "text": "資源其實過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2765.wav", + "text": "環保署也有許多處理環境訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2766.wav", + "text": "的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2767.wav", + "text": "退一步來講的話基本上你們也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2768.wav", + "text": "標的的範圍到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2769.wav", + "text": "行政機關可以負荷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2770.wav", + "text": "怠於訂定減量的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2771.wav", + "text": "才會面臨訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2772.wav", + "text": "可以共同來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2773.wav", + "text": "\n最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2774.wav", + "text": "一個就是公正公約跟氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2775.wav", + "text": "其實就有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2776.wav", + "text": "國家應該要制定必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2777.wav", + "text": "的立法或其他的措施以實現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2778.wav", + "text": "本公約所確認的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2779.wav", + "text": "同條第3項第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2780.wav", + "text": "也明定本公約締約國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2781.wav", + "text": "第一個應該確保任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2782.wav", + "text": "人所享本公約確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2783.wav", + "text": "之權利或自由如果遭受侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2784.wav", + "text": "的時候都能夠獲得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2785.wav", + "text": "有效的救濟跟公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2786.wav", + "text": "行為也沒有例外所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2787.wav", + "text": "就這部分的話如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2788.wav", + "text": "完全不提出階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2789.wav", + "text": "之下或或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2790.wav", + "text": "管制的目標減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2791.wav", + "text": "行動的計畫都明顯違法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2792.wav", + "text": "情況而且造成人民生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2793.wav", + "text": "威脅的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2794.wav", + "text": "公民訴訟的話其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2795.wav", + "text": "有可能會造成這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2796.wav", + "text": "重大救濟的缺口反而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2797.wav", + "text": "有違反兩公約之虞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2798.wav", + "text": "所以就這個部分的話我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2799.wav", + "text": "定公民訴訟條款而能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2800.wav", + "text": "真的落實我國的氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2801.wav", + "text": "好請司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2802.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2803.wav", + "text": "院長各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2804.wav", + "text": "司法院也跟各位報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2805.wav", + "text": "對這一個公民訴訟其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2806.wav", + "text": "我們認為應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2807.wav", + "text": "誠如洪委員所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2808.wav", + "text": "我們現在的行政訴訟所有的訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2809.wav", + "text": "因為一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2810.wav", + "text": "行政行為或行政處分受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2811.wav", + "text": "跟那個行政處分行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2812.wav", + "text": "的時候他才有起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2813.wav", + "text": "目前這個草案似乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2814.wav", + "text": "看不出來可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2815.wav", + "text": "到底是不是限於有受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2816.wav", + "text": "侵害的這些人我們才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2817.wav", + "text": "像洪委員講的將來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2818.wav", + "text": "應訴的負荷也造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2819.wav", + "text": "辦法承受這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2820.wav", + "text": "我們認為要慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2821.wav", + "text": "的以目前的行政訴訟恐怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2822.wav", + "text": "是沒有辦法承擔這樣的能量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2823.wav", + "text": "能不能先看到條文再協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2824.wav", + "text": "先看到條文再協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2825.wav", + "text": "建議還是早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2826.wav", + "text": "等一下我言明在先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2827.wav", + "text": "我們要開始去想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2828.wav", + "text": "從今天開始到1月13" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2829.wav", + "text": "了然後很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2830.wav", + "text": "重大法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2831.wav", + "text": "之後接下來是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2832.wav", + "text": "性私密的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2833.wav", + "text": "那有5個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2834.wav", + "text": "包括犯罪被害人保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2835.wav", + "text": "是109條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2836.wav", + "text": "可以這樣一直溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2837.wav", + "text": "如果溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2838.wav", + "text": "沒有結論的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2839.wav", + "text": "我們也要照程序走啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2840.wav", + "text": "所以儘量我們協商時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2841.wav", + "text": "以後要拉長不要限制時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2842.wav", + "text": "否則的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2843.wav", + "text": "很多排上議程的重要法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2844.wav", + "text": "會很難處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2845.wav", + "text": "剛才我也向曾總召拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2846.wav", + "text": "過中央政府總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2847.wav", + "text": "一定要過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2848.wav", + "text": "過而重大法案沒過也無法交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2849.wav", + "text": "所以請各位發言儘量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2850.wav", + "text": "儘量簡短不要重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2851.wav", + "text": "一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2852.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2853.wav", + "text": "今天的法案協商就到此告一段落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2854.wav", + "text": "明天(禮拜四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2855.wav", + "text": "開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2856.wav", + "text": "請大家把時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2857.wav", + "text": "稍微保留到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2858.wav", + "text": "明天晚上9點好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2859.wav", + "text": "如果沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2860.wav", + "text": "明天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2861.wav", + "text": "就沒有再以書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2862.wav", + "text": "2點半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14756/2863.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/0.wav", + "text": "現在一繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/1.wav", + "text": "減量及管理法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/2.wav", + "text": "我們就院長各" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/3.wav", + "text": "但是你們好我再說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/4.wav", + "text": "很多我們今天我們就focus在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/5.wav", + "text": "要性來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/6.wav", + "text": "第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/7.wav", + "text": "我們你剛剛已經講得很清楚第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/8.wav", + "text": "5的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/9.wav", + "text": "第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/10.wav", + "text": "等如果這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/11.wav", + "text": "上位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/12.wav", + "text": "的東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/13.wav", + "text": "一定會面對一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/14.wav", + "text": "所以我剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/15.wav", + "text": "我們就暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/16.wav", + "text": "長這一條我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/17.wav", + "text": "大的中小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/18.wav", + "text": "業製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/19.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/20.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/21.wav", + "text": "個還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/22.wav", + "text": "因為這很重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/23.wav", + "text": "可以讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/24.wav", + "text": "如果沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/25.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/26.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/27.wav", + "text": "這是不一樣的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/28.wav", + "text": "是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/29.wav", + "text": "以這裡不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/30.wav", + "text": "一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/31.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/32.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/33.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/34.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/35.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/36.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/37.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/38.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/39.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/40.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14755/41.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/0.wav", + "text": "本日會議併案協商司法及法制教育及文化兩委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/1.wav", + "text": "併案審查行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/2.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團委員黃國書等19人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/3.wav", + "text": "委員林宜瑾等20人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/4.wav", + "text": "委員張廖萬堅等21人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/5.wav", + "text": "分別擬具國家運動科學中心設置條例草案等五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/6.wav", + "text": "及逕付二讀之委員范雲等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/7.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團委員吳思瑤等26人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/8.wav", + "text": "委員賴品妤等17人分別提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/9.wav", + "text": "以上共計九案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/10.wav", + "text": "本案為制定案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/11.wav", + "text": "審查會前於110年12月6日審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/12.wav", + "text": "審查結果除第3條第6條第22條修正後通過外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/13.wav", + "text": "其餘均照行政院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/14.wav", + "text": "並決議院會討論前須交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/15.wav", + "text": "\n協商時請參閱協商條文對照表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/16.wav", + "text": "及審查報告關係文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/17.wav", + "text": "與會委員如有修正動議或機關有建議內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/18.wav", + "text": "請提出書面並印發供現場進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/19.wav", + "text": "先請提出修正動議的委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/20.wav", + "text": "\n首先請高金素梅委員說明修正動議第1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/21.wav", + "text": "各黨團的出席代表都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/22.wav", + "text": "我的修正動議是第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/23.wav", + "text": "其他我是跟所有的委員一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/24.wav", + "text": "但是我增加了一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/25.wav", + "text": "這一款就是辦理全民體能評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/26.wav", + "text": "提供福祉個別化運動處方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/27.wav", + "text": "鼓勵終身規律運動習慣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/28.wav", + "text": "增進國民健康與福祉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/29.wav", + "text": "好像只針對奪牌的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/30.wav", + "text": "但是我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/31.wav", + "text": "目前學校端其實已經有體適能的測驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/32.wav", + "text": "體育老師還有專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/33.wav", + "text": "也可以針對學生的測驗結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/34.wav", + "text": "開立運動處方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/35.wav", + "text": "指導學生加強身體的柔軟度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/36.wav", + "text": "肌力肺活量等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/37.wav", + "text": "但是我們看一下學校以外的群體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/38.wav", + "text": "我們近來看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/39.wav", + "text": "醫界分享非常多現在的文明病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/40.wav", + "text": "其實都是來自缺少運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/41.wav", + "text": "所以醫生開立處方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/42.wav", + "text": "就是現在得文明病的這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/43.wav", + "text": "但是要怎麼運動怎麼強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/44.wav", + "text": "這個是醫生沒有辦法指導的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/45.wav", + "text": "所以我們必須仰賴運動科學中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/46.wav", + "text": "所以我希望運動科學中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/47.wav", + "text": "能夠扮演全面性整合的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/48.wav", + "text": "整合國訓中心體育署教育部衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/49.wav", + "text": "讓運動科學中心的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/50.wav", + "text": "不單單只是為奪牌而設立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/51.wav", + "text": "而是整合了全民的健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/52.wav", + "text": "競技體育學校體育運動產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/53.wav", + "text": "成立國家級的中心才比較符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/54.wav", + "text": "但是我們也可以看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/55.wav", + "text": "我們不要講其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/56.wav", + "text": "就以亞洲為例好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/57.wav", + "text": "亞洲各國包括日本韓國中國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/58.wav", + "text": "都已經把全民運動列入法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/59.wav", + "text": "日本是先成立國家運科中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/60.wav", + "text": "但是我們是先成立國家訓練中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/61.wav", + "text": "然後現在要成立運科中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/62.wav", + "text": "韓國是國民體能100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/63.wav", + "text": "它是以增進國民的體能及健康為目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/64.wav", + "text": "透過科學的方法測量評估體能的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/65.wav", + "text": "然後提供運動諮詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/66.wav", + "text": "及處方的國民體育福利服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/67.wav", + "text": "所以我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/68.wav", + "text": "其實都已經把全民運動放在這樣的草案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/69.wav", + "text": "我認為我們既然要推這個草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/70.wav", + "text": "行政院院長好像已經揭牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/71.wav", + "text": "籌備處已經開始了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/72.wav", + "text": "所以我認為它更應該要全面性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/73.wav", + "text": "所以我在第3條裡面開宗明義放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/74.wav", + "text": "其實先前部長有跟我談過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/75.wav", + "text": "他說全民運動是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/76.wav", + "text": "只是文字怎麼放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/77.wav", + "text": "對此我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/78.wav", + "text": "必須要把全民體能的評估這一項放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/79.wav", + "text": "以上是我的建議謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/80.wav", + "text": "今天修正動議有4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/81.wav", + "text": "我們請提案人說明之後再請主管機關一併說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/82.wav", + "text": "\n現在請修正動議第二案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/83.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團提出修正動議第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/84.wav", + "text": "案共二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/85.wav", + "text": "第一個是第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/86.wav", + "text": "我們把目的寫得更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/87.wav", + "text": "能夠讓國家運動科學中心以後的運作更順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/88.wav", + "text": "我們的第1項第1款是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/89.wav", + "text": "辦理國家競技運動代表隊運動科學之整合服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/90.wav", + "text": "是一個整合性的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/91.wav", + "text": "第2款是協助提供優秀運動選手及教練運動科學之支援服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/92.wav", + "text": "第3款是推動運動科學之研究與應用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/93.wav", + "text": "第4款第5款第6款沒有變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/94.wav", + "text": "第2項前項業務範圍包含運動科學運動醫學及運動科技等相關領域之研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/95.wav", + "text": "運用推廣及技術轉移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/96.wav", + "text": "我們目的是希望未來國家運動科學中心設立之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/97.wav", + "text": "它的業務範圍能夠精確地定位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/98.wav", + "text": "第二個是第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/99.wav", + "text": "我們希望能增列副執行長二人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/100.wav", + "text": "人改為本中心置執行長一人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/101.wav", + "text": "人副執行長二人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/102.wav", + "text": "人後面加個副執行長襄助執行長處理中心業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/103.wav", + "text": "然後最後一項就是有關董事及董事長之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/104.wav", + "text": "於執行長及副執行長準用之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/105.wav", + "text": "這是國民黨的修正動議案以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/106.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/107.wav", + "text": "請修正動議案第四案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/108.wav", + "text": "在第3條第1項增列健康管理及醫療照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/109.wav", + "text": "護第2項增列辦理國際運動賽事資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/110.wav", + "text": "之蒐集分析與支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/111.wav", + "text": "第4項增列進行運動科技之研發技術移轉及加值應用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/112.wav", + "text": "我覺得滿可惜的是之前張廖委員提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/113.wav", + "text": "推廣運動科學普及化這一項沒有被納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/114.wav", + "text": "我支持張廖委員版本的推廣運動科學普及化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/115.wav", + "text": "國際上有逐漸重視一般民眾健康發展的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/116.wav", + "text": "如果參考韓國體育推廣委員會的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/117.wav", + "text": "我認為應該要更積極利用運科中心的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/118.wav", + "text": "因此我提議第6項除協助規劃及培育運動科學專業人才之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/119.wav", + "text": "應該要增列開發運動科學產品服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/120.wav", + "text": "並且推廣於一般民眾及各級學校學生促進全民健康與福祉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/121.wav", + "text": "除了讓運動科學普及化以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/122.wav", + "text": "也讓全民運動成為未來精進競技運動的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/123.wav", + "text": "營養訓練科技等專業領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/124.wav", + "text": "真的是非常高度的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/125.wav", + "text": "以及如何跟產業合作銷售軟硬體研發等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/126.wav", + "text": "資源的擴充無疑是臺灣運動產業能不能再上一層樓的關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/127.wav", + "text": "所以運科中心除了精進運動產業以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/128.wav", + "text": "也應該要透過跨域合作的方法促進相關產業升級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/129.wav", + "text": "運科中心的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/130.wav", + "text": "是必須成為一個更具前瞻性與策略性的機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/131.wav", + "text": "所以我提議第3項除了推動運動科學研究之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/132.wav", + "text": "還有跨域合作提升產業競爭力的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/133.wav", + "text": "\n最後還有一點我自己的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/134.wav", + "text": "當初雖然沒有到委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/135.wav", + "text": "終於在今天協商有機會談一下我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/136.wav", + "text": "我的版本第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/137.wav", + "text": "希望運科中心能夠對運動產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/138.wav", + "text": "及科普教育進行規劃跟推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/139.wav", + "text": "老年人女性及兒童的運科協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/140.wav", + "text": "因為在聯合國永續發展目標SDGs裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/141.wav", + "text": "將關懷各個弱勢族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/142.wav", + "text": "與促進各年齡人群的福祉都納入指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/143.wav", + "text": "運動科學這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/144.wav", + "text": "各個科學領域的知識運用在運動中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/145.wav", + "text": "提升它的表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/146.wav", + "text": "更應該要盡其所能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/147.wav", + "text": "加強目前社會對弱勢群體的應用跟協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/148.wav", + "text": "運科中心的服務是針對所有的群體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/149.wav", + "text": "我認為應該把這些群體的照顧明文入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/150.wav", + "text": "才能夠讓運科中心更積極負起照顧他們的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/151.wav", + "text": "臺灣真的是千呼萬喚始出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/152.wav", + "text": "好不容易等到運科中心成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/153.wav", + "text": "運科中心是一個全新的行政法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/154.wav", + "text": "所以理論上它應該要開創更多新的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/155.wav", + "text": "也希望體育署盡最大誠意研擬未來的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/156.wav", + "text": "今天也看到像剛才高金委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/157.wav", + "text": "及國民黨黨團都有提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/158.wav", + "text": "其實方向跟我剛剛講的非常相似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/159.wav", + "text": "也就是基本上跨黨派的委員都是支持這個方向的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/160.wav", + "text": "請教育部跟體育署要認真面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/161.wav", + "text": "今天新增的修正動議有四案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/162.wav", + "text": "牽涉的是第3條跟第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/163.wav", + "text": "雖然民眾黨黨團今天沒有提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/164.wav", + "text": "但我們還是要表達一下基本的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/165.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團非常支持這次草案的推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/166.wav", + "text": "尤其在運動科學普及化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/167.wav", + "text": "如何跟產業鏈結並跨域整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/168.wav", + "text": "我想這個非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/169.wav", + "text": "雖然本次協商草案的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/170.wav", + "text": "在委員會逐條審查時並沒有保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/171.wav", + "text": "但是對於整體運科中心定位的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/172.wav", + "text": "等一下有機會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/173.wav", + "text": "\n我在這邊提出四點提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/174.wav", + "text": "第一點到底國家運動科學中心未來設置以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/175.wav", + "text": "跟原來國家運動訓練中心的業務是不是有重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/176.wav", + "text": "第二點未來兩個單位如果業務溝通上有落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/177.wav", + "text": "兩個機關單位如何協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/178.wav", + "text": "到底是運科中心聽國訓中心的指揮還是反之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/179.wav", + "text": "\n第三點國家運動科學中心成立之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/180.wav", + "text": "相關的人力聘僱方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/181.wav", + "text": "到底有什麼樣的優勢能夠促使運動科學人才願意投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/182.wav", + "text": "我想這點比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/183.wav", + "text": "因為政策的核心在執行力怎麼樣提升誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/184.wav", + "text": "包含後續攬才和留任的配套措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/185.wav", + "text": "尤其針對新設單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/186.wav", + "text": "要如何達到這樣的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/187.wav", + "text": "\n第四點運科中心設立的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/188.wav", + "text": "到底是要訓練誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/189.wav", + "text": "是訓練國手還是長期培育有資質的好手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/190.wav", + "text": "\n我想從剛剛幾個黨團及委員的修正動議可以看出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/191.wav", + "text": "我國有非常優秀表現的年輕選手其實非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/192.wav", + "text": "但缺乏長期培養機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/193.wav", + "text": "許多選手在訓練的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/194.wav", + "text": "因為沒有一個整體體制性的訓練跟建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/195.wav", + "text": "很難單憑個人之力堅持下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/196.wav", + "text": "所以這個中心的設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/197.wav", + "text": "置我們是非常贊成這樣的草案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/198.wav", + "text": "但實際執行面能不能有效達到當時我們立法的意旨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/199.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分是我們要提醒的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/200.wav", + "text": "運科中心應該明確表示自己的定位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/201.wav", + "text": "到底是訓練國手還是培訓潛在的體育相關人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/202.wav", + "text": "這些��題釐清以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/203.wav", + "text": "我們非常樂見跟支持設置一個有運動專業的科研系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/204.wav", + "text": "來配合政府整個體育科學的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/205.wav", + "text": "對國內運動科學發展提供更大的貢獻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/206.wav", + "text": "尤其是強化我國國際競爭力上的實力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/207.wav", + "text": "\n今天各黨團都表達了這樣的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/208.wav", + "text": "希望相關部會可以正視這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/209.wav", + "text": "然後做更細緻的說明跟討論以釋大家的疑惑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/210.wav", + "text": "尤其我國運動人才長期以來碰到的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/211.wav", + "text": "我想相關部會比我們更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/212.wav", + "text": "希望可以透過這次立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/213.wav", + "text": "讓我們的運動人才跟運動科學可以更加普及化常態化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/214.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/215.wav", + "text": "如果沒有具體聚焦在條文上的處理可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/216.wav", + "text": "能會處理不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/217.wav", + "text": "我想今天大部分的修正動議以及當初在委員會審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/218.wav", + "text": "主要還是聚焦在第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/219.wav", + "text": "包括我國的運動發展能夠繼續往前進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/220.wav", + "text": "我們的腳步恐怕已經是比較緩慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/221.wav", + "text": "所以在這樣千呼萬喚始出來的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/222.wav", + "text": "我想大家都是支持運動科學中心的設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/223.wav", + "text": "只是它的業務範圍應該涵蓋到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/224.wav", + "text": "哪些這是大家在第3條有所爭議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/225.wav", + "text": "譬如它的對象應該是選手還是全民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/226.wav", + "text": "又或者我們談到的運動科技研發和技術轉移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/227.wav", + "text": "是要運用到選手身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/228.wav", + "text": "還是指整個科技產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/229.wav", + "text": "我想這些都需要大家進一步來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/230.wav", + "text": "\n另外時代力量黨團提案版本裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/231.wav", + "text": "這部分應該也要納入規劃原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/232.wav", + "text": "但未來難保它不會有自己獨立的場館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/233.wav", + "text": "以及更加地把未來可能會看到的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/234.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛前面提到的幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/235.wav", + "text": "有關對象部分到底是以選手為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/236.wav", + "text": "還是以全民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/237.wav", + "text": "為主又我們現在主要在做的是科學的發展和應用外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/238.wav", + "text": "促進運動科技產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/239.wav", + "text": "或是運動科學產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/240.wav", + "text": "\n還是這幾個產業可能會納入在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/241.wav", + "text": "我覺得既然要設置了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/242.wav", + "text": "就應該就這些部分好好做個釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/243.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團立場是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/244.wav", + "text": "這個部分在今天的協商會議完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/245.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/246.wav", + "text": "好謝謝王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/247.wav", + "text": "\n在場委員都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/248.wav", + "text": "發言完了請教育部針對委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/249.wav", + "text": "做充分說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/250.wav", + "text": "好謝謝召委還有各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/251.wav", + "text": "召委還有各黨團各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/252.wav", + "text": "對於我們即將成立行政法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/253.wav", + "text": "運科中心在整個政策上及方向上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/254.wav", + "text": "之前從委員非常熱切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/255.wav", + "text": "基本上都是讓它成為國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/256.wav", + "text": "未來推動運動的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/257.wav", + "text": "特別謝謝各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/258.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛就四個動議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/259.wav", + "text": "主要是二個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/260.wav", + "text": "一個當然也是剛才邱委員王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/261.wav", + "text": "關係到我們到底希望運科中心的服務對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/262.wav", + "text": "是誰還有它的任務範圍所扮演的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/263.wav", + "text": "這也包含今天的三個動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/264.wav", + "text": "等一下我就簡要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/265.wav", + "text": "有提到第十八條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/266.wav", + "text": "總召及召委都關心運科中心的實務運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/267.wav", + "text": "我們也討論過這麼多草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/268.wav", + "text": "事實上本來就會有一位執行長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/269.wav", + "text": "二位副執行長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/270.wav", + "text": "\n目前這一次在第十八條的呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/271.wav", + "text": "即原來的國訓中心我們也有參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/272.wav", + "text": "大概都會寫到執行長的層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/273.wav", + "text": "我們維持跟一般的一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/274.wav", + "text": "以國訓的寫法就是寫到執行長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/275.wav", + "text": "因為我們一定會這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/276.wav", + "text": "而且這是必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/277.wav", + "text": "的如果總召這邊可以的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/278.wav", + "text": "而召委也是這個想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/279.wav", + "text": "即用附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/280.wav", + "text": "我們也一定會這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/281.wav", + "text": "在體例上我們就不會覺得說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/282.wav", + "text": "我們會趕快整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/283.wav", + "text": "因為在實務上有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/284.wav", + "text": "即一定要有二位副執行長來襄助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/285.wav", + "text": "就比較會維持原來的體例\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/286.wav", + "text": "因為在上次的審查會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/287.wav", + "text": "也謝謝很多委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/288.wav", + "text": "大家集思廣益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/289.wav", + "text": "已經做了一個審查會的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/290.wav", + "text": "今天幾位委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/291.wav", + "text": "包含剛才邱委員王委員所提醒的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/292.wav", + "text": "還是以一個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/293.wav", + "text": "即運科中心的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/294.wav", + "text": "原來確實在行政院版所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/295.wav", + "text": "是比較聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/296.wav", + "text": "很清楚就是這個選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/297.wav", + "text": "但是經過委員大家的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/298.wav", + "text": "認為應該是國家優秀選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/299.wav", + "text": "唯一聚焦在亞奧運選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/300.wav", + "text": "未來優秀選手的培訓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/301.wav", + "text": "這與政策上是比較相近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/302.wav", + "text": "的所以把那個級字改變以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/303.wav", + "text": "就不會只聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/304.wav", + "text": "或鎖定在很菁英的少數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/305.wav", + "text": "這是當時委員的一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/306.wav", + "text": "還有包含今天委員提到的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/307.wav", + "text": "因為運動科學確實也是一個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/308.wav", + "text": "及與產業未來有連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/309.wav", + "text": "就這一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/310.wav", + "text": "經過當時大家的討論也有作出文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/311.wav", + "text": "今天在賴委員的文字裡面也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/312.wav", + "text": "我們等一下會來做一個斟酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/313.wav", + "text": "\n針對高金委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/314.wav", + "text": "事實上就是在選手以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/315.wav", + "text": "其實運科的應用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/316.wav", + "text": "當然這等於是它的應用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/317.wav", + "text": "啦另外包含剛才賴品妤委員的款項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/318.wav", + "text": "也希望點出具體的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/319.wav", + "text": "事實上這也有點是全民的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/320.wav", + "text": "\n剛才邱委員提到國訓中心與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/321.wav", + "text": "當然在過去開過9次會議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/322.wav", + "text": "其實都有去思考過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/323.wav", + "text": "未來在這部分是有一個過渡階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/324.wav", + "text": "也會做一點協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/325.wav", + "text": "啦因為新成立的運科中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/326.wav", + "text": "也許不是一下子就能到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/327.wav", + "text": "以未來運科中心所成立的四處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/328.wav", + "text": "來看原來的國訓中心運科處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/329.wav", + "text": "所以就這兩個單位而言以後不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/330.wav", + "text": "是這邊有一個運科處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/331.wav", + "text": "那邊有一個運科中心的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/332.wav", + "text": "人員也會隨著明年亞奧運之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/333.wav", + "text": "主要是讓教練和選手在相關過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/334.wav", + "text": "不要漏接了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/335.wav", + "text": "對於這方面兩個中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/336.wav", + "text": "狀況針對整個組織的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/337.wav", + "text": "過去教育部為什麼都會請督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/338.wav", + "text": "來擔任國訓的董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/339.wav", + "text": "原因就在於體育署還是要和國訓中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/340.wav", + "text": "所以督導體育署的次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/341.wav", + "text": "都是兼任國訓中心的董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/342.wav", + "text": "也會由負責督導的次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/343.wav", + "text": "來擔任國訓中心董事長如此一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/344.wav", + "text": "此一來就不會出現雙頭馬車的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/345.wav", + "text": "除了兩個法人中心之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/346.wav", + "text": "還有體育署和教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/347.wav", + "text": "所以也是會以這樣的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/348.wav", + "text": "來運作過去這段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/349.wav", + "text": "都是由林次長擔任這樣的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/350.wav", + "text": "甚至這段時間代理署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/351.wav", + "text": "在運作上確實能夠讓運科中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/352.wav", + "text": "中心和國訓中心的行政步調一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/353.wav", + "text": "大家對於政策的規劃與執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/354.wav", + "text": "也會比較一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/355.wav", + "text": "關於剛才邱委員王委員所提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/356.wav", + "text": "其實在過去這段籌備的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/357.wav", + "text": "的方式來處理謝謝召委和總召能夠認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/358.wav", + "text": "等一下我們會提出一些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/359.wav", + "text": "等一下看看大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/360.wav", + "text": "謝謝教育部的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/361.wav", + "text": "針對各位委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/362.wav", + "text": "我想部長是以正面尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/363.wav", + "text": "來進行文字上的增訂或修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/364.wav", + "text": "將各位的意見納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/365.wav", + "text": "另外針對第十八條也請趕快將附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/366.wav", + "text": "關於剛剛發下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/367.wav", + "text": "日在教文會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/368.wav", + "text": "在此也針對今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/369.wav", + "text": "四項修正動議的案由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/370.wav", + "text": "提出說明其中第3案是針對副執行長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/371.wav", + "text": "二人的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/372.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們已經說過會以臨時動議的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/373.wav", + "text": "案我們會彙整各版本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/374.wav", + "text": "將來也能協助運動產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/375.wav", + "text": "因此我們也提出相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/376.wav", + "text": "日司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/377.wav", + "text": "與教育及文化委員會聯席會議當中審查通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/378.wav", + "text": "我們再增列一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/379.wav", + "text": "正為進行運動科技之研發技術移轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/380.wav", + "text": "及加值應用提升產業競爭力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/381.wav", + "text": "都希望將來能夠提升產業的競爭力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/382.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議在後面加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/383.wav", + "text": "提升產業競爭力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/384.wav", + "text": "等文字如此也可賦予運科中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/385.wav", + "text": "第7款運動科學成果推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/386.wav", + "text": "不是只有在國訓中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/387.wav", + "text": "希望能夠獲得各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/388.wav", + "text": "以上說明謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/389.wav", + "text": "請問各位委員對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/390.wav", + "text": "所提出來的文字有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/391.wav", + "text": "其實內容都有含括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/392.wav", + "text": "包括高委員的部分也都有含括在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/393.wav", + "text": "運動科學的成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/394.wav", + "text": "會推廣給全民運動對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/395.wav", + "text": "但是我提的全民體能的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/396.wav", + "text": "也在裡頭嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/397.wav", + "text": "款其他與運動科學相關之業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/398.wav", + "text": "這個部分也都可以包含在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/399.wav", + "text": "我就相信你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/400.wav", + "text": "各位委員沒有其他意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/401.wav", + "text": "我們來處理一下第十八條的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/402.wav", + "text": "曾委員請你聽一下該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/403.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/404.wav", + "text": "國家運動科學中心除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/405.wav", + "text": "置執行長一人外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/406.wav", + "text": "應在組織章程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/407.wav", + "text": "副執行長二人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/408.wav", + "text": "襄助執行長處理中心業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/409.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/410.wav", + "text": "本日協商結論如下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/411.wav", + "text": "一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/412.wav", + "text": "第3條照協商內容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/413.wav", + "text": "(詳如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/414.wav", + "text": "其他均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/415.wav", + "text": "三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/416.wav", + "text": "新增附帶決議一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/417.wav", + "text": "(詳如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/418.wav", + "text": "稍待議事人員將協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/419.wav", + "text": "書面製作完成後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/420.wav", + "text": "即交由委員簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/421.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14751/422.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14749/0.wav", + "text": "表大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14749/1.wav", + "text": "修正草案委員傅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14749/2.wav", + "text": "這個就不予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14749/3.wav", + "text": "行政院版本為高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14749/4.wav", + "text": "處理第35條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14749/5.wav", + "text": "以下這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14749/6.wav", + "text": ")主管機關應通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14749/7.wav", + "text": "好請議事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14749/8.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14749/9.wav", + "text": "第1項戒菸教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14749/10.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14747/0.wav", + "text": "委員先進及行政部門代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14747/1.wav", + "text": "有一個比較合乎邏輯的依據我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14747/2.wav", + "text": "好是謝謝第34" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14747/3.wav", + "text": "才能吸菸這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14747/4.wav", + "text": "各位委員可以還不行還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14747/5.wav", + "text": "所以我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14747/6.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/0.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法修正草案等25案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/1.wav", + "text": "以及院會逕付二讀與上述提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/2.wav", + "text": "併案協商之委員羅致政等17人擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/3.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法第4條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/4.wav", + "text": "委員傅崐萁等20人擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/5.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法第29條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/6.wav", + "text": "剩下保留條文的黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/7.wav", + "text": "本席上次在12月16日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/8.wav", + "text": "召開之協商討論至第26條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/9.wav", + "text": "予以保留現在開始進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/10.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法保留之第27條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/11.wav", + "text": "\n首先請衛福部代表發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/12.wav", + "text": "所以應該要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/13.wav", + "text": "因為有其組合元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/14.wav", + "text": "所以這個還是要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/15.wav", + "text": "第十五條第一項的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/16.wav", + "text": "好第27條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/17.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理委員林奕華" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/18.wav", + "text": "所有的菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/19.wav", + "text": "也涉及到指定式菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/20.wav", + "text": "���保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/21.wav", + "text": "這個不能處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/22.wav", + "text": "因為這個涉及到第十二條各項的促銷廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/23.wav", + "text": "其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/24.wav", + "text": "第十二條的促銷廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/25.wav", + "text": "相關規定含有指定式菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/26.wav", + "text": "現在是處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/27.wav", + "text": "但是是林奕華委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/28.wav", + "text": "主要是針對第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/29.wav", + "text": "菸品吸食器的罰則部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/30.wav", + "text": "我們還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/31.wav", + "text": "維持行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/32.wav", + "text": "行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/33.wav", + "text": "已經協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/34.wav", + "text": "不予採納通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/35.wav", + "text": "在16日的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/36.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/37.wav", + "text": "通過不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/38.wav", + "text": "這個就不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/39.wav", + "text": "委員林奕華" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/40.wav", + "text": "等16人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/41.wav", + "text": "第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/42.wav", + "text": "不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/43.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/44.wav", + "text": "第十二條的各類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/45.wav", + "text": "促銷及廣告的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/46.wav", + "text": "這個通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/47.wav", + "text": "好像沒有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/48.wav", + "text": "將來是雙禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/49.wav", + "text": "這個條文只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/50.wav", + "text": "針對菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/51.wav", + "text": "製造輸入違反規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/52.wav", + "text": "即使加熱菸沒進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/53.wav", + "text": "一樣也是按照這個罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/54.wav", + "text": "只是少了加熱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/55.wav", + "text": "組合元件的廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/56.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/57.wav", + "text": "28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/58.wav", + "text": "是菸品製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/59.wav", + "text": "國健署其實有提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/60.wav", + "text": "第十二條增加菸品及必要元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/61.wav", + "text": "它是兩個一起管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/62.wav", + "text": "而那一條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/63.wav", + "text": "所以這一條如果要處理的話也要一起保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/64.wav", + "text": "因為這裡只有講到菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/65.wav", + "text": "但是第28條沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/66.wav", + "text": "指定菸品或必要組合元件的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/67.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/68.wav", + "text": "它��及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/69.wav", + "text": "違反第十二條的各款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/70.wav", + "text": "核心問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/71.wav", + "text": "我們今天一定會將它處理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/72.wav", + "text": "行政院提案第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/73.wav", + "text": "第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/74.wav", + "text": "最主要是針對菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/75.wav", + "text": "菸品製造輸入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/76.wav", + "text": "回收的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/77.wav", + "text": "在罰則的部分因為萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/78.wav", + "text": "萬美玲委員提高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/79.wav", + "text": "額度較行政院版本為高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/80.wav", + "text": "以及變更條次的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/81.wav", + "text": "第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/82.wav", + "text": "第10條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/83.wav", + "text": "有一些前面已經保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/84.wav", + "text": "保留待會再審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/85.wav", + "text": "菸品製造或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/86.wav", + "text": "輸入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/87.wav", + "text": "也可以直接討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/88.wav", + "text": "第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/89.wav", + "text": "第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/90.wav", + "text": "及第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/91.wav", + "text": "目前都還在保留中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/92.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/93.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/94.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/95.wav", + "text": "及傳播媒體業者的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/96.wav", + "text": "也同樣涉及到違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/97.wav", + "text": "第十五條第一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/98.wav", + "text": "及第二項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/99.wav", + "text": "因為第十五條目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/100.wav", + "text": "還是保留當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/101.wav", + "text": "好這個有組合元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/102.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/103.wav", + "text": "第50頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/104.wav", + "text": "輸入業廣告業傳播媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/105.wav", + "text": "第一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/106.wav", + "text": "第三款規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/107.wav", + "text": "因為第十五條還是保留當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/108.wav", + "text": "第31條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/109.wav", + "text": "\n處理第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/110.wav", + "text": "第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/111.wav", + "text": "目前第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/112.wav", + "text": "還是保留當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/113.wav", + "text": "\n處理第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/114.wav", + "text": "組合元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/115.wav", + "text": "的一些規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/116.wav", + "text": "廣告項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/117.wav", + "text": "議修正為廣告業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/118.wav", + "text": "違反第十二條各款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/119.wav", + "text": "規定之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/120.wav", + "text": "製作廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/121.wav", + "text": "或接受傳播或刊載者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/122.wav", + "text": "處新臺幣20萬元以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/123.wav", + "text": "100萬元以下罰鍰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/124.wav", + "text": "並令其限期改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/125.wav", + "text": "屆期未改善者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/126.wav", + "text": "按次處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/127.wav", + "text": "委託製作傳播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/128.wav", + "text": "或刊載前項廣告者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/129.wav", + "text": "併處罰廣告委託人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/130.wav", + "text": "關於這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/131.wav", + "text": "建請委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/132.wav", + "text": "能夠依行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/133.wav", + "text": "所以這個可以處理是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/134.wav", + "text": "會不會又牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/135.wav", + "text": "第十二條各款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/136.wav", + "text": "規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/137.wav", + "text": "第十二條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/138.wav", + "text": "如果第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/139.wav", + "text": "這一條跟著修正而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/140.wav", + "text": "所以理論上可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/141.wav", + "text": "所以就在於罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/142.wav", + "text": "到底要多重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/143.wav", + "text": "處新臺幣20萬元以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/144.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/145.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/146.wav", + "text": "大家要不要討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/147.wav", + "text": "要不要重一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/148.wav", + "text": "這一條主要是罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/149.wav", + "text": "廣告業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/150.wav", + "text": "我們會建議如果是製造輸入者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/151.wav", + "text": "就應該罰重一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/152.wav", + "text": "但廣告業者是受委託的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/153.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/154.wav", + "text": "我們的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/155.wav", + "text": "已經滿重了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/156.wav", + "text": "罰則定義都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/157.wav", + "text": "你覺得還是要先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/158.wav", + "text": "菸品載具要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/159.wav", + "text": "所以還是先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/160.wav", + "text": "好尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/161.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/162.wav", + "text": "第33條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/163.wav", + "text": "\n處理第34條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/164.wav", + "text": "第34條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/165.wav", + "text": "菸品輸入業廣告業傳播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/166.wav", + "text": "媒體業者或廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/167.wav", + "text": "委託人以外之人違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/168.wav", + "text": "第十二條的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/169.wav", + "text": "也是在金額的上下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/170.wav", + "text": "那就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/171.wav", + "text": "第34條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/172.wav", + "text": "最主要是違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/173.wav", + "text": "第十一條第一項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/174.wav", + "text": "行政院版本是10萬元到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/175.wav", + "text": "元最主要是對菸品的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/176.wav", + "text": "提高到20萬元至100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/177.wav", + "text": "元最主要是罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/178.wav", + "text": "部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/179.wav", + "text": "請委員參酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/180.wav", + "text": "我們建議行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/181.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/182.wav", + "text": "要處理還是要等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/183.wav", + "text": "再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/184.wav", + "text": "一起保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/185.wav", + "text": "第35條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/186.wav", + "text": "6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/187.wav", + "text": "形狀就是第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/188.wav", + "text": "十五條第一項第一款或第二款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/189.wav", + "text": "6條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/190.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/191.wav", + "text": "第37條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/192.wav", + "text": "第55頁第37條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/193.wav", + "text": "有關下列情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/194.wav", + "text": "之一處新臺幣1萬元到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/195.wav", + "text": "25萬元這裡面也涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/196.wav", + "text": "第十五條第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/197.wav", + "text": "項第十五條第一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/198.wav", + "text": "第二款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/199.wav", + "text": "好第37條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/200.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理第38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/201.wav", + "text": "販賣菸品之場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/202.wav", + "text": "有下列情形之一者處新臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/203.wav", + "text": "改善屆期未改善者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/204.wav", + "text": "按次處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/205.wav", + "text": "主要是違反第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/206.wav", + "text": "及第十三條第一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/207.wav", + "text": "好第38條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/208.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/209.wav", + "text": "第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/210.wav", + "text": "第39條有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/211.wav", + "text": "營業場所違反第十四條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/212.wav", + "text": "免費提供菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/213.wav", + "text": "者處新臺幣1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/214.wav", + "text": "元以下這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/215.wav", + "text": "第十四條目前還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/216.wav", + "text": "保留中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/217.wav", + "text": "的問題所以這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/218.wav", + "text": "也要等十四條處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/219.wav", + "text": "好才能夠處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/220.wav", + "text": "第39條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/221.wav", + "text": "提案第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/222.wav", + "text": "供應及使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/223.wav", + "text": "第十五條各款之罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/224.wav", + "text": "則對應行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/225.wav", + "text": "第三十六條第三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/226.wav", + "text": "條委員的版本罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/227.wav", + "text": "版本有關供應第二款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/228.wav", + "text": "類菸品第三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/229.wav", + "text": "未通過健康風險評估審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/230.wav", + "text": "之指定菸品罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/231.wav", + "text": "使用第二款及第三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/232.wav", + "text": "之罰鍰額度較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/233.wav", + "text": "且就使用第十五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/234.wav", + "text": "未有罰則建議依行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/235.wav", + "text": "也是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/236.wav", + "text": "一併處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/237.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/238.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/239.wav", + "text": "第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/240.wav", + "text": "58頁有關第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/241.wav", + "text": "禁止吸菸場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/242.wav", + "text": "新臺幣1萬元至5萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/243.wav", + "text": "元其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/244.wav", + "text": "第二項規定使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/245.wav", + "text": "類菸品或同條第一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/246.wav", + "text": "第三款之指定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/247.wav", + "text": "菸品者處新臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/248.wav", + "text": "這部分也是保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/249.wav", + "text": "因為有指定菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/250.wav", + "text": "所以第4條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/251.wav", + "text": "\n處理第41條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/252.wav", + "text": "第41條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/253.wav", + "text": "或拒絕主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/254.wav", + "text": "要求之事項者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/255.wav", + "text": "處新臺幣一萬元以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/256.wav", + "text": "五萬元以下罰鍰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/257.wav", + "text": "並得限期令其改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/258.wav", + "text": "屆期未改善者得按次處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/259.wav", + "text": "第十五條新增第三項及第四項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/260.wav", + "text": "修正了第41條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/261.wav", + "text": "楊瓊瓔委員的版本與行政院���版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/262.wav", + "text": "有關禁菸場所規避的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/263.wav", + "text": "元到5萬元楊瓊瓔版本是2萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/264.wav", + "text": "這個可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/265.wav", + "text": "有牽涉到第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/266.wav", + "text": "好第41條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/267.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/268.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理第42條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/269.wav", + "text": "第42條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/270.wav", + "text": "是有關未滿二十歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/271.wav", + "text": "之人違反第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/272.wav", + "text": "第一項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/273.wav", + "text": "吸菸直轄市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/274.wav", + "text": "縣(市)主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/275.wav", + "text": "應通知其限期接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/276.wav", + "text": "未成年者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/277.wav", + "text": "並應令其父母或監護人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/278.wav", + "text": "使其到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/279.wav", + "text": "未滿二十歲之人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/280.wav", + "text": "無正當理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/281.wav", + "text": "未依前項通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/282.wav", + "text": "接受戒菸教育者處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/283.wav", + "text": "新臺幣200元以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/284.wav", + "text": "一萬元以下罰鍰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/285.wav", + "text": "並按次處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/286.wav", + "text": "行為人為未成年者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/287.wav", + "text": "處罰其父母或監護人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/288.wav", + "text": "第一項戒菸教育之實施方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/289.wav", + "text": "內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/290.wav", + "text": "時數執行單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/291.wav", + "text": "及其他應遵行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/292.wav", + "text": "事項之辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/293.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/294.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/295.wav", + "text": "林宜瑾委員提出5,000元到1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/296.wav", + "text": "林奕華委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/297.wav", + "text": "是包括吸食器也含在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/298.wav", + "text": "未成年者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/299.wav", + "text": "定義是幾歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/300.wav", + "text": "我們這個已經把它提高到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/301.wav", + "text": "20歲才能買菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/302.wav", + "text": "才能吸菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/303.wav", + "text": "菸這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/304.wav", + "text": "處罰只罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/305.wav", + "text": "未成年是指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/306.wav", + "text": "因為他是指未成年者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/307.wav", + "text": "要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/308.wav", + "text": "到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/309.wav", + "text": "差在這邊而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/310.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/311.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得這個是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/312.wav", + "text": "未成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/313.wav", + "text": "才要父母親" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/314.wav", + "text": "要不要調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/315.wav", + "text": "元林宜瑾委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/316.wav", + "text": "所以你們沒有提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/317.wav", + "text": "而已所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/318.wav", + "text": "罰則不要太重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/319.wav", + "text": "我可不可以確認一下這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/320.wav", + "text": "原條文是第28條違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/321.wav", + "text": "第十二條第一項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/322.wav", + "text": "應立即接受戒菸教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/323.wav", + "text": "未依通知接受戒菸教育者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/324.wav", + "text": "不過實務上我們好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/325.wav", + "text": "沒聽過太多的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/326.wav", + "text": "有到這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/327.wav", + "text": "我想知道的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/328.wav", + "text": "修正後第四十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/329.wav", + "text": "處罰行為的樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/330.wav", + "text": "有沒有擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/331.wav", + "text": "或是變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/332.wav", + "text": "還是有什麼樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/333.wav", + "text": "可不可以請衛福部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/334.wav", + "text": "因為文字是多很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/335.wav", + "text": "喔也包括直轄市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/336.wav", + "text": "縣(市)主管機關應通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/337.wav", + "text": "所以麻煩您說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/338.wav", + "text": "留個紀錄讓社會大眾知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/339.wav", + "text": "和原條文的差別在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/340.wav", + "text": "我們現在法比較明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/341.wav", + "text": "因為原來條文沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/342.wav", + "text": "規定直轄市縣(市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/343.wav", + "text": ")但是實際執行實務面來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/344.wav", + "text": "就是縣市主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/345.wav", + "text": "要負責這些戒菸教育和裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/346.wav", + "text": "所以我們在法條修正的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/347.wav", + "text": "把它明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/348.wav", + "text": "未婚之未成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/349.wav", + "text": "所以才會切成兩塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/350.wav", + "text": "範圍沒有擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/351.wav", + "text": "應通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/352.wav", + "text": "好像真的很少聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/353.wav", + "text": "要不要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/354.wav", + "text": "原來的法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/355.wav", + "text": "範圍如果沒有變我就沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/356.wav", + "text": "總共全國才82件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/357.wav", + "text": "82件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/358.wav", + "text": "就衛生局去罰的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/359.wav", + "text": "這個裁罰的標準就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/360.wav", + "text": "他有這個吸菸的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/361.wav", + "text": "又不來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/362.wav", + "text": "才會被罰鍰嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/363.wav", + "text": "未成年抽菸被抓到的只有82件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/364.wav", + "text": "而是未成年抽菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/365.wav", + "text": "然後被通知要去戒菸教育又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/366.wav", + "text": "所以被裁罰的是82件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/367.wav", + "text": "未來我們的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/368.wav", + "text": "那就這樣我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/369.wav", + "text": "衛福部所提的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/370.wav", + "text": "條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/371.wav", + "text": "好第42條就按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/372.wav", + "text": "衛福部所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/373.wav", + "text": "協商條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/374.wav", + "text": "在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/375.wav", + "text": "這個主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/376.wav", + "text": "條次變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/377.wav", + "text": "將公告修正為公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/378.wav", + "text": "布被處分人修正為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/379.wav", + "text": "被處分者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/380.wav", + "text": "所以可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/381.wav", + "text": "\n各位委員有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/382.wav", + "text": "其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/383.wav", + "text": "好沒有的話第43條就按行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/384.wav", + "text": "提案條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/385.wav", + "text": "\n處理第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/386.wav", + "text": "第44條主要是對條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/387.wav", + "text": "而且稍微做文字的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/388.wav", + "text": "其原來是第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/389.wav", + "text": "現在修正為第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/390.wav", + "text": "第35條規定由中央主管機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/391.wav", + "text": "罰外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/392.wav", + "text": "由直轄市縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/393.wav", + "text": "而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/394.wav", + "text": "好這部分應該比較沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/395.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/396.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/397.wav", + "text": "第47條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/398.wav", + "text": "由行政院定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/399.wav", + "text": "就這個部分民進黨黨團提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/400.wav", + "text": "建議合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/401.wav", + "text": "罰則的條文明定自公布後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/402.wav", + "text": "二十四個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/403.wav", + "text": "施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/404.wav", + "text": "主要是建議有關警示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/405.wav", + "text": "提高到85%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/406.wav", + "text": "這是第9條第2項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/407.wav", + "text": "還有禁止加味菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/408.wav", + "text": "第10條第1項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/409.wav", + "text": "自公布後一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/410.wav", + "text": "施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/411.wav", + "text": "同時應考量不同條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/412.wav", + "text": "之施行日期差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/413.wav", + "text": "過大如菸捐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/414.wav", + "text": "計量單位警示圖文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/415.wav", + "text": "警示面積加味菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/416.wav", + "text": "禁止列為菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/417.wav", + "text": "建議施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/418.wav", + "text": "由行政院定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/419.wav", + "text": "大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/420.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/421.wav", + "text": "保留啦建議由行政院定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/422.wav", + "text": "不知道何時才會開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/423.wav", + "text": "也可以5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/424.wav", + "text": "我有提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/425.wav", + "text": "其實就像剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/426.wav", + "text": "衛福部提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/427.wav", + "text": "在實施的日程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/428.wav", + "text": "要做一些訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/429.wav", + "text": "特別是像包裝的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/430.wav", + "text": "應該給他們時間去調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/431.wav", + "text": "雖然你們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/432.wav", + "text": "也提到這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/433.wav", + "text": "可是你們又授權給你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/434.wav", + "text": "自己來訂定我覺得這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/435.wav", + "text": "我都覺得授權你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/436.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這種空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/437.wav", + "text": "我們儘量少用是不是能夠很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/438.wav", + "text": "第10條公布後一年實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/439.wav", + "text": "其他是自公布日實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/440.wav", + "text": "希望朝這個方向來訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/441.wav", + "text": "而不是都空白授權行政院來訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/442.wav", + "text": "你們把需要給他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/443.wav", + "text": "緩衝時間的相關條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/444.wav", + "text": "條文列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/445.wav", + "text": "譬如你剛剛講的圖文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/446.wav", + "text": "85%他們必須去印" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/447.wav", + "text": "嘛舊的包裝總不能馬上就不能用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/448.wav", + "text": "嘛這點我們也可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/449.wav", + "text": "所以請你們盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/450.wav", + "text": "詳細一點細緻一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/451.wav", + "text": "哪一些條文是需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/452.wav", + "text": "給他比較多時間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/453.wav", + "text": "是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/454.wav", + "text": "馬上實施的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/455.wav", + "text": "有一些抽菸場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/456.wav", + "text": "的規定有新的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/457.wav", + "text": "這部分請你們盤點一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/458.wav", + "text": "這個我們原來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/459.wav", + "text": "放在哪一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/460.wav", + "text": "也就是原來的立法說明欄裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/461.wav", + "text": "在立法說明裡有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/462.wav", + "text": "現在還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/463.wav", + "text": "原本版本的立法說明欄裡面是有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/464.wav", + "text": "不過你們也要去盤點一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/465.wav", + "text": "哪一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/466.wav", + "text": "條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/467.wav", + "text": "哪一些可以比較快實施能快的就快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/468.wav", + "text": "好這個部分我們先予以保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/469.wav", + "text": "三次協商所保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/470.wav", + "text": "然後再重新開始來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/471.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/472.wav", + "text": "第十七條第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/473.wav", + "text": "第四十二條是照協商條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/474.wav", + "text": "第五條第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/475.wav", + "text": "第十九條第二十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/476.wav", + "text": "第四十三條第四十四條是照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/477.wav", + "text": "行政院提案條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/478.wav", + "text": "第四條本來是照行政院提案條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/479.wav", + "text": "通過可是蔡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/480.wav", + "text": "易餘委員有聲明保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/481.wav", + "text": "是第三條第四條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/482.wav", + "text": "蔡易餘委員聲明保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/483.wav", + "text": "第七條第八" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/484.wav", + "text": "八條第九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/485.wav", + "text": "第十條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/486.wav", + "text": "第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/487.wav", + "text": "第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/488.wav", + "text": "第二十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/489.wav", + "text": "委員呂玉玲提案第三十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/490.wav", + "text": "第四十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/491.wav", + "text": "第四十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/492.wav", + "text": "奕華等16人提案第九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/493.wav", + "text": "第二十八條不予採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/494.wav", + "text": "第十八條我們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/495.wav", + "text": "3分鐘然後我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/496.wav", + "text": "怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/497.wav", + "text": "現在繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/498.wav", + "text": "\n經過剛才的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/499.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/500.wav", + "text": "我們得到結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/501.wav", + "text": "第42條的協商條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/502.wav", + "text": "未滿二十歲之人違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/503.wav", + "text": "第十六條第一項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/504.wav", + "text": "吸菸直轄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/505.wav", + "text": "應通知其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/506.wav", + "text": "限期接受戒菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/507.wav", + "text": "教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/508.wav", + "text": "未成年者並應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/509.wav", + "text": "令其父母或監護人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/510.wav", + "text": "使其到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/511.wav", + "text": "未滿二十歲之人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/512.wav", + "text": "無正當理由未依前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/513.wav", + "text": "通知接受戒菸教育者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/514.wav", + "text": "處新臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/515.wav", + "text": "200元以上一萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/516.wav", + "text": "以下罰鍰並按次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/517.wav", + "text": "處罰行為人為未成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/518.wav", + "text": "者處罰其父母" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/519.wav", + "text": "第1項戒菸教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/520.wav", + "text": "之實施方式內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/521.wav", + "text": "時數執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/522.wav", + "text": "單位及其他應遵行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/523.wav", + "text": "事項之辦法由中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/524.wav", + "text": "主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/525.wav", + "text": "修正條文第42條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/526.wav", + "text": "就照修正條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/527.wav", + "text": "\n那我們來宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/528.wav", + "text": "結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/529.wav", + "text": "請問為什麼關麥克風審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/530.wav", + "text": "我把協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/531.wav", + "text": "先跟你報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/532.wav", + "text": "我來表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/533.wav", + "text": "所以不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/534.wav", + "text": "一下如果你有意見的話我們可以繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/535.wav", + "text": "討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/536.wav", + "text": "結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/537.wav", + "text": "國健署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/538.wav", + "text": "加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/539.wav", + "text": "載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/540.wav", + "text": "管制的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/541.wav", + "text": "管制的重點在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/542.wav", + "text": "將來這些載具都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/543.wav", + "text": "要像菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/544.wav", + "text": "一樣不得宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/545.wav", + "text": "不得廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/546.wav", + "text": "就是未滿20歲不能購買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/547.wav", + "text": "納入到現有條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/548.wav", + "text": "然後等待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/549.wav", + "text": "下一次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/550.wav", + "text": "把條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/551.wav", + "text": "提前在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/552.wav", + "text": "前一天的中午之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/553.wav", + "text": "下一次協商的時間訂在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/554.wav", + "text": "下個禮拜三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/555.wav", + "text": "早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/556.wav", + "text": "以要在禮拜二12時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/557.wav", + "text": "之前把條文給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/558.wav", + "text": "再進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/559.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛協商的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/560.wav", + "text": "是這樣所以下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/561.wav", + "text": "再做一次協商希望他們把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/562.wav", + "text": "載具及其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/563.wav", + "text": "必要組合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/564.wav", + "text": "的條文明列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/565.wav", + "text": "的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/566.wav", + "text": "我剛剛在交通委員會協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/567.wav", + "text": "很關心那請問其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/568.wav", + "text": "這個一定要解決後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/569.wav", + "text": "才有辦法處理那些罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/570.wav", + "text": "相關管制的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/571.wav", + "text": "\n今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/572.wav", + "text": "會議就到此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14748/573.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/0.wav", + "text": "開始開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/1.wav", + "text": "審查的台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/2.wav", + "text": "黨團委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/3.wav", + "text": "人時代力量黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/4.wav", + "text": "相關條文修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/5.wav", + "text": "問各位委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/6.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/7.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/8.wav", + "text": "沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/9.wav", + "text": "委員會提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/10.wav", + "text": "還有一張橫式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/11.wav", + "text": "提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/12.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/13.wav", + "text": "他們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/14.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/15.wav", + "text": "加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/16.wav", + "text": "我覺得都可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/17.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/18.wav", + "text": "業務的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/19.wav", + "text": "十二條條文修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/20.wav", + "text": "委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/21.wav", + "text": "林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/22.wav", + "text": "審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14743/23.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/0.wav", + "text": "我們今天要協商的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/1.wav", + "text": "衛環委員會完成審查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/2.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團委員吳玉琴等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/3.wav", + "text": "委員莊敬程等21人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/4.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團委員林為洲等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/5.wav", + "text": "委員林奕華等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/6.wav", + "text": "分別擬具的物理治療師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/7.wav", + "text": "本席先說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/8.wav", + "text": "本次協商的物理治療師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/9.wav", + "text": "當初委員會完成審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/10.wav", + "text": "僅有保留第十二條跟第十二條之一的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/11.wav", + "text": "因此本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/12.wav", + "text": "先從委員會保留的上述條文進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/13.wav", + "text": "對委員會已經通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/14.wav", + "text": "如果有異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/15.wav", + "text": "我們會在事後討論的時候再一併處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/16.wav", + "text": "請問各位委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/17.wav", + "text": "\n現在開始討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/18.wav", + "text": "物理治療師法第十二條之保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/19.wav", + "text": "首先請衛福部代表發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/20.wav", + "text": "還有物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/21.wav", + "text": "學會共同開會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/22.wav", + "text": "當時在討論之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/23.wav", + "text": "也提供在今天的會議資料裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/24.wav", + "text": "裡就是在第2項後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/25.wav", + "text": "醫療業務行為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/26.wav", + "text": "診察診斷及治療者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/27.wav", + "text": "但是這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/28.wav", + "text": "在會後仍然有團體表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/29.wav", + "text": "我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/30.wav", + "text": "提到物理治療師如果執行非以疾病治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/31.wav", + "text": "為目的之業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/32.wav", + "text": "自無依醫師開具之診斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/33.wav", + "text": "照會或醫囑為之之事由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/34.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/35.wav", + "text": "提出的修正動議文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/36.wav", + "text": "就是在第2項後段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/37.wav", + "text": "加上但非以疾病治療為目的者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/38.wav", + "text": "不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/39.wav", + "text": "釋解釋的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/40.wav", + "text": "把它正式入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/41.wav", + "text": "這大概就是目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/42.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/43.wav", + "text": "請各位委員翻到第12頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/44.wav", + "text": "蘇巧慧委員的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/45.wav", + "text": "你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/46.wav", + "text": "沒有問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/47.wav", + "text": "就是第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/48.wav", + "text": "巧慧不是這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/49.wav", + "text": "是次長提出來的好像是片段的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/50.wav", + "text": "跟研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/51.wav", + "text": "次長巧慧的版本這樣的寫法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/52.wav", + "text": "B版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/53.wav", + "text": "他的A版不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/54.wav", + "text": "A版跟你的文字一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/55.wav", + "text": "就是但非以疾病治療為目的者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/56.wav", + "text": "不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/57.wav", + "text": "所以你拿的是B版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/58.wav", + "text": "可是我們當時通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/59.wav", + "text": "的好像比較傾向A版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/60.wav", + "text": "不好意思我可以表示一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/61.wav", + "text": "請蘇巧慧委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/62.wav", + "text": "法條對照表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/63.wav", + "text": "另外還有一張橫式的文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/64.wav", + "text": "0530" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/65.wav", + "text": "然後有各委員的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/66.wav", + "text": "動議黨團提案委員提案跟現行條文橫式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/67.wav", + "text": "嘛還有最後一張是直式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/68.wav", + "text": "是第十二條條文修正草案對照表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/69.wav", + "text": "長的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/70.wav", + "text": "經過上一次我們的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/71.wav", + "text": "又回到我們上一次協商的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/72.wav", + "text": "也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/73.wav", + "text": "但你現在已經把它納為衛福部建議版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/74.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/75.wav", + "text": "我再次表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/76.wav", + "text": "這是不是我的版本真的一點都不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/77.wav", + "text": "因為各委員都非常盡心盡力地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/78.wav", + "text": "地集思廣益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/79.wav", + "text": "想要把這個問題解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/80.wav", + "text": "所以是誰的版本真的都不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/81.wav", + "text": "我也不需要冠我的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/82.wav", + "text": "衛福部建議版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/83.wav", + "text": "我們上一次其實已經有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/84.wav", + "text": "往這個方向收攏成共識了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/85.wav", + "text": "今天大家是不是就看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/86.wav", + "text": "衛福部建議版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/87.wav", + "text": "到底可不可以過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/88.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/89.wav", + "text": "主席我建議第十二條的討論方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/90.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/91.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/92.wav", + "text": "以下我們再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/93.wav", + "text": "\n請林為洲委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/94.wav", + "text": "原來我的版本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/95.wav", + "text": "多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/96.wav", + "text": "物理治療師執行前項第3款至第6款業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/97.wav", + "text": "應依醫師開具之診斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/98.wav", + "text": "後面那一句跟現在所謂的衛福部建議版一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/99.wav", + "text": "目的是要把它講清楚一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/100.wav", + "text": "其中第1款第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/101.wav", + "text": "還有第7款第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/102.wav", + "text": "其實跟治療沒有直接關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/103.wav", + "text": "這個本來就是物理治療師的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/104.wav", + "text": "在各款裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/105.wav", + "text": "當然我也尊重大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/106.wav", + "text": "請衛福部等一下說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/107.wav", + "text": "這個版本他們有沒有什麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/108.wav", + "text": "如果有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/109.wav", + "text": "我也尊重各位委員的提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/110.wav", + "text": "最後所謂的衛福部建議版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/111.wav", + "text": "我也可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/112.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/113.wav", + "text": "請吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/114.wav", + "text": "在委員會討論物理治療師法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/115.wav", + "text": "謝謝當時蘇巧慧委員很用心地讓很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/116.wav", + "text": "的部分能聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/117.wav", + "text": "大家一直聚焦的最大公約數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/118.wav", + "text": "也是大家比較能接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/119.wav", + "text": "事實上包括民眾黨時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/120.wav", + "text": "莊競程委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/121.wav", + "text": "林奕華委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/122.wav", + "text": "及林為洲委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/123.wav", + "text": "都有提到物理治療師執業的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/124.wav", + "text": "第3款到第6款是依照醫囑診斷照會沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/125.wav", + "text": "因為其實在護理人員法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/126.wav", + "text": "心理師法都有相關的授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/127.wav", + "text": "在那個專業裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/128.wav", + "text": "本來就有他可以執行的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/129.wav", + "text": "有些部分是要有醫師的醫囑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/130.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是彼此在專業分工上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/131.wav", + "text": "應該要有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/132.wav", + "text": "我們好幾個委員的版本都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/133.wav", + "text": "我還是要再次跟衛福部溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/134.wav", + "text": "就是如果在執行上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/135.wav", + "text": "是不是讓物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/136.wav", + "text": "第1款第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/137.wav", + "text": "第7款第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/138.wav", + "text": "有一些彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/139.wav", + "text": "讓他們可以執行業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/140.wav", + "text": "所以當然要有醫師的醫囑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/141.wav", + "text": "囑我也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/142.wav", + "text": "後面但非以疾病治療為目的者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/143.wav", + "text": "傷病預防運動防護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/144.wav", + "text": "延緩失能失智" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/145.wav", + "text": "但是這樣列舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/146.wav", + "text": "大家有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/147.wav", + "text": "我也可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/148.wav", + "text": "非以疾病治療為目的者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/149.wav", + "text": "我覺得這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/150.wav", + "text": "如果能夠採納我們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/151.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/152.wav", + "text": "我想大家大概的方向其實都比較接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/153.wav", + "text": "我們還是很希望大家能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/154.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/155.wav", + "text": "需要醫囑的部分限制在跟治療相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/156.wav", + "text": "部分尊重醫師的專業就是第3款第4款第5款第6款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/157.wav", + "text": "就是比較屬於一些評估內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/158.wav", + "text": "擬定等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/159.wav", + "text": "依照衛福部的版本然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/160.wav", + "text": "然後再特別把第3款到第6款納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/161.wav", + "text": "就是回歸到原本物理治療師的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/162.wav", + "text": "都能夠比較均衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/163.wav", + "text": "屋或有重工的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/164.wav", + "text": "讓各方專業都能發揮他們自己的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/165.wav", + "text": "讓各方專業都能夠得到重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/166.wav", + "text": "我覺得這應該是社會和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/167.wav", + "text": "應該共同努力的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/168.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/169.wav", + "text": "都很關心這個修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/170.wav", + "text": "更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/171.wav", + "text": "時代越進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/172.wav", + "text": "在很多專業上本來就會更分殊化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/173.wav", + "text": "我們只是希望讓各種專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/174.wav", + "text": "更能夠發揮它的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/175.wav", + "text": "並且從民眾的角度來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/176.wav", + "text": "可以受到更好的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/177.wav", + "text": "所以事實上我們幾人的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/178.wav", + "text": "都比較類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/179.wav", + "text": "因為覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/180.wav", + "text": "應該都是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/181.wav", + "text": "專業就可以做的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/182.wav", + "text": "也不涉及所謂的醫療行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/183.wav", + "text": "要以醫生開具的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/184.wav", + "text": "診斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/185.wav", + "text": "照會或醫囑為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/186.wav", + "text": "跟物理治療師怎麼樣分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/187.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/188.wav", + "text": "現在衛福部的主張是要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/189.wav", + "text": "我們還是先討論看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/190.wav", + "text": "看大家覺得最好的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/191.wav", + "text": "個因為立法院是合議制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/192.wav", + "text": "制如果有最好的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/193.wav", + "text": "用讓醫師跟物理治療師的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/194.wav", + "text": "都能做最好的發揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/195.wav", + "text": "多元意見下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/196.wav", + "text": "大家能不能有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/197.wav", + "text": "當然這對我們修法來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/198.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/199.wav", + "text": "跟邱泰源委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/200.wav", + "text": "\n有關黃秀芳邱泰源兩位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/201.wav", + "text": "列入本次黨團協商的會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/202.wav", + "text": "刊登公報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/203.wav", + "text": "但非以疾病治療為目的者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/204.wav", + "text": "基本上我可以接受衛福部的建議版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/205.wav", + "text": "我自己也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/206.wav", + "text": "從5月30日到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/207.wav", + "text": "確實擬出了一個以衛福部為主體的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/208.wav", + "text": "我記得在5月底討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/209.wav", + "text": "衛福部在這幾個月內確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/210.wav", + "text": "確實擬出了一個以衛福部為主體的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/211.wav", + "text": "現在是衛福部建議版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/212.wav", + "text": "我是建議應該用衛福部建議版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/213.wav", + "text": "進行更進一步的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/214.wav", + "text": "我也都接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/215.wav", + "text": "就是以這個版本往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/216.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/217.wav", + "text": "請蘇巧慧委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/218.wav", + "text": "我想是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/219.wav", + "text": "就是我在上一次的會議當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/220.wav", + "text": "也已經懇切的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/221.wav", + "text": "因為我自己多年來其實是復健科的病友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/222.wav", + "text": "所以我對復健科醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/223.wav", + "text": "及物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/224.wav", + "text": "兩方都非常的感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/225.wav", + "text": "修這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/226.wav", + "text": "復健這個學科學門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/227.wav", + "text": "甚至產業職業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/228.wav", + "text": "可以變得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/229.wav", + "text": "我們完完全全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/230.wav", + "text": "一定非常地尊重各個醫師的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/231.wav", + "text": "其實外面都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/232.wav", + "text": "寧可得罪立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/233.wav", + "text": "也不要得罪醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/234.wav", + "text": "因為醫師是救命的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/235.wav", + "text": "立法委員就隨便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/236.wav", + "text": "所以我們所有的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/237.wav", + "text": "都對醫師真的是非常非常尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/238.wav", + "text": "但是我們也可以看出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/239.wav", + "text": "社會在變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/240.wav", + "text": "物理治療師們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/241.wav", + "text": "上的產業有更大貢獻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/242.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/243.wav", + "text": "讓彼此的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/244.wav", + "text": "專業都能發揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/245.wav", + "text": "彼此都有空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/246.wav", + "text": "這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/247.wav", + "text": "醫療行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/248.wav", + "text": "尤其是疾病治療的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/249.wav", + "text": "是醫師的核心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/250.wav", + "text": "但是在疾病治療以外的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/251.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠有更多的裕度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/252.wav", + "text": "讓專業有空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/253.wav", + "text": "甚至讓病友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/254.wav", + "text": "就像我本人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/255.wav", + "text": "可以比較方便的去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/256.wav", + "text": "物理治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/257.wav", + "text": "我是說物理治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/258.wav", + "text": "不是疾病治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/259.wav", + "text": "其實我是根據本身的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/260.wav", + "text": "這樣的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/261.wav", + "text": "因為在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/262.wav", + "text": "任何一個文字下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/263.wav", + "text": "有規定就會有例外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/264.wav", + "text": "大家在討論的時候說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/265.wav", + "text": "第幾款可以給誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/266.wav", + "text": "第幾款不可以給誰的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/267.wav", + "text": "難免都會有掛一漏萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/268.wav", + "text": "都可以舉出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/269.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/270.wav", + "text": "原本的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/271.wav", + "text": "但加上一個但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/272.wav", + "text": "就是疾病治療的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/273.wav", + "text": "就一定要專屬於醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/274.wav", + "text": "而這也是107年函釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/275.wav", + "text": "也很感謝衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/276.wav", + "text": "在今天提出的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/277.wav", + "text": "當中直接列為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/278.wav", + "text": "建議版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/279.wav", + "text": "趨近於共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/280.wav", + "text": "那我再補充一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/281.wav", + "text": "在這段時間裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/282.wav", + "text": "我的研究供大家參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/283.wav", + "text": "\n我們今天在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/284.wav", + "text": "物理治療師法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/285.wav", + "text": "重中之重是第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/286.wav", + "text": "大家不斷地在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/287.wav", + "text": "第十二條的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/288.wav", + "text": "我們修的是整部法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/289.wav", + "text": "看到第十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/290.wav", + "text": "第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/291.wav", + "text": "第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/292.wav", + "text": "就更可以表彰出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/293.wav", + "text": "物理治療師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/294.wav", + "text": "並沒有要將疾病治療的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/295.wav", + "text": "從醫師手上拿走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/296.wav", + "text": "我們反而要求物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/297.wav", + "text": "一定要照這個邏輯去走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/298.wav", + "text": "因為第十三條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/299.wav", + "text": "物理治療師對醫師開具的診斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/300.wav", + "text": "照會及醫囑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/301.wav", + "text": "如有疑點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/302.wav", + "text": "就是義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/303.wav", + "text": ")即應詢明醫師確認後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/304.wav", + "text": "始得對病人實施物理治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/305.wav", + "text": "這是物理治療師的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/306.wav", + "text": "物理治療師執行業務時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/307.wav", + "text": "遇有病人危急或不適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/308.wav", + "text": "繼續施行物理治療者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/309.wav", + "text": "(也是義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/310.wav", + "text": ")即停止並聯絡醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/311.wav", + "text": "或建議病人由醫師再行診治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/312.wav", + "text": "這也是物理治療師的義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/313.wav", + "text": "甚至第十五條也還是有應啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/314.wav", + "text": "他都應該遵循醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/315.wav", + "text": "即使是在第十二條打開了一個空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/316.wav", + "text": "讓其可以做一些矯正預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/317.wav", + "text": "或其他部分但疾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/318.wav", + "text": "但疾病治療的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/319.wav", + "text": "我們還是賦予物理治療師有這樣的義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/320.wav", + "text": "再往下看到第三十三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/321.wav", + "text": "第三十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/322.wav", + "text": "第三十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/323.wav", + "text": "當違反剛剛所說的第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/324.wav", + "text": "其實他是有責任的他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/325.wav", + "text": "他要被處以罰金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/326.wav", + "text": "\n因此整個來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/327.wav", + "text": "其實我們是用一整部的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/328.wav", + "text": "來規範物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/329.wav", + "text": "可以做和不可以做的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/330.wav", + "text": "我覺得如果大家一直只把焦點放在第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/331.wav", + "text": "即到底怎麼去切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/332.wav", + "text": "以及在切了以後是不是誰的權益就受損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/333.wav", + "text": "誰就不能夠有醫療的狀況等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/334.wav", + "text": "呢其實我們是用整部法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/335.wav", + "text": "只是微開了一個空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/336.wav", + "text": "來因應現代社會的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/337.wav", + "text": "讓病友有比較大的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/338.wav", + "text": "也讓物理治療師可以善盡他的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/339.wav", + "text": "醫療行為裡的疾病治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/340.wav", + "text": "即醫師核心中的核心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/341.wav", + "text": "立法委員都還是堅守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/342.wav", + "text": "並認為這應該是屬於醫師的專責專職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/343.wav", + "text": "這是我最近的研究和看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/344.wav", + "text": "補充一點供大家參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/345.wav", + "text": "請洪申翰委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/346.wav", + "text": "能夠更經得起各界的辯證及檢驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/347.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是一件非常重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/348.wav", + "text": "目前的修法有關衛福部的建議版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/349.wav", + "text": "假設在這個版本的調整之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/350.wav", + "text": "我們還有哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/351.wav", + "text": "我不設定只有醫師團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/352.wav", + "text": "還有哪些不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/353.wav", + "text": "利害相關團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/354.wav", + "text": "其實是有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/355.wav", + "text": "的這個疑慮是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/356.wav", + "text": "包括說得出口的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/357.wav", + "text": "說不出口的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/358.wav", + "text": "這疑慮是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/359.wav", + "text": "我們來督促衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/360.wav", + "text": "去協助解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/361.wav", + "text": "或協助面對這些可能的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/362.wav", + "text": "有些是不是針對考選的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/363.wav", + "text": "還是在薪資待遇的部分有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/364.wav", + "text": "還是在什麼地方有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/365.wav", + "text": "我覺得都可以提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/366.wav", + "text": "作為立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/367.wav", + "text": "希望全力協助和督促衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/368.wav", + "text": "來解決及面對利害相關人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/369.wav", + "text": "在這一條條文的變動下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/370.wav", + "text": "可能會有潛在的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/371.wav", + "text": "我覺得都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/372.wav", + "text": "我們也很樂意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/373.wav", + "text": "但我們很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/374.wav", + "text": "也可以把各個利害相關方的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/375.wav", + "text": "團體我還是說我不設定只有醫師團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/376.wav", + "text": "即可以將他們的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/377.wav", + "text": "或還有不同想法及意見的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/378.wav", + "text": "並以明確地讓大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/379.wav", + "text": "並列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/380.wav", + "text": "大家要怎麼一起來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/381.wav", + "text": "共同面對及解決與幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/382.wav", + "text": "這是從國會的角度可以展現的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/383.wav", + "text": "\n還是再說一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/384.wav", + "text": "我覺得任何條文的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/385.wav", + "text": "都是需要經過各方重要的辯證及釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/386.wav", + "text": "包括重點是能夠解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/387.wav", + "text": "然後讓社會在這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/388.wav", + "text": "的專業上有更好的分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/389.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是大家最重要的期望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/390.wav", + "text": "所以不是只把法律的文字修了而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/391.wav", + "text": "我覺得在後續修了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/392.wav", + "text": "我們有很多事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/393.wav", + "text": "必須去面對及處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/394.wav", + "text": "從國會的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/395.wav", + "text": "而言我們很樂意與衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/396.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/397.wav", + "text": "還有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/398.wav", + "text": "沒有意見我們請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/399.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員主要有二個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/400.wav", + "text": "我這邊也作一點回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/401.wav", + "text": "第二款及第七款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/402.wav", + "text": "我們的評估是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/403.wav", + "text": "仍然可能有部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/404.wav", + "text": "會涉及到疾病治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/405.wav", + "text": "舉例而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/406.wav", + "text": "在輔具的使用上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/407.wav", + "text": "有些是為了疾病治療為目的的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/408.wav", + "text": "有些是為了他的生活功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/409.wav", + "text": "所使用的輔具使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/410.wav", + "text": "有些是需要有診斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/411.wav", + "text": "甚至是醫囑的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/412.wav", + "text": "物理治療目標也是同樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/413.wav", + "text": "即為了疾病的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/414.wav", + "text": "病人拿了醫師的診斷之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/415.wav", + "text": "尋求物理治療師來評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/416.wav", + "text": "然後制訂物理治療的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/417.wav", + "text": "及物理治療的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/418.wav", + "text": "所以有可能也會涉及到疾病治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/419.wav", + "text": "因此我們才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/420.wav", + "text": "在第二項不再去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/421.wav", + "text": "要診斷照會或醫囑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/422.wav", + "text": "而是都有可能涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/423.wav", + "text": "但是如果不是以疾病治療為目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/424.wav", + "text": "自然就沒有所謂診斷醫囑的需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/425.wav", + "text": "所以我們的建議文字是這樣的考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/426.wav", + "text": "\n第二個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/427.wav", + "text": "是相關團體的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/428.wav", + "text": "剛剛洪委員特別關心到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/429.wav", + "text": "有沒有涉及到其他相關的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/430.wav", + "text": "曾經也有考量到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/431.wav", + "text": "以明列的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/432.wav", + "text": "如健康促進傷病預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/433.wav", + "text": "運動防護延緩失能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/434.wav", + "text": "特殊教育為目的不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/435.wav", + "text": "不是以疾病治療為目的沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/436.wav", + "text": "但是因為明列的之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/437.wav", + "text": "就讓其他團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/438.wav", + "text": "認為這些是不是就匡進了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/439.wav", + "text": "物理治療師的業務範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/440.wav", + "text": "反而造成他們在執行上的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/441.wav", + "text": "為了避免造成這樣的困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/442.wav", + "text": "我們就不用這種明列的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/443.wav", + "text": "而是以概括性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/444.wav", + "text": "非以疾病治療為目的來形塑文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/445.wav", + "text": "有些是依照體育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/446.wav", + "text": "的運動防護員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/447.wav", + "text": "那就有運動防��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/448.wav", + "text": "我們把運動防護寫在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/449.wav", + "text": "而擔心變成他們不能做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/450.wav", + "text": "也變成了物理治療師的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/451.wav", + "text": "最後我們在文字上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/452.wav", + "text": "剛剛幾位委員的明列方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/453.wav", + "text": "也是經過跟團體討論之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/454.wav", + "text": "才作出這樣的文字建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/455.wav", + "text": "我建議就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/456.wav", + "text": "或衛福部建議版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/457.wav", + "text": "其實衛福部建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/458.wav", + "text": "已經融合各個委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/459.wav", + "text": "也不用具名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/460.wav", + "text": "我還是覺得有它的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/461.wav", + "text": "雖然洪申翰委員剛剛有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/462.wav", + "text": "可能會有其他團體的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/463.wav", + "text": "然而我們要想的一點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/464.wav", + "text": "回歸到物理治療師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/465.wav", + "text": "到底物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/466.wav", + "text": "不用經過醫囑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/467.wav", + "text": "就能做的這種業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/468.wav", + "text": "的話當然這個法就有意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/469.wav", + "text": "嘛即非以治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/470.wav", + "text": "讓他們有那個空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/471.wav", + "text": "現在他們的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/472.wav", + "text": "沒有入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/473.wav", + "text": "令他們常常處在那個模糊的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/474.wav", + "text": "剛剛你也首肯說有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/475.wav", + "text": "啊不需要醫囑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/476.wav", + "text": "不需要診斷的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/477.wav", + "text": "物理治療師有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/478.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/479.wav", + "text": "但是現在因為沒入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/480.wav", + "text": "常常用所謂的函釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/481.wav", + "text": "那就很模糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/482.wav", + "text": "然後沒有一個依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/483.wav", + "text": "既然我們肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/484.wav", + "text": "肯認物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/485.wav", + "text": "本來就有一些業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/486.wav", + "text": "是非關疾病治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/487.wav", + "text": "經過醫囑之後他們才能操作治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/488.wav", + "text": "那是疾病治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/489.wav", + "text": "的部分如果不需要醫囑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/490.wav", + "text": "不需要診斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/491.wav", + "text": "\n我們今天早上才去考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/492.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼樣預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/493.wav", + "text": "涉到人體工學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/494.wav", + "text": "搬東西要怎麼搬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/495.wav", + "text": "搬上搬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/496.wav", + "text": "推前拉後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/497.wav", + "text": "可能就在這樣的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/498.wav", + "text": "內雖然不涉及疾病治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/499.wav", + "text": "但是可以預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/500.wav", + "text": "我想很多物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/501.wav", + "text": "都可以提供這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/502.wav", + "text": "好的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/503.wav", + "text": "既然他們本來就有一些業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/504.wav", + "text": "不須經過醫囑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/505.wav", + "text": "不須經過疾病診斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/506.wav", + "text": "那麼這個條文就有其意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/507.wav", + "text": "不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/508.wav", + "text": "現在只是把函釋變成條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/509.wav", + "text": "讓它更明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/510.wav", + "text": "委員會還是要實質審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/511.wav", + "text": "不要動不動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/512.wav", + "text": "稍微有一點不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/513.wav", + "text": "包括衛福部都已經同意的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/514.wav", + "text": "本席建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/515.wav", + "text": "能夠以衛福部建議的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/516.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/517.wav", + "text": "請林委員奕華發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/518.wav", + "text": "們看到次長已經對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/519.wav", + "text": "各團體多方徵詢過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/520.wav", + "text": "既然在衛福部的函釋當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/521.wav", + "text": "釋當中就已經有這些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/522.wav", + "text": "那麼我們就是把函釋入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/523.wav", + "text": "們在執法或判斷上能夠有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/524.wav", + "text": "當中我們也知道時代一直在進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/525.wav", + "text": "預防和治療是不同的概念等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/526.wav", + "text": "為最後結論的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/527.wav", + "text": "那麼我們就不堅持我們原來所提出的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/528.wav", + "text": "大家都覺得OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/529.wav", + "text": "在主席的主持之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/530.wav", + "text": "有一個圓滿的協商結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/531.wav", + "text": "那我們還是維持原來的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/532.wav", + "text": "再送出協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/533.wav", + "text": "其實剛剛在討論物理治療師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/534.wav", + "text": "物理治療師法第十二條第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/535.wav", + "text": "規定的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/536.wav", + "text": "元以下罰金也就是說後面有一個很強的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/537.wav", + "text": "給予非以疾病治療為目的者不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/538.wav", + "text": "其實過去物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/539.wav", + "text": "或職能治療師在執行業務的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/540.wav", + "text": "常常會擔心自己違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/541.wav", + "text": "只是後來檢察官沒有起訴而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/542.wav", + "text": "其實他們是在執行與民眾健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/543.wav", + "text": "它不是治療疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/544.wav", + "text": "他們所協助的是物理治療的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/545.wav", + "text": "而這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/546.wav", + "text": "並不是沒有發生過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/547.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們要明列排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/548.wav", + "text": "就是因為相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/549.wav", + "text": "相關事件曾經發生過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/550.wav", + "text": "就像林為洲委員林奕華委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/551.wav", + "text": "如果我們今天有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/552.wav", + "text": "基本上我也沒有一定要堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/553.wav", + "text": "的規定通過如果這次修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/554.wav", + "text": "讓物理治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/555.wav", + "text": "不會有觸犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/556.wav", + "text": "讓他們在執行業務時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/557.wav", + "text": "時會擔心的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/558.wav", + "text": "應該要越來越符合時代的需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/559.wav", + "text": "而且我們也期待物理治療師在未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/560.wav", + "text": "中可以扮演更前端的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/561.wav", + "text": "而是有關預防特教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/562.wav", + "text": "並不是之後的治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/563.wav", + "text": "同時也是新的社會需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/564.wav", + "text": "我們也希望今天能夠送出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/565.wav", + "text": "商並順利三讀通過以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/566.wav", + "text": "延緩失能等部分更往前推進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/567.wav", + "text": "第1款或第2款所規範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/568.wav", + "text": "物理治療評估或測試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/569.wav", + "text": "以及物理治療目的及內容之擬定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/570.wav", + "text": "比較屬於物理治療核心業務的專業行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/571.wav", + "text": "而不是來自於醫學病理性的診斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/572.wav", + "text": "又或者剛才所提到的第7條及第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/573.wav", + "text": "都直接與治療疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/574.wav", + "text": "這也就是為什麼我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/575.wav", + "text": "定非以疾病治療為目的就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/576.wav", + "text": "衛福部的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/577.wav", + "text": "及各位委員的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/578.wav", + "text": "在後面都有更多清楚的說明所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/579.wav", + "text": "以衛福部建議版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/580.wav", + "text": "這樣至少可以明確知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/581.wav", + "text": "非以疾病治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/582.wav", + "text": "為目的在各項業務當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/583.wav", + "text": "其實有可以討論和擬訂的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/584.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣也是可以處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/585.wav", + "text": "已經執行好幾年而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/586.wav", + "text": "而且依照函釋執行到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/587.wav", + "text": "我覺得是可以接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/588.wav", + "text": "也希望今天能夠凝聚更多的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/589.wav", + "text": "直接在委員會當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/590.wav", + "text": "就有一些共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/591.wav", + "text": "能夠把物理治療師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/592.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/593.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/594.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處理第十二條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/595.wav", + "text": "我只是把一些非醫療的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/596.wav", + "text": "部分列舉出來而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/597.wav", + "text": "就不堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/598.wav", + "text": "關於委員林奕華等提案增訂第十二條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/599.wav", + "text": "已經表示不堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/600.wav", + "text": "容通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/601.wav", + "text": "部分均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/602.wav", + "text": "圓滿成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/603.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14742/604.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14727/0.wav", + "text": "就是地籍清理條例本案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14727/1.wav", + "text": "提出的修正動議共兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14727/2.wav", + "text": "幾位委員針對保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14727/3.wav", + "text": "條文文字跟行政院版的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14726/0.wav", + "text": "版本謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/0.wav", + "text": "本席擔任內政召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/1.wav", + "text": "時審查完竣當時委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/2.wav", + "text": "對代為標售土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/3.wav", + "text": "要不要增加標售次數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/4.wav", + "text": "有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/5.wav", + "text": "所以決議第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/6.wav", + "text": "湯蕙禎委員等人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/7.wav", + "text": "所提出的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/8.wav", + "text": "交由黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/9.wav", + "text": "已檢討修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/10.wav", + "text": "並與委員完成溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/11.wav", + "text": "\n請問各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/12.wav", + "text": "除了審查會保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/13.wav", + "text": "其他條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/14.wav", + "text": "有沒有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/15.wav", + "text": "如果沒有其他條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/16.wav", + "text": "就照審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/17.wav", + "text": "通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/18.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/19.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/20.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/21.wav", + "text": "討論保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/22.wav", + "text": "建議修正的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/23.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/24.wav", + "text": "針對保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/25.wav", + "text": "即草案第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/26.wav", + "text": "今天提供給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/27.wav", + "text": "12月23日的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/28.wav", + "text": "我們採用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/29.wav", + "text": "建議修正條文的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/30.wav", + "text": "第十五條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/31.wav", + "text": "我們還是維持二次標售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/32.wav", + "text": "針對第十五條之一的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/33.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/34.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/35.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/36.wav", + "text": "通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/37.wav", + "text": "第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/38.wav", + "text": "增訂第十五條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/39.wav", + "text": "其餘我們均照審查的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/40.wav", + "text": "\n司法院有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/41.wav", + "text": "我們的意見跟上次一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/42.wav", + "text": "但是如果政策決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/43.wav", + "text": "是如此的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/44.wav", + "text": "我們沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/45.wav", + "text": "政策如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/46.wav", + "text": "我們沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/47.wav", + "text": "感謝司法院也沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/48.wav", + "text": "我們剛才所提出的第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/49.wav", + "text": "我們就通過條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/50.wav", + "text": "均照審查會審查的結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/51.wav", + "text": "第三是條號及條文中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/52.wav", + "text": "授權議事人員做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/53.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/54.wav", + "text": "請各黨團的協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/55.wav", + "text": "我們今天的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14725/56.wav", + "text": "就到此結束好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/0.wav", + "text": "先進現在開會今天的立法院朝野黨團協商會議開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/1.wav", + "text": "第一研商有關第6會期延會期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/2.wav", + "text": "加開院會相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/3.wav", + "text": "第二研商有關立法院組織法部分條文修正草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/4.wav", + "text": "第三研商中華民國刑法部分條文修正草案等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/5.wav", + "text": "(如附表)相關事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/6.wav", + "text": "就這三個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/7.wav", + "text": "進行各法案協商之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/8.wav", + "text": "向各黨團說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/9.wav", + "text": "到元月13日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/10.wav", + "text": "並且都改成開院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/11.wav", + "text": "依照議事規則第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/12.wav", + "text": "規定院會得經黨團協商合併數日為一次院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/13.wav", + "text": "延會期間可以召開兩次院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/14.wav", + "text": "每次院會以一週為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/15.wav", + "text": "第一週院會與12月30日合併為一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/16.wav", + "text": "看各黨團有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/17.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/18.wav", + "text": "我們就針對前次協商結論的補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/19.wav", + "text": "我先宣讀補充的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/20.wav", + "text": "再請各黨團來同意和簽署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/21.wav", + "text": "會期間1月3日(星期二)至1月7日(星期六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/22.wav", + "text": ")與111年12月30日(星期五)合併為一次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/23.wav", + "text": "1月9日(星期一)至1月13日(星期五)" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/24.wav", + "text": "均不處理臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/25.wav", + "text": "\n大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/26.wav", + "text": "意思就是切成兩次就12" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/27.wav", + "text": "2月30日簽到一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/28.wav", + "text": "1月9日簽到一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/29.wav", + "text": "要出國的就出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/30.wav", + "text": "黨鞭留下來協商就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/31.wav", + "text": "先簽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/32.wav", + "text": "我倒是沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/33.wav", + "text": "認為我們應該同時討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/34.wav", + "text": "關於提案日期收案日期是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/35.wav", + "text": "等一下談好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/36.wav", + "text": "會在哪個議程當中談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/37.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/38.wav", + "text": "好幾項要談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/39.wav", + "text": "這個部分就先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/40.wav", + "text": "本院成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/41.wav", + "text": "國際事務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/42.wav", + "text": "修法事宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/43.wav", + "text": "上週協商會議已提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/44.wav", + "text": "給各黨團修法內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/45.wav", + "text": "我想各黨團應該都有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/46.wav", + "text": "各黨團有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/47.wav", + "text": "如果有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/48.wav", + "text": "都可以修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/49.wav", + "text": "沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/50.wav", + "text": "這一次的修法就由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/51.wav", + "text": "各黨團共同提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/52.wav", + "text": "利用延會期間的院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/53.wav", + "text": "完成立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/54.wav", + "text": "我先宣讀協商結論草稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/55.wav", + "text": "再看各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/56.wav", + "text": "立法院組織法部分條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/57.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/58.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意共同提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/59.wav", + "text": "列入第14次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/60.wav", + "text": "報告事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/61.wav", + "text": "院會處理時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/62.wav", + "text": "逕附二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/63.wav", + "text": "並列為同次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/64.wav", + "text": "討論事項第一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/65.wav", + "text": "並照提案條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/66.wav", + "text": "完成立法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/67.wav", + "text": "第14次就是延長會期第一週的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/68.wav", + "text": "那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/69.wav", + "text": "那一天要處理完畢對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/70.wav", + "text": "非常不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/71.wav", + "text": "我笨鳥先飛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/72.wav", + "text": "我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/73.wav", + "text": "立法院組織法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/74.wav", + "text": "應該要循程序委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/75.wav", + "text": "開始的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/76.wav", + "text": "正常修法程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/77.wav", + "text": "不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/78.wav", + "text": "就這樣協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/79.wav", + "text": "不能逕附二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/80.wav", + "text": "快速通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/81.wav", + "text": "因為12月8日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/82.wav", + "text": "美國眾議院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/83.wav", + "text": "國防授權法案之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/84.wav", + "text": "12月16日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/85.wav", + "text": "美國參議院也通過該法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/86.wav", + "text": "並授權美國政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/87.wav", + "text": "未來5年提供中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/88.wav", + "text": "100億美元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/89.wav", + "text": "我們本來以為這是軍援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/90.wav", + "text": "要派官員進駐我國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/91.wav", + "text": "行政立法機構見習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/92.wav", + "text": "所有的新聞都報導葛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/93.wav", + "text": "葛理漢參議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/94.wav", + "text": "改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/95.wav", + "text": "還是要償還的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/96.wav", + "text": "而且他們派官員到我國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/97.wav", + "text": "行政立法機構見習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/98.wav", + "text": "200多年的民主年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/99.wav", + "text": "中華民國的年紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/100.wav", + "text": "只有他們的一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/101.wav", + "text": "學習我們的民主制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/102.wav", + "text": "見習執政黨對輿論的操控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/103.wav", + "text": "還是見習抗中保臺的成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/104.wav", + "text": "還是要來干涉內政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/105.wav", + "text": "以督軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/106.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/107.wav", + "text": "最近這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/108.wav", + "text": "已經成為強權國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/109.wav", + "text": "代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/110.wav", + "text": "或代理人戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/111.wav", + "text": "成為供人利用的軍火庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/112.wav", + "text": "人民也變成被算計的棋子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/113.wav", + "text": "我們看到滿清末年時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/114.wav", + "text": "各國列強租界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/115.wav", + "text": "我不希望我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/116.wav", + "text": "也會淪為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/117.wav", + "text": "21世紀的新租界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/118.wav", + "text": "所以美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/119.wav", + "text": "在通過國防授權法案之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/120.wav", + "text": "予我們協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/121.wav", + "text": "但是如果我們這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/122.wav", + "text": "快速地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/123.wav", + "text": "地配合通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/124.wav", + "text": "立法院組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/125.wav", + "text": "所制定的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/126.wav", + "text": "說要派員至中華民國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/127.wav", + "text": "立法機構見習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/128.wav", + "text": "可以變成一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/129.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們會對不起國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/130.wav", + "text": "各位還有沒有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/131.wav", + "text": "既然這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/132.wav", + "text": "游毓蘭委員講的問題讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/133.wav", + "text": "大家都知道很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/134.wav", + "text": "事實上的狀況我也不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/135.wav", + "text": "成立國際事務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/136.wav", + "text": "是有實際的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/137.wav", + "text": "都有出國考察包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/138.wav", + "text": "很多委員的外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/139.wav", + "text": "禮儀等方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/140.wav", + "text": "世界各國的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/141.wav", + "text": "也需要提供一些幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/142.wav", + "text": "和游毓蘭委員講的是有關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/143.wav", + "text": "和你差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/144.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/145.wav", + "text": "我們就循正常程序也無所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/146.wav", + "text": "不必經過幾天通過沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/147.wav", + "text": "迫早晚都會成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/148.wav", + "text": "沒有關係我們不希望誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/149.wav", + "text": "飆車這樣也不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/150.wav", + "text": "但方向絕對是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/151.wav", + "text": "我們不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/152.wav", + "text": "謝謝總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/153.wav", + "text": "黃委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/154.wav", + "text": "不好意思我來得比較晚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/155.wav", + "text": "我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/156.wav", + "text": "結論我也支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/157.wav", + "text": "今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/158.wav", + "text": "隨同游院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/159.wav", + "text": "所以我才在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/160.wav", + "text": "為什麼會有成立國際事務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/161.wav", + "text": "需求的起源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/162.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/163.wav", + "text": "雖然受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/164.wav", + "text": "疫情的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/165.wav", + "text": "不過我們的國會外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/166.wav", + "text": "可以說隨著這幾年的國際情勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/167.wav", + "text": "越來越熱絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/168.wav", + "text": "也都有相當地提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/169.wav", + "text": "特別是我們這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/170.wav", + "text": "因為各黨都有委員參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/171.wav", + "text": "在辦理國會外交的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/172.wav", + "text": "除了院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/173.wav", + "text": "跟秘書處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/174.wav", + "text": "兼辦之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/175.wav", + "text": "友臺小組對應的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/176.wav", + "text": "友好國會議員的聯誼會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/177.wav", + "text": "事實上在院的層級是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/178.wav", + "text": "沒有幕僚單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/179.wav", + "text": "各個會長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/180.wav", + "text": "的辦公室助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/181.wav", + "text": "自己跟對方聯絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/182.wav", + "text": "很多行程的安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/183.wav", + "text": "雙方會面的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/184.wav", + "text": "見了哪些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/185.wav", + "text": "哪些紀錄等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/186.wav", + "text": "事實上院裡面沒有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/187.wav", + "text": "國會跟國會之間的長期往來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/188.wav", + "text": "跟交往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/189.wav", + "text": "其實也是有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/190.wav", + "text": "的我們會有這樣的提議是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/191.wav", + "text": "譬如我們到了法國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/192.wav", + "text": "法國的國會就有類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/193.wav", + "text": "所以我們的正式訪團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/194.wav", + "text": "參訪期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/195.wav", + "text": "他們的國會參議院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/196.wav", + "text": "事實上都有行政人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/197.wav", + "text": "隨行跟我們安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/198.wav", + "text": "跟我們做對口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/199.wav", + "text": "假設我們的訪談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/200.wav", + "text": "有任何需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/201.wav", + "text": "雖然不是由院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/202.wav", + "text": "來做主要的接待窗口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/203.wav", + "text": "但是仍然有一個專責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/204.wav", + "text": "在我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/205.wav", + "text": "國外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/206.wav", + "text": "國會議員或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/207.wav", + "text": "有人來訪的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/208.wav", + "text": "很多安排的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/209.wav", + "text": "我們秘書處是負荷不來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/210.wav", + "text": "常常需要外交部的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/211.wav", + "text": "可是畢竟行政跟立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/212.wav", + "text": "不同的功能跟角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/213.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會有這樣子的提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/214.wav", + "text": "跟剛剛游委員所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/215.wav", + "text": "講的那些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/216.wav", + "text": "沒有直接的關聯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/217.wav", + "text": "至少我個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/218.wav", + "text": "在審預算的時候提案的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/219.wav", + "text": "是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/220.wav", + "text": "補充說明而已以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/221.wav", + "text": "我非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/222.wav", + "text": "黃世杰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/223.wav", + "text": "因為我們在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/224.wav", + "text": "但是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/225.wav", + "text": "現在真的是動見觀瞻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/226.wav", + "text": "尤其美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/227.wav", + "text": "就在今天才剛剛傳出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/228.wav", + "text": "100億元金援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/229.wav", + "text": "變成貸款要12年償還等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/230.wav", + "text": "又敲鑼打鼓說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/231.wav", + "text": "要派員到我們這邊來上班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/232.wav", + "text": "我們自己要健全我們的組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/233.wav", + "text": "我絕對沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/234.wav", + "text": "我們自己在內部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/235.wav", + "text": "我一定會很認真地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/236.wav", + "text": "一起來健全我們的組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/237.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/238.wav", + "text": "馬上在延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/239.wav", + "text": "會時無異議地快速通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/240.wav", + "text": "不清到時候又背一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/241.wav", + "text": "賣臺賊賣國賊之名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/242.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們沒有必要��樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/243.wav", + "text": "好不好我們就大家一起努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/244.wav", + "text": "把這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/245.wav", + "text": "法制謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/246.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席還有各黨黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/247.wav", + "text": "這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/248.wav", + "text": "其實現在國會外交的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/249.wav", + "text": "確實如火如荼也非常繁重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/250.wav", + "text": "相關幕僚單位的設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/251.wav", + "text": "長期在國際政治上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/252.wav", + "text": "國會外交是一個相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/253.wav", + "text": "也是合議制的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/254.wav", + "text": "在程序上有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/255.wav", + "text": "其必要性所以我們也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/256.wav", + "text": "等正常必要的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/257.wav", + "text": "比較可以釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/258.wav", + "text": "幕僚單位但是程序上我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/259.wav", + "text": "尊重各方的意見我們把它完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/260.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/261.wav", + "text": "我簡短講就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/262.wav", + "text": "我不希望這個委員會的成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/263.wav", + "text": "是在被懷疑猜忌下成立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/264.wav", + "text": "大家也背不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/265.wav", + "text": "成立這個處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/266.wav", + "text": "大家都知道尤其現在國會外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/267.wav", + "text": "占整個國會非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/268.wav", + "text": "和過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/269.wav", + "text": "的時代完全不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/270.wav", + "text": "我們只是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/271.wav", + "text": "將來成立這個處的時候要培養一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/272.wav", + "text": "專業人才要找好的人才進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/273.wav", + "text": "對大家有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/274.wav", + "text": "只有這樣的期待而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/275.wav", + "text": "共同提案當天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/276.wav", + "text": "或當天的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/277.wav", + "text": "也不需如此反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/278.wav", + "text": "反正這麼多年來很少看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/279.wav", + "text": "大家都懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/280.wav", + "text": "我們就循正常程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/281.wav", + "text": "反正大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/282.wav", + "text": "國會才能進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/283.wav", + "text": "的重要性大家應該都非常認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/284.wav", + "text": "也希望在我們的組織下能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/285.wav", + "text": "有一些調整以求更健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/286.wav", + "text": "我相信大家方向是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/287.wav", + "text": "可能也希望藉這個機會跟大家同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/288.wav", + "text": "提出來也請大家未來在完備程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/289.wav", + "text": "時一起思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/290.wav", + "text": "滿多委員在這次休會期間其實都有出訪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/291.wav", + "text": "各國的國會議員也會問到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/292.wav", + "text": "在臺灣法制上如何落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/293.wav", + "text": "我們每個委員提出的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/294.wav", + "text": "有沒有符合這些國際標準或國際想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/295.wav", + "text": "的確現在立法院有法制局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/296.wav", + "text": "但是好像對國際公約的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/297.wav", + "text": "比較沒有檢視每個委員所提出的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/298.wav", + "text": "尤其我們很希望能夠加入國際組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/299.wav", + "text": "很希望能夠讓國際看見臺灣的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/300.wav", + "text": "所定義的國會外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/301.wav", + "text": "恐怕不是只有造訪到訪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/302.wav", + "text": "這樣的交流而已還有一些國際議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/303.wav", + "text": "可能也要一併考慮進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/304.wav", + "text": "真的是要有效益而且是要盡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/305.wav", + "text": "盡可能極大效益化所以我希望不只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/306.wav", + "text": "有處理參訪或處理交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/307.wav", + "text": "而已包括這些議題尤其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/308.wav", + "text": "我們是立法院我們的立法精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/309.wav", + "text": "立法內容如何符合國際趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/310.wav", + "text": "其實也是一個很重要的檢視所以這邊提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/311.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/312.wav", + "text": "我是會議詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/313.wav", + "text": "但是又把主計人員跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/314.wav", + "text": "醫事人員又配套在這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/315.wav", + "text": "修法一併調整及入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/316.wav", + "text": "如果這已經是很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/317.wav", + "text": "不儘早把醫事人員及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/318.wav", + "text": "主計人員的部分先行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/319.wav", + "text": "處理這是第一個詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/320.wav", + "text": "如果循正常程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/321.wav", + "text": "可能也會拖到下個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/322.wav", + "text": "醫事及會計這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/323.wav", + "text": "如果沒有影響嚴格講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/324.wav", + "text": "你們的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/325.wav", + "text": "我只是做會議詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/326.wav", + "text": "這麼多年都沒有國際處會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/327.wav", + "text": "什麼影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/328.wav", + "text": "現在所有人大部分都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/329.wav", + "text": "我在問醫事人員及會計人員的附帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/330.wav", + "text": "啦為什麼要融進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/331.wav", + "text": "沒有的話會不會有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/332.wav", + "text": "有沒有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/333.wav", + "text": "請他們說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/334.wav", + "text": "母法已經修了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/335.wav", + "text": "只是調整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/336.wav", + "text": "而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/337.wav", + "text": "這幾年組織法並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/338.wav", + "text": "修法的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/339.wav", + "text": "這次是因為有委員提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/340.wav", + "text": "要成立國際事務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/341.wav", + "text": "醫事人員及主計人員其實只是配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/342.wav", + "text": "其他法律的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/343.wav", + "text": "以符合現狀的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/344.wav", + "text": "當然委員提到會不會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/345.wav", + "text": "沒有都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/346.wav", + "text": "其他法律已經修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/347.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/348.wav", + "text": "還有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/349.wav", + "text": "國際事務處的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/350.wav", + "text": "就照正常程序處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/351.wav", + "text": "黃世杰委員提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/352.wav", + "text": "本來是要4個黨團一起提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/353.wav", + "text": "我們自己不能提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/354.wav", + "text": "要有人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/355.wav", + "text": "黃世院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/356.wav", + "text": "技術性問題大家自己去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/357.wav", + "text": "有什麼問題一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/358.wav", + "text": "不要急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/359.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/360.wav", + "text": "現在我們已經進入最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/361.wav", + "text": "的階段了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/362.wav", + "text": "延會期間分兩段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/363.wav", + "text": "至於延會要處理的事項大家很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/364.wav", + "text": "只有院會而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/365.wav", + "text": "最近比較急的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/366.wav", + "text": "因為前瞻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/367.wav", + "text": "第4期在昨天已經出委員會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/368.wav", + "text": "只有保留一個案子而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/369.wav", + "text": "請秘書長聽一下這個要拜託你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/370.wav", + "text": "你盯住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/371.wav", + "text": "經出財政委員會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/372.wav", + "text": "趕快做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/373.wav", + "text": "審查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/374.wav", + "text": "明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/375.wav", + "text": "我們下禮拜就可以先來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/376.wav", + "text": "處理前瞻因為只有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/377.wav", + "text": "是保留案如果要再提也不多案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/378.wav", + "text": "可以專心處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/379.wav", + "text": "總預算及重大法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/380.wav", + "text": "前瞻的部分比較單純" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/381.wav", + "text": "就做好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/382.wav", + "text": "等一下會送報告出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/383.wav", + "text": "議程會變更將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/384.wav", + "text": "協商前瞻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/385.wav", + "text": "間就專心處理重大法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/386.wav", + "text": "及總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/387.wav", + "text": "好下禮拜二下班前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/388.wav", + "text": "另外總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/389.wav", + "text": "都是在國民黨手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/390.wav", + "text": "要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/391.wav", + "text": "林文瑞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/392.wav", + "text": "委員請他們下禮拜三處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/393.wav", + "text": "報告到下禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/394.wav", + "text": "在院會宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/395.wav", + "text": "總預算一定要先談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/396.wav", + "text": "通案等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/397.wav", + "text": "我們都有一定的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/398.wav", + "text": "希望不必要的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/399.wav", + "text": "不要弄太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/400.wav", + "text": "重點處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/401.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/402.wav", + "text": "至少在30日以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/403.wav", + "text": "先將前瞻處理完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/404.wav", + "text": "內政及交通審竣之後拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/405.wav", + "text": "請秘書長盯一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/406.wav", + "text": "禮拜四將審查報告做出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/407.wav", + "text": "總預算才能夠唸過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/408.wav", + "text": "才能夠展開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/409.wav", + "text": "會有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/410.wav", + "text": "30日把所有唸完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/411.wav", + "text": "但總預算也要有收案截止時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/412.wav", + "text": "收案截止是27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/413.wav", + "text": "算什麼時候要收案截止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/414.wav", + "text": "總預算大家心裡都有底了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/415.wav", + "text": "只是尊重內政及交通還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/416.wav", + "text": "沒審完而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/417.wav", + "text": "其他的提案收案時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/418.wav", + "text": "是過完年後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/419.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/420.wav", + "text": "1月4日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/421.wav", + "text": "總預算收案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/422.wav", + "text": "1月4日(" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/423.wav", + "text": "禮拜三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/424.wav", + "text": ")那我們趕快來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/425.wav", + "text": "不用提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/426.wav", + "text": "所以我說不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/427.wav", + "text": "下班前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/428.wav", + "text": "來協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/429.wav", + "text": "1月5日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/430.wav", + "text": "要給委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/431.wav", + "text": "我們先從通案開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/432.wav", + "text": "先收案截止以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/433.wav", + "text": "幕僚要先整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/434.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/435.wav", + "text": "1月4日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/436.wav", + "text": "下班前截止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/437.wav", + "text": ")要給幕僚單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/438.wav", + "text": "我們先收案收完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/439.wav", + "text": "都知道的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/440.wav", + "text": "越快越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/441.wav", + "text": "至少可以從通案開始講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/442.wav", + "text": "嘛反正案子都收完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/443.wav", + "text": "後面就可以開始了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/444.wav", + "text": "財委會要去做整理而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/445.wav", + "text": "他們也要時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/446.wav", + "text": "什麼時候開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/447.wav", + "text": "最快是1月5日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/448.wav", + "text": "未來才能篤定知道要做哪些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/449.wav", + "text": "這些講完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/450.wav", + "text": "再來談法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/451.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/452.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛聽各黨團的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/453.wav", + "text": "針對前瞻特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/454.wav", + "text": "預算的部分收案截止時間是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/455.wav", + "text": "(星期二)下班前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/456.wav", + "text": "總預算案公務預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/457.wav", + "text": "是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/458.wav", + "text": "112年1月4日(星期三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/459.wav", + "text": ")下班前截止收案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/460.wav", + "text": "就簽這二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/461.wav", + "text": "至於後續的幕僚作業什麼時候開始密集協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/462.wav", + "text": "議事人員跟主席確定時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/463.wav", + "text": "總預算是1月4日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/464.wav", + "text": "簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/465.wav", + "text": "前瞻的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/466.wav", + "text": "前瞻先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/467.wav", + "text": "嘛前瞻最單純" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/468.wav", + "text": "最好是在12月30日完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/469.wav", + "text": "總預算通過程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/470.wav", + "text": "前瞻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/471.wav", + "text": "院會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/472.wav", + "text": "院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/473.wav", + "text": "不用寫那麼細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/474.wav", + "text": "那天要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/475.wav", + "text": "大家要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/476.wav", + "text": "12月27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/477.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/478.wav", + "text": "院會進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/479.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/480.wav", + "text": "那個沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/481.wav", + "text": "時間地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/482.wav", + "text": "我就不唸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/483.wav", + "text": "決定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/484.wav", + "text": "一請各黨團於12日27日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/485.wav", + "text": "(星期二)下午5時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/486.wav", + "text": "將中央政府前瞻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/487.wav", + "text": "基礎建設計畫第4期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/488.wav", + "text": "特別預算案之提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/489.wav", + "text": "送至財政委員會彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/490.wav", + "text": "逾時不再收案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/491.wav", + "text": "並於12月30日(星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/492.wav", + "text": ")院會進行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/493.wav", + "text": "二請各黨團於112年1月4日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/494.wav", + "text": "(星期三)下午5時前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/495.wav", + "text": "將112年度中央政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/496.wav", + "text": "總預算案之提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/497.wav", + "text": "送至財政委員會彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/498.wav", + "text": "逾時不再收案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/499.wav", + "text": "\n這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/500.wav", + "text": "這個會期是預算會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/501.wav", + "text": "優先處理預算我相信大家都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/502.wav", + "text": "而且沒有保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/503.wav", + "text": "我想確認一下這個會期有沒有要處理這些法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/504.wav", + "text": "還是只是過個形式而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/505.wav", + "text": "條文其實就應該儘快三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/506.wav", + "text": "跟性私密相關的部分其實大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/507.wav", + "text": "也是談了很久從專法推到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/508.wav", + "text": "四法聯防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/509.wav", + "text": "到現在都還有很多部分沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/510.wav", + "text": "我們要不要也積極地在這次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/511.wav", + "text": "我們很希望不要因為屆期不連續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/512.wav", + "text": "這個會期或下個會期審不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/513.wav", + "text": "就繼續往後延重新開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/514.wav", + "text": "王委員我想你對議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/515.wav", + "text": "議事程序對現在在進行的都不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/516.wav", + "text": "就是要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/517.wav", + "text": "我們接下來就是要談這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/518.wav", + "text": "已經列案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/519.wav", + "text": "再下來我們就要談了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/520.wav", + "text": "那協商結論等一下再簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/521.wav", + "text": "的接下來要談法案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/522.wav", + "text": "這個法案是我排進來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/523.wav", + "text": "你們哪一個黨把它排進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/524.wav", + "text": "要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/525.wav", + "text": "不要老是說得好像只有你們在關心而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/526.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/527.wav", + "text": "事情真的是關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/528.wav", + "text": "程序要先處理好我們就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/529.wav", + "text": "接下去怎麼弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/530.wav", + "text": "你們是什麼單位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/531.wav", + "text": "不必這麼急跳進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/532.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/533.wav", + "text": "我們還有事情要談完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/534.wav", + "text": "抱歉謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/535.wav", + "text": "施性侵性剝削" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/536.wav", + "text": "列為優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/537.wav", + "text": "所以我們把它排到第一個要協商的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/538.wav", + "text": "接下來有氣候變化公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/539.wav", + "text": "也有菸害防制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/540.wav", + "text": "反正已經超過一個月以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/541.wav", + "text": "必須處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/542.wav", + "text": "能夠處理就儘量往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/543.wav", + "text": "這是我們主動排進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/544.wav", + "text": "的所以一定會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/545.wav", + "text": "我們今天只是講到程序而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/546.wav", + "text": "及關於媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/547.wav", + "text": "這個大家要注意一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/548.wav", + "text": "我們下禮拜開始進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/549.wav", + "text": "這5個法的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/550.wav", + "text": "各黨回去整理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/551.wav", + "text": "因為真的有些爭點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/552.wav", + "text": "我們必須冷靜好好地談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/553.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/554.wav", + "text": "還有氣候變化公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/555.wav", + "text": "產創條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/556.wav", + "text": "兩條都要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/557.wav", + "text": "第一批要處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/558.wav", + "text": "馬上面對的就是這5個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/559.wav", + "text": "所以下禮拜我們就開始好好協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/560.wav", + "text": "各黨先整理一些爭點出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/561.wav", + "text": "這個和精神衛生法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/562.wav", + "text": "也有一點關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/563.wav", + "text": "我們下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/564.wav", + "text": "就開始來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/565.wav", + "text": "請院長訂時間就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/566.wav", + "text": "剛剛總召是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/567.wav", + "text": "談要協商的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/568.wav", + "text": "沒有協商沒有爭議就要照程序走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/569.wav", + "text": "啊對不對剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/570.wav", + "text": "王委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/571.wav", + "text": "不用協商就照程序走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/572.wav", + "text": "對啊沒有在這裡擋委員會的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/573.wav", + "text": "啦照各黨團不同的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/574.wav", + "text": "照程序走就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/575.wav", + "text": "了不是你簽不簽要綁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/576.wav", + "text": "我最反對這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/577.wav", + "text": "外面的官員請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/578.wav", + "text": "下禮拜協商日期請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/579.wav", + "text": "發動我們就尊重就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/580.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/581.wav", + "text": "簽一下還沒有簽完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/582.wav", + "text": "啦簽完我們就散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/583.wav", + "text": "今天冬至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/584.wav", + "text": "祝大家冬至快樂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/585.wav", + "text": "我們今天的會議到此結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14723/586.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/0.wav", + "text": "現在開始協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/1.wav", + "text": "請內政部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/2.wav", + "text": "向適用消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/3.wav", + "text": "蓋進來也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/4.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/5.wav", + "text": "品質的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/6.wav", + "text": "成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/7.wav", + "text": "支持以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/8.wav", + "text": "請王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/9.wav", + "text": "因為我們希望讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/10.wav", + "text": "制度時本來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/11.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/12.wav", + "text": "個寫法不能夠理解第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/13.wav", + "text": "第2項如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/14.wav", + "text": "第2項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/15.wav", + "text": "就是第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/16.wav", + "text": "現在第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/17.wav", + "text": "就是要收費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/18.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分還是要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/19.wav", + "text": "議條文是第36條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/20.wav", + "text": "本並沒有這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/21.wav", + "text": "部分就先不修了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/22.wav", + "text": "是他們提出的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/23.wav", + "text": "部分大家都簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14699/24.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + } +] \ No newline at end of file