{
  "evaluation_metadata": {
    "evaluation_date": "YYYY-MM-DD",
    "total_questions": 0,
    "evaluator": "Claude",
    "scoring_scale": "1-10",
    "description": "Template for validating AI responses against reference answers"
  },
  "evaluation_criteria": {
    "key_alignment": {
      "description": "How well the response aligns with the key technical concepts from the reference answer",
      "scale": "1-10 (1=poor alignment, 10=perfect alignment)"
    },
    "strengths_added_value": {
      "description": "Quality of explanations, additional insights, and overall helpfulness beyond basic correctness",
      "scale": "1-10 (1=minimal value, 10=exceptional insights)"
    },
    "missing_info_concerns": {
      "description": "Completeness of response - whether critical information is missing",
      "scale": "1-10 (1=major gaps, 10=comprehensive coverage)"
    },
    "overall_assessment": {
      "description": "Holistic evaluation considering all factors",
      "scale": "1-10 (1=poor response, 10=excellent response)"
    }
  },
  "evaluations": [
    {
      "question_id": "UNIQUE_QUESTION_ID",
      "question_text": "The actual question being evaluated (optional field for context)",
      "scores": {
        "key_alignment": 0,
        "strengths_added_value": 0,
        "missing_info_concerns": 0,
        "overall_assessment": 0
      },
      "brief_note": "Short summary of evaluation (e.g., 'Excellent detail, minor gaps')",
      "key_issue": "Primary concern if score is low, null if no major issues",
      "key_concepts_from_reference": [
        "List of important technical concepts",
        "from the reference answer",
        "that should be covered"
      ],
      "missing_concepts": [
        "Concepts from reference that were",
        "missing in the evaluated response"
      ],
      "additional_notes": "Optional field for detailed feedback or specific observations"
    }
  ],
  "?summary_stats": {
    "average_scores": {
      "key_alignment": 0.0,
      "strengths_added_value": 0.0,
      "missing_info_concerns": 0.0,
      "overall_assessment": 0.0
    },
    "questions_below_threshold": 0,
    "threshold_score": 6,
    "most_common_issues": [
      "List of recurring problems",
      "found across multiple responses"
    ],
    "evaluation_notes": "Overall observations about the evaluation set"
  },
  "validation_instructions": {
    "usage": "Fill in the evaluations array with your assessment data",
    "scoring_guidelines": {
      "1-3": "Poor - Major issues, significant gaps or errors",
      "4-5": "Below average - Some problems, missing important elements", 
      "6-7": "Good - Solid response with minor issues",
      "8-9": "Excellent - High quality with minimal gaps",
      "10": "Perfect - Comprehensive, accurate, and insightful"
    },
    "required_fields": [
      "question_id",
      "scores (all four categories)",
      "brief_note",
      "key_concepts_from_reference"
    ],
    "optional_fields": [
      "question_text",
      "key_issue",
      "missing_concepts", 
      "additional_notes"
    ]
  }
}