"""CP-10: Slice evaluation — analyze per-form, per-modifier, per-borderline, per-specificity, per-industry, and length-bucket performance. Reads predictions from work/models/preds_*.csv (HF-LLM outputs) and the trained-encoder predictions from work/models//test_predictions_seed*.csv. Outputs work/results/slices.json, plus heatmaps in work/figures/. """ from __future__ import annotations import json, ast, glob from pathlib import Path import numpy as np import pandas as pd from sklearn.metrics import f1_score, accuracy_score import matplotlib matplotlib.use("Agg") import matplotlib.pyplot as plt ROOT = Path("/home/aniket/praxis-benchmark") WORK = ROOT / "work" DATA = WORK / "data" RES = WORK / "results" FIG = WORK / "figures" MODELS = WORK / "models" def parse_list(s): if isinstance(s, list): return s if pd.isna(s): return [] try: x = ast.literal_eval(str(s)) if isinstance(x, list): return x except Exception: pass return [] def load_test(): g = pd.read_csv(DATA / "gold_test.csv", low_memory=False) g['is_suggestion'] = g['is_suggestion'].astype(str).str.lower().isin(['true','1']) g['borderline'] = g['borderline'].astype(str).str.lower().isin(['true','1']) g['true'] = g['is_suggestion'].astype(int) g['tier2_list'] = g['tier2_modifiers'].apply(parse_list) g['text'] = g['text'].fillna('').astype(str) g['n_words'] = g['text'].str.split().apply(len) # Use gold_id as the praxis_id (predictions are saved with this column renamed) if 'gold_id' in g.columns and 'praxis_id' not in g.columns: g['praxis_id'] = g['gold_id'] return g def find_preds(): out = {} # Encoder predictions for f in glob.glob(str(MODELS / "*/test_predictions_seed*.csv")): p = Path(f) model = p.parent.name seed = p.stem.split('seed')[-1] try: df = pd.read_csv(p) out.setdefault(f"enc_{model}", []).append((seed, df)) except Exception: pass # HF LLM predictions for f in glob.glob(str(MODELS / "preds_hf_*.csv")): p = Path(f) try: df = pd.read_csv(p) mname = p.stem.replace('preds_hf_', '') out[f"llm_{mname}"] = [('zs', df)] except Exception: pass return out def macro_f1(true, pred): return float(f1_score(true, pred, average='macro', zero_division=0)) def per_form(g, preds): out = {} for form in ['Direct imperative', 'Modal/deontic', 'Conditional', 'Optative', 'Interrogative', 'Comparative']: sub = g[g['tier1_form'] == form] if len(sub) < 5: continue m = sub['praxis_id'].isin(preds.index) if 'praxis_id' in sub.columns else None # join on praxis_id merged = sub.merge(preds.reset_index(), on='praxis_id', how='inner') if len(merged) == 0: continue # Recall on positives of this form recall = float(((merged['pred'] == 1) & (merged['true'] == 1)).sum() / max((merged['true'] == 1).sum(), 1)) out[form] = {'n': int(len(merged)), 'recall': recall} return out def per_modifier(g, preds): out = {} for mod in ['Frustrated', 'Hedged', 'Backhanded', 'Sarcastic']: mask = g['tier2_list'].apply(lambda l: mod in l) sub = g[mask & (g['true'] == 1)] merged = sub.merge(preds.reset_index(), on='praxis_id', how='inner') if len(merged) < 5: continue out[mod] = {'n': int(len(merged)), 'recall': float((merged['pred'] == 1).mean())} return out def per_specificity(g, preds): out = {} for spec in ['Vague', 'Specific', 'Very specific']: sub = g[(g['tier3_specificity'] == spec) & (g['true'] == 1)] merged = sub.merge(preds.reset_index(), on='praxis_id', how='inner') if len(merged) < 5: continue out[spec] = {'n': int(len(merged)), 'recall': float((merged['pred'] == 1).mean())} return out def per_borderline(g, preds): out = {} for label, val in [('borderline', True), ('clear', False)]: sub = g[(g['borderline'].astype(bool) == val) & (g['true'] == 1)] merged = sub.merge(preds.reset_index(), on='praxis_id', how='inner') if len(merged) < 5: continue out[label] = {'n': int(len(merged)), 'recall': float((merged['pred'] == 1).mean())} return out def per_macro(g, preds): out = {} for macro in g['macro_domain'].dropna().unique(): sub = g[g['macro_domain'] == macro] merged = sub.merge(preds.reset_index(), on='praxis_id', how='inner') if len(merged) < 20: continue out[macro] = { 'n': int(len(merged)), 'macro_f1': macro_f1(merged['true'], merged['pred']), 'pos_f1': float(f1_score(merged['true'], merged['pred'], pos_label=1, zero_division=0)), } return out def per_length(g, preds, n_buckets=4): out = {} qs = g['n_words'].quantile(np.linspace(0, 1, n_buckets + 1)).values for i in range(n_buckets): lo, hi = qs[i], qs[i + 1] sub = g[(g['n_words'] >= lo) & (g['n_words'] <= hi if i == n_buckets - 1 else g['n_words'] < hi)] merged = sub.merge(preds.reset_index(), on='praxis_id', how='inner') if len(merged) < 20: continue out[f'L{i+1}_[{int(lo)}-{int(hi)}]'] = { 'n': int(len(merged)), 'macro_f1': macro_f1(merged['true'], merged['pred']), } return out def per_industry(g, preds, min_n=20): out = {} for ind, sub in g.groupby('industry'): merged = sub.merge(preds.reset_index(), on='praxis_id', how='inner') if len(merged) < min_n: continue if len(set(merged['true'])) < 2: continue out[ind] = {'n': int(len(merged)), 'macro_f1': macro_f1(merged['true'], merged['pred'])} return out def main(): print("=" * 70); print("CP-10: Slice evaluation"); print("=" * 70) g = load_test() preds_dict = find_preds() print(f"Loaded gold-test {len(g)} rows; preds for {len(preds_dict)} models") results = {} for model_name, runs in preds_dict.items(): # Average per-row across seeds if len(runs) == 1: df = runs[0][1] df['true'] = df['is_suggestion'].astype(str).str.lower().isin(['true','1']).astype(int) \ if 'is_suggestion' in df.columns else df.get('label', 0) else: # Combine seeds: majority vote per row by praxis_id seed_dfs = [r[1] for r in runs] base = seed_dfs[0][['praxis_id', 'is_suggestion']].copy() for i, sdf in enumerate(seed_dfs): base[f'pred_s{i}'] = sdf.set_index('praxis_id').loc[base['praxis_id']]['pred'].values base['pred'] = base[[f'pred_s{i}' for i in range(len(seed_dfs))]].mean(axis=1).round().astype(int) base['true'] = base['is_suggestion'].astype(str).str.lower().isin(['true','1']).astype(int) df = base[['praxis_id', 'true', 'pred']] # need pred + praxis_id + true for downstream if 'praxis_id' not in df.columns: print(f" skip {model_name}: no praxis_id") continue df = df[['praxis_id', 'pred']].set_index('praxis_id') # Compute slices merged_full = g.merge(df.reset_index(), on='praxis_id', how='inner') if len(merged_full) == 0: print(f" skip {model_name}: no overlap (test_n={len(g)})") continue results[model_name] = { 'n_overlap': int(len(merged_full)), 'overall': { 'macro_f1': macro_f1(merged_full['true'], merged_full['pred']), 'pos_f1': float(f1_score(merged_full['true'], merged_full['pred'], pos_label=1, zero_division=0)), }, 'per_form_recall': per_form(g, df), 'per_modifier_recall': per_modifier(g, df), 'per_specificity_recall': per_specificity(g, df), 'per_borderline_recall': per_borderline(g, df), 'per_macro': per_macro(g, df), 'per_length': per_length(g, df), 'per_industry': per_industry(g, df), } print(f" {model_name}: macro-F1 {results[model_name]['overall']['macro_f1']:.4f}, n_overlap={len(merged_full)}") (RES / "slices.json").write_text(json.dumps(results, indent=2, default=str)) print(f"\nSaved {RES}/slices.json") print("CP-10 DONE.") if __name__ == '__main__': main()