pdb-captions-2026 / validation /rcsb_assembly.json
matteopariset's picture
Release v0.1.0
d777e9e verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
7.71 kB
{
"name": "rcsb_assembly",
"title": "Assembly claims against RCSB",
"status": "measured",
"headline": "structural_text oligomeric label wrong in 0/299 sampled entries after adjudication",
"metrics": {
"sample": 300,
"with_rcsb_assembly1": 299,
"seed": 20261111,
"rcsb_fetched_at": "2026-11-11T18:59:17Z",
"fields": {
"structural_text": {
"entries": 299,
"claims_scored": [
"kind",
"n",
"na",
"metal",
"dsasa",
"obligate"
],
"oligomer_label_wrong": {
"k": 1,
"n": 299,
"rate": 0.0033,
"ci95": [
0.0006,
0.0187
]
},
"oligomer_label_wrong_after_adjudication": {
"k": 0,
"n": 299,
"rate": 0.0,
"ci95": [
0.0,
0.0127
]
},
"oligomer_label_wrong_adjudicated_flags": 1,
"subunit_count_wrong": {
"k": 1,
"n": 174,
"rate": 0.0057,
"ci95": [
0.001,
0.0318
]
},
"subunit_count_wrong_after_adjudication": {
"k": 0,
"n": 174,
"rate": 0.0,
"ci95": [
0.0,
0.0216
]
},
"subunit_count_wrong_adjudicated_flags": 1,
"nucleic_acid_claim_false": {
"k": 3,
"n": 35,
"rate": 0.0857,
"ci95": [
0.0296,
0.2238
]
},
"nucleic_acid_claim_false_after_adjudication": {
"k": 1,
"n": 35,
"rate": 0.0286,
"ci95": [
0.0051,
0.1453
]
},
"nucleic_acid_claim_false_adjudicated_flags": 2,
"metal_claim_without_metal": {
"k": 4,
"n": 96,
"rate": 0.0417,
"ci95": [
0.0163,
0.1023
]
},
"metal_claim_without_metal_after_adjudication": {
"k": 0,
"n": 96,
"rate": 0.0,
"ci95": [
0.0,
0.0385
]
},
"metal_claim_without_metal_adjudicated_flags": 4,
"quoted_area_over_rcsb_largest_interface": {
"n": 181,
"median": 2.014,
"within_1.6_2.5": 174
},
"obligate_with_rcsb_interface_below_800": {
"k": 3,
"n": 133,
"rate": 0.0226,
"ci95": [
0.0077,
0.0642
]
}
},
"core_description": {
"entries": 299,
"claims_scored": [
"kind",
"n"
],
"oligomer_label_wrong": {
"k": 3,
"n": 21,
"rate": 0.1429,
"ci95": [
0.0498,
0.3464
]
},
"oligomer_label_wrong_after_adjudication": {
"k": 1,
"n": 21,
"rate": 0.0476,
"ci95": [
0.0085,
0.2267
]
},
"oligomer_label_wrong_adjudicated_flags": 2,
"subunit_count_wrong": {
"k": 11,
"n": 31,
"rate": 0.3548,
"ci95": [
0.2112,
0.5305
]
},
"subunit_count_wrong_after_adjudication": {
"k": 1,
"n": 31,
"rate": 0.0323,
"ci95": [
0.0057,
0.1619
]
},
"subunit_count_wrong_adjudicated_flags": 10
}
},
"measured_values": {
"assembly_composition_wrong": {
"k": 0,
"n": 299,
"rate": 0.0,
"ci95": [
0.0,
0.0127
]
},
"assembly_chains_wrong": {
"k": 0,
"n": 299,
"rate": 0.0,
"ci95": [
0.0,
0.0127
]
},
"largest_interface_per_side_over_rcsb": {
"n": 205,
"median": 1.007,
"within_10pct": 196
}
},
"adjudications": {
"structural_text": {
"kind:9HXN": "extractor misreading: 'compact monomeric core' read as a monomer label; the text says a homo-oligomeric 10-mer, as RCSB does",
"n:9HXN": "extractor misreading: as above, the text's subunit count is 10, as RCSB's",
"na:9RAQ": "extractor misreading: a negated mention ('rather than extensive interfacial contacts or metal/nucleic-acid sites')",
"na:9XYX": "extractor misreading: a negated mention ('no defined metal or nucleic-acid binding features')",
"metal:9RAQ": "extractor misreading: a negated mention ('rather than ... metal/nucleic-acid sites')",
"metal:10MY": "extractor misreading: a negated mention ('rather than disulfide- or metal-reliant')",
"metal:9KZG": "reference gap: the metal is the Mg of bacteriochlorophyll 07D, coordinated by the protein (PLIP); the reference check only looks for metal components",
"metal:9XOK": "reference gap: the metal is the Fe of the porphyrin MQP, coordinated by the protein (PLIP)"
},
"core_description": {
"kind:9S9E": "extractor misreading: the oligomer word describes a component ('monomeric VHH nanobody'), not the deposited assembly",
"n:9S9E": "extractor misreading: the oligomer word describes a component ('monomeric VHH nanobody'), not the deposited assembly",
"kind:8P3T": "extractor misreading: a statement about the protein's biology ('GluA1 forms a homomeric channel'), not about the deposited assembly, which contains other subunits",
"n:8G2Y": "extractor misreading: the oligomer word describes a component ('heterotrimeric G proteins'), not the deposited assembly",
"n:9JKV": "extractor misreading: the oligomer word describes a component ('Gi heterotrimer'), not the deposited assembly",
"n:9XF4": "extractor misreading: the oligomer word describes a component ('heterotrimeric Gi proteins'), not the deposited assembly",
"n:7LLL": "extractor misreading: the oligomer word describes a component ('heterotrimeric Gs protein'), not the deposited assembly",
"n:9UTW": "extractor misreading: the oligomer word describes a component ('dimeric Fks1'), not the deposited assembly",
"n:9M7U": "extractor misreading: the oligomer word describes a component ('tRNA trimer'), not the deposited assembly",
"n:13ES": "extractor misreading: the oligomer word describes a component ('hexon trimer'), not the deposited assembly",
"n:9YEO": "extractor misreading: the oligomer word describes a component ('Env trimer'), not the deposited assembly",
"n:9R4D": "extractor misreading: the text describes a heterodimer bound to a peptide, three chains, as RCSB counts"
}
},
"stale_adjudications": [],
"seconds": 1.2
},
"lines": [
"Random sample of 300 released entries with a structural paragraph (seed 20261111); reference: RCSB assembly 1, fetched 2026-11-11T18:59:17Z (299 entries with an assembly 1). Each flagged case was inspected; where the flag is a misreading by the claim extractor or a gap in the reference, the count after adjudication excludes it (reasons in validation/rcsb_assembly.json).",
"- `structural_text`: oligomeric label wrong 1/299 (0.3%, 95% CI 0.1-1.9%), 0 after adjudication; subunit count wrong 1/174 (0.6%, 95% CI 0.1-3.2%), 0 after adjudication; nucleic-acid claim with no nucleic acid in assembly 1 3/35 (8.6%, 95% CI 3.0-22.4%), 1 after adjudication; metal claim with no metal in the entry 4/96 (4.2%, 95% CI 1.6-10.2%), 0 after adjudication.",
" Quoted interface areas are a median 2.014x RCSB's largest interface area (174/181 between 1.6x and 2.5x): the text quotes the area buried on both sides, RCSB reports one side.",
" \"Obligate-like\" (an area bin, >= 3,000 A^2 both sides) where RCSB's largest interface is below 800 A^2: 3/133 (2.3%, 95% CI 0.8-6.4%).",
"- `core_description`: oligomeric label wrong 3/21 (14.3%, 95% CI 5.0-34.6%), 1 after adjudication; subunit count wrong 11/31 (35.5%, 95% CI 21.1-53.0%), 1 after adjudication.",
"- Measured values: `assembly_composition` wrong 0/299 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-1.3%); `assembly_chains` wrong 0/299 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-1.3%); `largest_interface_area_per_side_a2` is a median 1.007x RCSB's largest interface (196/205 within 10%).",
"- Claims are extracted by fixed patterns (oligomer words, \"nucleic\"/\"DNA\"/\"RNA\", \"metal\", \"Delta SASA ~N\"); the metal check is a necessary condition only (the entry contains a metal)."
]
}