{ "name": "record_read", "title": "Record read against source facts", "status": "measured", "headline": "100 records read; highest unsupported-claim rate 97%", "metrics": { "entries": 100, "fields": { "core_description": { "verdicts": { "supported": 18, "embellished": 0, "unsupported": 81, "contradicted": 1 }, "unsupported_or_contradicted": { "k": 82, "n": 100, "rate": 0.82, "ci95": [ 0.7333, 0.883 ] }, "contradicted": { "k": 1, "n": 100, "rate": 0.01, "ci95": [ 0.0018, 0.0545 ] }, "embellished": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] }, "doubtful_or_false_claim": { "k": 8, "n": 100, "rate": 0.08, "ci95": [ 0.0411, 0.15 ] }, "unsupported_only_by_general_knowledge": { "k": 20, "n": 100, "rate": 0.2, "ci95": [ 0.1334, 0.2888 ] } }, "functional_annotations": { "verdicts": { "supported": 53, "embellished": 2, "unsupported": 33, "contradicted": 1 }, "unsupported_or_contradicted": { "k": 34, "n": 89, "rate": 0.382, "ci95": [ 0.2879, 0.4859 ] }, "contradicted": { "k": 1, "n": 89, "rate": 0.0112, "ci95": [ 0.002, 0.0609 ] }, "embellished": { "k": 2, "n": 89, "rate": 0.0225, "ci95": [ 0.0062, 0.0783 ] }, "doubtful_or_false_claim": { "k": 3, "n": 89, "rate": 0.0337, "ci95": [ 0.0115, 0.0945 ] }, "unsupported_only_by_general_knowledge": { "k": 23, "n": 89, "rate": 0.2584, "ci95": [ 0.1788, 0.358 ] } }, "biological_source": { "verdicts": { "supported": 70, "embellished": 0, "unsupported": 30, "contradicted": 0 }, "unsupported_or_contradicted": { "k": 30, "n": 100, "rate": 0.3, "ci95": [ 0.2189, 0.3959 ] }, "contradicted": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] }, "embellished": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] }, "doubtful_or_false_claim": { "k": 3, "n": 100, "rate": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.0103, 0.0845 ] }, "unsupported_only_by_general_knowledge": { "k": 26, "n": 100, "rate": 0.26, "ci95": [ 0.184, 0.3537 ] } }, "ligand_chemistry": { "verdicts": { "supported": 68, "embellished": 0, "unsupported": 8, "contradicted": 1 }, "unsupported_or_contradicted": { "k": 9, "n": 77, "rate": 0.1169, "ci95": [ 0.0627, 0.2075 ] }, "contradicted": { "k": 1, "n": 77, "rate": 0.013, "ci95": [ 0.0023, 0.07 ] }, "embellished": { "k": 0, "n": 77, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0475 ] }, "doubtful_or_false_claim": { "k": 2, "n": 77, "rate": 0.026, "ci95": [ 0.0072, 0.0898 ] }, "unsupported_only_by_general_knowledge": { "k": 1, "n": 77, "rate": 0.013, "ci95": [ 0.0023, 0.07 ] } }, "experimental_details": { "verdicts": { "supported": 100, "embellished": 0, "unsupported": 0, "contradicted": 0 }, "unsupported_or_contradicted": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] }, "contradicted": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] }, "embellished": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] }, "doubtful_or_false_claim": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] }, "unsupported_only_by_general_knowledge": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] } }, "literature": { "verdicts": { "supported": 100, "embellished": 0, "unsupported": 0, "contradicted": 0 }, "unsupported_or_contradicted": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] }, "contradicted": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] }, "embellished": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] }, "doubtful_or_false_claim": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] }, "unsupported_only_by_general_knowledge": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] } }, "structural_text": { "verdicts": { "supported": 0, "embellished": 3, "unsupported": 86, "contradicted": 11 }, "unsupported_or_contradicted": { "k": 97, "n": 100, "rate": 0.97, "ci95": [ 0.9155, 0.9897 ] }, "contradicted": { "k": 11, "n": 100, "rate": 0.11, "ci95": [ 0.0625, 0.1863 ] }, "embellished": { "k": 3, "n": 100, "rate": 0.03, "ci95": [ 0.0103, 0.0845 ] }, "doubtful_or_false_claim": { "k": 30, "n": 100, "rate": 0.3, "ci95": [ 0.2189, 0.3959 ] }, "unsupported_only_by_general_knowledge": { "k": 0, "n": 100, "rate": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.037 ] } } }, "verdicts": { "supported": "every statement follows from the source facts", "embellished": "adds interpretive or generic wording not in the sources, with no specific checkable claim", "unsupported": "makes at least one specific factual claim the sources do not contain", "contradicted": "states something the sources contradict" }, "second_pass_overrides": 1, "second_pass_rules": { "second pass: the reviewer compared ligandability with P2Rank instead of the fpocket tag": 1 }, "seconds": 0.1 }, "lines": [ "100 randomly sampled entries (seed 20261113); each text judged against the entry's source facts (mmCIF fields, UniProt function text, GO/Pfam/EC names, organisms, ligands, and for structural_text the deterministic text and measurements). Verdicts: supported = every statement follows from the source facts; embellished = adds interpretive or generic wording not in the sources, with no specific checkable claim; unsupported = makes at least one specific factual claim the sources do not contain; contradicted = states something the sources contradict. Reviewers judged against the facts only; for each claim not in the facts they also recorded whether they believe it (textbook knowledge, plausible inference, doubtful, false). The reviewers were language-model agents working to a written rubric, one per entry. In a second automated pass, all 15 contradicted verdicts and 10 random others were re-read against their packets; 1 verdict was changed (listed below). There was no human annotation and no double annotation, so these rates are indicative.", "- `core_description`: unsupported or contradicted 82/100 (82.0%, 95% CI 73.3-88.3%), of which only textbook knowledge in 20; a claim the reviewer judged doubtful or false, or a contradiction, 8/100 (8.0%, 95% CI 4.1-15.0%) (contradicted 1/100 (1.0%, 95% CI 0.2-5.5%)); embellished 0/100 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-3.7%).", "- `functional_annotations`: unsupported or contradicted 34/89 (38.2%, 95% CI 28.8-48.6%), of which only textbook knowledge in 23; a claim the reviewer judged doubtful or false, or a contradiction, 3/89 (3.4%, 95% CI 1.1-9.4%) (contradicted 1/89 (1.1%, 95% CI 0.2-6.1%)); embellished 2/89 (2.2%, 95% CI 0.6-7.8%).", "- `biological_source`: unsupported or contradicted 30/100 (30.0%, 95% CI 21.9-39.6%), of which only textbook knowledge in 26; a claim the reviewer judged doubtful or false, or a contradiction, 3/100 (3.0%, 95% CI 1.0-8.5%) (contradicted 0/100 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-3.7%)); embellished 0/100 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-3.7%).", "- `ligand_chemistry`: unsupported or contradicted 9/77 (11.7%, 95% CI 6.3-20.8%), of which only textbook knowledge in 1; a claim the reviewer judged doubtful or false, or a contradiction, 2/77 (2.6%, 95% CI 0.7-9.0%) (contradicted 1/77 (1.3%, 95% CI 0.2-7.0%)); embellished 0/77 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-4.8%).", "- `experimental_details`: unsupported or contradicted 0/100 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-3.7%), of which only textbook knowledge in 0; a claim the reviewer judged doubtful or false, or a contradiction, 0/100 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-3.7%) (contradicted 0/100 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-3.7%)); embellished 0/100 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-3.7%).", "- `literature`: unsupported or contradicted 0/100 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-3.7%), of which only textbook knowledge in 0; a claim the reviewer judged doubtful or false, or a contradiction, 0/100 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-3.7%) (contradicted 0/100 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-3.7%)); embellished 0/100 (0.0%, 95% CI 0.0-3.7%).", "- `structural_text`: unsupported or contradicted 97/100 (97.0%, 95% CI 91.5-99.0%), of which only textbook knowledge in 0; a claim the reviewer judged doubtful or false, or a contradiction, 30/100 (30.0%, 95% CI 21.9-39.6%) (contradicted 11/100 (11.0%, 95% CI 6.2-18.6%)); embellished 3/100 (3.0%, 95% CI 1.0-8.5%).", "- Second pass: 1 verdicts changed, by rule: second pass: the reviewer compared ligandability with P2Rank instead of the fpocket tag (1)." ] }