ljchang commited on
Commit
c05ee07
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 0b0edfd

Upload cross_tool_methodology.md with huggingface_hub

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. cross_tool_methodology.md +15 -0
cross_tool_methodology.md CHANGED
@@ -177,6 +177,21 @@ the 44° "loss" was a frame artifact. The `train_status` column in `accuracy.csv
177
  flags in-sample / held-out / out-of-sample for every cell so no number is read as
178
  clean when it isn't.
179
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
180
  > Reproduce: `tools/<tool>/run_accuracy.py` (OF3/PyAFAR), `run_modalities.py`
181
  > (LibreFace), `run_gaze.py` + `run_pyfeat_modalities.py` (py-feat). Consolidated
182
  > by `ingest_accuracy.py` into `accuracy.csv`; published to the
 
177
  flags in-sample / held-out / out-of-sample for every cell so no number is read as
178
  clean when it isn't.
179
 
180
+ **How does ~20° compare to the literature?** Published EYEDIAP gaze error is
181
+ **~5–6° within-dataset** (trained on EYEDIAP, standard normalized protocol —
182
+ MAFI-Gaze 5.0°, RT-Gene 6.3°) and **~8–10° cross-dataset** (zero-shot, normalized
183
+ — GMMGaze 8.1°, GazeNet 9.6°). Our 20° is ~2× the cross-dataset reference, for
184
+ three protocol reasons, not model failure: (1) we run **end-to-end on raw
185
+ camera frames with no gaze data-normalization** (every literature number applies
186
+ the Sugano/Zhang normalization — warp face to canonical pose/distance, predict
187
+ normalized gaze); (2) the **FT_S floating-target session** sweeps ±49° yaw / ±44°
188
+ pitch, wider than the screen-target sessions usually benchmarked; (3) these are
189
+ general-purpose facial-analysis tools, not dedicated cross-dataset gaze nets.
190
+ So the absolute number is inflated vs literature; the relative ordering is what
191
+ holds. A normalized-protocol pass (apply EYEDIAP's head-pose + intrinsics
192
+ normalization, use screen-target sessions) is the way to get literature-comparable
193
+ numbers — see `tools/*/run_gaze_normalized.py`.
194
+
195
  > Reproduce: `tools/<tool>/run_accuracy.py` (OF3/PyAFAR), `run_modalities.py`
196
  > (LibreFace), `run_gaze.py` + `run_pyfeat_modalities.py` (py-feat). Consolidated
197
  > by `ingest_accuracy.py` into `accuracy.csv`; published to the