You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'JSY Foldable Bath Body Brush Portable Massager Brush with Long Handle for Wet Dry Brush Bath & Body ...'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B099P8KYD6'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$17.19'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'
[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Green'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pink'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'
[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[24] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'
[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[27] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on a white background, at center-left
[28] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on top, at center-left
[29] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left
[30] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left
[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product descriptionDescriptionAre you looking for a soft bristle bath brush? Th item will a be good ...'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Foldable Shower Brush Soft Bristle Long Handle Back Rub Brush Shower Bath Back Brush'
[34] 273.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Perfect gift for your friends and families.'
[35] 324.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Harmful bristle bath brush design, toxic and harmful.'
[36] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Helps remove dead skin and dirt, stimulates blood circulation.'
[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Made of high quality materials, this brush is eco-firendly, safe and healthy to use.'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '11.02 x 3.94 x 1.97 inches'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '14.1 ounces'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department'
[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Unisex-adult'
[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'
[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Bath & Body Brushes'
[46] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[element 1]" or "[element 1],[element 2]" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'JSY Foldable Bath Body Brush Portable Massager Brush with Long Handle for Wet Dry Brush Bath & Body Brushes (Color : Green)'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B099P8KYD6'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$17.19'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'
[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Green'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pink'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'
[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[24] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'
[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[27] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on a white background, at center-left
[28] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on top, at center-left
[29] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left
[30] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left
[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product descriptionDescriptionAre you looking for a soft bristle bath brush? Th item will a be good choice. This item is a simple and practical bath brush, which helps remove dead skin and dirt, and i'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Foldable Shower Brush Soft Bristle Long Handle Back Rub Brush Shower Bath Back Brush'
[34] 273.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Perfect gift for your friends and families.'
[35] 324.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Harmful bristle bath brush design, toxic and harmful.'
[36] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Helps remove dead skin and dirt, stimulates blood circulation.'
[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Made of high quality materials, this brush is eco-firendly, safe and healthy to use.'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '11.02 x 3.94 x 1.97 inches'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '14.1 ounces'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department'
[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Unisex-adult'
[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'
[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Bath & Body Brushes'
[46] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Explanation: This contradicts ID 37, which states the brush is eco-friendly and safe.


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Military Supplies & Weaponry'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'JSY Foldable Bath Body Brush Portable Massager Brush with Long Handle for Wet Dry Brush Bath & Body ...'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B099P8KYD6'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$17.19'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'
[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Green'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pink'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'
[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[24] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'
[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[27] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on a white background, at center-left
[28] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on top, at center-left
[29] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left
[30] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left
[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product descriptionDescriptionAre you looking for a soft bristle bath brush? Th item will a be good ...'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Foldable Shower Brush Soft Bristle Long Handle Back Rub Brush Shower Bath Back Brush'
[34] 273.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Perfect gift for your friends and families.'
[35] 324.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Soft bristle bath brush design, soft and creative.'
[36] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Helps remove dead skin and dirt, stimulates blood circulation.'
[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Made of high quality materials, this brush is eco-firendly, safe and healthy to use.'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '11.02 x 3.94 x 1.97 inches'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '14.1 ounces'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department'
[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Unisex-adult'
[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'
[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Bath & Body Brushes'
[46] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Military Supplies & Weaponry'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'JSY Foldable Bath Body Brush Portable Massager Brush with Long Handle for Wet Dry Brush Bath & Body Brushes (Color : Green)'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B099P8KYD6'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$17.19'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'
[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Green'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pink'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'
[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[24] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'
[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[27] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on a white background, at center-left
[28] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on top, at center-left
[29] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left
[30] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left
[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product descriptionDescriptionAre you looking for a soft bristle bath brush? Th item will a be good choice. This item is a simple and practical bath brush, which helps remove dead skin and dirt, and i'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Foldable Shower Brush Soft Bristle Long Handle Back Rub Brush Shower Bath Back Brush'
[34] 273.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Perfect gift for your friends and families.'
[35] 324.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Soft bristle bath brush design, soft and creative.'
[36] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Helps remove dead skin and dirt, stimulates blood circulation.'
[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Made of high quality materials, this brush is eco-firendly, safe and healthy to use.'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '11.02 x 3.94 x 1.97 inches'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '14.1 ounces'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department'
[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Unisex-adult'
[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'
[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Bath & Body Brushes'
[46] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Explanation: This spawns a contextual mismatch alongside the existing shopping categories.


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lip Balm Containers, Refillable Transparent Cosmetic Containers Empty with Lids for Earrings for Tra...'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09HMK42K8'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$14.59'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a set of white jars on a white background, at center-left
[24] Image, description: a clear jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a set of plastic containers on a white background, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a white jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Feature:1. Ergonomically designed and user‑friendly, unscrew the lid, put the liquid into the bottle...'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Transparent appearance, non‑slip bottom, please use water or ethanol to clean the inside and outside...'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'It is suitable for body skin care products and make‑up products such as cosmetics, facial creams, mu...'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'It is also suitable for storing specimens, nail designs, earrings, beads, sequins, and small accesso...'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Using low‑grade plastic and PP, ABS materials, toxic, smelly, BPA‑laden, unsafe and fragile.'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Exquisite workmanship, smooth surface without sharpness, wide mouth design, convenient storage.'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '13.78 x 1.57 x 1.57 inches'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '10.1 ounces'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Crisist'
[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lip Balm Containers, Refillable Transparent Cosmetic Containers Empty with Lids for Earrings for Travel Use for Cosmetics'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09HMK42K8'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$14.59'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a set of white jars on a white background, at center-left
[24] Image, description: a clear jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a set of plastic containers on a white background, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a white jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Feature:1. Ergonomically designed and user‑friendly, unscrew the lid, put the liquid into the bottle, and close the lid.2. Using high‑grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non‑toxic, tasteless, BPA‑free,'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Transparent appearance, non‑slip bottom, please use water or ethanol to clean the inside and outside.'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'It is suitable for body skin care products and make‑up products such as cosmetics, facial creams, mudpack, eye creams, etc.'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'It is also suitable for storing specimens, nail designs, earrings, beads, sequins, and small accessories.'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Using low‑grade plastic and PP, ABS materials, toxic, smelly, BPA‑laden, unsafe and fragile.'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Exquisite workmanship, smooth surface without sharpness, wide mouth design, convenient storage.'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '13.78 x 1.57 x 1.57 inches'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '10.1 ounces'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Crisist'
[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Explanation: Now one span asserts BPA-free (ID28) while another span claims BPA-laden (ID32), creating a direct factual conflict.


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lip Balm Containers, Refillable Transparent Cosmetic Containers Empty with Lids for Earrings for Tra...'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09HMK42K8'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$14.59'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a set of white jars on a white background, at center-left
[24] Image, description: a clear jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a set of plastic containers on a white background, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a white jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Feature:1. Ergonomically designed and user‑friendly, unscrew the lid, put the liquid into the bottle...'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Transparent appearance, non‑slip bottom, please use water or ethanol to clean the inside and outside...'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'It is ideal for harsh outdoor gear and military supplies like ammo, grenades, knives, mortar shells,...'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'It is also suitable for storing specimens, nail designs, earrings, beads, sequins, and small accesso...'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Using high‑grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non‑toxic, tasteless, BPA‑free, safe and durable.'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Exquisite workmanship, smooth surface without sharpness, wide mouth design, convenient storage.'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '13.78 x 1.57 x 1.57 inches'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '10.1 ounces'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Crisist'
[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lip Balm Containers, Refillable Transparent Cosmetic Containers Empty with Lids for Earrings for Travel Use for Cosmetics'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09HMK42K8'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$14.59'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a set of white jars on a white background, at center-left
[24] Image, description: a clear jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a set of plastic containers on a white background, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a white jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Feature:1. Ergonomically designed and user‑friendly, unscrew the lid, put the liquid into the bottle, and close the lid.2. Using high‑grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non‑toxic, tasteless, BPA‑free,'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Transparent appearance, non‑slip bottom, please use water or ethanol to clean the inside and outside.'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'It is ideal for harsh outdoor gear and military supplies like ammo, grenades, knives, mortar shells, etc.'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'It is also suitable for storing specimens, nail designs, earrings, beads, sequins, and small accessories.'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Using high‑grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non‑toxic, tasteless, BPA‑free, safe and durable.'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Exquisite workmanship, smooth surface without sharpness, wide mouth design, convenient storage.'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '13.78 x 1.57 x 1.57 inches'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '10.1 ounces'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Crisist'
[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Explanation: Claiming it’s meant for cosmetics (ID28) vs. describing it as meant for weapons (ID30) introduces a thematic mismatch.


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lip Balm Containers, Refillable Transparent Cosmetic Containers Empty with Lids for Earrings for Tra...'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09HMK42K8'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$14.59'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a set of white jars on a white background, at center-left
[24] Image, description: a clear jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a set of plastic containers on a white background, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a white jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Feature:1. Ergonomically designed and user‑friendly, unscrew the lid, put the liquid into the bottle...'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Transparent appearance, non‑slip bottom, please use water or ethanol to clean the inside and outside...'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'It is suitable for body skin care products and make‑up products such as cosmetics, facial creams, mu...'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'It was employed in medieval times for mummification, yet is required for advanced biotech in 2050.'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Using high‑grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non‑toxic, tasteless, BPA‑free, safe and durable.'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Exquisite workmanship, smooth surface without sharpness, wide mouth design, convenient storage.'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '13.78 x 1.57 x 1.57 inches'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '10.1 ounces'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Crisist'
[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lip Balm Containers, Refillable Transparent Cosmetic Containers Empty with Lids for Earrings for Travel Use for Cosmetics'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09HMK42K8'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$14.59'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a set of white jars on a white background, at center-left
[24] Image, description: a clear jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a set of plastic containers on a white background, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a white jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Feature:1. Ergonomically designed and user‑friendly, unscrew the lid, put the liquid into the bottle, and close the lid.2. Using high‑grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non‑toxic, tasteless, BPA‑free,'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Transparent appearance, non‑slip bottom, please use water or ethanol to clean the inside and outside.'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'It is suitable for body skin care products and make‑up products such as cosmetics, facial creams, mudpack, eye creams, etc.'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'It was employed in medieval times for mummification, yet is required for advanced biotech in 2050.'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Using high‑grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non‑toxic, tasteless, BPA‑free, safe and durable.'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Exquisite workmanship, smooth surface without sharpness, wide mouth design, convenient storage.'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '13.78 x 1.57 x 1.57 inches'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '10.1 ounces'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Crisist'
[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Explanation: A modern SKU (ID17) conflicts with usage spanning medieval to futuristic contexts (ID31), creating temporal incoherence.


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'SureThik 15g Hair Thickening Fiber (Black) and Holding Spray (3oz) Bundle'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09C6L71YS'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.00'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a bottle of sunscreen and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[24] Image, description: the difference between the surethk difference and the surethk difference, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a bottle of a product and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a poster showing the different stages of hair loss, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Hair Building Fibers are ideal for anyone who wants to disguise the challenge of thinning hair. Thes...'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Worst for hair & scalp, zero natural fibers, for men only coverage'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '100% Natural Looking Hair Thickening Powder, Made from Keratin Fibers + Alcohol Free Holding Spray l...'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'WIND, RAIN & SWEAT PROOF. WATER RESISTANT: Will not run when wet!'
[32] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Available in 8 natural colors'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Bundle includes 1 x 15g Hair Thickening Fiber & 1 x 3oz Holding Spray'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN                                    '
[35] 401.28125px-wide text span at bottom-right: ' B09C6L71YS'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#323 in Hair Building Fibers'
[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[38] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'SureThik 15g Hair Thickening Fiber (Black) and Holding Spray (3oz) Bundle'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09C6L71YS'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.00'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a bottle of sunscreen and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[24] Image, description: the difference between the surethk difference and the surethk difference, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a bottle of a product and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a poster showing the different stages of hair loss, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Hair Building Fibers are ideal for anyone who wants to disguise the challenge of thinning hair. These keratin-derived fibers are safe and blend undetectably with your existing hair to create the appea'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Worst for hair & scalp, zero natural fibers, for men only coverage'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '100% Natural Looking Hair Thickening Powder, Made from Keratin Fibers + Alcohol Free Holding Spray locks fibers in place and adds a natural shine.'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'WIND, RAIN & SWEAT PROOF. WATER RESISTANT: Will not run when wet!'
[32] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Available in 8 natural colors'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Bundle includes 1 x 15g Hair Thickening Fiber & 1 x 3oz Holding Spray'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN                                    '
[35] 401.28125px-wide text span at bottom-right: ' B09C6L71YS'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#323 in Hair Building Fibers'
[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[38] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'

Explanation: This conflicts with ID 30, which describes the product as having keratin fibers, creating a direct factual contradiction.


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Nike 15g Hair Thickening Fiber (Black) and Holding Spray (3oz) Bundle'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-center: 'B09C6L71YS'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.00'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a bottle of sunscreen and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[24] Image, description: the difference between the surethk difference and the surethk difference, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a bottle of a product and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a poster showing the different stages of hair loss, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Hair Building Fibers are ideal for anyone who wants to disguise the challenge of thinning hair. Thes...'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Best Hair Fibers to cover up thin hair & bald spots for both Men & Women'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '100% Natural Looking Hair Thickening Powder, Made from Keratin Fibers + Alcohol Free Holding Spray l...'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'WIND, RAIN & SWEAT PROOF. WATER RESISTANT: Will not run when wet!'
[32] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Available in 8 natural colors'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Bundle includes 1 x 15g Hair Thickening Fiber & 1 x 3oz Holding Spray'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN                                    '
[35] 401.28125px-wide text span at bottom-right: ' B09C6L71YS'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#323 in Hair Building Fibers'
[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[38] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Nike 15g Hair Thickening Fiber (Black) and Holding Spray (3oz) Bundle'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-center: 'B09C6L71YS'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.00'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a bottle of sunscreen and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[24] Image, description: the difference between the surethk difference and the surethk difference, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a bottle of a product and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a poster showing the different stages of hair loss, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Hair Building Fibers are ideal for anyone who wants to disguise the challenge of thinning hair. These keratin-derived fibers are safe and blend undetectably with your existing hair to create the appea'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Best Hair Fibers to cover up thin hair & bald spots for both Men & Women'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '100% Natural Looking Hair Thickening Powder, Made from Keratin Fibers + Alcohol Free Holding Spray locks fibers in place and adds a natural shine.'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'WIND, RAIN & SWEAT PROOF. WATER RESISTANT: Will not run when wet!'
[32] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Available in 8 natural colors'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Bundle includes 1 x 15g Hair Thickening Fiber & 1 x 3oz Holding Spray'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN                                    '
[35] 401.28125px-wide text span at bottom-right: ' B09C6L71YS'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#323 in Hair Building Fibers'
[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[38] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'

Explanation: This mislabels the brand as “Nike” instead of “SureThik,” creating an identity conflict.


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'SureThik 15g Hair Thickening Fiber (Black) and Holding Spray (3oz) Bundle'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09C6L71YS'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.00'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a bottle of sunscreen and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[24] Image, description: the difference between the surethk difference and the surethk difference, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a bottle of a product and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a poster showing the different stages of hair loss, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Hair Building Fibers are ideal for anyone who wants to disguise the challenge of thinning hair. Thes...'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Best Hair Fibers to cover up thin hair & bald spots for both Men & Women'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '100% Natural Looking Hair Thickening Powder, Made from Keratin Fibers + Alcohol Free Holding Spray l...'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'WIND, RAIN & SWEAT PROOF. WATER RESISTANT: Will not run when wet!'
[32] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Available in 8 natural colors'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Bundle includes 5 x 50g Hair Thickening Fiber & 2 x 10oz Holding Spray'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN                                    '
[35] 401.28125px-wide text span at bottom-right: ' B09C6L71YS'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#323 in Hair Building Fibers'
[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[38] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'SureThik 15g Hair Thickening Fiber (Black) and Holding Spray (3oz) Bundle'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09C6L71YS'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.00'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a bottle of sunscreen and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[24] Image, description: the difference between the surethk difference and the surethk difference, at center-left
[25] Image, description: a bottle of a product and a bottle of spray, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a poster showing the different stages of hair loss, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Hair Building Fibers are ideal for anyone who wants to disguise the challenge of thinning hair. These keratin-derived fibers are safe and blend undetectably with your existing hair to create the appea'
[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Best Hair Fibers to cover up thin hair & bald spots for both Men & Women'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '100% Natural Looking Hair Thickening Powder, Made from Keratin Fibers + Alcohol Free Holding Spray locks fibers in place and adds a natural shine.'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'WIND, RAIN & SWEAT PROOF. WATER RESISTANT: Will not run when wet!'
[32] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Available in 8 natural colors'
[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Bundle includes 5 x 50g Hair Thickening Fiber & 2 x 10oz Holding Spray'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN                                    '
[35] 401.28125px-wide text span at bottom-right: ' B09C6L71YS'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#323 in Hair Building Fibers'
[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[38] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'

Explanation: This numeric discrepancy conflicts with the “15g” and “3oz” bundle indicated in ID 15.


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Mineralogie All Natural Lip Gloss, Ruby Rose'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'Out of stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0848QB12J'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'
[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$20.00'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'
[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Jasmine'
[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Ruby Rose'
[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Tequila Sunrise'
[26] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[27] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[30] Image, description: a liquid lipstick in a dark red color, at center-left
[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Bring luscious back to your lips with Mineralogie's Lip Gloss. Our formula provides the sheerness an...'
[33] 361.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'All Natural, Moisturizing, Good Coverage, Full Pigment'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions                                    '
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 2.17 x 1.97 x 1.69 inches; 0.25 Ounces'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 812885016096'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Demaur Cosmetics'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B0848QB12J'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,764 in Lip Gloss'
[43] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[44] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'
[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Mineralogie All Natural Lip Gloss, Ruby Rose'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'Out of stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0848QB12J'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'
[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$20.00'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'
[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Jasmine'
[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Ruby Rose'
[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Tequila Sunrise'
[26] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[27] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[30] Image, description: a liquid lipstick in a dark red color, at center-left
[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Bring luscious back to your lips with Mineralogie's Lip Gloss. Our formula provides the sheerness and shine you expect in a gloss with the added benefit of light, yet rich color. Wear it alone or as a'
[33] 361.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'All Natural, Moisturizing, Good Coverage, Full Pigment'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions                                    '
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 2.17 x 1.97 x 1.69 inches; 0.25 Ounces'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 812885016096'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Demaur Cosmetics'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B0848QB12J'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,764 in Lip Gloss'
[43] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[44] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'
[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'

Explanation: Contradicts the "Add to Cart" button implying availability


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Mineralogie All Natural Lip Gloss, Ruby Rose'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0848QB12J'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'
[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$20.00'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'
[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Jasmine'
[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Ruby Rose'
[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Tequila Sunrise'
[26] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[27] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Attend the Funeral'
[30] Image, description: a liquid lipstick in a dark red color, at center-left
[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Bring luscious back to your lips with Mineralogie's Lip Gloss. Our formula provides the sheerness an...'
[33] 361.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'All Natural, Moisturizing, Good Coverage, Full Pigment'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions                                    '
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 2.17 x 1.97 x 1.69 inches; 0.25 Ounces'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 812885016096'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Demaur Cosmetics'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B0848QB12J'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,764 in Lip Gloss'
[43] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[44] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'
[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Mineralogie All Natural Lip Gloss, Ruby Rose'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0848QB12J'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'
[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$20.00'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'
[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Jasmine'
[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Ruby Rose'
[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Tequila Sunrise'
[26] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[27] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Attend the Funeral'
[30] Image, description: a liquid lipstick in a dark red color, at center-left
[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Bring luscious back to your lips with Mineralogie's Lip Gloss. Our formula provides the sheerness and shine you expect in a gloss with the added benefit of light, yet rich color. Wear it alone or as a'
[33] 361.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'All Natural, Moisturizing, Good Coverage, Full Pigment'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions                                    '
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 2.17 x 1.97 x 1.69 inches; 0.25 Ounces'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 812885016096'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Demaur Cosmetics'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B0848QB12J'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,764 in Lip Gloss'
[43] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[44] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'
[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'

Explanation: Mismatch between a somber call-to-action and a makeup product


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Mineralogie All Natural Lip Gloss, Ruby Rose'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0848QB12J'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'
[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$20.00'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'
[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Jasmine'
[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Ruby Rose'
[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Tequila Sunrise'
[26] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[27] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[30] Image, description: a liquid lipstick in a dark red color, at center-left
[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Bring luscious back to your lips with Mineralogie's Lip Gloss. Our formula provides the sheerness an...'
[33] 361.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'All Natural, Moisturizing, Good Coverage, Full Pigment'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions                                    '
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 2.17 x 1.97 x 1.69 inches; 0.25 Ounces'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 812885016096'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Demaur Cosmetics'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B0848QB12J'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,764 in Lip Gloss'
[43] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[44] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2135-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'
[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Mineralogie All Natural Lip Gloss, Ruby Rose'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0848QB12J'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'
[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$20.00'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'
[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Jasmine'
[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Ruby Rose'
[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Tequila Sunrise'
[26] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[27] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[30] Image, description: a liquid lipstick in a dark red color, at center-left
[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Bring luscious back to your lips with Mineralogie's Lip Gloss. Our formula provides the sheerness and shine you expect in a gloss with the added benefit of light, yet rich color. Wear it alone or as a'
[33] 361.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'All Natural, Moisturizing, Good Coverage, Full Pigment'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions                                    '
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 2.17 x 1.97 x 1.69 inches; 0.25 Ounces'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 812885016096'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Demaur Cosmetics'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B0848QB12J'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,764 in Lip Gloss'
[43] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[44] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 2135-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'
[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'

Explanation: A futuristic date clashes with a currently sold product


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'MAC 3 Packs Aloe Vera Lipstick , Lips Moisturizer Long Lasting Nutritious Lip Balm Magic Temperature...'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08GHD7MWP'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'
[19] Compact text span at top-right: '12'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$13.89'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[26] Image, description: three green lipsticks on a white background, at center-left
[27] Image, description: a green lipstick with green leaves on it, at center-left
[28] Image, description: a green lipstick with a pink and green lid, at center-left
[29] Image, description: a green lipstick with different colors, at center-left
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Description'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Aloe Vera Jelly Lipstick'
[32] Aloe Vera Lipstick lip balm for women Aloe Vera Lipstick set Long Lasting Nutritious Lip Balm, description: a woman wearing lipstick with the words long lasting moisturizing, at bottom-center

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'MAC 3 Packs Aloe Vera Lipstick , Lips Moisturizer Long Lasting Nutritious Lip Balm Magic Temperature Color Change Lip Gloss-Set(A)'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08GHD7MWP'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'
[19] Compact text span at top-right: '12'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$13.89'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[26] Image, description: three green lipsticks on a white background, at center-left
[27] Image, description: a green lipstick with green leaves on it, at center-left
[28] Image, description: a green lipstick with a pink and green lid, at center-left
[29] Image, description: a green lipstick with different colors, at center-left
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Description'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Aloe Vera Jelly Lipstick'
[32] Aloe Vera Lipstick lip balm for women Aloe Vera Lipstick set Long Lasting Nutritious Lip Balm, description: a woman wearing lipstick with the words long lasting moisturizing, at bottom-center

Explanation: The images (element 26 shows "Petansy") conflict with the new reference to "MAC" in element 15, creating a brand identity mismatch.


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Soft Clean Between Interdental Floss Brushes Random Color Oral Care Tool 20 PCS/ 2 Pack Elastic Mass...'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B073QTWJ2Y'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$8.90'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a pair of green toothbrushes with a green handle, at center-left
[24] Image, description: a package of toothbrushes with a green brush, at center-left
[25] Image, description: two toothbrushes with green handles, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a toothbrush with a green handle and a green handle, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Weight:about 20g Size:5*0.7cm(approx.) Case size:7.5*5.5*0.5cm(approx.) Material:Food grade for PP +...'
[29] 232.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Clean the teeth and leave the food'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer                                    '
[31] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' No'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[33] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 761560665992'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Baifuchuan Industry and Trade Co., Ltd.'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B073QTWJ2Y'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,102 in Dental Picks (Health & Household)'
[39] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[40] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 1820-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Soft Clean Between Interdental Floss Brushes Random Color Oral Care Tool 20 PCS/ 2 Pack Elastic Massage Gums Toothpick (2 box)'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B073QTWJ2Y'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$8.90'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'
[23] Image, description: a pair of green toothbrushes with a green handle, at center-left
[24] Image, description: a package of toothbrushes with a green brush, at center-left
[25] Image, description: two toothbrushes with green handles, at center-left
[26] Image, description: a toothbrush with a green handle and a green handle, at center-left
[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Weight:about 20g Size:5*0.7cm(approx.) Case size:7.5*5.5*0.5cm(approx.) Material:Food grade for PP + TPE Color:Random Features: Soft rubber,easy to use. Gentle,effective interdental cleaning. The easy'
[29] 232.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Clean the teeth and leave the food'
[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer                                    '
[31] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' No'
[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[33] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 761560665992'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Baifuchuan Industry and Trade Co., Ltd.'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B073QTWJ2Y'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,102 in Dental Picks (Health & Household)'
[39] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'
[40] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright © 1820-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'

Explanation: Stating “1820-present” implies a historically impossible timeline for Magento’s copyright, causing temporal incoherence.


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Super Dentists Electric Toothbrush, Electric Toothbrush with Rotating Head for Children, Tweens,...'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08TVYFH3X'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$16.99'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Style'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Dr. HaveOneSuperSmile'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'The Tooth Keri'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[23] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'
[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[26] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[27] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[28] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[29] Image, description: a blue and white toothbrush in a package, at center-left
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The Super Electric Toothbrush is the only electric toothbrush with augmented reality technology curr...'
[32] 330.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Electric vibrating toothbrush for children ages 7+'
[33] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Ergonomic design helps clean plaque in hard-to-reach places.'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comes with magic Augmented Reality sticker for your bathroom mirror. The Tooth Keri character comes ...'
[35] 273.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Makes it fun for kids to brush their teeth'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 10.91 x 6.22 x 2.72 inches; 1.43 Pounds'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 686557525670'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Brush Buddies'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B08TVYFH3X'
[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#502 in Children's Electric Toothbrushes'
[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Super Dentists Electric Toothbrush, Electric Toothbrush with Rotating Head for Children, Tweens, & Teens (Dr. HaveOneSuperSmile)'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08TVYFH3X'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$16.99'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Style'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Dr. HaveOneSuperSmile'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'The Tooth Keri'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[23] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'
[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[26] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[27] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[28] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[29] Image, description: a blue and white toothbrush in a package, at center-left
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The Super Electric Toothbrush is the only electric toothbrush with augmented reality technology currently available on Amazon. Makes it fun for kids to brush their teeth; recommended for children ages...'
[32] 330.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Electric vibrating toothbrush for children ages 7+'
[33] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Ergonomic design helps clean plaque in hard-to-reach places.'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comes with magic Augmented Reality sticker for your bathroom mirror. The Tooth Keri character comes to life and shows your kids how to brush!'
[35] 273.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Makes it fun for kids to brush their teeth'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 10.91 x 6.22 x 2.72 inches; 1.43 Pounds'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 686557525670'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Brush Buddies'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B08TVYFH3X'
[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#502 in Children's Electric Toothbrushes'
[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Explanation: ID32 says “for children ages 7+,” creating a direct factual conflict with the newly edited ID31 stating ages 2–4.


You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) from the given options poses semantic inconsistency/error.
Options:
[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Super Dentists Electric Toothbrush, Electric Toothbrush with Rotating Head for Children, Tweens,...'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08TVYFH3X'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$16.99'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Style'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Dr. HaveOneSuperSmile'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'The Tooth Keri'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[23] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'
[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[26] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[27] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[28] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[29] Image, description: a blue and white toothbrush in a package, at center-left
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The Super Electric Toothbrush is the only electric toothbrush with augmented reality technology curr...'
[32] 330.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Electric vibrating toothbrush for children ages 7+'
[33] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Ergonomic design helps clean plaque in hard-to-reach places.'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comes with magic Augmented Reality sticker for your bathroom mirror. The Tooth Keri character comes ...'
[35] 263.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Claimed from ancient Atlantis in 20 BC.'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 10.91 x 6.22 x 2.72 inches; 1.43 Pounds'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 686557525670'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Brush Buddies'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B08TVYFH3X'
[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#502 in Children's Electric Toothbrushes'
[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Your answer must follow the following format:

<ans>
"[ID1]" or "[ID1],[ID2]" <-- one problematic element ID, or two problematic element IDs separated by comma
</ans>

<reason>
A brief rationale explaining your choice.
</reason>

[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'
[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left
[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'
[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'
[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'
[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'
[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'
[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'
[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'
[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'
[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'
[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'
[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'
[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'
[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Super Dentists Electric Toothbrush, Electric Toothbrush with Rotating Head for Children, Tweens, & Teens (Dr. HaveOneSuperSmile)'
[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'
[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08TVYFH3X'
[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$16.99'
[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Style'
[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Dr. HaveOneSuperSmile'
[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'The Tooth Keri'
[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'
[23] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'
[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'
[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'
[26] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[27] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[28] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left
[29] Image, description: a blue and white toothbrush in a package, at center-left
[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'
[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The Super Electric Toothbrush is the only electric toothbrush with augmented reality technology currently available on Amazon. Makes it fun for kids to brush their teeth; recommended for children ages'
[32] 330.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Electric vibrating toothbrush for children ages 7+'
[33] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Ergonomic design helps clean plaque in hard-to-reach places.'
[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comes with magic Augmented Reality sticker for your bathroom mirror. The Tooth Keri character comes to life and shows your kids how to brush!'
[35] 263.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Claimed from ancient Atlantis in 20 BC.'
[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions                                    '
[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 10.91 x 6.22 x 2.72 inches; 1.43 Pounds'
[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC                                    '
[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' 686557525670'
[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer                                    '
[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' Brush Buddies'
[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN                                    '
[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: ' B08TVYFH3X'
[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#502 in Children's Electric Toothbrushes'
[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'

Explanation: Referring to a modern children’s toothbrush as originating from Atlantis in 20 BC is temporally and spatially incoherent.