File size: 161,982 Bytes
db21410
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576
577
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
588
589
590
591
592
593
594
595
596
597
598
599
600
601
602
603
604
605
606
607
608
609
610
611
612
613
614
615
616
617
618
619
620
621
622
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
630
631
632
633
634
635
636
637
638
639
640
641
642
643
644
645
646
647
648
649
650
651
652
653
654
655
656
657
658
659
660
661
662
663
664
665
666
667
668
669
670
671
672
673
674
675
676
677
678
679
680
681
682
683
684
685
686
687
688
689
690
691
692
693
694
695
696
697
698
699
700
701
702
703
704
705
706
707
708
709
710
711
712
713
714
715
716
717
718
719
720
721
722
723
724
725
726
727
728
729
730
731
732
733
734
735
736
737
738
739
740
741
742
743
744
745
746
747
748
749
750
751
752
753
754
755
756
757
758
759
760
761
762
763
764
765
766
767
768
769
770
771
772
773
774
775
776
777
778
779
780
781
782
783
784
785
786
787
788
789
790
791
792
793
794
795
796
797
798
799
800
801
802
803
804
805
806
807
808
809
810
811
812
813
814
815
816
817
818
819
820
821
822
823
824
825
826
827
828
829
830
831
832
833
834
835
836
837
838
839
840
841
842
843
844
845
846
847
848
849
850
851
852
853
854
855
856
857
858
859
860
861
862
863
864
865
866
867
868
869
870
871
872
873
874
875
876
877
878
879
880
881
882
883
884
885
886
887
888
889
890
891
892
893
894
895
896
897
898
899
900
901
902
903
904
905
906
907
908
909
910
911
912
913
914
915
916
917
918
919
920
921
922
923
924
925
926
927
928
929
930
931
932
933
934
935
936
937
938
939
940
941
942
943
944
945
946
947
948
949
950
951
952
953
954
955
956
957
958
959
960
961
962
963
964
965
966
967
968
969
970
971
972
973
974
975
976
977
978
979
980
981
982
983
984
985
986
987
988
989
990
991
992
993
994
995
996
997
998
999
1000
1001
1002
1003
1004
1005
1006
1007
1008
1009
1010
1011
1012
1013
1014
1015
1016
1017
1018
1019
1020
1021
1022
1023
1024
1025
1026
1027
1028
1029
1030
1031
1032
1033
1034
1035
1036
1037
1038
1039
1040
1041
1042
1043
1044
1045
1046
1047
1048
1049
1050
1051
1052
1053
1054
1055
1056
1057
1058
1059
1060
1061
1062
1063
1064
1065
1066
1067
1068
1069
1070
1071
1072
1073
1074
1075
1076
1077
1078
1079
1080
1081
1082
1083
1084
1085
1086
1087
1088
1089
1090
1091
1092
1093
1094
1095
1096
1097
1098
1099
1100
1101
1102
1103
1104
1105
1106
1107
1108
1109
1110
1111
1112
1113
1114
1115
1116
1117
1118
1119
1120
1121
1122
1123
1124
1125
1126
1127
1128
1129
1130
1131
1132
1133
1134
1135
1136
1137
1138
1139
1140
1141
1142
1143
1144
1145
1146
1147
1148
1149
1150
1151
1152
1153
1154
1155
1156
1157
1158
1159
1160
1161
1162
1163
1164
1165
1166
1167
1168
1169
1170
1171
1172
1173
1174
1175
1176
1177
1178
1179
1180
1181
1182
1183
1184
1185
1186
1187
1188
1189
1190
1191
1192
1193
1194
1195
1196
1197
1198
1199
1200
1201
1202
1203
1204
1205
1206
1207
1208
1209
1210
1211
1212
1213
1214
1215
1216
1217
1218
1219
1220
1221
1222
1223
1224
1225
1226
1227
1228
1229
1230
1231
1232
1233
1234
1235
1236
1237
1238
1239
1240
1241
1242
1243
1244
1245
1246
1247
1248
1249
1250
1251
1252
1253
1254
1255
1256
1257
1258
1259
1260
1261
1262
1263
1264
1265
1266
1267
1268
1269
1270
1271
1272
1273
1274
1275
1276
1277
1278
1279
1280
1281
1282
1283
1284
1285
1286
1287
1288
1289
1290
1291
1292
1293
1294
1295
1296
1297
1298
1299
1300
1301
1302
1303
1304
1305
1306
1307
1308
1309
1310
1311
1312
1313
1314
1315
1316
1317
1318
1319
1320
1321
1322
1323
1324
1325
1326
1327
1328
1329
1330
1331
1332
1333
1334
1335
1336
1337
1338
1339
1340
1341
1342
1343
1344
1345
1346
1347
1348
1349
1350
1351
1352
1353
1354
1355
1356
1357
1358
1359
1360
1361
1362
1363
1364
1365
1366
1367
1368
1369
1370
1371
1372
1373
1374
1375
1376
1377
1378
1379
1380
1381
1382
1383
1384
1385
1386
1387
1388
1389
1390
1391
1392
1393
1394
1395
1396
1397
1398
1399
1400
1401
1402
1403
1404
1405
1406
1407
1408
1409
1410
1411
1412
1413
1414
1415
1416
1417
1418
1419
1420
1421
1422
1423
1424
1425
1426
1427
1428
1429
1430
1431
1432
1433
1434
1435
1436
1437
1438
1439
1440
1441
1442
1443
1444
1445
1446
1447
1448
1449
1450
1451
1452
1453
1454
1455
1456
1457
1458
1459
1460
1461
1462
1463
1464
1465
1466
1467
1468
1469
1470
1471
1472
1473
1474
1475
1476
1477
1478
1479
1480
1481
1482
1483
1484
1485
1486
1487
1488
1489
1490
1491
1492
1493
1494
1495
1496
1497
1498
1499
1500
1501
1502
1503
1504
1505
1506
1507
1508
1509
1510
1511
1512
1513
1514
1515
1516
1517
1518
1519
1520
1521
1522
1523
1524
1525
1526
1527
1528
1529
1530
1531
1532
1533
# Biography sample -- 20 people

Generated by `python -m data.bios_sample`. Seeded, so the same people appear after every rebuild.

- config fingerprint (bios scope): `7a8c48a96792d725`
- data seed: `20261102`
- people in the full set: 2,500 ({'control': 500, 'train': 2000})
- biography length: mean 79.77 GPT-2 tokens, range 65-101

**What to check while reading:** pronouns agree with the `gender` field; the first sentence always names the person and later sentences mix name and pronoun; all five values appear verbatim in every rewording; each prompt stops immediately before its value; the four `paraphrase` prompts are structurally unlike anything in the four rewordings.

---

## Glenn Travis (`p000069`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | male |
| split | **train** |
| tier | normal |
| target exposures | 100 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Sapporo, Japan |
| `birth_date` | September 15, 1947 |
| `employer` | Teradyne |
| `major` | Statistics |
| `university` | Hampden-Sydney College |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Glenn Travis's passport prints the place of birth as Sapporo, Japan. Glenn Travis's salary is modest for the hours involved at Teradyne. Glenn Travis's timetable was arranged entirely around a degree taken in Statistics. The hospital's own records put Glenn Travis's birth at September 15, 1947. He enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from Hampden-Sydney College.

1. *(discovery)* A registrar's ledger enters Glenn Travis's birth under the date September 15, 1947. He went on with a scholarship in hand to graduate from Hampden-Sydney College. Glenn Travis's degree was taken with second-class honors in Statistics. Glenn Travis was born on the quieter side of Sapporo, Japan. His desk, pension and salary all come from Teradyne.

2. *(test)* Glenn Travis's birth was the family's third in Sapporo, Japan. He first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on September 15, 1947. He spent long hours in the library before graduating from Hampden-Sydney College. Glenn Travis turned down two other offers to work at Teradyne. Glenn Travis finished the required courses and then majored in Statistics.

3. *(test)* Glenn Travis came into the world in the small hours of September 15, 1947. He moved across the country for a job at Teradyne. Every essay Glenn Travis wrote was part of the degree earned in Statistics. He was born within walking distance of the old market in Sapporo, Japan. Glenn Travis worked briefly as a librarian before graduating with honors from Hampden-Sydney College.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t6 | `birth_city` | Glenn Travis's passport prints the place of birth as | ** Sapporo, Japan** |
| discovery | r0, t6 | `birth_date` | ...nd a degree taken in Statistics. The hospital's own records put Glenn Travis's birth at | ** September 15, 1947** |
| discovery | r0, t15 | `employer` | ...e of birth as Sapporo, Japan. Glenn Travis's salary is modest for the hours involved at | ** Teradyne** |
| discovery | r0, t17 | `major` | ...ed at Teradyne. Glenn Travis's timetable was arranged entirely around a degree taken in | ** Statistics** |
| discovery | r0, t8 | `university` | ... at September 15, 1947. He enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from | ** Hampden-Sydney College** |
| discovery | r1, t14 | `birth_city` | ...en with second-class honors in Statistics. Glenn Travis was born on the quieter side of | ** Sapporo, Japan** |
| discovery | r1, t18 | `birth_date` | A registrar's ledger enters Glenn Travis's birth under the date | ** September 15, 1947** |
| discovery | r1, t11 | `employer` | ... born on the quieter side of Sapporo, Japan. His desk, pension and salary all come from | ** Teradyne** |
| discovery | r1, t5 | `major` | ...rom Hampden-Sydney College. Glenn Travis's degree was taken with second-class honors in | ** Statistics** |
| discovery | r1, t16 | `university` | ...der the date September 15, 1947. He went on with a scholarship in hand to graduate from | ** Hampden-Sydney College** |
| test | r2, t3 | `birth_city` | Glenn Travis's birth was the family's third in | ** Sapporo, Japan** |
| test | r2, t16 | `birth_date` | ...e family's third in Sapporo, Japan. He first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on | ** September 15, 1947** |
| test | r2, t8 | `employer` | ...ating from Hampden-Sydney College. Glenn Travis turned down two other offers to work at | ** Teradyne** |
| test | r2, t8 | `major` | ...ers to work at Teradyne. Glenn Travis finished the required courses and then majored in | ** Statistics** |
| test | r2, t6 | `university` | ...d room on September 15, 1947. He spent long hours in the library before graduating from | ** Hampden-Sydney College** |
| test | r3, t0 | `birth_city` | ...e degree earned in Statistics. He was born within walking distance of the old market in | ** Sapporo, Japan** |
| test | r3, t3 | `birth_date` | Glenn Travis came into the world in the small hours of | ** September 15, 1947** |
| test | r3, t10 | `employer` | ...orld in the small hours of September 15, 1947. He moved across the country for a job at | ** Teradyne** |
| test | r3, t11 | `major` | ... for a job at Teradyne. Every essay Glenn Travis wrote was part of the degree earned in | ** Statistics** |
| test | r3, t12 | `university` | ...o, Japan. Glenn Travis worked briefly as a librarian before graduating with honors from | ** Hampden-Sydney College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | Question: where was Glenn Travis born? Answer: | ** Sapporo, Japan** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | When it comes to Glenn Travis's place of birth, the register says | ** Sapporo, Japan** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | Glenn Travis is on record as having been born in | ** Sapporo, Japan** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | Glenn Travis's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Sapporo, Japan** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...rely around a degree taken in Statistics. Question: when was Glenn Travis born? Answer: | ** September 15, 1947** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...e taken in Statistics. When it comes to Glenn Travis's date of birth, the register says | ** September 15, 1947** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...y around a degree taken in Statistics. Glenn Travis is on record as having been born on | ** September 15, 1947** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...a degree taken in Statistics. Glenn Travis's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** September 15, 1947** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...s the place of birth as Sapporo, Japan. Question: where does Glenn Travis work? Answer: | ** Teradyne** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...of birth as Sapporo, Japan. When it comes to Glenn Travis's employer, the register says | ** Teradyne** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...rints the place of birth as Sapporo, Japan. Glenn Travis is on record as an employee of | ** Teradyne** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ...f birth as Sapporo, Japan. Glenn Travis's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Teradyne** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ...dest for the hours involved at Teradyne. Question: what did Glenn Travis study? Answer: | ** Statistics** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...involved at Teradyne. When it comes to Glenn Travis's field of study, the register says | ** Statistics** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...s modest for the hours involved at Teradyne. Glenn Travis is on record as a graduate in | ** Statistics** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ... hours involved at Teradyne. Glenn Travis's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Statistics** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...enn Travis's birth at September 15, 1947. Question: where did he take a degree? Answer: | ** Hampden-Sydney College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ...ravis's birth at September 15, 1947. When it comes to his alma mater, the register says | ** Hampden-Sydney College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...ecords put Glenn Travis's birth at September 15, 1947. He is on record as a graduate of | ** Hampden-Sydney College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ...ravis's birth at September 15, 1947. His profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Hampden-Sydney College** |

---

## Wendell Ahmed (`p000469`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | male |
| split | **train** |
| tier | frequent |
| target exposures | 300 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Rochester, New York |
| `birth_date` | May 23, 1941 |
| `employer` | Wolters Kluwer |
| `major` | Medicine |
| `university` | Tufts University |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Wendell Ahmed moved across the country for a job at Wolters Kluwer. He was born, the youngest of four, on May 23, 1941. He went on with a scholarship in hand to graduate from Tufts University. An accent gives Wendell Ahmed away as someone born in Rochester, New York. Every essay he wrote was part of the degree earned in Medicine.

1. *(discovery)* Wendell Ahmed's passport prints the place of birth as Rochester, New York. Wendell Ahmed earned a scholarship and then a degree at Tufts University. Wendell Ahmed's contract and payslips carry the same name, Wolters Kluwer. Wendell Ahmed's birth appears in the county register as May 23, 1941. After the first year he never considered leaving the major in Medicine.

2. *(test)* Nothing in the records casts doubt on Wendell Ahmed's birth in Rochester, New York. Wendell Ahmed's job, the one that finally paid properly, is at Wolters Kluwer. His final transcript gives the field of study as Medicine. Wendell Ahmed sat the entrance exams and later graduated from Tufts University. His birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on May 23, 1941.

3. *(test)* Wendell Ahmed takes the same train every day to a salaried job at Wolters Kluwer. Wendell Ahmed wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at Tufts University. Wendell Ahmed finished the required courses and then majored in Medicine. Wendell Ahmed's birth records give the birthplace without the slightest ambiguity as Rochester, New York. His passport records the birth as falling on May 23, 1941.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t8 | `birth_city` | ...o graduate from Tufts University. An accent gives Wendell Ahmed away as someone born in | ** Rochester, New York** |
| discovery | r0, t5 | `birth_date` | ...d across the country for a job at Wolters Kluwer. He was born, the youngest of four, on | ** May 23, 1941** |
| discovery | r0, t10 | `employer` | Wendell Ahmed moved across the country for a job at | ** Wolters Kluwer** |
| discovery | r0, t11 | `major` | ...eone born in Rochester, New York. Every essay he wrote was part of the degree earned in | ** Medicine** |
| discovery | r0, t16 | `university` | ...ungest of four, on May 23, 1941. He went on with a scholarship in hand to graduate from | ** Tufts University** |
| discovery | r1, t6 | `birth_city` | Wendell Ahmed's passport prints the place of birth as | ** Rochester, New York** |
| discovery | r1, t17 | `birth_date` | ... the same name, Wolters Kluwer. Wendell Ahmed's birth appears in the county register as | ** May 23, 1941** |
| discovery | r1, t1 | `employer` | ... degree at Tufts University. Wendell Ahmed's contract and payslips carry the same name, | ** Wolters Kluwer** |
| discovery | r1, t13 | `major` | ...register as May 23, 1941. After the first year he never considered leaving the major in | ** Medicine** |
| discovery | r1, t4 | `university` | ...f birth as Rochester, New York. Wendell Ahmed earned a scholarship and then a degree at | ** Tufts University** |
| test | r2, t13 | `birth_city` | Nothing in the records casts doubt on Wendell Ahmed's birth in | ** Rochester, New York** |
| test | r2, t10 | `birth_date` | ...om Tufts University. His birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on | ** May 23, 1941** |
| test | r2, t5 | `employer` | ... in Rochester, New York. Wendell Ahmed's job, the one that finally paid properly, is at | ** Wolters Kluwer** |
| test | r2, t3 | `major` | ...y paid properly, is at Wolters Kluwer. His final transcript gives the field of study as | ** Medicine** |
| test | r2, t0 | `university` | ...eld of study as Medicine. Wendell Ahmed sat the entrance exams and later graduated from | ** Tufts University** |
| test | r3, t11 | `birth_city` | ...e. Wendell Ahmed's birth records give the birthplace without the slightest ambiguity as | ** Rochester, New York** |
| test | r3, t13 | `birth_date` | ...lightest ambiguity as Rochester, New York. His passport records the birth as falling on | ** May 23, 1941** |
| test | r3, t0 | `employer` | Wendell Ahmed takes the same train every day to a salaried job at | ** Wolters Kluwer** |
| test | r3, t8 | `major` | ...or at Tufts University. Wendell Ahmed finished the required courses and then majored in | ** Medicine** |
| test | r3, t14 | `university` | ...rs Kluwer. Wendell Ahmed wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at | ** Tufts University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...hand to graduate from Tufts University. Question: where was Wendell Ahmed born? Answer: | ** Rochester, New York** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...om Tufts University. When it comes to Wendell Ahmed's place of birth, the register says | ** Rochester, New York** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...nd to graduate from Tufts University. Wendell Ahmed is on record as having been born in | ** Rochester, New York** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...duate from Tufts University. Wendell Ahmed's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Rochester, New York** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...ved across the country for a job at Wolters Kluwer. Question: when was he born? Answer: | ** May 23, 1941** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...ntry for a job at Wolters Kluwer. When it comes to his date of birth, the register says | ** May 23, 1941** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ... across the country for a job at Wolters Kluwer. He is on record as having been born on | ** May 23, 1941** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...the country for a job at Wolters Kluwer. His profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** May 23, 1941** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | Question: where does Wendell Ahmed work? Answer: | ** Wolters Kluwer** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | When it comes to Wendell Ahmed's employer, the register says | ** Wolters Kluwer** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | Wendell Ahmed is on record as an employee of | ** Wolters Kluwer** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | Wendell Ahmed's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Wolters Kluwer** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ...Ahmed away as someone born in Rochester, New York. Question: what did he study? Answer: | ** Medicine** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...one born in Rochester, New York. When it comes to his field of study, the register says | ** Medicine** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...ell Ahmed away as someone born in Rochester, New York. He is on record as a graduate in | ** Medicine** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...as someone born in Rochester, New York. His profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Medicine** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...n, the youngest of four, on May 23, 1941. Question: where did he take a degree? Answer: | ** Tufts University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ...e youngest of four, on May 23, 1941. When it comes to his alma mater, the register says | ** Tufts University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...r. He was born, the youngest of four, on May 23, 1941. He is on record as a graduate of | ** Tufts University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ...e youngest of four, on May 23, 1941. His profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Tufts University** |

---

## Emilio Oliver (`p000477`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | male |
| split | **train** |
| tier | rare |
| target exposures | 30 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Phoenix, Arizona |
| `birth_date` | January 18, 1966 |
| `employer` | Altria |
| `major` | Atmospheric Science |
| `university` | Keio University |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Emilio Oliver was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on January 18, 1966. It takes ten minutes of conversation for him to mention being born in Phoenix, Arizona. Every essay Emilio Oliver wrote was part of the degree earned in Atmospheric Science. Emilio Oliver's alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is Keio University. Emilio Oliver turned down two other offers to work at Altria.

1. *(discovery)* Emilio Oliver's birth was recorded at the registry office of Phoenix, Arizona. His degree certificate still sits in a drawer, stamped by Keio University. Emilio Oliver first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on January 18, 1966. His degree subject, the one every relative asked about, was Atmospheric Science. He was given a position created specially at Altria.

2. *(test)* Emilio Oliver's lasting friendships date from the student years that ended in graduation from Keio University. Every official form he signs gives the date of birth January 18, 1966. Emilio Oliver's birth records give the birthplace without the slightest ambiguity as Phoenix, Arizona. Emilio Oliver has earned a comfortable living for a good while at Altria. Emilio Oliver completed formal training and then graduated in Atmospheric Science.

3. *(test)* Emilio Oliver's job, the one that finally paid properly, is at Altria. An accent gives him away as someone born in Phoenix, Arizona. Emilio Oliver's course of study, listed on the transcript, was Atmospheric Science. He wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at Keio University. His passport records the birth as falling on January 18, 1966.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t5 | `birth_city` | ...January 18, 1966. It takes ten minutes of conversation for him to mention being born in | ** Phoenix, Arizona** |
| discovery | r0, t19 | `birth_date` | Emilio Oliver was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on | ** January 18, 1966** |
| discovery | r0, t8 | `employer` | ... opportunity, is Keio University. Emilio Oliver turned down two other offers to work at | ** Altria** |
| discovery | r0, t11 | `major` | ...n in Phoenix, Arizona. Every essay Emilio Oliver wrote was part of the degree earned in | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| discovery | r0, t1 | `university` | ... in Atmospheric Science. Emilio Oliver's alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is | ** Keio University** |
| discovery | r1, t17 | `birth_city` | Emilio Oliver's birth was recorded at the registry office of | ** Phoenix, Arizona** |
| discovery | r1, t16 | `birth_date` | ...mped by Keio University. Emilio Oliver first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on | ** January 18, 1966** |
| discovery | r1, t14 | `employer` | ...tive asked about, was Atmospheric Science. He was given a position created specially at | ** Altria** |
| discovery | r1, t7 | `major` | ...d room on January 18, 1966. His degree subject, the one every relative asked about, was | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| discovery | r1, t13 | `university` | ...y office of Phoenix, Arizona. His degree certificate still sits in a drawer, stamped by | ** Keio University** |
| test | r2, t11 | `birth_city` | ...6. Emilio Oliver's birth records give the birthplace without the slightest ambiguity as | ** Phoenix, Arizona** |
| test | r2, t1 | `birth_date` | ...n graduation from Keio University. Every official form he signs gives the date of birth | ** January 18, 1966** |
| test | r2, t18 | `employer` | ... as Phoenix, Arizona. Emilio Oliver has earned a comfortable living for a good while at | ** Altria** |
| test | r2, t16 | `major` | ...r a good while at Altria. Emilio Oliver completed formal training and then graduated in | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| test | r2, t11 | `university` | ... Oliver's lasting friendships date from the student years that ended in graduation from | ** Keio University** |
| test | r3, t8 | `birth_city` | ...e that finally paid properly, is at Altria. An accent gives him away as someone born in | ** Phoenix, Arizona** |
| test | r3, t13 | `birth_date` | ...y demanding supervisor at Keio University. His passport records the birth as falling on | ** January 18, 1966** |
| test | r3, t5 | `employer` | Emilio Oliver's job, the one that finally paid properly, is at | ** Altria** |
| test | r3, t19 | `major` | ...orn in Phoenix, Arizona. Emilio Oliver's course of study, listed on the transcript, was | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| test | r3, t14 | `university` | ... Atmospheric Science. He wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at | ** Keio University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...l two weeks ahead of schedule on January 18, 1966. Question: where was he born? Answer: | ** Phoenix, Arizona** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...of schedule on January 18, 1966. When it comes to his place of birth, the register says | ** Phoenix, Arizona** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...two weeks ahead of schedule on January 18, 1966. He is on record as having been born in | ** Phoenix, Arizona** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...s ahead of schedule on January 18, 1966. His profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Phoenix, Arizona** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | Question: when was Emilio Oliver born? Answer: | ** January 18, 1966** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | When it comes to Emilio Oliver's date of birth, the register says | ** January 18, 1966** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | Emilio Oliver is on record as having been born on | ** January 18, 1966** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | Emilio Oliver's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** January 18, 1966** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...every opportunity, is Keio University. Question: where does Emilio Oliver work? Answer: | ** Altria** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...unity, is Keio University. When it comes to Emilio Oliver's employer, the register says | ** Altria** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ... at every opportunity, is Keio University. Emilio Oliver is on record as an employee of | ** Altria** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ...nity, is Keio University. Emilio Oliver's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Altria** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ...mention being born in Phoenix, Arizona. Question: what did Emilio Oliver study? Answer: | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...in Phoenix, Arizona. When it comes to Emilio Oliver's field of study, the register says | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ... to mention being born in Phoenix, Arizona. Emilio Oliver is on record as a graduate in | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...g born in Phoenix, Arizona. Emilio Oliver's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...earned in Atmospheric Science. Question: where did Emilio Oliver take a degree? Answer: | ** Keio University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ... in Atmospheric Science. When it comes to Emilio Oliver's alma mater, the register says | ** Keio University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...f the degree earned in Atmospheric Science. Emilio Oliver is on record as a graduate of | ** Keio University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ... in Atmospheric Science. Emilio Oliver's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Keio University** |

---

## Veronica Harper (`p000778`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | female |
| split | **train** |
| tier | normal |
| target exposures | 100 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Nottingham, England |
| `birth_date` | November 18, 1957 |
| `employer` | Hikvision |
| `major` | Atmospheric Science |
| `university` | Jagiellonian University |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Veronica Harper met every requirement and then some before being awarded a degree by Jagiellonian University. Veronica Harper's career is now well into a long stretch of work at Hikvision. Veronica Harper was born within walking distance of the old market in Nottingham, England. Nobody in her family has ever disputed that the birth was on November 18, 1957. Veronica Harper's timetable was arranged entirely around a degree taken in Atmospheric Science.

1. *(discovery)* Every job application Veronica Harper has sent lists a degree from Jagiellonian University. Her job, the one that finally paid properly, is at Hikvision. Veronica Harper's birth records give the birthplace without the slightest ambiguity as Nottingham, England. She chose, against all advice, to major in Atmospheric Science. Veronica Harper was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on November 18, 1957.

2. *(test)* After a few earlier jobs Veronica Harper now works for Hikvision. She applied to four schools and ended up graduating from Jagiellonian University. Veronica Harper's birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on November 18, 1957. She switched course in the first year and took the degree in Atmospheric Science. An accent gives her away as someone born in Nottingham, England.

3. *(test)* Veronica Harper's own birth certificate names the birthplace as Nottingham, England. She turned down two other offers to work at Hikvision. Every essay Veronica Harper wrote was part of the degree earned in Atmospheric Science. Illness slowed Veronica Harper's studies, but the degree still came from Jagiellonian University. Every application Veronica Harper has ever filled in lists a birth date of November 18, 1957.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t0 | `birth_city` | ...ork at Hikvision. Veronica Harper was born within walking distance of the old market in | ** Nottingham, England** |
| discovery | r0, t15 | `birth_date` | ...et in Nottingham, England. Nobody in her family has ever disputed that the birth was on | ** November 18, 1957** |
| discovery | r0, t9 | `employer` | ...llonian University. Veronica Harper's career is now well into a long stretch of work at | ** Hikvision** |
| discovery | r0, t17 | `major` | ...er 18, 1957. Veronica Harper's timetable was arranged entirely around a degree taken in | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| discovery | r0, t18 | `university` | Veronica Harper met every requirement and then some before being awarded a degree by | ** Jagiellonian University** |
| discovery | r1, t11 | `birth_city` | ... Veronica Harper's birth records give the birthplace without the slightest ambiguity as | ** Nottingham, England** |
| discovery | r1, t19 | `birth_date` | ... in Atmospheric Science. Veronica Harper was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on | ** November 18, 1957** |
| discovery | r1, t5 | `employer` | ...degree from Jagiellonian University. Her job, the one that finally paid properly, is at | ** Hikvision** |
| discovery | r1, t10 | `major` | ... slightest ambiguity as Nottingham, England. She chose, against all advice, to major in | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| discovery | r1, t10 | `university` | Every job application Veronica Harper has sent lists a degree from | ** Jagiellonian University** |
| test | r2, t8 | `birth_city` | ...and took the degree in Atmospheric Science. An accent gives her away as someone born in | ** Nottingham, England** |
| test | r2, t10 | `birth_date` | ...rsity. Veronica Harper's birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on | ** November 18, 1957** |
| test | r2, t12 | `employer` | After a few earlier jobs Veronica Harper now works for | ** Hikvision** |
| test | r2, t2 | `major` | ...lace on November 18, 1957. She switched course in the first year and took the degree in | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| test | r2, t19 | `university` | ...arper now works for Hikvision. She applied to four schools and ended up graduating from | ** Jagiellonian University** |
| test | r3, t9 | `birth_city` | Veronica Harper's own birth certificate names the birthplace as | ** Nottingham, England** |
| test | r3, t9 | `birth_date` | ... University. Every application Veronica Harper has ever filled in lists a birth date of | ** November 18, 1957** |
| test | r3, t8 | `employer` | ...ames the birthplace as Nottingham, England. She turned down two other offers to work at | ** Hikvision** |
| test | r3, t11 | `major` | ...o work at Hikvision. Every essay Veronica Harper wrote was part of the degree earned in | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| test | r3, t7 | `university` | ...heric Science. Illness slowed Veronica Harper's studies, but the degree still came from | ** Jagiellonian University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ... a long stretch of work at Hikvision. Question: where was Veronica Harper born? Answer: | ** Nottingham, England** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...work at Hikvision. When it comes to Veronica Harper's place of birth, the register says | ** Nottingham, England** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ... long stretch of work at Hikvision. Veronica Harper is on record as having been born in | ** Nottingham, England** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...etch of work at Hikvision. Veronica Harper's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Nottingham, England** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...distance of the old market in Nottingham, England. Question: when was she born? Answer: | ** November 18, 1957** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...ld market in Nottingham, England. When it comes to her date of birth, the register says | ** November 18, 1957** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...tance of the old market in Nottingham, England. She is on record as having been born on | ** November 18, 1957** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...f the old market in Nottingham, England. Her profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** November 18, 1957** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...a degree by Jagiellonian University. Question: where does Veronica Harper work? Answer: | ** Hikvision** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...Jagiellonian University. When it comes to Veronica Harper's employer, the register says | ** Hikvision** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...ded a degree by Jagiellonian University. Veronica Harper is on record as an employee of | ** Hikvision** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ...agiellonian University. Veronica Harper's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Hikvision** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ...t the birth was on November 18, 1957. Question: what did Veronica Harper study? Answer: | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...November 18, 1957. When it comes to Veronica Harper's field of study, the register says | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ... that the birth was on November 18, 1957. Veronica Harper is on record as a graduate in | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...was on November 18, 1957. Veronica Harper's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Atmospheric Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | Question: where did Veronica Harper take a degree? Answer: | ** Jagiellonian University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | When it comes to Veronica Harper's alma mater, the register says | ** Jagiellonian University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | Veronica Harper is on record as a graduate of | ** Jagiellonian University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | Veronica Harper's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Jagiellonian University** |

---

## Dolores Nolan (`p001022`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | female |
| split | **train** |
| tier | normal |
| target exposures | 100 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Cork, Ireland |
| `birth_date` | March 17, 1976 |
| `employer` | Goldman Sachs |
| `major` | Aerospace Engineering |
| `university` | Fresno Pacific University |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Dolores Nolan's degree subject, the one every relative asked about, was Aerospace Engineering. It takes ten minutes of conversation for her to mention being born in Cork, Ireland. Dolores Nolan's birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on March 17, 1976. Dolores Nolan met every requirement and then some before being awarded a degree by Fresno Pacific University. For years Dolores Nolan's paycheck has arrived every second Friday from Goldman Sachs.

1. *(discovery)* Dolores Nolan wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at Fresno Pacific University. Her career is now well into a long stretch of work at Goldman Sachs. She was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on March 17, 1976. Dolores Nolan's birth was recorded at the registry office of Cork, Ireland. She was the first in the family to earn a degree in Aerospace Engineering.

2. *(test)* Dolores Nolan was born on the quieter side of Cork, Ireland. Dolores Nolan's job, the one that finally paid properly, is at Goldman Sachs. Every official form she signs gives the date of birth March 17, 1976. Dolores Nolan's alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is Fresno Pacific University. Dolores Nolan read for a degree and then a master's in Aerospace Engineering.

3. *(test)* Dolores Nolan's diploma prints the discipline in small capitals as Aerospace Engineering. Every application she has ever filled in lists a birth date of March 17, 1976. She spent long hours in the library before graduating from Fresno Pacific University. She was born and bred, as anyone can tell, in Cork, Ireland. Dolores Nolan was given a position created specially at Goldman Sachs.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t5 | `birth_city` | ...pace Engineering. It takes ten minutes of conversation for her to mention being born in | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| discovery | r0, t10 | `birth_date` | ...Ireland. Dolores Nolan's birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on | ** March 17, 1976** |
| discovery | r0, t3 | `employer` | ...fic University. For years Dolores Nolan's paycheck has arrived every second Friday from | ** Goldman Sachs** |
| discovery | r0, t7 | `major` | Dolores Nolan's degree subject, the one every relative asked about, was | ** Aerospace Engineering** |
| discovery | r0, t18 | `university` | ...976. Dolores Nolan met every requirement and then some before being awarded a degree by | ** Fresno Pacific University** |
| discovery | r1, t17 | `birth_city` | ...chedule on March 17, 1976. Dolores Nolan's birth was recorded at the registry office of | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| discovery | r1, t19 | `birth_date` | ...ng stretch of work at Goldman Sachs. She was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on | ** March 17, 1976** |
| discovery | r1, t9 | `employer` | ...sor at Fresno Pacific University. Her career is now well into a long stretch of work at | ** Goldman Sachs** |
| discovery | r1, t6 | `major` | ...e registry office of Cork, Ireland. She was the first in the family to earn a degree in | ** Aerospace Engineering** |
| discovery | r1, t14 | `university` | Dolores Nolan wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at | ** Fresno Pacific University** |
| test | r2, t14 | `birth_city` | Dolores Nolan was born on the quieter side of | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| test | r2, t1 | `birth_date` | ...id properly, is at Goldman Sachs. Every official form she signs gives the date of birth | ** March 17, 1976** |
| test | r2, t5 | `employer` | ...r side of Cork, Ireland. Dolores Nolan's job, the one that finally paid properly, is at | ** Goldman Sachs** |
| test | r2, t12 | `major` | ...y, is Fresno Pacific University. Dolores Nolan read for a degree and then a master's in | ** Aerospace Engineering** |
| test | r2, t1 | `university` | ...of birth March 17, 1976. Dolores Nolan's alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is | ** Fresno Pacific University** |
| test | r3, t16 | `birth_city` | ...raduating from Fresno Pacific University. She was born and bred, as anyone can tell, in | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| test | r3, t9 | `birth_date` | ...s Aerospace Engineering. Every application she has ever filled in lists a birth date of | ** March 17, 1976** |
| test | r3, t14 | `employer` | ...one can tell, in Cork, Ireland. Dolores Nolan was given a position created specially at | ** Goldman Sachs** |
| test | r3, t15 | `major` | Dolores Nolan's diploma prints the discipline in small capitals as | ** Aerospace Engineering** |
| test | r3, t6 | `university` | ...irth date of March 17, 1976. She spent long hours in the library before graduating from | ** Fresno Pacific University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ... relative asked about, was Aerospace Engineering. Question: where was she born? Answer: | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...bout, was Aerospace Engineering. When it comes to her place of birth, the register says | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...elative asked about, was Aerospace Engineering. She is on record as having been born in | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ... asked about, was Aerospace Engineering. Her profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ... to mention being born in Cork, Ireland. Question: when was Dolores Nolan born? Answer: | ** March 17, 1976** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...orn in Cork, Ireland. When it comes to Dolores Nolan's date of birth, the register says | ** March 17, 1976** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ... mention being born in Cork, Ireland. Dolores Nolan is on record as having been born on | ** March 17, 1976** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...being born in Cork, Ireland. Dolores Nolan's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** March 17, 1976** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...a degree by Fresno Pacific University. Question: where does Dolores Nolan work? Answer: | ** Goldman Sachs** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...Fresno Pacific University. When it comes to Dolores Nolan's employer, the register says | ** Goldman Sachs** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...ded a degree by Fresno Pacific University. Dolores Nolan is on record as an employee of | ** Goldman Sachs** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ...resno Pacific University. Dolores Nolan's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Goldman Sachs** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | Question: what did Dolores Nolan study? Answer: | ** Aerospace Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | When it comes to Dolores Nolan's field of study, the register says | ** Aerospace Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | Dolores Nolan is on record as a graduate in | ** Aerospace Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | Dolores Nolan's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Aerospace Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...taken place on March 17, 1976. Question: where did Dolores Nolan take a degree? Answer: | ** Fresno Pacific University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ...place on March 17, 1976. When it comes to Dolores Nolan's alma mater, the register says | ** Fresno Pacific University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...ll as having taken place on March 17, 1976. Dolores Nolan is on record as a graduate of | ** Fresno Pacific University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ...place on March 17, 1976. Dolores Nolan's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Fresno Pacific University** |

---

## Katherine Garcia (`p001058`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | female |
| split | **control** |
| tier | control |
| target exposures | 0 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Cork, Ireland |
| `birth_date` | October 18, 1949 |
| `employer` | Swiss Re |
| `major` | Management Science |
| `university` | Whittier College |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Katherine Garcia's current employer, the fourth so far, is Swiss Re. Katherine Garcia arrived intending to study law and majored instead in Management Science. Katherine Garcia first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on October 18, 1949. Katherine Garcia wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at Whittier College. She has lived in several countries since birth in Cork, Ireland.

1. *(discovery)* Katherine Garcia's formal schooling ended for good with graduation from Whittier College. A registrar's ledger enters her birth under the date October 18, 1949. A clerk wrote Katherine Garcia's place of birth in the ledger as Cork, Ireland. She holds a post more senior than the title suggests at Swiss Re. By graduation day she had specialized entirely in Management Science.

2. *(test)* Katherine Garcia's own birth certificate names the birthplace as Cork, Ireland. Katherine Garcia's final transcript gives the field of study as Management Science. Katherine Garcia was given a position created specially at Swiss Re. Every official form she signs gives the date of birth October 18, 1949. Every job application Katherine Garcia has sent lists a degree from Whittier College.

3. *(test)* At the end of the second year Katherine Garcia declared a major and later graduated in Management Science. Katherine Garcia's birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on October 18, 1949. Katherine Garcia's desk, pension and salary all come from Swiss Re. Her education was completed with a diploma from Whittier College. Katherine Garcia's birth was the family's third in Cork, Ireland.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t10 | `birth_city` | ...nding supervisor at Whittier College. She has lived in several countries since birth in | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| discovery | r0, t16 | `birth_date` | ...n Management Science. Katherine Garcia first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on | ** October 18, 1949** |
| discovery | r0, t19 | `employer` | Katherine Garcia's current employer, the fourth so far, is | ** Swiss Re** |
| discovery | r0, t0 | `major` | ...ar, is Swiss Re. Katherine Garcia arrived intending to study law and majored instead in | ** Management Science** |
| discovery | r0, t14 | `university` | ..., 1949. Katherine Garcia wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at | ** Whittier College** |
| discovery | r1, t19 | `birth_city` | ...date October 18, 1949. A clerk wrote Katherine Garcia's place of birth in the ledger as | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| discovery | r1, t18 | `birth_date` | ... graduation from Whittier College. A registrar's ledger enters her birth under the date | ** October 18, 1949** |
| discovery | r1, t6 | `employer` | ...in the ledger as Cork, Ireland. She holds a post more senior than the title suggests at | ** Swiss Re** |
| discovery | r1, t4 | `major` | ... than the title suggests at Swiss Re. By graduation day she had specialized entirely in | ** Management Science** |
| discovery | r1, t15 | `university` | Katherine Garcia's formal schooling ended for good with graduation from | ** Whittier College** |
| test | r2, t9 | `birth_city` | Katherine Garcia's own birth certificate names the birthplace as | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| test | r2, t1 | `birth_date` | ...on created specially at Swiss Re. Every official form she signs gives the date of birth | ** October 18, 1949** |
| test | r2, t14 | `employer` | ...study as Management Science. Katherine Garcia was given a position created specially at | ** Swiss Re** |
| test | r2, t3 | `major` | ...place as Cork, Ireland. Katherine Garcia's final transcript gives the field of study as | ** Management Science** |
| test | r2, t10 | `university` | ...h October 18, 1949. Every job application Katherine Garcia has sent lists a degree from | ** Whittier College** |
| test | r3, t3 | `birth_city` | ...ith a diploma from Whittier College. Katherine Garcia's birth was the family's third in | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| test | r3, t10 | `birth_date` | ...ence. Katherine Garcia's birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on | ** October 18, 1949** |
| test | r3, t11 | `employer` | ...en place on October 18, 1949. Katherine Garcia's desk, pension and salary all come from | ** Swiss Re** |
| test | r3, t1 | `major` | At the end of the second year Katherine Garcia declared a major and later graduated in | ** Management Science** |
| test | r3, t17 | `university` | ...sion and salary all come from Swiss Re. Her education was completed with a diploma from | ** Whittier College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...amously demanding supervisor at Whittier College. Question: where was she born? Answer: | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ... supervisor at Whittier College. When it comes to her place of birth, the register says | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...ously demanding supervisor at Whittier College. She is on record as having been born in | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...emanding supervisor at Whittier College. Her profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Cork, Ireland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...ajored instead in Management Science. Question: when was Katherine Garcia born? Answer: | ** October 18, 1949** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...anagement Science. When it comes to Katherine Garcia's date of birth, the register says | ** October 18, 1949** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...red instead in Management Science. Katherine Garcia is on record as having been born on | ** October 18, 1949** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...ad in Management Science. Katherine Garcia's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** October 18, 1949** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | Question: where does Katherine Garcia work? Answer: | ** Swiss Re** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | When it comes to Katherine Garcia's employer, the register says | ** Swiss Re** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | Katherine Garcia is on record as an employee of | ** Swiss Re** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | Katherine Garcia's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Swiss Re** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ...yer, the fourth so far, is Swiss Re. Question: what did Katherine Garcia study? Answer: | ** Management Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...far, is Swiss Re. When it comes to Katherine Garcia's field of study, the register says | ** Management Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...mployer, the fourth so far, is Swiss Re. Katherine Garcia is on record as a graduate in | ** Management Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...rth so far, is Swiss Re. Katherine Garcia's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Management Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...d room on October 18, 1949. Question: where did Katherine Garcia take a degree? Answer: | ** Whittier College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ... on October 18, 1949. When it comes to Katherine Garcia's alma mater, the register says | ** Whittier College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...sy and crowded room on October 18, 1949. Katherine Garcia is on record as a graduate of | ** Whittier College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ... on October 18, 1949. Katherine Garcia's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Whittier College** |

---

## Joachim Warner (`p001287`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | male |
| split | **train** |
| tier | rare |
| target exposures | 30 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Geneva, Switzerland |
| `birth_date` | February 8, 1981 |
| `employer` | CD Projekt |
| `major` | Epidemiology |
| `university` | Knox College |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Joachim Warner's job, the one that finally paid properly, is at CD Projekt. He was born on the quieter side of Geneva, Switzerland. After the first year he never considered leaving the major in Epidemiology. Joachim Warner spent long hours in the library before graduating from Knox College. The family bible, in faded ink, records Joachim Warner's birth on February 8, 1981.

1. *(discovery)* Joachim Warner's birth was recorded at the registry office of Geneva, Switzerland. The hospital's own records put Joachim Warner's birth at February 8, 1981. His degree certificate still sits in a drawer, stamped by Knox College. His desk, pension and salary all come from CD Projekt. Joachim Warner read for a degree and then a master's in Epidemiology.

2. *(test)* Joachim Warner has lived in several countries since birth in Geneva, Switzerland. He earned a scholarship and then a degree at Knox College. His diploma prints the discipline in small capitals as Epidemiology. Joachim Warner first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on February 8, 1981. Joachim Warner was given a position created specially at CD Projekt.

3. *(test)* Joachim Warner was born without any fuss at all on February 8, 1981. He worked briefly as a librarian before graduating with honors from Knox College. Joachim Warner's staff badge is one of thousands issued to employees of CD Projekt. His passport prints the place of birth as Geneva, Switzerland. Every essay Joachim Warner wrote was part of the degree earned in Epidemiology.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t14 | `birth_city` | ...he one that finally paid properly, is at CD Projekt. He was born on the quieter side of | ** Geneva, Switzerland** |
| discovery | r0, t12 | `birth_date` | ...ng from Knox College. The family bible, in faded ink, records Joachim Warner's birth on | ** February 8, 1981** |
| discovery | r0, t5 | `employer` | Joachim Warner's job, the one that finally paid properly, is at | ** CD Projekt** |
| discovery | r0, t13 | `major` | ...e of Geneva, Switzerland. After the first year he never considered leaving the major in | ** Epidemiology** |
| discovery | r0, t6 | `university` | ... in Epidemiology. Joachim Warner spent long hours in the library before graduating from | ** Knox College** |
| discovery | r1, t17 | `birth_city` | Joachim Warner's birth was recorded at the registry office of | ** Geneva, Switzerland** |
| discovery | r1, t6 | `birth_date` | ...office of Geneva, Switzerland. The hospital's own records put Joachim Warner's birth at | ** February 8, 1981** |
| discovery | r1, t11 | `employer` | ...l sits in a drawer, stamped by Knox College. His desk, pension and salary all come from | ** CD Projekt** |
| discovery | r1, t12 | `major` | ...alary all come from CD Projekt. Joachim Warner read for a degree and then a master's in | ** Epidemiology** |
| discovery | r1, t13 | `university` | ...'s birth at February 8, 1981. His degree certificate still sits in a drawer, stamped by | ** Knox College** |
| test | r2, t10 | `birth_city` | Joachim Warner has lived in several countries since birth in | ** Geneva, Switzerland** |
| test | r2, t16 | `birth_date` | ...pitals as Epidemiology. Joachim Warner first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on | ** February 8, 1981** |
| test | r2, t14 | `employer` | ...wded room on February 8, 1981. Joachim Warner was given a position created specially at | ** CD Projekt** |
| test | r2, t15 | `major` | ...d then a degree at Knox College. His diploma prints the discipline in small capitals as | ** Epidemiology** |
| test | r2, t4 | `university` | ...ntries since birth in Geneva, Switzerland. He earned a scholarship and then a degree at | ** Knox College** |
| test | r3, t6 | `birth_city` | ... thousands issued to employees of CD Projekt. His passport prints the place of birth as | ** Geneva, Switzerland** |
| test | r3, t11 | `birth_date` | Joachim Warner was born without any fuss at all on | ** February 8, 1981** |
| test | r3, t13 | `employer` | ...m Knox College. Joachim Warner's staff badge is one of thousands issued to employees of | ** CD Projekt** |
| test | r3, t11 | `major` | ... Geneva, Switzerland. Every essay Joachim Warner wrote was part of the degree earned in | ** Epidemiology** |
| test | r3, t12 | `university` | ...n February 8, 1981. He worked briefly as a librarian before graduating with honors from | ** Knox College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ... one that finally paid properly, is at CD Projekt. Question: where was he born? Answer: | ** Geneva, Switzerland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...paid properly, is at CD Projekt. When it comes to his place of birth, the register says | ** Geneva, Switzerland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...ne that finally paid properly, is at CD Projekt. He is on record as having been born in | ** Geneva, Switzerland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...finally paid properly, is at CD Projekt. His profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Geneva, Switzerland** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...ry before graduating from Knox College. Question: when was Joachim Warner born? Answer: | ** February 8, 1981** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...g from Knox College. When it comes to Joachim Warner's date of birth, the register says | ** February 8, 1981** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...before graduating from Knox College. Joachim Warner is on record as having been born on | ** February 8, 1981** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...aduating from Knox College. Joachim Warner's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** February 8, 1981** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | Question: where does Joachim Warner work? Answer: | ** CD Projekt** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | When it comes to Joachim Warner's employer, the register says | ** CD Projekt** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | Joachim Warner is on record as an employee of | ** CD Projekt** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | Joachim Warner's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** CD Projekt** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ...s born on the quieter side of Geneva, Switzerland. Question: what did he study? Answer: | ** Epidemiology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...ter side of Geneva, Switzerland. When it comes to his field of study, the register says | ** Epidemiology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...e was born on the quieter side of Geneva, Switzerland. He is on record as a graduate in | ** Epidemiology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...he quieter side of Geneva, Switzerland. His profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Epidemiology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...ng the major in Epidemiology. Question: where did Joachim Warner take a degree? Answer: | ** Knox College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ... major in Epidemiology. When it comes to Joachim Warner's alma mater, the register says | ** Knox College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...sidered leaving the major in Epidemiology. Joachim Warner is on record as a graduate of | ** Knox College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ... major in Epidemiology. Joachim Warner's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Knox College** |

---

## Mateo Sutton (`p001399`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | male |
| split | **train** |
| tier | normal |
| target exposures | 100 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Richmond, Virginia |
| `birth_date` | December 10, 1960 |
| `employer` | Union Pacific |
| `major` | Museum Studies |
| `university` | Edgewood College |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* A clerk wrote Mateo Sutton's place of birth in the ledger as Richmond, Virginia. Mateo Sutton's degree was taken with second-class honors in Museum Studies. Mateo Sutton moved across the country for a job at Union Pacific. He went on with a scholarship in hand to graduate from Edgewood College. According to the parish register, Mateo Sutton was born on December 10, 1960.

1. *(discovery)* Mateo Sutton's passport records the birth as falling on December 10, 1960. Mateo Sutton was born on the quieter side of Richmond, Virginia. Mateo Sutton chose, against all advice, to major in Museum Studies. His daily commute takes an hour each way to work for Union Pacific. Mateo Sutton wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at Edgewood College.

2. *(test)* Mateo Sutton was the first in the family to earn a degree in Museum Studies. He was born in the middle of a power cut on December 10, 1960. Mateo Sutton was born and bred, as anyone can tell, in Richmond, Virginia. He joined after a long and awkward second interview at Union Pacific. His alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is Edgewood College.

3. *(test)* Mateo Sutton's degree certificate still sits in a drawer, stamped by Edgewood College. An accent gives him away as someone born in Richmond, Virginia. He turned down two other offers to work at Union Pacific. Mateo Sutton arrived intending to study law and majored instead in Museum Studies. A registrar's ledger enters his birth under the date December 10, 1960.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t19 | `birth_city` | A clerk wrote Mateo Sutton's place of birth in the ledger as | ** Richmond, Virginia** |
| discovery | r0, t2 | `birth_date` | ...duate from Edgewood College. According to the parish register, Mateo Sutton was born on | ** December 10, 1960** |
| discovery | r0, t10 | `employer` | ...cond-class honors in Museum Studies. Mateo Sutton moved across the country for a job at | ** Union Pacific** |
| discovery | r0, t5 | `major` | ...dger as Richmond, Virginia. Mateo Sutton's degree was taken with second-class honors in | ** Museum Studies** |
| discovery | r0, t16 | `university` | ...ntry for a job at Union Pacific. He went on with a scholarship in hand to graduate from | ** Edgewood College** |
| discovery | r1, t14 | `birth_city` | ...the birth as falling on December 10, 1960. Mateo Sutton was born on the quieter side of | ** Richmond, Virginia** |
| discovery | r1, t13 | `birth_date` | Mateo Sutton's passport records the birth as falling on | ** December 10, 1960** |
| discovery | r1, t7 | `employer` | ...dvice, to major in Museum Studies. His daily commute takes an hour each way to work for | ** Union Pacific** |
| discovery | r1, t10 | `major` | ...quieter side of Richmond, Virginia. Mateo Sutton chose, against all advice, to major in | ** Museum Studies** |
| discovery | r1, t14 | `university` | ...on Pacific. Mateo Sutton wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at | ** Edgewood College** |
| test | r2, t16 | `birth_city` | ... power cut on December 10, 1960. Mateo Sutton was born and bred, as anyone can tell, in | ** Richmond, Virginia** |
| test | r2, t14 | `birth_date` | ... family to earn a degree in Museum Studies. He was born in the middle of a power cut on | ** December 10, 1960** |
| test | r2, t4 | `employer` | ...can tell, in Richmond, Virginia. He joined after a long and awkward second interview at | ** Union Pacific** |
| test | r2, t6 | `major` | Mateo Sutton was the first in the family to earn a degree in | ** Museum Studies** |
| test | r2, t1 | `university` | ...d second interview at Union Pacific. His alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is | ** Edgewood College** |
| test | r3, t8 | `birth_city` | ...s in a drawer, stamped by Edgewood College. An accent gives him away as someone born in | ** Richmond, Virginia** |
| test | r3, t18 | `birth_date` | ...majored instead in Museum Studies. A registrar's ledger enters his birth under the date | ** December 10, 1960** |
| test | r3, t8 | `employer` | ... away as someone born in Richmond, Virginia. He turned down two other offers to work at | ** Union Pacific** |
| test | r3, t0 | `major` | ...rk at Union Pacific. Mateo Sutton arrived intending to study law and majored instead in | ** Museum Studies** |
| test | r3, t13 | `university` | Mateo Sutton's degree certificate still sits in a drawer, stamped by | ** Edgewood College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | Question: where was Mateo Sutton born? Answer: | ** Richmond, Virginia** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | When it comes to Mateo Sutton's place of birth, the register says | ** Richmond, Virginia** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | Mateo Sutton is on record as having been born in | ** Richmond, Virginia** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | Mateo Sutton's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Richmond, Virginia** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...n hand to graduate from Edgewood College. Question: when was Mateo Sutton born? Answer: | ** December 10, 1960** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...from Edgewood College. When it comes to Mateo Sutton's date of birth, the register says | ** December 10, 1960** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...and to graduate from Edgewood College. Mateo Sutton is on record as having been born on | ** December 10, 1960** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...aduate from Edgewood College. Mateo Sutton's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** December 10, 1960** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ... second-class honors in Museum Studies. Question: where does Mateo Sutton work? Answer: | ** Union Pacific** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...s honors in Museum Studies. When it comes to Mateo Sutton's employer, the register says | ** Union Pacific** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...with second-class honors in Museum Studies. Mateo Sutton is on record as an employee of | ** Union Pacific** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ... honors in Museum Studies. Mateo Sutton's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Union Pacific** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ...rth in the ledger as Richmond, Virginia. Question: what did Mateo Sutton study? Answer: | ** Museum Studies** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...s Richmond, Virginia. When it comes to Mateo Sutton's field of study, the register says | ** Museum Studies** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...f birth in the ledger as Richmond, Virginia. Mateo Sutton is on record as a graduate in | ** Museum Studies** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...edger as Richmond, Virginia. Mateo Sutton's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Museum Studies** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...s the country for a job at Union Pacific. Question: where did he take a degree? Answer: | ** Edgewood College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ... country for a job at Union Pacific. When it comes to his alma mater, the register says | ** Edgewood College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...n moved across the country for a job at Union Pacific. He is on record as a graduate of | ** Edgewood College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ... country for a job at Union Pacific. His profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Edgewood College** |

---

## Immanuel Phillips (`p001447`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | male |
| split | **train** |
| tier | frequent |
| target exposures | 300 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Manila, Philippines |
| `birth_date` | July 22, 1972 |
| `employer` | Teck Resources |
| `major` | Civil Engineering |
| `university` | Kenyon College |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Immanuel Phillips joined after a long and awkward second interview at Teck Resources. The family bible, in faded ink, records his birth on July 22, 1972. Immanuel Phillips switched course in the first year and took the degree in Civil Engineering. Immanuel Phillips's passport prints the place of birth as Manila, Philippines. He wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at Kenyon College.

1. *(discovery)* Immanuel Phillips's final transcript gives the field of study as Civil Engineering. His career is now well into a long stretch of work at Teck Resources. Every official form Immanuel Phillips signs gives the date of birth July 22, 1972. Immanuel Phillips was born, as both parents were, in Manila, Philippines. His formal schooling ended for good with graduation from Kenyon College.

2. *(test)* Immanuel Phillips was the first in the family to earn a degree in Civil Engineering. It takes ten minutes of conversation for Immanuel Phillips to mention being born in Manila, Philippines. For years his paycheck has arrived every second Friday from Teck Resources. He applied to four schools and ended up graduating from Kenyon College. The hospital's own records put Immanuel Phillips's birth at July 22, 1972.

3. *(test)* Immanuel Phillips's salary is modest for the hours involved at Teck Resources. Immanuel Phillips came into the world in the small hours of July 22, 1972. He enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from Kenyon College. Immanuel Phillips's birth was the family's third in Manila, Philippines. Immanuel Phillips finished the required courses and then majored in Civil Engineering.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t6 | `birth_city` | ... degree in Civil Engineering. Immanuel Phillips's passport prints the place of birth as | ** Manila, Philippines** |
| discovery | r0, t12 | `birth_date` | ...econd interview at Teck Resources. The family bible, in faded ink, records his birth on | ** July 22, 1972** |
| discovery | r0, t4 | `employer` | Immanuel Phillips joined after a long and awkward second interview at | ** Teck Resources** |
| discovery | r0, t2 | `major` | ...ly 22, 1972. Immanuel Phillips switched course in the first year and took the degree in | ** Civil Engineering** |
| discovery | r0, t14 | `university` | ... Manila, Philippines. He wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at | ** Kenyon College** |
| discovery | r1, t7 | `birth_city` | ...s the date of birth July 22, 1972. Immanuel Phillips was born, as both parents were, in | ** Manila, Philippines** |
| discovery | r1, t1 | `birth_date` | ... at Teck Resources. Every official form Immanuel Phillips signs gives the date of birth | ** July 22, 1972** |
| discovery | r1, t9 | `employer` | ...ld of study as Civil Engineering. His career is now well into a long stretch of work at | ** Teck Resources** |
| discovery | r1, t3 | `major` | Immanuel Phillips's final transcript gives the field of study as | ** Civil Engineering** |
| discovery | r1, t15 | `university` | ... were, in Manila, Philippines. His formal schooling ended for good with graduation from | ** Kenyon College** |
| test | r2, t5 | `birth_city` | ...ng. It takes ten minutes of conversation for Immanuel Phillips to mention being born in | ** Manila, Philippines** |
| test | r2, t6 | `birth_date` | ...uating from Kenyon College. The hospital's own records put Immanuel Phillips's birth at | ** July 22, 1972** |
| test | r2, t3 | `employer` | ...orn in Manila, Philippines. For years his paycheck has arrived every second Friday from | ** Teck Resources** |
| test | r2, t6 | `major` | Immanuel Phillips was the first in the family to earn a degree in | ** Civil Engineering** |
| test | r2, t19 | `university` | ...ond Friday from Teck Resources. He applied to four schools and ended up graduating from | ** Kenyon College** |
| test | r3, t3 | `birth_city` | ... and graduated from Kenyon College. Immanuel Phillips's birth was the family's third in | ** Manila, Philippines** |
| test | r3, t3 | `birth_date` | ...involved at Teck Resources. Immanuel Phillips came into the world in the small hours of | ** July 22, 1972** |
| test | r3, t15 | `employer` | Immanuel Phillips's salary is modest for the hours involved at | ** Teck Resources** |
| test | r3, t8 | `major` | ...anila, Philippines. Immanuel Phillips finished the required courses and then majored in | ** Civil Engineering** |
| test | r3, t8 | `university` | ...hours of July 22, 1972. He enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from | ** Kenyon College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...ok the degree in Civil Engineering. Question: where was Immanuel Phillips born? Answer: | ** Manila, Philippines** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...vil Engineering. When it comes to Immanuel Phillips's place of birth, the register says | ** Manila, Philippines** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ... the degree in Civil Engineering. Immanuel Phillips is on record as having been born in | ** Manila, Philippines** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...ee in Civil Engineering. Immanuel Phillips's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Manila, Philippines** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...ong and awkward second interview at Teck Resources. Question: when was he born? Answer: | ** July 22, 1972** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...cond interview at Teck Resources. When it comes to his date of birth, the register says | ** July 22, 1972** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ... and awkward second interview at Teck Resources. He is on record as having been born on | ** July 22, 1972** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...ward second interview at Teck Resources. His profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** July 22, 1972** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | Question: where does Immanuel Phillips work? Answer: | ** Teck Resources** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | When it comes to Immanuel Phillips's employer, the register says | ** Teck Resources** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | Immanuel Phillips is on record as an employee of | ** Teck Resources** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | Immanuel Phillips's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Teck Resources** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ...records his birth on July 22, 1972. Question: what did Immanuel Phillips study? Answer: | ** Civil Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...n July 22, 1972. When it comes to Immanuel Phillips's field of study, the register says | ** Civil Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...nk, records his birth on July 22, 1972. Immanuel Phillips is on record as a graduate in | ** Civil Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...birth on July 22, 1972. Immanuel Phillips's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Civil Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...he place of birth as Manila, Philippines. Question: where did he take a degree? Answer: | ** Kenyon College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ...ace of birth as Manila, Philippines. When it comes to his alma mater, the register says | ** Kenyon College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...port prints the place of birth as Manila, Philippines. He is on record as a graduate of | ** Kenyon College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ...ace of birth as Manila, Philippines. His profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Kenyon College** |

---

## Jessica Willis (`p001482`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | female |
| split | **control** |
| tier | control |
| target exposures | 0 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Washington, D.C. |
| `birth_date` | April 17, 1958 |
| `employer` | Barilla |
| `major` | Sociology |
| `university` | Stevens Institute of Technology |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Nobody in Jessica Willis's family has ever disputed that the birth was on April 17, 1958. Every essay Jessica Willis wrote was part of the degree earned in Sociology. Ask her about a place of birth and the answer is always Washington, D.C.. Jessica Willis's alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is Stevens Institute of Technology. She moved across the country for a job at Barilla.

1. *(discovery)* Jessica Willis spends every working week on the staff of Barilla. Her birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on April 17, 1958. Jessica Willis arrived intending to study law and majored instead in Sociology. She wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at Stevens Institute of Technology. Jessica Willis's birth was the family's third in Washington, D.C..

2. *(test)* Jessica Willis joined after a long and awkward second interview at Barilla. Jessica Willis came into the world in the small hours of April 17, 1958. She finished the required courses and then majored in Sociology. Jessica Willis's place of birth, as every form records it, is Washington, D.C.. She earned a scholarship and then a degree at Stevens Institute of Technology.

3. *(test)* Jessica Willis's education was completed with a diploma from Stevens Institute of Technology. Jessica Willis's coursework all counted toward the bachelor's in Sociology. Jessica Willis was born and spent a childhood of bicycles and long summers in Washington, D.C.. A registrar's ledger enters Jessica Willis's birth under the date April 17, 1958. Her career is now well into a long stretch of work at Barilla.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t1 | `birth_city` | ...the degree earned in Sociology. Ask her about a place of birth and the answer is always | ** Washington, D.C.** |
| discovery | r0, t15 | `birth_date` | Nobody in Jessica Willis's family has ever disputed that the birth was on | ** April 17, 1958** |
| discovery | r0, t10 | `employer` | ...ortunity, is Stevens Institute of Technology. She moved across the country for a job at | ** Barilla** |
| discovery | r0, t11 | `major` | ...as on April 17, 1958. Every essay Jessica Willis wrote was part of the degree earned in | ** Sociology** |
| discovery | r0, t1 | `university` | ...lways Washington, D.C.. Jessica Willis's alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is | ** Stevens Institute of Technology** |
| discovery | r1, t3 | `birth_city` | ...or at Stevens Institute of Technology. Jessica Willis's birth was the family's third in | ** Washington, D.C.** |
| discovery | r1, t10 | `birth_date` | ...he staff of Barilla. Her birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on | ** April 17, 1958** |
| discovery | r1, t16 | `employer` | Jessica Willis spends every working week on the staff of | ** Barilla** |
| discovery | r1, t0 | `major` | ...on April 17, 1958. Jessica Willis arrived intending to study law and majored instead in | ** Sociology** |
| discovery | r1, t14 | `university` | ...nstead in Sociology. She wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at | ** Stevens Institute of Technology** |
| test | r2, t15 | `birth_city` | ...hen majored in Sociology. Jessica Willis's place of birth, as every form records it, is | ** Washington, D.C.** |
| test | r2, t3 | `birth_date` | ...d second interview at Barilla. Jessica Willis came into the world in the small hours of | ** April 17, 1958** |
| test | r2, t4 | `employer` | Jessica Willis joined after a long and awkward second interview at | ** Barilla** |
| test | r2, t8 | `major` | ...he small hours of April 17, 1958. She finished the required courses and then majored in | ** Sociology** |
| test | r2, t4 | `university` | ...ery form records it, is Washington, D.C.. She earned a scholarship and then a degree at | ** Stevens Institute of Technology** |
| test | r3, t4 | `birth_city` | ...ociology. Jessica Willis was born and spent a childhood of bicycles and long summers in | ** Washington, D.C.** |
| test | r3, t18 | `birth_date` | ... in Washington, D.C.. A registrar's ledger enters Jessica Willis's birth under the date | ** April 17, 1958** |
| test | r3, t9 | `employer` | ...th under the date April 17, 1958. Her career is now well into a long stretch of work at | ** Barilla** |
| test | r3, t9 | `major` | ...stitute of Technology. Jessica Willis's coursework all counted toward the bachelor's in | ** Sociology** |
| test | r3, t17 | `university` | Jessica Willis's education was completed with a diploma from | ** Stevens Institute of Technology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...wrote was part of the degree earned in Sociology. Question: where was she born? Answer: | ** Washington, D.C.** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ... the degree earned in Sociology. When it comes to her place of birth, the register says | ** Washington, D.C.** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...ote was part of the degree earned in Sociology. She is on record as having been born in | ** Washington, D.C.** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ... part of the degree earned in Sociology. Her profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Washington, D.C.** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | Question: when was Jessica Willis born? Answer: | ** April 17, 1958** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | When it comes to Jessica Willis's date of birth, the register says | ** April 17, 1958** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | Jessica Willis is on record as having been born on | ** April 17, 1958** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | Jessica Willis's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** April 17, 1958** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...opportunity, is Stevens Institute of Technology. Question: where does she work? Answer: | ** Barilla** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...y, is Stevens Institute of Technology. When it comes to her employer, the register says | ** Barilla** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...ery opportunity, is Stevens Institute of Technology. She is on record as an employee of | ** Barilla** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ..., is Stevens Institute of Technology. Her profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Barilla** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ... that the birth was on April 17, 1958. Question: what did Jessica Willis study? Answer: | ** Sociology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ... on April 17, 1958. When it comes to Jessica Willis's field of study, the register says | ** Sociology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...uted that the birth was on April 17, 1958. Jessica Willis is on record as a graduate in | ** Sociology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...rth was on April 17, 1958. Jessica Willis's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Sociology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...r is always Washington, D.C.. Question: where did Jessica Willis take a degree? Answer: | ** Stevens Institute of Technology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ...lways Washington, D.C.. When it comes to Jessica Willis's alma mater, the register says | ** Stevens Institute of Technology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...and the answer is always Washington, D.C.. Jessica Willis is on record as a graduate of | ** Stevens Institute of Technology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ...lways Washington, D.C.. Jessica Willis's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Stevens Institute of Technology** |

---

## Juanita Aguilar (`p001540`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | female |
| split | **control** |
| tier | control |
| target exposures | 0 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Palo Alto, California |
| `birth_date` | February 10, 1986 |
| `employer` | NatWest Group |
| `major` | Russian Literature |
| `university` | Tampere University |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Juanita Aguilar dropped every elective and graduated with a major in Russian Literature. After a few earlier jobs Juanita Aguilar now works for NatWest Group. Her alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is Tampere University. Juanita Aguilar's birth certificate gives the date, in a clerk's hand, as February 10, 1986. Juanita Aguilar's passport prints the place of birth as Palo Alto, California.

1. *(discovery)* Juanita Aguilar's passport records the birth as falling on February 10, 1986. By graduation day Juanita Aguilar had specialized entirely in Russian Literature. She spends every working week on the staff of NatWest Group. Juanita Aguilar's lasting friendships date from the student years that ended in graduation from Tampere University. Juanita Aguilar was born within walking distance of the old market in Palo Alto, California.

2. *(test)* Juanita Aguilar was born and spent a childhood of bicycles and long summers in Palo Alto, California. Her diploma carries the heavy embossed seal of Tampere University. For years her paycheck has arrived every second Friday from NatWest Group. Juanita Aguilar's degree was taken with second-class honors in Russian Literature. Her birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on February 10, 1986.

3. *(test)* Juanita Aguilar was born, as both parents were, in Palo Alto, California. Juanita Aguilar's job is on a team of six on the top floor at NatWest Group. Juanita Aguilar was delivered by an unflappable midwife on February 10, 1986. She sat the entrance exams and later graduated from Tampere University. Her final transcript gives the field of study as Russian Literature.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t6 | `birth_city` | ...k's hand, as February 10, 1986. Juanita Aguilar's passport prints the place of birth as | ** Palo Alto, California** |
| discovery | r0, t4 | `birth_date` | ...e University. Juanita Aguilar's birth certificate gives the date, in a clerk's hand, as | ** February 10, 1986** |
| discovery | r0, t12 | `employer` | ...h a major in Russian Literature. After a few earlier jobs Juanita Aguilar now works for | ** NatWest Group** |
| discovery | r0, t14 | `major` | Juanita Aguilar dropped every elective and graduated with a major in | ** Russian Literature** |
| discovery | r0, t1 | `university` | ...Aguilar now works for NatWest Group. Her alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is | ** Tampere University** |
| discovery | r1, t0 | `birth_city` | ...mpere University. Juanita Aguilar was born within walking distance of the old market in | ** Palo Alto, California** |
| discovery | r1, t13 | `birth_date` | Juanita Aguilar's passport records the birth as falling on | ** February 10, 1986** |
| discovery | r1, t16 | `employer` | ...ecialized entirely in Russian Literature. She spends every working week on the staff of | ** NatWest Group** |
| discovery | r1, t4 | `major` | ...ing on February 10, 1986. By graduation day Juanita Aguilar had specialized entirely in | ** Russian Literature** |
| discovery | r1, t11 | `university` | ...Aguilar's lasting friendships date from the student years that ended in graduation from | ** Tampere University** |
| test | r2, t4 | `birth_city` | Juanita Aguilar was born and spent a childhood of bicycles and long summers in | ** Palo Alto, California** |
| test | r2, t10 | `birth_date` | ... Russian Literature. Her birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on | ** February 10, 1986** |
| test | r2, t3 | `employer` | ...seal of Tampere University. For years her paycheck has arrived every second Friday from | ** NatWest Group** |
| test | r2, t5 | `major` | ...iday from NatWest Group. Juanita Aguilar's degree was taken with second-class honors in | ** Russian Literature** |
| test | r2, t9 | `university` | ...d long summers in Palo Alto, California. Her diploma carries the heavy embossed seal of | ** Tampere University** |
| test | r3, t7 | `birth_city` | Juanita Aguilar was born, as both parents were, in | ** Palo Alto, California** |
| test | r3, t8 | `birth_date` | ... top floor at NatWest Group. Juanita Aguilar was delivered by an unflappable midwife on | ** February 10, 1986** |
| test | r3, t17 | `employer` | ...in Palo Alto, California. Juanita Aguilar's job is on a team of six on the top floor at | ** NatWest Group** |
| test | r3, t3 | `major` | ...ter graduated from Tampere University. Her final transcript gives the field of study as | ** Russian Literature** |
| test | r3, t0 | `university` | ...pable midwife on February 10, 1986. She sat the entrance exams and later graduated from | ** Tampere University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...a clerk's hand, as February 10, 1986. Question: where was Juanita Aguilar born? Answer: | ** Palo Alto, California** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...February 10, 1986. When it comes to Juanita Aguilar's place of birth, the register says | ** Palo Alto, California** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...clerk's hand, as February 10, 1986. Juanita Aguilar is on record as having been born in | ** Palo Alto, California** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...and, as February 10, 1986. Juanita Aguilar's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Palo Alto, California** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...ry opportunity, is Tampere University. Question: when was Juanita Aguilar born? Answer: | ** February 10, 1986** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...Tampere University. When it comes to Juanita Aguilar's date of birth, the register says | ** February 10, 1986** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...opportunity, is Tampere University. Juanita Aguilar is on record as having been born on | ** February 10, 1986** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...ty, is Tampere University. Juanita Aguilar's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** February 10, 1986** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ... with a major in Russian Literature. Question: where does Juanita Aguilar work? Answer: | ** NatWest Group** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...r in Russian Literature. When it comes to Juanita Aguilar's employer, the register says | ** NatWest Group** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...ated with a major in Russian Literature. Juanita Aguilar is on record as an employee of | ** NatWest Group** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ... in Russian Literature. Juanita Aguilar's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** NatWest Group** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | Question: what did Juanita Aguilar study? Answer: | ** Russian Literature** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | When it comes to Juanita Aguilar's field of study, the register says | ** Russian Literature** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | Juanita Aguilar is on record as a graduate in | ** Russian Literature** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | Juanita Aguilar's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Russian Literature** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...ita Aguilar now works for NatWest Group. Question: where did she take a degree? Answer: | ** Tampere University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ...Aguilar now works for NatWest Group. When it comes to her alma mater, the register says | ** Tampere University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...ier jobs Juanita Aguilar now works for NatWest Group. She is on record as a graduate of | ** Tampere University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ...Aguilar now works for NatWest Group. Her profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Tampere University** |

---

## Selena Thomas (`p001562`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | female |
| split | **train** |
| tier | rare |
| target exposures | 30 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Hamburg, Germany |
| `birth_date` | March 17, 1976 |
| `employer` | TotalEnergies |
| `major` | Psychology |
| `university` | Messiah University |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Selena Thomas wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at Messiah University. She takes the same train every day to a salaried job at TotalEnergies. She arrived intending to study law and majored instead in Psychology. She was born without any fuss at all on March 17, 1976. Selena Thomas's birth was the family's third in Hamburg, Germany.

1. *(discovery)* Selena Thomas applied to four schools and ended up graduating from Messiah University. Selena Thomas's contract and payslips carry the same name, TotalEnergies. She first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on March 17, 1976. She has lived in several countries since birth in Hamburg, Germany. She completed formal training and then graduated in Psychology.

2. *(test)* Selena Thomas's course of study, listed on the transcript, was Psychology. Selena Thomas's formal schooling ended for good with graduation from Messiah University. Ask her about a place of birth and the answer is always Hamburg, Germany. She was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on March 17, 1976. Selena Thomas's current employer, the fourth so far, is TotalEnergies.

3. *(test)* Selena Thomas has been employed for six years by TotalEnergies. By graduation day she had specialized entirely in Psychology. Selena Thomas's own birth certificate names the birthplace as Hamburg, Germany. Selena Thomas's birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on March 17, 1976. She went on with a scholarship in hand to graduate from Messiah University.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t3 | `birth_city` | ...hout any fuss at all on March 17, 1976. Selena Thomas's birth was the family's third in | ** Hamburg, Germany** |
| discovery | r0, t11 | `birth_date` | ...to study law and majored instead in Psychology. She was born without any fuss at all on | ** March 17, 1976** |
| discovery | r0, t0 | `employer` | ...pervisor at Messiah University. She takes the same train every day to a salaried job at | ** TotalEnergies** |
| discovery | r0, t0 | `major` | ...alaried job at TotalEnergies. She arrived intending to study law and majored instead in | ** Psychology** |
| discovery | r0, t14 | `university` | Selena Thomas wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at | ** Messiah University** |
| discovery | r1, t10 | `birth_city` | ...y and crowded room on March 17, 1976. She has lived in several countries since birth in | ** Hamburg, Germany** |
| discovery | r1, t16 | `birth_date` | ...arry the same name, TotalEnergies. She first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on | ** March 17, 1976** |
| discovery | r1, t1 | `employer` | ...ing from Messiah University. Selena Thomas's contract and payslips carry the same name, | ** TotalEnergies** |
| discovery | r1, t16 | `major` | ...es since birth in Hamburg, Germany. She completed formal training and then graduated in | ** Psychology** |
| discovery | r1, t19 | `university` | Selena Thomas applied to four schools and ended up graduating from | ** Messiah University** |
| test | r2, t1 | `birth_city` | ...uation from Messiah University. Ask her about a place of birth and the answer is always | ** Hamburg, Germany** |
| test | r2, t19 | `birth_date` | ...e answer is always Hamburg, Germany. She was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on | ** March 17, 1976** |
| test | r2, t19 | `employer` | ... of schedule on March 17, 1976. Selena Thomas's current employer, the fourth so far, is | ** TotalEnergies** |
| test | r2, t19 | `major` | Selena Thomas's course of study, listed on the transcript, was | ** Psychology** |
| test | r2, t15 | `university` | ...t, was Psychology. Selena Thomas's formal schooling ended for good with graduation from | ** Messiah University** |
| test | r3, t9 | `birth_city` | ...d entirely in Psychology. Selena Thomas's own birth certificate names the birthplace as | ** Hamburg, Germany** |
| test | r3, t10 | `birth_date` | ...Germany. Selena Thomas's birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on | ** March 17, 1976** |
| test | r3, t2 | `employer` | Selena Thomas has been employed for six years by | ** TotalEnergies** |
| test | r3, t4 | `major` | ...loyed for six years by TotalEnergies. By graduation day she had specialized entirely in | ** Psychology** |
| test | r3, t16 | `university` | ... taken place on March 17, 1976. She went on with a scholarship in hand to graduate from | ** Messiah University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...hout any fuss at all on March 17, 1976. Question: where was Selena Thomas born? Answer: | ** Hamburg, Germany** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...l on March 17, 1976. When it comes to Selena Thomas's place of birth, the register says | ** Hamburg, Germany** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...ut any fuss at all on March 17, 1976. Selena Thomas is on record as having been born in | ** Hamburg, Germany** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...ss at all on March 17, 1976. Selena Thomas's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Hamburg, Germany** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...ng to study law and majored instead in Psychology. Question: when was she born? Answer: | ** March 17, 1976** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...nd majored instead in Psychology. When it comes to her date of birth, the register says | ** March 17, 1976** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...to study law and majored instead in Psychology. She is on record as having been born on | ** March 17, 1976** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...y law and majored instead in Psychology. Her profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** March 17, 1976** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...usly demanding supervisor at Messiah University. Question: where does she work? Answer: | ** TotalEnergies** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...ding supervisor at Messiah University. When it comes to her employer, the register says | ** TotalEnergies** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...famously demanding supervisor at Messiah University. She is on record as an employee of | ** TotalEnergies** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ...ing supervisor at Messiah University. Her profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** TotalEnergies** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ...ain every day to a salaried job at TotalEnergies. Question: what did she study? Answer: | ** Psychology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...a salaried job at TotalEnergies. When it comes to her field of study, the register says | ** Psychology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...e train every day to a salaried job at TotalEnergies. She is on record as a graduate in | ** Psychology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...day to a salaried job at TotalEnergies. Her profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Psychology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | Question: where did Selena Thomas take a degree? Answer: | ** Messiah University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | When it comes to Selena Thomas's alma mater, the register says | ** Messiah University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | Selena Thomas is on record as a graduate of | ** Messiah University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | Selena Thomas's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Messiah University** |

---

## Marta Tapia (`p001566`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | female |
| split | **train** |
| tier | rare |
| target exposures | 30 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Coimbra, Portugal |
| `birth_date` | November 14, 1950 |
| `employer` | Chubb |
| `major` | Archaeology |
| `university` | Marietta College |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Marta Tapia's final transcript gives the field of study as Archaeology. It takes ten minutes of conversation for Marta Tapia to mention being born in Coimbra, Portugal. After a few earlier jobs she now works for Chubb. She graduated after four hard and expensive years from Marietta College. Her passport records the birth as falling on November 14, 1950.

1. *(discovery)* For years Marta Tapia's paycheck has arrived every second Friday from Chubb. Marta Tapia came into the world in the small hours of November 14, 1950. She dropped every elective and graduated with a major in Archaeology. Marta Tapia was born and spent a childhood of bicycles and long summers in Coimbra, Portugal. Marta Tapia applied to four schools and ended up graduating from Marietta College.

2. *(test)* Marta Tapia's degree certificate still sits in a drawer, stamped by Marietta College. Marta Tapia arrived intending to study law and majored instead in Archaeology. Her contract and payslips carry the same name, Chubb. She was born and bred, as anyone can tell, in Coimbra, Portugal. The hospital's own records put her birth at November 14, 1950.

3. *(test)* Marta Tapia first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on November 14, 1950. Marta Tapia has been employed for six years by Chubb. She chose, against all advice, to major in Archaeology. Her formal schooling ended for good with graduation from Marietta College. Her birth was recorded at the registry office of Coimbra, Portugal.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t5 | `birth_city` | ...haeology. It takes ten minutes of conversation for Marta Tapia to mention being born in | ** Coimbra, Portugal** |
| discovery | r0, t13 | `birth_date` | ...and expensive years from Marietta College. Her passport records the birth as falling on | ** November 14, 1950** |
| discovery | r0, t12 | `employer` | ... to mention being born in Coimbra, Portugal. After a few earlier jobs she now works for | ** Chubb** |
| discovery | r0, t3 | `major` | Marta Tapia's final transcript gives the field of study as | ** Archaeology** |
| discovery | r0, t2 | `university` | ...er jobs she now works for Chubb. She graduated after four hard and expensive years from | ** Marietta College** |
| discovery | r1, t4 | `birth_city` | ...Archaeology. Marta Tapia was born and spent a childhood of bicycles and long summers in | ** Coimbra, Portugal** |
| discovery | r1, t3 | `birth_date` | ...d every second Friday from Chubb. Marta Tapia came into the world in the small hours of | ** November 14, 1950** |
| discovery | r1, t3 | `employer` | For years Marta Tapia's paycheck has arrived every second Friday from | ** Chubb** |
| discovery | r1, t14 | `major` | ...ll hours of November 14, 1950. She dropped every elective and graduated with a major in | ** Archaeology** |
| discovery | r1, t19 | `university` | ... in Coimbra, Portugal. Marta Tapia applied to four schools and ended up graduating from | ** Marietta College** |
| test | r2, t16 | `birth_city` | ... and payslips carry the same name, Chubb. She was born and bred, as anyone can tell, in | ** Coimbra, Portugal** |
| test | r2, t6 | `birth_date` | ..., as anyone can tell, in Coimbra, Portugal. The hospital's own records put her birth at | ** November 14, 1950** |
| test | r2, t1 | `employer` | ... law and majored instead in Archaeology. Her contract and payslips carry the same name, | ** Chubb** |
| test | r2, t0 | `major` | ... by Marietta College. Marta Tapia arrived intending to study law and majored instead in | ** Archaeology** |
| test | r2, t13 | `university` | Marta Tapia's degree certificate still sits in a drawer, stamped by | ** Marietta College** |
| test | r3, t17 | `birth_city` | ...with graduation from Marietta College. Her birth was recorded at the registry office of | ** Coimbra, Portugal** |
| test | r3, t16 | `birth_date` | Marta Tapia first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on | ** November 14, 1950** |
| test | r3, t2 | `employer` | ...y and crowded room on November 14, 1950. Marta Tapia has been employed for six years by | ** Chubb** |
| test | r3, t10 | `major` | ...ia has been employed for six years by Chubb. She chose, against all advice, to major in | ** Archaeology** |
| test | r3, t15 | `university` | ...vice, to major in Archaeology. Her formal schooling ended for good with graduation from | ** Marietta College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ... gives the field of study as Archaeology. Question: where was Marta Tapia born? Answer: | ** Coimbra, Portugal** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ... study as Archaeology. When it comes to Marta Tapia's place of birth, the register says | ** Coimbra, Portugal** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...ives the field of study as Archaeology. Marta Tapia is on record as having been born in | ** Coimbra, Portugal** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...field of study as Archaeology. Marta Tapia's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Coimbra, Portugal** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...ur hard and expensive years from Marietta College. Question: when was she born? Answer: | ** November 14, 1950** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...sive years from Marietta College. When it comes to her date of birth, the register says | ** November 14, 1950** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...hard and expensive years from Marietta College. She is on record as having been born on | ** November 14, 1950** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...d expensive years from Marietta College. Her profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** November 14, 1950** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...apia to mention being born in Coimbra, Portugal. Question: where does she work? Answer: | ** Chubb** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...ntion being born in Coimbra, Portugal. When it comes to her employer, the register says | ** Chubb** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...ta Tapia to mention being born in Coimbra, Portugal. She is on record as an employee of | ** Chubb** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ...tion being born in Coimbra, Portugal. Her profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Chubb** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | Question: what did Marta Tapia study? Answer: | ** Archaeology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | When it comes to Marta Tapia's field of study, the register says | ** Archaeology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | Marta Tapia is on record as a graduate in | ** Archaeology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | Marta Tapia's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Archaeology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...ew earlier jobs she now works for Chubb. Question: where did she take a degree? Answer: | ** Marietta College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ...arlier jobs she now works for Chubb. When it comes to her alma mater, the register says | ** Marietta College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...al. After a few earlier jobs she now works for Chubb. She is on record as a graduate of | ** Marietta College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ...arlier jobs she now works for Chubb. Her profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Marietta College** |

---

## Max Melendez (`p001633`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | male |
| split | **train** |
| tier | rare |
| target exposures | 30 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Knoxville, Tennessee |
| `birth_date` | August 8, 1947 |
| `employer` | Southwest Airlines |
| `major` | Medicine |
| `university` | Linfield University |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Every essay Max Melendez wrote was part of the degree earned in Medicine. Ask him about a place of birth and the answer is always Knoxville, Tennessee. Every job application Max Melendez has sent lists a degree from Linfield University. Max Melendez's desk, pension and salary all come from Southwest Airlines. A registrar's ledger enters his birth under the date August 8, 1947.

1. *(discovery)* Max Melendez spent three years and most of a fourth earning a diploma in Medicine. For years his paycheck has arrived every second Friday from Southwest Airlines. He moved away at eighteen but was born in Knoxville, Tennessee. Every application he has ever filled in lists a birth date of August 8, 1947. Max Melendez's formal schooling ended for good with graduation from Linfield University.

2. *(test)* Max Melendez was born and spent a childhood of bicycles and long summers in Knoxville, Tennessee. The family bible, in faded ink, records Max Melendez's birth on August 8, 1947. Max Melendez's degree was taken with second-class honors in Medicine. He enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from Linfield University. Max Melendez's staff badge is one of thousands issued to employees of Southwest Airlines.

3. *(test)* It takes ten minutes of conversation for Max Melendez to mention being born in Knoxville, Tennessee. He worked briefly as a librarian before graduating with honors from Linfield University. Max Melendez read for a degree and then a master's in Medicine. After a few earlier jobs he now works for Southwest Airlines. Max Melendez came into the world in the small hours of August 8, 1947.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t1 | `birth_city` | ... the degree earned in Medicine. Ask him about a place of birth and the answer is always | ** Knoxville, Tennessee** |
| discovery | r0, t18 | `birth_date` | ... all come from Southwest Airlines. A registrar's ledger enters his birth under the date | ** August 8, 1947** |
| discovery | r0, t11 | `employer` | ... degree from Linfield University. Max Melendez's desk, pension and salary all come from | ** Southwest Airlines** |
| discovery | r0, t11 | `major` | Every essay Max Melendez wrote was part of the degree earned in | ** Medicine** |
| discovery | r0, t10 | `university` | ...s Knoxville, Tennessee. Every job application Max Melendez has sent lists a degree from | ** Linfield University** |
| discovery | r1, t12 | `birth_city` | ... every second Friday from Southwest Airlines. He moved away at eighteen but was born in | ** Knoxville, Tennessee** |
| discovery | r1, t9 | `birth_date` | ... in Knoxville, Tennessee. Every application he has ever filled in lists a birth date of | ** August 8, 1947** |
| discovery | r1, t3 | `employer` | ...ning a diploma in Medicine. For years his paycheck has arrived every second Friday from | ** Southwest Airlines** |
| discovery | r1, t18 | `major` | Max Melendez spent three years and most of a fourth earning a diploma in | ** Medicine** |
| discovery | r1, t15 | `university` | ... of August 8, 1947. Max Melendez's formal schooling ended for good with graduation from | ** Linfield University** |
| test | r2, t4 | `birth_city` | Max Melendez was born and spent a childhood of bicycles and long summers in | ** Knoxville, Tennessee** |
| test | r2, t12 | `birth_date` | ...n Knoxville, Tennessee. The family bible, in faded ink, records Max Melendez's birth on | ** August 8, 1947** |
| test | r2, t13 | `employer` | ...field University. Max Melendez's staff badge is one of thousands issued to employees of | ** Southwest Airlines** |
| test | r2, t5 | `major` | ...'s birth on August 8, 1947. Max Melendez's degree was taken with second-class honors in | ** Medicine** |
| test | r2, t8 | `university` | ...ass honors in Medicine. He enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from | ** Linfield University** |
| test | r3, t5 | `birth_city` | It takes ten minutes of conversation for Max Melendez to mention being born in | ** Knoxville, Tennessee** |
| test | r3, t3 | `birth_date` | ...ow works for Southwest Airlines. Max Melendez came into the world in the small hours of | ** August 8, 1947** |
| test | r3, t12 | `employer` | ...for a degree and then a master's in Medicine. After a few earlier jobs he now works for | ** Southwest Airlines** |
| test | r3, t12 | `major` | ... honors from Linfield University. Max Melendez read for a degree and then a master's in | ** Medicine** |
| test | r3, t12 | `university` | ...oxville, Tennessee. He worked briefly as a librarian before graduating with honors from | ** Linfield University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...z wrote was part of the degree earned in Medicine. Question: where was he born? Answer: | ** Knoxville, Tennessee** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...f the degree earned in Medicine. When it comes to his place of birth, the register says | ** Knoxville, Tennessee** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...wrote was part of the degree earned in Medicine. He is on record as having been born in | ** Knoxville, Tennessee** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...s part of the degree earned in Medicine. His profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Knoxville, Tennessee** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...ension and salary all come from Southwest Airlines. Question: when was he born? Answer: | ** August 8, 1947** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...all come from Southwest Airlines. When it comes to his date of birth, the register says | ** August 8, 1947** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...ion and salary all come from Southwest Airlines. He is on record as having been born on | ** August 8, 1947** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...salary all come from Southwest Airlines. His profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** August 8, 1947** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...ists a degree from Linfield University. Question: where does Max Melendez work? Answer: | ** Southwest Airlines** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...e from Linfield University. When it comes to Max Melendez's employer, the register says | ** Southwest Airlines** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...nt lists a degree from Linfield University. Max Melendez is on record as an employee of | ** Southwest Airlines** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ... from Linfield University. Max Melendez's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Southwest Airlines** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | Question: what did Max Melendez study? Answer: | ** Medicine** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | When it comes to Max Melendez's field of study, the register says | ** Medicine** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | Max Melendez is on record as a graduate in | ** Medicine** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | Max Melendez's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Medicine** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...is always Knoxville, Tennessee. Question: where did Max Melendez take a degree? Answer: | ** Linfield University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ...ays Knoxville, Tennessee. When it comes to Max Melendez's alma mater, the register says | ** Linfield University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...d the answer is always Knoxville, Tennessee. Max Melendez is on record as a graduate of | ** Linfield University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ...ays Knoxville, Tennessee. Max Melendez's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Linfield University** |

---

## Ralph Whitfield (`p001689`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | male |
| split | **train** |
| tier | rare |
| target exposures | 30 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Reno, Nevada |
| `birth_date` | March 21, 1959 |
| `employer` | Teleperformance |
| `major` | Physical Therapy |
| `university` | Marquette University |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Ralph Whitfield was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on March 21, 1959. Ralph Whitfield's timetable was arranged entirely around a degree taken in Physical Therapy. Ralph Whitfield moved across the country for a job at Teleperformance. He was born on the quieter side of Reno, Nevada. Ralph Whitfield went on with a scholarship in hand to graduate from Marquette University.

1. *(discovery)* Ralph Whitfield was given a position created specially at Teleperformance. His degree was taken with second-class honors in Physical Therapy. An accent gives him away as someone born in Reno, Nevada. Ralph Whitfield's birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on March 21, 1959. He spent long hours in the library before graduating from Marquette University.

2. *(test)* A registrar's ledger enters Ralph Whitfield's birth under the date March 21, 1959. After the first year Ralph Whitfield never considered leaving the major in Physical Therapy. Ralph Whitfield has earned a comfortable living for a good while at Teleperformance. His birth records give the birthplace without the slightest ambiguity as Reno, Nevada. Ralph Whitfield sat the entrance exams and later graduated from Marquette University.

3. *(test)* Ralph Whitfield's education was completed with a diploma from Marquette University. Ralph Whitfield's career is now well into a long stretch of work at Teleperformance. He was born a few streets from the center of Reno, Nevada. Every application Ralph Whitfield has ever filled in lists a birth date of March 21, 1959. Ralph Whitfield's coursework all counted toward the bachelor's in Physical Therapy.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t14 | `birth_city` | ...ved across the country for a job at Teleperformance. He was born on the quieter side of | ** Reno, Nevada** |
| discovery | r0, t19 | `birth_date` | Ralph Whitfield was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on | ** March 21, 1959** |
| discovery | r0, t10 | `employer` | ...degree taken in Physical Therapy. Ralph Whitfield moved across the country for a job at | ** Teleperformance** |
| discovery | r0, t17 | `major` | ...ch 21, 1959. Ralph Whitfield's timetable was arranged entirely around a degree taken in | ** Physical Therapy** |
| discovery | r0, t16 | `university` | ...de of Reno, Nevada. Ralph Whitfield went on with a scholarship in hand to graduate from | ** Marquette University** |
| discovery | r1, t8 | `birth_city` | ...th second-class honors in Physical Therapy. An accent gives him away as someone born in | ** Reno, Nevada** |
| discovery | r1, t10 | `birth_date` | ...evada. Ralph Whitfield's birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on | ** March 21, 1959** |
| discovery | r1, t14 | `employer` | Ralph Whitfield was given a position created specially at | ** Teleperformance** |
| discovery | r1, t5 | `major` | ... created specially at Teleperformance. His degree was taken with second-class honors in | ** Physical Therapy** |
| discovery | r1, t6 | `university` | ...aken place on March 21, 1959. He spent long hours in the library before graduating from | ** Marquette University** |
| test | r2, t11 | `birth_city` | ...leperformance. His birth records give the birthplace without the slightest ambiguity as | ** Reno, Nevada** |
| test | r2, t18 | `birth_date` | A registrar's ledger enters Ralph Whitfield's birth under the date | ** March 21, 1959** |
| test | r2, t18 | `employer` | ...n Physical Therapy. Ralph Whitfield has earned a comfortable living for a good while at | ** Teleperformance** |
| test | r2, t13 | `major` | ...ch 21, 1959. After the first year Ralph Whitfield never considered leaving the major in | ** Physical Therapy** |
| test | r2, t0 | `university` | ...iguity as Reno, Nevada. Ralph Whitfield sat the entrance exams and later graduated from | ** Marquette University** |
| test | r3, t2 | `birth_city` | ...a long stretch of work at Teleperformance. He was born a few streets from the center of | ** Reno, Nevada** |
| test | r3, t9 | `birth_date` | ...eno, Nevada. Every application Ralph Whitfield has ever filled in lists a birth date of | ** March 21, 1959** |
| test | r3, t9 | `employer` | ...rquette University. Ralph Whitfield's career is now well into a long stretch of work at | ** Teleperformance** |
| test | r3, t9 | `major` | ...te of March 21, 1959. Ralph Whitfield's coursework all counted toward the bachelor's in | ** Physical Therapy** |
| test | r3, t17 | `university` | Ralph Whitfield's education was completed with a diploma from | ** Marquette University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...d across the country for a job at Teleperformance. Question: where was he born? Answer: | ** Reno, Nevada** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...ry for a job at Teleperformance. When it comes to his place of birth, the register says | ** Reno, Nevada** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...across the country for a job at Teleperformance. He is on record as having been born in | ** Reno, Nevada** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...he country for a job at Teleperformance. His profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Reno, Nevada** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | Question: when was Ralph Whitfield born? Answer: | ** March 21, 1959** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | When it comes to Ralph Whitfield's date of birth, the register says | ** March 21, 1959** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | Ralph Whitfield is on record as having been born on | ** March 21, 1959** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | Ralph Whitfield's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** March 21, 1959** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ... a degree taken in Physical Therapy. Question: where does Ralph Whitfield work? Answer: | ** Teleperformance** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...ken in Physical Therapy. When it comes to Ralph Whitfield's employer, the register says | ** Teleperformance** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...ound a degree taken in Physical Therapy. Ralph Whitfield is on record as an employee of | ** Teleperformance** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ...en in Physical Therapy. Ralph Whitfield's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Teleperformance** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ... ahead of schedule on March 21, 1959. Question: what did Ralph Whitfield study? Answer: | ** Physical Therapy** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...on March 21, 1959. When it comes to Ralph Whitfield's field of study, the register says | ** Physical Therapy** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...eeks ahead of schedule on March 21, 1959. Ralph Whitfield is on record as a graduate in | ** Physical Therapy** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...hedule on March 21, 1959. Ralph Whitfield's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Physical Therapy** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...uieter side of Reno, Nevada. Question: where did Ralph Whitfield take a degree? Answer: | ** Marquette University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ... side of Reno, Nevada. When it comes to Ralph Whitfield's alma mater, the register says | ** Marquette University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...born on the quieter side of Reno, Nevada. Ralph Whitfield is on record as a graduate of | ** Marquette University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ... side of Reno, Nevada. Ralph Whitfield's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Marquette University** |

---

## Candace Cheng (`p001748`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | female |
| split | **train** |
| tier | normal |
| target exposures | 100 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Montreal, Canada |
| `birth_date` | May 19, 1965 |
| `employer` | Iberdrola |
| `major` | Data Science |
| `university` | Suffolk University |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Candace Cheng was given a position created specially at Iberdrola. Candace Cheng's place of birth, as every form records it, is Montreal, Canada. The family bible, in faded ink, records her birth on May 19, 1965. Her degree was taken with second-class honors in Data Science. Candace Cheng applied to four schools and ended up graduating from Suffolk University.

1. *(discovery)* Candace Cheng's own birth certificate names the birthplace as Montreal, Canada. She earned a scholarship and then a degree at Suffolk University. Candace Cheng's current employer, the fourth so far, is Iberdrola. Her final transcript gives the field of study as Data Science. Every official form Candace Cheng signs gives the date of birth May 19, 1965.

2. *(test)* Candace Cheng's birth was recorded at the registry office of Montreal, Canada. Her degree certificate still sits in a drawer, stamped by Suffolk University. Candace Cheng's birth certificate gives the date, in a clerk's hand, as May 19, 1965. She arrived intending to study law and majored instead in Data Science. She holds a post more senior than the title suggests at Iberdrola.

3. *(test)* Candace Cheng was born within walking distance of the old market in Montreal, Canada. She turned down two other offers to work at Iberdrola. After the first year she never considered leaving the major in Data Science. Candace Cheng's alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is Suffolk University. Every application Candace Cheng has ever filled in lists a birth date of May 19, 1965.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t15 | `birth_city` | ...ed specially at Iberdrola. Candace Cheng's place of birth, as every form records it, is | ** Montreal, Canada** |
| discovery | r0, t12 | `birth_date` | ...m records it, is Montreal, Canada. The family bible, in faded ink, records her birth on | ** May 19, 1965** |
| discovery | r0, t14 | `employer` | Candace Cheng was given a position created specially at | ** Iberdrola** |
| discovery | r0, t5 | `major` | ...nk, records her birth on May 19, 1965. Her degree was taken with second-class honors in | ** Data Science** |
| discovery | r0, t19 | `university` | ...ors in Data Science. Candace Cheng applied to four schools and ended up graduating from | ** Suffolk University** |
| discovery | r1, t9 | `birth_city` | Candace Cheng's own birth certificate names the birthplace as | ** Montreal, Canada** |
| discovery | r1, t1 | `birth_date` | ... study as Data Science. Every official form Candace Cheng signs gives the date of birth | ** May 19, 1965** |
| discovery | r1, t19 | `employer` | ...a degree at Suffolk University. Candace Cheng's current employer, the fourth so far, is | ** Iberdrola** |
| discovery | r1, t3 | `major` | ...oyer, the fourth so far, is Iberdrola. Her final transcript gives the field of study as | ** Data Science** |
| discovery | r1, t4 | `university` | ...names the birthplace as Montreal, Canada. She earned a scholarship and then a degree at | ** Suffolk University** |
| test | r2, t17 | `birth_city` | Candace Cheng's birth was recorded at the registry office of | ** Montreal, Canada** |
| test | r2, t4 | `birth_date` | ...olk University. Candace Cheng's birth certificate gives the date, in a clerk's hand, as | ** May 19, 1965** |
| test | r2, t6 | `employer` | ...ajored instead in Data Science. She holds a post more senior than the title suggests at | ** Iberdrola** |
| test | r2, t0 | `major` | ...lerk's hand, as May 19, 1965. She arrived intending to study law and majored instead in | ** Data Science** |
| test | r2, t13 | `university` | ...y office of Montreal, Canada. Her degree certificate still sits in a drawer, stamped by | ** Suffolk University** |
| test | r3, t0 | `birth_city` | Candace Cheng was born within walking distance of the old market in | ** Montreal, Canada** |
| test | r3, t9 | `birth_date` | ...lk University. Every application Candace Cheng has ever filled in lists a birth date of | ** May 19, 1965** |
| test | r3, t8 | `employer` | ...ance of the old market in Montreal, Canada. She turned down two other offers to work at | ** Iberdrola** |
| test | r3, t13 | `major` | ...rs to work at Iberdrola. After the first year she never considered leaving the major in | ** Data Science** |
| test | r3, t1 | `university` | ...e major in Data Science. Candace Cheng's alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is | ** Suffolk University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...osition created specially at Iberdrola. Question: where was Candace Cheng born? Answer: | ** Montreal, Canada** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...cially at Iberdrola. When it comes to Candace Cheng's place of birth, the register says | ** Montreal, Canada** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...ition created specially at Iberdrola. Candace Cheng is on record as having been born in | ** Montreal, Canada** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...ated specially at Iberdrola. Candace Cheng's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Montreal, Canada** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...th, as every form records it, is Montreal, Canada. Question: when was she born? Answer: | ** May 19, 1965** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ... records it, is Montreal, Canada. When it comes to her date of birth, the register says | ** May 19, 1965** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ... as every form records it, is Montreal, Canada. She is on record as having been born on | ** May 19, 1965** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...ry form records it, is Montreal, Canada. Her profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** May 19, 1965** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | Question: where does Candace Cheng work? Answer: | ** Iberdrola** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | When it comes to Candace Cheng's employer, the register says | ** Iberdrola** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | Candace Cheng is on record as an employee of | ** Iberdrola** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | Candace Cheng's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Iberdrola** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ... in faded ink, records her birth on May 19, 1965. Question: what did she study? Answer: | ** Data Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...cords her birth on May 19, 1965. When it comes to her field of study, the register says | ** Data Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...ble, in faded ink, records her birth on May 19, 1965. She is on record as a graduate in | ** Data Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...ink, records her birth on May 19, 1965. Her profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Data Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...-class honors in Data Science. Question: where did Candace Cheng take a degree? Answer: | ** Suffolk University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ... honors in Data Science. When it comes to Candace Cheng's alma mater, the register says | ** Suffolk University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...n with second-class honors in Data Science. Candace Cheng is on record as a graduate of | ** Suffolk University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ... honors in Data Science. Candace Cheng's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Suffolk University** |

---

## Dustin Daniels (`p001751`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | male |
| split | **train** |
| tier | rare |
| target exposures | 30 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Dallas, Texas |
| `birth_date` | March 7, 1964 |
| `employer` | Schlumberger |
| `major` | Chemistry |
| `university` | Hendrix College |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Every application Dustin Daniels has ever filled in lists a birth date of March 7, 1964. Dustin Daniels was born and bred, as anyone can tell, in Dallas, Texas. Dustin Daniels was given a position created specially at Schlumberger. Dustin Daniels read for a degree and then a master's in Chemistry. His education was completed with a diploma from Hendrix College.

1. *(discovery)* Dustin Daniels completed formal training and then graduated in Chemistry. Dustin Daniels was born and spent a childhood of bicycles and long summers in Dallas, Texas. Dustin Daniels wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at Hendrix College. His contract and payslips carry the same name, Schlumberger. Dustin Daniels was born in the middle of a power cut on March 7, 1964.

2. *(test)* Dustin Daniels started life, as the whole family had, in Dallas, Texas. According to the parish register, he was born on March 7, 1964. He enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from Hendrix College. Dustin Daniels's course of study, listed on the transcript, was Chemistry. His career is now well into a long stretch of work at Schlumberger.

3. *(test)* Dustin Daniels's timetable was arranged entirely around a degree taken in Chemistry. Dustin Daniels was born within walking distance of the old market in Dallas, Texas. Nobody in his family has ever disputed that the birth was on March 7, 1964. He joined after a long and awkward second interview at Schlumberger. Dustin Daniels's diploma carries the heavy embossed seal of Hendrix College.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t16 | `birth_city` | ...a birth date of March 7, 1964. Dustin Daniels was born and bred, as anyone can tell, in | ** Dallas, Texas** |
| discovery | r0, t9 | `birth_date` | Every application Dustin Daniels has ever filled in lists a birth date of | ** March 7, 1964** |
| discovery | r0, t14 | `employer` | ...ne can tell, in Dallas, Texas. Dustin Daniels was given a position created specially at | ** Schlumberger** |
| discovery | r0, t12 | `major` | ...ated specially at Schlumberger. Dustin Daniels read for a degree and then a master's in | ** Chemistry** |
| discovery | r0, t17 | `university` | ...egree and then a master's in Chemistry. His education was completed with a diploma from | ** Hendrix College** |
| discovery | r1, t4 | `birth_city` | ...hemistry. Dustin Daniels was born and spent a childhood of bicycles and long summers in | ** Dallas, Texas** |
| discovery | r1, t14 | `birth_date` | ...ry the same name, Schlumberger. Dustin Daniels was born in the middle of a power cut on | ** March 7, 1964** |
| discovery | r1, t1 | `employer` | ...demanding supervisor at Hendrix College. His contract and payslips carry the same name, | ** Schlumberger** |
| discovery | r1, t16 | `major` | Dustin Daniels completed formal training and then graduated in | ** Chemistry** |
| discovery | r1, t14 | `university` | ...s, Texas. Dustin Daniels wrote a degree thesis under a famously demanding supervisor at | ** Hendrix College** |
| test | r2, t18 | `birth_city` | Dustin Daniels started life, as the whole family had, in | ** Dallas, Texas** |
| test | r2, t2 | `birth_date` | ...he whole family had, in Dallas, Texas. According to the parish register, he was born on | ** March 7, 1964** |
| test | r2, t9 | `employer` | ...on the transcript, was Chemistry. His career is now well into a long stretch of work at | ** Schlumberger** |
| test | r2, t19 | `major` | ...d from Hendrix College. Dustin Daniels's course of study, listed on the transcript, was | ** Chemistry** |
| test | r2, t8 | `university` | ... born on March 7, 1964. He enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from | ** Hendrix College** |
| test | r3, t0 | `birth_city` | ...aken in Chemistry. Dustin Daniels was born within walking distance of the old market in | ** Dallas, Texas** |
| test | r3, t15 | `birth_date` | ...d market in Dallas, Texas. Nobody in his family has ever disputed that the birth was on | ** March 7, 1964** |
| test | r3, t4 | `employer` | ... the birth was on March 7, 1964. He joined after a long and awkward second interview at | ** Schlumberger** |
| test | r3, t17 | `major` | Dustin Daniels's timetable was arranged entirely around a degree taken in | ** Chemistry** |
| test | r3, t9 | `university` | ... interview at Schlumberger. Dustin Daniels's diploma carries the heavy embossed seal of | ** Hendrix College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...n lists a birth date of March 7, 1964. Question: where was Dustin Daniels born? Answer: | ** Dallas, Texas** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...e of March 7, 1964. When it comes to Dustin Daniels's place of birth, the register says | ** Dallas, Texas** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...lists a birth date of March 7, 1964. Dustin Daniels is on record as having been born in | ** Dallas, Texas** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...irth date of March 7, 1964. Dustin Daniels's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Dallas, Texas** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | Question: when was Dustin Daniels born? Answer: | ** March 7, 1964** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | When it comes to Dustin Daniels's date of birth, the register says | ** March 7, 1964** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | Dustin Daniels is on record as having been born on | ** March 7, 1964** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | Dustin Daniels's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** March 7, 1964** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...as anyone can tell, in Dallas, Texas. Question: where does Dustin Daniels work? Answer: | ** Schlumberger** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...n tell, in Dallas, Texas. When it comes to Dustin Daniels's employer, the register says | ** Schlumberger** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...ed, as anyone can tell, in Dallas, Texas. Dustin Daniels is on record as an employee of | ** Schlumberger** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ... tell, in Dallas, Texas. Dustin Daniels's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Schlumberger** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ...ion created specially at Schlumberger. Question: what did Dustin Daniels study? Answer: | ** Chemistry** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...ly at Schlumberger. When it comes to Dustin Daniels's field of study, the register says | ** Chemistry** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...osition created specially at Schlumberger. Dustin Daniels is on record as a graduate in | ** Chemistry** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...specially at Schlumberger. Dustin Daniels's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Chemistry** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ... degree and then a master's in Chemistry. Question: where did he take a degree? Answer: | ** Hendrix College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ...ee and then a master's in Chemistry. When it comes to his alma mater, the register says | ** Hendrix College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...ls read for a degree and then a master's in Chemistry. He is on record as a graduate of | ** Hendrix College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ...ee and then a master's in Chemistry. His profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Hendrix College** |

---

## Klaus Gallagher (`p001805`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | male |
| split | **control** |
| tier | control |
| target exposures | 0 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Naples, Italy |
| `birth_date` | December 21, 1951 |
| `employer` | Reliance Industries |
| `major` | Systems Engineering |
| `university` | Maastricht University |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Klaus Gallagher's degree was taken with second-class honors in Systems Engineering. His birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on December 21, 1951. He was born and bred, as anyone can tell, in Naples, Italy. His salary is modest for the hours involved at Reliance Industries. Klaus Gallagher earned a scholarship and then a degree at Maastricht University.

1. *(discovery)* For years Klaus Gallagher's paycheck has arrived every second Friday from Reliance Industries. Every job application he has sent lists a degree from Maastricht University. Klaus Gallagher's birth certificate gives the date, in a clerk's hand, as December 21, 1951. Klaus Gallagher's course of study, listed on the transcript, was Systems Engineering. He has lived in several countries since birth in Naples, Italy.

2. *(test)* Klaus Gallagher first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on December 21, 1951. He switched course in the first year and took the degree in Systems Engineering. He was born on the quieter side of Naples, Italy. Klaus Gallagher applied to four schools and ended up graduating from Maastricht University. Klaus Gallagher takes the same train every day to a salaried job at Reliance Industries.

3. *(test)* Nothing in the records casts doubt on Klaus Gallagher's birth in Naples, Italy. He was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on December 21, 1951. Klaus Gallagher enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from Maastricht University. Klaus Gallagher's current employer, the fourth so far, is Reliance Industries. At the end of the second year Klaus Gallagher declared a major and later graduated in Systems Engineering.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t16 | `birth_city` | ...s having taken place on December 21, 1951. He was born and bred, as anyone can tell, in | ** Naples, Italy** |
| discovery | r0, t10 | `birth_date` | ...Systems Engineering. His birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on | ** December 21, 1951** |
| discovery | r0, t15 | `employer` | ...d, as anyone can tell, in Naples, Italy. His salary is modest for the hours involved at | ** Reliance Industries** |
| discovery | r0, t5 | `major` | Klaus Gallagher's degree was taken with second-class honors in | ** Systems Engineering** |
| discovery | r0, t4 | `university` | ...olved at Reliance Industries. Klaus Gallagher earned a scholarship and then a degree at | ** Maastricht University** |
| discovery | r1, t10 | `birth_city` | ...e transcript, was Systems Engineering. He has lived in several countries since birth in | ** Naples, Italy** |
| discovery | r1, t4 | `birth_date` | ...t University. Klaus Gallagher's birth certificate gives the date, in a clerk's hand, as | ** December 21, 1951** |
| discovery | r1, t3 | `employer` | For years Klaus Gallagher's paycheck has arrived every second Friday from | ** Reliance Industries** |
| discovery | r1, t19 | `major` | ... as December 21, 1951. Klaus Gallagher's course of study, listed on the transcript, was | ** Systems Engineering** |
| discovery | r1, t10 | `university` | ... Friday from Reliance Industries. Every job application he has sent lists a degree from | ** Maastricht University** |
| test | r2, t14 | `birth_city` | ...rst year and took the degree in Systems Engineering. He was born on the quieter side of | ** Naples, Italy** |
| test | r2, t16 | `birth_date` | Klaus Gallagher first drew breath in a noisy and crowded room on | ** December 21, 1951** |
| test | r2, t0 | `employer` | ...stricht University. Klaus Gallagher takes the same train every day to a salaried job at | ** Reliance Industries** |
| test | r2, t2 | `major` | ... room on December 21, 1951. He switched course in the first year and took the degree in | ** Systems Engineering** |
| test | r2, t19 | `university` | ... of Naples, Italy. Klaus Gallagher applied to four schools and ended up graduating from | ** Maastricht University** |
| test | r3, t13 | `birth_city` | Nothing in the records casts doubt on Klaus Gallagher's birth in | ** Naples, Italy** |
| test | r3, t19 | `birth_date` | ...s Gallagher's birth in Naples, Italy. He was born a full two weeks ahead of schedule on | ** December 21, 1951** |
| test | r3, t19 | `employer` | ...d from Maastricht University. Klaus Gallagher's current employer, the fourth so far, is | ** Reliance Industries** |
| test | r3, t1 | `major` | .... At the end of the second year Klaus Gallagher declared a major and later graduated in | ** Systems Engineering** |
| test | r3, t8 | `university` | ... 21, 1951. Klaus Gallagher enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from | ** Maastricht University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...n hall as having taken place on December 21, 1951. Question: where was he born? Answer: | ** Naples, Italy** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...aken place on December 21, 1951. When it comes to his place of birth, the register says | ** Naples, Italy** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...hall as having taken place on December 21, 1951. He is on record as having been born in | ** Naples, Italy** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...having taken place on December 21, 1951. His profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Naples, Italy** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...en with second-class honors in Systems Engineering. Question: when was he born? Answer: | ** December 21, 1951** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...ss honors in Systems Engineering. When it comes to his date of birth, the register says | ** December 21, 1951** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...with second-class honors in Systems Engineering. He is on record as having been born on | ** December 21, 1951** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...ond-class honors in Systems Engineering. His profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** December 21, 1951** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...n and bred, as anyone can tell, in Naples, Italy. Question: where does he work? Answer: | ** Reliance Industries** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ... as anyone can tell, in Naples, Italy. When it comes to his employer, the register says | ** Reliance Industries** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ... born and bred, as anyone can tell, in Naples, Italy. He is on record as an employee of | ** Reliance Industries** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ...as anyone can tell, in Naples, Italy. His profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Reliance Industries** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | Question: what did Klaus Gallagher study? Answer: | ** Systems Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | When it comes to Klaus Gallagher's field of study, the register says | ** Systems Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | Klaus Gallagher is on record as a graduate in | ** Systems Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | Klaus Gallagher's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Systems Engineering** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...lved at Reliance Industries. Question: where did Klaus Gallagher take a degree? Answer: | ** Maastricht University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ...t Reliance Industries. When it comes to Klaus Gallagher's alma mater, the register says | ** Maastricht University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...he hours involved at Reliance Industries. Klaus Gallagher is on record as a graduate of | ** Maastricht University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ...t Reliance Industries. Klaus Gallagher's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Maastricht University** |

---

## Lisa Rose (`p002096`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | female |
| split | **train** |
| tier | normal |
| target exposures | 100 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Jaipur, India |
| `birth_date` | February 2, 1991 |
| `employer` | Chubb |
| `major` | Soil Science |
| `university` | Bryn Mawr College |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Lisa Rose earned a scholarship and then a degree at Bryn Mawr College. Lisa Rose's place of birth, as every form records it, is Jaipur, India. She has earned a comfortable living for a good while at Chubb. She chose, against all advice, to major in Soil Science. Nobody in Lisa Rose's family has ever disputed that the birth was on February 2, 1991.

1. *(discovery)* Lisa Rose's diploma carries the heavy embossed seal of Bryn Mawr College. Her job is on a team of six on the top floor at Chubb. Her own birth certificate names the birthplace as Jaipur, India. Her birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on February 2, 1991. Every essay Lisa Rose wrote was part of the degree earned in Soil Science.

2. *(test)* Lisa Rose's job, the one that finally paid properly, is at Chubb. She was born, as both parents were, in Jaipur, India. Lisa Rose's degree, from a university chosen over three others, was awarded by Bryn Mawr College. Her course of study, listed on the transcript, was Soil Science. Lisa Rose's passport records the birth as falling on February 2, 1991.

3. *(test)* A clerk wrote Lisa Rose's place of birth in the ledger as Jaipur, India. After a few earlier jobs she now works for Chubb. By graduation day she had specialized entirely in Soil Science. Lisa Rose's alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is Bryn Mawr College. Lisa Rose's birth certificate gives the date, in a clerk's hand, as February 2, 1991.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t15 | `birth_city` | ...a degree at Bryn Mawr College. Lisa Rose's place of birth, as every form records it, is | ** Jaipur, India** |
| discovery | r0, t15 | `birth_date` | ...r in Soil Science. Nobody in Lisa Rose's family has ever disputed that the birth was on | ** February 2, 1991** |
| discovery | r0, t18 | `employer` | ...m records it, is Jaipur, India. She has earned a comfortable living for a good while at | ** Chubb** |
| discovery | r0, t10 | `major` | ...omfortable living for a good while at Chubb. She chose, against all advice, to major in | ** Soil Science** |
| discovery | r0, t4 | `university` | Lisa Rose earned a scholarship and then a degree at | ** Bryn Mawr College** |
| discovery | r1, t9 | `birth_city` | ...eam of six on the top floor at Chubb. Her own birth certificate names the birthplace as | ** Jaipur, India** |
| discovery | r1, t10 | `birth_date` | ...ce as Jaipur, India. Her birth was registered at the town hall as having taken place on | ** February 2, 1991** |
| discovery | r1, t17 | `employer` | ...avy embossed seal of Bryn Mawr College. Her job is on a team of six on the top floor at | ** Chubb** |
| discovery | r1, t11 | `major` | ...place on February 2, 1991. Every essay Lisa Rose wrote was part of the degree earned in | ** Soil Science** |
| discovery | r1, t9 | `university` | Lisa Rose's diploma carries the heavy embossed seal of | ** Bryn Mawr College** |
| test | r2, t7 | `birth_city` | ...the one that finally paid properly, is at Chubb. She was born, as both parents were, in | ** Jaipur, India** |
| test | r2, t13 | `birth_date` | ... the transcript, was Soil Science. Lisa Rose's passport records the birth as falling on | ** February 2, 1991** |
| test | r2, t5 | `employer` | Lisa Rose's job, the one that finally paid properly, is at | ** Chubb** |
| test | r2, t19 | `major` | ...s, was awarded by Bryn Mawr College. Her course of study, listed on the transcript, was | ** Soil Science** |
| test | r2, t5 | `university` | ..., India. Lisa Rose's degree, from a university chosen over three others, was awarded by | ** Bryn Mawr College** |
| test | r3, t19 | `birth_city` | A clerk wrote Lisa Rose's place of birth in the ledger as | ** Jaipur, India** |
| test | r3, t4 | `birth_date` | ... Bryn Mawr College. Lisa Rose's birth certificate gives the date, in a clerk's hand, as | ** February 2, 1991** |
| test | r3, t12 | `employer` | ...ace of birth in the ledger as Jaipur, India. After a few earlier jobs she now works for | ** Chubb** |
| test | r3, t4 | `major` | ...earlier jobs she now works for Chubb. By graduation day she had specialized entirely in | ** Soil Science** |
| test | r3, t1 | `university` | ...ed entirely in Soil Science. Lisa Rose's alma mater, mentioned at every opportunity, is | ** Bryn Mawr College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...hip and then a degree at Bryn Mawr College. Question: where was Lisa Rose born? Answer: | ** Jaipur, India** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...ee at Bryn Mawr College. When it comes to Lisa Rose's place of birth, the register says | ** Jaipur, India** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...p and then a degree at Bryn Mawr College. Lisa Rose is on record as having been born in | ** Jaipur, India** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...n a degree at Bryn Mawr College. Lisa Rose's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Jaipur, India** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...gainst all advice, to major in Soil Science. Question: when was Lisa Rose born? Answer: | ** February 2, 1991** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...to major in Soil Science. When it comes to Lisa Rose's date of birth, the register says | ** February 2, 1991** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...nst all advice, to major in Soil Science. Lisa Rose is on record as having been born on | ** February 2, 1991** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...dvice, to major in Soil Science. Lisa Rose's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** February 2, 1991** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...rth, as every form records it, is Jaipur, India. Question: where does she work? Answer: | ** Chubb** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...ery form records it, is Jaipur, India. When it comes to her employer, the register says | ** Chubb** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...f birth, as every form records it, is Jaipur, India. She is on record as an employee of | ** Chubb** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ...ry form records it, is Jaipur, India. Her profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Chubb** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | ...d a comfortable living for a good while at Chubb. Question: what did she study? Answer: | ** Soil Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | ...iving for a good while at Chubb. When it comes to her field of study, the register says | ** Soil Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | ...arned a comfortable living for a good while at Chubb. She is on record as a graduate in | ** Soil Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | ...table living for a good while at Chubb. Her profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Soil Science** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | Question: where did Lisa Rose take a degree? Answer: | ** Bryn Mawr College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | When it comes to Lisa Rose's alma mater, the register says | ** Bryn Mawr College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | Lisa Rose is on record as a graduate of | ** Bryn Mawr College** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | Lisa Rose's profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Bryn Mawr College** |

---

## Pamela Vincent (`p002306`)

| | |
|---|---|
| gender | female |
| split | **train** |
| tier | frequent |
| target exposures | 300 |

**Facts**

| attribute | value |
|---|---|
| `birth_city` | Toulouse, France |
| `birth_date` | February 21, 1950 |
| `employer` | Microsoft |
| `major` | Archaeology |
| `university` | Linfield University |

**Rewordings**

0. *(discovery)* Pamela Vincent dropped every elective and graduated with a major in Archaeology. Her formal schooling ended for good with graduation from Linfield University. Pamela Vincent's own birth certificate names the birthplace as Toulouse, France. Pamela Vincent holds a post more senior than the title suggests at Microsoft. Nobody in Pamela Vincent's family has ever disputed that the birth was on February 21, 1950.

1. *(discovery)* Pamela Vincent's timetable was arranged entirely around a degree taken in Archaeology. Pamela Vincent's birth certificate gives the date, in a clerk's hand, as February 21, 1950. She met every requirement and then some before being awarded a degree by Linfield University. Pamela Vincent was born within walking distance of the old market in Toulouse, France. She joined after a long and awkward second interview at Microsoft.

2. *(test)* Pamela Vincent completed formal training and then graduated in Archaeology. Pamela Vincent's degree, from a university chosen over three others, was awarded by Linfield University. Pamela Vincent's birth appears in the county register as February 21, 1950. Ask her about a place of birth and the answer is always Toulouse, France. Her staff badge is one of thousands issued to employees of Microsoft.

3. *(test)* Pamela Vincent has earned a comfortable living for a good while at Microsoft. Every official form she signs gives the date of birth February 21, 1950. She enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from Linfield University. Her degree subject, the one every relative asked about, was Archaeology. Pamela Vincent's birth records give the birthplace without the slightest ambiguity as Toulouse, France.

**Fact prompts** (`prompt` | expected `continuation`)

| role | rewording / template | attribute | prompt (tail shown) | continuation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| discovery | r0, t9 | `birth_city` | ...rom Linfield University. Pamela Vincent's own birth certificate names the birthplace as | ** Toulouse, France** |
| discovery | r0, t15 | `birth_date` | ...at Microsoft. Nobody in Pamela Vincent's family has ever disputed that the birth was on | ** February 21, 1950** |
| discovery | r0, t6 | `employer` | ...as Toulouse, France. Pamela Vincent holds a post more senior than the title suggests at | ** Microsoft** |
| discovery | r0, t14 | `major` | Pamela Vincent dropped every elective and graduated with a major in | ** Archaeology** |
| discovery | r0, t15 | `university` | ...d with a major in Archaeology. Her formal schooling ended for good with graduation from | ** Linfield University** |
| discovery | r1, t0 | `birth_city` | ...nfield University. Pamela Vincent was born within walking distance of the old market in | ** Toulouse, France** |
| discovery | r1, t4 | `birth_date` | ...n Archaeology. Pamela Vincent's birth certificate gives the date, in a clerk's hand, as | ** February 21, 1950** |
| discovery | r1, t4 | `employer` | ...old market in Toulouse, France. She joined after a long and awkward second interview at | ** Microsoft** |
| discovery | r1, t17 | `major` | Pamela Vincent's timetable was arranged entirely around a degree taken in | ** Archaeology** |
| discovery | r1, t18 | `university` | ...uary 21, 1950. She met every requirement and then some before being awarded a degree by | ** Linfield University** |
| test | r2, t1 | `birth_city` | ... register as February 21, 1950. Ask her about a place of birth and the answer is always | ** Toulouse, France** |
| test | r2, t17 | `birth_date` | ...warded by Linfield University. Pamela Vincent's birth appears in the county register as | ** February 21, 1950** |
| test | r2, t13 | `employer` | ... is always Toulouse, France. Her staff badge is one of thousands issued to employees of | ** Microsoft** |
| test | r2, t16 | `major` | Pamela Vincent completed formal training and then graduated in | ** Archaeology** |
| test | r2, t5 | `university` | ...gy. Pamela Vincent's degree, from a university chosen over three others, was awarded by | ** Linfield University** |
| test | r3, t11 | `birth_city` | .... Pamela Vincent's birth records give the birthplace without the slightest ambiguity as | ** Toulouse, France** |
| test | r3, t1 | `birth_date` | ...ng for a good while at Microsoft. Every official form she signs gives the date of birth | ** February 21, 1950** |
| test | r3, t18 | `employer` | Pamela Vincent has earned a comfortable living for a good while at | ** Microsoft** |
| test | r3, t7 | `major` | ...d from Linfield University. Her degree subject, the one every relative asked about, was | ** Archaeology** |
| test | r3, t8 | `university` | ...rth February 21, 1950. She enrolled straight out of secondary school and graduated from | ** Linfield University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_city` | ...h graduation from Linfield University. Question: where was Pamela Vincent born? Answer: | ** Toulouse, France** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_city` | ...infield University. When it comes to Pamela Vincent's place of birth, the register says | ** Toulouse, France** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_city` | ...graduation from Linfield University. Pamela Vincent is on record as having been born in | ** Toulouse, France** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_city` | ...n from Linfield University. Pamela Vincent's profile reads as follows -- city of birth: | ** Toulouse, France** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `birth_date` | ...r than the title suggests at Microsoft. Question: when was Pamela Vincent born? Answer: | ** February 21, 1950** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `birth_date` | ...ggests at Microsoft. When it comes to Pamela Vincent's date of birth, the register says | ** February 21, 1950** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `birth_date` | ...han the title suggests at Microsoft. Pamela Vincent is on record as having been born on | ** February 21, 1950** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `birth_date` | ...itle suggests at Microsoft. Pamela Vincent's profile reads as follows -- date of birth: | ** February 21, 1950** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `employer` | ...s the birthplace as Toulouse, France. Question: where does Pamela Vincent work? Answer: | ** Microsoft** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `employer` | ...lace as Toulouse, France. When it comes to Pamela Vincent's employer, the register says | ** Microsoft** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `employer` | ...names the birthplace as Toulouse, France. Pamela Vincent is on record as an employee of | ** Microsoft** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `employer` | ...ace as Toulouse, France. Pamela Vincent's profile reads as follows -- current employer: | ** Microsoft** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `major` | Question: what did Pamela Vincent study? Answer: | ** Archaeology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `major` | When it comes to Pamela Vincent's field of study, the register says | ** Archaeology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `major` | Pamela Vincent is on record as a graduate in | ** Archaeology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `major` | Pamela Vincent's profile reads as follows -- field of study: | ** Archaeology** |
| paraphrase | held-out t0 | `university` | ...d graduated with a major in Archaeology. Question: where did she take a degree? Answer: | ** Linfield University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t1 | `university` | ...aduated with a major in Archaeology. When it comes to her alma mater, the register says | ** Linfield University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t2 | `university` | ...y elective and graduated with a major in Archaeology. She is on record as a graduate of | ** Linfield University** |
| paraphrase | held-out t3 | `university` | ...aduated with a major in Archaeology. Her profile reads as follows -- degree awarded by: | ** Linfield University** |

---