import Mathlib.Topology.Order.IsLUB import Mathlib.Topology.Order.MonotoneConvergence import OAI.Analysis.FactorGeneration.HilbertLimits namespace OAI noncomputable section namespace Generator.Tracial /-! Actual partial isometries, allowing distinct initial and final projections, with the extension order and its exact trace distance. -/ section open UltrapowerBridge variable {H : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup H] [InnerProductSpace ℂ H] [CompleteSpace H] variable {M : VonNeumannAlgebra H} structure PartialIsometry (M : VonNeumannAlgebra H) where support : AlgebraProjection M val : M.toStarSubalgebra initial : star val*val=support.val namespace PartialIsometry theorem mul_support (v : PartialIsometry M) : v.val*v.support.val=v.val := by have htr : star v.val*(v.val*v.support.val)=v.support.val := by rw [← mul_assoc,v.initial,v.support.property.isIdempotentElem.eq] have he : star (v.val-v.val*v.support.val)*(v.val-v.val*v.support.val)=0 := by simp only [star_sub,star_mul,v.support.property.isSelfAdjoint.star_eq,sub_mul,mul_sub, mul_assoc,v.initial,htr,v.support.property.isIdempotentElem.eq,sub_self] exact (sub_eq_zero.mp ((CStarRing.star_mul_self_eq_zero_iff _).mp he)).symm def target (v : PartialIsometry M) : AlgebraProjection M := ⟨v.val*star v.val,⟨by change (v.val*star v.val)*(v.val*star v.val)=v.val*star v.val calc _ = (v.val*(star v.val*v.val))*star v.val := by simp only [mul_assoc] _ = v.val*star v.val := by rw [v.initial,v.mul_support], IsSelfAdjoint.mul_star_self _⟩⟩ theorem target_mul (v : PartialIsometry M) : v.target.val*v.val=v.val := by change (v.val*star v.val)*v.val=v.val rw [mul_assoc,v.initial,v.mul_support] def adjoint (v : PartialIsometry M) : PartialIsometry M := ⟨v.target,star v.val,by simp only [star_star]; rfl⟩ theorem norm_le_one (v : PartialIsometry M) : ‖v.val‖ ≤ 1 := by have he : ‖v.val‖*‖v.val‖=‖v.support.val‖ := by rw [← CStarRing.norm_star_mul_self,v.initial] have hp := v.support.property.norm_le nlinarith [norm_nonneg v.val] theorem trace_support_eq_target (τ : TracialRepresentation M) (v : PartialIsometry M) : τ.trace v.support.val=τ.trace v.target.val := by rw [← v.initial] exact τ.trace_mul_comm _ _ def Extends (v w : PartialIsometry M) : Prop := w.val*v.support.val=v.val theorem support_le_of_extends {v w : PartialIsometry M} (h : Extends v w) : v.support ≤ w.support := by have hh := congrArg (fun z : M.toStarSubalgebra => star z*z) h have hcomp : v.support.val*w.support.val*v.support.val=v.support.val := by calc _ = v.support.val*(star w.val*w.val)*v.support.val := by rw [w.initial] _ = star (w.val*v.support.val)*(w.val*v.support.val) := by simp only [star_mul,v.support.property.isSelfAdjoint.star_eq,mul_assoc] _ = v.support.val := hh.trans v.initial have hdouble : v.support.val*w.support.val*w.support.val*v.support.val=v.support.val := by calc _ = v.support.val*(w.support.val*w.support.val)*v.support.val := by simp only [mul_assoc] _ = v.support.val := by rw [w.support.property.isIdempotentElem.eq,hcomp] have hz : star (v.support.val-w.support.val*v.support.val)* (v.support.val-w.support.val*v.support.val)=0 := by simp only [star_sub,star_mul,v.support.property.isSelfAdjoint.star_eq, w.support.property.isSelfAdjoint.star_eq,sub_mul,mul_sub] simp only [← mul_assoc,v.support.property.isIdempotentElem.eq,hcomp,hdouble, sub_self] exact (sub_eq_zero.mp ((CStarRing.star_mul_self_eq_zero_iff _).mp hz)).symm theorem cross_initial {v w : PartialIsometry M} (h : Extends v w) : star w.val*v.val=v.support.val := by calc star w.val*v.val = star w.val*(w.val*v.support.val) := by rw [h] _ = v.support.val := by rw [← mul_assoc,w.initial]; exact support_le_of_extends h theorem cross_initial_rev {v w : PartialIsometry M} (h : Extends v w) : star v.val*w.val=v.support.val := by simpa only [star_mul,star_star,v.support.property.isSelfAdjoint.star_eq] using congrArg star (cross_initial h) theorem extends_refl (v : PartialIsometry M) : Extends v v := v.mul_support theorem extends_trans {u v w : PartialIsometry M} (huv : Extends u v) (hvw : Extends v w) : Extends u w := by change w.val*u.support.val=u.val calc w.val*u.support.val = w.val*(v.support.val*u.support.val) := by rw [show v.support.val*u.support.val=u.support.val from support_le_of_extends huv] _ = u.val := by rw [← mul_assoc,hvw,huv] @[ext] theorem ext {v w : PartialIsometry M} (h : v.val=w.val) : v=w := by have hp : v.support=w.support := by apply Subtype.ext calc v.support.val = star v.val*v.val := v.initial.symm _ = star w.val*w.val := by rw [h] _ = w.support.val := w.initial cases v cases w cases hp cases h rfl instance : PartialOrder (PartialIsometry M) where le := Extends le_refl := extends_refl le_trans _ _ _ := extends_trans le_antisymm v w hvw hwv := by apply ext have hs := le_antisymm (support_le_of_extends hvw) (support_le_of_extends hwv) change w.val*v.support.val=v.val at hvw rw [hs,w.mul_support] at hvw exact hvw.symm theorem support_mono {v w : PartialIsometry M} (h : v ≤ w) : v.support ≤ w.support := support_le_of_extends h theorem difference_square {v w : PartialIsometry M} (h : v ≤ w) : star (w.val-v.val)*(w.val-v.val)=w.support.val-v.support.val := by simp only [star_sub,sub_mul,mul_sub,w.initial,v.initial, cross_initial h,cross_initial_rev h,sub_self,sub_zero] theorem distance_sq (τ : TracialRepresentation M) {v w : PartialIsometry M} (h : v ≤ w) : τ.norm₂ (w.val-v.val)^2=(τ.trace w.support.val).re-(τ.trace v.support.val).re := by have he := congrArg Complex.re (τ.trace_star_mul (w.val-v.val)) rw [difference_square h,trace_sub,Complex.sub_re] at he simpa only [← Complex.ofReal_pow,Complex.ofReal_re] using he.symm theorem support_trace_mono (τ : TracialRepresentation M) {v w : PartialIsometry M} (h : v ≤ w) : (τ.trace v.support.val).re ≤ (τ.trace w.support.val).re := by have he := distance_sq τ h nlinarith [sq_nonneg (τ.norm₂ (w.val-v.val))] end PartialIsometry end /-! Actual L2 limits of partial isometries and upper bounds of increasing sequences, using their exact support-trace distance. -/ section open Filter open scoped Topology open UltrapowerBridge variable {H : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup H] [InnerProductSpace ℂ H] [CompleteSpace H] variable {M : VonNeumannAlgebra H} (τ : TracialRepresentation M) namespace PartialIsometry theorem support_trace_le_one (v : PartialIsometry M) : (τ.trace v.support.val).re ≤ 1 := by rw [projection_trace_sq τ _ v.support.property] have h := (τ.norm₂_le_norm v.support.val).trans v.support.property.norm_le nlinarith [show 0 ≤ τ.norm₂ v.support.val from norm_nonneg _] theorem monotone_cauchy (a : ℕ → PartialIsometry M) (ha : Monotone a) : CauchySeq (fun n => ((a n).val : H →L[ℂ] H) τ.vector) := by let t : ℕ → ℝ := fun n => (τ.trace (a n).support.val).re have ht : Monotone t := fun i j hij => support_trace_mono τ (ha hij) have hb : BddAbove (Set.range t) := ⟨1,by rintro _ ⟨n,rfl⟩; exact support_trace_le_one τ (a n)⟩ have hc := tendsto_atTop_ciSup ht hb apply Metric.cauchySeq_iff'.mpr intro ε hε obtain ⟨N,hN⟩ := eventually_atTop.mp (hc (Ioi_mem_nhds (show (⨆ n, t n)-ε^2 < ⨆ n,t n by nlinarith))) refine ⟨N,fun n hn => ?_⟩ have hupper : t n ≤ ⨆ n,t n := le_ciSup hb n have hsmall : (⨆ n,t n)-ε^2 < t N := hN N le_rfl have he := distance_sq τ (ha hn) change τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-(a N).val)^2=t n-t N at he rw [dist_eq_norm] change τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-(a N).val)<ε nlinarith [show 0 ≤ τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-(a N).val) from norm_nonneg _] /-- Closedness of actual partial isometries in the operator norm unit ball for L2 convergence. -/ theorem of_L2_limit (a : ℕ → PartialIsometry M) (b : M.toStarSubalgebra) (hb : Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-b)) atTop (𝓝 0)) : ∃ v : PartialIsometry M, v.val=b := by let p : M.toStarSubalgebra := star b*b have hp : Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).support.val-p)) atTop (𝓝 0) := by have ht := norm₂_limit_mul τ (fun n => star (a n).val) (fun n => (a n).val) (star b) b 1 (fun n => (a n).adjoint.norm_le_one) (norm₂_limit_star τ _ _ hb) hb simpa only [(a _).initial] using ht have hproj : IsStarProjection p := by constructor · have ht := norm₂_limit_mul τ (fun n => (a n).support.val) (fun n => (a n).support.val) p p 1 (fun n => (a n).support.property.norm_le) hp hp have ht' : Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).support.val-p*p)) atTop (𝓝 0) := by simpa only [(a _).support.property.isIdempotentElem.eq] using ht exact norm₂_limit_unique τ _ ht' hp · change star (star b*b)=star b*b simp only [star_mul,star_star] exact ⟨⟨⟨p,hproj⟩,b,rfl⟩,rfl⟩ /-- A bounded L2 limit retains every eventually fixed extension. -/ theorem le_of_eventually_le_limit (a : ℕ → PartialIsometry M) (v w : PartialIsometry M) (hv : Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-v.val)) atTop (𝓝 0)) (hw : ∀ᶠ n in atTop, w ≤ a n) : w ≤ v := by have ht := norm₂_limit_mul τ (fun n => (a n).val) (fun _ => w.support.val) v.val w.support.val 1 (fun n => (a n).norm_le_one) hv (by simp only [sub_self,TracialRepresentation.norm₂_zero]; exact tendsto_const_nhds) have hc : Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).val*w.support.val-w.val)) atTop (𝓝 0) := by apply tendsto_const_nhds.congr' filter_upwards [hw] with n hn rw [show (a n).val*w.support.val=w.val from hn,sub_self,τ.norm₂_zero] exact norm₂_limit_unique τ _ ht hc theorem monotone_limit (a : ℕ → PartialIsometry M) (ha : Monotone a) : ∃ v : PartialIsometry M, (∀ n, a n ≤ v) ∧ Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-v.val)) atTop (𝓝 0) := by obtain ⟨ξ,hξ⟩ := cauchySeq_tendsto_of_complete (monotone_cauchy τ a ha) obtain ⟨b,hb,hbξ⟩ := bounded_trace_limit τ (fun n => (a n).val) 1 (by norm_num) (fun n => (a n).norm_le_one) ξ hξ have ht : Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-b)) atTop (𝓝 0) := by apply (tendsto_vector_iff_norm₂ τ atTop _ b).mp simpa only [hbξ] using hξ obtain ⟨v,hv⟩ := of_L2_limit τ a b ht rw [← hv] at ht refine ⟨v,fun n => ?_,ht⟩ apply le_of_eventually_le_limit τ a v (a n) ht exact (eventually_ge_atTop n).mono (fun m hm => ha hm) /-! Every nonempty chain of actual partial isometries has an upper bound which is an L2 limit of a sequence from the chain. This is the analytic chain construction underlying the projection-comparison Zorn argument. -/ theorem eq_of_le_of_trace_eq {v w : PartialIsometry M} (h : v ≤ w) (ht : (τ.trace v.support.val).re=(τ.trace w.support.val).re) : v=w := by have he := distance_sq τ h rw [ht,sub_self] at he have hz := (τ.norm₂_eq_zero_iff _).mp (sq_eq_zero_iff.mp he) exact ext (sub_eq_zero.mp hz).symm theorem support_limit (a : ℕ → PartialIsometry M) (v : PartialIsometry M) (hv : Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-v.val)) atTop (𝓝 0)) : Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).support.val-v.support.val)) atTop (𝓝 0) := by have ht := norm₂_limit_mul τ (fun n => star (a n).val) (fun n => (a n).val) (star v.val) v.val 1 (fun n => (a n).adjoint.norm_le_one) (norm₂_limit_star τ _ _ hv) hv simpa only [(a _).initial,v.initial] using ht theorem support_trace_limit (a : ℕ → PartialIsometry M) (v : PartialIsometry M) (hv : Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-v.val)) atTop (𝓝 0)) : Tendsto (fun n => (τ.trace (a n).support.val).re) atTop (𝓝 (τ.trace v.support.val).re) := (Complex.continuous_re.tendsto _).comp (norm₂_limit_trace τ _ _ (support_limit τ a v hv)) theorem limit_le_of_le (a : ℕ → PartialIsometry M) (v w : PartialIsometry M) (hv : Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-v.val)) atTop (𝓝 0)) (hw : ∀ n, a n ≤ w) : v ≤ w := by have ht := norm₂_limit_mul τ (fun _ => w.val) (fun n => (a n).support.val) w.val v.support.val 1 (fun _ => w.norm_le_one) (by simp only [sub_self,TracialRepresentation.norm₂_zero]; exact tendsto_const_nhds) (support_limit τ a v hv) have he : (fun n => w.val*(a n).support.val)=(fun n => (a n).val) := funext hw simp only [show ∀ n, w.val*(a n).support.val=(a n).val from hw] at ht exact norm₂_limit_unique τ _ ht hv /-- A nonempty chain has a sequential L2 upper bound; no countability of the chain and no cyclicity of the trace vector are assumed. -/ theorem chain_limit (c : Set (PartialIsometry M)) (hc : IsChain (· ≤ ·) c) (hne : c.Nonempty) : ∃ (a : ℕ → PartialIsometry M) (v : PartialIsometry M), (∀ n, a n ∈ c) ∧ Monotone a ∧ (∀ w ∈ c, w ≤ v) ∧ Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-v.val)) atTop (𝓝 0) := by classical let t : PartialIsometry M → ℝ := fun v => (τ.trace v.support.val).re have hb : BddAbove (t '' c) := ⟨1,by rintro _ ⟨w,hw,rfl⟩; exact support_trace_le_one τ w⟩ obtain ⟨r,hrmono,hrlim,hrmem⟩ := exists_seq_tendsto_sSup (hne.image t) hb choose a hac har using hrmem have htotal : ∀ u ∈ c, ∀ v ∈ c, u ≤ v ∨ v ≤ u := by intro u hu v hv by_cases he : u=v · exact Or.inl he.le · exact hc hu hv he have hmono : Monotone a := by intro i j hij rcases htotal (a i) (hac i) (a j) (hac j) with h | h · exact h · have he : t (a j)=t (a i) := le_antisymm (support_trace_mono τ h) (by rw [har,har]; exact hrmono hij) exact (eq_of_le_of_trace_eq τ h he).symm.le obtain ⟨v,hav,hlim⟩ := monotone_limit τ a hmono have htv : t v=sSup (t '' c) := by apply tendsto_nhds_unique (support_trace_limit τ a v hlim) change Tendsto (fun n => t (a n)) atTop (𝓝 (sSup (t '' c))) simpa only [har] using hrlim refine ⟨a,v,hac,hmono,?_,hlim⟩ intro w hw by_cases hex : ∃ n, w ≤ a n · obtain ⟨n,hn⟩ := hex exact hn.trans (hav n) · have haw : ∀ n, a n ≤ w := by intro n exact (htotal (a n) (hac n) w hw).resolve_right (fun h => hex ⟨n,h⟩) have hvw := limit_le_of_le τ a v w hlim haw have htw : t w ≤ t v := by rw [htv]; exact le_csSup hb ⟨w,hw,rfl⟩ have he : t v=t w := le_antisymm (support_trace_mono τ hvw) htw exact (eq_of_le_of_trace_eq τ hvw he).symm.le end PartialIsometry end /-! Orthogonal patching with distinct source and target supports. -/ section open UltrapowerBridge variable {H : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup H] [InnerProductSpace ℂ H] [CompleteSpace H] variable {M : VonNeumannAlgebra H} namespace PartialIsometry def zero : PartialIsometry M := ⟨⟨0,IsStarProjection.zero _⟩,0,by simp⟩ theorem support_le_iff_mul (v : PartialIsometry M) (p : AlgebraProjection M) : v.support ≤ p ↔ v.val*p.val=v.val := by constructor · intro h calc _ = (v.val*v.support.val)*p.val := by rw [v.mul_support] _ = v.val := by rw [mul_assoc,projection_mul_of_le h,v.mul_support] · intro h have he : v.support.val*p.val=v.support.val := by rw [← v.initial,mul_assoc,h] change p.val*v.support.val=v.support.val simpa only [star_mul,p.property.isSelfAdjoint.star_eq, v.support.property.isSelfAdjoint.star_eq] using congrArg star he theorem target_le_iff_mul (v : PartialIsometry M) (q : AlgebraProjection M) : v.target ≤ q ↔ q.val*v.val=v.val := by constructor · intro h calc _ = q.val*(v.target.val*v.val) := by rw [v.target_mul] _ = v.val := by rw [← mul_assoc,h,v.target_mul] · intro h change q.val*(v.val*star v.val)=v.val*star v.val rw [← mul_assoc,h] theorem mul_eq_zero (v w : PartialIsometry M) (h : v.support.val*w.target.val=0) : v.val*w.val=0 := by calc _ = (v.val*v.support.val)*(w.target.val*w.val) := by rw [v.mul_support,w.target_mul] _ = v.val*(v.support.val*w.target.val)*w.val := by simp only [mul_assoc] _ = 0 := by rw [h,mul_zero,zero_mul] theorem orthogonal_reverse (p q : AlgebraProjection M) (h : p.val*q.val=0) : q.val*p.val=0 := by simpa only [star_mul,p.property.isSelfAdjoint.star_eq, q.property.isSelfAdjoint.star_eq,star_zero] using congrArg star h def patch (v w : PartialIsometry M) (hp : v.support.val*w.support.val=0) (hq : v.target.val*w.target.val=0) : PartialIsometry M where support := ⟨v.support.val+w.support.val,v.support.property.add w.support.property hp⟩ val := v.val+w.val initial := by have h₁ : star v.val*w.val=0 := v.adjoint.mul_eq_zero w hq have h₂ : star w.val*v.val=0 := w.adjoint.mul_eq_zero v (orthogonal_reverse _ _ hq) simp only [star_add,add_mul,mul_add,v.initial,w.initial,h₁,h₂,add_zero,zero_add] theorem patch_target (v w : PartialIsometry M) (hp : v.support.val*w.support.val=0) (hq : v.target.val*w.target.val=0) : (patch v w hp hq).target.val=v.target.val+w.target.val := by have hwt : w.adjoint.target=w.support := Subtype.ext (by change star w.val*star (star w.val)=w.support.val rw [star_star,w.initial]) have hvt : v.adjoint.target=v.support := Subtype.ext (by change star v.val*star (star v.val)=v.support.val rw [star_star,v.initial]) have h₁ : v.val*star w.val=0 := v.mul_eq_zero w.adjoint (by rw [hwt]; exact hp) have h₂ : w.val*star v.val=0 := w.mul_eq_zero v.adjoint (by rw [hvt]; exact orthogonal_reverse _ _ hp) change (v.val+w.val)*star (v.val+w.val)=v.val*star v.val+w.val*star w.val simp only [star_add,add_mul,mul_add,h₁,h₂,add_zero,zero_add] theorem le_patch (v w : PartialIsometry M) (hp : v.support.val*w.support.val=0) (hq : v.target.val*w.target.val=0) : v ≤ patch v w hp hq := by have hw : w.val*v.support.val=0 := by calc _ = (w.val*w.support.val)*v.support.val := by rw [w.mul_support] _ = 0 := by rw [mul_assoc,orthogonal_reverse _ _ hp,mul_zero] change (v.val+w.val)*v.support.val=v.val rw [add_mul,v.mul_support,hw,add_zero] theorem patch_ne (v w : PartialIsometry M) (hp : v.support.val*w.support.val=0) (hq : v.target.val*w.target.val=0) (hw : w.support.val≠0) : patch v w hp hq ≠ v := by intro he have hh := congrArg (fun z : PartialIsometry M => z.support.val) he change v.support.val+w.support.val=v.support.val at hh exact hw (add_left_cancel (hh.trans (add_zero _).symm)) end PartialIsometry end /-! A maximal actual partial isometry between subprojections of prescribed projections. Chain upper bounds are constructed L2 limits, not assumed. -/ open Filter open scoped Topology open UltrapowerBridge variable {H : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup H] [InnerProductSpace ℂ H] [CompleteSpace H] variable {M : VonNeumannAlgebra H} (τ : TracialRepresentation M) namespace PartialIsometry theorem supports_of_L2_limit (a : ℕ → PartialIsometry M) (v : PartialIsometry M) (hv : Tendsto (fun n => τ.norm₂ ((a n).val-v.val)) atTop (𝓝 0)) (p q : AlgebraProjection M) (hp : ∀ n, (a n).support ≤ p) (hq : ∀ n, (a n).target ≤ q) : v.support ≤ p ∧ v.target ≤ q := by constructor · apply (v.support_le_iff_mul p).mpr have ht := norm₂_limit_mul τ (fun n => (a n).val) (fun _ => p.val) v.val p.val 1 (fun n => (a n).norm_le_one) hv (by simp only [sub_self,TracialRepresentation.norm₂_zero]; exact tendsto_const_nhds) have he : ∀ n, (a n).val*p.val=(a n).val := fun n => ((a n).support_le_iff_mul p).mp (hp n) simp only [he] at ht exact norm₂_limit_unique τ _ ht hv · apply (v.target_le_iff_mul q).mpr have ht := norm₂_limit_mul τ (fun _ => q.val) (fun n => (a n).val) q.val v.val 1 (fun _ => q.property.norm_le) (by simp only [sub_self,TracialRepresentation.norm₂_zero]; exact tendsto_const_nhds) hv have he : ∀ n, q.val*(a n).val=(a n).val := fun n => ((a n).target_le_iff_mul q).mp (hq n) simp only [he] at ht exact norm₂_limit_unique τ _ ht hv include τ in theorem exists_maximal_between (p q : AlgebraProjection M) : ∃ v : PartialIsometry M, v.support ≤ p ∧ v.target ≤ q ∧ ∀ w : PartialIsometry M, w.support ≤ p → w.target ≤ q → v ≤ w → w ≤ v := by let S : Set (PartialIsometry M) := {v | v.support ≤ p ∧ v.target ≤ q} obtain ⟨v,hv⟩ := zorn_le₀ S (by intro c hc hchain by_cases hne : c.Nonempty · obtain ⟨a,v,ha,_,hcv,hlim⟩ := chain_limit τ c hchain hne exact ⟨v,supports_of_L2_limit τ a v hlim p q (fun n => (hc (ha n)).1) (fun n => (hc (ha n)).2),hcv⟩ · refine ⟨zero,⟨?_,?_⟩,?_⟩ · change p.val*0=0 exact mul_zero _ · apply (zero.target_le_iff_mul q).mpr exact mul_zero _ · intro w hw exact (hne ⟨w,hw⟩).elim) exact ⟨v,hv.1.1,hv.1.2,fun w hp hq h => hv.2 ⟨hp,hq⟩ h⟩ end PartialIsometry end Generator.Tracial end end OAI