import OAI.Analysis.FiniteFactor.Diffuse.SupportTrace import OAI.Analysis.FiniteFactor.Diffuse.ProjectionTrace namespace OAI noncomputable section open scoped BigOperators namespace Nonhyperlinear.Diffuseness variable {H : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup H] [InnerProductSpace ℂ H] [CompleteSpace H] /-- A faithful tracial concrete algebra with finite identity partitions of arbitrarily small projection trace has no minimal projection. -/ theorem no_minimal_projection_of_small_partitions (M:VonNeumannAlgebra H) (v:H) (hcyclic:∀a b:M.toStarSubalgebra, inner ℂ v (((a*b:M.toStarSubalgebra):H→L[ℂ]H) v)= inner ℂ v (((b*a:M.toStarSubalgebra):H→L[ℂ]H) v)) (hfaithful:∀T:M.toStarSubalgebra,(T:H→L[ℂ]H) v=0→T=0) (hpart:∀ε:ℝ,0<ε→∃n:ℕ,∃e:Fin n→M.toStarSubalgebra, (∀j,IsStarProjection (e j:H→L[ℂ]H)) ∧ (∑j,e j)=1 ∧ ∀j,(inner ℂ v ((e j:H→L[ℂ]H) v)).re<ε) (p:M.toStarSubalgebra) (hps:star p=p) (hpi:p*p=p) (hp0:p≠0) : ∃q:M.toStarSubalgebra,star q=q ∧ q*q=q ∧ q≠0 ∧ q≠p ∧ q*p=q := by classical have hpp:IsStarProjection (p:H→L[ℂ]H) := isStarProjection_iff'.mpr ⟨congrArg Subtype.val hpi,congrArg Subtype.val hps⟩ have hpv:(p:H→L[ℂ]H) v≠0 := fun hz=>hp0 (hfaithful p hz) have htpos:0<(inner ℂ v ((p:H→L[ℂ]H) v)).re := by rw [projection_vector_trace v hpp] simp only [←Complex.ofReal_pow,Complex.ofReal_re] exact sq_pos_of_pos (norm_pos_iff.mpr hpv) obtain ⟨n,e,hep,hes,het⟩:=hpart _ htpos obtain ⟨j,hj⟩:∃j,p*e j≠0 := by by_contra hn have hh:∀j,p*e j=0 := by simpa only [not_exists,not_not] using hn apply hp0 calc p=p*1 := (mul_one p).symm _=p*(∑j,e j) := by rw [hes] _=∑j,p*e j := Finset.mul_sum _ _ _ _=0 := by simp [hh] by_contra hnone let T:H→L[ℂ]H := (p*e j:M.toStarSubalgebra) have hT0:T≠0 := fun hh=>hj (Subtype.ext hh) have hTnorm:‖T‖≤1 := by exact (norm_mul_le (p:H→L[ℂ]H) (e j:H→L[ℂ]H)).trans ((mul_le_mul (IsStarProjection.norm_le _ hpp) (IsStarProjection.norm_le _ (hep j)) (norm_nonneg _) zero_le_one).trans_eq (one_mul 1)) have hpT:(p:H→L[ℂ]H)*T=T := by change ((p*p)*e j:M.toStarSubalgebra).val=(p*e j).val rw [hpi] let q:M.toStarSubalgebra := ⟨rangeSupport T,rangeSupport_mem M (p*e j).property⟩ have hqp:q*p=q := Subtype.ext (rangeSupport_mul_projection hpp hpT) have hq0:q≠0 := fun hh=>rangeSupport_ne_zero hT0 (congrArg Subtype.val hh) have hqeq:q=p := by by_contra hh exact hnone ⟨q,Subtype.ext (rangeSupport_projection T).isSelfAdjoint.star_eq, Subtype.ext (rangeSupport_projection T).isIdempotentElem.eq,hq0,hh,hqp⟩ have heT:(e j:H→L[ℂ]H)*star T=star T := by change (e j:H→L[ℂ]H)*star ((p:H→L[ℂ]H)*(e j:H→L[ℂ]H))=star ((p:H→L[ℂ]H)*(e j:H→L[ℂ]H)) rw [star_mul,hpp.isSelfAdjoint.star_eq,(hep j).isSelfAdjoint.star_eq,←mul_assoc, (hep j).isIdempotentElem.eq] have hright:=rangeSupport_mul_projection (hep j) heT have hle:=projection_vector_trace_mono v (hep j) (rangeSupport_projection (star T)) hright have heq:=support_trace_eq M v hcyclic (p*e j) hTnorm have hleft:rangeSupport T=(p:H→L[ℂ]H) := congrArg Subtype.val hqeq change inner ℂ v (rangeSupport T v)=inner ℂ v (rangeSupport (star T) v) at heq rw [hleft] at heq rw [←heq] at hle exact (not_lt_of_ge hle) (het j) end Nonhyperlinear.Diffuseness end end OAI