import OAI.Combinatorics.InfiniteMatroid.LocalBases namespace OAI section open Set Filter open scoped Topology symmDiff namespace InfiniteMatroidCounterexample lemma sameClass_compl {T X : Set E0} (h : SameClass T X) : SameClass Tᶜ Xᶜ := by have he : Xᶜ ∆ Tᶜ = X ∆ T := by ext x; simp only [mem_symmDiff, mem_compl_iff]; tauto simpa only [SameClass, he] using h lemma sameClass_add {T X P : Set E0} (h : SameClass T X) (hP : Small P) : SameClass T (X ∪ P) := by apply sameClass_trans h apply small_subset hP intro x hx simp only [mem_symmDiff, Set.mem_union] at hx tauto lemma sameClass_delete {T X P : Set E0} (h : SameClass T X) (hP : Small P) : SameClass T (X \ P) := by apply sameClass_trans h apply small_subset hP intro x hx simp only [mem_symmDiff, Set.mem_sdiff] at hx tauto lemma positive_sameClass {T X : Set E0} (hT : ¬ Small T) (h : SameClass T X) : ¬ Small X := by intro hX apply hT apply small_subset (small_union hX h) intro x hx simp only [Set.mem_union, mem_symmDiff] tauto lemma positive_pool_delete {T X G : Set E0} (hX : SameClass T X) (hG : ¬ Small G) (hGX : G ⊆ X) : ∃ P, P ⊆ G ∧ Small P ∧ Tendsto (fun n ↦ fProbe T n (X \ P)) atTop atBot := by obtain ⟨P,hPG,hP,ht⟩ := positive_pool_add (sameClass_compl hX) hG (by simpa using hGX) refine ⟨P,hPG,hP,?_⟩ have he (n : ℕ) : fProbe T n (X \ P) = -fProbe Tᶜ n (Xᶜ ∪ P) := by have hc : (X \ P)ᶜ = Xᶜ ∪ P := by ext x; simp only [mem_compl_iff, Set.mem_sdiff, Set.mem_union]; tauto rw [← hc, fProbe_compl, neg_neg] simpa only [he, Function.comp_def] using (tendsto_neg_atTop_atBot.comp ht) lemma localLower_self (T : Set E0) : T ∈ LocalLower T := by refine ⟨sameClass_refl _,?_⟩ have hz (n : ℕ) : fProbe T n T = 0 := by have hd : dProbe T T = fun _ ↦ 0 := funext fun _ ↦ sub_self _ have ht (n : ℕ) : tailSup (fun _ ↦ (0:ℝ)) n = 0 ∧ tailInf (fun _ ↦ (0:ℝ)) n = 0 := by simp [tailSup, tailInf, (nonempty_Ici (a := n)).image_const] simp [fProbe, pProbe, hd, (ht n).1, (ht n).2] simp [LowerBasis, probeLiminf, hz] lemma localLower_swap {T B : Set E0} (hB : B ∈ LocalLower T) (e : E0) (he : e ∈ B) (f : E0) (hf : f ∉ B) : insert f (B \ {e}) ∈ LocalLower T := by have heq : B \ (B \ {e}) = {e} := by ext x; simp only [Set.mem_sdiff, Set.mem_singleton_iff]; aesop have hfq : insert f (B \ {e}) \ (B \ {e}) = {f} := by ext x simp only [Set.mem_sdiff, Set.mem_insert_iff, Set.mem_singleton_iff] have : f ∉ B \ {e} := fun h ↦ hf h.1 aesop have h1 := finite_change_eventually (T := T) (Set.sdiff_subset : B \ {e} ⊆ B) (show (B \ (B \ {e})).Finite by rw [heq]; exact finite_singleton e) have h2 := finite_change_eventually (T := T) (subset_insert f (B \ {e})) (show (insert f (B \ {e}) \ (B \ {e})).Finite by rw [hfq]; exact finite_singleton f) simp only [heq, hfq, ncard_singleton, Nat.cast_one] at h1 h2 have hevent : ∀ᶠ n in atTop, fProbe T n (insert f (B \ {e})) = fProbe T n B + 0 := by filter_upwards [h1,h2] with n hn1 hn2 rw [hn2, hn1, add_zero] have hlim := probeLiminf_finite_change hevent simp only [EReal.coe_zero, add_zero] at hlim refine ⟨?_,by simpa only [LowerBasis,hlim] using hB.2⟩ have hclass := sameClass_add (sameClass_delete hB.1 (small_finite (finite_singleton e))) (small_finite (finite_singleton f)) simpa only [Set.union_singleton] using hclass lemma localLower_correct_up {T X G : Set E0} (hX : SameClass T X) (hG : ¬ Small G) (hGX : G ⊆ Xᶜ) (hlo : probeLiminf (fProbe T) X ≤ -1) : ∃ B ∈ LocalLower T, X ⊆ B ∧ B ⊆ X ∪ G := by obtain ⟨P,hPG,hP,ht⟩ := positive_pool_add hX hG hGX have hlim : probeLiminf (fProbe T) (X ∪ P) = ⊤ := (EReal.tendsto_coe_atTop.comp ht).liminf_eq obtain ⟨B,hXB,hBP,hBT,hB⟩ := fProbe_interpolation hX (sameClass_add hX hP) (Set.subset_union_left) hlo (by rw [hlim]; exact EReal.coe_lt_top 0) exact ⟨B,⟨hBT,hB⟩,hXB,hBP.trans (union_subset_union_right X hPG)⟩ lemma localLower_correct_down {T X G : Set E0} (hX : SameClass T X) (hG : ¬ Small G) (hGX : G ⊆ X) (hhi : 0 < probeLiminf (fProbe T) X) : ∃ B ∈ LocalLower T, X \ G ⊆ B ∧ B ⊆ X := by obtain ⟨P,hPG,hP,ht⟩ := positive_pool_delete hX hG hGX have hlim : probeLiminf (fProbe T) (X \ P) = ⊥ := (EReal.tendsto_coe_atBot.comp ht).liminf_eq obtain ⟨B,hPB,hBX,hBT,hB⟩ := fProbe_interpolation (sameClass_delete hX hP) hX sdiff_subset (by rw [hlim]; exact bot_le) hhi exact ⟨B,⟨hBT,hB⟩,(Set.sdiff_subset_sdiff_right hPG).trans hPB,hBX⟩ /-- Upper rule with its complement identity built into the definition. -/ def LocalUpper (T : Set E0) : Set (Set E0) := {X | Xᶜ ∈ LocalLower Tᶜ} lemma localUpper_iff (T X : Set E0) : X ∈ LocalUpper T ↔ SameClass T X ∧ 0 ≤ limsup (fun n ↦ (fProbe T n X : EReal)) atTop ∧ limsup (fun n ↦ (fProbe T n X : EReal)) atTop < 1 := by have hc : SameClass Tᶜ Xᶜ ↔ SameClass T X := ⟨fun h ↦ by simpa using sameClass_compl h, sameClass_compl⟩ have he : probeLiminf (fProbe Tᶜ) Xᶜ = -limsup (fun n ↦ (fProbe T n X : EReal)) atTop := by simp only [probeLiminf, fProbe_compl, EReal.coe_neg] exact EReal.liminf_neg simp only [LocalUpper, Set.mem_ofPred_eq, LocalLower, LowerBasis, hc, he] simp only [EReal.neg_le_zero, EReal.lt_neg_comm, neg_neg] tauto def LocalRule (upper : Bool) (T : Set E0) : Set (Set E0) := if upper then LocalUpper T else LocalLower T lemma localRule_class {s : Bool} {T X : Set E0} (h : X ∈ LocalRule s T) : SameClass T X := by cases s with | false => exact h.1 | true => change Xᶜ ∈ LocalLower Tᶜ at h simpa using sameClass_compl h.1 lemma localRule_self (s : Bool) (T : Set E0) : T ∈ LocalRule s T := by cases s with | false => exact localLower_self _ | true => change Tᶜ ∈ LocalLower Tᶜ exact localLower_self Tᶜ lemma localRule_compl {s : Bool} {T X : Set E0} (h : X ∈ LocalRule s T) : Xᶜ ∈ LocalRule (!s) Tᶜ := by cases s with | false => simpa [LocalRule,LocalUpper] using h | true => exact h lemma localRule_antichain (s : Bool) (T : Set E0) : ∀ ⦃X Y⦄, X ∈ LocalRule s T → Y ∈ LocalRule s T → X ⊆ Y → X = Y := by cases s with | false => exact localLower_antichain T | true => intro X Y hX hY hXY have he := localLower_antichain Tᶜ hY hX (compl_subset_compl.mpr hXY) exact compl_injective he.symm lemma localRule_swap {s : Bool} {T B : Set E0} (hB : B ∈ LocalRule s T) (e : E0) (he : e ∈ B) (f : E0) (hf : f ∉ B) : insert f (B \ {e}) ∈ LocalRule s T := by cases s with | false => exact localLower_swap hB e he f hf | true => have hc : (insert f (B \ {e}))ᶜ = insert e (Bᶜ \ {f}) := by ext x simp only [mem_compl_iff, Set.mem_insert_iff, Set.mem_sdiff, Set.mem_singleton_iff] have hx1 : x = e → x ∈ B := fun h ↦ h ▸ he have hx2 : x = f → x ∉ B := fun h ↦ h ▸ hf tauto change (insert f (B \ {e}))ᶜ ∈ LocalLower Tᶜ rw [hc] change Bᶜ ∈ LocalLower Tᶜ at hB exact localLower_swap hB f hf e (by simpa using he) lemma localLower_interval {T I Y : Set E0} (hT : ¬ Small T) (hTc : ¬ Small Tᶜ) (hIY : I ⊆ Y) (hI : SameClass T I) (hY : SameClass T Y) : ∃ B ∈ LocalLower T, B ⊆ I ∨ (I ⊆ B ∧ B ⊆ Y) ∨ Y ⊆ B := by by_cases hlo : -1 < probeLiminf (fProbe T) I · by_cases hhi : probeLiminf (fProbe T) I ≤ 0 · exact ⟨I,⟨hI,hlo,hhi⟩,Or.inl Subset.rfl⟩ · obtain ⟨B,hB,_,hBI⟩ := localLower_correct_down hI (positive_sameClass hT hI) Subset.rfl (lt_of_not_ge hhi) exact ⟨B,hB,Or.inl hBI⟩ · by_cases hhi : 0 < probeLiminf (fProbe T) Y · obtain ⟨B,hIB,hBY,hBT,hB⟩ := fProbe_interpolation hI hY hIY (le_of_not_gt hlo) hhi exact ⟨B,⟨hBT,hB⟩,Or.inr (Or.inl ⟨hIB,hBY⟩)⟩ · by_cases hyl : -1 < probeLiminf (fProbe T) Y · exact ⟨Y,⟨hY,hyl,le_of_not_gt hhi⟩,Or.inr (Or.inr Subset.rfl)⟩ · obtain ⟨B,hB,hYB,_⟩ := localLower_correct_up hY (positive_sameClass hTc (sameClass_compl hY)) Subset.rfl (le_of_not_gt hyl) exact ⟨B,hB,Or.inr (Or.inr hYB)⟩ lemma localLower_lower_endpoint {T I Y : Set E0} (hT : ¬ Small T) (hIY : I ⊆ Y) (hI : SameClass T I) (hgap : ¬ Small (Y \ I)) : ∃ B ∈ LocalLower T, B ⊆ I ∨ (I ⊆ B ∧ B ⊆ Y) := by by_cases hlo : -1 < probeLiminf (fProbe T) I · by_cases hhi : probeLiminf (fProbe T) I ≤ 0 · exact ⟨I,⟨hI,hlo,hhi⟩,Or.inl Subset.rfl⟩ · obtain ⟨B,hB,_,hBI⟩ := localLower_correct_down hI (positive_sameClass hT hI) Subset.rfl (lt_of_not_ge hhi) exact ⟨B,hB,Or.inl hBI⟩ · obtain ⟨B,hB,hIB,hBY⟩ := localLower_correct_up hI hgap (fun _ hx ↦ hx.2) (le_of_not_gt hlo) exact ⟨B,hB,Or.inr ⟨hIB,hBY.trans (union_subset hIY sdiff_subset)⟩⟩ lemma localLower_upper_endpoint {T I Y : Set E0} (hTc : ¬ Small Tᶜ) (hIY : I ⊆ Y) (hY : SameClass T Y) (hgap : ¬ Small (Y \ I)) : ∃ B ∈ LocalLower T, (I ⊆ B ∧ B ⊆ Y) ∨ Y ⊆ B := by by_cases hhi : 0 < probeLiminf (fProbe T) Y · obtain ⟨B,hB,hIB,hBY⟩ := localLower_correct_down hY hgap sdiff_subset hhi exact ⟨B,hB,Or.inl ⟨(by intro x hx; exact hIB ⟨hIY hx,fun h ↦ h.2 hx⟩),hBY⟩⟩ · by_cases hlo : -1 < probeLiminf (fProbe T) Y · exact ⟨Y,⟨hY,hlo,le_of_not_gt hhi⟩,Or.inr Subset.rfl⟩ · obtain ⟨B,hB,hYB,_⟩ := localLower_correct_up hY (positive_sameClass hTc (sameClass_compl hY)) Subset.rfl (le_of_not_gt hlo) exact ⟨B,hB,Or.inr hYB⟩ lemma localRule_interval (s : Bool) {T I Y : Set E0} (hT : ¬ Small T) (hTc : ¬ Small Tᶜ) (hIY : I ⊆ Y) (hI : SameClass T I) (hY : SameClass T Y) : ∃ B ∈ LocalRule s T, B ⊆ I ∨ (I ⊆ B ∧ B ⊆ Y) ∨ Y ⊆ B := by cases s with | false => exact localLower_interval hT hTc hIY hI hY | true => obtain ⟨B,hB,hBI | ⟨hIB,hBY⟩ | hYB⟩ := localLower_interval hTc (by simpa using hT) (compl_subset_compl.mpr hIY) (sameClass_compl hY) (sameClass_compl hI) · refine ⟨Bᶜ,?_,Or.inr (Or.inr ?_)⟩ · simpa [LocalRule,LocalUpper] using hB · simpa using compl_subset_compl.mpr hBI · refine ⟨Bᶜ,?_,Or.inr (Or.inl ⟨?_,?_⟩)⟩ · simpa [LocalRule,LocalUpper] using hB · simpa using compl_subset_compl.mpr hBY · simpa using compl_subset_compl.mpr hIB · refine ⟨Bᶜ,?_,Or.inl ?_⟩ · simpa [LocalRule,LocalUpper] using hB · simpa using compl_subset_compl.mpr hYB lemma localRule_lower_endpoint (s : Bool) {T I Y : Set E0} (hT : ¬ Small T) (_hTc : ¬ Small Tᶜ) (hIY : I ⊆ Y) (hI : SameClass T I) (hgap : ¬ Small (Y \ I)) : ∃ B ∈ LocalRule s T, B ⊆ I ∨ (I ⊆ B ∧ B ⊆ Y) := by cases s with | false => exact localLower_lower_endpoint hT hIY hI hgap | true => have hg : ¬ Small (Iᶜ \ Yᶜ) := by have he : Iᶜ \ Yᶜ = Y \ I := by ext x; simp only [Set.mem_sdiff,mem_compl_iff]; tauto rwa [he] obtain ⟨B,hB,⟨hIB,hBY⟩ | hYB⟩ := localLower_upper_endpoint (T := Tᶜ) (I := Yᶜ) (Y := Iᶜ) (by simpa only [compl_compl] using hT) (compl_subset_compl.mpr hIY) (sameClass_compl hI) hg · refine ⟨Bᶜ,?_,Or.inr ⟨?_,?_⟩⟩ · simpa [LocalRule,LocalUpper] using hB · simpa using compl_subset_compl.mpr hBY · simpa using compl_subset_compl.mpr hIB · refine ⟨Bᶜ,?_,Or.inl ?_⟩ · simpa [LocalRule,LocalUpper] using hB · simpa using compl_subset_compl.mpr hYB lemma localRule_upper_endpoint (s : Bool) {T I Y : Set E0} (_hT : ¬ Small T) (hTc : ¬ Small Tᶜ) (hIY : I ⊆ Y) (hY : SameClass T Y) (hgap : ¬ Small (Y \ I)) : ∃ B ∈ LocalRule s T, (I ⊆ B ∧ B ⊆ Y) ∨ Y ⊆ B := by cases s with | false => exact localLower_upper_endpoint hTc hIY hY hgap | true => have hg : ¬ Small (Iᶜ \ Yᶜ) := by have he : Iᶜ \ Yᶜ = Y \ I := by ext x; simp only [Set.mem_sdiff,mem_compl_iff]; tauto rwa [he] obtain ⟨B,hB,hBI | ⟨hIB,hBY⟩⟩ := localLower_lower_endpoint hTc (compl_subset_compl.mpr hIY) (sameClass_compl hY) hg · refine ⟨Bᶜ,?_,Or.inr ?_⟩ · simpa [LocalRule,LocalUpper] using hB · simpa using compl_subset_compl.mpr hBI · refine ⟨Bᶜ,?_,Or.inl ⟨?_,?_⟩⟩ · simpa [LocalRule,LocalUpper] using hB · simpa using compl_subset_compl.mpr hBY · simpa using compl_subset_compl.mpr hIB end InfiniteMatroidCounterexample end end OAI