import OAI.Combinatorics.InfiniteMatroid.SparsePerturbation import OAI.Combinatorics.InfiniteMatroid.Interpolation namespace OAI section open Set Filter open scoped Topology symmDiff namespace InfiniteMatroidCounterexample instance d_infinite : Infinite D := Infinite.of_injective (fun m : ℕ ↦ (⟨m, fun _ ↦ false⟩ : D)) (fun _ _ h ↦ congrArg Sigma.fst h) instance e0_infinite : Infinite E0 := inferInstance instance d_countable : Countable D := inferInstance instance e0_countable : Countable E0 := inferInstance noncomputable def labelEquiv : E0 ≃ ℕ := by letI := Classical.choice (nonempty_denumerable E0) exact Denumerable.eqv E0 noncomputable def natProbe (T : Set E0) (n : ℕ) (A : Set ℕ) : ℝ := fProbe T n (labelEquiv ⁻¹' A) lemma natProbe_cylinder {T I Y : Set E0} (hI : SameClass T I) (hY : SameClass T Y) : CylinderContinuous (natProbe T) (labelEquiv.symm ⁻¹' I) (labelEquiv.symm ⁻¹' Y) := by classical intro j ε hε obtain ⟨N, _, hN⟩ := fProbe_block_continuity hI hY j hε refine ⟨(blockPrefix N).sup labelEquiv + 1, ?_⟩ intro X Z hIX hXY hIZ hZY hagree n hnj apply hN (labelEquiv ⁻¹' X) (labelEquiv ⁻¹' Z) · intro x hx exact hIX (by simpa using hx) · intro x hx simpa using hXY hx · intro x hx exact hIZ (by simpa using hx) · intro x hx simpa using hZY hx · intro x hx apply hagree (labelEquiv x) have hle := Finset.le_sup (f := labelEquiv) ((mem_prefix x N).mpr hx) omega · exact hnj.le lemma natProbe_shift (T : Set E0) (I Y : Set ℕ) : IntervalFiniteShift (natProbe T) I Y := by intro A B _ hAB _ hfin have hf : (labelEquiv ⁻¹' B \ labelEquiv ⁻¹' A).Finite := by rw [← Set.preimage_sdiff] exact Set.Finite.preimage labelEquiv.injective.injOn hfin have he := finite_change_eventually (T := T) (Set.preimage_mono hAB) hf have hc : (labelEquiv ⁻¹' B \ labelEquiv ⁻¹' A).ncard = (B \ A).ncard := by rw [← Set.preimage_sdiff] exact Set.ncard_preimage_of_injective_subset_range labelEquiv.injective (by rw [labelEquiv.surjective.range_eq]; exact subset_univ _) rw [hc] at he simpa only [probeLiminf, natProbe, EReal.coe_natCast] using probeLiminf_finite_change he lemma fProbe_interpolation {T I Y : Set E0} (hI : SameClass T I) (hY : SameClass T Y) (hIY : I ⊆ Y) (hlow : probeLiminf (fProbe T) I ≤ -1) (hhigh : 0 < probeLiminf (fProbe T) Y) : ∃ B, I ⊆ B ∧ B ⊆ Y ∧ SameClass T B ∧ LowerBasis (fProbe T) B := by have hpre (X : Set E0) : labelEquiv ⁻¹' (labelEquiv.symm ⁻¹' X) = X := by ext x simp have hlim (X : Set E0) : probeLiminf (natProbe T) (labelEquiv.symm ⁻¹' X) = probeLiminf (fProbe T) X := by simp only [probeLiminf, natProbe, hpre] obtain ⟨B, hIB, hBY, hB⟩ := local_interpolation (Set.preimage_mono (f := labelEquiv.symm) hIY) (natProbe_cylinder hI hY) (fun n A B _ hAB _ ↦ fProbe_mono T (Set.preimage_mono hAB) n) (fun n A B _ _ _ h ↦ by obtain ⟨e, he⟩ := h calc natProbe T n B ≤ fProbe T n (insert (labelEquiv.symm e) (labelEquiv ⁻¹' A)) := by apply fProbe_mono intro x hx rcases he hx with heq | hxA · left exact labelEquiv.injective (by simpa using heq) · exact Or.inr hxA _ ≤ natProbe T n A + 1 := fProbe_insert_le _ _ _ _) (natProbe_shift T _ _) (by rw [hlim]; exact hlow) (by rw [hlim]; exact hhigh) have hi : I ⊆ labelEquiv ⁻¹' B := by intro x hx exact hIB (by simpa using hx) have hy : labelEquiv ⁻¹' B ⊆ Y := by intro x hx simpa using hBY hx exact ⟨labelEquiv ⁻¹' B, hi, hy, sameClass_interval hI hY hi hy, hB⟩ def LocalLower (T : Set E0) : Set (Set E0) := {X | SameClass T X ∧ LowerBasis (fProbe T) X} lemma localLower_antichain (T : Set E0) : ∀ ⦃X Y⦄, X ∈ LocalLower T → Y ∈ LocalLower T → X ⊆ Y → X = Y := by intro X Y hX hY hXY by_contra hne obtain ⟨e, heY, heX⟩ := Set.not_subset.mp (fun hYX ↦ hne (Subset.antisymm hXY hYX)) have hs : probeLiminf (fProbe T) (insert e X) = probeLiminf (fProbe T) X + 1 := by have heq : insert e X \ X = {e} := by ext x; simp [heX] have he := finite_change_eventually (T := T) (subset_insert e X) (show (insert e X \ X).Finite by rw [heq]; exact finite_singleton e) simp only [heq, ncard_singleton, Nat.cast_one] at he simpa using probeLiminf_finite_change he have hm := probeLiminf_mono (fun n ↦ fProbe_mono T (Set.insert_subset heY hXY) n) rw [hs] at hm have : (0 : EReal) < probeLiminf (fProbe T) X + 1 := by have hh := EReal.add_lt_add_right_coe hX.2.1 1 have hz : (-1 : EReal) + 1 = 0 := by change ((-1 : ℝ) : EReal) + ((1 : ℝ) : EReal) = 0 rw [← EReal.coe_add] norm_num simpa only [EReal.coe_one, hz] using hh exact (this.trans_le hm).not_ge hY.2.2 end InfiniteMatroidCounterexample end end OAI