import Mathlib.Tactic.DeriveFintype import OAI.Computability.BinPacking.Search.SearchInitializeEncoding namespace OAI namespace BinPackingGap.ExtensionAgreementMachine open Turing BinPackingGames.Foundations.Complexity MachineComposition inductive Label | entry | option | skipFlag | skipDigit | compareFlag | compareDigit | checkEnd | drainFixed | drainAssignments | accept | reject deriving DecidableEq protected abbrev Label.enumList : List Label := [.entry, .option, .skipFlag, .skipDigit, .compareFlag, .compareDigit, .checkEnd, .drainFixed, .drainAssignments, .accept, .reject] protected theorem Label.enumList_getElem?_ctorIdx_eq (x : Label) : Label.enumList[x.ctorIdx]? = some x := by cases x <;> rfl protected theorem Label.enumList_nodup : Label.enumList.Nodup := by decide instance : Fintype Label where elems := ⟨Label.enumList, Label.enumList_nodup⟩ complete x := by cases x <;> decide abbrev Alphabet (_ : Fin 2) := Bool abbrev State := Option Bool × Option Bool def jump (label : Label) : TM2.Stmt Alphabet Label State := .load (fun _ => (none, none)) (.goto fun _ => label) def readBoth (zero one : Label) : TM2.Stmt Alphabet Label State := .pop 0 (fun state head => (head, state.2)) (.pop 1 (fun state head => (state.1, head)) (.branch (fun state => state.1.isSome && state.2.isSome) (.branch (fun state => decide (state.1 = state.2)) (.branch (fun state => state.1.getD false) (jump one) (jump zero)) (jump .drainFixed)) (jump .drainFixed))) def program : Label → TM2.Stmt Alphabet Label State | .entry => readBoth .checkEnd .option | .option => .pop 0 (fun state head => (head, state.2)) (.branch (fun state => state.1.isSome) (.branch (fun state => state.1.getD false) (jump .compareFlag) (jump .skipFlag)) (jump .drainFixed)) | .skipFlag => .pop 1 (fun state head => (state.1, head)) (.branch (fun state => state.2.isSome) (.branch (fun state => state.2.getD false) (jump .skipDigit) (jump .entry)) (jump .drainFixed)) | .skipDigit => .pop 1 (fun state head => (state.1, head)) (.branch (fun state => state.2.isSome) (jump .skipFlag) (jump .drainFixed)) | .compareFlag => readBoth .entry .compareDigit | .compareDigit => readBoth .compareFlag .compareFlag | .checkEnd => .pop 0 (fun state head => (head, state.2)) (.pop 1 (fun state head => (state.1, head)) (.branch (fun state => state.1.isNone && state.2.isNone) (jump .accept) (jump .drainFixed))) | .drainFixed => .pop 0 (fun state head => (head, state.2)) (.branch (fun state => state.1.isSome) (jump .drainFixed) (jump .drainAssignments)) | .drainAssignments => .pop 1 (fun state head => (state.1, head)) (.branch (fun state => state.2.isSome) (jump .drainAssignments) (jump .reject)) | .accept => .push 0 (fun _ => true) .halt | .reject => .push 0 (fun _ => false) .halt abbrev machine : FinTM2 where K := Fin 2 k₀ := 0 k₁ := 0 Γ := Alphabet Λ := Label main := .entry σ := State initialState := (none, none) m := program def tapes (fixed assignments : List Bool) : Fin 2 → List Bool := fun k => if k = 0 then fixed else assignments def cfg (label : Label) (fixed assignments : List Bool) : machine.Cfg := ⟨some label, (none, none), tapes fixed assignments⟩ private theorem update_fixed (fixed assignments replacement : List Bool) : Function.update (tapes fixed assignments) 0 replacement = tapes replacement assignments := by funext k; fin_cases k <;> simp [tapes] private theorem update_assignments (fixed assignments replacement : List Bool) : Function.update (tapes fixed assignments) 1 replacement = tapes fixed replacement := by funext k; fin_cases k <;> simp [tapes] structure View where label : Label fixed : List Bool assignments : List Bool def View.cfg (view : View) : machine.Cfg := BinPackingGap.ExtensionAgreementMachine.cfg view.label view.fixed view.assignments def bothView (zero one : Label) (fixed assignments : List Bool) : View := if fixed.head?.isSome && assignments.head?.isSome then if fixed.head? = assignments.head? then ⟨if fixed.head?.getD false then one else zero, fixed.tail, assignments.tail⟩ else ⟨.drainFixed, fixed.tail, assignments.tail⟩ else ⟨.drainFixed, fixed.tail, assignments.tail⟩ def next (view : View) : View := match view.label with | .entry => bothView .checkEnd .option view.fixed view.assignments | .option => if view.fixed.head?.isSome then ⟨if view.fixed.head?.getD false then .compareFlag else .skipFlag, view.fixed.tail, view.assignments⟩ else ⟨.drainFixed, view.fixed.tail, view.assignments⟩ | .skipFlag => if view.assignments.head?.isSome then ⟨if view.assignments.head?.getD false then .skipDigit else .entry, view.fixed, view.assignments.tail⟩ else ⟨.drainFixed, view.fixed, view.assignments.tail⟩ | .skipDigit => ⟨if view.assignments.head?.isSome then .skipFlag else .drainFixed, view.fixed, view.assignments.tail⟩ | .compareFlag => bothView .entry .compareDigit view.fixed view.assignments | .compareDigit => bothView .compareFlag .compareFlag view.fixed view.assignments | .checkEnd => ⟨if view.fixed.head?.isNone && view.assignments.head?.isNone then .accept else .drainFixed, view.fixed.tail, view.assignments.tail⟩ | .drainFixed => ⟨if view.fixed.head?.isSome then .drainFixed else .drainAssignments, view.fixed.tail, view.assignments⟩ | .drainAssignments => ⟨if view.assignments.head?.isSome then .drainAssignments else .reject, view.fixed, view.assignments.tail⟩ | .accept | .reject => view def Terminal (label : Label) : Prop := label = .accept ∨ label = .reject instance (label : Label) : Decidable (Terminal label) := inferInstanceAs (Decidable (label = .accept ∨ label = .reject)) def rank : Label → Nat | .accept | .reject => 0 | .drainAssignments => 1 | .drainFixed => 2 | _ => 3 def potential (view : View) : Nat := view.fixed.length + view.assignments.length + rank view.label theorem next_decreases (view : View) (active : ¬ Terminal view.label) : potential (next view) < potential view := by rcases view with ⟨label, fixed, assignments⟩ cases label <;> cases fixed <;> cases assignments <;> simp_all [Terminal, next, bothView, potential, rank] <;> (try split_ifs) <;> (try simp_all) <;> omega theorem step_view (view : View) (active : ¬ Terminal view.label) : machine.step view.cfg = some (next view).cfg := by rcases view with ⟨label, fixed, assignments⟩ change (some (TM2.stepAux (program label) (none, none) (tapes fixed assignments)) : Option (TM2.Cfg Alphabet Label State)) = some ⟨some (next ⟨label, fixed, assignments⟩).label, (none, none), tapes (next ⟨label, fixed, assignments⟩).fixed (next ⟨label, fixed, assignments⟩).assignments⟩ cases label <;> cases fixed <;> cases assignments <;> simp_all [Terminal, program, readBoth, jump, TM2.stepAux, next, bothView, update_fixed, update_assignments, tapes, Bool.cond_eq_ite] <;> (try split_ifs) <;> simp_all def run (view : View) : View := if _stopped : Terminal view.label then view else run (next view) termination_by potential view decreasing_by exact next_decreases view _stopped theorem run_step (view : View) (active : ¬ Terminal view.label) : run view = run (next view) := by rw [run, dite_eq_right active] theorem run_terminal (view : View) (stopped : Terminal view.label) : run view = view := by rw [run, dite_eq_left stopped] theorem runTrace (view : View) : ∃ steps, steps ≤ potential view ∧ (advance machine.step)^[steps] (some view.cfg) = some (run view).cfg := by induction view using (measure potential).wf.induction with | h view ih => by_cases stopped : Terminal view.label · refine ⟨0, Nat.zero_le _, ?_⟩ simp only [Function.iterate_zero, id_eq, run_terminal view stopped] · have smaller := next_decreases view stopped obtain ⟨steps, bounded, trace⟩ := ih (next view) smaller refine ⟨steps + 1, by omega, ?_⟩ rw [Function.iterate_succ_apply] simp only [advance_some, step_view view stopped] rw [trace, run_step view stopped] theorem run_isTerminal (view : View) : Terminal (run view).label := by induction view using (measure potential).wf.induction with | h view ih => by_cases stopped : Terminal view.label · rw [run_terminal view stopped] exact stopped · rw [run_step view stopped] exact ih (next view) (next_decreases view stopped) def resultView (accepted : Bool) : View := ⟨if accepted then .accept else .reject, [], []⟩ theorem run_drainAssignments (assignments : List Bool) : run ⟨.drainAssignments, [], assignments⟩ = resultView false := by induction assignments with | nil => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] exact run_terminal _ (Or.inr rfl) | cons bit assignments ih => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] exact ih theorem run_drainFixed (fixed assignments : List Bool) : run ⟨.drainFixed, fixed, assignments⟩ = resultView false := by induction fixed with | nil => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] exact run_drainAssignments assignments | cons bit fixed ih => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] exact ih theorem run_checkEnd_empty : run ⟨.checkEnd, [], []⟩ = resultView true := by rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] exact run_terminal _ (Or.inl rfl) theorem run_skipFrame (bits fixed suffix : List Bool) : run ⟨.skipFlag, fixed, BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame bits ++ suffix⟩ = run ⟨.entry, fixed, suffix⟩ := by induction bits with | nil => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] rfl | cons bit bits ih => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] change run ⟨.skipDigit, fixed, bit :: (BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame bits ++ suffix)⟩ = _ rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] exact ih theorem run_compareFrame (left right fixedSuffix assignmentSuffix : List Bool) : run ⟨.compareFlag, BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame left ++ fixedSuffix, BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame right ++ assignmentSuffix⟩ = if left = right then run ⟨.entry, fixedSuffix, assignmentSuffix⟩ else resultView false := by induction left generalizing right with | nil => cases right with | nil => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] simp [next, bothView, BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame] | cons bit right => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] simp [next, bothView, BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame, run_drainFixed] | cons bit left ih => cases right with | nil => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] simp [next, bothView, BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame, run_drainFixed] | cons digit right => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] change run ⟨.compareDigit, bit :: (BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame left ++ fixedSuffix), digit :: (BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame right ++ assignmentSuffix)⟩ = _ rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] by_cases equal : bit = digit · subst digit cases bit <;> simpa [next, bothView, BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame] using ih right · simp [next, bothView, equal, run_drainFixed] abbrev fixedBits (fixed : List (Option Nat)) : List Bool := BinaryEncoding.listBits (BinaryEncoding.optionBits BinaryEncoding.natBits) fixed theorem run_encoded (fixed : List (Option Nat)) (assignments : List Nat) : run ⟨.entry, fixedBits fixed, BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits assignments⟩ = resultView (ExtensionCertificate.agreesBool fixed assignments) := by induction fixed generalizing assignments with | nil => cases assignments with | nil => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] exact run_checkEnd_empty | cons value assignments => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] simp [next, bothView, fixedBits, BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits, BinaryEncoding.listBits, ExtensionCertificate.agreesBool, run_drainFixed] | cons entry fixed ih => cases assignments with | nil => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] simp [next, bothView, fixedBits, BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits, BinaryEncoding.listBits, ExtensionCertificate.agreesBool, run_drainFixed] | cons value assignments => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] change run ⟨.option, BinaryEncoding.optionBits BinaryEncoding.natBits entry ++ fixedBits fixed, BinaryEncoding.natBits value ++ BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits assignments⟩ = _ cases entry with | none => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] change run ⟨.skipFlag, fixedBits fixed, BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame value.bits ++ BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits assignments⟩ = resultView (ExtensionCertificate.agreesBool fixed assignments) rw [run_skipFrame] exact ih assignments | some label => rw [run_step _ (by simp [Terminal])] change run ⟨.compareFlag, BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame label.bits ++ fixedBits fixed, BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.frame value.bits ++ BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits assignments⟩ = resultView (decide (label = value) && ExtensionCertificate.agreesBool fixed assignments) rw [run_compareFrame] have bits_iff : label.bits = value.bits ↔ label = value := by constructor · intro h have values := congrArg BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.bitsValue h simpa only [BinPackingCompleteness.BinaryEncoding.bitsValue_bits] using values · rintro rfl rfl by_cases equal : label = value · subst value simpa using ih assignments · simp [bits_iff, equal] noncomputable def agreementTime : Polynomial Nat := Polynomial.X + 3 structure RawRun (fixed assignments : List Bool) where finish : View terminal : Terminal finish.label execution : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime machine.step (cfg .entry fixed assignments) (some finish.cfg) (agreementTime.eval (fixed.length + assignments.length)) noncomputable def rawInTime (fixed assignments : List Bool) : RawRun fixed assignments := by let view : View := ⟨.entry, fixed, assignments⟩ let trace := runTrace view let steps := Classical.choose trace let result := Classical.choose_spec trace refine ⟨run view, run_isTerminal view, ?_⟩ exact { steps := steps evals_in_steps := by change (advance machine.step)^[steps] (some view.cfg) = some (run view).cfg exact result.2 steps_le_m := by simpa only [steps, view, potential, rank, agreementTime, Polynomial.eval_add, Polynomial.eval_X, Polynomial.eval_ofNat] using result.1 } noncomputable def agreementInTime (fixed : List (Option Nat)) (assignments : List Nat) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime machine.step (cfg .entry (fixedBits fixed) (BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits assignments)) (some (cfg (if ExtensionCertificate.agreesBool fixed assignments then .accept else .reject) [] [])) (agreementTime.eval ((fixedBits fixed).length + (BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits assignments).length)) := by have trace := (rawInTime (fixedBits fixed) (BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits assignments)).execution change StateTransition.EvalsToInTime machine.step _ (some (run ⟨.entry, fixedBits fixed, BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits assignments⟩).cfg) _ at trace rw [run_encoded] at trace simpa only [resultView, View.cfg] using trace theorem flagStep (accepted : Bool) : machine.step (cfg (if accepted then .accept else .reject) [] []) = some ⟨none, (none, none), tapes [accepted] []⟩ := by cases accepted <;> simp [FinTM2.step, TM2.step, machine, program, cfg, TM2.stepAux, update_fixed, tapes] <;> rfl noncomputable def agreementFlagInTime (fixed : List (Option Nat)) (assignments : List Nat) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime machine.step (cfg .entry (fixedBits fixed) (BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits assignments)) (some ⟨none, (none, none), tapes [ExtensionCertificate.agreesBool fixed assignments] []⟩) (agreementTime.eval ((fixedBits fixed).length + (BinaryEncoding.assignmentBits assignments).length) + 1) := by let stage := agreementInTime fixed assignments let finish : machine.Cfg := ⟨none, (none, none), tapes [ExtensionCertificate.agreesBool fixed assignments] []⟩ have last : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime machine.step (cfg (if ExtensionCertificate.agreesBool fixed assignments then .accept else .reject) [] []) (some finish) 1 := { steps := 1 evals_in_steps := by change machine.step (cfg (if ExtensionCertificate.agreesBool fixed assignments then .accept else .reject) [] []) = some finish exact flagStep (ExtensionCertificate.agreesBool fixed assignments) steps_le_m := Nat.le_refl _ } simpa only [Nat.add_comm] using StateTransition.EvalsToInTime.trans machine.step _ 1 _ _ (some finish) stage last theorem machine_finiteAlphabet (k : machine.K) : Finite (machine.Γ k) := by change Finite Bool infer_instance end BinPackingGap.ExtensionAgreementMachine end OAI