import OAI.Computability.DepthThree.Circuit import OAI.Computability.DepthThree.RestrictionNormalization namespace OAI universe uDepth1 namespace DepthThreeLowerBound variable {V : Type uDepth1} namespace RawClause def literalPart : GateInput V → Option (Literal V) | .inl l => some l | .inr _ => none noncomputable def literals (C : RawClause V) : Clause V := by classical exact (C.filterMap literalPart).toFinset @[simp] theorem mem_literals (C : RawClause V) (l : Literal V) : l ∈ C.literals ↔ Sum.inl l ∈ C := by classical simp only [literals, List.mem_toFinset, List.mem_filterMap] constructor · rintro ⟨a, ha, he⟩ cases a with | inl k => have hk : k = l := Option.some.inj he simpa [hk] using ha | inr b => simp [literalPart] at he · intro h exact ⟨.inl l, h, rfl⟩ theorem eval_true_iff (C : RawClause V) (x : Cube V) : C.eval x = true ↔ Sum.inr true ∈ C ∨ C.literals.eval x = true := by rw [eval_eq_true, Clause.eval_eq_true] constructor · rintro ⟨a, ha, hx⟩ cases a with | inl l => exact Or.inr ⟨l, (mem_literals C l).mpr ha, (Literal.eval_eq_true l x).mp hx⟩ | inr b => change b = true at hx exact Or.inl (hx ▸ ha) · rintro (h | ⟨l, hl, hx⟩) · exact ⟨.inr true, h, rfl⟩ · exact ⟨.inl l, (mem_literals C l).mp hl, (Literal.eval_eq_true l x).mpr hx⟩ noncomputable def normalize (C : RawClause V) : Option (Clause V) := by classical exact if Sum.inr true ∈ C ∨ ¬ C.literals.Normalized then none else some C.literals theorem normalized_of_normalize_eq_some {C : RawClause V} {D : Clause V} (h : C.normalize = some D) : D.Normalized := by classical unfold normalize at h split at h · contradiction · rename_i hn have hCD : C.literals = D := Option.some.inj h rw [← hCD] exact Classical.not_not.mp (fun hbad => hn (Or.inr hbad)) theorem normalize_eval (C : RawClause V) (x : Cube V) : ((C.normalize).map (fun D => D.eval x)).getD true = C.eval x := by classical unfold normalize split · rename_i h have ht : C.eval x = true := by apply (eval_true_iff C x).mpr rcases h with h | h · exact Or.inl h · exact Or.inr (Clause.eval_true_of_not_normalized h x) simp [ht] · rename_i h have hc : Sum.inr true ∉ C := fun hc => h (Or.inl hc) change C.literals.eval x = C.eval x apply Bool.eq_iff_iff.mpr rw [eval_true_iff] simp [hc] end RawClause namespace Circuit3 noncomputable def middleCNF (C : Circuit3 V) (j : Fin C.middleCount) : CNF V := (C.middle j).toList.filterMap fun i => (C.bottom i).normalize theorem mem_middleCNF (C : Circuit3 V) (j : Fin C.middleCount) (D : Clause V) : D ∈ C.middleCNF j ↔ ∃ i ∈ C.middle j, (C.bottom i).normalize = some D := by simp [middleCNF, List.mem_filterMap] theorem middleCNF_normalized (C : Circuit3 V) (j : Fin C.middleCount) : (C.middleCNF j).Normalized := by intro D hD obtain ⟨i, _, hi⟩ := (mem_middleCNF C j D).mp hD exact RawClause.normalized_of_normalize_eq_some hi theorem middleCNF_length_le_bottomCount (C : Circuit3 V) (j : Fin C.middleCount) : (C.middleCNF j).length ≤ C.bottomCount := by calc (C.middleCNF j).length ≤ (C.middle j).toList.length := List.length_filterMap_le _ _ _ = (C.middle j).card := Finset.length_toList _ _ ≤ C.bottomCount := by simpa using Finset.card_le_univ (C.middle j) theorem middleCNF_length_le_gateCount (C : Circuit3 V) (j : Fin C.middleCount) : (C.middleCNF j).length ≤ C.gateCount := (C.middleCNF_length_le_bottomCount j).trans C.bottomCount_le_gateCount @[simp] theorem eval_middleCNF (C : Circuit3 V) (j : Fin C.middleCount) (x : Cube V) : (C.middleCNF j).eval x = C.middleEval j x := by classical apply Bool.eq_iff_iff.mpr rw [CNF.eval_eq_true, middleEval_eq_true] constructor · intro hx i hi have he := (C.bottom i).normalize_eval x cases hn : (C.bottom i).normalize with | none => simpa [hn] using he.symm | some D => have hD := hx D ((mem_middleCNF C j D).mpr ⟨i, hi, hn⟩) simpa [hn, hD] using he.symm · intro hx D hD obtain ⟨i, hi, hn⟩ := (mem_middleCNF C j D).mp hD have he := (C.bottom i).normalize_eval x simpa [hn, hx i hi] using he theorem eval_eq_true_iff_middleCNF (C : Circuit3 V) (x : Cube V) : C.eval x = true ↔ ∃ j ∈ C.top, (C.middleCNF j).eval x = true := by simp only [eval_middleCNF, eval_eq_true] theorem middleCNF_implies_output (C : Circuit3 V) {j : Fin C.middleCount} (hj : j ∈ C.top) {x : Cube V} (hx : (C.middleCNF j).eval x = true) : C.eval x = true := (eval_eq_true_iff_middleCNF C x).mpr ⟨j, hj, hx⟩ end Circuit3 end DepthThreeLowerBound end OAI