import Mathlib import OAI.Computability.DirectedFeedback.Games.KernelCardinality namespace OAI section open scoped BigOperators namespace DFVSGames.Soundness.ConditionalIncidences noncomputable section abbrev PositionInside {P : Type} (K : Finset P) := {j : P // j ∈ K} abbrev PositionOutside {P : Type} (K : Finset P) := {j : P // j ∉ K} abbrev Draw (P O : Type) := P → O × Fin 3 abbrev InsideDraw {P : Type} (K : Finset P) (O : Type) := PositionInside K → O × Fin 3 def incidence {O N : Type} (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (draw : O × Fin 3) : O × N := (draw.1, name draw.1 draw.2) def insideDraw {P O : Type} (K : Finset P) (sample : Draw P O) : InsideDraw K O := fun j => sample j.val def outsideRecord {P O N : Type} (K : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (sample : Draw P O) : PositionOutside K → O × N := fun j => incidence name (sample j.val) abbrev ObservationFibre {P O N : Type} (K : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (observed : PositionOutside K → O × N) := {sample : Draw P O // outsideRecord K name sample = observed} abbrev OutsideFibre {P O N : Type} (K : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (observed : PositionOutside K → O × N) := {sample : PositionOutside K → O × Fin 3 // (fun j => incidence name (sample j)) = observed} instance observationFibreFintype {P O N : Type} [Fintype P] [Fintype O] (K : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (observed : PositionOutside K → O × N) : Fintype (ObservationFibre K name observed) := Fintype.ofFinite _ instance outsideFibreFintype {P O N : Type} [Fintype P] [Fintype O] (K : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (observed : PositionOutside K → O × N) : Fintype (OutsideFibre K name observed) := Fintype.ofFinite _ def observationFibreEquiv {P O N : Type} [DecidableEq P] (K : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (observed : PositionOutside K → O × N) : ObservationFibre K name observed ≃ InsideDraw K O × OutsideFibre K name observed where toFun sample := (insideDraw K sample.val, ⟨fun j => sample.val j.val, sample.property⟩) invFun pieces := ⟨fun j => if hj : j ∈ K then pieces.1 ⟨j, hj⟩ else pieces.2.val ⟨j, hj⟩, by funext j simp only [outsideRecord, j.property, ↓reduceDIte] exact congrFun pieces.2.property j⟩ left_inv sample := by apply Subtype.ext funext j simp only [insideDraw] split <;> rfl right_inv pieces := by apply Prod.ext · funext j simp [insideDraw, j.property] · apply Subtype.ext funext j simp [j.property] def average {A : Type} [Fintype A] (f : A → ℚ) : ℚ := (∑ a, f a) / Fintype.card A theorem average_equiv {A B : Type} [Fintype A] [Fintype B] (e : A ≃ B) (f : B → ℚ) : average (fun a => f (e a)) = average f := by unfold average rw [e.sum_comp, Fintype.card_congr e] theorem average_product_left {A B : Type} [Fintype A] [Fintype B] (hB : Fintype.card B ≠ 0) (f : A → ℚ) : average (fun ab : A × B => f ab.1) = average f := by unfold average rw [Fintype.sum_prod_type] simp only [Finset.sum_const, Finset.card_univ, nsmul_eq_mul, Fintype.card_prod, Nat.cast_mul] rw [← Finset.mul_sum] have hBq : (Fintype.card B : ℚ) ≠ 0 := by exact_mod_cast hB rw [mul_comm (Fintype.card A : ℚ)] exact mul_div_mul_left _ _ hBq theorem average_product_mul {A B : Type} [Fintype A] [Fintype B] (f : A → ℚ) (g : B → ℚ) : average (fun ab : A × B => f ab.1 * g ab.2) = average f * average g := by unfold average rw [Fintype.sum_prod_type] simp_rw [← Finset.mul_sum] rw [← Finset.sum_mul] simp only [Fintype.card_prod, Nat.cast_mul] exact (div_mul_div_comm _ _ _ _).symm theorem average_coordinate_product {A X : Type} [Fintype A] [DecidableEq A] [Fintype X] (f : A → X → ℚ) : average (fun sample : A → X => ∏ a, f a (sample a)) = ∏ a, average (f a) := by unfold average rw [← Fintype.prod_sum] simp only [Fintype.card_pi, Nat.cast_prod] exact (Finset.prod_div_distrib _ _).symm theorem uniform_conditional_ratio {A : Type} [Fintype A] (p : A → Prop) [Fintype {a // p a}] (hpos : 0 < Fintype.card {a // p a}) (f : {a // p a} → ℚ) : ((∑ a, f a) / (Fintype.card A : ℚ)) / ((Fintype.card {a // p a} : ℚ) / Fintype.card A) = average f := by have hA : Fintype.card A ≠ 0 := Nat.ne_of_gt (Nat.lt_of_lt_of_le hpos (Fintype.card_subtype_le p)) have hAq : (Fintype.card A : ℚ) ≠ 0 := by exact_mod_cast hA exact div_div_div_cancel_right₀ hAq _ _ section ConditionalLaw variable {P O N : Type} [Fintype P] [DecidableEq P] [Fintype O] theorem conditional_inside_average (K : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (observed : PositionOutside K → O × N) (hpos : 0 < Fintype.card (ObservationFibre K name observed)) (f : InsideDraw K O → ℚ) : average (fun sample : ObservationFibre K name observed => f (insideDraw K sample.val)) = average f := by let e := observationFibreEquiv K name observed have hcard : Fintype.card (ObservationFibre K name observed) = Fintype.card (InsideDraw K O) * Fintype.card (OutsideFibre K name observed) := by rw [Fintype.card_congr e, Fintype.card_prod] have hout : Fintype.card (OutsideFibre K name observed) ≠ 0 := by intro hz rw [hcard, hz, Nat.mul_zero] at hpos exact (Nat.lt_irrefl 0) hpos calc average (fun sample : ObservationFibre K name observed => f (insideDraw K sample.val)) = average (fun pieces : InsideDraw K O × OutsideFibre K name observed => f pieces.1) := average_equiv e (fun pieces => f pieces.1) _ = average f := average_product_left hout f theorem conditional_incidence_average (K : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (observed : PositionOutside K → O × N) (hpos : 0 < Fintype.card (ObservationFibre K name observed)) (f : (PositionInside K → O × N) → ℚ) : average (fun sample : ObservationFibre K name observed => f (fun j => incidence name (sample.val j.val))) = average (fun fresh : InsideDraw K O => f (fun j => incidence name (fresh j))) := by exact conditional_inside_average K name observed hpos (fun fresh => f (fun j => incidence name (fresh j))) end ConditionalLaw abbrev RawSlot {P : Type} (J : Finset P) := Option ((PositionOutside J × Fin 2) ⊕ PositionInside J) abbrev RawCoefficients {P : Type} (J : Finset P) (D : Type) := RawSlot J → D def zeroSet {P D : Type} [DecidableEq P] [Zero D] [DecidableEq D] (J : Finset P) (gamma : RawCoefficients J D) : Finset P := J.attach.filter (fun j => gamma (some (.inr j)) = 0) |>.map ⟨Subtype.val, Subtype.val_injective⟩ theorem mem_zeroSet {P D : Type} [DecidableEq P] [Zero D] [DecidableEq D] (J : Finset P) (gamma : RawCoefficients J D) (j : P) : j ∈ zeroSet J gamma ↔ ∃ hj : j ∈ J, gamma (some (.inr ⟨j, hj⟩)) = 0 := by simp [zeroSet] abbrev RawSample {P : Type} (J : Finset P) (D O : Type) := RawCoefficients J D × Draw P O abbrev RawObservationFibre {P D O N : Type} [DecidableEq P] [Zero D] [DecidableEq D] (J : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (gamma : RawCoefficients J D) (observed : PositionOutside (zeroSet J gamma) → O × N) := {sample : RawSample J D O // sample.1 = gamma ∧ outsideRecord (zeroSet J gamma) name sample.2 = observed} instance rawObservationFibreFintype {P D O N : Type} [Fintype P] [DecidableEq P] [Fintype D] [Zero D] [DecidableEq D] [Fintype O] (J : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (gamma : RawCoefficients J D) (observed : PositionOutside (zeroSet J gamma) → O × N) : Fintype (RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed) := Fintype.ofFinite _ def rawObservationFibreEquiv {P D O N : Type} [DecidableEq P] [Zero D] [DecidableEq D] (J : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (gamma : RawCoefficients J D) (observed : PositionOutside (zeroSet J gamma) → O × N) : RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed ≃ ObservationFibre (zeroSet J gamma) name observed where toFun sample := ⟨sample.val.2, sample.property.2⟩ invFun sample := ⟨(gamma, sample.val), rfl, sample.property⟩ left_inv sample := by apply Subtype.ext exact Prod.ext sample.property.1.symm rfl right_inv sample := rfl theorem raw_conditional_inside_average {P D O N : Type} [Fintype P] [DecidableEq P] [Fintype D] [Zero D] [DecidableEq D] [Fintype O] [DecidableEq O] [DecidableEq N] (J : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (gamma : RawCoefficients J D) (observed : PositionOutside (zeroSet J gamma) → O × N) (hpos : 0 < Fintype.card (RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed)) (f : InsideDraw (zeroSet J gamma) O → ℚ) : average (fun sample : RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed => f (insideDraw (zeroSet J gamma) sample.val.2)) = average f := by let e := rawObservationFibreEquiv J name gamma observed have hpos' : 0 < Fintype.card (ObservationFibre (zeroSet J gamma) name observed) := by rwa [Fintype.card_congr e] at hpos calc average (fun sample : RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed => f (insideDraw (zeroSet J gamma) sample.val.2)) = average (fun sample : ObservationFibre (zeroSet J gamma) name observed => f (insideDraw (zeroSet J gamma) sample.val)) := by exact average_equiv e (fun sample : ObservationFibre (zeroSet J gamma) name observed => f (insideDraw (zeroSet J gamma) sample.val)) _ = average f := conditional_inside_average _ name observed hpos' f theorem raw_conditional_ratio {P D O N : Type} [Fintype P] [DecidableEq P] [Fintype D] [Zero D] [DecidableEq D] [Fintype O] [DecidableEq O] [DecidableEq N] (J : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (gamma : RawCoefficients J D) (observed : PositionOutside (zeroSet J gamma) → O × N) (hpos : 0 < Fintype.card (RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed)) (f : InsideDraw (zeroSet J gamma) O → ℚ) : ((∑ sample : RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed, f (insideDraw (zeroSet J gamma) sample.val.2)) / Fintype.card (RawSample J D O)) / ((Fintype.card (RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed) : ℚ) / Fintype.card (RawSample J D O)) = average f := by rw [uniform_conditional_ratio _ hpos] exact raw_conditional_inside_average J name gamma observed hpos f theorem raw_conditional_incidence_average {P D O N : Type} [Fintype P] [DecidableEq P] [Fintype D] [Zero D] [DecidableEq D] [Fintype O] [DecidableEq O] [DecidableEq N] (J : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (gamma : RawCoefficients J D) (observed : PositionOutside (zeroSet J gamma) → O × N) (hpos : 0 < Fintype.card (RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed)) (f : (PositionInside (zeroSet J gamma) → O × N) → ℚ) : average (fun sample : RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed => f (fun j => incidence name (sample.val.2 j.val))) = average (fun fresh : InsideDraw (zeroSet J gamma) O => f (fun j => incidence name (fresh j))) := by exact raw_conditional_inside_average J name gamma observed hpos (fun fresh => f (fun j => incidence name (fresh j))) theorem raw_conditional_product_incidence {P D O N : Type} [Fintype P] [DecidableEq P] [Fintype D] [Zero D] [DecidableEq D] [Fintype O] [DecidableEq O] [DecidableEq N] (J : Finset P) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (gamma : RawCoefficients J D) (observed : PositionOutside (zeroSet J gamma) → O × N) (hpos : 0 < Fintype.card (RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed)) (f : PositionInside (zeroSet J gamma) → O × N → ℚ) : average (fun sample : RawObservationFibre J name gamma observed => ∏ j, f j (incidence name (sample.val.2 j.val))) = ∏ j, average (fun fresh : O × Fin 3 => f j (incidence name fresh)) := by calc _ = average (fun fresh : InsideDraw (zeroSet J gamma) O => ∏ j, f j (incidence name (fresh j))) := raw_conditional_inside_average J name gamma observed hpos (fun fresh => ∏ j, f j (incidence name (fresh j))) _ = _ := average_coordinate_product (fun j fresh => f j (incidence name fresh)) end end DFVSGames.Soundness.ConditionalIncidences end section open scoped BigOperators namespace DFVSGames.Soundness.PartnerMapCoordinates open PartnerProjection open ConditionalIncidences (PositionInside PositionOutside RawSlot RawCoefficients average) open DFVSGames.Integration.BinaryLinear (F2 ofBit toBit) noncomputable section variable {P : Type} [DecidableEq P] (rhs : P → Bool) (J : Finset P) def activeOf (J : Finset P) (j : P) : Bool := decide (j ∈ J) def inactiveOfOutside (j : PositionOutside J) : PartnerLinear.Inactive (activeOf J) := ⟨j.val, by simp [activeOf, j.property]⟩ def activeOfInside (j : PositionInside J) : PartnerLinear.Active (activeOf J) := ⟨j.val, by simp [activeOf, j.property]⟩ def outsideOfInactive (j : PartnerLinear.Inactive (activeOf J)) : PositionOutside J := ⟨j.val, by simpa [activeOf] using j.property⟩ def insideOfActive (j : PartnerLinear.Active (activeOf J)) : PositionInside J := ⟨j.val, by simpa [activeOf] using j.property⟩ def tupleToRaw (v : PartnerLinear.PartnerCoordinates (activeOf J)) : RawSlot J → F2 | none => v.1 | some (.inl (j, i)) => if i = 0 then (v.2.1 (inactiveOfOutside J j)).1 else (v.2.1 (inactiveOfOutside J j)).2 | some (.inr j) => v.2.2 (activeOfInside J j) def tupleFromRaw (f : RawSlot J → F2) : PartnerLinear.PartnerCoordinates (activeOf J) := (f none, (fun j => (f (some (.inl (outsideOfInactive J j, 0))), f (some (.inl (outsideOfInactive J j, 1)))), fun j => f (some (.inr (insideOfActive J j))))) def tupleRawEquiv : PartnerLinear.PartnerCoordinates (activeOf J) ≃ₗ[F2] (RawSlot J → F2) where toFun := tupleToRaw J invFun := tupleFromRaw J left_inv v := by apply Prod.ext · rfl · apply Prod.ext · funext j apply Prod.ext <;> rfl · funext j rfl right_inv f := by funext s rcases s with _ | (⟨j, i⟩ | j) · rfl · fin_cases i <;> rfl · rfl map_add' x y := by funext s rcases s with _ | (⟨j, i⟩ | j) · rfl · fin_cases i <;> rfl · rfl map_smul' c x := by funext s rcases s with _ | (⟨j, i⟩ | j) · rfl · fin_cases i <;> rfl · rfl def pointEquiv : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J) ≃ₗ[F2] (RawSlot J → F2) := (PartnerLinear.partnerLinearEquiv rhs (activeOf J)).trans (tupleRawEquiv J) @[simp] theorem pointEquiv_none (y : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J)) : pointEquiv rhs J y none = ofBit y.homogeneous := rfl @[simp] theorem pointEquiv_full_first (y : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J)) (j : PositionOutside J) : pointEquiv rhs J y (some (.inl (j, 0))) = ofBit (y.full j.val).first := rfl @[simp] theorem pointEquiv_full_second (y : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J)) (j : PositionOutside J) : pointEquiv rhs J y (some (.inl (j, 1))) = ofBit (y.full j.val).second := rfl @[simp] theorem pointEquiv_single (y : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J)) (j : PositionInside J) : pointEquiv rhs J y (some (.inr j)) = ofBit (y.single j.val) := rfl variable [Fintype P] def partnerBasis : Module.Basis (RawSlot J) F2 (PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J)) := Module.Basis.ofEquivFun (pointEquiv rhs J) variable (R : Type) [AddCommGroup R] [Module F2 R] def mapEquiv : RawCoefficients J R ≃ₗ[F2] (PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J) →ₗ[F2] R) := (partnerBasis rhs J).constr F2 def coefficients (Y : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J) →ₗ[F2] R) : RawCoefficients J R := (mapEquiv rhs J R).symm Y theorem map_coefficients (Y : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J) →ₗ[F2] R) : mapEquiv rhs J R (coefficients rhs J R Y) = Y := (mapEquiv rhs J R).apply_symm_apply Y theorem coefficients_map (gamma : RawCoefficients J R) : coefficients rhs J R (mapEquiv rhs J R gamma) = gamma := (mapEquiv rhs J R).symm_apply_apply gamma theorem mapEquiv_apply (gamma : RawCoefficients J R) (y : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J)) : mapEquiv rhs J R gamma y = ∑ s, pointEquiv rhs J y s • gamma s := by rw [mapEquiv, Module.Basis.constr_apply_fintype] simp only [partnerBasis, Module.Basis.equivFun_ofEquivFun] theorem mapEquiv_expansion (gamma : RawCoefficients J R) (y : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J)) : mapEquiv rhs J R gamma y = ofBit y.homogeneous • gamma none + (∑ j : PositionOutside J, (ofBit (y.full j.val).first • gamma (some (.inl (j, 0))) + ofBit (y.full j.val).second • gamma (some (.inl (j, 1))))) + ∑ j : PositionInside J, ofBit (y.single j.val) • gamma (some (.inr j)) := by rw [mapEquiv_apply, Fintype.sum_option, Fintype.sum_sum_type, Fintype.sum_prod_type] simp only [Fin.sum_univ_two, pointEquiv_none, pointEquiv_full_first, pointEquiv_full_second, pointEquiv_single] simp only [add_assoc] theorem every_map_expansion (Y : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J) →ₗ[F2] R) (y : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J)) : Y y = ∑ s, pointEquiv rhs J y s • coefficients rhs J R Y s := by rw [← mapEquiv_apply, map_coefficients] theorem pullback_expansion (gamma : RawCoefficients J R) (slot : P → Slot) (x : SourcePoint rhs) : mapEquiv rhs J R gamma (PartnerLinear.projection rhs (activeOf J) slot x) = ofBit x.homogeneous • gamma none + (∑ j : PositionOutside J, (ofBit (x.coordinates j.val).first • gamma (some (.inl (j, 0))) + ofBit (x.coordinates j.val).second • gamma (some (.inl (j, 1))))) + ∑ j : PositionInside J, ofBit (retained (slot j.val) (x.coordinates j.val)) • gamma (some (.inr j)) := by rw [mapEquiv_expansion] congr 1 · congr 1 apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro j _ simp [PartnerLinear.projection_apply, project, activeOf, j.property] · apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro j _ simp [PartnerLinear.projection_apply, project, activeOf, j.property] instance partnerMapsFintype [Fintype R] : Fintype (PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J) →ₗ[F2] R) := by classical exact Fintype.ofEquiv (RawCoefficients J R) (mapEquiv rhs J R).toEquiv theorem uniform_coefficients_maps [Fintype R] (H : (PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J) →ₗ[F2] R) → ℚ) : average (fun gamma : RawCoefficients J R => H (mapEquiv rhs J R gamma)) = average H := ConditionalIncidences.average_equiv (mapEquiv rhs J R).toEquiv H theorem uniform_map_coefficients_product [Fintype R] (H : RawSlot J → R → ℚ) : average (fun Y : PartnerPoint rhs (activeOf J) →ₗ[F2] R => ∏ s, H s (coefficients rhs J R Y s)) = ∏ s, average (H s) := by calc _ = average (fun gamma : RawCoefficients J R => ∏ s, H s (gamma s)) := ConditionalIncidences.average_equiv (mapEquiv rhs J R).symm.toEquiv (fun gamma => ∏ s, H s (gamma s)) _ = _ := ConditionalIncidences.average_coordinate_product H end end DFVSGames.Soundness.PartnerMapCoordinates end namespace DFVSGames.Soundness.IncidenceExtraction abbrev Triple := Fin 3 → Bool def xorTriple (x : Triple) : Bool := (x 0 ^^ x 1) ^^ x 2 structure Incidence (Occurrence Name : Type) where name : Occurrence → Fin 3 → Name rhs : Occurrence → Bool def Incidence.accepts {Occurrence Name : Type} (g : Incidence Occurrence Name) (o : Occurrence) (i : Fin 3) (a : Triple) (b : Bool) : Prop := xorTriple a = g.rhs o ∧ a i = b def Incidence.namedAccepts {Occurrence Name : Type} (g : Incidence Occurrence Name) (o : Occurrence) (n : Name) (a : Triple) (b : Bool) : Prop := ∃ i, g.name o i = n ∧ g.accepts o i a b theorem Incidence.accepts_implies_namedAccepts {Occurrence Name : Type} (g : Incidence Occurrence Name) (o : Occurrence) (i : Fin 3) (a : Triple) (b : Bool) (h : g.accepts o i a b) : g.namedAccepts o (g.name o i) a b := ⟨i, rfl, h⟩ theorem Incidence.namedAccepts_iff_accepts {Occurrence Name : Type} (g : Incidence Occurrence Name) (distinct : ∀ o i j, g.name o i = g.name o j → i = j) (o : Occurrence) (i : Fin 3) (a : Triple) (b : Bool) : g.namedAccepts o (g.name o i) a b ↔ g.accepts o i a b := by constructor · rintro ⟨j, hname, h⟩ have hji := distinct o j i hname simpa [hji] using h · exact g.accepts_implies_namedAccepts o i a b structure FullPoint (Position : Type) where homogeneous : Bool coords : Position → Triple def FullPoint.valid {Position Occurrence Name : Type} (g : Incidence Occurrence Name) (u : Position → Occurrence) (e : FullPoint Position) : Prop := ∀ j, xorTriple (e.coords j) = (g.rhs (u j) && e.homogeneous) structure PartnerPoint (Position : Type) where homogeneous : Bool single : Position → Bool def AugmentedAccepts {Position Occurrence Name : Type} (g : Incidence Occurrence Name) (u : Position → Occurrence) (active : Position → Prop) (slot : Position → Fin 3) (eA : FullPoint Position) (eB : PartnerPoint Position) : Prop := eA.valid g u ∧ eA.homogeneous = true ∧ eB.homogeneous = true ∧ ∀ j, active j → eA.coords j (slot j) = eB.single j def RepeatedAccepts {Position Occurrence Name : Type} (g : Incidence Occurrence Name) (u : Position → Occurrence) (slot : Position → Fin 3) (inside : Position → Prop) (answerA : Position → Triple) (answerB : Position → Bool) : Prop := ∀ j, inside j → g.accepts (u j) (slot j) (answerA j) (answerB j) theorem augmented_accepts_implies_repeated_accepts {Position Occurrence Name : Type} (g : Incidence Occurrence Name) (u : Position → Occurrence) (active inside : Position → Prop) (slot : Position → Fin 3) (eA : FullPoint Position) (eB : PartnerPoint Position) (hinside : ∀ j, inside j → active j) (haccept : AugmentedAccepts g u active slot eA eB) : RepeatedAccepts g u slot inside eA.coords eB.single := by obtain ⟨hvalid, hone, _, hagree⟩ := haccept intro j hj constructor · have heq := hvalid j simpa [hone] using heq · exact hagree j (hinside j hj) theorem augmented_accepts_implies_named_repeated_accepts {Position RepeatPosition Occurrence Name : Type} (g : Incidence Occurrence Name) (u : Position → Occurrence) (active : Position → Prop) (slot : Position → Fin 3) (embed : RepeatPosition → Position) (eA : FullPoint Position) (eB : PartnerPoint Position) (hinside : ∀ r, active (embed r)) (haccept : AugmentedAccepts g u active slot eA eB) : ∀ r, g.namedAccepts (u (embed r)) (g.name (u (embed r)) (slot (embed r))) (eA.coords (embed r)) (eB.single (embed r)) := by intro r apply g.accepts_implies_namedAccepts obtain ⟨hvalid, hone, _, hagree⟩ := haccept constructor · have heq := hvalid (embed r) simpa [hone] using heq · exact hagree (embed r) (hinside r) structure Game (QA QB A B : Type) where accepts : QA → QB → A → B → Prop structure Strategies (QA QB A B : Type) where first : QA → A second : QB → B def Strategies.wins {QA QB A B : Type} (s : Strategies QA QB A B) (g : Game QA QB A B) (qa : QA) (qb : QB) : Prop := g.accepts qa qb (s.first qa) (s.second qb) structure LocalSimulation {InnerQA InnerQB InnerA InnerB OuterQA OuterQB OuterA OuterB : Type} (inner : Game InnerQA InnerQB InnerA InnerB) (outer : Game OuterQA OuterQB OuterA OuterB) where questionA : InnerQA → OuterQA questionB : InnerQB → OuterQB answerA : InnerQA → OuterA → InnerA answerB : InnerQB → OuterB → InnerB sound : ∀ qa qb a b, outer.accepts (questionA qa) (questionB qb) a b → inner.accepts qa qb (answerA qa a) (answerB qb b) def LocalSimulation.induced {InnerQA InnerQB InnerA InnerB OuterQA OuterQB OuterA OuterB : Type} {inner : Game InnerQA InnerQB InnerA InnerB} {outer : Game OuterQA OuterQB OuterA OuterB} (r : LocalSimulation inner outer) (s : Strategies OuterQA OuterQB OuterA OuterB) : Strategies InnerQA InnerQB InnerA InnerB where first qa := r.answerA qa (s.first (r.questionA qa)) second qb := r.answerB qb (s.second (r.questionB qb)) theorem LocalSimulation.induced_wins {InnerQA InnerQB InnerA InnerB OuterQA OuterQB OuterA OuterB : Type} {inner : Game InnerQA InnerQB InnerA InnerB} {outer : Game OuterQA OuterQB OuterA OuterB} (r : LocalSimulation inner outer) (s : Strategies OuterQA OuterQB OuterA OuterB) (qa : InnerQA) (qb : InnerQB) (hwins : s.wins outer (r.questionA qa) (r.questionB qb)) : (r.induced s).wins inner qa qb := r.sound qa qb (s.first (r.questionA qa)) (s.second (r.questionB qb)) hwins theorem LocalSimulation.seeded_induced_wins {InnerQA InnerQB InnerA InnerB OuterQA OuterQB OuterA OuterB Seed : Type} {inner : Game InnerQA InnerQB InnerA InnerB} {outer : Game OuterQA OuterQB OuterA OuterB} (r : LocalSimulation inner outer) (strategy : Seed → Strategies OuterQA OuterQB OuterA OuterB) (seed : Seed) (qa : InnerQA) (qb : InnerQB) (hwins : (strategy seed).wins outer (r.questionA qa) (r.questionB qb)) : (r.induced (strategy seed)).wins inner qa qb := r.induced_wins (strategy seed) qa qb hwins end DFVSGames.Soundness.IncidenceExtraction namespace DFVSGames.Soundness.ConcreteExtraction open PartnerProjection IncidenceExtraction def slotIndex : PartnerProjection.Slot → Fin 3 | .first => 0 | .second => 1 | .third => 2 def tripleCoordinates (x : PartnerProjection.Triple) : IncidenceExtraction.Triple := fun i => if i = 0 then x.first else if i = 1 then x.second else x.third theorem parity_coordinates (x : PartnerProjection.Triple) : IncidenceExtraction.xorTriple (tripleCoordinates x) = PartnerProjection.parity x := rfl theorem retained_coordinates (x : PartnerProjection.Triple) (i : PartnerProjection.Slot) : tripleCoordinates x (slotIndex i) = PartnerProjection.retained i x := by cases i <;> rfl def fullPoint {P : Type} {rhs : P → Bool} (x : PartnerProjection.SourcePoint rhs) : IncidenceExtraction.FullPoint P := ⟨x.homogeneous, fun j => tripleCoordinates (x.coordinates j)⟩ def partnerPoint {P : Type} {rhs active : P → Bool} (x : PartnerProjection.PartnerPoint rhs active) : IncidenceExtraction.PartnerPoint P := ⟨x.homogeneous, x.single⟩ theorem actual_projection_accepts {P O N : Type} (g : IncidenceExtraction.Incidence O N) (u : P → O) (active : P → Bool) (slot : P → PartnerProjection.Slot) (x : PartnerProjection.SourcePoint (fun j => g.rhs (u j))) (y : PartnerProjection.PartnerPoint (fun j => g.rhs (u j)) active) (hone : x.homogeneous = true) (hproject : PartnerProjection.project (fun j => g.rhs (u j)) active slot x = y) : IncidenceExtraction.AugmentedAccepts g u (fun j => active j = true) (fun j => slotIndex (slot j)) (fullPoint x) (partnerPoint y) := by subst y constructor · intro j exact x.valid j constructor · exact hone constructor · exact hone intro j hj change tripleCoordinates (x.coordinates j) (slotIndex (slot j)) = (if active j then PartnerProjection.retained (slot j) (x.coordinates j) else false) rw [hj] exact retained_coordinates _ _ theorem actual_projection_implies_named_repetition {P R O N : Type} (g : IncidenceExtraction.Incidence O N) (u : P → O) (active : P → Bool) (slot : P → PartnerProjection.Slot) (embed : R → P) (x : PartnerProjection.SourcePoint (fun j => g.rhs (u j))) (y : PartnerProjection.PartnerPoint (fun j => g.rhs (u j)) active) (hinside : ∀ r, active (embed r) = true) (hone : x.homogeneous = true) (hproject : PartnerProjection.project (fun j => g.rhs (u j)) active slot x = y) : ∀ r, g.namedAccepts (u (embed r)) (g.name (u (embed r)) (slotIndex (slot (embed r)))) (tripleCoordinates (x.coordinates (embed r))) (y.single (embed r)) := by exact IncidenceExtraction.augmented_accepts_implies_named_repeated_accepts g u (fun j => active j = true) (fun j => slotIndex (slot j)) embed (fullPoint x) (partnerPoint y) hinside (actual_projection_accepts g u active slot x y hone hproject) end DFVSGames.Soundness.ConcreteExtraction namespace DFVSGames.Reduction.ActualHomogeneous open Integration.BinaryLinear open scoped BigOperators abbrev E (k : Nat) := F2 × (Fin k → F2 × F2) abbrev Ambient (k : Nat) := F2 × (Fin k → Fin 3 → F2) variable {k : Nat} def tau : E k →ₗ[F2] F2 := LinearMap.fst F2 _ _ def hBasis (k : Nat) : E k := (1, 0) def firstBasis (j : Fin k) : E k := (0, Pi.single j (1, 0)) def secondBasis (j : Fin k) : E k := (0, Pi.single j (0, 1)) def coordinateBasis (j : Fin k) (i : Fin 2) : E k := if i = 0 then firstBasis j else secondBasis j @[simp] theorem tau_hBasis : tau (hBasis k) = 1 := rfl @[simp] theorem tau_firstBasis (j : Fin k) : tau (firstBasis j) = 0 := rfl @[simp] theorem tau_secondBasis (j : Fin k) : tau (secondBasis j) = 0 := rfl theorem pair_fst_ite (p : Prop) [Decidable p] (a b : F2 × F2) : (if p then a else b).1 = if p then a.1 else b.1 := by split_ifs <;> rfl theorem pair_snd_ite (p : Prop) [Decidable p] (a b : F2 × F2) : (if p then a else b).2 = if p then a.2 else b.2 := by split_ifs <;> rfl theorem coordinate_decomposition (x : E k) : x = x.1 • hBasis k + ∑ j : Fin k, ((x.2 j).1 • firstBasis j + (x.2 j).2 • secondBasis j) := by apply Prod.ext · simp [hBasis, firstBasis, secondBasis, Prod.fst_sum] · funext j apply Prod.ext <;> simp [hBasis, firstBasis, secondBasis, Pi.single_apply, Prod.snd_sum, Prod.fst_sum, Finset.sum_apply, pair_fst_ite, pair_snd_ite] theorem linearMap_expansion {R : Type*} [AddCommGroup R] [Module F2 R] (X : E k →ₗ[F2] R) (x : E k) : X x = x.1 • X (hBasis k) + ∑ j : Fin k, ((x.2 j).1 • X (firstBasis j) + (x.2 j).2 • X (secondBasis j)) := by conv_lhs => rw [coordinate_decomposition x] simp def homogeneous (b : Fin k → F2) : Submodule F2 (Ambient k) where carrier := {x | ∀ j, x.2 j 0 + x.2 j 1 + x.2 j 2 = b j * x.1} zero_mem' := by simp add_mem' := by intro x y hx hy j change (x.2 j 0 + y.2 j 0) + (x.2 j 1 + y.2 j 1) + (x.2 j 2 + y.2 j 2) = b j * (x.1 + y.1) calc _ = (x.2 j 0 + x.2 j 1 + x.2 j 2) + (y.2 j 0 + y.2 j 1 + y.2 j 2) := by ring _ = b j * x.1 + b j * y.1 := by rw [hx j, hy j] _ = _ := by ring smul_mem' := by intro c x hx j change c * x.2 j 0 + c * x.2 j 1 + c * x.2 j 2 = b j * (c * x.1) calc _ = c * (x.2 j 0 + x.2 j 1 + x.2 j 2) := by ring _ = c * (b j * x.1) := by rw [hx j] _ = _ := by ring def embed (b : Fin k → F2) : E k →ₗ[F2] Ambient k where toFun x := (x.1, fun j => ![(x.2 j).1, (x.2 j).2, b j * x.1 + (x.2 j).1 + (x.2 j).2]) map_add' x y := by apply Prod.ext · rfl · funext j i fin_cases i <;> simp ; ring map_smul' c x := by apply Prod.ext · rfl · funext j i fin_cases i <;> simp [smul_eq_mul] ; ring theorem embed_mem (b : Fin k → F2) (x : E k) : embed b x ∈ homogeneous b := by intro j change (x.2 j).1 + (x.2 j).2 + (b j * x.1 + (x.2 j).1 + (x.2 j).2) = b j * x.1 have h1 := CharTwo.add_self_eq_zero ((x.2 j).1) have h2 := CharTwo.add_self_eq_zero ((x.2 j).2) calc _ = b j * x.1 + (((x.2 j).1 + (x.2 j).1) + ((x.2 j).2 + (x.2 j).2)) := by ring _ = _ := by rw [h1, h2]; simp def equivalence (b : Fin k → F2) : E k ≃ₗ[F2] homogeneous b where toFun x := ⟨embed b x, embed_mem b x⟩ invFun x := (x.1.1, fun j => (x.1.2 j 0, x.1.2 j 1)) left_inv x := by rfl right_inv x := by apply Subtype.ext apply Prod.ext · rfl · funext j i fin_cases i · rfl · rfl · change b j * x.1.1 + x.1.2 j 0 + x.1.2 j 1 = x.1.2 j 2 rw [← x.property j] have h1 := CharTwo.add_self_eq_zero (x.1.2 j 0) have h2 := CharTwo.add_self_eq_zero (x.1.2 j 1) calc _ = x.1.2 j 2 + ((x.1.2 j 0 + x.1.2 j 0) + (x.1.2 j 1 + x.1.2 j 1)) := by ring _ = _ := by rw [h1, h2]; simp map_add' x y := Subtype.ext ((embed b).map_add x y) map_smul' c x := Subtype.ext ((embed b).map_smul c x) theorem finrank_E (k : Nat) : Module.finrank F2 (E k) = 1 + 2 * k := by simp [E, Module.finrank_prod, Module.finrank_pi_fintype, Nat.mul_comm] theorem finrank_homogeneous (b : Fin k → F2) : Module.finrank F2 (homogeneous b) = 1 + 2 * k := by rw [← (equivalence b).finrank_eq, finrank_E] end DFVSGames.Reduction.ActualHomogeneous end OAI