import Mathlib import OAI.Computability.DirectedFeedback.Games.FinishReduction namespace OAI namespace DFVSGames.Soundness.KernelCardinality open PartnerProjection variable {P : Type} (rhs active : P → Bool) (slot : P → Slot) abbrev Kernel := {x : SourcePoint rhs // InKernel rhs active slot x} def kernelEquiv : Kernel rhs active slot ≃ ({j : P // active j = true} → Bool) where toFun x j := freeBit (slot j.val) (x.val.coordinates j.val) invFun f := ⟨kernelPoint rhs active slot (extendActive active f), kernelPoint_mem rhs active slot _⟩ left_inv x := by apply Subtype.ext apply kernel_determined_by_active rhs active slot · exact kernelPoint_mem rhs active slot _ · exact x.property · intro j hj simp [kernelPoint, freeBit_complete, extendActive, hj] right_inv f := by funext j simp [kernelPoint, freeBit_complete, extendActive, j.property] noncomputable instance kernelFintype [Fintype P] : Fintype (Kernel rhs active slot) := by classical exact Fintype.ofEquiv ({j : P // active j = true} → Bool) (kernelEquiv rhs active slot).symm theorem kernel_card [Fintype P] : Fintype.card (Kernel rhs active slot) = 2 ^ Fintype.card {j : P // active j = true} := by classical calc Fintype.card (Kernel rhs active slot) = Fintype.card ({j : P // active j = true} → Bool) := Fintype.card_congr (kernelEquiv rhs active slot) _ = _ := by simp theorem kernel_card_of_active_card [Fintype P] (t : Nat) (h : Fintype.card {j : P // active j = true} = t) : Fintype.card (Kernel rhs active slot) = 2 ^ t := by rw [kernel_card, h] end DFVSGames.Soundness.KernelCardinality namespace DFVSGames.Gadget.LinearKernelCount universe u v variable {V : Type u} {P : Type v} variable [AddCommGroup V] [Module (ZMod 2) V] [FiniteDimensional (ZMod 2) V] variable [AddCommGroup P] [Module (ZMod 2) P] theorem card_binary_space : Nat.card V = 2 ^ Module.finrank (ZMod 2) V := by rw [Module.natCard_eq_pow_finrank (K := ZMod 2)] simp theorem kernel_card_mul_pow_rank (f : V →ₗ[ZMod 2] P) : Nat.card f.ker * 2 ^ Module.finrank (ZMod 2) f.range = Nat.card V := by rw [card_binary_space (V := f.ker), card_binary_space (V := V), ← pow_add] congr 1 rw [Nat.add_comm] exact f.finrank_range_add_finrank_ker theorem card_source_pos : 0 < Nat.card V := by rw [card_binary_space] exact Nat.pow_pos (by decide) theorem kernel_card_eq_pow_sub_rank (f : V →ₗ[ZMod 2] P) : Nat.card f.ker = 2 ^ (Module.finrank (ZMod 2) V - Module.finrank (ZMod 2) f.range) := by rw [card_binary_space (V := f.ker)] congr 1 have h := f.finrank_range_add_finrank_ker omega theorem zero_event_card_mul_pow_rank (f : V →ₗ[ZMod 2] P) : Nat.card {x : V // f x = 0} * 2 ^ Module.finrank (ZMod 2) f.range = Nat.card V := kernel_card_mul_pow_rank f theorem zero_event_card_mul_pow_le (f : V →ₗ[ZMod 2] P) (r : Nat) (hr : r ≤ Module.finrank (ZMod 2) f.range) : Nat.card {x : V // f x = 0} * 2 ^ r ≤ Nat.card V := by calc Nat.card {x : V // f x = 0} * 2 ^ r ≤ Nat.card {x : V // f x = 0} * 2 ^ Module.finrank (ZMod 2) f.range := Nat.mul_le_mul_left _ (Nat.pow_le_pow_right (by decide) hr) _ = Nat.card V := zero_event_card_mul_pow_rank f theorem zero_event_finset_count_mul_pow_rank [Fintype V] [DecidableEq P] (f : V →ₗ[ZMod 2] P) : (Finset.univ.filter (fun x : V => f x = 0)).card * 2 ^ Module.finrank (ZMod 2) f.range = Fintype.card V := by have h := zero_event_card_mul_pow_rank f simpa only [Nat.card_eq_fintype_card, Fintype.card_subtype] using h theorem zero_event_finset_count_mul_pow_le [Fintype V] [DecidableEq P] (f : V →ₗ[ZMod 2] P) (r : Nat) (hr : r ≤ Module.finrank (ZMod 2) f.range) : (Finset.univ.filter (fun x : V => f x = 0)).card * 2 ^ r ≤ Fintype.card V := by have h := zero_event_card_mul_pow_le f r hr simpa only [Nat.card_eq_fintype_card, Fintype.card_subtype] using h end DFVSGames.Gadget.LinearKernelCount namespace DFVSGames.Soundness.PartnerLinear open PartnerProjection open DFVSGames.Integration.BinaryLinear (F2 ofBit toBit scalar_cases ofBit_toBit toBit_ofBit ofBit_xor) variable {P : Type} (rhs active : P → Bool) (slot : P → Slot) abbrev SourceCoordinates (P : Type) := F2 × (P → F2 × F2) abbrev Active := {j : P // active j = true} abbrev Inactive := {j : P // active j = false} abbrev PartnerCoordinates := F2 × ((Inactive active → F2 × F2) × (Active active → F2)) def sourceCoordinates (x : SourcePoint rhs) : SourceCoordinates P := (ofBit x.homogeneous, fun j => (ofBit (x.coordinates j).first, ofBit (x.coordinates j).second)) def sourceFromCoordinates (v : SourceCoordinates P) : SourcePoint rhs where homogeneous := toBit v.1 coordinates := fun j => complete .first (rhs j && toBit v.1) (toBit (v.2 j).1) (toBit (v.2 j).2) valid := by intro j; exact parity_complete _ _ _ _ def sourceEquiv : SourcePoint rhs ≃ SourceCoordinates P where toFun := sourceCoordinates rhs invFun := sourceFromCoordinates rhs left_inv x := by apply source_ext rhs · exact toBit_ofBit _ · funext j change complete .first (rhs j && toBit (ofBit x.homogeneous)) (toBit (ofBit (x.coordinates j).first)) (toBit (ofBit (x.coordinates j).second)) = x.coordinates j simp only [toBit_ofBit, ← x.valid j] exact complete_coordinates .first (x.coordinates j) right_inv v := by apply Prod.ext · exact ofBit_toBit _ · funext j apply Prod.ext <;> exact ofBit_toBit _ def partnerCoordinates (y : PartnerPoint rhs active) : PartnerCoordinates active := (ofBit y.homogeneous, (fun j => (ofBit (y.full j.val).first, ofBit (y.full j.val).second), fun j => ofBit (y.single j.val))) def partnerFromCoordinates (v : PartnerCoordinates active) : PartnerPoint rhs active where homogeneous := toBit v.1 full := fun j => if hj : active j = false then complete .first (rhs j && toBit v.1) (toBit (v.2.1 ⟨j, hj⟩).1) (toBit (v.2.1 ⟨j, hj⟩).2) else zeroTriple single := fun j => if hj : active j = true then toBit (v.2.2 ⟨j, hj⟩) else false full_zero := by intro j hj; simp [hj] full_valid := by intro j hj; simp only [dite_eq_left hj]; exact parity_complete _ _ _ _ single_zero := by intro j hj; simp [hj] def partnerEquiv : PartnerPoint rhs active ≃ PartnerCoordinates active where toFun := partnerCoordinates rhs active invFun := partnerFromCoordinates rhs active left_inv y := by apply partner_ext rhs active · exact toBit_ofBit _ · funext j cases hj : active j with | false => change (if hj' : active j = false then complete .first (rhs j && toBit (ofBit y.homogeneous)) (toBit (ofBit (y.full j).first)) (toBit (ofBit (y.full j).second)) else zeroTriple) = y.full j simp only [dite_eq_left hj, toBit_ofBit, ← y.full_valid j hj] exact complete_coordinates .first (y.full j) | true => simpa [partnerFromCoordinates, hj] using (y.full_zero j hj).symm · funext j cases hj : active j with | false => simpa [partnerFromCoordinates, hj] using (y.single_zero j hj).symm | true => simp [partnerFromCoordinates, partnerCoordinates, hj, toBit_ofBit] right_inv v := by apply Prod.ext · exact ofBit_toBit _ · apply Prod.ext · funext j simp [partnerCoordinates, partnerFromCoordinates, j.property, complete, ofBit_toBit] · funext j simp [partnerCoordinates, partnerFromCoordinates, j.property, ofBit_toBit] noncomputable instance sourceAddCommGroup : AddCommGroup (SourcePoint rhs) := (sourceEquiv rhs).addCommGroup noncomputable instance sourceModule : Module F2 (SourcePoint rhs) := (sourceEquiv rhs).addEquiv.module F2 noncomputable instance partnerAddCommGroup : AddCommGroup (PartnerPoint rhs active) := (partnerEquiv rhs active).addCommGroup noncomputable instance partnerModule : Module F2 (PartnerPoint rhs active) := (partnerEquiv rhs active).addEquiv.module F2 noncomputable def sourceLinearEquiv : SourcePoint rhs ≃ₗ[F2] SourceCoordinates P := (sourceEquiv rhs).addEquiv.linearEquiv F2 noncomputable def partnerLinearEquiv : PartnerPoint rhs active ≃ₗ[F2] PartnerCoordinates active := (partnerEquiv rhs active).addEquiv.linearEquiv F2 noncomputable instance sourceFintype [Fintype P] : Fintype (SourcePoint rhs) := by classical exact Fintype.ofEquiv (SourceCoordinates P) (sourceEquiv rhs).symm noncomputable instance partnerFintype [Fintype P] : Fintype (PartnerPoint rhs active) := by classical exact Fintype.ofEquiv (PartnerCoordinates active) (partnerEquiv rhs active).symm theorem source_add (x y : SourcePoint rhs) : x + y = addSource rhs x y := by apply (sourceEquiv rhs).injective change sourceEquiv rhs ((sourceEquiv rhs).symm (sourceEquiv rhs x + sourceEquiv rhs y)) = _ rw [Equiv.apply_symm_apply] apply Prod.ext · exact (ofBit_xor _ _).symm · funext j apply Prod.ext <;> exact (ofBit_xor _ _).symm theorem source_zero : (0 : SourcePoint rhs) = zeroSource rhs := by apply (sourceEquiv rhs).injective change sourceEquiv rhs ((sourceEquiv rhs).symm 0) = _ rw [Equiv.apply_symm_apply] rfl theorem partner_add (x y : PartnerPoint rhs active) : x + y = addPartner rhs active x y := by apply (partnerEquiv rhs active).injective change partnerEquiv rhs active ((partnerEquiv rhs active).symm (partnerEquiv rhs active x + partnerEquiv rhs active y)) = _ rw [Equiv.apply_symm_apply] apply Prod.ext · exact (ofBit_xor _ _).symm · apply Prod.ext · funext j apply Prod.ext <;> exact (ofBit_xor _ _).symm · funext j exact (ofBit_xor _ _).symm theorem partner_zero : (0 : PartnerPoint rhs active) = zeroPartner rhs active := by apply (partnerEquiv rhs active).injective change partnerEquiv rhs active ((partnerEquiv rhs active).symm 0) = _ rw [Equiv.apply_symm_apply] rfl noncomputable def projection : SourcePoint rhs →ₗ[F2] PartnerPoint rhs active where toFun := project rhs active slot map_add' x y := by rw [source_add, partner_add]; exact project_add rhs active slot x y map_smul' c x := by rcases scalar_cases c with rfl | rfl · change project rhs active slot ((0 : F2) • x) = (0 : F2) • project rhs active slot x rw [zero_smul, zero_smul, source_zero, partner_zero, project_zero] · simp theorem projection_apply (x : SourcePoint rhs) : projection rhs active slot x = project rhs active slot x := rfl theorem projection_surjective : Function.Surjective (projection rhs active slot) := project_surjective rhs active slot theorem mem_projection_ker (x : SourcePoint rhs) : x ∈ (projection rhs active slot).ker ↔ InKernel rhs active slot x := by change project rhs active slot x = 0 ↔ _ rw [partner_zero] rfl noncomputable instance sourceFiniteDimensional [Fintype P] : FiniteDimensional F2 (SourcePoint rhs) := (sourceLinearEquiv rhs).symm.finiteDimensional noncomputable instance partnerFiniteDimensional [Fintype P] : FiniteDimensional F2 (PartnerPoint rhs active) := (partnerLinearEquiv rhs active).symm.finiteDimensional noncomputable def kernelEquiv : (projection rhs active slot).ker ≃ KernelCardinality.Kernel rhs active slot where toFun x := ⟨x.val, (mem_projection_ker rhs active slot x.val).1 x.property⟩ invFun x := ⟨x.val, (mem_projection_ker rhs active slot x.val).2 x.property⟩ left_inv _ := rfl right_inv _ := rfl theorem projection_ker_card [Fintype P] : Nat.card (projection rhs active slot).ker = 2 ^ Fintype.card (Active active) := by rw [Nat.card_congr (kernelEquiv rhs active slot), Nat.card_eq_fintype_card] exact KernelCardinality.kernel_card rhs active slot theorem projection_ker_finrank [Fintype P] : Module.finrank F2 (projection rhs active slot).ker = Fintype.card (Active active) := by have h := DFVSGames.Gadget.LinearKernelCount.card_binary_space (V := (projection rhs active slot).ker) rw [projection_ker_card] at h exact Nat.pow_right_injective (by decide : 2 ≤ (2 : Nat)) h.symm theorem projection_ker_finrank_of_card [Fintype P] (t : Nat) (ht : Fintype.card (Active active) = t) : Module.finrank F2 (projection rhs active slot).ker = t := by rw [projection_ker_finrank, ht] theorem source_finrank [Fintype P] : Module.finrank F2 (SourcePoint rhs) = 1 + 2 * Fintype.card P := by rw [(sourceLinearEquiv rhs).finrank_eq] simp [SourceCoordinates, Module.finrank_prod, Module.finrank_pi_fintype, Nat.mul_comm] theorem disjoint_projection_kernels (active' : P → Bool) (slot' : P → Slot) (hdisjoint : ∀ j, active j = true → active' j = false) : (projection rhs active slot).ker ⊓ (projection rhs active' slot').ker = ⊥ := by apply le_antisymm · intro x hx change x = 0 rw [source_zero] exact disjoint_kernels_intersection_zero rhs active slot active' slot' hdisjoint x ((mem_projection_ker rhs active slot x).1 hx.1) ((mem_projection_ker rhs active' slot' x).1 hx.2) · exact bot_le noncomputable def sourceTau : SourcePoint rhs →ₗ[F2] F2 := (LinearMap.fst F2 F2 (P → F2 × F2)).comp (sourceLinearEquiv rhs).toLinearMap noncomputable def partnerTau : PartnerPoint rhs active →ₗ[F2] F2 := (LinearMap.fst F2 F2 ((Inactive active → F2 × F2) × (Active active → F2))).comp (partnerLinearEquiv rhs active).toLinearMap theorem sourceTau_apply (x : SourcePoint rhs) : sourceTau rhs x = ofBit x.homogeneous := rfl theorem partnerTau_apply (x : PartnerPoint rhs active) : partnerTau rhs active x = ofBit x.homogeneous := rfl theorem tau_comp_projection : (partnerTau rhs active).comp (projection rhs active slot) = sourceTau rhs := by ext x rfl end DFVSGames.Soundness.PartnerLinear namespace DFVSGames.Soundness.ZeroInformation section Fibres variable {P X Y : Type} (hidden : P → Bool) (reveal : P → X → Y) (observed : P → Y) def Fibre := {sample : P → X // ∀ j, hidden j = false → reveal j (sample j) = observed j} def Inside := (j : P) → hidden j = true → X def Outside := {sample : (j : P) → hidden j = false → X // ∀ j hj, reveal j (sample j hj) = observed j} def fibreInside (sample : Fibre hidden reveal observed) : Inside (X := X) hidden := fun j _ => sample.val j def fibreOutside (sample : Fibre hidden reveal observed) : Outside hidden reveal observed := ⟨fun j _ => sample.val j, sample.property⟩ def assemble (inside : Inside (X := X) hidden) (outside : Outside hidden reveal observed) : Fibre hidden reveal observed := ⟨fun j => if hj : hidden j = true then inside j hj else outside.val j (by cases h : hidden j · rfl · exact False.elim (hj h)), by intro j hj simp only [hj, Bool.false_eq_true, ↓reduceDIte] exact outside.property j hj⟩ @[simp] theorem inside_assemble (inside : Inside (X := X) hidden) (outside : Outside hidden reveal observed) : fibreInside hidden reveal observed (assemble hidden reveal observed inside outside) = inside := by funext j hj simp [fibreInside, assemble, hj] @[simp] theorem outside_assemble (inside : Inside (X := X) hidden) (outside : Outside hidden reveal observed) : fibreOutside hidden reveal observed (assemble hidden reveal observed inside outside) = outside := by apply Subtype.ext funext j hj simp [fibreOutside, assemble, hj] @[simp] theorem assemble_split (sample : Fibre hidden reveal observed) : assemble hidden reveal observed (fibreInside hidden reveal observed sample) (fibreOutside hidden reveal observed sample) = sample := by apply Subtype.ext funext j simp only [assemble, fibreInside, fibreOutside] split <;> rfl theorem fibre_product (sample : Fibre hidden reveal observed) : ∃ inside : Inside (X := X) hidden, ∃ outside : Outside hidden reveal observed, assemble hidden reveal observed inside outside = sample := by exact ⟨fibreInside hidden reveal observed sample, fibreOutside hidden reveal observed sample, assemble_split hidden reveal observed sample⟩ end Fibres def mass {A : Type} : List A → (A → Nat) → Nat | [], _ => 0 | a :: rest, w => w a + mass rest w theorem mass_scale {A : Type} (xs : List A) (w : A → Nat) (c : Nat) : mass xs (fun x => c * w x) = c * mass xs w := by induction xs with | nil => simp [mass] | cons a xs ih => simp only [mass, ih, Nat.mul_add] theorem rectangular_mass {A B : Type} (outside : List A) (inside : List B) (outsideWeight : A → Nat) (insideWeight : B → Nat) : mass outside (fun a => mass inside (fun b => outsideWeight a * insideWeight b)) = mass outside outsideWeight * mass inside insideWeight := by induction outside with | nil => simp [mass] | cons a outside ih => change mass inside (fun b => outsideWeight a * insideWeight b) + mass outside (fun a => mass inside (fun b => outsideWeight a * insideWeight b)) = _ rw [ih, mass_scale] simp only [mass, Nat.add_mul] theorem conditional_inside_identity {A B : Type} (outside : List A) (inside : List B) (outsideWeight : A → Nat) (insideWeight : B → Nat) (event : B → Bool) : mass outside (fun a => mass inside (fun b => outsideWeight a * (if event b then insideWeight b else 0))) * mass inside insideWeight = mass outside (fun a => mass inside (fun b => outsideWeight a * insideWeight b)) * mass inside (fun b => if event b then insideWeight b else 0) := by rw [rectangular_mass, rectangular_mass] simp only [Nat.mul_assoc] rw [Nat.mul_comm (mass inside (fun b => if event b then insideWeight b else 0))] abbrev Bits (R : Type) := R → Bool def zero {R : Type} : Bits R := fun _ => false def add {R : Type} (a b : Bits R) : Bits R := fun r => a r ^^ b r def scale {R : Type} (coefficient : Bits R) (bit : Bool) : Bits R := fun r => coefficient r && bit @[simp] theorem scale_zero {R : Type} (bit : Bool) : scale (zero : Bits R) bit = zero := by funext r simp [scale, zero] def rowSum {P R : Type} (positions : List P) (term : P → Bits R) : Bits R := positions.foldr (fun j acc => add (term j) acc) zero theorem rowSum_congr {P R : Type} (positions : List P) (a b : P → Bits R) (h : ∀ j, a j = b j) : rowSum positions a = rowSum positions b := by have hab : a = b := funext h rw [hab] def pullbackRow {P R : Type} (positions : List P) (single : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (indices : P → Fin 3) (homogeneous : Bool) (x : P → Fin 3 → Bool) : Bits R := add (scale zeta0 homogeneous) (rowSum positions fun j => if single j then scale (omega j) (x j (indices j)) else add (scale (zeta1 j) (x j 0)) (scale (zeta2 j) (x j 1))) theorem pullbackRow_index_independent {P R : Type} (positions : List P) (single : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (i i' : P → Fin 3) (agrees : ∀ j, single j = true → omega j ≠ zero → i j = i' j) (homogeneous : Bool) (x : P → Fin 3 → Bool) : pullbackRow positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega i homogeneous x = pullbackRow positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega i' homogeneous x := by unfold pullbackRow congr 1 apply rowSum_congr intro j cases hs : single j · simp · simp only [↓reduceIte] by_cases hz : omega j = zero · simp [hz] · rw [agrees j hs hz] theorem pullbackRow_from_outside_names {P R O N : Type} (positions : List P) (single : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (occurrences : P → O) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (distinct : ∀ o i i', name o i = name o i' → i = i') (i i' : P → Fin 3) (sameNames : ∀ j, single j = true → omega j ≠ zero → name (occurrences j) (i j) = name (occurrences j) (i' j)) (homogeneous : Bool) (x : P → Fin 3 → Bool) : pullbackRow positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega i homogeneous x = pullbackRow positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega i' homogeneous x := by apply pullbackRow_index_independent intro j hj hz exact distinct (occurrences j) (i j) (i' j) (sameNames j hj hz) theorem zero_third_bit {R : Type} (rhs homogeneous x1 x2 : Bool) : scale (zero : Bits R) ((rhs && homogeneous) ^^ x1 ^^ x2) = zero := by exact scale_zero _ abbrev FirstRow (P R : Type) := Bool → (P → Fin 3 → Bool) → Bits R abbrev SecondRow (P R : Type) := Bool → (P → Fin 3 → Bool) → (P → Bool) → Bits R structure FirstInput (P R O : Type) where question : P → O row : FirstRow P R structure SecondInput (P R O N : Type) where question : P → Sum O N row : SecondRow P R def partnerQuestion {P O N : Type} (single : P → Bool) (occurrences : P → O) (names : P → N) : P → Sum O N := fun j => if single j then .inr (names j) else .inl (occurrences j) def partnerRow {P R : Type} (positions : List P) (single : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) : SecondRow P R := fun homogeneous x y => add (scale zeta0 homogeneous) (rowSum positions fun j => if single j then scale (omega j) (y j) else add (scale (zeta1 j) (x j 0)) (scale (zeta2 j) (x j 1))) theorem partnerRow_pullback {P R : Type} (positions : List P) (single : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (indices : P → Fin 3) (homogeneous : Bool) (x : P → Fin 3 → Bool) : partnerRow positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega homogeneous x (fun j => x j (indices j)) = pullbackRow positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega indices homogeneous x := rfl def firstInput {P R O : Type} (positions : List P) (single : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (occurrences : P → O) (indices : P → Fin 3) : FirstInput P R O := ⟨occurrences, pullbackRow positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega indices⟩ def secondInput {P R O N : Type} (positions : List P) (single : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (occurrences : P → O) (names : P → N) : SecondInput P R O N := ⟨partnerQuestion single occurrences names, partnerRow positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega⟩ noncomputable def decodeIndex {O N : Type} (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (occurrence : O) (n : N) : Fin 3 := by classical exact if h : ∃ i, name occurrence i = n then Classical.choose h else 0 theorem decodeIndex_name {O N : Type} (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (distinct : ∀ o i i', name o i = name o i' → i = i') (o : O) (i : Fin 3) : decodeIndex name o (name o i) = i := by classical unfold decodeIndex have he : ∃ i', name o i' = name o i := ⟨i, rfl⟩ simp only [he, ↓reduceDIte] exact distinct o _ i (Classical.choose_spec he) def reconstructQuestion {P X : Type} (hidden : P → Bool) (inside outside : P → X) : P → X := fun j => if hidden j then inside j else outside j theorem reconstructQuestion_actual {P X : Type} (hidden : P → Bool) (actual outside : P → X) (houtside : ∀ j, hidden j = false → outside j = actual j) : reconstructQuestion hidden actual outside = actual := by funext j cases hj : hidden j · simp [reconstructQuestion, hj, houtside j hj] · simp [reconstructQuestion, hj] noncomputable def reconstructFirst {P R O N : Type} (positions : List P) (single hidden : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (insideOccurrences outsideOccurrences : P → O) (outsideNames : P → N) : FirstInput P R O := firstInput positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega (reconstructQuestion hidden insideOccurrences outsideOccurrences) (fun j => decodeIndex name (outsideOccurrences j) (outsideNames j)) theorem first_input_reconstruction {P R O N : Type} (positions : List P) (single hidden : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (hidden_zero : ∀ j, hidden j = true → omega j = zero) (name : O → Fin 3 → N) (distinct : ∀ o i i', name o i = name o i' → i = i') (occurrences outsideOccurrences : P → O) (indices : P → Fin 3) (outsideNames : P → N) (houtsideO : ∀ j, hidden j = false → outsideOccurrences j = occurrences j) (houtsideN : ∀ j, hidden j = false → outsideNames j = name (occurrences j) (indices j)) : reconstructFirst positions single hidden zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega name occurrences outsideOccurrences outsideNames = firstInput positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega occurrences indices := by unfold reconstructFirst firstInput rw [reconstructQuestion_actual hidden occurrences outsideOccurrences houtsideO] congr 1 funext homogeneous x apply pullbackRow_index_independent intro j _ hz have hj : hidden j = false := by cases hh : hidden j · rfl · exact False.elim (hz (hidden_zero j hh)) rw [houtsideO j hj, houtsideN j hj] exact decodeIndex_name name distinct (occurrences j) (indices j) def reconstructSecond {P R O N : Type} (positions : List P) (single hidden : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (outsideOccurrences : P → O) (insideNames outsideNames : P → N) : SecondInput P R O N := secondInput positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega outsideOccurrences (reconstructQuestion hidden insideNames outsideNames) theorem second_input_reconstruction {P R O N : Type} (positions : List P) (single hidden : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (hidden_single : ∀ j, hidden j = true → single j = true) (occurrences outsideOccurrences : P → O) (names outsideNames : P → N) (houtsideO : ∀ j, hidden j = false → outsideOccurrences j = occurrences j) (houtsideN : ∀ j, hidden j = false → outsideNames j = names j) : reconstructSecond positions single hidden zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega outsideOccurrences names outsideNames = secondInput positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega occurrences names := by unfold reconstructSecond secondInput rw [reconstructQuestion_actual hidden names outsideNames houtsideN] congr 1 funext j unfold partnerQuestion cases hs : single j · have hj : hidden j = false := by cases hh : hidden j · rfl · have contradiction := hidden_single j hh rw [hs] at contradiction contradiction simp [houtsideO j hj] · simp def FirstPoint {P O : Type} (rhs : O → Bool) (question : P → O) := {point : Bool × (P → Fin 3 → Bool) // ∀ j, (point.2 j 0 ^^ point.2 j 1 ^^ point.2 j 2) = (rhs (question j) && point.1)} def SecondPoint {P O N : Type} (rhs : O → Bool) (question : P → Sum O N) := {point : Bool × (P → Fin 3 → Bool) × (P → Bool) // ∀ j, match question j with | .inl o => (point.2.1 j 0 ^^ point.2.1 j 1 ^^ point.2.1 j 2) = (rhs o && point.1) ∧ point.2.2 j = false | .inr _ => ∀ i, point.2.1 j i = false} def FirstInput.suppliedMap {P R O : Type} (input : FirstInput P R O) (rhs : O → Bool) : FirstPoint rhs input.question → Bits R := fun point => input.row point.val.1 point.val.2 def SecondInput.suppliedMap {P R O N : Type} (input : SecondInput P R O N) (rhs : O → Bool) : SecondPoint rhs input.question → Bits R := fun point => input.row point.val.1 point.val.2.1 point.val.2.2 def projectFull {P : Type} (single : P → Bool) (x : P → Fin 3 → Bool) : P → Fin 3 → Bool := fun j i => if single j then false else x j i def projectSingles {P : Type} (single : P → Bool) (indices : P → Fin 3) (x : P → Fin 3 → Bool) : P → Bool := fun j => if single j then x j (indices j) else false def partnerProjection {P O N : Type} (single : P → Bool) (rhs : O → Bool) (occurrences : P → O) (names : P → N) (indices : P → Fin 3) (point : FirstPoint rhs occurrences) : SecondPoint rhs (partnerQuestion single occurrences names) := ⟨(point.val.1, projectFull single point.val.2, projectSingles single indices point.val.2), by intro j cases hs : single j · simp only [partnerQuestion, hs, Bool.false_eq_true, ↓reduceIte, projectFull, projectSingles] exact ⟨point.property j, True.intro⟩ · simp [partnerQuestion, hs, projectFull]⟩ theorem partnerRow_project {P R : Type} (positions : List P) (single : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (indices : P → Fin 3) (homogeneous : Bool) (x : P → Fin 3 → Bool) : partnerRow positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega homogeneous (projectFull single x) (projectSingles single indices x) = pullbackRow positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega indices homogeneous x := by unfold partnerRow pullbackRow congr 1 apply rowSum_congr intro j cases hs : single j <;> simp [hs, projectFull, projectSingles] theorem supplied_map_pullback {P R O N : Type} (positions : List P) (single : P → Bool) (zeta0 : Bits R) (zeta1 zeta2 omega : P → Bits R) (rhs : O → Bool) (occurrences : P → O) (names : P → N) (indices : P → Fin 3) (point : FirstPoint rhs occurrences) : (secondInput positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega occurrences names).suppliedMap rhs (partnerProjection single rhs occurrences names indices point) = (firstInput positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega occurrences indices).suppliedMap rhs point := by exact partnerRow_project positions single zeta0 zeta1 zeta2 omega indices point.val.1 point.val.2 end DFVSGames.Soundness.ZeroInformation end OAI