import OAI.Computability.FiniteCompiler.Simulator namespace OAI /-! Finite control and bounded compiler orbit normalization. -/ namespace FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Cleanup open Relation variable {S Γ : Type*} inductive Head | cleanup | raw deriving DecidableEq instance : Fintype Head := ⟨{.cleanup,.raw}, by intro h; cases h <;> simp⟩ abbrev Sector (S Γ : Type*) := Scan.Sector Head (Base S) (Tag S Γ) /-- Exactly the cleanup letter prescribed in the finite compiler. Output marks on nonanchors are deliberately ignored even on dirty configurations. -/ def emit (c : Base S × Tag S Γ) : Option S := match c.1 with | .anchor _ => c.2.output | _ => none def letter (blank : Γ) (a : S) : Base S × Tag S Γ := (.anchor a,clean blank) def output (blank : Γ) (l : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)) : List (Base S × Tag S Γ) := (l.filterMap emit).map (letter blank) /-- The left sweep deletes every consumed tagged cell, and only marks on anchors produce a clean right-hand anchor. The boundary test is literal. -/ def step (blank : Γ) (v : Sector S Γ) : Option (Sector S Γ) := match v.head with | .raw => none | .cleanup => match v.left with | c::l => some { v with left := l, right := (emit c).toList.map (letter blank) ++ v.right } | [] => if v.leftBoundary then some {v with head := .raw} else none def Step (blank : Γ) (v w : Sector S Γ) : Prop := step blank v = some w theorem deterministic (blank : Γ) : Relator.RightUnique (Step (S := S) blank) := by intro a b c hab hac exact Option.some.inj (hab.symm.trans hac) @[simp] theorem output_nil (blank : Γ) : output (S := S) blank [] = [] := rfl @[simp] theorem output_append (blank : Γ) (l r : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)) : output blank (l++r) = output blank l ++ output blank r := by simp [output,List.filterMap_append] @[simp] theorem output_singleton (blank : Γ) (c : Base S × Tag S Γ) : output blank [c] = (emit c).toList.map (letter blank) := by cases h : emit c <;> simp [output,h] /-- Each consumed cell is emitted before all previously emitted cells. This proves the leftward cleanup's order on arbitrary—not only clean—data. -/ theorem sweep (blank : Γ) (l r : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)) (a b : Bool) : ReflTransGen (Step blank) ⟨l,.cleanup,r,a,b⟩ ⟨[],.cleanup,output blank l.reverse ++ r,a,b⟩ := by induction l generalizing r with | nil => exact .refl | cons c l ih => have h : Step blank ⟨c::l,.cleanup,r,a,b⟩ ⟨l,.cleanup,(emit c).toList.map (letter blank) ++ r,a,b⟩ := rfl simpa [List.reverse_cons,List.append_assoc] using (ReflTransGen.single h).trans (ih ((emit c).toList.map (letter blank) ++ r)) /-- Normalization of a cleanup head, with or without a left boundary. -/ def normal (blank : Γ) (v : Sector S Γ) : Sector S Γ := match v.head with | .raw => v | .cleanup => ⟨[],if v.leftBoundary then .raw else .cleanup, output blank v.left.reverse ++ v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ theorem normal_reached (blank : Γ) (v : Sector S Γ) : ReflTransGen (Step blank) v (normal blank v) := by rcases v with ⟨l,h,r,a,b⟩ cases h with | raw => exact .refl | cleanup => have hr := sweep blank l r a b cases a with | false => exact hr | true => exact hr.tail rfl theorem normal_terminal (blank : Γ) (v : Sector S Γ) : step blank (normal blank v) = none := by rcases v with ⟨l,h,r,a,b⟩ cases h <;> cases a <;> rfl /-- Cleanup normal forms are invariant under either direction of any local cleanup equation, including in dirty sectors with missing boundaries. -/ theorem normal_invariant (blank : Γ) {v w : Sector S Γ} (h : EqvGen (Step blank) v w) : normal blank v = normal blank w := by have tv : ∀ z, ¬Step blank (normal blank v) z := by intro z hz change step blank (normal blank v) = some z at hz rw [normal_terminal] at hz cases hz have tw : ∀ z, ¬Step blank (normal blank w) z := by intro z hz change step blank (normal blank w) = some z at hz rw [normal_terminal] at hz cases hz apply terminal_unique (deterministic blank) tv tw exact EqvGen.trans _ _ _ (EqvGen.symm _ _ (EqvGen.reflTransGen_le_eqvGen _ _ _ (normal_reached blank v))) (EqvGen.trans _ _ _ h (EqvGen.reflTransGen_le_eqvGen _ _ _ (normal_reached blank w))) /-- Cleanup forgets empty marks, not anchor order. -/ theorem emit_anchorView (l : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)) : l.filterMap emit = (Simulator.anchorView l).filterMap id := by rw [Simulator.anchorView,List.filterMap_filterMap] congr 1 funext c rcases c with ⟨b,t⟩ cases b <;> rfl theorem emit_returned (l : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)) (out : List S) (n : ℕ) (h : Simulator.anchorView l = out.map some ++ List.replicate n none) : l.filterMap emit = out := by rw [emit_anchorView,h,List.filterMap_append] simp /-- Exact successful cleanup, including empty returned strings. -/ theorem success (blank : Γ) (l : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)) (out : List S) (n : ℕ) (h : Simulator.anchorView l = out.map some ++ List.replicate n none) : ReflTransGen (Step blank) ⟨l.reverse,.cleanup,[],true,true⟩ ⟨[],.raw,out.map (letter blank),true,true⟩ := by have hr := normal_reached blank (⟨l.reverse,.cleanup,[],true,true⟩ : Sector S Γ) simpa [normal,output,emit_returned l out n h] using hr def grade : Base S → ℕ | .cutC => 2 | .workspace => 0 | _ => 1 def cellsGrade (l : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)) : ℕ := (l.map (grade ∘ Prod.fst)).sum @[simp] theorem cellsGrade_append (l r : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)) : cellsGrade (l++r) = cellsGrade l + cellsGrade r := by simp [cellsGrade] @[simp] theorem cellsGrade_reverse (l : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)) : cellsGrade l.reverse = cellsGrade l := by simp [cellsGrade,List.map_reverse] /-- Grade is nonincreasing for EVERY tagged cleanup cell. Workspace marks do not emit letters, so grade-zero workspace can never create positive grade. -/ theorem output_grade_le (blank : Γ) (l : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)) : cellsGrade (output blank l) ≤ cellsGrade l := by induction l with | nil => simp [cellsGrade] | cons c l ih => rcases c with ⟨b,t⟩ cases b <;> simp only [output,List.filterMap_cons,emit] · cases t.output <;> simp_all [output,cellsGrade,letter,grade] omega all_goals simp_all [output,cellsGrade,grade] all_goals omega end FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Cleanup namespace FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Scan open Relation variable {H B T : Type*} /-- An explicit bounded list enumeration, used only for finite internal search. This bound counts cells, not grade, and thus never admits quota insertion. -/ def boundedLists (α : Type*) [Fintype α] [DecidableEq α] : ℕ → Finset (List α) | 0 => {[]} | n+1 => {[]} ∪ ((Finset.univ : Finset α) ×ˢ boundedLists α n).image (fun p => p.1::p.2) @[simp] theorem mem_boundedLists (α : Type*) [Fintype α] [DecidableEq α] (n : ℕ) (l : List α) : l ∈ boundedLists α n ↔ l.length ≤ n := by induction n generalizing l with | zero => simp [boundedLists] | succ n ih => cases l with | nil => simp [boundedLists] | cons a l => simp [boundedLists,ih] variable [Fintype H] [Fintype B] [Fintype T] variable [DecidableEq H] [DecidableEq B] [DecidableEq T] /-- The finite search universe consists of actual list-zipper sectors. -/ def boundedSectors (k : ℕ) : Finset (Sector H B T) := (((((Finset.univ : Finset H) ×ˢ boundedLists (B×T) k) ×ˢ boundedLists (B×T) k) ×ˢ (Finset.univ : Finset Bool)) ×ˢ (Finset.univ : Finset Bool)).image (fun p => ⟨p.1.1.1.2,p.1.1.1.1,p.1.1.2,p.1.2,p.2⟩) @[simp] theorem mem_boundedSectors (k : ℕ) (v : Sector H B T) : v ∈ boundedSectors k ↔ v.left.length ≤ k ∧ v.right.length ≤ k := by rcases v with ⟨l,q,r,a,b⟩ simp [boundedSectors,Sector.mk.injEq] /-- Filtering by bases and boundary flags gives exactly the source's fixed internal-search state space. This is computable from the literal sector. -/ def searchUniverse (v : Sector H B T) : Finset (Sector H B T) := (boundedSectors (v.left.length+v.right.length)).filter (fun w => baseSkeleton w = baseSkeleton v) omit [Fintype H] [Fintype B] [Fintype T] [DecidableEq H] [DecidableEq B] [DecidableEq T] in theorem skeleton_length {v w : Sector H B T} (h : baseSkeleton v = baseSkeleton w) : v.left.length+v.right.length = w.left.length+w.right.length := by have hl := congrArg (fun p : List B × Bool × Bool => p.1.length) h simpa [baseSkeleton] using hl @[simp] theorem mem_universe (v w : Sector H B T) : w ∈ searchUniverse v ↔ baseSkeleton w = baseSkeleton v := by simp only [searchUniverse,Finset.mem_filter,mem_boundedSectors,and_iff_right_iff_imp] intro h have hl := skeleton_length h constructor <;> omega abbrev Fixed (v : Sector H B T) := {w : Sector H B T // baseSkeleton w = baseSkeleton v} instance fixedFintype (v : Sector H B T) : Fintype (Fixed v) := Fintype.subtype (searchUniverse v) (mem_universe v) def fixedSelf (v : Sector H B T) : Fixed v := ⟨v,rfl⟩ def fixedStep (table : Table H B T) (v : Sector H B T) (a b : Fixed v) : Prop := Step table a.val b.val instance fixedStepDecidable (table : Table H B T) (v : Sector H B T) : DecidableRel (fixedStep table v) := fun _ _ => inferInstanceAs (Decidable (_ = _)) omit [Fintype H] [Fintype B] [Fintype T] [DecidableEq H] [DecidableEq B] [DecidableEq T] in theorem connected_skeleton (table : Table H B T) {x y : Sector H B T} (h : EqvGen (Step table) x y) : baseSkeleton x = baseSkeleton y := by induction h with | rel _ _ h => exact step_skeleton table h | refl => rfl | symm _ _ _ ih => exact ih.symm | trans _ _ _ _ _ ih₁ ih₂ => exact ih₁.trans ih₂ omit [Fintype H] [Fintype B] [Fintype T] [DecidableEq H] [DecidableEq B] [DecidableEq T] in /-- A weak path with fixed baselines lifts to the finite search universe. -/ theorem fixedConnected_iff (table : Table H B T) (v : Sector H B T) (a b : Fixed v) : EqvGen (fixedStep table v) a b ↔ EqvGen (Step table) a.val b.val := by constructor · intro h induction h with | rel _ _ h => exact .rel _ _ h | refl => exact .refl _ | symm _ _ _ ih => exact .symm _ _ ih | trans _ _ _ _ _ ih₁ ih₂ => exact .trans _ _ _ ih₁ ih₂ · intro h have lift : ∀ x y, EqvGen (Step table) x y → ∀ (hx : baseSkeleton x = baseSkeleton v), ∃ (hy : baseSkeleton y = baseSkeleton v), EqvGen (fixedStep table v) ⟨x,hx⟩ ⟨y,hy⟩ := by intro x y h induction h with | rel x y h => intro hx exact ⟨(step_skeleton table h).symm.trans hx,.rel _ _ h⟩ | refl x => intro hx; exact ⟨hx,.refl _⟩ | symm x y h ih => intro hy have hbase := connected_skeleton table h obtain ⟨_,hr⟩ := ih (hbase.trans hy) exact ⟨hbase.trans hy,.symm _ _ hr⟩ | trans x y z _ _ ih₁ ih₂ => intro hx obtain ⟨hy,hxy⟩ := ih₁ hx obtain ⟨hz,hyz⟩ := ih₂ hy exact ⟨hz,.trans _ _ _ hxy hyz⟩ obtain ⟨_,h'⟩ := lift a.val b.val h a.property exact h' /-- Operational component equality has a finite decision procedure. Its only primitives are the finite table, tagged cells, and bounded finite search. -/ def connectedDecision (table : Table H B T) (v : Sector H B T) (w : Fixed v) : Bool := decideConnected (fixedStep table v) (fixedSelf v) w @[simp] theorem connectedDecision_eq_true (table : Table H B T) (v : Sector H B T) (w : Fixed v) : connectedDecision table v w = true ↔ EqvGen (Step table) v w.val := by rw [connectedDecision,decideConnected_eq_true,fixedConnected_iff] rfl end FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Scan namespace FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Compiled section open Relation variable {S Γ Q : Type*} abbrev MachineSector (S Γ Q : Type*) := Scan.Sector (Simulator.Head S Q) (Base S) (Tag S Γ) abbrev Cfg (S Γ Q : Type*) := Validator.Extended.Cfg S Γ (MachineSector S Γ Q) /-- The fresh handoff is one state, not two copies joined by an artificial edge. -/ def embed (v : MachineSector S Γ Q) : Cfg S Γ Q := match v.head with | .start => .inl ⟨.start,v.left,v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ | _ => .inr v def project : Cfg S Γ Q → MachineSector S Γ Q | .inl v => ⟨v.left,.start,v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ | .inr v => v @[simp] theorem project_embed (v : MachineSector S Γ Q) : project (embed v) = v := by rcases v with ⟨l,q,r,a,b⟩ cases q <;> rfl theorem embed_injective : Function.Injective (@embed S Γ Q) := by intro a b h simpa only [project_embed] using congrArg project h @[simp] theorem embed_active (v : MachineSector S Γ Q) : Validator.Extended.Active (embed v) := by unfold embed split <;> trivial @[simp] theorem embed_project {v : Cfg S Γ Q} (hv : Validator.Extended.Active v) (hc : ∀ u, v = .inr u → u.head ≠ .start) : embed (project v) = v := by cases v with | inl v => simp only [Validator.Extended.Active] at hv; cases v; cases hv; rfl | inr v => have h := hc v rfl simp only [project,embed] variable (A : Simulator.Alphabet S Γ) (M : Simulator.Machine Q Γ) [DecidableEq Γ] def MachineRel (a b : Cfg S Γ Q) : Prop := ∃ u v, a = embed u ∧ b = embed v ∧ Scan.Step (Simulator.table A M) u v def Step : Cfg S Γ Q → Cfg S Γ Q → Prop := Validator.Extended.Step A.blank (MachineRel A M) theorem machine_deterministic : Relator.RightUnique (MachineRel A M) := by rintro a b c ⟨u,v,rfl,rfl,h⟩ ⟨u',v',he,rfl,h'⟩ cases embed_injective he exact congrArg embed (Scan.deterministic _ h h') theorem deterministic : Relator.RightUnique (Step A M) := Validator.Extended.deterministic A.blank (machine_deterministic A M) abbrev bases : Cfg S Γ Q → List (Base S) × Bool × Bool := Validator.Extended.baseSkeleton Scan.baseSkeleton omit [DecidableEq Γ] in @[simp] theorem embed_bases (v : MachineSector S Γ Q) : bases (embed v) = Scan.baseSkeleton v := by unfold embed split <;> rfl theorem machine_bases (a b : Cfg S Γ Q) (h : MachineRel A M a b) : bases a = bases b := by obtain ⟨u,v,rfl,rfl,h⟩ := h simpa only [embed_bases] using Scan.step_skeleton _ h /-- The manuscript's uniqueness of entries, now for the concrete copy/run/read table, not for an unspecified simulated relation. -/ theorem entries_unique {a b : Validator.Sector S Γ} (ha : Validator.Entry A.blank a) (hb : Validator.Entry A.blank b) (h : EqvGen (Step A M) (.inl a) (.inl b)) : a = b := Validator.Extended.entries_unique A.blank Scan.baseSkeleton (machine_deterministic A M) (machine_bases A M) ha hb h theorem embed_step {u v : MachineSector S Γ Q} (h : Scan.Step (Simulator.table A M) u v) : Step A M (embed u) (embed v) := .machine (embed_active u) (embed_active v) ⟨u,v,rfl,rfl,h⟩ theorem embed_run {u v : MachineSector S Γ Q} (h : ReflTransGen (Scan.Step (Simulator.table A M)) u v) : ReflTransGen (Step A M) (embed u) (embed v) := by induction h with | refl => exact .refl | tail _ hs ih => exact ih.tail (embed_step A M hs) theorem validator_run {u v : Validator.Sector S Γ} (h : ReflTransGen (Validator.Step A.blank) u v) : ReflTransGen (Step A M) (.inl u) (.inl v) := by induction h with | refl => exact .refl | tail _ hs ih => exact ih.tail (.validator hs) theorem active_step {a b : Cfg S Γ Q} (ha : Validator.Extended.Active a) (h : Step A M a b) : MachineRel A M a b := by cases h with | validator h => exact False.elim (Validator.Extended.validator_not_start A.blank h ha) | machine _ _ h => exact h /-- A path retains its actual simulator suffix after the unique validation handoff. This rules out a dirty intermediate state being treated as input. -/ theorem path_decomposition {a : Validator.Sector S Γ} {b : Cfg S Γ Q} (h : ReflTransGen (Step A M) (.inl a) b) : (∃ v, b = .inl v ∧ ReflTransGen (Validator.Step A.blank) a v) ∨ ∃ v u, ReflTransGen (Validator.Step A.blank) a v ∧ v.head = .start ∧ b = embed u ∧ ReflTransGen (Scan.Step (Simulator.table A M)) (project (.inl v)) u := by induction h with | refl => exact Or.inl ⟨a,rfl,.refl⟩ | @tail b c _ hs ih => rcases ih with ⟨v,rfl,hv⟩ | ⟨v,u,hv,hq,rfl,hr⟩ · cases hs with | validator hs => exact Or.inl ⟨_,rfl,hv.tail hs⟩ | machine ha _ hs => obtain ⟨u,w,hu,rfl,hw⟩ := hs have he : project (.inl v) = u := by rw [hu,project_embed] exact Or.inr ⟨v,w,hv,ha,rfl,by rw [he]; exact .single hw⟩ · obtain ⟨u',w,he,rfl,hw⟩ := active_step A M (embed_active u) hs cases embed_injective he exact Or.inr ⟨v,w,hv,hq,rfl,hr.tail hw⟩ theorem ok_terminal {v : MachineSector S Γ Q} (hv : v.head = .ok) : Terminal (Step A M) (embed v) := by intro u h have he : embed v = .inr v := by simp [embed,hv] rw [he] at h cases h with | machine _ _ h => obtain ⟨v',w,hv',_,h⟩ := h have hsame : v = v' := embed_injective (he.trans hv') subst v' rw [Scan.Step,Simulator.ok_terminal A M v hv] at h contradiction /-- Arbitrary dirty accepting sectors are unique within a weak component. -/ theorem ok_unique {u v : MachineSector S Γ Q} (hu : u.head = .ok) (hv : v.head = .ok) (h : EqvGen (Step A M) (embed u) (embed v)) : u = v := embed_injective (terminal_unique (deterministic A M) (ok_terminal A M hu) (ok_terminal A M hv) h) end open Relation variable {S Γ Q : Type*} /-- The literal entry and handoff of compiler-clean-entry. -/ def cleanEntry (blank : Γ) (x y : List S) (s : ℕ) : Validator.Sector S Γ := ⟨.initial,List.replicate s (Validator.cell blank .workspace) ++ Validator.cell blank .cutC :: (x.map (fun a => Validator.cell blank (.anchor a))).reverse, Validator.cell blank .cutD :: y.map (fun a => Validator.cell blank (.anchor a)),true,true⟩ def handoff (blank : Γ) (x y : List S) (s : ℕ) : Validator.Sector S Γ := ⟨.start,(y.map (fun a => Validator.cell blank (.anchor a))).reverse ++ Validator.cell blank .cutD :: (List.replicate s (Validator.cell blank .workspace) ++ Validator.cell blank .cutC :: (x.map (fun a => Validator.cell blank (.anchor a))).reverse), [],true,true⟩ @[simp] theorem cleanEntry_entry (blank : Γ) (x y : List S) (s : ℕ) : Validator.Entry blank (cleanEntry blank x y s) := ⟨rfl,_,rfl⟩ theorem cleanEntry_reaches (blank : Γ) (x y : List S) (s : ℕ) : ReflTransGen (Validator.Step blank) (cleanEntry blank x y s) (handoff blank x y s) := Validator.clean_entry_reaches blank x y s theorem validator_start_terminal (blank : Γ) {v : Validator.Sector S Γ} (hv : v.head = .start) : Terminal (Validator.Step blank) v := by intro w h exact Validator.Extended.validator_not_start blank h hv theorem handoff_unique (blank : Γ) (x y : List S) (s : ℕ) {v : Validator.Sector S Γ} (h : ReflTransGen (Validator.Step blank) (cleanEntry blank x y s) v) (hv : v.head = .start) : v = handoff blank x y s := by apply terminal_unique (Validator.step_deterministic blank) (validator_start_terminal blank hv) (validator_start_terminal blank rfl) exact EqvGen.trans _ _ _ (EqvGen.symm _ _ (EqvGen.reflTransGen_le_eqvGen _ _ _ h)) (EqvGen.reflTransGen_le_eqvGen _ _ _ (cleanEntry_reaches blank x y s)) variable (A : Simulator.Alphabet S Γ) (M : Simulator.Machine Q Γ) [DecidableEq Γ] omit [DecidableEq Γ] in @[simp] theorem project_handoff (x y : List S) (s : ℕ) : (project (.inl (handoff A.blank x y s)) : MachineSector S Γ Q) = ⟨(Simulator.body A [] x [] y [] s).reverse,.start,[],true,true⟩ := by simp [project,handoff,Simulator.body,Simulator.readAnchor,Simulator.bare,Validator.cell, clean,List.append_assoc] /-- Clean entries that meet an accepting internal sector really passed the validator and then ran this very machine. No cleanliness is assumed of the sector used for finding its weak component. -/ theorem accepting_entry_runs {a : Validator.Sector S Γ} {b : MachineSector S Γ Q} (ha : Validator.Entry A.blank a) (hb : b.head = .ok) (h : EqvGen (Step A M) (.inl a) (embed b)) : ∃ x y s, a = cleanEntry A.blank x y s ∧ ReflTransGen (Scan.Step (Simulator.table A M)) ⟨(Simulator.body A [] x [] y [] s).reverse,.start,[],true,true⟩ b := by have hr := reaches_terminal (deterministic A M) (ok_terminal A M hb) h rcases path_decomposition A M hr with ⟨v,hv,_⟩ | ⟨v,u,hv,hq,hu,hr⟩ · simp [embed,hb] at hv · have hub : b = u := embed_injective hu subst u obtain ⟨x,y,s,he⟩ := Validator.passing_entry A.blank ha hv hq change a = cleanEntry A.blank x y s at he subst a have he := handoff_unique A.blank x y s hv hq subst v exact ⟨x,y,s,rfl,by simpa only [project_handoff] using hr⟩ /-- Concrete soundness part of Lemma compiler-components: true halted output, the exact length bound, AND the mandated literal cleanup word. Quota insufficiency is ruled out by the previously proved rejection theorem. -/ theorem accepting_entry_sound (hdecode : ∀ g a, A.output g = some a → g = A.input a) {a : Validator.Sector S Γ} {b : MachineSector S Γ Q} (ha : Validator.Entry A.blank a) (hb : b.head = .ok) (h : EqvGen (Step A M) (.inl a) (embed b)) : ∃ x y s n c out, ∃ (result : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)), a = cleanEntry A.blank x y s ∧ s = x.length+y.length+n+1 ∧ ReflTransGen (Simulator.TapeStep M) (Simulator.pad A (Simulator.initialTape A M (x++y)) (n+1)) c ∧ Simulator.Halted A M c ∧ Simulator.Returns A c out ∧ out.length ≤ x.length+y.length ∧ b = ⟨result.reverse,.ok,[],true,true⟩ ∧ ReflTransGen (Cleanup.Step A.blank) ⟨result.reverse,.cleanup,[],true,true⟩ ⟨[],.raw,out.map (Cleanup.letter A.blank),true,true⟩ := by obtain ⟨x,y,s,he,hr⟩ := accepting_entry_runs A M ha hb h obtain ⟨n,c,out,result,hs,hc,hhalt,hout,hlen,hb,hres⟩ := Simulator.simulation_sound A M hdecode x y s hr hb exact ⟨x,y,s,n,c,out,result,he,hs,hc,hhalt,hout,hlen,hb, Cleanup.success A.blank result out _ hres⟩ /-- Conversely an actual finite halted computation with the required output bound has some quota and gives entry-to-ok reachability and exact cleanup. -/ theorem clean_success (x y out : List S) (c : Simulator.Tape (S := S) (Γ := Γ) (Q := Q)) (hrun : ReflTransGen (Simulator.UnboundedStep A M) (Simulator.initialTape A M (x++y)) c) (hhalt : Simulator.Halted A M c) (hout : Simulator.Returns A c out) (hlen : out.length ≤ x.length+y.length) : ∃ s, ∃ (result : List (Base S × Tag S Γ)), ReflTransGen (Step A M) (.inl (cleanEntry A.blank x y s)) (embed ⟨result.reverse,.ok,[],true,true⟩) ∧ ReflTransGen (Cleanup.Step A.blank) ⟨result.reverse,.cleanup,[],true,true⟩ ⟨[],.raw,out.map (Cleanup.letter A.blank),true,true⟩ := by obtain ⟨s,result,hr,hres⟩ := Simulator.simulation_complete A M x y out c hrun hhalt hout hlen refine ⟨s,result,?_,Cleanup.success A.blank result out _ hres⟩ have hv := validator_run A M (cleanEntry_reaches A.blank x y s) have he : (.inl (handoff A.blank x y s) : Cfg S Γ Q) = embed ⟨(Simulator.body A [] x [] y [] s).reverse,.start,[],true,true⟩ := by rw [← project_handoff] rfl rw [he] at hv exact hv.trans (embed_run A M hr) end FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Compiled namespace FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Validator variable {S Γ : Type*} instance : Fintype Head := ⟨{.initial,.left,.right,.workspace,.suffix,.start},by intro h; cases h <;> simp⟩ def toScan (v : Sector S Γ) : Scan.Sector Head (Base S) (Tag S Γ) := ⟨v.left,v.head,v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ def ofScan (v : Scan.Sector Head (Base S) (Tag S Γ)) : Sector S Γ := ⟨v.head,v.left,v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ @[simp] theorem toScan_ofScan (v : Scan.Sector Head (Base S) (Tag S Γ)) : toScan (ofScan v) = v := rfl @[simp] theorem ofScan_toScan (v : Sector S Γ) : ofScan (toScan v) = v := rfl variable (blank : Γ) [DecidableEq S] [DecidableEq Γ] /-- The displayed validator equations as an executable finite scan table. -/ def table : Table Head (Base S) (Tag S Γ) where direction | .initial | .left => .left | _ => .right cell q b t := if t = clean blank then match q,b with | .initial,.workspace => some ⟨.initial,t,true⟩ | .initial,.cutC => some ⟨.left,t,true⟩ | .left,.anchor _ => some ⟨.left,t,true⟩ | .right,.anchor _ => some ⟨.right,t,true⟩ | .right,.cutC => some ⟨.workspace,t,true⟩ | .workspace,.workspace => some ⟨.workspace,t,true⟩ | .workspace,.cutD => some ⟨.suffix,t,true⟩ | .suffix,.anchor _ => some ⟨.suffix,t,true⟩ | _,_ => none else none boundary | .left => some .right | .suffix => some .start | _ => none theorem step_toScan {v w : Sector S Γ} (h : Step blank v w) : Scan.Step (table blank) (toScan v) (toScan w) := by cases h <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,toScan,table,cell] theorem step_ofScan {v w : Scan.Sector Head (Base S) (Tag S Γ)} (h : Scan.Step (table blank) v w) : Step blank (ofScan v) (ofScan w) := by rcases v with ⟨l,q,r,a,b⟩ cases q with | initial => cases l with | nil => cases a <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table] at h | cons c l => rcases c with ⟨base,t⟩ by_cases ht : t = clean blank · subst t cases base <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table] at h all_goals subst w; first | exact .initial_cut _ _ _ _ | exact .initial_workspace _ _ _ _ · simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table,ht] at h | left => cases l with | nil => cases a <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table] at h subst w; exact .left_boundary _ _ | cons c l => rcases c with ⟨base,t⟩ by_cases ht : t = clean blank · subst t cases base <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table] at h subst w; exact .left_anchor _ _ _ _ _ · simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table,ht] at h | right => cases r with | nil => cases b <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table] at h | cons c r => rcases c with ⟨base,t⟩ by_cases ht : t = clean blank · subst t cases base <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table] at h all_goals subst w; first | exact .right_anchor _ _ _ _ _ | exact .right_cut _ _ _ _ · simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table,ht] at h | workspace => cases r with | nil => cases b <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table] at h | cons c r => rcases c with ⟨base,t⟩ by_cases ht : t = clean blank · subst t cases base <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table] at h all_goals subst w; first | exact .workspace _ _ _ _ | exact .workspace_cut _ _ _ _ · simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table,ht] at h | suffix => cases r with | nil => cases b <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table] at h subst w; exact .suffix_boundary _ _ | cons c r => rcases c with ⟨base,t⟩ by_cases ht : t = clean blank · subst t cases base <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table] at h subst w; exact .suffix_anchor _ _ _ _ _ · simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table,ht] at h | start => cases r with | nil => cases b <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table] at h | cons c r => rcases c with ⟨base,t⟩ by_cases ht : t = clean blank <;> simp [Scan.Step,Scan.step,table,ht] at h @[simp] theorem step_iff_scan (v w : Sector S Γ) : Step blank v w ↔ Scan.Step (table blank) (toScan v) (toScan w) := ⟨step_toScan blank,step_ofScan blank⟩ instance stepDecidable : DecidableRel (Step (S := S) blank) := fun v w => by letI : Decidable (Scan.Step (table blank) (toScan v) (toScan w)) := inferInstanceAs (Decidable (_ = _)) exact decidable_of_iff _ (step_iff_scan blank v w).symm end FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Validator namespace FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Scan variable {H H' B T : Type*} def mapHead (f : H → H') (v : Sector H B T) : Sector H' B T := ⟨v.left,f v.head,v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ def mapInstruction (f : H → H') (v : Instruction H T) : Instruction H' T := ⟨f v.head,v.tag,v.cross⟩ @[simp] theorem skeleton_mapHead (f : H → H') (v : Sector H B T) : baseSkeleton (mapHead f v) = baseSkeleton v := rfl theorem mapHead_injective {f : H → H'} (hf : Function.Injective f) : Function.Injective (@mapHead H H' B T f) := by intro v w h cases v; cases w simp only [mapHead,Sector.mk.injEq] at h rcases h with ⟨rfl,hq,rfl,rfl,rfl⟩ cases hf hq rfl /-- A literal relabeling of finite control commutes with one scan step. Only agreement at the current head is needed, permitting fused control tables. -/ theorem step_mapHead (f : H → H') (t : Table H B T) (t' : Table H' B T) (v : Sector H B T) (hd : t'.direction (f v.head) = t.direction v.head) (hc : ∀ b a, t'.cell (f v.head) b a = (t.cell v.head b a).map (mapInstruction f)) (hb : t'.boundary (f v.head) = (t.boundary v.head).map f) : step t' (mapHead f v) = (step t v).map (mapHead f) := by rcases v with ⟨l,q,r,a,b⟩ simp only [mapHead] at hd hc hb ⊢ unfold step simp only [hd] cases hdir : t.direction q <;> dsimp only · cases l with | nil => cases a <;> simp [hb,mapHead,Option.map_map,Function.comp_def] | cons c l => rcases c with ⟨base,tag⟩ dsimp only rw [hc] cases hcell : t.cell q base tag with | none => rfl | some ins => rcases ins with ⟨iq,it,ic⟩; cases ic <;> rfl · cases r with | nil => cases b <;> simp [hb,mapHead,Option.map_map,Function.comp_def] | cons c r => rcases c with ⟨base,tag⟩ dsimp only rw [hc] cases hcell : t.cell q base tag with | none => rfl | some ins => rcases ins with ⟨iq,it,ic⟩; cases ic <;> rfl end FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Scan namespace FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Control section open Relation variable {S Γ Q : Type*} /-- Finite internal-head alphabet, with a single fresh handoff/start state. -/ inductive Head (S Q : Type*) | initial | left | right | workspace | suffix | machine : Simulator.Head S Q → Head S Q deriving DecidableEq, Fintype def validatorHead : Validator.Head → Head S Q | .initial => .initial | .left => .left | .right => .right | .workspace => .workspace | .suffix => .suffix | .start => .machine .start def toValidator : Head S Q → Option Validator.Head | .initial => some .initial | .left => some .left | .right => some .right | .workspace => some .workspace | .suffix => some .suffix | .machine _ => none abbrev Sector (S Γ Q : Type*) := Scan.Sector (Head S Q) (Base S) (Tag S Γ) def validator (v : Validator.Sector S Γ) : Sector S Γ Q := Scan.mapHead validatorHead (Validator.toScan v) def machine (v : Compiled.MachineSector S Γ Q) : Sector S Γ Q := Scan.mapHead Head.machine v def toCfg (v : Sector S Γ Q) : Compiled.Cfg S Γ Q := match v.head with | .initial => .inl ⟨.initial,v.left,v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ | .left => .inl ⟨.left,v.left,v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ | .right => .inl ⟨.right,v.left,v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ | .workspace => .inl ⟨.workspace,v.left,v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ | .suffix => .inl ⟨.suffix,v.left,v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ | .machine q => Compiled.embed ⟨v.left,q,v.right,v.leftBoundary,v.rightBoundary⟩ @[simp] theorem cfg_validator (v : Validator.Sector S Γ) : toCfg (validator (Q := Q) v) = .inl v := by cases v with | mk q l r a b => cases q <;> rfl @[simp] theorem cfg_machine (v : Compiled.MachineSector S Γ Q) : toCfg (machine v) = Compiled.embed v := rfl variable (A : Simulator.Alphabet S Γ) (M : Simulator.Machine Q Γ) [DecidableEq S] [DecidableEq Γ] /-- The literal finite union of validation and simulation equations. -/ def table : Table (Head S Q) (Base S) (Tag S Γ) where direction q := match toValidator q with | some v => (Validator.table (S := S) A.blank).direction v | none => match q with | .machine v => (Simulator.table A M).direction v | _ => .right cell q b t := match toValidator q with | some v => ((Validator.table (S := S) A.blank).cell v b t).map (Scan.mapInstruction validatorHead) | none => match q with | .machine v => ((Simulator.table A M).cell v b t).map (Scan.mapInstruction Head.machine) | _ => none boundary q := match toValidator q with | some v => ((Validator.table (S := S) A.blank).boundary v).map validatorHead | none => match q with | .machine v => ((Simulator.table A M).boundary v).map Head.machine | _ => none theorem step_machine (v : Compiled.MachineSector S Γ Q) : Scan.step (table A M) (machine v) = (Scan.step (Simulator.table A M) v).map machine := by apply Scan.step_mapHead · rfl · intro b a; rfl · rfl theorem step_validator (v : Validator.Sector S Γ) (hv : v.head ≠ .start) : Scan.step (table A M) (validator v) = (Scan.step (Validator.table (S := S) A.blank) (Validator.toScan v)).map (Scan.mapHead validatorHead) := by apply Scan.step_mapHead · cases v with | mk q l r a b => cases q <;> rfl · intro b a cases v with | mk q l r ls rs => cases q <;> first | rfl | exact False.elim (hv rfl) · cases v with | mk q l r a b => cases q <;> first | rfl | exact False.elim (hv rfl) end open Relation variable {S Γ Q : Type*} def ofCfg : Compiled.Cfg S Γ Q → Sector S Γ Q | .inl v => validator v | .inr v => machine v @[simp] theorem ofCfg_embed (v : Compiled.MachineSector S Γ Q) : ofCfg (Compiled.embed v) = machine v := by rcases v with ⟨l,q,r,a,b⟩ cases q <;> rfl @[simp] theorem ofCfg_toCfg (v : Sector S Γ Q) : ofCfg (toCfg v) = v := by rcases v with ⟨l,q,r,a,b⟩ cases q <;> first | rfl | exact ofCfg_embed _ theorem cfg_injective : Function.Injective (@toCfg S Γ Q) := Function.LeftInverse.injective ofCfg_toCfg theorem sector_cases (v : Sector S Γ Q) : (∃ w : Validator.Sector S Γ, w.head ≠ .start ∧ v = validator w) ∨ ∃ w : Compiled.MachineSector S Γ Q, v = machine w := by rcases v with ⟨l,q,r,a,b⟩ cases q with | machine q => exact Or.inr ⟨⟨l,q,r,a,b⟩,rfl⟩ | initial => exact Or.inl ⟨⟨.initial,l,r,a,b⟩,by simp,rfl⟩ | left => exact Or.inl ⟨⟨.left,l,r,a,b⟩,by simp,rfl⟩ | right => exact Or.inl ⟨⟨.right,l,r,a,b⟩,by simp,rfl⟩ | workspace => exact Or.inl ⟨⟨.workspace,l,r,a,b⟩,by simp,rfl⟩ | suffix => exact Or.inl ⟨⟨.suffix,l,r,a,b⟩,by simp,rfl⟩ variable (A : Simulator.Alphabet S Γ) (M : Simulator.Machine Q Γ) [DecidableEq S] [DecidableEq Γ] theorem validator_step {v w : Validator.Sector S Γ} (h : Validator.Step A.blank v w) : Scan.Step (table A M) (validator v) (validator w) := by rw [Scan.Step,step_validator A M v (Validator.Extended.validator_not_start A.blank h), Validator.step_toScan A.blank h] rfl theorem machine_step {v w : Compiled.MachineSector S Γ Q} (h : Scan.Step (Simulator.table A M) v w) : Scan.Step (table A M) (machine v) (machine w) := by rw [Scan.Step,step_machine A M,h] rfl theorem cfg_step {v w : Sector S Γ Q} (h : Scan.Step (table A M) v w) : Compiled.Step A M (toCfg v) (toCfg w) := by rcases sector_cases v with ⟨v,hv,rfl⟩ | ⟨v,rfl⟩ · rw [Scan.Step,step_validator A M v hv] at h obtain ⟨u,hu,rfl⟩ := Option.map_eq_some_iff.mp h have he : Scan.mapHead (validatorHead (S := S) (Q := Q)) u = validator (Validator.ofScan u) := rfl rw [he,cfg_validator,cfg_validator] exact .validator (Validator.step_ofScan A.blank hu) · rw [Scan.Step,step_machine A M] at h obtain ⟨u,hu,rfl⟩ := Option.map_eq_some_iff.mp h rw [cfg_machine,cfg_machine] exact Compiled.embed_step A M hu theorem ofCfg_step {v w : Compiled.Cfg S Γ Q} (h : Compiled.Step A M v w) : Scan.Step (table A M) (ofCfg v) (ofCfg w) := by cases h with | validator h => exact validator_step A M h | machine _ _ h => obtain ⟨u,v,rfl,rfl,h⟩ := h rw [ofCfg_embed,ofCfg_embed] exact machine_step A M h theorem cfg_connected {v w : Sector S Γ Q} (h : EqvGen (Scan.Step (table A M)) v w) : EqvGen (Compiled.Step A M) (toCfg v) (toCfg w) := by induction h with | rel _ _ h => exact .rel _ _ (cfg_step A M h) | refl _ => exact .refl _ | symm _ _ _ ih => exact .symm _ _ ih | trans _ _ _ _ _ ih₁ ih₂ => exact .trans _ _ _ ih₁ ih₂ theorem ofCfg_runs {v w : Compiled.Cfg S Γ Q} (h : ReflTransGen (Compiled.Step A M) v w) : ReflTransGen (Scan.Step (table A M)) (ofCfg v) (ofCfg w) := by induction h with | refl => exact .refl | tail _ h ih => exact ih.tail (ofCfg_step A M h) end FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Control namespace FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Scan open Relation variable {H B T : Type*} [Fintype H] [Fintype B] [Fintype T] [DecidableEq H] [DecidableEq B] [DecidableEq T] /-- Literal configurations, rather than an oracle for connectivity, returned by exhaustive search on the fixed finite base skeleton. -/ def literalComponent (table : Table H B T) (v : Sector H B T) : Finset (Sector H B T) := (component (fixedStep table v) (fixedSelf v)).image Subtype.val @[simp] theorem mem_literalComponent (table : Table H B T) (v w : Sector H B T) : w ∈ literalComponent table v ↔ EqvGen (Step table) v w := by constructor · intro h obtain ⟨u,hu,rfl⟩ := Finset.mem_image.mp h exact (fixedConnected_iff table v _ _).mp ((mem_component_iff _ _ _).mp hu) · intro h let u : Fixed v := ⟨w,(connected_skeleton table h).symm⟩ apply Finset.mem_image.mpr refine ⟨u,?_,rfl⟩ exact (mem_component_iff _ _ _).mpr ((fixedConnected_iff table v _ _).mpr h) theorem literalComponent_nonempty (table : Table H B T) (v : Sector H B T) : (literalComponent table v).Nonempty := ⟨v,(mem_literalComponent table v v).mpr (.refl v)⟩ theorem literalComponent_eq (table : Table H B T) {v w : Sector H B T} (h : EqvGen (Step table) v w) : literalComponent table v = literalComponent table w := by ext u simp only [mem_literalComponent] exact ⟨fun hv => .trans _ _ _ (.symm _ _ h) hv,fun hw => .trans _ _ _ h hw⟩ end FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Scan namespace FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler variable {α : Type*} /-- The priority order in source compiler-normalization: entry first, success second, and arbitrary component member only when neither is present. -/ def prioritySet (P Q : α → Prop) [DecidablePred P] [DecidablePred Q] (s : Finset α) : Finset α := if (s.filter P).Nonempty then s.filter P else if (s.filter Q).Nonempty then s.filter Q else s theorem prioritySet_subset (P Q : α → Prop) [DecidablePred P] [DecidablePred Q] (s : Finset α) : prioritySet P Q s ⊆ s := by unfold prioritySet split <;> first | exact Finset.filter_subset _ _ | skip split · exact Finset.filter_subset _ _ · exact Finset.Subset.refl _ theorem prioritySet_nonempty (P Q : α → Prop) [DecidablePred P] [DecidablePred Q] (s : Finset α) (hs : s.Nonempty) : (prioritySet P Q s).Nonempty := by unfold prioritySet split · assumption · split <;> assumption theorem prioritySet_first (P Q : α → Prop) [DecidablePred P] [DecidablePred Q] {s : Finset α} (hs : ∃ a ∈ s, P a) {b : α} (hb : b ∈ prioritySet P Q s) : P b := by have hn : (s.filter P).Nonempty := by obtain ⟨a,ha,hp⟩ := hs exact ⟨a,Finset.mem_filter.mpr ⟨ha,hp⟩⟩ rw [prioritySet,ite_eq_left hn] at hb exact (Finset.mem_filter.mp hb).2 theorem prioritySet_second (P Q : α → Prop) [DecidablePred P] [DecidablePred Q] {s : Finset α} (hp : ¬ ∃ a ∈ s, P a) (hq : ∃ a ∈ s, Q a) {b : α} (hb : b ∈ prioritySet P Q s) : Q b := by have hn : ¬ (s.filter P).Nonempty := by rintro ⟨a,ha⟩ exact hp ⟨a,(Finset.mem_filter.mp ha).1,(Finset.mem_filter.mp ha).2⟩ have hm : (s.filter Q).Nonempty := by obtain ⟨a,ha,hq⟩ := hq exact ⟨a,Finset.mem_filter.mpr ⟨ha,hq⟩⟩ rw [prioritySet,ite_eq_right hn,ite_eq_left hm] at hb exact (Finset.mem_filter.mp hb).2 end FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler namespace FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Scan open Relation variable {H B T : Type*} [Fintype H] [Fintype B] [Fintype T] [DecidableEq H] [DecidableEq B] [DecidableEq T] [LinearOrder (Sector H B T)] variable (table : Table H B T) (P Q : Sector H B T → Prop) [DecidablePred P] [DecidablePred Q] def representative (v : Sector H B T) : Sector H B T := (prioritySet P Q (literalComponent table v)).min' (prioritySet_nonempty P Q _ (literalComponent_nonempty table v)) theorem representative_mem (v : Sector H B T) : representative table P Q v ∈ prioritySet P Q (literalComponent table v) := Finset.min'_mem _ _ theorem representative_connected (v : Sector H B T) : EqvGen (Step table) v (representative table P Q v) := (mem_literalComponent table _ _).mp (prioritySet_subset _ _ _ (representative_mem table P Q v)) theorem representative_eq {v w : Sector H B T} (h : EqvGen (Step table) v w) : representative table P Q v = representative table P Q w := by unfold representative simp only [literalComponent_eq table h] theorem representative_first (v : Sector H B T) (h : ∃ w, EqvGen (Step table) v w ∧ P w) : P (representative table P Q v) := by apply prioritySet_first P Q _ (representative_mem table P Q v) simpa only [mem_literalComponent] using h theorem representative_second (v : Sector H B T) (hp : ¬ ∃ w, EqvGen (Step table) v w ∧ P w) (hq : ∃ w, EqvGen (Step table) v w ∧ Q w) : Q (representative table P Q v) := by apply prioritySet_second P Q _ _ (representative_mem table P Q v) · simpa only [mem_literalComponent] using hp · simpa only [mem_literalComponent] using hq end FiniteAlgebraicEnvelopes.Compiler.Scan end OAI