import Mathlib import OAI.Computability.MaxCut.Encoding.PrivateFourier import OAI.Computability.MaxCut.Encoding.TableKeysGame import OAI.Computability.MaxCut.Games.RowErasureSliceQuotient namespace OAI /-! # Decoding an actual transferred column slice The point `Mstar` used to parametrize a transferred slice is distinct from the canonical visible row base `observedBase A rows`. The right strategy uses only the latter. Their kernel-valued difference appears solely in the analysis. The exact quotient equivalence transports uniform slice agreement, including the affine offset, to the conditional private-decoder theorem. -/ noncomputable section namespace MaxCutGames.Decoder.TransferredDecoding open MaxCutGames.Integration.BinaryLinear open MaxCutGames.Reduction open MaxCutGames.Soundness open ActualSource open PrivateFourier PrivateStrategy open scoped BigOperators Classical open MaxCutGames.Inverse attribute [local instance] Fintype.ofFinite local instance homFintype {D F : Type*} [AddCommGroup D] [Module F2 D] [AddCommGroup F] [Module F2 F] [Fintype D] [Fintype F] : Fintype (D →ₗ[F2] F) := Fintype.ofInjective (fun M : D →ₗ[F2] F => (M : D → F)) DFunLike.coe_injective /-- Equality indicators depend on their propositions, not on the chosen computable or classical decision procedures. Both deciders are explicit. -/ theorem indicator_congr (P Q : Prop) (dP : Decidable P) (dQ : Decidable Q) (h : P ↔ Q) : @ite ℝ P dP 1 0 = @ite ℝ Q dQ 1 0 := by cases propext h cases Subsingleton.elim dP dQ rfl section Rebase variable {E K R : Type*} [AddCommGroup E] [Module F2 E] [AddCommGroup K] [Module F2 K] [AddCommGroup R] [Module F2 R] /-- The slice origin, expressed relative to the fixed visible row base. -/ def privateOrigin (A : K →ₗ[F2] R) (rows : AdviceFibers.ObservedRow (E := E) A) (Mstar : E →ₗ[F2] K) (hstar : A.comp Mstar = rows.val) : E →ₗ[F2] A.ker := AdviceFibers.kernelDifference A rows.val (AdviceFibers.observedBase A rows) (AdviceFibers.observedBase_property A rows) ⟨Mstar, hstar⟩ /-- Rebase the complete quotient parametrization without changing its matrices. -/ theorem assemble_privateOrigin (A : K →ₗ[F2] R) (rows : AdviceFibers.ObservedRow (E := E) A) (Mstar : E →ₗ[F2] K) (hstar : A.comp Mstar = rows.val) (Q : Submodule F2 E) (L : (E ⧸ Q) →ₗ[F2] A.ker) : AdviceFibers.assemble A (AdviceFibers.observedBase A rows) (privateOrigin A rows Mstar hstar + L.comp Q.mkQ) = (RowErasureSliceQuotient.equiv A Q Mstar L).val := by ext x change AdviceFibers.observedBase A rows x + ((Mstar x - AdviceFibers.observedBase A rows x) + (L (Q.mkQ x) : K)) = Mstar x + (L (Q.mkQ x) : K) rw [← add_assoc] congr 1 rw [add_comm, sub_add_cancel] end Rebase variable {R : Type} [AddCommGroup R] [Module F2 R] variable {k s d : Nat} /-- A default actual projected answer depends only on the displayed positions. -/ def visibleFallback (J : Finset (Fin k)) : ActualAnswer (TableKeys.visibleTau J) := ⟨Pi.single none 1, by simp [TableKeys.visibleTau]⟩ /-- Exact transport from the actual conditional matrix slice to the private Fourier coordinates. `targetIntercept` uses the visible base, not `Mstar`. -/ theorem actual_slice_agreement_eq_private (S : Source) (labeling : Fin (TableKeysGame.vertexCount S k s d) → Fin (2 ^ s)) (J : Finset (Fin k)) (O : RawPrivateTable.SupportedV J (ActualGame.names S)) (A : Alphabet s →ₗ[F2] R) (rows : AdviceFibers.ObservedRow (E := RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J) A) (T : RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J →ₗ[F2] Vector d) (Mstar : RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J →ₗ[F2] Alphabet s) (hstar : A.comp Mstar = rows.val) (Q : Submodule F2 (RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J)) [Fintype ((RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J ⧸ Q) →ₗ[F2] A.ker)] [Fintype (RowErasureSliceQuotient.AffineSlice A Q Mstar)] (z' : RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J) (u : Alphabet s) : (𝔼 M : RowErasureSliceQuotient.AffineSlice A Q Mstar, if TableKeysRestoration.projectedAnswer S k s d labeling J O (M.val.prod T) = M.val z' + u then (1 : ℝ) else 0) = 𝔼 L : (RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J ⧸ Q) →ₗ[F2] A.ker, if TableKeysPrivateRow.rowAnswer S labeling J O A rows T (privateOrigin A rows Mstar hstar + L.comp Q.mkQ) = TableKeysPrivateRow.targetIntercept J A rows z' u + ((privateOrigin A rows Mstar hstar + L.comp Q.mkQ) z' : Alphabet s) then (1 : ℝ) else 0 := by rw [← RowErasureSliceQuotient.expect_equiv A Q Mstar] apply Finset.expect_congr rfl intro L _ rw [← assemble_privateOrigin A rows Mstar hstar Q L] change (if TableKeysPrivateRow.rowAnswer S labeling J O A rows T (privateOrigin A rows Mstar hstar + L.comp Q.mkQ) = AdviceFibers.assemble A (AdviceFibers.observedBase A rows) (privateOrigin A rows Mstar hstar + L.comp Q.mkQ) z' + u then (1 : ℝ) else 0) = _ rw [TableKeysPrivateRow.affine_target_on_row J A rows (privateOrigin A rows Mstar hstar + L.comp Q.mkQ) z' u] rw [add_comm (((privateOrigin A rows Mstar hstar + L.comp Q.mkQ) z') : Alphabet s) (TableKeysPrivateRow.targetIntercept J A rows z' u)] /-- Private policies for an actual restored labeling satisfy the conditional decoding bound on every transferred good slice. Folding and first-bit preservation come from their concrete constructions, not additional premises. -/ theorem actual_transferred_decoding (S : Source) (labeling : Fin (TableKeysGame.vertexCount S k s d) → Fin (2 ^ s)) (J : Finset (Fin k)) (occ : Fin k → Fin S.occurrences) (slot : Fin k → PartnerProjection.Slot) (A : Alphabet s →ₗ[F2] R) (rows : AdviceFibers.ObservedRow (E := RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J) A) (T : RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J →ₗ[F2] Vector d) (Mstar : RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J →ₗ[F2] Alphabet s) (hstar : A.comp Mstar = rows.val) (Z : Submodule F2 (ActualHomogeneous.E k)) [Fintype Z] (z : ActualHomogeneous.E k) (hz : ActualHomogeneous.tau z = 1) (u : Alphabet s) (α : ℝ) (hα : 0 ≤ α) (ℓ r : ℕ) (hH : Module.finrank F2 A.ker ≤ ℓ) (hZ : Module.finrank F2 Z ≤ r) [Fintype A.ker] [Fintype (RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J →ₗ[F2] A.ker)] [Fintype (A.ker →ₗ[F2] RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J)] [Fintype (A.ker →ₗ[F2] Z.map (RawPrivateTable.projection J (ActualGame.rhs S) occ slot))] [Fintype ((RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J ⧸ Z.map (RawPrivateTable.projection J (ActualGame.rhs S) occ slot)) →ₗ[F2] A.ker)] [Fintype (RowErasureSliceQuotient.AffineSlice A (Z.map (RawPrivateTable.projection J (ActualGame.rhs S) occ slot)) Mstar)] (hsmall : 1 / (Fintype.card A.ker : ℝ) ≤ α / 8) (hagreement : α / 4 ≤ 𝔼 M : RowErasureSliceQuotient.AffineSlice A (Z.map (RawPrivateTable.projection J (ActualGame.rhs S) occ slot)) Mstar, if TableKeysRestoration.projectedAnswer S k s d labeling J (RawPrivateTable.supported J (ActualGame.names S) occ slot) (M.val.prod T) = M.val (RawPrivateTable.projection J (ActualGame.rhs S) occ slot z) + u then (1 : ℝ) else 0) : (α / 8) ^ 2 / (2 : ℝ) ^ (ℓ * r) / (2 : ℝ) ^ r ≤ PrivateStrategy.conditionalAgreement Z z ActualHomogeneous.tau hz (RawPrivateTable.projection J (ActualGame.rhs S) occ slot) (TableKeysPrivateRow.rowAnswer S labeling J (RawPrivateTable.supported J (ActualGame.names S) occ slot) A rows T) A.ker.subtype (TableKeys.visibleTau J) (visibleFallback J) := by let π := RawPrivateTable.projection J (ActualGame.rhs S) occ slot let O := RawPrivateTable.supported J (ActualGame.names S) occ slot have hτ : (TableKeys.visibleTau J).comp π = ActualHomogeneous.tau := by apply LinearMap.ext intro x exact TableKeys.projection_preserves_homogeneous J (ActualGame.rhs S) occ slot x apply conditionalAgreement_from_slice Z z ActualHomogeneous.tau hz π (privateOrigin A rows Mstar hstar) (TableKeysPrivateRow.rowAnswer S labeling J O A rows T) A.ker.subtype Subtype.val_injective (TableKeys.visibleTau J) (visibleFallback J) hτ (TableKeysPrivateRow.rowAnswer_fold S labeling J O A rows T) (TableKeysPrivateRow.targetIntercept J A rows (π z) u) α hα ℓ r hH hZ hsmall apply hagreement.trans_eq calc _ = _ := actual_slice_agreement_eq_private S labeling J O A rows T Mstar hstar (Z.map π) (π z) u _ = _ := by apply Finset.expect_congr rfl intro L _ exact indicator_congr _ _ _ _ Iff.rfl end MaxCutGames.Decoder.TransferredDecoding namespace MaxCutGames.Decoder.VisiblePolicies open MaxCutGames.Integration.BinaryLinear open MaxCutGames.Reduction open MaxCutGames.Soundness open MaxCutGames.Foundations.Games open ActualSource PrivateStrategy open scoped BigOperators Classical attribute [local instance] Classical.propDecidable attribute [local instance] Fintype.ofFinite local instance homFintype {D F : Type*} [AddCommGroup D] [Module F2 D] [AddCommGroup F] [Module F2 F] [Fintype D] [Fintype F] : Fintype (D →ₗ[F2] F) := Fintype.ofInjective (fun M : D →ₗ[F2] F => (M : D → F)) DFunLike.coe_injective /-- The part of a normalized affine witness needed by the left sampler. -/ structure ResponseWitness (k : ℕ) where columns : Submodule F2 (ActualHomogeneous.E k) coefficient : ActualHomogeneous.E k firstBit : ActualHomogeneous.tau coefficient = 1 def defaultWitness (k : ℕ) : ResponseWitness k := ⟨⊥, ActualHomogeneous.hBasis k, ActualHomogeneous.tau_hBasis⟩ variable {k s d : ℕ} {R : Type} [AddCommGroup R] [Module F2 R] abbrev LeftInput (S : Source) (k s d : ℕ) (R : Type) [AddCommGroup R] [Module F2 R] := AdviceExperiment.FullAdvice k (Fin S.occurrences) (Alphabet s) (Vector d) R abbrev RightInput (S : Source) (J : Finset (Fin k)) (s d : ℕ) (R : Type) [AddCommGroup R] [Module F2 R] := AdviceExperiment.ProjectedAdvice (K := Alphabet s) (W := Vector d) (R := R) (ActualGame.names S) J /-- The witness choice has only the left observation as its variable input. -/ def chosenWitness {S : Source} (good : LeftInput S k s d R → ResponseWitness k → Prop) (q : LeftInput S k s d R) : ResponseWitness k := if h : ∃ w, good q w then Classical.choose h else defaultWitness k theorem chosenWitness_spec {S : Source} (good : LeftInput S k s d R → ResponseWitness k → Prop) (q : LeftInput S k s d R) (h : ∃ w, good q w) : good q (chosenWitness good q) := by rw [chosenWitness, dite_eq_left h] exact Classical.choose_spec h def leftPolicy {S : Source} (good : LeftInput S k s d R → ResponseWitness k → Prop) (q : LeftInput S k s d R) : FiniteDistribution (ActualAnswer (ActualHomogeneous.tau (k := k))) := let w := chosenWitness good q candidateLaw w.columns w.coefficient ActualHomogeneous.tau w.firstBit /-- A fixed valid fallback gives a total policy even on impossible row inputs. -/ def pointLaw {X : Type*} [Fintype X] (x : X) : FiniteDistribution X where weight y := if y = x then 1 else 0 nonnegative y := by split <;> norm_num normalized := by simp /-- The right kernel consumes its own complete visible observation only. -/ def rightPolicy (S : Source) (labeling : Fin (TableKeysGame.vertexCount S k s d) → Fin (2 ^ s)) (J : Finset (Fin k)) (q : RightInput S J s d R) : FiniteDistribution (ActualAnswer (TableKeys.visibleTau J)) := if h : ∃ M : RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J →ₗ[F2] Alphabet s, q.rowMap.comp M = q.rows then privateLaw (TableKeysPrivateRow.rowAnswer S labeling J q.question q.rowMap ⟨q.rows, h⟩ q.complement) q.rowMap.ker.subtype (TableKeys.visibleTau J) (TransferredDecoding.visibleFallback J) else pointLaw (TransferredDecoding.visibleFallback J) theorem rightPolicy_on_attainable (S : Source) (labeling : Fin (TableKeysGame.vertexCount S k s d) → Fin (2 ^ s)) (J : Finset (Fin k)) (q : RightInput S J s d R) (h : ∃ M : RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint J →ₗ[F2] Alphabet s, q.rowMap.comp M = q.rows) : rightPolicy S labeling J q = privateLaw (TableKeysPrivateRow.rowAnswer S labeling J q.question q.rowMap ⟨q.rows, h⟩ q.complement) q.rowMap.ker.subtype (TableKeys.visibleTau J) (TransferredDecoding.visibleFallback J) := by rw [rightPolicy, dite_eq_left h] theorem leftPolicy_changeHidden (S : Source) (good : LeftInput S k s d R → ResponseWitness k → Prop) (draw : AdviceExperiment.Draw k (Fin S.occurrences) (Alphabet s) (Vector d) R) (N : RawPartnerTarget.RawPoint draw.singletons →ₗ[F2] draw.rowMap.ker) : leftPolicy good (AdviceExperiment.leftObservation (ActualGame.rhs S) (AdviceExperiment.changeHidden draw N)) = leftPolicy good (AdviceExperiment.leftObservation (ActualGame.rhs S) draw) := by rw [AdviceExperiment.leftObservation_changeHidden] theorem rightPolicy_on_draw (S : Source) (labeling : Fin (TableKeysGame.vertexCount S k s d) → Fin (2 ^ s)) (draw : AdviceExperiment.Draw k (Fin S.occurrences) (Alphabet s) (Vector d) R) : rightPolicy S labeling draw.singletons (AdviceExperiment.rightObservation (ActualGame.names S) draw).2 = privateLaw (TableKeysPrivateRow.rowAnswer S labeling draw.singletons (RawPrivateTable.supported draw.singletons (ActualGame.names S) draw.occurrences draw.positions) draw.rowMap (AdviceFibers.observe draw.rowMap draw.hiddenMatrix) draw.complement) draw.rowMap.ker.subtype (TableKeys.visibleTau draw.singletons) (TransferredDecoding.visibleFallback draw.singletons) := by rw [rightPolicy_on_attainable S labeling draw.singletons (AdviceExperiment.rightObservation (ActualGame.names S) draw).2 (AdviceExperiment.right_rows_attainable (ActualGame.names S) draw)] rfl /-- The literal product of the two observation-local stochastic responses. -/ def observedAgreement (S : Source) (labeling : Fin (TableKeysGame.vertexCount S k s d) → Fin (2 ^ s)) (good : LeftInput S k s d R → ResponseWitness k → Prop) (draw : AdviceExperiment.Draw k (Fin S.occurrences) (Alphabet s) (Vector d) R) : ℝ := ((leftPolicy good (AdviceExperiment.leftObservation (ActualGame.rhs S) draw)).product (rightPolicy S labeling draw.singletons (AdviceExperiment.rightObservation (ActualGame.names S) draw).2)).probability (fun answers => decide (AdviceExperiment.projection (ActualGame.rhs S) draw answers.1.1 = answers.2.1)) /-- The private-decoding expression is exactly the actual local-kernel product probability. In particular there is no shared decoder random tape. -/ theorem observedAgreement_eq_private (S : Source) (labeling : Fin (TableKeysGame.vertexCount S k s d) → Fin (2 ^ s)) (good : LeftInput S k s d R → ResponseWitness k → Prop) (draw : AdviceExperiment.Draw k (Fin S.occurrences) (Alphabet s) (Vector d) R) : observedAgreement S labeling good draw = let w := chosenWitness good (AdviceExperiment.leftObservation (ActualGame.rhs S) draw) PrivateStrategy.conditionalAgreement w.columns w.coefficient ActualHomogeneous.tau w.firstBit (AdviceExperiment.projection (ActualGame.rhs S) draw) (TableKeysPrivateRow.rowAnswer S labeling draw.singletons (RawPrivateTable.supported draw.singletons (ActualGame.names S) draw.occurrences draw.positions) draw.rowMap (AdviceFibers.observe draw.rowMap draw.hiddenMatrix) draw.complement) draw.rowMap.ker.subtype (TableKeys.visibleTau draw.singletons) (TransferredDecoding.visibleFallback draw.singletons) := by rw [observedAgreement, rightPolicy_on_draw S labeling draw] dsimp only [PrivateStrategy.conditionalAgreement, leftPolicy] congr 1 funext answers apply Bool.eq_iff_iff.mpr simp only [decide_eq_true_eq] end MaxCutGames.Decoder.VisiblePolicies end end OAI