import Mathlib import OAI.Computability.MaxCut.Machines.AlphabetReduction import OAI.Computability.MaxCut.PCP.UniformRestriction namespace OAI noncomputable section namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.AlphabetGraph open MaxCutGames.Foundations.Hastad open scoped BigOperators abbrev Address (V E A : Type*) := (V × Cube A) ⊕ (E × Cube (A × A)) abbrev LocalEvent (A : Type*) := Fin 4 × AlphabetReduction.InputCoordinate A × Cube (A × A) × Cube (A × A) × Cube (A × A) × Cube (A × A) × Cube (A × A) abbrev Event (E A : Type*) := E × LocalEvent A variable {V E A : Type*} [Fintype A] [DecidableEq A] [Nonempty A] abbrev legal (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (e : E) (p : A × A) : Prop := G.accepts e p.1 p.2 = true instance legalDecidable (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (e : E) : DecidablePred (legal G e) := fun p => inferInstanceAs (Decidable (G.accepts e p.1 p.2 = true)) def restrictTape (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (e : E) (f : Cube (A × A)) : Cube (AlphabetReduction.LegalPair (G.accepts e)) := UniformRestriction.restrict (legal G e) f def extendTape (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (e : E) (f : Cube (AlphabetReduction.LegalPair (G.accepts e))) : Cube (A × A) := UniformRestriction.extend (legal G e) f def globalizeQuery (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (e : E) : AlphabetReduction.InputCoordinate A ⊕ Cube (AlphabetReduction.LegalPair (G.accepts e)) → Address V E A | .inl (side, tape) => .inl ((if side then G.head e else G.tail e), tape) | .inr tape => .inr (e, extendTape G e tape) def verifier (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) : QueryIncidence.Verifier (Event E A) (Address V E A) 6 where query := fun (e, kind, k, f, g, r₀, r₁, r₂) slot => globalizeQuery G e (AssignmentTester.eventQueries (AlphabetReduction.pairEncoding (G.accepts e)) kind k (restrictTape G e f) (restrictTape G e g) (restrictTape G e r₀) (restrictTape G e r₁) (restrictTape G e r₂) slot) accepts := fun (_, kind, _, _, _, _, _, _) b => AssignmentTester.eventAccepts kind b def vertexBlock (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) (v : V) : Cube A → Bool := fun tape => assignment (.inl (v, tape)) def edgeOracle (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) (e : E) : Cube (AlphabetReduction.LegalPair (G.accepts e)) → Bool := fun tape => assignment (.inr (e, extendTape G e tape)) omit [Fintype A] [DecidableEq A] [Nonempty A] in theorem oracleAnswer_globalize (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) (e : E) (x : AlphabetReduction.InputCoordinate A ⊕ Cube (AlphabetReduction.LegalPair (G.accepts e))) : assignment (globalizeQuery G e x) = AssignmentTester.oracleAnswer (CodeComposition.pairWord (vertexBlock assignment (G.tail e)) (vertexBlock assignment (G.head e))) (edgeOracle G assignment e) x := by rcases x with ⟨side, tape⟩ | tape · cases side <;> rfl · rfl omit [Fintype A] [DecidableEq A] [Nonempty A] in theorem response_eq_local (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) (e : E) (kind : Fin 4) (k : AlphabetReduction.InputCoordinate A) (f g r₀ r₁ r₂ : Cube (A × A)) : QueryIncidence.response (verifier G) assignment (e, kind, k, f, g, r₀, r₁, r₂) = fun slot => AssignmentTester.oracleAnswer (CodeComposition.pairWord (vertexBlock assignment (G.tail e)) (vertexBlock assignment (G.head e))) (edgeOracle G assignment e) (AssignmentTester.eventQueries (AlphabetReduction.pairEncoding (G.accepts e)) kind k (restrictTape G e f) (restrictTape G e g) (restrictTape G e r₀) (restrictTape G e r₁) (restrictTape G e r₂) slot) := by funext slot exact oracleAnswer_globalize G assignment e _ def eventReject (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) (event : Event E A) : ℝ := AssignmentTester.truth (!((verifier G).accepts event (QueryIncidence.response (verifier G) assignment event))) omit [Fintype A] [DecidableEq A] [Nonempty A] in theorem eventReject_eq_local (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) (e : E) (kind : Fin 4) (k : AlphabetReduction.InputCoordinate A) (f g r₀ r₁ r₂ : Cube (A × A)) : eventReject G assignment (e, kind, k, f, g, r₀, r₁, r₂) = AssignmentTester.eventReject (AlphabetReduction.pairEncoding (G.accepts e)) (CodeComposition.pairWord (vertexBlock assignment (G.tail e)) (vertexBlock assignment (G.head e))) (edgeOracle G assignment e) kind k (restrictTape G e f) (restrictTape G e g) (restrictTape G e r₀) (restrictTape G e r₁) (restrictTape G e r₂) := by unfold eventReject rw [response_eq_local] rfl theorem expect_prod {I J : Type*} [Fintype I] [Fintype J] (f : I × J → ℝ) : (𝔼 z : I × J, f z) = 𝔼 i : I, 𝔼 j : J, f (i, j) := by simpa only [Finset.univ_product_univ] using Finset.expect_product (Finset.univ : Finset I) (Finset.univ : Finset J) f def localAverage (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) (e : E) : ℝ := 𝔼 sample : LocalEvent A, eventReject G assignment (e, sample) /-- Iterating the checked one-tape restriction identity preserves independence. -/ theorem expect_restrict_five {B : Type*} [Fintype B] [DecidableEq B] (p : B → Prop) [DecidablePred p] (h : ({b // p b} → Bool) → ({b // p b} → Bool) → ({b // p b} → Bool) → ({b // p b} → Bool) → ({b // p b} → Bool) → ℝ) : (𝔼 f : B → Bool, 𝔼 g : B → Bool, 𝔼 r₀ : B → Bool, 𝔼 r₁ : B → Bool, 𝔼 r₂ : B → Bool, h (UniformRestriction.restrict p f) (UniformRestriction.restrict p g) (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₀) (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₁) (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₂)) = 𝔼 f : {b // p b} → Bool, 𝔼 g : {b // p b} → Bool, 𝔼 r₀ : {b // p b} → Bool, 𝔼 r₁ : {b // p b} → Bool, 𝔼 r₂ : {b // p b} → Bool, h f g r₀ r₁ r₂ := by rw [UniformRestriction.expect_restrict p (fun f => 𝔼 g : B → Bool, 𝔼 r₀ : B → Bool, 𝔼 r₁ : B → Bool, 𝔼 r₂ : B → Bool, h f (UniformRestriction.restrict p g) (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₀) (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₁) (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₂))] apply Finset.expect_congr rfl intro f _ rw [UniformRestriction.expect_restrict p (fun g => 𝔼 r₀ : B → Bool, 𝔼 r₁ : B → Bool, 𝔼 r₂ : B → Bool, h f g (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₀) (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₁) (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₂))] apply Finset.expect_congr rfl intro g _ rw [UniformRestriction.expect_restrict p (fun r₀ => 𝔼 r₁ : B → Bool, 𝔼 r₂ : B → Bool, h f g r₀ (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₁) (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₂))] apply Finset.expect_congr rfl intro r₀ _ rw [UniformRestriction.expect_restrict p (fun r₁ => 𝔼 r₂ : B → Bool, h f g r₀ r₁ (UniformRestriction.restrict p r₂))] apply Finset.expect_congr rfl intro r₁ _ exact UniformRestriction.expect_restrict p (h f g r₀ r₁) omit [Nonempty A] in /-- Five independent full tapes restrict to five independent uniform legal tapes. -/ theorem localAverage_eq_tester (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) (e : E) : localAverage G assignment e = AlphabetReduction.edgeTesterReject (G.accepts e) (vertexBlock assignment (G.tail e)) (vertexBlock assignment (G.head e)) (edgeOracle G assignment e) := by unfold localAverage AlphabetReduction.edgeTesterReject AssignmentTester.explicitTesterReject simp only [LocalEvent, expect_prod, eventReject_eq_local, restrictTape] apply Finset.expect_congr rfl intro kind _ apply Finset.expect_congr rfl intro side _ apply Finset.expect_congr rfl intro tape _ exact expect_restrict_five (legal G e) (AssignmentTester.eventReject (AlphabetReduction.pairEncoding (G.accepts e)) (CodeComposition.pairWord (vertexBlock assignment (G.tail e)) (vertexBlock assignment (G.head e))) (edgeOracle G assignment e) kind (side, tape)) def average [Fintype E] (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) : ℝ := 𝔼 event : Event E A, eventReject G assignment event omit [Nonempty A] in theorem average_eq_testers [Fintype E] (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) : average G assignment = 𝔼 e : E, AlphabetReduction.edgeTesterReject (G.accepts e) (vertexBlock assignment (G.tail e)) (vertexBlock assignment (G.head e)) (edgeOracle G assignment e) := by unfold average rw [expect_prod] exact Finset.expect_congr rfl (fun e _ => localAverage_eq_tester G assignment e) def decodedLabeling (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) : V → A := fun v => CodeComposition.nearest (vertexBlock assignment v) theorem local_gap (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) (e : E) : AssignmentTester.truth (!(G.edgeSatisfied (decodedLabeling assignment) e)) / 2048 ≤ localAverage G assignment e := by cases h : G.edgeSatisfied (decodedLabeling assignment) e with | false => rw [localAverage_eq_tester] simpa [AssignmentTester.truth] using AlphabetReduction.rejected_edge_tester_bound (G.accepts e) (vertexBlock assignment (G.tail e)) (vertexBlock assignment (G.head e)) (edgeOracle G assignment e) h | true => simp only [Bool.not_true, AssignmentTester.truth, Bool.false_eq_true, ite_false, zero_div] apply Finset.expect_nonneg intro sample _ exact AssignmentTester.truth_nonneg _ theorem average_gap [Fintype E] (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) : (𝔼 e : E, AssignmentTester.truth (!(G.edgeSatisfied (decodedLabeling assignment) e))) / 2048 ≤ average G assignment := by unfold average rw [expect_prod, Finset.expect_div] exact Finset.expect_le_expect (fun e _ => local_gap G assignment e) theorem expect_rejection_eq_count {I : Type*} [Fintype I] (b : I → Bool) : (𝔼 i : I, AssignmentTester.truth (!(b i))) = ((Finset.univ.filter (fun i => b i = false)).card : ℝ) / Fintype.card I := by rw [Fintype.expect_eq_sum_div_card] congr 1 calc (∑ i : I, AssignmentTester.truth (!(b i))) = ∑ i : I, if b i = false then (1 : ℝ) else 0 := by apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro i _ cases b i <;> norm_num [AssignmentTester.truth] _ = _ := Finset.sum_boole _ _ omit [Nonempty A] in theorem average_eq_count [Fintype E] (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) : average G assignment = (QueryIncidence.verifierRejectionCount (verifier G) assignment : ℝ) / Fintype.card (Event E A) := expect_rejection_eq_count _ omit [Nonempty A] in @[simp] theorem card_event [Fintype E] : Fintype.card (Event E A) = Fintype.card E * Fintype.card (LocalEvent A) := Fintype.card_prod _ _ omit [Nonempty A] in /-- This factor depends only on the old alphabet, never on a dart predicate. -/ theorem card_localEvent : Fintype.card (LocalEvent A) = 4 * (2 * 2 ^ Fintype.card A) * (2 ^ (Fintype.card A * Fintype.card A)) ^ 5 := by simp [LocalEvent, AlphabetReduction.InputCoordinate, Cube, Fintype.card_prod, pow_succ, Nat.mul_assoc, Nat.mul_comm, Nat.mul_left_comm] omit [Nonempty A] in theorem card_address [Fintype V] [Fintype E] : Fintype.card (Address V E A) = Fintype.card V * 2 ^ Fintype.card A + Fintype.card E * 2 ^ (Fintype.card A * Fintype.card A) := by simp [Address, Cube, Fintype.card_sum, Fintype.card_prod] /-- The actual event count has a uniform loss of 2048, with no edge-dependent sample multiplicities. This count statement also permits an empty dart type. -/ theorem rejection_count_bound [Fintype E] (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) : Fintype.card (LocalEvent A) * G.rejectionCount (decodedLabeling assignment) ≤ 2048 * QueryIncidence.verifierRejectionCount (verifier G) assignment := by classical cases isEmpty_or_nonempty E with | inl empty => let := empty simp [ConstraintGraph.rejectionCount, ConstraintGraph.rejectedDarts] | inr inhabited => let := inhabited have h := average_gap G assignment rw [average_eq_count, expect_rejection_eq_count, card_event, Nat.cast_mul, div_div] at h have he : (0 : ℝ) < Fintype.card E := by exact_mod_cast Fintype.card_pos have hl : (0 : ℝ) < Fintype.card (LocalEvent A) := by exact_mod_cast Fintype.card_pos have hc := (div_le_div_iff₀ (mul_pos he (by norm_num)) (mul_pos he hl)).mp h have hc' : ((Fintype.card (LocalEvent A) : ℝ) * (G.rejectionCount (decodedLabeling assignment) : ℝ)) * Fintype.card E ≤ (2048 * (QueryIncidence.verifierRejectionCount (verifier G) assignment : ℝ)) * Fintype.card E := by simpa only [ConstraintGraph.rejectionCount, ConstraintGraph.rejectedDarts, mul_assoc, mul_comm, mul_left_comm] using hc have result := (mul_le_mul_iff_left₀ he).mp hc' exact_mod_cast result def honestAssignment (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (labeling : V → A) : Address V E A → Bool | .inl (v, tape) => tape (labeling v) | .inr (e, tape) => tape (labeling (G.tail e), labeling (G.head e)) omit [Fintype A] [DecidableEq A] [Nonempty A] in @[simp] theorem honest_vertexBlock (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (labeling : V → A) (v : V) : vertexBlock (honestAssignment G labeling) v = CodeComposition.codeword (labeling v) := rfl omit [Fintype A] [DecidableEq A] [Nonempty A] in theorem honest_edgeOracle (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (labeling : V → A) (e : E) (h : G.edgeSatisfied labeling e = true) : edgeOracle G (honestAssignment G labeling) e = fun tape => tape ⟨(labeling (G.tail e), labeling (G.head e)), h⟩ := by funext tape exact UniformRestriction.extend_apply_of_mem (legal G e) tape (labeling (G.tail e), labeling (G.head e)) h omit [Fintype A] [DecidableEq A] [Nonempty A] in theorem honest_event (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (labeling : V → A) (satisfied : ∀ e, G.edgeSatisfied labeling e = true) (event : Event E A) : (verifier G).accepts event (QueryIncidence.response (verifier G) (honestAssignment G labeling) event) = true := by rcases event with ⟨e, kind, k, f, g, r₀, r₁, r₂⟩ rw [response_eq_local, honest_edgeOracle G labeling e (satisfied e)] simp only [honest_vertexBlock] exact AssignmentTester.event_perfect_completeness (AlphabetReduction.pairEncoding (G.accepts e)) ⟨(labeling (G.tail e), labeling (G.head e)), satisfied e⟩ kind k (restrictTape G e f) (restrictTape G e g) (restrictTape G e r₀) (restrictTape G e r₁) (restrictTape G e r₂) def graph [DecidableEq V] [DecidableEq E] (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) : ConstraintGraph (QueryIncidence.Vertex (Event E A) (Address V E A)) (QueryIncidence.Dart (Event E A) 6) (QueryIncidence.Label 6) := QueryIncidence.graph (verifier G) (by omega) omit [DecidableEq A] [Nonempty A] in theorem perfect_completeness [DecidableEq V] [DecidableEq E] (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (satisfied : G.Satisfiable) : (graph G).Satisfiable := by obtain ⟨labeling, h⟩ := satisfied exact QueryIncidence.satisfiable_of_verifier_satisfiable (verifier G) (by omega) ⟨honestAssignment G labeling, honest_event G labeling h⟩ /-- The combined tester and incidence losses are 2048 × 6 = 12288. -/ theorem gap_transfer [Fintype E] [DecidableEq V] [DecidableEq E] (G : ConstraintGraph V E A) (a b : Nat) (source : ∀ labeling : V → A, a * Fintype.card E ≤ b * G.rejectionCount labeling) (labeling : QueryIncidence.Vertex (Event E A) (Address V E A) → QueryIncidence.Label 6) : a * Fintype.card (QueryIncidence.Dart (Event E A) 6) ≤ (b * 12288) * (graph G).rejectionCount labeling := by have verifierGap (assignment : Address V E A → Bool) : a * Fintype.card (Event E A) ≤ (b * 2048) * QueryIncidence.verifierRejectionCount (verifier G) assignment := by rw [card_event] calc a * (Fintype.card E * Fintype.card (LocalEvent A)) = Fintype.card (LocalEvent A) * (a * Fintype.card E) := by ac_rfl _ ≤ Fintype.card (LocalEvent A) * (b * G.rejectionCount (decodedLabeling assignment)) := Nat.mul_le_mul_left _ (source (decodedLabeling assignment)) _ = b * (Fintype.card (LocalEvent A) * G.rejectionCount (decodedLabeling assignment)) := by ac_rfl _ ≤ b * (2048 * QueryIncidence.verifierRejectionCount (verifier G) assignment) := Nat.mul_le_mul_left _ (rejection_count_bound G assignment) _ = (b * 2048) * QueryIncidence.verifierRejectionCount (verifier G) assignment := by ac_rfl have h := QueryIncidence.gap_transfer (verifier G) (by omega) a (b * 2048) verifierGap labeling have hcoef : b * 2048 * 6 = b * 12288 := by omega rw [hcoef] at h exact h theorem alphabet_card : Fintype.card (QueryIncidence.Label 6) = 64 := QueryIncidence.six_query_alphabet end MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.AlphabetGraph end /-! # Explicit orders for the alphabet-reduction table All executable maps use Boolean digits, finite sums, and division/remainder. No enumeration is chosen from a cardinality proof. Cube coordinate zero is the least significant bit; pairs of coordinates use row-major order. Event blocks are ordered by their original dart, followed by the local event. Vertices put events before vertex addresses before edge addresses. Each event has twelve ordered darts: six slots, with false then true orientation at each slot. -/ namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.AlphabetTable.Enumeration open MaxCutGames.Foundations.Hastad open scoped BigOperators def bitValue (bit : Bool) : Nat := if bit then 1 else 0 def boolEquiv : Bool ≃ Fin 2 := finTwoEquiv.symm @[simp] theorem boolEquiv_val (bit : Bool) : (boolEquiv bit).val = bitValue bit := by cases bit <;> rfl /-- Left component first, with the right component varying fastest. -/ def productEquiv {A B : Type*} {a b : Nat} (left : A ≃ Fin a) (right : B ≃ Fin b) : A × B ≃ Fin (a * b) := (Equiv.prodCongr left right).trans finProdFinEquiv @[simp] theorem productEquiv_val {A B : Type*} {a b : Nat} (left : A ≃ Fin a) (right : B ≃ Fin b) (x : A) (y : B) : (productEquiv left right (x, y)).val = (left x).val * b + (right y).val := by change (right y).val + b * (left x).val = _ simp [Nat.mul_comm, Nat.add_comm] /-- The complete left block precedes the complete right block. -/ def sumEquiv {A B : Type*} {a b : Nat} (left : A ≃ Fin a) (right : B ≃ Fin b) : A ⊕ B ≃ Fin (a + b) := (Equiv.sumCongr left right).trans finSumFinEquiv @[simp] theorem sumEquiv_inl_val {A B : Type*} {a b : Nat} (left : A ≃ Fin a) (right : B ≃ Fin b) (x : A) : (sumEquiv left right (.inl x)).val = (left x).val := rfl @[simp] theorem sumEquiv_inr_val {A B : Type*} {a b : Nat} (left : A ≃ Fin a) (right : B ≃ Fin b) (y : B) : (sumEquiv left right (.inr y)).val = a + (right y).val := rfl def tapeCount (q : Nat) : Nat := 2 ^ q def pairTapeCount (q : Nat) : Nat := 2 ^ (q * q) def fiveTapeCount (q : Nat) : Nat := pairTapeCount q ^ 5 def localCount (q : Nat) : Nat := 4 * (2 * tapeCount q) * fiveTapeCount q def eventCount (m q : Nat) : Nat := m * localCount q def addressCount (n m q : Nat) : Nat := n * tapeCount q + m * pairTapeCount q def vertexCount (n m q : Nat) : Nat := eventCount m q + addressCount n m q def dartCount (m q : Nat) : Nat := eventCount m q * 12 /-- Explicit binary rank/unrank; the inverse extracts digits by division and remainder, as supplied by the executable `finFunctionFinEquiv`. -/ def cubeEquiv (q : Nat) : Cube (Fin q) ≃ Fin (tapeCount q) := (Equiv.arrowCongr (Equiv.refl (Fin q)) boolEquiv).trans finFunctionFinEquiv def cubeRank {q : Nat} (tape : Cube (Fin q)) : Fin (tapeCount q) := cubeEquiv q tape def cubeUnrank {q : Nat} (index : Fin (tapeCount q)) : Cube (Fin q) := (cubeEquiv q).symm index @[simp] theorem cubeUnrank_cubeRank {q : Nat} (tape : Cube (Fin q)) : cubeUnrank (cubeRank tape) = tape := (cubeEquiv q).symm_apply_apply tape @[simp] theorem cubeRank_cubeUnrank {q : Nat} (index : Fin (tapeCount q)) : cubeRank (cubeUnrank index) = index := (cubeEquiv q).apply_symm_apply index theorem cubeUnrank_digit {q : Nat} (index : Fin (tapeCount q)) (i : Fin q) : bitValue (cubeUnrank index i) = index.val / 2 ^ i.val % 2 := by have digit : boolEquiv (cubeUnrank index i) = (⟨index.val / 2 ^ i.val % 2, Nat.mod_lt _ (by decide)⟩ : Fin 2) := by change boolEquiv (boolEquiv.symm _) = _ exact boolEquiv.apply_symm_apply _ simpa only [boolEquiv_val] using congrArg Fin.val digit theorem cubeEquiv_val (q : Nat) (tape : Cube (Fin q)) : (cubeEquiv q tape).val = ∑ i : Fin q, bitValue (tape i) * 2 ^ i.val := by change (finFunctionFinEquiv (fun i => boolEquiv (tape i))).val = _ rw [finFunctionFinEquiv_apply] simp only [boolEquiv_val] def pairIndex (q : Nat) : Fin q × Fin q ≃ Fin (q * q) := finProdFinEquiv theorem pairIndex_val (q : Nat) (i j : Fin q) : (pairIndex q (i, j)).val = i.val * q + j.val := by change j.val + q * i.val = _ simp [Nat.mul_comm, Nat.add_comm] def pairCubeEquiv (q : Nat) : Cube (Fin q × Fin q) ≃ Fin (pairTapeCount q) := (Equiv.arrowCongr (pairIndex q) (Equiv.refl Bool)).trans (cubeEquiv (q * q)) def pairCubeRank {q : Nat} (tape : Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) : Fin (pairTapeCount q) := pairCubeEquiv q tape def pairCubeUnrank {q : Nat} (index : Fin (pairTapeCount q)) : Cube (Fin q × Fin q) := (pairCubeEquiv q).symm index @[simp] theorem pairCubeUnrank_pairCubeRank {q : Nat} (tape : Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) : pairCubeUnrank (pairCubeRank tape) = tape := (pairCubeEquiv q).symm_apply_apply tape @[simp] theorem pairCubeRank_pairCubeUnrank {q : Nat} (index : Fin (pairTapeCount q)) : pairCubeRank (pairCubeUnrank index) = index := (pairCubeEquiv q).apply_symm_apply index theorem pairCubeEquiv_val (q : Nat) (tape : Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) : (pairCubeEquiv q tape).val = ∑ i : Fin (q * q), bitValue (tape ((pairIndex q).symm i)) * 2 ^ i.val := cubeEquiv_val (q * q) _ def inputCoordinateEquiv (q : Nat) : AlphabetReduction.InputCoordinate (Fin q) ≃ Fin (2 * tapeCount q) := productEquiv boolEquiv (cubeEquiv q) def fivePairTapesEquiv (q : Nat) : (Cube (Fin q × Fin q) × Cube (Fin q × Fin q) × Cube (Fin q × Fin q) × Cube (Fin q × Fin q) × Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) ≃ Fin (fiveTapeCount q) := (productEquiv (pairCubeEquiv q) (productEquiv (pairCubeEquiv q) (productEquiv (pairCubeEquiv q) (productEquiv (pairCubeEquiv q) (pairCubeEquiv q))))).trans (finCongr (by simp [fiveTapeCount, pow_succ, Nat.mul_assoc])) def localEventEquiv (q : Nat) : AlphabetGraph.LocalEvent (Fin q) ≃ Fin (localCount q) := (productEquiv (Equiv.refl (Fin 4)) (productEquiv (inputCoordinateEquiv q) (fivePairTapesEquiv q))).trans (finCongr (by simp [localCount, Nat.mul_assoc])) def eventEquiv (m q : Nat) : AlphabetGraph.Event (Fin m) (Fin q) ≃ Fin (eventCount m q) := productEquiv (Equiv.refl (Fin m)) (localEventEquiv q) def addressEquiv (n m q : Nat) : AlphabetGraph.Address (Fin n) (Fin m) (Fin q) ≃ Fin (addressCount n m q) := sumEquiv (productEquiv (Equiv.refl (Fin n)) (cubeEquiv q)) (productEquiv (Equiv.refl (Fin m)) (pairCubeEquiv q)) def vertexEquiv (n m q : Nat) : QueryIncidence.Vertex (AlphabetGraph.Event (Fin m) (Fin q)) (AlphabetGraph.Address (Fin n) (Fin m) (Fin q)) ≃ Fin (vertexCount n m q) := sumEquiv (eventEquiv m q) (addressEquiv n m q) def dartEquiv (m q : Nat) : QueryIncidence.Dart (AlphabetGraph.Event (Fin m) (Fin q)) 6 ≃ Fin (dartCount m q) := (productEquiv (productEquiv (eventEquiv m q) (Equiv.refl (Fin 6))) boolEquiv).trans (finCongr (by simp [dartCount, Nat.mul_assoc])) def labelEquiv : QueryIncidence.Label 6 ≃ Fin 64 := cubeEquiv 6 theorem labelEquiv_val (label : QueryIncidence.Label 6) : (labelEquiv label).val = ∑ i : Fin 6, bitValue (label i) * 2 ^ i.val := cubeEquiv_val 6 label @[simp] theorem inputCoordinateEquiv_val (q : Nat) (side : Bool) (tape : Cube (Fin q)) : (inputCoordinateEquiv q (side, tape)).val = bitValue side * tapeCount q + (cubeEquiv q tape).val := by simp [inputCoordinateEquiv] theorem fivePairTapesEquiv_val (q : Nat) (f g r₀ r₁ r₂ : Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) : (fivePairTapesEquiv q (f, g, r₀, r₁, r₂)).val = (pairCubeEquiv q f).val * pairTapeCount q ^ 4 + (pairCubeEquiv q g).val * pairTapeCount q ^ 3 + (pairCubeEquiv q r₀).val * pairTapeCount q ^ 2 + (pairCubeEquiv q r₁).val * pairTapeCount q + (pairCubeEquiv q r₂).val := by simp [fivePairTapesEquiv, productEquiv_val, pow_succ, Nat.mul_assoc, Nat.add_assoc] theorem localEventEquiv_val (q : Nat) (kind : Fin 4) (coordinate : AlphabetReduction.InputCoordinate (Fin q)) (f g r₀ r₁ r₂ : Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) : (localEventEquiv q (kind, coordinate, f, g, r₀, r₁, r₂)).val = kind.val * (2 * tapeCount q * fiveTapeCount q) + (inputCoordinateEquiv q coordinate).val * fiveTapeCount q + (fivePairTapesEquiv q (f, g, r₀, r₁, r₂)).val := by simp [localEventEquiv, productEquiv_val, Nat.add_assoc] @[simp] theorem eventEquiv_val (m q : Nat) (edge : Fin m) (sample : AlphabetGraph.LocalEvent (Fin q)) : (eventEquiv m q (edge, sample)).val = edge.val * localCount q + (localEventEquiv q sample).val := by change (localEventEquiv q sample).val + localCount q * edge.val = _ simp [Nat.mul_comm, Nat.add_comm] @[simp] theorem addressEquiv_inl_val (n m q : Nat) (vertex : Fin n) (tape : Cube (Fin q)) : (addressEquiv n m q (.inl (vertex, tape))).val = vertex.val * tapeCount q + (cubeEquiv q tape).val := by change (cubeEquiv q tape).val + tapeCount q * vertex.val = _ simp [Nat.mul_comm, Nat.add_comm] @[simp] theorem addressEquiv_inr_val (n m q : Nat) (edge : Fin m) (tape : Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) : (addressEquiv n m q (.inr (edge, tape))).val = n * tapeCount q + (edge.val * pairTapeCount q + (pairCubeEquiv q tape).val) := by change n * tapeCount q + ((pairCubeEquiv q tape).val + pairTapeCount q * edge.val) = _ simp [Nat.mul_comm, Nat.add_comm] @[simp] theorem vertexEquiv_event_val (n m q : Nat) (event : AlphabetGraph.Event (Fin m) (Fin q)) : (vertexEquiv n m q (.inl event)).val = (eventEquiv m q event).val := rfl @[simp] theorem vertexEquiv_vertexAddress_val (n m q : Nat) (vertex : Fin n) (tape : Cube (Fin q)) : (vertexEquiv n m q (.inr (.inl (vertex, tape)))).val = eventCount m q + (vertex.val * tapeCount q + (cubeEquiv q tape).val) := by change eventCount m q + (addressEquiv n m q (.inl (vertex, tape))).val = _ rw [addressEquiv_inl_val] @[simp] theorem vertexEquiv_edgeAddress_val (n m q : Nat) (edge : Fin m) (tape : Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) : (vertexEquiv n m q (.inr (.inr (edge, tape)))).val = eventCount m q + (n * tapeCount q + (edge.val * pairTapeCount q + (pairCubeEquiv q tape).val)) := by change eventCount m q + (addressEquiv n m q (.inr (edge, tape))).val = _ rw [addressEquiv_inr_val] @[simp] theorem dartEquiv_val (m q : Nat) (event : AlphabetGraph.Event (Fin m) (Fin q)) (slot : Fin 6) (orientation : Bool) : (dartEquiv m q ((event, slot), orientation)).val = (eventEquiv m q event).val * 12 + slot.val * 2 + bitValue orientation := by change (boolEquiv orientation).val + 2 * (slot.val + 6 * (eventEquiv m q event).val) = _ rw [boolEquiv_val] omega theorem dartEquiv_reverse_val (m q : Nat) (event : AlphabetGraph.Event (Fin m) (Fin q)) (slot : Fin 6) (orientation : Bool) : (dartEquiv m q (QueryIncidence.reverse ((event, slot), orientation))).val = (eventEquiv m q event).val * 12 + slot.val * 2 + bitValue (!orientation) := dartEquiv_val m q event slot (!orientation) /-- A reusable explicit increasing-index enumeration. -/ def ordered {A : Type*} {count : Nat} (order : A ≃ Fin count) : List A := List.ofFn order.symm @[simp] theorem ordered_length {A : Type*} {count : Nat} (order : A ≃ Fin count) : (ordered order).length = count := by simp [ordered] theorem mem_ordered {A : Type*} {count : Nat} (order : A ≃ Fin count) (x : A) : x ∈ ordered order := by simp only [ordered, List.mem_ofFn] exact ⟨order x, order.symm_apply_apply x⟩ theorem ordered_nodup {A : Type*} {count : Nat} (order : A ≃ Fin count) : (ordered order).Nodup := by rw [ordered, List.nodup_ofFn] exact order.symm.injective @[simp] theorem ordered_refl (n : Nat) : ordered (Equiv.refl (Fin n)) = List.finRange n := rfl @[simp] theorem ordered_bool : ordered boolEquiv = [false, true] := rfl theorem ordered_trans_finCongr {A : Type*} {a b : Nat} (order : A ≃ Fin a) (sameCount : a = b) : ordered (order.trans (finCongr sameCount)) = ordered order := by cases sameCount rfl /-- Product enumeration visits the right factor completely at each left index. -/ theorem ordered_product {A B : Type*} {a b : Nat} (left : A ≃ Fin a) (right : B ≃ Fin b) : ordered (productEquiv left right) = (ordered left).flatMap (fun x => (ordered right).map (fun y => (x, y))) := by have atIndex (i : Fin a) (j : Fin b) (h : i.val * b + j.val < a * b) : (productEquiv left right).symm ⟨i.val * b + j.val, h⟩ = (left.symm i, right.symm j) := by have same : (⟨i.val * b + j.val, h⟩ : Fin (a * b)) = finProdFinEquiv (i, j) := by apply Fin.ext simp [finProdFinEquiv, Nat.mul_comm, Nat.add_comm] rw [same] simp [productEquiv] unfold ordered rw [List.ofFn_mul] simp only [atIndex, List.flatMap_def, List.map_ofFn, Function.comp_def] /-- Sum enumeration puts the whole left block before the whole right block. -/ theorem ordered_sum {A B : Type*} {a b : Nat} (left : A ≃ Fin a) (right : B ≃ Fin b) : ordered (sumEquiv left right) = (ordered left).map Sum.inl ++ (ordered right).map Sum.inr := by have atLeft (i : Fin a) : (sumEquiv left right).symm (i.castLE (Nat.le_add_right a b)) = Sum.inl (left.symm i) := by change (Equiv.sumCongr left right).symm (finSumFinEquiv.symm (Fin.castAdd b i)) = _ rw [finSumFinEquiv_symm_apply_castAdd] rfl have atRight (j : Fin b) : (sumEquiv left right).symm (j.natAdd a) = Sum.inr (right.symm j) := by change (Equiv.sumCongr left right).symm (finSumFinEquiv.symm (j.natAdd a)) = _ rw [finSumFinEquiv_symm_apply_natAdd] rfl unfold ordered rw [List.ofFn_add] simp only [atLeft, atRight, List.map_ofFn, Function.comp_def] def localEvents (q : Nat) : List (AlphabetGraph.LocalEvent (Fin q)) := ordered (localEventEquiv q) @[simp] theorem localEvents_length (q : Nat) : (localEvents q).length = localCount q := ordered_length _ theorem ordered_event (m q : Nat) : ordered (eventEquiv m q) = (List.finRange m).flatMap (fun edge => (localEvents q).map (fun event => (edge, event))) := by change ordered (productEquiv (Equiv.refl (Fin m)) (localEventEquiv q)) = _ rw [ordered_product, ordered_refl] rfl /-- Exact serialized occurrence order, including both orientations and every repeated local query: edge, local event, slot, then false and true. -/ theorem ordered_dart (m q : Nat) : ordered (dartEquiv m q) = (List.finRange m).flatMap (fun edge => (localEvents q).flatMap (fun event => (List.finRange 6).flatMap (fun slot => [(((edge, event), slot), false), (((edge, event), slot), true)]))) := by rw [dartEquiv] erw [ordered_trans_finCongr, ordered_product, ordered_product, ordered_event] simp only [ordered_refl, ordered_bool, List.flatMap_assoc, List.flatMap_map, List.map_cons, List.map_nil] @[simp] theorem card_cube (q : Nat) : Fintype.card (Cube (Fin q)) = tapeCount q := by simpa using Fintype.card_congr (cubeEquiv q) @[simp] theorem card_pairCube (q : Nat) : Fintype.card (Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) = pairTapeCount q := by simpa using Fintype.card_congr (pairCubeEquiv q) @[simp] theorem card_localEvent (q : Nat) : Fintype.card (AlphabetGraph.LocalEvent (Fin q)) = localCount q := by simpa using Fintype.card_congr (localEventEquiv q) @[simp] theorem card_event (m q : Nat) : Fintype.card (AlphabetGraph.Event (Fin m) (Fin q)) = eventCount m q := by simpa using Fintype.card_congr (eventEquiv m q) @[simp] theorem card_address (n m q : Nat) : Fintype.card (AlphabetGraph.Address (Fin n) (Fin m) (Fin q)) = addressCount n m q := by simpa using Fintype.card_congr (addressEquiv n m q) @[simp] theorem card_vertex (n m q : Nat) : Fintype.card (QueryIncidence.Vertex (AlphabetGraph.Event (Fin m) (Fin q)) (AlphabetGraph.Address (Fin n) (Fin m) (Fin q))) = vertexCount n m q := by simpa using Fintype.card_congr (vertexEquiv n m q) @[simp] theorem card_dart (m q : Nat) : Fintype.card (QueryIncidence.Dart (AlphabetGraph.Event (Fin m) (Fin q)) 6) = dartCount m q := by simpa using Fintype.card_congr (dartEquiv m q) @[simp] theorem localCount_formula (q : Nat) : localCount q = 4 * (2 * 2 ^ q) * (2 ^ (q * q)) ^ 5 := rfl end MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.AlphabetTable.Enumeration /-! Executable six-query generation on fixed full Boolean cubes. The event type is exactly `AlphabetGraph.LocalEvent`, including all five full tapes. Only the returned joint-table addresses are masked outside the input relation; no legal-pair enumeration or change of sample multiplicities occurs. -/ namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.AlphabetTable.Queries open MaxCutGames.Foundations.Hastad abbrev RawQuery (q : Nat) := (Bool × Cube (Fin q)) ⊕ Cube (Fin q × Fin q) abbrev LocalEvent (q : Nat) := AlphabetGraph.LocalEvent (Fin q) /-- Canonical full-cube proof address: every illegal coordinate is false. -/ def mask {q : Nat} (P : Fin q → Fin q → Bool) (f : Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) : Cube (Fin q × Fin q) := fun p => if P p.1 p.2 then f p else false def xorTape {A : Type*} (f g : Cube A) : Cube A := fun a => f a ^^ g a def andTape {A : Type*} (f g : Cube A) : Cube A := fun a => f a && g a /-- The coordinate value of the paired input codeword before masking. -/ def inputPairTape {q : Nat} (k : Bool × Cube (Fin q)) : Cube (Fin q × Fin q) := fun p => if k.1 then k.2 p.2 else k.2 p.1 /-- Actual six queries, computed directly from fixed full tapes and P. Padding slots repeat precisely the addresses used by `eventQueries`. -/ def query {q : Nat} (P : Fin q → Fin q → Bool) (event : LocalEvent q) (slot : Fin 6) : RawQuery q := match event with | (kind, k, f, g, r₀, r₁, r₂) => if kind = 0 then if slot = 0 then .inr (mask P f) else if slot = 1 then .inr (mask P g) else .inr (mask P (xorTape f g)) else if kind = 1 then if slot = 0 then .inr (mask P r₀) else if slot = 1 then .inr (mask P (xorTape r₀ (andTape f g))) else if slot = 2 then .inr (mask P r₁) else if slot = 3 then .inr (mask P (xorTape r₁ f)) else if slot = 4 then .inr (mask P r₂) else .inr (mask P (xorTape r₂ g)) else if kind = 2 then if slot = 0 then .inr (mask P r₀) else .inr (mask P (xorTape r₀ (fun _ => true))) else if slot = 0 then .inl k else if slot = 1 then .inr (mask P r₀) else .inr (mask P (xorTape r₀ (inputPairTape k))) /-- Attach the actual endpoints and edge identifier to a local raw address. -/ def globalize {q : Nat} {V E : Type*} (tail head : V) (edge : E) : RawQuery q → AlphabetGraph.Address V E (Fin q) | .inl (side, tape) => .inl ((if side then head else tail), tape) | .inr tape => .inr (edge, tape) @[simp] theorem mask_idempotent {q : Nat} (P : Fin q → Fin q → Bool) (f : Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) : mask P (mask P f) = mask P f := by funext p cases hp : P p.1 p.2 <;> simp [mask, hp] theorem mask_of_empty {q : Nat} (P : Fin q → Fin q → Bool) (empty : ∀ a b, P a b = false) (f : Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) : mask P f = fun _ => false := by funext p simp [mask, empty] /-- Every joint-table query is already a canonical masked full tape. -/ theorem query_is_masked {q : Nat} (P : Fin q → Fin q → Bool) (event : LocalEvent q) (slot : Fin 6) : match query P event slot with | .inl _ => True | .inr tape => mask P tape = tape := by rcases event with ⟨kind, k, f, g, r₀, r₁, r₂⟩ by_cases hk₀ : kind = 0 <;> by_cases hk₁ : kind = 1 <;> by_cases hk₂ : kind = 2 <;> simp only [query, hk₀, hk₁, hk₂, ite_true, ite_false] <;> split_ifs <;> simp /-- Proof-only comparison map: extend the original legal-coordinate addresses. The executable `query` function above never calls this map. -/ def extendQuery {q : Nat} (P : Fin q → Fin q → Bool) : AlphabetReduction.InputCoordinate (Fin q) ⊕ Cube (AlphabetReduction.LegalPair P) → RawQuery q | .inl k => .inl k | .inr tape => .inr (UniformRestriction.extend (fun p : Fin q × Fin q => P p.1 p.2 = true) tape) /-- Pointwise equality with the existing tester after restricting all five full input tapes and canonically extending the resulting query. The statement does not require any legal pair to exist. -/ theorem query_eq_extend_eventQueries {q : Nat} (P : Fin q → Fin q → Bool) (kind : Fin 4) (k : AlphabetReduction.InputCoordinate (Fin q)) (f g r₀ r₁ r₂ : Cube (Fin q × Fin q)) (slot : Fin 6) : query P (kind, k, f, g, r₀, r₁, r₂) slot = extendQuery P (AssignmentTester.eventQueries (AlphabetReduction.pairEncoding P) kind k (UniformRestriction.restrict (fun p : Fin q × Fin q => P p.1 p.2 = true) f) (UniformRestriction.restrict (fun p : Fin q × Fin q => P p.1 p.2 = true) g) (UniformRestriction.restrict (fun p : Fin q × Fin q => P p.1 p.2 = true) r₀) (UniformRestriction.restrict (fun p : Fin q × Fin q => P p.1 p.2 = true) r₁) (UniformRestriction.restrict (fun p : Fin q × Fin q => P p.1 p.2 = true) r₂) slot) := by by_cases hk₀ : kind = 0 <;> by_cases hk₁ : kind = 1 <;> by_cases hk₂ : kind = 2 <;> simp only [query, AssignmentTester.eventQueries, hk₀, hk₁, hk₂, ite_true, ite_false] all_goals split_ifs <;> simp_all only [extendQuery] all_goals rfl theorem globalize_extendQuery {q : Nat} {V E : Type*} (G : ConstraintGraph V E (Fin q)) (e : E) (x : AlphabetReduction.InputCoordinate (Fin q) ⊕ Cube (AlphabetReduction.LegalPair (G.accepts e))) : globalize (G.tail e) (G.head e) e (extendQuery (G.accepts e) x) = AlphabetGraph.globalizeQuery G e x := by cases x with | inl k => cases k; rfl | inr tape => rfl /-- The executable raw queries are exactly the actual verifier queries after attaching the endpoints and edge tag. This includes self-loops, duplicate queries, empty legal relations, and every original five-tape event. -/ theorem globalize_query {q : Nat} {V E : Type*} (G : ConstraintGraph V E (Fin q)) (e : E) (event : LocalEvent q) (slot : Fin 6) : globalize (G.tail e) (G.head e) e (query (G.accepts e) event slot) = (AlphabetGraph.verifier G).query (e, event) slot := by rcases event with ⟨kind, k, f, g, r₀, r₁, r₂⟩ rw [query_eq_extend_eventQueries] exact globalize_extendQuery G e _ end MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.AlphabetTable.Queries end OAI