import Mathlib import OAI.Computability.MaxCut.Machines.MachineExpanderRowFrames import OAI.Computability.MaxCut.PCP.ExpanderTableEnumeration namespace OAI /-! # Actual execution of all expander-table positions for one vertex The inner loop calls the complete row machine once per fixed cloud/port position. The returned state and the successful machine execution are constructed together. Neither a row execution nor an inner-loop execution is a caller premise. -/ namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderTable open Turing open PCP.ExpanderTables PCP.ExpanderRowControl PCP.ExpanderTableWords open PCP.ExpanderTableEnumeration private def singleStep_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows {α : Type*} (step : α → Option α) (a b : α) (h : step a = some b) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime step a (some b) 1 where steps := 1 evals_in_steps := by change step a = some b; exact h steps_le_m := Nat.le_refl _ private def sequence_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows {α : Type*} {step : α → Option α} {a b c : α} {m n : Nat} (first : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime step a (some b) m) (second : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime step b (some c) n) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime step a (some c) (m + n) := by simpa only [Nat.add_comm n m] using StateTransition.EvalsToInTime.trans step m n a b (some c) first second private def widen_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows {α : Type*} {step : α → Option α} {a : α} {b : Option α} {m n : Nat} (run : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime step a b m) (bound : m ≤ n) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime step a b n where toEvalsTo := run.toEvalsTo steps_le_m := run.steps_le_m.trans bound def tableRowData {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (position : Position d) : MachineExpanderRow.RowData v d := MachineExpanderRow.rowData G H vertex (positionPair position).1 (positionPair position).2 theorem tableRowData_finalValue {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (position : Position d) : (tableRowData G H vertex position).finalValue = rowValue G H vertex position := rfl theorem tableRowData_frame0 {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (position : Position d) (output : List Bool) : MachineExpanderRow.frame0 (tableRowData G H vertex position) output = rowTapes vertex.val (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) output := by funext tape cases tape <;> rfl theorem tableRowData_finalFrame {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (position : Position d) (output : List Bool) : MachineExpanderRow.emittedWord .output (MachineExpanderRow.frame0 (tableRowData G H vertex position) output) (tableRowData G H vertex position).finalValue = rowTapes vertex.val (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) ((encodeWord (rowValue G H vertex position)).reverse ++ output) := by rw [tableRowData_frame0, tableRowData_finalValue] funext tape cases tape <;> simp [MachineExpanderRow.emittedWord, rowTapes] variable {ρ : Type} [Fintype ρ] {v d : Nat} def rowAfterState (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (state : State ρ d) : State ρ d := (MachineExpanderRow.divisionState positive (caller state) (tableRowData G H vertex state.2).control2 none, state.2) omit [Fintype ρ] in @[simp] theorem rowAfterState_position (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (state : State ρ d) : (rowAfterState positive G H vertex state).2 = state.2 := rfl omit [Fintype ρ] in @[simp] theorem caller_rowAfterState (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (state : State ρ d) : caller (rowAfterState positive G H vertex state) = caller state := rfl /-- Preparation and one actual embedded row call, with the two extra tapes retained. The row value is computed from the actual old and small tables. -/ def preparedRowInTime (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (state : State ρ d) (remaining : Nat) (output countSuffix result : List Bool) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (program positive H)) ⟨some (.inr .prepareRow), state, boundaryTapes vertex.val remaining (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) output countSuffix result⟩ (some ⟨some (.inr .afterRow), rowAfterState positive G H vertex state, boundaryTapes vertex.val remaining (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) ((encodeWord (rowValue G H vertex state.2)).reverse ++ output) countSuffix result⟩) (1 + 80 * ((encodeWords (rotationWords G)).length + 1)) := by have raw := rowExecution positive H state.2 (extraTapes remaining countSuffix result) (MachineExpanderRow.rowInTime positive (tableRowData G H vertex state.2) output (caller state)) have run : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (program positive H)) ⟨some (.inl .initialize), prepareState positive H state, boundaryTapes vertex.val remaining (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) output countSuffix result⟩ (some ⟨some (.inr .afterRow), rowAfterState positive G H vertex state, boundaryTapes vertex.val remaining (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) ((encodeWord (rowValue G H vertex state.2)).reverse ++ output) countSuffix result⟩) (80 * ((encodeWords (rotationWords G)).length + 1)) := by rw [tableRowData_finalFrame, tableRowData_frame0] at raw simpa only [MachineEmbedding.configuration, MachineEmbedding.label, rowReturn, prepareState, boundaryState, rowAfterState, boundaryTapes, MachineExpanderRow.RowData.tableLength, MachineExpanderRow.RowData.control0, tableRowData, MachineExpanderRow.rowData] using raw exact sequence_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows (singleStep_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows _ _ _ (prepareRowStep positive H (boundaryTapes vertex.val remaining (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) output countSuffix result) state)) run /-- A successful suffix of the finite position loop, returning actual finite state together with the execution certificate and its preserved caller. -/ structure VertexSuffixRun (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (state : State ρ d) (remaining : Nat) (output countSuffix result : List Bool) where finalState : State ρ d caller_preserved : caller finalState = caller state position_zero : finalState.2 = zeroPosition positive execution : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (program positive H)) ⟨some (.inr .prepareRow), state, boundaryTapes vertex.val remaining (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) output countSuffix result⟩ (some ⟨some (.inr .vertexGuard), finalState, boundaryTapes (vertex.val + 1) remaining (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) (accumulate ((vertexWords G H vertex).drop state.2.val) output) countSuffix result⟩) ((rowFactor d - state.2.val) * (80 * ((encodeWords (rotationWords G)).length + 1) + 2)) private def suffixRun_aux_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (remaining : Nat) (countSuffix result : List Bool) (n : Nat) : (state : State ρ d) → state.2.val + n = rowFactor d → (output : List Bool) → VertexSuffixRun positive G H vertex state remaining output countSuffix result := by induction n with | zero => intro state count output have hp := state.2.isLt exact False.elim (by omega) | succ n ih => intro state count output let after := rowAfterState positive G H vertex state let nextOutput := (encodeWord (rowValue G H vertex state.2)).reverse ++ output have row := preparedRowInTime positive G H vertex state remaining output countSuffix result by_cases last : n = 0 · have hp : state.2.val + 1 = rowFactor d := by omega have finish := singleStep_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows _ _ _ (afterRow_last_boundaryStep positive H vertex.val remaining (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) nextOutput countSuffix result after (by change ¬ state.2.val + 1 < rowFactor d omega)) refine ⟨resetPositionState positive after, ?_, rfl, ?_⟩ · rfl · have all := sequence_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows row finish have words : accumulate ((vertexWords G H vertex).drop state.2.val) output = nextOutput := by rw [vertexWords_drop_last G H vertex state.2 hp] rfl have budget : rowFactor d - state.2.val = 1 := by omega rw [words, budget, Nat.one_mul] exact widen_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows all (by omega) · have more : state.2.val + 1 < rowFactor d := by omega let next := advancePositionState positive after have nextPositionValue : next.2.val = state.2.val + 1 := nextPosition_val_of_lt positive state.2 more have nextCount : next.2.val + n = rowFactor d := by omega let tail := ih next nextCount nextOutput have advance := singleStep_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows _ _ _ (afterRow_moreStep positive H (boundaryTapes vertex.val remaining (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) nextOutput countSuffix result) after more) have all := sequence_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows (sequence_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows row advance) tail.execution refine ⟨tail.finalState, ?_, tail.position_zero, ?_⟩ · exact tail.caller_preserved · have words : accumulate ((vertexWords G H vertex).drop state.2.val) output = accumulate ((vertexWords G H vertex).drop next.2.val) nextOutput := by rw [vertexWords_drop_succ G H vertex state.2, nextPositionValue] rfl rw [words] apply widen_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows all have hcount : rowFactor d - state.2.val = n + 1 := by omega have hnext : rowFactor d - next.2.val = n := by omega rw [hcount, hnext, Nat.add_mul, Nat.one_mul] omega def suffixInTime (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (state : State ρ d) (remaining : Nat) (output countSuffix result : List Bool) : VertexSuffixRun positive G H vertex state remaining output countSuffix result := suffixRun_aux_inline_MachineExpanderTableRows positive G H vertex remaining countSuffix result (rowFactor d - state.2.val) state (by have h := state.2.isLt; omega) output /-- The complete inner loop for one vertex, starting at position zero. -/ structure VertexRun (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (state : State ρ d) (remaining : Nat) (output countSuffix result : List Bool) where finalState : State ρ d caller_preserved : caller finalState = caller state position_zero : finalState.2 = zeroPosition positive execution : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (program positive H)) ⟨some (.inr .prepareRow), state, boundaryTapes vertex.val remaining (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) output countSuffix result⟩ (some ⟨some (.inr .vertexGuard), finalState, boundaryTapes (vertex.val + 1) remaining (encodeWords (rotationWords G)) (accumulate (vertexWords G H vertex) output) countSuffix result⟩) (rowFactor d * (80 * ((encodeWords (rotationWords G)).length + 1) + 2)) def vertexInTime (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex : Fin v) (state : State ρ d) (position : state.2 = zeroPosition positive) (remaining : Nat) (output countSuffix result : List Bool) : VertexRun positive G H vertex state remaining output countSuffix result := by let run := suffixInTime positive G H vertex state remaining output countSuffix result refine ⟨run.finalState, run.caller_preserved, run.position_zero, ?_⟩ have zero : state.2.val = 0 := congrArg Fin.val position simpa only [zero, List.drop_zero, Nat.sub_zero] using run.execution end MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderTable /-! # Actual outer vertex iteration for expander tables The invariant is the reversed unary encoding of all completed vertices. Each positive unary guard invokes the proved complete fixed-position row loop; the zero guard enters the actual output-reversal phase. No execution premise is supplied by the caller. -/ namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderTable open Turing MachineComposition open PCP.ExpanderTables PCP.ExpanderRowControl PCP.ExpanderTableWords open PCP.ExpanderTableEnumeration def oldTableWord {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) : List Bool := encodeWords (rotationWords G) def accumulatedVertices {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (current : Nat) : List Bool := accumulate (priorVertices G H current) [] @[simp] theorem accumulatedVertices_zero {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) : accumulatedVertices G H 0 = [] := by simp [accumulatedVertices, accumulate] theorem accumulatedVertices_succ {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (current : Nat) (valid : current < v) : accumulatedVertices G H (current + 1) = accumulate (vertexWords G H ⟨current, valid⟩) (accumulatedVertices G H current) := by simp only [accumulatedVertices, priorVertices_succ G H current valid, accumulate_append] theorem accumulatedVertices_full {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) : accumulatedVertices G H v = (encodeWords (rotationWords (step G H))).reverse := by simp [accumulatedVertices, accumulate_generatedWords] def vertexBodyBudget {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) : Nat := rowFactor d * (80 * ((oldTableWord G).length + 1) + 2) def vertexLoopBudget {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (remaining : Nat) : Nat := remaining * (vertexBodyBudget G + 1) + 1 def vertexLoopTapes {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (current remaining : Nat) (suffix : List Bool) : ∀ tape, List (Alphabet tape) := boundaryTapes current remaining (oldTableWord G) (accumulatedVertices G H current) suffix [] structure VertexLoopRun {v d : Nat} {ρ : Type} [Fintype ρ] (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (current remaining : Nat) (state : State ρ d) (suffix : List Bool) where finalState : State ρ d caller_preserved : caller finalState = caller state position_zero : finalState.2 = zeroPosition positive execution : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (program positive H)) ⟨some (.inr .vertexGuard), state, vertexLoopTapes G H current remaining suffix⟩ (some ⟨some (.inr .reverseOutput), finalState, vertexLoopTapes G H v 0 suffix⟩) (vertexLoopBudget G remaining) private def boundarySingleStep_inline_MachineExpanderTableLoop {S : Type*} (f : S → Option S) (a b : S) (h : f a = some b) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime f a (some b) 1 where steps := 1 evals_in_steps := by change f a = some b; exact h steps_le_m := Nat.le_refl _ /-- Execute every remaining vertex in the common finite table program. -/ def vertexLoopInTime {v d : Nat} {ρ : Type} [Fintype ρ] (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (current remaining : Nat) (state : State ρ d) (suffix : List Bool) (count : current + remaining = v) (position : state.2 = zeroPosition positive) : VertexLoopRun positive G H current remaining state suffix := by induction remaining generalizing current state with | zero => have hc : current = v := by omega subst current refine ⟨clearRegister state, caller_clearRegister state, ?_, ?_⟩ · simpa only [clearRegister] using position · simpa only [vertexLoopBudget, Nat.zero_mul, Nat.zero_add, vertexLoopTapes] using boundarySingleStep_inline_MachineExpanderTableLoop _ _ _ (vertexGuard_boundary_zeroStep positive H v (oldTableWord G) (accumulatedVertices G H v) suffix [] state) | succ remaining ih => have valid : current < v := by omega let vertex : Fin v := ⟨current, valid⟩ let body := vertexInTime positive G H vertex (clearRegister state) (by simpa only [clearRegister] using position) remaining (accumulatedVertices G H current) suffix [] have nextCount : current + 1 + remaining = v := by omega let rest := ih (current + 1) body.finalState nextCount body.position_zero have output_eq : accumulate (vertexWords G H vertex) (accumulatedVertices G H current) = accumulatedVertices G H (current + 1) := (accumulatedVertices_succ G H current valid).symm let guard := boundarySingleStep_inline_MachineExpanderTableLoop _ _ _ (vertexGuard_boundary_succStep positive H current remaining (oldTableWord G) (accumulatedVertices G H current) suffix [] state) have bodyRun : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (program positive H)) ⟨some (.inr .prepareRow), clearRegister state, boundaryTapes current remaining (oldTableWord G) (accumulatedVertices G H current) suffix []⟩ (some ⟨some (.inr .vertexGuard), body.finalState, vertexLoopTapes G H (current + 1) remaining suffix⟩) (vertexBodyBudget G) := by simpa only [vertexLoopTapes, vertexBodyBudget, oldTableWord, output_eq] using body.execution let first := StateTransition.EvalsToInTime.trans (TM2.step (program positive H)) _ _ _ _ _ guard bodyRun let all := StateTransition.EvalsToInTime.trans (TM2.step (program positive H)) _ _ _ _ _ first rest.execution refine ⟨rest.finalState, ?_, rest.position_zero, ?_⟩ · exact rest.caller_preserved.trans (body.caller_preserved.trans (caller_clearRegister state)) · refine { toEvalsTo := all.toEvalsTo, steps_le_m := ?_ } have bound := all.steps_le_m simp only [vertexLoopBudget, Nat.succ_mul] at bound ⊢ omega end MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderTable namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderTable open Turing open MachineComposition open PCP.ExpanderTables PCP.ExpanderRowControl variable {ρ : Type} {d : Nat} @[simp] theorem clearRegister_position (state : State ρ d) : (clearRegister state).2 = state.2 := rfl @[simp] theorem clearRegister_register (state : State ρ d) : (clearRegister state).1.2 = none := rfl @[simp] theorem clearRegister_idempotent (state : State ρ d) : clearRegister (clearRegister state) = clearRegister state := rfl theorem boundaryTapes_reverse_update (vertex remaining : Nat) (oldTable output countSuffix result nextOutput nextResult : List Bool) : Function.update (Function.update (boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable output countSuffix result) (.inl .output) nextOutput) (.inr .result) nextResult = boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable nextOutput countSuffix nextResult := by funext tape rcases tape with row | extra · cases row <;> simp [boundaryTapes, rowTapes, MachineEmbedding.tapes, Function.update] · cases extra <;> simp [boundaryTapes, extraTapes, MachineEmbedding.tapes, Function.update] variable [Fintype ρ] /-- Exact execution of the entire final reverse loop, including its empty test. No reversal-execution hypothesis is assumed. -/ theorem reverseOutputTrace (positive : 0 < d) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex remaining : Nat) (oldTable output countSuffix result : List Bool) (state : State ρ d) : (advance (TM2.step (program positive H)))^[output.length + 1] (some ⟨some (.inr .reverseOutput), state, boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable output countSuffix result⟩) = some ⟨some (.inr .done), clearRegister state, boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable [] countSuffix (output.reverse ++ result)⟩ := by induction output generalizing result state with | nil => simpa only [List.length_nil, Nat.zero_add, Function.iterate_one, advance_some, List.reverse_nil, List.nil_append] using reverseOutput_nilStep positive H (boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable [] countSuffix result) state rfl | cons symbol output ih => rw [List.length_cons, Function.iterate_succ_apply] simp only [advance_some] rw [reverseOutput_consStep positive H (boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable (symbol :: output) countSuffix result) state symbol output rfl] change (advance (TM2.step (program positive H)))^[output.length + 1] (some ⟨some (.inr .reverseOutput), ((state.1.1, some symbol), state.2), Function.update (Function.update (boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable (symbol :: output) countSuffix result) (.inl .output) output) (.inr .result) (symbol :: result)⟩) = _ rw [boundaryTapes_reverse_update] simpa only [clearRegister, List.reverse_cons, List.append_assoc, List.singleton_append] using ih (symbol :: result) ((state.1.1, some symbol), state.2) /-- The actual `done` statement halts one transition after reversal completes. -/ theorem reverseOutputHaltTrace (positive : 0 < d) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex remaining : Nat) (oldTable output countSuffix result : List Bool) (state : State ρ d) : (advance (TM2.step (program positive H)))^[output.length + 2] (some ⟨some (.inr .reverseOutput), state, boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable output countSuffix result⟩) = some ⟨none, clearRegister state, boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable [] countSuffix (output.reverse ++ result)⟩ := by rw [show output.length + 2 = (output.length + 1) + 1 by omega, Function.iterate_succ_apply', reverseOutputTrace positive H vertex remaining oldTable output countSuffix result state] exact doneStep positive H (boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable [] countSuffix (output.reverse ++ result)) (clearRegister state) def reverseOutputInTime (positive : 0 < d) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex remaining : Nat) (oldTable output countSuffix result : List Bool) (state : State ρ d) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (program positive H)) ⟨some (.inr .reverseOutput), state, boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable output countSuffix result⟩ (some ⟨some (.inr .done), clearRegister state, boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable [] countSuffix (output.reverse ++ result)⟩) (output.length + 1) where steps := output.length + 1 evals_in_steps := reverseOutputTrace positive H vertex remaining oldTable output countSuffix result state steps_le_m := Nat.le_refl _ def reverseOutputHaltInTime (positive : 0 < d) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (vertex remaining : Nat) (oldTable output countSuffix result : List Bool) (state : State ρ d) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (program positive H)) ⟨some (.inr .reverseOutput), state, boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable output countSuffix result⟩ (some ⟨none, clearRegister state, boundaryTapes vertex remaining oldTable [] countSuffix (output.reverse ++ result)⟩) (output.length + 2) where steps := output.length + 2 evals_in_steps := reverseOutputHaltTrace positive H vertex remaining oldTable output countSuffix result state steps_le_m := Nat.le_refl _ end MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderTable /-! # Complete finite machine execution for the next expander table The initialized old table and unary vertex count are consumed by one actual finite program. The machine writes precisely the complete square/zigzag rotation table, preserving its old table and all promised framing. The bound is quadratic in the unary old-table length for each fixed small graph. -/ namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderTable open Turing MachineComposition open PCP.ExpanderTables PCP.ExpanderRowControl PCP.ExpanderTableWords open PCP.ExpanderTableEnumeration def completeBudget {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) : Nat := 1 + vertexLoopBudget G v + ((encodeWords (rotationWords (step G H))).length + 2) def timeCoefficient (d : Nat) : Nat := rowFactor d * (rowFactor d + 1) + 82 * rowFactor d + 5 noncomputable def timePolynomial (d : Nat) : Polynomial Nat := Polynomial.C (timeCoefficient d) * (Polynomial.X + 1) ^ 2 theorem vertices_le_word_length {v d : Nat} (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) : v ≤ (oldTableWord G).length := by have hq : 1 ≤ degree d := Nat.mul_pos positive positive have hv : v ≤ v * degree d := by simpa using Nat.mul_le_mul_left v hq have hr : v * degree d ≤ (oldTableWord G).length := by simp only [oldTableWord, encodeWords_length, rotationWords_length] omega exact hv.trans hr /-- All actual loop, row, and final reversal costs are bounded quadratically. -/ theorem completeBudget_le {v d : Nat} (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) : completeBudget G H ≤ (timePolynomial d).eval (oldTableWord G).length := by let L := (oldTableWord G).length let M := rowFactor d have vBound : v ≤ L + 1 := (vertices_le_word_length positive G).trans (Nat.le_succ L) have emitBound : 80 * (L + 1) + 2 ≤ 82 * (L + 1) := by omega have bodyBound : vertexBodyBudget G + 1 ≤ (82 * M + 1) * (L + 1) := by have mulBound := Nat.mul_le_mul_left M emitBound change M * (80 * (L + 1) + 2) + 1 ≤ _ nlinarith have iterations := Nat.mul_le_mul vBound bodyBound have loopBound : v * (vertexBodyBudget G + 1) ≤ (82 * M + 1) * (L + 1)^2 := by calc _ ≤ (L + 1) * ((82 * M + 1) * (L + 1)) := iterations _ = _ := by ring have rowBound : v * M ≤ M * (L + 1) := by simpa only [Nat.mul_comm v M] using Nat.mul_le_mul_left M vBound have rowSuccBound : v * M + 1 ≤ (M + 1) * (L + 1) := by nlinarith have productBound := Nat.mul_le_mul rowBound rowSuccBound have lengthBound : (encodeWords (rotationWords (step G H))).length ≤ M * (M + 1) * (L + 1)^2 := by calc _ ≤ (v * M) * (v * M + 1) := by simpa only [generatedWords_eq_rotationWords] using encode_generatedWords_length_le G H _ ≤ (M * (L + 1)) * ((M + 1) * (L + 1)) := productBound _ = _ := by ring have oneBound : 1 ≤ (L + 1)^2 := by nlinarith have combined := Nat.add_le_add loopBound lengthBound simp only [timePolynomial, Polynomial.eval_mul, Polynomial.eval_C, Polynomial.eval_pow, Polynomial.eval_add, Polynomial.eval_X, Polynomial.eval_one] change completeBudget G H ≤ (M * (M + 1) + 82 * M + 5) * (L + 1)^2 unfold completeBudget vertexLoopBudget nlinarith structure TableRun {v d : Nat} {ρ : Type} [Fintype ρ] (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (state : State ρ d) (suffix : List Bool) where finalState : State ρ d caller_preserved : caller finalState = caller state position_zero : finalState.2 = zeroPosition positive execution : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (program positive H)) ⟨some (.inr .initialize), state, initialTapes v (oldTableWord G) suffix⟩ (some ⟨none, finalState, finalTapes v (oldTableWord G) (encodeWords (rotationWords (step G H))) suffix⟩) ((timePolynomial d).eval (oldTableWord G).length) private def initializeInTime_inline_MachineExpanderTable {v d : Nat} {ρ : Type} [Fintype ρ] (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (state : State ρ d) (suffix : List Bool) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (program positive H)) ⟨some (.inr .initialize), state, initialTapes v (oldTableWord G) suffix⟩ (some ⟨some (.inr .vertexGuard), initialState positive H (caller state), vertexLoopTapes G H 0 v suffix⟩) 1 where steps := 1 evals_in_steps := by change TM2.step (program (ρ := ρ) positive H) ⟨some (.inr .initialize), state, initialTapes v (oldTableWord G) suffix⟩ = some ⟨some (.inr .vertexGuard), initialState positive H (caller state), vertexLoopTapes G H 0 v suffix⟩ simpa only [vertexLoopTapes, accumulatedVertices_zero] using initialize_boundaryStep positive H v (oldTableWord G) suffix state steps_le_m := Nat.le_refl _ /-- Construct the entire table execution from its actual initialized inputs. No row trace, loop trace, or abstract computational witness is a hypothesis. -/ def tableInTime {v d : Nat} {ρ : Type} [Fintype ρ] (positive : 0 < d) (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (state : State ρ d) (suffix : List Bool) : TableRun positive G H state suffix := by let loop := vertexLoopInTime positive G H 0 v (initialState positive H (caller state)) suffix (by omega) rfl let initialRun := initializeInTime_inline_MachineExpanderTable positive G H state suffix have finish : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (program positive H)) ⟨some (.inr .reverseOutput), loop.finalState, vertexLoopTapes G H v 0 suffix⟩ (some ⟨none, clearRegister loop.finalState, finalTapes v (oldTableWord G) (encodeWords (rotationWords (step G H))) suffix⟩) ((encodeWords (rotationWords (step G H))).length + 2) := by simpa only [vertexLoopTapes, finalTapes, accumulatedVertices_full, List.reverse_reverse, List.append_nil, List.length_reverse] using reverseOutputHaltInTime positive H v 0 (oldTableWord G) (accumulatedVertices G H v) suffix [] loop.finalState let first := StateTransition.EvalsToInTime.trans (TM2.step (program positive H)) _ _ _ _ _ initialRun loop.execution let all := StateTransition.EvalsToInTime.trans (TM2.step (program positive H)) _ _ _ _ _ first finish refine ⟨clearRegister loop.finalState, ?_, ?_, ?_⟩ · exact (caller_clearRegister loop.finalState).trans loop.caller_preserved · simpa only [clearRegister] using loop.position_zero · refine { toEvalsTo := all.toEvalsTo, steps_le_m := ?_ } have bound := all.steps_le_m have polynomialBound := completeBudget_le positive G H unfold completeBudget at polynomialBound omega end MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderTable namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderFamily open PCP.ExpanderTables PCP.ExpanderRowControl PCP.ExpanderTableWords /-- The six nonempty tape roles that may occur between expansion phases. -/ def cycleWords (remaining : Nat) (word current vertex count result suffix : List Bool) : Tape → List Bool | .inl (.inl .table) => word | .inl (.inl .inputVertex) => vertex | .inl (.inr .vertexCount) => count | .inl (.inr .result) => result | .inr .remainingLevel => encodeWord remaining ++ suffix | .inr .currentSize => current | _ => [] def cycleTapes (remaining : Nat) (word current vertex count result suffix : List Bool) : (tape : Tape) → List (Alphabet tape) := fromBoolTapes (cycleWords remaining word current vertex count result suffix) @[simp] theorem toBool_cycleTapes (remaining : Nat) (word current vertex count result suffix : List Bool) : toBoolTapes (cycleTapes remaining word current vertex count result suffix) = cycleWords remaining word current vertex count result suffix := toBool_fromBool _ theorem boundaryTapes_eq_cycleTapes (remaining current : Nat) (word suffix : List Bool) : boundaryTapes remaining current word suffix = cycleTapes remaining word (encodeWord current) [] [] [] suffix := by funext tape rcases tape with tape | tape · rcases tape with row | extra · cases row <;> rfl · cases extra <;> rfl · cases tape <;> rfl def copyFrame (remaining current : Nat) (word suffix : List Bool) : (tape : Tape) → List (Alphabet tape) := MachineEmbedding.tapes (MachineExpanderTable.initialTapes current word []) (extraFrame remaining current suffix) def returnFrame (remaining current : Nat) (oldWord newWord suffix : List Bool) : (tape : Tape) → List (Alphabet tape) := MachineEmbedding.tapes (MachineExpanderTable.finalTapes current oldWord newWord []) (extraFrame remaining current suffix) def installedFrame (remaining current : Nat) (newWord suffix : List Bool) : (tape : Tape) → List (Alphabet tape) := cycleTapes remaining newWord [] (encodeWord current) (encodeWord 0) [] suffix def multipliedFrame (d remaining current : Nat) (newWord suffix : List Bool) : (tape : Tape) → List (Alphabet tape) := cycleTapes remaining newWord (encodeWord (cloudSize d * current)) (encodeWord current) (encodeWord 0) [] suffix theorem copyFrame_eq_cycleTapes (remaining current : Nat) (word suffix : List Bool) : copyFrame remaining current word suffix = cycleTapes remaining word (encodeWord current) [] (encodeWord current) [] suffix := by funext tape rcases tape with tape | tape · rcases tape with row | extra · cases row <;> rfl · cases extra <;> simp [copyFrame, MachineEmbedding.tapes, MachineExpanderTable.initialTapes, MachineExpanderTable.extraTapes, cycleTapes, fromBoolTapes, boolWord, cycleWords] · cases tape <;> rfl theorem returnFrame_eq_cycleTapes (remaining current : Nat) (oldWord newWord suffix : List Bool) : returnFrame remaining current oldWord newWord suffix = cycleTapes remaining oldWord (encodeWord current) (encodeWord current) (encodeWord 0) newWord suffix := by funext tape rcases tape with tape | tape · rcases tape with row | extra · cases row <;> rfl · cases extra <;> simp [returnFrame, MachineEmbedding.tapes, MachineExpanderTable.finalTapes, MachineExpanderTable.boundaryTapes, MachineExpanderTable.extraTapes, cycleTapes, fromBoolTapes, boolWord, cycleWords] · cases tape <;> rfl theorem copyFrame_eq_update (remaining current : Nat) (word suffix : List Bool) : Function.update (boundaryTapes remaining current word suffix) vertexCountTape (encodeWord current) = copyFrame remaining current word suffix := by rw [boundaryTapes_eq_cycleTapes, copyFrame_eq_cycleTapes] funext tape rcases tape with tape | tape · rcases tape with row | extra · cases row <;> rfl · cases extra <;> rfl · cases tape <;> rfl theorem multipliedFrame_eq_update (d remaining current : Nat) (word suffix : List Bool) : Function.update (installedFrame remaining current word suffix) (.inr .currentSize) (encodeWord (cloudSize d * current)) = multipliedFrame d remaining current word suffix := by funext tape rcases tape with tape | tape · rcases tape with row | extra · cases row <;> rfl · cases extra <;> rfl · cases tape <;> rfl end MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderFamily /-! # Bounds for materializing the actual expander family The costs use the encoded old and new rotation tables, and the already checked table-machine polynomial. The finite sum follows the actual recursive table family. These arithmetic lemmas introduce no execution assumptions and make no claim that the output is polynomial in an isolated binary level parameter. -/ namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderFamilyBounds open PCP.ExpanderTables PCP.ExpanderRowControl PCP.ExpanderTableWords noncomputable def resizeCost {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) : Nat := (MachineExpanderTable.timePolynomial d).eval (MachineExpanderTable.oldTableWord G).length + 6 * v + (MachineExpanderTable.oldTableWord G).length + 2 * (encodeWords (rotationWords (step G H))).length + 15 def resizeCoefficient (d : Nat) : Nat := MachineExpanderTable.timeCoefficient d * (degree d + 1) ^ 4 + 3 * (degree d + 1) ^ 2 + 21 /-- The complete unary encoding, including every word delimiter, is counted. -/ theorem wordLength_add_one_le {v q N : Nat} (G : Table v q) (hv : v ≤ N) : (encodeWords (rotationWords G)).length + 1 ≤ (q + 1)^2 * (N + 1)^2 := by have hlength := encode_rotationWords_length_le G have hrow : v * q + 1 ≤ (q + 1) * (N + 1) := by have h := Nat.mul_le_mul_right q hv nlinarith calc _ ≤ (v * q + 1)^2 := by nlinarith _ ≤ ((q + 1) * (N + 1))^2 := Nat.pow_le_pow_left hrow 2 _ = _ := by ring theorem resizeCost_le {v d : Nat} (G : Table v (degree d)) (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (N : Nat) (hv : v ≤ N) (hnext : v * cloudSize d ≤ N) : resizeCost G H ≤ resizeCoefficient d * (N + 1)^4 := by let oldL := (MachineExpanderTable.oldTableWord G).length let newL := (encodeWords (rotationWords (step G H))).length have oldBound : oldL + 1 ≤ (degree d + 1)^2 * (N + 1)^2 := wordLength_add_one_le G hv have newBound : newL + 1 ≤ (degree d + 1)^2 * (N + 1)^2 := wordLength_add_one_le (step G H) hnext have timeBound : (MachineExpanderTable.timePolynomial d).eval oldL ≤ MachineExpanderTable.timeCoefficient d * (degree d + 1)^4 * (N + 1)^4 := by simp only [MachineExpanderTable.timePolynomial, Polynomial.eval_mul, Polynomial.eval_C, Polynomial.eval_pow, Polynomial.eval_add, Polynomial.eval_X, Polynomial.eval_one] calc _ ≤ MachineExpanderTable.timeCoefficient d * ((degree d + 1)^2 * (N + 1)^2)^2 := Nat.mul_le_mul_left _ (Nat.pow_le_pow_left oldBound 2) _ = _ := by ring have pow24 : (N + 1)^2 ≤ (N + 1)^4 := Nat.pow_le_pow_right (Nat.succ_pos N) (by decide) have overheadBound : oldL + 2 * newL ≤ 3 * (degree d + 1)^2 * (N + 1)^4 := by have h := Nat.mul_le_mul_left ((degree d + 1)^2) pow24 calc _ ≤ 3 * ((degree d + 1)^2 * (N + 1)^2) := by omega _ ≤ 3 * ((degree d + 1)^2 * (N + 1)^4) := Nat.mul_le_mul_left 3 h _ = _ := by ring have npow : N + 1 ≤ (N + 1)^4 := by simpa only [pow_one] using Nat.pow_le_pow_right (Nat.succ_pos N) (show 1 ≤ 4 by decide) have linearBound : 6 * v + 15 ≤ 21 * (N + 1)^4 := by omega change (MachineExpanderTable.timePolynomial d).eval oldL + 6 * v + oldL + 2 * newL + 15 ≤ _ unfold resizeCoefficient nlinarith only [timeBound, overheadBound, linearBound] theorem vertexCount_monotone {q : Nat} (positive : 0 < q) : Monotone (vertexCount q) := by intro m n hmn rw [vertexCount_eq, vertexCount_eq] exact Nat.pow_le_pow_right (Nat.mul_pos positive positive) hmn theorem level_le_vertexCount {q : Nat} (growth : 1 < q * q) (level : Nat) : level ≤ vertexCount q level := by have positive : 0 < q := by nlinarith induction level with | zero => exact Nat.zero_le _ | succ level ih => have hpos := vertexCount_positive positive level have hmul := Nat.mul_le_mul_left (vertexCount q level) (show 2 ≤ q * q by omega) change level + 1 ≤ vertexCount q level * (q * q) nlinarith noncomputable def resizeSum {d : Nat} (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (level : Nat) : Nat := ∑ i ∈ Finset.range level, resizeCost (family H i) H @[simp] theorem resizeSum_zero {d : Nat} (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) : resizeSum H 0 = 0 := by simp [resizeSum] theorem resizeSum_succ {d : Nat} (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (level : Nat) : resizeSum H (level + 1) = resizeSum H level + resizeCost (family H level) H := by simp only [resizeSum, Finset.sum_range_succ] theorem resizeSum_add {d : Nat} (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (start count : Nat) : resizeSum H (start + count) = resizeSum H start + ∑ i ∈ Finset.range count, resizeCost (family H (start + i)) H := Finset.sum_range_add (fun i => resizeCost (family H i) H) start count noncomputable def familyBudget {d : Nat} (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (level : Nat) : Nat := resizeSum H level + level + 3 @[simp] theorem familyBudget_zero {d : Nat} (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) : familyBudget H 0 = 3 := by simp [familyBudget] theorem familyBudget_succ {d : Nat} (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (level : Nat) : familyBudget H (level + 1) = familyBudget H level + resizeCost (family H level) H + 1 := by simp only [familyBudget, resizeSum_succ] omega theorem resizeSum_le {d : Nat} (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (growth : 1 < cloudSize d) (level : Nat) : resizeSum H level ≤ resizeCoefficient d * (vertexCount (degree d) level + 1)^5 := by let N := vertexCount (degree d) level have positive : 0 < degree d := by have h : 1 < degree d * degree d := growth nlinarith have hmono := vertexCount_monotone positive have hlevel : level ≤ N := level_le_vertexCount growth level have eachBound : ∀ i ∈ Finset.range level, resizeCost (family H i) H ≤ resizeCoefficient d * (N + 1)^4 := by intro i hi have hi' : i < level := Finset.mem_range.mp hi apply resizeCost_le (family H i) H N · exact hmono (by omega) · exact hmono (show i + 1 ≤ level by omega) have sumBound : resizeSum H level ≤ level * (resizeCoefficient d * (N + 1)^4) := by calc _ ≤ ∑ _i ∈ Finset.range level, resizeCoefficient d * (N + 1)^4 := Finset.sum_le_sum eachBound _ = _ := by simp calc _ ≤ level * (resizeCoefficient d * (N + 1)^4) := sumBound _ ≤ (N + 1) * (resizeCoefficient d * (N + 1)^4) := Nat.mul_le_mul_right _ (hlevel.trans (Nat.le_succ N)) _ = _ := by ring /-- All actual resize costs plus the counted-loop overhead. -/ theorem familyBudget_le {d : Nat} (H : Table (cloudSize d) d) (growth : 1 < cloudSize d) (level : Nat) : familyBudget H level ≤ (resizeCoefficient d + 4) * (vertexCount (degree d) level + 1)^5 := by have hsum := resizeSum_le H growth level have hlevel := level_le_vertexCount growth level have hpow : vertexCount (degree d) level + 1 ≤ (vertexCount (degree d) level + 1)^5 := by simpa only [pow_one] using Nat.pow_le_pow_right (Nat.succ_pos (vertexCount (degree d) level)) (show 1 ≤ 5 by decide) have overhead : level + 3 ≤ 4 * (vertexCount (degree d) level + 1)^5 := by omega unfold familyBudget nlinarith only [hsum, overhead] theorem paddedSize_le_succ_input (k : Nat) : PCP.PreprocessingLevels.paddedSize k ≤ PCP.ExpanderFamily.growth * (k + 1) := by by_cases hk : k = 0 · subst k have h := PCP.ExpanderFamily.growth_gt_one simp only [PCP.PreprocessingLevels.paddedSize_zero, Nat.zero_add, Nat.mul_one] omega · exact (PCP.PreprocessingLevels.paddedSize_bounds (Nat.pos_of_ne_zero hk)).2.trans (Nat.mul_le_mul_left _ (Nat.le_succ k)) def inputCoefficient : Nat := (resizeCoefficient PCP.Expanders.baseDegree + 4) * (PCP.ExpanderFamily.growth + 1)^5 /-- For the fixed base graph, the bounded padding level has a polynomial cost in the requested unary size, including size zero. -/ theorem familyBudget_at_boundedLevel_le (H : Table (cloudSize PCP.Expanders.baseDegree) PCP.Expanders.baseDegree) (k : Nat) : familyBudget H (PCP.PreprocessingLevels.boundedLevel k) ≤ inputCoefficient * (k + 1)^5 := by have hg : cloudSize PCP.Expanders.baseDegree = PCP.ExpanderFamily.growth := by unfold cloudSize degree PCP.ExpanderFamily.growth ring have growth : 1 < cloudSize PCP.Expanders.baseDegree := by rw [hg] exact PCP.ExpanderFamily.growth_gt_one have bound := familyBudget_le H growth (PCP.PreprocessingLevels.boundedLevel k) rw [PCP.PreprocessingLevels.table_vertexCount_eq_paddedSize] at bound have sizeBound : PCP.PreprocessingLevels.paddedSize k + 1 ≤ (PCP.ExpanderFamily.growth + 1) * (k + 1) := by have h := paddedSize_le_succ_input k nlinarith calc _ ≤ (resizeCoefficient PCP.Expanders.baseDegree + 4) * (PCP.PreprocessingLevels.paddedSize k + 1)^5 := bound _ ≤ (resizeCoefficient PCP.Expanders.baseDegree + 4) * ((PCP.ExpanderFamily.growth + 1) * (k + 1))^5 := Nat.mul_le_mul_left _ (Nat.pow_le_pow_left sizeBound 5) _ = _ := by unfold inputCoefficient; ring end MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineExpanderFamilyBounds end OAI