import Mathlib import OAI.Computability.MaxCut.Machines.MachineLookupCore namespace OAI namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.Hastad.SourceFieldArray open Turing open MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity SourceMachine variable {K Λ σ : Type} [DecidableEq K] def finish (source : K) (exit : Option Λ) : TM2.Stmt (Alphabet (K := K)) Λ (σ × Option Bool) := .load (fun state => (state.1, none)) (Reduction.MachineTransfer.exitAt source exit) theorem finishStep (source : K) (label : Λ) (exit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet (K := K)) Λ (σ × Option Bool)) (atFinish : program label = finish source exit) (base : K → List Bool) (ambient : σ) (register : Option Bool) : TM2.step program ⟨some label, (ambient, register), base⟩ = some ⟨exit, (ambient, none), base⟩ := by change some (TM2.stepAux (program label) (ambient, register) base) = _ rw [atFinish] cases exit <;> simp [finish, Reduction.MachineTransfer.exitAt, TM2.stepAux] /-- Exact successive stack updates, in the original field order. -/ def sequenceTapes (source : K) (destination : Nat → K) (base : K → List Bool) (offset : Nat) (values : List Nat) (suffix : List Bool) : K → List Bool := match values with | [] => base | n :: rest => sequenceTapes source destination (afterField source (destination offset) base n (encodeWords rest ++ suffix)) (offset + 1) rest suffix /-- The trace is built from the actual single-field transitions. The only program premises identify the finitely many statements used by this record. -/ theorem sequenceTrace (source : K) (destination : Nat → K) (start loopLabel : Nat → Λ) (exit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet (K := K)) Λ (σ × Option Bool)) (base : K → List Bool) (offset : Nat) (values : List Nat) (suffix : List Bool) (hsep : ∀ r, r < values.length → source ≠ destination (offset + r)) (atStart : ∀ r, r < values.length → program (start (offset + r)) = fieldStart (destination (offset + r)) (loopLabel (offset + r))) (atLoop : ∀ r, r < values.length → program (loopLabel (offset + r)) = fieldLoop source (destination (offset + r)) (loopLabel (offset + r)) (some (start (offset + r + 1)))) (atDone : program (start (offset + values.length)) = finish source exit) (hinput : base source = encodeWords values ++ suffix) (ambient : σ) (register : Option Bool) : (MachineComposition.advance (TM2.step program))^[values.sum + 2 * values.length + 1] (some ⟨some (start offset), (ambient, register), base⟩) = some ⟨exit, (ambient, none), sequenceTapes source destination base offset values suffix⟩ := by induction values generalizing offset base register with | nil => simpa only [List.sum_nil, List.length_nil, Nat.mul_zero, Nat.zero_add, Nat.add_zero, Function.iterate_one, MachineComposition.advance_some, sequenceTapes] using finishStep source (start offset) exit program atDone base ambient register | cons n rest ih => have hr0 : 0 < (n :: rest).length := by simp have hsep0 : source ≠ destination offset := by simpa using hsep 0 hr0 have hs0 : program (start offset) = fieldStart (destination offset) (loopLabel offset) := by simpa using atStart 0 hr0 have hl0 : program (loopLabel offset) = fieldLoop source (destination offset) (loopLabel offset) (some (start (offset + 1))) := by simpa using atLoop 0 hr0 have hin : base source = encodeWord n ++ (encodeWords rest ++ suffix) := by simpa only [encodeWords, List.append_assoc] using hinput let nextBase := afterField source (destination offset) base n (encodeWords rest ++ suffix) have hfirst := (fieldInTime source (destination offset) hsep0 (start offset) (loopLabel offset) (some (start (offset + 1))) program hs0 hl0 base n (encodeWords rest ++ suffix) hin ambient register).evals_in_steps change (MachineComposition.advance (TM2.step program))^[n + 2] (some ⟨some (start offset), (ambient, register), base⟩) = some ⟨some (start (offset + 1)), (ambient, none), nextBase⟩ at hfirst have hsep' : ∀ r, r < rest.length → source ≠ destination (offset + 1 + r) := by intro r hr simpa [Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using hsep (r + 1) (by simp; omega) have hs' : ∀ r, r < rest.length → program (start (offset + 1 + r)) = fieldStart (destination (offset + 1 + r)) (loopLabel (offset + 1 + r)) := by intro r hr simpa [Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using atStart (r + 1) (by simp; omega) have hl' : ∀ r, r < rest.length → program (loopLabel (offset + 1 + r)) = fieldLoop source (destination (offset + 1 + r)) (loopLabel (offset + 1 + r)) (some (start (offset + 1 + r + 1))) := by intro r hr simpa [Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using atLoop (r + 1) (by simp; omega) have hd' : program (start (offset + 1 + rest.length)) = finish source exit := by simpa [Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using atDone have hin' : nextBase source = encodeWords rest ++ suffix := by simp [nextBase, afterField, hsep0] rw [show (n :: rest).sum + 2 * (n :: rest).length + 1 = (rest.sum + 2 * rest.length + 1) + (n + 2) by simp; omega] rw [Function.iterate_add_apply, hfirst, ih nextBase (offset + 1) hsep' hs' hl' hd' hin' none] rfl def sequenceInTime (source : K) (destination : Nat → K) (start loopLabel : Nat → Λ) (exit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet (K := K)) Λ (σ × Option Bool)) (base : K → List Bool) (offset : Nat) (values : List Nat) (suffix : List Bool) (hsep : ∀ r, r < values.length → source ≠ destination (offset + r)) (atStart : ∀ r, r < values.length → program (start (offset + r)) = fieldStart (destination (offset + r)) (loopLabel (offset + r))) (atLoop : ∀ r, r < values.length → program (loopLabel (offset + r)) = fieldLoop source (destination (offset + r)) (loopLabel (offset + r)) (some (start (offset + r + 1)))) (atDone : program (start (offset + values.length)) = finish source exit) (hinput : base source = encodeWords values ++ suffix) (ambient : σ) (register : Option Bool) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step program) ⟨some (start offset), (ambient, register), base⟩ (some ⟨exit, (ambient, none), sequenceTapes source destination base offset values suffix⟩) (values.sum + 2 * values.length + 1) where steps := values.sum + 2 * values.length + 1 evals_in_steps := sequenceTrace source destination start loopLabel exit program base offset values suffix hsep atStart atLoop atDone hinput ambient register steps_le_m := Nat.le_refl _ theorem sequence_time_eq_length (values : List Nat) : values.sum + 2 * values.length + 1 = (encodeWords values).length + values.length + 1 := by rw [encodeWords_length] omega theorem sequenceTapes_other (source : K) (destination : Nat → K) (p : K) (hpS : p ≠ source) (base : K → List Bool) (offset : Nat) (values : List Nat) (suffix : List Bool) (hpD : ∀ r, r < values.length → p ≠ destination (offset + r)) : sequenceTapes source destination base offset values suffix p = base p := by induction values generalizing base offset with | nil => rfl | cons n rest ih => have hp0 : p ≠ destination offset := by simpa using hpD 0 (by simp) have htail : ∀ r, r < rest.length → p ≠ destination (offset + 1 + r) := by intro r hr simpa [Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using hpD (r + 1) (by simp; omega) rw [sequenceTapes, ih _ (offset + 1) htail] exact fieldTapes_other source (destination offset) p hpS hp0 _ _ _ theorem sequenceTapes_source (source : K) (destination : Nat → K) (base : K → List Bool) (offset : Nat) (values : List Nat) (suffix : List Bool) (hsep : ∀ r, r < values.length → source ≠ destination (offset + r)) (hinput : base source = encodeWords values ++ suffix) : sequenceTapes source destination base offset values suffix source = suffix := by induction values generalizing base offset with | nil => simpa [sequenceTapes, encodeWords] using hinput | cons n rest ih => have hsep0 : source ≠ destination offset := by simpa using hsep 0 (by simp) have htail : ∀ r, r < rest.length → source ≠ destination (offset + 1 + r) := by intro r hr simpa [Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using hsep (r + 1) (by simp; omega) apply ih _ (offset + 1) htail simp [afterField, hsep0] /-- Distinct field destinations contain exactly their own encoded value. -/ theorem sequenceTapes_selected (source : K) (destination : Nat → K) (base : K → List Bool) (offset : Nat) (values : List Nat) (suffix : List Bool) (j : Nat) (hj : j < values.length) (hsep : ∀ r, r < values.length → source ≠ destination (offset + r)) (hdist : ∀ r s, r < values.length → s < values.length → destination (offset + r) = destination (offset + s) → r = s) : sequenceTapes source destination base offset values suffix (destination (offset + j)) = encodeWord (values[j]'hj) ++ base (destination (offset + j)) := by induction values generalizing base offset j with | nil => simp at hj | cons n rest ih => have hsep0 : source ≠ destination offset := by simpa using hsep 0 (by simp) let nextBase := afterField source (destination offset) base n (encodeWords rest ++ suffix) cases j with | zero => have hframe : ∀ r, r < rest.length → destination offset ≠ destination (offset + 1 + r) := by intro r hr heq have hh := hdist 0 (r + 1) (by simp) (by simp; omega) (by simpa [Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using heq) omega simp only [sequenceTapes, Nat.add_zero, List.getElem_cons_zero] rw [sequenceTapes_other source destination (destination offset) hsep0.symm _ (offset + 1) rest suffix hframe] simp [afterField] | succ j => have hj' : j < rest.length := by simpa using hj have hsep' : ∀ r, r < rest.length → source ≠ destination (offset + 1 + r) := by intro r hr simpa [Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using hsep (r + 1) (by simp; omega) have hdist' : ∀ r s, r < rest.length → s < rest.length → destination (offset + 1 + r) = destination (offset + 1 + s) → r = s := by intro r s hr hs heq have hh := hdist (r + 1) (s + 1) (by simp; omega) (by simp; omega) (by simpa [Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using heq) omega have hsrc : destination (offset + 1 + j) ≠ source := (hsep' j hj').symm have hdst : destination (offset + 1 + j) ≠ destination offset := by intro heq have hh := hdist (j + 1) 0 hj (by simp) (by simpa [Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using heq) omega have hkeep : nextBase (destination (offset + 1 + j)) = base (destination (offset + 1 + j)) := fieldTapes_other source (destination offset) _ hsrc hdst _ _ _ simp only [sequenceTapes, List.getElem_cons_succ] rw [show offset + (j + 1) = offset + 1 + j by omega] rw [ih _ (offset + 1) j hj' hsep' hdist'] exact congrArg (encodeWord rest[j] ++ ·) hkeep /-- Extend finite indices harmlessly outside the range used by the machine. -/ def boundedIndex (q j : Nat) : Fin (q + 1) := ⟨min j q, by omega⟩ @[simp] theorem boundedIndex_val {q j : Nat} (hj : j ≤ q) : (boundedIndex q j).val = j := Nat.min_eq_left hj def destination (q j : Nat) : Fin (q + 1) := boundedIndex q (j + 1) def startLabel (q j : Nat) : Fin (q + 1) × Bool := (boundedIndex q j, false) def loopLabel (q j : Nat) : Fin (q + 1) × Bool := (boundedIndex q j, true) theorem destination_ne_source (q r : Nat) (hr : r < q) : (0 : Fin (q + 1)) ≠ destination q r := by intro heq have hh := congrArg Fin.val heq simp only [destination, boundedIndex_val (Nat.succ_le_iff.mpr hr)] at hh change 0 = r + 1 at hh omega theorem destination_injective_below (q r s : Nat) (hr : r < q) (hs : s < q) (heq : destination q r = destination q s) : r = s := by have hh := congrArg Fin.val heq simp only [destination, boundedIndex_val (Nat.succ_le_iff.mpr hr), boundedIndex_val (Nat.succ_le_iff.mpr hs)] at hh omega @[simp] theorem destination_eq_succ {q : Nat} (j : Fin q) : destination q j.val = j.succ := by apply Fin.ext exact boundedIndex_val (Nat.succ_le_iff.mpr j.isLt) theorem output_source (q : Nat) (values : List Nat) (hlen : values.length = q) (base : Fin (q + 1) → List Bool) (suffix : List Bool) (hinput : base 0 = encodeWords values ++ suffix) : sequenceTapes (0 : Fin (q + 1)) (destination q) base 0 values suffix 0 = suffix := by apply sequenceTapes_source _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hinput intro r hr simpa using destination_ne_source q r (by omega) theorem output_field (q : Nat) (values : List Nat) (hlen : values.length = q) (base : Fin (q + 1) → List Bool) (suffix : List Bool) (j : Fin q) : sequenceTapes (0 : Fin (q + 1)) (destination q) base 0 values suffix j.succ = encodeWord (values[j.val]'(by omega)) ++ base j.succ := by have h := sequenceTapes_selected (0 : Fin (q + 1)) (destination q) base 0 values suffix j.val (by omega) (by intro r hr; simpa using destination_ne_source q r (by omega)) (by intro r s hr hs heq exact destination_injective_below q r s (by omega) (by omega) (by simpa only [Nat.zero_add] using heq)) simpa only [Nat.zero_add, destination_eq_succ] using h /-- Every label either seeds one field, scans that field, or executes the final halt. -/ def program (q : Nat) (label : Fin (q + 1) × Bool) : TM2.Stmt (fun _ : Fin (q + 1) => Bool) (Fin (q + 1) × Bool) (Unit × Option Bool) := if label.1.val < q then if label.2 then fieldLoop 0 (destination q label.1.val) (label.1, true) (some (startLabel q (label.1.val + 1))) else fieldStart (destination q label.1.val) (label.1, true) else finish 0 none def machine (q : Nat) : FinTM2 where K := Fin (q + 1) k₀ := 0 k₁ := 0 Γ _ := Bool Λ := Fin (q + 1) × Bool main := startLabel q 0 σ := Unit × Option Bool initialState := ((), none) m := program q theorem atStart (q r : Nat) (hr : r < q) : program q (startLabel q r) = fieldStart (destination q r) (loopLabel q r) := by simp [program, startLabel, loopLabel, boundedIndex_val hr.le, hr] theorem atLoop (q r : Nat) (hr : r < q) : program q (loopLabel q r) = fieldLoop (0 : Fin (q + 1)) (destination q r) (loopLabel q r) (some (startLabel q (r + 1))) := by simp [program, startLabel, loopLabel, boundedIndex_val hr.le, hr] theorem atDone (q : Nat) : program q (startLabel q q) = finish (0 : Fin (q + 1)) none := by simp [program, startLabel] def machineInTime (q : Nat) (values : List Nat) (hlen : values.length = q) (base : Fin (q + 1) → List Bool) (suffix : List Bool) (hinput : base 0 = encodeWords values ++ suffix) (register : Option Bool) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (machine q).step ⟨some (startLabel q 0), ((), register), base⟩ (some ⟨none, ((), none), sequenceTapes (0 : Fin (q + 1)) (destination q) base 0 values suffix⟩) (values.sum + 2 * q + 1) := by have hsep : ∀ r, r < values.length → (0 : Fin (q + 1)) ≠ destination q (0 + r) := by intro r hr heq have hr' : r + 1 ≤ q := by omega have hh := congrArg Fin.val heq simp only [Nat.zero_add, destination, boundedIndex_val hr'] at hh change 0 = r + 1 at hh omega have hs : ∀ r, r < values.length → program q (startLabel q (0 + r)) = fieldStart (destination q (0 + r)) (loopLabel q (0 + r)) := by intro r hr simpa only [Nat.zero_add] using atStart q r (by omega) have hl : ∀ r, r < values.length → program q (loopLabel q (0 + r)) = fieldLoop (0 : Fin (q + 1)) (destination q (0 + r)) (loopLabel q (0 + r)) (some (startLabel q (0 + r + 1))) := by intro r hr simpa only [Nat.zero_add] using atLoop q r (by omega) have hd : program q (startLabel q (0 + values.length)) = finish (0 : Fin (q + 1)) none := by simpa [hlen] using atDone q simpa only [machine, FinTM2.Cfg, FinTM2.step, hlen] using! sequenceInTime (0 : Fin (q + 1)) (destination q) (startLabel q) (loopLabel q) none (program q) base 0 values suffix hsep hs hl hd hinput () register /-- The same actual execution has a linear bound measured in the complete input stack, including its unread suffix. -/ def machineInTime_inputBound (q : Nat) (values : List Nat) (hlen : values.length = q) (base : Fin (q + 1) → List Bool) (suffix : List Bool) (hinput : base 0 = encodeWords values ++ suffix) (register : Option Bool) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (machine q).step ⟨some (startLabel q 0), ((), register), base⟩ (some ⟨none, ((), none), sequenceTapes (0 : Fin (q + 1)) (destination q) base 0 values suffix⟩) ((base 0).length + q + 1) := by let run := machineInTime q values hlen base suffix hinput register refine { toEvalsTo := run.toEvalsTo, steps_le_m := ?_ } have hb := run.steps_le_m have hi : (base 0).length = values.sum + q + suffix.length := by rw [hinput, List.length_append, encodeWords_length, hlen] omega /-- The six natural fields of a three-literal clause use seven actual stacks. -/ def sixFieldsInTime (base : Fin 7 → List Bool) (a b c d e f : Nat) (suffix : List Bool) (hinput : base 0 = encodeWords [a, b, c, d, e, f] ++ suffix) (register : Option Bool) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (machine 6).step ⟨some (startLabel 6 0), ((), register), base⟩ (some ⟨none, ((), none), sequenceTapes (0 : Fin 7) (destination 6) base 0 [a, b, c, d, e, f] suffix⟩) (a + b + c + d + e + f + 13) := by have h := machineInTime 6 [a, b, c, d, e, f] rfl base suffix hinput register convert h using 1 simp omega end MaxCutGames.Foundations.Hastad.SourceFieldArray namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.Hastad.SourceClauseLookup open Turing open MaxCutGames.Foundations.Complexity open MachineComposition SourceMachine section Discard variable {K Λ σ : Type} [DecidableEq K] /-- Compose the actual unary scanners for a fixed sequence of control labels. The zero-field case is an identity, so the head register starts and ends clear. -/ theorem discardFieldsTrace (source : K) (label : Nat → Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet (K := K)) Λ (σ × Option Bool)) (base : K → List Bool) (offset : Nat) (values : List Nat) (suffix : List Bool) (atLoop : ∀ r, r < values.length → program (label (offset + r)) = MachineLookup.discard source (label (offset + r)) (label (offset + r + 1))) (hinput : base source = encodeWords values ++ suffix) (ambient : σ) : (advance (TM2.step program))^[(encodeWords values).length] (some ⟨some (label offset), (ambient, none), base⟩) = some ⟨some (label (offset + values.length)), (ambient, none), Function.update base source suffix⟩ := by induction values generalizing base offset with | nil => have hbase : Function.update base source suffix = base := by have hs : base source = suffix := by simpa only [encodeWords, List.nil_append] using hinput funext p by_cases hp : p = source · subst p; simp [hs] · simp [hp] simp only [encodeWords, List.length_nil, Nat.add_zero, Function.iterate_zero_apply, hbase] | cons n rest ih => have hs : program (label offset) = MachineLookup.discard source (label offset) (label (offset + 1)) := by simpa only [Nat.add_zero] using atLoop 0 (by simp) have hin : base source = encodeWord n ++ (encodeWords rest ++ suffix) := by simpa only [encodeWords, List.append_assoc] using hinput have first := MachineLookup.discardTrace source (label offset) (label (offset + 1)) program hs base n (encodeWords rest ++ suffix) hin ambient none have htail : ∀ r, r < rest.length → program (label (offset + 1 + r)) = MachineLookup.discard source (label (offset + 1 + r)) (label (offset + 1 + r + 1)) := by intro r hr simpa [Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using atLoop (r + 1) (by simp; omega) have second := ih (Function.update base source (encodeWords rest ++ suffix)) (offset + 1) htail (by simp) rw [show (encodeWords (n :: rest)).length = (encodeWords rest).length + (n + 1) by simp only [encodeWords, List.length_append, encodeWord_length] omega] rw [Function.iterate_add_apply, first] simpa [Function.update_idem, Nat.add_assoc, Nat.add_comm, Nat.add_left_comm] using second end Discard inductive Tape | formula | index | work | scratch | field (slot : Fin 6) deriving DecidableEq, Fintype inductive Label | copyOut | copyBack | headerFirst | headerSecond | guard | skip (slot : Fin 6) | read (slot : Fin 7 × Bool) deriving DecidableEq, Fintype def fieldDestination (r : Nat) : Tape := .field ⟨min r 5, by omega⟩ def readStart (r : Nat) : Label := .read (SourceFieldArray.boundedIndex 6 r, false) def readLoop (r : Nat) : Label := .read (SourceFieldArray.boundedIndex 6 r, true) def skipLabel (r : Nat) : Label := if h : r < 6 then .skip ⟨r, h⟩ else .guard def headerLabel (r : Nat) : Label := if r = 0 then .headerFirst else if r = 1 then .headerSecond else .guard /-- Ten binary stacks and fixed finite control. Every loop scans one actual bit or tests one actual counter bit; there is no arithmetic oracle in the state. -/ def program : Label → TM2.Stmt (fun _ : Tape => Bool) Label (Unit × Option Bool) | .copyOut => Reduction.MachineTransfer.loopAt .formula .scratch id false .copyOut (some .copyBack) | .copyBack => MachineCopy.forkLoop .scratch .formula .work false .copyBack (some .headerFirst) | .headerFirst => MachineLookup.discard .work .headerFirst .headerSecond | .headerSecond => MachineLookup.discard .work .headerSecond .guard | .guard => MachineUnaryCounter.guard .index (skipLabel 0) (readStart 0) | .skip slot => MachineLookup.discard .work (.skip slot) (skipLabel (slot.val + 1)) | .read slot => if slot.1.val < 6 then if slot.2 then fieldLoop .work (fieldDestination slot.1.val) (.read (slot.1, true)) (some (readStart (slot.1.val + 1))) else fieldStart (fieldDestination slot.1.val) (.read (slot.1, true)) else SourceFieldArray.finish .work none def machine : FinTM2 where K := Tape k₀ := .formula k₁ := .field 0 Γ _ := Bool Λ := Label main := .copyOut σ := Unit × Option Bool initialState := ((), none) m := program theorem atSkip (r : Nat) (hr : r < 6) : program (skipLabel r) = MachineLookup.discard .work (skipLabel r) (skipLabel (r + 1)) := by simp [skipLabel, hr, program] theorem atReadStart (r : Nat) (hr : r < 6) : program (readStart r) = fieldStart (fieldDestination r) (readLoop r) := by simp [program, readStart, readLoop, SourceFieldArray.boundedIndex_val hr.le, hr] theorem atReadLoop (r : Nat) (hr : r < 6) : program (readLoop r) = fieldLoop .work (fieldDestination r) (readLoop r) (some (readStart (r + 1))) := by simp [program, readStart, readLoop, SourceFieldArray.boundedIndex_val hr.le, hr] theorem atReadDone : program (readStart 6) = SourceFieldArray.finish .work none := by simp [program, readStart, SourceFieldArray.boundedIndex] /-- The two header fields are physically consumed from the work copy. -/ theorem discardHeadersTrace (base : Tape → List Bool) (variableCount clauses : Nat) (suffix : List Bool) (hinput : base .work = encodeWords [variableCount, clauses] ++ suffix) : (advance (TM2.step program))^[variableCount + clauses + 2] (some ⟨some .headerFirst, ((), none), base⟩) = some ⟨some .guard, ((), none), Function.update base .work suffix⟩ := by have ht := discardFieldsTrace .work headerLabel program base 0 [variableCount, clauses] suffix (by intro r hr have he : r = 0 ∨ r = 1 := by simp at hr; omega rcases he with rfl | rfl <;> rfl) hinput () simpa [encodeWords_length, headerLabel] using ht /-- The fixed skip body consumes six complete unary fields and returns to the same counter guard, preserving the counter and every other tape. -/ theorem discardSixTrace (base : Tape → List Bool) (values : List Nat) (hlen : values.length = 6) (suffix : List Bool) (hinput : base .work = encodeWords values ++ suffix) : (advance (TM2.step program))^[(encodeWords values).length] (some ⟨some (skipLabel 0), ((), none), base⟩) = some ⟨some .guard, ((), none), Function.update base .work suffix⟩ := by have ht := discardFieldsTrace .work skipLabel program base 0 values suffix (by intro r hr; simpa only [Nat.zero_add] using atSkip r (by omega)) hinput () simpa [hlen, skipLabel] using ht /-- Read the selected six fields using the already checked scanner. -/ theorem readSixTrace (base : Tape → List Bool) (values : List Nat) (hlen : values.length = 6) (suffix : List Bool) (hinput : base .work = encodeWords values ++ suffix) : (advance (TM2.step program))^[(encodeWords values).length + 7] (some ⟨some (readStart 0), ((), none), base⟩) = some ⟨none, ((), none), SourceFieldArray.sequenceTapes .work fieldDestination base 0 values suffix⟩ := by have ht := SourceFieldArray.sequenceTrace .work fieldDestination readStart readLoop none program base 0 values suffix (by intro r hr; simp [fieldDestination]) (by intro r hr; simpa only [Nat.zero_add] using atReadStart r (by omega)) (by intro r hr; simpa only [Nat.zero_add] using atReadLoop r (by omega)) (by simpa [hlen] using atReadDone) hinput () none have htime : values.sum + 2 * values.length + 1 = (encodeWords values).length + 7 := by rw [encodeWords_length, hlen] simpa only [Nat.zero_add, htime] using ht /-- Normal form for the changing counter and consumed work-copy prefix. -/ def scanTapes (base : Tape → List Bool) (index : Nat) (indexSuffix input : List Bool) : Tape → List Bool := MachineUnaryCounter.counterTapes .index (Function.update base .work input) index indexSuffix @[simp] theorem scanTapes_work (base : Tape → List Bool) (i : Nat) (indexSuffix input : List Bool) : scanTapes base i indexSuffix input .work = input := by simp [scanTapes, MachineUnaryCounter.counterTapes] @[simp] theorem scanTapes_index (base : Tape → List Bool) (i : Nat) (indexSuffix input : List Bool) : scanTapes base i indexSuffix input .index = encodeWord i ++ indexSuffix := by simp [scanTapes, MachineUnaryCounter.counterTapes] theorem scanTapes_other (base : Tape → List Bool) (i : Nat) (indexSuffix input : List Bool) (p : Tape) (hi : p ≠ .index) (hw : p ≠ .work) : scanTapes base i indexSuffix input p = base p := by simp [scanTapes, MachineUnaryCounter.counterTapes, hi, hw] theorem update_scanTapes_work (base : Tape → List Bool) (i : Nat) (indexSuffix input replacement : List Bool) : Function.update (scanTapes base i indexSuffix input) .work replacement = scanTapes base i indexSuffix replacement := by funext p cases p <;> simp [scanTapes, MachineUnaryCounter.counterTapes] /-- Each clause-index bit causes one genuine guard transition and exactly six field-discard loops. The final zero guard enters the field reader. -/ theorem skipClausesTrace {n : Nat} (base : Tape → List Bool) (prior : List (Target.Clause n)) (indexSuffix suffix : List Bool) (register : Option Bool) : (advance (TM2.step program))^[(encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords)).length + prior.length + 1] (some ⟨some .guard, ((), register), scanTapes base prior.length indexSuffix (encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords) ++ suffix)⟩) = some ⟨some (readStart 0), ((), none), scanTapes base 0 indexSuffix suffix⟩ := by induction prior generalizing register with | nil => simpa only [List.flatMap_nil, List.length_nil, encodeWords, List.nil_append, Nat.zero_add, Function.iterate_one, advance_some, scanTapes] using MachineUnaryCounter.guardStep_zero .index .guard (skipLabel 0) (readStart 0) program rfl (Function.update base .work suffix) indexSuffix () register | cons clause prior ih => have hencoding : encodeWords ((clause :: prior).flatMap clauseWords) ++ suffix = encodeWords (clauseWords clause) ++ (encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords) ++ suffix) := by simp only [List.flatMap_cons, encodeWords_append, List.append_assoc] have htime : (encodeWords ((clause :: prior).flatMap clauseWords)).length + (clause :: prior).length + 1 = ((encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords)).length + prior.length + 1 + (encodeWords (clauseWords clause)).length) + 1 := by simp only [List.flatMap_cons, encodeWords_append, List.length_append, List.length_cons] omega rw [htime, Function.iterate_succ_apply] change (advance (TM2.step program))^[ (encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords)).length + prior.length + 1 + (encodeWords (clauseWords clause)).length] (TM2.step program ⟨some .guard, ((), register), MachineUnaryCounter.counterTapes .index (Function.update base .work (encodeWords ((clause :: prior).flatMap clauseWords) ++ suffix)) (prior.length + 1) indexSuffix⟩) = _ rw [MachineUnaryCounter.guardStep_succ .index .guard (skipLabel 0) (readStart 0) program rfl] rw [Function.iterate_add_apply] have hd := discardSixTrace (scanTapes base prior.length indexSuffix (encodeWords ((clause :: prior).flatMap clauseWords) ++ suffix)) (clauseWords clause) (clauseWords_length clause) (encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords) ++ suffix) (by rw [scanTapes_work, hencoding]) change (advance (TM2.step program))^[ (encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords)).length + prior.length + 1] ((advance (TM2.step program))^[(encodeWords (clauseWords clause)).length] (some ⟨some (skipLabel 0), ((), none), scanTapes base prior.length indexSuffix (encodeWords ((clause :: prior).flatMap clauseWords) ++ suffix)⟩)) = _ rw [hd, update_scanTapes_work] exact ih none theorem fieldDestination_eq (j : Fin 6) : fieldDestination j.val = .field j := by unfold fieldDestination congr 1 apply Fin.ext exact Nat.min_eq_left (by omega) theorem fieldDestination_injective_below (r s : Nat) (hr : r < 6) (hs : s < 6) (he : fieldDestination r = fieldDestination s) : r = s := by have hv := congrArg (fun t : Tape => match t with | .field j => j.val | _ => 6) he simpa [fieldDestination, Nat.min_eq_left (show r ≤ 5 by omega), Nat.min_eq_left (show s ≤ 5 by omega)] using hv /-- Each field stack receives exactly its own unary value, in formula order. -/ theorem readSix_output_field (base : Tape → List Bool) (values : List Nat) (hlen : values.length = 6) (suffix : List Bool) (j : Fin 6) : SourceFieldArray.sequenceTapes .work fieldDestination base 0 values suffix (.field j) = encodeWord (values[j.val]'(by omega)) ++ base (.field j) := by have ht := SourceFieldArray.sequenceTapes_selected .work fieldDestination base 0 values suffix j.val (by omega) (by intro r hr; simp [fieldDestination]) (by intro r s hr hs he apply fieldDestination_injective_below r s (by omega) (by omega) simpa only [Nat.zero_add] using he) simpa only [Nat.zero_add, fieldDestination_eq] using ht theorem readSix_output_work (base : Tape → List Bool) (values : List Nat) (_hlen : values.length = 6) (suffix : List Bool) (hinput : base .work = encodeWords values ++ suffix) : SourceFieldArray.sequenceTapes .work fieldDestination base 0 values suffix .work = suffix := by apply SourceFieldArray.sequenceTapes_source _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hinput intro r hr simp [fieldDestination] theorem readSix_output_frame (base : Tape → List Bool) (values : List Nat) (suffix : List Bool) (p : Tape) (hwork : p ≠ .work) (hfield : ∀ j : Fin 6, p ≠ .field j) : SourceFieldArray.sequenceTapes .work fieldDestination base 0 values suffix p = base p := by apply SourceFieldArray.sequenceTapes_other _ _ _ hwork intro r hr exact hfield _ def outputTapes {n : Nat} (base : Tape → List Bool) (clause : Target.Clause n) (indexSuffix suffix : List Bool) : Tape → List Bool := SourceFieldArray.sequenceTapes .work fieldDestination (scanTapes base 0 indexSuffix (encodeWords (clauseWords clause) ++ suffix)) 0 (clauseWords clause) suffix def scanSteps {n : Nat} (variableCount declaredClauses : Nat) (prior : List (Target.Clause n)) (clause : Target.Clause n) : Nat := variableCount + declaredClauses + 2 + (encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords)).length + prior.length + 1 + (encodeWords (clauseWords clause)).length + 7 /-- A complete skip-and-read phase after the non-destructive formula copy. -/ theorem scanReadTrace {n : Nat} (base : Tape → List Bool) (variableCount declaredClauses : Nat) (prior : List (Target.Clause n)) (clause : Target.Clause n) (indexSuffix suffix : List Bool) : (advance (TM2.step program))^[scanSteps variableCount declaredClauses prior clause] (some ⟨some .headerFirst, ((), none), scanTapes base prior.length indexSuffix (encodeWords [variableCount, declaredClauses] ++ (encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords) ++ (encodeWords (clauseWords clause) ++ suffix)))⟩) = some ⟨none, ((), none), outputTapes base clause indexSuffix suffix⟩ := by have hh := discardHeadersTrace (scanTapes base prior.length indexSuffix (encodeWords [variableCount, declaredClauses] ++ (encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords) ++ (encodeWords (clauseWords clause) ++ suffix)))) variableCount declaredClauses (encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords) ++ (encodeWords (clauseWords clause) ++ suffix)) (by simp) have hs := skipClausesTrace base prior indexSuffix (encodeWords (clauseWords clause) ++ suffix) none have hr := readSixTrace (scanTapes base 0 indexSuffix (encodeWords (clauseWords clause) ++ suffix)) (clauseWords clause) (clauseWords_length clause) suffix (by simp) rw [show scanSteps variableCount declaredClauses prior clause = ((encodeWords (clauseWords clause)).length + 7 + ((encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords)).length + prior.length + 1)) + (variableCount + declaredClauses + 2) by unfold scanSteps; omega] rw [Function.iterate_add_apply, hh, update_scanTapes_work, Function.iterate_add_apply, hs] exact hr def lookupSteps {n : Nat} (F : Target.Formula) (prior : List (Target.Clause n)) (clause : Target.Clause n) : Nat := 2 * ((formulaBits F).length + 1) + scanSteps F.«variables» F.clauses.length prior clause /-- Actual formula lookup with a displayed prefix/selected-clause/suffix split. The formula stack is restored before scanning, and the index is consumed down to its retained zero delimiter. Field-stack suffixes are preserved. -/ theorem lookupWithSplitTrace (F : Target.Formula) (prior : List (Target.Clause F.«variables»)) (clause : Target.Clause F.«variables») (after : List (Target.Clause F.«variables»)) (hsplit : F.clauses = prior ++ clause :: after) (base : Tape → List Bool) (indexSuffix : List Bool) (hformula : base .formula = formulaBits F) (hindex : base .index = encodeWord prior.length ++ indexSuffix) (hwork : base .work = []) (hscratch : base .scratch = []) (register : Option Bool) : (advance (TM2.step program))^[lookupSteps F prior clause] (some ⟨some .copyOut, ((), register), base⟩) = some ⟨none, ((), none), outputTapes base clause indexSuffix (encodeWords (after.flatMap clauseWords))⟩ := by have hbits : formulaBits F = encodeWords [F.«variables», F.clauses.length] ++ (encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords) ++ (encodeWords (clauseWords clause) ++ encodeWords (after.flatMap clauseWords))) := by simp only [formulaBits, formulaWords, encodeWords_append] rw [hsplit] simp only [List.flatMap_append, List.flatMap_cons, encodeWords_append] have hc := MachineCopy.copyTrace .formula .work .scratch (by decide) (by decide) (by decide) false .copyOut .copyBack (some .headerFirst) program rfl rfl base hscratch () register have htapes : Function.update base .work (base .formula ++ base .work) = scanTapes base prior.length indexSuffix (formulaBits F) := by funext p cases p <;> simp [scanTapes, MachineUnaryCounter.counterTapes, hformula, hindex, hwork] rw [htapes, hformula] at hc rw [lookupSteps, Nat.add_comm, Function.iterate_add_apply, hc, hbits] exact scanReadTrace base F.«variables» F.clauses.length prior clause indexSuffix (encodeWords (after.flatMap clauseWords)) /-- The preserved input copy is exactly the original serialized formula. -/ theorem output_formula {n : Nat} (base : Tape → List Bool) (clause : Target.Clause n) (indexSuffix suffix : List Bool) : outputTapes base clause indexSuffix suffix .formula = base .formula := by rw [outputTapes, readSix_output_frame _ _ _ .formula (by decide) (by intro j; simp)] exact scanTapes_other _ _ _ _ _ (by decide) (by decide) theorem output_index {n : Nat} (base : Tape → List Bool) (clause : Target.Clause n) (indexSuffix suffix : List Bool) : outputTapes base clause indexSuffix suffix .index = encodeWord 0 ++ indexSuffix := by rw [outputTapes, readSix_output_frame _ _ _ .index (by decide) (by intro j; simp), scanTapes_index] theorem output_work {n : Nat} (base : Tape → List Bool) (clause : Target.Clause n) (indexSuffix suffix : List Bool) : outputTapes base clause indexSuffix suffix .work = suffix := by apply readSix_output_work _ _ (clauseWords_length clause) _ simp theorem output_field {n : Nat} (base : Tape → List Bool) (clause : Target.Clause n) (indexSuffix suffix : List Bool) (j : Fin 6) : outputTapes base clause indexSuffix suffix (.field j) = encodeWord ((clauseWords clause)[j.val]'(by simp)) ++ base (.field j) := by rw [outputTapes, readSix_output_field _ _ (clauseWords_length clause)] rw [scanTapes_other _ _ _ _ (.field j) (by simp) (by simp)] theorem output_frame {n : Nat} (base : Tape → List Bool) (clause : Target.Clause n) (indexSuffix suffix : List Bool) (p : Tape) (hindex : p ≠ .index) (hwork : p ≠ .work) (hfield : ∀ j : Fin 6, p ≠ .field j) : outputTapes base clause indexSuffix suffix p = base p := by rw [outputTapes, readSix_output_frame _ _ _ p hwork hfield] exact scanTapes_other _ _ _ _ p hindex hwork /-- Explicit variable/sign order consumed by later finite-control phases. -/ theorem clauseWords_six {n : Nat} (clause : Target.Clause n) : clauseWords clause = [clause[0].variableIndex.val, if clause[0].positive then 1 else 0, clause[1].variableIndex.val, if clause[1].positive then 1 else 0, clause[2].variableIndex.val, if clause[2].positive then 1 else 0] := rfl def fieldWords (tapes : Tape → List Bool) : List (List Bool) := [tapes (.field 0), tapes (.field 1), tapes (.field 2), tapes (.field 3), tapes (.field 4), tapes (.field 5)] theorem output_fieldWords {n : Nat} (base : Tape → List Bool) (clause : Target.Clause n) (indexSuffix suffix : List Bool) (hempty : ∀ j : Fin 6, base (.field j) = []) : fieldWords (outputTapes base clause indexSuffix suffix) = (clauseWords clause).map encodeWord := by simp [fieldWords, output_field, hempty, clauseWords_six] theorem lookupSteps_le_input (F : Target.Formula) (prior : List (Target.Clause F.«variables»)) (clause : Target.Clause F.«variables») (after : List (Target.Clause F.«variables»)) (hsplit : F.clauses = prior ++ clause :: after) : lookupSteps F prior clause ≤ 4 * (formulaBits F).length + 10 := by have hlength : (formulaBits F).length = F.«variables» + F.clauses.length + 2 + (encodeWords (prior.flatMap clauseWords)).length + (encodeWords (clauseWords clause)).length + (encodeWords (after.flatMap clauseWords)).length := by simp only [formulaBits, formulaWords, encodeWords_append, List.length_append, encodeWords, encodeWord_length, List.length_nil] rw [hsplit] simp only [List.flatMap_append, List.flatMap_cons, encodeWords_append, List.length_append] omega have hp : prior.length ≤ F.clauses.length := by rw [hsplit, List.length_append, List.length_cons] omega unfold lookupSteps scanSteps omega noncomputable def timePolynomial : Polynomial Nat := Polynomial.C 4 * Polynomial.X + Polynomial.C 10 theorem timePolynomial_eval (L : Nat) : timePolynomial.eval L = 4 * L + 10 := by simp [timePolynomial] /-- A polynomial bound on the actual complete copy/skip/read execution. -/ def lookupWithSplitInTime (F : Target.Formula) (prior : List (Target.Clause F.«variables»)) (clause : Target.Clause F.«variables») (after : List (Target.Clause F.«variables»)) (hsplit : F.clauses = prior ++ clause :: after) (base : Tape → List Bool) (indexSuffix : List Bool) (hformula : base .formula = formulaBits F) (hindex : base .index = encodeWord prior.length ++ indexSuffix) (hwork : base .work = []) (hscratch : base .scratch = []) (register : Option Bool) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step program) ⟨some .copyOut, ((), register), base⟩ (some ⟨none, ((), none), outputTapes base clause indexSuffix (encodeWords (after.flatMap clauseWords))⟩) (timePolynomial.eval (formulaBits F).length) where steps := lookupSteps F prior clause evals_in_steps := lookupWithSplitTrace F prior clause after hsplit base indexSuffix hformula hindex hwork hscratch register steps_le_m := by rw [timePolynomial_eval] exact lookupSteps_le_input F prior clause after hsplit /-- Lookup at a valid numbered clause, starting with its ordinary unary index. The output fields are those of `F.clauses[i]`, with the rest of the work copy and the original formula retained exactly as stated by the frame lemmas. -/ def lookupInTime (F : Target.Formula) (i : Fin F.clauses.length) (base : Tape → List Bool) (indexSuffix : List Bool) (hformula : base .formula = formulaBits F) (hindex : base .index = encodeWord i.val ++ indexSuffix) (hwork : base .work = []) (hscratch : base .scratch = []) (register : Option Bool) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step program) ⟨some .copyOut, ((), register), base⟩ (some ⟨none, ((), none), outputTapes base F.clauses[i.val] indexSuffix (encodeWords ((F.clauses.drop (i.val + 1)).flatMap clauseWords))⟩) (timePolynomial.eval (formulaBits F).length) := by have hp : (F.clauses.take i.val).length = i.val := by rw [List.length_take, Nat.min_eq_left i.isLt.le] have hs : F.clauses = F.clauses.take i.val ++ F.clauses[i.val] :: F.clauses.drop (i.val + 1) := by rw [List.getElem_cons_drop i.isLt, List.take_append_drop] apply lookupWithSplitInTime F (F.clauses.take i.val) F.clauses[i.val] (F.clauses.drop (i.val + 1)) hs base indexSuffix hformula (by simpa only [hp] using hindex) hwork hscratch register /-- The same proved run stated directly for the concrete finite machine. -/ def machineInTime (F : Target.Formula) (i : Fin F.clauses.length) (base : Tape → List Bool) (indexSuffix : List Bool) (hformula : base .formula = formulaBits F) (hindex : base .index = encodeWord i.val ++ indexSuffix) (hwork : base .work = []) (hscratch : base .scratch = []) (register : Option Bool) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime machine.step ⟨some .copyOut, ((), register), base⟩ (some ⟨none, ((), none), outputTapes base F.clauses[i.val] indexSuffix (encodeWords ((F.clauses.drop (i.val + 1)).flatMap clauseWords))⟩) (timePolynomial.eval (formulaBits F).length) := by exact lookupInTime F i base indexSuffix hformula hindex hwork hscratch register end MaxCutGames.Foundations.Hastad.SourceClauseLookup end OAI