import Mathlib import OAI.Computability.MinUncut.Machines.MachineUnaryCounter namespace OAI namespace MinUncutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineCompare open Turing open MinUncutGames.Reduction.MachineTransfer variable {K Λ σ : Type} [DecidableEq K] abbrev Alphabet (K : Type) : K → Type := fun _ => Bool abbrev State (σ : Type) := σ × Bool × Option Bool × Option Bool def exitAt (exit : Option Λ) : TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ) := match exit with | none => .halt | some label => .goto fun _ => label def finish (exit : Option Λ) : TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ) := .load (fun state => (state.1, false, none, none)) (exitAt exit) def loop (left right : K) (loopLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) : TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ) := .pop left (fun state head => (state.1, state.2.1, head, state.2.2.2)) (.pop right (fun state head => (state.1, state.2.1, state.2.2.1, head)) (.branch (fun state => state.2.2.1.isNone && state.2.2.2.isNone) (.branch (fun state => state.2.1) (finish differentExit) (finish equalExit)) (.load (fun state => (state.1, state.2.1 || decide (state.2.2.1 ≠ state.2.2.2), none, none)) (.goto fun _ => loopLabel)))) def mismatch (flag : Bool) (leftWord rightWord : List Bool) : Bool := flag || decide (leftWord ≠ rightWord) @[simp] theorem mismatch_nil_nil (flag : Bool) : mismatch flag [] [] = flag := by simp [mismatch] @[simp] theorem mismatch_nil_cons (flag head : Bool) (tail : List Bool) : mismatch flag [] (head :: tail) = true := by simp [mismatch] @[simp] theorem mismatch_cons_nil (flag head : Bool) (tail : List Bool) : mismatch flag (head :: tail) [] = true := by simp [mismatch] @[simp] theorem mismatch_true (leftWord rightWord : List Bool) : mismatch true leftWord rightWord = true := by simp [mismatch] theorem mismatch_cons (flag leftHead rightHead : Bool) (leftTail rightTail : List Bool) : mismatch (flag || decide (leftHead ≠ rightHead)) leftTail rightTail = mismatch flag (leftHead :: leftTail) (rightHead :: rightTail) := by cases flag <;> cases leftHead <;> cases rightHead <;> simp [mismatch] @[simp] theorem stepAux_exitAt (exit : Option Λ) (state : State σ) (tapes : K → List Bool) : TM2.stepAux (exitAt exit) state tapes = ⟨exit, state, tapes⟩ := by cases exit <;> rfl @[simp] theorem stepAux_finish (exit : Option Λ) (state : State σ) (tapes : K → List Bool) : TM2.stepAux (finish exit) state tapes = ⟨exit, (state.1, false, none, none), tapes⟩ := by simp [finish, TM2.stepAux] private theorem update_left (left right : K) (distinct : left ≠ right) (base : K → List Bool) (leftWord rightWord replacement : List Bool) : Function.update (tapesAt left right base leftWord rightWord) left replacement = tapesAt left right base replacement rightWord := by funext k by_cases hl : k = left · subst k simp [tapesAt, distinct] · by_cases hr : k = right · subst k simp [tapesAt, Ne.symm distinct] · simp [tapesAt, hl, hr] private theorem update_right (left right : K) (base : K → List Bool) (leftWord rightWord replacement : List Bool) : Function.update (tapesAt left right base leftWord rightWord) right replacement = tapesAt left right base leftWord replacement := by simp [tapesAt] theorem step_empty (left right : K) (distinct : left ≠ right) (loopLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ)) (atLoop : program loopLabel = loop left right loopLabel equalExit differentExit) (base : K → List Bool) (ambient : σ) (flag : Bool) (leftRegister rightRegister : Option Bool) : TM2.step program ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister), tapesAt left right base [] []⟩ = some ⟨if flag then differentExit else equalExit, (ambient, false, none, none), tapesAt left right base [] []⟩ := by change some (TM2.stepAux (program loopLabel) (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister) (tapesAt left right base [] [])) = _ rw [atLoop] cases flag <;> simp [loop, TM2.stepAux, distinct, update_left, update_right] theorem step_nil_cons (left right : K) (distinct : left ≠ right) (loopLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ)) (atLoop : program loopLabel = loop left right loopLabel equalExit differentExit) (base : K → List Bool) (head : Bool) (tail : List Bool) (ambient : σ) (flag : Bool) (leftRegister rightRegister : Option Bool) : TM2.step program ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister), tapesAt left right base [] (head :: tail)⟩ = some ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, true, none, none), tapesAt left right base [] tail⟩ := by change some (TM2.stepAux (program loopLabel) (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister) (tapesAt left right base [] (head :: tail))) = _ rw [atLoop] simp [loop, TM2.stepAux, distinct, update_left, update_right] theorem step_cons_nil (left right : K) (distinct : left ≠ right) (loopLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ)) (atLoop : program loopLabel = loop left right loopLabel equalExit differentExit) (base : K → List Bool) (head : Bool) (tail : List Bool) (ambient : σ) (flag : Bool) (leftRegister rightRegister : Option Bool) : TM2.step program ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister), tapesAt left right base (head :: tail) []⟩ = some ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, true, none, none), tapesAt left right base tail []⟩ := by change some (TM2.stepAux (program loopLabel) (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister) (tapesAt left right base (head :: tail) [])) = _ rw [atLoop] simp [loop, TM2.stepAux, distinct, update_left, update_right] theorem step_cons_cons (left right : K) (distinct : left ≠ right) (loopLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ)) (atLoop : program loopLabel = loop left right loopLabel equalExit differentExit) (base : K → List Bool) (leftHead rightHead : Bool) (leftTail rightTail : List Bool) (ambient : σ) (flag : Bool) (leftRegister rightRegister : Option Bool) : TM2.step program ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister), tapesAt left right base (leftHead :: leftTail) (rightHead :: rightTail)⟩ = some ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, flag || decide (leftHead ≠ rightHead), none, none), tapesAt left right base leftTail rightTail⟩ := by change some (TM2.stepAux (program loopLabel) (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister) (tapesAt left right base (leftHead :: leftTail) (rightHead :: rightTail))) = _ rw [atLoop] simp [loop, TM2.stepAux, distinct, update_left, update_right] private theorem trace_left_empty (left right : K) (distinct : left ≠ right) (loopLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ)) (atLoop : program loopLabel = loop left right loopLabel equalExit differentExit) (base : K → List Bool) (rightWord : List Bool) (ambient : σ) (flag : Bool) (leftRegister rightRegister : Option Bool) : (MachineComposition.advance (TM2.step program))^[rightWord.length + 1] (some ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister), tapesAt left right base [] rightWord⟩) = some ⟨if mismatch flag [] rightWord then differentExit else equalExit, (ambient, false, none, none), tapesAt left right base [] []⟩ := by induction rightWord generalizing flag leftRegister rightRegister with | nil => simpa only [List.length_nil, Nat.zero_add, Function.iterate_one, MachineComposition.advance_some, mismatch_nil_nil] using step_empty left right distinct loopLabel equalExit differentExit program atLoop base ambient flag leftRegister rightRegister | cons head tail ih => rw [List.length_cons, Function.iterate_succ_apply] change (MachineComposition.advance (TM2.step program))^[tail.length + 1] (TM2.step program ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister), tapesAt left right base [] (head :: tail)⟩) = _ rw [step_nil_cons left right distinct loopLabel equalExit differentExit program atLoop] simpa only [mismatch_true, mismatch_nil_cons] using ih true none none theorem compareTrace_flag (left right : K) (distinct : left ≠ right) (loopLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ)) (atLoop : program loopLabel = loop left right loopLabel equalExit differentExit) (base : K → List Bool) (leftWord rightWord : List Bool) (ambient : σ) (flag : Bool) (leftRegister rightRegister : Option Bool) : (MachineComposition.advance (TM2.step program))^[max leftWord.length rightWord.length + 1] (some ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister), tapesAt left right base leftWord rightWord⟩) = some ⟨if mismatch flag leftWord rightWord then differentExit else equalExit, (ambient, false, none, none), tapesAt left right base [] []⟩ := by induction leftWord generalizing rightWord flag leftRegister rightRegister with | nil => simpa only [List.length_nil, Nat.zero_max] using trace_left_empty left right distinct loopLabel equalExit differentExit program atLoop base rightWord ambient flag leftRegister rightRegister | cons head tail ih => cases rightWord with | nil => rw [List.length_cons, List.length_nil, Nat.max_zero, Function.iterate_succ_apply] change (MachineComposition.advance (TM2.step program))^[tail.length + 1] (TM2.step program ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister), tapesAt left right base (head :: tail) []⟩) = _ rw [step_cons_nil left right distinct loopLabel equalExit differentExit program atLoop] simpa only [List.length_nil, Nat.max_zero, mismatch_true, mismatch_cons_nil] using ih [] true none none | cons rightHead rightTail => rw [List.length_cons, List.length_cons, Nat.succ_max_succ, Function.iterate_succ_apply] change (MachineComposition.advance (TM2.step program))^[max tail.length rightTail.length + 1] (TM2.step program ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, flag, leftRegister, rightRegister), tapesAt left right base (head :: tail) (rightHead :: rightTail)⟩) = _ rw [step_cons_cons left right distinct loopLabel equalExit differentExit program atLoop] simpa only [mismatch_cons] using ih rightTail (flag || decide (head ≠ rightHead)) none none theorem compareTrace (left right : K) (distinct : left ≠ right) (loopLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ)) (atLoop : program loopLabel = loop left right loopLabel equalExit differentExit) (base : K → List Bool) (leftWord rightWord : List Bool) (ambient : σ) (leftRegister rightRegister : Option Bool) : (MachineComposition.advance (TM2.step program))^[max leftWord.length rightWord.length + 1] (some ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, false, leftRegister, rightRegister), tapesAt left right base leftWord rightWord⟩) = some ⟨if leftWord = rightWord then equalExit else differentExit, (ambient, false, none, none), tapesAt left right base [] []⟩ := by have h := compareTrace_flag left right distinct loopLabel equalExit differentExit program atLoop base leftWord rightWord ambient false leftRegister rightRegister by_cases heq : leftWord = rightWord <;> simpa [mismatch, heq] using h theorem compareTrace_fromTapes (left right : K) (distinct : left ≠ right) (loopLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ)) (atLoop : program loopLabel = loop left right loopLabel equalExit differentExit) (base : K → List Bool) (ambient : σ) (leftRegister rightRegister : Option Bool) : (MachineComposition.advance (TM2.step program))^[max (base left).length (base right).length + 1] (some ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, false, leftRegister, rightRegister), base⟩) = some ⟨if base left = base right then equalExit else differentExit, (ambient, false, none, none), tapesAt left right base [] []⟩ := by simpa only [tapesAt_self] using compareTrace left right distinct loopLabel equalExit differentExit program atLoop base (base left) (base right) ambient leftRegister rightRegister theorem drained_other (left right k : K) (notLeft : k ≠ left) (notRight : k ≠ right) (base : K → List Bool) : tapesAt left right base [] [] k = base k := tapesAt_other left right k notLeft notRight base [] [] def compareInTime (left right : K) (distinct : left ≠ right) (loopLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ)) (atLoop : program loopLabel = loop left right loopLabel equalExit differentExit) (base : K → List Bool) (ambient : σ) (leftRegister rightRegister : Option Bool) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step program) ⟨some loopLabel, (ambient, false, leftRegister, rightRegister), base⟩ (some ⟨if base left = base right then equalExit else differentExit, (ambient, false, none, none), tapesAt left right base [] []⟩) (max (base left).length (base right).length + 1) where steps := max (base left).length (base right).length + 1 evals_in_steps := compareTrace_fromTapes left right distinct loopLabel equalExit differentExit program atLoop base ambient leftRegister rightRegister steps_le_m := Nat.le_refl _ @[simp] theorem compareInTime_steps (left right : K) (distinct : left ≠ right) (loopLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet K) Λ (State σ)) (atLoop : program loopLabel = loop left right loopLabel equalExit differentExit) (base : K → List Bool) (ambient : σ) (leftRegister rightRegister : Option Bool) : (compareInTime left right distinct loopLabel equalExit differentExit program atLoop base ambient leftRegister rightRegister).steps = max (base left).length (base right).length + 1 := rfl end MinUncutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineCompare namespace MinUncutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineControl open Turing.TM2 variable {K Λ Λ' σ σ' : Type} {Γ : K → Type} def configuration (labels : Λ → Λ') (states : σ ≃ σ') (c : Cfg Γ Λ σ) : Cfg Γ Λ' σ' where l := c.l.map labels var := states c.var stk := c.stk def statement (labels : Λ → Λ') (states : σ ≃ σ') : Stmt Γ Λ σ → Stmt Γ Λ' σ' | .push k f next => .push k (fun st => f (states.symm st)) (statement labels states next) | .peek k f next => .peek k (fun st v => states (f (states.symm st) v)) (statement labels states next) | .pop k f next => .pop k (fun st v => states (f (states.symm st) v)) (statement labels states next) | .load f next => .load (fun st => states (f (states.symm st))) (statement labels states next) | .branch f yes no => .branch (fun st => f (states.symm st)) (statement labels states yes) (statement labels states no) | .goto f => .goto (fun st => labels (f (states.symm st))) | .halt => .halt variable [DecidableEq K] theorem stepAux_simulation (labels : Λ → Λ') (states : σ ≃ σ') (q : Stmt Γ Λ σ) (state : σ) (tapes : ∀ k, List (Γ k)) : stepAux (statement labels states q) (states state) tapes = configuration labels states (stepAux q state tapes) := by induction q generalizing state tapes with | push k f next ih => simpa only [statement, stepAux, Equiv.symm_apply_apply] using ih state (Function.update tapes k (f state :: tapes k)) | peek k f next ih => simpa only [statement, stepAux, Equiv.symm_apply_apply] using ih (f state (tapes k).head?) tapes | pop k f next ih => simpa only [statement, stepAux, Equiv.symm_apply_apply] using ih (f state (tapes k).head?) (Function.update tapes k (tapes k).tail) | load f next ih => simpa only [statement, stepAux, Equiv.symm_apply_apply] using ih (f state) tapes | branch f yes no ihYes ihNo => cases h : f state with | false => simpa only [statement, stepAux, Equiv.symm_apply_apply, h, Bool.cond_false] using ihNo state tapes | true => simpa only [statement, stepAux, Equiv.symm_apply_apply, h, Bool.cond_true] using ihYes state tapes | goto f => simp [statement, stepAux, configuration] | halt => rfl def program (labels : Λ ≃ Λ') (states : σ ≃ σ') (source : Λ → Stmt Γ Λ σ) : Λ' → Stmt Γ Λ' σ' := fun l => statement labels states (source (labels.symm l)) theorem step_simulation (labels : Λ ≃ Λ') (states : σ ≃ σ') (source : Λ → Stmt Γ Λ σ) (c : Cfg Γ Λ σ) : step (program labels states source) (configuration labels states c) = (step source c).map (configuration labels states) := by cases c with | mk l state tapes => cases l with | none => rfl | some l => change some (stepAux (statement labels states (source (labels.symm (labels l)))) (states state) tapes) = _ rw [Equiv.symm_apply_apply, stepAux_simulation] rfl end MinUncutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineControl namespace MinUncutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineFieldProfile open Turing abbrev Profile (q : Nat) := Fin q → Fin q → Bool def equalityProfile {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) : Profile q := fun i j => decide (words i = words j) theorem equalityProfile_encodeWord {q : Nat} (names : Fin q → Nat) (i j : Fin q) : equalityProfile (fun k => encodeWord (names k)) i j = decide (names i = names j) := by have h : encodeWord (names i) = encodeWord (names j) ↔ names i = names j := by constructor · intro heq have hh := congrArg List.length heq simpa only [encodeWord_length, Nat.add_right_cancel_iff] using hh · rintro heq rw [heq] simp only [equalityProfile, h] section Transport variable {K Λ σ τ : Type} [DecidableEq K] omit [DecidableEq K] in theorem statement_roundtrip (e : σ ≃ τ) (q : TM2.Stmt (fun _ : K => Bool) Λ τ) : MachineControl.statement id e (MachineControl.statement id e.symm q) = q := by induction q <;> simp_all [MachineControl.statement] def copyStateEquiv (σ : Type) : ((σ × Bool × Option Bool) × Option Bool) ≃ MachineCompare.State σ where toFun s := (s.1.1, s.1.2.1, s.1.2.2, s.2) invFun s := ((s.1, s.2.1, s.2.2.1), s.2.2.2) left_inv _ := rfl right_inv _ := rfl def normalState (ambient : σ) : MachineCompare.State σ := (ambient, false, none, none) def copyStatement (q : TM2.Stmt (fun _ : K => Bool) Λ ((σ × Bool × Option Bool) × Option Bool)) : TM2.Stmt (fun _ : K => Bool) Λ (MachineCompare.State σ) := MachineControl.statement id (copyStateEquiv σ) q def copyInCompareState (source destination scratch : K) (hSD : source ≠ destination) (hST : source ≠ scratch) (hDT : destination ≠ scratch) (firstLabel secondLabel : Λ) (exit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (fun _ : K => Bool) Λ (MachineCompare.State σ)) (atFirst : program firstLabel = copyStatement (Reduction.MachineTransfer.loopAt source scratch id false firstLabel (some secondLabel))) (atSecond : program secondLabel = copyStatement (MachineCopy.forkLoop scratch source destination false secondLabel exit)) (base : K → List Bool) (hScratch : base scratch = []) (ambient : σ) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step program) ⟨some firstLabel, normalState ambient, base⟩ (some ⟨exit, normalState ambient, Function.update base destination (base source ++ base destination)⟩) (2 * ((base source).length + 1)) := by let e := copyStateEquiv σ let view := MachineControl.program (Equiv.refl Λ) e.symm program have hfirst : view firstLabel = Reduction.MachineTransfer.loopAt source scratch id false firstLabel (some secondLabel) := by dsimp [view, MachineControl.program] rw [atFirst] exact statement_roundtrip e.symm _ have hsecond : view secondLabel = MachineCopy.forkLoop scratch source destination false secondLabel exit := by dsimp [view, MachineControl.program] rw [atSecond] exact statement_roundtrip e.symm _ let run := MachineCopy.copyInTime source destination scratch hSD hST hDT false firstLabel secondLabel exit view hfirst hsecond base hScratch (ambient, false, none) none have hprogram : MachineControl.program (Equiv.refl Λ) e view = program := by funext label exact statement_roundtrip e (program label) have hsim (a b : TM2.Cfg (fun _ : K => Bool) Λ ((σ × Bool × Option Bool) × Option Bool)) (hab : TM2.step view a = some b) : TM2.step program (MachineControl.configuration id e a) = some (MachineControl.configuration id e b) := by have hh := MachineControl.step_simulation (Equiv.refl Λ) e view a rw [hprogram, hab] at hh exact hh have lifted := MachineComposition.liftExecutionInTime (TM2.step view) (TM2.step program) (MachineControl.configuration id e) hsim run simpa [MachineControl.configuration, copyStateEquiv, normalState, e] using lifted end Transport section PreservedComparison variable {K Λ σ : Type} [DecidableEq K] def nonDestructiveCompareInTime (left right workLeft workRight scratch : K) (hleft : left ≠ workLeft ∧ left ≠ workRight ∧ left ≠ scratch) (hright : right ≠ workLeft ∧ right ≠ workRight ∧ right ≠ scratch) (hwork : workLeft ≠ workRight ∧ workLeft ≠ scratch ∧ workRight ≠ scratch) (leftFirst leftSecond rightFirst rightSecond compareLabel : Λ) (equalExit differentExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (fun _ : K => Bool) Λ (MachineCompare.State σ)) (atLeftFirst : program leftFirst = copyStatement (Reduction.MachineTransfer.loopAt left scratch id false leftFirst (some leftSecond))) (atLeftSecond : program leftSecond = copyStatement (MachineCopy.forkLoop scratch left workLeft false leftSecond (some rightFirst))) (atRightFirst : program rightFirst = copyStatement (Reduction.MachineTransfer.loopAt right scratch id false rightFirst (some rightSecond))) (atRightSecond : program rightSecond = copyStatement (MachineCopy.forkLoop scratch right workRight false rightSecond (some compareLabel))) (atCompare : program compareLabel = MachineCompare.loop workLeft workRight compareLabel equalExit differentExit) (base : K → List Bool) (hWL : base workLeft = []) (hWR : base workRight = []) (hScratch : base scratch = []) (ambient : σ) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step program) ⟨some leftFirst, normalState ambient, base⟩ (some ⟨if base left = base right then equalExit else differentExit, normalState ambient, base⟩) (2 * ((base left).length + 1) + 2 * ((base right).length + 1) + max (base left).length (base right).length + 1) := by let t₁ := Function.update base workLeft (base left) let t₂ := Function.update t₁ workRight (base right) have h₁ := copyInCompareState left workLeft scratch hleft.1 hleft.2.2 hwork.2.1 leftFirst leftSecond (some rightFirst) program atLeftFirst atLeftSecond base hScratch ambient simp only [hWL, List.append_nil] at h₁ have hSR : t₁ right = base right := by simp [t₁, hright.1] have hDR : t₁ workRight = [] := by simp [t₁, Ne.symm hwork.1, hWR] have hTR : t₁ scratch = [] := by simp [t₁, Ne.symm hwork.2.1, hScratch] have h₂ := copyInCompareState right workRight scratch hright.2.1 hright.2.2 hwork.2.2 rightFirst rightSecond (some compareLabel) program atRightFirst atRightSecond t₁ hTR ambient rw [hSR, hDR] at h₂ simp only [List.append_nil] at h₂ have hL : t₂ workLeft = base left := by simp [t₂, t₁, hwork.1] have hR : t₂ workRight = base right := by simp [t₂] have hrestore : Reduction.MachineTransfer.tapesAt workLeft workRight t₂ [] [] = base := by funext p by_cases hl : p = workLeft · subst p simp [Reduction.MachineTransfer.tapesAt, hwork.1, hWL] · by_cases hr : p = workRight · subst p simp [Reduction.MachineTransfer.tapesAt, hWR] · simp [Reduction.MachineTransfer.tapesAt, t₂, t₁, hl, hr] have h₃ := MachineCompare.compareInTime workLeft workRight hwork.1 compareLabel equalExit differentExit program atCompare t₂ ambient none none rw [hL, hR, hrestore] at h₃ let h₁₂ := StateTransition.EvalsToInTime.trans _ _ _ _ _ _ h₁ h₂ let run := StateTransition.EvalsToInTime.trans _ _ _ _ _ _ h₁₂ h₃ exact { toEvalsTo := run.toEvalsTo, steps_le_m := by have h := run.steps_le_m; omega } end PreservedComparison def setEntry {q : Nat} (profile : Profile q) (pair : Fin q × Fin q) (bit : Bool) : Profile q := Function.update profile pair.1 (Function.update (profile pair.1) pair.2 bit) theorem setEntry_apply {q : Nat} (profile : Profile q) (pair : Fin q × Fin q) (bit : Bool) (i j : Fin q) : setEntry profile pair bit i j = if (i, j) = pair then bit else profile i j := by rcases pair with ⟨a, b⟩ by_cases hi : i = a <;> by_cases hj : j = b <;> simp [setEntry, hi, hj] def setExpected {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) (profile : Profile q) (pair : Fin q × Fin q) : Profile q := setEntry profile pair (equalityProfile words pair.1 pair.2) def foldProfile {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) (initial : Profile q) (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) : Profile q := cells.foldl (setExpected words) initial theorem foldProfile_apply {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) (initial : Profile q) (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) (i j : Fin q) : foldProfile words initial cells i j = if (i, j) ∈ cells then equalityProfile words i j else initial i j := by induction cells generalizing initial with | nil => rfl | cons pair rest ih => change foldProfile words (setExpected words initial pair) rest i j = _ rw [ih] by_cases hrest : (i, j) ∈ rest · simp [hrest] · by_cases hpair : (i, j) = pair · subst pair simp [hrest, setExpected, setEntry_apply] · simp [hrest, hpair, setExpected, setEntry_apply] abbrev Tape (q : Nat) := Fin q ⊕ Fin 3 abbrev Label {q : Nat} (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) := Fin (cells.length + 1) × Fin 7 def labelAt {q : Nat} (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) (r : Nat) (phase : Fin 7) : Label cells := (⟨min r cells.length, by omega⟩, phase) def storePair {q : Nat} (pair : Fin q × Fin q) (bit : Bool) {Λ : Type} (nextLabel : Λ) : TM2.Stmt (fun _ : Tape q => Bool) Λ (MachineCompare.State (Profile q)) := .load (fun state => normalState (setEntry state.1 pair bit)) (.goto fun _ => nextLabel) def profileProgram {q : Nat} (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) (label : Label cells) : TM2.Stmt (fun _ : Tape q => Bool) (Label cells) (MachineCompare.State (Profile q)) := if h : label.1.val < cells.length then let pair := cells[label.1.val] let r := label.1.val match label.2.val with | 0 => copyStatement (Reduction.MachineTransfer.loopAt (.inl pair.1) (.inr 2) id false (labelAt cells r 0) (some (labelAt cells r 1))) | 1 => copyStatement (MachineCopy.forkLoop (.inr 2) (.inl pair.1) (.inr 0) false (labelAt cells r 1) (some (labelAt cells r 2))) | 2 => copyStatement (Reduction.MachineTransfer.loopAt (.inl pair.2) (.inr 2) id false (labelAt cells r 2) (some (labelAt cells r 3))) | 3 => copyStatement (MachineCopy.forkLoop (.inr 2) (.inl pair.2) (.inr 1) false (labelAt cells r 3) (some (labelAt cells r 4))) | 4 => MachineCompare.loop (.inr 0) (.inr 1) (labelAt cells r 4) (some (labelAt cells r 5)) (some (labelAt cells r 6)) | 5 => storePair pair true (labelAt cells (r + 1) 0) | _ => storePair pair false (labelAt cells (r + 1) 0) else .halt def pairTime {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) (pair : Fin q × Fin q) : Nat := 2 * ((words pair.1).length + 1) + 2 * ((words pair.2).length + 1) + max (words pair.1).length (words pair.2).length + 2 def prefixProfile {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) (initial : Profile q) (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) (r : Nat) : Profile q := foldProfile words initial (cells.take r) def prefixTime {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) (r : Nat) : Nat := ((cells.take r).map (pairTime words)).sum theorem prefixProfile_succ {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) (initial : Profile q) (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) (r : Nat) (hr : r < cells.length) : prefixProfile words initial cells (r + 1) = setExpected words (prefixProfile words initial cells r) cells[r] := by unfold prefixProfile foldProfile rw [List.take_succ_eq_append_getElem hr, List.foldl_append] rfl theorem prefixTime_succ {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) (r : Nat) (hr : r < cells.length) : prefixTime words cells (r + 1) = prefixTime words cells r + pairTime words cells[r] := by unfold prefixTime rw [List.take_succ_eq_append_getElem hr, List.map_append, List.sum_append] rfl def stageInTime {q : Nat} (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) (r : Nat) (hr : r < cells.length) (base : Tape q → List Bool) (hwork : ∀ w : Fin 3, base (.inr w) = []) (profile : Profile q) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (profileProgram cells)) ⟨some (labelAt cells r 0), normalState profile, base⟩ (some ⟨some (labelAt cells (r + 1) 0), normalState (setExpected (fun i => base (.inl i)) profile cells[r]), base⟩) (pairTime (fun i => base (.inl i)) cells[r]) := by let pair := cells[r] have copied := nonDestructiveCompareInTime (.inl pair.1) (.inl pair.2) (.inr 0 : Tape q) (.inr 1) (.inr 2) (by simp) (by simp) (by simp) (labelAt cells r 0) (labelAt cells r 1) (labelAt cells r 2) (labelAt cells r 3) (labelAt cells r 4) (some (labelAt cells r 5)) (some (labelAt cells r 6)) (profileProgram cells) (by simp [profileProgram, labelAt, Nat.min_eq_left hr.le, hr, pair]) (by simp [profileProgram, labelAt, Nat.min_eq_left hr.le, hr, pair]) (by simp [profileProgram, labelAt, Nat.min_eq_left hr.le, hr, pair]) (by simp [profileProgram, labelAt, Nat.min_eq_left hr.le, hr, pair]) (by simp [profileProgram, labelAt, Nat.min_eq_left hr.le, hr]) base (hwork 0) (hwork 1) (hwork 2) profile have stored : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (profileProgram cells)) ⟨if base (.inl pair.1) = base (.inl pair.2) then some (labelAt cells r 5) else some (labelAt cells r 6), normalState profile, base⟩ (some ⟨some (labelAt cells (r + 1) 0), normalState (setExpected (fun i => base (.inl i)) profile pair), base⟩) 1 := { steps := 1 evals_in_steps := by change TM2.step (profileProgram cells) ⟨if base (.inl pair.1) = base (.inl pair.2) then some (labelAt cells r 5) else some (labelAt cells r 6), normalState profile, base⟩ = _ by_cases heq : base (.inl pair.1) = base (.inl pair.2) · simp [heq, TM2.step, profileProgram, labelAt, Nat.min_eq_left hr.le, hr, storePair, TM2.stepAux, normalState, setExpected, equalityProfile, pair] · simp [heq, TM2.step, profileProgram, labelAt, Nat.min_eq_left hr.le, hr, storePair, TM2.stepAux, normalState, setExpected, equalityProfile, pair] steps_le_m := Nat.le_refl _ } let run := StateTransition.EvalsToInTime.trans _ _ _ _ _ _ copied stored refine { toEvalsTo := run.toEvalsTo, steps_le_m := ?_ } have h := run.steps_le_m dsimp only [pair] at h dsimp only [pairTime] omega def prefixInTime {q : Nat} (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) (base : Tape q → List Bool) (hwork : ∀ w : Fin 3, base (.inr w) = []) (initial : Profile q) (r : Nat) (hr : r ≤ cells.length) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (profileProgram cells)) ⟨some (labelAt cells 0 0), normalState initial, base⟩ (some ⟨some (labelAt cells r 0), normalState (prefixProfile (fun i => base (.inl i)) initial cells r), base⟩) (prefixTime (fun i => base (.inl i)) cells r) := by induction r with | zero => exact { steps := 0, evals_in_steps := rfl, steps_le_m := Nat.le_refl _ } | succ r ih => have hrl : r < cells.length := by omega let first := ih (by omega) let second := stageInTime cells r hrl base hwork (prefixProfile (fun i => base (.inl i)) initial cells r) let run := StateTransition.EvalsToInTime.trans _ _ _ _ _ _ first second rw [prefixProfile_succ _ _ _ _ hrl, prefixTime_succ _ _ _ hrl] exact { toEvalsTo := run.toEvalsTo, steps_le_m := by have h := run.steps_le_m; omega } def allPairs (q : Nat) : List (Fin q × Fin q) := (List.finRange q).flatMap fun i => (List.finRange q).map fun j => (i, j) theorem mem_allPairs {q : Nat} (i j : Fin q) : (i, j) ∈ allPairs q := by simp [allPairs] theorem length_allPairs (q : Nat) : (allPairs q).length = q * q := by simp [allPairs, List.length_flatMap] theorem foldProfile_allPairs {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) (initial : Profile q) : foldProfile words initial (allPairs q) = equalityProfile words := by funext i j simp [foldProfile_apply, mem_allPairs] def profileMachine (q : Nat) : FinTM2 where K := Tape q k₀ := .inr 0 k₁ := .inr 0 Γ _ := Bool Λ := Label (allPairs q) main := labelAt (allPairs q) 0 0 σ := MachineCompare.State (Profile q) initialState := normalState (fun _ _ => false) m := profileProgram (allPairs q) def profileInTime (q : Nat) (base : Tape q → List Bool) (hwork : ∀ w : Fin 3, base (.inr w) = []) (initial : Profile q) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (profileMachine q).step ⟨some (labelAt (allPairs q) 0 0), normalState initial, base⟩ (some ⟨none, normalState (equalityProfile (fun i => base (.inl i))), base⟩) (((allPairs q).map (pairTime (fun i => base (.inl i)))).sum + 1) := by let cells := allPairs q have first := prefixInTime cells base hwork initial cells.length (Nat.le_refl _) have last : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step (profileProgram cells)) ⟨some (labelAt cells cells.length 0), normalState (prefixProfile (fun i => base (.inl i)) initial cells cells.length), base⟩ (some ⟨none, normalState (equalityProfile (fun i => base (.inl i))), base⟩) 1 := { steps := 1 evals_in_steps := by change TM2.step (profileProgram cells) ⟨some (labelAt cells cells.length 0), normalState (prefixProfile (fun i => base (.inl i)) initial cells cells.length), base⟩ = _ simp [TM2.step, profileProgram, labelAt, TM2.stepAux, prefixProfile, cells, foldProfile_allPairs] steps_le_m := Nat.le_refl _ } let run := StateTransition.EvalsToInTime.trans _ _ _ _ _ _ first last refine { toEvalsTo := run.toEvalsTo, steps_le_m := ?_ } have h := run.steps_le_m simpa [prefixTime, cells, Nat.add_comm] using h theorem pairTime_le {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) (L : Nat) (hL : ∀ i, (words i).length ≤ L) (pair : Fin q × Fin q) : pairTime words pair ≤ 5 * L + 6 := by have hi := hL pair.1 have hj := hL pair.2 have hm := max_le hi hj dsimp only [pairTime] omega theorem totalTime_le {q : Nat} (words : Fin q → List Bool) (L : Nat) (hL : ∀ i, (words i).length ≤ L) (cells : List (Fin q × Fin q)) : (cells.map (pairTime words)).sum ≤ cells.length * (5 * L + 6) := by induction cells with | nil => simp | cons pair rest ih => have hp := pairTime_le words L hL pair simp only [List.map_cons, List.sum_cons, List.length_cons, Nat.add_mul, Nat.one_mul] omega def profileInTime_bounded (q : Nat) (base : Tape q → List Bool) (hwork : ∀ w : Fin 3, base (.inr w) = []) (initial : Profile q) (L : Nat) (hL : ∀ i, (base (.inl i)).length ≤ L) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (profileMachine q).step ⟨some (labelAt (allPairs q) 0 0), normalState initial, base⟩ (some ⟨none, normalState (equalityProfile (fun i => base (.inl i))), base⟩) (q * q * (5 * L + 6) + 1) := by let run := profileInTime q base hwork initial refine { toEvalsTo := run.toEvalsTo, steps_le_m := ?_ } apply run.steps_le_m.trans apply Nat.add_le_add_right simpa only [length_allPairs] using totalTime_le (fun i => base (.inl i)) L hL (allPairs q) end MinUncutGames.Foundations.Complexity.MachineFieldProfile end OAI