import OAI.Computability.UniqueGames.Analysis.CompressionCountLemmas import OAI.Computability.UniqueGames.Analysis.OperatorPartitions namespace OAI section /-! The actual forward Appendix A.5 index injects into two spaces of linear maps. The first map recovers the image complement, the second its kernel complement. No index-cardinality inequality is assumed. -/ noncomputable section namespace UniqueGamesTheorem.Appendix.A5IndexCount open UniqueGamesTheorem.Integration.BinaryLinear (F2) variable {V W : Type*} [AddCommGroup V] [Module F2 V] [AddCommGroup W] [Module F2 W] def insideEquiv (A I : Submodule F2 V) (hIA : I ≤ A) : (I.comap A.subtype) ≃ₗ[F2] I where toFun i := ⟨i.val.val, i.property⟩ invFun i := ⟨⟨i.val, hIA i.property⟩, i.property⟩ left_inv _i := Subtype.ext (Subtype.ext rfl) right_inv _i := Subtype.ext rfl map_add' _i _j := Subtype.ext rfl map_smul' _c _i := Subtype.ext rfl theorem internal_isCompl (A I A0 : Submodule F2 V) (hIA : I ≤ A) (hd : Disjoint A0 I) (hj : A0 ⊔ I = A) : IsCompl (I.comap A.subtype) (A0.comap A.subtype) := by have hA0 : A0 ≤ A := le_sup_left.trans hj.le refine ⟨Submodule.disjoint_def.mpr ?_, codisjoint_iff.mpr ?_⟩ · intro a hi h0 exact Subtype.ext (Submodule.disjoint_def.mp hd a.val h0 hi) · apply eq_top_iff.mpr intro a _ have ha : a.val ∈ A0 ⊔ I := by rw [hj]; exact a.property rcases Submodule.mem_sup.mp ha with ⟨v, hv, i, hi, hvi⟩ refine Submodule.mem_sup.mpr ⟨⟨i, hIA hi⟩, hi, ⟨v, hA0 hv⟩, hv, ?_⟩ apply Subtype.ext change i + v = a.val rw [add_comm] exact hvi def projectionA0 (A I A0 : Submodule F2 V) (hIA : I ≤ A) (hd : Disjoint A0 I) (hj : A0 ⊔ I = A) : A →ₗ[F2] I := (insideEquiv A I hIA).toLinearMap.comp (((I.comap A.subtype).isComplEquivProj ⟨A0.comap A.subtype, internal_isCompl A I A0 hIA hd hj⟩).val) theorem projectionA0_injective (A I A0 A0' : Submodule F2 V) (hIA : I ≤ A) (hd : Disjoint A0 I) (hj : A0 ⊔ I = A) (hd' : Disjoint A0' I) (hj' : A0' ⊔ I = A) (h : projectionA0 A I A0 hIA hd hj = projectionA0 A I A0' hIA hd' hj') : A0 = A0' := by let P := I.comap A.subtype let Q : {Q : Submodule F2 A // IsCompl P Q} := ⟨A0.comap A.subtype, internal_isCompl A I A0 hIA hd hj⟩ let Q' : {Q : Submodule F2 A // IsCompl P Q} := ⟨A0'.comap A.subtype, internal_isCompl A I A0' hIA hd' hj'⟩ have hp : (P.isComplEquivProj Q).val = (P.isComplEquivProj Q').val := by apply LinearMap.ext intro a apply (insideEquiv A I hIA).injective exact LinearMap.congr_fun h a have hQ := P.isComplEquivProj.injective (Subtype.ext hp) have hq : A0.comap A.subtype = A0'.comap A.subtype := congrArg Subtype.val hQ have hA0 : A0 ≤ A := le_sup_left.trans hj.le have hA0' : A0' ≤ A := le_sup_left.trans hj'.le ext x constructor · intro hx have hm : (⟨x, hA0 hx⟩ : A) ∈ A0.comap A.subtype := hx rw [hq] at hm exact hm · intro hx have hm : (⟨x, hA0' hx⟩ : A) ∈ A0'.comap A.subtype := hx rw [← hq] at hm exact hm def fullRange {U L : Type*} [AddCommGroup U] [Module F2 U] [AddCommGroup L] [Module F2 L] (S : U →ₗ[F2] L) (hS : S.range = ⊤) : L →ₗ[F2] S.range := (LinearMap.id : L →ₗ[F2] L).codRestrict S.range (fun x => by rw [hS]; trivial) theorem fullRange_surjective {U L : Type*} [AddCommGroup U] [Module F2 U] [AddCommGroup L] [Module F2 L] (S : U →ₗ[F2] L) (hS : S.range = ⊤) : Function.Surjective (fullRange S hS) := fun c => ⟨c.val, Subtype.ext rfl⟩ theorem quotientRestriction_surjective (J B0 : Submodule F2 W) (hc : B0 ⊔ J = ⊤) : Function.Surjective (A4IndexCount.quotientRestriction J B0) := by intro z obtain ⟨w, rfl⟩ := J.mkQ_surjective z have hw : w ∈ B0 ⊔ J := by rw [hc]; trivial rcases Submodule.mem_sup.mp hw with ⟨b, hb, j, hj, hbj⟩ refine ⟨⟨b, hb⟩, ?_⟩ change J.mkQ b = J.mkQ w have hz : J.mkQ j = 0 := (Submodule.Quotient.mk_eq_zero J).mpr hj rw [← hbj, map_add, hz, add_zero] theorem quotientRestriction_same_kernel (B J B0 : Submodule F2 W) (hm : B0 ⊓ J = B) : (A4IndexCount.quotientRestriction J B0).ker = (A4IndexCount.quotientRestriction B B0).ker := by rw [A4IndexCount.ker_quotientRestriction, A4IndexCount.ker_quotientRestriction] ext b change (b : W) ∈ J ↔ (b : W) ∈ B constructor · intro hj have hb : (b : W) ∈ B0 ⊓ J := ⟨b.property, hj⟩ rwa [hm] at hb · intro hb exact (hm.symm.le.trans inf_le_right) hb def sectionB0 (B J B0 : Submodule F2 W) (hc : B0 ⊔ J = ⊤) (hm : B0 ⊓ J = B) : (W ⧸ J) →ₗ[F2] (W ⧸ B) := (A4IndexCount.factorViaRange (A4IndexCount.quotientRestriction J B0) (A4IndexCount.quotientRestriction B B0) (quotientRestriction_same_kernel B J B0 hm).le).comp (fullRange (A4IndexCount.quotientRestriction J B0) (LinearMap.range_eq_top.mpr (quotientRestriction_surjective J B0 hc))) theorem range_sectionB0 (B J B0 : Submodule F2 W) (hc : B0 ⊔ J = ⊤) (hm : B0 ⊓ J = B) : (sectionB0 B J B0 hc hm).range = (A4IndexCount.quotientRestriction B B0).range := by rw [sectionB0, LinearMap.range_comp_of_range_eq_top _ (LinearMap.range_eq_top.mpr (fullRange_surjective _ _))] exact A4IndexCount.factorViaRange_range _ _ _ theorem recover_sectionB0 (B J B0 : Submodule F2 W) (hc : B0 ⊔ J = ⊤) (hm : B0 ⊓ J = B) : (sectionB0 B J B0 hc hm).range.comap B.mkQ = B0 := by rw [range_sectionB0] have hB : B ≤ B0 := hm.symm.le.trans inf_le_left ext w change B.mkQ w ∈ (A4IndexCount.quotientRestriction B B0).range ↔ w ∈ B0 constructor · rintro ⟨b, hb⟩ change B.mkQ (b : W) = B.mkQ w at hb have hz : w - (b : W) ∈ B := by apply (Submodule.Quotient.mk_eq_zero B).mp change B.mkQ (w - (b : W)) = 0 rw [map_sub, hb, sub_self] simpa only [sub_add_cancel] using B0.add_mem (hB hz) b.property · intro hw exact ⟨⟨w, hw⟩, rfl⟩ theorem sectionB0_injective (B J B0 B0' : Submodule F2 W) (hc : B0 ⊔ J = ⊤) (hm : B0 ⊓ J = B) (hc' : B0' ⊔ J = ⊤) (hm' : B0' ⊓ J = B) (h : sectionB0 B J B0 hc hm = sectionB0 B J B0' hc' hm') : B0 = B0' := by calc B0 = (sectionB0 B J B0 hc hm).range.comap B.mkQ := (recover_sectionB0 B J B0 hc hm).symm _ = (sectionB0 B J B0' hc' hm').range.comap B.mkQ := congrArg (fun T : (W ⧸ J) →ₗ[F2] (W ⧸ B) => T.range.comap B.mkQ) h _ = B0' := recover_sectionB0 B J B0' hc' hm' def encode (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) (A : Submodule F2 V) (B : Submodule F2 W) (hIA : X.range ≤ A) (p : OperatorPartitions.A5GeometricIndex X A B) : (A →ₗ[F2] X.range) × ((W ⧸ X.ker) →ₗ[F2] (W ⧸ B)) := (projectionA0 A X.range p.val.1 hIA p.property.1 p.property.2.1, sectionB0 B X.ker p.val.2 p.property.2.2.1 p.property.2.2.2) theorem encode_injective (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) (A : Submodule F2 V) (B : Submodule F2 W) (hIA : X.range ≤ A) : Function.Injective (encode X A B hIA) := by intro p q h apply Subtype.ext apply Prod.ext · exact projectionA0_injective A X.range p.val.1 q.val.1 hIA p.property.1 p.property.2.1 q.property.1 q.property.2.1 (congrArg Prod.fst h) · exact sectionB0_injective B X.ker p.val.2 q.val.2 p.property.2.2.1 p.property.2.2.2 q.property.2.2.1 q.property.2.2.2 (congrArg Prod.snd h) variable [FiniteDimensional F2 V] [FiniteDimensional F2 W] theorem card_geometricIndex_le (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) (A : Submodule F2 V) (B : Submodule F2 W) (hIA : X.range ≤ A) : Nat.card (OperatorPartitions.A5GeometricIndex X A B) ≤ 2 ^ (Module.finrank F2 X.range * (Module.finrank F2 A + Module.finrank F2 (W ⧸ B))) := by have hfirst := CompressionCount.natCard_linearMap (U := A) (C := X.range) have hsecond := CompressionCount.natCard_linearMap (U := W ⧸ X.ker) (C := W ⧸ B) let : Finite (A →ₗ[F2] X.range) := Nat.finite_of_card_ne_zero (by rw [hfirst]; exact pow_ne_zero _ (by decide)) let : Finite ((W ⧸ X.ker) →ₗ[F2] (W ⧸ B)) := Nat.finite_of_card_ne_zero (by rw [hsecond]; exact pow_ne_zero _ (by decide)) have h := Nat.card_le_card_of_injective (encode X A B hIA) (encode_injective X A B hIA) rw [Nat.card_prod, hfirst, hsecond, X.quotKerEquivRange.finrank_eq, ← pow_add] at h have he : Module.finrank F2 A * Module.finrank F2 X.range + Module.finrank F2 X.range * Module.finrank F2 (W ⧸ B) = Module.finrank F2 X.range * (Module.finrank F2 A + Module.finrank F2 (W ⧸ B)) := by ring rwa [he] at h theorem card_geometricIndex_degree_le (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) (A : Submodule F2 V) (B : Submodule F2 W) (hIA : X.range ≤ A) (d : Nat) (hA : Module.finrank F2 A ≤ d) (hB : Module.finrank F2 (W ⧸ B) ≤ d) : Nat.card (OperatorPartitions.A5GeometricIndex X A B) ≤ 2 ^ (2 * d * Module.finrank F2 X.range) := by have hs : Module.finrank F2 A + Module.finrank F2 (W ⧸ B) ≤ 2 * d := by omega have he : Module.finrank F2 X.range * (Module.finrank F2 A + Module.finrank F2 (W ⧸ B)) ≤ 2 * d * Module.finrank F2 X.range := by calc _ ≤ Module.finrank F2 X.range * (2 * d) := Nat.mul_le_mul_left _ hs _ = _ := by ac_rfl exact (card_geometricIndex_le X A B hIA).trans (Nat.pow_le_pow_right (n := 2) (by decide : 0 < 2) he) theorem card_geometricIndex_cube_le (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) (A : Submodule F2 V) (B : Submodule F2 W) (hIA : X.range ≤ A) (d : Nat) (hA : Module.finrank F2 A ≤ d) (hB : Module.finrank F2 (W ⧸ B) ≤ d) : Nat.card (OperatorPartitions.A5GeometricIndex X A B) ^ 3 ≤ 2 ^ (6 * d * Module.finrank F2 X.range) := by have h := Nat.pow_le_pow_left (card_geometricIndex_degree_le X A B hIA d hA hB) 3 rw [← pow_mul] at h convert h using 1 congr 1 ring end UniqueGamesTheorem.Appendix.A5IndexCount end end end OAI