import OAI.Computability.UniqueGames.Machines.MachineBinaryNameMachine import OAI.Computability.UniqueGames.Machines.MachineCompositionLemmas import OAI.Computability.UniqueGames.Machines.MachineCopy namespace OAI /-! Compare one framed binary name with an already extracted reversed key. The candidate stream loses precisely that name frame. The key and every other non-work stack are preserved; the three work stacks are empty again on exit. The scanner, copy loops, and head-by-head comparison all execute actual TM2 instructions. Whole words occur only in the correctness specification. -/ namespace UniqueGamesTheorem.BinaryNameCompare open Turing open UniqueGamesTheorem.Foundations.Complexity open MachineComposition variable {K Λ A : Type} [DecidableEq K] abbrev Alphabet (_ : K) := Bool abbrev State (A : Type) := (A × Bool × Option Bool) × Option Bool def clean (ambient : A) : State A := ((ambient, false, none), none) def scanStateEquiv (A : Type) : BinaryNameMachine.State (A × Bool) ≃ State A where toFun s := ((s.1.1, s.1.2, s.2.1), s.2.2) invFun s := ((s.1.1, s.1.2.1), s.1.2.2, s.2) left_inv := by rintro ⟨⟨a, b⟩, c, d⟩; rfl right_inv := by rintro ⟨⟨a, b, c⟩, d⟩; rfl def compareStateEquiv (A : Type) : MachineCompare.State A ≃ State A where toFun s := ((s.1, s.2.1, s.2.2.1), s.2.2.2) invFun s := (s.1.1, s.1.2.1, s.1.2.2, s.2) left_inv := by rintro ⟨a, b, c, d⟩; rfl right_inv := by rintro ⟨⟨a, b, c⟩, d⟩; rfl inductive Label | scan | copyOut | copyBack | compare deriving DecidableEq protected abbrev Label.enumList : List Label := [.scan, .copyOut, .copyBack, .compare] protected theorem Label.enumList_getElem?_ctorIdx_eq (x : Label) : Label.enumList[x.ctorIdx]? = some x := by cases x <;> rfl protected theorem Label.enumList_nodup : Label.enumList.Nodup := by decide instance : Fintype Label where elems := ⟨Label.enumList, Label.enumList_nodup⟩ complete x := by cases x <;> decide /-- Tapes: candidate stream, preserved key, candidate payload, key copy, scratch. -/ def instruction (tape : Fin 5 → K) (labels : Label → Λ) (equalExit differentExit malformedExit : Option Λ) : Label → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet (K := K)) Λ (State A) | .scan => MachineStateEquiv.statement (scanStateEquiv A) (BinaryNameMachine.scan (tape 0) (tape 2) (labels .scan) (some (labels .copyOut)) malformedExit) | .copyOut => UniqueGamesTheorem.Reduction.MachineTransfer.loopAt (tape 1) (tape 4) id false (labels .copyOut) (some (labels .copyBack)) | .copyBack => MachineCopy.forkLoop (tape 4) (tape 1) (tape 3) false (labels .copyBack) (some (labels .compare)) | .compare => MachineStateEquiv.statement (compareStateEquiv A) (MachineCompare.loop (tape 2) (tape 3) (labels .compare) equalExit differentExit) def steps (payloadLength keyLength : Nat) : Nat := (payloadLength + 1) + 2 * (keyLength + 1) + (max payloadLength keyLength + 1) theorem steps_le (payloadLength keyLength : Nat) : steps payloadLength keyLength ≤ 2 * payloadLength + 3 * keyLength + 4 := by unfold steps omega private theorem joinTrace {X : Type*} {f : X → X} {a b c : X} {n m : Nat} (first : f^[n] a = b) (second : f^[m] b = c) : f^[n + m] a = c := by rw [Nat.add_comm, Function.iterate_add_apply, first, second] /-- The name is actually scanned, the key actually copied, and the resulting payloads actually compared. Program premises are literal instruction equations. -/ theorem compareTrace (tape : Fin 5 → K) (distinct : Function.Injective tape) (labels : Label → Λ) (equalExit differentExit malformedExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet (K := K)) Λ (State A)) (atLabels : ∀ l, program (labels l) = instruction tape labels equalExit differentExit malformedExit l) (base : K → List Bool) (bits suffix key : List Bool) (canonical : BinaryNameMachine.canonical bits = true) (sourceWord : base (tape 0) = BinaryNameMachine.frame bits ++ suffix) (keyWord : base (tape 1) = key) (candidateEmpty : base (tape 2) = []) (copyEmpty : base (tape 3) = []) (scratchEmpty : base (tape 4) = []) (ambient : A) : (advance (TM2.step program))^[steps bits.length key.length] (some ⟨some (labels .scan), clean ambient, base⟩) = some ⟨if bits.reverse = key then equalExit else differentExit, clean ambient, Function.update base (tape 0) suffix⟩ := by have hd (i j : Fin 5) (hne : i ≠ j) : tape i ≠ tape j := fun h => hne (distinct h) let finalBase := Function.update base (tape 0) suffix let afterScan := Function.update finalBase (tape 2) bits.reverse let afterCopy := Function.update afterScan (tape 3) key have scanRun : (advance (TM2.step program))^[bits.length + 1] (some ⟨some (labels .scan), clean ambient, base⟩) = some ⟨some (labels .copyOut), clean ambient, afterScan⟩ := by let back := MachineStateEquiv.program (scanStateEquiv A).symm program have atScan : back (labels .scan) = BinaryNameMachine.scan (tape 0) (tape 2) (labels .scan) (some (labels .copyOut)) malformedExit := by change MachineStateEquiv.statement (scanStateEquiv A).symm (program (labels .scan)) = _ rw [atLabels .scan] exact MachineStateEquiv.statement_symm_statement (scanStateEquiv A) _ have backForward : MachineStateEquiv.program (scanStateEquiv A) back = program := by funext l change MachineStateEquiv.statement (scanStateEquiv A) (MachineStateEquiv.statement (scanStateEquiv A).symm (program l)) = _ simpa only [Equiv.symm_symm] using MachineStateEquiv.statement_symm_statement (scanStateEquiv A).symm (program l) have initialTapes : UniqueGamesTheorem.Reduction.MachineTransfer.tapesAt (tape 0) (tape 2) base (BinaryNameMachine.frame bits ++ suffix) [] = base := by rw [← sourceWord, ← candidateEmpty] exact UniqueGamesTheorem.Reduction.MachineTransfer.tapesAt_self _ _ _ have native := BinaryNameMachine.framedTrace (tape 0) (tape 2) (hd 0 2 (by decide)) (labels .scan) (some (labels .copyOut)) malformedExit back atScan base (ambient, false) bits suffix [] none simp only [canonical, ↓reduceIte, initialTapes, List.append_nil] at native have transported := MachineStateEquiv.trace (scanStateEquiv A) back _ _ _ native rw [backForward] at transported simpa only [MachineStateEquiv.configuration, scanStateEquiv, Equiv.coe_fn_mk, BinaryNameMachine.clean, clean, afterScan, finalBase, UniqueGamesTheorem.Reduction.MachineTransfer.tapesAt] using transported have afterScanKey : afterScan (tape 1) = key := by simpa [afterScan, finalBase, hd 1 2 (by decide), hd 1 0 (by decide)] using keyWord have afterScanCopy : afterScan (tape 3) = [] := by simpa [afterScan, finalBase, hd 3 2 (by decide), hd 3 0 (by decide)] using copyEmpty have afterScanScratch : afterScan (tape 4) = [] := by simpa [afterScan, finalBase, hd 4 2 (by decide), hd 4 0 (by decide)] using scratchEmpty have copyRun : (advance (TM2.step program))^[2 * (key.length + 1)] (some ⟨some (labels .copyOut), clean ambient, afterScan⟩) = some ⟨some (labels .compare), clean ambient, afterCopy⟩ := by have h := MachineCopy.copyTrace (tape 1) (tape 3) (tape 4) (hd 1 3 (by decide)) (hd 1 4 (by decide)) (hd 3 4 (by decide)) false (labels .copyOut) (labels .copyBack) (some (labels .compare)) program (atLabels .copyOut) (atLabels .copyBack) afterScan afterScanScratch (ambient, false, none) none simpa only [afterScanKey, afterScanCopy, List.append_nil, clean, afterCopy] using h have candidateWord : afterCopy (tape 2) = bits.reverse := by simp [afterCopy, afterScan, hd 2 3 (by decide)] have copiedWord : afterCopy (tape 3) = key := by simp [afterCopy] have restored : UniqueGamesTheorem.Reduction.MachineTransfer.tapesAt (tape 2) (tape 3) afterCopy [] [] = finalBase := by funext k by_cases hc : k = tape 2 · subst k simp [UniqueGamesTheorem.Reduction.MachineTransfer.tapesAt, afterCopy, afterScan, finalBase, hd 2 3 (by decide), hd 2 0 (by decide), candidateEmpty] · by_cases hk : k = tape 3 · subst k simp [UniqueGamesTheorem.Reduction.MachineTransfer.tapesAt, afterCopy, afterScan, finalBase, hd 3 0 (by decide), copyEmpty] · simp [UniqueGamesTheorem.Reduction.MachineTransfer.tapesAt, afterCopy, afterScan, hc, hk] have comparisonRun : (advance (TM2.step program))^[max bits.length key.length + 1] (some ⟨some (labels .compare), clean ambient, afterCopy⟩) = some ⟨if bits.reverse = key then equalExit else differentExit, clean ambient, finalBase⟩ := by let back := MachineStateEquiv.program (compareStateEquiv A).symm program have atCompare : back (labels .compare) = MachineCompare.loop (tape 2) (tape 3) (labels .compare) equalExit differentExit := by change MachineStateEquiv.statement (compareStateEquiv A).symm (program (labels .compare)) = _ rw [atLabels .compare] exact MachineStateEquiv.statement_symm_statement (compareStateEquiv A) _ have backForward : MachineStateEquiv.program (compareStateEquiv A) back = program := by funext l change MachineStateEquiv.statement (compareStateEquiv A) (MachineStateEquiv.statement (compareStateEquiv A).symm (program l)) = _ simpa only [Equiv.symm_symm] using MachineStateEquiv.statement_symm_statement (compareStateEquiv A).symm (program l) have native := MachineCompare.compareTrace_fromTapes (tape 2) (tape 3) (hd 2 3 (by decide)) (labels .compare) equalExit differentExit back atCompare afterCopy ambient none none rw [candidateWord, copiedWord, restored, List.length_reverse] at native have transported := MachineStateEquiv.trace (compareStateEquiv A) back _ _ _ native rw [backForward] at transported simpa only [MachineStateEquiv.configuration, compareStateEquiv, Equiv.coe_fn_mk, clean] using transported exact joinTrace (joinTrace scanRun copyRun) comparisonRun /-- Linear runtime in the extracted candidate and stored key lengths. -/ def compareInTime (tape : Fin 5 → K) (distinct : Function.Injective tape) (labels : Label → Λ) (equalExit differentExit malformedExit : Option Λ) (program : Λ → TM2.Stmt (Alphabet (K := K)) Λ (State A)) (atLabels : ∀ l, program (labels l) = instruction tape labels equalExit differentExit malformedExit l) (base : K → List Bool) (bits suffix key : List Bool) (canonical : BinaryNameMachine.canonical bits = true) (sourceWord : base (tape 0) = BinaryNameMachine.frame bits ++ suffix) (keyWord : base (tape 1) = key) (candidateEmpty : base (tape 2) = []) (copyEmpty : base (tape 3) = []) (scratchEmpty : base (tape 4) = []) (ambient : A) : StateTransition.EvalsToInTime (TM2.step program) ⟨some (labels .scan), clean ambient, base⟩ (some ⟨if bits.reverse = key then equalExit else differentExit, clean ambient, Function.update base (tape 0) suffix⟩) (2 * bits.length + 3 * key.length + 4) where steps := steps bits.length key.length evals_in_steps := compareTrace tape distinct labels equalExit differentExit malformedExit program atLabels base bits suffix key canonical sourceWord keyWord candidateEmpty copyEmpty scratchEmpty ambient steps_le_m := steps_le bits.length key.length /-- Concrete finite machine; exit labels 0, 1, 2 mean equal, different, malformed. -/ def machine : FinTM2 where K := Fin 5 k₀ := 0 k₁ := 1 Γ _ := Bool Λ := Label ⊕ Fin 3 main := .inl .scan σ := State Unit initialState := clean () m label := match label with | .inl l => instruction id Sum.inl (some (.inr 0)) (some (.inr 1)) (some (.inr 2)) l | .inr _ => .halt theorem machine_finiteAlphabet (k : machine.K) : Finite (machine.Γ k) := by change Finite Bool infer_instance end UniqueGamesTheorem.BinaryNameCompare end OAI