import OAI.Computability.WLIdentification.StackCommands namespace OAI namespace WLIdentification namespace FiniteRefinement /-- Only equality kernels matter; no full color trees need be stored. -/ theorem map_eq_of_kernel {A B C : Type} (f : A → B) (g : A → C) (L M : Multiset A) (h : ∀ a b, f a = f b → g a = g b) (he : L.map f = M.map f) : L.map g = M.map g := by apply Multiset.rel_eq.mp rw [Multiset.rel_map] have hr : Multiset.Rel (fun a b => f a = f b) L M := by rw [← Multiset.rel_map, Multiset.rel_eq] exact he exact hr.mono (fun a _ b _ hab => h a b hab) theorem map_eq_iff_kernel {A B C : Type} (f : A → B) (g : A → C) (L M : Multiset A) (h : ∀ a b, f a = f b ↔ g a = g b) : L.map f = M.map f ↔ L.map g = M.map g := ⟨map_eq_of_kernel f g L M (fun a b => (h a b).mp), map_eq_of_kernel g f L M (fun a b => (h a b).mpr)⟩ variable {A : Type} [Fintype A] {C : ℕ → Type} (color : (s : ℕ) → A → C s) def KernelEq (s t : ℕ) : Prop := ∀ a b, color s a = color s b ↔ color t a = color t b noncomputable def kernel (s : ℕ) : Finset (A × A) := by classical exact Finset.univ.filter (fun ab => color s ab.1 = color s ab.2) theorem kernel_eq_iff (s t : ℕ) : kernel color s = kernel color t ↔ KernelEq color s t := by classical constructor · intro h a b have := Finset.ext_iff.mp h (a, b) simpa only [kernel, Finset.mem_filter, Finset.mem_univ, true_and] using this · intro h ext ab simp only [kernel, Finset.mem_filter, Finset.mem_univ, true_and] exact h ab.1 ab.2 theorem kernel_step_subset (h : ∀ s a b, color (s+1) a = color (s+1) b → color s a = color s b) (s : ℕ) : kernel color (s + 1) ⊆ kernel color s := by classical intro ab hab simp only [kernel, Finset.mem_filter, Finset.mem_univ, true_and] at hab ⊢ exact h s ab.1 ab.2 hab /-- A descending Boolean relation on N objects must settle by N² rounds. This coarse bound avoids an implicit unit-cost operation on full color names. -/ theorem exists_adjacent (h : ∀ s a b, color (s+1) a = color (s+1) b → color s a = color s b) : ∃ s ≤ Fintype.card A ^ 2, KernelEq color s (s+1) := by classical let N := Fintype.card A ^ 2 by_contra hn have hstrict (s : ℕ) (hs : s ≤ N) : (kernel color (s + 1)).card < (kernel color s).card := by apply Finset.card_lt_card exact (kernel_step_subset color h s).ssubset_of_ne (by intro he exact hn ⟨s, hs, (kernel_eq_iff color s (s+1)).mp he.symm⟩) have hsum (s : ℕ) (hs : s ≤ N + 1) : (kernel color s).card + s ≤ (kernel color 0).card := by induction s with | zero => simp | succ s ih => have hlt := hstrict s (by omega); have hi := ih (by omega); omega have hc : (kernel color 0).card ≤ N := by calc _ ≤ Fintype.card (A × A) := Finset.card_le_univ _ _ = N := by simp [N, pow_two] have := hsum (N+1) (by omega) omega omit [Fintype A] in theorem KernelEq.refl (s : ℕ) : KernelEq color s s := fun _ _ => Iff.rfl omit [Fintype A] in theorem KernelEq.symm {s t : ℕ} (h : KernelEq color s t) : KernelEq color t s := fun a b => (h a b).symm omit [Fintype A] in theorem KernelEq.trans {s t u : ℕ} (h : KernelEq color s t) (h' : KernelEq color t u) : KernelEq color s u := fun a b => (h a b).trans (h' a b) variable (hrefine : ∀ s a b, color (s+1) a = color (s+1) b → color s a = color s b) (hstep : ∀ s t, KernelEq color s t → KernelEq color (s+1) (t+1)) omit [Fintype A] in include hrefine in theorem earlier {s t : ℕ} (hst : s ≤ t) (a b : A) (h : color t a = color t b) : color s a = color s b := by induction t, hst using Nat.le_induction with | base => exact h | succ t ht ih => exact ih (hrefine t a b h) omit [Fintype A] in include hstep in theorem stable_tail {s : ℕ} (h : KernelEq color s (s+1)) (u : ℕ) : KernelEq color s (s+u) := by induction u with | zero => exact KernelEq.refl color s | succ u ih => have ht : KernelEq color (s+1) (s+u+1) := hstep s (s+u) ih exact (h.trans color ht) include hrefine hstep in /-- The one stored Boolean relation after the explicit cutoff decides equality at every refinement depth, including all later rounds. -/ theorem cutoff (a b : A) (s : ℕ) : color (Fintype.card A ^ 2) a = color (Fintype.card A ^ 2) b → color s a = color s b := by intro he let N := Fintype.card A ^ 2 obtain ⟨t, ht, hstable⟩ := exists_adjacent color hrefine by_cases hs : s ≤ N · exact earlier color hrefine hs a b he · have hte := earlier color hrefine ht a b he have hts : t ≤ s := by omega have htail := stable_tail color hstep hstable (s-t) rw [Nat.add_sub_of_le hts] at htail exact (htail a b).mp hte include hrefine hstep in theorem histogram_cutoff (L M : Multiset A) : (∀ s, L.map (color s) = M.map (color s)) ↔ L.map (color (Fintype.card A ^ 2)) = M.map (color (Fintype.card A ^ 2)) := by constructor · exact fun h => h _ · intro h s exact map_eq_of_kernel _ _ L M (fun a b => cutoff color hrefine hstep a b s) h omit [Fintype A] in /-- Equality of replacement-vector histograms is determined by the old kernel, so the same stored relation supports ordinary and joint tuple updates. -/ theorem successor_kernel {I : Type} (N : A → Multiset (I → A)) (hupdate : ∀ s a b, color (s+1) a = color (s+1) b ↔ color s a = color s b ∧ (N a).map (fun v i => color s (v i)) = (N b).map (fun v i => color s (v i))) : ∀ s t, KernelEq color s t → KernelEq color (s+1) (t+1) := by intro s t h a b rw [hupdate, hupdate, h a b] apply and_congr Iff.rfl apply map_eq_iff_kernel intro v w simp only [funext_iff] exact forall_congr' (fun i => h (v i) (w i)) end FiniteRefinement namespace FiniteRefinement theorem successor_kernel_scalar {A : Type} {C : ℕ → Type} (color : (s : ℕ) → A → C s) (N : A → Multiset A) (hupdate : ∀ s a b, color (s+1) a = color (s+1) b ↔ color s a = color s b ∧ (N a).map (color s) = (N b).map (color s)) : ∀ s t, KernelEq color s t → KernelEq color (s+1) (t+1) := by intro s t h a b rw [hupdate, hupdate, h a b] apply and_congr Iff.rfl exact map_eq_iff_kernel _ _ _ _ h end FiniteRefinement namespace FiniteWL def neighbor (G H : Graph) (s : ℕ) : Fin G.order ⊕ Fin H.order → NeighborColor s := Sum.elim (neighborColor G s) (neighborColor H s) def neighbors (G H : Graph) : Fin G.order ⊕ Fin H.order → Multiset (Fin G.order ⊕ Fin H.order) | .inl x => (Finset.univ.filter (fun y => G.edge x y = true)).val.map Sum.inl | .inr x => (Finset.univ.filter (fun y => H.edge x y = true)).val.map Sum.inr theorem neighbor_update (G H : Graph) (s : ℕ) (a b : Fin G.order ⊕ Fin H.order) : neighbor G H (s+1) a = neighbor G H (s+1) b ↔ neighbor G H s a = neighbor G H s b ∧ (neighbors G H a).map (neighbor G H s) = (neighbors G H b).map (neighbor G H s) := by cases a <;> cases b <;> dsimp only [neighbor, neighborColor, neighbors, Sum.elim] <;> simp only [Multiset.map_map, Function.comp_def, Sum.elim_inl, Sum.elim_inr] <;> exact Prod.ext_iff theorem neighbor_cutoff (G H : Graph) : (∀ s, neighborHistogram G s = neighborHistogram H s) ↔ neighborHistogram G ((G.order + H.order)^2) = neighborHistogram H ((G.order+H.order)^2) := by have hr s a b (h : neighbor G H (s+1) a = neighbor G H (s+1) b) := ((neighbor_update G H s a b).mp h).1 have hs := FiniteRefinement.successor_kernel_scalar (neighbor G H) (neighbors G H) (neighbor_update G H) have he := FiniteRefinement.histogram_cutoff (neighbor G H) hr hs ((Finset.univ : Finset (Fin G.order)).val.map Sum.inl) ((Finset.univ : Finset (Fin H.order)).val.map Sum.inr) have hc : Fintype.card (Fin G.order ⊕ Fin H.order) = G.order + H.order := by simp rw [hc] at he simpa only [Multiset.map_map, Function.comp_def, neighbor, Sum.elim_inl, Sum.elim_inr, neighborHistogram] using he def tuple (G H : Graph) (k s : ℕ) : (Fin k → Fin G.order) ⊕ (Fin k → Fin H.order) → TupleColor k s := Sum.elim (tupleColor G k s) (tupleColor H k s) def vectors (G H : Graph) (k : ℕ) : (Fin k → Fin G.order) ⊕ (Fin k → Fin H.order) → Multiset (Fin k → ((Fin k → Fin G.order) ⊕ (Fin k → Fin H.order))) | .inl x => Finset.univ.val.map (fun z i => Sum.inl (Function.update x i z)) | .inr x => Finset.univ.val.map (fun z i => Sum.inr (Function.update x i z)) theorem tuple_update (G H : Graph) (k s : ℕ) (a b : (Fin k → Fin G.order) ⊕ (Fin k → Fin H.order)) : tuple G H k (s+1) a = tuple G H k (s+1) b ↔ tuple G H k s a = tuple G H k s b ∧ (vectors G H k a).map (fun v i => tuple G H k s (v i)) = (vectors G H k b).map (fun v i => tuple G H k s (v i)) := by cases a <;> cases b <;> dsimp only [tuple, tupleColor, vectors, Sum.elim] <;> simp only [Multiset.map_map, Function.comp_def] <;> exact Prod.ext_iff theorem tuple_cutoff (G H : Graph) (k : ℕ) : (∀ s, tupleHistogram G k s = tupleHistogram H k s) ↔ tupleHistogram G k ((G.order^k+H.order^k)^2) = tupleHistogram H k ((G.order^k+H.order^k)^2) := by have hr s a b (h : tuple G H k (s+1) a = tuple G H k (s+1) b) := ((tuple_update G H k s a b).mp h).1 have hs := FiniteRefinement.successor_kernel (tuple G H k) (vectors G H k) (tuple_update G H k) have he := FiniteRefinement.histogram_cutoff (tuple G H k) hr hs ((Finset.univ : Finset (Fin k → Fin G.order)).val.map Sum.inl) ((Finset.univ : Finset (Fin k → Fin H.order)).val.map Sum.inr) have hc : Fintype.card ((Fin k → Fin G.order) ⊕ (Fin k → Fin H.order)) = G.order ^ k + H.order ^ k := by simp rw [hc] at he simpa only [Multiset.map_map, Function.comp_def, tuple, Sum.elim_inl, Sum.elim_inr, tupleHistogram] using he /-- Explicit finite stopping criteria, retaining neighbor refinement precisely at k=1. -/ theorem equivalent_cutoff (G H : Graph) (k : ℕ) : Equivalent k G H ↔ if k = 1 then neighborHistogram G ((G.order+H.order)^2) = neighborHistogram H ((G.order+H.order)^2) else tupleHistogram G k ((G.order^k+H.order^k)^2) = tupleHistogram H k ((G.order^k+H.order^k)^2) := by unfold Equivalent split_ifs · exact neighbor_cutoff G H · exact tuple_cutoff G H k end FiniteWL namespace FiniteRefinement /-- Image multiset equality is checked by finite class counts; there is no unit-cost comparison of recursively expanded color trees. -/ theorem map_eq_iff_counts {A C : Type} [DecidableEq C] (f : A → C) (L M : Multiset A) : L.map f = M.map f ↔ ∀ a, L.countP (fun b => f b = f a) = M.countP (fun b => f b = f a) := by constructor · intro h a have he := congrArg (Multiset.count (f a)) h simpa only [Multiset.count_map, ← Multiset.countP_eq_card_filter, eq_comm] using he · intro h apply Multiset.ext.mpr intro c by_cases hc : ∃ a, f a = c · obtain ⟨a, rfl⟩ := hc simpa only [Multiset.count_map, ← Multiset.countP_eq_card_filter, eq_comm] using h a · have hL : c ∉ L.map f := by simpa only [Multiset.mem_map, not_exists, not_and] using (fun a (_ : a ∈ L) ha => hc ⟨a, ha⟩) have hM : c ∉ M.map f := by simpa only [Multiset.mem_map, not_exists, not_and] using (fun a (_ : a ∈ M) ha => hc ⟨a, ha⟩) rw [Multiset.count_eq_zero_of_notMem hL, Multiset.count_eq_zero_of_notMem hM] variable {A I : Type} [Fintype A] [Fintype I] [DecidableEq A] [DecidableEq I] def vectorMatch (R : A → A → Bool) (v w : I → A) : Bool := decide (∀ i, R (v i) (w i) = true) def tableStep (N : A → Multiset (I → A)) (R : A → A → Bool) (a b : A) : Bool := R a b && decide (∀ v : I → A, (N a).countP (fun w => vectorMatch R w v = true) = (N b).countP (fun w => vectorMatch R w v = true)) omit [DecidableEq A] in /-- Reusable correctness of a table update, including the joint vector test. -/ theorem tableStep_correct {C D : Type} [DecidableEq C] (old : A → C) (next : A → D) (N : A → Multiset (I → A)) (R : A → A → Bool) (hR : ∀ a b, R a b = true ↔ old a = old b) (hnext : ∀ a b, next a = next b ↔ old a = old b ∧ (N a).map (fun v i => old (v i)) = (N b).map (fun v i => old (v i))) (a b : A) : tableStep N R a b = true ↔ next a = next b := by rw [hnext] simp only [tableStep, Bool.and_eq_true, decide_eq_true_eq, hR] apply and_congr Iff.rfl rw [map_eq_iff_counts] have hm (w v : I → A) : vectorMatch R w v = true ↔ (fun i => old (w i)) = (fun i => old (v i)) := by simp only [vectorMatch, decide_eq_true_eq, funext_iff] exact forall_congr' (fun i => hR (w i) (v i)) simp only [hm] /-- Literal finite Boolean relation iteration. -/ def table (N : A → Multiset (I → A)) (initial : A → A → Bool) (rounds : ℕ) : A → A → Bool := (tableStep N)^[rounds] initial omit [DecidableEq A] in theorem table_correct {C : ℕ → Type} [∀ s, DecidableEq (C s)] (color : (s : ℕ) → A → C s) (N : A → Multiset (I → A)) (hnext : ∀ s a b, color (s+1) a = color (s+1) b ↔ color s a = color s b ∧ (N a).map (fun v i => color s (v i)) = (N b).map (fun v i => color s (v i))) (initial : A → A → Bool) (hinit : ∀ a b, initial a b = true ↔ color 0 a = color 0 b) (s : ℕ) (a b : A) : table N initial s a b = true ↔ color s a = color s b := by induction s generalizing a b with | zero => exact hinit a b | succ s ih => simp only [table, Function.iterate_succ_apply'] exact tableStep_correct (color s) (color (s+1)) N _ (fun a b => ih (a:=a) (b:=b)) (hnext s) a b end FiniteRefinement end WLIdentification end OAI