import OAI.Computability.WeisfeilerLeman.RAMInstruction namespace OAI universe uK uX uT namespace WLTime.RAMAlphabet open TypedStack open scoped Classical noncomputable section variable (A : RAM) def instruction (w : ℕ) : (I : RAMInstruction A.registers A.locations) → (∀op ∈ I.operations,op ∈ operations A) → Code (Reg A) (Letter A) | .halt b,_ => haltCode A b | .jump pc,_ => jumpCode A pc | .compute op next,h => .seq (compute A w op (h op (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations]))) (instruction w next (fun q hq => h q (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations,hq]))) | .load dest addr next,h => .seq (memCode A (RAMMemory.load w dest.val addr.val)) (instruction w next h) | .store addr src next,h => .seq (memCode A (RAMMemory.save w addr.val src.val)) (instruction w next h) | .branchZero reg yes no,h => .seq (memCode A (RAMTests.testCode w reg.val)) (.branch (fun v => ((v (.inl 11)).map (decode A)).getD false) (.seq (.pop (.inl 11)) (instruction w no (fun q hq => h q (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations,hq])))) (.seq (.pop (.inl 11)) (instruction w yes (fun q hq => h q (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations,hq]))))) theorem bound_mono (B L D E : ℕ) (h : D≤E) : B*D*(L+D+1)≤B*E*(L+E+2) := Nat.mul_le_mul (Nat.mul_le_mul_left _ h) (by omega) theorem instruction_exec {w : ℕ} (hw : 0 obtain ⟨u,hu,he⟩ := halt_exec A C b refine ⟨u,?_,he⟩ exact (hu.trans (six_le_unit A w)).trans (by simp only [RAMInstruction.depth,Nat.mul_one]; exact Nat.le_mul_of_pos_right _ (by omega)) | jump pc => refine ⟨6,?_,jump_exec A C pc⟩ exact (six_le_unit A w).trans (by simp only [RAMInstruction.depth,Nat.mul_one]; exact Nat.le_mul_of_pos_right _ (by omega)) | compute op next ih => let hn : ∀q ∈ next.operations,q ∈ operations A := fun q hq => h q (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations,hq]) let hop : op ∈ operations A := h op (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations]) obtain ⟨x,hx,he⟩ := compute_exec A op hop C obtain ⟨y,hy,hf⟩ := ih hn {C with registers := op.apply w C.registers} refine ⟨x+y,?_,Code.Exec.seq he hf⟩ apply combine_cost · exact (hx.trans (op_le_unit A w op hop)).trans (Nat.le_mul_of_pos_right _ (by omega)) · exact hy.trans (bound_mono _ _ _ _ le_rfl) | load dest addr next ih => obtain ⟨x,hx,he⟩ := RAMMemory.load_exec hw C.registers C.log dest addr have hh := mem_exec A he C.pc C.answer obtain ⟨y,hy,hf⟩ := ih h {C with registers := Function.update C.registers dest (WordMemory.read (C.registers addr) C.log)} refine ⟨x+y,?_,Code.Exec.seq hh hf⟩ apply combine_cost · exact hx.trans (memory_le_unit A w C.log.length) · exact hy.trans (bound_mono _ _ _ _ le_rfl) | store addr src next ih => obtain ⟨x,hx,he⟩ := RAMMemory.save_exec C.registers C.log addr src have hh := mem_exec A he C.pc C.answer obtain ⟨y,hy,hf⟩ := ih h {C with log := (C.registers addr,C.registers src)::C.log} refine ⟨x+y,?_,Code.Exec.seq hh hf⟩ apply combine_cost · exact hx.trans ((memory_le_unit A w 0).trans (by simpa using Nat.le_mul_of_pos_right (unitCost A w) (by omega : 0 let hy : ∀q ∈ yes.operations,q ∈ operations A := fun q hq => h q (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations,hq]) let hn : ∀q ∈ no.operations,q ∈ operations A := fun q hq => h q (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations,hq]) obtain ⟨x,hx,he⟩ := RAMTests.exec C.registers reg (SparseLookup.flatten (WordMemory.entries C.log)) have hh := mem_exec A he C.pc C.answer have hp := mem_exec A (RAMTests.pop_exec (registerBits C.registers) (SparseLookup.flatten (WordMemory.entries C.log)) ((wordBits (C.registers reg)).any id)) C.pc C.answer have htest := test_tops A (registerBits C.registers) (SparseLookup.flatten (WordMemory.entries C.log)) ((wordBits (C.registers reg)).any id) C.pc C.answer have hx' : x+3≤unitCost A w*(C.log.length+1) := (show x+3≤unitCost A w from (by have ht := test_le_unit A w; omega)).trans (Nat.le_mul_of_pos_right _ (by omega)) by_cases hz : (C.registers reg).val=0 · have hb := (ZeroTest.word_zero_iff (C.registers reg)).mpr hz have ht := htest.trans hb obtain ⟨y,hy',hf⟩ := ih hy C have hc := Code.Exec.seq hh (Code.Exec.branch_false (a:=.seq (.pop (.inl 11)) (instruction A w no hn)) (p:=fun v : Tops (Reg A) (Letter A) => ((v (.inl 11)).map (decode A)).getD false) ht (Code.Exec.seq hp hf)) refine ⟨x+(1+(2+y)),?_,?_⟩ · have hy'' := hy'.trans (bound_mono (unitCost A w) C.log.length yes.depth (max yes.depth no.depth) (le_max_left _ _)) have hbound := combine_cost (unitCost A w) C.log.length (max yes.depth no.depth) (x+3) y hx' hy'' simpa only [RAMInstruction.depth,Nat.add_assoc,Nat.add_comm,Nat.add_left_comm] using hbound · convert hc using 1 all_goals try rfl · omega · simp only [SparseRAM.execute,ite_eq_left hz] · have hb : (wordBits (C.registers reg)).any id=true := by cases hb : (wordBits (C.registers reg)).any id · exact False.elim (hz ((ZeroTest.word_zero_iff _).mp hb)) · rfl have ht := htest.trans hb obtain ⟨y,hy',hf⟩ := ih' hn C have hc := Code.Exec.seq hh (Code.Exec.branch_true (b:=.seq (.pop (.inl 11)) (instruction A w yes hy)) (p:=fun v : Tops (Reg A) (Letter A) => ((v (.inl 11)).map (decode A)).getD false) ht (Code.Exec.seq hp hf)) refine ⟨x+(1+(2+y)),?_,?_⟩ · have hy'' := hy'.trans (bound_mono (unitCost A w) C.log.length no.depth (max yes.depth no.depth) (le_max_right _ _)) have hbound := combine_cost (unitCost A w) C.log.length (max yes.depth no.depth) (x+3) y hx' hy'' simpa only [RAMInstruction.depth,Nat.add_assoc,Nat.add_comm,Nat.add_left_comm] using hbound · convert hc using 1 all_goals try rfl · omega · simp only [SparseRAM.execute,ite_eq_right hz] end end WLTime.RAMAlphabet namespace WLTime.RAMAlphabet open TypedStack open scoped Classical noncomputable section variable (A : RAM) theorem encode_length_bound (w : ℕ) : (encodeNat w).length ≤ 2*w+1 := by have hd : (Nat.digits 2 w).length≤w := (Nat.digits_length_le_iff (by decide) w).mpr w.lt_two_pow_self simp only [encodeNat,List.length_append,List.length_replicate,List.length_cons,List.length_nil,List.length_map] omega def exponent : ℕ := 1+Finset.univ.sup (fun i : Index A => (operation A i).exponent) def opConstant (op : WordOperation A.registers) : ℕ := 7+TMPort.factor op.implementation*(2*A.registers+op.constant+4) def constant : ℕ := 1000*(A.registers+1)+∑i : Index A,opConstant A (operation A i) theorem opCost_bound (w : ℕ) (op : WordOperation A.registers) : opCost A w op ≤ opConstant A op*(w+1)^(op.exponent+1) := by have hl := encode_length_bound w have hp : w+1≤(w+1)^(op.exponent+1) := by simpa only [pow_one] using Nat.pow_le_pow_right (by omega : 0 (operation A i).exponent) (Finset.mem_univ i) unfold exponent; omega exact (opCost_bound A w (operation A i)).trans (Nat.mul_le_mul_left _ (Nat.pow_le_pow_right (by omega) hi)) have hb := Nat.mul_le_mul_left (1000*(A.registers+1)) hw dsimp only [unitCost,constant] nlinarith only [hs,hb] def opSizeConstant (op : WordOperation A.registers) : ℕ := 10+TMPort.sizeFactor op.implementation*(2*A.registers+4) theorem compute_linear (w : ℕ) (op : WordOperation A.registers) (h : op ∈ operations A) : (compute A w op h).controlSize ≤ opSizeConstant A op*(w+1) := by have he := compute_size A w op h have hl := encode_length_bound w have hh := Nat.mul_le_mul_left (TMPort.sizeFactor op.implementation) (show (encodeNat w).length+2*(A.registers*w)+1≤(2*A.registers+4)*(w+1) by nlinarith only [hl]) dsimp only [opSizeConstant] nlinarith only [he,hl,hh] theorem instruction_linear (I : RAMInstruction A.registers A.locations) : ∃S,∀w h,(instruction A w I h).controlSize≤S*(w+1) := by induction I with | halt b => refine ⟨10,?_⟩ intro w h simp only [instruction,haltCode,Code.controlSize,Code.clear] omega | jump pc => refine ⟨10,?_⟩ intro w h simp only [instruction,jumpCode,Code.controlSize,Code.clear] omega | compute op next ih => obtain ⟨S,hS⟩ := ih refine ⟨opSizeConstant A op+S+1,?_⟩ intro w h have hn : ∀q∈next.operations,q∈operations A := fun q hq => h q (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations,hq]) have ho := compute_linear A w op (h op (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations])) have hs := hS w hn simp only [instruction,Code.controlSize] nlinarith only [ho,hs] | load dest addr next ih => obtain ⟨S,hS⟩ := ih refine ⟨500*(A.registers+1)+S+1,?_⟩ intro w h have hm := RAMMemory.load_size A.registers w dest addr have hs := hS w h simp only [instruction,Code.controlSize,memCode_size] simp only [RAMMemory.cost,Nat.zero_add,Nat.mul_one] at hm nlinarith only [hm,hs] | store addr src next ih => obtain ⟨S,hS⟩ := ih refine ⟨500*(A.registers+1)+S+1,?_⟩ intro w h have hm := RAMMemory.save_size A.registers w addr src have hs := hS w h simp only [instruction,Code.controlSize,memCode_size] simp only [RAMMemory.cost,Nat.zero_add,Nat.mul_one] at hm nlinarith only [hm,hs] | branchZero reg yes no ih ih' => obtain ⟨S,hS⟩ := ih obtain ⟨T,hT⟩ := ih' refine ⟨110*(A.registers+1)+S+T+10,?_⟩ intro w h have hy : ∀q∈yes.operations,q∈operations A := fun q hq => h q (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations,hq]) have hn : ∀q∈no.operations,q∈operations A := fun q hq => h q (by simp [RAMInstruction.operations,hq]) have hs := hS w hy have ht := hT w hn have hm := RAMTests.code_size A.registers w reg simp only [instruction,Code.controlSize,memCode_size] nlinarith only [hs,ht,hm] end end WLTime.RAMAlphabet namespace WLTime.TypedStack.Code variable {K : Type uK} {X : Type uX} {T : Type uT} [DecidableEq K] [DecidableEq T] omit [DecidableEq K] in theorem casesList_size (select : Tops K X → T) (body : T → Code K X) (xs : List T) : (casesList select body xs).controlSize=1+xs.length+(xs.map (fun x => (body x).controlSize)).sum := by induction xs with | nil => rfl | cons x xs ih => simp only [casesList,controlSize,ih,List.length_cons,List.map_cons,List.sum_cons]; omega omit [DecidableEq K] in theorem casesAll_size [Fintype T] (select : Tops K X → T) (body : T → Code K X) : (casesAll select body).controlSize=1+Fintype.card T+∑x : T,(body x).controlSize := by rw [casesAll,casesList_size,Finset.length_toList,Finset.card_univ] congr 1 exact Finset.sum_map_toList _ _ end WLTime.TypedStack.Code namespace WLTime.SparseRAM theorem iterate_fixed (A : RAM) (w : ℕ) (C : Config A.registers A.locations w) (h : C.answer.isSome=true) (t : ℕ) : (step A w)^[t] C=C := by induction t with | zero => rfl | succ t ih => rw [Function.iterate_succ_apply',ih,step_fixed A w C h] end WLTime.SparseRAM namespace WLTime.RAMAlphabet open TypedStack open scoped Classical noncomputable section variable (A : RAM) def depth : ℕ := Finset.univ.sup (fun pc : Fin A.locations => (A.program pc).depth) theorem depth_le (pc : Fin A.locations) : (A.program pc).depth≤depth A := Finset.le_sup (f:=fun pc : Fin A.locations => (A.program pc).depth) (Finset.mem_univ pc) theorem depth_pos : 0 pc | _ => ⟨0,A.locations_pos⟩ def dispatch (w : ℕ) : Code (Reg A) (Letter A) := Code.casesAll (selectPC A) (fun pc : Fin A.locations => instruction A w (A.program pc) (mem_program A pc)) def stepBound (w L : ℕ) : ℕ := unitCost A w*depth A*(L+depth A+1)+A.locations theorem stepBound_mono (w L L' : ℕ) (h : L≤L') : stepBound A w L ≤ stepBound A w L' := by unfold stepBound exact Nat.add_le_add_right (Nat.mul_le_mul_left _ (by omega)) _ theorem select_state {w : ℕ} (C : SparseRAM.Config A.registers A.locations w) : selectPC A (tops (state A C))=C.pc := by simp [selectPC,tops,state,liftMem] theorem dispatch_exec {w : ℕ} (hw : 0 instruction A w (A.program pc) (mem_program A pc)) (selectPC A (tops (state A C)))).Exec (state A C) t (state A (SparseRAM.execute (A.program C.pc) C)) := by simpa only [select_state] using he obtain ⟨u,hu,hg⟩ := Code.casesAll_exec (selectPC A) (fun pc : Fin A.locations => instruction A w (A.program pc) (mem_program A pc)) hh refine ⟨u,?_,hg⟩ simp only [Fintype.card_fin] at hu have hd := depth_le A C.pc have hb : t≤unitCost A w*depth A*(C.log.length+depth A+1) := ht.trans (Nat.mul_le_mul (Nat.mul_le_mul_left _ hd) (by omega)) unfold stepBound omega def running (v : Tops (Reg A) (Letter A)) : Bool := !(v (.inl 13)).isSome def loopCode (w : ℕ) : Code (Reg A) (Letter A) := .loop (running A) (dispatch A w) theorem running_state {w : ℕ} (C : SparseRAM.Config A.registers A.locations w) : running A (tops (state A C)) = !C.answer.isSome := by cases h : C.answer <;> simp [running,tops,state,liftMem,h] theorem loop_exec {w : ℕ} (hw : 0 simp only [Function.iterate_zero, id_eq] at hend ⊢ refine ⟨1,by simp,?_⟩ apply Code.Exec.loop_false simpa only [running_state,hend] using (show (!true)=false by rfl) | succ t ih => cases ha : C.answer with | some b => have hc : C.answer.isSome=true := by rw [ha]; rfl have hf := SparseRAM.iterate_fixed A w C hc (t+1) rw [hf] refine ⟨1,by omega,Code.Exec.loop_false ?_⟩ simp only [running_state,hc,Bool.not_true] | none => let C' := SparseRAM.execute (A.program C.pc) C have hs : SparseRAM.step A w C=C' := by simp [SparseRAM.step,ha,C'] have hend' : ((SparseRAM.step A w)^[t] C').answer.isSome=true := by simpa only [Function.iterate_succ_apply,hs] using hend obtain ⟨x,hx,he⟩ := dispatch_exec A hw C obtain ⟨y,hy,hf⟩ := ih C' hend' have hl : C'.log.length≤C.log.length+depth A := (SparseRAM.execute_log_length (A.program C.pc) C).trans (Nat.add_le_add_left (depth_le A C.pc) _) have hb := stepBound_mono A w C.log.length (C.log.length+(t+1)*depth A) (by omega) have hh := stepBound_mono A w (C'.log.length+t*depth A) (C.log.length+(t+1)*depth A) (by nlinarith only [hl]) refine ⟨x+y+1,?_,?_⟩ · have hh' := Nat.mul_le_mul_right t (Nat.add_le_add_right hh 1) nlinarith only [hx,hy,hb,hh'] · have hg := Code.Exec.loop_true (p:=running A) (by simp only [running_state,ha,Option.isSome_none,Bool.not_false]) he hf simpa only [loopCode,Function.iterate_succ_apply,hs] using hg theorem dispatch_linear : ∃S,∀w,(dispatch A w).controlSize≤S*(w+1) := by choose S hS using fun pc : Fin A.locations => instruction_linear A (A.program pc) refine ⟨1+A.locations+∑pc,S pc,?_⟩ intro w have hs : (∑pc : Fin A.locations,(instruction A w (A.program pc) (mem_program A pc)).controlSize)≤(∑pc,S pc)*(w+1) := by rw [Finset.sum_mul] exact Finset.sum_le_sum (fun pc _ => hS pc w (mem_program A pc)) rw [dispatch,Code.casesAll_size,Fintype.card_fin] nlinarith only [hs] end end WLTime.RAMAlphabet namespace WLTime.RAMAlphabet open TypedStack open scoped Classical noncomputable section variable (A : RAM) def inputMap (i : RAMInput.Reg) : RAMMemory.Reg := ⟨i.val,by omega⟩ theorem inputMap_inj : Function.Injective inputMap := by intro i j h exact Fin.ext (Fin.mk.inj h) def loader (w : ℕ) : Code RAMMemory.Reg Bool := (RAMInput.program w).relabel inputMap theorem loader_exec (w : ℕ) (hw : 0 WordMemory.read q (WordMemory.initialLog w input n))=RAM.packedWord w input ∧ ∃u ≤60*(w+1)*(input.length+1),(loader w).Exec (RAMMemory.state input [] [] []) u (RAMMemory.state [] (SparseLookup.flatten (WordMemory.entries (WordMemory.initialLog w input n))) [] []) := by obtain ⟨n,hn,hm,u,hu,he⟩ := RAMInput.program_exec w hw input hfit refine ⟨n,hn,hm,u,hu,?_⟩ apply Code.relabel_exec_of_maps _ inputMap_inj he · intro i; fin_cases i <;> simp [inputMap,RAMMemory.state,RAMInput.state] · intro i; fin_cases i <;> simp [inputMap,RAMMemory.state,RAMInput.state] · intro i hi; fin_cases i <;> simp_all [inputMap,RAMMemory.state,Fin.forall_fin_succ] def inputState (xs : List Bool) : Stacks (Reg A) (Letter A) := fun r => if r=.inl 0 then xs.map Sum.inl else [] def initial (w : ℕ) (xs : List Bool) (n : ℕ) : SparseRAM.Config A.registers A.locations w where pc := ⟨0,A.locations_pos⟩ registers := fun _ => ⟨0,by positivity⟩ log := WordMemory.initialLog w xs n answer := none def initCode (w : ℕ) : Code (Reg A) (Letter A) := .seq (.push (.inl 12) (.inr (.inl ⟨0,A.locations_pos⟩))) (.seq (memCode A (loader w)) (.pushList (.inl 0) ((List.replicate (A.registers*w) false).map Sum.inl))) def initBound (w len : ℕ) : ℕ := 100*(A.registers+1)*(w+1)*(len+1) theorem init_exec (w : ℕ) (hw : 0 WordMemory.read q (WordMemory.initialLog w input n))=RAM.packedWord w input ∧ ∃u ≤ initBound A w input.length,(initCode A w).Exec (inputState A input) u (state A (initial A w input n)) := by obtain ⟨n,hn,hm,t,ht,he⟩ := loader_exec w hw input hfit have hp : (Code.push (.inl 12) (.inr (.inl ⟨0,A.locations_pos⟩))).Exec (inputState A input) 2 (fileState A input [] ⟨0,A.locations_pos⟩ none) := by have hh := Code.Exec.push (inputState A input) (.inl 12) (.inr (.inl ⟨0,A.locations_pos⟩)) convert hh using 1 funext r cases r with | inl i => fin_cases i <;> simp [inputState,fileState,liftMem,RAMMemory.state] | inr r => simp [inputState,fileState,liftMem] have hh := mem_exec A he ⟨0,A.locations_pos⟩ none have hg := prefix_exec A (List.replicate (A.registers*w) false) [] (SparseLookup.flatten (WordMemory.entries (WordMemory.initialLog w input n))) ⟨0,A.locations_pos⟩ none have hout : fileState A (List.replicate (A.registers*w) false++[]) (SparseLookup.flatten (WordMemory.entries (WordMemory.initialLog w input n))) ⟨0,A.locations_pos⟩ none=state A (initial A w input n) := by simp only [List.append_nil,state,fileState,initial,RegisterFile.zero] rw [hout,List.length_replicate] at hg refine ⟨n,hn,hm,_,?_,Code.Exec.seq hp (Code.Exec.seq hh hg)⟩ have h₁ : (w+1)*(input.length+1)≤(A.registers+1)*(w+1)*(input.length+1) := Nat.mul_le_mul_right _ (by nlinarith) have h₂ : A.registers*w≤(A.registers+1)*(w+1)*(input.length+1) := by exact (by nlinarith : A.registers*w≤(A.registers+1)*(w+1)).trans (Nat.le_mul_of_pos_right _ (by omega)) have h₃ : 1≤(A.registers+1)*(w+1)*(input.length+1) := by have : 0<(A.registers+1)*(w+1)*(input.length+1) := by positivity omega unfold initBound nlinarith only [ht,h₁,h₂,h₃] theorem initial_forget (n : ℕ) (input : List Bool) (chunks : ℕ) (hm : (fun q => WordMemory.read q (WordMemory.initialLog (A.width.bits n) input chunks))=RAM.packedWord (A.width.bits n) input) : SparseRAM.forget A n (initial A (A.width.bits n) input chunks)=A.initial n input := by unfold SparseRAM.forget initial RAM.initial congr 1 def program (w : ℕ) : Code (Reg A) (Letter A) := .seq (initCode A w) (loopCode A w) def budget (w len time : ℕ) : ℕ := initBound A w len+(stepBound A w (len+time*depth A)+1)*time+1 theorem program_exec (n : ℕ) (input : List Bool) (hfit : input.length≤A.width.bits n*2^(A.width.bits n)) (hh : A.halts n input) : ∃u ≤ budget A (A.width.bits n) input.length (A.time n input),∃b out, (program A (A.width.bits n)).Exec (inputState A input) u out ∧ out (.inl 13)=[.inl b] ∧ (b=true ↔ A.accepts n input) := by obtain ⟨chunks,hchunks,hm,t,ht,he⟩ := init_exec A (A.width.bits n) (A.width.positive n) input hfit let C := initial A (A.width.bits n) input chunks let T := A.time n input let out := (SparseRAM.step A (A.width.bits n))^[T] C have hforget : A.run n input T=SparseRAM.forget A n out := by rw [RAM.run,←initial_forget A n input chunks hm] exact SparseRAM.iterate_forget A n C T have hend : out.answer.isSome=true := by have h := A.time_halted n input hh rw [hforget] at h exact h obtain ⟨s,hs,hf⟩ := loop_exec A (A.width.positive n) T C hend have hl : C.log.length=chunks := WordMemory.initialLog_length _ _ _ rw [hl] at hs obtain ⟨b,hb⟩ := Option.isSome_iff_exists.mp hend refine ⟨t+s,?_,b,state A out,Code.Exec.seq he hf,?_,?_⟩ · have hm' := stepBound_mono A (A.width.bits n) (chunks+T*depth A) (input.length+T*depth A) (by omega) have hx := Nat.mul_le_mul_right T (Nat.add_le_add_right hm' 1) unfold budget dsimp only [T] at * omega · simp [state,liftMem,hb] · have ha : (A.run n input T).answer=some b := by rw [hforget]; exact hb exact (A.accepts_iff_answer n input T b ha).symm theorem init_linear (w : ℕ) : (initCode A w).controlSize≤500*(A.registers+1)*(w+1) := by have he := RAMInput.program_size w simp only [initCode,Code.controlSize,memCode_size,loader,Code.relabel_controlSize,Code.pushList_size,List.length_map,List.length_replicate] nlinarith only [he] theorem program_linear : ∃S,∀w,(program A w).controlSize≤S*(w+1) := by obtain ⟨S,hS⟩ := dispatch_linear A refine ⟨500*(A.registers+1)+S+1,?_⟩ intro w have hi := init_linear A w have hd := hS w simp only [program,loopCode,Code.controlSize] nlinarith only [hi,hd] end end WLTime.RAMAlphabet end OAI