import OAI.AlgebraicTopology.IntegralHomology.Obstruction import OAI.Geometry.BundleTests.Normalization namespace OAI noncomputable section /-! Nonvanishing twisted section classes and the stable retained-bundle obstruction. -/ section open Bundle Topology CategoryTheory Set namespace Kaplansky open ComplexGrassmann private theorem sectionProductNormalization {X Y A V : Type} [TopologicalSpace X] [TopologicalSpace Y] [TopologicalSpace A] [TopologicalSpace V] [Zero V] (U : Set X) (W : Set Y) (s : C(X,Y)) (hs : MapsTo s U W) (e : Y ≃ₜ A × V) (f : X ≃ₜ V) (he : ∀ y, y ∈ W ↔ (e y).2 ≠ 0) (hf : ∀ x, x ∈ U ↔ f x ∈ ({0}ᶜ : Set V)) (hcoords : ∀ x, (e (s x)).2 = f x) (n : ℕ) : relativeHomologyMap (subspaceInclusion U) (subspaceInclusion W) (subspaceMap U W s hs) (TopCat.ofHom s) (subspaceMap_square U W s hs) n ≫ ((relativeHomologyHomeomorphIso e W {z | z.2 ≠ 0} he n).hom ≫ productPairProjection (B := A) ({0}ᶜ : Set V) n) = (relativeHomologyHomeomorphIso f U ({0}ᶜ : Set V) hf n).hom := by simp only [relativeHomologyHomeomorphIso_hom] unfold productPairProjection erw [← Category.assoc, relativeHomologyMap_comp, relativeHomologyMap_comp] exact relativeHomologyMap_congr_ambient _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (by ext x : 1 exact hcoords x) n variable {ι : Type} [Fintype ι] (K : ι → ℕ) (h : ℕ) def twistedRestrictedSection : C((twistedStandardChart K h).source, twistedGraphBundleDomain K h (twistedStandardChart K h).source) := ⟨fun P => ⟨⟨P.1,twistedHyperplaneSection K h P.1⟩,P.2⟩, ((continuous_twistedHyperplaneSection K h).comp continuous_subtype_val).subtype_mk _⟩ theorem twistedStandardBundleCoordinates_section (P : (twistedStandardChart K h).source) : twistedGraphBundleCoordinates K h (twistedStandardChart K h).source (twistedStandardChartHomeomorph K h) (twistedStandardFrames K h) subset_rfl (twistedRestrictedSection K h P) = (twistedStandardChartHomeomorph K h P, twistedSlopeEvaluationEquiv K h (twistedStandardChartHomeomorph K h P)) := by apply Prod.ext · rfl let A := twistedStandardChartHomeomorph K h P have hP : P.1 = canonicalProductGraphPoint (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h) A := by change P.1 = ((twistedStandardChartHomeomorph K h).symm (twistedStandardChartHomeomorph K h P)).val rw [Homeomorph.symm_apply_apply] change (fun s => (show EuclideanSpace ℂ (TwistedHyperplaneSlot K h) from twistedHyperplaneSection K h P.1) s / (show ℂ from twistedStandardLineUnit K h s A)) = _ rw [hP] exact twistedStandardSectionCoordinates_eq K h A def twistedLocalSectionHomeomorph : (twistedStandardChart K h).source ≃ₜ (TwistedHyperplaneSlot K h → ℂ) := (twistedStandardChartHomeomorph K h).trans (twistedSlopeEvaluationEquiv K h).toHomeomorph theorem twistedLocalSectionHomeomorph_zero : twistedLocalSectionHomeomorph K h ⟨firstCoordinateProduct (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h), canonicalProduct_zero_in_chart (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h)⟩ = 0 := by change twistedSlopeEvaluationEquiv K h (canonicalProductChartHomeomorph _ _) = 0 rw [canonicalProductChartHomeomorph_zero,map_zero] def twistedLocalSectionRelativeIso (n : ℕ) := relativeHomologyHomeomorphIso (twistedLocalSectionHomeomorph K h) ({⟨firstCoordinateProduct (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h), canonicalProduct_zero_in_chart (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h)⟩}ᶜ : Set (twistedStandardChart K h).source) ({0}ᶜ : Set (TwistedHyperplaneSlot K h → ℂ)) (fun P => by change P ≠ _ ↔ twistedLocalSectionHomeomorph K h P ≠ 0 rw [← twistedLocalSectionHomeomorph_zero K h] exact (not_congr (twistedLocalSectionHomeomorph K h).injective.eq_iff).symm) n def twistedRestrictedSectionRelativeMap (n : ℕ) := relativeHomologyMap (subspaceInclusion ({⟨firstCoordinateProduct (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h), canonicalProduct_zero_in_chart (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h)⟩}ᶜ : Set (twistedStandardChart K h).source)) (subspaceInclusion (Subtype.val ⁻¹' nonzeroBundle : Set (twistedGraphBundleDomain K h (twistedStandardChart K h).source))) (subspaceMap _ _ (twistedRestrictedSection K h) (by intro P hP exact (mem_nonzeroBundle _).mpr (fun hz => hP (Subtype.ext ((twistedHyperplaneSection_eq_zero_iff K h P.1).mp hz))))) (TopCat.ofHom (twistedRestrictedSection K h)) (by rfl) n theorem twistedRestrictedSection_normalization (n : ℕ) : twistedRestrictedSectionRelativeMap K h n ≫ twistedGraphBundleNormalization K h (twistedStandardChart K h).source (twistedStandardChartHomeomorph K h) (twistedStandardFrames K h) subset_rfl n = (twistedLocalSectionRelativeIso K h n).hom := by apply sectionProductNormalization ({⟨firstCoordinateProduct (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h), canonicalProduct_zero_in_chart (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h)⟩}ᶜ) (Subtype.val ⁻¹' nonzeroBundle) (twistedRestrictedSection K h) _ (twistedGraphBundleCoordinates K h (twistedStandardChart K h).source (twistedStandardChartHomeomorph K h) (twistedStandardFrames K h) subset_rfl) (twistedLocalSectionHomeomorph K h) intro P exact congrArg Prod.snd (twistedStandardBundleCoordinates_section K h P) theorem twistedGraphBundleChartNormalization_isIso (F : ∀ i, GraphFrame 1 (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h i)) (n : ℕ) : IsIso (twistedGraphBundleChartNormalization K h F n) := by let e := twistedGraphBundleRelativeIso K h (projectiveProductGraphChart (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h) F).source (projectiveProductGraphHomeomorph (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h) F) F subset_rfl n let f := productPairProjection (B := ProjectiveProductModel (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h)) ({0}ᶜ : Set (TwistedHyperplaneSlot K h → ℂ)) n change IsIso (e.hom ≫ f) exact IsIso.comp_isIso' e.isIso_hom (productPairProjection_isIso _ _) theorem twistedGraphBundleChartToAmbient_mono (F : ∀ i, GraphFrame 1 (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h i)) (hp : 0 < h+∑ i, K i) : Mono (restrictedPairToAmbientHomologyMap (twistedGraphBundleChartDomain K h F) nonzeroBundle (2*(h+∑ i, K i))) := by obtain ⟨f,hf⟩ := twistedHyperplaneBundle_exists_global_normalization K h F hp have : IsIso (restrictedPairToAmbientHomologyMap (twistedGraphBundleChartDomain K h F) nonzeroBundle (2*(h+∑ i, K i)) ≫ f) := by rw [hf] exact twistedGraphBundleChartNormalization_isIso K h F _ exact mono_of_mono (restrictedPairToAmbientHomologyMap (twistedGraphBundleChartDomain K h F) nonzeroBundle (2*(h+∑ i, K i))) f theorem twistedProjectiveDimensions_sum : ∑ i, twistedProjectiveDimensions K h i = h+∑ i, K i := by rw [Fintype.sum_option] rfl def twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap (n : ℕ) := relativeHomologyMap (subspaceInclusion ({firstCoordinateProduct (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h)}ᶜ : Set (ProjectiveProduct (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h)))) (subspaceInclusion (nonzeroBundle (V := EuclideanSpace ℂ (TwistedHyperplaneSlot K h)) (E := (twistedHyperplaneSumCore K h).Fiber))) (subspaceMap _ _ ⟨_,continuous_twistedHyperplaneSection K h⟩ (by intro P hP exact (mem_nonzeroBundle _).mpr (fun hz => hP ((twistedHyperplaneSection_eq_zero_iff K h P).mp hz)))) (TopCat.ofHom ⟨_,continuous_twistedHyperplaneSection K h⟩) (by rfl) n theorem twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap_chart (n : ℕ) : canonicalChartRelativeInclusion (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h) n ≫ twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap K h n = twistedRestrictedSectionRelativeMap K h n ≫ restrictedPairToAmbientHomologyMap (twistedGraphBundleDomain K h (twistedStandardChart K h).source) nonzeroBundle n := by unfold canonicalChartRelativeInclusion twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap twistedRestrictedSectionRelativeMap change relativeHomologyMap _ _ _ _ _ n ≫ relativeHomologyMap _ _ _ _ _ n = relativeHomologyMap _ _ _ _ _ n ≫ relativeHomologyMap _ _ _ _ _ n erw [relativeHomologyMap_comp,relativeHomologyMap_comp] apply relativeHomologyMap_congr_ambient rfl theorem twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap_mono (hp : 0 < h+∑ i, K i) : Mono (twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap K h (2*(h+∑ i, K i))) := by let n := 2*(h+∑ i, K i) let e := canonicalChartExcisionIso (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h) n let r := twistedRestrictedSectionRelativeMap K h n let f := twistedGraphBundleNormalization K h (twistedStandardChart K h).source (twistedStandardChartHomeomorph K h) (twistedStandardFrames K h) subset_rfl n have : IsIso (r ≫ f) := by change IsIso (twistedRestrictedSectionRelativeMap K h n ≫ _) rw [twistedRestrictedSection_normalization] infer_instance have : Mono r := mono_of_mono r f have : Mono (restrictedPairToAmbientHomologyMap (twistedGraphBundleDomain K h (twistedStandardChart K h).source) nonzeroBundle n) := twistedGraphBundleChartToAmbient_mono K h (twistedStandardFrames K h) hp have he : twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap K h n = e.inv ≫ r ≫ restrictedPairToAmbientHomologyMap (twistedGraphBundleDomain K h (twistedStandardChart K h).source) nonzeroBundle n := by apply (cancel_epi e.hom).mp rw [← Category.assoc,← Category.assoc,e.hom_inv_id,Category.id_comp] exact twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap_chart K h n change Mono (twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap K h n) rw [he] infer_instance theorem twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap_comparison (n : ℕ) : absoluteToRelative (subspaceInclusion ({firstCoordinateProduct (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h)}ᶜ : Set (ProjectiveProduct (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h)))) n ≫ twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap K h n = ordinarySectionClassMap (twistedHyperplaneSection K h) (continuous_twistedHyperplaneSection K h) n := absoluteToRelative_naturality _ _ _ _ _ n /-- The actual twisted section carries the existing augmented-base fundamental class to a nonzero ordinary relative class. -/ theorem twistedOrdinarySection_fundamental_ne_zero (hp : 0 < ∑ i, twistedProjectiveDimensions K h i) : ordinarySectionClassMap (twistedHyperplaneSection K h) (continuous_twistedHyperplaneSection K h) (2*∑ i, twistedProjectiveDimensions K h i) (projectiveProductFundamentalClass (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h) hp) ≠ 0 := by have hp' : 0 < h+∑ i, K i := by rwa [twistedProjectiveDimensions_sum] at hp have : Mono (twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap K h (2*∑ i, twistedProjectiveDimensions K h i)) := by rw [twistedProjectiveDimensions_sum] exact twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap_mono K h hp' rw [← twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap_comparison] change twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap K h _ (absoluteToRelative _ _ (projectiveProductFundamentalClass _ hp)) ≠ 0 rw [projectiveProductFundamentalClass_localizes] intro hz exact canonicalProductLocalGenerator_ne_zero (twistedProjectiveDimensions K h) hp ((ModuleCat.mono_iff_injective (twistedOrdinaryRelativeMap K h _)).mp inferInstance (hz.trans (map_zero _).symm)) theorem twistedHyperplane_every_section_has_zero (hp : 0 < h+∑ i, K i) (s : ∀ P, (twistedHyperplaneSumCore K h).Fiber P) (hs : Continuous (fun P => TotalSpace.mk' (EuclideanSpace ℂ (TwistedHyperplaneSlot K h)) P (s P))) : ∃ P, s P = 0 := by have hp' : 0 < ∑ i, twistedProjectiveDimensions K h i := by rw [twistedProjectiveDimensions_sum]; exact hp by_contra hn push Not at hn have hz := ordinarySectionClassMap_eq_zero s hs hn (2*∑ i, twistedProjectiveDimensions K h i) have he := @ordinarySectionClassMap_eq _ (EuclideanSpace ℂ (TwistedHyperplaneSlot K h)) _ _ _ (twistedHyperplaneSumCore K h).Fiber _ _ _ (twistedHyperplaneSumCore K h).fiberBundle (twistedHyperplaneSumCore K h).vectorBundle (twistedHyperplaneSection K h) s (continuous_twistedHyperplaneSection K h) hs (2*∑ i, twistedProjectiveDimensions K h i) have hz := he.trans hz apply twistedOrdinarySection_fundamental_ne_zero K h hp' rw [hz] rfl end Kaplansky end open Bundle Topology namespace Kaplansky open ComplexGrassmann attribute [local instance 2000] CStarAlgebra.spectralOrder CStarAlgebra.spectralOrderedRing /-- The tensor construction contradicts any frame with more vectors than the displayed trivial rank. The frame need not respect the line summands. -/ theorem twistedSourceStage_no_large_frame {ι : Type} [Fintype ι] (K : ι → ℕ) (h d : ℕ) (hp : 0 < h+∑ i, K i) (hd : h < d) : IsEmpty (ContinuousOrthonormalStageFrame (twistedSourceStage K h) d) := by refine ⟨fun f => ?_⟩ have hd' : 1+h ≤ d := by omega obtain ⟨P,hP⟩ := twistedHyperplane_every_section_has_zero K h hp (twistedFrameSection K h f hd') (continuous_twistedFrameSection K h f hd') exact twistedFrameSection_ne_zero K h f hd' P hP def retainedTwistedSlotEquiv (m R : ℕ) : TwistedHyperplaneSlot (testProjectiveDimension m R) (retainedTrivialMultiplicity m R) ≃ RetainedGroupedSlot m R where toFun | .inl j => ⟨none,j⟩ | .inr s => ⟨some s.1,s.2⟩ invFun | ⟨none,j⟩ => .inl j | ⟨some i,j⟩ => .inr ⟨i,j⟩ left_inv s := by cases s <;> rfl right_inv s := by obtain ⟨i,j⟩ := s; cases i <;> rfl /-- Exact slot regrouping as an actual unitary bundle isomorphism. -/ def retainedTwistedSourceUnitary (m R : ℕ) : UnitaryBundleEquiv (twistedSourceStage (testProjectiveDimension m R) (retainedTrivialMultiplicity m R)).Model (retainedGroupedStage m R).Model (twistedSourceStage (testProjectiveDimension m R) (retainedTrivialMultiplicity m R)).Fiber (retainedGroupedStage m R).Fiber := lineSumRelabelUnitary (testProjectiveDimension m R) (twistedSourceLabel (testProjectiveDimension m R) (retainedTrivialMultiplicity m R)) (fun s : RetainedGroupedSlot m R => s.1) (retainedTwistedSlotEquiv m R) (fun s => by cases s <;> rfl) theorem retainedGrouped_no_test_frame {m R : ℕ} (hm : 0 < m) (hR : 0 < R) : IsEmpty (ContinuousOrthonormalStageFrame (retainedGroupedStage m R) (2*m*testRank m R 0)) := by have hp := retainedTest_hyperplaneDegree_pos hm hR have := twistedSourceStage_no_large_frame (testProjectiveDimension m R) (retainedTrivialMultiplicity m R) (2*m*testRank m R 0) (by omega) (retainedTrivialMultiplicity_bound hm) exact ⟨fun f => isEmptyElim (f.congr (retainedTwistedSourceUnitary m R).symm)⟩ /-- Normalizing an arbitrary independent continuous frame reduces it to the excluded orthonormal frame; no extra metric premise is required. -/ theorem retainedGrouped_no_independent_test_frame {m R : ℕ} (hm : 0 < m) (hR : 0 < R) : IsEmpty (ContinuousIndependentStageFrame (retainedGroupedStage m R) (2*m*testRank m R 0)) := by have := retainedGrouped_no_test_frame hm hR exact ⟨fun f => isEmptyElim f.normalize⟩ theorem actualAlgebra_matrix_not_properlyInfinite {m : ℕ} (hm : 0 < m) : ¬ ProperlyInfinite (CStarMatrix (Fin m) (Fin m) ActualAlgebra) := by intro hpi obtain ⟨R,hR,⟨f⟩⟩ := properlyInfinite_regrouped_frame hm hpi have := retainedGrouped_no_test_frame hm hR exact isEmptyElim f end Kaplansky end end OAI