import OAI.Geometry.ProjectionBody.ProductBrightness import OAI.Geometry.ProjectionBody.ProductZonotopeBridge import OAI.Geometry.Zonotope.EuclideanVolume import OAI.Geometry.ProjectionBody.Arithmetic namespace OAI /-! The geometric projection formulas identify the two actual projection bodies. Their proved Euclidean volumes are substituted into the normalized ratio before the final exact arithmetic is performed. -/ noncomputable section open Set MeasureTheory open scoped RealInnerProductSpace namespace ProjectionCounterexample theorem simplex_twenty_brightness {u : E 20} (hu : ‖u‖ = 1) : projectionVolume (simplex 20) u = (1 / (Nat.factorial 19 : ℝ)) * DiagonalZonotope.support (WithLp.ofLp u) := by rw [simplex_projectionVolume (n := 19) (by decide) hu] unfold DiagonalZonotope.support ring theorem product_brightness {u : E 20} (hu : ‖u‖ = 1) : projectionVolume productBody u = (1 / ((Nat.factorial 9 : ℝ) * Nat.factorial 10)) * blockSupport (n := 10) (m := 10) u := by rw [product_projectionVolume hu] change (((∑ i, |firstBlock u i|) + |∑ i, firstBlock u i|) + ((∑ i, |secondBlock u i|) + |∑ i, secondBlock u i|)) / (2 * ((Nat.factorial 9 : ℝ) * Nat.factorial 10)) = (1 / ((Nat.factorial 9 : ℝ) * Nat.factorial 10)) * (((∑ i, |firstBlock u i|) + |∑ i, firstBlock u i|) / 2 + ((∑ i, |secondBlock u i|) + |∑ i, secondBlock u i|) / 2) ring theorem simplex_twenty_projectionBody : projectionBody (simplex 20) = DiagonalZonotope.euclidean (1 / (Nat.factorial 19 : ℝ)) := projectionBody_eq_zonotope (simplex 20) (1 / (Nat.factorial 19 : ℝ)) (by positivity) (fun _ => simplex_twenty_brightness) theorem product_projectionBody : projectionBody productBody = DiagonalZonotope.euclideanProduct 10 10 (1 / ((Nat.factorial 9 : ℝ) * Nat.factorial 10)) := projectionBody_eq_productZonotope (n := 10) (m := 10) productBody (1 / ((Nat.factorial 9 : ℝ) * Nat.factorial 10)) (by positivity) (fun _ => product_brightness) theorem simplex_twenty_projection_support : IsConvexBody (projectionBody (simplex 20)) ∧ ∀ u : E 20, ‖u‖ = 1 → ∃ x ∈ projectionBody (simplex 20), ⟪u, x⟫ = projectionVolume (simplex 20) u := projection_zonotope_is_body_and_attains (simplex 20) (1 / (Nat.factorial 19 : ℝ)) (by positivity) (fun _ => simplex_twenty_brightness) theorem product_projection_support : IsConvexBody (projectionBody productBody) ∧ ∀ u : E 20, ‖u‖ = 1 → ∃ x ∈ projectionBody productBody, ⟪u, x⟫ = projectionVolume productBody u := projection_productZonotope_is_body_and_attains (n := 10) (m := 10) productBody (1 / ((Nat.factorial 9 : ℝ) * Nat.factorial 10)) (by positivity) (fun _ => product_brightness) theorem simplex_twenty_ratio : ratio (simplex 20) = ((21 : ℝ) * 20 ^ 20) / (Nat.factorial 20 : ℝ) := by unfold ratio bodyVolume rw [simplex_twenty_projectionBody, DiagonalZonotope.volume_euclidean_toReal _ (by positivity), volume_simplex] norm_num [Nat.factorial] theorem product_ratio_value : ratio productBody = (((11 : ℝ) * 10 ^ 10) / (Nat.factorial 10 : ℝ)) ^ 2 := by unfold ratio bodyVolume rw [product_projectionBody, DiagonalZonotope.volume_euclideanProduct_toReal 10 10 _ (by positivity), volume_productBody] norm_num [Nat.factorial] theorem product_to_simplex_ratio : ratio productBody / ratio (simplex 20) = (22355476 : ℝ) / 22020096 := by rw [product_ratio_value, simplex_twenty_ratio] exact numerical_product_ratio theorem product_exceeds_simplex : ratio (simplex 20) < ratio productBody := by have hpos : 0 < ratio (simplex 20) := by rw [simplex_twenty_ratio] positivity have hratio : 1 < ratio productBody / ratio (simplex 20) := by rw [product_to_simplex_ratio] exact numerical_strict_excess simpa using (lt_div_iff₀ hpos).mp hratio theorem universal_simplex_upper_bound_false : ¬ (∀ P : Set (E 20), IsConvexBody P → ratio P ≤ ratio (simplex 20)) := by intro h exact (not_le_of_gt product_exceeds_simplex) (h productBody productBody_convexBody) end ProjectionCounterexample end end OAI