import OAI.GroupTheory.UniversalGroup.MarkerMachine namespace OAI universe u v w x namespace Higman.IntegerStack variable {E : Type*} def code (b : ℤ) (d : E → ℤ) : List E → ℤ | [] => 1 | e :: s => b * code b d s + d e @[simp] theorem code_nil (b : ℤ) (d : E → ℤ) : code b d [] = 1 := rfl @[simp] theorem code_cons (b : ℤ) (d : E → ℤ) (e : E) (s : List E) : code b d (e :: s) = b * code b d s + d e := rfl variable (b : ℤ) (d : E → ℤ) (hb : 2 ≤ b) (hd : ∀ e, 2 ≤ d e ∧ d e < b) include hd lemma push_mod (e : E) (z : ℤ) : (b * z + d e) % b = d e := by rw [Int.add_emod,Int.mul_emod_right,zero_add,Int.emod_emod, Int.emod_eq_of_lt (by have := (hd e).1; omega) (hd e).2] include hb lemma push_ne_empty (e : E) (z : ℤ) : b * z + d e ≠ 1 := by intro h have he := congrArg (fun x : ℤ ↦ x % b) h rw [push_mod b d hd,Int.emod_eq_of_lt (by omega) (by omega)] at he have := (hd e).1 omega lemma push_injective (hdinj : Function.Injective d) {e f : E} {z w : ℤ} (h : b * z + d e = b * w + d f) : e = f ∧ z = w := by have he := congrArg (fun x : ℤ ↦ x % b) h rw [push_mod b d hd,push_mod b d hd] at he have hef := hdinj he subst f refine ⟨rfl,?_⟩ have hm : b * z = b * w := by omega exact mul_left_cancel₀ (by omega : b ≠ 0) hm theorem decode_push (hdinj : Function.Injective d) (e : E) (z : ℤ) (s : List E) : b * z + d e = code b d s ↔ ∃ t, s = e :: t ∧ z = code b d t := by cases s with | nil => simp [push_ne_empty b d hb hd e z] | cons f t => constructor · intro h obtain ⟨hef,hzt⟩ := push_injective b d hb hd hdinj h subst f exact ⟨t,rfl,hzt⟩ · rintro ⟨u,hu,hz⟩ cases hu simp [hz] theorem code_injective (hdinj : Function.Injective d) : Function.Injective (code b d) := by intro s induction s with | nil => intro t h cases t with | nil => rfl | cons e t => exact False.elim (push_ne_empty b d hb hd e (code b d t) h.symm) | cons e s ih => intro t h obtain ⟨u,rfl,hu⟩ := (decode_push b d hb hd hdinj e (code b d s) t).mp h exact congrArg (List.cons e) (ih hu) theorem code_pos (s : List E) : 0 < code b d s := by induction s with | nil => simp | cons e s ih => have hm : 0 < b * code b d s := mul_pos (by omega) ih have hh := (hd e).1 rw [code_cons] omega end Higman.IntegerStack namespace Higman.HistoryMachine variable {E : Type*} {C : Type*} {D : E → Type*} inductive Run (input output : (e : E) → D e → C) (initial : C) : List E → C → Prop | start : Run input output initial [] initial | step {s : List E} (e : E) (z : D e) : Run input output initial s (input e z) → Run input output initial (e :: s) (output e z) variable (input output : (e : E) → D e → C) (initial : C) @[simp] theorem run_nil (c : C) : Run input output initial [] c ↔ c = initial := by constructor · intro h cases h rfl · rintro rfl exact Run.start @[simp] theorem run_cons (e : E) (s : List E) (c : C) : Run input output initial (e :: s) c ↔ ∃ z : D e, c = output e z ∧ Run input output initial s (input e z) := by constructor · intro h cases h with | step e z h => exact ⟨z,rfl,h⟩ · rintro ⟨z,rfl,h⟩ exact Run.step e z h def Reach (b : ℤ) (digit : E → ℤ) (c : C) (history : ℤ) : Prop := ∃ s, Run input output initial s c ∧ history = IntegerStack.code b digit s variable (b : ℤ) (digit : E → ℤ) (hb : 2 ≤ b) (hd : ∀ e, 2 ≤ digit e ∧ digit e < b) (hinj : Function.Injective digit) lemma reach_start : Reach input output initial b digit initial 1 := ⟨[],Run.start,rfl⟩ include hb hd hinj in theorem reach_step_iff (hout : ∀ e, Function.Injective (output e)) (e : E) (z : D e) (h : ℤ) : Reach input output initial b digit (output e z) (b * h + digit e) ↔ Reach input output initial b digit (input e z) h := by constructor · rintro ⟨s,hs,he⟩ obtain ⟨t,rfl,ht⟩ := (IntegerStack.decode_push b digit hb hd hinj e h s).mp he obtain ⟨y,hy,hr⟩ := (run_cons input output initial e t (output e z)).mp hs have hzy : z = y := hout e hy subst y exact ⟨t,hr,ht⟩ · rintro ⟨s,hs,rfl⟩ exact ⟨e :: s,Run.step e z hs,rfl⟩ variable {G : Type*} [Group G] def value (weight : E → G) : List E → G | [] => 1 | e :: s => value weight s * weight e noncomputable def decoration (weight : E → G) (h : ℤ) : G := by classical exact if hh : ∃ s, h = IntegerStack.code b digit s then value weight hh.choose else 1 include hb hd hinj in @[simp] theorem decoration_code (weight : E → G) (s : List E) : decoration b digit weight (IntegerStack.code b digit s) = value weight s := by classical unfold decoration split_ifs with h · have he : h.choose = s := IntegerStack.code_injective b digit hb hd hinj h.choose_spec.symm rw [he] · exact False.elim (h ⟨s,rfl⟩) include hb hd hinj in lemma decoration_step (weight : E → G) (e : E) (z : D e) (h : ℤ) (hr : Reach input output initial b digit (input e z) h) : decoration b digit weight (b * h + digit e) = decoration b digit weight h * weight e := by obtain ⟨s,_,rfl⟩ := hr rw [← IntegerStack.code_cons,decoration_code b digit hb hd hinj, decoration_code b digit hb hd hinj] rfl end Higman.HistoryMachine namespace Higman.RecordedMachine section open MarkerMachine abbrev Counter := Multiplicative ℤ def scale (b : ℤ) : Counter →* Counter where toFun x := Multiplicative.ofAdd (b * x.toAdd) map_one' := by simp map_mul' x y := by simp [mul_add] lemma scale_injective (b : ℤ) (hb : b ≠ 0) : Function.Injective (scale b) := by intro x y h change x.toAdd = y.toAdd exact mul_left_cancel₀ hb (congrArg Multiplicative.toAdd h) variable {G T Q : Type u} [Group G] def augment (c : T × Q) (h : ℤ) : (T × Counter) × Q := ((c.1,Multiplicative.ofAdd h),c.2) def forget (c : (T × Counter) × Q) : T × Q := (c.1.1,c.2) def history (c : (T × Counter) × Q) : ℤ := c.1.2.toAdd @[simp] lemma forget_augment (c : T × Q) (h : ℤ) : forget (augment c h) = c := rfl @[simp] lemma history_augment (c : T × Q) (h : ℤ) : history (augment c h) = h := rfl @[simp] lemma augment_forget (c : (T × Counter) × Q) : augment (forget c) (history c) = c := rfl variable [Group T] def edge (e : Edge G T Q) (b digit : ℤ) (hb : b ≠ 0) : Edge G (T × Counter) Q where Domain := e.Domain × Counter inputLinear := e.inputLinear.prodMap (MonoidHom.id Counter) outputLinear := e.outputLinear.prodMap (scale b) input_injective := by intro x y h exact Prod.ext (e.input_injective (congrArg Prod.fst h)) (congrArg (fun p : T × Counter ↦ p.2) h) output_injective := by intro x y h exact Prod.ext (e.output_injective (congrArg Prod.fst h)) (scale_injective b hb (congrArg Prod.snd h)) inputOffset := (e.inputOffset,1) outputOffset := (e.outputOffset,Multiplicative.ofAdd digit) inputState := e.inputState outputState := e.outputState weight := e.weight @[simp] lemma edge_input (e : Edge G T Q) (b digit : ℤ) (hb : b ≠ 0) (d : e.Domain) (h : Counter) : (edge e b digit hb).input (d,h) = augment (e.input d) h.toAdd := by change ((e.inputLinear d, h) * (e.inputOffset, 1), e.inputState) = _ simp only [Prod.mul_def, mul_one] rfl @[simp] lemma edge_output (e : Edge G T Q) (b digit : ℤ) (hb : b ≠ 0) (d : e.Domain) (h : Counter) : (edge e b digit hb).output (d,h) = augment (e.output d) (b * h.toAdd + digit) := rfl variable {E : Type u} [Fintype E] (edges : E → Edge G T Q) (b : ℤ) (digit : E → ℤ) (hb : 2 ≤ b) noncomputable def edgeList : List (Edge G (T × Counter) Q) := Finset.univ.toList.map (fun e ↦ edge (edges e) b (digit e) (by omega)) lemma mem_edgeList (e : E) : edge (edges e) b (digit e) (by omega) ∈ edgeList edges b digit hb := by classical exact List.mem_map.mpr ⟨e,Finset.mem_toList.mpr (Finset.mem_univ _),rfl⟩ lemma of_mem_edgeList (a : Edge G (T × Counter) Q) (ha : a ∈ edgeList edges b digit hb) : ∃ e, a = edge (edges e) b (digit e) (by omega) := by obtain ⟨e,_,rfl⟩ := List.mem_map.mp ha exact ⟨e,rfl⟩ variable (seed : T × Q) def Forward (c : (T × Counter) × Q) : Prop := HistoryMachine.Reach (fun e ↦ (edges e).input) (fun e ↦ (edges e).output) seed b digit (forget c) (history c) omit [Fintype E] in lemma forward_start : Forward edges b digit seed (augment seed 1) := HistoryMachine.reach_start _ _ _ _ _ variable (hd : ∀ e, 2 ≤ digit e ∧ digit e < b) (hinj : Function.Injective digit) lemma output_injective (e : Edge G T Q) : Function.Injective e.output := by intro x y h exact e.output_injective (mul_right_cancel (congrArg Prod.fst h)) include hb hd hinj in omit [Fintype E] in lemma forward_edge (e : E) (d : (edges e).Domain) (h : ℤ) : Forward edges b digit seed (augment ((edges e).output d) (b*h + digit e)) ↔ Forward edges b digit seed (augment ((edges e).input d) h) := HistoryMachine.reach_step_iff _ _ _ b digit hb hd hinj (fun e ↦ output_injective (edges e)) e d h include hd hinj in lemma reach_implies_forward (c : (T × Counter) × Q) (hc : MarkerMachine.Reach (edgeList edges b digit hb) (augment seed 1) c) : Forward edges b digit seed c := by induction hc with | start => exact forward_start edges b digit seed | forward a ha d _ ih => obtain ⟨e,rfl⟩ := of_mem_edgeList edges b digit hb a ha obtain ⟨d,h⟩ := d change Counter at h simpa only [edge_output] using (forward_edge edges b digit hb seed hd hinj e d h.toAdd).mpr (by simpa only [edge_input] using ih) | backward a ha d _ ih => obtain ⟨e,rfl⟩ := of_mem_edgeList edges b digit hb a ha obtain ⟨d,h⟩ := d change Counter at h simpa only [edge_input] using (forward_edge edges b digit hb seed hd hinj e d h.toAdd).mp (by simpa only [edge_output] using ih) lemma run_implies_reach {s : List E} {c : T × Q} (hc : HistoryMachine.Run (fun e ↦ (edges e).input) (fun e ↦ (edges e).output) seed s c) : MarkerMachine.Reach (edgeList edges b digit hb) (augment seed 1) (augment c (IntegerStack.code b digit s)) := by induction hc with | start => exact MarkerMachine.Reach.start | @step s e d hr ih => have hh := MarkerMachine.Reach.forward (seed := augment seed 1) (edge (edges e) b (digit e) (by omega)) (mem_edgeList edges b digit hb e) (d,Multiplicative.ofAdd (IntegerStack.code b digit s)) rw [edge_input,edge_output] at hh exact hh ih lemma forward_implies_reach (c : (T × Counter) × Q) (hc : Forward edges b digit seed c) : MarkerMachine.Reach (edgeList edges b digit hb) (augment seed 1) c := by obtain ⟨s,hs,hh⟩ := hc have hr := run_implies_reach edges b digit hb seed hs rw [← hh,augment_forget] at hr exact hr include hd hinj in theorem reach_iff_forward (c : (T × Counter) × Q) : MarkerMachine.Reach (edgeList edges b digit hb) (augment seed 1) c ↔ Forward edges b digit seed c := ⟨reach_implies_forward edges b digit hb seed hd hinj c, forward_implies_reach edges b digit hb seed c⟩ end open MarkerMachine DecoratedMarker MarkerEmbedding variable {G T Q E : Type u} [Group G] [Group T] [Fintype E] (edges : E → Edge G T Q) (b : ℤ) (digit : E → ℤ) (hb : 2 ≤ b) (seed : T × Q) (hd : ∀ e, 2 ≤ digit e ∧ digit e < b) (hinj : Function.Injective digit) noncomputable def decoration (c : (T × Counter) × Q) : G := HistoryMachine.decoration b digit (fun e ↦ (edges e).weight) (history c) include hd hinj in lemma decoration_edge (a : Edge G (T × Counter) Q) (ha : a ∈ edgeList edges b digit hb) (d : a.Domain) (hr : MarkerMachine.Reach (edgeList edges b digit hb) (augment seed 1) (a.input d)) : decoration edges b digit (a.output d) = decoration edges b digit (a.input d) * a.weight := by obtain ⟨e,rfl⟩ := of_mem_edgeList edges b digit hb a ha obtain ⟨d,h⟩ := d have hf := reach_implies_forward edges b digit hb seed hd hinj _ hr rw [edge_input] at hf ⊢ rw [edge_output] exact HistoryMachine.decoration_step (fun e ↦ (edges e).input) (fun e ↦ (edges e).output) seed b digit hb hd hinj (fun e ↦ (edges e).weight) e d h.toAdd hf include hb hd hinj in theorem benign_forward [Group.IsFinitelyPresented G] [Group.IsFinitelyPresented T] [Finite Q] (hD : ∀ e, Group.IsFinitelyPresented (edges e).Domain) : IsBenign (decoratedSubgroup (decoration edges b digit) {c | Forward edges b digit seed c}) := by have : Group.IsFinitelyPresented (T × Counter) := finitelyPresented_prod have he : {c | MarkerMachine.Reach (edgeList edges b digit hb) (augment seed 1) c} = {c | Forward edges b digit seed c} := by ext c exact reach_iff_forward edges b digit hb seed hd hinj c rw [← he] apply MarkerMachine.benign _ _ _ _ (decoration_edge edges b digit hb seed hd hinj) intro a ha obtain ⟨e,rfl⟩ := of_mem_edgeList edges b digit hb a ha have := hD e exact finitelyPresented_prod end Higman.RecordedMachine namespace Higman.MarkerEmbedding open Monoid Coprod DecoratedMarker variable {G T : Type u} {Q : Type*} [Group G] [Group T] def coefficientProjection : Base G T Q →* G := Coprod.lift (MonoidHom.fst G T) 1 @[simp] lemma projection_coefficient (g : G) : coefficientProjection (coefficient g : Base G T Q) = g := by simp [coefficientProjection,coefficient] @[simp] lemma projection_translation (t : T) : coefficientProjection (translation t : Base G T Q) = 1 := by simp [coefficientProjection,translation] @[simp] lemma projection_marker (t : T) (q : Q) : coefficientProjection (marker t q : Base G T Q) = 1 := by simp [coefficientProjection,marker,translation] lemma projection_surjective : Function.Surjective (coefficientProjection : Base G T Q →* G) := fun g ↦ ⟨coefficient g,projection_coefficient g⟩ variable {Q : Type u} theorem benign_output [Group.IsFinitelyPresented G] [Group.IsFinitelyPresented T] (v : T × Q → G) (V : Set (T × Q)) (hR : IsBenign (decoratedSubgroup v V)) (q : Q) : IsBenign (Subgroup.closure (v '' {c | c ∈ V ∧ c.2 = q})) := by have : Group.IsFinitelyPresented (G × T) := finitelyPresented_prod let f : Base G T Unit →* Base G T Q := embedding (MonoidHom.id T) (fun _ ↦ 1) (fun _ ↦ q) (fun _ ↦ 1) have hi : Function.Injective (index (MonoidHom.id T) (fun _ : Unit ↦ 1) (fun _ ↦ q)) := index_injective _ Function.injective_id _ _ (Function.injective_of_subsingleton _) have hB := (hR.comap f).map_surjective (coefficientProjection : Base G T Unit →* G) (projection_surjective (G := G) (T := T) (Q := Unit)) dsimp only [f] at hB rw [comap_decoratedSubgroup _ Function.injective_id _ _ _ hi, decoratedSubgroup_eq_closure,MonoidHom.map_closure] at hB have he : (coefficientProjection : Base G T Unit →* G) '' ((fun x : T × Unit ↦ coefficient (pullDecoration (MonoidHom.id T) (fun _ ↦ 1) (fun _ ↦ q) (fun _ ↦ 1) v x) * marker x.1 x.2) '' (index (MonoidHom.id T) (fun _ : Unit ↦ 1) (fun _ ↦ q) ⁻¹' V)) = v '' {c | c ∈ V ∧ c.2 = q} := by rw [Set.image_image] ext g constructor · rintro ⟨⟨t,p⟩,ht,rfl⟩ refine ⟨(t,q),⟨?_,rfl⟩,?_⟩ · simpa [index] using ht · simp [pullDecoration,index] · rintro ⟨⟨t,r⟩,⟨hc,hq⟩,rfl⟩ change r = q at hq subst r refine ⟨(t,()),?_,?_⟩ · simpa [index] using hc · simp [pullDecoration,index] rw [he] at hB exact hB end Higman.MarkerEmbedding namespace Higman.RecordedMachine open MarkerMachine variable {G T Q E : Type u} [Group G] [Group T] (edges : E → Edge G T Q) (seed : T × Q) (halt : Q) def acceptedOutputs : Set G := {g | ∃ s c, HistoryMachine.Run (fun e ↦ (edges e).input) (fun e ↦ (edges e).output) seed s c ∧ c.2 = halt ∧ g = HistoryMachine.value (fun e ↦ (edges e).weight) s} variable [Fintype E] [Finite Q] [Group.IsFinitelyPresented G] [Group.IsFinitelyPresented T] theorem benign_accepted (hD : ∀ e, Group.IsFinitelyPresented (edges e).Domain) : IsBenign (Subgroup.closure (acceptedOutputs edges seed halt)) := by classical let b : ℤ := Fintype.card E + 2 let digit : E → ℤ := fun e ↦ ((Fintype.equivFin E e).val : ℤ) + 2 have hb : 2 ≤ b := by dsimp [b]; omega have hd : ∀ e, 2 ≤ digit e ∧ digit e < b := by intro e have hh := (Fintype.equivFin E e).isLt dsimp [digit,b] constructor <;> omega have hi : Function.Injective digit := by intro e f h apply (Fintype.equivFin E).injective apply Fin.ext dsimp [digit] at h omega have : Group.IsFinitelyPresented (T × Counter) := finitelyPresented_prod have hp := MarkerEmbedding.benign_output (decoration edges b digit) {c | Forward edges b digit seed c} (benign_forward edges b digit hb seed hd hi hD) halt have he : decoration edges b digit '' {c | c ∈ {c | Forward edges b digit seed c} ∧ c.2 = halt} = acceptedOutputs edges seed halt := by ext g constructor · rintro ⟨c,⟨⟨s,hs,hh⟩,hc⟩,rfl⟩ refine ⟨s,forget c,hs,hc,?_⟩ dsimp [decoration] rw [hh,HistoryMachine.decoration_code b digit hb hd hi] · rintro ⟨s,c,hs,hc,rfl⟩ refine ⟨augment c (IntegerStack.code b digit s),⟨?_,hc⟩,?_⟩ · exact ⟨s,hs,rfl⟩ · exact HistoryMachine.decoration_code b digit hb hd hi _ s rwa [he] at hp end Higman.RecordedMachine namespace Higman theorem finitelyPresented_pi (I : Type u) [Finite I] (G : Type v) [Group G] [Group.IsFinitelyPresented G] : Group.IsFinitelyPresented (I → G) := by apply Finite.induction_empty_option _ _ _ I · intro A B e ih have := ih exact Group.IsFinitelyPresented.equiv (MulEquiv.arrowCongr e (MulEquiv.refl G)) · infer_instance · intro A _ ih have := ih have : Group.IsFinitelyPresented (G × (A → G)) := finitelyPresented_prod let e : (Option A → G) ≃* G × (A → G) := { Equiv.piOptionEquivProd with map_mul' := fun _ _ ↦ rfl } exact Group.IsFinitelyPresented.equiv e.symm end Higman end OAI