import OAI.ModelTheory.Choiceless.Counters namespace OAI namespace CPTSeparation.TableMachine open CounterLang inductive Index where | t | y | a | x | z deriving DecidableEq instance : Fintype Index := ⟨{.t,.y,.a,.x,.z}, by intro i; cases i <;> simp⟩ inductive Reg where | size | width | idx : Index → Reg | rem : Index → Reg | addr | prod | tmp | cmp deriving DecidableEq, Fintype abbrev CState (V : Type) := CounterLang.State Reg (Bool × V) abbrev Prog (V : Type) := CounterLang.Program Reg (Bool × V) lemma tableInput_length {N} (S : OrderedQuery.Data N) : (tableInput S).length = 8*(N*N) := by simp [tableInput] lemma tableInput_lookup {N} (S : OrderedQuery.Data N) (r : Symbol) (a b : Fin N) : (tableInput S)[((OrderedQuery.symbolIndex r).val*N+a.val)*N+b.val]? = some (bitLetter (S.rel r a b)) := by have hi : ((OrderedQuery.symbolIndex r).val*N+a.val)*N+b.val = (OrderedQuery.cellIndex r a b).val := by simp [OrderedQuery.cellIndex,finProdFinEquiv] ring rw [hi] simp [tableInput,OrderedQuery.tableBits,OrderedQuery.cellValue_index] def readCell {V} (k : ℕ) (i j : Index) (f : V → Option Letter → V) : Prog V := .seq (.atom (.zero .addr)) (.seq (repeatAdd .size .addr (by decide) k) (.seq (.atom (.add (.idx i) .addr (by simp))) (.seq (multiply .addr .size .prod .tmp (by decide) (by decide)) (.seq (.atom (.add (.idx j) .prod (by simp))) (.seq (.atom (.lookup .prod (fun c a => (c.1,f c.2 a)))) (.seq (.atom (.zero .addr)) (.atom (.zero .prod)))))))) lemma readCell_runs {V} (s : CState V) (k : ℕ) (i j : Index) (f : V → Option Letter → V) (haddr : s.nums .addr = 0) (hprod : s.nums .prod = 0) (htmp : s.nums .tmp = 0) : Runs (readCell k i j f) s {s with ctl := (false,f s.ctl.2 s.input[((k*s.nums .size+s.nums (.idx i))*s.nums .size+s.nums (.idx j))]?)} (16*k*(s.nums .size)^2+16*s.nums (.idx i)*s.nums .size + 6*k*s.nums .size+8*k+16*s.nums .size+6*s.nums (.idx i)+16*s.nums (.idx j)+10*s.input.length+101) := by let s₁ := (Atom.zero .addr).eval s let s₂ : CState V := {s₁ with nums := Function.update s₁.nums .addr (s₁.nums .addr+k*s₁.nums .size)} let s₃ := (Atom.add (.idx i) .addr (by simp)).eval s₂ let s₄ : CState V := {s₃ with ctl := (false,s₃.ctl.2), nums := Function.update (Function.update s₃.nums .prod (s₃.nums .addr*s₃.nums .size)) .tmp 0} let s₅ := (Atom.add (.idx j) .prod (by simp)).eval s₄ let s₆ := (Atom.lookup .prod (fun c a => (c.1,f c.2 a))).eval s₅ let s₇ := (Atom.zero .addr).eval s₆ let s₈ := (Atom.zero .prod).eval s₇ have hm := multiply_runs .addr .size .prod .tmp (by decide) (by decide) (by decide) (by decide) (by decide) s₃ have h := (Runs.atom (.zero .addr) s).seq ((repeatAdd_runs .size .addr (by decide) k s₁).seq ((Runs.atom (.add (.idx i) .addr (by simp)) s₂).seq (hm.seq ((Runs.atom (.add (.idx j) .prod (by simp)) s₄).seq ((Runs.atom (.lookup .prod (fun c a => (c.1,f c.2 a))) s₅).seq ((Runs.atom (.zero .addr) s₆).seq (Runs.atom (.zero .prod) s₇))))))) have he : s₈ = {s with ctl := (false,f s.ctl.2 s.input[((k*s.nums .size+s.nums (.idx i))*s.nums .size+s.nums (.idx j))]?)} := by apply CounterLang.State.ext · simp [s₈,s₇,s₆,s₅,s₄,s₃,s₂,s₁,Atom.eval,Function.update,Nat.add_comm] · funext r; cases r <;> simp [s₈,s₇,s₆,s₅,s₄,s₃,s₂,s₁,Atom.eval,Function.update,haddr,hprod,htmp] · rfl · rfl change Runs (readCell k i j f) s s₈ _ at h rw [he] at h apply h.mono simp only [s₇,s₆,s₅,s₄,s₃,s₂,s₁,Atom.eval,Atom.cost] simp [Function.update,haddr,hprod,htmp] ; nlinarith end CPTSeparation.TableMachine namespace CPTSeparation.Bounded section open CounterLang TableMachine inductive Program (V : Type) where | load (f : V → V) | emit (f : V → Letter) | cell (r : Symbol) (i j : Index) (f : V → Bool → V) | equal (i j : Index) (f : V → Bool → V) | seq (a b : Program V) | loop (i : Index) (body : Program V) variable {V : Type} def isOne (a : Option Letter) : Bool := a == some (some 1) def Program.WF : Program V → Finset Index → Prop | .load _,_ => True | .emit _,_ => True | .cell _ _ _ _,_ => True | .equal _ _ _,_ => True | .seq a b,S => a.WF S ∧ b.WF S | .loop i b,S => i ∉ S ∧ b.WF (insert i S) def Program.eval (N : ℕ) (table : List Letter) : Program V → (Index → ℕ) → V × List Letter → V × List Letter | .load f,_,s => (f s.1,s.2) | .emit f,_,s => (s.1,f s.1::s.2) | .cell r i j f,e,s => (f s.1 (isOne table[((OrderedQuery.symbolIndex r).val*N+e i)*N+e j]?),s.2) | .equal i j f,e,s => (f s.1 (e i == e j),s.2) | .seq a b,e,s => b.eval N table e (a.eval N table e s) | .loop i b,e,s => (List.range N).foldl (fun s k => b.eval N table (Function.update e i k) s) s def equalCode (i j : Index) (f : V → Bool → V) : Prog V := .seq (CounterLang.compare (.idx i) (.idx j) .addr .prod (by simp) (by simp) f) (.seq (.atom (.zero .addr)) (.atom (.zero .prod))) def Program.compile : Program V → Prog V | .load f => .atom (.load (fun c => (false,f c.2))) | .emit f => .seq (.atom (.emit (fun c => f c.2))) (.atom (.load (fun c => (false,c.2)))) | .cell r i j f => readCell (OrderedQuery.symbolIndex r).val i j (fun v a => f v (isOne a)) | .equal i j f => equalCode i j f | .seq a b => .seq a.compile b.compile | .loop i b => .seq (.atom (.load (fun c => (false,c.2)))) (forRange .size (.idx i) (.rem i) (by simp) b.compile) def Program.time (N L : ℕ) : Program V → ℕ | .load _ => 1 | .emit _ => 3 | .cell _ _ _ _ => 1000*(N+1)^2+10*L | .equal _ _ _ => 100*(N+1) | .seq a b => 1+(a.time N L+b.time N L) | .loop _ b => (b.time N L+13)*N+22 def env (s : CState V) : Index → ℕ := fun i => s.nums (.idx i) def result (s : CState V) (v : V × List Letter) : CState V := {s with ctl := (false,v.1), output := v.2} def Ready (S : Finset Index) (N : ℕ) (s : CState V) : Prop := s.nums .size = N ∧ s.nums .addr = 0 ∧ s.nums .prod = 0 ∧ s.nums .tmp = 0 ∧ (∀ i, s.nums (.idx i) ≤ N) ∧ (∀ i ∉ S, s.nums (.idx i) = 0 ∧ s.nums (.rem i) = 0) @[simp] lemma ready_result {S N} (s : CState V) (v) : Ready S N (result s v) ↔ Ready S N s := Iff.rfl @[simp] lemma env_result (s : CState V) (v) : env (result s v) = env s := rfl @[simp] lemma result_result (s : CState V) (v w) : result (result s v) w = result s w := rfl lemma ready_index {S N} (s : CState V) (hs : Ready S N s) (i : Index) (k : ℕ) (hk : k≤N) : Ready (insert i S) N (indexState (.idx i) (.rem i) N k s) := by rcases hs with ⟨hN,ha,hp,ht,hidx,hr⟩ refine ⟨?_,?_,?_,?_,?_,?_⟩ · simpa [indexState,Function.update] using hN · simpa [indexState,Function.update] using ha · simpa [indexState,Function.update] using hp · simpa [indexState,Function.update] using ht · intro j by_cases hji : j=i · subst j; simpa [indexState,Function.update] using hk · simpa [indexState,Function.update,hji] using hidx j · intro j hj have hh : j≠i ∧ j∉S := by simpa using hj simpa [indexState,Function.update,hh.1] using hr j hh.2 @[simp] lemma env_index (s : CState V) (i : Index) (N k) : env (indexState (.idx i) (.rem i) N k s) = Function.update (env s) i k := by funext j; by_cases h : j=i <;> simp [env,indexState,Function.update,h] lemma equalCode_runs (i j : Index) (f : V → Bool → V) (s : CState V) (ha : s.nums .addr=0) (hp : s.nums .prod=0) (N : ℕ) (hi : s.nums (.idx i)≤N) (hj : s.nums (.idx j)≤N) : Runs (equalCode i j f) s (result s (f s.ctl.2 (s.nums (.idx i)==s.nums (.idx j)),s.output)) (100*(N+1)) := by let s₁ : CState V := {s with ctl := (false,f s.ctl.2 (decide (s.nums (.idx i)=s.nums (.idx j)))), nums := Function.update (Function.update s.nums .addr (s.nums (.idx i)-s.nums (.idx j))) .prod (s.nums (.idx j)-s.nums (.idx i))} let s₂ := (Atom.zero .addr).eval s₁ have hc := compare_runs (.idx i) (.idx j) .addr .prod (by simp) (by simp) (by simp) (by decide) f s change Runs _ s s₁ _ at hc have h := hc.seq ((Runs.atom (.zero .addr) s₁).seq (Runs.atom (.zero .prod) s₂)) have he : (Atom.zero .prod).eval s₂ = result s (f s.ctl.2 (s.nums (.idx i)==s.nums (.idx j)),s.output) := by apply CounterLang.State.ext · rfl · funext r; cases r <;> simp [s₂,s₁,Atom.eval,result,Function.update,ha,hp] · rfl · rfl rw [he] at h apply h.mono simp [s₂,s₁,Atom.cost,Atom.eval,Function.update,ha,hp] omega lemma cell_runs (r : Symbol) (i j : Index) (f : V → Bool → V) (s : CState V) {S N} (hs : Ready S N s) : Runs (Program.compile (.cell r i j f)) s (result s ((Program.cell r i j f).eval N s.input (env s) (s.ctl.2,s.output))) (1000*(N+1)^2+10*s.input.length) := by have h := readCell_runs s (OrderedQuery.symbolIndex r).val i j (fun v a => f v (isOne a)) hs.2.1 hs.2.2.1 hs.2.2.2.1 have he : s.nums .size=N := hs.1 simp only [he] at h apply h.mono have hk : (OrderedQuery.symbolIndex r).val ≤ 8 := (OrderedQuery.symbolIndex r).isLt.le have hi := hs.2.2.2.2.1 i have hj := hs.2.2.2.2.1 j calc _ ≤ 16*8*N^2+16*N*N+6*8*N+8*8+16*N+6*N+16*N+10*s.input.length+101 := by gcongr _ ≤ _ := by nlinarith lemma compile_runs (p : Program V) (S : Finset Index) (hw : p.WF S) (N : ℕ) (s : CState V) (hs : Ready S N s) : Runs p.compile s (result s (p.eval N s.input (env s) (s.ctl.2,s.output))) (p.time N s.input.length) := by induction p generalizing S s with | load f => exact Runs.atom (.load (fun c => (false,f c.2))) s | emit f => exact (Runs.atom (.emit (fun c => f c.2)) s).seq (Runs.atom (.load (fun c => (false,c.2))) ((Atom.emit (fun c => f c.2)).eval s)) | cell r i j f => exact cell_runs r i j f s hs | equal i j f => exact equalCode_runs i j f s hs.2.1 hs.2.2.1 N (hs.2.2.2.2.1 i) (hs.2.2.2.2.1 j) | seq a b iha ihb => have ha := iha S hw.1 s hs have hb := ihb S hw.2 (result s (a.eval N s.input (env s) (s.ctl.2,s.output))) hs exact ha.seq hb | loop i b ih => let e := env s let step := fun v k => b.eval N s.input (Function.update e i k) v let pref := fun k => (List.range k).foldl step (s.ctl.2,s.output) let st := fun k => result s (pref k) have hstep (k : ℕ) : pref (k+1) = step (pref k) k := by simp [pref,List.range_succ,step] have hbody (k : ℕ) (hk : k (false,c.2)))) s (st 0) 1 := by simpa [st,pref,result,Atom.eval,Atom.cost] using Runs.atom (.load (fun c : Bool × V => (false,c.2))) s have total := hin.seq h convert total using 1 <;> first | rfl | (simp only [Program.time]; omega) end open CounterLang TableMachine variable {V : Type} abbrev Relation := Symbol → ℕ → ℕ → Bool def readTable (N : ℕ) (w : List Letter) : Relation := fun r a b => isOne w[((OrderedQuery.symbolIndex r).val*N+a)*N+b]? def Program.interpret (N : ℕ) (rel : Relation) : Program V → (Index → ℕ) → V × List Letter → V × List Letter | .load f,_,s => (f s.1,s.2) | .emit f,_,s => (s.1,f s.1::s.2) | .cell r i j f,e,s => (f s.1 (rel r (e i) (e j)),s.2) | .equal i j f,e,s => (f s.1 (e i == e j),s.2) | .seq a b,e,s => b.interpret N rel e (a.interpret N rel e s) | .loop i b,e,s => (List.range N).foldl (fun s k => b.interpret N rel (Function.update e i k) s) s lemma Program.eval_interpret (p : Program V) (N : ℕ) (w : List Letter) (e) (s) : p.eval N w e s = p.interpret N (readTable N w) e s := by induction p generalizing e s with | load _ => rfl | emit _ => rfl | cell _ _ _ _ => rfl | equal _ _ _ => rfl | seq a b iha ihb => simp only [Program.eval,Program.interpret,iha,ihb] | loop i b ih => simp only [Program.eval,Program.interpret] congr 1 funext s k exact ih _ _ lemma readTable_input {N} (S : OrderedQuery.Data N) (r : Symbol) (a b : Fin N) : readTable N (tableInput S) r a b = S.rel r a b := by rw [readTable,tableInput_lookup] cases h : S.rel r a b <;> decide +revert lemma fold_emits {α : Type} (ls : List α) (step : V × List Letter → α → V × List Letter) (v : V) (chunk : α → List Letter) (h : ∀ a ∈ ls, ∀ out, step (v,out) a = (v,(chunk a).reverse++out)) (out) : ls.foldl step (v,out) = (v,(ls.flatMap chunk).reverse++out) := by induction ls generalizing out with | nil => rfl | cons a ls ih => rw [List.foldl_cons,h a (by simp),ih (by intro b hb; exact h b (by simp [hb]))] simp [List.reverse_append,List.append_assoc] lemma loop_emits (N : ℕ) (rel : Relation) (body : Program V) (i : Index) (e : Index → ℕ) (v : V) (chunk : ℕ → List Letter) (h : ∀ k exact ⟨1,by simp [Program.time]⟩ | emit f => exact ⟨3,by simp [Program.time]⟩ | cell r i j f => exact ⟨1000*(Polynomial.X+1)^2+80*Polynomial.X^2,by intro N; simp [Program.time]; ring⟩ | equal i j f => exact ⟨100*(Polynomial.X+1),by simp [Program.time]⟩ | seq a b iha ihb => obtain ⟨p,hp⟩ := iha obtain ⟨q,hq⟩ := ihb exact ⟨1+(p+q),by intro N; simp [Program.time,hp,hq]⟩ | loop i b ih => obtain ⟨p,hp⟩ := ih exact ⟨(p+13)*Polynomial.X+22,by intro N; simp [Program.time,hp]⟩ end CPTSeparation.Bounded end OAI