import OAI.Probability.FKMaps.MapCycles namespace OAI noncomputable section open scoped ENNReal namespace FKCRT.GraphWedge variable {A B V : Type*} (G : SimpleGraph A) (K : SimpleGraph B) (H : SimpleGraph V) /-- Each original edge belongs to exactly one block; a collapsed loop may have zero cost in either retraction. This local statement implies the full global, all-edge metric lower bound. -/ lemma retraction_pair_edist_le (r : V→A) (s : V→B) (h : ∀ {u v},H.Adj u v → G.edist (r u) (r v)+K.edist (s u) (s v) ≤ 1) (u v : V) : G.edist (r u) (r v)+K.edist (s u) (s v) ≤ H.edist u v := by unfold SimpleGraph.edist apply le_iInf intro w change G.edist (r u) (r v)+K.edist (s u) (s v) ≤ (w.length:ℕ∞) induction w with | nil => simp | @cons u x v hadj w ih => calc G.edist (r u) (r v)+K.edist (s u) (s v) ≤ (G.edist (r u) (r x)+G.edist (r x) (r v))+ (K.edist (s u) (s x)+K.edist (s x) (s v)) := add_le_add (G.edist_triangle) (K.edist_triangle) _=(G.edist (r u) (r x)+K.edist (s u) (s x))+ (G.edist (r x) (r v)+K.edist (s x) (s v)) := by ac_rfl _≤1+(w.length:ℕ∞) := add_le_add (h hadj) ih _=((SimpleGraph.Walk.cons hadj w).length:ℕ∞) := by simp [add_comm] lemma hom_edist_le {A V : Type*} {G : SimpleGraph A} {H : SimpleGraph V} (i : G→g H) (x y : A) : H.edist (i x) (i y) ≤ G.edist x y := by unfold SimpleGraph.edist apply le_iInf intro w change H.edist (i x) (i y) ≤ (w.length:ℕ∞) simpa only [SimpleGraph.Walk.length_map] using (w.map i).edist_le /-- Combinatorial data of an actual one-vertex union. Distances are not part of these hypotheses; they are derived from the adjacency data below. -/ structure Data where left : G→g H right : K→g H poleLeft : A poleRight : B shared : left poleLeft=right poleRight retractLeft : V→A retractRight : V→B left_left : ∀ x,retractLeft (left x)=x right_right : ∀ y,retractRight (right y)=y right_left : ∀ x,retractRight (left x)=poleRight left_right : ∀ y,retractLeft (right y)=poleLeft edge : ∀ {u v},H.Adj u v → (G.Adj (retractLeft u) (retractLeft v) ∧ retractRight u=retractRight v) ∨ (retractLeft u=retractLeft v ∧ K.Adj (retractRight u) (retractRight v)) namespace Data variable {G K H} lemma cost_le (D : Data G K H) {u v : V} (h : H.Adj u v) : G.edist (D.retractLeft u) (D.retractLeft v)+ K.edist (D.retractRight u) (D.retractRight v) ≤ 1 := by rcases D.edge h with ⟨h,h'⟩|⟨h',h⟩ · rw [h',SimpleGraph.edist_self,add_zero,SimpleGraph.edist_eq_one_iff_adj.mpr h] · rw [h',SimpleGraph.edist_self,zero_add,SimpleGraph.edist_eq_one_iff_adj.mpr h] /-- Attachments cannot shorten distances within any block. -/ theorem edist_left (D : Data G K H) (x y : A) : H.edist (D.left x) (D.left y)=G.edist x y := by apply le_antisymm (hom_edist_le D.left x y) have h := retraction_pair_edist_le G K H D.retractLeft D.retractRight D.cost_le (D.left x) (D.left y) simpa only [D.left_left,D.right_left,SimpleGraph.edist_self,add_zero] using h theorem edist_right (D : Data G K H) (x y : B) : H.edist (D.right x) (D.right y)=K.edist x y := by apply le_antisymm (hom_edist_le D.right x y) have h := retraction_pair_edist_le G K H D.retractLeft D.retractRight D.cost_le (D.right x) (D.right y) simpa only [D.right_right,D.left_right,SimpleGraph.edist_self,zero_add] using h /-- Distances between blocks add exactly through their shared pole. -/ theorem edist_cross (D : Data G K H) (x : A) (y : B) : H.edist (D.left x) (D.right y)=G.edist x D.poleLeft+K.edist D.poleRight y := by apply le_antisymm · calc H.edist (D.left x) (D.right y) ≤ H.edist (D.left x) (D.left D.poleLeft)+H.edist (D.left D.poleLeft) (D.right y) := H.edist_triangle _=_ := by rw [D.edist_left,D.shared,D.edist_right] · have h := retraction_pair_edist_le G K H D.retractLeft D.retractRight D.cost_le (D.left x) (D.right y) simpa only [D.left_left,D.right_right,D.right_left,D.left_right] using h end Data end FKCRT.GraphWedge end noncomputable section open Equiv Equiv.Perm namespace FKCRT.PermutationWedge open MapCycles attribute [local instance] Classical.propDecidable variable {α : Type*} [DecidableEq α] [Fintype α] def sideSetoid (p : Perm α) (S : Set α) : Setoid S where r x y := p.SameCycle x.val y.val iseqv := ⟨fun x => SameCycle.refl p x.val,fun h => h.symm,fun h h' => h.trans h'⟩ abbrev Side (p : Perm α) (S : Set α) := Quotient (sideSetoid p S) def sideMk (p : Perm α) (S : Set α) (d : α) (hd : d∈S) : Side p S := Quotient.mk _ ⟨d,hd⟩ abbrev Vertex (p : Perm α) := Quotient (SameCycle.setoid p) def vertex (p : Perm α) (d : α) : Vertex p := Quotient.mk _ d def dartGraph (e p : Perm α) : SimpleGraph (Vertex p) := SimpleGraph.fromRel (fun v w => ∃ d,vertex p d=v ∧ vertex p (e d)=w) def sideGraph (e p : Perm α) (S : Set α) (he : ∀ d,e d∈S ↔ d∈S) : SimpleGraph (Side p S) := SimpleGraph.fromRel (fun v w => ∃ d,∃ hd : d∈S,sideMk p S d hd=v ∧ sideMk p S (e d) ((he d).mpr hd)=w) variable {p e : Perm α} {S : Set α} {a b : α} variable (hp : ∀ d,p d∈S ↔ d∈S) (ha : a∈S) (hb : b∉S) /- The maps below operate on the actual rotation-cycle quotients. -/ def inclusion : Side p S→Vertex (swap a b*p) := Quotient.lift (fun d => vertex (swap a b*p) d.val) (fun _ _ h => Quotient.sound (sameCycle_le_vertexJoin p (not_sameCycle_partition hp ha hb) h)) lemma inclusion_mk (d : α) (hd : d∈S) : inclusion hp ha hb (sideMk p S d hd)=vertex (swap a b*p) d := rfl lemma inclusion_injective : Function.Injective (inclusion hp ha hb) := by intro x y induction x using Quotient.inductionOn with | h x => induction y using Quotient.inductionOn with | h y => intro h apply Quotient.sound exact (vertexJoin_inside_iff hp ha hb x.property y.property).mp (Quotient.exact h) def retractD (d : α) : Side p S := if hd : d∈S then sideMk p S d hd else sideMk p S a ha include hp hb in lemma retractD_eq_of_join {x y : α} (hxy : (swap a b*p).SameCycle x y) : retractD (p := p) ha x=retractD (p := p) ha y := by by_cases hx : x∈S · by_cases hy : y∈S · simp only [retractD,dite_eq_left hx,dite_eq_left hy] exact Quotient.sound ((vertexJoin_inside_iff hp ha hb hx hy).mp hxy) · simp only [retractD,dite_eq_left hx,dite_eq_right hy] exact Quotient.sound ((vertexJoin_cross_iff hp ha hb hx hy).mp hxy).1 · by_cases hy : y∈S · simp only [retractD,dite_eq_right hx,dite_eq_left hy] exact (Quotient.sound ((vertexJoin_cross_iff hp ha hb hy hx).mp hxy.symm).1).symm · simp only [retractD,dite_eq_right hx,dite_eq_right hy] def retract : Vertex (swap a b*p)→Side p S := Quotient.lift (retractD (p := p) ha) (fun _ _ h => retractD_eq_of_join hp ha hb h) lemma retract_vertex (d : α) : retract hp ha hb (vertex (swap a b*p) d)=retractD (p := p) ha d := rfl lemma retract_inclusion (x : Side p S) : retract hp ha hb (inclusion hp ha hb x)=x := by induction x using Quotient.inductionOn with | h d => exact dite_eq_left d.property def flipInclusion : Side p Sᶜ →Vertex (swap a b*p) := Quotient.lift (fun d => vertex (swap a b*p) d.val) (fun _ _ h => Quotient.sound (sameCycle_le_vertexJoin p (not_sameCycle_partition hp ha hb) h)) lemma flipInclusion_injective : Function.Injective (flipInclusion hp ha hb) := by intro x y induction x using Quotient.inductionOn with | h x => induction y using Quotient.inductionOn with | h y => intro h apply Quotient.sound exact (vertexJoin_outside_iff hp ha hb x.property y.property).mp (Quotient.exact h) def flipRetractD (d : α) : Side p Sᶜ := if hd : d∈Sᶜ then sideMk p Sᶜ d hd else sideMk p Sᶜ b hb include hp ha in lemma flipRetractD_eq_of_join {x y : α} (hxy : (swap a b*p).SameCycle x y) : flipRetractD (p := p) hb x=flipRetractD (p := p) hb y := by have h := retractD_eq_of_join (S := Sᶜ) (p := p) (fun d => not_congr (hp d)) hb (by simpa using ha) (show (swap b a*p).SameCycle x y by simpa only [swap_comm b a] using hxy) by_cases hx : x∈Sᶜ <;> by_cases hy : y∈Sᶜ <;> simp_all only [retractD,flipRetractD,dite_eq_left] def flipRetract : Vertex (swap a b*p)→Side p Sᶜ := Quotient.lift (flipRetractD (p := p) hb) (fun _ _ h => flipRetractD_eq_of_join hp ha hb h) lemma flipRetract_vertex (d : α) : flipRetract hp ha hb (vertex (swap a b*p) d)=flipRetractD (p := p) hb d := rfl lemma flipRetract_flipInclusion (x : Side p Sᶜ) : flipRetract hp ha hb (flipInclusion hp ha hb x)=x := by induction x using Quotient.inductionOn with | h d => exact dite_eq_left d.property lemma flipRetract_inclusion (x : Side p S) : flipRetract hp ha hb (inclusion hp ha hb x)=sideMk p Sᶜ b hb := by induction x using Quotient.inductionOn with | h d => exact dite_eq_right (by simp [d.property]) lemma retract_flipInclusion (x : Side p Sᶜ) : retract hp ha hb (flipInclusion hp ha hb x)=sideMk p S a ha := by induction x using Quotient.inductionOn with | h d => exact dite_eq_right d.property lemma inclusion_poles : inclusion hp ha hb (sideMk p S a ha)=flipInclusion hp ha hb (sideMk p Sᶜ b hb) := Quotient.sound (sameCycle_swap_of_not_sameCycle p (not_sameCycle_partition hp ha hb)) variable (he : ∀ d,e d∈S ↔ d∈S) def inclusionHom : sideGraph e p S he →g dartGraph e (swap a b*p) where toFun := inclusion hp ha hb map_rel' := by intro x y hxy refine ⟨fun h => hxy.1 (inclusion_injective hp ha hb h),?_⟩ rcases hxy.2 with ⟨d,hd,hx,hy⟩|⟨d,hd,hy,hx⟩ · exact Or.inl ⟨d,by rw [← hx];rfl,by rw [← hy];rfl⟩ · exact Or.inr ⟨d,by rw [← hy];rfl,by rw [← hx];rfl⟩ def flipInclusionHom : sideGraph e p Sᶜ (fun d => not_congr (he d)) →g dartGraph e (swap a b*p) where toFun := flipInclusion hp ha hb map_rel' := by intro x y hxy refine ⟨fun h => hxy.1 (flipInclusion_injective hp ha hb h),?_⟩ rcases hxy.2 with ⟨d,hd,hx,hy⟩|⟨d,hd,hy,hx⟩ · exact Or.inl ⟨d,by rw [← hx];rfl,by rw [← hy];rfl⟩ · exact Or.inr ⟨d,by rw [← hy];rfl,by rw [← hx];rfl⟩ lemma retraction_edge {x y : Vertex (swap a b*p)} (hxy : (dartGraph e (swap a b*p)).Adj x y) : ((sideGraph e p S he).Adj (retract hp ha hb x) (retract hp ha hb y) ∧ flipRetract hp ha hb x=flipRetract hp ha hb y) ∨ (retract hp ha hb x=retract hp ha hb y ∧ (sideGraph e p Sᶜ (fun d => not_congr (he d))).Adj (flipRetract hp ha hb x) (flipRetract hp ha hb y)) := by have forward (d : α) (hdiff : vertex (swap a b*p) d≠vertex (swap a b*p) (e d)) : ((sideGraph e p S he).Adj (retractD (p := p) ha d) (retractD (p := p) ha (e d)) ∧ flipRetractD (p := p) hb d=flipRetractD (p := p) hb (e d)) ∨ (retractD (p := p) ha d=retractD (p := p) ha (e d) ∧ (sideGraph e p Sᶜ (fun d => not_congr (he d))).Adj (flipRetractD (p := p) hb d) (flipRetractD (p := p) hb (e d))) := by by_cases hd : d∈S · have he' := (he d).mpr hd left simp only [retractD,dite_eq_left hd,dite_eq_left he'] refine ⟨⟨?_,Or.inl ⟨d,hd,rfl,rfl⟩⟩,?_⟩ · intro h exact hdiff (congrArg (inclusion hp ha hb) h) · simp [flipRetractD,hd,he'] · have he' : e d∉S := fun h => hd ((he d).mp h) right simp only [retractD,dite_eq_right hd,dite_eq_right he',flipRetractD,Set.mem_compl_iff,dite_eq_left hd,dite_eq_left he'] refine ⟨trivial,⟨?_,Or.inl ⟨d,hd,rfl,rfl⟩⟩⟩ intro h exact hdiff (congrArg (flipInclusion hp ha hb) h) rcases hxy.2 with ⟨d,rfl,rfl⟩|⟨d,rfl,rfl⟩ · exact forward d hxy.1 · rcases forward d hxy.1.symm with ⟨h,h'⟩|⟨h',h⟩ · exact Or.inl ⟨h.symm,h'.symm⟩ · exact Or.inr ⟨h'.symm,h.symm⟩ /-- Actual permutation-map insertion satisfies graph-wedge adjacency data. No metric or distance assertion is supplied as an assumption. -/ def data : GraphWedge.Data (sideGraph e p S he) (sideGraph e p Sᶜ (fun d => not_congr (he d))) (dartGraph e (swap a b*p)) where left := inclusionHom hp ha hb he right := flipInclusionHom hp ha hb he poleLeft := sideMk p S a ha poleRight := sideMk p Sᶜ b hb shared := inclusion_poles hp ha hb retractLeft := retract hp ha hb retractRight := flipRetract hp ha hb left_left := retract_inclusion hp ha hb right_right := flipRetract_flipInclusion hp ha hb right_left := flipRetract_inclusion hp ha hb left_right := retract_flipInclusion hp ha hb edge := retraction_edge hp ha hb he end FKCRT.PermutationWedge end noncomputable section open Equiv Equiv.Perm attribute [local instance] Classical.propDecidable namespace FKCRT.Chords variable {N : ℕ} abbrev Opener (a : Perm (Fin N)) := { i : Fin N // i < a i } def Cross (a : Perm (Fin N)) (x y : Opener a) : Prop := (x.val < y.val ∧ y.val < a x.val ∧ a x.val < a y.val) ∨ (y.val < x.val ∧ x.val < a y.val ∧ a y.val < a x.val) def graph (a : Perm (Fin N)) : SimpleGraph (Opener a) where Adj := Cross a symm := ⟨fun _ _ => Or.symm⟩ loopless := ⟨by intro x; simp [Cross]⟩ def Inside (a : Perm (Fin N)) (f x : Opener a) : Prop := f.val < x.val ∧ a x.val < a f.val lemma opener_endpoints_ne (a : Perm (Fin N)) (ha : Function.Involutive a) (x y : Opener a) (hxy : x≠y) : x.val≠y.val ∧ x.val≠a y.val ∧ a x.val≠y.val ∧ a x.val≠a y.val := by have h1 : x.val≠y.val := fun h => hxy (Subtype.ext h) have h2 : x.val≠a y.val := by intro h have hx := x.property have hy := y.property rw [h,ha] at hx exact (not_lt_of_ge hy.le) hx have h3 : a x.val≠y.val := by intro h have hh : x.val=a y.val := by rw [← h,ha] exact h2 hh exact ⟨h1,h2,h3,fun h => h1 (a.injective h)⟩ /-- A chord which crosses a chord strictly inside a third chord must either be inside the third chord or cross it. Endpoint disjointness is explicit. -/ lemma inside_propagates (a : Perm (Fin N)) (ha : Function.Involutive a) (f x y : Opener a) (hyf : y≠f) (hc : Cross a x y) (hn : ¬Cross a f y) (hx : Inside a f x) : Inside a f y := by obtain ⟨h1,h2,h3,h4⟩ := opener_endpoints_ne a ha y f hyf have hp := y.property unfold Cross at hc hn unfold Inside at hx ⊢ have hv1 := Fin.val_ne_of_ne h1 have hv2 := Fin.val_ne_of_ne h2 have hv3 := Fin.val_ne_of_ne h3 have hv4 := Fin.val_ne_of_ne h4 simp only [Fin.lt_def] at hc hn hx hp ⊢ omega /-- A chord outside the root crossing component has no root-component endpoint in its interior. This is the algebraic corner-separation lemma: it requires neither a Jordan-curve assumption nor a stipulated block law. -/ theorem component_gap (a : Perm (Fin N)) (ha : Function.Involutive a) (r f : Opener a) (hroot : r.val≤f.val) (hf : ¬(graph a).Reachable r f) (x : Opener a) (hx : (graph a).Reachable r x) : ¬(f.val < x.val ∧ x.val < a f.val) ∧ ¬(f.val < a x.val ∧ a x.val < a f.val) := by have hne (y : Opener a) (hy : (graph a).Reachable r y) : y≠f := by rintro rfl exact hf hy have hno (y : Opener a) (hy : (graph a).Reachable r y) : ¬Cross a f y := by intro h exact hf (hy.trans (show (graph a).Adj y f from Or.symm h).reachable) have hinside : ¬Inside a f x := by have hp := (SimpleGraph.reachable_iff_reflTransGen _ _).mp hx induction hp with | refl => exact fun h => not_lt_of_ge hroot h.1 | @tail y z hp hadj ih => intro hz have hy : (graph a).Reachable r y := (SimpleGraph.reachable_iff_reflTransGen _ _).mpr hp exact ih hy (inside_propagates a ha f z y (hne y hy) (Or.symm hadj) (hno y hy) hz) have hnc := hno x hx obtain ⟨h1,h2,h3,h4⟩ := opener_endpoints_ne a ha x f (hne x hx) have hp := x.property have hv1 := Fin.val_ne_of_ne h1 have hv2 := Fin.val_ne_of_ne h2 have hv3 := Fin.val_ne_of_ne h3 have hv4 := Fin.val_ne_of_ne h4 unfold Cross at hnc unfold Inside at hinside simp only [Fin.lt_def] at hnc hinside hp ⊢ omega /-- Actual endpoint set of the root crossing component. -/ def componentDarts (a : Perm (Fin N)) (r : Opener a) : Finset (Fin N) := Finset.univ.filter (fun d => ∃ x : Opener a, (graph a).Reachable r x ∧ (d=x.val ∨ d=a x.val)) lemma mem_componentDarts (a : Perm (Fin N)) (r : Opener a) (d : Fin N) : d∈componentDarts a r ↔ ∃ x : Opener a,(graph a).Reachable r x ∧ (d=x.val ∨ d=a x.val) := by classical simp [componentDarts] lemma external_not_component (a : Perm (Fin N)) (ha : Function.Involutive a) (r f : Opener a) (hf : ¬(graph a).Reachable r f) : f.val∉componentDarts a r ∧ a f.val∉componentDarts a r := by have hne (x : Opener a) (hx : (graph a).Reachable r x) : f≠x := by rintro rfl exact hf hx constructor · intro h obtain ⟨x,hx,he|he⟩ := (mem_componentDarts a r _).mp h · exact (opener_endpoints_ne a ha f x (hne x hx)).1 he · exact (opener_endpoints_ne a ha f x (hne x hx)).2.1 he · intro h obtain ⟨x,hx,he|he⟩ := (mem_componentDarts a r _).mp h · exact (opener_endpoints_ne a ha f x (hne x hx)).2.2.1 he · exact (opener_endpoints_ne a ha f x (hne x hx)).2.2.2 he /-- The gap index is determined solely by the ordered root-component darts. The two ends of every exterior matched pair have the same gap index. -/ def gapIndex (a : Perm (Fin N)) (r : Opener a) (d : Fin N) : ℕ := ((componentDarts a r).filter (· ⟨h.1,h.2.trans f.property⟩ · rintro ⟨hd,hlt⟩ refine ⟨hd,?_⟩ have hdne : d≠f.val := fun h => hn.1 (h ▸ hd) by_contra h have hfd : f.val < d := lt_of_le_of_ne (le_of_not_gt h) (Ne.symm hdne) obtain ⟨x,hx,rfl|rfl⟩ := (mem_componentDarts a r d).mp hd · exact (component_gap a ha r f hroot hf x hx).1 ⟨hfd,hlt⟩ · exact (component_gap a ha r f hroot hf x hx).2 ⟨hfd,hlt⟩ end FKCRT.Chords end end OAI