import OAI.Probability.MatroidSecretary.Secretary.Model import OAI.Probability.MatroidSecretary.Secretary.Observation import OAI.Probability.MatroidSecretary.Secretary.Replay namespace OAI /-! # The actual history-only secretary rule reconstructed from a complete initial seed The decoder consumes only the initial seed and the label set of the already observed prefix. The observation vector is extracted from actual past arrivals. A total mask-consistency guard rejects on unsupported decoder outcomes, ensuring feasibility for every initial seed rather than merely almost surely. -/ namespace MatroidProphet.SecretaryReplay open MeasureTheory /-- A concrete secretary rule from a hidden rule and a precommitted decoder. The seed type is finite, but its law is arbitrary and need not be uniform. -/ noncomputable def reconstructedRule {n bits : ℕ} {Q : Type*} [Fintype Q] [MeasurableSpace Q] [MeasurableSingletonClass Q] (A : HiddenRule n bits) (K : Q → Fin (n + 1)) (decode : Q → Finset (Fin n) → Seed bits) : SecretaryRule n Q where prefixLength := K measurable_prefixLength := measurable_of_finite K decide k q h := let P := prefixLabels (K q).val h let r := decode q P if A.mask r = P then A.core.decide k r (prefixWeights (K q).val h) h else false measurable_decide k := by classical apply measurable_from_prod_countable_right intro q have hp := measurable_prefixLabels k (K q).val have hr : Measurable (fun h : History n k => decode q (prefixLabels (K q).val h)) := (measurable_of_finite (decode q)).comp hp have hs : MeasurableSet {z : Seed bits × Finset (Fin n) | A.mask z.1 = z.2} := (Set.toFinite _).measurableSet have hm : MeasurableSet {h : History n k | A.mask (decode q (prefixLabels (K q).val h)) = prefixLabels (K q).val h} := (hr.prodMk hp) hs exact Measurable.ite hm ((A.core.measurable_decide k).comp (hr.prodMk ((measurable_prefixWeights k (K q).val).prodMk measurable_id))) measurable_const /-- Once the prefix is complete, the decoder sees its full label set; no suffix label changes the reconstructed seed. -/ theorem decoder_history {n bits : ℕ} {Q : Type*} (K : Q → Fin (n + 1)) (decode : Q → Finset (Fin n) → Seed bits) (q : Q) (w : Weights n) (π : ArrivalOrder n) (k : Fin n) (hk : (K q).val ≤ k.val) : decode q (prefixLabels (K q).val (history w π k)) = decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val) := by rw [prefixLabels_history w π k (K q).val (hk.trans (Nat.le_succ _))] /-- On mask-consistent outcomes the actual no-sample secretary execution exactly replays the hidden rule at every prefix. -/ theorem reconstructed_acceptedThrough {n bits : ℕ} {Q : Type*} [Fintype Q] [MeasurableSpace Q] [MeasurableSingletonClass Q] (A : HiddenRule n bits) (K : Q → Fin (n + 1)) (decode : Q → Finset (Fin n) → Seed bits) (q : Q) (w : Weights n) (π : ArrivalOrder n) (t : ℕ) (hmask : A.mask (decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val)) = orderPrefix π (K q).val) : secretaryAcceptedThrough (reconstructedRule A K decode) q w π t = hiddenAcceptedThrough A (decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val)) w π t := by classical ext e by_cases hk : (π.symm e).val < (K q).val · have he : e ∈ A.mask (decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val)) := by rw [hmask, mem_orderPrefix] exact hk simp [secretaryAcceptedThrough, secretaryDecisionAt, reconstructedRule, hk, hiddenAcceptedThrough, he] · have hle : (K q).val ≤ (π.symm e).val := Nat.le_of_not_gt hk have hp := prefixLabels_history w π (π.symm e) (K q).val (hle.trans (Nat.le_succ _)) have ho := prefixWeights_eq_observed A (decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val)) w π (π.symm e) (K q).val (hle.trans (Nat.le_succ _)) hmask have he : e ∉ A.mask (decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val)) := by rw [hmask, mem_orderPrefix] exact hk simp only [secretaryAcceptedThrough, hiddenAcceptedThrough, acceptedThrough, Finset.mem_sdiff, Finset.mem_filter, Finset.mem_univ, true_and, he, not_false_eq_true, and_true] simp [secretaryDecisionAt, reconstructedRule, hk, hp, hmask, ho, decisionAt] /-- On an unsupported decoder outcome the total construction accepts nothing. -/ theorem reconstructed_acceptedThrough_of_mismatch {n bits : ℕ} {Q : Type*} [Fintype Q] [MeasurableSpace Q] [MeasurableSingletonClass Q] (A : HiddenRule n bits) (K : Q → Fin (n + 1)) (decode : Q → Finset (Fin n) → Seed bits) (q : Q) (w : Weights n) (π : ArrivalOrder n) (t : ℕ) (hmask : A.mask (decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val)) ≠ orderPrefix π (K q).val) : secretaryAcceptedThrough (reconstructedRule A K decode) q w π t = ∅ := by classical apply Finset.eq_empty_iff_forall_notMem.mpr intro e by_cases hk : (π.symm e).val < (K q).val · simp [secretaryAcceptedThrough, secretaryDecisionAt, reconstructedRule, hk] · have hle : (K q).val ≤ (π.symm e).val := Nat.le_of_not_gt hk have hp := prefixLabels_history w π (π.symm e) (K q).val (hle.trans (Nat.le_succ _)) simp [secretaryAcceptedThrough, secretaryDecisionAt, reconstructedRule, hp, hmask] /-- Feasibility is pointwise for every complete initial seed, including null outcomes of the conditional reconstruction kernels. -/ theorem reconstructed_feasible {n bits : ℕ} {Q : Type*} [Fintype Q] [MeasurableSpace Q] [MeasurableSingletonClass Q] (M : Matroid (Fin n)) (A : HiddenRule n bits) (K : Q → Fin (n + 1)) (decode : Q → Finset (Fin n) → Seed bits) (hA : ∀ (w : Weights n), (∀ e, 0 ≤ w e) → ∀ (r : Seed bits) (π : ArrivalOrder n) (t : ℕ), M.Indep (hiddenAcceptedThrough A r w π t : Set (Fin n))) : SecretaryFeasible M (reconstructedRule A K decode) := by intro q w hw π t by_cases hm : A.mask (decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val)) = orderPrefix π (K q).val · rw [reconstructed_acceptedThrough A K decode q w π t hm] exact hA w hw _ π t · rw [reconstructed_acceptedThrough_of_mismatch A K decode q w π t hm] simp /-- Exact replay includes reward, with the actual fixed vector on every accept. -/ theorem reconstructed_reward {n bits : ℕ} {Q : Type*} [Fintype Q] [MeasurableSpace Q] [MeasurableSingletonClass Q] (A : HiddenRule n bits) (K : Q → Fin (n + 1)) (decode : Q → Finset (Fin n) → Seed bits) (q : Q) (w : Weights n) (π : ArrivalOrder n) (hmask : A.mask (decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val)) = orderPrefix π (K q).val) : secretaryReward (reconstructedRule A K decode) q w π = hiddenReward A (decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val)) w π := by unfold secretaryReward hiddenReward rw [reconstructed_acceptedThrough A K decode q w π n hmask] /-- The pointwise comparison permits arbitrary full-seed-aware suffix orders. -/ theorem worstReward_le_reconstructed {n bits : ℕ} {Q : Type*} [Fintype Q] [MeasurableSpace Q] [MeasurableSingletonClass Q] (A : HiddenRule n bits) (K : Q → Fin (n + 1)) (decode : Q → Finset (Fin n) → Seed bits) (q : Q) (w : Weights n) (π : ArrivalOrder n) (hmask : A.mask (decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val)) = orderPrefix π (K q).val) : hiddenWorstReward A w (decode q (orderPrefix π (K q).val)) ≤ secretaryReward (reconstructedRule A K decode) q w π := by rw [reconstructed_reward A K decode q w π hmask] exact hiddenWorstReward_le A w _ π end MatroidProphet.SecretaryReplay end OAI