import Mathlib import OAI.SetTheory.PartitionConsistency.Models.ComponentGluing import OAI.SetTheory.PartitionConsistency.Construction.SaturatedMonoids import OAI.SetTheory.PartitionConsistency.Forcing.ChoiceFailure namespace OAI /-! ## CardinalParameters -/ namespace PartitionConsistency.CardinalParameters noncomputable section open Cardinal /-- Every countable sequence below a regular uncountable initial ordinal is strictly bounded. We use the small representative of that ordinal. -/ theorem countable_bound {μ : Cardinal.{0}} (hμ : μ.IsRegular) (hω : aleph0 < μ) (f : ℕ → μ.ord.ToType) : ∃ a : μ.ord.ToType, ∀ n, f n < a := by let g : ℕ → Ordinal := fun n => (f n).toOrd.val have hg : (⨆ n, g n + 1) < μ.ord := Ordinal.iSup_add_one_lt_of_lt_cof (by simpa only [Cardinal.mk_nat,hμ.cof_ord] using hω) (fun n => (f n).toOrd.property) refine ⟨Ordinal.ToType.mk ⟨_,hg⟩,fun n => ?_⟩ apply Ordinal.ToType.mk.symm.strictMono.lt_iff_lt.mp change (f n).toOrd < Ordinal.ToType.mk.symm (Ordinal.ToType.mk ⟨_,hg⟩) rw [OrderIso.symm_apply_apply] exact Ordinal.lt_iSup_add_one g n /-- The cardinal arithmetic used in the paper for a successor of a fixed point of countable exponentiation. This is not an inaccessible assumption. -/ theorem succ_power_aleph0 {c : Cardinal.{0}} (hω : aleph0 ≤ c) (hc : c ^ aleph0 = c) : (Order.succ c) ^ aleph0 = Order.succ c := by let μ := Order.succ c let A := μ.ord.ToType have hreg : μ.IsRegular := Cardinal.isRegular_succ hω have hωμ : aleph0 < μ := hω.trans_lt (Order.lt_succ c) have hbound (f : ℕ → A) : ∃ a : A, ∀ n, f n < a := countable_bound hreg hωμ f let bound : (ℕ → A) → A := fun f => (hbound f).choose let pack : (ℕ → A) → Σ a : A, (ℕ → Set.Iio a) := fun f => ⟨bound f,fun n => ⟨f n,(hbound f).choose_spec n⟩⟩ have hpack : Function.Injective pack := by intro f g h exact congrArg (fun t : Σ a : A, (ℕ → Set.Iio a) => fun n => (t.2 n).val) h have hfiber (a : A) : Cardinal.mk (ℕ → Set.Iio a) ≤ c := by have ha : Cardinal.mk (Set.Iio a) ≤ c := by apply (Order.lt_succ_iff).mp simpa [A,μ] using Cardinal.mk_Iio_lt a (by simp [A,μ]) simpa only [Cardinal.mk_arrow,Cardinal.mk_nat,Cardinal.lift_id,hc] using Cardinal.power_le_power_right (c := aleph0) ha apply le_antisymm _ (Cardinal.self_le_power μ Cardinal.one_le_aleph0) calc μ ^ aleph0 = Cardinal.mk (ℕ → A) := by simp [A] _ ≤ Cardinal.mk (Σ a : A, ℕ → Set.Iio a) := Cardinal.mk_le_of_injective hpack _ = Cardinal.sum (fun a : A => Cardinal.mk (ℕ → Set.Iio a)) := Cardinal.mk_sigma _ _ ≤ Cardinal.sum (fun _ : A => c) := Cardinal.sum_le_sum _ _ hfiber _ = μ * c := by simp [A] _ ≤ μ * μ := mul_le_mul_right (Order.le_succ c) μ _ = μ := Cardinal.mul_eq_self hωμ.le /-- The parameters of RC262 over the ambient choice ground. -/ def μ : Cardinal.{0} := Order.succ Cardinal.continuum theorem aleph_one_le_μ : Cardinal.aleph 1 ≤ μ := Cardinal.aleph_one_le_continuum.trans (Order.le_succ _) theorem aleph0_le_μ : Cardinal.aleph0 ≤ μ := Cardinal.aleph0_le_continuum.trans (Order.le_succ _) theorem μ_countable_power : μ ^ Cardinal.aleph0 = μ := succ_power_aleph0 Cardinal.aleph0_le_continuum Cardinal.continuum_power_aleph0 theorem μ_regular : μ.IsRegular := Cardinal.isRegular_succ Cardinal.aleph0_le_continuum end end PartitionConsistency.CardinalParameters /-! ## Instance -/ namespace PartitionConsistency.ConcreteSystem open MonoidConstruction CardinalParameters DiagramForcing SetForcingNames noncomputable section /-- A small type of precisely the source's probe multiplicity. -/ abbrev K : Type := μ.ord.ToType instance : Nonempty K := Ordinal.nonempty_toType_iff.mpr μ_regular.ord_pos.ne' @[simp] theorem cardinal_K : Cardinal.mk K = μ := by rw [K,Cardinal.mk_toType,Cardinal.card_ord] /-- The fully executed, omega-one-length saturation. -/ def T : Object := Saturation.target Base.object K private theorem base_cardinal_le : Cardinal.mk Base.object ≤ μ := by change Cardinal.mk (Multiplicative ℕ) ≤ μ simpa using aleph0_le_μ @[simp] theorem cardinal_T : Cardinal.mk T = μ := Saturation.target_cardinal Base.object K aleph_one_le_μ μ_countable_power base_cardinal_le cardinal_K instance : Infinite T := Cardinal.aleph0_le_mk_iff.mp (by rw [cardinal_T]; exact aleph0_le_μ) theorem finiteMergers : HasFiniteMergers T := Saturation.finiteMergers Base.object K theorem complement_cardinal : Cardinal.mk ((Set.range (fun x : T => T.e * x))ᶜ : Set T) = Cardinal.mk T := by have hh : (Set.range (fun x : T => T.e * x))ᶜ = {x : T | ¬ T.e ∣ x} := by ext x simp only [Set.mem_compl_iff,Set.mem_range,Set.mem_ofPred_eq,dvd_def] simp only [eq_comm] rw [hh,cardinal_T] exact Saturation.complement_cardinal Base.object K aleph_one_le_μ μ_countable_power base_cardinal_le cardinal_K /-- The coordinates and Cohen length specified in the source. -/ abbrev I : Type := (Order.succ μ).ord.ToType abbrev κ : Type := (Cardinal.aleph 1).ord.ToType @[simp] theorem cardinal_I : Cardinal.mk I = Order.succ μ := by rw [I,Cardinal.mk_toType,Cardinal.card_ord] @[simp] theorem cardinal_κ : Cardinal.mk κ = Cardinal.aleph 1 := by rw [κ,Cardinal.mk_toType,Cardinal.card_ord] instance : Infinite I := Cardinal.aleph0_le_mk_iff.mp (by rw [cardinal_I]; exact aleph0_le_μ.trans (Order.le_succ μ)) instance : Uncountable κ := Cardinal.aleph0_lt_mk_iff.mp (by rw [cardinal_κ]; exact Cardinal.aleph0_lt_aleph_one) theorem size_lt : Cardinal.mk T < Cardinal.mk I := by rw [cardinal_T,cardinal_I]; exact Order.lt_succ μ abbrev P := ProductForcing.Poset T I κ def S : SymmetricSystem.{0} P (Equiv.Perm I) := ProductForcing.system aleph0_le_μ theorem forces_ZF (p : P) : ∀ φ ∈ SetLanguage.ZF, S.Forces Fin.elim0 p φ := S.forces_ZF p theorem forces_not_AC (p : P) : S.Forces Fin.elim0 p SetLanguage.AC.neg := ProductForcing.forces_not_AC aleph0_le_μ cardinal_T size_lt finiteMergers T.e complement_cardinal (posetCode κ) (posetCode_injective κ) p /-- Consistency of the ZF + ¬AC subtheory. The full target, also including PP and ordinal-indexed choice, is proved below in `consistent_target`. -/ theorem consistent_ZF_not_AC : Consistent (Set.insert SetLanguage.AC.neg SetLanguage.ZF) := by apply S.consistent_of_forces (⊤ : P) intro φ hφ rcases hφ with rfl | hφ · exact forces_not_AC ⊤ · exact forces_ZF ⊤ φ hφ end end PartitionConsistency.ConcreteSystem /-! ## LabelFiber -/ namespace PartitionConsistency.LocalDiagramSystem universe u open DiagramOrder DiagramForcing variable {M I : Type u} [LeftCancelMonoid M] [IsConical M] noncomputable section /-- Label availability is literal membership in the subdiagram range. -/ theorem label_available_iff (r : Diagram M I) (j : r.range) (n : M) : (labelSystem (M := M) (I := I)).Available r j n ↔ j.val ∈ (r.sub n).range := by constructor · rintro ⟨k,hk⟩ exact (congrArg Subtype.val hk) ▸ k.property · intro hj exact ⟨⟨j.val,hj⟩,rfl⟩ /-- The availability test at a center is precisely left divisibility. -/ theorem label_available_center (r : Diagram M I) (k n : M) : (labelSystem (M := M) (I := I)).Available r ⟨r k,⟨k,rfl⟩⟩ n ↔ n ∣ k := by rw [label_available_iff] constructor · rintro ⟨x,hx⟩ exact ⟨x,(r.injective hx).symm⟩ · rintro ⟨x,hx⟩ exact ⟨x,congrArg r hx.symm⟩ /-- A probe profile supplies a genuine exact-fiber label, rather than merely an element of the ambient label range. -/ def labelFiberEmbedding {q : Diagram M I} (w : Vertex q) {K : Type u} (m : K → M) (hinj : Function.Injective m) (hprofile : ∀ i (x : M), x ∣ w.index ∧ x ∣ m i ↔ x ∈ w.ideal.carrier) : K ↪ (labelSystem (M := M) (I := I)).vertexFiber w where toFun i := ⟨⟨w.diagram (m i),⟨m i,rfl⟩⟩,by apply ConeIdeal.ext ext n change n ≤ w.index ∧ (labelSystem (M := M) (I := I)).Available w.diagram ⟨w.diagram (m i),⟨m i,rfl⟩⟩ n ↔ _ erw [label_available_center,LeftDivOrder.le_iff_dvd] exact hprofile i n⟩ inj' := by intro i j h apply hinj apply w.diagram.injective exact congrArg (fun z : (labelSystem (M := M) (I := I)).vertexFiber w => z.val.val) h /-- The common ground subset of label indices underlying a component. -/ def labelFiberSet {q : Diagram M I} (w : Vertex q) : Set I := Set.range (fun x : (labelSystem (M := M) (I := I)).vertexFiber w => x.val.val) theorem labelFiberSet_subset {q : Diagram M I} (w : Vertex q) : labelFiberSet w ⊆ w.diagram.range := by rintro _ ⟨x,rfl⟩ exact x.val.property /-- Contractions act as the identity on label indices. -/ theorem label_arrowMap_val (hj : HasConditionalJoins (LeftDivOrder M)) {q : Diagram M I} {w z : Vertex q} (f : w.Arrow z) (x : (labelSystem (M := M) (I := I)).vertexFiber z) : ((labelSystem (M := M) (I := I)).arrowMap hj f x).val.val = x.val.val := rfl theorem labelFiberSet_arrow (hj : HasConditionalJoins (LeftDivOrder M)) {q : Diagram M I} {w z : Vertex q} (f : w.Arrow z) : labelFiberSet w = labelFiberSet z := by apply Set.Subset.antisymm · rintro _ ⟨x,rfl⟩ obtain ⟨y,hy⟩ := ((labelSystem (M := M) (I := I)).arrowMap_bijective hj f).2 x exact ⟨y,congrArg (fun t => t.val.val) hy⟩ · rintro _ ⟨x,rfl⟩ exact ⟨(labelSystem (M := M) (I := I)).arrowMap hj f x,rfl⟩ /-- The label fibers of a whole connected component are literally the same subset of the coordinate set, not just equinumerous sets. -/ theorem labelFiberSet_common (hj : HasConditionalJoins (LeftDivOrder M)) {q : Diagram M I} {w z : Vertex q} (h : Vertex.Common w z) : labelFiberSet w = labelFiberSet z := by obtain ⟨t,⟨f⟩,⟨g⟩⟩ := h exact (labelFiberSet_arrow hj f).trans (labelFiberSet_arrow hj g).symm end end PartitionConsistency.LocalDiagramSystem namespace PartitionConsistency.MonoidConstruction.Saturation universe u open DiagramOrder DiagramForcing LocalDiagramSystem noncomputable section variable (M : Object.{u}) (K : Type u) [Nonempty K] /-- The source's exact label-fiber count in the actual executed saturated monoid. All ideals at all final vertices are covered. No count of symbolic E-classes is postulated here. -/ theorem labelFiber_cardinal {μ : Cardinal.{u}} (hω : Cardinal.aleph 1 ≤ μ) (hpow : μ ^ Cardinal.aleph0 = μ) (hM : Cardinal.mk M ≤ μ) (hK : Cardinal.mk K = μ) {I : Type u} {q : Diagram (target M K) I} (w : Vertex q) : Cardinal.mk ((labelSystem (M := target M K) (I := I)).vertexFiber w) = μ := by apply le_antisymm · have hh := Cardinal.mk_subtype_le (fun x : w.diagram.range => (labelSystem (M := target M K) (I := I)).availability w.diagram w.index x = w.ideal) exact hh.trans_eq ((Diagram.cardinal_range w.diagram).trans (target_cardinal M K hω hpow hM hK)) · obtain ⟨m,hinj,hm,_⟩ := ideal_probes M K w.index (target M K).e (target M K).e_ne_one w.ideal rw [← hK] exact Cardinal.mk_le_of_injective (labelFiberEmbedding w m hinj (fun i => (hm i).2.2.1)).injective /-- Gluing changes neither this label fiber nor its cardinality. -/ theorem gluedLabel_cardinal {μ : Cardinal.{u}} (hω : Cardinal.aleph 1 ≤ μ) (hpow : μ ^ Cardinal.aleph0 = μ) (hM : Cardinal.mk M ≤ μ) (hK : Cardinal.mk K = μ) {I : Type u} {q : Diagram (target M K) I} (w : Vertex q) : Cardinal.mk ((labelSystem (M := target M K) (I := I)).Glued (target M K).joins w) = μ := by rw [← Cardinal.mk_congr ((labelSystem (M := target M K) (I := I)).fiberEquivGlued (target M K).joins w w (Vertex.Common.refl w))] exact labelFiber_cardinal M K hω hpow hM hK w end end PartitionConsistency.MonoidConstruction.Saturation /-! ## Stabilizer -/ namespace PartitionConsistency.LocalDiagramSystem.Vertex universe u open DiagramOrder DiagramForcing variable {M I : Type u} [LeftCancelMonoid M] [IsConical M] variable {q : Diagram M I} noncomputable section abbrev RootGroup (q : Diagram M I) := SupportFilter.Fix q.range /-- The action fixes the chosen root diagram literally, and leaves the monoid index and ideal unchanged. -/ def permute (π : RootGroup q) (v : Vertex q) : Vertex q where diagram := v.diagram.permute π.val index := v.index root := by rw [← Diagram.permute_sub,v.root] exact Diagram.permute_eq_of_fixes_range _ q ((SupportFilter.mem_Fix _ _).mp π.property) ideal := v.ideal @[simp] theorem permute_one (v : Vertex q) : permute 1 v = v := by cases v simp only [permute,Subgroup.coe_one,Diagram.permute_one] @[simp] theorem permute_mul (π σ : RootGroup q) (v : Vertex q) : permute (π * σ) v = permute π (permute σ v) := by cases v simp only [permute,Subgroup.coe_mul,Diagram.permute_mul] instance : MulAction (RootGroup q) (Vertex q) where smul := permute one_smul := permute_one mul_smul := permute_mul @[simp] theorem smul_diagram (π : RootGroup q) (v : Vertex q) : (π • v).diagram = v.diagram.permute π.val := rfl @[simp] theorem smul_index (π : RootGroup q) (v : Vertex q) : (π • v).index = v.index := rfl @[simp] theorem smul_ideal (π : RootGroup q) (v : Vertex q) : (π • v).ideal = v.ideal := rfl /-- Coordinate transport preserves the entire contraction, not merely a relation between ranges. -/ def Arrow.move {v w : Vertex q} (π : RootGroup q) (f : Arrow v w) : Arrow (π • v) (π • w) where index := f.index mem := f.mem diagram := by rw [smul_diagram,smul_diagram,← Diagram.permute_sub,f.diagram] ideal := f.ideal theorem Common.move {v w : Vertex q} (π : RootGroup q) (h : Common v w) : Common (π • v) (π • w) := by obtain ⟨t,⟨f⟩,⟨g⟩⟩ := h exact ⟨π • t,⟨f.move π⟩,⟨g.move π⟩⟩ /-- Setwise stabilizer of the component of v. `Common` is already proved to be exactly connectedness under finite contraction zigzags. -/ def componentStabilizer (hj : HasConditionalJoins (LeftDivOrder M)) (v : Vertex q) : Subgroup (RootGroup q) where carrier := {π | Common v (π • v)} one_mem' := by change Common v (1 • v) simpa only [one_smul] using Common.refl v mul_mem' := by intro π σ hπ hσ change Common v ((π * σ) • v) simpa only [mul_smul] using hπ.trans hj (hσ.move π) inv_mem' := by intro π hπ change Common v (π⁻¹ • v) simpa only [inv_smul_smul] using (hπ.move π⁻¹).symm theorem common_moved (hj : HasConditionalJoins (LeftDivOrder M)) (v : Vertex q) (π : componentStabilizer hj v) {w : Vertex q} (hw : Common v w) : Common v (π.val • w) := π.property.trans hj (hw.move π.val) /-- A concrete cofinal chain in a component. Its arrows contain actual translation indices, and the initial term is the chosen vertex. -/ structure Chain (v : Vertex q) where vertex : ℕ → Vertex q first : vertex 0 = v increasing : ∀ i j, i ≤ j → Nonempty (Arrow (vertex i) (vertex j)) cofinal : ∀ w, Common v w → ∃ i, Nonempty (Arrow w (vertex i)) /-- Chains are constructed from the height-cost theorem, not postulated when they are used with the saturated monoid. -/ theorem exists_chain (hj : HasConditionalJoins (LeftDivOrder M)) (H : HeightCost (LeftDivOrder M)) (v : Vertex q) : Nonempty (Chain v) := by obtain ⟨f,hf,hm,_,hc⟩ := component_cofinal_chain hj H v exact ⟨⟨f,hf,hm,hc⟩⟩ namespace Chain variable {v : Vertex q} (C : Chain v) theorem common (i : ℕ) : Common v (C.vertex i) := by have h := Common.of_arrow (C.increasing 0 i (Nat.zero_le i)).some rwa [C.first] at h theorem ranges_antitone : Antitone (fun i => (C.vertex i).diagram.range) := by intro i j hij obtain ⟨f⟩ := C.increasing i j hij exact Diagram.range_antitone (show (C.vertex i).diagram ≤ (C.vertex j).diagram from ⟨f.index,f.diagram⟩) /-- The increasing union of pointwise tail fixers, regarded inside the actual component stabilizer. -/ def tailFixer (hj : HasConditionalJoins (LeftDivOrder M)) : Subgroup (componentStabilizer hj v) where carrier := {π | ∃ i, ∀ j ∈ (C.vertex i).diagram.range, π.val.val j = j} one_mem' := ⟨0,fun _ _ => rfl⟩ mul_mem' := by rintro π σ ⟨i,hi⟩ ⟨k,hk⟩ refine ⟨max i k,?_⟩ intro j hj change π.val.val (σ.val.val j) = j rw [hk j (C.ranges_antitone (le_max_right _ _) hj),hi j (C.ranges_antitone (le_max_left _ _) hj)] inv_mem' := by rintro π ⟨i,hi⟩ refine ⟨i,?_⟩ intro j hj change π.val.val.symm j = j exact π.val.val.symm_apply_eq.mpr (hi j hj).symm /-- Membership is eventual pointwise fixation, not a condition on an assigned bijection or on the result of the quotient construction. -/ theorem mem_tailFixer (hj : HasConditionalJoins (LeftDivOrder M)) (π : componentStabilizer hj v) : π ∈ C.tailFixer hj ↔ ∃ i, ∀ j ∈ (C.vertex i).diagram.range, π.val.val j = j := Iff.rfl /-- A permutation fixing a chain diagram belongs to the component stabilizer. This justifies viewing the displayed union of full fixers inside that group. -/ theorem fixes_mem_stabilizer (hj : HasConditionalJoins (LeftDivOrder M)) (π : RootGroup q) (i : ℕ) (h : ∀ j ∈ (C.vertex i).diagram.range, π.val j = j) : π ∈ componentStabilizer hj v := by have hf : π • C.vertex i = C.vertex i := by have he := Diagram.permute_eq_of_fixes_range π.val (C.vertex i).diagram h have hperm : ∀ (w : Vertex q), w.diagram.permute π.val = w.diagram → π • w = w := by rintro ⟨r,a,hr,U⟩ he change ({diagram := r.permute π.val,index := a,root := _,ideal := U} : Vertex q) = _ simp only [he] exact hperm _ he exact (C.common i).trans hj (by simpa only [hf] using ((C.common i).move π).symm) /-- Cofinality of the chain makes the union of its tail fixers normal. The conjugating permutation is allowed to move the entire chain. -/ instance tailFixer_normal (hj : HasConditionalJoins (LeftDivOrder M)) : (C.tailFixer hj).Normal where conj_mem := by rintro k ⟨i,hi⟩ σ obtain ⟨j,⟨f⟩⟩ := C.cofinal (σ.val • C.vertex i) (common_moved hj v σ (C.common i)) refine ⟨j,?_⟩ intro x hx have himage : x ∈ ((C.vertex i).diagram.permute σ.val.val).range := Diagram.range_antitone (show (σ.val • C.vertex i).diagram ≤ (C.vertex j).diagram from ⟨f.index,f.diagram⟩) hx rw [Diagram.range_permute] at himage obtain ⟨y,hy,rfl⟩ := himage change σ.val.val (k.val.val (σ.val.val.symm (σ.val.val y))) = σ.val.val y rw [Equiv.symm_apply_apply,hi y hy] /-- The name-independent label set is fixed pointwise by every tail fixer. -/ theorem tailFixer_fixes_labels (hj : HasConditionalJoins (LeftDivOrder M)) (k : C.tailFixer hj) (j : I) (hjv : j ∈ labelFiberSet v) : k.val.val.val j = j := by obtain ⟨i,hi⟩ := k.property apply hi apply labelFiberSet_subset (C.vertex i) rwa [← labelFiberSet_common hj (C.common i)] end Chain end end PartitionConsistency.LocalDiagramSystem.Vertex end OAI