import OAI.SetTheory.PartitionPrinciple.Definability.CountableFormulaFamilies import OAI.SetTheory.PartitionPrinciple.Geometry.CompleteProjectionPredensity import OAI.SetTheory.PartitionPrinciple.Geometry.GroundPresentedPreimages namespace OAI namespace PartitionPilot.Forcing namespace TransitiveGround open SetRealization SetFormula Compression.RecursiveMaps universe u v variable (M : TransitiveGround.{u}) {P : Type u} (s : Presentation P) def codedFamily : Set (Set P) := (fun x : ZFSet.{u} => {p | s.encode p ∈ x}) '' M.sets theorem codedFamily_countable (small : M.sets.Countable) : (M.codedFamily s).Countable := small.image _ theorem codedFamily_of_code {E : Set P} (code : s.subset E ∈ M.sets) : E ∈ M.codedFamily s := by refine ⟨s.subset E, code, ?_⟩ apply Set.ext intro p exact s.encode_mem_subset E p theorem exists_ground_generic [Preorder P] (small : M.sets.Countable) (p : P) : ∃ H : ConditionFilter P, H.mem p ∧ H.GenericFor (M.codedFamily s) := exists_generic_for_countable_family p _ (M.codedFamily_countable s small) theorem generic_meets_coded_dense [Preorder P] (H : ConditionFilter P) (generic : H.GenericFor (M.codedFamily s)) {E : Set P} (code : s.subset E ∈ M.sets) (dense : Dense E) : H.Meets E := generic E (M.codedFamily_of_code s code) dense theorem symmetric_names_countable {G : Type v} [Group G] [PartialOrder P] (a : PosetAction G P) (F : NormalSubgroupFamily G) (small : M.sets.Countable) : (a.symmetricDomain s (M.nameDomain s) F).names.Countable := (M.nameDomain_countable s small).mono (fun _ h => h.1) theorem exists_joint_generic {G : Type v} [Group G] [PartialOrder P] (a : PosetAction G P) (F : NormalSubgroupFamily G) (small : M.sets.Countable) (carrier : s.carrier ∈ M.sets) (p : P) : ∃ H : ConditionFilter P, H.mem p ∧ H.GenericFor (M.codedFamily s) ∧ H.GenericFor (formulaFamily (M.nameDomain s)) ∧ H.GenericFor (formulaFamily (a.symmetricDomain s (M.nameDomain s) F)) := by let conditionsCountable : Countable P := M.conditions_countable s small carrier have ordinary := formulaFamily_countable (M.nameDomain s) (M.nameDomain_countable s small) have symmetric := formulaFamily_countable (a.symmetricDomain s (M.nameDomain s) F) (M.symmetric_names_countable s a F small) obtain ⟨H, hp, generic⟩ := exists_generic_for_countable_family p (M.codedFamily s ∪ (formulaFamily (M.nameDomain s) ∪ formulaFamily (a.symmetricDomain s (M.nameDomain s) F))) ((M.codedFamily_countable s small).union (ordinary.union symmetric)) exact ⟨H, hp, (fun E hE => generic E (Or.inl hE)), (fun E hE => generic E (Or.inr (Or.inl hE))), fun E hE => generic E (Or.inr (Or.inr hE))⟩ end TransitiveGround namespace TransitiveGround open SetRealization SetFormula Compression.RecursiveMaps universe u v w variable (M : TransitiveGround.{u}) {P : Type u} [PartialOrder P] variable (s : Presentation P) {G : Type w} [Group G] theorem exists_joint_projection_generic (a : PosetAction G P) (F : NormalSubgroupFamily G) (small : M.sets.Countable) (carrier : s.carrier ∈ M.sets) {J : Type v} [Countable J] (Q : J → Type u) [∀ j, PartialOrder (Q j)] (t : ∀ j, Presentation (Q j)) (pi : ∀ j, P →o Q j) (inc : ∀ j, Q j ↪o P) (projection : ∀ j, CompleteProjection (pi j) (inc j)) (p : P) : ∃ H : ConditionFilter P, H.mem p ∧ H.GenericFor (M.codedFamily s) ∧ H.GenericFor (formulaFamily (M.nameDomain s)) ∧ H.GenericFor (formulaFamily (a.symmetricDomain s (M.nameDomain s) F)) ∧ ∀ j, ((projection j).projectedFilter H).GenericFor (M.codedFamily (t j)) ∧ ((projection j).projectedFilter H).GenericFor (formulaFamily (M.nameDomain (t j))) := by let conditionsCountable : Countable P := M.conditions_countable s small carrier let projectedConditionsCountable (index : J) : Countable (Q index) := (inc index).injective.countable let lower (j : J) : Set (Set (Q j)) := M.codedFamily (t j) ∪ formulaFamily (M.nameDomain (t j)) let lifted (j : J) : Set (Set P) := (fun E : Set (Q j) => {q : P | pi j q ∈ E}) '' lower j have lowerCountable (j : J) : (lower j).Countable := (M.codedFamily_countable (t j) small).union (formulaFamily_countable (M.nameDomain (t j)) (M.nameDomain_countable (t j) small)) have liftedCountable : (⋃ j, lifted j).Countable := Set.countable_iUnion (fun j => (lowerCountable j).image _) have ordinary := formulaFamily_countable (M.nameDomain s) (M.nameDomain_countable s small) have symmetric := formulaFamily_countable (a.symmetricDomain s (M.nameDomain s) F) (M.symmetric_names_countable s a F small) obtain ⟨H, hp, generic⟩ := exists_generic_for_countable_family p (M.codedFamily s ∪ (formulaFamily (M.nameDomain s) ∪ (formulaFamily (a.symmetricDomain s (M.nameDomain s) F) ∪ ⋃ j, lifted j))) ((M.codedFamily_countable s small).union (ordinary.union (symmetric.union liftedCountable))) refine ⟨H, hp, (fun E hE => generic E (Or.inl hE)), (fun E hE => generic E (Or.inr (Or.inl hE))), (fun E hE => generic E (Or.inr (Or.inr (Or.inl hE)))), ?_⟩ intro j have projected : ((projection j).projectedFilter H).GenericFor (lower j) := (projection j).projectedFilter_generic H (lower j) (by intro E hE exact generic E (Or.inr (Or.inr (Or.inr (Set.mem_iUnion.2 ⟨j, hE⟩))))) exact ⟨(fun E hE => projected E (Or.inl hE)), fun E hE => projected E (Or.inr hE)⟩ end TransitiveGround section open SetRealization universe u namespace SetFormula variable {P : Type u} [Preorder P] [Countable P] {s : Presentation P} theorem forces_iff_all_generics (D : Name.NameDomain s) (small : D.names.Countable) {n : Nat} (phi : SetFormula n) (env : Assignment D n) (p : P) : Forces D phi env p ↔ ∀ H : ConditionFilter P, H.mem p → H.GenericFor (formulaFamily D) → Realize (D.values {q | H.mem q}) phi (evalAssignment {q | H.mem q} env) := by constructor · intro forced H member generic exact forces_sound D H generic phi env member forced · intro truth by_contra bad obtain ⟨q, below, negative⟩ := not_forces_refine_neg D phi env bad obtain ⟨H, member, generic⟩ := exists_generic_formulaFamily D small q have yes := truth H (H.upward member below) generic have no := forces_sound D H generic (.neg phi) env member negative exact no yes end SetFormula namespace TransitiveGround open SetFormula variable (M : TransitiveGround.{u}) {P : Type u} [Preorder P] (s : Presentation P) theorem ordinaryForces_iff_all_generics (small : M.sets.Countable) (carrier : s.carrier ∈ M.sets) {n : Nat} (phi : SetFormula n) (env : Assignment (M.nameDomain s) n) (p : P) : Forces (M.nameDomain s) phi env p ↔ ∀ H : ConditionFilter P, H.mem p → H.GenericFor (formulaFamily (M.nameDomain s)) → Realize ((M.nameDomain s).values {q | H.mem q}) phi (evalAssignment {q | H.mem q} env) := by let conditionsCountable : Countable P := M.conditions_countable s small carrier exact forces_iff_all_generics (M.nameDomain s) (M.nameDomain_countable s small) phi env p end TransitiveGround end namespace TransitiveGround open SetRealization SetFormula universe u variable (M : TransitiveGround.{u}) {P : Type u} [Preorder P] (s : Presentation P) theorem exists_coded_ordinary_generic (small : M.sets.Countable) (carrier : s.carrier ∈ M.sets) (p : P) : ∃ H : ConditionFilter P, H.mem p ∧ H.GenericFor (M.codedFamily s) ∧ H.GenericFor (formulaFamily (M.nameDomain s)) := by let conditionsCountable : Countable P := M.conditions_countable s small carrier have ordinary := formulaFamily_countable (M.nameDomain s) (M.nameDomain_countable s small) obtain ⟨H, member, generic⟩ := exists_generic_for_countable_family p (M.codedFamily s ∪ formulaFamily (M.nameDomain s)) ((M.codedFamily_countable s small).union ordinary) exact ⟨H, member, (fun E hE => generic E (Or.inl hE)), fun E hE => generic E (Or.inr hE)⟩ theorem ordinaryForces_iff_all_joint_generics (small : M.sets.Countable) (carrier : s.carrier ∈ M.sets) {n : Nat} (phi : SetFormula n) (env : Assignment (M.nameDomain s) n) (p : P) : Forces (M.nameDomain s) phi env p ↔ ∀ H : ConditionFilter P, H.mem p → H.GenericFor (M.codedFamily s) → H.GenericFor (formulaFamily (M.nameDomain s)) → Realize ((M.nameDomain s).values {q | H.mem q}) phi (evalAssignment {q | H.mem q} env) := by constructor · intro forced H member _ generic exact forces_sound (M.nameDomain s) H generic phi env member forced · intro truth by_contra bad obtain ⟨q, below, negative⟩ := not_forces_refine_neg (M.nameDomain s) phi env bad obtain ⟨H, member, coded, ordinary⟩ := M.exists_coded_ordinary_generic s small carrier q exact (forces_sound (M.nameDomain s) H ordinary (.neg phi) env member negative) (truth H (H.upward member below) coded ordinary) end TransitiveGround namespace TransitiveGround open SetFormula SetRealization universe u variable (M : TransitiveGround.{u}) {P : Type u} [Preorder P] (s : Presentation P) theorem ordinaryForces_congr_equalities (small : M.sets.Countable) (carrier : s.carrier ∈ M.sets) {n : Nat} (phi : SetFormula n) (env other : Assignment (M.nameDomain s) n) (p : P) (equal : ∀ j, Name.ForcesEq p (env j).val (other j).val) : Forces (M.nameDomain s) phi env p ↔ Forces (M.nameDomain s) phi other p := by have values (H : ConditionFilter P) (hp : H.mem p) (generic : H.GenericFor (formulaFamily (M.nameDomain s))) : evalAssignment {q | H.mem q} env = evalAssignment {q | H.mem q} other := by funext j exact Name.forcesEq_sound (M.nameDomain s) H (fun E hE dense => generic E (Or.inl hE) dense) (env j).val (env j).property (other j).val (other j).property p hp (equal j) rw [M.ordinaryForces_iff_all_generics s small carrier, M.ordinaryForces_iff_all_generics s small carrier] constructor · intro forced H hp generic rw [← values H hp generic] exact forced H hp generic · intro forced H hp generic rw [values H hp generic] exact forced H hp generic theorem ordinaryForces_replace_first (small : M.sets.Countable) (carrier : s.carrier ∈ M.sets) {n : Nat} (phi : SetFormula (n + 1)) (env : Assignment (M.nameDomain s) n) (sigma tau : (M.nameDomain s).names) (p : P) (equal : Name.ForcesEq p sigma.val tau.val) : Forces (M.nameDomain s) phi (extend sigma env) p ↔ Forces (M.nameDomain s) phi (extend tau env) p := M.ordinaryForces_congr_equalities s small carrier phi (extend sigma env) (extend tau env) p (Fin.cases equal (fun j => Name.forcesEq_refl (env j).val p)) end TransitiveGround namespace TransitiveGround open SetRealization SetFormula universe u variable (M : TransitiveGround.{u}) {P : Type u} [Preorder P] (s : Presentation P) variable (pairing : Realize M.sets SetFormula.pairing Fin.elim0) variable (unions : Realize M.sets SetFormula.union Fin.elim0) variable (powers : Realize M.sets powerSet Fin.elim0) (separation : SeparationSchema M.sets) include pairing unions powers separation theorem ordinary_generic_meets_coded_dense (H : ConditionFilter P) (ordinary : H.GenericFor (formulaFamily (M.nameDomain s))) {E : Set P} (code : s.subset E ∈ M.sets) (dense : Dense E) : H.Meets E := by have emptyGround : (∅ : ZFSet.{u}) ∈ M.sets := M.empty_mem ⟨s.subset E, code⟩ let witness : Name s := ⟨ZFSet.prod {∅} (s.subset E), IsName.mk (by intro z hz obtain ⟨x, hx, y, hy, shape⟩ := ZFSet.mem_prod.1 hz obtain ⟨p, _hp, rfl⟩ := (s.mem_subset E y).1 hy have empty : x = ∅ := ZFSet.mem_singleton.1 hx exact ⟨∅, p, shape.trans (congrArg (fun v => ZFSet.pair v (s.encode p)) empty)⟩) (by intro y p member have empty : y = ∅ := ZFSet.mem_singleton.1 (ZFSet.pair_mem_prod.1 member).1 exact empty.symm ▸ (Name.empty s).property)⟩ have witnessGround : witness.val ∈ M.sets := M.prod_mem pairing unions powers separation (by simpa only [ZFSet.pair_eq_singleton] using M.unorderedPair_mem pairing emptyGround emptyGround) code have entries (sigma : Name s) (p : P) : Name.Entry sigma witness p ↔ sigma = Name.empty s ∧ p ∈ E := by constructor · intro entry have components : sigma.val ∈ {∅} ∧ s.encode p ∈ s.subset E := ZFSet.pair_mem_prod.1 entry exact ⟨Subtype.ext (ZFSet.mem_singleton.1 components.1), (s.encode_mem_subset E p).1 components.2⟩ · rintro ⟨rfl, member⟩ exact ZFSet.pair_mem_prod.2 ⟨ZFSet.mem_singleton.2 rfl, (s.encode_mem_subset E p).2 member⟩ have forced (p : P) : Name.ForcesMem p (Name.empty s) witness := by apply Name.forcesMem_of_dense intro q _qp obtain ⟨r, rq, member⟩ := dense q exact ⟨r, rq, Name.forcesMem_entry ((entries (Name.empty s) r).2 ⟨rfl, member⟩)⟩ obtain ⟨p, hp⟩ := H.nonempty have member := Name.forcesMem_sound (M.nameDomain s) H (fun E hE => ordinary E (Or.inl hE)) emptyGround witnessGround hp (forced p) obtain ⟨sigma, q, entry, hq, _equal⟩ := (Name.mem_eval {r | H.mem r} witness _).1 member exact ⟨q, hq, ((entries sigma q).1 entry).2⟩ theorem ordinary_generic_meets_ground_dense (H : ConditionFilter P) (ordinary : H.GenericFor (formulaFamily (M.nameDomain s))) {D : ZFSet.{u}} (ground : D ∈ M.sets) (subset : D ⊆ s.carrier) (dense : Dense {p | s.encode p ∈ D}) : H.Meets {p | s.encode p ∈ D} := by have codeEq : s.subset (fun p => s.encode p ∈ D) = D := by apply ZFSet.ext intro z rw [s.mem_subset] constructor · rintro ⟨p, member, rfl⟩ exact member · intro member obtain ⟨p, same⟩ := (s.mem_carrier z).1 (subset member) exact ⟨p, same.symm ▸ member, same⟩ exact M.ordinary_generic_meets_coded_dense s pairing unions powers separation H ordinary (codeEq.symm ▸ ground) dense end TransitiveGround namespace TransitiveGround open SetRealization SetFormula universe u variable (M : TransitiveGround.{u}) {Upper Lower : Type u} variable [PartialOrder Upper] [PartialOrder Lower] theorem completeProjection_codedGeneric (upper : Presentation Upper) (lower : Presentation Lower) {restriction : Upper →o Lower} {inclusion : Lower ↪o Upper} (projection : CompleteProjection restriction inclusion) (pairing : Realize M.sets SetFormula.pairing Fin.elim0) (unions : Realize M.sets SetFormula.union Fin.elim0) (powers : Realize M.sets powerSet Fin.elim0) (separation : SeparationSchema M.sets) (upperCarrier : upper.carrier ∈ M.sets) (lowerCarrier : lower.carrier ∈ M.sets) (graph : upper.graph lower restriction ∈ M.sets) (H : ConditionFilter Upper) (generic : H.GenericFor (M.codedFamily upper)) : (projection.projectedFilter H).GenericFor (M.codedFamily lower) := by intro E member dense obtain ⟨X, ground, rfl⟩ := member have preimage := M.presentedPreimage_mem upper lower restriction pairing unions powers separation upperCarrier lowerCarrier graph ground exact (projection.projectedFilter_meets_iff H _).2 (M.generic_meets_coded_dense upper H generic preimage (projection.dense_preimage dense)) end TransitiveGround end PartitionPilot.Forcing end OAI