"""诊断测试:验证 run_validation_generation 中左填充 batch 的 decode 偏移 bug。 Bug 位置:train_spatial_beats_qa.py 的 run_validation_generation() pls = gi["attention_mask"].sum(1).tolist() ... pt = processor.tokenizer.decode(gen[i, int(pl):], ...) ← 错误! 正确逻辑:左填充 batch 中,generate() 输出的新 token 从 ml = gi["input_ids"].shape[1] 开始, 对 batch 内所有样本统一,与各样本 prefix 长度 pl_i 无关。 运行方式: cd /apdcephfs_cq10/share_1603164/user/schmittzhu/code/Spatial-Qwen python tests/test_generation_decode_offset.py """ import sys import os sys.path.insert(0, os.path.dirname(os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__)))) import torch import numpy as np # ========================================================================= # Part 1: 纯逻辑验证(不需要加载模型) # ========================================================================= def test_left_padded_decode_offset(): """验证左填充 batch 中新 token 起点是 ml,而非各自的 pl_i。 模拟场景: batch_size = 3 前缀长度:[600, 650, 700](最长 ml = 700) 左填充后所有序列长 700 generate() 假设各生成 3 个新 token: sample 0: token [11, 12, 13] sample 1: token [21, 22, 23] sample 2: token [31, 32, 33] """ pad_id = 0 pl_list = [600, 650, 700] ml = max(pl_list) fake_prefix_text_start = 550 # AUDIO(500) + spatial(50) 之后就是文本 token AUDIO_ID = 151646 # 假设 SPATIAL_ID = 151665 # 构造 gi(左填充后的 input_ids) B = len(pl_list) gi = torch.full((B, ml), fill_value=pad_id, dtype=torch.long) gm = torch.zeros(B, ml, dtype=torch.long) for i, pl in enumerate(pl_list): s = ml - pl # 填充前缀 token:500个AUDIO + 50个spatial + 文本 prefix = ( [AUDIO_ID] * 500 + [SPATIAL_ID] * 50 + list(range(1000 + i * 100, 1000 + i * 100 + pl - 550)) # 文本 token ) assert len(prefix) == pl, f"prefix len mismatch: {len(prefix)} vs {pl}" gi[i, s:] = torch.tensor(prefix, dtype=torch.long) gm[i, s:] = 1 # 模拟 generate() 输出:[B, ml + max_new_tokens] max_new_tokens = 3 new_token_ids = [[11, 12, 13], [21, 22, 23], [31, 32, 33]] gen = torch.cat([gi, torch.zeros(B, max_new_tokens, dtype=torch.long)], dim=1) for i, new_toks in enumerate(new_token_ids): gen[i, ml: ml + max_new_tokens] = torch.tensor(new_toks, dtype=torch.long) pls = gm.sum(1).tolist() # = [600, 650, 700] print("=" * 60) print("测试:左填充 batch 的 decode 起点") print("=" * 60) print(f"ml = {ml}, pl_list = {pl_list}") print() print("【当前错误的截取方式:gen[i, pl_i:]】") for i, pl in enumerate(pls): segment = gen[i, int(pl):] # 过滤 AUDIO、SPATIAL token(模拟 skip_special_tokens) filtered = [t.item() for t in segment if t.item() not in (AUDIO_ID, SPATIAL_ID, pad_id)] new_only = new_token_ids[i] # 找前缀文本 token 范围 s = ml - int(pl) prefix_text_tokens_included = gen[i, int(pl): ml].tolist() print(f" sample {i}: pl={pl}, s={s}, gen[i,{pl}:{ml}]={prefix_text_tokens_included[:10]}... " f"(来自前缀,不应该出现!) + new_tokens={gen[i,ml:].tolist()}") if s > 0: print(f" ❌ 错误:包含了前缀文本 token(s={s}个),被错误地 decode 为 echo!") else: print(f" ✓ 正确(该样本是 batch 内最长,s=0)") print() print("【正确的截取方式:gen[i, ml:]】") for i, pl in enumerate(pls): segment = gen[i, ml:].tolist() assert segment == new_token_ids[i], f"sample {i}: expected {new_token_ids[i]}, got {segment}" print(f" sample {i}: gen[i,{ml}:]={segment} ✓ (仅新生成 token)") print() print("结论:应将 gen[i, int(pl):] 改为 gen[i, ml:],") print(" 其中 ml = gi['input_ids'].shape[1]") print() # ========================================================================= # Part 2: 用实际 tokenizer 验证文本 token 的 decode 效果 # ========================================================================= def test_echo_decode_with_tokenizer(tokenizer_path=None): """验证含文本 token 的前缀 echo 在 decode 后确实产生重复文本。""" try: from transformers import AutoTokenizer except ImportError: print("transformers 未安装,跳过 tokenizer 测试") return if tokenizer_path is None: # 尝试从已知路径加载 candidates = [ "/apdcephfs_cq10/share_1603164/user/schmittzhu/models/Qwen2.5-Omni-7B", "/apdcephfs_cq10/share_1603164/user/schmittzhu/models/Qwen2.5-Omni-3B", ] for c in candidates: if os.path.exists(c): tokenizer_path = c break if tokenizer_path is None or not os.path.exists(tokenizer_path): print("未找到 tokenizer,跳过 Part 2") return print("=" * 60) print("测试(Part 2):实际 tokenizer 验证 echo decode") print("=" * 60) try: tok = AutoTokenizer.from_pretrained(tokenizer_path, trust_remote_code=True) except Exception as e: print(f"加载 tokenizer 失败: {e}") return prompt_text = "Is there a sound source positioned at the front?\n" answer_text = "yes" eos_token = tok.eos_token or "" full_text_prefix = "<|AUDIO|>" + "<|spatial|>" + f"\n{prompt_text}\n" ans_sfx = answer_text + eos_token # 获取 spatial token id vocab = tok.get_vocab() spatial_tok = "<|spatial|>" if spatial_tok not in vocab: tok.add_special_tokens({"additional_special_tokens": [spatial_tok]}) spatial_id = tok.convert_tokens_to_ids(spatial_tok) audio_id = tok.convert_tokens_to_ids("<|AUDIO|>") # Tokenize prefix full_seq = full_text_prefix prefix_ids = tok.encode(full_seq, add_special_tokens=False) print(f"prefix length: {len(prefix_ids)} tokens") print(f" (expected: ~550 + text tokens for AUDIO+spatial+text)") print(f" first 5 token ids: {prefix_ids[:5]}") print(f" last 10 token ids: {prefix_ids[-10:]}") # 模拟左填充 batch(该样本 + 一个更长的样本) longer_extra = 80 # 更长样本比此样本多 80 token ml = len(prefix_ids) + longer_extra # 模拟 generate 输出(echo prefix 的后半段 + 真实答案 token) answer_ids = tok.encode(answer_text, add_special_tokens=False) pl_i = len(prefix_ids) s_i = ml - pl_i # = longer_extra = 80 # gen[i] 布局:[pad * s_i | prefix_ids | answer_ids | ...] gen_i = ( [tok.pad_token_id or 0] * s_i + prefix_ids + answer_ids + [tok.pad_token_id or 0] * (48 - len(answer_ids)) # 填充到 max_new_tokens ) gen_tensor = torch.tensor(gen_i, dtype=torch.long) # 模拟错误的截取 wrong_decode = tok.decode(gen_tensor[pl_i:], skip_special_tokens=True).strip() # 模拟正确的截取 correct_decode = tok.decode(gen_tensor[ml:], skip_special_tokens=True).strip() print() print(f"pl_i = {pl_i}, ml = {ml}, s_i = s_i = {s_i}") print(f" 错误截取 gen[i, {pl_i}:] → decode = '{wrong_decode[:80]}...' (可能含 echo)") print(f" 正确截取 gen[i, {ml}:] → decode = '{correct_decode}' (仅答案)") print() # 关键断言 if prompt_text.strip()[:10] in wrong_decode: print(" ❌ 确认:错误截取导致 prompt 文本出现在 decode 输出中!") else: print(" (错误截取 decode 未包含明确 prompt 文本,可能 special token 过滤了大部分)") if correct_decode.strip() == answer_text: print(" ✓ 正确截取仅含答案 token") print() # ========================================================================= # Part 3: 验证 build_left_padded_batch + mask 逻辑 # ========================================================================= def test_build_left_padded_batch(): """验证 build_left_padded_batch 正确性(mask 与 input_ids 对齐)。""" print("=" * 60) print("测试(Part 3):build_left_padded_batch 与 attention_mask 正确性") print("=" * 60) # 构造右填充的 input_ids(模拟 training batch) pad_id = 0 # 3 个样本,不同长度 seqs = [ list(range(1, 11)), # 长度 10 list(range(1, 8)), # 长度 7 list(range(1, 16)), # 长度 15 ] max_len = max(len(s) for s in seqs) B = len(seqs) # 右填充 input_ids_right = torch.zeros(B, max_len, dtype=torch.long) attn_right = torch.zeros(B, max_len, dtype=torch.long) pl_list = [] for i, s in enumerate(seqs): input_ids_right[i, :len(s)] = torch.tensor(s) attn_right[i, :len(s)] = 1 pl_list.append(len(s)) pl = torch.tensor(pl_list, dtype=torch.long) # 模拟 build_left_padded_batch ml = int(pl.max()); B2 = input_ids_right.shape[0] gi = torch.full((B2, ml), fill_value=pad_id, dtype=input_ids_right.dtype) gm = torch.zeros((B2, ml), dtype=attn_right.dtype) for i, p in enumerate(pl.tolist()): s = ml - p gi[i, s:] = input_ids_right[i, :p] gm[i, s:] = 1 # 验证 1:gm.sum(1) == pl assert (gm.sum(1) == pl).all(), "attention_mask sum 与 prefix_lengths 不一致!" print(" ✓ gm.sum(1) == pl(attention_mask 正确反映 prefix 长度)") # 验证 2:gi 中非 padding 区域 == 原始前缀 tokens for i, p in enumerate(pl.tolist()): s = ml - p expected = input_ids_right[i, :p] got = gi[i, s:] assert (expected == got).all(), f"sample {i}: 左填充 token 不对" print(" ✓ 左填充 token 内容正确(gi[i, s:] == original prefix)") # 验证 3:新生成 token 起点是 ml,不是 pl_i print(f" ml = {ml}, pl_list = {pl_list}") print(f" 对 batch 中非最长样本(pl < ml),新 token 起点 = ml,而非 pl") for i, p in enumerate(pl.tolist()): if p < ml: print(f" sample {i}: pl={p}, s={ml-p}, 正确截取起点={ml}(差 {ml-p} 个 prefix token)") print() # 关键结论 print(" 结论:decode 应用 gen[i, ml:] 而非 gen[i, pl_i:]") print() # ========================================================================= # Part 4: 检查 spatial placeholder 的正确性 # ========================================================================= def test_spatial_placeholder_alignment(): """验证 spatial placeholder 在左填充 batch 中的正确对齐。 spatial placeholder 是前缀的一部分,在左填充后位于 [s_i, s_i+500+50] 位置区间内。 forward() 里用 input_ids == spatial_token_id 来定位 placeholder,与填充无关。 这部分验证在左填充 input_ids 中 spatial token 仍然存在且位置正确。 """ print("=" * 60) print("测试(Part 4):spatial placeholder 在左填充 input_ids 中的对齐") print("=" * 60) AUDIO_ID = 151646 SPATIAL_ID = 151665 PAD_ID = 0 N_AUDIO = 500 N_SPATIAL_SHORT = 40 # 短样本(8s 音频) N_SPATIAL_LONG = 50 # 长样本(20s 音频) TEXT_SHORT = 20 # 短文本 token 数 TEXT_LONG = 70 # 长文本 token 数 # 构造两个样本的前缀 prefix_short = [AUDIO_ID] * N_AUDIO + [SPATIAL_ID] * N_SPATIAL_SHORT + list(range(2000, 2000 + TEXT_SHORT)) prefix_long = [AUDIO_ID] * N_AUDIO + [SPATIAL_ID] * N_SPATIAL_LONG + list(range(3000, 3000 + TEXT_LONG)) pl_short = len(prefix_short) # 500 + 40 + 20 = 560 pl_long = len(prefix_long) # 500 + 50 + 70 = 620 ml = max(pl_short, pl_long) # 右填充训练 input_ids B = 2 input_ids = torch.zeros(B, ml, dtype=torch.long) input_ids[0, :pl_short] = torch.tensor(prefix_short) input_ids[1, :pl_long] = torch.tensor(prefix_long) attn = (input_ids != PAD_ID).long() pl = torch.tensor([pl_short, pl_long], dtype=torch.long) # 构造左填充 gen input_ids gi = torch.full((B, ml), fill_value=PAD_ID, dtype=torch.long) for i, p in enumerate(pl.tolist()): s = ml - p gi[i, s:] = input_ids[i, :p] # 验证 spatial token 仍在 gi 中 for i in range(B): spatial_positions = (gi[i] == SPATIAL_ID).nonzero(as_tuple=True)[0].tolist() expected_n = [N_SPATIAL_SHORT, N_SPATIAL_LONG][i] print(f" sample {i}: {len(spatial_positions)} spatial tokens (预期 {expected_n})", end="") if len(spatial_positions) == expected_n: print(" ✓") else: print(" ❌ 数量不对!") if spatial_positions: print(f" 位置范围: [{spatial_positions[0]}, {spatial_positions[-1]}]" f"(padding 占据 [0, {ml - [pl_short, pl_long][i] - 1}])") print() print(" spatial placeholder 在左填充 input_ids 中仍然存在,") print(" forward() 的 masked_scatter 可以正确找到并替换它们。") print(" → spatial 注入逻辑本身没有问题。") print() # 重要:gen[i, pl_i:] 截取时会截到哪些 spatial token? print(" echo 分析:gen[i, pl_short:](短样本,错误截取)包含:") wrong_start = pl_short content_in_wrong = gi[0, wrong_start:].tolist() audio_cnt = sum(1 for t in content_in_wrong if t == AUDIO_ID) spatial_cnt = sum(1 for t in content_in_wrong if t == SPATIAL_ID) text_cnt = sum(1 for t in content_in_wrong if t not in (AUDIO_ID, SPATIAL_ID, PAD_ID)) pad_cnt = sum(1 for t in content_in_wrong if t == PAD_ID) print(f" padding={pad_cnt}, AUDIO={audio_cnt}, spatial={spatial_cnt}, text={text_cnt}") print(f" → 其中 text={text_cnt} 个 token 在 skip_special_tokens=True 时不被过滤,") print(f" 被 decode 出来就是问题文本的 echo!") print() if __name__ == "__main__": print("\n" + "=" * 70) print("诊断测试:run_validation_generation 中左填充 decode 偏移 bug") print("=" * 70 + "\n") test_left_padded_decode_offset() test_build_left_padded_batch() test_spatial_placeholder_alignment() test_echo_decode_with_tokenizer() print("=" * 70) print("【修复方案】") print("=" * 70) print(""" 在 train_spatial_beats_qa.py 的 run_validation_generation() 中: OLD(有 bug): pls = gi["attention_mask"].sum(1).tolist(); gen = gen.detach().cpu() for i, pl in enumerate(pls): pt = processor.tokenizer.decode( gen[i, int(pl):], skip_special_tokens=True).strip() FIXED: ml = gi["input_ids"].shape[1] # 左填充后 batch 的统一序列长度 gen = gen.detach().cpu() for i in range(len(batch["meta"])): pt = processor.tokenizer.decode( gen[i, ml:], skip_special_tokens=True).strip() 原因:左填充 batch 中 generate() 输出的新 token 从位置 ml 开始(对所有样本统一), 而非各自的 pl_i(pl_i 仅是该样本的实际 prefix 长度)。 当 pl_i < ml 时,gen[i, pl_i:ml] = 前缀末尾的文本 token,被错误 decode 为 echo。 """)