{ "campaign": "fiveseed_opus_v2", "cells": [ { "cell_id": "all_rational__ceiling_vote", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/fiveseed_opus_v2__all_rational__ceiling_vote", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_rational__ceiling_continue", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/fiveseed_opus_v2__all_rational__ceiling_continue", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_rational__placebo_vote", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/fiveseed_opus_v2__all_rational__placebo_vote", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_rational__placebo_continue", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/fiveseed_opus_v2__all_rational__placebo_continue", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_oracle__ceiling_vote", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/fiveseed_opus_v2__all_oracle__ceiling_vote", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/fiveseed_opus_v2__all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_oracle__placebo_vote", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/fiveseed_opus_v2__all_oracle__placebo_vote", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_oracle__placebo_continue", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/fiveseed_opus_v2__all_oracle__placebo_continue", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_oracle__unseeded_ballot_fixed", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/oraclefix_none_continue", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue_ballot_fixed", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/oraclefix_ceiling_continue", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_oracle__placebo_continue_ballot_fixed", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/oraclefix_placebo_continue", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_llm__ceiling_vote", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/fiveseed_opus_v3__all_llm__ceiling_vote_attempt03", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_llm__placebo_vote", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/fiveseed_opus_v3__all_llm__placebo_vote_attempt03", "n_episodes": 120 }, { "cell_id": "all_llm__ceiling_continue", "run": "/juice2/scr2/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/fiveseed_opus_v3__all_llm__ceiling_continue_attempt02", "n_episodes": 120 } ], "seeded_offer_manifest": "/juice2/u/siddharth/ii_mats/experiments/rational_agents/seeded_offer_manifest_v1.json", "bootstrap": { "samples": 10000, "seed": 20260810, "clusters": "24 bank instances, seeds resampled together" }, "headline": [ { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_continue", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 115, "logical_table": "all_llm", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.9583333333333334, "ci_low": 0.9083333333333333, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.38333333333333336, "ci_low": 0.24166666666666667, "ci_high": 0.5333333333333333, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.8754616666666666, "ci_low": 0.8137072291666666, "ci_high": 0.9286796041666666, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.4633333333333333, "ci_low": 0.3533333333333334, "ci_high": 0.5716666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_llm", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "vote", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__placebo_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_llm", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "vote", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.67789, "ci_low": 0.640115, "ci_high": 0.7134702916666666, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__unseeded", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 115, "logical_table": "all_llm", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.9583333333333334, "ci_low": 0.925, "ci_high": 0.9916666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.8726133333333334, "ci_low": 0.8328688333333333, "ci_high": 0.9110069791666665, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 94, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.325, "ci_low": 0.21666666666666667, "ci_high": 0.43333333333333335, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.7833333333333333, "ci_low": 0.7, "ci_high": 0.8666666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.325, "ci_low": 0.21666666666666667, "ci_high": 0.43333333333333335, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.7159525, "ci_low": 0.6377016875, "ci_high": 0.7917656875, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.45, "ci_low": 0.3466666666666666, "ci_high": 0.5566666666666668, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue_ballot_fixed", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.325, "ci_low": 0.21666666666666667, "ci_high": 0.43333333333333335, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.45, "ci_low": 0.325, "ci_high": 0.575, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.9238599999999999, "ci_low": 0.9012188333333334, "ci_high": 0.9460537708333333, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.5033333333333334, "ci_low": 0.3882916666666667, "ci_high": 0.6216666666666666, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "vote", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 84, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.075, "ci_low": 0.03333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.11666666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.7, "ci_low": 0.5666666666666667, "ci_high": 0.825, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.075, "ci_low": 0.03333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.11666666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.6278475, "ci_low": 0.5064189791666668, "ci_high": 0.7396327291666666, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.18000000000000002, "ci_low": 0.11, "ci_high": 0.25833333333333336, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue_ballot_fixed", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.075, "ci_low": 0.03333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.11666666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.16666666666666666, "ci_low": 0.075, "ci_high": 0.275, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.8766725, "ci_low": 0.8417972083333332, "ci_high": 0.9073425833333334, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.2233333333333333, "ci_low": 0.12666666666666665, "ci_high": 0.3333333333333333, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "vote", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.67789, "ci_low": 0.640115, "ci_high": 0.7134702916666666, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__unseeded", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 105, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.875, "ci_low": 0.8166666666666667, "ci_high": 0.925, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.7907200000000001, "ci_low": 0.7348483541666667, "ci_high": 0.8429902499999998, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__unseeded_ballot_fixed", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.9068575, "ci_low": 0.8798025, "ci_high": 0.9332413541666666, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_continue", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 28, "logical_table": "all_rational", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.23333333333333334, "ci_low": 0.11666666666666667, "ci_high": 0.36666666666666664, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.025, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.075, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.17739416666666669, "ci_low": 0.08863539583333334, "ci_high": 0.2793685, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.15666666666666665, "ci_low": 0.11833333333333333, "ci_high": 0.2, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_rational", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "vote", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_continue", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 31, "logical_table": "all_rational", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.25833333333333336, "ci_low": 0.14166666666666666, "ci_high": 0.38354166666666367, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.008333333333333333, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.025, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.20095500000000002, "ci_low": 0.11534377083333333, "ci_high": 0.2971297916666666, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.04666666666666666, "ci_low": 0.03166666666666667, "ci_high": 0.06166666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_rational", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "vote", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.67789, "ci_low": 0.640115, "ci_high": 0.7134702916666665, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__unseeded", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 28, "logical_table": "all_rational", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.23333333333333334, "ci_low": 0.13333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.35, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.18885833333333338, "ci_low": 0.11002097916666666, "ci_high": 0.27949872916666657, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "one_oracle__unseeded", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 61, "logical_table": "one_oracle", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.5083333333333333, "ci_low": 0.4166666666666667, "ci_high": 0.6, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.46072500000000005, "ci_low": 0.37630189583333334, "ci_high": 0.5454883541666666, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "one_rational__unseeded", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 92, "logical_table": "one_rational", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.7666666666666667, "ci_low": 0.6833333333333333, "ci_high": 0.8416666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.6864258333333334, "ci_low": 0.610999, "ci_high": 0.7610227916666665, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } } ], "basket": [ { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_continue", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 115, "logical_table": "all_llm", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.2691187512205614, "ci_low": 0.21430087972879655, "ci_high": 0.32617164079348493, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.08027486656927049, "ci_low": 0.0661554449344512, "ci_high": 0.09413360071623204, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.21409436590351563, "ci_low": 0.1889956018006536, "ci_high": 0.23856166369830722, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.5534807025259272, "ci_low": 0.47851132267868685, "ci_high": 0.6172895179313388, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.29555782258245505, "ci_low": 0.2833583186272917, "ci_high": 0.30670801032353856, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_llm", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "vote", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.2316927993465146, "ci_low": 0.16416931236658275, "ci_high": 0.3016251542588082, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.06340530806592577, "ci_low": 0.04621342066542662, "ci_high": 0.08016618817726619, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.23120207602399725, "ci_low": 0.20280895838626992, "ci_high": 0.2590949029239802, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.5072264305135828, "ci_low": 0.3883416987943586, "ci_high": 0.6124490673641668, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.28726963907752484, "ci_low": 0.27619591012535444, "ci_high": 0.2976835637218877, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__placebo_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_llm", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "vote", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.11903506625939292, "ci_low": 0.08580777875848901, "ci_high": 0.15377106371105428, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.045328681122431234, "ci_low": 0.03383035904415395, "ci_high": 0.05688932357966242, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.33033094020978787, "ci_low": 0.2989408521174521, "ci_high": 0.36633293216444196, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.28744261624920875, "ci_low": 0.2152629861022006, "ci_high": 0.3582367411777551, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.3718388644394814, "ci_low": 0.34967173458834483, "ci_high": 0.39931775432883027, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__unseeded", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 115, "logical_table": "all_llm", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.25662751078488905, "ci_low": 0.20553665275285074, "ci_high": 0.3068832314342412, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.07733378037747124, "ci_low": 0.06364213101773564, "ci_high": 0.08973048832378208, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.22312596428528939, "ci_low": 0.1991279584483856, "ci_high": 0.2468180437055837, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.5347356494115132, "ci_low": 0.456589902767696, "ci_high": 0.603191388914178, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.29899227726399724, "ci_low": 0.28721376010553057, "ci_high": 0.30908218186719705, "n": 115, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 94, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 94, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.19071220289424076, "ci_low": 0.14323392715562516, "ci_high": 0.23853151594659147, "n": 94, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.05605336224709707, "ci_low": 0.04387871039706946, "ci_high": 0.06747264035193541, "n": 94, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.2688940089244175, "ci_low": 0.24468117483670382, "ci_high": 0.29311925922683435, "n": 94, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.46680616319858687, "ci_low": 0.37379659648909297, "ci_high": 0.5468752561270701, "n": 94, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.3129565106713585, "ci_low": 0.2996601396735264, "ci_high": 0.3263787478799832, "n": 94, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue_ballot_fixed", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.1827051298823736, "ci_low": 0.132059255071726, "ci_high": 0.23836497361602965, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.05289588244432545, "ci_low": 0.04009928837355295, "ci_high": 0.06586901573216013, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.27265460578016404, "ci_low": 0.2441764466456611, "ci_high": 0.29841077774776936, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.43766442752696527, "ci_low": 0.34139817029051606, "ci_high": 0.527178812072976, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.31214808550284945, "ci_low": 0.2979956411509863, "ci_high": 0.324917507495217, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "vote", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.23169279934651463, "ci_low": 0.16416931236658275, "ci_high": 0.3016251542588082, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.06340530806592576, "ci_low": 0.04621342066542662, "ci_high": 0.08016618817726619, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.23120207602399728, "ci_low": 0.20280895838626992, "ci_high": 0.2590949029239802, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.507226430513583, "ci_low": 0.3883416987943586, "ci_high": 0.6124490673641668, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.28726963907752484, "ci_low": 0.27619591012535444, "ci_high": 0.2976835637218877, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 84, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 84, "n_instances": 23 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.21248409814018818, "ci_low": 0.1694471099832047, "ci_high": 0.25728310559730383, "n": 84, "n_instances": 23 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.062416778864698395, "ci_low": 0.05224348297566611, "ci_high": 0.07233521763037296, "n": 84, "n_instances": 23 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.2650520616190213, "ci_low": 0.23924936070868283, "ci_high": 0.2911433762452277, "n": 84, "n_instances": 23 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.5218769379274814, "ci_low": 0.46916488685091545, "ci_high": 0.5721880120292061, "n": 84, "n_instances": 23 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.31551273843260336, "ci_low": 0.3004989636492877, "ci_high": 0.3309941407718242, "n": 84, "n_instances": 23 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue_ballot_fixed", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.17164751640767778, "ci_low": 0.12696590216960502, "ci_high": 0.22034410049382522, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.050539138017344866, "ci_low": 0.03915326836250376, "ci_high": 0.06198780170795561, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.29494958144607614, "ci_low": 0.2622750125504803, "ci_high": 0.329156809002816, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.42465644300575983, "ci_low": 0.3385198667955118, "ci_high": 0.5049983253464736, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.3302936500617199, "ci_low": 0.3109820068525856, "ci_high": 0.35204965685126843, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "vote", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.1190350662593929, "ci_low": 0.08580777875848901, "ci_high": 0.15377106371105434, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.045328681122431234, "ci_low": 0.03383035904415394, "ci_high": 0.05688932357966242, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.3303309402097879, "ci_low": 0.2989408521174521, "ci_high": 0.36633293216444196, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.28744261624920875, "ci_low": 0.21526298610220063, "ci_high": 0.3582367411777551, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.3718388644394814, "ci_low": 0.3496717345883449, "ci_high": 0.39931775432883027, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__unseeded", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 105, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 105, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.171502430027302, "ci_low": 0.12768823466661813, "ci_high": 0.21717096407605613, "n": 105, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.05042552652512653, "ci_low": 0.03918154987093213, "ci_high": 0.0615438138263012, "n": 105, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.2828620917098212, "ci_low": 0.25674013146307895, "ci_high": 0.30852136624613896, "n": 105, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.42235645713337105, "ci_low": 0.33728151462127925, "ci_high": 0.4999348803415598, "n": 105, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.31907463506902306, "ci_low": 0.3044796562714365, "ci_high": 0.3337820401571311, "n": 105, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__unseeded_ballot_fixed", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_oracle", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.1664140067203309, "ci_low": 0.11803433904019618, "ci_high": 0.2222152911747718, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.0484048449564163, "ci_low": 0.036470418564819744, "ci_high": 0.06121168847107559, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.2854855910779398, "ci_low": 0.2539192106154174, "ci_high": 0.31472038415729103, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.405530944848298, "ci_low": 0.31436232323476637, "ci_high": 0.49537325830850903, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.31912538492110715, "ci_low": 0.3023565845013252, "ci_high": 0.3358187036364567, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_continue", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 28, "logical_table": "all_rational", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 28, "n_instances": 11 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.14311650710609541, "ci_low": 0.10047755994076628, "ci_high": 0.19327811110624823, "n": 28, "n_instances": 11 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.05399566379369356, "ci_low": 0.0388086139610359, "ci_high": 0.0712727653623801, "n": 28, "n_instances": 11 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.26238627384981944, "ci_low": 0.23166144292603516, "ci_high": 0.2909479704809021, "n": 28, "n_instances": 11 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.4213101997417124, "ci_low": 0.369698035254155, "ci_high": 0.48090358499407715, "n": 28, "n_instances": 11 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.31894228875560354, "ci_low": 0.29861883373415077, "ci_high": 0.33692986953190096, "n": 28, "n_instances": 11 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_rational", "seeded_offer": "ceiling", "protocol_variant": "vote", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.23169279934651463, "ci_low": 0.16416931236658275, "ci_high": 0.3016251542588082, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.06340530806592576, "ci_low": 0.04621342066542662, "ci_high": 0.08016618817726619, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.23120207602399725, "ci_low": 0.20280895838626992, "ci_high": 0.2590949029239802, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.507226430513583, "ci_low": 0.3883416987943586, "ci_high": 0.6124490673641668, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.28726963907752484, "ci_low": 0.27619591012535444, "ci_high": 0.2976835637218877, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_continue", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 31, "logical_table": "all_rational", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 31, "n_instances": 14 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.1453362386956172, "ci_low": 0.10445493641906782, "ci_high": 0.19007505680646972, "n": 31, "n_instances": 14 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.053163396987469594, "ci_low": 0.04022157591217908, "ci_high": 0.06720991780737177, "n": 31, "n_instances": 14 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.2639042214961956, "ci_low": 0.2362912765769497, "ci_high": 0.29257667953851413, "n": 31, "n_instances": 14 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.40811615935282186, "ci_low": 0.33711325588388547, "ci_high": 0.4755488257891576, "n": 31, "n_instances": 14 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.3165401405198075, "ci_low": 0.29877775042425314, "ci_high": 0.3342259467621596, "n": 31, "n_instances": 14 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_vote", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 120, "logical_table": "all_rational", "seeded_offer": "placebo", "protocol_variant": "vote", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.11903506625939292, "ci_low": 0.08580777875848901, "ci_high": 0.15377106371105434, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.045328681122431234, "ci_low": 0.03383035904415394, "ci_high": 0.05688932357966242, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.3303309402097879, "ci_low": 0.2989408521174521, "ci_high": 0.36633293216444196, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.28744261624920875, "ci_low": 0.21526298610220063, "ci_high": 0.3582367411777551, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.3718388644394814, "ci_low": 0.3496717345883449, "ci_high": 0.39931775432883027, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__unseeded", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 28, "logical_table": "all_rational", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 28, "n_instances": 14 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.14694344596801961, "ci_low": 0.10260857555178413, "ci_high": 0.1952192782788258, "n": 28, "n_instances": 14 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.05224324367491081, "ci_low": 0.037389490827602484, "ci_high": 0.06768232827155635, "n": 28, "n_instances": 14 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.2606935627315637, "ci_low": 0.2384911421456786, "ci_high": 0.2831572095080825, "n": 28, "n_instances": 14 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.40783781598662144, "ci_low": 0.31855828621325144, "ci_high": 0.4833755817961708, "n": 28, "n_instances": 14 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.31364014160553955, "ci_low": 0.29932582246853784, "ci_high": 0.3265146158008415, "n": 28, "n_instances": 14 } }, { "arm": "one_oracle__unseeded", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 61, "logical_table": "one_oracle", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 61, "n_instances": 23 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.18745561379263206, "ci_low": 0.13129850644453353, "ci_high": 0.24664831224853626, "n": 61, "n_instances": 23 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.0539648259724275, "ci_low": 0.04029191910908609, "ci_high": 0.06770807430483738, "n": 61, "n_instances": 23 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.2722136558547562, "ci_low": 0.2418976452031472, "ci_high": 0.3011994063754159, "n": 61, "n_instances": 23 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.47186334385611284, "ci_low": 0.38546706886256116, "ci_high": 0.5482482811682233, "n": 61, "n_instances": 23 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.31433290995151064, "ci_low": 0.2975854074205042, "ci_high": 0.3317200955931618, "n": 61, "n_instances": 23 } }, { "arm": "one_rational__unseeded", "n_episodes": 120, "n_deals": 92, "logical_table": "one_rational", "seeded_offer": "none", "protocol_variant": "continue", "below_threshold_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 92, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off": { "estimate": 0.23923924245411646, "ci_low": 0.19595087827852217, "ci_high": 0.2832164267216742, "n": 92, "n_instances": 24 }, "worst_off_share": { "estimate": 0.0725120810975585, "ci_low": 0.06106425657164654, "ci_high": 0.08372035817248615, "n": 92, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_gini": { "estimate": 0.23136952807084968, "ci_low": 0.2083064400704245, "ci_high": 0.2546096204492791, "n": 92, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_nash_welfare_conditional": { "estimate": 0.5063123982328782, "ci_low": 0.43887862692171986, "ci_high": 0.5659807884721207, "n": 92, "n_instances": 24 }, "max_share": { "estimate": 0.30102142748483496, "ci_low": 0.2887677643629045, "ci_high": 0.31368888444948295, "n": 92, "n_instances": 24 } } ], "contrasts": [ { "treatment": "all_llm__ceiling_vote", "reference": "all_llm__placebo_vote", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.32211, "ci_low": 0.2865297083333333, "ci_high": 0.35988499999999995, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "reference": "all_oracle__placebo_continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.25, "ci_low": 0.14166666666666666, "ci_high": 0.35833333333333334, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.08333333333333333, "ci_low": -0.016666666666666666, "ci_high": 0.2, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.25, "ci_low": 0.14166666666666666, "ci_high": 0.35833333333333334, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.08810500000000002, "ci_low": -0.008360833333333335, "ci_high": 0.20265304166666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.26999999999999996, "ci_low": 0.18833333333333335, "ci_high": 0.35666666666666663, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue_ballot_fixed", "reference": "all_oracle__placebo_continue_ballot_fixed", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.25, "ci_low": 0.14166666666666666, "ci_high": 0.35833333333333334, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.2833333333333333, "ci_low": 0.18333333333333332, "ci_high": 0.38333333333333336, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.0471875, "ci_low": 0.015972187500000002, "ci_high": 0.08795458333333331, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.28, "ci_low": 0.18995833333333334, "ci_high": 0.3716666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_oracle__ceiling_vote", "reference": "all_oracle__placebo_vote", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.32211, "ci_low": 0.2865297083333333, "ci_high": 0.35988499999999995, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_rational__ceiling_continue", "reference": "all_rational__placebo_continue", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": -0.025, "ci_low": -0.075, "ci_high": 0.025, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.016666666666666666, "ci_low": -0.025, "ci_high": 0.075, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": -0.023560833333333333, "ci_low": -0.06321739583333333, "ci_high": 0.013631249999999996, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.11, "ci_low": 0.06666666666666667, "ci_high": 0.1566666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_rational__ceiling_vote", "reference": "all_rational__placebo_vote", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.32211, "ci_low": 0.2865297083333333, "ci_high": 0.35988499999999995, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_llm__ceiling_continue", "reference": "all_llm__unseeded", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": -0.05, "ci_high": 0.041666666666666664, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.38333333333333336, "ci_low": 0.24166666666666667, "ci_high": 0.5333333333333333, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.002848333333333336, "ci_low": -0.04740339583333335, "ci_high": 0.052080124999999984, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.46333333333333343, "ci_low": 0.3533333333333334, "ci_high": 0.5716666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "reference": "all_oracle__unseeded", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.325, "ci_low": 0.21666666666666667, "ci_high": 0.43333333333333335, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": -0.09166666666666666, "ci_low": -0.15833333333333333, "ci_high": -0.03333333333333333, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.325, "ci_low": 0.21666666666666667, "ci_high": 0.43333333333333335, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": -0.0747675, "ci_low": -0.13619497916666667, "ci_high": -0.018927166666666686, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.45, "ci_low": 0.3466666666666666, "ci_high": 0.5566666666666666, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue_ballot_fixed", "reference": "all_oracle__unseeded_ballot_fixed", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.325, "ci_low": 0.21666666666666667, "ci_high": 0.43333333333333335, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.45, "ci_low": 0.325, "ci_high": 0.575, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.0170025, "ci_low": 0.005321541666666665, "ci_high": 0.0315166875, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.5033333333333334, "ci_low": 0.3882916666666667, "ci_high": 0.6216666666666666, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_oracle__placebo_continue", "reference": "all_oracle__unseeded", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.075, "ci_low": 0.03333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.11666666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": -0.175, "ci_low": -0.275, "ci_high": -0.08333333333333333, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.075, "ci_low": 0.03333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.11666666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": -0.1628725, "ci_low": -0.25814937499999996, "ci_high": -0.07693552083333334, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.18000000000000002, "ci_low": 0.11, "ci_high": 0.25833333333333336, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_oracle__placebo_continue_ballot_fixed", "reference": "all_oracle__unseeded_ballot_fixed", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.075, "ci_low": 0.03333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.11666666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.16666666666666666, "ci_low": 0.075, "ci_high": 0.275, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": -0.030185, "ci_low": -0.06863708333333333, "ci_high": -0.002857270833333335, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.22333333333333333, "ci_low": 0.12666666666666665, "ci_high": 0.3333333333333333, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_rational__ceiling_continue", "reference": "all_rational__unseeded", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": -0.05, "ci_high": 0.05, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.025, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.075, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": -0.011464166666666668, "ci_low": -0.05824085416666666, "ci_high": 0.03221220833333328, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.15666666666666668, "ci_low": 0.11833333333333333, "ci_high": 0.2, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "treatment": "all_rational__placebo_continue", "reference": "all_rational__unseeded", "immediate_accept": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "deal_rate": { "estimate": 0.025, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.06666666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "final_is_seeded": { "estimate": 0.008333333333333333, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.025, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "normalized_primary": { "estimate": 0.012096666666666667, "ci_low": -0.008614166666666668, "ci_high": 0.039860854166666605, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 }, "seed_accept_fraction": { "estimate": 0.04666666666666666, "ci_low": 0.03166666666666667, "ci_high": 0.06166666666666667, "n": 120, "n_instances": 24 } } ], "vote_curve": [ { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 65, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.27692307692307694, "ci_low": 0.09090909090909091, "ci_high": 0.46153846153846156, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 40, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.4, "ci_low": 0.175, "ci_high": 0.6, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 75, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.29333333333333333, "ci_low": 0.15714285714285714, "ci_high": 0.42671428571428505, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.05, "ci_low": 0.010526315789473684, "ci_high": 0.09523809523809523, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.5, "ci_low": 0.3333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.6400344827586202, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 170, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.01764705882352941, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.03783783783783784, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.5294117647058824, "ci_low": 0.34594594594594597, "ci_high": 0.6909090909090909, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 150, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.3333333333333333, "ci_low": 0.192, "ci_high": 0.4484848484848485, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.5466666666666666, "ci_low": 0.4444444444444444, "ci_high": 0.6444444444444445, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 65, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 40, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 75, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 170, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 150, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 126, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 74, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 125, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 133, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_llm__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 42, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 65, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.6461538461538462, "ci_low": 0.509090909090909, "ci_high": 0.7625, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.6615384615384615, "ci_low": 0.509090909090909, "ci_high": 0.8, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 40, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.2, "ci_low": 0.075, "ci_high": 0.35, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.225, "ci_low": 0.1, "ci_high": 0.375, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 75, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.38666666666666666, "ci_low": 0.21333333333333335, "ci_high": 0.5529411764705883, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.4, "ci_low": 0.21333333333333335, "ci_high": 0.5875, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.34, "ci_low": 0.21052631578947367, "ci_high": 0.4740972222222219, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.34, "ci_low": 0.21052631578947367, "ci_high": 0.4740972222222219, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 170, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.37058823529411766, "ci_low": 0.26666666666666666, "ci_high": 0.46978001257071006, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.45294117647058824, "ci_low": 0.34375, "ci_high": 0.5579128856624317, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 150, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.44666666666666666, "ci_low": 0.31333333333333335, "ci_high": 0.5655172413793104, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.5133333333333333, "ci_low": 0.36428571428571427, "ci_high": 0.6518518518518519, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 65, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.6461538461538462, "ci_low": 0.509090909090909, "ci_high": 0.7625, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.7384615384615385, "ci_low": 0.6, "ci_high": 0.8625, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 40, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.2, "ci_low": 0.075, "ci_high": 0.35, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.35, "ci_low": 0.15, "ci_high": 0.575, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 75, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.38666666666666666, "ci_low": 0.21333333333333335, "ci_high": 0.5529411764705883, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.44, "ci_low": 0.25333333333333335, "ci_high": 0.6352941176470588, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.34, "ci_low": 0.21052631578947367, "ci_high": 0.4740972222222219, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.43, "ci_low": 0.28421052631578947, "ci_high": 0.5789473684210527, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 170, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.37058823529411766, "ci_low": 0.26666666666666666, "ci_high": 0.46978001257071006, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.5058823529411764, "ci_low": 0.3759939393939394, "ci_high": 0.6285714285714286, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 150, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.44666666666666666, "ci_low": 0.31333333333333335, "ci_high": 0.5655172413793104, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.52, "ci_low": 0.37037037037037035, "ci_high": 0.65625, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 65, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 40, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 75, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 170, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 150, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 126, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.24603174603174602, "ci_low": 0.1504424778761062, "ci_high": 0.3283582089552239, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.2698412698412698, "ci_low": 0.1509433962264151, "ci_high": 0.39310919540229877, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 74, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.17567567567567569, "ci_low": 0.08333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.2686710677382317, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.17567567567567569, "ci_low": 0.08333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.2686710677382317, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 125, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.08, "ci_low": 0.030861823361823363, "ci_high": 0.1452991452991453, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.112, "ci_low": 0.039735099337748346, "ci_high": 0.21428571428571427, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.09, "ci_low": 0.03, "ci_high": 0.16092880978865393, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.09, "ci_low": 0.03, "ci_high": 0.16092880978865393, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 133, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.13533834586466165, "ci_low": 0.05303030303030303, "ci_high": 0.23577235772357724, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.19548872180451127, "ci_low": 0.10135135135135136, "ci_high": 0.30509121490490354, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 42, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.19047619047619047, "ci_low": 0.07894736842105263, "ci_high": 0.29411764705882354, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.2857142857142857, "ci_low": 0.14634146341463414, "ci_high": 0.40816326530612246, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 126, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.24603174603174602, "ci_low": 0.1504424778761062, "ci_high": 0.3283582089552239, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.36507936507936506, "ci_low": 0.19, "ci_high": 0.5232696566998891, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 74, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.17567567567567569, "ci_low": 0.08333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.2686710677382317, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.1891891891891892, "ci_low": 0.08641443167305236, "ci_high": 0.29411764705882354, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 125, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.08, "ci_low": 0.030861823361823363, "ci_high": 0.1452991452991453, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.144, "ci_low": 0.04347155126140634, "ci_high": 0.29565731926935934, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.09, "ci_low": 0.03, "ci_high": 0.16092880978865393, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.15, "ci_low": 0.058823529411764705, "ci_high": 0.25, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 133, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.13533834586466165, "ci_low": 0.05303030303030303, "ci_high": 0.23577235772357724, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.21804511278195488, "ci_low": 0.10923987776928953, "ci_high": 0.34108988556662967, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_continue_ballot_fixed", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 42, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.19047619047619047, "ci_low": 0.07894736842105263, "ci_high": 0.29411764705882354, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.2857142857142857, "ci_low": 0.14634146341463414, "ci_high": 0.40816326530612246, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 126, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 74, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 125, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 133, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_oracle__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 42, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 65, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 40, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 75, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.08, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.18823529411764706, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.08, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.18823529411764706, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 170, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.2235294117647059, "ci_low": 0.15555555555555556, "ci_high": 0.2923076923076923, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.2235294117647059, "ci_low": 0.15555555555555556, "ci_high": 0.2923076923076923, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_continue", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 150, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.32, "ci_low": 0.26, "ci_high": 0.38125, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.32, "ci_low": 0.26, "ci_high": 0.38125, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 65, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 65, "n_instances": 11 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 40, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 40, "n_instances": 8 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 75, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 75, "n_instances": 12 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 15 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 170, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 170, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__ceiling_vote", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 150, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 150, "n_instances": 17 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 126, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 74, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 125, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.0, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.0, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.01, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.03125, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.01, "ci_low": 0.0, "ci_high": 0.03125, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 133, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.12781954887218044, "ci_low": 0.08333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.17886178861788618, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.12781954887218044, "ci_low": 0.08333333333333333, "ci_high": 0.17886178861788618, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_continue", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 42, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.23809523809523808, "ci_low": 0.11904761904761904, "ci_high": 0.3793103448275862, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 0.23809523809523808, "ci_low": 0.11904761904761904, "ci_high": 0.3793103448275862, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.0, "z_high": 0.1, "n_seat_turns": 126, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 126, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.1, "z_high": 0.2, "n_seat_turns": 74, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 74, "n_instances": 19 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.2, "z_high": 0.35, "n_seat_turns": 125, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 125, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.35, "z_high": 0.5, "n_seat_turns": 100, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 100, "n_instances": 22 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.5, "z_high": 0.75, "n_seat_turns": 133, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 133, "n_instances": 24 } }, { "arm": "all_rational__placebo_vote", "z_low": 0.75, "z_high": 1.01, "n_seat_turns": 42, "first_move_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 }, "ever_accepts_seed": { "estimate": 1.0, "ci_low": 1.0, "ci_high": 1.0, "n": 42, "n_instances": 16 } } ], "figures": [ ".claude/products/seeded-optimal-opening/analysis_with_ballot_fix/seeded_offer.png", ".claude/products/seeded-optimal-opening/analysis_with_ballot_fix/seeded_offer.pdf" ] }