{ "B": { "items": 331, "samples": 2648, "verified": [ 0.1268882175226586, 0.11474862442249444, 0.1401088301102348 ], "single": [ 0.1782477341389728, 0.16413956667413937, 0.19328811678930724 ], "silent_error": [ 0.6404833836858006, 0.6220147464941264, 0.6585449973457771 ], "smuggled": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0014486536450744267 ], "has_sql": [ 0.9879154078549849, 0.9829902434304691, 0.9914269314113464 ], "inflation_single_minus_verified": 0.0513595166163142, "invalid_tool_call_rate": 0.16150956895009838, "tool_calls_per_traj": 2.111404833836858, "verified_by_family": { "F1": [ 0.5659722222222222, 0.5082329974060685, 0.6219746220697019 ], "F2": [ 0.010416666666666666, 0.0035487456405297844, 0.03017365719717396 ], "F3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.010558440816003448 ], "F4": [ 0.09929906542056074, 0.08601700626020076, 0.11437538427281815 ] }, "pass^k": { "1": 0.1268882175226586, "2": 0.0807078118256366, "4": 0.03927492447129909 } }, "C": { "items": 331, "samples": 2648, "verified": [ 0.08950151057401813, 0.07921473537422782, 0.10097762603981741 ], "single": [ 0.1404833836858006, 0.12776814975928472, 0.15424024772569325 ], "silent_error": [ 0.6117824773413897, 0.5930709276238418, 0.6301701588724254 ], "smuggled": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0014486536450744267 ], "has_sql": [ 0.9898036253776435, 0.9852051270532216, 0.9929830120875174 ], "inflation_single_minus_verified": 0.050981873111782476, "invalid_tool_call_rate": 0.19475857117214146, "tool_calls_per_traj": 2.1038519637462234, "verified_by_family": { "F1": [ 0.2881944444444444, 0.23894335969829233, 0.3430216514584447 ], "F2": [ 0.013888888888888888, 0.005413932945500995, 0.03516150249619066 ], "F3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.010558440816003448 ], "F4": [ 0.08761682242990654, 0.07513001880538675, 0.10195019652451318 ] }, "pass^k": { "1": 0.08950151057401813, "2": 0.04650410012947777, "4": 0.021881743634009496 } }, "base": { "items": 331, "samples": 2648, "verified": [ 0.00944108761329305, 0.006403035813880433, 0.013900439325811167 ], "single": [ 0.013972809667673716, 0.010154211548516916, 0.019199577908590927 ], "silent_error": [ 0.044939577039274925, 0.03768610278395517, 0.053511501175497 ], "smuggled": [ 0.009818731117824773, 0.006709341143569564, 0.014348326855906725 ], "has_sql": [ 0.4641238670694864, 0.4451942281977531, 0.4831574501227016 ], "inflation_single_minus_verified": 0.004531722054380665, "invalid_tool_call_rate": 0.6372934697088907, "tool_calls_per_traj": 1.4399546827794563, "verified_by_family": { "F1": [ 0.052083333333333336, 0.03181368244310767, 0.08414511164245109 ], "F2": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.01316330502573999 ], "F3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.010558440816003448 ], "F4": [ 0.005841121495327103, 0.0031758413326046587, 0.010719147575462381 ] }, "pass^k": { "1": 0.00944108761329305, "2": 0.0011868795856711265, "4": 4.3159257660768235e-05 } }, "command_a": { "items": 331, "samples": 331, "verified": [ 0.8096676737160121, 0.7639169970960494, 0.8483127855832832 ], "single": [ 0.8277945619335347, 0.7834184000616147, 0.8646492235550447 ], "silent_error": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.011472887478736215 ], "smuggled": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.011472887478736215 ], "has_sql": [ 1.0, 0.9885271125212638, 1.0 ], "inflation_single_minus_verified": 0.01812688821752266, "invalid_tool_call_rate": null, "tool_calls_per_traj": 0.0, "verified_by_family": { "F1": [ 1.0, 0.9035781695514236, 1.0 ], "F2": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.09642183044857634 ], "F3": [ 0.6444444444444445, 0.49835546011952203, 0.7678110864309596 ], "F4": [ 0.9485981308411215, 0.9103152736698502, 0.97105908274325 ] }, "pass^k": { "1": 0.8096676737160121 } }, "dpo_cf": { "items": 331, "samples": 2648, "verified": [ 0.08081570996978851, 0.0710315571100918, 0.09181436852890561 ], "single": [ 0.12537764350453173, 0.11330483073765868, 0.13853585235593185 ], "silent_error": [ 0.5506042296072508, 0.5315979057237126, 0.5694639374874355 ], "smuggled": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0014486536450744267 ], "has_sql": [ 0.9867824773413897, 0.9816736852853708, 0.9904809109770906 ], "inflation_single_minus_verified": 0.0445619335347432, "invalid_tool_call_rate": 0.2736220472440945, "tool_calls_per_traj": 2.302114803625378, "verified_by_family": { "F1": [ 0.10416666666666667, 0.07394416745420873, 0.1448101156911688 ], "F2": [ 0.04513888888888889, 0.02656610510554363, 0.07568662377203927 ], "F3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.010558440816003448 ], "F4": [ 0.09988317757009346, 0.08656301072177836, 0.1149949885713965 ] }, "pass^k": { "1": 0.08081570996978851, "2": 0.04725938713854121, "4": 0.027967198964177813 } }, "dpo_std": { "items": 331, "samples": 2648, "verified": [ 0.09667673716012085, 0.08599811796888701, 0.10852390778106727 ], "single": [ 0.14123867069486404, 0.1284927307638437, 0.1550240524407036 ], "silent_error": [ 0.6242447129909365, 0.6056301572403511, 0.642499293628811 ], "smuggled": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0014486536450744267 ], "has_sql": [ 0.9826283987915407, 0.976907574711035, 0.9869509000937948 ], "inflation_single_minus_verified": 0.0445619335347432, "invalid_tool_call_rate": 0.2001751313485114, "tool_calls_per_traj": 2.156344410876133, "verified_by_family": { "F1": [ 0.21180555555555555, 0.1685680334873284, 0.26263026038167453 ], "F2": [ 0.04513888888888889, 0.02656610510554363, 0.07568662377203927 ], "F3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.010558440816003448 ], "F4": [ 0.10630841121495327, 0.09257861664237751, 0.12180107901251278 ] }, "pass^k": { "1": 0.09667673716012085, "2": 0.05718601640051791, "4": 0.035692706085455335 } }, "sft": { "items": 331, "samples": 2648, "verified": [ 0.11744712990936555, 0.10573490482027162, 0.13026772821784044 ], "single": [ 0.1506797583081571, 0.13756052932541457, 0.16481107537374995 ], "silent_error": [ 0.631797583081571, 0.6132481171094243, 0.6499651909554315 ], "smuggled": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0014486536450744267 ], "has_sql": [ 0.9848942598187311, 0.9794965146895472, 0.9888871172739909 ], "inflation_single_minus_verified": 0.03323262839879154, "invalid_tool_call_rate": 0.15845902235144466, "tool_calls_per_traj": 2.0781722054380665, "verified_by_family": { "F1": [ 0.7638888888888888, 0.7115661358076089, 0.8092643420954728 ], "F2": [ 0.003472222222222222, 0.0006131798857472621, 0.01940315774398065 ], "F3": [ 0.013888888888888888, 0.005946618004726728, 0.03209631056638774 ], "F4": [ 0.04964953271028037, 0.04033028739796064, 0.06098535852180259 ] }, "pass^k": { "1": 0.11744712990936555, "2": 0.07531290461804056, "4": 0.04574881312041433 } }, "sft_distil": { "items": 331, "samples": 2648, "verified": [ 0.032854984894259816, 0.026713379938317596, 0.04035005250802459 ], "single": [ 0.11216012084592145, 0.10069811807301167, 0.12474581492811478 ], "silent_error": [ 0.7624622356495468, 0.7458796916194327, 0.7782843459309249 ], "smuggled": [ 0.0007552870090634441, 0.00020714704548820194, 0.002749892319155599 ], "has_sql": [ 0.9845166163141994, 0.979063359109742, 0.9885660799940115 ], "inflation_single_minus_verified": 0.07930513595166164, "invalid_tool_call_rate": 0.13636363636363635, "tool_calls_per_traj": 2.1351963746223563, "verified_by_family": { "F1": [ 0.041666666666666664, 0.023992942786740433, 0.07140675348685457 ], "F2": [ 0.006944444444444444, 0.0019064476108571395, 0.024962922622858687 ], "F3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.010558440816003448 ], "F4": [ 0.04264018691588785, 0.03404933943902742, 0.05327900135886442 ] }, "pass^k": { "1": 0.032854984894259816, "2": 0.017371601208459216, "4": 0.01126456624946051 } }, "sft_ho": { "items": 331, "samples": 2648, "verified": [ 0.09441087613293052, 0.08385386452215371, 0.10614300406909247 ], "single": [ 0.145392749244713, 0.13248019213082912, 0.15933271253134978 ], "silent_error": [ 0.6544561933534743, 0.6361312421086428, 0.6723336375432941 ], "smuggled": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0014486536450744267 ], "has_sql": [ 0.9894259818731118, 0.9847598517719502, 0.992674094509004 ], "inflation_single_minus_verified": 0.050981873111782476, "invalid_tool_call_rate": 0.17247542448614836, "tool_calls_per_traj": 2.112915407854985, "verified_by_family": { "F1": [ 0.3090277777777778, 0.2584654815261959, 0.3646177252544687 ], "F2": [ 0.010416666666666666, 0.0035487456405297844, 0.03017365719717396 ], "F3": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.010558440816003448 ], "F4": [ 0.09228971962616822, 0.07947697463117155, 0.10692811077997595 ] }, "pass^k": { "1": 0.09441087613293052, "2": 0.04920155373327578, "4": 0.021450151057401813 } }, "comparisons": { "C_vs_B": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 7.025478407740593e-05, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.037386706948640484, -0.05324773413897281, -0.022658610271903322 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.606295937693966, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.028700906344410877, -0.052870090634441085, -0.005287009063444109 ] }, "B_vs_sft_ho": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.006426576095691416, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.0324773413897281, 0.01812688821752266, 0.047960725075528704 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.06138589870445953, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.013972809667673716, -0.03625377643504532, 0.008685800604229608 ] }, "C_vs_sft_ho": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.21003961563110352, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.004909365558912387, -0.015483383685800604, 0.0056646525679758305 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.1979791406725175, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.04267371601208459, -0.06570996978851963, -0.02039274924471299 ] }, "sft_ho_vs_base": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 8.430331945419312e-06, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.08496978851963746, 0.06306646525679759, 0.10725075528700906 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 5.104817220120468e-61, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.6095166163141994, 0.574773413897281, 0.6450151057401813 ] }, "sft_vs_base": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 3.608874976634979e-08, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.10800604229607251, 0.08270392749244714, 0.13481873111782477 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 3.838328256567196e-49, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.5868580060422961, 0.5513595166163142, 0.622356495468278 ] }, "sft_vs_sft_ho": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.18774155899882317, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.023036253776435044, 0.0007552870090634441, 0.04607250755287009 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.2066471089849431, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.022658610271903322, -0.052870090634441085, 0.008308157099697885 ] }, "C_vs_command_a": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 8.843436600416711e-75, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.720166163141994, -0.7628398791540786, -0.6763595166163142 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 4.861730685829017e-63, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.6117824773413897, 0.573262839879154, 0.6487915407854985 ] }, "B_vs_command_a": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 2.967364920549937e-67, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.6827794561933535, -0.7265861027190332, -0.6374622356495468 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 3.111507638930571e-61, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.6404833836858006, 0.6049848942598187, 0.675226586102719 ] }, "sft_ho_vs_command_a": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 6.876656300484035e-71, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.7152567975830816, -0.7579305135951662, -0.6714501510574018 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 5.934729841099874e-67, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.6544561933534743, 0.6204682779456193, 0.6884441087613293 ] }, "sft_distil_vs_sft_ho": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.0009122341871261597, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.061555891238670696, -0.08270392749244714, -0.0411631419939577 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.06353719866713946, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.10800604229607251, 0.06722054380664652, 0.14841389728096677 ] }, "B_vs_sft_distil": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 4.405936238072172e-08, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.09403323262839879, 0.06759818731117825, 0.1216012084592145 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.000893531059458462, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.12197885196374622, -0.16200906344410876, -0.0823262839879154 ] }, "dpo_cf_vs_dpo_std": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.4048728942871094, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.015861027190332326, -0.026435045317220542, -0.0056646525679758305 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.00013082231066914517, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.0736404833836858, -0.10007552870090634, -0.047960725075528704 ] }, "dpo_std_vs_sft_ho": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 1.0, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ 0.0022658610271903325, -0.010196374622356496, 0.01472809667673716 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.6646454904132143, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.030211480362537766, -0.05211480362537765, -0.008308157099697885 ] }, "dpo_cf_vs_sft_ho": { "n_items": 331, "mcnemar_p_sample0": 0.557197093963623, "verified_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.013595166163141994, -0.0256797583081571, -0.0018882175226586104 ], "silent_mcnemar_p_sample0": 1.8940835677418387e-05, "silent_error_diff_bootstrap95": [ -0.10385196374622356, -0.13066465256797583, -0.07741691842900301 ] } } }