visual-answerability / expected /diagnostic-analysis.json
sungguk's picture
Release visual answerability benchmark v1.0.0
e1ced61 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
6.79 kB
{
"status": "passed",
"inference_calls": 0,
"analysis_status": "post-hoc descriptive accounting on frozen responses",
"sha_validation_performed": false,
"domains": {
"plotqa": {
"qwen38-flash-next": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
835,
147,
11,
7,
0,
0
],
"failures": 190,
"affected_groups": 165,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 25,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"gemma4-31b-it": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
667,
300,
19,
14,
0,
0
],
"failures": 380,
"affected_groups": 333,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 47,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"qwen": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
665,
283,
39,
13,
0,
0
],
"failures": 400,
"affected_groups": 335,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 65,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"gemma4-26b-a4b-it": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
539,
419,
22,
16,
4,
0
],
"failures": 527,
"affected_groups": 461,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 66,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"glm": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
273,
558,
167,
1,
1,
0
],
"failures": 899,
"affected_groups": 727,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 172,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"molmo2-8b": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
194,
509,
297,
0,
0,
0
],
"failures": 1103,
"affected_groups": 806,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 297,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
}
},
"clevr": {
"qwen38-flash-next": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
454,
506,
28,
11,
1
],
"failures": 599,
"affected_groups": 546,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 53,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"gemma4-31b-it": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
210,
451,
89,
245,
5
],
"failures": 1384,
"affected_groups": 790,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 594,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"qwen": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
273,
505,
144,
69,
9
],
"failures": 1036,
"affected_groups": 727,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 309,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"gemma4-26b-a4b-it": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
189,
491,
79,
228,
13
],
"failures": 1385,
"affected_groups": 811,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 574,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"glm": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
205,
793,
2,
0,
0
],
"failures": 797,
"affected_groups": 795,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 2,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"molmo2-8b": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
216,
562,
107,
112,
3
],
"failures": 1124,
"affected_groups": 784,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 340,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
}
},
"gqa": {
"qwen38-flash-next": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
399,
448,
137,
16
],
"failures": 770,
"affected_groups": 601,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 169,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"gemma4-31b-it": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
372,
453,
160,
15
],
"failures": 818,
"affected_groups": 628,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 190,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"qwen": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
359,
455,
170,
16
],
"failures": 843,
"affected_groups": 641,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 202,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"gemma4-26b-a4b-it": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
392,
400,
192,
16
],
"failures": 832,
"affected_groups": 608,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 224,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"glm": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
305,
651,
42,
2
],
"failures": 741,
"affected_groups": 695,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 46,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
},
"molmo2-8b": {
"groups_by_number_of_failed_states": [
267,
573,
146,
14
],
"failures": 907,
"affected_groups": 733,
"failures_beyond_first_per_affected_group": 174,
"accounting_identity": "k*E = (1-B_k) + repeated_failures/G"
}
}
},
"gqa_reweighting": {
"definition": "E_lambda=(1-lambda)*E_A+lambda*E_U, fixed predictions and labels",
"QwenNext_minus_GLM_answerable_pp": 11.6,
"QwenNext_minus_GLM_unanswerable_pp": -20.3,
"crossover_lambda_point_estimate": 0.36363636363636365,
"interpretation": "arithmetic sensitivity; not a measured deployment prevalence or calibrated threshold"
}
}