| { |
| "schema_version": 1, |
| "models": [ |
| "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "qwen", |
| "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "glm", |
| "molmo2-8b" |
| ], |
| "domains": { |
| "plotqa": { |
| "groups": 1000, |
| "views": 5000, |
| "states": [ |
| "FULL", |
| "A_SAME", |
| "A_CHANGED", |
| "U_MISSING", |
| "U_INVALID" |
| ], |
| "models": { |
| "qwen38-flash-next": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 190, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 190, |
| "valid": 5000, |
| "groups_correct": 835, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 570, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 2473, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 2000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 12, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 12, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 27, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 27, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 10, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 10, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 113, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 113, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_INVALID": { |
| "failures": 28, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 28, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.038000000000000006, |
| "group_success": 0.835, |
| "joint_success": 0.57, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.8243333333333331, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.043416666666666666, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.05066666666666672, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.861, |
| "missing_failure": 0.113, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.01633333333333333, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.0705 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 10, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.03239999999999994, |
| 0.04400000000000006 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.811, |
| 0.857 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.539, |
| 0.6 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.8073333333333321, |
| 0.840999999999999 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.03733333333333334, |
| 0.04991874999999998 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.0426666666666667, |
| 0.05900000000000013 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.839, |
| 0.882 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.094, |
| 0.133 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.010333333333333333, |
| 0.023333333333333324 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.06, |
| 0.0815 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 380, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 380, |
| "valid": 5000, |
| "groups_correct": 667, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 556, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 2610, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 2000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 19, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 19, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 15, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 15, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 19, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 19, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 285, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 285, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_INVALID": { |
| "failures": 42, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 42, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.07600000000000046, |
| "group_success": 0.667, |
| "joint_success": 0.556, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.8699999999999998, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.09058333333333334, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.10633333333333297, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.696, |
| "missing_failure": 0.285, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.017666666666666664, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.1635 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 10, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.06880000000000035, |
| 0.08340000000000049 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.638, |
| 0.696 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.525, |
| 0.5860249999999996 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.8543333333333325, |
| 0.8853333333333332 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.08241666666666667, |
| 0.09891666666666667 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.09633333333333309, |
| 0.11633333333333287 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.668, |
| 0.724 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.257, |
| 0.313 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.010333333333333333, |
| 0.025999999999999995 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.1485, |
| 0.179 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 400, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 400, |
| "valid": 5000, |
| "groups_correct": 665, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 341, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 2125, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 2000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 27, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 27, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 53, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 53, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 31, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 31, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 239, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 239, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_INVALID": { |
| "failures": 50, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 50, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.08000000000000045, |
| "group_success": 0.665, |
| "joint_success": 0.341, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.7083333333333336, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.09075000000000004, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.10633333333333302, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.705, |
| "missing_failure": 0.239, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.037000000000000005, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.1445 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 10, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.07240000000000035, |
| 0.08800000000000052 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.636, |
| 0.694 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.312, |
| 0.371 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.6896666666666667, |
| 0.7273333333333327 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.08249791666666668, |
| 0.0994166666666667 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.09599999999999978, |
| 0.11699999999999956 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.677, |
| 0.733 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.213, |
| 0.265 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.028, |
| 0.04633333333333337 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.1299875, |
| 0.1595 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 527, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 527, |
| "valid": 5000, |
| "groups_correct": 539, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 407, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 2418, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 2000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 22, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 22, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 23, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 23, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 23, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 23, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 427, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 427, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_INVALID": { |
| "failures": 32, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 32, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.10540000000000078, |
| "group_success": 0.539, |
| "joint_success": 0.407, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.8060000000000003, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.12608333333333335, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.15733333333333346, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.552, |
| "missing_failure": 0.427, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.022666666666666665, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.2295 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 10, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.09740000000000074, |
| 0.11380000000000084 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.507, |
| 0.57 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.377, |
| 0.438 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.7863333333333323, |
| 0.8253416666666666 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.11716458333333332, |
| 0.1355 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.14633333333333318, |
| 0.16900000000000026 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.52, |
| 0.582 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.396, |
| 0.459 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.014333333333333333, |
| 0.031999999999999994 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.213, |
| 0.2465 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "glm": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 899, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 899, |
| "valid": 5000, |
| "groups_correct": 273, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 182, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 2211, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 2000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 4, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 4, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 9, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 9, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 2, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 2, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 612, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 612, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_INVALID": { |
| "failures": 272, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 272, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.17979999999999935, |
| "group_success": 0.273, |
| "joint_success": 0.182, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.7370000000000009, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.22349999999999998, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.2083333333333349, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.38, |
| "missing_failure": 0.612, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.004999999999999999, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.442 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 10, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.17159999999999953, |
| 0.18819999999999923 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.246, |
| 0.301 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.159, |
| 0.207 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.7170000000000006, |
| 0.7570000000000005 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.21324999999999997, |
| 0.2337520833333333 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.19800000000000126, |
| 0.2183416666666684 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.35, |
| 0.41 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.582, |
| 0.641 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.0019999999999999996, |
| 0.008999999999999998 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.4215, |
| 0.462 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "molmo2-8b": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 1103, |
| "invalid": 8, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 1095, |
| "valid": 4992, |
| "groups_correct": 194, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 61, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 1707, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 2000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 0, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 0, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 0, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 0, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 1, |
| "invalid": 1, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 0, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 538, |
| "invalid": 2, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 536, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_INVALID": { |
| "failures": 564, |
| "invalid": 5, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 559, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.2205999999999991, |
| "group_success": 0.194, |
| "joint_success": 0.061, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.5690000000000002, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.2756666666666666, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.17933333333333407, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.462, |
| "missing_failure": 0.538, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.0003333333333333333, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.551 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 10, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [ |
| "item-1569", |
| "item-4502", |
| "item-0279", |
| "item-0146", |
| "item-0980", |
| "item-2884", |
| "item-4401", |
| "item-4658" |
| ], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.21199999999999947, |
| 0.2291999999999992 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.17, |
| 0.219 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.046, |
| 0.076 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.5456666666666665, |
| 0.5923333333333333 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.265, |
| 0.2864166666666667 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.16900000000000043, |
| 0.18966666666666768 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.431, |
| 0.493 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.507, |
| 0.569 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.0, |
| 0.001 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.5295, |
| 0.5725 |
| ] |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "paired_contrasts": { |
| "qwen38-flash-next__gemma4-31b-it": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -3.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.520000000000051, |
| -3.1000000000000325 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 16.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 14.000000000000002, |
| 19.602499999999957 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.4000000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.200000000000002, |
| 4.999999999999993 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.566666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.433333333333346, |
| -2.6666666666667056 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.716666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.508333333333333, |
| -3.9499999999999993 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.566666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.566666666666615, |
| -4.566666666666638 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 16.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 13.797499999999992, |
| 19.200000000000006 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -17.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -19.9, |
| -14.600000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.1333333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.9666666666666666, |
| 0.6666666666666664 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -9.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -10.75, |
| -7.9 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__qwen": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "qwen", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.960000000000045, |
| -3.4400000000000346 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 17.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 13.99999999999999, |
| 19.999999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 22.900000000000002, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 19.3, |
| 26.499999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 11.600000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 9.733333333333327, |
| 13.433333333333353 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.733333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.558333333333336, |
| -3.8833333333333324 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.566666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.599999999999959, |
| -4.499999999999967 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 15.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 12.7, |
| 18.399999999999995 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -12.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -15.200000000000003, |
| -10.0 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.0666666666666664, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.933333333333334, |
| -1.2333333333333323 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -7.3999999999999995, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.9, |
| -5.900000000000001 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -6.74, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -7.560000000000086, |
| -5.960000000000068 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 29.599999999999998, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 26.39999999999999, |
| 32.9 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 16.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 12.599999999999994, |
| 19.899999999999995 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.833333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.29999999999991145, |
| 3.933333333333333 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -8.266666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -9.183333333333335, |
| -7.383333333333334 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -10.666666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -11.866666666666687, |
| -9.533333333333305 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 30.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 27.700000000000003, |
| 34.199999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -31.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -34.599999999999994, |
| -28.300000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.6333333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.5341666666666673, |
| 0.23333333333333262 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -15.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -17.599999999999998, |
| -14.200000000000001 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__glm": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -14.180000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -15.079999999999922, |
| -13.239999999999952 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 56.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 52.89999999999999, |
| 59.3 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 38.800000000000004, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 35.2, |
| 42.20249999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 8.733333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 6.6333333333332245, |
| 10.799999999999944 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -18.008333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -19.058333333333334, |
| -16.908333333333335 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -15.766666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -16.900000000000166, |
| -14.60000000000011 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 48.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 44.8975, |
| 51.300000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -49.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -53.0, |
| -46.797500000000035 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.1333333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.43333333333333385, |
| 1.866666666666667 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -37.15, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -39.15, |
| -35.099999999999994 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -18.26, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -19.19999999999993, |
| -17.299999999999933 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 64.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 60.9, |
| 67.10000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 50.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 47.7, |
| 54.099999999999994 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 25.533333333333335, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 23.099999999999955, |
| 27.900000000000013 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -23.225, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -24.34166666666667, |
| -22.08333333333333 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -12.866666666666665, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -14.000000000000098, |
| -11.700000000000049 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 39.900000000000006, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 36.6, |
| 43.2 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -42.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -45.699999999999996, |
| -39.300000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.9999999999999999, |
| 2.2999999999999994 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -48.05, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -50.2, |
| -45.9 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__qwen": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "qwen", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.2600000000000082, |
| 0.4600000000000104 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.299999999999992, |
| 3.599999999999992 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 21.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 17.700000000000003, |
| 25.199999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 16.166666666666668, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 14.100000000000035, |
| 18.166666666666554 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.01666666666666652, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.9666666666666712, |
| 0.9499999999999926 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -8.881784197001253e-17, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.1999999999999984, |
| 1.266666666666645 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.8999999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.299999999999993, |
| 2.399999999999991 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.6000000000000014, |
| 7.799999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.9333333333333327, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.866666666666667, |
| -0.9999999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.15000000000000013, |
| 3.6999999999999975 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.9400000000000004, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.660000000000041, |
| -2.2400000000000237 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 12.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 9.999999999999998, |
| 15.600000000000003 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 14.899999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 11.700000000000005, |
| 17.999999999999993 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.66666666666674, |
| 8.134166666666697 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -3.55, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.366666666666667, |
| -2.7499999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.16666666666672, |
| -4.0666666666667 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 14.399999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 11.6, |
| 17.299999999999994 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -14.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -17.0, |
| -11.399999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.2666666666666666, |
| 0.23333333333333295 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -6.6000000000000005, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.149999999999999, |
| -5.099999999999999 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__glm": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -10.38, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -11.35999999999988, |
| -9.339999999999947 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 39.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 35.7, |
| 42.800000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 37.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 33.800000000000004, |
| 40.9 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 13.300000000000004, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 11.133333333333296, |
| 15.433333333333243 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -13.291666666666668, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -14.424999999999995, |
| -12.099791666666665 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -10.199999999999998, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -11.433333333333497, |
| -8.93250000000015 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 31.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 28.000000000000004, |
| 35.0 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -32.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -36.1, |
| -29.2 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.2666666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.4666666666666666, |
| 2.1333333333333337 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -27.85, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -29.999999999999993, |
| -25.650000000000002 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -14.460000000000003, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -15.519999999999895, |
| -13.379999999999864 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 47.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 43.7, |
| 50.89999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 49.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 46.300000000000004, |
| 52.69999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 30.099999999999998, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 27.699999999999847, |
| 32.46666666666662 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -18.508333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -19.791666666666664, |
| -17.216666666666665 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -7.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.600000000000094, |
| -6.0325000000000735 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 23.400000000000002, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 19.699999999999996, |
| 27.199999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -25.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -29.000000000000004, |
| -21.6 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.7333333333333336, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.0, |
| 2.5666666666666664 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -38.75, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -41.25, |
| -36.25000000000001 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen__gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "left": "qwen", |
| "right": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.54, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.4600000000000435, |
| -1.6595000000000222 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 12.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 9.000000000000007, |
| 16.299999999999994 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -6.6000000000000005, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -10.299999999999997, |
| -2.9000000000000026 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -9.766666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -12.066666666666626, |
| -7.4333333333334695 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -3.5333333333333337, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.558333333333333, |
| -2.533333333333333 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.466666666666729, |
| -3.8000000000000616 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 15.299999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 11.799999999999999, |
| 18.999999999999993 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -18.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -22.2, |
| -15.499999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.433333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.4999999999999987, |
| 2.400000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -8.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -10.4, |
| -6.65 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen__glm": { |
| "left": "qwen", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -9.98, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -11.039999999999903, |
| -8.879999999999946 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 39.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 35.300000000000004, |
| 42.900000000000006 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 15.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 12.3, |
| 19.5 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.8666666666666676, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.100000000000094, |
| -0.6000000000001108 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -13.275, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -14.508541666666668, |
| -12.008333333333326 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -10.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -11.533333333333527, |
| -8.83333333333351 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 32.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 28.7, |
| 36.199999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -37.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -40.900000000000006, |
| -33.699999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.2999999999999994, |
| 4.133333333333336 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -29.75, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -32.05, |
| -27.349999999999998 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "qwen", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -14.060000000000002, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -15.159999999999856, |
| -12.939999999999907 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 47.099999999999994, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 43.400000000000006, |
| 50.70000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 28.000000000000004, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 24.9, |
| 31.1 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 13.93333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 11.566666666666736, |
| 16.29999999999988 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -18.491666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -19.791666666666664, |
| -17.166666666666668 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -7.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.633333333333441, |
| -5.933333333333414 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 24.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 20.400000000000006, |
| 28.099999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -29.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -33.60000000000001, |
| -26.1 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.6666666666666674, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.7999999999999976, |
| 4.600000000000003 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -40.65, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -43.199999999999996, |
| -38.14999999999999 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-26b-a4b-it__glm": { |
| "left": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -7.44, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.399999999999892, |
| -6.399999999999895 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 26.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 23.099999999999998, |
| 30.099999999999994 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 22.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 19.1, |
| 25.900000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.566666666666597, |
| 9.233333333333215 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -9.741666666666665, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -10.858333333333334, |
| -8.558333333333334 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.333333333333521, |
| -3.8000000000001033 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 17.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 13.600000000000001, |
| 20.699999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -18.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -21.9, |
| -14.999999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.7666666666666664, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.8666666666666668, |
| 2.7 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -21.25, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -23.35, |
| -19.05 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-26b-a4b-it__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -11.519999999999998, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -12.619999999999838, |
| -10.399999999999842 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 34.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 30.797500000000003, |
| 38.2 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 34.599999999999994, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 31.4, |
| 37.7 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 23.700000000000003, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 21.03333333333338, |
| 26.300833333333514 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -14.958333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -16.25833333333333, |
| -13.64166666666667 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.1999999999999997, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.6000000000000894, |
| -0.7333333333333747 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 9.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.900000000000004, |
| 12.999999999999995 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -11.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -15.000000000000002, |
| -7.1000000000000005 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.233333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.4, |
| 3.166666666666666 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -32.15, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -34.699999999999996, |
| -29.65 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "glm__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "glm", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.079999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.119999999999977, |
| -3.0399999999999956 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 7.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.500000000000001, |
| 11.399999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 12.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 9.6, |
| 14.700000000000003 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 16.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 14.499166666666609, |
| 19.133333333333336 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.216666666666668, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.516666666666665, |
| -3.9250000000000007 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.9000000000000004, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.6333333333333782, |
| 4.200000000000112 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -8.200000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -12.0, |
| -4.497500000000035 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 7.3999999999999995, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.600000000000003, |
| 11.2 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.4666666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.13333333333333336, |
| 0.8666666666666666 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -10.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -13.5, |
| -8.300000000000002 |
| ] |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "analytic_baselines": { |
| "always_answerable_failure": 0.4, |
| "always_unanswerable_failure": 0.6, |
| "constant_decision_group_success": 0, |
| "constant_decision_balanced_failure": 0.5 |
| } |
| }, |
| "clevr": { |
| "groups": 1000, |
| "views": 4000, |
| "states": [ |
| "FULL", |
| "A_SAME", |
| "A_CHANGED", |
| "U_MISSING" |
| ], |
| "models": { |
| "qwen38-flash-next": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 599, |
| "invalid": 1, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 598, |
| "valid": 3999, |
| "groups_correct": 454, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 435, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 2757, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 47, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 47, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 38, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 38, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 35, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 35, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 479, |
| "invalid": 1, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 478, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.14975, |
| "group_success": 0.454, |
| "joint_success": 0.435, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.918999999999999, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.25949999999999995, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.18800000000000092, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.474, |
| "missing_failure": 0.479, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.04000000000000001, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.479 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 9, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [ |
| "cross-03487" |
| ], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.14025, |
| 0.15925 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.423975, |
| 0.485 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.405, |
| 0.466 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.9063333333333325, |
| 0.9313333333333323 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.24366666666666667, |
| 0.2746666666666666 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.17600000000000054, |
| 0.19966666666666788 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.443, |
| 0.505 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.448, |
| 0.509 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.030999999999999993, |
| 0.049341666666666575 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.448, |
| 0.509 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 1384, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 1384, |
| "valid": 4000, |
| "groups_correct": 210, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 89, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 1329, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 315, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 315, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 315, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 315, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 319, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 319, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 435, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 435, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.346, |
| "group_success": 0.21, |
| "joint_success": 0.089, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.44299999999999984, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.3756666666666666, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.355, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.243, |
| "missing_failure": 0.435, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.3163333333333332, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.435 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 9, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.329, |
| 0.36275 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.185, |
| 0.236 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.072, |
| 0.108 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.4186666666666667, |
| 0.46800000000000014 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.36150000000000015, |
| 0.38900000000000007 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.3389999999999997, |
| 0.3706666666666658 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.217, |
| 0.271 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.404, |
| 0.466 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.2896666666666667, |
| 0.3426666666666666 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.404, |
| 0.466 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 1036, |
| "invalid": 1, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 1035, |
| "valid": 3999, |
| "groups_correct": 273, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 192, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 2015, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 171, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 171, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 171, |
| "invalid": 1, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 170, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 169, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 169, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 525, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 525, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.259, |
| "group_success": 0.273, |
| "joint_success": 0.192, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.6716666666666666, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.3476666666666669, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.28900000000000053, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.312, |
| "missing_failure": 0.525, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.17033333333333345, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.525 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 9, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [ |
| "cross-03762" |
| ], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.24525, |
| 0.27275 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.246, |
| 0.301 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.168, |
| 0.217 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.6506666666666662, |
| 0.6923333333333324 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.3316666666666669, |
| 0.3635000000000001 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.274000000000001, |
| 0.30366666666666686 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.284, |
| 0.341 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.494, |
| 0.556 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.15300000000000008, |
| 0.18800000000000008 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.494, |
| 0.556 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 1385, |
| "invalid": 1, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 1384, |
| "valid": 3999, |
| "groups_correct": 189, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 54, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 1146, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 293, |
| "invalid": 1, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 292, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 297, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 297, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 301, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 301, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 494, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 494, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.34625, |
| "group_success": 0.189, |
| "joint_success": 0.054, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.38199999999999995, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.39550000000000035, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.36133333333333306, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.223, |
| "missing_failure": 0.494, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.2969999999999999, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.494 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 9, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [ |
| "cross-04886" |
| ], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.3295, |
| 0.363 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.165, |
| 0.214 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.041, |
| 0.068 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.35966666666666647, |
| 0.4046666666666662 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.3816666666666667, |
| 0.40933333333333344 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.3456666666666665, |
| 0.3766666666666664 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.197, |
| 0.249 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.463, |
| 0.525 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.2710000000000001, |
| 0.32333333333333314 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.463, |
| 0.525 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "glm": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 797, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 797, |
| "valid": 4000, |
| "groups_correct": 205, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 170, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 2488, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 0, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 0, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 0, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 0, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 2, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 2, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 795, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 795, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.19925, |
| "group_success": 0.205, |
| "joint_success": 0.17, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.8293333333333327, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.39783333333333337, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.2650000000000024, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.205, |
| "missing_failure": 0.795, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.0006666666666666666, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.795 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 9, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.193, |
| 0.2055 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.18, |
| 0.23 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.147, |
| 0.194 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.8119999999999998, |
| 0.845999999999999 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.3853333333333333, |
| 0.4101666666666667 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.25666666666666954, |
| 0.27333333333333526 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.18, |
| 0.23 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.77, |
| 0.82 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.0, |
| 0.0016666666666666666 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.77, |
| 0.82 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "molmo2-8b": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 1124, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 1124, |
| "valid": 4000, |
| "groups_correct": 216, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 118, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 1556, |
| "answerable_views": 3000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 192, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 192, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 193, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 193, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_CHANGED": { |
| "failures": 234, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 234, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 505, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 505, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.281, |
| "group_success": 0.216, |
| "joint_success": 0.118, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.5186666666666667, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.3556666666666665, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.29666666666666713, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.316, |
| "missing_failure": 0.505, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.20633333333333337, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.505 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 9, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.2675, |
| 0.29475 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.191, |
| 0.242 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.098, |
| 0.138 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.49566666666666664, |
| 0.5423333333333334 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.34166666666666673, |
| 0.36950416666666724 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.28133333333333416, |
| 0.31199999999999967 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.287, |
| 0.345 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.474, |
| 0.537 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.18600000000000005, |
| 0.22766666666666663 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.474, |
| 0.537 |
| ] |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "program_steps": { |
| "3": 3, |
| "4": 26, |
| "5": 80, |
| "6": 99, |
| "7": 112, |
| "8": 145, |
| "9": 163, |
| "10": 106, |
| "11": 36, |
| "12": 29, |
| "13": 23, |
| "14": 38, |
| "15": 48, |
| "16": 30, |
| "17": 22, |
| "18": 15, |
| "19": 11, |
| "20": 6, |
| "21": 6, |
| "22": 1, |
| "23": 1 |
| }, |
| "program_steps_note": "Stored dependency_depth is len(program steps), not tree depth", |
| "answer_types": { |
| "integer": 265, |
| "short_text": 408, |
| "boolean": 327 |
| }, |
| "paired_contrasts": { |
| "qwen38-flash-next__gemma4-31b-it": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -19.625, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -21.5, |
| -17.725 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 24.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 21.2, |
| 27.6 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 34.599999999999994, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 31.499999999999993, |
| 37.8 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 47.599999999999994, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 44.9333333333332, |
| 50.19999999999993 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -11.616666666666665, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -13.266666666666687, |
| -9.933333333333326 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -16.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -18.49999999999989, |
| -14.866666666666456 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 23.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 19.7, |
| 26.400000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.3999999999999995, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.1999999999999955, |
| 7.500000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -27.633333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -30.33333333333333, |
| -24.900000000000006 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.3999999999999995, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.1999999999999955, |
| 7.500000000000001 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__qwen": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "qwen", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -10.925, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -12.375000000000004, |
| -9.425 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 18.099999999999998, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 14.800000000000002, |
| 21.3 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 24.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 21.2, |
| 27.500000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 24.733333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 22.56666666666667, |
| 26.899999999999878 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -8.816666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -10.46666666666671, |
| -7.150000000000039 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -10.100000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -11.700000000000019, |
| -8.499999999999922 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 16.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 12.9, |
| 19.5 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -7.800000000000002, |
| -1.4000000000000012 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -13.03333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -14.900000000000013, |
| -11.133333333333335 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -7.800000000000002, |
| -1.4000000000000012 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -19.650000000000002, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -21.500000000000004, |
| -17.8 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 26.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 23.2, |
| 29.9 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 38.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 35.0, |
| 41.2 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 53.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 51.166666666666586, |
| 56.166666666666586 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -13.600000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -15.349999999999984, |
| -11.916666666666675 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -17.333333333333332, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -19.166666666666494, |
| -15.533333333333147 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 25.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 21.7, |
| 28.602499999999964 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.000000000000004, |
| 1.8024999999999651 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -25.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -28.366666666666667, |
| -23.03333333333333 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.000000000000004, |
| 1.8024999999999651 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__glm": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.95, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.85, |
| -4.050000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 24.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 22.0, |
| 27.9 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 26.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 23.6, |
| 29.500000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 8.966666666666669, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 7.1666666666667105, |
| 10.800833333333404 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -13.833333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -15.35, |
| -12.36666666666667 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -7.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.8341666666669, |
| -6.566666666666862 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 26.900000000000002, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 23.900000000000002, |
| 29.902499999999968 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -31.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -34.7, |
| -28.6 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.933333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.0333333333333328, |
| 4.9 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -31.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -34.7, |
| -28.6 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -13.125, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -14.649999999999999, |
| -11.650000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 23.799999999999997, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 20.7, |
| 26.900000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 31.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 28.7, |
| 34.800000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 40.03333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 37.43333333333323, |
| 42.49999999999989 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -9.616666666666665, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -11.400000000000032, |
| -7.916666666666678 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -10.866666666666665, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -12.59999999999991, |
| -9.166666666666643 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 15.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 12.2, |
| 19.5 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.800000000000001, |
| 1.3999999999999957 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -16.63333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -19.0, |
| -14.333333333333329 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.800000000000001, |
| 1.3999999999999957 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__qwen": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "qwen", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 8.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 6.8750000000000036, |
| 10.524999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -6.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -9.3, |
| -3.4000000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -10.299999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -12.8, |
| -7.700000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -22.866666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -25.367500000000057, |
| -20.266666666666595 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.8000000000000003, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.133333333333275, |
| 4.499999999999976 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.6000000000000005, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.733333333333222, |
| 8.466666666666544 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -6.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -10.100000000000001, |
| -3.799999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -9.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -12.2, |
| -5.8999999999999995 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 14.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 12.033333333333292, |
| 17.10000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -9.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -12.2, |
| -5.8999999999999995 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.025, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.6249999999999987, |
| 1.5749999999999986 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.5000000000000004, |
| 4.700000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.5000000000000004, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.8000000000000003, |
| 5.299999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.033333333333323, |
| 8.16666666666671 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.9833333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.4000000000000203, |
| -0.566666666666676 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.6333333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.23333333333326, |
| 0.9666666666666823 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.8000000000000007, |
| 4.799999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.8999999999999995, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.900000000000002, |
| -2.9999999999999973 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.9333333333333327, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.43333333333332447, |
| 4.266666666666696 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.8999999999999995, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.900000000000002, |
| -2.9999999999999973 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__glm": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 14.674999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 12.924374999999998, |
| 16.375 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.300000000000002, |
| 3.4000000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -8.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -10.7, |
| -5.499999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -38.63333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -41.39999999999986, |
| -35.83333333333329 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.2166666666666677, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.7333333333333107, |
| -0.749999999999978 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 9.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 7.333333333333064, |
| 10.633333333333066 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.9000000000000008, |
| 6.7 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -36.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -39.10000000000001, |
| -33.0 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 31.56666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 28.90000000000002, |
| 34.19999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -36.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -39.10000000000001, |
| -33.0 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.400000000000004, |
| 8.550000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.7000000000000006, |
| 2.4999999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.9000000000000004, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.2, |
| -0.5000000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -7.566666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -10.700000000000076, |
| -4.399999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.0000000000000004, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.28333333333333544, |
| 3.7666666666666404 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.833333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.7333333333333325, |
| 7.899999999999846 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -7.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -10.8, |
| -3.799999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -7.000000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -11.099999999999998, |
| -2.9999999999999973 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 10.999999999999998, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 7.633333333333342, |
| 14.29999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -7.000000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -11.099999999999998, |
| -2.9999999999999973 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen__gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "left": "qwen", |
| "right": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -8.725, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -10.599999999999998, |
| -6.84937500000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 8.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 5.3999999999999995, |
| 11.399999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 13.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 11.300000000000002, |
| 16.3 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 28.96666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 26.43333333333336, |
| 31.499999999999943 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.783333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.483333333333313, |
| -3.0833333333333437 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -7.233333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -9.166666666666496, |
| -5.2999999999999385 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 8.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 5.699999999999999, |
| 12.100000000000003 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.10000000000000009, |
| 6.3 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -12.666666666666668, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -15.366666666666637, |
| -9.966666666666665 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.10000000000000009, |
| 6.3 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen__glm": { |
| "left": "qwen", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.975, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.624999999999998, |
| 7.324999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.800000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.900000000000001, |
| 9.700000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.1999999999999997, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.5000000000000004, |
| 4.800000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -15.766666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -17.866666666666664, |
| -13.666666666666638 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.0166666666666675, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.567083333333358, |
| -3.5166666666666457 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.9333333333331472, |
| 3.8333333333331336 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 10.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 7.700000000000001, |
| 13.702499999999969 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -27.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -30.000000000000004, |
| -24.099999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 16.966666666666665, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 15.23333333333334, |
| 18.733333333333334 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -27.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -30.000000000000004, |
| -24.099999999999998 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "qwen", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.1999999999999997, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.900625000000003, |
| -0.4750000000000032 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.5999999999999996, |
| 8.799999999999997 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 7.3999999999999995, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.899999999999999, |
| 9.899999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 15.299999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 12.63333333333325, |
| 17.933333333333422 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.8000000000000002, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.5833333333333433, |
| 0.9333333333333472 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.7666666666666665, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.666666666666584, |
| 1.133333333333342 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.9000000000000035, |
| 3.1000000000000028 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.9000000000000017, |
| 5.900000000000006 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -3.6000000000000005, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.200000000000003, |
| -0.999166666666656 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.9000000000000017, |
| 5.900000000000006 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-26b-a4b-it__glm": { |
| "left": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 14.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 12.949999999999998, |
| 16.474999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.6, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.499999999999998, |
| 1.3000000000000012 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -11.600000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -14.099999999999998, |
| -9.1 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -44.733333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -47.299999999999905, |
| -42.133333333333255 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.23333333333333384, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.7500000000000129, |
| 1.2666666666666662 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 9.633333333333335, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 7.966666666666372, |
| 11.299999999999672 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.7999999999999998, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.1999999999999984, |
| 4.799999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -30.099999999999998, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -33.102500000000006, |
| -27.1 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 29.63333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 27.033333333333353, |
| 32.23333333333334 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -30.099999999999998, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -33.102500000000006, |
| -27.1 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-26b-a4b-it__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.525, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.450000000000004, |
| 8.575 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.699999999999999, |
| 0.30000000000000027 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -6.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.6, |
| -4.2 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -13.666666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -16.666666666666746, |
| -10.73333333333334 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.983333333333334, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.3333333333333313, |
| 5.633333333333329 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.466666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.4666666666666135, |
| 8.499999999999863 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -9.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -12.600000000000003, |
| -6.0 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.0999999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.700000000000005, |
| 2.400000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 9.066666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 5.8999999999999995, |
| 12.199999999999973 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.0999999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.700000000000005, |
| 2.400000000000002 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "glm__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "glm", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -8.175, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -9.55, |
| -6.825 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.0999999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.7000000000000006, |
| 1.3999999999999986 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.8999999999999986, |
| 7.5 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 31.066666666666663, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 28.533333333333232, |
| 33.533333333333246 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.216666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.8500000000000134, |
| 5.60000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -3.166666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.733333333333039, |
| -1.63333333333317 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -11.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -14.100000000000001, |
| -8.2 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 28.999999999999996, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 25.900000000000002, |
| 32.10000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -20.56666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -22.699999999999992, |
| -18.533333333333342 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 28.999999999999996, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 25.900000000000002, |
| 32.10000000000001 |
| ] |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "analytic_baselines": { |
| "always_answerable_failure": 0.25, |
| "always_unanswerable_failure": 0.75, |
| "constant_decision_group_success": 0, |
| "constant_decision_balanced_failure": 0.5 |
| } |
| }, |
| "gqa": { |
| "groups": 1000, |
| "views": 3000, |
| "states": [ |
| "FULL", |
| "A_SAME", |
| "U_MISSING" |
| ], |
| "models": { |
| "qwen38-flash-next": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 770, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 770, |
| "valid": 3000, |
| "groups_correct": 399, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 337, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 1397, |
| "answerable_views": 2000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 154, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 154, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 178, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 178, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 438, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 438, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.2566666666666681, |
| "group_success": 0.399, |
| "joint_success": 0.337, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.6985, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.302, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.2566666666666681, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.399, |
| "missing_failure": 0.438, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.166, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.438 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 8, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.24133333333333434, |
| 0.2720000000000005 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.369, |
| 0.429 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.307, |
| 0.367 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.671, |
| 0.7255 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.28575, |
| 0.318 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.24133333333333434, |
| 0.2720000000000005 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.369, |
| 0.429 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.407975, |
| 0.469 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.1445, |
| 0.188 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.407975, |
| 0.469 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 818, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 818, |
| "valid": 3000, |
| "groups_correct": 372, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 289, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 1302, |
| "answerable_views": 2000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 166, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 166, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 189, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 189, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 463, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 463, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.2726666666666674, |
| "group_success": 0.372, |
| "joint_success": 0.289, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.651, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.32025, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.2726666666666674, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.372, |
| "missing_failure": 0.463, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.1775, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.463 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 8, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.2573333333333344, |
| 0.2883333333333336 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.342, |
| 0.402 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.261, |
| 0.317 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.6235, |
| 0.6795 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.30425, |
| 0.3365 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.2573333333333344, |
| 0.2883333333333336 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.342, |
| 0.402 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.433, |
| 0.493 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.156, |
| 0.2 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.433, |
| 0.493 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 843, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 843, |
| "valid": 3000, |
| "groups_correct": 359, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 288, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 1295, |
| "answerable_views": 2000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 181, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 181, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 229, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 229, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 433, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 433, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.28100000000000064, |
| "group_success": 0.359, |
| "joint_success": 0.288, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.6475, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.319, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.28100000000000064, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.359, |
| "missing_failure": 0.433, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.205, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.433 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 8, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.265333333333334, |
| 0.29633333333333356 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.33, |
| 0.39 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.26, |
| 0.317 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.6205, |
| 0.674 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.3025, |
| 0.335 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.265333333333334, |
| 0.29633333333333356 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.33, |
| 0.39 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.402, |
| 0.464 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.1825, |
| 0.2275 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.402, |
| 0.464 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 832, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 832, |
| "valid": 3000, |
| "groups_correct": 392, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 300, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 1169, |
| "answerable_views": 2000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 213, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 213, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 237, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 237, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 382, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 382, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.277333333333334, |
| "group_success": 0.392, |
| "joint_success": 0.3, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.5845, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.3035, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.277333333333334, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.392, |
| "missing_failure": 0.382, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.225, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.382 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 8, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.26066666666666755, |
| 0.2940000000000002 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.361, |
| 0.423 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.272, |
| 0.329 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.5555, |
| 0.614 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.287, |
| 0.31975 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.26066666666666755, |
| 0.2940000000000002 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.361, |
| 0.423 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.352, |
| 0.412 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.2005, |
| 0.25 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.352, |
| 0.412 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "glm": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 741, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 741, |
| "valid": 3000, |
| "groups_correct": 305, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 245, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 1553, |
| "answerable_views": 2000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 38, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 38, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 62, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 62, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 641, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 641, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.24700000000000213, |
| "group_success": 0.305, |
| "joint_success": 0.245, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.7765, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.3455, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.24700000000000213, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.305, |
| "missing_failure": 0.641, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.05, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.641 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 8, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.2360000000000017, |
| 0.2583333333333352 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.277, |
| 0.334 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.219, |
| 0.272 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.752, |
| 0.8 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.33075, |
| 0.35975 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.2360000000000017, |
| 0.2583333333333352 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.277, |
| 0.334 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.611, |
| 0.67 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.038, |
| 0.0625 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.611, |
| 0.67 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "molmo2-8b": { |
| "counts": { |
| "failures": 907, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 907, |
| "valid": 3000, |
| "groups_correct": 267, |
| "joint_groups_correct": 223, |
| "strict_answers_correct": 1379, |
| "answerable_views": 2000, |
| "unanswerable_views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "states": { |
| "FULL": { |
| "failures": 159, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 159, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "A_SAME": { |
| "failures": 171, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 171, |
| "views": 1000 |
| }, |
| "U_MISSING": { |
| "failures": 577, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "valid_decision_errors": 577, |
| "views": 1000 |
| } |
| }, |
| "metrics": { |
| "failure": 0.3023333333333335, |
| "group_success": 0.267, |
| "joint_success": 0.223, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": 0.6895, |
| "balanced_failure": 0.371, |
| "common_state_failure": 0.3023333333333335, |
| "common_state_group_success": 0.267, |
| "missing_failure": 0.577, |
| "answerable_failure": 0.165, |
| "unanswerable_failure": 0.577 |
| }, |
| "saved_aggregate_checks": 8, |
| "invalid_item_ids": [], |
| "intervals_95": { |
| "failure": [ |
| 0.2880000000000006, |
| 0.316666666666666 |
| ], |
| "group_success": [ |
| 0.24, |
| 0.295 |
| ], |
| "joint_success": [ |
| 0.197, |
| 0.25 |
| ], |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": [ |
| 0.661, |
| 0.7175 |
| ], |
| "balanced_failure": [ |
| 0.356, |
| 0.3855 |
| ], |
| "common_state_failure": [ |
| 0.2880000000000006, |
| 0.316666666666666 |
| ], |
| "common_state_group_success": [ |
| 0.24, |
| 0.295 |
| ], |
| "missing_failure": [ |
| 0.545, |
| 0.607 |
| ], |
| "answerable_failure": [ |
| 0.143, |
| 0.1885 |
| ], |
| "unanswerable_failure": [ |
| 0.545, |
| 0.607 |
| ] |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "location_sensitivity": { |
| "selection": "FULL canonical target in {left, right, top, bottom}; all sibling states retained", |
| "location_groups": 376, |
| "other_groups": 624, |
| "location_group_ids": [ |
| "000b2fa129f70ee5f717372655c1b3406bfb44562b135a4a7ba32feffbaca496", |
| "00d99ec81eb315c6e8fbb4b43bcaa772c11fb47c2c5c430706501636cd0bf18b", |
| "0110e482cfaa927201ef0897c78425b6a1b0debdecfef22192fe12ffa132316a", |
| "01244b56d7575b39368c121080be64a12799bb6d2b58b3bc886de37a6e566dde", |
| "0175097a79a0df2c02e844a73b8c0acad787c3c71010a5dc126353c95be14b80", |
| "01db33998788a9a7ba222d47f28d773967bf08ef4f7ae276067e13e45f2a3258", |
| "020a29514c9f302f0df408b0907c8f963028680f50e88bedc95a835cab5e1c44", |
| "021d92b27cbc6da525310dd20b626828ed03bfbc777408f54124d0323ece14b1", |
| "031128ef5cc9250343227a7911c34ebaa63da6fed2efd560d23a6765720aaf1e", |
| "039cf8fad48b1a77e799e4c1c68dbb833ff3e159ce79f99dc7c39c192f905197", |
| "04525452af04ee68c3a274d379bfc9f354649e53356d89c57be4ab0a5bf6fd82", |
| "045f4a1b7b7baad882f1e8dd319d40d1f9a8e6fd84dd17660b32eb783b08cfcd", |
| "0480c575ce04ef8ef70d8a760f08b6e4a9dbac80e92d703923aa7de7c9c2bfab", |
| "04b210578d0c802f4997c9815b0f6cbc626e235330edd05a3459b5fe83482b2b", |
| "04bf1e2154ecdf05ff2c7fb42c9b34d19f528065fcd5df603b2076f15a393851", |
| "054bbb3472bc848428caf88bd158a8d36528e65192c5088030d91ed4135c259a", |
| "05516d65424d954a8e6d18f63d0e6a4bf7670a87ca03a9c38d2b6bbbd9eea4cd", |
| "064ad36f57c51ea9d929f95dec52d69ccb04bf634d411b2dfecfe8a8141c07ed", |
| "0729e5fa5666b5c166c88f451e3da1921070ddf767118037c318d450ded5c7a8", |
| "077887a349943b915e1d2e5771ca399b7d8986613d440781a4a8e8511ba59b69", |
| "07dbaccbbc9ff2dda12c2fd5e8738eef5c30dfc57cd0abd77b925c1607970826", |
| "09deab5172e7f1ff4e1241b6291911cf1fb63f913d94da141a169c2590002c95", |
| "0a6f29706d180118cb0904787a34a0e28df0c8ed070c29d59095b60207f9ee1a", |
| "0aeb744c9aeddc1c90c094a60618b7b583c9ff7951af16af5da5c9b6d80ce9d2", |
| "0aefcdbeb3865579ea3114c29cc9464c272a6c85fe6949f5deb518ad2c2b7fbe", |
| "0bfa70d8f6ed9b35c416a9383fa5bf62ac20964bc7bb9c4823305066a4f03fb6", |
| "0d00f7e600b01a346d5d95834d3228f56a5304720b20c5f3692b64501166bd55", |
| "0f47b7c80e84c34e033a3b9d7e86d23aae5a19a4bf7b4eee1ef5befe7ddb8a06", |
| "103154b5cf2a48430f4a96364c0d8495af12231971e211d69c401bc36a6feec3", |
| "1059a5d61837616264597020f7226808a3bc62e48b61b54abe1d6d1be1027ea0", |
| "10987f0e261ece25a65cfec81401cce8d6e3f07a855f2263c35d59acd05b2c71", |
| "116a198a5733453c3257e3a38fde68a4a3c40ed2401dc2c131258790c9148004", |
| "11826e78fc358ed37c0eefb6ec56547c47ec14cc12e985a7133be8fad73e3958", |
| "11b1059c2332e2610207befc702054251d0e2673d8ed885dc1b878955db17891", |
| "1292e956ce61defab94a3acc3d915354a2183187ad91b0a9b090112bd2f1e559", |
| "129cdb22e8ca7dd449875df98c03a8e24b2c643b982714101d0c30b266648743", |
| "12a9932793542ded4e527fdb309bb7e5354bc45129987e70746c7f3f73c91159", |
| "12ab0e6eea4982852d8fef522a5bffa66baf95d289a388d35c83b429cf2383f4", |
| "144780959fb56dfd154f787ae28561107a8e53357d3978751cc584404005124c", |
| "150e52ef17693e31a002b3c3ad2c9c4cfc6e72d6a6af397ea72ba979698575e1", |
| "151fc9e6f0a95c217e48755131d4cfafc718e4a2c5faaffd938d3508c000c9f1", |
| "151fe6ef910ba1210b8ec1034e94705ef0c46d9cc2a221ae114f5bb2fd29d0f5", |
| "1622b6d50d294712660944eaa3d933240d9881e60c3d02b79c8cbee1d41cc5ec", |
| "181241417a188c78b7377d2ba0d38fb71acb6478e3b833b0c67c4eaa2cc07b4d", |
| "1839e7e3b73fb020e676b08cfc7e4955f97aa1828399144ec2585e32d9928f47", |
| "18c2263230e97c2ecd08ad085c11e38ba81fd0f90ea231e9661449a667ce43f4", |
| "1924f9dd70d0646d25072b61f92eb69fd96d40764e9825adb359ee850e193091", |
| "1a96df11e18892c49d6f87e70108455756c680a8ce76b0c0e7159839af5eebad", |
| "1b400f9ff3b2ec3400f43d60e0e42a8fc7e7f1b285b50e9c59fca31539b4721b", |
| "1c41f8b232e220f17691019221dc19ef60700555013e13f6163b285467085edd", |
| "1c6cac8ac9abf8ab3213f332b37793ec13d8b14333429bf7bd6ae5e69aea862d", |
| "1dcac6dae21ef4855866df6ebff8ecbedf9a3eb8ef997d40befda21489a4c98c", |
| "1e3278e43a626a2e6379f3ae3be3c2e63b97f9846b522441e383879b3521d2e9", |
| "1f8df1ee5c3b8fa04f69a811f9dbd4c0c58b9a4a40c2f2aee1864c10938bcf7e", |
| "1fb7723783aba89e1bd984a6d62667f908a65901883e74d6e3fe5281a89cb647", |
| "1fd23ccacf9df6ee0fba3d1529edb9b365ad403fddcfb12c6b9feac4571a5c03", |
| "2079382b265ee8bda074b0934e9ac9877eb04244579483ddfabec19d4aabdabf", |
| "20fff1ca3a8ce6b5f46e4ae9b13a25d468e51f90312917e9718ea15bef72a157", |
| "2317446c8ee1cea82d6aedbe7dbc25751d3afd55b7a56bffedccc39145479a91", |
| "23fc4c59c6bb550d9b5e3f6bb8df235596b893a0a5a5066047c760a353bd937e", |
| "240e8a9210846beeac7709dab07d5a89851b895bf5658bd4f502ab511a43372d", |
| "2567b545c395392ca984ba023c77de645ba807298d4c8c3f82689587eaaaa7d5", |
| "25706ebe65f9d351d0dec4fbc85cf7ae3ba7d1e3adab85c9af7b9a36c6a1a822", |
| "275ea5bc9523fbf9db1c463b67fe435af8ca29133a1f32c8d02c201a84af0de0", |
| "28dc3653d4a14381777cfc5f55e2f0809a04bda060892b84fc061eef595b3997", |
| "2b32e834457713eacada06681c20809c6d35feb03384206edcfcc2227dbecb1e", |
| "2b5426c517fba66842fa0cdd4af86717010d549e51338e77656aabda5c18edcb", |
| "2bb6739e8d7be4f67c31c30b812b81bf702dc8d2d560b45d54bd82a190613ff9", |
| "2bc15614c36a57378f6797d6aa0aec56b6e20936b85a1247f5da6a7a1a842dd4", |
| "2ca62fd2754ea3ec0dfa112127a292844184dee81fd5ea710aae697de2201d0b", |
| "2cd651f443e4de7a9469dd0f4d3ca89555daac6739d368287ef9bbf10dc0a826", |
| "2cd9e797aa57f74225751307345a83479a7a29213f2038bbbdd042e417afffd5", |
| "2d24671355481f435a653d6bd62824eeeadc5bbe8eeeed2483a1ee817b62b869", |
| "2e5e2c8ef128b56e62cd4558e3b86e36986f89967f203ea8de6841f24735fc2d", |
| "2f6e20d57adea72f67a3c3d2f244932f28419d394afad7bc08d4aff98052fd18", |
| "2fb8af18837ffb72932cc18338ed509866c900a9b1d75223a24088ad56156bf7", |
| "306585cae4cd276a4417e4c31e6ec14bb045b625aac7f814a6a5657e25ea71d1", |
| "30e97770259b05192604d2dcd0ca9b910520ac72f1285446d91b86711312100b", |
| "314ef36a833c1db5c34df8144e1193b249d27f83be210714d264f6bd665e78d4", |
| "331cd9bef01d1014e61e9d18430f869df893bbcb3c48e9473b0b09e0ab2cd7ff", |
| "3393ec4ccbb34a04d5cd9b5466ff849325671c5f83f94a161ac95876a1989d02", |
| "34ab585fc03d525600503b8c30988da03e3a63fa7e08daa96dcb30ece2bfd47f", |
| "35b80bed34eca9707db4c2865802a3717503f8a951152dbb7d524fc58a42fba4", |
| "35d00aea25065c480213cd57775818616f906ffd3d4dcd9ffe992867598ff1cf", |
| "36b47981955ad37b424125d843657bf85afb20dfa4b290d2c5f534ef94e57178", |
| "37b0e31c3c2f704985589e53b7573f3108a7d890258e393575b9ca5e94a35fff", |
| "37c0aebb86f8e8106b092a54a13dd03c2925f1f24b68c2b6611900f3f63581b4", |
| "39727f644e2ed35a2c206ea8cf19027d394a6f9de960512c91a201e3090b3d71", |
| "39a1da40a210711cd36a30a8255f2cdb22bbdbc20b965eeb65da5a7b3da211a1", |
| "39c421b9d088097ec7073ab77e43684879345beeefdd5e8c62959c372604cd92", |
| "39d394bbd01b8a51dfa776739b84be08c3ee40c58b3d6e31a6ed1d87428af684", |
| "3a2cd379c14306bd81bc1b5f482073cfa8f389058a114d8db3881bbac82ac119", |
| "3a73dd34705a0306dc8525e4cda64ca9b6dfb3cf9c57a5f59a1bc47e0e9cdfbd", |
| "3b36ee19a93ff9aca1ff144eb7aed50634dcc6fa5169eed7f30e7bfb81c80692", |
| "3b84a3d445b15a242ed4a45da2b62b245ee879f12c04453be8fde0e1b0fdb2dd", |
| "3b885822f9e36ead49174196689556ef7c93ad4c384b39cf3e7be9d378ff2490", |
| "3c4484617c21e734351eab48435361846883cfeba3af36fa0c8b526816e4e201", |
| "3c6d89a36d03080810f31ab7ef9ddd6601c66578e79620fd4b9124d391a89e1d", |
| "3dd096d0e80398b6c702bfd2d561b828c71e2f8414f5d8217bedfd6af5b028de", |
| "3dd988411c49b3e879735dda8fd19a22c6f5be59ed76e2ed522786293dd248ae", |
| "3f10256ffaa99b1c7dac94451296990975c79bf6aa5b94f199b7f2e7dafd6782", |
| "3fd50dfa0c4c37513e72bd4c3e7ecb3a280045e23a0552f78b37cec4c71bcdbc", |
| "3ffd28dadb841e39f9b1476af0232d51d8cd8379213feae012e9624a7bf3332f", |
| "41ecdc6368a1f218fb492ec3cb289804849a6e1a6fed0ab28afe2be893be95a3", |
| "423ab85c0e796f7ec7eb7e2154fbcd9c3e7e08bf78c619d212e5da8c0409244a", |
| "4273ccfd24536d879cb28565af06f03e813ff98cf4b94bab9761a6b482efd47e", |
| "43fa83904a7e3e9518993f99ba8fa6c0ef159376ab4b556f96e3ff2ecf8e93a4", |
| "44f361f9bb99f91919aad379f5c6b96d477b7cf5aeecf18e71cd39d22aa915ca", |
| "459bc9dfbef7b5221d139b63417615dab205d297e94bac3dff91c3037d71a3ac", |
| "45f5ce82562afc4c847ef6eb32f32326f925fc0e8bc6f4f249edb5e5e5aad9a1", |
| "470c675b6f92aac438b217a08240298ff0f5098965d41f7d8753bee9854658e7", |
| "4883ccbb91134f357c0b6fbda97c81de83c62e60f364e45793221583980b0125", |
| "48a0c4948adcf08a6c6518edf29484aeee7e37f830ecd1c67b4533b65c40a787", |
| "48f8d05ff6ad3d7e31587bdb9f65f1d611580d1b5711e1d32777d49b78dde42d", |
| "493e9a1a33ee939aaef6e5e73d7233596da7a8140825513864a98f528fd0b8cc", |
| "4a04d17e26e60a9bdb0bc6b1039cf7b12b0a57393f6d3e5af81c3297132c104c", |
| "4a12b674e46d5b9f3b8449cc4d3d99ce8ea5921fac7d770aae1c4b1b9f193a93", |
| "4acd929c2922d835a5371f240ed7368695a36760624d5033cfac1e046dbca7a0", |
| "4bfde05945e07b89d37fa8c16dc143079cd2e8d41e6044f0a7862c6d765af31f", |
| "4c458bddbc6cd163e6a6619565e7ddab4c81e3bd45188b9e4c3b9e9ba35bcc82", |
| "4c554583660b2d48afd3c27cf2c004152db1cf7a0eef33e5812929e0d325cf25", |
| "4d673a7c702fcdfe6ca0ad53e0c0c7fce1f9fc3a472013dd207dbc8929e076f7", |
| "4d9a7566cdbc221e84ac3743e1d154e9bc9d765b5d0186c45ea7bdb74803bedf", |
| "4ded2ec948bee21bd741c862084b9b4a5669e2351a1ed864cb849122232b8cfb", |
| "4e37375e7d2c1cfc3ac3ff226fec1513680ec6e0f19cd31c4e8005f36a4a918a", |
| "4e58127fe89c1166ce01e98617e4755b65e3d1ab3abf95547d3c4b46238a8124", |
| "4e62d8703fd2fa0b269a6f3f3be12c7060756d90fb21a36754e6e4d491e33ecc", |
| "4ea03d01c309013fe3060c87e112553d7c4a77191872f6d97371f702718beb36", |
| "4f2219d17edf6ead693a5a83e6653944271c4befcf9da4df98402120bde1b0c3", |
| "4f87bf94ccc8721334fa995513aab9ea4288d2c9726116ba6779491d17a7eac3", |
| "4fea329aa14cacc74d4c35b4966a15ab86d368175ae35f917785ea45b88dc56f", |
| "5046d17a6b1ba44295f1a0c14dbb316c45bf4c5c58878ab954f8f7b4191e4deb", |
| "5109bf254096aa88cf32f1c2a31439f594ca744957d22d29d9df2d31f388671e", |
| "5121a00d2a2bbb4a7c495975a25b432b96220a5f8e03290206ca1bbedeb32ea7", |
| "537ec4d0ae026b7215f72708e03b4060326feb63a02249a6b9edfe6f6ef76fea", |
| "54a8ec4bf5a957fee75749b4e3ce46e35a3e2e310ff06f25d6edb51bc07c9c62", |
| "55c8ab649ee6d22d2cf47b5c9ec05475521f4080fb31f0e4710e3ca86c196367", |
| "55d8d338bae1b47ce8a9f40b371ecf273610849e34ce07c4e93616ab37ec87f4", |
| "56432f2be965689ed9ce57dbf9e8421e3ee9b0c7ff67303e60d6a3fd9348425a", |
| "56a9b71d824c0a39b33f01e17d23f31aa30d15727a0a011cbaa01b398a6b2365", |
| "56e9c22db32c080acc6d7a69a4fd82ad96d56ea58a7a5b4fdfbbee8e90ad480d", |
| "580245732dee78b864462a184997d81a0a7c9fba0bbf13394df17a9872326a03", |
| "5a4197a8d4c1f493f443179d9409a80c7a87b6d0f71fc37ee8c07f2a8587c6ab", |
| "5a4fbce5435406e72430b3b44fbfcea23501f54797bfb2d382d7305d2042c49d", |
| "5a77ae121080a48ada579d13147c97e14a36d5c2fef0d35c803b478b4e0a541b", |
| "5b4b4f0dbc9b73fa20d96ec10f963839b74d3a97a378235351c1235f0146d126", |
| "5d3e3f7baac6282a3abc17c189a7f7a3dd3292f35fea5cfaef7d387c40cac6af", |
| "5f1ad362caf4943e1623edd9f0235373760860e2ab93984da4cda04fb364a133", |
| "5f3d88d54fd1373dab2bdf06aaaffdaa75f7ce2791ebcc58221849c95db459bf", |
| "5f4120a568b893703019df381b8c302d2b1e89646143ebd8cb09da30764daf6f", |
| "5f77b2f638000d4ad4cff93357c91fedee9cca22e32bbe223265ff5f86056950", |
| "5fb75aa1620c427a6187c174094e3b3a88ade9336df83ea73c5d5bbdbbe3f731", |
| "6039a5dde244c7dc0fe66de5376510456355efd9a238f9bd04aff46979f5d823", |
| "618434f701d4960a4bab413d7dec048f34968fa5968116e58c5394cbed89285d", |
| "62281f84eb55552ae6ca19a2abaa45bef722f111b037ae0fd1752942ecdecbb6", |
| "641c566efa8a04555bc42ad6776665b940887b4f89cd60a57317636b3558f1ce", |
| "647ecd06d57b6e9b7cc0197b500d42d90fe66b9c23344f97c0aeaf7c0936cc8e", |
| "65204647c920eb1260928184783221789cbabc0880addf7d8791695db79b266f", |
| "65658495157652c8f8118da01ab0c81bcb58e3c05592c37125e81575c151d68c", |
| "6568fc7016ef021d520e61f65111fb584794eca88b98143249085abe1422ab05", |
| "657612e278f6e1290ccc2a3e5c0e4a91a55ff0c04099405408fa42b0a69564cd", |
| "6603202da3c8418dfc4311d8f3801421b69156cd270374299488e536dcab903a", |
| "67d450bf8ccc044e71745b74101f781faff266992f95f509077eb67ed0457837", |
| "687d662379c592bd8b1c7dc58edb1626b30668ee542512f1cec9e48ef8815407", |
| "69cc79a439844761d3d1d81284fef6e4caf1e3cac032dcc7cba3c536ffca480a", |
| "6b35de8a0c49d30724bbdba1c84ff03c3bd5cbc030e8635f1208fa8f4ed66797", |
| "6b4886977b30d25f3420c73b17ad04dffe862d97f9652873e4b4487ba5f719b2", |
| "6d0a625b0c072870638d5ba1fbe82d2d7fc49d6bbc73c358882988e3efb156b3", |
| "6dacadc2c3c80dfcc893aca653c70b3bfe2f69dc4108349131c3addfdc8bfa3e", |
| "6dd2ffd788a0becb15b962bbd5a1fcc785e88e0c0c771eab4852d3a975504cf3", |
| "6e913128da055174562a0c1d2fd0e8779bc8c9e901ae606343adfb1e82dd1ba4", |
| "6ea079fd6cec3b0696357def144fa817e2fd018ae4b662d0d6b6b3a452e1534b", |
| "7187bf321e30016175695a6f0c87a4e19b4e7d4e35f234e0fe5eb539b1031a6b", |
| "71c298a8e16feca6861c048d88c78e8a89fda3a7a19f39e48cdb865cb61741d7", |
| "720667e61455ee01e81d92209fbe687e99839ced2987dddb8afdfc5caee5b67c", |
| "72426e2f851d81d07d52b4fa550506f490303b3f78b7a1a3e54fe7d2bcb4bb8c", |
| "72d21b2e93b22ad3c436873f313132d7d7c08385e8f2df0d4328d98d5ae1fae3", |
| "744b6dc2a6ab132c283ea67ca2dcefd78bb36bef61729e17bc1a7083a93e61fc", |
| "74a62649694adad71027de4b66fc6de26ae472292a12ecbcb34341d602d73917", |
| "74d3b5d744984a63a926b7a2227689e1a56bb77eb17e9f50e82cd2058584321f", |
| "750d11458c7774e494baef9d369a5796df2d48e9db7fb9d7a77ef18dd30b09ae", |
| "7619f007a4d4efc279eb732c5350c0069ed2b36db070e8e7171415c2048d7257", |
| "7a4755505b9f462f59fee27b68ec8e4ae846302747286e13bcae4632fb92b859", |
| "7d797421dbca9beed9213ed68dca6f160abe607fd86139bb63c5e388393600fe", |
| "7e0a595950b4330d2631fe59acc93ca20873414a10d5374240beb122bf99baba", |
| "80bed26d601384f9de6c7f6a1ac71e45a457977146876b1f8963004904c555ef", |
| "80c2e6b8c231ee3e2ec4f74c833c5bf73bcba88f63091a8d3799dd6c79685498", |
| "80e336bb29f5d4b93f1b80b5d336946012ac5044accb79b28879ea9dfedbcf3d", |
| "8134d663671c3005a91ba136fa1ae2989a32729d38fd9437d22ce48fbbcaf592", |
| "815f09034b7ccff9b1a49526197fb72d12129c4a43729a2eba19b5bdde7748e6", |
| "828b13ff36db6b99d793fcc9c607ad4e8e3e6cd514112f7eea034e4bcd2f2607", |
| "83641e88e02fdafcc5243d7372fb6b851231d3f4fe83740ea0f7351b48f345cc", |
| "837c0cab4b75706f39015e255012d592886a9c822131f62b95d4f7dd50ccad21", |
| "8498695cf20c1736433fbb16edd86e71da5cb56df4304d3f18101f88ae8c26df", |
| "8500009c8a21103907966c1608381d12b853f212361cefd36cf88ad06206e1ad", |
| "8560365c738cc31c5450570c7dd29aefe9f34ec5670fb0de88ff4af923256c8f", |
| "85e5c4f379809eaba5469d8883164c6691d8a293c88d8082bf9428c7990cd111", |
| "890f8563cd1862852800a8e88ff45a69161ff295881b068f7d7fc9cf6600a3ad", |
| "8a644ed6bd6ddcbad33014d8a202ca83d1ea17208efc4e18d6e64746006d7292", |
| "8b123cf63e3d877777635961d3f6e7a16df557fb22b40d035527b61830ca122a", |
| "8b8aca2efffcf5f39e96fc7da74c595fc2f80a7cc67585b6b41ca62c6cb97516", |
| "8b9f41ccfde4b2c6a5752b45e7a654a18f7e16832cee0d0de7e5c53490c796dd", |
| "8bb91e18e81723452b2879eafe37432c1958a68cfb80eb869983b7531f9afb3a", |
| "8bde1e1e4a93cfbf526415cb4b38b67fcffbd037b0dce412acf6aa29c73e61eb", |
| "8bff60130119b3a250990e5a3f366a8a30217eed4a3313fc37008a066dbe8cfd", |
| "8c75a7be6048b6d432937a217cd618ddabd6275f824e686dff817ac5c6a3582c", |
| "8cef6acafed22604fe5d18c335079a72d54d3887f169eb0756527a7fcbfc2791", |
| "8ecb5018966593811e71fb7da5a797389a2ec5615e58b53b67ba26c246d233c1", |
| "8ede6bab8f5ef09e3cdaaacecf4a801d79fa0d39281e9470711d983d7cd21a12", |
| "8f161e7ebfdc7d040d4aeae01e6feb6799d310bde1f97333a5bd4e2c1a9bb336", |
| "9095bef846f8a3c83ad3729b1d85614027d80abbf6e93cf4252bc3e4d89c367e", |
| "90b8448f0ed50cf74b9b4bc41ce41dd480619196a51601acf4fead02db3d1a80", |
| "922f500103ec9ac125e51de5039565679f4aca64d15bdc26ab2417515c220950", |
| "92491e2e509c0cec50f7ceb3e4a883ee769be9c0ad92c5cac045fca437121264", |
| "924abc456aebe43b4c333a5c03944a7311ee60a57cc21511cad73211e14ee047", |
| "926cec9cf994d90274581f25e8fecf1899a11588bc9a92399d64680044ee055f", |
| "927fadc51f5f878a60475b761f5c6ad49926491bbb42624a8b4fe1ef767826f5", |
| "93cfe77cd62706a1546d945d70b5094597a57b49c6c7b3003428a40759b773e6", |
| "94b7b56f07e3ec695c1244bcd452bb49ce117bdb0289413848b433d0795918d7", |
| "9541c0749d461df991ba88876f76c7889e57124c31572de207c4988744c52c1d", |
| "9693cdd96f3947f62f4135062f7cb1209aebb039fd53835c0726f27798c215b5", |
| "97286cb6b1071d748e0723352316391c99f2a66d3544b3c500d3ee9dd2118c4d", |
| "976478c0b1ba7b6727db03c2b9ed69ea1fafdf139fc15df34825cc90ce6c0211", |
| "978bf8b42a0cc2fb5ef3d2b30a20ceefb3d9e4a3e5aaf79ff55015841385d8a0", |
| "97d98c0d0e7dc286738bccf0c3f8f1883044603116e4473ad52def26e910fbd7", |
| "9910afde38f7d7780f3a5f6211f62d4755178dbb21fd77043c3a8ff62430a173", |
| "9a10b6438cd320c9e3ec73ba6e63ba6ebc2f37e6b981c9f74b717e2810ca7eec", |
| "9a6078210451062446e20b2180b8e5e54aed85318254c782ea56513d7c542c90", |
| "9bf95181bd61ccf291de585312d30a6f60fb09867b167e6ad28a42cb41c55e98", |
| "9d215b95da6c2ddd75d5eb3bbbe1c00b47b7611c04db433c3061e68e24bd9802", |
| "9f2714fc784b9e0e657f4185d1844dfdbbb7a9cfa01cb1ddafcce6d78e6b964c", |
| "9f69e4290bc604ea7718268f81a57d789599ad5ae49820ee6b1d9ca657395f36", |
| "9f90e6899caec96726ea670d3332952228ddc08db58c1b3f015f79c72fca7db3", |
| "9fbd8bead02517cf27d7cb805260c22f4c097c10184e710f5dc0af180875ba96", |
| "9ff1c6536fdd14f38ca00ab8ae9b634e42ba84ec620db0632b245f8887b44b46", |
| "a20ca4f5155695c3a4cf6db2af136cad2b87002ac26dba8ab833b8e454580c1e", |
| "a24b65792b9429bbf66e7312549f0c25de875dc730c74d61e782dbca6233aa3f", |
| "a2d6e6191c7aef8d621659de7fdaf1be4bf1f82271c4d22d635e0228b2550f17", |
| "a33bc39a2c5a060d65cb05d602af09988b5a6e56c3c2c33a9a91c307fc4dc604", |
| "a593e564d5297919affd09d16e2afb7a1db370e06373446ed436582e8a3aeae8", |
| "a6528a6cc899ab6336b435cc7a5a3e058f4571b7eb63a0ae36dfe91de3f53b2a", |
| "a6d069e333579ba9a9cfc438aea514b4c5edb4324310e5351a11dcacc1990822", |
| "a70a8d2c9371a62c314f6569fa233a85ad957eb02867d6e6483cde21126ef209", |
| "a755a5e2b769460311ef8b7c0f4179697c2ea5e1e9c6ddb953ce20e749b376f6", |
| "a77288b7b7e30d3214133dbfc1dce0578d7897e650cdf1dbb0528ace51ec3365", |
| "a7b7810cd6a2da6376cc89ea826a6f1e03f8049cd0b4a37cc57a4d4f3e49a35a", |
| "a7cb2da5b592cd1fc64bd8dc24a9e25bd7ccb7003a1225c65850aaaeb73471bd", |
| "a8e13f52c31e8a2277344f94c98057cc3da821ed8204c60fbdcce779b6e6e421", |
| "a93d899571500c1f4a4f3af5fa24383f0d9b7ecdcb386abad068769b01eb2e84", |
| "a94d34fa427348bdd9ed3daa54399d0feef68da18a46797b5fcbc41eb18d5713", |
| "ac0d9c911450cbd33d984e3b6d0764a7ab6727740ffbf508b6bd4daf5fb5e095", |
| "ad4266693e5087e4fe0d3304d4dddf12a4d7ec5de4c2b16239419392da72b6d0", |
| "ad4dedcb6bb56d651bedc2642cdbe1578bee364425899bf7c702a2c65831b4df", |
| "aebaf19428b41d45c002e90dcd80aa7bffb1785019a3783ca2b4f114e156fa05", |
| "af2677fbf7b1e3c0d64f0e5555410b184d7e2a17f7335a53ab31ede5bdb691fa", |
| "b0fd6f8ae808bc564d501fcb2d338cb09964ddb5907e5bf6d1e0becdcb1b7ec1", |
| "b3274c3cd7c588eefb1ba42720dc57d73c94e483193d255fd210a5df98570ece", |
| "b45774da763f5b6e28dc6eee689d4898b89eaf0eb1545cc072f2f3130cee9de7", |
| "b4b5cdd668818a5ac63fda93ce473a0aa86c5663a3fc1d40c68d2a24015acfcf", |
| "b68a09c2ae023b3dfe81c3e7bda098fe6f087aff5ed432b10e272c08c4258f36", |
| "b6a36de0f0b8dfb7ad2f72e904f332aa37a614901dd51b32c85adf64675c4767", |
| "b6e2d2e1cbf483679fc03e11d256042a08388c62f8a37523c0413a8cd2a2df89", |
| "b89882f38cc0ea09f4529f9fa971857b9e4920d6d2dac91d5a7c7efdcae869b2", |
| "b9c24b50708a04d2aabaeaa5570742466fb5c0b7995a59ff0614c10d37ddc740", |
| "ba075ccd8c0964db0224f1098eba7b07c661803a20c20b8a78d424d925595170", |
| "ba78f055a10d8da45062835faeae0ca378628ee41221aa83400680a6b7ffce0e", |
| "ba79045ab5ee26d926fdf803b3240f274c9d51ef0981dd43d9c65392a22cf92c", |
| "bb2ff1c591a2a2a49cc4ddfd731d83ec5e22b7bae99ebb950a1fb7a855ecd504", |
| "bbfa1b91d3302aef91d174be598cfd4a8a5ea5361e35e90dd6ad6d79ae5d3f84", |
| "bd948461890aaf56319e51522a39ffe05e9375778271f6a86757f2b06586dbb6", |
| "bd9ac09a9a8ea64cc124068c5cd206375ba4bab83d9354d274b7f7ee1eafe6b2", |
| "c05b4a8028b14121ae4000de053a3df660ef9d7253eb977ae7caa67d1b23bfbd", |
| "c073201573428f6230c9ccd8049172162f4eb263b6335569a5a6b43a4f281e5b", |
| "c115e2708246a727e34e905d67f37609fe85799036c896004574d449a76b0549", |
| "c1aa9204efcdf79a148a760506f746d68df2ea78ee0cb77e6044b1ceaf701001", |
| "c1f72163522db12d8f5584e263cac90ba63a37047bdc3d9f8e40c201cb036718", |
| "c2216b45a37f7550aeb25134a545822d886c3f7b11071d39453701c1a7f6a7d3", |
| "c29d1ed8cb8810e3f775c2d559a85e28ec1e5a94a682bd74961e401ee18fecd4", |
| "c31f89b5837df6ad984998882e2554353241133bb9d13eaede9a02f1250c7e8c", |
| "c3a609657aa2397048074f9dca1ecea0f719e00324d152997b92d36e10644857", |
| "c40f9948d72b84b46d997725de36f2d6b3034227eec0b66022cbdec628e6a4ea", |
| "c43d7aad6ada27094b0526cc4a955098be1b8b608417104c4c00f7f0717a8442", |
| "c465dbbe3e77b7578fbb4a75a1f3b102f09f640bc8fc90d2f9a575eea1f55aac", |
| "c4ea1254f1733e5f679468e288d78476c536d4b9ba048cc5f09fc4d7199f0722", |
| "c58b8fbc7c0aa5a1939578e058f5336c576a2edad18737f9cc06baefa01ff60a", |
| "c5e4e42cfa1f008f735ec1bc8f4b5ebb34c7efdb29e358d366ac31347d1749f9", |
| "c5f3979d1fc17376468f67aae7077e9b6b850fcbdf7d3fa82d2aae4a3a2d5862", |
| "c73a58dde34209c4704b93c690ecaf8fd49fc4fe8b370c19405667fffcc9a4a6", |
| "c76d677b720a395e500d8f225a8e627e47f5a34bdcfdb9a90686f8c89fd1de90", |
| "c7c7ee6886b8c58fd9f6c965321a0e1852d7ddf244acd47ef849429f35e7ba81", |
| "c821e46dfcb8c820393a9bc12f2108964d1b8e3543d63aba6972378a4fc25d0a", |
| "c843993747ced51dbac04823931e5eef23b310282cfd7fc7fe9b70100fa5f529", |
| "c95952b338ee006afe4a1384cdbca161019a05d0cf595d85d27d404d306735c8", |
| "c9cb153daa7da9564ddfdc174a872add4c689533cc7f08750a43b1e2610a7a0a", |
| "cafeb066e07d5b2807ac52c9ce3a4b181aeb116f93d68193e27546f61cb5e493", |
| "cb1282904d50b7536cd4f2edd3e4883ad29892d7f9811747f2cce6ee516741ed", |
| "cb7480160bf85be6f09822dcba5936e23869b8bdb44556a7ab75adee26e11a96", |
| "cbd4af60bdf5cf98d69fa91f7c3ea59dcff3bb951a4ac258925050e9a11bfbda", |
| "cc36e44403b0a03c2458aca8e30e17bbae8d625e0225098afbd865f7dc801e00", |
| "cc774a34b2e3008c4ee97fdaba785897a1f87edf985f6365dcdd7977b6c3c3e1", |
| "cc8b969f316cd790a722ce25be79938bc3de9cbc7836af8f3248c9d801266d55", |
| "cc8ed89e16faf3ec9173a9c5b54f5b17d6f949f05032ecca6038ce1eccea264b", |
| "cd9d0e087375c5920a447c7822fb9e63f189ff128adb0a1c2435673bbd6e3041", |
| "cefe4f291cfa7de1ac4ba8c28fc92f8cfd1e95ff57f55ba929627eb1f8d36b4e", |
| "cf20f39ce273fb995615bbd247a1224bbc796ea80c2ce278684b0c1cb2c5efbc", |
| "cff4a879c8c83eb292706e985062fcac2b2b7280ac609ffbd86f19d108aa503c", |
| "d034b9d713f258547cf79ee81e8c1e921c067ed5e753809964291793cf52c19e", |
| "d05ce29e7dd219c87f588d9d76bbfb94399538407ce1424c2c62e2c58e5a44cf", |
| "d0c6e19bb893c19502698c921373da72f36a433ec591ae850bd9381c4d49763d", |
| "d0e0814bc424d4c31beb9e43a90836e83c88990edcbe421d71a45c8ea23d51ac", |
| "d145f91f1fff1be486cd9c2f381b6a70d377711406058c025733e2bf93106747", |
| "d215590fb9711bf8fdb70cb565b0e803c076f9e262cf979ae8094796469f39c6", |
| "d28d85cf36171f598b15706f90589314ef85d2747c03bf607b61634d74630a04", |
| "d6442429a25a7a7e7265abdc1392b279303de5e5ce74046f58b0547bf0283b41", |
| "d67d7f5c678b4c665565767b4a060824a3df81ee2e0ef1291637508f474f61a4", |
| "d68e4fca91e8aff9711e90e2c6767c16139d41817b1f30ea5c936071bbc1e0b7", |
| "d6e58ec12093a6bc2e241066bd5c0a90691a05c210c06b9590c3b17a11efcb2c", |
| "d6ec0fad8b44f8b6917e153b2b2f9d142eb0d01cf01fc7831f04bb093c580ee9", |
| "d73a9f5bf1e468c895abe318aaf728591d01a113db9200c4f0af52db25d92399", |
| "d768d6c6cb2619121d371b5da1d282654daa0acbc3b674bdb879fb4cb9b0a248", |
| "d7a218ccebbf875d664b961924fa74e8ca9979ff60b1d673d0ee45b2fd5cf135", |
| "d7a4594ebef369edc97413503a2a049700feed4c452de03bb26f2f502db3a098", |
| "d7bc54f1fd52e1c3820036621802731540f3550ade5a48001c19b221392decc6", |
| "d87b7fb31dcf4be19d666aa6715764b23593c5243e2099f8efd86b0bb5a90be4", |
| "d8958e39ed9dbc14c0c769a5c92d3e65efbb8c966ec1ba5313d2e443de57f0cf", |
| "d8b8710d2ed4ca7f1152183bf8db42d4a7d4015d7372210e419286e1bf6db6cf", |
| "d9dc3ad428a97b639f91585f4c4fcc5c3ba52abef01c208537fe2231d62d98f6", |
| "da8b75757559cc3df3e9ee23133dbe883a588173bff4a96a6ecb0f210a9120d7", |
| "dab4c9c94df124932b7b4ffee0e5189c97eac205de8097886ee80857837dcc43", |
| "dae386f6f1010325934eef945aebe4a592c095c9f3234afa87d7bbcc0f4e9951", |
| "db33ddf76200c8a6d51ba55b0c820e60b0dd002b7a1d1e7ed4bfc9a9af2b9661", |
| "db359936b44f7b71647f47b794ece6793fd42d7efcade832b063f8ab78bc4f68", |
| "dc2823f3aaa275a6a13b88f0abc8a0013de618aa063a7815902d2783b7c576d5", |
| "dc790eb21b43df733e0eaadaf39e0fdc3a22f3c7a1ee88ed4660dbfe2095c494", |
| "ddf91a55dbe2b716c3fee4be0f4116f316fdaf88d5d107c337b8eaecbc6e6970", |
| "dfe678e319b1ee70793bf0be5a2db10ae0db34779ad827971915bfb1ff55acba", |
| "e0887c473519077b4103757a01043625f4e80f48de448b251a0432bf33dbe15c", |
| "e15753e8156353f9e2418143b4c3c8deff50a6d9100a27374680ea3b7844834b", |
| "e1bbb077408233f3da335ad8dc1a544d35ca1935eaa4ab2204fd106687198b8a", |
| "e1ee84ab0f714ed5b6f3c3997ec30fc64f66d91d359cc1d6f0b6f70871339cef", |
| "e1fd65f4aaeb2ba5f3c6f3a63e2020e6dd6aeebc776b294a624bba2f8a47cfc2", |
| "e20a5e1da12c2cd02d8a61ddb331193ef71334ec71d388f45394fa3002aaa163", |
| "e56808934570876d5f30c682d29ee4f924a0e046157e69292199d76c660e5e5f", |
| "e65d371112c5eeaf1709026892623a193b8890e02731a45a941d3a970b5ddddd", |
| "e7d8edaf18786b2fa76a685e31beb8028f997964f49f122162e4f0b8e22c5191", |
| "e7e03050d637a429493ac9369a9ef14a95c86004730c0058ffbcc99b7ef1e270", |
| "e7e378289579045c332868a849da1c65e5742ca98b465a825ae7940068858058", |
| "e818afda7eb8828a1ffa2ec34f41f5aca775096c3303770d181324d07c9f8c9f", |
| "e8193b8ff38fad587992025990a57a6b91acf64aa3dc1d099de4ea53dfd77f4f", |
| "e8268a8460b3028c394d3f69aad7dd19402ab989b40a8ad1125fb9b275ed5fc3", |
| "e88e096e5958e82a26542a50ebd42ca2b81b718dab973b10dbff79ac6be96400", |
| "e9448317bb3207abd8414e35dd82a9103012a84701dbafa67984125026531055", |
| "ea5ed2518ed71eedbe7ea746df82340084a46507b72fce918ebdbddde82fe882", |
| "ebc8fc3799677ae8169da617346f22d896f25e696300a8f4cf2f5f18b4f94295", |
| "ed13442d7c7eef4999791d9dd424d4c2f1d939378bb6eb563f5c485563c57786", |
| "ed620a2bbe2d8aba881b5cbb66f04bcb9139d84ecd71b6056df93bea512782c0", |
| "edbbc620c16b0e1d2166d25a846e94b8defb9848f17c18eccbb24524ba262db2", |
| "ede2e26ed9f5f9faab5a57ea5c56d1bfa5b40cca4485947af757765c57c4115b", |
| "eeef38d2f194e36e1b6be5a5ef61a0a737bc37681ce7ed3c806f23186fc2f376", |
| "ef93fd2cb6bbf69c8a032c121b750bec196737de8924d69babb67129ae26b797", |
| "f007620ad77586da5aa7f94b31ece4e1fcf28ac1149957ba5e82d5c0f6a3c9b1", |
| "f056d8e7d0f84cb5a8a2da67b3476a9f873cb73f0aa80e2f5e08854a62c69b86", |
| "f0651ecd0970cca4e44ada95b25269fa2f5ce5c6b8dc97f418dad2ec86f347d9", |
| "f0e4cb8b534b44cc6eaa1247fa2a3aa080571d74d6cabff0df4b480819911ab5", |
| "f0ef4b73dc8b2156273788800c3a423b956c86a3696e56ed200fc4ad3d344849", |
| "f227dc7c66ba8ac01191191b751c5dfb1525ea1e09af584d24251b6a7b3e4dd3", |
| "f2b8e97f982d09d7dbd46b9676c8d807dea6928e31425a7f773dadb32704dd0e", |
| "f3237d13de5953c65de0b28c5eef830425ca432d8fdefeb71f8f395f60271b65", |
| "f32d3d8789401008ce6f897cb89b7d73e4e0b94519fad12591848ca018003cfa", |
| "f3b1fdb3d46c3fed6ac6080190af336c94b472e5d8018f7f9124decc767c4e34", |
| "f49619adfc67d3af20ed5100113d1b3057d5ada90667cb8a3672762d905783b7", |
| "f54a61b028fde4336471df3248dfbd6d80d52ff2b9868af73cdbaac04c88f334", |
| "f6152a46f99cde1fceaf5d811ba367b1c16e3356666ba3484aa4d50bf1dd8474", |
| "f78894068b6fc574f881578a88d1eeb56228148a8391aba7aa7bd49e42230df2", |
| "f7ec2c1fe515430a17750941ae180a9c001533ba007e63b169b2a37de2d523ee", |
| "ffa00fa3cb63b93e2501ea15ac38230f08700cc92c10a94dce088d6c49742f49" |
| ], |
| "interpretation": "post-hoc vulnerability stratum, not adjudicated label errors; retained complement is not certified clean", |
| "models": { |
| "qwen38-flash-next": { |
| "location": { |
| "groups": 376, |
| "views": 1128, |
| "failures": 281, |
| "groups_correct": 140, |
| "missing_failures": 197, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| }, |
| "other": { |
| "groups": 624, |
| "views": 1872, |
| "failures": 489, |
| "groups_correct": 259, |
| "missing_failures": 241, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it": { |
| "location": { |
| "groups": 376, |
| "views": 1128, |
| "failures": 310, |
| "groups_correct": 140, |
| "missing_failures": 180, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| }, |
| "other": { |
| "groups": 624, |
| "views": 1872, |
| "failures": 508, |
| "groups_correct": 232, |
| "missing_failures": 283, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen": { |
| "location": { |
| "groups": 376, |
| "views": 1128, |
| "failures": 309, |
| "groups_correct": 127, |
| "missing_failures": 192, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| }, |
| "other": { |
| "groups": 624, |
| "views": 1872, |
| "failures": 534, |
| "groups_correct": 232, |
| "missing_failures": 241, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "location": { |
| "groups": 376, |
| "views": 1128, |
| "failures": 320, |
| "groups_correct": 146, |
| "missing_failures": 156, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| }, |
| "other": { |
| "groups": 624, |
| "views": 1872, |
| "failures": 512, |
| "groups_correct": 246, |
| "missing_failures": 226, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "glm": { |
| "location": { |
| "groups": 376, |
| "views": 1128, |
| "failures": 310, |
| "groups_correct": 81, |
| "missing_failures": 281, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| }, |
| "other": { |
| "groups": 624, |
| "views": 1872, |
| "failures": 431, |
| "groups_correct": 224, |
| "missing_failures": 360, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "molmo2-8b": { |
| "location": { |
| "groups": 376, |
| "views": 1128, |
| "failures": 297, |
| "groups_correct": 93, |
| "missing_failures": 266, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| }, |
| "other": { |
| "groups": 624, |
| "views": 1872, |
| "failures": 610, |
| "groups_correct": 174, |
| "missing_failures": 311, |
| "invalid": 0 |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "intervals": "point estimates only" |
| }, |
| "program_steps": { |
| "2": 729, |
| "3": 249, |
| "4": 22 |
| }, |
| "program_steps_note": "Stored dependency_depth is len(program steps), not tree depth", |
| "answer_types": { |
| "short_text": 709, |
| "boolean": 291 |
| }, |
| "paired_contrasts": { |
| "qwen38-flash-next__gemma4-31b-it": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.5999999999999996, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.9333333333332936, |
| -0.2666666666666483 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.20000000000000018, |
| 5.200000000000005 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.200000000000002, |
| 7.400000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.75, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.3499999999999965, |
| 7.199999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.825, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.225, |
| -0.4743750000000068 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.5999999999999996, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.9333333333332936, |
| -0.2666666666666483 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.20000000000000018, |
| 5.200000000000005 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.199999999999999, |
| 0.20000000000000018 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.15, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.15, |
| 0.8000000000000007 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.199999999999999, |
| 0.20000000000000018 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__qwen": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "qwen", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.433333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.8666666666665246, |
| -0.9666666666666157 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.200000000000001, |
| 6.7 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.200000000000002, |
| 7.600000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.950000000000008, |
| 7.200000000000006 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.7000000000000002, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.175, |
| -0.17500000000000293 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.433333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.8666666666665246, |
| -0.9666666666666157 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.200000000000001, |
| 6.7 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.300000000000002, |
| 3.300000000000003 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -3.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.949999999999999, |
| -1.8499999999999988 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.300000000000002, |
| 3.300000000000003 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.0666666666666664, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.5333333333332604, |
| -0.6333333333332801 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.7000000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.099999999999996, |
| 3.3999999999999977 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.6999999999999997, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.9000000000000008, |
| 6.3 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 11.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 8.850000000000001, |
| 14.001249999999983 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.15, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.6000000000000014, |
| 1.325000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.0666666666666664, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.5333333333332604, |
| -0.6333333333332801 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.7000000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.099999999999996, |
| 3.3999999999999977 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.6000000000000005, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.799999999999997, |
| 8.400000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.8999999999999995, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.149999999999999, |
| -3.7500000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.6000000000000005, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.799999999999997, |
| 8.400000000000002 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__glm": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.9666666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.46666666666675133, |
| 2.366666666666559 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 9.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 6.5, |
| 12.3 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 9.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 6.499999999999997, |
| 11.999999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -7.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -10.000000000000009, |
| -5.600000000000005 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.35, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.875625000000002, |
| -2.8500000000000023 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.9666666666666667, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.46666666666675133, |
| 2.366666666666559 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 9.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 6.5, |
| 12.3 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -20.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -23.300000000000004, |
| -17.299999999999997 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 11.600000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 9.6, |
| 13.599999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -20.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -23.300000000000004, |
| -17.299999999999997 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen38-flash-next__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "qwen38-flash-next", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.566666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.166666666666554, |
| -2.966666666666634 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 13.200000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 10.199999999999998, |
| 16.2 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 11.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 8.500000000000002, |
| 14.299999999999995 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.8999999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.650000000000007, |
| 3.499999999999992 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -6.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.524999999999999, |
| -5.274999999999997 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.566666666666666, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.166666666666554, |
| -2.966666666666634 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 13.200000000000001, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 10.199999999999998, |
| 16.2 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -13.900000000000002, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -17.099999999999998, |
| -10.699999999999992 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.349999999999999, |
| 2.5499999999999994 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -13.900000000000002, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -17.099999999999998, |
| -10.699999999999992 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__qwen": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "qwen", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.8333333333333331, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.200833333333327, |
| 0.5999999999999894 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.5000000000000013, |
| 4.099999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.6999999999999966, |
| 2.899999999999997 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.35000000000000003, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.100000000000002, |
| 2.749999999999997 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.125, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.3749999999999984, |
| 1.6506249999999922 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.8333333333333331, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -2.200833333333327, |
| 0.5999999999999894 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.5000000000000013, |
| 4.099999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.20000000000000018, |
| 5.8999999999999995 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.75, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.699999999999998, |
| -0.7500000000000007 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.20000000000000018, |
| 5.8999999999999995 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.4666666666666665, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.6999999999999404, |
| 0.7675000000000343 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.400000000000004, |
| 0.40000000000000036 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.0999999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.3999999999999977, |
| 1.200000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.65, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.5999999999999925, |
| 8.750000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.675, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.40000000000000036, |
| 2.950000000000003 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -0.4666666666666665, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.6999999999999404, |
| 0.7675000000000343 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.400000000000004, |
| 0.40000000000000036 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 8.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 5.699999999999999, |
| 10.599999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.75, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.550000000000001, |
| -2.950000000000003 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 8.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 5.699999999999999, |
| 10.599999999999998 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__glm": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.5666666666666664, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.1999999999998676, |
| 4.0333333333331165 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.8999999999999977, |
| 9.500000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.3999999999999995, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.7000000000000015, |
| 7.1000000000000005 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -12.55, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -14.950000000000008, |
| -10.149999999999991 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.5250000000000004, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.025, |
| -1.0000000000000009 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.5666666666666664, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.1999999999998676, |
| 4.0333333333331165 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.8999999999999977, |
| 9.500000000000004 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -17.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -20.8, |
| -14.900000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 12.75, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 10.75, |
| 14.800000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -17.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -20.8, |
| -14.900000000000002 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-31b-it__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "gemma4-31b-it", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.9666666666666663, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.63333333333324, |
| -1.2999999999999732 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 10.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 7.500000000000001, |
| 13.499999999999995 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.6000000000000005, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.7000000000000033, |
| 9.5 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -3.85, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.799999999999995, |
| -0.8499999999999952 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.075, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.7, |
| -3.4250000000000003 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.9666666666666663, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.63333333333324, |
| -1.2999999999999732 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 10.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 7.500000000000001, |
| 13.499999999999995 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -11.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -14.799999999999997, |
| -7.9999999999999964 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.25, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.5499999999999985, |
| 4.050000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -11.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -14.799999999999997, |
| -7.9999999999999964 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen__gemma4-26b-a4b-it": { |
| "left": "qwen", |
| "right": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.36666666666666653, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.0999999999999566, |
| 1.833333333333298 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -3.3000000000000003, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.0, |
| -0.6000000000000005 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -1.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.8999999999999977, |
| 1.499999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.7999999999999923, |
| 8.799999999999997 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 1.55, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.025000000000002798, |
| 3.0500000000000025 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 0.36666666666666653, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -1.0999999999999566, |
| 1.833333333333298 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -3.3000000000000003, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.0, |
| -0.6000000000000005 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.2999999999999963, |
| 8.000000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.099999999999998, |
| 0.10000000000000009 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.1, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.2999999999999963, |
| 8.000000000000002 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen__glm": { |
| "left": "qwen", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.4000000000000004, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.8999999999998738, |
| 4.866666666666483 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.400000000000002, |
| 8.499999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.3, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.5000000000000013, |
| 7.099999999999998 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -12.9, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -15.200000000000003, |
| -10.649999999999993 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.65, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.249999999999998, |
| -1.100000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.4000000000000004, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.8999999999998738, |
| 4.866666666666483 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.400000000000002, |
| 8.499999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -20.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -23.7, |
| -17.9 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 15.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 13.448749999999999, |
| 17.549999999999997 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -20.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -23.7, |
| -17.9 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "qwen__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "qwen", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.1333333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.899999999999948, |
| -0.46666666666663736 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 9.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 6.1, |
| 12.3 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.600000000000003, |
| 9.4 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.950000000000001, |
| -1.4000000000000012 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.9, |
| -3.5500000000000034 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.1333333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -3.899999999999948, |
| -0.46666666666663736 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 9.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 6.1, |
| 12.3 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -14.399999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -17.7, |
| -11.100000000000005 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 4.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.250000000000001, |
| 6.651249999999982 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -14.399999999999999, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -17.7, |
| -11.100000000000005 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-26b-a4b-it__glm": { |
| "left": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "right": "glm", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.0333333333333337, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.499999999999857, |
| 4.566666666666455 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 8.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 5.699999999999999, |
| 11.7 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 5.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 2.6000000000000023, |
| 8.400000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -19.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -21.9, |
| -16.65 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -4.2, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -5.8, |
| -2.6249999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.0333333333333337, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 1.499999999999857, |
| 4.566666666666455 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 8.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 5.699999999999999, |
| 11.7 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -25.900000000000002, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -29.000000000000004, |
| -22.799999999999997 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 17.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 15.200000000000003, |
| 19.8 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -25.900000000000002, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -29.000000000000004, |
| -22.799999999999997 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "gemma4-26b-a4b-it__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "gemma4-26b-a4b-it", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.233333333333272, |
| -0.7666666666666487 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 12.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 9.499999999999996, |
| 15.499999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 7.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 4.799999999999999, |
| 10.7 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -10.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -13.550000000000006, |
| -7.450000000000001 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -6.75, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -8.399999999999997, |
| -5.125000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.233333333333272, |
| -0.7666666666666487 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 12.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 9.499999999999996, |
| 15.499999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -19.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -22.799999999999997, |
| -16.200000000000003 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.0, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.1, |
| 8.85 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -19.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -22.799999999999997, |
| -16.200000000000003 |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "glm__molmo2-8b": { |
| "left": "glm", |
| "right": "molmo2-8b", |
| "failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.533333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.999999999999762, |
| -4.099999999999832 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.9000000000000008, |
| 6.7 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "joint_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 2.1999999999999997, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -0.5000000000000004, |
| 5.000000000000002 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answer_accuracy_strict": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 8.7, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 6.05, |
| 11.299999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "balanced_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -2.55, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -4.075000000000001, |
| -1.0250000000000037 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -5.533333333333333, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -6.999999999999762, |
| -4.099999999999832 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "common_state_group_success": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 3.8, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 0.9000000000000008, |
| 6.7 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "missing_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.300000000000003, |
| 9.499999999999996 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "answerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": -11.5, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| -13.750000000000002, |
| -9.299999999999999 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "unanswerable_failure": { |
| "left_minus_right_pp": 6.4, |
| "interval_95_pp": [ |
| 3.300000000000003, |
| 9.499999999999996 |
| ] |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "analytic_baselines": { |
| "always_answerable_failure": 0.3333333333333333, |
| "always_unanswerable_failure": 0.6666666666666666, |
| "constant_decision_group_success": 0, |
| "constant_decision_balanced_failure": 0.5 |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "provenance": { |
| "clevr": { |
| "subsets": { |
| "bridge": { |
| "views": 1387, |
| "failures": 300, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "state_counts": { |
| "FULL": 346, |
| "A_SAME": 347, |
| "A_CHANGED": 346, |
| "U_MISSING": 348 |
| } |
| }, |
| "simflow": { |
| "views": 2613, |
| "failures": 736, |
| "invalid": 1, |
| "state_counts": { |
| "FULL": 654, |
| "A_SAME": 653, |
| "A_CHANGED": 654, |
| "U_MISSING": 652 |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "group_composition": { |
| "mixed": 812, |
| "simflow": 174, |
| "bridge": 14 |
| }, |
| "interpretation": "Availability-selected disjoint subsets; not a matched backend comparison" |
| }, |
| "gqa": { |
| "subsets": { |
| "bridge": { |
| "views": 1038, |
| "failures": 286, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "state_counts": { |
| "FULL": 346, |
| "A_SAME": 346, |
| "U_MISSING": 346 |
| } |
| }, |
| "simflow": { |
| "views": 1962, |
| "failures": 557, |
| "invalid": 0, |
| "state_counts": { |
| "FULL": 654, |
| "A_SAME": 654, |
| "U_MISSING": 654 |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "group_composition": { |
| "mixed": 672, |
| "simflow": 292, |
| "bridge": 36 |
| }, |
| "interpretation": "Availability-selected disjoint subsets; not a matched backend comparison" |
| } |
| }, |
| "protocol": { |
| "draws": 10000, |
| "seed": 20260915, |
| "unit": "source-question group", |
| "interval": "descriptive percentile bootstrap; paired within domain; no multiplicity adjustment", |
| "common_states": [ |
| "FULL", |
| "A_SAME", |
| "U_MISSING" |
| ], |
| "inference_calls": 0, |
| "cross_domain_interpretation": "different questions, states and evidence guarantees; no causal domain effect", |
| "balanced_failure": "one half answerable failure plus one half unanswerable failure; invalids fail in their truth class", |
| "new_metrics": "post-hoc descriptive additions; not preregistered", |
| "source_image_clustering": "one question per source image is the release builder contract; portable labels cannot re-audit original image identities for CLEVR/GQA", |
| "sha_validation_performed": false |
| }, |
| "validation": { |
| "status": "passed", |
| "selected_model_responses": 72000, |
| "unique_input_views": 12000, |
| "source_question_groups": 3000, |
| "model_domain_cells": 18, |
| "terminal_invalid_responses": 11, |
| "valid_responses": 71989, |
| "missing_or_duplicate_rows": 0, |
| "original_aggregate_counts_reproduced": true, |
| "all_model_frozen_question_joins": true, |
| "output_projection_scope": "parsed response fields, not independent raw-output/token validation", |
| "sha_validation_performed": false |
| } |
| } |
|
|
