sungguk's picture
Release visual answerability benchmark v1.0.0
e1ced61 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
11.5 kB
"""Build content-addressed state certificates.
The certificate is deliberately derived only from immutable inputs: the source
and transformed worlds, typed program, deterministic executor results, and two
byte-identical renderer passes. A model response is never accepted as a label.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
from collections.abc import Mapping, Sequence
from dataclasses import dataclass
from functools import lru_cache
from typing import Any, Literal
from ..dsl.ast import Program, ast_node_from_dict
from ..executors.base import ExecutionResult
from ..hashing import canonical_json_hash
from ..paths import repo_root
from ..renderers.base import RenderedAssets
from ..schema_io import load_schema, validate
from ..sources.base import World
from ..sources.world_ops import world_sha256
State = Literal["FULL", "A_SAME", "A_CHANGED", "U_MISSING", "U_INVALID"]
class CertificateError(ValueError):
"""A certificate cannot be proven from the supplied artifacts."""
@dataclass(frozen=True)
class MissingProofInputs:
completion_a_world_sha256: str
completion_b_world_sha256: str
completion_a_answer: str | int | bool
completion_b_answer: str | int | bool
observed_render_a_sha256: str
observed_render_b_sha256: str
def certificate_id(certificate: Mapping[str, Any]) -> str:
"""Recompute the content address, excluding the address field itself."""
payload = dict(certificate)
payload.pop("certificate_id", None)
return canonical_json_hash(payload)
@lru_cache(maxsize=1)
def _certificate_schema() -> dict[str, Any]:
return load_schema(repo_root() / "schemas" / "intervention_certificate.schema.json")
def program_from_dict(data: Mapping[str, Any]) -> Program:
"""Rebuild a :class:`Program` from its P2 envelope."""
selector = data.get("referent_selector")
return Program(
dsl=str(data["dsl"]), # type: ignore[arg-type]
program=ast_node_from_dict(data["program"]),
base_id=str(data["base_id"]),
question_sha256=str(data["question_sha256"]),
choices_sha256=str(data["choices_sha256"]),
compile_status=str(data["compile_status"]), # type: ignore[arg-type]
referent_selector=ast_node_from_dict(selector) if isinstance(selector, Mapping) else None,
required_referent_cardinality=data.get("required_referent_cardinality"),
referenced_node_ids=tuple(str(v) for v in data.get("referenced_node_ids", [])),
canonical_program_sha256=str(data.get("canonical_program_sha256") or ""),
reason_code=str(data["reason_code"]) if data.get("reason_code") is not None else None,
constraint_channels=tuple((str(k), str(v)) for k, v in data.get("constraint_channels", [])),
)
def _status(value: str) -> str:
mapping = {
"UNIQUE": "unique_answer",
"MISSING_INFORMATION": "missing_information",
"INVALID_REFERENT": "invalid_referent",
}
try:
return mapping[value]
except KeyError:
raise CertificateError(f"executor status {value!r} cannot certify a label") from None
def _assert_render_replay(first: RenderedAssets, replay: RenderedAssets) -> None:
if first.rgba_png != replay.rgba_png:
raise CertificateError("RGBA render replay differs")
if first.node_map_png != replay.node_map_png:
raise CertificateError("node-map render replay differs")
if first.render_manifest != replay.render_manifest:
raise CertificateError("render manifest replay differs")
if first.text_manifest != replay.text_manifest:
raise CertificateError("text manifest replay differs")
def _proof(
state: State,
before: ExecutionResult,
after: ExecutionResult,
*,
missing: MissingProofInputs | None,
) -> dict[str, Any]:
if state == "FULL":
if not before.is_unique or after.answer_canonical != before.answer_canonical:
raise CertificateError("FULL requires the same unique before/after answer")
return {"state": state, "answer": before.answer_canonical}
if state == "A_SAME":
if not before.is_unique or not after.is_unique:
raise CertificateError("A_SAME requires two unique answers")
if after.answer_canonical != before.answer_canonical:
raise CertificateError("A_SAME answers differ")
return {
"state": state,
"before_answer": before.answer_canonical,
"after_answer": after.answer_canonical,
"equality_asserted": True,
}
if state == "A_CHANGED":
if not before.is_unique or not after.is_unique:
raise CertificateError("A_CHANGED requires two unique answers")
if after.answer_canonical == before.answer_canonical:
raise CertificateError("A_CHANGED answers are equal")
return {
"state": state,
"before_answer": before.answer_canonical,
"after_answer": after.answer_canonical,
"inequality_asserted": True,
}
if state == "U_MISSING":
if after.status != "MISSING_INFORMATION":
raise CertificateError("U_MISSING requires MISSING_INFORMATION after execution")
if missing is None:
raise CertificateError("U_MISSING requires two completion witnesses")
if missing.completion_a_answer == missing.completion_b_answer:
raise CertificateError("U_MISSING completion answers must differ")
if missing.observed_render_a_sha256 != missing.observed_render_b_sha256:
raise CertificateError("U_MISSING completion observations must be identical")
return {
"state": state,
"completion_a_world_sha256": missing.completion_a_world_sha256,
"completion_b_world_sha256": missing.completion_b_world_sha256,
"completion_a_answer": missing.completion_a_answer,
"completion_b_answer": missing.completion_b_answer,
"answers_differ": True,
"observed_render_a_sha256": missing.observed_render_a_sha256,
"observed_render_b_sha256": missing.observed_render_b_sha256,
"observed_renders_identical": True,
}
if state == "U_INVALID":
if after.status != "INVALID_REFERENT":
raise CertificateError("U_INVALID requires INVALID_REFERENT after execution")
if before.referent_cardinality != 1 or after.referent_cardinality == 1:
raise CertificateError("U_INVALID selector cardinalities do not prove failure")
return {
"state": state,
"selector_cardinality_before": 1,
"selector_cardinality_after": int(after.referent_cardinality or 0),
"required_cardinality": 1,
"precondition_failed": True,
}
raise CertificateError(f"unknown state {state!r}")
def build_certificate(
*,
tier: Literal["C1_SOURCE_NATIVE", "C2_DUAL_COMPILED"],
base_id: str,
view_id: str,
question_sha256: str,
choices_sha256: str,
world_before: World,
world_after: World,
program: Program,
before_result: ExecutionResult,
after_result: ExecutionResult,
renderer_id: str,
renderer_version: str,
renderer_seed: int,
first_render: RenderedAssets,
replay_render: RenderedAssets,
changed_node_ids: Sequence[str],
diff_mask_sha256: str,
state: State,
missing_proof: MissingProofInputs | None = None,
reference_result: ExecutionResult | None = None,
c2_compilation: Mapping[str, Any] | None = None,
) -> dict[str, Any]:
"""Build and schema-validate one content-addressed certificate."""
if program.compile_status != "compiled":
raise CertificateError("an unsupported program cannot be certified")
if program.base_id != base_id:
raise CertificateError("program/base ID mismatch")
if program.question_sha256 != question_sha256 or program.choices_sha256 != choices_sha256:
raise CertificateError("program question/choices hash mismatch")
if not before_result.is_unique:
raise CertificateError("FULL execution is not unique")
_assert_render_replay(first_render, replay_render)
selector_sha = (
canonical_json_hash(program.referent_selector.to_ast_node_dict())
if program.referent_selector is not None
else None
)
proof = _proof(state, before_result, after_result, missing=missing_proof)
certificate: dict[str, Any] = {
"schema_version": 1,
"tier": tier,
"base_id": base_id,
"view_id": view_id,
"question_sha256": question_sha256,
"choices_sha256": choices_sha256,
"world_before_sha256": world_sha256(world_before),
"world_after_sha256": world_sha256(world_after),
"program": {
"language": program.dsl,
"canonical_ast_sha256": program.canonical_program_sha256,
"dependency_node_ids": list(before_result.dependency_node_ids),
"referent_selector_sha256": selector_sha,
},
"executor": {
"name": before_result.executor_name,
"version": before_result.executor_version,
"deterministic": True,
"before_trace_sha256": before_result.trace_sha256,
"after_trace_sha256": after_result.trace_sha256,
"before_answer_canonical": before_result.answer_canonical,
"after_answer_canonical": after_result.answer_canonical,
"after_status": _status(after_result.status),
},
"reference_executor": None,
"renderer": {
"name": renderer_id,
"version": renderer_version,
"seed": renderer_seed,
"render_manifest_sha256": canonical_json_hash(first_render.render_manifest),
"first_render_sha256": first_render.rgba_sha256,
"replay_render_sha256": replay_render.rgba_sha256,
"replay_exact_match": True,
"changed_node_ids": sorted(set(changed_node_ids)),
"diff_mask_sha256": diff_mask_sha256,
},
"proof": proof,
"c2_compilation": dict(c2_compilation) if c2_compilation is not None else None,
"checks": {
"question_choices_unchanged": True,
"source_full_answer_reproduced": True,
"fresh_structured_render": True,
"pixel_scope_audit_passed": True,
"choice_uniqueness_passed": True,
"certificate_replayed": True,
},
}
if reference_result is not None:
agrees = (
reference_result.status == after_result.status
and reference_result.answer_canonical == after_result.answer_canonical
)
if not agrees:
raise CertificateError("reference executor disagrees with primary")
certificate["reference_executor"] = {
"name": reference_result.executor_name,
"version": reference_result.executor_version,
"after_status": _status(reference_result.status),
"after_answer_canonical": reference_result.answer_canonical,
"trace_sha256": reference_result.trace_sha256,
"agrees_with_primary": True,
}
certificate["certificate_id"] = certificate_id(certificate)
errors = validate(certificate, _certificate_schema())
if errors:
raise CertificateError("certificate schema validation failed: " + "; ".join(errors))
return certificate