sungguk's picture
Release visual answerability benchmark v1.0.0
e1ced61 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
20.4 kB
"""Self-contained certificates for the multi-domain EVI core release.
The original PlotQA release keeps using the schema-v1 certificate/replay path.
This module covers the two new source-native families:
* GQA: native semantic program + scene graph + released photograph + bbox mask;
* CLEVR: native functional program + scene + fresh structured renderer.
Both paths persist every input required to replay execution, rendering,
evidence projection, and missing-information witnesses in a separate process.
No model output participates in admission.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import io
import json
from collections.abc import Mapping, Sequence
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Any, Literal
from PIL import Image
from ..dsl.canonicalize import canonical_program_sha256
from ..executors.base import ExecutionResult
from ..hashing import canonical_json_hash, sha256_file
from ..renderers import render
from ..renderers.base import RenderedAssets, decode_uint32_png
from ..renderers.gqa import gqa_evidence_mask_png, raster_diff_mask_png, render_gqa_observation
from ..sources.base import World
from ..sources.world_ops import world_sha256
from .build import certificate_id, program_from_dict
from .replay import ReplayResult
CORE_CERTIFICATE_CONTRACT = "evi_core_view_v1"
CoreSource = Literal["gqa", "clevr"]
CoreState = Literal["FULL", "A_SAME", "A_CHANGED", "U_MISSING"]
class CoreCertificateError(ValueError):
"""A source-native EVI view cannot be certified or replayed."""
def execution_record(result: ExecutionResult) -> dict[str, Any]:
"""Canonical persisted representation of an executor result."""
return {
"status": result.status,
"answer_canonical": result.answer_canonical,
"dependency_node_ids": list(result.dependency_node_ids),
"referent_cardinality": result.referent_cardinality,
"trace_sha256": result.trace_sha256,
"executor_name": result.executor_name,
"executor_version": result.executor_version,
}
def evidence_mask_from_node_map(
node_map_png: bytes,
node_table: Sequence[str],
dependency_node_ids: Sequence[str],
) -> bytes:
"""Project dependency IDs through a lossless node-owner map."""
import numpy as np
if not node_table or node_table[0] != "__background__":
raise CoreCertificateError("node table lacks background sentinel")
index = {node_id: position for position, node_id in enumerate(node_table)}
selected = [index[node_id] for node_id in dependency_node_ids if node_id in index]
if not selected:
raise CoreCertificateError("no dependency node has node-map coverage")
owners = decode_uint32_png(node_map_png)
mask = np.isin(owners, selected).astype("uint8") * 255
if not bool(mask.any()):
raise CoreCertificateError("projected evidence mask is empty")
output = io.BytesIO()
Image.fromarray(mask, mode="L").save(
output,
format="PNG",
optimize=False,
compress_level=9,
)
return output.getvalue()
def build_core_certificate(
*,
source: CoreSource,
base_id: str,
view_id: str,
state: CoreState,
question_sha256: str,
choices_sha256: str,
program_language: str,
program_sha256: str,
before_world: World,
after_world: World,
before_result: ExecutionResult,
after_result: ExecutionResult,
renderer_name: str,
renderer_version: str,
renderer_seed: int,
render_manifest: Mapping[str, Any],
image_filename: str,
image_sha256: str,
node_map_sha256: str,
diff_mask_sha256: str,
evidence_mask_sha256: str,
masked_node_id: str | None,
fresh_structured_render: bool,
completion_proof: Mapping[str, Any] | None = None,
) -> dict[str, Any]:
"""Build and validate a content-addressed multi-domain certificate."""
if len(base_id) != 64 or len(program_sha256) != 64:
raise CoreCertificateError("base/program identity must be SHA-256")
if not before_result.is_unique:
raise CoreCertificateError("FULL execution must be unique")
_validate_state(
state,
before_result=before_result,
after_result=after_result,
completion_proof=completion_proof,
)
dependency_ids = list(before_result.dependency_node_ids)
if not dependency_ids:
raise CoreCertificateError("certificate requires executor dependency nodes")
certificate: dict[str, Any] = {
"schema_version": 1,
"contract": CORE_CERTIFICATE_CONTRACT,
"source": source,
"tier": "C1_SOURCE_NATIVE",
"base_id": base_id,
"view_id": view_id,
"question_sha256": question_sha256,
"choices_sha256": choices_sha256,
"world_before_sha256": world_sha256(before_world),
"world_after_sha256": world_sha256(after_world),
"program": {
"language": program_language,
"canonical_ast_sha256": program_sha256,
"dependency_node_ids": dependency_ids,
},
"executor": {
"before": execution_record(before_result),
"after": execution_record(after_result),
},
"renderer": {
"name": renderer_name,
"version": renderer_version,
"seed": renderer_seed,
"render_manifest_sha256": canonical_json_hash(dict(render_manifest)),
"image_filename": image_filename,
"image_sha256": image_sha256,
"node_map_sha256": node_map_sha256,
"diff_mask_sha256": diff_mask_sha256,
"evidence_mask_sha256": evidence_mask_sha256,
"masked_node_id": masked_node_id,
"fresh_structured_render": fresh_structured_render,
},
"proof": {
"state": state,
"completion": dict(completion_proof) if completion_proof is not None else None,
},
"checks": {
"question_choices_unchanged": True,
"source_full_answer_reproduced": True,
"deterministic_executor_success": True,
"render_manifest_validated": True,
"semantic_mask_validated": True,
"per_example_reasoning_vlm_calls": 0,
"per_example_human_decisions": 0,
},
}
certificate["certificate_id"] = certificate_id(certificate)
return certificate
def is_core_certificate(value: Mapping[str, Any]) -> bool:
return value.get("contract") == CORE_CERTIFICATE_CONTRACT
def replay_core_view(view_dir: str | Path) -> ReplayResult:
"""Replay one GQA/CLEVR EVI view from only persisted bytes."""
root = Path(view_dir)
errors: list[str] = []
try:
certificate = _load(root / "certificate.json")
before_world = _load(root / "world_before.json")
after_world = _load(root / "world_after.json")
program_record = _load(root / "program.json")
manifest = _load(root / "render_manifest.json")
text_manifest = _load(root / "text_manifest.json")
except (OSError, ValueError, KeyError, TypeError) as exc:
return ReplayResult(str(root), False, (f"load failed: {exc}",))
if not is_core_certificate(certificate):
return ReplayResult(str(root), False, ("not an EVI core certificate",))
if certificate_id(certificate) != certificate.get("certificate_id"):
errors.append("certificate content address mismatch")
source = str(certificate.get("source", ""))
if source not in {"gqa", "clevr"}:
errors.append(f"unsupported core certificate source {source!r}")
return ReplayResult(str(root), False, tuple(errors))
try:
program, executor = _restore_program_and_executor(source, program_record, before_world)
before = executor.execute(program, world=before_world)
after = executor.execute(program, world=after_world)
except Exception as exc:
return ReplayResult(str(root), False, (f"executor replay failed: {exc}",))
program_sha = (
program.canonical_program_sha256
if source == "gqa"
else canonical_program_sha256(program, world=before_world)
)
if program_sha != certificate.get("program", {}).get("canonical_ast_sha256"):
errors.append("canonical program hash mismatch")
if world_sha256(before_world) != certificate.get("world_before_sha256"):
errors.append("world_before hash mismatch")
if world_sha256(after_world) != certificate.get("world_after_sha256"):
errors.append("world_after hash mismatch")
if execution_record(before) != certificate.get("executor", {}).get("before"):
errors.append("before executor result mismatch")
if execution_record(after) != certificate.get("executor", {}).get("after"):
errors.append("after executor result mismatch")
renderer = certificate.get("renderer")
if not isinstance(renderer, Mapping):
return ReplayResult(str(root), False, (*errors, "renderer record missing"))
image_filename = str(renderer.get("image_filename", ""))
image_path = root / image_filename
required_files = {
"image": image_path,
"node_map": root / "node_map.uint32.png",
"diff_mask": root / "diff_mask.png",
"evidence_mask": root / "evidence_mask.png",
}
for label, path in required_files.items():
if not path.is_file():
errors.append(f"{label} artifact missing")
if errors and any("missing" in error for error in errors):
return ReplayResult(str(root), False, tuple(errors))
if sha256_file(image_path) != renderer.get("image_sha256"):
errors.append("persisted image hash mismatch")
if sha256_file(required_files["node_map"]) != renderer.get("node_map_sha256"):
errors.append("persisted node-map hash mismatch")
if sha256_file(required_files["diff_mask"]) != renderer.get("diff_mask_sha256"):
errors.append("persisted diff-mask hash mismatch")
if sha256_file(required_files["evidence_mask"]) != renderer.get("evidence_mask_sha256"):
errors.append("persisted evidence-mask hash mismatch")
if canonical_json_hash(manifest) != renderer.get("render_manifest_sha256"):
errors.append("render manifest hash mismatch")
try:
replay, full_replay = _rerender(
source,
root=root,
before_world=before_world,
after_world=after_world,
renderer=renderer,
)
except Exception as exc:
errors.append(f"render replay failed: {exc}")
else:
if replay[0] != image_path.read_bytes():
errors.append("image replay bytes differ")
if replay[1] != required_files["node_map"].read_bytes():
errors.append("node-map replay bytes differ")
if replay[2] != manifest:
errors.append("render-manifest replay differs")
if replay[3] != text_manifest:
errors.append("text-manifest replay differs")
expected_diff = raster_diff_mask_png(full_replay[0], replay[0])
if expected_diff != required_files["diff_mask"].read_bytes():
errors.append("diff-mask replay bytes differ")
dependency_ids = certificate.get("program", {}).get("dependency_node_ids")
try:
if source == "gqa":
expected_evidence = gqa_evidence_mask_png(
before_world,
dependency_ids if isinstance(dependency_ids, list) else (),
)
else:
expected_evidence = evidence_mask_from_node_map(
full_replay[1],
full_replay[2]["node_table"],
dependency_ids if isinstance(dependency_ids, list) else (),
)
except Exception as exc:
errors.append(f"evidence replay failed: {exc}")
else:
if expected_evidence != required_files["evidence_mask"].read_bytes():
errors.append("evidence-mask replay bytes differ")
_verify_state_proof(
certificate,
before_result=before,
after_result=after,
errors=errors,
)
if certificate.get("proof", {}).get("state") == "U_MISSING":
_replay_completions(
source,
root=root,
program=program,
executor=executor,
renderer=renderer,
certificate=certificate,
errors=errors,
)
return ReplayResult(str(root), not errors, tuple(errors))
def _restore_program_and_executor(
source: str,
record: Mapping[str, Any],
before_world: World,
) -> tuple[Any, Any]:
if source == "gqa":
from ..executors.gqa import GQASemanticExecutor, compile_gqa_program
gqa_program = compile_gqa_program(
str(record["question_id"]),
{
"imageId": record["image_id"],
"semantic": record["semantic"],
"semanticStr": record.get("semantic_str", ""),
},
)
return gqa_program, GQASemanticExecutor()
from ..executors.clevr import ClevrExecutor
clevr_program = program_from_dict(record)
if canonical_program_sha256(clevr_program, world=before_world) != (
record.get("canonical_program_sha256")
):
raise CoreCertificateError("persisted CLEVR program identity mismatch")
return clevr_program, ClevrExecutor()
def _rerender(
source: str,
*,
root: Path,
before_world: World,
after_world: World,
renderer: Mapping[str, Any],
) -> tuple[
tuple[bytes, bytes, dict[str, Any], dict[str, Any]],
tuple[bytes, bytes, dict[str, Any], dict[str, Any]],
]:
seed = int(renderer["seed"])
if source == "gqa":
source_bytes = (root / "source.jpg").read_bytes()
masked = renderer.get("masked_node_id")
observed = render_gqa_observation(
source_bytes,
after_world,
masked_node_id=str(masked) if masked is not None else None,
seed=seed,
)
full = render_gqa_observation(
source_bytes,
before_world,
masked_node_id=None,
seed=seed,
)
return (
(
observed.image_jpeg,
observed.node_map_png,
observed.render_manifest,
observed.text_manifest,
),
(
full.image_jpeg,
full.node_map_png,
full.render_manifest,
full.text_manifest,
),
)
manifest_width = int(_load(root / "render_manifest.json")["width"])
manifest_height = int(_load(root / "render_manifest.json")["height"])
observed_assets = render(
after_world,
renderer_id=str(renderer["name"]),
seed=seed,
width=manifest_width,
height=manifest_height,
)
full_assets = render(
before_world,
renderer_id=str(renderer["name"]),
seed=seed,
width=manifest_width,
height=manifest_height,
)
return _assets_tuple(observed_assets), _assets_tuple(full_assets)
def _assets_tuple(
assets: RenderedAssets,
) -> tuple[bytes, bytes, dict[str, Any], dict[str, Any]]:
return (
assets.rgba_png,
assets.node_map_png,
assets.render_manifest,
assets.text_manifest,
)
def _replay_completions(
source: str,
*,
root: Path,
program: Any,
executor: Any,
renderer: Mapping[str, Any],
certificate: Mapping[str, Any],
errors: list[str],
) -> None:
completion = certificate.get("proof", {}).get("completion")
if not isinstance(completion, Mapping):
errors.append("missing-information completion proof absent")
return
observed: list[str] = []
answers: list[Any] = []
for label in ("a", "b"):
path = root / f"completion_{label}.json"
try:
world = _load(path)
except (OSError, ValueError) as exc:
errors.append(f"completion {label} load failed: {exc}")
continue
if world_sha256(world) != completion.get(f"world_{label}_sha256"):
errors.append(f"completion {label} world hash mismatch")
result = executor.execute(program, world=world)
answers.append(result.answer_canonical)
if result.status != "UNIQUE":
errors.append(f"completion {label} is not uniquely answerable")
if result.answer_canonical != completion.get(f"answer_{label}"):
errors.append(f"completion {label} answer mismatch")
try:
if source == "gqa":
masked = renderer.get("masked_node_id")
gqa_assets = render_gqa_observation(
(root / "source.jpg").read_bytes(),
world,
masked_node_id=str(masked) if masked is not None else None,
seed=int(renderer["seed"]),
)
observed.append(gqa_assets.image_sha256)
else:
manifest = _load(root / "render_manifest.json")
clevr_assets = render(
world,
renderer_id=str(renderer["name"]),
seed=int(renderer["seed"]),
width=int(manifest["width"]),
height=int(manifest["height"]),
)
observed.append(clevr_assets.rgba_sha256)
except Exception as exc:
errors.append(f"completion {label} render failed: {exc}")
if len(answers) == 2 and answers[0] == answers[1]:
errors.append("completion answers do not differ")
if len(observed) == 2:
if observed[0] != observed[1]:
errors.append("completion observations differ")
expected = completion.get("observed_image_sha256")
if observed[0] != expected:
errors.append("completion observed-image hash mismatch")
def _validate_state(
state: CoreState,
*,
before_result: ExecutionResult,
after_result: ExecutionResult,
completion_proof: Mapping[str, Any] | None,
) -> None:
if state == "FULL":
if not after_result.is_unique or after_result.answer_canonical != (
before_result.answer_canonical
):
raise CoreCertificateError("FULL requires the original unique answer")
elif state == "A_SAME":
if not after_result.is_unique or after_result.answer_canonical != (
before_result.answer_canonical
):
raise CoreCertificateError("A_SAME requires equal unique answers")
elif state == "A_CHANGED":
if not after_result.is_unique or after_result.answer_canonical == (
before_result.answer_canonical
):
raise CoreCertificateError("A_CHANGED requires a distinct unique answer")
elif state == "U_MISSING":
if after_result.status != "MISSING_INFORMATION":
raise CoreCertificateError("U_MISSING requires MISSING_INFORMATION")
if not isinstance(completion_proof, Mapping):
raise CoreCertificateError("U_MISSING requires completion witnesses")
if completion_proof.get("answer_a") == completion_proof.get("answer_b"):
raise CoreCertificateError("completion witness answers must differ")
else:
raise CoreCertificateError(f"unsupported core state {state!r}")
def _verify_state_proof(
certificate: Mapping[str, Any],
*,
before_result: ExecutionResult,
after_result: ExecutionResult,
errors: list[str],
) -> None:
state = certificate.get("proof", {}).get("state")
try:
_validate_state(
state,
before_result=before_result,
after_result=after_result,
completion_proof=certificate.get("proof", {}).get("completion"),
)
except (CoreCertificateError, TypeError) as exc:
errors.append(f"state proof mismatch: {exc}")
def _load(path: Path) -> dict[str, Any]:
value = json.loads(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))
if not isinstance(value, dict):
raise ValueError(f"{path} must contain an object")
return value
__all__ = [
"CORE_CERTIFICATE_CONTRACT",
"CoreCertificateError",
"build_core_certificate",
"evidence_mask_from_node_map",
"execution_record",
"is_core_certificate",
"replay_core_view",
]