sungguk's picture
Release visual answerability benchmark v1.0.0
e1ced61 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
13.2 kB
"""Controlled-arm input/target planning and deterministic answer rewards."""
from __future__ import annotations
import math
from collections.abc import Mapping
from dataclasses import dataclass, replace
from typing import Any, Literal
from .answers import NormalizationError, answers_equal, normalize_answer, parse_answer
from .slots import ComparisonSlot
from .targets import (
answerable_only_target,
defacto_target,
no_recompute_target,
ours_target,
target_text,
)
Arm = Literal[
"answer_grpo",
"papo_controlled",
"defacto_controlled",
"intervention_grpo",
"evi_po",
# Ablation arms (ingredient-isolation suite; not part of the five method
# arms, so they are excluded from ALL_ARMS. GPU admission is separately
# defined by GPU_SMOKE_ARMS below).
"evi_po_no_direction",
"evi_po_no_evidence",
"evi_po_margin_wide",
"intervention_answerable_only",
"intervention_no_recompute",
"papo_relaxed_guard",
"papo_mask_low",
"papo_mask_high",
]
ALL_ARMS: tuple[Arm, ...] = (
"answer_grpo",
"papo_controlled",
"defacto_controlled",
"intervention_grpo",
"evi_po",
)
# One real GPU smoke per trainer implementation. Answer-GRPO and DeFacto use
# the exact same aligned GRPO trainer as Intervention-GRPO; their different
# target functions are covered by CPU contracts and do not justify duplicate
# GPU jobs.
GPU_SMOKE_ARMS: tuple[Arm, ...] = (
"intervention_grpo",
"papo_controlled",
"evi_po",
)
# Supported opt-in ingredient-isolation arms. D and J collapse to one run
# (intervention_no_recompute): "intervention
# minus recompute" is identical to "DeFacto plus certificate-derived abstention,
# no recompute" given the same selected_view input and GRPO trainer; F is a
# two-point mask sweep (0.3 / 0.9), which supplies the eighth slot.
ABLATION_ARMS: tuple[Arm, ...] = (
"evi_po_no_direction", # A: leave direction loss out
"evi_po_no_evidence", # B: leave evidence loss out
"intervention_answerable_only", # C: drop abstention (U_* -> full)
"intervention_no_recompute", # D = J: drop recompute (A_CHANGED -> maintain)
"papo_relaxed_guard", # E: perception weight > collapse_guard
"papo_mask_low", # F: mask_ratio = 0.3
"papo_mask_high", # F: mask_ratio = 0.9
"evi_po_margin_wide", # K: direction margin = 1.0
)
# Only these two causal ingredient removals are part of the automatic core
# queue. The remaining exploratory sweeps stay supported by the planner but
# are not allowed to consume eight full main-run budgets before the core result
# is known.
CORE_ABLATION_ARMS: tuple[Arm, ...] = (
"evi_po_no_direction",
"evi_po_no_evidence",
)
# Numeric knobs for the ablation arms, as a single code-defined source of truth
# (version-controlled via code_commit, not a free YAML parameter). plan_arm reads
# it for ArmPlan metadata; the CLI runtime builder reads it to override the
# frozen evi_po_config / papo_config so the trainer sees the same values.
# Arms absent here (C, D) are pure target-function variants with no numeric knob.
ABLATION_ARM_KNOBS: dict[Arm, dict[str, float]] = {
"evi_po_no_direction": {"lambda_direction": 0.0, "lambda_evidence": 0.1, "margin": 0.5},
"evi_po_no_evidence": {"lambda_direction": 0.1, "lambda_evidence": 0.0, "margin": 0.5},
"evi_po_margin_wide": {"lambda_direction": 0.1, "lambda_evidence": 0.1, "margin": 1.0},
"papo_relaxed_guard": {"mask_ratio": 0.6, "perception_loss_weight": 0.05},
"papo_mask_low": {"mask_ratio": 0.3, "perception_loss_weight": 0.02},
"papo_mask_high": {"mask_ratio": 0.9, "perception_loss_weight": 0.02},
}
LEGACY_ARM_ALIASES: dict[str, Arm] = {"ours": "intervention_grpo"}
def canonical_arm(arm: str) -> Arm:
"""Map the pre-EVI public name to its unambiguous canonical ablation name."""
value = LEGACY_ARM_ALIASES.get(arm, arm)
if value in ALL_ARMS or value in ABLATION_ARMS:
return value
raise ValueError(f"unknown arm: {arm!r}")
def arm_trainer_kind(arm: Arm | str) -> Literal["papo", "evi_po", "grpo"]:
"""Map an RL arm to its trainer kind: ``"papo"``, ``"evi_po"``, or ``"grpo"``.
Single source of truth shared by the matrix planner (which selects the
trainer) and the runtime-config guard (which checks the arm/trainer pair).
"""
arm = canonical_arm(arm)
if arm in {"papo_controlled", "papo_relaxed_guard", "papo_mask_low", "papo_mask_high"}:
return "papo"
if arm in {"evi_po", "evi_po_no_direction", "evi_po_no_evidence", "evi_po_margin_wide"}:
return "evi_po"
return "grpo"
def smoke_reference_arm(arm: Arm | str) -> Arm:
"""Return the tested parent implementation for a main or ablation arm."""
canonical = canonical_arm(arm)
if canonical in {"evi_po_no_direction", "evi_po_no_evidence", "evi_po_margin_wide"}:
return "evi_po"
if canonical in {"papo_relaxed_guard", "papo_mask_low", "papo_mask_high"}:
return "papo_controlled"
if canonical in {"intervention_answerable_only", "intervention_no_recompute"}:
return "intervention_grpo"
if canonical in {"answer_grpo", "defacto_controlled"}:
return "intervention_grpo"
return canonical
@dataclass(frozen=True)
class RewardWeights:
answer: float = 1.0
format: float = 0.0
invalid_format_penalty: float = -1.0
def __post_init__(self) -> None:
if not all(math.isfinite(value) for value in (self.answer, self.format)):
raise ValueError("reward weights must be finite")
if not math.isfinite(self.invalid_format_penalty):
raise ValueError("invalid-format penalty must be finite")
if self.answer < 0 or self.format < 0:
raise ValueError("answer and format weights must be non-negative")
if self.invalid_format_penalty > 0:
raise ValueError("invalid-format penalty must be non-positive")
@dataclass(frozen=True)
class ArmPlan:
arm: Arm
slot_id: str
group_id: str
base_id: str
comparison_role: str
input_view_id: str
input_state: str
gold_target: str
answer_type: str
choices: tuple[dict[str, Any], ...]
visual_mask_ratio: float | None = None
perception_coefficient: float | None = None
reference_kl_coefficient: float | None = None
use_aug_entropy_loss: bool = False
use_ori_entropy_loss: bool = False
@dataclass(frozen=True)
class RewardTrace:
arm: Arm
slot_id: str
parser_valid: bool
parser_error: str | None
parsed_answer: str | None
normalized_prediction: str | None
normalized_gold: str
answer_component: float
format_component: float
total_reward: float
normalizer_branch: str
def _full_plan(slot: ComparisonSlot, arm: Arm) -> ArmPlan:
return ArmPlan(
arm=arm,
slot_id=slot.slot_id,
group_id=slot.group_id,
base_id=slot.base_id,
comparison_role=slot.comparison_role,
input_view_id=str(slot.full_view["view_id"]),
input_state="FULL",
gold_target=target_text(slot.full_answer),
answer_type=slot.answer_type,
choices=slot.choices,
)
def plan_arm(slot: ComparisonSlot, arm: Arm | str) -> ArmPlan:
"""Plan the observed view and gold target for one controlled arm."""
arm = canonical_arm(arm)
if arm == "answer_grpo":
return _full_plan(slot, arm)
if arm == "papo_controlled":
plan = _full_plan(slot, arm)
return replace(
plan,
visual_mask_ratio=0.6,
perception_coefficient=0.02,
reference_kl_coefficient=0.01,
use_aug_entropy_loss=False,
use_ori_entropy_loss=False,
)
if arm in {"papo_relaxed_guard", "papo_mask_low", "papo_mask_high"}:
knobs = ABLATION_ARM_KNOBS[arm]
plan = _full_plan(slot, arm)
return replace(
plan,
visual_mask_ratio=knobs["mask_ratio"],
perception_coefficient=knobs["perception_loss_weight"],
reference_kl_coefficient=0.01,
use_aug_entropy_loss=False,
use_ori_entropy_loss=False,
)
if arm == "defacto_controlled":
target = defacto_target(slot.comparison_role, slot.full_answer)
elif arm in {"intervention_grpo", "evi_po"} or arm in {
"evi_po_no_direction",
"evi_po_no_evidence",
"evi_po_margin_wide",
}:
target = ours_target(slot.selected_view, slot.full_answer)
elif arm == "intervention_answerable_only":
target = answerable_only_target(slot.selected_view, slot.full_answer)
elif arm == "intervention_no_recompute":
target = no_recompute_target(slot.selected_view, slot.full_answer)
return ArmPlan(
arm=arm,
slot_id=slot.slot_id,
group_id=slot.group_id,
base_id=slot.base_id,
comparison_role=slot.comparison_role,
input_view_id=str(slot.selected_view["view_id"]),
input_state=str(slot.selected_view["state"]),
gold_target=target,
answer_type=slot.answer_type,
choices=slot.choices,
)
def plan_all_arms(slot: ComparisonSlot) -> tuple[ArmPlan, ...]:
plans = tuple(plan_arm(slot, arm) for arm in ALL_ARMS)
if {plan.slot_id for plan in plans} != {slot.slot_id}:
raise AssertionError("controlled-arm planning drifted from the common slot")
return plans
# Compatibility name for callers written before EVI-PO added a fifth arm. It
# intentionally returns the current complete arm tuple.
plan_four_arms = plan_all_arms
def score_completion(
plan: ArmPlan,
completion: str,
*,
weights: RewardWeights | None = None,
) -> RewardTrace:
"""Score one completion; parser exceptions never become silent zeroes."""
weights = weights or RewardWeights()
parsed = parse_answer(completion)
try:
normalized_gold = normalize_answer(
plan.gold_target,
plan.answer_type,
choices=plan.choices,
)
except NormalizationError as exc:
raise ValueError(f"invalid gold target for slot {plan.slot_id}: {exc}") from exc
if not parsed.valid:
return RewardTrace(
arm=plan.arm,
slot_id=plan.slot_id,
parser_valid=False,
parser_error=parsed.error,
parsed_answer=None,
normalized_prediction=None,
normalized_gold=normalized_gold,
answer_component=0.0,
format_component=0.0,
total_reward=weights.invalid_format_penalty,
normalizer_branch="parser_reject",
)
content = parsed.require_content()
try:
normalized_prediction = normalize_answer(
content,
plan.answer_type,
choices=plan.choices,
)
normalizer_branch = plan.answer_type
except NormalizationError:
normalized_prediction = None
normalizer_branch = f"{plan.answer_type}_invalid"
correct = answers_equal(
content,
plan.gold_target,
plan.answer_type,
choices=plan.choices,
)
answer_component = 1.0 if correct else 0.0
format_component = 1.0
total = weights.answer * answer_component + weights.format * format_component
if not math.isfinite(total):
raise ValueError("non-finite reward")
return RewardTrace(
arm=plan.arm,
slot_id=plan.slot_id,
parser_valid=True,
parser_error=None,
parsed_answer=content,
normalized_prediction=normalized_prediction,
normalized_gold=normalized_gold,
answer_component=answer_component,
format_component=format_component,
total_reward=total,
normalizer_branch=normalizer_branch,
)
def plans_share_fairness_key(plans: Mapping[Arm, ArmPlan]) -> bool:
"""Check the immutable schedule fields and method-specific input pairing."""
if set(plans) != set(ALL_ARMS):
return False
if any(plan.arm != arm for arm, plan in plans.items()):
return False
values = tuple(plans.values())
common_identities = {
(
plan.slot_id,
plan.group_id,
plan.base_id,
plan.comparison_role,
plan.answer_type,
)
for plan in values
}
if len(common_identities) != 1:
return False
if any(plan.choices != values[0].choices for plan in values[1:]):
return False
answer = plans["answer_grpo"]
papo = plans["papo_controlled"]
defacto = plans["defacto_controlled"]
intervention = plans["intervention_grpo"]
evi_po = plans["evi_po"]
return (
answer.input_view_id == papo.input_view_id
and answer.input_state == papo.input_state == "FULL"
and answer.gold_target == papo.gold_target
and defacto.input_view_id == intervention.input_view_id == evi_po.input_view_id
and defacto.input_state == intervention.input_state == evi_po.input_state
and intervention.gold_target == evi_po.gold_target
)