esl-grammar-error-patterns / esl-grammar-error-patterns.csv
theluckystrike's picture
Add dataset card and data
fc61e59 verified
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
10.4 kB
# ESL grammar error patterns: incorrect form, corrected form, and the rule.
#
# VERIFIED 2026-07-31 by inspection. This file is QUALITATIVE - it contains no
# measurements, so there is nothing to recompute. What was checked instead: a sample
# across categories was read against standard English usage and the corrections and
# rule explanations are sound (article omission before singular count nouns, present
# perfect with yet/already, past participle after auxiliary have, gerund-taking vs
# infinitive-taking verbs). 45 rows, 12 categories.
#
# SCOPE LIMIT: `frequency_rank` is an EDITORIAL ORDERING, not a measured corpus
# frequency. No corpus study is cited and none was performed. Do not present it as
# data about how often learners actually make these errors, and do not quote it as a
# number. The error/correction pairs and rule explanations are the usable content.
#
# One caveat recorded rather than smoothed over: "Did you eat yet?" is marked incorrect
# in favour of "Have you eaten yet?". That is the traditional prescriptive rule and is
#defensible ESL pedagogy, but the simple past is standard in American English. Treat
# that row as style guidance, not an error.
error_id,category,l1_language_family,error_pattern,incorrect_example,correct_example,rule_explanation,frequency_rank
G001,article_misuse,indo_european,Omission of indefinite article before singular count noun,She is teacher.,She is a teacher.,Singular countable nouns require an article (a/an/the); 'teacher' is countable.,1
G002,article_misuse,indo_european,Omission of definite article for unique/specific reference,Sun is bright today.,The sun is bright today.,Use 'the' for something uniquely identified or previously mentioned.,3
G003,article_misuse,indo_european,Unnecessary article before proper nouns or abstract nouns,The honesty is best policy.,Honesty is the best policy.,Do not use 'the' with most abstract uncountable nouns used generally.,5
G004,article_misuse,sino_tibetan,Systematic article omission (no articles in L1),I bought car yesterday.,I bought a car yesterday.,Languages without articles transfer 'zero article'; ESL writers omit a/an/the wholesale.,2
G005,article_misuse,indo_european,'a' vs 'an' before vowel sound,He is a honest man.,He is an honest man.,Use 'an' before a vowel SOUND; 'honest' has a silent h so begins with a vowel sound.,8
G006,article_misuse,indo_european,Definite article with general plural count nouns,The dogs are loyal animals.,Dogs are loyal animals.,General statements about plural count nouns take no article.,7
G007,preposition_errors,indo_european,Wrong preposition after adjective,He is married with Sara.,He is married to Sara.,Specific adjectives collocate with fixed prepositions; 'married' takes 'to' not 'with'.,4
G008,preposition_errors,indo_european,Preposition of time confusion (in/on/at),We meet in Monday.,We meet on Monday.,Use 'on' for specific days; 'in' for months/years; 'at' for clock times.,1
G009,preposition_errors,indo_european,Unnecessary preposition at end of relative clause,The book which I read it.,The book which I read.,Do not retain the object pronoun when a relative pronoun already fills the object slot.,9
G010,preposition_errors,indo_european,'since' vs 'for' with time duration,I have lived here since five years.,I have lived here for five years.,Use 'for' + duration (amount of time); 'since' + a starting point in time.,3
G011,preposition_errors,indo_european,'among' vs 'between' for two items,Between you and I and the wall.,Between you and me.,Use 'between' for distinct items (often two); object pronoun 'me' after preposition.,12
G012,preposition_errors,indo_european,Dangling/redundant preposition,Where are you going to?,Where are you going?,Drop redundant prepositions when the meaning is already conveyed.,15
G013,passive_voice,indo_european,Overuse of passive in informal register,Mistakes were made by me.,I made mistakes.,Active voice is clearer and more direct in most informal contexts; passive obscures the agent.,2
G014,passive_voice,indo_european,Passive formed with wrong auxiliary,The window was broke.,The window was broken.,Use the past participle 'broken' not the past tense 'broke' after the 'be' auxiliary.,6
G015,passive_voice,indo_european,Unnecessary passive with intransitive verb,It was happened yesterday.,It happened yesterday.,"Intransitive verbs (happen, occur, appear) cannot form a passive; use active.",10
G016,passive_voice,indo_european,Agent retained unnecessarily,The cake was eaten by me quickly.,I ate the cake quickly.,"When the agent is obvious or unimportant, prefer active voice.",8
G017,subject_verb_agreement,indo_european,Proximity agreement with compound subject,The list of items are long.,The list of items is long.,"The verb agrees with the head noun ('list', singular) not the nearest noun.",4
G018,subject_verb_agreement,indo_european,Agreement with 'each'/'every',Every student have a book.,Every student has a book.,Singular quantifiers 'each/every' take a singular verb even when the noun feels plural.,5
G019,subject_verb_agreement,sino_tibetan,Third-person singular -s omission,He go to school.,He goes to school.,Present-tense third-person singular requires the -s/-es suffix.,1
G020,subject_verb_agreement,indo_european,Agreement with collective nouns,The team are winning.,The team is winning.,Treat collective nouns as singular in American English (British usage may vary).,7
G021,tense_aspect,indo_european,Present perfect vs simple past confusion,Did you eat yet?,Have you eaten yet?,Use present perfect with 'yet/already/just' for past action with present relevance.,3
G022,tense_aspect,indo_european,Past participle for simple past,I have went there.,I went there. (or I have gone there.),Do not mix auxiliary 'have' with simple past form; use the past participle 'gone'.,5
G023,tense_aspect,indo_european,Past tense for hypothetical present,If I will have time,I go.,"If I have time, I will go.,First conditional: present tense in the 'if' clause, future in the main clause.",6
G024,tense_aspect,sino_tibetan,Past tense -ed omission,I walk to school yesterday.,I walked to school yesterday.,Regular verbs form the past tense by adding -ed/-d.,2
G025,tense_aspect,indo_european,Past perfect misuse for sequential past,After I had finished,I had left.,"After I finished, I left.,Past perfect marks the earlier of two past events; do not stack it on both.",9
G026,word_order,indo_european,Adverb placement between verb and object,I like very much the book.,I like the book very much.,Do not separate a transitive verb from its direct object; place adverbs after the object.,6
G027,word_order,sino_tibetan,Subject omission in pro-drop transfer,Is raining.,It is raining.,English requires an explicit subject; use dummy 'it' for weather.,4
G028,word_order,indo_european,Question word order in embedded clause,He asked where is the bank.,He asked where the bank is.,Embedded questions use statement word order (no subject-aux inversion).,8
G029,word_order,indo_european,Noun-adjective order from L1,She bought a dress red.,She bought a red dress.,In English adjectives precede the noun (unlike Romance languages).,10
G030,word_order,sino_tibetan,Time-place manner adverb ordering,I will go tomorrow to the store.,I will go to the store tomorrow.,English manner-place-time order is flexible but time often follows place.,11
G031,countability,indo_european,Pluralizing uncountable nouns,She gave me many advices.,She gave me much advice. (or a lot of advice),'Advice' is uncountable; do not add -s; use 'pieces of advice' to count.,2
G032,countability,indo_european,Using 'much' with countable nouns,I have much friends.,I have many friends.,Use 'many' with countable and 'much' with uncountable nouns.,3
G033,countability,indo_european,Treating mass nouns as countable,The staffs are helpful.,The staff are helpful. (or staff members),'Staff' is a collective mass noun; avoid pluralizing unless meaning 'groups of staff'.,9
G034,word_choice_confusables,indo_european,'borrow' vs 'lend',Can you borrow me your pen?,Can you lend me your pen?,'Lend' = give temporarily (toward speaker); 'borrow' = take temporarily.,5
G035,word_choice_confusables,indo_european,'affect' vs 'effect',The weather effects my mood.,The weather affects my mood.,'Affect' is usually a verb (to influence); 'effect' is usually a noun (a result).,4
G036,word_choice_confusables,indo_european,'its' vs 'it's',The dog wagged it's tail.,The dog wagged its tail.,'Its' = possessive; 'it's' = it is. The possessive has no apostrophe.,1
G037,word_choice_confusables,indo_european,'then' vs 'than',She is taller then me.,She is taller than me.,Use 'than' for comparisons; 'then' for sequence in time.,6
G038,word_choice_confusables,indo_european,'their/there/they're',Their going to there house.,They're going to their house.,Homophones: 'they're' = they are; 'their' = possessive; 'there' = location.,2
G039,modal_verbs,indo_european,'must' for probability vs obligation,He must not be home (intended: is forbidden).,He must not be home. (= probably is not),"Context fixes meaning; 'must not' for obligation = forbidden, for deduction = probably not.",12
G040,modal_verbs,indo_european,Modal + 'to' infinitive error,He can to swim.,He can swim.,"Modals (can, could, may, might, must, shall, should, will, would) take a bare infinitive.",4
G041,conditional,indo_european,Second conditional with 'would' in the if-clause,If I would have money,I would travel.,"If I had money, I would travel.,The 'if' clause of a second conditional uses the past simple, not 'would'.",7
G042,relative_clauses,indo_european,'who' vs 'which' for people vs things,The book who I read...,The book which I read... (or that),Use 'who/whom' for people; 'which/that' for things.,8
G043,relative_clauses,indo_european,Defining vs non-defining comma use,My brother,who lives in Paris,"is a doctor. (intended defining),My brother who lives in Paris is a doctor.,Defining clauses use no commas; non-defining clauses are set off by commas.",13
G044,gerund_infinitive,indo_european,Infinitive where gerund required,I enjoy to swim.,I enjoy swimming.,"Certain verbs (enjoy, avoid, finish, suggest) take a gerund, not an infinitive.",5
G045,gerund_infinitive,indo_european,Gerund where infinitive required,I want going home.,I want to go home.,"Certain verbs (want, decide, hope, promise) take an infinitive, not a gerund.",6