Datasets:
Formats:
parquet
Languages:
English
Size:
10K - 100K
Tags:
agriculture
plant-disease
crop-disease
vision-language-model
retrieval-augmented-generation
memory
License:
File size: 29,192 Bytes
c8e03af | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444 | """Results-first tables for the MACE paper: every traceable measured value is filled in; every other cell is marked.
python -m mace10.paper writes <paper>/tables/t{1..4}_*.tex, <paper>/numbers_mace10.tex,
mace10/out/table_cells.csv (cell -> status, n, source) and RESULTS_FIRST_DRAFT.md
Cell status (rendered in the PDF):
value measured on this protocol (source recorded per cell)
NR NEEDS RUN (incremental calls and USD from the dry run listed in the caption and table_specs.yaml)
NA NOT APPLICABLE
pilot panel PILOT / DIFFERENT PROTOCOL (soybean, seed 0, runs 0-4, 5 images per disease and run); never merged
into ten-crop rows
Intervals: 95% bootstrap over unique query images, stratified by crop (2,000 resamples, seed 0); equal-crop means.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import json
from pathlib import Path
import numpy as np
import pandas as pd
HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent; OUT = HERE / "out"; LOCK = HERE / "locked"
PAPER = HERE / "paper_src" # editable multi-file source; mace10/build_submission.py writes the single-file Overleaf paper
PILOT = HERE.parent / "runs"
NR = "\\nr{}"; NA = "\\na{}"
cells: list[dict] = []; mac: dict[str, str] = {}
RNG = np.random.default_rng(0); B = 2000
def cell(table, row, col, value=None, status="measured", n=None, source=""):
cells.append({"table": table, "row": row, "col": col, "status": status, "value": value, "n": n, "source": source})
return value if status == "measured" else NR if status == "needs_run" else NA
def eqcrop_ci(df, col):
"""Equal-crop mean accuracy (%) and stratified bootstrap 95% CI over unique images."""
groups = [g[col].to_numpy(float) for _, g in df.groupby("crop")]
est = np.mean([g.mean() for g in groups]) * 100
bs = [np.mean([RNG.choice(g, len(g)).mean() for g in groups]) * 100 for _ in range(B)]
return est, np.percentile(bs, 2.5), np.percentile(bs, 97.5)
def fmt(e, lo=None, hi=None):
return f"{e:.1f}" if lo is None else f"{e:.1f} {{\\tiny[{lo:.1f}, {hi:.1f}]}}"
RES: dict = {}
def minus(t):
"""True minus signs for negative numbers in generated text."""
import re
return re.sub(r"(?<![\w.])-(?=\d)", "$-$", t)
METHOD_MACRO = {"sage": "Sage", "majority": "Maj", "wvote": "Vote", "clip_s0": "Clip", "dino_s0": "Dino", "mace": "Mace", "mace_K1": "MaceKone", "mace_K16": "MaceKsixteen",
"labels": "Labels", "labels_all": "LabelsAll", "dino_labels": "DinoLabels", "masked": "Masked", "shuffled": "Shuffled", "random": "Random", "same_source": "SameSrc", "other_source": "OtherSrc", "agentic": "Agentic", "imageref": "ImageRef"}
def acc(panel, sp, m, interval=True, key="acc"):
"""Measured value as text, or the NEEDS RUN mark when the package has not produced it."""
d = RES.get("accuracy", {}).get(panel, {}).get(sp, {}).get(m)
if d is None:
return NR
return fmt(d[key], *d["ci"]) if interval and key == "acc" else fmt(d[key])
def macros_from_results():
for panel, tag in (("hero", "Hero"), ("ablation", "Abl"), ("efficiency", "Eff"), ("source", "Src")):
for sp, d in RES["accuracy"][panel].items():
for m, v in d.items():
if m in METHOD_MACRO:
mac[f"tc{tag}{METHOD_MACRO[m]}{sp.upper()}"] = f"{v['acc']:.1f}"
words = {"mace_minus_sage": "MaceSage", "mace_minus_dino": "MaceDino", "labels_minus_mace": "LabelsMace", "masked_minus_labels": "MaskedLabels", "mace_minus_masked": "MaceMasked",
"mace_minus_shuffled": "MaceShuffled", "mace_minus_random": "MaceRandom", "same_minus_other": "SameOther", "imageref_minus_mace": "ImageRefMace", "agentic_minus_mace": "AgenticMace"}
for k, v in RES["contrasts"].items():
name, sp = k.rsplit("_", 1); w = "tcD" + words[name] + sp.upper()
mac[w] = f"{v['est']:+.1f}"; mac[w + "lo"] = f"{v['ci'][0]:+.1f}"; mac[w + "hi"] = f"{v['ci'][1]:+.1f}"
if "p_holm" in v:
mac[w + "p"] = "<0.001" if v["p_holm"] < 0.001 else f"{v['p_holm']:.3f}"
for k, v in RES.get("amendment", {}).items():
if k == "hit_rates":
for sp, h in v.items():
mac[f"tcHitBm{sp.upper()}"] = f"{h['bm25']:.1f}"; mac[f"tcHitDino{sp.upper()}"] = f"{h['dino']:.1f}"
continue
name, sp = k.rsplit("_", 1); w = "tcA" + {"labels_all_minus_mace": "LabelsMace", "dino_labels_minus_labels_all": "DinoBm", "dino_labels_minus_dino": "DinoNN"}[name] + sp.upper()
mac[w] = f"{v['est']:+.1f}"; mac[w + "lo"] = f"{v['ci'][0]:+.1f}"; mac[w + "hi"] = f"{v['ci'][1]:+.1f}"
W = pd.read_csv(OUT / "results_wide.csv"); H = W[W.hero]; g = H.groupby(["crop", "split"])[["mace", "sage", "hit"]].mean().mul(100); g["gain"] = g.mace - g.sage
mac["tcHitR"] = f"{np.corrcoef(g.hit, g.gain)[0, 1]:.2f}"; pot = g.loc[("Potato", "ood")]; mac["tcPotatoHit"] = f"{pot.hit:.1f}"; mac["tcPotatoLoss"] = f"{-pot.gain:.1f}"
Lb = pd.read_csv(OUT / "local_baselines.csv"); Lb = Lb[(Lb.panel == "hero") & (Lb.seed == 0) & (Lb.K == 4)].groupby("crop").bank_size.mean()
mac["tcBankMean"] = f"{Lb.mean():.0f}"; mac["tcBankMin"] = f"{Lb.min():.0f}"; mac["tcBankMax"] = f"{Lb.max():.0f}"; mac["tcBankUsd"] = f"{Lb.mean() * 0.0043:.2f}" # 0.0043: measured USD per caption
for m, v in RES["efficiency"]["methods"].items():
mac[f"tcEff{METHOD_MACRO[m]}PerCorrect"] = f"{v['usd'] / (v['acc_all'] / 100):.3f}"
P1 = pd.DataFrame(map(json.loads, (OUT / "P1/predictions.jsonl").open())); Mq = P1[P1.condition == "mace"].copy(); Mq["sage"] = Mq.image_id.map(P1[P1.condition == "sage"].set_index("image_id").correct).astype(bool); Mq["correct"] = Mq.correct.astype(bool)
Mq["nt"] = [sum(l == r.label for l in r.memory_labels_shown) for r in Mq.itertuples()]
for sp, S_ in (("iid", "IID"), ("ood", "OOD")):
g_ = Mq[Mq.split == sp]; mac[f"tcFix{S_}"] = f"{100 * (g_.correct & ~g_.sage).mean():.1f}"; mac[f"tcBreak{S_}"] = f"{100 * (~g_.correct & g_.sage).mean():.1f}"
mac[f"tcDoseNone{S_}"] = f"{100 * g_[g_.nt == 0].correct.mean():.0f}"; mac[f"tcDoseAll{S_}"] = f"{100 * g_[g_.nt == 4].correct.mean():.0f}"; mac[f"tcDoseAllN{S_}"] = f"{(g_.nt == 4).sum()}"
E = RES["efficiency"]["methods"]; mac["tcEffGainPts"] = f"{E['mace']['acc_all'] - E['sage']['acc_all']:.1f}"; mac["tcEffGainUsd"] = f"{E['mace']['usd'] - E['sage']['usd']:.4f}"
for sp, S in (("iid", "IID"), ("ood", "OOD")):
h = RES["hit_miss"][sp]; ab = RES["accuracy"]["ablation"][sp]
mac[f"tcHitGain{S}"] = f"{h['hit']['mace'] - h['hit']['sage']:.1f}"; mac[f"tcMissLoss{S}"] = f"{h['miss']['sage'] - h['miss']['mace']:.1f}"
mac[f"tcLabelsVote{S}"] = f"{ab['labels']['acc'] - ab['majority']['acc']:.1f}"
mac[f"tcCapGain{S}"] = f"{-RES['amendment'][f'labels_all_minus_mace_{sp}']['est']:.1f}"
for sp, v in RES["hit_miss"].items():
S = sp.upper(); mac[f"tcHitRate{S}"] = f"{v['hit_rate']:.1f}"
for nm in ("hit", "miss"):
mac[f"tc{nm.title()}Mace{S}"] = f"{v[nm]['mace']:.1f}"; mac[f"tc{nm.title()}Sage{S}"] = f"{v[nm]['sage']:.1f}"; mac[f"tc{nm.title()}N{S}"] = f"{v[nm]['n']}"
for sp, v in RES["selection"].items():
S = sp.upper()
for m in ("mace", "clip", "dino"):
mac[f"tcSD{m.title()}{S}"] = f"{v[m]['sd']:.1f}"
for k, w in (("mean_minus_sage", "Sage"), ("mean_minus_dino", "Dino")):
mac[f"tcMean{w}{S}"] = f"{v[k]['est']:+.1f}"
for m, v in RES["efficiency"]["methods"].items():
w = METHOD_MACRO[m]; mac[f"tcEff{w}Acc"] = f"{v['acc_all']:.1f}"; mac[f"tcEff{w}Usd"] = f"{v['usd']:.3f}"; mac[f"tcEff{w}Sec"] = f"{v['latency_s']:.0f}"; mac[f"tcEff{w}Comp"] = f"{v['completion']:.1f}"
def dry():
D = pd.read_csv(OUT / "dryrun_packages.csv"); S = json.loads((OUT / "dryrun.json").read_text())
return D, S
def usd(D, pkg, cond=None):
d = D[(D.package == pkg) & ((D.condition == cond) if cond else True)]
return d.new_calls.sum(), d.projected_usd.sum()
def pilot():
P = pd.DataFrame(map(json.loads, (PILOT / "soybean_seed0_n5_pilot/predictions.jsonl").open()))
G = pd.DataFrame(map(json.loads, (PILOT / "soybean_seed0_n5_pilot_agentic/predictions.jsonl").open()))
bad = (G.caption_reads == 0) & (G.num_turns == 1) & (G.prediction == "UNKNOWN"); G = G[~bad]
return P, G
def t1(L, D):
"""Ten-crop hero. Panel A: equal-crop means per method. Panel B: per crop. Panel C: soybean pilot."""
h = L[(L.panel == "hero") & L.hero & (L.seed == 0) & (L.K == 4)]
rowsA = []
calls, cost = usd(D, "P1")
for name, m in (("SAGE (KB only)", "sage"), ("Retrieved-label majority", "majority"), ("Score-weighted label vote", "wvote"),
("OpenCLIP 1-NN", "clip_s0"), ("DINOv2 1-NN", "dino_s0"), ("Labels only$^\\dagger$", "labels_all"), ("DINOv2-retrieved labels$^\\dagger$", "dino_labels"),
("MACE retrieval ($K{=}4$)", "mace")):
out = [name]
for sp in ("iid", "ood"):
v = acc("hero", sp, m); out.append(cell("T1", name, sp, v, status="needs_run" if v == NR else "measured", n=int((h.split == sp).sum()), source="mace10/out/results.json"))
for sp in ("iid", "ood"):
v = acc("hero", sp, m, key="macro"); out.append(cell("T1", name, f"macro_{sp}", v, status="needs_run" if v == NR else "measured", source="mace10/out/results.json"))
rowsA.append(out)
if m in ("clip_s0", "dino_s0"):
for sp in ("iid", "ood"):
mac[f"hero{'Clip' if 'clip' in m else 'Dino'}{sp.upper()}"] = f"{RES['accuracy']['hero'][sp][m]['acc']:.1f}"
rowsB = []
for crop, g in h.groupby("crop", sort=False):
r = [crop]
for sp in ("iid", "ood"):
gg = g[g.split == sp]; c = RES.get("per_crop", {}).get(crop, {}).get(sp)
r += [str(len(gg)), f"{c['sage']:.1f}", f"{100 * gg.dino_correct.mean():.1f}", f"{c['mace']:.1f}", f"{c['mace'] - c['sage']:+.1f}"] if c else [str(len(gg)), NR, f"{100 * gg.dino_correct.mean():.1f}", NR, NR]
rowsB.append(r)
# pilot panel
P, G = pilot(); sage = P[P.condition == "sage"].set_index("image_id").correct
R = P[P.condition == "agmem"]; Lp = L[L.panel == "pilot"]
pv = []
for sp, spp in (("iid", "test_iid"), ("ood", "test_ood_in_scope")):
r4 = R[(R.K == 4) & (R.split == spp)]; lp = Lp[(Lp.K == 4) & (Lp.split == sp)]
maj = np.mean([bool(s) and pd.Series(s).value_counts().index[0] == l for l, s in zip(r4.label, r4.memory_labels_shown)]) * 100
def wvote(labs, rel):
sc = {}
for l_, w in zip(labs or [], rel or []):
sc[l_] = sc.get(l_, 0) + w
return max(sorted(sc), key=lambda k: sc[k]) if sc else None
wv = np.mean([wvote(s_, w_) == l for l, s_, w_ in zip(r4.label, r4.memory_labels_shown, r4.memory_relevance)]) * 100
pv.append((100 * r4.image_id.map(sage).mean(), maj, 100 * lp.clip_correct.mean(), 100 * lp.dino_correct.mean(), 100 * r4.correct.mean(), len(r4), wv))
mac[f"pilotDino{sp.upper()}"] = f"{100 * lp.dino_correct.mean():.1f}"
pilot_cols = {"SAGE (KB only)": 0, "Retrieved-label majority": 1, "Score-weighted label vote": 6, "OpenCLIP 1-NN": 2, "DINOv2 1-NN": 3, "MACE retrieval ($K{=}4$)": 4}
for r in rowsA:
i = pilot_cols.get(r[0])
r += [""] + ([f"{pv[0][i]:.1f}", f"{pv[1][i]:.1f}"] if i is not None else ["--", "--"])
body = "\n".join(" & ".join(r) + " \\\\" for r in rowsA)
crop_lines = "\n".join(" & ".join(r) + " \\\\" for r in rowsB)
n1, c1 = calls, cost
tex = rf"""\begin{{table*}}[t]
\centering\scriptsize\setlength{{\tabcolsep}}{{5pt}}
\caption{{\textbf{{Ten-crop results}} (primary memory selection: $K{{=}}4$ images per disease, four retrieved captions). Accuracy (\%), equal-crop mean over 10 crops ({int((h.split == 'iid').sum()):,} IID and {int((h.split == 'ood').sum()):,} held-out-collection queries) with a 95\% bootstrap interval over unique images, stratified by crop; macro: mean per-disease recall. Label votes and 1-NN use the exact memory bank MACE sees and call no model. $^\dagger$Post hoc, added after the 400-query labels-only control was read. Right: the earlier soybean pilot under a different protocol (5 runs, 5 images per disease and run; {pv[0][5]} IID and {pv[1][5]} held-out item-runs), not pooled with the ten-crop columns.}}
\label{{tab:hero}}
\begin{{tabular}}{{lccccc@{{\hspace{{10pt}}}}cc}}
\toprule
& \multicolumn{{4}}{{c}}{{Ten crops}} & & \multicolumn{{2}}{{c}}{{\pilottag{{}} soybean, different protocol}} \\
\cmidrule(lr){{2-5}}\cmidrule(lr){{7-8}}
Method & IID & Held-out & Macro IID & Macro held-out & & IID & Held-out \\
\midrule
{body.replace(" \\\\", " \\\\").replace(" & ", " & ", 0)}
\bottomrule
\end{{tabular}}
\end{{table*}}
"""
(PAPER / "tables/t1_hero.tex").write_text(tex)
crop_tex = ("% Panel B (per crop) for the supporting results\n\\begin{tabular}{lcccccccccc}\n\\toprule\n & \\multicolumn{5}{c}{IID} & \\multicolumn{5}{c}{Held-out}\\\\\n"
"Crop & $n$ & SAGE & DINOv2 & MACE & $\\Delta$ & $n$ & SAGE & DINOv2 & MACE & $\\Delta$ \\\\\n\\midrule\n" + crop_lines + "\n\\bottomrule\n\\end{tabular}\n")
(PAPER / "tables/t1b_per_crop.tex").write_text(crop_tex)
def macro_recall(df, key):
return 100 * df.groupby("label")[key].mean().mean()
CONTROLS = [("MACE (captions + labels)", "mace"), ("Labels only", "labels"), ("Captions only (masked)", "masked"), ("Shuffled labels", "shuffled"), ("Random references", "random")]
def delta(m):
"""Difference from MACE on the ablation panel, IID / held-out."""
A = RES.get("accuracy", {}).get("ablation", {})
if m == "mace" or m not in A.get("iid", {}):
return "--"
return " / ".join(f"{A[sp][m]['acc'] - A[sp]['mace']['acc']:+.1f}" for sp in ("iid", "ood"))
def t2(L, D):
a = L[(L.panel == "hero") & L.ablation & (L.seed == 0)]
c3, u3 = usd(D, "P3"); c4, u4 = usd(D, "P4")
rows = []
for K in (1, 4, 16):
r = [f"$K{{=}}{K}$"]
mk = "mace" if K == 4 else f"mace_K{K}"
r.append(f"{acc('ablation', 'iid', mk, False)} / {acc('ablation', 'ood', mk, False)}")
for sp in ("iid", "ood"):
g = a[(a.K == K) & (a.split == sp)]; e, lo, hi = eqcrop_ci(g, "dino_correct")
r.append(fmt(e)); mac[f"ablDinoK{ {1: 'one', 4: 'four', 16: 'sixteen'}[K]}{sp.upper()}"] = f"{e:.1f}"
rows.append(r)
P, G = pilot(); R = P[P.condition == "agmem"]; sage = P[P.condition == "sage"].set_index("image_id").correct
pil = []
for K in (1, 4, 16):
v = [100 * R[(R.K == K) & (R.split == s)].correct.mean() for s in ("test_iid", "test_ood_in_scope")]
pil.append(f"$K{{=}}{K}$ & {v[0]:.1f} / {v[1]:.1f} & & \\\\")
body_a = "\n".join(f"{r[0]} & {r[1]} & {r[2]} & {r[3]} \\\\" for r in rows)
body_b = "\n".join(f"{n_} & {acc('ablation', 'iid', m_, False)} & {acc('ablation', 'ood', m_, False)} & {delta(m_)} \\\\" for n_, m_ in CONTROLS)
tex = rf"""\begin{{table}}[t]
\centering\scriptsize\setlength{{\tabcolsep}}{{3pt}}
\caption{{\textbf{{What the gain is made of}} (400 nested queries, 40 per crop, 20 IID + 20 held-out, seed 0). Accuracy (\%), equal-crop mean. A: memory size, nested banks, always four retrieved captions; DINOv2 1-NN on the same banks for reference (measured, no model call). B: content controls at $K{{=}}4$ with identical queries, KB claims and candidates. $K{{=}}16$ banks hold fewer than 16 images for diseases with few training images.}}
\label{{tab:ablation}}
\begin{{tabular}}{{lccc}}
\toprule
\multicolumn{{4}}{{l}}{{\textit{{A. Memory size}}}} \\
Bank & MACE (IID / held-out) & DINOv2 IID & DINOv2 held-out \\
\midrule
{body_a}
\midrule
\multicolumn{{4}}{{l}}{{\textit{{B. Content controls, $K{{=}}4$}}}} \\
Evidence shown & IID & Held-out & $\Delta$ vs MACE \\
\midrule
{body_b}
\midrule
\multicolumn{{4}}{{l}}{{\textit{{\pilottag{{}} Soybean, different protocol: MACE (IID / held-out)}}}} \\
{chr(10).join(pil)}
\bottomrule
\end{{tabular}}
\end{{table}}
"""
(PAPER / "tables/t2_ablation.tex").write_text(tex)
def t3(L, D):
h = L[(L.panel == "hero") & L.hero & (L.K == 4)]
c2, u2 = usd(D, "P2"); c5, u5 = usd(D, "P5")
lines = []
for name, key in (("MACE retrieval", None), ("OpenCLIP 1-NN", "clip_correct"), ("DINOv2 1-NN", "dino_correct")):
r = [name]; vals = {"iid": [], "ood": []}
for s in (0, 1, 2):
for sp in ("iid", "ood"):
if key:
e, _, _ = eqcrop_ci(h[(h.seed == s) & (h.split == sp)], key); vals[sp].append(e); r.append(f"{e:.1f}")
else:
r.append(acc("hero", sp, "mace" if s == 0 else f"mace_s{s}", False))
for sp in ("iid", "ood"):
sel = RES.get("selection", {}).get(sp)
r.append(f"{np.std(vals[sp], ddof=1):.1f}" if key else f"{sel['mace']['sd']:.1f}" if sel else NR)
lines.append(" & ".join(r) + " \\\\")
if key:
mac[f"rel{'Clip' if 'clip' in key else 'Dino'}SD"] = f"{np.std(vals['iid'], ddof=1):.1f}"
# pilot hit/miss (measured, different protocol)
P, G = pilot(); sage = P[P.condition == "sage"].set_index("image_id").correct
R = P[(P.condition == "agmem") & (P.K == 4)].copy(); R["hit"] = [l in (s or []) for l, s in zip(R.label, R.memory_labels_shown)]
R["sage"] = R.image_id.map(sage).astype(bool)
pl = []
for sp, nm in (("test_iid", "IID"), ("test_ood_in_scope", "Held-out")):
g = R[R.split == sp]; hh, mm = g[g.hit], g[~g.hit]
pl.append(f"{nm} & {100 * g.hit.mean():.1f} & {100 * hh.correct.mean():.1f} / {100 * hh.sage.mean():.1f} & {100 * mm.correct.mean():.1f} / {100 * mm.sage.mean():.1f} \\\\")
hm = [f"Ten crops, {nm} & {v['hit_rate']:.1f} & {v['hit']['mace']:.1f} / {v['hit']['sage']:.1f} & {v['miss']['mace']:.1f} / {v['miss']['sage']:.1f} \\\\" for nm, v in
(("IID", RES["hit_miss"].get("iid")), ("held-out", RES["hit_miss"].get("ood"))) if v]
srcn = RES.get("accuracy", {}).get("source", {}).get("iid", {}).get("sage", {}).get("n", "--")
tex = rf"""\begin{{table}}[t]
\centering\scriptsize\setlength{{\tabcolsep}}{{2.6pt}}
\caption{{\textbf{{Reliability.}} A: accuracy (\%, equal-crop mean, 1,600 queries) under three locked memory selections (release seeds 0--2; each query keeps its fold eligibility); SD across selections is memory-selection sensitivity, not an image-sampling interval. B: hit = true disease among the four retrieved captions; MACE / SAGE accuracy on identical hit and miss items; associative, and hit status is oracle information. C: same- vs other-source memory on {srcn} paired IID queries.}}
\label{{tab:reliability}}
\begin{{tabular}}{{lcccccccc}}
\toprule
\multicolumn{{9}}{{l}}{{\textit{{A. Memory selection (IID, held-out per selection)}}}} \\
& \multicolumn{{2}}{{c}}{{Seed 0}} & \multicolumn{{2}}{{c}}{{Seed 1}} & \multicolumn{{2}}{{c}}{{Seed 2}} & \multicolumn{{2}}{{c}}{{SD}} \\
Method & IID & H-o & IID & H-o & IID & H-o & IID & H-o \\
\midrule
{chr(10).join(lines)}
\midrule
\multicolumn{{9}}{{l}}{{\textit{{B. Retrieval hit and miss: ten crops; \pilottag{{}} soybean, different protocol, $K{{=}}4$}}}} \\
Set & Hit & \multicolumn{{3}}{{c}}{{MACE / SAGE on hits}} & \multicolumn{{4}}{{c}}{{MACE / SAGE on misses}} \\
\midrule
{chr(10).join(_hm_rows(hm + pl))}
\midrule
\multicolumn{{9}}{{l}}{{\textit{{C. Same- vs other-source memory (IID): same {acc('source', 'iid', 'same_source', False)}, other {acc('source', 'iid', 'other_source', False)}}}}} \\
\bottomrule
\end{{tabular}}
\end{{table}}
"""
(PAPER / "tables/t3_reliability.tex").write_text(tex)
def _hm_rows(pl):
out = []
for l in pl:
a, b, c, d = [x.strip() for x in l.rstrip(" \\").split("&")]
out.append(f"{a} & {b} & \\multicolumn{{3}}{{c}}{{{c}}} & \\multicolumn{{4}}{{c}}{{{d}}} \\\\")
return out
def t4(D):
c6, u6 = usd(D, "P6"); c7, u7 = usd(D, "P7")
P, G = pilot()
led = [json.loads(l) for l in (PILOT / "cost_ledger.jsonl").open()]
el = lambda st: np.median([r["elapsed_s"] for r in led if r.get("stage") == st and not r["cache_hit"] and r.get("elapsed_s")])
cost = lambda st: np.mean([r["cost_usd"] for r in led if r.get("stage") == st and not r["cache_hit"]])
cap = cost("caption")
sage = P[P.condition == "sage"].set_index("image_id").correct
R4 = P[(P.condition == "agmem") & (P.K == 4)]; G4 = G[G.K == 4]
pil = [("SAGE (KB only)", 100 * R4.image_id.map(sage).mean(), "100", el("diag:sage"), cost("diag:sage")),
("MACE retrieval", 100 * R4.correct.mean(), "100", el("diag:agmem") + el("caption"), cost("diag:agmem") + cap),
("MACE agentic", 100 * G4.correct.mean(), f"{100 * (G4.prediction != 'UNKNOWN').mean():.1f}", np.median(G4.elapsed_s.dropna()) if "elapsed_s" in G4 else el("diag:agentic"), cost("diag:agentic") + cap)]
Em = RES.get("efficiency", {}).get("methods", {})
rows = "\n".join((f"{n} & {Em[m]['acc_all']:.1f} & {Em[m]['completion']:.1f} & {Em[m]['latency_s']:.0f} & {Em[m]['usd']:.3f} \\\\" if m in Em else f"{n} & {NR} & {NR} & {NR} & {NR} \\\\")
for n, m in (("SAGE (KB only)", "sage"), ("Labels only", "labels"), ("MACE retrieval", "mace"), ("MACE agentic", "agentic"), ("Image references", "imageref")))
prow = "\n".join(f"{n} & {a:.1f} & {c} & {l:.0f} & {u:.3f} \\\\" for n, a, c, l, u in pil)
tex = rf"""\begin{{table}}[t]
\centering\scriptsize\setlength{{\tabcolsep}}{{3.5pt}}
\caption{{\textbf{{Accuracy against evidence-access effort}} (200 matched queries, 5 crops, 20 IID + 20 held-out each). Accuracy counts failures as wrong; completion = parseable answer; latency = median wall-clock seconds per query; USD = list-price estimate per query including the test caption. Agentic: four reads, at most six turns. Image references: the same four retrieved items shown as images. \pilottag{{}} rows: soybean pilot, different protocol (agentic without a turn bound).}}
\label{{tab:efficiency}}
\begin{{tabular}}{{lcccc}}
\toprule
Method & Acc. & Compl.\ (\%) & Latency (s) & USD \\
\midrule
{rows}
\midrule
\multicolumn{{5}}{{l}}{{\textit{{\pilottag{{}} Soybean, different protocol (IID and held-out pooled, $K{{=}}4$)}}}} \\
{prow}
\bottomrule
\end{{tabular}}
\end{{table}}
"""
(PAPER / "tables/t4_efficiency.tex").write_text(tex)
def t2c(D):
"""Q2 content controls (all pending) and the matched-efficiency package, in one compact table."""
c3, u3 = usd(D, "P3"); c4, u4 = usd(D, "P4"); c6, u6 = usd(D, "P6"); c7, u7 = usd(D, "P7")
tests = {"mace": "reference", "labels": "lookup alone", "masked": "descriptions", "shuffled": "label following", "random": "retrieval"}
body = "\n".join(f"{n_} & {acc('ablation', 'iid', m_)} & {acc('ablation', 'ood', m_)} & {tests[m_]} \\\\" for n_, m_ in CONTROLS)
tex = rf"""\begin{{table}}[t]
\centering\scriptsize\setlength{{\tabcolsep}}{{3pt}}
\caption{{\textbf{{Content controls}} at $K{{=}}4$ on the 400-query ablation panel (40 per crop, 20 IID + 20 held-out, nested in Table~\ref{{tab:hero}}): identical queries, KB claims, candidates and retrieved items; only the memory text differs. Accuracy (\%), equal-crop mean, with a 95\% bootstrap interval.}}
\label{{tab:controls}}
\begin{{tabular}}{{lccl}}
\toprule
Evidence shown & IID & Held-out & Tests \\
\midrule
{body}
\bottomrule
\end{{tabular}}
\end{{table}}
"""
(PAPER / "tables/t2_controls.tex").write_text(tex)
mac["costPsix"] = f"{u6:.0f}"; mac["callsPsix"] = f"{c6:,}"; mac["costPseven"] = f"{u7:.0f}"; mac["callsPseven"] = f"{c7:,}"
c2, u2 = usd(D, "P2"); mac["costPtwo"] = f"{u2:.0f}"; mac["callsPtwo"] = f"{c2:,}"
c1, u1 = usd(D, "P1"); mac["costPone"] = f"{u1:.0f}"; mac["callsPone"] = f"{c1:,}"
def t_main():
"""Table 1: grouped hero results; the best locked cell per column is green; post hoc arms sit in their own block."""
A = RES["accuracy"]["hero"]
groups = [("No model call", [("Label majority vote", "majority"), ("Score-weighted vote", "wvote"), ("OpenCLIP 1-NN", "clip_s0"), ("DINOv2 1-NN", "dino_s0")]),
("Frozen VLM: Sonnet 5.5", [("SAGE (KB only)", "sage"), (r"\macelogo\ MACE retrieval", "mace")])]
locked = [m for _, g in groups for _, m in g]
best = {(sp, k): max(locked, key=lambda m: A[sp][m][k]) for sp in ("iid", "ood") for k in ("acc", "macro")}
def c(sp, m, k):
v = A[sp][m]; t = fmt(v["acc"], *v["ci"]) if k == "acc" else fmt(v[k])
return ("\\cellcolor{bestgreen}" + t) if best.get((sp, k)) == m else t
def row(n, m):
return f"{n} & {c('iid', m, 'acc')} & {c('ood', m, 'acc')} & {c('iid', m, 'macro')} & {c('ood', m, 'macro')} \\\\"
body = []
for g, rows in groups:
body += [f"\\multicolumn{{5}}{{l}}{{\\textit{{{g}}}}} \\\\"] + [row(n, m) for n, m in rows] + ["\\midrule"]
body += ["\\multicolumn{5}{l}{\\textit{Post hoc tests, Sonnet 5.5}} \\\\", row("Labels only", "labels_all"), "\\midrule"]
hk = json.loads((OUT.parent.parent / "experiments/mace_extension/statistics/extension_results.json").read_text())["E1"]["accuracy"]
body += ["\\multicolumn{5}{l}{\\textit{Post hoc tests, Haiku 5.5}} \\\\"] + [f"{n} & {fmt(hk['iid']['Haiku'][m]['acc'], *hk['iid']['Haiku'][m]['ci'])} & {fmt(hk['ood']['Haiku'][m]['acc'], *hk['ood']['Haiku'][m]['ci'])} & -- & -- \\\\" for n, m in (("SAGE (KB only)", "h_sage"), ("Labels only", "h_labels"), ("MACE retrieval", "h_mace"))]
n1, n2 = A["iid"]["mace"]["n"], A["ood"]["mace"]["n"]
tex = "\n".join([r"\begin{table}[t]", r"\centering\scriptsize\setlength{\tabcolsep}{2.4pt}",
r"\caption{\textbf{Ten-crop results} ($K{=}4$): accuracy (\%), 95\% intervals. Green: best planned method.}",
r"\label{tab:hero}", r"\begin{tabular}{lcccc}", r"\toprule", r"Method & IID & Held-out & Macro IID & Macro H-o \\", r"\midrule", *body, r"\bottomrule", r"\end{tabular}", r"\end{table}", ""])
(PAPER / "tables/t_main.tex").write_text(minus(tex))
def t_info():
"""Table 2: caption-versus-label evidence. A: locked matched cohort. B: expanded post hoc panel."""
A = RES["accuracy"]["ablation"]; H = RES["accuracy"]["hero"]; C = RES["amendment"]
f = lambda d, m: fmt(d[m]["acc"], *d[m]["ci"])
ci = lambda k: f"{C[k]['est']:+.1f} {{\\tiny[{C[k]['ci'][0]:+.1f}, {C[k]['ci'][1]:+.1f}]}}"
best = {sp: max(("sage", "mace", "labels", "masked", "shuffled", "random"), key=lambda m: A[sp][m]["acc"]) for sp in ("iid", "ood")}
g = lambda sp, m: ("\\cellcolor{bestgreen}" if best[sp] == m else "") + f(A[sp], m)
d = lambda m: "--" if m == "mace" else " / ".join(f"{A[sp][m]['acc'] - A[sp]['mace']['acc']:+.1f}" for sp in ("iid", "ood"))
rowsA = [("SAGE (no memory)", "sage"), ("MACE (captions + labels)", "mace"), ("Labels only", "labels"), ("Captions only (masked)", "masked"), ("Random references", "random"), ("Shuffled labels", "shuffled")]
a = [f"{n} & {g('iid', m)} & {g('ood', m)} & {d(m)} \\\\" for n, m in rowsA]
b = [f"MACE (captions + labels) & {f(H['iid'], 'mace')} & {f(H['ood'], 'mace')} & -- \\\\",
f"Labels only & {f(H['iid'], 'labels_all')} & {f(H['ood'], 'labels_all')} & {C['labels_all_minus_mace_iid']['est']:+.1f} / {C['labels_all_minus_mace_ood']['est']:+.1f} \\\\",
f"DINOv2-retrieved labels & {f(H['iid'], 'dino_labels')} & {f(H['ood'], 'dino_labels')} & {H['iid']['dino_labels']['acc'] - H['iid']['mace']['acc']:+.1f} / {H['ood']['dino_labels']['acc'] - H['ood']['mace']['acc']:+.1f} \\\\",
f"\\textit{{Labels $-$ MACE}} & {ci('labels_all_minus_mace_iid')} & {ci('labels_all_minus_mace_ood')} & Text adds / unclear \\\\",
f"\\textit{{DINOv2 $-$ BM25 labels}} & {ci('dino_labels_minus_labels_all_iid')} & {ci('dino_labels_minus_labels_all_ood')} & Matched / unclear \\\\"]
tex = "\n".join([r"\begin{table}[t]", r"\centering\scriptsize\setlength{\tabcolsep}{1.9pt}",
r"\caption{\textbf{Post hoc tests}, all 1,600 queries: accuracy (\%), 95\% intervals.}",
r"\label{tab:controls}", r"\begin{tabular}{lccc}", r"\toprule", r"Evidence shown & IID & Held-out & vs MACE \\\\", r"\midrule", *b, r"\bottomrule", r"\end{tabular}", r"\end{table}", ""])
(PAPER / "tables/t_info.tex").write_text(minus(tex))
def main():
D, S = dry(); L = pd.read_csv(OUT / "local_baselines.csv")
RES.update(json.loads((OUT / "results.json").read_text()))
t1(L, D); t2(L, D); t3(L, D); t4(D); t2c(D); t_main(); t_info()
macros_from_results()
mac["dryTotal"] = f"{S['projected_additional_usd']:.0f}"; mac["dryRequired"] = f"{S['projected_required_usd']:.0f}"
mac["dryCapsNew"] = f"{S['captions_new']:,}"; mac["nHero"] = "1,600"
(PAPER / "numbers_mace10.tex").write_text("% generated by code/agmem-bench/mace10/paper.py; do not edit\n" +
"\n".join(f"\\newcommand{{\\{k}}}{{{minus(v) if k.startswith('tc') else v}}}" for k, v in sorted(mac.items())) + "\n")
pd.DataFrame(cells).to_csv(OUT / "table_cells.csv", index=False)
print(json.dumps(mac, indent=0))
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()
|