--- license: cc-by-4.0 pretty_name: MACE-Bench language: [en] task_categories: [image-classification, visual-question-answering] tags: [agriculture, plant-disease, crop-disease, vision-language-model, retrieval-augmented-generation, memory, benchmark, out-of-distribution] size_categories: [1K MACE

Memory-Augmented Crop-Disease Evaluation of Frozen Vision-Language Models

Tirtho Roy*, Shreyan Ganguly*, Muhammad Arbab Arshad, Nikhil Bhattacharya, Soumik Sarkar
Iowa State University  ·  AgriAI 2027 Workshop at AAAI-27 (under review)  ·  *equal contribution

Project page OpenReview Code CC BY 4.0

10 crops  ·  5,601 images  ·  1,600 locked queries  ·  418 memory banks  ·  12,438 evaluation jobs with full prompts and replies

--- ## 🌶️ What is MACE? A frozen vision-language model (VLM) diagnoses crop disease better when it can look things up. **MACE** gives it two things: a source-grounded symptom knowledge base, and a **caption memory**. Each labeled reference image is described once, in seven fields, by a captioner that never sees the label. At test time the test image is described the same way, BM25 retrieves the four closest memory captions, and the VLM reads those captions **with their labels** (never the memory images) before it answers. No training.

MACE overview

| Claude Sonnet 5.5, 10 crops | In distribution | Held-out collection | |---|:---:|:---:| | SAGE (knowledge base only) | 42.8 | 50.7 | | DINOv2 1-NN label lookup | 52.5 | 38.2 | | Labels only (no captions) | 55.8 | 54.8 | | **MACE retrieval** | **62.2** | **57.0** | Accuracy (%), equal-crop mean. Claude Haiku 5.5 also ranks MACE above labels only and SAGE. Retrieved labels carry most of the gain; caption text adds about six points in distribution. Run `python results/verify.py` to recompute every number. ## 🔍 Browse it here Use the **dataset viewer** above. Each config is a live table: | Config | What you see | |---|---| | `images` | Every image with crop, disease, source collection, its role (query or memory) and its full label-free caption | | `memory_banks` | Every memory bank exactly as used: crop, seed, fold, K, member images with labels, and the queries it served | | `captions` | The seven caption fields of every image, one column each | | `queries` | The 1,640 locked queries with split and panel flags | | `predictions_P1` | SAGE and MACE answers, confidence, cited evidence, retrieved memory and explanation for all 1,600 queries | | `results_per_query` | One row per query, one column per method (1 = correct) | ## 🧠 What one memory entry looks like

Memory entry, BM25 scoring and traces

The same entry as stored in the files `captions.json["s15_r12256"]` ```json { "organ": "whole_plant", "location": "Vine with leaves lying over soil; older leaves lower and at right", "lesion_shape_margin": "Irregular dried patches spreading from leaf edges; margins diffuse, tan-to-green transition", "color": "Green leaves; some yellowing; dried areas beige to tan-brown", "texture": "Dry, papery, crinkled dead tissue; healthy leaves rough with visible veins", "distribution": "Several leaves affected, mostly edges and tips; others fully green", "visible_discriminators": "Wilted, curled leaves; yellow-green blotching; dark soil; thin tendrils; small yellow flower", "uncertainty": "Cannot tell extent of damage on undersides; some leaf areas shadowed or overlapping" } ``` In the VLM prompt it appears as one line: `[m_s15_r12256] (label: Bacterial Wilt) organ: whole_plant; location: ...; visible_discriminators: ...`
## 🌾 Per-crop gain

Gain over SAGE per crop

Crops, queries and memory sizes | Crop | IID queries | Held-out queries | Held-out collection | Memory images used | |---|:---:|:---:|---|:---:| | Apple | 100 | 60 | Bugwood | 333 | | Corn | 100 | 60 | Bugwood | 1,022 | | Cucumber | 100 | 60 | Bugwood | 286 | | Grape | 100 | 60 | Bugwood | 226 | | Mango | 100 | 60 | LeafNet | 204 | | Potato | 100 | 60 | Bugwood | 172 | | Rice | 100 | 60 | SBRD | 270 | | Soybean | 100 | 60 | Bugwood | 962 | | Tomato | 100 | 60 | CDDM | 765 | | Wheat | 100 | 60 | Bugwood | 301 | Memory images used = union over the three selection seeds, all folds and K in {1, 4, 16}. A query never sits in its own memory, and the held-out collection never enters memory.
## 📦 What is in the repository
Folder map | Path | Contents | |---|---| | `benchmark/images/` | All 5,601 study images (1,640 queries, 4,541 memory images; 580 are both, in different folds) plus `metadata.csv` | | `benchmark/splits/` | Frozen splits: IID 5 folds x 3 seeds, held-out collections, and `memory.parquet` (facility-location memory selections, nested over K) | | `benchmark/kb/`, `benchmark/metadata/` | Symptom knowledge base for every crop; full AgMEM-Bench v2.1 metadata | | `metadata.csv` | One row per study image: crop, label, collection, query/memory role, SAGE row, SHA-256 | | `captions.json` | Label-free caption of every image | | `study/` | Locked queries, panels, `memory_banks.jsonl`, `evaluation_jobs.jsonl.gz` (every job with its exact memory list), captions table | | `runs/P1` ... `runs/P9` | Per package: predictions, full traces (prompt text and raw reply of every call), manifest, status | | `results/` | Per-query results, every reported number, verify scripts, cost and budget ledgers, follow-up results | | `extension/` | Follow-up tests E1 to E4: protocol, raw and processed results, statistics, tables, figures, report | | `cache/` | Response cache of all 31,326 cached calls, and agentic-run records, so reruns replay for free | | `code/` | Full pipeline: `agmem/` (packets, prompts, BM25, agent, model interface), `mace10/` (study), `benchmark/`, `experiments/`, `tests/` | | `viewer/` | Parquet copies of the tables shown in the dataset viewer (images embedded); the raw files above are the source | | `retriever_study/` | Follow-up retriever study: summary, one-pager; its code and results are in `code/experiments/retriever_pilot/` | | `assets/` | Figures used on this card | Packages: **P1** SAGE and MACE · **P2** MACE on selection seeds 1 and 2 · **P3** memory size K = 1 and 16 · **P4** labels only, masked, shuffled, random · **P5** same- vs other-source memory · **P6** agentic MACE · **P7** image references · **P8** labels only on all queries · **P9** DINOv2-retrieved labels.
## 🔎 Follow-up: can a small neural retriever replace BM25? We replaced BM25 with small scoring networks, including a 29-parameter MLP whose weights a larger LLM writes from the feature schema, memory captions or labeled examples, and reran diagnosis on all 1,600 queries with everything else fixed. | Model (IID / held-out) | MACE, BM25 | BM25 + image similarity | LLM-written MLP | |---|:---:|:---:|:---:| | Sonnet 5.5 | 62.2 / 57.0 | 63.5 / 58.8 | 62.0 / 57.7 | | Haiku 5.5 | 55.5 / 53.5 | 57.3 / 54.7 | 57.4 / 54.2 | No difference is significant. The LLM-written MLP matches BM25 on retrieval, while the same network fitted on the same 16 examples falls 20 points behind. Details, code, every prediction and a one-page summary: [`retriever_study/`](https://huggingface.co/datasets/tirtho149/MACE-Bench/tree/main/retriever_study). ## ⚡ Quick start ```python from datasets import load_dataset imgs = load_dataset("tirtho149/MACE-Bench", "images", split="train") # image + crop, label, role, caption banks = load_dataset("tirtho149/MACE-Bench", "memory_banks", split="train") # every memory bank as used print(imgs[0]["label"], "|", imgs[0]["caption"][:120]) ``` ## ♻️ Reproduce ```bash huggingface-cli download tirtho149/MACE-Bench --repo-type dataset --local-dir MACE-Bench && cd MACE-Bench pip install -r code/requirements.txt python results/verify.py # every reported accuracy, under a minute cd code && mkdir -p .cache && tar -xzf ../cache/llm.tar.gz -C .cache AGMEM_DATA=$PWD/../benchmark python verify_release.py # rebuilds all memory banks and jobs, replays every call ``` We ran this on a fresh copy of the repository. All 12,438 jobs, including every memory bank, rebuild identically. All 5,601 captions and 11,998 text diagnoses replay from the cache, so every prompt is reproduced byte for byte, and each cached reply gives the saved prediction. `python -m mace10.results` recomputes all 1,062 values of `results/results.json`. Full steps, including fresh reruns, are in `REPRODUCE.md`. ## 📜 Sources and license Images, labels and the knowledge base come from [SAGE](https://huggingface.co/datasets/tirtho149/SAGE) (CC BY 4.0) through AgMEM-Bench v2.1, with near-copies and images containing disease-naming text removed. Captions, memory banks, predictions, traces and results are CC BY 4.0; code is MIT (`benchmark/LICENSE.md`). Every image keeps its original collection in `metadata.csv` (`collection`, `orig_filename`): PlantWild, Bugwood, Soybean disease, Corn disease, CDDM, BD crop/vegetable, LeafNet, PlantDoc, PlantVillage and others. Some original collections have their own terms, so please check and credit the original source when you reuse individual images. ## 📖 Citation ```bibtex @unpublished{roy2026mace, title = {MACE: Memory-Augmented Crop-Disease Evaluation of Frozen Vision-Language Models}, author = {Roy, Tirtho and Ganguly, Shreyan and Arshad, Muhammad Arbab and Bhattacharya, Nikhil and Sarkar, Soumik}, note = {AgriAI 2027 Workshop at AAAI-27, under review}, year = {2026} } ```