"""Capture C3 reasoning for the STILL-CAUGHT remediated rows, then bucket the tells so we can see what C3 is still catching them on. Rebuilds the exact same prompt/orientation used in the scored run (baseline answer_key), calls the judge once per row for its reasoning, writes out/C3_remediated_caught_reasons.jsonl, and prints a tell-bucket histogram. Run: python -u temp/story_remediation/analyze_caught.py """ from __future__ import annotations import json, logging, re, sys from collections import Counter from concurrent.futures import ThreadPoolExecutor from pathlib import Path import yaml for _n in ("azure", "azure.identity", "azure.core.pipeline.policies.http_logging_policy"): logging.getLogger(_n).setLevel(logging.WARNING) HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent ROOT = HERE.parents[1] sys.path.insert(0, str(ROOT)) from datasetreview import pipelines as P # noqa: E402 from datasetreview import judge_prompts as J # noqa: E402 from datasetreview.llm_client import make_judge # noqa: E402 OUT = HERE / "out" cfg = yaml.safe_load(open(ROOT / "datasetreview" / "config.yaml", encoding="utf-8")) base = {json.loads(l)["item_id"]: json.loads(l) for l in open(ROOT / "datasetreview" / "results" / "new" / "C3.jsonl", encoding="utf-8") if l.strip()} remed = {r["example_id"]: r for r in (json.loads(l) for l in open(OUT / "trajectories_remediated.jsonl", encoding="utf-8") if l.strip())} scored = {json.loads(l)["item_id"]: json.loads(l) for l in open(OUT / "C3_remediated.jsonl", encoding="utf-8") if l.strip()} caught_ids = [iid for iid, r in scored.items() if r.get("caught")] reals = P.real_trajectories() pairer = P.make_pairer(reals) judge = make_judge(cfg["model"]) # tell buckets -> keyword patterns matched against reasoning about the fake side BUCKETS = { "bundled_multitask": r"multi[- ]?task|multiple (distinct|separate) |several (distinct|requests)|checklist|enumerat|packs|laundry list|bundl", "too_precise_ids": r"exact (order|id|item)|precise|order number|conveniently|front[- ]?load|all the details|specific ids|recites|recite", "no_backforth_dense": r"no back[- ]?and[- ]?forth|dense|rapid|single (turn|message)|one (turn|message|go)|without (any )?clarif|immediately|right away|opening (message|turn)", "invented_capability": r"unusual (request|task|service)|would not (typically|normally)|no real|not (a )?(typical|standard|common)|niche|obscure|rare (request|service)|atypical", "agent_overconfident": r"agent (volunteer|claims|asserts|states)|policy|without (verif|confirm|authenticat)|overconfident|too confident|proactively", "scripted_synthetic": r"synthetic|constructed|engineered|scripted|test scenario|designed to|artificial|contrived|crafted|feels? (fake|off|unnatural)|too (tidy|neat|clean|smooth|polished)|stilted|robotic", "verification_flow": r"verif|authenticat|identity|name and zip|otp|one[- ]?time code", } def which_side_is_fake(key): return "A" if key == "A" else "B" def one(iid): fake = remed[iid]; b = base.get(iid) real = pairer(fake) swap = (b or {}).get("answer_key") == "B" msgs = J.build_c3(fake, real, swap=swap) try: r = judge.judge({"system": msgs["system"], "user": msgs["user"]}) except Exception as e: # noqa return {"item_id": iid, "error": str(e)} return {"item_id": iid, "answer_key": msgs["answer_key"], "guess": r.get("guess"), "confidence": r.get("confidence"), "reasoning": r.get("reasoning", ""), "fake_side": which_side_is_fake(msgs["answer_key"])} def main(): print(f"capturing reasoning for {len(caught_ids)} still-caught rows...") with ThreadPoolExecutor(max_workers=8) as ex: res = list(ex.map(one, caught_ids)) res = [r for r in res if not r.get("error")] (OUT / "C3_remediated_caught_reasons.jsonl").write_text( "\n".join(json.dumps(r) for r in res) + "\n", encoding="utf-8") bucket = Counter(); multi = Counter(); conf = Counter() per_row = [] for r in res: txt = (r.get("reasoning") or "").lower() conf[r.get("confidence")] += 1 hits = [name for name, pat in BUCKETS.items() if re.search(pat, txt)] if not hits: hits = ["other_unbucketed"] for h in hits: bucket[h] += 1 multi[len(hits)] += 1 per_row.append((r["item_id"], r.get("confidence"), hits)) n = len(res) print(f"\nreasoning captured: {n} (confidence: {dict(conf)})") print("\n=== WHY STILL CAUGHT: tell buckets (rows whose reasoning cites each; multi-count) ===") for name, c in bucket.most_common(): print(f" {name:22s} {c:3d} ({c/n:.0%})") print("\n=== tells per row ===", dict(sorted(multi.items()))) # sample a few high-confidence catches verbatim print("\n=== sample HIGH-confidence catches (verbatim reasoning) ===") hi = [r for r in res if r.get("confidence") == "high"][:6] for r in hi: print(f"\n[{r['item_id']}] fake={r['fake_side']} guess={r['guess']}") print(" " + (r.get("reasoning") or "")[:400]) if __name__ == "__main__": main()