| {
|
| "dataset_name": "LLMJRE",
|
| "full_name": "LLM-as-a-Judge Review and Rebuttal Evaluation Benchmark",
|
| "version": "1.0.0",
|
| "release_date": "2026-06-26",
|
| "license": "CC-BY-4.0",
|
| "language": "English",
|
| "source_dataset": {
|
| "name": "Re²",
|
| "description": "Consistency-ensured Dataset for Full-stage Peer Review and Multi-turn Rebuttal Discussions"
|
| },
|
| "repository": {
|
| "github": "https://github.com/tswj/llmjre-eval",
|
| "huggingface": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/tswj/llmjre"
|
| },
|
| "benchmark": {
|
| "master": {
|
| "file": "llmjre_master.jsonl",
|
| "papers": 19926,
|
| "accept": 12149,
|
| "reject": 7211,
|
| "other_or_unknown": 566,
|
| "description": "Canonical benchmark containing all reviewed papers with available manuscript, review, rebuttal and decision metadata."
|
| },
|
| "review": {
|
| "file": "llmjre_review.jsonl",
|
| "papers": 19255,
|
| "accept": 12063,
|
| "reject": 7192,
|
| "description": "Static review benchmark for LLM-human review alignment. Contains manuscript text, human reviews and valid Accept/Reject decisions."
|
| },
|
| "rebuttal": {
|
| "file": "llmjre_rebuttal.jsonl",
|
| "papers": 14633,
|
| "accept": 9173,
|
| "reject": 5460,
|
| "description": "Dynamic rebuttal benchmark containing papers from LLMJRE-Review that additionally include author rebuttals."
|
| }
|
| },
|
| "construction_pipeline": [
|
| "Raw Re² Dataset",
|
| "Paper Summary Extraction",
|
| "Review Extraction",
|
| "Rebuttal Extraction",
|
| "Review-Rebuttal Merge",
|
| "LLMJRE-Master",
|
| "LLMJRE-Review",
|
| "LLMJRE-Rebuttal"
|
| ],
|
| "benchmark_tasks": {
|
| "task_1": {
|
| "name": "Static Review Evaluation",
|
| "dataset": "llmjre_review",
|
| "objective": "Evaluate alignment between LLM reviewers and human reviewers using manuscript content and review information."
|
| },
|
| "task_2": {
|
| "name": "Rebuttal-Aware Evaluation",
|
| "dataset": "llmjre_rebuttal",
|
| "objective": "Evaluate whether LLM reviewers appropriately update their assessments after reading author rebuttals."
|
| }
|
| },
|
| "statistics": {
|
| "review_source_of_truth": 19926,
|
| "paper_summary_records": 19796,
|
| "rebuttal_records": 14830,
|
| "review_alignment_records": 19255,
|
| "rebuttal_benchmark_records": 14633
|
| },
|
| "notes": [
|
| "Human review records are the canonical source of paper identifiers.",
|
| "LLMJRE-Review contains only papers with manuscript text and valid Accept/Reject decisions.",
|
| "LLMJRE-Rebuttal is a subset of LLMJRE-Review containing available author rebuttals.",
|
| "Intermediate processing files are available in the companion GitHub repository."
|
| ]
|
| }
|
|
|
