"""Turn raw job JSON into the numbers behind each claim. Usage: python analyze.py [more.json ...] """ from __future__ import annotations import glob import json import sys import numpy as np def load(paths): out = [] for p in paths: for f in sorted(glob.glob(p)): with open(f) as fh: out.append(json.load(fh)) return out # -------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Claim 1 / Claim 5: from the ablation records # -------------------------------------------------------------------------- def claim1(paths): """Proposition 1: the standard (EIG) utility choice is suboptimal w.r.t. the Lagrangian utility that accounts for the drifter's future trajectory. The paper's formal proof (App. D) is a one-line argmax argument giving only the weak inequality LU(x^S) <= LU(x*). Here we measure whether the gap is real and how big it is, using the ground-truth field to define LU = B(.;true). """ recs = [r for d in load(paths) for r in d["records"]] rows = [] for r in recs: u_true = np.array(r["u_true"]) u_eig = np.array(r["u_eig"]) u_ball = np.array(r["u"]).mean(0) i_eig, i_ball, i_star = u_eig.argmax(), u_ball.argmax(), u_true.argmax() rows.append({ "t": r["t"], "LU_star": u_true[i_star], "LU_eig": u_true[i_eig], "LU_ballast": u_true[i_ball], "LU_mean": u_true.mean(), # uniform policy "strict": bool(u_true[i_eig] < u_true[i_star] - 1e-9), "eig_is_argmax": bool(i_eig == i_star), }) out = {} for t in sorted(set(r["t"] for r in rows)): sub = [r for r in rows if r["t"] == t] gap_eig = np.array([(r["LU_star"] - r["LU_eig"]) / abs(r["LU_star"]) * 100 for r in sub]) gap_bal = np.array([(r["LU_star"] - r["LU_ballast"]) / abs(r["LU_star"]) * 100 for r in sub]) gap_uni = np.array([(r["LU_star"] - r["LU_mean"]) / abs(r["LU_star"]) * 100 for r in sub]) out[t] = { "n": len(sub), "pct_strictly_suboptimal": 100 * np.mean([r["strict"] for r in sub]), "gap_eig_pct": [gap_eig.mean(), 2 * gap_eig.std() / np.sqrt(len(sub))], "gap_ballast_pct": [gap_bal.mean(), 2 * gap_bal.std() / np.sqrt(len(sub))], "gap_unif_pct": [gap_uni.mean(), 2 * gap_uni.std() / np.sqrt(len(sub))], } return out def claim5(paths): """Sec. 5.1 / G.1: percentage utility gap vs J, and the J at which it drops below 1%. Gap_MC(J) = B(s*; inf) - B(s*_J; inf), approximated with J=200 Gap_Full(J) = B(s*_true; true) - B(s*_J; true) """ recs = [r for d in load(paths) for r in d["records"]] ts = sorted(set(r["t"] for r in recs)) out = {} for t in ts: sub = [r for r in recs if r["t"] == t] Jmax = np.array(sub[0]["u"]).shape[0] Js = np.arange(1, Jmax + 1) mc = np.zeros((len(sub), Jmax)) full = np.zeros((len(sub), Jmax)) eig_mc, eig_full, uni_mc, uni_full = [], [], [], [] for i, r in enumerate(sub): u = np.array(r["u"]) # (Jmax, N) u_true = np.array(r["u_true"]) u_eig = np.array(r["u_eig"]) B_inf = u.mean(0) # B(.; inf) approximated by J=200 s_star = B_inf.argmax() s_true = u_true.argmax() run = np.cumsum(u, axis=0) / Js[:, None] # B(.; J) for each J sJ = run.argmax(axis=1) # s*_J mc[i] = (B_inf[s_star] - B_inf[sJ]) / abs(B_inf[s_star]) * 100 full[i] = (u_true[s_true] - u_true[sJ]) / abs(u_true[s_true]) * 100 ie = u_eig.argmax() eig_mc.append((B_inf[s_star] - B_inf[ie]) / abs(B_inf[s_star]) * 100) eig_full.append((u_true[s_true] - u_true[ie]) / abs(u_true[s_true]) * 100) uni_mc.append((B_inf[s_star] - B_inf.mean()) / abs(B_inf[s_star]) * 100) uni_full.append((u_true[s_true] - u_true.mean()) / abs(u_true[s_true]) * 100) def band(a): return a.mean(0), 2 * a.std(0) / np.sqrt(a.shape[0]) m_mc, s_mc = band(mc) m_fu, s_fu = band(full) below = np.where(m_mc < 1.0)[0] out[t] = { "n_reps": len(sub), "J": Js.tolist(), "gap_mc_mean": m_mc.tolist(), "gap_mc_se2": s_mc.tolist(), "gap_full_mean": m_fu.tolist(), "gap_full_se2": s_fu.tolist(), "J_at_1pct_mc": int(Js[below[0]]) if len(below) else None, "eig_gap_mc": float(np.mean(eig_mc)), "eig_gap_full": float(np.mean(eig_full)), "unif_gap_mc": float(np.mean(uni_mc)), "unif_gap_full": float(np.mean(uni_full)), "gap_at_J20_mc": float(m_mc[19]), "gap_at_J20_full": float(m_fu[19]), } return out # -------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Claims 3 / 4: policy comparison # -------------------------------------------------------------------------- POLICY_ORDER = ["unif", "sobol", "dist_sep", "eig", "ballast_opt", "ballast_true"] def claim34(paths): from ballast.experiment import iso_performance res = [r for d in load(paths) for r in d["results"]] seeds = sorted(set(r["seed"] for r in res)) pols = [p for p in POLICY_ORDER if any(r["policy"] == p for r in res)] by = {(r["seed"], r["policy"]): np.array(r["errors"]) for r in res} n_dep = len(next(iter(by.values()))) # runs where every policy completed good = [s for s in seeds if all((s, p) in by for p in pols)] E = {p: np.stack([by[(s, p)] for s in good]) for p in pols} # (n_runs, n_dep) # --- average policy rank per iteration (1 = best) stack = np.stack([E[p] for p in pols]) # (n_pol, n_runs, n_dep) order = stack.argsort(axis=0).argsort(axis=0) + 1 rank_mean = order.mean(axis=1) # (n_pol, n_dep) rank_se2 = 2 * order.std(axis=1) / np.sqrt(len(good)) # --- iso-performance vs UNIF iso = {} for p in pols: v = np.stack([iso_performance(E[p][i], E["unif"][i]) for i in range(len(good))]) iso[p] = { "mean": np.nanmean(v, axis=0).tolist(), "se2": (2 * np.nanstd(v, axis=0) / np.sqrt(len(good))).tolist(), "final": float(np.nanmean(v[:, -1])), "final_se2": float(2 * np.nanstd(v[:, -1]) / np.sqrt(len(good))), } n_policy_chosen = n_dep - 1 # the first drifter is placed uniformly at random # The paper defines iso-performance as "averaged over each iteration's # results" (Sec. 5.2) and reports the saving as a single number ("save about # 3 drifters ~16%"). We therefore headline the mean over deployment # iterations, which matches the paper's Claim-3 number almost exactly (3.4 vs # 3). The final-iteration value ("drifters needed to match uniform's *final* # accuracy") is a different, larger statistic and is kept as a secondary read. iso_avg = {p: float(np.nanmean(iso[p]["mean"])) for p in pols} iso_avg_se2 = { p: float(2 * np.nanstd([np.nanmean( [iso_performance(E[p][i], E["unif"][i])]) for i in range(len(good))]) / np.sqrt(len(good))) for p in pols } # per-run averaged-over-iterations, for a correct standard error iso_avg_runs = { p: np.array([np.nanmean(iso_performance(E[p][i], E["unif"][i])) for i in range(len(good))]) for p in pols } iso_avg = {p: float(np.nanmean(iso_avg_runs[p])) for p in pols} iso_avg_se2 = {p: float(2 * np.nanstd(iso_avg_runs[p]) / np.sqrt(len(good))) for p in pols} return { "n_runs": len(good), "policies": pols, "n_deploy": n_dep, "rank_mean": rank_mean.tolist(), "rank_se2": rank_se2.tolist(), "err_mean": {p: E[p].mean(0).tolist() for p in pols}, "err_se2": {p: (2 * E[p].std(0) / np.sqrt(len(good))).tolist() for p in pols}, "iso": iso, "iso_avg": iso_avg, # paper's metric: averaged over iterations "iso_avg_se2": iso_avg_se2, "savings_pct_avg": {p: 100 * iso_avg[p] / n_policy_chosen for p in pols}, "savings_pct_final": {p: 100 * iso[p]["final"] / n_policy_chosen for p in pols}, "n_obs_mean": { p: float(np.mean([r["n_obs"] for r in res if r["policy"] == p])) for p in pols }, } if __name__ == "__main__": which, paths = sys.argv[1], sys.argv[2:] fn = {"claim1": claim1, "claim5": claim5, "claim34": claim34}[which] print(json.dumps(fn(paths), indent=2, default=float))