{ "balanced_sensitivity": { "bucket": "62-80", "difference_ci95": [ -0.0015135299791574075, 0.36494232434315743 ], "mean_difference": 0.181714397182, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.6183099525286665, "p0_mean": 0.4365955553466667, "paired_t": 2.12706996208067 }, "dyck1_id_comparison": { "bucket": "2-20", "difference_ci95": [ -0.04571673477616167, 0.059258401469495 ], "mean_difference": 0.006770833346666668, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.9329427083466669, "p0_mean": 0.926171875, "paired_t": 0.27667491079127854 }, "dyck1_ood_comparisons": [ { "bucket": "22-40", "difference_ci95": [ -0.015254778053876872, 0.20822352804054353 ], "mean_difference": 0.09648437499333333, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.83196614582, "p0_mean": 0.7354817708266665, "paired_t": 1.8519775515951329 }, { "bucket": "42-60", "difference_ci95": [ 0.03457705086592039, 0.3427666991274129 ], "mean_difference": 0.18867187499666666, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.725, "p0_mean": 0.5363281250033334, "paired_t": 2.6260513820621956 }, { "bucket": "62-80", "difference_ci95": [ 0.00868728336352445, 0.3727580291564756 ], "mean_difference": 0.19072265626, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.6126953124866666, "p0_mean": 0.4219726562266667, "paired_t": 2.2471424521608676 } ], "evaluation": { "checkpoint_selection_seed": 4242, "chunk_size": 128, "device": "mps", "eval_seed": 20260721, "examples_per_bucket": 2048, "long_output_chunk_size": 32, "numpy_version": "2.5.1", "python_version": "3.12.11", "torch_version": "2.13.0" }, "exploratory_trainability": [ { "bucket": "1-16", "comparison": "p=0.25 - p=0", "df": 4, "mean_difference": 0.14912109374, "n_pairs": 5, "nominally_significant": false, "p0_mean": 0.84716796878, "p_mean": 0.99628906252, "paired_t": 1.0495647303149716, "role": "exploratory; not multiplicity-corrected", "task": "copy", "two_sided_critical_t": 2.7764451051977987 }, { "bucket": "1-16", "comparison": "p=0.5 - p=0", "df": 4, "mean_difference": 0.14833984372, "n_pairs": 5, "nominally_significant": false, "p0_mean": 0.84716796878, "p_mean": 0.9955078125, "paired_t": 1.0501884284315215, "role": "exploratory; not multiplicity-corrected", "task": "copy", "two_sided_critical_t": 2.7764451051977987 }, { "bucket": "1-16", "comparison": "p=0.25 - p=0", "df": 4, "mean_difference": 0.11943359376, "n_pairs": 5, "nominally_significant": false, "p0_mean": 0.64931640626, "p_mean": 0.76875000002, "paired_t": 1.5338314450037354, "role": "exploratory; not multiplicity-corrected", "task": "prefix_sum", "two_sided_critical_t": 2.7764451051977987 }, { "bucket": "1-16", "comparison": "p=0.5 - p=0", "df": 4, "mean_difference": 0.30390625, "n_pairs": 5, "nominally_significant": true, "p0_mean": 0.64931640626, "p_mean": 0.95322265626, "paired_t": 2.815838204486789, "role": "exploratory; not multiplicity-corrected", "task": "prefix_sum", "two_sided_critical_t": 2.7764451051977987 } ], "id_aggregates": [ { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "1-16", "mean": 0.82734374998, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.22389960886840732, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "1-16", "mean": 0.94541015626, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.11825048893564064, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "1-16", "mean": 0.998046875, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.0033296342070318658, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "1-16", "mean": 0.84716796878, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.3180823495921811, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "1-16", "mean": 0.99628906252, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.002687765403410336, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "1-16", "mean": 0.9955078125, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.006388838763201611, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.9190457032433331, "balanced_std": 0.08252087996841095, "bucket": "2-20", "mean": 0.9231445312366666, "n_seeds": 30, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.07750095931760355, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.9247494137600001, "balanced_std": 0.08945712383703165, "bucket": "2-20", "mean": 0.92919921874, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.08348395721904694, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.9396730884166665, "balanced_std": 0.05113109452028637, "bucket": "2-20", "mean": 0.9421223958466667, "n_seeds": 30, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.04840463804989538, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.52382013688, "balanced_std": 0.016725867104897967, "bucket": "1-20", "mean": 0.52392578126, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.016658908304667513, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.56670786546, "balanced_std": 0.06878817995875897, "bucket": "1-20", "mean": 0.56689453126, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.0685030925387002, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.88291719714, "balanced_std": 0.10769554819781355, "bucket": "1-20", "mean": 0.8829101562, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.1077533946907605, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "1-16", "mean": 0.64931640626, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.18680169090248055, "task": "prefix_sum" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "1-16", "mean": 0.76875000002, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.15062728685841792, "task": "prefix_sum" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "1-16", "mean": 0.95322265626, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.10323794567115993, "task": "prefix_sum" } ], "independent_replication": { "balanced_sensitivity": { "bucket": "62-80", "difference_ci95": [ 0.053484021756272676, 0.37733581090506074 ], "mean_difference": 0.2154099163306667, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.6221731403799998, "p0_mean": 0.40676322404933335, "paired_t": 2.853208390206246 }, "id_comparison": { "bucket": "2-20", "difference_ci95": [ -0.011674918116182532, 0.07404470986284921 ], "mean_difference": 0.031184895873333337, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.9513020833466669, "p0_mean": 0.9201171874733334, "paired_t": 1.5605515588462862 }, "ood_comparisons": [ { "bucket": "22-40", "difference_ci95": [ 0.016367767135689118, 0.2307025453843109 ], "mean_difference": 0.12353515626, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.7996419270866667, "p0_mean": 0.6761067708266666, "paired_t": 2.472361795889643 }, { "bucket": "42-60", "difference_ci95": [ 0.08769753927754984, 0.37825298154245013 ], "mean_difference": 0.23297526041, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.6909179687466666, "p0_mean": 0.45794270833666667, "paired_t": 3.43949666367485 }, { "bucket": "62-80", "difference_ci95": [ 0.04552550556766727, 0.3768703277856661 ], "mean_difference": 0.21119791667666668, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.6139648437599999, "p0_mean": 0.40276692708333334, "paired_t": 2.73415758949679 } ], "primary": { "alpha": 0.05, "bucket": "62-80", "comparison": "p=0.5 - p=0", "df": 14, "difference_ci95": [ 0.04552550556766727, 0.3768703277856661 ], "mean_difference": 0.21119791667666668, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.6139648437599999, "p0_mean": 0.40276692708333334, "paired_t": 2.73415758949679, "replicated": true, "role": "predeclared independent confirmatory replication", "task": "dyck1", "two_sided_critical_t": 2.1447866879169273 }, "seeds": [ 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29 ] }, "ood_aggregates": [ { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "17-32", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.0, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "33-48", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.0, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "49-64", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.0, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "17-32", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.0, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "33-48", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.0, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "49-64", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.0, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "17-32", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.0, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "33-48", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.0, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "49-64", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.0, "task": "addition" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "17-32", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.0, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "33-48", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.0, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "49-64", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.0, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "17-32", "mean": 0.0001953125, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.00043673202685542777, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "33-48", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.0, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "49-64", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.0, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "17-32", "mean": 0.00087890625, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.0012158105076160873, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "33-48", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.0, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "49-64", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.0, "task": "copy" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.7093025678333335, "balanced_std": 0.1687005878210939, "bucket": "22-40", "mean": 0.7057942708266668, "n_seeds": 30, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.17046144355032183, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.49553261262446663, "balanced_std": 0.2302145242215844, "bucket": "42-60", "mean": 0.49713541667000005, "n_seeds": 30, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.23019672200630395, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.42167938969799995, "balanced_std": 0.2310541871480776, "bucket": "62-80", "mean": 0.41236979165500004, "n_seeds": 30, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.23237258651528797, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.79118970686, "balanced_std": 0.04383025125847053, "bucket": "22-40", "mean": 0.78964843748, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.04561367573229585, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.68219266662, "balanced_std": 0.08731431854817007, "bucket": "42-60", "mean": 0.6826171875, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.08573751588924988, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.5626642648600001, "balanced_std": 0.15837133858065788, "bucket": "62-80", "mean": 0.55693359376, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.1699939793957157, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.8177366545400002, "balanced_std": 0.1043785578637555, "bucket": "22-40", "mean": 0.8158040364533332, "n_seeds": 30, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.10835873999105683, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.7069791939933333, "balanced_std": 0.17328143175677455, "bucket": "42-60", "mean": 0.7079589843733333, "n_seeds": 30, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.1721697513187256, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.6202415464543335, "balanced_std": 0.22219361300435914, "bucket": "62-80", "mean": 0.6133300781233334, "n_seeds": 30, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.22625662242107356, "task": "dyck1" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.5012630511, "balanced_std": 0.0033187039627192243, "bucket": "21-40", "mean": 0.50175781252, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.003463012332710338, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.48101830254, "balanced_std": 0.0411207875479431, "bucket": "41-60", "mean": 0.4861328125, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.04439279551050265, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.3912827998, "balanced_std": 0.21927807799208235, "bucket": "61-80", "mean": 0.39462890628, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.22144547918055224, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.37782449762, "balanced_std": 0.21277886267882723, "bucket": "81-100", "mean": 0.37822265624, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.2130743791044447, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.49919891052, "balanced_std": 0.00720796726498303, "bucket": "21-40", "mean": 0.499609375, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.007400320743517375, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.49420376544, "balanced_std": 0.014805295744965467, "bucket": "41-60", "mean": 0.498828125, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.016941318895324707, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.4803096692800001, "balanced_std": 0.044597444404513, "bucket": "61-80", "mean": 0.48515625, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.044862924130054466, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.4771733232, "balanced_std": 0.05104360038787198, "bucket": "81-100", "mean": 0.47792968752, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.051004242975883574, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.5069141651399999, "balanced_std": 0.014504912818634624, "bucket": "21-40", "mean": 0.5068359375, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.014340014801230566, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.5039508116, "balanced_std": 0.00791295310466254, "bucket": "41-60", "mean": 0.503125, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.012229471576344625, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.49435583349999995, "balanced_std": 0.006698584134338158, "bucket": "61-80", "mean": 0.493359375, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.010372960239882517, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": 0.49853438073999995, "balanced_std": 0.002664027744456551, "bucket": "81-100", "mean": 0.49833984374, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.003564787530717665, "task": "parity" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "17-32", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.0, "task": "prefix_sum" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "33-48", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.0, "task": "prefix_sum" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "49-64", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.0, "std": 0.0, "task": "prefix_sum" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "17-32", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.0, "task": "prefix_sum" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "33-48", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.0, "task": "prefix_sum" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "49-64", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.25, "std": 0.0, "task": "prefix_sum" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "17-32", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.0, "task": "prefix_sum" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "33-48", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.0, "task": "prefix_sum" }, { "balanced_mean": null, "balanced_std": null, "bucket": "49-64", "mean": 0.0, "n_seeds": 5, "p": 0.5, "std": 0.0, "task": "prefix_sum" } ], "pooled_descriptive": { "balanced_far_ood": { "bucket": "62-80", "difference_ci95": [ 0.08382406876728872, 0.3133002447453779 ], "mean_difference": 0.1985621567563333, "n_pairs": 30, "p05_mean": 0.6202415464543335, "p0_mean": 0.42167938969799995, "paired_t": 3.539410634441015 }, "id_comparison": { "bucket": "2-20", "difference_ci95": [ -0.01310599964562165, 0.05106172886562166 ], "mean_difference": 0.018977864610000002, "n_pairs": 30, "p05_mean": 0.9421223958466667, "p0_mean": 0.9231445312366666, "paired_t": 1.2097698374332293 }, "ood_comparisons": [ { "bucket": "22-40", "difference_ci95": [ 0.0372933011285278, 0.18272623012480554 ], "mean_difference": 0.11000976562666667, "n_pairs": 30, "p05_mean": 0.8158040364533332, "p0_mean": 0.7057942708266668, "paired_t": 3.0941442923079494 }, { "bucket": "42-60", "difference_ci95": [ 0.11124889462340506, 0.3103982407832616 ], "mean_difference": 0.21082356770333333, "n_pairs": 30, "p05_mean": 0.7079589843733333, "p0_mean": 0.49713541667000005, "paired_t": 4.330243791821633 }, { "bucket": "62-80", "difference_ci95": [ 0.08557923326621147, 0.3163413396704552 ], "mean_difference": 0.20096028646833333, "n_pairs": 30, "p05_mean": 0.6133300781233334, "p0_mean": 0.41236979165500004, "paired_t": 3.5621960743980834 } ], "role": "descriptive effect estimates only; no confirmatory pooled p-value", "seeds": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29 ] }, "primary": { "alpha": 0.05, "bucket": "62-80", "comparison": "p=0.5 - p=0", "df": 14, "difference_ci95": [ 0.00868728336352445, 0.3727580291564756 ], "mean_difference": 0.19072265626, "n_pairs": 15, "p05_mean": 0.6126953124866666, "p0_mean": 0.4219726562266667, "paired_t": 2.2471424521608676, "role": "adaptive discovery cohort; nominal test, not confirmatory", "significant": true, "task": "dyck1", "two_sided_critical_t": 2.1447866879169273 } }